HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-02437
i
t
,
F
JI
1
i
,
I
C'
rt):
-:r
(b
AU SA D, INGRAM.
Plnintlll
INTI IE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
ClJMUmU.AND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
vs,
1)~.24]7 CIVIl. TlmM
ROD E, INGHAM.
Dcl'endnnt
I'IHHECTION FIWM AUUSE
ORDER
AND NOW, this
I, ..
... dny of Mny. )1)')5. lifter hl'uring, nnd careful cnnsiderntion
of the testimony ndduced. the within petition for proteclillnordCl' is DENIED.
BY TilE COUHT,
Joan ClIrey. E51IUlrc It'''h 11'1.:J! ~ S-/nJ~ r
For the Plnlntlff , u '.. 11
, /? i/-
11-
Rohert Mulderig, ESljuire
For the Defendant
:rlm
I)
~
-i2.
'"
.t
~
~_/) ~
,,1
., ~
~j 'i
., 1
,
f
Thl1 defl1llllllnt III "II,jollled fl'olll hllllllllllllll ..lid IIl.1dklllll I,he
1'181111.11'1' Illld fl'om hlll'lllllllnM Ihl' ,,1/llnllff'lI no)lltlvOII.
The def"llllllnl. III "n.Jolnod fl'om "111.01'11111 I he ,,1111111 j 1'1""
plllcp of I1l1lployml1nt .
Tho dpf'Hldlllll. III ,,"jollll.d 1'1'011I 1"'DIlIVIIIl(, dallllllllnM,
dl1Hl.roylnM 01' 11,'1111111 /lny "loPI'I'ty oWlled .Iollllly hy I.hl! "arlteu
or owned lIolply hy 1111' "Iajlll Iff.
A vlolal.lon of Ihlll llrllflr lIay Hllhj.."" 1.1... ,11'11'''/11111111, t.or I)
arreat ullder 23 I'a. C.Il. 861131 II) H "rlvate edlllllol cmll"l.lnt
under 23 1'0. C.Il. 16113.11 III) .. "horlll! of IlIdlrnct. crllllnal
"olltelll'l, IInllor 23 1'8. lloll. 86114, 1"lIIlahahln by 1II,'rhlonllenl III'
to "Ix monLhll 811d " flnn of .100.00-.1,000.001 and Iv) "Ivll
conLellpt 11/1111'1/' 23 I'll. C.H. 80114.1. lIolllllllltlon of cO-/'Il.ldence
on t.ho part. of t.ho IlIalnl.ll'f a 11I1 dofe/ulllnl, IIhall 'lOt. nlll II fy t.IJa
I'rovl"lolIH of t.he DOllrl. ordnr.
Thill Order "hull l'em81n III pffe,'t 111.1.11 11I0111 fled 01'
t.el'ml/lllt.ed hy till' C,,"/'I IIft,,1' 11011,'" 01' 1"'81'1111( lind, C'1ll be
ext.end",II",y"'1I1 thaI \.I me , if Ih" """I't flllIl.. Ihal. till' d"r"ndanl
haR commllted ..nothe/' ,,'" "I' 1111111'" 0/' h"" ""IlIlI(,'d III a "aIle/'ll "I'
"rac\.l'~e thllt 1IIlllcIII118 "lJnl.ll"ll'd ,'I"k oj' hlll'ln 10 tI,I' 1'lllltltlfr.
A 11O/lI"!nll ..hili I 10" 1",ld 1111 tlil" 11I811.., "" lh..
'/,
/'
dRY 01'
Hay, I llllfi , Ill.
.U1'1 tll ('tlU, I f'Iiom No,
, Cllml"'I'llIlId
COllnt.y Clllll'lholl"", "'"'11 Hit., 1'.. II "" Y I ""nl...
'1'1,,' plllllll!1'1' IIiIlY I"'O"'''''! 1.'11 Ii "" I l'I"~I'''YD,,'rot of r......
1""11111'111 II I'lIl't Ii"I' ",'d,,1' II 111'" t Ii" 1"'lIf Inll,
TIi., Cllmb".'I'"l1l ('1I11t11 y 1'1111" I 1'1"" 1l1',,".IIIi"1I1 11101111 Illt"OJ,,1 t,o
makp HPI'vle!' III till' "lnin"ff'H I'!'q,..."t and wllhollt pl'!'-paymelll
of f(ll"!, bill HI'I'vI,,,' may hI' necompllHllI'd IIl1d!'I' nllY Rpplle/lhle
1'lIle of Clvi I I'I'o"..d'"'...
ThlH ol'd,,,' Hb/lll hI' ,Ioek!'t!'d III the offl,,,' o!' the
I'I'o\.hollotnry Illld fOl'wlll'ded \.0 t.Ill' Hhel'l ff fOl' H(,,'vlce. The
Pl'otllOllot,nl'y I<llId I IIU\. Belld a copy of thlH Ol'del' \.n the dnfelldllll\.
by mall,
Th.. PnllllHylv/lllia H\.IlI" Pollen will he Pl'llvlded wi \.h /I
pel't,lfi"d "01')' of \.hlA Ol'del' hy I,h" pllltllt,lff'H n\.I<H'IICY. ThlH
Ol'del' ..hili I h" ..lIfolTen hy /IllY Illw ['nfoITI'mell\. Il!leney wh"re a
vlolll\.lOIl occUl'S hy III'!""H\. 1'01' Illdlrec\. ,:rimlllld eon\.omp\. wlt.houl
warl'nn\. upon pl'ohnl')" CnUHI' lhnt !,hlll Ol'der hilA been vlolaled,
whrt.IwI' 01' not 1.1,,' vtolnt,Ioll III pomndt\.ed III t.he pl'eHllllee of lhe
po II ce 0 f I' I PI' I'.
III tI... l'v",lI, 1.11111 /Ul UI'I'eA\. 1M IIInde, IIIldel' lhis
M''''\. 1011 , thl'd"f"lld/l1l1 Hhnll hp tnkl'll wlthou\. UIlneeeB8ary delay
bpf,H'l' \.he CIlIlI'\. that i HHu..d tI,,. Ill'd[,I', WI"lII t ha\. COlli'\. is
IIII/l\'/lllablo, till' ,Inf..nd/lnt Hhllll h" \./lIll'1l before the 8pPI'oprlale
dlat!'lc\. .1111.\.1<,,,, (2:1 1'.8. ~ lIll:l).
By t h.. COIIl't ,
4?'
/
/
/:/ #----
-,
,ludll"
A 11 all D. Inllrllm,
1'1 II in t. i ff'
IInd un b~hlllf of
her minot' chi 1d:
Shnnnon Marie IlIllrnm
v,
I N TilE COUIlT OF COMMON I'l.f:AS OF
CUMIIElll.AND COUNTY, PENNSYINAN I A
NIl. llfi-
CIVIl. TlmM
PIHJTECT I ON FHOM ABUSE
Ilod E. Ingl'nm,
Defend"nt.
NOTIlJE
You h"ve \",p" HIlE'd III COIlI't.. I I' YOIl wlBh t.o defend fillalns\.
the clllims Bet, for\.h ill t.he followi"ll pIIllea, YOIl mllBt. t.llke act.lon
prompt.ly aft.el' t.hls Petition, Ol'llel' find No\.lce Ill'e served, by
Ilppenring per'lOnally or by "t.t.orney lit. t.ho hl'ul'ing seheduled by
\.he COUI'\. find IH'esent.lnll t.o \.Ill' COllrt YOIII' defenBes or objec\.ions
t.o \.he claims aet. for\.h IIllulnsl YOII. YOII Ilre warned \.ha\. If YOII
fnll t.o do BO t.he COIII'I. lIIay I,,'oeeed wil.hou\. YOII, and a ,iudllmenl.
may be enl.el'~d allfilnst. you hy t.he COUI'I. wi \.houl. fur\.her notice
fnl' flny mon"y eJllimed In t.he PeU t.ion OJ' fnl' Ilny nUlel' c181m or
reliof I'oquesl.od by t.ho pluint.lff. YOII mllY 10'"'' money or
proport.y or ot.h"I' rillht.s impol't.unt. t.o YOIl.
EUB AND COBl'.Ii
If t.he caae goeH t.o heurinll und lh~ judlle Ill'unt.s 11
Prolectlon Order, u surchllrlle of $25.00 will he ulIBelised Ilgains\.
YOIl. You mny nlBo he required t.o pay Illt.orney feeB lo Legal
Services, IlIc. 1'01' t.helr 1'l!preBlHllnUon of t.ho pluintlff.
You should lake \.hili pfiper \.0 your lawyer al once. If you
do no\. have a lawyer or canna\. afford ono, go lo or lelephone lhe
offIce Bet. for\.h bolow t.o find ou\. where you can geL legal help.
COU 11'1' A DM I N I S'l'IlATOII, -It h FJ,OOH
CUMBEIlLAND COUNTY COUIl1'1I0lJSE
CAIII,ISLE, PI';NNSYLVANIA 1701:!
TELf:PIIONE NIIMBEIl: (717) 240-112()O
AM!!;ltWAtfIiJJlTlI,IH1iALlHdTH:liAIa'QYJ II Ill!
The COUI'! [) f Commoll 1'1<"IlH [J I' Climb".. I und coullt.y I B l'e'lU I I'...d
hy luw t.o comply wit.h 1I11' AmerknllH wit.h lllllnld I it.lell Acl of
IU90. For' IllfoJ'mnl.ion "hout. neer-'HRlhl,. fnet I ilif"B nnd l'eollonl1b1e
",'('onlmod"t.lllIlH IlVnlluhlll t.o dlRuhl..d indivldul1ls huvlllll hUBlneall
hefon' lh... "Olll't, (Ilensll ,'ollt ul'! 0111' off'I,'... All IIrrnnllf'mllnt.B
mUlIt. h.. mudl' 11t. \,,""1. 72 hOll/'" Pl'lol' to /lilY h"ul'lllll or hu"inellB
hnfo.." t.h.. "'0111'1. Y,," IlIU"t llt.lPlld th.. "d".oIII1..d Cllllff"l'llllel1 or
hpllI'l "Il,
limited t.o, t.he following specific InstlllwlHI of nbulw:
a. On 01' IIbout. April 25, 19115, the defendant, while
holding his t.wo-year-old dAughter, shoved the plaintiff
against a wall. When the defendant put the child down,
she went into the kit.chen, picked up a liquid detergent
bot.tle and returned t.o t.he room with it, nnd t.he
defendant grabbed t.he bottle from the child, t.hrew It.
and hit t.he plaintiff on her knee causing her knee to
swell and bruise, The defendant., while again holding
his daughter, grabbed t.he plninLlff and shoved her
t.hrough the door cnuslng her to fenr for her safet.y IInd
Ulllt. of the child.
b. In 01' nbout. April 1995, the defendant thl'entened
the plnintlff saying that he was "going to Hlit her
throat, wntch the biood go out nll over the floor, chop
her body into different pnrts, nnd bury them in
different places where no one would ever find them."
lie then threntened t.u burn t.heir I.rllller down wit.h
eve ryune I nit..
c. In or about Harch 1996, the defendant lold lhe
plalnt.lff thllt if she 1..1'1. him, Ill' wuuld hunt her down
causing her t.u fear fur her safety, As the plaintiff
was t.ul'lllng t.o walk away, allll th..II' daullhtcr was
Blanding behind t.he plalnt,lff, till' defen.lant. t.hrew II
t,el"vlsilln .....t. lit, Ill'r which Inlllicd ai, t.he plalnt.lff's
2
feet. Ilnd hl'ok",
d, Sin"" IIppl'oxlmll\.ely o"tobel' 1992, \.he defendllnt
hils on seveI'll) dlff"ront. o"cllslons pushed \.0 the floor
or ont.o Il bed Ilnd frl'4Ul'ntly thrown objl'cta at her
caUB Inl! br'u I H"S Ilnd dlllll/lll" to the Will Is lJ f \.he I I'
trallel' ,
5. Thl' plllint.1 f'f Illo\lpveH and t.herefore avers t.hat she is
in immedlllt.e and present. danller of' abuse from t.he defendan\. and
that. they arc In need of' prot.ectlon from such abuse.
6. The plaintiff desires t.hat. t.he defendant be prohibited
fl'OIll havlnll Ilny direct 01' Irllllr"..,t contac\. with \.h.. plalnt.Jff
7. The I'lalnUff d.."II'e8 that \.he d"fAndant be "nJoined
i
I
,
!
,
i
I
i
I
!
I
I
l
!
i
Includln!l, hut not 1111I1 t.ed to, tel"phone and wrl\.I.lHI
eOlllmunlcIltlon8, pxcepL 1'01' lhe limited purpose of facill\.at.Jnll
cUIlt.ody arranllemenl.ll.
frolll haralllllnll and Iltlllklnll the plainl.lff, Bnd from IlarasBlnll the
plalnLlff's relatives,
B. The pllllnl.lf't' dl'sll'e8 thlll. lhe (!I'fl'ndant he restrained
from enter'lnll hel' pill"" of' elllployment..
!l. Th,' pl.lIntlff d.,,<lI'es that 1.111' defl!ndant be enjoined
f'I'ollll'elllllvlnl!, dlllllll!!lnll, d"IlI.I'oyln!! 01' H"lllnl! Ilny pl'o!,erl.y owned
Joinl.ly by the l"lJ'l.IeH 01' own..d solely hy thl' plllin\.lff'.
Il, _ ~;lI(:I,!1.!HV~; I,(lllfi~;ll!l Hm
10, The IIplll'lment whi<'h IIII' plllint iff' III IIl1klnlol till' COIlI't.
t,o order' Ull! d..f'"ndllnl. 10 IItllr IlWIlY f.'om IH I'l'nlf'd in I,h.. nllme of
:t
t.he plnin\.iff /lnd the d...fendnnt. h/lll neVIll' 1'1'lIided th"I'I',
II. ')'Ill' def...nd/lnt hllll Is own I'esldence 10CIlt.cd Ill. COllnt.I'Y
View Eatn\."s, Lot. II, 1l10a"I'villc, Cllmbel'lllnd County,
Pennllylvllnia,
QL Al''I'QIlNta'._lIEEIl
12. The plnlnl.1ff /lalla thnt. t.h" dcf...ndllnt. be OI'dOI'",1 t.o pay
I'esaonable at.torney feell t.o I.e!!al Servicell, Inc,
WIlF.IlEFOIIE, purllusn\. t.o the pl'ovialonH of th" "PI'o\."ct.lolI
from Abllse Act." of Oct.obel' 7, 1976, 23 I',S. ~ 1llOl ~l ~l., aR
amended, the plaintiff prnys t.his 1I0nol'IIble COlIl't t.o IIrant. lhe
followin!! 1'"llef:
A. Grnnt. II 'I'empol'sl'y Ol'der 11III'Bullnl t.o t.he
"Prot.ection from Abuse Act.:"
I. Orderin!! the defendnnt lo refrnin from
nbusin!! the plnint.iff nnd plneln!! her in fear of
abUHl".
2. Orderin!! the defendnnt. t.o refrain from havln~
any direct. or Indirect. cont.nct. with t.be plalnllff
incllldin!!, hul not limited to, t.ldepholll' nnd
written l'ommunicnt.lonll, "xc"pt 1,0 facllil,atc
clllltody al'I'lIn!!em..nt.lI.
3. Orderln!! lh" d..fendnnt t.o refrain from
hal'lIl1l1l nIl /lnd lit nl kin!! t,he 1'1 II 1 nl.l 1'1' a 11I1 from
hnl'lIlIlIln!! II... plnlllt,lf'f"s ....lnt,lvell,
4. Pl'ohlhltllll! t.I... d..fendllnt 1'1'1111I l'nterlnll the
,I
"I al 11\.1 ff'H I'll\cl' of l'ml'luyml'III"
6. I'J'l)hllll\.l1l1l \.hp defl!llIlant. fr'om l'llmovlllll,
damllll 1 1111 , deHl,l'oylnll or' Hellllllll'l'Oppl't.y Jolllt.ly
owned by I he pal'\.I eH 01' owned HO I" I y by t.he
pllllllll 1'1',
6, Onlt'l'lnll the defPllllunl \.0 HlllY away fl'om t.he
pl/llnltff'fJ "pHldeIlC" localed at. \J691 Upper
SIrll8lllll'II Ilond, 1I""er 8l1'aslluI'II, ~'I'ankl In County,
PellnHy)vnnla, which till' pnrt.tes have never ahared,
excepl, \.0 facllll,nle cuslody of lhell' minor child.
7. Orderlnll the defl!ndant to alay away fro. any
l'eal,hn,,:e \.lIp plaln\.t 1'1' may In t.hp future
pstabllah for hel'self, except to facllllate
custudy of tll.. millOI' child.
R. Hche.lule fI Iwal'lnll In /lccordallce wlt.h t.he provisions of
the "1'1'011',,11011 j'l'olll AbuH" Act," alld, aftel' such hearinll, enter'
an 01'111'1' to he In effec\. for n pel'lod of on.. year:
I, or'dpl'lng tile dp.fendant. to refl'Ilin from
abuHlnll Ihe "Iaint.lff and placing her in fear of
filiusI',
2. llr,lpl'lnll tI,p d,'fl'lIdflnt 10 ....fl"nln fl'om 11I\Vlnll
IIlIY ,11.'p('1 01' 1111111"','1 coni /let with tllP. plalllt.l ff
11II'ludlllll, hulllul Ilml\.l!d \.0, !pl""holle nnd
Wl'itt'>1I "llmm.IlIit'lIllllIIH, ..x,,"pt III faclll\.ate
l."..t CHt)' tl....nullf-nu.ut H.
fi
:J. Ol'del'lnll IIIl' dl'fendant. t.o refrain from
haraBslnll nnd nt.nlklnll t.he plalnt.lff nnd from
harasslnK t.he plalnt.lff's relatives.
4. pl'ohlhlllllll I.he defendllnl. fl'om cnt.IlI'lnll I.he
pllllll\.lff's place of employmllnl..
6. Prohlhllinll \.hl' defl'ndllnl, from I'emovlnll,
dnmal!Inll, d"Rtl'oylnll 01' selling propert.y .Joinlly
owned by the pal't.l..s or owned Bolely by the
plafnll fl'.
O. Orderlnll I.he defendant 1.0 slay away from I.he
plalntlff'a reBldence located at 9691 Upper
S\.I'/.lIWUI'g Hoad, Uppel' Strasburg, Frankl In County,
Pennsylvania, which I.he parties have never shared,
except to facilitate custody of their minor child.
7. Ordering the defendant to otay away from any
reoidence the plalnllff may In the future
eBlabllah for heraI'll', except to facilitate
cuatody of t.hell' mlnol' child.
S. ordel'inll the defetllian\. t.o pay reaeonable
all.ol'ney fel'U \,0 I,ellal Sel'vlcea, Inc.
The plaintiff fUI't.her aaku that thla I'etlt.lon be filed and
served wlt.hout, payment. of fl'l!a IInd CORI,H by the plaln\.lff,
pendlnll a further order at \.11<' he II !'I nil , 8mi \.hllt, 8 cert.lfled copy
of thla Petit Inn IInd 01"1<,,, he del lV"I'ed to the I'''nnaylvania State
II
,"I
, "
I,
.
,
, "
1 InN ,l!jYwl (\; I iJ 1 II I I';!.
f lHH~ ry ill 111"if'l hi I\tj:
'/':1
n
! III ,hAI1 AI 'i,
J tjl d\f,:"1 Ill:j
"'i'"r'
"I,. I ). t t
"-'11 r t '>1
flj l!
"
t., 'It
( '1111'1' h! ^ Ii:
! 'dill.:" )0' I;; I,.," I,',; 1'1 J ','
w, I II
!If)
11'1":.
II,
'.W,
j',"
fhi' !i"
"..., t hi- ). i I t; j if
I h( ,I f '
I' ,II I, "I'~l Ill""
HJ" 'II
t tJI.. Ii ,\11 I,," I
I tit
dt, t ('II i,Hjt " "1' Ii, I, " 1.1 ! !')'!' l'! "
1 '),'.)r., ;1' 1I11i L hi /.,rnJ (I, iii 1-, I I I I i ,iii , , h ifl ill' ",iIA!d-
" AI,I ] ! I I t ,', 1 "Iil'l 1'1 AlII
, .IJllf , Illl; " I '.'.11; I " II, . I r,'l hl'l' ! !I, ,f1/\l1
',' t , '.. ;IFI I ;It t " t , 'I , I I , !; II I I,' ,n ,\f'
t,I.'IJf' , 11)'1 " I . 'I Tl !1! , Ih/.. h " : I JI 't. 'h [, hi III I ~ I' All: I I I ! , Il
f 1)1, I ,..! 'II " I"'" , I,; ! "
, .
'ill' i ;tt , 1ft 'II"I' t I rH' , I , . I /,'J ,; .' , ;,1 ; , !. , 1 ~ t I t I ~" I . I' f
'.tl'
\ t f'
W,! '~.,,:,
r.w' (.,',:
. .
~ . . .
.',,' ."
,I ":-.ol..:'.'~
'I
---t" I r r
;-,1
11
<~'
/
,., r, ,,-..~
_ ' ~. i.~ '. \ '
t,f 11'1
'I) h
,":.'
';1.'
1'''','
I; ')I'
r
i'l.
1': I!,' ,
I;'
, ,
?(l(~i 1 ~l}}l~f~~, ff
W 1 , ill,l 'd, 'I I ! ;
! I' I fL' !:: '. t\' ~lIlh,/
! , (i( (..
~'lA--
c
,
1t~tL.- l. /J.'pf; -