The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About95-03424 Q.) "" Vv , ~ I!I,' c') ;jj i'l ~ '" ~ - -( r OJ .... -:::! PJ E> M itlQ ~ 8~ ~- '" ~ It L ,..... I" ..J, ~~ VJ ~' ~ (.d ,0 ~ (I)_I ," .." ~ ~~ " Cl'> Vo\ ~ ~'" ~ ..:-..to: : 'f-. . , "-l.. --::- ~ \ ..J.. ~ ~' S-. ~ '" 1'\ ,~(~~ OF Sf,HVICE OF NOTICE O~ AllPFAl ANI) HULl. 10 flU COMPLAINT ~.u"i"lil tl! lit r;'/IIt1f11 ("v/ ,IJi fi,\) ') ,;,1 il Ii f, !!'J 1/' '" ';/'11"'0/" i'l. I. .i/'I'I" ,J/llro/JO"':;} UlIINI'l' .)1 l.ll~'''Wlf,..\'VlI\l. III ~H l'UJNS)' t V 1l./\JlI~ -.- ,\!. AfFIDAVIT 1:.."1,, I' " 11.1111 If",t I ".' oj SWUIlN , 1\ t'~; r'lh ,,, <lfl" ,.,1 .1"1""''''''''''''1 I' "II, ,1 Iii 'j, I".' 'JI"\III)I,,I (.UI~I[n',111 Pi".!l, tl'l lip,)" 11' I) \I"I\! ,llj',II(1' d""I"IIl.llqJ Ihl.'IHlrI U~~. iii, ,/ ,''',,1'' I ,i q lJ', I)' 1"'110\1 ',q '. d,' I II', I, I'! 1III,:ll) tll;~ji',lllllldJ 1l~,I'I, "1~q'dl"l, '" , : I ,Il,I'J ,1.,1 '11'1,,' '111"11,, ,., _. on . I n. I.~r'" 1,1j'~!PI ill! Jcllh'.I'hclt'tfi:J~ _I'" ilhlll,,:J ;'1 II',.. I., I,! .'tI! ~"''1" 11'1 ,II l ,; 1.1' I II'. rd' ,..,' ,I' ,(i1! 111111)11 ill.l' 11~','d "11,1,,1111 t" l,h'.1 l;1I1l11Ii"dd '1'''1111 !11"Il,",' .1' ,1'1.1,. "'II'IIL Ill,I'!, ~,:"d"1 '., !"'q>,pl _Ill,,, 11,'(111"11"11 I ",'I,I)lIIP,II"/iI111 tll" '\111l~1' 1~,,11\ .', q~ I\PIU"ll It) i '\ I,,' PI\~"\~J,\::\ 'I i,\1 >Il: hv, ,:l;,',I,ild,t>dl IArflRMU11 litH'! I)^Y I'll' ~1)W;cr,lHllll\rrlll1r,- M~, 1'1 '''/'11' ,',IoI,)I,lfIU,i\ 1,"1',,111' " I') I'vly . I llllll), "", dl I I .~ Illll~~ 1)11 , ,! , 'l,i'l Ii .1 ",t,:' ,) ',; COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF curmEnI~AND H,__ '-I.'. ),q N" ]i{; '/( ~ J'I') '/C'l..:J Ti.--., COMMON PLEAS NOTIFICATION REQUEST FORM 09--:1"04 pI.A,Nrl/+ I MEDICOMP, INC. 15 N. ROCKBURN YORK, PA 17402 L NM.U 111\'1 "nOHI' no -I Il:r..,.",,,,/I ^.I.I,,'~" GLENN n. FAllNER 5002 LENKER STREET MECHANICSHUllG, PA ST. "'11"""'" <'T 17171; 1-,0230 17055-0000 OEFINDANJ r- "'AMI. II/HI ADOI\[ un BERGER, DDS, MAllVIN 4004 TRINDLE RD. CAMP HILL, PA 17011 L [D-oCk~IN~CV-OOOOI76-9j DOleFilod 3/29/95 ---_.._-~_.__._-_. VS. -' -, GI.ENN R. FARNEll 5002 LENKER STREET MECHANICSBURG, PA 17055-0000 :~..j ~ PIC05(l bo l1dVHWd tlnf on IlppNl1 illiG Loon Illed In Iho abo\lo cnplirmcd callc. Kindly UIII) Ihl, lorm to Indicate Ihe fOllJtt, in thil> ell: '.' i1tld /elll/Illa tlHI I~ ,llIt, J lluthority (lIr;lod nbovlJ) SUMMARY APPEAL M'p':r,!. GTnrCK=N ,Idlll: I ho:s boon dilloUoWQd :\, Pl:.^L D':;';:'ONTINIJl3U - ,lppOClI hall boon dll>onlinuod by appellant 1)1,:;1 flier .luSTlt;:[ 'l~:c.lrW)N UPHElD. co.,)url hOI$ rOllchod some decision (Hi o,iginal district jlJstico dOC/lIon. - _._ diGln:I,Ulitl':':O ""1';0'1$ to colloct ,om"lnlng IIncs/costs. APPFAL SUCCESSFUL. COUlt hns ronched decl610n lavorable to dofendnnt, lull 'rfund 10 ho Is~'Jtld by dI6trlr:llu~lico otlir.o, portinl 'ChHI[! 10 Iw 1I;5uod by d151riclju51ico office flEVISEC DISmOUTlON OF FINES AND COSTS If dlllt,icl jlJ/,lico offlco 1610 IS5UO n portlol rofund, pleoGo indlcalo any new dlltribuUon In Ihe amoun'(I) fllllr 01 Ill",! co~t& tU'1 n r06U1I ollho court's docislon, RESULUJEllfflfAL f'INL COli,"' Y..:1I1 COST STAn' em COST 9T/\',"[: CGT1 HEMIINO CO~T EMS CAT JCP DVC CVC CCO OThEn(p,oR!lo epoc;jly) CIVil ,lPI',:.IL Aj)PiAL STHICKE.;\.; nPWllI hem Iloon disollowod, Ai)PtAl olscounr lLJCO . oppeal hM boon dlscontinuod by oppol/ent, DISTRICT JUSTICE [J[;CrSI',)N UF-'HElO 0 court haG roochod tho somo decision 01$ tho district juaUco Judgment. OiGTRICT JUSTICE O.:CISICN DISMISSED 0 court hns loached 0 decillion Ihnl dace not concur wilh Iho dietrlcljuaUceludgment. WRIT Of CERTIORARI WRIT STRICKEN. opr::oal h,.Hi beon di6Clllowcd WAil DISCONTlr-;UlO. WIll hoo bf)on di$conUnued by nppellont (}ISrllCT JUSfICF. Of.CISION SF-T ASIDE 0 Iho cn!lo will bo rohoard duo 10 llIl:oguln'lty, lock 01 jurisdiction. or Improper venue. 1\..1", Jlsr.AI~)SED 0 dl51llCt j Jtil,r,(' docl5ion was nollound to bo flawed, locking juri6dlclion , Ot hnvlng improper venue, STATEMl:IH OF ODJECllCiU (PlciJlO glvo 0 gener.llumml'V 0' th. rOlult.) l..)~Jrcnol'l OI~(<'iN j INlll.O 0 ohJoction hn1. boon dl&C(lOlinuod by 1110 oppellanl ().JJL"GnO~1 DtNI!.:i. o:J;I.,:[lon lI{\s boon doni ad by Iho Court of Common Pions O:t..fCfl0rJ UPHf I: {r ,Jullnn!'s objoclio111M been upheld by tho Court 01 Common PIOlU --.-.--..--..-----.-. . ~____._~~..___._o_._____ -......- ~_.-_.-._. ..-- 0"0__- ..__'.___._'_0_.. ---- ...--- -'_'0_.._..,-.- _.._______________~_.._.._ AOPC I::' I,; F'OP.M PRINTED: 6/26/95 13:16:09 r,OMMONWfAL TH Of PENNSYLVANIA _._____.'.___.h._____ .. ~_ "_ _____ COURT Of COMMON PLEA:) CU1'1II~:HJ.l\rm COIHI'J'Y JUDICIAL Ol6TfHCt NOTICE OF APPEAL --l J fllOM DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT COMMONI'LEASNu 9$- 311J4 Ci""f I!_~<:'!J._ NOTICE OF APPEAL . N(I!I l'1! I' lJl\,l)(I Ih.1I 1111' ,JPPI!II,Ull 11.1'> lilt'l! III 1I11' .lllllve COWin' COIIIlIlOfl PII!il" .111 "ppl'.JI ltOIll 1111' jUdlJtlll'nl'l'lId"Il'tJ II'.' Illl! tJl'>IIICI JlJ'>tlOl till Itll! 1I,llt' ,ulll,1I IIh' e.I"I.' IllL'I1I11IlH.'d ""'nw iA....i 01' .....nll'" MJiliYIN BgHm~!"(, UDa ."0.....01' A""IH."'" - ;; i,'~' J.'~2'~~;~O~; ~...~. D' - __-, - -- lun ----.j"jt;QIJ.--- 4004 'fRINDJ,l:; u~,.'o" 'j':'D~"'If" 5-25-.95 lWAll, r ,,;. ; ;;;;~~~O~1J:> , CI\1W HIl,L PBlW:JYr,vllllIlI nOll T.NC. m:HC;SH, DLJ:J I NAI<V J:N " I -I"'.":~.r", '"''-'''';''''' ."....~~. ..'i.; -.'",-, ----. ", .. '\, H' ___h____ "_q _ ~ '..m I ~.~':..,~-" ..Hh___ .s wqLJUl.'d 1I1ldl1t Pi). II "ppvllalll W,IS C/(;'lIilllt (SVO' P./ H,CP.J.P. NtJ, 1001(6) III <Jctiou hf!fore Olstrlf.:r JIISt/Ct!, 1ft! MUST F/LE A COMPLAINT wltl/in tw""ty (201 <laysalw ,i/mY/lIs NOTICE 01 APPEAL, WIll UP'!liHL' iJS C"A.N ",g. CV~ -0900176-95 LT 19___, rtm block will tw SHIIll!d ONLY w/1I!1l R.C PJ P No IOOBll 1111", 1I00iltll)n TIlls NOIICl.' III AP\lI'dl. whl:rl /I~Cl!I\/I!tI tlY Ow DI'!III!.:I JUSIIt:t.', iJ SUPE RSEOE.AS It) tfw jllll!lnh.'llt h)/ pmsl.'....I(j1l 111 11m Cil'il!. ---~----~"-!i"III:;r;;;;;'Jip;'Jtl;rn;J',"Y Ii, a'Wllly PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE fTllls St'er/oll af form to hr.' 1ISl'If ONL Y wlJl.!f/ "lllwll.1IIr W,IS DfFENOANT (StH) Pd, R.C.P.J.P. No. 1001(7) III actIOn /wfort! District JlIsrict!. IF NOr USED, ctNaclt from fOllY of nollo! of 'J/JfJt.'iJl to 1m sl!rvtullllJOn appellf.'f!J. PRAECIPE: To Prol~lllllO,"ry MI:;IJCC~lP, ItIC. . iJPf)lJlIL'iJ(sl. III Ide iJ c~mplaint III 11m appeal N,mltJoI.Jfl/,elllff1(s) ".J (Common PIlIil5 No. 9S:~.~.J.tj__C,4-,-1"'_7{_iIrI Wllhlll twenty (20) dJV5 all,,'- serVice of rlJ~ 01 suffer untrv 'of audgrWJr1f of non pros, . I . I. r~ \ , J ".. r . <.. _....;....~.... J. Slgn,IIur" of IJfJP"'/(mt Qf'hlJ JftorntlV qr Jgeflf EnlfJr rule upon .. ,. RULE: To____/ompICgHI', INC. N.l!1l11 01 ,'PP,Jllt'"(sJ ...._~-__. appellee(s) (11 You arl' notified thai J rule IS hereby entered upon you to filt:! a compliJlIlt in this appeal Within twenty (201 day!'i iJfter the Jatu of service of thiS rule upon you by personiJl service or hV Cl!rtI fltHI or reglstcred mdiL 121 ~f you do nol file il cOlllpl.,nt within Ih" lillie, . JUDGMENT OF NON PROS WI LL BE ENT-tRED AGAINST YOU" f'" ,.. " , . - - . ". . (3) The uateof serVlclt oflhlsrule If serVIce was by mail is the date of mailing. t "." . p' ,,,'I' '~;', I D...:J~~ ;u. , 19~ ~ U\c...':'.[J mlliR.Rr(,;"~:" ,. '__ . .' Signimlfft of Prothbno,,,y 0 Deputy '. '. '" " "" .,to ..... AOPC 31200 ' r:OURT FIlF i'lltllH III SllWII;I nr N.~},Ic:r:~l)r: 'Ai'I'f,)\L ANI! [lUll: TO FILE COMPLAINT , "1,,1 r Ii. ,I I I I' i 1/' II//v' r( ~' /1'1,I.ol ,',', .' I I" 1,1" I., /1,,' 111'(",'. "'f'llo ',ji ! "'1' /, ./Ii/II,,'.//I'" fW'll,,' 'Il , LI!r,lM(JI\i','J! ,~~II. <j , III II'l~'ll ~ I\I~'^ CI)I.'" I ~ '1'4lll.('f.)'fLL ){., All ;:)^VII v " , ';, ", t ""'1 1J/~1. ',9J,' I.P/~~ /J" , '" I r I. II (I ICl0, '?;~~1 :, J" , ' (, .", '" I,d,',f III" II~ " I '",t: Illql'II" .11 Ill, I "",.1'" " \.!t'f', Ih', Ii! ,'1t,Il,. /11'"1' I, " " I' ". u# ( " " ""'''96- 'I "" ;1- ",,' 'I' '\1'111,,,1 1'1"" !Ill' ifill. ",1(. , " 1"1 " .. '. "YIII'"", , i d' I, 'I'" .t.: I , " 'II'"~ :;I~\'IJlll~ 'I\~ '1.:11':1 iI, ,.','9"- ";I;')}.I',l~"1 iJ Iii I 11.1', (p,ur;, . ......c; If' ,'/, I ;' J":' "I" ",J V, "~I L /1/)/ I,/t,' ,_ l., .(t'1- 1'1/ , i' /i,~' kl/" 1'/"': /; <. / , " ',,' I{.j, / ..h/ "I' NoIIIlll Belli CIlrlIllne l. '*"""lI. NeIjlIy Pullllo ""'':=' 0IuphIn CeilnIr MyCol<r ,E.p1,..AprIl2t"," Ji\1 ,I .90" '11 (J ~1(!7fi-Ycfd{!.M~~,,,,,,, (,- c.:: ..... _J .....) <:> '.... .."1 ::..:. -' .' - m '~ I!R ~ - " iE '1'; ", ,_I " , FJ 1- I.~ (Y) " , "r $ -, I , " " .) ~~i ~~< O<Z.. ._<.... .= on Wa.:;:;; ...J;.. i~Vl;Z r::s~E ;.;; ll:C a. . :wi ..J'" ",0 :::!;.. ',., 6, Said Agreement grants Defendant a non-transferable license to use software developed and provided by Plaintiff, and prohibits Defendant from disclosing, assigning, or transferring the said software program, 7, After entering into the said Agreement, Defendant opened a second office in Selinsgrove, Pennsylvania. 8, At the request of Defendant, Plaintiff modified the said software by changing the address to the Selinsgrove address. 9, Thereafter, Defendant changed his location in Camp Hill from Market Street to his present address on Trindle Road, and changed the practice name to Denicor Care Center. 10, In the fourth quarter of 1994, Plaintiff was contacted by Dr. Richard T, Herman, and advised that he had purchased the Selinsgrove practice from Defendant, and seeking to change the practice name and address on the software. 11. Plaintiff advised Dr. Hennan that he would have to purchase a site license to use said software, which he has failed and refused to do. 12. Plaintiff believes and therefore avers that Defendant sold, assigned, or , transferred said software to DI', Herman without the prior written consent of Plaintiff, in violation of the said Agwement between Plaintiff and Defendant, 13. As a result of Defendant's breach of his agreement with Plaintiff, Plaintiff has suffered damages as follows: a, Originailicense fee lost by said transfer $5,000,00 .' , C1 " n _I t" ';) Ii' 'I' (,' , .r:' ,., .....J " = - ...~ .... ._~ ,..,., '- ,.. :.~ ~ .. ;'~, '" ", ,'*:.).. ~l j . I'l',: ;'..t ~',J' ., {,"; ~. . & ';// I ~ ;;';,':: ,'r:~:' ,'.j'" ..HII ", '. . ~ "V SIKARJl,/(fOSIt ZONARlICH ^I!"IH.~,. ^11^'.\ 'I 0 ~ - ,... ~ .. < ~ '" z :l '" <, ~ a: > ~ .. .. .J " IJ) .. - l/I PI otl l/I '" Z .. .. Z l') w OJ I z " '" .. a: IJ) Il. F: 0 ~ ~ " r::: " a: OJ :l Ql !!! a: a: < J: 'i' 7. Adm~tted. 8. Admitted. 9. Admitted in part and Denied in part. It is admitted that Defendant changed his location to the current Trind~e Road address. It is denied that the practice name was ever officially changed to "Denticore Care Center". 10. Neither Admitted or Denied. After reasonable investigation Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to farm a belief as to the truth of the averment. Strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. 11. Neither Admitted or Denied. After reasonable investigation Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averment. Strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. 12. Denied. Plaintiff was made aware of Defendants intentions regarding Dr. Herman prior to the consummation of the sale of the practice to Dr. Herman and was privy to certain conversations with Dr. Herman and Defendant regarding the sale of the Practice. 13. Neit.her Admitted or Denied. After reasonable investigation Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averment. Strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. N.W MATUR 14. At some point prior to the consummation of the purchase of the Selingsgrove Practic~ between Dr. Berger and Dr. Herman, the Plaintiff was contacted by Defendant regarding the transfer of the practice to Dr. Herman to discuss whether or not certain changes could be made in the computer program to make it useable by Dr. Herman. At no time during this conversation did Plaintiff inform Dr. Berger that there would be any additional fee for the changes discussed or that the software could not be transferred to Dr Herman. 15. At the time of the transfer of the Selingsgrove practice to Dr. Herman, Defendant was no longer IIsing Plaintiff I s software. The transfer to Dr. Herman was merely inadvertent insofar as the computers still contained Defendant's old files. 16. As early as 1992, Plaintiff had been contacting Defendant regarding updating the software. Defendant never updated the software and did not wish to keep the software current. In addition, Defendant never paid the annual maIntenance fee and never received the updates or telephone support. In short, at the time Defendant sold. the practice, the Defendant no longer subscribed to Plaintiff's service. 17. At no time either prior to or subsequent to the transfer of the Selingsgrove practice to Dr. Herman did Defendant represent that the Plaintiff's software was for use by Dr. Herman. The