HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-00270
CI~Il'I'H'le^,,'lllN llV ..t'^ CllN'I'i'MI''f
CIIIlO
Numbor q.f::.?7?L(:ef.l. Ti.l""."
.fll '6' J1
...wW!l~*_."__ J,Jl.f} ftt!l.tUY.~___~
I " f CUd.:-fJ.V:-.&t..!!&_____
_tM~i.Jl~ I..,fLllJ'L.1..__
vtcU",la NlllnOI
Hllmll
ual&nco DUll I $ .BMO
170 Statu RUfchafgo
171 IHato t'tne
ADD Oe:Ll!TE
0 - .
, ,
,~ ,
, '0,00 ,
. 1',00 ,
260 Sheriff COlt "1.50 t any addtl!
207 Dtltrtct Attorney
204 Court COlta (Clerk of Court!
~02 IlllltltuUon
Name M~/~II~('"
Mdruu
. iff.,(:l . __
pi';" 1...<<. fi'/~I f1 cIt,. II 7 t 1
"' " III .
R"It'",S/7J'lt
CHv
tHat.
-
Zip
Nomo
.
.
Addr...
lL.:Li(' 1
cttv
_J- i)<b..
tHat.
-
Up
Name
;.!..-l..i
-
Add HI.'"
~""-'
',.~,~ :_~-:....,,~.--~~- -~
~.< ...... ~,........-.C',..,...."'..,,,...,,,.,..,.""""""","";_._~___._
nty IHue ,i"
=~"-'--~.....-""'j~"":"'..~.f'-<'"~.":e_""","'''".,'~'''._...''''_..~_."'._....""'~'''"...''''''....0;i'''__''.;<_ =a.,:._,,,~ V ~~
I'fllllHJrlflt -If}' Uf f I""
rMIW/I ('lift lInn', IlIffifl'Mlllltl C.~,dll<Ltl.Jl1f4tL !lit HI -'/1S/iS.
<:1-:11'1') 1'1 CAT 1011 OF I'FA CON'I'I,M('T
C,lllU Numhul QS::.J70. (~(.d /llJ'L/
Nilmo _-.J~~Jl1dtk .t._ik..{I.IJ1i!lL<'Ul.L
m_(J'(d.-_ ~~ 1\<t'1..d _
~4ti(4G:." PA 17N3
lla 111noo Duo, (I ~l(. K,l
170 Statu Uurohargo
171 fltllte .'ln8
260 Sheriff Cost ($1.50 . any addtll
207 District Attorney
204 Court COlts (Clark of Courtl
502 Rest Hutton
Nllma f4tM'~t4tJ.J~~~
Addreu
-
Citv
Nlm.
.
Addeo..
~ ,
CI tv
N4f110
"''^'-
"'''--
~'-~.';' -. "'-"''''''_.,',..M
Addeo..
---~--.
-~'"
-""-""""".,,,,,.,.~.,,,
<'it)'
"L"~~'_~~.,'_'. ""-'"";..".""""'o=-=c-',...,'a'''_,<,,,.~,,,,,,-..,:~._..,.,..",..:..._,,
VllJtj",.. NllmfH
4HJ~.Lt.1:!,HIl"1I1C1 IV
API> I>Kt.nle
. .
, . ."',
,'.,
,~ .
. lo,qo . -
, 1'),09, . ,..-
II, 'is: (0
,
.11
Stitt.
UP.. ~
~
--~
.
.
~ .
r .~.. 1
-
Stftt.
~
I j p =--.:-.T__ ,>et:t _J!;oiOIl'lil;C,~
~.d
fltiH"
I, , I' .'.,,"~_ ..,~__ ......
'-"'-"",'-~,~-"",
I'"" ho,w,.., V Of tl n.
'-""'''11 ("," i/y"", Illlo!m.Il)'," ti':r'.J.ll...t<. lrU'I.'1.; "11ft> 'I/.n/ll
nan, t' t(~^1'V. ^NII "'''^NUM ,.t"t'^'. "'" IIV.CUHIl
IIN II V. If
l'KHHl.!y,.v^N I ^ 'f1lt.1t IW ^t"'I(t.I,M"( I'lfll("mllll~ t 'J II 1(1)
To ,,,.. 1,,"'t""I1lI,uV 0' II". ^1'1',lll,.... ("HHI III whleh 'hf1
wllhlll mlHt~r h,lll IIlHtIl 1i"'''"11...11
QIII'ICHION COUNT or I'IlNNQYI.YANIA
'fltI'IINII"IOij(lNt:I1, "rolhlll111"HV 01 ,,,,, ("1111' 0' ewnmon l'l.illl
,,' .".<=\'H"~~.!t"NP Cou/lII" Ih", Ii.llil "ollr' ""'"U II ')our, of [(",ord,
.to hlt nilI' I!III ,,' V I h.lt IHWIJ II I'll hH' /I'll ,.. 'I t 111ft 11Il.t l'Uf ree t CVIlI'
"' tll. whullI ilflll YI1,!t1J flu'lIr.l. "WIIl.'I'll, ,If I IIp'ldlHI III thll cllurt
".. rellulr'.,1 lIy I'" II,^.I', Ilj2"1, Itlll "rll,lflil\ I'IiJllJll1l .ifHI 811I11 lid 'II ,
it ..nl' on tlh. tho Irlul.I'fl,.t III 'h" 1'1 (I('I.I\'IIIIIUII. tl lillI" arut Iho
,It'I'II.t Iillllrl.. In tll41 'lllluwll1Y !h,,,tllr,
CAID Nch ,!)-nO Chll Tun., No, 40" !lug 19l)~
LAUMA IC "AUOIl"A"
Vlt.
T"a4A" Ie "AU(IltMAN
TM dOfUllilHlt II (lOfflpr hot flU '1111 rowofll 'lilV. be.n numberu"
tWill No, I 'il Ho.,,~,.U'~,.. am' allile'lel' h"uto lUJt INtllbit ^ h a
IIMt of thl do~u~nllt ,'orrttllpllllt1IIll,t\v IWffil'uud .nd id'"tUied with
ull4lfcmabl, d'fln".fl4!U, tfl~ludtnQ wHh "'''!'itltlt tll .aoh document,
tit., /lYlflbu or pill,". IHJ/liJ'fl!!!lflQ lIul dIH!l/lflunt,
Trn. d.'. (Ill whl~tI l h. t.",ofd tun 1'"/"1 t unamH hd 10 HI'
IIN>.lliit. llourt lfl",.=~I.t.lJ=l!t"l'n."..,.,..,
(Mul of Cllun)
.~ J' I"
\,*,U"~l!1L,f:~~(t~I~t(""""
I'roUWIlOt4fY'
AH I4dltlltft.' PO" ~, 'hi. @.rtl'l~.'. I. .nplo'~, PIli...
.1~" ,nd gat. @~PYI 'hff'~f .@k"~I.a,lr~ r'~'lp, gf 'hi. flloord.
If/t('OIdf JtCtllVt;lH
'~r.C~"q!O 'N$l!9ft~ CMf
IJUl. Z G ~ 11
UdhH
h HI';,'" IIf \0 .. t H h< )
tl,;\;!~,~du~iJ
I f l.f,' I
.
Dtltl" , S
,
, 1
, (rllm
(;'11... .
, . ,
.
.,
,
,
i
,
Nu. 405 -1!!~
t rlln 1'111.
N 95-270 Civil
fl.
lrrml'l_
t..aut"a E. !ltIUlJI'rMn
.
WtrtUI
-ItJaniIw " tlIl,lQhMlJ
I
,
f.UMPUflt:n III('OIm
from cuttx!rllW4 t'U\lnt~
Int.
...
f
,f
19_
eftt.~ .nd f'ilfll
.
,
f
-
".~.
l.
, ",.,
,
.
.,
.
t!I'fi>
,-.
"to''';;:
;cot"",
''''''''''M 'h~ lh",,~' ..,,~ 1'"",n'.IIII,_ VflIl.II~iI '" Ihf fIlull U, ('ummulI 1'1,., III .1lII 1m Ih,
''',,"1~ "I C\,.t",,!.l~tt.. ""'"""''''''.''~'' I" Ih, ('ummuR..ulth ,"I',nR'~h..u.
~~,.j()'l 11111; 1\1""1
." 'II" ~"<:1U.~'~U...~~.~.-.,~~~., I'"R, t9 _.....~ I' mnl.illfillh. ,..11....11I1
(Ol'\' lit ,..,.'. _......._.I\Wt!\J[ll!IOiL.._~~._...~.__._~_.__.,_._. 1)(1('" t:r t' Nt M\'
I.^""^ ~. hAl!WIM.\N
Vii.
'l'I1OMMt f. Ml!mIM^,~
,'''or. NI,
III ,,'''", tll, 1M, l'\l11l1~"1 fl'" \'(nlliH.llw Onwr, Affldt!'/tl of lIU1uftklent hlldl
1"1 froIO, ""1 1'llI".'fMV I'fOl",.tjVfr (,"\lIr, 01...1,
NIl! ~<<'W, Ihlll !'lill dav of .'Mlll1IY, 1'/\;", 1/11111 '1flfllilldoraUlII1 I,r tllII
wiltdlll'Vll!lt41 /ill.' HIP'1 flr.UnQ t1lAt l"l\li(~r 10 III 1I"flcdlil/e did flr...1I1
,I,''''J"r ,.f dlJlllill 'flf/l ....r.n~lml, H. follpwll'll Tat~"r4fY I'n.fl!<.tlvti On'.,f III
t...."tt;Ju"'.t
1..."1......111 i. Itlmlt.y en\o!,*1 'n... r*'YIII"",Uy "',ulllllfJ ,'.UHnrlllf or
f.I,..I"'J ....I III tN' ('f 1I,,,,,rlil'fI' IWrl~l\,l1l !..,0y lr;jlilV Mt " lI11(:lYlkid frUll
II... rlOllllWofirll fI' r.l\tl'''.r iU J I "irt~1 "'"ttl"lon 1ir>fll1. ('lIdllll., CurtlOrlli/1l1
(,.,hIY, j'(o''''''yl'I'ttflt.. POU. Nil tf(fJI 1... 11I~ (If "I'*~t of ,..tHlnr..r
..\ WIotoItHl' HlnHo 'H~ It".... PO'l liArrllil.uu Pille, Cn II 1110 , Clrrtlurl/illd
I,.u.ly. '...."/IIIVI\J(l/ilfi 11011.
1111. Il(ll!ir .tit.11 rttlii4lfl 'fl tlff...'t l.!fil t1 n flMI orde,,' I' wnlend In
Itd" r,~, II tili'UIfj(J 'tlllH b. '.Id Itl ,h', "..tter on Jr4r!fl{Uty, thll 1Jr'd dAv
.,t .I111..lfY, 1't''''I, 4\ I. t(ll"!~h.,l! p,t(;, 10 "ourlroufI Nil. 1, C\rrbnl/illllt "nunty
(', ~H U..,", I:.U 1111., 1'ml/1IilV 1V<Ollln ,
11_ ".rll. MI.llU.!lJ', l\JWf~hW 1'/llh... ''''ilnll/PIlI Ilfd thlll MliliU...~ 1~1\ff1.
..,.1[' t'l.! h1l 1","'rtJ!l#.1 wi H Nf'h It! ft(uvld!!d wllh A (''('t'Y II' Ihl. OnWf I'Y
....1_1 j"r I'lltHh....1' Nit Ilii4V till".."... !hl. ("dot l.y ArrRt f(lr Il'lIUrtl(~t
. ! IlI,lJtttl Uil,I\lII1'" w!II."I! \WIn..,-,! IlJ.Hl JlfT4...w1. I'm... Iltdl till, (:l:tWr IWlIt II!! 1
,,'''1''1'''', ""..'hll' Uf IliA "!II vl.'I,,' It'i III rHftflttt...l !n If. 'If..-nee (If "
I..lil" (.tt!l....(, III H. -lit lIlilt NI t'in..t III ng'- Yf'Utr Ihl, 8lL'(:t~'n,
''''''1..''''',1 .,..11 ,,,., 'ff t..wn hi )1111, hll III_dl hll hlkl\!ll wlll.'ut Yflfll!('.1I111U
.\0> ,..'( I..''',. It. 1~'lIn ..tih'h liiMj 1"1811 Ihlll (lfll4;r, Wtil'lfl tt. ('(JIurt tll 1111-
..v"Ii<>i.I., MIU'.""lt .IIlIU I.. Iln~I\J1(IIll ,.f\'f. " Illlllrlf't ,llllltln' .t.l .1\0111
....1 1..11 1Ol"t~'ldH.q ." tl. t'fllvtll".'lij (" ct~"l"f 40(J(1 fl' U. I'lIlvlIIylvllnlit
It..I.... (It t'rlm"1i41 rff.'tIltli'...,
I)y Itill CIJllft, I~({lld 1;, l'll...jy, ....1.
II ,I.." lfi. I"", 1>1.., Hf'" ,""WrH \., ~r"''''., H hol.
l! ,1<#1, II!, I~. IJI.!IOf ,.f (\..n, nil".. III ~I 1',.,1...:\ I.'ll frUM N'WtI1I
Nlh '0'. H". !'.." !~tV ", J"'ij~'Y, J."'f'l, HlliI "'"',,OH "'l'f.llMn'" with
..."....1. w..,!"" t, !;;tlfOi~, ''''/i.,u., n.. I,,'/j(f./..".~ ....,...".. wHlul1 r'"i/'i/tiIl,
/1..." (...q.... l.i'(It IfI'llHHMI, 'thn.. I.... I....'. !il! ."'mltt toy /ttt, ,,*'\II.j/fIW.1m lH
'I.., ..1.,,,,,,,,,.\111(,,,, fl"~ "..,. M.. ..UIO, ",(11 it.r."',., I ,.-' Hr'''- II",. ItIiIl !i!"H Il,.
... !'~..I!I.,j.\f /lid I ilf,., AI",! "'''' 1'''.11',,/....,,1 ",~ 41;-_1 Ii",; ...UIt! ....UIII" It",.
'/~!jl:.jlji#J '.it H1f# ff'I1J!l.di'i .'4' kliNt Ml,JIUI N-:,'~,
1/., """'01 '".H ."*' '. !'fi,II;\.dl'.. '4,11#, ~"'Ii ,""A...H!~. 1"1""'1_1 '.it,:
"'" ,.,,.11,' ,H f n... IHIH bHtur ,lIr$>l'." U'fJ\ Ii.". ~4t~$>I~i.jf.~ ,...., Hilt f1!lI~.
c .>>~: '4f ,.d ,'Itf"l ,.!/+,i. F~ 44... ~;'''i~~ ..4lil~ .i ~ fi 4j:d.it*4'(.....F~1t.
>>'1 H.. t"",~.j'l ii!u'f"f,J t" }~t",.trf t:i-; J!j
t I * ~1J l! J
'--"'," "- -.,
,--".".~-~---....~~.....~
,'1111. :10, IlJlJ!). ProtoI" tVlil Onlef, flllllt.
flNIll'lW, thtll 27th Ct.1Y uf JanUllry, IlJ1j'l. ullln c,(~l.tdoml 10/1 of Ihe Cc~I-
Ilenl ^grl!llflcnl of the IkUtlell. the foltowtn!l Onlllf te ll/1teruh
I. I\lfelldlllll 11\Oo1A.<l 1':. UI\LXlIt1fIN 18 onlerod to rofmtn fm" /I111lelrll)
I'IIllntlff IAUM I!. !WOt1flN Uf pllldn\) her In lellr of nll\llle or Ihrlill1lenln\J II( .
2. l.,fellllant 1. ordered lu refrllt/1 In1n htrnRllng Plalnllff, "llllnt Iff
rolllt Ivell or the petlCII!lOe wtlh .hln I'Jlllnl Iff t. \lo\:JrklnlJ or reBldlng, Inchdj '(I
(Hrel't Inn C(1ll1WlknUCIOB, holh oral Bnd written, to her.
]. ()Jfllool1nt Ie enlolntlfl fn1n enterlnll l'lnlnllff '. pln('o ot mf1loYllllfll
lIt WeRt.em IHuUn Ilteak /louBe, 120'1 /lllrrlllllllC\I "Iku, ('lIr11l1le, (.u,blrlllllll
County, l'tInn8ylvllnlll l7011.
4. JJeteld/tnl III ocdered to sillY away fcnn Ihe rellldenl'D 01 ,'lt1inltff
(II n Nllrth MI&UetllO 'IOIlCl, CI1rl11118, ClIltlllrlallll County, I'onnllylvnnlll 170D,
(lnet tnln IIny reddencD IIoillc:h "Ialntiff I1lIlY aetallUeh for herulf In the fulul ..
'\. Thte Onler Ih<111 ruMln In effect fllr Il pliIrlnd of one year.
6. The North Mlddlelon Trl\\llahlp Police Oltl~rtnent Ilnd thlll Mlddh"lllC
'('ownahlp "II Ice OltP'lftJllIl/1t wll1 Mell bo pnlvlded wltl1 a copy of tl111 Onter
by CYlunltlel for I'llllntiff My rmy en10rcII thla Order by Ilrrellt fur llllHrect
ertmlno1l nWltC!l"lt without wol'Ti'lnt UIU\ pllwule CllUIII IhM Ihie onler IlIJa
I""'n violated, IIoilelher or not tlMJ vlnl/lt Ion la runnltted In tile prounce of
II ,Illke Officer. In the event tlvll an IIrrellt la !Md. urder Ihla leetl(IO,
l"ferll<1l1\ li11l'll! rot 110 taken 10 jail, but sMll be Illklln without UMeCellllry
lIetllY bofore the Ctlllrt IIoillch I~I Iuued thll onter, When thlll r.ourt Ie
IlMVlIllilble, ~f.ndant .'lAU be arratgned lJOfore a Plltrlet ,lu.Uell iloilO 1l1~11
"ot hIll Ilecorotng In ttlll prnvllllonll of CllIIpllr 4000 of tl1l1l Pen/lllylvanla IlUle
01 Crlmlntll 1'(11(...lure, The conlenl of Mr. UaUlJllflAn waa IIl1lCle In Clplln rourt.
Uy 11111I CrllJrt, Ildmld r.. lih..ly, I',J.
t\'lb. 2, 1.,.,'1. CerUflctlti(1O of ll/Jll tlllll DIscllArge
t\!tl, 6, 199'1. Onler ot Cclllrt, flied. In 1111 ^ptTltntmlnt of CQunllll
flNlll'l~, Ihtl ;tllll c1IIy of ..hOlllry, llWl, the Court IIflIllnta the l"ubllr
lit,ferll!l1r 1(1 11Ipretll.nt tha l"fellllant on Ihlll ChllfOl"
by t hd CtJurt, lI11nlld tJ:, liheely, p.J.
",b, 6, 1'1'1'1. (lnktr of Court, fthd. In 1111 IIdU lloolllllrlna ~t. Met
flNll tl.W, thl. 2nd c1IIy of tltholAry, IIlII'" , Ihl [Qterdllnt WO. IIrret1ted Ihll
1",,,,,lly ylllt,lt tng Uw proll!CUr~1 fill" IIblllnl order prevtclllllly lUlled lly nIt.
..t.. II l..flrlnlJ '10 the ablY. cHnplalnt tllf 1'lnlflfllly. l"lIlJf'llI'lry 9. 199'), al 11110
"~Ir\ lurllMlr <llrtle'tll I~I II.. l\'Jferwlllnt hetlt'Hn nnw IlId IMI. tlnl. Nlflllly with
· 10119 <lid cllrtle,tllmll ot 111ft prnt..,Uvo ord4lr tt~1 I IUll..1 rtl JQnUi1fY nth.
Hlllell Ih" Q1I.\JIllIl vl(>IQllli/l (lld nnt Inv(llv. Qny lilYIIICi'l1 AWe. lit tho
v 11'1 jill, IIMl r"rfl,danl 'MY I. r.lell...1 frun ellltldy t hi. date IlrrlO IUlIttnu
o 1011.1111 htlll for hi. i'l1'1""arQru:fJ l!1II dlrtK,ted for '''IohnwHY 'Hh, 1<11),\, I'ClI1l11nu
Ih, '....11/11] of IIlA! hlll Ill! tl USMI."" 10 111111 1.'tll4"dy flf IIIlt (\,I'Jllrll'l/d
(', OJnl V tlllllrl ff.
fly lhe ('ourl, '''nol.1 It. ~1_ly, ....I.
1\ ;.1 N,. 10. lY'~. Onwr or e(~lrl, ClI_I, tll 11....1 {'/Jnl\Ol~jt
^~l' N(~, thl, 'lIh ,t,ty ot 1"\111>nNJfY. 1"'1'\. it I..,arlr", Wttll liI!ld In14y m II
,,,, H ,'., n1l4l'J1r1l' ln.tt '~l ""ltWtllY ltd. l''''~, HI!? lltltlflUNlt ('I,ll..1 It. Nltln-
t II t '" hn 1..l.lII." of ~'rll ,>1 th", w..-,..\vrn I$lttlln 1<1<1<1,,11 ltol_, i..rd .,rU'1Q otllel'
"4,'>"-,n,,,,, )..11 ttollU.hw~1 Ill" If .," ,IH1r;'1 [fltuF' ,t tfll/)\! n.n,
11"" pn.h'Clly~ ord"'f '" Ihll. 1._ ....... tlllhd ,J""1\l<>fV HI h, l"i'l". iOId
/.>1.",(,./4. /, '.'U~'t.lt..r ""I"JIf. I.... ll"" foll!l"'lIllJ h,,\(jI...... "1f1l'h411nfl !llft'!'t
"HI 11l.t'~~tI, ,"1'"''', tr,lh ..".1 ,if" "'flli",". \.. ,.,,", n... !t!f<<f.!"M 01110""_ III\!
~tj!l t td I I'L.lh. ftf. 1M" ft",.,. H..'\~,.Otjlh tor h-Hii hlt t ''''f.. Uti" !iih~ ht."" (io'f."\dt1t~ly
i ,,111111 fit;'!, '4\ fht'!- Ii......" dlwt W._flfl'ilt .' ',.i'\Y ....!.II' ttflt..~flk't:l tf'i h~f f-h"hlh~J itnl
LL.:.~11.h~J~"_ '.~." W"" t.i1....._~..."'-c-~~.~~~......
%II"lt.';; ~lj:. If,>f'"i;f i.,ll ~i. ,t;!:,~ I,.,:;.... "!fitt Mi4. 11o.'jfiJ~"~l;1 itll', in Itli', rTlflkn:
;tI4114rt' ,,(Ii ti. 'T.I' It-.ttllt''}),,! f-i"'fl,,'ntj:'dJ tLl4 ifi' "''intj'-'Il, lr.~ j'li1i(,t\ft t"rty
1""11'; N.J.
II -
I~ -
il -
(Idle to. I
'fh, ('''If t
(l,IJI. Thtj
"II Ir,,,111
li,l,'),
."'"
.,"'_.'c
14
I')
/0
"
. .
Callo No. 1)~I-2"lO Civil 'I'ormr No. 40!i 11110 I'JlJ5
nmro.
2J _ 14 III ddditlon 10 (tlaeUIlKIII!) IIdll nklller, tho Il.ltelldant threlltorlt,,1 hor if IIha
did not return a phlfla cl'lll II~I\ lI(loothlllll Willi going to 1.11lJXJll 10 she alld
her chlldren. /IlUlffllgh Ih/lt studfl!: 11l1lIJU/l\Jll Willi not Incllxlllll III the C<<llpllllnt,
1 I.lve told Mrll. 1101ugl'"l1n t hat under 110 drcUl18tllnce8 and under no
re/llnn IItt.uld IIho In tho futuro over IMke II 1:1111 or write to Mr. IlItugltl1iln,
IInd If sho M0l111 /lny I ntom.1t Ion hun him it \lhould he clmo t hmugh her
attorney. 1 hilVll now told Mr. 1.1.1U\]hlliln lIlilt ho 1I1l)\lld In the future undor no
drclIfllftancllll cllll tlflr or write to her for IIny reallllfl, onll If he Il/III /lny
rell811fl tll I'O/ltael har than ho 8hlllld /1180 do tllilt through an IIttorney.
Therefore, I find Ihal I.hll I~KlI1e cl1l1 that Illlllkldll 10 Iho 1'11llntlff 1(1
Februtlry 2nd conl~enllng UIll IOI'lltlllfl of Mrs. l\t1uglrl1iln's dolhe8 /lrd or tho
children'. clothes wall Inltlat0l1 \Jy Ihe l'lalnllff herBolf, and he did nnt
vlollltu the t'rntectton frnn Abullo unler /Ill filr 118 that IXJllvl'lrB/ltlun 18 cIJI"'enKd.
A8 fllr tll the conversation lltXllll, 81100thlng vl\lld hIlppen to hur or her
children if 81l1t IUd not rlltum hll call. 1 will occept the 1'llIlntiff'lI teyttllnw
that, In fllCt, that WIlli allld, and 1 find Ihat II!! II In cmtempt of tho l>n)to,~t1(ln
fron Abuae order for IMklnlJ ttKlliIe rUlIllrk8.
1I0wVIlr, I do not feel that /lny entence to "rbon IoUUld be justified
hallld 'Jll Ihnllll rftllilrkll, lind, thorBfore, 1 direct IIlat II!! plfy tho COlIts Involvecl
frulI t1l1tle pnll'eedlngB. Nv1 I VIIlld IllY to Mr. UIlugtrnan thtlt If II!! colh I!pr
In the future for ony rf,lall,Jll H.lt 1 ,"null' proJXIle Ilt that time to lIeM tho
ll.lfend,lnt to prllm.
lIy tha Ctlllrt. II/lmld 11:. 600.ly, P.J.
2'i - lb March 6, llJn. Orner of Court, fllul. III ROI Cmtunpt
,\NO to'l, thlll lllth d/lY of t'ehnlllry, 19<J~, tho tlJtendant IIppIlllred in court
hday rel'retlllntod by Wtll1lW11 O. Draught, V.qulnr, Aulatllnt I'ublle tlJfender,
Thl! "rote<'1 Inn hun 1\bulI8 (mler prevloully ~nt.nlll In thle CIIS. loya tMt thlll
Ilefendant i. enjnln\ll!! fnln enlerlng 1'liJlntlff'. plm'. of 8l1110yment lit Wellern
IHulln IIte,lk IkJlISO, 1205 '''''rrlahurg Plko, Cllrllslo, CU'*l!!rlllllll County, "A.
TIId 1lI1fendilnt hili ,.;!mltted Ihllt he did violate thlll on!.r y"terilay llbfJut
10115 lI.m. \l4wn he did IJn III the vl<,tlm'. pltlCll of "",loyment. The t)trerlllltnt
IIpplfrently did rKlt see hi. wlf.. Olll! rllitdv no thrOilt. to hor nr tIl1ythlng .Ia.,.
lin. thllrefore, I an rKIt .ondlng Iho ll.lfendllnt tn jail tnlay, although I do
f1rd Il vlulat \llll of IIlfJ I'nltoet 1m fnln ^1JI11111 onler t..,CIlUle of that CUl1duct.
The Ct,/\U't dheelll thill the IlOferdilllt shall at /Ill t1111!' In lhe futuro
cu,,'ly with ttlll t'rllled Ion ffuII MlIlIItl Ottler, md till' 1.lllng hill 110W stvJ\ll<l
tlll vlolAI.. It lllJitln. refJ/1I1I1HI of w"lIlher hB thrOilt.rll1l1 hi. wife, 1I/lW hill
wtre or tmythlnl) ollie InvolVing htll wife, If tho lllller Is vlllllltl!d he III
lleftnltllly 111lnU III gn III lnll,
Uy till! (hut, t\(trold I!:, tit_ly, 1',,1,
n _ t'I March <14, 199'), C'nll'U1Wl!lllth'" l'IIt ltltlfl for II 1I.lu'lng 11!1 ChilflJl" of IrKllfllCt
Crlllllllfll (""'t<<*",I, ,11111 Onler ot Courl, tiled,
,\Nil tU." Ihl. J4th (tilY ot Moneh, 1'1'1"1. thl, C(lI.Jtt "lIrtlfllll ttl/lt Hili
(It I/)(,jll;ll;l ',""pllllnt h,lll Ill!ull ..w....r Iy ~'IlI1jII.tCll' /lid &,lotH Illll.l. and thelo I.
pnA..,bll! ('_II fot tlM> 111"\1/1111'. or "nll:.... III ,.tjflJljldeflltltifl nf Hili llHlld_t
,...JlI'ul....v"lIh.. I~t it IW, il WNtlllWl' I" IIW.\/fJJ IUI 11/1/. N!l<;:1il1' of tllll l.f.nwII,
'IHemS l':. IWJC4tWl.
It iliff d'lIhrl\illlt I. lu,...d d\/{JuIJ I1lJ.t'IlIll thllt/ll)\!II/j/ h.lIlr., thll doflffKltJll! I.
lu I" blt)\l(Jht 1"'''llli,llulv IlI'{Olll HViI {".at, U ,..1 f.>l"d rturlrnj {.'nurlhlll!W
I.JllUI, lhlll dl.{~dafll 'II II' III la~./I '0 H.. .flTridt 1l1lllflt'l )lllll.... AId hlU
I........ 'fl,
~
e"... Nil. 1I'i,;nU Clvl t Ttll III , Nu, 40'i lIun llIlI'i
!I 1/ 1KI1 I 'IfIIIWtIl I 10 II.. 11,,14>11 ..t CrllfIllIo1l I'I"'tt1lw.. 1\1111...,,,..,.., I'lth.r "".."rll.y
I...to,,, th. 111IIt{ if'I .1".1 In. IIlIiI ,lotl.,d<1"I I_ d1l'1l1l1>l1 '0 ''1I.'''M ''''OHI 11110
(',~,n AI'fllnl"lr"I..r I'll It... 1''''11 01 II.. ''''"1 hllll'l4'Ill. litty,
'..tf!l.....II! t~ ft r 11,"1 I" t.... ,.,I,'.....f11....1 'IV tul ,,"..n...y, It II. tt..lliInrlllnl
ntll,..I atfonlll!l 1,II""'!lV. "'(of, ,lIJfp_1 (4110 \WIll ,.. 1".\lJlMWI 111 r.,lr.ltlltOI
1111 .IIo'.."I.tfll, TII" ""_!illtIIf,I III .,.,. 10 I.. '141'''''''11*'11''1 Ih.. frllll .hatyu
1l1~l(6li'lfl"",I I.. Hlttl,
IIy II. "((1' I. 114111\1111 1;:, lll..,V. I'.J.
III Aflf" lO. I....'i. Old.., I.t (',("I. tll"..,. III ~I lksaflllu l\lllt "-I to CtJfIl'ha"
h...IIJI",Y
!,Nt) lOt. Ihl. I III II It/tV .., Aflrl'. 1'1'1'1. U.. 1'0"01'11<"1 hUll AtIUlHl I.,ull,',.
""", ''''lllrlll t',ldy. \Will I.. (".,tlllI*'" \lflllI WtIIIf*IIII\ny, N'Tti 16, 1""", III
"1111 l,.m. Thl' (11\111 ,'lrto4.'tll II.. It.lio,daftl r"'IAIII In ,."IItlntV YIIIIl U* 1"'/'IrlluJ
hI 1"11'1..1001 ,(, ,"M It.lllil,
Ity II. (~(Irt, Il4u"l,t!;:, nt....IV, 1',.1,
S'l II AfIl'II ;II, I..... Tr"")II{'rh.1 ,.t I'n"".IIII'lIJI', tlIMI,
14" III *V I), I<W'I. (inltrr I" (.""111, flhd, III lItol 1,.Ur..'1 Cr\1fllfllll ('onl""".t
Nil! ".., Ihl. 161h ,"'Y H' AJ,rll, 111';'\, I, Itllll.'IIIt1, tlI111 tt. r"hlllAnl
1.Jilllly fot l"IU'IoOI.'1 (<rlJliIMl "~;fIh.lf.1 ,., tHill, 11(1 ht ""Ie'll'4lll III Clm.rlAnrl
t'wMV 1'r1I1\J/' 'Ilf ill '4IIrlHt h' 'hlly'U",. I'laV.. ",.1 t. .t.all '* utVtltl f'1..l\t
'~I It... ..ltNe ",il~ll" tn", ^"lfll HUh, ''''''I,
II. IlWtY t. 1"(0111I1 wllhf'l4t flnllillr lIffltrr {" Itile (tillrt Utnl ..rvlrl\l It...
'..nv'llV4! Itwill In lAI\, \'J'.l/l Ult...- hI'" ,..tIN'" , lHrto('l IIIAI t. "t "II
Ilu", III 111/1I till III. IHft"V wllh It... 11.-1(1/1" h"l/iI on1 ItU..,t 1{.fIII IIf thll
'.Hltor. 1'1.. ('<lIilt tunl"'r ,1Ir.flll Ih,,' I. ,,,'( II.. r~." (it pl'f-.cUllI"I InvolvlHt
IlIlhl_ ,~_,
tit .,
tif.
tn
IlIi,.
Ity It. ('fllll t. IliIr.. 1<, II. 1ii1...1 y. 1',.1.
",. ~l """ l'i. 1M, {itfltrl, flIMI,
ANI! "'''' H.III .1'\11. ILlY p' 14ny, ,,,1,'1, Ntit h'/lM hI t.fililV \lflllllell1 IIIIIWIt 10
"11"".1 If! """'M ........11,
tty Hill ("".ft, It.lwll' It, lOt_Iv, 1',,',
h~ """ J'i, 1M. ,..t.ln. ,.f ~i"'" Ii lliIIl,
14<.1114' lit '..I"-IV \1"''''1 "..., IhtIM -., ~'IlIflVWl. l"h'f1l'latt1 ....."'. 'Wlilld,
I""...,.,. "'1.~I. I" 1/. lOlli_nUl ('{lInl hI "'"..,IV4IiI.. In", "1lJ h.tull!fll or
"""'1;<'118 lllt.....d In thill, ''-'''Ilr '</i At" H ...., '''WI,
IIyI WI 1I1..~ li.~IIfI,I, -'1iiI1,
,p Ilfny H, I'"", 'w" 4()'1 Hill; ,'I".' ,.....i.'....1 1'1' ",'{..'I", ~lIiH hI' "^
~1 .1".. I, 1M, t~.ht. ,.1' CI~.fl. tll.... If' 11Io' 1'11, Ii,A,I', IUI"I
Mli 14", ,1".. Hili !1.11' ,., 14M, ''''''I, ,..4IH'I 1~"'II,q t....". ItiIl''''\I'''' tl1ll1
<lh ",.-1 1(.. 1_' 'A,"," III II... ...."'..~'''f.II......1 1/(,111", 1\ III 1If1t1tr",t lI/d
,1l.",'I..III.H It... '''l"..II",,1 ,,,,It..llli tija. 10"" ""* tHql 11'''JIi q I~"'M'I..
..1'.'......111 '" It.. "..,.....,,, 1111.,1,,11_1 h' '" Ii... ....,.....1, 1'.1111II' wUII r"hnli/"...iI
." rill'( .I~I",.",V .....I'"f1h' f" ,f/.'t ,.;1.. I.t IH.n, PI.'1' II... 1',,1111I. ,,' U..
'1f1.dirlf'\ ,,. 0'1,1 ",* I. ,,,,..~'iI ..utilI. t,.,'If#t'/j 11ft ,ltf'!.. H... 1~.ln wH~ I"""".....
"." II... "'1"'''~ '.... ,......t1I ,.hf/.IH.....I,
"" .hJfw", l'M, 1.".,,'I>w /;1111,_,,1 lot ""'IIIOHI C''''l.i4V.' lot '(l~......l, '''.1.
....'1 ..,,/,H.,," 1I,.HiI"', """I, "., h,tit.
"1 ,M. U, tm, if.;,'....' If. Itlll It'iil,l l'I;'l. _
..../1 ,,,~,,14 ;'" ;:;......It, t",I,
'i' ""'t Iii, 'ljIfl~ "'''~ -ii'" Hi""., t.. ih;0, If,IH",1 1.~H"'f"., n..'",,,
1"'4 .l-'"t.'I"" .t,~" t...JuJ..*.
"
\\ l\~.t t'1~i'''
"...""""..,,,,,*
'tW~"";""'-+"~
. ,.,);,.- "'--"~...._..
);,-"
"'"
t""\
!.AURA E. DAUOIl"A",
Plaint! tt
IN Tltll: COURT or COMMON l'UAIiI Of
CUMftr"!.AHD COUNTY, PkNHMVLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION . LAW
I
I
t
I
I
I
t
v,
NO. Iltl- ~ '11)
CIVil. nit"
THOMA' IC, !'AVOIlMAN,
p.tlndAnt
PMOTreTIOH FMOM ADUlk
Tnr.WORARY ('ROTBCTIVU ORl>HR
AND NOW. thl. ,:f!:!j dlV of t.l\N~.~, lit!)!),
upon
con.lderation ot the within I'.t: IHon /1M YfiQn OmHno thllt
'etition.r 1. ln lmmedlat. Ind pr...nt almllr Qf abu.. tram
R..pond.nt, th- followhHI T'IIlI'grary protlcelYI order I. Intlft1llt,
"e'pond.nt i. herebv ."jolnea trom phv.tallly Abu.lnq
,.titioner or pllolnq her In t.lr of I..t".nl ..rlou. podl1V
injury And t. ..olull.a (HIm 'hill rnldltl"lJl lilt hthioll'" at n
North Mtddleton MOld, c.rll.I'. Cumb.rt.nd COUAty, ,.nn'YlvllnIA
1'I0\), Ind tram thl pl'''. of IlIiplCiVlli.nt (if r.'hlQn.r U WI."'"
.1uUn IIhllk 1101,1", nOI tlurhbyrl,f flk., cult.l', CUlIbllrllHHt
County, penn.ylYAnlA 1101),
Thill Ord.r .hAlt rfl1ll41" In .ff.v. yo\11 . flnAl Or4.r i.
.nund In thllil PUt!, A tlll.uln'4 -tiltH .... IHill!l III lllhl Ilh'Ulif (,II
.111.rvJA.i,,~",", 'II. ,lJ.~\l<ty pf ..t~M~..,", l'lll'l. 4t
,.lLJil_.. Q'chwk e.N. In ';'IiHat,[(,{'1II ffH, ..,....L...-, ('uIliWof'hhfi
County Cuur\t\ou.6/ Q4rllll., t.nn~ylv."I..
1'11. Hurtll "11i/H../,m 1'1.'w"AitHJf ""~U(i" ~.l',.n",.nt 41lf,l U...
H'IWi..,,, 1'{>\fnl!lhH. r'~UI.I. ''1'''J,,nt,,,...nt IB' .,....4', ~ f'r9Vl<l.,J ,,~Hi ..
1!{'P'1' {jf UWIi l)r~hlr tJ'f ~'@~in.~1 f~r t,..HUl'iIi4!'r Mid fiAY ."!{if",," Hd:t
Onllir \'1 urnt fl." 4~'lf..."t "f 4_'1'41 ""Rh"'" .H~,\.t .<tU"'"
.1
~
i.
51.
i {:
,"""
,.,-,
LAURA E. !JAUOIIMA",
1'1l\1nttrt
IN TUt: COV"T or C()HHOH t'UAII ot
CUHUMLANlJ COUNTY, l'INNJlVINAlH II
CIVIL ACTIQN . LAW
y,
NO. ~!i.. ,11"
CIVtI. TtflM
TIIOM-'lJ I!:. PMJaIlM^N,
Oet.ndant
P"OT~CT(PN 'POM ApU_t:
NOTiCe
vou hAV' b..n .ued In court. If YOy wl.h to d'fend A"4lnat
the olaim. ..t forth In the followlnq fAU", YOY Mue' take pra~rt
aotion att.r ..rvie. of thl. r.tltlon, ord.r ot court And NDt'D~
are ..rv.d upon YOll by appurlnq p.UQMlIy Qf by 1.~i41 QQllnul
at the hearing .clu.dul.d by UIII Cauft M!ll uy J1fI1!lI.ntlnq to illli
Court your de'.n... or obj.ctlon. to the plalme e.t forth 4VAln~1
you. You are warned that If vall fAil to ,10 .0 the p.e. lAY
proc..d without YOll 11M II. jYd1.l1\ont.m/lY b.. .nUt.,t .qAln.' yvll t.y
the Court without furth.r not c. for Any lon.y cIAI.ed In the
pl'Adinq. or for Any oth.r ol.t. ot r.ll.r r.qu..ted bV the
Plaintiff. You mAy 10.. mon.y or prop.r~v or other ft~ht.
important to you.
YOU SIlOULP TAJCE TillIS PAl'llt TO YOUM t,AwnM AT QNel. I' 'lOll
00 NOT IIAVE It. LAWnR OR CANNOT A"OMI> ON~, 00 TO OM T..UJ'1I0HIt l'j~
OFFICE SET rORTIl BELOW TO '"m OUT Wlmc~ YOU ('AN ol'<r Ug"l, IIf:U',
court Aamlnl.trfttor
Fourth naor
cump.rl.na county CourthQul.
carll.l" P.nn.ylvAnt" . &10U
T.llphont, (7"1 a.O"6~OQ
~:~,___c
J
!
Vt-, P-d . \1<\ ItJ d
-\111'<>>'-* ;Ii i ~~
~-t .-,-,;1 1"liI.,l-.-_d ;U.....J
I '1-1;.,1< ~,_l1.i,'"P___.;,j..
1',,-11
.......
(a) On November 14, 19Y4, n..pondent returned to
the marital dwel1inq viBibly into~icated and threw
Petitioner on the 80fa and proceeded to hit her in the
face and punch her in the .tom8ch/
(bl On December 21, 1994, R.epondent 898in
returned to the marital dwelling v18tbly intoKloated
and began verbally ftghting with Petittoner and ktoked
the microwave oven stating that the nOkt time he would
kick her,
(0) On December 27, 1994, Re.pondent went to the
plAce of employment of Petitioner and inCApAcitated
Petitioner'e vehicle. Petitioner CAlled the Mlddle.ek
Townehlp pOlice Department who reeponded to the call
but by the tim. th.y arrived, It..pond.lOt hlld ned the
ocene/ /lnd
(d) Ao. reoult of the.e dt.turbance., the
Newville pollee and tho Middle.oK Town'hlp pollc. have
b.en .ummon.d and hAve 10lUcl'lted their ioabUi tv to
tako action in the aba.nee of . Protective order,
!'l.
Petitioner believe. IInd therefore Aver. that .he will be 1n
111lmediah Ind Ilu..nt all "'JIU' of /lbu.. from !C.-ponde"t ahouid h.
b. porm1ttc/(1 to kilO At tho n.ido'lco or J'4It1tlon.r or pl.co or
o",ploYlll4lnt ot l'otit1onor MId th.U, ht1ttO/lU I. 1n n..4 ot
tllllllodht. .~ Pluto 11fotIH:ttO/l troll! CIU<:/l ..bu..,
-J-.t;.
"HJ4;1 t 'IHI\;
II,:;i''ll$lt lfI t~"
11 ".... V'.""1 !lotH".
! c1"j"b f'.)j.4'_;.I!."""
""It
,""'
^-
WIIEREf'OIlE, pUUllllnt to the provision. of tlu. "I'rotuotlon
from Abu.~ Act", 2] PII,C.8. S6101, at .aq" al amended,
Petitioner pray. thllt your 1I0norllbla Court qrllnt the tOllowlnq
reUef'
(ft) ^ Temporary Protective Order requirlnq
R..pondent to rerrllln from abu.lnq Petitioner or
plllclnu Petitioner In fellr of abU" And r.qulrinq
R..pon\lt<nt to refrain from IIbul1ll\1 Petitioner or
plaolng her in fear of abua. IInd orderlnQ Ile.pond.nt to
.tay away from the place of employment or Petitioner,
(b) The .ChedUllnq of a hearing In Accordano.
with the provl.lon. of the "prot.otlon frOm Abu.. Act"
and, atter .UQh hearing, the entry of an Ord.r, to be
In etteot tor a period of one year, requiring
Il..pondent to retrllln tram abu.inq petitioner or
plaolnq her in tear of abu..,
(0) Dlreotlnq .uch further reliat A' Iuthorl.ed
undar S6108 ot the Aot Inoludlng dlrectlnQ ....pondunt
to p.v Patltlon.r tor r,".onable 10.... .uff.r.d ,. II
r"ult ot the ,bu.., Inoludlnq, mediCAl, dental,
reloelltlon And movlnq ukpen..., coun'.llny, 10.. or
earninfJ' Dr IllUp.lort fwd othn Qut.ot".lofJkllt IQ.... tor
In'urlu. au.talnllu and flld.onabl_ attornllY f.lI./ and
.J.
,""'"
""""'
Bl mill..... Il HIC1\J1<N
(~lfffMli'^t.111 01" l'tmlYLVr.NI^1
I x . !Nl'Y (W CLMut:tllNlll
In 1t1O (;<"Ifl of CU"'"' "IOlllI of
('UI1llorlllnc:l CXlllnly, I"nnllylvantn
Nu. 'I".nn Civil Tenn
1'l"'.lfllry t'rot!let tvo order ,...)11<'0 IJ/d
Ivl It 1m for I'rnll\'ct lve orner
l,tlH II I. 1~~Il\lhf"'n
va
'I to ''''Ii I. I ~lll\lhfllVl
~,' ,,,_~!~.;lfnt 1... t'lnk, Kr,
. WJ<m~)r lX!fluly 8/loritf of
('UlblrIAld Coonty, l'ennaylVllIl.tI, WhO tl(ll1l11 duly .\IKlm acconllng 10 lllW, .ay..
'MILlO lIl:llVl'Id UlIII within T~rary 1'fl1tClCtlVll Oll'er ""1t!CO Int
- 1'r'o l~nv' onler
'V>fl _Thw.- f., !,\QUll'.fIWI , 1'hl!! dofeldMt al . '!1)0
l'vl it Ion for
o'clock
.~!.~_.M. mT I IICIQl, on IhliI
.1.I'L.I~~,rl c...... lC"...t, CAr 11.1.
;n
day of .IMuary
, 19 'J'l lit
-
,eumterland COUnty,
h:hllllY IV/ilfl III, by /Wldwg to 'fmmy Blen/nu, /lllIter (If Thull(II e;, !,\Quglman
.,_".1.
-
/I 'n. Nd aUett'" IXt'Y of thtll~~1:~t~~ ~I~o;tlve ~~., "'-'Ut'ti Mlt "'t It 100 for,
",.\ tit the lit"" till. dirClCtlllQ her aUentlOO to 1m coot."t. 1t.,lOt end
II'" "Nullp. 10 P1I/d- .rdo,...1 IIl.reollt
"I...rlff'. CoIItl.
1(Il;l!4JUllg
~IVJC"
I\ft14i1lYH
~iUnTku'"
14,00
.~ II(l
lOti
10 ""'wenll
, ,..>,51
~ ,,Yn,,;j.*. .
.,. ., ~....rl4
; t
I ft, ~~ ~lln.; Ihfrlff
~--
trt;~~7!4~~
!>\otllfi Ilfd llutolWr n.d tlJ bllf(u. If.
1',1" "~I!_d4lY (It<~~1~''"_
i'l ,'\ 1\,0,
"'. ;;O""*'i''''''''
~l.jty ~h'r1tt
'1--:.~,{;'''"t}lui;~,w.'''-ry.A', ..'.
J'((,~h'lll. iJJY
\\
/'"'\
f~'
l..AURA I. BAUGHMAN,
PlaintUf
I IN T'II COURT or COMMON PLEAS or
t CUMBERl..AND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I
t
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
t NO. '0-270 CIVIL TERM
V.
THOMAS I. BAUGHMAN,
Defendant
IN REt PROTECTION FROM ABUSE
ORDER or COURT
AND NOW, thi. 2~th day of January, 1"0, tho
Plaintiff app.ar.d with coun..l, Wayne F. Shade, I.quire. The
Detendlnt appeared without ccun..l. 80th plrtie. have
te.tifild, There hI' bien no dlnial by Mr. oauqh.an a. to the
alle9ltion. .Ide by hi. wite, and, theretore, I do find that hlr
t..timony i. credible and I tind that the Detendant hI' abueed
hie wite within the .eanin9 ot tho Proteotion From Abu.. Aot,
Thl court will .i9n I proteotion order when lubmitted
by ooun.el tor the plaintitt. The court turther direota that
tha Det.ndant pay the tilin9 coate and any other OOlt. involv.d
with thil proce.din;,
By the court,
, ,..1,
Wayne r. Shad., I.quir.
ror the Pllintlrt
Tho... r.:. ..u9hNn
Pro Ie
IUh
\1---
~
~';
.
~+~r
JJ
t ~i
t t.,
~ ,,5.
~~! f
.
..
51. ~ u Z ~~ "1(
.-
'.,
~,
y,
III Till' COlJIl'l' Of COMMON I'Ll':Ml 01"
CtlMPfML^ND COUNTV, 1't:NNSVLV^NIA
CIVil. ACTION. LAW
NO. 9~.~10 CIVIL Tt:kH
t'/W'I'IWTION fHOM APUII';
I,MJIlA l!:. MUQIIMAN,
rldnt tf f
'rltoMAII I. ..AVOIlMAN,
D.f.odlllnt
I'ROTUCTIVB Qlwmt
AND NOW, thl,'l ~ dillY of .hlnuuy, H19~, upon
conlld.,.U"" ,,~ tl,. Con.lllt. Mrnr.\t!lnt uf t/l. plltt.l.., th.
fQllow'n~ oralr 1. .nt.r'~1
1. O.hodlllnt 1'IIOH,\,* 1:. /lAlUIIIM^11 hI Qnh.ud to nfr"ln from
atl\Htln4il 'l.lnUre l.AUkA 1':. PAVQIIMM or pli\clnCJ h.r In f.Ar of
.\:Iu.. or thrut.nlnQ hllr.
J, p'f,nd.nl II or~.r.d to r'ffaln from h.r...lnCJ
VIAlntlff, 'l.lntlff'lI r.lallY'. or tht p.r.on. with whom
,111ntlff i. working or r..'dl~, lnclu~lnq dtrlotl"CJ
QQllill\unh,l.' ".l/ll, botll oral Anll wd Utn, tll ".r.
3, O'f.odAnt 11 In1(11n.d frPIll fflurh'9 1'1l\lnUft'lI plaCI of
uploy.."t It W..h.." /HuHn 8UAK Hou.., UO~ Harrilbllr9 Pike,
cinU.l., C\llll"-rl4ilnd Coullty, fIInrlllvlYitnll't nOll.
... Pllhuutl'tnt hi {lflhlu,t t.(i ..Ul' AW"" from t1HJ r..td.n"l or
~lAlfi'lrf ., '1 N~rth Hlqgl.tpn ~~,,~, CArli-I., CY~b.rlAnd
CPYfitv, '.nn.yl~AnlA 110ll, l'tnd ffQffl l'tnv r..ld.net WhlQh
~lAlntlf' ~V ..tapl'Mh ror n.l.,I, In th_ tutur..
_. Thlf QfQ~' an.lt r.~aln In .ftliiQt for... p.rlod of on"
y....,.
1/;. 'ft~. Hr.'ft'" MllJi.nllhfJ 'fmlfl~MJ' t'Q 11.;:. ".'lA1ftMllt '*1'14 th.
..~44hHM;~ l'~,..MJ; t-Plh'. ti.~ut",.r,t .oH ."{I~I 1;;. pHwl,ltI{l with lit
(,3
'-,
,-......
copy of th1. Order by coung.1 for Plaintiff and may on fore. thla
Order by arr..t for 1ndlrect criminal contempt without warrant
upon probable cau.e that thl_ Ordor haM bu.n violated, whether or
not the violation I_ committed In the pro.enco of a police
offioer. In the event that an arrygt I. mado under thl. .ection,
Oerendant ahall not bo taken to jull, but Hhall be taken without
unn.cu..ary delay b.rore the Court which has I..uect thl. order.
When thu Court is unavailable, Oerendant ahall be arraigned
b.rore a Di.tr1ot Justice who .hall .et ball according to the
provi.ion. or Chapter 4000 of the Penn.ylv~nla Rul.. of Criminal
I'rooedun. -\ \t..!' ( (.' \ ... ~ '\~ ", I /lq"I. {,,,Jdl..l.l j t" ~ "
\ It C\I''''I.,\U,',,-'
..' rl .. rll'<' " ,\", !ly the Court,
1m
-....,
Wayne r. Shad., ~.qu1re
Attorney for Plalnt1ff
Thorn.. E, aauQhman
Oefendant
(If
,
:lfll.",,,,,,;,,,,,,,,, ,,,,I ,I,."" ~ $100.00 ji
NHI UJUH 1\i,,'~'N
i ,,"'ld'I"'~ ,,1 /Id"l-.I' ''''''14 j'f,;" "'iij~ 4l1'1Y ",I I,U1I11 .,.hr.ll i",,-tlflUtf! i ,
I 1..,),.,*"," tiIIi.A;~:"_ Ct. ftn t<<1. 1
",!tj'r.t,onl hi nnl;;nd 10 n.tr"tin fft.n har...lIinq 1'"lflI. 2.9.\I!\@ 11130 ~ CillO, Co. Courtholl "
1'1" "1111, 1'!.,I"t1tf'. r~l..t V~ or plOJlJOI f " I
wtlll wl~," I'I"inllft t. ""Irking or l"\4ldlnlJ' I" lill,,,,"~,"IMl~'" LJou..
I'II'IIOIII'\J llln.ctlnlj IJUflllllllC'Ilt!OIllI, both Clr<<llllnd 1I...~;,,,..t'IU""IIi~lu.,.I.......I_'..t\l!f..,
w,lll",", to IK'f.
t jll, U.. ,"""'olo.,. kIf.. I""'" '" "","'I.,.",,~ "I
, .....~2;nct ~ ".~
I .
: J. ~~ "" .uJ fL!::w "~..tltt
......-.-~~~_ ,w'_....._
WI "" U/oj/.,HtKiIlltII, .._I...... _.,.,..... _....." ItoliII .......,... 'II. .,", ......II
(:UffunU'iW..ith uf ,.,*i'.f~,.,tNt.... ~ ~ ......,...
In RIVUtll 1101 fOR BAIL CONDITION'
CllllIIICAlION 0' lIA11
ANO t)lllCltAlHiI
':llN
. "l.1'."'f..'., ',"
T}l{Il!ldl1 r .ltd\Jqll!ll1Ht
1fJ';,
(Jlf1 Cd}' 1<IJlJit I
(',If I hdl'
I'A
II(ill",
'i\"'U1lidfhd
. .!I";l
~.H*~h .j6lti.~."",,:." ;*":'!'t6~rJ
.. .ld",tl',:""\' i All'
f 1...IIJI H' tl,lt! ,'''tllwd 1_4 hilll
\ _ i"',li ~'!>I,.;", ,-,,<.;11 tmJt
,",4!.."",I,'II'H;-If('f1Il'_
; ~ I Jr-it" II J, I' ..
llC' ,,,"',,,'. 1.'O[fI" \., tlltothl
;'11 -._1. :t, 'c...."in'.' ..,:1,<:.;,,'.
Ik'lI. 11,,,,,111 I'., 1#_ly, I',J.
APPIARANCI OR 1"". laND
tllll MOlOO " VAIIU 'PI! ,... 111I'11I1 PIll>CnOWOI AlIIO UIIIIIl
lUll "IOU "IOA( P",.UtllK"" Of THI tAl, lliICWPIlIIG ItlII4l
1..\I'u.III0lO VI Alii. I't lllKIIII lOll Will' Of C'"'1()flA1U 011
A,.,.IAI I,MilW Itllll 'III "" tvPIllMt COURT Of lHt UlilllUl
".,U
-. ."
j'" ~ i' I
,
i
,1><11",
,1'11>')'4""
'15.270 Civil
I'.A'! .1,,,1,11',1.'..,
"""'.il '",
Vloldllon at' I'l"^ Onl"r iRHllld
1.27.9',
\1W,.'~,.j~.1 fU...~1
. '''''''01 '4 ...... Wo" ..11I1.. ..- ..Ah.,l'O MV' ..,....
t,"",'IIIl(''''''''' 1...."'....01&11'11
. 'o.II,",',~ 1IlI,.'.. I"".. 'A.......1lI "" ...lot ',",,'CAly .'k'
,.0...... 11'.110",.... I... oltaj_, '....1\(11"016.01'
. lIt"lIl C""" ftouI ""'''''IA '" C;"",", \AoJI'
ll'oIjlAhUl ". AlIlI'It ..IIlU IAlllIOAIll f11O"W,llllIlIlH
'I 'Aifflll I !III1<<1 OIlC "t.A11!;t IHI\!j "4 .flI~ ".IIU
UIIlt,!1 uldH ltIy hlitd Wid U. Dtfl(*~ ~ ul 'hu. (""'.(Allt
.... I)~
"I'
10 1I~ UflltP PNtY'OII l'tllCtNlAO' tA'" .All
'I.., ,,, !f,I>,)'w"A .fl."Jt b j..,,, ';"., filtjlt..Ji, I" Hv k.~ ",4f;,;f'."hb t-ot-lIl,,1 ;j,t\.y .......;;II1!i.ti ii'hptlt/lH. '.'ilol#4i. iW.J ~rlt
i : 'L'., 1> .,j
,;l"'1 4,0:'111-",",
t le.,_". _.d'4".,liot:tii,A fJ!lUwl ',iliri'ii i-tj~w;i.!P1 il., Milt~Ol+:j
I:", ..Ii" :1 ~." ,.tt..4;,;:4:.....1 C;i.J;.i;4t Ji',(f-..iftfi -_~ 'H~'Wti
miP-~"" '''ffi4li>t Ji
#i4! 10'1'. fl"
i J ~rij Ht~ ~1it4t1 HI< '>tH, tAild ;;I ijI~ ""loA ~~:flf,4 4t; k..,**
!~.'. 1!;411:!J-itf1 1lfll~'4!.1
'. i h,"~, i_;!ft:d.c#'-i w4/-j 1$... ~.f.i~_H!''\t:<o:th~..-tlill !jiM knuw 11 ,_
M' /tlf _<#It!J ~,;,u.,'.A
Ii..., ! ..1J;~""'it 'f< i;,.;.It';ltfrJ!'."" ir.. 'Wff~ iIIJj#lt-'1fJlf,
, M-. "'11W1t I'l)l lttAf I AM U QAH' ItUl'ONtIIK, , 011 'HI 'f,/f,~ AIo/IWN I llt I'HI IAIL
Il~""'<"'"
~7/""~
j!,t Aj, I
.1 "t." "'';<;'1'" , +.H htdl ilk ;AiJil
" ";5
';<;i f.-,.-'>'
'i,';;, "'ftif.iJof.)'
I, ',,0 h. I..
fltJ..;,rf"h:IJ
l"
,i ,;.-f< ~'.ft:.<' '.,,, .I.;.;,,., ..-ii;.. ,".'.~
'),01
. ~ II
",,',1' A, ~""!,"'fY,
I ,,'
j, ," .... ",.'t,\~"~t..J'
, I ,
" "~
"';,.lt1~
~ "
'fa..' 'I.j
-.t ,;j;i',iW"!
jl;J"_AA I
'~I;',m;.# hi ).piil, J ~ Ifii'I /1I,JlIJlh/1UI, fIdIf 4If1JfJ4./1' I. 1.l1i.,.
)I.,.~...At~ 'Ii 1'~V;l/JtJTii tN....,"- 1;tw, IJJW:fdHtf ljj I~J ('1 fti6
_'~'Mi;/'flil'#4A,Jhtl)lh 11-. t,;lt!tJ hv WtW I!J ~ &tJi i;tWII.,M>
tlII,-Vt_W "-IY'lf~ ~
I"':" -;". -"
,..t' J'; J /'# t
;{,-'f;#t ".:"Ii<i ,"} ,;';Ih;--"'"
,\,. "" .J'~ J .'". " ,)" It l~ .
" ""." 'H"','i~ ... '\ ,. ....
,,I \_ f V
.~ ~... ~"""~:I~ ~ i ,~".t__
I~
MIOlIIA(
'I...'
''I I:
"
1I11i C.........,.. Ii
_"- tv,,,;
tAIl. l-PHDITIOIIl.
tlll> 'd~,-".... j,.. ~I ."''';:,.i....' h:fl.. t.....,.,. ., ... ,..1.
. -~ -j,;~. ... k' _.e <l.H.. 1ft"" t.;, ", I.. t~ ">!n "...'....f "k" i..
'-11 ~;. "m "" .... h..".' '-", Ii..... ,. ,.t;~tqI'1l _,
I>.t:... ,. ......'" .~ cnll "
'. rl.''''';
I I "'*(l\.;(1;... (I ,'~, !...,.,
. ...0,
IIi.
"
'i.'-; ~ ..,. ;.,
-1\.''',11 ,'" le.r" '.1";' iw, J
i.,
t."'...,~.
I"~ 1,1i"." , 1,
.~, .:
,,'. ..., ~ ',,' '.1 " ""
,I,,~ ,,,.,,,.,, . l..... ."-.K:...;;,. . "'",. ,'~ "'~"r'"
.' 'I .,. e"'" ~ " j !': ~.~ ,~ i;.. ....., l \, >:PjlL.,lf
,11.f .;It, ~!~, f f fl.''''' \I.... ..;.tlt'" ..Ii+..- ii
..... ,",'.ill:, ~"....'f"! "'.t~ l..~.tf
,."" ...,...'",/
I',,. V"~.
.<4'lIi:..j:lj>f ",(it. '.." ,<;..I.",~'( ""1' "~ifj" "tl ., 'Ii'~ '.Ii ,,"'1f ,..;,,,1 ,A
''''~.';''',,,All;i'. f~,. "f,'.J '''',~ H ~'i'Jt....." ~ J.,,....,...., ,... itl" td ."1 !",...,
'",;...,~..".; !,It l ,,,.,., ",;..,1\";,, .1 Yo': "".AI "~"~'..,t.'t. ,_. ~." w ,.<..j,,,,JI
" ".H";,~ .~.,. t, "....,. ,.~ tiT' -'.""0" '''~,:,t f-\fL'lt-;t.-Wltfj tr.'!' ,....
". -';f''' ~.-' .,t."i 1;;>. '" .J4..;"ht-.., '.oj ,..,,; ." ..; , I '."
", t., !'^ ..i ~,ioid( .,,~.! '~"-4'" ~. .~ ;,... ,~?4 'fIl1!,j,,.,. ....,'1111 !h't
','" .~,,~~.., '""''''''''"'' ';0,;'.. ,..",",t,~..t.......;._~d,
"iI,....- ...."I'- -!~o....-n1,~.:-...:J;'1i..".",,,tii..,.,~d__ ,""fl'.'" .Q~
,.4, .;"d", ".;j~"''liq, *:"'.." ,.<4 '... j"-~..,ilt uf """''''...., ill
!." ,..<'-;" H.;.'.~ o,.lJ ...;~...',,'til,_o.'-- "'>i.It, It'k.lI "1 ~"...l"....lC-liiol~
k. -.,;tr .., I, d...."; ,If." ,;"Jtl>". 4l>Ak:!Hll *ll'!f"''' 4 .~., tA.... '....hj .,.~ *lIflli'ft
l..-~. he j,' """"._~.~' 11M,,,, ".., ',,",~NI!-+~~. "J t. #... ''''i!IlIl4'I... /I; .....,... ~ ....,..".
"'. ~'i'l'" 'lit. r";i. i.!I'f!t,. H,.".;jfJ.:t<f.'_ ........,.
,.
.
.,
..',1
I I. I iI,
I.. a, '"
"'1 '-"""fa,
~I'. ",..'tl,..,
~
I ".. ,., J'I 1,.'11rj ,,# III. '.,....~ l~jIII" .~~,
, "I, ",' . t ~I ,U "Ii .',., """"'1I,"" ..~ .j'...,...... .;'1l"!'1II;: 1,_. .. ~., '.. ,F"*"""t"
d ( ',.. .,. I. IfIIIItI...l,.t"'+~"I~"'~'."'''' ~ ,io'>CIj!.,.AI"".'rI';ltI!
j i f..~ 'l~. .~ ",.~ .....;1." l- I,;t. ."':.... .t.o. f-Ol."'lll!l J,., I.. ,""'... 'J!.. l~ lit ,.~, h~'I.,-lI +...
.... t J "'''1' .,1,. ,,' "..~ 1,-" ~""t"... .'ltb#t.......... ......... N !IlftlI....... tlIl ~~,w."'I
,~ bl" ...., .. jt.! ilti..lu'll '" l~,~ ...,.. ....... II "~I i ~'" I. l.. ..
4'1(;;4",,11
f' J l'l~~ t..tt. u\l..." t-f"''''~.'' 0Iwt .. t..._.. ....'1 ..1If'......
lAi ~"'I.''''Il'''It~ '" U""" ..........
.,
CA'" on NOMINAL IAIL IOND
CEnmlCATlON Of IIAll
AND DISCItAIIOE
:o,,~
.
1",,,.11.4,,,,
-
'.;~',
('~t, ,..{;I.' III 'i'; 'i../<l.-'~J"f.~ /w4,,+ ,,~l iI."l1#~<'
111,"""11 F ,Illlullhll,,,n
II,., 01,1 nn" Ilull.t, {'nd hlll ,."
11'''''11..' .",.", 1 lNl......"'"
ltlUfljllli'I'11 iin".lfjt ...1, If ....'rl . .IIOCIOO
[ . I c.tJl~irlllJllk IJ1 fiffhl.... I.".. fl(JfIlIlWti'.u~ .iI WlM' ...."', ,"""III.
1 "f",.I<",1 i. un1KJ...t to I"rrldn fop oo....lfl(
I't..lnl iff, t'lillnt tft'. rulfttt~ (~ .....(1I(Ql
with wl.." 1'llilnt1ff h, Wlntno Uf NIIk1tllQ.
Inclldlll<J dlN:Unr.t CUlIII,,~ttm.. boUt of'lll
"'ftllton, 10 h"r,
. ~.~,'.~~
<.;I ( phil; ioH IJiJkl f'll' ,\If.l
I 1 (.~ In luU jjll....lnt of ~
1 ] .....<.,."1/0 I....' ....
[ ] Ml''"'' 1,.,."..11...
I JtJ.....,""~
Iallool ""'" c"t'!JU!ol t.. J.lllb.L~~,
Jtl(~w :.~ Ii';~,,"*j Att!llt,wl.
1"'0, 1!,tlnll1 1':. "__IY, ".J,
APPIARANCI 0" IAtt. IOND
THlI ION!) .. V.o.uo fOIl lilt UIT... """UOlIIlG. "NO UNTil
fUll A"'D flNA~ l>Ial'OlnlOli 0# tilt (;AH tIIlC\\IOIIIHI fIlIAL
I>llI'OlIrlO'" lIl' ANY f'lflflOli '0/1 WIlIT Of (lllflOlWll 0/1
A'..IAl f1MHY "liD IN lilt tUI'lllMl <<MIll1 01 fHl UMftO
ITAtU
i ,j' !(I'<\I4 '.."
t'-!iAl~1l-'_'"
I Vlul..t Ie., ..f I"'" O""'f 1_",1
t.n.".
1J'\.;!7U ,:Ivll
I 114'1 ,,j fl.-hi-A.!,I
,
i
,
...,u....., A{:'~
;;...nOt/o l,w .' .. Fit.Ol..et. ......'~;l
naUlt, :I....~'Pi., tI'.lll".. .... .~~,~. 0., '0:,,1:\ to.
10 fti:.- ('..Il'" kl (lII1tII
t '......, ....tIlr lIW! ~4 .... tw """.......
IJ lit ... ...... ,1 (r.lW'tillliI .. .....~ lo,
i.....,ni.III......' ......".,"'~".,,-"'-,
. ...,., 01.... hili ... " ~ WlI!i!!IllI.,. ""'"
'*....,...... ~l4fil'4(lI....'j
. """""lIf.........IWIHllfNll......__~w
!IO I!M ~ '*_ _ ""(11 iJI'Illllil JI.tUItUllI
. ""lI ~.., 11.....411' ,... .. '......i
71..... "'"/
-- ;--, ;~',.n ._,.-.,,:-~-,,_ . ..;.~;,-.",.,~.;
.......,.,.,. _.,,"'."^".-"1"""'.... .,..:..~:7...,:.:.,.."'"""_.."".,.,._"'=-~"".",...
~ lit MIIlIt -..~,,...MftIIY ,
1*'_11 HIi .. lilt<< fMit fIMlIlit Yfflt ~fll.
(i.."" "'....." ""'''' ..Ill.. <.............. M"'~.
"""
Al.
1m
III 7~
~ - . ..".-- .----~ .-..- --
WI. till UIilDIM'Kl'-'O ............ oM -v,..... ......._,......,.
(ununuHw".'th .., ,.,UII'-....... .... tlUft t;f
In "1\""" 1t01 JOII tA"' CONOf'1OJIl1
111I': h< .l,;[, '"il,J;;tt' ill.
hi! ';iji; 114Jt
.~J
~. jr.;.~.
ri""~'i..w.
"'''"''"'
...."""'...'--.
"'4' tfbf. ...
I
I
I
I
I
Jf
to \It UIIO OI'4LY 'Oil 1',"eUltAClI (...1t4 tAil
tIlt> \Hdt'f'.'f'.j'It,;J ..llId io ("":-'41., ~!f""/~:j". f,'" I;~ '.....,.,i 'a4oIl'b ~i;#t ~i!{' ~B~~;~ -ft#t,j ~
I l/t,,,tilo;,,j
'-1,,,,11';; 1>1 L,jf.itltiJlI if!,
" II",..*, I~J ..j..ij"~,_" (4 f,lfff-lPiiIf f....,. ~... fl. ...~..
It; tf~, (!'HI!If utll. 'ffl........ t4.4j,;rf' tr!-f('4'iA M t(..~
, I""'.... ~1 "" .... ~ 14 ..... "'''"*1'1 "'" .......
~.. _~.h! Wt~~
. 1'- ,..".",. '/i#ifI,.. ~"i~. </PlI "'... 4 If!
't.. .."'Iiiifhhf.~
. AClI'-OWUOOl lI"'t I AMLI~4" ""~HOlt'HI WU AAI/OiHfI' #H ,HIt fM.
"11I /1JP./IWIINj illluto.J/tlf*Y-hW. ijlilJt,p 1iI~
If hill kiiltjj'p~ f #' fIpi ". 'JWIlJ
.,.,.". j '.,- c., _to ~ ;
_.,.It-,_!,.#J "-!i,vJ'tc ~'-+ Ji-,I@
.i,i.l
''er flA~~.
f i , I
/d }'J I ~\Lf J
,/ ~.'-f ~ I__~ , ~~.".~--" i"""...,..""._:--
,
,
,,,~'-;
..
t' 1.1
I
I
.<,)
4; ~. , . ii,
,
,,4.
,~~,
,
"<4Jj'n>i+"
44'
~..." ...... ,,,,.., "'" -.-..... W ~.... '" ""_
.... </ -"if......... /..............--..., '" _ .... _
,*'- ~~~* ;if4.. '!JiW;.~.,. ~ 1H ~ ~. ....~...~
!FN;:-<t~ "..ii..~iii&#!~'
'ficfi'J;1O ........
1"
_i:"
;'-'.i~' -'_'~;'-' iti4f{~;.~(~\
F
~. ~ .~ ~~.. .-"~',4I- ~~ ~ .,.;~;:....
.
.-
.'
"
.-
( 'IIMII,J\[ (( 'MI'I AI'"
II'OIlC( ,
ICOUPlA'NT NUI.I8lA IVfAll
CU'llf,.J..il-11 Numb." If Olhlt' J'a,lu1l..nt..
fYIlI"- NUWI.Il '
(lIIlHICl JUIllCl
IolAOISUHIAL DIIlRICT NO
A tH; 3fJ~
0,o6_~JUCRNO:----llmr-' -.=.----
I, rTU1NlllHlill.'l\!.;::nm;;,r..lAIHlll. 1
,.1 Tlll,.HIPlIUIU.Dlf.ll.lLlCI Dll't.,..l.A..OUUllIL.
( J,wlll JI'/,"mIfH#II'.''''f",.,.,.~~;r,.'Ji''''''t"",,J1I~k''''l
~
M<<l
Af~ll4r B~
COMMONWeALTH OF PENNSYlVANIA
(ll./ l N1W.t VI.
r
T1IOM.U I lAU<llllWf
I6J OLDOAP aD
CAlLIILI, PA 17013
"IHI '-20-60
I" 164-'2-1lI13
IHlA
All A
".. h<l.h~ ".,.
III (!J 1.,,"Of 110. '~Il" ",nltd ",\,"111"1. 1I1k' hI" I' ,h. ..ldr... Wi 1..lIh .11.." "I.
o I ",n", Mil 1I111l~klu,1 11100" nlln" "uII~n...n '" Ill' ""11110.. Ii 11...."11',1" __,_.__
.
A
o till n,,~n.IIl' ", ,,"pulll II"I,"'lh," It un~n,"'n III m. .nll. Ih'lfh''', I 10,.. 11"1'11'1,11 him h'rellI ,t Jllhn
1It", .."10 1",1.lIn, lllll JIlIn,II,.., "' 110. ('umnl''''....lIh II' l'vlln~~h.nli al _~IG~m1I!.._.._" ...
JHILUAMIIIUMQ-llU.. ._____._ ____ I !:-"".' "'.....' ',. ..
MWlJ.1IU!ll/ImI!fU , In ..,tOOJ"'^liID _ ('l'unl~ 11/1 ", ,""ul fUII.I.lW 2 l>>U,_tlU~l!R~__...
1'.II"""o"h WrI.I"''''......,..,..,'"'." ,.........,_..... _,., ...........'~.,.....~I THOMA. It IolUCllHAM
i
i
121 II" O~h ~'''lImlll.i1 PJ IIot IIfcu..d ...r" (!) INIHUCT CIllHIIlAI. CONTEHI'T
Till'. IUlyg,.IlANT VIOLATlD THI '1I0nCT10" raoH AIUn OIlDIl NO. U-270 CIVIL, 1I11U!D ON
./ANlJAIIV 11 I9U n JlIDOI HAIIOLD ! IHULY. tHI DIlFltNDANT DID CALL THI VICTIM AT HU
nAt:r. Ot lC41'u/YMINT AND THUATlNllD HIll, THI DIFlHDAIIT 1110 TILL Till! VICTIM "HAT l'
.Ut; lltll NOT CALL IUM THAT HI WOIILD IlO .000ITNINg THAT IHI WOIILD llaUT '&.ACINa HllR
1M fr.Ai,
.11 11\ w~llh w.r. ,,'inti 1M pfln ."d dl'''"~ I'f I'" flllll_ll'ullh (II "'nnl~IYI"11 .nd ClII1lrlrr. leI Ih. A4'1 "" A"'lhhl~.
.., 1ft ~".I,IIIln \.\ ft.~~~.lIII '~M'~Z;;j""ij of th. ~II,I ::~\:~:~~=;UItli.I.~--...flW__
III t h. ~-~ -;' - 1~-_~.r-:~t'~'~':,~F::~.~'7&~ UNin.m. uf r1>;:~.o'ht-:-;"i~~..~:':;><'~-~ -7'f':O-'C~1[_'~: :Y;,,:-~.',ec(':~~\/;"'-_c:"'~~-: ,!t'c :_;~:;-___c." -..~,,-"-'
llf~I",J f~ Jill.....'
j II I ,"k 110,1 , "MII'1I1 ,I{ ,H"I "' II WIII"""'I It. j~1I lIIMI Ihll' IIot "nu..1I It. lfl/uI/.1I III .lllWtl 110, dUll'"
, I...~ mol'"
14/ , 'I/ifl Hull/;, \...11...,1/.."" III IhJI 1"11I"""111I' HlHIlIIMI III/III' 'H Ih.t ,...1 III m~ kill"'''''',' ,., 111"'''"''(".,
.,..j 1"llOt/hi' ~wt'Uf..tfI f. 1tIA44 lIf"I~I' ", '1Itt lIf/lifllll' ,./ ~II",,,, .'HM ur IIl.t ('(IIJl(' ('v.u "K I'll (' ,
, 4'/lU, ,.1,1",. 10 _.."'" fJU4ih,,'wJfl 1<, ,,,,,,,,,,,,'It'
,1~l.L."n.c " U,.,.
..~~~,~.
'''I. "II\l1t .", .... ...., ,.. t. I..,,,tl ,... ..-1"..'" h. ...m rh'fll'llt """pit"" ,""
....i ,.,1 .,~I '''01 ''*'11, ""........ UvOt It" .....ltiot. ..t ,....If"
, .~ { .~'~:' ~h-"'~""ifPj;~F;i ':-fl" ".
ill>fff'~r....H.it#1
- ? f"M;4,4';i';'fjj-'~-"--
.,_.__._._",..1 M:A I I
... ~ ~ ...
II
CIlIMINAI COM!'I AU"
\pOlICEI
.. tvpe" "liUMilln-
COMI'I"'1I11 NUMhtil run
COlllplalnl HUfhIiJl" if Olhll' 'l.utuIIHlIlI"
IOfN~'. ..
.11 or \lhlth \leI. ."""llh. I'f~' Ind dj."Il~. "f I~' (lIIIlll1P1l"..lth IIf "'nn1th,?llllld. .~onlfll~ I\II~ "'I of Allfrnlll~.
01 in ~iolllilln of ""ll(t~;~;:i"{##j;"i 'nd{'~i!';:;;;;;:P' (If the A(llIf ::':'A~:iA~tOIi.t.tF""w.U.t";';;'i;;~
01 the Ordll1lnn of .............. '. ..,..., ..,
N/Jl'Ji'''~''1
(II I ..k Ih.1 1 \lIltl111 (If 11,.-1 IIf , lumrnllfll II. i"\I,d In" Ih.1 Ih. 'HUl\lt.I Ii, "qulI.d III ,nl"''' the ~h'I'CI
I h.~e IIIld.,
IllS1I1ICl JUSIICE
MAOISlflllAL IlIS1IIICl NO.
1..Ne.lllt.NT. ".UMbIA 'IU.. ell..N.O.
. ~'06:,,".. ".
I......
COMMON WI Atlll 01 PlNN!lYlVANIA
; ~ Il ',"A', I VI'
I.
I'Tw lI'JIJHIi UU/'L .....
I \Imil"l Jtliulll.1
t"f.f..ll.
Af~fl
fi.lll,if it- ~I~t
flOUJ r. UUCIllWl
16' OUXW 1Il
CAaLt.LI. r. 1101'
111"/)-20.60
.If 16.-52-Un
lIA.l.lljll I
01
I
ll1i. HIlllIl.Ukl TWI' rOl,ltl fllPf I'A-(llll)!IO
it t..A
A~ A
do h('ld') \1 il h.'
II' l!l I .,n"" Ihe .t""e IlaI1IC,I,lch.".ldllI, \lhll h.cl ~I Ih~ 1,ldrc.. .vl f,lIlh Ihole ill.
D I ilnll'C un lIIdl,'duul "Illllo(l I1lmt II un~nu\ln tll lilt hUI \lh,' II d~.\nh~d ill
t
~
~
i
,.
,j
.~
D hll nldnu",~ ,II 11lIpulin dl'll.nallun I, U/I~lll'\I/I 111 mc Mnd, Ihelr"'I.. I hult "c.i.n.led him herein AI Juhn
I>..e: \lilh II,.lulin. Ih. "'/lullu\l1 ur Ih. CUl1l11111Il\lfUllh ,II' '''nlll~IIMII'. ut 1'"11 WUTlIIN SIULI".
I~O} NAllKtsDlIlW I'tKll r1V,.,' flJW".I\..ho(I,I...../
I'Jt/llLr.s.:X WWNIiIU' 1/1 Cl1~UIU..llilJ ('U\lnlt IIIl UI all,'ul nULl.UlY l. l!ln, 01551l1ClI
I'." klpan.. "CIC /1/,110.. ......,.....,""....","',,1........ "'.... ~l<Pl1".. III< ."..",J.ho"'''''h,I...1 TIttI\lJ t: lAUC.lIiMAll
(2) lhe .e1' t(lllIlIlilt'" by 'h, Ic~ulfd "frt: 0 UlllllltCf '.UUNA\. t.'OJII1'~PT
Tllf, Jlv.rf.Hr.lA1lT YJOLAtlf.lJ Till l'i'lTf.C'I'IOtl '10M "'11" filii.. NO, lI).ol1U CIVIl., IIIUrll 011
Jo\lIl!AU J1 I~n IV JIIP<l1 1WWl.D r. /lNnLY, fill 1IU'~DAJit IJllI CALI. TIIII VlCflH AT HII
rl.ACr: u. ItIofrWfIoIIllT A.III) TllhATkIl11l Itta, tlltt onilfttAllT DIll TtIJ. tlll Vl(''TUI fll4f l'
bUt OW "llT CAJ.L 111M ttl.\T III WO\IIJl DO ~I1'IlIHU fU., 1I1lt; Wl>UIJl rw;ur 't.ACfIlG ilIA
IIf flAil. .
14/ I .rllll' IhMI Ih, f'r" 1\11 fllrth 'n Ihh wmplullll .rt trn, I/ld ,"nnl iii Ih, 11,.\ III III~ .lIu~I,d., III Infn(//lllhlll
.n,1 helle'lh" ~.nfk.liml " m.d, '\llIl,\1 In Ih, "'/lalll.. "f ~\liufl 4V(14 Ill' Ih, (',illl" n'd, (1M I'll, (', 8,
I 4'J04) lel.\III, \(I U/I''''1//I f.I,lfl~.tllIll III .ulhullIl...
fkllWAlll a
,1'1.,
J i'A"''''~'
-..,-"'--~( ~. ~-/{i~lr,r/tf~';'IJ) ~-----~-"'---=-
^,,-Il NOW, 11/1 I hl\ lht. , 1'1 . I \frtlft lh, "'llIpl.illl h., b,'1I l"I'I'4,1t wrnpl.ltt.l 'lid
~N" It" ."" ,".1 Ih~ff I. pwh,hl., nn... IN '''UilIIU III Pill"'''
""'TIT;;,u"..",;,Jf1;i"illl
In^l.~
~
('WIt HOI
YO\! A..t COMlolAlilOfO to "".AM lI(r()llt
I.II<fDlIIW>HfO AT
", -:~~=:=>:~~===]
HIMCI OI~"
.......Il\i..... ""1,,,1 *'I ",';,1,,4 1#".1, '.'WI1 '''Nil l'UIloO,lfo,1.
'-#\. ;!>f \h) uf
\If
;~-ri~h'/-
.... .. ..'.,..........'w ~lfIo',.~ !.,..~ 1..... ......'." ifi "'- ~ ~t~ "'A_~ \i;o
No"" _i'OW f... ... ......., ... ".... ,~ ......'~. ... ~~... oIi ~<t'" ~
... flto....11 ;~ i.~1 ",',f.-'" tI.-,l \AI,,, "'.. .... ~ ... #K~P4;r.ll,../~ ....... :;"-,wi; Qr.Ji'
".... '"... I.,.,......lw<l tot " 1....1,.. ..'r4' ;ff9 (,~" ~" . ....1'.. ~ __..
..~... I.......'" ~
\,':-"';"#';',,','lr f'H."t'~" ~~1)\'t1t'd j~ ,...-
~-it'V f4
'<;--"-'''''~_"'f,?:.~_~~
",~"",...~_.,,,,,-~~.<..-,>,,, .
"..,.it ,~.;'i,
; !_~.. A.t !
'~~7ffil.i"'~'
Wi.J!tttfiWr.li'dm; I
.,,:;j"i~ .t,,'lif"1d
. ......".'"
CHIMINM. COMI'i!JN f
'''O~ICfl
IC~lINl~~ . .lvr~:~"~,:~,.,~.~."
(....,.J.,'" ......,1..'. U Ill"., li.'IIl~..",I.
I
lwclOM NUUNII IJCIlIlO. . IOTN
L.......IJ .- L_ "'- _ --
OIITflICT JUIIfI(;t
MAllI811RlAlllIIlIIICT NO.
A Be 'Hl4
,.--."" ,. ~', -
COMMONWUllll 01 "t N~4bYl VANIA
11ft' 4 ';'" , Vii
I. flla liUlU I~,. 114PioU 1
r~~.. 'J CPt~<# f
,.1 Tlfl .nUULUll TV' maGI N" ',t..{lllU\o
'''''.11
....;J.
hi..JUt: ';';"
1'llOKU I MUGtN.I
,t) (I{.l.)Gll' lit
c.w........ r. mil
V/III-....O
.., ....n.,,,,
ftii"
." .
II" h~lCt't ''''Ie
I IllJ 1.111.., Ih, '''1'1, ",111'" 1I,lrll""'il. .'llIl1.u .11!;f """I'" ...",,,Ih "h"H '"
.. 0 I ''''IU.e '1' ""I'\I.luIIII""" """If " Ii"\ 1110;; II I" ,... t;~1 ..".. I. "~"I,".il ..
J
1
~
Ol
[J '"' l1il~I1'III' '" ""llul., .Jt"'.III1Il.... to Iillh...R ,.. 1Ji. ill". Ihfl.fl~.. I "'" ..'.I.n...." "1ft! hfffUl .. "~III
ll"f, IOilIt .'Hlilin, Ih' ,..11.1,.", 1"1'" n'l1lIllUII"...tlll ,., !'ffIn..hilllll ., fll" v,,'tllIIf IlllLlI,
Illl' il.\llllnUlQ PIn ,1't... IU...", ..4/1....../
IIltlt'~."U 1\lWIIlllar III \l\ltlIJl4JJIlI (..1I111i ltfll'f 111.111' ''''WI l ."" OIUk..
1"111,11,,"1. "'" 111........._il'flll/t.p4>.~....,_...._.............,_ok...~'.1J ~. ~
Iho ..II ~l'mmjll'~ l>)' 1M "'""" _'f'; (!) Il\IltUC'f "IlI'I." M'lllCn
Ttil IlUl\lfIWIt vtoun" Tn '.O'flt'1'IOlI "'" "VII OIMII lKi, Ilt-H' elft"'. IIIVID PI
JAlfU4aY If It" II ""M' Il4..,U . II""', flil .ar...... ,.. c.AJ.l. 'hII net.. " ...
,un Of IMtt.lJncOT A/ltt fllwtllf... .... 111& OI,UD.\lIt I''l ,..... tu vu'tlM flU tr
JIlIl lllllllUT au, .IM tMAT .. IIOIIUl O(l MlITtUIlCl fIAT 'Ill WUC.ll......, ru.etM'"
lit un.
.11 01 lO"j~h lO'lf ,!!~.ln.II~l"'".'_M4 411l1~!."..':!..._.!~......(. ......_Mhll crll'tltA1t._....1 ,..... ".' ... ,,,,,I,., .. ... lllt.vl (if .^...mllIJ,
llf in Vt"l.lIIJII ,.1 \i~'1".~"'E' .._~ M4 ~+.,.,,~ "" lilt .vf-U"..flff .
ll.....J ,''' ~/IM/ ....~'"
Of ,ht ',.ffliJPW' PI ~jf";'\a1\;::.::;::matt!<e~Z~lfil':>:l;'f:$~:,:;;:r,:'x::~g;;:;:*-;-,,~:s,_/..;~';"i..4'-'~"q;i;;-,;:>-0:l,,_,i;,7~~
~.,~~""",..." . ''''->'' -" - '-'''''"'-'i-A'g;;,,:;;'-~;'';j;;';~-7-'''' "-"~-'-"'-""<"- ,--
III I ..k IIIiI . _milll vI iltlf" Ilf . tlllllftlI'fl' II, Illtllf4 .... 111ft ._ 4f,,_4 '" "lft/II.i! Itl .."..., l/if ~~..'
I hno m"".
141 I vtllh Ih~1 IN Iii" ..I ",,'11111 llli' ~t>fllpI,inl '" IHIf 11#4 .~flH W I_ .... "r lfif \A!Mltil.. ~ mlflfflUllkj/l
.nd 1i.Ii,r 111/, t,nf!ullllft II .... _lffl W tlif I'fUlIIft .., "'.1"'" ..... l'f IAt ('fllll. f... ,ll .... (' II
. 4'1114' ,,1.'IIl' I" ijIlU"lf" ,.ltlfiUIIlfII W .41lllllfllln
,
,u~, ,
,IV U
1O',,;:t:":!l;::::.i;lt,::l1!::._.i.
t~"l'1~iiiill ='-~~",,,~,'
Mm NOW, un Ihl> II." , IV , I fflll" HIf tltlll~ 11M I!ffIj ~r ..,..... IIl4
.."I...." it,,,l Ih.llto.'f to 1',...1>If Uli!tf "" I~f'" IW'-.Iol
. '-', " "
,'-, . .,.,",.., ,',.
~t}.~ti#i~~jiki-1L
-.., ".~- ""'-.,"""" t1i-;j;r/.i'1;.7fit:il!iT"""""'''''''=='''''' lltAL )
tlII\lAr~
,..... IIfIj
lW AlOt '{~~CI m ~"f_
__jj'l~p .f
'''''''''''''''.''-J:'' . ~"''''='''''''''~h'':3'_''''''''''
--.-,.....-. .- -, .. ".<........__. ~~
. i ..~ ". ,____"...=~''''__, _
____..'_:-.=~..::="':=<_,~~'l!';';.~~
k.oo.....~..1~....~'.......~.-L~~..~1 ~J:f1Jt~*"
-.... ~"....'...""~.. ..-......~~'. ..~~ .~-..
.................... ""... ..".0Pt .,""~.......,,~~~.Jrtro!ie.<'#!9 ..~-_
"fIJIA..... .......~..#._- ........_~~, ...... .....
-..-.... .
",I
r
rn
1:/
I...,.~.it'."..__
,,,.....,
., 1ioilriiT'lJj,j'..~f
.. _Ui "jffjJfl'"
CIHMIf/AI cnMI1 Aim
(rOller)
ICOMPlAINT HUMOln IYfAA ~--m..~~-'~ ~MH"
ICtjfllpi.unt Numbu" If Olh., '1.,lh..I",.1I1"
I
~97:'~t"'..l"'... ...
0181111Cl JUlllICI
MAOllIlLlIlAl ClIIlIIllCT NO
I
I
I
IA
Bf)18~
- -]OT'N--- - - - --- ---~~--
......v~,~.",.,__~..-"..~....,..._.,.""'"..-'<
COMMONWEAlllt 01 PtNNliYLVANIA
lit .(t,.ljM~f Vb.
t!..d ,',~a ~n~;""n,,;~.,1i u';.."!.J.LI
.
.., lt1' iI:".' Hf.~ r"t l',>,Ut, 1'~l't "'~'!~Il}\';J!
"AI'" TIlOK4I1 t M\IllltH411
M., It) ()tJ)(W' IJl
AI~~<1 '", c.tUOll...". lion
V/IC/)-Wo...ttI
hI,.. .., .u-u-nu
AI' '"
tlo ht"...tl) t.(:tlf
II' QiI I UI',II.e Illf .~..tf n~"'f\I Ilrffll".1I1, ..11lI III,o.t !hf .".tfU' toel h'lIh .I>"'f '",
o 1.11 ..If u" ""h.,oIu.1 ..h".. "."', ,. w"'"''''" h' III~ 111.1 ..hlll\ "f"'flhf,1 ..
t
f
.
I
..
o h.. ""'''illlf ,., /'l'P"'.' 11"I,".Ijllfl i. ""'""'''1 t" III~ Ill", Ihrffhll.. I h... de'l,n~I.II him h"'1II a. I,.hn
Il"f, ,"Ih IIII'"IIIl, III' 1,,""II~\n ,'/111' ('I'IllIllI.nw,.1th ."I\"I"o)II."i. ~I ,.,._ ~,,''iIHIi ~IUth,
1.'/, .'~!,.n~rH; I'lf_J ""'" /I~,..oi\."Ii"",..j
,,"'" ';0 1"."'Pllt in ~i!".lif."A"iI ('lllllll~ \1/1'" Mbout 'OilllAllY I IlIn, l'e))j,u
I'illi,orinl. "", 1~,......m"",'.I/Ol"" ,...,__,...,-"'IflI'/tiJ/'Iw.....,'II"""'.""'~1 'mM,\. r ..WIIII'"
Ul
III' .,lIlo,"mlll,1I1>)' lh, .~nlfll -If.; <!>
lfl"HtU (:w'''llII... fnHuiPl
.'" 'f1uLni \/tAHt,j! HI<< ~Hf'"(,fI(lil 'HII4 AIWU .,ll,;JU !!fi. ~)~l1U "nil.. unW"IOIl
"" U I " i V'j\ ill JUt!;,. '..4Ji'l..t. f llliHH. h~ I,.h"il""i .tHI t;AU. flit V1etlM AT IiU
n ;\U1' 'H.31i!'Ul 4111, fi<Uo\IU'I! lin. hit j,j'.fl!iwt;,\;~t lilt' nu, "Ill Y1CHI4 fMT H
h,; ,,;vH' .,.., L III" lM4f liIl .;MI"" I,lU il-11f'illllli!i! 'tl!il, ..... l/\,ltll>> "'1."" l'l.lClliG IlU
'" t~ 'rAil' j
III l>1 ..hl4'h _'''I,.if'''lht!lf~.~ '1Id "1'~I!r",I'" (.~~..""h of "'1",~.'V.~."I~ a!'4,!Clftlflrr, 10 lilt . NI. t>f ^lIfmbly.
IIf In \lul.III.II,1 ;.,;.n~\!Jifi:~ 1114 \'ii$w~~~~:f;f ," lilt .vI !ltlJl,,;t..':I'_l~Llllt~
"I 'Ilt / IiIMII Ordill.IIU III' ;~,~;;':;~i"it';';:'h:;!;'f"'4.i;~;,~~;f~!~;..:,'~ll*i~iftll'J7"''%:l,l
. "'/"'J/ihJWIII;~i,;'fI." .......
C I, I Il~ Ih.1 4 "."1111 "" arr.lt IIf . IU/ll/llIIIII b, I"Uftl Inll Ih,t th. .((Ulfll b. r.qul,.d ." aniII'I( Ih. ~hll'u
I to... 11I1,1.
14' I \fill) 11,.1 th. 'if If Ifl 'lItlll in Ihlt ,\"lIpl.11I1 "' \Ill' .nll "'HUt III th. h'I' llf flI' .nllwl.lI.. lit 1IIIIIflllllloo
I"" h,llr' Iltn l"lti~.lklfl I. /11111I '''''jut I.. I", fI'",I\l,I 1'( Mclloll .~ II' the (',im.. tod. 01 I'al, ('. Ii,
I 4'1f14, ,,1.1111' h' U"'ll'lItn 'alliliutlon Illluthurltln
Hu"uf "
. I~ ~ 1
"."1 _ ;..,~.w'..._
I.II"oiu."iI r~_ j
MW '-IIW "" 1111I il... . " . I ntli', tilt ClllIIlll.illt II.. "..n pfUptrl. CliIllp',t'd 1114
..II' ..,I .to'" ltoi' ,Ilt" I' !'full.Wf "ull IIJf '011.11" ,.f !'fIll''''
"--"";'.:'L"';>';;
llfA!.'
<< ~71t~1I7Jff:iJ- ~#,l-li "I
"C_'"___~'--' r,;"71/i l.i,t..:;t,. 1-
"
WAMAHT
I, ""J .~1I""'44 1'f''''I>i ""'w~1 b' 114ft ".oil'''''
t"\I 41," p",.#..;.uJt:tJ '~:i ~nfw.
.hfP;...-f:tt~, tl r."'t.J.~'H-. {fo! i~ (l_a;>.:~-lit"f-:4al1 )-4
r-ffH'!q, h-~Ad: ~h~t Jil,fi#i-' 'i~ ~:! ftH~-Jj!f- t-~
p;d",tlu'tlfl'''' ft',f ;+f.,P\-f +tJd/f'. ft. ith4'14t'-, 'M ft~.-"4;~f
( !o1l'pt.-;.H
(\'''It
.~". ""--"""";"":~;;:7t:.:;::;1:iif;Jti;'_Tc:r:"~-""'--""-'"-"
d--;t hiii~j{i
*i1
- - -.,-- i '~IJii~~'i'~.J (t;A~{/;'"
,""''''''''''..+. -....
UIIMINAI (OM!'I AilH
(l'Ollen
IcnMPI AilH NUMIIIIl lYrA"
iCWlljll.t1llt NUllllll!l~ 1111\11,., I '"tilt Illl,nll.
TYPE'
'tjljMd!1f
.,
IlISIIUCr JUSflCr
MAOISTrlllAl flISlIlICl NO
A }i'
. n 1
l.'-;
INCilltNf NlJMOtll IlJCh NO.
, O\(lt.~y,
t'N
III
1Ht, l'IlIiil.U..... f\t,. i'tltlet. otrr
. .
rA~(/':ll'vii
COMMONWLAlTtt Of f'~NNllYlVANIA
H II '.1,,,.,1 V5.
I .. ..
I."Mi TIlatA. I UUlllOlMl
M'" 161 Of.l)(;AI' IUI
AI"'I,:, ~11."l.&. r. I1IlU
W/./S-2o-60
IP,A ,., l..~n-"I'
AKA
n...'ft lIutlll~ 1lf\lt1 .
! \,'#;1,_,1 -tffl.llll i
"";~,f,' !
du I",,,..h\ ~'ilh.
I II (!) I ,,,,11'" Ih~ .hll\~ ".,"~d "~f~,,,I.1I1, ~h" II"'. .1 Ih~ allll,~.. '~I fllilh .I"'I~ "',
o I an"'~ all ",,11111111.1 \lh",,' "am, 1\ ""~lI'I\\" h' 1I1~ hill \It". ..llf..."h... ..
I
:1 0 h" Illdllam. "1 1~11,"ldr llf.I.lldllllll II UII~III'\ln hI 11I1' dllll, Ihtl~h,r~, , hMW ll'''.lIdltd hllll herein Ul Jnhn
I 1>,.., \I'lh "nidI "'. Ihe !'fIlUI tMII' 111' Ih~ (\11I\1I11111Ilealth ,., 1'l"lIll)hulIia al 1"' WUlUIi '!lULlII,
~ IN) H......Ulo\!;C fin lIV"'f,/M.,..J.../tJ""h..1
" "ltllli.f.SO 1I'1illt:lttt' III Cllj(II..Ullll ('l1ullb 1111 or MIIIIUI U...",..., j 1''1\, l.l'~)l\".
~ I'ailldl'allh \lere I d th,... .,..."""u."""" "'..<f1u-1I _. ,..... ."""1iI1I /..,.."",~,Jo.II'''~;oI.IU' lllt>>!AS f, JlA\i\;IlJ!}Jl
(2} The 111'1' ~l"n/lllllfllll)' Ih. 1i~~u...1I "".. @ 1......Hl~l,. !;Jtl'1l1AI. ~)IIHl"f
TIIP. 1l/;nitT,Ahl VWu.nll TII_ 'It'11U~'tIl}!I rnl1 A~IlU 1I111Ht_ liI'_ U-UIl CtYIL. tUl1t110.
.Jo\'uAay '1 UU at Jlltli:JI I14l1iUi Il IIIU,I,Y, flit br.h!tlUliiT l.11f! (AU. till VtCTIH AT filii
n..\\.:t v; Ii.Hrlm~u.T AInI t"lu.UII~11 lilli, llll f>Crt;liIl\UT UILI fl/.I.l. flU \'tellH TII4T tr
~lll; lillJ !tin CAl.t lilt! lMT Ii "!)lILt< Dn _"t!4Tlilli(; 'fl!.\T 'II" ilUliW ill4U.T'\.4C"" !In
i~ n... '
.11 o! ..hl~h \I'm ...lnll Ih, pt." .nd dltnllr ,If Ih, ttl/l1monwtlllh III l'.nnfr'~.nl. .nd conll.,,, III lhe Acl IIr Anembly,
j . I' r ".l'"~''.''''''''''''' -' ""'a"""'..'rlh ..t_r_....'.,.4...oIl:l'"""ln.D.I~r_--
Of "\1111111111110....'. _.~".\il:.'t!t."v\t''1" an.. "c'.""""'''''';;'''''. 'I 'no; v, ..'_~_ ....',....... ."''''''"~".
INo"",,1 If ......"" nUk AilVU
IOf Iho
Orlll"."" ..r
J/l#iI..1
(J I I i1,k Ihal I wlrrlnl or lirt'll 11/ I ,u/IIl1lon, II' lnu.1I Ind Ihal Ih. IHII"d b. "qulf,1I II. .",\\'" Ih. Ihlf,,,
I lIa~e IIIld.
(4, I HlIl~ tllll tI" rill. "I li'flh III Ihl, r(lmplMlnl IIf' Ill" Ind 1'llt'HI hllll. II'" \If m~ kllllwl,lIp llf Infonnlllllfl
.,..1 helief TIIIl ullflnljl'l1 It lI\id, -ullJ.el h. Ih, ",nllllltl IIf 5nthm .1/(" 1.1 Ihe (',Imn ('1111. (II "., (', fi.
I 4'i04, 'rial III' ,,, un'WIl/1I '.l.lnUllnlll" IIUlhllflll",
Hu,i,:All i
, " H
IV1,OIUhIW'" n.;yiu/ItIlti/T -
Mo/lI NOW, nil 1111' 'hIe , 1'1 , , ullllr Ill, {1t/II,,'.lnl 11111 "'eo "f.fly (tl/l1ple"d lIf1d
HI.llld, lill.) llllil Ih.,. I. 1"""'*"" UI/III/ fl" 1.~iUI" ..r rfl"'"
, i 1J,WJd':'~llt 'ttl!!,-;j "
""F"-""~-""-~'--'""""--77r:J;r;;"7fj;;:;;;j-r~'''''' '. I
:.-
,UAU
Ml~~'" N"~1" fOl.lHO
WARRANT
II..
._"--.-.-..~."-".~:'"':'~--~~~
I' ~,.' t 1ll'".1,4
'CO'''''' ,
II All) IHiltlitJt." ....,tl'ltl1 f\tt"..titt. h4 nH. ..jH.,~t
~;"~ ,i!v lPl11(fl,ftd-rd tu ~fh-:\.
\It'_....;~;tif;fil.i14*tw ~\:\w">>
~ TI. tt:'.r(i~ _d~:;' !1';l'1 t*'riil-.FJ ....tHlf""L<("=""""",,...,"."''''''''..,.,'7.
f1 "!.it!,,, ~Il
e.I ""f.,;.. .-,;~ t.c.. W'~-"'U'.
il\:fi!\lL'fl' d tt.tVhd lit ttw (iW\';f~n.'I;Ytt'4lt"" I"~
t., \"'HH-AtH." M~t tfHf\'I tn~ "-~-f ~~.fl"-" th~
,d,.hl\.'f,tll,.I H~-\; .J'..f"f' ,,\,"'r{\\ tl'. ,,\y.;.~! '~*'I~flij,M~i
( "jl'lf<lAiht
/\'~'H#;;, )'
,,--,,~" . (rlif.
l\t..\t I
fttNftH WHIRl liIJlIfMHT" HOT rOUHO
,"1" titl'.4I1 ..",tdt I ,,,,,hn' 'md Ih(li tHlu.-.t t'flt'1l.j~'lt
;,.H v#:l,j!~;,!
,;,,,,,11 L
L ...
iU''1!''.!dIHih.."..tl
__ __, ...c.:_. _ _"~_~-CM'_-"'._",-_~'_.'-__:'"_-~- ---"
Wo\III1AN 1111: \\INN
'j\'t"'<4JJ'U J
. , .. . ..... ........... -. {fj,}t i ...._--~.,.
LAUIlA I. IAUOHMAN,
,1IintUI
v,
TIlOMA. I, BAUOHMAN.
DoI.nd.nt
"~
,t/~ Its
I IN THI COURT or COMMON PI.IA. or
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, 'ENNIVLVANIA
I
I
,
, INDIRICT CRIMINAL CONTEMPT
I NO, "-370 CIVIL TIRM
IN RII APPOINTMENT or COUNIIL
QMQIR or t:QUBl
AMD NOW, thi. 3na aaV 01 Februarv, 1"1, thl
Court .ppoint. the PUblio O.r.nalr to repr..ent the Dar.ndant on
thh ghar".,
Tho... A. ,1,0IV, I~u'r.
A..i.'ln\ D'..rlut A"ornev
Will'.. Q, .lflUfht, I.quir.
A..'.'ant 'ublio O,"n4.r
,Uh
eft'.. ~t.lt <4/11 f,
d "
IV the court,
tl!~"
lJ.
\ '
,J 1
I.: ! '-
\.;
i.,. ,
lJ
."",,"
-~,..
')'/'/'1)-
LAURA E. 8AUGHMAH, I IN THE COURT 0' COMMON PLEAI or
Plalntiff t CUM8ERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
V, I
I
TUOMAS E. 8AUGHMAN, I INDIRECT crUHINAL CONTEMPT
Defendant I NO. 9,-a70 CIVIL TERM
IN REI 8AIL AND UEAltINO DATE SET
OltDER 0(': COURT
AND NOW, thi. and aay of '.bruary, 19", the
Det.ndant wa. arr..ted thl. data tor all.q.dlV violatinq the
proteotion trom abu.e ord.r prlviou.1V ia.u.a bV m.. Th. Court
..t. a h..rinq on the above compl.lnt tor Thur.d.v, February I,
1995, .t 11130 .... The Court turther direct. th.t the
D.t.nd.nt b.tw.en now and that date comply wlth .11 In.truotion.
and dlrection. ot the prot.ctlve ora.r that I 1..u.d en J.nuary
:l7th, 1995,
81no. the .lllqld vl01atlon dld not lnvolv. any
phV.lc.l abu.. ot the victim, the D.t.ndant .ay b. r.l....d trom
cUltody thi. date upon pOltlnq '100.00 ball tor hi. Appearano.
al dirlctld tor Febru.ry 9th, 1"'. 'Indlnq thl po.tinq of th.t
ball h. 1. rl.andld to thl cu.todV ot thl Cumborland county
Shlrltt,
IV thl Court,
..~ \r. . \:.:
" rold I. .hl.1V,
"""'\
I'""
l-J..-
Thoml. A. Pllcer' I.quire
Alli.tlnt Diltr at Attorney
Willilm O. 8rluvht, I.quire
Alliltlnt PUblic Der.nder
11th
t~- ~..L ~/'11u'
"" it
.......
.
-,
LAURA B. BAUGHMAN, I IN THI COt11tT 0' COMMON PLIAS 0'
plalntlff I CUMBBRLAND COUNTy, PENNSYLVANIA
I
V. I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
THOMAS B, BAVGHMAN, I 'ROTECTION 'ROM ABVSI
D.t.ndant I '5-0270 CIVIL TIRM
IN RII CONTIHPT
PB~llt or COURT
AND NOW, thl. .th day ot 'abruary, 1"1, .
haarln; wa. hald today on a patitlon all.gin; that on ,.bruary
2nd, 1"1, tha Datandant callad the 'laintltt at har plaol at
work at the Wa.tarn .1.llln .taak Hou.a, and among othar
convar.atlon thraatenad har If Iha dldn't return a phon. oall,
Th. prot.ctlv. ordar in thl. ca.. wa. dat.d
January 27th, 1"5, and paragraph 2, among other thing., ha. tha
following languag. -including diracting oommunlcatlon., both
oral and writt.n, to her-. Th. Dat.ndant admit. he dld oall
'laintift, and the r.a.on tor hl. call wa. that .h. had
pr.viou.ly oal1.d hl. on the phon. and wanted to know what
happ.ned to har clothing and olothlng ot her ohildren,
Th.re'. no qua.tion in thi, ca.. that Mr..
.aughaan did, in taot, ..k. a phon. oal1 to the O.t.ndant
r.qua.ting thl. intormation. Tha 'lalntitt .ay. ln addition to
dllou.llng thi. ..ttar, th. Det.ndant thr.at.n.d her it Ibl did
not r.turn a pbone call that loaathing wa. going to happln to
.h. and b.r ohildr.n, although that .p.cltic languag. W'I not
lncluded ln the o~lalnt.
I have told Mr.. 'a~~n that undar no
oirou.atano.. aft4 unda' no r.a.Qn lbould ,h. in the tutur. .ver
atke a oall or writa to Mr. 'aughaan, and it abe ne,4a any
infOrMAtion fr6a hi. lt Ihoytd b. done through har attornay_ I
.'i.~>
hive now told Hr. alughaan thlt h. .hould in the Cutur. undor no
o1roum.tano.. oall h.r or wrlt. to h.r for any r...on, .nd l' h.
ha. any r...on to oont.ot h.r th.n h. .hould .1.0 do th..
through In .ttorn.y.
Th.r.tor., I rind th.. the phon. ..11 th., h.
.ad. to the ,1.1nt1ff on r.bru.ry 2nd oono.rnln, the 100.tloR o.
Mr.. Ilughman'. oloth.. .nd or the ohl1dr.n'. oloth.. w..
1n1t1.t.d by the ,l11nt11f h.r..lr, and h. dld not viol.,. 'h.
'rot.otlon trom Abu.. ord.r I' I.r .. th., oonv.r..tlon 11
oono.rn.d.
A. lar .. the oonv.r..tion about ....thlO9 would
happ.n to h.r or h.r ohl1dr.n 11 .h. did not r.turn hl. ..11, I
wl11 .oo.pt the ,1.1nttll', t..tlacny thlt, In 'lot, th., w..
..id, and X tind thlt h, i. ln oont..,t 01 tho "otl'tloR .ro.
Abu.. ord.r ror ..kln, tho.. r.-ark..
IIOW.VII, I do Jlllt ,..1 tl\.- .ny .."hnn '0
pri.on would b. ju.ttfl,. b...d on tbo.. ,...'k., and,
th.r.lor., X dlr.ot that h. P'Y the oo.t. lnv.lv" If.. thl"
proo..dln,., And I would "y to Mr, "Ufhaln thlt i' h, "11.
h.r in the lutur. for .ny r.'.on thlt I would "."" ., 'hi'
tl.. to ..nd the D.r.ndant to ,'ilon,
Iy thl CtN,t,
J ^l
1 ! I.;. I
J.. n~"llJ;r-
t
Hiob"1 'obwoy.r, '.quir. )
A.,I.t.nt Dlltrlot A"or.l~
W&lli.. O. 'f'Vlht, ,.~irl)
Antill", ,\lbU, O,'eU" .c
1U1
,~-" \#,~ Ir ""; 4#,4
~/i~/'U .
. "fl.:"
."""
,.,....
'-1"/1('
LAURA .. IAUOKMAN,
Plaintiff
v.
. IN THI COURT or CONNON PUAI or
I CUMDIRLAND COUNTY, PINNIYLVANIA
I
I CIVIL ACT%ON - LAW
I "-0270 CIVIL TIRM
I
. PROTICTION rRON AlUI.
THONU ., IAUOKMAN,
D.fendant
%N Ill. CONTIM'T
gaDn o~ com
AND NOW, thi. 21th day of r.bruary, 1"1, the
D,f.ndant app.ar.d in oourt today r.pr...nt.d by Willi.. a.
'raugbt, I.quir.. A..i.tant 'ublio D.f.nd.r. Th. 'rot.otion
tr~ Abu., ord.r pr.viou.ly .nt.r.d in thi. 0... .ay. that the
D.f.ndant i. .njoined from ent.rlng 'lalntiff'. plao. of
e~loya.nt at W..t.rn li..lin .t.ak Hou.., 1205 Harri.burg 'ik.,
Carll'l., CWMb.rland County, '.nn,ylvanla.
Tha D.f.ndant ha. a~itt.d that h. did vlolat.
thi, ord.r y..t.rd.y about 10115 .... wh.n n. did go to the
vioti.'. plao. of ..ploym.nt. Th. D.f.ndant .ppar.ntly did not
... bi. wit., and mad. no thr.at. to h.r or anything .1... '0,
thlr.torl, I am not ..ndlng the D.f.ndant to jail tod.y,
although % do find a violation of the 'rot.otion from Abu..
or4.r b.cau.. ot that oonduct.
Th. Court dir.ot. that the D.r.nd.nt .h.ll .t all
tl... in tb. future cOMply with thl 'rot.otlon fr~ Abu.. or4lr,
and I 1M ,.lling hi. now .hould h. vlolat. lt .gain, r.gardl...
of wh.tb.r h. thr.at.nld bi. witt, .aw hi. wlr. or anythlng II..
lnvolvlnt hi, wire, it tbe ord.r i. violated h. 1, definltllY
toint to '0 to 'all.
...
....
I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I
I 91-270 CIVIL TERM
I
I
I CHARGE. INDIRECT CRIMINAL CONTEMPT
ORDE~ OF CQUI\I
J I l' . ,1'<_.1 \. i .. , \
AND NOW, thh ,- dav of ,'..nu~, llllll, thh Court
certlfll, that the attached complalnt hat been properly completed
.nd v.riti.d, and th.r. 1. probable clu.e for the i..uane. of
proc.... In con.lderltlon of the attlchld Commonw.llth'.
P.titlon, I WAaRANT 1. IS.UED FOR THE ARREST of the Defend.nt,
TIlOHAS E. BAUOIlMAN.
LAURA K. BAUOHMAN,
Plaintiff
V.
THOMAS I. BAUGHMAN,
Defend.nt
If the d.f.ndlnt i. found durlnQ narm.l Courthou.. hour.,
the d.f.ndlnt 1. to be brought lmmedl.tely b.tore the Court. If
not found durinQ Courthou.. hour., the d.fendlnt 1. to b. t.ken
to the on-clll Pi.trict Ju.tlc. .nd ball ..t pur.u.nt to the
Rule. of Crlminll Procedure. Furth.rmor., .ft.r appelrinQ b.for.
the Dl.triet Ju.tlc. the dlf.ndant i. .dvl..d to app.ar b.fore
thl Court Admlni.trator at the op.n of the nlxt bu.ln... d.y.
D.f.ndant ha. a rlght to b. r.pr...nt.d bV an .ttorney. It
the d'fendant cannot afford an attorn'Y, upon r.quI.t on. will be
...ign.d to r.pr..ent the def.nd.nt. The ......m.nt of co.t. to
be det.rmlned by the Trtal Judge ,ub..qu.nt to trlal.
BV thl Court,
I I I.
~(. '.~iy
)'1"
J.
Tho... A. 'l.cIY
'Inlor A..l.t.nt Dl.trlet AttOrneY
THOMA' I. 'AUOHH,ltl
'0/
.
r,
,~ ,
SSI ~" H 7 ;1 i'~
"'....
1"""\
I.AURA &. 8AUGHMAN,
Pl.1nlUf
I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I
. 9&~270 CIVIL TERM
I
I
I CHAROEI INDIRKCT CRIMINAL CONTEMPT
V.
THOMA. I. lAUGHMAN,
petend.nt
CQ~QN~~1U" rETltION,rO~ ^ Il!AR1~O Q~ ~1l~RO!B
at LHQ1~'Cr C'IKIU~L 'Q~T!MPT
thoml. A. ,l.cev, 'Inior A..i.tant Dl.trict Attorney ot
Cumb.rland county, 'Inn,vlvanla brlnOI the tollowlno 'etitlon tor
a hearinQ on chlcoe. at Indireot Crlminal Contempt I
1. A 'rotection trom Abu'l Ordlr WI' 1..uld bV the court.
^ tCUI and corrlct copy ot thl Ordlr i, attached.
J. The detend.nt'. violation ot thi. Order 1. av.rred in
th. .ttach~ prlv.tl crlmln.l complalnt.
J. The victim reque.t. the fl11no at .n Indirect Crlmlnal
Contempt ch.roo upon intor.ltlon recelvld.
.. The 01.triot AttorneY'1 otticl approve. the tl11no of
thl. privI'1 crlmln.l compll1nt.
.. Th. Co~nw'll\h 1. r.quI.tinO . hlarino on thl charo..
ut Indir.e, Crlmlnal Contlmpt purlu.nt to 2J PI.C...A. ,611J.
W"'MI'OMI, the Co.-onwl.lth r~u..t. thl d.tlnd.nt b.
~~Ad.a to app"f ~tor' the Cour' on the chi roo ot lndirlct
CrlM!n.l Cont._pt.
...pocttijl1r..vpmltted,
i
A. ,l.cIY
A..l.t.nt 01.triel Attorney
t
,{6
COMMONWEALTfI OF PENNSYlVANIA
1'1 I I NilAN' VS.
1-
NAM~ now; IWQltWl
AND '. 167 OlD GI.p RO
Aorn~~8 ~lLISLE.P^. 17013
E68;BI62~~~~8~~J
1 IIIMI"^I 1 1",11'1 Ml1
!POLICE I
r ...
ICClM~AiNtN.UMbr IYEAR '.' ,
iCUlHplllll11 NUIl1lHflIIlt Olh." Pd.ht'Ililntl
I
I
l.NtlotNT NuMOER JUCR NO,
rl)tH~)O~F
I'!\I'IA I', IWHI;'\1.
Ol811llCl JUSTICE
MAOISlrtllAllJlli1l1lCl NO, (J'J.!-1l1
I IWI:l1UISI: ~~~I^HI:
!:1IIt1,ISI.I:,I'A, 1/111 \
A 9r:3'/1-
.. ,) "J
l'I1N~".(,~{X,,(,~\Ynt.._~.,....~.____
I'"'''' ,,{ ~1""1l/ I
i N" ~ 1I111~IK!Ilt-l,Jl-II'J. mLll.JU)E1'I'.......,. IJ _ __~
( ,k"1I/1 JI'/Ij#llIIf1lllt1liRf".1 h'f!Il'!t>1IH,J7j;;[j:3ii"UIA" iU.IoiHII,
IUU
AKA
,j '""ch)' ,laic,
1 ) iii I ""u'c Ihe ahmc 1I~IllOllllcIOIl"lIl1l, "h., Ii~c. at Iho lI....re.. '01 '"rlh ah"'lI .11,
o I '''''u', all 'n,hlldual "h.,-, lIalll' I. unkll.."n 10 me hul "ho il "c...'iholl al .__,__
t ypll-- ,,' NUMbtR'
~.~etN
I 0 hil JI,dJlalllO ..r I'"l'ular dOlI,nationl, ullkllllWn III 1110 an", Ihcrolilro, I ha~' dell,nalfd him herein a, John
lI"e. w,lh lilllallll. Ih. JlC'Jlallu'. .>f the ('oml1lul1wealth IIf l\lnl1l~llanla at _ll,N.MJllIll.E'fiJN I/n
INMJ'i\lI!J~INU~Ui[1)[1"CI~ , , 111.., ffJiiii;rr;;]iJ/./Ajii,,1
,. ~",-,__ in (lMHflUAND ('uunl~ on IIr ahllut Will][ 11$'11\ Itt9~ IU' API'l.OX771L
l'afll~'IJlan', \\'rrc ,,1 ,1f/'11' ll"ff'IItI"flVtil,.,., ~:I ,Iw" ....,....lttW. ~i",'Atllu''''"J.,a'l'f'Jr.k''d..1tI1,
'llkH\S 11AIJClH\N t:'\
') I h~ al" '''111''1111,,1 II~ Ih, M~,u...1I 'ure, ~ INlIRn:r ClUHINM. ()Mt)1('I'.
'111E 1J1J1:NIlANI' VIWA'IUJ '1111~ UUJl1( IS!)Ul1'rUNIJar"lIn~ID'IU"ITMli<<.t1 MUSE N:r 00. 95.270
CIVIl. UJU'1 IrJ')) (,tl nil: 27'111lY1Y 01' JAMJAlIY. I\Y 11U~ IUUWiL1: I11f:'lIl>E.N'1' .1l1lX;F, IlMOLD E, SIIEf:J.Y.
,nunl (~(J)m lJIIlU:I'S 'IlU~ OEI'ENIWII' 1t> STAY NtJAY n<<.t111U~ IU:''lILlI'}JCl: 01" IAlJlIA E. IIAIXU~ lOCAl1:JJ
AT n tUlIIJlJIJ:lltl JUl, CAltl.ISW.I'A, IN 11lAT 110: DEf1':NLWl1' lllD HtlfJI (NIU 'Ille 1'I<<)1~1Y WIIDlF.
IAIIIUI I:, IW_tWIN WA'lIU'$lI>ltlJ ANlJ WA.'I SEt:N IW D1~IIIIA IlAVHi A I<<UtlAl1C 01" IAIJIlA E. IlAI.Xn~.
I ", ..IIIIh ",r. ~,~I".t Ihe ",.ft .rlll III.nl(~ tof lh, ('unmlllflWllllh llf '\'nn..11I1I1I .,,11 'tlnll'r~ hI II.. .vI (If ^'''lI1blv,
HI ,'"Idt'"" "' ..J.lll2Yt:;",.., ,.nll IW...';"OI.. (If lh. ^,l .1/' ,JUNE ~:I....l2Z8 PlIv'Q'UClf:~AN1~
III" lOOClQCXUJl);XXXXXum Orllin'"1' r.f YY'(WY~VYV'll/YYW\ClI~.
~
I I OIl III~I ~ "4'''''' "' ~tf'" It' . 'l/f1UlIIlfla ", 1..lIfll 0'1" tll~1 Ill. onu"" b, rel/l/I"" lu .nawer Ih, ,'..r,u
I lIa'f IIld,Jf
I I ..,,'~ "'" '",, ,'/\ to "'. IWIIt III 11m \'~III""jfll ",. trIM' .,1<' \ ,.jJfI I hi '1;. b,,1 ..( illY klll,...lf"'" v, jllfwmJlI...1
.,..J "d." II." ...,11. ,II., h II,'''' ....In' I.. ,.... l"'1l~"l{o. ..I' """...., .'N~ .., I~ ("11I", (\,..,. I" 1'.. (', "
I 4'''''', 'I'.'JI'K I.. ........" "'I>/I'IHI".., 1~',:""".I\lJ(' ~ ,',' ':1Ve'~" .~,.", "'c,,, _,.
A "M""'''''' '4L,"'I"""""
"II ...lfl\> "" II... .1,1' I. Ill"," fl.~ \''''loJ.,M Ii... t.,."" 1""/'1,,1; \ljjf'j'<I.,.d ....,
IIf IjOlt",\, It\>41 It;",.\,- n ''ifl'''~N.. ~ ;w~ f~., h~\i.hf:" I.f fihi, r\-'
(lQ.Z.Of '." "C ~. i
,. ~l,,,,","'/rdl /1<>.,/..; /
,f"OII'" f'~J..~ii, I
(\IAU
<,
r"""',\
AFFIDAVIT RIDER CONTAININD PROBABLE CAUSE FOR TIlE ISSUANCE Of A WARRANT Of AllIIUT
FORIH t:/l~; 1IA\1IIN\N 1111\ I) k'O-1.O
I. YI~IH AITIAI'II' IS 11FI'lCll\ CAlMl! of '1111: tHfI1t NtI~)IJ:lllNll4JW;U(I' 1~~,It:I( I~J'^,ml:Nr.
:'. ON S^"'llIl11Y ~"'J{l:1l IHIlI I'J'J~ AT AI'I'IIlX. UII, IUIS I 14Ni IlISl'AIOUll (I1~II1U~ ~lAU.jU
T1~U: 'I1IAT IVI:NINl:) 'Ill 21 N.NmIIJ:lllN IlU. JUt A 1'./".11. VlolA!'ltWV,
I. IJl~)N AHHIVINl; AT 21 N.NIIlDIJ:Jtt\ IUl. [ SlUI~ 'In II IAlUlA IWUtWi Wll !lTATf.1.l /tUt
IIIUtlA'm DEllltA DAVIS IWI,m un 'nu.; WINlX~ OF 'nlJ~ H/;,'iWI';H.:I; ANI) SI\W 11~ lJl~tlnWlI'
~;I'M1)IN(; IN l1U~ UUVll4AY 111-;''lIDI~ IU'll Vl:lIICW. 'l1I1S IS I~ VIOIATIlWi (JI111J:1t 1',1'.11.
/'(l. 9'l.UO. IWI11) '1111'; 2ml MY 01' ,IAMlAIlYI9()'l. SIGNI;!) ItV 'II"~ InUlMW l'IU-;.IjIDl:N1'
.JInx:!; 11AIlOlJ) E. SHEELY, W111U1 U\J.lUlllllux:m 'l1U~ D1':U':NIWl1' 'Ill STIIY ~Y unlll~
HESIl>I1>K:E OF IJl.nlA I;. IWK:tt~. II flI'J\llcll Ill" 'I1U: NU~ ItV SI;VUW. OJ'ltICm,ll ANO ".f)
HlHNm tll' /'{1l111/'{J. t~,. DI;!YlA MVIS DID IUU'li:m II liIA1UU1i1' ANI} !lll~ 11'. 'illY.
llEI'HlllANl' I4JlJ. 1m PICKEll UP Mi smN A.'lIIK IS IUOO IINU mw;w wmt 1tU!1U:Cf
I1UNINAI. OWIUU'l'.
.
["'}"d lhl' . a4Y 01 , . ",,,..,,,,,, It"""
.. r (It\<\~~.tA. Jv,'LVI~I~_I<I"_"_'_~<<'___"_~
" , (,,';11.. ~I' orAlltill.
hl\(lft,jll, jNjf,~I'lllj@."" 11\, 1\1I ,I' ,.... AI~ ~ ~ ... NiliiG fI;i'~ flJIN"
liltl"~lr(lI.~lliJqj"HJ IJ l..t.- _lI.llltld III,.' A. Ih"a~11 Illdff IIIl1'11. lIIt.wf jIlQ ~.\.~.~...., ~.....~.. ~ I;jfIJi
the't,1I ill' ",,~ .n,llfH'tlllolllfllt\1 01 AlIi,1I11 il\t1ll~ 1lI1t111\fl!4iR.,.,.,....'
1'\\'''''0 A\lt~{)f'fy)
ISlAll
,""\
1""'\
'.AUltA Ii:. "AUOIIMAN,
l'lAlntlff
IN 1'111\ COUWI' Of COMMoU l'l.CMJ of
CUMh~HL^NO COUNTY, PEUNUVLVANI^
C I V II, "en ON . I.A'"
v,
NO, U~.~70 CIVIL TEHM
l'IIO'I'Cc'I'ION VltoM AIIlJllE
TIlOM'" E. DAUOIIMAN,
D.f.nd"nt
PROTBCTlvn OIWER
ANP HOW, thl. rJ)lf dAV of Ji,"IHlrv, II)'iift. upon
Qon.ld.ratlon of the con.ent "qr.empnt at the partl.e, the
fOllQw'n~ Ora.r 1. .ntor.dl
t. D.fundant "110"". Ie. IlAUOIIMAN ill ord.tlHt to fatrilln from
Ilbualn9 1'1AlntlU LAU/(A It. '\AUOIIMAN or p'aclnq h.r In f...r or
Abu.. or thr.at.nlnq h.r.
J. D'f.ndAnt 1. ord.r.a to retrAin from hllrll..lng
~l.'nt'fr, PlAintiff" r.l.tlvG. or the p.r.on. with whom
,lAint.fr ,. working or r..ldlnq, Includlnq dlructlng
4,lOllllllynloAUOnl, l;oth onl "fld wrlthm, to hur.
l. p.f.nd"nt 1. .njoin.d from Int.rlnq PlAintiff'. plll~. ot
..ploy..nt At W..t.r" .'..lln Ut.ak lIou.., 'JO~ lI.rri,burg 1'1k.,
CArll"., cu~b'rlAnd county, ,.nnMylvanlA ,70l'.
4. O.renaant i. ordered to .tay AwaV from the r..ld.oce of
~l.i"t'ff at ~l Horth Middleton POld, cArll.la, Cumb.rland
COIH'lt)', t'tllllnllylvAol" P(HI, IInl' hVIlI /'lnv r..lalno. whiCh
,l.lntift ..y nhblhh fuf' tHl!fUU in the futun.
t. Tlllll On..r 1ii1i4ii rl11114in In liI't.ot for 1I ptlriooJ of (l,lli'
Y4l4f.
fI, 11'14' "'Jftb "'4.<U.tllll 'I'qlm",hhl l'llll":,, l141JI4rtlllll,.t .nd ill..
~H44hll.n r'''''''l4lllp ""Il,(i'<Il' Jjfif"4f'!1'~if\f "'" U .(1\:", v. r'fovl.1t14 wall ..
'"
-,-~
LAURA I. IAUOKMAH, I IN THI COU.T 0' CONNON 'L'A' or
'1Iln\1" I CUMllaLAND COUNTy, 'INN.YLVANIA
I
V. I CIVIL ACTION - LAM
I
THOMA. .. IAUOlOWl, I ,aOTICTloN ,aON AIUI.
D.r.nclant I .1-0310 CIVIL TlaN
IN a'l C:OWTIM'T
QJQIl~QLl:OVU
AND NOW, thl. 'th clay 01 'ebruary, 1"1, .
ha.rin, w" bl14 today on . ,.tltlon 'll.,ln, th.t .. r.bruary
3nd, 1"1, 'h. D.f.n~n' .111.4 th. 'laint&II a' h., plao. 0'
work at th. We.tern Il..lln .,..k Hou.., a84 .-ont other
ooov.r.atlon thr..t.nad h.r If .h. didA't r.turn I pho.. ..11.
Th. prot..tive or4er In 'hil 0... WI. da,.4
Jlnu.ry 37th, Ittl, and par'ffaph J, aaon, oth.r thlAt., ha. the
'ollowi"g lan",I,' 'I.ndu41q dlu.Hng UI'IIIU\iuUo"" both
oral ao4 wrlt'.n, '0 h.,'. Th. l).tendeR' ldait. he did .111
'lllotl", .nd 'h. rea.on '0' hi. Gall wa. 'hat .h. bad
pr.vlou.ly ..11.4 hia Oft 'hi ,~n. .84 wlftt,d t. ~now what
hlpp.nad to h.r .lothint .84 ol.'hlAt 0' ~r ohi14,.".
Th.r.'. ftO cYe.tlon in thi. .... 'ha' N...
'au,~" did, in t'lt, ..k. . fheft. .all ,. Ih. D.,.ft4a.,
r.que.tlnt 'hi. In'0,..,1&8. Th. 'lalfi'i" .ay. In &44i'i.. "
dl..u'.1Rf thi. ..".f, Ihl O.,.A4anl 'hf.a'.R44 h., if .hl 4i4
AQt r.'urn a ,~n. .al1 I~.t .~'h'&f w.. ,~IBf t@ ~.,.n ,.
.be a64 Ii., okUdfilt", .h~1l lJ9..u "/H1U. laHqlHV' .,.. M'
iAtlud44 AM ._. q~l.'~',
, NV. ..~'4 "ff. ~~ \I;..n !fIi4.t.. fiI<9.
tlln\iNUMI4i ,,(;4 ~.f ..... fa.H. ,k>..,.i,* 'N iM. ,... fw,hin .....,
..,. a ~.,' ~f wfl'. ,# Mf, _.~~.~, .~ 'f ,~. ~.~. .*y
'nfDt"f'~n ff... hi. If .~.~l~ ~. ~ft. f~f~~~~ hI' .l'~f"'y, I
3.$
",,'
have now told Hr. Paughman that he Ihould in the future under no
oiroum.tano.. oall hlr or writ. to her for any rla.on, and if h.
ha. any r.a.on to contlct hlr thin hI .hould allo do that
through an attornlY,
Therefore, I find that thl phone oall that hI
mad. to the 'laintiff on rebrulry 2nd cono.rning the looation of
Nr.. .aughman'. oloth', and or the ohildrln'. olotb.. wa.
initiated by the 'lalntifl h.r..lf, and h. did not violate the
'rot.otion frOM Abu.. ord.r a. far I' that oonv.r.ation i.
oona.rn.d.
A. far I' tb. conv.r.ation about .oa.thing would
happ.n to her or h.r ohlldren lf .h. did not rlturn hl. oall. I
wlll aoo.pt tb. ,laintifl', t..tiaony that, in taat, that wa.
.ald, and I tlnd thlt h. i. in oont.~t ot the 'rot.otion rr~
Abu.. or4.r tor ..king tho.. raaark..
How.v.r, I do not f..l that any ..nt.nol to
pri,on would b. ju.titiad ba..d on tho.. r...rk., and,
tb.r.tor., I dlr.ot that hi pay the oo.t. involv.d trGa tha..
proo.eding.. And I would .ay to Nt. 'aughaan thlt ir h. 0111,
hlr in the future for any r'l.on that I would propol. at thlt
tl.. to ,.nd tbe D.f.ndant to pri,on.
lay tbl Court,
,." '( ['1'1.&>01 { ''''('dfl
, .. f. - ~.,. ., ,.-,-1.....< , l
, ",1
.
rllil
I, r
; I,
;.1 f ~ "" J.k:-'
. .. - ~
(4" /
II,. .f." ...Ii ... ;
,
'J..,..,I j./ . /llt,.~, i,{
,..)';!.\,."),,,I..,..1hv4 ,~ ',,,m~
" OIt/;"',1;I'"
Niohlll 'obwoyu, I.quh. ~
A.aia'lnt pll,rao'.At'Of.1
Wllll.- g, 'rIYQ~t, '.~'r.
A.I'a'.nt t~l'. Oe'.~.r
Nl
"~JH I. ...,.,1,..t
./I'/"f Li-..~
~, ,..,..,
LAURA I. BAUGHMAN, I IN Till COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
pldntUf I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PINNSYLVANIA
I
V. I CIVIL ACTION . LAW
I 115-0270 CIVIL TIRM
THOMAS I. IAUOHMAN, I
Dehndant I PROTECTION PROM ABUBS
IN RBI CONTEMPT
QRPBR or CQm
AND NOW, thi. 28th day of r.bruary, 1115, tb.
D.f.ndant app.ar.d in court today rlpr...nt.d by William a.
Iraugbt, ..quir.. A..i.tant Public D.f.nd.r. Th. Prot.otion
from Abu.. order pr.viou.ly .nt.r.d ln thi. oa.. .ay. that the
D.f.ndant i. .njoin.d from .nt.r1ng Plaintiff'. plao. of
employm.nt at W..t.rn 81..11n Steak Hou.., 1201 Harri.burg pik.,
Carli.l., Cumberland County, p.nnlylvan1a.
The D.tlndant ha. admitted that h. dld violate
thi. ord'r y..t.rday about 10115 a.~. wh.n h. did go to the
victi.'. plao. of ..ployment. The D.f.ndant appar.ntly did not
... hi, wif., and made no threat. to h.r or anythina .1,.. '0,
th.refor.. I em not ..ndln; the D.f.ndant to jall today,
altbough 1 do tind a violation of the prot.otion fro. Abu..
order b.oau.. of that oonduot.
Th. Court dlr.ot. that the D.f.ndant .hall at all
ti... ln the future comply with the Proteotion from Abu.. order,
ao4 1 aM telling hi. now .hould h. vlolat. it again, r.aard!...
ot whlth.r h. threat.ned hl. wit., 'AW hia wire or anything .1.1
involving hia wif., l' the order 1. violated h. 1. d.finit.ly
,0i09 to go to 'all.
..""
,....,
By \: h. Co,... t .
11 .~!
. /
({ <0.-. . '-.
.'- IT,(J,C-~' __L.
H r Q I. 'n." , '-'3.
-
William I. Oabig. ..qulr.
Ir. A..i.tant Di.triot Attarn.y
William O. Drlught, I.qui,.
A..i.tlnt 'ublio n.e.nd.r
mal
e....t~., ,,,,,,..~t..,,
JIll ItA
... l'
TRutt COpy "",1''''' "r~ef'r)
,,,Jt" I"
:';!l!-~~. ...,' .
rA.lJ,..3!!~_'.4f ',,~!,.l"l.!;...~ ;'l{
.---, rA'J'" /.J....,JI4J"""..Ii~~T=.
"tIfJlI>t~"'l
~! I- Ij ;
... ... 0<1.1
... . 101
Ill", ... '" ....
~~ .. 'U 0....
. . It..A
... III .
~~ i= .... aH
. .~ Q
-I/o. Pj
i 1-0
~I -
1-\1'1
~ . ... 101101....
.. .:::l ..~~
0<
. .. ..,~w
~2 101 . ....
.., 3liU.
." i .... 0
n I :t:'"' i~
.. I!!
oJ ....
lI!
101.
....lI1y
.
...
.
. .
w
ill/;
i,V
-,;
""'\.
u.~
......
".
"j
......
"l
'1
~
J
~
.
,',,",
"'"
l.//~Q/q)
LAUIA I. IAUGlHJCAH , . IN THI COuaT OW COMMON PLIAS 0'
'la1ntlU 1 CUNBIRLAHD COUNTY, PlNNIYLVANIA
I
V. . CIVIL ACTION - LAW
. '5-270 CIVIL TIRN
THONA' I, IAUOIDIAN, .
D.r.nelant I ,aOTICTION raON ABUII
IN all fllARlNO DATI liT TO CONCLUDI TIITINONY
QaDIR or COUJU:
AND NOW, thi. 11th day of April, 1"1, the
'~ot.atlon rr~ Abu.. h.aring, aft.r h.aring today, will b.
oontlnu.4 until W.dn..el.y, April 21, 1"1, at 3100 p... Th.
court ell~.ot. the D.f.nelant r...in in ou.tody untll thl h.aring
1. oonolucl.cl on that dat.,
Iy the Court,
TboIu. A. n,o'I' I.quire
A..l't.nt Dl.tr ot Attorn.y
"illl.. a. .raught, I.quir.
A..l.t.nt '~11o D.e.nd.r
Probatlon
cc.
..1
.
~, ('" ",'0," .l......(..l
If J ~, Its
~.~1 .
3i
S~I ? j f,t r
t:,.'i
-",.
......
....
Ill/fj-
LAURA I. IAUOIDWf, I IN TlI COURT or COMMON 'LIA. or
'la1ntUf I CUMJllt.AND COUNTY, ,INNIYLVANIA
I
V. I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I '1-270 CIVIL TllH
THOMA' I. IAUOIDWf, I
D.hndant I PROTICTION rROM AlU.1
IN .~l tlAH.cal,TO' PIOCllDING.
'roo..41ng. h.ld b.for. tb. Honorabla HAROLD I.
.IIILY, ..J., Cwab.rland county courthou.., Carli.l..
r.nA'Vlvania, on Tu..daV, April 11, 1"1, in Courtroo.
M\&IIb.r On..
A"IAL\N'=I'1
TlONA. A. .LACIY, I.qul,.
A..l.'.nt Dl.triot A"orn.v
'.r 'h. C....nw..l'h
WILLIAN a. JaAUOKT, I.qulr.
A..i.,.nt ,ublio D.t.n4.r
ror tb. D.f.nd.nt
~
....
INDI! TO "~TNl881'
POR CONMONMaALTH DIRICT CROll RIDIRI~ RICIOII
Dabra Davh 7 13 21,24 U,21
Laura I. .aughlun 2. 30 33 ..
'"'"
-
1 .. 'LACIVI YO\lr Honer, tb. COMOnw..ltb
2 would 0.11 ~be "A ..~~.r, 'aufhaan v.r.u. 'augbaan. Do..
J Your Honor h.ve . ooPf oC 'b. ..... ,.o.nt oo.pl.int'
. THI coun I I don't bave anything.
I .. 'LACIY, Okay. I'll hand to YO\l, Your
. Honor,. IOPf ot ~h. "A lo.plalnt an4 a oOPY of your
7 pr.vlo\l' ord.r..
I TIll eouaT I An th... Cor .. or do you n..d
, lh...,
10 .. 'LACIY, I ..n ". whho\lt th...
11 TK' COVIlT I Okay.
13 .. 'LAC'Y, WHh ",.t 'h. C.-onw..ah h
IJ ,r.,.," ,. "......
14 TK' C'Otra'f I VO\I"y ,rol..4.
11 .. lJAUONfI Yo\l' It.M', b.fon th.
1. C....nw..l'" ..11. 'hei. VL'A..... .. Mr. 'aUfbaan, ., l.a..
17 ., fa, .. -V 1n,.,..'ion ,~., Wa. aff.,\14 1.., ni,ht on
1. 'hi. new ...,I.i.t. J\I" 'hi. ..,nLfi9 .. I wa.n" in -V
1. ."l...~,. ,.,.on by 'h. ft&MI ., JI.on C..'l. 0... ,. 'b.
30 ."i.. with . '~f' ,."., aft4 . li., .f wi tn...... and I'v.
31 .on'i~ ,kAt th... af. wL'n..... ,@, Mr. "Ufbaan.
3J I R4v.A'l ~..n ..1. ,. ,... in ..n'..' with
U 'UII folll.. I ...... MI, ".!,ifWft, h. ..., .ine. he w..
J4 'v., 'ff"'" 1.... Ai,~... I 'AI'~ WJ, "...y 0' ,.i.
n ~,un.. .i...,.. ~ f!f MI. W. WIf. ~iat ... ..11 fO' .
)
-
..
1 continuanc. to put on ou~ p.rt of the 0... .ino. the
2 Commonw..lth want.d to p~oo.ld with th.ir witn...... Tb.y
3 a~. h.~.. w. have .pp~oxi..t.ly fou~ witn..... in thi.
4 uttar.
5 THI COURT I Wh.n ar. you going to do th.t?
1 N.xt Tu..day ..yb.'
7 MR. BRAUOHTI Wh.n.v.r the Court would b.
8 av.ilabl.. % blli.v. lt w. ju.t had .bout 48 hour. notic.
~ or.o % can g.t a hold of th..e wi tn..... and b. abl. to
10 have tb.. ooa. in h.r.. And th.n w.'r. going to a.k the
11 Court to oonlidlr .oa. bail.
12 THI COURT I No bail. H.'. It.ying in j.il.
13 I think b. o.~tainly ha. a right to pr...nt hl. wltn.....,
14 and I'll oontinu. ..king a di.po.ition, but h. i. going to
15 .tay in jail until thil i. r..olv.d.
11 MR. BRAUOHTI If the Court ..y have . b..ring
17 th.n ..yb. Thurlday aft.rnoon or I' .oon I' po..ibl. 10 Mr.
18 Baughaan'. not in j.il until w. can .ch.du1. .o..thing.
It THI COUlTl Jo., would you g.t the
ao .ppointm.nt .oh.dul. frGa 'andy, Ind w,'ll ju.t ... wh.n w.
a1 oan do .oa.thing b.r.. W.'ll h.ar your wi tn..... today, Mr.
aa ,lao.y. I don't know it Ni.. ..ughaan would lik. to bl
ZJ b.r., I gu... .b. would, wh.n hi. wi tn..... t..tity. '0 I'm
a4 not .ur. what h.r work .ob.dule i.. Hav. h.r O~ up b.r.
at one.. rridlY, what Ir. your wor~ ~ur.'
.
'It,
1
3
3
4
I
.
7
.
,
10
11
13
13
14
11
l'
17
~
~
11 THI COURT, That'. r.ally not good tor ...
111 Thur.day aorning WI have ~uv.nill'. X don't know how lont
20 that'. going to tak.. Xt'. ~uat hard to work ,0Mlthin, lik.
31 thi. in thi. w..k. Lat'. .... o.t your .0h.dull out tor
32 n.xt w.ak. % oould do it Monday attarnoon.
3) Ha. DlAUGHT, X'd b. avallabl. at that ti..,
24 Your Honor.
35 Tal COU'T, Can you b. b.r. at ),007
M8. IAUOKNANI % work Monday through rriday
'130 to 1130, but .ino. thla i. oar ahow w..kand X have to
work until tiv., and it'. r.al hard for .. to get ofr thi.
w.ek.
THI cOURTI What'. that'
NI. IAUOKNANI It'a r.al hard for .e to ,et
off thi. w.ek. I took off today for thi..
THI COURT I You don't have to ooae baok.
NI. IAUOKNANI I want to b. h.re.
THI COURT I W.ll, % don't know what to do.
Ha. llAUOHTI X.. availabl. rriday
afternoon, Your Honor.
THI COURT I %'v. got a oar..r
M.ohanioaburg Higb lohool rriday aft.rnoon.
aft.rnoon i. out for ...
Ha. IlAUOHTI Thur.day aft.rnoon al.o I'YI
day in
'0 rriday
got.
.
I
!
.
r'
1
~
I
4lIIiI
""
1 .... IAVOIlMANI Y...
2 TNI COVlTI Ok.y. We'll ju.e .,.,. lor tho
, r..or4, 'h. ',ot..eion 'roa Abu.. ho.rin" ,'e.r h..rint
4 tod.V, wlll b. .oneiAu.d until Monday, April 34th, 1"', .,
I '100 p... Th. Cou,e dir.ot. 'h. D,'.nd.nt r...in ln ou.todv
. until 'h. h..rln, i. Qonolud.. on th.t d.to. W. wlll now
1 proo..4 to h..r tho t..tlaony ot wlenl.... 'or tb.
I C....nw..lth.t 'hi. \,...
, NI. 'LACIYI Th. C~nw..lth ,. ..llint
10 D..,. D.vl., Your MOn4r.
11 .... '~VOMTI I'. unawar. ot how ..ny
13 wltn..... 'hi C..-onw..lth In,.n4. t. ..11, bu' it th.r. .r.
lJ ..,. thin OA' wl'n... I would a.k for ..qu..traclon 01 tho
14 wi tn......
11 TlCI COVIT I I don' c know.
1. NI. 'LACIYI 1'. only pl.nnin, on ..11int
11 Nl.. Dovi, ... Ni.. "U9haan .c 'hi. poinc, Your Mono.. Z
11 4oft'l 'hilA "', ft......ry ,~ ..~..'.r h...
1. IMI COVaTI Pi4 .h. ... hi. ln 'h. bU1lding'
30 MI. 'LACIYI No, 140ft" bolllv, '0, on lh.,
n 'IY.
U TlCI eOfllT I On Uth oy .. I&lel you ... hi. 1n
31 'h. ~1lell.. '~l. "V'
U .... "'"'111M' NtI.
U tU corn.1. .. .11M. ....'. N' .. ey..."....
.
.,I(
1
2
3
4
5
.
7
.
.
10
11
13
U
14
15
11
17
11
11
20
31
n
33
;U
2S
""""
""
I'. not going to ..qu..t.r h.r. 00 ah.ad.
MR. 'LACIYI Tbank you, Your Honor.
Whereupon,
DllRA DAVU
having be.n duly .worn, t..tified a. follow"
DXlleT IXANINATION
IY MR. 'LACIYI
OM.'.., would you till u. your n..l, and .p.ll
your le.t nea. for the b.nlfit ot thl oourt r.port.r,
pl.....,
A My nea. i. Dlbr. D.vi..
o Do you w.nt to pull that .loropbon. a littl.
olo..r to you"
A My n... i. Debr. D.vi., P...v-i-..
o And whir. do you live"
A 33 Morth Middl.ton load.
o Who do you live thlre witb7
A With ~aur. I. .aug~n and MY thr.. ohildr.n.
Q And bow old ar. your thr.. obildrln'
A T.n, .i., and on. y..r. old.
o ".r. you hoa. .t the r..ideno. on Maroh l'tb,
lun
A Y.., I WI'.
Q D~ you know Thoaa. "U9baan"
A ,", I 40,
.,
'f)'
.,"",
1"""',
1 0 How do you know bi.'
2 A H. w.. IUrrhd to r..un .. laugl\llah.
) 0 On th. 18th of Maroh of thh y.ar, did you
4 ..a hi. whila you w.r. .t hoa.'
5 A Y.., % did.
15 0 Would you taU tha Judga about that, plla..'
7 A I w.nt to the bathroom, .nd I b.ard a nol...
I '0 I look.d out the window, and the porch light wa. on, And
, bltw..n -V car and har car, h. wa. .tanding th.r. .Making a
10 oig...atta. And I ran out qulok to gat r.lura and th.., to
11 t.l1 tham, and th.y .aid, call the oop.. and wa did. And
12 b.fora that happ.ned, ay oar light wa. on. 'o..body wa. ln
13 th.r. praviou.ly to that. and I .hut MY 0.1' door th.n, And
14 than wh.n the oop. arriv.d .nd .tuff, I w.nt baok out. My
15 oar light wa. blak on again. Jut, .ir, aVlry night ..
1. Tnl COURT I Now, w.it. I think you b.tt.r
17 ju.t an.wlr the qu..tion. that M~. Pllo.y a.k.. 00 aha,d,
lilY NR. 'LACIY,
U Q Now, you "y a nola. caught your aU.nUon.
20 Do you know what typa of I nol.. wa'r. talkin, .bout'
31 A It w.. a thuap.
22 Q C~lng fro. when'
3J A rro. out,16..
24 0 Now, what type 01 puklRf ..... are w, ,.11&&.,
a. about th.t your oar wa. looatad in?
I
,"
"
a
)
4
I
.
7
I
,
10
11
13
1)
14
n
u
17
U
It
JO
U
U
U
,"'"'"
,-.
A I' WI' in 'h. d~iv,wIY.
TN' COUJ". D~1vIWI)' to 'hi hou.e?
TN' WITMI... Y...
IV Ma. ,LAC., I
o
hou..hold'
A
o
And wh.r. w.r. 'h. r... or the .~.r. 0' tb.
Th.y wlr. out ln th. ki'.b.n.
Do.. 'h. _i,.h.n II" 'h. driv,wIY ln .ny
w.y'
A V...
o Wha' '1.. .1 4ay .r. w. 'alkint .~"
A IV.It'",.
o '1.1)' ,v'Al"" La,. ,vIRint'
A I' wa. latl .v'.1Rf.
o W.r. any ., lh. bou"hold -..b.r. in you.
..r'
A h.
o Why .id y.u ,..1 il n......ry t. t.l1 Llur.
l'" h. w.. 'h",'
A ....U.. ~n h. ..... .,0UA4 .nd h. 'l"" ..
Ma. lJAVOM'. ~,..'iOA, r.l.v.n.., .. &0 wh)'
.51 '.14 U",.,
"'. Coval, OOI.uloIl. the ..,.oUon. 00
I
I
i
!
H 4M44.
H
,
,.. 1fl"nfU"~ ... 51 .... u@Ull(l u4 ..
.
1
2
3
4
It
.
7
I
,
10
11
12
13
U
15
11
17
11
U
20
21
22
U
2t
n
~
1"""\
throw. .tone. and .tuff at th. wlndow. and all, I've got
th~.e kid. in th.r., and % alway. t.ll h.r beoau.a ,h.'d go
look.
IY MR. PLACIYI
Q Wa. th.r. any damage to your oar?
A No. %t wa. ju.t gott.n into.
o How about any damage to the hoa.?
A In the trail.r ther.'. lik. a .light d.nt in
the baok of th. wall of the trail.r, and th. door" b..n
pri.d. I r.plao.d the look in the trail.r.
o I. thi' from th. night ot the 18th?
A No.
o Wa. tb.r. any damage --
A My front door and .y look, it don't work no
IIlOn. .~body had a knife in th.re and hid b.en prying at
it.
Tnt COURT. Wait a .inut.. W.'re only
d.aling h.r. with an inoid.nt that alleg.dly ooo~rr.d "aroh
18th. '0 w.'r. not oono.rn.d about what happ.ned IIlOnth. ago
or what .h. didn't .... I'd like ju.t . littl. .or. d.t.il
where b. wa. when .h. .aw hi..
IY TIll COUaT I
o Wh.r. wa. h.?
A a. wa. in b.tw..n ., oar an4 ~.ur. ..~~'.
"'.".
10
1
2
)
4
,
,
7
I
,
10
11
12
U
14
15
11
17
11
U
20
21
2Z
2)
:It
:n
Q
you rant?
It
Q
It
"""
1"""'1
w.. thi. -- thi. wa. on your prop.rty wherl
Ya..
Wa. ha in tha driveway'
Y...
Q Ha w..n't out on tha .treatt
It No.
Q All right. What wa. h. doing Wh.n you look..
out and .aw hi.?
A H. w.. .making a aigar.tt..
THI COURT I Okay.
Ill' MR. 'LACIY I
Q How tar away trOll bl. wer. yout Nbat "I' th.
dietana.?
A It wa. about from wb.r. 1'. .1ttlRf to the
lady in th. ohair b.ok tb.rl .itting.
Q Dir.atly behind ..?
A Y...
IY Tltl COuaT I
Q
approxiaat.ly'
A
Q
A
o
And wbat ti.. did YO\l ..y thi. WI'
It wa. around 10, 101'0 at a1,h'.
10 to 10.JO. Did you "y anytblRf ,. h1.,
No.
Old YO\l '0 o\lt,&d"
u
1
a
J
4
.
.
.,
I
,
10
\1
13
U
H
, ,
U
17
U
"
Hi
H
U
.n
H
H
-.
,.,...,
A X w.nt out.id. aft.r the oop. got th.r.,
o And wa. h. .till th.r. wh.n the oop. got
'h....'
A
o
A
IY Na, .UCIY I
No, Th.y did not .11 hi..
OkaV.
That alway. happena.
o
A
W.r. you abl. to .- Gould you ... hi. fao.'
I ...n hi.. M. had a b.ard and .u.taob. and
. hat,
o W.r. you abl. to ..k. 'Y' contaot with hl.'
A X ~u., look.. at hi. taol to ..k. .ur. it wa.
bi., aAd I ran out quiGk.
o Th. p.r.on you .aw, i. h. in the oourtrooa
h.,. '''ay'
A YI" M.'. .ltting rilht ov., th.,.,
(lndt..Ungl
o Thr.. ..a'. away ',oa ..,
A YII.
o '.u w.,. p.int'ftI. low long dld you ..av in
'h. heu.. ~.r'f' lh. poll.. ar,iv..'
A It WI. .~.ul \0, 11 .'nut." I think, un'il
Ihay ,., Ih....
o Dht yw ... '" wMClh cUreotion he ..y hev.
I..H
u
so '
1
:I
J
4
5
.
7
.
,
10
11
12
13
14
11
It
17
11
1t
:10
:11
22
2J
:14
at
.-"",
,....
A
Q
.omlthing?
A
No.
Ar. you okay? Do you want loa. watlr or
Nay I?
HR. 'LACIYI Thlt'. all of thl qu..tion. that
% hav..
TKI COURT. Cro.......ln..
CROI. IXANINATION
BY HR. IUUOHT I
Q Ni.. Davl., you lndicat.d the Plr.on you .aw
.tanding bltw..n thl two oar. had a blard and a ~.taoh., i.
that right?
A YI..
Q Looking at Mr. Baughman h.r. todlY, 1. it
your rlooll.otlon that h. had thl .... typl oC b.ard and
au.tlchl that h. hi' today a. the p.r.on you .aw on the
lItb?
A YI..
Q What type oC hat wa. it that bl w.. w..ring?
Wa. it a ba'lball typl bat?
A It w.. a ba..ball type hat.
o And h. wa. w.arlng lt .0 that the bill wa.
,aoing forward? I. that . y..?
A YIt.
o Now. you didn't ... the "f'oa affive 1DtO
u
SI
;;li:~
......
~
1 tb. d~iv.way, did you,
2
3
A
No.
o
And you didn't '" th.. l..v. th, drivew.y'
. You ju.t .aw th.m .tanding out ther.' I'. lorry. You'r,
5 going to have to .ay y.. o~ no '0 the court r.por..r ..n ..
.
7
A
v...
o
And wh.n you .aw th.. .tandlng out tb.r.,
. w.r. th.y faoing on. ot tb. two o.r.'
II
A
The oar. w.r. like thl. way. Okay. And b.
10 wa. 11kl -- lik. tbi. .tanding 100klng up at the trailer,
11
o
H. wa. b.twe.n your oar and Nil' 'IUfhaan"
12 oar"
13
14
11
11
17
18
U
:10
A
VII.
And w.r. thlY park.d .ld. by .&da'
o
A
o
A
o
A
Q
Y...
And wh.t klnd ot oar do you own,
% own . "1 .ri...
And what kind ot oar 1. Nl., .IUfhltA'"
.h. own. a Mu.t.n,.
And the oar. w.r. p.rkld .ldl ~ .1dl IA .hi.
:11 driv.way,
22
23
A
Y...
o
And th. driveway ,.... l.t. tIM "... of '1M
24 tr,il,r ~7
n
A
Y..,
14
r~\
\ :.
~
,....
1 0 And thi. i. a tr.il'r proj.ot tbat you liv.
a in, i. tbat ri,bt'
3 A It'. wh.t,
4 0 It'. a trail.r h~. projeot tb.t you liv. in'
· A A trail.r w. livl 1n, y...
· 0 Jut th.r. ar. oth.r trall.r.,
7 A No.
· 0 Ar. th.r. any oth.r r..ld.nt. n.ar your __
· A Ny 1lOa'. rl,bt down b.low u..
10 0 Th. .tr..t .. i. th.r. . .tr..t ri,ht n..t to
11 wh.r. you pUll into your driveway, a .tr..t that oonn.ot. to
lJ your driveway,
13 Ather. i. a rOld.
14 0 Th.r. ar. no .tre.tli,ht. on tbat road'
11 A No.
1. 0 And you W.r. in.id. the hou.. at the ti..
11 waen you .aw the ,.r.on .. in.ide 0' your tr.tl.r'
1. A Y...
I' 0 Who .1.. w.. in.id. the trail., at tba. ti..'
ao A Llura ..ug....." and My kid..
al 0 W.... '0 ah.ad.
aa A And b.r boyt,ten4.
IJ 0 Nt.. "Uf~"'. boy'rilnd'
'4 A Y...
" 0 Aay... .1..,
II
l,,"",
"..,
1 A And hh frhnd.
2 0 Nr. laughman" friend?
J A No. Keith'. frhnlS.
4 0 Okay. Ni.. laughaan" boyfri.nd'. frienlS?
, A Right.
S 0 Tho.e p.opl. that you ju.t ..ntioned, w.r.
7 they all in tbe kitob.n at tbl. ti..?
1 A Ya..
. 0 And which room, again, w.r. you in?
10 A %n the b.throom.
11 0 Do the bathrOOM anlS the kitohen conn.ct?
12 A No.
13 0 How far apart an th.y?
14 A I'd .ay froa .a to a little pa.t you.
l' 0'0 about 20 f.at 01' .o? Do.. that .oun4
1. about right?
17 A % gu....
11 0 The phon. that you call.1S the polic. fr~,
l' wh.r. wa. that looat.d?
30 A % oall.d th.. on I.lth'. porta-phone, bit
21 o.llular phon..
22 0'0 that wa. right on x.lth', p.rlon?
2J A light.
24 0 NOW, the b.throoa that you w.re ln, ther.'. a
2' wlndow tb.t look. out onto tbi. driv.way?
11
1
2
3
4
5
.
7
I
,
10
11
12
U
14
11
11
11
11
U
30
U
n
n
24
at
''''
~
A light.
Q How bl, 11 tkat wl,","'
A It'. about ..
TIll COUlTI Ixo,," ... Ar. tho.. two IJ\IY'
baak thl" bi. wi tn.....'
Ma. alAUOHTI Not that I'. aw,,', 01, Your
Honor.
TIC' CouaTI Who an yo,,?
MAN 1M aACK or COVITlOONI I'. ..i'h.
TIC' COUlT I I'. .o....y,
Ma. alAUOHTI I b.li.v. h.'. .,.'lnt that
tb.y'r. with Nl.. 'a",baan.
TIC' COUlTI They'r. with h.,. OkIY.
If Ma. IUUOHT I
Q II ,h. bldro_ .. ...\111... TM It.,h,...
window tMt yO\! WI" 10aU", 0\1'. how It&, 11 tMt wi""""
A It'. thl. b&, and tkat wl".
Q '0 about .l, lMh.. wl'. aA4 ea.ft' . '00' 04
. MlI hllM
A Y...
Q Do.. l' MV' ."".lR' .. i"
A MI.
Q A.. '"'I w.... Of ..... 0\1"'" 'US
window?
A .,.,
\1
1"-
, .
1
2
3
4
I
.
7
.
,
10
11
12
U
14
11
U
17
11
11
30
U
U
U
at
U
,-,
,.....
o Now, the kitob.n al.o eao.. out onto tb.
drivlWaYI i. tblt rigbt'
A Y...
o And th.r." window. in tb. kltob.n'
AYe..
o Wh.n you w.nt from the bathroom into tb.
kitob.n, did you look out the window to ... if the p.r.on
wa. .till th.r.'
A When % wlnt to the kitch.n'
o y...
A No.
o Do you know if .nyon. .1.. in tblt roOM
100k.d out the wlndow to ... ir the p.r.on wa. .till tb.r.'
A No.
o Haw long from the ti.. you w.nt .- wh.n you
l.ft the bathrooa, a. tar .. you're aw.r., WI' the p.r.on
.till out in the driv,wlY'
A I don't know b.olu.. I' .oon I' % ...n hi.,
11k. I .aid, % turned around, 0... out, Ind I told ~aura.
o 'a i...dlat.ly fro. ...lng thlt p.r.an you
w.nt out inta the kltoh.n'
AYe..
o What w.. tb. p.r.on wllrint thlt nlgh"
A ~i.. I .ald, h. wa. w..rlng . hat.
a O.k.y, K. wu waul", . ha"
11
(.'1-
__> t'
.......
"'"
1 A Y...
2 Q Ad what .1Ia"
3 A And h. w.. w.aring a .hirt and j.an..
4 Q What 0010" .hirt.,
5 A What 0010"" I dic1n' t take notio..
, Q Could you hav. ...n th. oolo,,?
7 A Ylah, but % ju.t thought about -- aft." I had
I ...n hi. ._ g.ttlng out th.r. and t.lling h.r.
, Q What kind of pant. wa. h. w.aring?
10 A J.an., h. had on.
11 Q w.. the p.r.on you .aw .t.nding right by a
12 driv.r'. door to on. of th. car.?
13 A H. w.. .tanding lik. right up th.r. by the
14 top of the door, lik. by the hood ther..
15 Q And did you hav. a dir.ot.on vi.w fro. the
l' b.tbro~ to --
17 A Y...
11 Q What kind of .hirt wa. the p.r.on w.aring?
l' MR. .LACUYI Obj.ction, a.k.d and an.w.r.d.
20 MI. lRAUOHTI I b.li.v. I a.k.d what oolor
31 .h1rt, Your Konor.
22 THI COUJTI H. a.k.d what color. 1 don't
23 think b. .aid what type ot .hlrt. Tb. obj.otion"
24 ov.nuled.
n
u
5'7
,....,
~,
1 IY Na. IUUGJrf.
a Q What 'Vp' 0' .hi,t wa. thl ,.r.on w.aring,
) A IC, w.. w,.,i", . ,ho,t..l..v.d .hir..
4 Q W.. h a du.. .bArn A ,-.hhU
I A A t..hht.
. Q Ju.',o WI hav. a ol.ar und.r.,anding of wh.,
7 happ.n'd, -r UA4.r.'.ndln, i. you h..rd a nol.. out.ld., I,
I 'h., rl,h" An4 th.n you look.d out th.' window'
, A Y...
10 Q AntS you .IW . p.non " U,.t wln40w -. or
11 fUl.id' 1ft 'hi driveway, and th." you i...di.t.ly w.nt into
13 lh. kit.hen .ad you told Mi.. 'authaa"7
U A Y...
14 Q', you w.r. th.r. vlewlAf '''routh that window
I' II" lhaft 'Iv. ....nd. b..au.. you "..d,4 ,. '0 t.ll MI..
U '1118-'"
17 "Ye. .
1. Q Th. lit'" lhl' yeu ,.1k.d .-.ut th., w., on
If 8\1'''' ,... ,,'lfh, i. ,hat H' ., 'ho.. "118 11th'. ''''''.
30 y.l1aw ift ..II"
n A Mo, n'. wtlU"
U ... IJ.AVGH'. tNt"'l1 I UVI, YQI,I,Mo..,.
H t1UI eon,. Mr, fl..." &I\Y &441"...1
H ..........,
H
,"g
.t '\MR. 'If, 'nf~.,
it
1
2
:s
4
5
.
7
I
t
10
11
12
13
14
11
11
17
11
1t
:10
n
U
:J)
24
:II
'""
,....
alDlalCT IXAMINATION
BY MR. 'r.ACIYI
0
window,?
A
0
A
h.
0
Ni.. Davi., ar. th.r. ourtain. on tb. kitoh.n
Y...
Do you know what typ.?
w. have blind. and bright blu. ourtain. ov.r
Tb. poroh light, i. that -- what dir.otion of
the b~. do.. that .hln. onto?
A It .hin.. the whole w,y onto the hou.., and
th.n down by the driv.way, onto the driv.way.
o Th.r.'. only on. driv.way?
A y...
MR. 'LACIYI That'. all of the qu..tion. that
% hav., Your Honor.
BY THI COURT I
o Thi. tral1.r wh.r. you liv., do you own that
tuUar?
A My aoa do...
o Your aoa 401.. AA4 you r.nt it froa h.r.
And Ni.. ..ughaan, how lon, ba. .b. liv.d th.r. at that
traU.r?
A .h.,. "..n witb .. .1no. .b. l.'t b.r
bu."a"'.
u.
{ '/
.J
...."
r-,
1 0 And do you know about how long that would b.,
2 W.ll, % oan elk h.r that. All rlght. How ..ny ti... b.lor.
3 H.roh 18th hev. you ...n the del.ndant'
4 A Non., but I know h.'. b..n out th.r. b.aau..
5 of the noi.e and all.
S Q At any plaa., at any tl.. b.for. Narob 11th'
7 A Oh, h.'. 0... up to the traU.r and aotuaUv
8 knook.d on the door and I l.ft hl. in b.for. the ,rA ord.,
, had 0... through.
10 Q And do you know how uny U... th.. .i,h'
11 have b..n'
12 A That we. twlol.
13 Q'o at lea.t two tl... b,'.r. 'hi. i.ll'.A' hI
14 0... to thl trall.r end you l.ft hi. lA.14., aAd h. a" K1I.
15 Baughman talk.d. '0 you .aw bl. th.n. Dld VOY ... hi. IAV
11 oth.r ti.. oth.r tban th... two prlor ti...,
17 "No.
11 THI COUaTl '0 I ,",d."taM th." you would
l' hav. ...n hi. a tot.l of thr.. tl."1 twl.. ~"or. ao4 'hll
20 partioular nlght.
:n MJ. .-.AUGHTl hur "o".r, ..y I '.Uew v, "
~~ tho.. qu..tion.'
~) TNI C:OUlTl y.ah. 1'. '~n 'rylAf 'I 'II''''
~4 lf I want to a.k anytbi~ .1,.. Ar. YOY ,..,.iv. ,~, ,~
~5 guy you .aw tha' Bi,ht w.. hi.,
II
<""\
"'"
1 TNI WITNI"I Y",
a TNI couaTI 00 .h..d, Hr. Ir.ught.
J a.cao.. IIAMINATION
4 IV Ma. lAAUOHT I
. 0 Ni.. Davi., you indio.t.d th.t prior to thi.
t "A b.int .nt.red you b.d ...n or ..t Hr. '.ughaan twio., i.
., 'h., d,h"
I A Y.ah.
. 0 On tho.. two prior o....lon., w.. h. ol..n
10 . hav." ,
11 A Th.t Z don't ,...-b.r,
13 0 You don't r...ll .t .11 wb.th., h. b.d .
1) b..f..f' au.t.oh. or no f.aial bair at all?
14 A That I don't reMlMb.r. Look, .v.ry night I
11 ,. t. .1..p on th.' floor with -r kld. b...u.. Z .. '0
U p.nUl.d.
l? MA. lAAUGWTI Your Monor, th.r.', no qy,.tion
1. ~.,... 'h. wltn....
l' TNt COuaTI I .,....
~ 0 IY HII. IlAAlIOMT I
11 0 And you hlY' ROt ...n Mr. ..Uf.... .i...
II lh@.. ,wq ,'10' .....1.". ....,t lOf what y~'f' ...'llyl.,
JI ,. Mf' ,.y?
I. A Y."
n HI, '.L\'1CIIT1 TNt'I.U I MY'.
n
1
2
)
4
I
I
.,
.
,
10
11
12
U
14
11
11
17
11
11
20
U
22
U
24
at
~
~
Ma. 'LACIYI Your Honor, ir 1 ..y.
llDllleT IXAMINATION
IY Ma. ,LACIYI
0
.aughllan?
"
0
A
.aughllan.
0
"
Did you know Nr. laughllan blfor. Laura
y...
How did you know bi.?
I.oau.. I want out with hi. broth.~, Chl.tlr
Whan w.. thief
Thll wa. about, I'd .ay a y... and a balf ago
to alaol' 2 y.ar..
o And that wa. bator. you knew Laura 'augbaan?
A % knaw hII'.
IY TIll COtlaT I
o Wait. That doa.n't add nothlng. A Y'I~ and
a half ago you want with hl. broth.r?
A Y...
o Did you ... hi.?
" Y.., I ...n hl..
o I thought I a.k.d you how ..ny t1... blforl
'hl. date you .aw hl.. You .ald twi.. wh.n h. .... to your
'..aUer .
It. M.ll, I dldA't r.ali.. .. 1 'bougbt you
..ant ..
H
''J..
,"'"'
~
1 0 At any ti.. in the pa.t, how ..ny 'i... hlV.
2 you ...n tbi. guy?
J A Oh, go.h, I'v. ...n hl. lik. tour 'i... III
. tOllathtr.
5 Q rour tl... b.tor. th. two ti.a. thl' h. ,...
I to tha trail.r?
7 A ra., an4 ona ti.. witb hi. ~roth.r. And than
. tha night at the 11th. I'. .orry.
, 0 I don't know how aany .i.... 'ha .ay. .h.
10 .aw hi. on th. lltb. .h. .ay. h. ,... to h.r trailar twi..
11 b.fora, and I don't know how alny tl... b.for. that you 'IW
12
13
14
1!l
16
17
11
U
~o 0 ~u.t to oov.r tho.. .'h.r 'i... tn., y~I,.
~1 talking about b..i4.. thl two It 'h. "Iil." 00 I.y .r
~2 tho.. oth.r oGoI.ion. do you r"ll1 if Mr. ..~.... ha4
~) taolal h.ir It Ill?
at A V...
nOWay ~..ll . YII' 'M . MIf ..., tWO r.....
hill. Do you know bow aany ti... b.tor. that?
A I'd ..In ht. a ooupl. tt....
THI COVlT I A 001lp1l ...... AU rilht. Go
ahlac1.
.. ,LACS, I Thl", III I hav., 'WI ....."
TNS COVlT I Nr. "luthi, any'htnt al..,
.ICtO.. IXAMINATION
IY NIl. IUUGftTI
II
(,1
1
2
J
4
I
.
.,
.
.
10
n
13
U
14
11
If
11
U
U
10
U
U
U
U
at
,^""
I"".
a,o' I. tha' . V'"
A Y...
o Ivt you don" r.,al1 if h. had f.,ial hair
the two tt... h. ,... to yovr trail.r'
A Z don't r..UIbu.
Ma. lJAUOHTI Th.t', all Z hav..
TNI COUaTI No fu~th.~ qu..tion.. Than\ vov,
Ni.. Davi.. yov..V .t.p down. 00 .h.ad.
NI. .LACSYI Th. Co..onw.alth oal1. Lavra
la~haan, pl.....
Wh.reupon,
LAURA I. IAUCJIOWf
haviftl ~..n dvly .wo~n, ,..titl.d .. tollow.1
DIalCT .lAMINATION
IY Ma. .LACIY I
o ~'''' will you tIll u. your n...'
A L.ur. I. '.ughaan.
o AA4 whIr. do yov llv.'
A I) NOlth Niddl.ton aOI., C.rli.l..
g Would you .e.arib. that prop.rtv for the
11Mt.,
A What do you ..an by ...orlb.1 Th.r.'. a
aov.. .. okay. You oo.a off the road, olr ot North
Jll441et.. "d. you.... up the d,lYaway. ThIn'. a ho\a..
I. .-. ff~', aA4 ,... t.a ',atl., i. 11ka 3. f.., Ir.. the
H
''If
,"'"
1""\
1
2
3
4
5
,
7
.
,
10
11
12
U
14
11
U
17
11
U
20
21
U
23
24
:It
bou...
Q Clo..~ to tba road or b.bind tb. bou..'
A I.bind the bou...
Q All rigbt. Who liv.. in tbat bou..?
A D.b'. par.nt..
Q How big h tbh driveway? lIow wid.? How
many oar. Gan drive down ther.?
A W.ll, w. g.t thr.. Gar' .id. by .id. in the
driv.way.
Q %. that the only way into the trail.r?
A Y.., .XG.pt up and around the fi.ld., but
driving up, tb. driv.way, tbat'. the only way.
Q How far tro. tb. road h tb. tnU.r?
A I'd ..y about 711 h.t to 100 f..t.
Q Can you ..1 .. .trik. that. Do.. the boae
blOGk your -- any view from tb. road7
A 'rom the kitoh.n wlnc10w that D.b wa. talking
about and troa the door, you aan ... the whole way down the
driveway.
0 Now, on the lltb or NarGb, thh y.ar, )'01&
w.r. boa. .. w.r. you b~.?
A y.., I wa..
0 And wh.r. war. yo,,'
A % wa. out in tb. kHoh.n.
0 Wh4tt w.... you guy. doi~ cxat t.. tbe U",*"
n
b~
."""
r\
1 A WI wlrl 'Ilkln,.
2 0 Whit dld YOy do Wh.n D.b Illr,.d you,
J A My flr.' In.tlnot WI' to go out and look. ..
4 % opln.d up thl door, and I w.nt down. And by th. '1.. I
5 got th.r. nobody wa. th.r., but thl o.r door WI' .p.nf4
S bleau.1 .h. h.. . 11ttl. llght on h.r on. .1d. 01 b.r ...
7 that ..id it wa. op.n, you know.
S 0 Wh.n you .ay you went down, w.nt ~ wh.r.'
, A W. w.nt down to the v.hiol. ju.' to ... i. w.
10 oould ... anybody oOMlng out ot thl drlvaway or in ih.
11 ttald. or anything.
12 0 Old you go any furth.r'
13 A No.
14 0 Did you ..a anybody'
15 A No, You ha.'d th. dot. blrk .~.
lS 0 Who.. doU' bark'
17 A Th. peopl. aoro.. th. r.a4. V'uIlly ,'''',
lS how w. know that .~ona'. th.,a.
l' 0 A't.r you Ih.ok.d out the I.f.. wha, 414 y.u
:10 do'
21 A I w.nt ba.k up lnt. th. ".ll.r, I" tv ,&at
2:1 tl.. Dab w.. .till on th. phonl with '11.
:I) 0 How dill you ,..1 kJl.OW1Df tb." TMu. ,""'...
:14 w.. on your prop.rty1
:JI Ma. 'l.\VQft, OPtMUM, Ul...uu.
It
~""
'"
i TNI COURTI I'll .u.tain the Obj.ation. It
a do..n't r.quir. that .h. b. .oar.d Or anything .1,.. All it
J r.quir.... ir he'. on tb. prop.rty, h... in violation of .y
. ord.,.
t IV TNI COIIIIT I
I 0 Whil, ha'. thinklng, Ni.. Davi, t..ti,i.d
7 tha' ....ti.. I gu... a't.r you .nd h. had ..parat.d wh.n
I you w.r. living at the trail.r h. 0... out to the trailer
· ..v.ral ti... to ... you, i. tbat right?
10 A y... I w.. at work wh.n.v.r h. did tbat.
11 0 You w.r.n't in the tr.il.,?
13 A WOo Th.r. wa, on. tl.. h. drove my C'dlllaa
1) up th. drlveway and dropp.d it otr th.r..
It Q I thought 'h. .ald ,h. 1.t hi. in the hou..?
II A 'h, did. 'h,'. .oar.d to d..th ot tbi, aIn.
II 0 'ut you w.r.n't th.r.?
17 A Wo. I w.. at work.
II Q Okay.
1. A 'ut a. ,oon al I 0... hoat, that'. wh.n.v.r
ao .h. "1' .. tha' h. wa. 'h.r..
Jt 0 All rilht.
j~ A.. wa. ,I.. th.r. on. ti.. ..
U TlCI COURTI WaH. atnlA", I oAly ..kid )'OU
U lwln. '""'t/....n.... "14 ,hi ..w hi.. 00 .h.84.
U
u
~!'l ·
.-,
,-.
1 IY MR. 'LACIYI
2 Q Whit ",p, hive you tlk.n to kllp bi. olf thl
3 property?
4 MR. lRAUaHTI Obj.ation, r.llvlnal.
I THI COURT I I don't know what .tap. .. I told
, hl. to .tay 01' the prop.rty. I don't thlnk it matt.r. what
7 .t.p. .h.'. tlk.n. Would that havI any r.llvlna., Nr.
. ,1IalY, what .t.p. .h. took? If it dOl. I'. wllling to h.ar
, it, but .. go ab.ad.
10 NIl. 'LACIY, If I aauld ju.t bav. a little
11 ground hlr. to a.k on. qul.tion, and it may b. a littll
12 leading.
1) THI COURT, y..h. It hi'. 011 that property,
14 h.'. in vlolation 0' .Y ard.r and I'. going to ..nd hi. to
15 jlill but what .t.p. .h. took to k'lp hi. oft the prop.rty,
l' I'. not .ur. it thlt'. rll.vant or not.
17 MR. .LACIY, I'll withdrlw thl qu..tlon th.n,
II Your Honor. That'. III or the qu..tion. thlt I have.
11 THI COU.TI Cro.......in..
30 CRO.I .lAMINATION
21 IY MR. IRAUCJKT,
U 0 Ni.. Ilughaan, it'. .Y und.reundl.ng thl' ..
2) .oon I' Ml., Davl.l a&al into the kitab.n Ind told yo~ tbat
2. Toa 'aug~n WI' out I.n thl drlv.way, you l..-diat'lY wIlkl4
25 out thl door Ind down the drlvlway1
JO
""'"
"'"
A
Q
p&'obably le..
tnUn?
A
Q
A
Q
Q
A
Qontuling.
Q
tl....
A
H
1
2
3
..
5
I
7
.
,
10
11
13
U
14
15
11
17
11
U
20
21
n
:Ii
24
U
.....,
,-..
a "a'Ia, on tbo.e two oooa.ion. do you know ir
Thoaa. .aughman had taoial bair?
A Iver .ino. % left him .. tber. wa. one tim.
b. didn't bave it whenever % 1.ft him.
a Do you know if tbat would bave b..n around
tb. ti.e that "1.. Davi. i. .aylng that Hr. laughman oaml by
the bou..?
A I don't know. I didn't ... tha man.
MR. IRAUOHTI That'. all % bav..
BY THI COURT I
a Ml.. Davi. .aid tbat thi. inoid.nt took plao.
bltw.ln approximat.ly 10 to 10130 at nlght on the 11th.
What would your ..tlmatl b. of the approximate ti..?
A It wa. around that time beoau.. we w.r. ~u.t
putting the kid. down.
a And %'ve tQrgott.n fro. all of the oth.r
haaring., wben did you two ..parate?
A It wa. tbe day right att.r Chri.tma., Maroh
27tb .. or not Maroh 27tb. D.o.Mber 27th.
a It would havI b..n .o.ewh.r. in tb. .nd of
D.olMblr of 1"., i. that rlght?
A Y.ah.
o
bou.. with bu
b.,
In addition to Nl.. Davi. that ni,ht in the
thr.e ohildren, your boylri.nd .. and who i.
u
70
1
2
3
4
5
,
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
111
17
18
U
20
21
22
23
24
:u
,
,.....
A ICdth.
o lC.ith. An4. fri.nd 0' lC.i,h', W.. 11..
th.n?
A V... w. w.r. 'u.t .'.ndln, Iround ,.lkint.
T"I COuaTI Tha". all I h.v.. Any'hlnt
.1.., Mr. .lao.y'
MR. ,LAC'VI V.., Your "onor.
RIDIRICT IIAMINATION
BY NR. 'LACIYI
Q Otb.r th.n th. two oao..lon. ., ,.. .r.il..,
and the lltb at the trall.r, h.v. you b..n Wl'h D'~r. O.vl.
In the pr...no. ot Thoa.. laug~n?
A VtI.
o And how aeny U... w.. th.U
A That'. nuaarou. '1.... Wh.n.v.r I 11v" 1ft
N.wvlll. .b. u..d to 00.. to vlalt ...
o And wh.n you llv.d In Nawvlll. you llv" Wi'.
Thoma. laughman?
A Y.., I did. And 'h.n Wh.n.v., w. would ,.
out to dlnn.r or .oa.thlng Ilk. 'h." .h. wQV14, you kaow,
OOM' .10nf. .h. w.. 'h.r.. .h. w.. wp " 'h. .,.11.,. K.
v.ed to liv. wlth .. up .t th. ".11." The ~n kaow.
what b. look. lik. wltbQut tb. _..r. ,8d wl'h 'h. ~'I,4,
MR. '1.AC1Y, fiat'..n 0' ,.. fIIM'U., U...,
I btlv..
u
,"""
"...
1 TIll COU.TI Mr. .rautht, any addiUonal
2 qII..Uon.'
J Ma. llAUOHTI Z h... no .ddition.l qu..tion..
4 TIll COU.TI Z h.v. no t\luhu qu..Uon. for
I Nr.. "\lfhaan. YOy..y .t" d9wn.
. "I. ,LAC'YI Th.t'. all th. COIIIIOnw..lIlh
1 wo\lld pr...n',
. TIll ~OUIlTI Ok.)'. W,'l1 Itand adjourn.d th.n
. \lntil th. h..rtftl .." Shall I p,.vt.V.ly ..n'ion.d.
10 IWhlrty,.R, ,be p...."int. ,'joYf8.d ., 11140 ....)
11
13
U
14
U
It
11
11
11
ao
n
n
n
u
n
Jt
......
-
~nTnICATION
I h.r.by o.rtify that th. proo..ding. ar. contain.d
fully and aoourat.ly in the not.. tak.n by .. on the abOVI oau..
and that tbi. i. a oorr.ot tran.oript of .....
I ; It ( /:.tl /l ~'I"/: I
AIih.t. A. tippy
Offioial Court a.port.~
..................................
Tb. for.going r.oord or the proo..dinv_ on th. h..ring
of the within ..tt.r i. h.r.by .pprov.d and dir.oted to b.
fil.d,
t I {I (."
Dat.
n
r"'\
,....,
LAUMA I. IAUOIfMAN I
'hinUt; ,
,
V. I
,
TIfOMA. I. IAUOHMAH, I
Det.nd.nt I
IN THE COUJT or COMMON 'LEA' or
CUMIERLAND COUNTY, PENNSVLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. .1-370 CIVIL TIRM
,\4 ilL.. UQItIC'l' i:IUM1tfAL ~'Q1tTIM'"
'IrOJ~ ~'Ufl~Y, ,,~,
O,D'1l or COUIT
AND NOW, thl. a6th a.y of April, 1"1, 1,
th.r.tof'l 'lnd the p.t.naant 9ul1ty or indlr.ot orlainal
oont..,t of court. If. 1. ..nt.no.a to Cu~btrlln4 county .rl.on
for I ,.rlo4 ot torty-riv. d.y., and h. .h.ll be ,1v.n or.41t on
the 'Pov. ..nt.no. trot April ,.th, "'0.
If. "Y be ,.rol~ without turth.r ord.r ot thi. Court
upon ..rvlnq th. rorly-riv. d.y. in jlil. Upon r.l.... trOt
prt.on I dlr.ot th.t h. ., .ll \i... ln th. tutur. oo.plV wlth
the 1n.truetlon. .nd dlr.otton. of thi. ord.r. Th. court
furth.r dl,.ot. lh.t h. PI., lh' oo.t. 0' pro..outlon lnvolv.d in
'hi. H",
Iy th. COllrt,
. ,
1\ di \\
HtiJr.i ,. .1\..1'1 J; .~
r:t ,. "'1lI II W~
..iH-': -,:" -~
""'"
"...,
LAURA E. BAUGHMAN, I
Plaintiff I
I
V. I
I
THOMAS E. BAUGHMAN, I
D.t.ndant I
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS or
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION . LAW
NO. 115.270 CIVIL TERM
IN REI INDIRECT CRIMINAL CONTEMPT
BEFORE SHEELY, P.".
HEMORAND~ OPINION AND ORDER OF COURT
Paraqraph 4 of the protectlon from abu.. order in thl.
oa.. dir.ct. the Detendant to .tay awav trom the r..ldene. ot
the Pl.intitt at 3J North Middl.ton Road, Carli,l', Cu~b'rland
County, ,enn.ylvania.
In thl. ea.e on Maroh lSth, 1995, the Plaintiff, Laura
E. Bauqh.an, wa. livlnq with Edward Davle at 23 North Mlddleton
Road wh.r. .h. ha. be.n r.,ldinq .inc. approxl.at.1y the
parti.., ,eparation.
D.borah Davi. t..tlfled that at approxi.ately 10100 to
10130 on the .v.nlnq of the 11th .he .aw the D.tendant .tan41nq
in the drlvewav of the rl.ldlno. at 23 North Mlddleton Road.
She furthlr t..tltiea that .h. went and told Laura 8auqh.an who
wa. in the kitchen or thl tral1er about thl, lneld.nt and that
th.y w.nt out.lde and dld not ... anyon. at that tl...
At the h.arlnq today two witn..... t.,tlri.d, a aiat.r
Ind a tri.nd ot the D.tendant, that on the 11th h. wa. at a
publio .a1. ~.t ot the diY, that they raturne4 to the Old aap
aOld r..la'nol. that he va. th.re until approxi.atelY 10100 to
f"'\\
,.....
10130 wh.n hi walk.d from on. trail.r to anoth.r tr.l1.r, th.
l.tter trailar b.lnq that ot hl. .1It.r, and that h. dld not
leave the trail.r untl1 the followlnq morninq.
Thoma. B,uQh.an te.tifled al.o that h. w.. at tha
..1., that h. .tayed with hll .l.ter that n19ht, and that on the
fOllowlnq day, the 111th, he left the ar.a wlthout t.lllnq hl.
.l.t.r. He .ald h. waf ln the Atlantic Clty ar.a tor
approxlmat'lY on. month from that dat..
obvlou.ly the d.clelon ln thl. el.. lnvolv.,
or.dlbllltv at the wltn...... con.ld.rlnq .11 t.ct., I acoept
the t..tlllony at D.borah Davl. " b.lnQ truthful and oorrlot. I
flnd the D.t.nd.nt wa. at the r..ld.nee of the Plalntiff at 2J
North Hlddl.ton Ro.d on March 11th, 1'9&, .nd that thl. va. in
vlol.tion of the protection tram abu.. ord.r.
ORDER or coURt
AND NOW, thl. 26th day ot April, 1"1, I,
th.r.tor., flnd the D.t.nd.nt 9ulltV of indlr.ot orl.inal
cont..pt at court. lie 11 ..ntanc.d to Cu.berland County 'rl.on
for a p.riod ot fortv-tlv. d.y., and h. .h.ll be qlv.n ore4lt on
the above ..nt.nc. from Aprl1 11th, 199'.
H. .'V b. plrol.d without furth.r ord.r of tht. court
upon ..rvlnq the forty-tlv. dlY' ln j.ll. Upon r.l.... fro.
pri.on I dlr.ct that h. It .11 tl.... In the tutur. coaply wlth
the inttruetlcn. and dlr.ctlon. or tht. ord.r. Tn. c~rt
furth.r cU...ot. th.t h. pav the oo.ta of prol.ouUon &nvehe4 'I'
"""
~
th1. 0....
I)' the eOllrt,
LlJ H.tQl4 I, .h..IV .
P.j,
Tho... A, 'l.o.y, Ilqu1r.
l.n1or A..1.'ant D1.triot Attorn.)'
ror the eo..onv..l'h
Willi.. a. .r,utht, l.qu1r.
A..i.t.nt Publio a.f.nd.,
ror th. Dlf.nd.nt
CC.
IUh
C.~~. '~.A 'I.J~ r
..
..
I.AtlltA /l.IIAU(JII~,^N.
"lalnlllT
IIN ntll COlJRT Of COMMON PUlA" 0'1
I {'UMIlI!RI.ANl> (,OlJNTY. PHNNSYLVAN'A
I
I
I
" {'IVII. ACTION. LAW
I NO,IJS.270 : CIVil. TI!RM
V.
TIIOMAS 1!.IIAlJOIlMAN.
Iltftndanl
QRllIiR
AN() NOW. Ihlh?J(1I da)'o( tv'" r
In flll1n. pau/'frl..
,j 'I}I}'. ^ppU~1Il11. h,,..by aranltd ,"VI 10 ,prell
7(/ .
DY 11IIlCOlIRT.
l t
J.
Jlu1rj~'", ", . ,
::.J_'_ _~."_~""_ __.._~_._~___..,.,..__
..
'''it .1~W"'A."'H.tI ""1,..,1)
'."PH ...np3 .
AWnO;} OIolVl11Ull'ln"1 <10
..10...1..110 ::lI'IUhllllll ..0 1:>1....0
f i
..~_.._........,..,--.".,.."._~.,~.-,...~."'.,~".,.......,.....---_.-,. "'~
.
. ,
^
-
NO, 91-Z70 CIVIL TllM
LAURA K. "AVOIIMAN,
Plaintiff
V.
TIIOMA. 1:. IIAVOIIMAN,
O.f.M.nt
MOTION roM LIAYI TO APPIAL
IN fORMA 'AU'IM..
'"
\,
"
~
"-
Willi.M 'rauth', I.qul'.
qr'I4' qr tll' 11\I..... ..,....11
CW fIlM"IN.AN8 4iOIJIIfn
4WlJf ..,..
fM4MU, ,~,..._ '''''.
~~~.
~""_~",,"-,,,"".~.
,_'.'n-_"__~'_",_N_"';':;'"'""___."'_~""<""'''0
.~~
1,....
""'"
.
.
.
~~,
,
."
/
,
'"",
,-"
LAUMA 1l.lIMIOIlM^N,
1'lIlnlUf
: IN 11 II! COllkT 011 COMMON PI.I!I\S Olt
I CllMIWKI.I\NIH'OIlNTY. ('ENNSY!. VANIA
I
I 1tc. 'lor ~. /9'/S
I ('IVII. AniON .LAW
! NO, O,.~7(1 : CIVil. TI~RM
V.
'II 10M"" Ii. ItAIJUlIM^N.
l)Wfflldanl
Num;.c.UL\1'l'~
NlIlk. I, hmlty .l~.n thai 'Ihorn.. It 11Iu.lunan. l)wf.ndanl abo~. namtd. h,"b)' .ppe.11 10 the
\uJlftklt ('lllll1ltf ,..,....)1\'11I11 from the Judam.nlllf MI1ItlW.lmp"ttd III ,hi, tnallfr 11/1 April ~6. 199',
. (J.t: /f!;.~4~
William llrautll.1, Illqull1
AulManll'llbllQ Def.nder
A\Wmf)' fill Appellanl
^11omt)' 1.1). mo~
Mlkll)Wlindfr Oflk.
('un.NtIand (.'lIIltll)' (.',IUI1huu..
('.,II.".I'^ 17013
!'hoot: (117) 240.6215
<tt...
PYS510
1995-00270
Cumborl~~d County Prothonotary's Offlco Page 1
'viI Caoo Inquiry f-'
.HO'rEC'rlON .'HOM AOUSE .ded......... 1/18~~i
Judgo ABIIlgnudl
Judgmentl
SHEELY IIAIIOI.O E PJ
.00
Superior Co
Execution Date
Sllt/DlI/O(ltd. .
Jury Trial....
0/00/00
0/00/00
................................................................................
General Index Attorney Info
n~Hgll~~~ ~ngn~sEE gk~i~61k~ SHADE WAYNE'
................................................................................
· Date Entrle. .
................................................................................
01/16/95
01/26/95
01/26/95
01130/95
OVOV1I5
02106/95
OV06/95
OVIO/95
03/06/95
03/24/95
r.lAAr60~ 'RRE[OOJ!CTIVE ORDER AND TEMPORARY PROTECTIVE ORDER BY
~1I~nl~t:1 n8I~GN I~DXER ~~~BNDANT 1/23/95)
OIl~Er./)' COURT .' N *~ PWOTBCTION FROM ABUSE BY JUDOE HAROLD E
1~1~~I~lfi~f~;*f8~~~~~~i~1~~!~~~S~le~R~i~llfB!~:16~06Ix~:2:ERSONALLY
glt~ns 0 A ~~~ST :II 7/t~. R, ~PPOIJ.'NT COURT BY JUOO' "'OLD , "IE'L Y
~n~~r.yO egg"r lCfl ~ M rl.p.l'i !~4~ bND HEARINO DATE: SET BY JUDOE HAROLD E
~~DE~o~rciOH~~p;RY 2jV~9i51lAROl6 E SIlEELY . COPlES MAILED 2/13/95
8Sr.'~flO~A~P.~~TJ-6!U"lRE CONTEMPT BY JUDGE IlAROLD E SHEELY
8R~~?"~t:A~6U~~M(:~1'.lAboNR~~~ A HEMl~awYU X"~R9IS1i' ISD1RfiCT I
~'~i'i5or TilE DF.fENl>AN~ BY J8~i nbOLB R sltdt:Y . WOTICi Ml~fEO
04/20/9' fl~~fiVN8ycC~2~V~U6-I>IN,,~I/U~A~:gg ~ATlySSODO~ ~~~8tHDI iftlIlVONY
COVIES HA Llm 4 20 !
84/21/\15 TItAN8CIIII' VII.F.)
5/05/\l! ~~H~~~r.~U~ 8~lktVN8~U~EH~iSR gr i~~Rfl~=818oRJRlli~R~C6E~R~~1~~LTO
............~.~~~.~.~t.~.~~~~YTl~..;.~~.i~~2'.....;..f.,~...y...................
: Ye.. , Debtta Oe EI~[OW Jn~p~'la'on End Oil :
................................W........~.~....l............ ..................
MlllC. MONUli
10.00
10.00
.00
.~~--_.--.~~-~-.__..__.- -.---.---~--
...............................12.22.......12.22...........22...................
· lend of ClI..., Inform4t.lon .
............................. ..................................................
TRUE COPY FROM RECORD
'" l..tlmO/lY whettOf, I 114,. unto 1ft rrry IIInCl
and the ~ 01 MY' fwrt " Carllsle. PI.
''''I.J, J/: -7' .~d~.~.. Ill:".
. .. 1 1 "
,
! ~/i!1 ~ J
8:3
'.,j './.j ~/'I < '( J'c:
.., . /.,
.
1104. t YINYA'A'HN'~ ..,."....:)
.,nOH!wn03 .
UNnO:;J ONV'WUWfl:) ~O
IIJONll~Ja :lI1Unol .11.1. ~o J:;JI~~O
... ,",.._-",-~,,""'----""
NO. 95-27D CIVIL TERM
LAURA B. BAUGHMAN.
P1alntift
V.
TIlOMAII E. BAUGHMAN,
DefllndAnt
NOTICE or APPEAL
William .rauQht. I'Qulr.
01',,1:. 01' fH. 'LI...,Q 01"1010'"
01' 1:11"'1'''''''''0 COIlNTY
,,"It, """
'."4"1.1, ""1lI"4 YAIlI'. '"''
~.. '. .""': .......,-....,......._""~.."",..~.,.,..."",.....,,..,.,...:.:n.;.;_~.:y"-"'"""'_'""'""_.""'.~'-"':
"'"'."'.....-""
-~--".."""
'""" -
llllplH lv, ('0111 t. 01 hmfluylvillIl..
011 I elf or \. tHO 1',0\ h""t'\ <I, Y
4)4 M.. I II ("tlll \(J I Illl jj ,11 Ii'J
P,O. POl( HOO
"~rrl.t~ru, PlJnn.ylvAnl~ 1710_
('1\7) '1'I~"lOlU
MAy lOt un
NotlCtt of AN!..! 1)0(;II..llolJ
aUplllrtor Court DoolliJt NCI, AliilllQtIIlId
(I(l4QI)JlIl(J~'!.
PROTHONOTARY N(). 'IS' -,)10 tf~t r~
Cumberland COUNTY
cllmberlllnd cry. Coy.tllr~u..
CArli,lf. pa 17(11)
Ii II: 1 U.llghm4n/ t. V "Aughm"n, T
You Irl henby .dv!"..! tllll II.. atUchttd 4<;ellot
1 nformlltion hu b..n eountil 11\1(1 In. IUf,ulaf (lOuU (.cQrd.
In " ell. 10 which rOil Ipp..r A' an utfl(llilr of t". ~Qlln.
Pl.... rlvl.w thl. nfgrmatlon Clr.futly and nQtlfy thi'
office Imm.dl"tely it YQII b4lUI!lVliI {lon_CHord_' IUO In (lrd_f.
Thilnk YOy,
Oavid A. ",WOllk
,rOUtQMury
tA
,
,~
illj I J 0 1",1-1
10 J'I
:;IIPI(I(\ON l'OllHT (W I'KNNUVINANIA
(WI'ICIAl, f10CK~;T
lX)CKUT . 0040bHua,.
\,'LJI.I, tAl''f ION
oou !.AURA Il: PMJClIlMAN
V
ooaT TIlOMAil Ie IJAUOIlMAN
(;'Ot!N.ltI,
· f\UU WIl.LIAM IIMAUOIlT
PU"LIC o~rENpgK" OrrICK
"lMB~/(LANP '~UN1Y COURTHOUSE
C^RLI'L~, VA 17013
~'71a THOMA' A ~LAclY
A.SISTANT DISTRICT ATToRNey
C'UMPIUU..\NO rolJN'l'Y CO\lRTItOUiIl:
CARLIILK, fA 1701'
('ON'OLJO^T~D DOCKler HUMate/(
uACKCIIWUNO tlATA
TRIAL COURT RICORD'
CATIOORY,
COUIlT "AMI.
(,"Ol/NTY I
JUDICIAL PliTRICT,
CA'I TYPK/t~ARall
TRIAL COURT CIIUClIU"
Jueax (1111,
DI.ro't110N TYPI.
OJ.POIITION DATIl
^"IAL 'ILl PATI,
PI'POIITloN iNTIRRv.
~lAL CRT POCKIT NO. I
O"INII TRAcKINO NO, I
TITt.K
FOR MA II.
ABUT V.D. 002T Y
717.a40.6zn
OOU: Y
n'1.;.l40.UI0
cv
CIVIL
CUMaERLAHO
ot
fkOTICTION FRM AlUII
.liEELY, It
JUDGMENT or .INTKNCI
04/U/U
o'/l!$/n
U.210
sTATU' HI'OkMATION
04/U/n OOCIl.I:TINO Sl'f^'tjt;MfCNT DU<<
CI'f/04/!t~ WWlk l'OUWf IU:':O~lJ (:lUIe
[)()CJ(~T iHT,UlfI'
Q~/)O/'~ HQTIC~ 0' ^~~~^~ t'~
Q~/}Q/.~ ~CJ(#T1HQ mfAfgH~~f KX1TIO
1'.AJf,liJ.,W1 ';.Arrll,l.U "'CO\I.T AvtOIHT&-:O
'OK
OUT
ooaT
"""
~
LAURA B. BAUOIlMAN
V
THOMAS B. BAUGHMAN
a IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLBAS OF
a CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
a
a
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
a
a NO. 95-270 CIVIL TERM
Jtf RJSa ~a.R.A.P. UZ,
oaDn or COURT
AND NOW,
~.I ;~r
thh ~ day ot MAY,
1995, notio. havin9
b..n r,clivld that an app.al ha. b..n tak.n in tho abov.-
oaptioned ..tt.r, it i. ord.red and dir.ct.d that the appellant
torthwith tile with the trial judgl a oonoi.. .tatement ot the
matt.r. complained ot on the app.al, tog.ther with reterence to
any Itatutory authorlty or anv rule ot oourt. Upon the tailure
ot the appellant to till .uoh r.a.on. within tourt..n (1.) day.,
th~ oourt will pr..u.. that the app.al ha. be.n abandon.d.
.~.
Ottio. ot Di.trict Attorney
Willi.. Draught, E.quirl
A..l.tant 'ublio D.tlndlr
aeld
~ (o.~_ (t.J"I...t.l "js I.' '
..&' .' .
18,
1
"
f".,
l'I.lnlll1'
IIN TIll! COURT OF (:OMMON 1'1.I1A8 OF
I CIJMlIIIRI.ANI> ('OIJNTY. PHNNSYI.v ANIA
I
I (:IVIl, ACTION. LAW
I
: 1'!ton:t''I'ION FROM AI\\J1I1!
: 95..0270 ('IVIl, TERM
lAURA It. l1A\JOIIMAN.
V.
'IIIOMA" n. UAU<lIlMAN.
Offfndanl
~<:I~H nAICM~l Of ~1^U1iRS.t;Oh:U'1.AI~l!p Oll~
W TllflIlONORAI\I.l! J\Jf)(II\S 011 HAIIl ('OURT:
NOW COMI:H lilt l>tr,ndanl. '1lIum.1 Ii. UlluJhman. by and Ih,uuJh hI. ItlUmt)'.
William IIf.IIJhl. Haqulrc. A.II.tanll'ublllJ f),rrndrr. and fflV'Hntl tlw f(jllowlna". ~*l..
~lllIemcnlofdw l1\llIlffl IJ'lmr11l1fMlld ut on Irre.l:
I. Tho t\'ilJr~f w..ln.um~i'nllu IUlllli" dlll ~m\'llJdun on dw charvo of Indlr<<t
nlmlnall1{1nl,mpt.
1
.,
11111 \'ffdkt w'lllplnal tilt w'lJht Ill' Ihf rvldenl1f.
Kfll'fl:tlUlI)' .ubmllltd.
/J/ ,h
" /;;r ,,~.' '
___",'_'}",~r;(,'-' kJ_-'~'*-- "
William lIralllht. l~tquJ...
ADIWfnlI'vbllq ,,.,,..,.,
AllmlW)' 1\" IM.."",,"1
3'1
,...,
f""'.
"I;. 7/'1')'
LAURA I. IAualUWI
1M THI COURT 0' COMMON PLIAI or
CUMlIRLAND COUNTY, "NNIYLVANIA
y
THOMAI I. IAUOIIMAN
MO. '1-310 CIVIL TIRN
'\\
'M ,.. 1tq,J 1J1L
On April a., 1"1, .tt.r h.arlnt, I tound the a.t.nd.nt In
aonte.,t and .Int.no.d hl. to torty-tlve ct'l daYI In the
CU~lr1.nd County "lIon. An app..l h.1 b..n tl1ed to the
'up.rlor Court .nd oounl.l for the d.t.ndant ha. provldld the
followint f..lonl for .pp..l.
1. The .videnol v.. in.u"lcleAt to .u.taln the oonvlotlon
on the thar,1 of 1ndlreat orl.1nal oont..".
2. The verdlot V'I .,.1n,t the velQht 01 thl .vid_no..
Att.r the hearlnt on Aprll 26, 1"', ln the pr".noe ot all
p.rtl.., I diotat.d .n opinion whioh lit tcrib ~ flaaon. for
flndinv the d.t.ndlnt Quilty ot indileat orl_lnal OOAt..,t. I
WI' ..'llfi~ then Ind now th.t .u'tl,lent ,vld.no. w" produold
to "liVe tIy . p,.pond.,.n.,. .t the .vh"no. th.t tll. ca".nd.ni
viol.t.d the '.r.. of the orde,. I rely on tn. April ZI, lttl
deol110n II MY l'ZI oplnlon.
"VI' at, I'" I.lf ,,"' Ceut,
1~' A. '1*MlY, .tq~lf'
rQ( tk C.....-U'-
wilU.. Qf, 'f~/Iltf ft4\ih.
flif t'" ~f"i\
'lthi
,
~. '~
~l '. "Ill! ;t 'i.~
1""\
'*'
rl jla /q!i
LAURA I. BAUGHMAN, I IN Till COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
Plaintiff I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
V. I
I
THOMAS E. BAuaIlMAN, I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Def.ndant I NO. 95-270 CIVIL TERM
IN REI INDIRECT CRIMINAL CONTEMPT
Prog..dlngl h.ld b.for. the
Honorable HAROLD E. SHEELY, P.J.
Cumb.rland County Courthou.., Carll.l., p.nn.ylvanla
on W.dn..d.v, Aprll 26, 1995, gom..nglng at JIOO p...
in Courtroom Numb.r On.
APPEARANCI'1
Tho... A. ,i.a.y, I.quir.
'.nlor AI.i.t.nt Dl.triat Attorn.y
For the Plalntlff
Willia. o. Iraught, I.quir.
A..l.tant PUbllQ Def.nd.r
'or the a.t.ndant
11-
;
f.:;'';';'
tdl:f
~',\:
F'
~.~
~~ !i~ 1.1) t ~t:<<
f1III\
,..,
t"OJ~ TO Wlt~~1111
lOA Till gnINDAN" DIR!~ CROI. RIDIRI~ Rlreaoa.
aarbara .h..tt.r 1 7 . -.
Ta.MY 81...1n9 , 11 14 14
Tho... 8.u9hllan U 11 .. --
q.5
""'"
,....,
1 W.dn..dav, Aprl1 21, 1...
a 3100 p...
J
4 THI COURTI Mr. IInu\lht, VOIl "'Y proo..d.
II HR. IRAUOHTI Thank YOIl, YOllr Itonor. Wt'd
6 0.11 '.rb.ra Sh..ff.r.
7 Wh.r.upon,
8 BARDARA 'lIl."FlR
9 h.v!n; b..n dlllV .worn, t..t1rl." .. tollOwt'
10 DIRICT EXAMINATION
11 BY MR. DRAUGHT 1
12 Q M.'.m, could you .tat. vour na.. and 'P'll
13 YOllr la.t nam., pl.....
14 A B.rbara Sh..rr.r, ..h.....t.t...r.
III Q And wh.r. do you l1v., Mrl. .h..tttr7
16 A 165 Old Oap Ro.d.
17 Q Old G.p Roadl
11 A Old aap Roaa.
19 0 And wh.r. 1. that 10oat~1 Wh10h t.wnlnl,?
:10 A North Mlddl.ton.
21 0 Do you know Tho.... ',u\lh~.n?
U A Y...
23 0 A~d how do you know hi.?
24 A H.'... hi. .l,tar l'v.. ,luftt .~,...~ "tA'
l~ th.ra n.wt to our houI.. fh'f.'. 11~. ee 1n A "a'I"
>>
1""\
1!"""l
I ther.. Llk' n.xt door n.l,hbor.. HI" OVer It hi. .1.t.r'.
a . lot.
) 0 Did you know ThO.I' aluqh.an blok on Maroh
4 11th, 19ft"
Ii A V...
. Q And a,lln blck th.n you kn.w hl. b.elu., hl.
1 .l.t.r livid nlxt door to you1
I A Y",
'lI 0 Do you n"aU b.l", at a '111., . 'ha.blu9h
\0 .ale, on 'aturdav, March 11th, 1"'1
II A Ve., we all w.nt up to that .ale th.r.. W.
13 II" thl" in the ~rnln" Ilk. -. w.ll, To. w.nt wlth .y
I) brOther, Q,orge, end .y hu.band, Wlyn., 1104 .. and .y
14 .1.,er-ln-llw, QaOf91'a wlf., we tollow.d th.. up ln the
U Olf, and ...
l' 0 IAt .. .top you there for a ..oond and tHluk
" up. KId you, vour.,lf, Qonl to .h..bIU9h'. ..'el
U A V...
U 0 And wh." WII the '11e itllln
ao A ,t" tHl@k t@wArd the north .ountlln. It" on
al thl. .1da 0' the ..untlln Ilke.
JJ 0 ".lG'. v@yr..I' who .,.. 1\44 ,on. to lh.
l} ..,.1
H A.... 1M "''1 lir"t~..., 010'/11, ltn4 fa And "'I
~.., tw-fMM~ ~"rM, ilM "r ,'.h'.IA""lf, (i........'. wUe,
4
"'"
,-...
1 Q When vou .av Tom, who do VOU m.an bV Tom?
a A TOIII aau\lhman.
J Q Do you r.call about what tlme you would have
4 90n. to that .al. on Maroh 11th?
6 A t thlnk it wae around nlne ln the mornin\l.
6 W. went up th.re about all daV. It wa. 11k. we didn't come
7 back untl1 ln the art.rnoon.
S Q W.. Tom aauqhman up at the ..1e the .ntire
9 time that you wer. ther.?
10 A Y.., becauea he want wlth aeorqe and th.m.
11 Q Did you r.turn back wlth Tom aaughman?
1~ A Y", he want .. he oom. down to the truck
13 wlth lilY broth.r and thalli.
14 Q Wh.n did vou return to?
1~ A Baok to the tarlll, baok wh.re We liVe.
111 Q At It\!) allt Cap Road?
1"1 A 'I'"
la Q And vou eaV thatl. eOIll.tll11. ln the atternoon?
19 A 'I...
:10 Q Wh.n VOU Qot bAok to lU Old Cap Mold, what
21 41d you do ven.rally?
:12 ^ W. jUet went throuqh eOlll8 etutt. W. had Ukl
23 . truckload of .tutt We bou9ht up at the .al., end w. We.
24 901~ thro~h that to ... what we wanted end etutt.
25 0 And bow 1o~ did you rlllla1n at 16' old aap
\
f((,
1
a
l
4
~
6
7
8
9
10
11
U
13
14
U
16
17
11
19
ao
:n
22
n
H
;r~
"'."
"..."
ROld?
A Oh, I .taYld the r..t ot th. dAV. I dldn"
go "owh.re.
o About until how lAt.7
A All nl'.1ht.
o And that'. your r..tdlno., .0 you vould
hlv, --
A V...
o Do vou rlolll how long TOI aluqh..n r...ln~
It VOUr r..ldlne.?
A H. wal th.r. wlth UI, wtth MV broth."
Olorg., Ind u. for Iwhll..
Q Up untl1 whit tlM' appro.t.lt.IV, it you
reclll?
A All ntQht blulu.a ha WI' 'h.r. at 'V
broth.r", II. WII ov.r .t 'V brot""'. '''lfa, than VI Vlnt
ov.r to the hou.e, then "I we"t up to Tall al'I' DobbY"
around 10lJO or '0, I think.
Q Who do you ...n bV T.I and DObbV?
A 111. .1.t., And 'V broth,r, 'Ob~.
o Thl on.. that llvl AUf 0" tht .t,..t}
A Yet.
Q And do you r.Q411 hi.. l"Vl~~ YQur ~.. It
abOut... and whon I 1"'V h~MUI, thi. II " tuB., \f"r'
'aUd"q About?
to
It'!
"""
,....,
1 A Va., th.y h.v. . tral1.r ovar th.r., .nd w.
a w.r. ln the houa..
) 0 You llv. in the hou... You r.oall Thoma.
4 'au9h..n l.avlnq your hou.. about 101'0 or '01
. A V", w. w.r. all .tandln~ out th.r. llk.
. betw.en the hou.. and the tral1er Ilk..
1 0 Dld you ... hilll aotually laave your hou..'
. A Y.., and h. want on ovar to BobbV'I, V".
, 0 And vou .aw hla 90 over to T.. Bl...1n~"
10 hOu" or tral1.r1
U A V...
la 0.1 thAt the 1.,t vou .aw ot hi. that nlqht1
1) AVe" u..hua,
l4 0 H~ 1. 1t you r.oall ...in9 Tholll" a.uqh.an
l' .n that p.rtluul.r day?
1. A ,.oau.e he wa. with UI. H. wa. th.r..
11 0 W.ll, how 1. it that vau reo.l1 lt wa. thl.
1. ,.'tl~ul.r d'y, thl. Hafoh 11th aav, laturday?
1~ A ',OIU" w. all w.nt to that .al..
10 MM. DJAUaHT' I hlVI no other qu..tion..
a 1 1NII COUMT I cro.....u.l n..
U M/iI. '&..ACr;V, Thank you, Your Ilonor.
J) C~".r:XAH1~Atl0~
~. .y~, '~IYI
~~ Q IY'.", 4111 V'1U lINk at your IlIltern IlIh'" Td
f
q~
"'"
,-..
1 Bau9hman l.ft your r..ld.ne.?
a A NO, that'. why I .ald it wa. about 10130 wh.n
1 h. w.nt up th.r..
4 MR. PLACEYI That'. all the qu..tion. I hav.,
, Your Honor.
6 THE COURTI No qu..tion.. Thank vou. You
7 may .tep down.
S MR. BRAUOIITI MaV I uk on. mon qu..Uon on
9 r.c!1net1
10 REDIRECT EXAMINATION
11 BY MR. BRAUOIITI
la Q Mr.. 8h'atf.r, do you have an id.a ot how far
13 lt i. from vour r..iaene. to al North Mlddl.ton Road hlr. in
14 Carll.l.? W.ll, l.t m. a.k you thl. tir.t. Do you knov
l' vhlr. North Hlddl.ton Road 1.?
16 A Y...
17 Q 00 vou have an ..tlmat. about how far it i.
18 from vour hou.. to that addr...?
19 A It mu.t be Ilk. tvo, three mil.. or mor..
ao MR. IlRAUOIlTI That'. aU I hav., Your 1I0nor.
31 Till: COUMTI No qu..Uon..
22 HR, 1tRAUO/lTI Call Tn 81...1nq.
n Wh.reupon,
24 TAHHY IILE.BING
2!) havin9 be.n dUly .worn, t..tlfl~ I' follow.,
.
IN ,
10
11
13
1)
14
U!
16
11
I'
1li
;10
;Ii
U
U
U
l'li
~
,...
A
0
A
0
'hlaU,,?
A
Q
A
0
A
Q
YI..
00 veu know Tn.... ..",,,"",
'II'.
Kow do vou IInow M.'
I'. hi. .i.'.f.
w.. .. do VQU know wh',' TOM v.. llvl", or
.tayint .round M.r~h ",,, or 1"11
A HI w" ",vi~ ., IIV ,I...,
o And dQ you ,.u,ll .,.lnt hlll .1 .11 Oft MlrGh
l"h, "'I, whion would ~ . '.'"r4'V1
A V"" I..n hi. 'h" .o,n'"" .n4 "t w.nt
down to Q.Of,,'_ .round '100,
o Whl" .. .pqyl .,00 1" 'hi ~f"1~1
A""..
o AM Ifh." 4.i r~l# r~4U "..t .n'"", M~l
A w.H I \dI." ti'H!y (U.lM ....~." ff~ ,~ ....~ I
..
{Oo
1
~
3
4
I
6
7
.
\I
10
11
12
1)
14
1'1
16
17
111
1ll
ao
H
n
:n
H
Z~
f"'\
1""\
...n hl. otf and on, but h. dldn't co~. up to the trail.r,
o And who do vou ~.an by th.y, Barbara Sh.att.r
and that group that .h. juat .pok. about?
A Um-hum.
o And you .aw th.m?
A I ...n him walkln9 around down th.r..
o a..id.. ...ln9 hl. walk around aoro.. the
atr..t, do you r.oall ...ln9 hlm baok at your trail.r anv
time that nlght?
A W.ll, h. oa.. up around 10130 and 90t
.o.,thing to .at and 'aCk,d out on the couch.
o 00 vou know what ti.. you la.t .aw hi. in the
trllllr?
A That att.rnoon or -.
o Vou .ald vau tir.t .aw hlm back in the
trallu atter 1100 .... .bout 10lJO that nlqht?
A YI',
Q What till. 1. 1t that vou would hiVe 90na to
bid .nd lut ...n TOIII?
A Probably lIrouod 11100.
Q a.tw..n 10130 or .0 wh.n you flut ..w hi.
.nd 11100 whan Vo" tlr.t w.nt to bad, dld VOU IVer '11 Toa
l..v. the tr.ll.r?
A Ho.
o 00 you have a car It your trallar?
10
1
;I
J
4
5
6
7
.
9
10
11
12
II
14
l!i
16
17
18
19
;10
U
U
2)
Z4
~,
"""
fIlI'i\
^ I do now. I didn't at the tl...
Q Wa. there any oar at that tral1.r tor 'ob?
^ No.
Q For Tom?
^ No.
Q How 10n9 1. that trail.r?
^ It'. a twelve by -. I aln't .ure. Twelve
bV .- it'e a three or a two bedroom on..
o How tar would b. your bedroom from the door
.dt?
^ It'. r19ht out throu9h the hallwav. I would
have ...n ftnythinq op.n or .hut.
o Do vou r.oall h.arlnq anyone leave vour
tral1.r that nlQht art.r Tom oam. baok?
A No.
MR. DRAUOIITI That'. aU the qu..t1on. I
hav..
Till COURT I cro"-llCamlne.
MR. 'LACEY I Thank vou, Your 1I0nor.
CRo.a-EXAMINATION
BY MR. ,LACJ:YI
o
your pla(;'.?
A
o
How lonQ had Tom .auqhman b..n atavln9 at
Ev.r etnc. th.y .pltt up.
~ld he hIve hi. own ~.Y1
II
,
a
1
4
~
..
.,
.
!II
10
U
U
1'1
l4
"
,.
11
lit
,~
1(1
.H
n
H
H
H
"'"'
,......
A No.
o Po you hAve to unlook the door for hi. wh.n
he QOII.. hOIl.?
A U.UIlly hi'. th.re.
a How ..ny .ntranoe. Ire there to your tr.l1Ir?
A TWo.
a Wh.r." thl other .ntrlnol?
A It'l It thl ~.g~ .nd ot thl trll1.r.
o 00.. Hr. 'Iyqhll.n hive hi. own roo.1
A HI ,l.pt on th. oouoh.
o Whit WI" you dol", on thl l'th ot MlrOh,
un, that diY'
A I w., It no.. all dlY,
o 00 .nvthlnq ".011"
A No, 1u,' Ql..ntd hOYlf.
o KAv, anyihin, '0 drln~7
A No.
o Old YOij .OO~ It yOijf wlt.h whln Mr. ,.uthll.n
01.. ho.. thAt IVlnlnql
A No.
o At ,q.. f91nl you 'Q' up @f YO" l.ft wh.r.
Nr. '.~~n WI' .~ w.nt to your ~f~M 1" th. trtll.r?
A '~l'n.'. ~. n.44 ""f~t'v'ly,)
Q Aft'f W8,~h ~'At V~ a14hi~ ... hi. until
''"' MU 4.y. Di4 "" !HI. M* 1M ,...., \141'
D
/Cd
"""
,.,.
1
2
)
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
1]
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
;u
:u
U
2')
A YI., I ...n hlm that morninQ, Sunday .ornlnq.
Q Did you ... hl. at all att.r th.t?
A tll qot up and wlnt baok down to a.org..., and
th.n a.org. and hl. w.nt ,o.,whlr.. I'm not .ure wh.re thlY
w.re golnq.
Q You .aw hl. back down at a.org.'.. How tar
away 1. th.t trom your rl.ldene.?
A Thlrl'. a trall.r .1ttlnq hlrl .nd a tral1.r
Ii t t1 ng th.r., '0, I don't know, .avbl tw.ntv t..t or ..
Q Dld vou .11 hlm down at GIorgI"?
A YI..
Q Ilow manv other p.opl' llv. ln your hom."
A H.. my two kld., "V tlance now, and Tom wa.
th.r..
o I'm .orry. 1 didn't h.ar the lalt ..
A And To.. w.. thlra.
Till COURT I Wh.t'. the n.... or vour ti.nQ.1
THI WITHE... lob Diehl.
THI COURTI La.t na...'
THI WITHE'" Di.hl.
Till COURT. w.. h. hOIll. thh "iqht?
THE WITHE." Ho, h. wa. in pri.on It thl.
tt... .
H_. rLACEY' That" all the qUI.tion. 1 hlv.
lor thl. wlt~...
u
IlJ Y
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
II
10
11
12
13
14
U
16
17
11
19
20
:n
:u
:z:J
H
~"
''''
,...
TilE COURTI Anv othlr que.t1on.?
MR. BRAUOHTI Ye., Your Honor, v.rv bri.flY.
REDIRECT EXAMINATION
BY HR. BRAUOHTI
aM.. Bl...1n9, back around March 18th, 199~,
do vou recall whether Tom had anv faclal halr back th.n?
A No.
Q Let m. r.phraee that. Old h. have a beard
and mu.tach. llke he do.. now or wa. he clean .haven or what
klnd of faelal halr, lf any, dld he have?
A He had a au.tach..
a Dld he have a beard?
A No.
g And the tlm. of 10130 that you vave ln ter..
ot Tom returnlng hom., 1. that your b..t ..timat. that he
ca.e back .. wh.n Tom could have .hown up?
A That'. wh.n h. came up to the hOu", y...
MR. BRAUOIlTI That'. all I hav..
TilE COURT I Anythlng eha, Mr. Plee.v?
MR. PLACEYI Y.., Your lIonor. 1i1ank you.
RECROS. EXAMINATION
IY MR. PLACEYI
Q Wh.n dld hI qrow thl. b.ard?
A I don't know.
Q A day lat.r, A w..k lat.rl
14
10 ,)"
,"'\
""'"'
1 Ii H. dldn'\ have I b.ard tor awhUt.
2 0 w.U, wh.n cUd h. 'Irow the b.ard thlt h. hu
J nowl Wh.n did h. .tart 'Irowln9 that?
. A Probably about three we.k. IQO.
. 0 How do VOU know that?
. Ii WeU, h. w.. ah.vln".
'1 0 'hlvin, r'Qul.rly ev.rv dly1
. Ii V.-hIlM.
, 0 Up until ,bout thr.. w..ka 1"0 1. your
10 ,.0011.otlon1
\1 Ii U.-hUM.
11 0 And you WOUld know thi. blolu.. ha would
11 .hlve at your houa.?
U A VIII-hUll.
U Mil, ,LACey I n,t'. all the Clu..Uona I hlv"
l' 'tour Mo"n.
,'1 Mil. .MAWHTI Nfl "ttt., Q\l..t1on..
11 THII C'OVMTI Thl"" you. You M)' tt.p deMin.
l' "R. IMAUOIlfI Can Tho... 'authun.
'10 Wtl.uupon,
'11 flfOHAl IAUGHMAN
U Mvi"'l kiNn aulV .w4',n, ,..UU." iU toUOVtl
1~ ~1~1'~ C~AM1~AflOH
H t't HIi. IMWHT.
+.. 0"'" ..~#Jf. w#;Nld l'~ .Ut, Y<Nr 1,\1.. aM
u
,.'"
1"'\
1 .p.ll vour la.t nam., pl.....
:I A Thom.. 8auqhman, 8-a-u-q-h-m-a-n.
3 0 Mr. 8auqhman, baok on March 18th of 1995,
4 wher. did vou 11ve?
~ A At ay .1.ter'~ pl.c., Tam 81e..ln;.
6 0 And i. that the 161 Old aap Road addr..a?
7 AYe..
8 0 Back on March 18th, 1'9~, do vou r.c.ll where
9 vou were for mo.t of the daV?
10 AYe., 1 went alonq to . pUblic .ale back 944
11 up .lonq the mountain .t ShambauCJh'. .ale. Th.t'. wher. 1
1:1 bou;ht a table .aw.
13 0 Tabl...w you add?
14 A V..,
U 0 How long ware vou up th.n, frOm when to when
16 .pproklaat.ly?
17 A We .t.YleS until they qult .elllnq. I think
18 It wa. around :1130 or 3100 untll w' !Jot everythlnq loaded
19
:10
411
U
23
24 oth.r on.. th.re.
2~ 0 Jlloht ~.id. your .laur',?
up. It WII probably 3110 wh.n we 1.ft th.re.
0 Where did you 90 from th.re?
A Mlqht back to alorql Dllhl'. place.
0 And 1. thAt At 16' Old alp Road?
A I think hi. 1. 171. It'. rlqht be.ide ihe
H~
,.,,~
,....,
1 A VII.
3 Q And did you 90 .tra19ht Irol the .111 At
) .h..blvqh', to alor,. Dl.hl'. plao.?
4 A V...
6 0 Whln did vou ll'v, a.or,1 Dl,hl'. plloll
. A It w.. r19ht .found 10,'0 thlt nlQht I walk.d
7 Up to IV .i.t.r" pl.o..
. 0 .Itwlln thl tl.. that vau Irriv~ at Olor"
o 01.hl'. PI.oI alter l.avlnq Mha.blu9h" and the tl', thl'
10 vou l.,t and w.nt ov.r to your .I.ter'. plaol, did you .v.r
II 1..vI O'Of" Olehl'l plaol'
la A "OP', I n.v.r 1"\ th.t Ir...
11 0 Old you QO .trat9hi over to your .t.,.r"
14 wh.n you II" O.or,. OI.hl'l pllo,'
Hi A 'I'"
10 0 When did VQU nlwt 1.IY. your .1"1'" plloll
11 A It WI' probAblY Around '100 thl ft.., ..,nl"4,
II ana I thtnk l' WI' rl~h' 010.. to " when.Ylf .e .nd 0..",
" I." I.f tewn.
~Q 0 Qn th., ..'urdIY, "IrQn 11th, '.", did you
11 .v.r.o @ve' to lhl .4d,... .t al No,th Nld4I'lQn M@ld1
U A"".
II 0 '4~k O~ ~'Qh l"~, Itt', w~l tV" o. '441.1
H h.tl, Itht rw ~".1
~, 4. "'''11''', 'M' ..".. n,
p
/0'1
""'"
f"""c
1 Q You dldn't h.v. a b.ard?
2 A Nop..
J Q How 1. lt you r.oall wh.r. you w.r. on
4 I.turdav, Maroh 11th?
~ A Beeau.. of that publlo .al..
e MR. BAAUOtlTI That" all I have.
7 THI COURT I Cro....x..ln..
. MR. PLACIYI Th.nk vou, Your Honor.
~ CRUl,. eXAMINATION
10 BY HR. PLACIYI
11 0 Th. p.ople who 11ve .t 171 Old aap Road, 16.
12 Old a.p Road and 167 Old aap ROld ar. all relatad bV
11
14
lIarrlage ln .0.. wav, 11 th.t r 10ht1
A Will, I '. not relatad to any of th...
0 You're not related to vour .1.ter?
It W.U, IIY al.t.r, Y'" but they'r. -- .hl"
1~
It
aha naver .Ald
Q
A
0
OieM1
11
"""
,.....
A
Q
A
Q
10
ph"..
Q
1\1...1n9 --
A
Q
A
Q
u
110
,.,,\
r.,
1
2
3
4
5
A D.b?
o V...
A V", .h. 00.. blok . OOupl' diff.r.nt 'i...
came baok wlth Laurl one daV, Ind I Qot tllkl", to
untl1 .h.
h.r.
6
7
o
A
8
9 llvlno?
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
o
overrul.d,
.bout a month.
BY HR. PLACr.:VI
17
Q
It.
o
It.
Q
A
wlth InvthlnlJ.
18
111
:10
H
:12
2)
:u
n
qu..tton.
That'. how you ..t ~ur.?
Y...
Now, .rt.r the 11th of Maroh, wh.r. w.r. you
MR. BRAUOIlTI Obj.oUon. M.l.vlno..
THE COURT I Well, It'. oro.......ln.'&on,
Till WITNIJI. I went a"'IV. I w.. .,one for
Wh.r. dld you 90?
Atl.nUo City.
Who dld you "IY there with1
A frl.n4.
00" the frlend haYI . n...'
I don't ... wh.r. that ha. anyth'", t. 40
THE COUMT, I a.cld. tn4t. An.",., the
T"I WITNJj" ("'~. with .~ u,,&, .n.
ji.
II
. ,
0
^
0
^
0
A
piok.d a. up.
0
A
f"'\
1"'\
~l
III
1
:I
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
1&
16
17
18
19
:10
H
22
2)
24
n
~
".....
BY MR. PLACEYI
Q
A
Old vou tell vour .i.t.r wh.re vou had Qon.7
Nope, no one knew wh.re I wa. at. I ,u.t
took otto
MR. PLACEYI That'. all I hav., Your Honor.
THE COURT I Any other qu..tion., Mr. DrauQht7
MR. DRAUClItTI No other que.tion..
THE COURTI I have no que.tlon.. You mav
.tep down, Hr. Baughman.
MR. DRAUGHT I W. r..t, Your Honor.
THE COURTI Any rebuttal bV the Commonwealth?
HR. PLACEYI NO, Your Honor.
(Wh.r.upon, a m.morandum oplnion and ordlr ot
oourt wa. .ntered.)
TilE OEnNDANTI Mav I ..V .om.thing? 1'11I
t'lllnQ the honl.t to God'. truth. I dld not leav. th. tar.
that nlQht.
TilE COURT I t under.tend what Vou ..111.
TilE D1!:FEHDANTI 1 m.t .ome girl two month.
aQo. I hav. no rea.on to 90 bother tlllm.
TilE COURT I 1 und.nhnd what veil lilli, .Ir.
TilE Dr:nHDAHTI 1'" not lyl/llJ to you. I If..
nowhere near th...
Tile COURT!
had to ..~. that deul.lon.
Ok.V. I found oth.rwi.., .0 ~~ I
That'8 ~h.t I 'Ollnd.
n
.....
,-..
CERTIPICATION
I her.by certify that the proc..din,. are
contained tully and accurat.ly in the not.. takln by .e on the
abovI cau.e and that thi, i, a correct tran,cript ot thl .a.l.
\'
1 .r""
..~,IU let. fJs,H'\~J~~ '.r
~ r. r. Handley (
Offioi.l Court Report.r
................................
The tore901n9 record ot the procI'din" on the
h.arinv of the within .atter 1. her.bv approvld and direoted to
bl tUed.
'1'-
-I
~ (:"
,;4 , r:
..11. t'
L "c. " ,1 J
,:,..j, f' tV )If.' ..I
~r(/t -j~t:'
{)(',,)
1'"11' r Il
.... " -" I r' (1.'1 ~
~'"
f" /1
(,..ffll 'j.
If' ,I )
,
I-I (,l , ('\ y (' .' .' A " '" ( r:
,.)
,("I VI' il, ('j I, , ')
E~ t!f I f, ;., (' J"
:;f. II A.. 'I: j4'
.f/" ..
"it ;
- '
< l ,,~,
J,'
t .,.I~.( :.1.."./
f}>,....."., '-->'-,
............
, 1
J 'I'
e? f' tj
Iv~ f f
(' \p1
.I
.....
ff. t' .AI
)" .'
-
""
:,'1'
A t" I'""
/1
1',,:,"1,1
I'I.AINJ,,"
1>>."
I ~
(,.f / I
r' /.'1'
II
I' 'f' " II
!tl(
,
AI'I\(~
;1(>
(. ),ft:..
V
.' t'V
;!' 1/
,,) ill 1'1 "
.",.irlKfI'F
:;11' ,.. .. .' .. f'
(, /,c
'"
Of
".,,, + Z' A"",~
;'01'1 J' ""'J
y~~' .,lw;Yf
"11... I, ff # .1'
::~y
/
J ,....),
Jut "., (
I
::I ~-,
'I-
,
q"cI
Sf"
.... ""
<"I
...
J'(' ',! ,~
1/
" /.,,1
~","'''
l~1
I-.~- !'~
,., 'f "",.1
\- 1-''', v" .'
J I', -I 11.,.
.J.,
,
yc ';,./
II ....,
( "f
.~'i"~'"
" .~
YI" ,I
J
.n t' lvA.,. r t
J ,,.
{.-"'; .,..
",,,j
j
b v. 't f-
;. #
'-j,
I
;':J!J.~ j. '7
{ ~~.
<#
. ,
.
-#.
:',f
"1' i
, ,
..
. . } J r
"1(1 '~'J"" i ~
I ~,'
(.
..
Yt
'" .<,+
,r
IV A"...
/+1'
~ ,'i lit
f'
,:fit'.
j
eft
,It. ,~
~/)
.l
+';/,
)I ~ .'
c;, ~ "" ,dfF,}
f,1./'
....~".l 'f
Iff' 't
;1'1"
J<c if I JJ
~j!/-r
Jf t
#
)"
'yd .'
w',..
......"f
y""';
HJ f"
11...1
4. It, I
, /
;1. "1-'"
j'.c
Ii
p' ,
~~c ( ,. IV . /
, ,
.I: c /"t:,. V'~ '" ,..
,rlJ,
jI. ( ..;) // t
), c-)/ )'ql) J ,.1
...It:' " ,),. ~ Y" ~' #l
,.., I), ..',f'. :Z' ~. A f ,I:,
Ar~
S) f"{' . ''J "', ,. ",, ".; )'1" V t{ . ... .. {,;,A t #". "
(:'", q;l /f'J~1 ,-;.// ,I'If'! ,;I<A.~f /.. ..~,i) -:Jf!"'"
~; f1 r' "tJ, ',,:;, ?,A, /'d.i lA. "J' '" .11, ~
;t 1",.,.1 I J 1~ f:~),1 ",",1,{ Y~rl ( J.'" )'~"
".' /1
Itl' ')
(~ (t" j II !,trI ll"H ).
"..'
1-..,11..
lv' ,J~"A ;J./iIJ':J' :r
:1 ;'1"",1 J J".;' 1''''.-'
, ".-i
, '*
,
PlAINTIFF'8
EXHIBIT
,
ry
~, Lrtj
i... ., V I' '1 )
7.1;" ,.(.. .{". s. J t:. (. /1 " ~I.r. It -::f~
, I ."'1 . ~(.. .."1-,,.., J ~ ',r ) 6 c. Co Ii I.' :s {. '",v4r >' y
<::: i"i 'I r ",., j ~ If, J-f ...." v,. I 1"\ f( (.
,..... .' h ~/(< ~. /g,.. -t .z sr...;I/ -1 If " C'.. -/4 (~
~ 14", r ," "('4 1'1, 1 -J .,;: ;., [J r' ,.' ,J,) ;, .6il y
ofr 0'( 6" ~ .- tJ (., /I ,.~ ~ ", . ) .!je
W",,)./ pVI/ / r ,1'1.,1 Ad/p P1G S,,,"t
" ' f '/-? .. ..z j., r "'... '7 ~" :JCJ Jl"t
/~ f(, .1(: ? ..r .I} r:.c! J 1!1 S SO n.., ., 5
Z a.' If i';, I ~ 71 Yj"(.,/} /'1 t (G:r SC""c.
~A. ~ j.s .z 11("..41.." 7"t1 .., S (- y.,. v ..,IN (,1j
~t:.r;,e J Jt', :!' ,,{,.,,'f f41.r....., tt" <1c.f
}i it; .J ~, ~'" t,l,.( .. i vn U I b tI -7 I '{.'
J crl(/'),' 1- At"! ." ,., (' f I,'}J ~"... '" Ye:"'LI
rtl.1~ ,6 c If. r.";. J). . 0 0 ~ ;V"(JI-)
elf 1/ y t"1.1 i~ C"W ' $1.1 t I '.{' -7' Jv,' r.,\ 'r
7'1, -.. .( J hJ "J ), (' u t y , (J~) +' ~ v t". ~~ --r/. ~:..
.~ I ()' ~c," i Y" tI rlrH".{" ..;r-l ~ ..,,,,1/
,,11 y~vrl AlI;"I!. 'fJJ~\' ,.,cnv :;t:f
r-"I.J ~". },f c((// ;z' tfnt1M/ Y","v )t..,...
.5 c J~'" (>;.., e ,:;: I.:s e. I ..z: ,A ,y1'7' I~ ~#J ('!' f;' if /1
-1'4.;.'" ~ It;, ~. ft, Y I? V 4', -f'/.I It J - , .
(/ -~, , A, )~, 4-- ( ;' V ('". ( j :;/J<: (-Ie., I." '? ) I
C $ y, (, II! Y t? v ....'.^ l' .,. ~ (,. ! . I (
.J, I ! "1' l ~ .J....r I.
T'j {' (" / 'fl ~ jf' 1', ' f" /.')4'" 1', . "I"'"'!
}b' /1 ,b( J V~ ~ ft" ,I ,,' (I .I'" ! /Jk.' "'.
J. v!'~ r),~ ft",t ""'/:/ .", . ;;.(/..,~~; '1\1
P\AINTIFP'I
EXHIBIT
_.3 L-rtl
.
L. "'''''''I )
::r ,/p"lt ..""" t 1',. sr....'" /; Ie f;'
.IJ (l f~ I( .,., ;; y (> 1.1. ..r ~ tHlil ..' t ,...f ,,~ (. hI.' -/t..'. "J
Wfl'l1j' ..r J'v,;f vt..f Jc> t..,1+' ,...~..t
y... '" ( :J 0, J ?'o ~". ;2' .:}';' f L',s ""
-;1('1'/.(' <#Illff-"ly Ir. ...-,,71< <!. "Ie. ."t.:
n,.) \10'0 r'~,(. 1'''11 "''''1,4,,,,''1 .'., j{'s
. .,.. ~ /
WQtIJ. ~ Go...., :J~ 71.. <:.,.. It:)" -1'(.<(
)'t1() r I 't} ~ t ~ ""'l .'1' YflV ~"II) '" s t
, /c:.-f ""Co .c~,,- yov ;r t::/f'" of., r,{)H
./.t";)-/'&'[ YtlV ::Tf' )',1.1 "v,'II J'-'J7 ~&t;"t'..
: 1",,/: 70 Jl?e):;r P(o"" .'Ji,. Y,tIlI :;r wtll1'f
)1 t \I e( J ( , '':' ~ q J q ,;-,. ..,r I", (1 W y" v A (J ~ r
,b(!/,fI,J"- ~1e.)J,(.;t :.r (~fl/II' ~o ~1t::.1n ,'I
Jill.,,,)" .;r /""c y",,,, y""rt 'frJU' "'~~'''1
QHJ .:r w411t -to s~(;,ttd +~<< I(,.sf o-f 1<-1)"
/,~ ...,.,p, )'011 ",..A f'o """f" Ydl.l ..J/,e
Attf>.F~,~s:.i :J"/ ,~ ..,t;( wc>vlrl. P";"tfJl.I
:J' 'v It 1'1 .,;J.t" :r <' " " J (f .:d~ ~u" rlJ.J p (' ~ v (,
7t, y"V :;C ~(1.., .A... ,'I'" :r ..,11",~t ~,d
/+ Jt1;' If, I lH,It J.., :Jf1. ...., 70 :)e.7 Ae.?')
SQ 7If"t ): Ca- "/0 ,'t. pJ" If U. ep/"t:'",..f
_../1 -I' I.. t
... .. '" ~ '" _'C"....,. Yll1 1.1 .. e I)' v t'! (;I ;ry.. (; )
.
-
-
-
-
-
'-
,
.
,
,
"
t
"
J' '" v ~ ( t
-";1" f V i
~.. /
Y''OV, .-~..~
:J: I,..", 1'v.
C?
. "
.-r
.,.
...... .,jJ
, .
n".J(!f( ,(., r
OFFICE OF PROTHONOr ARY
COU/{ l HOUSl
'11".mu t:. IIIlIIQlunllR
___~"""'" 0',.""",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,---,,-,,
C,UII\II, 'A .~qJlIrlll.t1~.J9...., " ~'.
lb 1:11...11I111 IH.
,._J'!t1lYlU... ,.lLl1UL_ .--
-.. ..........*..,..~_.--~._---~"'...._..--.,...,........~-~
, ""'I'"
_._~..._". "'r"'._
" ,.. t.
TO The County of Cunlberland OR
"."'7.::.::c':...tt.-.....".f;..W'.o:.'t.r':"-';;#..,~*-.;.o.-
... $:'.: ~'...i.:.ii,.
.'1r:,' .,:.',."'"W' ~~.J'I',~:..w4" _.- I U ~-_-Oj.l:"" ',....~-
". t'IJlnll,,9u.~J!l J!LR.,
9~.~111 S.tY1L'l'e'm
IIllugljlnll'U(! L II.Ullh1nlll1 ,
., ,1._U '9_.
I
f ,...""-"..'...., "',
,
~''''''''
,. '~.--' ,,,,,"-" ...."".;. ,..,,,,, '
_~_ _~_M,..-."'"',. _,_, ...._..... "
..lil!~nf.c!l,~l!..\. fOf S.lIfY.!.fll...._
,.. .U '0
.~,,"'"
-" I '
,-~.,--~...--..,.'""'I-.~.._.~ -'"
'-""'''---.., -.-,..-
,_..--~..".-.,..~
,-.",-~........~"-,, """",-,,,~.--,, -:,.",."
- ; ~,. - ,...",......~'". '".-~ "
""-,"', <.-_._...-...~.......",._.~...~,,,,., ""
-"~,""'""'~- ---"-'{
",~,>...-''''~-'
..__.........-'>"p." .,....~._.....-._''IOC_'''''''^ >~._,..._...__.,+""'......~._.........- _~_.,_ ~i J+'_"''',_,"~ v'.,-.-""
AMOUNT DUll
. n 10
-- -, ,.,.,-.--. .,...,.. .
....~.._.-c..-....-.......""__
...--..-.,.....,.....
.. -. -.,-._-"._,_.----..-....-...~. .... -...,"-.....: ".,......,""..._--....-......,...._..~_.-
--.,-~
. -----.-------"'-',..,,~-~ .., '. ~""'''' ~._.,.,'.~.......~.-~.__._----...--.,..._........,.. ~
... __ ..-.-'""~""""..,._r
_ ,"':'_'..u..' ."''''' '''''.~'''''~'''. ".....__~>>-.~.,-.,.,""
"...,__,..,,,, ... .w""",' ,_. ,."'~'....~.__.._._._
-
,.",....,....."'~.."".-,
.......~~_.,. ,,,.,,.......,,...-""......,,-,,_..,,,. .,
"'.;..-~-~--...~.._~ ....."........,._._,'~-
---_._~-~",....- ;.,-...... "-'-- ."."',.....,."..
.~,..._..,.,~...,-"'-,.,... ,.~.,-...-._.,-_.~;..~,..-".--"'-~... -,_."'- '---"''' ~"""".- ~','.....-
~.""~....,'"
_.............' ! .'__O!"..".-.~....._."""--.------ -.-;.:.,~~.. *'*->
UAII CHIC. 'ATAIU ,n "OHtQHa'AU, COUMIJI. 'I'A' r.ouU I
.........,,"'""".,.;.... ~..,..\1I- ..,..... .~_~""'~~~~~4,':.-'~,~~ t'..'ciu-#'f--~" !;....".f.n',.1li,'t.~..,. ......~.;."'.~4-,;.1Ii;j>1i'~~,..'4"',,-..,""_':....._~ J
"
.~~,',,;=----....-""-.~
I l'lI
Cl\'" ,....i..t "ff: 1(,'1 cA.\ ,~t- 'l'.",
(1...,,(.,,1. 1t., 1101'-
, ,
"",,' .
(\. t\t;\
....-.".....
1.A1I1tA r;. flAlJOHMAH,
PIAlntUt
I IN Till COURT 0' COHMON I'l.CAI 0'
I Cl1t4P1t:RI.AHD COUNTY, 1't:HHIVLVANIA
I
I
I
I CIVIL ACTION - I.AW
I NO. 'I-J70 CIVIL Tt:ftH
Y.
THOMA' I, IAVOHHAN,
Dlt.ndAnt
IN MI. rMOTlctloH 'RoM AbUl1
Q.IUWlJ.U'~~alWlT
AND NOW, thai alah dAy of JAnuary, un, thl
I'lalnUtf apPuull wlth coun"'l, Wlvnl r. lIhAdl, t:.qulr.. Th.
O"'MAn\; .ppur.d wIU,,}ut OOY".... loth PArti.. III VI
t..ttttl4. Th.r. hA' ~In no d.nial bV Mr. '.uqll.An I' to the
All.vatlon. .ade by Ill. will, And, thor.tor., I do rlnd that hlr
t..tl~nv t. or.dlbl' and I rind that the O.tlnalnt ha. abu.14
hi, wlf. withln the ...nlnq or the 'rot.otlon 'rOM Abu.. Aot,
Th. Court VIII IIQn I prot,gtlon ord.r Wh.n lubMltted
by uQun..1 tor the "Iain'llt. Th. Court turth.r 41r.ot. thlt
the Offend,", PlY 'hf 'illft9 QO". .nd anv oth.r oo.t. involved
wl\h 'M. Pf"'4ldiftll,"',t..~ ;{I_ ,t..... f\..tA#H4..'J II 'H ,'"
, ~ . "6' '<4P "'~'" ,.,,,, h Iy , II, Court.
h'H' l.t.,4,& .t,~,Jg
V(tli~ Gr>
ri~~fine.fj, ,. ,
-1./u
W.Y~ r. 'Ald.. I~utf'
'{Jf Uti 'lllntlt'
'tt;~~... M, ...",,/'IN"
rf~ h
Ii 1,,,
(......~
..
, /7!1.f
-:"-iA
,
L~;,,;i. i f
L'
1:
~',', 1 J
>,,'t
C"'Cl
"
'''',
.~ ;:
y ~";;-i
;~.
h
,I
,~ '
'.t:.
T-
i
-?" ,~'~-\"'*;.;
,,. r f-, ~ J '{),
,:~. ~ ::,,; -! '2 "
~ i(
q
'If 1 ~ f.
, ,
'~..1::,1 :tH
! j, J;
{. ~i'nf;;~ J;!-
t:; . 1
.~."
~-v :
~"',:~~
. .,,',
,(t4r:l
~. ;< "
"j
.'t ;:4
." 'j
-~
of
,4
t~..
'I)
~tr'" (; ?~l"A(~/ , Ayt, J
, /l1~)
CC*lMONWKALn' 0' PICHHIYLVAHIA I
I
COUNTY 0' CUMUlCltlJ\H1l I
II,
OCA,
1'01 H, Thom41 Kltne, IIhuHt. or "ny duly "uthorUo" lAw enfQf"fNnt
of t 1 (~or ,
HKll'llQlMfl..ll.J1ALIQI\MI\tf OOBI.JllOiJ.QIOCIAL IICUMlTY U,U~U,::UU,
___CC~____~___ , ., a(IX I Jl~~Il^CIC l.JfJtLlrr 11~l:ltr, ~J,1Q,
_____.CARI.IBL.. J'A l1gU ICYlClIllt&cU _ttAUl,UQ,.,01'N1 HOff.
I.lue the WarrAnt ot Arr'lt tor V1Ql.tlon ot 'rot let Ion fro. Abut.
IJ'l, 02'10 CIVIl. 'frcllH
WIIKIUCAQ, the d,hndAnt Above na.d vlolAtod A court order dh.eU", hill to
rernln from IIhy'I"Ally abuttno thll plaintiff or her ralaUv.., or plAC11l(J
thl;un In fear of "buo,.
WlIKRKA/J, thlo Court on ...JUflJ l"Un ~.,..,' dtrtt<:tfd " lleneh "-'rnot t..u,
tor thll apl1roh.n.ton of tho dlt.ndant, Tht. i. thlr.for. to C'J.d-'nd you to
nrrelt the dofendAnt above And brtnQ thl Gif'n4ant btlor. .. It CArllllll,
l'011llIlylvilnla, without UM."....rv d.lilY to btI M.lt wUh ."eofd'", to lAW.
WITNKIlIJ thl uf\(lontgnod ""dU', .t CIrUII" thl. "'uL",,,~, dAy of
., "'WIIL",~~_ _ ,... o..A,P., l'U,~~,
Jt:lgtfi.<t~tf.t*U~ ~""----r~J;
A'I'I'ItWI',
(i') , < 'a.
(:i;II.'i!~~"MuJ~t'Jjif ~ ,I,t~ 1:... ~ tf{~
(lj KAl.)
TROll C"PY 'ROM ",COt,,)
rf '1i'ft/i"f;tf,( _if-;fNif(~f f; ;~t't;;F~f:-f~ 4i'ifii~ ~ -I
;:v,-~t _-.. ,if%i*~~~t, 'f-!in '-,.
t_ j "~I ..,'. ""-AC i, '."
~- .wr1t:::~-'!"""'~1;::;1ItJ' . '/ro'. _""~'~ 't' '"' ,~
""'...-;~"..."" t~,;~.""
41/'1flf
&.AU""' I. lAUGHMAN,
Plaintiff
I IN THI COU"T or COMMON PLEAI or
I CUM'IR~D COUNTY, PINN'YLVANIA
I
I
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I NO, ,D-170 CIVIL TIRM
v.
THOMAI I. lAuatfMAH ,
D.r.ndant
IN "II INDIRICT CRIMINAL CONTlMPT
QRPrll or CQVRt
AND NOW, thl. 8th aav ot June, l"D, I hav.
lndloUed to the CO.llonw..lth th.t .1ncI the aeoi.lon ln thl.
oa.. 1. ba..d on wh.ther or not the O.t.naant .otually vrot. the
l.tt.r and the oth.r lntormatlon on Co..onv.alth" Ixhibit 1 and
that thl. vll1 r.qulr. a handwrltlnq .xpert, I d.t.r .Y a.oielon
until tha' enaly.l. .ay b. oonduoted by the 'Inn.ylvania .tat.
Pollo.. On thl. partlcular QhafQI I ..t ball ln the .u. ot
'1.00~.OO. Th. D.t.ndant .av b. r.l....d fro. jall upon po.tlnv
b411 ln that a.ount.
Iy the Court,
, L \ ,. ,.j \',
I, .h..
Th.... A. ,1IQ.Y, I.qulr.
'.nl., AI...'ant Ol.trlot Attorn.y
WlI11.. G. 'raUfht, Ilqulr.
A,.l,',nt ru_llo O.f.nd.r
<:~,
lUll
, 4i,'-~~"...!d
, ,. ,., " ~ , _,__i.., .1
J< ~, .1.. . '; ,. -f
h'i,;.~~. . " 11
ll~i.{i'i
SIt II ft t ,....
, I' "Iii'
Ii ",...",!\ 4 ~ " r'f J
" "'t.,.", "
~+
>A
.'
t;ii
tA
ld'"
Ii
I ,,~
\~I
CIW'I'IPICAl'I; MW 'l'IIANllHI'I"I'M, IIV IIIWOIIIl
IINlllW
l'~~JlII,YI.v^,H ^ IIIIP'; III" A"J't:I.J,A'l'I': 1'1I0Ci(IIlJIIl.; IlJ II I H I
'1'0 III.. l'IOl/II11l1lliIlY 0' tllll App"II,.,,, Coull III ...hld, till!
wit hlo mallln 1Ii1.. hOI!f1 ""1'",11",11
1ll1l'RHIOH (:O\lHT Ot' I'RNNIIYI.vANIA
'rllt: tlNIJl,IHlIIlNI(Il, I'fll'JlOlllllolfY III t "ll Coull (.1 CU/lullon 1'111.."
II' .~'!""~!I!"NI) COUllty, tlm "..i'll'llll/t tllli/IlJ II I'oun 01 r"colll,
110 IlI'rlllly cur'ify Ihlll IIIHIUMI'II l"'/I111l ,...,111111 I\lId ,,,.,rcH~1 l'oflY
III lilt! wholt! IllId 11111 In. IIH'I.nl, IIWIIlfIlIlI' .11I "lllolllO lit Ih.. Cllurl
/III required by I'A II,^.I', I'Jl". 11111 lIrlllilllll 1"'(lutIl /11111 uMhlbUI,
II ilny UIl fHu. Iho IrlU1II.'rlfll III Ihll JlIOl'lHlIllIllJlI, If Ilny, tlnd Ihl1
dlle~et entrle" In Ih" InllowlllU mall"rl
C... No. 9!1.;I70 ctvl1 T"nn, Nn. 40' IIbg 19'15
I,AUMA R "AUOIIHAH
VII.
TII(>>fA' IC ItAUOIIHA"
Th. doc::umlPnll compr llltrHI tll. , ,,('(.nl hd'" bet" Illlmbe..ed
(r"", No. 1 to No, "~""ll.t-"" ilnd ilt tachod hl'UIO .1 t/Chlbh A h /I
II"t of the docllmo"U corull'Ontllnuly tHunhur.d IIlld Id'fltUltl1 whh
rUllllon.bl. dtflntleo.'I. tnaludlnu wllh r~~p.ot to tach dgcument,
I h. Ilumb... ()t (111\1'" cOl!lpr II 11111 t h.. dOCUfflllfll.
'I'h. dAto Oil which the ncord II.", bfllllt tran.mUted to the
af'IH,l1ott CQIUt t. ,_.....,\llt~Jh,0.ltU~~..., .
(li"l of CQurtl
,
1~!4~U,!11t_.,l~~J~,6tCl(N
I'wthonotary
An .adltlon.' oupy of thll cortltlcate II .nolo..d. Pl....
.I~n .nd d.t. oopy, thereby loknllwledVlnq r.cllpt of thl. reoord.
If':COIfO Ift:CIUVIIH
I14t..
~ ---,,,.,,_fto,__'-"", """C"."" ','.. "" .~"-_.~;cc,"--~ ,;--.'0.--',-.. >_~,.. ..
,'_"'.O"'-"_~__"_''''';'",~_..,_,u.~_"., .._,_.,_._ re';-'-, "'_'._~_____-C _~- ---
14lqn.ture ~ 411'.)
-W 1 r
. L
.
':".~T'
,
( i r J r I I (
I~
a ~
I
I I" ~
f :"
f Q ~
~
."
I
I i i ...
J
i i i ~
r I~
----..... . ":j~'__~."_~:':Tr::'_. '!l-~':Lf.Jt~.:.d: -__~~:,,-,-:' '..', ._'.'--. "', ::';,'::~-_'::cY-_",~-,:Z'" .-:-'-l::[~"~'.lC,'~~_':J~'~:':-:',~_~.-_--:s::g::--:-~:::~--~'~_.~_...:.;.-'"
r\IIIUIl, Ihe Me~I'ldl .nd 1'III~fflhll" fn,uU,'d in Ih, '"1111 11/ ('IIInllllln 1'1,.. in .nd Ill' lh,
,uullly \., _ C\I'.llI'r1 (lr.1 .___'___._ mlhe ('lImmlln~elllh III I',nnly/vlnl.
No. 40'1 'lIlCl 1'11)')
III Nil ~1n Civl1 ___ h,m, 1'1 __ II funlltned Ih. Inllu.'ln,
("(If'V (1/' __
N-'lf.ll/lCtllllJ1.______
_' I)()('KH I'NlltY
l.M!lI^ E. "^UOIIH^N
Vtl.
TIIOH^,i I', MlJGIfH^N
I'I\I~ /fl.
I. 10 JIlIl. 18, 19'J!I, '''UUN' fl'>r l'rotoctlvll otU<J/". MfidllVH of Inauff1IJlenl nlld
fllr 1'00', larll T81l'orllry Pmtoottve O"llIr, ruoo.
AND N;1I, thll 17th dav or ,JAnuary, l<j'j'l, IJIIl/l rnnlhlurllt1tlll ct tho
withIn ''eUtlCln end up'" findlnll thnt ''e'ltlnnor III 111 Inmedlato NId pre,.nt
llitnlJllr of llllu,. frun l1ea{T,'Odent, tho foll['\l/lng TClIrp:'rllry I'rotecllva On'or I'
enter.'.
Re'll'l1dent II III",by enlol1l8l1 fmn phy"IC:/Jlly "'A1alnll I'otltlOl'llr or
I'lnqlou !wr lrl fNr of tnrnlnenl HrlOUI lulUy IniUlV 0011 II ellc11.ded frull
lhe ""ldll(1<;'1I of I'et1tloner III 2J tVrttl ~jdtl",lon /lOIld, ('odlll., C'\IltlOrlmd
County, I'eMllyl'/lInlll 1701), Ilnd frun lhe pl11l'O of CIlflloynent of I'etltlO/lOr
at weAtem SlnHn '.\teAk lIou.., 1:/0') llArrlthlll'g I'lke, Cllrll,lo, CUlburlllrd
lbunly, !'vMllylv/lnl/l nOll.
Thll Onter IhIIll ruMln In eUll("t unt 11 A flMl OnJer II .nt.r.t In
Ihl. ca,.. A "'rt09 IMll I'll luld III th!, "WItter on Munday, the llnJ lk1V
of J40uary, J'j'J~, lit 11:10 n'ehlCk p.m. III COllrtm'" Nu, J, CUlb,rlNvJ County
ClIurthouI., C/lrllll., "-MlY JVllfI 1/1 ,
n. I'l)rlh Mlddt.too Townlhlp !'oll". lvrwulnlllflt /IRJ Iho MlMl..811 Town"
.hlp 1",111:'. rvl~rtl11ll1t will Meh be pl'llvldal with II ('('py of lhtl OnJer by
IUJl'IMl fllr ''oUtloMr aM 'MY enfon,. thll Unler by an"l ror trdlrClCl
crlmlMl oonlftl1lt wHhllut warrant Uflll1 11roblhl. raula that thl. orner 1"'1 t
vlolat.t, whellllr or not till vlolat 11111 II l'Ull1l1t t~t In I ho pr...oca of II
ll"l1ce ottt,,.r. In thll went that an afTlilIl Ip rmde under thl. hetl',",
IlG'jrlllllelll .111I11 not tlfl taken III jaU, hut "ltill b. laken wlthnut UI\I1II('II../l
delllY hornr. U. Court I,tlteh 111I1 t.'\JOlt thll Onler. When thll ('(lUlt tl un-
l1VlIl141blo, IlGlll('tI'Iltellt .hail Ill! Arralun.d hl1fnro II Otltrl"t JlIItiC4l lot., IhaU
IIOt 1>'111 /l<xwdlno to tho 1'((IvIIII,"1 ut c:t>'ll'l.r 4000 of the '..nn.V1vant/l
Irlll.. uf Crlll11l\ill f'rt1l~.Illr..,
Ily tlIII (,"ourt, ''''rnld \C. "hooly. P..I,
II JM. ;16, 1"'1, tlll.riff', ICululfI ..r ~rvkll, fllal.
II ,I/WI. 2t, 1""'1, Ouwr or ('("1ft I r 11011, In 1'1/1 l'fUtOCtllHI flun ^,iUlHI
ANlI N;W, thll J"lll ,lily uf JllfllliUY, 1'1"", till! l'l,II'itIU ItJIJ'II/lrtld wllh
",,"_I. W,'YIIll r, ~ttNW, 11'.11<1\11(/(" 11111 l...r~,lil"t "n."'lf.' Wit/lOUt ('(I\JI__l,
!tilth lUlU... lu...... h..tUII"I. 1'-". I... I~"t ru tlt",ldl I.." MJ", 1\J\J9t.,W1fl'" to
II... 1111-1'1""'1 IIH.... "~,,... I.." hili wltu, Illd. tto.Hl/lo,.., 1 I.. IllvI thll~ Iwr lilt#llm
I" nl'lllljltt ,lid I flrd th.\ II... 11IIf'l'I."'1I1l h.~ 1II.~d hi,lI ....U. ....Hlll" II..,
"'''II.I"e,1 III II., l'lll'eo'. 114' ~ ,.... N._ .....t,
TI.. \',,,.{\ 101111 1111" I' 101\01....' '''1 III<IVI IOhfll "".1'''111... 1'Y nJUl_1 h'l
t1~ l'I'Il1111H. "Il.. Ihul tHltI.., ,11f""'''' '10,1 \If' la.lt."L.'" "''I' II.. '111"'j
"..,,, ,..1 ,,"t ,,1111:11 ,...1,. 11M'''''''' w"la tI",. 1",._11111"
fry ".. n.II', I~.,,,"I ~. "'/i...lv, ", I.
('''I'll. I
:U,;-^"
1'11I3': I'll,
1\.
If, .
n. n
11,'11" 101 I
TI., n~lrt
tJ,lH. TII'
"II lrll.tn
I I,,}I') ,
14
.Ian, :10, 1995. Pmlcct Ive OnlC!r. fllld,
ANn N:W, Ihls 21th d.1Y (If .11InuollY, I'N'r, ul'''1 nll,"ldurllllflll ell IIWI ('.111-
sent ^grllmenl of the IkUUUS, 1m Illllelwlll\l OHlor III f!nlllttllll
\, IctendllJlt "kH\.'1 ~. 1,^lxnl^N Is nnll!fl.t 10 lvlraln Imn (JIWJIIIIIl,J
Plaintiff IAlll" 1':. IWXU1AN 01' plllCllllJ 11111' In IlInr 01 tlhlll" or IhJl!dIC!1111l1l I. ,
1" Icfendant III onJend 10 rolllllll Cn.n hUlllullny 1'llIlnlHI, "'nlnIHf
rel/ltivoll or Ihe pl!UreOllll with atun l'lnlllllf'f la "'.rklll\lllr fl'.hllfl\l, lnl'l ,t1 I 011
dlcecllnlJ lnlllUllk,ltlonll, holh oml Will written, 10 i.Jr.
], l:Clerdlllll 18 cnjulrltlll flun untllrlll\l l'I,llnllfl'lI I'lllI'u of C'fl'llf~IJO/\I
III WORlom IHulln Hleak Itnu.e, llll'\ It'urllhurgl'lkH, edllh.le, CIf't",rINd
County, l~nn8ylVimla I7llU,
4. Iclellllllnt hi urdecoJ tn IItay I'IWllY Inl" IIlU rwldene@ nl "I,iltlltlff
lit 111'<<"rlhMJddlelm HeWI, Carllllle, (''1J1tlJrlilldCtlllllty, 1'li!1\I1l1!ylvilnla 1'I0n,
and Inln OilY rellldenco which l'lalnlltl mtJY IIIJlllhlllh IlIr '.rH!f III t1fC1 tulm
5. Thll onter st~ll1 rumln In utll\'l:t fill' /l r~rinl of nn. y...u.
(I. Tho I'<<'lrth Middlelon 'I'oMlshill l'olle8 ~pIlrl".mt ard tho fo4hltU.I.1I
Township 1'01 tee Ix.pilrtJront wUl 8II('h he pmvlded with d ropy of Ihl. Onklr
by counsel lor I'lalnt Iff any IMY enforcD Ihll onll!, IIV arf.sl lur Indlrill:I
crllnlnnl C't11tOOllt without WlllTtlnt UIllll prnJable "IlUlle 1t\41 Iltll Onl4tr tVlII
boon Vlllltltlld, whether or oot Iho vlullltlnn I. I'Clrlnlt Itd in Ihe 1!n1..ooe ot
., rulles officer, In Ihe BVltnt UllIt ttn orr.'I II "'lite Inter Ihl. Helton,
fVferdttnl Dhall nol lit! taken to jlll1, bill 1~11 hu laken wlthoul \JI1IlIllC't!IIBllry
delay bafon Iho Court which hne l"UI!lI thle Otlklr. WhIIn U.. Cr~lrt II
unavailable, Ibhmd/lnl BM11 00 4Jrrallllllld /Jefore II Ollltrlet JU4Itll'e \.flo .'ltlll
101 tlllU lJCConHng to the provtllOll. of Chapler 4000 uf thl! l'ennllylv4l\11l IftJI
of CrlJnlllill Plnclldurv. T'lfJ conlent of He, 1l11l!JhMl1 WM IIII~ In Ilwm ("("!ft.
Py the Ct.l\lft, HlIfOld Ii:. 1I'_ly, ".J.
I'} .'ob, 2. 199!l, Cortlflcatlon of llaU Illd DIICIVll\Jll
20 fob. 6. 199'. Onler of COllct, tll""l. In Rel ^/lflJIIII.JIl8/1t (If (';:wI/I..I
ANO N::W, Ihll 21.1 day of reb0J4ry, lCJ9'I, It., Court /IjJJlJln!1 till "Jbll"
lufelder In repreBent tm /bteMant nn Ihil clvU\Jll.
By U. Ct"JI.t, 'lanlld Ie, lI'lNIV, 1'.J.
t'c1Il. 6, 199'. onSer of COllrt. f 11""1 , In nil hitl1 Nllt tlMrlno l\1h' IIIIt
ltNll ~." Ihll 2nd dllY of l"ebnlAry, IVV'l, the l-.f/lllld4nt WIll _fr.-tM 'hi
1I"Jl.clly vlolat Ing tlllt protllCtllll1 tnln /111\1II0 order flfwhl",.ly IllIMt tIV 9.
81. 'I 'Daring on the alll7VO CUIfIl/1lnt for nalf."'Y, floImlAry V, 19.,'1, 41. llJi()
our' furlll\!r dlrel"tl IhAt Ihe /bflll.lant hot\rIIMrl 1.'If IIfll thill cia!.. l'l~ly wilt.
Ilol1a 11/11I (ltroottoOIt or the proll<,Uve onSltr IllAt I ill'MI l~ J/lIII14fY ntll,
HIIl('1!l Iho 1I1lo\JOlI viol II! 1011 did /lol InvlltYll NI)' 1-'V.h'III "'__ nf HI!!
viet itn, Ill. ."f"".ll1l1t tmy 00 relea....l fmll 1'1I11.ul)' Ihilt MItt UJIlfl f{jlltlrtg
co WU,()() Mil f(lf' hi. Ill'rWillrllllCI.I . dlllill~'''' fur YllllfllMY !jIll, ''Iii''. ,..,dlliU
Itlll 1'181111\1 of tllIll holll I. t. r1ll1wwltlll III II. ellllluly of U.. CI'f_.rlllfl1
('willy IillOrlrr.
IIy !.tlfJ (hltt, II<IIold ~. 1l1....ly, !',J.
II. /4 "'eb. 10. 1m. Older of ('vlJrt. flh~l. In IlIH (:'wl!<fI".
~) M:W, l/lllt 'JIll (ldy lit f'Ul''''''YI IIf';'1, It ""MI'''l WhIf '.14 1'.14y (4" It
rl\!HI lc~1 1111~llt'll thllt '>1, .'vllf\IIlIY lid, 1';'1'1, HIlf l\lt..,.J,;/it ....1I1i111 II.. &oJ/W.,
I Hf ,It I.... 1114<'0 01 W11(k ". th'" W(;'"I~I/I Hlulin lile,JiI. 'hll!W, 'JI.I iJIll""J ~.H..(
nfl\it!(!ii,;\ i,l/\ "'.f"dl"I.~1 I.,r j rill., .lIdo', rill urn " ""'iI. ['"II,
'l'h.; f'.r'fi'~f'tiv4:; pf,t~:jIr- in Hil. f._~1 Wr~ ddttw:1 ,t~~,l,<-H.,. jl"1, lll;'~, ~..t
1"""111"11' I. ....."1 ',11"'1 I"H~...., I.... lh' t""'....II.} 1,>1.."",.. '"" l.ollf"I fll,..,
"it) ~'("'Hunltf.th"'h'f hill}! IIft11 rni' .'t "'''''Jt. to h:;'iiJ~ 'f." h-tfF'fdwlf ;.."'l'ia t~
I'ilt ~,{.ll "'i'lfltl", dHI1 tftt1 rrl-"~j"l '.if tljr; I.,tt w:"-:: 'h.lt ~t__~ hllt f'.r,",\;ii"'~tv
1.,Jlrtt 'll!'n flfl tflr1 '''..of... ,lilt' WtH'I'n:1 "1 ""tW wh.i .1t1',\_ ;'4~1 L. f,-" 'L ft..h... ~.t
...w.'~""_"'~I.", cC'_".'"'' _,___''.. , '",.__,,_...,,_...,..,_c _.._~__ .....,._..
"ltW'.f.I\io 110. lti..~", 1,,1, In ft" .,..,' ,I' "....., H _,,\~ 1,'., f., I ,""'"...~
(~11"" Nil. 1J'l.nll Civil "ulm, Nn, 411'1 IIl1n IIJ'J'i
..u~ N ~
:1 ,'4 '" ~"IHIIJIl le.III1'I'uIIIlIrIlJ 01111 ""II..,. Ih.. Ilolll/klll/11 Ih'BIlll'nell Illr It 111I.,
111,1 1..1 ,.tu,n a l_u\O ['110 II~II 1I...1.IIIIIIlJ WIlli going In 1.'PIIOIl III .1., /\/1d
'III' ':hUlIum, IIIlthJU(Jh 11"'1 _,''''1111' Illnl'Ud(,jU wtI. not Inclld",l III Iho 1'<11'1'111101.
. t"VII lulll 1<1'11I. l\lU'Jltl~~/1 111<11 uld.., "" l'I 11'111111 IInr'u. <1fwl ul1Il.r /111
IMlKlfl .t..,111 .1.. In 011I tulu,.. tI\i4O, II\lllu 11 ('11\1 or write hl Mr. l,",uI)II'I<II1,
",.. It alII 1_111 Anv InlollOilt 11~1 tlUII hl/1l It 1I1.",ld to IhlO lIunUlIh hor
III tnn_v. I Iwtlo'll 'WIllI Inld Mr. t\'u\J"'~ln Illl" lill IIIUlld In tho fulUro urdur nil
f'1f(JINt4111'.a t',dl I.,r 0' wrtte tu tllt' (IIr /lnv """1100. /tnd if I. I"'. tlnV
1",*lf1 10 nlfllpet I., tllIln h. at'JUI.' 111.0 1'" ""'I through /1/1 IIllolllev.
Thluefl>'., t nllrt IIItH II. I_WlI)lf ('lilt tlli'! he liVId. to the 1'1/llnliU nil
,'.,brwty l"t 1~I/lC.lfllnlJ th. lIw'IIt1,," fit MUI, l,",u\lIIII/I/1'. clotllftll Ml' or Ihe
.hUtlu,n'. Ilh.H_ wtIll Inlt Ilttetl hV II_ I'I/llnlltf hera.lf. IIrwl hB dtd lint
vlolAt. II. I'(fll",-,t I,,,, fruII AtJUlie (If.ler ... tar 1111 Ihlst rmverllntl(lf1 I. COIlI'llnl<~I,
AI fAr All Ihll '''lflVe,allt 11'0 dh~lt II(lfltlthln(J lotlllld hnrren 10 tiff Of hl,lf
Ihlldrtlf1 HilI. IlIl1n", ll!olum hla I'nll, I will ",,'1'8Il1 11-. I'lnlnlHf'1I 1..IlIlUIlY
It_H, In tlll't. thltt IollIlII 11.11('. /lrwl . find IIlIlt he III In ("(1I1Ifllll,)1 of thB I'rotertlnll
tn", AI..... (lr~r' for 1I11illhllJ tl~... rUlvtr"".
IlrlWV4ar. I do IV" t..l HIIlI ..nv ..nl Dill'. In prl.on 1I<<)\Ild lB j\lllt Hied
I....... ,.-. II... '.IIAr".. ,UKI, Ihef.f"r., I dhll<'t lIIAt ho l\'ty Ih. c..l. Invn I Vt'!C1
hi'" It_. l!(tI....IIII{J11. ^,,11 I ",'uIrIIl4V 10 Mr, 1\1IJ4;JtfMn tMt if he c411. tIIr
1/1 It. fulUll!1 fur N'1Y rNllnl thAt . IoIlJull1 ()I0(.... at It",t I 1fl1J to ..nd the
l..hudMII III ,..-111(1/'.
Pv IhIII (\Wlrl, ll<1rnld Ie, KhHIV. I'..'.
/';, 'f. ....-tlh.. ...,. (l"t.f I,f ('(jurI. Hhd. In He, Cl1n1llfl1>t
1<IIJ ,..~. thlll Jlllh day of ret'f\AAry. IQ'J') , IhIt t:ef.nd4nl 1l1'P'lIrlld In c(JurI.
lu14V r-vr....rttlill1 by WHit"" e1. Itrm~t, flll,"ir.. AI.lltAnt 1'Ilbltc (.t.rwler.
'11.. ""'IIK.tlr.,-, tTlfft A.t'Jyq 1',,14Ir vrevlvu.IV .nl.(lid In thl. ed.. II/1VI It"'t tI..
l..f.,lltMt III ."'nll_1 fnrfl .fllllrlll\ll'lnlntlff'l plac. of 'If..lnv"'.nt at WeIlIIlI'I
t;julln !HMII 1iI'Y/H1, IlO'\ l14nialllUU I'lktI, ('.<Irlllll., C\1lt18rlllrwl CtJllnty, 1''\,
n. r.fff.1Mt hAIl APltt..1 IllIl' ht did vlollU. thl. on14lr yelt"r'dav /lb~lt
W, I' ".11I, lit." t. did \JI. tll Itlll vii t lJII'lI 1'111I. of "'11tIJ)'llltnt. Till' ..ferwlllnl
1I1''''flllitly \lId r,ut ... htll wH.. .'ll' IIRIe /10 IhrN" to hili Of MylhllllJ .1110.
~'. tt.f.rll(l, I 4fl1J.t --1If111 II. lur",.IM' to JAU hdnv, I1lthouQh I .In
tlfd . vwI4tk;f\ lit tt.. I'fliltl4!tlw '((11I "'".. IIltler lwc/ll\lll. of IMt rorouct.
n.. '-''lfft ('IH_ll, U1iI1 ".. l.t"ld.'1l1 .,..11 4It All t1/l1Jl1 In tI. tulur.
'''''fib wUIl Ii. i"wt",!tU"I t((1II Atll_ 1Il1tor, "I'd I ,.., 1.1I1HO hll rw,lW II1lllJh1
I.. vllllAte H ~'h. ul(Jimll_" I.t wl(jU.r I.. thfNle,flIId hll wife. 14'W hIli
wlh. .'" Ii!flylhtr,;J ..I.. IHvulvlnu hili wit", It th. nrdflf II vlnl"llld 1111I I.
,...rHlII.IV \JI.IIJIj l(t \JI> ,.. 141\,
IiY 11'.. ",un. "...old Ie, iii_Iv, 1',J.
/ I, I i ~m ~.. I~, (".fItl."......ltt.'.. 1..1 ill..,t rIO, If '....rlnU 110 ClltU\JIf1l of Indl'....t
n ""ilIA I 1~"H..,.,., "'", 1111"" I.t ('44ift. t UtIl'.
/1HII '''f, ".,.. .141" '!.w ..t Mol/'", If",'l, n'llI <',,1ft ..flUI.. Il1nt 1111I
"',111I,1.' ''IfI<t.,j,.,,,, I~ ,_" J<{'''fiI'ly """,'.1",,' ",1I wr. U hod. Ill" I'..". It
'<1I.."""J. (illl_ "f/: H... ,,./tiI<1l"'" lit ""..',.,..... III "u'IIII~,.rlltloll of 1111I ..Hili,'..,'
I,"tfflO,of_HI"If ho~" 1''1'' " W/tJIit!Wt I'l l'*'I.1';U '~1II UIII: AIt/tJfflt lit II.. I..,t"".""",
".JttM ~. I1NUWff,
U At.. ''''''''f".w,' .. ".lfd ',~iI I.,,} '.>1;-'.1 (~"'rtt.w.. 1'"1''', It.. dd"".lN'l ,..
h ,... '''''411#'' "-*"....1'1 '''''''flll Itfil 04iH, It ''''1 fl""" .Iunnel t\w.fVn_
IH"", lki .......J"J,.f.~ .ro \,' I. 1"-"" I"~ U... '4"'.IH Ph" i~ \ ;..n... ..., h.1\
C"'RO No. \ls-nu Clvt I "onn, No. 405 11110 1\1\15
''N3~ I'll.
n - 11 1I111 IJUrlUtlllt 10 Iho IluleR uf Criminal I'/u~ldurn, "\lrthlllllnro. .,fler 1I/11lOIIrllltl
helor!! Ih., Ulltrlcl ,IUlltlcu Iho dofoldlml III .1llvhlal 10 .1pPllilr 110foru tho
Courl Mnlnlltrlltur lit Iho opoll uf Ih" noxt hUBtnolB day.
IQferdant Ik111 ., right In \Ill ropnll10nlt>/1 hv 611 tlttornev, If Ihe def"rdc1111
(',1nnol IlfflltU an ilttomev. ulnn [mluoRt OliO will ho 1118tuned to repre..nt
Iho lIoferd"nt, 1'ln MIIOIUlllunt of C1ll1tll to Ixl dolol1nlnoo bV Ihe Trial ,!IdlJll
lIutlllCl]\lCnl 10 trllll.
bV Iho Courl. 1I.u1lld lC, liheelv, I',J.
III AprU 20, 1995. Order of Court. 111od. In 1101 II!!/lrlng ~ltO Hot to Cl'>nchdo
TOIIIIIIIlIlV
NII!>~. thtl llHh d4y of AprU. IlJ'J5. the I'rotecllnn fron Ahu811 hOllrlnq.
..fter hearing t(xlIlY. wlll bo continual until WaII1l!BdIlY, April 26, 1995. lit
ItOO p,/O, 1'ho Courl dlrQCtl 11111 IQfelKlanl 11lIMln In eU81rdy until tho I"ilrlno
I.. c(lIll)hded I1Il thllt dilte,
Uy the Court. Iklmld lC. Khealy. I',J,
I') '/1 A&trU 21, 1995. Trllnlertpt of I'nlCeedlngl. "lIal,
74. 711 Itty 5. 1995. Order of Cuurt. fllal, In Rill Indirect Crlmlnlll Coot-.,t
AND ~M. thla 26th d4y of AprU. 1995. I. 111I1rofoOl, find tho fllJffIMnt
INUlY of Indirect crlmll1ll1 contempt of court. lie 18 IICInlenclld to C",b,rland
('punty l'rllKll1 for 41 (llIrlo1 of forty-five rt.'YI. and IB 'MU tIl, glv.n I:r..11t
'ijl tho Ilhlve aentonce fmn April 18th, 19'1'1,
II. IllIIY W r~rohKl without t'lu:ther aoler lit Ihl8 Court Ulr'lIl ',rvlng tho
fnrty-tlYll daYI in j4l11. Ilf'-JI1 ,.hm.. frun prllon I dlrClCt lIIAt he at 1111
ttllQlt In the future co",ly with tho ImltnJCttllne Md dlrectlOOll of thle
pnler. The ClJllrt further dh'/!Ctl tMt h. IdY Ihe CIlIt8 of IIro.lJCutlon tnvolval
In thll ('''<lBe.
/ty tt1l1 Court. 1I.1rold It, liI.,.ly. ".J.
/'!. /II Itty 25. 1995. Order. filllft.
AND MM, thla 2'Hh dllY of Hity, 199'1. ^rl1llcdnt 10 IIlretJy gfllnllld 1..,ve to
..,..,111 in fol1lW I"ulerlo,
lIy the Court, flilwld (l:, llhl!l8ly. I',J.
II}. 11'1 Itty 25. 1995. Nollett of ^rlllllltl, flied,
Nllt Ice II IlIQfllby glveu tho1t Tlnllol. It, llalllJlrlliln, CUfendant above MI1llIII,
IIt'rl'\Jy i1llJfllid" ti' IhIt !lu....rior Cnurt ot 1\!On1lY Ivtlnl41 hun tll/! JI.lI{Jlent of
Itl'ntencu lIIlI.al In Ihll IMttllr nil ^,'rH 26. 111'1"1.
"YI Wllll~n IInluuht. r.ll(l.
U(,. 111 Itty:n. 1995. Nil, 40'1 1I0Cl 1'.1'1'1 1I1l!l11JllD(t by !lHlflIf lor Court ht "^
1111 J,n, 2, 1m, O"ler of Court, fll\'llt, In RIll 1'/1, n,".I', 1<12'1
IIMlM_M. thla nit dtJy Ilf M.\Y, l'IIJ'l. /1111 h'. hwll1(J bHn rOl'ftIV\'ll.l thill
1111 ",,""I t\A' I~n tl1ken In the l.h1Ve"'II/lllollO(l ""tter. It II onler\'ll11l/1l1
tllrlJl(,'l\'ll1 tI~1t thol ItJ'Pllllllllt forthwith fllll with tIN>> Irl41 }lIllJl1l It 1)(11'1(11...
Illnl.fltlll ot U., fJ\lttlt'lI In",J'JlriEd ot ,.1 th, .J,....'I1. 1I.".,Uwr wl,th ,.,fllrt/.'ll
10 tI/lY Illtlllllllry 'liJlhlll.ly IIr II/IY IlIIIl ot "'.IlI. 1~J1f1 tlfiI 'alllIH' ot IIw
",,@Um)! III fll", .,ltl, l(#iIlO(ijljj wHhl" t!JUII....." (141 ,1i'YII. II'll ('(Illrl will 1//;/(11111'"
u..t \lilt ......,'1 11111I Ill""" tlhJ/dm4ltl,
Jww I, I"" {''''l/,:I~ IHtH4SIlti'!l1 tlf M,tllt.f'.. ('"",1.111...1 lit 1j(1 ~ljlt<d, It 141111.
Ilyl Willli.~ Ill.P~Jlil,. 1"""'1. for hlH.
J...., 11. .""",0..1/11'.' III "'<Of II\lle I'JJ~
l>vl U'Ul'}(l I'.. {~I"~IY. ..,J.
.hll., ... '"". 1I.\llf<ll\f lH. '11""1, 111....t II_Hf,'./t t'f1111il;,tJ {'H11~>t
1"L'IIIIHI'. t.lill,I!!,
/i', . '11.1
'II
II.! II~
IIf, IIH
LAN ., IAVOXMA.N, , IN TlI couaT 0' CONNON 'LIAS 0'
.hlntlU , CVMIIaLAND COUNTY, 'INNIYLVANIA
,
Y. I CIVIL ACTION . LAW
, ...a10 CIVIL TlaH
TKOHM .. IAUOIOWf, ,
Deeandant I ,aOTICTION ,aOM AIU.I
IN .., IfIAJlINO DATI "T TO CONCLUDI TIITIMONY
Oanla or com
AND NOW, thl. 11th day of Ap~ll, 1"1, the
"",,'1.. ',oa Abu.. haaring, aftar haa~lng today, wlll ba
,,,'lnu.d until WadA..dIY. April a., 1"'. at 3100 p,.. The
Cou,' .".... tbe O.,.ndant ,...In In cu.tody until the haaring
1. ....1u4e4 .n that d.t..
IY the Court,
j,1J ~~
' ~ I'
,/ l .' F- ' , "
, loll', .. '/, ,. '
~. A. 'l..er' ..~1'.
At.l...., Dl.., .. A".,n.y
Willi.... "IU9ht, 1.~l'.
A..l...., ru>>11. 0......'
,. ..lIl' htA
Ct:,
Nt
Cf.lITIFICATlON OF IIAll
AND UISCItAnOl
IOtN
'J'hllllldli L. H(lIH]llllldll
It" Old (;1111 UtI.
,_{:n~'.!,~I..! I'A 1'1011
H, -1\ !~,.
t,dll;'Il..tiIHti
!"
_.~ _, ~::_ ~_~'~_.. '_~~~',._' '_f,
" Il!'f!
...- ..-._-_._----~
\
I ',Pi! 1,,,"\ 111.-'1",1\" i,l~tjlfl I'lIill dpl;tId"lIl1 al H~u'l ;,l1fh tti'lJUl1t!d ,
{'''\III (",,:101,," <I.l.rrell untH handwrHlnu
.II,'1yoh may b. "ondueted by the renn.ylvanla
fitl1to Pul ico,
,..1Ij'j1 II H,"".Ilt.I,.n. !I "1-'( tt.."""1 I
.-------.....-.
"
'.i'f', -"'['-4
1''''1,.., y I..' '1',"
uooo,oo
1'+-1',
1,'1'.'
11011. 1I.,n.I.1 r... ,~~.e,,-lx.___ ____~,_____
APPEARANce OR IIAIL 1I0ND
HitS .O~D " YAlID 'Oil IHI IHIII'I 'IIOCUOiHOI AHD
V~1I1 fVll AHD "~AL Ill.,OIITIOH 0' tHI CAIIIHCIIiIlIHO
'I~AI OIiPU.IIIOH 0' A~Y "llTIOH 'Oil WIIIl 0' C.IIT10llA"1
OM A'PfAL lIMIL Y flLlO IH IHI IU'IIIMI COU"I 0' Ill'
V~llt '''AI''
-".OJ..."
11',-210 CIvil '1'."",
., ,
I n<lI...",1 Cr Imlnd Conloo'l,l
IVlulatlun ur I'rul..ctlon frllm "'"... \lnl"r)
....1., t IJUI,' Al 1ltJ~
...'t"'"
----~_. .------.--...-.--.-"--.
~ to, ...1,
'VI
( 'lh(~1
11.1
:.1 tJf~hmlt_//l(,,!ll"l
t 11t>!t'I-'~ ,..,!.Iv It,.;tl 1->.11 I/. II'!" 1,;iIII'.1i ,....,./1 "'l!t-'tlt'
~ it, !I'p -If. II''';! l' 1
iD (lI1l;td'iilliiIH1I1tK<le;llll'tlnitJ,
_J!Yl1!.!LR<!~~8r .
'f I .... 4 ..,. J- ~... , d .. "1
1111
~.-...------- .-_........._~'---<-.~..-7-:-;...~..,-;.~--
. 11i'hllIjJ...1 \ /Ihl, Ii",; I'.';; I,ll "'lfdM Wlllj'j ,;i,1 (jot,.. 41If.,
IU'd1'J'''ilh-.,(I/;!J 0',4"('( It 4fH',(HI
. At,!;.''!'' ,1,.;1 ill'-P! t,III';' ;,1 t.""j 'Ir,!ll* Ih''lt'"f,,,"lll'llliy .,fl....'
,'illlh" 1r,;'I'WI"1J 1,1,"1 _1-'_IIlI."h"ll IP... H c! ,~ Ati'-"I'Hj
. BI[!.lj(,h11lt,.lIh.... l-ll'! !1~Ul:.ti4I..It.~J\.ilt
,.~~..".~.._--""~-,---^',"'-- - '....~"..-. ..".-. ,..,~_...--...._---"-_.._~......_.- ~ .'.....~.." .~.._-_. ~ -.
IJI!.:.luAll(,! H!l "fhi,1 "~lDh.tt~UA"t IRtlr.HU~l\j[iV ,I
It. t _4.i~lllll.i1l '111 \ilMI N {A(j'jot tu.,t( lltt. 'MOw-t 5" Ii II
L "_ . - t, .' _1' I 'w f I" I , . I ,I'l, ~ JIl\( ;tti f."", .,1 ;I.\j ~ -"1" I
".9t!t.n_......,_, j.,.,,_.__~\m. ,__ ,,9~
____ l..bL,Q.. !'f~~'V-1' '.'1\'" I""
_.~~ "" (lplV, (0. OnollJlY
.---.......--'.~---_...,. ' '._'
w" "" U~UIl\"O~I() ..I......t ..... ....1' ,., ....n....., ho". .n. '''19''', ... ",",II, ..... ...,,"1, ......... t. ,., to tho
C..llllt'."....llh ."...nor,,,..i.lh...,,,.1 On. Thou../ul .................~.... ....11"." 1000 olIO
In ReVERIE 1I0e 'OR BAIL CONDITIONS
CflHlflCATION 01' COUNU" INDEMNITY AND PReMIUM 11\1'1'''(,>1"" ('t1l'V Wh"" tliJI~tv', ^ C"'l'''',ol',,'''
, ""'1"1'''; ,f".j
""i'I.lt
I,.,., 1,' Vel, 't,l ".,. "ljltl i_,lIIt Vi ~"1l1 ~1'!lU '1"11111 '~<l,,:1 h,jli-i, Ljl 1;,";1' ."" 111;1'0," I',iil~!'~' +~,,~~
....""... .'~...'~,""'..--.:_,_~...7--,~., ..-.,..,_,".,'A""... ..._,_.........."..
,,' i d. ,! ," '!" - "
_",~,,, 1,_ ,... j;.d HIfl'll\', t I" ;ht >~~I;I t.. "" 'j'''' ,,' .;ii~,_,~'i< 'Ill ',,;,I,t.t> t.,
I" ".1' . - f ""jl '. ".il I '.-' , ')1'" hjlllJ .~".-I ,. 1-, ',,jllt ,,\,'i~!l' i..,j;H' "'il""'_.',' - ,. .'.-..l"'lj eJ' .......~
4.KJ Hll !~lh"l t-40yuttM iUAtfJl4jlfr Ii, H. ~ j'dlH lIlt! ...ita ~"'I.!1 t. t j'
"',.'~'.""_~". .-"",'.r 't'....,,~,...,_""'"'...-,........."'--'.,.. --..".....",,~ .."""'''...........~ '~","'---.,
_ ...,. ~ ..v,....-....'~~.,"" ...""'_._..... ..,-".......!....-.".-."........"_,__..,.....'-'..._.____..__~..,,.... r.._
to- ';'!'II' . ~dtt "1011 HI";,, ,di' I", j"lh,;;'''..411 4;;.h,,);1 'I.~ ~...rl' "i",'.;l.- "HiHlr '1I'h;""'II~!1 ~"ri d!:t..w11,tt 1> ~w'l;._iil:1I filWI "ljJl tf~'llt Ii"t. "h'l< tilt ~1.u1 !II" \1,lt, .,1 .-i> I,
'1.'1,)'1<4 'I i'I' I'!"~ 11 Hl"lI II, *hq I.. l,.lll-kh flj 'ip"l! '11 ..;,,,11, liltl j!tUUi'*"1 i.....~ lli't!" It,.... !i'lu 1~1'!lI!!'" l_."!~_'Y-iyl.tlqj W
_.c.".."-'"....,.,.~.~....."..~...~_.,...,'__"""""..."....~_.,,.,..>s_ . __ ......~c.___
i ,~~ I" ;,
. .."'.~."._,~...",..,,_..........,~........"'''' ilf
.
MVIIII.'QHIIlIN ""ION
., 'HI A'''''QYI040INI
'A( ,,;oWlI QQ. IHAlI'1orI UOAU YI..,(lIIt/IU H).
'lit 'VII '!<IOU!;! 0' IHI I"'~
,. I
".".,
,,'1 ,.'1
, J
J"""ff ",
<';.tUuh.
.'u.
. f ~.'.
"'C' ,.
HI.
J\;l,.
H
..~h,~~..\
c( . ~!~~...
11,t V. t'f t.t J.~411.f.-H Y
.
^
1 ~..L
....
-".IL
_.__i'..kl>
.
'!I"ll
~~"..'_"".""!.__.....,.."'..,~".....'"'"'''..."''''._.....'.'''''''''''fii..,,,.,._'..''',.~.,."~.--"''''~.'...'''...'''''''''".,,....~.
.--'......' t .
~-"~:"'''",,('
.Lr ' ~ J h! I
,.~~:~t;r.~:~~t~~,..,..~_. -~ ..,~
_ .."\ _'~'1 .....--~..............._,__,.._..,J/l.\.
,'"f,."" ! ,.''''~ ~.Jj f~ J""'>t~jrffli 1,,+/ A'.p~II,.. 'j} 41 .,,'~
f.l,}-_"l:_.!'; '.1 _...~,;.,~_f" 1.., ".) i'f,'''''' 'N;:-'ft~",J'11~. '," ,~.-w".~.J '.~'. "",
..,. ...., ';r f_s.-.'" J!.~ It J_ - ,^"J 1,'-4' ;,,:;,it......' .I: -ff'~ ""_~,, ;.,l,,~~,''-''.
fl I .. ~"4-
.
,ill " .""t.
OII1(,,"Al
. ....'
.1oIl OlIlill/ll'ONI
., ,'I
.. J......." 1c . 'f , .. f . '" . .. f . .
jLfI:lU.'~All(iN Of \iU;j~h (HHf)+t lll4ft ,)4~H Ul\
.'u
t
,
"..,
,
,
q
I
.'
it
,
i'il;I'.
_.,.,-."_...__......,..."..,~.___ t~ ...._
nil
,"
~Il
.
j/l_l'
CLfl11FICA1l0N or 11M
AND DISCltAfHlL
! OlN
I
"""'lId. t:. UAUtJlunAn
lL I "Ill (;,,1' 1l.1.
."..,11.1.., ,." 11011
In<llrll(,l ('rlmln.1 ('oM.....'1
(Vlol.U.." ..t proltK't1on frOlI
9~-l10 civil Torm
l_~.'__~_.__
Abo.. uretor)
j" I.""
,II'
f ~I.II "I ,..' I\;tol
. iii: H. ,L ,"~ ." c.
.! .!,1'-_,
., u._..'_J.PQ!!"Q.q~ ..
... -." \. (;;'lltlf;(~G'lt~-~--~-' -'-,~.
: '.",1,1 ,t lh, "!'.I" .1"111' 1.,." ,I\ipl "!l'l~ .11 (11ljll t/rlttll.tlIIUlI9d I
--,~-,-~._....~,..~
;,; .,1, ''-'
J
'.~. I.. "_ .1.
cIIU, I 1>......I..n d.r.n...1 until h.n.lwrHlnll
o"..ly.l. moy bl condllctlOll by thl '.....".rlv.nl.
HI..II Polt".,
1U
,& 1\1'IF~'I".ll\.'t'l,IH
; l.m...!
it'lltH'Yl i',',lyJi.-tIHllIlI ,"Hltlftlill'Ali;f)f'I>I1f,l'll,.rtl,J
h1 d;H lHdl,,;:!..',!
; I (}I' t*',riil!A '''H ,.",I"fil'ilr.'I'y
,..!th."i41d,'H..lt.II'III,lJllfl.hdlYI
"0
--Y1Vl!!!. !'~~'l'
. ~.I~ .. .!. i, II .
101
"
",
I ,I,.
"
,'1\., 1'.".</'
tlooo.oo
. H,"..",. '-I, ...'.1\ 1..111 ...';1,(. ",+k. ",l!,,:1 ;';iJ'hlo ...lh~1
...,.i'lLl,j'lh!,.m i"..;;i.' I' .j"t'lll"j
I" ,',
'-"
. H,'Lh,j..t -11' "jLp, Ill';" . 11'1,; v<,ll h' 11',I(I"llfljflljlll~ "Ill"
.'; .1-1)" 1'~j\'''';!'1i I.hlf 'j. I V,'!ll~" ,tail f. f1 (" 'O'f..lt"11
.... -" "'-"',,",' .--.."..---.-,...-..,,."".""......-.
APPEARANCII OR BAIL BONO
. UI.,.lJ\ ."..1\,111.....11,'1,1\(1\ il"lllll(.-L)illl ,
__'''~''"'___.'r''r_''''.,_ ..__~,.. .__, __ ..._.__....._.'-"_"............_. .............__~____._...
!Ji:,;l HAill1 1111 M~[;,l 'l"'''''Ui'' j lttltAr.' 1 HI_I'" LV,.,mn 11 I.
.
q i4;~1 U' ti" ,-Illi'Hl" I 'dJ~t IUAtfl<<l AttO~t ,u.un I,
I
/
_._~ ~.j.,,,, -~Jl!!l'---..:..,.. .. 9~
, ~', 1/'
..,r<'tl; f',,'.;i'''i'll.'~.tj__l'i<l.If,litl~..ltJlltllil(-.,lUlt
IIUfl, Haruld I, Ih.."
HI15 10ljU II YALID fOil IHI INTI". ""OCUDINOI ANU
UN'" 'Ull AND fiNAL DI.,OlIIlOH OF fHI CAlIINClUD,NO
IlljAI "1"OlmON OF ANY PeIlIlON FOil Willi 0' CIIlIIOIIAIlI
UIl A"'Al IIMlL' '1110 IN 1"1 IUI'lIlli11 COUIlI OF '''I
U""" ~IAtU
,~"b
~',.\!h..... .f\,,",_Y~l'{.\..-H__ ,.. ,'.1 /",
'I. "".. ,,4-"'. ppty. rCO uCJnotary
"~"m' _~.*_._.__"..______...__. .,...- ._~__~.,.,_,-_..__'k '. _---..r . .' . _....._...__......___
wt IHt UNUUtl'ONIO ..t,Ad.... tnd .vrol" II'" .1IIi........., h.., ."d ",'u"" ... j<Il/lllW .IId .._.U, """" I. p" t. .h.
r..''''nl>/l...IIhvl....''.'I,OItIt'...._1I1 un. TlIwI.1! ....................._...ltIOOO.OO, I,
p."
au; RlVERIf !lIOE 'OR ltAll CONDlllONI
CE '''If leA liON 01' COUNTI" INDIMNITY AND PRIMIUM IAPI,I,{'lltJl\< ()',Iy WI'.", hUII;oly III A C"'I"" ..I'",,,
"',,,,, 't,.!, ~'.d
"......._......_,._..............__~..H
~-llltl! ,
'" 1.1. II '11!,~, 11.._ ~".'.,,'III...;otll.. I,o!'~ ...,;ij -p.' Ii..llmiu !.-II"', I'll I."" lilliit' "Ill ~t tt,;4I:.t;I.J.' .,.._.
-''''1'1... ',,'li,t<. '.-1'; ,"' ','1'1'~'1 I'; If 11""'11'''1t'11111!J~ '''to ~.ill"!<n i-,jti1i' ti"rIHo(' ..Jj f,jj, t"""till
hi I" a,to' " ',', 'f'lii ,".;,r! "HIII i~" h4JillI;It',lL It.-l,~ IHI'I--'I,. -\I"I';N '10""''''''..1, '~r',~'II"!\1 tr .~
,.,-,,,,,,..,_-.----. .,-.--.....-.--.-..--
"-:_ '....._.r..,..,..,.. ""'_...-".,__,~..,"",._____-..,..~.."=__~ ____~_._
t.<;...,
.,.....I.,ll
._.....-.-._____.....'..."'-i.. ".'-'..'U.__
._,............lifflf ll~ lttilhtfl HIW~ IhDufhl1Rf not. t4 VIV'"I1W II-ifll1 i].j""'~ t"/.-It'i.l
C'-' ............ . ...~..'....,.. .......~..-:-_'t ,.,........'..d<'_,__..............~,__~,,..,.,,..._,, .,...
~.""~.,_..-.-.~.'----_.....,""'- .....,.'...."'...".."."...,.-.,,. ,.
..._,_..,.....,,......,--,_..~.....,.. ....._.....~..~,.,."..,...."'....":"""'."":,.....""""""'~..._,,..~...-........-._"~'''',.....,'''''''..~,
IHi IlI'lHi ,t,'I,I~ llllflll~I.~. "\.1 IUIJVltfCill", ""J9l:".1 H~ \-oti-J IV'''''''''-' ~1--i'f.l, tlll,,,,,..hij,il:.j ...~ tfl.tllttU \liI....~ 1_,* Hjj't lt~! ltWft ~U l!~ftt.. u.\f \i If,. t''lf!, "I 'I' I,
1",1",'1,,,, I 1;'; Iej'; 1111,..... ,I, 4"'j" it j,I.I~!;.~ I~l '!fAtH ~Il w~ "II' Ihf Il)ft,Ill.V!II,....~ iiH.j, 1'lIw ","d 1~J.iWl.tUi>JoI:-d'~lol'~ ~
.,,,,
11I1.1'"'' tlQNID IN ""l0~
" IIlI A""QVIO AOINI
, ~u IjIJWU /,/1,11 HlA' I Alii UUAU Y Illtl'OH.IIII '0",
'lit "111 A"'''\INI (I' '''I I~I'
'''''Il'.""",.",,,_,...,.-,,,,,,,.~,.......,~,__. .-'--" ,.....>Y"~~,~,"'.,,'...~.. ......... """'"' ,__'.~'*" :><<.>1'.- ."._, ,.,.,
"':.1/""
.n
",4-:':' ~.~:,
~y~-lF'
.--- , ~.
-,',':j.'i"'_""/j ,./ ,,-'I,lt '''''''.i, I.: If,; .7~
!.J. -/>..,.,.. ~ ,,,,-;.,,,_,.,...., J_.. "J""'.' f
;__..'. ,.'."....~; ..hi --Ii J'.
","-"":"""".~......,o_....~~~...........",.,....,,.......,,.'.j #1
'"
" I" J,.~ h'f .1'i1: II -"1.1; .,;,. .. 111"" 4/,,0#'
',' "
f " JI/IIi4 t.
~Hu..
jj,
I"JI 4.","'/ t '_J I . ~ ,
-'-'. I" 1'"1--~..-I -'1;-'"".",-,.,,,J
...~I ",;..1 " ...1 ',....-1 ,~.(........" ~.
,. i k~~ , 1 ~.~'.,.~.
~-'-o!
tll.
.Iwrw
u
I
i .._
.
~. '.' i.~. ,. 'I/rr' -I A -, .. '. t '"
A,
.
.... I f./'
'.
... /:..-" I' ~".
, ,"
.' ,. .~
I.AWRt:NCt: t:, WUKt:K
r.m'MNlIfnAlt
Q!"'8ULANO COUNTY
CARLISLE, "A .lOlI
qO ~ a1'"
~ ,.~
r!ll?lf II It A~ 'SS
,TIIcIM.. I. "IAI~"
U Ch..'R\I' I',
".wvllf. 'A 11'41
DAuQ036 '724'~O" '2'D 01/11'"
OAWHt1iHt~rf8'~II"
.... ..,' . "_"".C'e
II/il! IIUlullul !u~l\ullUllliU,l.',I,~t~\\m !!lI!!m,~I,w,'.",..;.."", ;"..., i'I;U..lu 1.1
,
,'"" -~..,",
...
, i
II
OFFICE OF PROTHONOTARY
caul( T HOUSE
'I'll"",,,. t. llOl\ll,/tulltln
_..._>..,.."_...-,.-....,,.,-""...._~- ~....'''''''''
C,ULlSU, ..,
Jj!n\l4!rr ~~.
I'J!~
I~ thaatnllt It.
'.,.,..."'.''''',_.~''''....,_..,..,.~:.,,--...._~-~-.
HlIlwvUb.. .J'A...llUL..
TO The County of CUI11berland 011
r~~I~7r\~~~:~.~~;~ ".,
I ~_....-~+~_c._.__."_?,
".,<." ,_.. --,.
">',. <'""",-K-ti,-,,
;";~',,~":i-"~ ".,~ "~~"""~'k
-
~~.......
I
.,1 ~, tL
I
" ,.-..----~......."-
",119 ~llAl.1~r~
II<<Y\Jt~~!I11, "'. '<<\IlIt!llll'1I
--
- -.......-."'.---
_. ..--."""'......
-""'-.'" ,."....'-"'-
_..,.,- -...........,...
~-_.-..
"""riff'. t'f!.tf tll' II"K\!lH!
.. ..U '9.,.
f..''',''.,.:~.....,._
--I
~'~..,......,....,
--..""-..
.,.. .,........,., .~
,.....~..._",.....,...,-_." ................... ,-"", -- -- --~-~
-,..?,-~-,,~._, >>,'-~. -
"""'<''''':''"''~ """",..,....,.---....
-,- ~."'..... --.-.-...._-
'~...~.._"'.-,- ",""-".,,C."
"',.A
0.. -".-.",. """,",,~. ,*_.""'__~ ""'-i_ ,_".._
~-"
...~....<...~--,.,~.'.,..l!.,".=-:..:..",.,'
- ''''''.::....~-;-;j,,-~'-~...--'<-- 'f*'..~..,..,....."""~.~-,t.~....."~.,.,.,.....,., _....'_ -.. __ _ __._
AMOUIlT PUI
--'''''-":-.",.,~,."'-"..,,..,,.,.........~.:c., .."'...;;\\..,_'"""~T--."4.-~"_~_.....~...' """'f
.
U JO
-
---
I!....~~.~
,.~ ,
..."_..,,..'.-~~~-"'"P,(cifO
<ii>!'''''''............_~....'''';'H~~"..,.,..,~..o!:>,''ll,.,......"..~,_ ~ <l,._ ,_ .
~...- ,.,......--"'.....
.....--,.".~-'-"'''';-'',.,:~-:...,,-''''._t'
+.
'."r:-'~'''''''' ""'.,,'.'-,.-"".~-_.-'*~-.-..--"'~r..-:"",,~_...""~. ,~
- ~'-"'-'-' ---
-~
~
'''''''-'''''''''''''"!",,,.,,",, --.'",.:".'''''-..,.-;;.'''''"''''7'..,.;.....
'~"".,~~,
.,1-,.~......:<li<',.-...,.;<-_""";....."...,...,~.""'""""""...,.'lI',-'" ;.""
----,..~...."
~ "'.-""-._~:-."".,'_1 'Wc,-"",,,,;:->....~,,,
..-....."'.'<;.'~=...;,~~.,.~.,."''-'+--'~.~.m-"-._.:~_''*'''.;,~,.,,........,... _"'~ ,,___ _ _ ~_..,...,......
,,,,__,,,,~':""';_""M
.-",,,-~,'. '---"~"-~:., .."'....,'....,.t ..;.~--."'..:".,.;p,__..~,~.,.~.';.,__.. _~_....-."'.~ ~_"'_~.. ...._..... .._ ____...
~...........,1lI',-
~. L _....'...""-.;,..."~,..,,.."f~:_.~....,_ <."_."',....~~ ..._.'" ____",._
"........==..
"4" CHfC:. "'UU In '''''hOIm'''' r.OlolWQH 1'1-141 1:011"
.;.;"'.,'.....,;.~~.;;.'~~~f..,]'!-.-~-~.,M-:~"~'!1,~oi'4c.-~'\lit*".:.4--+-~f?+~"..d';.i<~M *_~;~-"'.J
:~
I
,
1'lalnlllT
: IN TIll! ('0\1141 UII mMMUN I'UWWf!
I (,IIMIU~IU.^NU WIIN'I Y,l'liNNliYIN ^1Il1^
I v,.o17(1l'1VII.llikM
! (,'IVll ^,'IIUN .1.^W
llNUIMfl''! (,HI~t1N"', ('ON Il,.WI
I
I
I Mit,^NT: 1'1 UI"M Y l' ^It Vt'M
I
,""\lRA I!, ,,^UUIIM^N,
\"
II 10M"" H. ,,^ll(IJIM^N,
l)q(endanl
OIlUUUJt:.WU1U
1 II "
"NU NOW, Ihl. ,)l...,= ....~ .,r..~'~:<il.J"!'L~....,~,,,.,..,...,~, '",. lIplift ..kin .,t
thv I ),(,ndanlln 1M aIllI".~.",kllWd ~.w, it i,lwff!ty ..... IIlli tlittlr1fd Nt . KuIt lit llIUId
1lJ'lln tho /)i.lrl,1 "\lorN)' o( l'lImlt.rlihd l'(II,\f\l)' III th<<w fM!f. It Ill) ht ..... ~tly dw Mllt(
tlwrqjn aholllll 1101 /I(l,rllllN
/(ul. r'tll1ll1",.l" .i,L,,, diI,.,
!l'r\'I,. IIf \hi. /(lIlt IIj11Jfl thf (,'um~ l'llUIlt) 1~1 ^""""r' 0fYWf It, ~
~r""f,
&tv lilt! ('(Jll,n.
i{iL~rlt-
H~~lnl:all)'. lho d.fenHltllutd lhal M.. l>llvlll:uuld nul be Induded wilhl" tho IlruI~llon From
Abu" Order.. ,h4l1, nola ~r"lh for whom r,Il,f mll)' be llranlN under 2) 111l. C.N.A. t
6108(a)(/I); If., II reblll"".
5. Allho 1\q1l1illll. M.. !,aunl ll. llllulIhmllll (e1;lIl1ell Ihal MI. l>ebrlll>llvl. was her
\Ill..lal,r,ln.law. Ms. l>llvllil1M 1IIIer of MI. OaulIhman'll1rll hUlballd, whu II nol Thoma,
Ilaullhman.
6, An ex..lller.ln.llIw l:lIMOl be l:on.lde.-.d I "r.II.lve,"
WI WRI!FOIU!, for all oflho lbl'Cl1lO1nll NIlt(}II.. lho llefendanl re.~lfull)' ffque,11 \hll
I hlllorablll t'OUI1 '"It'r I nolllulIl)' verdllll (In 1M tWllt of lodlr<<1 criminal 4Iulllempl.
MUl1u.tUUU..ACOlJlrIi\L
7, l>trfJldanllwrtln lnew!'of.". 11lU'llIfarh. I Ihruullh J .. Ihnullh full)' HI fonh
hefl/ln,
.. l'hq 41harlllllnllw AhtIV,'l,'lII'IlVlllld llIAller "trllt,r,d IlWUod an .1I11111t1on lhallho
IMlndlInl wM. . ',llt'r 10 .IMml 1)1Ivi.lhlll w..lhrelllenlllll inlllltuflI.
II, Tilt ('II/11I\",,,we.Uh I'"wllled Ihf t'.II/lI(III)' of 1.IIUfllllllullhman, wlulle.tlned
111M .hf httlif!t'f4 lhf lwtdwritln, lllllh4 1#114/' .......d k. 1\1>>. Olivia WlU lhitl I'l't/w
'J.t'~~'., Uw ('llllllllllllwr..J~ "'_. "''''hlNd \~Il(Il.ef' all(~dl)' wrill'" by I"'~ndam /AI
evld.nee. '1111. Wl\llhe 1101)' evldolWlI "roaenled b)' Ihe Commonwealth wllh rolJard 10 .hllwlnlJ
lhallhe handwrillnlJ on Ihll 1II1II1r wrltllllllll "'h, Unvl. wal Ihal IIf 1>lIfendanl'..
10. At tho tonelullun uf Ihe dllfllnMe caMe. Ihe IIIIOorabl. I lamld H, Shoely IlIdlealed
lhal he eould nol Ilmrl)' revlllw Ihe: lellllrl rrlllellled ill evidllllcll and delerllllnlllf Ihe: III1Ier 10
~h. Uavl. wal wTillet! b)' Ihlllw"ndanl,
II. Tho t'ullllllullwealth. allhill IXlilll, Ilill.d lhallhe)' wuuld lend Ih"lellon and
halldwrltilllJ uemrlarluf Ih.lkfenUanllulhc Slale I'ulke fur a handwrltlnlJ anlll)'.I'11I bo don.,
I %. Oil SCrlel11!lqr I). 191)S. all rrelll11lnary hellrinlJ bvforll UI.lricl JUIIII:e Curreal
relUlhl1J IIllh\! llUlllIl",ldllnl for whidl ()oflllldllnl wal tharlJlld with vlolalilllllM l'rolllcUon
rrum AbuI' Order, Iho l'onmlOnwllallh Ilalrd Ihllllhll)' had re.eclved rolult.uflM abuve.
menliuned lelUllland Ihallhe)' I:ould noll:llIl1:ludll from the II:lUnlJ Ihallh\l handwrlllnllun lho
ll:lIer tul)obrlll>avl. wallhaluflhIlUel,ndanl'l,
I), Thill, Ihll (1r11 and unty lllf'llrlllllllllll Ihal hat twon mlldllllvallubllllulh.
1 Milooanl with rtllIard IIlllw felultluf Illl)' hlllldwrhinllllnalylil ~rfllnned 11)' Iho !i(llIO 1'011",
14, Tho ('UlntllonwlIllhh Will ~rmilllld 114!\I1111IlUllru:V Ill'llw JUliO II. IIW'.lwarlllll fllr
.hl! 1~4!ilhl rU/'flI11III1l1' Illtlalnlllll " haoowrltlnl WllllYlil Ill' l>vtendllnl. Thll hllllllwrlllllllWIYll1
haM lJI'Jllr4'ntl)' twfll ~lIInl'lv"'ll whh lINlII(\lII1I1WIIlllill4'd rv.uhM.
U, n", rUIIlJIW'/IWl1jjlh, .11lWII)'" ill h'4'V1rt oflhe .flll'....UlIlllll'Alt-d I'fJUJ1I, b.lI.t 11111
I\'\4Iw4ukd Ilw Iw",m, l'Illlw hlJir<<1 nillllll;ll \'\ll~mpl "1iII~,
Hi. Ttw "llftIlt14lflwflllh'. tvklfMf, 1.1Il1umntly .1aI14..1I,",1~ hat not prov.n
lIf)'lIll1l. ff1Mwbl. lWubt that 1M handwTilllltl \lfllM 1ft'" addrfllltd \U l~brJ I).vl. WI' lhal
lIt 1M ,>.rfftdant \If \hat Itw Ud,,wl ""I Ihf '-tl" \(Il>chrl I).vl..
17, 1lw ('(t1MWltwMllh I, \IfIIIbl, \II ~lm. flllWard wilh any I\lrthfr fvldtlm:.ln \I.
filvor, 1,,,,,I\Hf.",, 'mlfilllh\lukl M d\ltfd,
WllfkllfUIU".1tw '>C".I ffJll"lfltlly ff\tWIlIt\hat !hIli k)f\\lflbl, (,'uun Ond Ihf
1>C\'m4am fkll Iullt)' tift Itw i_'_ (lr IndI",I "lmlMl (/(I"lfmpl.
M,*,*Ifltll)' 1IIbm1l1fd.
//1
J "
'.. ,,',. ~~/' .""~--
'NUI"l} .',." . IlllllUlrf __.-4.'
^-'1\lIft\ Ntllt \>.,....,
^\1(lfflf)' "'" l>.ffadInt
i'!Z
I,AUIlA It. PAUGHHAN,
Pl.tnt!tt
IN Tille COUMT or COHMON PI-leAl 0'
CUHRlIII,ANIl COUNTY, PINNI'I.VANIA
v,
THOMAS I. BAUQHHAN,
Defendant
V~.OZ70 CIVI~ TIKH
oaDER Or. CQU~T
J'1'1
AND NOW, thl. ~ day of october, 199~, aftar revl.w of 'hi
matter, the Court find. the derlndant 'hL,I.:~~LL.! of b.ln,. In
vl01atlon of thl. Court'e ~rote~tlon from Abu.e order,
Thoma. A, Placay
Senlor AuhUnt.
WilUam DrauQht,
far defendant
By the Court,
!UI.I f
Riro , .e If . . .
_ ('. . 'r...t""_n..H... '4/ A,l'1t ~
Dlltrlot Attorney IJ
t 'II It;'H/"
I.qulra ~ I.', I"i' ,.....,1..4 't~' (I · I .... '"' t'
"(."'"
.'-' ._~-.
LAURA It, PAUG/lMAN I IN 1'/I1!: COUR'r OF COMMON PLItAS OF
I'lalntur I CUMPltRLANO COUNTY, PItNNliYl,VANIA
I
I
V. I
I
I
T/lOHAS B. BAUGHMAN, I
Defendant. I '~-oa70 CIVIL TICRM
~OMH9~~~~Lt~'B ~.~~tp ~V~~ ,TQ .UO~ CA~BI
Thoma. A. Placey, 'Dnlor A..I.tant Dl.trlct Attornev tor
Cumberland County. Pennlylvanl., file. t.he followlnQ r..pon.. to
the Rule To Show Caul. llluld upon the commonwealth on
September ~O, 199~1
1. On October a. l'9~, the Otflce ot the Dl.trlct Attorney
rocelved, via t'K, a copy of the Lob report on the handwrltlnQ
Inaly.h.
a, A copy of thl. raport 1. attached.
). Th. r..ult. lndlclt., pa..d on the eXemplar. lubmltt.d,
that "no conelu.lve opinion wa. reached,"
WHBRIFORE, the Commonwealth requI.e. the Court to .nt.r a
verdict con.l.tent with the evidence,
R..pecttully .ubmltt.d,
/' i:\~\~'i~:~ 01",1.. ..tornoy
V\
tlllOIlU1~ 1111 H 1II'/UI':l
I."'ftl MIt'IHIUI Ii#'
.... "
.... I"''''
PINNIYWAtM ITATI f'0l.101
I..UOftATOtIy OIVIIIOH
HAI"'''UM "MIONAL WOMTOfty
,toO ~ A\'tIIIIt
~. ftA ""0'17"
TEl"~ONI! (111) 1M ,..,
CAli:
VICTIM:
AtOUlIOj
auO,.eoT;
,.\.ACt;
DAte'
'AOU:
DAl&;,
tT'MI'
Q.\
QI
..,
LAI.....c..T: t. '''''011.''>>11-0
"11'Ofn DATI: AuIUtt...M
INCI)'NY NO.1 tHO,,"
INT...IOATIOH Off WIlHlt.
Dill DAVII
Thomu lAUGHMAN
NottI uw.tan TowneIMp, ~ Ctwntt, 'tMI~
MIl; "I "..
NMI MIdlI..R Ttwll"" ,4Illlit D~ OWl" "";"~
June II. ,...
~ro~~,~", " Olb OM, ~ HaI.fllllllt ,,., .... war 00. ,....
Ont It).... "VOVI """...... 11\',. '.."... ,,, " I, ..... 1tIw. ,....
~. ~ .....lItflt .. ThomM ~
0l'It l'l tto1A "'""' dItId ...'..
OM II JoO W9Ill 0... ..... ,Oo'H.
"" I).... of NcI ~.-ow ,..,
a~i
u,tii N/rtMtll ., an lIflItrllt ""'""'*""" .. III.... IlILJIJII it,....
'-:lIulIIu ..,.1lOltd _MIl tw 1).' I/llI Q.1.lINlIlIn "'.., ItIUllrllllf. ~....,'
='" '" fill P*1 of ~ ','1ItItW ......tt, '*' tH VIltltMt fir..... '''1Nn fit
11M ~ lit I........ WlI\ .... ""11I." ..Jlfl1Ij" IIIlII fit .......... ...b.... ...
rllOl\....
,,~ ~, II II",," III ,... ..... ... M "....,trY It __ .l.itUn,l ".,."'....
..., '....~... ,,'II~ If fIt"t _.
OIl,oelTlOH: AU, tuIWmlO MAn.,.. HlMWtTH "'TVINO.
,.
COl"Qr.
(")&.D.O. ~ bIl--
~ ~.I... ''""'
0WtIIwrJl ~
c:HIII " ,..... ... ....1.. ~ 1f11. ..4.. hIIM o.pa.l,lM
Arm ,.,. _ c.t.,
~! 0
... II I
... .. .....
~~ .... .. ,.j
a~ ii g
III
~ k
.., G'; 0
~~ ... ...... ...
.'. llJ- flct
~.. III PI
~r; ..; III .....
.... :II
.. , . ..... 11\
~S ... ..... .. .
u ~ oC
i
0 ! 11\
~~ ... .
t'~ :u 1II
CJ .,j I- ...
. :l~
III i~
III III g, ~g
i~ .0
0
~I
, '
,,,", "'"
LAURA E. BAUaIlKAN, I IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS or
Pla1nt.1tt I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
V, I
I
T/lOHAI E, PAUaIlMAN, I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Defendant I NO. 9~-a'o CIVIL TERM
IN RBI INDIRECT CRIMINAL CONTEMPT
Proceedlnge held before the
/lonorabla /lAROLD E, SllltLY, P.J.
Cumberland County Courthoul', Carllal., P.nnlylvanla
on ThurldAY, Juna I, 199~. commenolnQ at 4100 p...
in Courtroom Numblr On.
APnARANCtll
Tholll" A. I' I.cay, t:lqu 1 re
'.nlor Alalatlnt Dlatrict Attorn.v
'or the ~I.lntlrf
Wllliam g, br~uQht, t:.qulre
AI.l.tant ~ubllc Oerender
ror the Oefendant
(.'*,
,...
I (Wh.r.upon, Co.aonw..lth', Ekhlbit No., 1 , 2
3 w.r. .ar~'~ IQr la.ntlfioatlon.)
J N_. 'LAcev, Oood aft.rnoon, Vour Honor,
4 Thl. 1. 'h. InlUnc1C (lrl.lnal Qont..pt h..rinq for Tho... E.
. ..UQh.An. 00" Vour HonQr h.va . QUpy 01 the Co.aonw..lth'.
. ,.UUon?
1
tile COUNT' Villi I thlnk I hAve It, V," I
I do.
~ "M. tLACCVI With that, wa'r. pr.p.r.d to
HI proo..d, Vour !lonur,
II Tilt COUNt' A~ do I Y~ar.tand, 'Ult oft the
12 QuIt, th.' th. PA.i. f&f 'hi. oharQ' I. frOM 'ar'Qr.ph J or
11 'h. orl,Io.' ord.r whloh ".t., thl' ha i. ord.r.d to
14 r,'ralo frOM hAr",im, th. 'lain'I", ,1.intl1", ral.tiva..
l' or 'h. p.r.on. wl'h WhOM "aintlft I. workinq or r..I"I"Q?
I. A~ you',e .'I~inQ th.. 'h' drawlnQ .adr..,1d to
11 thi. Gen., Ilay Viil.Cf4 th., p.rtlQuaar I.otlon in that
U 'hilt w.. "!Iuulrw 'Ii. IA'ly wHh wMJIi U'II "'alntUt r..ld.d,
I' Thl. WI' ngt wfltt.h t~ 'hI 'lalntlf'l I. th., ,I,ht?
~~ "~. rLArlll ,'w.. not .ddr....d to the
U taltloU".
II fffA: (5U1~"'tl n W/tlt .aot'...." t" 'Il. laeay wI'h
I' ~h~~ ,"_ llv..'
~4 "~. t~Ctll ~~ff.q"
~~
'f"~ ",~j(;lft I ~j~-l( , 1;." U MU It,
I
."",
,....
1 NR. PItAUOlI'r I VOllr Ilonor, w 1 th that
2 und.r.tandlnq. 1 would Ilk. to nota a prallmlnary objeotlon
J to ha'inq thl. h.aring at all on 2) Pa.C.S.A. 6108 whlch
4 d.al. wlth protaotion from abu.. ordar..
D sp.olflcally lt .tata. that the rel1.f that may be
6 9rant.d ln a prot.ction from abu.. ordar i. that tha court
7 may grant any proteotlon order or approve any con.ent
8 agra.ment to brlnq about. c...atlon of abu.. at the
9 Plaintltf or minor chlldr.n. Th. ord.r or Iqr.ement may
10 includ. -- and thIn lt 11.t. .1qht .ub..ction.,
11 sp.cltlcallY .ub.actlon .1x .ay., Prohlbltlnq the
12 Datandant tram havlnq any contact wlth tha Pl41ntlft.
1) lnoludlng, but not limited to, re.tralnlng the D.fendant
14 trom .nterlnq the plae. of employment or bu. In... or .chool
lD of tho Plalntltt And from hara..ln9 the Plalntlff or
16 Plalntiff'. r.latlv.. or mlnor chlldr.n.
17 Thl act It..lf do.. not provide tor the proteotlon
18 of .omeone who 1. A non-r.latlvu who the Plalntltt may b,
19 11vlnq wlth, and for that r.a.on WI would .tat. that thl.
ao do.. not fall under the protaotlon from abu.. aot,
21 TilE COURT I You .Iqht b. rlqht, Nr, Draught,
a2 but rlqht now I'm not pr.pared to maka that dlal.10n, I'll
2) heat thl t..tlmony. thin I'll make. deelllon .'tlr I h..r
24 It,
4!~ HII, ItMA\JCH'fl 'In. elr.
1
t""\
"""
1 HM. PLACEY, tn addltlon, Your Honor, I note
2 we have a etlpulatlon. The .tlpulatlon would be that there
3 are two waya ot qettlnq communlcatlon, wrltt.n
4 communlcation, out or the prl.on.
5 Firat 1. by . contact vl.lt. Th. .econd 1. vla
6 mall whlch Ie recorded -- the .ddre..ee 1. r.corded by the
7 prl.on prlor to .endlnq tho mall out, and it require. a
8 return .ddr.... They do not open the mall,
9 Hr, Dau9hman ha. made a requ..t tram the prllon,
10 ao we would etlpulate that it 1. r.rl.ctlv. of thelr r.cord.
11 lndlcltlnq that h. did 'end mall out on the 20th Ind 26th
12 .ddr....d to a Tammy 81...1n9 .t 167 Old aap ~04d In
13 Carlbl..
14 THE COURT' OkaV, You .ald the 20th Ind 26th
u ot Hay?
16 Hit. (,LACEY' ot Hay, un.
17 HR, URAUOIIT, And, J b.U.v., Your Honor, the
11 'tlpulat1on IllIO inQlull.. the f40t thllt Tho",.. Itlu9haan did
19 not have any QontaQt vl.lt. durlnq thl tlm. that he WI'
20 lncaro.rated In Cumberland Countv Prl.on.
21 H~. l'LACfiY, That'. coruot, Your 1I0nor.
2:1 1'111: COURT' Okay. all .hull,
2) HR. l'LACr.YI w. would c4l1 Oebra a.va. to the
24 .tand, pled",
l~ Whereupon,
4
f""\
'"
1 DEbRA DAVII
2 havlnq been duly .worn, t..titlld a. tOllow.,
J DIRECT EXAMINATION
4 BY "R, 'LACEY'
, Q MI'am, would vou pl.... .tat. your nam. and
6 .p.ll your l..t nama tor the court r.port.r, pl.a..?
7 A D.br. Jo Davle, D-a-v-l-..
B Q hack on H~y 30th of thi. year wh.r. dld you
\I llvl?
10 A 23 North Middleton Road,
11 Q And on the loth did you recelv. .ome .al1 In
12 your mll1bo.?
11 ^ Y.., I did.
14 0 L.t m. .how vou what ha. blln mark.d a.
10 Commonw.alth', ENhibit 1 and ..k you to take . look at that,
16 and you n..a to look at both .1d.., and .e. It you oan
17 id.ntltv that tor u.'
11 A V'"
llt 0 Wh4t. 11 th4t1
10 ^ It'e . llttlr I reoeivld 1n t.he mall on Hay
U 30th.
J~ H.. rLAC&V. That" all the qu.atlon. I have
I} tor thl. wltn.../ Your Honor.
l4 TH~ COUKTl Cro....w....ln.,
l~ CMO~~.eXAHIN^TIOH
~
"""
""'"
1 BY MR. BR"UOIITI
a Q M.. Davi., you're not a blood r'latlv. of
3 Mr.. Laura Bau~hman, ar. you?
4 A No.
~ Q And the l.tter that you r.c.lv.d .. juet .0
6 lt can b. ol.ar .. the .nv.lop. that that oam. ln, that dld
7 not have a r.turn addr... on lt, 1. that corr.ct?
8 A No.
9 Q And lt wa. po.tmark.d from Harri.burQ on May
10 the lOth, 101/&, 11 that r1q.....,1
11 "VII.
12 MR, DRAUGHT I That'. all the qu..Uon. I
13 have.
14 TilE COURTI Let m. .ee that onc., I h.vln't
U ...n it,
16 BY TilE COURTI
17 0 Ar. you familiar wlth the h.ndwrltlnQ on the
II out.ld. of the .nv.lop.?
1\1 "No.
20 Q What mak.. .. WhIt l.ad. you to bell.v. that
21 thl. wa. .tnt by Hr, PauQhman?
22 "",cau.. I t..tlfl.d b.for. and put hl. 1"
2) jail, and I don't have no oth.r .n.ml" out th.r., non..
24 I'. w.II llk.d.
l!l Q You I.vn't kno." tlUtt tl'll. th.n \lUI' frQ" hh'
(,
A"',\
"'"
1 for .ur.' Vou balllv, thlt lt 01.. fro. hlm b.cauI. VOu
a t..tltt.d 1911nl' hlm barora, but VOU Oln't ld.ntlfy who
) .ddr....d the latt.r or Invthlnq on the lott.r?
4 A IUllht.
!'I TUI COURT I OkaV. Vou .IV Ihp down.
6 MM. PLACeV, ~aur. PauQh.an. pl....,
7 Wh,raupon,
. ~URA C. PA\JOIl"AH
g hlvinq ~a.n dulV .worn, t'.titled .. fOllow.,
10 DIMICT IXAHIHATIOH
IllY HM. 'LACey,
IJ 0 K.,.., pi.... 'oil UI who you .r..
1) A Laura C. ',u9h..n.
14 0 And on MIV 10th, 1"1'1, wh.r. did VOU l1v.?
., A J) Horth Middleton reold, Carlll11.
'8 0 With whom dld you 11vll
11 A With Oobfil Otllvl..
1. Q Who II o.~f. Olvl. to you'
1. A ~h." ~y fir.t hUlband'l ,t,'er-ln-llw or .V
ao 'ir.' hYI~.n4'. .,.,.,. ,h.l. mv ....l.t.r.ln.l.v, but
H v.l,. Ukt _"Ufl,
II Q Qft t~ lutR, did YQU ..
jl fU~ ~QM.fl W.it. ~.t'. ,I' .. HI. DAVi. le
14 Y~~f 'ir.' HY.~4~'. 'l8'."
~, 'fH' l!inIlJ~IH "'1 flut;, ".,1"'41'14'. Itl'or.
t
i"""
"'""'
Till COURT I And vour tlrlt hUlband, Sa h. ..
TilE WITNESSI staven Calaman,
TilE COURT I Could you Iplll the hit na.e tor
uIT
TilE WITNESS I C-a-l-a-m-a-n.
THE COURT I Okay,
1
2
:J
4
IS
6
7 BY HR. PLACEYI
8 Q Were you Ihown th_ litter that Olbra Dayl.
\) racdvld1
10 AYe., 1 WI', aha come in my work hv.tarlcll.
11 Q Would you look at what 1. In tront ot you ..
12 Commonw.alth'. Exhlblt 1 and idantlfy that tor u., pl....l
13 It The what?
14 Q Would you ldantlty that tar U', pl....l
15 A Thl. 1. tha letter that .he ahowad m.,
16 Q Wlth the anvelopa?
17 It yu.
Ie Q In your prlor relation.hip wlth Tho.a.
19 UauQhman, had you raallv.a any corra.pondlnOI tro. hl.'
20 AYe..
:n Q Do you 1i."1 .ny that you w.re abl. to brlftQ
za to oourt h.re today?
ZJ A 'i'-I t do.
l4 Q And hQW ald you hava oee..lon to eo.. by It?
Z, A L4o' ye.r hi WI' 1n Perry CountV ,,1.on 40t"9
II
,"'"'
~
1 tl~e lor not paylnq ohlld .upport, and h. n.eded to .. thay
a h.d a r.t.lner over her. At '.ulA Corr.AI'" Ha na.dad
) th... I.tt.r. takan to raula Corraal, .0 I want ov.r and I
4 qot thu,
o lie QAva thl. to ~. In A brown anvelope, and In. Ilia
6
1
.
It
10 h.n~wrltlnq In thAt .-
U
U
11
14
U
16 alwAV' ,pIII. It V-h-'-", ~"t he .I.~ puta a QApltal " In
I' th. when. An4 lu" UII. thl uUtlr l.tUf, It pro".. it In
l' th. oth.r lett.f.
III Q W.. th.r. a"Ythl~ .,.. thA' YQU r'o09nl.,d
JO about tn. l.tt.r1
JI A lh. h4n4wrltl~~ @n th@ .n".l~p'.
n, 'flU; CfJUIlff "~\ij llt"', """1 ygy ..un lIIur I.d tg
I) HI, J4~~M~h~
H 'WI WnHUJ$1 I Hv.,. ~HtJ hh. '(If It y...r 4/14
~~ . ~"I., I ~4' ~rfl~ t~ ~l~ t~f, 1'4 '4Y, 4 ~nt~,
that brown .nv.lopa wa. th... I.U.... I and I took on. 01
thl'" up to ,.ula c~rrl.l, And I ilia 1I.d the othn on.. th.t
wlnt to .. th.y w.nt to -- It WI' to pAV Un...
0 __ron I )\lMp to th.t, do VQU uQol.lnll. tha
A V", I do,
0 .- l.un, Co..onw..lth'. ExhIbit 11
A V", I do.
0 How do vou rauoqnl'l tha vrltlnq1
A for on. thinq, Whan,,,,r vou .pell wh.n, h,
..
1
2
)
4
5
6
7
8
II
10
11
12
1)
14
U
16
17
18
HI
20
21
22
2)
l4
l~
'......
"'"
TilE COURTI 1'11I lorry?
TilE WITNEIIII I wu married to Hr. eauCjJhman
for a lIIonth' month and a half, two month.. 1 CjJot marrl.d
Oatablr 26th of lelt year,
TilE COUItTI Ootober 26th, 1994, and you lived
wlth hlm a year and a half bafore that?
Till!: WITNESS' Ye., 11r.
BY HR. PLACEYI
Q Durlnq that parlod of time -- I'm lorry, Your
Ifonor.
Tlit COURT I 1 jUlt wanted to 9.t that.
BY HR. PLACEYI
Q Durinq that period of tim., have vou rao.lv.d
wrltt.n corri.pondince from Hr. Pauqhman1'
A Yal, from when.vlr hi WI' in prl.on over In
.arry countv. 1 received l.ttar. throuqh the .al1.
a 00 you rlcoqnlae the handwrltlnQ In
Co.monwaalth'. Exhlblt 11'
A y,..
Q Who.. a. lt1'
A Hr, PAuqhman'..
a I'm qolnq to .how you what'. b..n ..rked .e
Co..onw..lth'. ~xhluat 2 and ..k you to ldlntify that for
UI.
A 'fMII 't tit. linn ttHlt To. ..nt .. In that
10
""""
,....
1 brown anvllop. to take to Paula Corraal,
3 0 I. that -. do you racovnll' the handwrltinv
3 In thl. latter?
4 A V."
o 0 Who.a handwrltinv 1. that?
II A It'. Thoma. Baughman'.,
7 MH. PLACIl:V, I b.li.v. that'. a 11 the
o qu..Uon. I have tor thl. wltn..., Your Honor,
II Till!: COURT' cro....Il.mln.,
10 CROSS-I!:XAHINATION
11 BY HR, IIRAUOllT,
13 0 Hr., Baughman, wlth regard to what't b..n
13 marked a. Commonwe.lth'. Exhiblt 3, I b.l1ev. that it'. that
14 Vellow latter in front ot vou, vou .ay vou got trom Hr.
n Daughman at Perry County 1'r1.on. 11010/ 1. it that you
16 rlaognla. that a. Mr. Oaughman'. handwrltlnq?
17 A aeaau.. thl. 1. the on. whan.v.r I w.nt to
11 vl.lt hlm at P.rry rounty, he handed it through thl Qate In
III a brown .nvulop..
20 Q Put you did not ... Tom wrlt. that latt.r, 1,
21 that corract?
n ^ 110. II. told Ille hu wrote It laU.r, and I wu
2) .uppo..d to 'lick it up,
l4 Q And did you indicate that 10 the Pl.t T~ h..
l' wrltten other letter. to youl I, that right?
11
.-...
"""
1
3
)
4
,
.
1
.
II
10
II
11
lJ
14
U
U
11
U
lli
illl
;q
n
in
H
~~
A VII,
(Wh.r.upon, D,'.nd.nt'. Ixhibit Ho.. i, 3,
.nd ) w.r. M.rk.d for id.ntl,lo.tlon.)
IV Mil, IRAUOIITI
o Hr., ..uqhM.n, If I .how you wh.t'. bien
M.rk.d .. D.I.ndl"'" CWhlbl'. I, 3, and ), cln you ,.k. .
look at tho.. thr.. dgQum.nt'l pl....l
A (W'tn..' QompU... I
o Do you r.Qoqnl.. tho.. .. I.tt.r. th.t Tho...
aluQIl.ln wrote to you?
A V'"
o An4 would 'hat hlv, ~..n ,o..el.. .round
D,o'lb,r '114, JAnuAry ".7
A ThlY w.r. ~'w..n 'h. '1.. I 1.,' hl. .nd the
tl.. thl. III .tlft~ h.r..
o .0 would lh.. ~ around th. tl.. fra.. that I
d '.Qu'''I17
A 'lilt.
o AIlII whln Y"u ,pGII. lPout th. I.Un thut.
".n ""fIl6HI u CIf!lijll;@fiWlh'I'n'. bhl"l" I, th. on. 'hat'. In
thl .nv.lo~. 'h.r./ y~y I.ld you p.ll,vla th.t Qould ~
Thom.,'. h'f~wr'tl~~ ~~.y_. wh,n h. wrlt.. the word wh.n h.
UI" . 'IP"" H 4,..r th. WI
A 1M'.. ",. '..'4;;,a,,"'l'
Q WI'l. I'~ )~f' 'f1'w~ ,~ WA4'f.'aAd VhV
u
......
~\
1 you'r. .ayln9 that. It" b.Clu.e of that clpltal It wlth tho
2 W?
J A V.., plu. tho 1", 1 ..an 1 Qot a lltt.r
4 r19ht h.r.. The ..cond lltt.r, tho ona that 1 Qot trom the
& prl.on, and I'm ..
6 Q So by oompar1nQ the two --
7 A By comparlnQ th.m, that'. what I'm .aylnQ'
8 MR. IlRAUOIlTI That'. all 1 hlv" Your Honor,
If TItE COURTI L.t m. ..1 thlt numblr onl a,l1n,
10 BY THE COURT I
11 0 L.ava m. ju.t a.k you. What'. the
12 lnt.rpratatlon of the drawlnq on that, that wa. lnolud.d In
IJ that? What do you det.rmln. th.t to be?
14 A W.ll, It'. .lth.r my .l.t.r" he.d or my
1& ha.d. X don't knoW. I don't know wh.th.r .. X ..an, It'. a
16 f.o., and It" .ick.
17
111
19
20
21 .wplaln my .motlon. wh.n .h. hand.d me thl. l,tt.r. It WI'
22 .1ok. Anybody Ilk. thi., you know, that would, you know..
l) Q You int.rpr.t that a. b.lnq I t.c., .nd you
24 "Y In YDur GplniQn it'. .lck?
4" A ll\ll-!liui. 1 w4ll IIC"UI' to ''It/Uh. It.... UkI
Q It'. . fllc,?
A It'. 1I1ok. Anybody with thl. ..
0 That" how you intarpnt thlU A. ...
It It'. . .. X can't 'Ilplaln lt, X c.ntt
II
.~'-;
I I hid to wAtch ~y ba~. IQaln. I .'In, .y .I.tar, .h. 41dn'I
3 ev.n wlnt to '0 .. V.b dldn't .v.n wlnt to 90 to work, .h.
1 Wi... h.r kid. .van ..w It. I ...n th.y ..
4 0 In oth.r word. It Qau..a vou alar.?
, A It Clul.d I 101 ot plln. I hid to 9.t
6 .vlot.1.! HIIIU.. 0' thA' hn.r, I'I.! HIl. you to Ilnow.
., 'till!: COO"T I Any qu..t hm., Nr. "nu9h\, 'n
. Iddltlon to ~tn.1
If 1411. PUUOUTI No, Your 1I0nor.
10 MM. ~~CCYI If I .ay.
" "JPI"~CT JXAMIHATIOH
Il bY MM. PLAC&VI
11 Q Mf.. .auqh..n, ,. th.r. ~re to 'h. ""., in
14 Co..onw..l'h'. l.hl~'I , Ihln 'u.t 'h. oo.p.r'.on '0
l~ Co~.unw'l\th'. J.htpjt Z th.t l..d. you ,. bell.v. 'hi' 't'.
1ft thl h.ndwf"'~ 0' ThOMa' ".~h..n1
11 A I d@n" un4.r.t.nd.
'M 0 I. tt .~f' thin )u.t ou.p.,'nq1
I~ A VI', ,t'. ,v.ryt"1nQ w.'v. bltn ,o,~
Jll 'hrouqh. nul 'UIW h. ,..nt, .. ".UIl, ii1M ..
I' 0 ,,~,. Oll.y. ~.t.. tu.t ..Il qu.."'"',
II It'. ~r. th4" )w" ~.f.r'.@n fgr you, rl~h"
;n '" U'. i!'ti~f. "14n 11.;1li'- ""/fIJ'.ulI1t1m,
H 0 &8 tr.u" fHI'I'r.lf1l# "l." ~H.UM"V. .~, 'M
4? ~4Y~. ~r".. '"41 ~f'W~. " ,~ y~~r ~,'.""~~1 ~ .~,
It
."",
..-.
1 .p.U , 041"
a A Ya., 'h.r.t. ..ny tl... h. ..k. .. hoW to
1 .p.ll, .nd " 'AV'. "r... It wl11 bl 'low .nd paintull."
4 'alntul h.. only onl L at the Ind, not two.
/)
6
7
.
If
10 Anv turther witn...... Hr. Placey?
11 MM. PLACey, We move tor tha _a.l..1on ot our
1a Iwhlbltl and r.." Your Honor,
13 Tilt COUf(TI Th,vtn lamithd.
14 (Wh.reupon, commonwealth txhlblt Ho., 1 .nd a
la wer. Aamittla into .videncI.)
16 Tilt: CQURTI Mr. ltr.uqht, do.. your oU.nt
17 wllh '0 ,.atltv?
11 MIC, .MtIOItTI V.I, Your /fonor. caU Tholllll
It IAuQhllhlln,
lO Wh.r.upon,
a 1 fIlOM^" 1:. '.WOIlMAN
n hav 1 fill ti."1Il du ly Iworn, t.., it 1.a II to1l0\!lll
aJ 01~t'~ tXAH1NAT10N
U ,... HI'. ..AVCItT,
~'> Q"r.. (114\,\111'1,.....0, I!;t" you ahh your MY 1.1\4
Till: COURT, All rlQht, Anvthln9 .1.11
MR. PLACI:Y I NO, Your Ilonor,
Till: (.'OVRT, AnVthlnq .111. Hr, PrAU\Jht?
HR. .RAUOIITI NO, Your Ilonor.
Tilt: COURT, Thank VOU. You IlIIV .up down.
HI
,"""'
.-
1 'Plll your l..t na.a, pl....,
2 ^ Tho..' I. eluQh_.n. e...u.Q.h.....n.
3 0 And whlre .re you ourrantly ra.ldlnq, Hf,
" Bau9h...n?
, ^ CUMberland County prl.on,
6 0 And h.va you baan hald froM todav" d.te ..
1 wh.n dld vou fir.' arrlva In Cumbarllnd county Prl.on?
. A 'evantaanth of April. It'. b..n flfty.two
I>> d.V' today.
10 0 I want to a.k you '0'" qu..tlona .bout I
11 nu..bar of l.ttar. that w.'va alr.ady talkad .bout. Th.
12 latter that" ln front of you th.t, J belleva, 1. ..rk.d ..
13 COIll.onwa.lth'. Iwhtblt 2, would you t,ke -. I. th.t on a
14 yallow plaoa ot paplr? Would you t.k. . lOOk at that? And
l' barore looklnq It thllt, did vou hav. an opportunlty to
16 ravl.w a copy that 1 .haw.d you of that l.tt.r?
17 A '1'...
It Q Co VOU naall qlvlnq th.t laUn to Laura
19 bluQh...n.t Parry county 'rllon about. v..r .qo or .o?
20 A '1'...
21 0 Dld vou wrlte that letter wlth your own hand?
n ^ '.0.
2) Q 0111 you hey. eO"lbolly .1.. writ. U.at 'Iun?
U A Y...
n Q Iff,!... till' "ttu. that hllva ~.n"'rl("l. UlIlt
1(;.
I
J
J
4
,
.
1
Ii
If
Hi
H
U
II
U
lit
,to
II
111
'"
Hi
H
n
,~""'i",
.,. fo y~~' 'I' riQhf, I' O,"n4An,t. I.hlult. I, " .nd
1 .. It. 'Ofry, your 'If le't .. 'ho.. ihr.. 1.".r., dld
you wri'. tho" 1."'" to LAu,. l.uQh..n?
It V," th'y'" .V hlnawrltlnt.
o ,. 'h.\ vour own hlnawrl'inQ?
It VtII.
o Aft,r y~y w.,. nq"".4 iha' you w.re b.lnq
QhA'Q,d with w,lfln~ I l.'f'f to O'D'. Dliv'e, aid you
,.qUI.t 'rOM cu_o.rllina County "l.on author"'.. a r.oord
0' the 1.,t.,. fh.t you .Allld f,o. Cu...,land County
I'rl.411\1
n
/Ii illl i, I 4111.
(Wh.f.upon, cQaaonv.el'h'. I.hlblt NO. 4 WI'
..rk.a tor '4.n,"'Q.'lon,1
IY MM. 1J(AlJOltTI
Q 4~. if I .how you whit'. ~..n "rk~ I'
CO.M4nv..lth', l.hl~l' 4 .. 1n4 __for. I do lh.t, thl. 1.
tn. a@Qy~.n\ whl~h Hr, 'l.~'y .~. I "0_' In t.r.. of I
.tH,ylUi@H, Hi'" 'h. inf9fH"'''' Q@nUiI'lM 01\ U.. DonO. 11'1
t.r.. ., tn. ,.tt.fi '.1'1\ ~y Mf. '4~h..l'I, tn.t th.f. .re
tW9, (1M fin Iky I~'I'I ilfl<t @iMP ~Il H., lUh of lffU to Ta..v
'l..'l~ it iI~~f4" lftt~f~iI't~1'I ill 'iI' ., tn_ r.nord .t the
C~.~Mfi.fl<' C~~I'I'Y f".~n,
UIi/'II, I ~~ yw wM". ~." ......11.4 .. o.r....Dt'.
l~Mt;i',f, 'If 1M' ,,,.. f~~.' U.,U 'f'iil,# "I'\t ,@ iM
H
~~,
p
.....
,-.,
1 cumberllnd County Prllon luthorltl..?
a AYe.,
l Q The upper portion of that, below the 11n., b.
4 .peolflo In eHplalnlnq requa.t, Th. handwrltlnQ thlt 1.
~ below that, le that your own handwrltlnv?
6 A Y'.,
7 Q And tha alqnature that 1. below that
. handwritlnq, 1. that your own .lqnltur.7
II AYe..
10 0 1'~ now qol09 to aek you to refer to what'a
11 baan mlrked II commonwe.lth'. EHhlblt 1, whlch la the lett.r
13 and env.lope ln front of you. Iflve vou hid In opportunltv
lJ to look It thOle documenta'
14 II No, I haven't,
15
16 now?
17
18
19 now?
ao
21
u
U
24
2'
o
Do you want to take I look It tho.e rlvht
"
o
Ve..
nAve Vau hid In opportunity to look It the..
v...
A
Q
Oid you write Or add..... .. did you write
thlt lener or /tddr... that envelop. to Debra Dlvl.?
^ No, I didn't.
0 Old you ..k anyone on your bohllf to wl;'lh
thlt lettlr or addr... th.t env4Hop4il to O.bn Olvl.?
II
1
a
,
4
6
6
7
^
.
!tV HR. PLACJ:Y,
o
"
o
0
^
0
A
Q
pr.v.nht' YOY
'rhon1
^
""'\
r~
NO.
HR. U~UOHT' Th.~f. III I have.
THI COURT, Cro.......ln..
eMOII.eXAMINATION
How do you .p.ll Tho...l
T.h.o........
Who wrota the 1."., lor yow ln '.frv c~n'v
llj
.~
-
1 0 You wlr' .tll1 able to wrlt. what your
3 ooun..l h.. exhlbltld a. on., two, and thr.. whl1. you w.r.
) ln '.rrv County Prllon?
4 A I don't r.mlmb.r whln thl dat.. w.rl or, you
, know, wh.n -. you know, all I know lt wa. .. I had .avb.
6 four w.lk. to 90 whlnever I broke my fln91r, .o..thlnv l1k.
7 that. I don't know wh.n .xactly I wrote th...,
. HR. PLACEY, That'. all the qu..tlon. I hav.,
, Your Ifonor,
10 THE COURT, I'm not .ure whit the jail
11 .xhlblt .how.. Po.. thlt .how that h. r.qu..t'd p.r.l..1on
13 to mall l.tt.r. on tho.. two dat..?
U Hit. "LACEY' No, Your /tonor, 1 t .how. that
14 two l.ttlr. w.r. mall'd out of the prl.on by hl., and what
l' the prl.on polley 1. 1. you havI to hlv. lt 90 throuvh thl.,
10 .nlt what th.y 101111 110 1. wrlt. down the nllll. of the pinon
11 YOY'r. ..ndln~ It to and that plreon" addr....
11 1'111: CQUkT, Okay. And what 101.. the nue of
It the Plr.on h. lIIal1ed the.. two lltt.r. to?
30 MR, VLACEY, Tammy Dle..lnv.
U Hie. IIMAUOIlT, At 161 Old alp Moad, carU.l.,
a3 YoUr Honor.
U Tilt: CQ\JkTI 110 thuI" nothlM froa the jll1
Z4 to ln41cate that he "ll~ a l.tt.r to Oebr. Oavl., 1. that
~~, rtll"'?
J(l
,""'"
^
1 HR. PLACE'll Th.t'. ccrrlo'. If I NY follow
a up on Your Ilonor'. qll..tlon. thera.
3 BY HR. PLACEY'
. 0 .ir. would you tell UI who T.may 111..1", 1.1
!) A. !t'. lilY .1Iter.
6 0 8h. WI' the ona who w.. ln the ll.t \1.. who
" ta.t1tled on your behdt1
8 10 RilJht.
{I TilE COUNT I Any oth.r qu..Uon. ot ter.
10 BlIuCJhman7
11 HR. PLACE'll Not frolll the COIll.onw,.lth.
12 HR. DRAUQIITI Non., Your Honor.
13 Till: COURT I 'loll .'V .t.p down.
U HR. IlAAUQIITI W. h,v. no ath., ",U!IOny,
l' Your 1I0nor. W. would 'u.t uk for tha ,d.l..hm lnto
16 evldanc. at D,r.nd.nt'. e.hlblt. 1 throu9h ..
17 MM. fLAelYI No ob'eotion.
18 (Whereupon, O,t.nd.nt'. 'Mhl~lt Ho.. 1. " '.
19 IInd 4 were adllltt,a lnto IVlll,nq'.1
20 Tltt: CQUIeTI If the '1111 h.... no uQorlt or hi.
21 malllnq I t.tter out oth.r than tu thl. ~1...1~ wo..n, h~
22 am 1 .uppo..d to lind that h, 1II111.d tnl. gyt \Q M.. 04vl,1
2J M/C. "i.Act'O 1'111 111I11. 1. nl.it Hlil' "'. ...U4f4
~4 1 tout, What the CO#llWh.....lIlth .uLnutt tQ U'4il ~O!lC" i. M
2' ..nt It. knowll\lj thAt the p,h')II I!Iilmhpu th. Nil h"'"
it
1 to hi. .1.t.r, to have hl. .1.t.r d.llv.r It elth" via .al1
J or via plr.onAl ..rvlo..
1 Till COUftTl Dld th.y chlak th.ir reoord. to
4 ... AnyplaQa durln9 that plrlod ot tlm. whathlr or not A
. l.tt.r wa. .al1.d out to a Dlbra Davl.?
. MR. rl~CEVI V", thlY dld do thAt.
1 Till COURT, w.. any mal1ld to har?
. "R. VLACEVl No, not from Thomal Oaugh.an,
, l.t.. '.V that to vou.
Hi Tltl: COURTl Couldn't th.V ju.t chick AU
11 th.lr ..1110Q' from that p.riod ot tim. Ind ..1 whether or
1~ not .nvon. from thl 'All mlll.d a Iltt.r to M.. DAVi.?
11 HR, ~~ACtYl 1 did not I.k thlt .p.oltlo
14 r.quI.t or tha.. Th.y po..lbly could do that,
.~ Till CQURTl I don't think th.re could b. that
,_ .any I.tter. ..11.d out '.Y In . p.rl0d of tour or flv.
11 day.. ThlY pouia ~'rt.lnlv chick Ind II' whlth.r or not
.. Anyon. .All~' . lltt.r to ..
.~ MR. ~LAC~YI Whln 1 ,p1oltloal1y ..k.d the
iU prl.on about lhAt .-
11 TII~ COURT' About hiM1
II MR. ~L^ctYl About hiM, th.y lndlo.t~ th,t
I. tn.y w~~14 f.qYir(il 4nybQ4y ~11'~1 " I_tt.r OY\ to nAY. A
H nt\ff~ !J!J4f(il.IJ \In It, 400 tM. (in. 4p.. !'lOt, If Y9~ look "n
t~ HI. (I"'1.I~f'.( It II,i4f{f (i(..t ti"V. " ,.tu,n addu...
n
,"'""
"..,....
1 TIlE COURTI 80 that would lndloate th.n lt
2 wa.n't mal1ed from the j.l11
J MR, I'l.ACEVI Cornet. And alia the evld.nca
4 1. that the po.tmark h trom lIarr hburq and not from
II earlhle,
6 TilE COURTI 80 how do VOU .. U h. wrote lt,
7 hoW dld it Qet tram hi. per.on out at the j.l1 wlthout
B .omabody maklnq a record ot it?
9 MR. Pl.ACEVI II. ..nt lt to hle .1.tar In an
10 .nvalopa, Ind hl. ai.t.r mall.d it tor hlm. Th.y do not
11 ch.ck the mall at the prhon .. to whilt'a lnaidl, only the
12 name at the p.r.on It'. b.lnq ..nt too and thay r.cord that
1) a. r.fl.ct.d in D,fane. Ekhiblt 4,
14 Tilt: COURT I 110 that'. on. po..lblUtv a. to
111 how lt could hlv, b.,n don..
16 HR. PLACEV, V,..
17 1'1It: COllRTI It could haVe b..n ln I letter
11 mll1ad to Ill. .i.t.r.
10 Hfe, Pl.ACEVI Or lt oould have b..n In I
20 oontlot vialt, but thar. were no oontAct vi.lt., and that
21 would be an iillQAl mlnn'r/ and th.v are not .uppo..d to 90
;U throuQh A conhct vi.it b.C4U.. th.V wouldn't b. abl' to
n r.ql.ter,
H TilE CO\JICTI "ut poult/ly, and WI don/t knoli
a~ whlth.r lo_.one .. Will, obviou.ly it cQuldn't hlv. ~.n
u
,""
1 ..11ed out ot the prl.on beo.U" 't w.. "..pea ".rr"burv,
a MM., 'LACEY I ThU'. (lontQ', Yoyr Honor,
1 Tile COURT I w.ll, Any'hlnq .1"1 Mr. PIIO.Y'
4 MM.. 'LACn 1 In UflllI or ArQulll.nt, Your
a Honor, I would At~U' to th. court th.t 1n f.vl.wlnQ
6 co..onw..lth" IMhl~t' 1 And a you o.n .a. . d,.tlng,
7 a'.ll.tlty b.tw_en the wrltlnq .'yl,. And the ,p.lllnq
. "Vle., ana ,plpitluAllY the 1.".r. E -- Ao'u.lly .or. A
~ .n~ ~ -- when II" cAr.fullV print.a. A' .r. both ot tho..
10 l.t'tr., A' ~Pl~..a to the deten.e ,.hibi' Ie".,. ot 1
11 thfou,h 4.
1;1 TIU: "OUJilTI 1 9u,', . .i.ur.in.lAw WO\l14 "
II . ral.tive. I don" know how W.bl'.r d.tine. A felatlv.,
14 And 'h. Agt 40.. cover (.l.'lv"1 r19ht'
ill Mil. I'LACl't1 I thlnk hOM the ..oUon you
U 1'..41..
11 MM. IlkAlJOlfTI n.. .peQUh'ltUV, Your Honor,
'i II "Y' 'rOM h,r...lnq tn_ I'l.lnttft @f Pl.lntirrt.
1_ r.I.'lv.., hOW.Vlf, If I UQuld .44,.,. tn.' for. .o..ni.
ltl J till"" 'h. un "'1(lftV i. thU .n. II An
11 ....I.l.r.ln.'4~,.~ I aQn'l knqw 'h.' ....1.t.r.ln.'.w
II q~.I'ftl'.'. r~I."v. ..~.qI4IiV _hln 'l'. nq\ . _1004
lJ f.14tlvl, ~4Y~ If .~. V4. 4 .. ~'r\4Inly 1"','.ln-'lw,
It '~4t Vv~'~ ~ 4 q....,lnt ~"'f, ~, t~'. .~
l~ ....i.'.f.*~.l~.,
H
-""',
--',
1
And if 1 could addre.. .oma of the handwrlUnQ
Z that Mr. ,l.cuy brou~ht out. What'. lntera.tln9 -. and Hr,
J Placay a.ked thl. question -- If you wlrl to look at
4 Commonwlalth'. Ewhlblt No. a, whleh 1. the Plrry County --
!)
TilE COUltTI I hop. you plopl. aren't uklnv
6 m. to do . h.ndwrltln9 oomparl.on, I'm not golng to do
7 that. That'. not mv job to eomparl handwrltlng and .ae
a whither or not .omethlnq wa. Ilk. .omlone .1..'. or not,
II
HIl, IlIlAUOIITI Without you aVln comparlnq the
10 handwrlUnlJ, Your lIonor, looklnq at that, the top Un. of
11 that eWhlblt, Thorn.. i. .pIllad T-o-m-o-. without an H.
12 It'. .pullea Incorrectly, and WI would .u9qe.t to
1)
14
1!ro
1& l.tter,
17 The only evld.nee pre.ented bV the Commonwealth
18 that Hr. OAuqhman wrote thl letter that we're harl for today
19 Wa. In gre.t part Hr.. OauQhmln .aylnq look At the.. two
ao letten, 1 know hili hlUldwrlUnQ, .nd thl. WAI hl.
~1 handwrltlnQ, ond thAt WI. the ..m. h.ndwrltlnq,
n WeU, it the,,'. 1"11I1 doubt that he wrota thl.
2} lettlr that'. Commonw..lth'. exhibit No. a, her oplnlon 1.
24 b...a upon lncorrect Inrorm~tlQn.
tha Court th"t Hr. UlulJt\man know. how to .plll hl. own Urn
naml, and thl fact that It 1. 1lI1upenea 1. certalnly
lndlcatlvl of the tAct that .omeone 11.1 prObAbly wrotl th1e
2'>
TilE COUR'fl ohy. .. YQ\,lf orOcl w1111"9 to
'Ii\:
. ~
--.,
/....'.
1 .p.nd the mon.y to hav. a handwritlnQ 'MP.rt oom. in h.r. to
2 t..tify ln thi. .atter it I'm wl11lnq to d.t.r my rUllnQ1
3 Hit, !'LACEY I Your lIonor, the Commonwaal th hll
4 packaQld thl. flrut letter In a manner ao that it can b.
Ii ..nt to thl oute l'ollcI Lab tor analv.l., not only on
6 tlnQlrprlnte but aleo ..
7 TilE COllRTI You hav. thr.. l.ttu. that he
8 admlt. wrltlnQ7
II HI', "LACEY I Correct.
10 TilE COURT I And you have the ....pl. h.n
11 whloh he d.nle. wrltlnQ. .ae.. to "' thlt the .a.l..t way
12 to have thl. datarmln.d would be to ..nd lt ovar to the
13 Stat. Pol lei for handwrltlnq 'Mpertl to look at th.. and
14 than wa would hold another hearlnq and I'll ba.. my d.al.ion
l' on that opinion. I think that would b, the ...1..t way.
16 Whit I'm going to do, I'll ju.t do an ord.t today
17 contlnulnq the hnrllllJ, And 1'11 ..t baU on thl. ohuq.,
18 and that wl11 b. It.
19 MR. I'IACEYI 1'h. only othtr thinq the .tAte
20 roUe. lnd lC4tell th.y 1Il1Qht nlld fro.. ... bee.u.. of \h. WIY
U thay do U'I In.lyel., thay IIlAY nUl. a handwrltlnq ...pl.
22 that le not. copy tur th'lr purpo... beeauI. ..
23 'l'I1I: COUIeT. II.'. ln j_U now on .,ultt;.er
24 chlr"" or .o~.thlnq, I. th4t rlqht1 Are you In )4111 ~t
25 tha. co., over 4rn1 qlt . 'A~vle of hll h4~rlt'~.
Iii
""'
.-~
1
"
,
4
t
.
7
.
Q
MIt. PLAcr:V,
Court there .av b. I dallV
to t.h.".
I would jUlt lndlclt. to the
In t.rm. of hl. 91ttlnQ lt down
TIIII: COUltTI All rlCJht, W.' 11 do thh ord.r,
(Wharaupon, an ord.r of court wa. .ntar.d.)
HR, DItAUQIITl Your lIonor, 1II1Y 1 addre.. the
bill I.,ye In t.rma of whit Mr. PluQhman'. curr.nt .tltU'
".,
Tltl COURTl I hlv. no 14.. wh.t hl. .tat.Ua
HI I..
11 MM. IlftAUQIITI Around May 'Oth or .0 h.
13 Unl.h,d Ijp thl ..nt.noa that VQur Ilonor hid l,11van hl. for
1) thl tr.,pa.lln9 ohlrql, ....nti.llV tha fortV-flva dav
14 ..nt.no.. Ita 1. now In ,.11 on two mItt.,., lnltl.llV on
It thl, .att.r, whioh Your 1I0nor dlraot.d, and thin al.o h'
,. w.... oh.rq.. w.rl tl11d In the form of a orl_lnal
11 oOllplalnt for ~rl..1nal tUIJI"" for the lno141nt tor Whlch
t. h. had .'r'lav bo.n found In cont.mpt of court bV thi. court
1~ tor ~Inq Qn tho ~rop'rtv .t Pobr. OAvl. Ind Laur.
IU '.uqh..n'. hou'l,
11 '.il on thAt 114tt.r II '1,UUO.00. A prall"lnary
ill ~.lUl""', w... hol4 ynhntitY on \tIlt Ihuth:ulu uhllKlll, 10 It
il thl. ~olnt ~.'. b.ln~ hold on th4t '1,000,00 ~11 and
i+ wh4t.v.r YOYf Uqn~r wQula do with f~4,d t~ th'l,
i' flit: "(lt1l1'f~ "" III"," ,,,,,, {'f. Uta. to
I 1
"
A"'>e..
1 $5,000,00.
2 HR. BRAUOIITl MV conoern, Your 1I0nor, 1. I'm
J not lur. how lon9 thi. 1. 901n9 to taka the Dlltrict
4 Attorney to hav. proa....d, wh.ther it 1. two dlV' or two
5 week. or two month.,
6 THE COURTl I lmaqine, Hr, Brlu9ht, thaV're
7 not the fa.t.lt ov.r th.r.. Can he make the $1,000.00 bail?
8 All rlqht. I'll lower ball on thle charge to 01,000.00.
1>> HRS. PAUOIlHAN I lIave vou qot a ..ta plac. to
10 put mil
11 TilE COURT I 1'11I not the one who marrild Illm,
12 vou marri.d hlml and I'm not .ure in my own mlnd whath.r
IJ thle 11 hl1 wrltlnq or 1.n't, '0 .. the onlV thlnq loan
14 .av, vo~ t.ll hlm that lt h. q.te out on ball, thar. batt.r
15 not ba anv rapaat. or h.'ll be back I'm lure.
16 HR. UAAUOIITl V.., .ir.
11 "ltl!: COUItTI So that'. the waV we're v01n9 to
1. handle it. Stand adjourned, I'm Qolnq to Itat. for the
19 rlcord that III .~hlbLt. ort.red ln thl. trl11 are now belnt
20 r.turned to the Dl.trlct Attornev" orrlca.
21 HI(, llRAUOIlTI V.., elr.
U (Whlllt'.upon, the above proc..dinq. con01UdN,)
2)
H
,,~
211
~"'"
""""""
'QIIrl/:'nIQ,lf
I h.r.by Q,ril,v 'h.i 'h. proo..4l"4' .r.
oont.lned fully .nd ,oour".ly in 'h. noi.1 "_.n _y .. on the
abov. OIU.. .nd thli thl. 11 . oorr..' ',an.orl" ., th. .....
;&~,!fij ~r:!'!~Lirl,', <'
u . '
Ol,10l.1 ~.wr""f"r
.......................-........
Th. lor-,Qlft9 ,equrd ., 'h. 'f~.1t1'"4' en th.
h..rl"4 ., 'h. wlthln ..,.., il h.,.~V "'f.V~ .n4 4'f'U'~ ,.
N ,Ued.
. 1 ., \
,
. ,
.
~~ ~.
~hi:~4.lV!~~;-'
;'i~ ' .
kH f~_.
; ,
1_ ~,l_ 1, tl. ~~
./.,.
LAURA I. BAUOHMAN, I IN THK COURT or COMMON PLIAS or
,la1ntUf I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
V, I
I 91-270 CIVIL TERM
I
THOMAS I. BAUGHMAN, I
D.fendlnt . CHARGE. INDIRECT CRIMINAL CONTEMPT
ORDER or CQUI\'J'
I ';,-{--
AND NOW, thh \- day ot Jun., uu, thh Court c.rtlU..
thlt the Itt.ch.d complalnt hi' be.n prop.rly compl.ted Ind
veritl.d, and th.re i. probable CIU.. tor the i..uanc. ot
proc.... In con.id.rltlon of tho att.ched Commonw.alth'.
P.tltlon, I WARRANT II IIIUID rOR THK ARRIIT ot the O.t.nd.nt,
THOMAS I, BAUCHMAN.
Thl. wlrrant 1. to b. lodO.d with the Cumb.rllnd County
prl.on to d.taln tho d.f.nd.nt from r.l.... prlor to d.t.ndlnt'.
app.ar.nce b.tor. the Court on thi. chi roe of indlrect crlmln.l
contempt.
D.f.ndlnt ha. . rloht to b. r.pr...nt.d by In attorn.y, If
the d.t.nd.nt cannot attord .n attorn.y, upon r.qu..t on. will b.
...10n.d to r.pr...nt the d.f.ndlnt. Th. ......m.nt ot COltl to
b. d.t.rmined by the Trlal JUdO. .ubl.qulnt to trial.
ay thl Court,
t r\'l <1/ ,
P,J,
Tho"l A. 'llolY
..nlor AI.l.tlnt Di.trlct Attorn.y
THOMA' I. 'AUO~
I,AURA B I BAUGHMAN, I IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS or
Pla1ntlU I CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
V, I
I "-270 CIVIL TERM
I
THOMAI I, BAUGHMAN, I
D.tandant I CHARGBI INDIRECT CRIMINAL CONTBMPT
COMMO~W~ALTij'l ~ITJTION tOR A T~IAL ON C~~Q'.
Qr tNDIRECT CRIMINAL CONTEMPT
Thomaa A, 'lac.y, ..nlor AIIlltant olltrlct Attorney of
Cumb.rland County, ,.nn.ylvani. bring. the following ,.titlon for
a h.arlnv on charg.. of Indlr.ct Crimlnal Contempt I
I, A prot.ctlon trom Abu.e Ordar wa. i..ued by the Court,
A true and corract copy Qf the Ord.r i. attached,
2, Th. d.f.nd.nt'. violation of thl. Order 1. averred ln
the attach.d copy ot the wrltt.n communication, identltled by the
pl.intlfr a. the handwritlng ot the d.tendant.
], Thl victlm raque.t. the tiling of an Indirect Criminal
Contampt charg. upon lntormatlon r.c.iv.d.
.. Th. Di.trlct Attorn,y'l Ottice approve. the ti11no ot
thl. privat. crlmlnal complalnt.
" Th. Commonwealth 11 requ.ltlng a trill on the charv..
of tndlr.ct Criminal Contempt pur.uant to 2] Pa.C,I.A, 16113,
6, Th. d.fandant communication with plalntitf and
plalntltt'l ral.tlv. 11 a vlo1atlon or paragraphl on. (I) and two
(2) of the Court'. prot.ctlv. Order.
7. The d.t.ndant 11 currently ln Cumb'rland County pr1.on
on I pr.viouI violation of the Court Ord.r, how.v.r, d.tendant"
r.l.... data 1. Monday, June " 199'. A copy of the Order i.
at.tochld,
,.
'.. ....
. ,I ., _to,,,,,., .............. ._..............".......h.
".
-
: .~) ou'LL Nc.:...e..D L~I(.~~ '11"'\ 'GHa.
", -: I3A~k 0" ?tc.J~ HLAcl, rD ~(.d.
-~.... ~Hef"\ J: A'1'.tAc! I< I l.V~It",., aD",", I
L(.~S"" a.~()~~T' iT; ~~P~T ,r
I
I
I
,
\
\
f
,
\
\
, )
l
J ~ . :,'~~~~,..
, ~,t. ~ ".... ..~.. _. ... ,............- \
.'_-...:...._.._r. \
J?S. T (,..J:LL ~, S~~< PAin J:l.JL~ ~ ,I /
........,.lI'f'..,,,,,.. .-,., I
"". . '..............,~".h. ................. /
",-.,.. r
(
I
I
.
J
,
I,AURA k. DAUOIl"AN,
Plaintiff
v.
I IN 'I'lff:; COllin ot' COMMON I'Lf:Ml ot'
I CIIMllt;JU.AlIO COVN'rv. l'tNNSV LVIIN IA
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I NO. 9~.l7U CIVIL TtRH
I
I 1'1l01'11:("TION rltOM ADIIIlt:
TIlO"A' e:. DAVOIlMAN,
O.fendant
AND NOW, thAi
JlROl'U('Tlvn oru>m~
~l J( f dAY ot J4nUAfY. t99!j, upon
~~,
con.id.ut1on of the con.ent Allreelllllnt or the partl.., the
tOllowlnQ order la enterodl
1. O.t.ndAnt TIlOMMI t:. DAUOIlMAH 10 onJeUd to retrlAln from
Ibu.ln", Plaintiff (.AUNA f. "AVOIlMAN or plaolng her ln fur of
abu.. or thra.tenln", hlr,
a. D.fendlnt i. ordered to reftAln from hlra"lng
'Ialntlt" ~l.lntlff" relAtiv.. or the p.r.on_ with whom
(1lalntHt h working or rnhUng, Inolu<Unq (Huettn",
oo..unioaUone, both oral IInd wraten, to hlllr.
J. O.'endlnt 1. .njoined from IInterin", 1'1.lntltt'l plloe or
..ploy..ot at W'lt.rn ailll1n It.lk Houla, 120' Harrl.buro ,lk.,
".-rU'I., CUllbnhnd County, ('enneyll/Anb POl),
.. Oerendant 1, ordered tl etay IWAV from the r..ldenc. or
,lalntUt lilt U North Hh'l1l"tc;ln !Co"il, Carll.l., CUllbullM
County. l'.nn'VlvAnl" nail, IUIIt from .ny ruld.nclit whloh
,...lntift IIIAy utablbh ((If hn."u in th", futur..
I. fh" Qrd.r IIttHtU u/II4ln III .ff.at flU /I p4/rlQd of on.
VillAr.
t. Ttu. ~~)fth "i",U.t911 Tvlt'lI"hil/ hili,;. O"I"trtlllIJrlt 41'l.d tn.
..~44I.ufl T(iW(Hoh$f. "'Hh''* Ij4#~I'.rt"...j( Iti II ..l\!h t... .,rovld.,' wHiI ..
copy of thll Order by coun"ul lor I'lillnllll i\lld m'lY unforce thla
Ordor by arrllst for lndlnwt crlmlnill eontuOlpt without wilrrant
upon probable cau.o that thlu Order haa beol. violated, whothur or
not the vlolatlon 1. committed In the presuncu of a pollee
offlcer. In the event that an arreet 10 mnde under this section,
Defendant shall not be taken to j411, but sha 11 be taken without
unn.c...ary delay betore the Court which hns Is.ued this Ordsr.
When tho Court 1. unavailable, Defendant .hall be arralqned
betore a Dl.trior Ju.tlce who .hall .et ball accordlnq to the
provl.lona of Chapter 4000 of the Pennsylvania Rul.. ot Crimlnal
Prooedure. -\ ~ { ,,," 'I: ".. \~~\ n"Yl. \~) ,~"-l ~ ("... ......
\.. (v" 'l T't ~.l .......... l.\I'~I,," 'v.I.'-... f
, . by the court,
IJ}.'-I I:: ~
~r E, Shee1 ~ . .
--
Wayne r. thad., Eaqulra
Attorney tor rlalntlff
Thorn.. E. Pauqhman
OerendAnt
"
, ><"Yl
.-.....,
1.AIlMA J. 'AUOIlHAN,
PlainUIt
V.
I IN Till!: CQUMT or COMMON PM':AI 01'
, CUHDIMLAND COUNTY, P~HNIYLVANIA
,
,
,
, CIVil. ACTION - I.tAW
I NO, VB-al0 CIVIL TeftH
TUOHAI I. IAUOHHAH,
D.t.rn1Ant
lH,JI1 L.~_1MIU UC:~l~WK1.lfA1,.,,~l'Wt
IClOl(lJIIUt,Y.hl'".,J...
QAOIUI or ,r;QUM
ANP HOW, thi. a6th dAV ot Aprl1, 1991, I,
th.r.for., fln4 the O.f.ndAnt oullty of indlr.ct orlalnal
oant.llpt. of court.. II. i. ..nt.no'd to CUllbullnd County 'rhon
for a parlod of fort.y-fly. dAY', and h. .hlll ~ qlv.n orldlt on
the ADoY' ..nt.no. fro. April 11th, 1.91.
II. ."V ~ pl'ol~ without furth.r or4.t of thl. court
upon ..rYl", the ,orty-fly. dlY' In j.ll. Upon r.l.... froa
prl.on I 41r.o\ thlt h. at III t1... In the future oo.plV vith
the Inttruotlona .Ra dir.vtlon. ot \hl. or4.,. Th. Court
furth., dl"o', thl' h. paV the ooat. of pro..outlon Inyolvtd In
thi. ,....
I)' th. coun,
.
:'~N!'J
j f~l""
,..
~.,. ,~I/.. , ~n~!t\, VtW.
~ ~,tv:.\, h. ',','/J, 'Jt:,....
LfV\ iI."..."",,~,
'''I>!
:!"i'r;
,.....
-'1
~
"
"I
-t
"
'->>
SR;
..
,......
-
~
''''I
~
t
1I.~ II ~
O~ 0<
~~ ....
&II'"
. Ow
. III "'&II
.... Ii ....
i~ s: .0
011I Pi
.......
U ~.= :::III! ....
0<11I ...""
OIl;" ..... ....0
..... , .& w .... ~ ~~
.. .. ..t:~
. It.l
kI II'IIJIW
~c 11'I ~S! i~ f
tIC I
..
w~ ~ II ;iU'"
~ ... W.~
. 1011
i~ "
CI I;;
--
=-
.
<~'J!
'~~/' ,
, 'I ,
. ,
"/I/Ir
III TilE SUPEIl!(11< COUI<T Of PENNSYLVANIA
HARRISBURG DISTRICT
CERTIFICATE Of CONTENTS or REMANDED RECORD
PENNIVLV^"IA RULEI or APPELLATE PROCEDURE 2571 AND 2512
THE UNDER'JGNED, Chl.t Cl.rk ot the .up.rlor Court ot ..nn.ylv.nl.,
the ..1. court b.ln9 a court ot r.cord, do.. h.r.by c.rtlty th.t ann.x.d
to the or191nal h.r.ot 1. . true and corr.ct copy ot the whole .nd .ntlr.
r.cord a. r.~and.. tro~ .,ld court, In the tollowln9 ~att.rl
1 pllrt
No, 405 lIarr1ebur\l, 1995
bau\lhman v. Baughman
C,P, Court Cumbo Co, Clvtl, "-270
In .oepl'.n.. With 'A, Rul. ot Appllllt. 'roc.dur. 2511.
,.h. 'al. on which the r.eor' hit bltn r.lMndtd.. MAR iW6
An .4dltlon.l oopy ot thi. ,.rtlfle.t. 1. .nelo..d with the or191"'1
her"f and th. duk or prothonotary ot the low'r court or the hUd, 'hUrt....'..
deputy or ...r.tlry ot the ,ov.rn..nt unit 1. h.r.by dlr.et.d to .cknowl.d9-
ru.i,t of the r.lMn..d ruor. by tIlIQutln9 .uch cavY " tlll' pl.n IndU.ted
.nd by forthwith r.turnln9 thl ....,
,~.l~,
gcONl, .tv,
gcllVIO OATIl. 7lJ ~H( /"'" '< '7 / t/ l C. -
l.~y~l;(, (2. )v;.((~~fY;!~y l!~t(J.~''''f(41.1
(Il,""",r. ,neJ 'tH It I r 1
J. A04001/96
LAURA E. PAUOHMAN,
Appelle.
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
PENNSYLVANIA
v.
THOMAS E. PAUOHMAN,
Appellant
No. 0040~ Harrieburg 1995
Appeal from the Judgment of Sentence April 26,
199&, in the Court of Common Plea. of
Cumberland County, Civil, No. 95-270
IU<:FOREI McEWEN, P.J.. SAYLOR, and HOFFMAN, JJ,
MEMORANDUM I
Appellant, Thomae E.
P I LEe FEB 1 4 1996
Paughman, appeale trom the judgment
ot eentence of 45 day. imprisonment impo8ed by the
dlstlngulehed Pr881dont Judge Harold K. Sh.ely ot the Court of
common Pls.. ot cumberland county, bu.d upon II findlng that
appall.nt had committed indirect crlminal contempt of court as
II ruult ot h1l viohtlon ot .. protaction from abu.. order.1
We affirm.
On January U, Ins, the court .nter.d .. tamporary ax
pattI proteotion trom abue. order which prohlblted appellAnt
trom phy.ical1y abueln~ appel1a., placing appell.e In f.ar ot
imminent ..riou. bodily injury, and elCcludlng him from both the
r..idence and tho pllC8 ot en'ployment of appoll... AppeUant
',U .erved with the onler by the aherHt on January :I), un,
and on JanUluy ~'I, 1'IU, an Older wa. 4mtllrel! b.ued U'IQII th.
. '~~~--""""""'.._....
1 Aqt of o.c. 1', 1"0, r.~, l~.O, "0. 206 $ 2, 2) ~a.C._. .S
U 01 I.f. UJ;I.
.J. M4001/v6
['Onll.llt of thet putt.. whldl pnlVtcl.ti. lntlll 1l,\..Lj, thAt
IJppIIIUAnt -..tAy .way hOltl th. ...hS.llc. of ... ("(lv.Ua.' lit
;n North Mlddl.ton /Co.d, ".., and from ally ..uid.llc. which".
IlIp~l.tl...1 mllY tIllublll1h fo.. hliluliIU in t:h.. futur.. - Th.
ordlllf, which W.1I1 Illllhlf,,'. in fll'.II1 t'QlIn. bdlll thlll handwritt.n
notation m.clil by Pr..lalilllt Judu. 8h,.ly that IIPPI1t.nt'liI
con..nt to th. twrmll Qt th. (Jrdn 101.. l'rovhS.d in 0('11'" court.
Th. pHlthQnoury pHlvllhta nQth~. of th. Qrdn tg .liP.nlllllt'. Qn
Jinuiry 10, 1"', pYf,ulInt to PII.M,Civ,f, ~J.l") (~).
.\pp.ll.. h.. nUl14l1Hi At ;n North Mld,U.ttm MQ",d .1M. th.
pitrt:l... ..parithm. Mil. PliI&x>uh P4vi.. 1\ rOQlllllUllt. {It
IlVP.ll.., IIIW AJlpl!UAllt ,umUnu in tn. drivewAY pf tll-
("'ld.n". AI; 21 North MlddltHm ICQlld ilt 10,,}O p.lIlq on thlll
IiIv.nlrlQ ot M.r~h It, 1".< Mil, Davi. l~dl.t.ly lnror~d
"pr'ttU.. jmd ll!\J.tl\tH IhlllV w.nt 01.ltti4. (it tn. r..id.n(1. put
111 Ii not ... IIlnYQn.,
Th. ~nwuHIi, Qfi MIH~1i ".. un, on Wih.U gt
4W.U.., fthHi " tfttUl(>fi ,,,, it '...rinl;l PO f!h4f!JU (;It lrt4hf{1t
~flmln.t QPfit~t _q.tnlt .vPliltllllnt b...d Y~Qn hi. .11.~.d
.Yr..i.rig. at tn. flQYI. ~fi North Middl.tQIl ~j.d Qft tn. .v.nir~
9t MiUl?h U. '''fiI, ili viQt.Hfm pI tn. t.'H.tfI"thm hl'>lfi atm..
on14H": MIL /?titl'PUtJ t,i,,!{!8 ~unUI\i"j iU t;~" hUfirv,f QIl U..
J'''UU,,'' Ht4~ !Il~ M,t !lilt/Hi .~~HilM 1m, HMt Jlff'PUty,
,\J,.,"H4fj~/. "~"Ulf .Pit_ If. IKl4HV_, '''i>ittMVfiIlf, 'if~~r, 1;.,I;"i,4 Ht4t
,..,-=~.~'.,<-.,.,:;.,_..,..,~,q,::t"'r."l"::"_"""";'",,, ._....,..,.~"',..~ "....,..~.~~,."..".~-"".,""~.,..,~...,,'_,.:,.:., ,~.'_~~.'~<;'f"f.'o:.,.,"....,~~~,__,.,",...~.".-..."';,;",."',,."~,_"...,.....~:,:
4. 'ft... ~Iii'~t ""~ ~E~''/.'f>i'"'''' .;>"f'.'....""il"s.. <wll.", "","
"....... ,_, ....,.. t"""" ",\i'" ....."'..,.,.. ........ ...
H(,'lilnr>jf H". ",4t.f ~,~ tl!it.f\..4!1 \{l, p:a" ;tf""t ~H"', lL \i~~,
'*
."
.J. A0400'l/'i6
apll.llant wae at h!1I liuter/li rell!dence at 10.)0 p.m., on the
evening at March 18, 1995, and that he did not leave until the
followlng mornlng. Appellant allo to.tified that he Itayed
wHh hie eilter that night and that on the following day, March
19. 19~~, he went to the Atlantic City area tor approximately
one month. The court, litting without a jury, found MI. Davis
to be credible and found appellant guilty ot indireCt criminal
contempt for violation of the order. Appollant filed thi.
direct appeal from the judgment at eontence.
Appellant contend. that the evidence wa. In.ufficient to
eatabll.h hi. guilt beyond a rea.onable doubt .inc. the
Commonwealth fal1ed to preeent any evidence which o.tablllhed
that appellant had knowledge of the order. Appellant contende
that, in the ab.enee of evidence ..tablilhing knowlodge of the
terme ot tha order. there cannot be . finding of the e..ential
element ot willful dllobedience. W. dieaur..,
Our .tandard of review at a challenge to the ,ufflciency
of the evidence h whltthu the evidence, .nd Illl .....on.b1e
lor.rence. d'~Uolble th.r.from, vi.we~ ln the 11ght mOet
f.vorabl_ to the Commonw.alth, .. the verdict wlnner, Ire
.uttlolent to ..ubU.h each of th. etem.nt. ot the oUen..
1;lIl1Y<llld .. uuollable doubt. c.\1JlJI.lIOIDl/Ultb y. Wi11l.4m.1, U:I 1'4,
H~, 2U, 4U A.:ld '/16, 7U 0'1'.1:11.
In u.<J4tr f(1r the court to have t"und I.lppellan\: 9u1 hy or
v14h<t1,1t IJfhllmt1 ~{)IlU"J)t b.u"d liV;,.fl II v.QhtHm of the ordn.
,)
.1. A0400J/96
the Commonwealth W41 required to ntablbh beyond a reuonab1e
doubt that the protection from abu.e order wa. in .tfect. that
appellant had knowledge ot that order, and that appellant. in
violation of the terml of that order. purpolllful1y enteud
upon the property located at 23 North Middleton Road.
The protection from abule order had been .nta...d ba..d
upon the con.ent. provided in open court, of both appelle. and
appellant,) Appellant .leo nCluv.d notice of th. order from
the prothonotary. Paragraph tour of the order IpeoUiclIlly
prohibited appellant from approllching appellee'. r..ldllnce.
The court found tho te.tlmony of the witn... who .aw appellant
on appellee'. property on Much 111. 19l1!l, eredible and found
that appellant had knowledge of the order b..ed upon the notlce
utl.cted on the dockat and the order. ltlt1t, of which the
court took judic hI notic., whlch nt leated appel IInt...
pr..ence and agr.em.nt.4
J The order .peo1tlcal1y .t.ted that lt would remAln in
effect for one ye.r.
4 ill. CQm~~p~'II~~Q Y,.QY,~, )2~ PI.Super. )2~, \)2, .72 A.2d
1141. llU (191141 (4 court InAY take jIJdif"lal noticl of
uncont..ted noUtlon. 111 tho (:Ollrt nconS) I In 18 rh~lIHI.hlb..l.A
Co. 'gr 044r40tae!n<l no{l~~.e. AP~eal ot ~4gnll, 14) ~4.'Yv.r,
40", 41:1. 17 A.211 6U, U4 (l'iU)(" court. !lilY tillk. j\HUc-141
notice of <t.cn.. which it h". l)roviou.ly ",..It. ill l'lIl/ll,Hnu
1'1..4i/19.I. aU 41&<;/1 "!.;I~I,"'lilHll. y.... ~"'IU'lIJ. 4U h.lh1liil\r,
4~fi, _ (1,1, U'i A,ld U. <;.;? n.l <1'1'14) OColly, J,
(;(WCYU ~n\J), ~lU>>.'" <:~~,Juwi4itb.",.x..~ l:l"''''l;.'l(, 11'1 hi. th".." Ufo,
1}0 A..ItS .~l (l'iUI I" COllff If""Y 1.._" j1HHtl4! fj(.n.... {If ..
llH:',nl which I,.,U. tit. ....: ',f ~HY "(II~1t III t.h. III..t..,
.
It
.
:;;:,.
"
.f~~.,
f\f
;',!"
"J:t
;?~:
H
~'-.
:ill"
'"
-0
I
t,i
!. r ,~
,:j
t',"
, "
, ~,~
" 'I
.it't
:~ ill
",j"
.J
Ii
(,(lI': i'l(INW I'; A 1.'1'11 I IN TItE COUR1' or COMMON PI.EAR Of
, CUMBERLAND COUNTY, l'ENNSYl.vAN 1 A
V, ,
I TroRM . NO. IlI\J'"!lO:no )
1'Il0MAIl ~ lIAIJOllMAN I
I CItAROEI CAst TRANSFt:RIlEl>
I FROM CIVIL DIVlSlO
O'I'N I I AFFIANT'
IN Itl': I Rllf.lC TO (mow CAUIE
2l\Q~" o~ ~OU"T
AN!) HOW, March 33, It I" ,
In conllderatlon of the attached
l'ul.ll. tlln, the court I"u" a RUle to Show Caule on th. d.f.ndant why
111_ !lhould not t>e adjudq.d In contempt. of court for falUnlJ to pay tho
!llImll ..1. forth In the petltton.
'rh.. l4ute h r.turnable and t.he he4rlnq .hall b. held on
AI'I II 31, 19U
at 9110 AM In Courtroom No.4,
of t.h.
('11111,111' land County Court.houl', Car 1111., P.nnlylYanla.
HlIrvlc. of t.he pet.lt.lo11 t.o b. mad. on the d.fendant. bV C.rt.lflad
M411, ".t.urn "ecIlpt M.queltld and bV reQular mati.
IV the Court.,
"'4t-d~
';h'PCIi ,("/iVIN' A, IIlIU
~lll'fl~t A\'UfntV" Ottlcl
,..~tjU(l o.'eMlr'. OU&e.
t'n'l'4t 'lJ~ O' f hr.
t'
"
fl
~~
(.'-e
-,j;t
,_.r.
....
'-1:"
\:;\
;
~~.
-,b
-l~
)i
,,'j
1,1,
:'11
.<t
'(
"
-
t!'"-'
"
.t,.t
,fI'
J
li
p~
Y.
IN THI COURT or COMMON 'LEAl
I or CUMBeRLAND COUNTY, PENMA.
I .
I ta0210 CRIMINAL 1..5
,II'oono CRIMINAL U.. /
I
COMMONWIALTH
TIIOMAI I. IAUOUMAN
IN _II IINCH VARRANT
OROIR or COURT
AND MOW, Thl. 211t day 01 April, 1"', bl..d on th.
f.co...nd.tlon 01 'h. Probation OlIIG' coll.ollon unl\, 'he
t>.nch warrant I,.u.d on April 2',
'he a.fand.n, hI. paid In full .11
IH.Mh..d.
I'" i. h.reby d&'.&"'d ..
IU.. du.. Th. p.\&tlon &.
IY ,tI. C'1I1 ,
~,'
r~.
Pl~TRIC' ATTORNIY" O"&CI
,~~jA'ION Of' Ice
.U~~I'r" Of' Ice
';"/'; I." ~,!,~
'PIt;-
\f;
~~
',,,,
~"..+J
......,
f~l
~.~
~J"
.
,.""
..
',\
.,.
"~I
"(1
,,' ,)
'-0.'.
J
, ~
:b
" 'J
o'fl'l
(:I
!
~'~1
.,