HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-03649
-If
J
I
~.
~
VJ
~
~
j
~
..j
ro
~
'}~
,.,.
I'IIAECl ~'!iJ::~.!U_,.!.I;T.~NG CAUE FOil A\lGllHEN'I'
(HWIt bo lYllllWritllJll mill lIulJnitlw in duplicate)
TO TilE 1'1I01'I\ONOTAIIY OF CUHllEllI.ANLJ COUNTY I
please l.ist the within l11iJlt:er for the next fIrg\I1leI1t coort.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CAPTION OF CABE
(entire capLion IlUBt be slatoo in fulll
SUPERIOR METALWORKS, INC.
(Plaintiff)
VB.
TilE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION
(PefeOOant I
l'b. 95
Civil 3649
19 95
1. Slate l11lltter to be argued (i.c" plaintiff's rmtiOl1 for new trial. defemant's
dewrrer to CCJ11llaint, etc.)1
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS, DEFENDANTlS DEMURRER TO COMPLAINT
2. Identify counsel who will arguc case I
(a) for plaintiffl GLENN R. DAVIS ESQUIRE
MdreBsl LATSIIA (0, CAPOZZI PC
PO BOX 825
IIAllRISBUlW PA 17108-0825
(b) fordefemantl GALE T. MAY01l0WSKI ESQUIRE
MdreBsl TilE PENN WAllIlANTY CORPORA1'l0N
360 SOUTII KEYSER AVENUE
TAYLOR !'A 18517
3. '1 will notify all parties in writing wiUlin tw days that UUs case has
been lis too for argIJOOI1 t .
4 . f\r9UlI!I1 t coort 1\1 to I
OCTOBER 11, 1995
(nllx!:
--il'ti'clrlmy TOrhl\FENIJANT GALE T MAYOROWSKI
~~~
G'
~:'!{i:j'
li:t. :~;
M'i.--'
',.:~:-*(.~
~ ~;~i
p!,,:";..t
Sl
If'
;:;
=
,.
..
tf1
.
SUPERIOR HETAWOllJ{S INe I IN TilE COURT OF COMMON I'LEAS OF
PlllintiCC I CUMBERI.AND COUNTY, l'ENNSYLVANIA
I
v. I CIVIL ACTION LAW NO. 95~3649
I CIVIL TERM
TilE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION I
I
Defendant I
I
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111llllllllllllllllllll~
o R D E R
And now this
dsy of
, it is
hereby ordered that the Preliminary Objsctions by the Dsfsndant to
Plaintiff I s complaint are hereby austained in paragrapha (26), (27) I (28),
and the claim for relief indicating consequential damages and loss of use
of the vehicle and business is hereby stricken. Dafendant shall have
thirty (30) days from ths day of this order to answer the complaint.
J
,_. '\.<. ..... ,',
-.,
'"
::1'"
"~;.' .'
It';-7\r'';.
!~t,j1;h~
if,"'"." t,
lr.U7'."
;.l...~'.!1.1M
~dJ ~
~n., ~
J"'."H
~t
"'lI,.
~
r
-
en
-
....
f5
II
tA
.
,
SUl'ERlOR HETALWORKS INC I IN TilE COURT OF COMMON I'LEAS OF
Plaintiff I CUHBERI.AND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
v. I CIVIL ACTION LAW NO. 95-3649
I CI VI L TEIlM
TilE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATlON I
I
De fendant I
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
PRELlHINARY OBJECTIONS
AND NOW, cornea the Defendant, The Penn Warranty Corporation, by and
through its attorney. Gele T. Mayorowski. Esquire. and prel1m~nary objects
to Plaintiff's complaint as follows I
DEMURRER PURSUANT TO PA,R,C.P. 1028 (a) (4),
I. Paragraph (26) of Plaintiff's complaint states that the Plaintiff
suffered the loss of use of this vehicle.
2. Paragraph (27) of Plaintiff's complaint states that os a result of
the loss of the use of the vehicle Plaintiff was unable to engage in ita
normal buainess aetivities and has experienced loss of customers and loss
of bus iness.
3. Psragraph (28) of Plaintif f' s complaint claims for consequential
damages to Plaintiff's business operations,
4. The claim for relief in I'lainliff's compleint demands the cost of
the vehicle. consequential damages and interest, in an amount of excsss of
ten thousand ($10,000.00) dollars,
5, Exhibit itA" attached te I'laintiff's complaint is the warranty
,
agreement between the parties at question hereby and clearly statesl
liThe I'enn Warranty Corporation will not be rosponsibla
for any time that you lose, for any inconvenience you might
be caused, or loss of your transportation, the quality of 0
repair by the repolr center, or for any other Incidental or
consequential damages you may hove, II
4. The warranty clouse is legally enforced between the parties at
is sue.
5. Plaintiff con neither alleged nor recover consequential or
incidental damages as 0 result of this warranty clause.
WHEREFORE, the Defendant demurs thet the portion of this eomplaint
which alleges consequential and incidental damages, be stricken from said
cemplaint.
Respectfully submitted,
~
THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION
360 South Keyser Avenue
Taylor PA 18517
(717)56H600
-2-
,
SUPERIOR MOTORWORKS INC I IN TilE COURT m' COMMON PLEAS OF
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I'lllintiff I
v. I
I
TilE PENN WARRNATY CORPORATION I CIVIL ACTION LAW
I
De fendant I
I
I NO. 95-3649 CIVIL TERM
I
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
C1!RTIFICATE OF SERVICE
,f
I. Gale T. Mayorowski, Esquire, hereby certifies thst on the /
day of Au ,; v 11 ,1995, I did serve a true and corract copy of tha
foregoing Preliminary Objections by first class mail, postage pre-paid to
the following I
Glenn R. Davis Esquire
PO Box 825
Harrisburg PA 17108
/
53397
The Penn Warranty Corporation
360 South Keyaer Avenue
Taylor PA 18517
(717) 562-7600
. ~ ~"""" \, _ .i,.. -...--
i~ ~
.1~~t en
\;Ii'iJw,"
~\;r~l,l =
iil~
-,.""..,:'.......--..
- - .... "
, .
~
.
~
. \
~. '..
SUPERIOR METALWORKS,INC, : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY I PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff
v.
: CIVIL ACTION NO, 95.3649 CIVIL TERM
PENN WARRANTY
CORPORATION
Defendant
NOTICE
YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT, If you wish to defend against the claims
set forth In the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this
complaint and notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by
attorney and filing In writing with the court your defenses or objections to the claims set
forth against you, You are warned that if you fall to do so the case may proceed
without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the court without further
notice for any money claimed in the complaint or for any other claim or relief requested
by the plaintiff, You may lose money or property or other rights important to you,
YOU SHOULD TAKE nus PAPER TO YOUR LA WYER AT ONCE, IF yOU
DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE
THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL
HELP,
Lawyer Referral Service
Court Administrator
Cumberland County Courthouse
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 240-6200
NOTICIA
Le han demandado a usted en la corte, 51 usted qulere defenderse de estas
demnndno expuestas en IlIb paglnas slgulentes, usted tlene vlente (20) dlas de plazo 111
partir de la fechll de la demanda y la notlflcaclon, Usted debe presentar una aparlenda
escrlta 0 en persona 0 por abogauo y archlvar en la corte en forma escrlta sus ue{ensas 0
sus objeciones alas uemanuas en contra ue su persona, Sea avlsauo que sl usted no se
ueflende, la corte tomara meuldas y pueue entrar una oruen contra usleu sin previa
avlso 0 notiflcacion y par cunlquler que)n 0 nlivlo que es peuluo en la peticlon de
uemanda, Us leu pueue peruer uinero 0 SUS propleuades 0 olros uerechos Importanles
para usteu,
LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABODAGO INMEDlATEMENTE, 51 NO
T!ENE ABOGADO 0 51 NO TIENE EL DlNERO 5UPIClENTE DE P AGAR TAL
5ERVICIO V A Y A EN PERSONA 0 LLAME POR TELEPONO A LA OPICINA CuY A
D1RECCION 5E ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABA}O PARA AVERIGUAR DONDESE
PUEDE CONSEGUIR ASI5TENCIA LEGAL.
Lawyer Referral Service
Court Administrator
Cumberland County Courthouse
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 240.6200
(717) 969.9600
SUPERIOR METALWORKS,INC, : IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plnln\ifl'
v,
'--
: CIVIL ACTION NO, 9.). ~fo49 Cut'! 1'i.lZn1
PENN WARRANTY
CORPORATION
Defendanl
COMPLAINT
AND NOW, comes PlalnlilT, Superior Metnlworks, Inc" nnd hereby complains
ngalnsllhe above-named Defendanl as follows:
I, PlalnlilT, Superior Melalworks, Inc, (hereinaOer "SMI"), is a corpornlion
organized under Ihe laws of the Commonweahh of Pennsylvania with principle offices
loealed al1416 Trindle Road, Carli sic, Pcnnsylvanla 17013,
2, Defendant, Penn Wnrrnnty Corporntion (hcrcinallcr "I'WC"), upon
informalion and belief; is a corporation organizcd undcr thc laws of thc Conlll1onweallh
of Pennsylvania with principle officcs locatcd at 730 S, Main Strccl, Old Forge,
Pennsylvania 18158,
3, SMI performs customl11ctal work scrviccs In Pcnnsylvllnla nnd
contiguous slalcs,
4, SMl's pcrlimllllncc ofcuslol1ll1lcllll work scrvlccs on hchlllfofcustomcrs
rcqulrcs it 10 tmvel tolhc spcdl1c loclltlons IhroughoutPcnnsylvllnillllnd conllguous
StlltCS,
5, In ordcr to hc IIhlc 10 dcllvcr scrvlccs tolls cuslol1lcrs, SMlls rClJulrcd 10
Imvello cuslol1lcr locutions In II vehicle of sull1dcnt slzc to dcliver mctlll work producls
und also to curry Ihe nccessury equlpmenl to pcrlimll on-site scrvlccs,
6, SMI derivcs slgnll1cant husiness und genemtes slgnificanl revenues from
milking cuslomer delivery IInd performing cuslomer location services III various locations
Ihroughout Pennsylvanlu und contiguous slules.
7, In order to provloe services lolls cuslolllcrs III thcse locations Ihroughoul
Pennsylvania IIno contiguous slates, SMI is rcquireo 10 make use of Iruck Iransportatlon;
8MI purchaseo a 1990 F-350 ("Foro") truck, VINII I FDlIF37117LNA98493 from
Cockrell's Auto Sales, locateo In Mechanlcshurg, Pennsylvunill on April 22, 1994,
8, In conjunction with thc purchase oflhc Ford, 8MI artlculuteo 10 Cockrcll's
Ihal the proper operullonofthe vehicle wus cssclltiul to 8M!'s husiness und Cockrell
suggcstco thai 8MI purchase IIn extenoeo II'lIrrllnty offered hy ('WC lin Ihe Foro,
9, Upon inquiry into IIn extcnded wllrrunty hy 8MI, Kcnllllrtzcllof
Cockrell's IIno IIclinglls IIgcnlof ('WC, o!lerco to scllutll'o-ycur wurrunty Issued hy
pwe, which is uttacheo herelollllo ineorporuteo 115 Exhlhit A,
10, 8Mlllcccptco the Icrms oflhe wurrunty contrucllllld elltcred Into the
warranty conlrllct with PWC uno 8MI 1'1110 III cOllsloerlltlonofthls cOlltruet Ihe IImount of
$480,00,
2
11, Cockrcll, IIctlnllllS IIllcnllbr I'Wl', Ibrwllrdcd thc cxcculcd wurrunty
ullrccmcnt to I'WC ulong with puymcnt Inthc umuunt uf$4HO,OO,
12, Thc wllrrunty contruct \Vus cntcrcd into bcl\Vccnlhc purtlcs in
Mcchunicsburll, "A,
13, Thc warrllnty contr'llct cntcrcd Into bctwccnthc Pllrtlcs pcrtlllncd to the
replllr IInd replaccmcnt of pllrts IInd scrvicc on thc Ford for II pcriod of two ycars from the
dllte ofpurchllse, (Exhlbil A),
14, In reliance upon thc purchase of the wllrranly contract, 8MI purchased the
vehicle for $7,343,00 (Exhlbil Il); tillc was transfcrred to 8MI as a rcsult of the
transaction,
1 S. The warrllnty conlruct issucd by "we on thc Ford llfiimlcd the purchase
condition of the Ford and promlscd to rcpair and rcplace, as the tcnns dcslgnated, thc
Ford regardless of condition,
16, The Ford had approximalcly 90,000 mllcs on Its odomctcr whcn
purchascd,
17, Wilhin the two ycar pcriod oflhe warrllnty contruct IInd lit 97,701mllcs on
the Ford's odomctcr, thc Ford cxpcricnccd transmission prohlcms which rcqulrcd the
rcplaccmcnt ofthc transmission lit Cockrcll's by havinllllused trllnsmissionlnstallcd
thcrein which rcpalrs wcre in the nature 01'$1,072.36 (Exhibit C),
3
18. Immcdiutcl)' upon Icurning of thc trnnsmission prohlcm with Ihc Ford,
SMI notlllcd PWC ofthc condition ol'thc vchiclc. tiling u c1ulm undcr thc pruccdurcs HCt
lilrth in thc wurrunt)',
19, Thc Ford's trnnsmissiun pruhlcm wus nut cuuscd h)' un)' use, misusc,
ultcrution, tumpering, Impruper udjuslmeut, impruper fuel. improper muintenunce or
failure of maintenance ofthc Ford In violution ofthc warrant)',
20, From the time ofpurchuse 10 thc tlmc ofthc transmission prohlcm, SMl
properl)' serviccd and malntuincd the Ford and fullilled 011 of its ohligalions under the
tcrnts of the warrant)' contract.
21. From the timc ofpurchuse to the time of the transmission problem, 8Ml
did not alter or change the condition of the Ford os purchased,
22, PWC has rcfused \0 repair or mukc rclmhurscmcntto 8MI for the cost of
the rcpalrs of the Ford,
23, SMlgavc propcr notice ofthc condition ofthc Ford und c1ahn agulnstthe
warrant)' to PWC within 0 rcasonahlc timc,
24, PWC's rcfusal to fullllllts obligallons undcr thc tcnns and conditions of
the warrant)' constltutc breach of contruct.
25, PWC's refusal 10 rcpulr thc Ford or makc rcimburscmcnt to SMI under the
tenns and conditions of thc wllrrnnt)' contrllct constitutes hrcuch.
26, PWC's willful. wllnton llnd outrngcous conduct In den)'lng this warrllllt)'
contract has caused SMI to sulTcr lhc loss of usc of this vehicle,
4
27, As u rcsult ofthc loss ofusc of this vehlclc, SMI WIIS unllblc 10 cnl!ullc In
Rcspcctfully submlttcd,
its nonnul busincss uctivitlcs IInd hils cxpcrlcnccd loss of customcrs und loss of buslncss,
2H, PWC's unwurrnntcd uctlons Inlmpropcrly dcnylng u propcr wurrunly
c1uhn undcr Ihc wurrunty conlrnct, hu\'c cuuscd conscqucntllll dumugcs to SMl's busincss
opcrullons,
WIIEREFORE, I'luinlitT, Supcrior MClulworks, Inc" dcmunds judgl11cnl ugulnsl
Dcfcndunl, Pcnn Wurranty Corporutlon lor thc cosIoI' repairs, cost of Ihc vchlcle,
consequenllal damagcs and Intcrcsl. In an al110unlln excess of ten thousand ($10,000)
dollars,
Latsha & Capo7zl, I',C,
Daled:
fl,dlpleldlnplwmplllnV,ml
( " .) \
,-~.............QLL')
OIenn R, Davis
Attorney 1.0, /I 31040
Post Omce Box H25
lIarrlsburg,l'A 1710H
(717) 761-IHHO
Allorneys lor Plalntlfi'
~
VBRtrICATION
I verify that the statements made in the foregoing complaint
are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information,
and belief, I understand that false statements herein are made
SUbject to the penalties of 18 Pa,C.S. 1.90. relating to unsworn
falsification to authorities.
DATED I
JUNE 3D. lUO
. ~(I -:
-.
eo . W. Baokenstoes, III
Vioe Preaident
superior Metalworks, Inc.
EXHIBIT A
., . . "
The Penn Warranty Corporation ~[p[pm@w @~@(4::'
730 South Main Street lJ
Old Forge, PA 18518
(800) 358.9441 M~Y /2 I~'.': II",
Und.r \hl. USED CAR LIMITED WARRANTY, THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORA TION ",'II r.,mbu,;, xPU lor th.'.P." or rOllI.c.m.nt of
.ny compon.nl co,.r.d by Ih'. agr..m.nl \hall. lound 10 b. o.l.c\l'. or ",o,n b.yond .."IC~ 11rtl1lllE N. ccimi><iiio;,~:llVl". mull
occur und.r norm.1 u.. 01 tho car during \h. ",."anly co,.rag. p.llod. Th. u..o car Ilmll.d "'.".IJl'l./fflVI'!.' qn tho o.y ",h.n Ihll
.gr..m.nl II .cc.pl.d by THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORA TiON and lOll' lor Ih. p."od ...1 10rlh il'.'l'0W'. '1i.p.ir ~lllm.t.. can b.
don. al any qu.lIl1.d '.parr .hop you cnoo... AII.r ,n,..tlgatlng your cl."n lor ,..mbura.m.n\' ,n thO co.. 01. dl.c'.pancy In IIndlng..
THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORA TiON may chao,. 10 h.'. Ih. r.pa". don. at a .hop dlll.r.n\ Ih.n \h. on. you hav. selecl.d. Wh.n
m.klng r.palr. Ih. r.parr InoP .hall u.. compononl. 01 Ih. .001. Iyp. ano quallly u Iho.. ramo,.d. THE PENN WARANTY
CORPORATION ""II r.,mbur.. you lor Iho .nW. amount 01 a co,.r.d compon.n\ lallur., I... r.lal.d chalg.. nol co,.rad by Ihl.
agr..m.nl, I... Iw.nly II.. dollarl p.r occur.nco. Should a co,.'.d '.parr I.k. mar. Ih.n .8 hour. THE PENN WARRANTY
CORPORA TION ""II pro"d.lran.porta\lon ..mlanc.. THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORA TION ""II r.,mbura. you a bu. r.n\al charg.
01 up 10 \",.nty II,. dollar. par day, lor no mOl.lhan Ihra. day.. THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATiON ""II nol I..mbu'Nlh. mllllg.
ch.rg.. on \h. ,.nlll car. II your car mU'1 b. \o",.d bocaulI a co,.r.d p.rI h.. la,l.d, THE PENN WARRAtITY CORPORATION ",'II
r.'mbur..low,ng 10 tho n..r..\ quallll.d r.palr c.n\or uP 10 a mall mum 01 lI11y dollar.. Thl. wa"anly Ooes nol co,.r \h. pan. and labol
Ih.1 are n..d.d 10 malOl.,n your'Cal 10"',1111..., .lc.l, Ih..parll 01 your clllhal or. lubi.cllo no,mal w.ar and 100rllan b.llI, radiator
ho..., .\c.), d.m.g. to your Jlllh.1 r..ull' Irom 11r.,lpccld.nl, 'hOII, or condlllon. ,qllh. .n,lornm.nl, d.mag. l/lat rllull. 'rom
.om.on.all.rlng Ih. car, mllu,'ng Ih. car, tamp.rlng wllh Ih. c.r, m.k,ng ,mprop.r adlullm.nll.lmprop.r lu.I., Improp.rly m.'nl.'nlng
Ih. CII, or 1.llIng 10 malOl.'n tho car. Thl. u..d c.rllmll.d w."an\y I. \ran.l.rabl.lo lub..qu.nl own.... To Iran,'.r Ihilagrllm.nl you
mull r.qu..t . \r.n,'.r 01 own.rahlp lorm Irom u. at \h. abo'. addr..., \h. charg. for \ran.l.r iI on. hundrod dollar.. Th.lran.la".d
warranly will r.maln In .II.CI lor Ih. r.malnd., ollh. Orlgln.1 co,.rag. pOllod. Wllhoul a \r.n,'.r 10 Ih. n.w own.r Ihla con\r.cl I.
I.rmlnal.d al \h. 11m. 01 ..1.01 Ih. ,.hlcll co,.r.d ,n Ihll con\rac\. No cr.dll ""II b. i..u.d on ..rly lI,mlna\lont.
Under thle uaed car limited warranty, the following Ie a lIat 01 covered componenta.
.
Cyllnd.r block, head., and all in\.rnal p.rts. Manllold'. Val,. Ir.IO and Co,.ra. Flywh..1. Camahall and \lmlng
drl,. compon.nl', 011 pump and 0,1 pan.
Cu. and alllnl.rnal pan.. To'qu. Con,.n., and con,.'ler hou.lng.
Fronl or r.ar drIVe axl. hou,'ng and alllnl.,nal parI.. Dr". .hall and unIYereallo,n\.. Tran,'.r cu. on lour wh..1
drlv. ,.hlcl.. and alllnl.rnal pan.. F,ont axl. iolnl. are co,.'.d only on lour wh..1 drIVe ,.hlclll.
COOLING Fan and Ian clUlch. EI.c\rlc radl.lor Ian molar, Wal.r pump.
STEERING Sleerlng g.ar and alllnl.rnal parts. Po",.r .I..rlng cool.r and IIn...
SUSPENSION Spring., Con\rolllm.. Balllolnll. Splndl. .nd splndl. luppon..
BRAKES All compon.nll oxc.pl...llnlng./pad., rOlors/drum..
ELECTRICAL AII.rna\or, ,oll.g. r.gulllor, ",Ind.hl.,d wlp.r 010\01, and lIarl.r molar.
LABOR Th. I.bor charg.. b...d on Indullry acc.pl.d lIal ral.. 10 raplac., or r.palr a co,.r.d compon.n\,
No olh.r compon.nl.. olh.r than Iho.. 1I.\.d, are co,ar.d by Ihl. ",arr.n\y. Th. procedure 10 lollow wh.n making a claim lor
r.lmburs.m.nl und.r Ih,', warran\y w,lI b. ..n\ 10 you wllh your acc.pl.d copy 01 \hll contract. Should yOU nol r.c.'VI notlflca\lon Irom
u. wllhln m-day. 01 Ih. lIalu. 01 your con\racl acc.planc., notify u. .1 cualom.r .."Ic. II 18001356.~1. THE PENN
WARRANTY CORPORATION ree.rv.. tho rlghl to r.l.cl or cancal wllh cau.., any conlract. THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION
dO.. nol aUlhorll. any p.rson 10 c,eel. lor 1\ any obllg.tlon or lIabillly In connoctlon wl\h thl. warranly. THE PENN WARRANTY
CORPORATION will not ba r..ponSlbl. lor .ny \1m. \ha\ you 10'., lor any inconv.nl.nc. you m,ghl b. c.u.ed, or 10.. 01 your
tr.n.port.\lon, Iha quallly 01 a r.palr by tho r.p.'r c.nl.r, or lor any olhOr Incldanlal or con..qu.ntl.1 d.mag.. you may hav.. Your
uaed .car.lIl1)lI.d w.rr.nly gIWlt')'<ltI"'POClllc rlgh)', You..g"y hav. oth.r "ghts \h.1 vary Irom "". 10 ".\.. Pl.... read Ihl. conlraclln
lull balora signing. . , ,~-, ,..' :
'( \'
. ,.- ~-'1't'- q't I F- ~ ~f-1 '7 H 1t:N i\" J"o.(CjJ'
DAn J Y1H . - WAIlIWITl PBlU!STlIIIdwoi IIlII
~
fUP,,'IOJ ,"~t'Yll.l..Jd'KJ' II./(. \ ''-Ie, C
0WNIIlS NAME VIIIKU VIAll
ENGINE
TRANSMISSION
DRIVE AXLE
!
,
...AJlIltI.
110
lOOlOI
14\(. r,II,~)L~ )\l,
(,\) \.l flii:
fiJll j
IlMaJlt1lh.
I3lIlJI
VlltICUMm
v
'j,/ur to:.
14manUlDTL
I4Ill1I
IllY
VDIIl1f MOon
STAll
)1\,
I
zw,'70(Z
q()~r7r
;
JI/ I ., r:o .r"b
tt'l.:';?_.J' OlAUR'S
PHONII'1I'1
')~01)..~ ./
"--'
MWGl
ltml/l!lD11.
IiI4lI
IlWNlllS PHON(
~I'I - ).4f.;''14(.P\JNl1ASlPIIICl
I undars\lnd and Igr.. \hll \h. IImlled wlrranly I am purchlSIOg IS In ag,..m.n\ belw.sn my.." and THE PENN WARRANTY
CORPORATiON. I lurifler under,,"nd Ind agr..lhlllh. cal dul.' 'rom wh,ch I pUlchU.d IhlS conllacl hIS no lIablll\y 10 Ihaagream.nl,
olherlh.n .ubm'\Ilng Iha paym.nl and n.cs..ary p.perwo'k 10 THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATiON lor proca,,'ng.
,,- -' DEALER'S NAME(' 1 ,~,I ill.; ,1v~ f,{'"~"
OWNERB ACCEPTANCE TOTEAt.'Sjr; rl_I~/,:. ".'~<'r...1- SALEMAN'S NA~E ~;;,~ tLloft'!.i"...<-
For",.rd \hlS conllac\ ",lIh payn1~nlln IU;I-I~ THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORA Tio\allh. aUo,. .dd'....
WHITE {MAIL WITH PAYMENn CANARY {MAIL WITH PAYMENn PINK (CUSTOMER) GOLD {CAR DEALERI
1,' 1990 HiE PENN WARRANTY CORPORA liON
.
aXHlPlT a
-.",.
jJ~r
1{i'~
COCKRELL'S AUTO SALES
717-788-4227
5270 East Trindle Read
Machanicsburg, PA 17055
NAMI... ,"-,4 " . - L 1':.0-
.lVle.,I<i. ,1\,!:-L1\L. V "",J"
ITllIIT
I '-f \" \,~ .;/)~;O: ,1),
art l!.r\~ 1..( fLE:. mrt I,\.
-
...
I DATI
!,Jr. 4-3..r.Cjr
/101J
,.
1::-
I'\.IAII en'" MY ORDlR I'OR THI fOllOWNl
o NIW. I] UIID 0 llIWO 0""" 0 mucK ='
nNlql)
_111
..... -
; Jll;>
lOOllIL
r ;. ,-"'3
1YPI
-ry
I1llQlIl1
I f ~ Ii f 7'; H ,} I.. ,J d '1 ( ~. '1 ':J
I J ( .-: I lAW"'" 110 IIll1UVtJWl ON OR AIOOT
, '" _ f.( .t,i.( .r: - -.: '. I~ 'to
ODOMETER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT
"...., I.. (1Ild Blalt law, II appllcallll) requlr.. Iha' you alalt \hl milllQI upon Iranata,
of ~Ip. Fallure 10 campllta Of providing. lal.. al.temlnl m.y "aul\ In fin.. .nd/ar
lmpr1aanlT*1l.
I, COCKRELL'S AUTO SALES , ala\1 that IhI adomllar
(tran.ferar'I n.me - PRINT] q" i '7 ~
(of !he vehicle daacIibed abcMl now "ada I. I _ (no lanth'l mil..
and to IhI ~ 01 my kMwledgtllhatll "nlClllhl .01uil mileage of Ihl .Ihlcll daacrtbed
-. un... ana atlhl foIlawtng alllam.ntala chocked.
a (111 hanlly certify '/lalla the b.at or my knowledg. Ihl adaml\er reading renoct. \hl
amount at mllMge In ...... of III moch.nlc" IImlta.
a (21 I hanlly CII1Ily l/Iat thl adomater r..dlng I. NOT thl a01ual mil..g.. WARNING-
ODOMET1!A DISCREPANCY.
TIW_ _~.. ""TID~tKUlAI
,( E',-.J f-\ it ,\ ~ "t .:.'; \.. ~
TWlI~_ ~ .1IOIWlN 1- jv\'
.f':....,...... 14. "_-
~_lJU\'l/ll1 .-,
\!0 .<f-'-J~n.:-'p -..,,:.:; r."'- I J~, I
'r.:; __~"'l\JOI.I...-:? .;<'.,{
f \IJ ../ ,('".-"'/'Y'" f_ " "r',,~" ~....'/
. . ,""""IN
YI!AA
SERIAL ,
T1TU! ,
MAKE
UCENSE
EXP. DATE
, .lIllthal tho adaml"r
(1tana1lllOl'l name-PRINT]
(of !he whlcJe deaCribad abcM) now "ad. (no lan\h.) mil..
IIld to \he beat of my kMwladga Ihatlt "nlClllhl' aclu.1 mileage of the v.hlcle doacrlbed
-. un... one of the lallowlng a""menllla chec"-d.
a (1) I tMnby carllfy \hatla Ih. blal of my knowledgl thl adomllor "adlng rollOCla the
amount 01 mlleaglln .IICI" 01 It. mlchlnlcalllmlla.
0121' hefeby c"lIly lhel \hl adometer raadlng la NOT \hl actual mll..gl. WARNING-
ODOMIlTl!R DISCREPANCY.
~ ~lID ""'''''CUSTOMERI
TfWW"lAOfft 8IONATUAI
Tf\AHInRI!n PfUHYfO NAMlloeAlfA A(PI
TfWWIRE.n IIOHATUAI
ACCI'TmIn":
_DAfl;
punCItASEn'lIIOHAfVRE X
'AICI Of' VIHCLI
~ '7 f:,) cl'"l
oICCUIORlU
.1 (,( ~ 'f ~ I~ ('-_
J- .
I ~ J-i,J !.JA/.l ..t,..,-.,
'+t'd ~
TOTAl. PReI
I ~ '2 '
.:1 ~I - v :..Jb
1l\AOI.w ALlOWANCI
--
~ r'2 rJ (f"t")
CASH twRAEHCI
IALUT....
L,- <) 'I (0
~ '9 I1/)
UCE/<SE. lAAHSFER. nne. ENe.
DOCWEHTAAY fiE
:;"'f ~(;
SUBTOTAL
t1~l(.2 n
--
)'1'(-'3 c.~
UNPAID tw.AHC! ON TRADE.IN
TOTAL
CEPO', r
CASH DOWN OH DIUVEAY
IAW<CE
UEHHOUlI"
ADDAUS
AUOUNT
OUEDATI
.... co.
POI.lCY .
o\llINCYPIiONI.
COHT'MC'TUAL DIIClOI'MIITATIIIDlT
POR UIID vma.a ONlY
~ lfttDnIIlODn """... on thlliMdoIII kInIl tor I'" WhIdI" '*'
oliN. conited. In~ an IN ......loml...,.... MY........
trwy ptCMIiOrll it thI..... 01.......
MCTOIIY WoUUWlTY
My wemney on MY "'" weI*tI 01 ~ ""'*:II .. ..... lilt .
~. wwrMfY lIl". mIldIby 1ht"""""1lftlW.
DATI:
" --~ ,- -... - -- ~-_._~
aXHllllT C
....-..0;.......=11 ==1:,: 1:'=======: ..a-r ..aa ::=::t::== JC:=r aaa.,. .......
I COCKRELL'S AUTO SALES
5270 E, TRINDL~ RD.
MECHANICSBURG, PA. 17065 (717) 766-4227
za===D=.=aso====~a===C=.==2=D.===2=a=a==.=~~====a=.a.==c:aac:==:==...aa~aD...a
Customer SuPERIOR ME7AL WORKS :~C,
Acdress ~416 T~I~CL~ R;.
City/Statel C~RLI5LE, PA,
Vehlc~s I 90 FORO
Plate 4 I YZ36025
Mileage In-097701
TeohnicIanl
Servlca8 performed I
SUBLET LASOR (TOWING)
~ & I TRANS (INSTALL USED UNIT)
CISASSEMBLE TRA~5 FOR INSPECTION
---EST, COST TO RE9UILO---Il,600,OC TO 12000,00
17013
F-3150 CUSTOM
C..at ,,: U3
Mile~Q' Cut- 09770~
04..8 . 03/05/9S
h~r.Il:1l ( 717 )
Workl~717) Z4e-2446
VINI 1FOHF37~7LNAge4~3
\in.i to .1
45.00
l:J!l.150
'5:l.SC
-
-~N![~WE RECOMMEND RETURNING IN 1500 TO
, H~VE i~ANS CHEC~EC AND SERVICiO,
PART I DESCRIPTION
USED EAOD TRANS
000 TRANS FLUID
1,000 MILIU TO
QTV.
1.00
8,00
PRlee:
8!O,O:O
2.'S
!XT.
BllO,OC
:l2,O~
I hmo, lulhollu 1r.1 IOnl tlUlI uOtllO bl dont lion, wilh thl amm1
Illltlll 1"/ h",by ,rlnl ,OJ lnd/tl ,our 'O,IOYIII p.rallllOI 10 O'lrlll
Ii, ,.niolo lor In, pur00011 " 1"Iinl Ind !nl,'llion, An IIPr'l1 llChl'ill
1111 il hor,or ,clno.IIOIIO 01 IbOVI "hlol. \1 IllUrl 1~1 I:ovnl 0/ 'IOI:~I thlflll,
loulnt 0,00
InSCIC\lOl UD
II,viclt 2)1,10
Ilrll '72,00
Neldl ImlCII
...................
M'I:tli I\~UO
!\K 11,11
rnvo!cl I 101
~mm / I
....~...-...............
1m:
\172,)$
lA/ t/ ,pI qr ;:;17- l,v s r4-u.J 11/ '?
tI:s G7? T,f.'#USIt)Jj5/'O.u
~t
b4
~ l(l *
~1)l.1
('0.()
'..t
q
J,
J
Ir
.r";
~. :
-.J
N
~ Iv
~ ~.
~j-J
I\l
CT.
l~ \
,
0-:-\
:.i.
..
1ft
1) 1/\ ~
~ 1>-
l\;i1~
:E ~ 1-'
~ ~'i_
f
'+
SUPERIOR METALWORKS, INC,
I
Plaintiff I
I
I CIVIL ACTION LAW
I
I NO, 95-3649 CIVIL TERM
I
I
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA
v.
TilE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION,
Defendant
ANSWER WlTIl NEW HA'lTKR
AND NOW, comes the Defendant, The Penn Warranty Corporation, by and
through its attorney. Gale T. Mayorowski, Esquire. answers and avers as
follows I
1. After reasonable investigation. Defendant is without knowledge or
information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the avermente of
this paragraph. the same would be denied,
2. Admitted, by way of further answer. Defendant, TIle Penn Warranty
Corporation's home office is located at 360 South Keyser Avenue, Tsylor.
Lackawanna County, Pennsylvsnis, IB517,
3. After reasonable investigation, Defendsnt is without
information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the
this paragraph, the same would be denied,
knowledge or
averments of
knowledge or
averments of
knowledge or
averments of
knowlsdge or
averments of
know ledge or
avermenta of
4. After reasonable inveatigation, Defendant ia without
information aufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the
this parngraph, the same would be denied.
5. After reasonable investigation. Defendant is without
information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the
this paragraph. the same would be denied.
6. After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without
information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the
this paragrnph. the same would be denied.
7, After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without
information sufficient to form n belief as to the truth of the
this paragraph, the same would be denied.
8. Denied. It Is apecificnlly denied upon 8m IS inquiry into an
extended warrnnty, Ken Ilartzell of Cockrell's ,mtl nctlng as agent of PWC,
oCfered to sell a two year warranty issued by PWC. On the contrary, Ken
lIartzell of Cockrell's is not an agent of The Penn Warranty Corporation and
is a car dealer who merely accepts applications Cor the warranty to be
Corwarded to The Penn Warranty Corporation for approval or denial.
9, Admitted, by way oC Curther answer. said contract went into effect
on May 12. 1994 when it wss approved by The Penn Warrsnty Corporation,
10. Denied. It is specially denied Cockrell. acting as agent for PWC.
forwarded the executed warranty agreement to PWC along with payment in the
amount oC $635.00, On the contrary, Cockrell is not an agent of The Penn
Warranty Corporation, but is merely a csr dealer who submits applications
to The Penn Warranty Corporation Cor approval or denial. In addition, The
Penn Warranty Corporation received $480.00 for this agreement between the
parties.
11.
effect
1994.
Admitted,
when it was
By way of further answer, said document went into
approved by The Penn Warranty Corporation on May 14,
12. The agreement between the parties speak Cor itself.
13, After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or
information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of
this paragraph, the ssme would be denied.
14. Denied, It is specifically denied the warranty contract issued by
PWC on the Ford affirmed the purchase condition of the Ford and promised to
repair and replace. as the terms designated, the Ford regardless of
condition, On the contrary, the agreement between the psrties clearly
otates that the vehicle must fail under normal conditions during the
warranty coverage period,
15, Denied, It is specifically denied the Ford had approximately
90,000 miles on its odometer when purchased. On the contrary, as pursuant
to the agreement between the parties attached to Plaintiff's complaint and
marked Exhibit A, the correct mileage on the vehicle was 90,278 miles.
16. After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or
information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of
this paragraph, the same would be denied.
17. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is edmitted that a claim
has been filed under the procedure set forth in the warranty. As to the
remaining allegation in paragraph seventeen (17) after reasonable
investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to
form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph, the same
would be denied.
-2-
18. Denied, It is specifically denied the .'ord's transmhBlol1 problem
was not caused hy any use, misuse, alteration, tampering improper
adjustment, improper fuel , Improper maintenance or failure of maintenance
of the .'ord In violation of the warranty. On the contrary, said
transmisaion was leaking fluid and run low on fluid and therefore, was not
properly maintained by the owner of the vehicle,
19, After reasonable investigation, Defendant Is without knowledge or
Informstlon sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of
this paragraph, the same would be denied,
20. After reasonable Investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or
informstlon suHiclent to form a belief ss to the truth of the sverments of
this paragraph, the same would be denied,
21. Admitted,
22. After reasonsble investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or
Information sufficient to form a bsllet as to the truth of the averments of
this paragraph, the same would he denied,
23, Denied.
obligations, repair
and conditions of the
the contrary, It was
caused the dsmsge and
It is specifically denied PWC's refusal to fulfill its
the Ford or make reimhursement to 8Ml under the terms
warranty contract constitutes hreach of contract, On
the Plsintiff's failure to maintain the vehicle which
thus not covered under the warrsnty agreement,
24. Denied, It is specifically denied PWC's actions in denying the
claim under this warranty contract constitute willful, wsnton and
outrsgeous conduct on their part. On the contrary, It was ths Plaintiff's
actions and failure to maintsin the vehicle which caused the dsmsge and
thus not covered under the warranty agreement.
25, After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or
information sufficient to form a hellef as to the truth of the averments of
this paragraph, the same would be denied,
26. After reasonable investigstion, Defendant is without knowledge or
informstion sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of
this psragraph, the same would be denied,
WIIEREFORll, lJefendant. The Penn Warranty Corporation, demsnds judgment
in its favor together with cost,
NEW MATTER
27, lJefendant incorporated hy reference paragrapha one (I) through
twenty-six (26) of this answer as if fully set forth herein.
-J-
28. Any and all damage suffered by the Plaintiff are clearly exeluded
under this warranty. The relevant exclusions include, but sre not limited
to, the exclusion which states lithe component fallure must occur under
normal use of the car during the warranty coverage periodll and IIdamage to
your car that results from fire, accident, theft or condition of the
environment, damage that result from someone altering the car. misusing the
car. tampering with the car. making improper adjustments. improper fluids,
improperly maintaining the car. or failure to maintain the car.
WHEREFORE. Defendant, The Penn Warranty Corporation. demands judgment
against Plaintiff plus cost.
Respectfully submitted,
/' "
(,
~..,
/
/'
Gale T. Mayorowski
Attorney for Defe
!DIll 53397
THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION
360 South Keyser Avenue
Taylor PA 18517
(717)562~7600
~Il-
AFFIDAVIT
I. Jeffrey H, Luhu, state that I am the I'reddent of nle Penn
Warranty Corporation. the Defendant herein, that I am authorhed to make
this affidavit on its behalf and that the facts set forth in the foregoing
Answer With New Hetter are true upon my personal knowledge. information,
and belief.
I understand that my statements are made aubject to 18 Pa.C.S.A, ,
4904 and related federal provisions providing for criminal penalties for
unaworn falsification to authoritiea.
Datel r /J~# /y J'
, .
~
SUPERIOR METALIo/ORKS. INO I IN 1'I1II COURT 011 CoMMON PLEAS 01"
1'1aint iff I CUMBERIJ\NIl COUNTY I l'ENNSYl.VAN1A
I
v. I CIVIL ACTION LAW
I
TilE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION I NO, 95-3649 CIVIL TERM
Defendent I
I
11111111111111111111111111111 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
~:
I, Gale T, Mayorowaki, Esquire. hereby certifies that on the l~'
day of /oj I [. I ' . 1995. I did serve a true and correct eopy of the
foregoing Anawer With New Matter. by first class mail. postage preMpaid.
return receipt request ad to the followingl
Glenn R, Davis Esquire
Latsha & Capozzi P C
Post Office Box 825
Harrisburg PA 17108-0825
t.l~<ay~~wJlkt-.-~Jl~qut~1l 10 153397
Attorney for 06fendant
Thl! Pllnn Warranty Corporation
360 South Keyser AVenUe
Taylor PA 18517
(717)562-7600
1"::1
!lK,
. i '
!f~;
-"'-"t1,
H~il.1
:JlI'
..
..
If
-
\
II
$
hi
u1
~
.~.
.
SUPERIOR METAL WORKS,INC, : IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMIIElU.ANI> COIJNTY,I'ENNSYLV ANIA
Plnlntll1'
v,
: CIVIL ACTION NO, 95.3649 CIVIL TERM
PENN WARRANTY
CORPORATION
Defendnnt
NOTICE
yOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT, If you wish 10 defend ngnlnstthe c1nlms
setlorth in the following pnges, you mustlnke nction within twenty (20) dnys nfter this
complnlnt nnd notice nre served, by cntering a wrlttcn appcnrancc personally or by nllorney
nnd filing in writing with the court your defenses or objections to the c1nims sct forth
ngnlnst you, You nre wnrned thnt if you fall 10 do so the cnse mny proceed without you nnd
n judgment mny be cntered ngninst you by the court withoUI further noticc for nny money
c1nimed in the complnint or for nny other c1nim or relief requested by the plnintifT. You
mny lose money or property or other rights importnnt to you,
yOU SHOULD TAKE TIllS PAPER TO YOUR LA WYER AT ONCE, IF YOU
DO NOT IIA VE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, 00 TO OR TELEPHONE
TIlE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE yOU CAN OET LEGAL
HELP,
Lnwyer Referrul Service
Court Administrutor
Cumberlnmt County Courthouse
Carlisle, I' A t 7013
(717) 240-6200
NOTlCIA
Lll hnn demnndndo u usted en In corte, Siustcd l)uiere defenderse de estns
demnndns expuestns ell Ins pUlllllns siguientes. usled tiene '/iente (20) dlus de pluzo ul pnrtlr
de In fecha de lu demundn y lu notification, Usled debe presentur unu upurlellclu escrltn 0
ell personn 0 por ubogudo y urchivur en lu corte en fimllu escrltu sus defensus 0 sus
objeclones n Ins del1lundus en contrn de su personu, Seu uvisudo que slusted no sc
SUPllItlOR METAL WORKS, INC, : IN TI III COURT OF COMMON P/.BAS
: CUMlIE/{I.ANIl COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plulnllll'
v,
: CIVIL ACTION NO, 95.3649 Civil Tenn
PENN WARRANTY
CORPORA TION
Defendant
AMENUF.1l COMIII.AINI
AND NOW. comes PlalnllO: Superior Metalworks, Inc,. and hereby complains
against the above-named Defendunt as fhl/ows:
1. PlulntlO: Superior Metalworks,lnc, (herelnaner "SM/").ls a corporation
organized under the laws of the Conllllonwealth of Pennsylvania with principle omces
located at 1416 Trlndle I{oad, Carlisle. I'ennsylvnnla 17013.
2, Defendant, Penn Wnrranty Corporation (herelnaner "pwe"). upon
Inthrrnatlon and bellet: Is n corporntion orl!nnlzed under the Inws of the Conllllonwealth
of Pennsylvanln with principle olllces locnled at 730 S, Mnln Street, Old Forge.
Pennsylvania 18 I 58,
3. SMI per/hrllls CUslOlllllletal work services In Pennsylvnula aud
contiguous stutes,
4, SMl's pcrlhrmuncc or custnmmcllll work scrviccs nn hchulf of cuslomcrs
rcqulrcs illolruvcllo thc spcdlic locutions throughoulPcnnsylvlIuillllnd contiguous
sillies,
5, lu ordcr to hc lIhlc 10 dclivcr scrvlccs to its customcrs, SMI is rcquircd 10
truvcllo customcr locntions In II vchiclc of sul11c1cnl slzc to dclivcr mcllll work products
and also 10 carry Ihc ncccssllry cquipmcnt to pcrrormon-sitc scrvlccs,
6, 8MI purchnscd II 1990 F-350 ("Ford") lruck, from Cockrell's Aulo Sales,
located In Mechanicshurg, Pcnnsylvania on April 22, 1994.
7. In conjunction wilh Ihc purchasc oflhc Ford, 8MI articulatcd 10 Cockrell's
that the proper opcrntlonoflhc vehiclc WllS esscntinlto SMl's husiness and Cockrell
suggestcd thnl 8MI purchase an cxlendcd warrnnty otlcred by PWC for the Ford,
8, Upon 8MI's Inquiry into an extended warrllnty, Ken Hartzell of Cockrell's
and aCling as agenlof PWC, otlcred 10 scll a two-ycllr warranty issued by PWC, (attached
hereto and incorporaled us Exhlbil A),
9, SMI acccpted the terms of the warrunty contract and entered into the
warranly contracl wilh pwe and 8MI puid in considerulionofthls conlrncl the umounl of
$480,00,
\0, Cockrcll, uctlnglls lIgent Ihr I'WC, forwardcd thc executed warrunty
ugreement 10 I'we nlong with paymcnt In thc lImount of $635,00,
II, The wnrrunty conlruct \VIIS enlercd inlo belwecn the pllrtles In
Mechanicsburg.PA,
2
12, The wurrunty conlrncl enlcrcd Into hctweenlhe purtlcs pcrlulncd tolhe
repulr und replucement of purts uml service onlhe Ford lilr u period or two yeurs from the
dale of purchnsc, (Exhlhil ^),
13, In rellnnce upon the purchuse of the wllrrnnty conlmcl, SMI purchused the
vehicle lhr $7,343.()() (Exhlhltll); title wus trnnslcrred to SMlus u result ofthe
transaction,
14, The wnrrllnty contract issued hy PWC on the Ford ull1rmed the purchase
condition of the FNd llnd promised to repulr und replllce, as the terms designoted, the
Ford regardless of condition,
I S, The Ford hud approximately IJO,()()O miles on Its odometer when
purchased,
16, Wilhlnthe two yeur period ofthe warranty contracl and at 97.7011ll1les on
the Ford's odometer, the Ford experienced transmission problems which required the
replacement ofthe transmission at Cockrell's by having a used transmission Installed
therein which repairs were In the nulure of$1.072J6 (Exhibit C),
17, hllmedlutely upon leurnlng of the trunsmlsslon problem wlllt the Ford,
SMlnotll1ed I'WC of the condition of the vehicle, 11 ling 0 e1ahllunder lhe procedures sel
forth In the warmnty,
18, The Ford's trunsmisslon problem wus not cnused hy nn)' use. misuse.
ullerutlon. tUl11perlng, Improper ndjustment, Improper I\lel, Improper mnlntenanee or
fullure of I11nlntenunce ofthe Ford In vlolutlon of the wnrrnnty,
J
19. Fromlhc limc ol'purchusc to thc timc ol'lhc lruusmlsslon prohlcm, SMI
propcrl)' scrviccd und mulntulncd thc Ford und Ihll1lblull 01' Its ohllgllllons undcr Ihc
tcrms of the wurrnnty conlrnct.
20, From the Ilmc ol'purchuse to the limc ol'thc trnnsmisslon prohlcm, SMI
did not niter or chunge thc condition of the Ford us purchuscd,
21, PWC hus rclilscd 10 rcpuir or mukc rcimhurscmcnt to SMI fin the cost of
the repuirs of the Ford.
22. 8MI guve proper notice ofthc condition ol'the Ford und c1uimuguinst the
wurranty to PWC within a rcnsonnhle time,
23. PWC's refusnl to fulfill its ohlignlions, repnir the Ford or Illake
reimhursement to SMlunder the tenns und conditions of the warranty contract constitutes
hrcach of contract.
24, PWC's actions in denying Ihe claim under this warranty contract
constitute willful, wanton and outrugcous conduct onlhelr part,
25, 8MI has suOcred damages in excess 01'$1,807.35,
26, The damages In this mutter lire within In the mandatory arhltration limits
sellbrth by this Court,
,I
WI IEIWFOIW, Plllllltill". Superior fl1ellllworks, Ine" demllnds judgment agulnst
Defendant. Penn Wurrllnly Curpurlltlon Ihr the COSlll!' repairs, and such lither cllsls as the
courl deems upproprlule Includlnglhc cosio!' Ihls sull.
Itcspcetf\llIy subll1l11ed,
Lutshll & CupllzzI,P,C,
Dated: (ilif({dlo, 1??5
r:ardlpICldlna",nmplllnVamll,eom
r ~n l ::1.03 ~\n
Glenn R. Davis
Allorney (J), /I 31040
Post Office Box 825
Harrisburg, JlA 17108
(717) 761.1880
AlIorneys for PlalntltT
~
VF.IUF1CA nON
I verity that the statements made in the (oreioin. Amended Complaint II' true
and concet to the best of my knowledse, INormado!\, and beUef. I understand that fal..
statements herein arc mad. subject to the penalties of 18 l'a,C,5, '4904 ralatln, to
unsworn tilslflc.uon to authorities,
DATED: 8-/8-?.r
..i~ ~ &4/,; ('I..J 11C
Gcarle W. Dickensto.., m
Viet Pr..ldcnt
Sup.rior Metalwork., lng,
I,
,
EXHIBIT A
. ,~
,
.
T' , Penn Warramy Corporation ~iP~m@~ ~@,'. "
730 South Main Slreet LL1 /
Old Forge, PA 18518
1800) 3ea.9W rLl 1m 12 I~':: I !)
',j
unaer In'a USEO C~R LIMITED WARRANTY, THE PENN W~RR~llrl C~RPCR~ TIO~j .dl roomeu'i' X>lu la, In. ltD." or rOOI.c.m.nl 01
any camDon.ne Colver,a ty this ac;".m.nt lI"oat II fcuna 10 be a.'.etl.... orNorn tle)cna llroIle l1iuae tt1el ~;;P~;fJVU(l mUlt
cc:ur una., norm'l ulI of the cat during tht Narranty CO'1.ra~. ;'t1ol1. Tt'I. uselJ car limited 'Nlrrarr:covfl'.' QI't l~' dly ...ht" thiS
~~,..m.nl ,. ~"CtDlla by THE PENN WARR~N'" CORPORA TICIl ~nQ 1~$15 la, In. :'"0a,lll 10lln bOlO.;l '11.D.,r ~Ilim.'" c3n C.
Clonl at any Qualified tlCI'f IhOD you ~nco". Att., invutl~allno your claim tor rllmoursement. In I'" CU, 01. dl.cr.:ancy In IInOinc;s.
THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION m~y cncc.. 10 n." lno ItD~'" acn,., . .ncD alll.ltnlln~n In. on. you n.v. "'OClla, Wn.n
m,.'no r,o.'" In. reD'" .noo .n~'1 u.. comcon.nlS 01 In. ..m. IVD. ~na au.,Ily as Ino.. remo"a, THE PE~N WARANTY
CORPORATION Will reImburse you lor Iht toW. amount of I. covered comeone"l 'allure, 1.11 relaltd Ch.r~.. not co...rld by 1t'1l5
.;r..m.nl, IIU tw.nly IIv. aollars Der oc:urence, snoula a coverea reo." laxe more tn.n 013 houre THE H~N WARRANTY
CORPORA TlDN w,lI prov,allren.oonlllon ualSt.nCI, THE PENN W~RRANTY CORPORA TlON w,lI rllmourn you a b.u renlSl Ch.';'
01 UD 10 Iw.nly live dOllars Der aay, lor no mare Ihan Ihrel a.VI, THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORA TION.,II nol rtlmcurUln. m,I..~.
cn~ro.. on Ih. '.nt.' car, II your car mUll b. lowed bec~u.. a cO"'la D.rt nas la,l.d, THE PE~N WARRANTY CORPORATION w,lI
rtlmourn low,no 10 In. nu,," Qutilllla reD au c.nler uD 10 a mallmum 01 lI11y dollars, Thll warranly 0011 nol co,er In. p.n. and laoor
Inal are nuala 10 m~,nla,n YOUl'03' tctl., IIl1er., 'IC,), t~..p.ru 01 your C3' In., are 'uCllcllo normti w..r.na tllrllan b.IIS, raalllor
no..., .IC,}, aam.g. 10 your car Inal rllulla 'rom 1I...I,IcCla.nl, In. It, 0' conalllon. ,9' In. .nvlornmlnl, d.m.~. !.nil rllull. Irom
someone llllrlng thl car, misusIng the car, tampeung with Ihe car, maklnQ Improper adjustments, Improper IUltl, Imcrccerly malnlllntng
lno car, 0' 'alii no 10 mllnla'n tn. car, Thlau..a car IIm,l.a w.rranlY II tran,'eraDI. 10 .ub..au.nl own.", To lren,'er InlS aorllm.nl you
mUll flQU'" a tr.n.ler 01 own."n,o lo,m Irom UI alln. .bo', .oarau, In. cnarg. lor tr.n.l" ,. ani nunarl<l dOllal1. Th. tran.f.rr.d
w.rr.nly will rem.ln In .II.CI lor In. ..m.InQer 0' In. ollo'nal covera~. PIIIOd, Wllnoul. tran,'er 10 Ih. n.w owner \nll contr.ct il
larmln"1<l alln. 11m. 01 UII olin. v.n'c:I coverea In In" contr.ct. No "tdlt w,lI D' Isauta on Ilrly term,nlllonl.
Und.r this used car IImlt.d warranty, the following la . list of coy.red compon.nts,
Cyllnaer block, nllal, .na .11 Inllln.1 pans, Manllold., Valv. Iraln and Cover., Flywn.ti, Cam.n.II and limIng
allv. compon.nll, 011 pumD ana 0,1 p.n.
Ca.. and alllnlern.1 p.na, To'au. Conv.ner .na conv.ner hOUllnO,
F,ont or rur drlvl axl. hou.100 and alllnllrn.1 pan., Olive Inall and unlvll..1 join", Tran.ler CUI on lour wn"l
dllv. "hlcl.. and .lIlnllrn.' pans, F,on! Ill. jo,n" ere coverea only on lour wn"l drlv. venlcl..,
COOLING F.n and Ian clulcn, Ei.clllc raal.lor I.n malar, Willi pumo,
STEERING SI.erlno gea' .nd .11 Internal p.nl, Power ""ling coolI' and IIn..,
SUSPENSION Sorlng., Control arm., S.lIlolnll, SOlnlll. .na ID,ndl. .uooonl,
BRAKES All comoon.n" UC.Dl...llnlOgalpaaa, rOlorSld,um.,
E~ECTRICAL Alternator, volta~1 ..~uIIlO" wlnd.nllld wlp.' malo" .nd .lIner malar,
LABOR Tn. labor Ch"~" bUI<l on InauSlry acelPlla lIal ralll 10 reDiae., 0' repair a covered componlnl,
No olner compon.nll, olher than Ino.. IllIed, ere coverld by Inl. ...rr.nly, Th. p,oel<lure 10 follow wn.n maillno a eltim lor
rllmbu,..m.nl unaer Ih,', werranlY WIlt b. ..ntlo you w,tn your "ceDlla CDDY ollnlS conlracl. Should you not rlellv, notlllcallon ,rom
ua wllnln (n-d'YI 01 In. II.'UI 01 your contract .cceDlanCI, no\ily UI al Cullomlr SlIVlc. II (80013ea.~1. THE PENN
WARRANTY CORPORATION ....,.,.. In. lI~nllo rel.cl or cancll w"n cau.., any contraCI. THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION
ae.. nOI aUlnollll any perlon 10 creall lor It any oCligllion or 1I.0;IiIY ,n conn.Cllon w"n IN. werrenly, THE PE~N WARRANTY
CORPORATION will nol D' r"Don.,bll lor Iny 11m. Inal you 10", lor .ny Inconvent.ncl yeu mlgnt bl eaUSla, cr Iou 01 your
trlnloonatlon, thl Quallly 01 a r,ollr by In. reclU center, or lor .ny olnll 'nclliinlii or 'con"Qulntlal a.mag.. you may hav., Your
u..a .c.ar.Il!t)II.a w.rranty Oi\1S'Y"""oec,lIc'I~n!., YO'lglay hIY. other r1~nllln'l VIr/from ',111110 11111, Pi.... rel<llhlS conlract ,n
lull before Ilgnlng. . , .~ . '; !. . . I' : .
I . 'I \. .
-,..'. .- r r--'1/_'L:'t l;;'nu--1?ur1<.:,JA"1''-I'11
OAll . ~ , '/IN . r -" " I' . 11 I WlM.IHlY RS:l.UTlIl _ ....
-' ,
fulc,IIoI ,'>\;'1:'ILl.Jal ".. /I'e.
IlWNlIlS NAME \1IlIQ! IlNl
ENGINE
TRANSMISSION
ORIVE AXLE
, ",:; c
....1JlDri.
IlIl.1l
AOOIIIS!
141(, T.llo'i)L~ iI p,
t,\) Llr,-~
F () "-Y
IDIJI
IlMoJll!lll11.
\1IlIQ!\WI
T,tur ""
IlCIJl
v
10024_
art
VllIIQJ \IOoa
STArt
1(1. ,
,
DpI1()(7
<"I \ ,,., IJ'
1 () ::I I r hJJlL1Jm ~
/
II 1 -1 n ~ ~ 1 'I ' , '}.~ '1
oj' ~ - J , CUWlS rHOHI~--1'~' ~
~Wlll
IlWNlIlS rHONl
~ 11 - ,;. ~.r.} -'4(. 'lJNlWl PIIllJ
--
I una.rslana Ind .gr.. Ihll In. IImlll<l..rranly I 1m purcnUtnO 'I In .~re.m.nl betw..n mysell ana THE PENN WARRANTY
CORPORA TlON,IIuiiiier unalllllnd .nd '0'" Inalln. car dulll 'rom wn,cn I purcnuea Ih'. conu.ct nu no IIIDlllly to Ine lorelm.nl,
olnor Ihan ,ubm,ltlnO \hl Daym.nt and nee....r/ paOlrwork to THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION 10' p,oc'''IMg,
/' . ~ DEALER'S NAMF.~~':t.,I..l\_,' ,-\u:-J ;.1....;&','
" ".l" " . _
OWNERS ACCEPTANCE TO TERMi.y' _. ,.,1. ,,,,_./.. ....~r~_.L-- SALE\1AN'S NAME l ;; ,v H.l ,IT' t.... ~L
Forwooa In,. con"aCI .'In paym~nl ,n ,:;;;;;r~~ PE,'I!I WARRANTY CORPORA T~\al In. aoo," ~aereu:.
WHITE IMAIL WITH PAYME~T! C~I4ARY IMAIL WITH PAYMENT! PI~IK (CUSTOMERl <3OLO IC~R DE.ALERI
t 19'1<l THE Pflltl WARRANT'( CORPORATION
.,
EXHlBIT B
~,r""
1 _ ~,I
..~
""CI ell VI I ~ 7 .f.J k~1
.lrCcu.sc....s I I I
~ t.l, ~ of .,-n ,It "... I l...:.~1 r--~1
,( u
I ' t..1\,t.l It...-:-\t I I I
I ! tJ,oJ
I I I
I I
I I I
I I
I
I I
COCKRI:LL'S AUTO SALES
717-766-4227
5270 E3St Trlndle Road
Mechanrcsburg, PA 17055
...... " I ,,- f ,A
"" \I f eo'l ~ u~.
ITNIT
llof\"
aTY
<!.-\/ll. ( {US.
-
011
1 ClAI1
,.J~ I. ~ ~ "\"
:,.... 'f . "") ..,
.tt i D'~
L....U :< {
II),
\.1 I,") :...G:
SWt
/101,J
U'
(,\,
1 ::"
MAllIN,." WY OtICIIII'Oll THlI<lUOWNI
O_.l]usm ODllOJ 0"-,,, OTll\,CK ='"
......qo
_Nl1
~ _ Ya)I]. T'r'P'I
ru{l) r;',-:) -r.<
I n Ii f 1.';: H '7 L ,J ,., '1 ? ~' q :-
I J ( ,;" 11ALlS....... 110 II DEUVlJ'1Il ~ "" uqrr. .
I .. .. r.t /1. ,oJ'.f.. S -.... " c., "'t
TlU.CI'" ALLCWANCI
+
TOTAL I'RCI
I
[,,-' '2 J I.r'"
;a.... - ........
IlOCll Nl1
ODOMETER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT
t.. ?' 1:l Ctl
L,.0 H?u
r;. ~ 1Ji)
~ " I~,'
.,..!" ......
CASH OtP"F'I.AVCI
F<<*aIlow (and Sla,.IIW, If IOOIlc:&llI'1 rlQulrll thatl'lu .111. Ih. mol..... ugon tnnsll'
of awnIrIhlp. FtiIUl"l to complet. or pRNldlng I lalst alll'mlnt may 'null in "n.. andlor
Imprioonmenl
I, COCKRELL'S AUTO SALES , Slilll/lltlht Odomll.'
(lnnlftro(l name-PRINT) q" . 1 ~
(allhlwhlclt _bed _I now "w ,1' (no l"'lhl) mil..
and to lhI bell of my knowlldQ' I/Iatll "nlCllllhl lctUiJ mlluQ' 01 the ,.hlc!, d.scnbed
IllcNoI, un_ on. 01 the Iollow1ng IWam.ntl II checked,
0(1) I her.oy CII1Ity 111I1 to 1/1, b.,t 01 my knowledQ' Ihl odom.llr ""dlng reflects the
amoun1 01 mllNG.ln ...,... 01 rill mecnanlcalllmllll,
o (2) I her.oy ClIftlty thatth. odom.ter reading i. NOT Ih. sctu.1 mllug., WARNING-
ODOMmR DISCREPANCY.
SALlST"""
UCEI<Sl TlWdFEl\ mu. E!<c.
OOCUl.IlNTMY '11
IUITCTolL
'11 It. 1 H
-+1
.) '! .~ '1 ~~I
I I
I I
1 I
UN'AIQ IAL>>CI eN nv.CI.lN
tOTAL
DePOSIT
nw ~ _ _., "..JtD JW411ll....l..D1
I' l: ," f-\ ;\'l r -: .:.; t,.'-
lYW___.JIlOIl.'WlI t'" U
/'..--___ II" . _ ./'
~_1JU1I1ll1 -,
~l .0J=.,., - i'< ''-,-:.:; r:" -: I J~, I
1JI:"'!"'N~"'l\JNl /? ,/' 1/
{~ ..,r. r~~f..'( .~ .~./ :~..~....
CASH DOWN eN CEUVIRY
..w.cl
Ulloll1OLDlA
ADOAW
, .
, . l....uE IN
AWCIUNT
llIJ'ClATI
YEAR
SERIAL ,
TTTU! ,
MAKE
UCENSE
EXP,OATE
...,el1
, sw. thlt llW Odom.t.r
I'OUC'/ .
(lranI11IIll'1 n&ml-PRINT)
(oIlh1whlclt dllCribed _I now reids (no t""hll mil..
and to the bell 01 my knowledQ' \1II11lrenlClllthl'lIC1ueJ mllug. 01 the vlhodt dlSC/lbed
IllcNoI, un_ on. 01 the IoIlow1llQ ,\allm.ntal. checkad,
0(111 her.oy ..,tlIy \hat tD 1/1. b..t or my knowledQ' Ih. odomlt.' r..dlllQ reflects the
emounl or m,I'IIl' In ...... 01 Jill mecn.n,,;llllmllll,
o (2) I hereby certlly thlt th. Odom.ler reeding I, NOT th. IctuII m,l..g., WARNING-
ODOMETER OISCREPAlICY,
1lWWUOfI ,....fID JrUUlIClATC...."1
AtW<C'f ""'HI ,
COHTlUoC'TUAL DLIa..DIl.IRllTlrtMlHT
~ UIID va.:u ONI.'t
"'The IrtfanftalJlln """ ... an .,. ____ ...... .. ,"" ..,.. il PM1
" t'" CIG1W'tICt. lll~ on IN ...... tQrm........ "" -
""~"N~Of....
nw.uon IIQHAT\JAI
TlUHIftJi'ln '~lHfID H.AUlIO(AL1A AIIII
""""'"'"""""""
My _,.,..., ~ '"' ,... "'-=" fit l*4 ~ ... _. . .
manu~..wntll'y It ".INlM'" IN 1NIIot--" aNy.
_nllO....ruo.
ofCClPTID IV':
'tJA::HAS(A'1IIQtt.ArUI! X
OA~
ClAta
EXHIBIT C
=a#=======aua..~~:~~~
"=t==~:loIl;aIUICla=.c;;;;;;;::=.:; ~====~==.:. .==r ,== ::aa==: Clifaaaaat.alllta..
I ~CCXRELL'S Auro S~LE5
5270 E. rR!~CL~ RO,
~ECHAN!C52URG, FA. L7055 (7L7) 7~6-4227
.==============:a====.============a.==R====~====Q==aa=D==-:c======_gaa=caaaa.a
Cw6:~mer I 5_P~~!CR ~E7AL ~CRKS :~C, Oa:. - OJ/CEI9S
Ac:re5S ~4~6 ~~I~CLE A;. ~:mel:7~7)
C!:Y/S:atlll C.~L.!5LE. P!~. 17013 "c:r~I\7:7) ,41!-2u6
Ve,,!.c ~ II 1 ~~ FCRO ;:-35~ C'..:5 Tel1 V:,'4I l,"O,"F::;7"17LNM5':'?J
::l:e II I 'I'Z!602S C~I: ", aJ \.:n1.: 81
Milease !n-C9770~ MLle~a' Cut- 0977C~
TechnLcIanl
sarvlC:33 performedl
Sl.'aLE7 !..,~eOR (TC\.JING)
Po, I TRANS (I~STALL USED UNtT)
C:SASSEM8LE TRA~S FeR INSPE:rrCN
---EST. ceST iO R!!UILO---IL,600.0C TO 0200C,OO
45.00
~36.50
1!~.5C
-
-~~~WE RECCMME~O R!T~ANrNa IN 500 TO
_I't~-!....../
HAVE T~ANS CHECX!O ANO s!~vrc!c,
PA~T It DESCRIPTION
US=:? EAOO TRANS
ceo iRANS FLUID
1 . CCO "'IIl.U TO
On'.
1.00
e,er:
PRICE
UO,O:O
2.7$
EXT.
eso,cc
.2.2.0':
HIIII hrvlCII
[ hmo, lut~onll tr.1 IlIYl mdr \lOti 10 bl 4m Ilu, ~m 1ft! :IUIW1
.,tlrlI1 Ino h., la, ,rlftt III Ift~/cr lout Illlo'lll ,.raIIIIO. 10 ,,'rlll
tt.1 lulcll for tnl ,mil" I' tllllnllnd luncH,", II m"" mWIII
1!1: il "mo, Iclno.laC1U 1ft IlIVI ubllll tllllirl tl,II:IUnt I' '1l/1111I.lltll.
fO.h, 0,00
[,Iu.clul O,OC
IItvlm llUG
IIrU II!.!O
...................
M'tlUl \l~UO
rl~ ll.l~
:m!:a j lel
~m,,~ I /
\lTl.l&
.........................
ht'~
l1'..Vj~ " .,,~ ..1 U .
/,.I/Pt?Iq!" ;:;;11...,. I,vST4'/..L.JIlly;
tl51;;? TIf,4.u'S"-'/J510.u
CIRTIFICATE OF SIRVICI
I, Olenn R. Davis, Esquire, of the law firm of Latsha &
Capoui, P,C" hereby certify that I am serving a true and
correct copy of the foregoing Amended Complaint on this day,
August Iff , 1995, by first-class V,S, Mail addressed as
follows I
Oale T. Mayorowski, Esquire
The Penn Warranty Corporation
360 South Keyser Avenue
Taylor, PA 18517
Latsha & Capozzi, P.C,
DATll:DI
(9). ::L0J.10
Olenn R. Davis
Attorney 1.0, #31040
P,O, Box 825
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0825
(7171 761-1880
Attorney for Defendants
olgrd/o.ot'.r/l~
, <_i
....,
"l~
"Vlt.
'fl]1,f, f
:r i'~ I,
;.r ~;:
,-
t.'~ ..+~:
i': .'or; ~l t I
~~ tt';I. ,~,
ki:'C'~
tf,:.~}r,n
';~1.lI"
..~
.....
~
If
N
-
w
tj
-.a
l:X
.
~
SuperJor Mctillworkll, Inc.
1'1 il JntJ ff
IN TIlE COURT OF COIlMON PLiiAS OF
cUtIDEIlL..\ND COUNTY, rEtrnSYLVAlIIA
v.
19 95
NO. 95-3649 CIVIL
Penn Warranty COrporation
RULE 1312-1. The Petiti!)n for Appointment of Arbitrators sholl be lub.tantialll'
in the following forml
PETI':'toN FOR APPOlNTlIENT or ARBITRATORS
TO THE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT:
Glenn R. Davis, Esauire
. counsel fur the plaintiff/defendant in
the above eetion (or actions), respectfully represents thatl
1. The above-captioned action (or actions) is (are) Jt iHsue.
2. The claim of the plaintiff in the sction is $ 1.807.35
TIle counterclaim of the defendent in the acti"n is none
The following attorneys are interested in th~ coae(s) us counsel er nre other-
wise disquslified to sit ss arbitratorsl Glenn R. Davis, Esquire
Gale T. Mayorowski, Esquire
WHEREFORE, your petitioner prays your Honorable Court to appoint thra. (3)
arbitrators to whom the case shall be submitted,
Respectfully submitted,
, . -, . \ \
( \'. ..,...J.- \\J \ L )
ORDER or COURT
AND NOW, ])1.<"'':' J11iUf(' kA I 19 q 5-; in conlidarstion of tho
foragoing patition, })IIN I'l.l_ .lJlIlI(c!Jkll Esq., Uisil/J IlkA/ IIfS
Elq" and ..J)I/ V, 'eJ /)/111..' 1 lJ ,Esq. I ara sppointed arbitrators in the
above-captionad action (or actions) IS prayed for.
Bll Court!
l J L
I
.Jh
P. J.
~
'"
N ~l
~
""'\ .
,~
-.
f'-\J
'-n
41
"-
f), .J
"t.
.'"" :..
c..,)
B
til
tit
,.
~., ....
..~.
~"
\.'" ".Wi! '" '.,:' ,I
liil'fli"";"'\".
1,1':'1"/) 1" l,":' ," ':"lto"
".",1.,1' 0".." ,,..,~l itJ
O'-~ tr. q\l
~ \) lIt
('j 'j' J' C't,
"- _... ..t .~,
{'
:;
\
JJ~.'}.C:.i;'
'~'.-l:I.Y) lL
,. ')
;. ..
. '.' ......
1:1
1.\ ~\
,.
,
M'AR -04 961\!1)~1 1(1,04 P[\N mmn 1.I"r TEL T.5fl, "(;j9 P ell;
'11ie Penn 'Wa~anty Corporation
,
AUlomobll. "'"",nUll' Au.. F1111l\tinl ' Vi 1"'''1 lll1r1ytl"l ROlld lIenl.. · T..,.I S."iu
TOI
\
'.PMI
DATI: s...d.JJ I
.v.;;.;., ;,.1,/" ^,.., '1(,l..l'''''r' u..."
rAXII (111) 2'/.1- /I,J{)
· 0"0." INCLVDIN. mil 'HEE", f-
CO"~TSI I
. . I .
-
IeOkulh KlrsclI A..nue , Tlr\llr,l'cnnl~I....I.I'.17
(IOCII aMf~I' (7171161,7110O' (71 I DOI.71lO1 . 17171.81.TllOg , 1?l71 ~1.TIlOI
, rAC5IMlt (1171161.71108 "
.,:1--
~I\R .1)4 G6i\'O\1 1004 1'1\'. '1IRR.\\r\ :lIP
T[: .:." If ~ .J,ll
f 1;,):
rrlie Penn Warranty Corporation
,\\1lGmohll, WlJ"I'II'IL" . AUlD I !n.ndn~ . 24 lIour Emrr,.,'" Ru.d 5.,.,.1" . Trll't'l ,",mlt
Harch 4, 1996
Danl.1 t. Deerdorff, Elquire
10 E Riah Streat
Carlille PA 17013
VIA FAX (717)243-1&50
PI SUl'U101 ~IIIU. JlKl. V, 'l'BI PEllllII.Ruvrr ~R1~t.~
JI). t5-~649-ClnL-1911S
Daar Attornoy D.ardorff:
AI you kr.ow. you .r. the Chairman of tha Beard of Arbitrator. for the
hl.rinl Icr.eduled on "ldnuG.}', lUrch 6, 1996, at 2100 PM perta1nlnA to tlta
mattar c.ptton,d above,
Prior to thls letter, I (equaltad a continuance from thl Plalntiff,
GincI 1 hlVI .nntnor carter Hc~erl\lIlG n that time. I received a rupon..
fro~ PI.lntttf h1mself, who Btlted he will not agrle tu my continuance and
11 ~olng to np(uent h1m.teH at tbl hearin., Thnofor'ft, tbte I. to tnfom
you that 1 raquest . continuanc. pertsining to thlB mltttr. If one can not
b. arnnilta, than plaia.) be on nutic. tnat 1 will not b. Ibll to .tt.nd
~hh haaring.
It you hlv, any quastions or commlntB, plell' do not baoit.te to
contact lila,
&lnc.rely,
TIlE PENN IIAl\1tAN:'Y Ct1I\POP.ATION
/~. ,"
':.1" ..
,-
.... ~..
lW.E T . YOaoWSKI
Cotporat. AttolUIY
al'Hld.
(,'0'~~ ~
'] j ~ I ')L.
~(\() \oulh Nlltr A".nllt . Tayl.", I't" '''11\'1nll IUI1
lelJO) '~6'9"1' ('117) b6~,lr,IJO . 17171 ~6~.71i01 . (7171 ~01,16Il2 . (717) ~6~.',60'
rAC~IMILE: 1717) ~f,2,;I,(I~
I IIIHdIAIAJtttMII\l',^MU.IIt..IIM r
SUPERIOR METALWORKS, INC,
('lnimitI'
IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
VS,
NO 95-3649. CIVIL. 1995
PENN WARRANTY COllPORATION,
Dcfcndant
TO: Glenn R, Dnvis, Esquire
LATSHA & CAPOZZI, PC
p, 0, Box 825
Harrisburg, PA 17108
Gale T, Mayorowski, Esquire
THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION
360 South Keyser Avenue
Taylor, PA 18517
NOTICE OF MEETING OF ARBITRATORS
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the Arbitrators appointed in the above captioned action will
sit for the purpose of their appointment on Wednesday, March 6, 1996, beginning at 2:00 p,m" In
the second noor hearing room of the Old Cumberland County Coul1house, Carlisle, Pennsylvania,
Any person for whom this date and time are not satisfactory will be expected to in turn
arrange 0 dole and time suitable lor 011,
Date: December 20, 1995
~K:~
Daniel K. Oeardortf. Esquire. ChaInnan
Joseph Hitchings, Esquire
David Baric, Esquire
cc: Cumberbnd County Commissioner's Office
Cumberi.llld County Coul1house
Carlisle, I' A 17013
t{j'
~
lIf.u
f.:I
.;1
~
, "
....
I
SHERIFF'S RETURH - OUT OF COUNTY
CASE NOI 1995-03649 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA I
COUNTY OF CUMUERLANO
SUPEHIOR METAL WORKS INC
VS.
PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION
R. Thomas Kline
to law, says, that he made
named defendant. to witl
. Sheriff, vho being duly svorn acoording
dilioent searoh and inquiry for the vithin
PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION
but was unable to locate
Them
in his bailiwick. He therefore
deputized the sheriff of LACKAWANNA
to serve the within COMPLAINT
County. Pennsylvania.
the attached return from
LACKAWANNA
County.
receipt of
Pennsylvania.
On AUllust
14th, 1995
. this offioe vas in
Sheriff's Costs I
Docketing
Out of County
Surcharge
LACKAWANNA COUNTY
18.00
9.00
2.00
30.00
;;;..
&::1'.:1.00 OLENN R
08/14/1
Sworn and subsoribed to before me
this .1.," d f{
ay 0 "l"F
19 o'i, A. D.
i:,..,. (, t/ld'." .Li:rt...
; I Protnonotllry r
-"
--,
. .
,
.~
Office of the Sheriff
JOliN SlYMAtJSKI sin RII f
I Al ~ """A!iljA I ! II 'I,ll . " ,.,'.',1' 'I I' '," '1 . t', r. t,_" , . ,,1" '+1, I \. /1 'J
SHERIFF'S AFFIDAVIT OF RETURN
1 PlAINlIFfiS,
SUPERIOR METAL ~~KS, INC.
3 DrfENlJAN I ISI
PENN WARRAN'I'Y ool~PORATlON
SERVE1& NAME OF INDIVIDUAL. COMPANY, r.Oll1'OflAl10N r Ie
.. PENN WARRAN'I'Y ooRPORA1'ION
'" 6 ADOnrSs {Streel or RFD, AJlllllmunl Clly UOIO 1 wp Slall' IIll1l ZIP Coda)
AT
~ c01ll1l NIJMfltfl
95-3649 CIVIL TERM
4 I Yl'l Of WillI OR COMPLAINT
OOMPLAINT AND NOTICE
CUMUERLAND 00.
OLD t'ORGE
1 Ilwlf.lly CERTIFV and RETURN that I have [J havlJ pcrsllflBlly hPlvml_)(X h/IVI! IUlfYf>d llll! 11l!I&OIlIll (hAlye, 0 have lorved I peUO" of lull-
nhln nge and dllcretlon tlllln Icalding at the detendalll.sllllulIllllaf,t! III ollndn. (J have fHlstml tile nbfJVU dUle'lbpd property with Ihe writ or
l.omplRIIlI dU6rribod on the Inti'Yldual. company, coqHllallon. ulc.llt Ihll ndlJwlili fthnWII nhUynllf on tho IndiVidual. company, corporation, etc.,
011lH! ,"lillUBS IIlserleil he low hV handing/or PoSllllg 0 TRUE AND ATTESTED COPY Iholl'"'
B n I hl~leLJy (;(Htlty and felurn NO SERVICE beCfWSO I fHlIllll;1llhl 10 loclltllllm 1I11livutllnl. rnrnpol1y, (;ofpofollon. olc. named .bove
9 Address whero served ICol!1plelpont)' tl d,lI'"lln' '''All'''''.'' A"'l,I'1 If;h,,,.t III fllll "'I"l'lll>l'..t ~~'l L,I~ ll'UII lllil'1l1 '0 01110 uf Sorvlr.e
11 Time
12 Name and lltle uf indlviduallsfved IIlllHl ,huWIl Oholllll
.~~_________!\RLENE ~ClINEadlecru:;'fARY.
13 IJt'SCllp\lOIl' Oespondent de&(;lIbca Iho mdlvldualli(!fvmt liS follows
o Mall' o Willie Skin o Black Hili! U Wlllt,! Ililll U 14 . ~n YIS o Ullder &' o Under 100 Lb,
o fOlTlole o Olack Skin o flrown Hnlr o 1I0hllng o 21. 3~YIS o &0" . &'3" o 100. 130 Lb,
o Brown Skin o Olond Ilnll o 30 . M) YIS o &4' . &0" o '31 . 160 Lbl
O' Yallow Skin o Rellllnn n Mw,laLtw 051.05Y" o &9" . 0'0" o 161 . 200 lb,
o Orav IIn" llllnn,,1 [J Dym or, VIII tl O,nr 0' o O,er 200 lb,
14 0 I du further 011011 and duclare thai I Am B Deputy 6hcrillIII BIIU lur Iho County 01 I nckuwllllflB, HIRln uf Penn_ylvanla. that I am.. fGlldent 01
tho Cuunty and Slale aforesaid. thai I Rm over tho 8go 0121 yunrs. IhUII Rill dulV (lUilhlilld lJIHim Iho rlllns 01 ollr c:otlf'llo mike lervlce
hf.ilcundof; "nit lhat I om nol 8 pafty 10 tho Within ocllon
1b (] AI the limo 01 sorvlce. the saId
WfI" /lot 1II1hu Armml SOl Yico 01 tho United 6t.tet
10 ADVANCE COSTS: ShOll" $30.00
NlllnrV I'lIhl", $2.00 PAID 1N t'ULL
XICPIUUXX
f~LI~Mil~
I
SO ANSW,Ef8._ JOHN 8YZ~jNSKII S~ERIFF
O"I",IV /!-<A~ t{) jfc.;?..C-t
II[l'lIl1llil III1IlYCKI I
\., Tnt) Court ci C.:mmC~1 rIa=::3 or c:;:....",l'l::nd (,~l},':;.:'/I ?-=nr:~yl'l~r:io
hllpPllor Ml'lnl WorkBr 1111',
'IS.
Penn Willl"illll y l'olpolill Ion
:-I II c. _ II. A II l' I v '.L 'l'n YO, ,~
. o. ,~~, 10 ...........l.__._-.... ....~_.....
~ow.
,July 12,1995
~9--. I. SEZP~~ 0::' C~~t:3:=:?.!.~'m COL~':'Y, :'.0\.., co
h=!ly dc;:u= t!:.o SbcI.ir 01
Lackawanna
C"W1ty to c.-:C':"Jt.: t:is 'Nri:,
::s d.:puc:icQ =e!:li =:!: U I!:.e l'IqUc:n :::::a rl.sk of t.!:= Pl=::i,
/~ d /~.
r!;i-;,,-..~,
SlIm!: at C:::::!lui.u:d C~Wlrr, :':10
.
Affida.vit or SernCl:l
~OW, 10 :.: o'dea ~L IC".-d
.- .
, w;r.!:.in
:.::=
'JpaB
u
by , "
:::u:~ to
1 t:pr 01 t.!:. ~rii'.::U
"
1l1a ::wi: , :0 :h.t ::ntc:a .I,c-i.
JClOWll -. ..-
So LI1SWC1,
Sbai! 01
CollAl'I'. ':10
,;wc~ :ilia llll:sc:-J:ed beicn:
com
SE.AVICZ
~aI.!AGZ
~:mA'y1T
J
== :his _ 6y or
19_
---~---.
s
f_ 0-10
Sld'LH IlIH fll,'1 ,I 1.\i{IItK~;. I N('. ,
1'1.11 III III
to The Court of Co.aon 'leaa 01
..!I:NN Ih\HH^N'1 \' c.':il't'li,11 r oi.,
IIl'lt'lltlillll
~
)
)
)
)
)
\
tlo. , '1',,11,1,'1 (' 1\'11 19'1',
CUmberland Count" 'enneylvanta
{
( ,
Vii,
OATIl
We do aolemol, rwear (or affirm) thet ve vill aupport, obey and dafend
the Conatitutlon of the Onitad Statea and the CODltitutloD of tbia CoIDon-
vealth and that we vill diacharle the dutiea of our office with fidality.
; ; . fj)...",.~i It \)~~,
11,,"1.,) K. 1'1"llw,rU-'l'/iq
/,' "Lv r) 1
".~!
I .'~.~ -
. .. .- -
. '.H'I"! I '
/.-" ?
"
,
. ('Ii" Irm,lll
,
\ .
I"V It!
AWARD
Wa, the uoderairoed arbitratora, having been duly appointed and rwOrD
(or affirmed), maka the follovinl avardl
(Notel If damalea for delay are avarded, they aball be
a.parately atated.)
ill" I....v
.r.:u..,~ ufo' PI'I./'1t...fj ''''
'N i l1 .l. 1~ f ~'i.~ Dc l k! r
~
l~
_4 ""'v~'1i
1,;
{'~ stJ .
~A-
applicable.
. Arbitrator, dialentl, (lneert name if
\T't.-cJll) ~. n
"
Date of Beerinll
I~~v.~ 4:_~..1 ~'I L
lIiJIlJ,,~1 )K, j)t"I)'\III.j;{f,
I /,,~_ ( /
, .. cli" Irm,,"
Date of Award: ~
,':Hrj I
".
( .' ..t., -' . " .
l"vl, II" I' 11'. EH'I" I 1'1'
NOTICE or ENTRY or AWARD
Now, the ~:I( day of ! ~ all t, , 19 'No, at !..J.i, L~H"
award was entered upon the docket and notice tRereof given by mail
parties or their attorDeya.
the above
to the
Arbitrators' compensation to be
paid upon appeal:
t_lJ,(\ (I
l rtll. If II C (
BYI f
,ii" ..I"/.' /Il.,j..,,, ,"''''''('fl ,."."..., ., t!'ni
,} .' i'(I \' '
;".,111., "11 ,/~"'''''' It. ,. ", OoJ-I...",.I' . It I
, . . ,.., t"'"
. " J l II
.,;,."". I lJ~<"- I)". d, , oJ " I' h
"
-~.....
1- ~
, "
,\
j: C
,
~p (
" l} t-i'
~. ~
., . :7
1I \I ',' f
.
,;. '.
, (W ,.
i 'r
~ ;,.t
..
t~
,
I
I
,'t-- ~
~ ...'..
ff~
~
'\
SUPERIOR HBTALWORKS, INC.
V.
PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION
111 RlI VACATI ARBITRATOR
I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I
I NO, 95-3649 CIVIL TERM
I
I
9RDER OF COURT
AND NOW, MARCH 12, 1996, the appointment of Joseph
Hitchings, Esquire is hereby vacated and Hark Duffie, Esquire
is appointed in his stead.
Daniel Deardorff, Esquire )
Chairman
Mark Duffie, Esquire ~
David Baric, Esquire
Court Administrator
Idd
By the Court,
\
t1f~ojm~.tl.t J/I'l-jq/P,
~ ,~,~,
I ~,'
III ~ ,;
,
i<
,
.
"
,
IN TilE COIJln 01' COMMON I'I.EASE 01' cUMIIElll.ANIl COUNTY, I'ENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTIoN . LAW
SUPERIOR MliTALWORKS, INC"
1'lalntll1'
v,
: No. 95.3649
PENN WAIUIANTV CORPORATION,
Ilefendanl
I'RAECII'E 1'0 ENTER JUDGMENT GN COMI'ULSORY AIUllTRA TloN A WARD
To Ihe Prothonotary:
Please enter judgmenlon Ihe award of arbllrators med In the above mailer on March 6, 1996, the
time for appeal having expired, and assess damages In favor of Ihe 1'lalntlfTs and agalnsllhe Ilefendant as
follows:
Arnounl ofaward
$1,172.36 I/"
\locket Costs
$ 128.50
Tolal
$1,300.86
LATSIIA & CAPOZZI.I',C.
lIy ~Ch.b
Olellnlt Davis, Esquire
Attorney I.IJ. N 31040
1'.0. 1I0K 825
lIarrlsburg, I' ^ 17108
Attorneys lilr I'lallltln'
Superior Metal Works,llIe,
, D~::;n;:&,
-2l j ''''~m"''". J
" Dale: ,iL jj ,,'l~--
MIU, I
-
~\ !,:)?'U
\ ~ ~ f'.
\~ ';:::....
, ~ ~t
'::i ~.t
\"""-J
~ ,-.t)
';r
,
, '.1
\
...., .,J I
L~' ,...... J
I , ")
. :,1
i ,')
,in
t....'
. ,",I ..
, -.7"
: "
~ ~J 'I
...
,
i
i
I
i
I
I
1
i
I
I
I
\
I
;~~~,.
,
LAT6HA &. CArom. P.C.
..~.u
~. '-. nt0lW5
IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
SUpERIOR METAL WORKS,INC.,
PlululilT
v,
No. 95-3649
PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION.
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
PRAECIPE TO SATISFY JtIDOMENT
t ,-,
, .,;
TO'THE PIWTHONOT AR Y:
r
Pleilse mark Ihe above-referenced mailer satisfied.
(i
If-
,-
e'; ~
Ill,
~
,
I
.." ,,)
LATSIlA & CAPOZZI. P.C,
, '
.,
By Gu3. oJo
Oleun R, Davis. Esq.
Attorney J. D, No, 31040
P. 0, Box 825
Ilarrisburll, P A 17108.0825
(717) 761-1880
Allorneys for Plaintiff
SuperlDr Melal Works. Inc.
80l6,I
r
,~
.L
.,... Fo'
.....
I,). AI
,
"".."-
,...........,.--
:..,-->.....,
,..~i'..-'~_ ,-... _.._,",","..~
~.. ~ ~.
't W
b
~ (J'1
-< UI
\
. ""'I.""","'!,, _ ~ . ""