HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-00200
.
-!
rJ
b
0.
~
J
8
'1
~'%..'VB**
c";j~~
T~:I
~ <~~I
, .1f
-" :":'~r,;;~_
':
,~
t '_"
Uominkk Pere!.
1'lalnllll'
IN TIll! COIlRT OF COMMON l'UIM ()II
('UMIIIlRI.^Nl> COlJNTV,I'I!NNSVLV ^NI^
\"
William SlIwllc:kJ, W.R.
SllI/lillc:k1 COllllnKllon COnlpllll)'
IU1l1 Kerry Shenk
l>cfonda/ll'
v. NO, 95.200
Clwle. C. 1.0010 and SO"" Inc,
Addl'll>Clbndant
v.
Iknchmark 1I0mot.lnc.
Addl" Uefendanl
CIVil. AC'nON.LAW
WUWl
---.
,
AND NOW, I~ _ day of _____, 1998. upon coMldmtlon of I"
fOlfllolnll Pellllon 10 I:nfol'(e SetllenwnllUld 1110 ^tIlIwer themo:
IT IS /IHRlmV ORU/!IUll> ANI> f)I(CRHlm Ihllt
(I) this ICtIIf/lmm be rnmrt<<J rwwana 10 Uw Imt\I oflbe Settlemmt ~ and Otneral
R,Ie..;
(2) IMt Uw ....fordanI. aIlllllddhlonallkfelldant. forward tho ~llernmC amount prevloual)'
lIVTc:ed uron. sno _h filr II 1111.1 IieIl!cmr:nI of $)000 111 dralt. made oul 10 "Shawn A. l101Jll1h.
b,qun, ^\IftII for l)(lmlttkk l'rrllllUld IhIIllhM /\Ind. .hall be drpo.lted Into lho ,ac,ow ,"aunt
ofShlwn A.lkllNlh until r",,","~ by 11lIrnJnkk l'tret;
(J) that tullll(IfllLl)"'1Oo (I(l.\% or $1000 fllr ShMwn A. IkwII'1h.llllllulrv.1hIII1 be dodlll:lrd
fr(lm 1110 Kllkmenl fUnd. fhrwlldnllb, IIeflll,lt 11110 lito rKf(IW lCl:(Junt ilf ShlIwn A. DoIA11h.
biqulr..
(4) I"" 1l1lptkl/l ~(,)It.of$200 fIIy.blll'o Mo'lllll A MorJll11htl1 ho dodlll:lod INm I'"
wulrnwnllUnd. furwardod ((If dfpo.llllllo tho 'KI'lIW *"oUlll urShlwn A. Ikl1.lllth.l1llqlllrt
(5) thill L1p1O ~ fJw lllItl~ II.n.1t.lI* ~AW WIl bo IlWhd "'111:4. d~lnucd.
I/ld ~.
flV nm COlJR'f:
Dominick I'e/'(/.
1'lalnlif1'
IN Tim COURT OF COMMON 1'l.IlAS OF
ClJMlIIlRI.ANI> COUNTY. I'I\NNSYL VANIA
v.
William SIIII!If1c:Id. W.lt
SIIII!IIM:1d CUllJlrucllon CUIl1JWl)'
and Kerry Shenk
1>C~ndanl'
v. NO. 9'.200
Char Ie, C. IAlOIOIIld 80111I, Inc.
Addt'II)e~ndant
v.
Iwnchnlllfk lIome.. Inc.
Addt'll>cf.mdllll
CIVIL At."TION.I.A W
I. AdmIttod,
2. AdmItted.
3, Admllted.
<t, AdmlIIcd. It)' WI)' of I\Irther 1II1IWW, .ut. \Wl1Cd dcmnI wu authorized by lhe Plalntllr.
Ill)' dlent. prior to tho Ma)' 13. 11197 Ietttt,
S. Admlllod.
6. AdmItted.
7. Admlttod, It)' wa)' offtmh<< wwtr, tho 1'IaIntllflndlealN lhal he /'IQtIVfd tho n:1ouo
by fIlIllIlDf w~ htl)' hit ~ ofthll l<<mI uftlle IICItlfment to wWttlna wwuel
",rtonall)' In lev,ral ((\nvl!nlltkllll. II, rcrca10d hit K'<<ptanco of the lOuwment IIrma to Scutt
MUllan, I!fKjulre. hit rrk1r <<IWIIWIIIld aIIlIlo hit fltlher.
I. Admltltld, II)' WI)' oflllnt..., www. all'" 1IIlIJII11me, lho "lalnti/Tlndlclled that '-' had
It~,lv,,, lho I1Ieuo by 1IlIll~ fllJlWII It. lDf W\,uJd "Ium It tu WWtrlnt (UUNt!. WlIhout
'llp/lwtkm, w .. .. ... 00i iJuIW 110, 01 'U~ lIlythlnf 10 wW'"'" (011I*1 otlwr IbM
Wll;'ondillolMd '"~. ur tht Ifmw or tlw rt_1Ild tJw bJtIf)' IbeRiA.
9. AJm.lt1td.
I (l AdmlItcd,
II. Admltttd
WHEREFORE, the Scukrncnl A~rccrnenl and Gcneral RelealiC should be enforced on lhc
lerms dellCrlbcd In Ihel'elhkllllo Enforce Sclllemcnl:
I. '!'halall eh:tb 1II1l1uld be deflosit~'Illn the CIICIOW accounl of ShPwn A. U01AJ1b. Hsqulre.
2, Thai all ch:tkt &IVluld he nwe oulln It.: 1\IlI111: of "Shawn A. lIo1AJ1b. Hlljulre, AIlCl1t for
Oomlnk:k Perez",
3, That a contlnllCllllltoffiCY'S fC\ of 33% be awarded 10 Shawn A. Uorarth or $1000,
purauant 10 Ihc fee all,eement he ...wllCII from Morlllll and Morllan when he ...wned
handlllllJ ofthe cue and toll' of $200, payable 10 Morllan and Morllan.
RI!Sltl!CTfULt Y SUDMI111m,
6G. C{ ~
Shawn A. 001Al1h Eaqulrc
Altonwy AI Law
\20 South Slroct
IltrrIabul'a. PA 17\ 0 I
117-232-4227
~
DOMINICK PEREZ,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT or COMMON P~E^S OF
CUMBERl.AND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
WILLIAM BTANSFIELD, W.R.
STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and KERRY SHENK,
Defondants
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
t
I
I
t
t
NO. 95-0200 CIVIL TERM
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
CHARLES C. LOOSE AND BON,
INC. ,
Additional Defendant
v.
BENCHMARK HOMES, INC.,
Additional Defendant
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 71 J day of June, 1998, upon consideration of
Plaintiff's Petition To Enforce Settlement, and following a
conference in which plaintiff'. coun..l did not partiCipate, Edward
L. Bchorpp, Esq., participated on behalf of Detendants William
stansfield and W.R. Stansfield Construction Company, John M.
popilock, I.q.. participated on behalf of Detendant Kerry Shenk,
Deborah M.a. Doyle, It.q., participated on behalf of Additional
r>llfendant Chuha C. LOOIIII and !lon., Inc., and Thom"s a. Collins,
EDq., partlclpllted on behalf af Mdit1an.d Defendant Benchmark
110m.., Inc., 1l 18 OR()IUUCD and OIRKCTED u folloWS'
(1) That lh1l ult hm.1l1 tlu ."forced purDulnl to the terms of
the Ittached !:eU lOlllelll A(Jree/l~lil IInd OeOlltlll Rul4lulI,'
(2) Thllt the O.fendonts and Ad\hU(lnal1>.f.nd"nu rorward th.
Illllt ll1ll19nt 1I1l>Qunt I'r~vh)\,l(lly ;aynH.lt upon, '750.00 ud\ ror . total
~&tll.~.nt of '..000.00 In dr.f'_ m4de Oyl to u~hllwn A. Ua.arth,
Esquire, Agent for Dominick Parez and that these funds shall bo
deposited into the escrow account of Shawn A. bozarth, Esquire,
until requested by Dominick Perezl
(3) That an attorney's fee of 33\ or $1,000.00 for Shawn A.
l3ozarth, Esquire, shall be deducted from thlt settlement funds
forwarded tor deposit into the escrow account of Shawn A. aOl!:arth,
Esquirel
(4) That litigation costs of $200.00 payable to MorQan &
MorQan shall be deducted from the settlement funds forwarded for
dopo.it into the escrow account of shawn A. l3ozarth, Esquirel
(5) That upon forwarding the settlement fundlll, this case
shall be marked settled, discontinued, and ended.
BY THE COURT,
Shawn A. notarth, IllIq.
120 South Street
Harrisburg, fA 17101
Attorney tor Plaintiff
Edward L. 6chorpP, ~llIq.
127 West High street
Carlisle, VA 17013
Attorney tor Oersnctant.
William atsn.field and
W.R. Stansfield Con.truotion Company
John H, Poptlock, E.q.
]O~ North rront Street
Harr1sburq, 'A 17101
At lorney (0/; Pe(ond4n.t.
f.eny Shenk
"
,
,
~VJtr){
SETTLE~1-!aREEHENT AND aENER~L RELEAQP
KNOW ALL PERSONS IlY THESE ('RESENTS I that Dominick Perez,
individually and throu\lh his attorney, Shawn A. bozarth, Esquire, tor
and in consideration of the sum of Three Thousand Dollara ($3,000), in
hand paid and tor other \load and valuable consideration, the receipt
of whiCh is heroby acknowledged, and intendinq to be legally bound
hereby, do hereby remise, relaase and forever disoharge William
StAnsUeld, W.R. Stansfield Construction Company, Kerry Shenk,
Charl.s C. Laos. and Son and Benchmark I{omas, Inc. and thoir
respective insurer8, alligno, IUccellor., hlirl, SUbsidiaries,
divisionl, operations, predecessurs in intlrelt, oxecutor. and
administrators, of and tram any and all mann.r of liability, actions,
causes ot actions, suits, debtl, dues, accounts, bonds, covenant.,
contract., agr.ements, judgments, 01a1ms and demands whatsoaver in law
or equ1ty, includinq any olaim tor contribution or indemnification
arising out ot an incident which occurred on or about August 17, 1993,
and, eopeoia1ly with respect to events II described in the pendinq
oivil action complaint captioned aSI Qominick Perez V. WilllQm
titansHeld. W.R. lItlln'U.Jd consttuct!on ~ompf1nv lInd Kerry lIlt.nk v...,
Cha!:'l.. c. Loo~. and IIQn. Ipe. y~ _.n(:hml\rk UPlllllSl 1/10., pendinq in
tho Cumborl.nd county, court at common rle.. civil Aotion No. 95.~OO,
and any and all 01aim8 made thorouna.r (inQluain~ Any alaiml tor 10..
at oonsortlum to tho extent any suoh olal.s ..y havo loqolly exi.ted),
wheth.r now ln eld.tonce or whloh ..y horeaCtor arl.., whloh a\JAimlt
tho .oid d.tend.nte and ...l....d puties ond thoir aulqnll,
auceonon, lloin, O.lC4Jcuton ud odllllni.tl'Atou they OVfr had, no...
hive, or vhtoh thotr hot,., OXfoUtor', laatnt_troto'., .uoo...or. Q(
(COlPV.
l'Iuniljllp ot" Ilny of them, hereaftor call, phaU or mny hava, for, or by
rORaon of any caUDo, mattor or thing whntaoovor, from the boqlnnlng of
tlmo to tho date of theso prosentsl
AND FURTHER, that plalntltf, Dominick Peru, by and though his
attorney Shawn A. Bourth/ Esquire h.reby contlrm. and ....rt. that
any and all lien. Inoludln9 mOdlcal, workers compen.atlon/ attorneys
feoa or other oxpon.o. ot any naturo what.oevor will be dlachar90d by
virtu. at thl. settlement. plalnt1rt and hls coun.el .peciflcally
warrant and repre.ent that tho workers/ compen..tlon carrior hOlding a
lien aqain.t any recovery by plaintiff tram thl' aotlon/ p.nn National
Inauranc. Company (olalm no. 0240!l1l71/8W) / 11 aware at thl.
.0tUelllent/ h.. a9u.d to thh .ettl'lIl.nt ,nd h" Authorlud tho
aen.ral R.I.... at all ala 1m. by plalntltf. Pl.lntltt turthor
repre.ent. th.t wrlttln proof at the .ame will be mads available to
all partie. prior to th. .x_cutlon at thi. a.n.ral R.I.....
AND fURTHER/ in "onlid.ration ot tho ..ttlllll.nt proc..d. and
other valuable consideratIon, all parties h.r.to Ixpr...ly aqre. not
to dl.010.. any ot tho .p.altlcs p.rtalnlnq to thl. ..ttl.lIlont
Inoludlnq, but not llmlt.d tOt tho amount at the slttlem.nt or any It.
particular. to any memb.r, employ.., aqent or repre..ntatIV. at the
now. ..dla or any third party/ qroup or orq.nhation. It h aha
aqr..d by all part I.. thlt no mon.t.ry jUdq..nt In any ..aunt will be
.nt.red In any court ot record aqalnlt any party hereto, nor will tho
-2-
CCCOtf?>l(
Bettlement agreement nor Bny copy thereot be provided to anyone other
than to the signatory parties heroto, their respective inuurero,
Bnd/or their counsel of record, and/or thoSG entities havinq a direct
interost as partioD or principals in this claiml
AND .'URTIlER, in oondderation at the mutual covenantl contained
heroin and intendinq to be legally bound thereby, the partill agree as
tOlloWl1
1. The total And complete lum ot Thre. Thou.and Dollars
($3,000.00) Ihall be paid to DominiCk Peru And Shawn A. Bozarth,
esquire AI attorney tor, in tUll, rinal, and complete dilcharq. and
sottlement of any And All olaim. pre.ently exl.ting or which may, in
tho tuture, arha,
;" By \II.king an .qual pro-rat.d paYJlllnt ot the .ettlnllnt
amount, each ot the partie. hereto do.. RELEAaE and FOREVER DISCHARGE
any and all adlting or future olaim. and oroa.-olai..1 and their
respective .ublidiari.l, divilionl, operation., IUCClllor.,
pc.decallor., al.ionl, in.urer., otticlr., ag.nt. and emplOY.'. trom
any And all liabilitia. to any aotlon., contr.ct., aqrelment_,
controverll.., jUdqmlnt., d..aO.I, clalml, liabl1itiel and demand_ ot
any kind or nature wh.t.oev.r wh.ther known or unknown, or tor
reimburlem.nt at any te.., co.t., or other explnee. paid or incurred
by Any party in conn.otlon with tho oo~..noe.."t, proe.cution, d.ten..
..)-
(C <<J u~~ \If
or sottloment of this suit as above-captioned, whether now in
existence or which may heroafter arise.
J. It is understood that the partiel hereto have entored into
this settlement Agreement tor the purpose ot avoiding litigation based
upon disputed olaims And that neither the entering into at this
Bettloment agreomont nor Anything containod herein shall bo taken or
construed to be an admission on the part at Any parties or the
validity or said alaim.
4. Thi. settlement agr80ment shall benerit and be binding upon
each or the pArties hereto and their legal repreeentAtiv08, heiu,
predeoessors, e~ecutors, administrators, assigns and successora.
,. Thle settlement agreement contains the entire agreement
Amon9 the parties hereto Ilnd the terms or thls Agreement are
contrAotual .. oppo.ed to mere recitAl..
d. Th. plaintiff, Dominick rere., hereby AcknOWledges and
undluhnds.
(a.) that by .lgninq thh Agreement he 1. glvinq up All
olaims Against .Ach ot the nel.ased rArtils, pa.t, pre.ent And ruturo,
wheth.r known or unknown, .. ..t torth In thl. Aqr...lntl .nd
-4-
... ,
TIl!l(,\hy 1. Hark, \!:llfl.
t~11 ~~rth frunt ntr..I
114I1lt\1tHHQ, .." nIl0.1~H
n.t,liuh N.Ii. PQylt1, \CII1'
WI J,.1$l.)H, la,lkl(. NO/SI<OW I n I
lDlhMAN A DICI(J(", J,.J..P
ft.. CyrIl. C.nter
/.l\Hllt .10 kut
I hlt'r..rllh1Ilo(j l:!{IIHlr. W.,t
HI11AdlllJlh'., .." HII06
.
H{J
. , J .(.(U'
C~t~... ('Mot\......... A 1'.
,
,
,
.
feJMY 07 1998
..
..
.
i
"
Ii
[
.I~'OM, .~..., MO..OWI'I, IDILKlM I Dlo..a LL'
IV. Debor.h M.I. Doyl., I.quirt Attorn.y tor Add'l. o.t.
Identifio.tion No. 71a.o Ch.rl.. C. ~o.t .nd 80n
The curti. C.nt.r . auitt .30 I..t
Ind.p.nd.nce 'quart w..t
Phil.delphia, PA 1910.
IU!)) U'7.6900
I'
~
I;
i
Ii
Ii
I
~
,
I
!
J
i
~
i
j
! JTlI,
COURT or COMMON 'LIAI
cUM8kMtAND COUNTY
DOMINICK ptllll.
.
.
I
I
I
.
.
I
I
I
NO. ....aoo
Plaintiff I
Y.
W1LLIAM .TANarIlLO, W.R.
JTAN.rIILD CON'TRUCTION COMPANY
IInd ICJ:RRV IHINl<
pet.ndanu
v.
CHARLE' c. LOOII AND ION. INC.
Additlonal D.tend.nt
v.
PleNCllMAJUC HOMI', INC.
Addltional O.'end.nt
o.aqJIJI
AIID "OW, thie day or , 1"'. it 1.
b.f.by OItoIIllD an4 DCClno tb.tl (1) thi. ..ttl...nt b4l .ntorc~
p~r.u."t to the ter.. ot the ..ttl...ot A9r....nt and O.ner.l ..1....;
(Jl the d.r.~ntl 'nd .ddltlonal d,tend.ntl for~.rd the lattl..ant
\VIl '" ,.; It "1 I! \'" )\I( '\Vll/, f 1)11 MAN !I Ill< KII{ It f'
lHl;luwli"II,,,w. """.';'111',1. ",(.il't/;(>t'fiftO.,MiWi\r. ~I"I^{jh"t!lIl~"^lVl(l4
hil:,1.1 (j\i.d.,II.'I(1,i. tA.. (ll\;/~11 'LI.~.
, \
.
II
Amount prevloU.lV .qued upon, ,ao tach tor . total ..ttlemlnt or
$3,000, for d.po.lt lnto the ..orow .ccount of pl.lntiff'. ooun.el,
and (1) upon defendant. forwardin9 the .ettle.ent fund., thi. c..e
.hall be .arked .ettl.d, dl.continued and ended.
The followlnq attorney. are required to be notified pur.uant to
Rule 206-61
Oanlel K. D.ardorff, E.quir.
KARSTON, DEARDORr" WILLIAMS' OTTO
T.n laat lIiOh IItreet
Carll.le, fA 17011
TimothY I. Mark, I.quire
CALDWELL , KEARNS
1611 North ,ront str.et
t1arri.bur9, PA 17110-1D13
taward L. 'chorpp, I.quire
~NDI', D~CK , 'CHORPP
16 .outll ttanovn Street
Carli.l., 'A 17011
I
,
fr
11
"
I
~
~
I
IY TIll COURT.
11.
-J.
1
I
\VII "on" " R. ~h iq;('\Vll/lllf I MN~ H r'WKI R III'
h.ttVi(fl\O..il*. '""II.hO,,,',!. ."('>IrP,f,,,.(j \,(j,I^~lwH'. f""tAnllflllA,f'AItH14
"ri()~t (/t~,j t.l' ~.'ii~) . 'A~ {In) 1..11 IhA\
\
.
"
WILIOM, IL''', NO.lOWlt., .DILMAN I DIO.I. LL'
BYI Deborah M.I. Doyll, l.qu1rl AttornlY tor Addtl. o.t.
Id.nt1f1oation No. 71340 Charl'. C. LoOI. and Son
Th. curti. Centar . 8u1ta '30 laat
Ind'pend.no. .quar. W..t
Philadelphia, PA 19106
(at5) 637"6900
DOMINICK PEREZ.
COURT or COMMON PLEAI
CUMBkRLAND COUNTY
PlalntUt,
v,
WILLIAM STANSrIILD. N.R.
STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
and KERRY 8HINK
O.t.ndant.
NO, u..aoo
V. I
I
CHARLES C, 1A)()rJIl: ANO SON, rNC. I
I
Additional o.tendant I
I
V, I
I
IlEHCIlMARX HOMIlI. INC. I
I
Additional oet.ndant I
U R , .
AND NOW, thb
h.reby ORDIRID and DECRIED
day or , "", 1t 1,
th.t, (1) thi. ..ttl...nt b. entorc.d
purauant to the tar.. ot the .ettl..ant AQr....nt and Canaral R.l....1
Il) the detendanta and additiQna' detendant. tor~ard the ..ttl...nt
\\'11 "(!t J II \111. \1\'\1 ,'\\11/, II )11 I,IM.J 1\ 111r. i, I Kill'
WI Cultl,', (11.'11< . '...>1" "101.....1 . ".(,1 nM""I ( '_"\lAwl WI\! . rtlll AI>tl rtllA. M IVI(IA
,..11(i1.t (/".,/./II-,"/i.) . fA.: l"") "II 1M.!';
1
.
amount previau.ly aQr..d upon, $7!l0 each tor a total .ettllm.nt ot
$3,000, tor depolit into the e.orow aooount ot plaintitt'. ooun..l,
and (3) upon detendant. torwardin~ the .ettlement fundi, thi. c...
.hall be marked lettled, di.oontinuld and ended.
The tollowinQ attorneYI are required to be notitied purluant to
Rule :106-61
Daniel K. Deardortt, E.quirl
MARSTON, DEARDORFF, WILLIAMS' OTTO
Ten Ealt Hi9h Str.et
Carli.le, PA 17013
Timothy I. Mark, Eequir.
CALDWELL . KEARNS
3631 North Front streit
Harri.burQ, PA 17110-1533
Edward L. Sohorpp, E.quire
LANDIS, BLACK , SCtlORPP
36 South Ifanover street
Carli.le, PA 17013
IY T"8 COURTl
J.
..3.
\\Ill \(ill II \I R. M(1"i.;1 )\\'11111111 I.I:\N II 1)Ii KI RIll'
lHIC\/~II\CtN"Ii, \U1l1p"OIA\I, IM>/f'IM>tMI ~OiJ^,'IWI\" MIllAOilt'IIIA,f'A1910l>
""10~ff cilt~}I.I! ,~!t(X)' 'A( (/'-")1./1 if..~,\
.
WILION, ILIll, NOIKOWITI, IDILNAH .
BY' O.borah H.S. Ooyl.. I.quire
Identification No. 71240
The Curti. Cent.r . Suite 830 gait
Indep.nd.no. Square w..t
Philad.1phia, FA 19106
(21!l) 627-6900
DIona LLP
Attorney tor Add'l. Oet.
Charl.. C, LoOI. and Son
DOMINICI< PEItEZ,
Plaintttt ,
COURT OF COMMON PLIAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
v.
WILLIAM STANSFIELD, W.R.
STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION COHPANY
and KERRY SHENK
NO, n-aoo
D'f.ndant.
v.
CIIAltLE8 C. LOOSE AND SON, INC.
Additional D.t.ndant
v.
BENCHMARK HOHE8, INC.
Additional D.f.ndant
aaD..
AND HOW, thh day of , 19", it i.
h.r.by ORDERED and DECRIED that, (1) thi, ..ttl...nt be .ntoro.d
purlu,nt to the t.r.. ot the 8.tt1...nt A9r....nt and o.n.ral Re1....,
(2) the d.f.nd,nt. .nd .ddition.l d.r.ndant' forvard the ..ttl...nt
WII "l1tJ. /I "lit ~h\"., \ i\\'II/. I /)11 "IAN ~I DK t;IR I trl
IHt (lJfI'l~ (lNUIl . \\}I\, ',10 IA~' . 11,('1 I'tM>II,(, \(ilJANt WI~' . /'UIIAPH"",^, M '.'06
'UOllt (1\',) 1.11 1.9(X) . lAX (11\) ~1I1MS
,
..
amount previously aqreed upon, $750 each for a total settlement of
$3,000, tor deposit into the escrow account of plaintiff'S counsel;
and (3) upon defendants forwardinq the settlement runds, this caae
ahall be marked Bettled, discontinued and ended,
The following attorneYB are required to be notified pursuant to
Rule 206-61
Daniel K. Deardorff, Esquire
MARSTON, DEARDORFF, WILLIAMS' OTTO
Ten Eaat High street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Timothy I. Hark, Esquire
CALDWELL , KEARNS
3631 North Front Street
lIarrhburg, PA 17110-1!l33
EdWard L. Schorpp, Esquire
LANDIS, aLACK , SCIlORPP
36 south Hanover Str.et
Carlisle, PA 17013
BY Till COURT,
.:s.
"3-
W1l5('lN.1I.5IR. MO'~;O\V1I1, fl)f1 MAN ~\ mn:fR til'
II.. (\)1111\(1...11. . ~(Jllt tlOfMf . INPI"IM>fNCI ~jl!A.1 WliI . MlltAOhJ'tIl....'A ",o.
f'HOM (In)'~'''l(XI' tAX t1HiUn..,
~
WILION, IL..I, "O'.OWI", BOlLMAN .
BY. D.borah M.I. Doyl., I.quir.
Id.ntitioation No. 71240
Th. curti. c.nt.r . luit. 830 Ea.t
Ind.pend.nc. Square WI.t
Philad.lphia, PA 19106
(215) 627-6900
Dlcn. LLJ
Attorney tor Add'l. Det.
Charl.e c. Loo.. and Son
DOMINICK PE~EZ,
COU~T OF COMMON PLEAI
CUKPt~LAND COUNTY
plaintiff ,
v.
WILLIAM STANSFIELD, W.R.
STANSFIELD CON8T~UCTION COMPANY
and KER~Y SHENK
NO. 91)-'100
Det.ndant.
I
V. 1
.
CIIA~LES C. LOO8I AND SON, tHC. I
I
Additional O.t.ndant I
I
v. I
I
otNCIlHARJ< HOM!I, tNC. I
1
Additional D.t.ndant I
DaD'.
AND HOW, tni. day of , 1991, it i.
hor.by ORDERID and DEC~IED thatl (1) tni. ..ttl...nt b. .nrorcad
pur.uant to the tar.. of the ..ttl...nt Aqr....nt and a.nlral P41....:
(~) tn. d.f.ndant. and additional d.f.ndant. tor~'rd tn. ..ttl...nt
WII \(>~J. 11 \1 f(, /,\1",.:\;\\,11/ 11>11 MMJ II lill t:I R II II
fI'Hvllll~CHjll" . I.I,II!t .lO'A;1 . ,MMH,I)IM I \(jllA~1 W1\f . rtlllA('fL"IM fA "If)/.
,."OM (/\\)/./11.'/(>) . IAl( rll'"MI11.~'.
.
amount prlviou.ly aqreld upon, t750 eaoh tor a total .ettlement ot
t3,000, tor d.po.lt into the e.crow aooount ot plaintitt'. ooun.el/
and (3) upon detendant. torwardlnq the ..ttlement rund., thla ca..
ahall be marked .ettled' dlaoontlnued and ended.
The tOllowlnq attornlY. are requlred to be notitied pur.uant to
Rule :106-61
Danlel K. Deardortt, I.qulre
HARSTON, DEARDORFF, WILLIAMS' OTTO
Ten la.t Hlqh Str..t
carll.le, PA 17013
TimothY I. Hark. E.quir.
CALDWELL , KEARNS
3631 North Front str..t
Harrl.burq, fA 17110-1533
Edward L. Sohorpp. I.qulre
LANDIS, BLACK , SCIIORPP
36 South Hanover str..t
carll.le, fA 17013
IY 'l'H1 CO\lRTI
5.L
w'.
\VII 'Oil II ',I f.l, 'I\P;~, "';\JlI I III t \lMI tl !\IC;.;r RIll'
h.t(",Jrfl\(lNI"'. '!.,,,,, II lill 10,' . ",h,r,/ffifMI'.q"Io.IWHI' r'tliAi>httllA,,.AI.,o.
""0',1 ii\~, ~il ~ti10 . IA~ 1/1\) &/'14\
WIL.OM, IL''', HOI.OIIT., IDILMAN , DICIIR LL'
BYI D.borah H.S. Doyl., I.quir. Attorn.y tor Add'l. D'f.
Idlntifioation No. 71240 Chari.. C. Loo.e and Son
The curti. Clnt.r I suit. 830 I..t
Ind.p.nd.no. square W..t
~hl1ad.1phia, ~A 19106
(n~) 62'1-6900
DOMINICI< PEREZ,
COURT or COMMON PLEAB
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
plaintiff,
v.
WILLIAM STAN.FIELD, W.R.
STANSFIILD CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
and 1<IRRY .HINI<
NO. 90-200
I
Defendant.
v.
CHARLIS C. LOOn AND ION, INC.
Additional Def.ndant
v.
PENCIlMAIUC HOHII, INC.
Additional D.f.ndant
O.D..
AND NOW, thla day of I 1"1, 1t 1.
h.r.by OaDlllD and DICRIIO thatl (I) thl. ..ttl...nt be .nforc.d
purluant to the tar.. ot the ..ttl...nt A9r....nt and O.n.rel R.l....1
(~) the a.tendanta and add1t10nal def.nd.nt. tor~.rd tha ..ttl...nt
\\,ilJ '\)~J II \II~, \\I)q,)\\111 11>1 P,1\~J illW U f{ 1111
'Ht("."\UP4ltll. \,111 hol"..I. ,',I>lft',Plr,'1 ''<i''^kl wl\I . rllil"('llh~".,,^I"06
"'''''.1 Ill',) 1./1 I,'/'~) . ,.... (/1'.) blllU',
.
WILSON, BLSIR, MOSKOWITZ, IDILMAN . DICXBR LLP
BY' Deborah M.S. Doyle, Esquire Attorney tor Add'l. Def.
Identification No. 71240 Charl.. C. Looee and Sons
The Curti. Center . Suite 830 Ealt
Independence Square West
Philadelphia, PA 19106
(215) 627.6900
DOMINICK PEREZ,
Pla1ntitf ,
v.
WILLIAM STANSPIBLD, W.R.
STANSPIELD CONSTRUCTION COMPANY
and KBRRY SHENK
Detendante
v.
CHARLBS C. LOOSB AND SONS, INC.
Additional Derendant
v.
BBNCHMARK HOMBS, INC..
Additional Detendant
,
,
I
I
I
I
,
I
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
COURT 01" COMMON PLIAS
CUMBRRLAND COUNTY
NO. 95.200
'aTl1~QN TO IH~OIC. I.TTL~
Additional deCendant Charlll C. Loole and 80nl, Inc., by and
through ite coun.el, Wil.on, 11..r, Mo.kovitz, Idel~n , Dicker LLP,
h.reby tile. ite 'etition to InCoree Settlement and aver. a. tOllow.,
WlI \{)N, II \1 R, Ml1"t;c)\VIl/, fI)11 MAN fi Dl< KI Rill'
lI.tCllwltHtllfllit '\.u,"_").A',!, .M)f/"iM>tM,I\.<WAtilIWHt, MhIAllh/"M,/'A19l(16
hiOM (/ gild) I."!)i.) . f A~ iI \ 1.1 loll 1/.4'
,
,
1. On January 13, 1995, plaintiff filed a complaint againBt
defendants alleging peraonal injury from a construction accident which
occurred on or about AUgUBt 17, 1993. aAA a copy of plaintiff's
complaint attached hereto aa Exhibit "A."
2. On April 5, 1995, defendantB joined Charlea C. LOOBe and
SonB, Inc. aa an additional defendant. a.a a copy of said joinder
complaint attach.d hereto aa Exhibit "B."
3. On or about May 24, 1996, additional defendant Charle. C.
Loo.e and Sona, Inc. tiled a joinder complaint again.t additional
defendant Benchmark Home., Inc. &II a copy of aaid joinder complaint
attached hereto aa Exhibit "C."
4. On or about May 13, 1997, plaintiff made a written demand of
$3,000 for full and compl.te aettl.ment or thia action. ill
corre.pondence from plaintiff'. coun.el of May 13, 19~7 attached
hereto aa Exhibit 'D.'
5. Shortly ther..fter, all tour def.ndant. agr.ed to equally
contribute '750 toward. .Ittlement of thi. matter and communicated
this .ettl.ment to plaintift', coun..l
6. On Or about July 22, 1997, a Settlement Agreement and
GOller.l ..1.... on behalf ot aU d.hnd.nt. .nd additional defendant'
..al>
\Vll~(JN. 11'Illt Ml \"~l '\VII/. , !lIt ~'AN 1\ IW Kl R I J I'
lilt l\JIlI'\CtNllil , \\J1Il*iOtA\I , lNOHIM>lM I \()\)"~I Wl\I . "lIiIAl>hhlll\, "" ''''(\6
,.,'0'" m \) 4)1 ..V(~) . ,,,~ "'\) bll 'M.~
was forwarded to plaintiff's counsel. ~ a copy of the
correspondence and Bettlement Agreement and General Release attached
hereto as Bxhibit "B."
7. In September, 1997, plaintiff'S counsel communicated to
various defense counsel in varioue telephone conversations that
plaintiff had just moved and had not yet signed the release although
he would be signing and forwarding same to counsel soon.
8. In December, 1997, plaintiff's counsel advised counsel for
additional defendant, Charles C. Loose and Sons in a telephone
conversation again that he expected to receive the signed release
shortly and would forward a copy Of ,ame as soon .s received from his
client.
9. Foll.owing additional telephone calls, counsel for additional
defendant, Charles C. Loose and Bans, wrote to plaintiff's counsel on
March 13, 1998, again requesting thu signed release be forwarded to
defense counsel. ill a copy of said correspondence attached hereto as
Exhibit "P."
10. To date, no signed relea.. has been received by plaintiff or
hie attorney 1n this matter.
.3.
\VIl50~J. WH It M~)~KI)WJll. m[l MAN (1 nlCKIR II II
h.HuIUlH;&NTIIt . ~l)1IU)(H"'$T . IM>f.'tMlINCBO\)Mlt waST . ,.H~t"Il1A,"'" '.'()6
"1l0Na (~IM 617 .tOO . 'AX (11\) '212"~
.
11. To date, .cmo nine month' fallowing eettlement Of thie
mAttor, neithtr pl.intiff nor hi. coun..l have voiced an objection to
the ..ttlement.
I
f
I
i
I(
WllliUtIVOJII, in the inur8lt. Of judloial efUdeno)', the
AltrtHional dehn4ant CMrl.. C, Loa.. and .on., r.qu..t the following.
(1) that thi. .tttltment be enforced pur.uant to th. t.rm. ot the
s.ttlement Agr....nt and aeneral R.1...., (3) that the d.f.ndant. and
lidiHt!Ollal d.f.OO.nt. rorward the ..ttl..".nt amount prevlou.ly I\lr,,,t
UpOIl for depo.i\: into the ..crow Iccount of pldntUt'. ooun..l tor
plAintiff', coun"l to dl.bur.. to hi. oll,ntl '00 11) that upon the
d.fendant. forwarding ..1d ..ttl.mtnt tund. that thi. ~tter be marked
,.ttlod, di.continued ao4 .nd.d,
,
,
i
I
I
...p.otfully .ubmltttd,
WILlON, ILlI., HOlXOWlT" .DltMAN . DICK'. LLP
'1'1 ~orlh M.., ~r~l . J:r,. ..A ."-
Attorn.v tor Addit onal Def.ndant
Charl.. C, Loa.. and .on
'..
wn...l~4.'I~'ff M,y,.l'\\lll ;Nl\!\'. 1\ f)l' "fR II"
t..., {t~.;i\H"f*. . "Mil it", .""t . 'MMIM.H" I '''~'''.' v.'~~ . I'>NAj>1!ti';..... M Itl,,,,
.....:~.,. lIt\'il.j1 '.,fli} . U~J/ !.,!\''n411 !f,.~1
"IL'OM, 11..1., MOUOWITl, IJ)ILIWf . Dlel'. LL'
UYI PeborAh H.', Doyl., I.quir. Attorn.y for Ad4'1. D,t.
Identification No. 71:140 Charl.. C. Loo.. and 'on.
The Curtis C.nter . '\.Iit. no .Alt
Independence .quar. W'lt
~hl1.delphl., fA 19101
(:115) 6::17.6100
DOMINICK PIUtll,
"aindre ,
COUIT or COItION .loW
CUMI..LAHD COUNTY
v,
I
.
I
I
.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
.
I
.
I
I
I
I
.
I
I
I
NO, 11.300
!
i
WILLIAM .TAN'rlILO, W,I.
aTAlftl'IILD COH.nUCTION COMPANY
and nllY .MINK
D.ftn4anu
y,
CllMLII C. I.QOI. AMI) ION', INC.
Ad41Uonal o.r.ndanl
y.
bJNCHHAlK KOMI', INC.'
Ad41U(mal PthndAnl
MIW.'~~~J~r~'Nl"J'.artOII,jJ~~' ra17tOlt-m ~.1It'f
On Of' ai:H.;l.lt MAy H, \n7, pl.tDUU'f qWM.' COl.'rt.p0M44 wHtJ
.11 4.r.u.f ~ounM.l . wrlt"n ..ttl~nt ~n4 QI '),000. ...
~4hl~1~ 'Q,' ~ 'Wijf 44f.~n'. ~f'~ tg \~,. .'tll~nt .n4 .~f.~
t;. .. J'f(l flit. IA". ~~ """ (If U-.. fQi,ff 4tlf,r>4iiil. @f f1tl>, Thh
\"'1I',,\'~ !I\lft \"".' ill l!.f1'!\', h r Ui<' fI!'
(n" (t!.';'\{'hHti. \'tA.j 14llt''''tl . ,~i,r.yp:..;"ty Ii '-~~~"Ait-t', wt:'U . th\tA(41."~HA r" ,,'04
nM='~ [J";;;..j#.i! !..~~; " ~h( ;jt'L 4/' ,d.4';
Mottl.ment .gr..ment w.. communicat.d to pl.intiff'. coun"l .nd .
Uettl.m.nt Agr.ement and a.ner.l R.I.... wle prep.r.d .nd torward.d to
pl.intiff'. counl.l on or .bout July 33, 19". ... Kxhibit "',"
^pproxim4t.lV nin. month. hAt pa...d .inc. the ..ttlement Agr..m.nt
A'm a.n.r.l R.l.a.. wa. forw.rded to plaintiff'l coun..l .nd no .iUned
r.l.... hAI Vlt been r.c.ivld, Hwmtrou. t.l.phone 0111. have b..n
mad. to plalntlff'. caun.el .. w.ll .. corr'.pond.ne. inquiring into
the wh.r..boute of the .ivnea r.l..... Coun..l for additional
d,tendant Chari., C. Loo.e .nd 'on. hI' con.i.tentlv b..n inform.d by
pl.intiff'. aaun.tl that the r.l.al. va. forw.rd.d to ht. cli.nt amt
(,I.intift .dvil.d h. would b. r.turning it to hi. attorn.y'. Offic.
e(lon. How.v.r, no .ivn.d r.l..'. ha. b..n r.ceiv.d.
p.on,vlvania c..e law 1. oltlr that Where , .'ttl...nt hat b.en
fl.chld ~ng th, part i.. and on. p.rty f.il. to fallow throuvh, that
the court ~y .nfore. thi. .'ttl...nt upon p.titlon, ~t1da~
Ulll, Jtt ". t', " A.3d 201 11"01. Th. court. have (urthlr h.ld
th.t .n or.l ..ttl..-nt .'r....nt i. 'nfore..bl. .nd l...lly bindi",.
j~.IJ.I.LCQllWU1&H'&4Qr'_v'.,>Minfll, ..1 ..za un 11'.. lupu. UUI,
lU4oj1l.l;b'l."lflwr;lWl'WS,'.Ugl'\ilc~lnll+. ..0 A.~d UU, UI1 U'.,.
py!~r. 1,.tl. In th. 111,tAne '.", not 0ftly W.' cher..n or'l
._ttl.~nc &fl....nc, DYe lh. ',r.~nc WI' r.duct4 CO vri'in, in ct~
t~!H'" f;l' th, ..Ul..."" Atn~~II' 1M 0.041.1 ..lM". TM. wriHrvl
f,'[<,'lulo, lM Uru "f'~ CQ by .U ,..ni... ..... Uo A,i4 A' UU.
'i..~U'J"PlIQr., eM MIOIiA&: or 1M "Ul"",ot v... Unt (If,J,LJ.IJ,l4'.CM lQ
i
WI! \( i'J n \t l'I \, 'i\h \\VH I Hln MM~ 1\ Nt U ft II f'
lh~{l-'"_"'}~{J'f!'. ':~\A~I.;W)'J\';J;f . -i-~~,.,.tM>l~-J ':;ot'fj-"'~:*fWJ,f, "h'1At.~tti4A r'- u.\(~
,.rlIi'~~ j,n'i:.4/' 4'A.~ . 'A.- ~!~"'1"1114J.~
Y__LI,J I_I eA..'l_J g .1
a.borlh N.'. Doyl., I.qulrl. Itlt.. thAt ,h, i. the Ittorn.y tor
o.r,naant Charl.. C. Loo.. and .on./ thAt .h. hi' the Authority to
mAk. thl. v.rificatlon on It. b1half, that .he 1. Acquaint.d wlth the
tact. let torth in the tor,voln, MtMorlndWR ot Law in lupport Ot The
Petition To Intorce ,.eel.-.ne/ that th. 'I~ Ir. tru. .nd corr.ct to
th. b..t ot h.r knowl.d9', lntor..tion And Deli'f/ .nd that thie
.tlcement i. .ad. .ubJ.cc to th. p.nalti.. of 11 r..C.I,A. '.'04
r.lati", CO untWOrn tal.lti'ltion to aUthoficl...
I
)0
l"l<"-'.~' k.. ...;.... I ,,1.~ -I ""I Itl' ,.,..
'"'' .' '~I!'. ,/ '"" '011"'" \ I", \ -"," """. ,~~-r--4,
, " 't " ' " ',. .f'I' > j " I !
-t,i'\, \,11 _,f .',' '.t' ;~ '" "\ ,,( 'j " 'I .P', _, . ,', I ;_' ,., to I"." '
. ...... . '''',. ,.;.iJ"',~ I ""~, f,' '"." .l'''\~ u" '" t, '/''', ,..t..... t'l. .,.....1 'ILl. Ill\: 1..'1.1., ,4, l; .,0",.\,_.,
1 I ,;. I' .":. ;, ;, '1'1 - ""j' ,., I. \"', .'" f,'. '" 'J"';~II" . III I'" tl'
· .,., I . """ " I , l' . I, t' 1".... I' ".", ,"
' '.' I " . ' , , ,I' '" . I I ' . '. ( .
MOROAN. loCOlOAN, ',e,
IY, ICOM' W, WOIOAN, UQUIU
l1)lSN1'I.P1CA110N NO, ,.121
lac IOUTK ITUIT
&"'-'-'UIO, '" 17101.1210
('717) Ju-m,
DOMOOac PDI%
30 1 MuJbIrry Drtvt
1l&rrlablU'J, M,
Pl&IAdtt
,
1
v,
wn , t~ .TANIPlILD
un IfriIlII'OI4
CAlI.laIi, Pi. 1'101,..704
and
W, I, ITANJPUaJJ CONmU011ON
COWPAHY
sm 'Jttq ....
Ctt'...., PI. 1101'
Iftlt
QMY IJllNX
101" laM A....
Ntw ~ PA 11010.
~'1lU
.' ~
I IN THI ouaT 01' COWttON ,I.IAI
, CUM.I COUNTY', PINNA.
: NO, I. .~ ~~
I
/' eVil, It
,
,lUlY
I
,
I
I ,
I
I
I
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
...
ON -LAW
-
L 0' TWII.VI DIWANDID
t
.i
t'
".
.
...._ You bM ..... .. IIlOllI'\, It tw.. to.'" .~I_ .. tit'. Nt
In II. ~ ,.,.., yoIltllM'lU .... wtra ,..-tIII1 CZ0 u~ 11IM ...
........114 ... lit UN"- ~ .. . ..,IUM=UIIIIQt ptrlO!lAJly 01 ~ UIOrnI1
a.w lU~ Ia wrtO. wlds m. GOl.II'I - ~ '" II '" "&hi Nt 6Ndt .,.lNt
= Y" lit VNIMd IbM It ~ ~ do 10 lilt (oUt I pl<<u4 wlr!oow. "" t.od .
. """1 M ...... ~, ~ ttl.ll.t COWl 'ff1rJloi;t (wI"'" .wo. .. M1l1NM~
lJ 1M ~!,!. ., kif _ __ ri&blItt tt11t' '"'*1t4 .y lit~. y" N,
!Nt ....,. tt ~ fit -- "pia ...... .. fW,
';'1" ,,,~,~. ~;c.~' l"~n;; 1". ..:1 "1' '.0
I'. .'" I." ,.., ,',; t . I ,... . d' ''', -,,_.-,
, . ". ' ,
, . I . .,'. ' , '.' .
"',.,, ' t.. ~.~ 't ,. ...... '/.'1 \ .,'1 \, . I. 0' I.,'. ". '~'.,. 14,1"1" ,"" .a; 1.1
1\,',' ..."11...,1'.......",.' ...I'C"''''...f..'IlII'......,f\.~..I\,.fl'.''.t'., .'....,,~ 'I" "W . '.' _f'~'j\'" ,.....'fII.I':.'I_.\...
, '.." " " . ..' '. ' I" 1'1' " .'... ... . ,...' . l' I") :' .. .
. I I I ' I : 1-"'" .,! t, ,'- ,', .. .t" 'I j !; ,t. ,I
Wo;UJAH. WOaaAM. '.e.
1\'1 1C01T W. WO~OAH, UQUIN
JI)"~ "'lCAnOlU~O. ,m1
120 IWI1IITU1T
twtDlUM, '^ 17101.1310
""." 2Uo1Hf
DOMlN1CJt PBUZ
SO& NlIlbInY Drlvt
Hartt'.~., IA.
,1&11&1"
,
v,
WIlJ..w4 5TANSPW.D
,rn .,n., laid
CulIa1.. '^ 1101,..704
.
&nd
W. L ITANa,lIL.D CONITIUCI1OH
COMPANY
sm ,Print ...
~j.'A 1101'
1M
ItDlV,HINK
3OfA..... 4vttW1
N", ClImMIiud.'4 11070.
DduIdUi
j
I .
.~t"O"~
1 IN 'mil ~uaT 0' eOMldON.l&U
I CONI COUNTYIPlNNA.
I
I NO.
I
I CIVIL A
I
I JUIlY T
I
,
,
I
I 4
I
I
.
,
I
,
,
,
,
I
,
0' TWlLVI I)INAHI)ID
.
.
~
<._<.
........
.. PlUIdft. .,... -p ~" _ur.. Mr.... . Mer.... ..C......,
~ ...... 0.....- ,Illd 'V'" It loll".." j
I
" ....."".. w.k w.Iv~ ,..~ iii .. '"". U41....
I
" Ot"."~I\,I" II *' ~ '''~ fI" ~. HGlPM1. IN....
I
. hi'" """ It 'II, ~ ...a.w ~ c..,__ U IN -. .,.......
. ..' f ~ -~ I ;. I fol. ~ ;. ~-,
" ' ","'.,-.... L. \'. " \ '.. r'" I ' " '., ..'~ ,', " " " . ',; ., ".t,. '~"" I.. '
I. ." " '.', .,.',' ,,' " I I 'I. ",' ....". t' '0"',
1 . \ .., . ,.' " .', , ' :\, , I , ,I, "
. ,:.t""\r.",",r~'\i'."l/l ','" ...'.'......,.." ,'\' ,..'1,...'-'''.'11'.'.,.\''.",.....,.
'f'_. f", \Y.p..\, ,..,-"'....._ ,,..,; '\"""/'* ..,~,I)I""j.t... ..\...1,,,,,,<,-,' .',' .~"'f.JI.\,'1"'(.,~I\..".L...,. \'~.-l.,',.i"
. "f , "I . '., ",l.".,., " 1.." t: ''''/1 _ A" ',. t' './, I, 0'
, '" . . ' , ., , ' "" , I ' I' I I" ",d, .t..' j. ." r,' .,.., '.' .'," I r .' 'I" ..
"" ", , ',' I' '.' ",, ", ~ ',". '," \., . .-, , I 'e" .", 1 . .' . ": . ,'. , . '. '.' \ . .,.... '1", . "
, ., , ' . ~ . I I : ,. , ., I . , , 0,
" Der.ndalu Sh,uk II 111 MS\lh 'ncuvtdlf 'MldlllC at dl.t t.bow 1d4ttN.
,
4. Pi 01 UoUI ^\lI1l1l 17, 1002, Pllbllir wu wortiIIIw I phlmblilllUlN=
tor C.P.Aarl.ulbt Down HID OONtnloUon ptoJtot 0 u.m.~11l RaId III New C~land~
"'~'w.nla,
.. DtteDdw K.arr)' SMn.Il: .... oYtr... ,lb. QOIII1J\lClIoo proJoct 011 wbloh
,I&lodtt WII ~"I.
O. Dlftndull WUliaA) 'lIIIItltld u4 a. .unold CONlI'\Icdon' CoIIIt'UY
ww. 1211 truD1nI.\IbcollInClIOn OIl lbt add ~ ptQJtct.
-
7. Tbe DaMd&Ala JCmy lberJc, WUI slWn.1d &lid W. R. IlWniW
, ,
~ Company fIlnOd " all dmte lndriallltrt Il\Itlvl4~Jy or Woup ",g.
......,. ancIIor employ... WllAlD Che OOIllM it? lOOP' f till" '.'DOy 01 .m,l~
I, At appro~lmaltl)' 13 p.m, 011 Alllllet 7,1903. PWallff, wbl1.lawMly OIl
,
lit ~ ,I. wu ItnIOk ODb bea4 &:ld tw by a Iat,e ~ltoIot llOlIItnIl:dcNs maarSI1 cQa ,.,1
or WIt ~ f\'om &IltlO\'u04 btlabt Ol1lbt blllldtnalln wllcJl PIaIIIllft wU ,1l\3r.d.
P. ~ ~ ACC~l "'" ... 10 Iht OIIlr--' llIl,I"'flNllIllI rtold~....
of tlIMU~, ~. JoWly WIot NVnl1y &lI4 ijIf4 1l'J1lt1et &lid danl.... to
''''hultt.... will lit WII'Il fIl1Jy Mllbnla Nlow,
,
"
cawaJ
^'^"^'-JlIII
..
10. twM<< kin',.,.... *.~ ~ f." .. ..u...... .t,.,.,..,~ 1
... , II II t4Ib' ... .." It..
IrM......~:. .~. d.~ ~.,.;. .; "f... h:'1 lajle'10
, . ,.... ,I, " ,--
I I,' . .
" ' ,. ,
I" . .' . , " I', I . t . '.. " '. '_ '" ',', ,'.'. I ' ,
t,'1 I "I III , .' I '.t. t' ,\'1' \.. 'If'" I " . I~"" _'II, \1' .., t' Iff ," ',"~' It'. .I,t 'It ,'/II' "'.
,', 'I"~ ""/~,.,. ,l,l '.. ,I',,:' ........'.,1... t~l'.J' "...,..,,, 11....,&'~....,",....".."",,'WI..1 .','''''11II'''' ~f,,\,'J ''''t\'"I'''~'f'l:1I
. ",' . '. 1""1' ,"", n ~" I If.., Illlft ~ a I, "., ~I _', f. " .,1' ",f".,J,""I\ I"~' . tl..
" ., I ,',II' j I I .t' f'." t' , ' ,It!." ." '.... "', 'f'/I'\I', ",'. . , If, " . t'
I. ' I . . ' , ,,' t, ,I,' '. . ,r
U. 'J'1lI DqlIaIl1lJlI .,..1..... ud reft...n... ot tIt"~ IAOlII\W1
. A.'aWq IP kMp . proper ~u1;
I
D. PaUl", 10 WVA port6n1 .uob t Pl.ln~tt of an
\IIItIMOnablt Nk of harm tram &belr I.1OlIlIlIC\j
I
c, A1lowlDc 1 pI_ of CONtnl1011 material or luppll..
10 tAIl ud ItI'tb P!.a1t\titf! !
I), '11110110 wrolM propel' ou+ hl cIII ~ of
'1 wodl. dlitJM It !be da/lI &Dd dill, all'1t4 ~1f'blI
I ~
.. J'atllq 10 llIte proper .. 1U1 *WI dle build""
IIMNlt llI&IIrl&l or auppllM Ib.u &It 4 .lnlOk Pla1nl.tffJ
I, PaI1bla ~.. p~ and ad \lIlI'1tpI1O pt'M1"
&tit OOlltlnl4dolllll&llrla1 or .uppllal fro taUlq &lid IIU'lldDI
~""ff,
!
12, ItA, rtIu!t of ~, mlloond+. Pl&lnetft tuteIIrt4 HVWI u4
.IIOUnlItJt.IrtN.lJlollJ4lll1 but not "",,* 10, 11IJIlt1tlJ: "II MlVtI, boDtl, mllMl... Jotn
114 .... pain M4 ~. INIAl lAd modollll d I""" aomt or atl of wllJlh art Of /ll&y
lit ~.I", In ftIAIr't, I '
i
U, ^'.,..~ of hie 1AJ1lIit" P1&lntJrt r madlcel .1lI. UlIt '-PW" lor
Art, "UMM IIId """'~. Iwt~. u.u0l *"1Ilf ..,..'" ... .1IItt.tt4 ..... .,.-
lIft'l ,ltyt* .. ___ ".~" ..., IIIMM. "".. lit " II\IJ M ..nDvIIlI ..
lWWI.
.
','
" ,
. ", ,", t.. . " t,;, " f ,'I, , . . I ", (, J '. ,
' /.,',t'" ""'11' t.',-.. -., .. ,1',,','" r.'"". .t"I""~;,,"'II\ ,"","\,'4',-. \"."'("1"" V'
.' , \ I .,".', " " ".\ I, " 'I t,'.,\ I '" 't,'
" t 4, j 't' I ' . I,' ., . I' ',". '.'" ' .', ' ' .
. . t'
.
ld. At a I'OIWI at D,tendl1l,', IlltseondllCI, Plallu1tr lutfcr04 MVue and
,
,
d.laabllq 11\111I'II" Inoludla, lJul not IImllAld co, 11\l1ll'l.. 10 hI' n,!'V.., NftM, 1l\1lI01u, Jolnu
,
.a4 laMia, P'l4 a.nd 'IItt.rll1&, menial &nit 'muUonaJ rlalrtl., ~11I' .r eJl 01 wlaru. "" '" m&f
,
'0 OOIlIfIll'''''- llllWutt. I
,
17. AA I ,..uJl 0' lilt llIJurl.., PlalAU~ IIIOIlITtd mtcllo&l bUl. ud Ul'fNtt tot
OU1,l'tItmell& &lid rdlAbUllatlon, ~l Wnlll&' and/o( WIlln, ClpKlIy and IUftutd IOU ot
I
II~'. pltUure, aDd dlmlnutloD ot!Lll d.aIl)' It'lt!vttkJ, blda ,",or IDa)' bl l101Idaul", !Jl
~,
,
"
~OU, Pl~lltltf dfll'Wll1l JucSa III aaalNt Oefendallr. IDdlvldlllllY,
Jollul~ lIIllIar tMrIlly, tn an &mollnllll.KC... or ,tw.OO,fllolllllv. of -." coeu &/14
d.l., cIa.tnq.. ,
t.QUHt.W
18. tlalndtr lnool}lMtt. bortln by
*""'" , II I' ftaIly .. tonhu It_.
", ".. ""n..no'l ~ lAd ",''''. 0' Dt'-4~II'. ~l
A. Palllq to bep . P\'GPII' 100 D\I\f
I. PaUlD. 10 WIm pIl"tON .110II U I'Ia1ndtr of u
.. f
WlI''''o~l. rlaJc or bum from th,1r \In;
C. AlJowtna.,1.tot OlOON . lIlIlNW ", .uppUef
,
. fAll .Mrtb ~Lla&UtI
lhtal1tpdoMot~,
'~
.
.'
f' '
TEl. NOI
I.
J.'
D, ,alUq 10 .urfl.. proptt ] ~ In me pwfclnnanoI of
wort dudM u ch. dala and lime aU'ltd hmln;
_tlll "1~
-..,.-
! '._.V"~:' '12~ .1: \"ll:!',
. ,
,
. '.
.
'I I .
~
., PtJll", 10 Iakt p~'r '''P' ..OIll1l.1he bull4ln.
tCl'\lONl'lll\&Wi&I or 'lIpPlltIlbal ,.11 IU\ICIr I"I&III11fti
P. JfaIlJat '0 ~ profit and ad quat ..,. ID prtVlDC
the tlOAIlnlOtIoI rnwrl&l or III,pll" reo flIl1l\1 ,lid .aikJlIf
PlaIndft.
20. Iu. rtluJl of Dtl'enOaAl" mlacoM ot. Plalnutt lutrad -.vm an4
.
ctladJlIlIIlnJuNa. InclUdllll but DOC limited 10, l4Jurlu hI. ne~, bonea, mlltcl.., Join.,
.... "'"'" paJn and '\Itrwlnf, IIItlllal and .modonal d lI"III.'otM or all of wlllob lit 01' IMY
be ~IIIlDUllti IA 1l&I1Ifl,
.
21, ~. ....1l1' o( hla lrIlurlH, l>laJnutt I ft\tcIlca1 bill. aDd ""11II1 tor
om, lrMC11InC aDd nbattllhadon. lot, eatIIlup 'Jllt/or 111I OIplOlry &Il41\1"'~ Iou Or
1Ie.1. pl..1Ite& and dlllllrMlou of bla dally act/viti... wlcb are << InaY be condnulllllll
nlQ.ll.'ll,
,
WHI!lIPOAl, PlAlnllff' dtnwl4t J I .,&111, Dlfen4&n&.lDdJyldua1ly,
Jolndy &!\d/or levm.lly, fft IA unouftt 11\"*' 0' W, .OO,mluafvt of fntaNI, 00ttI 1M
6tIa), liIma&",
nUl tort 'ItOM RlCOlD
III Tflt1JrlO11r wilt,"', I Mr. "ntO Itt MY haIIlI
and ,h. N' ~~~ C4vrl .t CarlI'I., ~..
Till. .-L1..~,. flY ~~;;z ~
" ......._~._~~:;.1i-W
MOl AN" MOIlOAN, P.C,
DA TlIDi
o...! U . 'l'\
-.-.
i
tIl
DOMINICK PEREZ,
Plaintitt
v.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. JURY TRIAL or TWELVB DEMANDED
.
,
,
.
.
.
IN THB COURT OF COKMON PLEAS
or CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNIYLVANIA
WILLIAM STANSFIELD,
W.R, STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and KIRRY SHENK,
Detendant.
e'-200 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
CHARLES C. LO081 AND
SON, INC,
Additional D.t.ndant
HO'1'IO~
You have been aUed in court, It you wilh to d.fend aqainst
the olaima set torth in the to11owin; paqel, you must take action
within twenty (20) days atter this complaint and Noticl arl
aerved, by entering a written app.aranc. personally or by .
attorney and tiling in writing with the Court your dltens.. or
objectiona to the claim. set torth aqainst you. You arl warned
that it you fail to do eo the ca.e m.y proc..d without you and a
judgment may be entered again.t you by the Court without turther
notice tor any money claimed in the complaint, or tor anr other
claim or re1iet reque.ted by the Plaintitt(s). You may ose
money or property or other right. important to you.
YOU 'HOULD TA~I THI. PAPIR TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCI. Ir YOU
DO NOT KAVI A LAWYIR OR C~O'1' AFrORD ONI, 00 TO OR TILI-
PHONI THI Or1ICI 'IT rORTH DILOW TO rIND OUT WHIRl YOU eAK
al'1' LlaAL HIL"
TRUe COpY FROM R~
8i-:;~~
i.. 1 f'l~
cuaberlan4 County Court A4alniatrator
One courthoua. .quarl
carli.ll, 'enneVlvania 11013
Telephone. (111) 140-'100
DOM I N I CX PEREZ,
Plaintitt
I IN THE COURT OF COMMO" PLEAS
I or CUHDERLA"D COUNTY,
I PENNIJYLVANIA
I
I ,a-aoo CIVIL TERM
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I JURY TRIAL OF TWILVI DEMANDED
I
I
I
I
I
I
v,
WILLIAM STANSFIELD,
W.R. STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and J<ERRY .HINX,
Oetendant.
v,
CJlARLE/I C, LOOSE AND
SON, It/C,
Addltlonal Dafendant
COMPLAINT or W~LLt1M ITAMI,t_LQ A.q
,. I. IJANI~IILD COH'T,pqT~O~ Qg~rAMY. DI,,_PAWTI
u...
gB&RLII o. LOCI' &NO 80N, t~g. AQDX1to~J~ DJ'INDAHT
Oetendant., Wllliam atanatllld and w. R, Btan.tiald
conltructlon company, by and throU9h thair attornay., Landt.,
Black' Schorpp, hereby ....rt the tollowin9 complaint a,alnlt
Additional Det.ndant, Charlls C. Loo.a and Ion, Ino,
1. Dltendant Wll1iam Stanatield 1. an adult 1ndlv1dual
r8.1din~ at 3672 .prinq Road, Carli.l., ,ann.ylvania.
2. Oetandant W, R. stanatield Conatruction Company 1. .
Dolo propriator,hlp ownad by William Itanatiald with ottlo.. at
3612 Sprlnq Road, carliala, rannaylvanla,
J. Additional Detendant Charla. C. Loo.e and 'on, Ino, 1.
a corporatlon doin9 bus in... 1n 'enn.ylvanla w1th a prlnoipal
ottlce at 50 w..t .tolver Avenue, "yer.town, Lebanon Countr,
Penn.ylvanl. 170.7.
4. There i. attaohud hereto a. ~xhiblt "A" .n~
incorporated herein by reterenc., a true copy at a Co.pl.lnt
tiled by Do~lniok Pere., Plaintift a;lln.t Wllli.M ,t.n.'1.14, W,
R. Stan.field Con.truotion company and ~.rry Ihlnk, oer.nd.ni..
5. At the time, date and place alle9'~ ln Plaintiff"
Complaint, the Defendant was the OWn.r ot a orane utili'fa .i the
job .ite tor the purpo.e of hoi.tin; wood.n root tru.... Into
pOlition on a re.id.ntlal oarao. und.r oan.truotion.
6. At the time, date and plac. al1eO.d in Pl.intl,f',
complaint, the op.rator Of .aid cran. w.. an 'Olnt, 'erv.n'
andlor employ.e ot Additional Oet.ndant, .nd h. aoe.d at .11
times material her.to within th. cour.. and .oop. ot hl. .,.n.V
or employment with Additional o.tendant,
7. At ..id tims and plac., Additional oer.ndlnt'. fr.n,
operator hoisted a wooden true. oVer the oarlWl, whioh tru.. v..
ultimately to be .eourld ln plao. by Def.ndan' WlI1i.. .t.n.'1.14
and hi, other employ.e. workin; on thl .1te.
8. At .aid tl~e and place, Addltion'l Olf.nd.nt', .p.rator
rolea.ed ,aid wooden tru.. tram the oranl oabll bllorl ..1d
operator ob.ervea and aec.rtained that Det.n~lnt l'an"1'14 and
hi. employ... ha~ ..cur.d and/or .'ab111'la .ald tru.. in
position,
9. At .aid ti~. and plac., AdditionAl Deflnd.nt't .p.r.tor
did in tact rele..e tro~ the cran, cable tne wooden \rvI. ,rior
to tho tru.. beinq handled and/or oth.rvl.. "cur~ ~ De,.~"t
5tanerield and hi. .~ploy""
10. TQ th. ..'.n' 'hit th. "fla.nt d"ofi~.d in
rl.lnti,,'. co.plalnt Dogy,r.4, ,n4 it .aid 'lllntt" r.o.tve.
anv injuri.. a. ..t torth ln ..1a e..pl.int, Illd In,",I.. Ana
r,,"'ttn, a...... .r. th. .01. r..ul\ ot th. n..119'~ ot the
^ddltlpnal O.f.na,n', The ""ll,.no. of th. A4ditlonal o.t'n4.nt
c~n.t.t'd 01 th' fOllowt""
A. In n.,lt,.ntly, r.okl..lly an4 oar.l..,ly
r.l.a.lnt tro- th. 'fane .Ibl. IUP"" th. wo@4,n tru..
whtoh ultl.".ly .truok '111"\l't, &"Of. pr.,.rlY
a.e.rt.tnin, an4 fontir.lnt that th. tru" hid ~"n ..our..
or 1"Dttl..4 by o.t.n4.nt "ana'l'14 an4 hil ..ploy...,
I. In 'allin, \1 prf,.rly o...rv. 'h' v.rk In proo...
an4 In f.l.a'lnt ..td \ru.. ,.t.re It VI' pfO,.flY ..our.a
or a"",Hilt4,
e. I" "8911..n\\y r'I,..int ..1d voo4.n 'rul' 'roa
'h. or,n, ol'le vithou\ fir.' hav!", "o.tVf4 , ",n,l a,
.'h'f Andl...,.n If'- o."na.n' .,.n.,i.14 Of ht, .,ploy...
thaI ..la trvlI WI' .,our,d if .'ab'li,.d In pll@.'
P. In '.Illnt \. u.. du. fa,. und., 'h.
otrO\lIll'\'""'I"
~. In ftillfiQ t@ '@\,~ lh. \I,u.l .nd fiUI,.M.ry
..t.ty PfOf'dUf" t'f hot.'tnt .n4 'f'fl'nt wood.n ,rul...
., . 'in'lru.Il'" M'l., .n4
r, In r.l1'nt " f@llov III 1.~f~1 ,.,ul.'ioRa
,.,uhHIV,1 ,'>> ,~ MilUM 1M UMUM " w.....,. or .hJUu
,ruf'.' .i j~~ ft"~t
11. 1hl P'f.ndant _v.r. thAt 1f tho plAintitr IUlt.lnl4 Any
lnjurl" Of a...,../ al 'llO,.d, th. .... w.r. oluI.d I' . rt.ult
or tho IQI. n'91i,.no. Of tho Additional OIt.nd.nt 1n tho ..nn.r
tn whloh It. ..ploy.a .u.pondta .Ita t~...., III .. d..orib.d
.boVI.
13. O.t.ndante belloYI, _nd th.r.tor. avor, th.t Addition.l
o,t,odlnt i. .ol.ly r..pon.iblt to tho Pl_intiffl and ther.tore
furth., Iv,r. that 'Iid Additionll OIf.ndant al lion. lilbl. to
tho 'Iaintlfr f.r tho QIUI. 01 lotlon d.olar04 upon.
11, Alt.rn.tlvlly, lf th. 'lalnti,r i. on\I\I.4 to .ny
r.l1.', Additional D.,.ndlnt 1. jointlY 11.bl' th.r.,or vith
p.t,ndln" Willa.. Itln.,1'14 ao4 W, M, 'tan'fi'ld Con.truotion
~~.p.nv, or 1. lllbl. ov.r to Ot,.nd.nt. Willi.. ,tln"i.ld Ind
W. M. Atln.'1.1d eon.truotion Co.plny/ .. t~t Def.n4.ntl MAllia.
~t~n.ti.ld tn4 M, M. 't.n.,l.IG Con"rvot!on COIp.ny dt..n4
'Ult~~.nt In their ,av@f. tottth.r with the QOlt 01 thl1 lotlon/
An~. In 'hi Il"fnltiv., d..an4 oontrt~tion Of ind..nity fro.
Additional Pel.ndAnt, Ch.rlt. C, LOo.e ana lon/ lno./ totttnt,
with the QOI'I 01 thi. .otlon.
LAM~II/ 'LACK . '~Q"P'
v.
I IN TilE COURT or COMMON 1't.J::AS
I or CUMbERLAND COUNTY,
, PElmlYLVMJA
,
I "-ZOO CIVIL TERM
I
, JURY TRIAL or TWILVE DEMANDED
,
I
I
,
,
I
,
,
/JoM 1111 CK 1'J:ItCZ,
l'IAintttt
v.
WILLIAN STANSFIELD,
W.It, STANSfIELD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and l<EnRY SIlENl<,
O.t.ndant.
CIIARLE8 c. UlOn ANO
SOH, IIlC.
Additional o.tendant
QIRTXrJC~TF Q' 'IJ~JQ'
1 her.by c.rtlfy that. oopy of the forevol"q dOQu.,nt,
COMPLAINT
WI' ..rv.d thl. date by d.po.ltlnv .... in the Post Offic. .t
Carll.1., p.nnlylvlnla, tlr.t-cla.. ..11, pO.tIVI prep'ld,
.ddr....d a. follow"
Icott W, Horvln, E.q,
Horvan . Horvan, P.C,
120 South stre.t
Harri.burQ, PA 17101-1210
TimothY I. M.r~, I.q.
Caldwell , K.arn.
'6'1 North Front str..t
".rri.burQ, fA 17110-10"
J.ck shea tlq,
Willon, Ei..r, Mo.kowitl, Ed,lmln . Olaker
The curti. Clnter, MUlti .30
Indtp.ndeno. .qulr. w..t
'h1hd.lplli.,'A 10100
IAHDU, ..1,,\CI( , ,el(o""
ItYI~~-= ...,'. ,
. taward I., IchofVP, .q.
()Atod' ~..:al' L28:l:.-
. , , ~
,
. " j .' , '"
':',.'"
..; , " ......,"., ,
'. .
'. ""
",.' ,'."
',1
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF
y au DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR
TELEPHONE THE OFFICI! SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN
GET LEOAl. HELP.
Cumberland County Court Administrator
Cumberland County Courthouse
Fourth Floor
One Courthouso Square
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 697-0371
A~SQ
Le han demand.do a uSled cn la torte. 51 uSled de(endorso de cstu domandu
expUCllA1 en law pa,lnu .llulonlOl, ustod Ilene volnle (20) diu de pluo al partir de la fecha
de la demanda y la notlflcaclon, Hacc falla asenlal' una comparencla clcrlta 0 cn pCrlona Q
con un aboaado y cntre,lt a la corte en forma elcrlla 11.11 dofonlal 0 IUI obJecioncl a 11$
demandal en conlra do .1.1 pOrlona, Sea Ivlsado quo .1 u.led no so deflonde. la corto tomara
,
medldas y pucdc continuer III demanda en contrllluya sin previa IvllO 0 notlflcaclon,
Adcmas, II corto puedo decodor a favor del demandlnto y requlero quo ullod cumpl. eon
loda. law provl.ionel de ulA dcmanda, Ulled puedo perder dlnero 0 .1.1. proplcdlde. 1.1 (lira.
dcrccho. importanlcs pllfll ullcd,
Ll.EVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOOADO INMEDIATAMENTB. 51 NO
TIENE AnOOAOO 0 51 NO TIENE HLDINERO SUFICIENTE DE PAOAR TAl.
SERVICO, V A Y A EN PERSONA 0 LLAMB POR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUY A
DIRECCION 5E ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARA A VERIOUAR DONDB 5B
punoe CONSEOUIR ASISTBNCIA I.EO^I..
Cumberland County Court Admlniltrator
Cumberland County Courthouso
I'ourth Floor
Ono CourthoulO Square
Carll.le, PA 17013
(717) 691'()371
. .
" "
, ,
. ,,' \',
,
, '
,.,'," '
,,'.. .,
.
:/"
',J .,
. .
~IOIlO^N ,I, MOROAN,I'.C.
II\': SCOrf W. MOROAN, ESQUIRE
I[JENTIFlCATlON NO, '67:1
1 ~o SOl.'T11 STR~IiT
IIARRJSPURO, I'A 17l01.IZ10
(717) :36.79'9
ATTOIlNBY' fOR PI.AINTlPP
DOMINICK PEREZ
201 Mulberry Drive
Harrisburg, PA,
IN THE COURT OP COMMON PLI?AS
CUMBERl.AND COUNTY. PENNA.
NO.
Plalnllff
v,
,
.
: CIVIL ACTION. LAW
JURY TRIAl. OP TWELVB DBMANDED
WILLIAM STANSFIEl.D
3672 Sprlna Road
Carlisle, PA 17013.8704
and
.
. .
W. R, STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION :
COMPANY
3672 Sprlnll Road
Carlisle. PA 17013
and
KERRY SHENK
30'A ROil Avenue
New Cumberland, PA 17070.
O.feManU
CQM~LAM
Plalnllff, by and :hrouah hll allorne)'l, Morlan" Mor,an. P.C"her.by
. .
cpmplalnl I,alnst Defendanl' and aVerI al follows:
I. Pl,lntlff Is an adult individual residine .l!he above addttu,
2. Defenea"l is an advlt jndlvidval rcsldinl .l!he abo"" address. and operatin&
A bll'"\C'U kr>lIWl\ al W. R. St.anJf'le1d ConnrlKtion Com~ny al tilt a~v. addr.u.
"
,t "
11. Tho'nc&lI&cnrc, carelessness and rcdbsncss of /)cfcndanl,lncluded:
^. railing to keep II pwpcr I(\okout;
U, rnllin, to warn penon. such III I'lnlntirf of an
unreasonable risk of harm (rom their conduct;
C. Allowlne a piece of construction material or supplies
to {all and strike Plaintiff:
0, Fallin. to uerclse proper care In tho performance of
work dutle. at the date and time alleged heroin;
IS, Pall In, to take proper steps to securo the bulldlne
structure msterlal or .upplie. that fell and .truck Plaintiff:
F. Fallin. to take propet and adequate steps to prevent
the construction material or .upplle. from falllne and slrlleln.
Plaintiff.
12, A. a mull at Defendant'. misconduct. Plaintiff luttered sevcrO ancl
disabllna1nJurle.. Includlna bUt not limited to. Injurlcs to hb neMI, bone., muscle.. jolnll
and fucla, pain and .ufferln,. menlll and emOtional distress, lame or all ot which art or may
be continuing In nature.
13, A. a re.ult of hi. InJuries, Plaintiff Incurred medical bills and cxpcnlCS (or
care, treatment and rehabilitation. lOll earnings and/or carnln, cap.clty and lurrered lOll or
life's plel1sqres and diminution orhls dally activities. which are or may bo conllnulnaln
Mture,
, ",
"
\\'IIEREFORE, Pl~inliff demands jud&ment aealnst Defendant, individually.
jointl~' and/or severally. In an amounlln excess of $2S,OOQ,QO.exclusl\'c of Interest. costJ and
delay damllges,
'-llUliI.ll
14. Plaintiff Incorporate. herein by reference the allelaliol\l of parallr.ph.l
Ihroullh 9 III If tully let forth at length,
U. The neaUllence. carelcssness and reckJcllneu of Defendant, Included:
A. Fallin, to keep a proper lookout:
B. Palllnllto warn penonJ luch u Plalnliff of an
unrcaJonablo rllk of harm from their conduct:
C. Allowln. a plceo of constrUction malerlal or IUppllel
to fall and urlko Plalnllff:
0, PalllnllO cxercln proper caro In Ihe performlllco of
work dulies at tho dall and limo a!lelled herein:
B. Palllnl to take proper ltepl to lecure tho build In.
tlrUl:lur. material or suppllel thaI fell and Ilt'uck PllIlnllff;
P. Palllnllo lAke proper and adequale lteplto prevent
tho cOlUtructlon material or supplltl (rom fallln. and .trlklnll
Plalnli!f:
III .
:. . '
\. .,
,.....'. "
16. As Ii result of Defendant's misconduct, Plaintiff suffered severe and
disabling Injurlos, includlna but nOt limited to, Injuries to his nerves, bones, muscles, Joints
and fucia, pain and su{ferina. mental and emotional distrcu, I.ome or all of which arc or may
be contlnulna in naturo,
17. AS a result of hi. Injuries, Plaintiff Incurred medical bills and expenses for
care, treatment and rehabilitation, 1011 earnlnas and/or earnlna capacity and luffered 1011 of
life's pleasures and diminution of his dally activities. which arc or may be contlnulna In
nature,
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demand. judament a,alnst Defendant. Individually,
Jointly and/or lonrally, In an amount In excCII at S2',OOO,OO,oxclullvo of Intere.t, costs and
delay damlaos, .
CQU.tiIJ1l
~, 'ii, R, S't6~S~JE\"Q CO~SIlUJcrl~^~Y
18. Plalntlft Incorporales herein by reference tho allcaatlons of paraar.phs 1
throulh 9 II It fully .et forth at lenath.
19, Tho neellccnce, cll1'elellncu and reeklessneJJ of Defendant, Included:
A. Falllna to keep a proper lookout:
0, Pail In. to wll1'n person. .uch a. Plaintiff of an
unrwonablo rllk of hlllm from their conduct;
C. Allowln, a pie" of construction /IIlterlJl or SV9PIlCl
to faU and lUlU Plaintiff;
. .
TIME STAMP & RE.JRN
i:
I
I Wll.BON, 1:l.UR, MO.KOWln, ItDEI..HMI ,
I flY' p.rna 0, 1I.1nn, I.qulre
John D. 'h.a, I. ir.
IDENTIFICATION NO. .O~70/7.'37
Till CURTII CllfI'P . 'U1T1 no EA.T
INDll'lMDINCI 'QUAM I WilT
J'1Il LADII:LPHIA , PA Ul01
(2111) 07..,00
DICI<lm
Attorn.v. for Addltion.l
Def.nd.nt Ch.rl.. C. Loos.
.nd 'on, Ino,
j r
DOHINICK I'II:luel .
'la1ntUt, .
.
v. .
.
WILLIAN 'TAM'rllLO .
W,R, .TAN.rIILD CON'TRUCTIOH .
COMPANY .ntI naRY 'HINIC, .
Def.ndant., .
.
v. .
,
ellAkLI. C. 1.0011 AND ION, INC. ,
Addltionll D.t.ndlnt. ,
.
v. .
,
ItNCHMARK HONI' IHC., .
Additlon'l D.t.nd.nt ,
IPtXQI
1M THI COURT or COMMON
.LEAI or CUNDlRWD COUNTY,
.IlfHIYLVANIA
.,-aoo CIVIL ACTION
r. I
JURY T~IAL Orl~1'WILVi
DIIWfOIO . ':
h -
.
r;
i
,
.
,
::1
:L1
.
, ,
....
, ;
. .
> F'
"
"'.'"
'I
You hlv, ~.n .u04 in Court. It you wi.h to d.f.nd ayaln.t tho
01.1.. ..t forth In the fOllowlnQ pIgt., you au.t tlk. lot on within
tw.ntv (30) dlY' att.r thl. Co.pl.lnt 104 HvtiQ' .r. ..ry.d, by
i ont.rlnq a wrltt.n .pp..rano. p.r.onallV or by .ttorn.y and fl11n9 in
"dUnq with tho court your d.r.n... or obj",Uon. to the dat.. ..t
rorth 'Q.lnlt vou. You .r. ".rn.d th.t it you ,.il to do .0 the oa..
..Y prQo..4 without you and a ju~.'nt .ay b. .nt.r.d _,ain.t you by
l tho cQurt without rurth.r notio. tor any aon.y ol.i..d in tho
~ co."lalnt, Qr tor any othor 01.,_ or r.l..t roquo.toa by tho
!, rlllnllft'.), You M.V 101. .onoV Of ,fop.rty uf oth.r rlQht.
t",'lJrtllnt to YQII.
yoq llOCI&.D 'All flU. 'A'"' '10 YOVI LAWnA At OliO.. Ir YOU
DO JOt IAYI A &.AllYl" oa CAOOt A"O.D 0"', 00 to oa
'...IIIOIf. till 0"10' ,n roan IIWi' '1'0 rllID Ottf Iflllll
Yoo CUt .n ,JeW, .IJ".
~.,.... c.v.ty ,Cov,t "'1.1"'0'0'
oat Cftft~.. tquu
06,&i,'04 ,. 11'11
'.1.'..... fllll ,.,..,..
""'~i"" h.... .......('lW\!I It,.,........ '....Ho . '''' hAlh" 0""'" · .,,,1'.... ...",
~.).,.,..f;.'J4(_ t{l\l^nt w,,' . "'tM.ld"'\I+~A M '.HUt.
i:
"
i:
I
1. Additional Oetendant Charl.. C. Loo.e and Son, Ino. i. a
Venn.ylvanla corporation with. principal place ot bu.ines. at 50 WIlt
Stoever Avenue, Myer.town, ~enn.ylvani., 17067.
2. Additional Oetendant Btnchmark Home., Inc" upon intormation
and belief, i. a ~enn'Ylvania corporation with. principal place Of
bu.ine.. at 1105 Rana Villa Avenue, Camp lIill, PA, 17011.
3. On or about January 13, l'P5, plalntitf fl1ed a complaint
again.t original defendant. Kerry 8henk, Nllliam Stan.field and N.R.
Stansfield Con.tructlon Company. A true and correct copy Of
plaintift'. complaint i. attached hereto and incorporated herein a.
Exhibit "A..
4. Plaintlff', complaint ....rt., int~r 1liI, that on or about
Augu.t 17, liP), plaintiff .uffered an injury a. a rl.ult ot bling
atruck on tht h.ad and tact by a larvl piece ot con.truotion matlrial
whiCh teU or w.. dropped from an .1.vattd helght on the building in
which the plaintltt wa. worklng,
II. ,1aintUf' a c0lllP1aint a1 '-"!!II, ~ntu a1.1a, the injuria. wu..
luttered a. . r..ult ot the nOQlig.nc., car.l...n... and rlckl...n...
ot the daf.ndant., individually, jointlY and/or .ever.lly,
!
I 6. The plaintif' did not
iae an original detendant.
~
jJ
/;
Ii
Ii
I'
"
~ 'etitioninw Defendant C,C. Loa..
'i~1'
\IV"'('" "'HI Ull\HIWtIl, I(,""'M.. (><(.,11I . ,.,. tl.lIl'" tlloi'H. . t\lIfI l)(l IU'
l\IWt"'IOl.'~:' '"\1''''' W't' . ,.."" 11(71\"''''11, "" '11('It
7. On Ot about Match 6, 1995, original derondant. wllliam
Btan.fiela and W.R. Stansfield Con.truction Company tiled. Writ to
Join Additional Deten~ant C.C. Loo.e.
I. On or about April 5, 1"5, origlnal deftndant. William
Stan.fleld, and W,R, 'tan.field Con.truotion Company flied a joinder
complaint naming C.C. Loa.. a. an additional d,rendant, A true and
correct copy of the joinder campl.1nt i. attaohed hereto and
incorporated hertin a. Ixblblt '.,'
,. Additional Defendant C,C, Loo.e provid.d pl"fabricated
rooting tru.... tor a con.truction projeot to ..nchmark H~', Inc.,
who wa. the aeneral Contraotor. A true and correct copy or .aid
contraot i. attached h.reto and incorporated her.in a. Ixbiblt 'C."
10. A orane wa. ne.ded to tran.ter the prefabricated roofing
I trul... form C,C, LOa'.', dellv.ry vehiole to the oon.tructlon
! project.
11. Additional D.tendant .enchmark "~" Ina., a. aeneral
Contractor ot the con.truction pro1ect, had a duty to en.ure the
~con.truation ar.. WI' .at. and fr.e trom d.nger to all individualt
I
i working at the con.truotlon .it. whl1. the [ootlO9 tru.... were
, teAR.terred by ov.rntad crane tro. the delivery vehlole to the
~Qn.tructlon project,
.).
W1'l~'" .H'" \tl;1\ti~l" 1l.t1MA,," '';1(,._ · "If tliIII'" "..... . w" tJlJ 'A"
...r.tM.;f'ett tel\l"1I4 W'" . "'''1 A (ri,,....A, ,." I.l~
I,
l'
II
I ~
'I
II 12, Additional Oefendant Benchmark lJomes, Inc. wu negligent inl
I
I
(a) F.iling to keep a proper lookoutl
(b) railing to warn per.one .uah a. Plaintitt ot an
unreaeonabl. ri.k ot harm,
(0) 'al11ng to ex.rei.e proper car' in the perto~nce Of
th.lr dutiea at the date and tima all.ged,
ld) ,al1ing to t.k. proper and adequat. .t.p. to eeCur. the
con.truotion .lte and .n.ur. . .at. worklnv environment
tor Plaintiff,
(.) 'ail1ng to po.t warning lignl to indic.t. the u.. ot
ov.rh.ad machln.ry/
(t) 'a111ftg to tap. and/or rope Oft the .r.a wh.r. overhead
mach1nery wal ln u.e, and
(9) '.111n9 to coordinate thl aotlvlti.. ot the v.rioue and
n~rouI .ubcontraatorl working It the con.tructlon
Ilet.
.4.
i ""'..,.. ''''A MO.-OWl" UltIM.... r.c.... . '... (\JlIll" (it..". . WItt iN .."
~ ~"".{lt'-l(l .'.,.J..... Witt . ..."'.C>h......, "" '!I,(It
I
13. Aa a r.ault ot Additional Detendant Benchmark Homes, Inc,'s
negligence, Plaintiff sUftered the alleged injurie. a. .et forth in
his complaint.
14. In the event it i. detennined that additional detendant
Charles C. Loo.e and Son, Inc. acted negligently, carele..ly,
recklessly and without due cere in accordance with their contractual,
atatutory and common law dutie. and respon.ibilities with respect to
the accident as alleged in plaintiff'. complaint, all at which having
heretotore b.en denled, then proposed additional defendant Benchmark
Homes, Ino. would be liable over to Additional Detendant tor
contribution and/or indemnitication.
WlIBRBrORB, Additional Defendant Charles C. Loose and Son, Inc.,
it tound wholly or partially re.poneible tor plaintift'. alleged
injurie., leek. indemn1flcMtion and/or contribution trom Additional
Defendant Btnchmark Homt., IhO,
Re.ptctfully .ubmitted,
WILION, ILIIR, MOSKOWITZ,
~~
IDILMAN , DICKBR
6
.rnd a, He n.., I.qu re
John D. ,hea, .Iqulre
Attorney. tor Additional D.fendant
Chuh. c. Looee and .on, Inc.
.,.
w,,~(~ hill" t,.O\tlOW," U,ll"'''''''' ('If<'" . ,..'I'U"f" fiN"" , lillllt U(I'''II'
...(..f""'(>'Nl' 1o!iIlA'" \'II'" , r"'IAn,."''''' rA IO"'ft
.
r:r
EXHIBIT A
.. .. ~' II "'fi'jli
. . .' . '," . ~, '. ",',"; , ,,; .: ...:. _,~'... "'" : !["'" . :", ,',.',:,'l~',,~.\,: :""'~'::"
...... "','i't:..1..', "..,,'..l.~. r/,..ht~'\.".';I'i"'w'""", .,. . ..I'.'..."..~.., I t'", .~l.',:-,,,,, .'..,,"'..,....'/.-... "'/,,,.:..1\-.....)
" '~t, ,- ".;, ...., ,'..'...,", ", I ," . I ,'I" 1 I, t, I 'j', ,I , '\~.,.,. ',."'" '. .' . .l I... '0 . ,_,' . t . It ."....
"" ." ., . '~'i" "",f ". ~ "~' . : ,':'" ,,' '," -,' .',C" ,.'. .' .. ,t . ~ ,. '.l~ ~'. """,1\
. . " ," , , . .
3. Deftndanl 5h~uk II In adulllndlvtd r..ldln. at lbA &bow &d4rtaa"
.t. Pll or llloUI A\lfUlll'7, 10P3, PI&1QU wu work1o, .... plvmblna wlmnt
(or C,P I Actl, U &he Doacon Hill collAlt\Ictlon project 0 LImeIc}lo Rotc11ll Ntw CwnIltrland,
Ptr~'vanla.
I, Dtttzldw XAn')' Shellle wu OVOlfOO ,!he conullIClJoQ p~ OIl whloh
PI&IDll<< wu woddDI.
,
~
a. D.ttndu!I WUl!am SlaIIIftGld IIId
Wtr,llhI hDI1na 'lIbcontraCloc1 OIl tbo Aid 1-
1. TIle DeteManll Jeen)' SberJc, WUI
,
~ Company acted tJ 1.11 tUn.. mawiaJ horo
Jl, SlaJUtlo14 CONlr\ImOn Colllpally
project
Sl&nIn.ld and W, 1\. Sl&IlIntJd
,
Incllvld\l&lI)' or \broup "'IUI,
, .
actVlI\lI aMlot cmplo)'MI wlthhl!he COlllM e;t toopt r ClIett I"noy or emJlloynlt1\t.
., At approxlmaraly 12 ,.m, 011 A\IIlUt 7, 19931 Plaladff, wbn.llwtuJl)' OQ
,
Iht Jo\l .h, wu .tnack 011 th, bead &lid taco by . lull 1000 'of ClOAIlnl.cldoD muuIal dill ""I
or ",.. 4rOppe4 ft'om &II elovl104 hO"ht on the bllndlna In Which P1a!lldff wu .11Ulttd.
9. 'nIA W41OGld./Il wit dw 10 lbo noal once, ClZtlOUI\&Q Uld rooldlUlIM.I
. ,
.
ot CoCIDdIDg,Ia4lvIdll&Uy, jo1At1y l/I4Ior ""any IZId und InJutltt U1d dam.... to
.
Plallwrt, WIllclt will be ~ MJy .tllbn.lI INlow,
anu:a:J ~
..
lilt .u."dfll ot p&rqrtphll
,
10. PI&I-=(( IMorporUN htreln by I1fer
I
WO\lfIl , .. lftull)' Nt !oM It Icll,Cth.
.- ,
II, Tnq 1\'811,'11(', CI1I1"111'" il\\1 r'iild\l~"'~u or l>~f'l1l.\llnl, inclutllld:
^, falUn. to ke.p 1 prPJIu lookoul:
p, F.iUII, to wltn pmQtU lueh .. ("111011(1 {If .11
uN...onabl. rl.k of hltm (rom tMlf <<lMUCI;
C. Allowlll, a pit<< o( ~l\IllUctlon m'\frltl Of Iupplll.
to r.1I and .d, Plaintiff;
D. flalllq to pmll. proptf Af' In I.ht ptrtormanilt of
work dud.. " lht datt and lim. all.,1d IImln;
8. I'alllll' to Ilk. ptopU .ltpt 10' UWtt lilt bulldllll
.trueNr. ,"*1&1 Of tvppll.. Ill" tell and .IM\( Plallll1(fl
" Pall In, 10 Ilk. proptf "'" I4tquatt '1fP' to prmnt
lht conancdon ftWfflaJ Of IIIppllft from flllln, and '!llk/1lI
'IaIndff,
12. AI a rMIIII of Dfftndanl'. mlKotl4i101, ,l&Inllff 11Ifttft4 MYtrt and
dlubU". IIlJurlt.. lneludllll IN' not IlmhH lO. llljufltllO lilt "'IV", boM', ",,,td.., JolllU
alld l'mla, plll\ and .ufffllll', mmallIId ~ cllllrfH,lOmt 0I111 of whldl 1ft Of NY
bo CcOlItlllllln, In 1II1\1r.,
l), A.I '''\111 of hit \$fltt, Pt.illnff h~lIfl'f4 mtdlu! bill. and ""Nf' fOf
,ar" IINt1tl4l\l and rtlllblHlItlon, Iotl HfItlii,11fI4IfIf -_ ,.,.cIty 1114 IUtftft4 '- 01
IIr,', fl/"1~'" and dlml_R .t,hll 0#1 MI/.,if.IH. wftM" Nt Of NY" M.11lf lit
ftMW4
16, ^I, rmll III D,t'fld~fit', ffiIIKQrnllI't, "l.imiff lutfmd 1"'''11 .nd
Qilllbllll,lnjuflcll, lnt;llIIlln. bul ""llimn.1t IV, injufiu 10 hlt rif"'''. bOil", mutel", Jvillu
And fuela. pain Ind luUtrin" m."tIl .114 ImQllOtlil diJu,U, 101M (If III 01 whkll ar. (If mly
bo ,onlinuln, In naM',
17. At I ruull 01 III. illjuflcl', flallllllt lnwntd IMdklll bill. Ind uptlUt, tot
CU'. "..llMnl and ,.habllltatlon. 10.1 'lfllln,. and/o, tlfllln, ,.,Mil)' and .uffwtd lot. of
lit,'. pl...urN and diminution of hit dally "livid... wbloh &It or may k ~Iq In
fIINf'.
WHW'OU. Plaintiff dflUlldt Jucffmtllt .plAlI DfftAclant.ln4lvktuaJlr,
jolntJy .nd/or IMflUr, In III amoutlt lit IMII. .f '21,000.00, Nwdw ot --. tot.. 11I4
d.IIY dlmlpI, *
~
I'. Mallltlff IncotporIIff IIw,lA lty ftftftnet lha 1I1f1ll1oM ot ,.,..... I
WOII.h , u It tvll)' ..I 'MIl """'UI.
IP, Tllt ""I\J'net, ur,lfullfu .I'd fKklfu/lfu of Dtftndalll, 11lt1u4t41
A. '11Ii". 10 kup a (if"Vff lQl>i/;tljtl
It. 'alltJt, 10 wa'" "'MllI (JJ4llt II 'lalmlff of In
""","-14 'Ilk 01 W"' ftll". Ih4l1lio.t;
C, MIowIlJe. pivA fJt {!lMU'I4JIq" IIlM4fIM fH .'iU
l(t tilt IIi4 .... f1tllifltt,
. .
/), 1'IIIIoglo ocn:lJe proper care in thf pcrfnrmancfl of
work 41uliu at tlle dato and time all'.,d hmin:
t;, Faillnllo l.Ike prllp,r "cp. 10 mur, lhe build!n.
.1IuCtur. malerlal or luppllea thaI (.11 and IltUck Plalnd((;
p, Fallin, 10 ,lakl prop.r and ad.qulto 'lOp' to pr.v.nl
chI conllnlctlon malerlal or luppllu (rom flllln, and .lriklnl
Plllntlff.
20, A.. r..ult of Defendant'. mbconducI, Plalnll(f .uf(tred ..v.... and
dl.lblln. injurlu, Includina but ROtllmhed 10, injurl.. to hlJ nerv.., bOllCl, mUICI.., Jolnll
and tuCII, pain Ind .uffcrln" m.nlll and .modonal dlallN" .om. or all of whlclt It. or mlY
be cOnllnuln, In natur.,
.
21. At. ,..ult ot hlllr\Jurl.., Plllntiff Incurred medical bill. and axp'N" for
~If', llutmentlnd rthablJllltlon, 1011 urnln,. and/or IIIIIln, capacll)' Ind .u"trod lOll or
11(,', pltUur.. and diminution or hi. dilly acllvlU.., which Ifl or mlY b. conllnuln,ln
nature,
WIlBRBFORS, Plalnllfr d.mancb Jud.m.nt alalNt Dof.ndanl, Individually,
Jointly and/or ..verally, In an amount In emu or S25,OOO.OO,ueJu,'vI or inler..t, cOltaand
d~l.y dam',III,
TnUf COpy FROM RECORD
III Ttllimofly Whllflfll, ,lit,. unto '" my hAnd
.r,d the ani ol,JfJd (ov,' il '"U,I" ",
;~ '. ."J.3.~~" d.y O.~." ,..,,,,,,,,' 19,1.,(
.~1I.t.""J?."*~,,f?J
.f PfothMoltty
MORO^N" MOROAN, P,C,
{JAIU): _.. 1"'\.."........ " '. 1",,\
'0.'.'.-'.' ~ ~ ~~ ~ . ,..,,,,,,-, ~._.~~~
..
[lOH lilt Cl< PIREZ,
Plaintift
I IN THI COURT or COMMON PLIAS
I or CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
1 PINN'YLVANIA
1
1 II-aoo CIVIL TERM
I
I CIVIL ACTION . LAW
I
1 JUftY TRIAL or TWELVE DEMANDED
1
1
1
1
t
I
v.
WIL~IAH ITAN.rIILD,
W.R, STANSFIILD CON.TRUCTION
COMI,^,'Y and JIRRY ,HINK,
DeUndant.
v,
CltAllLEII c, LOOn AND
BON, IHe,
Additional D.fendant
Q9J<<,unn a. VIWo1M 'tU1lJ'lf..Q lJrQ
~I ~. 1'1'1....I'I1D pq"''A'lIJ1Q2'JPl! oo..,...y. DI"II(Jl""'~
XL
gK.IL~1 Q, LOa.1 1ND 19M. J.9. ~DD~~f9'JLJPI"I~~
Dltendant.. W1l11.. .tan.tllld and W. R, 'tan.f111d
cQn.truotion company/ by and throuQh thlir attorney., Landt.,
blaok . 'chorpp, h.r.by ....rt th. tollowin9 co.plaint a,ain.t
Addition.l O.tendAnt, charll, c. Loole and ,on/ Ino.
1. Dlf.ndant Wllltaa .tAnatilld i. an adult individual
r..ldinQ at '612 sprtn9 Road/ carlial., ,enn.yIvania,
~, o.tlndlnt w. ft. Itanlfi.ld conatruation Company i. a
.al. propri.torehip owned by Wl11ta. 'tan.ti.ld with ottiae. at
)672 ,prtn9 Ro34, carli.ll, ',nn.ylvania.
). Additional o.t.ndlnt en.rl', C, Looe. and 'on/ Ino/ i,
a corpor.t~on doin9 bu. In... in r.nn,ylvani. vitn . principAl
pCCic. at ~Q w..t #toov., Avonu_, Hy.r.tovn, Lib.non CQ~nty,
h'nr....y'Y~IIIA pun.
4, There i. attaohed hereto al Exhibit "A" Ind
inoorporated herein by reference, a true copy ot . Complaint
filed by Oo.tniok rer.., plaintiff IQain,t Willilm Itan'fiold, W,
R. .tan.field Conltruotlon complny Ind ~.rry Ih.nk, Pefendante,
t, At tho tim., date and plloe alleQed in Plaintiff's
Complalnt, the Defendant wa. tht own.r of I orane utili.ed et the
job ,lte for the purpo.e of hoistinQ wooden roof tru.... lnto
vo.ition on I r.sidentill qarlqe und.r con.truotion.
a. At th. tlm., dltl and pllC' al1'ged in Plaintiff"
complllnt, the op.rator of said cren. wa. an aq.nt, .erv.nt
and/or e.Ploy.e of Additional Olfendant, end hi act.d at all
ti.e. .lterll1 hereto wlthln the cour.. and .cope ot hi. aqency
or emplor-ent wlth Addltlonal Oef.ndant,
1. At .a14 tl.e and place, Addltlonal Oetendant's orane
operltor hol.ted a wooden tru.. oVlr the qara91, whioh trul' wa.
ultim.t'ly to be .ecur.d in pllce by Defendant William .tlnltield
.nd hie other employe.e worklnq on the elte,
I. At .aid tia. Ind plaoe, Additional Oetendant'. op.rator
r.l....d .,id Woodin trues trom tho oran. Dible b.fore .ald
op.rator obl.rvea And a.cert.inla that U.tondont Itan.fiold and
hl. ..ploy... had a,gurta Ind/or .tabil11.4 ..1d tru.. in
[iQ.tt1on,
9. At .aid tt.. Ind plIO., Additionll Det.naant'. optrltor
did 1n t.~t r.l.... fro. tho crana clble tha wood.n tru.. prior
H' tho trUflI VtiA(j I;.ndltllt ."d/or oth*rvil* ..cur.it by o.flruilnt
r.t ,M'IIf!.'11 "00 hll! .1IlJllQV....
10. To tho eKt,nt that the accident d'lcrib.d in
Plaintitt'l Complaint occurrod, and it .aid Plaintitf r.c.ivod
any injuri.s a. .It torth in .aid Complaint, eaid injuri.. and
ro.ulting dameoo. ar. the eolo result ot thl neOlioonce ot the
Additional Oat.ndant. Tho noqlio.noe ot the Additional O.t.ndant
con.ieted at tho tollowinOI
A. In neolioently, r.oklessly and careleesly
r.lea.ino tram the orane oabl' support tho wooden tru..
whioh ultimat.ly .truck Plaintitt, betore prop.rly
.eoortainino and oonfirmino that tho truel had b.en s.cur'd
or .t.bilia.d by Oetendant Itansfiold and hi. .mploy...,
8, In tailino to properly ob.erYo the work In prooel.
.nd in role..ing .aid true. bofor. it was properly eecur.d
or .tabilia.d,
C, In negligently r.lea.ino .aid woOden tru.. trom
the orane cable without flret having rlc.iv.d a .ignal Or
other indication from Def.ndant .tan.ti.ld or hi. Imploy.a.
that .ald tru.. wa' .eoured or .tabil11.d in plaoe,
D. In tailino to u.e due car. under tho
circum.tane'I'
E. In tallinq to tollow the usual and ouato.lry
.af.ty proo.dur.s tor hoi.tinq and er.ctinq wood.n tru....
at . oonotruotion .ito, and
r, In t.ili09 to tollow .ll lawtul r.qul.tlono
plrtainlnq to tho hoiltlnq and .r.ctinq ot wooden or .i.llar
tru.... at Job .tt...
11. The Detendant &lVerD that if the Plaintiff 8uota1ned any
injurie8 or damaqoo, aD alleqed, the same were cau8ed as a reRult
of the oole neqliqence of the Additional OOfendant in the manner
in which it. employee ou.pended oaid truooeo, all as deocribed
above,
12. Defendanto believe, and therefore aver, that Additional
Defendant ie .olely re8poneible to the Plaintiffl and therefore
further avers that said Additional Defendant ia alone liable to
the Plaintitt for the cauoe ot action declared upon,
13, Alternatively, it the Plaintlft io entitled tn any
reliet, Additional Detendant i. jointly liable there tor with
Defendanto William stanstield and W. R. stansfield Conotruction
company, or i. liable over to Oetendantl William Stanstield and
W. R, Stano field construction company, so that Detendants william
stansfield and W, R. stanlfield construction company demand
judqment in their tavor, t0gether with the COlt ~t this aotion,
and, in the alternative, demand contributlon or indemnity trom
Additional Defendant, Charle. C, Loo.e and Son, 1no., tOV8ther
with the costs ot thle aotion.
t..\NDII, Dt..\Cl< " 'CItORPP
IY~~
Ed....ard L. C orpp q, .
Attorney. tor o.tendlnt. .
v.
I IN TilE COURT Of' COMMON PLEAS
I OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
I PENNSYLVANIA
I
. 9~-~OO CIVIL TERM
I
I JURY TRIAL OF TWELVE DEMANDED
.
.
.
.
I
.
I
.
.
DOMINICK PEREZ,
plaintiff
WILLIAM sTANSFIELD,
W,R, STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and KERRY SIlENK,
D.f.ndants
v.
CHARLES C, LOOSE AND
SON, INC.
Additional Defendant
9ERTI'IqA~. 9' BERVIQI
I h.r,bY c.rtity that a copy at the for.going document,
COMPLAINT
was a.rv.d thl, date by depositing .... in the po.t Office at
carlisle, P.nn.ylvania, fir.t-Ola.s mail, po.tage prep.id,
.ddr....d .e follOWS'
scott W, Morg.n, E.q.
Hor;an , Horgan, p.c,
120 south str.et
H.rtl.burg, PA 17101-1210
Timothr I, Hark, E.q,
caldw. 1 , Kearns
)1)1 North Front str..t
Ilarrisburg, PA 17110.1~JJ
Jaok Ih.a, Esq.
wil.on, Els.r, Moskowlt., Edelman' DiCker
The curti. C.nt.r, 8uit. 1)0
Ind.p.nd.nc. .quar. w..t
phlladelphl., PA 1.106
LAIlOt., lLACK , BCHORPP
"y~b::/b :~..<
Jl;dwud (.. ~
11'11 mIl r:f~1f./(' ~-; /2%'
, '.
,4., ;"..., ..... , :'.
.. ' ; I ,', ~
. !,. .' ,
. .
MORGAN & MORGAN. r.c.
DY: SCOTT W. MORGAN. ESQUIRI3
IDENTIFICATION NO, 36721
120 SOUTH STREET
HARRISBURG. PA 17101.1210
(717) 236.7959
A1iORNBYS FOR PLAINTIFF
DOMINICK PEREZ
201 Mulberty Drive
Harrlsburi. PA.
: IN THE COURT OP COMMON PLl!AS
: CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PENNA,
: NO, I/.oS'. 0.'00 ~ ~
Plaintiff
. v,
,
.
: CIVIL ACTION. LAW
WILLIAM STANSFIBLD
3672 Sprlnl Road
Carlisle, PAI7013.8704
and
.
.
: 1URY TJUAL OF 1WELVS DEMANDED
t
:
W, R. STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION I
COMPANY I
3672 Sprln, Road I
Carlisle. fA 17013 I
and
KERRY SHENK
30.5A Rob Avenue
New Cumberland. PA 17070,
Defcndanl,t
t<<XI.U:E
You have bun .ued In court. Jr yoU wl.h 10 dofend .,alnu the cJllm. sel
forth In the' followlni p.ett. you must l&U .cdon wlulln lWenty (20) d.y. aflu !hI,
compl.lnt .nd notlee are lfl'Ved. by enterlne . wrltlen .ppeaune. p",on.\lly 01 by .tlOIM)'
and nlin, In wlldn, with die COUfI your defenses or objections 10 the clalnu .et (<<Ill l.ahuI
you. Vou are warned thl' if you rail to do so the case JI\IY Ploe<<d wiWM you and .
Judement may be enleled Icainst you by the COlIn without fUMel notiee f~ any mollOY
claimed il1 the eomplaint 01 for any other dahn ~ ldid requuted by the pl.ajnTi(f, You may
1I)Ie mllllCY Of PlOpefly or (llher ri,htt impmtanl to y()y,
kXHtIIlT "
,'- '," "
,..," " ,
'!, ,0", .'. '
,', '.' ,
. . . ,..
: "','
, , ,'~ . '-
. ..
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE, IF
YOU DO NOT If A VB A LA WYlll~ OR CANNOT AfFORD ONU, 00 TO OR
TELEPHONE THE OPPICE SET PORTI! BaLOW TO riND OUT WHliRB YOU CAN
GET LEOA'. HELP,
Cumberland Counly Court Admlnls!"lor
Cumb.rland County CouflhoUII
PourUl Ploor
Ono COUrthOUII SqulI'
Carlisi., PA 17013
(717) 691.0371
Al:lS.Q
1A ban d.mandado . lilted .n la CON. 51 ullOd d.t,ndmt de 111&1 dtmalldu
ellpucaW en law pa,ln.. IllullnlOl. Ulted II.no v.lnlt (20) diu d, pluo II panlr de II ("ha
de la demanda '1la notlncaclon, Hact falll ..enl&l' una complI.ncla ucrlll 0 In pmO/ll q
con un aboaldo 'I entr"1I . 1a COrIO en forma CJcrlll IUI d.(.lIJu 0 'U' ob~101lQ a lu
demand.. en contra dl IU plrsona, Sea Ivlaado QUI .1 uIlId no .. defltndt. la CON !omara
mcdld.. 'I pued. conllnu.r la demanda In conGoa .uya .In prevlo avllo 0 nollnc.clon,
Adem... la CON pued. decodor a favor d.1 d.mandanlt 'I r.qultr. qll' u.ttd cvmpla con
lodu law provlaloMl d. 1111 d.manda, Ulled pued. perd.r cJlllfro 0 III' propltdld.. u OUOl
derechol ImporllnlU para Ulted,
LLBVB ESTA DBMANOA A UN ADOOAOO INMEOIATAMENTB, 51 NO
TIENE ADOOAOO 0 51 NO T1ENB ELOINBRO SUPICI1!NTB DB 'AOAR TAL
SERVICO. VA VA EN PERSONA 0 LLAMI! POR TBLEPONO A LA OPICINA CUY....
DIRECCION 5S ENCUENTRA BSCRITA ADAJO PARA AV8RIOUAR OONDUI
PUBOS CONSEOUIR ASISTBNCIA l.EOAL.
Cumberland County Caliri AdmlnllualOr
Cumb.rland County Colluboutl
POIIM PlOOf
011I Courthoul' SqulI'
Cllllal., PA 17013
(717) 691.0311
. .
~
MOllO^N". MO/tOAN,I',C,
bY' SCOrf W. MOROAN, aSQU11l1l
Jl)I;N1IJIICAT10N NO, ,ml
1:0 SOVTIIITIU!IlT
"^PJUSDUItO.I'A 11101,1210
(111) m.""
Arro~.YI POk PWN1l"
_.-
DOMINICK PEREZ
201 MulbtlT)' Drlv.
lfmlabur" M,
: IN TIfB COURT OP COMMON PLaAS
I CUMDBRI..AND COUNTY, PENNA.
Plalnlt"
I
: NO,
y,
.
,
: CIVIl. ACTION. LAW
lURY TIUA!. 01' 1WILVB DIMANDID
WILLIAM STANSPIBLD
3671 Sprln, Road
Cullal,,'A 170J).,7()4
I
I
I
I .
W, R, STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION I
COMPANY I
3m Sprln, Road I
Culla", M 170" I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
and
and
KeRRY SmINK
)0'" ROil Ay.~
Nlw Cumbtrl&nd, PI. 1'7070,
0.,....
~
'lalml", by Ind mrtllp hit IUOIMY', Mot..,. " M<<IU, P.C.,1ItrBy
. .
((l/llpl.tlflll,lllt.t1 o.ftn4.wt 1114 IVtl. II fo/l1,l'N4:
t "'intltf II on t4.;lllMlvlt..W "jillrll'IL th4 ~, ~ft..,
l C>4f4/1d-fM i4 '/l.l4lilllh4l'1l4~ 'f'i4'I" .f& r.... ~. *fU, 41!4 ~f+t-j~~
4 !,.;;hl!'~' _filr~" ~ W. it S~f..W (:{>"'Il~l"JI; (:li~V"It:t ff il>f ~~. ~.u
,t
, ~ ,
,0;
I " , .
II. The ne,!ilellec. carclellrlut and rccklcuncu o( Defend"lI, Included:
^, r.llln, Iu keep. proper l(lQkoul;
p, l'alllll,lo warn p.r.ulU JU(:h u I'talnllf( ur an
UNWOlllbl. rille or harm (rom their conducl:
C, Allowln,l piOl:' of cONlnIcdon mllOrial Of .\lppll..
10 fall and '!llk. Plaintiff:
D. fallin, 10 llI.reil' prop.r ell1ln tilt parformal\Qt or
work dutlta " the date and tima all'led her. In:
B. 'allin, to take proper 'ItP' cO' 'OCW'Ilho build In,
Ill'IIeNfI lIlIterlal or luppllol tIIlt f,1I and .truck Plllmltt)
P. 'alllllllO takl prop'land adequlte ...p. to pl1f1nt
dIf COIIIltllClion maltrlil or .uppllu trom IaIlln. and .alk1na
Plaintiff.
,%, At. mult or [)fr.ndallt'. mlROndUC:I, PlaIntiff .uff...... RVtft and
dltablln. Inj\lflt" Inclu41n, but not Ilmllfd 10, InJvrli. to hll 1\11'\''', IIoMJ, ,,"*1... 10lnll
antS tlKla, pain .nd lutf.rlnl, mtntal.nd .motlonal dl'lf.tI, JOint or all or wll1c:h II' or may
t;, continuln. In !\I1Il,.,
'), A' a rmll of hi., I"Jurlet. Plalnllff lnollfffd mtdlul billa and ""NIf for
,ar.. IIfllment and ,.hIbUital~t1. kitt 'Ilnlll" and/or wnl", c:aptclly &114 ,lIfflftd k111 ot
lif,', "f\tlfftllll4 4lmlftlllloll 0(1111 ally Ktlvftlft, wIllch 1ft 01 may IN OOIMlllUlq In
fi4M4..
A:.
, ,
\\'1111<11010:, Plaintiff demands Judllment acalOst Defendant, individually,
Jointly and lor .overall)', in an amount In OXCOII of $Z',OOO.OO,cxclulivc of Inleroll, cOIlS and
delay damaan.
CQUW'JJ
14, Plaintiff IncorporatCI herein by reference tho allo.lllol\I of parl,rlphl 1
throulh , u It tully Itt (orth It len,\II,
U. Tht ",.II..nco, carel..."'.. and reckle..ne.. of Defendant, Included:
A. 'aUln. to keep a proper lookout:
II. f,Uln, to warn persOIll .uch u Plalnll(( of an
IlllftllOnabl. rllk of harm from thelt conduct:
. .
,
C, Allowln, a 1'1", of COllJ\nlctlpn material or lupplle.
10 fall and .ttlkt Plalntlffj
D. 'allin, 10 ...rel.. proper WI In the per(ormanco of
work dvtlt. at thl da'- and tlm. alle.ed herein:
II. 'allin, to take proptf .tep. to ..cure the buUdln.
.tfllC1Vff ",.terial or '\11'1'111. thlt reU Ind .lllIck Plaintiff;
fI, ,.111", to tIkt proper and adeqUl1l ltepllO prevent
&!If CONUWUon /Nwl.tl Of .upp/lt. from faUln. and '1IIk/n.
'Wm,ltt;
.
..
16. As a result of Defendam', mitconduct, I'lalntiff sufiered severe and
disablina injuries. includinc bUI not IImiled 10, injurie. to his nervol, bonu, mutcl.., joinlJ
and (ucla, pain and suffer In.. menlll and emotional di.treu, lome or ,II of which If. Of may
bo contlnulnl in nature,
17. ^I a result of his InJurl.., Plaintiff Incurred medical bill. and expenm for
care. treatmenl and rehabilitation, 1011 earnln,. and/or earnln, capacity and luffored 10.. of
Ilf.'. pJouurCll and diminution of hi. dally actlvltl.., which are or may b. condnulnlln
nalUro,
WHERBFORB, Plaintiff demandt Jud.mtnt.,alnst Defendant, Individually,
Jointly andlor ..verall)', In an amount In uco.. or SU.OOO,OO,uchl'/v, or In",..t, COlli and
delay dama'el, ,
CQUli.tlU
II, Plalnllft Inco'1'ora". heroin by r.rere"" th. .Ilelallon. ot paralrapN 1
throu.h P u ,t tull)' ,e. (OM 111.n,th.
I p, Th. ",.III.neo. car.leun... and r"lllounen ot De(endant. Included:
^, Falllll' 10 kotp I proper lookoul;
0, Failln,!/) wlln ptr'OIlI luell at P1,'nllff or In
unlluonabl, ,I.tk of lIarm ffom lIMit conduct:
C, ^'Iowin,. p,"" or CC1lJttlloCtlOIlIM~ll.Il or .vppli<<
10 r.1I ,114 'f,fike Pl.ittllff;
. .
, ,
..
YERIl!IC^ !lOtS
Dominick Pern III\e. \hal he II Plaintiff In thll mailer. and \ha' the all~mcnlJ
made In tho (ore,oln, Complalnl aro IfUll and correcllo tho b~1 of hi. knowlcdeo.
In(ormallon and bellof. Ho undCflllndl thaI Ihe IlIlernenll In .ald ple,dlne aro made 'UbJllct
10 \hd penaltles of 18 Pa. C.S,A, f4P04, relalln, to ul\lworn tllalncatlon 10 authorities,
~~'-!:~' r
- Dam n ck Peru
,
. .
r:
I, ~ 1'1 I~'
t f ~1
II'
I :.
I r; r
I I II I
1 I..
.~ ~J[J I
~
~
~
i
.
u
~ ~
-
Z"'~ it:
. ..,
.., ~l
o fi tri
tZ) g~
-~ ~ ~ ~
"'0 l;) C f.
rT'l ~ ". X
~ 9 . ;c
C/'.) ~ 6 u;
o 111 ><
O .i
~o. to
~o Iloi,_
~ . N
cJ~~i
CI"J ~ @;:
~i mi
...l~ ;
u
. '
jJ
~
,
" ,
..
'"
n
w
w
..J
.
.
U
11'I
W
..J
'"
C
:z:
u
u
:.
,.~
~
I.:~
i ,.,.
. . II>
" . V>
" :::J
'1 .~
l' ...
,
I:: ',~ ,,~I:I' ..,' ';':{:,'j h ~4t"'I;(
" .: t, \ . '..... '-!: I'! :11 '." .i ~ 't", 'r. ':'"
...' . f ) , . l ' . 1\ ~;' · I.' ,~ .
." ,r ~ " t '\, I ~\ 'I . . l ," ";, t, .
:\ " . , . .:;. ;Y,' J " Il :', .... ,.
~ , " . .,. ", 'I ., .
. f . 4 ~ ".:', J i I, ,~ I I i7" .,.
. " j. , :': ~ -.' ' , ., .' .,!
,. ,
"
~ 'I . ~ ' ~
b'i I
~ ,.
i"
.:(:
!!' "
,
,-,
(J
,.....
. 0
,
V>
- o. W
'" II:
U ~ D
... ;I;..l
.. ..l
'. III W...
.... lll;l;
III a c
'W: Ie
.. ~ :co
uu
"" 1 ..c
... w....
... fdOll
';1 ,,~:/\", ,tl "
r -'.
::l , i
0- ~'.
"_,, ,I,' t .
'tIC I 'l"~ '..! I . ' ,- '.
0 t.t,,- I" ',',,- .
.... \.. -.' ..II, . "..
;.,'f,ll ., .,"
.. . " " ,
fd ';'1
"" . .,
. ','
"
.... ~. ,':
, lit
CI
CI
-'
'i' --
j' "
J , ,,'
, "
../ .
. '"
0\
....
:::>
." , "Ie
'..UW.....
fir=- ......
... ......~Q
"'"' ;.....
,n VI C ri
. to< UJ....
,,0 w: -'
I (l.......-
A '1.;I;>n..
,--
.. W:.-J
n rJ:"iIf..-I
.. I ,~,"" 'III( ~..
-.: .1.. .:,,1:
... . ":J:t
t(l ,UUl f\.
. lit ,:) .
.' W.'."
IV "'t U
'1fj
~'^
,
I
,
i
~
WILSON, ELSER. ~10SKO\VITl. EDELMAN {,~ DICKER
11.. ('."u ft.'"" lU1lOI10tln4f,..lldtu.. Jq W"" r~llolu" rA !t101I q.1 IJUI6JHIKKI' fR ('''I'J1':~61
p,fti..
Iff. r.. . ... ~flfI' .... "MtI.'.' ..........,i!fll Ii(. .,..... I ..".." . ""'1tIII ....".,..
_,(......' ...,"'~, 11/.11<III<o;' .t/joM" II/.~. r....
~ fiIIo.. ,....' r...... ,..,.,.... ~,....._
July u, un
...... tHIff.
-,-
.... ~ ........ ,.
.......,...
--.-
.... ....
--
-.,.....
--
.... ....
....., ........,
.....' ......... t.
.....4~.
.. WP'MM1M . ....... ft,
......" ..... II
....,~...
.h.wn A, lo..rth
120 .outh .trl.t
ltarrhbuf9,'A 11101
~.! P.r.. v. 'h.nk, .t .1. Y.
0,0,0,'. Ho, .i-Zoo CV
Qur rit. "Qt' oglt~,oooQ1
D..r Hr, 'oJarth!
Enclo..d pl.... find tour or!qinal DOp!" ot tht ..ttl...nt
AI/r....nt .nd o.n.r.l M.l.a.e in r..ard to the abov.-r.tertnoed
1 tlfJlUon, Pl.... have Hr, ,eru IXIOllt. aU four cop!.. and hlV.
..ch oOPV notari..4, Al.o, kindly provide wr1thnoonU....Uon
tro. 'enn Hltlonll Insuran.. eoap.nv indl.atin, th.lr lntent to
dileharo' Hr, p'r..'. work.r'a oo.plna.t!on 01.1. eClll. Ho.
O~40"71.'W) II . r..ult ot thi' ..ttl...nt.
c.c. Loo.. .nd
. ........
It ____..
t ........... .......
.. ...........
.. .......
. .........
H........... ......
'on
Dy earbon eopy of thi. latter to all coyns.l, I a. advllinv
th.t I will torw.rd tho ..tQut.4 r.l..... to tach roun'll .. thlt
tho r..p.ottv. ..tUtunt tUndl '''In ,u"'4tq\l.nUy " torwarded to
Hr. Do.aUh.
It you, or any oth.r ooun..l, hlv, ant q\l..tion. or oo..ent.
r.qardinv thl t.rtfoint, pl.a.. do not he. tat. to oontao, ..,
V.ry truly your.,
Ifl UOH , ILUA, MOUOWITI,
r~fOILMAM . DICKIR
I .,
/ l~t!Ow' (..~ ~ 1
!.70"" D, Ih..' /.....-.
,
JO,/.'b
1/1.01011&'"
Q4. 0."ie1 I. Nt..""", Ifq~&r. ev/.".l.}
'iMillY I. .....r. It, ',vi'l (w'11l41.1
r4vU4 10. HM,,,.Aq\llrt ,vt.""ld
.
~~lr){
nTTUlfltft lQ1\l~IlI.tiWL...u.L.WJ
KNOW ALL Pr:UOII. BY TIll!U I'ItE/lt:MT&lI
that Do.inlok 'er.I,
lndlvidu.lly Ind throuqh hl. .ttorn.y, ahawn A, Do.arth, I.quir., tor
And in oon.la.r.tlon ot the .u. ot Thr.. Thou.and Dollars (",000), In
hilnd pald and tor oth.r qood .nd valu.bll oontld.ratlon, the r.c.lpt
of whlch 11 hereby .oknowl.d\J.d, and int.nlSln\J to bt lei'UV bound
har.by, do hlr.by r.alae, r.l.... .nd lor.v.r di.ohlrv. Willla.
tiUnlll.1d, W,R. .tanatt.lIl Con.truQUon Co.p.ny, lenry &lh.nll,
ChAri.. C, Loo.. .nd .on and ,.noh.uk 110.", InCl. and thllr
rur..ath. In.ur.'', ...lvn., luoo...on, h.ir., lub.ldlarl..,
IHvldon., opl1"aUon., pr.4.0.IIOf. in lntl....t, elCIQutcln Ind
iI<1alnl.tratorl, of and Iroa .ny and all ..nner of lllbl11ty, aotlonl,
o.u.... 01 I"Uon., aultl, d.bU, duft, .ooount., bondi, oOVlnlntf,
contraot., .9'....nt., 1"4,..n'., olal.a and 4...nda wh.t.olver 1n law
Of aqul ty, lnolu4 il\ll .ny olata lor o.ntf lbutton or ind.."U lolt lon
Arl.ln, out 01 an ino14.ni whloh ocourred on or .bout AUfU.i 11, It.),
If..., ..p.ollny with ,.aplot to Ivent. .. a.."'l".4 ln thl p.ndinf,j
olv,! Ig\lon oo.plalnt Qlptloftea .11 QQ.~plGk P~I v, Wll11la
aUf1lUI.!4. I'Jl. JUDaH.l" ~W\I.\IJ."alQLCQ'P'~Y ~M "rry Ib.alt.'4
CUU!lI._StLl.t1.1f tf>d 1Q.t\. In." '(I BlllllI:IIUIlJu,.I.,. IOU... p.n41nq ln
\h. c".~rl.ft~ county, Court 01 CO"Oft '1... Clvil Ae\lon No, '.-JOO,
And any and .11 Ql.ia. ..ae thereunder (lnQlu41nt .ny olal.. tor 1~..
~t con,ortlv. t, th. fM'lnt Iny 'vgh vlll.. ..y hIve 1"II\Y 1.1.,.dl,
w~.\~.r ROV 1n 'Nl.'.~' or w"lQA ..y ~re""f .rl.., vbloh 1.llht'
tn. ..14 6tl.wJentf 11'4 r,1....4 pntt.. .114 'Mh' ...19M,
.~"IOU, Mi,., uH\lhin 1M u..hdtn.Un 'M~ IVI' 1144, ~
~.~.~ @f ~'fft tR4ir ~if'. '.~'@f'. ""~i.tr".f" t~'''f' ~f
...-
(C(OfP1f
AUdignd or any at them, her.arter ~an, .hall or mAY have, tor, or by
rea Bon at any cau.e, matter or thlnQ what.oevar, from the beQlnn1nQ or
time to the dat. at the.. preeenta,
AND FURTHER, that plaintift, Dominick Per.., by and thouOh hit
attorney Shawn A. Bourth, Zaquire hereby cont1rllll and ularta that
any and all lien. 1naludlno mediaal, worker. compen.ation, attorney.
te.a or othar .wpenaes ot any nature what.oever will be di.oharoed by
virtue ot thia ..ttlem.nt, PlaintUt and hie coun.1l Ipec1tically
warrant and repr.lent that the work.r,' camp.n.atian aarri.r hald1no a
l1en aoa1nlt any reoavery bV Plalntiff from thia action, Penn National
Insuranc. Company (olaia no. OZ405971/.WI, ie aware ot this
uttlement, hi' aoreed to thl8 .atU...ent and haa luthor1ud the
Oeneral R.leal. of all alai.. by pl.intltt. Plaintitt further
r.prasenta that written proat ot the a.... will b. mad. av.llable to
all parti.a prior to the .wacution of thia a.n.ral R.l.....
AND FURTHER, in con.ideration at the aetU...nt proo..da and
oth.r valuabl. con.ia.ration, all parti.a hereto ewpreally lor.. not
to disaloae any of tha ap.oltica partaininq to thl. .ettle.snt
inoludlnq, but not limited to, the amount Of the ..ttle..nt or any it.
particular. to .ny .emb.r, emplOY.', lo.nt or r.pr..entative ot the
n.w. \IIedia or any third party, oroup or oro.nhatlon. It 18 a180
.qreed bV .ll part i.. that no monetarv jUdo.ent in any ..ount will b.
enter.d in Inv court Of reoord a~ain.t any party her.to, nor will the
.3.
.,....
CC (QJ r 'l{
..ttl.m.nt aQr..m.nt nor any copy thereot p. provi~.4 to Anyon' other
th.n to the .1Qnltory pArtl.. hereto, thelr r..p.otlYI in.urer.,
And/or thelr coun.el of record, and/or tho.e entitle. havlnQ a dlrect
int.r..t a. partl.. or principal. ln thi. 0111./
AND 't1RTIU:~, in oonl1derlUon ot the MutUal oovenlnt. oontlln.d
hlr.ln Ind intendln" to b. l'"llly bound ther.by, the plrtl.. a.,r.. a.
tollo",..
1. Th. totll Ind oo.plet. .u. of Thr" Thou'lnd Oolllr.
(",000,00) .han b. pald to OOllniek ..n. Ind 'hl"n A. 1J0urth,
..quire .. attorn.y for, in NU, final, and oo.plet. dl.ohar". anc1
..ttl...nt ot any and all olli.s pr.s.ntly .wlatint or whloh lay, ln
the tutur., arl..,
J. Iy .akin., In .quIl pro....ted payw.nt ot the ..tU...nt
amount, each ot th. plrti.. h.reto do.. RELlA. I and rO'EVER Dl'CI"ROE
any an4 all ..hUn" or future olal" and ol'o..-olall. and th.lr
re.peotlve .ub.idiari.., dlvi.lon., op.ration., .uoe...or.,
Jlud.o...on, a..l"n., inluun, otUeu., a.,.nta and ..ploV'" tro.
Iny and all lilbllltle. to Iny lotlon., oontreote, aqr....nt.,
controv.r.l.., judQ..nt., d.'I"", olal.., liabllltie. Ind deM.ndt of
any kind or nature what.o.ver wh.ther known or unknown, or tor
r.i.bur....nt ot any t..., oo.ts, or oth.r expen... plld or lneurr.d
by any party ln conn.otion with the oo..,no,..nt, pro,.oution, d.t.n.e
.).
-
(( :' (( ))' I ~"- I '.1/
\: ..., \.... J I
-'" ".~.
or .uttle~'nt of tht. autt .M above-captton.d, whether now in
.Kilt.nee of whlch may her..ftor arl.e.
J. It it understood that the putt.. hereto have entered lnto
thl. s.ttle..nt .qr....nt tor tho purpoI. of avoidinq litlvation baled
\1{lOn dhpute4 olAhle .nd that nelth'" th. .nt.rinq lnto ot thl.
.ettl...nt .Vr....nt nor .nythlnv oontain.d har.ln Ihall be tak.n or
oon.trud to b. an aa.illion on th. put ot any partt.. ot the
valldity ot s.ld Claim,
4, Thil ..ttl...nt .Vr....nt .h.ll b.neflt and b. blndinQ upon
..eh ot th. parU.. hareto anc.t their l,val npr..antat1v." h.ira,
predla...ors, .xeoutor., admlnlltratorl, a..19n. .nd lueO.lsors.
0, Thl. ..ttl...nt avr....nt Gontalnl the .ntlr. .'r....nt
..on9 the plrtl.s h.r.to .nd the t.raa ot thi. avr....nt ar.
contraotual ., oppo..d to .ere r.oital.,
t. Th. pl.intiff, Dominick 'er.., h.raby loknowledve. .nd
understendl'
(I.) that by liqnlnq "M. Aq,.....nt h. 1. q1vlnv up 111
alai.. 1,.1n.t ..oh ot thl R.I....d ,.rtl.l, p..t, pr"lnt Ind tuture,
wh.ther known or u~nown, a. ..t forth In thl. A9r....ntl and
...
,.."~
(b,) that he cannot; herutter, mike. clailll or brinq In
Action at anv kind aqlinat the R.l....d Varti., tor the mattere
rele..ed in th1e AQr..mant avan it it ,hollld turn out that thalr
alaimC') Ir. Qr.ater than pr.,ently known or .xpeot.d,
tH WITHE" WHEPEO', plaintift, Dominiok '.r.., 1n the pr..ence at
hi, attorney h.. u.outed th1e .etU...nt A9u....nt on th. day ana
ye.r flr.t written btlOW,
rei
WITHI"
DATED'
, un
'W(llUf TO AHD lu"elUIlO
IlrORI MI THII ____ DAY
or , &tn,
IfOrUy ,tI.tlo
Hy C~l..lOft I.plr..
.IN.
wI-
...,..- .
\VILSON, ELSER, MOSKOWITZ,. ;::D2LMAN 8 DICKER LLP
Th. CUfIIl Cfnlrl, ~llllelUll E~II, In.lrj>tnJw\I' S'Ium w..t, I'lulJ.lcll'lua, I'^ 19106
Tel: (JI~) c>27-fl')O() I'u: (21~) 1,27-21.(,5
NIl_ t"" . j.. A..... I. Itwta,int. M~"'''''IJL~' ,.......,,. . PIt,tMlrlplaJ'" ....'."f t .,~
,-..,.. "".1'IowM ..... D.IM I .."""V. Nt. .. Ilffp I II....Wftt LII""""" Ii"',.
AMNirom..wt A.h" ft_..,.,.. It..../IIff. MlHlfIt. ............. '
w""w....".....,um
.......,. .............
u..-,....... ..,............
IntIr........... ""~
.....,.- --.u..,...u,
............. ..... k&d-
-...,..., ........IlU'NM.
-'.... ........ ........
..."........
Haroh U, 19118
'.tUIII6IIfnIII"'"
., MM"""""
,.................
.........tNf1It..'r
-11/.II'---.. ......,
....--.........,
Shawn pOlarth, I.quir.
no South street
Harri.bur9"A 17101
R.I Old.ant
Insured
Date of Lo"
Type ot Lo"
p~r New rl1.
D.ar Nr, Bozarthl
A r.l.a.e wa. torward.d to your att.ntion tor your cli.nt'.
.iqnatur. in July, 1997, tollowinq ..ttl..ent ot the .bove-
r.f.renc.d .atter. To dat., a .iqn.d release ha. .till not be.n
r.c.iv.d, In the pa.t .ev.ral month., you have provided variou.
reason. for the delay, however, w. have not heard tram you in
several month. and you have not return.d my telephone call from
l..t we.k, It a .iqn.d rel.... is not r.c.ived within the n.Kt
thirty ()O) day. or by April 1), 1998, w. will have no option but
to tila a p.tition to enforce the s.ttl.ment.
I Dominick P.rel
I Charl.. C. Loos.
I Auqu.t 17, 1993
I p.r.on.l Injury
NO.1 00140.00001
, son., Ino.
I look torward to r.o.ivinq your oli.nt's .iqn.d ral.a..
within the n.xt 30 day.. ShoUld you wi.h to di.cu.. thl. matter
furth.r, plea.. oontaot me at any tim.,
V.ry truly your.,
WILSON, ELSER, MOSKOWITZ, EDELMAN , DICKER LLI'
~M,S,~
D.bor.h H.S. Doyl.
l>KSDlda
COI
John Popl1ock ~,qutre
Edward L, .chorp, J.qulr
Daniel K, p.ardortt, l.quire
DOMINICK PEREZ,
Plaint! ff
v.
WILLIAM STANSFIELD, W.R.
STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and KERRY SHENK,
Defendants
v,
CHARLES C. LOOSE end SONS,
INC. ,
Additional Defendant
v.
PENCHMARK HOMES, INC.,
Additlonal Defendant
1
,
1
I
1
1
I
I
I
I
1
I
I
,
I
1
I
I
I
I
1 N THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
C'JMDERLAND COUNTY, I'ENNBYINANIA
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
NO, 95-0200 CIVIL TIRM
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this \~Itl day of Hay, 1998, upon consideratton of
the Petition To Enforce Settlement filed by additional Defendant
Charlus C. Looae and 80nl, Inc" and of the Answer to the Petition
To Enforce Settlement tiled by Shawn A. Bozarth. Eaq., .oonfereno.
ia SCHEDULED in the ohamber. at the underliQned judQe for Tuelday,
June 2, 1998, at 8145 a.m.
Danlel K, Deardorff, Elq,
Ten Cast HiQh street
CilrUale, fA. 17013
Edward L. Schorl'p, F.sq.
36 South Hanover Street
Carliale, FA. 1701)
BY THE COURT,
Timothy I. ~ark, Esq.
3631 North Front Streot
Harrisburg, PA 17110.1533
Deborah M.S. Doyle, Esq,
WILSON, ELSBR, MOSKOWITZ,
EDEL~AN & DlCKER, LLP
The Curtis Center
Suite 830 East
Independence Square West
Philadelphia, PA 19106
Ire
e~ n>w\..l4A.> ;-/'5I1t;,
., ~,r'
I 'Hl'd"1\IUIIIlI\lh"II~. 11.""""1.1
I "-"1,,1 ll~ I' ... ,.... 1. II "I,.'
Il",,,,,l ,,\ .,,,,!N '.'11,,\4
v,
IN TIll! couln OF COMMON ('LEAS OF
CUMBEltLAND COUNTY ,I'ENNSYl.V ANIA
CIVil. ACTION. LAW
NO, 9S.200 CIVil. TERM
DOMINICK l'EREl.
Plaintiff
WILI.IAM STANSFIIH.D
w.n. STANSFWI.D CONsmUC'TION
COMPANY bnd KElUtY SIIENK.,
[)efendants
v.
C/lAIUJ:S C, I.OOSI\ ANI> SON. INC,.
Additlnnal Defendant
v.
BENCIIMARK 1I0MES.INC.,
Additlnnall>efendant
JURY TIt/AI. DEMANDED
"N~Wlm Of DE~CIlI\IAIU( HOMES, INC. TO Pt:Tl'flON
'1'0 F.NI;OQCE IIETfI.Un:NT
Addl1ll1nal Der~'IIdant Benchmark Ilnmes,lnc, has nllllbJectllln llltho retltllln and 8JPW1 that
the I'elltlon In Enfllree 5elllement shnuhl he ir8nl~...I.
Relpl.'l:lfully lubmllled,
Alt(lIIwys for Additional [~fendanJ Derwhrnlltk
Ihtmn.lrw,
MARTSON UHARI>ORFJI WILLIAMS" ana
lIyJ1;it._~-
Uanlel K, l>e.rdllrlT,IJ11Iulro
1.1>. Nil, 171137
len E..llIllIh Street
{'arUlle,I'A 17(11).)(19}
(717)241.))41
()ale: May If. IIN,
~l.llUfl("1\'UWi
Uanlel K. (~anlllrIT. 1:Il/ulr\!, 41f Ih, Orm lit ~MM180N OMMOORf'f
WII.LlAMS It. on'O, IUome)'. for fJlIIIi:hnlllrk 1l1l",...lrw, In 1M wllhln "Ikl/l, !;..,in.. thallht
Nlalemenl. mado In Iho furelllllnll Anlwer 11IIh,,'~itllln IlIl:nfl~f $~Ilfmflll tr, l/\If and !;(l/l<<1
IlIlho bo., of hi. knllwledllll, In(ormltllJlllnd bellor, II. undtrltaml.lhII II'" ...lfnWft'. Mr,ln
"fll 1II1IlIIlIUhJOI:IIOlh\! Nn.lIIl1.or Iii I'a. ,..!t. S~t1(JIl 4\104 r,II'ln, 10 un,w(lIlIl'a,.llkatlM III
lIullmfitlel,
l.il/~-
,"'IUUWICMll OJ' tU.\RV\(,:li
I. J"qliulilw A,(*k<<.lIn IIUlh(lfilcd III~"'I (If Mlnlllm.(_rd4lfff, WiIIilllTl." 0\14'. 11mb)'
c~rllfy Ihll . 1:01')' of Ihll nlfl/lIoinll "n'WlIf ilf lIl/rwhmlrk lI\1/nll'. Inl/, In !"tltlon 10 Ilnflltl/1I
S'-'1llemllnl w"l<<\'cd \hili dill. It}' d4'ro,ilhl' QmtJ III thtll'tltll Ol1kl/ II ('IIIi,III, 1''\, n..., dad mall,
JllltIllll' prl/"lld.lddr,.1l.ld .. fi.lhlWIi:
ShawII ^, lIoft.rlh. 1~"IlIlr.
120 Soulh Slf",
lIarrl.lttlfll, M 17 \II I
l)fbilrah 1)1l)'le, tlqulr.
Wn,80N.I'.Ul!It. MOSKOWIT1,. f,IWl.MAN It. UICKIUt
1'1111 ('uni. (',nlff. SuilllllJO
Ind\lptndlllW. ~uat. Wn.
Jthllldtlrhil. M 111106
John r(ll'll(~k. I'lqlllr.
1IlOMA!i, TIlOMA!lIt.IIAfI!M
)oj Nllfth hlll\l "If'"
II,(), 1\(., IJViI
IlllTlli/lurll' M 11\1111
I'Awlf4 t, 8l;htlfJ'P. ('.lqlllrt
U7 W.,,!lip Sit'"
C.rlllil.,M 170\J
MAIn ION. UMMUOIUJI. WIUJAMI t\ ono
"'e~O"ILY~~
('11I'..'..1'" POI)
(717.:"I1'U,U
^~. f,(iJ ~~~ l"~
I._~ H.~,I..
.~ ~) I~< I~
~~';;;,' ;-;:;;=~:<'-' ~.,' '''~~,~''''''''''':if;-;;
..
~! ! ~ ~
~h ~c~ ~ ~ ~
t~ ~i~8' I
~~ ~1' · I
! .~~ =j
~~",L",~"," ·
, '.-.- ,_.~
I. -i ~
. "..
<.
WILSON, ELSER, MOSKOWITZ, EDELMAN 8 DICKER LLP
The Cunl. Cenltr. Sulle 8)0 Eaol, 1IllI,,,"n.t.,,,, Square W"', I'hll..trl"hla, I'^ 19106
T.I, UU) 6l7-6900 f._: 1115) 627,1665
"". .,. . w..u,.IH' ..".,....-'............' ,.. t N,.,t . ,...... t...... . AI.....
('...,. "'" ,,..,. N't ,,,,,,,,.u.,. Nf. ... h,., H......"........ ft4)1'
AI'tJWI OjIIN.'''' t C......',."..,.,.. "'.......... ,'''_
-
......... ...........
...,...-.- ................,
....,......, ....../~t
.....,........ .....,. ....w
................ --,.......
.............., -......
................. ......,.......
........... .....
May 27, 1998
X1~.IMILI and RIOULAR MA~L
Shawn g, Bozarth, E.q.
120 South Dtr.et
Harrllbvr{l, VA 17101
,~...,...
....-....
......--..
... ~......t
... ......... III .....t
f ................'c
O.nlel K. Oeardorff, E.q.
M.r.ton, Oeardorff, Wl1ltam.
" Ot to
Ten Ca.t High Street
Carll.le, PA 1701)
Edward L. Schorpp, Elq,
L4ndi., Plack " Schorpp
), South Hanover Str.et
Carli,le, PA 17013
ReI P.r.. v, Charl.. C. Loo.e " Son, Inc" et al,
CCP, cumb.rland County, Civll Action No. '5-200
Our f'l~ No. OOJ40.PQ007
John Popl1ock, E'q,
Thoma., Thoma. " Hatter
305 N, 'ront Street
P,O, POI( 999
Harrt.burg. PA 17101
Dear Coun.el,
t have ,pok.n with Judge Ollr', ,ecretary with r.gard to the
conterenc. .chedul.d in the Judge" chamber' for Tueeday, June 2,
1~9', at .,41 a,m, She h., .dvi.ed th.t unll's any Of you ~r. in
oppo.ltion, t mAY .ttend thia conterence via telephone and .hl
will place the call when .veryone i. pr..ent in the judge'S
(:;hAmb.n. I h.v. mad. thl. requ..t ba..d on the di.tancI ot my
of tic I to the jud~e'. ch.mbers. Should any ot you have any
obJ.ction, pl.... contact me imm.dlAtely, If t do not hear tram
you, 1 wlll ..,urne thlre i. no obj.ction .nd I will wait for the
tolophont o~ll tt~~ chamber. neKe TU'DdAY morning,
Thanll: you tor your con.ld.r.tioll in thie matter.
Very truly Vola-.
WILSON, KLIER, MOSKOWITZ,
COlLMAN' DICK&R LLP
~ ~,Sl~
O.~~r~h M,9, ~)yl.
'1,'0, I. 0
. " .'jd
em/lid
(!(!' Tn. "QMublll J. W..ley 01u. Jr. {'Ilia u~\J\ll.. lll4ill
t)f(l./~
I
,
'., ~,
""
i::r
'i
t
',:}
~~~
PlJ.p l
;.
~.~
1...,<
'If..,
(f-I~~ a lh..u_ i,~IM.
I)()MINICK I'LU\l1.l,
1'lallllllT
IN TIIH (:OU!rJ' 011 COMMON I'LllAS 011
CUMUBl\LANU COUNTY, JIliNNSVl.VANIA
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
O,.~OO CIVIL TfiRM
v,
WII,UAM STANSIIIUl.D.
W It ST AN!l11l1!t.D
CONS'fIUJCTION CO~W^NY
COMPANY and KflRI\Y !lllUNK,
I),r,ndallta
v
CIIARU!!i C, l.OOSn AND
SON, INC
Additional O,"nd'lII
v'
nHNCIIMARK 1I0~m5. INC,
Additional o.r,ndant
JURY TRIAl, unMANOl!D
Mr.'I.'" 01' \VII.I,I.\'" nANiI'lf.I,D ANO W. M. STANSI'It:l.D
CONSTR1!(:'1'I0N COMI'AN\'lO Nf.W MAnt:" OF
. .
NOW COMBS u,rell(!anl William Slan.neld and W R SlIlllf\eld COIl.tllletlon
Cllmp.ny, by alld thtOllll" 1-lIlda., IlIa.k II> S,tlllfl'll alld t'llly tll th. N,w Mallfr of Additional
1>.(,lIIIanl UtnthltlAlk IIvm't. 1114' . ..1i)lIvw.
U lh. Av.lrllfnl. ufthl. paraplllh II. cun"\I,IOIII oflaw Ifqultina fl() Anlwtf
lIt"in
tANDIS. IIl.ArK " !lC'IIOltJIP
li4,".,d l. . e . I!...w.
('WIl$d r,,, l>4'f,,. wWWn
8.~ an4 w K Slw1W4
('(lMIf~'lt~ ('{oI!'i4\iA)'.I!IC!
.. ~i\4I'" IltNl\ff !111m
fj/41~, I'tI\IIHIHlfll, I'lU11
Hm w,nH
~mufIC^TIQ~
I v<<11')' 11I111h. 1111,""nll 4:(lOl.lntd h.r.ln .r. lrutllld rorrKI 1 und.,l,and IhAl
1\1.. IlIlfflWnll htttln at. mad. tl.IbJ<<IIO I'" ptnalJl" of II P. C SA 1~904, r,l.liltj 10
un.worn filaiftC:.llon 10 ,ulhorhl..
~.
Cdward I, S,horp . ((lqulr.
(>lltd.6....71=!I€.. .
,
I hereby certll)' lhal I copy oflho for'lIolni document, 11I!!'1. Y OF WIl.\JAM
STANSPU!I.D AND W. R STANSfIELD CONSTIlUCTlON COMPANY TO NnW MATI!!R
()II A()()\TI0NAL DHfl!NI>ANT UmsOIbcWU\llOb.lfiSJNC-. WI' ,crvcd Ihl. dllo by
dopo.ilin>> urno In Iho "011 Ol11co al C.rll.lo, I'cnmylvlnll. nUI-cl.., mill. pOll'''' preplld.
.ddreuod I' follow,:
Timolhy /. M.rk, /l1i{1
Clldwell " Kearn.
)6) I North Fronl Slr,,1
".rrlabur,. PA 17110
S"'II W Morll.n, P.aq
Marlin It. Mor>>.n, PC.
120 Soulh Slreel
U.rrlaburll' M 171 0 1.121 0
D.nI,1 " Deardorff. !lilt
M.rtton. Dflrdorlf, Wllllamt" 0110
Ten Ulllllillh SIr"1
C.,11ale. I' A 170 Il
Jack 0 She.. 11aq
WlllOn. HI..r. MOlkowllJ, I!d.hnln" Dlck,r
Th' ("urtl, Celll,r, 5ull,I10
tnil_rondenc. Squlr. W,"
111ll1.delphla, PA 1910b
I.ANnIS. IItA('"'' Se'IO""11
-"-....", - <"" "t>-.
l!dw&1d l. ~borpp. (1(11111.
l~fIf "((;:/,,l;- .~~
. ,
. ,
~ ,
t,' ,.. ..",
~1;~ c t:j
}I,r '" "''''''
')1 ,J",
_1 .,.-. -it"..
~\ .-.. . \-
. r 1'1-.. >~ ~ 1
\ !' .1
F,\ (1'\' f.-
\" . J
. ,., ..... !..
I - --- :-
It. r ...J
l~- '" )j!\"
"
I; .t. ')
() t.J\ :,,)
. .
~ .
! : ~II ~ 6
i J! ~ ~ II
~ II i~ ~~
~I~I i
L .!~ Ji
!I~! ~.!l
I I I I ~ ,.
~
~ i~
..-
"
v.
. IN THB COURT or COMMON PLBAS
· CUMBRRLAND COUNTY, PINNSYLVANIA
.
· No. 95'~00 civil Term
· CIVIL ACTION - LAW
.
.
· JURY TRIAL DEMANDBD
.
DOMINICK PIRIZ,
Plaintift
WILLIAM STANSFIBLD, W.R.
STANSPIBLD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and KBRRY SHENK,
Defendants
Ilfl'RY 0' APPBARANCB
TO I PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBBRLAND COUNTY
Pleae. Inttr my Appearance only on behalf ot D.rendant Kerry
Shenk.
lIy,
CALDWB,~L.:..1c .KBARNS (
'J~~"--~
Timoth I. . r , Require
Attorney ;,~ .~7758
3631 Nort~-Ptont Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
(717) :U2-7661
Attorney tor Detendant
Kerry Shenk
Dated. January 31. 1991
44l1t
.
CIRTI.ICATI or 81RV1CI
I hereby certity that I am thi. day .erving a copy ot the
foregoing document upon the per.ona in the manner indicated below,
which service satisfie. the requirements ot the ~enn.ylvani. Rulee
of Clvll Procedure, by depositing a copy of eame in the United
State. Mail, Ilarriaburg, Penneylv.nla, with tir.t-ela.e pottage,
prepald, .e followe,
Soatt W. Morgan, Blqulre
MORGAN' MORGAN
120 South Street
Harrl.burg, p~ 17101-1210
By.
CALDIfBLL (J,~BAJlN8
/
,/
mot y , , . equ r.
Attorney ~.D '277S'
3631 North\lROnt Street
Harrl.burg, PA 17110
(717) 232 -7661
Attorney for Defendant
Kerry Bh.nk
Dated' January 31, 1'95
..m
.,
-
.
Dominick Perel!
.vs.
William Btan.field and W,R, Stansfield
Construction Kerry Shenk
In the Court of Common Pleas of
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania
No. 95-200 Civil Term
Complaint in CiVil Aotion Law
and Notice
Michael Barrick, Deputy Sheriff who being duly sworn according to low,
saye on January 20, 1995 at 8146 o'clook A.H.E.S.T.. he lerved II true
copy of Complaint in civil Action Law and Notice, in the above entitle
action upon the wihtin named defendants to witl William Stansfield and
W,ll. Htanefiels conatruction Company, by making known unto Williem Stansfield
fopr both at 3672 Spring Road, Carli. Ie, Cumberland County, Penn.ylvania,
its contents and at the somB time handing to him personally the said true
and attested copisl of the Inme.
n, Thomae Kline, Sheriff who being duly sworn according to law,
oays he made diligent a.arch and inquiry for the within named defendant
to Witl Kerry Shenk, but wal unable to locate him in hia bailiwick,
lie therefore deputized the Sheriff of York County to aerve the within
Complaint in Civil Action LaW and Notice according to law.
YOllK COUNTY RETURNI Now, January 30, 1995 et 9122 o'clock AM lerved
the within Notice' Complait upon Kerry Shenk at 28 Ealt Market street, York
by handing to Kerry Shenk a true end attelted copy of the original
Complaint and notice and made known unto her the contentl thereOf at
York County Court IIoule, 28 Ealt Market Street, York, York County, PA.
Bo answers I Kenneth L.Markel Sheriff
York County Return 1. hereto attaohed,
So Anewen, ,
~. I. !
t ."~' ~ t,. f:
I
ahortef'. COlt.,
[)ockeli ng
out of County
flurchllrnO
llarvtcll
York County
R,
U.OO
!I.OO
6.00
12,]2
-16,00
, 1. 12 pd. by
atty 2-2-9~
netor. M.
" ~t
~.
I 'T' " C rt C I - "'t. ..'....,J .-.'1.......'1 p...... .. 1\... '
n I'ltJ ou CT .::mmon r =:3 or ....:.;.. .... .;1,1_:1_ \,.......... II ~..r:'4Y 1...t':I::
Ll:lldllick "en't
'IS.
Kerry Shenk
:-to.
9~.200 Civil Tenll
"~_'l
~~i.._
~OWt
"IlI1Utlry 25. 1995
~1I_ r. S~~1l' Oll' C~~t3D.!.A.'fD cot."}{,:,y, .?A.. co
h=!ly rl:pue:. w !hcI.:1' ol
:.!:is c.c;:u=~ 1Id.:1J =A " ll:a nquc.n =c1 riak ot t!:. 11=:6.
York
. ,
~U:11 III Cllt;'JI4 :!:is w:::.
. "",#, (;r.,
,.r ~".r"...-"f"" ",~,d
,
, .
,/ .n''''' ...~.'
" "
c' ('....f.;,;;"'-""
SlId of CilmbvW:d C'lIAlT. ':10
.
Afiidavit 01 Semco
:-low,
January 10.
I' 95
~, ,. ~2
.
o':!oci .' A ~c. Icr,~
:}:. ~c.!:!D
Notlce , Complaint
'Jpoa
~erry Shenk .
~8 ~aQt Market Street, York
.
u
by ~d1:t, to I(IIlIP"ry qhfllnlt
i true and att.lt.d
J.l1d cw:. m-a 10 h,r
np)' .t ~ mrirlul
York count~ Ciurt
~Q !. M.r~ ~ ~..
York County, f'A
lll.tUlIIUllI \!Ilmt.
Haul'e,
YOl:Is,
"
I..
i...
Soww,",
\:R uJ
. (/)
:i ::J <
,I {'l D..
,1/' rJ :0.,: ~
.Lj i..... :::: ~ "'. ~
;,: ~,: ~ d llO'AIIW, .......
,<.: U ~ -'.,... \';"41'1 II' /lUJI;f, .., ~
\: ..J v.n. .... c_" '-iIw...... com
~m .ud' "'~M ~){..,................~n .~" SDVla
=', ~~' )Otll4a~ ~ J"n.\j", ry _ If..!l. '-C1.Z.\OI
, 'In' I(f l~ , AmlM, \'11
'L"tLI/. ~ . IL, I hot ~Ij~;i;f..i;~;;.yfi.~~~t;i
~.... ~'-. '~......"'~
K9nn.th L. Hlrk.1 ~-~
...., " t oh c:-tr, h:
~ 1 4.00
... No".
. :f.Ol)
II & !II o-d"----....--.
'-'~
., ...J
COMMONWHAI,'fll 01" l'IlNNAI
COUNTY 01' I>^UI'lllN I
KItHltII'I"1! 1l1l1'lJIlN
NU. 9'-420
IIMII 42
ANll NOWI JanU/llr)' 30,
III 95 .111 210' l' M.
tilllWHO 'filII
WITIIIN
_Wll'lAltiLA.NarlCt. __...... ._. ."_..'_~~_' UPON
CA/'lI'ERAURY BUILDt:RS, INC, & lit.ve Kanott IIY I'I1IIttONAI.I.Y
IIAN\lINU '1'0 Marcia Rol:u:k, OUite Hanai.r ard peuon in charg. It t11l1ll of
servtce
2 COPIES
If. TlttHi ATTlltlTllU (~ 01' TI'" OltlIllNAI. tn1I'iAINr & NtTrtClt
ANI> MAKINlI KNOWN TO lIer 1'111\ CONTIlN'U TIIIlRI(OI' AT 611 North
Mountain Rd'1 Il4rrb~rll Dftur*tin CountYI Penna,
lu" AHIIWIlI,.. '
..t-.' . ./J i ·
.,,,,,1t;#A~.;}~... t~~\$~t':),
SHERIFF ~DAUPHIN COUNTYI PENNA
IIY ti-/j " ~f J A.~ d"
V ~'I"'~/f: .~
Ulwun "'I&RIVII
lhomrn I1Hd MublJctlbud tv
be/pro A:- thi.. Jl't~Y 01 Jan.
Jt{f) lM!) (#. 'l '."
I -"
" ,
l~ "
"I\Otllll"'1I1 ,\11 \'
NIU(fflf'l"M ('IUft .
" IA
l:1 Tnt:: Court ci C.:mmon ple::3 or C:.J:'.._:~It'I=nd c':Ju,;;','y, ?snr::::yl'l::r:i::
-
11<'111 OWl r!'" l" ilIulllcnry (JlllllT!(!110
'75.
C/lllll'IIMUY Ulltldl!/II. lnG, .'
~o.
QI\..42l) Cl'1.iJ '1'F.f1:l'
--. ~J..__
:-fOWl
JllnlU'rv 21). ltjCj'i
~,_ I, S~..:" 01 C~~t3I:?.!.A..'m eOt..ii':'"f. PA.. ~tJ
, '
!l~by cique:. l!l.I Shar4 01
flAllpt' i n
c:.m:t1 ~ fo'lll;'.lte ~ Writ,
:!::J Cqlll:= hlAl ::aU " 1!1. nlI'*' :.:G ria of l!:I 'lalA;!!.
.'. I A'*
.;/... '....
~ "... ,;, J
1 ..~.. J;...-4~ /l........~...,i:.
Ad It C_utaAd <:,11II\1'. PI,
.
ASc:laTit of S.rrica
~-,
I'
o' &Iocll
M. 'Q"'..n
.I.C
t!:. ~l.!Ila
'~poQ
l\
,...<11-
~ :udl"I 10
"
npr .t w tritUuJ
"
ud r:wlI iMWII .,
tM u....1I "",mi.
1o&IIIWcn,
1 VI
IMRI tI
c:.ur" 'i,
s.... .... ..~ Wert
.t ~ ,-, .,
com
SDVla
)aLZ.\Ol
AJl'U)A 'w'rr
i
..
- --,
I
,,-
-
f_ ',-,
DOMINICI( PEREZ,
Pla1ntirt
, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
, OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
I PENNSYLVANIA
I
I 95-200 CIVIL TERM
I
I JURY TRIAL OF TWELVE DEMANDED
,
I
v.
WILLIAM STANSFIELD,
W.R. STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION
company and KERRY SUENI(,
Defendants
'RABonl
TO THE PROTHONOTARY'
Plea.e enter our appearance on behalf Of Detendant. wl1l1.~
stan.field and W. R, stan. field construotion Company in the above
captioned matter.
To LAWRENCE E. WE~ER, prothonotary
February 16, 1995
LANDIS, BLACK , IcHOR"
8Y~~~~,
Attorney tor Defendant
.
~
~
~
\~'\ N
~'4'
....
JJ
Ir
.!II. -w.
1'"\", .
i;; "t. ,~
;JJ.' 1.:.1.1'1'.
,..;, r
. 1.
'0
"'. #-
~ "'.,
"5""
1-; ,
'"
..
~
.}
"
~I:
u ~ ~il ~ I
.z 1) :J I
R' III J~
,....
~I ; ~ I ,,~
J
I ! ~ J~fi
01
, . ~~
:1 j u i
, I I III' ~.
h
~ ~
-
~
....
.
'W'~lff" ~U~
P.... H... .1O,',PQiHIQ'
OI~HWII4J,."" 9. .1PfIoI1..V"'UU
~VN.Y or ~VH..~t
.u.u..~.Utlll . """.
-
v
VI.
.UItt.4J.UL,.Il"WM...~
~ 1
'...~ '!\t"".'~' "
_'. 'ft'f'ff, .~. .'&R. ~,y ...." ....,.,".
.&",.~, ...f.. .~ ,~w,'V f.. ,.. w.,.,~
- --
.~ ,~. "V" ,~., ft. ....
".....>1 >I.,.......... " .,.. .JlJIl'''-'j,JI '~'Il ~ "., ,p
J_
..,.._...,....,-,~_.,..,'"~""'._..j,:..n-,., ~.~ .il ..,
~ '.~
..
1ft "I' ..",.,... H. ,.""...
... III'tN"'Y. ..,,".v'.''''''
"... w.. .......,. .. l...... _..' ,.11...,
...,....u.~ .... ,~..Uf "' __.' .lrUtl".
.... ....... '1'1' 1f1"'&1l ..._ ,~IolUd.
.
-
-. ~
..
~,-~ .
"-,!"_"="~,>",,-",,,,,_,",,,,,~"d""
._.:,J:~_~
..-
.... ,1t.u.._,_.U,I.,~l.'lt ~. ."" ...,.. W" I" ,...,..- .f
,,,. ....@..... ,.IY'" f... _.~.~ aaw..y. ..",,'V'V."'.,
."..l"" ~.,~..
".......,,.,
..... (0' "'_M,y
............
...-.A_ . ~....Y
,. ."...,..
.....
....
....
...,..
.-;- h.......'uu.. '''inl.
fl.;.' ,"ANt ........,
@./U/....
.....~ .~ ."....._.. .. ..f." ..
I iJ, ,
-.n,. ._;..+~,:.:.~ ".V .. ."::1- -tll__
'."!-,-<.~!,._',,__1" Itl:.f
,,~="-='-p".t \j~,~~~~'fV- "",i!'~..
CumbCl'lund County, 88:
Tlw (:tJlllllllllIW('.lhh 01 1'('IIlIl)'lvllllia to__.~.r.l'"'~n lIgo. ~oou
{N"", 01 AddldoIlIIOff,Nt.nl\
1.-_
_~~..~~..!l;.C!Y!'r ~\1tII'\UlitI~.r.t.Cl\oIflL..J'^. ...1ZOtL___
.
You illl'lltJtlfjl'lllhdl_.W1!!l!"U~~l!",Ut!.I\t.!tI1!l.W~..JL..1\UNlU'14 CglI\All:UQrl.
(NImI (tl 01 Oe(,ndlnl (t) )
~.",_~.JlI'~~~Y_~'<"'-">.'",",",L=""'_"<1"_"""_'-~ ...,. ""~., .,........'''''_.,,,.......''''>_''''"'',..,, ~......."...,.
hu. (hl\\'I:) jolm'd yuu ill an udditlonal dl'fl'ndant IUlhl. action. which YOIl itre reo
(Iulrrd 10 (Idend.
l>l\II'.HlrdlO. uu._~_"'~~~~"~ .~~..=,~ "'llutl'
p...4I~....."
(1lIAL )
\
:~-
t
~ --4- _"^
8y_a,ieJ.~d~~
Dlplty
ll. ......
.
~,' ~n
It - ,
;f !tJ .'
.~ ~ t
~ '
k ,.. ,
4.
i" /I}'
l ' _,I 4:
it .. . '<I
n.
U~ j'j ~ I
.z 1 :'J I
J ,.
i I I~
~ -
j J
VI ~~ J I~~
I
~ I u i
t , I vl~!.1
J. ~~
l't '"
DOMINICK PIItIZ,
Plaintift
, IN THI COUItT OF COMMON PLlAS
, or CUMBERLAND COUNTY.
I 'INNln.vANJA
'0-200 CIVIL TIRN
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JUlty TRIAL or TWELVI DEMANDED
Y.
WILLIAN ITANIFIILD,
W.R. STANSFIILD CONITRUCTION
COMPANY Ind KERRY SHINIC.
o.t.nd.nt.
Y.
CHARLES C. LOOS. AND
SON, INC.
Addltlon.l D.t.nd.nt
~...n,
AHD NOW COMII the Det.nd.nt., Wll11.. .tan.fl.ld and W. R.
stan.tl.ld Con.truotlon Co.pany. by and throu9h th,lr attorn.y..
L4ndl.. Ilaok , Ichorpp, Who .n.war Plalntlff', Coaplalnt .,
tollowl'
l.-J. Ad.lttld.
4. OInl.d. Att.r r.a.on.bl. Inv..tlQltlon. Det.ndant 1.
without knowl.dq. or lntor.atlon .uttlcl.nt to fo~ . b.ll.t ..
to the truth of th... Iv.r..nt. and the .... ar. thar.tor.
d.nt.d.
I. Dlnlaa.. .tat.d. It 1. b.ll.v.a that Def.nd.nt lC.rry
ah.nk WI' I tra.lnq .upoontrlotor on th. pro'.ot and that h. .ub-
luboontract.d portlon. of the fr,.lnv work to Def.nd,nt w. R.
Stln.rl.ld Con.tructlon cOlp.ny.
t, Detendant W, M, It.n.rt.ld Con.tructlon COlplny w.. the
fr..t", .u~..ubQontr'otor on tn. ..ld oo~.trugtlon proj.ot,
plrtoralnQ port 1 on. ot the fra.lnQ work tor the .aln
.uboontraotor. Klrry 'hlnk.
7. Ad.lttld in.otar a. Detendant. Willia. .tanltllld and
W. R, .tanltield.
'.-9. The averaent. of th..1 paraQr.ph. are dlnled
pur.uant to Pa. R.C.P. Ho. 1029(e).
10.-n.
D.t.ndant..
POPNT l
Th..1 averaentl do not apply to thl In.wlrlnq
coun ~l
'LA'''l'' ,e. .1~LI~ 11AHI.IILQ
14. Thl Iv.ralntl ot thle. plra9raphl ar. dlnild purlulnt
to 'I. R.C.P. Ho. 1029('), Ixoept1n9 ,ploifio dlnial illYlrred
in thl followinQ partloular.,
c. O.f.ndant. Itln.tield dld not allow I pl101 of
oon.truotion .atlrial or .upplie. to f.ll and Itrikl
Plllntitf, on the oontrary, in thl IYlnt thi. h.pp.nld, it
WI' due to thl lotlon. or o.l,.lon. ot other. In oontrol ot
.ald .Itnlall,
I. It 1. d.nlla that Detlnaant. .tanltll1d tlllld to
.Iourl thl bulldlnq .truoturl .,tlri,l or .Upplll" on thl
contr.ry, the .... were under the po.....lon .nd oontrol of
other. .t the job eltl,
r. It 1. dlnled that o.t.P4.nt. ,tln.tleld tilled to
takl propar and adlquat. Itlp. to prlvent the con.truction
matlri.1 or .uppli.. trom f.11inQ .nd .trikinQ Plaintiff. a.
the .... w.r. undlr the control and po.....ion of oth.r. at
thl jOb aitl.
15.-17. Tha avarmlnt. ot th.a. p.raQraph. ara danild
purau.nt to P.. R.O.P. No. 1039(.).
WHEREFORE, Def.ndant d...nd. that Pl.intift'. co.p1aint bl
di..i...d .a to W. R. atan.til1d .nd W. R. Itanlfi.ld
Con.truotion Co.pany.
cpU~ III
'L&I~I" VI. .. ,. 'TJNI'IILD CO,ITRUQTlqM CO~,~
la. Th. avarm.nt. ot th... paraQraph. ar. danied purluant
to P.. R.O.P. No. 1039(.), .xclptlnQ .p.citle d.nial i. av.rr.d
in the t0110winQ p.rticu1arl'
C. D.t.ndant. Stan.ti.ld dld net .llow a pl.e. of
con.truotlon .at.rial or lupp1l.. to fall and Itrlke
Plaintitt, on tha oontrary. ln the av.nt thla happ.n.d. it
wa. due to the action. or oll..lon. ot other a ln oontro1 ot
.aid ..t.rlall'
I. It 1. d.nild that Pat.naant. .tanltl.1d talled to
..ourl the bulldlnQ .tructurl .aterlal or aupp11.., on thl
oontrary, the .... w.re und.r the po.....lon .nd control ot
othlrl at the jOb .ite,
r. It 1. denled that o.I.naantl .t.natleld talll4 to
take proper and adequate .t.p. to prevent the oon.truotion
mat.rial or .uppli.. from tallin9 and .trikin9 Plaintiff. ..
the .am. w.re und.r the oontrol and po.....iun of oth.r, at
the job lite.
19.~21. Thl averment. ot the.. paraqraph. are denied
pur.uant to Pa. R.C.P. No. 1029(8).
WHEREFORE, Detendant. W. R. stan.tield and W. R. Itan.tield
conltruotion company demand that Plaintiff'. complaint bl
diemi...d.
LANDt', BLACK' scHORPP
BY~~
Idwartl L. I horpp, Ilq.
Attorney. for Defendant.
v.
IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
iD-200 CIVIL TERM
JURY TRIAL OF TWELVE DEMANDED
DOMINICK PEREZ,
P1aintitt
WILLIAM STANSFIELD.
W.R. STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY .nd KERRY SIIENK.
Defend.nt.
v.
CIlARLES c. LOOSE AND
SON, INC.
Additional D.rend.nt
OIRTIrIoaT' or .IRYIOI
thereby c.rtity th.t a copV or the rora9oinQ docu.ant,
ANSWER
wa. .arv.d thl. d.ta by dlpo.itln9 .am. ln tha po.t ortioe .t
carli.la, P.nnaVlvania, tirat-olaa. mall, pOlta9a pr.p.id,
.ddr....d .1 tOllow..
Icott W. Mor9an. E.q.
Mor9.n , Mor9.n. P.C.
130 South Stre.t
H.rri.bur9. PA 17101-1al0
Tiaothr 1, H.rk, E.q.
Clldwe 1 , K..rn.
3631 North Front Stre.t
Harrl1bur9, PA 17110-1533
Jaok Sha., r:lq.
Wil.on. Il.ar. MOlkowltl, Idal.an , Dloker
The Curti. canter, suite 130
Ind.pendence Iquar' Wa.t
Phil.delphia, PA 19106
LANDIS, 81~CK , SCKORP'
D.tedl~~ ~I..r~ ~.
..i ;
MOIHlAN" MOMOAN, 1'.(',
IIY: SCOl'1' W, MORClAN.IlSQlllllll
11lI,NTII'Il'ATION NO, ).'JI
120 SOllTII Snlllll'l'
IlAIIMISDllltO. rA \1Io...JlO
(1171 JJ6.m9
Al1'OllNIlVl fIOlll'I.A1NTII'P
~~
"~Jl.__ _.
DOMINICK l'IlIUlI.
l IN 'mil COURT 011 COMMON PUlA"
I CUMDliRI.ANO COUNTY,PliNNA.
l'lalllll(f
II.
.
.
l NO, II',~OO CIVil,
WI\.l.IAM ST^NSI1IliLO.
W, N, STANsrllil.O CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and KHMRY SIIIlNK.
Dof,ndantt
l
l CIVil. ACTION. tAW
,
.
l JURY TRIAL. Of' 'Iwm,vn Uf.MANDIlP
II,
C\lARUi.. C, l.OO5R ANO BON, INC..
Additional Dof,lIdInl
'I.AINTIff'fI MUI'ONIII Tn
.
~
I'laIIll11', by bit aIWfrwy.. M()tpl\ A M()tpA, '.c..lIfr.., .. """
why Additional o.(,ndalll', Multi 141 81k1W fIlUM lhniIld fIllC bf madf IbtPIVIf,
I. On November l. 1m. t\(Hl{lfabltl I, We.lfy (}Iff 1ttUf4 a.. Ilttwftlblt
10 I'lalnlift lO.how"1IM why Addilklllll Utf,,*IlI" l>1t<<lVffY M{ifKIII ~ fIllC"
.rlllled,
2, On (If Ibout ()~.., :.. ,~, 11ft,,,. thI Mu" .... ktw4, .....'ff
PfOVldr4 Mlitlooi! 0.",.,.. ..1m AIM"'" 10 '1IIIf"'PlOfllft.
), (~IJI ~ 11<<.. '0, 1W6. I'WMitt .,~!J<<4 ~ o.flMJM
wWl AI\t-'ft 10 IC4lfKtf W, ff.'~J
Ii-
~
koIl W. Mo,..n, 81q1l1r. '11"1 lllat '" II c:oIIlllfl ot tf<<)l'd tor PI,lnllff In Ihf
wllhln II:lkm. II Illlhurlnd 10 lIk. Ihil V.rlnc.lion on hie bthalt, .nd lllal tho 111""""11
mIdf In Iht tor,,,,ln. MelponM 10 pitc(wtry Million ot Ad4l1ional Dtf.ndanllf. tnIf Ind
",If'"t IU I'" ,*1 or hie know ltd... Inr"'lnIlion Ind twlllf, II. llndtnllnde Ihlll'"
'11"""1111 In Mid ploadlll,lf. n1Idt lubjKllO IlIo ptn.hlte of \I rat C,li.A. 141104. rolillllJ
MlllMworn fallll'lelllon 10 avlhothl...
I, 5eot1 W, Mar..n, r.aqulre, hereby ccrlify "'at aervlco o( a tflll and corrccl
~lpy gt Iht within Plllntlfr. Rt.ponaa 10 DllOOver)' MOllon or Additional Dcfondanllooae
wI' fnadf OlIll1lt .....J.f../:;.. day of Novomber, 199', 10 lho pertOn, below named, b)' flnl
('\all Unlltd SIA", Mill. I'O'IA&O prrpald.
lIonorablo J. W..I.)' Oler
Cumberland COlInl)' Counhou..
0", Cwrlhoutt Squaro
ClIlble. JI,\ 1101)
John ShII, llaqulre
Tht Curll, C'/IlIr. SIf. 130 r...t
lndfpfndlnce Squar. W,.I
Phlladelphla.l'^ 111106
Timothy Mlrk. elqulro
)631 twrlll fronl Slmt
Illtfilbur..I'A 17110
fAwlf4 8chotpp. fitqulr.
J6 South lItnlWft 51rH!
Catllilt. PA 1701)
,/,.rrt;'""
MOAeAN A MOROAN. P,C.
>' ~
'-it;;. """'-',_v_.
, . t'..tllU
no ~ 511 l.. ._,4'"
.IM,...I'A l?IOI.IlIO
mYJ :.)6.19.111
AMw.)" ({It rlil.lff. 0, ......
Ii
r
-'
DOMINICK PBRII,
plaintift
IN THB COURT or COMMON PLIAS or
CUMBIRLAND COUNTY, PBNNSYLVANIA
v.
WILLIAM STANSrIILD,
W.R. STANsrIBLD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and KIRRY SHENK,
O.t.ndant.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
CHARLBS C. LOCSI ANO SON,
INC. ,
Additlonal o.t.ndant
NO. 91-300 CIVIL T.~
Ql'Q,:., 9" ~OI1R"
AND NOW, thl. ,~~ day ot F.bruary, 1996, upon oonlld.ration
ot the attaoh,d P.tition ot Additional Olt.ndant CharI.. c. Loo..
and 80n, Ino. for L.av. to Join B.nohllllrk Ho..., Ino. a. an
Addition.l O.tendant, a RULI i. hlrlby i..uld upon the Plaintiff
and Olt.ndant. to .how a.u.. why the rllllf r.qu..t.d ahould not b.
CJunt.d.
RULI r.turnabl. within 20 day. of ..tvia..
aY THI COURT.
loott W. Mor,an, I.q.
120 'outh Itrlat
"arriabur" 'A 17101.1210
Tiaothy I. Mark, .aq.
3631 North Front 'tr..t
Harriaburtl 'A 17110.1t3J
Idward L. 'ohorpp. I.q.
3. 'outh Manovar 'trllt
Carli.la, fA 1101)
I'
,'"
D,rnd a. Hein.e, I.q.
John o. She., S.q.
The Curti. Center
Buit. 830 But
Indep.nd.no. Square W..t
Philadelphia, PA 19106
Attorneye tor Additional
D.tendant Charl.. C. Lao..
and 80n, Ino.
Iro
C'1t44.. J1t,~ I..J.
,A/I"I" .
..4 r.
il
i'
'I
"
Ii
III "Ir.ION. Ir...., ICOnOWITI, It)luwr .. PICX..
I BY, Bnnd G, Hlinu, llquir, Attorney. for Additional
! John D. Sh.a. a,quire Derendant Charle. C.
IIIOBNTIVlCATION NO. 40670/746017 Loo.e and 80n, Ina.
'I TltK CURTIS CINTKR . SUITI 830 BAST
IlNOBPIlNDBNCR SQUARR WIST
I PIULADBLPJlIA, VA 19106
I (215) 627-6900
II DOMINICK PSRIZ
il
"
[I
! WII.LIAM ITAN8VULD.
i "', It. 8TAN&rIILD CONSTRUCTION
: COMPANY and KllRY SHINK,
.1 Defend.nt.,
n
Ii
II
~
,-'"
".'1'
)1
r'
i i
Plaintiff.
IN THI COURT or COMMON
PLW or CUMBIRl.AN1)
COUNTY. PINN8YLVANIA
v.
'5-200 CIVIL TIRM
CIVIL ACTION - LA"
v.
Ii
il CltAALU C. r..008. AND iON. INC.
ii AdcUtional perendant.
I'
Ii
JURY TRIAL or TWlu.v1
DIMANDIP
II PU.. O~ cwu
II
il AND NOM. thi. My ot rebruary, Uti, upon
!I con,idlrat~on or A4d~tional Derend.nt, Charle. C. Loo.. .nd 'on,
~ Inc.'. 'tt~tion ror L.av. or Court to Join Additional Deftndant
~ Benchmark Home., Ino.. a lul, i, horeby I.8UIO upon 'laintiff to .how
,I
!I cau.e why tht r~lier requ..tod 1n tho motion ,hould not be grant.d.
li
il
!I
II
11
;i
"
lULl RITURHAlLI 20 day. afttr ..rvie..
IY TN' COUlT I
[i
\1
)i
~.
! '.rnd O. >>-in.., '.qu~r.
. John D. 'h.., I.quirt
Th. CUrti, Ceot.r. 'uite ')0 '..t
Indeptn4tnct 'quart Wilt
Phila4tlpbia, PA 1910'
Attorn.y. fOf Ad4itlonal Dtt.n4Int
Chu1.. C, ~. .net .on, lno,
_to:... h"'" ~;'.(1W1I1 .1.>1\....... (m.,ll . 'n, (I""" C:tlllftft . lUlU 1)0 U"
....,.,..""'10('. t<iV.'" Wl'U' . ,..'" Al>hm.,..... ..,ot
I
I
,
I
II WILSON, ILSla, MOSlOWITl, RPILNAN . DICllR
I ny, Bernd a. Heinle, I,quire Attorn,y. tor Additional
John D. Shea, I,quire Oetendant Charle. C.
IDENTIPICATION NO. 40670/74627 Loo.e and Son, Ino.
TIIB CURTIS CINTJl:R . SUITS 830 lAST
INDBVKh~Jl:NCR BOUARI WEST
VIlILADRLPIIIA, VA 19106
(215) 627.6!l00
~
,
Ii DOMINICK
"
Ii
"
"
I[
:1
PIRRZ
Pl.intUr,
V,
i WILLIAM ITAN8rIlLD,
i W, R. STANSPIBLD CONSTRUCTION
" COMPANY and KllltRV "IINIt,
II Det.ndant.,
I
V.
i)
II CHAR LIS C. LOOSI AND ION, INe.
Additional D.tendant.
it
ORDIR
.It
n tl'"
"
j,
. IN TaR COURT or C~N
. PLIAS or CUMBBRLAND
. COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
.
.
. 95.200 CIVIL TI~
.
.
. CIVIL ACTION . LAW
.
.
.
. JURY TRIAL or TIfILVI
. DIMAHDID
II
,I
Ii
II AND HOW, thll day ot I 1ItI, upon
llcon.ideration or Additional D.rendant Charle. C. Loo.. and .on,
d
,
I Inc,'. Vetition tor Le.ve to Join Benchmark Home., Ino, " an
ii
IIAdditionAl Derendant, it 1, h.reby ORDIRID and DBCRIID that .aid
!i
:I~.tition 1. QRANTKD and that Additional D,tendant Charl.. C,
ii
I: 1.00.. and 80n, Ine. 1. Permitted Leavo at court to Join Benchmark
IlIomo., Ino. II Mditional Derendant..
li
::
IV TUI COllaT.
.,.
~K"" H"A MfltllJWlfl, U1tlt.4A."" 1"(ltll . I'" (Imll' (tljltlll . tl,ltlllnll''''''
....j.l'tllWt"'. '<WAN wu' . 11'>"'.(1...........,.... ",('*
.
--
"
WILSON, .LSla, MOSkOWITZ, IDILMAN . DICk..
BYl bernd O. Heinze, Bsquire Attorney. ror Additional
John D. Shea, lequire Detendant Charl.. C,
I IDINTIFICATION NO. 40670/74627 Laos. and Son, Ino.
THB CURTIS CINTBR . SUITB 830 BAST
I INDBPBNDBNCB 80UMB WIST
'I'! PHILADBLPHIA, PA 19106
! (215) 6:17'6900
il
n
" DOMINICK PBRBZ
:i
Pldnt1tt,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
IN THB COURT OF COMMON
PLBAS OF CUMBBRLAND
COUWrY, PBNNSYLVANIA
v.
WILLIAM STANSFIBLD,
W.R. STANSFIBLD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and KBRRY SHINK,
D.hndant.,
95-200 CIVIL TBRM
CIVIL ACTION . LAW
,
,
v.
'i
: CIIARLBS C. LOOSB AND SON, INC.
Additional Defendant.
JURY TRIAL OF TWBLVa
DEMANDBD
,!
Ii
;j
I'
I
II
II
I,
,/ Additional detendant, Charl.. C. Loose and Son,
I
al.o r.rerr'd to as "Petitioning Detendant"), by and
"TITION 0' ADDITIONAL D.rINDAHT CHAIL.S C.
LOO'. ANJ) SON, INC. ,oa LIAVI TO JOIN
IDlCIlUUIr HOIm,_ nlC:. All ~ ~PITIOHAL D.rRNnAH'!'
Inc. (hereinafter
through it.
attorney., Willon, Ilser, HO.Kowitz, Kdelman , Dicker, hereby .ubmit
the within Petition for Le.ve ot Court to Join benchmark Home., Inc.
(hereinatter t.terred to a. "Benchmark") AI an additional dlfendant
pursuant to Rull 2213 of thl Pennsylvania Rulel ot Civil Procedure
and, in support thlrlot aver thl followingl
1. On or abOut January 13, 199', plaintitf D~inick 'ere. tiled
. plreonal injury civll action c~laint again.t defendant. willi..
w'\&O" 11"'11I ~1I'"OWHI, H'II~A" .. o",u.. . lilt ["..,." """l! . l\l'" 1I)(l,A'!
Ifd>tl't"".'f(:' !l()\,AIl' w..! . ...tI\Alih............... "IOlil
A
StanSfield, W.R. Stan.field Con.truction Company and Kerry Shenk. A
true and correct copy of plaintiff's complaint i. attached hereto and
incorporated herein as Bxhibit "A."
2. Plaintiff" complaint a..ert., ~nte~ alLA, that on or about
II August 17. 1993, plaintiH .urtered an injury.. a re.ult of baing
iI
'I struck on the head and face by a large piece of con.truction material
I
,i which fell or was dropped trom an elevated height in the building in
which the plaintiff was working.
3. Plaintiff', complaint allege., ~qt., alLA, the injurie. were
'I Butfered .. a re.ult of the negligence. carelellne.. and reckl.llne..
! or the defendant., individually, jointly and/or IOverally.
:!
II 4. The plaintifr dld not name Petitioning Derendant Charles C.
,I
r Loos. and Oon, Inc. A. an original deC.ndant.
I
;
:1 5. On or about March 6, un, original defendant. William
I
II StansCield and W.R. Stan,ri.ld Con.tructlon Company Clled a Writ to
il
II Join Additional D'C.ndant Charles C. Loo.e and Son, Inc.
!i
!,
"
'I
i ~
6. On or about April 5, 1995, original derendante William
I Stansrield, and W.R. Itan.ri.ld Conltruction Company riled. joinder
complaint naming Charl.. C. Loa'. and Son, Inc. a. an addition.l
dOfendant. A tru. and correct copy oC the jOinder c~laint i.
attached h.r.to and incorpor.t.a herein al Jxhlbit 'a.'
.~.
w.ltll.. """. ~O'HI'NI". fllHM...... '''Ut" . "'. c......, 0.."" , "\1I1t uo tAli
,1I0t,..1I0t..<:t to\I"'''' WI" . ""I...jJf\,.'....., M "llMi
~
7. On or
, Answer Together
about May J, 1995, Petitioning Defendant
With New Matter and Cro...Claim.
f Ued an
8. On or about July 10, 1995, Petitioning Detendant .erved
Interrogatorie., Bxpert Interrogatorie. and Reque.t. tor Production of
Document. on plaintift.
9. On or about October 4, 1995, plaintitt provided veritied
'i answer. to Petitioning Detendant'. Bxpert Interrogatorie..
I
Ii
ii
i:
'1 10. On or about October 26, 1995, plaintitt provided veritied
1I anlwer. to Petitioning Detendant'. Interrogatorie..
"
i\
il
ii 11. On or about November 13, 1995 and November 17, 1U5,
"
II plaintitt provid.d docum8nt. re.pon.ive to petitioning Detendant'.
II Reque.t tor Production ot Document..
II
:1 12. Upon turther invenigation by Petitioning detendant
'ICharl.. C. Loo.e .nd Son, it ha. been determined that plaintift'.
I, injurie. were .uttered while working for a plumbing .ubcontractor at
~ the conltruction lite.
II
"
Ii
Ii
II u. Petitionin" Defendant allo learned that Benchmark Kom..,
Inc. wa. the Oenera1 Contr.ctor at the con.truction .ite where
plaintiff .11e".. he wa. injured.
.J.
~lOflf, """, u()'.O\IlIlII, 'OllM"N' {)o(,.'" . ,,,. CllfI',' ("",,, . tutti no "'''
fJW"1NO'Hf.I '(IV"'" W", . "m"I>>I""","" IIlOt
Ii
II
,
,
II
: that an employee or Benchmark Homes, tnc. Wile prosent at the
I construction .ite on Augu.t 17, 1993, the date or plaintirr'. alleged
I, injuries, punuant to an order and delivery request ror rooHng
II tru.... plac.d with Petitioning Oehndant by Benchmark 110m.., tnc. ^
Ii true and correct copy or the invoice ror the rooHng tru..e.
il
Ii indicating the purch..er AI Benchmark Home., tnc. i. attached hereto
,I
I and incorporated herein a. Bxhibit 'C.'
14.
Upon inro~tion and belier, Petitioning Derendant believes
"
15.
A. a re.ult or all the roregoing, and additional tact. and
,
I,
: circumatance. which may become evident and relevant during the courle
ot continued pretrial dilcov,ry and inve.tigation, the action. and/or
Ii inaction. oe the propolld additional der.ndant Benchmark Home., tnc.
i!
, either cau..d, .ub.tantially contribut.d to or w.re re.pon.ible ror
H
:; the injuria., damag.. or 10.... .et rorth in plaintifr', complaint.
"
Ii
Ii
~ 16. R.aeonabl. jUltirication exi.t. ror thie late joinder a.
:1
'I Petitioning Oer.ndante only r.c.ntly di.cov.red the r.levant
,
"
'i documentation .ubetantiating that Benchmark Home., Inc. WAl the
:I
!Igeneral contractor ror th. conetruction aite at which plaintiff
~.llegedly .ure.red hi. injurie..
17, The propo..d additional defendant will not be prljudic. by a
joinder at thil point ae dilcovery il in ite infancy and, a. a re.ult,
, the propo.ed additional defendant will have a full and complete
opportunity to enter thi. action and participate in all a.pect. or the
...
W'IIO..., Ill'" MOl' ()WtI I, toll~A"" Of('lll . 11I1 (:11'11I,1 tlll/"" , IIl'It UQ 'd'
lfol.>'I'f"'OI/<j(,' IOUA'" willI . ",,1\ AOll""A, "" "'06
.
litigation and discovery pursuant to the Psnnsylvania Rules o~ civil
Procedure.
18. Joinder of the propo.ed additional defendant at this time
will avoid circuity of action, will .erve the intereet or justice by
allowing for the efficient litigation of all the claim. ari.ing out of
plaintiff', injurie., will con.erve jUdicial time and other re.ource.,
1\ and will promote the po.eibility or amicably resolving all claims.
"
I
,
,
II
II 19.
I,
!! pursuant
There exist. ,ufficient cause to justify the late joinder
to Penn.ylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 2253.
Ii
;1
ij
:1 20. petitioning Defendant'. propo.ed joinder complaint against
Ii Benchmark Home., Inc. i. attached hereto, made part hereof and
I
I
I incorporated herein.. Bxhibit 00.0
I 21. In the event it is determined that propO'ld .dditional
,
I
, defendant Benchmark Home., Inc. acted negligently, c.rlle,.ly,
reckles.ly and without due c.re in accordance with their contractual,
Itatutory and common law dutie. and re.ponsibilities with respect to
the accident a. all.ged in plaintiff's complaint, then proposed
additional defendant Benchmark 110m", Inc. would bo liable over to
P.titioning Oot.ndant for contribution and/or indemnification.
WHIR.VORI, in light of the foregoing and as .et forth in the
attached ~rand~ of law, Petitioning Defendant Charl.. C. Loc'e and
.1-
w,,'()~, ""fI. MQlKOWtll. HltlMA~ . lI'('O'" . IH' (:v'".. (I~"" . 'Vi" 1'0 'All
IIIIO.,""'OIN" .nUA'" Wl" . 1'I'"AOIl"'flA."" ',,/.Ill
'i
Ii
,[
il
Ii
I!
Illlon. Inc. hClUby r.qu..tll th!. 1I0nor_blll Court grant llAv. to tUe ·
u joinder complaint .IJain.t t.he propo..d IIddltiona1 d.t.nd.nt lJ.nchtMrk
i ~
1!lIomO., Ina.
I
II
\1
!l
II
\,
:1
I
II
:i
,
Illlp.CChlUy .ubfll1tUcS,
"U.lO" , ILl III , MO,ICOWITI,
IOIUHAH . OlCKIR
1)'1
,
,
;j
:i
ii
l;
i!
ii
Ii
1I
ii
Ii
"
"
!
I
~'b~A'. -
r 0, . n.t, "q\I f'
oM 0, 'hd, ..quir.
Atcorn.y. fO~ Additional aefendant
Cblrl.. C, Loo,' 104 'on, Ino.
n
I,
n
Ii
!
~
"
1
'.'
W\..-!I<t "W. w~j''''''''1 .W,IIU'" ~H. . '.. t,4l"i! fit,,'.. · ...... ",.H~I
......HIIot>'...,. ~1't'''' ...H' . "'"',,'.,....... Hi "''''
I
~
" -, . >
, .,..,,' I' 'd
\If
,., ,".
MOItClAN A MOItOAN.I',c,
UY; SC01'T W, MOROAN. 'iSQVlIUI
llJIlNTIt'ICATION NO, '6121
1:0 ~O\JTII STIH/Ill
IlAJUUSBURO. f'A "101-1110
(1\1) U6-m'
ATTO~BY'PORrL^'NnPP
..... '...., .'J
DOMINICK PEREZ
201 Mulb'lT)' Drlv.
lIarrlabur,.I'A,
: IN TUB COURT Of COMMON PLEAS
I CUMDBRLAND COUNTY, PENNA.
1
I NO.
PI,lntiff
v.
.
.
: CIVIL ACTION . LAW
WILUAM STANSfIELD
3672 Sprln, Road
Carllll.. PA 17013.8704
and
.
.
: 1URY TlUAL 01' 1WBLVB DBMANDED
I
I
I
,
. .
W, It STANSfIELD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY I
3612 Sprln. Road I
Carllll., PA 17013
I
alllt I
KERRY SHENK I
30M Ro.. Av.nuI I
N.w Cumberland. PA 17070. I
O.f.ndanu I
~
PI.lntlft, by and IItroulh hi, IllOtlll)", Motpn " Morlan, P.C.,ll.reb)'
. .
cotnplaln.t ."hUl Dtrcndlnll and ....m II tollow.:
1. PlJIllllt,i, an ~~ll h14lv14v.' realdln"1 1M Jboy. t4drcu,
2, o.fefldanl i. 11l14vlt irn,lividl,lJl '.I14\IlIII W .1>0.... al!4ffU. .nd opofallf\1
. \11.1\11\4111 ~/l(fwn .. W. It S1i\lllfjeld ('.,rnlfllctKH\ Cumpany.. Iii, ablW. .dlllen,
f" .- , " ' .. " v...,......,.
. ~ ..., .. T ... ~ .., '.. - I.... .. .. .,.......
.. '.f..... ".,,' _l r",' 1"1 oJ'i : .-. Ii"" j"''' "\ I ,-... " I "..",- "1" ""f' ./,' .,... '
.,.,'/ ~ \~,J..,.\o,\..."..,.~,~,.",~,t'."'.f,,'"''.'.~I''''' II ..,t'.'\''! '.-; """~ "'''''.~\ "''''f,''*'r.,',,;It.. "",,""1"''./)
1!, " " .. ..' '" "'.,. ,.". I . t I ,~ " f l' I ~ t ','" I 1..1; \-:.,-. " I' ,'"." , .., , ." II! , ( 'I 'I<" i. ". *,." "
I' f, '. j" ',I~ " . ',' .," .' ',,' "j , :' f I ,'I "J
, '.. 'I '
S. De~1ldInI Sb,;i11 LI In adllh 'nd'vtdf ,..!dial at Ib.t ~ ad4ttM, '
.. Pll 01 aMUI AlIf\ltl 17, 10t.J, PlaIlU WU WOItUIt" I plllDlblllllll1Nm
to, C"IAMI,ulht ItIoon HIU ooNlIUO\lon ptoJeoI 0 UNklla Road III N.w Cumllwlwl,
,
~VMla.
., Dttu4a.aI x.ny IMIlIc WM ovtrHt . tht OONIU\ICdot p~ OQ wtIkIIa
PI&ldtfwu ~'11.
t. C.ftMulI WUl,*- ....tIeld IA4
.
a. 'lINt1a14 COn.nl'UOUOR ~
proJIQC.
..
'lWn.1d and W. R. 'lWniW
,
~
WI till tnIIllIIlIIbcJ lIIdWllllOn OIl 11M MId
" TIlt ~a., kmy 'heNc, Wll1
~ ~..... all dmtt....nll tltrt
....1lIt Ur4JfII emplO)'Ml wtthla Ill. COllIN UJS lOOP'
.. At ~llIllfaly l:J p.lII. 011 Auawl
.
au ~ ,lit ... atnIOk on the bM4 INS tw by alarp ltOI'ot ~ awWldlG -.1
,
Of wu ..... ftom II tllVU04 Iltl.lhC Oft eM bllfl4lna 1ft "lob PI&bldft'.... .malllt.
p, 1\6 1414 IOGldtA, "' ... 10 Iht ..I . cwtl...1lNI ud ~
,
Il\lllvldually or Ibrovp .,.au.
f lIltlr "'110)' ot tm,IO)'ft\tI\t
7,1903, PI&1adff, tt411.Iaw&l1y OQ
.
or ~.", 1IdMdlaaJ11, JoIIdy u4JOI NVtI'IJ1y an4
.
PI&Indtt, .. wtU be mart May lit Ilnb klOw.
1nJ\II''-' and daIa.." to
r.auw
'~'~
..
.. aUt,adOlt 01,.,..,.,.. J
w.p,..w......It..
. "".
. "
.
~ I. ~... '. .'
.,. ",
'I' .
1 L Thll nc.llacrwt. carclcn"ou and rcckJcuncu a( OofomlOnl. Irwluded:
A. l1allln, 10 b'p a proper lookout;
D. Pall In, 10 warn PfUOI\J luch AI Plaintiff of /In
unrtuonabla risk of hum from tllelr conduct:
C. Allowln, a pleco of corull'Uctlon malOrlal or '1.11'1'11"
10 fall and .lrlk. Plalntlffj
D, falllllJ 10 uercba prop.r cart In tho JIOrform.1lCt of
work dull" II tII. dall and 11m. aU'IIe<<! h.r.lnj
B. 'allln,1O taU proper '101" to mur. &he bulldlllJ
atnlCNr. material Of ,uppUtI that r,lI and .tnlCk Plalnllft;
P. Fallin, 10 taU propef and adeqUIlt 'lOp.1O prtvtnt
tht CONlMUon material or ,upplle. from fallin, and IllllclllJ
Plaintiff.
12, ^' a mult ot Off.ndant', misconduct, Plaintiff ,u<<,rtd ."'.,. and
dllabllnllnjurltl,lncludln. but not limited 10, lnjurltllO hll Mrvtl, !>onei, mIllCI.., jol""
and fucla, pain and .uft.,IIlJ, manlal and .motlonal dull'.... .oint or all of whldl arl or may
1;0 contlnuln,ln naM..
13. A' a ,..ult of hi. Injurl... Plaintiff Incumd medical bill. and '.INN" for
cau, uutm.nl .nd r.habllllltlon, 100t wni,.,. and/or .untn, capacitY alld .uft.red loa. or
life', pl.yyrn and diminution orM, dally "livid.., whleh .,. or may "00"1111II1"11"
IJ.tlll' .
.
,. ".'! '".'
~ '
Wlll!REI'ORIl.I'laimiff demandl Judlllncnt aealnst Defendant, Individually,
jointly and/or sevofally,ln an alnountln O.lteen of $2$,OOO.OO.nelullvo of lnterost, COlt.t and
dela)' dama.... '
CQUW'Jl
14. Plalndff Incorporllet herein by r,(,ronet tho allo,atloN of pll"r.ph. I
WOIllh , II If fully lOt forth at I.nath.
". Th. Malla'nce, car.le.unoll and reckJ...nw of D.f,ndant, Included:
A. fallin, to keep a pro,.r lookout:
8. PaUl1lI to warn peraol\l .uch u Plalndft or an
ulU'WOnabl. rlak of harm from their conduclj
C. Allowln, i pleco or CONU'IIetlon material or .upplltl
to r.1\ and .ulk. Plaintiff:
D. fallln.to .mclao proptr ell. In the performance of
work dud.. at tho dale and time all'aed herein:
B, rllUn, to tab proper .tep. to ..cur. thl buildln,
Jtructur, material or lupplles that (.U and 'If\Ick Plalntl(f:
P. faUlnalO lib pr(lper .nd adequate .ltp' to prevent
tb4 COMU'l)(lion /Il,I.lRrl.ll or 'U9Pl~. (rom tllJlJl,1Ild 'Illkl",
A"bll)ll{f:
. .
16. ^* 0 result of Defendant's milconduct. Plaintiff su(fmd severe and
dil:lbllnll inJutic., including bUI notllmhcd to. Injuries to hi. nerves, bone.. mu.clel. Jolnt$
and (lUcia, pain .nd suffering. menlal and emolloMI dl.lleu, lome or .11 of which arc or m.y
be comlnulnB In nature,
17. A. I result of hlllnJurlc., Plllntlff Incurred medical bill. Ind expeNes for
care. treatment and rohabllltatlon, 10.1 carnlna1lnd/or earnln, capaehy Ind auffered lOll of
life'. pleasures and dimInution of hts dilly ACllvltlu, which arc or mlY be contlnulna In
nalure.
WHERBPORB, Plaintiff demand. Jud,menll,alllll Pof'ndUll.lndlvldually,
Jointly andlor levenlly, In an amounlln exeoll of S2',OOO.OO,elcIUllvl of Inlefeal, CO&lIlnd
dclay damagu, ,
CQUW:.lll
18. Plaintiff Incorporales heroin by rer.renee the .1I0,lllolll of para,raphll
Ihrou,h 9 u If fully 101 fonh Illenath,
19. Tho lIOallaenco, CAfeleuneSl .nd reckleuncu of De(endanl,llICludld:
A. Fallin. to keep a proper lookout;
D. Pllllnlto warn penons .uch .. Plllntlff of In
ulIlcuonablo dale IJ( harm from their conduct:
C. Allowln,. 1'1<<0 o(collJlrUClton mmri.al or 'UW1iel
to Wllnd .ttib PI.iIltiff;
. .
I), Pnilinlllo uerclse proper cnro in Ihe performance of
work dulles at the dale nnd lime alleged herelnj
H. Failing to take proper Itepsto secure ,!he building
structure material Or supplies !hat fell and struck Plalntlffi
P. Palling to ,tako proper and adequato .top. to provent
tho construction matorlal or lupplles from falling and striking
Plaintiff,
20. As. result of Defendant'. ml.conduct, Plaintiff suffered .overo and
dlsabllnglnjurle., Including but not limited 10, InJurlo. 10 his neNCI, bonCl, mUICICI, Jolnll
and fascia, pain and suf(erln" mental and emotional dlllrell, some or all of which are or may
be continuing In nature.
,
21. As a relult of hll InJurlcll Plaintifr Incurred medical bill. and expenlCl (or
ClIe, treatment.nd rehabllh.tion,loJl wnlng. and/or wnln. capacity and suffered lOll of
life's pleasuru and diminution of hla dally actlvitlea. which aro or may be contlnulna1n
nature.
WHBREPOIUl, Plaintiff demanda Judgment .,alllll Defendant, Individually,
Jointly andlor .everally, In an amount In exec.. of S25,OOO.OO,exclualvo of lntcrClt, cosu and
delay damalloa.
TRUE COf'Y FROM RtCORD
In Tutimony whoroc', I hero unto ,,' my liar..!
.n~ the sui Qf.-,Id Coml .1 ,.,'hlt, P..
;~'I..!J",~, dcy o,~".."...," \fir.
, ~Qf.~t......~~~~;:y.~
MOROAN" MOROAN, P.C.
PATEl):
~, \ l __IY~
,
YI!~IFICA 1'ION
Dominick rere~ SlAleS that he la Plaintiff In this malter. and that the ItAtemenLl
made in the foregolns Complalnl aro true and corrCCl1O the best of his knowledgc.
informalion and belief. He understands thai the ItalernenlS In said pleading arc made .ubJecl
10 the penalties of 18 Pa. C,S.A. '4904. relallnSlo unsworn fal.tneatlon to authorities.
~~~~c~rp?-
.
. .
i
CD
,......
DOMINICI< PEREZ,
plaintiff
I IN TilE COURT or COMMON PLEA/J
I OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
I PENNSYLVANIA
I
I 9D-200 CIVIL TERM
I
I CIVIL ACTION . LAW
I
I JURY TRIAL OF TWILVE DEMANDED
I
I
I
I
I
I
V.
WILLIAM STANSFIELD,
W.R. STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and l<ERRY SHENI<,
Defendant.
V.
CHARLES C. LOOSE AND
SON, INC.
Additional Defendant
CQKP.LAI~T OF WILLI~ 8TAN8.I.~Q AND
.. .. .'AMsrilLD CONST.UCTI9~ COHtlNY. DI~INDAX!'
XL.
Q~~LIS c. LOOSS AND BON. INO. ADDlTIONAL DlrIKO~
Defendant., william stan.rield and w. R. stan.rield
con.truotion company, by and throuqh th.ir attorney., Landi.,
BlaCK . Sohorpp, hereby a..ert the rollowing coaplaint avainlt
Additional Detendant, CharI.' C, LoO'. and Bon, 1nol
1. Detendant William stan.field ie an adult individual
r.eiding at 3672 Spring Road, carli.l., Penn,ylvania.
2, Detendant W. n. Stanerield Conetruction company 1. ·
.ole proprietor.hip owned by William stanerield with ottic.. at
3672 Spring Road, carli.le, renn.ylvania.
3. Additional DotenJant CharI.. C. Loo.. and .on, IftO, i'
a corporation doin9 buein... in pennaylvania with I prinoi"l
ottloe at '0 w..t stoever Av.nue, "yer.town, ~b'non county,
rennlylvlnl. 11061.
4. Thuo h attAohod honto .. luchibit "A" And
incorporated heroin by ror.rono., a true copy ot a Complaint
tl10d by Dominiak roro., Plaintift A9alnet Willia. stan.tl.ld, W.
R. ItanlfL.ld Con,truotlon CompAny And ~.rry 'honk, Def.naani',
" At tho ti.., data and plac. all'90a 1n Plalntift'.
complaint, th. Defondant wa. tho own.r ot a oranG utili'ld at tho
job .It. tor tho purpo.. of hol.tin9 woodon root tru.... into
pOAltlon on a r..ta.ntia1 9Ar19. undor conetruction.
" At tho til" dlte and pile. .11'gea ln Plalntlff'_
cOMplAint, th. operAtor of ..1d crane w.. an agent, e.rvant
and/or ..ployo. ot Additlonal Defendant, and he Acted at all
~i... .at.rtll heroto withln tho oour.. and ecop. ot hie a9.noy
or ..ploya.nt wlth Additional Oefondant.
1. At .a14 tl.e and pliO., Additional Oofenaant'. oranG
op.r.tor hoi'tt4 . woodIn true. over the VArAO., which tru.. ~a.
ultl..t.ly to bl ..our.a in plao, by Det.ndant WilliaM Itan.field
and hi, oth.r ..pIQye.. worklnq on the 11t"
I. At ..i4 tl.. and pliO', Additional OIf.n4Iht'. op.r.tor
r,I..,.4 .,i4 v~od.n truI. fro. the grane oabl. b,for. .Iid
vv.r.tQf g~l.rvI4 ana a.@lrtainla that OIfendant .tan,fi_14 and
hl_ l.ploY.I. hi. "OYf~ ln4/or .ttbill,la ..id tru.. in
f.@1f H: hm.
~. At .aid tl,* .nd pl.o., ~ition.l Def.na.nt'. op.rator
ala in f.Qt '.1.... If~ t~ Qr.~ Q.'le in. ~o04.n tr~'1 prior
tQ tn. tr~" *'.IWil M1I41.4 1M/OJ o\~","l.. f"\U'414 kiy 0.1.1I41nt
!i\,.".nei4 a!'i4 M- ..,l~'f""
10. To tho Iktent that the acold.nt d..orlbea ln
l'lAlntUf'1 COllplAint occurred, And it ..id Plalntiff ree.lved
Anv 1njuri.. a. ..t forth 1n .ald COllplaint, .aid 1njurl" And
r.,ultln, da..,.. ar. thl .01. r..ult of the "e'119.nol of the
"(!tHUona! Detendant. The n.qUlIeno. ot the Addlt.1onal Detlndant
(\00,1Ited ~t thl toll ow In\l1
A, In nl,11\1lntly, rlokle..ly and olrel,..ly
r.l.l.in9 troll thl orAn. cAbl. ,upport thl wood.n tru..
whioh ulti.ltlly atruok PlAintiff, be for' prop.rly
..0.r'llnlnq And conflraSnlJ thAt the tru.. hAd b.en ..cur'd
or .t.bi11..a by Dltend.nt 'tln.fl'ld And ht. ..ploy...,
D. In tal11n9 to proplrly ob..rv. the work 1" proo...
And tn r'l.a.tnq "td tru.. betore It va, prop.rlY ..oured
or .tabiU..d,
c, In n..ltllantly rele.,int ..1d voodln tru.. troll
the or.n. gable wlthout tlr.t hAVlnt rlo.1Yld . .1'''11 or
O""f lmUoAUon froll o.t.l\dl"t 'unIU'ld or hhl ..ploy...
tha' .ald truI. VI' .loort4 Of .tAblll..d tn pl.o.,
P, In IAtll", to u.. 4u. eaf. un4.r th.
QlrOIJ..'UIHHUlf
I, tn t.lll~ to '.llvv tn. YIUAl Ana ~ult~lry
,...tv "..,4Y'" lor h@l.Urtq 1M 1f"\1", wOM.n tfU....
At . qfnttf\lQtion lit., .n4
r, In ,.1&'", '9 foll.w .11 &.wt~l r,,~l.'l.A4
,.".t"t~ \Q ,~ ~t.,t"' .A4 .,~tt"' qf ~0Q4f" Q' .twiI4'
",~U ., J,{i1> .U~,
11, Th. o.r.ndant Av.ra that lt the Plaintirf auatain.d any
injurl'l or damaQ", .. .ll.~.d, the a.m. ~.r. cau..d .. A r..ult
of tho .ole n.ullo.nc. ot the Addltlonal Def.ndant in the mann.r
ln whlch lta .mploy" .u.p.nd.d .ald tru...., .11 Aa d..arib.d
abov..
13. D.r.naant. b.ll.v., and th.r.tor. Av.r, that Addltlonal
D.f.ndant i. lol.ly r.aponalblo to the Plaintitf, and th.r.tor.
further av.r, that .a14 Addltlonal D.f.ndant 1. alone liAbl. to
tho Plaintifr tor tho cau.. or Actlon d.olar.d upon.
13. Alt.rnativ.ly, if the Plalntifr 1. .ntitl.d to any
rollot, Additional o.t.ndaAt 11 jointly li,bla th.r.for ~lth
Dot.ndant. Wlll1a. 'tan.t101d and W. R. .tan.fl.ld Con.truotlon
Company, or 1. 11abl. ov.r to D.t.ndant. wil11,. .tanotl.1d and
w. R. .tan,ti'ld Con.truotion Co.pany, '0 that Detendant. Wl11i,.
fttan.ti.ld and W. k. .tanafi.ld Conatruction c~p'ny do.and
jUdq..nt in their tlvor, toqoth.r with the OOlt ot thAa Aotlon,
And, ln the alternat.ive, d...nd oontrlbution ur io4..nity froa
^ddltlonAl D.fenaAnt, Chlrl.. C, toO" 104 'on, 1no, , tov,thar
w1th the coat. at thAi lotion,
LAMPI', ILACX . IcnORP'
DOMINICI< P~RtZ,
PlaintUt
IN TilE COURT OF COMMON I'LEAS
OF CUHP!R~ND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
to-200 CIVIL TERM
JURY TRIAL or TWBLVI DEMANDED
v.
WILLIAM STAN,FIELD,
W.R, STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and I<ERRY SHINI<,
Dlhndanh
v,
CllARLES C. 1.0011 AND
PON, IUC,
Additlon'l Def.ndant
a..TJrIq~~1 0' ...VIOI
I hlrlby o.~tity that . oopy ot the tO~looln9 doou..nt,
COMPLAINT
w.. ..rv.d thl. data by d.po.ltlno .a.. ln thl po.t ottl01 at
Carll.l., p.nnaylvanla, tlr.t-ola.. ..11, po.t.O' pr.p.ld,
.ddr....d .1 tolIOW"
.oott W. Moro.n, E.q,
MOf91n , Moro.n, P.C.
120 louth Stra.t
Hlrrl.buf9, 1'1. 17101-1210
Tlaothy 1. M'rk, E.q,
C.ldwell , K.arn.
")1 North '~ont str..t
lIarrl.bur9, &"1. 11110-un
Jaok 'h"/ I.q.
Wl1,on, EAI.r, KOlkowltl, Edal..n . Dloklr
The Curtl. clntar, gUita "0
Indlplnd,nc. 'quarl W.lt
Phil.dllphla, tA 19106
~Ol., BLACI< . .CHOkP'
......"..""'....-,.,.
fll\Uil1 ~/( .s; /?%
" .
.', .
.
,,'
, .
,,' ....,;',1 .,
. " I, ".'
, :' >,., : ~ ,..:,,' .."
.-'.', '
. l:~ ~', .. .'. , . .
.> ....,:..
: .,; .f It t'
, ,
MORGAN &. MORGAN. P.C.
flY: SC01T W. MORGAN, ESQUIRB
IDENTIFICATION NO, 3672\
120 soum STREET
HARRISBURG. PA 17\0\.\210
(717) 236.7959
A'rrORNBYS fOR PL.AINTIFF
-
DOMINICK PERaZ
20\ Mulberry Drive
Harrlsbur., PA,
IN THB COURT OP COMMON PL.BAS
I CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, rENNA.
NO. '1..(. -"'0 &~~
Plaintiff
, v.
CIVIL ACTION. I.A W
I JURY TRIAL OP TWBLVe DBMANDED
WILLIAM STANSPIBLD
3672 Sprlns Road
Carlisle, PA 17013.'704
and
,
W. R. STANSPIBLD CONSTRUcnON
COMPANY
3611 Sprln. Road
Carlisle, PA 170\)
I
and I
I
KERRY SHBNK I
30M Rots Avenue I
New Cumberland, PA 17070, I
D,r,ndanll
NOTICE
You have bun 1\1,4 In court, It)'ou wish 10 .t,nd a..ll\llllle clatm. ..t
tanh In tFi tollowll\' 1.'."" you llwsll.lll. action within twellly (1()) day. arw, Ihil
cQmplalllt and notie, lI' Mrv4'd. by tIlwrllll . wrl/If" JPpe.,.ance pltloNlly or by ItlOtney
,114 Win, in weilln, wttn \he ('WI rOll' df('IlH' or obJ<<tlol\S 10 \lit c'-Im. NI fotth .,.insl
you, YOIl tit wasned IM-Il{ Y ~t; ';'11 W CQ W tho cue may pr0c.ft4 withoUI YOll ~ .
}\ld~ll\'1'\1 may bt '"ltfM '&WIlI )i/IJ ~y the ~w" 'tVlthoIll (I,lrthf{ I!()I~ (Of any moM)'
(lalll'1td In III. ~1'l\'IrllH'\1 I.r (\If afl) ()ltI" (\ailfl Of r,H.t r,q\lfll.cl by Ih9 plltl\liff, yO\.! may
I"" n,pMY \If I'rl'l'wy N ,'t/WI I itl." m'f'I\fIll\IIO }till
UKtDlT Po
. ,X' ',I,
'.
".' .
.,,; ;" , ,
'. ".,",',,-.,'::' ,,".'. "
" I', ':'. ,. ~""'"
t,
" '
. 1 ' j' .-, "',,,.,' ,'.~" '\ . ~, ,," " .; , '
'I" . ,,: t :, "./,':,:: '.,\:'" ",'", '1 " "<C
':'
'" .
't", "", "
, .:
YOU SHOULD TAKH THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCH. Ir
yOU DO NOT IlA Vi! A L.A WYER OR CANNOT AfFORD ON!!, GO TO OP,
TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN
GET LEGAL HELl',
Cumberland County Court Administrator
Cumberland County Courthouse
Fourth Ploor
Ono Counhouso Squaro
Carllllc. PA 17013
(717) 697-0371
AY1SQ
Lo han demandado I usted en II corte. 51 usted defcnderso do caw dcmandu
expue1tas en law pa,lnu .I,ulenlOs, ulted tlene velnlO (20) diu do pluo ,I partir do la feeha
de la demanda y la notlficaclon. Haeo falta uentar una comparenell escrlla 0 en perlona 0
con un aboaado y onll'e,ar I la eortc en forma elcrlll SUI dofensal 0 IU' objeelones a lu
demandu en contrl do .u persona. Sea avlaado que .1 u.ted no Ie deOendc. la cone tomara
,
medldas y puede continuer la demanda en contra .uya Iln prevlo avlso 0 nOIIOcaclon,
Ademll, la corte puedo decodor a favor del demandantt y roqulero que Ulted cumpll con
todu law provlslonel do elll demanda. Ulted pucdo perder dlncro 0 'UI propledade. u 011'0.
derechos Importanttl para ulted.
LLBVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOOADO INMBDIATAMENTB. 51 NO
lIEN!! ABOOADO 051 NO TIliNE ELDINERO SUPICIBNTE DE MOAR TAl.
SERVICO. V ^ Y ^ BN PERSONA 0 t.LAMB POR TELEFONO A LA OPICIN^ CUY A
DJRBCCION 5B ENCUENTRA BSCRITA ^DAJO PARA A VERIOUAR DONOS SB
I'UEDB CONSEOUIR ASISTENC1A LEOAL.
Cumberland Cl,)unty Court ^dmlnl.ltalOr
Cumberland County Courthou.o
Fourth Ploor
One Courthouse SqUill
Carllllo. Ph 17013
(717) 697.0371
. .
" f';,,, . ,'"
" \ '.!.',' '." ,. '.- ,\
, , ,\.!, .,'. " .' ,;. . ,..... ". t'..".'
"
....',.. .
MOnGAN'" MOROAN. P,c.
DY: seon w. MOROAN. IlSQUIIUl
IDI;NTJI'ICATION NO. 36121
120 SOUTH STRllllT
IlAnR/saURO,"A /1101.1210
(711) 236.7959
ATTORNRn POR PLAINTIFF
DOMINICK PBRBZ
201 Mulberry Drive
Harrlsbura. PA,
Plaintiff
IN THB COURT OF COMMON PLl!AS
CUMBBRLAND COUNTY. PENNA.
NO.
v.
.
,
: CIVIL ACTION . LAW
WILLIAM STANSPIELD
3672 SprlAa Road
Carlisle. PA 17013-8704
.nd
.
.
: JURY TRIAL 017 TWSLVB DEMAND aD
.
. t
W. R. STANSP1BLD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY
3672 Sprlni Road
Carlisle. PA 170U
and
KERRY SHBNK
30'A Itou Avenue
New Cumberl.nd, PA 17070.
D,(ondanta
CP~l.t\wr
Pl.lnllff, by and Ihroulh hi. allornoy'. MOf,lIl A Morpn, P.C.,hOt,by
. .
compl.l," .,all\$I Oofflldlnu and aven u follow.:
1. Plaintiff It alllWlllt ill(jjvid"l' '<<141/1& al the ~v. addr....
2, D4f,n431'\1 i., 31\ 341,111 in4iv!dv,,1 r"idin, I' lho .\love tddteu. and optn'in&
a bUIII\l\'U kl10wn I' W, It Sllnaflehl CQlUtfll~,k1l\ Company a, \tit abov. addl'D,
.. ...., ~ .
" . .' ~ .-.. ......, .
, .'
.. " -". -: ' .'.'
\ ; .
.......;... ,. ,','\' ",-.. '"
WHEREFORE. Plaintiff demands Judgment against Defendant, individually.
Jointly and/or severally, In an amount In excess of $2S,OOO.OO, exclusive of In tereSI, costs and
delay damages.
CQUfiJ: II
El.AJtiIl~Fv. WILJ..Ie.M SjA(l/SFIS-Q
14. Plaintiff Incorporates herein by reference the aUcaatlons of paragraphs 1
through !l III If fully set forth at length.
15, Tho negllgenco, carelessness and recklessness of Defendanl, Included:
,
!
,
t
!
,
I
!
!
i
I
f
,
i
r
I
r
A. Failing 10 keep a propcr lookout:
B. Palling to warn penons .uch III Plaintiff of an
ulU'wonablo rl.k of harm from their conduct:
C. Allowln. a picco of construction material or .uppllu
to faU and .trlko Plalntlfr:
. .
D. Palling 10 exerclle proper care In tho performanco of
work dulie. at tho dale and limo allelled herein:
E, Palllna to tab proper .tep. to .ccuro the buUd/n,
atr\lcture material or .uppllc. that fell and .truck Plaintiff:
Jl'. PalllnlllO take proper and adequate .tepa 10 prevent
the cOlulruclion mater141 or supplies from fallln. and lltlkln,
Plalrlliff..
I
I
i
" ,
.
.:' ',. .'.:.', -"
. . . ~, .
, '
16. A5 a result of Defendant's misconduct, Plaintiff suffered severe and
,\ '-, -'.
disabling Injuries. Including but not limited to, Injuries to his nerves, bones, muscles, Joints
and fascia. pain and suffering, mental and emotional dlmen, lome or all of which arc or may
be continuing In nature.
17. As a result of his Injuries I Plaintiff Incurred medical bills and expenses for
care, treatment and rehabilitation, lost earnings andlor earning capacity and suffered loss of
life's pleasures and diminution of his daily actlvltle., which are or may be contlnuing In
nature,
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demand. judgment.galMt Defendant, IndlvlduallYl
Jointly andlor .everally, In an amount In excess of $2',000.00, exclusive of Intere.t, co.ts .nd
delay damages.
.
COUNT IU
~1,,~1NJ'IPF v, w..{t STANSfieLD CON~IRUCTIOt'/ COMPMO.'
18. Plalntlff Incorpor.tes heroin by reference the allelatlons of paragraphs I
through 9 u If fully let forth al length.
19. Tho negllgcnce, Clll'cleuncu and reckleJlne.. of Defendant. Included:
A. Fallin. to keep a proper lookout:
n. r.illne to warn persont luch u Plaintiff of an
. .
I/lllwon.ablc risk of harm from their conduct:
C. Allowing a pie~e of colUIrllClioll macer!,J or .uppllu
10 fall and 'lllke I'laintiff;
, "
.'
D. Failing to cxcrcisc proper care in the performance of
work duties at the dale and time alleged herein:
E. railing to lake proper steps to secure .lhe building
structure material or supplies that fell and struck Plaintiff;
F, Failing to tlIke proper and adequate steps to prevent
tho construction material or supplies from falling and striking
Plaintiff,
20, As a result of Defendant's miscondUCt, Plaintiff suffered severe and
disabling Injuries, Including but not limited to, Injuries to hi. nerves, bones I muscles, Jolnu
and fascia, pain and sufferlng, menlal and emotional dlstress, some or all of which are or may
be continuing In nature.
,
21. As a result of his InJuries, Plaintiff incurred medical bills and expenses for
care, treatment and rehabllhatlon, lost earnings and lor earning CApacity and suffered 1011 of
life's pleasures and diminution of his dally aCtivities, which arc or may be continuing In
nature.
WHBREFORB, Plaintiff demands Judament agalnat Defendant, lndlvldually,
Jointly andlor severally, In an amount In ClICCU ot S2',OOO.OO, Cllclullvo of Incerclt, cosuand
delay damllle..
TRUE COpy FROM RECORD
In Tflllmony wher.of, I hm unto I,t my h.r'"
$nd thQ sui ol.stJd Co!}rl at C.rUs't, PI.
;~"L,,,)J,y'\ doy ola~""''''''''1 ",.ff.:
,~&;jtt~,."",g:,.~'r:""w.
.' PtOI~flO"ry
MOROAN & MORGAN, P,C.
DATED:
~).o.., \ ~ ,I ,.....
^ ""It..... ) _.: L__:_-..-.J__:._ " ~
"
Yl11U1~
Dominick reru .IAIU OIal/1o I, rlalntlf( In !hi. ,"AUfr, Ind OIalOlo .lAtomelJU
made in 010 (Qr'loln, Complalnl are tru. .nd COntellO 01. b'll of hi. knowled..,
informal Ion and belief. H. Und.rIl4nd. OIallho .lAltm.nu In .11d ploadln, If. mad. .ubJecI
10 010 ponaltles of U PI. C.S.A.'49Q4, rollllll' to UNworn i'Il.IOcation to aulhoflllcl,
~~~b..
.mn .,...
,
. .
~
r
I \ .
, .
I ~j ,
I I II I
I I "
I l'll'l I
I ~
I I L
, II I
/,
.
f F
II
i
i
.
u
....
..,
.J
AI
~
;I:
u
...
VI
o
l.'
,.'
.
u
c:::
~
'~
"
I
....
.,. ....
Z.." ~ ~
, r',
-4 , '/, f.:
0.' r. v,
(/)~~i
~ '. -.,
~.~:;.. !.,;
"'0 tJ ,....,
,/, :t.;.o:
U..1 ,1 " ~
C/) ~ ~,
O...J ~...
(tj (j
0'1/1
, ~ ~~
...J._ . t.
.~~~<t
U .)~
~;:
C/) ... -
L1Ji;~
~~ ~
...:J ~,
~ ;rl
U
"
1.1
II
...
III
... 144
~K ~:j
= ~ ;;
t( e. ih
.. ~ li~
E l $:i
i
:I
...
~
if
p
d
t.
~~((
!'t
.)
$I
\-."",.
.. .. f'-'
...f4f-.f
,..
"'4.-1
...J .."...J
.. ..,,-,
lei .. flit
"" ..~-
~.. ",4
.... ~
4.- .,..
.,.. ~
.";'
'_1""""
..1u1.
;';1" ..
tH.. i,,#
nn
fl. ,.
it;
,
_r
'I
I
,I
.......-
....
" .,.
I ~
I 5
,~ Q
,"' .'
a ~ .
....
-:;: J
'~; I
- -~.!
I'
~
t
t' "
1\ "
,.,. .1 A
" "
I ,~~
It'
'{"'\
1,1,
h
~r;\
, . ';, '"1
. ,.
. ,
.... 4> ~~ - .. 'i ".'1 4::~ ..
'. .
, '..'.. :, ~1. t. I.',
. '. . ,c. "\ r. ': I..
4- 't" I 'i it
C '. i "i '
,
, .
~- ~ "
,',
(J
"I',
... It
... ,:;,
a '"
*"0
>,It ',1;';1
.;~ ' ,
1ft: '
~. ,I '
.,
~"
,'r:
'~4
'( ~
'fI'
',"
~
, .
t., i
J ..
! <. . ~
,
II
\~,
~
,.
(.
!/
I
c
'j
!:
"
Ii
I' WILSON, ILII., MOSKOWITZ, IDILIWf . DICit'"
Ii B'll Bernd O. lIein.., I.quire AttorneYI tor Ad(Ut1onal
,'1 John D. She., R.ql.lire Detend.nt Charlet C.
I IOKNTIFICATION NO. 40670/74627 Loa.. .nd 80n, Ino.
I TIlB CURTIS CENTBR . SUITB 8)0 BAST
! INDEPENDENCR SQUARB WEST
PIlILADBLPllIA, PA 19106
(2151 627-6900
DOMINICIt PBRHZ I IN TUI COURT or COII..,N
Pla1ntUf, I PLIAI or CUMBIRLAMtI
I COUNTY, PINN'YLVANIA
v. I
.
WILLIAM BTAN.rISLD, . .5-200 CIVIL TlaN
W.R. BTANSPIIILD CONSTRUCTION .
COMPANY .nd ItIRRY 'HINIt, I
Detendanu, I CIVIL ACTION . LAW
I
V. .
.
CltARLRS e. LOOn AND SON, INC. I JURY TRIAL or TWlLVI
Additional Detend.nt. I DINANDID
1701111)11 COIOLlDn' or ADDI'1'IOIfAL DlrlMlWl"l' CV.t.1I CI, LOOI. MD
lOll, trio. JO~I.n VQ~'1'JmrA.L blflllmAIrP IDl"WM1'" Btw1Il. I'~,
Additional detendant Ch.rle. e. Loo.e and Ion, 100, (hereinatter
reterred to al 'c.e. Loo.."), by .nd through it. attorney., Wil.on,
BI.er, Holkowlt., Id.lmAn . Picker, h.reby ....rt the within joinder
complaint pl.lrluant to the 'enn.ylvania lule. ot Civil proctdurt
.galn.t tht additional dlfendAnt, a.nehmark "~., Ino. (hlrtinafter
~'l.o reterrla to a. '..nehmark") Ind, in .upport thlr.ot av.r ..
tollowl'
w~.(..., h"", t,I(;k(lWIfl', tot H.'"'' , 00(;"" . ".. CI""I" UltH" . ,,,,ft *,(, fA!lI
lJfMHJff>t"'" "Ov""t wU' . ""''''l>l\h'''' "" I.",.
1. Additional Detondant Charl.. C. Loo.' and Bon, tnc. i. a
Ponn.ylv.ni. corporation with A principal place ot bu. in... at 50 We.t
:1 Sto.vor Avenu., Myentown, t>.nn.ylvania, 17067.
H
II
II
;1 2. Addit ional Oetendant a.nchmllrk /10m,', Ino., upon intonnat1on
II And beli.t, i. A penn.ylvania corporation with a principal placo of
!,
budne.. at 11011 Rana Villa Av.nu., Camp IIU1, PA, 17011,
J. On or about January 13, It'll, plaintiff fi1.a a complaint
again.t original a.f.ndant. X.rry 'hank, William 't.n.ti.1d and W.R.
Stan.fi.ld Con.truction company, A true and corr.ct copy of
plaintiff" complaint i. attached h.r.to .nd incorporated herein a.
bhibit "A."
., Plaintiff'. complaint ....rt., 1Dtar 1111, that on or about
Augult 17, 1"3, plaintiff ,uffered an injury a. a ra.ult of being
.truck on the h.ad and fac. by a 1arg. pi.e. of con.truction mat.ria1
, Which f.l1 or WI' droPP'd from In 'l.vat.d h.ight on the building in
which the plaintiff WI' working,
t, 'laintiff'. complaint a11.g.., Int,~ 1111, the injuri., were
.utrered a. a r..ult of the nO'li,.nc., car.le..n.., .nd reckle..ne..
i or the d.f.ndant., individuaUy, jointly and/or levu.Uy.
~
~
I 6. Th. plalntirr did not ~ ,.titloniD9 D.r'~nt e.c. Loo..
l
I.' an original dtr,n4ant.
llJ",
W,,\O" hUll 1,O('\'OWll/lf>t,...A/o"("(,,,, . """'''''\11.."" . ,,,,,, .lillA"
...'..r."'c".""{. ..tiuA... ~.\t .. "ffl.4fl.,"..A ,.It '.HtIi
7. On or .bout March 6, 1IIn, original detondant. William
Btan.tield and W.R. Btan.rield Con.truction Company tiled a Writ to
Join Additional Detendant C.C. ~ooee,
e. On or about April 5, 1995, original detendant. William
Btan.field, and W.R. Stan.field Con.truction company tlled a joinder
complaint naming C.C. Loo.e a. an additional derendant. A true and
correct copy or the joind.r complaint i, attach.d hereto and
incorporat.d herein a. Bxhibit '8,'
9. Additional D.tendant C.C. Loa.' provided prefabricat.d
rooting tru.... tor. con.truction project to .encnmark Home., Inc.,
who Will the O.n.ral Contractor. A true and correct copy ot .aid
contract i. attach.d her.to and incorporat.d her.in a. Ixhibit 'C.'
10. A crane wa. n..d.d to tran.t.r the pretabric.t.d roctlng
tru.... torm C.C. Loa..'. d.llvery vehicle to the con.tructlon
project.
11, Additional Def.ndAnt ..nchmark Homel. Inc., alaeneral
Contractor ot the conatruotlon project, had . duty to .nlur. the
eon.truoelon ar.. WI' ,ate and fr.. trom danger to all lnd1vidual.
working at the conttruction .it. whil. th. roofing tru.... Were
o
I tran.tened by OV.rhfa4 crane trODl tM dtUvuy vehlcl. to the
!con.tructlon project.
I
I
!
I
~
t
"
.~.
,
r
-)-
WI\t.<Wo! fI..... W'IIUW1fl, "'h~"" '1>1l:."" . hft .."',,, fI"'411 . ..."'. *)11'/01"
.Ht>I.....OU.U lClV""4 W*'" . ""~ 101>11.....11 I'll It''''
12. Additional Defendant Penchmark Ilome., Inc. "'AI negligent lnl
;i
jI
II
I'
(a) Failing to keep a proper lookout,
(b) Failing to warn persons such .s Plaintiff of an
unreasonable risk of harm,
(e) railing to exerei.e proper care in the performance ot
their duti.. at the date and time all.g.d,
(d) railing to tak. prop.r and ad.quat. It'PI to I.cur. the
conltruction lite and .nlur. a lat. working .nvironment
tor PlaintiU,
(.) 'ailing to polt warning lign. to indicat. th. UI. ot
overh.ad maChinery,
(t) 'ailing to tape and/or rope oft th. are. wh.r. overhead
machin.ry wal in UI', and
(g)
railing to coordinat. th. activit!'1 ot th. varioue and
numerouI .ubcontractor. working at th. conltruction
IiU.
,I
I'
!I
.4 ~
_'011. fl"" M<ll.(M/IlI, Illf'''A~'' .ne.... . hot CI/fOII' (;Ill"" . 'vll' .)(1'''''
...tltHlfflf~(f t(nIAlI' W'" . ...'I\A(j".....A, I'A IItflt
II
H
Ii 13. As a result of Additional Defendant lJonchmark Ilomes, tne,'a
il
r negligonce, Plaintiff BUffered the alleged injuries as set forth in
I hill complaint.
14. In tho event it is determined that additional defendant
Charles C. Loose and Son, Inc. acted negligently, careles.ly,
reckles.ly and without due care in accordance with their contractual,
statutory and common law duties and responsibilities with re.pect to
the accident as alleged in plaintitt" complaint, allot which having
heretotore been denied, then propo.ed additional d.tendant Benchmark
Homes, Inc. would be liable over to Additional Detendant for
contribution and/or indemnitication.
WHBRBFORB, Additional Defendant Charles C. Loo.e and Son, Inc.,
if found wholly or partially re.pon.ible tor plaintiff'. alleged
injuries, ...k. indemnification and/or contribution from Additional
Detendant Benchmark Home., Inc.
Re.pecttully .ubmitted,
WILlON, ILlIR, MOSJOWITZ, IOILMAN , OICICBR
....,
I)' . ..::::::::
..rnd o. Heln.., I.quir.
John O. .h.a, I.quir.
Attorn.y. for Additional Defendant
Charle. C. Loo.e a04 'on, Inc.
II
II
.,.
WII.ON, "'"'' MO'.OW"', UIIIMA., ""...111 . III. ('lllll,' UNll~ . 'lilt. .,,, .AlI
,..,(llI'tN".Ntt IllV"ft' Vi"1 . f'"" ""II"''''', I'A ItlClll
ji
,i
j,
"
:1
I
i
!
II WILSON, BLSIR, KOSltO"ITZ, IDILKAN
'i BY, Bernd O. Heinze, Slquire
John D. Shea, Bsquire
IDENTIPICATION NO. 40670/74627
THB CURTIS CENTER . SUITS 830 BAST
INDEPBNDBNCE SQUARE WEST
PHILADBLPHIA, PA 19106
.1 (215) 627.6900
;1
[: DOMINICK PBREZ
11
'i
. DICltBa
Attorneys tor Additional
Defendant Charl.s C.
LooI. and Son, Ino.
Plaintifr,
v.
, WILLIAM STANSFIBLD,
i W.R. STANSFIBLO CONSTRUCTION
l: COMPANY and KSRRY SHSNK,
" Oetendant',
v,
I
I
I
I
I
.
I
I
I
I
.
I
I
I
IN THB COURT OF COMMON
PLBAS OP CUMBBRLAND
COUNTY, PBNNSYLVANIA
"
j,
!l CHARLBS C. LOOSI AND SON, INC.
ii Additional Dehndant.
!!
!i
II
II
I
I
Ii I,
lJ
,I
:1
!I The Penn.ylvania RUle, or CivU prooedure permit joinder or an
Ii
II additional derendant beyond the
H
ii complaint upon a derendant upon oau,. .hown pur.uant
,I The rule provid.. in nlevant part, .. rollows.
95'200 CIVIL TRRM
CIVIL ACTION . LAW
JURY TRIAL 0' TWBLVB
DBMANDID
HIKOlAMDOK 0' LA" IN .U"O.T 0' ADDITIONAL D.'ENDANT,
CIULla C, Loosa AJm 8ON, INC" ,oa LIAVI TO JOIN
IIDlCIDIA1lJ: BOMIlS. INC. AS AM ADDITIONAL DIrIHDAH't
LIOAL AHALYSIS
.ixty (60) day. arter .ervioe ot a
to Rule 2211).
Neither praecipe tor writ to join additional
defendant nor a complaint it the joinder i.
c~nced by a complaint, .hall be riled by the
original defendant or an additional defendant
later than 60 day. atter the .ervice upon the
original det.ndant ot the initial pleading ot the
WI""", 1111'" M"II.OW'" 1l>1I~""" (,,( .,.. . '''I (\I""~ ('..,ltn . "wit no ,...,,,
1..1>11-. "("NfI ill"...... W,,,, . ""'1 "'1>' ",'IIi'" ,.... I II lI)ti
"
I
Ii
,I
I'
I
I
I
I
plaintitt or any amendment thereot unle.s luch
tiling il allowed by the court upon caUle .hown.
Pa.R.C.P. Rule 2253.
II Although Rule 2253 doe I not detine "caul' Ihown," the
I
:1 Penneyl vania courtl have provided guidance in thil relpect I In
il
:1 Marnell v. CraBB, 372 Pa. 82, 92 A.2d 685 (19521, the court ruled that
II
;1 determination at whether there il "caule Ihown" tor the allowance at
I
: joinder in contormanc. with the rule 18 a matter relting with the
I,
:)
i discretion at the trial court. In Zakian v. t.lljll8tr~nd, 438 Pa. 249,
!
264 A.2d 638 (19791, the Pennlylvania Supreme Court noted the purpose
,
i: ot Rule 2253 is to simplity and expedite the adjUdication at lawluits
involving numeroul partie. while guarding against unrea.onable delay
ii in tha pro.ecution ot an action. The Court in Za~iaQ turther Itated
"
I
II that when determining whether or not the petitioning party h..
'I
II estab1ilhed a cau.e Ihown, the court ahou1d be guided by the
,
! .objective lought to b. achieved by the ule at the additional
i
,
I defendant procedure."
1;
Ii
In DiLauro v. Qne Q,la ~v.ny, ^,.OQ~IC", 375 Pa. luper. 301, 515
A.2d 939, 941 (19841, the court set torth three prong .et ot
I guide1in.. in conlidering petition. tor joinder ot additional
detendant beyond the 60 day period. The requirement. are,
1. aea.onab1e ju.titication or excu.e tor the
d.1ays
.2.
W'"O.., flfo'" ~.f(".(lW"IIl)fI"."N lil"l.J'" . ..., (",,'I!> U""II . '"111.)01""
'''l-''''''<>'N(\ 'HI)"'" WI" . ""~"(>""'''''''I\ '.,fill
Ii
,
Ii
,I
I
.
2.
A statement ot the tacta allege to render the
proposed additional detendant alone liable or
liable with, or liable over to the
petitioning party, and
Allegations ot the late joinder will not be
prejudicial to the proposed additional
detendant.
3.
In the caee at bar, Petitioning Derendant wss not served with a tormal
complaint until April 5, 1995. There hae been little to no rormal
discovery to date, and only recently did Petitioning Defendant
Charles C. Loo'e and Son, Ino. obtain documentation indicating that
Benchmark Homes, Inc. waD the general contractor at the construction
site on the date ot plaintirt's alleged injuriee. rurther, after a
diligent .earch of it. books and record., Petitioning Oetendant
discovered the invoice for the roofing trueses, which are the alleged
item whiCh struck plaintitt in the head, indicating that aenchmark
lIomes, Inc. waR the purchassr of the rooting trusses.
The plaintitf's complaint alleges, inter Al1A. negligence,
car.l.sene.s and reckl.s.ness against the originallY named defendants.
The complaint .pecifically allege, failing to warning per.onl luch a.
plaintitf of an unrea'onable riek ot harm from their conduct; allowing
piece. ot con.truction material and .upplies to tall And 'trike
plaintitt, tailing to provide proper care and pertormance ot work
duties at the date and time alleged, tailing to take proper .teps to
secure the bUilding, and structural material or supplie.. Allot the
precedlng Allegation. apply to the dutl.. And respon,ibllitl.. at the
general contractor at the con.truction alte. Accordingly, the
*),
WIllI!)," 'U,,,, MO'~OWjfl, WIIM4,". (UCO'" . IIn (;"..", 0""" . 'till' no '4~'
1101>11'1101>'''0 '0\14'" WI" . l'IlI'4('I\"'''4 "4 '1110"
.
allf.l(jAlloIH' of tho l.lAlnlUC', complaint potontially rlnder thl
propo..d add1tlonal doCendAnt Bonchmark Hom.., Ina. ltabl. ovor to
a'1,11 tiolld dotondant Cllul.. C. Loa.. and Ion, Ino.
Tho propo..a additional d.t.ndant will not b. pr.judioo by
jo1nder to thi. llttllatlon at thil ttmo. '.Utioning Cotondant i. tho
only ~rty to conduct di'Covory to dati, .. thi. oa.. i. 'tl11 tn it.
pr.l1~inary Ita,... Th. propo'ld additional dofondant, Blnchmark
Home., InQ., will nave a full and compl'to opportunity to partioipatl
1n tho vartou. .v.nu.. ot di.covlry ptnnttt'd und.r tho 'onn.ylvani.
Rulo. at ctvil .roo.dur..
'or tho r...on. or jUdtciAl oco'" and t"'ditinv the lW1ll
proe.., by navtnv III potlnttllly r.,poR.lbl. partt,. pr...ne .nd
betorl thi. Honorablo CQUrt tor I .1ntl. 'u4iet.l proe.04tnv and tho
pro,plet or ..ttl...nt, tt t. appropriato to .llow tho joind.r ot tho
prpPQ.oa additional d.r.ndant It tht. t1... In 11ght 01 the
tot'Q01nt, ,.tttLoniRf c.l.ndant. r..ptotf~11y r.qu.,t. thi. Honor.blt
CQurt to ,r.nt tn.. l..v. to fl1. th. within pro,o.o4 c~l.tnt
join1n9 ..non..r_ ~., Inc. .. .n .dditlonal d.t.n4ant to tni.
lltiV.tlon,
RI.p.otfYlly .ubmi~tl4,
WiLtON. ILlIt, MO'KOW1Tl, ItlIUWf " IHCKIlR
Iyl~~~ !)u.~'-.'-. i.. ----'-.... ".,=."'
/ . r. ..., nl','q\I I'
. J"M 0, JtI.M, :a~&r'
AnuM}" tOf lUOMl u.rll'l4ant
c:bIrl.. C, ~'" .,.4 'on, IfJ~.
.f-
"""""'.."'...'''''''~,:/,~._...,w..... ...........,.."'..'1.. ",,,'t."'IH'
~"Jiitf4." ~-f~#-A'" wtit;t , "~.i,ti"~. ~. '~H4.
~
~" ;
i
I !'
I '
i.;;"
c
N
H
h
",
:
,'.1
....
l<
j!'''f
;,..t
'\
tl
II
ii
i: WILSON, ELSER, MO!lI<OWITZ, EDELMAN'
ii nYI nernd O. lIeinze, Elquire
1 John D. Shea, Elquire
i, IDENTIFICATION NO. 406070/746:17
'! TilE CURTIS CENTER - SUITE 830 EAST
il INDEPENDENCE SQUARE WEST
II PIIILADELPIIIA, I'A 19106
II (:n!l) 627-6900
Ii
.I
DICKER
AttorneYI for A~ditlonal
Defendant Charle. e. Loo.e
and Son, Ino.
,
;' DOMINICK PEREZ
plaintiff,
IN THE COURT or COMMON
PLEAI OF CUHBICRLAND COUNTY,
P1CNNBYINANIA
v.
WILLIAM STANSFIELD
W.R. STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION
, COMPANY and KERRY SHENK,
Def.ndantl,
95-aoo CIVIL ACTION
v.
cJlARLES C. LOOn AND SOH, IHe,
Addltlonal Defendant.
JURY TRIAL or TWELVI
DEMANDID
v.
BENCllMARX JlOHE81 INC..
Addlt onal Detendant
lfO'1';O.
You have been eued In Court. It you wlth to detend 19a1n.t the
clai.. .et torth ln the to11ovln9 pa9", you 1I\11t tlka acUon wlthln
twenty (ao) daye atter thl1 COllplalnt and Notlo. ar. I.rv.d, by
.nterinq a wrltten appear.ne. perlona11y or by Ittorn.y and tl11n9 In
writinq with th. court your de ten... or obj.ction. to thl 01al111 ,et
forth IQalnlt you. You are warned that it you tall to do 10 the ca.e
lIay proo..d wlthout you and a judqll.nt lIay be enter.d ageln.t you by
I the Court without further notice for any .aney clal.ed in the
I complaint, or for any other olai. or r.li.f r.que.t.d by the
Plaintltt(e). You lIay loe. mon.y or prop.rty or oth.r rl9ht.
important to you.
YOU 'HOULD TAl. THI' .A.IR TO YOUR LAIYIR AT ONC'. I' YOU
DO 110'1' IIlV. A UlnR oa CAXIIO'1' UroaD 0"1, 00 TO oa
TILI'MO.I TlI' orrle. .IT rORTH DI~OW TO '1110 OUT WHIRl
YOV CAN 011 LIOAL KIL'.
euaberlaa4 coun~y cour~ A4a1aietrator
Oae Courtbou.e .quar.
eerl1el.,'A 1'01'
Telepbone. (71'. '.0-"00
Wl\t()l!j. H...., UOUOW"', 1l11\A.tAI/. .,'tol" . 'It I I, Oi'I!I\ (II/II" . '''tit ..... '''!II
1N()fI1M;,..,t1 liOIlAIO' wl\l . "'"' AOIl !'"..., 1',1. "'~
i!
il
Ii
II
,
Ii
Ii
II
11 .ILION, ILIII/ MOIIO.ltl, .DILMAN . DIC...
il BY. I.rnd a. ",inl', I.quir. Attorn.y. tor Additional
Ii John D. .h.a, I.quin D.t.ndant CharI.. 0, Loo"
'IIDENTIrICATION NO. 40670/14131 and lon, Ino.
I TilE CURTII CINTIR - IUITI no IA.T
INDEPENDENCE IQUARI WIlT
PIn LADELI'IIlA, fA UI0.
(315) 627-6100
DOMINICK 1'11111
IN THI COURT or COMMON
PLEAS or CUMDlRLAND
COUNTY, PIHH,YLVANIA
Plllntltt,
v.
. WII.LIAH .TANIFULD,
. W,R. ITANarUU> CONITIIUCTIOH
COMPANY and KIRRY IHINK,
D.t.ndant.,
95-200 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL TERM . LAW
v.
','" CHARLES C. LOOII AND ION, INC.
Additional D.t.ndant.
JURY TRIAL or TWILVI
DINAHDID
v.
ii
"
I:
'I JEHCHMARX HOMI. INC.,
, AdditIonal D.t.ndant
JOINDI. COM.LlIN' O. aDDItIONAL D.r'MDANT CHAlL.. O. LOO'. AMP
.PII. UIO. )g~U"f ~DD1TI0JfAILDlrllfP~ ""OMnIa IIQ"". JtlQ,
Additional d.tendant CharI" C. Loo.. and 'on, Ino,
(h.nlnatter referr.d to a. .C,C, Loo....), by and throu9h It1
attorn.y., Wil.on, Il..r, Mo.kovit., Id.l..n' Diok.r, h.r.by
....rt the within joind.r co.pl.int pur.uant to the P.nn.ylvania
kul., ot civil procedure '9.in.t th. additional d.f.ndant,
Hnchaark Ho...." 1M. (h'r.l"altu .1.0 nhrred to .. "'I.nchaark"')
and, In .upport th.r~t aVer II toIIOY..
W~'("'" """ ...0..........'", \(>h....... '''' .... . ,... (II'"'' (lion" . "...It.)() t.1l1
......,.,'0(..0,/. M,u."" W'"I . "'",.OI\M". ,.,. 1,,(It
Ii 1. Additional D.t.ndant Charl.. C, 1.001. and Son, Inc. b a
I
'I Penn.ylvlnia corporation with a principal place ot budn... at lIO We.t
II
!I Stoever Avenue, Myer.town, Penn.ylvania, 17067.
!I
II
II 2. Additional D.tendant Benchmark Hom.., Inc., upon intonMtion
1! and belief, i. a Plnn.ylvania corporation with a prinoipal placI ot
!i
I' buline.. at 1105 Rana VUla Avenue, Camp lUll, PI., 17011,
J. On or Ibout January 1J, 1995, plalntitt tiled a complaint
'i auatnlt original detendantl Kerry .hlnk, William Stan.field and W.R.
Btan.tield Con.truetion company. A truI and correct copy ot
plaintltt'. complaint i. attach.d hereto and incorporatld herein a.
Exhibit "1..'
Plaintitf'. compl.int ....rt., ~nt.~ 111&, that on or about
17, 1P'), plaintitf Iuttered an injury a. a re.ult or being
on the h..d and tace by a large pile. at con.cruetion material
tell or wa. droPPld trom an el.v.tld hlight on the building in
the plaintitt wa. working.
.. .
Augu.t
.truck
which
which
~. Plaintitr'l complaint allege., !ntlt 1111, the injurl.., w.r.
lutt.red a. . rllult ot the nl911,enol, car.l'..nl" and rlck1e..ne..
or the detendant., individually, ~ointlY andlor ..vlrally,
6. The plaintltf did not ~ 'etitlonlng Offendant c.e. Loo..
.. an original defendant.
.~,
WUf;t; """ MO"OWlIl HlhUA.., 'I"':"" . ".. {'!fI'" UIf"'" . '\Jllt.)(;.."
Il\I()fHlWtlK. i(l\JAIlt wu' . ..."'"("',,..., f'A 1.'(It
7, On or about March 6, 1995, original defendante William
Btan.rield and W,R. Stan.field Con.truction Company filed a Writ to
Join Additional Detendant C.C. Loo...
8. On or about April 5, 19'5, original detendant. William
Stan.rield, and W.R. Stan.tiold Con.truction Company tilod a joinder
complaint naming C.C. Loo.. a. an additional der.ndant. A true and
correct copy or tho joinder complaint ia attached hereto and
incorporated heroin .. Ixhibit 'B,'
9, ~ditional Dotendant C.C, Loo" provid.d pratabrleated
roaring tru.... tor a con.tructlon proj.ct to Benchmark Homo" Inc.,
who wa. the aen.ral Contractor. A truo and correct copy ot ..id
contract i. attach.d h.reto and incorporat.d herein .. Rxhiblt 'C.'
10. A crane wa. ne.d.d to tran.tor the pretabricat.d rooting
tru..., tona C.C. Loa..'. d.liv.ry v.hicl, to the con.truction
project.
11. Addition.l Det.ndant Benchmark Homo., Inc., a.a,neral
Contractor ot the con.tructl0n proj.ct, had a duty to .n,ur. the
con.truction ar.a w.. .at. and tr.. trom dang.r to .11 individuala
working at tho conatruction .it. while tho rootlng tru..., voro
tranaterred by ov.rno.d cran. trom tho dlllvery v,hicl' to tho
cQnetructlon project,
.1.
Wl\~"'. ".." -..otll."WUI, '(lflM..."". Otf,U" . H.. t''''HI (I""" , "lift IWI'M"
~f1IoC>ftt<;. .Ou...... WHIt . ..."Ull"""... '" "loti
13. A.. re.ult ot Additional Oetendant aenchmark Home. I Inc,'.
neglig.nc., Plaintitf .uttered the alleged injurie. a. ,et torth in
hit complaint.
I 14. In the event it i. determined that additional detendant
:1 Charles C. Loo.e and Son, Inc. acted negligently, carele..ly,
II reckle..ly and without due care in accordance with their contractual,
: .tatutory and common law dutie. and re.pon.ibilitie. with re.pect to
the accid.nt a. all.ged in plaintitt's complaint, allot which having
,I her.torore been denied, then propo.ed additional detendant aenchmark
"
if IIomll. Ino. would be liable OVIr to Additional Oetendant tor
,. contribution and/or lndemnitication.
:1
I!
,j
;
i
d
Ii it round wholly or partially re.pon.ible tor plaintiff" aUeged
!i lnjud.., ..ekl indemnification and/or contribution trom Additional
Iloet.ndant Benchmark Home., Inc.
:1
i
:1
I'
I
MIBRBPORI. Additional O.f.ndant Charle. C. Loo.e and Son, Inc.,
!
i
:1
Ii
.1
II
'I
!
Re.pecttul1y ,ubmitted,
WILlON, ILlIR, MOSKOWITZ, IOILMAN , OICKRR
........
"
Iy, ~. ..:J .:~ '
... und Q. He nn, I.quire
! John D. Ihe., I.quire
/ Attorney. for Additional Derendant
Charle. C. Loo.e and 80n, Inc.
-!
.,.
w"t",. til'tII, MO'lawl", H>lU,l".. &,,1(1'1\ . lllf (I/'U,I (,I""" . '"H, UIl lA"
1NCl......"I..'1 IOu"'" W.., . t'lfIt AO",...,,,,.,, "'06
!'
I
I
,
YIRII'ICA'l'IOlf
John O. Sh.a, Esquire .tat.. that he 18 ths attorney tor
Additional D.tsndant Charl.. C. Loo.e and son, Ino., that he has
i, the authority to make this veritication on their behalt, that h. i.
"
it acquainted with the tacts s.t forth in the toregoing pleading1 that
Ii
the .ame are true and correct to the best ot his knowledg.,
il
Ii
:!
:,
intormation and bellet, and that this .tatement is made .ubject to
the
penalUes
relating
unsworn
18 Pa.C,S.A.
to
ot
s
4904
tal.ifioation to authoriti...
j!
,I
;1
Ii
II
'I
I
I
,
,
,'() ~
.
I
I,
II
I
i
I
[, DATED. .M.~ .J/. l Ul.
i!
W"IO.... "''',. MO,.OW' " , 'Pi'.......... 01(.'''' . lIlt '"""1 "...fllI . Wilt 1'0'"''
ttlj(,''''tW'''''' '0\1""" WI" . ....II"II'If.'"'' 1''' .tlOll
I
:.
, ,
. .', '.... ", ," " "
.,. ," ,', .'
"
MOnGAN &. MOnGAN, I',C,
IIY: SCOli W, MOnGAN, f:SQUIRll
Jl)I!NTIFICATION NO, 36721
120 SOUTIl STllIJlil'
IlAJUUSDURO. PA 11101.1210
(111) 236.1959
A,TTORNBYS FOR PlAINTlf"
DOMINICK PEREZ
201 Mulberry Drive
Harrlsburs. PA,
: IN THB COURT or COMMON PLIlAS
CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PENN^.
Plaintiff
.
.
: NO.
v.
.
.
: CIVIL ACTION . LAW
WJLUAM STANSFIBLD
3672 Spring Road
Carlisi., PA 17013.8704
.
.
: JURY TRIAL or 1WBLVB DEMANDED
"
and
'.
. ,
W. R, STANSPIELD CONSTRUCfION
COMPANY :
3672 Sprln. Road I
Carll.lo, PA 17013 I
I
and
KERRY SHENK
305A Rosl Avonuo
New Cumberland, PA 17070,
Defend.ntJ
~QMrYl1'fi
Plaintiff, by and throuJh hi. attorney.. MorJIn 81. MorJan, P.C..hcrtby
. .
complains a..lnst Defendarlt. and IVers u follow.:
I. Plaiotiff is an .dull individual raldin. II \he tbove addruI,
~, Ollr,nd.nl i. .n adult individual retidln, II the lOOV. tddfm. V\4 ~..,j..
a bll,in~n known II W, It Sllrllfield Con'tructlon Comp.ny I' the .bi,,'.lddlfll
, , r' ." '. ' .,1.,_ .i~
_', '" _ _ '. .. .. . } .... , . . f . . ' ',',' .' .,.., A.. .
... I ~ p , .... .' .. , " - . ...... .... -. ... . " . .', f. ,. .
"..1" \'9:,'.-- \.".....0...,.... {l'lr'~f~"""':I'("" ,..,..I.,.,':,'.,I....",~\.i "".' .d",-:".....f..'.....,~'.,,~/,\'tf'\ ':.,_
1 ~f' '... .,.. . ,,"',,', . ,.... '1'1..' II", /.;j'~.,.+. j" ',t - ~ ," '(.,'" ''""
I' f '" .I,l , . ,'r ,.", . -,' '"f' ',", I ", '". ", '}".I\
,. Dttllldanl 51I,uk II In adllh Indlvtd ,..ldlAf &l m. ~ ~,
" p. PI .Ul .\"'111111, 1m. Pll!au wu ~ .. . pl~lllblnl...ln&m
tv, C.P. Aorl, II &be IMoOn Hrn OOllAllUO\Ion ,'oJeo& 0 Lltnek,lIo Road III Ntw Cumberland,
hr~VlllIa,
" DttuWla JC6rrf 1M"" _ 0\....... IN OONUlICLIolI proJoc& oa wtIlGb
PIaladlt wu WIDtD&,
., Dtfendllll WUII&lll'lIIItfttld u4
,
.. '1&Nn.l4 CONtnIOdori CotllllU1
prqJlQt.
.
7, ".. ~&RCI1tmy .b.tl\lc, W1l1 'l&NfttW &lid W. It 'lWnew
,
CauIrvcdaa c..r.. ... &I all u.. lIOritJ be,. IlIlIlvl4\1lUy 0' IhrouP .......
,
""""'ITf4Iof..,~ wlU\la III. OO\IIN "I-1OOpt , NII.,.aoy 01 'II\II~
" AIIfFO~IIZl&"ly 13 p.m. 0.. AualUl 7, 1m, PI&1adtr, w1I0.1Awf\a111 "
,
At Jot .lIe ... .nek .. tbt bIllS &ad floe by a Iart. ltoI '0' ooulNltfoo llWU'Ia1 _ .-.1
. WIt ~ flom II tlwattd bllIl" on ~ buM"" 1ft W1I\o11 PIalauIIr wu .,..
t. fta W4 ICCl4t1ll wM dw 10 lilt ""I , CIII.I......... t.Ild rtOld.......
,
,
,
of ~.w,~, JoIIId1 u41fiII NYlRfly &lid ~ IIIJIA'," aM d&nI.... III
.
Pl&llIdft, .. will bt .. M1y ... fDnIl Mlow.
tin -1rI.aa1r41\1boomrU1on OIllbt MW
cawaJ '~
..
.. ~.,,....,.. .
WIt.1ti' II It ~ lit M II __
---.~--
.. ..'~."""""'''--~.'''''_'''''''''...W
, .. ,
., !
II, Tlte 1IIII1IlfJlC{l. el'flmlllUl af\(j rllCkhmnm or UCfl!M31!l. 1lI4\Iudtd:
A, ,Iaillna 10 b,p I prt'per lookOlIl;
It fallln. 10 wAIn p.noM luch I. "'aihlift of III
Illltfl,tOnabl. rl." ot !wm (rom Ih,l, (O!ldlltlj
C. Allow In. I plte. 0' eOlUtfVellon ml'lflal or .upplkJ
10 tallaoo .ulkt Plalntlft:
D. I'llIIn, 10 ,urelft ptoptr car. In 1M ptr'otmIIlOt o(
work du"" It 1M ... and dmt all,,1d htr.ln;
B. ,.Uln, 10 IIkt ptoplt .ltpt 10 MC1Ilf 1M bulldlnJ
.trVONf. InIIIfIat Of ,uppl," t.hal (tllaoo ."",Ie PlaIAU('l
,. '111""10 takf proptJ anet W.1f ''''110 prtvW
&1M COIIIuwdon ....Ial Of .unllM from tlllllllllld .vlilll'
Plalndtt.
a,. AI. fllllll ot Dtftndant'. mlmnclucl. 'lalntltt 1I1ffwt4 tMrtllld
dliabllll' iftjurll.. 11I41u4ln, WlllOlllmllfd 10, IlIJllrlM 10 hi. MIV", bontt. lIlVNIu, Jt>>atI
and fuell, pain 1114 fUfftrj"" flIfftIIIlncl.motloll&l di.If...,1OftIf Of all o( wlllollm Of !lilY
b. (Colllimlill, in IIllUft,
U, A. I fffllll of tilt in}vtil., PlJllllift JllINf"; _let) bill. Incl uptf,Ut fw
UT', If.tl.llMltl w ,tMbltiMtkm, foil tIIl!hIJt tn4I<< fllliillf ~.~ 11I4 IlIffltt4 10M .,
lif,', pl"!'I'" ltlIJ 4ifflilfl#ilH Ii',"it IMIty ",.lttitiff, W/J./tm Uf fit lIMy 1M fllMiMifJI JrJ
t'4fJillt
Wl/lilWrOlW, l'lalnll(( demand. Judemcn! l,allUlOcfendanl, Individually,
jointly and/!'f .eve,.II)',ln an '",Ollll! In lueeU of S%S.OOO.OO,uclu.lv. of Interell.co." and
dell)' dlma,...
CQ1J.W'J1
14. PI.lnd(( IncorporllO. "'r.ln by r.r.tlnct Illt 111....10", ot ,.,.,raphll
lhrou,h P u It fIIlly 'II (oM 111'"lth.
lS, TIlt MIUpllC4, w.It.."". &lid ttGkSIa,MU of Dtf.lldIm, IMlud04t
A. fllllna 10 kHP . Pfoptf Iookoul;
D. ,.UlllllO warn ptflO'" .Ildl u 'lallllltf or .n
ulVlIIOIlIlIlt flak of harm troftllhtlt condUCI;
,
C. Allowlll, I p,", 0' C4lUlNCtlon IIIIltrlal Of .uppllq
10 'all.nd .ulk. Plaintiff;
Dt 1',1111\110 lur~1M PWJItf carf 'n tilt ptrformanct or
work 4ullf. II Ui. dalt and Iltnf IU'I'" blr.ln;
It 'ailll,. 10 tak. ptopff t"" 10 mllt. tilt bulkU",
tlfWtVlf ",&\t,1J/ {If 'yWl... fhal ,.1I11ld 'IMk 'Itllll.ltf;
" JI.lIl1;J!iJ w. ,t., IIld ~ '1191 10 ,nv..
UI4 ~yttlm. rtWA,~ fjf .,.... "om '$II/hi W 4/f1lm.
. .
'~IM~lt.
. ,
\6. As D result ,If \)c(cndllnt's misconduct, Plaintiff suffered severe and
disabling Injuries. Including bulnolllmiled 10, Injuries to his nerves, bones. muscle.. joinll
and (ucla. pain and sufferlnl. menl,,1 and emotional dislrcu, lome or all o( which arc or ilia)'
be conllnulng In nalure,
17. A. a result of hi, Injurlu, Plaintiff Incurred medical bill. Ind expense. for
clCe. lIt-alment and rehablllllt\on, 100t earnlng'lnd/or carnlna caplcll)' Ind .uffered lOll or
Ufll'. pleuurca and diminution of his dally Ictlvltlca. which ICe or may be contlnulnl In
nature.
WHERBPOllB, Plllntlff demand. Judlment 1,llnst De(endant,lndlvldullIy,
Jointly and/or .everally, In an amount In exces. of $2'IOOO,OO,Ul;lu.lvo or Interest, COlla and
delay damqca. ,
CQUl:Q'J11
U. Plaintiff Incorporate. herein by reference th. allelatlons of jlll..raphll
throulh P II It tully lOt ronh at I.nl\h.
Ill. The Re.lllenee. welcuneu and recklellMII or O.(endant, Included:
A, Pallln, 10 keep. proper lookoul;
D. PaUln, to warn peUOllJ .uch If rlalnllft or .n
Ulllfl,lOnablt rllk of IIvm from lh4lr COnd~l:
., .
C. AUowllll' pif,ce of COIlstructi(ln lll-l\ffiJl or .upp11ti
to flU and l\tlkl rbll\utf;
f). Fa1lillll In (l~erci$r prollcr cure 111 the pcrflltlllnnco of
wOlk dlltl~' at the date and time nlleeed herein;
I!, I'ailinlllo lAke proper lIeI'I 10 .ccllrclhc bulldlnB
.Iruclurll material or .upplle. thaI fell and .truck Plaintiff;
1-'. Fallin, 10 lAke propor and adequllO 1101" to prevenl
the COIII\nlcllon material or .upplle. trom tallln& and .ulkln,
Plallltlt(,
20. A. a rtault ot Dot.ndant'. mlaconduct, Plalntltf .utfered "\'If, and
dl.abllllllnJurlu, Inelud1na bUI not limited 10, InJurlu to hit nuvu, bone.t, mUIClu, Jolnl.l
.nd fucll, pain and .utterln,. menlll and emotional dl.UOl., .omo or aUof which aro or may
be contlnuln, In nalUro,
,
21. AI a rtault of hi. InJurlo" Plaintiff Incwred medical bill. and OJpelllo' for
CIlO, treatm.nl and rohabllllallon, 1011 earnln,. and/or earnllll capacity and .uff_ed IOJ' of
lifo'. pl.duro. and diminution of hit dally actlvllleJ, which are or m.y b. condnulnlln
nalure,
WIIURBP01U1, Plalnll(f demand. Judlmontasahut Dofendant, Individually,
Jolnlly and/or ..v.rally,t" an amount In execll of SH.OOO.OO,.xclu.lvo of InlOreal, co,u and
delay dama,",
TRUE COf'Y Ff'OM ReCORD
III Ttll;mony wlltr"', II;',. I/lltO Uf my hi"'"
.nd IIl~ .,.1 of....Jd Cotlll ., C"U.I,. ",
;~t ",.l.J,~~" dfy o~""'" I ",y..{.
~.a.,,,,,,-!,,,;JIY:', ,X?}
,f 'ro1h.wtol.rf
MOROAN A MOROAN, P.C.
1'^1I0 .,~l>.::,....J-~,~, \'\ ',:':'b,.."."=
, ,
v.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAD
OF CUMPERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
9S-200 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL OF TWELVE DEMANDED
DOMIt/tCK PEREZ,
Plaint! rt
WII.Lt^" BTANSFIELD,
w.n. STANSFtIU..D CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and KERRY SI/ENK,
Detendant.
v.
CJlARLEB C. LOOSE AND
SON, INC.
Additional Detendant
COMPLAINT OP WILLIAN ITANIPIILD AHQ
W. ,. 8TAN'~II~D CONSTRUCTION OOM~ANY. DIPINDANTI
u...
gQ!~~IS O. LOOII AND SON. INO. ADDIT~ONAL D,PINDANT
Det.ndanta, WilliaN stanati.ld and W. R. Stanafield
conatruotion company, by and throu9h th,ir attorn.ya, Landi.,
Blaok , 8ohorpp, h.reby a..nt tho tollowin9 oomplaint aqa1n.t
Additional DOf.ndant, Charle. c. Loa.. and 80n, tno,
1. D.fondant William Itan.tield i. an adult individual
t..idtno at 3672 aptin; Road, Carli.l., PonnaYlvania.
2. Detendant W. R. stan.ti.ld con.truotion Company i. a
.ole proprietorahip own.d by WilltaN stanlti.ld wlth ottlo.. at
3672 sprlnq Road, corlllle, p.nn.ylvanle.
J. Addltional Det.ndlnt Chlrl.. C. Loo.. end 80n, Ino, i.
a corporAtion ~oln9 buetn... in 'ann.ylvanla with e prinoipal
orrtoo at ~o W..t Ptoovar Avenu., Kyaratown, Lebanon County,
I'elln"v I viHlI I; 1 'I lit.' .
4. There is attachod hereto IlII KlChibi t "A" and
incorporated herein by roforonoo. a true copy of ft complaint
riled by Dominiak Peroz, Plaintirr again.t William aton.rield, W,
R. ptan.rield Con.truction company and ~erry Ph.nk, O.rendant..
8. At the timo, date and plaoe allegod in plaintier's
Complaint, the Oerendant was the owner at a crane utilized at thl
job .ite for the purpo.e of hoi.ting wooden roof tru.... into
pOlition on a re.idential garage under conltruotion.
6. At the time, date and plaoe alleged in Plaintiff's
Complaint, the operator ot .aid ~ran. was an agent, .ervant
and/or employ.e of Additional Defendant, and ha acted et all
time. material hereto within the cour.e and .cope ot his agenoy
or employment with Additional oef.ndant.
7. At aaid time and place, Additional Detendant'. orane
operator hoi.ted a wooden tru.. over the garage, which tru.. wa.
ultimately to be .eoured in place by Defendant William Itan.rield
and hi. other employ... working on th_ .lte.
8. At .aid time and plaoe, Additional DeCendant'. operator
relea.ed .aid wooden true. tram the crane cabl' b.tore .aid
operator obeervea and aecertained that oerendant stan,ri.ld and
hi, employe., had aecurod and/or atablliz.d .ald tru., in
podUon.
9. At aaid time and place, Additional D.tendant'. operator
did in t.ot rol...e trom the crane cable the wooden tru.. prior
to the true. belnQ handled And/or otherwi.e ..cur,~ bV Ottendlnt
nt^n~tl~l~ ftnd hi" employ.on,
..1.'''--.
10. To the eKtent that the acoident d.soribed in
Plaintiff's complaint oocurred, and if .aid Plaintiff received
any injurie. as sot forth in said complaint, .aid injuri.. and
resulting damaqe. are the .ole result or the neqliqenco of the
Additional Defendant. The ne91iqenoe of the Additional Defendant
consi.ted of the tollowinql
A. tn negliqently, reckl.s.ly and careleSSly
relea.ing from the orane cable support the wooden tru.s
whioh ultimately struck Plaintitt, betore properly
ascertaininq and contirminq that the truss had been .ecurad
or stabiliced by Detendant stansfi.ld and his employe..,
8. tn tailinq to properly observe the work in prooa..
.nd in r.l...inq ..id tru.. botore it wa. properly ..oured
or .tabl1hed/
C. In neq1iqently r.1ea.inq ..id wooden truss from
the orana cable without tir.t havinq rtceiv.d a .i9nal Or
oth.r indioAtion from Detendant stan.field or hie employe..
that ..id tru.. WaR .ocured or .tabllh.d in placlI
D, In tailinq to u.. du. oar. und.r th.
olrcum.tanco.,
E. In tailing to follOW the usual and customary
.atety procedure, tor holstinq and 'rtctinq WoodIn tru....
at . con.truction sit., and
r. In ta111n\J to tallow all lawtU1 r1quhtione
p'rtAlnln~ to the hol.tlnq and erectlng ot woodon or It.llar
truI... At 1ah etten.
11. The DeCendant avora that if the plaintiff sustained any
1njuri08 or damagos, a. allogod, tho samo ware caused a. a roault
of tho solo neQligenco of tho Additional Defendant in tho mannar
in which it. employee su.ponded 8aid tru..es, all a. de.oribed
IIbove.
12. Defendant. believe, and therefore aver, that Additional
Defendant il lolely relponsible to the Plaintitt, and there tore
further avere that .aid Additional Defendant is alone liable to
the Plaintift for the cause ot action deolared upon.
13. Alternatively, if the plaintiff i_ entitled to any
reliet, Additional DeCendant is jointlY liable there tor with
Derendants Williem Stan_tield and W. n. stanstield Con_truction
Company, or is lilble over to Defendants Willilm stan.rield and
W. n. Stan.rield Con.truction Company, so that Defendant. William
Stanatiald and W. R. stan.tield Con.truction company demand
judgment in tholr tavor, tOQether with the co.t of thi. aotion,
and, in the alternative, demand contribution or ind.mnity tram
Additional Detendant, Charl.. C. Loo.. and 80n, Ino., tOQether
with the oo.t. at thie Aotion.
LANOts, BLACK , SCIlORPP
Jy~4:~
Edward 1;. chorpp q.
Attorney. tor Defendants
,
YERlrICATIOlt
I verity that the anawers and atat.m.nt. oontained
herein are true and correct. I understand that tala. .tatements
herein are made subject to the penaltias ot 10 Pa.C.8,A. 14904,
relatinq to un_worn
W. R. STANSFIELD
CONSTRUCTION CO~PAN '
D)'I
patedl
,- ~O - 'rS-
DOHJ/flCl< I'IPltZ,
PlatntHt
I IN Tilt COUItT 01' COMMON 1'1.1t^"
, or CUHPXPtAUU COUNTY,
I I*r:N.llnV^Ul^
I
I ,o-aoe QIVIL TURM
I
I JURY TPIAL or TWILV' DIKANDID
I
,
,
,
I
,
,
I
v.
WILLIAM .TAN.FlILO,
W.It. ITANlrIILO COH.TRUCTIOH
COHPAHY and MEltleY IlllHK,
Der.ndlnt.
v.
CIiARU. ". l.oon AND
'ON, life.
Additlonll Ofrendlnt
QIII1I1Ql'l Q. ...yrql
I h.r.by o.rel1y that I QOPV of the ro'.;ol"9 daou..nt,
COH'I.AIMT
WI' ..rvt4 thl. dA" by d.po.itl", .... ln the ,o.t orrioe .t
CI,11.1e, rann'rlv,nle, tlr.t-oll.. ..11, po."" pr.paid,
.ddr.'..a I' rollow"
'oot\ W, "or,.n, '.q.
Mor,.n . MOrtln, ..C.
\20 'outh Itr.et
tfurhb\lr,, rA lnOI-IUO
'flllOthr ., "'1'., 1:'11'
etldw. 1 . ~.rn'
J.,1 North rront .tr..t
IUlffhlllif41, VA \1UO"U}}
.1,,," 'he"l ClII'
Nl1"n, .I"f, MQ.k~wltl, 14.1..n . Dlok.,
~ CUrtl. C.nt.r, ."1'. .)0
Ut4.p.MenM IfiltSar. ....,
rhI114.1,blt, fA "10'
~Ol', .tAC~ . ,cno."
~e~~~...
.._ ,f;'. 0- ...._-',,__..\.,
Itt .. .. . . / ,_.,. .
F.1.,,,,.1 L ;;,,'hI. J'I'I 10'1-
IL" ',,1,
A.;h.~,N ti'~.~ ~Pjr..,F
'"1 . ~.."" E rr~
, ,
MOIIOAN iii. M()fUMN, I',C,
/IV: scorr w, MOJW^N, F~f)!lIlW
IDEN11PICATION NO JIm I
120 SOlJll1 ~ner.T
J1^,uusnURO, "^ 17101.U10
(717) 2)6.79'9
^,'rOkNBYJ fOR I'LAINTll'fI
...-,-,~. . .~- ~. -~-
.".__J. c. 1
~ ~~. ._.... ~.~.Il~.,.~\~._,ll~ ,_lIe
I>OMINICK Pl!lUlZ
201 Mulbffry Orlv.
Jlml,bur., PA,
IN TUft COURT 01' COMMON rU^'
CUMPftRl.AHD COUNTY, I'IHNA,
NO, 1M, -Xt'l ~ (~.>>(~
Plalnliff
I
I
I CIVIl.. ACTION. LAW
I
I JURY 1JIAL 0' TWBLVa DIMAHOIO
y,
WILl.IAM STANSPII!LD
3672 'prill' RoAd
Call1tlf, rA 1101,..704
and
,
W, It STANS'IIU,D CONSTRUCTION
COMI'ANY
3m 'prln. ..,
Culld., rA 1701'
and
Kt:UkY JIIIINK
)OM Roll A \lfl\llf
N.w ClImblftllld, "^ 11()'10.
U,,.,.,.
~Oltct
Yw M" I;IJItIJ '.1114 '# f,1if#1 It ~ w~1J 10 ,,*f4f14 ~ "'* .111".. Nt
t/!/fJl; .,. ,w,' tIJ#/qw~ ,.p.., ~,~ 1/'rI"'~ I~Jr illiUlHJ ."lIIIlfj Wt4M'! (ll11l#.ty. .",., rJHt
~"'I\f1W(f#,""" tIUl'll4 .,,, ""'11/1' If'! l/ffflfif'!l, 4 ..,,,f/ffl tWtW_w.4 tlfftfHNl/y 'II !,y ~IN"''I
VJ' /ilHHI ;4 w'ltillf w.u. ffI!J ~1J;ifl, 'Ifill' ,t.!I'ftlolilf f;f rAtJ#!<"'4f14 rq .,.. ~w~ M' flNlIJ _,'1M'
'f'''' y~ *'. '~*,"'I' liI.j;! ,., '1"" I+~ ,.. ,/;0, "'~ If.q Hi4!M11 ~''I/;IfJfl' W~+I- 'tf!l+ fI!4,
j..ia'....... "'''I t..J .y~I4'1 .(,p,~f..,,,. '-, <A,f' ;!h'" ..4>.... ~:>i(......F ~;(i" f<.4 ~I ~J
";,,,""1 Iii I~ 'I""1'M'M ~f 1<" ,;",~...... .,;f'" ... f,{~, ~'f,!,.n,'<14 lrt Wi t~,ff 'r;.tt w..t'j
), ,,~ ""'f_""li't ,,,J f-"'1fiiH+ .,~ ..-1t...;;;,. .";;,... ,~~__ _ti ;.;<;) F"~;
HI" fit" ~
.
" , f"
. ',' '.
YOU SHOUl.!) T^Kl! TillS I'M'Ut TO YOUlt L^WYflt AT ONCE, II'
YUU DO NOT /lA VB A LA WYlllt Olt CANNOT AfFORD ONE. 00 TO OR
TI,UH'1I0NU TUB Of PICE !ILl')' fORTII UflLOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN
(lET LEOAl. IU!I.!'.
Cumberland County Court AdminiStrator
Cumbtrllnd County Courthoul'
fourth Floor
OM CoUrthoUI' Squar.
Carlltl" PA 17013
(717) 697.l137 J
A.mQ
1A Iw\ dtmlndado IIltItd .n II cono. Sllltlfd def.Jldtrtt cSt ,,1&1 demandu
e.l'u"lIl .ft Ilw p.,lnu .I,ult""', ulltd II.", ",1"11 (20) diu de ploo al partlt de la (oehl
d. I. dtmanda '11IllOClneacton, Hact (alII wnw 111\1 colllpattllClI eICllla 0 tlI ptttonl 0
con un lbo.ado 'I tllU",u I II corle ,"10111I1 ucrlll .u. d.r'llI11 0 lilt obJOClontlllu
domand.. .11 contra d. .u ponolll, Sea Ivltad<t qUf Illltltd 110 " dtt'lendt. I, COtIIlO/lIl;la
meillllll y ,,\ltd. conllnlllf la demand. .n conu-a .uy. .In pr.vto IVIlo 0 nolltlcaclon.
Ad.f11II, I. corlt puedt deQOdOf I flVOl dtl d.mandanlt 'I ffqultrt qut UJItd cum, II COil
todu law I'rovl.loM. de 1111 d.manda, UIIfd putdt pordtr dlMro 0 .11I pfopltdldt. U OlfO.
der'-chollm!'OfllnlfJ par. 1II1fd,
LLHVB I!$T^ OIlMANDA A UN A8ooADO INM2DlATAMIlNTIl. II NO
TWNI: AIIOO^OO 0 51 NO TlnN!: fLOINBKO SlJlflCU!NTl! Of rAOAk TAL
SliM Vlca, V A YARN rflUON^ 0 LLAMU rOR TBLEfONO A LA OPICINA cur A
I>IUHCCION sa !NCUI!NTRA IlSCRIT^ ^BAJO PARA AVIiRIOUAR OONDlllll
Jj\JBPR CONJBOUIR ,ulm1NC'^ l.oo^L.
Cum\)frllnd CoIInty Coun Admlnlault()f
Cumbtflllld County Courthoult
founll Ploor
OM CwrtOOvH 'qull.
Clllillt. VA 110.,
(711) 691-O)71
. .
"
, ",.,
. It.
t ", ....
II, The Mg.lir,cncc. carclellllen And reckle',nllu of I.)c(clldanl, Included:
A. Fllilillg 10 keep A (!foper lookout;
11. Pa1linllto warn (lcrlOIl' Mh .a l'I.lnlll/ 01 an
ummonable rl.k or hArm (rom their conduct:
C. AUowln. a piece of cOllnructlon material or luppllc.
10 tllll and Ilrlke Plalnllff;
0, 'alllnllO uerelto proper CArt In tho perrormanet of
work dutle. at tho dalO and limo a1lo,ed hlfoln;
B. PalllnllO 1Ak. proper .!tp.1O .ocllr. \110 build In,
.tnlcwrl material or .uppllca \IIat r.1I and .truck Plalntlft;
F. Pall In, to like propes and adoqualO .\tp' 10 pr.vent
\h. COIlllJ\lctlon material or lupplle. from fallin, and ,"lilq
PI.lntiff.
I', Ala re.ult o( Oorend.nt'. mlJCOnduct. Plalnliff .u(tmd ..WIland
dlaabllnl InJurltl, Includlnl bul hOlUmlled 10, InJurltJ to hil norvel, bon.., mUICI.,.1olnll
and fucla, pain .nd .uffnl"., menlll and emollQnal diatrou, .om. 0( allot whleh 1ft Of may
be c.onllnuln.ln naluro.
I), AI a fflull (If hi, inJurlea. Plainliff Incurred modlcal bill. and upt/IIQ (or
care, lIulm.n! and r,habilltatlon, I<ul wnlll" .nd/or .arnl", cap"'IY and Miffed 1011 o(
11(,'a pl.~vrf' 1114 dlm/nUlio" of hi, dally "IIV/llft. whkn." or m.y" cond/lllln. h.
nll\/f"
WIIFlHTOIW.I'lailllirr demand. judllment .,.inu Defendant. Individually,
Jointly and/or ICverally. in an amounlln cmeu o( $2'.OOO,OO,o~clull\'e or in!erell. CO'II and
do lay dama,.,,
to.UliUI
14, Plllnll(( IncorporalO. herein by re(ercncotho 111'1111001 of pltllrlph. 1
throu.h 9 u If tully ..I (orlh 111.nath.
.,. Th. MIII,.lICIt car.I,,11\II1 and rockJeUMIt of Oetendanl, Inclu4ed:
A. '111 In. 10 k..p I pr""r lookoul;
D. Plilln.1O wltn perlOlII'uch u Pllinllrt of In
uIVouonable rl.k of harm from lbtlr conducl:
C. Allowlnl' plect of coNltUellon mllOrlal or .lIppllo.
10 (alllnd au",. Plalnllff:
D. PIli In, 10 lI.rel.. proper Clt. In tII. p.rform..," of
work dUlltl al tIIo dllf Ind 11m. IU".d he,.ln;
n. Plilln, 10 lake prop.r .I'p, 10 IOcur. Ih. build In.
.lr",eMe mllOrl.ll,lr lupplle. thll f.lllnd .lflKk l'lalnli((;
f/, '111111,10 &all.pr"Ptr alld adequ.1t 'ffp. 10 provenl
lII4 eOfl.'I1'Kllon lllllOr'" (If .upplle. trom. 'alUn. .IId ""I~ln,
"laW.lff "
. .
1 (j, ^~ a rClillt of I)efend:tnt'a misconducl, Plainllff suffered seVero .nd
di!abllnllinjuries, Including but not Iilllitcd to, injuries 10 his nerves, bonos, musclol, jollll.l
and fascia, pain and sufferin., mental and emotional dimeSi, lome Of all of whICh IIrc or may
be continulnllln natufe,
17. AlII result or hi. InJurle., PI.lntiff incurred medical bill. and cxpellltl for
care, treatmenl and rehabllllAllon. 10.1 carnine' andlor earnlna capacity and suffered Iou of
lifo', plcuure. and diminution of hi, dally actlvitlcs, which arc or may bo continulna In
naNro.
WHEIU!FORB. Plaintiff demand. Judamcnt "alnu Defendant. IndivIdual I)',
jolnlly and/or .ov.rally, In an amount In Ollecll of U'.OOO.OO.lllclu.lvo of InlOl..t. c:oIl.I and
del.y damalN.
,
tQ1I1aJJ1
I'. PlalnUff Incorporale. heroin by reference tho allcl.llont of paralraplu 1
Ihroulh 9 u If fully 'II forth allenllll.
19. Tho ne,ll,.nco, careluaneu and reckleunm of Defendant, Included:
A. 1',lIln,to keep a proper lookout;
P. 'allln, to W8In persollsfllCh AI PI,loII(( ot '0
Ull1wonable rLtk of hum frollllMl1 condlj(t;
. .
C. Allowin, a plue of c(lnslI"'t\Qn m.tIlrill or 111:991;,.
\(1 f.U .l1Ij Unk, .'l.ln\lff;
11. l'nilln/llo ul'Il:isu prnl'cr ~'are in tho p('rlormanet) ot
W()lk dUliel atlh\! dale and time alleged herein;
Il, fallinlllo 1.1kc pl'l'()cr Iteps 10 lCCUrll lhe buildlnc
Itructura material or sllppliol tllal (ell and struck Illalntiff;
F. Failing to taka proper and adequato 1I0plto prevent
tho COlUlructloll malerial or lupplles from fallln& and lulklna
Plaintiff.
20. AI a relull o( Derendanl'l mllconducl, Plalnllfr .u(rcred .evero and
dlsabllna lnJurlea, lncludln, bUl nOlllmlted 10, Injurle. to hi. nerve.. bone. I mu.clea, jolnll
and (ucia. pain and Iu(rerln" menIAl and emotional diltfell, .ome or all of which are or may
be eonllnulnlln nalure.
.
21. A. a relull of hi. InJurie" Plaintiff Incurred medical bill. and expelUeI for
care, treatmenl and rehabilitation, 1011 wnln'l and lor earnln, capacll)' and .uffered 1011 of
\ife '. plumel and dlmlnullon of his dally activities, which are or may be conllnuln, In
nature,
WUBREI'ORll, Plalntlf( demand. Judlment al\alrul De(endant, Individually,
Jointly andlor severally, In an amount In exem of n',ooo.OO.oxclullvc of lnlorolt, COIU and
delay damagel.
iHUE COpy FltOM R~CORO
,,, Ttltlmony whtlOC', I htl, UIlto "' my /!troll
.nd rhc ICII?l.slld Cavil ., Cedltl" Po,
:' , HHJJ~~" doy ol~..",,,,, 19..?.r.
~!I!..,..J{, :tdr;,,,~
,f "Otl.~..'Y
MORO^N & MOROAN, r.c,
IWI hP
I)..., t L ,,''',
,.............-,.,_- .~T-<'..=.~~<_""""."',......,
I
n
II
l
I
II
Ii "UBOII, ILBIR, MOBllO"ITI, IDILICAH . DIOnR
II BY' Bernd a. Heinu, Eequire Attorneye for Additional
I' John D. Shea, Eequire Defendant Charlee C. Looe.
',ill IDENTIFICATION NO. 40670/74627 and Bon, Ino.
TilE CURTIS CENTER - SUITE 830 EAST
il INDEPENDENCE SQUARE WEST
Ii PHlLADELPIlIA, PA 19106
II (215) 627-6900
i
ji
DOMINICI< PEREZ
Plaintiff,
p
v.
i
H
:: WILLIAM STANSFIELD,
W.R. STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION
,
:1 COMPANY and l<ERRY SHENI<,
Ii Detendant.,
,
v.
i CHARLES C. LOOSE AND SON, INC.
Additional Defendant.
:1
,
ii
II BENCHMARK HOMES INe. ,
'I Additional Defendant
I,
il
II
Ii
'I
11
.I
1
I,
II
,I
,
;1
v.
,
,
,
,
,
.
,
,
,
,
.
I
I
.
I
I
.
.
.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON
PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND
COUNTY, PENNsYLVANIA
95-200 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL TERM - LAW
JURY TRIAL OF TWELVE
DEMANDED
QIITIrICATI or IllVIOI
I, John D. 'h.a, lequire, attorney tor additional detendant
Charle. C. Loo.e and son, Ino., do hereby oertity that a true and
II correot oopy of the Joinder complaint of Additional Detendant
:1
,
.,
Charlee C. Loo.e and 80n, Inc. A9alnat Additional Detendant
Dench.ark 110"', Ino. wu ..rv.d upon the tOllowin..., parU.. on
May 21, 1996 by tir.t 01... ..il po.teve pre-paid.
'cott W. Morvan, E.quire
Morvan . Morvan, P.C.
laO south str.et
Hlrr1.bur9, PA 17101-1310
WIiIOfi. HIIII. MoIUlWIIl. UltlMAfi' fl'(.'" . 'It. (;tl""1 elfin" . Will eJO IAI'
\fiO""",OI-.c, "OW'''I WIll' . ,..",Atitl"','A, I'A "'Oll
d
II
!:
d
n
II
!i
'I
II
!<
I
~
,I
II
:1
\1
~i
,I
jj
~
fl
r
,!
!
~i
~
ff
2j
~ DA'I'II
i
"
j
H
~
:!
II
I
,
j
;
~
i
~
1
i
.,
,
,
1
:.:.iIIL
~
Ti.othv 1. Mark, I.qulr.
e.ldw.11 . MI.rn.
'1'1 North Front .tralt
MarrilbUr9, PA 1'110-113'
Edw.rd ~, .chorpp, I.quir.
Landll, alack . lohorpp
'I 'outh Hanovlr lir'lt
C,rlilll, 'A 1701'
'Inoh..rk Hoa.., Inc.
110. R.n. Villa AVlnul
ea.p Hll1,'A 11011
(To 'I '.rved Iy .hlrl"
of CUabtrland county)
e. ~.-: 'L-
J n D. lei, I.qu r.
tiornlV 'or Additional
Oe,.n4.nt Chlrl.. 0, LoO..
and 'on, Ino.
~~. ..... M(~("...f1 tlihllM.... k.... . ,... f''''~ u..,.. . "".. tJ<t ,"t
M\f,-.llMt\/<(. \(l\,"-' .....' . ""'" ......"'... .... 1"041
, ";. ~ l' I ~j II I II fl.,1,,,~1 jljlli' II' t'i\ ...
'ON_ '''''''''$1''\111~\4
~'........ ;....lj, ""'" I'....W
I )()\IINI(,K "'HUll.
I'lainlilf
IN 11111 ('OURT Of COMMON PU!A- OJ!
nJMlJl:RLANO rOlJNTV.I'RNN!lVIN ANIA
nVIL AC'lION . LAW
Nt) <I~.:(lO ('IVIL TIlRM
\'
WILLlM.1 !iT ANSFIIlW
W R liT ANlifmLU fONSTKlJC'TION
COMI'ANV and KllKKY SII1!NK.
f),r,ndinlt
\'
rllAKlHII (' t..()()"ll AND liON, INC'.
^ddllklllillH~aflt
\'
III NCUMARK 110\1111. INC' ,
J\ddltltlAll Of(fIllhnI
J\JRV TRIAL DIMAND'D
~
IU 'If(f, PMnmONOT^"" of nJMPI{RLM..P fOIJN'fV
t:ntff IIw 'WW-, of MAl\ nON. I)MJUXUUt'. WILLIAM. . uno ill IItfWt llf
t\ddlllooll o.~ ~ IkilM_, 1fl4l 1II tllt.. malt"
"'AfU!iUN, "I!MUM)R". WIU.JMI." 0"0
lii .a \'
"'f.;t~k{~"r~~_~~.
~ K 1...,,,,1I1f r~;(f;"
It) Nit 111)1
f", Ii... t f.lttlt "'f'"
(' .,..., '" 17/l I J
l1!n :,. J<1H I
Nkff/lln'. ~ Nhhl#JI!M. ~M
......... IkllM-. "..
l~ _'-1M
CI1/f,TIFIl't\TI! nil ~1'llVIC~
1 hlrtby <<I1i~ lhal. '''lp)' ordw ftlf~pln>> Ilflfi:ipt Wit I.~td Ihl. d... by 4.po.lIl", ..m.
in lilt POll OIlk..1 (.'arllil.. I'A. flul d... ma.l. l'llil'II' p'.paid. .dd"."" .. rollow.
Tllnlllhy I M'fk. I:aqllir.
(' AUlWl!L1. " KI!ARNS
JM I NlInh film' !iUNI
Il.rrl.buf.. I'A 17110
S~(lll W Mot.,n. IZaqlll"
MORnAN " MUKOAN. I' ('
1%0 811Ulh 8lfHl
lIatrllblUII. PA 17101,1%10
~dwatd I. "dI(IfPP till"'''
LANDI!, hL.At'K A 8CIIORI'I'
J(J 8wlh tlwwlt' lIlIHI
C'1I11,1.. I'A 170 II
JpM () 8hq. l:lqIIIr.
WILSON. EUllk. MO!iKOWITZ. liUlil.MAN A PICKfik
TtIt ('UI1I. ('.IItIt' . 8uil' 110 I!.I'
11Idt~ lIqUJI. Witt
l'hIItdf1pm. M 1 Q HttI
MAlUliON. UMkUORff', WILl-IAM!J " OTTO
'Iy_ ~J .\kr~.,"~(~~=-
IWlIfI K UwdPrlf, t:tq\l~-tQ
Tfft eM( Iti.h .,,",
('at1ItIt. J'.\ I1lJ II
(717) :.....HI
AlI4"/lft1 ((I, A44!1k,"" u.~
Bft!{IlmM" Uo",,,, 111/I
."...., "- 1. 1'*
t~. .T'
''4 ;;
t'it, ~.~ '.4<
t ,.. . 11'~
IL'- "i "!' .~
/,1
I.' "., .
(. .J!
;.. I . "
ul,. ;f; t;J
;.....; u.-
H... ~n
t,,; ,,1;
..;'>'" ",,' ~r__ ,~.-t~" - t~ ~ ~. -~,> ~ .",,,,,_,~_~a-_...,~,;j 1Zt~i7k:ai\f"~.~"'Y'~N7"'o '_"..
(lj~ 'I · ~
~a I ~ j l\ ! 8
~~~~ I ~1 a .~ .l1\ili~
~ ~ dn ~' ~ 81 ~ 1 . i G ~
I
~i~g I ~I~ I I fl ~
;:":". ."~",',.'~:A',;:/,;':;,!~_"';"&-_;;.;<#A:e?"_&"~"'-A1tm:'r1,;",, .,;",n"'_,,;ii2;i:>Ai;_;;,,_"'.,g.~k:;'., '",~~~::~ --"C _ r-'">" !7
''''<r': O:.'1~' ~'iW.~..
.
. 1I11'~.ll.U
... .. '. ~ - ..
17 lIenehm..k I, enlllled 10 Immunit)' blUed Oil Iho Wlltke'a' ('ompell'lllIm Ael
III Tho leli,'n Illinll lIenchma,k I, bmed b)' Ihe 1IIIulo ofllmilalhltll
19 Tho joinder ofllenclunlfk WII nol pwper.
20 l'llinliffallll teh"'lnllirnea IIlUn"d Iho rllk of Injury.
21. l'lalllllff al III tel,vallllimel WII "ltIlribullllily nelllill'"'
22 l'lalllllfl',llljufl'l wefU ,'auaed by Iho ICIIIlIII of olhm
WIII!IUlI'ORI!. Add!llllnal Uefendlnl llenehmllk 1I0mel, Ine demllldl judllm.nlin h,
llsvllr
NF\I( ~1t\1)"Elt Ie/TIlE Nt\T\JRI1 OP CR(~SS.CI.AIM
A(J1\I~ST ()T\mR Q~FENP~N~S t\Np ADI)ITIO~AL.I)l!~I!"'P{\NI I.OQ$ll
2.1 In Iho "''''I ill. de1ennlned Ihll Additlollall>.f,ndlnlllellehmark &tIed IIellllllenll)',
'>Atelo..I)'. rCl;kleuly .nd wllhoul duo w.ln .ecllrdll\(O wllh hi eonlllclual, '1llUlol)' .nd "i'l\1l1lOn
law dUll" and rraponaibilillel wilh felpeel h.l Ihf "e1dent II all'lled In Plllnlllfl ('ol\1plllnl. all
tlf whk:h havinll hrrelofor. \leen denied. lhen Ih, olh" I),fendlnll Ind Additional Def,nd.nl L,lOlO
would b. Ilabl. over III AdditloNlllel\'fIdanl 1I'l\(hm.,k I' Of eontribulllln .nd/or IndemniOcallon
411\ Iho bllll of avermenla mad. alllinlllhem in PI.intlff, ('omplllnl .nd lho Addillun.1 D,f.ndanl
(' olllPlllnl
WIIHRHI'OIUi. AddlllllNIU.fe41d.fIlUelWhm.rk. If,hund whnll)' (If p.nlally r"PI,n.ibl.
fill 1IlailllUra .1I'(led InjUfl... IN'" Ind.mni~.lllIn .ndlllr ~lI\lrlbull(ll\ Ihlln Addlllolllllltf.ndanl
Lilli.. and Ih. olh., I>.lfndanll
IhtPklAllly IUhmill....
~1.~KTSUN. Ul!AKUOIUlr, WlI,\.I^MS " ono
II'JJ:/;:ddt~~----
II) Nil 171117
T m I;,.. 1I11th StH,,1
r"Il.-". M 170Il.J(I'I)
(117)%4l.J""
AII4ll11Q' fit( A44lt~ Off~
8.-Mwk tl4i4tWi, ''''
Uil~ J~ 1, II;llJ(\
VJlIUI1ICATION
Oanlel K UeardllffT. Hlqulre, of Iho Orm uf MARTSON. OEAROORffl.
WILLIAMS" OTTO. allorneYI nlr lIen~hmark I1nme.. Ine In Iho wllhln a~llon. tOnlOellhallhe
.talement. mad. In lho fi1rolllllnll Additional ()efend.nt nen~h,"lIk 1100101, 'ne 'I Anlwer with New
Maller 10 Addillunal Defendant Charlea C. 1.00Je and Son, Ine 'I Joinder Curnplalnl ar.INC and
currocl lOlhe btll of hll knowledllo. InfilrOlallon and belief 11. undentand. Ihal falae Ilalernen"
herein arc mad. JUbjoct 10 lhe penaltlea of 'I'la CS Soclion 4904 relalln>> lu un.worn fal.IOcallon
to aUlhorltlet.
ru " ,/
O.niel K Oeardorlt Eaqulr. t
CERl'IrlCATE or Sl!IlVICll
I herolly certil)' thai a ~py IIftho fhrelloil111 Additional Uefendant Benehmafk lIorno..lnc'.
A/llwer wilh New Maller to Addilill/1allJefendant Charlel C. LootCI and Son, Inc', Joinder
Complaint Wllserved thi. dato by depolltinfl .arno in the 1'011 omeo at Carli lie. ItA, Onl cia.. maU,
pOllallo prepaid. addfe..ed a. follow.
Tirnothy I. Mark, nlquire
C ALUWI!t.L "" KIiARNS
363 I Nonh Fronl Slrcel
lIarri.burll. ItA 17110
Sellll W Morflan. Ii.quire
MOROAN"" MORClAN, I'C.
120 South Slreet
lIarrlaburll.I'A 17101.1210
Edward L. Schorpp, I!lquiro
LANDIS. BLACK" SmOR"p
36 Soulh lIanover Slreet
Caflllle,PA 1701l
John U Shea. Elquirt
WILSON. BLSHR., MOSKOWITZ. l.!Om.MAN &\ DICKER
The Curtil Cerller . Suit. 110 na'l
Independence Squart We.t
I'hUadelphla, I' A I Q I 06
MARTSON. I>I!ARDORFJ1, WILLIAMS" ana
lIy_~J~~~N"'_'___
Uanlel K I>tardorn: nlquirt
IIlNlII7Il7
1'.n f.,.llIi,h 5U"1
C..IlIl.,I'A 1701l
(717) W.U41
AIIUlllfYa Ii" A4dilioAall>ettndMl
IJwhmat1l1olllfl. Inc
lla'fd J\IIW 1. 1\1%
. . . / . ,
, , ...~ ~I ." " 'I'
..... .,
!, (-.I
h(! '~~ i,\
-\ . ':;-
l. . ~ . Ii
lJf ;-.
, , I.!J
f~, ~. ;- .! '..
b..1. i-. f}l
I. &.'l : :'...
II. VI '.,
II U' IJ
........... .... .~""..".~."'""";~.~"..".'''''.=..''''''~'~ .0~~',...<-,~~"'~,.~,.,"-~"...=_~_."" ~._~_._" I...._"""___--~-~
~ Ii ~II ~ ~ I R
I~m ~1 d~.a i. ~~~!i
. I a ~ ~ glHl i ft ~~
55 r1 'n ,;] fi 11'1
.;g~ I di i I J f!'~
~,. ..._"")1);"..;......-.~.,v_,,-.:_;.-'\!:'h,R':'o.t,...:r__k"f-_':;":>;.;."'''::v,....-.:-"'c__._.r:;.;'lI"'t'/'.-,:&",;;.--'~..:z;..,:.._. ."~~ ~ r.' .~
_-:-l~,,"" 1 ~-~:;.
~ . (I
. I.
I
I
il
p
;1
I:
,I
II WILSON, ILSBR, MOSKOWITZ, BDILMAN
Ii BYI Bernd G. Heinze. Rsquire
:1 John D. Shea. Rsquire
~ Identification Nos. 40670/74627
1:,." The Curtis Center e Suite 830 East
Independence Square West
Philadelphia. PA 19106
ii (215) 627-6900
iI
I'
II
H
:1
iI
"
:1
:i
i
,
,
r. DICKIR
Attorneys for Additional
Defendant
Charles C. Loose and
Son. Ino.
IN THB COURT OP COMMON PLBAS
OP CUMBBRLAND COUNTY.
PENNSYLVANIA
95.200 CIVIL TBRM
CIVIL ACTION . LAW
JURY TRIAL OP TWBLVB
DEMANDED
DOMINICK PBREZ.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
.'
Plaintiff.
v.
WILLIAM STANSPIBLD.
W.R. STANSPIELD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and KBRRY SHBNK,
Defendante,
v.
CIIARLBS C. LOOSB AND SON, INC.,
Additional Oetendant
I
,
II
I
Elfl'llY o~ M..P3J.~CI
TO THll PROTHONOTARY I
II Kindly enter our app.aranoe together with ~ury trial
':1
behalf of additional detendant. Charl.. C. Loo.. and Son.
il
I,
n
II
II
I
1
,
I
demanded on
InCl.
RespecttullY sUbmitted.
WILSON, ILlER, MOSKOWITZ.
KOlLMAN " DICKIlR
II
'I
fj
n
il
I _
nd O. Heinz.. asquir.
ohn D. Shea. asquire
Attorneys tor Defendant
CharI.. C. Loo.. and lon, Inc.
By'
i'
l;
H
11
WllaoN U"", MOI~ownl, 'OhM."" (1'(.'" . ,It, (,\11I"" Ufill" . WIt UO,."
Ifi(;tI1N(I.IiIt. IOU,lIl, Willi . ""Ii,llihl'U'.,"A "'iii
hlUIILl. IU .-'LLJ\U
TO h I'IJ7\rrrrF
You IflJ hPll11,; fh1tlflt'1llll 'Ilt.
a ""'"ttollll)"'fll)llM~ 10
ths s"clo..~ tlJ/~lv ",~rrFt::..
'WIUlIn 1311 d.lyl f1f1l11ltIIVlftl hmeol of a
IUlJgltwnt I1hl'1 'IU IllIh"OI' AIl,tllla.1 you
~,,~ ~ S/----
~fltlY r . (/w,,/.... c, 'W'W aHI '~If,.tt...
I
I
Ii
,I
II
II
il,'l' WUSON, ELSER, MOSKOWITZ, EDELMAN
BY, Bernd O. Heinze, Esquire
John D. Shea, Esquire
I Identification Nos. 40670/74627
! The Curtis Center . Suite 830 East
Independence Square West
Philadelphia, PA 19106
(215) 627-6900
NOllel 'u PLI. All
fa 1::l1>'f~Nli"'H1"
You Ala hl'If'li, UlItl'h'lj In !tIll
a 'WlIlh'll 'l'hPqll~... III
Ihs .''''(lOt'1I I-lrw fIIP,TTfR.Crl"'6c1.ATM
WllhHlI~ day. "Pill fiiIJIV!rU h"llIO' 01 II
'Ud\.JIIIVllt IIhl')l 'I" "lIlt'It'd 8\1;1111111 yOu
(':},.- C..:-l:;. '5/....-
AUM7IH; I" r~Q,.lrt' c. .tll>>... ...CooI ~....., T..c .
. DICKER
Attorneys for Additional
Defendant
Charles C. Loose and
Son, Inc.
!I DOMINICK PEREZ,
'I
I
I
Plaintiff,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLBAS
OP CUMBBRLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
95-200 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL OF TWELVE
OKMANDED
v.
WILLIAM STANSFIELD,
W.R. STANSPIELD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and KERRY SHENK,
Defendants,
v.
CllARLES C. LOOSE AND SON, INC.,
Addltional Defendant
ANSWaR or ADDITIONAL DlrlOO)ANT
CIWlLIS C. LOOSl AND SON, INe. TO THI JOINDIR COMl'IoAJNT
or WILLIAM STANsrIILD AND W.R. STANsrllLD COMPANY
TOOITHIR WITH Hint MATTia AND HI1f MATTia
CROSS-CLAIM PQK8UAHT TO paIR,C,P.. RULI a2521~)
Additional derendant, Charla. C. Laale and SOli, Inc.,
(hereinatter referred to a. "additional defendant") by and through it.
,
,
!I attorney., Willon, IUser, Mo.kowltz, KdellMn .. Dicker, and
j
J Pernd O. Heinze, Isqulre, and John D. Shea, I.quir., hereby re.pond.
"
!i
~ to the joinder complaint or William Stansfield and W.K. stan.tield
'I
~ Con.tructlon Company (hereinatter collectively ret.rred to a. -the
it
IllHaneUeld det'Mant.s, u rollow.,
:!
Ii
W"l!)lO tI"", ~()'.(1W'". UllIM".... 0'(:.'" . 1"1 [II"'" (I""" . lV'" no I"U
,fill'PIMlIlOn 'OII"It' wlU . "..,,\f.u.....,, "A "'0"
ii
1";1, Denied. After r...on"ble lnv..tigltion, additiond
IIehndlnt i. without .ufUcient intol1Nltlon with wl\1ch to tom"
'I
'i bellef .. to the truth or fahity of che.. alligation. aOd, th.retare,
! IIenl.. ..me and delllAnd. .trlct proof chu'Qt It trial.
i
i
I
i
1,
Adm! t t ed .
il
;!
i
!i 4, Doni,d, Only a partial QOPY of w~t U purponld eo
i be thl complaint fUe4 by DOllIinlck Ptrl., plalnt Hf, 'flain.t
i
i: WilUam .un.tt.ld, W. It. ltan.ttlld Con.e ructlon Company and
ii
:1 1(1Irry Ihenk, dlfend"nu, i. .Uached to the jolndu complaint I'
,
Ii hhlbtt 'A.' 'a\ll. at the undulyi", pl.lntHf'. cClIIlpl.lnt, which
'!
Ii include par'lJraph' )-10, wnl not atUehttd ., .11I\1ld.
:'
ii Ii. Dlntld. Attu r...onable 1nv..'lv.Uon, additional
H
II deroMant 1, without .uttielent lnforNtlon with which to tOflll .
:1
:: beUef II to thl tf\lth or t.l.hy of tilt.. .UIlIaUan. and, thlfetorl.
"
i l1enle. liMIt And dUlAndll .triet proof cherlor at ui.l.
1
:1
;1
I
I
.. 0.0104. To tho ..t.nt tn... IlllVltlon. eOAteleycI
CCinQ\llllon. 'If l1W, no tlluMr rt'J!'lIl.lvI pl..dloll eMflco i. r'<lllll",-'
: . rid , theretore, th. aU'UilUt1f1. iilfl 4...... d.n'~ And Inlet proof
,
,
! It..rlut 1. dNlAndtd a' trlAl. IV WilY lit furtnn An.wn, .. tn.
~l\.Q.4 '.q.n~. gf t441'i~all 4ff.'~nt ,_ unl4t"tlfi~, In. aY.f__n~
1. ovniy lirQW, ~ly V&1fIl41 &114 hWJI!Il'.'.MMlbl. to .ut;ti an .Jlun.t
I
""'..... h.... M(>!ttl(lW!lj .....1,'14.."....'" , ... """j'.l....lj~ . .,...,tit)',Ut
........."""..... ".",411, ...,~. . P',,, "",......" ..... \.....
that a prol).r re.ppnl1n pl..lUng thereto cannot b, mAd.. Thu., all
allIgation. ot 'av.ney. Ire .p.cltlcally ao4 unequlvocallV denled and
.trict proat thlrlof i. d.mao4.d It triAl.
7,.9, Denied. Aft.r rel.onabl. tny..tlVAtlon, Idd1tlonal
lIehndant 11 without .utrici.nt lntol'1l\Aeion wlth which to rona a
11.11et .. to the truth or fllllty af th... .ll.wation. And, th.retor..
d.nl.. .ame and d.mand. .trlct proot th.r.or.
10, Denl.d. To the extent the.. allegAtlon. con.tleut.
canelu.lon. at law, no further u.ponl1v, pleadlnll th.nto 11 requlnd
and, th.r.fare, the.. 111eg.tion. .re de.~d denl.a and .tr1ct proof
tharaof 1. dMlndea It tr1al. Iy wlY of further re.pon.., .ddltlonal
dafendant .peciflc.llV deni.. 1t, or Iny of it. -.ploy.e., were
<<aUllo,nt, reckle.. or clrele,. a' .lle9~ in the .pecltlc&11y
enumtrAted .ubpara,r.ph. A.r, and d.-an4. .trict proof therlot At
tr1al. IV way of further re.pon.e, Idditional attendant .peelflc'lly
d.nla. that pl.intiff w.. clu..d to lu.taln any injuriel, daMage. or
10.... I' the re.ult or Any .ct, f.11ure co .ct, or -.ploy.. of
Addltional dlfeo4ant, ana d~n4. .trict proof thereof It tr1al,
Hl1r.ovu, a<Witi!)""1 a.r.ooant ....n. it illh4 pflIMntlv, PfQpuly,
;lhll witt, .U du. CAn 1.~h.4 of It dUfl", the nl.vanl it"" Mlnia'
I
i t 1".., .IAI.a in tn. cOIIIJII.lnl, An4 a.Mndt .uiet PI"f 101M
l,!1,lfIlfUY I' ulal,
, },
f\o\tt"" hMlIi. ~m(~" ,,,,,"JI., II "".... . hit ("''''t~ (I""." . ~,.f' .\I(H4~'
OI\of>IiH~IttI'(i\'4'" "'I'll . "''''4,'''~'''' ~ l.l~
11. Doniea. To tho ext.nt tho,. Alleu.tion. con.titut.
condu'ion. of lAw, no turthctr ruponeiv. plci'.dinll thento 1. Hll,uhlHl
/l1l(I, thuefon, no further r..pon.tv. pleAdlnll l' u')uirllt, By WilY ot
further re.pon.., .adltionAI d.t.ndAnt .peclrlcally denl.. that lt Will
ln any mann.r n.ol10.nt Ind rurth.r, thAt plalntift WI' CAu.ld to
'll.tAln .ny lnjuri.., aamage. or 10.... a. the r.,ult or any let,
r31lur. to Act, or ~loy.. or Iddltlonal d.r.r~ot, and d~nd.
.trict proot th.r.or .t trial,
1~.'1), Dlnlla. To tho ..tont tho.. 111~.tion. con.tituto
conelu.lon. or law, 1\0 tUfthu ullpon.1v. pl.adint thereto l' r.quhllll
ilr~, th.r.tor., th4 Illovatlon. aro da~d a,nloa aAd .trlot proot
thereot 1. a.MAna.a a' trtal, If WAY of rurtblr re.pon.., additional
ddendAnt aoot.. it w.. in any NRner novllv.nt a. AUog.d tn thinS
Vilrty plaintifr'. e~l.tn~ And, turchlr, ,pfelfle.l1y ana
une')u &VQcaU)' d.ni.. tM~ In ~h. tVlnt ,t141 aUellltion. or I,,'urt..
~1~l/pr ~,., 111".d In plllncltr', e~laint ar. prov.n truI at
tdal, thAt additioMI a,f,ndant Wil' ln IIny WAY tbl ,oll, pro_ilM~.
And/Qf eOflutwUN, e.\.i" of ~M" lnJurl" ana/or ~\f" Qf ~h4~ H
t. .tth.l' '~ll\)' ltlblt to tht ~1.1ntlfr Of, in thw Alt.fnativl, th4t
It t, in any MInn., Jut"tl)' and/or "vlral1y It.blt with Of llabl.
"'1*1' to 4l1'lIrttl&nt WHUM Mun.Ulhl And/Of W,II. nAnllt.ld
C(Jrltf' rulll hm "~n)', aOO "..Ad. .n ict p.oo' ",ulclI It &flit.
,.t.
~,I~ hM'" W~(6M" tMl........ ~.t. . ,tlt t~f!t tt'!ll,1 . Nlt.. fit!
l!!IIMJPt!l'li!>t".u t(jla. wUI . fWl,At>t\,*",," ,....
WIlKMK'ORI, anawering ad~ltiQnAl defendant .pecitlcally daniel it
,. .Qlely liabl, to the plaintlff or, in the alternatlve, that it i_
In /lny Il\Annu jolntly and/or ..verally liable with or liable over to
<loronctant. WU Ham 'tan.field and/or W. R. Itan.field Con.truct lon
CompAny in any 'UlI\ or 'UIU, and pray. plalntHt'. complaint and t.lle
'(llnd.r cOftlplalnt b. (H.lIIi...d wtth J1rajud1ca, and that additional
rl.rtmdant here1n b. award.d COlte and at torn.v. t.e..
MIlW MATTIa Dlllcra 'rO ,LAZN'I'Z" AND DI'INDANT.,
lfIL~INI"T"Ir.t.&.D AJIl'l....L-.,I'tU"IIWLc:OJI.mc:uall ~.MIY
14. ,laintifr'. complaint and the 'tAn.field defendant.' joinder
(~(Jl!\Jjliitnt t.U to naU " cay.. of acUon and/or a claim upon which
rollar can be granted a,ain.t additional detendant.
1.. Additional d.f.ndant .p.cilical1y deni.. aach ana every
Illleu.tion in plaintttt'. complaint .nd tht joinder eomplalnt alleging
IlllY Act or lailur. to .ct or addh tonal defendant al provilUnt any
t'4IIIia Pf nUel to the pl.inUU.
1.. The r.lvecliv. clai.. 01 the pl.intitf and .t.nefield
ih.ftondanu u. ban.1t bV UI4! IlpPUcilbl. ,ta'ute of limttation, and/or
t.y UI" "I.lb.untly. law (it ,~ CQIIIIIOnwuhtl of ,.nn.Vlv.nt..
I
,
,
I
I
t
1
i
i
,
~
{
17, In ...... .v.n.. H i, I.ktu.iM4 H"'" .<Wit tonal lkt.n4Ant va.
(UIMiIl,lb!. faf plllllltlfl'. .1l.'f~ l/i'urt.., ~9.' Qf &0.... 'wMch.
"
~~... hU'" Ul'~(_" .(>fl"...." ,~. .... . 'F,' .....'11 0.."" . ...~.. ..., I""
tIlfPt:....~""'. !h'''J"~tit' w.'" . ,.l"".'-"U"."''' "Ai ,tit,,",
has pruviou.ly been .pecifically den1edl, then and in that event. it
wa. the action. or inaction. or other p.r.on.. partie. or .ntiti..,
and/or the lack or care by the plalntitf, the atln.fi.ld dttendantl
and/or detendant Kerry Shenk, or oth.r partie. which clu.ed the
incident, and the alleged injurie., damag.. or 10.... Illeu.d in
plalntitf'. complaint, tor which Idditlonal def.nd4nt cannot b. hold
r..poneible.
18. The injurie.. damage. and/or lo.... compl.in.d of by tho
plaintiff and/or tht Itan'field d,fendante r..ultld from the letl and
omi..ion. at other partie., p.r.on. or entitie., including the actions
or inactione of the pllintiff .nd the 'tln.f1.1d d,t,ndlnt., ovor
which additional detendant had no l.ual re.pon.ibl1ity or control and,
theretore, additional detendant cannot be hlld liable.
19. Plllntift Ind the Stan.ti.ld d.fendant. a..um.d full ri.k ot
the con..qulnc.. ot their r..ptctiv. Iction.. condUCt, and
undertaking. thlroby pr,cluding any recovery by the plaintitt and/or
Stan.field d.t.ndant. ba.ed upon the doctrine of ...umption of thl
rl.k.
21. Th. act. and ami..lon. at tho plaintiff and the Jtan'field
d.f,ndlnt. or other per.on., partie, or ent&tlel, over which
additional defendant hid no le9a1 re.pon.ibl1ity Or control,
con.titut.a a luper,tdlng or lntervtnlQ9 cau.. of th4 .ll'9~ d&mA9.',
. i +
Wl\lKlfi IU'", ~.'HM1", WilMA", f~.'.. . II.. {''''hI U"UIIi . till" no tAtt
Ifi(IH1Ji{l'''ce '(iliA... wUt . I'IlI\A(''''''''A, I'A .t,ot
in1udu l\nd lo.... ..t. forth in pldnt.Uf', cOIIIpldnt. and thf!l jolndllr
complaint, and tor which .ddlt.lonal d.t.ndant cannot. b. h.ld 11Mbl..
22. Th. conduct. and Act.lvltl.. ot t.h. plaintltt and It.an.tl.lel
dor.ndant.. and/or thelr .mploy.... .g.nt.. ..rv.nt. or workmen were
loyally untor.....bl. a. . ~t.t..r ot law.
~). Th. incld.nt ln que.tlon and any r..ulting da~g'" lnjurioa
or 10.... w.re cau.ed by the contributory or cOIIIpAratlv. n.gllgence ot
the plaintitt and/or the 'tan.tl.ld det.ndant. to .uch an ext.nt that
it ellmlnat.., .up.r..d... or proportionat.ly r.duc" any All'W.d
liabilit.y producing conduCt on tho p.rt of .ddltional d.t.ndant
her. In. in accordanc. with the applicAbl' provi.1on. at the
~.nnaylvania compArAtiv. N.glig.nc. Act.. 4Z 'a.C.I.A. 17102 .t ..q.
24. Th. r..p.ctiv. cl.i~ A...rt.d again.t additional d.t.nd.nt
Are barr.a by the doctrin. ot lach...
21. 'lA1ntiff and/or the .tan.t1.1d a.t.ndant. tAll.d to
mitlgat. tho daMag." lnjurl.. or 10.... a. alleg.d ln tho plaintltt'.
n>>ftplllnt and/or tho joind.r oOlllpla1nt..
26. In the .v.nt the plalntltt'l 1njur1.., damag., or 10"" are
1'{Ov.n uv. at. trial, al'l4 an 4IllIploy.. of t.h. a<l<litional dtf.ndAnt
h4lH,ln w.. in '(MM IMrlMr at. th4 let... or U'l. undtrlyin9 inddtnt
.,.
~\(... """ M!,itlOW,'" H'hM"". {>o<d" . "It (I/OI'" ({"'tI" . Ivtft no tAil
...r>tf'totf,.!tf{f ~l\l"'" WI" . f"t"'Ab"",..""A "'Oll
.
(which hu htlr.to!otlJ b..n d.niedl, t.hen th. employ.. or additional
(Ief.naanl WU Acting undn th. control .nd .upervlllc," ot !lnd PUUUAllt
to tho orden or the Itan.tbld de,endante .nd/or defend.nt Kerry
8henk. All cl.1~ .uain.t additional defendant th.retote, at. b.r~ed
tJY tho borrow.d env.nt doctrine.
~~. Additional det.ndant Qive. notic. it lnt.nd. to rely upon
"ueh other .nd further .ftirmatlv. defen... which may beCom. Available
or appar.nt during di.covery proceeding.. or during the cour.. of
trial ot thl. Action and hereby re.ttve. thl right to ....rt any .ueh
Attirmative d.ren.e., A. WIll al any of the aftirmative and new mAtttir
dot.n... Which may hAve b..n or which may be ....rt.d by any other
V4rti.. to thi. Action, which .1'. lncorporat.d herein by r.terenee A'
through .et torth tully herein at length.
... MATTIa Cao',.CLAIN 0' caAlLII C. LOOI. AND ION. INC.
AClAIM.T WILLIAM .TANIPIII.D, W... .TUIPIII.D CON.TlUCTION
~.,m ~ ~IUY nllJl ruJ.,VAII't..m..L\...LQ. r. ,U Ia h'l
)0. In the ev.nt the aUeWiltlon. or plAlntHt'. COllIPlalnt are
filOVtln t.ru. AnlS corr.ct At the tilTltl ot trial (uld aU.vatio", beln!)
1IlCCJl'~;(jrlllt.d hereln by roCuonee only t(lf' the pllrpo.. of thl, erOIll'
clAim. t~t which n.vo horetotoro be." Ipecitically deniedl then, And
HI tn.t ovent, tho injud..,lo.... and/of M/fIAII" alloved thlU'oln
W.f41 cA""d in whole at' in (111ft. by tho "0\1 11l1onee, cAr.le..n... aml/Qr
r.~kl"'n'e' of a.f.ndant. Wll1i.- ItAn.fiold ana w.a. .tan,field
C9netrllctloA C~ny and/or d.t.nd4nt Xerry 8hen~, actiD9 individUAlly
".'
WI\\H" ""f" "1>"'t>W1'1 II>l.MA.. "'1>1('111 . ,..I (l,IiI'" '1""" . "IiU')O tAlt,
..,l>II-IM.f..(f '(lI.A"1 WUI . I"...\A(,,,,..,,,, I'A 1O.(i.
/lillI/or jointly, anti/or through their relpectlve employeel, agent.,
p"rVantl, workmen or other. over whom addltionel derendant herein had
no l.gAt r..ponl1bUity or control. thu., additional detendant heulu
cannot be held liable,
J1. AI a re.ult at the actione or inaction. on the part or
derendante William Stan.rield and W.K. Stan.rield Con.truction Company
and/or defendant !Cerry Shenk, a. ..t torth in plaintttt' I complaint
and the joinder complaint, and a. further .pecitically identitied
during the cour.e at trial, defendant. William Stan.field and
W,K. 8tanarield Con.truction Company and/or derendant Kerry Shenk Are
ealely and alone liable to the plaintirr, and/or jointly and .everally
liable with or liable over to additional derendant herein tor
contribution and/or indemnirication, in the eVent that liability which
ha. heretotore been .pecitically denied 1. .110 round agaln.t
additional derendant.
WIIKU'ORK, additional derendant, Charle. C. LOa" and son, Inc.
hereby re.pectrully reque.t. thl. Honorable court to tinrt d,rendant.
William Stan.field and W.K. Stan.fi.ld Conltruction Company and
derendant Kerry Shenk, ,olely and alone liable to the plalntift,
jointly and/or ..verally liable with or liable over to an.wlring
.t.
w,,~jt,j UII" U(lt"QWlfl, IOUMAfi. 0.0111 . Iltl till.... (.'""" . 11)1" no fA"
~()I""'()f".tlIOliA'" WUIt . "'.., AUIlf'ttlA.'" '1'041
i\tldltlonal detendant herein tor contribution and/or indemnification,
1nclUiHng reuonablo attorn.y te.., COlt. and .xpen... with regud to
i t he mAt t.r. proven lit trial.
Ii
;I
Ii
II
"
II
II
II
I'
II
I,
h
I!
II
]I
I
~..pectfully .ubmitted,
WILSON, ILSIR. MOSKOWITZ,
i
!
i
ROlLMAN " DICKER I
I
1
I
4-
ernd Q, Heinl', I.quire
John D. Sh.., I.quire
Attorn.y. tor Addition.l D.rendant.
Charl,. C. Loo.e and Son, Inc,
i:
;:
:j
-\0'
WIlIOfi"IIIIII MO'.OWlfl. .ut4M"~' bfC.'" . h., c;uIlflt Ct~'t11 . tvlf. 1)0 I""
ffoIllll1N<n",C' '01110'" WftH . "'Il.AIl""'ttlo. f'A "tOt
I I
I ~
I '.
'I
II
i!
Ii
!i
Ii
i!
11
q
II ,IRI.IOA'1'IOK
!
I
!
I John D. .h.a, lequire, .tat.e that h. 1. the attorney tor
,
i additional detendant, Charlet C. Loo.e and Son, Ino., that he ha. the
I
I authority to make thi. verifloation on it. behalt, that he i.
II aoquainted with the flct. .et torth in the fore90in9 An.wer at
!I Additional Defendant Charle. C. Loo.e and Son, Inc. To The Joinder
'I
I[ Complaint Of William stanefield And W.R. stan. field Conetruotion
!i
company Toqether With New Hattor And New Hatter Cro"-Clai.. pur.uant
i
,
,
i
I To Pa.R.C.P., Rule 252(d), that the .1..0 are true and correct to the
i
I
I
!
i
II
,
,
i
be.t of hi. knowled...,e, intormation and bolief, and that thio .tltement
1. Illade
,ubjoot to the penaltie. of 18
ral.itioation to authoritie..
Pa.e.s.A. 14904 relatin..., to
un.worn
".,~ ~S t-
bn D. 'h.., l.qU r.
Wl\a()H, ''''", MOt.I(()W'", IbhMA.." ble.11I . IItl (.lIft'" ON"" . 'vll, 1)0 'A*,
INO''''''O'fiU 'l!tIA"', wI" . ""., AOIl I'lItA, I'A '1I'0ll
DOMINICK PEREZ,
Plaintiff
IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
95-200 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL OF TWELVE DEMAN PEP
v.
WILLIAM STANSFIELD,
W.R. STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and KERRY SIIENK,
Pefendants
v.
CHARLES C. LOOSE AND I
BON, INC. I
Additional Pefendant I
am'LY or DlrlNDANTI WILLIAM .TAN.rIILD AMD
w. R. .TAN.rIILD CONITRUOTIOH COM'ANY TO ",. HATTla or
ADDITIONAL DlrlNDANT OHARLI8 C. LOaII AND ION. INC.
14. Denied. Thl. averment 1. a oonolu.ion of law requiring
no answer herein. With respect to the olalm. of the plaintift
thi8 avermsnt i. admitted.
15. Denied. Defendant. William StanSfield and W. R.
stan.tield construction company incorporate each and every
averment of its joinder complaint herein by reterenee.
Ie. Penied. The averment. of thl. paragraph are
conclu.lons or law requiring no an.wer. With re.peot to the
claim. of the plaintiff this aVerment 1. admitted.
17. oenied. Thl aVlrment. of this paragraph .re
conolu.lon. or law rlquirlnv no an.wlr hereln.
11. Denied. Tho aver_ent. or thle paragraph ar.
conclueion. of law requiring no an.wer her.ln. oerendant.
Stanerleld rurther aVlr, all a. 1. .It rorth in their 101nder
complaint, that additional defendant did have le9al
responsibility and control of the in.trumentality involvld, Ind
its operator, and therefore, additional defendant ie li.ble to
plaintiff upon his cau.e of action.
19.-25. Denied. The averments of the.e parlqraph. are
conclu.ions of law requiring no an.wer herein.
26. Denied. The averments of thl. paraqraph are
conclusions of law requlrin9 no anewer hereln. oy way ot turth.r
answer, defendants stan.field deny that addltlonal d.rendant'.
employee wa., at anytime relevant to thl. action, aotlnQ und.r
the control or .upervi.lon or pureuant to the ord.r. at
defendants Stan.field. On the contrary, .eld e.plovee wa. at III
time. acting as a .ole employee of addltlonal defendant.
29. Denied. The averment. ot thl. paraqraph Ir.
conclu.lon. ot law requiring no an.Wer hereln.
.J~~l TO ClO'. Q~JN
30.-31. The avermlnt. ot derlndant. .tan.fl.14., In.ver
and joinder oomplalnt are incorporated hereln bV rer.rena.. IV
way of further an.wet, all oonoluelone or law 'It forth in ihi.
paragraph are denied.
D,I'lWIOILI.,., VIO"'UQl UQIliIDGI
.. .lmWIIOII .g'IIIIID. n ,ag"W'
I v.rlfy that I .. thl Defendlnt(.) in the tur,qol"9 lotion/
In4 that thl attlohed ",plV to NeW Hatt.r 1- bl.ed upon the
lnror..tion whloh h.. b.en qlth.red bV .V oauna'l in pr.parltlon
at thl defena. or thta lawault. The la"9ul,e ot thl Rlply to New
Hatt.r 1. thlt ot QO~nl.1 and nat _lnl. 1 hlYI r'ld the Replv ta
NIW Mltt.r and/ to thl '.tent thlt it 1a bll.a upon tnro~tion
whloh I haYe ,tv,n to .Y ooun,'I, it 1. true Ind correot to thl
~..t or 'V knovll4,l/ lnlo~atlon, Ind b.ll.t. To the .wtent
lhlt the oont.nt. or thl R.ply to N.w Hltt.r I. that of ooun.el,
I hlYe relll4 upon ooun.el In Makin, thtl V.rilialtlon.
I under.tand that Intlntlon.l r.I,. Itate..nt. hereln ar.
..d. .ubjeot to the plnAltl.. or 1. 'I. C.'.A. . .'0. rel.tlnt to
unlworn 1.1.1110.tlonl to luthoritte..
o.ttl__.t!tt}U' _
Iyl
.'.""" -
"
Iyl_~~~.~iil '
ce.plny
t.
Y.
. IN THI C:OUIlT or COMMON PLIAS
I or C\JMDIIU.AHO COUNTY,
I P&NN.Y1NANIA
.
. "-300 CIVIL TIRM
I
. CIVIL ACTION - LAW
.
I JURY TIlIAL or TWIINII DIHAIIDID
.
I
I
I
I
I
DOMINICI( I'IRU,
1'1.1ntUf
Y.
WILLIAM .TAM.rIILD,
W.R. 'TAN.,IILD CON'TRUCTION
COMPANY and IClaRY 'HINK,
o.t.ndant,
ClIA"LX' C. LOOJC ANP
I.ION, INC.
Additional Detendant
QIUII1C1Ulor_I"UU
I, IOWARD L. ICHOR", I'QU1RI, h.feby o.rtlty that I ~Y"
on the b.1OW datI, 0.u..4 . true and oorr.ot ooPY of th.
tore9011\9 "&PLY TO IIIW NATTIR to b. .und llpon th. p'UGn' ,nd
in the ..nn.r lndloat.4 belowl
nUt (a~.. ~'L,_tQl'1'AQIiI'III1'A1Q'4~Pl!fll"lb A,I roP~'J
.oott W. Mor"n, I.q.
Mor,ln . HOf,ln, P.C.
130 .OYth Itr..t
Harrl.bufq,'A 11101-1'10
TiMOthY I. ~rk, I.q.
Clldw.ll . K.a,n,
3"1 North rront I'r..t
"afrl.ourf,'" 11110
Q.I,.~,Y :~.11:~!/::. "
Jlok P. .h.., I.q
wil.on, 11..f. HO.lowlt., Id.l..n . Olok.r
Th. ~r'l. o.nt'f, lult. ')0
In4.,.nd.~ .quar. Wee'
",Uad'IPhl"~A ." I lOt ~
I . . .-" '. '-... . " . .
'I'''.IT~''~'
~w.r~ L. 9onorpp, I.q.
Weill!, IiIACK . 8CHQat,
,. tlwtIJ ""MY'" .tr..t
C.rl&.'., ~A \70\)
(711) Ul.-J1H
J-4.~
Id
fd
~
. -
, j
. '-
;1 N
I ~i al I !I~
I I-II
5i
nd II I i !il
1,1
.
, . ~
,
MOIICI"N'" MOIlOAN.I',('.
II": s('on W. MOIlOAN.IiSQIJlIlIl
IllhNTII'I<.'Al'ION NO, 361~1
IlU SOUTIl STIlIlII1'
IMlIltlSIlURO.I'A 11101.U10
(1111 :)(..19'9
ATTOItNlIYl POR I'LAINTll'f
()OMINICK I'l!Rf.Z
1 IN TlUl "OURT 01' COMMON P\..I!AS
: CllMDI!Rl.AND C:OUNTY, rUNNA.
1'lalOllff
V.
.
,
: NO. 9'.200 CIVIL
WIUJAM STANSf1WLD.
W, R. STANSIIIllW CONSTRUCTION
COMI'ANYand KllRRY SIII!NK.
Offendan'-
.
,
: CIVIL ACTION. I.A W
,
.
I JURY TRIAL 01' rwtn.vn DllMANPIlP
V.
('IlARLf,.~ C. LOOSU AND SON. INC..
Additional O4IfendAnl I
I'UINTIf'F'8 REPLY TO NEW MAmR
P1alnllff. by and IhrUll.h hi. IIWfMYI. MOl,."" M(Il'pn, P,C..hortby
r'PI!.11O New M....r of l>cr,ndanl (:harle. (', 1.ooH and Son. lne.. and IV'rI &I follow.:
1.-29, 1'h. all'Pllon. uf Ihf.. parqr.,h. ar. dtnlod &I (.'(lnelutkmt of law w
whkh 00 a",w.r il required.
WIIl!IUlI'OMIl. Plaintiff dtllllnd. N,w Mattlf 1M ditmlttfd and Jud.mcnl
.nllrtd In hit favOf.
MOltOAN" MOIWAN, r.(:.
UAlf,U, ,,,__14..:\, HI
~
By --- " "lcc'-
. Mol . ,f
^lttlr_yt f~l( t'lIitltI
I~\(
! .. ...A _. ~
\
~
Scotl W. Morpn. I1lqulro 11110' Ihal h, II roI.!flNl of fOCOfd fOf Plalnllff In Iho
within ICllon, II .Ulhoflud 10 11110 Ihll VOflflcallon on hi. behalf. .nd 111.11110 IlItementl
made In lhe fOff,oln, Reply 10 New Malter are Irue and rorrecllo Ihe be'l of hi. knowled,o.
lnr(lrmadun .nd boll". II. und.nllnd, Ihal tho IlI\Omonll In did pludln. are mad. lubjecl
to .he ptllllllo. ot II Pt. C.S.^. 14004. f,'a,'n. 10 ul\Iworn falllficallon to .Ulhorlllel.
( .
~W-~~~l;:~
~, . Mor.,... '1I1lIu f.
DOMINICK PIRIS,
Plaint1ft
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
INC., *
*
v.
WILLIAM 8TAN.rJILD, W.M.
STAH.rIBLD CON'TRUCTION
COMPANY and ICBRRY 'HBNK,
Oefendant
v.
CllARLI8 C. LOOII AND 80N,
Additional Dar.ndant
IN THI COURT or COMMON PLIAS
CUMaIRLAND COUNTY, PINN8YLVANIA
No., ~5.200 . Civil T.rm
CIVIL ACTION . LAW
JURY TRIAL DBMANDID
.OT~C. '(1 l'Lnn
TO, Dominick 'ere., Plaint~CL and
,cott W. Horgan. I.quir., hi. attorney
MOWAH .. MOROAH
10 'outh Market 8quare
Harri.burg, PA 11101
YOU ARB HIRlay NOTJrIBD that the New Matter .et forth hlreln
contain. avermenu asain.t you to whlch you are requlred to r..poneS
within twenty (20) day. art.r .ervlce thereot. rallure by you to
do .0 may con.titut. an admll.ion.
.eepectrully .ubmitt.d,
~"J( NS
1'1" tt,.'\\.~ ~ ')/" , r j
IIIOt 'I , ~
Attorne 1.0. 12771.
3'31 North rron~ Itre.t
Harrl.burg, PA 17110
(717) 2)2.7661
AttornlY tor D.f.ndAnt
Iterry .hlnk
Patld, Hay It. "~'I
m..
OOMINICK P8aBZ,
pla1nt1ff
* IN THB COURT or COMMON PLIAS
* CUMBBRLANP COUNTY, PBNNSYLVANIA
*
* No.1 95-200 . Civil Term
*
* CIVIL ACTION - LAW
*
* JURY TRIAL OBMANDID
v.
WILLIAM STANSPIILD, W.R.
STANSPIBLD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and KBRRY SIIINK,
oetendant
>>rlna WITH NI1f MATTIa or DIrIDlDAN'l' IIOY SBIDl'l TO
PLAIHTI"'_ C~LAIHT
1. After. reasonable inve.tigation, the an.wering Oetendant
ia without knowledge or information sufficient to form. belisf .a
to the truth of the .verments of paragraph 1 llnd the aame are
therefore denied and proof thereof i. demanded.
2. The averment. of paragraph 2 appear to be directed to a
Oefendant other than Oetendant Kerry Shenk and theretore need no
r..pon.., however, becllu.e the averment' of paragraph :I are
.ueceptible to ditterent interpretationa, the an.wering oetendant
do.. deny that he operue. a bu.ine.. known AI W.R. Itandied
Con.truction Company at the addU" lilted in tho Compla1nt
caption, and proof thereof to the contrary ia demanded it relevant
at time Of trial.
J. Admitt.d upon information and beliet.
4. Denied in conformance with Pa.R.C.P. 1029(e) and, by way
of further an,wer. it w.. not Lhwldln Road, it w.. Maplewood
Drive.
5. It is denied, as alleged in paragraph 5, that Defendant
Shank was overseeing the construction project on which the
Plaintiff was working and. on the contrary, it is averred that
Defendant Kerry Shenk had no direct or other .upervisory
re.pon.ibilitie. of the location or .ite of Plaintiff'. acoident
becau.e, prior to the incident involving the Plaintift. Defendant
Shenk, who had an oral agreem.nt with the g.neral contractor,
Benchmark Hom.., Inc., for the framing. had orally pa...d along
that re.ponsibility, with the gen.ral contractor'. approval, to
Detendant W.R. Stan.field Construction Company.
6. It wa. W.R. Stan.tield Con.truction Company, not William
Stansfield, which was the framing subcontractor on the con.truction
project where the Plaintiff alleg.dly was working, Stan.field
having orally agreed to ..sume Defendant Kerry Shenk'.
re'pon'ibilities, which subcontract was approved by the general
contractor, Benchmark 110m'., Inc., berors the incident in que.tion.
7. It i. denied, a. alleged in paragraph 7, that Defendant
Kerry Shenk acted individually or through agent., .ervant. or
employee. acting within the cours. and .cope of their agency or
employment for, on the contrary, it ie denied that any .uch
individual, including Kerry Sh.nk, w.re at the .ite of Plaintitt'.
injury at the time ot his accident or committed any act or ami..ion
material to thll litigation, lna.much .. beton the incident
involving the Plaintitf, W.R. Stan.fi.ld Con.truction Company, a
Oefendant herein, had orally agr.ed, with the general contractor'.
approval, to a..ume the r..ponllbilieiee tor the eubc:ontract tor
carpentry and trami"9 at the con.tructlon .ite.
8. After a reasonable investigation, the answering Defendant
is without knowledge or information eufficlent to form a belief as
to the truth of the averments of paragraph 8 and the same are
therefore denied and proof thereof is demanded.
g. The averments of paragraph 9 conai.t of legal conclusion.
of the Plaintiff and/or hi. coun.el which, under the Rulee of Civil
Procedure are deemed to be denied and no response is neeeesary, to
the extent an anewer may be required, it ie denied that the
an.wering Defendant, individually, jointlY or .everally. caused any
injury or damage to the Plaintiff, it being further denied that
there w.. any negligence, carele..ne.. or reckl...ne.. on behalf of
the an.wering Defendant and strict proof thereot i. demanded if
relevant at time of trial.
COONT I
Plaintiff v. I'r~ J~,n~
10. The answers to paragraphs 1 through 9 above are
incorporated by reference.
11. In re.pon.e to the averments of paragraph 11, Oefendant
incorporates a. if eet out in full hi. an.wer. to paragraphs 5 and
7 above, otherwi.e, the averment. of paragraph 11 are denied in
conformance with Rule 10~9(el.
13. U . In nepon.. to the avermenu ot paragraph. U and 13,
Defendant incorporatee by nterence .1 it eet out 1n full hie
answer. to paragraph. 5 and 7 abov., otherwise, the averments ot
paragraphs 12 and 1) are denied in accordance with Rule 1029(e).
WHBRIFORl, the an.wering Oerendant d8lllAnds that the COCIlplalnt
be di.mi..ed and judgment entered in hi. favo~ and again.t the
)
Plaintiff without cost to him but together with such costs,
expenses and attorney's fees as authorized by law and which the
Court deems necessary, just and appropriate under the
circumstance..
cotnn' II
Plaintiff v. Milliam Stansfield
14,17, These allegations pertain to a Defendant other than the
an.wsring Defendant and, under the Rules ot Civil Procedure, need
no response by the answering Defendant and are deemed to be denied.
WHBRRVORB, the an.wering Detendant demands that the complaint
be dismia.ed and judgment entered in his favor and again.t the
Plaintiff without co.t to him but together with such coets,
expensee and attorney's fees a. authori.ed by law and which the
Court deems necsesary, just and appropriate under the
circumatancee.
cotnn' UI
Plaiptiff v. M.R. 8tansfi,1~ ~~et~ot~on C~any
18'21. These allegations pertain to a Defendant other than the
answering Defendant and, under the Rule. ot Civil procedure, need
no response by the an.wering Defendant and are dsemed to be denied.
WHRRBFORB, the anewaring Defendant demands that the Complaint
be diemi..ed and judgment entered in his favor and aga1nlt the
Plaintift without COlt to him but together with .uch cOltl,
oxpenles and attorney's fe.. as authori.ed by law and Which the
Court d..ms n.c...ary, jUI\; and Appropriate under the
clrc~tanc...
4
arv PTT"
33. Th. Complaint and it. all.g.tlon. .ualn.t th. .n.w.rino
Defendant K.rry shenk, tall to .tat. a claim upon which rel1et can
be grant.d.
33. O.t.ndant K.rry Shenk operat.. hl. bu.ln.., II k.~ry A.
Sh.nk Con.truction.
34. Th. inoid.nt .U.".d to have lnvolv.a the ,1.1nUU
occurr.d on Maplewood Driv., not Llmoklln Road, in N.w ~rland.
25. Although prior to Plaintiff" lneld.nt on AulJ\lU 1'1,
1993, Kerry A. Ihllnk Con.truction had blln hh.d by th. ,.nuIl
contractor, l.ncNnuk Home./ Ino" by way ot an or,l contract,
Def.ndant: Sh.nk obtain.d the verbal approval ot ..nchMfll KomI I ,
Inc. to have W... .tan.tl.ld Con.truction c~ny a,,~ tb4 work
that Shenk had originallY aVf..d to und.rt,k. Ie the .1t. and W...
Stan.tied Con.truction Company. by way ot an 01"1 .vr.tlMne, ."re.d
to a..umI 'h.nk'. .ubcontr.ct r..pon.lbilltl', to l.nchMfll ~./
Inc.
a.. At and b.tor. the tl.- or thl 'lalntltt'. 1AC1~nt or
AUllu.t 17, 1'11. D.t.ndant Kerry In.nk WI' not pafllC1pat1nt al a
eubc:ontr.ctor phYllcally on the jOb IU. whir. th. ,i.lnUff
all.gedly wal lnjurad.
:17. At and b.tor. thl tl.. of 'lalntltf'l lneld.nt of Autu.t
17, UU, O.r.naant Ktrry .h.nk hAd no dh,e' or ather IV"l'Vl.lon
ot the location or lit. ot .1.lntlll'l In61d4nl.
2.. At or b.ror. en. tl.. 01 'lllnt""I tnqt4tfit O' AMtv,t
17, UU, no a,.nt, ,unnt or "",loyt. ut tnt wUbi!l t'" cwr..
.
and .cop' ot thoir employm.nt for Oeremtant Kerry Shonk won
llhy.icaUy pre.ent at tho .ita or Plaintifr', injury or cOlmIitted
any act or eml..ion material to thie litigation.
at. Rule 1010 w.. amendod .Uect tv. septalllbor 1, U94 to
provide that clrtain atrirmative det.n.e. need not b. pl.aded and
will not thereby be waiv.d.
WHIRB'ORI, the an.werino Der.ndant demand. that the Complaint
be dhmi...d and judllment .nt.nd in hi. ravor and aoaloot the
PlalntUr without coet to him but tOO.thu with .uoh co.tI,
expen... and attorney" r... a. authorl..cS by law and whieh the
Court d..1IIII n.e....r)', jUlt and Appropriate under tho
01 rcUllllluno...
.'Ipootrully .ubMlttecS,
~LL . J( IUI.
1)'1 rl ~lW
IIlO Y .r, .qu
Attorn I.D. .2111.
J.)\" th 'ront Itr..'
Marfl.burg. PA 11110
11\1' 2);1.7161
Attorney tor o.r.n4Int
Klfry '~nk
0.'14, MIl)' II. ntl
",It
.
YIRIPIq.TlOtf
% verity that the ave~nu IMde in the torelJoinlJ docwntnt ne
true all4 cornet upon my penona1 knowledg., infol1lllltion and
b.li.r. I under.tand that fAl.. Av.~.nte herein ar. mad. .ubjlct
to the p.naltb. ot 18 1'.. C.I. leo. "'04 relating to un.worn
ral1iticat1on to authoriti...
If 1
, ......" "4*"""
o.t.d, ~"" /(1~ ?,~
..".
CBaTIrJCAT, pr SBaVICI
I hereby certity that I am thie day servlng a copy of the
toregoing document upon the persons ln the manner lndicated below,
which eervic8 .atl.fie. the requirements of the penn.ylvania Rules
ot ClvU Procedure. by depo81ting a copy of ..me in the Unlted
State. Mail. Harri.burg. Penneylvanla. wlth riret.ela.. postage.
prepaid, ae rollow'l
Scott W. Morgan. Isqulre
MORGAN , MOROAN
130 South Street
Harrisburg, PA 17101.1310
Attorney for Plaintiff
Idward L. Schorpp, B_quire
LANDIS. BLACK AND SCHORPP
36 South Hanover Street
Carllsle. PA 17013
Attorney for Defendants
Wllliam Btanstteld and
W.R. 'tansfield Con.truction Company
John D. Shea. asquire
WILlON. ILIIR. MOSKOWITZ. BDILMAN . OICKIR
The CUrti, Center. Suite 130
Independence Square Waet
philadelphia, PA 1'106
Attorney for Additional Oefendant
Charle. C. Loo.e and son. Inc.
IYl
PAced, Har 11, 1'"
~
If::
.
?,J
'_l
:1'7
~.~'-~",",,-__..-.v,
.
.
~
III, ..
~u !l
~IEI!I
= I I
'5 ~
. x
--
DOMINICIC ,SRlZ,
PlaintHt
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
.
INC., ·
.
v.
WILLIAM 8TANSFIBLD, W.R.
STANSFIBLD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and KIRRY SHINK,
D.fendant
v.
CHAlLIS C. LOOSB AND SON,
Additional D.fendant
IN THB COURT 0' COMMON PLIAS
CUMaIRLAND COUNTY, PBNN8YLVANIA
NO.1 95-200 . Civil T.rm
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DBMANOBD
"'LY or DlrDlDAft UUY 8RIHI '1'0 'l'II1 ow MATTIa
IN TlI NATUaI or A CaOl8eLAtIC 'ILID IY ADDITIONAL DlrlKDAft
Mlnf.., C. LQOSlI ~ SOH. IBC. ,tJU~ ~ ,.,.,c.'. 2212 (e)
30. Th. av.rment. of paragr.ph 30 conei.t at l.gal
conclu.lon. ot the pl.ad.r and/or It. couneel which, und.r the
Rul.. of Civil proc.dure, are d.emed to b. d.ni.d .nd no r.epon..
t. n.c....ry, to the .xt.nt an anewer may be requir.d, 1t 1. d.nied
that th.r. i. any l.gal re.poneibility or that th.re wal control,
II all.g.cS in parauraph 30 ov.r 10lI\tI unknown or un.peciU.d
.mploy.., ag.nt, ..rvant, workman, or other individual or .ntity at
. INltertal time to the .v.nt retured to in the Plaintiff'.
Complaint to impol' liability upon Det.ndant K.rry .h.nk and Itrict
proot th.r.or to the contrary i. d.lNlnd.d it r.l.vant at time of
trial and oth.rwl.. the averment. are d.ni.d punuant to Rule
1029 (e) ,
)1, It i. d,nl.a, A' al1.g.d ln paragraph )1, that D.fendant
K.rry 'n.~ acte4, or 'al1e4 to act, at a RAt.rlal t1.. r.l.vant to
th1B litigation or that Defendant Shenk has any liability to
anyone, either solely, alone, jointly or severally or has liability
to or with other. for contribution or indemnification with etrict
proof thereof to the contrary demanded. if relevant at time of
trial, any liability or re.pon.ibUity on behalf of Defendant Kerry
Shenk b.ing hereby .xpre..ly denied.
WlIBRSFORB, the an.wering Defendant demand. that the Cro..claim
be di.mi...d and judgment entered in hil tavor and again.t the
Additional Det.ndant without coat to him but together with Buch
CO.tl, exp.n..a and attorn.y'. fee. a. authori.ed by law and which
the Court deema n.e....ry, juet and appropriate under the
c i rcumetance.,
R.ep.cttully eubmitt.d,
~LLo , K~NSI! ,(i
By,"""""-'tJ)1U hrCl r' i fOill.!
'i'lhiOthy 1,. .Mirk, R.quire
Attorney'I,D. 127758
3'11 North Front Stre.t
Karri.burg, PA 17110
(717) 232.7661
Attorn.y tor Def.ndant
Iterry Sh.nk
Oattdl May 11, 1...
NIIU
VRRIPICATION
I verity that the averments made in the foregoing document are
true and correct upon my personal knowledge, information and
belief. I understand that false averments herein are made subject
to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. Sec. 4904 relating to unsworn
falsification to authoritie..
By.
ION
Dated, . .p./~-~
. .
..'"
.
CSRTI'ICA~ 0' SSRVIes
I hereby csr~ity that I am this day eerving a copy or the
torsgoing document upon the person. in the mannSr indicated below,
which service satisrie. the requiremente of the pennsylvania Rul..
of Civil Procedure, by depoeiting a copy ot ..me in the United
State. Mail, Harrisburg, pennsylvania, with first-class postag.,
prepaid, ae tollows.
Scott W. Morgan, Rsquire
MORGAN .. MORGAN
120 South Street
Harri.burg, PA 17101-1210
Attorney tor Plaintitt
Idward L. Schorpp, Require
LANDIS, BLACK AND SCHORPP
36 South Hanover Street
Carli.le, PA 17013
Attorney for Oefendants
William Stanetield and
W.R. StansCield Conetruction Company
John O. Shea, Require
WILSON, ILaRR, MOSKOWITZ, RORLMAN .. DICKRR
The CUrtis Center, Suite 830
Independence Square W.et
Philadelphia, PA 19106
Attorney for Additional Defendant
Charlee C. Loo.e and Son, Inc.
By.
C1J,DWBt.L ..
rj Uc\I.'t.......',
mot 1. .
Attornly 1.0 121751
3631 North 'ront Stre.t
Harriebury, PA 17110
17171 232-7661
Attorney Cor Der.n4ant
Kerry Shenk
Dated. Hay 1'1 1'"
..'"
~
.
~-.':
,
N
\(1
M
.c;o~'\
'."",,"
.~
ifl>..
~
IllS ~
f~~ ~!
~ f oJ ti >
:.:: 3 ~ ~ ~
14I1EliV
I. ~ r
- ~ I ~
f ~ = i
· ... r
I
. ,
. .
.
"
~
l)omlnkk Ilt'tI ,ta'" Ihal lit II Plalnllff In Ihll mall". and lhallht ltaltrntnll
madt In Iht for'JOln, Kepi)' 10 N.w M....r are !rue and wrrOC:l1O Iht bell of hi_ knowlcda',
infCll'madon and belief. II. undenllndllhallhl .laltmanllln ..Id pl.adln, aro madt lubJ<<1
IU IhI ",nalllel of \II'., C,I.A. '4904, ,.111111' 141 ul\lworn f.I,lflcalkm 10 .ulhorlllcl.
''"~jt7ltl''''''-'7':;';
- mln k '"
v.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMDERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
9'-200 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL OF TWELVE DEMANDED
DOMINICI< PERE~,
Plaint! ff
WII.LIAM STANSFIELD,
W.R. STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and KERRY SHENK,
Defendante
v.
CHARLES C. LOOSE AND
SON, INC.
Additional Defendant
ItPTlOI
You have been .ued in court. If you wieh to detend a9ain.t
the olaim. .et torth in the followinq paqa., you mu.t take aotion
within twenty (20) day. after thl. complaint and Notice are
.erv.d, by enterinq a written appearance pereonally or by
attornay and flllnq in writlnq with the court your defan.e. or
objection. to the claim. .et forth avain.t you. You are warned
that if you fall to do .0 tha oa.. may proceed without you and a
judgment may be entered again.t you by the Court without further
notice for any money olalmed in the Complaint, or tor anr other
olalm or relief raqu..ted by the Plalntlff(.). You may oee
money or property or other right. important to you.
YOU .HOULD TAli THI8 PAPIR TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCI. Ir YOU
DO MOT HAVI A LAWYIR OR CANNOT ArrORD ONI, 00 TO OR TILI-
'HOMI THI OrrICI 81T rORTH BILOW TO rIND OUT WHIRl YOU OlM
alT LlaAL .In.
cuabarlan4 oounty Court A4ainl.trator
Ona oourthou.e .quare
Oarllele, '.nneylvanla 17011
Tel.pbon.1 (111) 140-.100
v.
I IN Till COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
I OF CUMbERLAND COUNTY,
I PENNSYLVANIA
I
I 95-200 CIVIL TERM
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I JURY TRIAL OF TWELVE DEMANDED
I
I
I
I
I
I
DOMINICK PEREZ,
Pldntitt
v.
WILLIAM STANSFIELD,
W.R. STANSFIELD CONSTRUCTION
COMPANY and I<ERRY SHENI<,
Defendant.
C/lARLES C. LOOSE AND
SON, INC.
Additional Detendant
COMPLAU'" 0' WILLIAM ITMlI'IIlLD MID
w. a. I"MllrIILD COIIB"RUOTIOM COMrAft. DlrlMDAMTI
!h
OBAaLII a. LOC81 AND 80M. 1.0. ADDITIONAL DlrIND~
Detendante, William stan.fleld and W. R. Stan.tleld
Con.truotion Company, by and through their attorneye, Landie,
Black' Sohorpp, hereby a..ert the following oomplaint againat
Additional Detendant, Charle. C. Loo.e and Son, Ino.
1. Defendant William Stan.tield 1. an adult individual
re.lding at 3672 spring Road, Carll.le, Penn.ylvania.
a. Detendant W. R. Stan.fl.ld Con.lruction company i. a
eo1e proprietorehip owned by Willi.. Stanefield with ottioe. at
3672 'pring Road, Carli.1e, penn.ylvanla.
3. Additional Defendant Charlee C. Loo.e and 'on, Ino, 1.
e corporation doing bu.lnee. in PenneYlvanla with a prinoipal
ottlc8 at 50 We.t stoever Avenue, Myeretown. Lebanon County,
,.nn.ylvania 17067.
4. Th.re h attaohed h.reto u Exhibit IJA" .nd
incorporated herein by reeerence, a true copy ot a compl.int
filed by Dominick Perez, Plaintiff agaln.t William stan.fi.ld, W.
R. stan. field con.truotion company and I<erry Shenk, Defendant..
5. At the tim., date and plac. alle...,ed in Plalntift'.
complaint, the D.fendant wa. the own.r of a crane utilized at the
job _it. for the purpoee of hoi.ting wooden roof tru.... into
po.ltion on a re.ldentlal garage under con.truction.
6. At the tim., date and place alleged in Plaintift'.
complaint, the operator ot ..id crane waG an .gent, .ervant
and/or employee of Additional D.fendant, and h. acted at all
time_ mat.rial h.reto within the cour.. and .cope ot hi. agenoy
or employment with Additional Defendant.
7. At laid time and plac., Additional Defendant" crane
operator hoi.ted . wooden tru.. over the garave, which tru.. wa.
ultimately to be ..cured in place by D.f.ndant William Stan. field
and hi. other employ..a working on the .it..
8. At .aid time and plac., Additional D.fend.nt'. operator
r.l....d laid wood.n tru.. from the orane cable betor. .aid
operator ob..rved and a.c.rtain.d that oetendant atanlti.ld and
hi. ..ploy.e. had .ecured and/or .tablllz.d ..ld tru.. in
polit1on.
9. At .aid time and place, Additional Def.ndant" operator
did in fact rale... from the crane cabl. the wood.n tru.. prior
to the tru.. being handl.d and/or oth.rwl.e .ecured bV Def.ndant
at,nlrl.ld and hi. .mploV....
10. To the .xt.nt that the acoident de.cribed in
Plaintiff'. Complaint occurred, and lt .aid Plalntltt reoeived
any lnjuri.s es set forth in .aid Complalnt, .ald injurie' and
resulting damag.s are the eole re.ult of the n'9l1gence ot the
Additional Defendant. The n.gligence of the Additional D.fendant
coneisted of the fOllowing.
A. In negligently, r.ckle..ly and carel..sly
r.leaslng from the crane cabl. .upport the wooden tru..
which Ultimately struck Plaintiff, before properly
aec.rtaining and confirming that the tru.s had been ..cured
or etabililed by Defendant Dtanefl.ld and hi. employe..,
B. In failing to properly ob.erve the work in proc...
and in rel.a.in9 .aid tru.s b.fore it wa. prop.rly ssoured
or etabililed/
c. In negligentlY r.lea.lng .aid wood.n tru.. tro.
the crane cabl. without flr.t havln9 r.ceived a .iqnal or
other indloatlon from Defendant stan.field or hie e.ploy...
that eaid tru.. was .ecur.d or .tabllilld in plaoe,
D. In failinq to use due care und.r the
oiroum.tano../
E. In failing to follow the u.ual and cu.to.ary
e.fety proc.dur.s for holstin9 and .rlotinq wood.n tru....
at a con.truction .it., and
r. In failing to follow all lawful re9ul^tionl
pertaining to the hoi.ting and .r.cting of wooden or Ilallar
tru.... at job sltes.
11. The Defend.nt av~rl that it th. Plalntltf IUltalnld .ny
injuril' or da.a9'1, a. a1119.d, thl .... wer. oau'ld .. a relult
or the ,ole n19119.noe at the Additional Defend.nt in the .ann.r
1n whloh itl e.ploYI' .u.pended lald tru...., all aa daeoribld
.boy..
la. Defend.nt. b.l1ava, and th.rafor. aver, thet Addltional
oefendant i. ,01ely r..pon.ibl. to the Pl.lntifrl and ther.tore
further Iv.r. thAt .ald Additional Defendant i. .10na 1iabla to
the plaintifr for thl CAU" 0' .otion deolarad upon.
11. AlternAtively, it the 'laintiff i. .ntitled to .ny
rel1,t, Addltionll Dlr.odlnt 1. 'ointly liebla theretor wlth
DIfendant. Wl11ia. .t.n.fi.ld and w. M. .tan.ti.ld Con.truotion
co,plny, or i, liabl' ov.r to Dlrendlnt. "1111a. Itan"i.ld and
W. M. Itan'filld Conatruotlon COMpany, ,0 th.t Dlr.ndlnt. willla.
_tan.field and W. R. .tan,tleld con.truotlon Co'plny da..nd
judq..nt in th.lr favor, toteth.t vlth th, oOlt or thla lotlon,
and, ln th. alternative, d..,nd oontrlbution or lndeanlty trol
A4dltlonal Dlllnd.nt, Ch.rle. c. LoOII .nd lon, Inc., toq.thlr
with the oOlt. of thi, aotlon.
LAHDI', .LACK . ICHOR"
~
ono,p, 4.
'or o.f.A4ant.