HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-01283
",oj
"I .t_
~. Jt~\~: ~
l~
It;f\j~;tJ)__ ~,",:'-
, ,,,, '\I) ,
~~{~~~; 'Y _'
~(t'rz. ~',,-"
f~<,~
;:1,"7' ,
~"p.'-;-' "i,,'.
~1~~<
'r;lf:'~;~y' "
~!1F:)"
:ti,,\8.' ,,',
,~~\(:
l'.@-'~'"
r~\'<
"
II
"
,
,!" ,-
"~;} .
;.,,:..t',...
..', ,
;':p
-
',;";. __i -
j
I'
-
DAVID CAUTHEN, Individually
and DAVID CAUTHEN,
Assignee of PROPERTY
MANAGEMENT, INC" or
PROPERTY MANAGEMENT,
INC.,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
PLAINTIFFS
V.
DENNIS NESS,
DEFENDANT
95-1283 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 13th day of November, 1995, pursuant to Pennsylvania Rule of
Civil Procedure DJ1016, a hearing shall be held In Courtroom Number 2, Cumberland
County Courthouse, at 11:30 a,m. on Monday, November 27,1995, pursuant to the
Statement of Objection filed pursuant to Rule 1017,
Edgar B. Bayley,\!,
..~
Robert L. O'Brien, Esquire
For Plaintiffs
:saa
.,
.-
,-,.
',r"':
.~ .., ~.
" ,.. 'f
,. ~ '.. ) .i.
.~ ~ . .~#
\'" t ' .....
\:',~:, ~..::~
. :r
',,1
."..'t).o
"
, /1
'-,~
....
~~
,
.g..
~
.?
/
-<
,n
,-
1II
..:
l>l
'}'.,t-1 ...
'11<:><
:<!:,Eo<
Oe5'
:E:o":
:E:CJH
O~ '
CJ ....
~~
r....::><
O."'llll
Eo<II::<!:
.,..15ffil>lffi '
, '011<
CJCJ
'l>lr..
',tl:o,
".Eo<
:<!:
H
.~
, ,
,
".
, .~
. .
>,QJCJCJ
MQJZZ
M~HH
Itltll
::s..... .. ..
'tl1llE-<8
'M,lIIZZ
,~..:~ !;J.
'tl -l>ll>llll
~ZClClr..
Hl>l":oo(r..
.~~~~
:<!:t:l:e::E::<!:
l>l":H
tllCJ><><":
E-< E-<E-<"'l
t:lAP:II:1I<
oo(Hl>ll>l
CJ> II< Poi
, ":00
AAP:P:
H 11<11<
>'tl
oo(~......
AItlOO
r..Eo<
t1<Z
l>loo(
, Z~
> 1IIl>l
Hr..
Zl>l
i:'JA
A
.
+
t :<!:
+ 0
+ H
+ Eo<
+ 't:l
+ ~
+ H
+ II:
+ Eo<
+ 1II
+ H
+ Q
+
+ II:
+ 0
+ r..
t :<!:
+ 0
+ H
+ Eo<
+ H
+ 8
+ l>l
+ II<
+
~
filil:
800(
t-1~
HI
>:2:
HO
C)H
E-<
roC)
(1)00(
N
o-<~
IH
10>
(llH
C)
.
o
Z
. . ~
'. ."
" ;.J/,..J
'-'-I
j
I
k
~
"-
, ...
.....
j
,~
\'
~ ~ ~
~ ~ i I
;0 ~ .. ~
s 5 ~ ~
~ ~ ~
~..
~'
DAVID CAUTHEN, Individually
and DAVID CAUTHEN, Assignee of
PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, INC"
or PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, INC"
Plaintiffs
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
--.... .... ,.,...;,;.;.......~.,...
,.
V,
.
NO, 95-1283 CIVIL TERM
DENNIS NEFF,
,
,
Defendant
AND NOW, this
ORDER OF COURT
day of
, , 1995, upon review of
the attached Petition for Distribution, this Court orders and directs
the office of the District Justice Paula Correal to distribute the
funds escrowed, in the amount of $1,304,00, with her office in this
matter to Plaintiff, David Cauthen,
BY THE COURT,
J,
\
-
.
.
DAVID CAUTHEN, Individually
and DAVID CAUTHEN, Assignee of
PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, INC"
or PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, INC"
plaintiffs
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
V,
NO. 95-1283 CIVIL TERM
DENNIS NEFF,
Defendant
PETITION FOR DISTRIBUTION
1) petitioner is Robert L, O'Brien, Esquire, attorney for David
Cauthen, Mr, Cauthen has pending before the Court a statement of
Objection to a determination by a district justice, A copy of the
Objection is attached hereto, marked as Exhibit "A", and incorporated
herein by reference,
2) Subsequent or concurrent to that filing, Mr. Cauthen
initiated a Complaint in Mandamus against District Justice Susan Day
which matter was determined by disposition of preliminary objections,
3) Mr. Cauthen has already expended the fOllowing sums in an
effort to secure possession of his mobile home from Mr. Ness, the
Defendant in both actions,
A)
B)
C)
D)
E)
D,J, Day filing fee 10/27/94
D,J, Correal filing fee 11/28/94
D,J, correal Execution fee 2/2/95
Prothonotary Cauthen v, Day 3/1/95
Prothonotary Statement of Objection 3/10/95
TOTAL
$65.50
$65,50
$66,00
$45,50
S45,25
$287,75
4) District Justice Day's office has indicated that in order to
issue a writ of execution, Mr, Cauthen must pay an additional $71.00
in costs, In the event that Mr. Cauthen pays this amount, he will
have expended $1,300,00 to settle tbe claim of property Management and
$358.75 in costs to the two District Justices' offices and the
1
..
r
'1
-.
prothonotary's office.
5) District Justice Correal's office is holdinq the sum of
$1,304,00 from the sale of the Defendant's property left in the mobile
home,
6) Pursuant to Pa, R,C,P, 1016, the Court of Common Pleas has
jurisdiction to reconsider the property claim pursuant to D,J. Rule
420 Determination of Property Claims and Disputes, Rule 420(c)
states:
The district justice from whose office the order of
execution issued may, upon written request of any party in
interest made before delivery of property sold pursuant to
the order and upon proper cause shown, set aside the sale of
that property and order a resale or enter any other order
Which may be just and proper under the circumstances,
WHEREFORE, Petitioner respectfully requests that, pursuant to Pa.
R,C, P. 1016 and Pa, D,J, Rule 420(c), the Court, in the interest of
justice, order and direct that District Justice Correal turn over the
$1,304,80 escrowed in her office to David Cauthen,
Respectfully SUbmitted,
O'BRIEN, BARIC & SCHERER
BY:
~~
Robert L, O'Brien, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
I,D. II 28351
17 West South Street
CarliSle, PA" 17013
(717) 249-6873
2
-
.
I verify that the statements made in the foregoing petition
are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and
belief, I understand that false statements herein are made subject to
the penalties of 18 Pa, C,S, ~ 4904, relating to unsworn falsification
to authorities,
"
r~~
ROBERT L, O'BRIEN, ESQUIRE
Dated:
/0 I~ '1<')
. ,
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
JUDICIAL DISTRICT
cu"'~~ b.v-ol. (\,,11 \~
~TATEJ'<1ENT OF OBJECTION TO RULE 420
ORDERS AND DETERMINATIONS
OF DISTRICT JUSTICE
/ ~i., ; r..~/J./"..1 /;_...___
COMMON PLEAS NO, ~ S _ \1'~)
STATEMENT OF OBJECTION
1. On ":1, I (" I CiS- ,19 ,~~II\rL 7 (I\':"\'~r\~ '\' .::,u'O(,........ \c:..
J {d.rt (n,m" 01 Oi.,rlcl JUlli,,1
, District Justice, In connection with execution proceedings on the judgment rel"dered In the case of
l"I...IIIA (",..l"\-I,"'....... vs i), ",,", ".. 1:..,0; ,Claim Number TA 19 made
t r _ ~ .,. c>' LT 19: -I f<.,,':,'f\ -'CjLl
Dn..J\c\ C(\\J h...,.... f1"~""'_~,,,,- \ rl'~"'---o"\.\ ",~\v-~ ..", I'Co. \..l' '"('1"::"\ I
(an order) (a determination) ~concernlng: \j \ '~L::~' L T ~ l <oe. 3t;'l - 9,",
,)"\.,,,,<;, \ ~ S~
(')r\ u
\
ChIck ,ppli"bl'
box or bons
o an appeal taken by
(appralsall (designation) of property made by the executing office.
from an
Gk
[]
an appeal taken by
setting aside of property by the executing officer.
a claim to all property levied upon flied by l)n .. i (~ ('" u'\\, <..>---
a claim to the following property levied upon flied by ry. ....A (''',*'\.L.......
r ,~,...~.' \ ,<. ";,",elI \\, "",......Jc '~.... r....."J; , \"
\.A" (bri,t dlller/pr/on of prop.' yJ
.,..,.. ~.....t,.O;-\JW--
from a
o
J
[1l an exception to distribution filed by \)(\\.J le\ (C\.u'\\"'\:'v-....
o a request made by to set aside the sale of
tbrll' dlScliplion o( prop,rlY}
2. The (order) or (determination) referred to above was I), r ,'" "(' \ '" ". .i". '~ ,.<.c ~ II .\r\ "~,,
ISri.' dflJcription of ordlf or d"~rminlt;onl
..:tI1';" ..Q~,,<l,. .-"_,d,,:,,, -11.. 1', <on'~ .__ ,-1--(" ("",,~<, 1'-\. (i -\-r,
. \ <;>. .,. " - ;
~0C:;;-lo'"'l<,,'" .~..A. 0"1 '1)-"l \"" -".l..,\. -,\( .....-r,N-"...., ("'...T'...~
0..... _ ,Q (C' , '-\-h ~,- 1 ?'~1" ~~ 1\\ r, .....d "I."C - . an aggrleyed party In Interest,
- (n,m, of obj,cringp",yl \ . I
3.
objects to this (order) (determination) of the District Justice.
(This fo,m must be filed with the
Prothonorary AND the Districr Jusrice
WITHIN TEN (10) DA YS (rom Ihe dare of
the order or delerminarion 10 wllicll
objection Is made.)
TO BE FILLE~ IN BY OFFICE OF DISTRICT JUSTICE
AOPC 314.00
TIME AND DATE FILED
.3 I kJ() (? /,1'\ 3 - )() ,cj $'
FILING PARTY'S COpy
.
..'
t of certlnrllrlls
Inner Its receipt by
lranamlttlnll 10 the
~f tho recurd of the
rt.
II or th. "ro,oodin",
n"llnJ. c.py or th.
by tho Stalo Co.n
JlUI.I~ 101.1. oJln~:ns OF COUJlT IN
CmtTIOJlAIU l'JlOCl~BDlNGS .
,\, I( thu cUlll1 uf common plellS nnda In fllvor of
thu pllrt)' ohtlllnlnll the writ, It Ahllll enter IIn order
thuttho jllllh'l1wnt Is aetllAhle lIithout projudlce to tho
CIIUAO of octllln,
II, If the court nf c"nllnnn plona nndA ulllllnst tho
pllli)' ohtlllnlnll tho writ, It shllll onter IIn order thllt
the IITlt Is .lIsmlssed.
30, 1082, .erorUI'e 30
Note
S.bdM,lun A .Int.. the "d. th.t Ir th. co.rt find. In rovor
or th. part). obtalnlng tho \\'rlt, II m.rely ..I! tI,. Judgtnenl
below Mill!;' "ithout prt!Judlce to the cuu~e of ucUon. The
ground. for c.rtlorart do not go to the meril! or the ClUl. but
only to matters. that usuully can he cured hy later 8el~tJng Q
proper tribnnal. Se. Statler v, A1exondor Finn Co., 21 D. '"
C, 612, 1D:J.l,
Subdhi.i.n n provide. ror dl.mi..al or the \\'rit tr Ihe
finding 1I agaln.t the p.rty oblninlng It, This leaves the
Ju,lgm.nt holo\\' In roll roree ond .er.cl, See Rul. 1013C,
Adopt,,) June I, 1071,
;EJlTIOJlAJII
:AS
I
I'nrl b)' the district
~holl oporate os 0
n subdivision n of
I
rvo)yes 0 judgment
I receipt of the writ
. as n supersedeas
rl'lit files lIith the
approved by the
poyment of rent
ron pleos proceed.
ssed, If tho porty
I, the prothonotary
pies 0 notation thot
leos when recell'ed
RULE 1015. CERTIORARI AND
APPEAL NOT PERMITTED
A judgment mil)' not be the sllbject of both certloro.
rI ond oppclIl, The prothonotary sholl mark stricken
from thc record any lI'lit of certiorari concerning 0
judb'l1lent Ill! to which on oppeolls pendlnlllf proof of
sel'lice o( caples of the notice of appeul bos been filed,
I( the IIppelllls stricken nr voluntllrll)' tennlnllted, tbe
lI'lit nf cCl11nrlUi ahllll be relnstoterl upon praecipe of
Ihe 1)lIrt)' obtulnlng the writ,
NolO
Thl. rul. r"rbltl. brinKing both ccrtloruri and un oppeal.
An Rl'Pl'ullnvtllvL'1I n trial de novo on the menta, although In
muny c.... fil~t In the r."n or compul.ory arbitration,
\\ithout regnrd to Dny detects in the Ilroccrolnga bt!lo\\.,
whereas certiorari dlles attnck detectJ', not going to the
morll!, In tll. proco.dlnga bolow, To atlompt to combine
tho.o t\\'o p"",.duro, would mu.e sdmlnl.tratlv. dlfficultle,
hardly worth the errort, con.ldoring thst 0 luree..CoI c.rtlo.
rarI would on.n m.rely allow tho cOle to be tri.d ogaln,
.ith.r b.rore onoth.r dl.tri,t JUlU,. or In the court or
comm.n pl..., and that on spp.a1 "'tually II 0 I..ond trisl
although It may hav. .hang.d ..pe,ts (I.. Rule 10070),
Probabl)' b...UI. or th..e sdmlnlatraUve dlrt1rultl,", the
COUrtA or common pl... hove rathcr unlrormly prohlbit.d
Joining tho two rem.dles of app.al and certiorari and have
.Ith.r r.quired un .I.ctlon or fore.d the prol.cuUon or th.
l\rlIt t!')l. filcd to the exclu.lon or the oth.r, S.e. ror
.xump., Ward v, HlU'lIgan, I W,N,C, TJ, 1874; RUIs.1I v,
Shirk. 3 C.C, 287, 1888, Since und.r th. 1068 COllltltuUon 0
porty I. .ntlU.d .. or right to on opp.ul lArt, V, f D) but not
to c.rtlorarl (Art, V, Sch.d.I., f 20), It \\'WI d.cld.d to
prol1d. In this role thut the remedy or opp.o1 \\'ould take
prec.d.nce In all cu... and thut 0 \\'rlt of certiorari sd,
dr....d to 0 Judgm.nt und.r opp.a1 Urom the time or filing
proor or ..nic.) would b. stri,k.n, This \\'ould opply ev.n
In th. perhops rare c... \\'h.n on. party sppeols and th.
oth.r IU.. certiorari,
Adopled J.ne I, 1971, Am.nded June 39, 1082, .rr.cUI'e 39
da)'s oller July 17, 1082,
, ,
STATEMENT OF OBJECTION
Note
This rul. ond Rules 1917-10:!0 provide 0 .y.tem ror recon,
.Id.rollon In the court or common pt... or ord.... 011I1
d.t.rmlnaUolll or dl.tri't Ju.tlco dealing 111th ...c.tI.n mat,
tel'll,
Und.r lubdlvillon B or thlarule, Ih. stat.ment or obJ.ctlon
mu.t be m.d lIithin len do).. on.r the date Dr the q..IUoned
order or d'lermlnatlon, S.. Rule 42IC, Th. tlm. limit ror
ming 0 .tot.m.nt or objection n.ed not be the ..me 01 thut Adopted June I, 1071,
755
RULE 1016, STATEMENT OF OBJEC-
TION TO RULE 420 ORDERS AND
DETERMINATIONS
A, Any party In Interest oggrleved by on order or
detennlnatlon made by a district justice under Rule
420 moy obtain n reconsideration thereof In the court
of common pleos by filing 0 statement of objection 10
the order or detennluotlon lIith the prothonotalJ' ond
lIitb the dlatrict justice In whose ornce the order or
detennlnlltlon WlIS mode,
D. The otntement of objection shull be filed lIith
the prothonotary and the district justice lIithln ten
(10) doys uner the dute o( the order or detennlnotlon
to which objection Is mode,
icken, dismissed or
d on It sboJllennl,
orarl operates .. on
d WIIump.lt motlel'll
t jUlUce, )( the IIrlt
on or real property,
upon rec.lpt by th.
dllloned .. stat.d In
y mude In c.rtlorori
s not legaity payoble
(lee Rul," 1000 ond
rrom thos. In n.le
rmJttlng un e"I'D\\'
landlord ond tenont
uld be gOI'em.d by
25, 1070, .erecllv. In
.. oll.r July 17, 1982,
i~;
ror filing a notice or sppeol rrom 0 Judgment, See the
Judicial Code, f 55711c)(4), 42 Pa.C.s. f 557I(c)(4), WI
am.nd.d by f 10(07) er the Judiciary Act R.peol.r Act, Act
or April 28, 1078, P,L, 20:!, No, 63, It may be noted that
und.r Pu,R,C.P, Nos, 32061b) ond 3207(b) obJ.ctlons to sher-
urs d.t.rminutlons mu.t be made 1I1thin t.n duys oller the
date or malllng or th. determlnuUon.
Adopled June I, 1971, Am.nd.d April 25, 1070, .rr.ctlv. In
30 days; June 30, 1082, .er.ctlve 30 day. oller July 17, 1982.
RULE 1017. FORM AND CONTENT OF
STATEMENT OF OBJECTION
Tbe stalement o( objection, wblch sholl be on 0 fonn
whlcb sholl be prescribed by the State Court Admlnls,
Imlor, sholl merel)' state thot the party filing It
objects to the order or detennlnotlon described In tbe
statement,
Noto
This ruI. prescribes the rorm ond cont.nt or the stat.m.nt
or oh).cUon, ComplU'e Po.R.C.P, NOI. 3206(b), 32071b),
Rule 429
D1STIlICT JUSTICES
RULE 420, DETERMINATION
OF I'HOI'ERTY CLAIMS
AND DISPUTES
A. The district justice from whose offiee the nrder
of execution Issued shall hear ond determine the (nl.
lOlling motters:
(1) An oppeal mode In occordonee Ilith lIule 408C
from on oppralsol, deslgnotlon or setting aside of
property by the officer exeeutlng the order,
(2) Any objection by the defendont to the lel~' on
the ground that It Is Illegal or excessive which wos
filed In occordonce Ilith lIule 413,
(3) Clolms of third portles to the property lel'led
upon which were filed In accordance Ilith Hule 413,
(4) Exceptions to the prnposed distribution filed In
accord once Ilith Rule 41l1C, ,
ij, In acting under subdil'lslon A of this 111le, the
district justice may:
(1) Reoppralse or redeslgnote "roperty upprulsed
or deslgnoted by the executing offieer, or order Inrlu.
sian In the lel'Y of propel1y set uslde by thut officer,
(2) Stay or order the ubundoument of the IeI>' In
whole or port, or releuse property from the lel~"
(3) Stay or prohibit u sale of ull or part o( the
property levied upou,
(4) Order that propert~'lelied upon be released tn u
third port~. who hos a \'ulld elolm thereto.
(5) Stay the distribution, or ol'der u dlstrlbu!lou
different thon thot proposed hy the exeeutlng officer,
C. The district justice from whose office the order
of execution Issued muy. upon written request of ony
porty In Interest mode before ,1elll'el1' of pro"ert~. sold
purs\lont to the order und upon pl'o"er couse ShO\ll1,
set oslde the sole of thut propem' and order u resule
or enter any other order which moy be just ond
"roper under the ch'eumstances,
Nute
Subdivision. A ond 8 oC Ihis nile set Corth the I'urioos
dL"put.es concerning the execution which. nlouR' \\i1h IlrlJl~rt>.
c1olm" the dl.lrict Justice Is to heor and delennlne and whnt
he roa)' do In connection therc\\ith. The sub~(!ctlol1s DC A
and B should be cOlnpared \\ith the Pl'nn!l~'I\'nnla Hull'S or
Chit Procedure us Collows:
AIIl-See l'o.Il,C,P, Nu, 31~3(d)
A(~)-Sl'e I'll.n.C.r. Nu~. :JIHI(~1 U1ul :H~l
A(3}-Sce l'a.H.C.P. Nil:;. :11~llul(:1) lIull :I:':O:.!
A(4l-Rt'e I'n.\l.C.I', No. :1I:illlO
lI(lh~I'e l'o,1I,C.I', Nil. :1I~3(,11
nt2)-St!c I'R,n.C.p. NUll. :11 IU(~) 111111 :II:H
1Il3l-Ree l'a.Il.C.I', No. :II~I
llI.J)-See l'Il.H.C.P. ~lI", :I~Ol-a:,na
HlM-Hel' l'll.H.C,I', No~, :U:Hi null :1:!l:1
Thl. MIle doe. not l"ol'lde Cor 0 preliminary detennlnatlon
by the executing officer OK to the menta or 0 "roperty claIm
~y 0 third porty (.ee I'o.n,c.p, No,. 3200, 3207), Cor It 11'..
considered thaI the district Jo.tlce .hould ~e readily ovuJla~le
Cor till. pUJ')lOse nnd that It would not he de,lroLle to allow
I:onstnblea to make any lIuch detennlnnUon, ~o. It \\1lA
thought to he permissible to require the district Ju,tlce to
rnuke the d~temllnntlon8 and to take the acUons mentioned
In thl, rule.. on exercl,e DC JlOwer onclllal')' to his general
power to order execution or the Judgment.
Suhdilislon C oC the nile Is ho.ed on l'a.Il.C,I'. No, 3132.
Amended June 30,11'82, eCrectlve 30 dnysllflt>r July 17, 1082.
HULE 421. TIME FOR HEAHING AND
DETERMINATION; SUBPOENAS; EF.
FECTIVE DATE OF ORDERS AND DE.
TEIU\tINATION ..
A, The district justice _hull hold heurings on mal,
tel'_ to be determined by him under Hule 420 not later
lhun lil'e (5) do~'o ufter they ure filed In his office, ond
he shall notir~' ull purtles In Interest or the date Dud
time of the heurlng b~' telephone or other timely
meuns o( communlcotlon, He shall moke his detenol,
nation not luter thun three (:1) dll~'s ufter the heorlng,
II. At the time of the entry of the determlnotlon,
the district justice shall l,>ive or moll to the purtles
111itten notice of Ihe determlnutlon, If a purty hos an
ullorne~' of recurd the written notice sholl be given or
mailed to the ullorney of record Insteud of to the
port~.. Notice of the determination shull contain od.
vice us to the light of the pat,tles to lile 0 Stotement of
Objection, the !lme IIi thin which the statement must
he filed, und thut the stutementls to be filed Ilith the
court oC commou "Ieus.
C. The dlsllicl jus!lce mo~' Issue subpoenos
throughout the Commonweolth to require the ullend'
once of Ilitnesses,
n. Any Stll~' of the whole or "UI't of the execution
"mceedlngs ol'del'ed by lhe district justice sholl be
effective Immedlatell', All othel' ol'del'l! lInd detenul'
nations Ilith respecl to the whole. or "011 of the
execution "roceedlngs sholl not toke effecl until ofter
the expll'utlon of ten (10) (h,~'s from lhelr dote,
Note
Sululi\'llIlon A or this rule pro\;t!es n time scht!t1ule \\ithln
which the ltluttl'rK rnentlonl'tlln Rille ~::!o mu~t he hl!:U'd and
dotennlned. The.e '":lne" .hooltl he ,Icalt lIith exJlt'dl'
tlnu!!I)',
Rulllli\'lillllll C' 111'l1\'lde~ tllllt. eM'l'pt fur IItn)'s. Ilctcl1uln:\.
tlmu. ul\tlurdL'1'1' ur Ifill Ihstrict Justice l'Clllcl'l'nlng till' eSl'CU.
tlon prlll't'l'llll1l!lol tlhllll Ilnt tllke em'ct until ancr the l'sl'lra.
tlnn ur It'll 1111)'" fl'lllll tllt'lr tllltl.', Thl~ will "'''\'l' nn)' p~.
~rrll'\'t'd 111trl)' 111 Inll'I'l'l't II cham'l' tn llhtllln It l'11I)' h)' t1l1n~ a
Io'llltl'lIIl'lIt flf IlhJI'l'tloll III thl' court of l'ulIllllon plt'IIN dUl'n~
tllllt p"I'lud uf tlllH', l'il'l' Hull, 1111111I.
'Pull. Suit': l"flllI ur'l~'1IlIlI, I'rllhalll)' ~hilUM 11'1111 "U".
TIll' (onll 10 Ill' lIl'll'll ror till' Nutle(' 1'1'IIIlII'('JI h)' Huh' 4~1
.-hall !II' 111 /'lllh~l:iIIt1ltll,\' tilt' rnHemill/! Cunn:
7:lS
PLAINTIFF ----!
this I' to notlC)' )'ou i
Docket No. _ :
You hal'e the rl~ht to
(10) dB)'S Crom i
The Statement uC Ot!
Common Pie.. oC ...J
District Ju.tlce urnc
I
Courthou,e Add",.. i
i
Date oC Decision
i
Amended June 1. 19:
June 80, 1982, e!Tectl
27, 1992, errectll',. Ju
.. Pub, Not<!: Tho d
R.le, 200, SOl, SM. au,]
616.617, &lS, &19, t'OJ. 1,
Promuli.ting thl, Ordl
Ju,Uoe A.lOmaUon ProJ
th.~ th.reCore. th"e ~
etrecU\'t .. the DlJtrid
c. blOA, the Court .1100
referred to In the n.l.
If unUl their oMel' hllo\"
" (S.. Explonslory
"
,
, RULE ,181.
,
, All Acts of Ass
,
, lIith the execution
i'. 400 series) ore sus
:,
." slstcncy.
I,' Amended errectlve
f'.~ .rrectlve In 9D do)'s; j
." 25. 1979, errectlve In
I}
;\i RULE ,182.
,. N
f' The foUolling
,.1
,,:.' suspended or IIf~
(I:' (1) The Unlfo
'A reenacted by the A;
, Pa,C,S, A 1101 et i'
"
(2) Section (I of Ii
P,S, 112099,
This Section Ilrolid
tlons .hsll be In,lilidl
Is.ued agoln.t sllY m
\1 Judgment against thi
" whole or In port,
;';' (3) Section a:177
claries Code, ~II PI
HI
.~"
'~.. ....."'f.o-.,i )Ii;:, ~,~ "'-.',,. . ... ,- -'P~~-~--"" . '-' - - '~rfr'
. . .\~'T " '." -_._~ -----.- '.... "'''..~.",
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
JUDICIAL DISTRICT
C\Jw.~~ ~Il~
STATEMENT OF OBJECTION TO RULE 420
ORDERS AND DETERMINATIONS
OF DISTRICT JUSTICE
/ .J J 3 ~ t..u..-.....
COMMON PLEAS NO, 95 - \~
STATEMENT OF OBJECTION
1. On
3 ' L Ct, I Ci5
~,
,19
~u\,,- --p, Co~~~ ~ S~~ \<. .{)o..M
(""me 01 D,Uric, JuUictJ \
District JuSlice, In connection with execution proceedings on tho judgment rendered In the case of
.n""u~ CA~~ ysYV/l.v..\s \'\i!..~S ,Clohn Numbor TA 19 ClSS ,.l1)~de
DNlUI. CA.,)~"", cu.~\~.. ri- '"PN>t~~......,," :J;'..........OT~w/l~..~LTjI@-OOO _0-'1'1
(on order) (0 determination) concerning: .D~~\!. r'\e.:s ~ ~......, > J.. T'1't- 0000 30lt - 9 L\
~:.~
w
Chec. applicable
bo~"iJi' bOJfttl
Dan appeal taken by from an
(...)
;:J (appraisal) (designation) of property mode by the executing office,
'{Jon appool taken by from a
-
C1LIJ ..~-
..... setting aside of property by tho executing officer,
~ 0 claim to all property levied upon filed by ,~~ c:1..v~ Q,-..
~ a claim to the following property levied upon flied by~ Ca..u~
-'?JLf~ 'b~ ~ oM.~ \"'~Cfl. \~ \~ lTY--- ~
~'^"""""'" Ibrie/description of propt lyJ
I7.$] an exception to distribution filed by~a W~
o
a requost made by
to set aside the sale of
(brief description of property)
2. The (order) or (determination) referred to above was D;:S. G~~ ,~. ~r.. ~ ,^~\J~
ISriel desCflPllOn 01 order Of det'1fmin~tion) --I
-11.u> ~ po....Q,...: ~ '"'t'k ~I..rv-::. ____ +tu.. "'Oc:., ..ll!:-C.-O ft:.
I . ~
4:FCfS -10'10 ~.D;r. ~ ~ ~~~ c:& ~~c..v~ r....~...~'15
3, DCMrI..'J.... ~~ 't- PC"\l,,~ M"w::k :4:"'-.~., on oggrieyed party in Interest,
{n..me 01 oblectmgp"r,yJ \ J
objects to this (order) (determination) of the District Justice,
(This (arm must /)0 (ilod wilh tho
Prot/lollot.1ry AND 1/10 Di,,,ict Justico
W(THIN TEN (10) DA YS (rom t/lo (1,110 o(
the orrler or dotermination to which
objoctioll is marlo.!
AOPC 31..80
TO BE FILED WlTli PROTHONOTARY
,
,
,
,
. i
I'
I
I' .
"
,
.
"
I
:x
'" ...
n.... ...
~ r: .,
-n:E:;1.: _.,. -=
'''~I'I,~
-r..:n...., III
':&,- n, t... W
~ (/1),0.;; -,
~:c_~. ...
~ '.:Q;ii~ ....
,. t:"~ JC-n -",
.;I:"'~UIt" ::z:
~<'~-;~
.;.t:,. -
-". lLD
....~ "'"
<:...t:::- --t--
0\ tJ\.D
- I
~ .....
'""\
;1.
'.
,
i
i,
"
".~
.
i,
- \':.I
t~
~
~
......,
-.
;::~, .'," :!.:;"
....
j'
.,'.r
.;
,<,
NORTH MIDDLETON TOWNSHIP
CARLISLE BOROUGH
PAULA P. CORREAL
DISTRICT JUSTICE 09.2.01
EAST WING. COURTHOUSE
1 COURTHOUSE SQUARE
CARLISLE, PA 17013
Counly 01 Cumborlond
OUlco (717) 240,6564
Fax (717) 240,6566
NOVEM8ER 24, 1995
MONIES PAID TO TillS OFFICE FROM TilE DEFENDANT
11-10-94..........,;...$65.50 ORIGINAL FILING FEE
02-02-95...............$66.00 ORDER OF EXECUTION FEE
CONST A8LE. . . . . . . . . . . . . $115 .00
CLERK................. 60.00
HELP. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20.00
POSTING............... 10.00
$205.00
CONSTA8LE YORK'S EXPENSES FROM SALE:
; PETITIONER'S
I EXHIBIT
~~)
\
\
.. "!.
; >.. ~
, ,
,n; ~i tit
, "~:L\~i.:;,;tQ.'~""'~rfit'~~i1i
of ~,~h. :;. .:lr.....t..~1W..1f~,~.
;~~i~~;~fl ,,~\: }!;;~.; ;~;r~ ~;'.,~;J,i. '
\ -. . .
,hi . ~'f:
",'''~' " ,."
',t""J' 't, '~o,.r.'" "'''- . , '
J. o~~~~;:~;"'"j:',~~~/.i~~'S:
tr ~.~ ,,""-;..'t:~~~- ,.j...I,
~ ., ' .,-........--....;.....l,..
'., ".:' ~__t ~ T ....--
".;); .,......"',,.....'". ','
\,p,O' ,...1.":, >,,1., ..;.';~,,_.,'l'"'d~
'i-l,>"i'h " - ; .
I.'Jf.-':I' . - ".. -~'.'
. ".. -- .
f
\
-..
.__.
;;,
j:JU';.-;,:",_.
'T1f"}~~~(';'.'~-' .
-~~_..."
;,.j~:,~i.!iI.,J.;,. .:
.\, '~ ' ,...".' .. .
-, -.
q-
(Y)
...-i
...-i
U')
~I;,
~l'
'6~
J
01
...
'cUE
.a~
.....:.
=ci
Q.)~
r.n~
...,.0'
_M
-=-:
~.B
o
.
(:)
-
-
61)
:;;
5
o
E
,g
al
,~
B
OJ
a:
~
'C
OJ
Jg
:s
, oo~
?- \ e I
'-.I i3
"
'r 1....'.,.t:
:,~. ......:... i' :,;",,,,~~I.~I..il'. -~:..,;., '-J.
,.
..
ci
z
B
'~
.5
T,......'
,.
,.
o
C'{
iij
OJ
OJ
-'
vi
gj
C3
.~~~.. ~."lt~.;:- ..,.;,~..
, . "'"" ,,~ ,-' ,.
,tt",;t...,."..,., ,-... 't', .~',., ' .
1o..o;",\i~.'t'ti,"'''''' .1:,:.,' .t; I:, .t\"1 ~t ~ ,..\ .Jo!'" 'l...,' ~
. ~!.,..~:.j'~~'l:";:--~jll . ,'~I .l~\'l ,l..lr . ,. '1.!tO.,,,-
_W&" _____
"i~.:~,~ril.'..;;';'/~: f".!i:,' ,I ".' .;' j~ ~.
j:i~~~~~Vt~'~~" .;, "
>#_~-'-_...- --
..:,
,.,.
. .~,.
....1 ~"'_~' 04:. ~. j
.... .,..~-.,.~...~~-......,,,.,,', .....
,
~..
~
..
\
PETITIONER'S
EXHIBIT
~
LT ,,'2.1.'\
~
&
,,-......
-.--- ~.-~_."'~-'--' -. ....,. -.-...
.......
. - ",-.-
~
.
"
;
i "
-------.
----. --~, -.....
..
4750 '.
,-
..:..''';
SANDRA \.. CAUTHEN lHl3
DAVID E. CAUTHEN
.~ 134 B SmEET 243.(1939 ' lI!-I!
',: .' CIoRUSLE. PA. 17013 :', ',;2 _..It). "-:7;'flf T.f4871
~ ~=~3' . '~{ '~tfi/~~::
~~~J!!7~ /J.Ij?'. ' /~~ ~
,,~~~Bcnk ~~-dL:: .
1:031 ~3100a3l1,1: 2311111,8 ~ ~I,SIl' qq I,'i'SO ,"00000 ~ ~OO'i',"
.-
.......~-,..
.~ . '. .
, .... . ....... ......;----:-.
.,. ''''''''~ oI..L.'J .u-;..
~''''. "I\:,,,,."'~d':'-"'i:
..,(.,;._--,~,,,,,,,,,,,"';.'(;':""'" r.
."~.."'I(!ltl!l'""':':' ~~.. ",,-""'''
- ......
--------....--- ~_..,~._---
,."... .. .~".-lIt__..IU........".lUJ,;........'"
SANDRA \.. CAUTHEN lHl3
DAVID E. CAUTHEN
13. B SmEET 243.(1939
CIoRUSLE, PA. 17013
/(}?.sS
4744
d. ,3~
t7
, dt::' ~4871
1P.,L.,.t!...
I
i
I
i
.
I $ 13tX; Dt>
.At> ,..
J---~
.
'. "mJ
L2.0cP~,~
qq l,'i'l,l, tOOOO~3100001
"
.. PETITIONER'S
1 E)(.HIBIT
, [" ~",\)
., -j
," . ...~t""'r".'"' ,. -~
.,.......,. '..!
---'''''-''-''' ......"....
ASSIGNHIlN'l'
In consideration of the payment of $780.00, as well as
other good and valuable consideration, Property Management, ,Inc.
sells, assigns and transfers all of its right, title and interest
to David cauthen, in its claim against Dennis Ness, formerly of Lot
18 Spring Garden Estates, Carlisle, Pennsylvania and transfers all
rights it has obtained as a result of the judgement docketed as
ProDertv Manaaement. Inc. v. Dennis Ness; Magistrate Susan K. Day,
229 Mill street, Box 167, Mount Holly springs, Pennsylvania; Docket
ATTEST:
Said judgement being in the amount of $780.00.
, "~.GEHE"" IHe.
'-. (SEAL)
No. LT-0000309-94.
)5"4~q{
'",--
.
~ PETITIONER'S
I EXHIBIT
/... T 11\,Z,1''l5
DAVID CAUTHEN, Individually
and DAVID CAUTHEN, Assignee of
PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, INC.,
or PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, INC.,
plaintiffs
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
.
.
V.
.
.
NO. 95-1283 CIVIL TERM
IYC$S
DENNIS tmFF,
.
.
Defendant
AND NOW, this ~~
, 1995, upon review of
the attached Petition for Distribution, this Court orders and directs
the office of the District Justice Paula Correal to distribute the
funds escrowed, less expenses, in this matter to Plaintiff, David
Cauthen.
/
BY THE co~~f,. ..~
1\;/";
I
J
J.
,t' 0.1., t "1".1. u,.. Ilut'C.-, II/)J/'l~- - '\''''-
L. C \ ""w:.,,; L J\~:", "'/ ~
4
I' i, ',' '. . J ,- II ", .~ ...
J..t I ,\'t ' q; idr,~)
_11,',_ /. ,;'..' ,,;~_ ~~, ;" ;
,JdJO '1, l'
56. Hd 9S I
IZ ^ON