HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-02847
\
d
c,s
11
.
;#
",
)
/
"
?
(
~
J
.
f.'
:t-
()ol
rtS l
.
,
DEI'ARTMENT OF TRANSPOItTATION,
I! COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,
I' Appellee
II
I v.
II HOWARD BELL,
II
II
I,
I
"
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERI..AND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO, 05- 28 Lf 7 CIVIL TERM
APPEAL FROM LICENSE SUSPENSION
Appellanl
ORDER OF COURT
/' tit
AND NOW, 1I11s ~ dRy of U It N ~ _ . 1005, upon presenlalion Md conslderallon of lhe
wilhln Pelllion for Appeal from License Susl'enslon, a de novo heMing is sel for lhe ,}f" (I) dRy of _
IlJu I '/ , 1005 al ,~ . ),/ Jo'clock / ~M, in Courl Hoom No.1 of lhe Cumberland CoUllly
I
Courlhouse, Carlisle, PennsylvMiR,
Furlher, lhe molor vehicle license suspension In lhls case Is stayed pending lhlB appeal hearing,
BY THE COURT:
(\kUcU . ,\f~~_
I \
II') \ t. \
(y I) I I \ " ( ~I, (, ~ 0
('( IL ) I'
-' Ill.
I
m;I'^lIl'M~;N'I' nt' '1'ltANHI'OIl'I'A'I'ION,
COMMONW~;^I:I'II tn' 1'~;NNHYI.v^NI^,
Ap,..lIrn
IN 'I'm: coli 11'1' tW COMMON I'U;Afl
cllMln:IlI.ANIl COIINTY, 1'~:NNSYI.v^NIA
v,
NO, U~,
CIVil. n:IIM
1I0WAIU) IIKI.I.,
AI'I'~;AI, mOM J.Il$NH~: HUfil'ENBION
Apl..llanl
..
i;
I
I
II
I'K1'11'IUN JlUlI AI'I'KAI.
fROM I.ICI':NHI': HUHI't:NHION
AND NOW, romea AplK'llnnl, lIownrd IIrll, hy /I.ullhrOllllh hll nUorney, Robert J, MulderJa,
!i
Ii EI,tulre, /lnd OIel tho folluwlnlll'etlllun:
Ii
Ii
Ii
I
[i Shlppen1burll, Cumherlluul Cuullly, I'rllnlylv/lnIA 17~~7,
I,
II
II
II
I'
,I
:i Departmellt uf'I'r/lIlII..rlallun .Ihl rl'<'lIl1lhn Apl..llAlIl'I.lrlvhlll prlvllell"1 for IlIllndefinlte period,
L
"
'I
II
Ii WII~:II~:~'Oln:, fur Rlllhr /l1.,vl' rrnlulIl, the ApprllAllt,llowlII'd lIell, by IlIld throllflh hIa allomey.
"
Ii llobert J, Mulllerlll, ~:"Iulre, rellun.'" fur IIUllor/lhle Cuurlto lei a lime for hearing In the propriety of
I'
ii
Ii AppellAlIl'llIrenlt' rl'<'/l1I RI\II, I\lrthrr, Itay Ihe hnlK'.UlolI oflhllllcen"" rccall pendlna IIIld hearing IlIld.
I.
Ii aner enld he/lrlnll, rever.e tho r"'III1II1'rl""furo pr..vluu.1y lunml,
!I 1I1'.p..l'lflllly .nhmlllo,l,
Ii
I'
:1
,
"
"
I
! J)RI~
1.
AppellAlIl I. I h,wlII',1 11011, nil /ldull hullvldunl currently relldlna at 180 But KIna Street,
2,
Oil MIll"" AI, IllU~, Iho AplJe11lu11 luffered /I poulble eellure dIaorder,
8,
~'ullowlnlllhl. IlIl'Idont, meclil'a1 relK.rtl were lubmllled to Appellee,
0,
lIy Irller IIf April ~II, IllU~, /I ('ol'y of whll'h II IItUlrhed IlIld a made part hereto, the
7.
'I'he AplK'lIanl w"" lI11tllivell all III'IK.rllllllty 10 .how Ihat he II not Incompetent to drive,
I.AW tWflt:~:H tW liON TUllO
,/
. i.," ,
~ .:.....:...----.--
.
( " "i" J
I " .
'I 't.- " --'''''
,,t;'/; ~ l'-J..i.. "//"
Ill,l..rl ,r~uttrrlll, ~:.'lulrd
:12 Huuth n..dfurd Htreel
Cllrll.lo, I'A 170tA
17171 :l4~'\lOHH
Allumey fur Appelhmt
.,
:i
Mill..j.... ,; "
il i II t il t f I d:.
t r, II
I " . . 1 .": ~
i. .
j;,
COHMONWIALTH OF PINNIVLVANIA
UtPANlHINT UF TRANIPORTATION
Iur.lu U, DrSv.r LS~.n.1n.
Hlrrilburg, PA 1712.
APRIL 26, 19911
HOWARP THO"A5 WLLL
UU t kINIi liT
SHIPP[NSIUR' PA ~?~~1
'.~U'~i~1D~L!!L DOL
Dll/l'IL"S
llo3100U5
Ul/ililL'lf~
U..r Motu, SIt I
",dae.l rluu,~, lu..atlld lu lh. U'Plrl..nt 1ndi~.t.
lh.l ~uu h.y. I ..diu.l cond'tivn which a. nat caIP.tibl.
with thl 1"1 ap.rltion vt . .otor v.hlol..
Vour drivin. priyil.... II" h.r.bv
IIUltutorv lY,d.nu il "r"lnlld ..
coI".hnev .. luthu,.iud hl/ ..oUon IIIl9c
Cod..
r.celhd untH
to p,.au' 0'
at the Vlhld.
In 01'.'1' to 001.1" with thi. ..netion I/au .,.. r.quirld
to ,..turn IIIV curr.nt dr'v.r'. lic.n.., hltner'. ".rIU
enll/lr "IDlrerl/ driur'. Ho.n.. (01.11'1 olrdl In I/Our
DD.....lon no lit.,. thin the Ifl.ctivI dlt. la.l.d. If l/ou
elnnot coIPh wUh the r...\,j',....nh .hlld .bovl, I/UU .,..
r..ulr.. to .ubllt I nLI6LC '01" Dr I lltt.,. eckn.wl...ln,
thl 'Inaliun of "eul' ~raYin, prlvil.... Flilu,.. to ao.pll/
with thll nDtlel Ihell r.lult in thS. lu,..IU r.flr,.1n, thJI
.eth,. to thl Plnn'l/lunSI Ut.te Polic. fur prol.cullon
und.r ,acTION 111111)(4) .t lht Vlhicl. tod..
IfIknIWhll::::nt ~hi t ~"'ila"~,:~t.I/::C:lr".'e'l-i:r.aif~~::~n:i'--"- _.
r,e,lv' thl. r.e.ipt wlthln II dl,,1 contlet the d.pI,.t..nt
I...dlltllv. Dth'twi'l, "ou II" not b. ,Iy.n .,..dit towerd
Ilrvin. lhil 'Inclivn,
.......
MAr'IH~ IF I',: 1/.1 SHlffEIIW.If:j I.IIIIV - fi':
fAX 11(1. 717:,304009
1. 3
9!i10"111D'liIU
Thl' decl.lon h.. been m.d, bV compe~Sng you~ medical
condition with the shnduds recoMmended bv our M,dical
Advhorv Bo.rd and adopted by thh Dapartm,nt. If your
condition I'P~OV'I, your phvalcl.n ahould lubmit . new
phV.ic.l ,xa.in.tion report fDr reevaluetion. If yoU h.ve
. I.ilure dSsordar yOU mUlt remlin .eilu~e free for . six
.onth period, with Dr without .'dication, before vou will
be ,ligible for reinatat.ent Df your driving privilege.
You h.ve the right to .ppe.l tD the Court Df Co.mon
,....---- ----P 1_.._--0# ..th...-C4ul1u/' a f I/our rui lI,nee. wi.tH.!L ,thjr.ll'_<.~,D_!..
d.V' of the .al1 d.te af thl1 notice. If vau .pp..l, your
11cenll will be rein.tatad pending a fin.1 deci.lon by thl
Court.
Effectiva D.ta of BUIPln.lon. 08/11/1"S, la.Dl ....
Slncerelv,
,.-.:..
:::0 ,J , 4ft' -r::::i' I _
-- ~-
DDU,l'l K. TDb!n, Dir'ctD~
Bur,aU of Driver Llcanling
ADDRt.S CORRESPONDENCE TOI
Dap.rtment Df fran.port.tlon
.ur..u of Driver Lic.nling
P.O. lox una
H.rrS.burg, PA 11106-8682
IN'ORMATION (7100 AM to ,.10 PM)
Pittsburgh Are. ~ 4IZ-!'I~.'70
phil.delphi. Ar.. - 211-"8~'IOO
Herrleburg Are. - 717~787~IIIO
Toll Fre. 1- 'OO~"2-4'OD
.. .-_..._. -- . - --- .-,...-.
;.
m;PAIlTM.;NT OF TIlANSPOIlTATION,
COMMONWEALTII OF P.;NNSYLVANIA,
Appellee
IN TilE COUIlT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBEJU.AND COUNTY, PENNSYINANIA
v,
NO,95.2847 ctVIL TEnM
IIOWAHD BELL,
APPEAL mOM LICENSE SUSPENSION
Appellant
MOTION ""Oil eONTINUANCE
AND NOW, comes the Appellant, lIowRI'd Bell, by IU1d through his aUorney, Robert J,
Mulderlg, Esquire IU1d makes a Mallon ror Conllnuance, staling:
1. On June 5, 1905, thlsllonorable Court set a hearing In the above captioned case ror July
26, 1094 at 2:30 P,M, In Courtroom II't.
2, Counsel ror Appellant hl\.8 been negotlallng 0 setllement or the Issues raised in this ClIlIe I
with Matthew X, lIaeckler, Esquire, counsel ror Appellee,
8, Counsel ror Appellant request thot the case be conllnued until after October 10, 1095 to
complete the negotiations,
4, Counsel ror Appellee concurs in the requested continuance,
WIIElmFORE, the Awellnnt respectrully requests this lIonorable Court to conllnue the above-
cnplloned cl\.8e unlU nner October 10, t995,
Ilespectlully submitted,
LAW on "ICES OF 1l0N TUllO
~;/7J
Dote '
Iderlg, Esquire
32 South edrord Street
Cnrllsle, PA t7013
(717) 245,0688
Altorney ror Appellant
.
.
""-'-".."
_,uO""._
...-.'ft5/f
-,""'ii:
"".," "I:
':~> ~_-?~~{~f~~~i?~t
"';;:
I~ ~~- ," "j~!3:~~,;"",','{~\0;~~(.~_~::11'-
;,~jE:;;'~;~~~~L\:~::;;i~:~tt~~,~~,
~_ .. '-.,..;." , '7';;:10
',;
...-..-.-.,.,.....-'.-
.. -,:~:~~:<.._;~.
;:<~{;~i-,.
{;~~
- - -.,.~~~ r _~-- - - ~ ~ _ __
,"
m;PAIlTMgNT m' '1'llANSPOIlTATION, IN TilE counT m' COMMON I'LEAB
COMMONWEALTII OF I'ENNSYLVANIA, CllMIlEIU.ANO COUN'/'Y, PENNflYINANIA
Al'I'eUee
v, NO, U5.2847 CIVIL TEIW
1I0WAIlU DEI.L, : AI'I'.:AI. FIlOM LICENSE SUSPENSION
Appellanl
ORDEll 0.... COVllT
ANO NOW, Ihts It, "'t::Ildny of () e...iAbFlt_
, tOO5, In accordance wllh
Appellant '. Motion for Continuance, ill. hereby ordered t1Ult the hearllli IICheduled for the above case,
ls continued unUlthe,J,lr t:A day of..br~ .rnhElt..... , tOO5 at ~ o'clockt!...M,
BY TII E COUnT:
;1 L l/ 1.( I ,JX ,
I b.
J,
DEPAlI1'MEN1' m'1'RANBpOIITA1'ION,
COMMONWEA!,1'H OF I'ENNBYLVANIA.
Appellee
IN 1'IlE COUII1' m' COMMON PLEAS
CUMBEIlLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v,
NO, 05,2847 CIVIL TEIIM
1l0WAllD BELL,
A1'I'EAJ.. mOM LICENSE SUSPENSION
Appellant
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I cerllfy that I served a copy of the Mollon for ConlinUROce by depositing 8IlIIle In the United
States Mall, Orst clllos, postage prepaid from CarUsle, Pennsylv8l1iR, on the 16th day of October, 1005,
addre88ed as follows:
George KabU8k, E8qulre
A88istant Coun8el, Motor Vehicle Seclloll
Office of Chief CouII8el
Department of Tr8l18portallon
Commonwealth of Pe/lllsylv8II1a
103 Tr8ll8portallon & Safety Building
Harri8burg, pA 17120
,,'1 'l.lJt/'
.,{.~{l., ./~;t;:I(~,
, Robert J, Mulderig, E8qulrel..-
:!-=
(".-~
, I)
"'....
\)0 ..J\
1;- -J
...
........
Q
"
'i:
'1
4
'r
tR
-
r-
N
c "
0-
0,'
=
/lEI'AIlTMENT O~' TRANSI'OIl'I'A'rJON,
COMMONW~;ALTII OF I'f;NNSYLVANIA,
Appellee
IN Tim COUIlT Of' COMMON PLEAS
CUMm;IlLAND COUNTY,I'ENNSYLVANIA
v,
NO, 95,2847 CIVIL TEIlM
1I0WAIID BELL,
Appellant
APPEAL FROM LICENSE SUSPENSION
MOTION FOil CONTINUANCE
AND NOW. comes the Appellant, lIownrd Bell, by and through his attorney, Robert J,
Mulderig, Esquire and makes a Motion for Continuance, stating:
1. On July 25, 1095, this Honorable Court set a hearing In the above captioned case for
October 18, 1005 at 8:30 A,M, in Courtroom... 1.
2, Counsel for Appellant has been negotllltlng a settlement of the Issues raised In this case
with George Kabusk, Esquire, counset for Appellee, Necessary for the resolution of tills case is a report
li'olll Appellant's doctor, Appellant has nn appointment with his doctor scheduled for October 24, 1995,
3, COImsel for Appellnnt request that the case be continu~d until aIler November 30, 1995
to obtain nnd process Ihe medlcal report,
4, COUllsel for Appellee concurs In the requested continuance.
WIIEREf'ORE, the Appellant respectfully requests this Honorable Court to continue the above.
captioned C88e until aIler November 30, 1095,
IlespectfuJly submitted,
LAW OFFICES Of' RON TUllO
c-:)
"
-,
l. , "j "
."~ to: I.)
Dale
., ., -'.
" .' J ' I
. . -, {J .- (. / .,"'. '"
o,,"!f1u' f'dd'dt~
!lobert J. Mulde'rlg, Esquire'"
32 South lJedford Street
Carlisle, I'A 17013
(717) 245.9688
Altonley for Appellant
(. '
'"
,
LI'
Lll
[)J~I'AIl1'MENT m' 1'HAN8I'OIl'I'ATION,
COMMONWEALTH OF I'ENN8YI..VANIA,
Appellee
IN Tim COUIlT OF COMMON I'I,EAB
CUMm:IU..AND COUNTY, PENNSYI..VANIA
v,
NO, 05,2847 CIVlL TERM
HOWARD BELL,
APPEAL FROM LICENSE SUSPENSION
Appellant
CEIlTIFICATE OF SEIlVlCE
I certify that I served n copy of the Motion for Continuance by deposltlng BIIIl1e In the United
States Mall, first class, postnge prepald from Carlisle, Pennsylvnnln, on the 10th day of October, 1095,
addressed as follows:
George Kabusk, Esquire
ABslstant Counsel, Motor Vehicle Section
Office of Chief Counsel
Department of Transportation
Commonwealth of l'elUlsylvnnla
103 Transportation & Safety Buildlng
Harrisburg, PA 17120
, .' -' .1 ' ~ ./J/ .
j !J' l ".,,.'
~ .-{/6,r ../ft/d{t:;::(':~'
Robert J, Mulderlg, Esqulre'-
IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMIlERI.AND COUNT\', PENNS\'LV ANIA
COMMONWEALTlI OF l'ENNSnVANIA
DEI'ARTMENT OF TRANSPOlnATION
V.
NO. 95-2847 CIVIL TERM
I(OW ARI> BELL
l.ICENSE SUSPENSION AI'I'EAL
OIun:1t
ANI> NOW, this ,_'L!!.,~. day of .Lt'-.L.Ll.iJ.L"_...._, 1995, upon representations of
George II. Kabusk. Esquire, Assistant Counsel fllr the Department of Transp0l1ation, thatlhe
Departmenl received a Ieport liolll Mr Bell'~ physician and the physician's report Is adequate
medical documentation 10 rescind the l1ledicalleclllI ofMr Bell's opemting privilege fhr a
medical condition pursuant to Seclion 1519 (c) of the Vehicle Code, the appeal in the above-
referenced matter is (tEMANUEU to the Uepal1mentto updale its records and to RESCIND the
recall, which is the basis of this appeal
UY TilE ('OlJIn
J.LJLYC
...-~-->..-
J
Distribution
OeOllle II KllhllSk, hquile, 101 Tralapoltation /(; Safely Buildin!!, Illlllisburl!, PA 17120
t\<t/-i" ,1."t1d;((
Itobelt J Muldetil!, Esquire, 32 Soulh Uedfold Stleel, Calliile, I'A 17UI3 I '/1/~ I
.\ .,'