HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-03724
CDMMllNW._LIH 0/ ,.NNUIV_NI_
Cl)ij., I)' ~DMMoN ~U_.
.;lli I I, I I ,
NOTlCI 0' APPIAL
IIU)M
lijDICI_L 0111.1<1
DISTRICT JUSTlCI JUDOMINT
CI)MMI)N ,L._. N..
'1"I-:rU4 civiL 'l"'rln
NOTICE OF APPEAL
NQ".:e j, I.Ilvell Ihlll II,., IIppttllu/l1 '~n fllt"l ill Ih" (JbIJVII CmJl' ul Cl)l)unou Phil" 111I 1J1~lttillll'}/1I 11111 jlJalUlllIJll1 IlHldlJtltd hy Ih. OJ,''I'' JIJ,tk, on th,
dot. "ud ll1 If. em, "NtflI1OfWd "-low.
NM.lii'>>#NU...tJI
I'l, l.'1'/',I\, I 'r'I'li I': I i, I"
'jj)bjmOl.""".M
'\UU II. 1"1",,,,)1;
'bllrOl JiX>Ml!NI
('J/11'/'I"
'l\lJ1.\1lI)
I MAi\ MI tIt) r'W n.w N IH -+- -- ., . ,
l)' 1- 'I-()' I (II. J': .1\1 ,:' III)
Ill) ~I~H" ,. ';(oUr-
;\1,. _ __ __ _ l'iflll!illIli t:IIlHII'I". I ^1I10:?~J.____..
j"'''H'''' "',''''',':'''' ,rrIl1'01<1 ill;OlllJllt'l"",lll Illtl,,~,..t'J
V " ,e" " 1',11 (;01" 'l.'lI . " '<'I II 11",1' t I lil", \ nil} J I.
flI.,tl..!ljllll)l .1'1'111 ~llollt...) '(>lrf1Hll ----.-____o_____
CV 19 'i')('()U()'I;)I'~')~ .. -'# ce ,Y /C~,::.-./ ",,'70'''''7 ,,,,'.L ,Jf',-"c.,.' ,.,vr
LT 19" .. ", u , -, /'fi'",n.... ".1".
--filii-block ;;'lIh.~o".,'ONl'l"h." Ihl, "o'olio" ,. '.'i"h~;I,;;,;,., 1'0 RcFTi'r::l?:"(/I~m 111I1 WII~ CLAIMAfrr-(~~o'p;/.nCPJP No,
loon
Thl. Noli,. of A"p.ol, wh." ,.,.,""" by Ih. Oi,,,lcl J",I"", Will 01""01" n'" /00 /( (j) 1lIllclio" IJo(olO Dmlflr;1 JI/~IIC<1, 110 MUST
SUPERSEDEAS 10 the Judgment 'Of pnulJulofl in Ihll nalt.
~i'rllt,"llll' Ii' JIr. l/ltc WIIl/,/I 'Y ,)/ /11 'Ill II V
11/ [ A C()MPL AlN T WIIIIIII Iwollly (20) (Jny~ nltar
IIIIII(} IllS NO riCE oj APPEAL.
PRAECIPE TO ENTU RULE TO FILE COMPLAI....T AND RULE TO FILE
(This 6OCtl0l1 01 (()1m to Ifll IJsoll OM Y wIll'" d/lfldl,/ltl WiJ', In I 'NIlAN' ("".'n /1,1 Ill: 1',/ I' MI. 100'( 1) III ilt:I/OII IJI.'foft.l O''IllIct Just/ca.
IF NOT USED, r/v,r#(:11 110m o-Vw o( ""'In! o( "I'OI!il! tlJ hI! 1,"/\'1'11 UIIlIlI "/~)l'I".'''J
PRAECIPE, To PlOlho"olory
E"'.rtul."po,, Jltl\'old ,il;<ItlO!;cll'r';111'/V ,I' :, :: 1';liL'ir')ll'ii.
Nll'IIe' 'i/ ,11,,,'{lt"1.~J
, 01'1'.11.."1, 10 Iii. 0 ,omplol"'I,, Ihl. 01'1'.01
(C"""oot, PI.o, N", 95-37~,4 Civil ,/,,,t'/II
I wHhl" Iw",,'y ',,0) ""y. ofl., ,.,,1,. of ,,,I. J2ii?"".' ."It of I"dgm.nl of non pro.
--~ ...
, ..--' ,/'~4"''''', ::l:~'~ '~Y-<:~,&,W,;.,f'lt.r
h_ ~Ir~ 'If ,I'''lfIf!i1l11 1)/ !w; Ill/oml!Y 01' t1IJt'ttf
, "pp.1I0""I,
Hlll.'old :i1;ollObOI'I'.'()I'!
RULE, To V ,II', .: ":nt;'ll'prB.
N.~,," III ,IHlf"~'I~.~1
(II YQlJ are ""lIfi.d lhot 0 rol. I. h...by .nlo,." "/lon yo" 10 Iii. " <OlIIplullllln Ihl, "1'".01 within 1I"'1H1'Y (201 "oy' Olt., Ih. dot. of
,",vie. of Ih'. rule "pan YO" by "."""ol'.tvl,. or by '",Ilfiod or '.01"."," 1II011.
12}lf yoo do nol fil. 0 cOlllplolnl wllhln Ihl. lillie, IJ JUDGMENT 0F NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU,
(31 The do'. of ..tvlc. of Ihl. rol. If ..tyk. wo. by 1II0,I i, Ih. do'. of 1II011l''9'1' d J . ~
Doto:JuJ.~J.2L-__,19,2j.. --, -~!,::',-,t 'r' lJ:L~lLc, ~(
(f~ ,",,,,,,, ~o/lIo1ot..y
( '/
N:JPc 3lp.fM
PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT
, ""t) '''001 '11 ~l1IVICU MUS' IJf 1-'11.10 ~VI' IUN /' N f It/} IJI\ \i.', ,\1 " 11 fl/lfI') IIIIIIIIJlIII} IJI ,'/Jill/,ll Clllld "/Jpltt:llIJ1IJ IWI",'fJj
COMMONWIIIL TH OF P~NN8YLVANIA
COUNTY OF , "
AFFIDAVIT: lIllI/pi))' hWPl1I III ntfulI1lhull tiIHVW!
I 1 .1 (Upy II' 1/11\ N1Jlltll .l' ^lllllllll, Ctl/lll11tlllI11t...I" Nt) ,IIP'HlI11U n1611h~1 ,1116111:1l rJulilunnl1uJ 111'"UIII tJll
,,101/11 'l/,"".'CIII ' _____. , III . ,.., I 'I IJ~ 1"lIu""111 UIlt.II;1I r 1 Il~ l"u,IIIII1'I) 11I1UIII""o,JIIIIIIII, ,uI1,luI'.
IIleujpl nllllchud hlHnlll, IIllll upun 1I1I} lIfJflll/lLlU. /111111I11). _ __,. __ ...__..., 1m
,-,..,,--- -. ------ , 1U___.... IJ Ii~ 1"!",,""1 '""I<U I J IJ~ (rl1"lfl'jdIIIIlUI~/oIlI1'1I 1111111, ''''''JuI'. Il1uHpl IIl1l1dllJd I1mulo
[I 111101 /lJlII"" 1111111 'u' ''',11I1U Illllu 101 I' "" II <';"111/1/')1111 ''':',''II1/1'11\~1I1U I 11 Ii II1l0'1i N"II"" 0' ApllUl/I U(llJl1lhli op/loIII/IIIS)10 1'1110111
thl) Hulu Will) iltllllmitilJd nil .. ilL.. ___, [1 by pmaonnl fil)lVH:U [] hy 11;IUIIIII1ll) 1ll1U1lihHOtjl
fIlIIII, 6u/ldlH't; flJCltlpl a1l1ndllHI hl/tnlo
SWOIlN IAfHIIMW, AND SLJUl;CIlILlED U1:iOIlE ME
TliIl; , .. IJA Y OF" ",_,..,..,. _'.. , 10"
Slii'lall~I~.;",.;i"m'
S,tJ,WIII,IJ 1!1 ,)1111 ,(II /:II/I)"! l~lil)m ,IIIPlI,I~I' W,lll IllI"'I/
r,l/oIJfUIlIl:1/I1
MV co""nI6Iuon I)MpUeS on
,\ij-.
~ (::., ~'--' ~ - ~
~ \<"'"> ~~ ,',' J;a
..... r I
\<..1.) ~ ~
,.. N '-,)-.J
1..IJ ~ '-i
- ...... 0F f') \.-
~ ~ ':-' 1.>1 't--.
~ ~'
..... . .~t
\ .....
~ \ :'L
!'t- - ':J
If- ~ ~ Jjil
.... \'
rs- '-I ~~, <" I
f.
.... \-.
q """\ -, r'
I
~ I \
. ';::-"
("
(
COMMONW'.UH Q' '.NNmV.NI.
CQij'l QI COMMQN '11.'
tJ IJ i I: \ .,' i I j ) I' < [J r
jUDI".~ DIIIIICI
....oncl 0' APPIAL
''''I)M
DIUMICT JUSTICI JUDGMlNT
(I)MMON ,~... H..
')'I--I,/H "lv!.1 'I'urlll
NOTlCI 0' APPIAL
Notl(e I, UIVttfl Ihot Ih. IJPl>l.Il1tJ/lt lit,. Willi in tlUt I,bo\,u CnlJl t or (Q4IUUOn Plulu IIIl 'lf~)ltIl( '10m l"lf IIJlIUIllItIll 'ltnd.lIuJ by Ih, P1.IIld JIJ,tlt. on the
olalt and In Ih. COli m."II....d bel"""
'N.llilN /.HllI.N' I M.,II,llllij "'Hm#llIbl ,....
\IIIL'J'hl/, i "'PHI dill b. O')-j-l)~ Ui.~;.I\fJi\L1l)
-l!lIlIoH! 01 >1>1;11,11I "II M.lt ' ,,' 1111001
~U() 0'1. l:IIJ.',\l:J!. ,)~. l,u<:I"'lllo:"i1,UJ,'L!" I A 170:;5
~TfN)j)l'~NI IIt'dllt("U~d~'IIW"1I HU1,'(jlJ fltolll.Jhovrl.:Jr! ,1),11.~I,-..III' -- - ..----
b/1lJ/\J~} V J ~I I.i Lilt <.i1' l'U. " ',11I1:,IlI.', IIlLJ i,olu L.
lUJMN('l hkili.lll.lllll'll U">III~," '*.....lh,.I;i~ 'MI ~tNI .'_h_______M___~.
cv 19');;, ,1,()Y()l~ilJ~'/j ....-.:' ~,/',,~,.,
LTI9, ' /.;, ?"
---ii;I."biQ~kwiilb~ "lI"ed ONLY wti.n Ih,. ""luli""I. "'l",..d "..I., Pu, R,(j>Jp,Nu,.... /lllWullllfll WI18 CLAIMANT (80U Po, /lCPJ.P. No,
100BB.
",I. Noll" of Ap".ul, wh." ,."Iv.,l by Ih. Di'I"" J".tl<., will ul'"",I. ," 'I 100 I( Ii) I/IllcUonlJrllofO Oml,icl JIJ811';tl, Ill! MUST
5UPER6EDE"6 III Ih. 111.10"'."1 ,'" pu"."iu" I" Ihi, "".,
" ,/'
, '
tilfll1ill'/IIJ 0/ nl/t/lrlllll/iIIV 'Jl/l1llllily
1'11./: A COMPLAIN., WillI/II IWUIIIv (20) '''lV8 1/1/0/
/1111111 /IIS NOTICE 01 AI'/'EAl..
PR,'ICIPI TO INTER RULI TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO "LE~
(This 6<1CI/OIl 01 /'){111 10 UII ,,",vi ONLY wlll'lIl1lP!/loIlIl Wil" IJUfNIMNT ""'1' /'i1 lIe/',I./', N,) WOU7} III "';/1'1/1'/)1"0'" lJlsI,lel JWi/iCtJ,
IF NOT USED, (iulaeh (fOm c~y 01 nOfU;I} fJ1llfJlJHlJI III 110 M!/VL'r.ll/p"f1 il(.YJIIIIIWJ
PRAECIPEI Tu P,olhonoto,y
E"I.,,"I. ""on HIl.l'ol<l_JtoIlUU\H'ClJr/V ,J 1-,', :,j Entlll'lJl'(j.
Nlln!!' "/ .11,1,"lr'I'f.~1
, 01'1'011.0(.), ", fII. 0 lompl"lniln Ihl. """.01
(COtllmon PI.o, N", 9~.LJJ7I.,L,C1YJJ T\lnP
1 within lwenly POI duy. "II.r .0,,1c. of '!Ii, '" ."ff., .nl'y of l"domlf1! of non pro.
. _'",,0."'--- 'oJ.' / ,,/
/,' " .~~.~ ',., ..
J_ . ...... -:-,!7"'~-.~I'I"il~1 ~;-;'~~II';-:';;;~:N~;;-~~-:rj,~;;
lIul'old :3tOl1Guel'l':ur/
RUllI To _ '{rl~~uJ::.rl_t.(},n;_l;I},
NI~"IJ 01 (jnm'~'I'1"J
, "",,0110,('),
(I) You ore 1I"lIfi.d 1""'0 ,"1. I, hereby .nl...d "1''''' yO" 10 iii. 0 (ompl"',,lllIlhl. 01'1,",,1 wllhl" IW.llly (20) d"y" aflef Ih. dul. of
...vl.:o of Ihl. ",Ie upon you by ",,,.onol ..,,1<. '" by (O,lIfo.d <It ..ol'l.red moil,
DaIa:
(2111 you do 1101 fIIo 0 (..""Iolnl wllhl" 'hi. IIn.., u JUDGMENT OF NON PROS Will BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU,
(31 The d"l. 0' ..tvlce of Ihl. ,"1. II .o,vk. W<J' by moll I. th. dol. of n",llI"o, 4 j
t~j' . , /,
JlIly]7. _,19.9.5" --- - "
,.",.",. ~/1l>loIWy ..
, (
, '
"
v
"""
HJ!i'C ;11/,,"
COURT FILE
H, L, S'l'ONEBIi:ROliJR PLUMBING
,. HEM'ING, INC"
Plaintiff
~N THIi: COURT O~ COMMON PL/ilAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
va,
NO, 95-3724 CIVIL TERM
PATRICIA L, WALTER
Defendant
OOMPLAItrr_
1. Plaintiff, H, 1.., Stoneberger Plumbing" Heating, Inc" is
a Pennsylvania corporation with a registered office and principal
place of business at 937 Nixon Drive, Mechanicsburg, Cumberland
County, Pennsylvania 17055.
2, Defendant, Patricia [,. Walter, is an adult individual
residing at 300 North Market Street, Mechanicsburg, Cumberland
County, Pennsylvania 17055.
3, Plaintiff is engaged in t.he plumbing, heating and alt'
conditioning business and as part of its business installs,
replaces and repairs domestic water well pumps and systems.
4, On Saturday, September 3, 1994, Defendant telephoned
Sharon Stoneberger with a request for emergency repair or
replacement of the well pump at her son's house located at 221
Maple Lane, Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17055.
5, Defendant explained that her SOil, Lee Walter, was
experiencing financial difficulties and promised to pay Plaintiff
for the services if her son did not pay.
1
6. ~laintiff inspected tl~ well pump, found it to b~ beyond
repair, and replaced it and related piping, wiring and nacesaary
miscellaneous parts, on the sarna day F.HI Defendant placed the
emergency aervice call, IJaturday, September .J, 1994,
7. ~lnintife performed the worl{ in a good and workmanlike
manner.
8. 'rhe description of the materials and parts used, and labor
charges for the water well pump system replacement and the prices
therefor, are set forth on Invoice 003127 dated September 12, 1994,
a copy of which J.a attached hereto as Exhibit "A", and totals
$1,010.75.
9. The charges and costs set forth on Exhibit "A" are
reasonable and customary.
10. Plaintiff. would not have performed the services if
Deftlndant had not promised to be responsible for payment.
11. By check dated October 2, 1994, Defendant made a $250.00
payment "On Account," a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit
118",
12. Defendant has failed to make any further payments, despite
demand, breaching her original verbal promise to pay for the
services rendered to her son.
13. Plaintiff is eu_itled to statutory interest at 6\ per
annum on the unpaid balance, which interest totals $38.00 as of
July 31, 1995, and is also entitled to continuing interest until
paid in full, and claim is made therefor.
2
H, Plaintiff ia also entit;led to Piatrict Justice Cloata
incurred in the amount of $67.00.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requ&ata entry of judgment againat
Defendant in the amount of. $'/60. '/fJ, plus interest at 6' per annum
through July 31, 1995 in the amount of. $38.00 and continuing until
paid in full, plus Piat rict Just ice costa in the amount of $67,00
and costs. The amount claimed is within the limits for compulsory
arbitration.
CLICKNIR AND 'IARIN
(.l (\ ','I ~-~.._,.,-.'\
ay I ,'l.. W.J\.'~ / .. - to\ln.1
P. Daniel Altl n , Ersqurre
Attorney I.D. No, 25438
31 North Second Street
P. O. Box 111J47
Harrisburg PA 17108-1847
(717) 238-1731
Attorneys for Plaintiff
3
,"
JIlL ~"'Oll Willi l:llll" OrlJllI!lI~IUll:" 1'~.lJHllntQ
1l1'1:BU.J.,....,
"
...............
. .
. IHVO/CIt .
. .
...............
, "
IJ T' '\.,1
, ;:..:'~ rroNU....G~ ,', '/od,. ".
i~-!~:~t:~~.l1m. 'v' ~
~. .' Ii !.~;.t':.:ffi!JjfJ.,'40
pt.1'IUmlln~
IWmlloJ'I
Ol!~IH
QU/I'lIU.1
I)I)OUJllIllt lllltlll
I'O~1l1 I
--.-.-.-
, "I",. P
.,~, '" I I
,'" I j t,
'I, "I ,i:' /.,1
.. ,," r
,,: " ,.' "I.. "1'
"j 'I' ,
. '" 11"1, (.'
. ','"'
, " I I,
, "
,~
/lulll
, ,Tul
I.I~~ IIM.Tl\11ll '
2IH''IV,I>LI!',~~~~, "
,~ItC,J1A~l~~~~~~!,,'P,A;,. '
, 1 ~~~.~.,,' ." '...... 1,1'" .
, , ,
. .,::" .,' .' I' I
, ~.
IIi.
,I Jj','1
1'1'.,'"
""'1/
d.';
":'1.:,
, 'iIIIQ.~
'. I,' t~\ l
,
---
Lilli wAL1'I!.HR
2111 MAI'Lt LANIl.
.1F.CIIAN1C~OlmQ.' I'~I '
17UOO, . · ,
ship
'(0 I
,
,
~
--
-----
.__u____..
(:U81:. I :D" .'. , I' IIl~3:.l~ "',',"':" ",.
, "
Bllill Via, I 1',0, Numllor,.1 . ... .' '. "'},'" ':,
llhLp OBhl OrJ/12/94 .}.O. Oill.o,:, ',.1 :9?n~l.~l, I;;;:,,':. ,";.,> ' '
DUll D~"Il, I \l1(,I2/94 , " JlJu/OriJ~r No, I; ,': ." ,.;~I:,.,.: ,', : ,,';,
. TIII'IlI" " "I Hel ~o DAHl tlalllllllllleQII"I" ,'I',"" ,{,,;(f/'. , ,I. :,1,''''
, , ' , ",I, .," ,I' ,,. 'll.":":~"j"lr '''~li/V/II':'~''; ~'I: ','I,'.'
./ .' . ,,' , '.' " ~ " "I . , ' ,I , " ,,' \. I ,,:' " ,,", III
/' , . ..' , "",., '1.1 ", 1:', ,',' ,~~j'. .' "",1., I, .jl.
,",HlIlIl J. D./DolI~' Orlhtrnll HIIl/'lled' thIll' I~d(:ll:. '/;,.;:,,;;.,': N~.1;..,::'~.' iV'tlt
~..... ......' ..... .....___...._....... __...... _.... .................. "'.... .._.~~~... 101 .....l,i.lfpL........- _ '-,......... ......,"" .~l/....... ",l.!.ll-o.. .._...lot~- J,:....
,',:))!!SCRII''rIOIl 1,00 1,00 ,,', .':, :. ': '..o'~oobiJ ",",. . ',\",~:I, 'O',:()Q ,'-:1(.
.: ..~.' l.ADOR ANI) NA1'l\nIAl 'l'O llllPUCli l'lIMP , ';,,;',':.'1:: .'",\, : ," ;r. ;.".)/ ,',' :.IAI' i. ': "':\<' .:.;:tXllr:'I'!~'"
, "it ,\, "I', .'It'.,,' ," ", .' .,'1..1 ' " ,.' ".., ,\\, 'll,..,I,'I: : ",'
. :(M,\1'f,IUU. . 1.00 l;OO/',' ,!::'., :.,,', ~'.. 'i~Il/l:I)O~Il)'1 :/: I ,,'I~~l\iO(j .'1; l!
, l,', l/2np BO\lM~,Il~laL,E PlJ~JI' ,...,. " "" ,:"',:,,,,).:....:.,',"'. ".'.,.:;:: ,li.~I"I""J.~'i"',i,"'~:'~"''''
, '\.. "" , ",,' . I I'. t!, ,1 .> f I .. " .. ,'I '
. '\r. !. " , ". ,\"; :'1 Jl' "1'\'" ;'. ',, 'Ii ; ',t ,Ii' ""...1\,1""":'/.1'("
'MUnnIAL. 1.00' l,b/1 " ""'".,, Illl,'WOO".... ',I'.,:I,.~i:u' ,All ./1'.
" 60' on 7" "'lOLL h/PE ,,""," ',", .','./ . I' ",.,""""1,',"
'" a.!. 1:-, ,. ~,". " ti,l " '..' " II.' ,./l ,'1,"" 1'~:IJ'~"~~'I~~;Ji ..!
I " I" "1'," ,/"",/1' ,I" \l
'bl,;,.'., '." " ..:: " '~~'o::: t;'l ,.,t:'I~i""ll ':;1'" ,',1',
'H~TEJlI"L 1.00." v'"' " . "'1,~'l'{/V'.',,",,i'f""!:"f' .l14\.dl
.'J10BE tL,\.IPS . :,', '1: :""',::i~':;(:.:J:",:""'/;"i;!';I'J(l+~'
. r"I"" ' , ,I ' ~ I " .. '" 'r " '/1' I I "f' ',1,\
" ",' I" .. :' I; , if '" ;., :.,,, 'i" .'1 } It!. '.q.tl' j":. '"
"A,'imIAL 1.0n 'l.00 If"~,. .;,::! ,';"'.lO';'~20Q:I\':I.:i',:';"I!I::.,"11l,;~ij/l'E
rr I ,,'I, .f i! ,"<, "1: 1\ .(1', '1,1. "11".' ","'<~If It"I"
2 fl IHOS III . .;,r\, , . ,~. ~':,I "IV',,",,I' 1'"III,I.....L..,(,til !"t., "
.1 I I 'i' , " lit'Il' " ,'I ": ',,/ , I,. , 111,,1; ';, I;: ;.([;,IG"{ ..r.,' 1,1' ,~..
MAl'!!" 1 AI. , .01) '. .. 00 ','I,:I;':"~',l,;:. ." .<.'..i.1','a.oo~: .:i;:;:::..' ':)"~":~:"'I"~~;:" I!
BO' 0" 1/"1..1 "lnl!' .,',' "I ", ,., " I flit 'J, ,~, ,I, "
r ,.. ." .. ' '. '. , .....' ," " '''' ,.
. ' , , " I ' . ','" I :~...' \,~, f d. ~, ',;,'1 ,
\ , .,,(~ ' ' , " ' . '" ' , ,
1.01) , H, ~n,o~.." ';., ,'.:. l~'i ~~ ': IS
. "I I ',' I " 't!, 011 I,""" "I, I,W', ,Iii
I " '" I . ", ~ ,: ':., J:' . : ,,(,'\ ' '1'1 'I r,'~,ll" "{,
"l' ,,~',l'" \" ,'" ~:!'ill',,~ ..,I""""'~.;~"."I'~!,(1,t,.
, , ~ "qo ~ ," ',', I~;',. ,',\ ~:/, I::'" 1 '~, ,IOb:QI~"; II.': ::;\I'~)',I:,':,:'~i2'~'.\OQ'?;"~
. . ','.. ..,,' '11 ", . ~, .,.."',, I', , ''L' I' , ,.,
. lit',' , ,,:,"~' I~" " , "1":,.' ,I,' ~' .' \, II,,' ','r '. ; 'fI, I:/l':t I '..; '1 " I . ,r'
~ , ., , ,,' '\' I ,. "'II I, ,.\ I. ." 'I" \
, ' ,",'" ',. " ". 1 " , ,,:' ~ .,:1... V. ,':, ,./ ''''I., ',I I'
a 80 la 'Gb'. ," "'.. " . .,". 4'(j 0;\0...." :,':W.I\i',' 1'L .:. ~ll' . '.,
t' " ."','".1"1' 1":"."~.,.,\'t~~,"I',~..,,;,,,,f4,"f.)"\ .
, I" "" .' . I, 1 " .. .','.., I " .
" 'iN C;I( 1't1..$' , ~1"I'l.0;I.' ' . .,1...',::'...;....,1,.',.'::' ',".1. :""":."::'1 :';,<,...t~ '1"':-;'::"1",':,;,:,
", 'll"'~ "~\ ~ "f ,. I'"~ ....." oJ""" .,.,. ,,'.i:";"., '1""1.1"",. '.' "r'" ,", ,""', ..,..,..." '.", ",.,1"", 'f',,/,..
'~I t I.~. III I ~'t1'"J"'t I,rl,l 1'\ ,I, ,I 'l'ld, "I",\,","I'p'~"'1 "
I, ~" ~ \11 , , 1.,",,.11,11,', "111'1",.,1 ,', :,", "I':~' ~~ ~11"rl" I'l, "..I'r'''" "
" li I HI'~' t\ L I" II' I I ,,' 'I','" ,Ir )1 J' ,~, '\ ' '
'II:VI : n IJ~""":::,tl",,,'.I'II"L" ,I;,:~'li, ~~:,I~ l"':l(il\:'~," \'\ " '
1~r.J~~' ,'I ~. ,1~~I::,I:'i," ".~'f"""t: .,)~,i:.'I""..~,. ,,:\'1' ,:: 'I.gubtC)~"ll 1010.16
'~~. r..[.i' ~", ~" Il~'~I~~::I'.{j':: i:',,~./::.". '. .\O!:rf,,/' ",\,., ";',: ,i',,'1',,,X,' I" . I I 0.00
'. ~I . ~ '/I! .'." ,~'.:" ",.r'i,...../' '.. ...'" teHal I J010 75
'\ " ~, .,~"I ,.,,\" 'I'. ',"1, "'.L ,,: '1':,1,' ,., ..".' . . I" " .
,~~ t ' , I' "1 II ,~l " "IJ'", ,t I I"" /11.1" I,' I \ ,I \ '" . , '
'~'l1' f" ~"I \ ,f, I,,,,~ II", ',~, ,;.1,,'''' I ~""I,~"","1 ; ,1,1"."1,',, I"" ' 'I',
,., ,,, "",1"",' ,I ","'''' " " -" .'
MA'fllRlAL
60' OF ROPF.
I.no
. LAtlOR - JOliN
0-3.94
: UtlOIl - H~nOI.D
0,00
",
:,)
EXHIBIT "A"
JUL-a~-D~ Wttp 12,e4 Q'OHnUn~Q~~ PLUNDIHU '11030~1~Q ~,Q3
,.;(;:~r,,"m.1J
rto'~I'm\I~I!~M""'rll ,II)" //) ,1 O/J{":~~~"
~ NJflr, ,\'~ldili\J/III:I'^ IIUD" ',\ IJ _. I {,,_, -.....~ ",\V,rJt'..;
~;~:i::z-;t~:~s~~~~~' dd ,
,~' WJ l~MJ,A~l^~~:.f.'4t'''JI,r'~~I. IJolt} 'tJ rt, , /
"lAf(IIl\libnll,~~~r!\~' '"I (' /1,...." ,#'I j 1;.
:7iltlr!:ll'd<. I.' ll~, ' \' Yq;p;'~'4;(1!..J~fi1.,
,au ~a Q ~'. ~Il~'~ a 5 11',1 ~B ~o ~ all ~,~~'~~,I, .....,_... ~"""'-'''''\'''"
' ... " .",... ',., ...".., .... " " "'10, "~'I" .... ~'" I"". ',"1'",1 ~'.., III'I","'~/I '"~ ""1,1""'\1','1',,,,,,,
r"...."'-.,..
.". ..... ~"hj""""""""'1'\f"'I1"'''''11~)'''','1. \1~.1"'.1;
, ,
".'
BXIfISI'l' "S"
, L~
., P
l_',)
....
J;..
,.,
~,
" ...."
, ~.:
" l:tl
9, Denied, After reasonable Investigation Defendant Is without knowledge or
Information sufficient to form e belief as to the truth of averments contained In Plalnllffs
Paragraph 9 and strict proof thereof Is demanded at trial
10. Denied, The entirety of paragraph 10 Is denied Insofar as Defendant did not
make a promise to Plalnllff that she, the Defendant, would be responsible for payment.
By way of further answer Defendant Incorporates the everments contained In
Defendant's New Maller,
11 ,Admllled, By way of further answer Defendant avers that the check marked
es Exhibit "B" for Plalnllffs complaint was issued at the request of Plaintiff's son,
Defendant's averment for same being set forth more fully In Paragraph 20 of
Defendant's New Maller
12, Denied, The entirety of Plalnllff's Paragraph 12 is denied for the reasons sat
forth In Defendant's New Maller,
13, Denied, The enllrety of Plalnllff's Paragraph 13 Is denied for the reasons set
forth In Defendant's New Maller,
14, Denied, The entirety of Plaintiff's Paragraph 14 Is denied for the reasons set
forth In Defendant's New Maller,
NJ:W MATm
The averments contained In ParagraphS 1 through 14 of Defendant's Answer are
Incorporated in Defendant's New Maller
15, On or about Septamber 3, 1994, Defendant was visited at her apartment by
her adult son who complained of problems with the well system at his residence of 221
Maple Lane, Momoe Township, Cumberland County; a premises In which Defendant
has no legal or equitable Interest.
16, Defendant, In an effort to assist her son, contacted Plalnllff and inquired
whether Plalnllff could provide plumbing services for her son during the Labor Day
holiday weekend,
17, Defendant, after placing the telephone caltto Plalnllff, permllled her son use
of her telephone to speak with Defendant's representallve concerning the nature of the
problem and provide directions to his home,
18, At no lime during the September 3, 1994, telephone conversation nor at any
lime subsequent to the telephone conversation did Defendant assume respcmslblllly for
payment of her lion's obllgallon to Plalnllff,
19, On October 2, 1884, Plaintiff's representallve, Sharon Stoneberger, entered
Defendant's apartment unannounced and demanded payment from Defendant for the
services provided to her son,
20, Defendant, in response to this action and while In the presence of Sharon
Stoneberger, telephoned her son who, in turn, Instructed Def~ndant to make a payment
of $250,00 from her account as he would reimburse her for the same; Defendant's
son's reimbursement for the full amount of this payment being more fully evlderlced by
Defendant's son's check, a copy of which Is attached hereto as Exhibit "ONE",
21, At no lime during the October 2, 1884, Incident nor at any time subsequent
to this Incident did Defendant assume responsibility for payment of her son's obligation
to Plalnllff,
22, At no tlma after September 3, 1994, or October 2, 1994, was Defendant
provided with an Invoice from Plalnllff for services provided to Defendant's son,
23, Subsequent to October 2, 1894, Defendant's son declared bankruptcy as a
result of the failure of his business.
24, Thereafter, Defendant was telaphoned at her place of employment by Harold
Stoneberger who acknowledged Defendant's son's bankruptcy and demanded payment
from Defendant. Defendant, during the course of this telephone call, stated her non-
liability for the debt.
25, The contract alleged by Plalnllff Is an oral contract; Plalnllff has not allached
a copy of a memorandum of the alleged contract to Plaintiffs Complaint nor does such
a memorandum exist.
26, The contract alleged by Plalnllff Is governed by the Statute of Frauds which
requires El written and signed memorandum,
27, Insofar as no written and signed memorandum of the alleged contract exl8ts,
Plainllffs claim that Defendant is obligated to make payment for services provided to
Defendant's son Is barred by the Statue of Frauds,
LlI!E,WALTER 330
MELISSA R, WALTER I rUt M.,..
UI MAPle lANU / t1 " , "'-='
MECHANICBIIUI\Q, I'~ 170&3 ( III
~11l1L/A.-t:= N~ ' J s (--It) . r,-{)
~O_LLc~4~6~V4n:"tt'l--t~f.lI1-i;-~~ J)(j~lAU
F~~. ~ I /;/
,~..."....",..,.,." \ .~~/~( ~
11M.... __~
I:OilUQI,?20l: 1I'~~1l1r.?55i1" OUO
.,'00000 25000'"
.
'"
PRt.PHJLA'~*~*..MIX~P . 8 'ctl~
. ,,!
I ,,.
Cl::i) I CI. 0004 (1 ,.If
0500'''0'' '" - "" - 04 'K' (,\ T. o::r
;.,
~ .. 1 ," '''' '" i', ""'" I) '"''\\'' , .~
,~ If 1'''1,1 ,;1, " .' '..' ,I .... 0 ~15
~ I,' 1,1 ~. ~ ~~ ..
. ~%l . (f)
e 0::::> ~~~
0 lD c:; ,
~ lJ'
0 ~\ -:to ~ ~
. " ,
g ~~ - "
"
.
.
~ '<--
~ ~ "
= . .
,
a "
n
n
k 1<'.8 ll,N'F
The Superior Court hes addressed the partlel payment Issue and held In 'fLJ...
Snyder COW4 v, Caracciolo, 373 Pa, Superior Coun 486, 541 A,2d 775 (1988). tlllll
partial paymant of an Indivisible oral contract enables that Gontrllct to ue enlorced
despite the provisions of the Stilt ute of Frauds, Further. In un old SupfHlor Court case
of .6.ll11Hi.!lJL\L, Millmllll, 111 Pu, Superior Court 54, 169 A, 242 (19331. tho COlUt helll
that under the Statute of Fruuds It wus Inlflllllerlllltllat u third party lIctlJully received
the personal property sold. if 110 wos properly lIuthorllod to do 50 by the buyer and
the buyer authorized tl1ut the pluco of delivery was tho fuctory of the third party
Instead of buyer's plant. Although t111l( cuse urose under the predecessor to the
Uniform Commercial Codo, I,e" the Uniform Sules Act, tho Statuto of Frauds language
was substantially the same,
Therefore, In accordance wlth13 Pa.C,S, Section 2201 (c)(3). the oral contract
and promise by Defendant, Patricia L, Walter, 15 enforceable In that the goods and
services were received and delivered to the person specifically authorized and directed
by her, Hel' payment "on account" In the amount of $260,00 enables her oral promise
to pay the bill for the emergency repair work to her son's well pump enforceable,
In addition, although It 15 not necessary to base the decision upon on additional
section of the Uniform Commercial Code, Section 2201 (c)( 1) provides an additional
basis for enforcing the contract despite the lack of II written egreeme,lt betwoen
Plaintiff and Defendant, Patricia L, Walter, That Sactlon provides that If the goods are
to be specially manufactured and not suitable for sale to others In the ordinary course
4
were rurnlshed on the credit ofthll promisor, theUlldltrtaklllO 15 all orlglllullJlldltrtuklllg
alld not wlthlll Ihll Statutlt tlf Fruuds, Sue, !IJ.Uu ~Ild v, CrJ511.l1JJlJ!I, 3 Grullt 113
(Pa, Supral11lt Court 18621, T111J specific holdlllO 01 thut CUSIt WUS thut when one
agrees 10 puy for lumbar conlrnclod for by, und IUrlllshud to, unolllOr, uHur crudlt hus
boen refused to thut olllOr, this Is UI1 orloll1ul prol11iso lJnd 110tU cOl1truct of ouurunlell
and 15 blndln(l, though 1101 In wrltlno, ili;s;.QTJL YllfL\UL.M.\llQJ.lh.Jn.GI..-~JJJJ.!.!JN, 16
Beavllr 159 (19551,
II 15 Plulntlll's lestlmony Ihnt IIHI work lor Leo Wnltor would not huva baan
performed bUI for the promise ul1d reliance upon the credit of Potrlcle L, Walter,
Patricia L, Walter explained the t1nnl1cllJllHlversltles of Lee Wulter, end promised to
pay the bill for the repair work 10 his PUI11P, WlthOllt IhlJt promlso, Plulntlff would nol
have perforrned the roplJlr work, Plnlntlff wns rulylng upol1lhe credit ollho prol11lsor,
Thereforll, the promlso 01 Pnlrlclu L, Wnllor wus an orlgllllllul1derlfll<lng ill1d promise
and she Is personally obllgatrld f<H puyment 01 Iho bolunco of Iho bill.
Even If the Arbitrators find tllol tile promlsu of Oofundent, PlJtrlclo L. Welter, 10
pay the bill for Ihe emergency repair work 10 her son's well Is wltllln 1110 StatlJle 01
Frauds set forth at 33 P,S, Section 3, the wrltll1g requirement Is sotlsflod,
As discussed under the Uniform Commorclal Code above, Patricia L, Walter
made a partlel payment of an Indivisible contract which satisfies thaI. Statute 01
Frauds, In addition, It has been held that a check tendered In payment and negotiated
Is sufficient to satisfy the "writing" requirement of the Stetuto of Frauds, In Re:
6
.
Larson's Estate, 64 D&C,2d 318 (Lycoll1lng County 1971). Although that cusu
apeclflcelly dealt with a check tendured with rllapoct to u rool oatatrl trul1aactlon, Ita
dlacuaalon of the satisfaction of the "writing" roqulroment la equally applicable herein,
CDD.!lJJJ.DUlD
In consideration of Ihe foregolnu, It 16 reBpectfully Bubmlltud by Plaintiff thallhe
Statute of FraudB conlalnad In Iha Uniform COlllmorclal Code does not bar
enforcement of Defondanl'B promlae to l11uke paymunt for Ihe Ul11ergoncy repair work
to her son' a well. TllO Bervlco5 und lIood5 with r05pect to the ol11orUency ropalr work
werll received and accopted by her 50n and 110r partial pllyment on Ihe Indivisible
contract enabllls Ihe contract (ller prol1115e to puyllo bo enforced, II doe5 not malter
that the servlce5 and goods wore actually received by a tlllrd party, In Ihat
Defendant's son was properly aUlllOrlzed 10 receive the good5 and services by her and
she also knaw that the goodB und services would be provided ot her 50n'5 piece of
residence,
Furthermore, Plaintiff In agreeing to perform tile emergency repair work relied
upon the credit and promise of Defendant, Patricia L, Walter, and not that of her son,
The oral promise of Patricia L, Walter waB an original promise and an original
undertaking, therefore, the StatlJle of Frauds requiring a writing In order to enforce an
action to answer for the debt of another Is Inappllcabla, In the alternative, If the
7
, ,
,
llTA'l'IJT~l 0.. ..IlAllllll
u. Jlllam Yo Wotth, I r.at..
I:::rltl y, Un'lulU, I UIIHI. I~::
hl~'t~/'yV"~I'~:I~:~ . t'l';:" II, 61,
,tll:h \'. ."1111, I IIAwl. I~~l. U~,
" 1"\\!,','I~,".'h'IIIII" 1.1t. il~:l~~~
. '... HU, I I
I WAIII ~U~ lUll :1 ~'""tl" ~,
f W " I lhtllllhll'.. ~.
, , \I.... ,. I~ ':I~" II", ,Wl/llII Y,
'111'1' . ,lUll 1111,,1111'\'
,'I'll 3~J tl'~'HIU" '1'11111111,1 \'
'n. no I'U' .' JlIIII"'HI" Ih'l.
J ' I "IIIIIlIlIlj, \ I.t",..
.' I'h':~ un, 111111111111" "\I,pl'nl'
, :" t'l"lcl \', \\'hll.. H I'll'
I \~llhlJn \'. \'llln'lll II I'll .
I 1...1Inllll \'. W 11-1 II 1 1111I;. D P:II"'
It Mllllwnll'll I':lllull' ,. WN ;'
II 11II111l1nll'. I':.IIII~ I l" I,
IIlh'lIttr In U I I I' 11.1.
Htr M ' .. liD, 13 l'tll.
I l~fU' II)'''' .... t"'II)III,I. 7 w
,i, IH' IIUIIlIlIl11'. "111'/'/lt Ii
I'~ / Ifln_wntl'll '\11I'lInl, II' ^.
2 . (II, IUb, WlhlllA \' M
.F',II;; ::'j I,Un, 1I1/111111"'jI t.:~:
" ltd' llii' ,t'U',IU l'hUII Illl,
I ' , I II".. t.:,.lnht '11
, nUl JIII,IlI'll" "I '
Ino .11 III 1.', u
r I fh'IIIU'I!~'.I':/llllll' 1111'1'
'1Ilht)". I':blnle, t~ "I~ gr,!. II)
1ll0Il lIrnllNDr y, IIIJIIII III
I 0011 11~IlI/lttl'. 1';"11111" ~It
114, I\lOIl! Whlll,,'I,h" \
~, ~~ ',rllW. ~t1, I 11IIb , 'l'III1HI'1 ~
,,\, ClH,lIl_I'Il, 3G1, 10r)7.
L '"Mlllon plll dlllU'B 1 I' II '
. own 11IUI\II "lilt IIII.' III';;I'~/~-
, " rr~llllIlIH' 1I'llllt ntlll"1I I" , "
t"'"rlll II (.
171 II' n)",III1I1'. Allll1'nl, (,~
,I Illl1llrU, Aa11'rDI. a I'a..
tihull ~,NI?lIlllll)' 3" I I ~
'J:, IS I'hlln, tOl, 11I71i, J ,,' Ill,
I tnlll.. pl,lrdllutI llUl,l wllh
m,lll. to Ill, Itllll, 111111 IlIln'l
I own lI"'IlIt, "HIl.I I1tl.1II I
I. c"lllI qlle Itll.I" n
'Ill ' ,rrlnn/lV
fin, 3011, Iltll Wnll '
r 6, & It UI /llll v,
I & at i. ,UIII II1ltlll111lll"
, .., ual Will' v 1"1
,:t p, k W, 341, IIiHr 1';\'~Il~';
"~hfl1. no, lUll UtoWIt'll':,-
rI' APPltll!), I .1,., .U UHtI
NeI<uhall, :t l'lL 118,' !fiUi'
)I,conk.y, e IllL 161 114'
r~~~I'I:D3 I'... UI, Ileal 'tlltl~Tt~
, ,IUOI Bny. v ~llll
'1:11~ H.un,neu" AI1.;t'..I, ii
Illk ~ewatt. AIl".,."I, II l'.~,
, a .,. ~11"le. U A, Uf, 120
1,11P~~.~ y, UIJOlOII, U A. TU,
, I' I Ooodwln v, ColwGlI U
n, "., IUO~. '
A t,utdl..o II... I
In~1I IIHltI..., IIHIII.II : '~t41.,.
III' "'.. N' hll ''AI Ihllltlll&t
wllh a I'ruml.. lIt l,,::;~:'II' a'
tllmhut.e,","t 01 II ... IQ Ihl
..IIIIUIUIIIIl,,, will I I. IlIltd
'Illl'.ahl. 1m "'It 1111.1111 1"111"" a
IO~I"r, I W,.1I1 n~, UII;~~~IIII,
fl..1\ H
,IIlluQ'Qllhl.tllllltl "
1l""lI,11I1I1 11M IIIIII/It
l'UBIIIl'II'IJ 1'1} ""'llnrl''': "It hI.'
.r"lo, "hldl ",\.11 pilI ~III :" 1.lahl
Ih. 1'11,11 hi be 1111,; 'II~'" Ihu h
IIIIUII'III, 111111 Ill'lllH ':1" 1111I,
1"lIlnO" ",-". 1m'",,, I ~~ Ihe
1I1111lllNHllnh,IIIltlllllll Ih. .'1
""UIUN 11/1 1I1111t IIt),1 ,,;'II\rlll, Ib
hi.. Il'lqlh'lllL/ 11111111,1'1' ,'~ r, I.,l.,
I'r Ihl IlIIV"llIlt"llhtll)'I,/,~lh'lt 110
11111, .11I1IJllllh I"'llln I t14/l1l1
Il.'hll,l.,ltIlt 11I1I1I1111r, '1~'I/I~;I' 111~ loll
,"lllIn, 11111 .11','1" I I .' II'
11111'1 ,uI,1 'II/flll ,i'G ;~O'QI!Hhlll Ib
uhkh 111'llll')' II. 'I 111111<).U
'1IL1t1lh. Ihl.t /'1""'\'1',;1:'111111111,
1"'111'1'1 I)' "llt'l hll "I~II! . lli~I')'IlII('
'III "'lIhll~lI)1 III \nlll t. '~"'!tl"
111.1111'. 1 frill 111111 IlN ht al't
Ijlll'tlll)' 1'1111"'1( IlIln ~~:ttlt1lUll,
1"llllIh'/I, ""lll!.1 lilt IIHrl1t: unlit.
If 111'I"''-1Il Iht' 1'''HII'ld ('Ito .pt
hlltl 'I' flH"tll, lIhlll' n '"4 I
IliI, I" Hllltll. III Iit,l un<ler Ul.
" r 11 ~l)"II'Ilel ..
1111'.1'111,11111"11111'111
1'111111 111111 II 1 I' .I'l~t, In
11111l Will I IIlI II. \,.".Iut UllIlhl"10
11 I"IIIP", I
IHlMIII. r'lt 1/111 1I,'uI'I1I jl) 1'1l1l.14.
~llliH"I"l!nt lill Ilr hi. Villi"
I,' It l,lll<'III1IH'd lJ'
IHtllllltl. \', ,'tl)\\,II lit ^ '
1111. lUll. ,. IU, If
I ^ Int~l I'll "IUI"'I."hl nrl~(. 'rol'
.. I'" 11' IRJI,1 wllh 111l1l<:'e 1
1'l1\l1,11/l1( ro'IIIII" 1'1" or
II. ' n'nr I)' ...
111,lrlllllll 111111,111111 I.J I -.
JI'lllhhlll 1.t1l1llu!t t'll_ 12 "Oil"
.I~ IUI)~ "Al,,'.,"
1tt1~11tt r, r, ", "IHlIl 11 rre41l0r
I k ,wllh IlIlIlltluwll',I.e fJt the
n I"rtlllll 1\ ItUI' I Itl! I
In.llvhlUaf tJ~11 ," lill>,lIItnl
I. a l'1l/l\'r)'lllll'e oll
11~"pert)'. JIlduUIl ~ '1'1
IQUO, n~ 111l. :lU, 1e00,' )'llIUOII,
&:1, "" Il.Idh':IU
, '
'Ihe 'net Ihat In a I
lIlhm Ihlt 1111 , pr IJr .ull lot,
I I e 0 the IU.lllet ...
o 11 .1I'l)lule will lint pre"tl! UI'
~'~ troll) l'1l'OtCIIl" Ih. tru'l lln
r.'~ 112:,)~~~I~':1 'l'lllll Ollntn;,ly'cei"
, '
, Will'll) In an tJl'clnlrnllhlll ....fdfne.
'Jrll~ 11I1l\\'1 Ihlll Ih~ !Jllrl/ll" or
I!II1C mlllt I, 10 hn\"1l IIlI! ,11'((114&n
446 ""., " Innlte 1)), IHlllerl"l!), II. alll&
H'I'^,1'I1'I'I'; 01" FllhllllH
.."11)' I'ull 11ft 1'1" JII'UI'lla ",-Ill
,.11 ~llI'lI II l'I'lwlltJt Ihul Iha
'11' ,he 11111111)' r'lll VI'UII I') hn\'1l ~
olulll 1111 1'" ,.."" ,II"'lIl1l',1 ILl II.
" 1'l)Il\'l'~'IIIl'" 'Jt Inlllt II. I'ullnlcrnl ,II.
l'''I'II)' "Ir Ill" l'II>'llll'Illl)t n ,Idll. Jna:M'
,"Oil y, 'I'hIJIIUlJlI, CI ^, UI, gin I'n, ~Q~,
IUIJ/j,
.. l'rulIIl..' hIIlIlN\\','r fur .ll'Ill'I' IIl1ullll'r
1.~.cll'"1 ,h,,1I11< 1I1")lII!hl whel'"I.)' I" ,hili:" ""Y .."',,,,,,1' "I' ",I,
IIl1 trnl'}I', "1"'" "")' 1",",,1.< \,' ,,"'11',,1' ,I""!ill!'" ""I ,,( hi, "11'11
;liltl Ill' wh"l'ell)' 10, dllllll< Ih< oId<lId""I, "1"'11 "'I)' 'l'<ri"II'I,'"I'
, !O nll'w<1' ("I' Ih< ,I<hl "I' ,ld",,11 "J "",,11,,,1', II Ii 1<", Ihe "UI'<<'
~l ul"'" whi<h ,,,d, "l'lI'"1 ,IInU I.'" III ""Ilhl, ,"' """e 1I1<1111ll'nll-
~ or 11,,1< Ih,'I"'''[, ,h,,1I h< III WIIIIIII!, ,,",1 ,11l1I"'\ Il)' Ihe 1'"1'1)' \"
.. CbDI'HCd Ih<r<wllh, "I' ,,,111< Illhel' I'el 'IJII Ill' hllll ""lhlllit<l\.
IPPIiIlII 211, I',\, ,\l)~, ~ I.
I
""
Nuh. lit ))I'I'hlllll'
~. IN QUNlIltAL I H)tl
II- IP.CIt'IC A"PlIU\. 1" ION 1UI. U~
,I
." ----..
I,'
~ltlI.tftl 1-1Ql3
",,"10",1 tClullJ,r"tlu,1 HI
~lnl'lrohlrl 111
H~IIP.r1)' 11,1 [cl1lro1(1 rr'lljhlll\l 'htl',
)1t."ulfldll1[)' 131 wl'ltlnU III
...,.nlnt. III bl/)"1I nll,j ..II". 108
"''''111 DW/lltt. UlllIrolnl)' "'
~lnm.n'IILJr(tl"'HI'lI" \01
AKtrn..,t. feu ,Ql'
....fIt Ie; Iltllnlhcr, o:;<),"IIJ.1II111,111 16
llhi ,nd netu 10'~106
I" 1l,,,.,,1 101
Indorllmlllnt Il' hltl ot noh, .Uru,
nllnt 1M
Judlllll.nt IlQlu '06
111l",tUre 11' till I. IIltr' f11"tllrll)'
1\ 104
Iroklt... tel1ltnl..lcnl 107
1u~lnor Ilroor M
Ilnlnl" IIU'IlrlU. l/lltr..' ut 111"lJlllllor
I
UI.lInl ulh.!lrl.I<II1U 7--n
o..141"l\0l\ 14-18
In glntr/ll 14
i ,~ddlllcll.I c:oluld.rlllloll ,&
"In. fit 10 1lt001lh<lr 111
"I'lllllhII1l111 01 cOI1lld.rlltl.m 18
lulllellllnc)' 11
Ct/lltru[Uon and 'llplll;/llltJn ,
Cellltruellon eotl'rneh 'QI}~lI:f
IlIgllln.rtl,ot
,....,I.lnttll 111'1
lull[ontr.dorl ,I'
Worklllttl 112
Cot'lltJr,lllclu ,nd Utll!)t." It9ck lis...
"0
InU.lItr.1 ,"
Mr"lltlJ COI'llOU,lILJllt "IIIIII11IIIHl 0'
11.t:lh llot
!I.rllJI1. WCl1lhl,IO 11I1)'111111t 0'
cotl)Orlll. Jofbll 1I~
5t.)("," ...t",11I1111 Illi1ll1lu 10 fl''''
".
(,rdll d 1"lltIlIIQrl ollUlnAI 111Htlrt.klntl
'"
Orlllall Il' flJnlJl, rHIlI..lI IlI&
Olnd 1II'IHII"., el"llIllI.1 cr nlltltroll
1/1111,..1....11111 K
thlll/lJlltllll'tlt 131 ~OIl.ld".tlllll 11
I!ltlJlll,,1 1)1
EU(lIlc~' 11l1tlll,ll1llllllltll'llr. "1
Elllllnu "..hi, crlulll.I er (olltlt,,1
unIJH,.kll1lJ g
Q'"nllll)' nUlullltll' U",
OUUlll1l>, (Clltrll[tI, IltJUtrlll1 ar 1tI1,
"HHIlI uIHh~I"/lklll\l "
IIOlhAtllJ and wI" ,~O
1IILIQtUIIltll' iJf hili cr notlll, .UtullItnl
'"
Indorll!lI1rnl d I' "If .1 lI.rmotlndunh
IIJf!ldl'l1()' ul ....rHI"',I p:iZ
IIIIUI',,'I ullltlllflll Dr l'le,n.... U&
IIlttnllc" cf IlrOI1II.or, I~' IgIll" ut col.
Ill'trlll 'jn,hrlllklnu III
fnhru' or Iltoll1l.LJr 4~e
In.I.I1..."I)
NIll"'" 131111111I1,.1 I't
pUlllllnr)' or Iillllt\,.1 jt,ltpo... ·
Int"nlltn)'nl""\ liZl
JudIJI1It'lItt10l,. loe
447
that she would do 110, l3aaed upon that auuranoe I Shal.'on
Stoneberger indic.1ted that plumbing aerviceJ:l would be pel.'tormed by
plaintiff,
19, Penied, By way of further reply, on October 2, 1994
after announcing her presence at the common area at the bottom of.
the ataira to Def.endant'll aecond flool: apartment I Pefendant invited
Sharon Stoneberger to come into her apartment anar which Sharon
Stoneberger and the Defendant, having been friends, diacul3sed
personal issues and then Defendant asl{ed J:lome queationa concerning
the wOl.'I{ performed for her son and expreased her gratitude that
Plaintiff. waa able to perform the worl<, Sharon Stoneberger did not
demand payment but Pef.endant willingly gave her a personal checl< in
the amount of $250 to be applied against the bill,
20, Oenied, After reasonable investigation, Plaintiff h
without knowledge or infol'mation sufficient to form a belief aa to
the tr.uth of the averments contained in paragraph 20, which are,
therefore, deemed denied, By way of further reply, Defendant did
speak with her son by telephone while Sharon Stonebel'ger was
present but Sharon Stoneberger. did not hear any statements
allegedly made by Defendant's son,
21, Denied, As in the second telephone callan September 3,
1994, on October 2, 1994 after Defendant presented Sharon
Stoneberger with her personal check for $250 she stated that she
. 2 -
intended to make $50 per month payments on the aocount and Sharon
Stoneberger directed her to contact l'lltint iff's secretary and set
up a payment f1chedul~,
22, It ia admitted that Plllintiff. did not mail an invoice to
Defendant, but Defendant was aware of such invoice at the time of
her promise to pay $50 monti'll y installment.a made on October 2,
1994.
23, Admitted in part IInd denied in part, It is admitted that
Defendant's son declared banl{ruptcy, After reasonable
investigation, Plaintiff is without Imowledge or information
sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averment that
the filing of bankruptcy was "as a reault of the failure of his
business", which averments are, therefore, deemed denied,
24, It in admitted that Harold Stoneberger requested
Defendant to comply with the promises made on Sl!lptember 3, 1994 and
on October 2, 1994 and that Defendant stated she was not liable for
the bill when she aaid "you can't get blood out of a turnip,"
25, Admitted in part and denied in part, It is admitted that
the contract was oral, I t is denied that a memorandum of the
alleged c::ontract does not exist, By way of further reply,
Defendant' a check ill the amount of $250 dated October 2, 1994 iF.!
evidence of her agreement to pay the amounta due to Plaintiff,
26, Denied, The averments of paragraph 26 constitute
conclusions of law to which no reply is necessary, If reply is
deemed necessary, it is denied that the Statute of Frauds requires
. 3 .
WRIT OF EXECUTION ond/or ATTACHMENT
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNliYlVANIAj
COUNTY OF ClJM13EfTlANlJ)
NO
]'U'l CIVil Ie 95
CIVil N:T10N ,lAW
TO THE GHEIlI/'/' OF~liMII":IlI.III'II) COlJNI Y
106oI16rythlldobt,lnlor06Iundl;06t6dLJo II, r.. titoneber<jo!:" Plulllbing 1i,.lIell..t~_~~~..!rlr::,'
flOm
Patrlcill I., Walto!:"
,,__PlAINTlFF(S)
IOI} N",.lh M.t r1<tt I Ht n'"I, M,.,'lldll klllllll 'I , I'll J'/iI'VI
, . '..__m_ _u, . m___....___ .. ..OEFENDANT(S)
(1) You nre dlrectad 10 lovy LJpolllho propolly of Ihe dolondanf(SI alld 10 soli",!, 11, .hClU,~~Jl,l)}_~,JI.~~~!!~,_
"J!!rnJ!'lJ1Jn911 t ,J!1<?n~Y_,9n ~he p!:"elulaell,.6nY_lllOtoE'__ v~hlc lea .t~ t l~lnt~Il_I1~I~M3,o~_!~I!~:..I':..~~_r,'_'
,\1!!.l_~lilt: And ,,~t,1Y,.()t!ler ,tall~ j,ble ot:.ln~lIngl':Jl(!per.a?nAl prope~ty "lo<::~_~~~~~,~,h,~_~!~idence_
ot I'Atdcll! [.. WAite!:" At 300 No!:"th MA!:"ket Street, Mecl1l1nicaburg, I'll 17055
l~) You aro also dlluctod 10 allnch 1111) propully of 1I1U Ihllalldanf(6) nolluvlod upon In tho p06sosslon 01 ,___
,Q..ef.e!1!,oIIl1ct~~i_t.!.'l/J l-'llde!:"Al Creel I t Unlol1l 6275 1':lIat 'l'rlndle Hoad, P. O. l.lox 4~,--_,____,_
__~~~ani<:Bbur~, I'll.... ,,17055
,.._ _____ _ , _GAIlNISHEE(S) aslollows:
_.Jlm'-bIInJsa';;J;;9Yn~lulhi<:h Plltrlc[a L , ,WaltaI:' ,haawgh Defenall_-^..c~iyi_t.ie_aJe<!e!:"al ~redit ,
ancflb~o\liy \<<h18~r'nISi~~?sl'Mr (n) all nllachrnunl has been Issued; (b) the gaIl11611ue(5) Is/aro onjolnod Irom paying any
dobt 10 or lo(~ho accounl ollho dolondanl(s) and 110m delivering any properly ollhe dolendanl(s) 01' olhorwlse disposing
Ihoreol; "
(3) II property ollha defendanl(s) nollovled upon an subloCllO allachrnent 1610und In lho possosslon 01 anyone olher
thana namod garnlshoo, you aro dlreclod 10 nollly hlnllhertl1at ho/sllO hU5 boon addod as a gal'l115hoo and Is onjolnod as above
slaled,
Amounl Dua ,J_~~.'l._60
Inler051
L.l, _______~__.._"..']D___ __,_____
Due Prolhy ..\l.....J' .00__,___ ,_,
Olher Cosls
Ally's Comm %
Ally Paid ___.\1. 42.00
Plalnlllf Pald___
Dale:
^pdLlL....l'J96
Lilwr.ence E. Welker.
Prolhonolary, Civil Division
{r '
CeL~.t/<.LtL. d , '/1.i(Jtt~.l-
D.puty
by:
REQUESTING PARTY:
Nama P. Daniel Alt111nd
Address: 3l 1'1. 2nd St., P. o. Box 11847
Har!:"i~bu!:"q PA 17108-1847
AlIornay lor: ___Pll1in~i.U..
Tolephone: _L212L23fl:olI'JL________, _,,_____
Supreme Court 10 No, .____254~!L.....",__...._, __....._
"0 . .~..:a . _ ! ..
.
.
II. I.. STONlmEIHiElt 1'l.lIMIlINCI
& IIHATIN(i, 11'1('"
PIIIIIIIIH
IN TilE ('Ol/ItT 01; ('OMMON PI.EAS
CLJMIlEIU.AND ('OllNTY, PA
VN,
NO, lJ5 - 3724 CIVil, Tl'.ItM
IWI'itICIA I.. WAl.TER,
Dcfclldlllll
l!RAE1:11!JU~lU;rrI1n' ()to' JJ.lJ>!I.MJ::1S1
TO TIlE PIWTIIONOTAltY:
PICI1SC Clllcr .IudlllllClll lI11lliuSI PlIlrldll I., Wullcr IIl1d III Ihvur uf II. I., Slullcbcrgcr
Plumblllg & IIcutlug, IIlC, IUlhc Ull111UIll uf $HHH,60 IUllccllrduncc with Ihc AWllI'll uf Arbltrulurs
dOICd JlIllullry 30, IlllJ6, uUllcc ufclllry ufsuch AWilrd hllving bccu glvclI ulIl'chruury 2, I lJl)Cl ,
tugclhcr with CllUrt custs IIl1d stlllUlury illlcrcsllltthc mlC uf 6% pCI' llllnUIll cUllllllulng ullllI paid
III full.
PlllC: 4'1.11 1; /ffi
Cl.ECKNER ANI) FEAREN
By: I ~ ('i,II~'L ( .LllLltt,,(.
p, DlIlllcI Altland, Esqulrc
AlIurllcy 1.1), Nu, 2543H
31 Nonh Sccund Strccl
p, 0, Bux IlH47
Harrisburg PA 171OH-1847
(717) 238,1731
AlIllrllcys fur Phllllllff
WRIT OF EXECUTION Bnd/or ATTACHMENT
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA)
COUNTY OF CUMl3EALANDI
NO, __..3}_~.'I___._._. CIVIL 19 2!!..
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
TO THE SHERIFF OF _._gYMJJ'l;iBJ!ANlL.____ ...,__...COUNTY:
To sollsfy thl! dobl, Inlorllst and cosls duo ,_!!.!,._I'-'._!3-",~ebllr'J~,~-X.lulllb!.,t!~~!at ing, Ino.
,___,_._,._..__,__________._____,_._______...._._______pLAINTIFF(Sl
Patricia L, Walter
lrom
------.- ._-~.-.--- ---~---------~ ....----------.------ -----.----,
-------....._-----_..-.~-,._--------.._...._.._,--_._-~.----------.-----.........--....-----.-
___.____..,__,__.___.__,____,....".,."",___.,____,._,.________,_.___..,._DEFENDANT(S)
(1) You arll dlrocllld 10 lovy upoJ1lhll propolty ollho dolondaJ1l(s) und 10 soll-'!.!-_!..,bousllhol~-'Jooda at,~_
JYm,Wllng~,LIJ!9!l~y_.9!L~ll!U~~~!l1isel'L~.Dy_~~Lv.'l!lic:.~'!!l__"!l:..~~,.1n the nsme of Patricia L.
Walter and any other tana iblll or intangible personlll property locllted lit the residence
-.-~----------_.._---_._----_...----
of Patricia L. WlIlter lit 300 Nort.h Market Street, Mer:hlln1cebur\l, I'll 17055
_._.____.._______._'~._ __.__...,.__.___..___._..__....____._____.__._.__d_...____..______..._....__.____..__~_._~___.___
(2) You oro also dlructod 10 ollnch Il1u proporty ollho dulondnl1l(s) notlovlod upon Il1lho possosslon 01 __
Pe fense .A.s~ !y.!.t:.!,I3llE~IJ.ra!.~r.ed_itu. Un ~ on -,.!i2!?_.!':afl~_!r i':l~~ e I~,?.a_~ ~~u?,:_u~!._<1.~~_
_ Mecha~~~.Eul:'.L~~__..,]?CJ.?5__,u, .._u"...._ _un. ___um.uuU__,._,__.____.,___,
_.__",.....,_....._'.., .. ".. _..'___..n..' ""_..._...____,..,._.. __ _____ GAHNISHEE(S) os follows:
any bank ac;:~nt~LJ!'b!91 P,atrici~__b. Walter, haa "!',ith Defe!l~e 1I~t..~vities YedeE~l Credit
amflb~Jt~y \~oi811r'nl,jj,~wMRgr (0) un ollocl1monl has boon Issued; (b) Iho gornl~hoo(slls/oro onjolnod Irom paying any
debl to or lor tho accounl ollho delondonl(s) and Irom dollvllrlng any proporty 011110 dol~ndonl(s) or olherwlse disposing
thereol;
(3) IIproporty olll1e dofondanl(s) nollevled upon on subjOCllo ollochmonllslound In Iho possusslon of anyono oll1or
tl1an a namedgornlsl1ell, you oro dlreclodlo nollfy hln1lhorll101110/sho hos boon addod os agornlshoe and Is onjolned as above
staled,
Amounl Duo
Inloresl
Ally's Comm
Ally Paid
Plalnll" Paid
$ 888.60
L.L.
'1 :J;v.'IMM": { ,tJ
ttU~J .
%
Duo Prolhy _
Olhor Cosls
Dale:
Prolhonotary, Civil Dlvlalo"
by:
Depuly
REQUESTING PARTY:
Name p, Ollniel 1I1tland
Addreee: 3l N. 21ld St., P. O. Box 11847
lIardsburq PII 17108-1847
Allorney lor: plaintiff
Tlllephone: (717) 238:::lU.l
Suprllme Court 10 No, --25438
II, 1-, ':J} {Ji/t.' ~l'" (-I,: It.
II ll.uIT/!'L'1 /,h
IN'llU'; (X.llll' OF (~""~ 1'1.1':M,OF ,m111l':lIl/lNl) (UI~I'Y, "I'~IYI.V/IN',^
CIVlJ, IllVIH/(~
I'. I "'III I oj! "J
111,. No!, (('5l..'-~'L " L r
, , -, ,., "l, 1-" " _J.wLL _ILU~1
^,'~HIIII ,.,,, l.'all,2L.,<LC______..___
11I1.'n"ul
"
f'i,..,,I.{)
v"
(Iii r Ii I( /11 L, I JIll T/: /!. I
1)':Jt ",k'1 ~
'It) 'I'IIE P/lOlllON:/I'M/Y OF TilE HMP ('<Il)H'I',
. '__"'4'__",_.~,_____
^I ty'u ('IW11U........__,_,______
Couts
- _.. --'--.-. ..-- --~-
Tho ul1derBi'll1ud II1J1'Qby conti: los tlllH tllo below dOI'u not 11I:1so Ollt of II retail
installnlJnt MIl!, contract, 01' lIccOllllt bllSed on II COl1tl'mlJon of jlldgnont, but if it doos,
it is based 011 tll" ,lPP1TlIll'i,/lto ol'i\lil1l1.J pI'ClCOQdlll'l Ulod plllSIUlnt to ^ct 7 of 1966 as
amendedr and lor nwl pnl/Ktrty pllnlllilllt to ^et I, of 19'/,1 <IIi ;umndod.
!,1Y\frI!,F. ..r~9J~X:xaUI~I.'!:I
Issue writ of [)xeclIti,on in till! IIIKIVC /Inltcl' to till' :illl!J Iff Of-1~LJ~ltlj'.A
County, for debt, ll1tereut lIIld eoutB lI/KJr] tile foll'illllIl',j delO',lbed property at t le
,
defondan t ( s I jJlL Jl.tJlJ:wJ;d.tL4JlJ.tl.::L .:..1.I1..L<)u.-'LI.:..IU'I<-l,:J_,<uJ...J>:.U, ,..,i--Jl.s......fJ..JIA.,'.... \ ~"" ,'u.Jt.~..J;',1
-41' lJ ' ,:) 1 1 r
I.H"'( /'1 Ii, 11(.,", ~-t.J.HU..._..L,'-W:.../-l4.--~1JJ_...J."'/..~dJ!I.F_jLL;,lJ../L+=--+lJw~~_~'I,J! l''f''',-/L;
I,~.J. d I. /. I)., i>uJ.AJ,ML J_,J1JJ':"'~"-L ,-,!::k,jj!.L...J,'oJ--~..A;"<_/__'l_lt~~.,Jt:4~~1 ,1I1"/v'~'i )~"'I
'J fJt} !'!ulS 0/ /
,~!.~ql)E,J:9!l_N1'!~.~_, f:X.!~I:I~
'.
Issue writ of Ilttdc/V1Jent to the Shen ft of .C'!clJfl..LIUil..c.!.__,.._county, for debt,
intorest <md cos t U, liS <loove, dtrectJ II~, ilttllclvlk'lIt a~'lJl.I1st the ilbove-nal11ed ganlishee( s) for
the followlnn property (If real t!6UJte, 6lJpply "LX cOIl.leu of till' descriptlOnr Bupply four
copies of longthy per60lldlty L1Sl)--Lt)1f-__{~r..IJJh--/1Jj'-,-'-.,. (.J,.,/Ir, h"1 d"~
;), t/ I- I' ,( l~______,_ _
IInd all other property of the defendBl1t( s) In the possodsion, ClIstody or Control of the
said garnishee( s),
(Indicate) Index this writ against the garnisholl( s) as a lis pendens against
real estate of the defendant(s) described in the attached exh,ibit,
"'", <//;1/1(" S1W"'"""~~(),"M/"t~
Print NlUllCl -L_/')''<l.h'd_..l1Lf/tII/ "t
Mdressl,3L_d:L:2u.L_J.Lt-P-'L i~'X //8' ~/7
-L.&.c~~jf!MT 111 J 7)O';r- 1-0 '1 7
Mtomoy fOl'l..f)lltLI..~
TelePhone,_-6.0}~ ~LLl3.1
SUprel11e.> COllrt l[) 1'<<" '...i2:s- '-I '~ ')('
Notlltll. If. rlllll propttrty, Il11PP~Y Ilix COllillll ot dllllcriptlon inclllQing ilfllL'OVl!II1l9ntll II/1d an
originaL /llld copy of. at'fhlllvH of oWl1o:trllhip (Pall.C.P. No, 31~91.
If lllnythy perllonalty list, Ilupply four capillll of. Hilt,
To index writ, fillll Illlpllratll prlleoipe with writ.
~ ,
, , ~
':' - ."
~ ~ ~~ 111_i ' .
1Ji , ,
~ ~ I' , I
~ c:> ~ ~ ' i ../ :;;~
(:. ~ ~ ' "
::\
~ I' ~ ~ , ,,)
r- ~p' , .. :
; "- -
. r
~ r . 1".,.1
~ ~ ~ .$
, 1
'\
,
'}
l)
0
t