HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-00063
t \"...I\fl,U1r" tt~"""
,
v.
I IN 'nil' (:OUHT 01' C:OMMON PLEA.'i 01'
I CUMllltHIANU COUNTY, PKNNSYI,VANI4
I
I NU. fl. (11.:$ nVII. TEHM
I
I
I
I
JOliN W. l.yrKK, III
Appellanl,
ZONINO II....AKINU IlOAMU or 1111
1I0lCOlJelll 01' (:4'",IIU,I'...
Appell".
:<<rtlaJU'~
JOliN W.I.\"fItK.IlI. AI'ptlllnlapllflllt ffllm Ih, ~~I,wn ot Ihf lONINO UEAHINU ItOARD
ot' Tim IIUKUlIcm OF CAMunlf. CUMIlItIUAND {'(H'N'I'Y, rr.NN.\".VANIA, on lilt .mulllh
~~I (IIrlh beluw;
I. 111. Apllflhml It JOliN W. 1,\"rU. Ill. of nl W"I 1,fflIltltf SIr"I. (,'illli,I,.
CUlllhellllfld CounlY, r'"ll.ylvllnhtI101.1. (AI'lIfIli41l1 WIl' f,fm.4ltl In llIltulMnlt nltd with AplttUn
11\ "Juhn l.yl'()
2, Thf ApplIllu it 1M ZONINU m:.4MINOIUMMU or 11 It: 1l0ICuUOtl or CAMU8UC,
nJ~IIIf.ICIANU (:O\JN"'V. rt:NNIYLVANI.\...t II W,.I ~l\ilh lill,.I. ('itflitit. r.Mtylvlnil non.
l 'nl' ^r'flfUi4IiI. Illt idlIh In4ivitIll.t. I, UIf ilWMf lit (lwp'rJ)' whhlft ttlt 1k1ltlUJh ht
('1l,1i,1~1 'Il'flfklllly III n.. W,i.14lijlhf, ~UHI
4, AI'llfllln. i. 1I11Jlf1l1ill, frlffllll dfd~iIJ ... .... ZuN,NO 1l~'''NO lOAM" or 'n..e
llOICOIJUII Of (:A'U.Uil,t:, \Jilt" Iltnffltlf'., ,..... .114 "Imld 10 II 7,11" Of'" . ;~{j.f, It. topy
fit Ih~ \\'1111'11 IlVj(lj1l1t fWIJ ",..i.kll' 01 A~lhft' ,.. itll.ftiwil 1M t:tfijt./t 'A',
~. lhf 1f1#1t4' twitOf/f AW-UII' ./Wtili IfwtliJIJ Iff Ih4lbt,;Mm, IJJ1j.lfiithl4 tJIHft.1M M ~.,
Il'y 1114k!IltI'1l ('UUI,_ tWill 1+ lt4.,.m,I(##H#f ut 1114 1..f.tfI4ff, U'ifI,n, Uttiw. ~4 Ot;~, l.. t'JIM.
I \~I'\I\I"ff'r....l)k'.....at
r1ndlnlllln Impropor o,pllnllnn nr a nnn~nnrurmlna UIO of a pwperl)' localed on North Oranae Slreel
111 IIn 1.2 J.I11hllndullrlllll)lllrlcl.
6. Th. II,clllo" of Ih. ZONINO I....ARINO IIOARU 0"1'1 IF. 1I0ROVOII Of' CARUS"':
lllllrunllnlllho lIppnl or Dkklnl,," Cnllello frum IlIld delermlnatlnn wu, Ilrbltral)'. ClIprlcluul and IIn
lIhUIO uf dlm,llnn anl.l cunlrlll)' 10 haw In Ihal:
I. Th. lIoarll ,rrrd In Itl cnndullun uf haw Nu. J Ihllllho UI' of Iho lubJecl pre mile.
tJ)' Allen I>llilrlbllllun (which 1..lIellllld prtrmll" flllm I>lcklnlun Cullelle) II a conllnuatlun of IIl1un-
wnfurmlnll u" IIr lubJO"1 pr.ml... III . wlIrolwul' b)' Klnno)' Shllo Curptlflltlon (torrner IIwner
IhorellO.
b. Tho UOlird trrod In III ~u",lullon II( law No. .. Ihlillho 1""ro...II l"lenlih)' of ule
of II nun-con(ufml", 1110 duoI nol cllnllllullI an "llanllon o( a nlll1.cun(urmln. uao,
~. 'Ill. UOIml m.d In f.I)'ln, upon Iho holdlnllo( Ih. l',nnl)'lva"la Supromo Cllurt
ill JU\UU.blJLuU:'lwllCU..,.J.~.1lt.ku1u...n.....Wl1Ulm..1L-~JI1Il ChAwbtrt PCnWlImml
(.'ujllVw..Jn~,JllWUf1~WU ('U ^2d 1,1" (I'll. IV"II)) ill Ihlll Illld filiI! InvulvtI a lublUllltlally
IJIH...r...nl UliO Ihlln Ihal In Itu,..ll'n; Ihlll, "olik. 11I,lnulull clltO.lurrllunllillll n.lllhbmlln Ihlll "lUll had
..11\ l'lflienled fVld'IlC. Ihilllh.lllm'lllf In I""rilliu"' wUIlI41 adv'Ufly ,ff."llh.m or Inn"l.lI11lric
W,,_,ullln; and Ihlll ,..h. Cll'. l"tIll~.iJ II tubtllllllllllly dlff,r'IIIIYIIlJ lit r'tlll.nlllll n.l.hborho(Ji! thlln
Ihit! 10011,,, lilt tUbjtfl ,If.mi... In Ihll i/\.lllllll ,,~, Iii 1("'III,d.
It 'Hili Uwm' .m,., In fillU". UI (fln..j\l."... 111II "',",Iv. .,mNnt 0' ,,.,lmony IIml
~"'I;J,,"4" o/t'fII,j by ^PV'lIiflU ,.,14 olM' MI.bbml". ~t~'ly ~~'t lI" 11I1"- dl4lnp In IN 1<<'11...11)'
!Hi ItHI 'lI"j,,,1 p"rIli,Itf"
:
t ,*p\PII.n"...llk"'..,....
e. The UOIm! erred In It. ,ondullon (If law No, 6 Ihallho determlnallon madc by
the Zonlnll orn,cr of tho Uoroullh of Carllllo dated O'tobor 14, 1994, walluued In error.
f. The Uoard erred In falllnlltCl ,unduct II full hearlnll on tho mallor II a Ipedal
exceplllln and In falllnlllo fullow Itl cUllomary practice In lu,h Clllel lIf referrln. Ihe mailer In Ihe
l'lannlnll Curnmlulon of Ihe UOWUllh lIf Carlllle, purauanl to a pruvllllln IIf Ihe Carllslo Uoroullh Cllde,
fur commenlllll In Its ImplI'l upon Ihe surroundlnll nelllhhorhood,
II, Appellanl relervn Iho r11lhllO IlalO addltlonlll reasonl for revonal of Iho UlIllrd'l
ded~llln, afler Appellanl hili had Ihe ol'plItlunlty w review Iho Iranmlpl of Ihe lenlllhy hearing
Invulved,
wm:Kf.t'oKE, Apllellllnl rel/ueU, yuur IIl1nucabl, Court rcvme Ihe died l"llllo lIf Ihe
ZONINO IIEAKINO 1I0AKU 0"" TIlt: IIOKOl)OIl 0.... (:AKl.ISl.F.,I't:NNSVI,VANIA and dlrecllhat
'I
II
il
I[
'j
I
Ihe delermlnatlon of Ihe 7.onlnllllearlnll Offlw daled Ocwber 14, 1\194 be sUllaloed; or It Ihe
alternative. remaodlnlllh. mailer 10 Appellee (ur a (ull special eaceptlon hOllrlnll.
Fl.OWItH. MOKUf.NTIIA1.. FWWKM , UNPSAY
AlIorntYI flit Al'llfllulIl
lIy:
,,>"11; ill' 'tjJ
Mo,., M. Milt fnlhal, Jlll/ulr.
n> , 1714.\
II Ilau 11I,11 SlrUI
CarU.'.. JlA 1701.1
(111) 24}.mJ
-
I
,
HOV-28-9. ~OH "..,
"...
r.ONING HEARING BOARD
BOROUGH or CARLISLE
Oall ot Doc:lalon: December 8, 1994
In lb. manet ot
Olck.lnaoQ COU'I'
AppUCll\t
ZHB CUe N\lmber: 040.94
I
I APPEAL PROM OBTBRMJNATlON
I OP ZONINO OFFICER DATED
I . ocrOBBR 14, 1994. fINDINO AN
I IMPROPER EXPANSION OF A
I NON-CONPORMINO USE OP
I PROPBRTY LOCA TBD ON NORTII
I ORANOS STREBT IN AN I.:Z LlOHT
I INDUSTRIAL DlSnuCf
g~JNIO/l( A:tD. DECISION
I. BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURE
Aftlt propet adVlrtll.mcnl. chi Board beld . "ubllc bllria,lII the Carib', Boroulh
Municipal DWldlDl1t 53 Wut SOUlh SlnItl, c.rlw.. PtnmylvaaJa, It 6:30 r.M. Oft 11Illtlday,
November 17. 1994. Zonhtl Hearia. Board mcmbora prtlellt Wtro Robert L. Ktuch, Cbalmwi.
WIlliam V. Solomon, William O. KOICO, and Donald B. Orell. n. Alto pnItOt "'.... ~!Il1
ornell Brian M. Otnnl. end Reben M. froy, ElqWl'l. u SoUcllOt. .
AppUcanI eontondllhal the IUO made ot lhII wlllhouM buiJdIn.IOCI&Id 1& lbo property OD lbI
eall lidO ot the lint block ot Nonb oren,1 lItact which "'u tom::X uaed by 1O.nDIy Shoo
COflloradon u a wIRhouae. b a UII ItilI 0 a WIRbouao DOW btla. and ocCup{td '" AJItA
Dlstribullon. Rlpres.nlla. DlckJnlon Colll,1 W'I SIIV.1l 1. W,14IItt'D, Baqultl, ud
I\!l'ruentiu. variOUl all.bberl wu Ro." M. MOI,lIltbal. Eaquil..
11. FINDINGS or FACT
I. '"'- propel1)' Oil the .ut aide ot the Clnt bJodc ot NOM ~. 111M wu t'onnItly
own.d and occupl.d by KJnlllY Shoo Corporallon IIId 11 now OWDtd by DlCIdAlOQ Coli....
%. Tbt .ubJcct property wu UI,d by KlaneY Sboo Corporation II . "'lftboule.
l. DlcklNon cou... IolHd the tubJ<<1 Pft'l'I'1Y 10 AllIn Olacnbutlon wbla:b condnUH 10
"'at 'l,IbJCCI ptOpoIrtY II' wlltboua..
... Tbe Intfn.slty of 11M WIRhou.sln,1IM by AJUn DUulbulJon bu IIIm&M4ltom dill of
Kln"y Shot CorpotllJoo In tb&l tbe Dumbel of /lUCks bdnp. mmtwl4U. foIstotl" bu
incRUcd 14 hql,lOl'ICY and the IlUIIlbu of lruI;ka ~.lvI.II' NQRilj /llI~/lMI1"1 11I4 refJ\Ov"', 11IM
tJ:om lJ1f WIltIlOuH It... 1Jlc;~ In ft"eql,lOncy Uld lht 110M l'l'ICrac.d by the Cl\ICk rnmc In4l.b1
lo.dJn. Nl4l.bf W1loAdlnl of mc~lw.uJSt.lnlQ an4 from !be wII'boIl.. bu In.cAuod.
, , '"'- 1It1 of tubJ"'1 pl'mU'" uHd by ADm DlIlIllmUon ... . wmhollN IIIMJ .f....'
Ihallln.lI.. UNd by lUn.My ,bot COlpQttUOII, Ult ~MO' Ol:~UVItIt. .. . WlltholiH,
"".j! i, Ii' .1 !
( II'
IN Tilt: COUl\T (W COMMON l'I.t:Mi 0
C'utlli(::ftt....NP C(lUWfV. !'I::NNSVt,vAN t
.
"'1'
liIlli
,'. J t.,y '55
John W. tyt.r, Ill,
^N1tllant.
, ~.
v.
tonin, UurtM 1*01(4 of the
DOfOyth or Carli.lo,
"ppoU,..
s. -
fl. a~'
Ii ,. l.s.-n4-.-A )
",",
"r.,I"~
MOTlee Of A,reAL
Mo. n.. (1. "
.
lu,*. 1;'2~""<<J-
__;.1J..
fLoweR, MOROINTUAL,
'LOweR' LlNDtA V
. 'Wf'~.\ {Oll'\lUfI(l/ll
4nYl~h. Af ~A"
II fAif Hleu.nUl
('AJUItU. flNHtnVANI4 I"~U
I . fAMe, U flQWIK HlU
If . .Q(~tlil M M(lfu;n.ml4L I1IH
I I ,-\MU (} nowI... I. mu
I j CAtlm t U~[Jf"Y .....
dA.,;.,t I,al
,q.'1 ,",.1." I t
,
- .....-....-----.- --. - .._._~_._.._-.- -.-. -
,JllIIN W. I.YTICM, It I
AppellAnt
I IN THJ COU"T or COMMON PLCA' or
I
I eVM'l'LANP eQUNrV, rCHNIVLVANIA
I
I
I
I NO. "-061 CIVlt TM~
VII.
IONINO IIIeARINO ft()AIID or Till
UlllCOUUlI or CAIII.ltlU
WIIIT or (I"IORAII
COI1MONWJ:AI,TH
Of U'NNIYI8ANIAI
I
ev"u: Iil-AHfll
!iil$.
C<'l,JN'f't Of
101 .nnln" "....Inq .....iUd of 1M .....rtlVtfh @f ear"a'e
lrilil, Wlr-q wHllflQ fh' ,.,t/Wl f~i!I. If> t....... """Uit'd ,. ~ftAln 4II4ltk'<n
t", tio~.rt ..,Julla..J. ~..L.y t'.f4.,lJJ~'4,,'UI'-lJtI,.tt'.d,J,\I.~tQ.f~e.l~wa
Q (..c.Arllll111="'"-"...,',....,...=..=.,,,,~--..=,.~,=_..=,~='"'~~=._g.""""""'. ..... . ..... ~--,_.,
1"',Hr"ll,,,fnu, y(;li, I..... (.,......,.t f'~ It"'" ,,. ,,,,,{if" pi It.. @!I4tH~1 MtiJf"illd .",.
.,n thlf.1J' I:rflt'/ilnilhil .iiW ""11'.', .t~n ,.. Flf,HflM !ifi4 ..", I,. (>II., ,,,"JIl" I.,
'..;1 C.lI.\H .,t ("t.....tfI riM' II' cllirH"I.., ..11M" ,_,,,It,,~"...~. ", H. \~t. tou,,",
, 'J!iH"f WIHi wh. It'fUI ~. I~I _ ~ NHt., f~ III t. *'** H..., ~l€tl '.'(jtit
!" .. l1f". ,lIG€<iftHfiiJ H. tt. 1;WIj W ff'f~H ~;,'lL4i i[.f ,MI fr""'.........Ut'.
wl'fl*~. n,. ~"'i\"fMii.
Co'f ..,,14 {:Hlf", ,,' ('iud.dlll 'j" H>li =.Ul, ~ "t."JIi!~(J".,."=,..,,.~,J 1'# ,.~n,.
~!~;fJ~&,~t '~i'(!Y.'rM~IJ;~'J
f'.",H",:;ri(,i~rl
IN Till!: counT or CCOOION l'f.t:AS 0
CUMB~RLAND COUNTY, VCNNSYLVANlj
JOHN ii, LVTlCR, nl,
Appel1lnt
VI.
10NINO IlIARINQ llCARD or THft
DOROUOH or cAntl0LI!:,
, App.Ue..
,
CIRTIrICATI or .IRVICB
, No. n-on CIVIL TlRM
,
,
FLOWER, MORCiENTHAL.
FLOWER" LINDSAY
"raottUIOH4L tOIl'(lU lION
ATTOINnuruw
n lAST IUGtlSTREET
CARLISLE, PENNSYLVANIA 110U
( I 'AMII 0, flOWER OUU
( Xl ROOEk M MOItClNTltAL 171U
I I ,AME' 0, fLOWER. lit, mu
I 'CAROL I LlNt>tAY ....J
,.
J4H 10 3 u PH '95
!,"-,;rf.;i::f.
, . c- '<~lf;b"?,'b~
!-'.'i't /;' ;J;tt~ .
r -. ,,_<:o:j;
. .j'
~OY-2'-'. ~OH I?II.
fl....
ZONING HItAIUNO BOARD
DOROUGH or CARLISLE
Oato ot Ooc:~lon: Dtctlllbtr 8. 1994
In th. manit of
OIc:kWon Colltll
AppUc:anl
ZKD CAM Nllmbtfl ()4()..94
I
I
APPIA1. PaOM DlITtiRMINAnON
0' ZONINO OffiCIR OA TlID
OC'TOOI!I\ 14. 1994. fiNDINO AJ4
IMPROPftR !X,^NSION 0' A
NON.cONfORMlNO use 0'
PROI'1RTY LQCA TllD ON NORnl
ORANoe STIU:!HT IN AN 1.3l.10nT
tNOUSllttAL DISTIUCT
0lWQlt.utU ~
r. BACKGROUND AND PROCIDUJlI
MIlt proper advert1tlmtlll. 1M DOlld HW . ~bU" Hili., iA .... Catlltlt ="
Munkll'&l BuiJdlll,1( 'J Will SO\Kll 51r.... C,vllllf, f't1uuylvuiI, I( 6s'" P,M. .. 'I.
November I', 199<6. ZonLIl. Jfuria, UOtVd lIIflIlbfn ~"" ~ L. KMi. ~
WWIw V. Sololl'lOll. WIUJ&m 0, KotCo. and DoMI4 I, Ott1l. U. Abo ptIjIlC "" ~I
attlc.r Brian M. o.nA1I and It_bell M. ,,.y.lhqlllrt. II s..U.lklf.
AppUeIftl COftlfMe tb.allht UM !Ndt of IN WlltlluuM ~I klHlfd 1& m. ~ _1M
.Ul Iide' ot lbt nnl bloek ot NoM 01'11I,' 'Utll wltWlI w.. ~ lIMd W ~_'1 '00t
COfllOllUon II a Wll'lhcxt.., It . \lM leU (i . WIl.IwMf!lOW btilI. and MuM by Ajkll
Dlllrlbullon. It.pr''llltlll' Dlcllhu(ln Coli.., Wil .t'VI. I, W,iA'lflfl, 1114111,.. ana
rtp,.ltllllJll VIIIQ\I. fttl,t!bon w.. fl()ltr ~t Mof.,mllal. ."t'Ulf,
n. nNDINOS or FACT
I. The F~ftY OIl tM ....1 .. lit IN tlnt ~i If' ~ ~ ... .tI fMMfly
ownld and oeGuplfd by lUAMY ,hM COJlOfIUlm u4lt AOW ow", Dr DtiiiMOl CttJfp, .
~. TIM tllbJ"1 pwptft'I WII _ iIY lUMfy ...~.... ... wlftlwNlf,
" DlckllooR eou... ItIH4 IH "/fI'1 ~ I@ AUM ~ w.. (hlIIMij~" 10
UN tllbJccI ptOptftY II . wllfbtNH, .
of. TbI iI'l/IM#y ot 11M 'IIItlfl/lfMIJI' !fM IIY AJJMt ~ ,.... ~.~ tffltn fltM iii
Kl""y .Ilot C~,. hI ~ 1M IIII1f11MI I;llMu It#Ut&llt. /IWliitM41M fIH tHH.... ItM
II1I:r.....4ln CJtqllfnlll' willi ~ fit !MY ..,Y/itI ~ fIfM,.... ~ "'.lftf tMt#f
tlom rht w~..1w lMr"llJ. ~'Y M4 "" ~ p~ Ify r;., ~ ~ ~ IN
kllIdln,lIId to. Wl~'lit IMlIiIJiH.dilpf IItf4 M4 flqm IIlI iUlflifNlpf hM /Wirfw4
" 1'_ "" ql .ooIK~t:li!~ it~.~ ity. ~ PI.wI!oli#l'ffl it.. '1t~~. ~ 1;(. 1f+fl4#
1""1\ In. if.. iLH1J 1>>1 Killl''-Y _ .' C!'ft"t~'" \lif fR'~U~f ~i!ij,4Il" .. .. ~*'~,
ttov-:a-.~ "ON l?'I~
,..Ihs
III. CONCLUSIONS or LAW
I. Tho u.. of 'lIbJ'" promllt' U & wanhouaol. & non.eonrormlnl II".
2. T1lt UH U . wanhou.. btc:1I1lI aol\-<onfDnnlnl wIMn Ihe CUomn, ~niJll OrdInance
wu adopfld btc:lu..lho 'lIbJ'" prtmlMl ar. no' part of I "pllMtd Indllllrial dlvllopmen'''.
,. U.. of .ubj"l preml... U I wll'lhouM by AlIon Dlltnbullon II a eontllluatlon of the
non.conrormin. UII of tub!"1 pr.mllII U a wartboul' by KInney Shoe COll'orallon.
4. Iner....d Inlln.llY of u.. wbleh I. . llon-conformln. u.. dOt' no' con.tllule an
upln.lon of & non-<onfonnln. U...
" Subjec, CI.. I. conltOU.d by tho bolJlnl of 11M p.nn.ylvIII11 Supremo Coun In the
Town.hlp or "Chilli.". 'olllioner, v.. WlUlaro H. Martin. Inc., Ind Chamberl Devolopmenl
Company. [nil.. Rllpondonu <,4~ A2d.9" (PL 1911)).
6. ThlI dolOmWlatiOn made by lbe ZoaUll Otrlctr of lht BOfO\I.h ot ClrU.II dated October
14. 1994, tindln, 11'1., an Iner.... In lb. hourt of optradoa ot rtcolvlnl &lid dllpatchlDI
mo~haIIdI.. Ilorld In IlIb],,' Wll'lbouM cOllllilUled III ,"panalon ot lbe non~nl 11I0 of
wuohOUH wull.1JId In ,001I Wth bu' In anor.
IV. ORDlut or TIIIIOARD
Tbt lon"', Ifoaria, Board uDulmoully atnrml lht appeal by DlckJnaon Colli,. and
rtVobl Ihe ~ mIIlt by lbI C.u.li loroup ZoNa, OttlUf lit fonb In leaet dated
October 14. 199",
AAyont IIIl1fvod by WI declaloA of till DoIrd baa 1M rtlbt to IPPta1to 1M Cwnbtrland
County Coun of CGmIOOft PStu wldIIA ~ (30) daf' from lbe IlI&I ot IlUa decltlon.
~
~
~
Oil. ..L1./~ <
--
~
0.,.
1
1
2
3
4
II In Rei
CI
1
.
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
11
11
Betore
TilE ZONINO HEARINO BOARD
or
BORouall OF CARLISLE
tJ ': . 0..,) C/4,J.:j>,
Appeal and Speoial Exoeptlon R.que.t
by Dickinlon ColleQe
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
11'01'11
ROBERT t. ~EUCH, Chairman
DONALD I. ORELL, Hember
WILLIAM O. ~OSCO, Hember
WILLIAM V. SOLOHON, Hember
ROBERT H. FREV, lequire, SOlicitor
DATIl Thurlday, November 17, 1994
at 71n p.m.
PLACE 1
II) WI.t Douth Stre.t
Carli.le, Plnneylvlnia
. .
,.
'"
f" .i.
,.)
11
30
31
APPlAlW/CIII
HCNKI', WALLACE . NURICK
BYI STEVIN J. WIINOAMTIN, I'QUIRE
rOR - APPELLANT
. .
l-.
ul
'LOWER, MOltOENTHAL, 'LOWER . LIND'AV
33 BYI MoolR H. HOROt.NTHAL, INQUIRE
'OR . Rt.tONOENT8
n
H
Al,/JO "/lUIN'1'1
'MIAN OtNNI', ~Qninq Officer
</1) x.vCUl'IA HU"I'~'IN(aH, fjecretary
~,-""."-'~"-~--'-'-'''''''''''-'''''''-. ' .. ..'...~,.,._---_.__..._~_..~. fI;~- - ,
... t~tIlI'lU,,1 I"lllHliflYl'tl4ni4 l.'O'lrtR.Jj~fdn(j Ilnv Ct,i .. .""
(Ilil ""111-1(,'1' ORIGINAL
:I
1 INDEX
2 WITNESSES DIREct CROSS REDIRECT RECRoa8
3 lIarvey Davia 9 14 -- --
4 Richard Evan. :14 27 ..... --
5 Ben Tay. 30 34 -- --
6 Miohael JUdO. 41 III ... .-
7 Dave Giordano !It 64 ..- --
8 Miohael JudO., noaUed 75 7. ... -.
9 prian D.nni. 80 .- .- ...
10 John B1Itl1ne 83 ... ... --
11 Harry Booth 8IJ .. -.. ....
12 John Lvter '3 .- ..- --
13 Don Niohter '7 .- .... --
14 Hlchael Plumenthal " -- ..- .-
llS Je..i. Miller 103 ... .... ..
16
17
18
1t EXHIBIT'
ao DIICRJPTIOt4 10lNTIrUO
U A LetUr Dated '.pt.lIlber 16, 111I. 4!)
U It l.ettar Dat.d ootober :lQ, I". to Jllll ^hon.n U
:n
i4 Alec .Ulch414 1, tho .pp..rancI .ntered by Hr. "or~.nth.l.
n
C.ntr~ ._nn*vlv4n ~ Court "_port
nit) J';ft-jt.,;t
1
1
THE CIlAIIU4ANI Th. appointed tim. and dl\to
a hAvin9 arrived, wa'11 oall the reqularly aoh.dulld ...t1nq
:J of the carlhl. Zonlnq tlear1nq lioud into ....ion.
4 I'd lik. to introduce the mambar. of the Board
. and our It,tf. To my tar rl\Jht 1. our 'oltottor, Hr,
. Robert Frey, nlNt to him 1. a memb.r of tho Board, Hr.
1 Oonald Orall. Nlxt to .. 1. Wll1iam ~o'co, 1\ .amber ot
. 'he Board. And 1'. Dob ~.lloh and the ohdtlllan of the
. "ard. TO'Y 1..ediate 1.ft 1. Mr. Wl11la. lololllon, a
10 ...ber or the loard. And to .y far 11ft i. Mr. Brian
II o.nnl., who i. our Joninq ottloer.
'a for thoe. of you who ar. not aw.ra or our
lJ p,oeldurl., I'd likl to t.~. hopetully ju.t iii brier 10.ent
,. Of two to explain the 'anner in whioh we'll proc.ed. We
II will Oall '.oh .pplioation and 'In.rally take the. in tn.
'6 or4.r in Whleh thlV ar. 'llt.a on the '!Jlnda.
n
The .ppile.ftt will havI an opportunlty to
11 provide wh.tev., intofuUon .na .vidlnoll thllY "'teh to
,. ,rovid. to the ioAfd. Any .vidlnoe that 1. !Jiven will b.
JO '.~.n uAd., oath. At the oonQlu.ion of th. pr..entation,
Jl I"Y ..m9lf g, tn. OQ4rd 8.V qUI.tion thl .,,1Ig4nt. And
al .t 'hI ~g~I~.IQR of .04r4'. ~u..'lo"iNI, 4nv m.m~r of
a) ,~. 4~"~' M4Y ~y..tl~n l~ 4~pllQ4nl,
I. wn.n 'n.l f~~~"4 If tlollh,a, 4ny ...~.r 0'
f' '~.~i.~. ~"~ ~'.h.f ,~ ~~,~ 4 it4"""' Imt pfQvi4e
\""I""fi4l~;I\"~fl""'f!i'\ f'."'f' ....r.~if. iNJ !I,HV .'U
1'111 H~'l"".
4
1 lntormation to the Board will bo qlven the opportunity to
2 do 10. Again, ir you wllh to provide facto or evldence to
J thio Bo.rd, it will be taken under oath.
4 The applicant and any member at the Doard may
5 queltion any lndivldual who 10 providing information to
6 the Board. Anyon. who wi.he. to make a g.neral comment
1 that doe. not inolude the providinQ of information or
. f.otl whioh io generally very diffioult to do would be
, giv.n an opportunity to do 10, aleo.
10
At the end at that prooe" the matter will be
11 aoneider.d ,ubmlttld, The BOlrl' (jen.rally d.cid.. the
12 c.... that ara before lt on the ag.nda on thl eveninQ in
l' whioh they are pre.entea, That io done .t the conolu,lon
14 of all of thl 0..... You are weloome to otay and lletln
15 to our brilliant and erudlte dilcu.lion of the i.eue. and
l6 our deal.ion. or you can contaot the lonlng oft1cer
11 tomorrow to flnd out what w. had deoided.
18 Thl n.xt it.m on the agenda ie A rlqueet
1. eubmitted by PiokinGon College oonoerning a prop.rty in
20 the t1rot block of ~orth Orang. .tre.t. And it they or
21 their r.prelentative would oomo torward.
u
"M. WtlNQAMTIH' My name ie at.v. Weinqarten
2) flam the law tir. ot "~H..., WAllaoe and Wyriok. I'm her.
24 repr...ntlnQ aickin.on Colloq.. With.. toniqht io D4ve
~~ aiorda"o, Virootaf ot rhy.ic~i rI4"\, .1 well at . numb.r
, \....,_'f'~l r.."'I''''1 va"T" CO"f,ir;J~inn{.i ~'.f;r'i;;"
p 111 J~.' wn
5
1 of witne..uB including two driverB tram Kinney Shoe.
3 Al.o, w. have the plant manager tram Kinn.y Shoe a. well
3 a. the g.n.ral manaqer for Allen Dl.tribution. And I will
4 call them a. wltn..... a. I proc.ed.
IS
THE CHAIRMAN I V.ry fln., .lr. Thank you very
6 muoh, netore proceeding, I'd just llk. to .tat. ror thu
7 record that I am a graduate ot Dlckin.on Coll.qu. I don't
8 know wh.ther that h.lps you or hurt. you, frankly. nut I
9 have looked lnto my heart and d.oldld that notwith.tandlnq
10 that a..oolation many, many y.ar. ln the pa.t, that I
II belleve I can act lmpartlally in thl. matter. And unl..e
12 th.r.'. en obj.ction, I would contlnu. to participate.
13
HR. SOLOHONI I certalnly won't obj.ct .lnce I
14 have to make the .am. conf.leion.
U
16
l7
Tile: CIlAIRMANI Pl.... proo..d, Coun.d.
HR. 'RKYI I QU'.. I .hould conte.., too.
HR. CIlAIRMANI Well, conh..ion i. Qood tor the
11 .oul.
11
HR. WKINOARTtNI W.'r. herl tonlQht, I QU...,
30 on two blelo Qround.. Ther.'e an appeal trom the lonln9
al offioer'. d.t.rmination. It WII al.o a requ..t tor a
22 ep.ctal IKceptlon. With re.peot to the appeal for the -.
a3 and thoee ere In the alternative,
l4 With rupect to the app.al 'ro. the lonlll9
a~ oUlcer'e Ih,tnlJlllnatlOtl, on October 7th, Hr. Denlt" .ade .
',...."..'~,.,..,... ,.,.....,. ...,. '. ,... ".."..........'..,...."..........,_..., ~r:--_. -". .-.
. l'l!ntnl "'J1nlylv"nllt \'UUft M.r'llrtlnql4.rv"J.... ....
Pill J "In * Ifill I
II
"~-~~,,,,,..,,,..,,...,,,,..,,...,...~..~...,..~,._-,~,~.--_..,......,..--..,.,.,..........--...,._.__. ,
1 determinAtion thAt Allen Dletrlbution'l ~.e of the old
2 Kinney wareho~'1 on North oranqe "tr.'t W.I .
J nonoonforminq Uea, The UI. w., the ...., it Wa' a
4 warahoue.. Ther. had b..n no dieoontinuance for a period
5 Qt..ter than elM manthe, th.r.tore, it w.. . continuation
6 of a nonoonrorminq ue..
7 ,ub..qu.ntly, on ootober 14th. an additional
1 lett.r wa. lllue41 and it I. that I.tt.r that w. app.al
e from. In that 1.tter th.re Wle an Indlultton that the
10 time limite .. thlt Kinney hId op.rated It. op.ration only
11 between 7 .... .nd 6 p... and that, ther.for., Allen
l~ Dletrlbution al the curr.nt u'er of the pr~,.rty n.,d,a tQ
1:1 contine he tlU to tho.. epeoltlo noyn.
14
Our app.al il on two qrouna.. One, I l.~al
10 qroundl na..ly, thA' the ohlnt' of the hDYf', In lnor....
16 of the hour., i. not in flot ,.,.I'Y the I.,an.ion of .
17 nonoonfOf.inQ y.. .ith.r II a ..'te' of ,Inlr.' 01.. llw
11 or even una'r your or4inanQI,
19
1\10, f,"JtUIUy, Uina 11 I\Q f.~h..tl pui. for
~o the de'er.ln4tion th., it i. ~t~"ft 1 ..a. .~ . p,l.
al Th.r. WI' ,~,uA'IV . ,y~'~.ij'~' l""f t~4' w.. atliv8rf4
u to HI. DIMl. 4.'''' Q.II,gl;ou in;. ii, !Ifill /lIlHi41.".tilln. '''10
Zl Chi" .~,l"..r f,g, ~l"".y .~ C@f~f4'1@A, l" ~n'~h n,
~4 u4,lc41ly .~,141".4 '~4' 'n, '"f~f~"lg" '~4' ~ ~44
l~ provla.a '.fllff lfM' lh. €i~'~~~ ,.," l....f ~ ~.n
""""~"'-"'1-""'''.'CC~7':~''-
~f;fi-'f;r ~.j;;...t 1"""1'. (...,.1 fJ.r/.if~ tr.1j i:OiH4!"'-"
Pill ~"''t'l!c''''
7
1 b..ed on wa. lncorreot.
2 Therarore, we will arque that a. a faotual
3 b..l., the 7 ..m. to 6 p.m. 1. .imply wrong. And then
4 ...uming that thl. Poard, nonethalee" dltermlne. that the
G expan.ion of a nonconforminq u.e -- that the appeal i. to
6 be d.nied, we would requa.t a .peoial exolptlon to permit
7 the u.e of the tacllity beyond the hour. .tated in Hr.
8 Dennl.' l.tter 7 a.m, to 6 p.m.
. With that brief introduction, 1 would like to
lO call my.. actually, betore dolnq that, though, Hr, Ron
11 Shindled.cker, the chief .nQlnler, had hoped to be her..
1<1 lie'. actually unable to b. here. tie wu Qoinq to be my
13 flr.t l.ed witn....
14 What I would like to do i. .- I've already
10 includea with the application the Octob.r Z,th letter that
16 Ron 'hlndledeok.r .ent to Brian Dlnni. on October a,th. I
11 would jUlt .. .Inol I'. not Qoinq to be able to brlnq it
l' out throuQh Hr. ahlndlld.cklr but ....nti.llV It'. elr..dy
l' pArt ot thl r.cord. I would jUlt 11k. to point out the
30 releVAnt portionl of Mr. 6hlndled.cker" letter which I
n ~1tev. 11 Alr.aay put ot the recorlt. Ilowever, U It'.
az not, I will .ub~lt it. It'. elr.edy part of the recordl
U Ollav.
34 Th. letter on october 14th that Hr. Olnni.
z~ wrote ana that WI .r. 4fpl4linQ trvM in4icat.a that the
;~~:'~',;-''''''''C'',,'-'''n_-
e'ntf41 t,"ft~tIV4" 4 CwyrtM_portlnq n.rv 0..
I 1\ I J";.. '1'.0"11
8
1 determination that it wIe 7 a.m. to 6 p,m. Wle baeed on
2 hie oonvereation with Ron Shlndledecker. Eleven day.
] later Hr, shindledecker wrote a subaequent lotter, which I
4 mUlt toll you I did not requeet, that the college did not
& requelt. When I received it, I waa rather pleaaed to
6 reoeive it but wa. rather lurpri.ed.
7 What the letter atatel ie that he attempted to
8 reaoh Hr. Dennie, that he had been unable to. And,
9 therefore, he wrote thle letter that he had elnce the
10 conver.atlon on which the Ootober 14th letter wae baled
11 that he had talked to two truok drivera both of which are
la here toniqht, that in .0 doing, he had to admit that ,the
1] information he qave wal incorrect, that both driver. will
14 atteat, and they wlll tonight, the taot thlY dropped
l5 trailerl and awitohed trallera at the rormer orange street
16 warehoue. el early ae , I,m. and a. late ae 9 p.rn, three
11 to tour dAV. a week.
11 lie goea on to point out that Hr. Pen Tay. who
1. We al.o have her. toniQht to te.tlry will verify that 80me
30 ot the employ.e. oame .. e.rly a. 2 8.m. and worked ..
al late a. 13 midnight. And the re.t or the letter i.
22 .elf.explanatory. W. wanted to point out th.t there i. 8
2) eub.tantial ohange in the tactual determination.
24 'a.ically, there wa. .ome per.one! reoollection
n of Non l#l'llndlfilJ8,llulr th"t ..4..11' un 01_ l.u.r tHo
C _ ,'n"~ -".~'-C-~~'c','~_.'-__"_'''_"''''''c_.~_'____''~ '-.'___'_"'_.'_.'
CentrAl '.nnjvlv~nl~ Cuu,C ~.portl"~ ~.fvlc..
P III J ~ II. III". f
~
~---~.-.,._"..
1 determined that after talking to 80me people he waD
a incorrect. And we have thoDe people tonight with UI that
3 he talked with.
4
With that .aid, I'd like to .tart pr...ntlng
~ the people that Mr. Shindl.decker talked with. At thi.
6 time I'd like to oall Mr. Harvey Davl..
7
(Harvey Davia waa .worn.)
TilE CHAIRMANI Would you idlntUy youne1t for
.
9 the r.oord with your name .nd .ddr..., pl....?
10
THE WITNESS' Harv.y Jama. Davi., 60 Or.a.on
11 Road, Plainfi.ld, PA,
12
U
THE CHAIRMANI Thank you, .ir. Coun.el?
14
HARVEY DAVIS, called AI a witn..., havlnl,J bun
15 previou.ly duly .worn, ta.tified a. tallow.,
16 DIRECT EXAMINATION
17 BY MR. WEINaARTENI
11
HI
20
Q
A
Q
Hr. Davl., who ie your ..ployer?
Klnn.y aha. corporatlon.
And for how lonl,J h.V. you been ..ployl4 BY
a1 Kinn.y Sho.?
U A Twenty-thr.. y..n.
U Q And whit 1. your petition?
24 A I drlv. trActor-trill 1.r.
U Q An you t..ill.r with tn. 'onn MinlMY
'"'~'~<"~-c;ni-r 4i'-r~r;';'Y'1 Vii" t "<';;';4f i~-lIi,t;f' ~ ;'~j . ~.f ;t~-II'.-' -
(llIi ~'1'sl(i,'i1
10
--,-~''"'',...,.,..,.-,-~=-----...~~.~'~._'---
1 war.hou.. on North oranq. Utr..t7
3
A
V.., .ir.
3 0 Could you de.crib. tor me the u.. that you and
4 other drlver. that you're familiar with mAde ot the
e fAoUltV"
, A We too~ trailer loadl in, bao~.d th.m into the
., door, And w. allo dropped in the drop lot. And We mAd. I
. drop out thlre when wa dropp.d trAilere. We pioked and
. dropped off tr.itere in and out of thare all the time.
10 Q And when vou e.v .U the time, q1lle me An IdeA
11 a. to how .arlv vou perlonally aiQht hove operated I truc~
" It the faoility.
,) A Ae a.rly .. tlOO in the morninq ana a. late ..
14 .idnh,"t.
'I Q ~o, ther.tor., it wa. a. .arly al 1100 Ind II
I' l.'..e aidnitht th.t you would Aotually b. on the
11 ".,.'lV vith th. 'ruck runntnq lith.r ptokinq up or
II droppl~ off. "Ail.r1
It A Yt., .If,
10 0 An4. AotUAllYI dld Mon 'hindl'd.~k.r ln 1'111
11 1.".,.." AQtu41ly pointed out th.t it v.. , I.M. ta ~
II ,.a. ~'it'. .@'~lly <<. V@ij IVln qo b.YQn3 that, thA'
Il it V4. ~~ ~~.~l~ft .1 ~.
~. ~<< ~Q" '" MU\ ~f W.,t Vif~int4 4M4 ~,op . 1Q44
;JI) ,,. U.n..
~iiA'ff" 't.;':~'"t! \/1f.\" r~"4;.li~':(jf H~;jli.ivT~i;~~~" .
liPI J"It.U."1
12
1
MR. ORELLa That'e what I'm trying to
2 underatand. And I believe you mentioned leaving the truck
3 running. What period ot tlme are we talkinq about?
4
THE WITNESS' Well, in the meantime I went in
D to aee what door they wanted to put the tral1er ln and
6 what they wanted pulled out. It would ait out there on
7 the lot and run until I baoked ln and awitched trailer.
. and left. And it waa running, I don't know, half hour, 45
9 minut.I, maybl, lometim.l,
10
11
13
13
HR. ORELLI That'l all. Thank you.
THE CHAIRMANI Nr, ~OICO?
HR. ~08COI (Shakin; head trom lett to riqht.)
HR. CtIAIRMAN. You ..id yean aQo they had
14 three Ihitt.. Did that ch4nQI .0 thlre Were no 10nQlr
11 three Ihitt. in that faoility?
16
Tilt WITNE8S1 Not anymore. WI're not a. larQa
17 a. ~e uled to bl, aut 1 waa laying back y.are 4QO w. had
l. three ehifte around the clock on.
I' HR. CIIAIRMAN. And when did that .top, lir?
ao TilE WITHEIIII I don't know el(Mltly. Haybo .. I
U don't. know .I(aotly when they cUd Itop that. It'e been 4
U whU..
n HI(, CHM JlMAN I Can you qive m. 4 derlnltlon or
~4 4 whil.? H... it beln " te.., yun, tow monthe?
a
THE WITHEIM' 101.11,. tew yeara, 1 9UI", yaah.
~:_=~~='C."t'r. r "~';;;n;y l y'401;" 2Q~'fr'M';i;of1TIl~t~" rv i ".'.-'~ N....
(1 P) JU~ I~"'"
13
1 THE CHAIRMANI Now, when you went from the
2 three shirts to tho rewer number of ehifts, ald tho hours
3 that wo're talklng about, 5 a,m. to midnight, did they
4 change because there was no lcnger shlft work?
5 THE WITNESSI No. No, the 5 a.m, stayed.
. 'filE CHAIRMAN 1 So over the lll8t period or --
7 last flve month. that plant was in operation by Kinney or
8 that warehou.., you would on a regular basis be there at 5
9 ..m. and many time. as late as midnight?
10
THE WITNESS 1 V,., 5 a.m., and a. late a.
11 midnight. Depend. on what load I had.
1:1
THE CHAIRMANI I'm eorry. I have -- I would
13 llke to get. little more Ipeolrlclty. And ie thl_ a
14 queltion of that would happen once a week, twice, two,
15 three times a week or once a month on the average or
16 lomewher. ln between that?
17
TilE WI1'NElIII Thr.e to four day. . w.ek and
II .ometlme. tive. It dlpend.d on our load., how many w. had
19 goin9 In,
ao
THle CIIAIRMANI 80 three to tour day. " week or
al maybe rive day. a week you would b. there at 5 a.m. and --
22 or you or other trueka would be th.r. at 5 .... or at
2l JJlictnight7
H
3~ BUM"Y..
THe WITHEsal I've oven went in there O~
""?~~""='='c.l,tf-~rci;;r;';;;vfv';nf4 "llurt: tteJlIut "'J lierv 17..
(n1) Hd~I""/
1 know.
2 Q
3 A
4 Q
5 midniQht?
0 A
7 VirQinia.
8 in.
9 Q
10 at midnight?
11
13
A
17
out you don't, though?
No, I don't have any.
How many day. a week would you be there at
Well, dlpanded on when I come back from We.t
If a load wa. Qoing in there, why, I'd put it
Could you e.timate how many day. you'd be there
Three, maybe four.
HR. HOROr:NTIiALI All r1Qht. I haVe no further
TIfE CHAIRMAN. All right, .ir. Thank you. Any
15 other member of the audience have any queetiona7
13 qu..Uon..
14
10
MR. MALEI Jonathan Hale. How many bay. at
l7 thie raol11ty are there? How many pllce. Ire there for I
1. traotor to pull up and ba unloaded?
U
30
U
U I belleva,
OIl
24 qAte?
3~
THI WITNUII. I think ..ven, 1 think.
HR. HALE. levln. I. that the -.
TIU: WlTNU'H 1 balieve thue'. eight of them,
HR. M^L~I Where the tractor. pull into the
THe WITH~~~I On both lidel ot the buildinq w.
"""'"""""c;ntr'.iY-.;.""IIIV \11"" I "riii'irt' ..l'ortifi'J'~.'rvTc;.~'~""'--'
11111 JOdi- It.... 1
19
1
HR. HA~~I BO it'o pooolbl. that lt m19ht be
3 unloaded at 61001
1
4
TUE WITNUlll Veah.
II
HR. HA~EI How about 10100 lit nlqht?
THE WITNr:ISI No.
HR. MALE. 80 the lateot that it would evor be
6
., aotuallY unloAded would be uouAlly about 5100, 41001
.
TilE WITNltllSI I think on thelr buoy tlm.. they
. aiQht be . 11ttle later than that,
10
MR. MA~II Thank you.
TilE CHAIRMAN I Any other qu..tton. trom .ny
11
la .e.ber of tho aUdienoe?
11
HR. DI.TLINII Ve.. I'm John Bl.tline.
14 Old you eVer have rlve tractor-trailer. there
10 At one Uae1 Do.e Mtnney have rlve traotor-trailere?
16 TilE WITNEIIII We u..d to. Yeah, WI had at
17 l.ut tour in then.
11 HI', IHIIT&.INII lut did you haVe two .-
l' Tilt: WITNElI' Well, w. had out. ide coaplnie.
ao 00.il\9 1n Ind loadinq out, too,
H Hit, BIIITLIN!' Wh. t.1
U THE W1'fNn1i1l It tl.lot Wit,,,' t, only IClnney in
U th.r.. WO had out.llla 1.1011I51.,,1.. co"'lnq in hlluUnq our
u .tuff (lllt,
n
Hit, DlnT~IN~f ~yt I ",..n ~~
.M..'".~,..___~ __'c<",'_" """ ~.. .;"'0 '_-~ - '.", "".' ......'.. -'-'C'.'" -, ,..___._.._,.,:....'..,..,.~ _,~,,___,.'C'""_.'"'.""
t'."fu i rllM'iy I \I"" 4 I;OYH p.v'H'iln'J lh.rvi~'.ii
IIPI J'ill.wn
21
1 HR. DENNISI Were all of thol. bay. in
a operation at one time or did you routin.ly ule the baya on
:I the aouth aide And at different tlme. ue. the bay. on the
4 north .lde? Could you give u. an indioation?
lJ Tllr: WITNESS I It depended on where our load wae
6 golng, where they were .toring it in the war.hou... We'v.
7 u.ed all .i9ht doora. It ju.t depended on what d4Y and
8 what load WI' golng to what eeotion ot the warehoule. And
9 then we would ..
10
HR. DENNISI 80 I'm olear on thi., wal it that
II you would OOme in on maybe the north lid. where there
la would be tive bay., truck I would drop and unlold their
13 ware.? Onos thlt eide ot the warehou.e tllled up, there
14 would be no activity on thlt lide beclu.e you would be
10 unloldinQ on the .outh .ide? Or WI' it I mix and match?
u
Tille WITNItI1I1I It WU kind ot I mix. A lot at
17 tlm.. We'd take our load. in on the .outh .ide, and we'd
1. tlke them out on thl north eld. a lot ot time..
11
30
HR. OlNNI81 Think..
TilE CIlAIRHAlh Any other qUlltton.? Hr. Ollvi.,
31 We think you very much for your Information and tor your
JJ attendanol tonlQht, ThInk YQU, .lr.
;u
HM, WtlNOAMTtNI N..t, I would like to cIll Hr.
H IUoh Evan..
n
'fllf: CtlAHOIANI 1'11I lorry. old lom.one el..
"~"'c;nrr~rr;nn'~vrv-..;' i ;"i'tll,"it' '''.,lQrt fn.j"r4.rv i e'.ij'~--"-"'"'
unl ,I'\8-1t.'\/
:n
1 aotivlty within a neiqhborhood to refer the matter a.
2 provided by the ordinance to the Planninq Commi..ion tor
J ite input? We would request that that be done,
"
And %'m eort of oonoerned that we're Qolnq to
o 90 movinq ahead directly without th.t, It ...m. that Hr.
6 O.nni., if he ie in raot overruled, the ev.nlnq could b.
? .pent with oth.r c...., but if h." not, then in fact
I would 90 with the .p.olal exo.ption and the Plannlnq
, Com.i..lon ehould be con.ult.d.
10
Till!: CIlAIRHANI I undentand. You mean
11 overrUled on the 1eQal i..u. of the Incr.... In houre
la beinQ an ekpan.ion1 I und.r.t.nd.
U
14
MR. MOIUUNTIIALI That'. cornct.
TilE CHAIRMAN I And we would taka the leqal
10 chall.nQe up flr.t in our dl.cuaaion. but it" b..n our
16 ekp8.1ence that many timoa th. r.oord on the other factual
11 di.put.. help. U8 .harp.n the 18qal laau., And that
11 .ound. like le9al..e, but I really don't think It ia. I
l' think It'. helpful to UI.
ao ..aondly. we have when we 'elt It appropriate
al And we are aWAf. ot th. requirem.nt it there i. qOinq to
22 be. deoi.ion tnet It i. . continuinq UI. or we'r. 90109
2l to ~ra"t a epeele. 8Xclptlon It W8 rind that th.r. ~.
l4 ~..n an exp4nalQn ~Q ay~.I~ the 841'0' to the 'l.n"i~
~. CQ..i..lon. ANt we U.".f~lly ~~ we foliow the I'atut. .~1
~-~---.~"------_.'
.-,...-,.._-.....,
-~;rl~r-..I "."'1MY "~1'I14 f"Nif It"~"n~in;i ~.";vr;;;'~~~""'~~
Pill /'1"..",.'11
24__
1 that would be one at the etepe that we could take in our
2 deliberatione.
3
HR. W~lNaARTEN' And on that leeuQ, we
4 coneidered that. And, obviou.ly, it i. at the option,
, it'. not a requirement, that the Plannlnq Commi.eion
6 review it, In tllct the ordinance refer. that lt would
7 only be ln thoe. cae.. that would have, quote,
. wide-ranQinq efteot., I'm not eure that the eKpan.ion at
9 the hour' or . prevloue nonoontorminq u.e ln tact ie
10 wid.-ranqinq efflcte.
11
Till!: CHAIJ\HAN I That'. another l..ue that
1:1 .ometllll.' a factual pre.entation help' u. .harpen our
13 judQIlI.nt. 80 let u. proceed.
14 (Rlchard Evanl Will .worn. I
1Il THE CHAIRMANI And would you identity your.elf
16 with your n... and your addre.., .ir?
17
TilE WITHE'" My nue 11 Richard L, Even., I
11 llve at 331 North II.t Street in Carli.le.
19
Till: CItAIItMANI Thank you, elr. Couned1
20
;U MlC'H""D L. I:VANfI, ",aUed II a witn..., havlnQ
a2 be.n prevlou.ly duly Iworn, tl.ttti.d .e tollow"
2J I.WU;C'f r.XAHIHA'I'10N
24 IV HM, wtlHOAkTf.Hl
H
o
Anq, Hr, r.v4n., your .~ployer ,,1
_ """"-"'~~'...."'f'._~""~.",,,,,,~,,"'''''''~;~~'',",,.~::,,....=,,=,.....,~-c'.'C-=C'--".~."'<_.'-_'." ...~'."~.~..-.,~/,..^_~-"."...,..r'.,;n=."_.~'-_.>.,,.,.,.-"',,...'.,,"""'''''~-:--''<'''''''_'!:",.~'''->'W1~;I' ,1 -
C_ntr.1 r'nn.ylv~nl. Court M,purtlnq aerv 01.
P \1) H"-I6'H
"_.,...<-~,...="""
1
a
,
4
.
.
.,
.
--~,~.._. ,
A
o
A
IHnnlY IIhgl CQflIOUUon.
And your pOlltlon wlth ~lnn.y Iho. 1. wh.tl
TrUll. drivOf,
And how lon9 have you b..n with Kinn.y Sho.l
I have be.n th.re 1100e 19", March 'rd.
'0 ov.r Ii. ye.r. th.nl
Q
A
Q
It
o
UI h\ll.
An4 YO\l ar. fa.ilia, wlth the tor.er kinn.y
, v.r.nOUle on North oranq. Itr..t?
10
U
It
Q
V'Ah, I haul.d in th.r. quit. ott.n.
Could you aUCriN tor II' the 14.. that you And
U other d"he" that you art ,uiUar with hi VI I.d. of t.hqt
U 'eolUty?
If A ,..io.l1y the .... AI Hr. Harvey. Whln I w..
I' thlf., I hA4 'Y .p.oitlo t.otori.. thl' I hauled out of
'I In'. th' Tho,,. Pl.t,iDYtion .r... At. any 9iv.n diY, I
11 WI' In 1n4 out of th.fl, uh "fOY, 10, 11 ti....
III
"
1I@ .t Iny giv,n d.y you .iqht hlv. N.n in Ind
" out of th.t p4rti~ullr Ilol'lty 10 or " tl...,
ao
n
A
o
V..n, ln I aay" ti.. ...y.
Ana wh., w~y.d ~ th. ..rl1." tt.. of d.y thl'
Ii Yllli ww14 MV. J;uft Hi.'"
H
A
_fill, t~'f~ tMWI,4t 'n, ,." QQwpl_ y..r. I
i+ w~f_44 44Y. .'4J.l~J 4~~. 4 ,~ ,~. ~rni"q. 'Q I w4.
ii ft!iiM~\Y Iii".' Uin_ 4f W, ~HJfJ, .'U., hi alof .. tuB...
t'lil1.U 'tjI,'!i"'tt"'.":4 ~!.~H~.i~ifnf'j;J 1I.,yi.'....
. !illl J'tft'l"'l~ .
26
"~-~-~..,,-----~_.....,...-_._-._-,---,---,_._.,-,,~--,~.._~-.,<-,---.~.",---_."y
1 or plok on. up, take It to CAmp Hill, brinQ it baCk/ ju_t
2 . nayole of trail_ra all the t1me, unloAdinq and lOAdlnQ
:) baok up.
4 Q And the lateat time durin9 any partioular day
II that you m1\Jht have b.en there?
6 " Probably around 6100 in the even1n9.
7 0 And I 9UI.. ju.t to addre.. .ome ot the
. que.tion. that WeU .ddr..I.d prevtou.ly, WI' thl. even
9 durinv the la.t teW montha? WI're not talkin(j about an
10 old un?
11
"
M1Qht betore they were 010e1n9 up, yeah, I
11 wa... in the procI.. of movlnq ahoel, I wa. the tlr.t one
11 to .tart .. tar .a pullinCJ .hoe. out. They'd have
14 tr.l1er. 10a4ed. I'd piok th.. up .arly and (jet the. out.
u
o
And, once '\Ja1n, in term. of your av.raIJe day,
16 w.e it your typloal day to be there at 11100/ or wa. that
17 an ab.rration?
11
"
Well, on the average, three or tour day. a w.ak
l' d.pendlnQ on what loaa WII to be moved to the Klnney
ao War.hoUle ln .hire.anltown Of wherever it wa. .uppo..d to
U QO.
al
o
And, OM. IQ'ln, I uk/f'.1 the "\,jut hm Aboyt thu
J) truak. runnl~. WI. It tn. .t.~~.rd pr~otic. to le.ve the
a4 trUQkl rynninq or not?
;u
"
J nlv.r .hut mine dpwn, nQt unle.. 1 ~Ad tg p.
n'''~'''"''''~';"if~itl!l\fH.V I '''''1 it emit t ";~(';fil;;~J ~~fvlt;;;""'~""
IIPI ,1'\li<III'\1
27
1 ln the warehouse whl1. the truck wae being loaded. But
2 that waG during normal workln\J houre. ItI WaG picking up
3 a traUer, I never .hut It otf or swltohlnlJ traUen.
4 MR. WEt NO"RTEtH No further que.tlon.,
G TilE CIIAIRMANI Any member ot the Board have a
6 qu..Uonl Do.. any member at the audience have a qu..tlon
7 ot thi. witn...l
.
, BY MR. HOROENTIlALI
CROSS EXAMINATION
lO
o
Hr. Evan., do 1 under.tand your dutie. were
11 .lightly differlnt from tho.e of Hr, Davi., that you drove
12 .horter haul. tor Kinney?
1)
A
Yeah, there toward. the .. well, the la.t thr.e
14 year., I've ba.ically been the jookeYlIIan.
10
o
You hauled betwean the OranIJe str.et raoll1ty
16 and where .1.el
17
A
Betw..n "nd.r.on Plant on the Ritn.r and the
11 OrlnQe Stre.t warehou.e.
1t 0 10 ju.t withln the Carli_ie areal
20 ,. That'. ri\Jht.
J1 Q Were YClU ever there at, laY, midniqht durlnQ
n tho" l..t tlW month..,
U ,.. NO, l've never be." there at lIIidn1t:}ht that I
a4 gIn rem..ber, Hy hlul It4rt,4 e4r1y ln the lIIornlnq.
n
Q
~Q you W'fl!, Ilk., trom l\IQrnlnq until 4 1n the
~~'j"'."<,,_"";'("".!'~";".')''-'''','''T''''''''''''''''''~~:~'''-.:'''-,.,.._"'-,..,_.,,......:._.-.,--...."-..-~".,:".~;..--.".-".,~.-"'~,_.,~~~~"'-~._.._.,--.....~_.""-""------""'""."'=''''''''~"""'.'~'-""
u .,..,. Cl",tr," ".nn~yl\l'Hdl\ l,'ourt ".,,{lft imJ .ervie.. " '
(lPII'%Il.llilij'
- ~8
\ Ift.rnoon"
a A Ye., w.U, lO-hour l"lye.
, Q Do you know how MAny a.llverie' total were IlIAaa
4 to thAt wAr.hou.. durin, the pour.. ot the d.y?
IS A
DurtnQ the Q(ll~ne of the dAY? Well, it
Ju.t like Mr. DAV1. Itat.d, dep.ndinQ on where
. vari.d.
7 the .hoe. w.r. .uPPoI.a to ~g, you know, diotat.d how ",.nv
. load' went wh.r..
. 0'0 thlt WI' a vArilbl.-typ. thinQl
10 A It WI. . vArtAbl.-type thinq. It could b. a.
11 hi~h A', lik. I .tatea, 10, It lOAd. a dlYI or it aiQht
13 .nd up thr.. or tour IQAa, I dav.
l} 0 You .ay not know thi.. but I'll a.k it anYWAY,
14 Do you know if th.r. are r.Qord. k.pt that .how.a how ..ny
l~ d.llv.ri.1 W.f. 1A4., ,av, duri~ th. pI.t two y.ar. or '0
l' p.'or. Minn.y .hut th. op.r.tion Qown1
11 A A~' the only r'~fd. that would ~ .. thAt I
1. oould think ot would P' th. ..., ~k r.pord..
"
ao
And wha' i. th.'"
o
A
W.'l, th.t'. .. w. ~V~ .h~. fro. And.r,on
11 fl.nt ov,r t@ thl f~rf' Pl.'r'~"~". Ali tr."er. hAv.
al to.. ...'~J. .~ W8 '""f ,~ ~'4i n~~r IN4 "~n th~
Il '"""'1 ,q ",
;It
I'
Q
,.,.4 wM 4.,J l~..." ,;;. 4HVf;ur
.\
Pf''t~fi 14ft/V.., U.M !11ft .~.., .'"~ '"* 'flt"k,
--..
too"",..l t"'\""d.'~fq,~ f';..~H ..,..t;<+.HI'..j \'llOf\lh'\iI'!i
liPl jHdJC'l'
1 like to OAIl i. Hr. Pen TAVs, T-A-V-S.
2
TItE CHAIRMANI Hr. TAV" it you would rain
3 your rlqht hand and be .worn by our ooun..l,
4
IS
(p.n Tav. wa. .worn.)
THE CIIAIRMAN. Thank you, dr, Would you
e pl.... identify your..lf with your name and addre..?
7
TilE WITNE881 Bin Tay., 12U Ritner lIiQhway,
. carll.le, PA,
,
TilE CHAI RMAN I Thank you v.ry much. coun..l?
10
11
BEN TAYS, called a. a witn..e, h.vinQ b.en
1a prevlou.ly duly .worn, te.tified A' follow.1
13 DIRECT EXAMINATION
14 BY HR. WEINGARTEN I
10
o
Hr. Tev., would you pl.... t.ll the Board who
16 your .mployer 1.7
17
11
11 'hot?
ao
21
U
A
o
IUnnev Shoe.
And what i. your ourrent po.ition with Kinney
2'
A
o
A
o
lIuperlnt.nd.nt.
And how lon9 have you h.ld that poeitlonl
Tw.nty-thr.e y.Ar..
Were you a lup.rlntendant both at the .. I
a. qu..., what 1. your current looatlon thAt you're
l~ .uplrlntlnd.nt At, currlnt plant location?
"~', "...... .......".. ....-..-...",.,,~-,., --""''',-,,-~'''-'''''' , ., - 1
('Int,..l "_""'Iylll""'" coun JcepQninQ '.ry 0..
(IP) 4U"li'''''
~,~ ,.~~c,,_,.,.-_- ,-,0-; _. ..
30
~_.,-.
1
2
3 Hay of 19941
4
5
___~_._~__'~.- .!1
A
Ritner "lqhway, And.r.on.
And wh.re were you a luperintendent prior to
Q
A
Oranu. 8tr.et, p,arord.
AOIl .0 YOIl wire tll. plant .up.r inundent At
Q
6 Kinney'. rorm.r North Oranoe .trelt wArehout.?
7
8
II
10
A
Not warehouI'.
o
A
Q
I'm .orry, ror th. faoil1ty, fActory?
Ril)ht.
WhAt u.e wa. .ade of th.t 'Aollity by ~inn.y
11 that you ar. aWAre of? lort of 'MplAin your role in the
12 Kinn.y ,aoilltv.
13
A
Well, .y role i. .akinq tho.. and tht' in tht
14 Bedford Plant, And I had nothinq to do with the
15 war.hou.e, nothinQ what.oever,
16
o
Pllt with ,e'plot to the faotory op.ra'10nl
17 which ar. on the .1.. pi.oe of Qround AI 'he WArehuule,
18 what ti.e wOllld the ..plovee. co.. '0 that rlol1i'y? wn.t
19 would be the earltl.t that an ,.,ioy., WQuid ~ tt the
20 faotory?
21
A
ror V"f' we worked frg. 1'00 '0 ),10 'iy, day.
22 a w..k. And in the illllt Hut. HI '~ur V'",, WlIi t,>tlIfM!f4
2) our workiwl hgur. frql .,}O ~"tl& .Iij~ f~if 4"11 If W...
24 and "00 to 10'00 QO fridAY.
n
Q
And wlr. there tt... ~Ci~" ~, tn. 'l'~l~i.
-~"~"''"''\;;';n-tf; ( tlll1fHiy i~..,,-i~ ff"!fi ~;t'~'fH,,'~
1'1'1 J~4<h""
3J
1
2
Q
What type of thing. did they oomplain about?
Well, they complained about the air
A
J conditionlng runnlnQ at night. And when we put up the
4 floOdllQhte, .ome of them complained about the
~ floodlighte, We had .everal complaint..
6
7
HR. WEINGARTEN I No further qu..tione,
THE CHAIRMANI Any member of the Board have a
8 queetlon of thie wltn..e?
,
HR, KOSCO I What were you able to do about the
10 complaint. you received?
11
THE WITNESS I Well, the air oondltionlng we put
13 a box around it to try to quiet it down, but the
l3 tloOdllght., there wa. nothing we eQuid do about that.
14
U
16
HR. KOSCOI Think you.
TilE CHAIRMANI Hr, Denni."
HR. DENNISI Are you aware of what the total
l7 .quare footage of thi. bulldinq le"
11
19
THE WITNESSI No, .tr, l'm not.
HR. DENNISI Vou t..tlfted that there were two
20 U.e. at the faotlity when you were workinQ there. Ther.
al wal a manuraoturtnq ule and warehoy.tog u.e, i. that
ail cornat"
;n
H
THE WITNt;tI'l Y",
HR. D~N"l.1 Could you ..tie.te the p.rc.nt4q8
~~ of the .quare rootaqe that w.. u.ed tor the manutaoturlnq
_''''-''''~_,,,c-- ~:<-_"~,,.,__,,,,",_,_~,,_,~,,,,,,_,_,,,,_,,,,,,,,_,,,,,_,,,,,,,_~"".-,.....~,i.'"'_'. ..,.."."'-'c '__""T''''--'-._'''_''--'-'':-'-'''.'''''''-'''~''' :""",>'"T"'''',.,,='''-.... _,,_ ",,: _0' .0 ....- .' .. ,...:. ~-'"-'. <~
.' --.c_n~f.lr~nn.ylv4ni4'rourtM~p~rtln~ ~~rv,~~~-
(1111 J"jft-If;";1
14
__,_....__._,.-~...,-....... _.~_...,..~__,_____~_.'_._"~_......,.,__~_.,.,.-,-_,~.,, "c.."" _,__~,__..._..,~'-><'c~_.."u_._ "
1 u.e and the plrcentlQe that wa. u..d tor the wlr.hDuelny
3 u..?
1
THI W1TNl... No. The only thlnQ I can tall
4 you i. thlt th. ..nutacturinQ w.. probably like twloe what
a th. di.trlbution.
.
MM. OlNNI.. H.nuf.oturlnq wa. twioe the
., .mount of the di.tributton?
.
THI W1TNlI.. I'd "'1 poe.iblv. Ve.. oloe. to
, It.
'0
MM. OrHHII. At whit polnt did Minnev 'hoe.
'1 .hut down it. oper.tlooe" Po 'Iou know the epeolfio aat..
11 the ti...,
u
THI WITH&... It WI' th. tlr.t of the year.
'4 No, I oouldn't t.ll VO~ that,
It
MM. OINNIII At the \1.. thtt it w.. .hut dgwn,
.. would that .t'~.f4 .tl11 'PPlV that th.r. WI. twic. the
" aaount of ..nuf.@'ufl~ 'plel .. th.re w.. W'f.hou.i~
11 .,.0.'
It
30
II
fH& WlflllUf VtI.
Nfl. (jiMNHII I MY' M fYr'htlf "u..U""..
'"I f""I~1 Anv ...IHf of th. .vd'."". h.Y.
JI .nv qUI.tl@n_1
n
;U 1ft HIt. N()"i;l~"'''W''/''!
J~
~~~~ ~~~I"'AflvH
Q
Nfl f~/~. .~ ,,~. ~~~~'4~.ijf~~1 @, ~~
4',,~,i..l h.lifoiit 1...."1.. ~:...!,. ".f~H 'i~.j~~;ivr~;~
. {it" ''Hd~';!' '
35
1 manutaoturinQ of .hoe., is that riQht1
a A RiCJht.
) 0 And were you in charCJ8 ot both operationl1
4 A No, .ir, I had nothlnCJ to do with the
D warehoU.e, nothin9 what.oever.
& Q What WII your epeaUla job, just the
., manufaoturing part?
.
,
A
Q
Vsa, sir.
Po a. far as the operation or the war.hou.e,
lO that Wa' eomebody else'. job oompletely1
11
12
U trucks?
14
111
A
Q
I had nothinCJ to do with that.
Did you have anythlnCJ to do with .chedulinCJ the
A
Q
No, .lr.
Dld you malnta1n any record. a. far a. Wh.n
11 d.liverie. were .acte?
1'1
11
A
Q
No, .1r.
The worker. that you were aWare ot who were in
l' there at 2 I.m" what did they do aCJaln?
ao
u
n
u
^
Q
^
Q
They were .tlt~her..
n.wln~ maohine operator.?
Ve..
And the on.. that would be 1n later, ..Y,
a4 around mldniqht or 80, they w.r. ~~
n
A
They Q4.. in at 4 And left At mi4niqht.
"'~~"~~"~;"t'f'..r'~;"";'vr..i';;nT; c;;~;r~'.;J;I;fiin'~ ~"I'V Poll..
(1111 J,\I~I~!\I
1
:I
3
Q
And what kind of worker. were they?
Computer .titcher..
A. rar as the location within that building,
36
4 which .ide -- north, which would be toward Louther street,
5 or .outh toward. the Ritner -- waG the manufaoturing on?
6 Wa. it broken down, like, part building for manufaoturing
7 or warehou.e?
8
11
Q
A
No, no. The Pedford Plant waG all one plant.
9 It wae two .eparate bulldlng..
10
11 location?
12
13
14 lot..--
l'
o
WaG the Bedford Plant at the orange stre.t
16 street.
17 0 rront of Oranq. street?
11 A ,tight.
11 0 And then chat WI. the .anufaoturin91
20 A ye.,
at Q And then the wlrehou.e WI. where, in the re.r?
aa A lIehlnd.
2) 0 Do you know or anybody who would have record'
24 of the nu",bn or truck. thlt vl.1Ced that .ite ..ch day?
n
A
Right.
Wher. Wa. that bUlldinQ then relative to the
Q
A
The Bedford Pul1dlnQ i. on the front at Oran;e
A
I'. Bure the ai,pltcher It the Ander.on
"_m~~~c.nfr ;r'iin"_vTv-;nT 4' {,;O" r-i-JC.p{jrtr,,~i' i.iv l{JI.
l't'l ~~.-}'" '
37
1 Bulldinq, I'm Bure they have records,
2
Q
"
But that wasn't your responsibility?
3
No, dr.
4
&
HR. HOROENTHALI Thank you.
THE CHAIRMANI Any other member of the audience
6 have a qu.stlon of this witne.l?
7
HR. BISTLINEI Isn't it true when you made
8 sho.. there and parked all the carl in the parkln9 lot of
9 your employ.e., that 9ate that came in from the we.t end
10 had a biQ si9n, No Truck Entrance, didn't it? You earn. in
11 around the .outh .1dl, didn't you?
13
13
TltE WITNESS I There were e1lJn., ye., Ilr.
HR. BI8TLINF.1 There were e19n. up that .ald,
14 No Truok Intranc.. That wa. when -- beoau.e there wa. .0
1& .any car. I !Jue.. they didn't want to take a chance.
16
17
11
19
THE WITHEJ81 But truck. did 90 through there.
HR. PI.TLINEI Yeah, they came out that way.
TItE CHAIIUtANI Hre. Dhtl1ne1
HR'. DI8TLIHEI t have a que.tion. Of all the
ao peoph, how .AIIV till" did VOU qet cOlllpla1nte about the
a1 noi.. from your truck.? In .11 tho.e y.ara, how many
2a complaint. did you qet?
:n
24
;Ii
THE WITNE'" Actually, 1 can't .ay I ever did.
"~., BISTLINEI Thank you.
THE CUAIItJlfANI Any othu llllJllbtlr of tho ludhlnc.
---~~-~"-~~-'~c.nt r.T"'.f,n"yT';;"f"eQ\j'ri"tr*partfn;j"ii.rvL 11..;---- .
(lP) ~,.-ll\\n
39
1 havI A qUI.tlen ot thl wltne..' Mr, D.nni.. you had ·
a qu..Uon?
1
HR. D&NHtel You hid atat.d that ther. woe a
4 .anutaot"rlnQ and a w.r.hou'lnQ "I' at the fAOility.
5 Would it b. loo"r.te to "Y that tho wlr.haulinQ "Ie w.,
t aoo.,eory to tho .lnut.oturln9 u.el ror .xa.pl., wlthout
1 the aanuraoturlnQ UI' th.ra, thar. would hova be.n no
I w.r.hou.inQ operational
.
10
TUI WIT"'U" 'Hqht.
HM, DINNt" '0 tha wlr.nou.inq WI' aotulllv ot
11 th. Qoo4. thli w.r. produold on .ita and w.r. iakan to
13 oiner loeationa?
n
THI WITHC'" Hot onlV 'adrord ~t fro. th.
14 ,..t of our f.atorie. thrQuQhout thl .tat..
It
M.. PfHHI', Thil WI' not I ol"tr.l Ihippinq
,. lQQ.tion for you or Iven I r~ion.l di.'r'~tion point
11 wn.r. you would PI r~,'YI", 'Inllh.a ..te,ll', thlt you
'I vould~' 'IndifiQ on to oth.r 'o~.'ion', would tn., Df
it ftO"."u
JO
II
II
THe WITNI~II VII.
"~. P~HHI~I Tn.nk y~.
TNI ~I~I Jij,'.Q I .. Vi~ ..'4 1\ WI' ftOt
'1 ,~, 'Y'~ ~"4~~,~,yl W4_ tR4' vq~, ~~..'l~hJ
u
fH~ Wlf"~~~1 ~..,
fH~ ~HA1~AHf 4~t~H. .,.. 'R 'R* ~~,.~.1
-.
4.
(C,UI"'" 'Ii;'...;. d"',jll4 "'~'Jf~ /l\ll~...!"i~~it.f-ir,;~.-
t" I ,'U dllo"l ,
)!I
1 V.a, alr.
2 HR. 800TIl, My name ia Ilarry Booth. I live at
3 681 W..t Louther street. Would it be poulble through
4 .om. flQure. or other to determIne ho.... heavy II load would
, be tor a tractor-trailer carry 1 ng .hoee'f
6
TilE WITNRSSI I couldn't an.....ar that qu..Uon.
1 I have no Idell.
.
HR. 800TIl' It you don't haVe it In your helld,
. would it be pO.libl. to tind that out at lomo point?
10
THE WITNESS, Po..ibly, t don't know, Maybe
11 on. ot the truok driver. could poe.lbly tell you.
12
HA. 1I00Tltl I' III Int.r..tod becau.e it .e.m. to
13 me that there miQht be eome .1gnlficance in the ditference
14 1n wliQht between. traotor-trail.r loaded wlth appl..aue.
II or apple juice in qla.. contaln.ra on the one hand and a
U traotor-trailer 10Adod with" tryIng to tiquu out Why W/I
17 d1dn't hear one and do h.ar the oth.r.
11
TtU: WITHUIJ, Th. weiQht, 1 ....ouldn't th1nk,
19 would have Inythln9 to do with it. I'm not II truck
30 drlvlr, .0 I don't know.
u
Tlla: CIIAI JiHANI You ..... utievlIla you're not
U lnvolVlrJ with the wAuhou.inq, too. 'fhAt (HIm. aoro.. loud
U iln4 Qlen.
H
U
TK~ WITU~a~1 I'm not.
THe CHAIJi~AHI Any other I..p.r ot tn. audi.nce
""-'-:'~,"'"""'~~"~'~"'fo~~T"'':'''''''':."""",,,~/eI''':;,'''''"'''.'~''''''''':'''-.~~-,":...".-.,,:t'~':'';''f'7'''-'er'''''''''-''''''':~'~"""'="'C""--r""=-~""'~'-"'''''''''''':~!'''''''''''''''~''''';E''m-~F>O'''''=~'=""'=,c"..-",e'
(,,/'It"'l hnnllylv"l'Iu\ \~mlft IillJ1ortll'lIJ hfVH'"
If PI HII-I,.,,,
40
1 have a question ot thia witn..s?
a
HR. GIORDANOl Hy na~. i. D~Ve Giordano, I
3 just had a queet10n to clarity your an.wer to Hr. Dennis'
4 que.tlon, Did you .ay that you did .tore .ho.. that wore
5 made in other ~anuracturln9 plante or did not?
6
7
TilE WITNESSl Ve., we do,
HR. GIORDANOI So in other place. where you
. manutaotur.d .hoe., you had .tored tro~ there. And then
9 truok. oame and dropped them off And plokld them up?
10
11
13
THE WITNESS I Y...
HR, OIORDANOI Thank you.
TtlE CHAIRMANI Thank you. That help. me. I
l3 va.. little oontu.ed after the answer,
14
Any other questions, members of the Board, ot
15 thi. witn..s or trom the aUd1enc.? Hr, Tay., thank you
l' very much. We appr.ciate your appearanoe and your tlme.
17 And you, too, may leav8 lt you'd like and m1s. our
1. intelli9snt and le9al dl.ou..ion at the end of ths
l' .veninQ. EverythlnQ'. a trad.-orr,
30 Coun.el, n.lCt whn...?
at
H~. WEINOARTENI Hy next witn.sl i. Michael
32 JudQe from All.n Dl.trlbution.
U
H
(Mlch.ll JUdql wa. sworn.)
Till CHAI~MAHI Pl.... idlnttfy vours.lt tor tho
a. r~ofd with your n4.1 .rnt .dar..., .1f.
""'--='.eli,~=,~""'~"'".Tr ,~",,,,~,"""'_'''='-''''''''~~'''',','''-:C~'_-' _.,,,:..f,'- """," :";-'-_'"-',,,'^~'-"'-""""'-";"-"'-"~"'-"""~.-"~'-~'-~""'~-""":",'~'^"""'~"""''''''''''r''"f''''''~''''-'''''''"'''-''
.. ,. cantut ...,w....iv..nilt CO\IH IhtfmH inq li.ry'~"
pit) ill'JIl-)UI
1
41
TilE WITNESSl My name ia Michaol Judge, 6105
2 Ilaymarket Way in Meohanio.burg, Pennaylvania.
3 MR. WEUlGARTEN' As an initial matter, I'd like
4 to point out that I'm planning to recall Mlohael with
II reapeat to the apeclal exclptlon. 80 we'll deal with the
6 appeal and then I'd 11ke to recall Michael ror the
7 .peoial-eKception portion of the caal.
8
9
HICIlAEL JUDGE, called aa " witne.., havinq been
10 prevlou.ly duly .worn, te.tifiad a. fOllow.'
11 DIRECT EXAMINATION
12 BY HR. WEINGARTEN.
1)
14
1!l
16 what?
17
11
Q
A
Michael, you are employed by whom?
Allen Dl.trlbutlon.
And your poaitlon with Allin Diltribution il
Q
A
The g,nerll managlr.
Q
And how long hive you been with Allen
19 Di.trlbutlon1
20
21
A
Q
SiN and I hilt Yllr.,
And are you tAmil1ar with the tor.er Kinney
22 wAr,haule on North Orange _treet?
u
u
A
Y,a.
o
Cln you d..crlb. the Actual Allen Dl.trlbutlon
a~ lotlvitl...t thAt War.hau.., what type ot qoo4, .na hour.
W~~"""w"c.;;r;tf;r-t.""~'y"I\I"" " "ourt iC;i;(jfHr1,i''''iS"..rvl'Q';.''''''''h'
111'1 .lU-Il\!\ I
42
__"h"""""".."'
1 or operation and so forth?
2
A
Allen Distribution ie in the public warehousin9
3 and di.tribution business primarily slrvin9 the Qrocery
4 clientele wlth dry-grocery and beverage produQtl. We
5 leased the former Kinney faoility as an overflow facility
6 due to lack of space at our core facilitie' and u.. it ta
7 .tore excess inventories of produots, primarily
8 appl.-harvest produots coming out af Adam. county ri9ht
\) now, apple.auce. and apple juices,
10 Q And when you lnitlally took over the faoility,
11 how would you compare your use at that time to its current
12 and probable expected future U18?
13 A W.ll, the f4011 i ty that We occupy 18
14 approximately 70,000 Iquars fe.t. I'm not surs what the
15 total property is, but that'. the portion that We'V.
16 l....d. Naturally, when We took lea.. or the fAoility, it
17 wa. .mpty. So for the fir.t many week. or oocupancy We
18 had a nood of product into the raoillty to fiU it uf"
19 That w.. driven bV two f'I'lts, the t.ot that w.
20 were payinCJ for It llnd the hot th.t it w.. .ppi. huv.u.t
21 time. And when the apple crop com.. In, .ppl."'uQ(I .n4
22 apple 1u1c& have to hi proc...14 rather quickly an4 put
2) into .tof491. 8ubs.quunt to 'LllLnq the '4ottity, our u..
24 i. now on 4 much mQr. r..trl~t.q b4.i., tYPlc411y Qn 4
)~ .ingll.shitt ba.i. typically .t4,tiKI ~y on. or \w@
('.nt rat ""llr1l1ytv4ni.. (\l\IH ""fIl1f tlft1t Ill.fv ~1n
(111) )'';11-11'1'\1
----- -
1 e.plovee. .nd with a qreAt reduction in the Amount of
a produot 1II0vlnQ now primarilY outbound from the facility,
1
o
Could you qlV' the Board an id.a al to the
4 Av.ra,e houri with the und.rltandln9 that thlr. may be
I dlff.r.no.e d.p.ndinQ on the time of year and produot.,
. but the ld.a with re.p.ot to hour. of operatlon whln
1 truok' 001' in and wh.n thlv l..ve the facl1lty1
.
It.
W.'r. in thl ..rvlo. bu.in.... ao our hour. of
, op.rAtio~ ar. driv.~ pri..rily by our cu.to.er.' requ..t.,
10 wh.n th.ir productlon equip..nt i. runninQ, when it'.
11 pru4.nt for the. to .ov. pr04uot to the point of
11 ..nutaotuJ' to u. tor r.clipt .1th.r by th.ir own truck.
l} Of ~ out.ld. oar,l.r.. w. have to re.aln v.ry flexible
'4 1~ our hour. of op.rAtion.
1. Typlc.lly, how.v.r, ..peoIAlly wh.n we'r. out
,. 0' '1'1'1. ..a.on, w. c,.rat. nor..l bU.in... hour.
17 ."r..i..'elY lIQU I... hI 1I}(J p... And thAt'. w.1Qht'l~
I' PV lAVln'O"'I, ~V n.~1. t@ 1II0V. produot rOf ..1.. to ·
I' ~f"~wl.f ~li.nt.l., an4 oth.r factor. that .ril..
aO
.ot to 11"'44 the a~ard, pqt th.r. ar. tim..,
{I
'1 u.~'ly 11~Q ,~ llJU .. th.r. wlil ~ tll11.. d.p.n4i~J on
II .~ ~~. ., yuur ~ll'"'. '~4' ~. w~ll ~ ~u~n ~r.
II ....~ .~" 1,~4 '" l'J~1
H
.
"'" .h,
I'
Q
.,. t~ ~~4f. Mf ~YhQ.rn. ~.ff'.8~ Py .n.
f.iH,,.i r!O/\I\4, 1~"l\i'" 1;'"..." jjl!il'l;f~ ir"j ";f~T;;;;'---""
ttltl ~'tt<Ti,,~~
4J
44
1 n.lghbors?
:I
A
Pefors tonlght we were made aware of them and
3 they've been relnforoed tonight.
4
Q
And have you attempted to address tho..
5 concern. in any way?
6
A
C.rtainly. Allen i. a relatlvlly stable
7 bu.ln... in the Carliel. area havlng flr.t opened In
8 November of 1981. W. are a substantial employsr and a
, 'Ub.tantial tax reV.nuI producer for both the Borough ot
10 Carli.l. and South Hlddl.ton Town.hip.
11
W. have faoilitle. looat.d on Shearer Orive in
12 CarU.l., on Allen Itoad in llouth Middleton. And we have
13 l.a..d faol11ti.s in downtown carli.l., downtown
14 Mechanio.burq and Harrl.burlJ. 110 we au intimately aware
10 of the tant that w. need to ..tabll.h IJood-n.l\Jhbor
16 polioie.. We try .nd do th.t.
17 Our bu.ln,.. re.trlot. storal)' to nontlammabll,
11 nonha"rdau. \Jood.. And we try and operate our tacilltil'
l' 1n impeocabl. condition. in term. or .anitation ana
20 appe.rance. And w. think that W.'ve don. In Ad.quat. job
21 1n tryinq to alldr.l. 111 tho.e l..ue..
23 0 Are YOy t..l11.r -- lit .. thow you a oOPY of a
31 letter. Are you f.Millar with tht, letter that w.. d.tla
24 'apt..ber 16th .na w4. ..nt to one of your cu.to..r.?
JO
A
Y,., f plnn~l thlM letter.
"c="~==Cc,"fr';i",,,,,.yrvC~lliR ..CU\1 r t'-a(..;i;ia"qti;fy~lc;.."L'~'
PHI ;,11)....')1
45
1
Q
Could you ploAso read that to the Board?
Yes. This letter was written in response to
2
II
3 aom. dlscus.lons with Dave Giordano from Dickinson
4 ColleCJe' "Per our discu..ion of todAY we appreolate your
5 wlllinqne.s to work with Us in reducing the "noi.e"
6 generated at our newly acqulred Dlokln8on/Klnn.y
7 warehoua.,
8 "We understand that you will lnstruot your
9 driver. a. well as diepatcher. controllinQ outalde carrier
10 driVer. to .hut off All truok engin.. while .taglng,
II loadlnq, or unlOAding at the .ubjeot faollity. You wll1
12 further reque.t that th..e .am. qroupa uee the EMit 12,
13 J.'1 aceea. route to the Dlokin.on/Kinney warehou'l rather
14 thin driving throuqh Carll.le and moat .peoltloally on
15 Louther street.
16
"We underatand that you cannot ab.olutely
17 oontrol th8 .ituAtlon but qenulnely appreciate your
11 oooperatlon In rlque.tlnq complieno8 from all drlvera and
l' carrier. .ervlo1nq thl. faolllty, Kind reqard8, Allin
30 Ol.tributlon. Mlohael Judqe."
H
o
I would like to AotUAllV now lntrodUoe that
32 letter.s INhibit A, And t have oaple' af thls tor the
n ltoud.
u
Tilt: CUAlJUolM4, '('I)_t.I. tin.. It'e be.n A......clled
~~ to t.he AppllQltlon, And 80 Itl, alre.dy a part ot the
c,-,~c"'n"'~c;nir4Y' ~~~rl;i.y Tv~n I"chi\ir!; c~;llorcrrn;;~il;rvl Q..-"~'"""
t fll) J'\ih III'"
46
1 record,
2 PY MR. WEINGARTEN'
3
Q
To recap then, you have in faot while Kinney
4 actually typically left ita truck. runninq, YOU've
, actually In.tructed your ulere to turn ofr their truok.?
6
A
We did eo at the requeet of Dickineon colleq8
7 actinQ on the neiqhbore' reque.t., We had not In.truoted
8 them initially when we occupied the faoillty, We poeted
9 two liqnl, one at the main entrance qate and one next to
10 the Ihippinq and receivlnq offioe alia relnforcinq thi.
11 policy and hAve In.tructed our foremen at that taoil1ty to
12 11'0 lolicit the driver.' cooperatlon in that reqlrd.
13 HR. WEINGARTEN, I have no further que.ticne.
14 TUE CIlAIRMAN, Hember. ot the Poard? Hr.
15 Solomon, I think you had A queltion, .ir.
16
HR. SOLOHoN, Mr. Judqe, you indicated that the
l7 normal operatinq houri werl 7'00 ln the morninQ to 3'30 in
11 the atternoon. And OAn 1 a.lume from thAt that the truok
l' trafflo will occur durinq tho.e Ipeciflo houre?
ao
TilE WITNEllfll No, .ir. We do hAve arnnQemente
31 wlth outelde motor cArrier. to move the 10Adl in and out
U of the tAciUty. Ott;entlm18, it thly're Icheduled tor.
33 7,00 delivery or 1100 piok-up, they'll errlv8 prior to
34 that. jo.. of them trAVel lonq diet.nee.. And 7100 to
3~ 1110 hour. of operAtion are .- t don't want to ml.1,aa,
<
~.P-__C:~_.'C"''''''''''''''''''''''.'''''''''''C-","",,_''''''''''T_''"'''''~~'.'-C:.'''''''t"'CC-'C"'-'-.'-'::-""".:' "_0 -,','c.':.'C"''''':''''''':'" "~"'"'' ""_,~,,'r:e.,,.".._''''T''"'''._': ,-,"-'~_'___ _ _ .. :4.0 1
'-"ent.r.' hnnIlVP~i4I'1I" C\1urt hf'ordn'J ".":"{o..- ,--
(Ill) J!\li. 11\'(\1
_ _,n
,-..,."."""',-,-..,,"."......"
1
They're o~r norlllilll hOlln Qf op.utlon. W.
2 oould b. ..ked to ov.n iIlt .. a.lI. tOlllorrow mQr"infJ or work
, u"tl1 1100 tomorrow eveninq d.p.ndlnq on th. volulII. of
. pr04uot th.t "..al to b. r.l....d.
.
HR. IOLQMOHI Would you .IY thAt .. in th,
. MOrnl", to 1 at niqht would pe th. ep.atru. thA' you look
1 It tor the hour. or th. 1'"9th?
.
TIl& WITHt:1l1t1 (iulin... 1. dict.t,d bV
. OUI'OIll'f', It'. obvloully in OUr b..t tnt.r..t to
10 r..triot th' hour. to .. .lni..S amount du. to .. pur. 001'
11 i"UI, If nothlnq .1... lut w. h"vI to r..paot whl' thl
la ou.to..,.' ,Iqulr'.ent. .fl, 10 It" va,v h.rd for ~ to
II A".w.r.. qu.'tlon dlr,otly a. to IoIh4t th' hour. ot
14 op.r.tlon .rl. Typlo.11y not .. thlY would no' OQOUf a.
U ""liff ill dAV.
u
How.ver, thtr. ..V ~ oirou..t.~,. IoIhlr. ..
11 pfo.hl.'", P1A"t "..d. to IIWV. prcodytlt to u. on '"OM
1. .hltt ,.tn.f th." tiflt .n.i'\. '0 @Yf hOu,. 0' ~p.r.tiQn
I' Ifill 4., ..V P4 h..Yii, .....a t~lr4. tn. 11)0 to II ,..,
'0 .nifl, T~.(. .~V ~ ~if~v.,tA~. Wfft(. tn., n..a to ,l.ft
'I tQ ~y. fr~"~t'Qn in It .I~U @( ~!gQ in th. ~rnl~. 'Q
" W. w@ij&4 ~,.n -.f&"r 4~ "~.n '4'& @tt '@W.f4 .~ .fi4 of
n 4.4y IIMU,
;If
"~, ~~~JU! 1~"~ V~~, f~4' ~4f'4ln'v ~l'4f.
~~ \"4' ijf f~f M#, t., -. 4~_ 1~ '~M"! 1~4 l~tl~4'~ ye~
(~ki,~l ~~kk.flw~k . ~~4~' ~.,~'liRq ..fwl~..
t;~ ~ :';~~t~~j
_..JJI.....__ .
1 operAtinq hour. .re 7100 in the morning until ]1]0 in thft
2 att.rnoon but not durlng the applo ....on, it 1 und.r.too~
] you correctly. What would you '.Y would be your .urQo
4 p.riod in term. of the .ppl. ....on .urg.? 110101 many dAYII,
II how lIulny w.ek.? lIow woulrt you d..orlbe thl. period at
. ti.. and ite impact on your operation?
7
THE WITNESSI Th. fall .urge u,u4lly l..t.
1 AUQUlt, ~Iptemb.r, October And into the month of Novomuor
, to .om. eMtent, And that'. the tr..h appl. crop. Th.r.
10 i. al.o a qen.rou. amount at appl.. that .r. put into
11 t..p.nture-control1.d atorAg., And th.re'. uauaUv .
13 .eoond production run the .pring or tho y..r aom.time
1) around MAroh, April and into HIV. w. would eMpeat tho
14 blQQ." eurge. to occur .t tho.. two tim.. ot the y..r.
11 The other thing th.t ..ybe I ehould addr...
16 relevant to that i. that when w. fir.t occupi.d th.
11 facility, wo put produot. in th.re other than .pple
11 produot., produot. that mOVe on 4 continuou, b..i. thAt
l' don't hav. the .pike. and p.ak. that the appl. crop do...
ao Main, 1n try1nIJ to work wHh D1uk!n,,,n Colleq.
31 Ind wlth the n.iqhborho04 i..uee that wlr. betnq rai.ea,
n wo puUed .U HI. produl,lt U)., W. hAd put 1nto that
Zl fao1lity b4Uk out .nd .t.rt"a r"tQckin~ ~t wtth prQduQt
J4 th.\ w. thoY9ht would n4V. 1... turnQvIJr, 1.,. tr.qu.nQV
on 4",1 nltult In II (tlll.,.r {1(lltlut\QIl 'Hlf1 lnlt .Ulttyrp4Iwl! tP
-,.,c"..._,...(."ff~'i-~;nn..y 1 V4f'1 i.. t'O\1 r t It,,ptlfT ii\;j ,. ~.fyT~;.==-.,-_..
1111) ~'Ill<<IIl'H
49
....-..--~'"""~....-.-...,.----_..__.~~'~_.~.~._~_-.-_.-,...,
1 the neighborhood.
2
HR. SOLOHONI 1 appreolate the oomment. on that
3 and the ract that in the information we have been provided
4 there are other eKlmpll' or .tepe you've taken, I que..
o then, l.t .e .ummarl.e, that in yen.ral term. about hair
6 of the y.ar or .iK month. out of the year -- l.t me put it
7 that way becau.e it'. fall and .prlnq -- rouqhly .1K
. month. out of the year you have hour. that are yr.ater
, than 7100 in the mornlnq until 3130 in the art.rnoon ba.ed
10 on the n.ed. of your cu.tomer. in Adam. County?
11 TIlP; WITNESS I Correct.
12 HR. aOLOHONI And.o I appreciate the faot that
13 1 think I Qat a b.tter qrlp on .Kactly what the houre ar.
14 that you ar. lnd.ea ln bu. in.... Thank you.
n
TilE WITNESSI You'u w.lcome.
16 HR. ~O.COI Haybe you could juat clarlty for
17 .e, Hr. Judl,Je, .........l.t'.nlthl,. b4tt.WUn-lt>>eIHllM o.dlilu.,.
18 ....rev.., thl. letter you wrote blck on the 16th or
19 I.pta.ber.
30 TilE WITtll:8141 The leUer on the 16 or '.ptember
al WI' not _uppaled to id.ntiry the n..e of the account. If
aa It doe. on the copy, that'. an error. And 1'11 hope that
23 you will _trike thAt information trom tn. record. Our
~. oltent relAt1on.hip 1e oon(14,nt1.1.
a~ flit: CI<<AlICHAlfl W.'d k;. h4PPV to .trike th.
'"='="===="ClJnG;;1' '~fiInft.Y 1".-" \.. ~(;tiit"i;'i;{;l't\r;;J'~;rvTl;.;".m._~"=
(Ill, J~.'I"''';I
50
1 re1'ennce to the client tram the record.
a HR, KOSCO I So thie is some ~~ CAn 1 uk the
3 question then? 1. somebody ele. hauling your lJoode? Ie
4 that what this was about?
G TilE WITNESS' In moat circumstance., .omeone
II other than u. ie tranaporting the good.. W. de operate a
7 modeat-aize fleet of trucka ours.lv.a, but in mo.t cae..
8 that'. correct.
9
HR, J<OSCOI Dut YOU'll r.ceive throulJh other
10 trUCking firms good. to thla warehouII facility?
11
12
13 deal with?
14
TilE WITNESS' Cornet.
HR. l<OSCOI How many dltterent on.. woullS you
TilE WITNESS. On an inbound buh on the
lG produot comlno in, no more probably than two or thre., on
16 en outbound basie over the cours. of a y.ar, it could be
17 dOllnl.
11
HR. KOSCO I DO you write letter. slmilar to
19 thl. to everybody?
20
Tilt WITHE'S' In thil particular c.... thil
21 cUetomlf oontrol. all at the movemente or truckl, wh.ther
22 thsY're their own or outaldl haulsr.. They oontr.ot for
2J their s.rvlole. 80 by writinq to thle, w.'v. ..ked th..
24 to notify their carri.re.
;u
"14. I(Of;l('O, I .n. Thanl{ you.
..,. ,.. ---'"'--'''''''-?~'''~-'''''''''''''''.~''''''''''''''''
I;_ntu (''''"l1llyl''''''1I1 Court Ihlptlrtlfl\1 tit.'Vh!!..
PIll J'lll.lfi..,
-~"",,~~~---...._.,_._....,... .,
-
,.,,,~L,
\
THII: CIlAIIU4ANI And y"u'vII IlIluJlllentl11 thlllt letur
a wlth .1,nl on thl 'I" It..lfl II that Qorr.Qt1
)
4
TIlII: WITHI"1 Thlllt II oorrlQt.
TilE CIIAl~MANI WIU, I'. lorry I OAn't think ot
D any othlr qu.'tlon.. A' An attorn.y, I AlWAY' likl to
6 oro....M..in.. judql. tut I Qu.e. I hlllv. to PA" on
1 that. Hr. Orll11
.
MR. QMltLI Tne I.tt.r w.'e. tllllkin9 About i.
. d.tea I.pt..'.r '6th. Whln .tqht .o..on' -. wh,n do you
10 think your aotion. to r.auel tn. nol.. on thl ait. .. when
\\ would they have Peln efflotlvI1 Whln .19ht th.y hlllv. pe.n
13 I\"Uoe.bl.1
u
THe WITHe..! W. ~Ia two thlnq. to AotuAlly
'4 rl4uoe thl noi.1 on thl .it,. w. dld thi. lltt.r whioh
" .44r..... turniAq 01' th" .~Ine' ana po.tlnq th. .iQ"a to
'6 that effeot lAd rl4uQinq th. tfUg. 'r.ffio on Louthlr
11 .tr..t. Th. oth.r thl~ w. ~Id W.' f.,tock thlllt '.oilltv
II! whit prti4uot U\4' t\lfllfJ4 ov., IlIit ff~...mt1V. And \110
,,, U\f!ftf wn. ,,,g >lU,..,.", '"'Mil \;14\ t@('Ill 11'''(;1..
JO "~. Q~tlbl .n." 8"fg.,..'tiy W.. 'hAt. tn.
II r..tooll,~1
u
t~~ WllNt~~! f~' f'8t~lll~ WQ~'4 ~.v. ...~
;n j\l.' ,"IiI"""Y ..lftllllll"tilJ!./ ,~ tUf\it\U/fffl. h~ t,...
14 f4.t'f~'~f"'W# 'f~.I~'f ty f,~.,.t~fhiWf pfQ4yett,
,Ii
.~, @~~~&I ..if~"t'~, 44/~ @f W..lltf
t.A'f~1 ~.PA.J'~iRli thY'. .~tM"'A~ ~.f~i~..
P'PI, I'H ",<,,"
52
--- -",~..-,_...~~~_.....----,-.
l
THE WITNESS I 1 would aAY in the lAat Week or
a two you would ... tho dlr.ct rllulte or thAt. You .hould
3 have ae.n the relultl or thi. beQlnnlnq .ix we.k. AqO, of
4 the turnlnQ ofr the engine..
II
6
HR, ORELI,. Thank you.
THt: CHAIRMAN I Would it be my undeutandlng
7 that that proQra. would apply to next eprlnQ and the next
. apple ....onl 1. th.r. going to b. An att.mpt made to
, have that apike aotlvlty at a dlffer.nt locatlon than thle
10 onel I'm not blndlnQ you but that would b. your lntont
11 unle.. you got lore .urplu. than you could manage
12 ,o.,wher. el'" I und.rltandl
1)
THIC WITNElII You'U probably very awan th.t
14 All.n bl.trlbution I. In the procl" or tryln~ to
III oon.truot addltional epace right now In an area that'a
11 b.tt.r ,ulted. W. are only In the ~Inn.y faol1ity, the
11 for..r ~lnneY faoillty, b.OAU.. w. did have .plk.d
11 inventor i.. that we needed to acoommodate. It would b.
l' our intlntlon a. or thil mom.nt to IUQQ.at that WI will
30 continua the .... produot .lx In th.re .. long II w.
21 oooupy the facllltv to h.ve the 1..lt ..ount or nol.1
U qen.,,,Ud.
u
MM. CII"'''M''H. (nlot.r.. puct:1r,lI\1, w.
a4 un4.rat4n4 th4t ~.In'" conditione cQuld ch4nQo
~~ tOlorrQw. Th4nk YOY, .Ir.
e.."if..1 hl;"",,'I' lV4l'1\~ 1'('\IFt Ilel'nrt irllJ !.l..r~vr(j...
(I \ II J I'; It oj I'l '\/
'!'!
~__"'__~_'-"_".""'_,"__"_"'~~_"_'c'".,.c_.,.._.."."....._..__<",.---~-<-=>"",~~-'=-=<~""""-""""-'"'""'''''~'''''---'-'''''
l
\)
W.r. YO" ..dl AWAre by Piakinlon when thl.
3 pUlldinq W.. 1..I.d thAt lt w.. . nonaonror.inq UI. ln
} thi. nelQhbothOodl
4
"
w. w.r. not.
lOWer. you edvil.d or qiven any indloation that
6 you alQht hev. to follow A aiailar u.. pettern to whet w..
7 th.r. bltor. with ~inn.y1
.
,
"
We lIt.r. not.
o
Now, it YOY'r. driven by au.to.er.' n.eae, th.n
10 ab,ent '01' r..,ri@tion frol out.ld. your operation lf th-
11 gu.to.era' n..a. i""io.'.a funninq trol, lay, . in the
13 morn'", until IldniQnt .v.ry a.y of the y..r, ia that wh.t
I} you would plln to dol
14 "Ho, that 'Aoility l.n't r.ellY lulteble for
I' thAt kiR4 @f Igt'v"y 'Iv.l on . aontlnuGu' b..".
"
o
If thl ~rQ~h, for ....p... w.r. to ,.,o.e
11 f..trio'loRI y~n y~ .. to e p.rtaln nY.~r gf a.'iv.rl..
II Qf' ~'f'.'n n~~r Qf hour. pi' aay for your op.retlpn.
I' @~14 you f.a.@~p'y ~Onfgf., ..y, t@ . 1 in thl ~'n'~
JO tQ. ,... 44yl
H
n
~
~O, .. r'4.~~ply e@Yl4 ft@l ~gnfQr' ,~ 'n4t.
~ ~~~ .t ,~~ ..r~ li",il84 4' I~ I~. ~_..r
Ii
Il (I' 'I!~~I.I 'I'MI ..,,"'iii ,,..rfll ,i,., l/'llf "itl,i/'! 44'{'
H
,\
!'iq, ltl!l IilOl+l.,* ilia lif,in'l,irlfl f,ir. .. 1l....,.44y ""Iili
~'i nJl/jlfi~4H'I(
f",I\H<ti 'f;lI\I\"t~'HI\I" n'IIft ."!i'b'lilINj Ilf;lhhif;li!!
. 1'111 11,.. U'l;
1
How about lf you were limltod ftU to hours
Q
2 durlnQ which truck. could be there, not overall
3 operatlona, but ju.t whlch truckload. could be there?
4
That'e the only buelneee that we're In. So
A
5 that would be ju.t a. re.trlctlve.
6
So lt you wire told that you couldn't have a
Q
7 truck at 4 ln the morning or l ln the mornlnQ, that would
. interfere With your operation.?
9
y.., it would.
A
10
11
12
HR. MOROINTIlALI Thank you.
THE CHAIRMAN I Anyone el.e In the audlence?
HR. POOTHI DurlnQ the three-month eurQe in tho
13 f.ll and the three.month .urQe ln the eprlnQ, would you
14 .ay that the typical arrival time would b. olo.er to ~IOO
1& in the mornlnQ and typical undocklng time would be olo.er
11 to 6100 1" the morning than the typical 7100 which ie what
17 we would all like?
11
THE WITNr;8111 Thl. put hll, AUf,lu.t,
19 .eptember, October and into the blQinnlnQ ot November, I
aD think that would be v.ry upr..entat1ve ot what we
21 eMperleno'dl that the main pu.h occurred b8Qinnin9 .round
a2 ~IOO In the mornln~ and ll.t.d into the e.rly houri of the
:ll arternoon. However, there hAve been other peak ..1.01'1.
24 where we have elen dlrterent hour. or operatlon pref.rr.d.
}
:!!')
HR. ~ITH' Lit me I.k you the .4me klnd or
c,,-
"~"""'~~.c;nrr4Tf.nn.'V l'V;nfi."CQuf r'tc.poft 'il'lq' M;f'vT~;;;'
Pill HII-I6'!il
56
57
._--
1 que.tion that t a.ked Mr, Tayel Doe. weight make a
2 ditterence in the noi.e that the forkllfte would make In
3 driving onto the trailer and driving off of the trailerl
4 that i. to .ay, if it hal a lighter load of .hoe., it
~ would not make the kind of noiee that a heavier load of
6 Qla..bound apple. or apple.auoe would?
7
TilE WITNESSI We dietrlbute a variety of
. produot., everything rrom what we call .allboat fuel,
, which 1. air, to .tuff that welgh. a .ub.tantlal amount.
lO And I'm not an Inglneer but I would .ay that my
11 ob.ervatlon. of being ln thl. bueln.l. i. that there
12 wouldn't be a liqnitlcant difference in the amount of
13 nol.. that would be generated. A forklift in and of
14 It.elt wligh. tar more than tho oargo that it'. carrylng
15 back and forth on or oft the truok. I think that would b.
16 thl pr.domlnant .ource of the noi.e.
17
11
HR, DOOTlll Thank you,
"HI!: CIlAIRHANI Anyone 11.. hAve. que't1on of
l' thil witn.e. trom thl audlenoe?
20
HR, PlBTL1NEI Pedtord Shoe, whln thlY ca.e
21 th.y baokld the trllller up to the dook, unhookld the
ZZ trector and went on. Everyone ot your truok. that either
2) oom. In or go out, you load and unload while It" there,
H r 19hU
~!\
THE W1TN~n~1 ThAt'. corr.ct,
"~""'__~.'_."'''''''~''':':'''''~''_''"'''_'~:'''''-'_'''',."=,_~~'"= .'_"~~. .' .__ ~.=,",'''-~W.'
~:."'fit I'llnnta... V"" i" ('(lIUt ""I'Oft inQ '.fvlcl.
(III) J"i II- H; '\ I
50
1
HR. PIBTLINEI The stoel platos go down, the
2 lift truok. run over the plates and make a olang, olang,
3 olang. A. soon as you unload one, you brIng another one
4 in and start It all over. It that'e 4 In the morning,
o that's what you get. I only live about 150 feet from
e there, I'd lik. to Q.t some .leop. And I've seen one
7 or -. not on. of your truok., but . truck from in there --
8
TilE CIIAIRHAN. Sir, let me remInd you that
9 wI'r. at the qU.ltion -- I don't want to stop you. Put
10 YOU'll have an opportunity to make a statement. And we're
11 at ths que.tlon point of the procedure.
12 Anyone e1.. have a que.tion ot the applicant?
13
HR. AUSTIN, Hy name i. Jeff Au.tin, 519 Adame
14 Road, Carlisl.. You .aid the intent wa. a .hort term to
15 1.a.. this buildlno?
16 TilE WITNESI!lI
17 HR. AUITIN,
11 TilE WITNElIII
19 HR, AUIJTINI
010 put thllt one Ylar1
U TIfE WITNl:lIlIl
v...
lIow lono 10 the 1.... for?
On. ye.r.
And your intent 1. not to use it
Well, our intent when w. algned
OIa the 1.... WAI not to us. It for more then one Vear, We do
2J haVe renewal option. on tho 104.. tor a two-year periOd
~4 beyond that. Qut our lntont 1e to ut111~. it tor on.
;l\j yeAr,
,. ......,...~..,......_~,~~............."_'...._',...___ _,...,w................,..,..._....___,..~_~_.
' .. (:(Il"tr~1 I'II/H1ltyty"nll\ t'41'Ut "oport IrllJ ..r\lHI."
In 11 J"lIl. lfl"l I
f>()
1 DAVID GIORDANO, called a. a wltnal.. havinQ
2 been previoully duly .worn, teetlfied a. follow.,
3 DIRECT EXAMINATION
4 BY HR. WEINGARTEN.
IS
Q
DAVid, would you plea.e ldentify your employer
6 for the record?
7
A
I'm employed by 'acllitle. Resource Management
8 Company and lerve aa a olient of Dicklnaon College,
9
10 II what?
11
12
Q
And it ia your pOlition with Dickinson College
A
Director of phYlical plant.
And how long have you been the dlreotor of
Q
13 phy.loal pl.nt at Dicklnaon College?
14
U
A
Q
Since Aprll Of 1994.
Are you f.mill.r with Kinney/. for..r war.hauI.
16 on North Or.nge Str..t?
17
11
A
Q
Vel. I ....
And are you famll1ar with re.ident.' complaint.
1V that have blln r.l.ad with conneotion wlth Allen'. us. of
20 th.t faoility?
u
u
^
o
Ve.. l alii.
What hAve you doni on behalf or the fJoUeqa to
JJ 4d4r.e. thosl concern.?
u
^
A. Hr, J~Sq. dlscU.,.d, I'Ve had .Mten.ive
~, QvRv.r..tiona with him poncarnlnQ the co.plaint. ralee4 by
.." .__.__..______.<._.~,...-." -~ .-_. .~~.,..-.'.k~~=______
(:'Hltr" rlOflt'Hiy'lv,ulllt \'lllift ~I!J,urt InIJIt.,vl".. -.,,-.-
{111l J'.Il~IIi"l1
61
1 the reeidente. We have talked about the path of travel or
2 the truck. and aleo the idea or keeping the trucke running
3 in the perlod of waltlng to load and unload and al.o
4 durlng the period or loading and unloading whioh he
5 re.ponded wlth hie letter that wae .ubmitted earlier.
6 I'm aleo currently eKamlning the poeeibilitie.
7 of u.ing exclu.lv.ly thl oouth oide of the bullding, thOBe
8 bay. on that eide or the faoility, for the loading and
G unloadinQ. currently there'e not enou;h room to turn a
10 traotor-traller around if there were two mar. at tho..
11 dook.. There's thr.e dook. on that .ide of the bulldin;.
13 I'm ourrently in dleou"lone with conrail who owne the
13 property direotlY ad,olnlnq.
14
o
In conneotlon with those di.ou..lone, are you
15 familiar with thl. letter (indicating)?
16
17
A
Yee, lam.
o
Would you like to delor1be that letter to the
11 aoard?
l'
^
8ure. Thi. 1. a letter that I wrote to Jlm
20 Ahonen with the conrail Real I.tate Oepartment and
al provlded him wlth a elt. drewing that inoluded the
22 railroad tracke end aleo the war.hau.e taoi1ity and ;u.t
23 dilcu..101 the poo.ibllitl.. or the 0011890 ullnq for ·
34 short period ot time a portion ot that .pao. for truck
a& turn-around.
~n~'~~'<~---c-';nTr;r-r;;.-;r;;'y-rYA"T;'~cl)urr'M;fl(lft:f;'IJ ~ii;ryrc;.=~~'
plJl ,i0;1l* U'i ,
hi
_"'._.....,"'..;_.":>^'"""'""'_,<...~..~.,_.~.....,,w,.... ~'._:...
...".,...",_.,
1
HM. W~lNOARTENI ^n~ I woulQ like to -.
a lotUlIllv, thl. WI' not put of the JllulkIHI.. llu I Willi III
) Ukl to lntr04llo1 t.h.-t. II AppeUllnt'1I e:lltll"lt P. Ami
4 h."I. a oopy tor tnl ..mber. or thl DOllrd.
t
THI WITHI"1 Al.o lionq tile ...1 lln.., Allen
t Dl.t.ribUt.ion h.1 .,re.d and h.1 p.II.d on to II.. thol.
1 .outh bay. wh.nlVlr it luitl thllr bllline.. If th.r.'.
. only onl trupll th.n'.. Ana 1 hAYI wHn.....,t (lO o(341ullIl1
, tha' thty .r. ll.inQ th. 10llth bAV" wh.." It', pOI,lbl..
10 1'1 MM. WIINOAIT&NI
U-
n
u
Ar. YOIl 'A,iliAr with thil llt"f1
o
A
o
'II', I ..,
II thAt a l.tter alt_a 'ep'..~r ~.th t. Mr.
14 Olnni, 'hI .oninq arrive'?
U
It
Thill I. @orrIlQt.
A
o
And 'hi. i. a p.,t 0' thl ...,d', rlOord.. w.
11 won" ,a_it I' l"to evid.nol. tut would you bra'fly
1. d,.Q,lbll 'hi 1.~on4 p.f.~rllph ~f th.' 'or thl 'u.rdl
"
A
n'lt "...hH,By tllll' IH.t'\j"I~ U,I II.' \If UU.
10 '.@illly ~ .ll.~ P"'f'~',~n It i' ,1'1'" ,~ 'h.
Il pr...,.'i~ ~~~Afqr.i~ ii.. Py lh. ~'n".y t@rpor.tion.
u w. 4l.liiitfll4 ,fj.It I!'futNff"@'f'" tIMt All.,. .'",... \0 IUk.
Jl 'f~~ tn. .~l. )~l~' 'f~J~M~ tg In, 4r~l..4u~' 'foav~',
If W~lg~ 't 4 .l~'f~~Yl~1 "tM~~H',
I~
U ,.,.a I,H..("........4 It,. I'''''' ... tltf",r>fl cr..
"".,,....:.:c-.~.-",.,_...
t~I\.,..\ *'..w~~fly'...i,. r"4f\ Il-....' I 11\" Ih'f" "".
lli'l JH".i.'
63
1 truokl orr when they're loading and unloading -- that has
2 been palled on -- and the exploratlon or uling the aouth
3 eido of the warehoule. I think allo in that paragraph --
4 I thlnk that oovera everything.
II
Q
80 to lummarize, you are oognizant of the
6 re.idanta' oomplaint. and you've taken balically all
7 .ffortl to try and re.olve them?
.
A
Vel, I think la, I've al.o reoelvod .peoiflc
, oall. from .peoific raeidentl and tried to work with
10 Michael JUdge ae a re.ult of tho.e calla, to talk to truok
II driver.. 80methinQ I haven't pal.ed on to -. on. .ploifio
12 co_plaint about truok. arrivln? in the taolllty and
l' oontinuing to run.
14 I talked to our director or leourlty, Bam
11 MoKelvey, and we're Qolnq to .ek thoee truck. .a we I'.
l' th.. eittlng there running to relocate to . truok .top ln
17 Carli.le until the floility i. opened up, to not ".e that
l' parking lot .. a plaol to re.t until theV're r.ady to load
l' And unlo.d.
20 HM. WltNQ^MTJNI 1 have no further. que.ticn..
U TIll; C/fAlJlAANI Any member of the (loard have.
JJ que.tlon ot thil wit"..I? Hr. Oenni.?
n
HM. DtHNlnl 04ve, do you know whAt thl total
l4 ~u4r. footage ot the ~uildinq ie?
u
'fur; WlTWIUI I r~Jr.t tl'l4t:1 didn't brinq that
~"~"'"""'F;;"t'f ~'l't:w-ftfj;ir v'~;;;r~ ~fjuft-'ii;I;~irt ir~'J' '~;f';;lt;;r-~~
filiI J"lth)""'"
6'\
",."---~......._.."",,,.--,",,,",",,",--",",,,--,,,,,,,:,,=~=-~~.""-'.~'''''''---'-'.''
1
A
I wu not pr..ent. at tho.. ",..tlnlJI, I WQuld
2 Imagine, thouQh, Hichul !tritton, till tuuurer of the
J college played a role.
4 Q So b.elcally your involvement ha. been alnol
5 the 1.... took pl.o. .nd you .tarted gettlnQ eo.plalntl
6 about it, the operatlnQ fAolllty?
7
A
Correot.
8 Q Now, with re,ard to lo.e ot the .t.p. that you
9 have taken in requ..ting .huttlnq thl truckl down,
10 reroutlnq wh.rl pOI.lble, uII09 the louth bAY', what gan
11 01okInlon do it the truok' don't obey? 00 you know I'
12 ther' are any lanotion. you oln '.Iot "Iina' Allen
13 Olatributlon it thlt doe.n'\ work?
14 A We haven't re.lly .wplor~ it to thlt l.vel
10 y.t, All.n'. been very ooo,.r.tivI In ouf rlqu.", to
16 work with u. and the oono.,nl of tho ,..14entl. 1'_ .ur.
17 that all of th.. hlVln't ~.n .et It thla pqlAt, pyt w.
1. haVen't qott.n to th.t l,vII of dilou'lion.
1V Q Out you're AWl" that the ,'Ild.ntl Af. lil11
20 unhappy, they Itill '.al tn.t I 1@\ of thi, i. ..kinq
al .NQ...lv. not..?
u
.
I n4V_ ~~l ~4r4 4"ytnl~ wltnln ,~ ,..\ lWQ
II w..k't I/d '.Y fr~Qr lQ lh4l, '~~~kf ~ .~. ~.'Y .~4r..
~4 Q I prq~4~lY 'h~u~4 ..Y ".Y I~~. W,'~ 'lUl4r4
~~ 19 tn. PQ.,i~tlt..y ~f 4~f..!r~J .~ ~f'4'~ r'f'f'~"'~~~
~,;r;tr~r h'M.".,! ii41\ i.. ~''''jH it-i'''f 'll~~ t:,.. ~l\<;."
PPI jijiiqHI
~..".",,;c"~i-.,...,.,..
66
1 that would be vigorou.ly impaled by the college, do you
2 havI the authority to accept anything if that would be
3 part of the di.cu..ion .ither with the Dorough or with the
4 n.id.nt.?
5
A
At thl. point I would eay thAt I am not 1n A
6 po.1tlcn to negotiate on behalf of the college on that
7 b.half.
. Q So anyth1nQ lik. that would have to be Hr,
, Britton'. r..pon.lb111ty or .om.on. .l..'.?
10 A Ye..
11 MR. HOROEHTIIALI Thank you.
13 THE CIIAIRMANI Any oth.r member of the audience
13 have . que.tion at thl. witn...?
lot
HR. AU.TINI Why wI.n't th.r. a repre.entat1v.
10 rrom the college that can act on behalf ot the colleQ.
16 here at thi. hearing whioh i. really important to the
11 n.iQhborl1
11
TlU: WITHUISI At thi. juncture it ..em. to be
1. an operation. i..ue, And .ino. 1 handl. the operation. of
ao the racility, it .e.mea to .ake 'enle that I repr...nt the
at QOU.,..
:u
u C:oU~e1
Z4
at
H~. AU~TIH' 10 you repr..ent Diokin.on
Tn& WlfU~'" At thle h..rln9. y..,
H_. AUjTINI '9 lr we ~.li.d the coll~., they
..=.".....,~~~_,.-.._,......:'-<N....._'"_'''~.'..~,...'''''''"..",..~~,.._.~ -.7C'C,,'-.-~~'__'.":':'-',-:--~'-:"--""'~'-~' '-~-'.-'-" -'~--"-."'-''':.-~-7:-' ""-c'-c"'-'-,
. ..d' ""Cwntnl ".nnitvI1I4.,14 t~{jUft Ml!lf.on "'J ~Ilrv l,n
tH'1 ~I\!I'I~'l'
67
1 would say you represent Diokinson ColleQe in the
2 nsiqhborhood problem?
3
TilE WITNESS I At this point tonlght they would
4 say, ye., I was here to represent Dlckln.on College.
o
HR. AUSTINI Okay.
TilE CHAIRM^NI Any other qu..tlona at this
6
7 witne..? ^ny member. of th. Doard?
8
VOICEI AI faallltlee manager, lf Dickln.on
~ College were to have part of thelr property or adjoining
10 prop'rty, let'e .ay, .taked out for purpo... of verifying
II owner.hip boundaries, would that be somethlnQ that you
12 would be In charQe or/ meanln9, would you havs -- would
l3 you be the p.r.on to initiate that?
14
TilE WITlUUJIJI I'm a Uttl. contu..d about the
U qu..Uon.
16
VOICEI If .omeonl at Dickin.on ColleQe or it
11 the 0011eve iteelf want.d to know the boundarle. or a
\. Property, th. l.gal boundarle. ot . partloular property,
I' any of the propertl.., would thl. be .omathing that would
ao oo.e und.r your juri.dlction? Would you handle that?
at
U
TilE WITNESSI V", mo.t likely.
VOIC~I W.re you .war. that there w.. a group
Z' ot peopl. from 'ome lnd.p,ndent company out 410nQ on thi.
24 partioular prop'rty .tAkinq this prop.rty out this y.ar?
J
~...
n
TIl~ WltNI'~' V," 1 w...
'""=""'~"i:.'n tf;" '0' r.nn".v 1"V4"T,," &iufrc~.'r;;fiTn;iii@-ryrtl;;'~"-"
liP) J'U-U\I)/
J
1 VOIC~I po, m..nloQ, YO" hlr.d th.a. plopto tor
a Diokinaoo?
J Tilt: WIT~t:IJ.' Yilt, WI hlnd iii aae olvll
4 1"9inoer to draw up A .1te plao for UI.
a VOICEI "II thi. ""Y way related to WhAt 1.
, Qoinq on now with thi. fagility?
., TilE WITI4Ult NO,
. VOICE' Tl\i. i. unre'"l1lS?
. TilE WITNI'I, Thi. 1. unrllatea )"" booAu" it
10 Wt.. new trAot ot land that the Qol1.q. had loqulrla and
II wlnted to gle.r up any qUI,tlon. with the d.ed. and plot
IJ pl.n. thl' were rtQiater.a wlth thl Dorouqh,
11 VOICe, '0 whit YOu',. .IVIIl9 1. you hId th...
14 "0,11 hirld to ."rv.y vour pro,.rty, not thl Id)o1nill9
U pro,.,U...,
at 1"11 WITHlnl conte'.
11 VOICII '0 VOU wI,.n't IWI'e th.' they wlr.
l' IOlUI'1V .ufv.ylnq t4)olniAQ proper,'.. tn.", .1'niRq, il
I' thay Wlfl @ut lher. .ufVlylnq _y "o"flY, Vow didn't hi,.
ao tn.. t@ 4i thatl
U f"1 "lTHUII 1"0, I 4hl M'.
U VOU~W:f "."y I ftl"M VW,
n ffi~ C....11iW f Arty IiIM'" /tll*_' h~~. fl' ltllt
14 "..,....1 "" 1,Hllf,f4M, tl'f4/'j/{ ';mf 'f'uy MI~", w.
II" 4ff4'~ ~..t. V~4f UN !4/l(j 'flioiU ",,,""Uf""., "1i'1l1l..l1
l
~t;"A"f~41t-_~;';..d'i"kI4 (10.... il.lf~~.~~;if f;t"'t~(~*""'~"" ,.
! II' I ~....' ''''It I
69
1
HR, WEINOARTENt Aotually, 1 have no further
2 witn...... That baeically this is the portlon of our
3 arqument with r..pect to the appeal from the zoning
4 otticer'. determination on a raotual ba.l.. W. also have
& an arQument --
6
T/IE CHAIRMAN I Excuse me. Pl.... l.t'. keep
7 our conv.r.ation. out in the hall .0 everyone oan h.ar.
I Thank you v.ry muoh.
t
MR. WEINOARTENI Wa are al.o app.aling the
10 loninQ offioer'. datarmlnatlon on legal ground.
11 Ipeolfioally that under both the ordinanc. and the
12 applloable ol.e law, the .xpln.ion at thl hour. of u.e of
13 an op.ration i. not the Ixpanllon ot a nonoonformlng usa
14 that r.quir.. the granting ot a Ipeolal exoeption.
10 peclu.e at that, it therefore que.tions such I'
l6 whloh bay. are beinQ u..d or what are the houri of
17 operation or the particular minutia of how thi. 1.
11 operating, whether thlY turn oft the truok. or leavs them
l' on and eo forth ar. aotuAllY not germane to the i..us of
30 .xpanlien of thl nonconrormtng u.s,
at w. adllre.. that to .ddre.. th. faotual i..u...
aa lut w. think that in larqe part, it not compl.tely, allot
al tho.. 1..u., ar. wholly irr.l.vant. In your ordinance 1n
at _.otion ~t~-all(p) the ai.cuI.ion of expansion relat..
J' 0niv to ai..n.ion.l I..Y.., In~r...inq lhe .i.. of the
,un..._
c.neral r.nn~ylv~nl. ~aurt ..portIR~ ..rv 0..
pit/ ,1'1.-111'1
70
1 buildlnq. There'e no diecueelon Anywhere in the ordinance
a definltione or otherwi.e with r..pect to the ewpan.ion
3 r.latlnq to the increaee of the hour. or operatlon
4 otherwl.e inorea.lnq the inten.ity of the u.e.
o Al.o. 1 hid previouelY in my application
6 referred to the Commonwealth Court oale 1984 of Zoninq
7 Uearinq Board of Adjuetment v.raue Llbro., which in that
8 ea.e the loninq hearinq board had ruled that each preeent
9 activity had to be traced to a previou. ule, did they run
10 their trueke, did they uel certain bay., they did he have
11 o.rtain hour. uf operation.
12 What the Court there .aid ~- overturned the
l3 loninq hearinq board and .aid that the lAw doe. not
14 require it to b. ehown that elch qaraqe i. u.ed today to
10 .tore IMeetly the .arne item. and kindl of ite.. that were
16 .tared prior to 1911, Which i. the date ot the adoption ot
17 the ordinance, nor doe. it require thlt the llQht lndu.try
18 or r.pair which occur. on the premi.ee be preoi..ly
l' ld.ntleal to what occurred before 19l1.
30 whit i. r.quired to b. .hewn i. that the
ai oVerall Ule ot the property trorn the rental of the
U faoility for etonaqe An,j lhJht indu.trilli purJ)o", hAll not
Zl been .iqnlflcantiy altered .in~. before l"l.
a. '0 the applicable .tlnalra 1_ whether of not
~. ther. ha. Po.n a eub.tlnti.l alteration in the 1,1.., not
="~"~'~-C;ntf ;r"r;nn'j~y lv;;;;r.... ~;l;i"rt.'II.f;Qf tTnii"';.'rvTii'e. - ._~
III n nlt'lll'\'
71
1 these various minutia. The case that I did not include in
2 my appeal is perhap. even more on point. I dld not locate
3 it at the time that I tiled the appeal, And I can include
4 in the -- I've got capias here that I can provids to the
5 Board. And, aotually, why don't I hand out -.
6
TilE CIlAIRMANI Why don't you diatribute the
7 COpi81 riQht now?
8
HR. WEINOARTENI (Complying,) This caee is the
9 Town.hip ot Chartiers ver.u. William Hartin. It'. A
10 Supreme court of Vennsylvania oase decided in 1988. WhAt
11 thi_ cale involved wa. a landtl1l that the .- aotually,
12 the ca.e points out startlng at 986 -. that the troublee
13 between the town.hip and this landfill began wh.n thl
14 re.pondente, which ie the llndrill, and the town.hip began
15 when Chambers contracted with four N.w Jer..y countl.. to
16 accept their WA.te.
17
In other words, they were slmply incr.asing the
18 amount of waste, the number of trucke that wer. dueplnq
19 wA.te at thie facility. What the court conoluded -- tlr.t
20 of dl, thh wa. d..med to b. a preexisting nonoontorllhilJ
al Y.e, And on pAge 987, the argument Was that thi.
22 con.tltvted an illeqal expanaion or the preewistlnq
2l noncontor~ln9 v.a and that, theretor., thare ne,dld to be
24 . variance In order tor thom to do It.
\...,J
n
Once again, .imilar to our Qa.., you'vI qat
-~"~","'7":''''='''''''':'''-''i.''':'-'''''''''.'''''''''~~-''''''--'-.....-.,.-,_.,,...,,.,._..,~.-"....,,.,__:"_,'_,.~-,,.,.'"""",...,...-"':':',..-~...,.-..,..,.."':_.",.."_."..,:"",~-:.,~....~.,,.:_....,. '--"'-"""'_" '."_ "C'O',
0.0 ..' d. . Clnt rill I I'wnnlly' I vClnlctd Cl'lurtMosioft lnii lltirvh'u'
(1L'1) Hit-WI'
--...................'.....-
-..lL_,_
(J
1 pre.xi.tlnQ nonaonformlnq u.e 4nd iner.... ln the
2 tnten.ity .nd I conaluaion by the town'hip th.t eome
1 vlriano. or oth.r loninq r.lief wa. required. At the
· bottom of 'I. Ind the top at 9'9, the Court .ay. thlt once
I 1t h.. been determined that I nonaonformlnQ ue. te ln
· e.l,t.no., the overly t,chniaal ......m.nt ot that u.. cln
1 not be utili..d to Itunt tt. natura. develop.ant and
. ,rowth,
· Th'n at the beqinnlnq ot '" and key Not. No.
10 JI Giv,n the.e p.r...t.r., it Would '..m .. and then tn
11 ..,ha,l... I' a ..ttar of loninq lAw thlt Ch..bar., the
12 landfill owner, ha. an ab'alut. rlqht to lnor.... tha
11 d.lly votu.. of lnta_. And to utl11.. the ...t vll1ey
14 vithout the naoef'lty of obtainl", . vlrlano..
11 Thl. i. .0 bealu.a Ch..o.r. WI. not oh.nwl",
II tha in,.ndtd u.e of tha prop.rty, WI' not ,.pln41ft9 the
11 u" "y'nd the .raa whloh WI' oonl..plataa for ,uoh u.. at
i. 'h. ti.. tha 1.~1flll beo..e no~~"tor.in9. Tha Court
It thIn fO" @o to t41. 4~~t .Q" uth., Q.... And b4.1Q411V
10 4i"1AQul'h'f th. uth., ~41",
It IillAl U.. J't1t.., fH Utili .... AM I thinlt "'lI )YIU
~~ .wtrlM4ly t"~l'."t .. t. th4t .tl @t th... gl,gUI.lon.
~l t~"t'ht with f..~~t tq ~"4t ~Y' 4'. U'.4 4~1 th. hQYf.
.I" ", (i,'u'4~hm u 4f1fl, 4.\itU4H'I, ~m. !olf1ty 't'*"'IU",,. I' lUWj;
4~ '~nl~n' 1. In_ 8~Rlr.g ~"lp,". 4.t.r.1"4"~R '~4' ~. t~v.
I';'~--f~~ ""''''''*t ""FI!" f'"..., _lOt",." il~j.fti"f\i f'."
pp! J~"sl....,
r~ t
73
1 to k.ep within thole houre of operation on .ueh thingl al
2 running engine' and 80 forth are aotuallY once again not
3 before the Poard.
4
The only thing i. the hour. of op.ratlon. And
5 that is an irr.levant i..u. limply because it is not the
6 .xpansion of . nonconforming use. Wo aro oontinuing a
7 nonconforming ue. au a matt.r of zoning law, A. the
e Supr.me Court of Penn.ylvania said, We oan continu. that
9 u.e eVen if there are .liQht technioal change' in how that
10 operatlon i. Used, ev.n if that lnolud'l in this o.s. a
11 ,ignlficantly inoreased vOlume a. a r..ult of oontractlng
13 the four NIW J.r..y, colon.
13 And .0 that i. ....ntially our l'9al argument
14 thlt both ba..d on your ordinano., whioh doe. not refer to
l' hour. of operation, and the applloabl. lonlnq law a.
11 ,t.t.d by the Supreme Court ot P.nn.ylvania that
17 ....ntiallV th.r. i. no l'Oal b.... for the .oning
11 Officer" interpr.tatlon.
19
That aotually oonoludee our oa.. with f..pout
ao to an app.al,
21
TI1I1: CHAIRMAN' coun..l, we l.1erhinly und.nt.nll
22 your 'SQA' position. And if, of course, the Doard were to
3l aeciae that the loninq otticer" interprltation wa.
24 incQrrect, then we und'r.ta~t that a qood deal of the
j
",. UCQfd WQuid tlQt be u,ev4nt to thlit '"qai '''UtiJ, On the
~..t,:-:,'7'~":'/.;"'~'''~'''~: ~ ..,
t.;,,"\ t", . "'" fin.;' V4"';; t;I;\ir'f";f'~;fn n~it;fylt.~;;'''''~~'=''''
(111) ~'111.111..t
1,1
11
19
20
21
U
:u
:J4
j ~!;
"'^".",,""
74
1 other hand, it 1. my intent and our lntent to complete the
3 record on thoee i.eue..
3 And I would ..k that -- you lndlcat.d .. to the
.. .p.olal eKceptlon requ..t whlch, ot cour.., would be
5 n.c....ry to you it you lo.t on both le9al i..uo .nd the
6 factu.l i.puo. And I'm not indicAtlnq Any deci.ion on the
1 ao.rdl wo h.ven't di.cu..ed it. aut we'd al.o like to
8 complete the record on th.t a.pect, too.
9 And I think unl... Coun.el will have Any
10 objection, it would bo be.t to let you oompl.te your
11 c.... And I know ther.'. 90in9 to be .vid.nc. pre.ent.a
la on the other .id.. And we can take .11 tho tactu.l
13 inform.tlon at the ..me time.
14 But b.tor. w. proce.d on th.t, 1t our youn9
15 lady do..n't neea a break, the Chalrman do... So we're
16 901n9 to tako a rive-mlnut. br.ak and bo back.
(A broak WA' tak.n trom '118 p.m. to ..48 p.m.)
TilE CHAIRMAN I It w. elln continue, pi.....
Coun..l, it WA' my undeUtllndlnQ th.t you would now be
901n9 to thAt pArt or tho r.cord tor the .p.CiAl
eKeeption. And we'll, or cour.e, Accept tor part at thAt
allot the evidence thAt you've alre.dy ,uomitted,
naturally.
HR. W!IHaA~TI~1 Th4n~ you very much. I'd Ilk.
to now reedl Klehnl JOO'JII.
C:f!lntr4 ~iltHH'V v.."i.. t"i\lft'~~JI;Jft 11\l~ f..tfVII!....
P III J'\Il~ u'n
16
1.1
11
19
ao
21
u
2)
U
,,,,,,~l ;HI
75
1
(Michael waD recalled.)
TilE CIlAIRMANI And you have previouely been
2
3 identitied, air, and, at cour.e, you're atill under oath.
. Welcome a9aln.
!l
TilE WITNESS' Thank you.
6 DIRECT EXAMINATION
1 BY MR. WEINGARTEN I
.
Q
Mr. Judge, al you are aware, there are certain
, .tandard. that thil Board mUlt analyze to determine
10 whither or not it 11 appropriate to qrant a Ipecial
11 ekception, thoae atandard. beinq .et out in Section
13 355-117(0) at the zoninQ ordlnance.
13 potore we proceed, I'd like to point out that
14 We will not addre'. for the purpoae ot the Board No.2,
15 Comprehlnl1ve Plan, or No.6, OeaiQn, inaamuch a. olearly
with reaplat to a noncontorm1nq ual and the eMpan.ion
ot the nonoontorminq ual tho tact that it II not
conai.tent with the comprlhenl1ve Plan or that we will not
be prov1d1nQ everqre.n acreeninq, .ite d.aiqn, and 10
torth.
However, with r..p.at to the other tour itema,
lte. Ho. 11 Other Law.. Mr. Ju~~., ar. you aWAr. or your
ue. balnq in .orloue conflict with Any other Borou9h
Jonlfi(J ord1nancl' or any other .tAte, rlderal, or othor
'awe?
contral .onney V~n ~ court poport n~ ~.rY c..
Pill J"Ii.l~""
.'_'-'"?,"".Hc~_"_"f'A"_"'__""'''''''~_.r'''',C'''''~__''''''_''
4
t
.
1
.
,
lCt
H
U
U
U
"
I.
&1
I'
I'
10
U
U
H
H
~.,J i~
'16
------~---=---,._-_.~~~---_.-- .~-~.._.,---_.__.._".- ....-.---
1
A
I'~ not AWAr. thAt w.'re In I.raou. QQnfllot
, with any lAWI. A.. ~.tt.r ot tAot, I'. not Aw.r. thAt
J wa'f. in any oontl10t .t all.
o And wlth r..peet to the tr.ttaa, woula thl. UI'
.l,nlrloantly .aa to . ..riouI tr.ttla hA..rd or .erloul
turrio ,",,,,nq.IUon? Al\4 thi. 11 . woul\t-not-,lIul\-ln or
.i,nl'io,ntly..aa-to.
A ..I.a upon our undlr.tA~inq of th. u.. of th.
,.olllty by Mann.v 'ho. a~ th.ir truok. "rYlgin9 it And
out.id. oarri.r. ..rYialn9 it, w. ... it A. I y.rv 'lallar
UII and ao not ~li.v. that It would .iQnl'iolntly aaa to.
o Ana with re'paot to .a,.ty, the requar...nt Ie
,~, you .h.ll no' or..'. . .i,nl'loAn' ~ub'ia ..r.,y
h"'fd inolu41ftq Ilr.., to_10 or ..ptoaiYI h...ra.. pg
you ...t tha' e'lnd.raJ
A WI ""rt.anty ao. W. oontrAPtuAlly prohIbit tho
"Of~' @r 'l....bl.., '.pl@,ly.e, .t Q".tA, 1n ~r
UQlUU...
o Ana, "~liV, With t..,lot to the ~1,hP9rhOQQ,
wll' v~r Ult .'~n"l~.ntlv n~lt,v.1V .f'~t the
~.'fA~l. ~fiAfA~t" 91 I" '.'jtl~ r'll~R'l41
M'~;.j,qfll~, H i;.tl~ _~ IINdo\lut.".Hfi/I, (i~' "".'''' .~.t
r~ 4r4 . ~~h'~Rj+4_l~~ ~I 4 ~....l.'lr~ ~~~Rt~r~l~
wt4?
. .~4'H,.. f..' tt... ~4~ ",. .~4,q ~. .~,'l*f tli
1:'.'\h'4\ '.f,,,..~I,,.t"I'4 H"j,l hr."llh'j I;l.f~'~;~~"'--'~'
I ~,' '. ;l ~ti ! i~1 t
l
a
J
4
0
6
1
.
,
10
11
11
U
14
1t
l'
l'
11
it
ao
n
u
J)
H
j n
77
--"""_....',..---_._..~'-----~<~'~ -
that or the prevloue occupnnt, Klnnoy ahos, and do not
th~nk that it would Ilgnlrlcantly alter thlnYI any
dittlrlntly from the way that the noighborhood wae with
thlir occupancy of thl facility.
Q And to olarity for the Board, what ,plcitic
,plcia1 oxception are you Iloking? What relief --
al.uming thAt the appoal 1. deniod and we mUlt havo A
apeoial eKcoption, what ,ro you ...king in terma ot a
Iploill Ixclption?
A We'rl limply ..ekinq an hour.-ot-optration
exception.
Q And with rOlptat to houra of operation, aro you
laeking anythlng more than what ~inntY arguably already
hl47
A tt'a our undtrttandin~ thlt Kinn.y through
their vlriou' oper.t~on. there operatld, II ha. bien
tl.tltild prlvioulty, trom a A.m. until mldnlQht It
night. '0 that't ju.t . two-hour window of operation that
in thlory they do not haVO recolloctlona ot operating.
W. would prlftr I a.-hour window of
opportunity, Igaln, to ...t QUlto.er-drlven requlre.enta.
lut If pr...ed, WI could 100lpt the .... houri of
op.rltion that ~io"'Y .nloy~ 10 the tacl11ty.
o 80 in 'I..n~. you art ...klnq nalhlnq ~r. than
the .... '1IKlbl1~ty that thl ~rlvloij. Ulllr, Kino.y, had I
;"_"'."T"~'""""'~'~'~!~'~--""""':'''''':''''~'~'-:''''''''--''''''''"''''"--':,_"""~,_"",,_::",,,:,,:,.,'f..."-'" ~-:--_.'->' .",:,.,;..-.,,,._,.~,,,.-.,,,.~...,.,-;._...-~,-::,~~~.-..-.,,..,.........~~.,-
<7tll'l......, "il/'1IU1V I V4n ,.. (,'CliH t "l!J',.rt ifl'J aerY 141--
11111 A~Ii'llq~1
78
1 nAmely, to uoe the fAcllity as its customers and as it
:z required?
J
A
That's correct.
.
Q
You are willinq to, it neceslary, have Il
G two.hour window ba.ed on the two hour. that we don't have
6 any Ipecitic evidence that Xinney utillzed the facility?
7
A
It that would be the decilion of the Board.
.
MR. WEtNaART~NI We have nothinq turther with
I relpect to the Ipecial eKception.
10
TilE CUAIRHANI Thllnk you, lir. Any member ot
11 the Board have a que.tion of thil witnel'? Any member or
12 thl audienc. have qUlltionl or thi. witnell?
13 CROSS EXAMINATION
14 av HR. HOROENTII^LI
u
Q
Ju.t a tew, Hr. JudO" If you wer. to become
II aware a. the manaoer of thll t'cility that the neiQhborl
17 arl lufforinq qreat impact trom thl hour. of operation
II and, turther, that their reoolllctlon. perhaps qoinq back
11 would convince the ftollrd that In tact your operation i.
20 tar more oKpanlive than what Xlnney hAd had, would you be
21 wl11inq to loale back to Whatever Xlnn.y had ewcept III the
22 loard miqht qrant you f.llet?
;n
A
The only thln~ that we're her. to dllcul. .1 I
24 under.tand It 11 the hour. ot oper.tion. And that'. all
2~ I'm prepared to addre.. in term. ot what WI would do
""""""",",w",_",,,,~'"'.'''''~>-'"~''''''''''''~,'''-''''::,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,-,V'''''''',",,;,.<.,:",,'''7''''."'."'S"~"'~"~"'".'~"~".""",..",:.,,.,.-,.,,,..,..,,._:,,,'_."':","r.,"""'~""C=,'~".,," .~.,""~S' .,<-,,:,_..,.,.. '~",".'" H""'._~""':"_""~,"'''
Central renneYlvania Court MepQrtinq a.rvlc..
n It) J 'III. }l\ 'l'
'/'J
1 operationally at that taclllty. Tho apocial exceptlon Is
a to requelt the expanded houri ot operatlon it It'e not
3 qrantea ae a contlnuanee.
4
o
I.at me rephra.. that que.tion then. It in taot
5 you were qranted extended hour. ot operation but there
6 were limitation. tound to eKi.t when Kinney we. there 4.
1 to the number at truck., al to the number at employeee, ae
. to the poeltloninq on the premi.e. at truck., anythlnq
g el.e, you could live with whAtever Klnney hid it you Qat
10 more hOllU?
11
12
1]
"
I don't know th,t We could Or that we couldn't.
HR. MORGENTHALI Think you.
Tilt CIlAIRHAN I Any other member ot the aUlUence
14 have. qU81tlon of Hr. Judqe on thl. iBlue? Member. at
15 the Board? Okay, .ir. Thank you a9'ln. We thank you tor
10 your attendlnce and your app.arance.
11
And I take it that conclude. your mlltter on
1. both Of the.e matter., Coun.el?
11
20
MR. WEINOARTENl Think you v.ry muoh.
Tltll: CIlA1JCHANI Ana It thh point I'll op.n the
al record to Anyon. who Would llko to prlBent Any other
22 evldence aoncernlnQ thl. matt.r. Coun.el?
n
HM. HOIiOtNTIlALI I thlnk ptrhll'. 1 .hould be
34 eworn _100 juet to cavlr any contlnqlna181.
-J
in
ROO1JC HORGINTHAL, cIllld I. . wltn..., hlvlnq
~~;"~~'-~'~._, '.-__ ~.. "'_.~'._'_"''''''''===:'~=~,'''_''''',~=4''''''!''';;'''''''~:''"''''''''-'';''''''.""'~'-1-.'-"'''''''''~'''''''',,,",,,,",,,,,,-.~.~,r''.,~:'.~,~,c,,
Central renn,ylvlnl. Court keportl"q lervla..
('Ill) ~U.tnl
.-111_.
1 Work. Departm.nt property tile.. And tho.e tile. would
3 inolude matter. ot inquirie. trom different property
3 ownerl pertaining to their Usel or enforcement action.
4 that may have been taken agAln.t prop.rty own.r. under the
5 provil1on. ot the zoning ordinance. Put there 11 no
6 .p.citic reqiltry, and there i. no proqram to .peclficAlly
1 r.gi.ter nonconforming u....
.
Q
Ar. you familiar with the provi.ion under the
9 Huniolpalitiee Planning Code whlch dO.1 permit that to be
10 done"
11
A
I'm tamiliar with that provialon. And it
la atate. thllt loning ordinAnCl1 may includ. requiromlntl
13 that the zoning otticer roqilter nonconforming u.... To
14 the b.lt of my knowledqe thl Carlille porough ~oninq
10 Ordinanoe A' ourr.ntly adopt.d by Counoil dOli not mandate
It that nonconforming ule. b. r.qllt.red.
11
o
Are you Iwar. alia that prior to 19'. there wa.
11 . period Of time wh.n that wa. Il mandatory r.quir.ment tor
l' borough' and munlolpalitl.. to do?
20
A
I'. aware ot that. And I'. al.o aware that
21 'O.e munlolp'lltll' do have th... nonoontorminq regiltera
22 trom that p'rlod prior to 19... To the belt ot my
2) knowledql 1 hlv, not ..,n ouch a reqiltry 'n the til.. ar
24 tha lorouqh of Carli. Ie.
-..J
n
o
Ami 91ven the intormatlon you mentioned a. ta
~=~~-~~-c..ntr.l--~in".yl v~nl~' E~\lft--p-;rQ-rtTn;rli;rvli,;;-~w~--
t 'PI ~"".,,,,,,
82
1 noncontormlnq uoe. where there have been complaintl or
a lome other actlono, did you review that intormation to eee
3 it there wal any lnformatlon there pertalninq to thil
4 particUlar former Kinney Shoe property?
e
A
Ve., I reviewed the property tile with
6 reterenoe to the complAint. that W. had been reoeivinq.
7 And there wa. no record of the extent of the prevloul
I nonoonforminq UI.. Theretore, we needed to contact both
9 the current uler, beln9 Allen oiltrlbution, and the prior
10 u.er, Kinney Shoe, and 9ather the b..t information that we
11 could obtain to try to make a determination.
12
Q
And did you allo coneult with .ome of the
13 nelQhboring property owner.?
14
A
Vee, I did. I .po~. with Hr. John nietline and
Ie I bel1eve Hr. Btln..
16
Q
And wa. it lort ot a cumulative relult of ,11
17 thele lntervlewe that led you to yo~r lmpr.ellon a. to
II what the prior ule wall
19
II
ThAt 1. corrlct. The bA.l. for thl
-,/
ao dltermlnatlon WI' prlmarl1Y on oonver.at'on. with Pon
:u Ihlndhdeckn, the chllf enlJln..r for Kinney Ithoe. And..
all the rloord hit. oha",r. tllle evenlnc}. there Wit. " telephone
;1) aonvilIrllttion thilt. 1 hod wlth Hr. I$hlndll:lde,:kltr prior to my
H October 14th lethr. ThAt letter Ii". retJelv4ut by Ul.
~~ colllQI" few d"YII "ttlr It. belnq written.
r"'/Itr" I hill\l'\ltylllltnlt1 t:Ollrt Ih'l,ort l"oJ Il.r..."'...
(1111 )'111.1(,."
84
1
A
I live rIqht aoroe' the alley where the Ie dock.
:I are, approKlmately 1:1~ or 150 teet.
3 Q Ilow 101\9 have you 11 ved In that property?
4 A Forty-two y..re.
& Q And are you employ.d now?
6 A No, I'm retlud.
1 Q Wh.n dld you retire?
. A About :10 y.ara a90. I work.d tor tha UI
9 Oovlrnment.
10
Q
So atter you r.tIred, dld you Ipend a
11 conaiderable Amount of tIme around the hOUII?
12
A
Q
V.., I did.
From that dietanee to the warehouI., did you
13
14 becoml ramili,r with the op.ration that KInney Shoe
1& oonduct.d there particularly with rer.renoe to the 1.lt
10 year or 10 befora th.y 1.tt the oplration?
p
A
Well, I've .e.n it 90in9 from. oorntiald to a
11 mon.ter. That'. what .- I m.an, 1 think when th'y bul1t
l' the ahoe rAotory, 1 th1nk thllY qot 1t relonea. And I
ao think they ,.ked tor lame klnd ot an eKemptlon when thay
ZI built the wlrehou.e. And 1 hAd never h.d no trouble WIth
\J
" Ktnn.y .hoe, non.,
Zl The factory. they had the poopl_ park ther.,
Z4 and the war.houI. w.. no proble., ThOY onLy ever had four
~~ Of flv., .ill HY4ikIJ 1n I d4Y, Put thlV dldn't unlQad thlt!m
~,---'....._+_.~." .~
..--.--.".,....--.....
.~_..,..,..., .."--"~"- - ._'~.'_.._--, ,_._~,"-- .-,,---
Clnl,aL ~.~na~lv"~l,, couit "aport nq "'rYI~..
tn 11 J,\.-\r,"I'
85
1 truck.. They brouqht them In and dropped them and took
:.I another And lett.
J Th... new on.., Allen olltrlbutlon, brlnQI them
4 1n and back. them up to tho dook, run. the 11tt truek. in
, and out and unload. th.m, pull1 that one out and brinq.
6 anoth.r on. in. It'. .tart.d at 4100 In the morn1nq
1 already. And my bedroom i. only about 1'0 t.et trom where
. the.. door. are.
.
NOW, I did e.. a truck oom. in at Il quarter or
10 two one morninq. And the area belnq rather .mall, 1t took
11 h111. while to qet that 40-toot trailer into the dock. II.
1:.1 had to jook.y it Around. The whole time it'. runninq, the
lJ air brlkl. lJ01nq on 'nd otto
14
10 I qat up. J Itayed up the re.t ot the
10 n19ht. It'. bien a re.l problem .in08 Allen took oVer.
16 aut whl1e Minnev WAI th.re, I never had A probl.. eKoept
17 one time I ..ked them to out the w.ed. alonq the rence
11 blloAu.e it WAG .cratchinq my car when I left.
l'
o
Mr. Illtlln., did you notice a 11Qnitlolnt
ao 00109. in the operatlon. at thle looAtlon .tter A.D. took
:.J 1 ovn1
u
A
I eUr. did, live .e.n two truoke At the do~k,
4
21 thre. w41tl"9 At 4100 in the morninq. How, Moat at the
"4 tl_. tn_ trUQK. w,r. there byt the people that unloaded
n tn.1lI dhtn't .t4ft ul'lttl _IlHl. AmI ttu.n IAh" Q(I UHIY
(.'","t ,.. j j'..f;YlI1lY h',\!'l 1!1 ('\I\ln It'''f'IH U I'\<j II.., \I 1'0..
Pltl )";Mol<'l'l1
116
1 atarted ,t 1100. But 1 have .een two ~t the dook and
2 three .ittlnq out then 4100 ana !lIOO in the morninq.
3
Q
Old you notlo. any chanqe atter Allen
4 Oiatribution took over a. tar aa the prooedure. that they
o were uainq to unload the truckll
6
A
Oh, yel. They uae lift truck.. And I'm not
1 aure but I believe Pedford loaded their trailer. by hand.
8
Q
II.. there been an increa.e in thl nolle from
9 the loading ,nd unloading?
10
A
A lot. When them litt truok. 90 out over them
11 ateal platel tram the trailer onto the dook, you can hear
12 them ev.ry time. They come out loaded and 90 in empty and
13 qat another onl. So that nol.. 1. contlnual whil. they
14 are unloading the truck..
10
Q
lIave you noticea any ditflunce 1n the manner
16 that the truck I for Allen Di.tribution enter the premi.ea
17 or leAva the premi.e. a. oppo..a to tha way Kinney did it1
11
A
There wu . oate thera. And when IUnnoy run
I' it, I belleva they OAme in off of Oranq. Street, went on
20 the .outh aldl of the bulldlnq. Now, I n.v.r a.an tham
21 u.. thl dock. oyer ther.. but thlV com. .round the
U bulldinq and pulled in her.. They only left throu(,lh thl.
u q.to her. to 90 out. but thin wa. a bl(,l .iqo on the qato
24 that ..i4, No Truck EntnotJl, H', .till ther.,
~J n Hit, H()JCQ lNfllA(.1 ThAnk you. Th"t'. .11 thl
~~_,="-~"..,.......,.-".._.-..,..~,...,..~...."~,"',,,,"~.~_-.cm~,._,.,.'.~...,,.-- - '".,.,.-.,-,,'
rentr41 rennlylvan1a c.urt ~'puft
(Iii I #";ll-'.'I"
..J1-.
1 q"eltion. I havI tor Hr. Diltline.
a
TilE CIlAJRHANI I takl it the 119n 1- ItHl
1 there, b"t ther.'. been' chanqe thAt the tr"ckl now <.10 In
4 that 9at' a. will a. out ot thet qlte?
II TilE WJTNr:1UlJ Thftt'l riQht, ell of thlll.
6
TilE CIlAJRMANI We heard lome u.tllllony that
1 there wa. 10m' .pik. activity with the .pple prOduut. And
I thAt Allen ha. mad. an .rtort to mOVe thet type ot .plk.
9 activity to enother werehouI.. I re.l1.1 that'. u..n
10 rec.nt, al Hr. orell'. q"l.tionl point out. Do yO" notlcl
11 any ohanll' for the better over the la.t thr.e w..ke or
12 month or Iny period at time?
13
TIll': WlTNr:UI 't'I, "JI to A lIlonth 'Qo th.y woula
It b. In ther. at 4100 and !lIOO in the .orninq, And I tAlked
15 to Mr. D.nnl, and I 'alk.d to Hr, Glordlno ao4 ..ld there
l' wA.n't -. WI oo"ll1n" do Inythtnq until WI hid thl.
11 h.arinq. '0 I telked to Mr, OWln., the oounoil..n, an4 hI
I' ClAlll' up.
I'
And hI lookea It the op.rAtlon, And hi ..Id, I
ao don't blu, yOll, Thla hilt to tie ItoPptil, 1M. OillnMf,
31 continue 11ko thi.. 1 CAn ..e wher. VOU'f' neVlr Qol~J \9
U Qlt n<l .1__p with thht HIJ4ljJ, ..,.IMI U4vk JllU'It.
n
AM4 Ln 'V gpLnlQn Il I. ~ 'fYP~ "f.lnAl
, _..J
~4 bleAu" WIt'V. ..." lQ Qf 40 'ru~k. Q~' Qf ,n-,' .lQ'~,
~t QO.' In d~1 QQ, iRQ'fi., Qfi. ~y~' i~ ~~1 aQ,
C.,nHI\ r.."tt...,lv"nl<4 \(,iuH ."";."'1"1 '=lonl'"."
Pill J'liidlt'?;
....__._._-_.---_.""""..._._..-'-~........,,,...
,-~-~- ---
1
TilE: CllA1l1HAN I Whl\t your 4n.w.r to lilY qu..t Ion
a 1. thlt there hll b..n .Olll. l.provlmlnt OVlr the la.t
] .onth?
4
.
TlfE WITNElllII Oh, Y'" In other word. --
HR. CIIAIRHANI Ther.'. beln lome attempt to
. ohlnql the houri and It a.tlrA?
'7
Tilt WITNI;:!"''' JHCJht. And 1f thlY wou ld CJO to
. the .outh dook. .- I CAn't IPI.k tor th..1 plopll -. but I
, wouldn't have 4 oomplllnt. But if thlY would jUlt try 4nd
10 AOOO.lodAtl u. a littll blt.
U Till: CIlAIRHANI Any othlr .e.ber of thl boara?
'3 Anv ...o.r. of the audl.nol have a qu..tlon of thl.
U wltne..' An,' I qu... I Ihoull1 ukl 00.. thl applioant
14 hAye a que.tion ot thl. wltn...?
u
MM. WI1NQAMTIHI AotUA11y, I ju.t have a
It .&.illr 11ne ot qUlltlon for" nuab.r of plopll. I juat
11 hAye I oontinullS obhot!on to the tact that the only h.uI
" ,. hour. ot opluUon/ thl' 1Il1 or th... other IIlUII are
l' Il.plV lfr.llvlnt.
30
Till CIlAlftKANI Uw1.r.tand. And w.'11 con.id.r
II that I oontlnulnq obj.ctlon to ..oh wltn... oalled on thl1
II '..YI. Th.nk yo~.
u
It t~4t" th_ B4.., Hr. Blltllol, th4nk you
y
~. v.rv M~~~ f9f Y9~r tlM. 4~. YQ~r 4tt.n~4na.. W.
i~ 4fff.~I~t. YQ~r nllp,
{:IOI" f.. t tli""" , I '0;41' I.. l'lH.H t ~.fo('ft In'., '~.r~TI:~'.'"''"-'''"
i qll j-.... I.....'
89
I
:I
HR. HOItOENTIIALI I'd lik. to clIll IIl1fry Dooth.
TilE CHAlRMANI Mr. Booth, would you ralee your
3 right hand to be .worn, pl....?
4 HAItRY OooTII, called II a witne.., havlnq b.en
5 duly Iworn, teltifled a. tolloW'1
6
TilE CHAIRMANI Hr. Booth, you've alrelldy been
1 identlfi.d for the reeord. WI thank you. Coun.el?
8 DIRECT EXAMINATION
II ItY HR. MOROENTIlALI
10
o
A
Mr. Booth, wh.re are you .mployed?
I'm retired ju.t a y.ar and II hAlt ago trom
11
12 Dlokinlon Col1.qe.
1]
14
o
A
You werl a profe.lor there?
I WAI a profel.or chere tor all year.. David
15 010rdano wal on. of my Itudent. And you were one ot my
16 .cudent.. I have an eNtreme atreotion ror Dickinlon
11 Colleqe. Michael Britton II II very good trlend of mlne.
II I ,dmlre the oolleqll'l enterprlle, and 1 underltllnd that
\11 the col1eql neld. to brln9 in money In order to contlnu.
:10 it. operatlone and that th.e. .r. hArd time..
:11 And It'. in eplt. of all that and wlth II h.avy
:1:1 he.rt that I nlv.rthel,.. have to .ay that what'l
:I) happenlnq there now i, totally dltrerent from wh.t wall
:14 happenlnrJ therl whl" ~ln".y wal oper.tln~ tho factory and
:I') the W4fllhou.... 1 'lIQuid uy that I'v" lived wh.re 111(Jw
"--",,"..".'t".,".,,.,.,
'-<,;;;'f,'a i ....'HHly lV411 .. ('ollr t .1l-J'llf t In;l ti..;:,il;....
(1111 Pili-if.'"
'JO
-'-".-'---.--"--
"
1 live tor 10 ye.r. 00 that I wao aware or the Klnney
2 operation.1 well al the pre.ent operation.
3
Q
Mr. Booth, your houoe actually l. acro.1
4 Louther street tram, tor eKample, where Hr. pi.tline
5 live., i. that correct?
6
A
I tall outlide the zoo-toot -- the .acred
1 aoo-toot lone. I meaoured it. It'. About 100 Ylrdl.
8
Q
I. it tair to lay, thouqh, that you are trom
9 that podUon able to noUcl a change In what h.. b..n
10 occurring there .ince Allen Pi.trtbution took over?
11
A
Yel. I like to lit on a patio ln front ot my
12 houle whlch i. on the Louther Street lidl at the hou...
1) And I won't repeat mYlelt to you but there wire Ikplltlv"
14 involved whln I tirlt realized on .ithlr the 2~th or 26th
15 of JUly that oomlthing qrollly ditterlnt wa. hlpp.n1nQ ln
16 that wlrlhoul. and in the land ln front ot it.
v
11 I walkea oVer there to Und out whit WIa
11 happeninq. I went into the warehoule and .flok. to ttle
19 plopl. who were working there, who were ooviou.ly not
ao relponlible tor whAt wa. qolnq on. hut I did Alk the.
al 10.e queltionl about what wa. 901n9 on. And that'. how I
22 round out that All.n ot.trlbutlon had l....a thl prQ~rty
2) tram 01cklnlon Colley..
Jot Ana the uuon th"t I went over ther. wu th.'
2!lo I..AI jolted" In,i I don't think th4t'lI tv" _"PM it
_~~...,.....~_--......~___...~ ~._~,... .._~ _,_~_ _ c~,.__ ._~.'" _, n._.. "._..__. .._
\?II1Otul l'IHlnllYlv""i,, \:Ollft IllIJ".rtihIJ ll4ilfVlliflllt
,'I') Jill- 1&;1
'.11
1 word -- by the noile, not the kind at nol.e that Mr.
a Bl.tlin. r.ferred to in term. at the truck. cominq in and
J wh...lnq and turninq around which would bother thai.
4 hou.el muoh alo..r, but the clanq, the janule, the jolt
& that you teel in the alr ,na ln the qround and In your
6 ..r. when the forklittl move back and rorth tram truok
1 trailer to war.hou.e and tram WarehouI' to trailer.
. I don't know why thAt hal to be that lOUd, why
, that can't b. cUlhlon.d. Put my eKperi.nce whioh il what
10 I con.lder to b. the .I..nti.l raot. and not a minutia at
II all -- my eKp.rl.no. il th,t that'. .xtr.mely d.qrad.d the
la li'e ot the p.ople who live in that neiqhborhood.
u
Q
lilt tair to lay th.n that thi. ha. had a
'4 IUb.tantial impAot upon you?
n
u
It hll.
A
HM. HOMOINTHALI Thank you, No other
11 que.Uon.,
It
HM. OJJLLI t.t.e aok tho qu..tionl that the
,. Ch.tr~n 'Iked the lilt witn.I.. W.'VI h..rd about
10 ,"ort. on behalt ot the ocoupantl to 1....n the nol.e.
II H,y. vou notiold any Qhanq.. ln the l..t couple 01 w.ek.?
u
THe WltH~#_, lnd..4, An4 1 took a
.J
3l ~n.plratori41 interpret4tion ot it at tiflt that wlth the
~. y,~.i~ hearl~ th4t they W~f' CQQll~ thlwJI down. lut
H f\W 1 YNtluh",a (n.III t(,n1IjM, tll.H tlllit'. not the "...,
(~"I'IH..I r..nn..y 1\t.."I~ e,,;IH 1I_"llft inq 1l.1;~Tr;.~'~""""'~
(1111 g.,Il\";i
_.__ 92__..
1 that the eplke or the pul.. or the ourge I. over tor the
a tall and that thlnql are naturally oalming down. And I
3 accept that.
4 But it atll1 Ilem. to me that the thr.e month.
5 tram Auquot -- blq summer and tall monthl tor people to
6 Ipend ln thelr yardl, that that surqo time plus another
7 three month. ln the lovIly sprlng are precilely the tlmeo
I when It'. going to b. busle.t and precl..ly the time. when
9 w. would like to have, and I think de.erve to have, lt
10 mOlt quiet.
n
MR. GRILLI I ,m very taml11ar wlth the
12 neighborhood. I u.ed to llve in that qenlrel area and run
13 by what mu.t be your hou.e. 00 you think ettort. to
U inonAle u.. ot the tar ,ide ot the buildinq would help in
lD Ibatlnq the nol.e1
16
THE WI TN t:1IIJI I think thAt the north wall at
17 the warehoule tunctlonl II a ,oundlnq Board. So that
11 everythinq that happen. at tho.e bAY' !lod everything that
19 happen. in the little oul.de-.ao nOKt to tho.. bay.
ao reverblrAtl' out toward Louthlr Ptrlet t:uward our hou....
al And, ol.arly, anythin9 that happened on the north .1dl
aa wouldn't: have that ,.me .- now e.lotlv how muoh noi.. that
II would e,u.e, 1 don't know. Put my que., i. that that
24 would be tar more 84tl.t.Qtory tor everybody.
y
a~
HH. a~tLL! Thank you,
",,"''''-'''''=''''''''''''''~''''''='''='?''=~'-''''t'''=''''''''''''':~''-'"'''_''''''''=-':-''''''':--=''=r-="'.'::_-='''''"='''''='''''''=''''"'-=-''''.-.-'~'''":'''';.'''''''''-'''="'''-~~~._---_.~.,..""",,"""'''-''''''''-.'''=-'"'~''''--
Cantu' r.no..,.lv.,,,. Cglut M.porUnq IhtrVllJlIll- .
(lln J '\II. }I/IIH
94
1 ~outher atr.et addr...?
2
A
Completed 43 year. there About June at thi,
3 year, on mv 44th vear there.
4 0 Are you retired?
II A I am.
6 0 Ilolt lonCJ hll that be.n1
1 A tllK veAu.
a 0 lIpend Il lot ot time at home?
, A Ve..
10 0 NOIII, where I. your hou.. relative to the Minn.v
11 \IIarehou.e 10eatlon1
13
A
I'. directly Aoro.. tram the ..ploV""
1) entr.no. to the .anuteoturlnq ere., in the lot it..lt, in
14 the parklnq lot It.elt, not the Oranql .tre.t but trom the
11 parklnl,} lot.
11
o
How, you've h..rd the t..tl.ony both ot Mr.
U DI.Uln. IInd Mr. Dooth. I. thuI anythlnq that you would
II Qar. to add to what they hAve 'Ald1
It
A
Vi., I QonQur with what thlV hAVI te.titled
ao to. I h,.rd the on. drlver for ~Inn.v etate that he QO...
Ii In th.r. III hour. of the nl,ht IInd .0 on. ThlY
II .".rentlY would CQ.e In off of Or.nq. on the .outh
~l drlvewllY .w~ QO.' .ro~n4. Th.y ~o~ldn't ..It that ~aau..
~. wn." tn. 4qqk f.q~l. or the W4r'~Y" plople would l.av.,
~~ 'hlY 19~.~t 'R4' ~4t. 4~t .~.,. W4~ R~ W4Y un'... th.y
("I'IH It i t'li!\j,lj,t I v,," " {'''14ft II;oJi\lft
"PI JO-;.d~'H
95
1 would have a key.
3 Now, I have a small garden out back. And I
J work that garden. I waved at that man back there a number
4 ot time. who Uet1t1ed and aleo the other driver. And I
IS had a chance in workinq my garden to observe just what
6 trattic came in there. I happen to dilagree that they
7 were in that many time. ln the evening. I think I would
8 have ob.ervsd.
9 Al.o, I'd like to go turther in the number ot
10 truok.. EVen it they would u.e the dock on the tar lids.
11 they would .till have to make that Iwing around and come
13 aorole and eKit on the north 11dl ot the buildinq. And al
13 hal beln brouqht out, the aluminum Ilding there il a
14 .ounding board.
15
Al.o, thlrl are the bumplr.. And mo.t ot the
y
16 driverl 1 think haVe learned eKclpt tor eome privati
11 oarriere that coml in there that they're pre'lnt. But it
11 thlY followed thl white line. going up through, they have
19 to hit the bumper .- road bumperl there.
30 I think John when he teltirled .e to the
al back-up trucx., I'm in A position -. I'm approwimatsly 100
a3 yarde, oh, bettar th," that, . gOod hAlt block. And I've
al lien the. stacked this lummar not only In the tan8 le.ding
:l4 in through the (Jilt. th4t wu eventu4l1y knocxld down
~~ bec411.. ot the hck of .p"ce in turninq or jockeyinq in
~~~='~c'~c--""c;nri4r'i.nft;Y i vMd" (Qyr-t "..'Qrt I "'J Ii;'iv rQ';---"---~
nnl J!'Ift<l,,"/
lib
~",-~~,.._.
,
1 th.r. to Qet to the paVI.
a
Thev would be In the lan. and a I.w av.r to the
3 .id.. And thll 1. . oontinuaul .tr.o.. I like to r.adl I
4 get up eArly In the .orninq. I tallQw the glock,
5 nor.ally. Vou know, II It Q.t. llqht At 6100, I'. up, qet
6 . .how.r. In the .u..er lonth., I co.. out th.r. .nd I
1 r'ld on the porch. And I IIQht (fo down to b.lt the h..t
I Ind pull w.ea. In 'v QArd.n.
. And it'. unpl,..lnt with truok. dle"llnQ
10 .I,ll.r. Ther. hi' ~.n '0" l.prov...nt on thlt, I think
11 I QUit d..1 I.prov..ent on U,.t, 1.ninQ their '/19i"..
13 run Ind dl...llnq. Th. plak ..I.Oft, Hlrrv brGy,ht out
13 thlt it QOy,r. thlt plri04 wh.r. w. liv. out.id..
u
I .It on IV blok P9foh in th. 'U..I" I hlY' ,y
II br.ak,..t th.r./ w. .It ~r 'U'f'f', 01...1 Iu... would
16 'ilt., In. the nol.e, It WI' Y~..fort.pl.. w.
11 virtuI1IV.. I f.w tt... w,nt in,idl. fhat'. I~ut all I
11 Qln 144.
n
"K. MOf<<UIf'f1tALI l"""k you. NQ o\h.,
30 "U..Ult"l.
U
f"1 f"AI~NI ~ftl 1~,'ton.' Anv qu.'tlQft' of
aa tn. A~l.~' (~r ..,.tl _~'~t.' Mf. blt.r, w. '~n~ V~
Jl 'or VQUf ,..~ .~ V~, A'..~~8. A,p,.~14l. y~t n.lp.
:It
"~, ~1.4~~fWA~~ J~ ~~, ~l~~'.t. ~.r.l Pl4 ygU
\J
I~ WIIR'~ '4( .N1tn.~jr
.~._......___ .~__.._ . ~ .. ._mm____...._.__._c.____
t.Of,H'*1 ,.iil\,.'; i~i..h ~"4H ...t'..., lli.j ::"f'ltjo.'."
I Ie \ ~ I 1 "ii: ! J iC.' !
911
1 that?
a A Yeah, 1 would echo that and attempt to juot
3 quaUty the volume at thu no18. level. My bedroom ia on
4 the baok 8ide ot the hOUI.. And sinoe July I've spent all
~ ot my time in that room with the Itorm window down and the
6 normal window down jUlt in an attempt to try to mitiQllto
1 the noise lev.l.
a And I miqht add that I'm unluccelltul in doin9
~ that. I'm still Awake almolt all the time until reoently
10 at 5100 or 5130 or 6100 in the mornin9 trom juat the noile
11 level alone.
1:1
o
Ha. tharl been a sub.tanti.l chang. in your
13 oplnion trom when ~lnneY'1 were there?
14
A
1 lived there, trankly, tor the previouI .iK
10 and a hlllt y.arl or eo wlthout eVer notioinq that there
16 w.. even Any aotivity. NOW, maybe that'. my blinders at
17 work, but 1 aimply didn't r..lly PAY Any attention to the
II Us. of that facility until July of this year.
19
HR. MOROr:NTtlALI Thank you. No further
30 qu..t1onl.
U
H
Till: CIIAlRHANI Any lIIembere of the loud?
HR. OENNtNI You h,4 .tated the levela of
~) nol.e, Can you identlry what time at the day you would be
24 experienclnq tho.. nol...1
..J
;r!)
THr: WtTN~j~J Well, 1 C4n ..Y that, frankly, 1
Centra renniytvan 4 Court ~.PQr
(lPI J~.'I"'!\I
I
;10
lit
U
n
H
.. :#~
Oil
1 work Ind .pend an awtul lot at time ln my ottlce lnoludlnq
a the .venlnQ. aut tor .. the hour. between ~IOO In the
J lIIornlnq And 1.00 Ir. prealoul. And lt'l a tAotual
4 .tlt...nt to ,IY thlt tour dlY' . week at lea.t and
, lo..ti... tive aaYI I w.ek I would wlke up .1.ply trom tho
6 nol.. llvll It '100. ~IlO in the .ornlnQ.
7
I Ictullly hlv, . record. I blQln to .tart to
. dOQu..nt 'hi U..I. And It would vary betw..n 1)110 Iml
, '14' on a r'QulA' bael., At lellt for .', thl rir.t Ihock
10 WIV. w~uld hit ot nol.e.
u
THI CHAI~NI Anyon. .11. on the 'oard?
13 Anvon. In thl ludl.no. ~ve a qUI.tlon of thl. witne.t?
1l
MM. MOa4IHTHALI ThInk you. MIohl"
14 "u..nthl'. dg you wl.h to 'I.tity?
"
THI CHAI~HI Mr. 'lu..nthAI. would you ral..
I' your rl~h' hand, .Ir, and '- tworn7
11
11
IMl~h..1 ,Iu..ntha' w.. .worn.)
fHt eHAI~MAHI WQu'd you ldlntlty your.llt with
I' your ft_" .~ .adr..., .lr1
THe WITHl~JI MV AMI. 'e M'@h..1 'Iu..n'hl&, I
live .. 61' W.., ~~'n'f .tr..'.
fHI { If A I liMA,. f fM"''' yf,lll.
MlfHA~~ .~U"~~~~~, ~411~j 4. . wl'~t., ~vIWJ
iI..,. fU"'@>t4Iy 4lil'( ,,;';Offf, tu'H1104 n .~U""'H
~-'~'"-'--'-'--~-'''
'.".-.- .......... _.-
-~li~~f~f~.~l~~t h~I~~"~~;+fr~~~h l~~@f;-i !;'..i
I~P~ iU.'IlU
'-',
JQ
at
U
n
u
WI n
100
1
a PY HR. MOROENTIIALI
OIRECT EXAMINATION
3
Q
Mr. 81umenthal, I'll aek you lome ot the sama
4 que.tionl I've a.ked the oth.r witn..a... Wh.re 1e your
a houle r.l.tive to the Klnn.y warlhou.. property?
6
II
I live dlreotly adjacent on the north lide. My
7 houle i. riqht b..id. where the truok. would park betore
I they would enter the qate to unload, I'd lAY probably 50
9 yardl at the maKimum trom where thole truck. would idle.
10 And I'd have to agre. with Mr. Nicht.r that we
11 naVer notic.d the nolle problem. I'm thl new kid on the
la block. My wlte and I moved there probably about thr.. and
1) a hait yearl aqo. And on. ot the realonl W8 cho.e that
14 hou.e WI' b.clu.e of thl neiqhborhood, very qui.t and very
1~ pelcetul. We thouqht it would be . nic. place to etart
16 our tully.
11
w. have a tour-year-old and a two-v.,r-ola.
II And they are both light 11e.perl. And our whole fAml1y
" hat been affeoted by the problem. W. have our children
Qattinq up at 4100 and ~IOO becau.a at the nol.e. And
it'. d1tticult for .nybQ~y to Qlt vauk to .leep ,t that
point.
1 r.al1v wanted to leplore .. 1 und.r.tand that
U'8 houri (If Qpeuthm U8 4t hliU8 IUIlf(i. Put the noi..
i. ,..lly . probl.., A. Mr. ..l.tllne .tateal it f..lly
",,"'-"","~c>(:';~ntCrirr;;n".';lv"nl; '(:~ur~"l;;vortlnQ"lf.'rvrc.'.~="'>'
(lln 1~'.H.,p
'''"'\
II
6
7
8
9
10
11
13
) 13
,
14
1!l
16
17
11
1.
20
~
101
1 doos ehake the area. 1 mean, our hou.e 8hakes trom the
2 noioe. And 1 really hadn't realized what tho noise wa.
3 until they indicated thAt it wal the torklitt. movlng.
4 It a180 lound. like they oame in and droppod
.omething. And I don't know it it'. in the building or
out in the parking lot, but lt really doe. Ihake the
neiqhborhood. And 1 really think that to hAVe thAt happen
in the early houra at any time at tho year oven if it'.
only lix month I out ot tho year il not acceptable. And
I'm concerned tor the quality of living tor my ohildren
and my family.
HR. HORQENTHALI No further queltione.
HR. CIlAIRHANI Hr. crell, do you have a
qUIIUon1
HR. QRELLI Have you noticed Any ditterenoe
over the lalt oouple weeke?
TilE WITN!lJB I V.., 1 have. 1 had .I.umed it
WAI beOAu.e ot the loning otflcer'. letter. And 1 ..Iumed
that Dloklneon came into compllanoe beoau.e they had to
until the hearinq. 1 had notioed a .lowdown, I'd lay,
at oVer the p..t month wlth the noi.e. But there hae .tlll
:u boo" I couple ,"ception. to thatl on., notably between the
2) hour ot 2100 and )100 within the paet month that there wa.
24 A 8ubot.ntlal Amount ot nol.. 1 think juat trOm one
at truok, lut it WI. atlll .o..What annoylnq.
-,~~"""",,,,,,,,,,-c,,,,,,~,,,._,,,,,-,~,,,,,,,,,,,,,,~,,,\.,,,....._,..,-,,,_.........._..<-~-'..."...."_"..",,,-....'C",,,",._'.,,,.'.:,..,._b~'~.....-.....~.,-'..-r."""".,.""'..~"...,=""....>W-,.."",...."....--:~,....,."....'-~
- . - - c.ntr.I -...nn.ylvAnllt c€"irt IHI('(I"lII'lQ ".rvic.... ....
P \II J..ll-Il';'\/
u
n
Il
H
\J ;J~
lO;!
,.,__..........~_.",...__~".H ' ..~_,n.."_~.._~,.~_ .... ,. ---.-____..-.-'_,_._'...__.___.. ..__""'_.___....._._...._.".
I H~. a"~~LI And you think that it'. ~or. tho
a fQrkl1fta thAn the truQk. i~11n91
) TtlJ: WITNUIlI HOlt of the tim. ft truck It hllll
4 i.n't too both.rlu~.. Wh.n they ActUAlly .ntlr thl lot,
. thlr. Ir' .p..a bu~p.. And lo.e of the'. truck, Are
6 tlklno th..1 Ip..d ~u'p' It whIt 1 would con,lder I hhlh
., rat. of .pe~ for A tully lOlded trActor-trAll.r.
. I don't know how ~uch thl.. thlnQ' we1Qh, but 1
, know lt '"kl' A 10n9 t1.. to Qlt th.. e1ow.d down. And
iO th.y'r. ju.t oo.lft9 thrQuQI'I t..t enO\l9h thAt lt 1. ~"klno
11 I .ub.tlntlI1 I.ount ot nol.. whln the truck QO" over. 1
lJ don't know how .any Iw1.. they hIV', but you f..l ..ch
U on..
14
MM. aMILL! Tnl"k V~Uf
T>>& C'MA I MAH I .n)'oM ln the ludl'n"l hIVe"
u
'6 qu..t10n of ,1'1, w1'nl..1 Mr. 'lu..nth.l, thInk you vory
11 'UOft for your ti.. .nd your hllp thl1 IVlnlnQ.
u
" ,..U tV"
'0
MM, MONGJNTKALI Mf.. Hl11@r, do you w1'ft to
MM. W~IMQA.fIHI fhlf.'. vlry rl. b....
on whl@h to Q,).~t .t . '@"'~ n.'f'~, ~t 'h.
r.,.'ltlv. .~j .rrallvIA' ".'lM#OY I. .~tuAl'V IbQy\
l~' ~ff'V ~*.~., .~j I '"I~- _.',. r..~"'~ tn4t
Jii*'"''
'ffl~ Oi,UltH,\U f 4'1.l,."H< L I It.... ijlii I /llj \(# lJW4'Jnt
~j.It.,... ~ '1Ii/';;<'1 lV'H'" If"".." .li"'''fiT~I~ ~"fyi;:".",--'
fil I ~'ad~~1
103
1 it it', pOB.1ble thAt 1f you hAVO witnesses that will
2 concur in this testlmony, thet we indlcAto that by tho
3 number and thow of handl, and the BOArd will accept thAt
4 th81e witnallos' teltimony would ba the eame unlo.1 you
D think that there mAY b. lome slqnlricAnt tactual
e dUterenc...
1
MR. MOROENTIIALI My only concern il that .ince
. they .ach live alonq the streat, that we've heard lomo at
9 them had dirtar.nt ob'.rvation. and eKpari.noel ba.ed on
10 the tlme they'vI b..n th.r.. Since we're kind ot in an
11 open proceadlnq h.ra not .ura .xactly whatll qoinq to be
12 conaldered ultimatlly, I'm. little raluctant not to qiva
11 them the opportunlty.
14
Tllr: CIlAUtMANI I aocept Coun..l', objeotion amI
l' I 'eo09n1'8 It. On tht oth.r hand, I don't want to out
16 you otf, .lthlr. 10 pl...1 proc..d.
17
MR. rREVI Will you r.l.e your rlqht hand,
11 pl.o.., Ms. Hil1er1
I' (J...i. Hiller wu tworn.)
30
TilE CHAIRMAN' And wOllld you id.ntity youruU
al Wlth your n..a and addrs" tor tha r.cord tor UI, HI.
U H11hr"
n
Till: WITNJ:..' 1'11I J.u18 MUler. 1 l1v. Itt 611J
24 Wett Lo~th.r Str.et.
""
lID
Tift: CHAUOol"lt' 'fMnk you vuy lIluCh.
_ ','c,"'_' "~,,,.t.,., ..
c.niiti l"'hnniylv"nli\ (:O\~ft '~'rlort (;';fJ'~~"fvI~:.;~ '__C'd
P\ll Jill<<IIi"/
104
")
1
JESSIE MILLER, oalled a. a witne.., having bIen
2 duly Iworn, te.titied .. followe,
3
4 DIRECT EXAMINATION
II BY HR. HOROENTHALI
6 Q And, Hr.. Hill.r, how long have you lived
1 there?
8 A Thirty-one years.
9 Q And where i. your hOUI' relative to the Kinney
10 property?
11 A It/. right in my baok yard praotically.
12 Q NoW, YOU'VII hlllrd the te.timony ot the other
} 13 witn...... Do you g.nerally oonour with that?
14 A Y...
U Q hi th.n anything that you t..l n.c...ary to
16 add to what th.y'v, .ald?
11
A
No, I wanted to reiterat. what Mr. Booth laid.
l' It'. that clanging, and my whol. hOUI. .hok... I
l' und.ratand that they mUlt drop a plate Or lomothing ln
ao ord.r for th... truok. to move In or out or whatever they
al do. And wh.n th.y drop that, the whole hOUle ahak., and
aa I'M wakened out at a .leep wh4t.ver hour it i.. And thIn
Zl you a.noot get back to .1e.p.
H
o
I' that lo..thlnq thAt did not ocour wh'n
..
~~ ~lnn.y" were thef.?
e.nt fit ".nfI-V V4n " {;~'\H t Ih;~mrt
pin .1"1_-11'11)'
u
U
I U
14
11
It
n
"
if
'0
n
u
n
..,
-"""'.~.
__...J
1 0 ~_._
1
a
A
I nav.r ha.rd 1t b.tor. in ~y lit..
only .na, ..
only .tt., ~h'Y e.... I hid ba.n out ot town.
3
Q
A
4 When lOA.' b,ek, thl' wa. an e.tabli.hed thin.. And I
, "'''' .hook.a It th. llI"unt ot noi.. thlt we wer. endurinq.
.
MM. MOROINTHALI Thank you.
Tltl (,IIMIlMAN I Anv ....b.r of the aud1.nce hlva
7
. . qUI.tion? M.. Mill.', th.nk you v.ry ~uch.
,
MM. MOf40INTltALI H.V 1t pl.... th. Board, I
10 "'Int to .nt.r 'Y 'pP8'ranc. ~n behalf of . ny.b.r of tho
r..id.nt.. I'll qiv. thi, to your .t.nQ9rAphlr to be
.",,11.0 to w~o..v.r VOU ,f.f.r. A nUlb.r of tll.
"'itn..... .ra lnoluata thore on I' ~'ll I' ,.v.ral who
hlV' not ta.tlf.ta. I'M .."IV 901nQ to Ilk whethor th.re
.r. any of tha gtnar folk. who . rapr"lnt who would Ilk.
t. .IY .nythinq'
MR. ~"I I knQW I "ok. b.tore, byt "v I
'IV on. lof' thl",' And that ,. tn.t .1thouQh fOOYI on
en. ..,ly a9rnlnq ftQYfl 'I very iMpgrtant, for tho.. ot YI
\In. .r. r.tlrf4, th. n@1,. that ~@nllnu., thro~hout the
dAV, lnter""ln"y t~ ~ 'ijr. pij' )~.\ AI )anqlln9 IAch
UN h CW~\,j"1 lit U htJ!lilfl.!;t \@ 1.18 iUI tn. ..rlv '(/tnlWI
I'IJNnh
H
"", /llQM~ffHAL. I wlNiI. ~I;I/'II;!lud. MY PQr\hm at
I~ l~ ""fl~ ., ,~t. ,~t~t, I w4R\ ,~ f.'lry. th. rlQnt tp
--- _M__m~;;::'"f~Chial"''''f ....,. f.. f"'Hft jI..;,nh,:!"it.,vlfi.;'"-.
11\/1 I';'" lil>t I
1()6
-_.--...~--..--'-
I participate ln Any Argument on the la.ue.
3
TilE CIIAIRMANI All right, Coun.el. Thank you.
3 tt that'. the CAle, then we'll -- unle.. th.re'. Any
4 rebuttal te.tlmony at thi. polnt --
5
HR. PlaTLtNEI Hr. Dennl. came up on. morning
6 to our home, lIke, at 4110 or DIOO. I don't know if he'.
7 Qoln9 to teltify Qr confirm what hi tound or whatever.
I How long aqo WAl that, .he w.ek. AlJO, Penn i.? lie wu
. th.re with my wlfe. And he had .ound meter. .nd the
10 work..
11
HR. PENNISI If YOU'd like, I can conflrm that
l
13 1 heard the lame nol.e. that were heard by the re.ldentl,
lJ the intermittent 011nQln9 noli... I don't rlme.bar the
14 .pecific data that We w.re there, but It wa. D ..m. in the
11 aornln9 that tho truckl wore entarlnq the property. And
'6 wa did ho.r. And loan lupport thl .viaenc. that they
11 hay. pre.anted.
11
It
20
THE CHAIRMAHI Thank you, Hr. Oennil.
No rebuttal te.tlmony?
HR. WIINOAftTINI I'd ju.t like to ..ke . v.ry
21 bri.' 01011n9 ArlJument.
u
THE CIIAlIUlANI At tht. point U that'. the
3) Q,,_, we'll clo.e tho rocord and .Ik Counlel 1t they'd
24 Ilk_ to ..ke ,ny .fque.nl,
w
n
(Wh.reuPQn, Hr. Weinq.rten ate.rea clOli~
_ ""~~,~,,,,,,:~.,,",,.~_~,._i_*,,.,,~,'i"""<"':_'''''_:''"'~'-_..,.~",.:,.,.",c"""""""":..~.~._-,.~..~_.."""",.,,,,,:.,,,,",,,,.,,,~,.~,,,,,"'~'''''':'--''''-'P''-~--''''''''''l''''''';'''''-~'''':'r'''~~~'''=
.. Centul ...nflllylv"nlA <;Ollf\ "apurt {n/J """H'"
Ill/) ~!\'.16'11
"
1
a
:1
4
II
6
7
I
I
10
11
12
1:1
14
111
11
1'7
11
l'
20
a1
U
;U
a4
"" U
......."..-."'-.--..-<!.-
__JllL_u
remark. on behalf at thl AppellAnt.)
(Whereupon, Hr. Horqenthal ottered 01011ng
remarkl on behalt of the Re.pondentl.)
(Whereupon, Hr. Oennll oftered oloeing remarkl
on behalf of the porough.)
(Whereupon, the hearing WAI oonoluded at
9111 p.lIIo)
Cen\ul ji,,,-i\."Vlv;Ml.- (\;ilirt""p(i'rt (Iui 'l!J'rvro;l~~~-
PPl J'\I"W'l1
4
IS
6
1
8
9
10
11
13
i 13
14
15
16
17
11
l'
:10
at
n
n
:14
~ U
___c_-_____,______.!.()II
1 1 hereby certlfy thAt the proceedinq. and
a evidence are contained tully and acourately In the note~
3 taken by me on the withln prooeedinql, and that thi. copy
i. a correct transoript of thG lame.
./"
centu
+_----,"',...<k.- _""'_...-----"'. =_....~__._'N.'...'._'
'Gnn.y \ VA" .COY,-,,' .-.,i" nu.Hlf.fyl~.'.--'
('IP) UlhWn
'. \...'I~.Ik""'~'"
.
1""'\
Donald J. NIchttf M"Y Martin
030 W.lt LlMhtt IV", eeo Wut LouthII' Strut
Gone Ivan, MIchItI Blumtnthal
801 W.ltl.outhll' Itr"' 078 W.1t LouthII' hut
Dorothy IVItlI Jtll'llt MIDII'
801 WItt l.outhII' IV", 010 W.1t Louthtr Strut
!ll,phtn ,t AYbV Mar~tt O'Harl
1!'.o(1 W.., LlMhtt Ilr"' 128 .It LouthII' Strut
Harvey D\lnkftbtfger Mr'. lM Boy"
..... 703 Will LouV'lIt .r", 111 W.1t LouthII' hut
John W. DlItllnt ~:rr' LouthII' Itrut
644 W,lt Lo\Atltt IV'"
J,lV'I Bitln Mn Booth
644 Wttl LwNr Itr", ., W'" LouthII' Iv",
.10M L vttr loll M. CowIf'
1~4 WHt ~ ..,... 7. WBt LouthII' Itrtlt
Nl\I'IC'f L~
n4 W.t' UIWltt .....
.
~
... ..