HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-00227
~
~
o
.
'7
, ,
~)
j
./
o.
"<
I
I
i
I,
11
FAUAGE AN)) MdllUllIt
THOMAS J, RUGGIERI, ESQUIRE
I.D. NO. 611186
IJ. 'uburb.n .t.tJon 'utldtng
"'7 John r, Kennedy .oulev.rd
PhJl.delphJ.,'A ",OJ
(2151 5U-Jl7J
Ii
,
I,
"
I,
I:
;
,
"
TRACIY .. LUll,
i
.1dlltUr
:i
,
,
,
,
"
I
I
v.
RAYMOND INYDIIl aIId
HICHAIL IIIYDIIl,
Derlndlllt,
i
I
1
NOTICE
YIIU have ...... IIUllIlln ..OUII, "~I'" wi"" III
old""" .,.UbI the .lal.. ... ',,/Ih ill the "~k""lAf
ra'..., 'IOU 1II\Illl1... IIbllll willli. 1_, 1211) 1Ia,.
.Il.r Ihi. I\lmrl.int anollM~i., .,. 1tH\'.oJ, 10, .'IIl'
. wnlhHI .",....,....'" f'HIII/lIU, "' 10, aII4,""" anol
lilin, In wrilin, wllh lhe .tlllll '''II' ...,.,..... iii
\lhj...ltnll. III lhe d.u". ... '\1M .,.,.at ,'III, Vull
.1lI w.mod lhaI If ,nil "11 II. IItI '" the .... till,
prl"'..... wuh\lul ,"u anol . JIIoI,_11llo11 ... _,.oJ
.,.In'l '\lU lo, the 111\1,1 wuhuull\ulllfl "'~I4.'vI 11I1
mnMY .Iairnool In the Illmrl.lnt 'If "" 11I1 "'...,
d.lm n' "I.., ,...-1o?i It, 1M pllllnllll, VUIlIlll'
I.... mn"", 'If p'.....n' III '~Iw' ,1,11I. ,,,.,...,..... ..,
,uu,
YOU IlI00ll.ll T A"lllllll I'AI'U 1U YIIU"
LAWnR AT ONCIl. If' VOl! IX) NUIIIAVIl A
LAwnR oM ('AN NUT A~I'l"Ul UNIl, (lUlU
UM TU,l1PlloNIl 11111 lInll'lI WI tWUII
Utl.OW TO "INll ()\ff WIII:MIi YIIll ('AN 01:1
L.I.C1AI, lit!.",
I,
I
I
,
!
"
I:
II
II
I'
I:
I'
h
,
Ii
I'
"
Ii
::
COllM'&' AI)MINL"'I'MA10M
('umbullllld (~lHIn~ l'l.IlIr1bllU.w
.'Ul/l1h noor, I . f,... H "11, (
CarlL-it. PA 1701J
(717) %~6%OO
'I
I
I
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
ooua, or OOMMON .LIA.
or OUM.I.LAND COUNtY
OIVIL ActION
, t
110. '/ )
.J..} )
(I. ~I\t~ ), I 1-\"
A \' I~O
,. .. tlrm..dllllll . IIol4'll .. If WI", IlltIokooI
..-. .,-,10-,.. .. ..... .--.loI. ..,........ .. ...
.."... ..,........ ...... 1_ ~fl/Ilf 11'11 iI... ..
"... .. ....... . It ...IlI . " "111I1- It , III
....._...., ,... Wit __ .. ...,..,_,.
___nil.... ,..,.... .. - - .....,. , _..'" . III
WfIf.. ""_ _... ... _ftlIw .. ..."_
. Iu "1""" ,'" '" WlMII . .... ,..,1111II. l01I .......II,
..... .. ...... IIH .. ...1ItltlIt, .. Wollf ~. 1IOl'J..;...
, ,....... HIllIIltlIII la .1II.hil, '" WIIIlf, ""11 ....
,..~... ....., III .....n... "... ~,It ...." ,......r..
....loII' . "Y~ eM "IRI",'."I, , '...... '4W .........
1""'f'III ... .... .... """1"'_ . .... 01.-....
IJIIooI ........."".. .,."..".- _'''''1'10 I.,.... .. '4""
.....IIi. ''''1''''''''''" ""II .......,
IUVIl UIA II"MAld'" A 11N Altllll,\lJH
INMU"ATAMI<NH: ., Net mNtt AltlllL\lJU
(l " NO 11l<NI: U, I"""UO '111'1('11'" II; I-I:;
"""AII TAL nIlVIOU, VA"A ~N 1'''11'11'''''' (i
I UMt; I'U" lUf;tuttll A '-A ('t'nN~ fli,,,
"'Ilt('("UH ,I; l:Nnl~N'U UUHA A"-\II'
"AU AVUNlllM( 'iI'NUI; 'I: I'l~f'"
nINUO~II. A'l,""Nf'" U.('At
I
I
I
I
!
I
!
i
!
,
!
1
i
I/'
'I
I,
'AMOK AND McBRIDE
THOMA, J. RUGal!RJ, "QUIRI
f.D. HO, UIIlI
,J, 'ubwr..n ....40n 'u41~4n,
1"1 JoAn 't K.nn.~y 'ouJ.v.r~
'h41.~."h4.,,~ "'OJ
Ii (JUI 'u-J"J
,
,
; fllACIV I. L.W'.,
'.7 Hountain Viaw Road
a.twyn, "ennaytvanil 19313
'lataUu
· OOUlf O' OOlOCON 'LIU
· O. OUQQUltO COun,
.
t
t
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
t
v.
ornL ACTION
IlAYMO.D '.VDIA,
37 Creek Road
Cusp 1ft 11, "ann.yl vanll
u.
17011
, "'eXAIL '''YD'.,
, a7 Cnell Road
I' Callp Htll, 'enn'Vlvant. 17011
; ~
ii
Ii Det"'lftl.
:;
I'
II
I'
J
I'
,I
Ii
/I
II
il
Ii
NO.
gQM'II'111
1.
'llintltf, Traoey 't Lewt., t. an Idult lndlYidual Ind
.utctent Of the COlUlOnwealth ot ".nneYIYanta, County Of MontIJOlll...y,
r..tdtn, .t '" Nountai" Vtew ROla, '.rwyn, 'enn'YIVantl 1"12.
I. Def'ndant, RaYMond 'nyd... (hentnafte" r.t.ned to ..
I"I!I/ "Nr. 'ny4.,,,,, 1. an adult tndtvtdu41 and ....1<<1."t ot the
I co-.onw..lth ~f r.nn'Ylvant., County of Cu'berllnd, r..t<<ll"9 at 17
il ernk .Old, CUI' HtU, "M'Ylvant. &70&1.
II
'I
'"
,pi>.'
I'
it
I
3. Oerendant, "ichlle1 Bnyder, i. the minor ehl1d ot
defend.nt, Hr. Dnyder, reeldln9 wlth detend.nt, Hr. Bnyder, at 37
Creek po.d, c.mp lti11, renn.ylv.nia 17011,
4, On or about Harch 30, 1993, at or about 8100 a.IIl"
p1aintirr, while we.rinq a eeat belt, w.. operatlnq In lutomobi1e,
owned by Thoma. Lewi., when .h. brou9ht her vehiol. to a complete
etop in ob.ervanee or a r'd traffio liqht at the inter..ction or
Route 311 and lieuhey Park Drive in camp lIill, renneylvania.
5. At the .ame tlm. and Qeneral looatlon, derendant, Hlohael
Bnyder, wa. operatlnq an automobile owned by derendant, Hr. Snyder,
In a northerly dinction .ome diltanoe behind plaintifr on Heuhey
Park Orive, near it'. lnter..etlon wlth Route 39.
6. At the .... time and qeneral loc.tion, defendant, Hichae1
Snyder, wa. operatlnQ der.ndant' Hr. Snyder'. automobile pur.uant
to Hr. snyder" requ..t ln that defendant, Hlchael snyder, wa.
uainq def.ndant, Hr. snyder'. automobUe to traneport ..verd other
I pa..enger. to an entertainment event In Her.h.y, ,enn.ylvanl..
I
Ii 7. At the ..... time and qenaral looation .. def.ndant, Hr,
Ii Bnyder'. lutomobUe w.. approachlnq thll inteneotlon of lIenhey
I
I' I'ark Drive and Route 39, derendant, Hlchul .nyder, w.. opentlne,
Ii
Ii Hr. Snyder" Automobile In A neqliqent, oarele.. And/or reck Ie..
~ m.nner.o ae to cau.e the front end of Hr. snyder'. automobile to
Ii
I: colllde viOlently with the nar end of the automobile belnq
;!
Ii operahd by plaintiff, Tracey 8. l.ew", dter the plaintUf hild
co.e to . full, leqal .top ln ob.ervanee of the red traffic 11qht
at the lnt.r..ctlon.
J
&, The negll0ence, carel...ness and/or reckl..s"es. of
defendant, Hlchael snyder, conalated of, but waa not 11mlted to,
the followlnQ I
(a) oplut1n9 dehndant Hr. Snydu'. ClutomobUe at a
hlgh and eKce..lve rate at .peed under the olroum.tanc,.,
(b) ta1l1n9 to maintain detendant Hr. Bnydn'e auto-
moblle under proper and adequate control at the tlm.,
(c) fal1lng to keep a proper lookout for the automobile
balng operated by plalntlff, Tracey 8. Lewl., whloh wa. legally
.topped 11'1 observance ot the red tratrlo 119htl
(d) operatlng detendant Hr. 8nyder'. automobile 11'1 eueh
a manner .. to eoll1de wlth the rear ot the automobUe belng
operated by plalntlff, whlch was le9ally stopped 11'1 ob.ervance ot
the red trattlo 11ghtl
(e) operatlng detendant Hr. snyder'. automoblle without
due regard tor the r19hta, aahtYI well belno and po.1Uon or
plalntlrr under the aforesald olrcumatanee.,
(t) operatlno defendant Hr. snyder'. automobl1. ln
vlolatlon of the ordlnance. of Camp 11111, Penneylvanla and the
.tatute. of the Commonwealth of PennsVlvanla pnhlnln9 to the
operatlon of motor vehlele. on publlt:1 hlqhways, whiCh conduot
conetltutee nev11geno. .. a .Atter of lawl
(0) .uoh other act. and n'911geno., oAr_le..n... and/or
uckl..sne.. AI ..V be datu,lllnod throu\Jh the proc..e ot dleoovny.
9. A. a dlrect and prolChlAte nlult or the cOIU.lon and
defend'nt, Mlch.el Snyder'. n4J(JUqent, carole.. Ind/or reckl...
}
conduct, plaintlff wa. thrown vlol.ntlY aqaln.t the lnt.rlor or hur
automobile and .u.talned ..ver. lnjuri.. to the lIIu,cl.., bloolt
v....l., n.rv.., t.ndon., conn.ctiv. til'U.', .kln, bon.. anlt
or9an. of h.r body lnoludln9' but not llmlt.d to, ..v.r. .traln to
ij
I: tha c.rvical vert.brae and contlquou. lort ti..u., ..van n.ok and
,
, should.r pain and frequ.nt h.adach...
10. ". a direct and proll1mate u.ult or the oolli.lon a 011
def.ndant, Hlcah.l Snyder" n.qllq.nt, car. 1... and/or r.okl...
conduct, plaintiff hll .utt.nd a IIv.ra lnjury to hn rillht
olavlcl. which now protrude. out at a IIr.at.r dl.tano. than her
left clavlol. and which cau..., and will oontlnu. ln the tutur. to
C4u.a plaintiff ,ub.tantlal paln and .uff.rin\l.
11. ". a diract and proll1mata r..ult at the colli.lon .nlt
, def.ndant, Hichaal snyder" neqUII.nt, cuele.. and/or raokl,..
condl/ct, plalntlff ha. .uft.r.d, and wll1 oontlnu. to lurrar In th.
rutur., \lraat pain, a\lony and lnconvenlenc..
12. A. a dlreot and prowlmat. re.ult of the oolll.lon and
d.f.ndant, Hlcha.l Bnyd.r" n.1I1lll.nt, "ar.l... and/or reokl'"
conduct, plalntlff hi' b..n, and In the tuture wl11 be, pr.Vlnt'd
from att.ndlnll to h.r u.u'l dally dutl.. a. a pr.-madlcal .tudant
at the Unlv.ralty at Vlrqlnla, II w.l1 II har yulttd awtu..
currioular actlvlt1.., lnoludlnq, but not U.lte" to, 'nqu.nt
}0991n9 and .wlmalnQ, to hllr \lr.at detrl..nt, d"'\la and 101..
1). A. a diract and prowl.at. r..ult of ths QOlll,lo" .~j
d.f.ndant, "lch"l snydtr'e ".~119.nt, ".,.1... all4/of r.ckhlu
~onduot, plaintl" h.. lncurrttd, and In tn. 'utur. wlll ~~t,~~. t9
'i
.
Incur, M.p.n... ror ~edtaal treatment and Phy.tcal therapy tn an
amount not yet a.oertatned.
14. A.. direot and proKlmAt. re.ult or the coll1.ton and
a.rendant, Htahael 'nvd.r" n'Ql19.nt, oar. Ie.. And/or r.okle..
oonduot, plalntUt'. autolllobll. w.. ..vnely d....Q.d, to
Platntltt'. ur..t d.ttt.ent and tln.noial 10",
COUNT I
Ir..., .. L.vi. Y. Nioh'.l 'n,d.r
11. ,111ntl,t lnoorporate. by ret.r.no. par.uraph. 1 throuQh
14 a. If fully ..t torth at lenoth.
U. petendant, "lch.,l 'nyder, b U.ble tor plalntHt'.
ioil/ri.. d..crlbld hlr'ln, In a. .uoh a. pl.lntlrf', lnjuri.. are
t.he dingt .nd prowlNU r..ult ot d.tendant, Hlch"l Inyd,r"
n.oliVlne., oltel...n... and/or r.ckle..ne.. I' ..t forth .bove.
.....roa" plalnttft de~.nd. da.a9" .v.tn.t d.tendant,
"'(lh.el 'ov"er, ln an ..ount 1n eICae.. of Twenty-rtvI Thou..nd
!Jllllu. (tn,ooo.1I0), l.olu"tvl ot lnhr..t. and (lona,
COUNT II
"..., .. Llvi. v. a.ra.nd 'n,.ar
11. '1110,t't lnoorpor.'.. by rererenoe p.rIQr.ph. 1 throuuh
1. .. ,t 'ully ..t 'orth .t ltnqth,
U. 0."004"', ".YIIWM '"Vdn, t. lhbl. 'Qr pl.tntUt'.
'n)lifiu UAY1UIV# trQII! \tl. /'I~llq.nt, CAul... and/or r.old...
/:I.~MiWt 01 4dln44n', HtQtt....l "Wdu, In .. II!U<:h .. d".ndlnt,
aH<1tJ4'1 tl\yIM" ...4. .",UfMJ u tl'!l "'l.nt of d'f.nd4"t / "AVMn4
~~~~fl. -, ,.. \1.. .~ f'~ ~f tn_ .~~'d'flt.
,
WHlllrOll, pllintitt de~lndl dl~1gel 19lin.t detendant,
Raymond 8nydn, in In amount in noe.. ot TWlnty-rive Thou..nd
Dollar. ('aD,OOO.OO), exclu.lve ot inter..t and OOltl.
rAllOI AND MaaRIDI
~. .
'YI /I~ ..
THOMA' 00 Ill', l'OUUlI
Attorney tor Plalntitf
I
i
I
I
!
II
l'
II
,I
Ii
lJ
Il
:j
ii
.
!IBlllgAtlQII
TlACIV .. LI.I', h.r.by v.riti.. that .h. i. the plaintiff in
thi. aotion and that the flot. .et forth in the foreQolnQ complaint
ar. true and corr.ot to the be.t of h.r knowledqe, information and
beUef.
Thi. .tat.m.nt i. mad. .ubj.ot to the p.nalti.. ot 18 Pa.e,s,
S4904, r.latinQ to un.worn fal.irioation to luthoritl...
DAUDtj.! /1 r.
,
I
-, ; .f
, 'tu.~.y;ill
/
). ,If,
- ",1 '. v~~ ~
'nil"
( ? ~Y:I
.
!
I'
I
I;
,
i
I
I
I
i
i
II
!I
II
Ii
H
11
" C'"
C .> !
/;,t: .;.-
Ll'5S
/~ 1l&1, 40 S4!
t) :)1
H .~ 5 ),'
(ljl, ~j11
;....1,1 ii /I?()
(1, J. ~ ~J
,
I
. r
~~'r, < #
{
.'
_B#t ;t:
. ,
i,I<,'.O:
COURT OF COMMON rLEAR OF
CUMBI!ItI.ANO COUNTY, PENNA.
NO. 95-227 CIVIL
'u
'55
TRACEY S. L~1S
VI.
RAYMOND SNYDER .nd
HICIIAEL 8NYPlUt
EHT~Y or APPEARANCE ANO DKHANP
ro. JURY TRIAL
McKISSOCK . HOrrHAN, P.C.
IVI John ), McGr.th
1.0, No, 42189
1700 Market Street
tuUe )ono
Phll.delphl', PA 1910]
(zu) m-mo
To 'ho W""I,/,~'III\J'nn:" V"" ."
h'-I{! ! I, " "1
f /1/,,<-, 1~1~11"
'I ~ ,j
HO~ISSOC~ , HOFFMAN, P.C.
PYI John J. McOrath
Identitication No, 42389
1700 Market street, suite
Philadelphia, PA 19103
(215) 246-2100
~I
~
3000
.f 1\
p. \\.e. \ ;1(1;:,11..
torney tor
"~
-4
Detendante
v..
.
.
I
.
I
.
I
COURT OF COHMON PLIAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
JURY TRIAL DEMA~OIP
NO. 95-227 CIVIL
TRACEY 8. LEWIS
RAYMOND SNYDER and
MICIlAEL SNYDER
D".~P~"~'~JI ~D HI. HATTER
Dltendant., Raymond Snyder and Michael snyder, by their
attorney., Mc~i..ock , "ottman, P.C., an ewer plaintittll
Complaint a. tollow..
1. Detendant. are without knowledqe or intormation
.utticient to torm I beliet al to the truth ot the alllVltion. or
paraquph 1.
2. Adlllitted.
3. Olnied I' .tated. Hichael snyder i. the adult .on ot
Ray.ond .nydar and pr..ently Uv.. in Ulthluhl., I'.nn.ylvlnie.
4, It 1. admitted that the accldent took place et the tl..
and plaoe alleved. At the time ot the accident, the trattic
119ht tor ItlnhlY park Driv. tratflc Wla qr..n. Dltlndlntl are
without knowledqe or lntor'lticn lutrloient to tora e belier e.
to the truth ot the rl.ain1n9 111.qltione ot plrAqraph 4.
5, Ad.itt~.
6, P.nl.d. AlihoU9h Hloha.l .nyd.r WA' op.r.tlnt hi.
t.th.r'. oar with hi. ,.th.r'. p.r.l..10n, h. w.. doln9 .0 on hi.
own p.r.on.l bu.ln.... Th.r. wa. only on. oih.r p....nQ.r in Hr.
llnyd.f" oar.
7, It 1. ad.ltt.d that the d,I.ndant.' o.r .truok the baok
ot the pl.1ntl"II. oar at the tl.. and piac. alllQld. Th.
r'MAlnl", al1.,atlon. 01 p.r'Qr.ph 7 oon.tltut. oonolu.lon. ot
lAW to Which no r..pon.. I. r.quir.d.
.. 1\ 1. .d.ltt.d that the d.f.ndlnt.' olr .truok the back
01 the plllntl'f" OAr whloh WI' .toppld. All 1111,ltion. ot
nl,11,.no., oar.l...n... .nd/or r.okl...n... ar. d.ni.d,
9-14. p.tlnalnt. .r. without knowt.dq. or lntor.atlon
luttl01.nt to for. A bflt.f al to the truth of the ragtual
.11',ltlon. ..t forth In p.ra,raph. , throuQh 14 and theretore
th.V ar. dlnl~. Th. d.r.ndant. .plolfioally d.ny th.t th.y
clu..d or contrlbutfd t. any lo'url.' or 10.... olat.-4 by the
pl.lntUr.
COVlt"l
't. Ofr.naan', Mtph..l loyd." inqorpor.'.. by r.r.r.no.
ht. r..pon... ,. "f.Qr.~h. 1 thfOWih 14 .. tnouQh lit fortn It
III\4U"
U. ,.". "U."iIlhln. 'If "~"'1f1J'h 'It (Jon."'",. 001\41111.10n.
IJ' 'lfW whh!h ..,. 4.nl~"
.......01., lk'.MiJ"', HhIM.' ."'(4u, ..Ill tMt '1149"'''' bo
.""ff4 In ~.. '4V~f 4~ 'Ml P'.'"'''''' C~l.'"t ~ 4&..,..14
loIh~ ,"11,i41",
C9V~ ~J
17. D.t.ndant, Raymond snyd.r, lncorporat.. by ret.renoe
hl. re.pon... to paragraph. 1 through 16 a. though .et torth at
1enqth.
18, Th. alleqatlon. of paraqraph 18 oon.tltut. oonclu.ion.
of law whloh are d.nl.d. At no r.l.vant tlm. wa. Hlcha.l Snyd.r
acttng a. an ag.nt or .ervant of Raymond Snyd.r. To the
contrary, at all r.l.vant tlm.., Htoha.l Snyder wa. aattng on hl.
own bu.ln....
WHI..rOa., d.fendant, Raymond Inyd.r, a.k. that judgment be
ent.red ln ht. favor and that plalntltfll. Complatnt b. di..l..ed
wlth prejudlce.
... ~Ttll
19. Plaintlft'. olal.. are barred ln whole or ln part by
the provl.10n. of the p.nn.ylvanta Hotor V.hlcle 'lnanolal
Re.pon.lblllty Law.
20. plalntlft'. tnjurle. Ind/or 10...., If Iny, Wlr' oau.ed
by per.on. or evente out,tde at the oontrol at def.ndant..
21. 10.. or III at platnttff" olalm" tnoludinu ln
particular platntltf', olal.. tor ..dloal ..p.n..., hIve be.n
paid and th.retore are not rlcoverable pur.uant to 70 P.'.A.
11712.
aa. At the tl.. ot the Icoident Illeqed ln plAintiff"
co.plalnt, Mich'.l Inyder w.. IQtlft9 on ~l. own behal' and wa.
not lotlft9 al an Iqlnt or ..rvent ot hi. tather, Maywood .nyd.r.
WHIRlrORI, defendant., Raymond Snyder and Michael snyder,
a.k that judgment be entered in their favor and that plaintiff"
complaint be di,mi..ed with prejudice.
McKIIJSOCK , 1I0r'""N, P.C.
to t'l ..
,#
.
Y.IIIJCA'l'IQW
Ray.ond Inyd.r h.r.by .tat.. that h. 1. the d.f.ndant ln thl.
aotlon and v.rlU.. that the .hh..ntl .ad. in the foreqolnq
ANSWER AND NEW MATTER are true and Clorr.Clt to the b..t ot hi.
knowl.dq., lntor..Uon and b.U.t. Th. und.nlqn.d und.retand.
that the .tat...nt. th.r.ln ar' ..d. .Ubj.Clt to p.naltl.. ot 18 Pa.
C.I. I.otlon 4'04 to un.worn tal.ltlCl.tlon to authorltl...
H.B 2 1 'Atf3
p.'~I'IC'1~ Qr .aaJlg.
John J. McOrath I.quir., attorn.y for o.rendant, h.r.by
cartit!.. that a true and corr.at copy or the for~oint AH.WIM
AND NEW MATTER ha. bl.n ..rved upon the followint bV Unitt4
Stat.. Ha!l, po.taq. pr.-paid, on thi. 'n~ day or Maroh, 1"1'
Tho... J. Ruqqi.rl, I.quir.
rarav. and Moarid.
IJI luburban Itltion lul141nt
1111 J,r,K. loul.vard
,hilad.lphll, PA 1910)
MoK~'1OCJ( , HOrnwt. '.0.
,". ",{ ~};/~h/I(.
it
""""
-
fJ
iI
tA
.'ARAGt: ANI> Mc:IUUI)R
T/lOHAS J. RUaalERI, ESQUIRE
I,D. HO. 61986
1/,/6 Suburban StllJ/onllulldln,
1611 J(/hn F. KtnMy IIf/1uword
I'hlladtlphlo, 1',4 1lII0J
am 36J.J91J
'rUOY I. Llln,
'hi"Uft
con'l' 0' COIOIOII .LUI
0' OUKIULUD COUltY
D"'''''uh
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
I
,
,
MO. .1-117 CIVIL
v.
RAYMOND IYlDII .""
HIOIAIL .WYDII,
'LAlIn'Ur" ....011.. '1'0 .... MAnu or
PI"WDAI1' ~flO'D "D .IO__.~ "lP"
Pl.tnttff, Tr.cy Lawi., by .nd throuqh h.r un.iqn.d coun..l,
Far.q. .nd Hcarid., r..pond. to H.w H.tt.r of d.f.nd.nt., Rlyaond
.nd Hioh..l .nyd.r, .. follow.,
I'. D.ni.d. Th. .11.q.tion. oont.tn.d in p.r.qr.ph l' Ir.
d.ni.d for the r...on th.t .... cont.in. oonolu.ion. of l.w to
whtch no r..pon.tv. pl..ding i. r.quir.d. To the .xt.nt th.t the
.ll'\J.tlon. tn par'\Jraph 11 are oon.ld.r'd tactual, ..id
all.q.tlon. .r. v.qu. .nd un.p.clfic .nd th.r.for. an.w.rtnq
plaintiff i. unable to r..pond.
20, D.ni.d. Plaintiff .p.oifically d.ni.. the av.r..nt. of
par.qr.ph 20 of d.f.nd.nt.' N.w M.tt.r. On the oontrary, all or
the injuri.. .uthr.d by plalntHt Wlr. the .01. u.ult ot the
n.~lt\J.nc. of tha d.fand.nt..
21, O.nll4. Tb. Illli.tlon. oont,lnl4 ln p'rlqr.ph 31 Ira
<1.nll4 for U~a raa.on that .... contain. cOMlu.ion. or II'" to
which no r..pon.tv. pl..din9 i. r.quir.d. To the .xt.nt th.t In
an.w.r i. r.quir.d, pl.intirr .p.oirl0111V d.ni.. th.t .xp.n... .r.
not r.cov.r.bl. und.r 75 P.I.A. 11722 .nd 1..V" d.r.nd.nt.' to
th.ir proor. on thi. i..u..
22. D.ni.d. Th. .11'9.tion. contained in par'9r.ph 22 .r.
d.ni.d tor the r'l.on that .... oontain. oonolu.ion. or law to
Which no r..pon.lv. pl..din9 i. r.quir.d,
.....roa., plaintirt, TraoV I. Llwi., a.k that jUdqa.nt b.
.nt.r.d in h.r tavor and aqain.t d.f.ndant..
rAAAal AND NCIIID.
av.
. ,
Attorn.y for Pl.intiff
VHR1F"'A TION
tlOMAI J. aVOII..I, "QUla., h.r.by v.ritte. that h. 1. the
.ttorn.y tor plllntttt ln thi. lotlon, .nd thlt the tlat. .et forth
1n the tor'901nq plllntlff" r..pon.. to d.r.ndlnte', "IV KAtt.r
are true .M oorr~t to the H.t or hle knovIHq', lntor..Uon.nd
b.U.t.
Thll .tat...nt t. .ad. .ub,.ot to thl ~n.1U.. ot 11 ....
C.'.A. '.'04, r.l.t,", to uneworn ',l'l'lo.,ton to .uthorl\i..,
DAUDI 'I1,l1lt
CSRTIF/CATB OF SHRV/CS
I her.by OtrtUv that on thi.\tlay ot Maroh, UID, . tru.
and oorr.ot oOPV ot thl tor,woinw Plaintlft'. R..pon.. to
d.tendant., Nlw Matter h.. b..n ..11.4 via tlr.t ala.. U.I. Hall
.ddr....d a. tOllow.,
John J. HcOrath, !.quir.
...1111001 . lorrlWf, '.0.
1100 Hark,t .tr.,t, .ulte 3000
Philadelphia, PA 1'10'
d~ ,,'
~~
It
-
"'"'
w
tw
II
~