Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-00217 . ~ .~ f ..-+- ..... 1 l j r- - C"'b , ~/ WILLIM\1I'. DOUGLAS, HSQUIKll A11'(>RNIlY J.D,' ;Wn6 OOUGLA.'4. IX:>UCI.A" " IX)UGI.M 27 wusr tflGU fJ'TMI!IlT 1',0. DOX 261 CAJ(UtiUl.I'A.17013 7IN.',I79() A1TORNRY (10M I'I.AINTIPF ~M. ..._.,,,"_(.., .t ....T],.__.I.J...lIJIf\!~.,. ~ . ..'~ J014L Ulll WIIITMIRI! .nd IJl:lTtlLl!ll WIIITMIRIl. hit willi I IN TUB COURT OF COMMON PLUM Oil CUMDllRLAND COUNTY.I'BNN$'(LV ANIA CIVIL ACTION. LAW NO. lW5. oJ I 1 CIVIL TRRM V. tI(,)UTH MI[)l)llrrON TOWN8Int' I JURY TKJAL [)(IMANDIU) tiQt1C1 You hAv" bftn tlWd In Clur\, It YIl" wt.h 10 d",M .,.tNII'" dAt~ ,,' ""," In th. 'ollowln& f'4''', Y"" l1I\l1' IAQ action within lWtn'y (%0) dAy. A'WI 'hit ('ompl.ln, .nd 1I0U". Art mv,d. by '"lffln, .. WIlli," 'Pp'IUI\(" pfft(ltlllly 01 by It\OlOf)'. And 1111"1 11\ wrllln, wllh UI4I Court YOUI d.ffNft (If o\1jt<UIlN 10 tfw ,"tml NI ((Iun 1..lnll Y(lu, Y (lU Ir, WI,.wd 1n.1 I' you ,.11 In d(l Nt. tilt 'AN 1M)' pfll("'ffd will\(lul Y{lU And A ludanwllI IMY bit .nltrfd '1'1ntl )'lIU by In. ('PUll wlllwu' 'urlh., n(tlte. 'VI II\Y l1\Clntty I.'IIhNCt In In. rompl.I'" III ,(" Ill)' (IIMI ('141m (II ffllr' f"{U'tlfd tJ)' 1M plilllllilf, Y"u may IlIH fll('I\.Y (lI ItIC"'f!)' (II NMI rlJlhtJ hnl'l(}fllnllu Y\l\l, YOU lit IOOLU T AICU TIII~ I' Ar'eN TO YOllR '"A WYF,M AT ()Nell. IP YOU IX) N(yr 1I,\V1t A I,AWYUJ( OM CANNOT A"fiOJ(U ON". CO TO OM l'liUII'IlONH TUll OVJiK'N lUff' 1i()KTIl DfiLOW TO ,lINO OUT WlUUtK YOU CAN CI:lT LIIOAL. tlliI.J', (:lIUfI Adm'nit'''kll I'(/UI th Jlkl(tJ (:umllfrl4nd C"!,IDIY ('lIuttNIUH e.."...,...'" 110U 717-%.foQ.1;.%OO IXXlCLM OOWtA~ .lX:700LA~ I .. '. \,/ ~L" ,.... y,~-~~lA..~l,_-_ ,", :\:~r ,,,~-,-" l""'f~ Atk'fMY "If ."Wfttitf ~ I, Th. pl.lnllfl, Jo,ll," Whltmllf, I. .n Indlvldu.1 r..ldl". .1 9.' RId.. RNd, Dlcldnf(ln TClwn.hlp, Cuml>trl."d Counly, I',nn.ylv.nl.l. Z. Th. dllf.nd.nl, !illulh Mlddlllllln Town.hlp, I. . p"lIl1ul .ubdlvl.lcm 01 Cumlltrl.nd ('(lunly, ",n/l.ylvanl., h4vlll. . p1ll". 01 bu.III'" 1\1 '201'"k Prlv., 8<1111"1 tiprlll.', Cllmllfrl.II" COllnly, 1',nll.ylvAnIA, ,. On J.nuArY 21, IW~, .1 clr ,""Iul :U~ I',M., Ih. pllllnllll, J,,"1 L'. Whltml", Wit 01","11"" . 11117 Ch'v,ol,IIII In ....I..rn dl"ctl(ln Oil M(lunl.ln Ro.d, .If(l k/\Own .. Town.hlp ROlli. T."", .nd Wit .ppw.'hlllll A .I'.ilm n,., W.y'" NIlII Pwwff.ln !ioulh Middlel"n Towruhlp. 4, AJ Ihe pIAlnllflllu.mpl.d III n..oll.lf . ('lUV', h, .lId cln Ih, Ie" .nd .lflKk. f.l"" ('cl""ffl' ('ulvllrt .bulm.nl.1 Ih. ..id al".m, cllu.ln. .,'W", h,,,lnllfttr ""nllon.d pt,,,millln/llrle'. ,. Tho d.I,nd.nl Md . duly IOINQ iI. ht.hw.y' "."IN1>ly NI, lor Ihflf Inlended PUfp'lIf, 6. Th. d,f,,,cllnl mlllnlillll.d Ih. ..let ,.Itld 1:0"""1, (ulvll" .bul""l\l. 1. Thf 'ilt, c1"IIl" And m"lnleMn"f Clt thf tAid f.l.td ronefft' Nlvfrt .bul"",,1 Will Ih. ,ftp'I"'lblllly (ll Ihf ckol.nd4l\t fl. Thf c1.I,nd4nt Wil' MI",,"I In ItIt d,.I,n .nd INIlnl'''llnc. ollht IIld fll~ e(ll\('ftl. eulv." .ttulmtlll I" ItIt Mlow1n. "'1'<<1', (,l) Tilt" Wit /\0 fluid. "u <<J prn"'l Ih, plAlnlllf fwm .Irlliln. lilt fAtmt rCII~"I. (uIV"1 .""Immt; (b) Ttltr. Will "(I wllf"ln, .1,,, 11\41 lilt tal"d ((I Mr... (ulVfJl .bulnwnl W'I I"'rf. .nd (d Th" "4Incr'lf (ulvfft .bullnf,,1 did "(It h.v. to " ,.I,f(t t"1nf tl_ll\(hft .ty(I~.I,,* '1."'"'' ullN tuuvun4Jn. u...aw.y. II, AI . ,ftuJ. (,I I'" '''1111'1\(' III 1"* 4t1t'J\!Un', I'" pl.tiIHill.u.lt.,fd . ((lmrnll\ut,d ".(IUff 411 IIt.f dMIIl "',. utili .114 II.WMf .114 . IW:h"It pi I~ r~h' wdl.tl NIINt;IW., 10. Aa A ,.',ull (If Ih. lIhlrr..I" inlurln. Ih, plllnllll h'" ~"" ""Ablll h. "Iurn In hla wl'rk .a A "',chAnk. And hAa IIllfllrrlt . hl.a pf !nwm, fH.m Ihll "AlII II' Ih. 1I~c1It,nl U"IlIlh. p""nl Un" 11. AI . ,..,,,11 (It Ih, Afor....llt 'nlurlC't, Ih. pl,,'nUIt hu und,'.o", 1'''1 p.ln And ,uff,,"'" An" willltl' It,I" Ih. 'ulu", 12, A' . ".ullllf Ih. "fllr,."ld Inlurlfl, Ih, pl"lnUfI h.u ,uUmd . p',m.",nl p",UAI Itla"bUlIy hI hlll,ft IIIW" 1'., 1;\, AI . ",uIIIlI Ih..,lnju,'", Ih, p&.llnllff h.u lualtlln4ld A ptrm.n,nl dllnlnutllln II' hla ,,,,,,lnllc"pAelly. WtlIlRIUQRIl, Ih, pl.lnllff e&.llma II' Ih. d.ffn""'nl A lum In '''''If ,I' Ih, .rb!trall(ln limit II' Ih. Cumlltr&.lnd C(lunl)' CllU,l. 14, Th. pl.lnllff, Ptlhl" Whllml,.. I. .n Indlvldu.1 ",Idln. AI IU~ Rid.. lCu.d, DltklNlln Tuwnahlp. Cumbtr&.lnd Counly.I',nnaylnm., I'. Th' .11"'1101" ", p.",r.pht J Ihwu,h " (lllhla Cumpt.lnl ar, 1"",,'po"lta hfr.ln by rtlrffnet Ihtrt\(l, 16. AI" ,..ull ollM ""U.",,,. (It Ih. d,l,ndAnl, 1M p&.llnlltt, lttthltf Whttmllf, hAl 'Ult.I",~ A Wit "lc(lJ\t(j,llum .nd "'Vie.. III h" l\ulttAnd. du. I" hla .tnr...ld InjUrl"_ WHURllPOIUl, Ih. pl.lnlill ct.l,," ,,'Ih. ~I,~nl A lum In ,,,(," (111M ,u\'li".li"n IImll III t'" Cuml1ftllnd ((lYnl)' (purt_ OOU(iLAJ, UOUC,il.N1. POUGLAIl ~ (", ~1~~'~1J .OUTH HIDDLITON TOWN'HI', Det.ndlnt. I I I I I I I I IN Title COUPT or COMMON J'l.lAlI or CUNIIIIU,^ND COUNTY, ,INN.noVAHIA CIVIL ACTION. lAW NO. 1"0-111 CIVIL TIMM JURY TRIAL OIMANDIO JOI~ ~II WHITNI"~ and ~tTH~1 WHITMIRll hll wit., '1IInUtt. v. lfO'l'l"...%O .fWD TOI Jotl Lt. ~,lt.lr. .nd ..t.hl.. Whlt..lr. D/O Willi" P. DoUtt.., alqutr. Doutl.., DoUqI., . DoU91la 17 W..t HIQh 'ir..t P.O. 10M UI clrllal.,.A 1101' You If. hereby noilUM \0 111. . wrhhn r..pon.. \. i"- .nglo'M H.w Matt.r and Cr."ulat. within tw.nty (JO) dlY' Ir.. ..rvlu. h.r.ot or . 'U4t..nt "v be .nt.rM 1,.1n.t you, OIUrrl1'H, ITIUCXLlIt, LlIUWf, IOLVMO' . CALMIN' . , .up,... court. 1.0. '0'.'0 IV ~i I, 'upr... Court. 1.0. .11... "t,orn'YI '0' t.h. Det.ndant 110 .ou'tI North'rn WIY Vork, ',.n,nIVlv.nil 1'.01 ('Ut "'..1601 'OUT" MIODI.ITON TOWHIlUP, o.r.ndant I I I I I I I C 1M 'fUe: COVMT or COMMON rU:AIi or CUM1U:fCl,AUD CoUNTY, nNHIIYlNANIA CIVI L ACTION . tAW NO. l.tO-all CIVIL TIKM JURV TAIAL OC:MANDIO JOItI. {.tIC Wllll'MIMI: and Iitl'lU.lK W"I'fMUO:1 hi. wU., Pl.lnt ft. v. U..Il.lKD........unU OOUIff I iQ'. "~I IIJf.I.'I~'QUt.Jl1Da~IOI,IQII"'1 ANP HOW, ooa.. th. O.t.nd.n\ by .nd thrQu,h It. ."grn.v., Grlfrith, .'rlokl.r, ~ra.n, IQ1Ylllo. . C.lkin., Ann ".r,ar.t Or.b, I.quir. .nd Mo~'rt A. ~r"n, I.qulr. Ind fll.. thi. An.w.r .nd ".v "Itt., in r..pon.. to Pllintlft'. co.plalnt, Ind .t.,.. .. rollow.1 1. o.ni". Aft., f.alonlbl. lnv"U'IUon, Per.nd.ni 1. without knovlldt. or lnfora.tion ,ufflol.n\ to fora' b.ll.f I' '0 th. truth or v.r,olty 01 th. .ll.,.tlon. oont,ln.4 in p.r.,raph I of ,llIntUI'. Co.pl.int .nd .... I,. 4,nl" And .trlot proot th....o' 4...04". a. WaiU". J. o.nl". Aftlf (...on.t11. lnv..U,.Uon, Pclhndlnt I. without k~lldt. or tnfof.,tlon .ur'lot.nt \0 tora , Ptll., II to th. truth or v.r.otty of lh' .ll.qltlo". oont.ln.d In p.r.,r.p" ] of 'latn.UI', CQlllplllnt AM .... 'f' 4.nl~ .nd "rhlt p.foof 'hlf'.' "...Mlt4. .. o."ill4. AIt'f ,,'..QMt-l. i"Y"U~.Uo", o.l.lt4an\ i. witnout k~l~. or ',,'Qr.4tion ,uI'io&."t to 'Of. . b4&l., " to lb.t nuth 0' Y'r.~it)' Of t/'14 .U.qUIOM ~ht.l~ t/\ par",uph . or PlI1ntUI'. Co.plllnt .n4 ".1 Inl 4,nt14 .n4 .t,lot proar th.r.ol d...nded. I. Dentld. r...a,r.ph 6 oon.t1tut.a . oonolu.ton 01 llw to whioh no ....pon.tv. pl..411\11 i. nlo...uv an4 .... i. d....a d.ntl", .. o.n1.". ,\fur .....on."l. inv..U".Uon, DlI.nd.nt .. vithout knovll4Q' or intor..tion lutttotant to tQ~ a bll1., .. to thl truth or vlraoltv of tha .11."at10n. oontaln." In p.r.,r.ph . ot 'lA1ntiff'a COlllphint .nd IA.' ar. d.ntld .nd .t,lot prool thar.ot 4...nd.a. 1. o.n1t4. ..r."r.ph 1 oonltltut.. I conolu.lon ot l.w to IIhloh no ....pon.tv. pt..4t"" ,. n.o,..uV 'M .... ia d,.Md dlntld. I. Dent.d. It t. ,ploifle",Uy 4.nl.4 that thl Dlt'M.nt v.. n~U,,'nt 1n thl d.al",n 'M .a1ntln"no. 01 th. ..td n1..4 oonorlU outv.rt abuta.nt in the 10110111", r"Plot" A. Th.... v.. no 9u1dlrall to ,rlvlnt th. ,1.lnt1Ir Iro. atrlkl", thl ,al'I" oonor.'. oulvlrt .but..nt, I. Ther. v.a no w.rnint It,," thlt th. rai.ea oonoratl oulvlrt .buta.nt V". th.r., Ind (:, Th. gon"..'''' "\llvnt abut...nt IUd not h.v. to b. rall.a 10.. eiM 1no".. .bov. thl IlIrlA". of th. .\lrrOUn41f\lJ rQldway. On th. oQntnry/ It 1, avnr.d thlt at aU U... ...l.vant h.r.to/ an.w.rlnq o.t.ndlnt/ 'Quth Ntddl.ton Townanl, IQt.4 "....tuUy/ lawfullY/1M pru4,nUy wU:b rllp,"' to th. ".19"/ ...lnt.MMa 01 it' "-0.4"'4V" t. (lIfQl4k1. U i. 'PHil1".Uy a.,..,~ ttl4t tM (lIff.Mtftt It.. n.~'i~'n'. Th. r...lnl", .ll~.tlQn. 0' p.r..,.ph , .r. d.nl.d in thllt .n'Wtrtllf Offtnd.nt 1. without know'..... or tn'.....Uon .,,'ltul.nt to 'or. I ~.Ht' It tQ \tll innh or vueotty 01 ttl. '11.watlon. oont.lntd ln p.r.,raph , 0' ,l.lntl,,'. Co.pleint. \0. o.nt.d. Aftlf r...onable lnv..Uq.Uon. DefeM.nt ta without knowl..... or lnfo~.tton ,u"iolent to fora I DIlt., al to the truttl or y.rlotty 0' ttlt Illt91'10", oontltn~ in ,.r"f.ph 10 t.t' ,1.lnUlt', COl!l,hint ana ..... u. dlnllld .nd .triot proof thereof de..ndlld. H. o.nt.d, Altu fluonebl. lnv..U,.Uon, Def,ndlnt 1. wlt~t knowl.d,- or In'orN'10n .urrlolent to rora . b.ll" .. to the truth Of vef.oity of the .11.wa'ton. oont.ln~ In p.r.,raph 1\ g, "atnUIt" eo.phint. Ind ..... art dtnltd Ind .trllilt proot ther.ot d...ndlld. U. o.n'''. AI'-r flllon.bl' tnv..U,I"O". De,.nd.nt i. wlthout knowl~. or tntoraation .utfiolent to ,Qf. . beli.' a. to 'ht truth Of ve'AGity Of the 111e9.tlon. Qont.i~ ln P"if,.ph 13 ~r ,laintiff', e"l,hint .nd .... 1ft deniH and .uiet' ,roo' ttln..' 4...ndH. U. o.nilld. An., unoA.bI. In..U. & flit hm, Defend.ni h. wtthQUt knowlldt. or tn,o,..tlon .uf'io',nt to for. I ~.lt.' I' to the 'ruth Of ve'l@tty 91 'hI .11e9a,'on. oon,.ln~ in ,.r.,r.,h 12 of fllinUff', eo.pllln' and .... Ife lI.fllM and .uhl\ ,roor th.flof d...~. IIHUno", o.I.rllUnt 'wth Hh...n.ton T(N'I'AIM, d...rt4. '\l4tfH"\ in .t. ,.vo~ 1M .~.in.\ \~ ,'ainti" t09.t~r wl'~ 'nter..' .~ ~.,. @f 'l.Ih. OOVM'I' II 11II.&.1__. DIDIO .l"",JQ.U1'I,,lUDDUtOlI ftD'''.u 14. o.nt~. Aft.r r",oft'~I. tov..tt,atton, Off.ndaot t. vlthout knovl.d9' or tnfor..,ton .ufflol."t to fora. b.lt.r .. to th. trut" or v,r.olty 01 th. .ll'Q.tton. oonl.in.d ln para,r.ph 14 or 'latntl1f" Coaplatnt and .... .r. d.nt.a end .trlat proot tl'1.r.or a.lIanaN. U. Th. o.f'ndant. an.wu, to par.trap"a a thro",h U of 'ht. Anaw.r IF' l11Oorpo,.'-d her'ln .. 'MUfh fully ..t torth at I.",,'h. 'I. OIntN. It I. .p.olfl..lly d.nl.d th.' lh. Oft,nd.ot w.a n~ll,,'nt. Th. r...tntnt .ll...llon. 01 p.ra,r.ph II ar. d.nl~ tn that In.w.rtnt OIt.na.nt 1. without kftQwl'4Q' ~r tntQraition ,ufftol.nt to tor. I b.li.r aa to th. truth Of v.r,alty of th. .Il".tton. ooot.tnl4 In p.ra,raph 1. of 'l.tn'ttl'. Co.pl.lnt. WfUIMlro'UI, Oltr.n4.nt IIouth HilWI.ton Town.hlp d...nd. 1I1441a.n\ In It, t'Yor .nd .,,.In.t th, ,1.toCIlt tot.th.r wt'" tnt'f..t Ind QO,', ." .uh. IILILlUU 11. 'tra"n,l\. I thrO\il,lh " 1ft It'lHu''por.'all baraln .. '1\01.191\ tully .et forth It l.ntth. I'. ,l.lnti','. Cpa,l.tn' t.ll. '0 .'at. . OIU.. 4'11 I"'lon .,.tn.l An.w.rlnt o.l.n4A"', IIg~'h HtckU.to" TWlt.hI" upon tthlfh r.lt., "In .. 9,."'14. 1f. 'lalnll", JQd I... Whtllllir.", .UtqM in)"'if. AM u...,.. ".,. t~ r"'l#li 4'lt hi. CWn '4'11. ,....U"."4.. ,g, 'ltintlf', J~.l ~ .~i'lIIlf' w.. ~4'ln'rl~'4'lrlIY Of {~"'h.,y ....."..nt, wtll{lft ~'flw"ny AMi", ~f4f'UV' n.Qliq.no, "I' th. ,ub,tlntl.l "0\0' in brinqinq APOUt. hi. And hi, wit." 1\1,,14 1n'urt.1 And al""'. al. "0 .ot or ,.llu,' to let on th. plft g' 'outh "lddl.ton TO\Itn.hip v.. . ,ub.UnU.l til!!t{:1r in brinqtftl,f Iboy\ t.h' ,..lnUU" Ill"t4 in,url" And d.~.q'" al. ,1.1nilff hI' not .u.t.ln.d I ..rlou, In'ury I' d.,ln.4 by Aut 1"0.., 1~ ,..C.'.A. 1110a. al. 'lltniltl'l 01.1- for non-.oono.to d...,.. at., De ~.rrt4 ~o.",. Pl.lntttt hi' .1.gtt4 . It.lt.d tori op,'on I' ,.t ,orth 'n Aut "'0-', 10 p"c,'.A. 1"0l1b)11)(dl. 14. 'latn"fl'. 111".a 1n,uri'l Ind al..,.1 ..y Il.y, b..n th. r.I\Ut ., .otl or o.l..'on. by Third ,.,\1.. over vho An.w.rl~ Oft.Rd.nt 'outh Nlddl.ton TO\Itn.hlp hll no 1".1 I..pqn.lbtll\y or gontrol. al. Otf.nd.nt 'outll Nlddl.ton TO\Itn.hlp 11 l..un. frOM th. wlthln .utt pur.u.nt to th. provl.lon. 01 ., 'l.e...A. ,..., .t ..... a.. .talntlf'" If. .t.,"'orl1V b.rrt4 Ir~ r.ooY.ry '9.in.t o.t'''''ln\, "outh "iddl.\oll Tovn.nt, lor t.Uur. to .Ly. no""1 of tnt.nt \0 .y. wLthln .i. IOn\l\. .fllr lh' d.t. 01 lh. O'U" Q' Ig'ion i. f~lr~ by 43 rA.e.I.A. . 'taal')' n. Thl. ."Uon i. ""n.d bV thl .ppltol"l. .ut"'. of 'i_".,ton. .. '" forth In .a '..c..,A. ...a4. ". DlI.n4."\. .outh "1441.\on Townwhtp, did net h'y, 10'u,1 writ'," nelle. 01 t~ .ll~.aly dl"9'fQU'I u~.f', ,Ad h...rdoV' cond'tlOfll ,.t lOlth in ,','ntl"'. c~,l.lnt, or in t~ .u.rMth'.. U ..id ..rlU." M\l" 101.. ru.iv.-4, lt It" ,..\ ucety..., it w.. net f.~.ty~ in .u"tldent U.' 10" d",OOAnt, pouch Middl.ton Townthtp, \0 hlYI oorr.o'~ it or t. hay. w.rntd trly.Illnt publte ot \~ .11.,." d.nt,rou. oondition. n. ft, aU'(lIi\1ol\' of t'lalntUt'. Co.pllii"t 19"tn.t o.,.OOln\ IOU\h "ld41,'on Tovnehip flU. '0 It.t' " (lliU" 01 IQUon "OO,r .ny ot \h' 'No.ptlon. to ,oyer".,n'.' i..untty .. .., forth in Aut HI, .n4 wtth n'PlIQt to th, \hr.ahoI4 nqui,...nu tor torintt", , pUlon.I in,,,,ry .oUO" AI .1' forth in U ,..C...A. "UI, J~. .boula lilbtltty be found un tb. p.rt of 'h. Def,nd.nt, 'outh "1I"U,ton Town.hip, any .uoh lia.Uit" Nt", tp.oUl",By 41n1e4, thl dl."" ,.ooy.rabl. .,aln.' 'outh "iddl.ton Town.hip If' li_i'" ln the .~nt .nd tV" .1 lit fOfth in ., '.'.A. 1'11'. H. If the a@-(lident Ol1Qurrtd II .ll.."- in 'l,inUff'. COllplain', it,.n 'I'll @-(IndiU"n oo.pllin~ of d14 not QU'" " r.,.on'bly for.....pl. ,l.. 0' ,~ .oQla.nt or 'h' In'urit. co.pl.ine4 ot. ,,"IIl'fOIlI, Offtndant 'ou\l, "l44I.\on Town.Mp a...nd. ,,",,..n\\ In 1" f.yor 'nd .,,In.' the 'lainiitl. 'ot.\h., wi\b In'.,.'\ And oo.t, Of 1I,lli. GJUrrITM, ITIUC1U"IM, L.lMAH, IOI.YMOtI . CAbXlHI , . 1.0, fOHfO aUUlWUl'..JIlYJ.a ANP NON, thl. _Llf~d.y of Miron, ",., I, kob.f, A. Llra.n, I'qul,., . ..aN, of t.h. flr. of OIU"IT", .TIUC:lCUR, LlMAN, 'OLYNO' , CALKIN', I.qulr.., h.r.by ~rtlfY th.t I h.v., thll dlt., ..rvl4 I oopy or th. 0,'.n4Int'. An.w.r and ".w Mitt., bV Unlt.d Iltat.. M.n, ll44u...d to the puty or aUgr".y Of rloCli'd .. foHowl! Willi.. P. Poutl.., I.qulr. Doutla., Dou91a, . DoU91.. a1 w..t H"h .tr..' P.O, Doll 361 C"II'I', PA 110') A"~fn.y for "al"tlt' ORI"ITH, "RICJURt LlMMAN, ,OI.YNO. . CAfJUN. IYIJ"",..~>> Ili,.!J. nn Mart.,., onb, I:.q. Attorn.y tor OIt.Rdant IUpl... court 1.0. "1'" 110 'outh North.rn W.y york, 'Innlylvlnat l1t03 (11'1) "'.?t03 u.. YI'lf"Afl~ I verUy thtt th. 'Qr~ol", '.OU U. \ru.. upon !If p"'IOM1 knovledv, or 'n'oraltlon .nd bell.', Tnl. v.r"'QI".n ,. ..de lubj.ot to the "nlltl.. 0' ,. ,..0.., I 4'04. """nt '0 un.vorn t,1.1'lo,"on t. .uthorltl'" Dltlf /41'11 , .' A ,jq..i.'~- .~. L." ..'., "C:- O' r It! 'OUTH MIDDLITON TOWN'HI. ~.. ~ ":i.' , Iyf ; :1'" .1;'*1(... . (J/.,:tc/ ..., I ,,"'1 .. ,h' ,.t.n Of 1"t t,'~~";'fU, lElIJitt' ,H:j t' ',,"h ft_'1~! .!~, ....- ~.,..., lilllM/ltl&fWJt .Ui.... '!f_-- ~~_ 11"''''' , ... ", ',!,,/ ;':':'" "";, . ",.>',C! '. '.,<:;:'~'..: .:'" .' . :'. . " ".' '. "J . . ::,. ',' :.':.L,,":":, ',: 1 .," ....: '. '.'. " " '.. ,".'.' ;,': ,:'.>,," ":, ,c,' ..... '. " . . "::C,> ':". .:',">::~:'i.\ '~'D'~ :~:::: D:.'," . ~ 30 3:u '"'95:",>;/>..:. . . .. ....! ~! 'H;:)(.~i... .." ,..'< .' j ;Ie.. ,.. ";'f ....':;)~ ~hl ..',' '... '.": . :,.!.;,):":",, ':.'.. .: .' ",.' '.~' . "" :d' ,'to ~:,i,:,. . '~':"."I( .... .': ~::,2,," ,::<:' \;i;/:::; : .. . ',<'.: . . :.',e " . . ... .'; /','.;'; , ,~.. : "C< :,".:,..;'::::.. ',' ::"..,: ,!,',,:.:.>. ',: ,;';:;" I~;' "",'.,;'.' """';:":':.'y.."''',,~,,:,i:::;:' ',' .... ",.' , "'" .' !.: / .'" ',,','''''' :;.';. '... '.. ' , " $';'~:"'~ ,,' ,:,', "" :.,: ,,;,"" . '; , ,: ,;7': ",' ' :. ,;' . .'. . ,. . ;,:>.': ',', ,.,,' ':,f", ' ;:. " ,;,~ '; ',' ';," ':, " ",,;' ", .-J., ' '. '", , ", ". ,\'; :' ""'"',,;).::,, '",,: ,,:.'...'" ::' ;,!,::: ";:::,: :.:' :,; ,.~:' , ". '.' ":,:.",,.;:;: '<'.-:' :';",J ',,';' ',., :: . '" ,,;, .' ,i'; , ' ,. ....::..;,.': ,'.: "C';;. . ';'" ,.; . '::':~!~~i . :,':,"" '.,;,}",:.,:"..,::,:,:, ;,:,::',: " . ."'.' , "C', ":.:', ,::< ".:., ", ", ' , :':, ,:...>,: "", " ","" ."", '.,:'.';, ;':, :' . .' '\,.! ".:,:.';., :;;,\ ',:" ',>',:';': :.; .:~~:': /{ ,: .' :...., ..... . . ":".!">~t':;: .::..". ' . :,}.,;' :. ".' , ." ......IIIOl.~=I/I...~ . ..',,::f: ' /' i~,,:: . . . ." , . ';'==:.m .;.:""t, ::: ;,,;"" ';'H> . ." . '", :"" "~:.;." .;-' .;< ;:;~',>~ '. ".':~ ""'-'/,> ' ',:,:,: .,c. ',', : .\:" '~;::, .., >; :;:'j.,'", ..' ........; 'C.:::!':;...... ~ - , ." ",'; , ; ..~.. .... ,~.;, . Cc . :~. . ..... . .' ~;:' .. .' " :~:: .' ' '.'. ,'..' , , ,'; " ) ";," ';, ~: . ~;: :: :, " it~"". JOEl. tUB WHlTMIR/l and lIlITllLUB WIIITMIRll, hI. wife IN TIIU COURT Oil COMMON 1)1.1IA.14 0(1 CUMlIllIU.ANIJ COUNTY, I'IlNNSYLV ANIA CIVIL ACTION. LAW NO. 199' . 211 c/VlI, TIlRM V. SOUTH MIOOI.UTON TOWNSHIP JURY TRIAl. I)IlMANOUO 11. The .lIosallonl ollhe orlgln'l romplalnl are IncorporAled h.r.ln and reference It made Iherelo. 18. Denied. The complalnl Ilalft' . c.u", 01 action lor f.llure 10 m.lnl.ln Ihe ro.dway In . rtAlOnAbl, And ",fll condition. 19. Dtlrned. The pl.lntllf, when ,nlerlns Ih. curve, IUd on Ic., which w.. Budden and unexpecled, and, due 10 Ihe lack of Ilulde rill, Ind Iho arllfldal condition Iher. exlltlng, Wit Ihe ('aule for Iho plalnlllf'.lnjurle,. 20. Denied. Ill. denied Ihal any l\.gI/8en('" which may p<,.,lbly bl! AlItlbulabl. 10 Ihe plalnllff, WiI. I .ubllantlllllaclor In bringing .bout the h.rm, 21. Del\lfd, Th. d,hll\d'l\l faU,d to properly malnlaln Ih. tllAdway, failed tel erecI approprlale lluldCl raUl, and faUed III Ilgn Ih. dAna,rou. condition. 22. Denied .1 II I,.al (,ol\(I\lllon. 23. l)fnled. Th. lImlttd lort opllon would hAVe no ,((<<I dUI 10 the lierlou. n'lur. of Ih. plAlnllff'.lnjurl... 24. ()fnl.d. II Wit Ih. mponllblllty 01 Soulh Middleton TowlUhlp 10 malnl.4ln 1lIk! nlAdway tn llAf. mndlllo". 2.111. Dtnitd. South Middleton TCIWNhlp I, nol humul". The provllloN 01421'... C,S.A. . 8541 et M41', '~4k IVI llwll\l4'lv<<. ZO. P4'~, 4Z ".. C.liA , 5'':': (.) .. /WI . t>.tr u d41n\rd by tilt \,M~lUt..nt, VuUhir, 1M dd~l\\t.flt w.. .w,u~ vt Ihb ",dd~flt, ill w~ll.. om.r l,t"lllt'l\tl whl(h \\('nmfd al tilt' kl('tlll':lfl \If thll Nld., "bUlllItll\1 COMMONWIlAL TH 011 I)UNNSYL VANIA ) I 59, COUNTY 0/1 CUMDfiRLAN1) ) Joel Lee Whitmire, being duly .worn according to law, depole. and aaya Ihatth, avermenll In the within pleading are Irue and correct, 10 Iho belt of Ilgner'. knowledgll, Information, and belief. ,J IilII"'lAl "" lAHUll UYIlOI.., "*10 CAllltt I toto, Will AIIO COUIIIf "'~I"~ /.,"'" ' Sworn and .ubtcrlbed 10 bt(o,.. m. Ihl1 I'I(~ day of MaKh, 1995, ~ . it" ., ~ . , It( ifh . '1 ~~) Notary -'i"' ,- .L . '; fl.""" ~ '-.. :':~j_:!;~..): ~ ".", ' ~,. , ^', .n . _, ,. . ,. ~, , . " . '. .,'...... 11;.11 .' '.,,":,cy .. ,:0}':: ,}, , n.'", "Z,,~~,~ '1$ , ,s, i :.\C"!"~ '~>':.'\j,. .. Olu\\\t~~~:l~\;W:..; , " , ;"., ' "'," .." . ' "" .::;,', . ': . ,'" ", ." ,,,:' :,:'" ," ' , !'" '-:,,:;', , .' ", " , " ',; ",,;,;,;: " "" ';'.:.;~ :' ..:,' ,., ,,''-,':,;1:)'' ,,;.' i,:, c/;~;."", " ,;:,', . · ~};;:':'i:,' ,.,:".',}",,<, '. "'~~;~z'i''':'';'',(' ,.,..~:tii;ij I".:, ':;",",~;~, ",,: :',;', ,,',;.,' ,:', ."'.:~"',, ".';,;' ',,' i;':" :: ' :. (. . '...,.. ,,' > ,':: , ,':', 'i'".; :";,;i,~" < ';", . " ,":,ii:,;;;;" .,' '. ;,"", ',' i,e.' ", ", . <',/)".: ..':,''''''''! :;,," ,',' ,,- ~;,t '. ,"',.} ;-" . ..; . ,,:' ';'. " .". . ~(t': ,". '; .' .... ": ", i:: .;( . ";;,.; .,' '" .:' " ':,.,;';'- '.,',;;;, 'J';',.,' ',' ~:; .:.., ,': '.: '..,,,-,' !:~':~:i ' " ., :,:;) , , ;:' :;....,' ,'. ,,:\ ",:,'. :c;(: r,:~':.' :: ." . " :,~} ,:,:'; ',' ,,:,~"<;,;'t ,; . ;,:'l "'c,,:.:>" ,< ..: ,:., . "'~~:~';.'." '. ".' >' . ::.);;',',::,,'~Y-';~':",,' ~'<,'~."''':'''''/1':',' [~~, , '::- "'"":.',', : ':':" "'..-:'c.,";, . '",;" , 'g; '" :.' ;:'- . ".,:/ ."i :":,;:-"," '~',... ,>.',",\ ..",c." 'C; , .' ; '... T;: ..; . y". .: ..::~'~:):' ,';;~::d:'~: "" .~ / ;'. '; ,'...-<,.'x. .'. :.', ,>~',: ';"', >:p~.. ..,. , --::':',",',:';".. " . , ' " '.' , ,'." " " ' :', .'.':, . '..::-,;:' ", :,' ',' ' . '; '" , " .... ....:.. ..:..~' '. ...' .',' ....... ',) "':' ...... '.~:.: '.,'; :,;'.: , "c',,'-',",;,';"': ".' ":'."".,\".c::.-,-"c", . ';. \', ",' , . ',.'" '" , '< <>" ,,' · , ..... F '. ',,; ," " . .' ,'. '.' .', .'.:: ./ .. '.. ,'; '~~'F; .' ",~'".:,' '. : " ~!:., "!: :c:,'{;\ ;',', " :';.":':', <)' ~\;~; \" ): ",;""",:,,,,'.:'~j: " ::~', ' : ,f " .' ~. '.: - "-. -.~ ;,:.. 't ,:,t: .' .' . .,' ,':";:';' . , " ' ..:' ::'''':.,'" ': ' " I""'IIUM. "IIl'IIUM" 1""'(11,"," " W. IIIl1l1lll, 1'1'" '61 ('.\IU,IS"': I'A 1701.1 It'U:rllIlNI( 'n.w,I'" WIU,IMl t. 1"Il'CIl,A', U() SUl"t"" C"~I"I'" ,'Nl~ CiIJIIllll! I' 1"11 ~lI.AS, III.I,W .UI.."...I...." I III MUI, J;';,r'[~;~;"'Wlllilli.i'r~."il,i'lr""''''''''''."._''''''''''''''''''''.""""j;i'''Hl,;''('',';;i'ir,';f',"j';;;i'j'illli,'''fI'lI;ii';','if''''''' IMhh'l' \Vhilmln', hi" wir", C"mll,'rlalllt ('lllInly 1','nn"ylvl1nll1 I'JIIII1I1H No, 1995.217 Civil T'rm VII Sllulh Mhtdll!hll1 'l'lIw""hll' l>l'fc'lIdilnl Civil ^,",llll\ LilW Jury Trlilll>l'IIlI11llI,'d .'"",,,..,..................,,...,,,,,,..,..,.........,,.,'......,..,,",,,,,..........,,,,.,,,,,..............,,,....,".,,...,.......,.."'....,.',".........".."....,......,...,..."..,..,,,.....................,,.. I. 11..11.... Whllmlr. 2, """ 1/111'12/111741 .1 I'.ll. 1111_ 2"1, Mt, IIHllr "I'rinll-, I'a, '706'1 ., ""' .I"w.. 'I, !It'f' .t",V.. It. "'I",til" "..uralllf, 'Il"'" 'iI.hllla" !II. 1',(', ",,_ 2'll1.\ h.h11lh \'4111.)',1'41, IIllKIBl.lt II. Olmm,(I(lflIIl ^"IU"", IOu..n lI.rtfAnllllllUIIll.', nil", lC'I.,....,III.t1V.., . 1t1ll.4M\I/ftIIII, IIl.'l'(,t.A" Ill'l'(;J,1I''' Ill'Ut, , . d . ,"t, ' ft~' \. J~ lJ _-~,~, _ _ ~ \vIlli,.", I', 1>11L1iiA" '.. III ' AllllfI,..Y hI' 1'I.llnliU. l>4~; J\lM "'. 1'H'i JUN 8 ~ OJ rK '95 H(.U 01 r,l( ",l"Cti~"'" fV"H",I.~ (,'\!l Hh.~I; ,~~ ~ ~',