Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-03843 ~ f J iii 7 ( b r- Ji (<)1 7: 00 r0 , , 01 Z! I I I I .,.. .,... - J ~1j it, \~ \ ~~ ~''-1 ~ ~ " ~ " ~ '" tt ~... ~- :'.=i' ',' .... en ~ ~ :';'" -, UI< <H ~Z ..:1< P<> ..:I z:>- OUl ~~ O~ UP< ~ QJ ....l/I QJ .... .... 0).... >. .... O'tl.... t-:lCC Ill.... 'tl III C'tl.-l I1lCP< III C.Q 11l1/l e ::s .<:.<: 01 ::s ~ III C III III e C.<: COl QJ ::s .-l11l Cllll lI'l 0\ 0\ ~ .... C III 'tl QJ C o QJ C .... III QJ '" Q ::s l/I C H e ~ '" l/I III QJ r.,.... C QJ III ....0. III e ....0 UlU :E: l>: ~ E-t ..:I H > H U r., . 0:>- E-t E-tU l>: OQ OZ U< ..:I ~l>: :r:~ E-t~ ZO HU . l/I :> . o z ...."....~"lill.............."U. OIol-:JJ O)l".....twoI1.UI",., .. . " H E-t i:i E-t H III ~ ..:I ~ P< :E: o U o E-t Z o H E-t H E-t ~ P< . .;.. ., A JUL L 0 \99\ l' . gj ti I- W :!; ~ ~ '" UjUla o I 3 ~ ~ !i ~ < .. z Q. t <( w ... z J: .. "V a: % ! 1&1 0 Ii ~ ii: ~ 06 ... z - 8 a: N (!) ti ~ W _ ~ < ... Ul Q. g ! g W c !: ~ i ~ Z l\l Ul Ii w o lD Z z ! ~ u ';." , " ..' l . '. ..p.~..... ; '7J e: 1 ~ , IJl ~ 0.. . \;; '1. ~ c- '1 A t vs. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA ~5- 3(':;'~3 ~./-d~... No. civil Term 1995 I GLENN BAUGHMAN and JOYCE BAUGHMAN, husband and wife, Petitioners L . STATE FARM INSURANCE COMPANIES, Respondent AND NOW this ORDER day of 1995, upon consideration of the Petition to Compel Arbitration of Glenn Baughman and the response of State Farm Insurance Company, it is hereby ordered that the Petitioner's underinsured motorists claim be submitted to arbitration in accordance with the provisions of the applicable insurance policy. The following individuals are appointed as arbitrators in this matter: State Farm Arbitrator George B. Faller, Jr., Esquire Martson, Deardorff, Williams & otto 10 East High Street carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-3341 Neutral Arbitrator C. Roy Weidner, Jr" Esquire Johnson, DUffie, Stewart & Weidner 301 Market Street Lemoync, PA 17043 (717) 761-4540 BY THE COURT, J. vs. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA q,>-:'-'S'.;.' (',. (.J",,"_ No. civil Term 1995 GLENN BAUGHMAN and JOYCE BAUGHMAN, husband and wife, Petitioners STATE FARM INSURANCE COMPANIES, Respondent B!U& AND NOW this %.'1. day of 1...L.r , 1995, a Rule is granted upon Respondent to show cause, if any, why Petitioner's under insured motorists claim should not be submitted to arbitration. Rule returnable '2<> c( 4-y I 0./ li- ./"<<-oJ I 'A.. . . BY THE COURT, J. .1 -.... .. "1 'C5 l'J 1'" .; \ GLENN BAUGHMAN and JOYCE BAUGHMAN, husband and wife, Petitioners IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA vs. No. civil Term 1995 STATE FARM INSURANCE COMPANIES, Respondent PETITION TO COMPEL ARBITRATION Petitioner, through his undersigned counsel, petitions this Court pursuant to 42 Pa,C.S.A. Section 7304(a) for an Order compelling arbitration in this matter, and in support hereof represents as follows: 1, Petitioner is a citizen of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania residing at 10 Windy Hill Road, Newville, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17241. 2. Respondent, State Farm Insurance Company, is an insurance company duly licensed to do business in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania with its principal place of business at 1 Slate Farm Plaza, Bloomington, IL 61710. 3. Petitioner was seriously injured in an automobile accident which occurred on June 10, 1992 on Newville Road in North Middleton Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. 4. Petitioner settled with the tort feasors automobile insurance carrier for the applicable liability limits. 5, Petitioner's physical condition improved to the point where he was able to return to work and he did, in fact return to work, subsequent to the accident. 6. Petitioner has, however, been treating with a physician throughout the time period from the date of the accident to present for the injuries sustained in automobile vehicle 1 ;;'-;;J; accident, Said physician noticed a deterioration in his condition and advised him to seek accommodations in his employment which would mitigate his deteriotating condition. 7. Petitioner ~ought such accommodations, however, it was determined that they were not feasible. 8. Petitioner's physician then advised Petitioner to stay off work indefinitely. 9. Petitioner believes that he will suffer wage lost and further medical bills, pain, and sUffering, above and beyond the liability policy limits. 10. At the time of the automobile accident, Petitioner was a named insured on an automobile insurance policy which was issued to Petitioner by Respondent and which was in full force and affect at the date of the accident. A copy of the insurance policy is attached hereto as Exhibit A. 11. The Petitioner demanded from the Respondent underinsured motorists benefits to which he was entitled under the insurance policy by written correspondence which acknowledged by the Respondent. 12. Respondent offered to settle Petitioner's under insured motorists benefit claim for an amount far below the policy amount and the damages suffered by Petitioner. 13. As of the date of filing this petition, the has not paid any under insured motorists benefits to pursuant to Petitioner's insurance policy. 14. Section III - coverage U of Petitioner's insurance policy with Respondent provides that either party may require the the was Respondent Petitioner 2 other to submit to arbitration and any dispute involving a party's legal right to recover bpnefits or other payments under the policy. 15. Petitioner's insurance policy provides in paragraph length that the arbitration shall be governed by The Pennsylvania Uniform Arbitration Act. 16. On or about June 9, 1995, Petitioner mailed Respondent demand for arbitration pursuant to the terms of the policy of insurance. Petitioner named in that demand its choice of arbitrator on Petitioner's behalf. On or about June 20, 1995, Petitioner sent a follow-up letter to Respondent requesting the name of counsel responsible for the defense of the UIM claim. 17. To date, neither of Petitioner's demand nor request have been answered by Respondent. 18. All conditions precedent to arbitration under the terms of Petitioner's insurance policy with Respondent have been satisfied. 19. Because Respondent has failed to arbitrate pursuant to terms of its policy and Pa.C.S.A. Section 7304, Petitioner requests that this Court appoint the remaining two arbitrators pursuant to Pa.C.S.A. Section 7305. 20. Petitioner presents the following individuals to be appointed as arbitrators in this matter: State Farm Arbitrator George B, Faller, Jr., Esquire Martson, Deardorff, Williams & otto 10 East High street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-3341 3 Neutral Arbitrator C, Roy Weidner, Jr" Esquire Johnson, DUffie, stewart & Weidner 301 Market Street Lemoyne, PA 17043 (717) 761-4540 WHEREFORE, Petitioner requests that this Court issue a Rule upon the Respondent to show cause, if it has any, why the Petitioner's underinsured motorists claim should not be submitted to arbitration and thereafter order that the matter be submitted to arbitration, naming the above attorneys as defense and neutral arbitrators respectively. Respectfully submitted, GRIFFIE & ASSOCIATES Attorneys for Petitioner BY J 2 North Hanover Street carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-5551 4 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE The undersigned hereby certifies that concurrent with filinq the foregoing Petition to Compel Arbitration, I have servod a copy of same by United states mail, first class, postaqe pre-paid to the fOllowing addresses: Edward A. McMerty, III state Farm Insurance Company 115 Limekiln Road P.O. Box 257 New Cumberland, PA 17070-0257 DATE "7/; i/J-;- "7 / n;( fer C. Deitchman, Esqu re .- Griffie & Associates 200 North Hanover street Carlisle, PA 17013 ,;.,. .. . < .. . - f< -~ . ... III ... :c .. w 1:. J 'l H '.Jllt 1 ~ ~1&'llfilf' .f . t J'. I ~ Jf1f"r' I .[ I. i .. ! fc .1 II . J 1(-1."11 ~ ]1OJ i ; i ..:.. ! .;:r8f ! ~ : ff'f:-,ft .f 6 ti J. 1.1 ;!"f - ill ill S: jHh t 1 ~ ~ 11 J 1"1 "1 ~l IJ It t. ":it}" .e...~J:e I !lQ ~.li I'j U.;'!:UliJ' i j 'ij!d;i1ed i ~ j~!!l~i jUi:j"~U~~.i.~I~ t~~ J8 ilhll! n j' ~ ~L~!:c .. ... 11 ..; .,' .... ..:..... J I , Bi!J;:.9.i~.'HhU~;i~'r' ~H .i, I J tJ ~ ~ dSg~ i a ... ~ I I h j f f r ' .. f ~9~Q~ "1~:?;'1 !~i 1igi~,.: ~r. i.. .~'! S~ ; jll f:t! tJ!f lli j-.:l li! ! ll!& 11- :1 i. g ! lj If I' f.! ~ '. rr (.1 :i i~ ~ t I h t 1 1 h I ~ f Hj II.~jJ:fl,.1111'1!~11 il,ltU1i tJ"'l' = Iltf I Ii ..f.. "f I I.... I J ';1" r 11 I a. f~!II" ~U :- !I.JilJ,j f ~ IJ:':~I~1 i jj . iUJ'f'!~ ~It..: .. ~[I ,,! tJ ..:.. .I J ..: . . . .-. .... . .. .' .' .z . , .~ . .~ ...... ....,r:. .: t... ~.:l~ ".~1~ ;:;:.~.. .... . ..0 '!;1;'<t,l '~if;i", ;:: ,'.'J ...11: .;......_+"11, .'I:-';J'I.~I' . I~..' ...,,<ot:'\, "I.......~..; -;.r~..,.,!". ".:;:"':,.f.~ : '::'~f~ ... " ,', . JilH III ,if~! H. f It IH 1 i h 1111; H~ II I. 'f!~ U iil I · U nn] IJI l;.~i fiff H .Iun. j Ii ]&11.. I i HII '_I! '1-1 E; ~.ii,d .if.. dR Illf~ !u' d,S! ~ ';'f ~ ! 'JI.I}.! ~.J ..: ~dljll · iorio ili Ir.: E '5.111 a s.1 ,.!l ..!I(.::.. h.ft:- oil JU .~ ;;.'3; H -:n :.J!; i J ~_1f1 H. I U .1'1... 8 0../i.8..... .:.....; :41.1;1 l::;,Ii !Ei ,; !11~J;,h e "'!H-- :-;t.......~ !,l ", '..... .. 01 .. . ':;-:.'_' .~ } a ii!.e 1'-.."'5 ..~ Ii! ,. 1 a t'lJ '''f~ ~,." r :J1'.I! !'~lhU ~. ij! [ ~ I . J.J.i .N-', f .!hi:! !! '5,.D , J .1 ~ '5~ i jl-l;:.s U~r!i g J' hI ,'I 1 1 1 'I 'I . ,! - -;I .-1' e IE · 11 . D & J i i ,i ~: :2tlr~: H.lI'5o .1.1;111 ~1' I -! ~ li U _ H i i 6 r ti,i ~ i'l i ~ .1 H 1 <, ~ :!! ! j .d. ji~!jj !lr~.~ 5 Jlif IIi Hi u ; H h f! ii~fH ~I!~~.I ~ Jlh 1n d.. Ej", '" .:''''''';"..; I~i,l!~! ~"'f::,;..ol"; · ~ . 1==1 .., iii~ 11_ Il!'I'4 .t 'i.~ I !.."JJ...l u.!:i.j 8 ;sl" M Jli '1 I- if' = I I II <01 . H! 'f 11 11. · ~. .. ~, ill!' l!jJfe f ji u: Ii f 'H J d. l'{;j '1'.8'1 1,1 u.i ,.' IJS "II. d,l. \\.~h. i 'i 11:1. i! J; iliJ f i~.! tIll) ',JIJlI I I> ,i II ,II f It~f~ JI. E i 'If; flj~.!~ f Ih !J.~".I 11 l'lll~ rl. :1 ; .;li11';. ~. :..... .., , t! I!:. _ f.. .II:> ~ 'I .. 'I! I 1.!1,,"11""1 .1.J is ~i '" N ..;: ..1&;fl .. Ie 150=1... .. I .. ~ l;I :>! e U:U.il e ..i '!'-,..I~j-;..l~l(I~"" ~'-i-i~ 5.... I 'I~! 1-""- ; 1 ~ jll f ~:-f , . I . u .J t i Ill.' .J ..:f .I! ag.!.,-!,!Il.ta IG' ! : (:;!;'I; ~Jl I" {J~!~~, ~ !{~! if r f!.ij JI . ill!!1 ~Ij: ;g.i nli ~ f ~ i ~j{lf iiii U If I;; (I! j jl-lt 1!:~i;Hill~l{ 'Ft'~IU.IJ;Uji~t l~fH l.f'lJL f.IIE J '~ , I! IE.!.. l,lr.U I'll '" '" ~I 111i1 j . f 0115 '" '" i '" N"; I j .. III :J=llJi~.r a.!.. ! !s , . .. -- . . '. " , . . 1'*" U.. 1 .6i':' - .. 1II1'''. I . t i Ell'" : 1I1~' " . ' .1 !.. ..f j 1 . If. J ., .l'. h ilIa]. ~.' -:;. h~ J : . i i.~ t I . 'I '. .. ,t]J .1 J IJ .:1. Ii J L. ., 'fl I -r.. 11 .' a .lll i il.....j. .f Mte'. ':. J ft f 1'''1 < h f 1 t1ts' i .sa.." ~l. ... u ~ ill'~ I-i. I! i ~.. I .i" r . If,r. i I '! s I 1j " t.J i I . I f .. II.jr"lj:;'''~, '1 .c.::, sf J =1 I Ji~ 11'11 s .I I tjJl~~ .hi.! .:I.!-e.J to.. 'El"l i 11H i .11-11 e I u ;a :I ,; . 1. ; .u~ 'f.t!a..; I r l H h. _ f.. r" :I ! · "1' . .. -.~I..:,~.It\ '~~I ~ C. ~N",,,,.ol,' I....."" S - rr. :1. rt' of' I ~ c I .- 'i C - .. .. ~ .. i ,'.aa . .. 3 ~ ... 3, ::!l,I.l'~:i~ l.J.&.:\ ~ f it .l':t. .if!; "iI.i, ..! , , ;1" ;JE;!1 jln:l.'~rU; ~h .1 la :. 1]&1 :.at~ - .. ...~ f .... ~& v...1' P :I' II I j Jl!jifa :hj! fi ~H!!~.! j'ljlJ' .11 ~ t .:I!! e I -(flU .~~ .!i~l~lli !tl~i I!' r. , ! d! i I .j: III J ! i H !t~ ~h p _I" 1 ai I lj:tr.-.l'.': .~ii~" ,:iI ":!hf-jr-If I':ll~ j !:f d J1! iJf.i"~h -JOJl i H u.. hll s (!if t~i! J ij !!oil... aEe:; i.l~J1 ~.1 V.!!4,; .. l:. ., . '! ..: ... .. "I . I ..:... .-\ .... ...!!-- .. .-'---...-. -- -~.- --.- ,. t t I" jJ 1=) U lJ' i IE.:J III j1 I"]. Jt 1 i J : J i f ~flfll ih~ rsf.ii r' i I J I II tb:ll III' J · f If- I i il.lfifl:1h "Iii 'I.rl.~. ..1-. lit 't -II .IE 1:1 1 f..t ,...11 '1 i ~..I t 11!1 j!! i11-J! Hit itl. Jf ji if! fl JJ Ii ii eel..=: e Jl11 .JJl1iic._! ... J;:..au J;8. .D 01 trr1ti~.'-:f;1"tj';lftlill~ '!J: . '.. iS1~! i!IJfilhh".JUifll if!hff;i1 i] ~ f-~ i~~ IJ!! i HI ht~~jn i Ii lil 'p ~ f..h it . -i. r.l'i"Jll~ r -Ii ftlli ffi!4)i J!l.-ilil:!l!if)i!Ji 'law, ,1 & ,- J-IJJI.l'fllt',li~lI hit.lniljl) lHif ihi,nH~h ., ..... .. '..I! . ., . .. ~ , .... .1. . . .! .- u~ =~a' ~Si5 et )'{1! !1j~t s · tn I:li ,@..Il . !ii~i .t~ db ! Uh.. 1 1111 e!; t~~; . h!~; ~~ t Iii'} t liHi ljhj ~!il" ~a;d. I. ~0~~.:9:1t: ! ~ IlId~.~ t IU~i a tn., Ii ia"'t; ii~~;:=5~G1i:sh!la~o ~S~r>" A if I ~i.~:;~nU!i~~H~11 i ni1ih jiJ!ll~ 11:[ oj.. ."'....~eo ...~o ~ .8 11;p.!U Jr.!)1! B !. t!ll! , . .., .~ 'Ii:. :... ~ ~J;!h i5i5 JI Ed _I...... ::0 II {.II! . . .,.,. . .. .. .. - ..: ...1 ..: ..Ii . ~ fil<! S-i.! c:i~~ II 'l5 II E ~\:ISi~l ~ ts I.el.! j. :~i*:'II.Uilii~~q=;' 1 It l ~ ih~z;!t ~~11!-1, ail:ll Ii ~ lL~llL'-:~s~ I t i .! ~ ~i~a..i.! ~~~l!! d!~~lliHfl~~5! i..ld:;.! ~ !;~~~nu~~Jjh ~ d c;l!!I t HJ;~ ~;~:j!i 1 !h ~~ ! ~~~~ul~ 10! ~~~ 01 ~ ~ <.."__. li,-I:lQIl'IW-X ............ >........0.:0 l a",of.M> :1:1 i~i I: 11.a r ~;g~;!!!! U.;J ~ ~z~Ill~~ l~ ~~::Ii~Ji U ii.~ul=:: .o..ir:';:e=~ J:.It*COII.:JO'" 9c",,::.III. .:;) ,; . ~ ,; . ~ ..: ... .. -- -- , .- . -' . - , -- _. -. .---..... tit <i5> "''11:-11111.1 I U f " 1= i *1 .. I 4 it i:!~ :~ ~ ;.fJ4Uhi 'h nr l]Ji I) Ii I'i .I If .1II~2. ::_Jr>1~1JtJ:;);tl .1,< . !.I IS ..~.. I r - OX>-~'.. III" tl" r r. . ~ 1ft, I I il!rl~!!l J iMi'adlh~!~!IU:l tl.lll iii I tIt i!lai!: i'l5IU".11 I. .e1.'l5." 1.1 tl II t .1 i II ell 5'1 :~~z815 ~ ~ li~~lt~~:-lljF.~lIH~!i tl1 tt i.;l1 ! !] ;; . ::1<11I - · 0 f'i! otl'" Jl ....11 i h iii ~ IIi! C J 11.1 ::I . i:=:c:l~a ! ~~;S,tU I l'ii H?Cl n!~.. ~.g i.5 s .!f:j!: ~ .- f:r ~'En..;U~!~~ tt.Jt "U. 1 :~ ij ~4-~i! ... II .. <!IS 1'!lB~. 'lJ. f~' i:l !l i. 1'1. li 11 .Jall~. g~i g~~;,~:'lll .. iji r~. uH ~f[lin J ~ ;:I.i< .. ....po h.. itS I!]r> p d 'P E~-e 1'1 ,,3~~ 'i:~~'~SU'11:'- ~fi~ in Ilil ~'If=h -!j is ~~~. .'. :o!l~! ~hHt li~! iU si 1 ,r~ ill!.I! 1:1 ~i ~~~;~i~n!lSllld:f l'~.tl. It UII"'tJfitlt~l.! iu :1 !!:. ...oi:oI... :IJ 1l~ 11. h'l~ - :~ .. t! -' PI : ~ ... U II ... i. l!! -I F ~.,; , 1= 1.... ..: I'll . - 1.1 6 '15 61 : J n.!. H. f' · .. J ... t t .. .1 . 1J.aa.. I ;:; .I. tift .tll i . HJ .11 oW J . Ii d ~.. ~ I t I,'" I lJ 1'1 ... i I. R ~I tf' J JI'I EI' - : I 1.1\-1 .J I · : 1 .J".:l i.. .1 ! 11 ~ 6 r. ~. . 1.1 IL = ; 1 t I " n ~ H!!,i ~j, !J~d t ~ I;ml! !i! ! ,uh !H " ~ 11',,'1. i1......... '_hW .. . __ ..",~JI_.t-~. _"" Iii.! ,! .':.. .E'~ .gj6 -t 1 ':'..J. ,!.. {....il'l I!i-a ~ U.~ .:IL :.]5lI1,~ .tHxIJj'{ "H~. T.Il.:- ~U:l:.IU = Sli.!L I i .1 Af .n fo ..1 .11 th.i~; III I J e'.~l ~H !lj!tt.t.jli111il1 l=ia :.I1111{1 ilf~ H I 1!:,8 ('I I :I~S... il fll.l. 'B. .1. aJ JI' I t - r..l!.:t. 1 i. 1I... .e . 'I .J -.1- ., i J.a g s; .s-R s IE:: -i.a. .1 (L i -1111.p h1.,g.i il." 1.~.60 H ~ ihi~ ;iL.ll 1 :G'i~ 11~i "'11 ti ~ :!,~ i, H iin ltH In tll it ~dh~t~ n H t[ " 6"!.! I i ii. ,.~ ~!.C ~ ,; · oj"; , :I "".. n de .!p '";;', - . ... .,-..--. .-....-.-.- . - ... ..... ..'---. [;: 0" f , , 1"'11 I'll ~ tit [!t .1.1 H It1lil.! JIU i!~ ! jl;t~!U ': tlJ-i lEi Iii {lIlt Iln . i, J lin.. hJlirl~.J dft&!:!l i II! '1...11._ I l'1lte. .. . ~~..~ Ii hll 1.4. 01 -:5Sw ;....--::1tl"...-6 .. e ...... ......~. "a, l.~! tal' t.. .. . ~~ . 1= 11' ia~.) i1H h . ~~~ .' dllj:! If. " -I < f~ f!.:I1 B Jl1 . .. Jig! ul ~ l'i)Jj{! . pd~ II nni!~1 .... . . ". ., .;,.... ._.- . 11".1" ~" ,<< ill. 1 ~ '1 oi il tll !!:~ I: it{U t !irb/l 1:1 i "Iti il'~ t!'t!tl iij-t~ :]'"Jil~i .I]I!H Hr! lilt" "l"l U. ul i~' Ir'''.1 'lilt"; I"." {J11:!l :!lif'! ,,,U1.l1; l:Ig"ltl ~tll.Ri = .I "I I. 011 Ii I'" f f - :t 1".11. l;j:a . r I.. Ifl.'." !1~SII -.. I d ".il{l'.'llit 5!d~ilth :J IH.l!t d F..!: .. ht~ {l {I {~.1_11 i!~~~5l1~Jd,iJ Ii:~ lid t! Iii it ~ ; J ~t~. d ~h! hl !.!h:~ll J!~ iJH Joe !-!'l.j I !.P I ~ _lfi.; ~ II"; i:i::z:.,,-! .:IlI..U .}.i ~ !J,::J.~ ...a!...I.. -' .1 - =i I JfHi i ., &;1 ~, ..~ ..~ I;l ~1I . t lJi11i1 il':' ~ ;,.:;-1~. r ! ~ Ih Iii ! ~i H! ; IhIu:!:J 1 II ~ '!.! 11:.1 i 1\,1 ]"1 Ili . ..,... _.to l 1 1 .! I.IIl J! I. I .1 il .I 1 l ... - I! I .i - ! 2 I:.j~ 1:..10:1'" --I'll 111 ~1 1 i .- I 1 ~ " E h e h i.. ~ ~ ~ ~r,,!~i~i 'i:h11i.'.i1lJe> Hi Hi ,Hi HI:. i I; h...g ate f I' lit 1- .Ii ~ u I-!~ u I-!~ 01 r l" ~ ~ I]"! .; · it- H I - = I ~ I U i I iU I ~U I JJir 1 ~!; ---...... , ' . . li l 8 It I II' >: I " ~ 'S: " " .' ~ a po! I fJ J.!~ : J. :, ~ ~. ! : ". : ~ .:!! '. .:! ! ! .. ~ II ! J Eo . I . . :: I;; . ....- . IIlo)f.!,~' hi-I.I " ~. ,:" !!~..' ;1111 !tf( .1 ;I I 'I'I".'IJII.I~' [.~IJj-~JlJ t! H I iJ .. 4! 'I. I... .111 t 'I I C''I - . I I JII'i' & . !l....-!''I.E-d'" l"iJ:t...,ts 'l:- ".,!!; I i 1 hUla ~.h ill ~ . h "l1 ;!N ] - ~ _ H"; U 0.:\.1 I" ."1011501.11::1.. .. fA"l"J!"" ,..;i.. t..~1!' . , .,.. .~'ti .w~I!~ 'J 11 n ,I~I' ,.:'1. II' i 1 il. ~!j !~~H ~ Iliff ~~iJiH!1 IJ.II u...tC' ~ i. ~ .:, u. .!!I.l!~.h&! fa .. =, H,!!i:t:\ ... ~ .iF.H:i r.ili:..-!!'& U ] J!j U :oil ~ ! io1 ~E':1!~ l.hijU~" 11 1. J _.!~ :;iI],!! ~. ~I ~ I. ~! 56 ~I'ie.! ;~Hi"i~jH 'I U. i Ii I)!" 1 i.!i ;; - - I~ I~~n !~Hllt:it! 111 J "-I If)d. ~ I:.~ :' ~ U e~ iii!H-!4!=~ I " I 1.1 t!:.n E! N;:;J OJ ~ 109 .I.: d.; ':.":hh 1:1 I _ _ H ..; . U g;; .!:I~ b; Uh-iUJ.i .! .- - - il .j] ~ al,. f" II. II os it ." !il . fl. :P''8 J~ lid!!' 1 t = I) . . .JLUJ.ic S ft.; .. ,. " ,., . ..' 'B.P. .1...=1'.' ..::J.......:.;.;.r..;"",;a..:.....J._,,~... r.......k....':..:......c.. .......... If> . =- - '. , . I .u ..'8 it -a . II ~ :e Ii- .Ie >. !I:lf. I' ~ ~j :a: j1! II-!et ~li!lI . _ __. -;"':.=::-~ .~. r . - -- -' .-:-:';':":':-;."':1 I, .lir~11 a f' i U1' II'Ja: "tl..ll~j i I )1 II ~f 6:-=' i a~ ..~ 9 I t r p!i;h · ~j .It H I if!;! ;1;j;ll1:1 t jdUu f r. II! 11lil ill! J' J iI!! 'aUJI:iflt.ll.! 111111...11 ! I'I! i JiiHIl! I ~I ~ Ii !I~t: i :i!~ ~j I J Is :Ih " ~ll! '."!~' ~n "","!r6';'''111!ll~!~:t tt ;"1"'8 ~aIU'" ,.... . J ~ ~ICS!! "~t: ~ I! <..~ii~~~ 11 ~ i~ sg .~ I! B!::; ;~c < ~2li hi i~i:!~;c~st~~ 5 ~!l~ e~ a f ~oi5 c!E2l 0 zti w~-!I= h 1C5~~~ l-!J ~ t sl!as~~ H iii ml ii! Uiftim~~!Uji igim~IU J ~ ~ id~ ~;! i2l i:=a i~iflm;I~;giU~t;; ~~ !g~i~1 J Cl:: ~e:!!i 01 .... ~e li:d\j~l:.....hlt ~2l. . ~ j':~ ..: ... Pi ~ .' .-. -- - - - ,. J] . Jl:I"ll~ . .I~~ i. .. .,1 ~ll t ':;'I';~ s: I . i if, t J. . I' 1 . I-IJ IlltJ I rUt' .111 !II.~' J oJt!.i J1U.'f.lf)t f4t. };:! I t I. .1 . t ,tlt .I i i 1 i.:U .1 :U.I I, t i · I · 1 S I J ~ ~~~I [liE-B.j UH : hH! 'II! i;H;1 II.. ~ :i N j. ; .UI", :o,~.".S'~ IS!<8.,~":"''''. 1.a.I.~... .. -1...._~.. -h..lI . Co Cf iii I "..J ",.. ..- - ::11 Ii i ,.5 .&'1 I ':lll U~p H ii ~ j =1 . i ! . . I .;.J J !~ h'll .&':! . il 1 'a · t.f . h....!.. tiJl)': llJl5 '11 I] .' l'l f oil If II!k h:~Uji Ii ; Ii' i ft~ . Ii' 1 'I'll h~hH~hll~ Ur ll~ jlll~ 1 It.. U 1 i l~thI,11~l!'i l[ at-- 1 ,1 ]J t jlildtl] lit J n i ltH ~! ~hHhl hi ! {I] I t1, ..lu-I . I 'I! I:h:". .Ii .,u .eo! I '" .:-1'1 . wl -.i11!..:"';.. :. wl !!I": -.-- - .. ... ....-- . f l lUU " Ii * 'IIj 1 ;- '" U 01 f. f l .! 'a I ~! i 1 '1:t ~ 'J. 'I 'I l! if L,:t!ii ; 'fd Ilin f PI .~ I ~ I h1Ul;ft i ! ItJ i "'al~!11 f h(' ~ 11 .1 U ,I, t .. ~ i 1'1 1 .. 1'1 II t 't,rrIUd.ij i iii L~J!.llt I'd Ii HI ~i~l!,j!l!i!t I! ~'n!!: ~.. II ~i~l!I.. If-~l'n"ff~n-~~p~" ~e'~. ---f 'I'" j 11' ~ ~.p. .:~--- :I .. . ;11 ~a~ ~i=ffii ~:~ ~1 Ij.l l I i 'ISH a.. I ~~~~ ~t~~i5 ~~~ ..~ i1 f"8 Elf j h] E I: 1'1 .. < ~ ...::! < < :!:r::: ~... - -!l i JI II =- i .. t~ft~l~ ~~~; ~~"~5 ~~~ i Ii 1'I.!~~.1 =IIJ I~~ eI ?.I-.1 r 1:l...1::L'l :i"'~."'~ ...:;:!O ,. 'a .1 I! 'I-!l-!l e! 1 p '" I . ~ 0:> c >-.... o. ... 0 '" . .1.&''11 a. .. 5 r ill~fi' ~!;~~ ~~:J~og Otci!: i 'I H t1i1i:i' J~ l ~i . J II'Il '18ot.. E-OC~l2 E<e .. R Ii:' ;; II. ~I IIlit . i &i ,1; ~hi ~~~s;~~i~ ~ llUlf~ ~"~.1:& 1 ,~: .&'1 :!<t!Q "2cffig~ i5 ~o I . .. " II U I .,t'l11. II "'~~= i!:lI:~~~5 ai~!: 0 ..: .1 .....I.j!:...:riil..: .. ,J ~p:~jj1j l!j ..fPi i.l l~1fdr1r !11 fJJ,&1r I. lil fa I illf!f~ I. I' '1Ihi~lf 11 Ijl~ll1 it latlhf,liifllt fld.1! I jJ fhlmHu~,1 !lmu ~; 'I , . ., A. .~ ....J':.......... -...,w...-..:.a........"'........,..;... ,.... !:. . ! ~ 5tl;5!;!;!~~! ~~g . of" . O~i:t- O' 1=.. c _ , IE.;i!: c~li:l:' ~i!: .o:"lIl~~. ; ,'. : ~ i i ~Il;S> .. ZE '"'1=.. ., J ~ i.. ~~~~i:g: E b~l~ . J ~ -c iii z~:1e~ I .. -2"" f I~J I ~ ~8~=~~ .t:E~S~8~ t .I h J ~ ::i~..~:Ct:l ~ ..5.. ~ >- I I if! :> 8 ~E~~~: ~ ~;8 ~E~ '" i ~f ~ t i S~~i:5g::: =Sel e:~3~ ! 1 E ! ; ."E~~~~ i!: ~~~ chj s - ; .. ~5ilI=2..f e ,;.Ii ,: a Iii:.; " Ill: .- I. ......... .....__... ......_.. ".._. . . 0_. . ............:l4 . Uil' Ujf'n;n'f:;llf j ;I J ... f Iii 1.1 i. , .. ~.I'f 'J:! 51 fllf:t It.a J I "IJ .aJ I" I 1:t11 fl.,i! il'nf'll!! Iii! c] j- I:. t ill ,II~. , "!t . 1,""IIJ ~'ia.~i S """'J1.1.1j (If I 1~JJI' IU~~jjfi'Mmi!i !;f JHl1iJ';bdU 'I'~IIJ! I"J:1~.I' jf~I~lltllLJ .ftlah1fl ti:!h.!' !!,d . :la~f.tt,:uiH dd d.. A'I ol au: ,:: s;~::.. ... ~.. "" I j~!;'t'r~.ml!c'rlr.5 fif" 1ft-- ..1~f~11~11~]! . ~B. .~ hiI,; tJiHihf:; ik.f !!iPmu! It j jiS atl.~l"'I!.lH!Hi HiL h t!tJ!flf'f~ff h.-!'~fE 11 'Ii :tn.lH]"r;ofEift 1'IlIi-!lrSj..hl JiJ .,11 'fll'll-! f"i.pr J. rill.! f ,l!.....f=.. I ,t~ I dl.;t ~i -ol~~.lil ,~H! If h U L'.f J,;~i f,ilJllli! 1Il1.::5e 0"'1 r '.I",. !:lo!I:t::SS il.fi.'I 1lIhl" tofl .1 " ..il ;,; '. A: ~ :U I. " .r. oil ., .' f ...-- . .- . --- -~- .-....- .. ... i ... -lISt I :~ 'id P I I It. j"! ~"i IIJ q .e3 I!.J i[ IJ J If .~ :~ ejr.ilr. 1; I' ~: ef' "j ~I !UIU]i~~~Ji.: Ii ;;,] Ig ~Ii JiB!! if!~HH~! lit flh lit · HIt III in m~U 11fl!J ~fl i~~ i~-! t! !l"~ .i! 1 i j t.1 ~ i~~ ~~~ & ~ Ji i~! !~ }., }!~i: :Jl,J!1'o ;;:~ 1 ~~!i ~S~ :ecr. ~. A - -=-"-::.: ..: ...~I ~~~J"'~-"'~_I!."ii~.... ..f;~~i.:i5BI.1 ,.. I" ~ ~_ .- NJIl . .. U ,E H H i i 1 ~" I: , i: i .. 5' j t" .i it! ~ .I! &.! - _ U JI i.'I5 tJ r F.! - ,'e ,. I ' I'll.!.!" .' .lJl1 >8 r. & t'" .If "Ii,i.'" -l~ = i ..' .. .'1.. . ~lIli'l! .;1 ,.e 1 -!l~ " ,"J, r. i S ...r. ,!c.ll "11 ...' '..i...'.! 'I 5 l!!, CI l:t!il.j~i~U f: J '!i i ilHI ii I1:!j Hi ~~iJ i :11 I .il.~-c.a !.! I F'II.l- [.I. fl l=l Ul . l r . II ,- i.. I:; 1 .. .. I CI ~ 2jr ii-~1!l~ I ~ ~I lu i'l5,ip.-! J~i J! ..= HI.I I !' ~ ..... it l 0 ~ oS . .I '" (.I .J j ii . r -- LU{~ftfUl f ~ !, !~.:.'~Iit!1 if'" ~ ~ gjt! · .. ' . 'I! J J t r'15 r. u till . E.. 1I. a a, j H ~ ~ ~ = & ~ !. .I i I!. ..:.. . ..;.. , '& U . l!!~I'. , ~ \,lie; . =,li.ib 15.1 i --.- -- - .-.. -:-~: - .' . ]i::;I ~ lJlf ~lij5 t illt~ ,! rl". 1 ~;;! l'jlobf~.lt!~~lll!'li 1 i I~!J'} t · I j f' ~fi~~ 1 -I RJ~ I! I ~J.a I I 'd. tf:.:iiiithf'~ij Itt.h h i i Jill I I. J 11 ~ 1 ... ill I .J 1.. 1 ~ 'I 'II li,ll "i ~I had . ~b,U L!: Hh! d . '~'''''":'~~~-'''f."l~"''';M91:1!'fttUUt 1l!J1 'Ill 11'- ~ 1 . !fJ ~ d.! i,.to ,fhj..tof H'!! r. dlt i1.1- 'I.... I j~ ..,. sl-! l~ !; elll ':.=1 .1J1h~I~:.'! ii'~I! tj ~.JI t 1& .:=!>o.. 11;. r.!, a.;1i.l!. 1.1 Ie! I & . It' ~:lJ 1 :fil. e: c-: '~'15'. J~f C ]: II h'i ~f' !:' a .I e .i I - -1. BPi i....a I"'':. ; '-1' 0 ~! . &1:;; · Ji /1 tdi m!~ mltfffbmmu Un m '1 ~!~ jUH i~ 'Iii ~ lh f jihftit ~!fu i~fif if! !I! 'I5.u e.lpt! 8 I.e ih ...-.--.--..----. .U~I. ".;U ~il'~ j. ~iii~f ~i~1 f I ~ ih1i. !c:du-. iiai1. ~Ig~ ]:1 ~ . dllJ ~!~. ~~~ai. ~J!rJ~! iia~ ; ~ 8 e. ~~ttJ , f 12U~J J!;e ~ ~~ i e~g~ih ~t!~ J].I;! !l~.;.f ~ ~!~oo...! ~:I.ll. a j::!. , .II c c ~~i~lll ~5~ I~~I ~~.~ ~ ~e~~HI ~I~~~:!.!! ~~ ~ ' ;. . .. . :~r . .............a..,.,._......... - '-~""" ......._.. .. __... _ I.. ""''' I=- =- .I 'it , unj. H&~ ...... ..~g i: ;":!i' '~1R~tg.;;1!d If I ;i ~a~ ~l 1 .' ,.I &'d....", I .~'" II.J I CI S"'O f.l ~: ..';1'1:' ,1J~~; II ~t I i ~ iI i: d~9 1 -l i. 1,1.;. d It e . a 1 f ~~ D1.. a IUl m)(I[fJi ! hhH i! 3 ~ ~~d~ih III -1'. fl. I!. in :! 'll. f .!l I d 8 ~ ......l..j!;~ di!IJltf~n!Uj ftl~feiJJ !Jf t! !~~h~i! · " 'Ii.l' ... . . ..:I:, I · ll.j a '-l! ! III ~ -. .... >.- N.; I Ii .Ii! 1::1.<,; . , ~ II h; ..:... '" i j: ..: - ;:~ - . I t i 1 f ~!~ I' ~ : :,.,. ~ I I l i! f! . i I.' l Ii! .. I I,; :' -II' f ~., J. 1. J fl-... . . I 'I! .. "'.I'.. ".I .I If,.IJ. 't Jd IH ,... f~ &1...1.1'.....1 I t I ::~l .. J t" i' .. I ~ I B '1 .!. II f.!~ J i It It: J .';t).lJhi. HPfi'. ji!~" Ii ill f : I i.' 'U,= . .... to . .. h ' umt JfIi H,I f Hi~ II n!'~ it iff h~.! .....: ... .. ~... c 1 "'. ..... .,..........T.1TP"*.J"'PP-rn:s...lillt....'.'/Hll'.i.P,.. -l'* Ii ,_. ,.' , ' · i.' ., &..:,.' c: II.. t I! 'j.., j !l'1~ .. . f'" J. ..:s I J' i:! r. $Ill i' o!l 'I i -1 II l U Ii fi.j U H ~: f~! liftl U fi~li:i: Hi ii 11.a H j ~ u 1) ~ I~l!: ==;i\)~1 ~ 11' Ii! 1i J'I t JIJi f 1'. ;i j re ii 11 !;~ f~ir ( JS j!~iB~ H ill. I .1 ~ Iii'" f1!us ~g~ tll"! J; . .I' H Ji-E a Boll :t!h!ali,; E '~~e~~HllJ! 1~!dhlilh'hJ 4& 1=. .. ..,. ..1 <....11'I....,-1.. .... .. ~ j , ... .; ""1'1 ,. .. Ui i. H I' li 111 il,l .fU 1111 I h 1114J =1 1 .i ],.111 ,h ilf flil ~ i1 f'-frIJ-:j lh h,li JibfJf,}'.'Ji f~ilJ if I iqi ' 11 fill II 'ita... I""" t .. J~I'll'l l't'. .II f.t dfl.~~!,;i J f!il Bfa!) f.!liHU {.illlt i t~ j fk'lflf llH If,,, I" oj !'!!I.,j,,[.Ua:f 1 ".I1hlo"U f i~:!i~fi~ Hii!i.!~ li;l ~H JI ~.f ~j-J,)=lj !fti~fJ 'f'~JhEJ iJl' f Mi .. .,-1 lo~.t'. .!!~~lJ f Ith}"I!J flI_ll:! 1) IiI; Iltl,I~'5 Hf;~ r! !hl ~f ~f]- hill H! 111,=11- fh- - Ci_..G.H__ - l "i GJ!_.!.. E .. - " . oj. tII~.. .: of , I l!: C . ~!~., ': ' , I ~z 1 ,f' ! . '. , So .."... .. : ,... e, ..;.... . ' II '. 10' t ." j t, - - '. ' ,., fl ~ :~ ;.1 ..~; 7 :)= ~'. ~ :' sf, ,; . ~ ~ i. :: " . . ,: :8 i1;~!.' ;! . ~ ." .:: ~., ; .. :.: : ". . " .' a 'I! e: '1:1., l'l so" ~ ~ , . " : 1 'j'" i'" " 5'. , . .. . J Iii D t $ j J. !. ji ~ ". 'f; ;:..';) ., i " ~" . ."~ ..:. .... ~ . ,..f f . .-,. " .Irmlrl f~. ~1I "'~.:' '.:: ':.::' ~., . ! 'j. !:! 11 .; :." . ;: , "~4""f:lfi:'i'~~f r~ ~- ~.'...~_.a"';',_'.4""~":) ..... , . ,)k rJ .!u 'I~' t..', ; :: ',:", . iI fdo! ,- .... , :t..~!JI'i~fl~(li~;~~fil:::.~' r::~'( " : 'A.~1!~f~~{Ji i:,': ", . JJI~I ~J:i;lj~ il ' ., ,:.. a.... .t.. .. j..Ih r. {.i t,; , !..~.!~:!~:~~j!~~~~= ':,.., . , '" ' ;1\. ' .............. . ,.' : r d:.E "i -,' a ]t & f If ') 11 ~ JI~ - " .. :oj' - ~ n...,:l A :i ~ l.~ <J~ iw~sd of! '1;1 . 'I i..1 . ...a.!". I!" liS. lit-II :I j.I""~ ! i~J ijs.HJ ffljl'f I J!~ t..1 ~h Iffald.( ~ ~.I Hi ~JI \; !fu!'5'.11 si ~ .Jh df fil].!.!Ifil1hh:i!.' f.t; ~~ J~lj!!~E!~!fi~ll lIt ~ - I r ~-" .0 oj ~ I': i~! l:l .: .0 &U -- .. . ~ ... "....................................... -.... '.' ... . ..1 fluja~1j I I t I UtI "uuu.un': ......... ,~ ...iiit1ijt .ll~ .. I h.PI~tl !IJ;I~Jnfi!t~. !; Uli~~ '''11>>1 .. ~II h ' ,111111 uJ~~f.. hi{Jim.i!1 rHiUU.. ieqUM1il J Uilill1f:!'iJ. IJ{' if lifl, m!. UtII!I).tUU"i ::>.d a ~"'i. i!l .. ..... . <-hil,..l!lli .... .............. ~ .. ~ ;,....,~:,.~~,~1tfr"rlr.:;.i:.~l":~.~JHiI.~.. :,.,~. -',' . J!.J. 1 J -I 'i oil ! l .. i'" -I t II ~. a - I "f,," '. U iil ji i :ilf ~ it IH.~ Iii j t ~HiiH III ..11 a J i Ita J "fi In IIl!.J ~;J Jl'll rill J5'~llIril... .. ..~1 .. J!~ts_fhlo!il~ J I It I {.J t h .. j {.... ~.I i 1 i! I fi u i ': .I :> i t d ~U !1.. H. f"ll jiij i ~Hhh.IU !:r;thldll~t :cl~.. .Ii F :>.!!.G'I...Ii .l! be .. · ~'1111.l t 11 i I. 4! 1 It ] p ~ ~ ittl! ~ I 11. t I t1111! 1. e ! lU Jill" It III Ii! .. 414 I J It ! .I' I. I ~ i .ld I ...,a l~ 11 It ~ I ..t tlJ1 l..l.l' ..pI l II .. I J .. I.J" 'i'l-l'-Ufi'!"ljl~ 11 ! 1 J I ,1'11Ii11'1 dd i I I i ~ I II i i'MII)t I dlMl Jilj]~ I 11 it Ii I ~a~~I~i~;~ d~.~~ l~i I !!.U) I. I" ......... ..==!3 :! ~ II . -- - .. .... ... ;:U~;:UUUI so . ' . ".:;r.' " '. .' . . , : . . .,.:: . .. .. . :' " . ,.... ;.... . . , .!..' . , . , , .., '. ' Jot': . i ! I t' .,hr.-.' :".'.'1-=1- . ~ ~ .~ .-.l:" I, ft, .lAM!S fll!YNOlDI, .Ill. JOHN HAVAS IIICIW!L II, IADOWIHI ' lIm'H!N L. IIANKO, .Ill, IIOU' !. KIlOU. _ A. I<IKlNTlW. ~! lI.lIAI<I!A.STNlft J.lCQU!UNI! A. f!NSl!flMACH!R REYNOLDS & HAVAS A P.u_DMl.c:o..c.fDl AT1llIIN!Y8 ~ CouNll!lDRS AT IJ.w 101 PIN! llnu!1lT POST OfflC! Box 1132 HNuuBIIlllO, PeNNSYLVANIA 17108-0932 AUG (} e "19'" I;:; v J...-" T___. (711)'._ f.. (711)'_ August 7, 1995 !1y'.. ,., ~'...{Lw. ! . vlV '~- J Mr. Thomas E. Cheffins Court Administrator of Cumberland County Cumberland County Courthouse One Courthouse Square Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013-3387 Re: Baughman v. State Farm Docket No. 95 Civil 3843 R&H File No. 3142-1 Dear Mr. Cheffins: I am in receipt of the Court's Rule in the above- referenced matter. I have agreed to the appointment of Mr. Faller to act on my behalf in the above-referenced matter. Mr. Faller and Mr. Rector are in the process of appointing a neutral arbitrator. Accordingly, with the concurrence of Attorney Deitchman, as evidenced by her letter of July 28, 1995, a copy of which is attached hereto, the issues raised in the Petition are now moot and the Petition may be deemed withdrawn. Counsel for Mr. Baughman reserves the right, however, to renew his Petition in the event Mr. Faller and Mr. Rector are unable to select a neutral arbitrator. By copy of this letter, I am advising Attorney Deitchman and both arbitrators of this communication. SincerelY, /}~I/I;j~~ i Rolf . Kroll ./ REK/slb3 Enclosure cc: George B. Faller, Jr., Esquire Charles Rector, Esquire Jennifer C. Deitchman 'CeItlftod u. CM! Trlol_ by Iho __ _ oITrIoIlvNoucy A Ponnay\Ionlo lklp_ eo..t Accr_ Agency ~ ....-...