The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About95-03767 1'1 ~ ,! ~ , It: cj I I 'tf " I> 'e ~ :". J " C' ~ CY) .t, , , , ,I " " " 'I " " I " I' , " " , , " " , , " , I " , " 'I " I , , , " " I , , I t, " " " , I, ,I 'i';' , ,I " " " , , " , " I'), " " " 'd " il " , 'i" " " " 1,1 , 'I "~I " I, ,,' " , , " Ii " , , ", " , , , , , " /11 ,'JirJ 'IJlt , '1.'~M 'I" ',I' 'li'l.'l i"'" 'It", ,! "II , J At",; ,'i;'jf , ,I, Ii' !]'I ',i':~ f 11\ 1'1 " , I ',":."!' 1'1,' 'I iG 1':\ 'II (; .. , " ,', 'I "t'e {it.' ,(I ,Ii ,\fc I I ~~ I"r;;' "tle ~ ')~!.' 'd. : ~'i '~'JI,i ':} <'I),i: ":;:~ ','1 i'I' , "I, 0';, 1:'.1 I,,'i ,',~] /' ,,',1 1';;(' ,~, "" ,,/ I), , "1 ",/ I" jl: ,', " .q II i ~t "I" , ,\'; 'It I -( '! ,ii, , d 1", i,llf ')~ !,Iiil !' 'Ii , ), ~ 'j,;,' i ! ."'1.1 ""'j"l ,In'r:'';;'}ll'' ',I',:., ~ i\t1 -j,11':'/J}!1 ' I"". '1,.,.:',.",1': ,'/il<~t~ ',' "'j' , '{ ,l. " ., " , " "t \,11 ~ .. ie . ," N ,I lv' \ ~ " ~ {' ,., I-('} \~ I "'-" to I t, ~. " I\~ .... , , ., I' .~ "'-e. . f\~ - ---- \'" ""! G I'\j ........ '-l ~)~;:; I,::) " ,~i I,-'~) .,.... "'I -- ') ',,~ r:i . :":I>l Z U HZ 0 ...:l III ~~ ~ P, H t:JlIl fJ :z . ... III ..J Vl 0 II: ... -..... p. '0 c: ~ III '... ., c: III W ~ ., ..,J Z ru ... ''0 0 . c: ...:)'! Po c: ~E .., rnU ~ It) 'lJ ~. P: III WHP:tJO ... H (] .-< ZI):~ZP: 'lJ r.; p. 1):'" Hl' Cl ,~ 0 o<I!U fooU": ~ 111 (a1 H "Z 0: l)l H ..JNl!)O 0 t:JC:zl H .I>l IIlH W OZ~ U W ..... e- U": ZUllY.U W I>lCil~ o-l . o-lOWo(D Po ..: t> r.ll): Ur.l 0: .... ~r.llll E-o ,.( E-t ......"'J;: E" U :z~~ci H II:Ui> Vl r.l Po (J r.l l)l ~ Z ..: 6 H Po r.l .0 l)l HUPoZ :l:VlUlo(U Po trl 0 !~I'I- ~ ! m l I ~ j i!: I e- N C ~ " r- ~ 't- C-~ 4"":llI ~'"")i 'I ,,,', ,:\, ' ",i?,',n'~',~'~,l~V'.L~~,' r.I'fIKi,~HI'I'.,'" \>i,;j~'N;it~,/ - t~l'~',~, IIMdt1} -' i. '1!)'i:!YUi.-1j;~I',_~'r v,fl \,;I!,//I "I) " ... ~ . , . -' "" "- - 11 - Ii, { "'I ",1'-J I' "ib? No, 19 civil ActTon-- (XT Law ( ) Equity IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON P[,EAS CUMBEIU,AND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CAPITAL CITY CAR WASH, INC, 3525 Hart~dale Drive Camp Hill, PA I7011 Plaintiff MICHAEL 1", BARNES, tla SPECTRON ELEC'rRICAL SERVICES 610 Lawther Road Lewisberry, PA 17339, ZIMMERNAN PLUMBING AND HEATING, me, 110 East Allen Street Mechanicsburg, PA 17055, and SHANE CONSTRUCTION GROUP 5256 East Trindle Road Mechanicsburg, lOA 17055 Defendants I I , I versus I I I I (!/ I I I I I I I I I I I I J1I11 {" , Lt~'( ~ (;.' , . I '. ,J( i~'(A'-1j "1'- /~-r"-\! ~ L~' !',1I'H :\(, l~: I 11t::I',' 'N' 'Ih~' A.~.t lJI~ "1'1" "'li( ''''fJ :,<;;U':." " " , I~'" .11/ ~Jl V, fl -- ! C~ 1'(.\ ., ~CIPE FOR WRIT OF SUMMO~S TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF SAID COURT, Please issue writ of summons in the above-captioned action. XX Writ of Summons shall be issued ( )Attorney (X)Sheriff Sheriff of Cunmerland County One Courthouse Square CarlJ.sle, PA 17013 (717) 697..0731 ext, 6390 re TO THE ABOVE NAMED DEFENDANTS I WRIT OF SUMMONS YOU ARE NOTIFIED THAT THE ABOVE-NAMED PLAINTIFF HAS COMMENCED AN AC'rroN AGAINST YOU, Datel Prothonotary By Deputy ( ) Check here if reverse is issued for additional information - \ /...:r!t\. /-d'llil",' 1 " I ,}}.!:tli~r'l'~lPt - :"''.11 ,,' I' J\Hi;~l+} \(l~;lit \.: ',' " ~I~f n fif~ [;) , f" .; 'lJ f" ro ~lr f" i-' rt ~ lQ ~ i'r :r> n I 0 ~ U1 C) r o I:l I rt ~ "1 n w f" tTJ. f" "-l j ~~~~ 0 rt'tli-' rt '" I:l ~i-'!1:0l '< "-l ~C)n - C) rt~ n (') rt '1 ~ ..' S , r< 1-' 1-" f" m .; n S' o I:l C) ..' 0 t; tJ lO O. .. :a: .... t-' I-< n C1 n' rt III '1l:lcn, I:l' o 0. ro n' . 06:t~ H i It f" I:l ~ C) C) S-~ , <0 . ti n . in any way, said allegations are denied pursuant to Pa,R.Civ.p, 10:l9 (e) . :l4. After reasonable investigation, Defendant Zimmerman is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments contained in Paragraph 24 of Plaintiff's Complaint, and proof thereof is demanded, WJlIRBPORIIl, Defendant Zimmerman demands jUdgment in itll favor, together with all applicable COurt costs, Cani tal COf.!NT II - -NeCl!iqenae Citv Car J!~.h. IM. v. ..z.l.mmumlln Plumbinll it Hell tinCl. Ino. Defendant Zimmerman incorporates by reference all 25. though fully stated herein the averments denials contained in Paragraphs 1 through 24 of this Answer and New Matter, 26, Denied as a legal conclusion to which no response is required. lly way of further answer, Defendant Zimmerman avers that it did install the plumbing system at the car wash in a reasonable, competent, good and workmanlike manner, 27-29, 30. Denied pursuant to Pa,R,Civ,p, 1029(e). Admitted, WJlBRBPORB, Defendant Zimmerman demands jUdgment in its favor, together with all applicable Court Costs. 3 COUNT III--Breaoh of Contrao~ Capital city Car Wa.h, Ino. v. Shane Con~~otion Qro~p 31. Defendant Zimmer.man incorporates by reference all though fully stated herein the averments and denials contained in Paragraphll 1 through 30 of this Answer and New Matter, 32-38, Par.agraphs 32 through 38 of Plaintiff's Complaint are directed toward a Defendant other than Defendant Zimmerman. Consequently, no response is required, To the extent. that the Court may deem these allegations applicable to Defendant Zimmerman, said allegations are denied pursuant to Pa,R,Civ,P, 1029(e), 39. After reasonable investigation, Defendant Zimmerman ill without knowledge or information sufficient to t.'orm a belief all to the truth of the averments contained in Paragraph 39 of Plaintiff's Complaint, and proof thereof is demanded, WHIIlRIllPORB, Defendant Zimmerman demands judgment in its favor, together with all applicable Court Costs, COUNT ~~liaeno. CaDital C~Car W..h v. Shene Con.truotion QrOUD 40. Defendant Zimmerman incorporates by reference as though fully stated herein the averments and denials contained in Paragraphs 1 through 39 of this Answer and New Matter. 41-47, Paragraphs 41 through 47 of Plaintiff's Complaint are directed toward a Defendant other than answering Defendant. Consequently, no response is required. To the extent that any of 4 these allegations may be d~emed applicable to Defendant Zimmsrman, said allegations are denied pursuant ~a.R,Civ.~. 1029(e), 48. After reasonable investigation, Defendant Zimmerman is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments contained in Paragraph 48 of Plaintiff's Complaint, and proot.' th~reof is demanded, WHIlRIlPORB, Defendant Zimmerman demands judgment in its favor, together with all applicable court costs. NnLHATTER 49. Defendant Zimmerman incorporates by reference as though fully stated herein the averments and denials contained in Paragraphs 1 through 46 of this Answer and New Matter. 50. Plaintiff's claims may be barred by the applicable statutes of limitations. 51. Plaintiffs' Complaint fails to state a cause of action against Defendant Zimmerman, 52. Defendant Zimmerman performed all worJ( in a reasonable, competent, good alld workmanlike manner, 53. Defendant Zimmerman's acts or omissions were not a substantial cause of Plaintiff's damages, if any. 54. Plaintiff's damages, if any, were not caused by any acts or omissions of Defendant Zimmerman, or any of its servants, workmen, employees or agents, but rather were caused in whole or in 5 part or were oontributed to by the negligence of Plaintiffl, Defendant Speotron, or others. 55. Defendant Zimmerman was not negligent:. 56, Plaintiff failed to mitigate its damages. 57. Plaintiff's claims of damage are not factually supportable. 58. Plaintiff is not entitled to attorney's fees either by statue or by contract, WHBRIPORIl, Defendant Zimmerman demands judgment in its favor, together with all applicable Court Costs, NEW MATTBR IN TUB NATURE OP A CROSSCLAIM AGAINST DBPENDANT MICHAEL~~S. t/. SPBCTRON BLBCTRICAL SBRVICBS. PURSUANT TO Pa.R.Civ.p. 2252ldl 59. Pefendant Zimmerman incorporates by reference as though fully stated herein the averments and donials contained in Paragraphs 1 through 58 of this Answer and New Matter, 60. Pefendant Zimmerman incorpor.ates by reference the averments contained in Plaintiff's Complaint against Defendant Michael F, Barnes, t/a Spectron Electrical Services (hereinafter "Spectron"I, in this action. Defendant Zimmerman does not admit the averments of the Complaint, but incorporates those averments solely for purposes of this crossclaim, If it J.s determined that Plaintiff is entitled to recover any or all of the damages set forth in its Complaint, which is specifically denied, then 6 (@ .~~ \~ " ~iif n fi'1~ Q , ", < 'tJ ~ mi ~ '" rt n 0 ~ ~ \D :I> VI n o 'i:I I ~ ~~ rt r ~ ~:'l n UJ ,,' ", -.J j 0 rt'tl 4 '" ~~ p ~ia~ -.J I - n n . ~ ", S E I:" ~'b' h' rn < ~ S' ~ 0; i:I Lll P' . ~ Q . I-' '"' Clg rt a en..... 17 p.mll! . .go:~ ~ r m ". II! n ~, ~ , IQ . Ii n , , I II'" I '; I '" 'I 1,( fe, III! '11 f' ll,' (. C, , r I 1nr J. \: I' ,1,1 .' 01 J,jQ CA~l'rA~ CITY CAR WASH, INC" Plaintiff IN 'l'lm COUll'!' Ol~ COMMON ~1,lilAS CUMJ:llEIU,ANP COUl'l'l'Y PIl:NNSY~VANIA ,. I v, MICHAE~ F, BARNSS, tla SPJ;:CT1WN SI,SC'1'IUC!Il, SERVICJ;;S, ZIMMBRMAN Pl,UMBING AND HEATING, INC" and SHANE CONSTRUCTION GROUP, NO, 96~1767 CIVI~ TERM CIVI~ ACTION - ~AW Defendants fiQ~ YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT, If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you, you are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entlH'ed against you by the Court without Complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff, You may lose money or property or other rights important to you, YOU SHOU~D TAKE nlIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYb;R AT ONCE, IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A ~AWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO '1'0 OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BE~OW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP, CUMBER~AND COUNTY LAWYBR R8FBRRAL SERVICE One Courthouse Square Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 240~6200 NOTICI/\ LE HAN OEMANPAPO A US'rEO EN I,A COR'I'E, S I lIS'I'IED QU URIi: PEIi'Jl:NDBRSIi: OS ES'I'AS DIi:MANPAS EXPUES'I'AS SN IJAS PAOINAS SIaUIENTES, US~'JEO 'rIENE VI8N~'E (20) DIAS IJE PLAZa AI. PAR'rIR DE LA FECHA OE I,A DEMANPA Y I,A NO'rIFICAcroN, IIS'l'BP DEBE PRESEN1'AR UNA APARIE:NCIA ESCRI'rA 0 ILN PBRSONA 0 POR ABOGAPO Y ARCIHVAR EN I,A CORTB BN FORMA ESCRI'rA SUS PEPBNSAS 0 SUS OBJECIONBS A LAS DEMANPAS BN CONTRA DE SU PBRSONA, SEA AVISAPO QUE SI US TED NO SE DJj;pmNDE, LA CORTE 'I'OMARA MEOIPAS Y PUED/;; BNTRAI~ UNA ORDEN CONTRA US'l'EO SIN PREVIO AVISO 0 NO'rIF'lCACION Y POR CUALQUIER QUEJA 0 ALIVIO QUE ES PEPIPO EN LA PB'I'ICION PE DEMANDA, USTED PUEOE PERDER DINERO 0 SUS PROPIEOAOES 0 OTROS DERECHOS IMPORTANTES PARA US TED , LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABODAGO IMMEDIATI\!o1ENTB, SI NO'rIENE ABOGADO 0 SI NO TIENE EI, DINERO surrCIENTE OE PAGAR TAL SERVICIO, VAYA EN PERSONA 0 LLAME paR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA OIRECCION SE ENCUEN'rRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONOE SE PUEDIJ: CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEGAL, CUMBERLAND COUNTY LAWYER REFERRAL SERVICE One Courthouse Square Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 240-6200 , I \.Jusiness entity with a place of business located at 5~56 ~ast Tdndle Road, Mechanicsbur9' cumberland County, PElnn13ylvania 17055 (IIB"AN~II), 5, Plaintiff op~rates a car wash business known as capital City Car Wash located C\t 3';25 Hart zdale pri ve, Camp Hill, pennsylvania ("CAR WASH"), 6, The Car waah was constructed in 1990, 7, Shane was the general contractor for construction of the Car wash pursuant to a contract with Plaintiff, a, spectron was the electrical contractor for construction of the car Wash, 9, Spectron was a subcontractor of Shane, 10, Zimmerman was the plumbing contractor for construction of the Car wash, 11, Zimmerman was a subcontractor of Shane, 12, The Car Wash opened for business in November 1990, 13, In July 1993, it was discovered that the underground water main was leaking at the Car Wash, 14, The leak occurred at an area where the copper water line pipe was connected with a brass compression fitting. 15, It is believed and therefore averred that the leak was caused, in part, by an improper connection of the electrical system to the copper piping, 16, It is believed and therefore averred that the leak was caused, in part, by an improp~r installation of the plumbing system. .. , 17, The leak was repaired at the expense of Plaintiff, 16, Until the leak was repaired, Plaintiff sustained a loss of business at the Car Wash, r COUNT 11 NEGLIGENCE CAPI'l'AL CITY CAR WASH, INC, v, MICHAEL F, BARNES, t/a SP8CTRON ELECTRICA~ID'ICES 19, The averments set forth in paragraphs 1 through 18 are incorporated herein by reference as if set forth at length, 20, Spectron owed n duty to Plaintiff to install the electrical system in a good and workmanlike manner, 21, As a result of the Bcts and/or omissions of SpectroD, Plaintiff has suffered damages arising out of Spectron's negligent installation of the electrical system, 22, As a result of the acta and/or omissions of Spectron, Plaintiff has suffered damages arising out of the costs to repair the leak and loss of business in an amount reasonably estimated to be $10,000,00, 23, As a result of the acta and/or omissions of Spectron, Spectron is liable to Plaintiff for its damages, 24, Pespite demand, Spectron has refused to remit payment to Plaintiff, WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, Capital City Car Wash, Inc, demands judgment against Pefendant, Michael F, Barnes, t/a Spectron Electrical Services, and in favor of Plaintiff in an amount less than $35,000,00 plus interest, costs of suit and attorneys fees, 32, It ill beHeved Bnd thorefore averred that Shane, as the general contractor, maintained and exercised control over the Bubaontraotors, 33, Shane is liable for the acts and/or omissions of its subcontractors, 34, Pursuant to the terms of the contract with Plaintiff, Shane promised to construct the Car Wash in a quality and workmanlike manner, 35, Shane breached the contract with Plaintiff by failing to canst ruct the Car Wash in a qualit.y and worl<manlike manner, 36, As a result of t.he Shane's breach, Plaintiff has suffered damages, 37, As a result of Shane's breach, Plaintiff has suffered damages arising out of the costs to repail: the leak and loss of business in an amount reasonably estimated to be $10,000,00, 38, As a result of Shane's breach, Shane is liable to PlaintiLf for its damages, 39, Despite demand, Shane has refused to remit payment to Plaintiff, WHEREFORE, Plaintiff, Capital City Car Wash, Inc, demands j udgmenl against Defendant, Shane Consl ruction Group, and in favor of Plaintiff in an amount less than $35,000,00 plus interest, Costs of suit and attorneys fees, CQUN'l' IV, NIU3LWli:NCIi: CAPITAL CI'I'" CAILWMlll.,_JJI1:,,__y_._,lJlIAtlJLCONSTRUCTION GROUP 40, 'l'he IlVElI.'l1\lllltll Ullt fOl.'th In paragraphs 1 through 39 are incorporated heroin hy I.'UI'Ul'lUleU au If set forth at length, .n, [t In hl11 luvHCI nnd tJlul'efore averred that Shane, as the general' c:ont l'tH!tOI:, 1IH1 intillnud dud exercised control over the supcontrilt..'tllrll, 4:2, Ilhnlll1 ill L lubLn fr,)l' the acts and/or omissions of its subcontractoru, 43, HllIInu owud II duty to Plaintiff to ensure that its subcontract.ot'lI pllrl'ollllllCl in II quality and workmanlJ.ke manner. 014, Hilann hr'lilchl}(l hIli dut.y to Plaintiff in t.hat Shane failed to elHlUl'Il thill illl IJ\lbc:ontractors performed in a quality and workl1llln J. LIlli lIIilllnl! I.' , 45, All n I.'UlIllLt of the acts and/or omissions of Shane, Plaintin lUIlI uultul.'l3d dal1lilges arising out of Shane's SUPc:ontl:nct.ot'lI' nu'! !.L'j,mt install at ion of the plumbing system and/ot' the u L'lCt I' i ,,:nl uyatem, 46, Au B reuult. of the acts and/or omissions of Shane, Plaint iff hall lIuf fet'l:!d damages arising out of the costs to repair thu lelll\ and losu of business in an amount reasonably estimated to bu 010,000,00, 4~, Au a result of the acts and/or omissions of Shane, Shnno is liable to Plaintiff for its damages, 48, Despite demand, Shane has refused to remit payment to Plaint.iff. , lo.J>.' ,., .~ II, I, tI! ,. ", , , , /" ~" . I ' , I q ~j. . I '/~ i ) , .1 f,): ; r', r II'" t" , " ~, "'! ," II, , , C.J ['j: I ,) . U ~ Z ~ ~ p. .... ~ ~ . 1llr.l5l0< 1'] !il 6 ffi ..., )Vl~ffi ~ E ~ ~ "" " ri '... ~ . '" E-< o . ... ... l'J ro p.. '0 ... ~~ ~ .:: 13 z.::t:l .:: .... ~ ,... .... H nJ 0 C)J .... t> III ~t~ ;e1 "" j .... .... C)J 0. 0 U IN 0 :E ! -r I-<UO< ~ r:tlr.l.JUZ 0 ~ ....r- .Jo.ZO U ::l IS 8 ~~~ .... . ~ H H U r.. ill ti . Z ~ . r.l ~ ~ J, .J t> o l!lO ..: Iil ~ ,Z IX ~ VlCl' I-< f~~""E-< .... U E-<Vl ~ ~Bo 0. r.l ..:Z (j HO'....r.lO H llo~ :EVlNlXlU , , ~" ro, , . lr: t',_: I i L '. ,-) ., ( . Ill" 11, ' t/ I.. lJ ' ," lip ,...: " lL'; " I . ..J . I .., b ,~ d ,)'1 . ~ ~ ~ ~ g J l !i ! ~ ~ I ! ~ , ' it " - " , I , . I I I I' , I I' v, !, r' 1': I)' (I -.- -- =..-.----- .. -, -.::=u== .- ~~ m. ~ '\;, iii ,., ~ . \: j ~ ~ I! i!1 ~I ~ ~.~~ ~~ ~N .~ ~!r: IJ iJ. j ~ . iJr:l . ~ e5 '. ~ ~ ~~ E~ 'H '~I~~~ 15 iJ ,~ m ~ . ~ ~ ....,)., s~ . J ~e~ ~f I> r~f5{jr J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ e ~~~~ ~ (5 ~ !i'!1rlp. -_.- --""-' -., ..' . '. , " . ,', ' I} " H~ I ''I 1 I, I , , I' I , I " 1 " I ',',1 ,q , .., I, . L:tlnlFIl'ATE tlJ:'JitJ!Ym I, JU~Lju~lIll~ A. D~~k~r, 1111 ullthllrl/cll UI!,~lltllr MUrtMIIl. D~lInlllrlr, WIIIIIIIIlK & Ollll, h~ruhy c~r1II'y Ihul U ~lIPy lIflh~ t'lr~glllllg I~~ply WIIK K~rvcllthlK 1I11l~ hy lICpllKlllllg KIIIIl~ III the IIUKI ()Ill~e ul l'urIlKI~. I'A, IlrKI dllKK 1111111, IlllKlilgc prcpuill. 1I<ldrcKKclIllK flll\lIWK: Tl'Ucy I.. McNIIIllIII'II, !:K'IlIil'c l.AW OFFICI'S OF STEI'III'N C. NUDE!. 21 '1l'lllc Strcct IIl1rrlKhurl!, I' A 17\ 0 I Tmlllll, Nurvlll. EKLjulrc TIIOMAS, TIIOMAS & IIAFER 305 Nllrlh Fnllll Strc~l 1',0. Illlx '1'1'1 IIl1rrlKhllrl!. I' A 1710H Slmllc l'lIllKtructillll (irllup 5256 Eusl Trllld\c RlIud Mc~huIlIcKhurg. I'A 17055 MARTSON. DEARDORFF, WILLIAMS & ono By 't.LIt.4J(LO/I..l~ J 'qljC Ill~ A, Dcckcr 'CIl EUKllligh Strcct CurliKI~. I' A 17013 (7\ 7) 243.3341 AlIOnlCYS fill' Dcfclldulll Michucl F. BUnlcs, VB Spcclrllll Elc~lri~ul Scrvi~cs [)BICd: OClober 7, 1997 CAPITA!. CITY CAR WASH, INC. ~,opp~ CUIHlY OP ~ - I I I I MICHAEL ~', /3A/ltIES, 'riA SPIiX.'I'Ilct/ ELf:;C'I'RICAl, I SERVICES, ZIMMIinMAN PLlJMllING /\NO IlEA'I'lNG, lNC,r 6nd SUM/!; ~S~'HUC'r Ict/ GROUP r v. File No. ~ 95"3767 CIVIl. TOr Middle Department Inepection Agency, 3901 Hilrt?dale Orive, Camp lIill, PA 17011 - (N~ of PerllOn 01" Entity) Within tWllrlty (20) diY, .ft.,. '.,.vfce of thfs subpoe"a, YOU are OI"dered by the CIClUrt to PI"OdJCI the following docun.,t, 01" thfngsl ~ all dOC'J01Ontll concerning the Capital City Car Waeh, Inc, conatruction project Which wae performed in 1990 (October and November, 1990) -----.----- ---- ~~R~~~A:a,:~~ a:oon:~~ --., It law ofUcee of MAR'I'SQ/, OEl\RDoRF1", WILLIAMS & arro, 10 Eaet lIigh Street, Carl1eJ.e, PA 17013 (Add-ellS ) You may daJjv.,. 01" mall legfb/e copl.. of the doall'lfll1ts 01" Pt'Oci.Jce thfnss requested by thl, I~, l:oseth.,. with the certlffcete of COTf)Jjll'lCe, to the party making thl. request It the Idd-Ns listed aboVe. You have the rfght to leek fn advll'lce the reasonable COllt 0' preparfng the COPlell 01" proa.,clng the thfngs sought. 1 f YOU flf J to PI"OdJce the doc:unants 01" thfngs requfred by thfl subpoe". within twenty (20) days Ifter Its ..ervlee, the party 1I.,.\llng this sLtlpoerle rillY seek I OOlrt OI"der ~"fr'll yOU to COTf)ly with It. DATEr~t. !(g#1 _ JCf97 Se I of the Oo(".t THIS SUlIPOEHA WAS ISSUED AT Tlf: REQUEST OF Tlf: FOlLOWING PERSONr NAMEr Daniel K, Deardorff, Esquire ~r~et Hi9h Street Carliele, PA 17013 ------~ ~' (717) 243-~41 COURT 10' 17837 A FORI Defendant Micheol F, Barnee, tla (l.~ ::;peCtrol'l tileCtrlCal ;:,erVICee BY TN;; exlLftTr ~..w1'e,.,(...Q c:: L,(j)/Olu.r -....''"'.... c',q ?""'''' G...ia.....J.J (V7t):1.e,1101n .~ Deputy (Eff. 1/97) " CAPI'l'AL CITY CAR WASil, INC. I Plaintiff IN 'l'lllll COURT Ol" COMMON Pl,lllAS CUMl:'llllRl,AND COUNTY PIi:NNSYlNANIA v. MICHAIllL F. aARNES, tla SPECTRON ELECTRICAL SERVICES, ZIMMERMAN PLUMBING AND HEATING, INC., and SHANB CONSTRUCTION GROUP, NO. 96-3767 CIVIL 'l'IllRM Defendants CIVIL ACTION . LAW RESPONSE-IO-NEW MATTER-Qf MICHAliL. F, BARI'IE,s" tla SPECTRON-1:;LECTRICAL SERVICES AND NOW, comes Plaintiff, Capital City Car Wash, Inc., by and through its attorneys, The Law Offices of Stephen C. Nudel, and respectfully files this Response to New Matter of Defendant, Michael F. aarnes, tla Spectron Electrical Services as follows. 49, The avermento in Plaint iff's Complaint are incorporated herein by reference as if set forth at length, 50. Paragraph 50 contains a conclusion of law to which no responsive pleading is required, 51. Paragraph 51 contains a conclusion of law to which no responsive pleading is required. 52, Paragraph 52 contains a COliC Ius ion of law to which no responsive pleading is required. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests your Honorable Court to dismiss Defendant's New Matter and enter judgment in favor of Plaintiff and against Defendant plus interest, costs of , I! I .. ", , , , jl , , /," ,.. I .~ I...' I " t /I,j , 1.'_ to, ,', " 1'1> I ". '.J o..l p. ~ & ~ ~ o. II U~ ::;l0<: ~6 ~ o U E-<\.JO< ~ HI' 8~~~ r.liil~J, ~r.l!li", ~ ~ . ~e~~ . . ~ I... . IJ: ~ p: d ~ H U ...:l 0<: E-< H ~ d .., .., 'H ., r: H P r>l p: z "11')8->: '-.lJl Z II: ;.1 ,.r, lI) ...1 . .. ~r: t, 10 l'l4 lJlU:7.r:b r~ H H ru 0 Zll:~ ll: ~ e-. .. t? ~t: tJ . III liI...J U Z 1-1 ~ Z 0 ,roll I~ H ru Z E-< o..l~~t!ig lilll:,,,,Zll: 0<: E- ~ H E-< IrU E-<lJl U Iii 0< Z HP.H~O rolJl N IJ: U w. III rl P. , I> III j.J r:: 'Q '0 r: <lI '" <lI r.l lilt! ll: '-. H /.) j.J I> E- I>: E-<'3r.l ;'!~lJl I>:...:l ~;;j6 Z 10-4 '1>: or><E-< E-< U ...:lW r.l1>1...:l l/) 1'( tal Ztl: OUZ 04 1>-40 lJlrol>: r.l E-< P: r>< tJ Or.l ~ tJl , , Iil :; I~JJ , ~ ~ ~ II ~ Tf E eAPn'AL CITY CAR WASH, INC., Plailltiff IN 'l'fllE COUR'l' OF COMMON PLIEAS CUMBERLANP COUN'l'Y PIENNSYLVANIA v. MICHAIEL 1.", BAI~Nli:S, t / a NO. 95-3767 CIVIL TIERM SPIEC'l'RON ELIEC'I'RICAL SIERVrcr,;s, 2IMMlERMAN PLUMBING AND flEA'l'ING, INC" and SHANE CON8TI~UC'l'ION GROUP, Defendants CIVIL ACTION - LAW BEfJ.Ji'ill'lll.1L1'SLNJ);!iJ>11ITIJi;E 01> DEFENWlli'LZ.lllMIEl{MAN ...e1.!JMBING AND HJ;;ATING, INe.. AND NOW, comes Plaint.iF.f, Capital City Car Wash, Inc., by and through it attomeys, the Law Off ices of Stephen C. Nudel, and t'espectfully files this Rasponse to New Matter of Defendant Zimmerman Plumbing and Heating, Inc. as follows, 49. The averments in Plaintiff's Complaint are incorporated herein by reference as if set forth at length, 50. Paragraph 50 contains a conclusion of law to which no responsive pleading is required, 51. Paragraph 51 contains a c<1nclusiol'l of law to which no responsive pleading is required. 52, Paragraph 52 contains a conclusion of law to which no responsive pleading is required. 53, Paragraph 53 contains a conclusion of law to which no responsive pleading is required, 54. Paragraph 54 contains a conclusion of law to which no I I r , I.... \ i' 5fi. Pat'8grllph 55 containa a conclullion of law to which 110 rellponBive pleading ia required. 56. Paragraph 56 containll a cOllcluaioll of law to which no reaponBive pleading ia required. 57, Paragraph 5'7 cont-uina a conc1uaion of law to which no responsive pleading is required. 58, Paragraph 58 contains a COllcluRion of law to which 110 responsive pleading is required, WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests your Honorable Court to dismiss Defendant/s New Matter and enter judgment in favor of Plaintiff and agaillst Defendant plus intereat, coats of suit and attorneys feea. Respectfully submitted. Datel IO-llo-C/l LA"JA~'~7;}Z: Step en C. NUdel, Esquire Attorney 10 #41703 Tracy L. McNamara, Esquire Attorney 10 #'72669 219 Pine Street Harrisburg, PA 17101 (717) 236-5000 NUDEL Attorneys for Plaintiff ',. -.. .- tf; IJlf' .. . I ll' " , ' ,., C' ~. ['I, I :' 1 L , I < . 1 .. " l,: ~. ..- . . U U lOll I-< P:~iO'l III I-< ~~~~ r>l I-< E-< ~ E* . E-< P! . Iii ~ ~ .... "-lJl;(O:: )'!iJ~ ~ .... +J lJl ~ E ,," .~ \!) '0 ~ 8i +J ~~~ ..:10< J: lJl :ZJ:i:J N"': I mHi I 1-<..:1 PI .... r,.lHHfQO :0.: ~ ~~ e, (J III lH~~ .l'J 1<-<0:: .... O:Z 0 U ~ .t u . ~~~ f<UO< :z I>< III r.l .1 U Z I or S~a:;S I<-< ..:I~ZO I-< .1>1 I-< H ::l IS 8 7~ U .... lOll E-< z....\!) ~ . . :z~ 'u o~:z e ~~~ ..:I I> ~o t.:lo ~Ol-< 0< PI :ZP: ~....~ E-< ..: f< f ,... E-< :z~!o~ I-< 5u I<-<fIl P:O 5 ~ "':Z ..:I I-<p'I-<1>l0 P, .... p,zu J:fIlNO::U I 1 " \' " . ~:.Lj , 1rttd!. ,jJ l'~ .t.,l a...-e &,,; (!,..,. f~iu 'iT ) " ) ) ) I ) [n Thll (;LJIJ~t .)f (oJll11110n l'lllu of Cwnblll'" LlInJ ';.)llllty I ~lInns:- l'IlIni4 ~o . 3 7~ ?' . l') 9 <;--- 'JA !ll t~e do .01olDlDly swea... (oJ... affim) the Con.titution of the Unit.d Stat.. ~.alth .nd that ~. ~ill disch....gll the thBt we will IlJpport, QbllY and def,nd 4nd the CoJniStitution of this ':Oll\ll\on" dutiu t OIJ.... ~1~~elit>'. ~ {j(Q ~ l'r \~::an -.cJ,c4u t{) 7 6j; ~J (; .\WARD (or We, the und.....ign.d arbitrators, having b.en duly appointed and sworn Itf.irm.d) , make the folLowing award I (Not., If damag.. fa... d.la>, ar. awarded, they shall be 53, ;;:ataly.'ta:;;) A (J~7t' L l'lIiU,'(j1J J'~',(I.: b:~~"/J I ..J. IJL .. f ~ ~'iJ V.,'l.: 'j ,', ) I ~''''''.. ,,' ' , ,,,' I,.. i : Il'"" ('e "J/'I<" {..,.: , dr, l'.'L/,' '. .t~JJ~ ~ Il."./..., , ,\ , 'I .JJ ~r 1~'1111 (..II. appl1c.ble, ) Oat. of Hearing: ~~ O.t. of Award: . A...bitrator, dissents, (Insert name 1: ~OTICE OF ENTRY OF AWARD ,C-) / Now, the h~( day of 'lp,.1 award wae .ntar.d upon the docket p.rti.. or th.ir Ittornevs, . 1 9-L,L , olt ~. L.:[" the 3bove and notice ther,:ot given b:- mail to the Arbitrators' comp.naation paid upon appeal I $ ,I 'f" ,I" to be ('It " ( ,( ;' , 'ploth6~.otar.., By I --....: 1,1 "t, I , /1 ) ),' , L l,. De!ll\t~' .i .. ," "'1 )' ,'" .' li: /l)l II; i' f).... I> "',11", II~ ' , I:'," ,I, I" }..} I' I" ....., , I ~,. I' -. , oJ ' (,/, , r i; I .', 'Id ~. '.1''' I' 2'\ " I d a o-l 110 i ~ ~~ ~ "'o-l ~ ~ ~ I o U Eo< U.rl Z PI HI'O t:>!iIZl"'.... o ~.rll'''' U..I>"'U Pl~.hoOl r.llllmo-l ~ .t;: &30.... " . I . U Z .... . ffl ~ PI t'J ~ .... U .... .... ,,.. .jJ p ,,., III .... llo . I> Cl ZI>J ....~ ~ffl III o-l ... p.'lJ .., r.: HZ to ... cn('j~ ,g; 1>1...."'UO ZPl~ZPI Pl!- HCl fOllU rJ3IiJH ""2 o-lNClO . ~ Z H ea.. ...1-4 E-4 ZlIl!-U ..J 0 l'oloOl.., I>1P1UI>JPI fOll!-H:>::!- !%:UI> III tJl'olPl Z Hllol>J 0 , 1 1 III +J r.: III 'lJ r.: <1J .... <1J o I>< "'0 lIlPl ;::~ ...:...: III z 00 !-.... Eo< ~l ...: lloP: H!- UH I>JIXl ;:i~ ~ , " .. Ii:! ::; 1~1'1- ~ ~ ~ ~ I ~ Tf t ,. I 1 f( p ~ CiI; to) "'l , ti n k , 1 '\'t "1 () " I IS' C il"l ,., ~ "'.1 ,I',) 10.1 " ~ ~ , I ~ "I jr) .. . I II ~ 1 1'1 " .. ' !{I "1 .,1 ~ ,J:'" I) ...j" I 1 -1:-' ,~ / ' , '.' '/' ; ,j ,1,1_' ! L ~ I ... ,:/ :('/ ' ..,1 'in:) 'I' ~",,'{ , i' . ... 1'-, \j .U( 'q ...:5 .,' ' .. '"": ~".l.." "" , '"i, ." '" . "0 ',J ..