The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About95-01045 to- ~ ~ I] l.. ~ (J... ~' € ~ J - j I j -_.-.. .' . .>>" , - =-.~; ~> C~) l:A - ...~ ....... "'", ""':;;:'l~ :~z.~".)< ...0 .... ... :C:O~' O.-;.I':'_f . '...." >- ~:ta~-JifJ ,.,.l '"" OC Z. :;:'t.....W. ""l"H\~ ;:X.... '" e;c..." E .... N N co ....., ... w ...... . 1ft :>0 -1"'1'" et.'!',.... ,...n "''''' ~..... It " ..~ "'..~ QJ&- q:T :0"" 0' "..! ~,':)....~ "-C"'~~ .. .-~.~ ~ . , . ~'O ~ ~ ~ \~ ~ n--< ~ ,...., ~ 4 oil'. .~ - , ~ <-io, ~ ~.. (::! ~) ~~H i ~ oil p IWI '~/....~...E. III.P' ,P", ~"rr<..I>"J I I'1t'!)U. t ~I;IN ,...". ".""r; "; ", f .j,;f,t'" .............. ", .... ~(:1\,i..,. t:. ..... .....,.. ~...'# .._"Ii f ....._..' ",'wI ~.,~.._, .... .'. ,,#... DAVID K. HUFFER and SUANNE HUFFER, his wife, Plaintiffs IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA . . v. . . NO. . . DONALD L. HOFFLER, Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED COMPLAINT AND NOW, come the Plaintiffs, by their attorneys Mancke, Wagner, Hershey & Tully, and file the following Complaint: 1. Plaintiffs David K. Huffer and Suanne Huffer, his wife, are adult individuals residing at 117 East Keller Street, Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. 2. Defendant Donald L. Hoffler, is an adul t individual residing at 5208 Oxford Circle, No. 87, Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. 3. At all times relevant herein, the facts and occurrences occurred on or about June 27, 1993, at or about 9:00 a.m., on South Market Street, Upper Allen Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. 4. At the above-mentioned time and place, the Plaintiff David Huffer, was operating a 1990 Honda and travelling south on South Market Street, at the intersection of Gettysburg Pike, Upper Allen Township. 5. At the aforement ioned time and place, the Defendant Donald L. Hoffler, was operating a 1992 Chevrolet, travelling north on South Market Street, Upper Allen Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. 6. At the aforementioned time and place, the Defendant did make a left hand turn into the path of the Plaintiffs' vehicle, violently colliding with the Plaintiffs' vehicle. 7. The Plaint iff Suanne Hu ffer, at all times relevant herein, was a passenger in the vehicle operated by her husband, Plaintiff David Huffer. 8. As a result of the aforementioned collision, the Plaintiff Suanne Huffer, did suffer the following injuries: a. Trauma to the nervous system; b. Chondromalacia of the patella; c. Medial lateral meniscectomy; and d. Arthritis. 9. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Plaintiff Suanne Huffer underwent great pain and suffering and will in the future undergo great pain and suffering. 10. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Plaintiff Suanne Huffer did suffer discomfort and in the future will suffer discomfort. 11. As a result of the aforement ioned injuries, Plainti ff Suanne Huffer suffered a loss of life's pleasures and will in the future suffer a loss of life's pleasures. 12. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Plaintiff Suanne Huffer has suffered a permanent injury in that she sustained post-traumatic arthritis in the knee, which is permanent in nature. 13. As a resuit of the aforementioned injuries, Plaintiff Suanne Huffer has suffered inconvenience and will in the future suffer inconvenience. 14. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, Plaintiff I' \ I Suanne Huffer will suffer a permanent loss of earning capacity and will undergo, in the future, medical costs as a result of the post- , I traumatic arthritis in the knee. 15. The aforementioned injuries and loss were a direct result of the Defendant's negligent and careless operation of his motor vehicle in: a. Failing to observe Plaintiffs' vehicle; b. Turning left in front of Plaintiffs' vehicle; c. Fai ling to yield the right of way to the Plaintiffs' oncoming vehicle; d. Failing to stop so as to avoid a collision with Plaintiffs' vehicle; and e. Colliding with the vehicle of Plaintiffs. 16. As a result of the aforementioned conduct and the operation of the vehicle by the Defendant, Plaintiffs sustained the injuries as aforementioned. WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs pray This Court to grant Judgment in favor of the Plaintiffs and against the Defendant in an amount in excess of $20,000.00. COUNT II DAVID HUFFER V. DONALD I.. HUFFLER 17. As a result of the aforementioned collision, the / .,1 Plaintiff David K. Huffer has been deprived of and will continue to be deprived of the care, companionship, consortium, and society of his wife, all of which is to his great detriment. WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs pray This Court to grant judgment in favor of the Plaintiffs and against the Defendant in an amount in excess of 520,000.00. HANCKE, WAGNER, HERSHEY, & TULLY Date: ';;--;;J- ( ~7"; . #23103 VBRX.XCATXOM I verify that the statements made in the foreqoinq document are true and correct. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. section 4904, relatinq to unsworn falsification to authorities. .j P 4L,,~1 J( iJc (~/~, /. DATE: c2 /; 3 /'15 ~ \..n en - ::c "'- .n "" ('0') ...., "" ... = .~. "'II ""." H)"I,W.'l.nu." JO 'S'" OttftlfO'O)l,.,...."OJ1hU.tw ... ;.0;,..... ';; i~; :"", ~~ "~ ,... ,~,~- . ) ..,~ . ';.I'",I;;"!~:. , ,:'- t/.; III Z ~ 0: ; ~ If( ~ .. 11I0 ~~~ 1d3Ul ..J~> .J~~ llliiia: ~:::O C~\: .J ~ 0( 4(a u. ;;~. , . \ :;, Q E :;;0( ... z ~ 0( "':i Hi o z ~ z .. w ~Q, IX . 0" z II: ::l ... ID "'Ill ... ~ II: 0( :J: ..... . ...' - DAVID K. HUFFER and SUANNE HUFFER, his wire. PlaintilTs : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA : CIVIL ACTION - LAW v. : NO. 95-1045 DONALD L. HOFFLER. Derendant : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED PRAECIPE TO THE PROTHONOT AR Y: Please enter my appearance on behalf of Defendant, DONALD L. HOFFLER, only, in the above-captioned matter. Respectfully submitted, BY:~.........r: James G. Nealon, III, Esquire Atty. 1.0, #46457 363\ North Front Street Harrisburg, PA 171\0 (717) 232-7661 Attorney for Defendant, DONALD L, HOFFLER CALDWELL Dated: March 10, 1995 .. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE AND NOW, this 10 day of March, 1995, I hereby certifY that I have served the foregoing Praecipe for Entry of Appearance on the following by depositing a true and correct copy of same in the United States mails, postage prepaid, addressed to: P. Richard Wagner, Esquire Mancke, Wagner, Hershey & Tully 2233 North Front Street Harrisburg, P A 17110 -4~ James G. Nealon, III, Esquire Dated: March 10, 1995 SHERIFF'S RETURN C'CMolCtlWEAL1l1 OF PENNSYLVANIA: COONTY OF ClMBERLAND David K. Hu~~r and Suanne Huffer, his wife In The Court of Common Pleas of CUmberland COunty, Pennsylvania No. 95-1045 Civil Term Ccrnplaint in Civil Action Law and Notice vs Donald L. Hoffler Timothy Reitz , ~r Deputy Sheriff of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, wno being duly sworn acc<;lrding to law, says, that he served the within Canplaint in Civil Action Law and Notice Upon Ibna1d L. Hoffler P.M. EST I ~, on the The defendant at 12:24 o I clock 02 March day of , 19~ at ,CUmberland County, 6022 Hunningbird Drive, Mechanicsburg Pennsylvania, by handing to Ibnald L. Hoffler a true and attested copy of the and at the same time directing his Canplaint in Civil Action Law and Notice attention to the contents thereof and the "Notice to Plead" endorsed thereon. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing Service Affidavit Surcharge 18.00 6.16 2.00 26.16 Ri. by Atty. 3-08-95 So answers: ~t'?..:~,1/;" p? r ";~~1-''':::?'~ R. Thanas Kline, Sheriff SWorn and subscribed to before me by -.-- rJ!L Z;--- fJ- A ;,.-:-,)' . I< -1 I . Deputy Sheriff this N ~ day of ">>~ 19 ~o( A.D. ~I'~ Q. )>"u,~, UY1J1 Prothonotary i " I , Q Ul E z . I- :! 0 ... II ~ ~ ... z 4( . 0( a: ~ 0 oJ I- I&J 0 VI ~ . l- I- 0 ~ 0 0( z ~ u III 0 z ~ )- a: Z .J . W .. W . % .J 0 Z l- ll. I&J ;; a: a: IS ~ " 0 0 w t: z a: 0 .. :J 0 ;:; .J 0 0( lD 4( . '" III U . 1'1 it a: 0( x Ln en - = u... ", '" N = '" "" ..... ."" . . . . . . .....M.... .t)"'&" .,.,.U.....,.... (llt""O'O"\uI'lt~I'U.,I"l9 .' - . v. * IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS * CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA * * No.: 95-1045 Civil Term * * CIVIL ACTION - LAW * * JURY TRIAL DEMANDED DAVID K. HUFFER and SUANNE HUFFER, his wife, Plaintiffs DONALD L. HOFFLER, Defendant NOTICB TO PLBAD TO: David K. Huffer and Suanne Huffer, Plaintiffs and P. Richard Wagner, Esquire, their attorney MANCKE, WAGNER, HERSHEY & TULLY 2233 North Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED that the New Matter set forth herein contains averments against you to which you are required to respond within twenty (20) days after service thereof. Failure by you to do so may constitute an admission. By: re Dated: ~,., I B f (q95 41019 6 - 17. The averments of paragraphs 6 through 17 of the Complaint are denied in accordance with Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 1029(e). WHEREFORE, the answering Defendant demands that the Complaint be dismissed and judgment entered in his favor and against the Plaintiffs without cost to him but together with such costs, expenses and attorney's fees as authorized by law and which the Court deems necessary, just and appropriate under the circumstances. NEW MATTER 18. Defendant incorporates his Answer to the Plaintiffs' Complaint as if set out in full. 19. Any damages to which the Plaintiffs are entitled are to be reduced, in whole or in part, in accordance with the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law, 75 Pa.C.S.A. 51701, ~ ~. 20. To the extent that losses were paid or payable under any group plan or other arrangement, 51722 of the Motor Vehicle Financial ReSp?nsibi1ity Law prohibits the Plaintiffs from recovering said amounts in this action. WHEREFORE, the answering Defendant demands that the Complaint be dismissed and judgment entered in his favor and against the Plaintiffs without cost to him but together with such costs, expenses and attorney's fees as authorized by law and which the Court deems necessary, just and appropriate under the . . , . . CBRTIFICATB OF SBRVICB I hereby certify that I am this day serving a copy of the foregoing document upon the persons in the manner indicated below, which service satisf~es the requirements of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, by depositing a copy of same in the united States Mail, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, certified mail, return receipt requested, with first-class postage, prepaid, as follows: P. Richard Wagner, Esquire MANCKE, WAGNER, HERSHEY & TULLY 2233 North Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 Attorney for Plaintiffs By: ~WELL -G"': rney Deb ah . Cavacini, Esquire Attor y I.D #67900 3631 North Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717) 232-7661 Attorney for Defendant Donald L. Hoffler Dated: IS 10Ci5 41033 Lr> ~ ;.. ._r ,...t (' \"'-') ''; ~!. = ;;0 ~ N ~... ':' ....l. '"'"" """ >- ... = 0:> ~ ::ll ~ I~~I~ nl~~ia: ~ ll! a <I: w ~J: " . WE 00 HI"EIIV CIPlT'''... THo" 'HI! W'1HU'" Ie A TRUI! AND COHo "leT COPY 0' THI ORIO.NAl 'IUO IN 1HlS ACTION IIY - .. --Arf6jlNf~--'-- . "..",<..0'<.1', .. ....:...r....,~..,Af.,; ...,til.;/j 'l) h. II .....".,.. .""O"U Irl '''' ~':'f~~:-l'''l'''' :'''' nil.. '"'''' "'....... .......r." ,JI.. "......,... ua. IO' 1...,""l>W......~, "" ..;~ . ."'.'"'' MANCKE, WAGNE.fl. HEHSHEY & TULL Y . " DAVID K. HUFFER and . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS . SUANNE HUFFER, his wife, . CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA . Plaintiffs . . . . v. . NO. 95-1045 civil Term . . CIVIL ACTION - LAW . DONALD L. HOFFLER, . . Defendant . JURY TRIAL DEMANDED . ANSWER TO NEW MATTER NOW, COMES the plaintiffs and files the following Answer to . New Matter. 18. No answer is required. 19. This is a legal conclusion to which no answer is required. 20. This is a legal conclusion to which no answer is required. WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs request this Court to dismiss the New Matter. Respectfully submitted, MANCKE, , HERSHEY & TULLY r" Date: sJ~:J.lq5 chard Wagn re #23103 Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 717/234-7051 VBRIJ'ICATIOIII I verify that the statements made in the foregoing document are true and correct. I understand that false .tatements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. Section 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. ~A).lj,l X ~~(~~ c]Ll"~"'1-'<'-< /-W'---- DATE: O/Iff /9) DAVID K. HUFFER and . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS . SUANNE HUFFER, his wife, . CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA . Plaintiffs . . : v. . NO. 95-1045 civil Term . . CIVIL ACTION - LAW . DONALD L. HOFFLER, . . Defendant : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, JoLene Freed, Secretary in the law firm of MANCKE, WAGNER, HERSHEY & TULLY do hereby certify that I am this day serving a copy of the foregoing document to the following person and in the manner indicated below, which service satisfies the requirements of the Pennsylvania Rules of civil Procedure, by depositing the same in the United states Mail, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, with first class postage, prepaid, and addressed as follows: James G. Nealon, III, Esquire CALDWELL & KEARNS 3631 North Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 By ......itc.c/ JoL ne reed, Secretary MANCKE, WAGNER, HERSHEY 2233 North Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 & TULLY P. Richard Wagner, Esquire Attorneys for Plaintiffs Ln en :c .:>... ~ '" m In "... ..... -" = Ii>- w :II!'! Z::l P C) I- ,. ~~~I~ ~~~ri" u en ~ z a: ~ <I: W"I: ~J: .. , WI: DO HEAEIIY CEAT"V THAT THE WITHI'" IS ... T"Ur: ANO COR. RECT cop" or T"r. OJhQINAL flUO If.j 'HIS ACTk)t. ay -~.- . ,,--ft~j;f,,-----~ . '0 "JI~ "",......,.. ... ,'f of', ii. ,., . ""'f'" "'V;',..V ". '.., '....;l"H' ......... '''''''. ~" ...~ ....... '0#.... ""f'. A. ,.......,... ;'::" ...Fj..'........-.. "" .....,..-... ......'."'./A. MANCKE, V"AGNER, HLf~SH( Y & lUll Y DAVID K. HUFFER and SUANNE HUFFER, his wife, Plaintiffs IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO. 95-1045 civil Term CIVIL ACTION - LAW DONALD L. HOFFLER, Defendant JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ANSWER TO REOUEST I'OR PRODUCTION 01' DOCUMENTS 1. See Exhibit "A". 2. See Exhibit nAil. 3. NIA 4. NIA 5. See Exhibit "C". 6. See Exhibit "C". 7. See Exhibit "0" Respectfully submitted, MANCK , WAGNER, ERSHEY & TULLY Date: S/~4/15 :. DAVID K. HUFFER and SUANNE HUFFER, his wife, Plaintiffs IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA . . v. . . . . NO. 95-1045 civil Term CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED DONALD L. HOFFLER, Defendant . . . . CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, JoLene Freed, Secretary in the law firm of MANCKE, WAGNER, HERSHEY & TULLY do hereby certify that I am this day serving a copy of the foregoing document to the following person and in the manner indicated below, which service satisfies the requirements of the pennsylvania Rules of civil procedure, by depositing the same in the United States Mail, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, with first class postage, prepaid, and addressed as follows: James G. Nealon, III, Esquire CALDWELL & KEARNS 3631 North Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 }I<.L J.A.u,i reed, Secretary MANCKE, WAGNER, HERSHEY & TULLY 2233 North Front street Harrisburg, PA 17110 P. Richard Wagner, Esquire Attorneys for plaintiffs 5/1J.4/15 @ s , ~ ! . . . I ~ ~ i t!j," ";;:" , \\ \.. 'I (XX)REFER TO OVERLAY SHEETS ~,.. . .~ POLICE INFORMATION .... - ._~- ..... - COMMONWEAL TH OF PENNSYL VANIA POLICE ACCIDENT REPORT REPORTABLE Cl!I NON. REPORTABLE 0 226-1655 PENNDOT USE ONLY ACCIDENT LOCATION 93-1719 7 2 yO N~ : L INCIDENT I NUMBER ! 2. AGENCY I NAME I:J. STATlONl PRECINCT 5. INVESTlllACTOR h G. . Tompson i 6. APPROVED BY 17. INVESTIGATION j CATE , 1 9. ACCIDENT DATE 11. TIME OF DAY : '3. '51LLED Upper Allen Twp. Police Dept. 14. PATROL I ZONE IlAOGE NUMBER IlAOGE NUMBER 18. ARRIVAL 06-27-93 I TIME 0910 hrs. _ ACCIDENT INFORMATION - tOli-27-93 10. DAY~nWi.)'l \0905 hrs. 12. ~~~'irs 114. 'INJURED 1 15. PRIV. PROP, I ACCIDENT 1'11. 010 VEHICLE HAVE TO BE REMOVED 7. VEHICLE DAMAGE I FROM THE SCENE7 0 . NONE UNIT 1 121 I UNIT 1 UNIT 2 1 . LIGHT '-l 2. MODERATE rI yO Nt] yON [) 3. SEVERE UNIT 2 UJ 1'6. HAZARDOUS 0 'xl 9. PENNDOT 0 Iif1 I MATERIALS Y N L.::J PROPERTY Y N I::J : UNITl/l,. 138, LEGALLY Y N 137. REG. vvp 737 1 38-STATE ; PARKED7 001 PLATE I.-A 39. PA TITLE OR OUT .oF.STATE VIN :~,OWNER Donald L. Hoffler 45543573701 '87 17055 o 1 I 22 052 681 Donald Lee Hoffler '87 17055 63. PHONE 691-0192 199 54 9578 Ice ... puc. (7] CARGO '-1 ODY TYPE 76)HAZARDOUS i'-..:. MATERIALS i ;".1 Gi/WR : n ~El~SE Qf..HAZ MAT vU ~jU IJNKC CODE 21 21. MUNICIPALITY CODE UPoer Allen Two. 104 PRINCIPAL ROADWA Y INFORMA TION ZO. COUNTY 2 22. ROUTE NO, OR STREET NAME 23. SPEED LIMIT 40 26, ROUTE NO. OR STREET NAME 27. SPEED LIMIT 30. CROSS STREET OR SEGMENT MARKER 31. DIRECTION N S FROM SITE 33, DISTANCE WAS Cumberland S. Market St. (Sa 1141 1(24.)TYPE 1l25.1ACCESS I~ HIGHWAY 0 1"-' CONTROL INTERSECTING ROAD: 1 Gettvsbura Pike I(2B.)TYPE 25 I~ HIGHWAY 0 IF NOT A T INTERSECTION: K29.]ACCESS I~ CONTROL 1 E W 132. DISTANCE I FROM SITE MEASURED 0 ESTIMATED ~~RAFFIC PRINCIPAL CONTROL r:;-]2 DEVICE L..=...J FT. MI. o INTERSECTING [I] ~~ONSTRUCTlON ZONE ~ UNIT II 2 HPE 626 138.~~TE 38. LEllAU. Y Y N 37. REG. PARKED? 00 PLATE 39. PA TITLE OR OUT.oF.STATE VIN 40. OWNER 68, CARRIER ADDRESS 69 CITY. STATE . ZIPCODE 10 USOOT , 7'21'1EH -':/CONFlCi 15 NO OF AXLES 42830927301 David K. & Susanne Huffer 117 E. Keller Street Mechanicsburg, PA 144. MAKE I Honda 17055 141. OWNER I ADDRESS 5208 Oxford Circle 42. CITY . STATE & ZIPCODE Mechanicsburg, PA 43. Y9~ I.... MAKE <5. ~g;';.:,~~~T Geo Storm ',47,IBODY 02 ,4ll.]SPECIAL l'-/rvPE '-'USAGE ~50,1INITIAL IMPACT '51.1VEHICLE ,'-" POINT 11 '-' STATUS j53,IVEHICLE 1 54)DRIVER I ; ~ GRADIENT '-' PRESENCE I 156. DRIVER . NUMBER ; 58. DRIVER , NAME 59. DRIVER ADDRESS 5308 Oxford Circle ,<;0, CITY. STATE , & ZIPCODE Mechanicsburo. PA '61. SEX 62. DATE OF M BIRTH 10-02-69 i 84. COMM. VEH.165. DRIVER 166. DRIVER i yO Nl(J I CLASS 1 I SS' i d7. CARRIER : : 1lB. CARRIER j ADDRESS '159. CITY. STATE & ZIPCODE -:"0. USOQT 4 I r;;VEH , CQNF IG ~5 NO OF AXLES 41. OWNER ADDRESS <2. CITY. STATE & ZtPCODE Chevrolet 43. YEAR 90 1<8. INs.,.., 45. MODEL. INOT I Y,,-, NO UNK 0 BODY TYPE) :49.]VEHICLE i47TBODY o '-' OWNERSHIP 1 :-;.;/ TYPE 52.lTRAVEL ,50:IINITIAL IMPACT '-' SPEED 99 "-' POINT 55)DRIVER (53)VEHICLE "'" CONDITION 1 ""'GRADIENT 157. STATE PA 58. DRIVER I NUMBER 58. DRIVER NAME 59, DRIVER ADDRESS 60. CITY. STATE & ZtPCODE Mechanicsburq. PA 17055 61. SEX 182. DATE OF 63. PHONE M I BIRTH 08-25-47 790-9376 64. COMM. vEH. 165. DRIVER 168. ORIVER YO NaI I CLASS liS s, 167 40 2479 67 CARRIER Acc:ord DX C4ll,]SPECIAL 04 "-' USAGE 0 15L)VEHICLE 11 ~STATUS 0 154.IDRIVER 3 "-' PRESENCE I 1 148,INS"" y", NO UNKO ,49.lVEHICLE "-' OWNERSHIP 1 52)TRAVEL "'" SPEED 99 I 55.)DRIVER ...... CONDITION 1 157. STATE I PA 13 181 966 David K. Huffer 117 E. Keller Street !'CC' I 7J jCARGO -900V TYPE K76 iHAZARDOUS !'-" ',4ATERI,AtS PUCf 74 aVWR n R,El.ft\SE Qf HAl MAT fU ~'U UUKO ~Nn 00/0--'0 3sn.3ij 0 1S31 ON og 51,nS3l::1 I ~Nn 0 --, 3sn.3ij 0 % 0 lSll ON 1lO 00 O@ DUON l~S~ 6u,uxn~ DtO,4D^ Z:Z:EE/:>^ ~ LINn :)IN :)1 (03!)l::IYH~ ~I A 'NO) St:t3BwnN NOll:)3S '()6 03J.VOIONI SNOI1Y1QI^ .69 3NOHd Z:9EE-Z:E~ 3NOHd SS3ijOOV 'SA;.:rOs~IMv8 ~ !INn NOI1VrlijO.NI 3~NVijnSNI 3r1VN S3SS3N11M '99 610LI Vd '6xnqstt,O ON A0l10d tVnlnw SP,AUO!lSN NVdWOO 9:l:SpUO!!. SO,UV!, 3WVN ON A~110d ANVdl'lO~ I !INn NOI1VrlijO.NI 3~NVllnSNI ~8Z:L90::l8S E~SCI8z:LLO SlVlSttV .0;:) .SUI 'aua:lS UO luaWlsaJl IS:llpaw pasnJaJ Z# al:l14aA ul Ja6uaSSsd 'l~St 6u,U:l:nl St,4A O,;;D:l:l 6u,soddo Ol A~A-~0-l4D,% PtS,A Ol t,D~ p,p t. :l:OlV%sdO lD4l SA04S lUSP,oov ~p UO,lDD,lSDAUI i 'SlusmSlDlS SAOqV pSm%,~uoo SSSUl,!!. .tSAD%l ;0 4lVd s,4 OlU, l~St psuxnl t' Sto,qsh 'S~,d 6xnqSAlls~ 4l,A UO,lOSS%SlU, sql lV 'lSS%lS lS~%VW 'S uo qlnos 6U,ttSAV%l SVA sq PDlVlS Z' %OlD%sdO 'Z' StO,qsh ql,A PSp,ttoo sq os 6u,op uodn 'S~,d 6xnqSAllsD oluO l;St D Slnosxs Ol pSldmsllv sq S~ld 6xnqSAlls~ 4l,A UOllOSS%SlUl sql lV 'lSS%lS lS~:l:VW 'S uo ql:l:OU 6UlttSAV%l SVA sq pSlvls t' %OlV%sdO 'lovdml/lU10d mo%; pSAom usvq pvq PSAtOAUl SStOlqsA tVA1%%V uodn 'NMON~ .1 'S31~IH~ O3MOJ.,jQ NOIJ.VOO1 ONV NOIJ.WlijO.NI 3~NVllnSNI 3>111 '511Y130 lVNOWOOV 30lAOijd ONV 'SJ.N3r13J. J.S SS3NJ.IM 'SJ.N3A3,jQ 53~N3no35 'S1KlJ.:lV. NOIJ.VSnV:l 'SJ.N3A3 tlNIJ.YlIdl~3ijd kl1J.N301' 3AlJ.WllVN 'La I I '" .. .,' ....................~.................. '" c ::a "': .,,: .......:....'.'...........'....,..'......'........ ......,...... I q-......q .....,~.....l...... 3NOHd SS3ijOV -' ",: ..m.:....... I' Ii='t"i"9 . , ~<: ij3NMO ~ ---'1S:'~W 'S-- AlIl3dOijd 03DWMI ,j() NOIJ.dlij0S30 .~ .,.: <I=C:I . l31SV:lnddV .0 J.:l11iLS10 1OOHOS V1NVA1A5NN3d .tQ [!] 3~'''ijns avo ~ ij3HJ.Y3M@ ~ NOIJ.VNlrlnlll'l rMltlVlO '99 0 0 II 9 6 ~ Z:. :l:OlV%S 0 sv smvs :l:s~~nH suuvns C t C U .a C z: 0 0 N 0 0 0 Z:. :l:OlV% 0 C t C S~ W I z: 0 0 N 0 0 0 ti :l:OlV%S 0 Z C CZ W I rI 1 ~ r H 5S3ltOOV 3t'IVN tl . 3 0 ~ S NOll VVlllO.NI 31d03d ' E6-LZ:-90 :31'10 !N30100V .un1:JV.1Y:lI03i'f '1lL 6ILI-E6 :/1 !N3010NI auoN A~N3DY Si'f3 tlNIONOdS3ij 'ill 9S91-9ZZ RE: Suanne Huffer September 9, 1994 Page 2 Sincerely, Her diagnoses at the time of discharge were left knee complex medial menisca1 tear, left knee lateral meniSCf&! tear and Grude II chondromalacia of patellar articular surface. These injuries were treated with the operative arthroscopy, with partial medial and lateral meniscectomies and chondroplasty of patellar articular surface. She has an excellent result from the surgical intervention. As well as the patient has done postoperatively, I do not anticipate any further treatment necessary in the near future. Statistically, the patient is at greater risk for post- ~umatic arthritis in the knee, but no one can say whether she will definitely develop this. Her prognosis is excellent. : ( ; Our office billings for Suanne's orthopedic care total $3,026.10. The adjusted allowable amount for reimbursement according to Act VI is $1,104.13. This has been paid in full yielding a balance of zero dollars and zero cents. In that the patient has an excellent result from my surgical intervention and is essentially asymptomatic, it is my medical opinion that no immediate future treatment will be necessary. Therefore, costs of future treatment are zero. I believe this answers all your questions and concerns regarding Suanne Huffer's orthopedic injury and my care of this injury. If you have any further questions, please feel free to contact my office. ~ w ~-1-C-----' ~ Fultz, M.D. CWF/mka . HUFFER, Suallne ( . SEPT. 204. 1993 MaN AH ~((J)lPlf SUanne i~ i wK post OPt She notds she's having somi so~'n'ss in her knee. She's down ta using a single crutch for ambul4tion. she is not up to 100 SLR exercisls yet. ., A,"~hroscopic portals ard ctean and dry 6t1dwel1"hli1ed. No calf tilidilrness. ROM is approximately 0-6061., She his 4 sllall effusion of her kneeJoint..k; "i';,:,' ,". . I .. ~6st left knee arthroscopy ~/P.Partial medial and lateral meniscectomy with chondromalacia of ~6tI11ar articular surfiell "~'" ..I' '. .', . :. , l.. P~~ 1~. patient was advised,dll WBAT. Wean herself off the crbtches. Do i 100 SLR exercises. Shd ~in get herself all an 'xlfcise cycle. Ice on post exereiils. RTO in two weekj. She can RTV,oftI9/21/93 With restrictions of eleva~. the leg as needed. Na kneeling. S~U4ttlndj or tifting. ..; . ~ '! ... ,~ ! ".".' 1 PE: OX: . "~~t1.': ~ . I '. . CWF:dmr RTel: 2 wRs " ,~ c/ ?I (r.' . October 4.'1993--MONDAV AM , , " , Suanne isl10W 3 wks. postop. She notes that she is dbllig better. Although, her kneeJs not 100%. Her principal complaint is intermittent. achiness about the fnfenor pole of the patella fit the peripate11ar area. She denies no paln referable to the joint line Iitea. There ill ho 10ctWtg or catching sensation I ,She is only up to approximately 50 SLR's Il day. PEl Arlh~scopic portals ar~'we1l healed.. 'They are deilri and dry. ROM of the 1tJi~ is 0-1200 or nexion. . ~he has no joint line . tenderness. The patient does have some mild tenderness about the p~pateI1ar region. DX: llbst:left knee arthrosco~y '.., . SIP partial medial and MIera! menisceclomy' with chondromalacia )P!l~~ articular surfac~.,.. .'" . . ~'J. . , "~'.. . . PL: ,The patient was advlsedJhat her symptoms ap~eAiJ.w be inore referable to cholidromatacia of her patella.' She has no /lYmptoId'l'Merable to the joint ,'.line atea.,. t .l!ncouraged her to fucrease her SLR exetdllt!ll and perhaps ankle WeIgb~'1 She Is to try toavofd kneelingl Ilquaf:t:tftg, and excessive stair clli6bift'l The patient shoUld continue her exerdlle ~cle; If she mcreased!.t1it! tension on it, she heeds to make iltire that the seat is elevilti!d;'.h will re-evaluate her Iii 4-0 wks. If ilhe ill hAving trouble advanciDlt .l1ill' strength, We will get her started on phYlitC:ll1 therapy. " ., CWF/mkli RTO: 4"'0 wks. ,( ... ~f0I~lt HUFFER, SUanne 117 East Keller Street Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 '" August 111 1993--WEDNESDAY AM 'f '. . , SeeLEtfER to David A. Long, M'.b./mka . 'f 't,' . ,'I, .: """ IP;" I. '1':\ -, ""'t. . August 2'6~)~93--THURSDAY PM~;,'; ,;iir":~;.i:.~.:'~ ::' suanneH6'~[~that she Is soo ha..itttg SymptO~~lii';Ii~i 181{,ktiee~ She notes thllbllte:~Hu paln over the medii1l:'J!ili1t lliie am'liB welt'Ai1 pidh arid a l&1apj)tfflflAtlsation about the, p@f!patellitr area,': ifhl!! 1i1lt:1l!ftt, haa; been doing he~ SL1t.~Al!\!tses. She does 211'a~ a time and'.doe8Yt~~eyeta1l:tmes a day. The patl~~~~,!=&king med1catiort1..~~i ll, reguIar""~~''''':'f~''.' '"... . . '."" ..,- PEl SHe. hllB exquisite tenderiiells,over the':medilll. JoUU;'llite. area. There appears td., bl!, a mUd McMurray's test at the ~dA~etior. liltliUa1 jOint line area. ,The: Itftl!e appears to be Itfdssly ligamerltiiUllty' st4blei;: She has a plus/minUII' iJllteuofemoral'compred!lf.oh test. Ttll!"t;ate11A '''l'ears to be trackihg;fdisottably well with a Iil!gatlve glide .test. sHe iil grossly n/v intact.""':' " ' i,;'I'..: '" !' , , DX: Left knee paln with probabie medial. mehisca1 tear and , patella chondromalacia ,', " PL: 1. have discussed with the patient operative arthroscopy to fully evaluate Her knee joint and her medial meniscus. The prognosis, risks and complications of surgery have been reviewed with her. She wishes to proceed. The patient is scheduled. for Holy Spirit Hospital on 9/13/93. History j physical, and consent forms were completed, today. I': CWF/mka Surgery 9/i3/93 , ..t. 'l . ~ ',!"., .. :1 , .J8eptemb~"jjt 1993 HSH OPBRATIVE NOTE ~ .' . . DIAGNOS~S i : LEFT knee compleX -'medial menisca1 tear . ,LEFT knee lateral mer1isca1 tear, horizontal" II small radial tear ,; Grade II chondromatitCia of patella articular sUrface , . PROCED{JRBI LEFT knee operativl! arthroscopy I Jlartla1 ibetiLlJ. and lateral ., . meniscectomy, chondroplasty of patellar llfticutilr surface PLAN: The patient will be WBAT and returntd lhe office 5 days post op for repeat clinical exam. SutUres will be removed probablY 2 days post oP. ;1 . CWF/kmJl . . '.". .....w~\Io\004'.."~i.:.............. ...,r- ._"..H....~....'..H..'.'".'. CumlJerIarta Ortrtopc\edic Associates, lTD. 99 November Drive, Camp Hili, pA 17011.5097 .. Phone 717.761-8844 Thomas H. Malin. M.D" F.A.C.S. William J. PolachecK, Jr" M.D. Craig W. Fultz. M.D. {,fOJ/Pt August 11 j 1993 '. David A. Lol1gj M.D. 4078 MarUi: Street Camp Hll1. pA 17011 ~ , RE: SulUlil~ Hutter r 111. Bililt Keller street; Meeli4ltit:s~Ui'lh pA 17055 \. .... . ,0 , , .' . .., .....\ Dear Dav6! .' I had tit!!: ~lWure of seeing SwUltie Hufter wl16 90U rell!ffed to my orfice on August ii, 11193. ;: ;, . " As you ...,I!tt lthew, she is a 4l-yl!8r-old white tem.a1e wlta \11M UntortunatelY involved lfi Ili1otor vehicle accidel1t on JUiie 21, 1993. slll! .WIis a passenger wearing a deiltbelt in the front 4&.t at the 1:I.a1l!' at Iinp4l!t: 1'1i1!J Impact caused tiEf l~ knee to strike tl1t! dalil1boll.rd !tor the gloVe compartment area. SUice that time, she has liid pairt in thl! lU1ee which ~ worse with kneelii1g, . sqUatting, and stair diliibing. she l&:a1lzes Rel' pain about the patel10fembrti area as well as over the anterior iIledial. joiiit line. The patient ill had previous surgeri.!h this knee' APproXiiJiatel1 five to eight years agd. This includes an operative arthrotti:Opy llnd II. pilrtial meniscectomy I She is unsure wliet~er it was a medial or l.ateral meniscectx'lmy. This was performed by Dr; Pattersonr. After surgery, she did not have ilr1y significant symptom6 in her knee until the time ot the auto accident. Her physica1 examination demonstrates no signittctnt ettueion of her knee joint. Slit! lias exquisite tenderrl.esa over the lUI.tl!ribr D1.1!dili.1 joint Une with a plus/miflUA McMurray's test. There i,j no teiidemeslt over the lateral joint line areal' slil! has palpable crepitation in the ~tri:lpate114r area. The . . 'fnlte11ll a~~@8f!t to be tracking rlluonably well. .The1'\! IJl 11 plus/minuS pate11ll sJidl! tf!st. She has a pottitl.ve patellofi!il1Oral coiJ1pfl!ssion test. The kne~ appl!l1'A to be grossly I1gaIlll!ntoUslY stabll!l ,I" , . , I reviewed iilfr outside MRI scan lIS well as her kni!~ x.:.ti1ys. I see no obvious rtletUres or dislocation II 611 her knee X':'fayll. iter MltI scan demonstrilteA lln abnormal signal tfi the medial meniscus principallY in the posterior llilt!ect. 1 t is unclear l:d ine whether titl! sisnli1 extends to the surface, therefore, one is unable to say whether there IJl it tear in the menisci. There Is some irregularlW on the retrollate11a1' area consistent with choridi"O\ila1acia of the pate11ll: , I _ ~rojnlclOntlal elu.:tl()~ ~dmplrl~~r.tJ(\d i~IlO~~~b!: 1:.0 1I0U want $3 10 go .0 ,n,s tunc? 'Wffl, ". .~, .'1"1", ~ II e oint :'Il\urn. jc<o~ ' <'>Ul" us. w,Lnt s.s t.; , e ;0 l~hi I...,~?,I\!' ~ I ' 0' Sf I,l~~<li;~' , . . '."~". " nge ' ,~, , """'" . t. 2 : ~ Married 1tIi1'JQ 10lot retufn ;..~ :t ot,l} cnt,h,~ ~nlXl!Mh ' , :l', 9. MBmlod ftilng &OP~r~t~ "'\'Jl'rii~~mor,,j;>>JfIt:a.llOOlal MCJJI1ly.lh<Jm , : : aboVu and fIi~ na"'~ nO(8.,lo-J't- . ...,....--~. ! ~ ,Q..H8ad of nWue>:'I01C (wllr q...a1ifylrl,. ~".IO<";: (S_ p.v~.(1a,~thl.t.;JAl:tyL'>(l:',)(n.M i " but ',ot your d6~nd9n~ ""'''' tnl& Onllc'~ r\4:IN 'r,nI, )00 -..- ~- '6 0' OueMM wid .f. "'ith ':BOorCO-: o~lId I oiIar aoou.. d:(J(l.)>o':'~ I . _ ' I~ PIleR ;':'Jth" ",ii<I":Y~'l:,"KY:>.lP,,"","jOt """ ,....... .oIH.I.....elal'l\.trJ...l~. .~""If1...... ~,'...Ol.. Y""JI' '. ';,"""'''':'\''/-' ~ ,'"' ~ t<:oi.lt,tl<.t '" lilt l.~ iloo " .,........ .... i b ~ ~ '':''.~T~'''''~';~I..:.''':-~'l~f,\~~-';~I~I':t~,.I~~~~~ , ' ", ft. ~:'I: ..,:-- .riooa (, G D*~ .':,1:: '. .....~I~': ~6t-""", s,;..PI;r~. '-qto:oor.j,.& t14)llIoptt-.J....' itilto.lllt\OrC'. '~~~~ ~J.!l '_ '~ :I ~''''d&;~;'ltnt'..e..o~~' ':.~ \' h..t~"",.~ .-. , 11IN*M~ir'WtU,rr4'It'6/'W' 'I . ~ .af"..r'\ l11J',......., ., - you'... '''ll:.~ . ~ ,,,,, ,~j,AtJ})til' (1 ! I :. I,DAJ~im~;' . (.......' ".., ' p,..j I tr 1_ 1(---' : '; s;;;:J, ",),~f\<:." "'.. I I . - I . "t~"'Jldn. """ 1-1,~--+-t;1~ 1 " I I ~~~ d If:fOUr~j;lidd!d~'li:YC~I~~YO...but:SC':ll:T~,1~f~'~Ilo:IC:'\1'' ...:: '~=~""'. undora pre"1eS5 ag-cH...ment,.::;nctk :;orli.'~~e~';j:~Y~(~I~~~~' - , ,,'~-.tl)'" e Tolal numo.... "r "...mutlons cilllmed, " '". , ' . ...- ? Wages. Gll'urtO$, tipb, ....e. Tl11$ shuUld 00 $\1own.lnliox ~ c.f jQl,lt;W'2:fi1!.:>-,"') formCs). Attach fcrm:zt: W"';.I '.";!~~'::-'..'" .1; :,~':' ":,,01" '~I r;",;~1I'g",m~i~:.,li ;:. 2., 2:f j I~.';_ aa 'r:S"Xhed8b18, 'i ~nlo:wt, I~c~:, (!,,:,,}p~Q'~;;)iti/I~.~~:a~:,.$;l?2~t:.~~~ 1 , b T~("x~;;('p;in'~I"Jl,DO~OTI""k.~~~I",,:<<::": e~"~r~~~,;,':,, ~~ II :D.~ ~ OlVldonda. If O'(6f :\40::, ;,t1itcr. 6~l.J. ~~..".., ~.' ". .'" ~';'''ty_...., ':-;~"'_ S !J _ _ I 0 .1Oft ToIallAA ,\;,\"",." "1 ,;, !'lPU ,axat.16 .mO\;nl.Cli::l""'Ct=t' ' '_" ...dlstrlbutlons,"" 'Oa~ 1_'::' ".,,,, (8~!.~e 26): Ifri'11Q~J' 0 '118 10taJ pooslon~ ~.''''~~ T ~~".:'\.~~b:,Taxabte :lmo,.mt~,ff;t't.J, , t .:':.. and annul~'B$:." '118,.___ ~. ,I' ," {~e pane 2TJ.....l.~I...~~:'I .._ 12 Une~Y(':''''1\ ce:n~""sa:.:>r (Mil p.;;~ :SQ" , ' ''',': - .,. ~..!. ...lL 13, Social se.;;~~it). ,~",o,' '\itrI1~3" ,7.~abj~ /I.-noun\,: !! ll""" I .' 'no'"'' ~"'.. ooneltto. 130, " ,eoo;;;.' 1. ~:;;" . . .,. . ...:;. "i'" ....,. .0-.. ,,' -=r,,~. 'i:. I .' '".1,1 'i~.:e ..-,i;-" '" ,Add 81188 7 through 130 Ifar ri;m:'~Iu".,rJ ih.. i. vo.~: Inr..o<M: (... ~~ " ~ 2 $'1 ---;68 Your I"" d'~~~tior (.~ ?ge~~l'.,7 ,'':'.~;'''''~.S"t ~....Q...' ,~.;". . ',' "', ,'.1 ".' ,I' ',",. "... 1'.- ',' ,'. ,,..-..','If' ~.. !' ,'I . . r.:..l'~"'~"'f to ~ .~, . . , II SprxlSO'. IRA ~~~!or ',>n<l..L!!:J" :)I,}.:, : ' .,'! . , Eb ' V..., ,)oi _. E_.~~~ lIrws ~Sa nnd 15t;--.ihoue J.re ,!Ol~ :~tli .1djubtrMnb. ,I.,",~~'" ~ ~5r.' 1t> ; Sublr&ct 11M .'fie!rem ii'Q,14:Thlo!a yo\-! lldlu"od g~.e '''ICOm.'~''''.\f'~' ~ " II 10m 1hsn !o?5,?'J5 41':0 ~ :;"ic loyed ~,~th 10J il~~ :r.an S9,Cf>;Jf,~,01,j ., '1 dldnll live ~itn )OO}I :J~ .E.'1'~ tncOfM c.ttrWIt'" on :iB 0 441: ~...'iPk'::~-' ....:1'.. f\.. :~ t. ;:~:""t.~': "~-MJ2.'A... ,- ~~4~;1~~~~' .~a\,~;~1~}' I..' :,; l,i\. ~~ ! ,."I't-J lit" ~'.., ',,' hI>. I," to"'" "~"~,' the lo".. 'qng 'I ~t'. .~ . ,;)1.. t~:; ~ ''''i fl.')f ,11.j' ".,.." < .. .......... ndil \,l,' ,'J ~,_~ .),1"1 -T ..~~:,~'l:r.,_ .' , - ~ ..~. . ':,... Ul""'0I"~,,1"Ioa,......,"""1I1';,~..ft'I'WI.'" IU....~ "'/In... _1'.:-". J"r... , I' .. ,:~ : -, . . -7. . - ~~.. ~ " .' . '" ,,~, r ,~~;::T ':of>I7;,~ .:) ..'-".- ...,.... ":-~'CA paoe 2 1ck1 Check [1 YOIol WUFtJ 05 or cll.;,i\.<<( 0 c.,,"::: '. !;.nttr nwnber 01 I': 0 5pouIO Wbt 135 or .:!te!::r Cl a)ll."d t bOA." I:n.ukea .. b If your ~AMnt i.or t.Om;~nnl'.;:r.'(1) c;1I1~T.i;:" yoJ flR R dapand~nt. Check hllra, . . . , ' . . ~ ltlb u If yO" are mJrriod lilil'lG sOila:alQIy Q~~ y.u' SPOI.ll;O tolot Form 1040 and ttem:zll8 d~\''':I~t;onf'J .~~~ ?~~6 3! 3.."l,j cnoc.o( here. >- , Jc \ C Cntcr the atondord .:loductlon ahOwn below f.:>r yo"r t.liflll .tatu., Ou: If you chockod any bOX or. IIno 16/\ M b, ,p te piI(lll 36 te> fIno your Llllndard d.duclioc. Ir you chocked :;'01 1 'c. ilrnijr .0.. . 5,nOI-45.800 . \1arll~'O iilin. )v;r,.iy :;r OUd:iiy!t1g wklow{wr,...,.\.:\,350 . Head 01 h:uaoholc-$5,6UC . M~,7i6d tlli~,O Mp^ratet;-$3,175 ,;; Subtract line 19 trom IIr"lft 17. ;- Ih,,:,. ;7;'i., IT>nrfl ~hn" line ~ 7. entor .0... '-0 Multiply $2,':"~lll>y..!!'I.IOla1 ~,~~y!.u.!'!'Dpji2:2!.'!1ffi!mId on line 6., 2' SUb\rQct Ilna 21 trom ,:ne 20. It lire 21 is more Ihan ('ne 20, enler -0-, This In your toxable Incoma. J- :>? 23 Find the lax Oil t"" ~1!I0Iln: ",n lill~ 22. Chl,,-c< If from: _=U:I!X Tab10; (P_B968 G2~!1_c.!m__Q =mn 8.6_'2 (- p.y9'l 40\, 24a Credit tor child 3nd aUilcnaCr,\ 03rc oxpcnaos. AlIacn Scher1ulo 2. .; Credit for tha ..Id,,"y ur th.. oi:Hlul.tJ. Attaeh Schad"l" 3. 2(1) c Addllnos 249.nd-2~.'c-Tnore-irO ym;, .otal crlKiltll. 2/i Subtract line 24C ':'01'1', iine 23, It .!he 24C is more Ih3n lone .3. ""to' .~" 26 AdV8nce:earii~d ir.e~1mo r.rhGlt r.aym~r.!'l fmm Form W-2, 27 Add lines 25 anti 2e. ;"1. I. Y!?.!:'! to:.II", 2&0 Total Federal Incom.. IdX Vli:hheld, It an)' tax !!.1mm Forr.1isl 1099. :heck here, ~ ':J b 1994 estimatod telX pnymfJC'~~ and ..lo1i01.mt ~2pliod 1'0'11 , ~~~ r....urn. c Earned Inc:ome credit. If re<{ulred, .,tlac, Schadu'a E:C ,see paqe 44), Nonlaxscle earned inc~mc: smount .. ,_ I era t,'PO ,. d Add IlnAS ?8a. 28b. ard 28c (don.t Inc!:,.d. nonlaxablo ..."nod Incorn,,), Th8S1l aM ,,"r 101..1 ~ mnnts. .. 2Sd 29 If Un.. 28<J is mo~ than line 27, sub:r.lc: iin[ 27 from IIno 2Sd. ___J!:1!~!!! the a"lount you overpaid. 30 Amounl o' IIno 29 yeu 'I!ant ror~n.?od to you. 31 Amount or Iinu 29 you want applied to '/Our 1995.!&lImalltllt~ll._________.:;; I 32 If line 2T i~ marc thll~ tlno 28c. &UCt'3ct ,Ino 2Bd from line 27, Th;s Is tho amount y~u owo. For d6tcilS 0,', hO'/l to pay, including what 10 writo on you:" payment, 90& oc~o ~2. 33 Estimated lax penalr1 (soo pogo 52;. Also. Includ. on line 32, 3:i Jut ~~~~~~~ :.f\~:o.:;:t.:~n~~f2~.~IT~~~~~~:I~~~ ~~I=~~~ r=~~ :~~~.7Y.~~~::;.1~ ~l ,~~~w= . w........r. tJ\ol41 'lfl(i ~,tj1.lYf'l(, I. tala!'! r.n ,'I .fltcr'l1111lV-',"I 'N!\(t 1/101 P'VP':''': ....... ..." ",':)MIC'ii*. ~ ....r.u' "U'l.l'llft: L~IU9 1 >(0'4 ::cg.~r.~0I:\ .:.".; '.~'-"Jy of. . ~ 'f>( ~ !i~W:,lil" .;gn'!~f., t j:)lr'. ,,,'I"". (lUT., fft.i\ ~". ~~W 1 "I~II r..tf'~. ....-.l "...,j,), - ~ ~" I ~....... p,..v, ,. ,.!'!~ ~1l.tt'Jt u___.__ i ',0"'/ Flf'I".".."!tlll'tIWt. ~ lI......,r,...lV",.1I.nd ,"kiN" fl\,,' Y'),!. ;;, ff,rHi;! rtJ (j'- .t!,~ tion. ;)1I(,}r\ , '" an.. ... \. . ;" ~Jr('ll' FH:~} " t,I~, ,\ :;",)". GI.U(,...',. .r""; PC' .. 'fits l,t t'!e 'I1ti ~,' . ., yoUl ".,' ('C, th.: ",.:.tIOl\' '0 - J...... ~.~~ 0" o.G~~t. ~l~l f'igUfU your ,,~'d t '!'I'J or .,:\ )~"" :""'$ ,", ..-......--... ---.-'-.---- 1" Enior tno ;'lrf'("I;Jnt ~r(11'1'" Ii.,o i.;. I ,-;. 5':"...i. 5tJ !lQ. 1801 c I g g 20 21 22 t..'H~~ "IS.~q'i 0 . pO "0 2S ~.!e..\ (><4 0 S_"L.~ :>4a ,0 --"-r;' 2~c .~ 2_L-~~1 L 0 26 c> --~.--. "'---.;,,1"";. ~^,. )0 21___,~!,. 1'1 I~O I ?s.. .._~~(" ~ !~o 28b l~" 2Bc 2Q 30 '1 .t;" 1/ 1,,0 ~.I ~$ (.)~, ?.1.. :;2 ... F.~l\,I.iloo,.:.".,.,.U"'lYf'C,o. ..r-+;..,...... . ~1.""1I('..r_i'1 .-.:! : , ' l...t:.Iro.;, , "t-..."'" '001. ~grrn '04n, PODO 2 -J I . CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE t; AND NOW, this 6th day of May, 1996, I hereby certify that I have served the foregoing Praecipe on the following by depositing a true and correct copy of same in the United States mails, postage prepaid, addressed to: P. Richard Wagner, Esquire Mancke, Wagner, Hershey & TUlly 2233 North Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 James G. Nealon, III, Esquire Dated: May 6, 1996 .-. n C I,.'" V) n '" ::-} .i,~ ':ITl .';:J ;t.':'> . oil j::J 'C.I .-sm :-1 :;,; -;; -- ...,. --c. ~-}~: y): r~.' :".; . L. --... _..: -.J -~J ;.;~ .~ {:~) "'" CJ1 PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL (Must be typewritten and submllled In duplicate) TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY (Check onel Please list the following case: (X ) for JURY trial at the next term of civil court. for trial without a Jury. DAVID K. HUFFER and SUA~~E HUFFER, his wife, Assumpsit n .n 0 ~:; O'l -" ?': :J --0 [1 ('~1 ..j;1:l till" ........ " r- "'. I ..1m 7L, ]~ Cf).' G) ~- r,,- -n l.~ :i'; ( -- ~.1l.. ." :..".( :.:? Cjm ;>>f. ..1 t:" o~ .. .t:" ~ CAPTION OF CASe (entire caption must be stated In full) (check one) Trespass ~respass (Motor Vehicle) ( ) (other) (Plaintiff) vs. The trial list will be called on 12/17/96_ (Defendant) and Trials commence on 1/ 27/97 Pretrials will be held on 1/ 2/97 (Briefs are due 5 days before pretrials.) rrhe party listing this case for trial shall provide forthwith a copy of the praecipe to all counsel, pursuant to local Rule 214.1.) CONJ\LD L. HOFFLER vs. No. 1045 Civil " . 95 '., 19__.. .' Indicate the attorney who will try case for the party who flies this praecipe: P. Richard Waqner, Esquire . ..' '::... Indicate trial counsel for other parties If known: James G. Nealon, III, Esquire . .. . ./>..~. '7 . ...r :' . This case is ready for trial. Esq. ....;.. . .. .~ ,," Date: Allorney for: Plaintiffs 21. DAVID K. HUFFER and SUANNE HUFFER, his wife, Plaintiffs IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA vs. 95-1045 CIVIL TERM DONALD 1- HOFFLER, Defendant CIVIL AcrlON - LAW IN RE: PRETRIAL CONFERENCE Prescnt at a pretrial confcrcnce held January 2, 1997, wcrc P. Richard Wagner, Esquire, attorney for the plaintiffs, and Jamcs G. Ncalon III, Esquirc, attorncy for thc defcndant. This casc arose out of a motor vchic1c accident that occurred in Junc of 1993. Mr. Nealon has recently bcen advised that thc dcfendant, Mr. Hofflcr, is schcduled to work in Tennessee for the three-wcek pcriod commencing January 20, 1997. In addition, counsel for the defcndant has another casc on thc Cumbcrland County trial list and also a case on the Dauphin County trial list whcrc cascs will also bc tried during the week of January 27th. Mr. Wagner indicated that, dcspitc having given thc dcfendant amplc notice of the time of trial, he was not informed of the defendant's unavailability until rccently. In addition, thc plaintiffs desire to concludc this mattcr. For these reasons, the plaintiffs' counsel opposcd any continuance of the matter. We will grant Mr. Nealon's request and continuc the case until March with thc understanding that further rcquests for continuance from the defendant will not be entertaincd. P. Richard Wagner, Esquirc For the Plaintiffs ~;..~d January 2, 1997 James G. Nealon III, Esquirc For thc Dcfendant Vi/-JI//\lASNN3d I """')') ,".. ", '''~'''n'' ~.I'.; ;~.. _:;'"1'.' "'c-'}.:/,l J 2!i :6 HV C- tn1l' L6 ACNKi.\C.L.C.:d ~ill ':0 30!:l:lQ-Q31!:J r . DAVID K. HUFFER and SUANNE HUFFER, his wife, Plaintiffs, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 95-1045 CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED v. DONALD L. HOFFLER, Defendant. PRB-TRIAL IIDORAllDUJI OR BRRIl.T.J' OJ' PLAIIITIJ'J'S I. J'ACTSa On or about June 27, 1993, at 9:00 a.m., on Market Street, Upper Allen Township, Pennsylvania, the Plaintiff, DAVID K. HUFFER, was operating a motor vehicle with the Plaintiff SUANNE HUFFER, his wife, a passenger. The Defendant, DONALD L. HOFFLER, made a lefthand turn on Market Street directly in the path of Plaintiffs' vehicle violently colliding with the Plaintiffs' vehicle. The accident was investigated by Offier Thompson of the Upper Allen Township Police Department. Officer Thompson interviewed the Defendant and obtained a statement from the Defendant that he was traveling north on South Market Street when he executed a lefthand turn cOlliding with the vehicle of the Plaintiffs that was traveling south on Market Street. --,- . . witness, Janice Wonders, confirmed the same that the Defendant failed to yield the right of way and did turn into the path of the Plaintiffs' vehicle. II. DAMAGBSa As a result of the aforementioned accident, the Plaintiff, SUANNE HUFFER, suffered a chondromalacia of the patella, medial lateral meniscectomy as well as trauma to the nervous system, and further, is a likely candidate for the development of arthritis. The plaintiffs were extremely active athletically prior to the accident. Of particular interest the the Plaintiffs was the sport of golf in which they participated on a regular basis. Of course, because of the condromalacia of the patella, the Plaintiff was unable to golf for a considerable period of time, and now suffers difficulty in attempting to golf, and has extreme difficulty in bending and/or flexing. She was also an avid gardner, boater, hiker, and jogger, all of which have been extremely limited as a result of the injury to her knee. As a result of the aforementioned injuries, SUANNE HOFFER sought treatment with the cumberland Orthopaedic Associates, Dr. craig Fultz. Dr. Fultz diagnosed the . condromalacia of the patella, and the meniscal tears as noted above. III . WITJfJISSBSa A. David K. Huffer, Plaintiff B. Suanne Huffer, Plaintiff C. Janice Wonders, 8 Mill Drive, Dillsburg, PA D. Officer G. C. Thompson, Upper Allen Twp. Police E. Dr. craig Fultz IV. BDIBITSa A. A Police Accident Report - Upper Allen Twp. B. Medical Records V. AllTICIPATBD TRIAL TIUa One Day VI. IIISBCLLAHBOUSa None DAVID K. HUFFER and SUANNE HUFFER, his wife, plaintiffs, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 95-1045 CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED v. DONALD L. HOFFLER, Defendant. PRABCIPB TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Please mark the above-captioned matter as settled and discontinued. Respectfully submitted, , TULLY .~..., d wagner, Esquire . #23103 2233 North Front street Harrisburg, PA 17110 (717) 234-7051 Attorney for plaintiffs DATE: .l/I g lfi// I I n .0 ~ c: ..... ;~ .., =P-:o -0", ,." cpn CD ~;~ ..._ ~l Zl- N UJ.' U1 '~5 r:: 2: .,~- -. ::'j::;,. . 5- -';-"..l .- ....:=....('.. C:;' >~ ~f. ""-1 .._J ~- ~o) ;.;! .-1 -~ (n :5! "