The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About95-01078 ,:i.' -', ~ : ! . '~1i:~~:~~' . ~'l""; ';~~?rJr(,'" 11~-:'" ;:1~d<;:: -~ " ' I ",}",,'. t.. ~;:.;;;'),:tQ) JiJ}(.;,.:- .n,. ",...:r-,., "1 !~4(/~:-: ~-- ~",'''.~ ~rt~V.' \-i{\'~-:"""; ,-."'(," -,.-.', .1j}t'~;!' f '.:.f':l":\ ;; ;~f"'i' , );l'&, .,;;_..,.,.'7;,',.:, ,'~'i~;tr:~?? r :~,t/:: " ,;.,',' ~j~y. :~;;kt~:~;\:'. t'i!~.I,:.:'__~.~J '-;,'r~J ':,. ~~~'~".- ,-: '" >;- !1i;~);': :::t;~~"/;.;",,, ..rl'._\ .:: , \ ~. ,i '11. ,; .;1 .', " , . ~ , ,. 'I " , '-~ ,- ~,- . c,~." ; .?:~~t( jQJ. \~'" "0' ":."'::',. . '_,Co' '_ . I 'i. . .il :1' " -j,.. ,.-, .'; ,I :.1 (/ ;,' " , , ,'l n' n ,I'"~ "I' " l' " /;/\,1 'I, , .-' ~t' , > l t, I _," f ).~, ! . "'I .:,i,~\ . . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PNC NATIONAL BANK, Plaintiff -vs- BENJAMIN J PARISER AND ISHWOREE M PARISER, Defendants. G,..J U/ ~ - I' , NO. 10 . / () 7 a (i1...t,L, 'lA1'^-- TYPE OF PLEADING: COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION FILED ON BEHALF OF: PLAINTIFF, PNC NATIONAL BANK COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFF: MURRAY A. FELDER, ESQ. Pa. I.D. #39331 TWO LOGAN SQUARE SUITE 1520 Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 963-3400 I I I [ NOTICE TO DEFEND You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or hI an attorney and filing in writing with the court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed .without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the court without further notice for any money claimed in the complaint or for any claim or relief requested by the plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you, YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE OR KNOW A LAWYER, THEN YOU SHOULD GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP, LAWYER REFERRAL SERVICE COURT ADMINISTRATOR'S OFFICE 4TH FLOOR, CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE ONE COURTHOUSE SQUARE CARLISLE, PA 17013-3387 (717) 240-6195 . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PNC NATIONAL BANK, NO. Plaintiff \ -vs- BENJAMIN J PARISER AND ISHWOREE M PARISER, Defendants. COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION AND NOW, comes Plaintiff, PNC National Bank, by its Attorney,Murray A. Felder, Esq., and files this Complaint in Civil Action of which the following is a statement: 1. Plaintiff is PNC National Bank, a national banking association with an office located at 103 Bellevue Parkway, Wilmington, Delaware 19809. 2. Defendants are BENJAMIN J PARISER AND ISHWOREE M PARISER individuals residing at 625 W OLD YORK RD., CARLISLE PA 17013 and 37 W. Ridge Street, Carlisle, PA 17013, respectively. 3. On or about November 21, 1989, defendants opened a Mastercard/Visa Account with Plaintiff bearing account number 4081704011008126. 4. Defendants made use of said account and have a balance due and owing to Plaintiff in the amount $4,490.38. . 5. Plaintiff has made repeated demands for payment, but defendants have steadfastly refused to pay the balance due to the Plaintiff. 6. The application and contract for the charge account provided for the addition of reasonable attorney fees if the account is referred for collection to outside counsel and it is alleged that attorney fees based on 20% of the principal balance due is reasonable. 7. The following amounts are currently due and payable: Principal amount due: $4,490.38 Reasonable Attorney fees of 20%: $ 898.08 Total amount due: $5,388.46 WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against both defendants jointly and severally in the / Q $5,388.46 plus costs and interest. Murray A. Attorn PNC Na Felder, Esq. or Plaintiff o al Bank \ " ..,.,.. , .' r- ; . . .~-; ,.J' 'r' . ,-,. . ,"~ ',. >. . ,......-:- , " 'l. ~ r " < 7-.i 'le- ::: ~ 7- o 'e ~i ?3'~ ~ " .!', ~ . ~ ,. -, ,;' " . ~,;;: ~ .-" -& ~ \ C::' 't. J-~\~,\\t ~ \..o^\o;:::.l:t-' C ,~ t- O . ~ ---; '='" .,..\ n ,~..,. ,... o .~ ,.."%... """ :,.,:' _...- ....... '," ",0 ~'te r~' 'tJn ,~: ,VI,~ .n "\ .-. ~; ., ~.g.L":~ ~l\; ,~~ l T lj' 'C -.i", 84 .~' ~ .-:):1' l_~ ~ ., . ,.,....; ,\~ ,-'" " !,~ '3 1" ,~ 0 .~ ,~'" ~ :r.> . ci ~ ~ i .... ,. ~ ' , ;I ~ \ 8\ \ i ~, \~ ~, \:l ,~ ; ,.. ,I ",,'" ~,wZ ' ~i ';2& '" wu ~..u ' . LJC I ... ' ;l C : \ ~~;~ \ u' -.. I , ~~::;\ ~..l~t1 \ ;.; uf I ~~ 0 ';;i ~ \1 \ , ~. ~ \1 ~ \ \JU \ i h \i ~ 1Il,1cS5l ,~ ~ .... ., .. ,. 'hll ~t \ r, \ f'll'- I!a; ~~~\ \~ ~ \t~\ ,k; ~i~\~~J1 ~~~'i\i~\ If -:- ,~ ~ I \.\ \.~\ i \ . ~, l'loJ.' t 0 \.....' , ;.".... ~:~ \3 ~\,~ \ ~\~ \..;, \~ \' \t\ rt.!, l~ I t"~ I ~ \.1 I~ \ ~:.- ~'.-,:l!'-'; ....\-- .~ ,--" \,_. ?/"l'~~lll ';"":1 \~!l \ I!r:$, cr.' I I ,~ ....1 !- 2"~ \ :-; \~' I : I -;:! .~ I l\.\~ \ -s -. 1 "It i :~ 'l/'c5 0),/6 I E i~; ,/)' . . ~ VO' -'1 :I: - c::>!1 ", v'I-' \ ~, ~ I ' ," , _~ J" I ,,':1: ~ i c:., : ~ 1l.!1' ~' '" ~~' ,:l, " 0;::: _ -3\ <"'I 1:', \ \~ r't :tr'll ,~ Ie'" i n..! t"'\ a: . J' -, . ~ ~ ""'-' i;' ~1.j:r. i""." ;fi \~ .~ _-S\ ~\_~, (""II_I g1 \ \t~\-'\t -.> ~~ ~i~ tI' ..J \ '0 ~j I~'..n ,0 3 ~~. ~~ ~i \~u 1\~\ :~ ~ !\~ ....., 11 ~ ~i'i \-livi\ O,~ ~\ i~ "':~ ~ ~~ ~~ Sli~\~ ,I! 1\i~~ \~ .~\t';i ~ t {:,\.si ~\b\t.J.i\'g4 1\ \,10., ~,\ \I~ V ~Cli~Q,I!E:~~I~V'I\~-\1l ~ b.....~ II , \l \' i liP .(' ! ;-i,~ . ,\ .... I \1Jl! ~ It t!p' ': \ _. +-\f\;;ll - _ fl" tr \ ~djq~ , \~ t~ t\ \ \\ .~ a " ~ ilt t I ~ I\i- + Hti. q-, :I ~. \ n \ f" ! 1 \... t 1 , '\ ? '~ I l ~ .. ,,,- ~nh~\~~1\~: tt\b~~ r N I- ~ r I! \ '\, S ~ r. } ~l \lt~ "'- :r-::: 3{l1\l' ~ H l\\ !l l1" . n'l t !, a <t \ ~i.b' !. i," g , ~lY~\) 1- ~ VI -c I' .;J l D..., I: 1 ~::a rot :~\ \ (it t 1 ~ ~ ~ r- \i~t"I\t\l~l\ \ ~: ~ ,~ ,}~}H k ~ l! ~.u~ -\ If ~;~ it 0I2~::: 1..!Jt 'I ~l\-lt1 ~~ It ~\A 1_' \~ I I~ I'!> ~ \f:i... \ if- \~ l:.IIN I :~:l s,-:.L I \~ "'- I" 'J~i I 1 ~,. ~~' '!~~\ r"~ \i ,.... .,~\'& M \.-,,~ \ f l;; A os P i ~ \~ I \i).. ~ ~"'~~It::: l \H \- ~'" (I,~.. 1 \~ \ \\ ~~. n ?; ? tt. l~ Co ~ j ....., !. r: .- I ~~~ E5 \IJ~,":'! 1. in ::= D I t..J &,. ,~., \' c:.. RI> 1:."', h F DE .s' ~iU ir' i;: 11'; iP ~'&~~~'~ 1."1.' i \ ~ rli: p.." . . tl ~ ;:~ /DO:.' 5../ :i :: h~ t . t e -.. ' t t ,~ . ; =z\ .L~ ~ ~~...; .~t ~l ,~~, 71 -.. -1:_ 81: 5 __ . ..f ,_..- ,r '- i " ., ,0 .,.. .'. ,.~ ,it t ...L.~c.t ~ ,--',j: jl i~ ~ :c I " ~ 'cl Z I .--::-:.... ~ ' ,~ :~ ~ ! ,"4 :~ ~~~ ''It t ; \\\ ~~ II ! l\ I lh ....., 1 .... ~ ~ I~ u - i ~ l .' l, i ~" i;" I!L ~ '.~':; I I ' ' , rC:; ,~:. .,' -.....,; ~.,' .. . - -~i.....:........ . .,'.... ~\, ,,," ~ , ....................". , . - ~~ ~ . d~d ~ ~i~ ~~ ::r!\~ 1~1\~\ ,~, Ill' '8. ~~ fi. ,cH'" I ~~- 1).....,._ I~ . i~ " i ",,: ~,g~ ~ t t\~\t' . ,,\a- 1. ~.... '" 0 ~ ~ \: \~W.. .~ >> i \~\~I\ "" ..:::. :.t4'.\r q ~ b\~\~~ ~ % fbf"=-i~ ~ ~~\;~~\ ~ "'::::s}~ltl. ~ u:.\I~tI ~:t C.) ,,", Cl ~u I. . I 1m \ "" . 'd I \~ \~ \< t. ." _...-.,....,;::... -~,.......-... VERIFICATION The undersigned hereby states that he is SR. BANKING OFFICER for the Plaintiff in the within case and verifies that the statements made in the Complaint in Civil Action are true and correct to tho best of his knowledge, information, and belief and understands the statements therein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.e.S. 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. r:i ~,:...v\///~, /' z:..,.~/ ,f/' )(-4,./" Michael ~: ~amill, Sr. Banking Officer L.../ ,'I t_.1 ,,!1.1Itl{ Date: ~ 'u ,'-' = a.- Ll'> .::r N :'.,... "-,- .... . In L-; ~_:;~! t.)-.....". i-=O\";':' I.... "r:"-I- r;1 ~.~;: ;:.: " .... _ ",If I III ~:....:~~ ~ ::...: ::.!~~wi ;:::r.o.. la... :J; 0"-' ~ V) ., -;::) ..') --.:::r- ~ ~ IV) '...::t- '-' '" I'- ~ ~~'"t< \::j ~6\ 1'0 r0 Lrl C") - ~ .... c: ., = ~ 0...< l.. ~ .;: d:. ~ ~ ~ ...:.. \/"\ '... 0 ~ V/ -... ~- "VJ'~ ~ {..1 J - A~V 10NOH10~d .................... ..~~i;~~~~.R;;;;~1;;... .,:..\~:61 ,............,....j.f.,'..;.:.:p.;;-iiZ.. ,L:II'twU"lpwV-'''''''''-1ff Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION. LAW NO. 95~ CIVIL TERM /07J )I PNC NATIONAL BANK, v. f' I' \) I BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, Defendant PRAECI~E FOR CON5ENJ JUDGMENI TO: PROTHONOTARY: Please enter judgment in favor of Plaintiff and against Defendant Benjamin J. Parlser by consent In the amount of $4,927.52. .. FLOWER, MORGENTHAL FLOWER & LINDSAY, P.C. Attorneys for Defendant Benjamin J. Pariser By: ~-:, 't'I\.,?~ .', '''l\..&. Benjamin J. Pariser, Defendant II~ '3" . 'I f Date .... co . b:; "J L:: j;!.: (.~:) ~3'""~ ~JQ ).". (:.J:-:- It' ' , .7 u... '.' , ,... .~:! ;:~ 2" C,; C" : ,{;. e' ('J '!:: ' ~ I. ._ , ~.II' . (l"j~.' J l::: .. ~'~: I" F.: , :;:~- , , .- :::l d ..'.' C,", 0 ~..-/ '-S. ~ '->- ~ '- J .. ..e. \.., " ,~ \ .., '<I. .J ~ " ~ ,~'-....... J .c .n ' ~ ~~~!'~'i O~~ '.l~'--' -~~'1.\' PNC NATIONAL BANK PLAINTIFF IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, DEFENDANTS 95-1078 CIVIL TERM BEFORE HOFFER. J. AND BAYLEY. J. ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 22nd day of August, 1995, the preliminary objections of both defendants to plaintiff's complaint, ARE DISMISSED. Edgar B. Bayley, Anjella A. Englesbe, Esquire For Plaintiff J James M. Bach, Esquire For Defendant Ishworee M. Pariser Carol J. Lindsay, Esquire For Defendant Benjamin J. Pariser ~-, I l,j :saa n l "IO):l>!bs-. c.,.tt':"". tn<-t:"".. Q 1 ~.f. '6\ . ~ ". ::> ""'" ~:: -::,.:L,4 ut'~'=I;r '-!.~Q'''\ i'::~O.::l 0"-'(':"'- t,..f;n ';..' J,;: ~~, i~. It',;r .Ill/;l'_~ ":-;1;<l..- t-'.-, '~'l..~ '-' :a::: a- tD IJ1 ("oJ ,. I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PNC NATIONAL BANK, Plaintiff NO.. 95-01078 -vs- TYPE OF PLEADING: BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER ANSWER TO PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS Defendants. FILED ON BEHALF OF: PLAINTIFF, PNC NAT IONAL BANK COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFF: I MURRAY A. FELDER, ESQ. Pa. I.D. # 39331 1520 TWO LOGAN SQUARE Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 963-3400 Plaintiff COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA No. 95-01078 PNC NATIONAL BANK v. BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER Defendants. ANSWER TO PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS Plaintiff, by its attorney, Murray A. Felder, Esq. hereby replies to Defendant, Ishworeee M. Pariser's, Preliminary Objections: 1. In response to Defendant's Preliminary Objection in Paragraph 1. there is no such requirement that Plaintiff include in its complaint all items purchased by the Defendant including when they were purchased and by whom they were purchased. WHEREFORE. Plaintiff demands judgment against Defendant in the amount of $5,388.46 plus costs and interest. ~ .~ c{l MURRAY A. Attorney 0 1.0. /I 393 LDER, ESO Plaintiff Two Logan Square Suite 1520 Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 963-3400 " CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Murray A. Felder, Esq., do hereby certify that I served a true and c~rrect copy of the attached document on the party or his/her attorney listed below on the date indicated below by first class mail. Date -Mailed: 3/29/95 TO: JAMES M. BACH, Esq. 352 South Sporting Hill Road Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 wJ a. Murra~ A. Fer, Esq. Attorney fo Plaintiff V'> !:!7 -';,w ;:_;~~ rH, :~!~~" :>: ~;r In "" - - ., ,-..: m <>: ... = l.;.:t,' " C;I.1 ~ ! :1 SHERIFF'S RE1URN i i i I I I I I I CXMo1Ct'MEALTIl OF PENNSYLVANIA: CCXJNTY OF ClMBERLIIND In The Court of Cannon Pleas of CUmberland County, Pennsylvania No. 95-1078 civil Term Complaint in civil Action PNC National Bank VS Benjamin J. pariser and Ishworee M. pariser SERVE: Ishworee M. pariser Kpnnp.th GasBert , S~xtftxXOCXDeputy Sheriff of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, that he served the within Complaint in Civil Action Upon Ishworee M. pariser The defendant at 8:45 o I clock -IL-_.M. EST /~, on the day of March , 1995 at 08 37 West RidQe STreet, Carlisle pennsylvania, by handing to Ishworee M. pariser ,Cumberland County, a true and attested copy of the Complaint in civil Action and at the sane time directing attention to the contents thereof and her the "Notice to Plead" endorsed thereon. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing Service Affidavit Surcharge So answers: 18.00 2.80 . . . .,';' ~_.-..;;y'(' t. . ~ . . ~. . ,.................'..... .." ~_..-:~""'i.....1o':..~4....'. . . -, 1"- .~ ,/" .._..~.t:.....'1....-: , R. Thamas Kline, Sheriff 2.00 22.80 Pd. by Atty. 3-10-95 Sworn and subscribed to before me this ,,, f!- day of }1l...I", by r4-€ ?q / Deputy Sheriff 19 Ij{ A.D. L.L"._ C. ) It "i, ~ A..(i ,~. . , I .i I Prothonotary PNC NATIONAL BANK . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF . PLAIN'l'IFF . CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA . : vs. . No. 95 - 1078 CIVIL TERM . . . BENJAMIN J. PARISER and . . ISnWOREE M. PARISER . . DEFENDANTS . COMPLAINT IN CIVIL ACTION . PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS AND NOW comes the Defendant, ISHWOREE M. PARISER, by her Attorney JAMES M. BACH, and files the within PRELIMINARY OBJECTION. 1. MOTION FOR A MORE SPECIFIC PLEADING. In paragraph number four (4) of said Complaint, reference is made to user of said account and a particular balance owing to the Plaintiff in the amount of $4,490.38. There is no specificity as to what items were purchased, by whom they were purchased, when they were purchased, and so on and so forth. In order to properly defend herself, Ishworee Pariser, who is now engaged in a bitter divorce with her husband, requires and requests this specificity in order to adequately defend herself. Respectfully submitted, DATE :r/z. z/7' S ~~. dl--< JAMES M. BACH, ESQUIRE Attorney I.D. No. 18727 352 S. Sporting Hill Road Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 717-737-2033 """ ll2:'>. - ,- .;.~ ..,...... j.. .,.. '..." ,"" EG~::'!i . ,. :r.:. f~~ 0, =ZO. C'Y), ~"1 '"'I '~! ~~.' ::~ ,': :,: .-. -, 6<#' - N 0: -, ::a: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PNC NATIONAL BANK, P.O. BOX 8927 WILMINGTON, DE 19899 NO.: 95-01078 Plaintiff, -vs- BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, Defendants. PRAECIPE TO REINSTATE COMPLAINT TO: PROTHONOTARY Please reinstate the Complaint in Civil Action in the above referenced case. . \...1 BANK 1520 Two Logan Square Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 963-3400 A .. - ..... ~.,........ , . .....- .~... "--- . , ' , ' "", . . . . . ,t .' , , I " " ".~ - =;x In '=' - . d. )- ..t "~ :~~~.i ..->:1 ~ ,~! 2.: ,:~ -<I .-~. l;,' ,II. a"_q.-".r . -'~il:; "~":' ~w - - - ...., Q; ~ ~. PNC NATIONAL BANK, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSVLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION. LAW NO. ll!l 018 CIVIL TERM 9S - /07t PlaIntiff v. BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, Defendant TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Enter my appearance on behalf of Benjamin J. Pariser, one of the Defendant's in the captioned case. FLOWER, MORGENTHAL FLOWER & LINDSAY Attorneys for Benjamin J. parlser By: ~ Carol J. Undsay, Esquire 10 # 44693 11 East High Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-5513 Date: 1 J I Y;/1.r !f1 ,. , - :~"=' . ...... .. ", <- '. ':::> .<- "-r " .' n:, - . ,'. '" ".. '. ."" I, ~ ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE I , I accept service of the Complaint in Civil ^ction Law and Notice (on behalf of Oeniamin J. pariser certify that I am authorized to do so.) t.-/ / II ((/l.,- oae';; I and 11 East HiQh street, Carlisle. P^ 17013 Mailing Address 99OL~ VNN3d '~~1n8SOIN\fH03V\1 crvo~ lllH elNW::JOdS HinOS ~st MVllVl::1013SNnOOONVA3Nl::lOllV HOVB 811\I S3WVr .... ,..- .~ ..~ ,. eeO~.LeL (L ~L) ~. .. JAMES M. BACH ATTORNEY AND COUNSELOR AT LAW 352 SOUTH SPORTING HILL ROAD MECHANICSBURG, PENNA 17055 (717) 737-2033 \, . '. . ,.~f".':'~",,,,,,' ...-.... --.....,.. ._~"'....~....~-..,...,.t..."-"- T... - , , : 'I t 1 : .~.' ". ~ . " . '~' " ,'wf"'" '. .'..f ( , . . . ' . '.. .- . ';'paril('r\rrtlim,obJ I' " , PNC NATIONAL BANK, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNlY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION - LAW NO. 95-e1t1 CIVIL TERM IO'/f Plaintiff, v. BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, Defendant. BENJAMIN J. PARISER, Defendant above, objects to the Complaint filed by the Plaintiff, as follows: 1. In its Complaint, Plaintiff avers a balance due and owing in the amount of $4,490.38. 2. Plaintiff does not state with specificity whether said claim Is based upon a writing, nor does it attach a copy of the writing establishing the amount due and owing to be $4,490.38. 3. Pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1019(h), "a pleading shall state specifically whether any claim or defense set forth therein is based upon a writing. If so, the pleader shall attach a copy of the writing..." 1:'pariK.\prdim,obj I i WHEREFORE, Defendant, BENJAMIN J. PARISER, prays thIs Honorable Court i to dismiss the Complaint. FLOWER, MORGENTHAL FLOWER & LINDSAY Attorneys for Benjamin J. pariser By: arol J. ndsay, EsquIre 10 # 44693 11 East High Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-5513 2 \ '.- \. -, .'---',"\..; ~"""';':.;l!t~1...r-- -, ..' '. . '. " . , , ~ I, the undersigned, hereby verify that the statements made herein are true and correct. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa, C.S. g 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. B'n~ q-2,7-1( Date: 1:\r.rlur\rrrJim.obJ Plaintiff, IN THE COURTOF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION - LAW NO. 95-010 CIVIL TERM PNC NATIONAL BANK, v. BENJAMIN J. PARlSER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, Defendant. AND NOW, this / day of 4ft! I;' 1995, I, CAROL J. LINDSAY, Esquire, of the law firm of FLOWER, M6RGENTHAL, FLOWER & LINDSAY, Attorneys, hereby certify that I served the within Preliminary Objection of Defendant, Benjamin J. Pariser, this day by depositing same in the United States Mall, First Class, Postage Prepeld, in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, addressed to: Murray A. Felder, Esquire Two Logan Square, Suite 1520 Philadelphia, PA 19103 FLOWER, MORGENTHAL FLOWER & LINDSAY Attorneys for Benjal11!n J. pariser By: 3 o ~~ H!;1 P<lIl Z~ o ill ~P< o ' ~t 00 o ~tJ ~I E-<gj ZP HtJ Ln en - = c._ .... lJ) >- .. ~ ~,'-> ~ I Z o H 00 H i:i Q H H :> H tJ . . .~". .<....,. ,~~ c- "t'. ,~' .... . ., , ., '.l,;<. ,(.,.' p , 'H 'H ..1 .jJ I:: ".I ~~ . III > . ~ ~ "tl !5gjffi lIllll'H ~~2l P<P< P: r.l 00 {j ~ 00 Z . o I':l H E-< Z tJ H ~ ~ o &l ~ ~ ~ ~ H Z gj ill P< f:l Q '" .... o ...J ~ t>- el; >- 0 .... :c<~ lU~ .....Ul"'~~~ ZOO.J......... t.LlZ~...lIl> lj:iO<:r:~ !l': UIIl o~~~!:2;2 ~!l':Z ~:r: z . t.Ll Q 0.... t.Ll !l': :?; 1H1:: 1Il D: ~ O~ < ~ ~ ;;;> ...l "' .... 1Il OIJ..Ilo ....- ...l < ...l IJ.. ~ U .., .. .... ~ '" .. ",...J!::.., t>- < '" '" "'~ '" '" . .. o e>::" '... e>::wci>- wlJw< ::e>::::Ul 0000 ...J::E...Ji?; ... .......J .::E . . Oe>::O:l UlWUlO WlJWe>:: ::EO::Elj <~< ...", ... ~ o H E-< ~ . . I':l~ ZiIl Hffi ~g lilIl r.llll fllH ---- ---~ '. " . I' , " . " " ........... - :, ..-...... ,~~-"",., " .' tJ Z P< PNC NATIONAL BANK COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA Plaintiff 't. CIVIL DIVISION- LAW No. 95~ CIVIL TERM lo7~ v. BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER Defendants. ANSWER TO PRELIMINARY OBJECTION~ Plaintiff, by their attorney, Murray A. Felder, Esq. hereby replies to Defendant's Preliminary Objections: 1. Paragraph 1 of Defendant's Preliminary Objections is denied. Defendant has a balance due and owing in the amount of $5,388.46. 2. Paragraph 2 of Defendant I s Preliminary Objections is denied. The agreement is based on a credit card account that was opened by Defendant with a Credit Card application; this application was attached to the complaint. Plaintiff does not have to establish its claim in the pleadings, but merely allege the amount it claims is due. Nevertheless, a copy of the Defendants' final statement on their account is attached hereto. ....... ~.r"'.. , ~. .,~ ,_' r ,.~ "". . ~ ' , . i - .' ' . . .' . . 3. Paragraph 3 of Defendant's Preliminary Objections is denied for the reasons stated in Paragraph 2 of this Answer which is incorporated herein by reference. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requests Defendant's Preliminary Objections be dismissed; and that judgment be entered in favor of Plaintiff and against Defendant in the amount of $5,388.46 plus costs and interest. (} ul MURRAY A. Attorney Two Loga Suite 1520 Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 963-3400 i j PNC BANK ON-LINE STATEIlENT I i I; , ' I , PARISER,BENJAIlIN J PARISER,ISHWOREE H 625 W. OLD YORK ROAD CARLISLE PA 17013-9155 ACCOUNT NUlIBER 4081704011008126 STATEMENT DM'E 111394 DUE DATE 120894 IlINIllU1l DUE 813.00 CREDIT LIIIIT 4000 TRAN POST REFERENCE NUIlBER CHARGES, PAYIlENTS, & CREDITS AIlOUNT DATE DATE ---------------- ------------------------------------- -------- 1 1027 1027 74081701lW06GSQIlHL PYIlT 040/0011557/0117 WILHINGtON DE000 125.00- 2 FINANCE CHG PURCHASES $29.88 CASH ADVANCE $33.45 63.33 PREVIOUS BALANCE 4552.05 PAYIlENTS CREDITS CHARGES FEES FINANCE CIlARGE 63.33 NEW BALANCE 4490.38 125.00 .00 .00 .00 17.99\ APR ON FIRST $1500 OF BALANCE \ APR ON BALANCE OVER $1500 THIS IS A COllPUTER GENERATED STATElIENT. IT \'IAS GENERATED ON THU. FES 23,1995 I AND SHOI~S THE ACTUAL CREDIT INFORIIATION PROVIDED ON TilE ORIGINAL STATElIENT DATE I lIAILED TO THE CUSTOIIER. !' i CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Murray A. Felder, Esq., do hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of the attached document on the party or his/her attorney listed below on the date indicated below by first class mail. Date Mailed:5/1l/95 TO: CAROL J. LINDSAY, ESQ. F~WER, MORGENTIIAL, FLONER & LINDSAY 11 EAST HIGH STREET CARLISLE, PA 17013 Lr> en ., -- u..: c:> .... -::r tn >- _t :.:L;; . , , " PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT (Must be typewritten and subnitted in duplicate) TO THE PROTflONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY: Please list the within matter for the next J\rgIJnent Court. ------..-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be stated in full) PNC NATIONAL 1lJ\NK, (plaintiff) VB. BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHII'OREE M. PARISER (Defendant) JD7f No. 95-Gtfr Civil Action 19 95 1. state matter to be argued (1.e.. plaintiff's IlDtion for new trial, defendant's deniu:rer to canplaint, etc.): THE PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF BOTH DEFENDANTS NEED TO BE ARGUED ON THE SlIME DATE. 2. Identify counsel who will argue case: (a) for plaintiff: MURRAY A. FELDER, ESQ. Address: TWO LOGAN SQUARE, SUITE 1520 PHILADELPHIA, PA 19103 (h) for defendant: CAROL J. I,INDSAY, ESQ. JAMES M. IlhCH, ESQ. Address: 11 EAST HIGH STREET 352 S. Sporting Hill Road CARLISLE, PA 17013-3016 Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 (Atty for Benjamin J. Pariser) (Atty for Ishworee M. Pariser) 3. I will notify all parties in writing within l:'ioU days that this case has been listed for a.rgunent. 4. J\rgIJnent COUrt Date: August 16, 1995 GV~ Dated: ~ 5/./95 #39331 ...., ~ ,-r;: .-c m Ln m "" "" => -, I I \ I ~ .r.>- ~- ~_. ,. HI I ~.I .:: ;!;1 ,:, ~~ ;'-; '5' " . ""-1'/' .J' ,1.,.:-, ,. , , l..(.. ~I - .. " PNC NATIONAL BliNK, : Plaintiff : . . VB. : . . BENJAMIN J. PARISER and . . ISIIWOREE M. PARISER : Defendants . . IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEA OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA No 95 - 1078 CIVIL TERM ANSWER. AND NOW comes the Defendant, ISIIWOREE M. PARISER, by her Attorney JAMES M. BACII, and files the within ANSWER: 1-2, Admitted. 3-7, Denied. To the contrary, at no time during the period set forth in complaint did Ishworee M. Pariser have in her possession the card nor use the card. Liability, if any, is the exclusive liability of Benjamin J. Pariser. WIIEREFORE, Defendant ISIIWOREE M. PARISER Respectfully Prays that the Complaint against her be dismissed or in alternative all liability, if any be that of Benjamin J. Pariser. Respectfully submitted, DATE 08/29/95 --Jm ~ ES M. BlICII, Esquire At orney 1.0. No. 18727 352 S. Sporting lIi11 Road Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 (717) 737-2033 , , Lr). ::'"' ~Jop .r'- t- ... illf), '''I ';:':' .....;'- T '4-\=,(.''''1 ;~ I~- ,.\" ':f' ;/; \.,:r _fJlll .1 n , elL = -=>: ....., In co en '" <., :::> or.:< ., , , SSOL~ VNN3d 'mmSSOlNVH03W aVOI:/ lllH E>NIlI:/OdS HlnOS C:SE MVlIV 1:/013SNnOO aNV A3NI:/OilV HOY8 .W S3WVr '\:. '. . ~., ~ &eOi:-.L&.L (U.L) . JAMES M. BACH ATTORNEY AND COl.X-JSElOR AT LAW 352 SOUTH SPORTING HILL ROAD MECHANICSBURG, PENNA 17055 (717) 737-2033 " .. I ! \, -. ~ ...- . . , , PNC NATIONAL BANK, . IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEA . Plaintiff . OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA . . . vs. . . . . BENJAMIN J. PARISER and . No 95 - 1078 CIVIL TERM . ISIIWOREE M. PARISER . . Defendants . . CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE AND now, this 29 day of August 1995, I, James M. Bach, Esquire, hereby certify that I served the within Defendant I s Answer to the Complaint this day by depositing same in the United states Mail, First Class, Postage prepaid, in Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania, addressed to: Murray A. Felder, Esq. Murray A. Felder Associates Two Logan Squere Suite 1520 Eighteen & Arch Streets Philadelphia, PA 19103 .' ~ 7--fh ~ J ~S M. BACII, Esquire Attorney for Defendant Attorney 1.0. No 10727 352 S. Sporting Hill Road Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 (717) 737-2033 It., i " , um. am, .. ,- ,a)oo.. ",,.-- ~ 114 -I ;:~ 2J ~ -;:.~ ... 'J' -::: -.1:' CD m .- I \ I co '.~ I "- UJ V1 ~~~ ,~: \ ! I i I I .,", Ii SSOH VNN3d 'Ell:lnaSOINVH03W OVOl:lllIH ElNIIl:lOdS HInos i:!i& M\fllV l:1013SNnoo ONV A3Nl:lOllV HOVB .W S311\1Vr .0.:..' ...... .~ EEO~.lf;lJl ~lr ..~.. ~ JAMES M. BACH ATTORNEY AND COUNSELOR AT LAW 352 SOUTH SPORTING HILL ROAD MECHANICS BURG, PENNA 17055 (717) 737.2033 , " ,. . .' #.... ~ . j......,.............-..,......,...... .'" ~.......- ~.", ~ .. : " ,-., . , , .. ~.it ".."."-., ....)I,.~., ..' . 'r ~ . ...." , . _ , .' " . ~ " ' .' . ... -~. ~- =~. . . -..-~-' .".... a:'answer file' 3874.9S.oJ Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION. LAW NO. 95-9'Ht CIVIL TERM 107 !} PNC NATIONAL BANK, v. BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, Defendant v, '" ." I'..' of" ~WE F DEFEND T BEN.JA I -0 = .,-;:: - r..c <..n NOW comes Defendant Benjamin J. Parlser, by and through his attorneys, FLOWER, MORGENTHAL, FLOWER & LINDSAY, P.C., and answers the Complaint as follows: 1. Admitted. 2. Admitted. 3. Admitted. 4. After reasonable Investigation, Defendant Benjamin J. parlser is without information sufficient to form a belief as to the balance due and owing to Plaintiff. 5. Admitted that Plaintiff has made repeated demands for payment. Denied that Defendant Benjamin J. pariser has refused to pay the balance due. By way of further answer, all attempts to work out a payment schedule have been rejected by the Plaintiff. 6. After reasonable investigation, Defendant Benjamin J. Pariser Is without information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the assertions in Paragraph 6 and said assertions are therefore denied. a:\ln.wer me I 3874.95.(j] 7. After reasonable Investigation, Defendant Benjamin J. Parlser is without information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the assertions In Paragraph 7 and said assertions ere therefore denied. WHEREFORE, Defendant Benjamin J. Parlser prays this Honorable Court to dismiss the Complaint. FLOWER, MORGENTHAL FLOWER & LINDSAY, P.C. Attorneys for Defendant Benjamin J. Parlser By: .., i arel J. Lind ay, Esquire 10 # 44693 11 East High Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-5513 2 .:\hoc:k.n:p ~ I, the undersigned, hereby verify that the statements made herein are true and correct. I understcmd that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. ~ 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. q f),~~-- Benjamin J"'parlser (l..r~'rr Date: RECEIVED SEP - 8 \995 ADS'd........... . PNC NATIONAL BANK, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERlAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION. lAW NO. 95-010 CIVIL TERM v. BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, Defendant E E V AND now, this J /1{\ day of .....?1fh1./,f lJ?V, 1995, I, Carol J. Lindsay, Esquire, of the law firm of FLOWER, MORGENTHAL, FrOWER & LINDSAY Attorneys, hereby certify that I served the within ANSWER OF DEFENDANT BENJAMIN J. PARISER this day by depositing same In the United States Mall, First Class, Postage Prepaid, in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, addressed to: Murray A. Felder, Esquire Two Logan Square Suite 1520 Eighteenth and Arch Streets Philadelphia, PA 19103 James M. Bach, Esquire 352 South Sporting Hili Road Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 FLOWER, MORGENTHAL FLOWER & LINDSAY Attorneys for Defendant BenjamIn J. Parlser By: ( Carol J. Lind ay, Esquire '-......./10 # 44693 11 East High Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-5513 ! ~ . . . . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PNC NATIONAL BANK, PLAINTIFF NO. 95 - 01078 CIVIL TERM -VS- BENJAMIN J. PARISER & ISHWOREE M. PARISER, DEFENDANTS. MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS AND NOW, comes Plaintiff, PNC National Bank, by its Attorney, Murray A. Felder, Esq. and files this Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings for the following reasons: 1. Suit was filed in the above case on or about February 27, 1995 against Defendants for collection of the balance due on a Mastercard/Visa Account. 2. Defendant Benjamin pariser began paying Plaintiff $100 per month on or about March 15, 1995 through Plaintiff's attorney. 3. Subesquently, both defendants refused further payments and filed an answer denying the allegations in the Complaint, but offering no facts to constitute a defense to the action. . . 4. Defendant, Benjamin Pariser, indicates in his Answer that Plaintiff has rejected all efforts to work out a payment arrangement. 5. Said allega~ion does not constitute a defense to this action. 6. As neither defendant has raised any facts sufficient to constitute a defense, the Answers are general denials entitling . Plaintiff to Judgment on the Pleadings as a matter of law in the amount of $5,288.46, the amount claimed in the Complaint less the $100.00 paid on March 15, 1995. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requests this Court to on the Pleadings in favor of Plaintiff and Defendants, jointly & severally, in the amount of costs & interest. enter Judgment against both $5,288.46 plus , . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PNC NATIONAL BANK, Plaintiff NO.: 95-'1078 -vs- BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARIBER, Defendants. MEMORANDUM OF LAW Rule 1034 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure provides thut, "after the pleadings are closed but within such time as not to delay trial, any party may move for judgment on the pleadings." A motion for jUdgment on the pleadings should be alleged by a party when a decision must be made on a controlling question of law. In this case, Benjamin J. Pariser admits to opening and using the credit card account. In Ishworee M. pariser' s Answer, she generally denies opening and using the Credit Card account without substantiating her averment. Thus, in accordance wi th those matters specified by Rule 1032(2), a motion for judgment on the pleadings is proper since the Defendants have failed to state a legal defense to the claim alleged. . . Additionally, under Rule 1029 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, averments in a pleading to which a responsive pleading is required are deemed admitted when not denied specifically. Since Benjamin J. pariser has admi tted to owing the debt, Defendant has failed to raise any facts that constitute a defense. Further since Ishworee M. pariser has failed to substantiate her averments she too has failed to raise any facts that constitute a defense. Therefore, the Movant is entitled to judgment on pleadings pursuant to Rules 1029, 1032(2) and 1034 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. MURRAY A. FELDER, ASSOCIATES BY: (fi'-/,o/.t"/,:)... Cl.,/3"r;/!j!Itt' Anjella/A. Englesbe, Esq. ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF PA J.D. #74176 1520 TWO LOGAN SQUARE PHILADELPHIA, PA 19103 (215) 963-3400 . . CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Anjella A. Englesbe, Esq., do hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of the attached document on the party or his/her attorney listed below on the date indiGated below by first class mail. Date Mailed: October 2, 1995 To: Carol J. Lindsay, Esq. (Attorney for Benjamin J. Pariser) 11 East High Street Carlisle, PA 17013 James M. Bach, Esq. (Attorney for Ishworee M. Pariser) 352 South Sporting Hill Road Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 MURRAY A. FELDER ASSOCIATES BY: a /- (,("'/'~. (/) r/;:;7.Q.:/".e-/ Anjella A. Englesbe; Esq. PA 1.D. 1174176 TWO LOGAN SOUARE, SUITE 1520 PHILADELPHIA, PA 19103 PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT (Must be typewritten and subnitted in duplicate) TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERl.AND COUNTY: Please list the within matter for ti'.e next Argunent coort_ I: I' --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CAPTION OF CASE (entu:e caption l11II6t be stated in full) PNC NATIONAL BANK, NO.: 95-01078 ( plaintiff) .-=:> n -. VB. uJ BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, .... O' ::.~ ~. - . .~ ,..., ... .~" lD c..n ( Defendant) No. 95-01078 Civil Action 19 95 1. State matter to be argued (i.e., plaintiff's I1Dtion for new trial, defendant's denw:rer to ccrnplaint, etc.): MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS 2. Identify counsel who will argue case: (a) for plain".i.ff: J\ddress: MURRAY A. FELDER, ESQ. TWO LOGAN SQUARE, SUITE 1520 PHILADELPHIA, PA 19103 (b) for defendant: Carol J. Lindsay, Esq. (Attorney for Benjamin J. Pariser) J\ddress: 11 East High Street, Carlisle, PA 17013 James M. Bach, Esq. (Attorney for Ishworee M. pariser) 352 s. Sporting Hill Road, Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 3. I will notify all parties in writing within two days that this case has been listed for argunent. 4 _ 1\rgUnellt court Date: December 6,1995 D3ted: 10/2/95 _Cl~ NC NATIONAL BANK , ESQ. (215)963-3400 PNC NATIONAL BANK, Plnintiff vs. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW BENJAMIN J. PARlSER llnd ISHWOREE M. PARISER, Defendnnts 95-107H CIVIL TERM . IN RE: MOTION TO COMPEL DEPOSITION ORDER AND NOW, this 20' dny of October, 1995, n rule is issued on the defendnnts to show cause why the requested relief should not be granted. This rule returnnble fifteen (15) dnys nfter service. BY THE COURT, .AIL Gel iJJ :1 21 i;1 '95 ,!., I ,0 . a:lQ" --'~ l'l '"I ~ .... .oj' "cl ,i t J r=- , OCT 1 9199511\ IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PNC NATIONAL BANK, Plaintiff NO. 95-1078 -vs- BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, Defendants. ORDER AND NOW, this day of , 1995, upon consideration of the Plaintiff's MOTION TO COMPEL DEPOSITION, it.is hereby ordered that the Motion is granted and Defendants, BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, shall appear for a deposition in Plaintiff's attorney's office within 30 days. By the Court: , J. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PNC NATIONAL BANK, Plaintiff NO. 95-1078 -vs- BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, Defendants. MO'I'ION 'fO COMrl~l. DEPOSITION Plaintiff, by ite nttorlloy, Murray A. Felder, Esq., requests this "onorablo Court to IHellO 1111 Order Compelling the Deposition of Defendants, BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, I. Defellllants, m,NJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, were sorved with Plaintiff's Notice of Deposition on June 21, 1995. 2. Bald Defendants failed and/or otherwise refused to attend the deposition on August 16, 1995. Wlmlml~Olm, Plalnti ff rospectfully requests this Court to enter an Ordor (lOmpelllnu Defendants, BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARIBlm, tu Iltlond II Ileposl tlon within the next 30 d~YS:.\n ~ .~ ELDER, ESQ. ATTORN Y R PLAINTIFF PNC NATtONAL BANK PA ID 1139331 'rwo l.OGAN SQUARE, Sui te 1520 PIIII.ADEI.PIIIA, PA 19103 (215) 963-3400 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PNC NATIONAL BANK, Plaintiff 95-1078 -vs- BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, Defendants. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION To: JAMES M. BACH, ESQ. 352 S SPORTING HILL RD, MECHANICSBURG, PA 17055 CAROL LINDSAY, ESQ. 11 E HIGH ST CARLISLE, PA 17013-3016 Kindly take notice that the depositions of DEFENDANTS, BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, will be taken upon oral examination at the Cumberland County Courthouse on August 16, 1995 @ 10:00 a.m. The purpose and scope of these depositions is to inquire into any facts relevant to establishing the Plaintiff's claims & Murra~l;elder, Esq. #39331 Attor.~r PNC, Plaintiff 1520 2 Logan Square Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 963-3400 outlined in its Complaint in Civil Action and thereto. efenses DATED & MAILED: June 21, 1995~ M~ORANDUM OF LAW In addlllon lo lhe general rules of applicability, the Pennaylvanld Rules of Civil Procedure contain speCific rules governing depoBillons by nral examination. Rule 4007.1 stales that a party desiring to take the depoBltion of another person upon oral examination shall give roasonable notice, in writing, containing the time and place of taking the deposi tion and the name and address of each person to be examined if known, to every other party to the action. A party noticed to be deposed is required to appear without subpoena. The Explanatory Notes to Rule 4007.1 state that notice is sufficient to support the subsequent sanction procedures provided under Rule 4019 for failure to appear. Pursuant to Rule 4019(a)(I)(iv), entitled Sanctions, the court may, upon a motion, order the party, who after notice under Rule 4007.1 fails to appear for a deposition, to be examined. Section (c) of Rule 4019, lists the orders that a court may make upon the deponent for the failure to appear for a deposition. Among this list of orders, the court may issue such an order as is just to facilitate discovery. Subsection (g)(l) of Rule 4019, provides that the next step in compelling compliance of a deponent who fails to submit to a diacovery request after notice, ia to file a motion with the Court to compel compliance. 'I 0, ,J!/1.. MURRAY A. 'LDER, ESQ. ATTORNEY OR PLAINTIFF PNC NATIONAL BANK CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE James M. Bach, Esq. c/o Ishworee M. pariser 352 South Sporting Hill Road Mechanicsb g, PA 17055 MURRAY A. FELDER ASSOCIATES .", BY: (':2u./<..f"Q" c1 ('8(,.'~~ Anjetla A. EngleSb~, Esq. I, Anje1la A. Englesbe, Esq., do hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of the attached document on the party or his/her attorney listed below on the date indicated below by first class mail. Date Mailed: Octo:: ~r 13, 1995 Carol J. l.indsay, Esq. To l:/oBeniamir. J. Parl'ser 11 E. High Street Carlisle, PA 17013 PA I.D. #74176 TWO LOGAN SQUARE, SUITE 1520 PHILADELPHIA, PA 19103 . ,n en :r.: 0_ r4 ". J) f';l ,- u c::.;) tJ:ltJflIlI'tr,l'm JIlt' J.'41o1.~J,OJ PNC NATIONAL BANK, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION - LAW NO. 95-G:Hl CIVIL TERM 10 '1l"' Plaintiff v. BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, Defendant ANSWER OF BENJAMIN J. PARISER TO MOTION TO COMPEL DEPOSITION NOW comes Benjamin J. Parlser, by and through his attorneys, FLOWER, MORGENTHAL, FLOWER & LINDSAY, P.C., and answers the Motion to Compel Deposition as follows: 1. Admitted that Benjamin J. Pariser was served with a Notice of Deposition on June 21, 1995. 2. Admitted that Benjamin J. Parlser failed to attend the deposition on August 16, 1995. By way of further answer, Defendant Benjamin J. Pariser was unable to attend the deposition at the time and place stated and so notified the Plaintiff who refused to reschedule. 3. Plaintiff seeks to take the deposition of Benjamin J. Pariser at the office of Its attorney, at 2 Logan Square, Suite 1520, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103. The location of the office, some 2 1h hours from Defendant Benjamin J. Pariser's residence and place of employment places an undue burden on Defendant Benjamin J. Pariser. 4. On or about October 2. 1995, Plaintiff filed a Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings. Said Motion was filed approximately two weeks before the filing of the Motion to Compel Discovery n:lmuu'..r,lt", flt... J,'t7".IJJ.O.f which is before the Court. A copy of the Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings is attached hereto as Exhibit "A". 5. The Motion for Judgment on the Plec:dings is presently before the Court and undecided. No deposition Is permitted in a Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings. If the Motion is successful, there will be no need for a deposition. If the Motion Is unsuccessful, Plaintiff can arrange to take Defendant Berjamin J. Pariser's deposition at that time. WHEREFORE, Defendant Benjamin J. Pariser prays this Honorable Court to deny the Motion to Compel Deposition. FLOWER, MORGENTHAL FLOWER & LINDSAY, P.C. Attorneys for Defendant Benjamin J. Parlser By: parol J. Un say, Esquire j'ID # 44693 11 East High Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243.5513 1 a:lmuwr,.brtl fllr' J,'1U.IJJ.OJ I It I' I , EXHIBIT II A II PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT (Must. be typewritten and subnitted in duplicate) TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY: Please list the within matter far the next J\rgIJnent Court. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be stated in full) PNC NATIONAL BANK, NO.1 95-01078 (Plaintiff) VB. BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, (Defendant) No. 95-01078 Civil Action 19 95 1. State matter to be argued (i.e., plaintiff's IlDtion far new trial, defendant's denutrer to COTplaint, etc.): MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADItllS 2. Identify counsel who will argue case: (a) far plaintiff: Address : MURRAY A. FELDER, ESQ. '1'1\'0 LOGAN SQUARE, SUITE 1520 PHILADELPHIA, PA 19103 (b) far defendant: Carol J. Lindsay, Esq. (Attorney for Benjamin J. pariser) Address: 11 East High Street, Carlisle, PA 17013 James M. Bach, Esq. (Attorney for Ishworee M. Pariser) 352 S. Sporting Hill Road, Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 3. I will notify all parties in writing within M days that this case has been listed for argunent. 4. Argl.Inent Court Date: December 6, 1995 Dated: 10/2/95 IN THE COMMON PLEAS COURT OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PNC NATIONAL BANK, PLAINTIFF NO. 95-01078 TYPE OF PLEADING: MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS VS. BENJAMIN J. PARISER & ISHWOREE M. PARISER, DEFENDANTS. FILED ON BEHALF OF: PLAINTIFF, PNC NATIONAL BANK COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFF: MURRAY A. FELDER, ESQ. PA I D #39331 TWO LOGAN SQUARE SUITE 1520 PHILADELPHIA, PA 19103 (215)963-3400 IN THE COMMON PLEAS COURT OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PNC NATIONAL BANK, PLAINTIFF NO. 95-01078 VS. BENJAMIN J. PARISER & ISHWOREE M. PARISER, DEFENDANTS. . , ORDER AND NOW, this day of , 1995, upon consideration of Plaintiff's Motion for JUdgment on the Pleadings, it is hereby ordered that the Motion is granted and JUdgment is entered against both defendants jointly and severally in the amount of $5,288.46 plus costs & interest. , J. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION PNC NATIONAL BANK, PLAINTIFF NO. 95 - 01078 CIVIL TERM -VS- BENJAMIN J. PARISER & ISHWOREE M. PARISER, DEFENDANTS. MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS AND NOW, , comes Plaintiff, PNC National Bank, by its Attorney, Murray A. Felder, Esq. and files this Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings for the following reasons: . . 1. Suit was filed in the above case on or about February 27, 1995 against Defendants for collection of the balance due on a Mastercard/Visa Account. 2. Defendant Benjamin Pariser began paying Plaintiff $100 per month on or about March 15, 1995 through Plaintiff's attorney. 3. Subesquently, both defendants refused further payments and filed an answer denying the allegations in the Complaint, but offering no facts to constitute a defense to the action. . r .. ~~ "'...-, "'_~___ . .....,.. "..I':'~~~~"tI~..""""""""".';" 'r '" to ..~._..._ , -...,. _________--_,./-"-- " 't"," '.' ,f,'. 0' . - ._, 4. Defendant, Benjamin Pariser, indicates in his Answer that Plaintiff has rejected all efforts to work out a payment arrangement. 5. Said allegation does not constitute a defense to this action. 6. As neither defendant has raised any facts sufficient to constitute a defense, the Answers are general denials entitling Plaintiff to JUdgment on the Pleadings as a matter of law in the amount of $5,288.46, the amount claimed in the Complaint less the $100.00 paid on March 15, 1995. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requests this Court to enter Judgment . on the Pleadings in favor of Plaintiff and against both Defendants, jointly & severally, in the amount of $5,288.46 plus costs & interest. FELDER, ESQ. F R PLAINTIFF, BANK I '! ,! ;! , . a:lmuwtr.b,.,. flit"' J8701.IJ$.0) PNC NATIONAL BANK, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION - LAW NO. 95-010 CIVIL TERM Plaintiff v. BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, Defendant AND now, this CERTIFICATE OF~ERVICE ce:;' day of J~}fJVI LLtI>J 'v, 1995, I, Carol J. Lindsay, Esquire. of the law firm of FLOWER, MORGENTHAL, FLOWER & LINDSAY Attorneys, hereby certify that I served the within ANSWER OF BENJAMIN J. PARISER TO MOTION TO COMPEL DEPOSITION this day by depositing same in the United States Mall, First Class, Postage Prepaid, In Carlisle, Pennsylvania, addressed to: Murray A. Felder, Esquire Two Logan Square Suite 1520 Eighteenth and Arch Streets Philadelphia, PA 19103 James M. Bach, Esquire 352 South Sporting Hill Road Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 FLOWER, MORGENTHAL FLOWER & LINDSAY Attorneys for Defendant Benjamin J. Parlser By: tl~ '/,-"Carol J. LI say, Esquire ( .__/'10 # 44693 11 East High Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-5513 1:\ln",-'cr.mnt file" 3H7.t.')S-OJ 1(, -- r 1 . (I r Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION. LAW NO. 95.Q;K) CIVIL TERM /0 If PNC NATIONAL BANK, v. BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, Defendant ANSWER TO MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS NOW COMES Benjamin J. Pariser, by and through his attorney, FLOWER, MORGENTHAL, FLOWER & LINDSAY, P.C., and answers the Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings filed by Plaintiff as follows: 1. Admitted. 2. Denied that Defendant Benjamin J. Pariser began paying $100.00 per month on or about March 15, 1995 through Plaintiff's counsel. By way of furthar answer, although Defendant Benjamin J. Parlser made one $100.00 payment, that payment cannot be an acknowledgment of the debt alleged to Plaintiff in the amount specified. 3. Admitted In part and Denied in part. Admitted that subsequent to the filing of the Complaint, Defendant Benjamin J. Pariser made no further payments and filed an Answer denying allegations in the Complaint. Denied that the Answer offered no facts to constitute a defense In the action. Defendant Benjamin J. Parlser offered a legally sufficient Answer denying, for a lack of Information sufficient to form a belief as to the amounts asserted as due and owing by Plaintiff. 4. Admitted. 5. Admitted. .:'.".,..r,"OI m., 3874")5~)] 6. Denied that Defendant Benjamin J. Parlser has not raised facts sufficient to constitute a defense. Denied that his Answers to the paragraphs of the Complaint are general denials. Denied that Plaintiff Is entitled to Judgment on the pleadings. WHEREFORE, Defendant Benjamin J. Parlser prays this Honorable Court to deny the Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings. FLOWER, MORGENTHAL FLOWER & LINDSAY, P.C. Attorneys for Defendant Benjamin J. Parlser By: Carol J. Un ay, Esquire ID # 44693 11 East High Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-5513 ,,'..,wer.n,,;, me' 3874.'/5.113 Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION. LAW NO. 95-010 CIVIL TERM PNC NATIONAL BANK, v. BENJAMIN J. PARISER AND ISHWOREE M. PARISER, Defendant AND now, this ~FICA'(E OF SERVICE .' 7 day of ({)ePtJ/:J'I/-" , 1995, I, Carol J. Lindsay, Esquire, of the law firm of FLOWER, MORGENTHAL, FLOWER & LINDSAY, P.C., Attorneys, hereby certify that I served the within Answer to Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings this day by depositing same in the United States Mail, First Class, Postage Prepaid, in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, addressed to: Murray A. Felder, Esquire Two Logan Square Suite 1520 Eighteenth & Arch Streets Philadelphia, PA 19103 James M. Bach, Esquire 352 South Sporting HIli Road Mechanlcsburg, PA 17055 FLOWER, MORGENTHAL FLOWER & LINDSAY Attorneys for Defendant Benjamin J. Parlser By: /)~ arcl J. LI asay, Esquire ID # 44693 11 East High Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-5513 u-> <r> :1-:"': ..-r N t.l ':Q r;:~ ") ,- '.' c....;.:., '. PNC NATIONAL BANK . . PLAINTIFF . . . . vs. . . . . BEN,YAMIN J. PARISER and : ISBWOREE M. PARISER . . DEFENDANT . . IN THE COURT OF COHHON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION - LAW 95 - Oto CIVIL TERM /U7t ANSWER OF ISBWOREE M. PARISEI{ TO MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS. AND NOW comes Ishworee M. Pariser, by her Attorney JAMES M. BACH, and answers the Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings as follows: 1. DENIED. To the contrary the suit was filed against Defendants on March 1, 1995. 2. DENIED. After reasonable investigation, Defendant Ishworee M. Pariser is without information sufficient to form belief as to the truth of the allegations in paragraph 2. 3. DENIED. The Answer filed of record constituted a defense to the action. 4. DENIED. After reasonable investigation, Defendant Ishworee M. pariser is without information sufficient to form belief as to the truth of the allegations in paragraph 4. 5. DENIED. After reasonable investigation, Defendant Ishworee M. pariser is without information sufficient to form belief as to the truth of the allegations in paragraph 5. " 6. DENIED. Defendant Ishworee H. Pariser has raised facts sufficient to constitute a defense. It is denied that the Answers filed are gcneral and it is denicd even further that the Plaintiff is entitled as a matter of law to Judgment on the Pleadings. WHEREFORE, Defcndant Ishworee M. Pariscr respectfully prays this Honorable Court to deny the Motion for JUdgment on the Pleadings. Respectfully submitted, DATE 11/09/1995 ~->.,e~ MES M. BACH, Esquire ttorney I.D. No 18727 352 s. Sporting Hill Rd. MECHANICS BURG, PA 17055 (717) 737-2033 By: L~ '-D') <:n, ~ ~. ':-,. ..- ., "C- '''- ,,.. N ~-~~:..:~ (.1' . . , '...11 " ., - ~~ .. ~ ..t.,~: , .,., . i...... '" ._~ CT) :- -,= - .. ,j SSOH VNN3d 'mmaSOINVH03W OVOl:llllH E>NI1I:IOdS HlnOS i:~ M\f11V 1:I013SNnOO ONV A3NI:IOllV HOYB .W S3INVr ..' ~ , ' EEO~.lEl ~(l ~l) . . _. r "\ JAMES M. BACH ATTORNEY AND COUNSELOR AT LAW 352 SOUTH SPORTING HILL ROAD MECHANICSBURG, PENNA 17055 (717) 737.2033 PNC NATIONAL BANK . . PLAINTIFF . . . . VB. : . . BENJAMIN J. PARISER and . . ISHWOREE M. PARISER : DEFENDANT . . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION - LAW 95 - ~CIVIL TERM fIr/ r ANSWER OF ISHWOREE M. PARISER TO MOTION TO COMPEL DEPOSITION. AND NOW comes Ishworee M. Pariser, by her Attorney JAMES M. BACH, and answers the Motion to Compel Deposition as follows: 1. DENIED. Ishworee M. pariser was not served with a :Iotice of Deposition on June 21, 1995. 2. ADMITTED. 3. Plaintiff seeks to take the deposition of Ishworee M. pariser at the office of its attorney, at 2 Logan Square, Suite 1520, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The travel distance to Plaintiff I s office from the Defendant I s residence is in excess of 100 miles. 4. Defendant Ishworee M. Pariser is currently undergoing the treatment for medical prOblems. Defendant Ishworee M. Pariser does not have the income to go to Philadelphia with her attorney as her only source of income is Alimony pendente lite from her husband at this time. The deposition of her in Philadelphia would cause an undue medical hardship as well as financial hardship on her. 5. On or about october 2, 1995, Plaintiff filed a Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings. The Hotion for Judgment on the Pleadings is presently before the Court and undecided. 6. The Hotion for Judgment on the Pleadings is scheduled for the Argument Court on December 6, 1995. Plaintiff can arrange to take Defendant Ishworce M. pariser I s deposition at that time. WHEREFORE, Defendant Ishworee M. Pariser respectfully prays this Honorable Court to deny the ~Iotion to Compel Deposition. Respectfully submitted, DATE 11/09/1995 ~ . ~ iSL-s=-- ~ES M. BACH, Esquire Attorney I.D. No 18727 352 S. Sporting Hill Rd. MECIIANICSBURG, PA 17055 (717) 737-2033 , . , .,,'.:;;.' '," ,......~-~ ,\-,,~....- ' " .' In en .' , ,- .~c ',; ., -.:= (1.= In N t. ....., ,~: ,; " 1,'....: , , --'.', ....;, \..Ll_...._ .r 'I>jloir 1111' '. ,J,n. :.> ",(.) 4 ,'-,"\ ~ " , \"..., ".. ~~~ .... PNC NATIONAL BANK Plaintiff :IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : IO'7V : No. 95-~ CIVIL TERM VB. BENJAMIN J. PARISER and ISIIWOREE M. PARISER Defendant . . : CIVIL ACTION - LAW . . NOTICE TO PRODUCE. To: MURRAY A. FELDER, ESQ. ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF 1520 2 Logan Square PHILADELPHIA, PA 19103 You are directed to produce the following: 1. Each and every Application for Mastercard/Visa Account signed by each Defendant. 2. Each and every Credit Card agreement with the Plaintiff signed by each Defendant. 3. Each and every financial statement for Defendants' Mastercard/Visa Account showing the actual balance for each and every month. 4. Each and every document showing and specifying what items were purchased, by whom they were purchased and when they were purchased. 5. Each and every document showing each and every payment made on the account, the exact amount of each and every payment, by whom the payments were made and when the payments were made. 6. Each and every charge slip signed by each and any of the Defendants, for each and every purchase made with each and any credit card issued to the Defendants by the Plaintiff. You are directed to produce all at the Law Office of Attorney James M. lIill Road, Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 no 5, 1995. the required documents Bach, 352 S. Sporting later than December If you fail to produce the documents or things required by this notice to produce, you may be subj ect to the sanctions authorized by Rule 234.5 of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. Date November 14, 1995 I.:. --.-.-. /?-T) .~ J ES M. BACII, Esquire A orney for Defendant ISIlWOREE M. PARISER Attorney I.D. No. 18727 352 S. Sporting lIill Rd. MECIIANICSBURG, PA 17055 (717) 737-2033 I I I I 1 "" -<=> =:: lr> 0'> - .' Ire:. -, .- ~.'~ ~-t -'. ';;r k.: t :.j'-1 4.:J . ,:-. nt :-;M' , :. .~ " ;;:::' ...!:~ .-'~. :HI::: '.1111.u .. J.I'l. :.:J .", '.... "T In rrJ Q) .") ." ., PNC NATIONAL BANK PLAINTIFF IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA IO'lY : NO: 95-~ CIVIL TERM . . vs. BENJAMIN J. PARISER and ISHWOREE M. PARISER DEFENDANTS . . CIVIL ACTION - LAW CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, YURI GASPAR , hereby certify that I have this date caused a true and correct copy of the within NOTICE TO PRODUCE to be served upon the person set forth below by depositing same in the United States mail, first class, postage prepaid at Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, addressed as follows: MURRAY A. FELDER, ESQ. Two Logan Square, suite 1520 PHILADELPHIA, PA 19103 Respectfully submitted, Date: 11/14/1995 35 :2 ing Hill Road PA 17055 1 I I ,I ! U'") ~ ~). ",'- "'It;;-t ~:.'= ":.Ji= 4... ,:' ~-'..i, h.:: \-.1:" OJ: :_....J ~l :.:'.~:.; ~n-:.t;'- .UJL..::: d, r:~)h" j ':J:,Il.. ~ ~U = ..:: tD M Q) n >- <:> -- -- , . .... r"'- ~1"_'_'1-'m__"" . " . . . .' '. ' ' . ,~ . . '- " ,., K'..... ,...,. . '. " , . . --,... t, i " ,', " " ,.'. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA PNC NATIONAL BANK, CIVIL DIVISION Plaintiff NO. GD 1~55-0107a 1999 9S. /O'?J;; C,U" ( IErZ-rl vs. BENJAMIN PARISER, Defendant. PRAECIPE TO ENTER APPEARANCE PRAECIPE TO SATISFY JUDGMENT TO: Prothonotary, Cumberland County Please enter my appearance on behalf of Plaintiff, PNC National Bank. Kindly mark the Judgment entered in favor of Plaintiff and against Defendant, as satisfied. Respectfully submitted, ~~~e Attorney for PNC Bank, National Association Sworn to and subscribed before this 7'~ day of ~P./ L ~d~ Not Public me , 199.P. My Commission Expires: jbg\ :1 , i' ! j, I: , "'... ... \ i ,- -' . i.~ u .~ (), r:: , , -' c/J~:.> ':') r.. , u. [; L: i i ,j 4.,- ..:'- f^,': ....: I I (-'" ':i ...:.J C:\ (.)