HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-00248
'j\..
, 1
,
.
I
1
i
,
,
j
I
,
CAROL A. LLEWELLYN, I IN THB COURT or COMMON PLE^8 or
Plalntirr I CUHPERLAND COUNTY, PENN8YLVANI^
I
V. I CIVIL ^CTION - LAW
CONSTANCB VALENTINE, I
t/d/b/a THB HAIR TICIINICIANS, I
Darendant I NO. VD-248 CIVIL TERM
ORDla 0' cotJtt~
AND NOW, thl. ~ day or Ootober, lVV', upon ravlew or
the attaohed Motlon to Vaoata riled by Steven J. rlah.an,
I.qulre, the oourt-appointment. or ataven J. ,i.hman, I.qulr.,
Jaokie J. DeArmond, laqulre and Johnna J. Dally, I.qulre are
hereby vaoated.
IY THE COURT,
I.'" ":1:Jt,~lJ.. l,.....5L "'J
J.
" "',' ; ~1"(1~t)
~' cu-'
I .~
174",. (](t, 17 ?,f
...Ill",','" ' ,,~~...o_""
"-f$ b""'",,~t'llt
!f'!l""
CAROL A. LLEWELLYN, I IN TilE COURT OF COMMON rUM OF
Plaintltt I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLV^NIA
I
V. I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
CONSTANCE V^LENTINE, I
t/d/b/a TilE IlAIR TECHNICIANS, I
D.f.ndant I NO. 9'-248 CIVIL TERM
HO~ION ~O VACA~I
1) Movant 11 st.v.n J. ,1lhman, Elqulr., court-appointed
Chalrman ot the Board ot ^rbitrltorl in the abov.-caption.d
aotion.
2) Movant Ich.dul.d an arbitratlon h.arlnq ln thl1 matter
tor Ootob.r 3, 199'. Upon r.qu'lt or counl.l tor both partie.,
the h.arlnq wal continued p.ndlnq .ttortl towardl a I.ttl...nt.
3) Movant r.c.iv'd writt.n contlrmatlon or a I.ttl.m.nt on
Ootober 4, 19". ^ copy ot .... i. attach.d h.r.to, ..rk.d a.
Exhibit "A" and incorpor.t.d h.r.in by r.t.r.nc..
WHEREFORE, Movant, It.v.n J. 'iah..an, Elquir., h.reby
requ..t. that Your Ifonorabh Court vacat. the appoint..ntl ot
It.v.n J. ,ilh.an, I.quir., Jacki. J. D.^rmond, E.quir. and
Johnna J. D.l1y, I.quir. a. arbitrator. in thi. ..tt.r.
R..p.ottully .Ubllltt.d,
O'BRIEN, BARIC' .CIIICRIR
tr""""" ..,...
IYI
~...
.t.v.n J. r .hm.n, E.qu r.
17 w..t 'outh .tr..t
clrli.l., PA 17013
'717) 249-6173
-
EXHIBIT "A"
MAltSHALL & FAnnElL
. ,.01_....., .""......
A"OlNan -'l LAW
IJU NOIlH 'IONT "un
1I.4"'..IIIQ. ""'Nn~\'-'MA ,"ff
. ~
'llANell UI'uIIIAlL.II.
MI<:IIAIL A, '''''IlL
10urH ", IICC'
nuy VOlIlMnll
ClfAlLIS I, IlADDIC~, II,
.
LOll "PAMCIK KAlIn
KINNfTIf J, 'UCla
KIVIN C. COTTON"
TlUfIfONIln'll II..,...
'U I"" U...",
~I,"","'~ """'''
4f1Ml....' lHIM1 t\.K
MII1l..
....IM...., Iftlff
""", 11I10.. 1"'1
~.1I1!l..._
144 11'III..._
Oelobtr.. 1"1
......".,""..,...,...
.. '41\''''K4__
Steven J. PIJhman. Etqull.
O'DIUEN, DAlUC" SCHWR
11 Welt South Str.et
Carlisi., M 11013
RE:
Cwn~fland Couney NOI 9'-2<41 ClvU Tn
Our FU. NOI C<6.9
Deu Mr. PlshmlU11
The abov.-r.ferenc.d cu. hu tmltd. Thlrtfort, W,... no Ioftt". Mt4 tot 1ft
arbltraUon hoartn.. Pl.... rlCllllhac I hwtn. In lNt NMf had """ tcNdultd tot
October 3, 1995, but Wit eondnUt4 It W ftq\ll" of W pIIUtI to U\lIIftIon. W. had
not yet rttdltduJ.d the Mann, prior 10 mdtmtnt
ThanJc you for your eooptnUon In thlI !MUff.
Vff"/ Ny )'OlIn.
\1t ~ t. (Jicla lJ1C:~(ll~~O
Lift AdamdJI kIrttt
eel Thonw I(UCI.llquit.
HlLO CORPORATION, . Now York
CorporAtion,
I IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLE^S Of'
I FRANKLIN COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I DID-19U-..,
I
I
I
PlAintiff
V.
DAVID 8. HECKMAN and
MRY ANN HECI<HAN,
aehndant.
"l~QA~IT Q' MAILING
I, O.vid A. 'arlg, I.quir., do affirm that, thl. 3rd dlY of
Auvu.t, 1"', I did pllc. In thl U... H.tl, po.taV' pr.pald, the
Att.chld corel,pondlncl .nd anolo.ur.. .ddr....d to OAVID D. HICKMAN
and HARV ANN HECKMAN to thatr 1..' known Iddr,."
14)) Hlmory Lanl
Chamb.r.burq, r,nn.Vlv.nll 17301
Thl. .tat...nt 1. ..d. 'UbJ.ot to th. p.naltl.. ot 11 'a. C... I
4,Q4 r.latlv. to un.worn fal.1rleltlon to authorltl...
by.
.~;~ ~.~....
David A. '.rlo, l.quIr.
1.0. . UIU
Attorn.y lor Plltntl',
17 w..t 'auth Itrea'
C.rll'le. 'Inn'VIvanIa 1101'
I
!
i
,
i
I
"
_ic':,;,\'-I~
.
,
.t
Lt
, t
HILO CORPORATIOll, a New York
Corporation,
I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
I FRANKLIN COUNTY, PENNSYLV^NI^
I
I CIVIL ^CTION - LAW
I
I 080-1995-689
I
I
I
Pla1ntitt
v.
DAVID O. HECKMAN Ind
~RY !.NN HECKMAN,
Oetendant.
ArrlPAVIT or HAILING
I, Dlvid ^. Uaric, E'quire, do attirm that, thl. 3rd day ot
^U9U.t, 1990, I dld pllc, in the u.s. Hill, PO.tI9' pr.pald, the
attach.d corr..pondene. Ind enclo.ur.. addr....d to O^VIO B. HECKMAN
and ~RY !.NN HECKMAN to th.ir l..t known addr""
1.33 H.mory Lan.
Chamber.burg, Penn.ylvlnl. 17201
Thl. .tlt.ment 1. mid. .ubject to the p.nlltie. or 18 Pa. C.S. I
4904 r.l.tlv. to un.worn tl\l.lticltion to luthorlti...
bYI
~:;;:Z'~"'.'.
Oavld A. Uarlc, I.qulre
1.0. . UIll3
Attorn.y tor Plllntiff
17 We.t South Str..t
carll.l., Pann.ylvlnla 17013
~Z::.&1
~ :~.~.~~~
~
f
~
r-
. .
. ,
..
LflW Off'flt
O"'UIN, IIMUC.. SCIIUIIC
1111',., .rUll'~ $/lf"
C~ffill~, 1',/llIHlfillllll 11(Jf J
SI,I'," J, lillt"'fl/l
01 C",,"1I1
Xubf" /,., O'II",n
"tIff" ,~, Dime
,Ifl,'htltf ,j, S,It,f"
(111) :4P.U1J
,,~,'( an) uP.""
Au<,JI.IU ~, itll
Oavid D. >>Iok.an Ind
Mary Ann >>tokMan
143) MI.ory Lin.
Ch.mblr.bur" ,.nn.ylvAnia 11201
.11 Ml10 v. "'Q~.n
eo.plain' ln eonf...lon
0' Ju49.lnt
O..r Hr. a"~ H", "Iok.anl
lnolo..~ pl.... tlnd . 01,'1'1.4 .ru. and oor,..\ oopy
of a Complaln, 1n Conf...lon 0' JU4,..nl And A Con,...lon we
JUdW.lnc '11'd .,.1n.' you. Th. '1" of .n'ry ~.. '\U9U.' 1, I'"
1n \hl Court 0' Co._on Pl.l. 0' ',anklln Couney, 01'-1"'-'" 1n
the ..oune of 11","1.00.
V.ry ,.uly your.,
O'lallH, IA.IC , .CHlalR
~c/ &: ~
OIvld A. '1'10, I.quir.
DAI/IU
I:no
QQI HU. Cff'"''''''
,u.
iI
:1 CAROL A.
,
LLEWELLYN,
Plaint1tt
. '.
IN THI COURT OF COMMON PLE^S or
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PINN8YLVANI^
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I
" I
'IV I
I CONSTANCE VALENTINE, I
'j t/d/b/a THI ItAIR TECIINICIANS, I
1 Detendant I
,
NO. 95-248 CIVIL TERM
iI
'I
"
NOTIOI 0' ARBITRATORB' KIARIHQ
AND NOW thil 29th day ot Slptember, 1995, you Ire
'!hereby notitied that the arbitration hearin9 loheduled tor
~ I
Tuelday, Ootober 3, 1995 il hereby oontinued. Notioe will be
',torwarded upon the r.lahedulin9 ot ...e.
i
O'BRIEN, B C' SCHERER
,.
"
BY
Iteven J. , .h.an, Ilqu re
I
i
'iOOI
:,
,I
Jaoki. J. D.Araond, I.quirl, Arbitrator
Johnna J. Deily, Ilquirl, Arbitrator
Tho.a. H. Kutl, Ilquire, Attorney tor Plaintitf
K.rry Vo.. '8ith, t.qulre, AttornlY tor Detandant
court Adainlltrator ~
lull.tin Doard, Prothonotary" Ottlcl
:,
;,
i
I
i
"
"
'I
'I I
I 'I. /,
1/' ! i I 4i /.I/'I "\
;/((
CAROL A. LLlWILLVN,
Plaint & tt
I IN THI COURT or COKMON PLlAI or
I CUMDCAtANO COUNTY, 'ENNIVLVAH1^
I
I OIVIL ACTION . LAW
I
I
I NO. t'-a4' CIVIL TERM
V.
CON'TANCI VALlNTINI,
t/d/b/a THI KAIR TECHNICIAN',
o.f.nalnt
_lal. gr ,...llllmy' "_1'.-1111
AND NOW thi. .th alY of '.pt.ab.r, l"t, yo~ af' h.,.by
notltl,d th.t the arbitr.tor. Ippointt4 in the aboy,-o.ptloned
aotlon will hold. h..,inq for the purpo.. of th.ir .ppoint..nt
.. followlI
Dahl TU..dIY, OQtO"' J, Uti
Tl... lUO p...
LooaUonl ',"114 floo, ....,,"" aou, Old CVUerlan4 eounty
Courthou.., e,rI111., 'A,
O'aR.,N, IARIO , 'eNIRIR
IV ~"J. ;m..", 'lIqUlr.
HI "..Ill. tI. OeArtttII4, &'fCUh., A,1I1U.t.,
JOhnnI .I, DIlly, I.~&,., Ar.lt",.,
~. Nt Kut., I.qulr., A".f~Y f.r '1.&ntl"
",ry VO" 'Il'h, '.,uir., A".f~Y '0' o.'.n4Int
Cour\ ~&n'.'r"@f
~ll.'l" lo.r4, ff@'~nv"ry" 0"1-.
CAROL A LLEWELL VN.
PI.lntiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
v,
,
: No 95.248 Civil T.rm
CONSTANce VALENTINE,
VdIbI. THE HAIR TECHNICIANS.
D.f.nd.nl
NOTIC!
You h.v. b..n lu.d In court, If you wllh 10 d.f.nd .galn.1 Ihe cl.lml 1.1
forth in the following pig.., you mUll Ilk. .ctlon within twenly (20) dlY' .n.r Ihll
compl.lnt .nd notice .r. ..rv.d, by .nl.rlng . wrlll.n .ppear.nce p.r.on.lIy or by
allorn.y .nd filing in writing with the court your d.f.n... or obj.ctlon. 10 Ih. clllml ..I
forth .g.lnll you You art w.rn.d th.1 if you f.il 10 do 10 th. ce.. may proceed
wllhout you .nd . judgm.nl m.y be .nt.red ag.lnll you by Ih. court wllhoul furth.r
notice for .ny mon.y cl.lmtd In Ih. compl.int or for .ny olh.r claim or rell.f requ..t.d
by th. pl.lnllff, You m.y 101. mon.y or property or other right. Import.nllo you,
YOU SHOULD TAK! THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYeR AT ONce. IF
YOU DO NOT HAve A LAWYeR OR CANNOT AFFORD ONe, 00 TO OR
TI!LePHONI THI OFFICI lIT FORTH BILOW TO FIND OUT WHERI YOU CAN
oeT LeOAL HILP.
Cour1 Admlnl.tr.lor
lith 'loot. Cumberland COYnly Courthoutt
Carll.I., '.M'rlvenl. 171113
T,'.p/'lont (717) 24o.e200
CAROL A. LLEWELL VN,
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
Plaintiff
v,
,
: No, 95.246 Civil Term
CONSTANCE VALENTINE,
IId/b/a THE HAIR TECHNICIANS,
Defendant
COMPLAINT
1, Plaintiff, CAROL A, LLEWELL VN, I. an adulllndlvldual with a re.ldence at 1526
LOp8X Road, Apartmenl No. P.20, Harrl.burg, Penn.ylvanla,
2. Oefendan\, CONSTANCE VALENTINE, I. an adull Indlvlduallradlng and doing
bu.ln... a. THE HAIR TECtmlCIANS, with 8 place of buelnell .14200 Trlndl. Road,
Camp Hill, Cumb.rland County, Penn.ylvanl.,
COUNT ONE
3. Paragraph. 1 and 2 ar. incorporal.d by rel.r.nce.
4. On or about May 31, 1994, Plalnlllf w.nt to Defendant'. place of bu.lne.. to Inquire
about. product that .top.the temporary 101' of hair due to chemical damage from hair
dye.
S Plaintiff met with Oefendanl and advi..d Oefend.ntthll .he, the Plalnllff. wa.
experiencing t.mporary h.lr lOll broughlabout by th. u.. of hllr color.
6, During the cour.. of the May 3111 moollntl PI.lnllft w.e advl..d by Oelendant Ih.t
PlalnUff .ufftred from "mal. pattern b.ldn..... and that PI.lnllff required a "hair
r.placementlnt.gration 'Yltem" conellUng of human hair fallened 10 a not which In
lurn would bo allachld to Plaintiff. own hair, Plainlift w.e a..ur.d by O.f.ndantthat
the delcrlbed ly,l,m would be Plalnllffl bllt hope and would work for h.r,
7. During Iho coor.. of Ihe May 31.t meel1ng Plalnllff wle al'o advleed of "hair proleln
Ir.,lmtntl" .vail,ble through O.I.ndant'. bUlin... and thaI 'uch Ir..tmont, would
bulld up the ttrongth of PI.inllft'e own hair
8 Pltlnbff. relying on o.t~. rtpttMntatlont. .nttttd Into a c:onttact with
Otfef\dMt tOl ~ "halt replac:emtnt lo\tOfltlQll ,y.1ttn" lInd the "hail pt'cMin
tr.~.",
o Plelnllff bell.v.. .nd Ih.r.for. .v.rl lhal lhe ..ecuted I Wflll.n conlrlcl with
Oefendenl for m.lerl.l, Ind ..Met I d..Cllbed lbOv. whieh conllin.d varloul
warranlin Plelnllff WII 001, howev.r. provided wtlh I QOpy of 1M ,amt by D.f.ndanl
who r.m.lnl In ,.cluliv. po.....ion of 'uch wrtll.n contract
10 Pllln\lff we, provid.d Wllh In invoiet dll.d Jun. " 100. fot \he "hllr r.plactmtnl
integration IYII.m", I copy of which il 1111ehed 10 Ihll Complllnl II Eahlbll "A", The
lOll' COlt of th. IYII.m, Including I.non thr.1d 111lehmtnl, WII " 030 00
", Th.r..ft." on diver.. oecallonl bttwa.n M.y 3111 Ind 8.ptambtrl7lh, ,"",
Plalnllff received !W.lv. ''hllr prol.ln Irtllmtnll" .1 Otlfendanfl plact of bullot..
12 PI.lnltff wel ch.rged 1101., of 1370 13 for \he ''hlir prol,ln Iltllmtnll" Ind
luppll.. for Ih. period bttw..n MIY 3' II Ind 8.pt.mbtf '7th. ,09<t
13 On or .boul 8.pl.mbtr 2", '"", Plllnllff wtnllo Det.ndanU pilei of bu.IOt..,
received Ihe "h.lr rtpllC41mtnllntegrlllon IYlltm" and had II IlIlChtd by o.ttndlnr.
employea, Nicole O..orid., TM IVlltm WII llIaehtd by "'Ing PI,ln"'''' ....lIng
hair 10 Ii. or Inchor II 10 her heed
14 On or aboul Octobtr IS, , 00., Plllntlff wtnl 10 Offtndtnf'1 place of bullMlllO
have Ih. "hili 'Vlttm" chtckld and WII Idvlled by Otlftndlnl \hallt w.. IIt<<hed 100
10010 Oatendlnl r.flllld lhe IVlttm by r"vtng '110 Pt,1ll\1tf'1 hHd With Plllntltrl hilt
15 On or .bout Oclobtt 22, ,00<4, PI.",lIff wtnt 10 Otftndant'. pllCf of butintll fOf
Ihe monlhly IT.llntlnanct of lhe IYlt.m TM IYII"" w.. rtmOVed from PlllnW" hftKt
whereupon PI,lnllff dllcovered \hit "., 'lllltng hili on 1ht lop Jnd ,Ide, of htt hfId
had bltn bfok.n Of pulled out by lhf IYllIm, ,.poIIl'lO htt Kalp and etul"'O I'Itf
emb.rre..menl Ind humtlilllon
16 Plalnllff WI' not warned by Otlftndlnl Of"" tmf,joyH \hi' the "hili r'pt~
Inleoretlon IVII.m" WOlJld c.u..1htI prtJVlOI.Illy dtt((1btd dItflIQI to htt own hilt
16 A' I rflull of 1M hili dImIgt tuHtltd by PllI/lIllf the WII rtqYlfed to purcNM .
full wig ., I lolel COil 10 her of 1239 70
17 Tht llIllmenll by Offend",. atKflbtd '" PIIIQf"" MQ 1 01 &till ~
conllltulo tlp'e.. W"'''''''' oIlhf tffKtlVtllftl of Ihf "hilt r~ ~1OOn
IvtlOm" and "hllf prOUtln lfellJNnl," AtJc1IlltiNI W'HIf"J" ffllY ,.,M 11.H4lJJiOf' IN
bClhlvtd wflll4Hl coNfl(t rtf.,tfl<</fJ In ~1Qf'"
, It PIIW1l.!ff" ~ 10 r'KIM IN <<ItlfI,..;' Wltn f)t#~ "." IN "MIf '1I(.iI~
1O~.ll()fI tyttfm" 1M .... "h.w pt~ II~' (jj1 N .,_ {1Il/f.w. 0<< W"'~
and fr t\.id
WHEREFORE, Plalnllff d.mand. jUdgm.nt agaln'l O.(.ndanl (or $1.648.89 plus
Inler..t and co.t., Said $1,648.89 b.lng Ih. tolal co'l to Plalnllff of tha "hair
replacement Integration ,ysI.m", Ihe "hair proleln Irealm.nt." and the wig purchased
a. a n..ult of the d.mage cau.ed by Defendant'. .y.t.m .nd Ireatm.nt..
COUNT TWO
19. Paragraph. on. through elght..n are Incorporated by ref.rence.
20. Oefend.nl knowingly ml.repre.enled the need and effectlven... of Ihe "h.lr
prol.ln tr..tm.nt...,
21, Defendant mlsrepr8lenl.d Ih. need for the "hair r.placement Inlegratlon .yst.m"
and f.lI.d 10 dl.close Ihe pOI.ntlal for damage 10 PI.lntlffs hair c.us.d by th. system.
22. O.f.ndanl'. cour.. of conduct which Induced Plaintiff to purchaltlh. "hair prot.ln
Ireatm.nt... and "h.lr replacement Integr.tion .y.t.m" was done Intentionally and with
the knowl.dg. of Ih.lr lack of effecllvene.. and polenllal for damag..
WHEREFORE, Plalnllff demands judgmenl not 10 exceed Jurisdictional emounl for
arbltrallon in Cumberland County, P.nn.ylvanl.. agaln.t Oefendan\, .ald judgment to
Includ. a comp.n.atory d.m.g.. .ward of $1,648.89 and punltiv. damag.. logelMr
with Inter..1 and co.t..
COUNT THREE
23 Paragraph. one Ihrough twenty two .re Incorpor.ted by r.feronce.
24 The mltr.pr...nl.tion., omllllon. and conce.lm.nl of facl. by Oefendanl
constituted unfair methods of competillon and unf.lr or deceptive act. or practices
Within tho moaning of the ponn.ylv.nl. Unf.lr Trade Praellce. and Con.um.r
Protection Law
2~ PI.lnllff .uff"ed .n llcert.lnable 10.. as Iho r..ull of Oefondanl's UIO or
employment 01 th..e unlalr method. 01 competition .nd unfair or deceptlvo .cts or
pracllce.
WHEREFORE, Pl,lnllff demands judgment not 10 olCce.d 1M jurl.dletion.1 Umlt for
Olblltltlon In Cumb'tlend Counly, Ptnn.ylvanJ., against Oofendlflt, sald j4ldgmenllo
Include an 1IW00d In OflllJlOUl'lt of Uv.. t""" tht acw.1 dltmeot. 'u'l.j~ and
allOf~y" f... pursuant to tht PtMlylvanla UnflJl T,q P,actiCt. end COOJUm<<
Ptoltction llw
'~
,.1
,
,-
f
"~
.
)
..
"
/
.'
"
. 'I' ,
,.
.
GuenUty
)
, '=~-=--/7i:J.--:J~'._--=~~';AX.-
__,~____ ... ... ._:..---..L
o.ectlptlon
i..'vvLl~'t, 7J..~11 ~...
f'1Ioe
,
_.....--.--.-~~
'.' ,
,
,
-
.
-. ......_*---~."--~._-'-~-
'!.._'L ...k'
O/J, (Jv
a V ()u
,
I
!
1
1
f
~
~
i
j
i
f
_._..........~ -"
.
.
~. ._--,~~."_...~--,....-_-,,.._.,.
,
,
-
"f A 1.I>'Vz,I,1f ': 'Do:'
__" .<<-,__._______.1~_.~___,,_., --~ '-~
",U. .0
';:'
....-1AiDJ/4/Ji- --
N1"",- _ """" ... ....... ... .. .... """"........, ....... _,.. r .1 10
_to. ~'II"_" ... ""," nrMNKlI,N_ "," ,~~.....Id ,....._ AI'. "'~...,............
_.... _...._ "".. III *' IIor4. ....."" 1'."..._..... CflW/T .IJlU.A\I(1I' Bl1kA1t11
_lI(WftU IOVO''''_'''''5ai. "'" _Ill........ ......-''''IIt... ,..,....." 'tOIlN'
(~fl .. .. ". I."'v......., uf "...,. III tWtNIUh tf,I it.. ~,t1...~ AAtw.. U,... .,..
....I... ."',,",..................,.... ,.......... ~"HI"''''r''''l/O .., WI.AN
""'" M) IIlt~* .. ..- ;,./ /
lIU't" ( ~ '-:(~ ~[':'~':J/~.,,- (l.llt 6 ~ /' ! y.
",""~'-(Jf...t --(lI.lIl_"..
e"JTO~
~1.1b1'r
81'i01.J<aMJ6,
~
.
,'\ ... I
CAROL A, LLEWILLYN,
,.,inUII ,
f IN 'l'H1 COU~T or COMMON 'LXAI
I or CUMICMLAHD COUNTY 'INHIVLVAHI^
I
I
I HO. at. C1Yil I'"
I
I
I
I
I CIVIL ACTION . LAW
VII.
CONNIC VALENTINI,
tldlbl, THI HAIR TECHNICIANI ,
D.tend,n'.
6lfllflltT.Q 'f'~'W.rr
AND NOW, 00." Det.nd,nt, Connle Val,ntlne, by .nd throU9h h.r
attorney, Rob.rt L. lu.,.ndore, I.qulr., .nd ln .vp,." of h.r An.w.,
to COllpl,lnt ,y.r. ,. tollow"
1. AdIIU.<t.d.
a. AdlllUlId.
~_J.
,. ,u'9r.pl\. on. Inca two art lntotpO,.," by '."ffM' "
tl\ou9" tully ..t torth h.r.ln.
4, Ad.ltt.d.
.. Dlnl.d. It i. ,,.0111,.11Y dlnl" ,ha, 4f,.AClnl l"for-.4
pl.lntlf' th't .h. '.p"l.no.d h'lr 10" \. ..lorlnt. To 'hi
contrary, ,111ntltr ,...In.d ,w.r. of 'n. 'Iv.. o. h., n.lr 10...
It riot proof tl\.r.ot 1. 4...nd.d.
.. AGllttlld In Plf', d.nltd In ,,'t, It i. .,..&'10111y d.nl.a
th't O.t.nd'nt a..vr.d pl.1n\lff \h.\ 'h. 'Y"" ~1. .. hlr be,t
hop..Th. rlatind., of th. p.r.qr.ph &. ~&,\t4, '\'la\ 'fool
th.r.ol 1. d...nd44.
" ~lUlld,
I. Admittld ln plrt, dlni.d in plrt. It i. Idmitt.d thlt I
contract WI' .nt.r.d into bV d.f.ndlnt And plAintiff but it i.
.p.olflc.1lV d.ni.d thlt contrAct lnclud.d ..rvle.. oth.r thIn thl
ord.rlno and m.lnt.nlnel of the hllr unit, Strict proof thlrlof Ie
dlmlndld.
g. Admlttld in plrt, d.ni.d in p.rt. It i. .p.olflc.llV d.nled
thlt pllintiff .nt.r.d into I contract for ..rvle... To the
contrarv, ..rvlc.. for the hltr unit incurr.d In Iddltionll co.t.
Tho r.malnd.r 01 tho p.r.gr.ph t. admitt.d.
10. Mmitt.d.
11. Admitt.d.
12. D.ni.d. It 1. .p.elfie.lly d.ni.d that Del.ndant oharg.d
')70.13 for thl prot.in tr.lt.-nt. frolll HIY '1 to '.pt'MOIt 17,
19,.. To the contr.rv, o,'.ndant', invoio. lor ..rvle.. rend.r.d
totlll.d '111.73 during thi. p.riod 01 tilll..
13. Adllitttd.
1.. AdlIitt.d in plrt, deni.d in plrt. It 1. aa.ttt.d thlt
plalntitf vi.itod d.t.nd.nt on "ptoMbor 24, 1"4. It t.
.poeiftcllly d.ni.d thlt thl .y.t'llI WI' Ittlchld too 100", To thl
contr.ry, d,'endlnt Idvi.od plllntifl thlt thl hlir unit will
qrldullly 00.. 100.0 IItlr thl lir.t tlml it I. Attlched, Itrlot
proof thlroo' 1. d..lnd.d.
15, AdMltt.d 1n plrt, d.nl.d In part. It 1. adalttld thlt
pl11ntl1' Vl.ltod dolOnd,nt on Ootoblr 22, 1"4. It 1. 'Plcl11ollly
dlnl.o that thl hllr unit CIUlla a,..o. to plllntlff'. hltr. To the
corltrny, plltntllf'. hid bl.n cut 104 thl. I~COUAt.o tor UII
.P(i......w. of UIO ~lf, 'U14\!t Proof thU*'Ot t. dMAIIn4N.
la. Denied. It i. .pecificllly denied thlt the hair unit
cau.ed dlmage to plaintiff'. hlir and therefore, no wlrning WI'
required. To the contrary, defendant Idyi.ed pleintiff thAt the hair
required cutting.
la. (P1Aintiff'l complAint li.t. two con.ecutive pAragraph.
de. ignited 16). ^fter rea.onable inve.tigltion, defendant i. without
lutficient knowledge of informltion to torm a belief AI to the truth
of the Averment,
17. Denied. PArlgraph leventeen i. I llgll conclu.ion to which
no re.pon.iv. pl.Ading J. r.quir.d. To the .xtent Any tAct. are
Averred, they Ire .pecificIlly denied and proof thereot i. demanded.
18. Denied. 'Irlgraph eighteen ie I legll conclu.ion to which
no r..pon.ive pleading i. r.quired. To the extent any fact. are
averred, they Ire .pecificIlly denied and proof thereot i. demanded.
WHEREFORE, Def.ndant pray' that judgment be entered in her fayor
Ind again.t Plaintiff.
~OU6I 11
19. 'aragraph. one through eighte.n ar. incorporat.d by
reference a, though fully ,et forth herein.
30. OenJed. It i' .pecifically denled thlt detendant
mi,repr..ented the .ff'ctiv.n.,. of the prot.ln hlir tr.at..nt.. To
the c~ntrary, defendant advl..d plaintiff that protein tr.at..ntl may
.trength.n h.r remaining hair but could not correct hair lOll,
Itrict prOOf thereof il de..ndad.
31. Danied. It il Ipacifically dani,d that defendant
.iaraprl.lnted tha hair rlplaca..nt .y.ta.. To tha contrary,
detendlnt adYI.,d plaintiff that the hair ay.ta. coyer. hair loa..
.
Moreover, it il denied that the Iyltem cauled damage to plaintiff'l
hair. Strict proof thereot il demanded.
22. Denied. Paragraph twenty-two i. . leoal conclulion to
which no re.pon.ive pleading ie required. To the extent any tact.
are averred, they are Ipecifically denied becaule defendant properly
I\dvi.ed plaintift ot the hair replacem.nt .y.tem.
WI/EREfORE, Oetendant prayl that judoment be entered in her tavor
and again.t Plaintitt.
~9UNT III
23. Paragraph. one through twenty-two are incorporated by
reterence al though tully let forth herein.
24. Denied. Paragraph twenty-tour il a leoal conclulion to
which no relpon.ive pleading i. required. To the extent any tactl
are Iverred, they are Ipecitically denied and proot thereat il
demanded.
2'. Denied. It i. Ipecitically denied that plaintitt luttered
1\ 10'. trom the hair replacement ay.tem or that dfttendant u.ed untair
method. ot competition. To the contrary, detendant Ippropriltely
advi.ed pllintitt ot the hlir replacement .y.tem.
WHEREFORE, Detendlnt prayl that judgment be ent.r.d ln her tlvor
and Iglin.t Pllintltt.
,aUNT IV
21. '.rlorlph. one through twenty-tlve .re incorporated by
reterence .. though tullV .et torth hereln.
27. Adaitted.
21. Denied. It i. epeclfic.lly denied thlt the hlir ey.te. wa.
ln I def.ctlve conditlon. To the contr.ry, defendant ordered the
hllr r.plIQ...n~ 'V.t.. In 10oordlnOl with th. ,plolflal,ion. 0'
pllln~l", "rlo\ prool th.rlof I. d...nded.
at. o.nled. I' 1. .,.olflOllly dlnled thl' the hllr protlln
tr..t..nt WI' lnl'f.otlV.. To th. contrAry, plAlntlf' oOMMent.d
Ibout thl h'll'h 0' h.r hllr I',.r rlg.lvln, the 'r'I'..nt. 'trtet
proof th.r.ot I. d...nd.d,
30. o.nt.a. It 1. .p.oiflellly dlnl.d thlt the hllr prot.I"
tr..t..nt or the repl.o...nt .y.t.. eAul.d dl"" to plllntll'. To
the oontrlrv, d.flRdlnt prop.rly IdVl..d plllntll' 01 the IYlt.. Ind
tr.lt..nt. 't'lot proo, th.r.ol tl d...nd.d.
31. O.nled. 'trl,rlph thirty-on. II . 1"11 uonolu.lon to
whloh no r..ponllvl pl..dln, I. ,.qulred. To the ..t.nt tnv '.otl
arl AVI,rld, tn.y Irl 'plolflullly d.nled Ind proof th.,.of 1.
dl..ndlca ,
wHIMlrOMI, OIf.ndlnt ,flV' tn., Ju4t..nt De .ntlred In h.r 'Ivor
And IVIln.t ,lllntl'"
...,.'tfuIIV .v'-I'ttd,
). ,/,c,
n' . tll.t r.o. it' "
lOll "10M '. OIUlJ)O! '
AU.fMV I.P. IfO. . In
4.07 Mor'h 'ron' 't,..,
'.0. "'" IUO
?ttJt'IlI!6,t;nn'V1Vlna.
Attorney fOf a.ftn4fn'
uno
Ii
i
"
;
"
!I
J
11
"
ii
"
Ii
"
H
,
ii
1
I
!
,
V<<RJr~~~Tlotf
jJ
'I
i!
,
ij
,[
I verLtv thlt the .tlt.m.nt. mlde In the toreQolnq An.wer to
Complllnt Ire true and corr.ct. I under.t.nd thlt tll.. .tlt.m.nt.
h.r.ln Ir. mlda .ubjact to the panaltle. of 18 PI.e... '.otion .'04,
rllatln9 to un.worn fll.1flcltlon to authorltla..
Ii
i
/i
/ .' ,
("''t't\'1' ~,C;~'"
connl' v.ltK~ln...tllft~Itr
lA
~.
'"
...
~.
r"')
l1
'"
~';h
.
L
ft:.
'II""
:J
.
.
(~l 1\ 1t)"I','
MIl"'..~.... V.'I ( IIIif \.,..,
.\n.-,,-..,,', ...." ('t-' ...,..,,'.... H , ...~
t'() f\t" Id' "'.tiH'" ... 1"~~~lH\""I' r I'"
/\.,
1-1! 'j- ,f i) ! I: I
.~ 1 ' If': 1 i
CAROL A. LLEWELLYN,
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
v,
: No, 95.248 Civil Term
CONSTANCE VALENTINE,
Vdlbla THE HAIR TECHNICIANS,
Def.ndanl
I, Thoma. M Kutz, E.qulre, do her.by certify Ihat I trua .nd corrtct copy
of PI.lnllff.' Complalnl enl.r.d 10 Ih. above caplloned malt.r w.. "nl on F.bruary 8.
1995. 10 Ihe D.fendant via rlr.l-cla.. United SI.III m.lt.ddr....d.. follows:
By Fir.t Cia.. M.il
Con.lance V.lenline
clo The Hair Technlci.n.
04200 TrlOOle Ro.d
Camp Hili, PA 17011
--- ' .'
.~~~- .); ./ /
. ---- ,z:''/.... ;' ../"
,// .' \-J.."
/.. ~' '-.
. (,.",,~ .f - ~#~...
--
Thom., M, Kutl. e.qulr.....
Attorney for Plalnllf, ;
8u~.me CourtlD, NO. 38887
21G~111'1
Mechanlc'burg, PA 17055
(717) 795,9277
date F.bNtIy I, '*
CAROL A. LLEWeLLYN,
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
PI"nti"
v,
,
: No. 95.248 Civil T.rm
CONSTANce VALENTINE.
VdIbI. THe HAIR TECHNICIANS,
O.f.nd.nt
I, Thom.. M Kutz. Elqulr., do h.r.by oertity th.l. true and correct copy
of PI,'nUtf,' P.tlllon for Appolnlm.nl 0' Arbilr.lor. .nlered to the abov. capUoned
mllter w.. Itnt on Jun. 22. 1995, 10 Ih. Coun..1 ror o.r.nd.nt vi. fir,tod... United
SI.t.. malllddr..1td II follow..
By Firat CI... Mill;
ROBINSON AND GERALDO
P.O, Box 0320
H'ffl'burg. PA 17110-0320
Atilt Robtrt L, Bvzzlndor'. Eequlr.
._-~. ,. -/.. ,/. .
<. ,....,. y" ./
<r:. . ...., . . . :'" ",....;
f'~.",~t.~ f ," - _ cl'
Thomil M I<W. eequlr......
AlIOltltX ror PI.lnutt ) v
Suprtmt-clKJrtiEHfO. 38887
210 1.11 ~In 8lrMt
Mtchanlclburg, PA 17060
(7m 7tM277
-., ~22.1.
(OMMONW'Al'H ()' tIHH.YlVAHIA
(OUII Of (OMIolON .11"
t'lllh)MTlillld l'(lllllt y
NO'('.IO'''11C1
'It Ii !lInt ,let
NOllCl 0' A""AL
,
,.
'lI{lM
DllfalCT JU'''CI JUDOMIN(
(DMMON.,..'... qll'1~f J 1 G......v 71:/1'1
.
NOTlCI 0' APPIAL U \
Noh.. .. \1'-' ,..., ,10. tlJ....II.,,~ .... ''''''' .. ,he ....... '-", 01 COl......I'lea' ,.. .......'" I"".. II. fI'dw.... ,...." "" .... tiotl'_, ""'.. "'. n.
d.... ..od .. ,.. (C... ......'....... b4oIow,
'~~::~, ~~1:.: 1..0 11 y~'''"'-'' .'", .., ,-,." Iffr J~~ :;tl:::~;l: '~"~rry>r IWI4
'.L', Iq"X It,t, Nit '1'~20 1~1trlliburq I'A 11111
n..,,(tlUi(..w'ff llfn((llf{if:~,iI---~ - - "'''''1
11/"/'14 . t~u(ll. ^,.' 1.1""". 'lIyn. rt v,,\":I':ll'l'., I IlItir'l\"\.'1l1llf'liln..
1\...,<1',' "" ..'''' tli/llltoIIJll<<iIlofllAHlN~~1IIHt '-~-'=" 0 . .",
C,,:t...._l!~0045(),.1J1__.._.. ~y 'iiiq'
.. .. u.~!c::..:',,:.='.""';=.,;.,:..:., . ,,'..-.. _.__., .. ,. / .;,... \ ... > .. ,
1I.1lM>t~ "II bo ty...J ONlV """" t/tj, """',.... II ..'l\Iil.d .... ,.. I fiJI, NIA 1/ ~l/ _ CL AlMAN' III.. r", It(: I' J I' N..
loon
lhit Nu'u 01 A~. when ~..d by the Oit~i<' ....,"'.. ..II _.... ," a 1001(61" (ICIi<<I tlMf_' Ort/l", Ji.'I(,/I, I. MllllI
Wf>flMDfA' 10 the ~ IuI ""'........ in Ihl, ,- flLt A CQMPf.AlNr Within IW4lflly ([;0111111"1 ..11.11
'iIIIlU hit 00 TlCI vi AI.,., At
-'""-"'I.,u.l.n ulAt4i.iI';.L", ,ill\,,,,lr
'RAICiplTO 1t41'1R'UILITO'IU COMPLAiNT AND RULI TO 'IL(
0"'" """,,(1 01 Imll '" lx' ,-I ONLY ~., ill'"'' _llCIlI'IUMn 1...'fI PIl. IICf'JP No. I(KH/lI.' IIf:II(Jf! />IiII!flI fl<ttl(.f ,4M"..
W NO/ /r.>/O, ""1<1I10 "'.11 ('<"V 01 ,,,fllIi,,.4 II/J.1/l11u W _."fU'II/..JI/<.,1I
PRAICIPI. I~ ,.,.,,,.........v
"..... """""""
~~"K._~__~.~ '<"_"'''-'''_._~_.'''_"'_' ~.._ _..._ ,"'.'_u-o,_'_.,
~ 11# .."",i
, .,lIIrrl'~ It HI ........... III.......,....,
(c......... PlIo... ~..
,..C l..iIhIft ,--V (lO'*,,' ""- ..._ '" .... .. tlMttI ......, .. ,"Tel' '" _.....
, .~....;;;, ..0;...... ... .... .. _'
RULI, fll
, . _._.. ","'O'''~...''''__.'m._...._ .....m.......... ..._... , ~,rrll'r.('~
,.,. ll..~.j
( I) Y"" .... """'*l """ .. .... It ......... -... _, ,..., let ,ilt .. ......... In ... ....,; w...... 1-.1, (1OJ ~, """ lilt M '"
...... ~, II... .tAt ~ ,..., "" ,...tlll\!ll ...... .. "" ...,.,." III ~ IIlIl4
I Jl " ............... '... .. ......... ...... tItit ,_. .. liIDOMCN' Of NOH PIO. Wll" tN'ttW AtM'., YOU
III 'he ..... III ....11.. '" ..... .tAt ~ ....... _ by ..... it the... III......
"':l'rar~tl. ,~
lltM "; .. JI.-rT\".".' -~_Q.
. ,,,...., .... .~ "- -"~Ifi.... iI.w..wt'_ f~
..~ ..J.
T' ,
, j
f ~
, ,/ " VI
t___'
" ) i
r'{ ,J 'I
1'1 ,,'1:..
.1 ,
1- ~ , ,
" . -'
~ - . ,
.. -' h , h .
A "
(' .
i.' ;\ ~
U
""",.""--'~,~"'.!'." ,
PROOF OF IIRVlce OF NOTIce OF APPIAL AND RULE TO FiLl COMPLAINT
; /'"'1''''''' ,,/ '."". MtJ~" IU flUP WI/Ii/N If N (hllilA YS Ai /1'/1 /'/"'11 "'''!U'.., H/ ./,/...., G".(l 'PP"t'bl, /'V""
COMMON_tAl IH 0' .../jNanVA/jIA
(CUliN" Of
i"
AFFIDAVIT: I ,..,..I,V ...... 01 .ff"," It..ll.......'
; ,i t 1't'Y {If HlflI NlJtu:e Lt' ApV..I, Cutl\luun 1'1... N4 _'- .'_''''''__,'''''' . If'.IIH tho. f)H.ttlU JuttJte dltl\JrUI,..tJ 1t',,''''ltl (111
"'." HI '."'.'1 '''_"m,._m..._.." III~.~., Cl b, ".,WIl"",V". n \t, j""tll..dl (l.gi.'.""1 .....1, ""U."
lie-I .<lJt' Iflt.(;ft.", h*tefo, and UPUl1 'hi .,)~"'1I.1. III4m'l ,..--_".,.,,,~.-,,,~,,__,,,,_,._,, _"'_""-"""'~"~_"~_""'''_-;-"_,~,~,,,,,-;-,_,,~_,,",,,,:,,,-____-,,,,_~",_><>,_ ""'." ._....__ . ('1\
........,-_.... ._-~ , 1I1_,_,LJ D, P",<,II/,/ ..,,'.. U b, ("811,It_al ("11,.".,.1)'11"1. .'''11". '''''''11' ,'t.. hll" h.,.",<
! ) ./1(1 /Ii' Ih" fI'.. ',,'v.II Ih. 1\..1.1" f ". II CWIII"i1"'lilH"m"''''Y'''Ii'''' .....v. ~,(..lI VI 1\1'11".1 111/\1" Ih. 'N'.""!II "1""'''"
'10. II.... lO" ."u,.......o I,"'"~~,_",.._~^~."..."...._....~""~..~" Ilt...."..~ [) b, ""'tIJ,,,,I"hl~" 0 If, 11'.,1;1'''''/110\1'''.'.'11
~l.ll .."d.". '"ftlpt .Uac:.h.l' h.ffiitu
......01<.. ,AIt II,l,lf PI i\/i;O IUU~CnlbtP IItHIII' MJ
"ti~,,,,fjAY Of p,...~..,..+.,,~.., ....,.",."
'''''''.'''''''''''''''':'''<;~!:''''''''''-_~''''Y.t',,,~~,,,,,_'-_.,",,,,<w,,,,,,,,,,"'>,,_,,--,_~,,,,,~_~_
- - . 6i,n,"U. fi' ,111''''
"'If"""". .>(" If' 1,1"'''. .km" "UJ/fMr"-." "l,,~
- ""."='_"lC.~"" "'o._,......>..~".~..,."..'''"'~"''.......,.~..,.:,.;..._.'''.~,....~.''':_
I '-iii vI ..11,,_...,
_.._"'t'_'~~"~~~,*"",~~".~
r.f; tj....#f't."~ ..,fk,.,Off ..",...".=~~, 'L.-_~
, ~
11.+1'."_\
Glenn n, FAHNEn
5002 LENKKH STHEET
MKl:IIANH:aIlUIlO. r^
,..,,",~ 17171 761-0230
17055-0000
1/" J'tr i. til II lff,-'
COMMON PLEAS NOTIFICATION
REQUEST FORM
rJAINllft' If"t,lt .'.,I"!'ld"'I~
I.LICWEI.I.YN, C^,llll. ^
525 I.OI'AX 1\11, AI"I',' IL211
IIARR I5I1UIIO. I'A 17112
L-
VII.
llIHNllANI
'CONNIE VALENTI"Nt:7It'Aiit TECHNICIAN"
4200 TRINOLE IUI.
eAHp 1111.1.. P^ 17011
I
[g~:~~~;;~~"~~1~4;O --'41
~.~___...<,...,...",,,,,,,,,,,_.,,,~~..,.,",,,,,,.....,...,..........._J
'*
COMMONWEAllltOll'1 NWlYIVANIA
COUNTY Of CUMJlI':IILAtlll
.-'":....C".~.,~_..;.~'-.""'=;o~~
1,oI"'I,h,ll.."
0<) - J 114
i II ,~..".., 'I, ".
~.._..-.-----------""--~-,,,-,'----"-'
Olonll II. t'^RNJ!:R
5002 LENKER STREET
HECIlANICfJDURG. f'^ 170!l5-0000
Plet.."" t,., 'Hf~.'.lt Pill .It .,'pefil h.. ~.n f,l,d tn th, .buy. uplloMd u.. Kind'. vl' 'hll '0"" to !nU1l>_ 'hi ,.tuttl
III ihl. I HU ,11I1(. 'fllum to th" J..UlfIY authultt~ (h....d "IJOv,'
ftUULUJUPPW,
IUMM""Y"PPrAl
"I"'f"~ ~1II~;KlN' ."poolh.'l>Hn ~,.."_d
""I'I"L IlttCONIINUlp. .ppool ....1.... ~'_lnuod b, .pp.lI.nt
l'IB111lCf JlJlIflCI PtC'1IION lJPHflU, .OUIl...' ....hod..... "'.....n.. ."gl..,..'....., ",_-..-
...~._ ~'t1<l<IIUII"'''''''''' fOllow ..m.'n... fin..,.....
""PI "I SUCCI.GrUl. . ."'" .... ....".~ ",oi.1oA ......""'" 10 tIof.nd.nt
_ ,.." ,"u.~ Ie "" ..tIIId W 11,.".., j..- ""...
"."'., ,olund ... "" III"",, b, ..,....., 10111... .....
flfVIlfO 0I.ff\tllU11(.IIj Of flNf....NO cOt I II
.. cIltltlOl jutIIo. ,,"It, .. to ...... . .....ial,....... pIo'" Indltllo OAf AltO ......lIowll4MIln... ~
oj ,.".. ond 00'" .. , ,"uM to! 1IttI_ . "","1oA
ftNll
COUNTY CIIf OOIT
ITATI eln OOIIl
trATII (;IT I
HtAftlHO COlT
.....
CAf
U
ovc
eve
ceo
- .;....
...
~
lk
~~
A.MII
OTHeR!plt... .,..oily,
-
...
~_...._._~..r
--~
-
CIVil "PPIAI
"f'I't "I 11 I f1ICl<Vl . opfHI" "" ...... ....1IIowN
"PI'! At OtllCONflNl,lfO ' _Ill h.. ...... .....ntl.lI4I4 W lIP........
[1101 flIC f JlJ!lllC1 I>fIC~ Uf'Hllll ' """ .... '....... .... ...... ~ .. .... .....114 jIitIIH 1\I4t.......'
IIlB ".Cl JUlll ICI OtCltllON llf""*9tu . ,,11II .... ,........ , ..........,..... ... 044 .- .... ... _ill jIIMI jII.......
WHII or CtHTlO/IA1Il
""n t1IHKj(IN .OPpool.... ...."...........""
Wit' [JlIlUlNllNUtO' .,, .... ..... "'............., "'........'
"',IUIU )tI~IW;t PtJ;lBj(!tUII "M'" .........wIII ...'......d duo... .,,,,,,,..<tr '-It li4 /III........., III IIIJ/II'IHI._
"".'[111>1,11"',141 . 1/1....4 "'.... do.'...". .... .... """'" ... ... ,.....1. '-""'91""-' '" ""''''' <I"tH...,.., .-
"" It MAl H' ()I OllJICflON lI'Io_.... . "'110/01 ...-,.. lItO,""
'lIjil(lj("" [~J;lN'lN\ltO .....,.,_ ...._. _"'~..., IN~'
(Jl'il,.I~lNVl,to;lfll ~,,,,\ow,,,,,,,,,,,,w....~lAl_""''''
,1I.l.ll (I'... \>>'1 II Hl __. '....""'A'.... '.... _.......... lor ... {,Wfi "C""_.......
'-;c~t\'~'?:",.,==,~--.-
-- - t,~['$~f'-'"__~v.n.~n"'t~.~:"~
- - .,.~:-., __'-;-~.';."t"t":~.,;"f~;':'F':.."-'i't-'r.
""If" In....
rOftH f'1IlttUtlI
I/ll/'~ "lltlOI
CAROL A. llEWELLYN,
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENN8YLVANIA
Plaintiff
v,
: NO, 9&.248 Civil T.rm
CONSTANCE VALENTINE.
Vdlbla THE HAIR TECHNICIANS,
,
D.,.ndanl : Civil Ac:Uon. LIW
ORDIR 0' COURT
AND NOW, ~fp ,,). " ,J. / , ,oe...i In contldtt'lIon of tht IorIQOi'lo
petition. ()'l: ~ ~. ill J. ~), J IJ/lii/ .f IIq.. t III( ):_1 'L.'
.l~l /"'~"JtL'ijl,l, f!eq., and lJ":/Jllti{"I 1)[" I~"-I , I",., .,.~
arbllralor. In tht IbovHaptIOntd tlCtlon II pr.)'td tor
8y tht Court.
!'
II ,,'.
! II C. If I....
)()
~
ill'
,.,J,
.
CAROL A, LLEWELL VN,
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSVLVANIA
Plaintiff
Y.
.
,
: NO, 95.246 Civil Term
CONSTANCE VALENTINE,
IId1b1a THE HAIR TECHNICIANS,
Oerendant : Civil Acllon . Law
PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS
TO THE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT:
Thoma. M, Kutz, coun.el ror the plaintiff In the above action, r"p'ctfully
repr...nta that:
1, The lbove-c.aptloned Icllon I. at l..ue,
2, The claim. or Ihe plaintiff In Ihe action are a. follow.:
Tota' damage. not In exce.. of $25,000.00
The counterclaim of the defend.nlln the acllon I.: NlA
3. The following attorney. ere Inter..led In the ca.. I' coun..1 or are
otherwl.. dl.quallfled to .It " arbllralore:
Robtn L, Ouuendort, e.quir., coun.el for the defendant
WHEREFORE, your petitioner pray. your "onorabl. Court to appoint
thr.. (3) arbitrator. to whom the ca.. ahall ~ .ubmltted.",
*"""".........". ",
T-A''''''' ,~",*.,'f'I"'!' I l . ~
.. '/ "..
/<,.. '. I ,7 ;,I;t~':f'
, /'-""1',> f ./ ... /f' .
Thoma. M. KuIZ,/
Counttl '01 PjalnlJff
.~"""', ,.
219 ENt MIln Stt..l
~g, PA 17066
(717) 1~2n
Supreme Court 10 No *"
CAROL 1.. UEWELLYN,
Plaintiff
I IN TIlE COURT Of COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUN1Y. PF.NNSYLV~I^
1
v.
.
.
: NO, 95.248 CMI Tenn
CONST~CP. VALENTINP, Vd/b/a
TIlE 1I^11\ TECIINICIANS,
De(endant
.
.
: CIVIL ^Cll0N u LAW
AMENDID ANSWIR TO COMPLAINT WITIt NEW MATl'ER
0' DlflNDANT, CONSTANCE V^LENTINE
AND NOW. rome. De(endanl. ConJt8nt'e Valentine Vd/b/a The Hair TechnldlUU,
by and throulh her counsel. Manhall . farrell, P.C., by Kerry VOII Smith, Esqulre, and
Nuwen the PlalntUf. Complaint and auen. New Matter III (ollow.:
1, Admllted.
2. Admitted,
~
3, Mtwertn, Oet.ndant Inrorporatn by r.(erence h. respol\let 10 para,r.pba
1 and .. u It mort (utly III (onh herein It 101\lth.
4. Admitted In pan, denied In pan. It I. admitted thai, on May 31. 1994.
Plaintiff and the D.(endant m't In r..ard to PlaintlN't pennanent halr lOll. To the
fllttfll the re,nalnln. .vennenu In thlt plU"l.raph relate to Plalntlrf. .ubJcctlve bell,(
4'OA(tmlnf her J'C'nlllMlU tualr MI, ahff rfUQNlblt InveulJlUlon, l>dcndllu It wtth.oUl
knowltd.. Of WuOMlWn .uI/\d4',u 1,(1 1<",,, . belltl .. to the truth or I.blty 01 the
Ilvtrmnlt. rontall'lf4 in Ihit !WIt,.pIland, 1("'Ofdtl\lly. .4k1 .vemenu art .pcdWy
and unequivocally denied and su1ct proof thereof Is demanded at trial If deemed
material.
5. Denied. It Is speclncally and unequivocally denIed that PlaintIff advised
Defendant that Ihe, the PlaIntiff, WlU experienclng temporary haIr loss brought about by
the use of hair color and, accordingly, Itrict proof thereof I. demanded at trial If deemed
material. To the contrary, 11lalntlff IU\lBelted to Defendant that her pennanent hair Iou
may have resulted from prior use of hair color.
6. Denied. It II .peclncally and unequlvocally denied tMt Defendant advi.ed
Plalntlff that .he luffered from "male pattern baldness" and that she requIred a "hair
replacement integratIon l)'Item" consllllng of human hair fastened to a net which In turn
would be attached to PlaIntiffs own haIr and, lIccordlllJly, Strict proof thereof I.
demanded at triallf dermed material. lIy way of funher Ill\Jwer, It Is lpedncally and
unequIvocally denied that Defendant allured Plaintiff that the haIr replacement
Intesratlon ')'Item would be Plalntlffs ben hope and that It would work for her and,
Iccordlngly, Itrict proof thereof I. demanded at tnal If deemed material. To the
contrary. at all tlmel material hereto. Plaint I" souaht Defendant duo to pemanent hair
10.. and w.. properly and approprialOly lnstructe4 on the uso, IS well IS the mllerlal
ri,kJ and benen", ot II cwlom,mad.. human hair replacement s)'ltem.
7. Admitted,
8. Admltled In pan. denlt<! in pan. The aV'Menl' conooned in thl.
partaraph 1ft conclUllol\J 01 law 10 whld\ no amnnallv. re'pont.. .... required. To Ih.
extenl tmnntllvo r01pol\J" may bo roqulrt<!. .ald Ivennenl. 1ft .p<<tftcally and
unequivocally denied and t1rk1 proollhereot I. demand.a lllhe lIme ollrtal \I deemed
malerial. II" admlttt<!IMt Plalnll<<, aft., bot", pro~r1y and appmpnal,ly \ntINCtt<!
on lhe ute and II\IIIrtaI rt,kI and bo",ftll ut . hair rtpllK'em,nl ')'Iltm, purchucd a
CUllom. mad.. human hair r,p\a(cmfl\t ')'II.m which wu .uar.nu!1d lor twO (2)
mOlllht und.r the manulanUfe", WIITII\I)'.
9. Pcnlt4. II I. .ptritkally and llMqwvoodly d.nItd thaC lhe conUlIC\
.m.rt<! Into by Plaintiff and Ptltndtnt 1ndu4f4 "tultrlal. and "",,"I which coma1Md
vartoul wlITantle." and. Imlrdln.ly. .tM proof d"rtot I. dtmandfd It 1M IImt of uW
\I dmntd mat.riIl. To the romrary. I( all ttm.t mat.rtal "'MO, Pla1ndlt, aft., bet",
properly and .ppform"l)' WIN4't,d 00 tM \1M and mlttrtal rhk. and "","U 01. halr
r'plle'IM", ')'II.m, pwd\llfd a Ntw""'fildf, tluItw\ IWt ffpllfflJlfllt ')'Itm whkb
wu .uarantm1 tttt two ca> PWIlIhI ., ItMllMINI*"w,n Wlffant)'.
10. Mmtllf4,
11. PtnW, II" .~.,ty 1M III'Itiqw",,.:.uy dfn1f4 IhItI New"" May 31.
199. and "pt...,." 11/1I", tWmIft ,,,'t1vf4 lw.lv. '1Wt prfJl.-tn t~.~ II
lJ4htl/JMl&'. pJMt "" ~Mt 1M. lfi'fJf_", tlJt41 ,,001. ,fMt~ ~ ~ .. &be
WN QI t,w It.~ ~ To I'" ~li1l'1, (~!i Nm~ r~. rf4M
that between May 31,1994 and September 17. 1994, Plalntl((walleen by Defendant on
nine (9) occltlolll for hair treatmentl.
12. Denied. It Illpectftcally and unequlvocally denied that Defendant chars cd
Plaintiff $370.13 durin, tho pertod of May 31, 1994 and September 17. 1994 and,
accordlnsly. Itrlct proof thereof II demanded at the time of trlallf deemed material. To
the contrary, Defendant'l Involcel renect that Plaintiff wa. clwsed $111.73 durtolthat
perlod of time.
13, Admitted In pan, denied 10 pan. It II admitted that on September 24.
1994. Nicole OllCnr1der, an employee of tho Defendantl, ntted Plaintiff with a "hair
replaCClment tnt'lratlon l)'Item." It II lpectflcally and unequivocally denied that the
l)'Item Wit .ttached by \IIIOJ Plalntlffl exlltln. hair to tlo or anchor It to her head and,
lcc:ordlna1y, Itrtct proof thereof II demanded Iltrta11f deemed materta).
14. Denled, It I. ,pfctfleally and unequivocally dfnled lhat on October 8,
1994, Defendant advt.cd Plaintiff lhat the "hair ')'Item. wa. "attached too 100"" and
that Defend.nt "renued tho .)'Stem by retyln, It to tllalntlfr. head with Plalntltrl hair"
and, A<<Ordln.ly. .tl1(1 proof thereof II demanded .ttho time of tri.111 deemed material.
'To the contrary, Delendant advtl,d I'lalotlft that tile hair unit wlll.radually romo 100..
lltIer the ftmllm. It I, 'UlChed.
15, Mmtued tn piU't, dc'nltd III pIIn, It.. Wmlued only tho.! on OClobtr 22.
199", PI.lnutf w... wen II &tit lkfendwu'a plare of bu.tlnelS, It II Ipt41Ika11y and
WWlqulvO('aUy 4wJtd lhall'Wn.tUtl tlhtlnj hiU on lh4ltup and .kIn (It hn hHd \Wfe
ever broken or pulled out hy tho '>'Ilem and that I'lalmlfrl Icalp wal fun her expoled.
Accordlnaly, urict proor thereof II demanded at the time of trial If deemed material. To
tho contrary, PlalntUrl hair had been cut and thll accounted for the appearance of the
hair. By way of funher aOlwer, to the extent the avermenll In thll paraaraph relate to
IIIUOI of cawatlon. they are conclusion. of law to which no afOrmatlve relpomel are
requIred and Itrict proor thereof I. demanded at time of trial If deemed material.
16. Dented. It II IpectOcally and unequivocally dented that the hair unit
caused dama,e to Plalntlfrl hair and, accordingly, Itrict proof thereof II demanded at the
time of triallr deemed material. By way of runher IUlIwer. Ilnce the hair unit did not
caule dama,e tll Plalntlfrl hair, no wamln, wal required. Defendant did adYlae Plaintiff
that her hair needed to be cut In order to properly fit the hair unit.
16. Dented. Mer realonablolnveltl,allon. Defendant II wllhout knowled,o ar
Informatton lurftdcnt to fonn a belltt u to tho truth or falllty or tho avermentl
contained tn thl, paragraph and. accordingly, .ald avermenu are lpectftcally and
unequivocally dented and Itrict proof thereof II demanded at tl1allf deemed material.
17. Denied. 1'ho averment I contaIned tn thl, paralraph arc conc:1ulloN of law
to whlch no aI11rmallve rcapont'. ar. required. To the elltent aJ'f1rmlulvI r.lpoNe. may
be requlred. laid .v.nnenu Irt tpecll\clllly and unequivocally del\lo'" and Itnct proor
tt\(>rco( Is "mandfd III tt\(> ttme oltr1alll dC'tmed matenal.
18, l>mJC'd, The .vennenu c.onlll1nedln thll pIIl'lr.ph are cumlUllona or law
10 whlch no all\nnallve r"po"t" Ill' rfqulred, To the elIttnt aeOmallv. rClpam" 11\I)'
be required. .ald Ivennenta Ir. 'Pfdncllly and WlIqulV(l('a1ly deNt<! and 11M proot
IhereoC I. demanded II tho lime ot Inall( deemrd malenal.
WJIF.REFORP., Defendanl rerptafully \'tqu.tUlhll .Iud,m,nl be .nllftd In hfr
favor and 1,lInlll'llIntl<< Ind Ihll ()tf.ndant bet awardtd Ipprol1rtall rom and t...,
~
19. A1uwenn. Oefendanllnrorpvrlll" by r.t",Jl('f III r..poNtI to 'Ilqrlpha
Ilhrouah 18 u It more tully .el tonh h.,eln Illen,lh,
20. Denled u a condualon ot law to whkh no ".puNt I. rtqwtd. To tht
eXlent that I fe'poN. I. requlrtd. II It .pedftca1ly and untqulYO(l1ly dtnif4 lhal
l>eCendanl knowtn,ly mlarevr..'nttd lilt noed and ,rtKlIv.1W1I ot 11M "hair pMein
treallnenu" and. acrordln,ly, 111141 proot IlltrC'ot II demand.d II IIw IIInt at Irtallt
dtemed malenal, To tho rontrary. al aU Ilmtt mllfrtal twftlo. I'taIntllf IOUI'"
I)efendanl duo to ptrmantnt hair lOll and WI' pn:llltrly and approprtal.ly lntlM1td M
Ihll use. u well I' lilt malertal n.u and l'Itntftn. 01 . Mlflff""ltdf. hUIMA hilt
,evllceme", ')'IIC'm,
21, Denled u . rondutlon 01 law 1(1 which 00 f"poNt I. ,tqWttad, Tu Ihf
C'xlenl lhal I r"polU' I. required. II II tp.dlkally and ~ulWlfally ~ 1M
l>efelldanl mllf.pre.'nt,d lilt n<<d Il)r lilt "hit, "rIM"",,,. In<<,,'i&~.m .ytlfm" 11I4.
l&('('ordinJly. 1Irk1 proof th4'rwl '" ""fJlJII~d .. IIW II lk'm4'4 NI.tWo Jy Vit'J uI
funlwl aNWfr. it it .P<<Ukt.Uy and Ull4"lulv~..uy lk1lk4 ,110M 1Ji4 ~ uM fMH'4
dAR~" lo'IaiNtft. hIl, 1Ild. 'H,.,~~l)'. ."141 Pfwt Itlttt# ltlkMMl4f4 .. ltit ..
of trtalll dftmod materi"l. To Iho ronlllU')', at all time. material hereto, Plalntlfl.oUlht
Defeodant duo to penn.nent hair 10" and wa. properly and apl,ropriately IllItructed on
tho ut.. .. well II' the matenal rl.b and l>eneftll. of . cu.tom-made. human hair
r'placement ')'Itllm,
22. Df/mod .. a conelu,lan of law ta which no re.pon.o I. requlred. To the
,xlent lhat . re.pomo I. required. 11 I, 'peclftcIIlIy and unequlV<X'IUy denied lhat
Ocf.odanl en.lled In a count of conduct whlt'h "Induced" Plaintiff Into purclwlnl tho
"hair protein Irealment'" and "hair replacement IllIclr.llon ')'Ilem." and. accordlnlly.
urict proot thfreot I. demanded al Um. ()f tr1allt deemed mat,rlal, To the wntrlU')'. II
all timet ntlt.rtal hereto. Plaintiff .ou8'" I>efendanl duo 10 penMnent hair lOll and.
all., beln, properly and approprialely IlUtructed on the UII and ma"r1" rUb and
beoeftll of. hair "placement l)'Itm. decided 10 pllfdllUO . Mtom,mide. human halr
r"I,lac,m.m ')'Item,
WlIltRltfOR!, Utf.ndanc rflp<<\lully requem that Judlm'nI be f"l.red in her
flVQf and ..atml Plaintiff and lhat Del,ndant bt .ward'" .ppropriale roltl and 1m,
~
2:J. MtWfnn, Oefendanlln<<!fJl()'.t,. by f,f'ffllCtlll r"poN" to Pllfq,.pha
ltlvWJh 22 II lIl1l1J1'<< tuJJy .... fanh twrfln It '-n8th.
U. UtAifd ... /I 4"QIWI~lM ollllw to wbkh 00 '"P<>M' it "quk.d, To It"
nkAt tMa . '"fOAM it 'fQultf4, It l.t 'P4"1IkiUy lfld ww.quiv{X'-.1Jy dfnkd It""
'>t',ft4w fl_ any mb'..P<<mfiljlk..... vmMoo VI 1(1flt'~lU v( fiM' W fWmltf and.
'..;"-::
accordlnlly, strict proof thereof I. demanded at tho limo of trtallf deemed material. To
tho contrary, at all lime. matertal hereto, Plaintiff .ouaht Defendant duc to permanent
hair Iou and was properly and appropriately Inllructed on the u.e and material rt.ks and
benenu of a hair replacement ')'Item.
25. Denied II a rondUllon of law to whkh no r".ponlll I. required. To the
extent that a re.ponsll I. required, It I. .pedncally and unequivocally denied that
Defendant employed any unfalr method of competition or any unfalr or deceptive act of
practice and, accordlnaly .trict proof thereof I. demanded lit the time of trial If deemed
mater1al. To tho contrary, at .11 lime. material hereto, Plalntlff .ou,ht Defendant due tn
pt.rmanent halr Iou and, .fter beln, properly and appropriately Inllructed on tho use
and material ri.ks and benen.. of a halr replacement ')'Item, decided to purchaso a
CUltom-made, human hair replacement ')'Item. Dy way of fun her aOlwer, II "
.pedncally and unequivocally denied that Plalntlff .uftered any ....cenatnable 10.... and,
acrordln.ly, strict proof thereof" demanded at tho limo of triatlf deemed malerial.
WHEREFORE, Defendanl re.pectfully reque.t. thai Jud.ment be entered in her
favor and a,alOlI Plaintiff and that Defendant be .warded appropriate COlli and fees.
~
26. Mlwerlna Defendant Incorporate. by reference Itl responsel to Paraaraphl
lthrouah 25 II If more fully let fonh herein atlensth.
21. Admitted.
28. Denied II a ronduslon of law to which no relponse II required. To the
extent a re'pol\le I. required, laid avermenu are .pedncaJly and unequivocally denied
and llrict proof thereof It demanded al the lime of Irtallf deemed material.
29. Denled. The avermenll conI/lined In thll par..raph are conduslol\l of law
to which no aft\rmatlvo re.ponse. aro required. To the extent .rnrmatlve responsel may
be required, lald avermenll are lpednCAlly and unequIvocally denied and strict proof
thereof I. demanded at the lime of trtallf deemed material.
30. Denled. The avermenll contained In thll paraaraph are conclusIons of law
to which no aftlrmallve relpontet are required. To the extent aftlrmatlve relponse. may
be required, laid avermentl are .pedncally and unequivocally denied and Itrtct proof
thereof II demanded at tho limo a( trtallf deemed material. Ily way a( further an.wrr, It
II lpedncally and unequivocally denied that the halr unit caused any damaac to
"Ialntlrrl hair and, accardln,ly, 1II1ct proof thereof II dernanded II tho lime or trtall(
deemed mater1al. To the contrary. Plalntltr. halr had betn cut lIIld thlt accoWlted (or
the apll'lfll\4'f olthc halr.
31. Denled. The avenMnI' 4'OntIJn.ed in thlt parqr.ph Itt ronduswN 01 law
10 whk'h no Ifftnl\lllvt ""potU" Itf rcoqwred. To ttlt ..Ifflt aft\rmatlVf ("pool" may
tIf rtqu1rtd, .1Id IV,01\.nt. .r. 'Jlf'1t\4'ally 1114I uMqulvO('a1ly <lfnled and ur1ct proof
thmof't dmandtd Ittht ,1m. of trtallf dtcm.d mlt,.lilll.
WlIER!fOlt~, Utf,ndln' 'etp<<lfully r~Ut." tlmt .Iud.m,nt be ent,red In her
"V(lt and a'lIllUl P1il1nlltt Ind thai Otf,nd.nt bo IWllrd,d .pproprtat. ~,. and fHl.
1.
fW.Y..a1mII
rIIIMff lUll talltd 10 ..... . dIlIn upon which r,Utf ran bt Il'IllItd.
PWndl" da1m It bitmd and/(JI limlttd by thf .pplkablt Slat\IUl of
a.
IJfnlwm.
3. 'I It ~ 1M thfftfw. Ivmtd, tMt ttw dtt<<MI)' wUI .how tfw the
l'Wnt1tt WIll ""llpnt and that twr flf'U.~ ,~ tJw !WID"""" It 111)'. 01 Uw
lUltwff1nl I~, lbmby lw1inI Mt r~ by opmtton (1/ d,. ~
C(JlTIJWlIUW N~ Nt.
4. 'I it l'IfbMd. II1d l_tim. MlfN. tl1M ~ wmthow ttw d" PlilnUtf
WM flfJttlm and lhat by w,,,- {J( lwt ftfI~, hff (ialIfU mil)' .. Ilmhfd by the
/Jr*fll4klft ttl thIl'tMt~ (''(lIIlplnlllw ""UIfMI N'I,
5, It It btu.wd.and IM.-AIt' ~ tMt ~ wUI tOOw dw lht PllAndlf
VlJltlllfi#1ly ~ . kflrM'll. ritk t~ liwf1nI K\'PWry by thf .,.doo f!llht ~
/Jf ~IJffl$if.ll;1tJ l1t ftMk.
t. ~. ~,II ill')', wm ~ .. . ".lIi /ill. IMlwtd (If ~
~... W!4 W*I. ~ +~ tly l'" f"~
7. IU all timet mater1a1 hereto, Defendant provtded fUll, complete, proper,
reasonable and adequate halt lOll productS and treatment in accordance with tho IppUcablo
Industry Itandard or standard of care.
8. No conduct on the pan of Defendant was a subnantlal factor In causlna or
rontr1butlna to MY harm which the Plaintiff may have suffered,
9. If JIlalmtfr suffered any damage, the dama.el were caused by the conduct of
othen over whom tho Defendant had no control or right to control.
10. All claim. and caUlCl of IlCIlon plead agall\lt the Defendant are baITed by
Pla1nturl knawtn8 and voluntary Wonned COl\lenlto the treatment rendered.
11. Plaintiff II not entitled to punlllve damaaes II she tw (ailed to plead facts
which cvtdmce Defendant'. evil moUvc or recklesslndltrerence to the Ii,htt of plalnt1ff.
12. My award of punlllve damaaes baled upon Vlllue, ltndeftned .tandardI of
IUlbIllty would vIolato the pue Procetl Clause of the Founeenth Amendment of the United
States Col\ldtudon.
13. l'lalntltr u.ed tho .ubJcct product In an Improper maMcr which WII a
lubuanttal factor and lupenedlna caul. of the Plaintiff. alle.cd Injury and dama,eI.
14, To the extent Defendant WII obll.ated to do 10, lho properl)' and
.pproprtalely complied wilh .11 wmantle', elpr".. or Implied, If an)'.
1$. Plalntlff fll11N &0 lIve edeqUlllt notl<< /Jf any alltSed dtfMIn lIw .ubJc(t
pnxJ\,\(t .
AND NOW, thh 26th day of September, 1995, I, Lori Adamdk 1<artII, F.aqulre, hereby
cently thai I Mrwd . U\lO and ro~ ropy of the rorCllolna document on aU pan1et by
dtJultlnl . l.'Opy of lamo In the UnllN 51al$;l mall, re,ular deUvcl)', poslllle prepaid al
IlIn1tburJ, hnN)'IVMla.Iddrea'N II foUows:
Thoma M. l<ulJ, l!tqulr.
319 !Ill Maln Sir"'
MtchanlaburJ. PA 11055
, j ,
~1)f' '/
Lon
~
kANt. Esquire
CAROL A. LLEWELLYN,
plaintifr
I IN THI COURT Of' COMMON PLEAS OF
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I
I NO. gS-248 CIVIL TERM
V,
CONSTANCE VALENTINE,
t/d/b/. THI IIAIR TECHNICIANS,
Derendant
ANO NOW,
'Coan.a or CQP,T
- ('I
thie I I day or October,
1995, upon review or
the attached Motion to V.cate riled by Steven J. Piehman,
lequire, the court-appointmente or Steven J. Piehman, lequire,
Jackie J. DeArmond, lequire and Johnn. J, Deily, Eequire are
hereby vlcated,
BY Till COURT,
,j~~~,,'l
J.
1
CAROL A. LLEW\la.LYN, I IN Till COURT or COMMON PLEAS OF
Plaintitt I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
V. I CIVIL ACTION. LAW
CONSTANCE VALENTINI, I
t/d/b/a Till IIAIR TICIINICIAN', I
Dltlnd.nt I NO. 80-2.' CIVI~ TERM
.O~IO~ TQ Y.C~T'
11 Mov.nt i. Itlvln J. 'ilhman, Ilquirl, court-.ppointed
Ch.iraan ot thl POlrd ot Arbitr.tor. in the .bov.-captionld
aClUon.
21 Movant .ohldulld an arbitration h..rln9 in thi. matter
tor OCltob.r " Ilia. Upon r.qu..t ot Cloun..l tor both parti..,
thl h.arin9 w.a oontinuld plndin9 Ittort. tow.rd. . 'Ittle.ent.
'1 Mov.nt reolivld written contira.tion ot . .Ittll.ent on
octoblr 4, Ilia. A copy ot .... i. attaohld hlrlto, .arkld ..
exhibit MAM and inoorporatld hlrlin by rltlrlnol.
~llae'ORI, Movant, .tlv.n J. ,ilh.an, I.quir., h.reby
nqu..t. thlt Your lIonorabl. Court ...ag.te the appoint..nt. ot
.t.van J. ,i.h.an, I.quir., J.okil J. OIAraond, I.quir. .nd
Johnna J, Dilly, I.quir. I' Irbitrator. in thi. ..ttlr,
n..p.ottully .ubmltt.d,
O'DRIIN, DAIClC , .ClllltER
c:--
I'll .,
.t.v." J. r .naan, E.qu rl
17 WI.t .outh Strllt
Carli.ll, fA 1701'
P17) 349...."
EXllIlJl1' "A"
MAUSHALL & FARRELL
. p,c.tI_u,," corpur..on
A"OINna AT LAW
In.! HOlm flOHT nurr
11A..IIIUIO. PlNNnLVANIA tnOI
'UNCI' .. t.CAlIIIAU. II.
NICIlAIL A. 'A..ILL
/011'11 A. I\CCI
OUV VOII.NITI!
ClIAlLU I.IIADDICK.II.
-
LOll ADAMCIK ""1111
KlNNITII ,. IUOUV
kIVIN C. ConONt'
fiLIP/ION' Iml u."oo
'AX In" as..,,,,
__UlAND (WNn limn
.n1WWUTDmCUI.DO
11II"'"
.... ".UR""'"
CAy, tllll. ,.,,,,,
October 4, 1995
,,""'DH' ,,~ n,_
'41 ..,If.._
.......,.,."..,...'..'
- .""'0M..AI..~.g
Steven J. Flthman, Elquln:
O'URlEN, BARlC . SCHERER
17 Well South Street
Carlllle, PA 11013
REI
Cumberland Count)' No: 95.248 ClvU Tenn
Our File No: C.689
cc: Thoma leutl, Esquire
Hl
..
~
".
"..;~
~I
.J
j , ~
t"'"
r.l
1;".)
~ ~
I~s . .
~ ~ ,.
~ . c I ! i
h ~
i1S" t
:- SM= IJ
~g~ ~ , ~1 .. I j : ~
o III ... fIo .,
~~B e ' " S~~! N
i~ I
.~~ H 11\ i '. l
~ if!
6~ , Q ~
r.~ I
lO!\
. '
't,,'
t f
,
_ ,. t ,~i
~Il,.
_'1
to
..::.
Q
...
1
1
j
~t