HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-03338
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
: CUSTODYNISITATION
. J'l?
; NO. 95_33 CIVIL TERM
v.
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN
Defendant
AND NOW, ,::TIA,," ~
ORDER OF COURT
, 19 9S,-upon consideration of the attached
Complaint, it is hereby directed that the parties and their respective counsel appear before
~. 'f.. 6-: l,uy tsq , the conciliator, at L ....0), (Un-.b,
((l. ("'.r1h>"/I on the 115'/ k day of ;!}v.,'JIAd-' , 199..2...., at )D: 3:.>
.
o'clock, Pm., for a Pre-Hearing Custody Conference. At such conference, an effort wilJ
be made to resolve the issues in dispute; or if this cannot be accomplished, to define and
narrow the issues to be heard by the Court, and to enter into a temporary order. All
children age five or older may also be present at the conference. Failure to appear at the
conference may provide grounds for entry of a temporary or permanent order.
FOR THE COURT:
By: ~<-{L;~k -fi I 'J~I#L~
~ConciliatOr -t~~1
The Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County is required by law to comply with the
Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. For information about accessible facilities and
reasonable accommodations available to disabled individuals having business before the
court, please contact our office. All arrangements must be made at least 72 hours prior to
any hearing or business before the court. You must attend the scheduled conference or
hearing.
YOU SHOULD TAKE nus PAPER TO YOUR LAwYER AT ONCE, IF
YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAwYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO
TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND
OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Office of the Court Administrator
Cumberland County Court House, Fourth Floor
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 240-6200
!
/.-.
JUL 3 3 25 I'n '95
_, '.'.., );HlE
Of .tli '!li}I1' !'f I
Gill,' . ,..,1
''JI''":!'t' "1,,1, ,. . f"
., ".;^ ,. . ,
t ~ ...', .. ! L ... ,ij ...
7/3/95" ad. tbf;; Iffd..d./ ~ 4- j~~
'7/3/95 ~ ~ ,0 df!
'1/3/93 ~ ~eI -4. 0/1. ~ #
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
PlaintiCC
v.
: IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
.
: CIVIL ACfION - LAW
: CUSTODYNISITATION
: NO. 95- CIVIL TERM
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant
COMPLAINT FOR CUSTODY
1. The PlaintiCC is RONNIE E. HONICK, SR, residing at 8 Franklin Street, Lot 4,
Mt. Holly Springs, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, 17065.
2. The DeCendant is MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN, Connerly MICHELLE R.
PORTER, whose last-known residence is 1016 Hullview Avenue #A, NorColk, VA 23503.
3. Plaintiff seeks custody of the following children:
NAME
RESIDENCE
DOB
3/22/89
AGE
6 yr. 3 mth.
Autumn R. Honick
Ronnie E. Honick Jr.
8 Franklin Street, Lot 4
Mt. Holly Springs, PA 17065
8 Franklin Street, Lot 4
Mt. Holly Springs, PA 17065
The children were born out of wedlock.
10/12/90
4 yr. 8 mth.
The children are presently in the physical control of the Defendant, Michelle R.
Rabenstein. However, in accordance with an agreement between the parties dated
October 25, 1993, and since October 25, 1993, the children have been in the custody of the
Plaintiff, Ronnie E. Honick, Sr.
During their lives, the children have resided with the following persons and at the
following addresses:
NAME ADDRESS
DATES
Ronnie E. Honick Sr. 8 Franklin Street, Lot 4
Mt. Holly Springs, PA 17065
Michelle R. Porter, now 538 W. Louther Street
Michelle R. Rabenstein Carlisle, PA 17013
10/93 to Present
4/93 to 10/93
ft>
Ronnie E. Honick, Sr.
(Ronnie E. Honick Jr.
only)
Michelle R. Porter 538 W. Louther Street
(Autumn R. Honick only) Carlisle, PA 17013
8 Franklin Street, Lot 4
Mt. Holly Springs, PA 17065
1/93 to 4193
1193 to 4193
Ronnie E. Honick, Sr.
Michelle R. Porter
538 W. Louther Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
To 1193
The mother of the children is MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN, formerly MICHELLE
R. PORTER, who it is believed currently resides at 1016 Hullview Avenue #A, Norfolk,
Virginia, 23503. She is married.
The father of the children is RONNIE R. HONICK, SR., currently residing at 8
Franklin Street, Lot 4, Mt. Holly Springs, Pennsylvania, 17065. He is unmarried.
4. The relationship of the Plaintiff to the children is that of Father. The Plaintiff
currently resides alone with the children.
5. The relationship of the Defendant to the children is that of Mother. The
Defendant currently resides with her current husband, Edward L. Rabenstein II.
6. Plaintiff has not participated as a party or witness, or in another capacity, in
other litigation concerning the custody of the children in this or another court.
Plaintiff has no information of a custody proceeding concerning the children pending
in a court of this Commonwealth.
Plaintiff does not know of a person not a party to the proceedings who has physical
custody of the children or claims to have custody or visitation rights with respect to the
children.
7. The best interest and permanent welfare of the children will be served by
granting the relief requested for the following reasons:
A. On October 25, 1993, Plaintiff and Defendant entered into a
written agreement which provided that Plaintiff, Ronnie E. Honick, Sr., would
have custody of the two children who are the subject of this Complaint. A
copy of that agreement is marked Exhibit A, attached hereto, and made a
part hereof.
B. Since October 25, 1993, the children have continuously resided with
the Plaintiff, Ronnie E. Honick, Sr., at his home at S Franklin Street, Lot 4,
Mt. Holly Springs, Pennsylvania, 17065.
C. Since October 25, 1993, Defendant, Michelle R. Rabenstein,
formerly Michelle R. Porter, has only had sporadic contact with the children
and, in fact, up until June S, 1995, had not seen them for approximately S
months.
D. By the agreement of the parties and at the initia lion of the
Plaintiff, Ronnie E. Honick, Sr., because he thought it was in the best interest
of the children, arrangements were made for Michelle R. Rabenstein to pick
up the children on June S, 1995, and as part of that agreement she was to
return them to Plaintiff on Father's Day, June IS, 1995.
E. The Defendant has failed to return the children to the Plaintiff as
previously agreed upon, has failed to contact the Plaintiff regarding the
children's whereabouts, and when Plaintiff has attempted to phone Defendant
Plaintiff has been advised that the phone has been disconnected.
F. Plaintiff has undertaken and performed the primary parental
responsibilities for the children and specifically has been their primary
caretaker since October 1993.
G. Plaintiff is bcst able to provide thc carc and nurture which the
children need for healthy dcvc10pmcnt and, in fact, thc children have
consistently bcen enrollcd at the Bethel Christian Acadcmy which Plaintiff has
paid for.
H. A court ordcr of custody is nccessary so that thcre are no
misunderstandings rcgarding custody and partial custody and so that the
children are not used in a manipulative fashion.
I. Plaintiff desires to maintain the family household which has been
established since October 1993 and thc continucd stability of the household is
in the best interest of the children.
J. Defendant is erratic and apparcntly attempted suicide in
approximately April 1994, and her behavior poscs a threat of harm to the
children.
8. Each parent whose parental rights to the children havc not been terminated and
the person who has physical custody of the children have been named as parties to this
action.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully rcquests this Honorable Court to enter an order
granting custody of the children to Plaintiff.
Rcspectfully submitted,
ANDREWS & JOHNSON
Ronald E. Jo s
Attorney for I' tiff
78 West Po f t Strcct
Carlisle, P~ 17013
Tclephone: (717) 243-0123
Supremc Court Ib No. 16453
~
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA )
: SS.
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND )
I verify that the statements made in the foregoing Complaint are true and correct. I
understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of IS Pa.C.S.
g4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
DATE: c"TuAJ' p~ 9-r
~~.~;/
Ronnie E. Honic , Sr., Plainl1ff
':-;"~:.~~:~~~:-~~:~::~,':::.:::.;.", ~.:.':~':'7:~~.._~::':~'.7;~ :~-~.: "" .
!
.... .~ .,., . . . .. ~':' ~_............ ,
6f10lS; /7'93
O~ ,4~/,~;4?E/U1 1 ~;AJ/~' c! /L,'cJ
,H~J ~c~~ z g~1/f" 'fY~f<:'
~I ~~~~ cr. 4/c~~ /A.JI'/I- ~A(J<-
i euslcct/ .3';: oU'~ 7UJO ~,;{/~/J,
!A~/F7~ )(~/l~ /~/'c/ ~d ~/wE. E,
#,v/c/( -r-4k /N~O ?VI'/( ,}z AiS~ 5r;1/:;:;-
:14/ ,8- frHNPt $1 o~ (1~
4f~~.5, ~C:I7~& . ~/C c: :7
i to 6 I' 5 \ ~ U ,'I\..l t9 /071 #;r.A!!"...-e/',
chI! d 1Ci.^J <2.U<i-tey o1k<i.K W ~ ~k5N
e>~A ~1\~ ON /1- '5"- 93 ~t:At,l~ R
i ;:z,&,<'.:!:>j /rJ ~~j(~Nds ~{ftJ;ef.:s ' slL
I IV/It ~f.56 ,,5.4t.1'L /k Ch/~~A.J
/I- ~A//' /1 ~7 6MJ /1/1 Aol"t'l1ys
/?/Vd ~~C,l~/ oce /9.;5/0"/f./..:3 :5ucf{,
I,4S };I'~d~/,.s c>r<: /Z~l~/;v'i.5 UISI/,'tj9""
/11 - e:2S'- 73
l 0 -;;":5" . 'lJ..
I
:1~ ~ ~~
OrJJwuo?y'/ /C{q3
~~~~~~J~L,;t .
"" .~..
I.~l/.'.. \1 ~.. I
f ~I.:~....;. 'rCIl-:-: ~'t":.R', '::1;:1. r
I' O:;Arctlt.Ll 60F\tllh~l, (1.11l'r:( fit Al;("l UJUPtlV
_ H\' l:OMMI~SION [~pr~lS AH\II ..Z '~97
..............-..--
e,K /I
::::J
. ..
..... .r:>-
~ -r"-
Q..; "', I ..-
N ufOl,:..;<j
r:) 4:;;;-:"~
t'o... ;'; jl:- ~:~ ,!
- ,;;.'.oj.-.'
",o" ~i 1'1
~ """":1':;;
.,;,.[jj!,o.J
,~~ :.~;'"
\~ ",'.'
'1j
~
\'i
t') \
'1~
~\)
~
^~
" \:P
~~
~~
J ~ ~
~ ~ -4-< -
O!~ it z
~] 0
-~U@i cn~1
~ I ~ r- I~ ~ ~~ ~~
r · . I i~I~~
d~1 . a:
w > i
! ~I~!~
~ u2B !fl ~<~
. .
.' .
. .
. .
/If. ~l'<{
f;
,. -.
Ju~ 29
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintif~, :
I l~f~ '9~N THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
. , ":' : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
!:', ~I.:, ~
,> ,
v.
,: ,; CIVIL ACTION - LAW
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant
.
.
.
.
95-3338 CIVIL TERM
IN RE: CUSTODY
TEMPORARY ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 29th day of June, 1995, upon
consideration of the Plaintiff's Petition for Special Relief
Pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. 1915.13, and following a hearing at which
the Defendant did not appear notwithstanding that she was served
with notice of the hearing, it is ordered and directed as
follows:
1. Legal custody of the parties' children,
Autumn R. Honick, born March 22, 1989, and Ronnie E. Honick,
Jr., born October 12, 1990, shall be shared by the parties.
2. Primary physical custody of the said children
shall be in the Plaintiff, Ronnie E. Honick, Sr. Temporary or
partial custody of the children shall be in the Defendant,
Michelle R. Rabenstein, on alternating weekends from 7:00 p.m.
on Friday until 7:00 p.m. on Sunday, on a half-day on each
holiday, and on a half-day on special occasions such as
birthdays or visitation of relatives.
This Order is a Temporary Order which shall
remain in effect only until the custody conciliation conference
-
is held in this matter and further Order of Court.
Both parties are advised that any violation of
this Order could result in sanctions for contempt of court.
By the Court,
RONALD E. JOHNSON, ESQUIRE
78 West Pomfret Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
For the Plaintiff
Michelle R. Rabenstein
1016 HUlview Avenue, #A
Norfolk, VA 23503
wcy
_ ~ ~ t,/.Jq(QS'
.Jl~.
-
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant
95-3338 CIVIL TERM
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Wendy C. Yinger, Court Reporter, do hereby certify
that I have served a true and correct copy of the attached Order
of Court by depositing the same in the United States Mail at
Carlisle, Pennsylvania, first class postage prepaid, on the date
indicated below, upon the following person at the following
address:
Michelle R. Rabenstein
1016 Hulview Avenue, #A
Norfolk, VA 23505
Date: June 29, 1995
..-..:
-
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff
v.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant
NO. 95-3338 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 2{~t day of June, 1995, upon consideration of
Plaintiff's Petition for Special Relief Pursuant to Pa. R.C.P.
1915.13, a hearing is SCHEDULED in this matter for Thursday, June
29, 1995, at 8130 a.m., in Courtroom No.5, Cumberland County
Courthouse, Carlisle, Pennsylvania.
BY THE COURT,
Ronald E. Johnson, Esq.
78 West Pomfret Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Attorney for Plaintiff
:re
[r
.t1
-l:
iA-El-
{: t~
, ,
~
~f
~ .
,,,,,
....t(
..
viH1:",S!iH3d
H""o)~ OIIV'1l31nn~
':''lV1:'HC\llo)~'! 11li. JO
3~IHO"P-'''
56. "J EO 2 IZ NOr
"
RONNIE E. I-IONICK, SIt
Petitioner/Pla in tiff
IN TIlE couln OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUM/lEl~LANI> COUNTY, I'ENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
NO. 95"33J~ CIVIL TERM
CUSTOI>Y/vISITATION
V.
MICHELLE R. I~ABENSTElN
Respondent/Defendant
ORI)I~R m" COURT
AND NOW, this
dllY of June, 1995, in consideration of the
attached Petition for Special Relief, the I'etltlon is grantcd and custody of Autumn R.
Honick and Ronnie E. Honick, Jr., is hereby awarded to Petitioner, RONNIE E. HONICK,
SR., pending the conciliation conference which shall be scheduled on the custody complaint
which has been filed, or until further order of this Court.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED AND DECREED that Respondent, MICHELLE R.
RABENSTEIN. shall inunediately deliver custody of Autumn R. Honick and Ronnie E.
Honick, Jr., to the Petitioner, RONNIE E. HONICK, SR., upon service of this Order of
Court.
BY THE COURT:
J.
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.
Petitioner/Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 95- CIVIL TERM
CUSTODYNISITATION
V.
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN
RespondentlDefendant
PETITION FOR SPECIAL RELIEF
PURSUANT TO PA. R.C.P. 1915.13
Pursuant to Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure 1915.13, the above-named
Plaintiff, RONNIE E. HONICK, SR., by and through his attorneys, Andrews & Johnson
and Ronald E. Johnson, Esquire, respectfully sets forth the following in support of his
Petition for Special Relief pertaining to custody:
1. Petitioner is RONNIE E. HONICK, SR., an adult individual residing at 8
Franklin Street, Lot 4, Mt. Holly Springs, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, 17065.
2. Respondent is MICHELLE R, RABENSTEIN, formerly MICHELLE R.
PORTER, an adult individual, whose last-known residence is 1016 Hulview Avenue, #A,
Norfolk, Virginia, 23503.
3. Petitioner and Respondent herein are the parents of Autumn R. Honick born
March 22, 1989, and Ronnie E. Honick, Jr., born October 12, 1990, said children being the
subject of this custody action.
4. Contemporaneously herewith, Petitioner has filed a Complaint for Custody. A
copy of the Complaint for Custody is attached hereto for reference as Exhibit and
the averments of the Complaint for Custody are incorporated herein.
t..___
5. On October 25, 1993, l'etitioner and Respondent entered into a written
agreement which provided that Petitioner, Ronnie E. HOllick, Sr., would have custody of
the two children who are the subjects of this custody action. A copy of that agreement is
marked Exhibit A, attached hereto and made a part hereof.
6. Since October 25, 1993, the children have continuously resided with Petitioner,
Ronnie E. Honick, Sr., at his home at 8 Franklin Street, Lot 4, Mt. Holly Springs,
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, 17065.
7. Petitioner herein, following the execution of the written agreement referred to
in paragraph 5 above on October 25, 1993, filed a support action through the Domestic
Relations Section of the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County. An Order of
Court dated December 14, 1993, ordering the Respondent herein to pay the Petitioner
support for the two children was entered based upon the agreement of the parties. A copy
of the Agreement and Order of Court for support is marked Exhibit B, attached hereto and
made a part hereof.
8. In support of Petitioner's averment in paragraph 6 above that the children have
continuously resided with him since October 1993, a copy of a recent print-out from the
Domestic Relations Office dated May 17, 1995, indicating the continuing support obligation
due from the Respondent to the Petitioner is marked Exhibit C, attached hereto and made
a part hereof.
9. Since October 25, 1993, Respondent, Michelle R. Rabenstein, formerly Michelle
R. Porter, has only had sporadic contact with the children and, in fact, as of June 8, 1995,
had not seen the children for approximately eight months prior thereto.
10. As a result of questions posed to Petitioner by the children regarding their
mother and her failure to see the children, Petitioner initiated contact with Respondent and
suggested that she spend some time with the children.
11. As a result of said contact, Petitioner and Respondent reached an agreement
whereby Respondent was to pick up the children on June S, 1995, and return the children
to Petitioner on Father's Day, June IS, 1995.
12, Respondent did not return the children as previously agreed to on Father's Day,
Sunday, June IS, 1995, and in fact as of the date of the filing of this Petition Respondent
has not had any contact with Petitioner.
13. Petitioner has attempted to telephone Respondent at two separate phone
numbers which he had available to him and he has been advised in both instances that
those telephone numbers have been disconnected.
14. Petitioner is unsure as to the whereabouts of his children and is extremely
concerned regarding their whereabou ts and their safety and welfare since he has had
absolutely no contact regarding their whereabouts and Respondent has breached the oral
agreement previously entered into to return the children.
15. Petitioner has contacted the Mt. Holly Springs Police Department to obtain
their assistance in having the children returned to him, but to date the Mt. Holly Springs
Police have been unable to be of any assistance in that regard.
16. Petitioner is afraid for the safety of his children, is unsure as to where they may
be, and believes that unless an immediate order granting him custody of the children
pending a conciliation hearing is granted, that the Respondent will fail to respond and
appear at said hearing and that the safety and best interest and permanent welfare of the
children will be in jeopardy.
WHEREFORE, Petitioner prays your Honorable Court pursuant to Pennsylvania
Rule of Civil Procedure 1915.13 to enter an interim order granting Petitioner, RONNIE
E. HONICK, SR., custody of Autumn R. Honick and Ronnie E. Honick, Jr., until the
conciliation conference or until further order of this Court and to further order that
Respondent deliver custody of the children immediately to the Petitioner.
Respectfully submitted,
ANDREWS & JOHNSON
By:
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA )
: SS.
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND )
I verify that the statements made in the foregoing Petition are true and correct. I
understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of IS Pa.C.S.
g49Q4, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities,
DATE: ~..'I ,;} I,; ?~
?I~. ~~~/ J
. Ronnie E, Hoilic, r., Petitioner
. -~a1t..:::~~;;:~"': . '-:i~;::;~.'~~:.:.~~;. :.~.:;\;~:v,::::,<'/.::-: .
, . '
_.__........._..u.:.....,......_~., ....... _..... ., ,.
6f10lS; /7'93
O~ ,4~~~;4?E/U11 ~;AJ/~' c! /L,'cJ
,H~J ~c~~ z ~~,,< 'fY~5<:'
~I ~~~~ cr. 4/c~~ /A.JI,'/I- ~A(J<-
I euslcct/ .3';: oU'~ ~o ~.;{/~/J,
I A~/F7~ )(~%~ /~/C/ ~d ~/wE. E,
/A; I 'e/(E', IN.)o ?VI'/( .Jz AiS~ 5r;1/:;:;-
:14/ 8 -r-4 kHNPt $1 ou"V/ (1~~
~~s. ~'ct7..1k . Z <!: /?
to 6 " 5 \ ~ U.'I\:I t9 /071 ///f'",e'",e/'
Chtlct1Ci.^J <2.u<i-rey 01('\<(')(' W~~k5N
e>~A ~1\~ ON /1- '5"- 93 ~t:At,l~ R
;:z,&,<'.:!:>j /rJ ~~j(~Nds ~{~Jef.s . $JL
IO/If /J{56 ~/1t/!.. ;/l~ C~/~EAJ
~ hA/~ /I ~/ eN ~/I Aolt'/1ys
/?/Vd ~~C,l/;/ ace /l~/O.N..:3 :5C/cf[.
,,4:5 ,b1'~;r/~yrS 01< /Z~/AliV~.5 U,SI htvj>.-
I
~Wvw, ~ ~~
{Jd!~ ,xy/ I W3
~~~ ~~"'~.
, '~uTl.';' \1 s:' I
f, ~;,:~~~:, ~ h)tJ:;.: f't. :.R', '~:Hl, f
I i CA~l,t.ll &OFltjU\,~, Cll,.h:d';[ AI; ['I' C.OUft!V
MY \~OMMI~SION EXPIHlS ^P;,U ~z 1~~1
1_ l ..
/d -e2:9- 93
{O-;vs.'{J.
A/
&/9
AGREEHENT rOil OIUlER or 5UI'I'OHT
"bovl' llilmJd \>lailltiff and Defendant hereby ar,ree that the Defendillll shall pay the
35.00 per week for and toward the support of hilr children. Autumn R..
22 89 and Ronnie E. born 10 12 90. There is no affordable
e available at the resent time. Arreara es are set at 155
direct a ment of 20.00. Defendant to a 5 00 er wee
--
IlCHELLE R. PORTER
, llEn:NIlANT
DR _U..H.L_
IN TIl~: COURT 01' COHMON PU:AS OF
CUHBERLAND COUNTY, P~:NNSYLVAN1^
DOMESTIC R~:LATIONS SECTION
CIVIL ACTION - SUPPORT
NO. lliL2_ OF 1993
:ONNIE E. 1l0NICK
, PLAINTlFF
v.
which sum shall be paid through the Domestic Relations Office, P.O. Box 320, Carlisle, PA
17013, beginning 11116/93 The Defendant agrees to pay the costs in the amount of
S 16.00 which sum includes the pro-rated Service Fee of $ 1.00 , payable 90 davs
fhe parties further agree to inform the Domestic Kelations uttice of any change in writing
within seven days of such change. Should a party wilfully fail to inform the Domestic
Relations Office of the required information, the court may adjudge the party to be in con-
tempt of court pursuant to Rule 1910.21 and may order tbe party to be punished by one or more
of the following: jail, fine or probation. X l./hen accumulated arrears equal or exceed one
month's support obligation the Defendant 's i~me will automatically be attached. The
defendant's income is attached,
Dated: This 14th day of December
J .'
_~.1 ~ .J. ~.u_
\Htness to ignatures .
, 19-21..,
L/?~. ,
#, tit" !:,
De' n~nt
ORDER OF COURT
AND NO\~. this 14th day of December . 19 93 . upon consideration of the above
Agreement. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND DIRECTED that the iie1Cndant pay through the Domestic
Relations Office. P.O. Box 320, Carlisle, PA 17013, the sum of S 35.00 per week
for and toward the support of her children, Autumn R.. born 3/22/89 and Ronnie E.. born
19/12/90. There is no affordable medical insurance coveraRe available at the oesent time.
Arrearages are set at $155.00 as of this date due to direct payment of $20.00. Defendant
to pay $5.00 per week on the arrearages.
The first payment shall be due on 11/16/93 and subsequent payments shall be due
every week thereafter, The Defendant shall pay the costs of $ 16.00 . which sum in-
cludes the pro-rated Service ree of S 1.00 ,payable 90 days IT IS FURTHER
ORDERED that the parties inform the Domestic Relations Office of any change of address of any
child receiving support, and/or employ",ent in writing within seven days of such change.
Should a party wilfully fail to inform the Domestic Relations Office of the required infor-
mation, the court may adjudge the party to be in contempt of court pursuant to Rule 1910.21
and may order the party to be punished by one or more of the following: jail. fine or pro-
bation. X ~len accumulated arrears equal or exceed one month's support obligation the
Defendant~ncome will automatically be attached. The Defendant's income is attached.
BY THE COURT. ~
~~
Sally S. Kreilzer
Plaintiff & Defendant
U;$
J.
ORO:
XC:
-. -------,
n;'197~j
11.'5 fi '1:1
filiP P !lH'1
05/\7/95
'II'NGIUN, MICliFI.II'
,t, A filii I I V H W AVI.
.'FOLK, '.'/1
1 cJ 1 6'r.!'lll,;!6
II/071l1
2350~J r 0
. I
950;~0~?
linN I C K. IlIlNN I E 1'. 1/25,',/,'/H5
f1 f HAN"'I 1 tI filllEr 1 O;'/O;'I'I~I
IIII' IJ
~n. HDlI Y !;l'fU NG!l, I'A \70b!d 1(1(1 1 C
N 4~041
:l~l. on W It 116/<,':1 l;'/;Jl/l/:1 ('", KH :15 I~!I~ 1 ~1
."
n.oc)
o. DO
'IEARS 1461.58- t t /~1;2I94 40.00 PAY/"IEN rH Co. 00 n.oo 0.1)0
';'18 15. on,. 10/~!1I94 3~~. 42 ClI/lnm H 105.00- ~!45. 00, "i/O.OO
1"-) 53.00- 10/lt/94 80.00 AD.)",} r,:; 0.00 c.. 00 a.oo
\JMS 0.00 0.00 f'^YMFNH~ 0.00 0.00 0.00
'irITUl ION 0.00 0.00 PAYMENlS 0.00 0.00 O.O!)
'II II 0.00 94081EI 40.00 PAY/"lFNn: 0.00 0.00 (1,(10
0,INNING BALANCE 726.58-
';'1/94 nUl: 85.00- 761.5B- (II
1c)3/95 DUE :35.00- 1'76. 58- 0:2
105/95 FEF!i 2t.. no- 796. 58, Or.~
110/95 DUE 35.00 - 831.58- 03
117icl~i DUl: :15. 00,- f166. 58,' 04
1~~4/95 DUE 35.00- 901.58- 05
131/95 DUF :15.00- 936. 58- 06
'/07/95 DUE 85. 00- 971. 58- 07
114/9~, DUE': 35.00" 1006.58- 08
'/21195 DUE :15.00- 1041.58- 09
'/28/'/~, nur :l~,_ 00- 1076.58- 10
1/07/95 1)1),= 35.00 . 1111.58-- 11
1/14/95 nllE :<';,00- 114b.5EI- 12
1/21/95 DUE :15.00, 1181. 58- 13
:;;'8/'15 DUE :1~,. 00-- 1;'16.5EI' 14
1/04/95 DUE 35. 00 - 1 :~51. 58- 15
',I 111'15 DUI: :lti.OO- 12E16.5H' It.
.f/18/95 DUE 35.00 - 1321. 58- 1 7
1/25/95 Dl!F' 3~I, 00- 1356. 58, 1[1
i/02/95 OUt-: 35.00- 1391 . 58 ' 19
,,/09/95 DUE :l~j. 00- 1421>. 58,. t:!O
.~ / I h/fi5 DIIE :l~;. 00" 1 4 t, 1. 58- 21
4.c...
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
: CUSTODYNISITATI0N
.
: NO. 95- CIVIL TERM
v.
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN
Defendant
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW,
, 19_, upon consideration of t~e attached
Complaint, it is hereby directed that the parties and their respective counsel appear before
, the conciliator, at
on the
day of
, 199-, at
o'clock, _.m., for a Pre-Hearing Custody Conference. At such conference, an effort will
be made to resolve the issues in dispute; or if this cannot be accomplished, to define and
narrow the issues to be heard by the Court, and to enter into a temporary order. All
children age five or older may also be present at the conference. Failure to appear at the
conference may provide grounds for entry of a temporary or permanent order.
FOR THE COURT:
By:
Custody Conciliator
The Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County is required by law to comply with the
Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. For information about accessible facilities and
reasonable accommodations available to disabled individuals having business before the
court, please contact our office. All arrangements must be made at least 72 hours prior to
any hearing or business before the court. You must attend the scheduled conference or
hearing.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE, IF
YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO
TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND
OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Office of the Court Administrator
Cumberland County Court House, Fourth Floor
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 240.6200 f1< tJ
"...~
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff
v.
: IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
: CUSTODYNISITATION
: NO. 95. CIVIL TERM
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant
COMPLAINT FOR CUSTODY
1. The Plaintiff is RONNIE E. HONICK, SR, residing at 8 Franklin Street, Lot 4,
Mt. Holly Springs, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, 17065.
2. The Defendant is MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN, formerly MICHELLE R.
PORTER, whose last-known residence is 1016 Hullview Avenue #A, Norfolk, VA 23503.
3. Plaintiff seeks custody of the following children:
NAME RESIDENCE DOB AGE
Autumn R. Honick 8 Franklin Street, Lot 4 3122189 6 yr, 3 mth.
Mt. Holly Springs, PA 17065
Ronnie E. Honick Jr. 8 Franklin Street, Lot 4 10/12190 4 yr. 8 mth.
Mt. Holly Springs, PA 17065
The children were born out of wedlock.
The children are presently in the physical control of the Defendant, Michelle R.
Rabenstein. However, in accordance with an agreement between the parties dated
October 25, 1993, and since October 25, 1993, the children have been in the custody of the
Plaintiff, Ronnie E. Honick, Sr.
During their lives, the children have resided with the following persons and at the
following addresses:
NAME ADDRESS
DATES
Ronnie E. Honick Sr. 8 Franklin Street, Lot 4
Mt. Holly Springs, PA 17065
Michelle R. Porter, now 538 W. Louther Street
Michelle R. Rabenstein Carlisle, PA 17013
10193 to Present
4193 to 10193
...'....
Ronnie E. Honick, Sr.
(Ronnie E. Honick Jr.
only)
Michelle R. Porter 538 W. Louther Street
(Autumn R. Honick only) Carlisle, PA 17013
8 Franklin Street, Lot 4
Mt. Holly Springs, PA 17065
1193 to 4193
1/93 to 4/93
Ronnie E. Honick, Sr.
Michelle R. Porter
538 W. Louther Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
To 1/93
The mother of the children is MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN, formerly MICHELLE
R. PORTER, who it is believed currently resides at 1016 Hullview Avenue #A, Norfolk,
Virginia, 23503. She is married.
The father of the children is RONNIE R. HONICK, SR., currently residing at 8
Franklin Street, Lot 4, Mt. Holly Springs, Pennsylvania, 17065. He is unmarried.
4. The relationship of the Plaintiff to the children is that of Father. The Plaintiff
currently resides alone with the children.
5. The relationship of the Defendant to the children is that of Mother. The
Defendant currently resides with her current husband, Edward L Rabenstein II.
6. Plaintiff has not participated as a party or witness, or in another capacity, in
other litigation concerning the custody of the children in this or another court.
Plaintiff has no information of a custody proceeding concerning the children pending
in a court of this Commonwealth.
Plaintiff does not know of a person not a party to the proceedings who has physical
custody of the children or claims to have custody or visitation rights with respect to the
children.
7. The best interest and permanent welfare of the children will be served by
granting the relief requested for the following reasons:
A. On October 25, 1993, Plaintiff and Defendant entered into a
written agreement which provided that Plaintiff, Ronnie E. Honick, Sr" would
have custody of the two children who are the subject of this Complaint. A
copy of that agreement is marked Exhibit A, attached hereto, and made a
part hereof.
B. Since October 25, 1993, the children have continuously resided with
the Plaintiff, Ronnie E. Honick, Sr., at his home at 8 Franklin Street, Lot 4,
Mt. Holly Springs, Pennsylvania, 17065.
C. Since October 25, 1993, Defendant, Michelle R. Rabenstein,
formerly Michelle R. Porter, has only had sporadic contact with the children
and, in fact, up until June 8, 1995, had not seen them for approximately 8
months.
D. By the agreement of the parties and at the initiation of the
Plaintiff, Ronnie E, Honick, Sr" because he thought it was in the best interest
of the children, arrangements were made for Michelle R. Rabenstein to pick
up the children on June 8, 1995, and as part of that agreement she was to
return them to Plaintiff on Father's Day, June 18, 1995.
E. The Defendant has failed to return the children to the Plaintiff as
previously agreed upon, has failed to contact the Plaintiff regarding the
children's whereabouts, and when Plaintiff has attempted to phone Defendant
Plaintiff has been advised that the phone has been disconnected.
F. Plaintiff has undertaken and performed the primacy parental
responsibilities for the children and specifically has been their primacy
caretaker since October 1993.
G. Plaintiff is best able to provide the care and nurture which the
children need for healthy development and, in fact, the children have
consistently been enrolled at the Bethel Christian Academy which Plaintiff has
paid for.
H. A court order of custody is necessary so that there are no
misunderstandings regarding custody and partial custody and so that the
children are not used in a manipulative fashion.
I. Plaintiff desires to maintain the family household which has been
established since October 1993 and the continued stability of the household is
in the best interest of the children.
J. Defendant is erratic and apparently attempted suicide in
approximately April 1994, and her behavior poses a threat of harm to the
children.
8. Each parent whose parental rights to the children have not been terminated and
the person who has physical custody of the children have been named as parties to this
action.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests this Honorable Court to enter an order
granting custody of the children to Plaintiff.
Respectfully submitted,
ANDREWS & JOHNSON
By:
Ronald E. Johnson, Esq.
Attorney for Plaintiff
78 West Pomfret Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Telephone: (717) 243-0123
Supreme Court Ib No. 16453
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA )
: SS.
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND )
I verify that the statements made in the foregoing Complaint are true and correct. I
understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of IS Pa.C.S.
g4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
DATE: c"TuAJ' ;1'., ?~
6~o~~~
In
~ ;..
Jl ttY;,
f:::! t, ,~ ~ L.) :..
", :;; ~ J
.,j-.l
-... "; ,'~
''oJ .. 1";
lJo; , ".
..:.~: ~~ '-)'
il ~
i!~~~
~ ~~~
~ e!i8
J I-I
!liE '"
-~ ~
ti~ I
~D . ~
.~ a<J!
i > ~
Ii!
~~
II
z
o
fI):tll
~j~~!:l
g~l!"e
olj!!il::~
fI)~lff~
~~~~6
~<Ie
.
.
. .'
.
-
. .
.
,-~--".. ,/'-)
-_____<'1/ \.' '" .
.
. .
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.
Petitioner/Pll'intiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 95- CIVIL TERM
CUSTODYNISITATION
V.
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN
Respondent/Defendant
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA )
.
.
COUN1Y OF CUMBERLAND )
AND NOW, this ~ "" day of 9",,-,,-
, hereby swear that on June ;; ;;1 , 1995, at approximately
, 1995, I, MIKE SUA W,
;;l :;;J. ~
o'clock,
r:J .m., I personally served a true copy of the Order of Court scheduling an emergency
,
hearing regarding custody pursuant to Plaintiffs Petition for Special Relief upon the
Defendant at her residence at 1016 Hulview Road, #A, Norfolk, Virginia, 23503, by
handing the same to her.
/~~~ d
MIke Shaw
Sworn and SUbSCri':'.d to before me this
';}f'~ day of r.....,.,. , 1995.
t/
~,'d_ .v ~.._u(';._
Notary Pub Ie
NOTARIAl. SfAl
IABlDA L 1IftEH1l. IIOTARY f1UBUC
CAllUSU 1IlllO. CUII8ERlMD COUNTY
llY ClIIIIIISSIOII EXPIRES JAIlUARY e. 1tlI8
:~~~:~.'-'~~:7-.~~:."'- .
. '. ,. .~ . ",~'. ~.. ~ . ...
,,--~~
....--_.~-.-...-... .
" -
.... - ...
..._-- ...~.'_.......,
6f10l5j /7'93
O~ ,4Y;/,~;4?E/U11 ~/V/~' c! /k,'cl:.
,HAl' /7:%'c~~ ~ g~1A' ~~ ~
i euslcct/ ..~.;: DuX' 7UJO y~/C/A~:/J
I At~/F7~ ;1;{1~ Atv,.c/ A d t'J",v/ll~E. E,
:14/ 8r4 frHNj'tt $1 ou~/ (1~
4f~~.5.. ~'cI7~& . & c: :7
to 6 115 \~u,'1\,) t9 /071 ~.A!!"",e~'.
chi! ct1Ct^J <2.u<i-rey o1k<(.)(' w ~~k5N
e>~A ~1\~ ON /1- '5"- 93 ~cAE,I~ R
i ;:z,&,<'.:!:>j /rJ ~~fC~Nds c5).{M;ef~. slL
/Vilt ~(.J6 ~~cJ~ /k c.4/,704'~A.J
/I hAIl" ,A ~y eN ;4/1 ,ho/'l1ys
I /?,;vd ~2CIA/ ace /1~/o'/LI..:3 SclC/{,
,,4S ,b1'/t!'7/~Y'rS 01'< ,R~/AI/lI~.5 Ut'SIJ,.tJj>...
I
i
.J~I ~ ~itJ
OcJo.kuo?y/ fW3
~~_r:1dO"'~ .
r ' ':0TA~'.L sr.,
, (,',~~.., .,... 'tOUI\"~ ~!(.' :,p.', "r,lr:l,r
I' CAAli~ll fl~i~I'j:Jl1'1 i:U~ira r.lMW C.OllNTV
MY t:OMM!~S'ON EXPI~(S N'RII ,2 1997
I 1:Q....... '"
/d -.;<97'3
{O-"J-:S.'{i
'f/
Elc/'9
. f'\.AJtmFP8
EXHIBIT .
0-
~/o>r, W~
0fY
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA
: CIVIL ACTION. LAW
: CUSTODYNISITATION
. J'b'
; NO. 95.33 CIVIL TERM
v.
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN
Defendant
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW,
, 19_, upon consideration of the attached
Complaint, it is hereby directed that the parties and their respective counse:l appear before
. the conciliator, at
on the
day of
,199_, at
0'c1ock, _.m" for a Pre-Hearing Custody Conference. At such conference, an effort will
be made to resolve the issues in dispute; or if this cannot be accomplished, to define and
narrow the issues to be heard by the Court, and to enter into a temporary order. All
children age five or older may also be present at the conference. Failure to appear at the
conference may provide grounds for entry of a temporary or permanent order,
FOR THE COURT:
By:
Custody Conciliator
The Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County is required by law to comply with the
Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. For information about accessible facilities and
reasonable accommodations available to disabled individuals having business before the
court, please contact our office, All arrangements must be made at least 72 hours prior to
any hearing or business before the court. You must attend the scheduled conference or
hearing.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF
YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO
TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND
OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP,
Office of the Court Administrator
Cumberland County Court House, Fourth Floor
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 240-6200
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff
: IN TIm COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
: CIVIL ACfION - LAW
: CUSTODY/vISITATlON
: NO. 95. CIVIL TERM
v.
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant
COMPLAINT FOR CUSTODY
1. The Plaintiff is RONNIE E. HONICK, SR, residing at 8 Franklin Street, Lot 4,
Mt. Holly Springs, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, 17065.
2. The Defendant is MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN, formerly MICHELLE R.
PORTER, whose last-known residence is 1016 Hullview Avenue #A, Norfolk, VA 23503,
3. Plaintiff seeks custody of the following children:
NAME RESIDENCE DOB AGE
Autumn R. Honick 8 Franklin Street, Lot 4 3/22/89 6 yr. 3 mth.
Mt. Holly Springs, PA 17065
Ronnie E. Honick Jr. 8 Franklin Street, Lot 4 10/12/90 4 yr. 8 mth.
Mt. Holly Springs, PA 17065
The children were born out of wedlock,
The children are presently in the physical control of the Defendant, Michelle R.
Rabenstein. However, in accordance with an agreement between the parties dated
October 25, 1993, and since October 25, 1993, the children have been in the custody of the
Plaintiff, Ronnie E. Honick, Sr.
During their lives, the children have resided with the fOllowing persons and at the
following addresses:
NAME ADDRESS
DATES
Ronnie E. Honick Sr. 8 Franklin Street, Lor 4
Mt. Holly Springs, PA 17065
Michelle R. Porter, now 538 W. Louther Street
Michelle R. Rabenstein Carlisle, PA 17013
10/93 to Present
4/93 to 10/93
''j''. ~
Ronnie E. Honick, Sr.
(Ronnie E. Honick Jr,
only)
Michelle R. Porter 538 W. Louther Street
(Autumn R. Honick only) Carlisle, PA 17013
8 Franklin Street, Lot 4
Mt. Holly Springs, PA 17065
1193 to 4193
1193 to 4193
Ronnie E. Honick, Sr.
Michelle R. Porter
538 W. Louther Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
To 1/93
The mother of the children is MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN, formerly MICHELLE
R. PORTER, who it is believed currently resides at 1016 Hullview Avenue #A, Norfolk.
Virginia, 23503. She is married.
The father of the children is RONNIE R. HONICK, SR., currently residing at 8
Franklin Street, Lot 4, Mt. Holly Springs, Pennsylvania, 17065. He is unmarried.
4. The relationship of the Plaintiff to the children is that of Father. The Plaintiff
currently resides alone with the children.
5. The relationship of the Defendant to the children is that of Mother. The
Defendant currently resides with her current husband, Edward L. Rabenstein II.
6. Plaintiff has not participated as a party or witness, or in another capacity, in
other litigation concerning the custody of the children in this or another court.
Plaintiff has no information of a custody proceeding concerning the children pending
in a court of this Commonwealth.
Plaintiff does not know of a person not a party to the proceedings who has physical
custody of the children or claims to have custody or visitation rights with respect to the
children.
7. The best interest and permanent welfare of the children will be served by
granting the relief requested for the following reasons:
A. On October 25, 1993. Plaintiff and Defendant entered into a
written Rgreement which provided that Plaintiff, Ronnie E. Honick, Sr" would
have custody of the two children who are the subject of this Complaint. A
copy of that agreement is marked Exhibit A, attached hereto, and made a
part hereof.
8. Since October 25, 1993, the children have continuously resided with
the Plaintiff, Ronnie E. Honick. Sr., at his home at S Franklin Street, Lot 4,
Mt. Holly Springs, Pennsylvania. 17065.
C. Since October 25, 1993, Defendant, Michelle R. Rabenstein,
formerly Michelle R. Porter, has only had sporadic contact with the children
and, in fact, up until June S, 1995, had not seen them for approximately S
months.
D. By the agreement of the parties and at the initiation of the
Plaintiff, Ronnie E. Honick, Sr., because he thought it was in the best interest
of the children, arrangements were made for Michelle R. Rabenstein to pick
up the children on June S, 1995, and as part of that agreement she was to
return them to Plaintiff on Father's Day, June IS, 1995.
E. The Defendant has failed to return the children to the Plaintiff as
previously agreed upon, has failed to contact the Plaintiff regarding the
children's whereabouts, and when Plaintiff has attempted to phone Defendant
Plaintiff has been advised that the phone has been disconnected.
F, Plaintiff has undertaken and performed the primary parental
responsibilities for the children and specifically has been their primary
caretaker since October 1993.
G. Plaintiff is best able to provide the care and nurture which the
children need for healthy development and, in fact, the children have
consistently been enrolled at the Bethel Christian Academy which Plaintiff has
paid for.
H. A court order of custody is necessary so that there are no
misunderstandings regarding custody and partial custody and so that the
children are not used in a manipulative fashion.
I. Plaintiff desires to maintain the family household which has been
established since October 1993 and the continued stability of the household is
in the best interest of the children.
J. Defendant is erratic and apparently attempted suicide in
approximately April 1994, and her behavior poses a threat of harm to the
children.
8. Each parent whose parental rights to the children have not been terminated and
the person who has physical custody of the children have been named as parties to this
action.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests this Honorable Court to enter an order
granting custody of the children to Plaintiff.
Respectfully submitted,
ANDREWS & JOHNSON
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA )
: SS.
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND )
I verify that the statements made in the foregoing Complaint are true and correct. I
understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of IS Pa.C.S.
g4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities,
DATE: C h.,.,u, p~ ?~
L~.~~
Ronnie E. Honic , Sr., Plainllff
7tz:~."-':~~~~';~'~;'~.'~';'-'.'.-.~:..". .. :.:'....', ':
. .' ... .>....._.-....~yo1''"'.....-~"W....,.-......._
6f10lS; /7'93
O~ r1~/~/J?E/U1 1 ~;AJ/~';:" /L,'cJ
,H/V ~c~~ Z &1/t" 'fY;e'.~C:'
; eU.5~C7 .,3';: DuX' 7!.uo ~,;{Ic~~,
! ,4;'~/F7~ )(<J%~ /~/'c/ ~d C0//w:; E,
#,v/C/( ,E'. IN~O ?VI'/( ,}z ~~5r;v~
;::1/ 8 -r-4 frH^-I. 1~ $'/' ou~/ (1/t~
i tN 6 I 5 \ \ U 1'1\:} t9 /0 71 ~",e/ '
I chI! ct 1Ci.^J <2.u<i-rey 01(",<(.)(' w ~~k5N
e>~A~1\~ ON 11-'5"-93 ~t:AtR~ )?
! ;:z,6,<'.:!:>j /rJ ~'l..j(~Nds ~/~~i.s .slL
I IV//( /J{56 ,ht4L1!- /k c~j;A,~A.J.
/l- ,,7A//' ~. ~/ eAJ ./1/1 hCJ!'ci1ys
.h'/Vd ..p2C/A/ occ /1~JC/N,:5 $c.lcf[,
I,4S ,b/,tf!' //~/rS C!>,e /<~/Ali(/Z..5 u, S i I,'tvy..
,
I
,J'wvwJ t ~
{)d!o.k o?y/ /f{q3
~~~~,~~~,
I. :;Akl.:....l hDF:..;:j.~\1 \.11r.r-. r.~ ftl.rl r;')qfc"f
ur l~OMMI!:SION l>>:PhtlS AI'::II ~~ 1~~1
~-.._--
/tJ -e2S- 73
lO~~)5.'?3.
ex /I
, ,
:
/
/
"1,_._ ' ~"
.jJ
QI
QI
.tl~
:Z:1Il0
o r-
1Il.jJ....
~fl
OIl-lICC
hElI14
o
.., 114 .
QI
1Il.jJ....
~cncn
QI....
~.-l
eo:>~
:;;!r-U
,
I-
o~
0<
~: ,~..
.
Q<
cd'" <!I
.. c
Z... lil! .,
OZ ~I
VI..
ZO 1l ~~
" - ,
CO...
0... 5'\ilo
p-
12< xE
.......
'~...........-.--:'----- .~
~.. .----:-..~
v.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
RONNIE E. HONICKH, SR.,
Plaintiff/Respondent,
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant/Petitioner
NO. 95-3338 CIVIL TERM
AND NOW,
ORDER OF COURT
this Z.S(t,day of August, 1995, upon consideration of
Petitioner's Petition for Emergency Relief, a hearing is SCHEDULED
for Thursday, October 19, 1995, at 9100 a.m., in Courtroom No.5,
Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle, Pennsylvania.
BY THE COURT,
J.
Ronald E. Johnson, Esq.
78 West Pomfret Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Attorney for Plaintiff/Respondent
Robert L. Buzzendore, Esq.
4407 North Front Street
P.O. box 5320
Harrisburg, PA 17110-5320
Attorney for Defendant/Petitioner
~,~
8J~~/9S:
~. 'f!
:rc
t~HY',~ I '~;tHj)d
41Nt..JJ fJ"V":tP'iHno
.~~\'1~IIOHJ.) .! ": In
'lOljji:' :"
56, Ud EE I BZ onv
,,~.. ..
. .
, ,
'i
Ii
ii
ii
"
d
i'
I
,I
II
1
I
I
I
Ii
II
II
Ii
Ii
"
Ii
I'
I'
I
I,
Ii
i!
Ii
I:
1\
Ii
i'
!I
II
II
r
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
RONNIE E. HONICHK, SR.,
Plaintiff/Respondent,
VS.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
NO. q5 ~ 3338
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant/Petitioner.
CIVIL ACTION--CUSTODY
ORDER
AND NOW, this day of 1995, upon
consideration of the within Petition for Emergency Relief, it is
hereby ordered and decreed that the June 29, 1995, Order of Court
granting Plaintiff/Respondent temporary primary physical custody of
the Parties' two minor children is vacated and the December 23, 1992,
Order granting Defendant/Respondent primary physical custody shall be
upheld and binding pending further order of court.
BY THE COURT:
J.
II
,I
II
'I
Ii
,I
!l
,
!!
p
ii
ii
il
, .
Ii
iI
i'
I:
I
d
II
r
I
II
II
i-
II
II
Ii
Ii
Ii
Ii
II
I'
II
II
I'
I
I
II
II
rI
Ii
i
I
I
,
I
II
II
II
II
II
I
I
RONNIE E. HONICHK, SR.,
Plaintiff/Respondent,
vs.
I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I
I NO. 'IS' 333~
I
I
I CIVIL ACTION--CUSTODY
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant/Petitioner.
PETITION FOR EMERGENCY RELIEF
Petitioner, MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN, through her attorneys,
Robert L. Buzzendore, and Gerald S. Robinson, of Robinson' Geraldo,
requests this Honorable Court to grant her emergency relief by
vacating the temporary order of court granting primary physical
custody to Plaintiff/Respondent (hereinafter Respondent) and
upholding the previous order of court granting Defendant/Petitioner
(hereinafter Petitioner) primary physical custody. In support of
this request Petitioner provides the following:
1. Petitioner is MICHELLE RABINSTEIN, an adult individual
currently residing at 1016 Hulview Avenue, 'A, Norfolk, Virginia.
2. Respondent is RONNIE E. HONICK, an adult individual
currently residing at 8 Franklin Street, Lot 4, Mt. Holly Springs,
Pennsylvania.
3. The Parties are the natural parents of two children to wit:
Autumn R. Honick, born March 22, 1989, and Ronnie E. Honick, Jr.,
born October 12, 1990.
4. In or around December 1992, Petitioner filed a custody
action in conjunction with a Protection from Abuse action which was
docketed by this Honorable Court at 4379 Civil 1992.
ii
'I
q
"
ii
!i
jI
!
5. On or about the 23rd day of December 1992, an Order of Court
was entered relative to the custody of the above children giving
Petitioner primary physical custody of the Parties' children.
Respondent was given a limited custody schedule which included
alternating weekends and holidays and one uninterrupted week in the
summer. A copy of this order is hereto attached as "Exhibit A."
6. In or around October 1993, the Parties mutually agreed to
allow Respondent to assume primary physical custody of the children,
and to allow Petitioner to assume limited custody. Petitioner
maintained contact with the children as often as she was permitted.
7. In or around June 1995, the Parties mutually agreed to
resume their prior custody agreement as articulated in the December
23, 1992, Order of Court.
8. On or about June 21, 1995, Respondent, despite his knowledge
of the December 23, 1992, custody order, filed a Petition to Confirm
Custody alleging that "Plaintiff has not participated as a party or
witness, or in another capacity, in other litigation concerning the
custody of the children in this or another court."
9. On or about June 21, 1995, Respondent, also filed a Petition
for Special Relief alleging that Petitioner had failed to return the
children to him.
10. On or about June 22, 1995, Respondent and a friend traveled
to Petitioner's home in virginia. When they arrived, in an apparent
state of intoxication, they began threatening Petitioner and
demanding that she relinquish the children. Petitioner was alone at
the time and quite fearful for her health as well as that of the
II
II
II
I
ii
I ~
Ii
II
I!
Ii
II
II
I
I
I
I
I
I
II
II
I,
I
I
i
Ii
II
il
Ii
il
Ii
II
if
I,
I
:1
Ii
,
I'
I
"
Ii
~
Ii
~
U
"
I:
~
children. In addition, Petitioner was experiencing difficulties with
her pregnancy and was unable to aggressively react to Respondent's
threats. As a result, Respondent took the children from Petitioner's
home in Virginia and returned with them to Pennsylvania. Since that
time, Petitioner has attempted to maintain contact with the children,
but Respondent has violently and repeatedly denied her any contact.
11. On or about June 29, 1995, this Honorable Court held a
hearing on Respondent's Petition for Special Relief, and entered a
temporary custody order wherein primary physical custody was with
Respondent.
12. Petitioner was neither aware of this hearing, nor was she
able to physically travel the distance due to her current health
condition.
13. As a result of the Petition to Confirm Custody filed by
Respondent, a custody conciliation conference has been scheduled
before Hubert X. Gilroy on October 6, 1995.
14. Petitioner has taken the steps necessary to enroll the
children in school in Virginia. With the current temporary order,
however, the children will be unable to attend the first days of
school in Virginia, as would be proper based on the custody
arrangement established by the December 23, 1992, order of court.
15. It is in the best interest of the children to be returned
to Petitioner's care.
i:
J
U
f
'i
"
~
,
~
~
r
j
~
u
I
~
~
~
I
I
I
j
l
~
~
U
o
r
J
~
~
Ii
~
i
I:
!I
Ii
:'
ii
"
d
Ii
WHEREFORE, Petitioner prays this Honorable Court to vacate the
June 29, 1995, temporary custody order, and uphold the December 23,
1992, order of court granting primary physical custody of the minor
children to Petitioner pending further order of court.
'I
I,
!I
il
Ii
II
II
Ii
I'
ii
Ii
I!
Ii
II
Ii
I:
II
Ii
'I
'I
II
Ii
II
II
I
I
I
II
"
!I
II
II
Ii
I'
II
II
Ii
'i
!,
Respectfully submitted,
Dated:
~I iJ-~(q5
I I
By-
Rob r . uzzen ,
Attorney I.D. . 5 7
Gerald S. Robinson, Esquire
ROBINSON & GERALDO
Attorney I.D. No. 27423
4407 North Front street
P.O. Box 5320
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17110
(717) 232-8525
Attorney for Petitioner
VERIFICATION
I verify that the statements made in this Petition for Emergency
Relief are true and correct based on information provided to me by my
client. I understand that false statements herein are made subject
to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. 4904, relating to unsworn
falsification to authorities.
~~i&~~
er L. uzze re, squ re
Ii
:1
Ii
Ii
I'
,I
ii
i:
"
Ii
"
,
Ii
, Mlcnelle Porter,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT ~ COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLANO COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
vs.
NO. 4379 CIVIL 1992
Ronnie E. Honick,
Defendant
PROTECTION FROM ABUSE
AND CUSTODY
AND NOW, this c;eI,d
~~SlP'UY_OR!:L1;,,13
day of December, 1992, upon
consideration of the parties' Consent Agreement, the fOllowing
Order is entered with regard to custody of the parties'
children, Autumn Robin Honick and Ronnie E. Honick, Jr.
1. The plaintiff, hereinafter referred to as the mother,
will have primary physical and legal custody of the children.
,
2. The defendant, hereinafter referred to as the father,
will have partial custody of the childrAn evepy Dt~ar weekend
from Friday at 6:00 p.m. until Sunday at 6:00. p.m. beginning
December 25, 1992.
3. The father and mother will alternate Christmas Eve and
Christmas Day each year, one parent having the children on
Christmas Eve Day at noon until Christmas Day at noon and the
other parent having the children from Christmas Day at noon until
December 26, at noon with the mother having the child beginning
on Christmas Eve in 1993.
4. The mother and fath,~ will share the fOllowing hOlidays,
at times to be mutually agreed upon by the parties; Easter,
Thanksgiving, Memorial Day. the Fourth of July, Labor Day, and
New Years' Day.
5. Each party will have the right to partial custody of the
: Exhibit
nAn
children for ono'woek of oach Gummor including two weekends.
Each party will givo the other party 0 thlrty notice as to when
the period of summer custody hill take place.
6. ' The mother and father. by mu tuo 1 ngreement, may vary
from this schedule at any time.
7. The fLlther Vlill ,::it It:''J 1110901 dl'lIgE' or alcohol or be
under the influence of illegal drugs or alcohol when the children
are in his custody.
8. Each parent will notify the other immediately of medical
emergencies which arise while the children are in that parent's
care.
9. Neither party sholl do anythlng which may estrange the
.
children from the other parent. or injure the opinion of the
children as to the other parent or which may hamper the free
and n~tural development 01 thE children's love or respect for the
other parent.
By the Court.
jsJlt.'!L.IL./J..~ ',,\
K~vin A. Hess, J.
TRUE COpy FROM RECORD
In Tcsllmno1Y wlJ~rf:O', I hora UOlo sot my hand
;\11~ tfl.n ~~I o~ s'3!d Cr.orl a,I C.1rl/sle, fW.
ThlG.2.L'-'~d"Y 01 ~ 1Q Q:z-
._.__.._-;.~- (.I~;~(I('f:: . ~i .
Prothonotary
, \
!,
"
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
o
I
h
1
~
"
I
~
h
I!
r
~
~
u
I
I
I, Robert L. Buzzendore, Esquire do hereby certify that on the
~ day of August 1995, I caused a true and correct copy of the
Petition for Emergency Relief to be served upon the following counsel
of record by depositing same in first-class U.S. Mail in Harrisburg,
Pennsylvania:
ROnald E. Johnson, Esquire
ANDREWS & JOHNSON
78 West Pomfret Street
Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013
~
~
I,
U
f
~
i
i
~
"
I
I
I
I
I
I
~
Respectfully Submitted,
~
By
Ro e . uzzen or
ROBINSON & GERALDO
Attorney 1.0. No. 977
4407 North Front Street
P.O. Box 5320
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17110-5320
(717) 232-8525
h
i
~
Ii
h
Ii
II
, .
(717) 28US25
"
~
E
...,
~
N
~f:
:;!~
w,,~:;J:!
~':I:Oz
",,"OU..
1"'%'0>
O"'-:"OE'~
. ... ~-~ "'t.":
0- ...,J....
.., -.c;,;:z!:
.J,.Jl.lJ:6:,
....,,,..It;
i:: x{L.
;..0
::,....
. ~ .....
.',
CeA~fp:I~~ i~~E6l
AND.CORRECT COPY
ROBINSON AND GERALDO .
,
AlTORNEYS AND COl~SI!LLORS AT LAw
P.O. 80"5320, HARRisBuRo. '~EeR'f'6IN1\t
..~.,
-.."..,"" !'nd.~ ~,~'
. ; }__7::"':4.:s.~ ~ "'":c..-::-:~~;;::. __ '-.. }
.....
......
g
-
,
RONNIE E. HONICKH, SR.,
Plaintiff/Respondent
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
.
.
v.
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant/Petitioner
.
.
95-3338 CIVIL TERM
AND NOW,
ORDER OF COURT
this \~1Lday of October, 1995, upon
relation of Ronald E. Johnson, Esquire, counsel for Plaintiff,
that issues raised in Defendant's Petition for Emergency Relief
have been resolved through the custody conciliation process, the
Petition is DEEMED MOOT and the hearing scheduled for October
19, 1995, is CANCELLED.
By the Court,
RONALD E. JOHNSON, ESQUIRE
78 West Pomfret Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
For the Plaintiff/Respondent
ROBERT L. BUZZENDORE, ESQUIRE
4407 North Front Street
P.O. Box 5320
Harrisburg, PA 17110-5320
For the Defendant/Petitioner
~
(. .
~,
c:,
:::::>
--.;
<.0
v-.
- c-F'" ~
I c/,'ilqs',
...&. "f.
- :.
wcy
,~
c,
-,
~
OCT 25 1995 tJ
.
RONNIB B. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff
IIN THB COURT OF COMMON PLBAS OF
ICUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PBNNSYLVANIA
I
INO. 3338 - CIVIL - 1995
I
I
ICIVIL ACTION - CUSTODY
v
MICHBLLB R. RABBNSTBIN,
Defendant
COURT ORDER
AND NOW, this ~day of "'M~t_., 1995, upon consideration of
the attached Custody CO~Report, it is ordered and
directed as follows I
1. The Hearing scheduled in the above case for October 19, 1995,
is cancelled.
2. The parties shall submit themselves and their two minor
children to a custody evaluation to be performed by a
professional as agreed upon by legal counsel for the
parties. Costs of this evaluation shall be shared equally
by the parties with an adjustment such that the Mother
shall incur any expenses directly related to involvement
of her husband in the evaluation process. Upon completion
of this evaluation and in the event the parties are unable
at that time to reach an agreement, counsel for either
party may contact the Custody Conciliator at which time
the Conciliator can either convene a second Conciliation
Conference or file a report with the Court to schedule
this case for a Hearing before a judge.
3. Pending further Order of the Court, this Court's Order of
June 29, 1995, shall remain in effect.
BY THB COURT,
Judg
cc:
Ronald E. Johnson, Esquire
Gerald S. Robinson, Bsquire
- Cof~fl>'<\,~,t>/a."'IIjs".
A.i'.
56 ,.. (7 nl ", !~O
' I <, ... t t....1
,
.
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff
IIN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
ICUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
INO. 3338 - CIVIL - 1995
I
I
ICIVIL ACTION - CUSTODY
v
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant
PRIOR JUDGEI JUDGE J. WESLEY OLER, JR.
CONCILIATION CONFERENCE SUMMARY REPORT
IN ACCORDANCE WITH CUMBERLAND COUNTY CIVIL RULE OF PROCEDURE
1915.3-8(b), the undersigned Custody Conciliator submits the
following reportl
1. The information pertaining to the children who are the
subject of this litigation is as follows I
Autumn R. Honick, born March 22, 1989, and Ronnie E.
Banick, Jr., born October 12, 1990.
2. A Conciliation Conference was held on October 9, 1995,
with the following individuals in attendance I
The Father, Ronnie E. Honick, Sr., with his counsel,
Ronald E. Johnson, Esquire, and the Mother, Michelle R.
Rabenstein, with her counsel, Gerald S. Robinson, Esquire.
3. The parties reached an agreement in the form as attached.
16/~~ qs'"
. DPi E
re
{;)(M-
,\L....~...:, ,,'", :
jJ:~~u'-'J.: ".J
" ,
, ,
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff
v.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant
NO. 95-3338 CIVIL TERM
AND NOW, this Z..cl. day of October, 1996, upon consideration
of the Motion to Withdraw, a Rule is hereby ISSUED upon the
Defendant and Plaintiff to show cause why the relief requested
should not be granted.
RULE RETURNABLE within 10 days of service.
BY THE COURT,
J Wesley
Michelle B. Stokes, Esq.
4407 North Front Street
P.O. Box 5320
Harrisburg, PA 17110-5320
Attorney for Defendant . A.J.
. ~V'U"-
11.~
lol'>lflf~"r-
Michelle Rabenstein
9421 Atwood Avenue
Apt. B
Norfolk, VA 23503
Michelle Rabenstein
c/o Thomas , Connie McConnell
30 Ray Road
Middletown, PA 17057
Ronald E. Johnson, Esq.
78 West Pomfret Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
:re
~'\"\~ 1 ""11,:'"1.'
\j, " " "..",
J" ."'- ! ' . . I
".., ,"
.. 'I .'~ :,. ,- '0,/'''; - '
t:v .', , " '. -
.
. . t .
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
P lllinti ff,
VS.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I
NO. 3338 1995 CIVIL TERM
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant.
I
I
I CIVIL ACTION--CUSTODY
ORDER
AND NOW this day of 1996, it is hereby
ORDERED and DECREED that Defendant's Counsel's Motion to Withdraw is
granted, and the appearance of the law firm of Robinson & Geraldo is
hereby withdrawn as counsel of record for Defendant for the above
proceedings.
BY THE COURT:
...
J.
.
.
. ,
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff,
VII.
I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I
I NO. 3338 1995 CIVIL TERM
I
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant.
CIVIL ACTION--CUSTODY
roM
AND NOW, this day of , 1996, a Rule is hereby
issued upon all parties to show cause why the Motion to Withdraw
should not be granted.
RULE RETURNABLE
DAYS FROM SERVICE.
J.
-,,,:,,
,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff,
vs.
I
I
I NO. 3338 1995 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION--CUSTODY
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant.
MOTION TO WITHDRAW
AND NOW COMES Michelle B. Stokes, Esquire of Robinson' Geraldo,
Petitioner, who, in support of this Motion to Withdraw, avers the
following:
1. On or about August 22, 1995, Defendant, MICHELLE R.
RABENSTEIN, retained the law firm of Robinson , Geraldo to represent
her throughout the above-docketed custody proceedings. See Exhibit
"A" attached hereto and incorporated herein.
2. Petitioner has prepared various court documents, attended a
custody Conciliation Conference, and corresponded with Defendant and
Plaintiff's counsel with regard to the custody proceedings.
3. Defendant currently has an outstanding balance with Robinson
, Geraldo in the approximate amount of $927.50.
4. Defendant has refused to cooperate in attending her
scheduled appointments for the custody evaluation, as ordered by the
October 25, 1995 Court Order. See Exhibits "B" and "C" attached
hereto and incorporated herein.
5. Petitioner has been unable to contact the Defendant by
telephone or by letter.
6. Upon telephoning Defendant's home telephone number,
Petitioner discovered that the telephone number had been disconnected.
7. Petitioner has made numerous attempts to contact Plaintiff,
and her parents, by first class mail. See Exhibits "D", "E", "F",
"G", "H", "I", and "J" attached hereto and incorporated herein. The
correspondence sent to Defendant by first class mail is not returned,
however, Defendant has not contacted Robinson & Geraldo as requested.
8. Petitioner has been unable to locate Defendant's whereabouts.
9. Petitioner's continued representation of Defendant has been
rendered unreasonably difficult by virtue of the client's absence,
and good cause exists under Rule 1.16b(5) of the Pennsylvania Rules
of Professional Conduct for Petitioner's withdrawal of appearance in
the case.
10. Despite a fee agreement requiring payment by Defendant for
Petitioner's services and the submission of bills to Defendant,
Defendant currently has an outstanding balance of $927.50.
11. The continued representation of Defendant without payment
of Petitioner's fees, or the prospect of such payment, has resulted
and will further result in an unreasonable financial burden on
Petitioner, and good cause exists therefore under Rule 1.16b(5) of
the PennJylvania Rules of Professional conduct for Petitioner's
withdrawal.
WHEREFORE, petitioner, Defendant's counsel, respectfully
requests this Honorable Court to grant this Petition of Counsel for
Withdrawal of Appearance.
Respectfully submitted,
/J1Pq;\~
:rche{~~e'i;, Esquire
ROBINSON & GERALDO
Attorney I.D. No. 76272
4407 North Front Street
P.O. Box 5320
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17110-5320
(717) 232-8525
Attorney for Defendant
p,
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
.. ....O.IS'.ONaL CQllflO""'rO".
ATTORNtYS AT LAW
Poll OffICe 80, 5320
Harnsburg. Pennsytva0l8
17110-5320
WIll Shote
351Q nondlO Rood
Camp Hili, PA 170"
(717) r.J7.2779
Hartlabutg
..01 No<1h Front 51.
H.lfllbutg. PA 17110
(717) 2328525
Wls/WlglOn, DC
1318 Ponn_ No, S E
WIs/WlglOn, DC 2OllO3
(202) 5<0.2888
RETAINER AND FEE AGREEMENT
1. This is a Retainer and Fee Agreement entered into
between THOMAS AND CONNIE MCCONNELL (CLIENT) and ROBINSON AND
GERALDO (ATTORNEYS).
2. Client does, hereby, retain ROBINSON AND GERALDO as
attorneys concerning: Representation of Michelle Rabenstein
regarding Custody.
3. The following matters are to be undertaken by ATTORNEYS
for the CLIENT pursuant to this Agreement: Representation of
Michelle Rabenstein regarding Custody including preparation and
filing of all necessary and pertinent documents, and providing
legal counsel as necessary.
4. The CLIENT agrees to pay the following costs for
services performed:
a. The CLIENT agrees to pay $150.00 per hour for ATTORNEY
time.
b. The CLIENT agrees to pay $150.00 per hour for ATTORNEY
time in regard to all Court appearances, hearings or
depositions.
c. The CLIENT agrees to pay $125.00 per hour for
Associate Attorney time.
d. The CLIENT agrees to pay $50.00 per hour for Paralegal
time.
e. The CLIENT agrees to pay $20.00 per hour for word-
processing services.
5. CLIENT also agrees to pay for all out-Of-pocket
expenses, including, but not limited to, expenditures for filing
fees, transcripts, subpoena and deposition fees, long distance
telephone calls, postage, xeroxing, travel and all disbursements
necessary for the proper performance of legal services.
6. CLIENT will be billed on the basis of the time spent
and services performed on this matter. Telephone conversations
between the ATTORNEY and the CLIENT will be billed at a minimum
of one-quarter (1/4) hour. Telephone conversations between the
ATTORNEY and opposing counsel, party or other interested party
in this matter will be billed at a minimum of one-quarter (1/4)
hour.
Exhibit
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
,. II II , t 'j '} I ., ... ... l C q " to 'I II ~ , , .) "
RETAINER AND FEE AGREEMENT
Page 2
7. The CLIENT agrees to pay ATTORNEYS a retainer of
$600.00 against which the charges described in Paragraph 4 will
be deducted. This Agreement will not be effective until the
retainer fee is paid and this Agreement is signed by ROBINSON
AND GERALDO.
8. ROBINSON AND GERALDO will bill the CLIENT as work
progresses on the matter as itemized in Paragraph 3. The CLIENT
agrees to pay ROBINSON AND GERALDO when billed, but in no
circumstances later than ten (10) days after receipt of the
statement. A 12' annual interest charge will be added to all
accounts with balances due for more than ten (10) days.
9. The CLIENT understands that ATTORNEYS may not ethically
bear the costs of litigation for CLIENTS. Therefore, ROBINSON
AND GERALDO, at their sole option, may withdraw as counsel
should CLIENT'S account become delinquent by a period exceeding
sixty (60) days. ROBINSON AND GERALDO relinquishes no legal
claim against CLIENT for any unpaid balances as a result of such
withdrawal and will utilize the law to its fullest extent as a
means of recourse to fully protect their interests. If it
becomes necessary for ROBINSON AND GERALDO to pursue their legal
rights, CLIENT agrees to bear the cost of all attorners' fees
associated with the litigation of the matter at preva ling
attorney rates.
10. If CLIENT disputes any charges, the CLIENT must notify
ROBINSON AND GERALDO in writing within thirty (30) days.
ROBINSON AND GERALDO will make every effort to clarify or
correct any disputed charge.
11. The CLIENT understands and agrees that this Fee
Agreement does not include legal services in connection with the
appeal of this case. CLIENT will have the choice to retain
ROBINSON AND GERALDO under a new Fee Agreement should this
matter involve an appeal.
12. I have read this Fee Agreement in its entirety, and it
has been explained to me, to my satisfaction. I understand the
~~a;~~~:;;in the Agreement and hereby agree to abide by
~~~~~ & ~~ DATE
0#. . to?hq ~ /JP'
~~h'NRtLL ?/~ENT)
/) . -'//J'!:/J, a~
~NYt Mcc6NNfa.~":'" (CLIENT)
~.:s/95
/f-:;(.;?- 95-
DATE
. '
Pauline' Wallin, Ph.D.
Licensed Psychologlsl
& Associates
201 Soulh 32nd SIICCI
Camp Hill. PA 17011
(717)761.1814
PAX (717)761.1~42
July 9, 1996
Ms. Michelle Rabenstein
9421 Atwood Avenue
(Apartment B) ,
Norfolk, VA 23503
Dear Michelle:
I'm sorry you missed your appointment with me today. As you will recall, when we
spoke on the phone a few weeks ago, I set aside 2 hours today, July 9, and 2 hours
tomorrow, to see you and the children.
This Is the second time you have failed to show for an appointment. Although the
appointment was for 2 hours, I am billing you for only 1 hour for a missed appointment.
Because this time was reserved for you, no one else could be scheduled.
If you wish to re-schedule, please be advised that all future appointments must be paid
for IN ADVANCE. I regret that we need to do chis, but I cannot continue to reserve blocks
of time when you do not show up.
Sincerely,
.,~' ~
~- I
'- U.t 11/(
~E WALLIN, Ph.D
Licensed Psychologist
PW/eg
cc: Gerald Robinson, Esq. ~
, Exhibit
CONSl
PSYCIIOTIIERAPY
B
(
.'
1}I;r 2 5 1995
, -..
OCT, 27 1995
RONNIB B. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff
IIN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
ICUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PBNNSYLVANIA
I
INO. 3338 - CIVIL - 1995
I
I
:CIVIL ACTION - CUSTODY
v
MICHELLB R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant
COURT ORDER
~ ~
AND NOW, this .dL Ciay of , 1995, upon consideration of
the attached Custody Conc 1 at on Report, it is ordered and
directed as follows:
1. The Hearing scheduled in the above case for October 19, 1995,
is cancelled.
"
2. The parties shall submit themselves and their two minor
children to a custody evaluation to be performed by a
professional as agreed upon by legal counsel for the
parties. Costs of this evaluation shall be shared equally
by the parties with an adjustment such that the Mother
shall incur any expenses directly related to involvement
of her husband in the evaluation process. Upon completion
of this evaluation and in the event the parties are unable
at that time to reach an agreement, counsel for either
party mar contact the Custody Conciliator at which time
the Conc liator can either convene a second Conciliation
Conference or file a report with the Court to schedule
this case for a Hearing before a judge.
3. Pending further Order of the Court, this Court's Order of
June 29, 1995, shall remain in effect.
BY THB COURT,
lS/ ~. 1.s'A~ &.J a-v.
Judg J. Wesl y Oler~qJr.
CC: Ronald E. Johnson, Esquire
Gerald S. Robinson, Esquire
-~.,-
- ',' ":";""'1 ':".......\ "l:"'ORD
t-.. . .... ~ I
',~ ;.;' 17Iy hand
(,'. .
'. - . .. " ."a~.'.! p
, .1::t:..' . .., ...1. -,..J, a.
TIi:. .;{ 10 " ' /f'\.....
, ,,-~ cr ~c.LO;"" J9,?€.
.......,,~,tt. )~cAf.V.
~. PrOjt:or.~I~ry .............
exhibit .
c
,',~
';,
.....
, "
:f~i:t:'f>
,~> .' .. ."
....~.l..~/,....,
"~:~;~~?~';..:.:~ ..
... ;.~~. .. .
,><!<~",:.- '.
,". r..~.. ,
';" , . '...~~. .'," .
;r~J':';;
:~~F~7<(~';"': .
..1;~.';.',' .
:;?~':':'."
I;Y';i,~.: ,
-... ~...' . .
" ...;",
v.;.....
.......~.ll.
'~t I~:~?:.
',t.~..,.
JMl.~,
'..\..:....
:...............
.;r.".l.....
:~~~ .
,
, ,
'.
:.~
ROBINSON &.. GERALDO
.. ~.O""'a..., cO..o..t,o..
ATTO.NtvS AT LAW
Post OffICe 90. 6320
H.,,/IbuIg. Penn..,.."n..
17110.6320
cno.
"EaIl..,_
CoAtoo, "" 171113
171 ~ l'H'~t
>w-..g
<<<<0' """",.... St.
~""",.o
('m 13H~15
June 28, 1996
Michelle Rabenstein
9421 Atwood Avenue
Apt. B
Norfolk, Virginia 23503
Rei
Dear
MBBljmm
CCI
Outstandina Bill
Ms. Rabenstein:
"
~lon. D.C,
'3'0 PrnI\+N>il AVI" S.E,
Walhi"oglon, D,C, 10003
I202l &<<.2889
.-:. ..
. '" ,~.
". ~~~ -:.
, .~ :..:~j!.':
,I
.,
:r.~.f.. 'f...,;.~.~:a;...
~'.:. "',' ;,; .... ", ',..
f"
','
T. & C. McConnell
Exhlbll
D
. ~'. ..::;~~~~t~::,:
.......... I
. ".\'" '.. .
'. ..~';~' ,:: '.~:.
". H:", \~!':..,
". ..~', ~ . '..' .
".
<1\,:,.,'...' .
..'I...:..;-'\'~..:l~. ,,;.~!-,.
'J
'?'
-
, ~(
'!
. .
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
,. '.0.....0...' cO..o....o..
,',
AnoINtl'S AT IJ\W
PDII 0Ila !IoI ~
Herlllbulg. ~...
1711l).53:!O
c..
"bolHQll_
c... '" 'ro,~
11tlU4HOSI
...........
-__II.
.......... '" "" 0
(1I7UJ2'_
'_'ll"""D,C,
'~Ie PlMI)lvIniI A..,. 5 E,
~ton, D,C, 20003
l202l&4HlIH
'J
July 10, 1996
. ;". ,', r\~ '.>:~'
, ..... ......
. . :1' 0/
. ,p.' ::-':1
"..; ';'.
. ....
"
.:
.
"
'~.:: .
) '.' .",
.." (rJ~~;~~~;',
. "'::. ...~'\ -;~.. ~ \'.j""" (
',~'i/;}}~~;:' ;~: ;t~~
'_ . -.;; ~:;~f~~;\"l~~.~~~:iq:...)~!,~~.
" -'.""', :-''''~;;''' ~~.i,~~'I'\.;ii'
. '...... ~..~:.,~,.~, .":\~'?
I have attempted to contact you by telephone but' have''i'::;::''~e~l\'~:';'I~!';':
discovered that your phone has been disconnected. Additionally, :;:'~":,:{,",
I forwarded letters to you on June 18 and 28, 1996, but you',have';:.'",,:;~/~;
not responded. It is important that you get in touchwith':me,:~l!o~k':'~"}+i,.::
that we can communicate. Therefore, please contact me w~~~~~~~f;~~~:.~~~
correct new phone number. """'~'.N""'''': ,;,"W/"",
. ,f. .. ...... '.~,,-'. ...,. ::?."__ ..,
. .., 'f,.:;", """1.tf';-:"""'~'~~' "Jf?~',-i
I am still waiting to receive from you Ronnie Honick.'s :',~1R~;'".~f~(,1:~~\'~':',
Social Security number and date of birth. Please send this;,~~,~':~~~:i,;:~.t:
information to me as soon as possible so that we can request,'.;an\:>;I'ol,<;;:~~<;.r.::::,""'~"
i i 1 d h k ','..,.. ., ...~ ",le""~.",,.
cr m na recor c ec . '~;"""~'f..:."1'i"('"o:;".;":
. ' ,'ff~ ..,'- '~.:, f~~~;: ;,~~:t'~..': ::~'., 8';
Please note that I was co"tacted by Dr. Wallin today,:. a,nd~h"'''''<\(:' ...',
IIhe informed me that you did ,not appear for your sChedule~.::,!~;;,t:d~0:!l~,,;\"
appointment with her. Obviously, she had lIet aside an amount..of f':\
time to meet with you and was inconvenienced when you ,did, not ~' ~1:~~~
appear or call her in advance to cancel the appointment. i!:'Dr";~,.. ,1{:~!..~:':
, Wallin ill now going to require that you pay in advance forr alr:'l~., ,,':,f.-f:\:':,
future appointments. You should be aware that your failure tci:t ,?~~<,.,,(.,. '
. appear for your appointment is not onlr delaying the progre'ss":of"~",;,'''',
' your calle, but is also causing Dr. Wal in to believe that' you1' 'f,;. ~~;g;i~;-:'1'
are not cooperating. . !:' :':, "i.;'!o."tt..f;J';', ,
. .... "'lotI!:rf.I~ ~ "'.......
..,.,C\t~,'v.
. . }~m~1'0'f
, . . ::;' '~., '...- . "':,'.., ,
:', ::".~,~,,~,::.~",:,\'.:
.'. ~.:,..~'ti' \)'~
. ...,.:J!. '.
"<\'fo"';f.ii-Il.' "'.:
::'.' "'/':';'.;Y';;,.,.r.::
'.' "~-,>?,':'. ;~. , ,;~
., ~"'~~~~~'.;\
i.:. 't(.;:t;.!,.~:.,~
.;",. :~~ :'.;f;:.~~
, "
"
Michelle Rabenstein
9421 Atwood Avenue
Apt'. B
Norfolk, Virginia 23503
ReI
Custody
Dear Ms. Rabenstein:
.
. I'.
.. .~.", "
: ,.~.
~. ..
.,\'1/-,
...,t.
""1''':. .-'
:-~'?..: '. . .
......... ...,
.....
Exhibit
..-. .
'f . ~, . .
. - 100.;'"
...
.: ."
"
,"
..,--....-..
.' "
'J;'!"'\
.it. !t9~1!'!~~!'!.8:- ~~~~~
l Michelle Rabenetein
July 10, 1996
Page Two
"
Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter.
'have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me.
.
Sincerely yours,
ROBINSON , GBRALDO
'.
BY~
Miene . 0 es,
.:.~..'
MBS I jllllll
CCI T.' C.
MCConnell
:'~~;;~\;' .
. ''f>"
','
'.
"
- ...
....~.J. :. .
.:;,.,\;....
'1i:,!. '
,i,;";, .
,',,;,
',.r.~
.1;
...>
I'
'.
...
"
"." ...
: t. J' '-:~ L.
, , ~~.. .. '
.::' '~"
""'.,.;', .
'...~.4.;' .
, .,', ~';":~.f~:;~;"
, t:;,. :,\J!,h<:..,
. ',......, !J".
If: yoi(~; ': .
. .', l'
,~ ,.
." '1':'
.'. "
.' ~'.
EsqUire,!:;, _~':' 1:\ .
0,:""" ,~:"t~:\;..~~.,.
.. ..,'. :~.:' ~ .'h<.iJ.I:i~~~:' .
. .~'~~' '~, ,;-~~: ;t7{:::::~~
'- .t ,.,..,'..1"
';'\\:~r:r~' ,
. '\". .
"
~L'
,,'
~"
,~. .:'
I'
,
I
.... .,i, ,......,,;,..... . 'j
I :'~'" ..;}::~;~j$~~~~~~~j~~~;~f I.
. :. . \'~:,~~\.:.:.;...:~~t~.:i~\~!..::..
',' ~.i':...,.:..:....~.....:\.~_...,...J
. - . .~, ... '~'~'1i.......;t.,'
.. ...:{~.........:.~.~ul.tt~ ....
i ,.~..'.:I ~,'~~it...(I:;~~~',~t~.:~.I'
~;:.;. .1::'.<::' .',1' ~~t.~'.i;~';;;'"
. ... ~.. -y,"'''' ~:~,. ,
.' :~\.-'J~:f[/~~~tr;'i;g:
. 'l"'~'.'" :(..I.'f...W......
~-~ ~:,..;;'::. .:-..:~~{~'-'..,.,
.(''1''';.':'~ ;.. ....~-....?!t.:
\ . ',:':' I;".<r!. - ::.:,,"'~'. .
,'t. '.~ .....\i,'jJ..".
.' ,~.
.; '~''''-;:';'i.,j.. . .
.: l::\(..~
't~':'~ ~.
-7: :~
I
<!~t.~.. ~; '.
" ,..,'~..;. : .
j_.;-,:t'.....
,: '{.. .
,__i
t.
. :'.:
.'~...'
,"
" ,
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
.. '.0....10...." cO_'O...tIO"
AnoRNtVS AT LAW
Poll Oflice Box 5320
Hlrrilburg. PennlylYlnil
,7110.5320
CIo'oIo
I7E"I~Sl"'1
C"'Ilo, "" 17013
1717)2C~'1l'~1
-......g
ceo, ,....,"""Sl.
-......g. "" 17110
(7'7)23208$25
WaINngton. D,C,
131e~Ave" s,e,
WaINngton. D,C, 200lXI
(202) 54C.2880. ... I : .~'. ~.1(,/f ~
:.'~l~;r:':,'
". . d.,
, " 10
JUly 26, 1996
'"
Thomas & Connie McConnell
30 Ray Road
Middletown, Pennsylv~nia 17057
Re: Michelle Rabenstein
Dear Mr. and Mrs. McConnell:
"\ ..I),t~'kf~:
,-\.,'
~" .
. ,
I am writing to you in an attempt to reach "ichelle i
Rabenstein. She apparently missed her appointment with Dr.
Wallin without calling in to cancel. Additionally, I have
attempted to contact her numerous times by telephone and by .
letter, but I have been unable to reach her. Recently, I have
discovered that her home telephone number has been .
disconnected. Obviously, her case will not proceed if she is
unwilling to communicate with me. Also, she does have an
outstanding balance with this firm. Any help you can provide, me '
would be appreciated. I look forward to hearing from you in::the,':...
.oor 'uturo o. thot hor cuotOOy ..t:::C:::1~0 y:::::V"":(~'[t
ROBINSON & GERALDO,' i'~<ir';",~'.\l'
:rc..~. -.;..1ro :'i~~~'~
.. '; ;.~:'~'.\ ";~::i:~~ .;~:.\:'.
~ ~ ' . t..:. ~~"-;'~~'';.''~
'. "...:,.,11; ',~,:.:;
,;, ~ ....Yo... ;.I:~.
t.' "'f~" .,11J....J
~. ";~ ,,;,'~'l:,fQri ,:.1..:. ~ ':
, ,\ ','.);;.' .
.... ~'"..'I~": .,:
.. .'
:::',:: .~t~:~::
" .,.... ,I: .'
. : ""..~., ,~1:,~}F,'-:
.' . ~ ~.: \!':- ~~ ~f~").,
.?T.\~;'i. : "
, ....<....
" '
.... .....
"."r.: .:'
.t.- ,:-.'..;.:
~ . '. .
..
MBS:jmm
,"
.'
cc: M. Rabenstein
!',
.
,;,'.
"". '
, .
, .'
.;:~'~ ..
~:.::';:.h
.'... "
. .
. .~.
..:' .
Exhibit
:',i~i:..: .
. ~\~ ~ ~~~~ :';'" ~#
:....
--.
.
'I
{':,
.......- .'
'J,i: ~~'.. .~'.
:!I~!':..' ".
.? . ,~. . '; ,
.', .
I
j . ~
i
I .'
, ,.
I .~.-i;..: .~~:
I -.. ?.l':.,....
i
i
I
I
I
I
,
i
I
.
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
. 1t1l0'.".0""., cO."O.."O""
AnoRNtYS AT LAW
Poll OtIce Bo. 5320
H.rrllbYrg, "'nnsylYenll
17110.5320
~
..07 NooIn'""" SI.
~,""'17\10
(l'7lU2,.m
WlI/Wlg.on, D.C,
131.,..,."........ "VO.. S.E,
WloIWlglon. D,C, 20003
12021....21l1l9
ea.....
17 E.II Hto" StlWll
~,""'170'3
17171 2..,04.'
August 12, 1996
:~ ./:~~~J'f.,~:"',,'
..,...
.'.....,...
.~ .
Thomas & Connie McConnell
30 Ray Road
Middletown, Pennsylvania 17057
ReI Michelle Rabenstein
Dear Mr. and Mrs. McConnell:
'. ~\'...; /
." i.......
, ,
.. '.,
. ',. \'
I am writing to you in an attempt to reach Michelle .' " .,.
Rabenstein. She missed an appointment with Dr. 'Wallin, and she ..~ ,~/ ;,
has not answered my letters. Additionally, I ha,ve attempted ,to.:', '....,;.'
contact her by telephone, but have discovered that her home "'.:"'':'''<''
telephone number has been disconnected. As I indicated .in a', ;':',' . ',';'
previous letter to you, her case will not proceed if she is ,','., '., ,
unwilling to communicate with me. Also, she does have an '. "::~:> :'. '
outstanding balance with this firm. If she does not intend, ,t,~,;o':.!:~':;';:;:r';':'
proceed ',lith this custody mattor, I am requesting that she '. :"~:~;'I'.":,I;,,\
inform me of that decision so that we can close her flle,with',i~~\>i'I':"'"
this firm. . ;,:.:,', I~:-'>
" . >:,!: ';::,. ~ ~. ,
Thank you for your
help you can provide me
hearing from you in the
can be resolved.
prompt attention to this matter. Any""....:'
would be appreciated. I look forward'to ",
near' future so that her custody matter" ,I,.
"
.,
. .:-: t .:~<;.,
'; ,::~,:, ..~:.~~:.: '
-', '" ."'~' " "
;. ~.
Sincerely yours,
ROBINSON , GERALDO
..
B~ .
Me. 0 es, Esquire
"
..
"
~ ',0.
MBS: jmm
CCI M. Rabenstein
"
'.
\
.'
. ~ j-
, exhibit
. ,
"
1
1
I
1 ;'
! '.,.~,'
j) .;'.~'
1 ,t .~ .'" ',_
"1 .:
I' .'.
, ,,~
1: ..
;.; .
11 '
,\
il
"
,
j
"
,i,,'
. ..
. '
. ' 'ROBINSON &. GERALDO
.. '.0""10"'" cO."O.."OH
AnOIN[\'S AT LAW
Poll OKce Bo. 5320
H.rr~bu'g, PennSylvan,.
171t()'5320
!:Milo
17 EIII H9" Sl,",
C....... PA 11013
(711J24~.9451
HImtWg
"07 Nc>1" ,.... $1.
~,PAIIIIO
171FJ :32.&525
WaSlwlglon. O,C,
131' PIM~ Ave.. SE.
Walll"lllon, 0,0, 20003
l202l6'Haell
August 12, 1996
Michelle Rabenstein
9421 Atwood Avenue
Apt. B
Norfolk, Virginia 23503
ReI Custodv
Dear Ms. Rabenstein I
I have attempted to contact you by telephone but have ':.. "
discovered that your phone has been disconnected. Additionally,'..
I forwarded letters to you on June 18 and 28, and July 20,' 1996,
but you have not responded. It is important that you get in
touch with me so that we can communicate. Therefore, please
contact me with your correct new phone number.
't'
. ;,
.; :," :~ ';' ,
I am still waiting to receive from you Ronnie Honick's
Social Security number and date of birth. Please send this
information to me as soon as possible so that we can request
criminal record check.
('.;.~[~?' -',f,
. :',', . .~:.;;,
+ . . .... ~ . .:;..
a' ,'.
"
Also, please contact me regarding any appointments you have
made with Dr. Wallin. Your custody matter will not proceed. ,
until you have completed your evaluations. If you do not intend .:,
to pursue this custody matter, please contact me regarding that- .':' .
decision so that I can close your file with this firm. Thank~. ..:' ..,,' :
you for your prompt attention to this matter. If you have any" ': ~.
questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. '
Sincerely yours,
ROBINSON & GERALDO
"
:r~~~ Esquire
MBS I jmm
cc: T. & c. McConnell
Exhlbll
II
. .,
.',
t' . .
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
.. '110.1...0....' CO.'01l"'10..
ATTORNtl'S AT LAW
Post O"'CI Bo. S320
Harrisburg. Pennsytvania
17111).5320
C......
17Ea,'H.gloS'roeI
C....., PA 170'3
(711) 2'5'U'51
-..wv
U01 NotIh Fronl 51.
HamsbuIg, PA 17110
(7'1) 23208525
WaslWlgl.... D,C,
'''0 Pomsylyl"'" Avo,. S,E.
WaShington. D,C, 20003
i:!02) 0".2BllU
September 4, 1996
Thomas & Connie McConnell
30 Ray Road
Middletown, ~ennsylvania 17057
Re: Michelle Rabenstein
Dear Mr. and Mrs. McConnell:
I am writing to you in an attempt to reach Michelle
Rabenstein. She has not answered my letters or telephone
calls. Therefore, if she does not contact us by Friday,
September 13, 1996, we will file a Motion to Withdraw from her
case.
Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter. Any
help you can provide me would be appreciated. I look forward to
hearing from you in the near future so that her custody matter
can be resolved.
Sincerely yours,
ROBINSON & GERALDO
:t~~
Esqu1re
MBS: jmm
cc: M. Rabenstein
Exhibit
I
. ",
,',
. . ' .
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
" ".Olll'IO""L COIII'O..'IO..
AnoRNtVS AT LAW
Pall Off",. Box 5320
Hamlburg, Pennsytvanil
1711()'532O
c......
11 East Ho" SIIUlI
eo.o..., "" 11013
(717)2'H'!1
-~
"07 Notl" FI!XIl SI.
Hamsllulll, "" 171 10
(717) 232.8!2!
WaSllirlgIOll,D,C,
1318 ~Ave.. S.E.
WaSllirlglon. D,C, 20003
I202l54H889
September 4, 1996
Michelle Rabenatein
9421 Atwood Avenue
Apt. B
Norfolk, Virginia 23503
Re: Custody
Dear Ms. Rabenstein:
I have attempted to contact you numerous times through
letters and telephone calls, but have been unable to reach you.
Therefore, I am writing to inform you that if you do not contact
us by Fridav. SeDtember 13. 1996.we will begin proceedings to
withdraw from" your case.
Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter. I look
forward to hearing from you in the near future.
Sincerely yours,
ROBINSON & GERALDO
:r~s,
Esquire
MBS:jmm
cc: T. & c. McConnell
Exhibit
-
I
I .. .
." \ .
, . " ' I
VERIFICATION
I verify that the statements made in the foregoing Motion to
Withdraw are true and correct to the best of my knowledge. I
understand that false statements herein are made subject to the
penaltie~ of 18 Pa.C.S. Section 4904, relating to unsworn
falsification to authorities.
~l qL~ Ifl'~
d4ffi{(~
ROBINSON & GERALDO
Petitioner
Esquire
~ ., .
. . ' .
, .
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff,
vs.
I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I
I NO. 333B 1995 CIVIL TERM
I
I
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant.
CIVIL ACTION--CUSTODY
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
~ ~, Michelle B. Stokes, Esquire, do hereby certify that on the
~ ~day of September 1996, I caused a true and correct copy of
t e Motion to withdraw to be served upon the following individual and
counsel of record by first class mail by depositing same in the
United States Mail, postage prepaid, in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania:
Michelle Rabenstein
9421 Atwood Avenue
Apt. B
Norfolk, Virginia 23503
Michelle Rabenstein
c/o Thomas & Connie McConnell
30 Ray Road
Middletown, pennsylvania 17057
Ronald E. Johnson
ANDREWS & JOHNSON
7B West Pomfret Street
Carlisle, pennsylvania 17013-3216
Respectfully submitted,
:rd~~~~qU1re
ROBINSON & GERALDO
Attorney 1.0. No. 76272
4407 North Front Street
P.O. Box 5320
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17110-5320
(717) 232-B525
Attorney for Defendant
\
i
I
\
::-.~ - I
Lr; (''; ,
-, ,
, . !
11 ,~ (.; .-
u' , \
f" \
7-- r''': "
~r . ~ ~.I
I-:~ ,- \
lJ.! ('J ; ~,.~
-', I
L'';; ; CL ;'~iJ \
'l.
v; .<1..
I' ,.,") ::)
U C;"\ (..)
..... .....
.~i~
i
,
\
\
\
I
!
, .. i
(717~. 231:25
ROBINSON AND GERALDO
AtTORNEYS AIjD ~OH'sE("'R5 AT LAW
1',0. Box 5320. HARRISBURG. I'ENNSYLVANIA 17110,5320
'OCT C 1 1996_~
CERTIFIED TRUE
AND @"ORREe"r COPY
..I....,
. ".
.
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff,
v.
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
:
:
: NO. 3338 1995 CIVIL TERM
: CIVIL ACTION--CUSTODY
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant.
ORDER
\? tl.day of
orl-a/" "r
19961 upon
AND NOW this
consideration of the attached Motion to Make Rule Absolute, it is
hereby ORDERED and DECREED that the Rule which was Issued on October
2, 1996, to show cause why Defendant's Counsel should not be
permitted to withdraw her appearance of record for the Defendant in
the above matter, is made absolute, and that Defendant's Counsel's
Motion to Withdraw is granted, and the appearance of the Law Firm of
Robinson & Geraldo is hereby withdrawn as counsel of record for
Plaintiff for the above proceedings.
BY THE COURT:
't.tN,\l,\C;\lN3d
Al'ln:r'J C;'I,'(Elimn~
9S:!) I!\J BllJiJ%
^li/1C~::;i'llI.;8J 3'-t~ ~:>
301:1:10"Olltl .. ,
. ..
. ~
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff,
v.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant.
NO. 3338 1995 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION--CUSTODY
MOTION TO MAKE RULE ABSOLUTE
The Petition of Michelle B. Stokes, Esquire, of the Law Offices
of Robinson & Geraldo, respectfully moves this Court to make the Rule
to Show Cause absolute and in support thereof represents:
1. On or about september 30, 1996, Defendant's Counsel filed a
Motion to Withdraw from the above-captioned case. See Exhibit "A"
attached hereto and incorporated herein.
2. On or about October 2, 1996, the Court issued a Rule upon
Defendan~ and Plaintiff to show cause why Defendant's Counsel's
Motion to Withdraw should not be gr~nted. The rule was returnable
within 10 days of service. See Exhibit "B" attached hereto and
incorporated herein.
3. As of October 14, 1996, the parties have not answered
Defendant's Counsel's Motion to Withdraw nor the Rule to Show Cause
issued by the Court on October 2, 1996. The ten (10) days from which
the Rule was returnable has now expired.
I!
"....
.
. ,
WHEREFORE, Counsel for Defendant requests that this Court make
the Rule to Show Cause absolute and grant the Motion to Withdraw,
thus allowing Defendant's Counsel to withdraw her appearance, and the
appearance of the law firm of Robinson & Geraldo, for Defendant in
this action.
Respectfully submitted,
I
t
:r~~::es, Esqu1re
ROBINSON & GERALDO
4407 North Front Street
P.O. Box 5320
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17110
Attorney I.D. '76272
(717) 232-8525
Attorney for Defendant
~
. ,
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff,
vs.
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
:
:
: NO. 3338 1995 CIVIL TERM
:
:
: CIVIL ACTION--CUSTODY
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant.
ORDER
AND NOW this
day of
1996, it is hereby
Motion to Withdraw is
ORDERED and DECREED that Defendant's Counsel's
granted, and the appearance of the law firm of Robinson & Geraldo is
hereby withdrawn as counsel of record for Defendant for the above
proceedings.
BY THE COURT:
J.
CC(Q)rP~
Exhibl:
ItAII
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff,
VII.
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant.
AND NOW, this
.
,
,
I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I
I NO. 3338 1995 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION--CUSTODY
mu&
day of
, 1996, a Rule is hereby
issued upon all ~arties to show cause why the Motion to Withdraw
should not be granted.
RULE RETURNABLE DAYS FROM SERVICE.
J.
:1
.
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff,
VB.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I
I NO. 3338 1995 CIVIL TERM
I CIVIL ACTION--CUSTODY
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant.
MOTION TO WITHDRAW
AND NOW COMES Michelle B. Stokes, Esquire of Robinson & Geraldo,
Petitioner, who, in support of this Motion to Withdraw, avers the
following:
1. On or about August 22, 1995, Defendant, MICHELLE R.
RABENSTEIN, retained the law firm of Robinson & Geraldo to represent
her throughout the above-docketed custody proceedings. See Exhibit
"A" attached hereto and incorporated herein.
2. Petitioner has prepared various court documents, attended a
CustOdy Conciliation Conference, and corresponded with Defendant and
Plaintiff's counsel with regard to the custody proceedings.
3. Defendant currently has an outstanding balance with Robinson
& Geraldo in the approximate amount of $927.50.
4. Defendant has refused to cooperate in attending her
scheduled appointments for the custody evaluation, as ordered by the
October 25, 1995 Court Order. See Exhibits "B" and "C" attached
hereto and incorporated herein.
5. Petitioner has been unable to contact the Defendant by
telephone or by letter.
6. Upon telephoning Defendant's home telephone number,
Petitioner discovered that the telephone number had been disconnected.
~
" ~ -,
., '.
, . , I
'., ".
'.., ,-.
...,
'-- ?
'-. ,:,...,
.'')
"
, ,(')
" : rn
I
.
7. Petitioner has made numerous attempts to contact Plaintiff,
and her parents, by first class mail. See Exhibits "D", "E", "F",
"G", "H", "I", and "J" attached hereto and incorporated herein. The
correspondence sent to Defendant by first class mail is not returned,
however, Defendant has not contacted Robinson , Geraldo as requested.
8. Petitioner has been unable to locate Defendant's whereabouts.
9. Petitioner's continued representation of Defendant has been
rendered unreasonably difficult by virtue of the client's absence,
and good cause exists under Rule 1.16b(5) of the Pennsylvania Rules
of Professional Conduct for Petitioner's withdrawal of appearance in
the case.
10. Despite a fee agreement requiring payment by Defendant for
Petitioner's services and the submission of bills to Defendant,
Defendant currently has an outstanding balance of $927.50.
11. The continued representation of Defendant without payment
of Petitioner's fees, or the prospect of such payment, has resulted
and will further result in an unreasonable financial burden on
Petitioner, and good cause exists therefore under Rule 1.16b(5) of
the PennJylvania Rules of Professional conduct for Petitioner's
withdrawal.
WHEREFORE, Petitioner, Defendant's counsel, respectfully
requests this Honorable Court to grant this Petition of Counsel for
Withdrawal of Appearance.
Respectfully submitted,
,
:r~~~qu~e
ROBINSON & GERAL~
Attorney I.D. No. 76272
4407 North Front Street
P.O. Box 5320
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17110-5320
(717) 232-8525
Attorney for Defendant
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
...0...'110....." CO."OlllA'IO..
ATTORNtVS AT LAW
Pos' 0"":0 Bo. 5320
Hatrlsbutg. PennlVtvln14
17110,5320
WIll 5/10<.
35'0 R_ Road
Comp H., PA IIllII
(711) 737,2779
HAfIlIbUlQ
"lI7 NOIth FrOIlt 51
HamSOurg. PA 171 to
1711) 23US25
WlohonglOn, DC
t3te~...... SE.
WlohonglOn, DC 20003
(202) "".2N1
RETAINER AND FEE AGREEMENT
1. This is a Retainer and Fee Agreement entered into
between THOMAS AND CONNIE MCCONNELL (CLIENT) and ROBINSON AND
GERALDO (ATTORNEYS).
2. Client does, hereby, retain ROBINSON AND GERALDO as
attorneys concerning: Representation of Michelle Rabenstein
regarding Custody.
3. The following matters are to be undertaken by ATTORNEYS
for the CLIENT pursuant to this Agreement: Representation of
Michelle Rabenstein regarding Custody including preparation and
filing of all necessary and pertinent documents, and providing
legal counsel as necessary.
4. The CLIENT agrees to pay the following costs for
services performed:
The CLIENT agrees to pay $150.00 per hour for ATTORNEY
time.
The CLIENT agrees to pay $150.00 per hour for ATTORNEY
time in regard to all Court appearances, hearings or
depositions.
The CLIENT agrees to pay $125.00 per hour for
Associate Attorney time.
The CLIENT agrees to pay $50.00 per hour for Paralegal
time.
The CLIENT agrees to pay $20.00 per hour for word-
processing services.
5. CLIENT also agrees to pay for all out-of-pocket
expenses, including, but not limited to, expenditures for filing
fees, transcripts, subpoena and deposition fees, long distance
telephone calls, postage, xeroxing, travel and all disbursements
necessary for the proper performance of legal services.
a.
b.
c.
d.
e.
6. CLIENT will be billed on the basis of the time spent
and services performed on this matter. Telephone conversations
between the ATTORNEY and the CLIENT will be billed at a minimum
of one-quarter (1/4) hour. Telephone conversations between the
ATTORNEY and opposing counsel, party or other interested party
in this matter will 6e billed at a minimum of one-quarter (1/4)
hour.
E.h,b'l
A
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
.- II.. 'f r I I I I .. .. .- L .; II '1 .. '1 n 4 r , ., of
RETAINER AND FEE AGREEMENT
Page 2
7. The CLIENT agrees to pay ATTORNEYS a retainer of
$600.00 against which the charges described in Paragraph 4 will
be deducted. This Agreement will not be effective until the
retainer fee is paid and this Agreement is signed by ROBINSON
AND GERALDO.
8. ROBINSON AND GERALDO will bill the CLIENT as work
progresses on the matter as itemized in Paragraph 3. The CLIENT
agrees to pay ROBINSON AND GERALDO when billed, but in no
circumstances later than ten (10) days after receipt of the
statement. A 12' annual interest charge will be added to all
accounts with balances due for more than ten (10) days.
9. The CLIENT understands that ATTORNEYS may not ethically
bear the costs of litigation for CLIENTS. Therefore, ROBINSON
AND GERALDO, at their sole option, may withdraw as counsel
should CLIENT'S account become delinquent by a period exceeding
sixty (60) days. ROBINSON AND GERALDO relinquishes no legal
claim against CLIENT for any unpaid balances as a result of such
withdrawal and will utilize the law to its fullest extent as a
means of recourse to fully protect their interests. If it
becomes necessary for ROBINSON AND GERALDO to pursue their legal
rights, CLIENT agrees to bear the cost of all attorners' fees
associated with the litigation of the matter at preva ling
attorney rates.
10. If CLIENT disputes any charges, the CLIENT must notify
ROBINSON AND GERALDO in writing within thirty (30) days.
ROBINSON AND GERALDO will make every effort to clarify or
correct any disputed charge.
11. The CLIENT understands and agrees that this Fee
Agreement does not include legal services in connection with the
appeal of this case. CLIENT will have the choice to retain
ROBINSON AND GERALDO under a new Fee Agreement should this
matter involve an appeal.
12. I have read this Fee Agreement in its entirety, and it
has been explained to me, to my satisfaction. I understand the
~~~;m~a~~~~tain~~in the Agreement and hereby agree to abide by
i~ )z a.~
~ 08 & GERALDO DATE
~~~~h:/iCT)
/) . ???!/J I'JJ:
C&lf~ Mcc6NN~<<""'d""f-(CLIENT)
~;S/95
R - :;;(.;<- 9 s-
DATE
Pauline Wallin, Ph.D.
LIClnlld PJ)/ChO/II,IJI
'" Associates
201 S.u,h nnd Slreel
Camp Hill. PA 17011
(117)161.1114
PAX (111) 161.1942
July 9, 1996
Ms. Michelle Rabenstein
9421 Atwood Avenue
(Apartment BI .
Norfolk, VA 23503
Dear Michelle:
I'm sorry you missed your appointment with me today. As you will recall, when we
spoke on the phone a few weeks ago, I set aside 2 hours today, July 9, and 2 hours
tomorrow, to see you and the children.
This is the second time you have failed to show for an appointment. Although the
appointment was for 2 hours, I am billing you for only 1 hour for a missed appointment.
Because this time was reserved for you, no one else could be scheduled.
If you wish to re-schedule, please be advised that ail future appointments must be paid
for IN ADVANCE. I regret that we need to do this, but I cannot continue to reserve blocks
of time when you do not show up.
Sincerely,
C7y{,jJ ~
~L1NE vJAlJN, Ph.D
licensed Psychologist
PW/eg
cc: Gerald Robinson, Esq. ;"
Exhibit
CONSl
PSYCHOTHERAPY
B
'J';r 2 5 1995
OCT. 27 1995
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff
IIN THB COURT OF COMMON PLBAS OF
ICUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PBNNSYLVANIA
.
.
v
INO. 3338 - CIVIL - 1995
MICHBLLB R. RABBNSTBIN,
Defendant
.
.
.
.
ICIVIL ACTION - CUSTODY
COURT ORDER
AND NOW, this .;)S"1J.,day of ~j;;J~. , 1995, upon consideration of
the attached CUstody Concil-iatlon Report, it is ordered and
directed as followsl
1. The Hearing scheduled in the above case for October 19, 1995,
is cancelled.
2. The parties shall submit themselves and their two minor
children to a custody evaluation to be performed by a
professional as agreed upon by legal counsel for the
parties. Costs of , this evaluation shall be shared equally
by the parties with an adjustment such that the Mother
shall incur any expenses directly related to involvement
of her husband in the evaluation process. Upon completion
of this evaluation and in the event the parties are unable
at that time to reach an agreement, counsel for either
party may contact the Custody Conciliator at which time
the Conciliator can either convene a second Conciliation
Conference or file a report with the Court to schedule
this case for a Hearing before a jUdge.
3. Pending further Order of the Court, this Court.s Order of
June 29, 1995, shall remain in effect.
.-J'
BY THB COURT,
J~i/gl J!1~;!ily ~~~.'
CCI Ronald E. JOhnson, Esquire
Gerald S. RObinson, Bsquire
;:1"-:" ~-.~" !":'~J"'lrl~1 "t"""'ORD
'I- ~ .'. '. '.' . ......... .
~.',' ",: .':, ' , '.:' '1, ~.:, my hand
.. ". .";" \' '''''J'','"", Pa
I ~.t:It. .., - . I ..oJ, .
Tn,. ,:u.. =~y c; ~.
~ ~"., 19,~-:t
....,,,,, , (( .)~
."'" "", .'P~~jh:nt:a~"'.""''''
Exhibit
c
..-;
.
..
..' 0'.
.~'::~~~::};;:~' .
'r! ...t~'. "'.
':~,&;:j.;~ ';~..:.
.5f:...~.....-t~. .
. 'l'~~~i':~:;::"
'",I"A':;I'''''
"(lt~;i>: ,"
I', .t.!'"..... .;-.... .' "
, ~J~~l~,\:...:~.
.~....'.. .
,~i~.'f::,":~~ '
,.... a~ftl....~
," ..i"f.I..J.....
,:f~,r;~:D. ,
.~~~~:;...
., ""~.. ~
, t;'I.." ."
, ;,,~.:t--.... ","
.oJ . i.~~:;;'.
...,~I"'.: .,
. .. .. ~...'
~.
~ ~,:}:\>
'C!t.~. .
'~N' ,"
"~"''''''
.4:.....
iti",
t... .'
"
, .
.:
li:.."
"1r"..
~l...
I~' .......,' .
I ..
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
. ".0.....0..., cO."O_."O"
AnoRNM AT LAW
Poll 0IIce Ilolr S320
Hltlllllutg. ~...
1711()'5.:J20
Michelle Rabenltein
9421 Atwood Avenue
Apt. B
Norfolk, Virginia 23503
ReI
Out:8tandlna BIll
Dear MI. Rabenltein:
"
HBSljmm
eel
T. , C. McConnell
Exhibit
-
o
~
"bel...,.",""
~,~'ro"
(711l7'H.S'
.-.,
.co,......,.......
......." ~ ""0
(71 II m,M7S
June 28, 1996
Sincerely yourl,
ROBINSON , GERALDO
~",".D,C.
':lllS".II~Aw.. S,E.
WI~.... D,C. 7COO3
1207l54C.21le8
.
j:
.
:" !.:f~.:;;,;
~ c, :.:; ~. ";,..,
, .,
.....~.. .:. ~. .
"
.., to...'.,' ...~...;:~:. ". ',I,
':or'
,.I
'j
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
. ""'.'1"".' cO..O.."O_
ATTOlNM AT LAW
PllIl 0IIlCI1IclI ~
HIIftIburg. Pw~
17110.5:120
c..
,'.......,.-
~"""OIJ
(J"Ut:l-..,.
""""""
..o,......_ec.
~""""O
(J1'lDl._
WUI*'og'on, DC,
IJ,ePtM_A",..SE.
WUI*'og'on. D,C, 2DOO:J
l2D2l ,tHII89
July 10, 1995
.".. ...
.' ....
'. ,'-~' ':
'. '.
"
.:.... .'
.'
'.
.../ ;.
;,;'.',?i,:J>>:
'".1. \1:"': :"
'. '.. .'- _:..~. ",;1..-
.' :,.~~J~::i~~.;~~~~:~::
. .. .'.:: :';'..;':"'~"\"i\!.:r;'~1-'S~'
. ......,....,.!.':1.~ ~.,~.~.....,
1. .' "':";"r-.'~-r...~':t"A-
I have attempted to contact you by telephone but' have.::"'~!i:9..~,\\~~:'t~i.:,
discovered that your phone hils been disconnected. Additiorially~,::,;..:>:,':;"
. . I forwarded letters to you on June 18 and 28, 1995, but you.'.have"':';.:,.:;~'.:
,'.' '.. not responded. It ill important that you get in touch .withl;!li~:l!.ot,:'~;,:3.:;~
: )..., that we can communicate. Therefore, please contact me witll'~your.~ ,"'L~'
. . ',:, correct new phone number. :f~~~tt~J~:~i. ,:""0',_
.' . -_. ~~f~?'~,~'''''~",,~'~~~-'
,. ..' I am lltHl waiting to receive from you Ronnie Honick.r, s ::';!lO~~\~~;f.~~:,
Social Security number and date of birth. Please send th'iIil:~.;.:~~J~;'=':~t:i':
~-_~.':.,~,!._".'":.,'._:,',:;,.;,'.~.:.,.,, ~~f~~:~i~~c~~dm~h:~k~oon as POSSibl~ so that we can re~€~l~ii~~~(
. . Please note that I was cOf\tacted by Dr. Wallin tOdayt~nal;;;";"::;:{:C:t:,'
,,..,, , " she informed me that you did .not appear for your scheduled..~.!t.,..jf.~:'tii:!~'; :.;: .
:';::':'0::" , appointment with her. Obviously, she had set aBide an amount;::Of.~:k':t:.
'..i.7":,":ftf'~.~ ,time to meet with you and was inconvenienced when you. didhno,t~.f -'!'}~':%.:
l..~.~i:;,:,t:'j;_,..appear or call her in advance to cancel the appointment; :,!Dr~~~ . .'~;,;'j.'
,.."" ." 'q",.;-: Wallin is now going to require that you pay in advance. for~ all-::1~""~'::"';'~:'.\
...,/ future appointments. You should be aware that your failure,:to:~' '~0~i:""
.:'~ :~,appear for your appointment is not Onl! delaying the progr,ess'::of:-;rii,':"
"",~1,:.~.. your case, but i8 also causing Dr. Wal in to believe that' you~'? ~:"i';,;',:::: .':
ll<i"" are not cooperating '. ',.' ....,"'.. ... ,
",,~lS~:~,::~~::i~!~. .-' , . !~:,~::,~Y~~$~t;r
';"" .
',:::. ;:. '.. . . . ~. :
~ .... ".:. ::
, . ";'. ii ~:. .,...-.
;.i:....~...: ;" .: '..~: .
.~
Michelle Rabenstein
9421 Atwood Avenue
Apt'. B
Norfolk, Virginia 23503
Rei
CUIlt:odv
Dear Ms. Rabenstein I
:~.:.,~ '
i;:::,
-"'v, .
.'
. '
",:;::"'::~;~:~:.i .
'. .... .'r:"'~'..tc.'.'.
.: '.:~~ .:~.;.?:",.'.
. " ..:...:.'.. .~.
. . '.-'
. ," '" .
....:.
· ;:, ~(.,.1i:~';
E.h,b,1
,'.
-
E
.'
..--- ..
,;. . \:\~:'~;~"
. .' . ~. ll':.';"
''','', "';"'/l.!I-.' ,
"..' " ';..'-;'. ;;. Il:';',,'
'1'hanJc you tor your prompt attention to this matter. "It.you" '.' ,
any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. '. , , :1'\:':'
.....:. .~;
,~ti~,~ - ROBINSON &. <..iRALDO
,1!:~.. · ..0....'0..' .0..0..'...
;]"J..'
'\ ,f' Michelle Rabenstein
'" July 10, 1996
Page Two
'..
.i.'
"
'have
Sincerely yours,
ROBINSON , GERALDo
'.
:::,.
.1'. .
")Jl:
....
MBS I jllllll
Br~~
M cne . 0 es,
CCI '1'.
, C. McConnell
.
;i)::i':;, "
fIp:.....)J,', ~
."~~":~' :,\:
-'''''' '
....~.:~' .
.'
"
.'
:;.... ,,;.
'.. ..
';'..S~:~',~~:.!'
~1..'~'.~;;~' ; ;
.1k.~~"'" . ~'..
..~ " ,
~;:r,:,:. ."
~J;' '
~::'<
"
-
"
,.
" 'r ","
I:.:'. ;
"
'::,/ ~.
"
."
.
..:t
..' ,,'
.,' .'t,;.....
EsqUire ",:f;,::. ",'c', '
'::,,:: ;,':f.~::::~;:~~\~:;~.
"::;:I7.f:.~:;E:,~J,'::~1'
..:.... :.~:!-~~P.~i::..
;A',<',~ t; ;?~,:~~:~r~.::'
"fi:f.... ..~,..- ,'~',~'~"!'
....."'."" . -.,..$ :......,.'
'If.,~ ,...~.r.'\,..~. ''j;'" -: \.
:i~',,~,~.' . t~;:.:::..;',"f'~;?~ ,:0-
~'"I''' ..~ .......,.,.,.-...1'..
...,:,~:.~ t: ~:~r""J~,I\C.;:-~',,,
~~::.~:ll'~\i~::~:'.~~~~;f. .
'-.~ .. 1:. ,:~)"ri;..;'~~~''''~
'," .', ;......':~..,.... :~"': .:;~~: ~~:.. ::',,":,,'1.
",; ". .,...".;,....."........0.;,.: ".....
"::::;:.}ti~:'4f.f~~h1:.
,.' i. ~. ';:"';;:"::'::"~':':fJfi"fttft(:~~~.
:;., ,;.~. '~'i>!i:'!.;:...~. ; ":~:';~!,
.,. ~..~.~1',~".~...~.<t...t'
t ,," Iklt..,~..,.. ......~~,'t;'-
'~;'. fl": ,!\"'::-:"::. ::r"..\:t..~...:.
.~. "",;, .~-~. :'.,: :gr, ;~;~.,.r"
. .:1.,::~ .>1f:ir.;'~i;/;:~.~:r\.~'
:.- .t..::. ~{~).~' '''f..~:r::::~.:..
:~.,! ;:,,;;),:-~.:.::':.::';i!:~":'.
'r ~':::" .:... "ij~q:,)..;:
'i I..' ,~. ......~'~~~. .
.;,' "t: ';:.; :;~~\~~:\~1.
'. r..'O. \'~~:~~:' ~
! i[}~~ti ,
-;' ::t.;;':~..'\:l-":i.":
lJ, -.'..,
~: ''', ',.1, ".;,".;-
" . ,.:.:~....
.':' ~-:
""
'~,
'.' .'
......... .,:
...,J'I,t......
..' .?, +
..:...:,....
.'
.,
,
II
I.
~.
,
.-
"':':. :
'-l\..~:.... "
....
'"
.. :.~..,
...... ..
.:~.r~: ',::;:
,,:.;~~"..;.
"..........0.,.
:""'0\. /~~.
....~..,.~~...... .
oQl...~~...ri:.;...:. .
.~~f l:'.~.i,~' .
.).~'''lr''',,,,:,,
.~..:. ~~..\..
~7~~;~~:}~. .
"'...."...t:...;l. "f
. "l.i":~f;'
.". '". f) .
. ?'\,ii.
"" '9(.
->.'\.'i _i~
, !-.oll',:l'.
. .'.~,;
...".,
,'.
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
· '.0'....0...' cO.IIlO."'to..
AnoRNtvS AT IJ\W
Pool 0IIice Boll 5320
Hllriabutg. ~
17110.5320
c......
'FEIII"IJII_
eM........ !F013
171 II 20s.o0S1
~
O<OF ..... ,.... Sl.
HItrlIIug..... !FIIO
P1IIm.8SJS
WaIllinglon,D,C. ,
1311 PoM......... A.... SE,
lYiII*lo..... D,C. 20003
C202J SrW.2118 ." I .:: ~~l/"
: " ..f~~F'
July 26, 1996
.. .
Thomas , Connie McConnell
30 Ray Road
Middletown, pennsylv~nia 17057
Rei Michelle Rabenstein
, "
'.
Dear Mr. and Mrs. McConnell:
';,
" ,
. , ~. . " .'
. i;,.' ._, ;.1-;' ~~-i~:';~:.~.~'
I am writing to you in an attempt to reach l!fichelle'j' '. ,,~:: ):.r> ,
Rabenstein. She apparently missed her appointment with Dr.,- . ' :.:"',:~,,
Wallin without calling in to cancel. Additionally, I have " ", 0.:. ,-.
attempted to contact her numerous times by telephone and by " ' " ",~,:'
letter, but I have been unable to reach her. Recently, I have ':~:'O:::"
discovered that her home telephone number has been ' ;'.' , . ~ ..'.'~:. '
disconnected. Obviously, her case will not proceed if she is ,._:' ,:", ,
unwilling to cOllllllunicate with me. Also, she does have an:,., ", ,;:'"
outstanding balance with this firm. Any help you can provide, me ,.' ::':,
would be appreciated. I look forward to hearing from yoU:"'i~:rthe::> ';;: '
near future so that her custody matter can be resolved. '.... "'::::'~;;:;:\~"i:;r'~I":'
. ,'. ~ ," :.~<~,:: :':~~~!'~:::f~::
. .It.' ......~.
... :.:i}::-~'.~;;'
''':'.' ~"'~'\~'"
....' _c"~.~.\r":.r~~f'-
:. . .,~ .I.f....
McWo~~, -.~qu'".:~~~t~:
'},J':: A~~~:;~~f~~!j' ,
'.." .'.'."I'~~'i:1i.
A.:, Ift~r
.0 . '.;;~.ta.~').i::~~.~"&. '.';.
)';??~::{i.;' ,
.....\".. .
:> ::~.. '.:r::. .
. I :~:: '.~\ !.
. .. .
. ~ ..
Sincerely yours,
ROBINSON , GERALDO
"
MBSI:l1IIllI
CCI M. Rabenstein
. .
..
..
;r
....
.....
Exhibit
, . .
:: I ,i..: . .
. i:;.;/ ~~ ~;.~: ~.l~:~:"~_'~'
'. ..
.-
F
;....
;..; . ~.;.
~:~:.'tt'~ .
)."'..;t.,;~ ~~ :
~./t:~::'~ f
",
.' ....
"... '.. '_f,
'. ......
:.~l::~r::..
~. t.
"~fi"~..~ ....
.......
-
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
. 1l1l0'C"10"., CDIIIlOII..,O"
ATTO.NtYS AT LAW
Poll Offoce &0.. 5320
HllriIburg. ~...
11110.5320
c...",
I' Eo., "V" 51...,
c:"q", '" "Ol~
I' "1 ~'H'51
-...g
.og'......,.... SL
-...g, '" ""0
l''''un.&lD
Wlww.g..... D,C,
'~IIPtm_",-,. se,
WI~..... D,C, 2000:1
l20ZJ "'.zen
August 12, 1995
.:. ...~:......
.' '.' ..,;,~~:(,!
;' .~::: :.',. .
Thomas , Connie McConnell
30 Ray Road
Middletown, Pennsylvania 17057
.. .'
~.' ~'1'~'4 ,.
," .........:;
. , '
'.. r:'..~'::,
~. ;,
'....
Re: Michelle Rabenstein
Dear Mr. and Mrs. McConnell I ;',
" ::. l~ '
I am writing to you in an attempt to reach Michelle , :". ~~>:'r,
Rabenstein. She missed an appointment with Dr. 'Wallin, and IihfL:;:,~l:';:'"
has not answered my letters. Additionally, I ha.ve attemp,ted .,.tc?,~/"~':'<:
contact her by telephone, but have discovered that her home ;"I"",.:~,,;'\t:,,:;, '
telephone number has been dillconnected. As I indicated .in a }t~,:,: \'i( ", '
previous letter to you, her case will not proceed if she Is, ,f,Y,.';.:""."
unwilling to communicate with me. Also, she does have an. ,',:' :.;:{.: <.".:L.., '
outstanding balance with this tirm. If she does not intend, to,'r"f;",:;::,'Jk'"
proceed 'dth this custody mattor, I am requesting that sh'e .:I::~,~'''''!''''1',:t:.;:'\
inform me of that decillion so that we can close her f.1le.,;:wit~.~il;i'~~~f~~h'('"
this firm. " "',,1- . _.",'" ,
. ;,.. . ~':"~it~$:'~.~~'~";"
Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter.:', Any':.~:~":::}~"
help you can provide me would be appreciated. I look forward' to "1!'"
hearing from you in the near' future so that her custody matter',; ':-,.",t "
can be resolved. ".:".~....
00 ,.;. .f....
Sincerely yours, ':~~;'~ij~J':::'
ROBINSON' GERALlJO . ...f"...\
:':~ .~:.::~.;~~~~ ::.:.'
MBSljmm
CCI M. Rabenstein
=~es,
~ "
,
. ":~'" .'
Esquire
"
'. :"'" ", . ~
.1.. _:..:.'.
. .
, ,.'
". ,..
. "
" 't.
. ,
\
',..,
.
,',
" ,
.:...., '.
",
,./ .,
Exhlbll
::~ ;..,
, .
'I'
G
"," .
-
-- --,_,-"c~, ,,_~,_. '__,
-,
...........:-,,---,
,.,,' '.
..',
.,
~,.
'. "
{
I::
I". '
I'~': :",:
,.,;. "
..... ....
10' ,
l ",. .'.
; '~
.
i \..
..
i
,
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
, '.0'.11'0".' cO."O..'IO..
AnolNtl'S AT LAW
Potl OtIC' eo. 5320
H,lrIlbutg. Pennrytven..
17110-5320
c......
'7 Ea""'1'SI...,
c:......."" 11013
1"7)~4H4~1
"-Wg
4407 ......,..... 51.
H.JmslIuog. "" 17"0
(717) ~3z.aS~S
\YNIwlg..... D,C.
131IPOM~A".. 5e.
\YNIwlgton, D.C. 2000:1
I20JJ SOHII8
August 12, 1996
Michelle Rabenstein
9421 Atwood Avenue
Apt. n
Norfolk, Virginia 23503
ReI Custody
Dear Ms. Rabenstein:
r, '....
I have attempted to contact you by telephone but have ;} ';,; _,;..,. "
discovered that your phone has been disconnected. Additionally,.',~
I forwarded letters to you on June 18 and 28, and July 20,' 1996,.... " ,',
but you have not responded. It is important that you get in ',,'. .:, ".
touch with me so that we can communicate. Therefore, please. .' '::. ,,'.
contact me with your correct new phone number. . .:,_.' >J,:~ :,;,,;
,'. , ':',"::,'~'~:-'.:':"':f:~'.:':';:',
I am still waiting to receive from you Ronnie Honick's ";:< '.;':'.':F>"
Social Security number and date of birth. Please send this ...';::::.,,!..(~':..::,
information to me as soon as Possible so that we can request:' a': "~"':~'
criminal record check. , , '..: ':'::,' .
,. . . - " ~.
Also, please contact me 'regarding any appOintments you'have
made with Dr. Wallin. Your custody matter will not proceed .'..' ..
until you have completed your evaluations. It you do not intend. '';','
to pursue this custody matter, please contact me regarding that"" ,.'.,
decision so that I can close your file with this firm. Thank~, ,':: ~"': '
you for your prompt attention to this matter. If you have any...::,',. ;~'
questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. : . .,..
. .. ,
.'
Sincerely yours,
ROBINSON & GERALDO
".. ".: ~" .
'.
~l~~~ EsqUire
MBS l;Jmm
CCI T. & C. MCConnell
E.h,blt
H
.-.-..-...-
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
. ..O'."IO".L cO."O..'ID'"
ATTOINtl'S AT LAW
Poll Ofl'el Bo. 5320
HllriIbuIg. l'Innoylyenil
1711()'532O
c......
'7 elS'HogIISI...1
CIIttIo. "" '70'3
11"12'5"'51
HlnOSllutV
"07 _. F.... 51.
Hamtllurv. "" III 1 0
11"1232,1S25
WltftinV.....O,C.
'311~.Ioo..s.e,
Washing..... O,C, 200lXl
~5U.2en
September 4, 1996
Thomas & Connie McConnell
30 Ray Road
Middletown, ~ennsylvania 17057
Re: Michelle Rabenstein
Dear Mr. and Mrs. McConnell:
I am writing to you in an attempt to reach Michelle
Rabenstein. She has not answered my letters or telephone
calls. Therefore, if she does not contact us by Friday,
September 13, 1996, we will file a Motion to Withdraw from her
case.
Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter. Any
help you can provide me would be appreciated. I look forward to
hearing from you in the near future so that her custody matter
can be resolved.
Sincerely yours,
ROBINSON & GERALDO
:I~~
Esqu1re
HBS: jmm
ce: M. Rabenstein
Exhlb.1
I
· '.0'....0...." CO.~O..'IO..
ROBINSON &. GERALDO
ATTORNtl'S AT LAW
Poll OHIC. eo. 5320
H.,t1,bu,g. "-nnsy/vlnit
17110.5320
COlt'"
.7EoIlHogllSIIlltI
c......."".7013
17'7)20500451
~
0007 NotI" ,..... 51.
Ham~'''''17''0
(7171232'e.l25
Was/WlgI.... O,C,
1318 Ponnl)lvlnil "..." s,e,
WalNngton, O,C. 2OOO:l
l202l ,.0.2_
September 4, 1996
Michelle Rabenstein
9421 Atwood Avenue
Apt. B
Norfolk, Virginia 23503
Re: Custody
Dear Ms. Rabenstein:
I have attempted to contact you numerous times through
letters and telephone calls, but have been unable to reach you.
Therefore, I am writing to inform you that if you do not contact
us by Fridav. SeDtember 13. 1996.we will begin proceedings to
withdraw from. your case.
Thank you for your prompt attention to this matter.
forward to hearing from you in the near future.
Sincerely yours,
ROBINSON & GERALDO
I look
MBS: jrnm
cc: T. & C. MCConnell
=r~s,
ESqui.re
"
E,'"bll
("
\
"
(
, ,
.
VERIFICATION
I verify that the statements made in the foregoing Motion to
Withdraw are true and correct to the best of my knowledge. I
understand that false statements herein are made subject to the
penal tied of 18 Pa.C.S. Section 4904, relating to unsworn
falsification to authorities.
~
ROBINSON , GERALDO
Petitioner
Esquire
RONNIE E. BONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff
v.
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant
, " .
. . , .
I
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
NO. 95-3338 CIVIL TERM
AND NOW, this Z..c:l. day of October, 1996, upon consideration
of the Motion to Withdraw, a Rule is hereby ISSUED upon the
Defendant and Plaintiff to show cause why the relief requested
should not be granted.
RULE RETURNABLE within 10 days of service~
BY THE COURT,
Michelle B. Stokes, Esq.
,/4407 North Fr~nt Street
V P.O. Box 5320
Harrisburg, PA 17110-5320
Attorney for Defendant
Michelle Rabenstein
9421 Atwood Avenue
Apt. B
Norfolk, VA 23503
Michelle Rabenstein
c/o Thomas , Connie McConnell
30 Ray Road
Middletown, PA 17057
Ronald E. Johnson, Esq.
78 West Pomfret Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
:rc
TRUE COpy FROM .RECORD
In Testimony whereof, I hire unto ,set my hand
and the seel of Slid Court at Carlisle, Pa.
~Is .~~~... day of,..&.d;,.:...., 19?-'_
~./l~...~.t'.~
Prothonotary
Exhibit
liB II
. . , .
. t I .
. . . .
VERIFICATION
I verify that the statements made in this foregoing Motion to
Make Rule Absolute are true and correct. I understand that false
statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S.
Section 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
MiC~~SqUire
ROBINSON & GERALDO
Counsel for Defendant
~
.. - . .
I ., .
. - , .
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
RONNIE E. HONICK, SR.,
Plaintiff,
'/8.
NO. 3338 1995 CIVIL TERM
MICHELLE R. RABENSTEIN,
Defendant.
CIVIL ACTION--CUSTODY
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I~Michelle B. Stokes, Esquire, do hereby certify that on the
ay of October, 1996 I caused a true and correct COP! of the
Mo on to Withdraw to be served upon the following individua and
counsel of record by first class mail by depositing same in the
United States Mail, postage prepaid, in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania:
Michelle Rabenstein
9421 Atwood Avenue
Apt. B
Norfolk, Virginia 23503
Michelle Rabenstein
c/o Thomas & Connie McConnell
30 Ray Road
Middletown, Pennsylvania 17057
Ronald E. Johnson
ANDREWS & JOHNSON
78 West Pomfret Street
Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013-3216
Respectfully submitted,
:t~~~~es, :EsqUire
ROBINSON & GERALDO
Attorney 1.0. No. 76272
4407 North Front Street
P.O. Box 5320
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17110-5320
(717) 232-8525
Attorney for Defendant
"
~:
i'
i
~.
~;
~'
\@
,",
,.
11:
i~-'-:
IU;:
<..)".-
E~"
'['
~f-,
~"
u:l'
r::=
l\..
o
(') f::
c ,
("') :!<
,17
-'~~
4J.. .;~
...:> :'~/?
1-' J:Ji5
(..., ~~-~ u.
c;..: ~.::
V'l ::>
u' <J
. . '5
.'... . .
.
(717) 232.8525'
ROBINSON ^l'.:!:> Gtn.ALDO
ATTORNEYS AND ~OUlist~J.ORS AT LAW
P.O. Box S3Z0. HARRISDURCi. PENNSYLVANIA 17110.5)ZO
.. ..
.~
~,
)r
..
~
....
.~
J
s=-
.
; III ! ..
~EnTIFJED TRUE
^ D CO'''''ECT COPY
:J6