HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-03548
NOTICE OF APPEAL
COMMONWEALTH or PENNSYlVANIA
counT III COMMON l'llAS
I 110M
JUlllCIAllllSTlIICI
Cumbcl'lllnd County
DISTRICT ,IUSTlCE JUDGMENT
COMMON I'He AS No
95-3548 civil Tl:rlll
NOTICE OF APPEAL
NnIICI~ I' qlVt!lllh..1 lIlt' dllJlt'lIanl 11.1\ 1111'11111 lllP ,Ihuvt! CUlllt 01 ClIlllllllltll'leas illl i1Pllt!i11 ftumUlt! jtlllU"Wfll 1l!lldelml hV ,he Oi!lllICI Jus'teu
nil thl! clatH ,lIIil III I Ill! l:asr. llli'tlllUIlUtllwluw
ii"'iii'i"Dt- .".LLAH'---
...,h;
jiic!1grd J;,_Wmlll@r .
...uo.... VI' "'''.'H''~r
--------rTty'---"- -----.----- n
... "'-"";;:-U'U NO. cui tu'.."i' 0' cu.
---1RQbert V. Manlove (09-1-02\
..ioU ." elOI
-.ll;UprtlnL:ltr~Ctl. ., "., .
0"'" or IUtICa..."" lit IH' C.... 0' ,
_JlidJU,)J_~_ _ .-1Q.!m!h.J. Rll~...
CLAIM NO.
I!grrh~~rll .
I'L.
l7l02
,'.,.".
CV-OOOOIBS-95
____,_._-"~_..R!~!l.aI!!._~!_ Wagne r
IIIH.,U.' 0' ....'.~L""t 011 ~II ..'011...... 011 .......,
TA 19
LT 19
--' ~~.._.
WHit!! Pa.
/I a"I'e/lalll was Claimalll (see Pa, R,C,P,J,P,
Tim hlm:k Will 1m SllJlWtl ONLY whel1 this nutilllUll IS leqllirl!(l
R,C,P,J,P, Nil, IOOal!,
Thli Nlllu:l! 01 Appeal, wllell It!cl!Ivell hy Ill(! Dlslln:t Justll:e, will OPt'111"! as
a SUPERSEDEAS In the jlul!)lllent 10l1'1I\SHSSlIH11111111s (:iISI!.
No, IOOlf6) ill aclioll hefore Dislrict JIISlice, he
MUST FILe A COMPLAINT wilhin r"""IV (201
days afler fdillg f,is NOTICE of APPEAL.
S'!lIl,ttUff' of PwtllilmHJrv ur {J'~/llltV
PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE
(This seclioll of form to he IISf.'d ONL Y wfrell .1111ll'/Ii/1I1 was DEFENDANT (see f'a, II, C, f',J.f', No, 1001(71 ill aclioll fJefore Dimicl JIIstlce,
fF NOT USEO. II.lacll Irom copy of 1I0lice of "pl,,'al /0 1m selVl.'d 1111011 apI'elle,,),
PRAECIPE: To P,ulhullut"y
Joscph F, Roe
EIlI!!1 I ule upon
, appolluel.1, tu 'liu a colllpl.int in thi. appeal
N.mlfl 0' oJP/u!fllJl!fsJ
ICo/l1lllnll PI",,, No,~A.lL..C.iYil Tllrln
S'gnature of appell.nr or hI' illlorn,v 0' ,Igt''''
RULE: To_...lQSCI'J.LJL1l..C!!'...._ ........._.______._, "ppullell(.1
Nallwo/oJlll,efl(,f'fsJ
(1) You i1rt! notificd that a ,ulu is hCluhy l~nlclI!tlllll()1l you tn flit! u wrnpltJil1t in Ihis i1I1IJ1'al within twenty 120) daV5 alter the date of
service of 11115 lull! UllUll yuu hy PtJlSUlHl1 serVI(:t! 01 hV f,eltilH~il tll I(llJlUI!lI!d mail,
(21 II YOIl liu nol 1,1" "culllplaint wllhln 11111 IIUll!. a JUDGMENT UF NON PilUS WI LL HE ENTEIlEO AGA'NST YOU.
(3) The dil't! nl 5t!1vicc IIf lhis ,ule II U!lVIt:l! was hy lIIi1ills the c1ule nlmoihnu j , IJ
Datu: _~~.!Y~-L.!..~ ~i _. .._ _ _JLJl-t-li.
S n/JW'flDfP,
AOPC 312 04
"(HIlt/llilltllllIIlIIlWllIiPlnlll\,jj,,I/lllv
t:/ > ~.',
... -... ...... (;:,'
~;, G: ;'\..J - .....
"I'\': ,', IS
r- -,. '~"-'
c\ ~. ' t
" , LoU
~ --. 'A .x,.,
~ ~
k. i~ Q Q:l
.., -J .t:::-. ti
"'
\-~ ~ ~ " I.~
:\1 u '-" \- .'il,_ t:
~ ...1 ,{
~ ",.
N ....t) "" ::J., ..
VI <..... <':'- .~ ~
I
., \.- . \
\-.
! '"\ -
') \
....
\I)
~
'->
"
;_(,,:;-''''' ~'., .'/. .L. ,
PllOOI' OF SEIlVICE OF NOTICE OF'J\fll't;AL AND !lUI.1: HJ FILIi COMPLAINT
I...,\.)
vI
"*'
'4
~
r
~
0-
r--
~
If! _t,.
-11,1\:", ,.,~1il_';1'(!i tli FOlr1T1lii.'.l i\'! ,:", n.;}~:,', fifl'_ 1,;t1;, !',;I ""ii-'p\:! Ch;,,-t.j/!Ji,icr.ttl!(!'!"~"')
ClJMMllNI~1 "",I" 01 I'INNS\ LVANIA
r.OW'Jl Y III
. ~,
AITlD^VI1, I!" 01" ',. ," ,,,,..,, ,h.d I" "','
J' , 11, ,;1 Ill!
rJII!iL\-' ij! !\jljlh3\
COl\l!11U'1 Pl".\!> No
f i
10
. ;WIP, till'
hf' Ih'll.t)ilJ) :'l;I~;(!J -t
D ~1';~,1 Jli\!H,J~ dt'~l\Jlldtrd HIl,'!l','! 'Ill
"1
'I ,.V jet ildll'dlltfljISh,\H~fJl !Ilild, ,i'lIdl'! 't
(HI
!,.i"t"l,.,,,.!\'!tl,i
," i,j-t!,r /i."111.; .'111, i1!Hllljh ;1 Ill' iH" l!l'!' ill-i,!iPi
Iii
\.r l;""~"i,,~j ';-11"1.' ! j hi ir>:-l\iL j1 ip !nld,-.}j l!lail ~f'l\dIH't. itl~:I;Pt fll1..dll'11 "+'Ifll()
! l ;liHl fUII!I!'1 lkit I !;!"\i111! IIw Huh; III hit, .. ,'o"'I;.Lt+ol dI.UH\'I'M\y..i'l
hUll !L.' H,;[; "_h ,.,Llll;~"'1 pi) HI
Hl,. Ilh,',vp Nljl;i() ill ^nfl~~al IlIJutl 11t!1 i:lI'JlPlllil'h I III
Ly j\'i'f~!j!!;jl ~tIVI'!,' [ ,j Ii',' {u'lldiFlIIIH'lj".\I'I!.,11
ilWd, 'il'ptlpt'" Il'fl'lpt i\ll,U;hHI ill..!('lo
GWtJHN
IHIS
.
\AlllliMI OJ ,\fHl
Il^Y PI
'.,. ,t--"
~\j!lSCftlfl[tJ IIUtlht, Ml
ill
,\"iI11,HU'I'lli."f.ml
,')";:','/1" /,,1' f /i:,""
il;-li"t.1J:'"
'!I'" pI ,,'I ,,;
~1y 11111\11\ ,,,,;, t aj 111'" ,in
.__, IlL__
COI\1MONWlAL' If 1)1 f1[NNSVI.VANIA
- .. -_....^.~.._...-... .~_..__.-
NOTICE OF APPEAL
counT 01 COMMON I't fA"
1111),\1
,/UIlIC:lnl 1llSlItlCl
DISTRICT .IUSTlCE JUDGMENT
ClItnh"r I III III COllllty
COMMON IILl.AS Nu
~5-154n Civil T~rm
NOTICE OF APPEAL
NOII!:t' 1\ I/I~,'n 111.11 tllP .111111'11,1111 11,1\ l!lt'd tll Ihl' ,Ihllld! Cn'''t nl ClllIlIlllllll'll'i" ,111 dPlll'.lllrtltll 1111' ludql111:1l111'11I1l!1l'1I hy lilt: Ik,lld:t JU!l1a:u
1111 Ihl' 1I,11i' ,ll\d IlIllw 1:.1\1.' ItIHlltllllll'tlIIl'IUW,
,,'iM,'m .. .PU L..i..,
.Richllrd .t;, Illl!;llCr
AtHI."'ll" ......au.....'
.--'-'1-.'"
J... . --'----,---..,------
. ....~, PIt.. "'0, D" ........ U" ".1
-- lobut V-lInnl()vL.(Q!I~JJ1'__
~ . 1..7u 1:1 II
.ll2J ilnrtillc littcn _ _ _
0"'" u. IUU~N,..t /'" '"III C..... 0.. .
_()fJ/15/~j_ __ ...L1lUCllILf.Kuu
CL...I'" "0.
!lllrr!oburt:
I.'A
--___J1J!!L_
TA 10 C:V-1I011ill H~-q'l
LT 19
-/ -- - - -,,-- -~,ll:lllmLJ';,-Mllw1!tr
..It.....hH''. 01' ".I"~L"'''' Olt Nil ..UO..... o. ...au"
. '\ '\l,.
, ,\ '\" ) "\ .
-__:-:~.b~ ',-: '": _ '~\,~~:"'''-_u_ . ___
1\ It'ljlllll!tI lJlltll)' Pal.
If "'I1/".'II.lllt
W.1S
C/,limmlt (iel.' PI), Il,C,P.J.P,
TIlt.. bInd will hi! lillJtWd ONLY when 11m
fl.C PJ,P, N" 100HII,
1101,111011
Thl5 Nullet! of A"'h!JI, whl!11 ,pcI!llJed by Ilw ()1\I,u':l Jtnlil:l!, will UPI'I,IW 11\
iI SUPEIlSE[J[AS to I III! lutl!jlllclIllOl IIms."\\IIlI1I11llm C'i1SI'.
SI!JII.,tllll' 01 "fllthflll~;;:;;-;'~J1 (}t'IJl/t~'
No, 1001(61 m .lr'tic}fJ twlatt.' District Justin.', ilL'
MUST FILE A COMPLAINT witllill nWllry 1;20)
II.IVS illw, II/mg III, NOTICE of APPEAL.
.-----------
PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE
(TIII~ ~l'('fio" ul form to 1m lis/HI ONi Y wllL'tI 0111/1I-'1/.lllt "'ilS DEFENlJANr(1/.'/.'I',l U.C.P"t.P. No. 100lfl) in JetiolJ befort. OiStflctJustiu!,
IF NO T USED, (h!tl1rIJ from CO/IV 01 "O/Il:I! of .-I"'I!.'J//o Ilt' SI..rVl'(/ II/lOll .lfJI1tl/k'/,'),
PRAECIPE: To P/lllho'1<ll"'V
AOI'c ;11",) LI
I:()IJHI I ILl'
, i1fll1ulh'uhl. In fill! t1 cOlllplaint in tlm .IPlwal
['11l!' lUll! tllltll1
J08oph-L.. Roe
N,mWII''',',II'lIl'l'fsJ
IC"""",,,, Ph'.fI No!l.5-J5411 uClvlL..Iu.rm_1 Wllhio IW'!lIlV 1201 ",'YI all... ""VICe 01 '1,1. '" '''''0' ent,v oll""u",olll ,,' 1I11111"UI,
\ ".\
, ,\ ,~, \"";---
\ 'I:~\k_\ <~. 't.V ' "'\"" . _
S'JlfldWte IJ/.wPf111.", ur IllS .lttome.' (11 "l/II'II'
RULE: r" ,- Jt'Ilr.ph .', ROIL.. _ ________.. ____, al'l'oll.",1I1
N,''''I) ul ,1"1"'11""(0
111 VOII "'" ,,,,,,,,,,,, Ihill il 11110 II ho'"hv ""1""'<1"1'011 VOII I" 'iI" ,I "'>1>11'1""'1 H' Ihi, "1'1ll'ill \~ilhill IW""IV 1201 ".VI alluI Ihe <latu uf
~l!IVlr" 01 IIH~ IIdt! upon you lIy 1l",ISIIIHlI "t!lvicD Of hV CUllificd' III 1t~!lhll!ll!l1 mIld,
121 "V'H' "" nlll 'iI,'" I'OIlpl'''"1 wllhilllhi. lilllll. a JUDGMENT or: NON I'1l0S WilL III r Nt EflED AGAINST VOU,
fJ) lit.. d,III.' \II \l'i\lICe II' Ihis IIllp If \prVIU' WiU hy 111,1111\ Ihl! dill\! of IlWIIIlIII,
Dalo:_n.JuJy J,__19,9)~_.
J
.
PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT
ITlli.. "'001 01 """''''l' MUST BE fll E {J Wlnl/IV riVE l!il /J,11'S A r Tn; /do,u 11"'''1'1'''' 01 "/'1"..,1, CI"!t,A "'>I>"cd/ilV 1111"...1
~---_.._--
COMMONWEAL IIi OF "LNNSYLVAI\I'A
COUI\ITY OF-,-GIIHIlIiIU,AWIl_____ -;t.
AFFIDAVIT: I hl'ldJ\' ~\\I',1I \1/ .Jlfllllllhilll ~l.'fH'd
(Civil '1'111:1.1) ,
I);' .1 I"PY "'II.., N"'lll' ", Ap,,,,..I, C"I1\III"" ","''\ NlI 95-J54~, "I"'" lr", (JII'"I' J""I",. ''''''11'''''''''11'''11'111 1I11
(rldl" 1I1""l1i..'el., U7/0J/US ',.'._, 10.._.>>, 1 J "v P"""""I I. ',i"" L\J "I' 1""'111"<11 111)l!llt~;'Jt'IIII"iI. 11/111""1 \
"'II"P'.I'''" 1"'<111""".,, .,,"1111""'"'" .IPP.II"I'.I",/II,,'I. ,IOH.,,,II ... llu.. " '" ""
,1l7/03/U5.. '-, iii '''' -I I l1y P"I\OI,..I 11'1\"'" 1.:.1 "v (C"'l"""III'!/Il:.,I!lI~' Ill,,,,. "'''''CI', ,ec.illt Oll"c"r,' "r"""
SWORN IAFFIIlM[[J1 ,\ND ~UBSCTlIB[[) UHOIH Mt
THIS'~(.(_lJAY OF... ;SJ;;.RcJ-' 1U'Is:
~;)7t,{,~'i,;"Q,~~,;,,~:#i;~
<JAUlR....-tJ..-I-:t)4J4.~.::~.__._,_ _,.
Tir/eo1offll,.'/al
Mv CUlIIIlllSillHl 1')(11111.'\ Oll__._____~.,~__. 10___
Ixi 011111 flllll"" Ill;;, , II!! VIlli 'he Ilul" III ""e ,I Cur"I"JIIII .lln""PJ"V'"1/ III" "huv. NUII!:c lit ^"fl",,1 UflU" II," "PII"""",.I,,,
"holll 110' nolI' \\'.1\ .001""'''1'01 001., 07/UJ/US '", to ", I I hv 1"'''''''"1 10'.,,,,, Ix] "v hl'II"""" (~Wj~\l'iH!
"lilli, sundel '!, lel:IJlJH iJllddwd hl'loto.
J 'll
\ ( l.l/ (), d.t i)... L
r
(I I ,., .'j
LL LL-tLL _
S'I/tI,ltUft'1)1"III,I'"
No!arIaI Seill
lhi1 J. OIslol./ klfaty P\.ljo
H~ Dillfhn/mjy
I.ttQ1flV1tl.'I5llriE't>Jf<l~ 8.1996
iiisyI;a,j,J~1iir anes
~ .
ORIGINALS A'rI'ACHED TO COpy FILED WITH THE COURT
\'
/,
Z 025 SbD sa?
Receipt for
Certified Mall
~'
-
~:rol=\
Nl) Insurancu CO\'l!filUU f1wvujud
Do 1101 use hll httClnallonl1 MltI
ISIll' RnvCl\cl
'.,."
Jose h F, Roe
'n', '",
c
orth 24th Street
17011
$
2
10
I "i
<,'H'-I!',
",P ,i'.,.,...'.
.".d. ",II" 0'" t.-,
S2 I'r' ,'" ",-, t I' - . I
Ii I., .\, ,..,.." I'. ,_, "--'
~
I
(
j
Ie
1.10
"rl.''''''-''l''-''''''''!''''''''
Pol'" ,,-,., ^ I.!....'''., fill<!
',dt., """11'
,.".-,-
$
2 52
""',1,,.,"1 P P.11,
JULY 6, 1995
Z D2S SbD saa
~ Receipt for
- Certified Mall
Nu In!lUlancu Coverage PUMded
~'lt:'J'IJ,\ Dn nul use 101 Inlemllliunal Mail
ISep. RUVfHsel
DISTRICT JUSTICE MANLO E
"
1901 STATE STREET
j '" ,-.\ ,
CAMP lULL. PA 11011
$
,- "'.
".,(.,,,
1
"j"" "li,.
Il'-";"";"l"",.,I.
!il1',."""H,,;, t.,',_...]
I!! ."j.... ," ),;".1._;1,..,.."
i ';", h.," ,', "" .\'
:'.;-', ,,".lA l_j" ," ,.h.IH'.
r, ~ ^, I..._!, -I '
g"'"
PI 1'., '~I'" I't ,-, I' l!"
!
f
$
JUI,Y 6, 1995
.
Ii"
r
.....!-..
t~. ,
tl:*' .:\.
".\~ I ~
'I;; 0
tK.f-
~~':t . -; j'~
F~,"I
;,f,t'l^1l
~,,~",~b
'4 '''i un
..e- .:,-
!t;
-404
lJ\
(,;)
i
d1
~
,
JOSEPH F. ROE,
Plaintiff
I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I NO. 95-3548 CIVIL TERM
v.
RICHARD C. WAGNER,
Defendant
IO~ICE TO DEFEND
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against
the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action
within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served,
by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and
filing in writing with the court your defenses or objections to the
claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to
do so, the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be
entered against you by the court without further notice for any
money claimed in the Complaint, or for any other claim or relief
requested by the plaintiff. You may lose money or property or
other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF
YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR
TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE
YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Court Administrator
4th Floor
Cumberland County Courthouse
carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 240-6200
JOSEPH F. ROE,
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
:
: NO. 95-3548 CIVIL TERM
v.
RICHARD C. WAGNER,
Defendant
COMPLAINT
AND NOW, comes Plaintiff, Joseph F. Roe, who avers the
following:
1. Plaintiff is Joseph F. Roe, an adult individual residing
at 9 North 24th Street, Camp Hill, Pennsylvania, 17011.
2. Defendant is Richard C. Wagner, an adul t individual
residing at 923 Bartine street, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, 17102.
3. Plaintiff is the owner of a 1983 Subaru automobile bearing
Pennsylvania license JS-JFR.
4. Defendant is the owner of an oldsmobile Sierra sedan
automobile.
5. On April 6, 1995, at approximately 2:15 p.m., Plaintiff
was operating his automobile in a westerly direction on the
northern side of Market Street in the Borough of camp Hill,
Pennsylvania, approaching the intersection of the east end entrance
to the Giant Supermarket and Market Street at which time he came to
a stopped position in anticipation of making a left hand turn into
the east end entrance of the Giant Supermarket.
1
6. At the same time, Defendant WQS operating his automobile
in an attempt to exit the east end exit of the Giant Supermarket
and enter the eastbound lane of Market street.
7. Because of the negligence of Defendant, his automobile
collided with Plaintiff's automobile which was stopped in the
westbound lane of Market street at the intersection of the east end
entrance of the Giant Supermarket and Market street.
8. Defendant was negligent in driving his automobile into the
left front portion of Plaintiff's stopped automobile while turning
into the eastbound lane of Market street.
9. Plaintiff's automobile sustained damage to the left front
fender and the left front door.
10. On May 12, 1995, Plaintiff paid $479.01 to Maaco Auto
Painting' Body Works Centers, 6498 Carlisle Pike, Mechanicsburg,
Pennsylvania 17055, to replace the automobile's left front fender
and repair the left front door.
WBBRBrORB, Plaintiff requests this Honorable Court to award
him damages in the amount of $479.01 plus costs of this action.
i
r
I
i
i
I
I
I
I
Respectfully submitted,
Date I ?,/;~r
~"".~ok.. 9. ~
JOB H F. ROE
2
...
,
>-
JOSEPH F, /W/~,
PlainUff
IN '/'II/~ eOUH1' OF COMMON PLEAS
OUMUlmLAND COUNTY, PA
NO, UII.:l1i4R ClV/L T/mM
v,
RlCHAHD C. WAGN/m,
Dofendllnt
mv/1. ACTION - LAW
AND NOW CIIIIIIlK tho I>ll'","IIIIII, Hldl/II'CI C, WIIUllor by and through his
IIttorneYK, M/~'I"I'E, EVANS & W()Of)HII>J.:, IIl1d l1IllK the fllllowing response to
Plalntlll'8 CIIlIlplllillt:
]-2. Adlllittlld,
:I. DUlliod. Allur rUIIKlIllllhlo illVOKlllflltlllll, tho Dofendant is without
knllwledgo III' illfcmnlltillll KlIflIclllllt III limn II Iwllef 118 to the truth of the
IIvorlllont8 lit' PlIrlllfrllph:l, Hllid lIVurlllUlltH t1wroforllllre denied and strict proof
thorollf i8 e1UlIIlIllllt'd lit Irllll.
4. Adllllt!u!!.
Ii. DUlliud. Alll'l' rtlllHllllllhlo IIIVt'HUlflllllln, tho Dofendant Is without
knowlodlfo or llIliu'lIIl111oll HlIOkh1llt 10 lill'lII 1\ hollut'lIH tll tho truth of the
lIVOrlllontH 01' PllI'lIlfl'lIph Ii, Hillel 1I\'l'f'III11IlIH t1wl'ofhrll 111'0 dOllied and strict proof
thorool' IK e1ulIIlIlldud IIttl'llIl. '1'0 IIw t'Xlt'lItll wply iH I'oqulrod, it Is denied that
PJllilllllT WIIK Hluppud In Ihl! W('HIllIIlIlld 1:1110. '/'0 tho contmry, contnct between the
vohlcloH hllppulwd IllthuIllIHthoullI1 (J}ufllndllllt'K) IlIno of trnvollllld both vehicles
WUl'llllluvhllf.
"
';
,:.~.' t"".
t-,;."i;
"p ,j
I1l'c,'
~ - '
L'#;P:; ~! i'i
'(_H
t..it:
:..U. :1
;:-';~ ~f :~!
,...,.....,;;...
~-t!1
"'Ii ,lk
,.-'11
..'
fs-
,..
-
CI;)
-
-.
01:-
'-.l
fi?
~
6, Admlltod In p/lrt /Ind denlod in port. Il is odmiltod only that on tho
dato /Ind limo In IJIIIlHlion, l>ol'ond/lnt wnll intonding to exit tho oost ond oxit of the
Ginnt Suporlllnrkutnllll unlllr thu u/lllthound lono of Morket Street. By woy of
furthor rUllponHe, Dlllolldnllt'H vehiclll wnH properly located in the right hand side
of the (llnnt oxltnndnt no limo untered the westboulld lone of Market Street,
7, DIIIIII'II. 'I'hll /IVernll!ntH of Puragrnph 7 constitute conclusions of law
to which no rllHponHlvo plu/ldilll{ is required under the Pa.R.C,P, '1'0 the extent a
responllo IH duon\l!d rl'l(U I rl'll, it Is specifically denied that the vehicles collided
hecllUso of tho 1I01{1tl{UIICO of l>ul'undllnt or that Plaintiffs nutol11obile was stopped
in the wosthoulldl/llloof M/lrkot Street nt the time of the collision. '1'0 the
contrnry, PlnlnliO', In oXllcullll1{ hill lell. hand turn into the east end entrnnce of
tho (]Innt Huporm/lrkot, fillled to provide Ilufficient clearance to Iluccessfully
oxecute tho turn. The Defendnnt's vehicle was lnwfully proceeding with a right-
h/lndturn Into tho e/lHthoulldl/lne of Market Street when the collisioll occurred,
/l, Denied. 'l'11l! nVI!rments of Pnrugrnph 8 constituto conclusions of law
to which no rusponHlve ple/ldlng is required under the Pn.H,C.P. To the oxtent a
rUHllIllIHIl Is dmJllll!ll required, it is dellied thnt Defendnllt WIlS negligent by driving
hiH /Iutolllohllo Into the lult I'mnt portion 01' I'lnintiO's Iltoppednutomobilo whilo
turning inlo Mnrket Street. To tho cOlltrul'Y, It wns tho Plnintill's fnilurelo
pruporly oxecute his lelt hund turn which cnulled the nccident. Further, contact
occurred ill the Defendallt'lleulltboundlnne, not tho welltbound I/lne averred by
PlninllfT,
2
9. Adl11itted in part and denied in part, It is admitted only that
Plaintifl's automobile sustained some minor damage as a result of this collision, It
is specifically denied that Plaintifl's vehicle sustained damoge to the left front
fender ond to the left front door os 0 result of this accident be couse, upon
reosonable investigotion, Defendont is without knowledge or informotion sufficient
to form a belief os to the truth of the averments of Paragroph 9, Said averments
therefore are denied ond strict proof thereof is demanded ot trio\.
10. Denied. After reasonable investigotion, Defendant is without
knowledge or informotion sufficient to form a bolief as to the truth of the
averments of Porngraph 10, Said overments therefore are denied and strict proof
thereof is demanded ot tria\.
NEW MATTEIl
11, The foregoing responses to tho Complaint arc ineorporated herein by
reference and reolleged as a defense.
12, The Complaint fuils to state Il claim upon whieh relief can be granted.
13. The contoct botween thu \'chicles wos caused by Plaintifl's follure to
properly negotiote a loft hund turn into thu Giant Supcrmarkut parking lot.
14, '}'he dllmnges to Plainlifl's vehicle did not warrant rOJllocement of a
fender,
3
WHEREFORE, Defendant, Richard C, Wagner, respectfully requests that
this Court dismis8 Plaintiffs Complaint with prejudice and enter judgment in his
favor and against tho Plaintiff, together with an award of such eosts, interest and
other relief as the Court deems just and r01l811nable,
METrE, EVANS & WOODSIDE
,
BY:
\, \'. \' \\ - '
\ ,~1~.,- \. \,' ,\. ,\\,
DAVID A, FITZSIMONS, ESQUIRE
Supreme Court LD. #41722
3401 North Front Street
P,O, Box 5950
Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950
(717) 232-5000
Attorneys for Defendant
DATED: 08104195
~
I, RICHARD C, WAGNER. horeby vorlfy nnd stnte thntto tho extent that
tho foregoing document contains faels supplied by mo. thoy arc true and correct to
tho best of my knowledge, Information nnd belief; however, to the extent that the
foregoing document and/or its lanaunge is that of counsel, I have rolled upon
counsolln making this Verification.
I understand that false statements made herein arc subject to the penalties
of 18 Pa.C,S.A, 04904, rolating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
;;LL~I [J ~AI\Y\
Richard C, Wagner
DATED:
I, DAVID A. FITZSIMONS, ESQUIRE, heroby cortify that on tho ~ day
of AUGUST, 1995, I sorved a copy of tho foregoing documont upon the porson(s)
and in tho manner indicated below, which service satisfies tho requirements of tho
Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, by depositing a eopy of same in the U.S,
mail, First.class postage prepaid, as follows:
Joseph F. Roc
9 North 24th Streot
Harrisburg, PA 17011
(Pro so Plaintlm
METrE, EVANS & WOODSIDE
"-,
BY: ",>~\\:~, \':). ~\~~. .\\~\,'>
DAVID A, FITZSIMONS, ESQUIRE
Supreme Court LD. #41722
3401 North I~rollt Street
P.O. Box 5950
Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950
(717) 232.5000
Attornoys for Defondant
i
'L,,\-.~~
-,.. --......
.' '-
I
~ '
,
~
fl
<-~ i,
01,.':!.
;,F
, ,
;r,..,i..
tR
JOSEPH F, ROE,
PlolnUff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
NO. 95.3548 CIVIL TERM
v,
RICHARD C. WAGNER,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
p
Please mark the above-captioned action sellled, disconllnued and ended
with prejudice. Also, mark any indexed judgments as sollsfied,
2 It ,," VGu:.-_
,..,I-'.~r ......
J'o ph F, Roo
9 North 24th Street
Camp HiII, PA 17011
Pro Be Plaintiff
DATED: March 22, 1996
61183.\
I, JOSEPH F, ROE, Pro Se Plaintiff, horeby certify that on tho...2..2nd.. day of
MARCH, 1996, I served \I copy of the foregoing document VIA HAND DELIVERY
upon tho person(s) and in the manner indicated below, which sorvico satisfies tho
requiroments of tho Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Proceduro:
Kathleen D. Yaninek, Esquiro
METrE, EVANS & WOODSIDE
3401 North Front Streot
P,O, Box 5950
Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950
t7,
~ "'rA... 'I- ,..",,-
JO:p~ F, Roo, Pro Se Plaintiff
it) \
~,;''t q
...,... ;<1
.,.~ , .
u:' n :TJ
','
b !'--.) '~
L' (~-\
r;' ~". Jj
./ .
. .,,-to Irl
\ l~'l '"II
, "
,~ ,)
...; !'>) -J
.,~