HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-00281
,
...-tI
...
~
~
;f
.
-7
~
J
~
J
\"
\
}
,
.~
'tii!"";; IIAIl';!!,
.. ! Ii lid I tf
li.!.r (0 ~! (H Ul~~I". !'l A'. [It
f ulillHlli ,\":j [IU"" ( I""".',r '''MilA
..
,11 Ii , H'IIIIT ilIHl"Ul
"PII "1111 l I' /IlA!wf.t, ~ Ii
l1,trli(4tlf.h
(lVIl Milo, " iAW
~o it.Olil CIVlt Tr~"
r~UUA~ COlt'Ot'1,t:
41 U fJi,tri!H tOllf,ftlftttl IHiW fl,! ifllltllH nun,
nit/Ol'" ffivlJf" 1\(\)'1,,'. W(fl,j'. IHfI_~Il! 'M 'lQI'lUtf "0\ llrll'W!
I /l!lHtfllo hQf4tf#. f#flfj tilt V",f1ffiHIH. ~tIV'/'j b ~11,(Jtlr,
t "Illlf.
fnit " n (IUH1!fl!l nilQI U'Mll flllllll \1\ 11111('/'1 IHfHAtl"
It'llinl!llh~ ".. Itlft.nilf frOIll tl riH.flJnH' lJ(ffJ'Hi4h ll' (j rUIiH Of
!f,,, '111/41. tQ WIl.h tHUlIIHH. oM tllHH "It Q/)lum(/HlU,
j'l,llHIH \.," lIi'rtW~1 '111'M,,, IfU lfg911\ OM {j,,,.rot
il,i'ill'jn hH~t,d HlIlf M tr IIIL t"". allYl
..,,11I'/1'1'1\ Utl!lt (If 4Htl1V'f, rnn"H". ..PtrU nutlt to
t,., (ljJt<t>I.ho hat; tfifliJ9" t"" tfiUJ it ntH ot IUU'. If' win
t..V lIon tft, tflll trh.aul~ Drt tn, f'trlt.,ntUfIDn b. I,Ift
11""\111 'M! Hitt witl fl).~I.tlt '''ill dIHO'i'f~ If 'IHI'1'
,iL,,,,,,,1 l'iu~H 11 {(ihfl!\lffll1(. I1jCfIU\' !1IHO\l!ll'r M\ tHjf l>urJ
II~Pl_lta, 'N.. .~ould "'Ift"lln "Qtlt, In. court U._l""tratof
! I OlrrliNhl", "'l' tC1 jrHnH'"c, -.dunl f,nlfet (.t l1,t,fjiJ~l1t
. "'4iHIHftii 1m hni h't IHlfltlHIM 'n Mqh ~lItrH I'IIHtlllftL 011
"fflff il' fidllt(jflt., ..n t fl. 1II/lI1. HI Hll"tltlf
. ..- ..-. . -
It"'lflff~ ,iIH'h'hY Hflt qllhl1!1fl!t! ""IU!lt; J4tHji,ltffj,
i"" 1,'1 "'''fa(j.r,~ 1,I,I1!I"q" rtifUl'<'nW'I' t
. I ~!,. ~, ~ I
; 'i 'I ~ {; L
~i {';'IJ f f: tJifn- ~ J;
1 y!
~ri;J
t t
'-;;
dt#' 1t{-,rJ~(jP, ~
; ..
~-~ ~ t,; ,~_ J;
I ~. ~. .~.. '~.'d~~'
"":.,. u.. -:'.,- '1,'-'': '1 ''''.'';
iii'
., ..,
"d ~. ~,~1't;t
"
~
~-~/.~ /;#~.
t,~ ~ f- -~~i'4i! ~ ~
t<,) Ilf PttilHII '" iiblh!t\t'1f'!1 h'l] ~U.t'.~l Pi' ':.t.i,tf,.Jl~tH"i .~'O.
; j'j I ,I f,t- ni)~ tiutl;t'UI;ttflll" j.,.f-' tIlt' f~!liPlfJJI1Ii~f!l 01 10...
''I'.i'II,,; 0/1\1 ,>, !IVlliV i"" "t quI"
1'\11\1,11 ff ltHlIl1!ulfl\ ItIll!
jt H "w IIHllijfl~H!llltv lIt I1lttl'!!!,\! tOUl1Hl1 10 IlfI)OIH\i Dr
ilt'!QiO 01 HtoL ilfH1 If tw rIM' nut OtIlHwr thOI {) f1H(lnttvl!
III t (<I Mil.. .,/luulll hI' ( IHlf (ll'll tll Ittl1 )!j/ V tlilhHtU I IHIOU 1 n(lli
I' d\(fltr.ll thot IIl'I will fjt tltffllH to tin ViJI Ilf lllllufU I100"or una
I,j i I nho nlt.lfllPI to nlHoln flr rl..llifll'~ (Urfl'llt lflflltlllfl Ul
thdl r.l'I Inn tit "ihfl(llH'll,1,1 ht Plqiflltff
1 f I'll' lltlurQ !lOU fI(1t
I,HiI!llf Il 11IHlnru Will 1'H1ViI' t l'l till iI.lIl lluHlr141 Ilf 1M JUry !Ill
lhol olnlntlft't CQIiIlUI con mllhlt I! rfi'r/Jfd I" to Why HIll fuh
It'll! 11"'IH\~j f'OUIiUl Iho,,1I1 f)\i tu,ld 10 (l flHWlfll!li.n, of
tJfntluctFiIl ru, O.lu((l, and
I' n. dO'~ not aOPfOf
I' 'Cl, WhO! tI!!m'dY \hClilld
I
/1
,
b, ij/llplovet1
~Dnl" J, MO"'lIO. "qulr,
fur I'HHnt.,t
~t.v~n D '"Va.r, r,QUlr.
r IIr OftfllM(lf'lh
IIf ,
~t~ r ~
I. ; !:'
t'-i"
iJJ~
tl t;
.7.:t.t'o't;
~j;tJ
,. .~
i,
...
i
!
!
I
I
I
t
,
,
I
{
RICKARD W. MANlAY,
Plaintiff
. IN THI COURT or COMMON PUAII
. CUMBIRLAND CO., 'INN'YLVAHIA
.
. CIVIL ACTION . tAW
.
. HO. to-I' 1 CIVIL TIRN
.
. JURY TAIAL DIMANDID
v.
1I0LY "UUT JIOIPITAL .net
fltlLLI, MAGUIR', N.D.,
O.t.ndanU
ICiAtlllflf 'OU.Ilk ....QUGIDI
I, ",...IldIlIALIUU1l
1hi, 1. . lN4aQll n~l",.no. .0Uon trill", out ot the
Pel.nd,nt., f.lllne to UNly dl'9no.. ''!'i".~!?e~~",~f~lglt1.
~---,,,,.,., ~-"
f,.ultanw In the rupture of 'l.antltt .loh.rd R....y'. ,pp'ndlx on
,_ '. ,_..,".~..~,.-::_"",."~"od",,;~,,,'--M
J.hU.ry aa, 1">>. A.. r,.ult Of the OItend.nt.' ne,II,lno., Mr.
M..,.)' dlvelop.a ..v.,. ,.,ltonl\l. .nd h.d to Und.fVO extenelv.
..n"enoy 'Uf9IfY '*lUlU"" In I PfolonQld .nd .tol1lY hoeplt.l
",,,un.. ...anUff 'ti"h'rd "'.IIY euU.u Iroa .n .whn.lv.
IUf'llu'l 'on .114 1. at. tI,<I,..." rille of d.vlloplnq bow.l
~P.truQtlon dll. to thl '.',n,lv. n.tllr. Of the 'UfV'rv.
On ""I\un)' Il, un, .t '"foxlU'lly II" ...., Rlohard
-....)' WI' ,.ken ~)' '.PIIllnOI tft e.r.n4ant 1I01y Iplrlt lIo.plt.l.
.nltl l\4r WII ...n an the ...,,,.noy rooa by e.t.nd.nt ..hUlp
.4~~lrl, H.P. Al ,"., '1.., Nf. Ma...y'. Qo.pl.lnt. w.r.
Jtultl.,.", ftlf"' ,...., "".'un' .WulNl p.'" whh "'001&\14
"../#.tit. .1'14 '1M"'""" I,/fIIA ....IMU." ~ 0411.1'14.,,\ Matllh., Hr.
ti!'lN~
'14m1AY w.. not.d to b. ".out.ly 111 Ind wrlthlnq ln paln holdlnq
riqht lower qu.drant of Ibdo..n." Ol.lrlnq Hr. R....y'. .tay ln
O.fendlnt Holy Iplrlt "olpltal 'lIIuq.noy rooll. hh plln WII 10
.xoruolltlnq thlt h. r.qulr.d tour do... ot n.rootlo .'dlo.tlon.
lntrlv.nou.ly.
Hr. R....y n.Aln.d ln lIoly Iplrlt "o.pltll 'lIIuq.noy roo. for
Ipproxl.lt.ly t.n hour.. durlnq which tl.. dllqnoltlo t..t. w.rl
order.d by Det.ndant Haqulre. Dlt.ndant M.quln" dift.rentiAl
allonoll. for Mr. RI.lay lnolud'd .1th.r .ppftndloltl. or kldn.y
.ton... Wh.n D.t.nd.nt Mlqulr. w.nt ott duty .t 7100 ...., h.
Idvl..d Dr. DeLuo. thlt h. b.ll.v.a Mr. RI..lY W.. lutflrlnq fro.
.1th.r .pp.ndl01tl. or kldn.y .ton... An lntr.vlnoul pYI109r... a
allonoltio t..t Ip.oltloally d..lq".a to r.dloqraphlo.Uy 1..ql
kldn.y .ton... w.. to b. p.rtora.d th.t .ornlnq. At .ppro.l..t.ly
0,]0 ..... thl IVP WI' r.port'd baok to Dr. DeLuo. I' n.q.tlv..
a..on.tr.tlnq no Ivld.no. ot kldn.y .tonl.. Mor.ov.r, thl r.nal
funotlon atudl.. p.rtora.d .Irll.r thlt .ornlnq w.r. wlthln norall
1 halt..
Althou\Jh the .tor...ntion.d .tudl.. oharly lndloltla th.t Hr.
Rla.lY WI' not .uff.rlnq frolll kldn.y 'ton.., Dr. D.Luo. dl.oh.r,.d
Hr. R....y wlth . dllono.l. or .out. .nd ..v.r. rlnal 00110 (kldn.y
.ton..).
Approxl.at.ly U houre lat.r, Mr. "....y r.turned to Dlr.ndlnt
1I01y Ip1rlt Ho.pltll ...rq.noy roo.. wh.r. h. w.. 1...d1.t.ly
dla\Jno..d .. .uft.riM fro. r.troc.cal .pp.ndlClltl. with
J,utontlon 'M perltonltl.. OUt to the rupture .M the p.nuiv.
a
nlltur. ot thl pultonlU.! Mf. ......y und.N.nt ."hn.lY. .urQuy
with. 1.v.,. ot hl. lnt..tln. .nd hi. ebdo.lna1 oavlty, with .
pllo...nt ot dr. In. In 'h. f19ht low.r qu.dr.nt. Att.r an .ltht
dllV ho.plt.UnUon. Mr. ".."'y w.. cU.ohar".d ho.. on oral
.ntlolotlo.. Du. to the d.1.y In dIIQno.l~ 'h. .pp.ndloltl. and
thl d,vl1op..."t ot p.rHanlt", Mr. ......y had a pro10",14 and
pratt.ot.a r.oov.rv .n4 1_ now .t an lnor...ed rl.k of d.v.lopl",
~Qw.l obltrugtlon.
11...,JUU...uteD....u
Th. ,lelntltt lnour,e4 .u>>.'an'lal aldl.e' ..,.n... In ord.r
'0 'rl.t hi. ruptur.d .,p.n41. .nd hi. ,.rl',nl'll.
In .\WlUon to Halo.1 ..,.n..., 'lelnU" all. lu.tllnad
appro.l..t.ly ..v." (11 we.k. 1" lo.t w.,... At th. 'I.. ot th.
lnold.nt. Mr. ......V w.. . .11.. f.pr...nt.'lv. WOfklnv tor Irl,'ol
Nprth...t, lno. tor ..I.ry p1u. oo..l..lon.
tlllntUI .1.0 ...k. ".neUl d...".. 'U(lh II ..nUl and
1'11)'.1".1 p.ln .nd .uU.,l"" lnQo"v.nl.M.! .u.n....."t .nd
hUIlll.tlon. dl.t19ur...,,'. .nd 10" 0' lit.'. ,1...Uf.. .nd
.n 1 (iV..M .
tl.1nUII wlll .uppl...", thl. U..lIlU." .f d...,.. "Un
.~r. pr.ol.. 11,ur.. In . 'l...ly ,..hlg" prlfr \@ \ri.l.
lU"e",dui,u,.IUVt. ..tLJJuU1'J....~.JUM...
tnl. i. . .'f.l~"'.tQfW.r4 ~l~'l ~ll,.~ ~.. Vh4r. ,~
.....l(l 'uw.. " lr'Mt...., ~f.M./'I' ~~h., o~, "'-WM 4114 Moly
I
/Jplr1t Ito.pital throuQh lh .o.nt.. .pp.rent .Olnh, ..rv.nh
And/or ..ploy.... which inolud. Dr.. H.ouir. .nd D.Luo.. tail.d to
...t the .ppropriat. .t.nd.rd ot care with ra.p.ct to th.ir
treat..nt or Rloh.rd R....y, wh.ther th.ir d.viation rroll the
It.ndard ot o.r. wa. a .ub.t.nti.l r.otor in o.u.lno Hr. R....y'.
injurie. .nd the ..ount of da..o.. Whioh Pl.intiff 1. .ntltl.d to
I. a ra.ult ot the Oaf.ndanta' oonduot.
It. ~.g.1 I..V..
Thi. 0... do.. not involv. any unu,uIl 1.9.1 1.'u..,
Y --.......IilA.. "I
Richard R....y
Rioh.rd and Dolor.. R....y (Plaintlff', p.rent.)
Phllip H.oulr.. M.D. (Def.ndlnt al on orol.)
Richard D.Luoa, M.D.
David .purl.r. M.D.
Hurl. connl. ..v.rino
o.vid Fro.hlioh. M.D. (,ub..qu.nt tra.tino Phy.ioi.nl
J.... olon.ll. M.D. (Pla1ntUf'. .xp.rt on l..u.. of 1 abUlty
and da.IO..).
M.dical r.oord. ou.todiln.
laploy... ot Itoly 'pirit ItOlpital involved in Mr. R....y'.
oare tor ..lrQ.nay rooll .dllhalon or 1/:11/93, l/n/93 and
.d.il.ion froll 1/33/" throuQh 1/30/93.
Dr. D. Kunk.l (r.diolooi.t who p.rform.d IV' on 1/31/'3)
All wi tn..... id.ntitiad by d.t.n.. ooun'.l
'hintitt. r...rv. the rivht to .uppl..ent thi. U.t in .
ti..ly f..hion prior to tri.l.
4
,
Y1 ~_IJJ1UlU.
1, ".~lo.1 r.oord. ot the lollowlnt provld.r.,
"alr 'plrlt Ho.plt.l
DIV d rro.hl1oh. H.O.
2. ".~lo11 ~111. froll the .for...id provld.r..
l. H.dlo.1 bill ,uII..ry
4. Ixp.rt r.port(.)
I. w.,. 10.. oh.rt
.. Pl.lntltt'. f.d',.l lnoo.. l.w r.turn.
1. An.ta.io.l .od.l. .nd dl'tr...
"hlMltt. n..rv. lh. rl,hi t, .",,,1"',,, '''', U., ln .
tl..1y I..hion prior to trl.1.
Yl1."--LlAllb-Il trlll
Thr.. (:J) dIV"
uu.. ....U...."~....UaUlu
tl.1ntlrt hi' d..lnd.d tl'I,OOO ln 'vll and 'lnaa "'la...",
at .U 01 hi. ollb.. 0.1."".,,\ it.. .... . flO,OOO ..Ul...",
QU.r.
1l._Qu1IUtt\luu
'1.1ntltt r'qu..t. that t~ ,a,tl.. .tipvla'. I. lh.
lIuth.nUQhv .114 .lflll..l111y (jf lh41 M4hJ.l .....'d. 1M IINl..1
bUI. 10 .. to ..vi.t. th, "'.. ,., 'N ','UMIt)' .f 'MO,4.
01.1'\041'.".
t
.lltn\t'f rurni.h.d o.,.Rdlnt. wtth th.l' flr.' '.P'Ft f.,ort
on Jldy II, "" Ind th. ..00n4 up,,\ rtpgr\ on HOV.DIf II, un,
Vi.1ntl" hi' not r.o.lv.d .ny 'WP'Ft rlpoft. 'roa th. Der.n4ln\..
IStnQ' it h only thu. ",..k. untH th. trhl 0' tht. ..n."
'l,lntl" r.qu..t. thlt th. 0.'.A4Int. b. ord.r.a to provld. \hltr
'~p'rt r.port. l...dlat.ly. Th.,..,t.r. 'lAlntl" .hlll hlVI yntl'
Jlnuuv 17, lilt to produo. Iny nbutUl 'WI'''' rlpoftC'), If
v.t.Rdant, r.u. to provtd. In '1(51.,t "pQri 1....dlaU1V, ,111nUft
,.qu..t. thlt th.y b. pr.olud.4 'rol p,..."'l", InV ..,."
wltn..... ., th. 'la. " 'rl.l.
11I'ICTfULLY tuIMITTID,
AMGINO . aqvMll, ,.0.
Ol'.a. I'j /.'. Y.'.. A :g,...-,.
. . ~,~.hF':,
. I I, ''IV .
.D. If.. .t...
.101 Horth 'ron\ """
"lfrl.,uf.,'A 171\0
en') IU-'1fl
C~ft.., '.f '111,,\1",
.
IN TUN (~OURT olt' (.,n.tMOM ''LtcAH or
. (~\lMIIKKI.ANIl (~UUNT", '~t:NNMYI.vANIA
, NO 1Il'l.\lIt,
IIOI.V ~WI"'T m)jWITAI. : (,IVII. M~rlUN . lAW
Itwll'IIII.I,Jll "'AOUlIue, Mil .
tJ.llIncMl\lil . JURV TItIA1. U~'IAMU~U
UICIIAltU W KAM,.^"
''t~lllll If
v
'tRmKIAt, (~ONVIt:KI!:N(~t: MJo:MOKANUUtrl
or m:n:NI)AN'n4, tlOl,y tWIIU'f II(I;Wl'l'At.
~~
I, KTATICMICN1' or UNtil! VAt:'f" N'TO t.lAtul.lTV
On J_nual')' \l I. 'Wil ~, 1Il't"tJtIlll......ly \lira it 1ft , ,... plAt",U'MfM W "'-
""w'"'MY r_m ., II..ly ""I,lt III11VI\A1 fl<ml.taintfi,lIt flIlln 1ft ht4 ~n.
~Hl~j hili bMIi, Ind InW hi_ ....Ufl.. Vr l'hlllip II MIt'ui,., Itn fi'ft14l'I'!W1 room
l.hnlftAn, ~nfjd I hl,w,y from pWnulf Ilfl" lilIrfllrm.... It .....''"'1.. ,uWM\Wn
U, "'.."11' 'N'" II'.'''' vIII,"y, ...... lW' HItY'
Uf. MI\IUI,.'II .M, ,,""'III' APJlfi.li.....k4y 100 It m, It' _tmh \lmf I".
t(idlAf" T. U.I.UM _YIM" f(IIIIliIAAlltlhh' "if \htr pWnul1'1t Mr. Itnd \tfJ.'fflffl'
u~t tlllOft ,htr .114ln\II1', fllfl~1 lifi'HrtM'Wft Itfltl ...., ,Mitt", I" (hll..",,,
dllt,,~1 Ut# VJ.itiflUn '" kit.'1lI MWt ..wi Hn,. r~,1JtJ .ffltli IItllllJMiMtptl ,h-
.....".utt it\ I" fftJ iJ Jf' lWn" ~'Iilitllf~ f.I. ltu.!f.iJIi\ lk l'ftHlwft4~~.. WIAt~'. ,...,
,MY iiI' If,. "1'~\fIIi!..t I" ''''I,Uf;II~; INlflilif,!;l! l;'" "MiAlUf l# '.\WA ll; dw
1'1l1j!r"IIIl~)' dlll,nrtlllllnt or COlluu't n IIC1~tllr II' hll 111111 III1Y Ilrublllm. IIr hili ,'OIllUUlIll
WUfllllnett
l.-ter thllt II11Y IIIl ,Jllllllllry lll. IOU:I, till' pl/lIIlUll'lI ~IIIIIIllloIIIWI'/ll'tlntly
wofll(!f\tlll, but tlllll,llllnUl1'l1llver ""I1I/let(lIl Ur, I'nlllllodu 10 IICllCldulo 1111
lI(111l1lntrnllllt or lIou!Cht 11llllll"lIll111I1Il\lun, 1\11 Illlllrucll!t! by Ur, lM,uCII, Tho
IlllluwllllC day Iho Illllln\lll'lI cllI\lliUUII l'lInUnUllIl \II Wllrlll'n 1\1111 ho rlllurn(lt! to Iho
IHllllfJllll4'Y rllllllll\l 1Illly Hlllrlt II UIII 111.111 III lIpprllJllm/lll'ly :1.:10 pm, 11IIt! wn.
dillICrnl.wd All h"vinIC " rl!t.rlK'l!~ul. rolrllllultI IIwc1mlklUII wlIh 1m 1,b.cet'II, Th.
IlllllnUff unelllrwclIll IIUfIC"\')' Illter thAI day, Thet .urlvl')' Witll 1"'"Urmod by ^.
HAvld (t'flKIltllch, MU,
It i. tit. II"(,,nllnnl.' 110.1\101\ Ihat nr, nol,Uct"!I IIII1.nOllI. of aeuUlllnd
IIUV4l'. ,.rutl c<llle on Jalluary lll, loo:J WA' ,ultlOnabl. undor Ih. rircu"",lnnco.
lIrnt Ihlll \h(lrB Wall nel hrtlltelt In the IItanllarll of "')fe. TII. dllftlnllanu 1"'0
fOlltllnd that tho IllalnUlf' WA' nllclllllllll Illr 1101 ,etuml", to tho o,"lIr"one)'
Ih'lmrlnl4lnt or "(,j"'1\ dodllr whon hi. cumUlllln Wlllie"t"III" JltnUlu)' ~l, loo:t.
c~ ~
II IIMl(' loIMY'" i\."I'ff) IJAMAlIII:H
Itlll"''' ,lIl1 th. 1.lldflll/f', Ilflltrlnl f\Il1f11llfllOO"f11 h .houlel 1M! fllIl.d tllAt
"."11 If Ihll 1.lltlnIUr. HIIIM!lllllfili. IUI.I liNlll dill.nulltlflllfl JI"l!UtfY .11. Ul(j;t,
liUf'tll')' IlIlvIlrlhlllClII. would hltVll bpf!IIIWf"jjIlIU)' 'nlUll. Ihll 1IIlthllllt wl/uhl hltVtl
IIl1dl'rllllll4' IIUrlllifY. hlf"frt.d IIICfdiml Illll.."IIHI", ,11,,,,,1,,,,,,...1 It ,..'Iud Ilf f~l\'llfY,
111111 hlllt 11111. from wllrk lIV'11 if'l4n ...Ulllff dlltlfnulIl.. hltd I,...." IMI$tt rllt1lIflAwly,
IIIIl Illainlilt ml4ll11IUl lIulIlh"ll (..,'llYflry "nd Willi III~harll.,.1 frl.m IIf, rf'ltlhlit'h'll
l'iIfll un Mltfth:l, I\lu:f, nlll'fUIIIIMWly 11111 wlUOlul'l,lIllWlIlll Ulll 'ltfllllf)', rhcl
1,1.,lnU'T flllurllfl' W wllfk III Ml\ffh lool
III (1IUtWII'At. l.!<<HtlrJt or (,IAlIlI,ITY ANU uAt.,^urJt
A
It
Wluilhti, fh. tl",ndilntl It\4i' U.. .IMrnl4,d lit tWill ltl1plkltblf \4. Itt.m
In (tif'flfttltin wilh Ih, fitflJ llnel t,.,..lnwf" 11M'ld.,.1 ll. Ih_ v.t4inUm
Wtwllw, U, 'htl.lWl1', dlitllll.JtI, Ilf """'" ltne' "nf' ,ilMI (If;1l. wu
rflUlIMt.!. "Ill'" I.... tlffU'n.ttllflfll. "",I Jhf;'lIWf. within I""
.laOOnf" IIr fAr. ."'fllt Ihld IIllt.(\(.... WIU loo..".tl'
WhMltt.r llw 141lUlUff w-.. fil'If'.llflfll 111 fitthl\l W Mlaw ull with U,
1',,,tI'04111 Ur ..,..k funllll' IfMoltlf..lllllAlfllMi jjUI.'Uilf t!AMId lIVUft U..
dlHhAfllllnAtrmiklwt 1I'.lIft Ii, tltlfl"
WtIlIttlllr It... 1t.lllftllitlllA' fiffidmt WIU It .ubitlanU,d fltfWf 1ft ,.",1",
ltflY hltr". VIU.. 141111"lIf /till" ,f "', VI whitl lIt~t'nt Ul4'l'l#lntur .1#1
hnfllt(flt"
l' ,
u
'.
~ tl. >::
II' Jtrr~ (fublr, Illlllolifr. .lIll4lrvl...r
"I IIn.\.I11 Nllo,",,,.I, l.h,tr,Wr.. Ifllll,,")'..r;
I~l IM.ndlto... f.'''rv.. 'h.. fl.M \.I. ~ItIlIUlY
will"''' 1l.~1 11)1 'hll 1111'10\111\ IUIII
1:11 IMllllditl\LI ,lIll1rvtl ,hll 11'''1 \.If .1I11111lflll(lOl
thllt h.I, If OM'tI""'!f. 1111110 t"IUlJMbI" nllUlltI
\.If th.. ('"UO ,,1\11 '''"MIll
V I lC"lIl1t1'flJt
I' l'Wnllff. ,....11',,1 f~'fll. fruit' 1I...ly
"I"r" 1I111111~1 '1lllUdlo, ".."InMfol Ilf..vlct.ct
(ffl Juty.. IWI; Jieow")' ~I. 100:1 Ihwuah
JltnUM)' tW, IWit, lint! ^1'111 T 'hflllllh
^prll U. 100:1,
ii' Ut, t'fIHlhhlh'. nw.fifitl IlIw,d. fOM,mln,
It.. 1114Inliff.
III 11,"nU'f. IIml""YIfMIOI fl'{llfll.t wllh
tI,I.WI Ntl,UUluI.
.. i 11/t1nY'f. 1~lttlJllilio', ,h""unry 'NJlUM"',
/WI t1.I"lllltillo "ltl*'f1I", if "",iI..ltry;
Ai 1"'t."danLl 'IIMrv.. I.... rllht W 11M
Itf\Y fIIIhlbn liaWlI tlY 1"11 1....'nUff; llrut
III IM..RWtnLl ft'Mtvtl ,t.. filM W III1IIJ....nWftl
thlll hll'. If 11ftf.."itrY. "Iilm 'toifMlMt.I.. IWU~
W .... (~Iill" ,t1I1'"llYflMtl
'rh.; ''''~/"JiullA ''''l~' 'hit' ,."" "Jim...... ~lIl"'...W w ..... ."'INAUd'y ql'tw
,.14m.llt'. ffjltlllt;i4J '1(411'4,. MI/l ,..... UIIi., 4U1j,t'"W l/ANl.IIft~ '''~'III~
,ti
VII K1'ATlJH 01' Ht:1'TI.KMICNT NKOOTIATION"
l'I"lnUlf h", ,ulrllllttflll It ...Ulllm..,,' II..mlt.lIll" ,'" I.,OOU'" lif "1lA.(J(KJ.
ThlllMlmdllnil hM"1t ,,If,,r''ll UO,1I0IJ
',"I~""II)I .ulrmlUttel,
Mtm'IC. Ir:VANK' WOOIU4IUtr:
lIy;
I r )
..,; 'f
.J..J. ......S .v! 1.' -_
""'Vlin IJ Hn)lll." '':.111,11"
HUll. (~t I J) U4:....
:UOI Nonh "rll"t Hlr.,'
I'. (), I"', /lIIMJ
Illt,.,.w,ur..I'A 171l1HIUlIO
('7 171 ~:I~,MI(JO
A'MIW)" fur J)..ffnclltn'
1M)' "pI'" lIU1pilAl.ncl
.1..lUll MAlul,.. ~t.().
UNrlC; IJflftmber WI. 100ft
. 'I .
,
I "rUl)' ~hAt Iltll\ till, lilt)' lervlll' It ,'uIW 1I1't11\l fUfll,uhl' chiC:lll11l1nt 1111011
III.. IlCffIMIII and in tI'll "'lilliit" h\llkllt..d 1II,Iow, whir!l 'IIrvl,'u ,ntllfl,. thll
rmllllnllmmlJl of th.. 111'11I11I)'lv""lll ICIIII!lIllf eivlll'rllctllllltll, h)' dlllln.IUII, It cOil)' III'
II/mil! in LIII! 1II1ltlll'''tll\.llll AlRlI, tI",n,huf', l~nnll)'lvllllli.. with "rlt-ch...
!,1I11tllllll, IIICJIlllhJ. IlII fullllwl:
lWitt" J, Mllrulla. KIM,ulrt!
MlfM" ltovn.r. II,(~,
4M.1 Nurth "'llIIt HI,"t
IIAnUln.f..IIA tTllO
MIm't:. IWANH II W000810R
II)'~
/1 r I \, j , /
.'{ .' :(. -' . 4,J. _ '_'-,
Mktv.n Ii Hn)'lillf.'f:.llulnl
tlUI" (~t, l, U, .:14:144
:-'01 North I"rul\t Ht,lIl1t
I', (1 nOli nUM
llAm.lmf.,I'^ tTIIIHm/iO
11171 ~:l...auo(l
Allllfl")'1 IlIf Illllundltnt
1I",lv tI,li,IL 1I111111Hll11tl\d
I'hllllll ~tltllJi"l. M ,l),
HAlK I~~ :U, 1M,
t.',O", *
,
Im'''Altl) W, MMIl^Y. IN um ('OUR'!' OJ! C'OMMON N,MJ Of
I'ljllnlllf C'l1MltlUUANI) C'OLJNTY,I'I:NN~nV^NI^
Vi, I C'IVIL AC~IION ,lAW
\I~1I1l11 C'IVII.'Il\l(M
1101." 111'11\11' IlU!ll'll"" lIod Illlt" 'II4IAI. m~M"NUm)
I'IIIUJI' M"ClUlIUt, Mn,.
()~ If 1\\1.111.
IN.lWl..MUllWU:UIUlWrucu~u {,U\Wlll
OlUlCK
"Nn NOW, ~hli
q' dlIy ,I{ AII"'II. I"". II Ruw It ~d UllllMt rWfIlUf kl
.Iww rau" why 'M 1.lltr "qllftlnlln IIw within ftIllljllll fUf I'f'lfirliv, ("., (f\!ploot IU !Ill
1I111I1(ld,
llll. RIIWlflvIRil"" tw,nly (ZlII dlI)'1 llhtll ...,.~, &'fAdIIll ''''.1''>11 ii' Ihit millW'"
IIw IUflIltUkl1ll _11M. IIlf IIw Illltjfft MIl'''' ", t1~.tt
ItV 111ft fOUR1.
~~~~
~, '"',
~,
/
~. MOt''l.lv~r, OIW lIf Ih" d~."lnll"hi II oul (If Ihll '-(lunltY And IIw tllmAlnh11l
IllJfl4l/Wnll haw Illher (ummUmrnll And Mil UMvaUAblllllltlt! dllpowd AuguII 9,
11195,
tl. In .dllllhm, 11w", II nil clAim for (lIfputAle 1W8\lllllnre In Ihl, CAW,
Th~rtlfur., 1110 1IIIIIlm1ny uf IhoH 1~lvld"all 11IUlhllll btI dllp4lled by pl.lnUff "
m,Uhllr tllk\'.nl oOlllkllly 10 Iliad lolhll dllcowry of adml..ibIIlIlVldIlO'", Tht, II
AlfIIlltUf of lho p41tfMllUWl fII. of RJ,hard IM.u''-. M,O, whkh II fllque.led In 'Ach of
llw NIIIl'tI of ~f'lllltlllO, ~ ll_hlbU A.
7. I'I.R.C,I'. 4007,1(11) p(IlVidll1 flit Itw dl.'p(lIIIUoII of . corpotAl1I follly
wtwt...by Ih. ('(lrp4IIAllon 11111111""1'" OIW (It mllrv of lI,offlclIII, dllllclon (It mAMlIlog
"!ClInlaltl tlltlity. l:iCllI'.RC,I', 4001,1(11).
It, 1'lIlntlff hu fAilvd hI rom ply wilh I'.,R,C,I', 4007,1(0),
9, l'a.ltC,I', 401: plllvldlll thAllhb Cllutl mAY, upon mollon by " p.rty
Aod flit 'll\ld (AU.. .howo, "mak. Any ordllt which lu.lke ",qui",. 10 pt(ll,d A p.rly
1111~,.un hum unrvulIMbl. .nnlly,u\(lI,lImbnt...nwnl,lIppt4lnlon, burdl/n Ot
..-pr,,"," 1'.ltC,I', .wI:,
. , .
HJ. fl' pt'f1tlit pJjIOlllf k' Wfl\'\4,t IIw dt-fi'tiItk,,,,, "!I ~I ,,"th In Ihf NvH{~
AIIA'twd Iwrtw it r,thlbll ^ wli4tJli ,,,"'" Uf\ff"a(INP'* Afwty.no', tll4n~ft.~
IItJ~f\lltJ IU Uol)' Spllll 'kllt!,I"'!' ""If"''''''' IIw 1'llllfl4lt1Y (If Ihl. IMI\'id",,~ IIOOlIhI
III tJ. ,t"JiI..a by plAlnllff II fwinwf ,,In.nl 1l(1Iltktly W If,d '0 Itw li'''1t\''')' (l'
Adml..lttlf IIvkkl\{.,
11, Aft:1tfdln.ly, Ikily ,pili' 1\.pitAII_ fntlllfd kt if Pfllff,1tV' "'..
f1u,.","1 kl rAke,I', ~U INt ItIt .l"ttU14m' ...~ Il(JS Pf "tnl'~ 'M ttwl
plt1lrtlltt th4..,W In ltw M\If." ffq~ kt <<,",ply with r. ker 40011('1, t(lllw
,.ffnl lhAllM mtlffMltly il4IlAJIU by pJjlntlf' It ~lK1l\'fI,"'l(l 14Mff Iftf 1't1W7lnf\i,t
Mulft III Civil J'fll(.dU(f
lJ, In ItIt ,,*,Im ktwffn Uw ,~ Jlf IN. ~ ",.. AII,mlt, ,.,
ttlll)' ;plfll IIl.pi.., f~'" INllNt (ilY" tY)' Itw lftJ'l"flllfll In ItIt fVtftt INt 1M
mtln.. ()f IN' ffMitlon {Iflfllll " ,u'fw1t J'fl'lf kt ""'I dAt41,
WUtlIUtK1IU~, ItllI, iplfll IktllJllYI ,~ttWlY HIl1lMlttt lhil'" fWft fflfff'
priJl<<t1n 01.' p\uflI.Itlt k' r. K.cr ~m rll~~ ttw ~mw whtrdWtd It"
.'. ~
I\lllll,,1 II, ,W', ..~t MUttr llullhl, ,'o'lfl 'IllY "U rr\l\'w~IIIl&' m",,"whll\lln tlw
'\'fnlllu' Itw mllrlll ot Ihll mulll", ,,,nl\,,1 "" rllad,,,d prim hI llul d"lu,
1W.~\'lfully .ubmllllld,
MIlTfH, IiV ^NS . WOOOSILJIl
Py: ..-
St, 1\ . Snyd\'r, ll"'l" II,
tiu . Ct. I. 1.). IIJU.H ,
I. 11011 1(, W"lfll"nac, Blqul"
tlup, Ct. I.P, "ft207ft
3401 N,tr'" fronl Slr",1
r. O. Ill", 5950
tbrrlaburlC' 1'1\ 1711().(W5(l
(717) 11%.5(lOO
AlIlmwy. fltr LNf"nd.nt
Uuly Splrll Uoaplt.'
PATI; Au,",U, I"'
., .
f._II.
'If}
J.l U lA''.
I IN T"I CO\lJT or COMMON I'UA'
1 CVMIIJLAND co., 'I"N'VLVANIA
I
I CIVIL ACTION - tAW
I
I NO. .,-all CIVIL TIRM
I
I JURY TRIAL DlMAHOIO
tiQTICIQ'pIPO.I~ION
01 M.~lcal Dlreotor or Chllraln 01 raef,lnay Mletl,lnl
o.part..nt 01 tloly 'phlt tlolpltal
0/0 .t.v.n D. .ny4.r, I.qulre
M~TTI, IVAN' . WooD'IDE
3401 North 'ront 8tr..t
P.O. !SOle llUO
tlArrhburQ,'" 17110
ICItARP W. JWUlAY,
PlAlntift
v.
IOLY IPIRIT tlO.'ITAI. and
'1IILLI" )\AQUIRE, H.O.,
Deten4lnt.
p~A~e TAKE HOTICI thlt pur.Ylnt to 'I. R.e... No. 4001.1, .1.1n'11'.
In the .bov,-oaptioned .atter "Ul tlke thl d.poI1Uon ., 'hi ...d,..l
luotor or Chat",a.. 01 l.u,'DOl ...dtohl D.p."..." ., ..11 .,h"
olpl hl upon oral llealllnaUon. tor the PUf1)o" 01 eU.oover)' or for u.. .t
rial. or for both purpo"'l bltor. I p.non .uthorlad \0 reOOn IIn Qlth,
t the lIIW ottlcn ot Anq: no . Rovn.r. P.C.. UO) North 'font IU..t,
ludabunJ. rlnnaylv.nil, b.Qlnnlnq at "00 .... 011 ~\l"\l" '1 Uti. (in aU
Attn. not prlvlhq.a whlch are rehvant and ..t.rld to th_ h'l,\lI .,,,t
uoi,et ~.tt.r lnvolv.d In the .bov.-o.ptlon.d .otlon. Th. apov"nl~la
lod v ldu.1 11 requnted to app..r .t the dor...ll1 ti.. It \til .t.o.....
ddr... and .ubalt to exa.lnatlon under oath.
Pl.... br1n9 v1th you the tollowln91
1. The or191n.1 ..dlo.1 oh.rt p.rtalnln9 to ~loh.rd ,....yl an4
2. The or191na1 R1chlrd D't.uo., H.D.. plr,Qnnel tl1..
ANQINO , ~OvNtR, ~,c.
~~{::ll"""h.'
410] North rront ~tr..t
Harrhbur\1. l'll'lfjlylv.nla 1"1ll0
(117) 2,.-UlH
Count.1 tor 'lalntitt
4t., July 20. I'"
:01 Miry Ann .tl11, Court ~eport.r
n.U/IU
JJ.. l~ I''; ·
1/.
I 1M TNI eovn 0' eoMMON f&.lM
I CVM"ILAMD eo., 'CNN'VLVANIA
,
, CIVIL AOTIOlll · LAW
I
I MO. "-"1 CIVIL fIlM
I
I JVMY TIUAI. "'KAlfUID
H'Ii,MIP W. MM'A',
,t.l",'"
If)I-V "unT ..onlTA&. 1M
lIH..I.'" MA4Ulkl. M.O.,
o."M'"''
~ICI Ot QltQllflAH
(Ii M.altJ'l DhMU, ., hi)' .,1'1' 1t..,lUI
c/~ IllV'" O. 'nV4'f, J.~lf'
M~~ff, &V~. . WOOp"~'
l401 "~f\h fftn' ..,..,
to,o, (In UU
l!.ffl..Yr~. tA 1111~
"I.un TAJl N(TfICI ,,..., fUUI.I."' " ". ...e.p, "e. 400'.\. PillnU''''
If. H... iil>lit".."IIf'tl@,," ..U.f vUl Ull. il\. ..,..IU'" ot In. M.....,
lhu.., .t ..1, .,hl' ,,,,UIl 1.1"" (lnl ....1M\10n, tor ,.... flirf"" (if
11.;;(0".')' lif lOf 1.111' .. "hi. Of fn ~th 'ijffO'U. ""if' I fU'{ofi
,.~lM'fh.lt \t:i nn4.f Al't o.t". 't 'hI IIw out".. (,i AnqtMJ' l@V"ar. f.C,.
te,. NI'Ht, tr",,\ llU...t, If<lf,htlufQ. I'tI\fl'rtvAnll, t>.tflnntll'lIU &t,.......
A A~~~.\ It ".., .n all ""'f' "(,ii pr vlt~.a w"ten If. fl'lvAnl 1,.4
.t.rl..l \~ t~. "IU.' .r>4 '~~"Qt ..ii.f 'r.v~lv.4 in ifi. '~QV'-@'f\lpn.a
p~If;>", 1M. .irf,iV."'f>AlIIi.a lMlv1dw.' 1. rtf,iJUUII to .,.,..u Ii H,.
frilUi4ilt ..... U tnt ilto~V. .aaru. Iml ."".1-' tu uulliUh.n wndff ",Ui,
rl.I.' ~f1~ wlth f~W tn. '~11~'~1
I, fhl ~'l9'A.l -.41@.1 tn.rt ,.ri.tnlnt ,. Mlfh.,4 I'."YI .nd
J, Th. .'l'&fttl Il.na,4 ~~" ".P.. f'f.~nn.l fll..
ANOI~Q , lOVu~~, t.c.
111. ~tb~t~~-
I. P. /f.ulfJ,.
.'Ol "4rlh tr."' 'ir..'
".rr"~ijr~, ~'h""y1v.nl. 11'10
(H1) Ht"4YU
Cyyn..l t~f t141nlltt
~,., Jvl, 20, 1't'
'!,iI H4,'f AM nUl, "~n J<fl"lnn
v.
1 IN Tttl COURT or COMMON '&.IA.
1 CUM'IM~D co., 'INN,YLVAHIA
I
I CIVIL ACTION . tAW
I
I HO. ,,-a'l CIVIL TIRM
I
I .w(llY TaIAL DCJWIOIO
lCHARO W. IWCIAV,
P1.lnUrr
IOI.Y IIPUl1T "OOITAL Ind
IUL1.1' MAQUUtl, M.P.,
Def.n4In'.
KQrI~1 o~ QltplJTI9U
01 cto/pre.lden' of HOly .plrlt Ho.pl"l
c/o 'tlv.n O. gnyd,r, I.quir,
MtTTI, IVAN' . WooD.lol
1401 North front .tr.et
",Q, POlC nllo
IIlrr1lburQ, I'A 11110
VL%AII TAKE HOTICI that purlu.nt to PI. (II.e.,. Mo. 4001.1, ,l.1ntltt.
In th. Abov.-olpUon.d ..nn 11I111 t.k. the depo.1Uon of 010/,,..1'1'" at
oly .plrlt 'o.plt.l upon or.l ....1n.tlon, for the purpo.. or dlloovery
lr tor u.. at trill, or for both purpo.." betor. . Plr.on authorl..d to
. .ndllr In oath. at the 1111I ortlo.. of A091no , (IIovner, ,.0., 400) Horth
ront ntr..t. H.rrl.bufQ, 'Inn'Ylvanla, bl91nnlnQ at 11100 .... on AuqUlt
, 1"', on All ..ttlr. not prlvl11Qed which .r. r.llv.n' and ..t.rlI1 to
1111 luun and lubjlot ..n.r lnvolv.d In the .bova-cAptlone" AcUon, The
. bove-nAIII,a IncUvldull 11 uqu..tld to .ppear at th. .ronuld tlllI' at the
pov. addr..' An~ .up.1t to ....In.tlon und.r o.th.
1'1.... br1n9 with you the tol10wln91
1. Th. orl91n.l .l4lc.1 ch.rt p.ri.ln1nv to Rich.rd ft....yt .nd
a. Th. orlqlnll _Ich.rd D.Luca, M.D.. per.onn.l tl1..
AHOIIIO , MOVllrR, P.C.
~r~~"
I. D."O 6UU
410) North rront Itr..'
U,rrllburQ. "ennlylv.ntl 17110
(717) 2U-6791
Coun..l tor 'lalntitr
Oat.. July 20, "~'I
c, Huy AnA .UU, CO\Irt ~portlf
'l~n/\ u
II 'i.'" ,
\~ ,.>. '
I CIIMW W. JtAMIA V /
,1.lnUII
I IN THI COURT or COMMON PLIA.
I CUM'C"tAMO co" ,fNNIYLVANIA
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I NO. "-31' CIVIL TlfiM
I
I JURY TJlIAL DeMANDeD
v,
IOl.V Iilt'UlIT HOII'ITAL .nd
. 1111.1.11' MAQUlftI, 14.0./
o.,.I\4.nu
tmlCl JU DUPUTWf
1'01 Ph'.ilUf.' 'trlOnn.' ., H,'V .,"1' HfI,ll..
QIU ".vln D. ,"yd." I.qvl'.
Mtnt:. rvMf' . WOOOItOI
1401 WUfth front "f.lt
".0. loW "to
H.rrt.bufq, fA "110
I'lsA_r TAM~ NOTice th.' pur.Utn, " ,.. ..0.', Mo. 4001.., '.,In'l'''
In thi .~~y..~.p\'on.d ..'t., wl.l t.ke 'he d.p..l".n ., 'h. Dif..'" .f
','.0...1 .f .'" .,1'1' 1..'1'" upon .,a' ....1".".", '.r tho fYfpw"
It at'Qwv.ry or for u.. I' ""', or ,or ..'h ,ur,..." ~,'or' I p.r1wn
ythQr...a to "nd., In o.th, .t 'he ,'V "",.. 01 Ant'"" ".v~r, '.e"
'101 l4urth rum" It,.... "Ufl."""., rennly,nnl.! ".,11\""'" .t UU. ,...
ft au~u.' '1 ,.." on I" ..'t.r' not pfIVl'.~~ w~loh .f. ,"IVi"' I~i
.urI,,1 '(:I \tI. ,..U.. .nd .IiD'"' ...nn lnv,'vllI in 'h. "t>QVfj"...iIlf.U"".lt
u\ lpn. 'lh. .k,.pv..nu.4 in41vidu.l ,. u'fll..t.4 '0 ."fI' A' HI'
r"u....11t \; I". A' \t,. a'flve .44f... .114 '\It>l!lh 'll nuhu,U~;m \loon (l"th.
~I.... ~f'ftq vi'h rO" 'he 'o'l~ln'l
1. the 0'1,1".' ..al,'l gh.r, ,.".lnt"9 \, "l'hard .....yl .114
J, Tne .'1,1"., Milh.rd Ot~Q'1 M.O./ p,r.,"",' ,lit.
~-;:r1):~I",~:'Q'
fF(t~ . I"' ; ''l\* f' T
h O. Nfl. .....
(101 NOf'h ff'"' ."..,
"'ffi,pur., f,nn'Vlv,",. "110
e1l1) nl-nu
e~At.l 'ff 'l.in,i"
}4hl July '0, un
'1,/ I Ktry AM .ll II I. "",, ...,.,..,
~Hj,"
I
c'.~I.leAT' O. I'.'IC.
I, Lort A. 'hlttO, .n ..ploy.. of tho llw flra of Anv1no , Rovner.
.c., hereby o.r'lry thl' I tru. Ind OOfrlot copy or tho torl901n9 Hotic..
t V.f@lttton VI' ..rvld upon thl followtn, p.r.on by f1r.t-ol... United
-till' ..11, POltl" pr,pl1d on ~uly 20, 1"0, .1 followl'
.llv.n D. .nyd.r, l.qu1r.
HJTTI, IVAN' . WOOD.fDI
l401 HQrth rr~n' I"..t
r.o, to. "'0
"Irtl.bur" 'A 11110-0"0
tJlIll\)lt I
"",,'tit..... ..Hit.
~....,,,,,h . . ~4...4
..I....' ........
pu""'. _.4< f
,tI... _ .h.....
l4:'''.' ,...a..;..
.,I.~""" .. ~i .......
,........ " o,llloff
,......... ~ "'iui"..ot
.,t.,....ltt ...{~U
..,.,,',."nU... l.~IiI-"".
"Hi' .,oIi-.U
...."./.. 11 Jot.'f';'r~
...".U.1. .. .t.L.f.o
IiA
~
..
J'""1'''. "VAN'" . "'......"'"UI
.. "f-4.''''~''' ...........t,......
An".""" "" I,."
i.., ".."," ......., '1"*","
.. lot ....t ....
~"III...I'.... .... IIt"-
UH....
....,. .......~I.
"'-
~.,.,.,~
...
- ... ....
......
.. .......
.~"'f . MtNU ..
'''044 ~ ~f
"...U J .....
to,..,. 4 .' W*~If.
,,\.if' .....yt.h..
........ . "'.
I.U.... ...ji......,
l-i4f'" I ..."....
,AtWw' ."-.~4"
-- -,..
.."'...'" Ii ~....._
.....,~_......
M"H..... Ai ~if'-~
. ",1.U." .. u~....
"~#.."4411''''''''
Jllly atl, I,M
1\<<1,111 J r.!iUltlla, KIllYlr.
MIl/Hltl , IWvIl.'
,gO;1 N,.r\n rf{i!I~ lItf"'
llml.llltrJ, PA 11110.nOl
Ii".., f(<.l.iff
K.
CwA'1 No, M<2t1
I jilt' r~i.td 10\1' .GUm .t tt.ptlIllwftl. MtIM' ,"...,.iioM.t "" Il\fttkl'
Ilil"dl'( Iff tt..drmIR r.t ,mtr"M1 mfldiflft4llt tI(l1y 'pln, IlotpIt.II, tIlf llIfItlo14ltM\(lf
<<t 11<<lt tif.lrlt lw.pU81, Ill. C~(JI"I"Id.8' ., IWly8,ifl\ 1~(iIW. u4. thf 4ir~. Hf
!,.'....mu' IIf t\(fly tII(fttlllltl.tp'Ia' tw vllriwt tilMt fA Au"", t. l"t, AA 1~ ktww, W.
,hit. Wllilj fI..~ ,1.MId 1ft ..lvl"K4l wUt. m1 (J1I\f4I.Ad , 11m Wf1Wtt ~ I"m )'OU I"i , PI
hi,l it~...14"llJ l'fI ~It., Itit"" 11l1rt....y klV4l 1ft .,,,,,,,.UuA ..I;..t\lltd 11\ addlUolJ. 11\...
hl,1 ,101 ball IIn ""pIilll<<lhy kl fI'''I..i Ihf IlIdlridll.l. W~ ..","11\(18' )'(l1i hn. "(tiiml,
\,..111 i. fl'flilinlY \u\flJiUI,IlIM. Wt "{Iff' In., IhMtlndlrullfitJ. W\l\Ik! ~ avaa.t... .ft
"wi, .hl.,1 fj(4i<<J. ,inn ,_..If ~llWh' .i IMy 1I{lI,1\ ttu.plllil. hit .iUI'rl4Il1. ,....i)'\l\I
...,,1" 1.1.1 wlUlfl, \(l "..Dd if; 1t....ll\4lvlduiil. ,... litlllll ~".)'..t ,\vl(\, ill.", M
"1'1,/f(\iH\lIY ta J"lfYhh, YIiIj wllt! Iht.t loA width ,Iii')' In IIY8II..IoI, 1/\ il\y t..nl. iM
,j",,,,II\\M,1j fMm.i iil"- J>llIfof 1..11.. {It Utt """if I 1ft my fil>>idllki,
I ft....'Wf\ ,,", fi4l4tDi\y .t 'lllIf '~8' U'tIt. "'~IW.., I wwld .pp,..litl4l lilt
J"t~ Wl,I..1ft .., m. koow wli1 )'/1" W,llt Ii It Ii......." III a.ptIH i'" fwt lrtdIYidMt.
tillMfftly,
;f!;,;; n ..,....
~tM'J~
I rerllly I"'" I.u" thl. 4tay ""'I\'lnl a ('upy Ilf the flrell"lnK durumcnt uplln Ihc
pl.'ltlun and In t"" manner Il\dirall.'d t>I.'IIlW, which ",,'rvlrl/ ..U.flelthl/ requlrl1menll uf
too I'enmylvanl. Rulli, III Civlll'(\Jfedurl.', by depu.itinl& it r(lPY llf liame In the
Unllelt SIAl,,' Mail, tt.urlwufK. 1'...n"aylvanIA, wllh firat-da.. plllltal&'" prepaid, AI
flllhlWli:
Rabin J. MAr~l/lIa, r.,qulr"
A"ICIOO .. Rov""r. r.c.
.503 Norlh front Strnrt
t"rrlabu,.. I'^ 11110
MUTTII,liVANS" WOO[)SIDB
lI)'l
Jay n It WIlIf"anl&, Hli
Su . Ct. I. O. .fl201fl
:HOl Nurth 1'(\lI\t Sln.ltt
I', (1 11(1\ '115<1
ttArrI~t>urlC, I'A 1111().(l'I5{)
(111) 2J2,'IlOO
Auur",,)'. fllr Ollf,ndllll
Huly Srlrlt tbritll
l>An ^up'." 1m
r<'
~r
.t
-
{\
"
II
<-l
I'
J
_ ; Jr.
"",=.(:.1
;~ ;.
-~j
..'"
~
Ir#
',,~)
1
I
.
.J
~-~
,
V,
I IN T"I COU~T or COMMON .LlAS
1 CUM'IALAND CO., PINNSYLVANIA
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
: HO. cf.f ... ~ ,v / (( t",:i 1"HrhV
I
I JURY TMIAL DIMANDED
JtICUARD W. WlAY,
PlalnUIt
IIOI.V IPIMIT HOAPITA&. .nd
I'IIILLIP MAOUU!I. M.D.,
Det.nd.nt.
U01'ltl
YOU UAVE IIUN IUID IN COUltT. U you wl.h to d.t'nlS aQaln.t
the ohi.. lit forth 111 th. followlnQ p.,... you .u.t t.k. .0Uon
wlthin h.nty (30) d.y. aft.r thi. Co.pl,'nt .na HoUo. art ..n.d,
I-V IIntninQ a wrltt.n .pp..uno. plnonaUy or by .ttor.n..y .nd
rll1n9 In wrtt'", wlth thl Court your d.t.n.. or ob,.atlan. to th.
cl.'.. I.t forth 'Q.'n.t you. You ar. w.rnl4 th.t lf you fall to
Ita .0 the 0... ..y proo..4 without you ana a jud9..nt .'V b.
.nt.r.~ 'Q.tn.t you by th. Court without furth.r notlo. far .ny
lon.v 01.,.-4 '1'1 Ch. Co.pl.,nt or for .ny oth.r 01.1. or r.l1.t
Ulluut.IS by the .1.11'1" rr. YOll ",y 10.. Mon.y or prop.rty or
lither rlQhtl "parhnt to you.
YOU IlItOUW TAIlI Tltll 'AI'IM TO YOO" !.AWYlR AT ONCI. IF YOU DO
NOT ItAVI A !.AWYI.. OR CANNOT ArrOAD ONI. 00 TO OM TII.I'ltO"1 T"I
orflCI ItT rORTH .,lOW TO riND OUT WHIM. YOU CAN OIT LIOAL HIL'.
cQUrt Ad.tnl.tr.tor
Cuablrland county CQurthou..
one cou,thou.. 'quar.
e.rll".,'A "011
C1 11>> 140..,00
v.
I IN Till COURT or COMMON 'LlM
I CUMBERLAND CO., ,INNIVLVANIA
I
I CIVIL ACTION . LAW
I
I NO.
I
, JURY TRIAL DlHANOED
IHCIlARD W. AAMIAY I
'l"nUft
1I0LY I'IRIT HOIPITAL and
l'IULLI' NAOUIRI. M.D.,
Detendant.
tfO'txCI4
IA han d..andldo a Ulhd en 11 oortl. Ii ".t.d fI\IiuI
detendlr.e dl ..t.. d...nd.1 IXpU..t.. In la. p'9ina. .iqulnt'.,
uatad ti.ne vl.nte (20) dlaa da p1.lo a1 partir d. 1. '.oh. dt 1.
da.and. y 1. notitlo.olon. U.tad d.bt fr...ntl' un. ap.ri.nola
..arlt. 0 .n p.r.ona 0 por aboQldo y Iroh v.r en 1. oortl In tor..
..crlta .ua d.t.n.a. 0 .u. objeoione. . 1.. de..nd'l .n oontr. dl
au panon.. I.. avlaado qua .1 u.t.d no .e d.U.nd., 11 oorte
tomlra .adld.. y puede .ntra, una ordan oontr. u.ted .1" pr.vlo
Ivi.o 0 notltioloion y por aualqul.r que'a 0 allvlo qUI e. pedldo
.n la pltiaton dl d'lIIanda, Uated pUld" pardi' dlono 0 .UI
prop'ldadll 0 otro. dlrloho. 'mport.ntl' p.ra u.tod.
LL~VE CITA DIMANDA A UN A~OACO INHEOIATAMINTA, .1 NO TIINI
AI~^DO 0 II NO TIENE 11. OINERO IUrlCllNTI DE PAOAR TAL .e.VleIO,
VAYA EN PIRlONA 0 I.LAHI POR TIU.ErONO A LA orlCUlA C\lYA OlRICC10N II
ENCUENTRA IICRSTA ABAJO PARA AVlRI0UAR DON PI IC VkUOC COM'lOUIR
ABIBTtNerA LEOAL.
court Admlni.trator
cUlb.rlAnd County Courthou.e
On. courthoull .quar.
eArllll., PA 1101)
(111) 340"1200
/HeIIAMD If. fWllAV,
'''l"UU
I IN THI COURT or COMMON I'Ll'"
f CUM'CALANO eo., rCNN.VLYAMIA
I
f CIYIL ACTION . LAW
f
f NO. ~ ", I
I
I JUICV TRIAL O'MAHPIO
v.
/101.'1 .,UIIT IWlrlTA&. .nca
..ltllol.I' MAGUIRI, N.D.,
Oe,.nd."u
Dlt-a111
I
1
I
I
I
I
j
I. ",inUff, ..",hull W. Il....y, II .n .dllU; ineI\Yhl,,'l
f..ldlnt In N.v C",a>>.,lanca, York C"""'y, ,.nn.ylv.nl..
a. Ai .11 r.l.v.n' il... h.r.in. Qf,.ncalni, tbil11p Mlq",i,..
M, p" .n .4Id' a neUvlcl\it1 , "".n..4 ,. ,..0"41. H41"tne an 'h.
(.'lillllWnw..\\h 0' "M.yh."I., whQ I" lU), "'.. 'f1QI'M 1n ",.
PUQUo. 0' ...r".""y Nell"". in C.., NUl, CuMi.,lanca CQuniy,
... 1111. V a vln 'a.
l. o.r.ncaini ""Iy "hh NO.pU.1, II . Qorpouh .-4'41.1
III.UhIUQR vhh .uau.. .nca iIH'/illl 'l"i"U.. In C.., N"I.
C~M~'r"nca County. tlnn.yav.,,'..
4. Ai.ll r.'.v.,,' U... 1\I"i", o.,.nd.", ....""n, .11
/.hy.l{!i,,,,, I,,"rn., r..hll"h. "\f"", fl4101c;(fll", '''fQI''tiV
ri>~1II p,nonMI .nca .ni' 'M .ll H4alJ.l ,.rtonMl who provided
..alpa' oar. .1\4 'f.a'..,,' '0 NlQhlr4 .....y in January 0' "'},
WI'I '9'1", " '~'"'" Iff' f'''' ".",., .,rvl"" .n4/0f '"&OY'''
f;l' UfI,.Il4I1f1\ 1141... "i,l, 1Hf'l'i,.I, .114 wu. ."U/Wf wl".11\ ,~ 'f"t*
~f kh.', .~fl.V"'" ., ,~. ".. .r "1' ,.,.,
",,"'41"""
I
;
~. On or .bout J.nUAry ~t, tYil, It .pproMt..t.ly 3.J5 .....
rlalnt", Mtchard MA..ay WAe t.k.n by Allbul.no. to Def.nd.nt Holy
llptrlt llo.pttAl 'IInq.ney roo.,
I ., At the .....9.noy roo.. I"h1ntttt w.. Ad.ithd by the
I [l.t.fIlIAnt Holy 'p1r1t leo.pital '.u"lnoy roo. dootor. D.r.nd.nt
!
! ""qulr.,
,
1, At thn U." Plaint! tt, R1ohll'd R....y. cO.plain.d or
"bOQ.1n.1 pl1n wh1ch h.d P'Uhtld tor .pprod..hly two d.y.
b'QQ.ln9 pr~r"'1v.ly wor...
,l, Th. p'ln atUt.d Around hl. nlv.l (p.riuMbiHoIl '1"..) .nd
IIl"Ut'd to the ,iUht low., qUAdrant or ht. .bdoll'n .nd thl
,..tloull' If.. by the ti.. Pl11nt1tr. Rich'rd RI.a.y. pr'.,nt'd to
the o.t'n4Ant Holy 'p&r1t no.p1t.1 '..rq.noy .ld1g1nl dlplrt..nt,
.. In .dd1tion to the P11n. Hr. A....y inror..d OIt.ndlnt
"'''!,fulr. 104 the ''''9.noy roo. IUrt or D'f.nalnt HOly 'phit
Uo'pttAI 'ha' h. had b..n ,wp.ri.noih9 n,u"1 'nd vO.ltinq tor the
.,ut r.w dlY',
10. Att.r Riohlrd A....y'. Irr1v.d It Det.ndlnt Holy 'p1r1t
Ut"pltAl ...r,IMy roo., h. w.. .1I..in.d by o.t.nd.nt H.,u&r.
Mid/or In ',.nt, I'PArant ,.,.nt, ""nnt. Ind/or '.Ploya. ot
P.t.n4.nt Holy Iplrlt Ho.p1tll.
11. Upon Ivaluatton, tlalntltt, A&chard A....y, WI' notld to
b. .'~ijt.ly III 1n4 vrithtn9 in pain hOldinq riqht IQWI,. qUldrlnt
lJt "'batt"n."
a
U. 'Hollard XIIIII.")". viUl .iqnl r,v"I.d a pul.. of '0,
blood pr...ur. of 1.'/13, r..plr.tlon. or 40 Ind t'"p.r.t"r. of
..... orllly.
lJ. '''V.loll 'Nt.ln.tlon r,v'll.d d.or....d bow.l .ound. with
t.nd.rn... Ind 9"'"r41n9 ot the rlQht low.r qUldr.nt.
14, During Mr. .....V'. .uy In o.t.nd.nt Holy 'plrlt
lIo.pltal ..nq.noy 10011, hl1 plln WII 10 tl(or",01IUn9 thlt h.
r.quirla tour do... or n.rootlo ..dloltlon. lntr.v.noullv.
II. "ow.v.r. the p.ln "dloltlon n.v.r oO'Pl.t.ly rlll.ve4
the Pl.lntltt'. p41n.
U. Monov.,. nArootlo ..dleIUGn WII eontralndl"It:.d b.o.u..
it ...k.d the .I,n. and .y.pt:oll' .'1", 'V,IU4ttd, l.p.41nt prop.r
........nt ot Hr. R....V'. oondltlon ao4 pr09r...lon.
11. OUrlng Hr. .'..4r" 10 hour .tay In Dlf.naant Holy 'plrlt
lIo.pltAl ...rt.noy d.parta.nt, YUlou. dla,no.Uo hltt "u.
p.rrOrNa.
I'. 1I...tolO9Y .tudl.. r,v'llad IIIVltt4 woe at 1).' With In
.1.VAt.d leg..ntal n.utrophll Dount 0' 1..
II. R.nll tunotlon atUdI., Ind an IV' wlrl nor..l Whl"h rul.d
out th. kldnlY, And urinAry trAgt A' thl .ow,.. of tn. '19n. ana
.y.pto.. Mr. R....V ~.. ..p.,I.RQtnt,
30. An Ab4oainl1 ott,trUQUv, ..,t.. of ""ny. werl 11'0
int.rpr.t.d II within nor"l lialt..
31. 'lalntttt, "lun.ta .....Y'. phy.lu41 .y.,to.. lna t..,
re.ult. ~'r. ooo.i.t.nt with tn ,out. ,ur~lQ'l '~"n.
)
l ~ , lfOliftlV6f, 0.. t.'IIl<lnl ""'Jill r.. ,nul/ur .n 4lJ(fltl, "1'1'.HlOnt
.'lllllt:, ..rYAnt Ifld/Of ur1loy.. of P.f.n~Ant: !l01 y Ilfll tit: IlIlIlJIH II
11 hI not onltr Of obUlln III ."rl,lled QOIIIYlut!on prior to Mr,
k...IV'. dl,oh.r,_ tro. th. ...r"nov roolll.
U. o.f.ndlnt NaQuin .nd/or .n .9Int. .pp.,.nt IQlnt.
nrY/IIot or ..ploV" at Def.odant Jlgly .phi\: Jlg.piUl di.ohuql"
rl/lllnt:llf Mioh.fa R....y ho.. at Appro_i..t.ly 10110.... th.' ....
(11llV wlth . di."no.i. ot .out. Ana IIvne nnal ooUo.
34. A' the ti.. of di'oh.rq., o.t.ndant MaQulr. .nd/Of .1'1
il"lfnt, IIlfpulnt ."nt, ..rvant or IIIploy.. of Del.odant Holy 'pirit
lfIJII.'lhl told Mr. ......y 'h.' hI gOllla do nQthlnq IIIQ,. 'Il.n ....
th. pain until tll. .tona p...Id.
30. Upon diloharQ', Hr. .....y ~.. ,iv.n . pr.,orip'ion for
l'yl"ngl with H4lth~. an4 in'tf\UolUClnl to OllU Pf. 'rva,noio, ..
urglaqil'. if hi. 'YlllptO.' p.r.i.'Id.
U. TVhn91 Wa" goo,in. WII "ntflln4io.'Id bUlu" " ...h
HI. Iit"l ."" .y.,t.... tll_t ft,"" u tI. .".}WI'", I.,"i", 'f.,...
A..,....nt 0' M'. klI..ay'I ooftdltion 1114 protr"'lon.
31, ro'I&~int di'~ll.r,., Mr. M....y did, in t.Ol, t.l.phon.
Ill'. h\.ld'Mio.
U. Nf. k....Y IntoraH 01'. "l.I44J""IQ tl\at h. M4 illn
dhf,JfllltM at "tvi"" . kidn.y 'UM W o.f,""ln, Nt"Hr. n
l~t.n4ant. Hoiy .,Ifit Me.,i'I' .Ifil., 'kit ..'nlnt.
n. Mr. ......y '..v..," '''."'I1f '111'1 -.4lf'U," ".. Or.
tJ.wkrwhl,
I
I
I
!
i
!
I
t
30. 1I0w.ver, Or. I'rudlnolo advl..d Hr. ltameay thllt hi would
bl unllb1e to prl.oribl any pain mldiaatlon .inol hi h.d nlVlr blln
advl.ld ot hi. ea.e by Oltendant Haquire. nor had he .Ia. him in
Ddlndant Holy Spirit 1I0.pital emlrQlnoy rooll.
31. The to11owinw day, at approximately 2130 p.mq Plaintitf,
Richard Ram..y. returnld to Cdendant Holy Spirit Ho.pital
Imlrqlnoy d.partm.nt with continuld complaint. ot 'Ivlre abdominal
pain in the riQht 10101.1' qUlldrllnt.
u. Upon evaluaUon by thl emerqlnoy roo II phy.io1an. Hr.
nameay 101.. 11lll11.dlatl1y dlaqno..1I .. .utterinq tro. rltrooecal
rltral1.al applndioiti. wlth plrtoratlon and plrltoniti..
33. Plaintitt, Riah.rd Ra..ay, WI' illllllldiatlly tlkln to thl
oplratinQ room. wherl hi wa. tound to b. .utterinq tram a rupturld
rltroclcal rltrol1e.1 applndi~ with an ab.c... and p.rltonitl..
J4. Du. to thl rupturl Ind thl Plrv..tvl nature at thl
plrltonitl.. Hr. Rlml.y undlrwlnt mOI'l l~tln.ivl lurqery with .
lrIvaql at hl. lnt..Unl and hi. abllomin.l oavity. with pllo...nt at
llrge draln. in thl riwht lower qUldrlnt.
3S. Dul to thl .Iverlty at Hr. R....y'. condltlon at the tlme
ot lurq.ry. hi. po.t-oper.tlve cour'e 101.. .tormy.
36. Athr In eivht day ho.pitalh.Uon, Hr. ".m..y 101..
di.ch.rqed ho.e on or.1 .ntiblotio..
:n. Mr. R....y'. noov.ry 101" .10101 dUI to thl dllay in
diaqno.lnq app.ndloiti. .nd the lub.equ.nt rupture with the
d.vIlop..nt at perltonltl..
I
ll. Due to the d.1AY In dll,no.lnq .pp.o4lol\l" th.r. WA' .
.ub..qu.nt ruptur. 0' the 'PP'Mlx with the dev.lop..nt of
Ab.e..... and perltonltl. .nd I olel. II al4. there tor.
)I. PU. to the del.y ln dll,no.tnq .ppeo4lotU. Ind 'h.
.ub..qu.nt rupture with the d.v.lop..nt of p.rlto"ltla. plllntltl.
"lchard "....y, 11 now It In tnor....a rllk 0' dlvlloptnQ tntr.-
AbdoMln.l lah..lon. .nd/or bowel ob.truo'tone for the r...tnder of
hie 11'. .nd . ol.t. ta ald. ther,'or,
40. A.. dtr.ot .nd proMt..tl r..ult Of o.'lo4.nt.'
n..,& l!Jlnol II .UI".d ner.tn .1\4 tflfG'pOU'.a by r,'nlnol.
Va-lnUff Richard If. .......y hu .uU.,1d p.runt"t Ind ..v.,.
lnjurl.. .nd . 01.1.. 1. ald. \herl'or.
41. o.l.nd.nt. Holy .,trh Ko.pl..l .114 tMUt, "',uh..
M.O.. UI jointly .nd .evn.Uy ".tlle tor tM lnjurl.. .nd d...,..
u .., torth h.r.tn.
U. A.' dhag, ana "owt..,. ,..\,iI' 'if o.tln41nu'
neqtl'IRQ', 'lalnttlt, "toh.rd W. .....V, .ul'.r,a . ,.,..".nt.
IUIUQ"rlnq .nd tUultUnq In)uf)'. w.. lorQId t@ "ndulI" pail'll"l and
nrh.u. 1M ..Un.lve .\lrQ...t.., Ch. ,,."'."U1\y or re4JUtflnq
..M 1 tl.,flll ,u".,l.. .nd ....,,,., ","Ml'lt II lfwf...Id, .n4 a
Qt.,. A. .-a. th.r.tof.
U. A." dh.t" .nd pf.""" f""" of In. o.rl"'""t.'
nlfflllq.I'l4l'. ".'1'1"". tUlft\IU4 If. o...y, It.. hn'QId 'II &M\l1'
il'~l"tv IOf .-4&".1 'f..C.-nt, ,,~""f" ~'t1.1 ~'peIh"
MJ,uQlr,U, bo.,,,.,,..tio,.,., ,..",ntWf q.... ."" .taU'" atM.U,MOIH
.
I
..pen... tn an ettort to r..tor. hlm..lt to h.alth an~ a olalm i.
."d. theretor.
U. ". . dtr.at: Ind prod.lt. ,..ult or the Det.ndant.'
nOUl1.,.nce. Plltnt1tt. R1chlrd w. R....y. will h.v. r..ldu.l
11rpbl.1I1 for lhl rlllllnd... ot hil Uf. r.quirin9 Idditional ..aicll
tro.t..nt. .urq.rl.. .nd th.rlpi,. Ind I ollim 1, mad. th.r.to,..
41. A. a dlr.ot and proxilllat. ....ult of the Det.nd.nt.'
n0911,.noe. 'lllntlff. Rlch.rd w. Ram.ay. ha. .u.tain.~ I pa.t and
futuro 10.. ot ..rnlnQ' and an implirlll.nt ot ....nln9 pow.,. Ind
..rntn9 clpaoltv and I elll. " .Id. th.r.tor.
... "I a dl,.ot Ind proxi.lt. r..ult ot the Det.ndtnt.'
00911,.no., 'lllntlft, Rloh.rd w. R....y, hi' und... vone Ind will
1n the tutur. ul\4"to ,raat ..ntal Ind phy.tell paln and .uU...ln9.
uro.' tnconv.ntano. In el..rytnv out hi. dillY aot1v1tt.., 10.. ot
lit.'. plo..ur.. and a olat. t. .ad. th.r.tor.
41. A' . dtr.ot: and prod.lt. ""'lIt of the Def.ndlnt.'
n~ltQlnQ', 'latnt1ft, Rlohard w. R....y, ha. b..n and 101111 1n the
future tlo "''''lot \0 flra.t hUlllUIUon .nd .llIbarn"lII.nt due to hi.
IH.tl(jun..nt and .njov..nt Ind I ol,hl t. .,d. ther.tor.
U. ". . dha"t .1\4 prod.lt. n.ult ot the Dat.nd.nt.'
ft.~",.n~e, ".tn\ttt, Mtoh.rd w. R....y, h.. .utt.r.d .or.
-.'.n.tv. IWf.IQa' .o.rrtnq and a o'al. 1. ..d. tn.r.tor.
... 'll'nt'ff h.. "ean advl..d .nd tharator Iv.ra that th.
44.4~" .~ '"'wr'" .,,~.d h.r.tn ar. p.r..n.nt tn n.tur. and a
ul.l. i. ~ ih4r.for.
l
I
I
..,
gQun I
.IOKA,D 11.~~11I J4-l11L~lr ..ggl..~.A4
DO. Pauquph. 1 throuc"h 49 ot thl. co.p1alnt IU
lncorporat.d h.r.ln by r'C.r.ne. .. 1. ..t Corth at 1.nQth.
11. DeC.ndant Vhllllp Mlquir.. M.D. 1. 11.b1. to the
Plalntiff for the lnjuri.. and da.av.. II .11.".d heuln "l\1oh w.r.
dlr.ot1y .nd proxi.al1y oau..a by hi. n'Ql1".no. 1nl
(.) fall1nq to prop.rly .v.lu.t. .nd .x..ln. Mr. M....y
1n a tl..1y f..hlon,
(b) f.lllnQ to properly Monltor Hr, M....y durl"" hi.
.tay ln the ...rQ.ney roo.,
(0) fal11nq to dl.ono.. Mr. M....y .. lufferint Iroa .n
acut. .ur910.1 .Woaen .nd/or .ppeo4101tl.,
(d) tA1Un9 to r.coqnh_ Mr. It....y'. phy'l"al .1"n. .04
'Y.~lto.. .. oon.l.t.nt wah .n aout. .urvl".' .Wo.an .nd/or
app.ndlolU.,
(.) qlvlnq/pr.,orlblnq n.rcotlo Inll"l.lo. ln th'
pr...no. of aout. IWo..n ...klnq 119n. .nd .y.pt~. and ..pt4lnq
prop.r ........nt of hl. ooo41tlon and protr...lon,
(t) f.Ulnll to uOg(Jnh. Mr. .....y'. phy.1oll .atnl .04
Iy.ptall .. lnoonll.tent wlth aoute .04 .,v,re ranal Q0110,
(9) r.ll1nq to tre.t Mr. It....y lor an lout. lur,1"1'
abdal.n and/or app.nalo1tl.,
(h) ral1lnq to ora.r or o~taln . .urvl011 oon.ul"
(1' rall1", to ord.r or parlor. .n l~ln.l cr If,n,
(i) '1111", to ordar or parfor. 'n ,.yl... ,..t,
.
(II) taUlnlJ to order or putor. IUf9UY on Hr. R....y In
A tl..ly f..hionl
(1) Ilproperly dt.ono.lnQ Mr. P....y .. .utf.rin9 rrom
".aut. and .ever. r.n.l 00110"1
(m) laprop.rly dt.Gh.rolnq Hr. M....y ~Ith In.truotlon.
to tollo~ up ~lth Or. Prud.notol
(n) fdUn., to oQn.ult with Dr. 'rud.nolo or .nothlr
urolowl.t prior to dllQh.rtlnQ Hr. M....y'
(0) 1I1vlnt Mr, .....y . pr"Qrlptlon for Tyllnol ~Ith
cod.ln. upon dl.oharlle In the pr...no, ot .n .oute .bdo..ln. ...kln9
.lqn. .nd .y.pto.. .nd 1.p.dl"4 prop.t ........nt or hll condition
I",d JH'alI 1"" hm .
(p) t.lllnq to r,009ol'l the r..ult. of the dl'9no.tlo
Ilhldle. AI oon.l.'.n' wUh .n .out. lurthld .Wo..n .nd/or
"f'('lndlQ1U.,
(II) fdUn" to r'''09nl.. th. woe of U.. with .n
Il.v,ted ."..n'll ~utrophll equnl ot 7. .. eon.l.'.nt Vlth an
Acut. .urQloll aP4o..n an4/or ,pp'ndlft'l"
(r) f.l1l"9 to reoQQnl'l 'hi r'lult. or 'h. di.,no.'Io
.tuttle. ., lRQOnll.t.nt wl\h IlQut. .,v,r. (.n.1 OQ1101
(I) "llyl", lh. 1I&''IOO'&'.nd 'unMnt ot ,,,,"cUoIU.
t.<4lUilll4l 'h, ,up'ur, @, 'h. .,,.ndl. wl'h Ut. lI,v,I.,..nt ot
4V.g..... .04 ,.f'l@nl\l., 104
(t; f.lll", to f'Q~n'" .~ lMf"'~ WIQ, low 9f.4.
hvu, .114 ,i,,", 1000u q;u4f.,., ,a',. II .i,,.. 1M '""toN of
4J",+M'",U.,
,
~a. AI I dir.ot and proximate ra.ult ot Dlt.ndlnt HIouirl"
nlolioano. a. alllo.d h.r.in. Plaintitt hll .u.tlin.d injuril' Ind
damao.. a. ..t forth in paraoraphl 34 throuqh 40 abov. Whioh ara
inoorporat.d harlln by rltlr.nol lIlt .at torth at lan\Jth Ind a
clalm 11 mad. th.r.tor.
WIlEREFORE, Plaintlff RiChard W. Ramny damlnd. jUdo"ant
aq.in.t Phillip Haoulra. M.D. tor damaOI. ln an amount in ewoI.. at
Twenty Thou.and Dollar. ($ao,ooo.OO), .xelu.lv. ot lnter'lt and
COlt. and in .xe... of any juri.dlotional amount r.quirino
compul.ory arbitration.
C:O\lJl'l' ~I
JIOHA\D ,. RANIAY V. HOLY .'IaIT HOI'IJA~
n. Paraoraph. 1 throuoh 49 and count I ot thia Co.plaint arl
incorporatld h.rain by rlflrene. a. it .at torth at llnqth.
54. At all nllvant tim.. hlnln. Datendlnt HI\Julre. all
f,hyalolan.. lntlrn., realdlnh. nur.... radloloQht.. e..r",anoy
par.onn.l, and any and all medlcal par.onnll who provided 011" and
tr..tmlnt to Rlohard W. Ram..y ln Jlnuary ot U93 w.r. 10Int..
Ipparent aOlntl. .ervant.. apparant .nvantl, ..ploya.. and/or
apparant .mploya.. Of Dltlndant Itoly IIpirit Ho.pital Ind war.
aotino within the lOOp' ot th.ir Imploy..nt wh.n proVidln4 ..id
oar. Ind treat.ant.
n. Datendant Itoly lIpirit Ilo.pitll. lotlll9 thro~h it.
aoant,. appar.nt aoent,. ,arvant., Ipparant aarvant., ..ploya..
and/or apperlnt ..ploYI" 1. liabla to the 'l,intilf for the
in'uri,. Ind d'''ge. IlleOld harein which wlr. 41r.ctly .nd
10
11roxtllllllUy CAy.ea bV it. neu1tuencI with rupeat to MlchArtl W.
1i....V by.
(.) r.lllnQ to prop.r1y tv.lu,'e .04 .x..lnt Mr. M....y
in . ti,'ly r.'hian,
(b) r.il109 to properly lon1tor Mr. "....y dur109 hl'
.tAV in the ...rq.nov roo.,
(0) r.l11nQ to 41'9nol. Mr. "....y ., lutt.rt", trOt an
Icute IU'910.' Ab4Q..n .nd/or .ppao4101tla,
(d) I.U1", to r,009nl.. Mr. b...y'. phy.lo.l .t,nt anll
IV.ptO" .. Clon.tlt.n, wtth In IllY" IY1",tol1 IWo.,n Ind/or
app.ndao1U.,
(.) ,lvl",/pr..or1ba09 n.rQOtto Inll,..to. ln the
pr..eno. 01 I"ut. ab4o..n ...kl", .a,n. .nd 'V-PtO" .nd '.pe4109
prop.r ........nt of ht. oonditlon and proqr",lon,
(I) I,Ull\9 te r,oQ(Jnl.. "r, .....V'. phYl1o,I .t,n. .nd
'VllptO'1 .. 1nooll''''lot wtth lIl"utl 104 ..ver. ,.nal oolh..
(9) 'a1111\9 to tr..t Mr. ""'v lor .n 'oUt, ,u"lo,l
abde..n and/of a'plodtotell'
(h) r.ll109 to .rd.r or .>>t.&n I .u"lo.1 ..~"l\'
(1) ,.1111\9 to ord.r 0' p.rto~ In .~~.i~.1 Of lo,n,
(,) l.ill"9 te or4.r or ,.rter. an '.VI... t.."
(k) IdU", to order or ,,,'n.. .\JflllfY @n H,. .....)' ln
. tl.a'V r..nlon,
(l. 1.,rop.,lv di.,~.,", Nr. .....)' " .\i"",", 'f..
-.Q\i', en4 ..V.f. "h4l ~'IQ.'
II
i
i
~
I
I
I
I
(II) hlprt.....rIV IH'H'hi$flJtnlJ H.. k.......y with ""'iPWl: it",.
tv fQllqw Up ~tth Pro ~rYd.oal~1
(n) raHIOI' '0 QQ"ltuli with Or. J'rua"wlo or 'Mtllu
urol~l.t prior \0 dl.v".r~l~ Nr, k....y'
(0; "Vl~ N" M....y I pr.."rlptlo" ror Tyl.nol ~I'h
eva.ln. upon dl'(1hUI,fI In 'hi pn,"nlr?l 0' .n .ou.. .Wo.,". ...klnq
ltlQn. .nd .y.pt~.. .nd j.p.dlR9 prop.r ........"t gf hi, oOndl,jo"
ana pr~r""on.
(PI r.l'IR9 Co ,"Qoqnll. th. '"'ul', o. thl dl.vnQ."Q
1It:ii4lu .. lIOn'lnl"' wltll .n .glih 'uf91"A' .W".." .nd/or
IJ'J'.n4l1l1U.,
(It; II'U", ,. rl"QfI"hl 'hi WJQ 0' U.' wUh ."
-1.v.Cf4 ....."'.1 ","'rephll QOU"\ o' 74 .. QQft.I"""t Wl'h In
II,lU'. ,ur,lol' .840.." .nd/o, ",.11410"1',
(f) '.'11"9 to r.ooqnl.. Chi ,I'ult, of Ch. dl.tno.tl"
.iyal.. II 'noo","""\ with IOU" 'IV.'I r.n.l 0011(1'
('i dllilyl"9 th. d",,",'ll 1n4 h..t..nt Qf '''f.'''''oHl'
l"'lY.1Afl thl f\l,ll.lf. ot thl 1"'114'. whIt 'hi ".nl,pp"' of
.~'P"'" 'AG ,.'lton'\l" lAG
el) till'", '0 f~nl'l 'h' lngf....a WOOl lev 'f14.
hV1!If1 lna fiG'" lown {(\i.d'I"' plln II '1"\1 1M 'y.p,... lif
-r'Vtn4lQ"'"
u. o.ftU-t4Aftl "(Jly "h" ....'ltdl ItH", '''flNt'' It,
.~.fi"1 ""f.nt ~'n'., .ftv.nt'l ',p.f.n' ..rv'""1 ..,lif'"
1I'"UlJf ."u.,., ..,It,)'... a. H.>>lt t. '"' 'id""U' '0' lM
Antl,lf'" 1M 41~'. .U.." Mr.a" Itldlll It.,. CU'MU)' 1M
u
l'rOll 1m" 11 y cllusud by it.. nUIJl1tJunce by the acta ...t torth in
(luAlJrAph. &1 (a) throuCJh ~1 (t) above which lire Incorporated hneln
by reterenoe a. thouqh .et torth at lenQth.
117, A. a direot and proximate reault of Detendant Uoly spir1t
lIo.pit.l'. n'QUIJeno. aa IIU_Qed herein. the 1'1alnt1tt h.. .uttered
injuri.. and a..aqe. a. ..t forth 1n pllraqraph. J4 throuqh 4e above
Which .re incorporatea har.in by ret.renc. .. it ..t forth at
1.nlJlh and a ol.i. h .ad. ther.tor.
WIlERr:rOIUl:, Plalntiff RiChard W. Rallluy d...nd. jUd9..nt
A\I.ln.t Phillip MaQuir., M.D. tor d..aq.. in an a.ount ln .xc... of
Twenty Thou..nd Dollan (UO.OOO.OO), .lCclul1v. ot lnter.,t and
coate and ln .xce.. of any jurl.diotlonal a.ount r.qulrlnQ
co.pul.ory arbltration.
ANGINO '... ROVN,C" P.C.
J) . ,'/' /:' "
"-J(
. ara. a, r.
Ho. UUt
41 J H. Front ntr..t
K.rrllburq, PA 17110
(71'1) IU.l7tl
Coun..l for 'l.lntiff
u
,
I
~~.lrl~'IGM \
I
I
I
I, RICKAkO W, MAM.AY h'r'~y v,rl'y 'h" 'h. r.... ... '.r'h 'n tn. i
'0""0'''' \''(HJ'I,AIl'tt ar. 'flI' .M oo"H' to \t,. i
b..t 0' _Y knovlH9', '"'Qnullo" and MU.r, :
,
I
I und.,.t.n4 that .ny ,.1.. ",'...nt. th.,.I" .f. ald. '~"Q' '9 I
th. p.n.l'l.. 0' l' ,.. C." 1.'0., r.l..l", t. un.v.rn ,.1.1'10"'0" ,q
.uthor'U...
,
/
j~
Iit"?
f't"'"
~
I
.,",
1;
". "1
,.. ~ '1..
~ . ..
~: ,'J 'i
.:J
;i<<~~. ~.
, .~~ - \
~ ,\!~
~j,
tJ -~ t fA
':" \(i i ";)'
· \4
C'
';C'
" '"
..) -
rc ~
.....
,~ .,
'''.V
'd (..t"
~
:':.'e."':':"""'''''';':':";:,;,,.~~
~II
III' Ii
!iH '~
,
.
~,
CIltUlCAtlOf".IUYJCI
I c'rtify ,hit I 1m thl' air "lvinQ I copy 01 th,
foro,01nt docu..nt upon tha p.rlon Ind In the m.nnar
indlQ.taa balow. which I.rvice ..'1'fi.. tho r.quir...ntl of
thl 'ORR.ylv,nl. .ul., of Civil 'rocodur.. by d.po.ltlnt I copy
0f .... In the Unltod l'lto, Mill, ".rrl.bur" '.nn,ylvlnll,
wIth fl,.t-QI... pO.tl". prlplld. I' rolloWl1
'obln J. ".f..II.. laqulr.
Antlno . Rovn.r. r.c.
4102 North rront Itfa.t
Nlrrllbur" fA 11110
"'TTI, IVANa . WOOD.IOI
"1
~d1~~~~')f.~.j_.,,___
.tlv.n P. 'nydtr. .Iqulr.
lup. Ct. I, D. .34344
3401 North rront Itr.tt
P. O. 101 tno
Hlfrl.burQ.'A 17110-0'to
(717) 331-1)000
Attorn'f' for Def.ndlnt
Holy If (It "o'pltll Ind
'hill p MIQulr.. M,D.
'"
PATI. ,.bru.ry J, l't'
v.
, IN TIt. COUIn' or COMMON rUM
, CUM.,RLAMD co., ,INMIYLVAMIA
,
, CIVIL ACTION . tAN
,
, NO. .1-J'1 CIVIL TIRM
,
I JURY TRIAL PIMANPIO
III CIIAMO If. IWCIA Y ,
,lalnUU
IIOI.'t .,IIUT MOIPITAL ,1\4
VHILLIP MAGUIRI, M.D.,
o.r.n4.nu
r&.l~ll'llr '. IIlItQIl.lIAJUItJIIUIIQ.NIQUQlL.U
WI''''l'!ft IIQLl"UWLIQUJ'llIl,UO, IIIUU...."UI....IJD..
I. Ad.lttld. ,1.lnUtf r.h.rn.. .Ioh ,,,,,,.U01\ ., hi.
Co.pl.lnt which .11.,.. th.t thlllp M'Qulr., ",[I" .nd Moly .,1,1'
lIo.plt" n'/JU"nUv ,.UId to "'1."1\0" Mr. ""."V'. oM1Uon,
th.t b.l", .pp.n4loIU.. whloh uUhan.ly 1M to th. rvptu,. 0' M.
.pv.n41x .nd th. dtV'lop..nt of ,,'l'.nltl..
J. Adldttld.
), Ad.lnld.
4. Ad.1UId.
0, o.nll4. ',r.,t.ph. '1('. .n4 (b) 0' th. e..plaln', Wh.n
r.ad In oon'unotlon with the f...lnd., 0' th. Coaplalnt, ... 'ofth
with .p.olttolty th. '.otu.l ...ta .uf'lol.n' to auppe,' . .'U" 01
aotlon .,.1n.t o.I.I\4.nt. "-9ul,. .n4 MolV 'plrl' "o.,lt.l.
I. Ad_lUcid.
1. AdaU;tld.
I. Ad.1UId.
9. ,,"Q,.ph. "CI' I"" ,_. of 'hi Co.,'li"', wa.n "" In
conjunction vith th. ,...1"'" Of tb. COIPllint, .., '.r" wi'.
"M'fIU
I
l
!
I
I
,
I
I
"J'-l3lthJi'y 'h. ,."vtl ...i. "If""i.n\ ,,, ,"ppor' . "'III" @f
.~ltgn .,.in.. Def,nd.ft'. ",,"1r. Ind Hely Ipiri' NO.",.l.
~'pfU'fll"Y 'wP.i"td,
ANGiNa . ~IM, "e.
'.
"".~1Jilt,/r %I/h c
i
I
,
!
r.
QllllrlCa" Qr IllYlQI
I. Olan. A. Lut... an ..ploye. of the law firM of Anqlno ,
Rovn.r, '.e., h.r.by o.rtlty that a true and oorr.at oOPY ot the
fQr'qoinq Plaintitf'. R.apona. to 'r.ll.1n_ry Obj.otlona ot
o.r.n4anu l'ht1llp Naqulre, H.O. and lIoly 'plrlt Hoapital w..
a.rv.~ upon the followlnQ p.r.on by firat-ola.. Unlt.~ .tat.. .all.
POltlQ' prepal~ on ,.bruary ILL, 1911, a. foUowlI
.t.v.n O. .nYder, laqulr.
MITTI. IVAN' . WOODlIOI
'401 North 'ront .tr..t
'.0. low IUO
Harrl.bur9,'A 17110-0'10
a.'~
. ~ "' "
lA ".t
~ 'n..'.
~ '\':
;i.
\':1
,I'
"1'~
;:"
~.{:'
;,'~
>
.. ,~",..".~,,,,.,,, ,,.,,....-
.~
Mil
111111
'ill &
., "',. ~, ," Ir ,.11'<-0 I
'.1.. _
-.
':hAEt'l/'I: H* LI ';Title (^~;E tlJlc AvCIl}1WT
(I1\J~1 I." 1'/lil:..vrltll:1I <Jrlll ~\lI.lHlIl..,,1 III d\lldl~'lijt4ll)
TO TIIY. l'I\(JIII01Hil'^,cY,
.1..., 11,t th. wlth1n matt.r tur th, ".Xl I
(... loe.l ful. ot cpurt
'6 tor pr~p.r forum)
CJ
GJ
(Ch.~1l V",,)
'ft*Tri.l Araum.nc Court
AraUNM couu
~ ~ . . . . . . . . . << . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
CAl'nON or CAn
(I' l_lnU tt)
(CNTlIC& CAPTION MUIT IC .TAUtI 1" fULl.)
"H1Wl!j W. IlIf1MV.
VI.
(Dd.ndAM)
IUt t;l"Ult'f IUlVlTN. ... "Ul4JII Wdllfll, H.O.
v..
.
No. '~4'1 ~lVU .... l'
J,-A ~
1, It.c. "',.r co b, .flut4 (li'" ,1.1nCl"', ~'lon 'Of ~ trial,
ddlndane'. "."nn co c. .inl. .et.) I "-.1""1MIY (}JJwtu.-..
I H (,'(,,,Illiclt.
Z, ldlnei fy 41OY"lfl \rlIo v, U 1f1V. nUl
(.) tor ,1IiOlitH,) I rUilfl oJ. *'HU", ~flil..
_ h__~,
_.
~~
(it) tOf Vd.nd.nU,) I .tI!1IWtft RA..b.11If1 ,Jtlf!\Wf
4
,-.~ =~-~-, .
.--_.-
__.J~l"
(~) tQf Mth'f(.)i-=__~____
.4..
---
-~-<<~-~,'"" ,
~,. __ _ ~~__JL_
_L......;1><-..~._.~_=-__'_.."'__ _ ~_
""""'..'e'.",
~~--_.-
), I wtll nQclty III ",'l., In Wrlll", wich'n two 41Y' t~.. lhl_ q,-.
..~:;;::;;;:t::, :;" "';'~/ ~~~~,
, tJtor.'tt;SAflf
'.~ '4'~~";~d ti~ !::S..'t___ t;~;~~.J.~ ta,fftif
e\;
if
-
"'"
.;. .
,,"..:...-..'i
;:.'1c' :it
r~ ~
~. ~'.)
..~l.il
'"
':N
'.
'"
tJ
ill
tff
;"
RICHAMP W. lAMIAV.
'IItntU'
I IN THI COUNT 0' COMMON ,LIA. 0'
I CUM.IM~NP COUNTY. ,INNIVLVANIA
I
I tIO. n.all
I CIVIL A~'TION . LAW
I
I JUMV TMIAL PIMANOID
v.
HOLY .'IIIT HO.'ITAL
.nd 'HILLIP MAnUIM" M.P..
Olflndlnt.
'MILIMINAMY OIJICTIONA 0'
OI'INPANT'. HOLY .'IMIT IID.'ITAL
AND 'HILLI' ~JUIMI. ".P.. 10
rUINTlrr'. CQft'LAUtT
AND NOW. 00.. 'h. d.tend.nt.. HQly .,1'1' Ho.,t'll .nd
'hllllp ".qui,.. M.O.. by thet, .'to,ney.. Me".. .v.n. .
Wood.ldl. .nd pr.It.tn.,Ily obt.et to plllnti"'. Qo.,I.l"t ..
to HOWl!
I. On Jlnuery ". un. the pl.tntltt fil... .00.,llint
purpo,tlnt '0 ..t torth 0.1.1... ot .otton .q.tn., 'h. d.t,Rdlnt.
tur ..dlo'I ..I".otlol In oonn.ctlon with 0'" .n4 "..,.."t
r.na.,ed to pl.lnttlt. IIoh.rd W. .....y.
HOtlQN TO 11IllI
a. In Count I. pU'Quph. U UHQuQh U. 01 'n.
c(IIli,Idnt, u.. ,hlnUte uti 't.Htll tJh ~h'M I,Il,tI' '",UI,
"'9ulu" M.D.
7. In paraOfaph ~5 of the complalnt, and aubparaorapha
thereunder. tho plalntlff purport. to alleoe neolloence on the
plrt of Holy Splrlt Hoapltal,
e. SUbparaorapha 5~(a) and (b) of the plaintlft'a
compl.lnt provide ea followal
Potendlnt Holy .pirlt Itoepltal, .ctlnQ
throuQh ita 'Q.nt., Ipparent IQ.nt.,
.erv.nta, Ipparent .ervant.. employee.
and/or applrent employee. 1. liable to the
Pl.intiff for the injurie. Ind d.mloe. I'
.lleoed herein which were dlrectly .nd
proalmltely clu.ed by It. neollOlnee with
reapeet to Rlch.rd W. R.m..y bYI
(I) tilling to properly eVllu.te and
ealminl Mr. MamalY In a timely flahion,
(b) tlillno to properly monitor Mr. R.m..y
during hi, atlY in the omoroeney room,
(Plllntlff', complaint. .ubparaoraph. 55 (a) and (b)).
t. Subplraorapha ~~ (a) and (b) of the compl.tnt flil to
.et forth wtth particularity Ind .pecitlclty the tlctull ba.t.
for the alllOltlon. contained theraln Ind, ther.fore. tall to
comply With law and Rul.. ot Court.
aatl,lCATI or 1lIV1Cl
I a..'I'y th.t I 'M 'hi. d.y ,",vlnQ I aopy 0' th.
'o,.,oln, doov.tnt upon 'h. Plr.on Ind In th. M.nntr
\ndlo.'.d billow. whloh ..,vlet l.tl.'I,. th. 'Iqulr...nt. 0'
tna ',nAlylv.nl. aul.. 0' Civil P,ocldu", by alpo."ln, I QOP'
0' I'~ In thl Unlt.d "It.. Mill. "I"l,burl. ,.nn,ylv.nl..
with ,I..t-ol... po.t.,.. p.lplld, ., 'ollow,l
.obln J. M....1I.. .1.""1
An,IftG . .ovn... r.c.
.tOJ lO.th '.ont 't...,
"1,.l,bU". rA 11110
MlTTI. IYAIIt. . WOOOIIDI
IV'
I . : ·
..:.J,.. .'c)J. (
t!:~~~.; ~R&~ i i. ~:~w rf.~"'~~'C"C~'
J401 No,'h "un, ..,..\
.. Q. IIQI ,uo
H...',bu". 'A 1'110'0"0
(111) IU.tOOQ
A'tO'~Y' 10. OII.AI,n,
Holy" I" HQ.",., .A4
,h 1'1, ".,~II', ",P.
PATII r".UIIY./ ".,
RICHARD W, RAMSAV,
PI.AlNT1FI'
V,
HOLY SPlAIT HOSPITAl.
and PI1ILLIP MAGUIRE, M,D,
DeFENOANTS
; IN THI COURT 01' COMMON PLlAI Of
: CVMIIMLANO COUNTY, PlNNIV&,VANIA
.
,
,
: tuatl CIVIL l1AM
14QItDH1.~
~U8J'
ANO NOW. thJ, ,3lh (jl~ of Mate". tM, Iht pI'fflmil'll'" objlC1lont Of
dtftndantt 10 pllintlf,. complain,. Aftl PI'MllltO. I
By tht Cf1,
\~f:
Robin ,J, Matt,,,a. 'ICIWt
For PIalntlft
ehovon 0, Inydff.11CI1Mt
For Otftndltltt
.. ('~I".'
..,.,,-,, .1,'#/~t
If ;'
:tM
Y.
I IN THE COUI'T or COMMON PLIAS
I CUMDII'LAHD co., PENNSYLVANIA
I
I CIVIL ACTION - tAW
I
I NO. ',-all CIVIL TERM
I
. JUI'Y TMIAL DEMANDED
IUCItAIlD W. ltAM'AY,
Plaint iff
1I0LY 'PIRIT 1t01PITAL and
.>IIILLIP MAQUIRI, M.D..
Defendant.
IHtB1 0' APrEA~CI
To the prothonotary of Cuab.rland County.
'1.... ent.r .y epp.arance on behalf of the Plaintiff.
Dat.."()Z(U{~' ~'11, If/~~~'
ANGINO , MOVNER, P.C.
~t~~
a .rln. . MA a y-O.
I.D. 147:1,a
4'0) N. 'ront street
Harri,bufq, VA 17110
(717) aU-6791
Coun..l for Plaintiff
..,,~
t::1:R'l'IUWI..Ol. UlYUI
I h.r.,,)' OtrtUy that. I. Dian. M. Lut... an ..ploy.. of Anvlno
. Movn.r. ~.O.. have thi. al.t day ot Maroh. I"', ..rv" I t.ru.
and oorr.ot. oopy of the MeAICH,. roM INTMY or A'PlAIIWfCC upon
a.t.nd.nu' ooun..1 DY .1001"9.... Unitea "hUI fi,.t-ol... ..U.
po.taw_ pr.paid, .ddr....a .1 tOllow"
.teven D. .nydlr, Ilqulre
NITTI. IVAN' , MODotlO'
3401 North Front 'tre.'
..0. 10. .tOO
Harrilbur,.'A 1'110-0'10
ACCo,nev or Dlt'n4ant. HolV .,i,'t. MlI,t..1 and
Phillip Ha,uirl. H.D. ..
"
I~... ...(,
U' ,:.. \~-niU: /~~,
I
....~
"" '
..
~
,..
#
,
'1
, I
',~ ,
.-'
"'-<'-"-'-~.<""""","", -
~i~
. .
II <<.
..
RICIIARU W RAMSAY.
l'lalnlllf
; IN TItH COLJU OF COMMON PLIlAI OP
. CVMIIURLANI> ('OIJNTY. PfiNNSYI. VANIA
v
. NO IIS."I
ItOLY SPIRIT 1l0SPITAL CIVIL. A('TlON -1.AW
and PIIILLlP MAOIJIIU!. M D ,
Dff'tn411111 IV" Y TRIAL UllMANDl!I)
&wWQrU~D
TO Rklw'd W. Ramqy. PIalntUf
elo ('IIMrint M Mahady-lImllh. f.tqUil'
A/lIlM" Ruvllff. 11('
.UO, North ',OOl IIfHl
Itarritbur.. PA 17110
Y W If. "".by ootllW I(J rlf.l4 IQ ,ht wilhift docvmtnt wlIhift twtllty (20) 41)"
aft" Nn'kf IMrtOt. Of. dtftuIt ju4p1t11t N)' '" ffllfft4 'PAM yOU
Manal. IV ANt A WOODIlDK
fly'
....'" D 111)'.. ~ .
_ ('I I D n"4.
1401 Ntmh "001 811M
, () 110_ '11'0
,lit,... PA 11110<01I40
m 1) : U.'1XlQ
AUIjIJ"'~" All n.f.mtilfl.
I~ "". Iblllll Mti
"""" ~,. M ()
u"n~ Afflt ilL l~
...
IN Tllg COVIlT 0' (~()MMON 'LMI 0'
('VMlllillt,ANO ('OUNlY. ,tiNNIVL VANIA
NOIi~,m
('IVIl, AniON, lAW
IIJIlY TKIAl PIiMANoeo
1l1(~t1AR() W. MMs.\Y,
rlalmitf
BOt Y IPum 1I01'PIT AL
IIId 'Ull,UP MACiUIlUt. M 0 ,
n.ftndam.
ANiWlltl ANt) NliW MA HI," nt Ill1fti.Nll!\N'ffj,
1I0L Y Ilfllllf tlOlJl'1T AI, ANII PlUU.I..
i. 1.AWI
AND NOW, f(lftlf 'M .~., IkJjy 8pl,14I~III11d'_ MafuIr.. M D ,
~ ....1Mf1Wt'.. Mftlf. ~..."'." WWll.... IlI4Ill rt'flOOlt W 1M ~I ~
....ff .. lWluw.
I u.Nfd Aft<< f~ i1w'''ltplWA, .... .,.nd.",.Il. wldlcNt
kll\ftllWtt (af ~ ~ W IPffft . lItIIfr It W 'M 1f\llJ. {If IIw '~<<mflIl' WI fooh
III pM."" I (l( IIw~' ~ IIMI, """.... ..w IUffMlllllff'"
2 ~
1 A/I."II#14,
Q Ptnlfd 'ItIt 1Iltnmlf'( IIl4J thatklfli,"'kltl (J(,~ pWntilfllthllJl)'.
'lltnfllainll. ~If', "Hlll1flll, 'iIll4Uj(lR, Ifld dl'JIII'''' 1f,Ik<nlfd ^ 1001' 'OInpltt,1lllJUfWy
It 'tlllla/MIl 'ft ItIt lllfltiul'ffWdt ~hkh, \Ifill" It,illffl ""'''IJIfI\It, t"ak All I""n"'~"
I (I U,III'" At tl'lf!l II i, adlflllltd 1""1 ItIt pllint!" WII mmitwd ~ Uf
M.p'. llflilll.. lilt pltinlilf "", ~ hi _ity by IIAIfW \If "",!plinn lilY (II""
"'ifill, 'WIfflll '..III, ..tUIII, 1IllII(if flftJlllft'" II( llilty 8plJil lli'-rita/" "IW'''' to ill
..,.,r1J ill ptr.....ph 10, \JIf 4tf~, Iff IIMWt W 'ftplHkt /Unhtt IfId uld ,yfllllfllU Iff
""""" ~
II o.ru.d 1'" ~ Ifld .hatKlfmllklft PI lilt pWmi/1'.Itt~,
~.. ..., Uwmtlll, 'i~ W ~tIt If, iIf.nItd ^ 1OOf. '~f ~
i. ~.jllflf ill lIIt~.. ".tlll" _lIKlt ..., lHIII"'~" .,. Ail I........
I :.,. I~ 1t1t lWflIllMy IIl41 tlw"I"lI.IIf(lft .., I tit ~i/1'.IiI"IIfJ,
~.'Ilf" itff, IfHlItWl'lt, ft~I_1#I4 "'PI"t"f "'Ai'" 1\ tfl(lf, ft.' ltilfl.lllMJ
~ .~tiIwtI /It tlw fNltIHia/ 'ffflf4t It~tt. kiAt \il"flfII...~t, _ WI l~..
I t I,.. An... If~,* /fftlfl!l~ 11M .r.lII1.wt /If. ..~
,~_ ~ /AAlfrw,JllOIi ~1ttfIf.1#. (In"....., .. k~ _ w~ t;if ~ .""",.. ~ ~..
I!!i fill." . 'lit Ik ~ilh ~Ij~.,t...,.. .... ~..... ~ .~ff"""1W ~
Z 1 lJ.nlfll l'ht mrftlf/lll (If ""I,,,'pt! 21 .1. dfftltdllld .1 11M putlKWllIP
Rul. 1019(.) oflh.I',nn.)lv.nl. Mul.. offlvlll'lIKtdur.
22 l>tnled ..Ilalrd II it .dmillfd lhal a lIUI~ul lilll1l1UlI.II(llt Wit 001 ~alMd
bt(IIl,lht rl.tnllff wa. ditd11llled flom the .mtlj&ffWY 11141R1 II II dfnlfd, W lilt "I"
mired or Imrlled, Ih.'llIUllli~.1 ~~II\I\IIt'lilln Wlln<<ft.,ry
ZJ lJ.nltd II Mat'" II i. ad,mll"" .hat Iht pltinlllT wll dlldlllpd ..
.pprOlllllAltly 10 JO. m , bul II il dtnltd .Iu. Ur ttlif'll' dIKhat.. tlw,... ~..
.h, rlaimllf hat fail"'u. idf/lll/y by Mmf (I' d'Kllp!<<llI any (IIhtr .....' IPJIM"If4III.
Ifrvlnl (II ,",ploy". of Ihlly KpUIl UQlpilal """''''10 in f'II'ral ill parlffaph Zt, 1110
d,l'mdantl." unabl,.o Ittllt,n611tl1 1llI41\'ffn\lf1lll/f """"" dtnlfd lilt 1--
mrllllnlllfl fllnh in plfl/ll.ph :u o( lilt plaint",.. ~4.IIftPIainlll' dfftiflI an4 " I....
Il\IrllUlnl W Mul. I02Q(I) U(lht PlMt,lvanll kul,. o(('MI 'f(I~.'
14 o.nitd It It df1\1f4 INI U, MajUifupl,kfllllhe plllflliff' wlwll tlw,&.lmur
WII dltdllfpd 1.~IY..1I11 plaiflllff hAt '.iltd h1lllf/lll/)' by Nlflf (If _lptkln lilt
-.,tnt, .ppllf/ll '''/11, Mlnfllllf fffI,klt'" lit 111,1, ~pIIIIII(lijlitJllttwrt4 '" In. MfIlIIJI III
Pllllftptt %4 ",t tbl pWnIjlf'li(~flt ,'" .,.ffI/4.Wtll" ~ W "~ ~ MI4
wi4 '\ff'JWmt tI. ~4 1'- l\ff,,.t (11,.,'11I" :'IJ!Il/f _11ft w.~ tI.
111(1..,.. 1I"1IIf p1MWIfIt l(t "lilt 1019(.) of I'" '"",t)'tnnll Mvltt ofClvll
"~.t
I' lMftlfd. 1M MIlMIIfY ItI4 dw~1fflulk", (triM pIalnll"" hi..."
~,~.. (.lff, 1f...1Mftt, ~iofl. ~.... lAd lnMMlkmt I"~. It. mort
i~~' ~ II ~.IIIl.iAfllIllIM IllfditIAl'i'f(tf4. "Ilkh. btinlt WliU", dllI1WI1IfJIl.
.,...I\lr ~ft
16 0fRlH lilt ....../MflU /It ,.,.... U. o( tlw pIalmift'U(lmptliRt lit
~ 11I4 II'" pulMI'lt ... U. 10111(.) (It....~.... "uItt /ltCMt "......
11,)(! (,.. Mtf ,..~MlII, 1llt.......iM. IlIt Wt/ldlIlU II' wiItKM
k~Wd,. i.lI k4Aw1lll/l41ft IIl!1tkltm '" Milt I Wl.t It '" tlw IMh /if 1M I"",*""I lit Awlh
III ,.,..,...lJ WflY'- ." toIlht ptti8Illf. ((iIJ1fltillt MIl, IIwftfulf. ui4 IVtrftlflllllffÿ~
, I 1ltM4 It... It *",1f41tyJ .... ",""lIf ,~M4I" t~ .plrit
.~., JIM ~1fIt "" 'N W,I"IM/V Mit. .twlKlfriaIllJft I!f 11M pMjM"'t ...."
~"i'" tJtlt, U~, IH_~ . 4ti~ ~n'" M'" It.".",
I(Im,htf 'IJ~IY lit _6IMfltrw4 /(f ~ ~.t4 ,~4. "'-.., ~ ""~ _m...
~ ~ Ilw.!ltl~
U.U PfIlif4 1M ~ ud (lw~ffjH4l4tft 41ft'" plalmi",.lUtlUf)',
".ifIlI, ~.,.. "fIllMfll, ~UtIt. "~l, Illd Ifi"V~ II' dtNfd ^ lIl4t1t ,~,
~ it fOOl_1ft 1M ~1I1t<<lf41 ~lmh. ~ ~lilllMl ~wntIlt.. ....... fbt
IhlmAthtt Ib w.~ vf l\In1ltf Ift__ff, ,... '\'fflflfllll '" IPtlh in pII'Jf.pht U ''''(Ill''' U
If. ~ ud .. iUllf /IlIftlWt4I{' Mtd. IO:VC.' "(I'" 'fM-.h<am. K4llft "rnvi!
"HIII..
I" A4mlf.1f4
11 IlfRj lilt ....IlWI.. ... AwdIlll ,... n.r_,....,... ...lltt
1f.4tft1t4 u4 Ii i.... pwtllUllllkt.. IO~.) (l(ttw Pmnl)t\'HlI RullI .rCMI
,.~
JI 0tfilf4 lllt .WIt.... ... ~ 1ft JIM."" .. ".,.... ,...urt ~
1ft ... u4 .. liM pllftlllll1 kt M4lIf 1<1:'1(.,,,., m. 'fftMttv.. It/1ft (i( Civil
t'f__.
W<>W I~'''' ~ffl'flf$' Wi tiM,,,,,, JIM~_ Iii Ill#wp.w "tlllt
~. fi_f,,~ .,. ~ ~.. ~".nWiMlf"" ~ 't;1:'iCIJ' qt- ,~..
.. f!I. r...,. 'I~' lw "'ff~' III. ~I_"; 1i<A~ .,",~'
'" I'" ...,1tf4 h ,..4Rllttfl!IMI I)f ~.... WIUII~" tllkiIY
liplm "".111 Pfflll'flllt ptalMilfhlt"" 1I.l4tMI~ ~ IIIIN jjf ""MIll ~ liIlltf
'~"'IIM, IItttfltj, IfWtfltt 11III.... ,~It4..., tfIltf!lffl"~ ptIf~1lIIIfl1ll4 III" 11I4 tit
~II ptftooMt. ,tffUf'J II' III 'lfl""" H "'lilt "-,mjl1't "~, Ihf ~t
If. \I~ lit l~ fWl/lff 11III. Ihff.'t tAllI'\<ffmtftltll' 4"''''''....
''''' I,... lilt '~ffflltf14. wtlbnlt... JIM....,..." 11Itwp thhht
plalft\lITt ~ ,If ~ 11I4 .. iWlf "'1Il1l1. lit .vJ. 1(I:~'llif ,'" ~klllit
"11If('i\;!l '(~.. llv w." (,hilt ftfftlltf IMWff, pat...... ...lltfff4lt *",putllf41
htf.... ~ '''''f/IC' .. It !1ft WIlli III ft.lI
WlIIiIUifOlU:. ...~. IWY '''''" I~ '......".. ~.... ""...,f4I iI
lit r..()f ..... ~1IM1 "" _If ifill \lilt "" ""1IIlft't "-.Ju,lillII "" 41......, ""
".lI!ff
I
~
~
!
t
~,
i
f
,
,
!
!
!
M'll...... ,.., \f'1WoU1. ,.. 0 1fIlI1W,.. tkJtpflal. AI1W Pff It Wltwt
'I
,.,...~ I ""''' " /;Mff,it .,.It/Iil.l#~_ w. lw '"'' M If Nt
~
,
,
,
~
t
WIJ ~. .""
tt 1. _Id'. 'II"""!. ...... ... tIIlf . .......l/{II!ft wtitit ,M fM ...
"tiltH
.0 1M IM*~ ......... ,,~Wttf ftlI, "." 11I4 14"1111' Nff 1M
Uflflflllt klllw plailllilf tl all """* _hilt lit _It . ,... tllllt ~ M4 ~ M tilt
~ IIl4ltt11 "udau' {t( "" f.tIlI (illhfm ill all If",".'
.. II tJw plaIn<<If ~. !l(lfft . ~lAA (If lIIjwritt II IlJtpd. -~ IH
".lll Ni4 wlulilitJfl (if ..,ltt ,....Itf4 Ii_ tllWll'M.ftfft ~.Itftlt .1It f(IllU(iII ftt!tlt
~tllld A>>t _1Ii41t lIIty lit lIi't 'flptJfll4l1. (if ~iN IftIalIY I6IWf
"'.'RAlIly .......
Mint;. ~V.\NIt A WOOOtlOI
Iy
~! . '~"" I
I,', t :"
~. ., " , ,,).~ ~ Vi · ~
I , -, ~', - 4>-- IN:
!ltt\o.11 IllYM, t:....
hf "t I P 'H'''-
1401 ~,,_ .If'"
, () h4 \fitO
I~ M IfIlQdJfitl,t
,1mJll.~
~tItHPt~,
M,~",M()
~ llu/, !t",.. J~
I)A n Af'i' It, ...
YUlflCAT10M
I. Tenley N. Wlllilmlon. vlrlty th.t the Itlt~ntl m.d. ln
the fore901n9 InIW.' Ind now matter whloh .re wlthln the
p.rlonll knowledVI ot tho und,rll9ned. I'e truo Ind COII.ot.
and .1 to the flot. bll.d on th. lnformltton of othe,.. tho
und.r.lvned, Ift.r dllt"nt InqullY. bellovo. lt to bo tIUO.
And harther. I .l,nod thil vorUleaUun on the locommondltlon
of QUI .ttorney., who .dvl.. 1.11 thlt the Illlg.tlonl .nd
1.n9U"1 ln thl, document Ire required ",'lly to r.l', l..ue.
for r..olutlon at trill. by the Court, or by contlnulng
lnv"tl,.tlon .nd pr,p.r.tlon for trill. I undlr.tand thlt
.ome at ChI" .110,.tlon, m.y prove In.pproprl.tl .fto,
lnve.tl,atlon .nd trlll preplratlon Ire comploto Ind I lelVI
altlrmlnltlon of the,. mltterl to our .ttorneYI on thelr .dvloo,
I undorltlnd thlt .11 It.temont. her.ln Iro mldo ,ub,.ot to
th. p.n.ltle. ot 1. 'I. C...A. 14'04, rol.tln9 to unlworn
t.l.l"".tloll to 'Ut.holltl...
HOLY nllllT HOSPITAL
. j ).;"
, .. ....0....- -.",
.,~~ ,1i.c. I P,. .. i".. /f:,/'~_; <_~"i"'f- ..' ~A
_;~",,""'~'5~..,""""'''''__''''''>''''''-'''-'-'--_''''''''';'''''''-*'''~''''_~.T.4if.:n~"tI>
Tenl.y M. .Nl1111..on
Olrector ot .l.k M,n.,...nt
Va'"
f""j / i
.,-,' /...." oj,,'
j,_~-,,..;o...(~~:'1".a~,~:>"'!=--,,--,,,;<
YUU JCA1' 10M
I. 'ft"'l, ""wI'., M.P.. v"l'Y 'h.. 'h. .'.t...n'. ..G.
In 'h. "I.,olnt '"'~" Ind now MI"" whloh I" wlthl" 'h'
,"'Oft" kRQWlt4,. o. 'h. un4."ltn.d, '" .'U. lAd tOI,'Q'.
lAd " '0 'h. ,.@,. b..t4 on 'h. lA'OIM.'lon of o'h..., 'h.
ynd.,.ltn.d, ..,., 411"ln' InqullY, b.Ilevl' I' \0 ~, ,'U..
And 'U,'h'f. I .19n14 'hI. v"I,Ig."on on 'h. ,.go~Rdl,lon
gf ou, .""n.,.. whQ .dvI.. V. 'hi' 'h. .".,.'lon, InG
I.n,v.,. In 'hI' dutu..n' '" "qvl,t4 1.,.'1, '0 ,.1,. I"u..
'Of f..ulu,Ion ., ,,1.1. by 'h. Cou". 0' by fon'lnuln,
Inv,.'I,,'lon .nd ".,.,.'lon '0' ,.1.1. I una-,.,.nG 'hi'
.0.. v, 'h.', .'I.,.'IoR' .,, ,'OV, In.",o,.I.,. ..,.,
lRv,,'lt.'IOft ,na ,,1.1 ",p...'IOA ." 00.,1.,. .n4 I '..v.
d".,.ln.,Ioft II ,~,. ..".,. " ou, "'O'A'Y' on ,n.I, IdYl",
I uftfl,.,.nd 'h.. ," .,.'...n'. h.f.l" .,. ..d. .ub).., "
'h. ,.n"'l" If 'I ,.. C.I.A. 1.10., ,...,,", ,. un.wel"
,.I."l,.'Ion " .u,hQ'l'I,.,
}/~?
~~==".,~f('l'l,: ~ }.,~-'~,.\~::~",:,~
...ILI,., aWNll,. It.O.
D"",.,itJlt (,
RICHARD W. aAM'AV.
'1.lnUff
I IN THI COUll,. or COMMoN '(.1M
. CUM'llItANO eo., 'INN.VLVAHIA
I
. caYIl. AeTlOH · &.AW
I
I NO. ".all CIVIL TIRM
.
I JVIIY TIIIAL UINAHPeo
I
I
I
I
I
Y.
1I0l.V .,UUT "o"n".. .nd
,uILLI' MAOUIIIC. H.O.,
Det.ndlntl
,...'ItIU!..Ir~'II. 0'
DUUOlnl IOLL'''III,JlOIUTAJ.."AlD,'IILLII,lIAtvINll,D..
I
I
I
I
I
!
i
i
~
I
i
,
I
~
.,
I
1
,
It. Th. 'llltQ.tlon. h.r.ln .tAt. I oonQhl.ion or 1.", to "'hioh
no r..pon.. 1. n.o....rv. To th. ..'.nt In In."'.r .-v b. r.qylr.~,
any and all al109ltlon. thlt thl rlalntltt'. Coaplain' rail' to
.tat. . ol.i. upon whioh r.l1., o.n b. ~r.nt.d ar. .,.olllollly
d.nl.d.
'0, Th. IUltQ.Uon. h.,.ln .hh . QonQlu.hm of llv to whlQh
no ,..pon.. 1. n.o....ry. To th. 'Ilhnt .n ,nIW., .IV b. ,.q\llrl4.
any and all 111',ltlon. that th. o.f.n4Ant. ,rOVldl4 full, prop.r
.nd Id.qUlt. o.r. and tr..t..nt to th. .1alntlff whll. h. v.. a
p.tl.nt at the Det.M'nt 1I0.plhl art ,p.QitleIUy a.ni.a, Any.nd
III Ill'9atlon. thl' th. In,w'rl~ Dlt.M.nt. att the -.41011 and
1'"" .Undult. of OU' nqulr4J1l of th.. In AU r"plQh art
,ptoiflQAlly d'nl.a. Any Ana all AllltQltlon. th., th. In.warl~
V.f.nd."t. ar. without ll.blllty In thl. ..tt.r .r. .,.oltlollay
~."1.4. Th. I".w.rlnq OII.nd.nt' ar. 'olntly an4 "V'fllly ll.bla
IQf thl In'url.. .uataln.o by tht rl.lnt'tt II .at forth in tn.
Co.pa.lnt. ..ld in'url.. 1M al-..q., VU. Uti dir..ot .114 proldu'.
I
!
I
.
H")i,..
r".YI~ Qr th. n~U",e"(I. e>>t All llAMa P4Jt.ndllnt,. Anv and all
~11"QAtlQ'" 'h'l 'hI 0.,.,,41"" a' no 'i__ ".~11~.ntlY Qlu..a or
nIJ'JU",.nUv "c;nt,I"uh;4 tQ "au.. .nv I"Sury or au.,. to thl
~'.lntl" arl ','PI'l".lly dl"l.a.
... Th. anl"""o", hu.ln .ut. . "onQlu,hln Q' law to whll1h
M rnpon'l I. flt"...UY, To 'h. ..t."t an a".",n "IV a:.. requIred.
IIIlY .nd aU 1"~IUc;n. th.' the 'lalnt"", 'n)url" r"\lU'" 'r".
ol,oY..t.n"., ".yond the """trol 01 'h. Def.na.nt, an4 'Of whl"h
\hllY .r. not r..pon,I"'. or "'h.rwl" I"ally 'labl' IIr.
....Q1U"'.Uy a.nl.a. ""h", 'h. ...,.nail"" Ifl jointly 1n4
..v.ral'y "Ib'. '0' InS"".' Ana a...,.. t. th. ".'n'l" ., .1'
f~r'h in 'h. Co.,l,I"t. '.&d I"Ju'I" .nd a...,.. ""f' th. dlr.et
1,,141 PfO"'"'' f"Un, 0' 'n. "'ffU,.noa ., .U nallH OIII",."t..
AnI' ana 'II .l,,,.'Ion. 'hat 'h. Ott.naln'. ., no 'I.. n-.ll,,"tlv
~'4..d Of "'fllt.nlIV von"IDull4 to ~.u.. 'nv Injury .~ aa..,. to
thl tl.'"'I" .,a .,..,r".llv "n'I4,
...,..'tvllY,'vPil"I4.
)' ,
;4
.....,I/ry/I7"';'<:;
fI'
I . ......
.10) North 'rf"' ",..,
NAffl,Jij'ff, fA 11"0
rrl1' IU-UU
A".,"*y '.f rt.l",t,..
COMMOfirWIAt.TIt 0' 'IHM.YLVAHlA I
I "t
C(WUfY or DAUrltl" I
I, ~Qbln J, ".f..l'I, r.q~'r.. "'nt d~'y '~Qfft looofdlnt to l'w,
~.~o,. ana I'Y 'hi' I II ,own..l for p,.t""'f, 'h.' I .. aW'hO,l,.a t~
-4M. 'hl. af'ldavl' on ~.h.l' @, ..14 pl.lntl". .nd th.. 'ha IIQ', ..t
fMth In tht 'orllJoI~ ,tAINTI"" ItIf'&'Y 1'0 Mew MATTC,. or OlrCHDAlfl' IWl:t
MVI~IT HO,'ITAL AHa fHILtl' NAQU1MC, M,P, .ra ,~ and vorrag, tQ th.
to.,t gf lilY knwl~a. In'.f.-UoA lna "'U", Of, art U.... Ind OQfuvt
~...d vn th' 'n'o,..'lon oD'.l~d 'ro. p'.'n."',
<~/ //
e /, J .~.
r.
~WOfn .. And IYDI.rl8t4
~.f9f' .. 'hi' ,i~\t dlY
~ \ . ....:
{lfJiJ,.I+~ _4 -,,,,"-, , l'b.
h,;~lll I '.f I' t j Or
-U1ii,:t"f;...lImr"'.-- ~. ,,,.
14/ ~"p,..h;n ..phu, 0:/'" f'~
~,.~:t,_,_i:t\ -~f:~
_, '..Ii -.', . ..
",- .' f, ~_""-f., f't""9
tll;"h~t'i*r -,_..:~",-~ WM'fl '14
lilt ill ~.. ........... 1\ 1M
" I
!flJ4;:41.~
~
~
!
r:
I
I'
"
I'
II
1i
fi
n
C!~TI~lCATE or '~BVJCI
I her.by clrtify that I. ~~n. R. Lute., an IlIIploy.. of Anolno
, Rovn.r, P.C., have thl. ~~ day of Hay, ItGD, .Irv.d II true
IIncl oornet copy or thl 1'L.\IHTlfr'8 RESPOHSE TO HEW HATTER or
OI!I"J1:NDANT/J UOLY SPIRIT 1l0fJPITAL AHO PIULLIP HAQUIRE, H.O. upon
d.t.ndllnt.. eoun..t by ..ndlnq .alll. Unit.d Stilt.. flr.t-ola.. 11I1111,
po.t.Q. pr.pald. .ddr....d I' tollow..
f
~
I'
~
i
.t.v.n D. Snyd.r, r:,qulrl
METTE, EVANS . WOODIIDE
'401 Horth Front .tr..t
P.O. POle 5910
H.rri.burq, PI\. 17110-0950
Attern'r tor DIt.ndant. 1I0lY .pirit HOlpital
Phill p "Iqulr., M.D.
lfiA,,~9
enan. . 11.1
i
i
I
I
R
!
,
f.
.\l4ni~
and
Mil
KlC'IIAMU W, MMMV.
rtAilllltf
h,
J IN nUl {'OUR'I' or C'OMMON I'IJI",u ()f
nJMhlHUANU ('OtJN'll'. rl!NMiVINANIA
('lVII, AC11ON, lAW
ljju.lIIl ('lVII, 'mIlM
WRY 1 "'AI, 111:MANUtU
1101, Y ,,'IIUT IlU",,.fAl, _All
"UUUI' MAOUIMt!. Mn.
n.{k<Ikt3ft~
~QUo.rtt~lw.;UMtl:L..Al:ll;.!"'l;ti\m
"NO NOW. 111M
utWtK
I, '" 1M, ,., All...... IIN,., II AIIItt It l\-lIfII (lft Midi,.. ')f'AWI,
\t I), 10 ,114M flIll!tf .", lt4I,IkIl/Jil",.. Illwll4l il ""","11M' "hf.~ Itlf Alf"". JI. IW,. II
I Ul ,.,IIt, II Ihr! IiIw ,lftiw, 1" "/IfIIJI' II f4;~IW'. fe',
'"", M"iI! ftlt+fMMt< ,... (1Oj 11<1), .tIt. "f\'~,
MY lHf, fOUKT.
((~ p. \." I" Z "/1:;:
, :~ ..'.".
If ."
RICHARD N. RANlAY,
Plaintiff
Y.
I XII TIft COVin' or eoMNOlI ,LIAI
I CUM.IlLAHD co., ,IIIII.VLVANIA
I
I CIVIL ActiON · LAW
I
I NO, "-J'l CIVIL TIRM
I
I JURY TRIAL DIMANDeD
itaLY ..'IIUT HOlflTAL Ind
'lilt-loll' MAGUIRI, M.D"
Defln4ln'.
9101.
AHD NOW. tht. _ day 0' , "'1. UPQn
con_td.nUon of th. w'lhtn MQUon t. COlI,., An......M. .,
OepollUon, ,Uohud DeLvoI. M.D., i. .r4.," ,. ,'''n4 I tI,,.ltUgn
.Qhed~l" for AUQu,' 'I, 11", ., 1100 p.... I' 'hi l.v 0"101' 0'
Anqtno' Movne,. ',C,. or 'aoe 'IM'tone 'apo.t4 ~ 'hil COUrt,
-l1!,
iI.
IY TIt. COUM1'.
'H'flu'
y.
I IN '1'tf1 COURT or COHJCON PU!:AI
I CUM81MLAHD CO.. PENNSYLVANIA
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I NO. ,,-all CIVIL TERM
I
I JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
RICIIARO W. RAMJAY.
Plaintiff
/lOLY SPIRIT 1l0IPITAL .n"
PHILLIP MAGUIRE, M.D..
D.t.ndant.
lLllIflIl!' 'Qr~Q. JQ QPN'IL &trINDalQI at QJfP.JTIO.
AND NOW Qom.. the pl.intift. by .nd throuoh hi. .ttorn.y.,
AnQino , Rovn.r, P.C., .nd aov.. your /lonorabl. Court to oomp'l the
attend.no. of Rioh.rd D.Luc.. ".D., at a di.oovery d.po.ition tor
the followinq te..on'l
1. Th' .bov.-o.ptione" .edio.l .alpr.otio. aotlon w"
Initlat.d by the tillno ot a Coapl.lnt In the court ot common ,1.1.
of Cuab.rllnd county. P.nn.ylvania, on January 19, l"~'
3, Th. d.po.ition ot Rioh.rd D'Luca, ".0., an ..ploy.. und.r
the oontrol ot o.r.ndlnt Itoly 'pirit 1I0.plt.l and Illatnlal wltn...
in thi. 0"', WI' .ohedul.d tor W.dne.d.y. July 19, 1"0, at 10100
.... It Holy .plrlt lIo,plt.l. A oOPY ot the Notic. ot D.po.itlon
of Rloh.rd DeLuo., M.D., 1. att.ohed h.r.to .. INhibit "A."
3. Th. afor.eald Notlo. or Depo.1Uon WII ..rv.d upon ooun..l
for D.f.ndant Iloly .pirlt 1I0.pltal on Jun. 13, 1991'), by tlut-ola..
United Itat.. ..U. Thn.attu, I .ubpoen. wu ..rv.d upon ah,hard
I O.l,uc., H.O., at hi. rUld.no. at 410' whwl.don Drlv., tlarrl.burq,
l
I Plnn.ylvanlt, on Jun. 3./ 199', by p.rlon.l ..rvie. by ThO." J.
,
Malon.y, an ..ploy.. of Ant;llno , Jlovn.f. ...C. A copy 0' ..Id
lubpolnl Ind a.turn 0' ..rvlc. Ir. att.ch.d h.r.to .. txhlblt ~n."
lei CUAPD W. IWUIA Y .
PlAintler
I 1M T"' couwr or COMMON ,I.&U
f CUMICIlWD CO. / "HNIYI.YAMIA
f
f OIVIL ACTION . LAW
I
f NO. ".a'l OIVIL TlaM
I
f .JUItV T1UA" O&JWfOID
Y.
IIOLY .PlKIT "O..ITAL Ind
"IIILI.1f """UIIlI. M.D. /
&Me.ndlnU
Gtl~1 TO TAllI DUg.1UOII
TOlDI'. O.tuCI. ~y In4 throuQh hl. Ittorn.y
"'Vln o. .nyd.r. I.qulr.
MITTI. IVAN' . WOOOlIOI
'401 North 'ront .tr.et
p.o. 11011 IUO
Ulrr1lbllr".'A UUO
,LeA.1 T".I NOTICI that ,ur.~.nt to 'I. Il,O,'. Mo. 4007.1. 'lllntifr.
tn tht Abov,.QI,tion,d .'tt.r will tiki thl dlpo.ltton of DI. DeLV". uvon
(.rAI .lClUlinaUQn. tor th. (lur,o" ot di.QQVlry or tor uu .t trlel. UI! for
'.otll 'IIr'o.... ".tofl , p.uon AYthorind to rel'l4tr In oath. It H..
pfflca. of M.'l./ IVI'. . W....,... 't', ..,,_ "..~ ",e'" 'a,".~llf9/
,.nn.yIYlala, v.~lnnlnq At '0,0' .... .. July 't/ ,.... on III ..tt.f. "~t
,.rlvUIlIl.d whlph UI UIIVAllt And "AtniAI to \1'\. h.Il" .nd ,u\;.'aH
milthr InvQly.a In U'" Abov.."Apt:lcm.a IQUCIO. The Abov,.n...d lndlvldu'-I
t. rwqll..,.a to Appa.r .t tha .for__aid '1.' It th. ,boy. addr... aw'
.u~.'t to .w..inAtion und.r OAth.
rt.... pr'~1 wlth you the followlnq, I
t. Tht oriQln.1 IIt4iQI' ftOOf'" ,.r'.'nin, t. MiohAf4 M....VI .r~1 I
J. Any w,in.n or QU'1f ..""".nU/ ',",1\141nt tN, n.' "_itM t{.t. I
~ll ~.I.r~lr', di.rt,.. Qnr.nol""'/ fiit... ....,.nd. .r @'her do~u..nt. I
I
I
I
I
I
I
i
i
f
I
~.~
I
t .t h. t\
~.rt.lnint ,. 'h. 0'1" an4 'f..'..nt r.n4.r.4 to Rleh.rd R....y.
ANGINO , ROVNER. P.C,
>~(
04tll(2l-~ ~ 1"5'
GOI ~v AnA "ll'. e.u"
. '1' ne . ..
I. D. No. 47252
4103 North 'ront Str.et
Hlrrl.bur9, penn.ylvanla
(117) n'-6791
eoun..l tor PlI1nt1tt(.)
17110
"'porUr
I
I
crttOll4f1J..111 Of f'rl'J!jyt.VI~tll"
~...O(~Rl~'~ .
1'1.1.",1 W. 1~,'I*,flY.
,
Plalnll!! I
I . '
~lfll"I..1 >litl l'hllllV />WJulf"'. .....IJ.
l\lhll,d4l11ll I
~
nl, f<<)....?'i,J,~) ~.lyJ..Ul'Hll
It.
1I''\y f4.IIH
n2t _ IHdVlld 1-.J,IIl14l ,..,11,
__ "",,11101'1' tjl~ritlh'llil"l. Ni',ftlllJ'l' tllBJ1' 0 {',.,.tel 1\111 1'&. pilI'
1. \'(>11 lU. ClrdefMJ by .'hI ~ lo 0UIl! '0. t~IIY 1P~11I 1~"'l'I"d-" U' r"~tf"rl"'. MI ,..
,.,
"
"I Ill,Oll
IIf<'ClUy QOUIt~ Of alt., Jll~1
('",h.tINd Co\r\ty. l'tMIylv..u., on ,hity I", I'J'J',
or g'cloak. .. 14.. to t..Hfy on \lIhAU of ._0""
_.,_.-,
III ""''1' 11\11
~.<""'
--",..
lol..lhllft
-
~..
IIld to f..un WIt 11 PCo"Uttd.
.,. - .,,,~
fllrtt I..". dl.l'(!(IIUI4lli. '1('. 14lIi, ~",,4NJ14 vr ttthlll ,l<>{t"oIi;"\ti! ..n4IHlH'J H. Hili 1411' 10101
-;'Z'fr'~,:~:'::fe"':i~: r..~*" I~'~~' .:.t.~.-
ut CWll I'rt!(;<<tia.. lflOl~ wt 1'10\ liffll,MJ \<;t CQ'''. .nofftltY IN' IIld Ul\'filWffIWfI\.
1~!:ut:P U'1 A r.un"1/ccww. IN (X)I'I.JNC Wl'nlr....e,.. tel. 2,..21.1
t-W'<<. ~~~l'~ ~J iJ-i .,I.l .tj4t UtI' d
1>.Wf@1,
H.lP HlqJIJI"N\f eu",,!..
IIR{I 1..1~1{'I. t" qUe
11UttlH1.J.lI.lI n,.tol'!\.
wrmc CWJn' It/I t.Ml""
.."'f......
ti\n:,~.,;n l5t1f
"~or ,tit tow\
~ < 4~r-
t:'~".t1~.~
llIPIty
(>nlcu.t. Km~ ft\i, '"'" f't Nfr"'" tt.U ... \IH4 llt.....f . ~ .. &.."..1,.,
,~\\4l1if tlMft,. i,. ~.+w'i-M wi"" .....Ukifif ... Mm. Af"iu.h"iff, IMt""
{f.........'....... .,.. il\ @{~.H4f1H wU" h",e.'. '-:i, 1M,', If. ~.,. IN ~tW
(,t t1l~Vt/IfIU. 't(Ntl8 1" ,~ " dlth"". @{tlfitt. tAf.. "
_"'; - '11\1\\
~ or mNlCEI
()\ ... ;l, r rt
I.
_1 I
n""'"
rwt'Il
, - ) ,~jJ
.
7~-.Jrnl~~
(,t.....
..,.+ ....._ _...~,~_-'io_~";
, "
,-
.,
"'~,~}'-;'d;~'1:~i>\';'1~~_~-~~~$:~:ft:urt;_:1:~tt~l1:lIfttJ"':~~~'m:~(~~~-" jWttC~.":- ;~,,"'"L"-,___~,':'- :,___~;-_;,;c
,
..
f .
I
,,~,
t
.
/".
t:-
.-.if< ~,,;i-
.-4"._+~_.+ _
!:'t~
f\'l
t t
~;"".:j
'-J
F
4~
n
W
.
t1C
t
, ,
"
.
("0.
G""
~>
""
'"^.,.,
Ii
..... I"'. '\
., /'.
f" .
"\ it
it ,.
liI'lf1Qtmtnl. fOI '"' dtpot,tlOnt of . hO'P,t., rnKtl.na .motOfl'Cy foom ph)'tlCl'" ..
,~ttt<1 by pllllltlff'. ~.." -'fort,to contact Ot OtlucaIO~' hi' dfPOlI\Jon
wOt. not ,~..fuI ~,. Of D.luca Wit end .. on . !ntdl(.tllt.v. of IbM"'"
ffom \NI hO'P'W dutllO IfljUfttll ,uff.,td Ill'" .ulomobll. ~1l1 and hi hit bttfl oul
c;lllal. tnd not WOf1ltd II Hol)' Iplt" HO'I)IIII 'I~ MIft.flJO, ,H& It 1,IdmItltd \hat
. ~ of a 00\l(4 of dtPOllttOn of "Ic;tIltd D.Luca, M 0 .1 Ittldltd \0 thl plll(lljff',
mOIIM.t IIM,)!t'A', bI.It II.. o.ro.d!hlt tho dtpOt1llOn Wit 'lChtd\.Iltd' end lNt Of
O.LueA hid MI~ of '"' dtpOtitlOt\
3 ~ II tl,tld It.. NnItttd lhat undtftlgrltd~'" f~lVtd ~ of
dtpOtillOn Jot Of Ottuet', QfpOtI\Jon on NIt ,... '"6 It, howtv." II dtf1lId tNt.
~ w., Mf'ftd upon Mlc;t\IId OtLuca, '" 0 It hit ,tt1dtne4t M 4'06 WlfflOItdon
Onv.. ".fllNO, J'tMlYWtlfllt on Jynf a.. '"6, by ptttonal MfV~ by ThoIflM J
~, an ~"of pllfntJff' COUIl..1 To 1M eontfery, Of Otl.lU ,~)'
t4f't~ undtI'tl{,JMd ~ by ..~ tnd tnfOffMd undIftlO"fd COUflttl Nt hi
w.. not HrVtd with . ~ WId hit "'" bMn III N COfMlOIlWHIth of
PtMI,ww. tlflee Mat,")O, ,... 1M Ihlt hf II now In IN tiN of MaInf It "
~tIf/I N . C<iPV of . ~ 1M "tum of WvlC4t 1ft ~ 10 Iht "MiMI
JrrfJf~ M I~Miit 'D',lM "11 (~'Of tnf ,..toot Nt'oM t1fftlfl INt N ~
w.. Mf'f"" f,Wl 01 a.~~ 11M "". 1M ,tfIJI" 01 MfYUif .. IIQM"'" Or WI'; of MN
V",If'" Hit"., % NKtfiI j,flf'(;QfpOff/W,l Nfftf\ t;y ,""'" M " .... ~ ~"..
,
t~
,
MICKAMO W. MAM'A'.
'l.l"U"
I ." TN' eovn or ClOMMOM 'UM
f CVN'I.~O eo.. 'INNIYLVAHIA
I
I CIVIL ACTION · LAN
I
I NO. "-1" CIVIL TI~
I
I JV"Y TIIIAL OfMAHOIO
v.
J(
~
IIQ
..
{ *'
~,' iJ
I, I~rl A. 'halto. In ..,loy.. or tn. I'W 'Ir. ., A~ .
M~vn'r. '.C., h.r.~y Q'ftlfy that. tru. an4 O.ff'~' oo,y of t~
A"qu,t '. ..... orlt., vu ..rv.a Up"'ft 'n. fwUWlnt ,.UGn. -'Y
flr,'.QI... Vnltt4 .,.t.. ..'1, ,Q,'", p,.,.ld @n Auqu.' 10, I"',
AI toUW11l
tlot.Y .'IIHT twlrlTA&. .n4
f"ttt.I' MAOUI~I, M.D..
o.f.n4.nU
CUflrlalll~ot.Jmm
NI.RArd o.~Q'. M.P,
4101 Mi.-l.t.nOrlv.
Itirrl.~r,.'A Inll
'ltv." P. '''V4t,. I.qul"
Mmll. CVAH' . IfOOOffOI
1401 ",:tn rfQnt .tr..t
r.o. ... tno
Haffl'IYf.,'A 11110-0"0
~;/ . I j 1_'.f.1!/_L-
V i~ f+J,fA:.sn\!:~..'.
~lCKAMO W. MAHIAY,
plaintiU
IN THII COURT or COMMON PI.IAB
CUN'IRLAHO CO., PENNIYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
I
I
I
I
I
I NO. .0-a81 CIVIL TERM
.
. JURY TRIAl. DEMANDED
HOLY .,IRIT HO.'ITAL .nd
MIILLIP MAQUIRI, M.D.,
o.t.nd.nt.
1~IWflr,'.~'~'1 ~ ..,LV at p,r'.D~
'o~y 1I1ltf IQ"IIAL', "'LV_TO RLAIHTlll!I
KO.tl01ll 'CO _rlL Att.IIOAltOl ." 01'0111''1011
AND NOW, the 'l.intiff. by .nd throu\Jh hia attorn.ya, Anl,Jino
. Ravnn, P.C., r..ponda to the ....ply of Oefendant Holy .pirit
Hoapit.l to 'laintiff" Notion to compll Att.nd.no. at a.poaltion
II followa.
1. No r.apon.. 1. n.o....ry.
a. In r..pon.. to pa,avr.ph a. a.fendant Holy .plrlt Hoapit.l
hu adlllltttd that '10hlf'd o.Woa, M.O., i. .n e.ploy.e ot Itoly
Ipirit Hoepit.l. AI' phYliol.n ..ployed at Holy Spirit "olpltal,
it ClInnot b. dllputtd th.t the o.f.ndllnt 1I0.pital would b. in I
bitter pOlition to know the whereabout. of Dr. o.Woa. Hor.ov.r.
.. a phYllolan ...ploye" by O.f.ndant Iloly splrlt lIolpital, any and
all n'911,ent ..dloal tr.at..nt r.ndared by Dr. DeLuoa would b.
cov"e" by t1cHy .plrlt HoapltAl" 1nluranea oarrl". A. hll
..ployer, Holy IIplrlt lIolpltal hu lupervllory and manaIJerhl
control over ,Uchard a.Wca, H.O.
If Oehndant UolV Spirit
I Ifo.pital u.roi..d their authorlty ovu Or. 04Luc_ .. hle elllployu,
,
, they could "Mat. hle _thM_nee at th. afor....nUon." depo.lUon.
'U., 1\"
Ih.WllVU. for rtI.Ultlfll Ilflkoo'm \{. ..'.lflUff', ""IUlll.'. (l.hm44n~ 111'1<;
liJ'lr't th'I~'hl AM "uyn..' thu.'!), hllv, lih"..n ng, \Q ~g .€I,
~'lIln\I'f. hAve b..n "'..p'lnt ,,, ,Qht4ul. 'h' a'fOll'l"n of Pro
l Pt(~Q' for th. p,,' thr.. .onth.. .,.V. .nyd.r, ~"n..1 'gr "~Iy
I
! IIplrl' Ho.pl"I, ".. \In.v.llabl. ynUI J\llV " 1(,", At. Hr.
i
I Ilnydtr" .p.gl'lo r'~"', 'h. d.po.I\lon. 0' 'h. ..plgy...
I
I Inv(ilved In Hr. ......y.. gar. ".,. .oh14lll.a '0' "\lly 'I, ,....
I Th. ""Ug, t" tllk. 'h. d.,..I\&on 0' Or. PeWQI W.. prop."y "~'4
on pgyne.1 ,or "olV .plrl\ ",.,1,.1 on Jyn. ., I"'. on Jyn. 'I,
! "". Hr. .nya., gonflraH \I,. '"h8411''''' 9' 'hI ae,o.ah1l11 ., Or.
I ~pyrrl.r.nd Nyr.. ..rv.rlno. "~tv.r. h. 11'141".'14 'n.\ h. hll4
I not. b..n abl. .,et In 'oyoh wl'h" Pr. o.~Q., a..pl'. 'h' 'aot 'hi'
I ht w.. an ..ploy" 0' "'IV 'phlt "".pIUI. on Jyl'l' JJO, &tn.
~I.lnt'tt" ooyn..I .,.In OOff..pondtd w"" Hr. Inydtr ,-.",.'Int
ehd h. oonUr. 0... Olta.uo.'. ..po.'Hem 'Of Jyly It, "tI, Of
pfovld. y, "I'h In .I'.rn.tlv. 41" '0' Pf. Ot~'" ~po.I"on,
A popy 0' th. Jyn. 30, "". l.'t.r I. .".oh~ h.,.to II I.h.bl,
-A.- Mor.ov.r, 'lllnti,,'. coyn..' .,."I'lg.lly .t.t.4 th., 11 no
f"pon.. w.. 'or\"oo.l"4 "0. pounl.I 'or Holy .,I,lt "0"."1, .h.
wDuld ~. 'oro'd \0 .ubpo.na Dr. Ot~o. to .".., 't 'h. JUly".
"", d.po.I\lon. 110"4 wl\" \h. .'h.r N@ly .,1,1\ M..,I'II
..'Ioy.... 'hlnUU'. Goyn..I 1,."UIOIlly 4I4vl'f4 M,. .nrdn
'hn ..\41 woull1 WI" yft'" .'00 p... on Jlln. It, \t", 'ff tII.
",,"UrN"O" UlU Or. OfIW4Ja "oula i. .",.ulR/f n 'h. pH"lfly
nqtlQt4 4fpo.ltion 0" July'., ".,. Now.VI'1 ~ r",,~' ""
'Of'noo~I""
Qft Jyft. i.. 1"'. Th@", H41~A'Y. .n ..,loy,. ~, A~lR@ .
! '''''1fl.', '.e., ,.,.....Uy "fY" IUi'tlud ~l.lW., M.O,. wl'h A
! '~f~'n4" hl. ~ '@q"" " .I.t W'''',tift Prlv,. ""'I'~U"f
;
~
i hnn,ylv."I.. 11\. P.,., Q' 'h. .Upct.fll il ,'U~.4 hu.to ..
I
! l_hiDI' "ft" .1\4 . ~fY Q' Ih. ,.Iw," 8' "fYl~. I' "I.~hM h.,.l@
!
i .. l.hlDI' "C." A,t.f Id."",yi", h,...l' I' Pf. Mlyn,r. OI~~.,
i
I Mr. M.I@rMY ..fVM 1\1M vl'h . ."~~.nt if4'flnt hiM t. I'f'.f ~n
! J\.41V '.. ,.U. .. till ,1". @t ..,Ioyunt h~f . d,,@'IIhm.
I AUlu,Ih.\I hn.h, .. 111II,h.1\; .0. 1,11\0." MIIl@n.v" IW9I1\ .Uhlnh.
I eQYAI.' '9f OI,.n4ln, Holy _,I,lt "9""" Indlg.,.. In hi.
i k,'fion.... ,,.In'''''' MQ".n t@ c..,., 'hit PI, o.~ n.. ~..n
ij ...
! 1>/'1 Md'ol' ,.IV. ., ....M. "... Ih. MI,".' 411' ,(; '"'lift..
,
~
IhiU.r4114 In .n .wt~iH. IHht.flt 1M MI "'1" tNt (if .U" .iflH
I "'rQn lO, I"'. 11\. "f.' ".. th.' ".l""'f/, ~"*.I WI' 'V"
I lilY." IIlV f.U@" ,., ih. IIUlllNl".. 4.'."*. !ltU hlvlftll vllh
I {<@f\UgUlMI pr. o.W~1 wu fIIn JYly If, 'tn, At 1ft. UM @, tM
i .~h.d"ltd .,,""'.n. "QW'~'f, ""fn., ,., If.', "lrl' Ku.,II.,
I IHlt no, 'ftW'''. '..IMU," "un..' w't" . HMut, ,,,,.,,.-
I ft'lJualrlfl Uf. OeL4wal. ..,lvY""1 ,..Iw. Vltn MQiy tlpl'" M."ll.l
j Ifr hi. ,n..,,' vftff"."UU, Glv.n U" f.", 1M' Ufo 0e1Mf1 VU
I
! ('.ul'mIUy iffY" wUh In. tfgrf..nihmtt4 l\4ttpq'M Ii ht. ,l.~ @f
i
I r."II.,," in Hurl._nfl, '.flft"''''I" I.. ih. .UI...", 1M' ht tiu
I ~.." @u, @f .1.', .Inf. MI'"'' )0, ,..., I. W~'Il~".~,V ,.1."
I J. ~r.".. "(fl;Il'.' Itlfl!ll'. 1M' Il9UH 9' 4,,,,."16" It..
t
j
,
,
.u....... liJ'fjn Mw (@f ,,,. ~I.AW. iifn J~ 14/ ,t~., ~....." 4.f.~
I 4.n'.. ,~, . It~M It., ..fVM \i~" .'vh4f4 f.J4(,.w., ~,p" I'MIt
I rulil./loH Ii U~.~ '-1.'.'4f~ 1if"1v" KlffbWfft" f'!'i.~.~lviln'." 4;,.
f
,1,,'.11 U. lliU. "l' ..n'~II<" .'rvl~. "'.. 'IUt;'Il4' ), "14'''''.V, ""
..,I(.tYu (I' A"'l''"' . "'''VIlU, 'te, In HwM {o, H.I flnlil~Ii.4
Iltt1vnlllil, Uit Uhfft !il' .UV,". .M If'. "."'.MY" '~QfA ."hlnl,",
" i. ~I.., 'n.' Pr. ~~." ....f.I@" 'h.. h. WIiI. II@' pr~"flv
.uv~ w"" lh. ....,..... WI' ',I'tt ., 1ft '1'., " I. "I"hua
V.I~~., M.P." f."l'@ft lh.. 1\. v.. ~, ..rvf4 w"h ,~.
.f~r.,,",lpfit4 'wP,..nl fiI" Jwlf ", I.... . .,'~ "'la.Yl, 'f Pr,
u.~"". .nfu'4 hillY' .,.ft .".~hf4 ,. 'h. "~f..."'I@nt4 ~'fQlI",
..."~ 4,'.n., @~".., 'h'" "" " lllqlwa, 'h. ,.~lff4 Y'f"I~"'Qft,
t. .. 'hi. C.uU I. .1" IWln.. fU.,.hlU4 O.~., M.O.,
,H.rtH,.,4.., \h. ."11,.."" .1\4 hUf4 ,. .".., 'liIf 'h' ..h4l4ultkl
@IIJo(i.hlfil'l (In J\HY u, un, II (,'If. P4J1dW1 I. f.a4v ,. ..~. "
Iwp,n .'.....11' ,. 'hi' C'QU,' 'ha' 1\. w.. fti' 'f,,.'Il' ..rvf4 wl\n
.Ii. '''.'fiIIM tv f~' J, ".IfillI'V iii" JUM II, I'.., 'll'n,I"'1
~~yn"l w~I4 f.qyl.' . 'W~f" ."'d,y" ff41l'ftt \~.
llh,uMnHflA4J4.
t. rl.'"",'" uovA..I hi' .4vl.., ~.,.".. ~R,'l or ,~&,
In'.Alton ,. H.' tM. "... 'v, UII !hIV....,. un, lollvU "hi
"flIl, All {i' P'.lAU"" illH€fVtlfy I. fi@A"'WH, >>"t ,., Pr.
flf~." ...~.",..". M(lf.II"". 9ft Jwly ". UU. "'.1""""
~(lijA..i ".viii,.. 4.,.n.. ~vw""I . ,f.'I.1A.fY ","l ,.,.'l .1\4
114v&.., d,'I".. ~ftI.I 'h4' . "R""" '.P'" "Pi'l vavld .1
",@ylll... III Ii.,.," .. "'f, "'!Aw,', ...,(#."Ien WI' (,l@,~hw'tkI. o."n..
~~~n..I ~.. '~I'~"M .~~. h. I. .v.'I,pl' ~" A~ij.t l\, l..t, .,
lfl/ll l1,ftIl, h, .U~J It ~JiII.U'~n fI' Qt. u.t.w.1.. "II",UI'.
qq!ffl"'& " ."11 ...,Il li..a. fin ,,... ,'ljf...."' 19M4 44'. ,,;4 UN.
w,.."9"n, 'v, 1+",,&.'f144 ,..4(if", lif, ""~ ~. ,.,1fH4 ,~ N~ ,
.,
i hl.~,'f .vIII.~" f~f \>>. a.~~tlt'Pft 1ft U.fr"~Yr~, r'fifi~V'VI"14.
~
I
I
I
I
!
I
I
I
I
!Jr. QtJWf;lIl'1 ",(\iflll hi looi{Jf~Y' in lh.,ht (I' Ii.'.n.. Q@\lRnP,
rtiff...n,.,i@"1 ,~., ~. it .llll ...,lQf~. PV ~ly _'1'1\
twtf-lllll. 0.',1\" HUn.,1 MI 1",,"'\14 'hil' It, HMyql Ult
.t~f...ntl@nt4 a.,..t'tift tft Mlt~ on A""\l.l 'I, I.... In It,h' @,
t~ t.q\ 'n.' 'la,,,'t"'. ~ftf.l ~. ~..n ."..,'i~ l@ '~h.<<"l.
In. ,'@r...n,t@A4d ,.,..l\t@A I@, in. t.., 'h'.. ~n'~I, 'n. ,.@\
\1",., [If. tltl~. It.. 'f'i'ftflr "IV" "hen. 'lI"f"n. It",h, f..i41~
in ~.ffi'~Yf', '.nntylvlnt.j flat"'lfl "QUia r..,tQ\,ully f~~"
H.", 'hill e@Yf' naif Of. ~lM(H' \~ f.'Ii'" \., nt. ,11\1' @,
.-fI9VM"i ,., 'M "~Utll" fif ,n. ".,...u." fiR A\if\'" H, lU'1
; lit 1100 "I, I... 'M .U.,naUv., if '!HI c~ljn w",11l .f4., '"4'
!
I [j.((lMi.,I' "liIl, f1fll,l' "el,IUl 'flaW,.,..", fll'"'''''' "",n..'
Ii t~f 'f.v.l, ".. .ft4 f.l"~ ..,.n,.. '~W'ff4 In @@n4ij~'IA9 'h.
a.p@.I'tQI\ In MI'"" ".1"""" Q9Un,.' ~'4 Iff.. t. 4@ .~ ....
i
I
AYqYt' )1, Itt'.
lfflJlllrO'", fl..,,"tI n"."U"U, '"\M''' 'M' 'Ill. "'Mfltllt
C~vf' '''''f ." 0,4., ...,.'liA9 .lfn'f~ o.~." M.D,'. .".fl4.~
.. 'h. ,.,..l'l.~ tfkf4vl" fif A~ij" ll, I'.., 'S IlQO p,.. .t
'h. @ff'~. .f Aft4tM . ~ftf" ,.e.
~.,.@'fvllr '~1"t4,
I
i
ANtIMO . ~W'., ,.e.
I
I V;t'4H
I
I
I
.
> L'
't '
. Lj~L'_._ '
~nti"ni~'i~lini..
I,O~ _(I, UU.
.to, _~"h 'fQ~' "r..'
N4"i'~fi, fA 11110
PH" 1l,".7"
C~., '9f 'I.'~"'f
~
~; ,
(
I. 11
.
t,
~.lo'f,.AJ."1 Of "tl'I'\lV~J~
., .Or~all~". ._: _
Ii.. I.,. ,\ W. k4'..~V.
t
rl41ft,4tf I
V, . ,
lI..l\, ~[lln' Ilh40Jlita. Nit tiltH 1(. *iJl1lr., "\oCl.
llMttJIdMU t
J..ll.t,SU.l!..
m. No. I,j,)+l"~
-
.12l..-_'l\ftWd f~, ",P,
Ik,l~ P\:lfttltotlp".I. ~'Qh lIlt fitr_~. r;ISfIJ !JIll I'A qQ"
1. YQU Al. Clrtt.rtd by .'hI ooun t. ClCIltf t., IWI~ 'V.llpL Un"plHI ~ ,.,...f.,.!",'II !tvt',
I'
l(J ,1)(1
-
1 ~ifY COIIoI'1IVC11l Of OUlII' pUct I
,C\tia-.rlNd COiIIW, .....)'lvMll, on July Ill, ,1'1'1"1
0'01.,., . H.. '0 ,..,try on bth&U of ...__
., Cra'l' ,nil
"llIi"IIU
10 ,he aWv' ".... NId ,. rWl\l1n \IItU ~.
2. Altd bdfIQ with you 'h. loUwi/l\Jl 1'1'.. url~lJifd lIMlt.NI r~~"td!l ~'~PI.
M........ IlId tAllY wrlUell {if pHllr iK&,;WtliflU llil1111.r~ fll:.t JulIH g.. ., t1f....
.. .r
~ _~ A-
'IIAI i.., (. hwr,,'l!J 1.10. (l(,U... ff...tlfi1lfM (II lJtt"r Ckll1lftllf,'1 p.rt.1filn<;l to U. ,...- Nd
1.1."",1"1# ~...11t.t. If''t.IfA llllf'~
If )'01.1 faU to a ,rill or 1(' p~ .flll dQNIW\b or-uwiii U~hL' .~.
)'Cl\l ""Y t.. .vt>jllCt to Hili .NlCtlonl 'ijttlQrh~ b)' -.1. U4:lo' the r.MI)'lvlI\U rw'l
flf CJv 1 I"roo~, tnducUnt but flO' .\J.IIIi\'" ,. ClOtt., '''otnf)' I... lIIId """'ilOtAl\t.
lUUUJ flY A J"AJlTV/CQJtG:!.. IN CUG'lJNC WI". '.....e.f, IC). 224.31')
,w<<- 1~IJd(~ JI. tJonleP'
N.(lWllI
4~(). t4c'1{ltl rr}j(lt tittvt
_" tlM~i.'~Il~1 I'll PHil
'lUtJ'tDCI PPlln.m1
fM'rt1<< COOIfI' lOt ."....
_.a.a '._.
h'n:I~ ~~ !t1tJ[
-~;, u. court
tf: ~f;)A- t:.~. ~
(f ClfpUt Y
(iJ1'lelA.!. tc1ll1 l'h1a to", (It ~ .hall "" I.AMlt ~., . ~ b ",,*,1e,
lnc1ldJ.1\9 t...v,,. '" ~,~ ..U~ __it"'"" I/l4 _tox. U1Iitr.'on. ...'w.
tx"....t>.luWru.. .tQ. in ((:. with ..,I,e,f, IV, n..1, U.'~ fQ' pcv6ulitiM
Cif ~J(\""'U. f~da Of , it "","" tV'Plttt pu.., Z,
.
l flt>v, litO I
I
i
!
I
I
""'.f\
.,..
.,.
i" .
r:
ie,
( "
f
*'"
.
r_
~ or ....1(:1.
atltlll_. ~ ({'~ .0'
i?~ .' 1,'J""
l rM J. ;r, /?14f1"'P' S"t..
,tWt1l ~ ~.-
,..- .. pefNt NMid'
"Uh ,.. foR91lnG 1\4-- W'
CPMOribl"',", o. "fYi~'
iU...o.,u ii. "j .-J...lo.ro- f . j',{."
~' ~~, ~L__ ....-
. W"';J~,!J-. ....ld!:.~~;,Iw,~,l:.
. _ fA ,,,/,Al,_
. writy ,Nil, it. .,,,"""",, ht 'h1l
n'unt (If NfYw. ~ 'I'\lf .,.. ,'vu.....
I \ll'OJA.... \hi' '''',, It.tfllllllfttf
~tA.. __ .wjec$\ let t~ f4MlU"
of .. ".C.'.A. . "04 ..taUnt t.
IMIf 11m ,,,,.UlcIaU", to flUtt...'....
..
~
._1Wd
Mft.
-~
(~~f-ri
-
~..;.~
C t
't'c
,
. :.
I
.
ill, ,.
!"'"
,
1,
"'~- ~-
0,.,4':"'-.." '.
COMMOHWIAI.11t or "NJI'YLVAffIA I
I"
COUNTY or PAUI""" I
I, TIfOMAI J. MALONIV. an ..,lty.. .r Antino . RoV,.., , '.0"
l;.i1\9 dull' .worn 'N"d.", Co "". ".,... .nd "r 'h,' I pe,.on,ny
..rnd a GO'f vt thl ana"'h"- .uttpo.na on an indivtduII f..tdt", It
4'0' Wi_bl,'on Oriv., "Irfi.iu'f, ,.nn,vlvanta, whu .,.oi'ioll1V
la.nUn.a hl...U ,rlor " ..rvlo1 II IUohAfd o.lAIli1l, M.O. I
v.rlty 'hi' lh. .."...", atd. .~. 1. 'fU. ana QOfr.o\ I' Ih.
~.., 0' 'Y knewl...., t"'.""lo"'nd .'11.,.
7",,~ i#.-jf
triiM.. .,.,.~
l\torn ,..NI ',,"fft~.. "'on
.. tM. .~,p:"i day ., ~. "...
'I
.v
, ",t*'f "*4' n"'it':__"",.. -~- 4"':1.
..-f1Uft ~;.c*4
I.... *,~,(....,., (' .;. '. 1'.,,, \.
~__ M:-~f':_~ ..>fIc ',I}.,_ _
l ~- 1,!,,~,~; 'c'.. i ~ ;'_',~1J
..,~ -''C. -,. t -( -. -. ..... ..if.:"!;
I
,
~
~ICKAkO W, RAMlAV,
,1.inUff
I IN 'ml COUftT or COMMON '(.IA'
I CUM,IRLANO eo.. 'IHN.VLVAHIA
I
I CIVIL ACTION . ~w
I
I NO. '0-"1 OIVIL TIRM
,
I JURY TRIAL OIKAHOIP
v.
"O~y IVI,lf MO"ITAL .nd
tIUt.Llt' MAQUlItI:. M.D..
o.'encl.n'.
IlIallflll!I_..IIU. ,ICLMOfIOM lOl taoflO'UU
olD"J~r. W'.D.U .lQl.l. nUll. MQUIT..,
AND NOW, th. fltlnClr,. by and thrQY~h hl1 .ttornev., Anqlno
. koV~r, P.C.. ,..pond. th.t 'h. MOtlon '~r ,rot.ottv. Ordlr ot
o.r.nd..,t MolV 'phU; ....'iUl pufluln' to ,..14.0.'. 40U .hoyld b.
a.nl.a, b...a upon in. ,olltvl",'
1. W.iu.a.
J. MalUM.
J, o.nl.a" ".,.a, 11\". i. no r.qui,..e"t bV the
"""naVlv.nl. ~ule. 0' oivll ,~, tht ob,..t. 01 propo..d
a'f>o.lUo,u. Of th.l, 'U"'MY' ... oon.uU.a 'flu to thl 'ohedullnq
wt a.po.1Uon.. N....."Ml..., ln thl .,1flt Q' ooopultton,
~I.ln""" o@un.el hi' ."..,'14 OVI' 'hI P'" Ilver.1 aontnl to
.lIhlJdlll' 'M dtpi.hhn 01 Of. o.w.. It . aut".U)' convenlent
Uh. "tv....u. n.lthff 1.I"ln.. own.d Mf Of, o.l..uOil tin lot.d ln
'4l1(#j ,.IUt. And,.. Utl, ('QUrt II WIU 'WAr., Dt'. 0.1.410. wu
I.rflfinly ''''''114 WU~ . '~'@.Illt tf1 T~~' IUl@MY QIl JUM n, it'll,
4'r.'JHM M". \" II".'" .\ M. Jllltq. Q' .~l(fy..t1l \0 ~iv. ·
a.P"..U.I(;-. (I~ J\lly 19, 1''1.. ~.vu, Of, o.l4W8 'U....,.u4td lb.
.""~4!"',
~
4. IIch.dulln9 ot th. d.po,IUoo, of th. C'hairllu,n ot th.
E..rQ.nay Roo~, th. "'dtoAl Dlr.otor ot Holy .plrlt Ho.ptt.1, th.
CEO of Italy IIplrli Ito.pltal 1114 th. Dlu"tor of I'u.ono.l of Holy
.ptrlt Ita.pltal would not hlVI b..o n.o...uy U ooun..l tor Holy
uplrlt Itc.pitll hid .1.ply .dvl.ed PlllntiU', cOlln..1 uQlrdlnQ
th. .tAtll' of Dr. PltllCI'. ..ploy.,nt It HolV .plrlt "".pitll, ~hV
h. 1. on Illlv. fro. the ho.pltll or why h. h.. b..n tnalnai.a And
the olrollm.tlno.. .urroundlnq hi. dl.1I1..ll, .u.p.n.lon or l'IVI
from Italy .pblt "".pltd. PlllnUff', QOlln..l h.. r.qu..t.lI thl,
tntormltlon fro. d.f.n.. ooun"l on nu,"rOIl. oool.lon., thl ll.t of
whtoh wn by l.nn dltld AU9Il.t 1, !tn, .tUoh.d hn.to ..
Exhiblt "A." Iv.n Afhr r.o.lpt ot the Ifor'lI.ntlon.d
corr..pond.nc., d.f.n.. oOlln..l oho.. not to provld. ,111ntlff',
cOlln..l with thi. rtl.v.nt lnto....Uon .0 thlt th. "'polltiont
.eh.dlll.a for AUV",t I, 1"', oOllld b. Olno.lled. In.t..d. oOllnl.l
tor Itoly 'ptrlt 1I0.plt" oho.. to tU. II Notton tor. ProtlOUYI
Or~'r.
,. ,1.intUt l. ",ithol.lt knowl.dq, lutrloJtnt to tOI1l "
b.ll.t ". to the trllth ot the aAtt'f ....'t.4 h'f'ln.
6. A. pf.violllly .t.t.4, the '".'i.cny of tht tour
indiVidUAl. In4 MlchArd DlLllell, N.P,'. p.r.onn.l fl1. If' felev"nt
Ind n.e...uy to d.tuMln. t1\1 .1lI0' n.ture ot Of. Plwe.'.
t.,.inlltlon, .ulp.n.lon .nd/o, l'lve troll lIelv .,1rlt H,.pll.l.
'I, Ad"t'".
,. o.nled.
9. M.itt4Mt.
x':'~~ii
..'<
~'!~
" '.
...~
,
t.i
'.,t
w
w
iJ
it
rlt.\ftlrl: rldl U'.Il'ff, \' \H f<JH Tltl \l,
,......--~"',.~_...~.--~"~~~"~-'---_....~-_.~'-'-- ".."".,..,.......,.--...,. -~~-,-~~""'~-.---~
1\1~\1 t" 'fl',,,'II"" ...,1 ,~',.."I",J III 4u\,II"'"
to HlL( 'IHmW~(JTMtV Of Cl \lutRl.,,""P COIj'in
'I.... iltl 'lo' I"il..'~. Htf
')
i{;.f\' ;;flt'
I il' II" 11."'1' '..Ii ., <1\4 /JUI If"" #f ""t1 .'lIll
I ) Iff IIW wtllMNt . I'H'I'
h~~
"
"'.
....__._..,a..M.......... w' "'"-
"'__"""'~"""~~..~___~4__~M..~- -
C,\fl\(}1<I Q, C4"
(IMIII U,iWll !Ii1itt .. HI". III f\llll
f'"~
~A
(tMfII ....)
'i'-,-"
"'"
tA
11 WUAAI' I1,1f1t.\A"'.
I'hUftt U,
( I
, ;
, ;
, K )
1'P1 h"'!...MAlf>f~U{..
'f'"'"
AtIlHll''''
TIf"'"
lIfffUI IMf'" V.lliff'l
.
~
Tht IlilL L1,I will ~. ..11.4 fR
!.tII"lfi,) "M
-
.
"'
Inv IWHlt"!' !ie.ITA(. ..
l'lIlIJ.U' /iWlJu.... ".li,
'hilh ..,..nc. on I iU"(~f'
.
hUfUlt wUl t. ".llt on UOif'J"1
(111.,. .f' dut , 4&y, b.tgr. "..aA
n1&lI. )
(Tbf ",'y 11.elnl enl. .... tOf criJl.
.hlll ,fov14. h..lhwUh . toP)' d It..
'"1'1''' 10 .11 .oun..l, ,Ulluanc co
Ifla1 1\&1, HIt.l.)
(~MlItj
,..
,..~ 181
I'..:t.....
elf' _
lHift.. 1M t<<tflMr _Ill ftl tfI' Hit f9IlM 'if I,! ."" flItt WI "...',.' ~.;l".J tic..< 1"11...
~'1fHrifi' _N'fi8f. t.~.o,. 1MJJ ti~ hftr-.t ~t*r '~~rt:!&ii4u'll. ~A l'lttd
1tWIffJ* 1(. ~ iff -.,.,,,, 1/ llH"fJ; li.'Ii'~" \1. bfPf""c ""'/,d'"
-
~tl~~ f1/;,u. * "'4_.11".. J1,j~ tf1~~ifi-lt_-'it U4dLl.~~t; ~A i.UtlJ
--.
~- ,*,.,,,,, ~
..... . /I/l +-f%-
J;w ".... ,
,;,..~_.~-~
-~~.."""'~'"
-
~_~..L~.
~..:'.-
Pi,.
"{[H.., tft
r- ,,~ {j~l. r f
.
~;o;
~
tf ~"Z~ II
}i. '; I. " ~:'<
li'_ r'/~
,; ~f'
"
.
'-. ...
tJf. t"
Jill. ~"
q
If.
, IN THI COUIIIT 0' COMMON i'l.'M
, WHIt"WP CO., flNHIVLVAHIA
,
, CIVIL ACTION - ~W
,
, NO. .,-a'l CIVIL TlKM
,
, JURY TR'AL DIMANDID
IIICIIAJlO W. MAH&lAY,
'lllnt'"
110&.'1 .'IIIIIT HO.'ITAL ,na
~IIILLI' MAGUI"I, H.P..
0.'1""'"''
JIIl~ftlrll!..JlOUg, ro .,11I ,UII'''~IQ"JlUaoYIl1
uo.UUU...JO.D".~.rrl.IQ"r "WI-MaIn...
alDral"'II..,9V1....M,R~
,l.l"tl", IIIlch,rd w. Ma.'IY, ~v And thro"ih hi. "'.fn.y.,
Ar~In0 . Rov",r, ..e., ,..p~tlWllV "VII 'hi. "gnor.~I. Cow,. to
p".p.l ve,.ndanU HolV 'phlt 1I01,IUI ana ","Up MA'\Ilr., M.O. tv
,II. '\Ill .nd o~,II" ,n.V.f. '0 '1""""" 41'OOV'ry r.qu.."
fur th. follov'", ,.,.pn"
I. The tn.Unt ,oUon VII OPNnot4 by thtt flU", 01 .
c~.,laln' on Janvlry I'. I...,
I. on (I' '''eN' ,.tlrwuy II. I'''. 'hlnti".' hn",.,dtkl
\Q o.f.na."" Moly""" Mo"',al 'nd Ht,w'r. th"f
In\.ffQ9".rl.. ,na R'qu." for ',odwo",n of ~\I..n\.. A eo,y Q'
th... d'IQov.ry '..v.." ar. at'aoht4 al I.h'bl' -A-.
I. To dll', OIf.Mln' MolV .",., lloap",1 hAt n(l'
,..,onded '8 '1.'"'1"" In'.ff"".,l.. H... '-1, 11, It-I'. JO-
", 11-1., 10-11, Jt and )1, .nd ~.a' '(If 'rod~'l." ~,
'~Ov.f"\' Ho.. 1-.. lO-lt, aa, "-'1 .nd I.-II. Ind .a14 "'fVOI"
4f' l(llYf 0'1.,4114I.
.. "0 44\', Q41,.",...n' ....."". MI M" ,..,.1I4M .0
f"'~"t'" I~'.rf~.'~r'.. ~., )-tt 1-'" IO.ltt ~O" "-)0 .~ ;t.
l~. An4 R.~e.' ,or 'rP4yg,'on 0' OQou..n'l NQI. '-6, 10-10. aa,
;,.-n Ind JQ..n.
I, PI"naIR" nlve ,,'114 to oo.ply with the dlloovery
.. r.quir~ ~y ..,..C.f. NOI. 4001 .na 400..
.. AU Q' "" di,Q9V.ry .~h' by 'he '1tlnUtt thro\.lQh
IllI Int"fQ9a'.ri.. .nd hff\l'" r.f 'r04Il"thm 0' OOou.enh 1a
r.t.vlnl '0 the tn.t.nt a"tton.
1. PI'lnd.n'. hlVI had .ure tnan ..pl~ tt.. to ,e.pona
tu 'l.ln't"., In"frot."'I'1 lna ..qu..t '0' 'roduotlon of
rlO4/u..nh.
I
H
i
~
I, 01.1, "",.. PI cHvU 'ro,,"\lrl provtdl tor thl llbull
~r.ntl"9 0' 'l,,,.very,
t. '..".0.'. 40" ,rovtd.. I"" upon qUon 01 . party,
the Court Ny ukl an .pproprlAI. em.., \th.n . pu'y .'aU. to .Ako
dl'oOVtry-, ,....e.r. 401.(.)(vlll),
10. 'I.lntt', ~.l'.v.. t~' ,nlwetlnt 'l.lntl,'"
dl.oovery r~'lt' would not 5"rdtn Of .p,r"1 th. OI,anaent..
U. 'latoH"'1 @...n..1 ."e.,tl4 to r..olv. thil ..U.r
wtlh~t ..t.l", thll Honor.i'. C.ur", In,.rventton 10 .. not to
w~.,. th. (OUf"1 i'...
n. una., U,n. C.Hf@V..,.rtQ.., o.'.n4,n'l Ihould b.
~Q.,.IIf4 ,. ,..,@n4 ~1.,.11 .nd prOMptlv to '11 out.'.ndlnQ
41,QQv.ry f'~..\1 Qf ,.~ @QVr' ..",,".n..
WHUnOIlI, 1'1.'Al'" f"f"UIlUy ..lt4....... thi. Ilonorabl.
(.'I>>iJU \0 .,.,., . ~a. Ii,~m Off.Mot,.,. Holy .,h'" No.pi... and
~~af' '9 ,'(Wllk ,~U .114 f"f/l'" "...pq,..H \0 PI.intUI'.
1"'''f~.IQrt" .#14 ""j'" 'w.f t"~'l"" CO, f).NlIlI'Al. In I "..ly
I
I
,
I
,
.~
I
!
I
i
.
~
i
i
l
~
t4~A
/I "",,'
!"'"'\
.
.
,
rll4 111\ I ,,_. thriYijlt tnth .UifntlY, ".,.lI)' ffGptNM thl folllNh1lj
I'ihHI"<,fAUrl.. \9 11.(1"0011"" 'Ijf'~f'lt tfl ,.M.ylv,nl, Multi ~t
l'lvit I"fO~f.hUf 4(Hl(l "l tI. 1"'\IInN vi'hln ,hir'" (IOJ d..,. ""1'1
.."IV hi. \t\tI,flQf, 'ft.... InUff"."',I.. .hlU t.. 4....4 t9 ...
\c;:."..lrmIM Inun~4U'I", If tI.",.." \It. UN of '(Q\lf ,".w.nt Vel
"41(~ lIiUHWIlUr'.. And \I't! U.. flf tnf 'rid Cilf ,M. I.lUtl j'(i\l Pf
4hyt.r;1l fIll;i\IM (U1 yoot "(iIlIlU lu,n. ,tit ldfnUty Ind \IIt,n..tiQ\iU fif
4"'( liUH.r VUflil!tU liP' ,ali",,,,.4 in "(<If' ullI Ill'''''', {if if l'vY
(.,.1. In {if "...(.... "\IIn. {if ,,44'''(11\'1 f'lfjU...UI1 Illf{ifl!lIlUf.if\ ,\<.\
I> \IN' \ ,..4 In V4illr .'llI!WtlU, yw \tlt"n ffli'.pUV f\ttnltth tn. lUlU '{.t
,.141MHI,' .U!in..y *'V '1i""'~f\UI lli"W.rIIl.
~;~::rIi~~..~.':*:~i;Jtl~"~AA::~r1.=~~:;::
<1 11 QUllil[..J!t,t"f\.....,.(j.fi....lU.ntlu.tnu~~,t \lH' 4U~l",.w1
UHiH..tUn. ""bY" tltlfii fYfHlI,f 'M wi. .\1 J'.Uf.i1i1l ~f1 WiW.H.
l'I2MU d"".rnhnU rfi>lI."llfUi thll .€tlctll Ind "U p'UM" wM W III
l.""",f'" M 1;. Itl€fftlh' ii'(.Ii/'t(~ iiy \I'i' utltlU p' 'till lIa\lriJ'l, 'lvII'
.."'i"fiU to tli. InUrr€I(JlIUtl(ij Ihlll n"fJfJt .fllt flonhln H,.
kr".\il.<t'j. Qt Itll (if n,,, U(iV' fi.nlH'ill. It.fllt.ft.." tll V1.'J'i\ltf
A,,'VUr a.hifldllflt !li'liHl t.. Inun.uU4 .. ,1!'\lNI'" {if pluul.
",.r,,,'HH"'j up~n th. fiHth'Y1U (llriH;".'"fl'''.''' {,f .A<lh (iU..
HH. tlf-" NauQflr.thm" "I' "4u",I"." It \lu4 tH'f.ln .tiltH IJl!illl\ \Mt
till. lhlf."'tlllntl liMit ut f~nh ,", nUt. aM .4""u' (if th. "yUlOf
(Of ..r llJI nilH;r , ailh', uu. ~r 'li~"'.'" "iii".', tn. fr...nt
,.'\(lItl;..H'fl' III HI. (i,lq'lHll 1M liif 1f\1 ~~,Hllt, ilf~ hn krwwh
i4,t'~H'U (Of """ (lYlit@ltUn. N{j(1\gl,tMnt l"aU .nn ."y wrHhll,
l,nIlUl1, tYPld li'f fI'Il" 'Ira,,,,, NUn .., '"1 kiM, wt\iJUUH
iI. ,id;; I' Ut,". tVI'.4 fill' f' IntH. ~UI.r db" 1l1\1tiJ(l (if
uf..H.uH>iJt,H1. n litldl r+flu4t wiU,,,"\ U.iuUtln ,.tUnt,
"""('14114", nth.l.... ,tu4hIlJ. n@UtOIJlUI. (ll'fl,lI .nd n~t... lilt ...i i
... Ili ~'Qn'nl~.' ,"4 .l'~'r@nl~ li~un4 (,@@rdi~' ~f 'f'".Qfl~t"
th"r.~f In tli_ ~Qli....'~ft @f ~@RtrQI @f tilt a,'.~.n'. (if k"~w" ~i
H.". (I' tIllI.', "ltllIll .,... MilR .1 I @v,IU 91 11~(,lva..nU (.1
.It~,..v.r ...n. ~44..
"",,.n u~h ifltfffl"l4\(ifY IR th, ,,'n f@UtNlM U,. 'n\"f~"'l'f l'
"1~"J,'u,\"'jttl IIHUIUIMV .. t"l(lhf4 ,n /t"i\t.U wM6!h fti!li4Ul>
4.i'Hl. hmd IJJ"~'" 1'1.... Uk' '"'"". 'hAt Y(lij Uli' ftI{fijU.ul f('
UfV. 11 Ji(!/I (Ii. Yf",j.U'''~ y~lIr .n.lfn. in wfUI~ Itl'"," U.iny
(l11J a.y. fVrliy41l( \Q t,~.jyIY'nl' '~l. M' Civil fr(l~44IJJ. .VIJ~,
'tti.~" lftt."U(>I,J"fIi.UU Uf 4.'.*'" Iltl"UlYtil". 4~' ltl.tl'l'l.,..f1Ui
4",.",,,f. .tI~..IIJ riftnMlfkflY H IIrqdll.4,
,
,
I. UV"'''',",,, ,n forth lhe 10\10\11", d.l.U.
f.,.r41", )'@Vf fro'I..lon.' Iduo.tlon .04 ".,.r.'lon 'or ,rlo'ioe
.,.,. thl ,folt..lonal .onoo'C.1 .".04". d,"'.1 0' .l'eo4.no..
.nd y..f") of ,r.dYA'lon, plI01(" ,nd "flod(.1 of In'.rn.hl,,
n.... .00 ""'lllU.. of J>uQU\lonuI vb" 'rAlnM )'Q!,I d\lrl",
,"t.fnth'" "IO'('l Ind ,lrlode'l 01 r""lno)'1 .gD1lot 0'
f'.ldlnoy, ft.... 1M .plol.ltl.. .t "..'l',.n.r. ~ho ,,.In.4 )'ou
llilflnt f..ld.nu)', 'M n.'u,. .1\4 ,triN 01 .ny ,,.dl.ln. .tYCIi.. IncI
plI01'1' ~h'f' ,ur'\I".
1
.
r
...
I
3. .., forth thl I"...f ..oh ..4iod .r,"'i..'l.n vi'h
whioh you v.r. .ffl1i.,.4 .r .f whlGh yOU v.r. · .....r in 'h'
V"" ,... ..,.... .... ......... ... ... .... .. .... .......
oruln'l.tion viih whioh yOU .r. Gurr.nilY ,f'i1il't4 or ., whiGh
you ,re Qurrently . ..ab.t.
\
\
i
I
I
,
\
I
I
,
j
4
i
,
I
i
j
I
I
!
I
\
.
..
I
t. Arl you or haYI you .Ylr a\t..,\.o \0 bl Otf\ll'ld
bV anv .,..l.11\V ~.r4. II ". ..\ lorth the na.. .nd .44f'" of
..oh .,..a."y bo.r4, 'hi d.t. you w.r. 0.r",t.4. b.o... . ..ab.r
pr .U..,t.o ,. t;lone oerUI'.o, .nd it you Ifl no aO",1f
".,ta,... n . "UU, .,v. th. d.tl y,",r o.rUU'.Ucm or
"aP.r.h', WI' '.ratna'" .nd 'h. r.a.on lor 'h' .....
.
"
,
., (II' 11I.,,~UV tiy lII~hOf UU., .114 yur (If
fui/U..U.n, .v...y ,ourn.. t ,..,~"" ., .th., r.,....niJ, ln In\una.
llId/., '''''IRQ)' fH_ .M1Clln. llhion ye'l\l ,..uhrlY r"lffl4 \0
.n4l.r ,.11.. upon lor ,ft. y..r. 1"'-1"),
('" III.nUly.U ....mU.ut.n.. lnol\l41nt iN, "Q'
11.1'" ,. pap.,., 'QUrnAl .rllal... I'l'.,. to lhl ..llor,
,..'''"11., .y.p..hi..} nu.. I'Mf" yeu ."'hOl'14 .r ,onlflw'" 'Q.
."olultl", 'hi '1'1. Of 'h. vo,Il, 'h. nA" ., 'hi perlodlo.l or bOok
In Whlth ., v.. prln''', 'hi ,.,.. you Vf." .n4 'h. d." 01 11'
prln'lftfI.
I
r
r
.. 14.nUt)' .toh .".... oU,,'. or .\"er l".\&.n
,.s.Unt i. \I,. pr.oU.. ., Mdt.iM ..i,,'lined Ity yw. .r i" v1\toh
VOU .lh.rwt.. work", .~.tfY.n' ,. ,w, in'lrnlhl, .r r..id.ney
.nd .., t.nb 'h. intlll.iv. ..,.. )'0\1 ,,'nlliM4 ...h '\IOh
SOH".n.
,
'"
.
I. W.,. VOlA ..,"l",4 Of In partnn.hl, vith any 9th.,
..4lo,' prlotltlon.r 'or th. y..r. 1"'-1")1 I 10. "1" 'h.
n..., .4dr..., .p.gialty, 1n4 ,1A.ll'lo,tlon. of .Ioh p.f,Oft vith
who. you wn. '''OQllh4 Of in pntnn.hlJH 'hI M'lAn of YO"'f
pUI'n... r.'atlon.hlp to .lAoh plr,onl th. t.~. 1n4 OOn4l'lon. 0'
th. ,.,.Uc;nlhlp/ th. a.,. VOlA 'oru4 'hi ,.l.U,nIMpI "ti.'h... tl\.
r,ll"on.hlp .tlll ..1.\. 1n4, i' not, th. r..lon 1n4 dati 't v..
'.rain.,.41 ,n4 "h.th.r 'ny vflt'.n .,'....nt l.l.\e4 b.tw..n YOIA
and YOUf ,..OglAt.. or putnn. 1n4. i '0, th. ntH 1n4 ...,... 01
'h. p.,.on who h.. ou.t04y 01 'h. .'r....nt.
.
...
.
.
'1 hlanUI)' your .pa01l10 partlo1p.Uon in .nv hVluU;.
Qlv11 or ar .1ntl. othar th.n thl pra.ant on..
10
"
~
(
r
U. It you, ....on. 'f'llll,f on your b,h.., 01' loo.on. not
In ..pert ,u"'eot '0 ,., ..e... Mo. 400J.I, von4uot.4 Iny
tnv..",.U.n. .r \h. lnoi4.n\, id.nUt)'1 ...1\ p.....n. .1\4 Ui'
I.,loy.r ot ...1\ "f.on, WhO oon4uot.d any inv..,.,.t.one.), and
.U no'... upo," or o'hll' dlHfu..nu pr.pu'" lIIur.", or .. .
rl.ult ot 'h. lnYI.tl,.Clone.) 1n4 'h. p.r.on. WhO hay. Qu.tody
th.no' .
".... lon.ld.r 'hi. . a.qu..t I.f 'roduG".n 01 your
tRY..t.,.'lon f'fOr',
u
.
I'. PO fO~ olal. thlt th. PI.lntiff WI' eontrlbutorlly
or ~o.p.r.tlv.IV n.vltv.nt .nd/or 1..WI.d th. ri.k of in,urll' .nd
d..".. I' I.t forth in th. Co.pl.'n'? If th. In.Wlr to thi.
int.rrOVI'ory i. In thl .ttlra.tiv.. .tlta thl oont.ntion. whioh
you or Anyon. aotint on your behllf b'I' . olal. for oontrlbutory
or eo,plr.tiv, ".,lIV'not .nd/or I..wa,tion of th. rl.k.
,.
". Id.n\i'v ..oh ,.,..n who. you ..p.gt to g..I .. In
a.pnt "'it"... at 'h. \ri.I Q' thl. 41.... In ,(lOordl"'" ",Uh
fann.yIYlni. .ul. 0' ciYil "oo.dur. No. 400).' you '.Y 'i'. I'
Y.OYf .n."'., .n ..plrt r.,.rt Of h.Y. thl i"tlrr.w.to,a.. .n.",.r.d
bV 'hi ..,.rt, Th. .n''''lr .~.att.a .. . ..,.r.t. r.port .h'" ~.
"qnla ~y th. ..p.,t, With ,..p.o\ to ..oh p.,.on th" lOU l.pIPt
.0 0.1. I' ." ..per' ",itn... I' 'fi.1 0' 'hi. 0"', .tl .,
e.) n..., ,..ia.", .nd by.in... .4dr....., prof...ion .,",
eQQU,"Ion, 'h. Il... .na .adr... 01 hi. Of h., p,..'nt
..,IOy" Of. a, .."...ployed, thl n'" 01 'h. ~u.an...
.nd h . or hlf ooou,.'io",
CD) hi. Of h.r edu~.'ion.' ~.ok'fOYnd, ',Ioityl", oo'I.q..
.".n4ed, a.,.. 0' .'t,ndlno" a..r... .t,.in.d, .nd .
d"I'laa Ii., 0' III ""It'"" praplr'd Dy 'ha ..part ~r
In "'hioh 'hi ''''ft plr'lgi,.,.d 'n Iny ""y ",hl,.o.v.r,
el) thl ..,Uon. InohuH", th. Hur' Ind \look., nug., 01 .ny
.'h'f 0.... In Vhioh thl ..,." hi. p.rtIQip.'.a in .nv
,..hion einqlv4'", d,po."'Qn., h..,lnq., 0' .ny o'h.,
p,....ai"9 ~I'hln lh. '1" 10 V..r.),
(eI) 'h. H,Uon. Inqlv4l", o.ur' .n4 dHIl., n~., ot .nv
..tion ,. ~ivh "Oft "P'" h.. -'.n . ""y,
(.) 'h. '"'"' uner on ",hiGft h. or .h. " ",,"ed I'
"""y .nd 'h' ',Q', tnd .,inion. ,. vhlQh h. or .h. I'
..,.,," '" ",,"y .n4 . .UNlry ,f th. .,ound. IOf ..ch
.,'n"ln,
(It "",.'h" In. '''''I .n4 opini,", U.'1li In 'h. .to"v.
In'.'fot.,.,I.. .f. "nl.in.~ In . ",,"'.n r.,ort,
....flnd~ ., fi\h., ".n.nlp' .nd. " 'h'Y U', ,IYI 'n.
N.. ,n4 .14'." (i' th. pr...nt ,"'.'liI4Hln .f 'h. .... .na
.1'" ""'.,,..., Y"" "'I U ,'.'11.'0' .... ",Ithov' th. n...nav
., , MUon,
th. .,,'hOf. 'i"., d.t, .nII pw511.h.r of .ny ,f.iQ'..
".,. p.,I 0' . "_1, 'f..'i... ,.,., 0' .,..oh of .ny
.'hlr ..y,~ .f Inf,,.."on upon ~h'oh th. ..,.r' ",ill
f.ly in .."...1", hi. .,'"I.n, And
I'.nl'fy .11 ".v..n'. .~.I"~ ,. 'h. ..,." .n4 'II
,re4lltJU If IH"" In'r:"'ed lor th' ..,.n 'n .fnn,,,' hm
~I'h ,..,.,.'It" Iff h . .f h" ,..'i~ny.
Ct)
CtI)
II
..
r-
n. It It II your oontention that you wara not na\lUllent.
with rl.p.ot to t.r..t..nt of Plaintiff" oondition, providl t.h.
flotl lupporUn9 that oont.ntion, id.ntity Iny documlnh oontainlrll,J
faota lupportlnll th.t oontantion, identity of .aoh individual who
hu knowladlll of a flot .upportinll thlt oontention, the idlntity of
aaoh Individual who w111 t..tity to tha taote .upportlnll that
oontention, and a aunary of thl aubltanol of the talti.ony of ..ch
indlvldu.l idlntifiad hlr.ln.
10
ao. It you oontend th.t anoth.r lncUY1du.1 "'II neqHQ.nt
or In .ny v'V r..pon.1bl. or that any oth.r Indlvldu.l 1.
re.pon.lbl. for Rlch.rd a....y'. injurll' .. alle,ld 1n the
eo.pl.lnt, plt..e .tat. the taotual b..,. tor your oontent1on,
identity any dooua.nU oont.inlnQ t.otl .upportln\J that contention,
the .ann.r in wh1ch the Individual.. d.eorib,d i. re'fon'1bl' tor
the Injurie., the Identity ot the indiyiduIl who viI t..tlty to
any t.ot In eupport ot your .n.",er herein, .nd a .u...ry ot the
t..tl.ony ot ..oh Indlyidua' id.ntltied In r..pon.. to thl.
lntnrQ9ltory.
u
-.
a2. 'Of ..eh non...pert ",ltn... who you Int.nd to oil'
.t trill. proYlde thelr n..., addr... and ,.Iephon. nuab.rl th.lr
rel.tlon to you, l' any, .nd . .uaa.ry ., th. '.ot. ..oh vl11 olt.r
Into t..,laony.
aa
n. In'lInn"l, ... It YOII If. lJov.,ftd by anv typ. of
In,uf.no., tnoludl"9 .ny ..0." or uabr.lla in.urlno./ tha' .ith'
~. Ippll..bl. to th. InQld.nt in 'hi. ""'f, .tl" th. l011owl",
",lth ....,.0\ to f1.,h IUQh poUoy, 'h. nu. of the In.ur.ne.
olr,l., "'hQ 1"u'4 'h. ,01loy, 'h. na..a Inaur.a und.r ..on policy
lna th. polioV nuab.r of .Ioh po1tay, 'h. 'yp.e.) .nd .tllo'IY.
dlt.e.) 01 .aoh polloy, th. ..ount 0' ooy.r.,' provld.a for in'ury
to .aoh ,.,.on, tOf I.gh ooourr.na., lna In 'h. ."f..a'. for 'Ioh
polloy, lna ..oh ..glu.lon, if .ny, 'n 'h' polloy whloh I.
.ppUlllbl. t. .ny ol.l. thlflunau .nd any r.llon., it any, why VOu
or 'h' ol,rl., 01.1. 'h. 'MQlu,lon I. a,pllo.bll.
u
It, (.) Id'ntl'y .ny oth.r ..lIlotlll (lU"'''I..n." nllfU,
Pliny .th., "".n. "'t'h whet yO" (Jonlul't4 ('or..lly Of
Inht,.a'h) oonotrnlnq 'ha dle,no.te Andler tn"..n' 0'
"aintl,,}, oondltlon fo, ",ht~h h. lou,h' four ..aio.l tf..,.."t,
(lI) Givl 'h. da"U. 0' 'he uon.ulhUon, InolucUnt
IUPI'.no. ot oonlull.llon, 'Indlnq., irl.'..nl, ana
r.Q....na.tlon.. All' Identl'y 'he "n.uit.nt by n..., QOQUf.t.ont
'li"l a44f"', 'f'. 0' .paQlall..tlon Ind ,rof...ion.
r,l., on.hl, t. you, ih. d.'e, ,... 0' diY, nl'Ufl, Ind '0", .,
)'INf r.qu... 'n I ..n.uHa\lon, 'h. "Uu,. .nd 'Hf' 0' 'hi
u,lnlon ,iVI" ~f ihe oon.ultl"9 'f".I.ion.I, lhl idlnt ty ., Inr
d~u.ant In Iny way f.I.'lnt t. .Ioh .on.utiltton, and I.'i,n tak.n
" I f"ul' Of 'h. ..~ul'.'t8ft.
n
11. MAY' r'~ Of Veur ,.un..l, .r InV9A, .,.. on Vtijr
p*htl' H"lIO\" .ny .f ,llln\"". "..'int phyalgiln(.) involved
In Inv t..M'" '" )"Intl"'. flU', It '1.', 1'''''\ "" "... 01
J'hy.lgl.n ",,'IOU4, dati, U.., An4 lHIUc;n .t ""Ug\ .nd
dl ""'"I,,,, Ill.. 1n4 144re.. .t .nvtlm. .he ,r...n', Ind 'hi
Iden'lly 0' .ny dGQ~.nt, not., flOOf4, ..aor.n4I, I."., or Iny
~'h., re4uQ'lon ., in'eraa'l'" " I 'Inti&l. to" flflrdi", IIQh
oon'-.\.
at
n. With nqard to y.-ur "..ta.n' ., ""nUll, .tat. In
a.tall 'h. ..dlol' hi.tory 01 'I.lnt"t r.llt.d to you 'h. 'Ir.t
tt.. you ",.r. In oont,o\ ""th "Ilntlt" '''y oth.r "d'o.1 hl.tory
YOII hun.d r.,udlnq ".IntU', I 00""" allorlpUon 01 .U
I'tly.loll IIl..inltion(') whloh you rnto....d (In ",lntU', 'noludinq
the un of your ttndinq. 'hue roa' any laboratory or .iaUar
'e.t. p.r'o....a by you or ,t your dlr.o"on, Inolud'nt th. r.,u't'
th.r,'ro., .nd the Id.nt"V 0' .y.ry dooualnt oont.lnlnt
rl.lntltl'. 11410.1 hi'tory, r..ultl 01 Iny phy,'oll ....Inltlon,
or l.bor.tory t.lt.
II
ll. Il.t. Qo.pl.t.1V .nd in d,\.'1 ,y.ry opinlon that
y@~ ,.'Ionally or Inv p,r.on ..ploV.d by YOY wl'l '1Y' It trill
(lon".,,,I", .uh of th. to11O\lll,," ar..., 'h. .Undnd ot 101....
Ippllolbl. \Q thl. ~II" your Qo"'o~.no. or non.QonIQ~'''o' vlth
the '''Mnd .t ontl Iflr ottlff phy.lohnl' or h..lt.hQIf' Pfovlct.u
(l4nf(lin~IM' 0' Mno"I.'ffl ",..,'1\(11 w Uh th. ",nd.rel ot on" UI'
.~l.t.nQ' Q, non-..l.t.na. (lif n'''11Q.no. on you, P'fl or \h. p.rt
ot Anv p."on p.rtlolpltlOQ in tl.ln'1ff'. 0"" th. pr".nQ. or
'Ick yf I olu...l oOIU\'{lU~n b.""..n your tr..tl.nt and th. Iniur'"
.'I'Q'4 In th. Co.pl.lnt, wh.th.r tll1ntifl'. gond~ot oontrlbut.a
in .ny fa.hlo" to hl. lnjurVI what th. outoo.. In Mieh.rd J....y'.
ou. w""ld h.y, to..n, h.1I hi. 'PPlnalo'''1 t;..n dll,no.~ Ifld
trfllted .nUn thin tn. U.. hi "'" I'\l.h~ \0 >>olY .plrit >>o.plUI
(in I/n/U,
u
..
I
u. ror .aoh opl"lon in the prloedl", InUrr09ltory
It It. thl 'a.,uII ~..1. lor tha' oplnlon, 11., .v.ry t..tbOok or
portion 01 the .edlo.l ll,.rltur. you oon.ulttd or r.l11d upon ln
'oral", 'h., .pl"10n, and It not h.retoror. provl..d .uaaarl.. th.
vround. 'or .Ioh oplnlon.
It
,...
r
'4. It VOU oontend no", or It you ",111 oontend at trial
that the treat.."t utl11..d by vou In tr.atlnQ ,111ntltt'.
condition "'I' conll.tlnt vlth the reoOfnl..d ..thod' oont.ln.d In
.'d1eal 11t.rlture, provld. by luthor, tltl', publioatlon ana dlt.
of publioaUon, ..01'1 r.ter.no. upon "'hloh you wiU ba.. th.t
cont.nUon.
It
r
JI. I. th.r. any lntoraatlon record.d In Holy 'pirlt
"o.pltll'. ...rvency roo. r.oor.. t~r th. 1/11/1' Id.l.llon whloh
YOU p.r.onally dtd not r.yl.v at Of n..r the tl.. the not. 1. dlt.d
nth. chlrt' It '0, proyld. the Idlntlty ot .Ioh not. ",hioh you
did not r.vle", nelr the tl.. It va. "'r1tt.n, .wpla'n why the not.
"'., not r,vl.",.d, .nd .tlt. wheth.r the not. "'I' .VI' r.vl.wed ~y
you, Ind If 10, ",h'R Ind Und.f what olro~.tlno",
It
.
r
RICKARD W. RAMlAY,
'lalntUf
Y.
tlOLY "IIUT "O.,ITAL .nd
ftuLLI. MAQUUll, H.D.,
OtiC.Rd.nt.
t
I IN THI cocntT or COMMON PUAI
I CUMIIMWD CO., ,IHHIYLVAMIA
I
I CIVIL AOTION . LAW
I
I NO. ...a'l CIVIL TIRM
I
I JURY TRIAL DlMAHOID
''''111'I'11''' tllTl.IQG~Ul.II' raotommlD uto.
o.r'ND~ IQLY l.l~IT _O.r~TA~ . IJ"~ I-r
TO,
It.y.n 'nyd.r, I.qulr.
MITTI, IVAN. , WOOD.IDI
'401 North 'ront .tr..t
Harrl.bur9"A 17110
f
ji
i
I
!
!
OATil Ftl>tudIUIli,ltM5
i\"'*'
AlfGllfO . ROVIfn, P.C.
n.
1.0. .... .
410J North 'ront .tr..t
Klrrl.bur9,'A 17110
~ln) u...,n
Attorn.y tor 'lalntlff
,'Idntlth, throu\lh th.ir .ttorn.y, hn.by prOI)Ound tho 10110lilnll
IntntotJAtorl.. to d.flndlnt. puuu.nt to I'.nn.ylvlni. Itul. at
civil rtoc.duro 4006 to b. In.li.r.d ",ithin thirty ()O) dlY' fro_
141"....10. th.nof. Thll. JntnroQltorh, .hlU be d....d to 110
contlnulnQ InUrtoqltorl... It b.tv..n tho ti.1f or your .nlw.rI to
laid Int.r,oqAtorl" Ind tho ti.e of the trl.1 of thi. 0'" you or
IInyon. .otin9 on your b.h.1I l.arn. the id.ntlty .nd wh.rllbout. ot
/lny othor wltna.... not ld.ntifl.d in your ..1d an.w.r., or It you
oblaln or b.colllo .war. of Iddltion.l r.qullto.s info....Uon not
IIuppl lid In your .n,worl, you .hlU pto.ptly turnllh the .... to
pl"lntlff.' attorn.y by .uppl...nt.l Inlw.r..
tor the purp.o... at th... Jnt.;o.r rrr~ .torl.., "~~u" or "y~U " r.for.
to tho l1tttlll.tlnt.- tnd UlUt-Ulu, the IlIl.nrJ'll 1 11IuuncI1!
~QlIl1!llnY_..nlLU..t..tilu, the IltUrutIPt,-I . II, Ind
111 Lut!lflt._llIUJ2n......a..u.nt. _ Qf UDl'lItnU . Cd tilL lSu-.w1lnt.l ,.AnlJ
lhdLJUU. "You" Ihll11 turUI.r inolud. .11 p.uon. on whou
behlllt dofend"nt. prCl..cut. thh .ction Ind III p.tlon. who will
honotH M b. 1091111y bound by the rllua. 01 thl. .otlon. Your
IInlwon to the InhrrolJltorl.. .hl" fltI.et Ind contain tho
knowlodq' of all of tho abov. perlon.. Refer.nc.. to plAtntlff
lind/or It'flnd"nt .hall be lnt.rpnhd .. aln(Jular or p'uul,
dopoMlntJ upon the pArticular "Ireu..tane.. ot lIeh c...,
ThO t'rlll "dlJl!cript Ion" or "dncrlb." .. und h.reln .hdl IlIl1n thllt
tho IIl,tondl,"U .h.n u' forth the nU' Ind addu.. of till Author
ur oriqlnator, dA'.', title or lubj.ct .att.r, the pr..ent
L'uetmJl4nl of the orlqln'l and of .ny cople., IInd lAit known
/lddr... of ..ch cultodl.n. "l)OQu..ntol IhAl. ....n any "'rltun,
prlnted, typad or othn qraphio ..U.r of .ny kind, wheth.r
hAndwritten, tyr.ct or rrlnt.d, \lhether dlltributtd Pr
undhlrlblltod. H . hill 1 1'01114. without lI.itation l.tt.n,
~lllIII0f41l11.. .rt Illla., l'udl'I, noUboolli, dlarla. .nd not.., .1 well
~I all 1II0ehant".1 and .Io"tronl" .ound recordtnqi or tran.orlpt.
thor.ot In the po.....ton or control of the dorendant. or kno\ln by
tholll to ui.t. It .hlU 11.0 lIl..n .U eopi.. ot docu..ntl bV
Wh4lllver .o.n. IIIl1de.
AII.w.t ..vh I ntor rllal' ory In the Ipll"O follo"'Inll the int.rroq.torv,
tlul'l'lu.nh1 "1"'" III.V h AttAoh.d tor AnllWlU whloh r.qulre
IllhHtlcmal .~.co. I'leu. taka notl"a U,,' you .u Uq\lIr.d to
Norv. upon the un4.rMlqn'd your .n.wer. In wrltt"~ \ltthtn th~rty
(IU) ~dY' pur.u~Nt to r.n".y~v.nl. ~ul. of c~v~I ~rQQ.dur' 4aO~.
"110" I nhrrc:ul4t or I., u. d..IIM Qontlnutrv" .nd I "(lpl.lII.nh1
4n.w.r. .hould r'4IQn4~ly b. proylde4.
:J.
action or it.
npr..ontlt1vo
and addn.. of
whon Ind wh.n
...
I
lIav. you <<Jiven any atato.ont(.) concernin9 thh
oubj.ct ..tter to anyonal. includin9 an a9.nt or
ot your inaurana. carrierl It 00, .t.t. tho nlme
.ach p.r.on to whom the .tatemont wa. 9iv.n, Ind
.uch .tato.ent w.. 9iven.
Pl.... con.ider th1l . nqu.at to producll tho..
.tate..nt. reterr.d to in tho above anow.r.
4
l
r
r
4. It you know ot anyone that h.. qivan Iny .tlt.gant
(aa datined by the Rul.. ot Civil Prooadura) oonoernin9 thi. action
or it. .Ubieot .attar, .tlta the idantity ot .uoh parlon, whan,
whara, by whom, and to whoa .aoh .tlt...nt w.. ..da, Ind whath.r it
wa. r.duo.d to writin9 or otherwi.. r.corded, and tha identity ot
any p,r.on who h.a cu.tody ot any .uch .tat..ant that wa. reduo.d
to writinq or otherwi.a recordad.
.
.-
I
5. IIIV. you or Inyon. actlnll on your b.half conducted
any inv..tillltion. of the ..dical car. which i. the .ubj.ct .atter
ot thi. cc.plaint? If .c, .tat. the na.., Iddr... and e.ploy.r of
all p.reon. who conduot.d any inv..tillation., the dat,e ot the
lnv..tillation" and the dat.e of any r.port. of any lnve,tillltione
and the id.ntity of the par.on. who have po.....ion ther.ot.
PI.I.. oon.ld.r thh a requ..t to produoe your
inve.till.tion r.port.
.
r
r
6. Do you claim that the Plaintift wae contributorilY
or comparatively neqliqent and/or .e.umed the riek ot injuri.. and
damaq.. a. lit forth in the complaint? It the anewar to thil
interroqatory ia in the attirmative, .tate the contention. which
you or anyone Icting on your behalf ba.e . olaim for contributory
or comparative neglig.nc. and/or a.eumption of the riak.
,
1\
'I
,
,
I
,
I
,-
(
7. II thare any peraon who hu knowl.dq. or information
concernin9 thi. oa.e who.a nema and addre.. i. not li.ted in the
pr.cedinq an.wer. to interroqatori.., other than the named
Detendant. and their coun.e1? For each peraon, pl.... etate
hi./her name, addr..., oocupation, and place of .mploym.nt.
.
I
'.
r
r
9. pookg, magazine., etc. ~. If you int.nd to u.e any
book, maqlzine, or other .uoh writing at trial, .tate the name of
the writ1nq, the author of the writ1nq, the publhhlt' of the
writinq, the date of pUblication of the writinq, and the identity
of the au.todian of the writing.
10
II
(f)
name, re.ident and bUlline.. addre..II', profea.ion and
oocupation, the name and addr... of present employer or,
if .eU.employed, the name of the bu.ine.. and hil or her
oocupation,
eduoatlonal back9round, .peoUying colleges attended,
datea of attendance, degr... attained, and a detaUed
list of all writing. prepared by the expert or in which
the expert partioipated in any way whataoever,
the oaption, inoluding the court and docket nUlIlber of any
other oasel in which the exp,rt has partioipated in any
fa.hlon (including deposition., hearing., or any other
proc.eding within the laat 10 years),
the caption, inoluding court and dook.t number of any
Iction to which eaoh expert haa been a party,
the .ubj.ot matter on which he or .he is expected to
te.tify and the facts and opinion. to which he or ahe ia
IXpeoted to t..ti fy and a summary of the r,Jround. for uch
opinion,
whether the faot. and opinion. 11.ted in the above
interrogatorie. art contained in a written report,
.elllorandulI or other tranaoript and, it they are, give the
nIUD. and Iddr..a of the pre..nt cuatodian of the ..me and
atate whether you w11 1 produce aa.e without the neoe..ity
at . motion'
the author, title, date and publhher of any artiole,
text, part of a text, tr.atiae, paper or apeech or any
other .ource 01 informltion upon which the .xp.rt will
rely in expra,.ing hia opinion,
Id.ntity III dooue.nta .ubmitted to th. .xp.rt and all
produot. or 10011.. in,p.oted by the .xpert 1n conneoUon
w1th preparation tor hi_ or her t..timony.
10. IdentifY eaoh peraon whom you expeot to oall aa an
expert wltne.a at the trial of thi. case. In accordance with
Penn.ylvania Rul. ot Civil Procedure No. 4003.5 you may file aa
your an.wer an expert roport or have the interrogatorie. an.wered
by the export. The an.wer aubmitted a. a .eparate report shall be
eigned by the expert. with respect to eaoh porllon that you expect
to call as an expert witne.. at trial of thie ca.e, atat.,
(a)
(b)
(0)
(d)
(.)
I
f
(g)
(h)
11
~l
,'-'
I
13. If you contend that any othor individual wae
noqllgent or in any way reeponsible Qr that any other incHvidual is
re.ponsible for Richard Ramsay's injuries aa alleqed in the
complaint, plea.e state the taotual basia for your contention/
identity any documente containing facts lIupportinq that contention,
the manner in which the individual as desoribed i8 respon.ible for
the injuries/ the identity of the individual who will testifY to
any tact in support of your answer hereinr and a 8ummary of the
te.t1mony of eaoh individual identified in re.pon.. to thh
interroqatory.
\
I
I
l'
Ii
I!
I
,:
ij
~
II
i
14
r
r
15. For e.oh non-eKp.rt witne.. who you intend to call
at tri.l, provide th.ir n..., addre.. .nd telephone nuaber, their
relation to you, if any, and a .umm.ry of the f.ct. each will otf.r
into t..timony.
II
Ii
Ii
16. In.uranee. -- It you are covered by any type of
in8uranee, including any exee.a or umbrella in.urance, that might
be applicable to the incident in thia matter, atate the tollowin9
with rup.ct to each luch policy I the name ot the indurance
carrier who i.au.d the policy, the named inaured under eaeh policy
and the policy number ot each policy, the type II) and ettective
dat'(I) ot each policYI the amount ot coverage provided tor injury
to .ach p.raon, tor each occurrence, and in the aggregate for each
policy I and each exclusion, if any, in the policy which i.
applicable to any claim thereunder and any reason., it any, why you
or the carrier claim the excluaicn il applicable in thil ca...
1'1
I
I
r
r
1.. '1.... d.,orlb. Phillip "IQuir." po.ition, role,
r..pon.ibl1it'.., dutiee, Ind/or jOb at Iloly .pirit lIo.pitll fro.
t~. yelr. 1'" throuVh 1'" inolu.iv.. Pl.... Inolud. the nuab.r
or hour. worked and how a..IVRlent. or .oh.dulinv "'.. determined.
g
I
i
I
I
I
,
I
j
~
~
i
!
,
I
,
~
I'
IV. Id.ntify each rul., policy, proc.dure, re9ulation,
quid.llne, in.truotion, reoomm.ndltion, .anull, handbook,
cOll.ction of ord.r. or notio. Ind/or oth.r docum.nt. in ett.ct
durino the y.ar. IVV2 throuoh 19V3 !nolu.!ve .t the Oelendant Holy
Spirit lIolpital rGqardin9 the component. ot appropriate
oar'/examination., dlaono.i. and tr.atm.nt of Ipp.ndloitl. and/or
Icute abdom.n and the criteria for plrtoraan"e ot Ibdominal .uron')'
in the Itorementioned pltient..
~
i
!.
I
I
!
It
r
20. Ollor1be your courae ot tr..tlDent tor Plaintiff
apart froll what II nporhd in the .edied rlcord. thlt are
routinely luppli,d throu9h a ..diell euthorla.tion.
!
I
I
n
24. o..crib. in detail every di.ou..ion or contact of
any nature which you had with plaintiff or any .ember of hi. fa.ily
reqardinq hi. .,dical condition, treatment or die9no.i. or Iny
other relevant .atter. The de.crlption .hould include, but not be
limit.d to the time and place of the di.eu..ion, the identity of
any dooument, note, reoord, memoranda, letter or any other
roduotion of information to a tanqibl' form reqardinq .aeh contaot,
the .ub.tanee of what you laid to the identified individual, the
eub.tanee of what th, identifi.d individual .aid to you, and what
eonolu.ion. cr a..umption. you dreW from your oonver.ation with the
identified individual.
J'
ij
I
I
i
.,.
u. With u\lud to your tr..ta.nt or PIIlnUtt, .tlte In
dotall the .edloll hi.tory ot Plllntlrr rellt.d to you thl rlr,t
tl.. you wlr. In oontlct with Pllintlff, Iny othlr ..dloll hl.tory
you learnld tI\llrdlnq Plaintiff, I ooapl.tt dllorlptlon of .11
phyalcll ew..ln.tlon(a) whloh you f.rfO,.ld on 'Illntlff, inoludlng
the lilt or your tlndln\l' thlrl ro" .ny laboratory or IlaUlr
tl.t. p.rfo,..d by you or It your dlr.ctlon, lnoludln\l thl re,ult.
thor.tro., .nd thl idlntlty or Iyery docu.ent oontllnln\l
Plaintlff'l .edloll hlltOry, r,lult. or Iny phy.lo.l ....in.tion,
or laborltory t..t.
t
~
i
~
f
i
,
i
i
~
!i
r
at
(-
... a.latlon.hlp b.tv..n ho.pltll ana pr.otltloner. ..
Id.ntlty eaoh .nd .v.ry oontr.ot or othe.r doo~..nt 'Itlbl1Ihl", or
uthervl.. r.t.rrln9 to the relatlon.hlp ~et"'e.n Holy 'plrlt
Ha.pitll and Ph'lllp MI;Ulr.{ M.D., Ind/or hi. e.ployer Ind/or
dooy..nt relltl", to the prlvl .,.. 9rlnted by Holy .plrl\ HOlpltll
to Phillip "I,U're, M.D.
I
I
,
w
~
I
I
i
I
I
I
~
! "
,
1
1
~
1
j
!
r
r
21. st.t. with plrticul.ritv the flctu.l b..ia for ..oh
det.n.. you .r. ....rtin~ in thi. olai..
.1
.,
r
(
:10. It you ever con.ultacS with any other prlotit1oner in
conneotion with the oare IncS treat.ant of the plaintiff/pltient,
Bet forth the dlta(a) ot the oonaultation, the icSent1ty Of the
praotitioner, the aUbjeot .attar of the conaultation, aotion tak.n
.. . re.ult of the oonaultltion, ancS the icS.ntity of Iny cSoou.ent.
ralatinq to the conaultation.
)I
(h
f
31. Identify by naml, la.t known addre"l phone number
and employment pOlition .very perlon who.e handwrit n; appear. on
the note. forI Richard Ram.ay). January 21, lee3 .merqlnoy room
admi..ion to Holy spirit Ho.pital.
I
f
I
I
JI
32. state completely and in detail every opinion that
you perecnally or any pereon employed by you will give at trial
concerning .ach ot the tollowing areas I the atandard ot care
applicable to thi. ca." your contormance or non.contormance with
the etandard ot care, any other phyeiciane' or healthcare providera
contormance or non.contormance with the .tandard ot care, the
exietence or non-exi.tence ot negligence on your part or the part
ot any per. on participating in ~laintitt'a care, the pre.ence or
laok ot a cau.al connection between your treatment and the injuriee
alleged in the Complaint, whether ~laintitt'e conduct contributed
in any taahion to hi. injury, and
what the outcom. in Richard Ram.ay'. ca.. would have be.n, had hi.
condition been diagno.ed and treated earli.r than the time he wae
ruehed to Holy spirit Hcepital on January 22, 1993.
u
(
(f
n. For ..ch opinion in the priced in., Interr09ltory
8tat. the factual ba.il for thlt opinion, liet Ivery textbook or
portion of the medioal lit.r.tur. you oon.ult.d or r.lied upon In
tormin., that opinion, ond It not h.r.tofor. provided lu...ria. the
qroundl tor .ach oplnicn.
!\
i
u
.
r
'4. It you oonten4 now or It you will oontend at trill
thlt the treat.ent utlll.e4 bV you In tr.atin9 .lllntitl',
oondition w.. oonai.t.nt "'Ith the r.o09ni.ed .ethod. oontlln.d In
.e410.1 l'tlrlture, provide by luthor, title, publioatlon .nd date
ot publlo.tion, ..oh reter.noe upon ",hioh you wlll b... th.t.
oontlntion.
eERTlrlCATE or 8ERVleE
I hlr.by clrtlfy that I, Dllnl R. Lut.., an.~ploYII of Angino
. Rovnlr, P.C., h.v. thia 2J1M day of I?tIlilll/tl(', 1115,
..rvld . t1'\l1 and cornet copy of PLAINTIFF'I INTIRROGATOIUII
PROPOUNDED UPON DEFENDANT 1I0LY SPIRIT 1I0SPITAL - FIRlT liT upon
d.tlndant.' Goun..l by ..ndlng .1.. Unltld It.t.. tlr.t-ola.. .Iil,
poatag. prlplld, .ddr....d I. tollow"
It.v.n D. Snyder, Eaquir.
HITTE, EVANB . WooDBIDB
3401 North Front Str.at
P.O. DolC &150
Hlrrl.burg, PA 17110-0'50
Attornlr for Det.ndant. 1I01y Ipirit Ho.plt.l .nd
Phlll . H'''l~.. H'~
~h
In', ..
-"""
r
f
v.
, IN TlfE eoURT or COMMON PL!A8
, CUMBERlAND eo., 'Il:NNIYLVANIA
,
I CIVIL ACTION w LAW
I
I NO. 9!i-all CIVIL TERN
I
I JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
RICHARD W. RAHJAY,
pl,lntHt
1I0LY SPIRIT t10SPITAL and
PIIILLIP HAQUIRI, N.D.,
o.t.nd.ntl
'!.AInu". UQI1..!' 1'0. PIlOQpQfIOlf or DOQUKBlf'l'~
~ DI'IND~ IOLY 'PlIlI!' ao.rJ!'AL w ',Ra!' ..!'
TOI stlvln D. snyd.r, Ilqulra
KETTE, IVANS . WooOSIDE
'401 North rront streit
P.O. Boll DUO
t1arrl.burq, PA 17110
PLEASE TAKE NOTICI that pur.uant to 'a. R.e.p. Noa. 400).4 .nd
4009, pl.... turnllh at our expln.e, at our ottlc., on or b.torl
thlrty (30) d'YI Itt.r ..rvlol hlrlot, I photo.tltlo oopY or llk.
r.production ot the ..tlrhl. conc.rnlnq thh action or it. .ubjlct
.attar whlch al'l in your po.....lon, CUltody or oontrol, and ",hleh
arl not protect'" by the .ttornly/ol hnt prlvlll\J" or, In the
alternative, produo, thl .atd ..tter at ..Id ti.e to p.nlt
lnlpeotlon Ind oopylnq th.rlof'
1. All atat...nh, .uaaarl'l of .tate..nt., tran.crlptl
of rlcorded .tlt..lnt. or lnt.rvll"", reoorded It.t...nt. if not
tranaoribed, or Iny auaaary of r.oordad .tlt...nt. r'l.tlnq to,
referrino to or 1n any way d..crlblnq tbl. loUon/ IYlnt., or
.ub'.ct ..tt.r ot thl. lult.
'l"'l~
a. All doou.enta prepared by Detendant, ita agenta or
employeea or anyone aotin; on ita behalt, durin; an inveeti9ation
of the allaqation. and eventa which are the aubject .atter of thia
ault, or prepared in antioipation ot litl9ation Dr trial of thia
matter, exoludino the .ental i.preaaiona, oonoluaiona or opinlons
of ita coun.a!.
3. All photQ9r1pha, fU.a Dr vidlotap.. taken in reOlrd
to thia incident.
4. All .tate.enta of any eyewitn.aa(e.) to the
treat.ent rendered to the patient.
~. All atate.enta of any perlon(a) who will be oal1ed
a. a witn... at trial or who. you cr anyone aotinq on your behalt
ha. oontacted reoardino thia .atter (other than experta retained
tor the purpoae. of litlqation).
6. A oopy of the documentation .oat recently .ubmitted
to the Pennaylvania Medlcal Licenaino BOlrd docu.entino your
continuinq .edical education.
7. All .edlcal Irticle. reviewed and con.ulttd in
ant1oipltion ot l1tiqat1on or trhl, ",hich will be u..d for
purpoa.a ot oroaa-exa.ination at trial.
I. All docu.enta or other de.on.tratlve .vidence whioh
will be introduced at trial.
t. A current curriculum Vitae tor each exp.rt expected
to be cllled by Defendent to t.etlty It trial.
10. All inv.at19Itlon., report., incident report., tl.t
re.ult., drevift9a, .~etch.e, euaaarle. or recorda ot thia incident
a
i
,
and the .vent. .urroundlnq thl. lnold.nt, lncludlnq .ame prepared
by repre.entatlv.. ot your 11abl1lty oarrler.
11. AU documente, lnoludlnq but not lhllted to report.,
record., note., .ummarle. prepared, q.nerated or obtaln.d by any
lnve.tlqator employed by Detendant or it. ooun.el to lnv..tlqate
thl. matter.
12. An ltemlzed .tatement ot any and all charqe. tor
e.rvlce. rendered to plalntltt..
13. Any and all document. r.t.rred to ln any An.wer to
any Int.rroqatory or u.ed by the Detendant ln re.pondlnq to the
plalntlft.' Int.rroqatorl.. tll.d ln thl. law.ult oth.r than
.edlcal record. prevlou.ly .upplled.
14. Any and all docum.nt. contalnlnq lnto~atlon
relatlnq to any an.w.r to any Int.rroqatory.
15. Any Ind III record. relatlnq to your prot...lonal
oontaot wlth Plalntift, other than .edloal reoord. pr.vlouely
.uppUed.
16. Any and all ",rlt1nq., ...oranda, r.port., .taU.ente
and record., eto., whloh you and/or your oompany and/or oU.nt
po..... concernlnq the care, exa.lnatlon, trelt..nt, lnv..tlqatlon
or r.vl.w ot plllntltt and thl. 01.., other than ..dlcll reoorde
pr.vloully lupplied.
17. Any and all .xpert opinlon., expert report., exp,rt
.ua.ariee, or other writinq. of expert. to be uI.d It trial "'hich
rel.t. to the .Wbj.ct ..tter or thi. litl9ation and the inoident in
qu..Uon.
J
18. Any intorwation euppli.d to thai' .xp.rte vho. you
intend to oall at trial it not inolud.d in nepone. to oth.r
r.qu.ete tor production. but not to inolud. ..dical r.cord. ot the
plaintitt..
19. Any and all contract. betw.en Holy spirit Hoepital
and Phillip Kacauire, K.P. in .tt.ot It any time in 1993,
inclualv..
20. Any and all exhibit. end d.mon.trativ. .vid.no. to
b. ott.r.d at trial.
21. All documente conc.rninq Holy Spirit Ho.pital'.
cndant1alin9 Ind appointm.nt to .tatt at Phillip Maauire, K.D. and
hi. .ntir. p.r.onn.1 til..
U. The .ntire cont.nt. at any inve.Uc;ration tile or
ti1.. or any other docu..nt. or .vid.nc. in your po.....ion which
.upport. or r.lat.. to the all'9ation. at plaintitt.' Complaint or
any d.t.n.e thereto. (Exoludln9 reterenc.e to ..ntal I.pree.ion.,
conc1u.ion., or opinion. r.pr...ntinc;r the valu. or ..rit at the
clai. or d.ten.. re.p.ctin9 to .trat.9Y or tactic. and privil~9.d
communicltion. to and troa coun..l.)
23. All docu..nte d.aUnq with I'hillip Kacaulre, K.P.'.
c.rtitlcltion in ...r9.ncy rooa ..dioin. indlcatinc;r t..t re.ult..
a4. All Depart..nt ot II.al th .urv.y r..ul t. tram un.
21). AU Joint couhalon AooracUtation at Ho.pital.
orqanl.atlon (JCNIO) .urv.y r..ult. tram 1993.
26. Any and all docua.nt. contalnl"9 the n.... and ho..
.eldr..... .nd/or bu. In... .eldr..... at .very Individual contact.d
4
a. a potential witn.... (EXcludin9 docu..nt. to or trom an .xpert
who Wa. r.tain,d by you but i. not expeot.d to t..tity at trial.)
37. All ..dioll r.cord. in your po.....ion which in any
way related to the a1le9aUon. ot the Co.plAint or any d.t.n..
th.reto. (Th1l requ..t may be .at1lU.d by your p'r'IIittin9
Plalntitt. to r.vi.w the ..dioll rlcord. in your po.....ion It .
mutually oonv.nl.nt tlml and pile..)
38. All proo.dur.., polloi.., .nd protocol. relatin9 to
the dla9no.i., treat..nt, ..dlcal .ana9...nt, and/or olre ot
patient. with Ippendloitlc. Ind/or aout. Ibdom.n.
:It. M.dlol1 .tate rul.., re9ulat1on., and bYIIW' in
.relot in In3.
30. Ho.pl tal policy Ind proc.dur. ..nual lndex tor un.
31. Nur.ln9 polloy and proc.dur. ..nual ind.x tor 1993.
33. All written polioi.., proc.dur.., protoool',
9uldIUn.., and oar.plan. rlQardlnQ pltient. pr..,nt.d to the
...r9.ncy rool ",ith ..v.r. abdominal plln.
Thl. r.qu..t 11 int.nd.d to eov.r all doeu..nt. in the
po......on, cu.tody and Clontrol oe Def.ndlnt, it. ICJlnta, ..ploy...
and Ittorn.y., Ind 1. d....d to b. continuin9, thu. r.qulrlnq
.
f'
.
. .
CERTIFJCATe OF S~~VICE
I hnebv entity that I, Dxne R. Lute., In e.plov" or AnQino
, Rovner, P.C., have thi. ~I(I) d.y or rebruary, 1'95, ..rvad a
true and oorreet copV of p~INTIrr'S REQUEST rOR PRODUCTION or
DOCUMENTS TO DEFENDANT HOLY SPIRIT lfOSPITAL - rIRST SET upon
derendant.' eoun.el bV ..ndinQ .... United Stat.. rir.t-ela.. ..il,
po.t'Q' prepaid, .ddr....d .. rollow..
st.ven D. snyd.r, !Iqulr.
HITTI, IVANS , WOODSIDE
3401 North rront street
P.O. Dol( 5"0
Harri.burq, PA 17110-0950
Attorn.y tor Dtr.ndlnt. Holy spirit HOlpital an4
Phillip Hlquire, H.D.
6OU'/t14
.
r
r
v.
. IN TlIB COURT or COMMON PLEAS
. CUMBERLAND co., PENNSYLVANIA
.
. CIVIL ACTION - LAW
.
. NO. '&-281 CIVIL TERH
.
. JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
RICHARD W. RAMSAY,
Plaintift
HOLY SPIRIT HOSPITAL and
PHILLIP MAGUIRE, H.D.,
Detendlnh
PLAINTIfr'1 "QUBIT FOR 'RODU~IO~ or OOCUKlMTI
~ DIFIHD~ 'H~~LJ' ~cqul". _.p. - rIR~T liT
TOI Steven D. Snyder, Eaqulre
METTE, EVANS , WOODSIDE
3401 North Front Street
P.O. BolC !lt50
H.rrl.burQ, PA 17110
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE th.t pur.uant to PI. R.C.P. No.. 4003.4 and
4009, pl.... turnl.h .t our '!Cp.n.I, It our ottloe, on or b.tor.
thlrty (30) d.y. atter .ervlc. h.r.ot. a Photo.tatle copy or Ilk.
reproduction of the ..hrlah concernlnQ thla action or It. .ubj.ct
..tt.r whlch ar. ln your po.....lon, cu.tody or control, and which
.ra not protlcted by the .ttorn.y/cU.nt prlvlh\Je, or, ln the
altern.Uv., produce the .aid .attar .t fA'd tI.e to p.nlt
In.plctlon Ind copylnQ thereotl
1. All .tate.lnt., .u..arh. of .tat...nt., traneor1pU
ot reoord.d .tlt...nt. or Intervi.w., reoord.d .tate.ant. it not
tun.crlbad, or Iny .uuary ot regorded .tat..ent. ralaUnq to,
uterrlnq to or in Iny "ay d"Crlbil\9 thh lotton, av.ntl, or
eubject tAtt.r ot thle .ult.
t'UtJPtL
. .
.
a. All docu.ent. prepared by Detendant, it. aqent. or
e.ployee. or anyone aotin~ on Ita behalt, durinq an inv..tiqatlon
ot thl III,qltlon. and ev.nta which ar. the .ubjlct .att.r ot thl.
.uit, or prepared ln antlcip,tlon ot lltiqltlon or trial ot thl.
.att.r, Ixcludlnq the 'Intal i.pre..ion., conclu.lon. or oplnion.
ot it. coun..l.
,. All photOClraph., U b. or v id.otape. tlkln In I'fqard
to thi. lncident.
.. All .tat...nt. of any eyewltne..(..) to the
treat..nt rlnder.d to the patient.
~. All .tlt...nt. ot any p,r.on(.) who will be olll.d
a. a wltne.e It trlal or who. you or anyone .ctlnq on your blhllt
ha. contlcted raqardlnq thl. .atter (other than expert. retlin,d
tor the purpo.e. at 11tlqatlon).
6. A oopy ot the docu..ntatlon .o.t r.oently .ub.ltt.d
to the Plnn.ylvanla Medlcal Llc.nlinq Board docu..ntlnq your
contlnulnq .edlcll .duoatlon.
7. All ..dical artiole. nvilw.d and con.ultld in
antiolpation ot Utiqlt10n or trial, which will bl u.ed tor
purpo... ot oro.a-.xl.lnltion at trl.l.
I. All docu.enta or oth.r de.on.trltive .vld.nc. "'hioh
wl11 b. introduced at trill.
9. A curr.nt curriculum Vita. for .Ioh Ixplrt explctld
to be call.d by Det.ndant to te.tlfy at trial.
10. All lnveatiqltion., reportl, incident r.portl, t..t
r..ult., dra",I~., .ketche., luaaarl.. or record. of thl. incident
J
f""'
.nd the eVlnt. .urroun~lnq thl. lnold.nt, Ino1udinq .... pr.p.r.d
by rlpr...ntativ.. of your 11.b111ty c.rrllr.
11. All docu..nte, lnoludln\J but not H.lt.d to r.pol'h,
rlcorda, not.., .u..lrll. prlparld, Vlnerat.d or obtain.~ by any
tnv..ti\J.tor ..p10y.a by Det.n~lnt or It. coun..1 to lnv..tiqatl
thh .att.r.
U. An ita.hed .t.te..nt of Iny and aU ahu\J'. for
..rvic,. r.nd.r.~ to P1.intlff..
13. Any and III aocu.ent. r.f.rrla to ln any Anlwlr to
.ny Inhrro\Jiltory or u..d by the Def.ndlnt in r..pondln\J to the
Plaintiff.' lnt.rroq.torla. tl1ad In thi. 1lw.uit othlr th.n
..dlcl1 r.cord. pr.viou.1y .uPPli.d.
14. Any Ind III docu.ent. contllnlnq lnforaatlon
r.l.tln\J to any In.".r to any lnt.rroq.tory.
15. Any .nd III r.cord. r.1.tlnq to your profe..lonl1
cont.ct wlth Plalntitf, othar than .,diQal record. previoully
aupPUld.
16. Any Ind III "'dUnq., ...oranda, report., .tat...ntl
.nd rloord., .ta., Which you .nd/or your co.p.ny Ind/or cU.nt
po..... cono.rnlnq the o.re, eXI.inltlon, tre.t..nt, lnv..tlq.tlon
or r.vi." ot Pllintlft .nd thl. c..., othlr thin .ealo.l reoord.
pr.yiou.ly lupp11.d.
17. Any and III .xpert oplnlon., Ixp.rt r.port., .xp.rt
'~Irl.., or othlr writlft1J. ot Ixp.rt. to be u..a at tri.1 which
re1at. to thl .ubjeot ..ttlr 01 th1. 11tiqltlon Ind the lncident 1n
qu..Uon.
l
.
II. An1 Intoraltlon .uppll.d to tho.. .wp.rt. whoa you
intend to oaU at tl"hl U not Inoludld In ra.pon.. to othar
r.que.t. tor produotion, but not to Inol\ld. ..dlce1 record' ot the
PlainUtf..
19. Any an<l IU oontraot. b.tw..n Holy Ilphit lIo.pitel
IIn<l Phillip HacOuire, H.D. in .tf.ot at any Ua. In 19U,
inclu.lYe.
ao. An1 and all ..hiblt. and d..on.tretiv. .vldenoa to
b. ottlr.d et trial.
U. All dooa.nt. oonolrnln9 your ondentlaUnQ and
appoint..nt to .taft It "oly spirit Ho.pit.l amt your .nUn
p.nonne1 tUI.
2a. Th. anU r. content. ot any invIIUQat10n t Ua or
tile. or any oth.r doou..nt. or .vld.nc. In your po.....lon "'hloh
.upport. or r.l.t.e to the all'9Ition. of Plaintlfta' Coaplalnt or
IIny d.ten.e thar.to. (IXOludinQ r.t.reno.. to ..ntal i.pr...ion.,
concludon., or oplnlon. repr...ntln\J the Ya!ue or 'trlt ot tha
clei. or d.ten.. re.pactln9 to Itrat.qy or taotic. and prlvl1'\J.d
oo..unloatlona to Ind tro. oounl.1.)
n. All doou..nt. dea11n9 with your otrtU iOltlon In
...rQ.noy roo. proca<lur. IndloatlnQ t.at r..ult..
24. All Depart..nt ot H.alth .urv.y r..ult. troa It''.
n. All Joint Co..i..lon Aocr.ditation ot 1I0apltll'
orlllnl.ltlon (J~IO) .urv.y r..ult. troll").
U. MY end all dOClWtenta conta1nll19 the NM' and ho..
.<ldr..... and/or bu.l"e.. .ddr..... ot Ivary in41Yldull contact~
4
(
a. a pot.ntll1 wltn.... (EXo1udlng doou.ent. to or tro. In expert
who wa. r.tllned by you but 1. not expeoted to t..tify at trlal.)
37. All ..dloI1 rlcord. In your po.....lon whioh ln any
wlY r.lat.d to the Illeqltlon. ot the Co.plllnt or Iny det.n..
th.reto. (Thl. r.qu..t .ay b. .aUltild by your p.I'1II1tUnq
l'lalnUfta to revl.w the .ldlca1 ..'oord. ln your po.....lon at a
mutually conv.nl.nt tl.. and plao..)
38. All proc.dur.., polloi.., and protoool. relatlnq to
the dllqno.h. tr.at..nt, ..dloal .anIIJ...nt, and/or oare ot
patl.nt. wlth Ipp.ndlcltl. Ind/or aout. abdo..n.
29. All wrltlnq., ..q. .1nut.., r.1ltlnq to .ny
...tlnq(.) ",hlch oon.ld.rad or dl.cul.ed the dlllJno.l., tr.at..nt,
and/or clr. at Plalntltt..
30. N.dlca1 .tatt rule., requllUon., and byl.w. ln
atract In 1993.
31. 1I0.pltal polioy and proo.dur. .anual Index tor 1993.
3a. Nur.lnq polloy and proc.dure .anu.l Index tor 1993.
33. All ",rltten poliel.., proc.dure., protoool.,
quld.Un.., and elreplan. r.qudlnq paU.nt. pr...nt.d to the
a.arq.ncy roo. ",ith ..v.r. abdo.lnal pain.
Thl. requ..t h Intended to COVIt' III doou..nt. In the
po.....lon, oUltody and control ot Det.ndlnt, It. aIJlnt., ..ploye..
and attorney., Ind i. d....d to be continuing, thu. requi..lnq
.
r
Defendant to .odify and/or .uppl...nt it. re.pon.. to Pl.intiff.'
Roqu..t a. Defendant obtain. further or additional docum.nt. up to
the ti.e of trial.
P.c.
arz
856
45 N. Front stre.t
Harriaburq, PA 17110
(717) 2J8-6791
Coun.el for Plaintiff
.
r
r
CER11'ICATlJOIIIBYICI
1 h.r.by o.rtify th.tI, v.ne R. lout.., In ..ploYII of Antlno
. Rovner, P.C., h.ye thl. it~} d.y of r.bru.ry, 1"1, lerved I
true and oornot oopy of Pl~I"Tl'r" J(IQUr:lT rOJ( PRODUCTION or
DOCUMENTS TO DEFENDANT '1I1LLIP MACOUIRI, M.D. . rlgT '11' upon
dd.ndln'" ooun..l by ..ndln9 .... unlt.d nltel tint-ol'" ..U,
po.t'Q' pr.paid, .ddr....d .. tollo",.1
Itev.n D. 'nyd.r, I,qu'r.
MIn'I, IVAN' . .,0001101
J401 North 'ront .tre.t
P.O. Jox '"0
H.rrl'bur9, fA 17110-0'10
At~r~~Ip t::9~.':~~~~~ Ho'y 'P~. I'.. M.,hl' Ind
" t r;~: ~.v
Int. I'
*WItI\
~IRfIrI~TI Ot 'J'YI~~
I hlr.by oertl'v thlt I, D~nl M. ~t.., .n e.ploy.. 01 Anqlno
, Rovner, P.C., haYI thl. 41.' 41V 0' OOtober, 1..., ..rv.a .
true .na "orr.ot oopy 01 PLAINTI"'. MOTION TO COM'EL ANIWIMI TO
l>UCOVIRY RIOUI'T' TO DIrr:NDAHT. IlOLY .'IIUT IlOUITAL AHD '111 LLIP
MACUIRI, M.D. upon defenalnt.' oGun..1 by IIndinq .... Unit.a
ntat.. fir.t-"l.ee ..11, pO.tIQ. pr.p.id, .dd'...." .. 'OlIo"'..
.t.v.n D. .nyd.r, I.quir.
MITTI, IV"N' . WooDlIDI
J401 No,th 'ront "r.et
',0. loll 1110
Klrrllburt,'A '7110-0'10
A"orn.y lor OII.nd.nt, Moly .pirlt "o'Plt'l .nd
PhIUI, M.,ulr.~, M.D. .__,
/' . .. }
~ ~z;
II
..~
:, t:t.:.'1
'-.J
,. .
.
~'~..,."."""'.......
...
_~.r 1:0.<.-
~i~
II,; I~
!ill~1
\", ,,'
\1"'"
-~
...
-::. r'
t. ~r.
'it
, I
,
. J ~
t/, ,j
r
-.---.
, -..~.~:
. ~....
. .. ~
.
,
.
.
I hereby C:1I11~ Ihlll, 1)lan. R J.Ulet, any employ" of Mahldy.Smllh"
Marull.. hlv.lhI. Jrd dlY of January, 19Q6, ..rvod llru. Ind rorrtc:1 C:Op)' o(lhI
I'RAl!CIPH FOR I!NTRV Of AI'I'I!AMNC'I! upon O.fendlnll by "ndln,1lll1t
Unllod 5'1'" nnl tla.. mall, .ddrl!lIod a. follow.
Sleven D Snyder, l!aquilt
MBTIll. HV AN! " WOOOSII>I!
3401 Nonh Pronl SlIecl
PODOll 5950
JllI'rllbur" P A 1711 O.Q9 SO
Allome)' (or Defend.nl.lIoly SpirllllolpilaJ and PhIlUp M.JUIr..
MD
P' ---'.''''".
.' ".~.. ~.'i
. / ~~> . . .
{///t /;;;/tt. ..~'
01111I R. WI.. ..
"
'"
~
{'"
."1
~.:' .
.;;rr)
.,!,t.
:f\a~l
:'l'
.
1\
:i
F}
4i\
t1
~t
l
.'"
,.."
.'!>cl!
fr~'"
,I.
II
ItWIIAIUJ W. ItAMHAY
1'lalnWT
: IN TII~ COUrtT Of/' COMMON I'I.~M OF
: ()UMIIRIU.ANU COUNTY, I'RNNHYI.YANIA
v,
,
: NO, 06.281
1101.Y HI'J1UT 1I0HI'ITAI. : CIVil. ACTION. I.AW
itntll'llII.I.II' MAOl1UtM, M.f), :
IMlInd.nt.t : JUltV TIU^" f)~MANf)~U
MWWJill
ANU NOW, thl. it .. dlt)' ur JanUllry, 1006. thlll,.rUff MYl", nol been
..bI. lo rompl,'" dlKllV\lry And IlItvln. julntly rllflUtI.tttd thatthtllrlal uf !.hit
maU., be eonUnulId. ."Id rllflllll.tl. UltANTRO ""d thl. mal...r I. her.by
conllnued from th. JanUllry lIJDfllrlal tttrm, TIll. mall4lr. wi.." ready, will be
r,lI.teel by (~unlC!l,
I
I
I
I
I
.
i
,
!
1
!
I
I
i
1
f1V TilE COUltT:
J.
I
1
~
,
f
.~
j
I
/ ~- tf '1~
I' .
~{I) )'If'''14H/II/( 11/
. .. I.). I~j ,Jt.j'U,
h,/~", IA 'J
I' '" A'.. q ,^.
'It~q
I 1/" 1"
''<t.:...''
""".~"":~_..
1I,...llll MIIU
1'-''-41\. h"N~
, '111 Ii I Mdd'l
t ""JlI'\' '."11 y
1't IIJ ~ IlU'.1'"
I i,"Il. 11_,>\1.4
( ."to, A ~ll'tjl
JAt.tI\ A III 'II
hH/111 1 Milll\AN
'lI'IN h \1,',lItll
'"111'1''''11111I I I\J....M.
II' 'I l .. 'lie.'.' ~
At-,I>lJ:I. H 11ll1'l'UNl.
Mil !lAI! b HH~
.Il
JJ
PIIOTTIO. ",',\NH ,. WOOIlNIU"
.. "NUr",MltUllIIt41, 10HI'O)lA II"""
.\.:111:.'" H,",vwH m
,""uIA J IH~1l1
(,AU J illl..
~"\o'-I'/1 A, tjll\iI,I(;t4\
t.liy , N-kt~'W'''NU
Mk-UA" fj fIIt'A
UklN W H}H~H Y
'l".lJlYN" .At/MAN
JAY\ON I "'~H,,,Nt:,
m/4lftlt M ( Alt. A(,NQ
..,un l- f<<,Jl1...A..
.....tu... ~ f.t~lIJ/A.
lAHUlN ~ UNjhlU
ttANIU .. ("MI'.u
"1'1.tllt~tt.:"" A'" I.A'"
1140t fril:U"1'U "'Nu~1' "'rtuu,..'
1'0. UII. &\lI\U
1I4WHIMlu:tm. 1'4 "un..,.."'.
JIIIIlHi
1;(.:." "t_>t.\ll';
tW1-l'ttL.~t
\/'/1 . J~ tl\IOU
f"
(lm,Ut '_Iii
",NU
,I ,,,_uu!lo
January II, 1006
llANO DRLIWRRD
ThllJna. R. Chumn.
Court Admlni.trAtor
Cumberland County Courthou'll
On. Courthou,e Hqunl'll
Carli. Ill, ItA 11013
lw: Ram'll)' v. 1101)' Spirit 1I00pltal, et al.
e.J'. Cumberland County No. 911.281 Civil
ll4Jnr Mr. Ch.lnn.:
AI a follow.up to our Janual")' 10, lOO6leltll,hon. wnvlInaUon l'tIIantln, thl! above
rofll/llnetld mAtler. durin. which Ilnfurmud )'ou that tho ,..rtl.. have been unable to
compl.te dllCOVury and Itl'll Jointly f(~IUIl.tin. thnt thl. matlAlr bu ~lOtlnued from the
JAnuary 1996 trial term, I havo \lndo,t'Cllln oM,lnnland two ropl.,. of a dral\ unier,
.ranUn. a wnUnuanee, ^' Ilndlellted to you durin. our tel.phone ronvenatlon and a'
indicated In the dran o"ll'r. Ih" part III' havlIllIlI'n unabllt to roml,l.t.lIlhe dl~v.1")' thlt
wa. ref,,"'nrtoclin Judl. lIayl".y', 1l<<lImlwr :17, 19911 pretrial "mfi'",n", ord.r and the
rllllulllt for a contlnuan", I. a Joint rt.IUll.t on blIhlllf of thll I,IaintllT and th. dllAtndllntl,
UlIClIUIO )'ou Indlcatllll that 1\ draf\ ordl!r I, all thAt I n..led to provide to you, I hlIYlI nllt
11",(JAflIIl .. fonnlll JllltlUon, If you hlll.l any thin. furthllr, howl/ver, Illell" lilt me know.
1'11I11(1 date 'lamtl onll of thllllOdoud COI,IN and ",turn it In thll poallll\tl p"',lald
Imvlllopo I'Mld...1 for that IJurlllllll, I, In turn. wllll,",vldu a copy of th....lIt:uWtI onlut to
IllalnUll'. t'Ounlll!.
ThAnk )Iou for your cOMldllrlltlon,
S'~~'t!",11' ~
__#-~ : .... I.' /
ti -x} .> ,(/f/ f.
SWvfl'n I), 81\)'4'.,
1I1).'lMb
t:nf!411Ur.
n Kkk..rd (' MtlII\4~ ~lIlr. IwA'fIfktlll",1
RICHARD W. RAMSAY,
PlalnUff
, IN TilE COURT or COMMON PLltAliI
, CUMBIRLAND co., PENNSYLVANIA
,
, CIVIL ACTION - LAW
,
I NO. 95-381 CIVIL TERM
I
, JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
v.
HOLY SPIRIT 1I08PITo\1. and
PIIILLIP MAOUIRE, M.D.,
Dettndanh
WIQUI
TO TilE PROTHONOTARY'
Pl.... .nter illY Ipp.arano. on b.halt ot Pla1ntUt in the
abov.-caption.d 0....
AHOINO , ROVNER, p.e,
_' /. ..x/
"{/:,j '/
4:"' c,~/ i i.
o ar . ~ no, r.
1.0. No. 07140 '
4DO) North Front str.et
Hlrrl.burq, PA 11110
(7U) 331-1I1t1
Coun..l tor 'llinti".
Dat.d,
r.brulry ., 1...
..ou,....
~'--
. .. n rl . pade
QJRTIrIg~TI or 8IRYIp.
1, Sandra K. Spade, an employee ot the law firm ot Angino ,
Rovner, P.C., her.by certity that a true and oorreot oopy ot the
toregoing a Praecipe tor Entry ot App.aranoe wa. ..rved upon the
tollowing per.on by tiret-ola.. United stat.. mail, po.tage prepaid
on February 6, 1996, a. tollow.,
steven D. snyder. lequire
HIT1'I, EVANS , WOODSIDE
3401 North Front street
P.O. 80)( DUO
Harri.burg, PA 17110-091S0
~
J^,
~l
",-'I
;;i
;
I
U
~
.,
,"'j
( f
l~ _1
!~i
I
'il
",
,......
i1
.r:'ft
H
Cl
\...;
PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL
(Mull be Iypewrltten and submitted In dupllcalo)
TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
(Check one)
Pleue 1I111he lollowlng cue;
(X ) 'or JURY trial Illhe ne.ll.rm 01 civil coull.
"..,.
( ) lor trial wlthoul IluIY.
............-.-....-........-...--..................\....................-........-........--................".................................-,.........
CAPTION OF CASE
(entire cap lion mUll b. Ilaled In lull)
(ch.Ck on.)
) A..umpIII
) T"IPI"
) T"IP"I(Molor V.hlcle)
H1CIIMO IW1MY,
( X)
tkwii.-.".] f,4,,~;~,",~
01 .r)
(Plllntlll)
VI.
"
Thelllalllll will beelll.d on Apr1~ 22. 1996
IK>I.Y SPIRIT IKlSPITN. Ml1
11m.l.tI' MAQJIRE. H.D.
~
(O"endlnt)
Trlall commence on May ~O. 1996
Pr.IIII'1 will be hl'd on May 1.1'~\lfl
(BII.II III due & dlYI b.fol, pl.lrlall.)
(Th. parI, 1IIII"g Ihl, CI.. lOr 11111 IhlU provide
lorthwllh I copy 01 Ihe plI'clpe 10 III coun..',
pur.ulnllO lOCI' nul. 21".1.)
V,.
No. 1~1
IU'V..
Civil
Indlcll.lh, ,\Iorn,y who wllllry Oil' 'or Ih. plrly who III.. Ihll pratclp.: IUcoon] C. Nlf~I!!:).
Nl~lfltl .. rtmner, V.C., 41)0] N, t'ront lit., IIMrlat>l,lf9. I'A
17110
r__._
I J
In<llcII'l,lal cOlln..' lor olh" plrU" II known: Ilt.ven lJ. lltl}d.r..t....!~llr., ~____,
t:!'ttCf, t)vMII .. Wod.UW( 14()l N. hont 1lt.1 lIt1nlalJUt'9. M
11110
--
.._'-
~. ,~-
- -_._---(!~~-----.._--~"... -...,
., ..
liQl'II<l ~&..~!_-).
_.e'- ,.-
p,,", '~Im. !t~.':lt~,,~.~I!I'.:. ~
~',_~,- ~r
1'll1Wllfl
11110'11'" 10' ,~c~,,~.."'.~ '''_ _..~_.
Till, Uti I' It.d" 1(11 tI..l
""~-""--~,
Oalt
MAllh ". IfJfJf.
,.-.o,.-,''-'C''''..~=-__=,~-__,
,<I
-'
RICHARD w. RAMSAY,
Platnt1ff
I IN THB COURT OF CONHON PLEAS
I CUMBERLAND CO., PENNSYLVANIA
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I NO. 95-281 CIVIL TERM
I
I JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
v.
HOLY SPIRIT HOSPITAL and
PHILLIP MAGUIRB, M.D.,
D.f.ndant.
'L~IHTI.r'8 RISPONS. TO DI.ZNDANT8'
RIOUZ8T rOR ADMISSIONI AND CORRISPONDING
JNTIRROOATORII8 AND RIOUZ8T rOR 'RODUCTIOn
0' DOCUMIHT8 Qr plrZNDANTS TO PLAINTI"
1. Admitted.
a. Admitt,d.
J. Admitt.d only that Exhibit "A" 1. . copy of part of what
w.. .uppU.d by Brbtol North.aat in Jun. 1119!l in n.pon.. to
Defendant'. .ubpoena for docum.nt. Ind d,.oribed a. "oopi.. of
Richard Ram..y'. compl.t. p.r.onnel fl1e and payroll .h..t. from
w..k .ndin9 F.bruary 7, 1991, to curr.nt we.k .ndin9 Jun. ., 1995.
4. Adllithd only that Exhibit "A" renect. wh.t lt nfl.ch.
5. Admitt.d that Millic.nt V. Bobb i. curr.ntly ..ploy.d .t
pri.tol North...t a. Dir.etor of HUllan a.loure... Admitt.d only
th.t Plaintiff rlc.iv.d a copy of . l.tter dated June 14, 1995,
.ddr....d to Def.ndant'. attorn.y and .i9n1d by Millioent V. Bobb
id.nt1t1e<l .. "Director Human ae.ourc.." on Brittol North...t, Inc.
lett.rhead .nclo.inq a copy of Exhibit "A" with other documenta,
II. Adm1tte<l.
ANGINa' ROVNER, P.C.
<'.'~
~c'l~-~ C~' /~,
o ar - . Anq no, .a.
1.0. No. 01140
400J North front .treet;
Hlrrilbur9, PA 17110-1799
(717) n8-Un
Cou~el for Plaintiff
AprU 10, 19,.
.nu/.u
YERU'IC",TION
I, ~ICHARD W. RAMSAY hereby verify that the flot. .et torth in the
fore9oin\l Relponae to Request for Admlt1110ns & Rogs are true .nd oorreot to the
belt ot .y knowledge, information and belilf.
I under.tand that any tal.e .tate.lntl therein .re mad. .ubjeot to
thl plnalti.. of 18 Pa, C.S. 14904, relatinll to un.worn tal.irioation to
author1t1e..
WITNESS,
~t,l{v!//-~
o u -W, It....y
.'..,.'.
.tY
IUClIARD W, n.AMSAY
Plaintiff
: IN TilE COUnT OF COMMON PLI<=A8 OF
: CUMBF.R1.AND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
,
.
: NO. 95-281
1l00.Y SIJlRIT IlOSPITAI. : CIVil. ACTION - I.AW
Rnd PlIILLlP MA(1UlRF., M.D. :
Dofondan\.ll : JUllY TIUAL m=MANDED
v.
IT IS llEItEBY STIPULATEl> and alCl'cClI by Anll betwoon coun.el that
defendant Phillip Maguire. M.n. .hall be di.mi..ed Il. n party In thl. calo with
Jlrejudlco.
ME'M'E. EVANS & WOODSIDE
<<1.. ("0.' L
lJy: ..."~_.~- ~
tovon D. SnYdOr~I'J(re
a401 North Front Stroot
lll\m.burll, PA 171l0.09110
()"tIt: ~Y!JQp6-_
.c.
By: _---.
IUchnrd C. AnIPr 0 Elllulro
4503 North Frol t trllut
llam,bur.. PA 1 1l0-1108
Dale: H-~/.1t-~~J-q.j-
I
AIJIJR()VEO IJY TilE C:OlJltT:
. j;/~'
..... ./
I 'f
. J
UAtll: ./ ~ 9,11""'"
J,
\
IUGIIA'Ul W, ItAMHAY,
PIAlnllff
y,
IIOI.Y HI'IIUT II0HI'ITA1..
llor.,"lanl
: IN TilE COUltT or COMMON I'I.EM or
: CUMnEIU.ANll COUNTY, I'KNNHYI,VANIA
,
.
: NO, OI\.IUII
,
,
: CIVil. ACTION. I.AW
TO TII" I'ROTIIONOTARY:
1'l.ICMB ma,k t'" .bov. Adlon ..ul.d and dIKGnUnu.d,
RfI iL'
PAlf: ,.l~'. , '1M
1~H
ANOlNO A KOVNICIt. 11,
.603 NlH1h "'{in' Hl'.'
IIArri.b",., I'A n 110
A'wnw)'. fllf 11A1ntacr