HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-03067
~I "Wi?)/? ('~" X1JC,
,
In The Court of Cocmon PI.aa of
.)
)
1
)
)
)
lc.
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania
:10..13:..-. '30(,'1('IVIL. 19'1-;
dlltHA'TlotJ
GYN"i/;hA- SLo THoI.4JE /'l:
-
OA7H
We do aolemoly ewear (or affirm) that we will support. obey and deiend
the Conatitution of the United Statea and the Constitution of this Co~on-
~ealth ~d ~~t we ~ill dischargl the dutie. of our office ~ith fidelity.
?"i :: ~",,;. 7t."'j' ,/<-Lv
1"':' ',.Cnau~nan
'.:{!~ 9!. ~Idv:ar
;: ~aJJr!t1t(JJtZ~
AWARD
(or
WI, the undlrsigned arbitrators, having been duly appointed and sworn
affirmed), make the followin. award:
(Notll If damaSI. for delay are awarded, they shall b.
..paretaly .tacld')JJ.k'I~1 c? /"Ytt,..f.'t eFr..ft"." J/-(.okrc"..Ift.,.
, I' 4
/ / ro. 90 LJ.tll..{) it.8-.I a.
r,< ,
13
applicable. )
Oate of Rearing I / 'I /lulp.cf (
:late of Award: / If IJ, "br 'It
. Arbitrator, dissents. (Inserc name i!
/t:'- ?he (1
.:/~ ;. . Chair.nan
$r/k~;~tf;L
~OTICE OF ENTRY OF AWARD
:lev. the N~ay oi 'tll11l<:'''-.. . 19-1!L. at L!2., r..:I.. the above
award was entered upon the docket and notice :hereof given by mail to the
parcia. or their attorney..
Arbitrators' coopeosation :0 be
paid upon appeal:
S ~"b ~
,.kt-ut,r-{'.'
<!. "^- 1:0_( ~,~'-'
Prothonotary
y) .
n 'O~AlI1"u
Dejrut7'
llYI
,JiLf;,
~
}.
l'
\lJ
~
~~
"b'
..
.
.
. .
an
!?"" .~,.
:c*"-".
Q.._ \I.. . :.;~('
..-.. ':t, , ':
\.rl' "'
{Y) , I
\ '"1
....
t..
;;.:;:.l ,
~
~ ..;!jl
~~~M
I fts!
. '
. .
, .
r.\wpSl\Rottr\PId&\SloIhonr,po\omr
GRAHAM MOTOR COMPANY, INC., a
Pennsylvania Corporation,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERU,NDCOUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
~
Plaintiff
v.
NO: 95-3067 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
CYNTHIA SLOTHOWER,
Defendant
AND NOW, comes Cynthia Slothower, Defendant In the above-captioned action and states
the following Preliminary Objections to Plalntlff's Complaint, In the nature of . demand for more
speclflo Complaint:
1. Paragraph 6 of said Complaint falls to state with specificity any Items which are
Included In the description of 'varlous service and repair work;" or to state with specificity prices
of said Items Included In the alleged total amount of $2,748.58.
2. In paragraph 7 Plaintiff falls to state with specificity Items comprising the alleged
category of "total payments and adJustments' amounting to $1,607.68 so that Defendant can
determine whether she has received all credits to which she was entitled.
3. Each of the exhibits to said Complaint has a substantial portion of Its writing blocked
out, as If by placing another sheet of paper over It before copying, thereby obscuring what may
be Important Information and preventing Defendant from being able to respond to said Complaint.
~Afl, 0 .
\~~:
"1\
, / / \ \
~, ~. / I:
(' (/ I ) / I, '
) .
/'~" '{II'
/
~. I, \ (,
,j
-
I c"
" c(
~,
I/L, "
.,\wpl'\""",\rw,\!IIot_"po\.mr
WHEREFORE, Defendant requests your Honorable Court to require Plaintiff to file 8 more
specific Complaint.
FLOWER, MOROENTHAL, FLOWER. LINDSAY
Attorneys for Plaintiff
B~'l /l.lt'~'l\.I\-
Roger M. Morgen ai, Esquire
10 * 17143
11 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243-5513
2
r.\wp5 t\Rop'\PWa\Sloth.-"PO\.nI,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I;. /1
AND NOW, this .. " 1\ day of
!
; ,
(., t :,
" ,1
, 1995, I, Roger M.
Morgenthal, Esquire, of the law firm of FLOWER, MORGENTHAL, FLOWER & LINDSAY, Attorneys,
hereby certify that I served the within Preliminary Oblectlons this day by depositing same In the
United States Mall, First Class, Postage Prepaid, in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, addressed to:
Robert Purvis, Service Manager
GRAHAM MOTOR COMPANY, INC.
1402 Holly Pike
Carlisle, PA 17013
FLOWER, MORGENTHAL. FLOWER & UNDSAY
Attorneys for Plaintiff
By
/114) /L IlJv
Ro er M. Morgenthal, Esquire
10 # 17143
11 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243-5513
~
I
I
I
'- ..- l~-
.~-!-
GRAHAM MOTOR COMPANY, INC., a
Pennsylvania Corporation,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
NO. 95-3067 CIVIL TERM
CYTHNIA SLOTHOWER,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
PLAINTIFF'S REPLY TO
DEFENDANT'S NEW MATTER
AND NOW, comes Graham Motor Company, Inc. by and through its
attorneys, Saidis, Guido, Shuff & Mas land, and replies to
Defendant's New Matter as follows:
9. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is admitted
that Richard J. Magaro on occasion contracted for maintenance to
Defendant's vehicle.
The remaining allegations therein are
denied. After reasonable investigation, Plaintiff is without
knowledge or information sufficient to forra a belief as to the
truth of the averments set forth therein and strict proof thereof
is demanded at trial.
10.
Denied.
The averments contained therein ere
SAlOIS, GUIDO,
SHUFF ..
MASI,AND
26 W, lUsh S'rtt'
eMlllle, I'A
conclusions of law to which no response is required. By way ot
further answer, the said Richard J. Magaro had previouIly
requested Plaintiff to make repairs to Defendant's vehicle whloh
Defendant had authorized and/or paid for.
11. Denied. To the contrary, it was apparent tbI'OIA9lt::
Dafendant's course of conduct that the said Richard J. M'9"'O".i~}~~~
authority to act on Defendant's behalf in connection with ..r
auto repairs. By way of further answer, Defendant
authorized the repairs in question and/or accepted eaid repairs
and agreed to pay therefor.
12. Admitted in part and denied in part.
While it is
admitted that Defendant did not sign the work orders, she
specifically acknowledged that the work was to bs done and agreed
to pay for it. She made partial payments on work previously done
in order for Plaintiff to begin the repairs listed on the work
order dated November 14, 1994. Said payment was made by a check
which was signed by Defendant and drawn on a joint checking
account with the said Richard J. Magaro.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgmsnt against Defendant in
the amount of $1,140.90 plus costs.
Respectfully submitted,
UFF & MASLAND
. Dated:
10 II 3/'15
By:
Edward E. Guido, Esquire
Supreme Ct. 1.0. * 21206
26 West High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243-6222
Attorney for Plaintiff
2
VERIFICATION
I verify that the statements made in this Plaintiff's Reply
to Defendant's New Matter are true and correct.
I understand
that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of
18 Pa.C.S.A. S 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to
authori ties.
Dated:
loll J/~{
, I
,-;:j: 1./ ~("),1 / <:.. )
" '\ (,'C {(i(..t ':~./ tt ((('/ t't'~'
Robert Purvis'( Service Manager
SAIDIS, GUIDO,
SHUFF lit
MASLAND
26 W, III.h SUrd
Cullolr.l'A
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
tJ1,
I, Edward E. Guido, Esquire certify that on the /:? day of
( \ ( t(IC-"""
, 1995, I served a true and correct copy of the
within Plaintiff's Reply to Defendant's New Matter upon counsel
for Defendant in this matter by depositing same in the United
States mail, first class, postage prepaid addressed as followSI
Roger M. Morgenthal, Esquire
FLOWER, MORGENTHAL, FLOWER & LINDSAY
11 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013-3016
Datel
loltJ/~(
Respectfully submitted,
SAIDIS, GUIDO,
& MASLAND
By:
Edward E. Guido, Esquire
Supreme Ct. I.D. . 21206
26 West High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243-6222
Attorney for Plaintiff
GRAHAM MOTOR COMPANY, INC.,
Pennsylvania Corporation,
Plaintiff
a : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
NO. 95-3067 CIVIL TERM
CYTHNIA SLOTHOWER,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NOTICI
IOU RAVI BIIN SUID IN COURT. If you wish to defend against
the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action
within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served,
br entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and
f ling in writing with the court your defenses or objections to the
claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to
do so, the case may proceed without you and a jUdgment may be
entered against you by the court without further notice for any
other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose
money or property or other rights important to you
IOU 'BOULD TAli THIS PAPIR TO lOUR LAWIIR AT ONCI. IF IOU DO
NOT IAVI A LAWIIR OR CAIINOT AFFORD 0111, GO TO OR TILIPBONI TBI
OrFICI liT FORTB BILOW TO FIND OUT WHIRl IOU CAlI GIT LIGAL BILP.
Cumberland County Court Administrator
One Courthouse Square
Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013
(717) 240-6200
- 1-----)
/:7 ,- /C- ____ _
., / '.' L' ~j . ."..,..
v 1,"-,'. :",j(,,-,,~c?
Robert Purvis, Service Manager
GRAHAM MOTOR COMPANY, INC.
1402 Holly Pike
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243-3066
GRAHAM MOTOR COMPANY, INC.,
Pennsylvania Corporation,
Plaintiff
a I IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
NO. 95-3067 CIVIL TERM
CYTHNIA SLOTHOWER,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
COMPLAINT
1. Plaintiff is Graham Motor Company, Inc. a Pennsylvania
corporation with its principal place of business at 1402 Holly
Pike, Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
2. Defendant, Cynthia Slothower, is an adult individual who
resides at 41 Beachcliff Drive, Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania.
3. Defendant is the owner of a 1991 Cadillac El Dorado
automobile.
4. Plaintiff is in the business of, inter alia, serving and
repairing automobiles.
5. On February 7, 1994/ June 17, 1994, and November 14, 1994
Defendant brought her car to Plaintiff I s place of business for
service and repair work.
6. Plaintiff performed various service and repair work to
the vehicle on said dates and billed Defendant a total of
$2,748.58, representing the usual and customary charges for the
work done.
7. Total payments Ilnd adjustments of $1,607.68 have been
made, leaving an outstanding balance on Defendant I s account of
$1,140.90.
'.
8. Despite repeated demands, Defendant has failed or refused
to pay the balance due.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against Defendant in the
amount of $1,140.90 plus costs.
This is an amount requiring
submission of the matter to arbitration.
'--"-,
, .
, ../'s,Y \...........'
'I (.. (. 'ft." i iff ,',; ,..",..-.-.:.--
Robert Purvis, Service Manager
GRAHAM MOTOR COMPANY, INC.
1402 Holly Pike
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243-3066
2
..
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
On this 26th day of June, 1995, I, Robert purvie, Service
Manager, hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of
the foregoing Complaint upon Defendant record via United Statee
Mail, postage prepaid, addressed as followSI
Cynthia Slothower
41 Beachcliff Drive
Mechaniceburg, PA 17055
Date: 6/26/95
.',F' ~..._
\ / . - ~I :;,,--::..
1~ '~L(.(t ..- ....,(((etc.{.K.-'
Robert Purvis, Service Manager
GRAHAM MOTOR COMPANY, INC.
1402 Holly Pike
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243-3066
.' '-.
Ii;
'"
0;.,
.l:-
t:,
.....
",,-,
::.::
~
r:\"1'51\Rlll.r\I'I~I\Sllllhl1w.',.n.\.mr
GRAHAM MOTOR COMPANY, INC., a
Penn.ylvanla Corporation,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff
v.
NO: 95.3067 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
CYNTHIA SLOTHOWER,
Defendant
TO: Graham Motor Company, Inc., by and through their attorneys:
Edward E. Guido, Esquire
SAlOIS, GUIDO, SHUFF & MASLAND
26 West High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
You are hereby notified to file a written response to the enclosed New Matter within twenty
(20) days from service hereof or a judgment may be entered against you.
FLOWER, MORGENTHAL, FLOWER . LINDSAY
Attorneys for Defendant, Cynthia Slothower
Dated:
..1 1.11 'il'
By:~'}1 Jl1crt/lv~--
Roger M. Morgentflal, Esquire
10 # 17143
11 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243-5513
.: \wp.lI\RlIler\I'ldl\SllIlhllWe',lkl\.mr
GRAHAM MOTOR COMPANY, INC., I
penn.ylvlnll Corporltlon,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERlAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plllntlff
NO: 95.3067 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
V.
CYNTHIA SLOTHOWER,
Defendlnt
ANSWER WITH NEW MATTER TO
AND NOW, comes Cynthia Slothower, Defendant In the above-captioned action, by her
attorneys. Flower, Morgenthal, Flower & Lindsay and states the following answer to Plalntlff's
Complaint:
1. Admitted.
2. Denied. Defendant's present address Is 1100 Newberry Road, Middletown,
Pennsylvania.
3. Admitted.
4. Admitted.
~. Denied. On the contrary, Defendant believes and therefore avers that one Richard
J. Magaro took Defendant's car to Plaintiff's place of business, on his own Initiative and not at her
direction.
r:\wp.ll \Ku..r\I'IdI\Slulhu"''1..\.mr
6. Denied. After reasonable Investigation, Defendant is without sufficient information to
answer the averment, and proof, If relevant, Is demanded et trial.
7. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without sufficient Information to
answer the averment, and proof, If relevent, is demanded at trial.
8. Admitted. By WAY of further answer, refer to Defendant's New Matter below.
WHEREFORE, Defendant requests your Honoreble Court to dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint
with costs on Plaintiff.
N.EW....MAIIEB
9. Richard J. Magaro, a former friend of Defendant, frequently operated Defendant',
vehicle and on occasion contracted for, and paid for, maintenance to said vehicle.
10. Richard J. Magaro was not an agent of Defendant, nor did he have her permission
to obligate Defendant for payment on any contracts, Including In particular contracts for auto
repair.
11. Plaintiff, through Its employees, failed to obtain permission from Defendant before
performing the alleged service and repair work on said vehicle, end further, Plaintiff failed to
ascertain whether Richard J. Magaro had authority to bind Defendant for payment for said repairs.
12. Defendant did not sign any of the work orders attached to PlaintiH's Complaint in the
space provided for authorization of repairs, and the only work order signed was by Richard J.
Magaro.
r:\wp.ll \Ro..r\Pld.\Slolh....,.po\.mr
WHEREFORE, Defendant requests your Honorable Court to dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint
with costs on Plaintiff.
FLOWER, MORGENTHAL, FLOWER & LINDSAY
Attorneys for Defendant
By: '~l n1 L,1~/--
Roger M. Morgenthal: Esquire
ID /I 17143
11 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243.5513
4
l'<jl:'
., ,I.
l\.l,~1 \R"i~I\I'jlli''';!' lh I 'tJ~' ,-!q"
M(\tt,l'I \'.' pi,
I, CVntl .'.1 Z;' w:ll ~'.J. i ;-, '
. 1 fj:: r H"I .i;~~il ;\
. .- ...--.....-.-.
f(~ I;,;'
bolitl'. I 'Jnd"r~,,\il..,..i 11, \t ';',
t'
",' ,I.
vr"~IFIC;~,n9..N
,
! ~,i.I"
,. ~f\,-,f I, ," 'I.'
..
, ' t'. .; ....(.:' {!:~~.~'ii_\ll t 1.:.'"'
,
,.1....
:',' 11',f"nt .' " ,
'.. I ..', ~
, j,;
. 'll)l'r,(~ \:f I::~ Pd {~~,
.,
.<.
Sct.'ti\~~, ~~?(J4 ft!:..Jtl'I~J t',; t.ln'.:....'~,!(, i .:',:fl',1";;1 tv ':I!.ltll 1.1"
n,lIe:
0)fI:~,>f~~ ..
9-27-9...>-
c, \~I'\ I \"".,,\I'I~.\Slllhu~, 'I",\.mr
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
AND NOW, this 2.- ~ day of ~1 ~tlJL... ,1995, I, Roger M.
Morgenthal, Esquire. of the law firm of FLOWER, MORGENTHAL, FLOWER & L1NDSA V, Attorneys,
hereby certify that I served the within Answer With New Matter to Plaintiff's Complaint this day by
depositing same In the United States Mall, First Class, Postage Prepaid, In Carlisle, Pennsylvanls,
addressed to:
Edward E. Guido, Esquire
SAlOIS, GUIDO, SHUFF & MAS LAND
26 West High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
FLOWER. MORGENTHAL. FLOWER & LINDSAY
Attorneys for Defendant
r--5)-,\ dll L'V/l.v,I--
Roger M. Morgenthal, Esquire
10 # 17143
11 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243-5513
By
I,
I..,
!U
f'""
L. -.
(t)
H
'.11
:l1
t-f1
-
PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT
(!>bit be typewritten and subnitted in duplicate)
TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY:
Please list the within matter for the next I\rgII11eIlt court.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CAPTION OF CASE
(entire caption I1IlBt be stated in full)
Graham Motor company, Inc.,
....
~
"-'
L' \
(plaintiff)
,
L '
VB.
i:5
I"
C>
f!~
::s:
~
.", '~. j
. ..
'.: .,.
cynthia Slothower,
( Defendant)
lb. 3067
Civil
19 95
1. State matter to be aqJBl (Le., plaintiff's I1Dtion for new trial, deferdant's
dmurrer to cal1>laint. etc.)I
Defendant's Preliminary Objections
2. Identify counsel lIIho will ~ casel
(a) for plaintiffl Edward E. Guido, Esquire
~l Saidis, Guido, Shuff & Mas land
26 West High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(b) for deferdantl Roger M. Morgenthal, Esquire
~81 Flower, Morgenthal, Flower & Lindsay
11 East High street
Carlisle, PA 17013
3. I will notify all parties in writing within t1IIO days that this case has
been listed for argmEI1t.
4. A~t Court Datal October 11, 1995
Deted: ,<1 I~ Sic,)'
__A~
Attorney for rOO. 'v t, f 1-
r:\wp5I\R"I.r\I'I~I\Sllllhllw'r,"I\.mr '
GRAHAM MOTOR COMPANY, INC., a
Pennsylvania Corporation,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff
v.
NO: 95.3067 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
CYNTHIA SLOTHOWER,
Defendant
PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
I hereby withdraw my Preliminary Objections to Plaintiff's Complaint.
FLOWER, MORGENTHAL, FLOWER & LINDSAY
Attorneys for Defendant
'\ {-u/n'
BY:~;Z 1/41 {UJ---
oger M. Morgen ai, Esquire
10 # 17143
11 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243.5513
t'"
1.11
\U
~' .
L.
L.
...
.
Cj
~
,"
.
II' I" ." I
j . ... I ..,..., .1ot1Mlollel_. .
· -..........
. . ,..._..u:...... ..""-.'....-..lhol......
-IMI........ .
~~."" .....01""......... ...."" _ N_
I · ... . " ~""" --".Ill..........._""__
i ......lI!I.....Io_""____...""...
...
ZoO
I 11Io willi 10 reotIvt tilt
IolIowlne IIfYIoM IIot In.... J '
1.11
I. [J A.......... A....
J. [J 11...,10104 Dthtrv J
J.
Ii
,:
Ii
-
Z 02? 032 3bO
2:
':'''I.'4~\
Receipt for
Certified MIll
No Insurancl! Cll....erano P,ov11'ed
Do nOI tl!IU IUI InlorfllllHllltlf Mall
ISoll RO\luIsel
'.;.
',-I 'j '.'.
J:I .." "..
lJi t ,','.. ~'j;,
~
ti ", ,.'
I ". ,.,..".
f"',,,
!
Ie
^.,
I. (0
'-"1
.
"-,,-.
C_WIAIlH 0' PlNHlnVANIA
coulio,cOMMOj,f'IIAi-- ,
NOTICE 0' APPEAL
fROM
JUDICIAL DIUller
DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT
COMMONPUAI_~~__'!-_.95_J067 Civil Term
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notic. II gi- lhat lho appellant hal filed In tho above COUfI of Common Plool on oppeol from the judgment r.ndered by Ihe Dillrict JUlllc. on 'he
dalo and In tho co.. mentioned below.
. # 1 ~ " ;~'~~-I ~~-~~~~~~-=-OIY--_.
.- '} _,IY
--./1 c~ "dl. A,,~,,"______-:-__.1-~JJ.;..l~~ ----I-
tr,. (, . ~J- _~l'i,"j",,,, II/Ilk (~, l.r",
a....HQ - ClTVI~ Je,l- ;j' . _Um---[NAr"'_l7"(Pi/ilAN, ffi/1irJ)..
. ' ,~ till",
Thil block wll be I9wd ONlV when Ihil oofatlon II required under Po. R.CP.lJi: No. If appellant was CLAIMANT (see Pa, R.CP.JP. No.
lOOn.
This Nollce of Appeal. when received by lhe Dillrkt JUllico. will operale 01 a t001(6) In acllon betore District Jusllce, he MUST
SUPHSfOEAS fa tho Judgment fa.. pone,,1an In thll COle. FILE A COMPLAINT wl/hln fwenty (20) days after
filing his NOTICE of APPEAL.
"'Mllii~m:MlNllr- '
__Jvf(Q(t,.. tJ,'I'V-
;- I. COOl
II .() J
10. ....'"
L 51." -I ;'0' u . "-
5ignnluro of Pro,honoIary Of Deputy
PUIC"I TO INTlI lULl TO Fill COMPLAINT AND lULl TO FILl
(TIrItI seetlon of form 10 be used ONLY when awellslIl was DEFENDANT (500 Pa, HCP.JP. No,
IF NOT USED, detach (rom ctpy o( notico 01 awest 10 be sorved upon appolloo),
PIAIC"I. To Pralhanalary , / . JJ , J
Entorruleupon ~/J/,~ ".. /I("J,-<. C, k1vc
M-'IIfJ uI"II~lIco(sJ
, 00 1( 7 I ;11 ac/iOll beloro DistrIct Justice,
. oppellee(I). 10 fae a complaint In 111I. appeal
(Cammonl'toaINo.~67 9ivil Term
I wllhln twenly (20) daYI of
.
/) L:1 , rl
lULl. To (; p,J..I... r/f, /.A
tt tJame /1/ -",,-,./
., .....
(I) YOlI <110 ootiTAt a'<I.to II h...by enteted upon you to file" complaint in thil appeal within twenly (20) day' afler lhe dolo of
,",vlc. of 1I1I11Il1e upon ~ po<lllr-llervice 0< by ce,lifled or regillered mail.
(2) If you do 001 file a complalnl wllhin Ihll lime. 0 JUDGMENT OF NON PROS Will BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU,
(!
, ;
X;r oppenee(I),
I afnon~
,
(3) Tho date of .ervke of Ihi! rule If let vice wtll by mail II the date of mailing,
Dale:
t-~
'1::-
..19_,
-"--- ',~"
/
)/
, ~
" '/:F~~ ~;"_y 01 ~
AOPf; .11;1 fW
PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT
(ThIS ploof of SOlVI(;tl MUS TUf. III f(l WITHIN Tl N ~ III) lIA L'; AI" II ,;luJU Olll "otH;U of ,JPPlJdl CfltJclo. dpp/lCilblu bOlos)
COMMONWEALYl OF PENN&VLV\NIA
COUNTY OF ..lJJ.xUbe.C_ _0. '06 _ ,
,II
AFFIDAVIT: I hCIVhy swcar or altlllll ","II .""elt
~Opy 01 the Nollce of APLlCi~t. (~oml1lun Ple~ls N{J ._ (l> ..~_3(~fn '] lllHm~ ttl!~ DISlrlCI Jusllcr. (fl~signRlec1 therem on
(dale 01 .e/VIce) _ (. -1_. IU__q.:L, U by IJUQ"lal ',CIVILU p.. bYTcertll~) (registered) mail. sender's
recelpl"ltRched her.lo, e'(P5Jf~n Ih.. ""pellce, (niOme), _, ___'-,^J!Jl!"'" ,U!_~.:_L"-_,_'._ltC.~___ . on
(IJ ~ 7 , 19 by persunal 5CP/I(,;U M by (l;lHlllwd) (llJYlslell'u) nUl11. SHlldl1r'S roceipt attachod hereto.
o and lurttlcr thot lserved Ihu nulc 10 f Ilu a Complallll,H.LuflIpnnYlny Ihe abovu NuttLe 01 Appeal upon tho appollee(l) to whom
thc flu Ie w"s adllle.scd 011 ________'____m __ _____, IU____. [J IlY pm sunlit SI""CU 0 by ILUfllllod) (rcgistered)
moll, Bonder's receipt (lUnched hereto. (), //
__",__l ,In!tc~i-~ ,j(d--lk.v--
_7 . Slfln,tuI.o/a",.nl
M~ comml"lon
I.;). -;2OL
,19!tL
r.i
lilL! H
III 1',\
. " I ' i~)1
'"
.'...
c,
T -,
~~ 1I J .
rill'
I,:' ,
\II ~,
,.
f~.l" -. t:...
.. t~l~. ..!
J,.. ".Ie:'!'~
4 .'.,' n
.." I),""
.,
~...
..~
...
..
'Jrj;r'.~:'\I'JAI
r., i'-" ~ . ~ t ; I
-
......
[' ,
" .M........~.,.-.'_...
CD
=
..
ttl
COM_WIALYH 0' "",NIYLVANIA
-- --- coUiTo; C-OMMoN,iiAi
NOTICE 0' APPEAL
fROM
JUDICIAL DIIUIC!
DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT
COMMON PlIAI No.
u_
95-3067 Civil Term
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notie. is given that the appellant hen filed in the above Courl of (olnrno., Plem un appeal from Ih8 judgment rendered by the District JUltk. on the
date and In lhe co.. mentioned below,
Jjtb!,' L _SL.~4,,:;<------T~:::E=" .o~
..nr;~~ 1~1~r:J"~~~'h"," 1fJ.,"?ZIj2;~.;E r""slo :i:~:..
.~~- - ;:,~ 1~7~jU-' r'r:;:::h~~~~
Thll block will b. oigned ONLY when this ;';ta"on-i. -r.q~ireJ"und;; PC: Ri:P~- - -" awcnJnI was CLAIMANT (see PD. R.CP.J.P. No.
~8~tlee 01 App.al. when recei",d by the Di.trlct JUltic.. will opemte o. 0 100' (6) in acllon belore Dislricl Jusllce. ha MUST
SUPERSEDEAS 10 the JudgmenllOf po.....ion in this ca... FILE A COMPLAINT within lwenly (20) days alter
'" .____ filing his NOTICE 01 APPEAL.
-.-Sl{1ldtiiiiJ"Ur AOiookJlaf-Y -iv75tplfy-----
PIAECIPE TO INTlIiRULEfofILi-cOMPLAINT AND RULE TO Fill
(This section 01 /on" 10 bo l/Sod ONLY wlr(){1 uwel/ulIl was DEFENDANT ISIlll fh RCPJ.P, No, 100l(7) illacl/Oll belore Disuict Just/co,
IF NOT USED. detach 110m cq:>y o/lIotice 01 appc.111o bo selVL~1 UpOll <1llfJO/lCC},
'RAE~::~~1e :thona:~.4A...,~" 4!:';'I(~___~_~~_____. appell..{.). to fil. 0 complaint in thI. appeoI
M."e o/o.ll,JeIIt!llf!i1
._) within lwenty 1201 day. a(Jv~:ej~~~ or,'r ~:._ ~
(j () ---7/-- --.'-- .;2f~"," 0/ .."",,,,. at his attomey at -"
;f-~~oppella'I'),
(Canwnon Plea. No.
95-3067 Civi~ Term
IULE. To
a~~ v1/..~
~!f~'J
, ~,J
Dale:
II) Yoo ore notif,l!,lhat a ,ule I. h...by ent.r.d upon you 10 fil. 0 complaint in Ihi. appeal within t....nty (20) day. alter the date of
servle. 01 thI. /Ole """" ~ by per",",,1 .erv.. Of by certili.d Of I.gilt.r.d mail,
'"
(2) N you do not .1' caniplainl within this time. 0 JUDGMENT Of NON PROS Will BE ENTERED AGAINST YOu.
..
(3) The dat. 01 ... 01 thillul. if ,ervic. we. by moil i. th. dol. of mailing,
__ _~~,-__K ,~.t~ ~
/ Sogooo Y at llIIJuIy
t-I,
95
. 19_,
AO"Clll'~
PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT
f TIll. "1001 ol.olVleo MUS r Of FILED W/II/lN , IN (/(IJ IJA YS AfT/II /llllIg ,1'0 lIoI,co 0' ,'''''0"/ Cllock "1'1"IC.1V/01>0'0.)
COMMONWULTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF ; II
AFFIDAVIT: I herchy swear or allirm Ihallsmvcd
o 0 copy ollhe Notlco uf Appeal. Cummon Picas No upon Ow DISlllct Justll:O dosignated thetsm on
(dale 01 servIce) . HL___, 0 hy plH5011ltl 5011/1(0 [lilY (ctHl1flCdl (roglsterod) mall. sOl1der',
reeel", nlll1ched herelo. nnd upon thu i1p~)('lIee ((1(11110_' ..__.____ __ ____~___ . on
, 19--0 by porsonal SC''IH;U Ll by ({.l!ltllll'lJl tluUl5tUltHt) mall, s(JlH1p"s f1Jt.:1J1pl attached hOlolo.
o and lu,tho,lhatlservod Ihe Rulo 10 F,lo a Cu'"plilllllacculllpiHlylllU Iho dUUVU Nul'co ul App"al upunth. "ppellee(l) lowhom
the Rule WRS addressed on _._ ~ ~___ __, 19_ ..___~ [) hy PUISOllfll SOIl,tiCC 0 hy (CfHtlllcd) (registered)
mall, sandor's recoipt attached her[!to
SWORN (AFFIRMED) AND SUBSCRIOED BEFORE ME
THIS
DAY OF__,_,_H___. 10___
$lgflllhJtI 01 O'f'Cldl tHllma ""hum al/'lldl'l "',l~ rfI""R
r,fl. 010"1'1'1
MV COmmilllon 81lpUe!l on
,19__
l~
"'-
t;
~,
~'-
~J
'\:,
"-
~/\ :$.
<:";
&~
~ 't
.... ~
..... :'-
" "
~;~'~
~
.'--'
r
~
S/llrl"UI9 01 ,""n,
),",
.....
l' i.f
~,T "
.. "~I'
;;,!' .,
'.;. ".'
.r . t l~
l~"::.. ~I
t. l\'')''''
.< . ill! -
,w. .')'~
J" -'f
_, ,l-
~..
-<
..
0')
'"
"
~
ttf
COUNTY OF: ~UI'ID"""""U
PLAINTIFF "I:UUI:D I rU"M
r- NAt.lF.II'dAUnnIOA
GRAIIAM MOTOR COMPANY, INC.
1402 1I0LLY PIn
CARLISLE, PA 17013
L
J
IrMg B'1l No
.,
09-3-03
OJ N.rne "on
....-
SUSAN 1<' DAY
229 MILL STREET, BOX 167
MT. 1I0LLY SPRINGS. PA
DEFENDANT
r.; NAME and AOOf.B8
SLOTHOWER, CINDY
41 BEACIICLIFF DR.
CARLISLE, PA 17013
L
J
VS,
,_ 17171486-7672
17065
.,
SUSAN 1<' DAY
229 MILL STREET, BOX 167
MT. HOLLY SPRINGS, PA 17065
Docket No.: CV-0000107-95
Date Flied: 4/12/95
Pl.... be adviltd thlt an apPlal hal bltn flI.d In the ,bon captioned call Klndty ".. thl' form to Indlcat. the ,..un.
in thlt UII, and f,turn to thl illulng authority (hltod abovo)
REBUL T OF APPUL
IUMMARY APPEAL
APPEAL STRICKEN. .1'1'..1 h.. b.ln diullo,,"d
APPEAL DISCONTINUED. .1'1'..1 h.. b.ln dllonl,"".d by Ipp.lI.nl
DISTRICT JUSTICE DECISION UPHELD. CO"" h.. ,..ch.d I.m. d.clllon .. o/lgln.1 dlll/ic' J""llc. d.clllon.
_ dill' lei JUIlIel offiCII, to coll'GI r.malning fin.alool'l.
APPEAL SUCCESSFUL. CO"" h.I/.lchld d.clllon '.vo/.bl. 10 d.l.ndlnl
lull ,.I"nd 10 b. I,,".d by dlll,lcl 1""Uc. offlc.
partial flfund 10 be '"uld by dlltl!c' JUltlot oHlol
REVISED DISTRIBUTION OF FINES AND COSTS
"dl.lflct IUIUo. offic.l, to l..u. . plr1lel re'und, pl.... Indicet. any new dlllubutlon In thl Imount(l)
of fin.. and cOI'a II I ,lIult of Ihl COUlt'1 dlelllon
FINE
COUNTY CRT COST
STATE CRT COST
STATE CST!
HEARINQ COST
EMS
CAT
JCP
evc
CVC
CCD
OTHERlpl....lpoclfyl
CIVIL APPeAL
APPEAL STRICKEN. .1'1'..1 h.1 b..n dll.llo...d
APPEAL DISCONTINUED. Ippo.' h.. b.ln d..conl,n".d by Ipp.lI.nl
DISTRICT JUSTICE DECISION UPHELD. CO"" h..II.ch.d Ih. I.m. d.,ltlon.1 Ih. dlll"c' I""U,. J"dgm.nt.
DISTRICT JUSTICE DECISION DISMISSED. 00"" h.1 ,..oh.d I d.clt'on Ihll do.. nol conc", ..K" Ih. dllltlcl 1""lc.l"dgm.nt
WRIT or CERTIORARI
WRIT STRICKEN. .1'1'..1 h.. b..n dlUllo...d
WRIT DISCONTINUED. writ hi' be.n d.tLonlllwelt hr .ppeUIIlI
DISTRICT JUSTICE DECISION BET ASIUf: . the nil WIll bl f.h'I,d dUIlo lI11yullllty.I.';h ullUlltdictlon. 0' Improper v.n",.
WRIT DISMISSED. d..hlet IUlhe. dlCI'iun w.. nol found to b, 'I.wltt. IltklllQ )lJIltlhLUon , 01 hiving Impfoplf venuI
ITATEMENT or OIlJECTlON CPl.... Ilv.. ..n.,.I."mm.,y 0' Ih.,..ultl)
OBJECTION OISCONlINUl:O. objecllun lilt buon dllLU'llll1uld hV 1111 'Ilpellllll
OBJEctION OENIUl. obJ,cllon h.. hltn dl"I.I' hV Ih, Cowt of CnnutlQn PI'..
OBJECTION upttno . .pp.u."r. ObJI"lliJll ".. ,)"" upheld by Ih. Cow, ~I CtmHH(HI Plul
I
,
i
~ .
AOPC 12U.14
FOItH I'IIIN'I'EDI
6/011/95
"
14145104
Graham Motor Company, Inc.,
a Pennsylvania corporation,
I'lalnU ff
I N TIlE COURT ot' COMMON PI.KAS Ot.
CUMllt:RI.AND COUNTY. PENNSYI.v.\NIA
NO. 3067
CIVil.
1995
v.
cynthia SlothowDr,
DDflllldant
RULE 1312-1, The Petition for A"polntment of Arbitrators shall be substsntially
in the following forml
PETITION FOR APP(JlNTIll"NT 01' ARBITRATORS
TO TilE 1I0NORABLE. TilE JUDGES OF SAID COURT:
Edward E. GUido . ('uunsul for the plaillt1ft/<I~dant In
the above action (nr-lIC'tiomr), respectfully represunts that:
1. The abovo-captioned actloll /ur-ncetuns) 10 tanrl at IS8118'
2. The .:Ialm of the plaintiff in the Bctlon 10 $.1,140.90
The counterclaim of the defendant In tho action Is None
The followlnll attorneys are Interostod In the
wiss disqualified to sit as arbltratorsl
casa(s)
Roqer
as counsol or are other-
Morqenthal. Esauire
WH!RI!FORl, your pstitionsr prays your Honorable Court to appoint three (3)
arbitratora to vho. tha caae shsll be submitted.
Re~ubmltted'
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, !J l (' I , I L, [, ,
L
, 19~, in consideration of the
Esq., IJ,'J, /,"1 JJk (;,ilb
' ,J
,Esq., ero sppolnted arbitrators In the
forelloing petition,
It) )1 , J
f / I II.' ill .
/
I
Eiq.. and L I.
It, i~' "~
'J ' / l
~ >'1 11 " ~)
abovs-captloned action (or actions) as prayed for.
Byph' Court,
-- '_LL~'I\ -(~___) -L;
\ J It J.
q lfJ q
1" I tJl
:::J ::l
'"111-;-1 '1 I,~~
U1 j I :..,
~~ ~ J !
::'''f, I"~
1.1 ~'_: (.1
! '. ~ , :'7" c.J-
':;(1 :1: (j~
~. C J ~ ~
...~. ; ',.
::j .- ~
-< -I:'"
,
"
-,
Ll
...
",
~
~:
SAIDIS, GUIDO,
SHUFF "
MASLAND
26 W, IlIlh Slml
CIIII,I..PA
GRAHAM MOTOR
Pennsylvania
COMPANY, INC., a
Corporation,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
CYTIINIA SLOTIIOWER,
Defendant
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
NO. 95-3067 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
PRAECIPE
Please mark the above-captioned matter satisfied and paid in
full.
Date: .5'("/11..
." ~,'.
Respectfully submitted,
SAIDIS,
UFF & MASLAND
b
By:
Edward E. Guido, Esquire
Supreme Ct. 1.0. . 21206
26 West High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243-6222
Attorney for Plaintiff
l
r
I
"J
J
"
.:.1
'. l
~ j fl
-.
1
"
....: