HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-01014
j
-
d
~
e
l
".,:['.'~.'>\' '.
'. . .... ..' . ?)?> x '+;
. . {'~" . . . . ~. '.:' . .....,. '.
.~3~:(Y:;: . ;.' . .' . "'~,:,i.
. '.. ".:,\':","'> ......:> ." ':" ,,:::;.,~ "':'~', e'L'i .",' ,
, " .;> y ,"'.," " . '. 1;,', o,'.Y .
'".: .', r,} ;: ,,: ,:.'1/~~,: ' ,
:' :"}::;.i)):~,: '. ' ." \,":,:::,:~": .';, : ...:::~,:;:\ :>,';> '\ :.
..J';"""'''':'''''':'' ':',".'.." " " ........ · ;.':- ,,-..;;.,;. /;'..:: '
, ...., .,', . .,... , . ' ' '" :'.' .' "':' ; "".;' , .:' .:::':'
":':":,": ;;i'i':;' '." ;" ........, <'........;",:,::C. ;.'i:.
,', ;,.:;, . " -:\ ;,', ',;,,' .;>:;f
,);~{;:;' " .'..' ;e.,"';';'; ",
,;c,: '.'~ ;". .... '-.'<;:~ \'.' ,.' r.~' ,
":)';~ i;,J~ ".:~:;;'.~~~ "" .' ',:";.'< .,':;/..:",i:i;;
,,':'~"/, '. ......,; ',,'c,:,' . ,:.':"'; ,"
,:<~':".' ':;:.:,:... >".".,;".'.,:." ",;\: ""~::
. ../.i; ,.', i,:.:'.'.',":.:",:.;,' ::. :;;~;..,"):":~:' ;,':' ..'
. .'. ".;: .',',."........ ", .:: '." C";.' i? :F:,;"
I:: ;'::~,; .' \1 . :.'" " .': '::,"~
.' .... \::::,::,Y,;'::';;\: .:}:;.': :,:.(;'.""","'::" ."
. :' ,;:(i;;' ,.. ';. ':.J;''', "'" ....;;;':(;:?'{ ::':'~'(:Jl:~':)J'"
,',' '. ::,' .":,:>'::" ','", ~:'?;'::::;: ':'.,.';
, .. ~"jt.'''<'''' :;>,;;:,,;,::' )::;';}"f:",.. ,,':"
,:' .:' :",'. "i' '..\.;' ,',': :;,::;"<"'" ,....... .;;:;;,:,:
',: :,:,c.;" , :;'; :.>;;' ':,~;;' ':.~\:<
..,..:::.'....'.";:;>,;:';::: ..... "i:';: ,;,:~/':,".::".: .{:' ".}/": 'I,
..' :.:.;;.. .".': ": '. ':"LE:::''':'';
,:; "'::,;':"" :" '."": ' ',.::: ....
'. ., ,,;,.;:,;;;,; ":";.,':" :;/1.:' ... ~':,:' ":':\','
,;,/,',. r"',::", .....::,.~\,~:,.::::\'... ./: '.'; ;.::':; :'\ ;
'.:. >;:, ", ,{ :,:.~ .:?./'.......:,~'."y;'.;:.. '......>.::,:
:.:yfJ','P :.:;~: \;'<':, ,'" ..'>,.... .. ';,"';:-"'. ,(: ':.:
. . " ::::'i' ' i ~::,'r.::,.;,: . '''. '.' .'.; ;;.... . ~ ,,/:.~;::::~:.:,'H
',,",:" " ',....;',;. ,,;,';';,' :...,..;...,.....-::...',.. ,:.:~;.:...?;:..." :.,.;..:.' ".
. :':', .:.:' :; ,,:' " .. .' '.;..
""::::;:':,."::' . .... '........., "':"'/:':>,:;::;'
~~'::!/' ,.,., ,.",/';; ~
'. :,.. . :'......,. .,..., ,,' ",,' .' ,'.' .... ;',,;,,' .C.' :,,,;',"
. .' '..:', ,.;iF::'~
.' ." ';:.',;:<;~;;
. , ",';'.'<" .:;,
:":..,.<"." ..' ;::,':.:
7'-' ',.':~.::;':?:':.;~ .\.~)
:' , :'\:':':;;'>"":+>~;:',5 ,., :::.:l;;i'
, " '''''C:,: "
,< ". . . ,'.' ,::~
, '., ..',; . ,~,
" '.. ",.~:~' ;'. ..'
.... :,\:..' ". > ..,.'
. .:.. ...... ::;1,':" . . , .
. . . ' ~,
.
.n
7
i[
, .......
.'
,j
o
-1
'"
dJ
~
~
j
-
.....,/,..:, .....'? ':.:~':" ......
-." : .',- - ",:." "
q".::.,:, . .'> "
. ..':',' ';. ,,:.
", " . ":: .', <' ,
.":"""::' '. :'". .-.' ,"'.,
.', '.'.'. "".i .,\".,,": ".', .. .: "..\<,
. ..' .' i.,:;.::: '
,,'.,::,;../," -,"',,': '. ,'., '. .'; '..,
'.", : f " :,' '.' '" "" .,~;" ",
" " >
\,'" .
;r
~:;;
,'"
, . '. ._~ '" ..
4,;
~..
:4
C:h,
. ~~;
, '.~
,~
,-,,;'
.',,,...."
. :~';'t
.'p,j,
. .::~:t
.~ (I'
" ,'.i~~'
~;, ,
::~ .
'"
x~~~-
,'"
:, ,;. ,~.:':
. "i'..:;:.
, :'f~I,-:,~
. . " -~-~
:; :~;~~~
; :
~;,
C'
, ,,'f.
.~,:,.-
. ~ .:1.
, ',~;~r
:i~'~);~
~.'\};,
. :~:~
_ S~~
.;>/:.
. .~-,
.' :',~.
.,
.-
"
,..".
!;
':.
.
::
:,
.
, .-
'. t.~
":..
,
'J
,B & L GLASS,
PLAINTIFF
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
. CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
vs.
NO. 95-1014
MONRO MUFFLER/BRAKE,
DEFENDANT
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
APPEAL FROM D.J. JUDGMENT
NOTICE
YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against
the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action
within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served,
by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and
;, filing in writing with the Court your defenses or objections to the
ic1aims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to
; do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be
'entered against you by the Court without further notice for any
imoney claimed in the Complaint or for any other claim or relief
requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or
other rights important to you.
, : YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT
,HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE
'iSET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP
Le han demand ado a usted en la corte. Si usted quiere
"defenderse de estas demandas expuestas en 1as paginas siguienteF,
,:usted tiene viente (20) dias de plazo al partir de la fecha de 1a
: demanda y la notificacion. Usted debe presentar una apariencia
escrita 0 en persona 0 por abogado y archivar en la corte en forma
,escrita sus defensas 0 sus objeciones alas demandas en contra de
'su persona. Sea avisado que si usted no se defiende, 1a corte
tomara medidas y puede entrar una orden contra usted sin previo
',aviso 0 notificacion y por cualquier queja 0 a1ivio que es pedido
en la peticion de demanda. Usted puede perder dinero 0 sus
propiedades 0 ostros derechos impoprtantes para usted.
LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABODAGO INMEDIATAMENTE. SI NO TIENE
ABOGADO 0 SI NO TIENE EL DINERO SUFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICIO,
VAYA EN PERSONA 0 LLAME POR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DIRECCION SE
ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DON DE SE PUEDE CONSEGUIR
ASISTENCIA LEGAL.
COURT ADMINISTRATOR
CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURT HOUSE
CARLISLE, PA 17013
(717) 240-6200
:'
I;
I
I
Ii
i
;I B & L GLASS,
i i PLAINTIFF
II
I,
I
II
ii
"
II MONRO MUFFLER/BRAKE,
, DEFENDANT
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
vs.
NO. 95-1014
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
!
I
,~ hereby ordered
i I be held on the
~ i
11 Courtroom #
I, Pennsylvania.
j!
.1
!\
II
II
I
i
\
,
i
I
,
i
,
I
i
I
I
I
,
I
I
i
i
I
I
!
I
APPEAL FROM D.J. JUDGMENT
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this
, day of
1995, it is
that a hearing on the above-captioned matter shall
day of
1995, at
.m., in
at the Cumberland County Courthouse in Carlisle,
J.
II
Ii
I,
i
I
, I
\
\
\' B & L GLASS,
PLAINTIFF
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
i
I
I
I
I MONRO MUFFLER/BRAKE,
I DEFENDANT
!
,
I AND NOW, this
I judgment is hereby entered in favor of the Plaintiff, B & L Glass,
,
land against the Defendant, Monro Muffler/Brake, in the amount of
I
1$1,434.25.
,
,
vs.
NO. 95-1014
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
APPEAL FROM D.J. JUDGMENT
ORDER
, day of
1995,
J.
,
"
B & L GLASS, . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
.
PLAINTIFF . CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
.
:
.
.
vs. . NO. 95-1014
.
.
.
. CIVIL ACTION - LAW
.
MONRO MUFFLER/BRAKE, .
.
DEFENDANT . APPEAL FROM D.J. JUDGMENT
.
COMPLAINT
The Plaintiff, B & L Glass, through its attorneys, the Law
:j
"
ii
'i
I
i
!
,
I
I
,I
'I
i'
il Offices of Patrick F. Lauer, Jr. of Camp Hill, Pennsylvania,
II
Ii
respectfully avers the following in
support of its Complaint:
1.
The Plaintiff in this matter is B & L Glass, a Pennsylvania
:1
II business having its principal place of operation at 902 Market
II
'I
Ii
Ii
I'
II
I,
I
!i
II
"
q
II
Ii
Ii
II
"
"
il
I,
i;
,i
"
!i
Street, Lemoyne, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17043.
2.
The Defendant in this matter is Monro MUffler/Brake, a
Pennsylvania business located at 1051 Market Street, Lemoyne,
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17043.
3.
The Plaintiff took its 1979 Gruman van to the Defendant's
shop for state inspection and regular maintenance on April 4,
1994.
4. The Defendant subsequently indicated that the vehicle passed
inspection after performing various items of repair. See Exhibit
"A" attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference.
I 5.
'I
The Defendant released the vehicle in question to the
Plaintiff. Upon leaving the Defendant's shop and traveling South
on U.S. Interstate 83, the left-rear wheel fell off the vehicle.
i
,i
'\
6. Substantial damage was done to the wheel, housing, and body
of the vehicle, totaling one thousand four hundred thirty-four
dollars and twenty-five cents ($1,434.25) in damages, receipts
i
,
: for which are attached hereto as Exhibit "B" and incorporated
i
,
[
,
I
I
,
I
,I
I
il
"
I'
Ii
\I
H
I;
I,
"
herein by reference.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff in this matter demand judgment in favor
of the Plaintiff in the amount of $1,434.25 plus interest, costs
and such other relief as the court may deem appropriate.
I'
II
II Oatel 3/\1/q)
II
:1
"
I
i
i
Respe~ f lly submitted,
I:~~ Q-
Matthe J. Eshelman, Esquire
Law Offi es of Patrick F. Lauer, Jr.
2108 Market Street, Aztec Building
Camp Hill, Pennsylvania 17011-4706
ID# 72655 Tel. (717) 763-1800
I[
I
I
I
I
,
'I
II
II CBRTIFICATE OF SBRVICB
j I hereby certify that I am this day serving a copy of the
I
Ii foregoing Complaint upon the person, and in the manner, indicated
Ii below, which service satisfies the requirements of the
:,
j!
:: Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, by depositing a copy of
i
i the same with the United states Post Office at Camp Hill,
;;
"
:1 Pennsylvania, through first class mail, prepaid and addressed as
'i
'i follows:
I
Monro Muffler/Brake
1051 Market street
II Lemoyne, PA 17043
i
i
i
I
i
I
,
I
I
II Date'. ~17~'
11 ~
II
I
,
i
;
!
R..~~ct~'Y .abmittad,
Matthe J. Eshelman, Esquire
Law Of ices of Patrick F. Lauer, Jr.
2108 Ma ket Street, Aztec Building
Camp Hill, Pennsylvania 17011-4706
ID# 72655 Tel. (717) 763-1800
I
I
!I
II
!i
1
I
ii
r
+
n
.
~
,
"
,
IJAONRO
MUFFLER/DRAKE
MUFFLERS. BRAKES. SHOCKS. SPflINGS . ALIGNMENTS
C, V, JOINTS - RACK & PINION' B 4,) 41 0 0 6
',1 I.";,..'
THE FUTURE OF
UNDERCAR CARE
fl".. '...1,'..)
"'11_ :1
~...'Ej I ,"
i.1 L~nJ
d :.1.
..
J:' "'IJ
\~ .:':I~l-aJl..
" it. 1-~. '~'J
'. ,.'bI1IJ~~I,,.:':J'.~;
.~.L~: It...Wiil l. t.fti. \ hi
'I~~_hil~: LI"tlL. t. lJp~~:l,
~u '.
:.Lk~Jt.~-:i :'L:~.,~:iinn
l,t~[CTlr~j
r,; .:1 L II:,,".IC
:..1.' t.;IFl'\I:11 r;- \ f;'lt., ill , ;;r , In.i
,..,.;, ",[
..~. 'J hUITL<I l; P,l,~l 'Ii. ~b
L;ftl [;;I}l;'J'.a ::\.:ff~',i 5. ~S ~.1~ 1.\1.\
" M CLnHtl ),jU :. j~
i.\;17 E.i-r,lI ).~:. ,1. ;I~
" i\l~L. ['l.r!fl~r~r 1. ~~~ ',15 15.~~
:AI.tI:131 lor;,..
:'~.'~~~t~
L,JiR
,_F 1l,,:Till CI,:;I,..,HI
U' ~r.J~:CS
15.tu
;uc
.:J;,2~
6 !;~fil~r LE~l
a lllifi[ :IIUa:{,j
!J Ul!JI\;C~
B.47
1('1.')5
~7.~a
2'l,~~
Q J,_
ll."
",.':.1
,- ~ "t, .,
7J. n
;+il"(::' j:j; ~'~
",4'iIfE
11'~'
',. ',l/'J'I
Co":..
1....:( 1
f"~ f ~ '-"1' r ,: 1,
'.('\11: 7',
1.1ttt.SE '1
~:U:f.u: Ita
r'~,'!l'lT
4J,~,
1~.~\)
1. ~~'
l~.(J~
101...,
71,~,
9i,17
171.1 I
luL II
1',~fCi.1li: I
t1..o:,IGt: E..t~-:L-:r
Si:Ii'I!t:E jt::l,,~
2,\~~ ?t" 11.'1~ 13. ~5
',.,:..., ".,',) 1!.l):i ~~,.rJ5
3'I,~1l
~ ;'iJ
"""""";".--.~
-,
Lot,
!,;::...1
:,:..':',-":(;111..
S;.i.: ~it\
I'
CUSTOMER COpy
'.
\
~,
" "'.
, '.
32~. ~7
. "
2'J.t~
15,~~
!~.w
J.W
~'~'1
11,,"Jti.E t: I
~:t.'~~
; ;td-,(;: ll~U: j.;~ tUJLCL: Vh~
tu q~(b:: \ ~r: ;;'11
"':~J rillE...;; L'UTI ~
" ';
., /':. .-"i
.,j:,,~',' I.
~ ._(
'~. ~ !l..V':
. ~., '" _: ',.,'.
,.... .. i' :; r,rr ..
I aulholllO lito 'IlPilIl5 !illolNn on thIS ostJm.llo to bo m.tdo I
al(lOO lNtlh Iho nocvsfKlf)' malOllals,1 ogroo to pay chargosj
undC! 1I1l! 10ff :il)I!IU!de, yd1\11liQhJlCQruplolod, It ~;If 151
lull 11\010 Ulil'. (~) Udys allQr work is CQ/l\plvlud, II may bo
placoo in !li',talJu Oil my o.ponal, Company IS nol respen-
51010 lor II' .115 lull In car.
~l ho und Ifsignw, tla\lUlO hmdl:l'ud paymuot ollhlS in\lOICu
by clltli;' '. crudll '-ltd. or olllor char go. agrllO to pa1 MONnO
MUFfLt.i.;~'RAKE a sum equal 10 aU c:tliIrgu5 and Oil-
pttniOS, lIlcludmg uJu!ionable ulll"'noy 1005 and 'OIUffltJd
CllOCk charoo& incullod by MONRO. In the ovenl thalia' any
'tiJ!ion I>atd ctlu(;k ~".f!l; not Dew Iud to, c:ollecllon
und palO ID MallllO/l
SIGNATUR~""/. /J
AulhofllOd b~ I.
Oal8
/
TlUS 'NVOlr.E MUST BE
PRESENTED fOR AujUSTM~NTS
I,"'
'lI;;;;i \ 1U I (j;l LH.lJSJrli
~:'"I;U iUfLtR,LhktJ"
FeR ~i:F.llr( tW til. TRUSl.
,," .,:. I r;.... ',F'!' . ~..{~
,....,
~, ....."
';
..( '.:""
"
I' .'. :".
-it ,.
@)
~
-
::e:
0-
....
Q
("I')
~
a:
~
:s:::
r ~_
...c,.
4--;"";
--,..,
,,;r:"'" r
l.;'7.-r..-..,-
~i"""'~
(,:,~"3.f;l
"
r'O:/"
\;-l:.c:
,I Hl ~~.
:',:x.-
'~
'0'"'
.
,
.
PATRICK F. I.AllER. JR
Allorney .1 I.a..'
: lOR \.h.kt'l Slreel
:\/1ce Ituilding
eamp lIill. r,.\ 17011
(711) 7t.:t.II<IW
~
.
a:
..,
~
a: it -
~ " =
.. " .., -
:::l ..I ~ = .... :5
< Vi ~ '"
.. < -
..I .. U .
'; "" M
>- ... -=
to: ~ CD
.. .. ....
= ~ u i -
::,c: .. " ....
U Cl '" OS Q, -
.. = < e ....
- .. - -
a: < ... ..
e- t..o
<
ll.o
.
:
I~ .
iry
'\')
I~C
01,:-
' (01......
~~. 11'1
- 11 i H !II U i ~ II
"
a
~ ~
L ~!Ij
~ ~- ~~' B
;i::!! ~ ~ :.-- ~
Cl)a:: ~
O~:il~
..... '" ~
..._)( ..
EQ~g~ I ~
"''''o=>
i:':ul..: :ll
.... ..
... => ..
-:g -
~. ~.~
au i 1 ....
....
iii ~
o lilt I
iE...
"-..
\, ~~
, ~\
~t'~ ~
()
:3....r l\1
- ~~.
~ ~l\1
-.! ~ ...- 3 1"/'
~~ ~I~~' ~ ~
I~ j 15,1~,,:~
z .
~ ~ :!:~ \ ~
~... ~~ ~
.
t\
:: J: \"'"',
, ~) l~'~
\,j J- .
~
~ ~ '"N .
(~ ,,' ~ '
-.)1 ~ ~~
.., ... ""-:
~ '" \,
'~I~ ....:.:
-
/
'(19/691111'. n,.w,uw
.11l
~~
~
I~~
.1. . r--
I~
~(
"i
S ~~
,
~ J"~
~
~
-
~~
;
"5:: ,~
...",~
~N~
~
~. .~
~~
~ ,~
~~ I'
~ , ~l\:
.
,
I~ ~ ;
-..., 11"
~'
'. ....1
r.:.: ...
~;;--
.
..~
"
'""
II ."
t, Ui
<<. U1
. I .~
, :I:;
f. . f...)
, >-
. rr:l
('~';' .6
.. . '"
~ ~ p~ ;; cf:
c .'( ,='
. ,<r. 1.-::1
4J ".-r.
I . - .~ 1"1:
L' 'IU
<< 0 ';~
~ :.';: _'L
( r~ ~~.
~ i~
ill'"
a ::;
"0
h
~r
or
.....
.....1
~..... . [ , ',:(
I::t,_~,,_~
~'-~
~
a
':'
'"
r ...'
I' .......
.
.
n
"
I
~
..
o
X
III
Z % >-
o 00
i:: -J :of Go ~ g
!!: -c: Do U 0 .. m
5 ~~~ilimm~ ~
l:J 0( III X .. 000: 0:
o z>UOUULPJ "
U 0 UI 0 ~ C = ~ 0
~g~m""::E oz
~~~~~~!Zlfi .~
:5~~a~~~!a~
w
CJ
<
Z
o
a:
~
~ ~
1, ~
.~ ~
~,o
, ~ ~ W
, Cl ~ ~
.-. ~~ :-
t..J ~ ~ .
^ ~~
i~'::t. ~ ~
Q~ .~ ~
~'" Jl'('"
~;C7~i ~~,;-~r.H '.:C.~:::l-'" .-
~"'1'''1'''' :_:~ w.p .:~
j1,d~~f)", ~"" t.." f"ot..
='...-o~o L~~t.~:iT .:..
~ei~:~ r.~~~~;f. ,
.., ~.ft 11'~l~~. S
iIot:ntt... II ~i.. ~. II
.....,.....h. r!t 't~..~ r
~;91~~ fl. ",1'tI) :
:':i1~~~~ :~~rr.'ll u
'~~~"i h!.t:e~!t u
C~'n~:::r ......{ ~ L. ..
~......~~U !~~r':t1 ~
f,.11t.'<lS;:; l';::'''!';:t._
~;!~~~ ~!'~~~'!'t ~
'l~""'I~ r~~r:..; tl
~MOt~u Jb~tl ~~ ft
:::...n,IIU .~I'tt... ~
~~':J.lI'), . ,':or. 'I II
~;~~::: t. I'"i~i;~ ":
"':-!~:':l':i t1,:"t;:r?
f,-........ri1 i' t>rL\:' ~
U',Ir:':~:!I :.:b:;'J~ U ."
r;j~""" r<!,'t.,,~:,,:., ..
'",0 I:," . 'n_, .,
:!...~I.I~ rti,:rd;' _
..:;~~ ~'s:~:. T. ~
::~~;"~"1 ;.~.:: ~ :~~ - ~",
:'::~~":~:!. ~~::~;.~:: "
I~'" .~,' '""J,1'L
~::~:....;, )~l ~~~.
!
~
c
o
rn
c-1
ro
-
~
U
"
w
S~
"'~
~ at;
, cw
...:
...
1
. .
"
.
~"
~~
~"
001
:ia
-'.
.-"-"
h'
"X
0:"
0(<C
xU
U
s
..
~
I~
l:l
~
0:
"
0
~
d
0
~
~
. l!
w
f> 3
.. "
0 "
01 01
~ .
0 ~
..
'-
, '
TO PLAINTll'F(SI
YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED TO PLEAD
ronlll ENCLOSED NEW MA1TER
wmuN TWENn' (20) DAYS FROM SERVICE
HEREOF ORA DEFAULT JUDGMENT MAY
BE ED.uN ;yOU,
PENNELL, ]ENKINS, ROBINSON & WOLF
Barbara Pennell- I.D, No. 17192
JAMES A. GODIN, ESQUIRE
Identification No. 65914
756 Public Ledger Building Attorney for: DEFENDANT
Philadelphia, PA 19106 MONRO MUFFLER/BRAKE
(215) 627-3087
--------------------------
B &: L GLASS
VS.
: COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND
: COUNTY - CIVIL ACTION - LAW
: TRIAL DIVISION
MONRO MUFFLERlBRAKE
: APPEAL FROM D.], JUDGMENT
: NO, 95-1014
DEFENDANT. MONRO MUFFLER/BRAKE'S ANSWER TO
PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT WITH NEW MA TIER
The Defendant, Monro/Muffler/Brake, hereby responds to the Plaintiff's
Complaint and avers as follows:
1. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the allegations contained
in paragraph one. Same are therefore denied and strict proof thereof is demanded at
time of trial.
2. Admitted,
3, Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the allegations contained
in paragraph three. Same are therefore denied and strict proof thereof is demanded
at time of trial,
4, Denied, After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the allegations contained
in paragraph four. Same are therefore denied and strict proof thereof is demanded
at time of trial.
5. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the allegations contained
in paragraph five. Same are therefore denied and strict proof thereof is demanded at
time of trial.
6. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without
knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the allegations contained
in paragraph six. Same are therefore denied and strict proof thereof is demanded at
time of trial,
WHEREFORE, answering defendant demands judgment in their favor,
NEW MA TIER
7. Plaintiff's Complaint fails to state a cause of action against the defendant,
8. The plaintiff's claims are barred in whole or in part by the terms and
provisions of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law,
9. Plaintiff's claims are barred in whole or in part in that plaintiff assumed
the risk of any and ali damages that were allegedly sustained.
10. The plaintiff's claims are barred in whole or in part by the terms and
provisions of the Pennsylvania Comparative Negligence Act.
11, The plaintiff's claims are barred and/or limited by the Doctrine of
Collateral Estoppel.
12. Plaintiff's cause of action is barred and/or limited by the Doctrine of Ras
Judicada.
WHEREFORE, answering defendant demands judgment in their favor,
PENNELL, JENKINS, ROBINSON & WOLF
BY: ~~____________
ES A. G<>Efrril, ESQUIRE
i\1TORNEY FOR DEFENDANT
MONRO MUFFLER/BRAKES
.
VERIFICATION
JAMES A. GODIN. ESOUlRE says that he is the AlTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT In
the above case and states that he Is authorized to take this Verification on behalf of
defendant, Monro Muffler/Brakes and verifies that the statements made In the
foregoing PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT WITH NEW MAlTER are true and correct
to the best of his knowledge, information and beUef, The undersigned understands
that the statements therein made are subject to the penalties of 18 Pa, C,S. S4904
relating to unsworn falsification to authorities,
~~~--------
~AMES A. GO I ESQUIRE
U fJ,./1f/
DA TE: J+-:!1~-
PENNELL, JENKINS, ROBINSON & WOLF
Barbara Pennell - I.D, No, 17192
JAMES A. GODIN, ESQUIRE
Identification No, 65914
756 Public Ledger Building Attorney for: DEFENDANT
Philadelphia, PA 19106 MONRO MUFFLER/BRAKE
(215) 627.3087
--------------------------
B&LGLASS
VS.
: COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND
: COUNTY - CIVIL ACTION - LAW
: TRIAL DIVISION
MONRO MUFFLER/BRAKE
: APPEAL FROM D.J, JUDGMENT
: NO, 95-1014
PRAECIPE TO SUBSTITlITE VERIFICATION
TOTHEPROTHONOTAR~
Kindly substitute the attached Verification to Defendant's Answer which was
filed with the Court on April 21, 1995,
Respectfully submitted,
PENNELL, JEN NS, ROBINSON & WOLF
AMES~~iRE-- ----
ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT
MONROE MUFFLER/BRAKE
B&L GLASS,
:
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
NO. 95-1014 CIVIL TERM
Vs,
MONRO MUFFLER/BRAKE,
Defendant
NOTICE OF RESCHEDULED HEARING BY BOARD OF ARBITRATORS
You are hereby notified that the Board of Arbitrators appointed by the Court
in the above captioned case has rescheduled the hearing from Tuesday, June 18, 1996
at 10:00 a.m. ~o Wednesday, September 18, 1996 at 10:00 a,m, at the Second Floor
Hearing Room, Old Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle, Pennsylvania
Michael R. Rundle, Esquire
Michelle R. Calvert, Esquire
Paul B. Orr, Esquire
~,~(LQu-
By:
Michael R. Rundle, Chairman
Board of Arbitrators
DATE:~~ 2, \'\.t~ fc
To: Matthew J. Eshelman, Esquire
LAw OmCES OF PATRICK F. LAUER, JR,
2108 Market Street
Aztec Building
Camp Hill, PA 17011
James A. Godin, Esquire
PENNELL, JENKINS, ROBINSON & WOLF
756 Public Ledger Building
Philadelphia, PA 19106
n '0 0
G 0' 'II
-oi " '- -:-:l
,-
rv~. 1:':': ,:';:0
":-.' ,-
"/' I ,m
(ii'" '" .;~
-<> ....
(;:., ::." ~J'l]
~; . ...,
......: . .~~
:r~ '2
'::1
:.'1 ;ij
\.:) -<,;
,.
t,:~
BARBARA A. I"ENNELL
JOANfIo1i RUMSBY ,liNK1NS
LAWRENCE. L. IOBIN!KJN
DAVID S. WOLf
JAMES A, IIO!IAI<OWSI<I
BARBARA C. KARKUT
JOSEl'l-1 B. ERWIN
IIliNRY P. SlONELAkE
RlCIIARO J, IANDRY
BIlIINARO J, Md.AFFEIlTY. JK-
ANNE 1L. COLE
PAllUCk J, IIA5IlDN
DEBOlWl II, EV ANCElOU
JOSEPH I'. CRANE
JOANNR L. TAUFI!Il
ntoMAS P. CANNON
"^ n IER1NIi M, SIlEA
JF.NNIFEJI OIUN 5TIlAWN
JOSI!I'II c, 1I\11T1lMANN
DAVIOC. NOKER
JAMES A. GODIN
MARK F. MACDONALD
I'EllIlO J, RIVERA
SCOTT J, IOEI'IlN
MINNA J, ALLI!KJN
JAMES l'ATlUCK I-DCltEY
LAW OFFICES
Cf
PENNELL, JENKINS, ROBINSON & WOLF.
756 PUBLIC LEDGER BUILDING
6111& ClIESlNUT STREETS
150 SOUTIIINDEPENDENCE MALL WEST
PI IlLADELPIIlA, PENNSYLVANIA 19106
TELEI'IIONIl:
215-627,3OB7
215-627.3088
fAX: 215.629.1570
215-627.0399
'NOT A l'AR1NERSIIIP
June 28, 1996
Via Facsimile (717) 249-6154
and First Class Mail
Michael R. Rundle, Esquire
FOWLER, ADDAMS, SHUGHART & RUNDLE
P.O, Box 208
28 South Pitt Street
Carlise, Pa 17013-0208
RE: B&L Glass vs. Monro Muffler/Brake
No. 95-1014
Our File No. AB303-D43632-01
Dear Mr, Rundle:
I am writing this letter to confirm that the arbitration originally scheduled for June
18, 1996 has been rescheduled for Wednesday, September 18, 1996 at 10:00 a,m. Enclosed
please find a Notice of Rescheduled Hearing by Board of Arbitrators which I have prepared
on your behalf. Please sign and file same with the Prothonotary and return a time
stamped copy in the enclosed self addressed stamped envelope.
Thank you for your cooperation in this matter.
JAG/srg
Enclosure
cc: Matthew J. Eshelman, Esquire - (Via Fax - 717-763-4247)
Michelle Calvert, Esquire (Via Fax - 215-963-5462)
Paul B. Orr, Esquire (Via Fax -717-243-0061
MRIAIlA ... l'Il.'lIlliLL
)OANNIl1WWIIY JlNXlNI
I.AWUNG L. IOIINSON
PIoVJl) ! WOU:
IA)ItS I., ICIoUCWSI<I
IAUAIlIo Co JWUaJT
J05EPI/ I, ERWIN
llIiIiIlY P.1lDNUAG
IUQIIollD I. LIo/'o'llllY
IIINIoID I. l4d.Al'JIliIltv, JI.
IoNNI J(. COLIl
P~~l' KAImH
o II. BVIoNCELOU
)OGPK p, 0I0NI
~L. TIoUFIR
P. CANNON
ICIoIHElllNB lI. 5IIIlIo
JiIlNIPO 0lLIN IIUWH
JOlIEPH Co IlUI'IIlNIoNlI
DAVID Co NOICD
~ ... COllIN
P.IolIoCDONIoLD
PIDIOI' -
scorr JaIlPIlN
MINNA J, AWIDN
IAMBS PlollUtX H1C1C1lY
LAW OFFICES
Cf'
PENNELL, JENKINS, ROBINSON & WOLF.
756 PUBUC LBDCER BUILDINC
61H " CHEStNUT STREElS
150 SCUTa INDEPENDENCI! MALL WFST
PH1LADELI'HL\,I'ENNsYLVANIA 19106
21S.U1~17
215,621.50"
l1!I2J'Ha>/2;
PAX: 215.629.1510
215,621,0399
'NOT ^ I'AR'lNIl1lSlI1P
June 12, 1996
Yii.F.acsimile (717) 249-6t!W
Michael R. Rundle, Esquire
28 S. Pitt Street
Carlise, Pa 17013
RE: B&L Glass vs. Monro Muffler/Brake
No. 95-1014
Our File No. AB303-o43632-01
Dear Mr. Rundle:
I am writing to request a continuance of the above matter which is scheduled for
June 18, 1996 at 10:00 a,m, Plaintiff's counsel, Matt Eshelman, Esquire has no objection to
the continuance request,
;zery uly yours,
_ C/~c>d:::-
# -
?
James A. Godin
JAG/srg
cc: Michelle Calvert, Esquire (Via Fax - 215-963-5462)
Paul B, Orr, Esquire (VIa Fax -717-232-8411)
Prothonotary Cumberland County
Matthew J. Eshelman, Esquire (Via Fax - 717-763-4247
----~------------------- --.-----...------.---------.------. .---.----.--------.-----.--.--.-------------
JUtI 12 '96 03: 40PM PHILA LEGAL
P.I 2
LAW OFFICIlS OF
PENNELL, JENKINS, ROBINSON AND WOLF>>
756 PubUc Ledger BuDding
6th & chestnut 8treetS
Philadelphia, PA 19106
(215) 627.3087
.N.I a Parlnenhlp
TELBCOPIIlR NUMBBR
(215) 62P.1570
(215) '27.0399
FACSIMILE COVER SHEET
Please deliver the followIng material
FROM: AMES A. GODIN, ESQUIRE
DATE: JUNE 12, 1996
TO: MICHAEL R. RUNDLE, ESQUIRE
FAX NO, (717) 249.6154
TO: MICHELLE CALVERT, ESQUIRE
FAX NO, (215) 963-5462
TO: PAUL B. ORR, ESQUIRE
FAX NO, (717) 232-8411
TO: MATI'HEW . ESHELMAN, ESQUIRE
FAX NO. (717) 763-4247
RE: B&:L GLASS VS. MONRO MUFFLERlBRAKE
PAGES i INCLUDING COVER SHEET
........CONFIDENTIALITY NOTE.........
The documents accompanying this telecopy tral\&mlsslon contained Information from the law
flrm oE PeMeJl,lenklns, Robinson &. WolE which Is conEJdentlal and/or legally privlledged,
The information 15 Intended only lor the use oElhe Individual or entity named the Intended
recipient, you are hereby nollfled that any disclosure, COpying. distribution or the laking oEany
acUon In rellAllte on the contents of this telecopled infOl'TMllon Is strictly prohibited, and that
the documents should be returned to this firm Immediately. In this regard, IE you have received
this telecopy In error, please notlfy us by telephone so that we can arrange for the return of the
original documents to us al no cost to you.
........................f.........................~........................
B & L GLASS,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 95-1014 CIVIL TERM
v.
MONRO MUFFLER/BRAKE,
Defendant
NOTICE OF RESCHEDULED HEARING BY BOARD OF ARBITRATORS
You are hereby notified that the Board of Arbitrators
appointed by the Court in the above captioned case has
rescheduled the hearing from Wednesday, May 1, 1996 at
10:00 a.m. to Tuesday, June 18, 1996, at 10'00 a.m. at the
Second Floor Hearing Room, Old Cumberland County Courthouse,
Carlisle, Pennsylvania.
Michael R. Rundle, Esquire
Michelle R. Calvert, Esquire
Paul B. Orr, Esquire
By:
\~VJ \.lLt>>~ L~
Michael R. Rundle, Chairman
Board of Arbitrators
DATE: March 29, 1996
TO: Matthew J. Eshelman, Esquire
Aztec Building
2108 Market Street
Camp Hill, PA 17011-4706
James A. GOdin, Esquire
756 Public Ledger Building
Philadelphia, PA 19106
Court Administrator
B , L GLASS,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 95-1014 CIVIL TERM
v.
MONRO MUFFLER/BRAKE,
Defendant
NOTICE OF HEARING BY BOARD OF ARBITRATORS
You are hereby notified that the Board of Arbitrators
appointed by the Court in the above captioned case will sit for
the purpose of their appointment at the second floor hearing
room, old CUmberland County Courthouse, Carlisle, Pennsylvania,
on Wednesday, May 1, 1996, at 10:00 a.m.
Michael R. Rundle, Esquire
Michelle R. Calvert, Esquire
Paul B. Orr, Esquire
By:
~ll~QR QLuQ~
Michael R. Rundle, Chairman
Board of Arbitrators
DATE: March 19, 1996
TO: Matthew J. Eshelman, Esquire
Aztec Building
2108 Market street
Camp Hill, PA 17011-4706
James A. GOdin, Esquire
756 ~ublic Ledger Building
Philadelphia, PA 19106
Court Administrator
By:
,. James A. G~r(,'Esquire
ORDER OF COURT
tn/illf' j,,(j . 1996, in consideration of the
m,.e.J>A~/ IlUAldlL.Esquireand /lJ/LJaF.J/F- - 9;u/tJ'tl
. Esquire, and 1'A U L (j /G/C.
B&L GLASS
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I]'{aillliff
Vs.
MONRO MUFFLER/BRAKE
Vcjcnlfant
NO, 95-1014
PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS
TO THE HONOfABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT:
lames A. Godin. Esquire. counsel for the defendant in the above action (or
I
actions), respectfull}' represents that:
1. The above-captioned action is at issue,
2, The claim of the Plaintiff in the action is $ 1,434,25
The counterclaim of the defendant in the action is
The following attorneys are interested in the case as counselor are otherwise
disqualified to sit as arbitrators:
WHEREFORE, your petitioner prays your Honorable Court to appoint three
(3) arbitrators to whom the case shall be submitted.
Respectfully submitted,
PENNELL, JEN INS, ROBINS
G.
AND NOW,
foregoing petition,
CA/vEA7
. Esquire, are
appointed arbitrators in the above-captioned action as prayed for,
By t~e Court,
\.......i (L-l,
!
COMMONWEALTH Of PENNSYLVANIA
COUIT Of COMMON 'LIAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
JUDICIAL DISTIICT
NOTICE OF APPEAL
~-J7-qS
FROM
u.
Muffle
y
,
DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT
COMMON'UASNo, q5 -101'1- a>>J. T~
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Nollce I. given that the appellant ha. filed In the above Court of Common Plea. on appeal from the ludgment rendered by the DI.lllct Ju.llce ,
on the dole and In the co.e menlloned below.
B & L GLASS
'-'
FEbruar 2 1995
JU N
/"',,*1/)
09-1-01
,-
2. -2.. ,1S-
TA (~':; 0000311 - qlf
LT 19
Thl. block will be .Igned ONLY when this notollon Is required under Po. R.C.P,J.P,
No. l008B,
This Nollce of Appeal, when received by the District Jusllce, will operate os 0
SUPERSEDEAS to Ihe ludgment for possession In this case,
B & L Glas
SIgnature 01 Prothonotary Of Deputy
- 1,j)..
l/eW.::J'&~Ll~MJ 121h~
.
If appel/ant was CLAIMANT ( e Pa. R,C.P.J.P,
No, 1001(6) In acllon befo,e District Justice,
he MUST FILE A COMPLAINT within Iwenly (20)
days afte, filing his NOTICE of APPEAL
PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE
(This section of form to be used ONL Y when appel/ani was DEFENDANT (see Po, RCP,J,P. No. l00I(7)/n action bofore D/strlclJustice.
IF NOT USED. detach f,om copy of notice of appeal to be served upon appel/ee),
PRAECIPE: To Prothonotary ,
Enter rule upon -?nDn r-fI itl t) f: i='~ / A.,... t:-<. ,oppellee(.), to file 0 complaint In Ihls appeal
. Name ~l/eJfr
(Common Pleas No, 9' <;) -I b III (',' ",- '- ) within twenty (20) days after service of rulo or for entry of ludgment of non pros,
(
Signature of appel/am 01 hiS .ttorney or agenl
RULE: To "1r) pYl r-p 1n LA;].f Lll (. If? tL KR. , oppellee(s).
Nam!!, 01 ~tJtI8lfee(,) . .'
'.J ,-
'.
(1) You ore notified that a rule Is hereby enlered upon you 10 file 0 complaint In this appeal within twenty (20) days afte! the ddle 6f
service of this rule upon you by personal service or by certified or regislered moll.
(2) If you do not file 0 complaint within Ihls time, 0 JUDGMENT OF NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU,
(3) The dote of service of thl. rule If .ervice wa. by moil I. the date of moiling,
Dote:
.19_.
SlQnature 01 Ptotttono,.ry 01 Deputy
COURT FILE
AOPC 312.80
~.~
.~.:; ,;.I
\J ~:-...
':1;1'-
~
""
--
--'
,
....,
<....)
.r:
<To
-0
:;:)::
~
,i
n'<, ,....t.".-
'-_':':1' ~.
. - ., (~; -.,
'.:'0
h (~I":"
:..
__l ~_,
..;:..
PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT
(This prool o( service MUST BE FILED WITHIN FIVE (5) DA YS AFTER ''''''9 the flollce o( eppeel. Check applicable boltes)
COMMOIIWIAlTH OF PENNSYlVANIA .1
COUNTY OF C C,) IT) b Vt-( a.._
J--_: II
AFFIDAVIT: I hereby sweor or oHllm tholl ~Qfved
o 0 copV of Ihe Nol;e. of App..,,1 Co "'mo', 1'1"". No __!l~ --Jt2I-1__CY.: upon the DI.tr'cl Ju.llce designated therein an
(dille 01 cerViceL____~~_l~_",___, ,QjlJ, LJ by """cr.", ""V;'6 ~ (certilled) (registered) mail; iender's
,ecl.'lp' attached herolo, und IJpon lh~; op~r:llee, ('liImej___J:Orn..I!.~_~__~o~c:Lin ~.:) t1 , on
~ ,
'i . J J . 19 ..:...'l~:::""[l by po(~onol \ervic" l~ (~o:r!jflfo(l) (rngi,rereJ) moil, 'sende,'s receipt a"oched hereto.
o and flJrlher that I scr...cd the Rule 10 hln a Complainl o((om"onying the obu'4'o NOlico of Appeal upon the oppellee(l) to
whom the Rule was add,,,..ed on __ Y - 1-3-____-. I? Q~ by personal rvicea-t;y (certified) (registered)
moil, sender's receipt attached herolo.
~~Jl
S/QnIJt"",oIal/latfl
SWORN (AF!lfMED) AND SUBSCRIBfD BEfORE ME
THIS----13~AY 0 ~___. 19___.
I ,ltidal',t was made
Title 01 oftk",
My co
8)l: If ,BJ'
Malth., L.~, Notary P\dc
r."...-.-Ilco,; CiJntlel1ardCounly
~;CCO''\1.'<tlcnElcplresSepl.le.l!l95
Ir.;;.,. 19I"lIti'JfvI1OlaAGsodCbOn
,19_.
OJ Name: Hon
CHARLES A. CLEMENT,
1106 CARLISLE ROAD
CAMP HILL, PA
JR.
q}'~ ItJl'( ~ 'r....--
COMMON PLEAS NOTIFIC~ION
PLAIWIFF REQUEST FORM
NAME IIId ADDRE88 .
Ii & L GLASS I
902 MARKET STREET
LEMOYNE, PA 17043
L ~
VS.
DEFENDANT: .~_
r- NAMEIIId~
'MONRO MUFFLER/BRAKE
1051 MARKET STREET
LEMOYNE, PA 17043
L
I
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF: CUMBERLAND
MagOlllHo:
09-1-01
-,
T_, (717) 761-4940 17011
CHARLES A. CLEMENT, JR.
1106 CARLISLE ROAD
CAMP HILL, PA 17011
~
Docket No.: CV-0000379-94
Date Flied: 11/02/94
Pl.... be .dvl.ed that an .ppe.1 h.. be.n fllod In Iho .bovo c.ptlonod c..o, KIndly u.. thl.lorm to Indlc.I. tho ...ullo
In Ihl. c.... and return 10 Ih. I..ulng .uthorlty (Ii.I.d .bov.).
RESULT OF APPEAL
SUMMARY APPEAL
APPEAL STAlCKEN . .pp..1 h.. be.n dl..llow.d,
APPEAL DISCONTINUED. .ppe.1 h.. be.n dl'Onllnu.d by .pp.lI.nt
DISTAlCT JUSTICE DECISION UPHELD. cou~ h.. r..ch.d ..m. d.cl.lon .. orlgln.1 dlotrlct ju.tic. d.cl.lon.
_ dlotrlct julllc. ollie. I. 10 coll.ct rom.lnlng fln.oIco.ta,
APPEAL SUCCESSFUL. cou~ h.. ...ch.d d.cl.lon f.vor.bl. 10 d.f.nd.nt.
lull ralund 10 be I..ued by dl.I~ct ju.tlc. offlc.,
pallJal refund 10 be I..u.d by dl.trtct ju.tic. offlc..
REVISED DISTRIBUTION OF FINES AND COSTS
ff dlotrlct juatJco oIIIco 1.10 I..u. . partl.1 rolund, pl.... Indlcat. any now dlotrlbutJon In the amount(.)
of fin.. and coati .. a ,..ult of the court's decision.
FINE
COUNTY CRT COST
STATE CRT COST
STATE CSTI
HEARING COST
EMS
CAT
JCP
DVC
evc
CCD
OTHER(pl.... .paclty)
CIVIL APPEAL
APPEAL STAlCKEN . .ppe.1 h.. be.n dl..llowod,
APPEAL DISCONTINUED. .ppe.1 h.. be.n dl.contlnu.d by .pp.lI.nt.
DlSTRICT JUSTICE DECISION UPHELD . cou~ h.. r..ch.d tho ..m. docl.lon .. tho dl.trtct juotic. judgm.nt
DISTAlCT JUSTICE DECISION DISMISSED . cou~ h.. r..ch.d . d.cl.lon Ih.t do.. not concur with th. dlotrlct juotic.judgm.nt
WRIT OF CERTIORARI
WRIT STAlCKEN . appe.1 h.. boon dl..llow.d,
WRIT DISCONTINUED. wrR h.. be.n dl.contlnued by .ppellont
DISTAlCT JUSTICE DECISION SET ASIDE. tho c... will b. ..h.ard duo 10 Irrogulorlty. I.ck of ju~odlctlon. or Improper v.nu.,
WRIT DISMISSED. dl.trtclju'Ilc. d.cl.lon w.. not found 10 be tlowod, I.cklng ju~.dlctlon . or h.vlng Improper v.nu.,
STATEMENT OF pBJECTION (PI.... glv. . g.ner.1 .umm.1)' 01 Ih. ...uR.)
OBJECTION DISCONTINUED. obj.ctlon h.. boan dl.contlnued by Ih. .ppell.nt
OBJECTION DENIED. obJ.ctlon h.. be.n d.nl.d by Ih. Cou~ of Common PI...,
OBJECTION UPHELD. .ppell.nl'. obJ.ctlon h.. b..n uph.ld by tho Cou~ of Common PI...,
AOPe 729-&4
FORM PRINTED:
4/17/95 15:01:50
(") v:l ~
~ Ol
]En ~ :::t
fl, 'J
~ lj
=<-f:"' I
cnh N "J
......";. 'J
~C. ;!::.. :-;
~r - }
-..
~r;' ~ ~J
';--j
h, :.n ~
-; \.0
~
I
6~L
v.
)
)
}
)
)
)
MlAFfLfI2/ISRIWE )
,
\:X\"l'IAtI v.l OAm
G.Lj\ss
rl"nt"il
In The Court of Co~on Plaas of
C-
Cumberland County, ?enns~lvania
llo. 95: 10lLI 19
(Y\ON ~
We do solemnly swear (or affirm) that we will support, obey and derend
the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution or this Common-
wealth and that we will discharge the duties of our office Wi~.lh TIdelity.
'1\ ') \
E'; Ln- \ I,^'ll U,l OR k'........ l~ f7n.'
j':':': f~ ~~:: Cha1r:nan
~(:_- ,1 ~.Ii.
bi.. "",. ~ 'Cj..~ N ,( fjv,~'
.' C'J ,":J .;'..,1
8L "j{ v
r:! I.', C.~ . tb
~ ~ b: ':, Cl. AWARD
l'. \.n "')
L.' :.,) (j
We, the undersigned arbitrators, having been duly appointed and sworn
(or affirmed), make the following award:
(Note: If damages for delay are awarded, they shall be
separately stated.)
T ~ ll;, e~lk\"('JJ
~t~: <0\ ]}, Lt, "
.....~
b\( "0 rt'O L\'\!CC~ r~/11 vf,'f' r.
Arbitrator, dissents. (Insert name if
applicable.)
Date of Hearing: C)-t8.Qb
Date of Award: q-/S.qt;
j\/\ .1 U tel.! 0 () {l........ICel~
. AI II ~ ~a191lln
f'V\ I c.. t....>>..( It, (U/H...J--
~~~,
NOTICE OF ENTRY OF AWARD
lIew, the IS day or Gt/l1 Cl\lhtl~ , 19~, at I!:2.J:; .LL.:t.,
award was entered upon the do~kat and notice chereof given by mail
~arties or thei: attorneys.
the above
to the
Arbitrators' comoeusation
paid upon appeal:
$ <~ 0C'. I-!
to be
~1"l-tL1\-tJ
3y:
] ~"-' ~<<........... 5'L-;~d- ..
l
)j~'1f-'- D...-.r-,~
':...1 f.J (9.A~
.?
K<.......U~
'"'"
""'"
'--"
r
.,\
f
1",
f
-l:\
,
~
~
~