Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-03969 . TI Q ~i II "Q; ; 9.~ ~ I :g N ~ ~ i I , ~i ' ~~ I i~h ' I i I I P- I ;1 I ~ . ~i~ i S' II I ~ r ~ ~ "< I t. ,\ 1, i~ i ,- ;J ~ r J (! I \':"','li.1 , ,IH;'; 1ft ~ ! : ," n ~ {'Oil;'! \' 'in,. :It ''''';l'; :"" t!l"i ',l'.i) \' \fe. r ); '"*'! :ii;) ; \,.j t " ~',.,' t hi .,.,~ i Ii I ii y,'FIT .. 1<1 .' n h/ ii. , l,1 ~ . j \1 !l~>tn::.? f \':t I t ;;\i h ",f ,-,1' -1,ul j \-fC"T " j' 'Ull , I"~ !,:J,t~! HLiltl l'/;;;fi: l. t'r Ii;' in ~,u 1 .. th \ j _, ',,1 { r E klit' . ::In " J nF r<i\'/ " ,. ':!,ipV " > . ~. t i,._> \'~ j.; , , UI' nl\t1' - In. ; ~ Jt " , ; \ '- < r .1 I ~, "" I i II i f:\ 1 (,'l '.j, <7"'~., .~~ ;...:...':A....uI \ ;. 'i'- 'i. -." " ~:i ;i ,~/ .3 ,.wl <;)' Q<~J v..Jo' q'J ~ C. 71tde&..J I A1lp:, UNWOOI) II. 1'ltII.I.II'S. .1 R.llnd. EI)NA I.UCII.I.E 1'11I I. I.II'S , Plainliffs : IN TilE COllin OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA : CIVIL AC\'ION -LAW VS. RonERT I" (jRtER, IlIdl\'ldulIlI)' IIl1d. : NO, lJS-3l)()1) Civil Term lldlblll GRIER & ASSOCIATES Defendanl ~OI\U~LAIN,[ AND NOW. comes Linwood n. Phillips. Jr. UlIlI Edna Lucille Phillips. PlainlitTs. by and through Frey & Tiley A\lol1leys al Law and respectfully stutes as follows: I, Plainliffs are Linwood B. Phillips. Jr, and Edna Lucille Phillips. aduh individuals. husband and wife. residing al1)3 Eneks Mill Rmld. DickinsonliJ\vnship. Cumberland County. Pennsylvania, 2. Defendant is Roben L, Grier. an adult individual. residing al 624 West Old York Road. Dickinson Township. Cumberland Counly. Pennsylvania. 3. On or aboul June 15. II)I) I. Plainliffs and Defendant entered into a verbal agreement for Defendanllo perform cerlain work on land owned hy Plaintiffs, 4. Among the work to he performed was Ihe marking and slaking of 11101 previously surveyed and designaled as Lol No, II) on the Subdivision Plan for L, B, Phillips. reelll'ded in Cumberland COllnlY Plan Book 32. Pages 1)1) through I)I)C, A reduced copy of Page I)I)C of said subdivision plan is allached hereto and incorporated herein by reference as Exhibil "A". 5, Plainliff also made availahle 10 Defendant survey data which Plainliff had previously had performed for surrounding land of Plaintiff. Said survey data included boundaries common with Lol No. II). 6. Defendanl represenled himself and held himself out to Plainliffs 10 be a licensed land surveyor operating under Ihe business name of Grier and Associates and able to perfurmlhe work aeeufUlely and in a workmanlike manner. 7. Defendanl breached his verlmlagreemel1lwith PlaintitTs hy faiting 10 properly perform the work requesled. Defendant. in hreuch of his express representutions as 10 professional ubililies and in breuch of his implied wurrunty to performlhe wllI'k in u wurknlllnlike nlllnner. improperly. and with total disregurd tolhe dalamade uvailablc to him ul1ll10 licld dulll on Ihe property. murked the lot, fuiling to place stakes ullhe Lot corners hut insleUlI placing slakes so that it appeured thai a porlion of whal wus uctuully Lot III and Ihe lot known as the Richlallll School Lot were u part of lot 19, ll. Lot 19 \vus conveyed to Gregory J, Smith and Launl J. Smilh (hereinafter referred 10 as "Smiths") hy deed of Pluintiffs conlaining a special warnlllly of tille, Said deed was recorded in Cumhcrlund Counly Deed Book "V". Volume 35, Page 261. 9. Bused on the improper nmrking of the lot, Smiths hud conslructed on what they helieved to he their property, hut which was actuully olher property of Plaintiffs. a single family dwelling which was completed on or ahout June I, 1993, 10. Because the lot was not marked properly. Smiths caused their home to he constructed in such a manner that it encroached on huilding set back lines and was, therefore, in violation of ordinances of Dickinson Township and in violation of building and use restriclions imposed on lots in said subdivision. II. When the error was discovered and the dwelling was completed as aforesaid, Smiths demanded that Plaintiffs correct the error based on the speeial warranty of title to the land contained in the aforementioned deed, 12, Plaintiffs employed Statler & Brehm Surveyors to resurvey the lot and prepare a revised subdivision plan for the purpose of subdividing a lot from olher lands of Plaintiffs of sufficient size to convey to Smiths land necessary so that their new home would be in conformity with the applicable building and use restrictions and Township ordinances imposed on said lot. 13. Plaintiffs employed Dale E Shughart. Jr., Esquire to represent them in the resubdivision process. 14. Plaintiffs were successful in ohtaining approval for the Subdivision Plan from the Dickinson Township Planning Commission and Supervisors on or about January 16. 1995 and thereafter the Plan was recorded on January Ill, 1995 in Cumberland County Plan Book 72, Page 48. A reduced copy of the Subdivision Plan is allachcd hereto and incorpontted herein by reference as Exhihit "B", 15. On or ahout May 6. 1996, Plaintiffs conveyed the resubdivided lot addition to Smiths to correct the error of Delcndant. A Ime and correcl copy of the Deed refonnation agreement conveying said lots is alluched herelo und incorpllnlted herein by relcrence us Exhibit "C". DEED REFORMATION AGREEMENT f:NT/:'RIW INTO TillS fol/aay III' hlfLlKI996. II.;TWEEN I.IN\\'OOIlIl. l'III1.1.II'S, JR.. and E. LUCILLE PIIILLlPS. I;'-,U~~d and wife. of Dieki",on Tllwn,hip (lIIailillg oddress: 93 Enek, Mill Rood. Corli,le. Penll,)'lvanla 17(13). Cllmberland COOIII)'. Penn'ylvanio. hereinoner whether ,ingular or plural called "Phillip,". 1II1d GREGORY J. SMITH and I.,\URA J. SMITII, hu,hand an,l wife. of Dicklll,on Town,hip (moiling address: I()() Richland Road, Carli'le.Pen",)'lvolliil 17(13). Cumlle,lilnd Counly.Penn'ylvanio, herelllilner whelher ,illglllar or ploral called "Smith". WITNESSETH, Ihol in con,iderotion of Ihe lerlll' ond condillon, herein sel fOrlh. Phillips and Smilh agree os follows: I) Linwood n. Phillip'. Jr.. and E. LUelllePhilllp' do hereby gralll olld convey 10 Gregory J, Smllh alld Loura J. Smilh. Iheir heirs alld assign,. a, lenillll' by Ihc elllirely. AI.L THA T CERTAIN Irael of land ,iluale in Dlckln,on TOWII,hip, Cumberland Coomy. Pennsylvanio. numbered and de,cribed In accordance wilh Preliminlll)'lFinal Subdlvi,ion Plan of L, B, Phillips LOI Addilion prep....d by Sloller.Brehm Asso:iole" Inc,. daled Februory 14. 1996. llI1d recorded In Ibe he...inoner nBllled Recorde"s Office In Plan Book . Page . con,isting of Iwo pages. which Iwo pages are incorporaled herein by reference. os follows: BEGINNING ola poinl in Ihe origlllalcenlerlineof 33 fcel wide Township Road 1',465 known as Richland School Road. allhe dividing line belween LoIS No" 18 ond 19 n, ,hown on Final Pion of Subdivision for Linwood Phillip, recorded In Ihe herelnanernomed Recorder', Office in Pion Book 32. Page 99; Ihence from said polnl al Ihe Ploce of Beginning along Ihe dividing Une belween sold LOI No. 18 which is shown os LOl F on Ihe above.memloned Plan dOled February 14. 1996. and new Lot No. 19 which Is shown on said Plan daled February 14. 1996. Soulh 29 degrees 43 minules 24 seconds Eosl a dlSllll1ce of 638.80 reel 10 a poinlln line of new LOI No, 2 as shown on said Plan daled February 14. 1996; Ihence along Ihe dividing line belween new Lot No, 2 and new LOl No, 19 the foUowlng eight (8) COUrses and distance,: (I) Soulh 60 degrees 16 minule, 36 seeond, We't a di'lanceof 440.51 feel 10 a poim; (2) North 03 degree, 59 minules 38 seconds WeSl a di'lance of 479,82 feel 10 a polnl; (3) By a curve 10 U.. right hovinga radius of 270,00 reel an arc diSlanceof 69,21 feello 0 poinl; (4) By a curve 10 Ihe righl hoving a radius or 270,00 feet an arc diSlance of 7.57 feel; (5) By a curve 10 len having a radius of 330.00 reel an an: diSlance or 92,03 feel 10 0 poinl; (6) North 03 degrees 37 mlnules 04 seconds Wesl a diSlance or 54,53 feel 10 a polnl; (7) by a curve 10 Ihe righl having a radius of 25 feel an an: dislanceor 30,62 reel 10 a poinl on Ihe soulhern dedicaledrighl-of,way Une of Rlcldand Road. which soulhern dedicaled righl.or.woy line Is 25 feel from Ihe original cenlerUne of said Rlchland Road; and (8) Ibence in said Rlchland Rood. North 11 degrees 42 minules 42 seconds WeSl a dislance of 25,01 feel to a point in Ihe original cemerUnelhereof; thence by Ihe original centerlinethereor the following IWo (2) courses and dlSlances: (I) by curve to Ihe len having a radius of 400,00 feet an an: diSlance or 60,11 feel 10 a palm; ond (2) by a curve having a radlu, of 400,00 fccl an an: distance of 23,45 feel to a point atlhe Ploce of BEGINNING. THE ABOVE,described tracl of land i, all of new LOl No, 19 as shown on said Plan daled February 14, 1996. recorded os aroresaid, and conlalns an area or 4.096 acres. more or iess. llI1d has Ihe malling add...ss of 100 Rlchllll1d Road. Carli,le, Pennsyivania 17013. TilE ABOVE-described new LOI No, i9 include, LOI' No" 19 and I.D alld I.E ond 2,D os ,hown on ,aid Pion daled February 14. 1996. SO MUCH of the above-de,cribed lraCl of land as Ue, wllhin 25 feel of the original cenlerline or 33 reel wide Township Road 1'-465 known a, Rlchland School Road has been dedicaled as a portion of Ihe rlghl,of.way or ,aid road a' shown on ,aid Flllai Plan or Subdivl,lon ror Linwood Phillips recorded In Ihe herelnoflernamed Recorder's Omce In Plan Book 32. Page 99, and In Plan Book . Pa8e THE ABOVE-de,cribed new LOI No, 19 is conveyed loge liter wllh and ,ubjecllo public and privole rlghlS in tbe roodbed or Ihe 60 reel wide 'Irip of land abulllng Ihe above,de,cribed new LOI No, 19 on Ihe wesl, .ubJect 10 Ihe rlghl of Linwood B, Phillip" Jr,. and E, Lucille Phillips. husband ond wife, lheir heirs and assigns. 10 Use said 60 feel wide private right,of,way for UlC benenl of Ihemselves and of Ihe land, owned by Ihem abulling ,aid rlghl,of.way nnd 10 which ( ~uid righl.ufowu)' e~lcnd!lo and induulIlg thc rightll tn 1Il!rl,tall puhll( ilud Iltl\'illl' \\'illl'l MIPpl)' 11Ill'!lo, .anilar)' sewer lines. ilorm wuler !loewer lirlC!lo, cleCIril:lly hne!rl. leleplltJlll' Ianl'\, tdcviMunl.:llhle IInt.!l unll.uch olher public anti prlVale utility Iinc\nn, ovcr. under U1Hlllhnvl' Ihe 'lime, lugether wilh related upl'urulUli, unllto repuir aoll rrpluce Ihc !tIlIIU~ from time hJ limc, llnll in Utldilinn IlIl)' renin" huving the righllU me sul1l60 feel wille righl.ufowllY !lhlllluhll hllVC the righlln ucdlcl\lc the !loalllC tn puhlic U!lC os IlllUhlic tlJwlI!lhi(l nJUll hul MICh tlclIiclllil1n !lohlllllultllhlil!nlc IIny IlCr!loUll tn clHllrihule III Ihe cun!rttruclinn nr il11prm:clI\ent of !rIlIch 11 J1uhlk lll;hl ullle!lo' Ihe pl'rMIIt In he c1mrgell ,hilll nglec In wriling In Ihe '1lIne nr lInle" \llch dlllr}.:e \lIull hl' illl(ln!led hy gm'counenlul authority. 1'In: AIIOVt:,demibed Iraclof land is plIrlol II IlIrger ,,"cl ul land which plIullI. Woods and Elmo M. Wood.. hu.bond ond wife, by deed dilled AUiusl 27, 195K. IInd recorded AUiusl 27. 19'K. In Ihe ornce of Ihe Recorder of Deeds In and fur Cumherland Counly al Carlisle. Penn.ylvonio.ln Deed Book "Q". Volume 18. Paie 28. ironled ond conveyed 10 Llnwuod II. Phillips, Jr.. and E. Lucille Phillip.. husbond and wife. ond In addillon is pari of a larger Iroel of land which Oeorie II, Sluorl. elat.. by deed dOled March 3 I. 1955. and reclllded April 4. 195~. in ~Qld Recorllcr's Oml:C in Dcc:lI Uook "I", Volume Ill, P~'ge 199, grunted nnll conveyed In L. D. Phillip.. Jr.. and Edno Lucille Phillip.. ho,band and wife. and In addillon Indudcsa 1'011 lUll 01 Ihe land which Ihe Cumberlond CounlY Sheriff by deed recorded Oclober 5. 1959. In said Recorder', Office In Sherifrs Deed Book 6. Page 327. gmnled and conveyed 10 LiIlWOOlI B, Phillips and Edno Lucille Phillip.. husbl1l1d ond wife, I.. II. PJlII.L1PS. Jr.. ond Linwood B. Phillip.. Jr,. are une alld Ihe 'lime persun. U. Lucille Phillip, l1l1d Edno Lucille Phillips"", one ond Ihe same person. THE ABOVE-described Il'llct of ll1l1d Is Inlended 10 correcll1l1d refomllhe descriplion of Ihe propeny conveyed by Phillips 10 Smllh by deed daled AugU.1 , 1992. and recorded in sold Recorder'. Office in Deed Book "V". Volume 35. Page 261. THE ABOVE,described "ocl of lond I. conveyed under and subjecI. neverlhele".lo iI" followlni building re'lriellons shown on or sel fOrlh on Ihe above-menlloned Finol Plan of Subdivision for Linwood Phillip. recorded in 1'10" Book 32. Poge 99. and 10 Ihe building reslrlclions and condilions shown on Ihe above,menlioned Pion daled February 14. 1996. l1l1d inlended 10 be recorded In Ihe obove-menlioned Recorder's Office in Plan Buok . PlIge . and I. conveyed under and subject 10 ea.emenls. vi.lble or of rccord. and Ihe following building ond us< reslriction. whicb shall be binding upon Ihe obove-described II'llCI new LOI No, 19 only ond shllll nol be deemed binding on olher lond of L1nwooo B.phillip', Jr.. ond wife: I. Thlslract of ll1l1d sholl be used for resldenlinl purposes only, No business. commercial or Indumialus<s whalsoever sholl be pennined on Ihls tract of land. bUI his shall nol prohibit use of ony building. on Ihls tracl of ll1l1d for on office or a home occupalion, 2. Only one single-family residence and IIccc"ury huildings may he erecled nn Ihis Imcl oflond, 3. No livestock of ony kind. conle. .heep. hogs. goalS or horses and no poullry of l1l1Y kind. sholl be kept on this Il'llct of land. excepl household pel. which are housed In the principal dwelling house localed on Ihe within-described Iracl of land ond which pel. sholl nol be pennined 10 roam about out-of-doors unlenshed, 4. No breeding or \raining kennel. for dogs shall be kepi or moinlained upon this IraCI of lond. excepllng 0 dog which moy he a household pel which i. housed In Ihe principal dwelling house erecled on Ihe within-described Irael of land and which dog sholl nol be pennllled 10 roam oboUI oUI-of-doors unlenshed, I. No buildlni or any pOri or projeclion Ihereof shall be erecled or mainlalned within 25 feel of any side or rear properlY line, l> No willI of ony building shall be erecled nearerlhan 50 feel 10 Ihe legal righI-of-way line of any public slreel or road abuning Ihe wilhln-described Iracl of land, 7. No Iraller. mobile home or slmllor .Iruclure may be localed on Ihls Iracl of ll1l1d lemporarily or pennl1l1enlly. for l1l1Y u.e Whol.oever. excepl slorage of one reereallonlll vehicle, 8. No basemen I. lenl. shack. garDge. barn nr slnlclUre of 0 lemporary charncler shall be erecled on IhI. tract of land ond u.ed us 0 residence either lemporarlly or pennl1l1enlly, I). No advcrtising or display sign shall he erected 1Ir maintained un thi:\ trm:t uf laml other thun the customary "For Rcnt" und "Fur Sule" signs whcl1lhc Milne pertain tu the prclllhcl'l un which Ihey are I""aled, III Nuthing shall he done on this lut which ilia)' he 1Ir hecnmc un annu)'uncc m nuisancc tn Ihe neighborhood, and no unlicen,ed vehicle ,hall he kcplon Ihis Iraclof lan<lullle" 'lured ill,ide a building, II. The Wilhill.descrihed Iracl of lalld ,t,,,lIl101 he ,ul.livule<l. 12. All plans and speciOcations for any pruposcd building musl he ,uhmilled 10 Linwood 8, Phillips, lr.. or his nominee, ror appruval as In ,ile. slyle or urchilCClurennd male rials 10 be used, and no consutlction sball begin unlil approval has been given, which approval willuul be unreasonably withbeld and will be based in pan on Ihe conrormily ur any proposed building with Ihe size and style or existing buildings In Ihe urea. general charucleror Ihe area. and commonly accepted building slandards and practices. Approval or disapproval shall be given In writing within 30 days rrom Ihe dale or submission or plans, 2) Gregory l, Smith and Laura l, Smith. hosband and wife. do hereby granl alld convey and qUil,claim to Linwood 8, Phillips. lr., and E, Lucille Phillips. husband and wire. us lenants by the enlirely. any and olllnlerest which Gregory l, Smith and Laural. Smith or either or them may have In Ihe rollowing described lruel or land: ALL THAT CERTAIN UaCIOr landslluateln Dickinson Township. CumberlandCounly. Pennsylvania. numbered and described In ..eordanee with Preliminary/Final Subdivision Plan or L, B. Phillips LoI Addlllon prepared by Statler-Brehm Associates. Inc,. dated February 14. 1996, and inlended 10 be recorded In the hereinafter named Reeorder's Omeeln Plan Book . Poge ,consisting or two pages which are Ineorporaled herein by rererence. as rollows: BEGINNING at a point In Ihe original centerline or 33 reet wide Township Road T -465 known as Rlchland Road atlhe dividing line belween new Lot No.2 and new Lol No, 19; Ihenee along said dividing linelhe rollowlng eight (8) courses and distances: (I) SOUlh II degrees 42 mlnutes 42 seconds Enst a distance or 25,01 feet to a point on the soulhern line or Ihe dedicated right-or-way of said Riehland Road; (2) by a curve to thelen having a radius or 25,00 reetan are distance or 36,21 reet to 0 polnl: (3) South 03 degrees 37 minutes Q.I seconds East 0 distance or 54.S) reet to 0 poinl; (4) by 0 curve to Ihe IeI'I hovlng a rodius or 330,0 reel an ore distance or 57,02 reel 10 0 point: (5) II.ence slill by 0 curve 10 the IeI'I having 0 radius or 330,00 reeton are dlslanee or 35.Q1 reel 10 a poinl: (6) by 0 curve to Ihe len having a radius or 270.00 reeton are distance or 7,57 reel 10 a poinl: (7) by a curve to the len having a rodius or 270.00 reel an are distance or 69,21 reet to a polnl: and (8) Soulh 03 degrees 59 minutes 38 seconds East 0 distance or 479,82 reel 10 a point; thence along the soulhern line or said ncw Lot No, 19 und continuing aiong Ihe soulbem line or Pareel F and a ponion or Ihe soulhem line or Parcel G. Nonh 60 degrees 16 mlnules 36 seconds Enst 0 dislance 01'710,88 fecI to a point 01 comer orpurcell: thence oIong line of said Parcell and conlilluingolong line of Parcels l. K. L ond a ponlon orM, thefollowing two (2) courses and distances: (I) Soulh 54 degrees 01 IIllnute 50 seconds East a distance or 1960,01 feet to a poinl: and (2) Soulh 52 degrees 16 mlnules 50 seconds Easl a distance or 283,80 feet to 0 point al comer common 10 new Lot No, 2 ond Parcels M and N; Ihence alonll<llC dividing line between new Lot No, 2 and Parcel N. Ihe rollowing Ihree (3) courses and diSlances: (I) Soulh 46 degrees 52 minules 12 seconds West a distance or 717.75 feel; (2) Nurlh 47 degrees 07 mlnules 48 seconds West a distance or 165,00 reel; and (3) Soulh 49 degrees 52 mlnutes 12 seconds West a distance or 1275,45 reel 10 a polnlln line or Pun:el M: thence along the dividing line between said new Lol No, 2 and Parcel 0 and conllnulng alollg lille of Parcel A. Nonh 41 degrees 25 mlnutes 23 seconds Wesl a diSlance or 2174,70 reel to a poinl at comer common to new LoI No, 2 and Parcels A and 8: thence along the dividing line between new LoI No, 2 and Parcel B. Nonh 14 degrees 53 minutes 00 seconds Ensl a distance or 222,19 reet 10 a polnl aleomer common to new Lol No, I and new Lot No, 2 and Parcel B: Ihence along the dividing line between new Lot No, I and new Lol No, 2 the following eighl (8) courses and distances: (I) Nonh 60 degrees 16 minules 36 seconds East a distance or 593.84 reel 10 a polnl: (2) Nonh 03 degrees 59 minutes 38 seconds West a distance or 508,44 reel to a point: (3) Nonh 03 degrees 59 mlnules 38 seconds Wesl a distance or 40.60 reel to a polnl: (4) by a curve to lIle right having a radius or 330,00 reel on arc distance or 41.79 reet to a point: (5) s<lll by a curve 10 the righl having a radius or 330.00 reel an arc dlSlance or 52,41 reellO a polnl: (6) still by a curve 10 the lert having a radius of 270,00 reel an arc distance or 75,30 reet 10 a polnl: (7) North 03 degrees 37 mlnule. Q.I seconds West a dislanceor 54.29 reel 10 a point: and (8) Ihence by a curve 10 the lert having a radius or 25,00 reel an arc dlslance or 37.03 rcet to a polnl on thc southern .... - c\ 11: N I:'; t .. ~-'i ..::: u,~ " , .. L (1); . .' ~-.~ I.: i u.. .- }':.~ 9, C\ ~ " ~ "]' 1 II c I n l~ ~. 1-,) . }~;, . F -"J .. ,. o. , ,... < , I.J' (.) Z Q ~~ Q~.:5 z ..l~ ~ . ~- i<Z . r; ::IU ~?:JM! Q;~ ~:i eo ~ :>'" ~rol~: ..l ~<~ ~ ~cf E ~~RN ""!rI.lOl -olI ~ < 1=< ~~ Q ~., ..lW~ III Illllll~ o.l oIl~5~E -..l E-o~rol~ l:=- :> WW~ =- iUZXafm - - ~""ll. . llllllll ~ a: 1ii c U~ c"c"w a:O~~,g . ::I ..l Q Q >='~ =o.lll. = 0 u.~Jlog- . ~ U ~rI.lE-o Q~ o.l~ II) ;! ;<Z 8z !a rolOJ ~&1 Wi:: E-oo.lQ III OQ zll.~ o.l =z ... ~ d i . ,_d I I' I :::: i ,. . I . , , - . . ;~ , . :#j ! , r. I \;~~ \' ,...... .- .... , , ">- f'" " LY u: r~ .. ... (", :;-: ~,I .', l' p,- t .- ~.:-: !:i:- 'L l-~ 1" . .:>,- co .',~ (iV. ! ~i; ~. . \ I . m liE U'J \..1.1 ,11( I.' U. " 'I. t- =j U C1' U ffi ~ ~ 1 ~ ::I to-:.a:: . '( .. . . i = ~t;i': c ~ ~ ~ Clll: 0 ~ ~.... ~~c5~ c ... . .