The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About95-03829 , , 'I, , , " , , 'I , I ~ I 'II' ., , 'j", 1'- .., .1 ,. " " , J I '1 I', ., '1" .' , Ii o ...' or (.. V) ..' ., ,j'l " i! )1 , , ,\" 'I .> !. -j 'I , , , II ,/ I III , ' -p ~ rJ S ,,'I ., ]', I I' ! , , , Ilr , d , ' , " Ii I 'Ii; I ! I ," .' E: ~ J 0- ((J ~ 1',1 II N "'RJ (;:;) - ~) rr ! C> "'" ~ - . -- ...... ~ 0'.) ....... ~ ~q- N CO) N "" lli "'l -'.,., ~ \~ " " ~ ~ , I ~~ ~ /e ~ .. . .... I:Ji l" \"J\f"') ~ , I , I ... , . I i' 11 "I Ii q ;I " , ), ! i It , I' i l )' q , I " rw:f:~",~.~ ,! I I I p, ""f(, '10 ~/ ./. (I #<,,,Ji./;:r , QU1u..t '1< tJ C).~I-J- Q, n...~, ~r:, 3.<4 ClaTIrIC~TI or SlaVICI t.. . I I, SARAH W. AROSELL, ESQUIRE, horeby oertifY thAt I have served a true and correct copy of the foregoing PRAECIPE FOR EN'l'RY OF APPEARANCE on the following person by plaoing same in postage prepaid, on the ~day of __~' the United states mail, 19961 James R. Ronca, Esquire SCHKIDT , RONOA, P.O. 209 Stato street Harrisburg, PA 17101 Attornoys tor plaintitt THOMAS, THOMAS , HArlR BYI ~fM~,t~~ Sara W. Arose I Esqu re ~f.l - ~.:: ...... r" ,..t "-.I fl.) II .." ~ ~ ~ i 11 .. E JH ~ t M I 2 cj .. ii t '" ~ g . ~ .... I .. . tfJ :.... ~ j. I IE I IJ'. t.} ~ ~ ., I, I N , I I 0:>:) ,., , , II I.. ~.J , CO I I(,~ " . I, , . I, I , . ;1; " . . b ~~!:! j "a ~ II .. ~ ~ I ~ti~! j ~ g . ~ I I . . . NAR-17-93 WED 16:45 (HIEF JUSTICE NI~ F,)X NQ, 12\5660256\ P.01/03 II TN 'l'H~ $U~REMP: COURT OF l'ENl'lSYl,VANI!I , IN REI SILIcotn;; IMI?LAt!'r LITIC}~'l'ION NO, JUPICIhL .~MIatSTRATXVS POCKET NO, -- pRDER OF COURT AND NOW, this .J 7th day of ~l.srch , 1993. upon the r~colM1erl<iauoll o~ the Ad Hoc COlM1J.ttelll Oil l31hC0116 Implant ~iti9at10n, 1t is hereby ORDERED as folloWSI 1, Th19 order governs all pending and future lawoults tilvd in all COllrto ot the Commonwealth of Pennoylvan1a, Ileelung dal\14geOl for perAon4\l ~lljuriell alleged to have beell oustainod 1n tM use of silicone breast il1'plantS I ~. The following Judg~s are appointed to Olt as A three-judgo Coordinat1ng Panol tC IMnage and coordinlite casea governed bY this order I A. Honorable R. Stanton Wctt1ck. Jr. t t:h:u rplH~on B. Jionorable S,snurs Ma:er Moss C. Honorable l:mll.nuel A. CaOalmatlll , The 1\ llaghl/ny County court (,f COlM1on Pleas iLl . . deolgnated as thlll Coordinating Court and th~ jUQoes appointed to the Coord1nating Panel 1n the preceding paragraph ill~e asoi9n~d to oit 86 C'olM1CJn Ploaas Court Judges on thlS Court tcr tlH purposes of coordlna~lng :~tigatton, 4. Tile membero of the Coordtnating Panel snail serve at the pleasure of this Courtl 5. Cases claim1ng injuries as o!\ result o~ s;.licone ~:t\R.17 -93 WED 16: ,16 CHIEF JUSTICE NIX FAX NO, 1215&602661 P,02l03 ~mpl"'ntll lih.sll h. f:.lQd ~ll tllfi loc.l j\ldic~al d~lItl:~CI: U l:lIquil..d by the ponn5ylvania RUleB of civil procedure, 6, Till.! coordinating Panel PIllY transfer any cllse to any COUl;'t of Common plcas within this COll11lonwealth for good C8U", 7. The preeident Judges of all of toe courts o( ::ommon PlIolU, tOe CoorrHnat~ng Panel members, ano th~ Adrnillletrr.t.."N Cffice of Pennsylvsnia CourtS Bhall develop a proceS5 tont will permit notification of the Coordinating panel of the filing of a silicunc breast implant lawsuit w1thin a judicial d~Btrict and provid~ far tho disscmlOation of all ordere and rulingB of toe Cool'dinating panel. s. The Administrative OHice of Pennsylvllni:l Coul't15 shall be charged with the responsibilitY of arranging tel." expendit.ure!l necessary to pay for tM wOl'k of the coordinatin~1 [Janel: 9. The coordinsting Panel may I (al enter. etay or modify CSBe management Ol'derli af fecung pracnce and procedul'e which do not cnlal'ge or abridg,a the Bubstantlve nghts of tlle litigants which lltloll appli' 1n all judicial dietl'icts of the Commonwealth I Ibl stay. vacate or modify any exiat:l.ng ol'der 0: any conunon pleas Court tr.at is inconsistent with any o~'del' which tl'le Cool'dinatlng Panel has issued; Ie) exerCl.se any and all powers gIven t<l a court punluallt to I'a. R.C.P. No. 2:.2.1 coord1nation or. 1\e~ionfl HI cifter-ant counties; (dl remand i\ matter to the local Court of common "leas for decision of sqlected :l.ssues or for trial I ~AR-17.93 WED 16146 CHIEF JUSTICE NIX FAX NO, 1216660266\ P.03/03 . ee) enter any orde~ neou..lry to etteot the purpo.. ot tb1s ord.~, 10. The Coordinatinq ~anel phall .it as a court En Pano on any mattera before the Coordinating Panel unlel~ the Panel enters an order aaaigninq one member ot the Panel to consider a matter on behalt of the entire panelr 11. Rule 341 of the pennsylvania Rulos ot Appellat~ Procedure effective July 6, 1992, ahall apply to all llilicoJle breast implant calea certified to the coordinating Panal, including those filed prior to July 6, 19921 12. All appeala from any d~cieion at the Coordinating Panel Ihall be tiled in the superior Court ot Pennsylvania; 13. Appeals taken to the Superior Court of Pennsylvania ot casea involving now and novel silicone breast implant litigation shall be expeditiously hoard and disposed of initially by a permanent panel composed of five (5) judgell ot t.hl) S'Jpedor Court whOle decisiona shall have the full force and effect of a court En Panc. After the resolutJ.on of a legal ispue by the permanent panel, appeals in other cases involving the same issue would be heard before a three-judqe panel as the Superior Court may direct. BY THE COURT: .-- (" ..- -. .' '\ I / ~""'jUStlCoil -3- , " \ nl THE COURT Of' COH)lON PJ..ItAS OP ALi:.EOHENY COUNTY, PENNSYJ..VANl:A M THE COOROINATINO CO~T f'OR SIi:.ICONE IMP~ LITIOATION IN REI SIJ..ICONE IHP~ J..ITIOATION CASE HANAGEMmt' ORDER NO. 9 STAY--RESPONSIVE PLEADINOS/DISCOVERY ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this ~_ day of September, 1994, it: i~ hereby _.~'-.,. ordered t:hat I (11 All proceQdinqs are stayed in lawsuits seekinl'l damages for personal injuries alleged to have been sustained in the use of silicone breast implantsr (21 This stay applies (il to the filinl'l of any pleadings other than a complaint or prAecipe for a writ of sWl'lllons and (ii) to discovery I and (3) This order of court does not apply to the filinl'l of a cOll1Plalnt or a praecipe for a ....rit of summons to institut" any lawsuits permitted by Case Management Order No.7. BY THE COURT: /1/ 'f..~ ;1. c.. ~ HONORABLE ~~ A. CASSIMATIS ly' -S~... /l" ~.,..., /11 ~ , . HCNCRAB~F. SANDRA MAZE~-MOSS ) r:I' -1.I1111T f"~., R~I~./ HCNORAB~;;: ,STANTON 'NE'I"I'ICI(, JR."./..J CHAIRPERSON Schmidt and Ronca PC 101) SI.III: SIIeel 11;",151111'14, l'e 11115~1~."11" III 0 I '11'1/ UZ-OlOO I". 111/1..11-00101 AttOrllC)'1i ;\Illl CO\lIll'ichJr5 "" l.i\W .. , Ootober 1, 1998 The Honorable George F.. Hoffer, P,J. cumberland county Court of Common pleas cumberland county courthouse One courthouse square carlisle, PA 17013 REI Carol McCord v. Samir srouji, M.D" et al. ~o. 95-3829 cumberland county Pear Judge Hoffer I We have received notice that tho above-.;:aptioned matter will be dismissed on october 27, 1990, unleso good cause can be shown to keep it as an act i ve t:i Ie. Thl.s io a breast implant related claim subject to the Pennsylvania supreme Court Order pursuant to PA. R.C.P. 213,1, The case has been assigned to the Breast Implant Litigation coordinating Court. (See Pennsylvania supreme Court Order attached as IExhibit "A"). This case is also under a stay isoued by the coordinating Court. (See Exhibit "B" ,) Therefore, no activity can take place until the coordinating Court lifts the Stay. We respectfully request that thifJ Honorable Com-t find that good cause has been provided for the above-captioned matter to remain open. If thio Court is ot the opinion that good cause has not been shown, we respectfully request a hearing on the matter at the callan October 27, 1998. Further, we respectfully request jurisdiction of this case to the Court for all pre-trial matters. your signature. that this Court transfer Breast Implant coordinating We have enclosed an order for .,. ; -' f..',,' ,"~ ;;1 , ) . '. I I lIill . 'I Ii/! .1 'I' I I ''1 I. I I' 'I I"~ ',1 " ! '.1) ','I J '.. .~ '-', CAROL A, MCCORD, Plaintiff IN THE CoUr~T cw COMMON PLl!-;AB CUMBEI~LAND cOUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO, 95-3H29 ... . SAMIR J, BI~OU,J\, M,D, and PLASTIC SURGERY, P.C" Defendants CIVil_ ACTION tAW .)UI~Y 'mlAI. DEMANDED 9~PJ!)R ~ AND NOW, this Iff) dnyof , 2001, upon good cause shown, it is hereby ORDERIW AND IJEClmED thllt the above case shall be marl<ed as active and thllt the nbove-cnptloned mlltter will not be terminated; the case will be removed from the Innctlve IIt;t of October 30, 200 I; and, the case is stayed pursuant to the Silicone Breast Implu\1.t Coordinating Court's Order, Case Management Order No.9. ,Jurisdiction of this cllse Is hereby transferred to the Silicone Breast Implant Coordinlltlng Court for all pre-trial matters, As soon as this case has been certified as ready for trllll, it will be trnnsferred buck to this Court, at whieh time the trial will take place. BY THE COURT: J. . l~~ /() -/7 -0 I RJ\S .. I, II I. ( ,; Irt'/i\' QIOr;T'~ 1'''~ln4 CU~ld~h,..i)U tvUNTY Pr:JINlNI.V/WIII , , , , , I t',\R-IHJ ~EO \5,~G t:HIEF JIJSTlCE NIX FAX Ill). \2\55602551 p,02l03 1m[llo.ntll tlIhall bll t ~l..d In t.tllil locel jUdicLal dist.rict: Il~ ."quired by t.he PllnrUlylvanin Rule" of civil procedure, is. 'rhll ('oordl.nat.l.ng !?anol 1113Y trans fer any case r.o any court. of common Piau wl.thin chill commonwealt.b for good caillier 7, 'I'ho l:'rea ident Judgea of all of tr.e courtS o( common Pl~llS, t.he coordinat.ing Panal menIDera. and the ^~ini~tr~t.v~ effice of pennsylvanill Courta shall develop a proceGs tnnt will permit notification of ehe coordinatl.ng Panal at t.he filing at a silicone breast implant lawsuit wLthin a judicial district. and provide tar the disBCnlLnat ion of all orders and rul ings of the coordinating panel. e. The Administrative offiCII ot I?ennsylvania courts sha.ll be charged ~,ith the responsibil.ity of arranging tor expenditureB necossary t.o pay tor the work. of the coordl.natin9 "anal; 9. The coordinating panel may I (al enter. stay or modify caee management order~ atfecl:lng pl:'act Lee and procedure which do pot enlarge or abridg.a the substantive ngbtB of the litigantS which 101'1011 apply l.n a.ll judicl.al districtS of thE! commonwealth, (p) stay. vaca.t.e or modify any existing order: of any common pleas Court t~at is inconsistent with anv order which the , , coordinating panel baa issued; Ie) exercl.se any and a.ll powers glven to a court pUt'liluant to Pa. R.C.P. No. 2l3,l coordination o~ I\c\:ions l.n Difter-ellt counties; (dl remand a matter to the local Court of common Plea. tor decision of B~lected issues or for trial, ~~R-17-93 ~ED 16146 ~H I EF JUSTICE N I :\ FAX NO, 12\5660256\ P,03/03 (1,1) this order. 10. The Cnordinating Panel shall ~it a~ a Cou~t En Bane on , enter any order neQoa~ary to eft eat thu purpose ot any matters bofore tho Coordinating Panel unless the Panel enters an order assigning ono member of the Panel to consider a matter on behalf of the entire paneLI 11. Rule 341 of the pennsylvania Rulas of Appellato Procedure effective July 6, 1992, Bhall apply to Bll silicone breast Lmplant CBllea oortH Led to the l:oordiMt ing Pllno 1, includLrhJ those filed prior to July 6, 19921 12. All Appeals from any deoiaion of tho Coordinatinq Panel Bhall bo tiled in the Superior Court of Pennsylvania; 13. Appeals takan to the Superior Court of pennsylvania of casos involving now and novel silicono breast implant litigation shall be expeditiously hoard and disposed of initially by a permanent panel ccmpolS<ld of riVQ (~) judge/! of t.h~ superior Court whose deoisions shall have the full force and effect of a court En Banc. After the resolution of a 1I!9al issue by the pe/:1ll11nent panel, appeals in othor casea involving the Ba~a issue would be heard before a three-judge panel as the superior court ~ay direot. BY THE COURT: /.~/" ,/ ~"".1ustice -3- Sdllllidl, I~IIIII ,I .\: "1.11111'1 '" INJ1Jll\' lAW)', "r; ~()U f:ilahl Slrual 717.~a~,6300 Hlllllul!'lrU, f'unlluylyanlll17l01 Fa. 717.~3~,6467 WWW.B.~hlw.com . Septcmber ;.! I, :200 I The J-/()Ilorublc (Icorge ~~. J-/offer, P.J. Cumberlund County Court of Common Pleall Cumberlund County CourthoUtle One Courthoutle Squure Carlisle, PA 17013 Rill Carol McCord v. Bamlr Bro",I. M.D.. et -It No. 98.3829 Cumberland County Dear Judge J-/offc1': We have received notlcc thut thc ubovc-cuptlollcd mutter will be dismissed on October 30, 200 I, unlcllS good CUUse cun bc shown to I<ccp It as an active me. This Is a breast implant related c1uim subJcctto thc Pennllylvanla Supreme Court Order pursuant to Pa,RC,P, 213.1, The cusc hus becn ustllgned to thc Breast Implant litigation Coordlnutlng Court, (Sec Penntlylvllnia Supreme Court Order attach cd as Exhibit "A"). Thitl CUtlC Is also under a tltuy istlued by the Coordinating Court. (See Exhibit "8",1 Thercforc, no uctlvity can take place until the Coordinating Court Iifttl the Stay. We respectfully rcquetlt that Ihitl Honorablc Court find thut good cause has been provided for the above-cuptloncd matter to rcmaln opcn, If thitl Court is of the opinion that good causc hus not bccn tlhown, we rcspcctfully rcquctlt a hearing on the matter at the call on October 3D, 200 I, We huve cnclotlcd an Order for Your Honor's signature, Also, Your Honor previously signed u similur order In Ihis action on October 5, 1998, which I have encloscd. CAROL A. MCC01~P, l'I,MNTlFF IN Tim COlJ/(T OF COMMON PI,8AS 01' Cl1MIl81U,AND COUNTY, P~;NNBy[.vAN [A v, SAMIR SROUJI, Mn PLAS'rtc I:lUIW~~RY, D8F8NDANTS C I V Il, Ae'n ON - I,AW Y5-3ij~Y CIVIL T8RM olm!':/{ 01" COURT AND NOW, thin 30th oay of October, 2001, in the case of McCol.'d versus Brouji at No. %-3829 Civil Term, it appearing that docket activity has recently occurred in the case, the case i8 stricken from the purge list and shail remain dctive. By the Court, J James R. Ronca, Esquire 209 State Street Harrisburg, PA 17101 For the Plaintiff i/)~;'#I-4"".,l.. 11.,:)1. ~I ~ Linda Porr Sweeney, Esquire Ellis & Porr, P.C. P.o. Box 10696 Lancaster, PA 19605-0696 For the Defendant ('\ t..:! , . C' ~. '. 'TJf:: " .,... ..:i 1),1111 h;:, ,. ~i"1 ; , I ~~l' II:) . .. , I (I . I ," ~I ~ ' , .r-!l" ~. ,I r.,,') . ,!(: ;1:", ~. ~ 'dill ~ Ul I' \0 ~l , .... pcb , ,