HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-00782
~
1\
~5. '/t'.;>.
No.
l~l. Y /11
-II -' .
VS.
-.J.,
R-dad 9.A1,.~ ~
od,d .
.'
Court of Common Pleas
Cumbo Co.
;
. I
.
.
.
I'
._-"
~. .." . '-.~ .
_.. , .
,..--
~
.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL
RESOURCES,
Plaintiff
No. 95-7B2 CIVIL TERM
v.
RICHARD J MAGARO and
CINDY L . SLOTHOWER,
Defendants
PRAECIPE TO ENTER SATISFACTION
To the Prothonotary:
The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Department of Environmental
Resources, Plaintiff in the above action, through its attorney,
Stuart M. Bliwas, acknowledges having received from Richard J.
Magaro and Cindy L. Slothower, Defendants above named, full.
payment and satisfaction of the above captioned judgment, with
the interest an costs thereon due it: it desires tbat
satisfaction be entered upon the records thereof.
~4n,p~~
Stuart M. Bliwas
Attorney for Plaintiff
Dept of Environmental Protection
Office of Chief Counsel
P.O. BOlC B464
Harrisburg, PA 17105-B464
(717) 7B7-1956
Dated: 1'f;'- 'IS-
J
~
t
~
~
~
..
t1
fq ~
"
~
fu
(;"j
~
"'"
1<\
<>
'"
...
-
~
!;R
lE
....
...,
N
.-
,1:,,>-
...t .:
ud::; ~;-,
~~~;:.,~
1...(.1-':"
~~ I:':~:I".:
:~.~:,~.i~
LIlli .r
!.... ,=,'"
I' ~t.
I. ~:)
<.:..i~
-
-
.\' .."
,-
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL
RESOURCES,
Plaintiff
v.
No. 95-782 CIVIL TERM
RICHARD J. MAGARO, and
CINDY L. SLOTHOWER;
Execution No.
Defendants
and
PNC BANK,
Garnishee
PRAECIPE FOR WRIT OF EXECUTION
TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Issue Writ of Execution in the above
matter,
(1)
Directed to the Sheriff of Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania;
(2)
aga~nst Ri~~rrq J. Magaro and Cindy L. Slothower,
4 (l!Jc:af--c/dl !)v,. 0 u Li~k.. pI{.
(3)
and against ~C Bank,
(J.u.-r1,hL<.-
Mj lit a,1I,
defendant(s) ;
5 fL,~"lH.v Sf-.
garniahee(s) ;
(4)
and index this Writ
(a) against
defendant(s); and
(b) against
garnishee (s) .
. ,-
as a lis pendens against the real property of the defendant (e) in
the name of the garnishee(s) as follows:
All property of the above named defendant,
including without limitation, all savings and
checking accounts, certificates of deposit,
deposits and all debts and other obligations
oweing from the above named garnishee to the
above named defendants.
Amount Due: $ 4,000.00
Interest at a rate of 6 percent per annum from $
February 13, 1995
(Costs To Be Added By Prothonotary) $
Total amount due with costs as endorsed hereon $
_m~<,vt~"'t . ,6&u~<..
Stuart M. Bliwas, Assistant Counsel
Attorney for Plaintiff
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
Department of Environmental Resources
P.O. Box 8464
Harrisburg, PA 17105-8464
(717) 787-1956
'.,...!
f'"...) _
Dated: ~ - "1/'( -.(')
.'
WRIT OF EXECUTION and/or ATTACHMENT
COMMONWEAL TII 01' PENNSYLVANIA)
COUNTY OF CUMUEIlLANIJ)
NO, 95-782 CIVil 19_
CIVil ACTION. LAW
TO THE SI1EIlII'I' or
_ .(:UM 1l1~1! J.Aml.___._ COUNTY:
To sallsly Iho dobl, IlIlmosl nnd cools duo COllllllonwlwl th of Pennsylvania. Dl:!pt., of
l':nv irOn!lllfll.I:IlL..!.!!:~IO_1I""5:.1I~~...._.._...__. PLAINTIFF(S)
from__!~!l-'!.!::~~..~'L.MI~.r'IJ~I.rl)..Il.!1d Cl.n<ly I.. Slothowl:!r. 41 Beechcliff Dr..
Curlinlu PA 17013.
----,....__..~-_..-._..~._...-,.-._----.._......_..
OEFENDANT(S)
(1) You 11I0 dlroclulllo luvy upon Iho proporty ollhe defendanl(s) and 10 sell
(2) You lIIe nlso dlroclolllo nllnch Ihe property ollho defendanl(s) not levied upon In Ihe possession of
PNC flunk, M.I Mull. S. lIunovur St.. Curlisle PA 17013 GARNISHEE CiS fo1.1ows:
..-----.--------.
All propurty including without limittltion, till stlvings tlnd cheCking
---~--.__.
accounts, curtifl.cutuB of deposit. deposits and till debts and other
- "-- --. --.- .--...-. ~. -----.--
obligutiona owuing [rom gllrniahuu to defendtlnts.
GARNISHEE(S) as lollows:
and 10 nollly Ihe oarnlshee(s) Ihal: (a) all nllnchmenl has been Issued; (b) Ihe garnlshee(s) Isfare enjoined from paying any
dobllo or for Il1e occounl 011110 delendonl(s) and from delivering any property ollhe defendanl(s) or olherwlse disposing
thoreol;
(3) II property ollho dofondant(s) nollevled upon an sUbjeclto allachmenlls found In Ihe possession of anyone other
limn n named glllnlshee, you 010 direclod 10 nollfy him/her Ihal he/she has been addod as a garnishee and Is enjoined as above
staled,
An10unl Oue~.i.!.OOO. 00.
h1lerosl ...!~ 3:13-'?~..L~~ p..r unnun
Ally's Conun._____...___ .% ____.._
Ally Paid __~27. 00
I'lolnllll J>ald_________.______.
L.L.
$.50
$1. 00
~ue Prothy
Olher Costs
Oalo: __.........l:1I.!gILL_.)_2.'L~
Doputy
by:
f1mUESTING PAIlTY:
\
Norno _
Addross:
Htullrt M. f11iwlls. Asst. Counsel
Conlin or PA. DER. PO Box 8464
---..----..
'-'t1r:rlshurq PA 17105-8464
Allornoy lor: ......__!'Jclln. t I r r
Tolopl1o"o: .._.. (7.l. 7.L7-'!7..::.1 'L~(j
Suprorng Court ID No, ___'_nu
.~
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL
RESOURCESr
Plaintiff
v.
No. 95-762 CIVIL TERM
RICHARD J. MAGARO and
CINDY L. SLOTHOWER,
Defendants
and
PNC BANK,
Garnishee
PRAECIPE TO DISSOLVE WRIT OF EXECUTION
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
Kindly mark the Writ of Execution issued in the above subject
matter dissolved.
Dated: 3 -1-1 r
~~T..ut. ~-<-""!J
Stuart M Bliwas, Assistant Counsel
Attorney for Plaintiff
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
Department of Environmental Resources
Bureau of Legal Services
POBox 6464
Harrisburg PA 17105-6464
717-787-1956
IN THE
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
COMMONWEALTH OF 'PENNSYLVANIA,
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL
RESOURCES
Plaintiff,
Docket No. C(J ~ 7$' d. C~
v.
RICHARD J MAGARO and
CINDY L SLOTHOWER
41 BEECHCLIFF DRIVE
CARLISLE PA 17013
Defendants.
PRAECIPE FOR APPEARANCE
To The Prothonotary Of Said Court:
Kindly enter my appearance on behalf of the plaintiff,
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Department of Environmental
Resources.
~~-';'~,/, &~~
Stuart M. Bliwas
Assistant Counsel
Attorney ID #10242
Department of Environmental
Resources
Bureau of Legal Services
P.O. Box 8464
Harrisburg, PA 17105-8464
(717) 787-1956
I
'!
IN THE
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL
RESOURCES
Plaintiff,
vs.
RICHARD J MAGARO and
CINDY SLOTHOWER
41 BEECHCLIFF DRIVE
CARLISLE PA 17013
Defendants.
Docket No.
CERTIFICATE OF RESIDENCE
I hereby certify that the name and address of the person to
receive notice of this judgment, or last known address of the
defendant is:
RICHARD J MAGARO and
CINDY L SLOTHOWER
41 BEECHCLIFF DRIVE
CARLISLE PA 17013
;t:1;t~ a~
Stuart M. Bliwas
Assistant Counsel
Attorney ID #10242
Department of Environmental Resources
Bureau of Legal Services
P.O. Box 8464
Harrisburg, PA 17105-8464
(717) 787-1956
"
. ,
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA.
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL
RESOURCES,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA
Plolntlff
Dockot No,;
v.
Doto Entored:
RICHARD J MAGARO end
CINDY L SLOTHOWER
41 BEECHCLIFF DRIVE
CARLISLE PA 17013
Dolendants
CERTIFIED COpy OF JUDGMENT
To the Prothonotery 01 Sold Court:
Pursuant to Section 605 of tho Clean Streams Low. Act 01 Juno 22.1937, P,L, 19B7, os
amanded. 35 P.S. ~ 691.605. this Is 0 Cortllled Copy 01 Judgmantlor civil panaltlas to be entarad
of rocord by you and Indoxod as Judgmants ara Indoxed,
Data of Final
Assossmant Amount of Assessment
Amount Paid
(If onYI
Totol Due
OBf10/93 $B.OOO,OO
$4,000,00
$4.000.00
Totol
$4.000.00
Filing Fae
Tho undorslgnod certifies that tho aboyo civil penalties aro duo ond poyablo by the oboyo defendant
under the provisions 01 the Cleon Streoms Law. pursuant to Section 605 01 sold low. 35 P,S,
~ 691,605. 0 copv of sold Dssossmentls attached herDto and mode 0 part hereof, The obove civil
penoltlDs shell cunstltuto 0 Judgment In IDvor 01 tho Commonwoolth upon the property. or such
person Irom tho date entorod and dockotod 01 record.
;J-9-C/5
DatD
li'ILelltr/J!t€JLMt
KDnnoth F. Murin
Chlel. Permits ond Compllanco Section
Division 01 Stormwoter Managemont ond
Sedlmont Control
Bureou of Lond ond Water Conservotlon
ORIGINAL TO BE RETAINED BY PROTHONOTARY
..
o
-
1:
'"
::J
l!!
::J
Q.
Gl
,s
C
~ 0
Gl-'5l
EO_
OIGl'"
'COC
::J IE ,!!,
:2oii'l
Q Q)"D .
~,s ~ 1'1
DCS='
O'-c.> g
'C'5lGlen
Gl-.t::'-
",,""--,s
:e C-O-
Gl!P. 0
c.>.c ~Gl
Gl lJd!l;g
,s,"oen
en.c C !\1
';;; ti ~ ~
,- ,- e >
j!:jQ.l!!
C
B
1:
Gl'\:J
~[ij
~~
,- '\:J
,s'\:J
01'"
C .
,_ Gl
E E!Ii
1'I:g 6
8lJ:8
"0'"
c-.8
,galE
ii'ltlE
::Jl!!Gl
C"._ C
,.,'\:J 0
~.8-a
,
~ ~lfl
,~~ ,~ ~~
"'e c; 010
l~h; c1l ;:r--
. tli .. r;::
lo ~~C::&
iii 1: ro..J;Jj ."
. OJ I:! 0 )( ~~
:EE:l:Jo.so
~ 16 g ~ al ,(11,,&
'" 0. Gl ~ 'E III
i!Glll:::Jq"'Qj
UlO DlQ.J:~
~
J!l
o
c:
o
e
tli
o~
1'1'"
=~
o ::J
Zll:
'"
'c ..
l(!~ 'c
.s!W ~g
Q.c i:;'~
c: III C E ,,;
OQ. ~ C '\:J
E . c:
e '"
EE' ~~ eIDQ)~
o ::J '" ~ ,1; 0
00
'Dc.> ~ ,s_ g',sO....
"ffi 0 . :!:o~,....
1::'0 Ill- ..
::J lij ci ~ ~ ~ . Vi iJ <(
8~ Z ~ ..., tiOo
Ql 0~::J 'E.J .S!
1ig g III ~:dl ~~~.!!!
iii c: 't:
Olllll: ._._.- ro
.Ec.> 0 0 c.>c ll:c.>....c.>
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES
In the matter of:
Richard J, Magaro
Cindy L, Slothower
41 Beechcliff Drive
Ca,lisle. PA 17013
Violation of The Clean Streams Law
and Erosion Control Regulations
Found in Chapter 102 of
Title 25 of the Pennsylvania Code
Consent Assessment of Civil Penalty
Now. this J ~ day of , 1993, the Corr,nonwealth of Penn$ylvania,
Department of Envlron~e$ources De rtment"l, has determined the following findings of
fact:
" The Department 1$ the agency with the duty and authority to administer and enforce
The Penn$ylvania Clean Streams Law, Act of June 22, 1937. P,L, 19B7, 2! amended,
35 P,S, ~691,1, ~ 1!t!J., and the rule$ and regulations promulgated at Title 25 of the
Pennsylvania Code,
2, Richard J, Magaro and Cindy L. Slothower (hereinafter "Maga,o and
Slothower,",e$pectivelyl. who and maintains an address of 41 Beechcliff DFlve. Carlisle,
PA 17013,
3, Since at lea$t December 10, 1990. Magaro andfor Slothower have have conducted
earthmoving activities at the Beech Ridge Estates site. located along Rich Valley Road
approximately 0,1 mile north of its intersection with Green Ridge Road in Silver Springs
Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania,
4. On October 17, 1991, the Department issued to Magaro and Slothower, a Compliance
Order which set forth findings of the Department and ordered Magaro and Slothower
to take interim or ,emedial action to correct violations at the Beech Ridge site, A copy of
the Compliance Order is attached as Exhibit A.
5, The Department has dete,mined and Magaro and Slothower agree that Magaro and
Slothower caused or aliowed the following violations:
a, On December 10, 1990, January I, 1991, Ap,i116. 1991, August 20, 1991,
October 11,1991. January 6. 1992, January 14,1992, Februa,y20, 1992. March 17,
1992, May 13, 1992, and May 12, 1993, Magaro and Slothower did not develop,
implement, or maintain ero$lon and sedimentation control measures to
effectively minimize accelerated ero$lon and sedimentation at the Beech Ridge
site. in violation of 25 Pa, Code ~102.4. and Section 611 of The Clean Streams Law.
35 P,S, ~691.6". .
b, On December 10, 1990. January I, 1991, April 16, 1991, August 20, 1991,
October 11. 1991, January 6, 1992, January 14. 1992, February 20. 1992. March 17.
1992, May 13, 1992, and May 12, 1993. Magaro and Slothower conducted
earthmoving activities at the Beech Ridge $ite that created a danger of $ediment
pollution to an unnamed tributary to and Including the Conodogulnet Creek,
waters of the Commonwealth, in violation of Section 402 of The Clean St,eams
~aw, 3S p,S, S691.402,
c, On August 20, 1991, October 11, 1992. and January 14, 1992. Magaro and
Slothower caused or allowed accelerated erosion and ,esultlng sedimentation
from earthmoving activity at the Beech Ridge site to enter an unnamed tributary
to the Conodoguinet C,eek, a water of the Commonwealth, in violation of
Section$ 401 and 611 of The Clean Streams ~aw. 35 P,S. SS691.401 and 691.611,
d, On January 6, 1992. January 14,1992, February 20, 1992, Ma,ch 17.1992, May 13,
1992, and May 12. 1993, Magaro and Slothower conducted earthmoving activities
at the Beech Ridge site in a manner contrary to the Compliance Order iS$ued to
Magaro and Slothower on October 17, 1991. Conducting an activity contrary to
the terms and conditions of an order is a violation of Section 402 and 611 of The
Clean Streams ~aw, 35 P,S, SS691,402 and 69,,6,',
6, The violations described i:1 Paragraphs 4a through 4d comtitute a publiC nuisance
pur$uant to Section 402 of The Clean Stream$ ~aw, 35 P,S, S691,402,
7. Section 60S of The Clean Streams ~aw, 35 P,S, S691.605 provides that the Department
may a$sess a civil penalty of up to TEN THOUSAND DO~LARS ($10,000,00) per day fo,
each violation of The Clean Streams ~aw,
8, After full and complete negotiation$ in this matter between the partie$ he,eto, the
Department and Magaro and Slothower agree to a settlement of the Department's
claims for civil penalties for the violations identified in Paragraphs S through 6 herein as
follows: '
a, Pursuant to the Department's authority under Section 60S of The Clean Streams
~aw. 35 P,S, S691.60S, a civil penalty in the amount of eight thousand dollar$
($B,OOO,OO) is hereby assessed again$t and agreed to by Magaro and Slothower,
Payment of this civil penalty $hall be made as follows: Submittal of a certified
check or the like made payable to the "Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Clean
Water Fund". and forwa,ded to Chief, Permits and Compliance Section, Bureau of
~and and Water Conservation, Department of Environmental Resource$, P,O,
Box 8SSS, Harrisburg, penn$ylvania 17105.8555,
b, Payment of this penalty $hall be made according to the following $chedule:
The initial payment of four thousand dollars ($4,000,00) $hall be due and
payable upon Magaro's and Slothower's execution of thi$ Consent
Assessment of Civil Penalty, The remaining balance of four thousand
dollars ($4,000,00) shall be due and payable by no later than December 31,
1993, The payments $hall be submitted to the above in Paragraph 8a,
c, Magaro and Slothower hereby coments to this civil penalty assenment issued
pur$uant to Section 60S of The Clean Streams ~aw, 3S P,S, S691,605. and waives
Magaro's and Slothowe,'s right to a hearing concerning or to appeal from this
anenment. which rights are available pursuant to Section 60S of The Clean
Streams ~aw, 3S P,S, S691.60S, Section 4 of the Environmental Hearing Board Act,
3S P,S, S7514. and the Administrative Agency ~aw, the Act of June 4, 1945,
P,~, 138B. as amended, 2 Pa, C,S, Ch, 5A and 7A,~alla,
9. By entering into thi$ Coment A\$essment of Civil Penalty. the Department only
waives its right to bring an action for civil penalties for the specific violations set
forth in Paragraphs S through 6 for the dates set forth herein, Nothing he,ein
shall be construed to imply that the Department waives any other rights which it
may have concerning said violations or relieves Magaro and Slothower from any
future liability for environmental damages resulting f,om the activitie$ demibed
herein,
FOR THE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESOURCES:
r11 ,k4~cu--
Michael Sherman
Chief, Permits and Compliance Section
Division of Storm Water Management
and Sediment Control
(Date)
D0h~
. I -
IZct}//Y
( e)
FOR RICHARD J, MAGARO AND CINDY L, SLOTHOWER:
The undersigned states subject to the penaltie$ of 18 Pa, C,S, ~4904, relating to unsworn falsification
to authorities, that he/she is authorized to execute thi$ Consent A\$essment of Civil Penalty on behalf
of Richard J, Magaro and Cindy L. Slothower,
;1/'), / ",/
;, ~-.: ./' ~ ~,,"-' ,
Richard J, Magaro /,
Y?/~;.. ,~....u
/'~JCt. -7'
-~
(Date)
~. Wi- vf~-
Cin Dt~r ..
'1~ IS' '1.3
(Date)
1
~
r--
.......
'-
I
"'6
J
j
~ . ~
~ ~
$~j
~ \~
\\~ ~
;
J:J
J
,
,-.- ,
.~
-,
'-
~;
r\ -- ~
~rt~
~ r6 'i
-- ~\
~ <::L.. <::l
10 Q.t \~
\;:)
~
'n
(....-J
,
.,")
'"
\.....
\ .
. .