HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-02994
b
==e
u
.
0/)
"7
J
~
J
~I
I
0-1
,
0-1
~I
,
I
I
C$ltTlIIIC'ATE Oil SEIt\'IC'E
AND NOW, this 17th day llfNovemher,I1)l)7, I,IRA 11. WEINSTOCK,
Esquire, allomey for the Plaintiff, herehy ccrtify tlmt 1 servcd the within 1'ltAECl\'E this day
by deposiling the slime in the Uniled Sllltes mail, postage prepaid, in the posl oniee al
Ilurrishurg, Pennsylvania. 1Illdressed to:
By First Class Mail:
Jumes G. Nealon, III, Esquire
NEALON & GOVER
301 Market Street, l)lh Floor
1'. O. Box 865
Harrisburg, I' A 17108
By:
\.0l(,-I~ . LL((( j, 1'/1"'/-
IRA H. WEINSTOCK
'- ......
. 0-
,
".:_,;.,,:."
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA.
NO.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
EARL L. CRUM,
plaintiff,
VB.
GREGORY FIEDLER and MICHAEL
LEE BREWBAKER,
Defendants.
,~" . Lot 0iD
.M.
tv
J'~tt I '1'D
J[P~ -
)~..,,~ ~I
llH;""OiJ ~i~" .1!\-<II'~._ (.
A.f"WQ" ~ 'Q
:lUll I',
PRABCIPB
. S6. "d t~ Z \ Hflf
LAW OMCII
IRA H. WEINSTOCK, P.C.
5U111OO
800 N, SICONO 51N1T
HMMIlJIl(l. I'ElMnVANIA 11102
i~
TU1PHONL (7m.23&l651
...
EARL L. CRUM,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA.
Plaintiff,
vs.
.' ,
'I I
No.
)Iftl/,
I t I," (
)/, I I',,,.
GREGORY FIEDLER and MICHAEL
LEE BREWBAKER,
Defendants.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
PRAECIPE
TO THE PROTHONOTARY I
Please issue a writ of summons against the above
Defendants and ask the Sheriff to serve the Defendants at the
following addresses I
Gregory Fiedler
117 Whittier Lane
Lancaster, PA 17602
Michael Lee Brewbaker
6 East Beale Avenue
Enola, PA 17025
Respectfully Submitted,
IRA H. WEINSTOCK, P.C.
800 North Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17102
Phone I 717-238-1657
BYI . , II; \ \ , ,,(.
I~A H. WEINSTOCK
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
County of Cumberland
Et1rl L. Crul11
Courl or COInmon Pleas
\'1.
No. ___,___~_~:,?~,'!L~J.YH__.u____u IL..
[n ..n_._ _.<:.i_,:,.i.~__~~_t:..!.?l!. _:.:~'!~.__mm_
G~ego~y Fiudler t1nd
117 Whittie~ Lone
Lt1nct1ste~ PA 17602
Micht1el Lee Brewbt1ker
6 E. Bet1te Avenue
Enolt1 PA 17025
To _____ _Gul!lQU'__J':il~<JJ_t;;L_,m<J,-~J.cll<ltd L,,,, Bn,wbt1k,,~ I
You af' h...by notified that
Earl I.. Crul11
..__...._-_._...---------~-_._------------------_._-----------------------------------------------
the Plaintiff
S .. Rummons - civi tAction - Lt1w
ha. rommenced an acllon III u______._________u______________h______n____._______...
againll you whirh you are re1luir.d 10 defrnd or a del.ull judgment may be entered againll you
(SEAL)
Dale
.hlll" I,
-------.....--..-------..---------
f)~
19..__
LAWIlENCI.: E. WELKEIl
h., ,. --. -.. -.., - .-, P~ih~7~}.'.'.": - __Om --.
lIy ___.__jIl.~_. IL_:_:.lJ.1I.J.!U'_Y._..._
l5;puly r ,
(
I\~,i.
~",.,..
No. __~.?.:3.~?_4....!=.!~_!!_.._- 19___
-----..-----------------------------
Earl L. Crum
...
Gregory Fiedler and
Michael Lee Brewbaker
------------------------------------
Sa."'....... in
Civil Action - LaW
---------~--------------------------
Ir6 H. Meinst:ock, P.C.
800 N. BeconI St.
IlarrisWrg PA 17102
(717) 238-1657
-----------.-.----------------------
Allomey
t'
......
, '"'~..'.,_o
,
.'--- _____,......L..I
,.,:,,-~.-- u:;,.-.....-r_~. t..-_~-.::~t'::,]
!
'l
CALDWELL & KEARNS
Ii PRaHI.IONAI.. CORPOMATION
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
-
31831 NORTH FRONT STREET
HARRISBURG, PENNSYLVANIA 17110
I "'/\1
1\\1..1 .U
l\ iYI f\\ 'S~
. . t il~ ~
, I',." 1 f~)
,.', \ i ~ (
.,'1
-,',"
,_,'~-(""'./ . P/fi
1.... ~.;..~....~.;"I!;...t"J... f ~--
" ~_ J C
. '1'i.~'ll
P-Up
I~ r1
")
\.-l\.~"''''-'
II)'
\"jT'-' (" )Il'll~_ ,0f'1'
f.1~
, ,
'!,.
.,
J.
~.
,:.....
....t'
/
1lot.!.-
'--)/_- _.
lj'l'
--~ 'I L_'
(~.
')h.. UL_ Aj:f':'{
. " 1
SHERIFF!S OFFICE
!Jt)NonlltDlJKl ~~IIH.E' I^Nt:Milll~ IJl:Nfl~i,(IV^Nt^ l/hU;)'lll/)~I!lUH;llIU
...~
ItH;1I1UC1l0Nfi 'Oil U[llVlCr or rnocESS on Ih, IIV".. 01 1M taa' tNo
!,J UII'~ (., Ihl' Inun "I(l;UO typn or IlflnllttVil.lly ~)U llOt dollKh .n~.~~s
).\ {1l\llIl r~IJMllIll
!,
!
i
95-2994
\,PI (lI Willi UH COMl'j AINT
SUMMONS
;g
~
~
SHERIFF SERVICE
PROCESS RECEIPT, and AFFIDAVIT OF RETURN
i",)i-AIN1Irr.s
EARL L CRUM
:\ fWfl Nll^t~' S
GREGORY FIEDLER AND MICIlAEL LEE BREWBAKER
SERVE
.
AT
I, flAMI {ll ltJ!llVIIIlJAI I \Jt,1I'AN) \-I)lil'tlllAlll HI il!
It JIll ~,I HVI II
{
GREGORY FIEDLER
" "'HIIH ~;'~ \',j'I','1 PI 11111 AI',lItll','''1 rjot (,I, 11,",) 1 ,'d'
'.,l,tlp .1'''1 /11' 1",\1 I
....
00
117 WlIl1'rIER LANE, LANCAS'rER PA 17602
INlllt:AIl IINlt',IJAI ~,l IIVll I
t.l \t.\t.lllrj 111 I'^
1111'1111.'1
l,lH11I
Now,
I. SHLlllf I' or LANCM;l Ell COUNt Y I'A 110 I"""by t1uplIlilU Iho Shollll of
Cuunty to m:t~ClJtn t1mi Wilt ilnd 11H11o.0 lohJlIl lhmoolnccordlllg
to law ThiS deputatlull hnlllU mild!! ;11 II III IPqlJf!st allllnslo. 01 ttll! plillllllll
8. 8PECIAlINSTRUCTlONS Oil Dunn 1t4F0r1MATION THAT Will ASSIST IN EXPEDITING SERVICE:
1H
,,!"II" M,./.'.''''"'
;';"
NOlE ONLY APPLICABLE ON WRIT OF EXECUTION N B WAIVER OF WATCHMAN An't dPI'ut'l '.III'IIt! lI'II,!'III\! upOIl 01 atlildllllY any pmpelly undo'
Wlllllll 10'<111 tllilV luave !;iltlll! w,!lIIlI)1 i1Y,illr!1I1IiHl ,n !w,llhl\' .,t 1'to1,.;IIII,\,'1 ,~, 1,,,,pilll1 110',',1",""111 .,111'1 Jl'll"rIIHj f'lll!>Ol1ul h'vy Of ,1Hill-.lunpnl wltI'{H11 ha!lllilv un
tile jJlHt 01 fiuch llHIIl/ty (H tile Slll'111I ,,] ill\, 1:I,II!lllt! Ill'It',11 !Lll ,ii'\, III',~ '1l,~,\IIH'lltl!1 "I 1"11111\.111.1 ;111\, ~lill]lnl'I,p,t)'I)f'hlJt! !>hf'rllrs bdll~ \t1l1rllll!
-,fsioNATURE';l,'AnORNEY III ul!'l'! ORIGINAl OR
CUMERLAND CO SHERIFF PAID ADVANCE COSTS
12. SEND NOTICE OF SERYICE COPY TO NAME ANI! ADDRESS UElOW
IRA II WEINSTOCK, PC
SOON SECOND ST.,.HARRISBURG, PA 17102 --- --.
SPACE BELOW FOR USE OF SHERIFF ONLY - 00 NOT WRITE BELOW THIS LINE
-.. .. NAME 0,1'" ,n",",,'''llCSD Ih'("i'~ 0' \ I..'. . '111.1 (1;(11' i{';(f',wd . - -'\ Jlr)U-iL';'ii;~mtj-(~I~'-I-jf;n'II;;iidjjl8"
1.1 I ilC!<.P()WI..ldyl' fl;i'I'II:t i,l lllr: ",.,t}
It; ':',:,::':,:I,:"~~~~:~~'::::::I~~;:'"N ,',,' ,~~~~~~~:~}l~~ ,,,,,' ",""'", \!,,,~,:~-97,,,,, 1,."",It,,, ,,, "''''.,,~,, 1995
Hjlf";HI.S th' '\'" I' """l,LI"'1 Jh,~,"h'( ,," I!,l' .p.h,"j'I' ....1.,1". '1.,".11"." "r, ,01 P,. .I,LI" '.t".."", ;I[,."f' ;'" lill tt'l' lI11j'~."IIl.11 IdmpilOY nl!
11!!!iltaJtl f'II. dj Ill!' .I,jd'.':,', "",'II\',II,<,i",\ 1 \ 1',1"'\""1,1 TRUE and ATTEstED COPY lI1f!reol
\10 lLII."ln)t~l: NUMREH
I
I 238-1657
lThl' fuoa mUll 'lit compleled It nollce II 10 be mAiled}
l1i--bATE
JUNE 1 1995
II I hl"i'jl~' '1"tJ~ ;\I';! 'l.h"p., NOT rOUND I" "",1,1.1'" .",,!!.'f' I,
\.;J,~;'~'~:>~''''''5.'22:;;;7'''l;;,;;:\';;;;;~~' hA.l (l,{~~:Jl:
'" ~:~;i::',~~,;''z:''.'i:::I;::/7~4)j~1lf'';4'~''~~'''' A,,'",1<1' '" ","
, 0I#?~t! ./.-.;<, /t:... ,/ 7f ~ "/
: "'O~ ; Mil'" .: nep Inl Dall! Mill!.' Dell 1111 nnlf!
~/'7 ! /,;/,#(..
=''' Advijl>O f' [',',<..1" ' : i ;", '..0 t. j , .'1: II 1.<', I ,..,
",'I!",,",'I'.":I',d'
I..j"\
"'I.o.Ul,.', d
p,\'n,,,1 ,II"".!, (~;l'" Il'malk!'. 111'101'.'1
i''l
^ I""""'''' .""I.ll:'l! ,l(j!' 11','1 <.1,.,011"><'"
I",,,, "',,.H"J ," 11,t' d.,I,,,,,!'!"f ~ 1)",,11
1""0' ',1 'll~"h'
1',\1;
1;'1 'O,!ll' ot S~>r','~c~i; ';,? 1l1ne' --~-
!&-7"9,C //tJ,r
Mil.. \ Dop.lnl 10"0 _ Mlf..
1 211 1 ulill Cll'its 129 Cj'1' DUE 0 REFUND
I 3V''/DuWS!
(' ,k flj1o/ D
~/9/9 ,--
AM
--
-
[OST
f.~R,~?,~,", 100.00
30.50
Miles Oep 1111 i
i
!,It,'',I'lf.j'','ld'j!.til
3,&/0
DAle
~':l ATTEMPtS
0.,1 ^
, #
11#' ;..IV
I"J
_/ I'
cr,./-;"..i:.-I,H^,~ /f"....f/~rAl{'"'(".
11 Afl lHUII) <1;'1,,,1 ,'1'''11; :."
" 'I
j'
/ J ~ANSWER
~,~Nr"l" /<. ,,,,,,,.~r J-:(
'~"'.., .b'~-L
"1 """ . t /f r1:~ , .""'.-
.'........ '--)"..." .,.C',. .
BUEIUFF OF lANCASTER COUNTY
i.1 H, ..1
10<(<
7'~",. ~ -- .. .
" .'
j i.;..(4~;:; "..(
, IrJ;
1,1'. I 1;1,11,-1,', li ,I, I .oj '1'1 .
III I AI I' I j; '~''il t 1 .( d 1'1 I j ;j I . 'I ' 'I hUt IUf f Sill.' \Jilt. f;Hit~A' 1m.
I il hi II Hi 'I!'."I) 1 . l'llj'. I'd. tlli .;,.1 , i,f,l, 'O!II
..t'/
, .
.1'1 '
ll~ iJMt~:_H~t::~___
,I
,1,;
l~ Tn:J Court ci C.::mmc;-\ r-L=:::s or C:J:..;.:~;t';:::nd (;,::1.::-;.:/, P-anr:sylvc:r:i::
Earl L. CrulI1
'is.
Gregory Fled ler
:-fo.
IJ r, - ;") C) 4 C i v i J Tc 1'llI
...---..--.----, .....--.
:-iow,
.Julle 2
:922- !, S:~?..::::;' O? C:'~G::::?..!..A.'ID COt.~:-? ?A~ co
h~by ci:j:UC:::: th:: 5~E oi
LilnCi.18 tc r
Cuu:r; :., :"":::".lr.:: :.:.is '.v:i;
:.:.:s d.:;:u::cu :ili1t _~.J_ 1t ~ :-:qu=t :.:d :-:.u oi :.:.: ?!.ili:d.
--"I'?L, ,_.'-
::r qt.:, ,. " ,
I
~ -,
.I ~,
.,~.(-:~,,~....
SDe..-..:! o( Co=:e.r..u:ci C.nJ.:t'T. ?~
.4 fndavit or Sem~
:-iow,
~9
-.
-. .
o'.:.!cc!:
~[. 1::-.-d
. ...
:.:.:':"'t.'::n
'.1poa
11
'=r ~cili1; :0
J.
c::py of =: ::]::~
~
"
md -~,.;- cown :0
:.:: .::::n:::.:3 ~~:::-:i.
So~~t
Shc'.ii' 01
COWU'T. ?1.
Sworn :md r.lbsc:-J:c:i beicn:
=: :.::is _ 6y oi
19._
CCSTS
SL1.v"ICZ
~au.-\GE
A.::IDA ',IT
3
--_._~-_._......
s
1_ '-.t
CALDWELL. & KEARNS
'" ,AO"','ONAl CORftOR.tIO..
ATTORN~YS AT LAW
-
3831 NORTH tnONT STAEET
HARRISIURG, P~NNBYLVANIA 17110
Ui)
,lUG 211
4 07 rH '9S
II
'"if;t
JI,' ,1/,)
>'., " \ '11'
, I
~..,
_~Ii&..J .
EARL L. CRUM,
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
GREGORY FIEDLER and
MICHAEL LEE BREWBAKER,
Defendants
: 95-2994
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRAECIPE TO ISSUE RULE TO FILE A COMPLAINT
TO: PROTHONOTARY:
Please Issue a Rule upon the Plaintiff to file a Complaint within twenty (20)
days of service of said Rule, or suffer judgment of non pros
Respectfully submitted,
CALDWELL,~ KEARNS
~~;52
By: t~
James G. Nealon, III, Esquire
Atty. 1.0. #46457
3631 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
(717) 232-7661
August 25, 1995
TO: Earl L. Crum, Plaintiff and
Ira H, Weinstock, Esquire, his attorney
A Rule Is hereby issued upon you to file a Complaint within twenty (20) days
of service hereof, or judgment of non pros will be entered against you,
Dated: (r,,] .J J / /'I J
. YJ III
CERTIfiCATE OF SERVICE
AND NOW, this 25th day of August, 1995, I hareby certify thJt I have served the
foregoing Praecipa for to Issue a Rule to File a Complaint on the following by depositing
a true and correct copy of same in the Uniled States mails, postage prepaid, addressed
to:
Ira H, Weinstock, Esquire
Ira H, Weinstock, P,C.
BOO North Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17102
Gregory Fiedler
117 Whittier Lane
Lancaster, PA 17602
~~8:?
James G. Nealon, III, Esquire
Dated: August 25, 1995
....
l<;91'8tZ.Wll'lNOliJHlI
-
eOIll "INV^U~NNi<I':>~nU\I~~VII
llTi1~ QNOJ1~ 'N 009
00111 ln~
':)'d ')I:)O~SNI3M 'H V\l1
n:m.o h\'"
(/1
~H' \U j 2'; rH '95
,-,-! .
Ii,'
,\1
Plaintiff,
I IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 95-2994 (CIVIL TERM)
EARL L. CRUM,
vs.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
GREGORY FIEDLER and MICIIAEL
LEE BREWBAKER,
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
Defendants.
NOTICE
YOU IIAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wiBh to defend
against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take
action within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are
served, by entering a written appearance personally or by defenses
or objections to the claims set forth against you, You are warned
that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a
judgment may be entered against you by the Court without further
notice for any money claimed in the Complaint or for any other
claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or
property or other rights important to you.
YOU SIIOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF
YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE
THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FINO OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL
HELP.
Court Administrator
Fourth Floor
cumberland County Courthouse
Carlisle, PA 17013
717-240-6200
AVISO
USTED HA SIDO DEMANDADO EN LA CORTE. si usted desea
defenderse de las quejas expuestas en las paginas siguientes debe
tomar ace ion dentro de veinte (20) dias a partir de la fecha en que
recibio la demanda y el aviso. Usted debe presentar comparecencia
escrita en persona 0 por abogado y presentar en la Corte por
escrito sus defensas 0 sus objeciones a las demand~s en su contra.
Se Ie avisa que si no se defiende el caso puede proceder
sin usted y la Corte puede decidir en su contra sin mas aviso 0
notificacion por cuaiquier dinero reclamado on la demanda 0 por
cualquier otra queja 0 compensacion reclamados por el Demandante.
USTED PUEDE PERDER DINERO 0 PROPIEDADES U OTROS DERECHOS IMPORTA-
NTES PARA USTED.
LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO 1NMED1ATAMENTE. SI USTED
NO TIENE 0 NO CONOCE UN ABOGADO VAYA 0 LLAME A LA OF1C1NA EN LA
DIRECCION ESCRITA ABAJO PARA AVER1GUAR DONDE PUEDE OBTENER
ASISTENCIA LEGAL.
Court Administrator
Fourth Floor
Cumberland County Courthouse
Carlisle, PA 17013
717-240-6200
EARL L. CRUM, I IN TilE COURT 01' COMMON PLEAS OF
I CUMBEHLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff, I
1
vs. I No. 95-2994 (CIVIL 'r~HM)
1
GREGORY FIEDLER and MICHAEL 1 CIVIL ACTION - LAW
LEE BREWBAKER, I
1
Defendants. 1 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
COMPLAINT
NOW COMES, Plaintiff, Earl L. Crum, by and through his
attorney, IRA H. WEINSTOCK, P.C., and files the following Com-
plaint against Defendants, Gregory Fiedler and Michael Lee Brew-
baker, averring as followSI
PARTIES
1. Plaintiff, Earl L. Crum, is an adult individual
currsntly residing at 661 Front Strset, West Fairview, Cumberland
County, Pennsylvania, 17025.
2. Defendant, Gregory Fiedler (hereinafter, "Fied-
lor"), is an adult individual currently residing at 117 Whittier
Lane, Lancaster, Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, 17602.
3. Defendant, Michael Lee Brewbaker (hereinafter,
"Brewbaker"), is an adult individual currently residing at 8ix
East Beale Avenue, Enola, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, 17025.
VENUE
4. Venue is proper in thiD judicial district pursuant
to Rule No. 1006 of the Pennsylvania RuleD of Civil Procedure.
ugTUAI, Q^~ytm
5. On Juno 4, 1993, lit c1pproximlitoly 4111 p.m.,
Plaintiff waD operating his motor vnhicle in /I northhound direo-
tion on the 100 block of South Front Street, Wormleysburg Bor-
ough, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
6. On that same date and time, Defendant Fiedler was
operating his motor vehicle in a northbound direction on the 100
block of South Front Street, Wormleysburg Borough, Cumberland
County, Pennsylvania, in a position directly behind Plaintiff's
motor vehicle.
7. On that same date and time, Defendant Brewbaker
was operating his motor vehicle in a northbound direction on the
100 block of South Front Street, Wormleysburg Borough, Cumberland
County, Pennsylvania, in a position directly behind Defendant
Fiedler's motor vehicle.
B. As Plaintiff was proceeding along the aforemen-
tioned highway, his motor vehicle was suddenly and unexpectedly
struck in the rear by the motor vehicle operated by Defendant
Fiedler, who in turn was struck in the rear by the motor vehicle
operated by Defendant Brewbaker, causing the injuries and damages
set forth at length below.
COUNT I
NEGLIGENCE
(Plaintiff v. Defendants\
9. The allegations set forth in each and every
preceding paragraph is incorporated herein by reference.
10. The aforementioned collision occurred solely as
the result of the individual and/or joint and several negligence,
- 2 -
reckleesness and carelessness of Defendanta Fiedler and Drow-
baker, and was due in no manner whateoever to any oct or failure
to act on the port of Plaintiff.
11. The negligence, recklooonooo and carelooonoos of
Defendant Fiedler conoisted of the following,
(a) Operating a motor vehicle in willful and wanton
disregard for the safety of persono and property of otheru In
violation of 75 Pa. C.S.A. Section 3736(0)1
(b) Operating a motor vehicle In a reckleDo manner in
violation of 75 Pa. C.S.A. Section 3736(0)/
(c) Operating a motor vehicle in a careloou manner in
violation of 75 Pa. C.S.A. S 3111(a)/
(d) Operating a motor vehicle at an unoatu opuod In
violation of 75 Po. C.S.A. S 3361,
(e) Failing to keep a proper lookout for motor vehi-
cles before crossing an intersection in violation of 75 Po.
C.S.A. S 3321/
(f) Following Plaintiff's motor vehlclo moru cloooiy
than is reasonable and prudent in violation of 75 Pe. C.B.A. S
3310/ and
(g) Failing to opera to 1\ llIul.OI. Villi 101 II In olloh a
manner as to avoid causing a co11lulon.
12. The aforeeald negllgonce, reokleasneau and care-
lessness of Defendant nrewbaker consiol.od of the fo1lowingl
- 3 -
(a) Operating a motor vehicle in willful and wanton
disregard for the safety of persons and property of others in
violation of 75 Pa. C.S.A. Section 3736(a);
(b) Operating a motor vehicle in a reckless manner in
violation of 75 Pa. C.S.A. Section 3736(a);
(c) Operating a motor vehicle in a careless manner in
violation of 75 Pa. C.S.A. S 3l11(a);
(d) Operating a motor vehicle at an unsafe speed in
violation of 75 Pc. C.S.A. S 3361;
(e) Failing to keep a proper lookout for motor vehi-
cles before crossing an intersection in violation of 75 Pa.
C.S.A. S 3321;
(f) Following Plaintiff's motor vehicle more closely
than is reasonable and prudent in violation of 75 Pa. C.S.A. S
3310; and
(g) Failing to operate a motor vehicle in such a
manner as to avoid causing a collision.
13. As a direct and proximate result of the aforemen-
tioned collision, Plaintiff suffered the following injuries, some
or all of which may be permanent I
(a) Cervical and dorsal sprain;
(b) Neck pain; and
(c) Headaches.
]4. As a direct and proximate result of the aforemen-
tioned collision, Plaintiff has required medical treatment and
- 4 -
,
.-
,
has incurred expenses in connection therewith for medicines,
medical care, hospitalization and other medical services for
which a claim is hereby made.
15. As a direct and proximate result of the aforemen-
tioned collision, Plaintiff has suffered in the past and may in
the future continue to suffer excruciating and agonizing aches,
pains, mental anguish, humiliation, embarrassment, disfigurement
and deformities for which a claim is hereby made.
16. As a direct and proximate result of the aforemen-
tioned collision, Plaintiff has in the past been and may in the
future be disabled from performing his usual duties, occupations,
and avocations with a consequent loss of earnings, earning power
and earning potential for which a claim is hereby made.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, Earl L. Crum, demands damages of
Defendants, Gregory Fiedler and Michael Lee Brewbaker, in an
amount in excess of the jurisdictional amount for compulsory
arbitration pursuant to the local rules of court, plus costs of
suit and delay damages.
Respectfully submitted,
IRA H. WEINSTOCK, P.C.
800 North Second Street
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17102
Phonel 717-238-1657
/
/ "
//
/
BYI
MICIIAEL A. KORANDA
Atty. 1.0. No. 5BB08
Attorney for Plaintiff
- 5 -
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
8S:
I verify that the statements made in the attached
COMPLAINT are true and correct. I understand that false stats-
ments herein are made subject to penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. 54904
relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
DATED I
9/15/95
~,' [y" , I
~ ':.al, \, J / \. (t ),t-/
EARL L. CR H
'.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
AND NOW, this
,'" " day of
1995, I,
Michael A. Koranda, Esquire, hereby certify that I served the
within COMPLAINT by dspositing same in the United States Mail,
postage prepaid, in the post office at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania,
addressed tOI
By First Class Maill
James G. Nealon, III, Esquirs
CALDWELL , KEARNS
3631 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
Mr. Gregory Fiedler
117 Whittier Lane
Lancaster, PA 17602
I
41" ,
;7,
, ,./
...////
/ ,/,/ /1
I" ,I, __. t-
MICHAEL A. KORANDA
[.~
r" rr.
, l
I
(l-n~E
, ~ . ~ '1 ,
, I
l"r:!'71
"'i.
<0'
I' J
c.
,iY
, '
jJ';,\" Ii. I.," \
(0
.'
.
EARLl. CRU",
Plelnttff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CU"DERlAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 95-2994 CIVil TER"
Y.
GREGORY FIEDLER Dnd
MICHAEL LEE BREWBAkER,
DefendDnt
CIVIL ACTION - lAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ANSWI:R OF
DEFE.OANT ~ GREGORV FIEDLER
AND NOW, comes the Defelllllnt, Gregory Fiedler, by IInd through hIs
IIllomel/, OlIrrell C. Dethlefs, Esqutre, IInd IInswe~ the Pllllnttffs Compllllnt DS
follows:
1. Amnllled.
2, Amntlled,
3. Amnllled,
4, Amnllled,
5, Amnllled,
6. Admllled,
7, Amnllled.
e. DenIed, Defendlll1t, Gregory Fiedler, denies the lIverments stated In
PlIrlIgrllph e, Defendllnt, Gregory Fiedler, dente" .:' '. '9 he WIIS proceedtng 1I10ng the
lIforementloned htghwlIl/, hIs motor vehicle suddenll/llnd uneMpectedll/stl1Jck the rear
of the vehicle being OPlll1lted bl/ the PllllntHf Proof to the contrllry Is dernlll1ded lit
time of tr1111.
COUNT I
tiEWYEW
9. The allegations set forth In each amI evel1l precedIng paragraph are
Incorporated hereIn by reference
10, DenIed, The Defendent, Gregory FIedler, denIes that the aforementioned
collisIon was caused solely as a result of the Individual and/or joInt and sllYera!
neglIgence, recklessness and carelessness of him, Defendent, Gregory Fiedler,
flrtherdenles that the collIsion was caussd In any mannsr whatsoever by any act or
failure to act on hIs part, Proof to the contrary Is de mended at lime of trial.
I\. DenIed. The Defendant, Gregory Fiedler, denIes each and every
allegation of PlI'agraphs 11 a through' Ig, Proof to the contrary Is demanded at lime
of trIa I.
12. Paragraph 12 relates to Defendant, Brewbaker, Thus, no response Is
re~Irijd from Defendant, FIedler.
13. DenIed, Oefendent, FIedler, Is wHhoutsufftclent tnformal1on wHh whIch
to form a beltef as the truth or falsHy of the averments contained In Paragraph 13.
Thus, these averments are denied. Proof to the contrary Is demcrlded at time of trial.
14, DenIed, Defendent, FIedler, Is without sufficIent InformatIon wIth whIch
to form a beltef as the truth or falsity of the averments contatned In Paragraph 14,
Thus, these averments are denIed, Proof to the contrary Is demcrlded at tIme of trial.
IS. Dented, Defendcrlt, Fiedler, Is without sufftctentlnformal1on wtth wh1ch
to form a beltef as the truth or falstty of the averments contained In Paragraph 15.
Thus, these averments are denied, Proof to the contrary Is demcrlded at time of trllll.
16, DenIed Defendent, FIedler, Is wHhout sufficient InformatIon wtth whIch
to form a beltef as the truth or falsity of the averments contained In Paragraph 16.
Thus, these averments are denied Proof to the contral1l1s demcrlded at time of trllll.
- .~---~.--~.
WHEREFORE. the Defeooont, Gregory Fiedler, requests Judgment In his fovor,
.11
Dote)__ & . 'i G
,
lly: '
DllI"rel1 C, Dethlefs, Esquire
Attorney 10 No, 5llB05
WOlJler llulldlng - SUite 205
355 t<<lrth 2\ st street
Comp Ht11, PA \7011
(717) 975-9446
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
AND NOW. thl s '7 il, doy of J~R~~;Y,/ 1996, I do hereby cert Ify
thot 0 true ond correct copy of the foregoIng Answer hos been served upon
the followIng by deposlttng the some In the United Stotes Motl, first closs,
postoge pre-paid ond oddressed os follows:
James G, Neolon, III, EsquIre
Caldwell 6. Kearns
3631 North Front Street
Horrlsburg, PA 17110
MIchael A. Korondo, Esquire
Law Offices Iro H. WeInstock, PC,
Suite 100,800 North 2nd Street
Horrlsburg, PA 17102
Dote: ,J. ') - 'I (,
Respectfully Submitted,
LAW OF~];C OF_.DAR ~L C, DETHLEFS
t, '.Il--.
By:' t- .J
Dorrell C, Dethlefs, Esquire
Attomey 10- 58605
Wogner BUIldIng, SuIte 205
355 North 21 st Street
CompHtll.PA 17011
(717) 975-9446
...
-
.
EARL L. CRUM,
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
: CIVIL ACTION. LAW
GREGORY FIEDLER and
MICHAEL LEE BREWBAKER,
Defendants
: 96-2994
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRAECIPE
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
Please withdraw the appearance of Caldwell & Kearns previously filed in the
above-captioned matter,
CALDWELL & KEARNS
~ 1
By: J v U-
James L. smith, Esquire
3631 North F on Street
Harrisburg, P 110
(717) 232-7661
Please enter my appearance on behalf of the Defendant, Michael Lee
Brewbaker, in the above-captioned matter.
NEALON & GOVER
..,
By: ct
James G, Nealon, III, Esquire
301 Market Street -- 9th Floor
PO Box 665
Harrisburg, PA 17106-0665
(717) 232-9900
" -
;
<
!
ffi g
> : ~
o ~ .J
l!H ~
Kl~EI 8
~ ~ ~ ~
~ j ~ !
( 0
M
- '
, , .
WIlMllll'.lOltll"l.nU"IIUlI' O~"lIOt
'!fj"'lI<<'U"~.'I"""lWj'llY"l~(II""-IlI\l l'UIII,'Jlll'l
"
"
..
~
~
m
a 0
o ~
o 0
~ ~
~ (
II WI Z
~ ~
~
~ ~
lD Z
o ~
0: a
Ii
a
"
m
III
it
a
(
I
EARL L. CRUM,
Plaintiff
v.
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
GREGORY FIEDLER and
MICHAEL LEE BREWBAKER,
Defendants
95-2994
ANSWER OF DEFENDANT...MICHAEL LEE BREWBAKER
1-16, Paragraph 2 is admitted; it is further admitted that on June 4, 1993, at
approximately 4:11 p,m" Defendant, Michael Lee Brewbaker, was operating his motor vehicle
in a northbound direction on South Front Street in Wormleysburg, Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania; the remaining averments contained in the Complaint are denied pursuant to
Pa,R.C,P, 1029(e),
Respectfully submitted,
NEALON & GOVER
I
)
( \ -- "-\ \..-{.
By: _ - .
James G, Nealon, III, Esquire
Atty, 1.0, #46457
301 Market Street u 9th Floor
P,O, Box 865
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0865
(717) 232-9900
IfEHIFICA liON
I, Michael Lee Brewbakor, verify that tile statements made in tile foregoing Answer
are true and correct. 1 understand lilat false statements herein are made subject to the
penalties of 18 Pa, C,S,A, 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities,
D.'.d, lIjJQ Jq(,
f/(JJj ~
Micilael Lee Brewbaker
AND NOW, this 25th day of November, 1996, I hereby certify that I have
served the foregoing Answer on the fOllowing by depositing a true and correct copy of
same in the United States malls, postage prepaid, addressed to:
Michael A. Koranda, Esquire
IRA H, WEINSTOCK, P.C,
BOO North Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17102
Darrell C. Dethlefs, Esquire
Wagner Building - Suite 205
355 N. 21'1 Street
Camp HIli, PA 17011
James G. Nealon, III, Esquire
Dated: 11/25/96
I'HAECIPE FOil 1,IS'I'lNG CAS~; FOil 'I'IIIAI,
(Munt Ix! tYlx'wl'itlen '\lId nutmitted ill duplicilte)
:1
..t> n
..J l\
u'I :,S
In ,,31
-u
"~
_J :'~( ,
J ."
.." ' .,
::1- li: )
"" ,J-,IU
.. :~
..' '\1
II' .~
("l
\
'.
'10 '11 IE 1'1<<J11 IONJI'AHY OF CIlMIlEHI /lND COlJN'I'Y
.,.,
, . , ~
,.... .'.
P1eane list tho followinu easel
(Chock ono)
X) [or JUHY trial at the next tonn of civil cO\lI;L
for trial without a jury.
. ,
.~
-----------------------------------------
CI\l'rION OF CASE
(ontire caption nust be stated in [ull)
(check one)
BAHL I.. CHUM,
(X) Civil Action - Law
lIppea1 from Artlitration
(other)
(Plaintiff)
vs.
(Defendant)
'rhe trial list will be called on
and /(1. I V f//
'rria1s comrenco on / (.. ((J f/' I
pretrials will be held on /0 I J.. ? '/
(Briefs are due 5 days before pretrials.)
GHEGOHY FIEllI,BIl and
MICHAEl, LEE BHBWDAKlm,
No.95-2994 Civil IJ\W
19 95
VB.
('I'ho party listing this case for trial shall
provide forthwith a copy of the praecipe to
all counsel, pursuant to local Rule 214.1.)
Indicate the attorney who will try Cilse for the party who files this praecipe.
Anthonv Natale. 111. I::SlIuire of IliA II. WEINH'I'IlCK, I' C'
Indicate trial counsel for other parties if knawlll .James G. Nealon, IJ 1. I~Buuire
and Darre1 C. UcLh1c(n, Esquire
Print NarKH
'LL ~-(U. t~ (lL'
Anthony Natal!, III, Bnquire
ilIA II. WIONS'l'lCK, P.C.
This case is ready tor tr.t.,I.
Siunedl
l~llcl
Ileptcmhcr 1&, I'J97
AllonlCY fan
I':arl Crum