The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About95-04276 ~ A . '" "7 i ~ ~ F j ~ r- C1S :t ~~. cf) IS) PYS510 1995-04276 Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Civil Case Inquiry OTTO JOHN ET AL (vs) SMITH EARL F II ET AL Page 1 Reference No..: Case Type.....: COMPLAINT JUdgment.l",,: .00 Judge Ass gned: BAYLEY EDGAR B Disposed Desc.: ------------ Case Comments ------------- Filed. . . . . . . .: Time......... : Execution Date Jury Trial.... Disposed Date. Higher Crt 1.: Higher Crt 2.: 8/09/1995 3:56 0/00/0000 0/00/0000 .......................................................**..............**....... General Index Attorney Info OTTO JOHN PLAINTIFF PRO SE 2720 SPRING ROAD CARLISLE PA 17013 OTTO CAROLYN PLAINTIFF PRO SE 2720 SPRING ROAD CARLISLE PA 17013 SMITH EARL F I I DEFENDANT GILROY HUBERT X CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY 240 CLEARWATER DRIVE CARLISLE PA 17013 KOCH E LEE DEFENDANT GILROY HUBERT X CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY 240 CLEARWATER DRIVE CARLISLE PA 17013 SLYDER JAMES DEFENDANT GILROY HUBERT X 508 CHESTNUT STREET MT HOLLY SPRINGS PA 17065 CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY DEFENDANT 240 CLEARWATER DR CARLISLE PA 17013 Judgment Index OTTO JOHN OTTO CAROLYN CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY Amount Date 2/27/1998 2/2711998 6/05/1998 Desc JUDGMENT ON ORDER JUDGMENT ON ORDER AWARD OF ARBITRATORS 300.00 .............................**..........................*.......*****.*...***.. * Date Entries * ..*******...********.****...***********...***....*.....****.....**.**........... 8/09/1995 8/25/1995 8/30/1995 9/01/1995 10/18/1995 8/13/1996 9/20/1996 9/24/1996 9/24/1996 9/24/1996 11/07/1996 - - - - - - - - - - - - - FIRST ENTRY - - - - - - - - - - - - - - COMPLAINT - CIVIL ACTION ------------------------------------------------------------------- PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS ------------------------------------------------------------------- SHERIFF'S RETURN (SERVED LEE KOCH - EARL F SMITH II 8/14/95; JAMES SLYDER 8/18195) SHERIFF'S COSTS $42.72 PO ATTORNEY ------------------------------------------------------------------- AMENDMENT TO COMPLAINT ------------------------------------------------------------------- SHERIFF'S RETURN (SERVED EARL F SMITH II 10/5/95-AMEND COMPLAINT) SHERIFF'S COSTS $22.80 PO PLFF ------------------------------------------------------------------- PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT BY JOHN OTTO PLAINTIFF ------------------------------------------------------------------- MOTION TO STRIKE CASE FROM ARGUMENT LIST ------------------------------------------------------------------- COURT ORDER - DATED 9/24/96 - IN RE MOTION TO STRIKE CASE FROM ARGUMENT LIST - CASE STRICKEN FROM 10/2/96 ARGUMENT COURT LIST - BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J - COPIES MAILED 9/24/96 ------------------------------------------------------------------- PRAECIPE REgUESTING CASE BE WITHDRAWN FROM ARGUMENT LIST ON 10/2/96 BY JOHN OTT ------------------------------------------------------------------- PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS BY JOHN OTTO ------------------------------------------------------------------- ORDER OF COURT 11/1/96 APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS BY HAROLD E PYS510 1995-04276 Cumberland County Prothonotary's Office Civil Case Inquiry OTTO JOHN ET AL (vS) SMITH EARL F II ET AL Page 2 8/09/1995 3:56 0/00/0000 0/00/0000 Reference No..: Case Type.....: COMPLAINT Judgment......: .00 Judge Assigned: BAYLEY EDGAR B Disposed Desc.: ------------ Case Comments ------------- Filed........ : Time......... : Execution Date Jury Trial.... Disposed Date. Higher Crt 1.: Higher Crt 2.: CHARLES SHIELDS ESQ, AND 11/18/1996 12/11/1996 12/ 18/1996 1/15/1997 1/23/1997 2/20/1997 3/11/1997 3/12/1997 3/24/1997 4/01/1997 4/29/1997 5/23/1997 6/11/1997 6/11/1997 10/29/1997 12/05/1997 2/10/1998 2/10/1998 2/27/1998 3/13/1998 3/18/1998 SHEELY P JUDGE MARLIN MCCALEB ESQ, MARY K KENNEDY ESQ ------------------------------------------------------------------- ANSWER TO COMPLAINT AND NEW MATTER BY HUBERT X GILROY ------------------------------------------------------------------- REQUEST FOR EXTENSION FOR TIME TO FILE ------------------------------------------------------------------- COURT ORDER - DATED 12/17/96 - IN RE REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE - PLAINTIFFS TO FILE A RESPONSIVE PLEADING TO NEW MATTER WITHIN 40 DAYS OF SERVICE - BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J - COPIES MAILED 12/18/96 ------------------------------------------------------------------- ORDER OF COURT - DATED 1/13/97 - BOARD OF ARBITRATIORS IS VACATED - BY HAROLD E SHEELY PJ - COPY MAILED 1/15/97 1/24/97 BILLED COUNTY FOR ARBITRATION CHAIRMAN ------------------------------------------------------------------- RESPONSES TO COMPLAINT ------------------------------------------------------------------- SUPPLEMENTAL ANSWER ------------------------------------------------------------------- MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS ------------------------------------------------------------------- PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS BY JOHN OTTO PRO SE ------------------------------------------------------------------- MOTION FOR DISMISSAL OF JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS ------------------------------------------------------------------- PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT BY HUBERT X GILROY ESQ DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS ------------------------------------------------------------------- ORDER OF COURT 4/25/97 APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS BY HAROLD E SHEELY P JUDGE JAMES BOGAR ESQ- MURREL WALTERS ESQ - ELIZABETH STONE ESQ ------------------------------------------------------------------- ORDER OF COURT 5/23/97 APPOINTMENT OF JAMES BOGAR ES8 IS VACATED MARLIN MCCALEB ESQ IS APPOINTED HAROLD E SHEELY P J DGE COPY MAILED 5/27/97 ------------------------------------------------------------------- PETITION TO VACATE ARBITRATOR APPOINTMENT ------------------------------------------------------------------- COURT ORDER - DATED 6/11/97 - IN RE PETITION TO VACATE ARBITRATOR'S APPOINTMENT - APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS IS VACATED - BY HAROLD E SHEELY PJ - COPIES MAILED 6/11/97 6/18/97 BILLED COUNTY FOR ARBITRATION CHAIRMAN ------------------------------------------------------------------- PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT BY JOHN OTTO PLFF LAWN AND PLANT DAMAGE TO PLAINTIFFS PERSONAL PROPERTY ------------------------------------------------------------------- PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT BY HUBERT X GILROY ESQ MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS FILED BY DEFENDANTS ------------------------------------------------------------------- OPINION AND ORDER OF COURT - DATED 2/9/98 - IN RE MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS - MOTION OF EARL F SMITH II - E LEE KOCH- AND JAMES SLYDER FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS IS GRANTED - PLAINTIFFS CLAIMS AGAINST THESE THREE DEFENDANTS IS DISMISSED - THE MOTION OF THE CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS IS DENIED - BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J - COPIES MAILED 2/10/98 ------------------------------------------------------------------- CORRECTION OF COURT RECORDS - PLAINTIFFS BRIEF CONCERNING THE DATE THAT CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY TERMINATED THEIR SEWER/WATER CONNECTION VIS-A-VIS PLAINTIFFS LAWN ------------------------------------------------------------------- PRAECIPE FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT IN FAVOR OF EARL F SMITH II - E LEE KOCH AND JAMES SLYDER AND AGAINST JOHN OTTO & CAROLYN OTTO ORDER DATED FEBRUARY 9, 1998 ------------------------------------------------------------------- PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS BY JOHN OTTO ------------------------------------------------------------------- ORDER OF COURT 3/17/98 APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS BY GEORGE E PYS510 1995-04276 Cumberland county Prothonotary's Office Civil Case Inquiry OTTO JOHN ET AL (vs) SMITH EARL F II ET AL 3 Page 8/09/1995 3:56 0/00/0000 0/00/0000 Reference No..: Case Type.....: COMPLAINT Judgment......: .00 Judge Assigned: BAYLEY EDGAR B Disposed Desc.: ------------ Case Comments ------------- Filed........: Time......... : Execution Date Jury Trial.... Disposed Date. Higher Crt I.: Hiqher Crt 2.: STEWART ESO - ROBERT KLINE 6/05/1998 6/30/1998 12/14/1998 12/17/1998 HOFFER P JUDGE ARBITRATORS ARE RICHARD ESO AND JAMES C9MITALE ESO NOTICE MAILED 3 18/98 ------------------------------------------------------------------- AWARD OF ARBITRATORS IN FAVOR OF THE PLAINTIFFS AND AGAINST THE DEFENDANT CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY IN THE AMOUNT OF $300.00 NOTICE MAILED NOTE: CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY ADDED AS DEFENDANT SEPTEMBER 1, 1995 6726/98 BILLED COUNTY FOR ARBITRATORS ..------------------------------------------------------------------ NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM AWARD OF ARBITRATORS BY JOHN OTTO AND CAROLYN OTTO ------------------------------------------------------------------- PETITION ------------------------------------------------------------------- ORDER OF COURT - DATED 12/17/98 - BENCH TRIAL 2/25/99 CR 2 - BY EDGAR B BAYLEY J - COPIES MAILED 12/18/98 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - LAST ENTRY - - - - - - - - - - - - - - .**.*.........**.......***.**............................*.**....*.**.*...***... * Escrow Information * · Fees & Debits Bea Bal Pvmts/Adi End Ba1 · **.**...***.**.....**....**.....,.**..**..*****.,............................... COMPLAINT TAX ON CMPLT SETTLEMENT JCP FEE APPT OF ARBITRA APPT OF ARBITRA JDMT APPT OF ARBITRA APPEAL ARBITRAT 35.00 35.00 .50 .50 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 15.00 15.00 15.00 15.00 9.00 9.00 15.00 15.00 290.00 290.00 ------------------------ 389.50 389.50 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 .00 ------------ .00 ***..*.***********.**.**....*.....*.*.***..****.********..******..*.....*....*.* · End of Case Information · .........*.................................................*..**...*............ ~ .,.,. ."." ~, .....,- on '" '''? - "- ,'" r, . . . . "to . "" . " ~ , ",'"..,,,.,,..,,,,<.,,,., JtF:1 j C:TTC It,! TI'ir C'>:-'~';,,~r:'~ -lr: '~~.-Il l'i" r'L_[{1~:' . CAF'ClL (N QTTJ iJF :Ut'tFC::f~t r:irtD CC:Ut~T'~ FFlll'E:-\'~')tl.~l,', : le'j ';i --""1 '".," .... :le"" r (JI'~ L.f:,l< I. "J!~ , 4-27(, .- T I) r TEFr"'1 E~Rl. F. SMTT~~ II an:J E, LEE l'OC'1 3r"j ]("1f'1E~ SL ','DEF,: ~lnd CARLISLE SUBURBAN ';'_!TH:'Jr..1T'I' DeTendc'1.nt';'; i-JOTICE 'TOL'. h.:.i\/i.:. t.>2\?n 5uc.d in c.C:J\...:r~:.. ~ t ':-'0; -"': .::,h te, CC !l-"':l,C ;:\'~,-;tnst -t.he cl ai.-ns ..;;at fer t~~; If': U-;(--, t(]: ~ .J""J~,'l'~j ;::C::tges, ~'~U mu::.t. t~,i-e actiol, \..it~-lln ~...)e,:t~! ~':,:,) (~J)'~, ~;ftet'"' p~ tc::tdil1gs and >lot~c,=, :"~'-::; '.=~r"~'r::d, -fi1 ing li. ..lI-tf.::.nq ~'jlt~~ t.:.~-\e CCLwt YOll;" de;enc~s cr ob:~~~~ons t= th~ ~~~lms ~et {ar.th ~galn=t IOu. 'fOL\ ,:~,r'L' ~'klrr.ed that :.. '.~'CL\ .o.-,.i.' tc ".,-;~>.J ~..:-;;;.: ,><:-,~-:' '1);';")1 P!';')(",,...:.::"c v..; i tl'l:::)') I: 7"0'-, .f:-\'"ld 1..,;~Ji.'i;!i .r,t /r")',, t.e: 12ntE'rf:-:-: 2,'-;;1':' 1 rj5l~ Y'Jl..', tIe the r:CJ.~\r..4: \,'1\ U\(),_,f;, '1:'_lf,t.l;;,:'r :~':,!...; ~'(Jf' ~~rl:/ ;flanel c1311TIE,rj 11" t~l[: t:;: ~~~i\~~rl'~n:' 'It ....:,y i",ll: Ltt'i,':" .,::-'i::'<1.1: D't ,';.:.-110t t-eq'_\r~s:'.:?d ,::./ tho:;: ;~'l,'.\.inti;f;:, ~':JU ,1,7,,- ':c ,-iiCjr',,;.',. iJf jJt~c~erl' ,Jr- :::..t!-,et~ f'igr,:E, :m;:\or.l::..:.,-,L l.~('_ ~ :,_L, l'Cjtl :'"HC;q_!:: ~f:"~ [: 7H~':? ~tirC':':: ....~i ,~.,..... !.l"ll--;\'FF' ;:.- C:f,;CE. 'fDU r.Q IE'';" fir,'v'!? {, LJ',vl'([T, 0" ::r."I~':n ;,r;:','l[,:, ,J' i:, r,::, ~O Dc' TELEC::~jonE -:-~Jr;: ,i!='cTrE ~:F.-:- '"'-""Jr,TI.J -:-,r-:',_':!;'f 71J ~:"lr; (": 'T ~lJHERE YOU .~ i. , CAI~ GET L_EG~L hCLF . !:'>mt ,}-' i .'~ '~' I ~ft:CI,Cs.!L~1 KIm C, GUY.', :',olary Public Carlisle BolO. CL,'berland Countv lAy Commlsslcn Ew,res No., 10, 1~07 .-', ...,:" P\."t'V'CI)t,,;;; .-f7::vr.~lOtN,' C::;ur~~~ (:;diTll 1,,' ,,\ L'. >=,.':":,..JrU"i ':"'\ Co.x :-: ~ .. I - ~ ~ T~j Urj:"iC::I; /) r/ Ii (\ fro , il\..,,(l \.l \':l ) --...."--,...-.. ...._..-......... .. (~~! ~~~/.rJ~fi}t= 'y .. }OHj~ [;7TJ CAF,OLiN OTTO I I; THe C:~J'_!F;- Jr CO!'il-1:J! ~ r'Lr::ti~:, (10. CUMBEFLAND COUNTY, FENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ~CTIOf~ l.~W F'1aintlf-ts v. I'JD . C I '.'Ii. TEF:11 ~L '-'-'-- EA~L F. SI1ITI~ 11 and: E. LEE r;OCH and J;.';!1ES SL YDER ,jnd C~RLISLE SUBURBAN ,..UTHORITY Defendantr: AMENDMENT TO COMF~AINT 1. !=" ai.....t i1-f,::: are JOHf'l OTTO -:~n(l i--::r,F'CJL /"J '""IT""r'~. ..J' ':..1. 1<.:-;' 'J 1 ()g :Jeen marr"ied Since Feb''"'Li21t''';l 6, 194: f)nd he.vln~ 11'ved ~r. 't1leil~ sl~gle family home at :7:1~ Spring RQdd, Carl isle, Cumberland County, Penn5~'1\:~ni2 17()lJ'-'C7/.!8 sincE QctDb~r IG82; do COMPLAIN ~or BREACH OF CONTRACT. De~~rldant EARL =. S~'[~:.! :1, wt\r: I ':~ie CHt;Int-!i~N [1f the C')I-1~::;~~- 5uhLw'bt.1,n {H.tthct'it\ vJ:~_r', ..;t: l.." ;~.' ..~q' C':e~~'-~.;,i:;l~:SW Dr..vi? C1r>::l r'::~)lder,ce ,;~t 1:=,.::1] c:::,rt :nq ~:c.Jd, C;"~'1; :-.' L', Penn3\'1vaG~; 17'~':~. ])e'{.,-::..nd':\ilt E. LEE \-'D:_~i': :. ':~-r-;' " '~';-' "',"-,'- ~" ; ':' f ~. 1- OJl', I' Carll ~,l e ::llDI.~;-~:'::',c, ....!yt:" ~~ . -. , " " ('J, .... ','j." : . .'-~ . .. 4 rlf:: t" C?n(j <\r~ t Ji:tt-1~.':; !:;~_ yri[.-r. Hhe: - , t.!; l' ,\.:-1 '. ~ 1~ ~ i (, CONTf;';iC Tor. for-' :':.-.\[-.1 i::, 1 f? ;L'bur-t':lil ,'jutr,(.Jl l~: '., .11'10 i'~E.' -, 1 dr.:'~:' ,c'\ t- 5',:12 Cj,c~'>tnut: .;tr.,,~\:.t, '''',e'lt;',! H,: 1(" r',}!- " ""'-' 171>:(i. - :,>:~ ( ~.... d i.n: C':IF,'L! SLE SL;F;uh:r;f~1L {,ifr H;:-+: J "'r" ',' ~'. ~ ;: 1-', \.,' f f i ,--: E"o a'.:. ::4,) C1e,-,r~..,ater' ~)!"'lve::, CJr-l i:,l";~. F'(lnn:-,/1 ,.:\r',l,~1 i7()~:::-;. t, On .1'.\1,.; ',.1, t 'is;_, ;::. l~~t 1', L '. ~~ .; '., (. ell" .~r, LeJr i::' . (':C ~1_ t cd.:\ C .::1-, -+: r-;' ,'~ t. ~'. 1 ".!-+, ~. \', L- ::~F~L. J ,:",:.[ ;:,UE; n:r. :;ii:l~" ,.,'., ,.' - ~~ ..' , '_~ i? f ':-C:- the f.ur-'pe's,': c-t 1 ;:,yir,;] .;:\nd r:nnr.c.ct In'-J ,-,",;~'j ::-,:'-'.'Jer A, ~... ;. t :' ~ lnes ts the e;':lc;t:n~ m~ :on':. 0.. F~ - " ,~ ; ,c<'.,,; 'i r , ; J l 'I ~, , . ~orJ:me~ di~ rl,~t S~V2 tee 301 "'.~, ;d t<:.l: 1.,:;\, ,'c \,'\;:1 e; c~;,,'.('.:,t:t;.-:'L' i~fCi'bl~i~ (~c\jT,,:)gE\C: F-'; (:."\,~nt 'j.; i t, -: ,-;:":1- t"JC' ;::,., 1 '''::':'hi,:O'/ :<.n,::.; cJec. t. C;'-,;:'-: 1 ,~,., j; :.,,(1 i="J: <' "c,"::..:' c:ontl",~ct '::1(0" "':,j\( {)t 'i'~ 1,'--" ,. ; I;~ bl"E'ac:hcd '.' " - , _<.i,' ,-" "j ::::~ :;E'.::.r 's' c~ ':! ,,;1 _,0 " ,:,,-, i': Ll :", ,"j ,:,.+:: t ;",__ ~; l' ";:0, .. '7 ::~ t, (:1.\ L " ~... ".,~ , '--i. "'_: , . ':'i -,' .-.j I:; ;'<::In'::,:')', "':'1"1,' ..' r' . j l2 ~ ,.. ..r:.: !' );""" ',' i .)(' !.. .:n!. ;',:n 1; g '-':]Cl'~;. ,~;ll.~i);ie::' ai-,C' ~'-IE-F..ds=. F'hDt l~'Y ,<pl~ c,,'" ~ ~.!c d ~ I L .:,.,rid , ~t :::."" ....~'~:=.\d ':;lr,:-;wth a.r-e 3t hibit IIi' .. c:.- PhCtOg~3~hs a~ r'lai~tlffs yard be+clt- i;';.(~ ,,,f tel'" l.n':jf.:.:.;,t t-?';L/~.-,~t~on ,;',~i~ d rJt',)fe':l;~ion'~1.1 ;ilnd~",c.,1::)j ~l~,.'\r, rrC'l," ~_IP fC:l\.tnd 3t ::':~hJ'lt "D." ! \~. . F1Gintlifs r"opeated 2t:t(lir,~'~-: ,~ r.?'\ctl ~r~ ~r:'~2b'e settlement. ral-' dd.ll\;~ge':; 'tIlth df.'!f()nd"OiT~t~:; f~1.iled ['t=;.fend.Jnt'; of;e'~ o-f t 15(~.('(' v~as dl~:l j~-d;:'~. p,'it't :Ci.,: d.f"! ~Ir':c'r' [:'1 ~int.i-ff~;> Aight ~,ie.:H" ':)1 d i::1 ,].r', ~:j w~_)rc' c~ ;!np;-;"'u>-.! f--:, ;,:..r-,... i: d tl.'ki/-?'U" 01 rj pl~nt~ 2','~il,;.lj1e i"; :..~r'i 1'::",':' -~!-;.~., '':'E-1'1'' ~,- -{\:" ~", thiH"! t: .('1). E::hiblt !lr.::1I ClJnte~lli~: curre,::::,p':Jr,d(~r,ce c:unCFH~nlng ttH~ above i:-\nd sL\bs>:~'1'.'e;->.t :;.c,..,' ~ L';i'L'nt " ;(~':. , , 'T:"I\;" ~t~'':,''i';:~. C'/;r.,t:'f.i....1 Ct-; r,-. ;-)< ), ~ r ~ ;,-l_ ;-, t:. ; :~ J') "Ci t;.~e c;:J(lrtr' :'U',C: ~: h 0 i : -J t ~., 1_ . .' ,. .J'~: t '.; tt'l<;:;\ ..--' .. '-. ~, , r..t"erl';' . " r! ~ .'~ ; (. ~ ;, ; ': I-I,':. , , :'-'\'112": ;31 O;~fi':'f .-,:;p.:x c, ,; ,~-, I.. , ' "',-" "I; [' : ~1 ) t. ...,' ,~ . , , Ciulntlff-;:; CIVIL CJi"lr-Lr',I~~T ';i.ctlon ,'1:;:..,.i:~I,..t flpfc'11CJ \1'lt- [tc<1 ('~: I'J~).: C,-I-'28J'-9S. \'Jt..s;; he2<r"d on ]u1 r' i1"l, 199~. ,:c<;',:J i.n~'" dl'::"3ml is(~cl wltl-lout pt""Ju.l~c-:e. . -, j.,,;;. Afnendment tc Plairltif(~ rCMF'lAINT filed t h,,~ ,-'::ur::~ Gr- COl"1MOQ F'LF.A'; Or- C:Ur1FFT::"'{~h:D COUL17Y ~ PE!'H-J';YL"''/(il'JIr~, CIVIL A[Tr~~j -- LAW, tl 95-477b, CIVIL T[R~l. 1:1 . .....l-le :1t:.H\'t -::ittL~llpt:: '::] ',:t,'t 1 ;'.:' :hi:.. d..i~'.tf~t-' in ,~ :\ :," ~'~nd E'qL~i'::i:~l:"t:' lO/n:"\er' t-'I<-h'E' nlf:~ ~'H~~'. "~'::"J c',. l:'. WH[::nEFORE, F'! air", f.:. i + i::: :-'"t'qUi2'.:' L j '.,d-:'Ji.;;'men. ~,i~4d t, j t Defen~ant~ in the anlour1t G: t. f~', ,') p .\:". ;,.',i,d f,';: driveway damage, arid t~,\)O(I.1:j(:~ ;01" cnn~cauerltL~' JI~ln~iJ~ I3nd cc-':..wt co'~t~. ]1~"I',n Gttc: ~ ---'(( ({II (-"E7i:' _. -.------..-...------..---. · /f. . _ ---..~~L~r~-._(rri~_-- C;II.D~' 'r, 'Jt --:"',', r-'..,' [.:..r~ i. c:: 1 '.:.'. -: ~':?' '-'j.' f,:,r,r-, -.l'.', '-~(;~~I I<Im C, Guy",,: ,'Idry Public Carlisle 8oro, C,.,' "Ollond Counlv My Commission l:'"oo Nov. 10, ,P07 .,.:.P,'f'\fiolifV,. I-"-::;~'k:'-' .):.::, ,f-i ,"'" I ~ -, j' t '. I' t :t',f". ~ l- ':..:; .\; i(: ,. ,r" -;' -j ,-j' t,'::" i. ~, {, ';'1":; ,I_ ',7 .T; '~.j2 " ;:~".i .'. oJ t'~f.~.':':_'j!l'_ [ '.,,/.' co, ; t '-~, ~ >'.'I\,t:r. t. ., __.1 ~ ":", l.J[ '.I.,ljr,:'t-. :.:'..:<,i,rj :--:er-";l i i: ..'r _ n.:..'J"" . _ :J ~1 ':-'. 1.., : ; ~ ; :', ~ pf~rl<" 1 t J;';':;. Ci-f ~ E: r c.<. ::.:;. H.19(J.; i-'.l -'~.. i-:'~! ~ '. ;-;)1 1-;1.::~,,!_'~crol ~.C;C.T tr;cw'~l :E'". L.' -:~ -:'_ '.! : ,- . '-, y~ ~ / StfHI5" ~' Ii //~ ..~.. ~.C. <-.,~~ ' L( (t1l= ~-,..4~cdt/.'.L.([ttO-- "~CI3C 4rf-\ Kim C. Guyer, t:el.ry Public CMlale eoro, Ct.trborlond CounlX My Commission Eyc.ro~ Nov. 10. 1 ,_ ~7 . ~-. :~r.Per.r:s-Jt": 1.~:i~:<"'13tonclr~,-;,.- ~. . . . COPt UBBD or BASJDIZIIT, JUmrr-or-Hll!' AJDJ JUmn! or mrrKr .IlOR.BBIIZlIT THIS AGREBHENT made this (6"\ day of ~ ' 1991, between JOHN OT1'O and CAIlOLYN OT1'O (Grantors) and CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY, A Pennsylvania Hunicipal Authority with offices at 240 Clearwater Drive, Carlisle, Pennsylvania, (Grantee). . WHEREAS, Grantors are owners in Fee Simple of a certain tract of land situate in North Hiddleton Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, more particularly described in Deed recorded in the Recorder of Deeds Office in and for Cumberland County in Deed Book X, Vol. 29, Page 899. HYEREAS, Grantee has undertaken the construction of a building sewer/sewer lateral in order to connect the property of Hichael J. Rotz and Linda K. Rotz which is immediately to the East of Grantors' property across Pennsylvania Route 34; and WHEREAS, in connection with said construction, it is necessary for Grantors to convey to Carlisle Suburban Authority a Deed of Easement and Right-of-Way in order for the mentioned building sewer/sewer lateral to be connected to the existing sewer main of Carlisle Suburban Authority which is located on Grantors' property; and Wi/EREAS, Grantors are willing to convey said right-of-way, with the understanding that Grantors assurne no obligation for maintenance of the mentioned building sewer/sewer lateral. WITNESSETH, that in consideration of the payment of ONE DOLLAR ($l.OO), the said Grantors do hereby grant and convey to the Grantee, its successors and assigns, forever, a permanent easement and a free, uninterrupted and unobstructed right-of-way along the route designated and hereinafter described in the attached Exhibit "A", for tlle purposes of laying, installing, constructing, operating, replacing, renewing, enlarging, repairing and maintaining said building sewer/sewer lateral line and its accessories and appurtenances, together with all tIle rights of ingress, egress and regress in, to, over, upon, through and along said premises, necessary for full and complete use by the said Grantee, its ,-~.. ...;;", successors and assigns, oE the said easement and right-of-way and for the exercise oE said rights and privileges to lay, install, construct, operate, replace, renew, enlarge, repair and maintain said sewer line and its accessories and appurtenances, to keep the surface and subsurface oE the said easement and right-of-way cleared oE all timber, trees, roots, brush and other obstructions and to install and maintain gates and/or stiles in any fences ~rossing the said easement and right-of-way area. Grantors are conveying a permanent uninterrupted and unobstruc~ r>> 20 foot right-of-way and cr3nt&Ee-e~e-eeftveylng-e-eemp~e~~ ~. loot; CJ_stiEueti461l Pig-lit "t ljAJ ill th~ l"J.Yl"~d~~erl'gomrt"'Zlv cO Grantors do not assume any liability for repair or maiJi~~ance of 'i 1-S the building sewer/sewer lateral in question. ~The Grantee, in connection with the exercise of any of the rights and privileges herein granted, shall restore the surface of the ~ said premises of Grantors, as nearly as practical to its contour ~~. and condition as existed prior to the exercise of said rights ana ..a "privileges) u.> I1H",l NIV~~ .bfJY.s f){' 'le:111ll/WA17oAl 0(: 6'tU{ OCCV3WCE',Y); The terms "Grantors" and "Grantee" shall include the parties~~ t hereby, their resp~ctive heirs, executors, administrators, ~~~ successors and ass~gns. IN liB'NESS WHEREBY, the parties hereto have hereunto said their hands and seals the day and year first written above. ,/ f./J .-,-f111iJ'--'--- -y t...LA^-. ,llJl OHN 01'TO ,'\1'TEST: CARLISLE SUBURDAN AUTHORITY (v!.4'~~(,{(- I~w~tary By: _~~Q...-..), <;:".:J?- ChllJ.rmlln ON 'rHIS, the 10th , 1991, before me, Iog't,ed officer, itV"\iJaIi1r.Oee6rm::::~ ,;.''" ' 81m ~d tIIlt (dr sat s actor y proven), to e t e person/persons who name subscribed to the within instrument, and acknowledged the foregoing deed to be their act and deed, and desired the same to be recorded as such. WITNESS my hand and seal, the day and year aforesaid. 1101 ^RIAl SMl COIISUflO M. ROSllO, lIol'ry Public , Bo,o 01 C..II,t.. Cumb.rllnd Counly. Pa. I My Commlulon bplr.. Oclober 5. 1992 -('-~ Notary Public HY COHHISSION EXPIRES: I do hereby certify that the complete address of the within named Grantee is 240 Clearwater Drive, Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013. 'TONAl o 1II1"IND UIOtIOWlD.. 'x;;:::;"~~:;': '. 'I.! '1: ~'.' ".; .'....,J..~, ~, r--- "', , , . .:" ----.~ ,,;:,.~ " ' '\"'~ ' ~ ,; J : .-,' .:. " . -; ~; .4 '30 ,." 'f , , -. t . ,..'. ,. ,'J .- . -.!_--:...:.'. , ..j . " , :"v, '- ' .W:...... ;...", _. .J l I, i. ~', . ...' .\ ..' ...: I~~ .. '--.' .01 .' , (." . " ,r . -, ":' . . \ . i' ,'}~'. . .,t('" IJ ' '~' .J;:" I" ... , . ,'~" , .. - . .:/ ~lrJ : , I I , , ,..-.- III: I ;1 "._~ 'I -~: I ,.. .- ~( \ ,,) i:'::\ · $..',", "' '.. . -":':;';', \, ~ .:" ~ " ~ , ... " ... ) -, ,--:. '\ .. ."". I '~, i -:-,;,~ '....~.:.:....~ -.:. , ',' . I"'. . ' , ,.. . .' ..:.......,. . . .... y ..' a- p ~ .... ,.\ ,1._. / . ..~- '.', 'j.-. ";" \' '. \ . - " , ,;.,::;'" -' . I 'r< . <I) ~, "I, ':1. ,.. ,. . ,~ ' \ Michael Rotz 2731 Spring Rd. Carlisle, Pa 17013 September 16, 1991 Mr. E. F. Smith II ('Ch, CSA 1843 Spring Rd. Carlisle, PA 17013 Dear Mr. Smith, j' ',I t. " i Enclosed is the estimate for damages to the property of Mr. John otto, 2720 Spring Rd. These damages were incurred by Jim Slyder Excavating of Mt. Holly SlWings, while excavating for public water and sewer hookup. Carlisle Suburban Authority contracted Mr. Slyder for this work, therefore we are forewarding . estimates for the following reasons. ! " " 1. Our agreement specifies pestoration of excavated site and had excavation been handled properly topsoil would have been available from dig site. 2. Our agreement does not specify responsibility for destruction of personal property; said garden and driveway damage. , ,We hope this will be reconciled in a satisfactory manner for our neighbors, Mr. and Mrs. John otto. Sincerely, ~~ Michael Rotz " .. t " , " ! "" ~770 Spring ROAd CArl 1~1~, rn 1701~ Up!:..mh!?,. 31, 1991 110"",,,-1: Y. Iill,'''y n~ I r". ""y "I 1 "'" 11 U']t'~h 11,,,,,,,,,.,. !lh.....1: "", 111'11'. ,.,(\ 1701:1 R~II Ur :7.21091, Rot: IOHo connecl:lon 1.,.,Ar' 110'. 13lll'oy. , hAd hl"p"," ~ hll~, t h", dllmll9l? to my rro"I: y"rrl 'nr.u,.r..d by I:hl? CIl,'1 1..1.. C;',""r'hM' ""I1",,'Il:y "nd I:hah' r.onl:o."..:I:or .JAm".. 1,1. 'l1,1i..". F"rll""ll,,';l ,-r"Il" hAVP t,,'r.n "",II:lpd In fI re"sonflhl". qrsllQ t h II;? 1~..tI er)l.l.;\h 1 t-" 11\::\IlI1'lr. mo"f:hq At'I". 1 "ld r,',l c.,,,,,,,, I,h'I' lll,pl'?flnfl"t slll'Attoll tn p.s!:alflte to 1 h... n"""I"i I I I:v ~,r rn, h",,1"9 to ....el. 1 "'J"I ""n"~5ent:atlo". 11,,- ~H .pr "~t f.'rd In ~('~ I.'m"lr.,cI"t:p. t.he not~r; t"r-:'ClUl:'!;t. for' the '!":('1"lnt" f:f1fU,t"ICf:t'll1 (.,," I.",n t.r?l'SOIlr;. If: "'~15 ~1,r.'I' neighborly 'h'nn t,. ".. "'," I..., II"'!'!" Ihp. l"upp.rlelltlpnt C', Ihp Car'l Isl e 1-/"1:..,. ""l:hrwlt:y. tlo'. 1:. LeO! I':ock, p.::plalnp.d the process. Il",~,,, Iwlp Ahe'lll ICII" 11'1,1 by rour Ip,'" ~'c'llld be dug to the ""Ill:h ", l:hl" en""..,: I: 1"9 watel' and "p.wer ma Ins. Further, th..t th~ lanrl wOlllrf hI? properly restored. We !lccepted all 01 'his In good Iillth. , "m IIn..hl", It< ACCP.nt !l"y I:op !loll from CSA unless It Is "",'r-..,,~,""d I" ""'Itl",, 1-1,11.. free 01 ~1P.!?rln, "'....,t s!?eds, -'.""~-=. '-'" I,~ :nul 'l':I.:llt::-. Thp one de-l tvprF'd lonrl C\r csn IItop "'It'" r"r1l1~,,11l,,"1 "'I ", t:hn Itbovn. YOLl Itr", Invited 1:0 view e,,",~ t" tI.,. h ':I"~ ynt'''. 1 tlr. ,,,,I: ,,,t'?IId ~"hp. hltmboo~lp.d. CS"'~ p,"oponp.d settlement Ir; h,...!'h ,,,.., I.II:hl1',o': rn...,'II:. Slne"',.,p'v ,~ t. &:, 0"" 1'10' 't'l!' Pr'l~ V" II". lIr.lI.""rl "'1:''1''. I:h. 11111, Suprv 110 , r:. r, t:nol t. 10 J J. , I.. Cr." Sup,.. v .utCM.. Th f1 ' (ll.,.,t..t.JAAC1.M I - CSAIl f ~c.e (..,. 11M.~JU.ZU-t b.-"", 7' ~ ~dCk$ ~ ~b 7..~~V! ~ ~fug ~ ~ ,A:_~~1 ~ Ylto :1-lJlce 1/-1> ~l~~ 'h(.' ~1,e'7 .eTtL., 2..?-Ocr'1/ <.J'- 1=' I L- l2. ~pr ;-7:(1 E.p'- i ng r.:o;ld Cill'l i '. 1 e, r',. 17(,13 /'Apri 1 ~e,' 1992' ~1r'. Hl.bert t. Gi 1 ro,' ",t tOI-ne y-..t -LElI. .., IkU'"f.:.1I Ifilnc,.'et4 Sb~eet Carl ;.1., r~ 17018 [Ie...' 11. Ih.tbe,-t X. Gil,-o)', lharll: ~c.u for' )'c>ur' lettf!'r of f'ebrua,"y 7, 1';>92. It h~;, be':~n m}' sincet"e hopo the-t the incident cc:..r,cE?,"'ning (1',-1 islE' ~:uburbM' Authcwit)"s d"mllge to my f"ont )'a"c1 could have been settled in a fair and equitRble manner months ago. ",I though 1 arprE'ci"tpc1 c.Srl'S "tt"ml,1 tu pic-h'p somc' E,to""',,. 511,,1 e "n~ ~lher matter fo,'eign to top !'>oi 1 , the effort WtlS feeble and totally inadequ"le. 1'1'. Hubert X. Gilroy, in OIccord"nce ,.jil:h the itemi:ed eEli n.,.lpd cost m" i 1 ed to 111". E. r. Snoi th II, or, S~'ptl?mlll?" Ih,19;1 1 will ~~cept pRyment of II~b7.19 to restore my )'ard to its full beEluty prior to CSA's excavlItion. In conclll.'1fi::"., I I.ish to advise you that, to date, 1 hllve ne.t sC!ught the adviCE' of legal cOllsul. Should an eqL.itable I'g"eement not be re"chec1 in due time. it is my intent ior-, tt: plll'HIE this R.E\tle,' to itE, fullE,!:t exlent in the COLII-tE. In"smuch liE our fron( y"rd hlls been the subject of c~ntid~.Jr~bl(? emb~t-r?'E:'Enlcnt to m,. ftamil.., it-on, r,.iE.'f1,:'r i,!rld neigLbc"E al H:e, and be,,:ClLlse of the ino,'din;..le "mDunt of time "nd effol t expN.dE'd in b,-inging tld;: mater to Cln end, I do n~t fgel th~t it can be settled in Sm~11 Cl~im~ Court. Sinc(;.r G.I, John Otto cc lite Rot:s ~~. E. F. Smith, II, Ch, CSA ~1r. H. E<eal', eh, IJI'I TOl~NSHIf" JOHN H, BROUJOS HUBERT X. CILROY CHRISTOPHER C, HOUSTON BROUJOS. GILROY 8 HOUSTON. P. C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW . NOR.TH HANOVER. STR.EET CARLISLE, PENNSYLVANIA 17013 717'241'457.- NON. TOLL FOA. HAJUU,SIUkC AJUA: 717'7015-18&0 ,', fAX: 2.u.aa21 Hay 7, 1992 Hr. and Hrs. Hichael J. Rotz 2731 Spring Road Carlisle PA 17013 Dear Folks: As you know, our office is solicitor for Carlisle Suburban Authority and we have been in contact with Hr. John Otto with respect to the allegations he has made concerning the installation of the sewer line. Enclosed for your information is a copy of Hr. Otto's most recent correspondence in which he suggests he is seeking $1,467.19 to restore his yard "to its full beauty prior to CSA's excavation". It is the position of CSA that the excavation work done on the Otto property was properly performed and, at most, there lIIay have been some minor damage to a few plants and some minor damage to the driveway area. Pursuant to the Easement Agreement that you signed with CSA in connection with this project, you assumed the obligation to "restore any disrupted areas" on the Otto property as a result of the work performed. Accordingly, .should Hr. Otto feel it appropriate to commence any litigation against CSA relative to the allegations of failure to make appropriate restoration, CSA would be obliged to join you as a additional defendant and suggest that it is your responsibility to pay any monies owed for restoration. At this point, CSA is interested in resolving the case, but is not about to succumb to what we believe to be unreasonable demands on the part of Hr. Otto. In an effort to settle the matter in a prompt fashion, CSA will pay $300.00 to Hr. Otto in return for a release. Since we anticipate that Hr. Otto will also be seeking additional work with respect to restoration, we suggest that you review this matter and contact me yourself or through your attorney in order that we might discuss a joint proposal to Hr. Otto to finally resolv~ this matter. . . ' , .. . , . " Hr. and Hrs. Miohael J. Rotz Hay 7, 1992 I will look forward to hearing from you or your attorney in this matter. -2- cr Enol. (1) oc: E. Lee Kocll/CSA Earl F. Smith, Jr./CSA sfifer2f. y /JJe.Fx. ( 11 ., . , ... ~' '?:r~ ' "'II' ", ......;- -,-,.", '~,.;h""-,, COMMONW[ALttt or PENNSYLVANIA Or-riCE or ^noRNEY GENERAL IIAnnlSDunc, PA, 17120 , .. Iftl.. nooll "'"",,,,,ntnn, .O"#lont. 1I11."nl"'"\I"".I'A ""n (11')1'"-'1''' f:Rt":!'of 0 Pnr:^'t. In June 17, 1993 ,,"OIlNt_ orHrflAI Public Protection Division 14th Floor Strawberry Square Harrisburg, P1\ 17120 (717) 787-9716 Mr. and Mrs. John Otto 2720 Spring Road Carlisle, PA 17013 Dear Mr. and Mrs. Otto: This is to acknowledge receipt of your correspondence to the Attorney General regarding your complaint against the carlisle suburban 1\uthority. I can certainly understand why the damage to your property that was allegedly caused by the CSA. Many people complain about what they believe to be unreasonable actions or activities of authorities. Unfortunately, there is no body that regulates the rates or activities of authorities other than the Authority Board of Directors itself. State law permits authorities to establish their own rates, rules for service or procedures. 1\ customer has only a few alternatives when it com~s to protesting those charges. First, a customer has the right to file suit in Common Pleas Court to receive compensation for damage done. That, of course, requires a lawyer and resources. The only other alternative is to protest the actions to the elected officials who aoooint the members of the authority. While authority members are appointed, the people who assign them those positions are not. They may be sensitive to your concerns. , " ,- , ., Mr. and Mrs. John Otto Page Two I am sorry that we could not be of further assistance. If you would like to discuss this matter in more detail please feel free to contact me. Sincerely, \\~)J.J (t&}) ) Daniel Clea tield Executive De uty Attorney General PPD930099 tr/,ul!Otto19 . . , . ., I,', " f '.""1 " .., T.,/.," I I 1'~ j', I I "t "r '.....,..'1 ,I ".,f I i.'l:l' ." '/l! 1""'\11..,"",,1 I II"" i ;-.f"" ""'11 r' t 'RIll I .. "-",; . :! -", 11- -.,. ",I- 1- ,'-' , I itC--. r'-,c-.:I \f~1 ., 1 r 'j ", \' "', . (r ~IJd ill I I" j;"I '"1' II ~ .,. ,~,,' iI ~ r, I I ",. 1" t d I ,-,' I';" "(","" i ,b',! , pro~I:?~~ll:'ln II 1:".1'1'11, , .. , '1'" ~ .." .~ ~ :"':'" '" .., II"'''' ", "f "= ~n ~ IJnl/:? r. ! I"~' I I ; ._, ",'It ,I'offl"""""' c', ,- ".'~P,t (C-?A) Il,,, 1'1 j,'1 I ','" II" i .-'Ilb....' 1'1,- 'I' " ,I '.', " , .' ...~, ' ,,1-,; I ,,,, '\ 'O-'llt..,-.-I i II'~ 1'/"11~ . '-',. r." I . -. ~. ; , \.",1,_., ." , ~, "'."1:''''''', ,....,,,....-,1 ., I' d ,-, I ." I> 4 . II ~,r , I,.... ~ I , r,' :: rf I""' r', "" l- ,~" _.... I ~ "111 1:- 1- ...' 1 f1l ':" I ('.rl Ittl ""1' .f, .~., I " .. II,,, I.....p ,- !I/' ;'j ,- " "r 111, C.SA ~"Jp~r" i , ~~r Voch '1" "i~l .... ,~., ." t I ....... I 1 I ~ " , I" ~t~r:f " , " "'1, r,.1 , " , " . ~ I I" ,..' "'1' .; ,.1, " ..(trot .' (':', CSfl. " .-" ", , " II, :,; I" '.' ", "..," 'I "'1 !- 'I,; ,'t'. i , J'.'~' . , \ .; :'" I ,~_,I ,. C~A" _ I , ,~, ", ,,' " '~'" d. ,.1 1-.,. j" II.., I .~, .. ' j,..11,-._.... j',-, II' .~"I,.~: :<"r'r~ .,,-, r,l ".ill: ......~. ,_.".... ',.1 .",' fl" "I "''''1'.,., I.. ,-.( (,-, tl.r:. lit ""~ t. '),'HI "n ,-t 1,,~\I.1 ..,.., fJl?'.'l?r ~ff"r o!od. II, fH I -tt.l I.f. 1" '-'0\'- i,1 II '.,1.'....., -I rt..,,..,..~I.f,d ""'"""'''.r.1 t-n ~'I~" . ',r~ j'll. ,.\.. I ,., .. 1 ..,:- r: ll't-~ r'r,"!'::" ','" (i,,,," 'd r.rr "~.~ ip'~i'=:1fljfil~;:1nf' ,.,pd rJi,f "",-:"i,h~, -I';-:Ql ...~ ~'I~ fP-I'r"'~ l""":"";,"I~~ \1, .d,.....~;.,,' ,-or glJilt by CSA. I, , .,.. r~''-'II. 7' r" ... ,.... 1 II ( .. t"lT I"~"" jl,;,,.' '.1', "11" l.....:-i lol-'~ ".1; f 1.1' , II,'" 'r'\~ r-:,' rr"'I' -. ':'II' I.. ~'fn('l' "' '. ., .., I.:"'" ,_r."I,., !"",- ~':~'~'lll. 11- h,-.'" ~If:-,=", ':-b,-. :,;1',; -~.r1 1'_~':_11 e,l --:-"",11,-1 -in.; 1'1'. tr r ....':In:-.n' ':'If.'' j' I,I~ n'J~ct thL I ,,~ , ~I,'. 1'" ., It "I ~ ',r--",l"-l 1 ~\-'''I ,,~,..w, 111r;d t.... t..~p, "I,., 1'r::1 I':~ f 1.'1'. hr:>1 I'," '-ll 'n'~'1 ~ " '.... . .. ,~ "," I t:. ;, f1' I,? ~. I \ ~, l- r- ;., t~ I ' .~II 1"" 'npr;'1 ,. !l'1- ~;~~''"'t-. "'11 l""",I--t'~I,I':," i'l r'l,,:,,"'i".:'Ili'~I;. {,l--':-r'I'Ir:"'. '~"""'fl,....,~l ~~... b,"',- '.It-,~ it. EmEl_ck: 0.( f"'~IJd. 'I., I ;'''''\ 'l"'-d f..l, "'~I.-~"""-'" '~l '-1...~,.1.. inll (~Q!'in~t poor gO""l?rnml?n~:' ,'",,, - i '..-'"' l''' I I'l' r- i I 'l.f.~"'" /5/,,, ,,' ,. II f'," '1 IS t,'ll' ill I...... ,'. ,~, ,.. t I I I,,", ,::-l' ~: - \....., ';:r .^ , ~ ~ ~ ~ \ ~(" ~ 0l-~ -..' V -z '..;,. -, c-", '''''''''; '-' ' ~ ~ ~, ." .J '~ '-' ,,' .::t -- "----; -J ,; C\~ "'~ . . , . .. .... .' . \~ ~ \ ~ .--.....:. --- '\, I...,.., l<> (\" "'\ ~ ""- -.....!. '--...;':t' t:j --...!... 1'\\ r0 ...,. ';'j., r\........ \ "~ ,..,4,11, . .. '.. . . .JOHN OTTe CAROLYN OTTO IN THE COURT CF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERL~ND COUNT~. PENNS','L VAt J! A CIVIL ACT!ON - lAW PI aintiftg 'I. NO. 95- 4 1- 7r; t" T t I'" _.. t..L- ..=F,~1 EARL F. SMITH II and E. LEE f,:OCH and .JAt1SS SL '([1ER , Deiendants NOTICE You h~ve b~en 51J~d in Court. If you wi~~ ._ c~~~nc against tn2 claims set forth in the fol1owi~; ~n;~s~ ~cu must tai'e ~ction withln t~Jent). <:0) days ~~~~,- =~~nc:I~~s an~ NotIce are 5er~edt fll ing in writing with ~Me :=~lr~ Jour defensEs or objectlons to the claims set io!~~h 295~~S~ you. You ar~ warned tha~ i~ you fall to do 50 thE ~~$2 ~lLI procee~ without you and a judgement may be e~ter-~d 2~~~~~~ you be the Court without further notice for ~n', mc~ev claimed in the pleadin?s CI~ ,for any other c1~:~ ~~ ~s~ i~~ requested by the ~laintiff5. Yeu may lose mcn~v cr =rccer~! or ether right5 important to you. 'fOU SHOLlLD T.~fE THIS FAFER ,,:} ,(OUR ~_..,:.n;::= ;'7 ,-n,::::. ,- '(OU DO I>lOT HAVE A LAW'iER Of': U;M;CT HFFOr.,Li 01';:::. <:u 7C: :;: TELEPHONE THE OFF::E SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND CL- WHE;:::: ~:W CAN GE7 LEGAL HELP. Cou~t Administrator FOl\l'th Floo,- Cun~erland County Courthouse Carlis:E, Pcnrls~'lvania 1701~ Telephone: (717) 240 6~OO Tci"hr10t t 0--------.- Carc.l yr.-'Q-;::-;--------- 272(1 SprIng r,o~c, Ci\l~l iSle, r:..;r,r,~..1...,f':.,:.-- t7C1: Telephcne: ('II'll 2.137525 . JOhl\j DTTC CARCH_ '1 N 0 TTO II, TI if: CDUf; r JI' CO"1I'IDI': F'LE;,'o, or CUI1BCFLt,tm C,OlJl'JTl, F'ENtlc)'iL'JMi J i\ C 1\/1:. (1::~TI0rl Lt4!,' F'1ttint.lit~. ...... l-lL:. 17''3 .~ l"IV1L TEP!'~ EAF,L F. 3111TH I I ""',j: E. LEE I:OG~ "nd Jf::,!"1ES SL Y [IEF: [Ie-ft:.ndantc COMF'Li') I nr 1. F'l':\1nt iff; :Ire JOHi'J OTTO anrj C~IFOL'T'N OTTO. "\e\\I inq been jll;::\r~r:eU ~.ln:::i? Febt~ltar".., 6, lq~l':~ ,?<_n;-~ tla\.'lll"; 1 iv{!"d in theit- ~c.;ingl (! f::iinll',i hCJ1li~= ..:.\t :-:;:0 Sor';.nq F~Lid, C<J,t-~ i:;1 e, CUiTib0t~1-~nd Count y, F'ennsy 1-,,'ctn i fl: 1 7(113-87(1(; :~- i !t'.:;:' ::h- ': (l~:..pr 1 c~'B::-: 0>.::) COMPLAIN for BREACH OF CONTRACT, Defendant EAGL r-.. 3MITH II. 1:;:' UH:~' Ctl.,:"i,-'ill.;_lrJ 2f the Cdt.,~ l~le Suburb~n {l;.:thcw:;.t.. ~.J~_t.:.!~ ottlCes Ft ::4\=, C1E::..r-'~'Jater~ [trlve, Car; 1~1>?, F.~r;rp_,;,~< ',;-Inu:. if':l::.. -. . De-fendc"lnt E. LEE i Cji.::~l.. 1;"; the :::<l_~pjY"'iilLi?n':~i':"nt, \'::-1 th~ L :?'~""t J s:'~ c-- SuhIJI";-' ti!'~: h'.:_'~- ~ ,--"., . " F-~'~ -:.-~,:,ter ,... ~" ~ - "; . ~ c: F" '-. :'(' i.-i--?, Car' i;:>l.:,~ . ~' tJ, ,.--,'j'" , ' . , re;,,-"';-! 1 ,~, ~r~'~ ''-' . -I . ,,~ ...1,1\, .! .p":-. ,; ,t-, >1'- " 5. I I ,1 1 On July 10, 1991, Plaintiffs (Grantors) enecuted a contract with the Carl isle Suburban Authority (Granteel fer the purpose o'f 1 ay i n9 and connect in9 sewlllr 1 ines from the dwell in; across the Spring Road to the e::isti~g sewer m~in. A copy of the contract is attached as Enhibit Ill' 11 .... 6. During the e}~c~vation the corltractor dug ~wo di~cnEs using a large backhoe ~lith ten inch square (mcr~ :t~ 'essJ stabil i=ing ieet. Various pla~ements o.f the ~~=\~n~a ~ama;et Plaintifis blacJ~tcp ~ri\i~way, lawn~ and d~$trCj2~ '~m~r=ws plants. TopEoil Wc7tE n~t ~cr~ped ~n~ s~p~~~ta~ ~r~~ ~h~ under'" 'ling Sui 1 .:\r.d e:~cc;1Vctt2d 30i' ~.gstrCi'fe'~ ~ i;.;",tE ~hi=h .- was dumped upon. Photographs oi the afor~m~~~~cnec ;!~~~! 1 awn and drive~'a'l' ceEtrLlction are atta':::-,cd as :-:;;hibio;: ll":" II - . ~ . . an or abou~ :ura t2, 1991, ~~d in r~2C=S~~~:=n -- ~hel~ 'fCl.i 1 '_\re: to $ep~:-,..to:;. tc,pso~ i iU1':j I.i:",derSG11 , .~-2~..:.ij,:;:;;-~t~ deliver~d about or,e cubic yard oi ~il1 dir~ ~~n~~i~i~9 rOC~:5, stones and weed$. Attel",tion i~ inv~te~ t~ photographs of the fill dirt and later w..d ;~=~:~ at E::l1ibit "C." 8. Pholoq,-?pi1S oi F'l~intifis y~rd bef~l~e ~n= ~i:n'. 1:;~~~~~ e::Cl.o\Vi\t ion ttod i\ p('~,i;;,.;;~:;ion~l 1 Z\ndr~Ci\pC pl E.n ;;1:", :-...~ t':Jl..tflC .:.'.-t:. E::h it-.i t. "[1." << 9. PlaintifL~ repeated attempts to reach an amiable ,j i ! settlement for da~a;es Wlt~ defendants failed. Cefendants offer of 5150.00 was decl ined particularly whe~ Flalntiff~ eight year old plants were compared to one and :wo year old plants available at Carlisle area sellers for leSE than $2.00. E};hibit II::" =:;t,~atn5 corri?~pond.:.?nce c~r.c=rnln'~ the above and sub5eq~en~ settleme~t ofi~r6~ t.::l, The Attornev General of Pennsylvania adY!~ed Plaint!;; tc go to tho cour~e ~nd i~ that ~ails ~hen gc ~= ~~~ pc.l itiC:::.l ~u-el-,a. ;:; Eirt.ifT~ 1 etA..:,?,,,, to "':.he A'tt:'r"i='. G=-n2"'z'I and his response may ce O:=cl.\nd at ;:::.:,~b:.t UF." . , ,. . Piaintiiia ~i'~~ ~ SrVI:. ~O~lPL~!NT ac~ic~ ~;Sl~~~ Defendants, D~c~et ~Jo.: CV-283-95. bnd was he~~= on July :':~ 1995. Plaintii~5 ca5D w~5 di~mis~ed without =r?Judi=E. E:{hibit "GII cQij"t.~in~ c::,;:,ies tJT the CIV!L CC,!'jFLH!f~7 ~~::e~':;. . ,- Dei~n~ants in t~le ~~cunt c~ .t' .::('<;. ~H'l ;'cr ~ 5 \.-Ii, , ~~ ~~-: :....,- The tT':3n)' attel'ip'l:= 1:0 :set-:1 = ":rd5 rn.;ttl?t'.. .,, :\ Tcr,:.r :-.r.c ~quable manner hav~ me~ Nith ;ailu~e. ~HE~EFOF,E. F'l~~n~~;; :~enue1~i judgem~n~ 2C~1~~~ c,.: ,l;;i',~,\.", ~c.(!',6?e. ;1::. ':<< .(I\~' -::.,. ;.....,.-.. ::-.,,:: :: =,_:~,: - -:-;- "':: _'.._ a _ . " r,'. '.., ~,:' ~ . =:; '.":. l~n ~l'~}:;"'~"': KIm C. Guye, r;,I."I PubUc Carllsla Boro, Curr "",land Counl. ,~ly Commission ~,:'"u. Nov, 10, ':."::.. ., .'l..'1,~':~'_'{':''''''''Q.llonctN' CJ i'Jr:s<..:.:., (/IS :. :Jr, ~"::Oi..: _ia-!'.~: :';.. =;"Ijlr-.;:'::-: . .. . . {-(l-~- . ' , /.1" ;~ #/' / _ ..., J._c..'<'~~'::l.' !L_,.!k ,;. -"- -\.... . .-'" .:. ':;. -. . ' "12nr-r,:;,. " ,~. -. ,.; ,..... . - , WE. JDhr~ Otto snd C~roly~ Ot~D, ~~r~~;i ~h6t ~e ~re h\Jsbant ~nd WL;~ and t~~t WE make thi~ Yeri{ica~i~n :r ~t~ behalf bEing ~uthori=ed to dc so ~!,d that thl~ 5ta~emen~s made in the fOregolng Complaint are true and ccrrect. ~E understand that iala~ statefil~nt~ herein are made zubj~c~ t: th~ ~enaltiEs of 18 Pa. C.S. M4~04 r~18tin; t~ un~~crn f?1sification to 2uthorities. 0&':2: '1 Alffsr /1'1'5 ~ , - ~ .~!r.', ,r. '---)7 '7 /1 ~,//-' ~:'f 3(~t.L.(-L.-J:.:&.!-- Natali:ll Seal \ KIm C. Guyer. r~Qlary Public C.rt1s1. BOlO, Cu'rll8rland CounlY My Commllllon Exp.les Nov. 10, 1M? ;'-- .~~lIt'.~~L::".I.:o..~lotN(/~ . 2720 Spring Road Carl isle, PA 17013 November 3, 1991 Ur ref: Ltr 10/22/ 91, CSA/Otto et al Hubert X. Gilroy Attorney at Law 4 North Hanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 Dear Counselor: Regarding the "dispute" over the wrecking of my yard, neither the RotzsNor the ottos were provided a copy of their agreement with the Carlisle Suburban Authority. Mr. Lee Koch promised same and witnessed the signing. The ottos are not prepared to go forward in this matter until such time as a copy o'f the agreement is provided. We would also appreciate a copy of the notes taken at CSA meetings pertaining to this matter. Although it is not my intention to speak for the Rotzs, I would suspect that they are of similar mind. Sincerely, cc: John Otto Chair, CSA Super, CSA ....-The Rotzs . COPt DUD OF ~, JUmn!-OF-ny.&IID JUmn! OF zrrrxy .&GRZEIIER'r 'J'HIS AGREEMENT ilia de this lb'''\ day of ~ ' 1991, between JOHN OTTO and CAROLYN OT'l'O (Grantors) and CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORIfY, A Pennsylvania Municipal Authority with offices at 240 Clearwater Drive, Carlisle, Pennsylvania, (Grantee) . . WHEREAS, Grantors are owners in Fee Simple of a certain tract of land situate in North Hiddleton Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, more particularly described in Deed recorded in the Recorder of Deeds Office in and for Cumberland County in Deed Book X, Vol. 29, Page 899. WHEREAS, Grantee has undertaken the construction of a building sewer/sewer lateral in order to connect the property of Michael J. Rotz and Linda K. Rotz which is immediately to the East of Grantors' property across Pennsylvania Route 34; and WHEREAS, in connection with said construction, it is necessary for Grantors to convey to Carlisle Suburban Authority a Deed of Easement and Right-of-Way in order for the lIIentioned building sewer/sewer lateral to be connected to the existing sewer lIIain of Carlisle Suburban Authority which is located on Grantors' property; and WHEREAS, Grantors are willing to convey said right-of-way, with the understanding that Grantors assume no obligation for lIIaintenance of the lIIentioned building sewer/sewer lateral. WIfnESSETH, that in consideration of the payment of ORE DOLLAR ($1.00), the said Grantors do hereby grant and convey to the Grantee, its successors and assigns, forever, a permanent easement and a free, uninterrupted and unobstructed right-of-way along the route designated and hereinafter described in the attached Exhibit HAH, for the purposes of laying, installing, constructing, operating, replacing, renewing, enlarging, repairing and maintaining said building sewer/sewer lateral line and its accessories and appurtenances, together with all the rights of ingress, egress and regress in, to, over, upon, through and along said premises, necessary for full and complete use by the said Grantee, its \' : lIuccellsorll and assigns, of the said easament lIlld right-of-way lIlld :for the exercise of said rights and privileges to lay, install, construct, operate, replacd, renew, enlarge, repair lIlld maintain said sewer line and its accessories and appurtenances, to keep the surface and subsurface of the said easement lIlld right-of-way cleared of all timber, trees, roots, brush and other obstructions and to install and maintain gates and/or stiles in lIllY fences crossing the said easement and right-of-way area. Grantors are conveying a permanent uninterrupted and unobstruc~ N) 20 foot right-of-way olliS CEashp,s are tleftveyis!r a tltllll1lera~ S9 VV . . . W Grantors do not assume any liability for repair or mai ' enance of <i'1--..$ the building sewer/sewer lateral in question. "~he Grantee, in connection with the exercise of lIllY of the rights and privileges herein granted, shall restore the surface of the ~ said premises of Grantors, as nearly as practical to its contour ""Vr and condition as existed prior to the exercise of said rights and ~ "-!'rivileges; UJ Im,,v N'1J~ .b11Y.s ~{' ~fJ.(.1I wA1ToAl 01: eACH O(,CU~o/:JCE: . The terms "Grantors" and "Grantee" shall include the parties~~ ( hereby, their resp,,!ctive heirs, executors, administrators, ~-hS' successors and ass~gns. ~ IN WI~NESS WHEREBY, the parties hereto have hereunto said their hands and seals the day and year first written above. 8t~" Ca67J CAROL 'I'TO " A~~ES~ : CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY ~~j/O~ t:7' eo e azy By: ~-'1.-'l, s;:. ~ Chairman .-..,:...... .M~""'''''' ""- ;.-.., ~~ .,.... . . ~. ':.... ~,;;.:.~~.-... ......,.,. ~" - ~:~...~. .;.::;' #.'r";"~"";!';'~'~""'~': ". :iO..,'" .....-.:""" .,.- ,," -':' "- ," ,-,' .:_".:. ,_' ~'.! ' ",. 'f' -.' · .; :".~,.., :. ~...:,:",..'-',.--',<, ~'.' '.' _.- . ".;r' .' · .~ " ...', . -~ '~': ....,.. '" ,._..:,~'~_:':;' r,;' ,: ,- . ': {,....__:.....' ",,.,,- :'1"~.,,-.;.' , .. ~~{ ..,.r~"::iJ, .;-............01_.. ~",....,'" h~ ...'.......,.;.J..,' ~_....,--.~... ~.,.-.r.'t':-;.:ry. ,~_-'. 4,;J~""11~.... t'.' ,: cr., <<', ....... ~:.,6I:' ...' .- ~e;-t4~... ." - f -!- _.,:...' .r _ .- .-........... ..,::'. ,/...., \-:",'.....~~.....'4 0,. '. I \.. v.~.., ,..,;,'~ "."....~.,"':."".: ~. ...,.~~ ',""""~ ",' "100"""'" :\:r:.-" '.;....~.:-~:. . .~....., -t', -~..~ . ')'.... . . ,~"''''''-':I'' - ., . ..... ,............A,'JS. ....,,~ .......: ......t.....:::.......~ . ,- ~A~~,;-. ; . .,~ \. t:;....... ..' ... ...... .....:....... ""'-- .' . . ~. . ~." ...t._~ -"~:h~~ ,-l'-", ...:Y kL1r '7 : "'~~~, ' , t' ,... . "~ . -~_. ,,(. e". (!:1r.., . '. ...... '.~...,.....'r ," ~......, .. . ':. ..~;~. '~~~"~\. 'i!.U:~~"~' ,.~'~t~;.. ~ ,.\...~,~ '~.,... '. ' .. '..., t.\ 'j.:l"' '. ~I".H'~,~~ '. ' ... ""--.' ioI.....'I':"/c,1 . ,_ ~. "'1~'" ..--:1>..... ...::. ..... .;' .... .... '1"7'. ..tI>..,.. 'do ". ". . '"L~1...' ....- . . '1-, ~....,.. .:....,.,... t. ). ~._-' ". I;.:.'.,:..;....~;;.:. .; .:, ......;.,\;~..'. :,.f.i~It:~~. ~:i:.\ ':j,~~':;~' " ,~ . ,~, ...... .. '"' . '/':If;IL"~ ..~ ~ :r-'.".-" , . .:: ......iii. .:'-l}~': : '\l.\""..~... .." . "... "I! ~ . .,.J..../'": I. ~~ . .. ..-j.'~:-M t~....,t-.. .~~.::.~...l ,,' V:" "4"_' ....j'. \ .,. a : : -. ..,',~ -, ',. . .~., '. . ":,'(Jt'~:~ Ifi::...'). . . '.' . '-:- '. ~,,':.~1;;~'. . r...... .........., ~ .... -.:.a......;" .. . ,f ...:......J~~f...~.. ... ~ ~;,- ".:~~;'. ", " ~. .~. . "-,,., .)>. '.:1"...... "tif<'T.-...J ~~.;'. -). '.'~ 'r./~ ".'':l,'''' " . ....- ': .....~..>'--I..~~J _"'I1il('. ..". k",'''' ~.:. ~ .,.;; .-....'......: -..-'. ..... '\ '.... " '~ TotolAl ~o', ~O"D.' .'nscD J, l'l ,: ~$". . ., ., .... ;. ~ '30 \ '\. '--- .) ,---'-_._- ' I I , , ::! rIlL :r ,......\ - .: r-~~-I' : i':~ ~. ~.;.I t-..~:~,' :~'..'.~ ; ...., .. I .... ',' -,. . "'., - - ;' ~;.. "i-' ).~ ~ ;~: . .'!'" ....:.."'\..,..:.".. \. n..... ! ' ~~~~~~t'~~:. '.,:Lp:I. / -~ ':.... _' : ...~. ~ .." .;.,.. ... l. co ' ,;.. ~... .' i.' . ....,.,... . . ., \ .: \ c- 'r( \ E = <<\' '.i '" " , . Resident: Authority should pay By Kellie Patrick Sent In. I Reporter ~ -.........,.........--..... .~.+. .-.... :\ Nollh t\lllhlh.'IUII T\I\\'II''11111' Il',itklll I' 1I1111i1l1l11lf In ,~illlll,ll with t"uh,k SUhlll h.1lI AUlhoril)' O\:~r 111'0 )'ill\l. Juhn OUll, 1..,20 SPflllllHu,hl. h IIl\h,II'jl)' with Ihl' way thl' IIlIlhUIII)' 4:UIIIll'I,.:It',1 till' hnllll' of Olio', nci~hhOl~. Midml'lillhl LIIl- da Rull.. In the sewer lim' in JUlle I'll) I. Sume of the digging luulln he IJullc III IlIl' yard of lh~ OllllS, whu \ig,,,,..1 il ,Il"'tl uf easement granting (lcrmh:\hll1. ll,"ll'l the conHacl. the Rnl/!:s me "In rr!\olnrc lIuy ,II.,. IUr\X:l' rn.ulwity ur di\tUlhclll\rCil'" Il'\llltlllg frum the Sl'wer line wnr~ nn Iht' ()Ih'" pU'I",n)', Olin think, the Ili"T1:1~C\ Ihat 1t':\lIlh'll tn hb shrnhs. llIukh. !\tUllUHIIUpsuil ..Hie excessiVl'. Thl'H'fnre, he- \i')"i, IIIl' I(ul/l'\ shnuld nul he U'!ropnll,.hh!. Ih~ wnllh Illl' ~ulh(lrit)' In 1II<1J\C 1~'lilUliull. ~1rs. Rllt/. 'lays Suhurhilll AUlhmil)' SUl't~I' inlclIlknt "1.1'l' KtJi:h 1'~lll;lIl1~tIIU 'I' hdull.: Ihe 1i1l~ Willri in!rowllcll I' hllll' "'UlIllIlIl'I'lllu 1~ dug mlhl' Ollm' )'lllll illHI W~ \\tlllhllk': r''''1(llll1'lhll' hlr ll'sel'tlill~~ the .1Il!a." She !ool)"lri ,hc lllullll'f Im,hillul wunltt h,I\'I' "glitJly IMid" to rcstole Ihe ~iml whcn' II "';llri Illig II'" IInWl'\'I'I, ,Ill' 'i\)'S lIu.' lillul. Sf;tplllg Wil' 110t luinel! '" IUlIfh 1"-'I',W\l' It W;t'l tlul! up hul hl't.'IIU'C Ilh,' .lIIlhlH Ily pdell din Olllnl' of II. Shr "i1)'lri Ihl' ;lUlhnril)' filUM t'.I..,I)' IIil\'c pLln'll Ihl' pill' ul" tllll I'lwwlu'It., 'oil il ..hlllllillll' 1t''''lllll..ihll' till h...luliltit1u \\-tlll, SllhUlhan "tllhnrlly SUI'I'lintcluit.'1I1 1.\.'1,.' t\114. h ";1\'" "lhl' hullnmlllll!" Is 111l,' ()jIll' ;11,,1 Illl' HIII;I" '1)'H.'tl illl il~Il'~ml'1l1 !>>ilyill~ Ihl' Hill/I" W I.: It' Jl"IHllI'lhll' I'lIr tl.Ullitl!t." \'11,"1'.1 ,I' illl.',"1I nl Ihl' hOll~lIl'. "\V\' \\l1ul,I'\'I,.' .ll',lI, "'llh ()tit)." Km:h illltl-.. "hUIIIl' .hlt'..n', \\illlIIU" dl,.'JI. KUIIl ,ull" Ih,11. ..lillI,.' 01111 h,l' !\ougge!>>tcd 1111' 111.1111'1 1Il,1~' J.!ll hi hll~'illiun, Ihl.' .1lI,hmi- 1\".. "Illlrlh,'\' h".. ihhbl.'41 hlln nullo lIlilh' ,'ulllll'r (t1l1lill~1l1 ()lit) ,,"y' h\.' hq~;lI' ".lllll,.....pumlill}:. wilh the .lUlholil)' hy hulh h:llcr ilud phune a~ soon iI'i Ihl' WtJl~ WtI' linne, Iii, l:tSI corrcspon. tll'IKI.' wllh th~ Ollllhofily \\:IS in Ihe spring. Ih' 'iIY' 111\' ;1111110111) ~,,'1I1 " new 10 rCllltl\~ 1Ut:J\ \ 110m hi, g;IHkn light .,ncr Ihe WUlJ\ \\i1"I'Ollll'kll.:ll. iU1l1 "hit sent;, load uf h1lhtHI. lIu( h~ ",;I~'''' Ihe tupsuil was poor hl.'I,.'.IU'L' II 1'IIIlIillll~'11 wt'I.',I.. :IOtl rocks Ihe !t,IIl'IlIIWtln,I" III .\ len". ,1.1,,',\11<1. ~~, IW\, lIuben X. (illlo)' 01 Ihtllljo... Gllw)' ;uulllllusICH1. the ('iIIh..l~ Suhlllh.UI '\utlulfIly's sulicitor, pro. 1'11\\'11 all ;ICrl'I,.'lIll'lIt bl.'twC'cn Ihe ;mthurity. th~ Ollt,.. ;uul (Iu: 1(IJll'..... ThL' ;t~Il.l'llH.nl ,,;ti\llh~ OliOS would 11.'\."l.'I\'C a !o I ~(l t.':I!\h 1'.1)lIh:ntln rcplace :my "lilith, nl Ill"" thai \\"cn~ tI.unagcd .lI1l1 per- !llnll lI1ullilk;uinn!o lei Ihc ,lriVCWilY portilln ullhl' OliO 11IUPt.'I'Y, II Sli"C!'l the KlIlle:>> would perform Ihe "lillal )!ralling illHI ~cc(ling" of 111l~ 0110 P11IIU'rl)', ;lIulllll' .mthmit)' wuuld I'lOvidc at nOlll.ll~l' to H.utl. ruur cubic yards of lap' ~uillllllhl' in tha11'Hljl.'l'l. (JIll) ""Y" Ihl' mUlley \\'(llIlt.ll1ot Cl1\'('r lhe ll;lI11.H'l.' tlnlle. lriU hI,.' \\'I(lh~ Iht: law finn a lei. ler ..;;~'ing hl' \\'IIHItI lIt1t ;tCl'cpt Ihis off~r. Thl' "llthOlll)' 11", nnllll;ulc ;11l~\\' uffer. Utili l'sIIIIMtl'''' Ihl.:' t.l:nnacc ;11 $1.467.19. "hid1 hI,.' !'lot)'''' IS Ih~' ;l1m)1Int uf IIH1I1CY a Im'i11 1.llul"l'Jpt'r 10M him il would ensllo 1\.'1'1;II.'c Ihl' phmt!o. Itll'~nil ami olhcr lhings '" I JCffh!V Luwc/Ilte Scntilll'l John Olto shows soil provided by North Middleton. The Rotzes live in the house in the background. Quo says wcre u.lmagcd h)' Illc mllhurity. Otto silYs he is still looking for ways IU solvc lhis prohlem, Hc has talked 10 a local Ii\w\'cr who said nNhinl.! clluhl be.: done 10 makc Ihe :'1Uthol"ity pay tor Ihe dmnage. "The lawyer told me lhe i\ulhorit)' cuuld ..Iu Ihe same Ihinu .12ain to someone cisI.'. and nothing wouid happen," Ono says, ,,' think lhis is irresponsibl~ government:' ~~;.. ..".:- . :t" - : _-;.' ,'~i"',."" ',' ,."'. , ..;-......=<" .,~.....'..:>".,~ - , ,".r- '...t!:.. .,' -'" . .~..~"{'*'.,.. :>.J~f; ,i,:: ' . ~ t,~.,-, ".," . . r" . . " .,. · " . ..- '.-..c ...' . .... '",.,..~' ..~ It', {",-;." .".'........~o!' ~ ':. . . ...... .~.. ,......' ,.:.:...;.~~...."'~ ..r--oO ","", .. .'L' r'" ='<0. -",~, . ,,",,," or-....,..---...'- , 'T:- ........ ~, "........;' ,~....J_' '- "f." .~... ~} .,-'- - ,~'~,~ ' {., ." . ." ,_......,.,. .l-uo-~"," -.;" ' , .. ' -...........0*-."..' ' . ;;..,;..~;" ~-. '~-". .= ."1 ". .- '.' 1 ~ ::::: ::::: ji '-.;-:.: . ' .. . ' j -~ .",. .. :.~"..~~ \..... :.~ .,~ . ;;." ',' .-p.t.. ". "~.""'" '. .:.~. :.J. . ,~.i." , . -:...: ~.:..)" :-.............{-.~;,!......;- .:.,. . r" '. ..... ".~ r /.... ." <..;~I.:f' ".,. ....'. ."., ."'! ',-1. rt. fl [1.... 4' ~.;: If,; . -.... t-:' , ."'U"'i .7~.~='" ~ -'.1" ~.II..~..~.t;... ,', .... '.1 . -1 ; 'i;' , . ,.'..u...........h"'""-lLow.....1Mr,. I" ,,' Otto t;"Jl1I1HUt" hlUII ill "1;1..10' .,',' ,,\. .1"",., ';'.111: ", '"I''''' ".,' ~ " ,,' .,' ,",; ,', ""', " ~..I ,II. .:1 1..1 ',. ~h" "nd of the Iill. ' ." ,,'.,'1 .. .~. n,1 ... -<'1'.' 'i.t.' ,,1;,1,"""" "~ _...1"'-',11'\ ';!"'h,.l \1 ..!.l'" .... '.1, .:",.".,'1.' ~l-' . .11,1 . ",' .II. ",, "1'1,." .,~,Jllw,1 'a' lI'I'Uh' . ~ : . ~ ' .,,' ,11','" 1;,'1 . ~!'"_ .~j:-:~ 0: ..1 :,'...1... ...', .----. .._-- ------------- .~.... "":, 'j"':'j'."::""'-" ...r .. ".-' ..' :'.. - i'f','I,I~: :.~..: ,:': .d ,'Y,,~n 1 :>-!,'/,'r r" .\' I" ..' ........, ,'~" " '" TIme runs out on sewer fight "'.1 , H,.h'" \ . ',,'h.'I'l. Lly 0"\11I1','1"111'''' ~...I,".lll..",,,,,. ',",'!1I'" ....",,".,....:... ..",...' "',, . :\. ,. r"""'I'.1"1 ',.I"I'WI':". ,'-. ",I 1":"1',',"'..' '1""'''' "';1 . ",,'r.," ..' 'l ,!"I, . ~ ,'.1 ' . , ',' ,'" " . IlH....'. ..,,".' 1..,'.1"'1 ".'\ 'k '.1" '.\.'\1:,. .....1\..;,..., 'rh","',' 'I.'". , ,'.'1,.' , ,.....r. ...t-.. . .I--~ ,. ,...."'''.'I.It-..,I,I._ l",".',.:'r,,;,!,'1I1 ," .\ ~.. ,d ,',01 It "',' '..1'." .1...." ,,' . ,,,, '.. ~ ". -, . I. . :" ,....1 .,.,1,,,,,......,;'" """,' '.',' ....1 ,\1, 'I" " ()cCII",.d in ':unlt 1991 "ll' ,1.1. :.,""'.1 'I ',-7 ",,'l"'" Ol' ..,t' ...;;..... '1 '....,.1 " ,,' "1\ , ',' ," 'r , '" "..' " .. ,",l,.',' " "" ,." ,.,-.'" i L" ~ F't.~'-l" frlJ..J rtk/A f) ~/~'- 1 S.. r 'i' .tt:;, ~ 2720 Spring Road Carlisle, PA 17013 27 August 1991 Chairman Board o~ supervisors North Middleton Township 211 North Middleton Road Car1is1e, PA 17013 Dear Chairman Howard Bear, 1 wish to tal:e this opportunity to thank you and Supervisors R. Shearer and J. W. McBride ~or your kindness, prompt assistance and un~ai1 ing attention to your civic responsibi1 ities in the matter o~ my "wrecl:ed" ~ront yard. My wi~e and 1 are sti11 considerablY upset with the unpro- ~essiona1 manner in which Mr. Lee KOKE, o~ the Carlisle Suburban Au thor i ty <CSA) and "his" contracto." Hr. James SLYDER, handled the insta11ation o~ sewer/water 1ines on\my property. Hr. SLYDER conducts business as JAMES H. SLYDER, EXCAVATING, 508 CHESTNUT, St., Ht Holly Springs, telephone: 486 5490. Supervisors Shearer and McBride may recal1 the project was at the request o~ my neighbors, Mr. and Mrs. Hichael Rot:::. My wife and 1 absolutely did not appreciate Mr. 1(0kE's demanding and feisty attitude nor his uncouth 1anguage while addressing us. <Others were wi thin earshot.l As a publ ie servant, Mr. 1~.Of(E I eaves m~\ch to be desired. In recognition of the contractors unprofessional worl:, a 10ad of what was purported to be topsoi1 was delivered to my front yard. <See enclosurel T,"o wOI-I:men were provided by CSA for about four hours to pickup rocks I sha1 e and other debris from my property a ~e'" days after the e::cavation even t . Mr. Slyder's operation destroyed the fol10wing: 1. Blue Rug Junipers, three, age eight years 2. A:::a1ea, one, orange bird, age, eight years 3. Rhododendon, one, Nova Zemba, age, eight years . Mr. Slyder's operation destroyed the followingl 1. Blue Rug Junipers, three, age eight years 2. Azalea, one, orange bird, age, eight years 3. Rhododendon, one, Nova Zemba, age, eight years 4. Grass, one plant, Japanese variegated, age one year !5. Top soil (sod) and grass, 720 sq ft X 3 ft deep 6. Edging, black, garden, one piece, 20' L X 5" W 7. Backhoe, deep foot prints, macadam driveway and flower bed. B. Mulch, six cubic feet, estimated, from flowerbed. , ' tL- (1,oJr; ~ PA- f?C!)/3 Eb' Cjl;-;,_~ ~1-J991 ~ \.t oJ....~u-; · . . I . ~ ~ c:...L.~ 00 ~ '15 'i7u ~ V tl-~ ~ ~ '. ~~7.Yo 'ttu ~ ,U~ ?hld~ ~G-td.() ~~Vltry?,. ClU~~4 & ~~t{ ~~..J- ~ ~ ~t^~6-L~~ ~ ~ ~W\.rP... ~ ~(7)~'f .-L QCUL co. 0 .J . - \ {1 '~ ~ ~ ~.-4:J4. u, ee... 1M~~ . ~ . , ~ .~t~~( C1-u.& C u1A:&CD ~ S~ cLue . ~ u;r ~-/~ i: cJ/J(. , ~4-f )Sku ~ {)S, ,LbW0t9- J2~ ~u~~ /---, . . ' i-' It; .. Michael Rotz 2731 Spring Rd. Carlisle, pa 17013 September 16, 1991 , i .. 1 j '" I I \ , I " ~ ! Ii " ;11 ;.' '1 \. ,',1 I'! :, Mr. E. F. Smith II (oCh, CSA 1843 Spring Rd. Carlisle, PA 17m13 : j' !I' Enclosed is the estimate fo~ damages to,~he property of Mr. John otto, 2720 Spring Rd. These damages ~ere incurred by Jim Slyder Excavating of Mt. Holly Springs! while excavating for public water and sewer hookup. Carlisle Suburban Authority contracted Mr. Slyder for this work, there~ore we are forewarding I, ,estimates for the following reasons. 'If ill I. 1. Our agreement specifies Pilstoration of ~;ltcava.l!d ~nd had excavation been handled pr8periy . ~opBoil would have been a~ailable from dig site. ~'!~"~ 2. Our a . ,::,',.,~' 'Hty ,fo ,', . '..,. . .,:.' ',J' said . ,We hope this will be reconciled .in a our neighbors, Mr. and ~trB. John otto. Dear Mr. Smith, sattBfactory manner . !: for :, j: " Sincerely, ~fY~~ ~li~hael Rotz '.'. .:. , .' , :!' .::.: ) ~; '. .' ;y:.:,.~\':.~' :;:: ::.:~ .':., " ,'. .:. .. '... . ;I, ", jl: I' ii' . , ., , ,I: ., I. , i' h: CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY North Middleton Township 240 Clearwater Drive Carlisle, PA 17013 I 'I October 1, 1991 I I I 'i 1 Mr. & Mrs. Michael Rotz 2731 spring Road Carlisle, PA 17013 1 I Dear Mr. & Mrs. Rotz: In reference to the work recently completed at your residence I would like for you, Mr. Slyder and myself to sit down and discuss these matters. Please give me a call to make arrangements for such a meeting. Sincerely, a--k!~ E. Lee Koch Superintendent ELK/ks /, j I I I I I , Rew Busil1ess Respectfully submitted, i :~ l . , Mr. Koch distributed the first draft of the budget. AdjoUrIIIIIIIl1t Mr. Smith adjourned the meeting at 8:40 p.m. John C. Stewart Secretary Concetta Strayer Recording Secretary cs/kls 27~0 Spring, Road Carli91~, PA 17013 December 31, 1991 IIuhl'wl: '1.. Gill-n~' "ttClr'IH?Y ilt l.Iwl IJ Nor-th "'"({)'..", , Rtrp.'?1: CArlisle, p" 17013 Ref I Ur 221091, Rotz lotto c:onnec:tion Dear Hr. Gilroy, i , i 1 I h"d hopt"d thnt, t.hl' dnma9p. t.o my front yard I ncurred by the C,,,"llsle RlIhur'ban ""thority And their- conb'm:tor .JAmes H. Slyder'. F.:::cnv"UIl''' ("olllrJ hAve hlmn r,f)1:1:1!1l1 in A reasonAble, t1r>nslhle ..nrl I'!llu!\bll" "'':IIlI''1/' IOonl:ho; "lJu. I did r,r.1. .-.::p",r.1: I;hln 1IIlp'l'!illiAnt. 91l:lwtiOll to p.9calnt.e to 1111:' l1o:;r;ihil i.l:v or "'\ 11,,'\'\n9 to 5~ek 1~~lr,l ,"'r.?pl-'p.senl:af:ion. II,'. 1.11.. t(l~- tl~1t.t!pd lo i~cl"I:'m"IOcl;,t.p. the nol~s ,'p-Quest for' the ::'=r'!,'''?I- r:rnHH~cl:iollrfJl~ 1"'H:1 r'~i\SOn5. I': (',.:1-:; t.hp neighborly l-hj'lc:1 I." drl ;lllrl hr'r;\lI':"P llll'!' !;uperlf:lrtdrn,t '-Ir th~ Cl\r'lj~le I'j,,!:,.!!" f1'"thrll'll:y, Ih'. 1:. I..I'!(-! f':IJck, m:plain!?ll the pr'ocess. I)nly ,,\ Iwl!? alwul: fOil' f"pl: by four' f{'pl; "'Could be dug to t.he ""pth of the cnnn<!r:l:in9 '~al:el" and !lewm" rnains. FUI"ther, that the I and "IDul cI 1m properl y restored. ~Ie ilc:cepted all of I:his in goocl faith. I "rn unabl~ to ac:cept. nny t.op soil from CSA unless it is "1.I,H-".Ulf:l;1r-:?d in l'll"il:inu "n be Fr"ee of ",p.r?d~, "''1~rJ sp.eds, "::l1:"fl':'IO:;, t"r','I.I-:~~ :111(1 "",:h;\Ir... Thp. one d~'l jV(~I"pd lond t'f CSA lItop I"H)i III ,-:r:-nJ:;\i!lFHI :::l11 ,-,r UH~ ,.,bovf:~. '{nu ;'\.....~ invited t:o vie'" ~:\nH:' in 'I~'''' (1"~Jnl: v:\,'rl. , dp nr,l: in\:'?l1d t.'" he h;lmboo~l(?d. CS(\/~. P"'C'IIHHiP.d settlement: in h.:\I';;1I o1l1d ,.Ii ':111)1) I; llH~I'; I: . Si'H:p.r'p.l v cr' .J- (])11Il 01: I:u I-li' .lI'h' r,(ll: ~ \.--11" _ 1I1~1'1","..1 r'I:'':II', Cll. I lilT , SUPI"V '" . E. r, ''ll1l i '-' I J I. r 10. CSfl Supr'v ~""'- I'VI 11 . a..tJL-UUMCJ.L., I .- CSlI,r ~fJ-I.{.~ (., /lM.lLt..'fJitl~~f ~~rj. ~ -VAM&ck5 ~ I b~j Z~~V:I-" ~U;~&8 L~, ~ ,~?Y&:-&l)c/ c/I~ '11M .l~&l1ee 11"/1> '~l~1j t1"e.(.' {1.e'7,e1,L, 7,7_f.:r;71 ~-._J-- . -,I " :7:(' ,Spr i n9 Road Carli91e,'PA June 7, 1993 The Attorney General of Pennsylv~nia Strawberry Square Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 171:0 Dear Attorney General Preate, Your assistance is requested in what we consider to be a ~~aud and possibly a matter of consume~ p~otectlon concerning damages caused by the Carl isle Surburban Authority (CSA). Our property was damaged by CSA while connecting our neighbor's home, the Rotes, to city water and se~'age . . i Our lawn and plants were destroyed and cur driveway was damaged. Restoration is estimated to be 1n e::ceS5 of :1'14')0. C2~ Superviso~ Koch's verbal explanation of the written agreement is a part of the contract bet.,een CSA, the Ott=s and the Rotzs was violated. Also, princicals were not given a copy of the contract unt i I after the ,.jork was fin i shed. The CSA's attorney sent the Rotes a letts," in ~Iay 199: inr;licating in substance that Otto's cl,dm \',a5 e::ot"bitant. Th~y planned to offer the Ottos :t3~) to close the matter. Never offered. Tha Otto~ and the R~t=5 con~i~er ~~e Ma)' :~92 letter a deceitful attempt to sway the Rotes to influence the Ottos to close. The Rot=s d~c' ined C~ th~ b~~i5 th~~ the offer WRS insignificant and did net gi'/E iul1 consideration to the Otto's lo5Ee~. The cf~Er i~ t~nt5m=~~~ to an admission of guilt by CSA. LaNyers have dec:l ined tc repr~":~~'t !..t:: bC:~:>'..to;:a -:~.'.?;Y ~~.'.' ~.:z. would lose. We were fw"ther adviaed that CSA could cort:nue to give other property owners similar treatment and that nothina could be dene about it. We reject this! This situation W8rr~n~s inve5tigatic~, At~~-~5V GT~E~E' Pre8te, bec~u5e it ~macKs of fr~ud. :~s~=:: ~ ~~~c --- consum21- prot~ction (against poor gov~rnm~nt), ~~c 't'~ltr;:: ~ i:"".cr;:'r"'!.! v Incl F i 1 e ,Lj.).?95 CC Rote fS/ca"0I";1 H. O':.~c IS tOhn 0......,... ~ ~~ ~ COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL HARRISBURC. PA. 17120 ,.," 'LOOlll .'III"well:""1' aQu."e "..IIIIII".UIIIO, .A. 171'0 (,IP)'.'-IUI CANC:ST O. PRCATE. .JR. .."011I"'11:. QCNt...~ June 17, 1993 Public Protection Division 14th Floor Strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120 (717) 787-9716 Mr. and Mrs. John Otto 2720 Spring Road Carlisle, PA 17013 Dear Mr. and Mrs. Otto: This is to acknowledge receipt of your correspondence to the Attorney General regarding your complaint against the Carlisle Suburban Authority. I can certainly understand why the damage to your property that was allegedly caused by the CSA. Many people complain about what they believe to be unreasonable actions or activities of authorities. Unfortunately, there is no body that regulates the rates or activities of authorities other than the Authority Board of Directors itself. State law permits authorities to establish their own rates, rules for service or procedures. A customer has only a few alternatives when it comes to protesting those charges. First, a customer has the right to file suit in Common Pleas Court to receive compensation for damage done. That, of course, requires a lawyer and resources. The only other alternative is to protest the actions to the elected officials who appoint the members of the authority. While authority members are appointed, the people who assign them those positions are not. They may be sensitive to your concerns. . ~ '. Mr. and Mrs. John Otto Page Two I am sorry that we could not be of further assistance. If you would like to discuss this matter in more detail please feel free to contact me. \ 1 ! 1 . \ ! sincerely, ~vJC~(~) Daniel Clea~~ield Executive Deputy Attorney General PPD930099 DC/../DLto19 Incl Fi Ie, l./.;2EgS CC Rot:: (S/ca"Olyn H. Otto IS ~ohn Otto ;~7:::';1 Spr i ng Road Carl isle'" F'A JClne 7, 1993 The Attorney General of PennsylY~nia Strawberry Square Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120 Dear Attorney General Preate, Your assistance is requested in what we consider to be & fraud and possibly a matter of consumer protection concerning damages caused by the Carlisle Surburban Authority (CSA). Our property was dam~ged by CSA while connecting our neighbor's home, the Rot::s, to city water and S2.,age. Our lawn and plants were destt~cyed and cur drivGway was dama9':'::, Restoratio:1 i~ es~'imated to be in e::ces,;:; of :t14(H). CSA Supervisor Koch's '1",rtJal 2::plz.r,z,t'.on of tne written ilgreement is a part of th" c:ontr".ct b,~t"een CSA, the Ottos and the Rot::s was violated. AIBO. orincipals were not given a CCPy of the contract until after the work was finished. The CSA's attorney :;ent the ~:ot=s ,:\ 1 ettet' in ~Iay 1992 indicatin9 in substance that Otto's cl nim Nas e::orbitan4;.. They planned to offer tr,e Ott~s s300 to clc5e the matter. Never of-fered. T!-d~ OttO::i r~.r4.= -:~,~:: :::::t:~:~ c'::n~id.'?r the Ma)' ~t;92 letter a deceitful att9ffipt to sway ~he Ro~=s ~c influencE the Ottos to close. The Rot=s dsc1 in~~ O~ the basis th~t the offer was insi9nific~nt ~~~ did net giv2 ~ull consid~ration to the Otto's loz~es. The ~f~~r is t5nt~mo~n~ t~ an admi5sion of guilt by CSA. La'~yer3 have deel ino~ to re~re~ent uz bo~~~se they ~a\' W~ .,0L\ld 10=<1. ~le were fUl~ther' advised that CSr4 coclld continel€.' to give other property owner:; similar treatment and that nothing could be done abo~t i~. We reject this! This situation warrants inv9~tisation, Attorney Preat~1 because i~ $macks of ~raud. 7~~~~ ~~ ~ cons~mer protection (against poor 9overnm~nt), G'?ner:.l :'"'::::c .o:=C'''' .-- .'-- . Ycurs ~ irIC?I-c;.l 'I '. ~!).~ , ,~',~ .... . . :{~.~~ COMMONWCAlltl or PrNNSYLVANIA OFFICE OF ATTORNEY GENERAL HARRISDURG. PA,I7120 E.RNEST Q. PR[AT[, JA ...nORNe, otNC"A'- June 17, 1993 I.'" '..DO" tIo'''.....tR..'' .Qu....1; ...A.M'..U"O, PA. "UID (""J787.U.' Public protection Division 14th Floor Strawberry square Harrisburg, PA 17120 (717) 787-9716 Mr. and Mrs. John Otto 2720 Spr~ng Road Carlisle, PA 17013 Dear Mr. and Mrs. Otto: This is to acknowledge receipt of your correspondence to the Attorney General regarding your complaint against the Carlisle Suburban Authority. I can certainly understand why the damage to your property that was allegedly caused by the CSA. Many people complain about what they believe to be unreasonable actions' or activities of authorities. Unfortunately, there is no body that regulates the rates or activities of authorities other than the Authority Board of Directors itself. State law permits authorities to establish their own rates, rules for service or procedures. A customer has only a few alternatives when it comes to protesting those charges. First, a customer has the right to file suit in Common pleas Court to receive compensation for damage done. That, of course, requires a lawyer and resources. The only other alternative is to protest the actions to the elected officials who appoint the members of the authority. while authority members are appointed, the people who assign them those positions are not. They may be sensitive to your concerns. . .. Mr. and Mrs. John Otto Page Two Sincerely, ~vJ(fQJ Daniel Clea~~ield Executive Deputy Attorney General I am sorry that we could not be of further assistance. If you would like to discuss this matter in more detail please feel free to contact me. PPD930099 DC/../OttoU :-'7'2(1 "Ep,: i f1Q nOtln C,wl iGln, PI' 17('13 ~'ml~!'J:11rf.29~', ~lr. Hl,bert X. G i I rO'f (~t torney-at -Lal~ 4 I10I.th Hilnover Street Carl i$le, r~ 17013 Dear H. ~Jbert X. Gilroy, Than~ ~ou for yow' letter of February 7, 1992. It has been my sincere hopu thilt the incident concerning C,-,,-l isle Subw'bAn Authm'it)"s dAmilge to my f,'ont )'cwd could have been settled in a fair and equitable manner months ago. rllthoL,gh I app'-eciatec1 CS(.\'S attl"ml,l to pic-kup snn,s' E,tons'E,, sha I e And other matter foreign to top 50i 1 , the effort was feebl. and totally inadequate. Hr. Hubert X. Gilroy, in accordance with the itemized estimilted cost mailed to Mr. E. F. Smith II, on September 16,1~91 1 will a:cept payment of 11467.19 to restore my Yilrd to its full beauty p,.iol' to CSA's e::cavAtion. In conclusian, 1 wish to advise you that, to date, I hilve not sO'_lght the advice of legal con5ul. Shoul d An eqL,itable <,g.'eement not be reClched in due time, it is mf intention tc pursue this matter to its fullest extent in the courts. Inasmuch as ou,. f,.on~ yard has been the subject of considerable embar,.assment to m',' famil, f,-om f,-is'nd., ..rId neigt-,bors 81 i~e, and because of the ino,"dinelte amount of time and effort eupended in bringing this mate,. to an end, I do n~t feel that it can be settled in Smell 1 Claims Cou,.t. Sincl"'''I!,1 y John Otto cc The Rot:: s Mr. E. F. Smi th, I I, Ch, CSA Mr. H. Bear, Ch, NH TOWNSHIP COMMONWFALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF: CUMBERLAND CIVIL COMP~INT PLAINTIFF r ., NAMe... i\lXHJII John & Carolyn 'Otto 2720 Spring Rd Carlisle, PA 17013 .J YeQ.ClILHo.: 09-2-01 OJ NMle: Hon. PAULA P. CORREAL Add._, EAST WING - COURTHOUSE 1 COURTHOUSE SQUARE CARLISLE, PA ~~,a17) 240-6564 17013-0000 L VS. DEFENOANT: r .....E...NllllUS Contractor: ., E.Lee Koch, Supt. & James Slyder Carlisle Suburban Water Auth. 580 Chestnut E 240 Clearwater Dr. HT. Hblly Sprir. LCarlisle, PA 17013 PA 17065 .J Docket No.: CV-283-95 Date Flied: 06-06-95 FlUNG COSTa $ SERVING COSTS $ TOTAL $ AMOUNT 1,4.00 27.50 71.50 DATE P^,D / / / / 06 / 06/ 95 TO THE DEFENDANT: The above named plalntlff(s) asks judgment against you for $ 1/,00.00 togelher w~h costs upon the lollowlng claim (Civil fines must Include citation or the statute 01 ordinance violated): On or about June 14,1991, Contractor dug plaintiffs yard to lay/connect utilities to Michael & Lindo Rotz's house at 2731 Spring Rd. Ottors plants, and lawn were destroyed, top soil wns not saved, and their black- top driveway was damaged. Supervisor and Contractor were negligent. Damage went beyond reasonable expectations nnd requirementsoCi:Iie-jiiii site, and exceeded verbal and written agreements between Otto. and Rotzs, and Koch. Claim is for replncement of ten yenr old plants, sod, drive.,. way repnir nnd attendant labor. I, John & Carolyn Otto verily that the facts selforth In this complaint ale true and correct to the best of my knowledge, Information, and belief, This statemantls made subject to the penalties 01 Section 4904 of the Crimes Code (1 B PA, S.C,A. S4904) lelated to sworn falsification 10 authorities, Plnlnti",s At1ornoy: Add,o..: Tolophono: IF YOU INTEND TO ENTER A DEFENSE TO THIS COMPLAINT, NOTIFYTHIS OFFICE IMMEDIATELY AT THE ABOVE TELEPHONE NUMBER. YOU MUST APPEAR AT THE HEARING AND PRESENT YOUR DEFENSE. UNLESS YOU DO, JUDGMENT WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU BY DEFAULT, If you have a claim against tho plaintiff which Is within distrlcljustice jurisdiction and which you Intend to assort at the hearing, you mustlile II on a complaint lorm at this office al least liva (5) days befora Iho date sot lor the hearing, ff you have a claim against tho plaintiff which is not within dislrlctjustice jurisdiction, you may requostlnformatlon from this office as 10 the procedures you may follow. II you ore disabled and lequlre asslstsnce, pleaoe contoclthe Moglstellal District olflce stthe address above. Aorc 300A.94 . COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF: CUMBERLAND NOTICE OF INTENT TO DEFEND Mag. OItl No . 09-2-01 PLAINTIFF: , NAME OI'!'AcpIua .., roTTO, JOHN & CAROLYN 2720 SPRING RD CARLISLE, PA 17013 L ...J DEFENOANT: VB. r- NAME and AIXlfESS 'E. LEE ItOCK, SUPERINTENDENT" ET Ail 240 CLEARWATER DR CARL. SUBURBAN WATER AtlTIl ~LISLE, PA 17013 ...J DockelNo,: CV-0000283-95 Date Filed: 6/06/95 OJ Name: rion PAULA P. CORREAL , ......" EAST WING -. COURTHOUSE 1 COURTHOUSE SQUARE CARLISLE, PA ~~_:017) 240-6564 17013-0000 JOHN & CAROLYN OTTO 2720 SPRING RD CARLISLE, PA 17013 HEARING: CIVIL ACTION HEARING Dale: 07/10/95 Place: P.O. BOX 155 27 W. BIG SPRING AVENUE NEWVILLE PA 17241 Time: 10: 00 AM PLAINTIFF: OTTO, JOHN & CAROLYN You are hereby notified thaI the defendant named below has given notice 01 his Intenllo presenl a defense allhe hearing lnlhe above case, ~ DEFENDANT: E. LEE KOCH, SUPERINTENDENT, t. - !..':' ,rl\"' Date G2e<- G&--{ .......,....,......., :;'..6Jst~irJ.Ju'sJii:e;'.', . .:....~:J'..... . ....; "'~' .:..;': .' ~ ..... . . ,-. . '-SEAL,.....,.. -, : ~; _' .;,0," I. . :;.-,; . _.. . .... I,' ~ . ,_ . ~.'~', .... 00 '.:: ~ ...... . ,'.'Il. : ...t"'" '. . '. " : ........: -00 ...........;. "'0 I "["10'. .,- 0",., I ...... 11.1........ My commission expires firsl Monday 01 January, 2000 . AOPC 623-93 COMMONWEALTt;l OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF: cuMBERLAND , ~ ';,~.9..TICE OF~IN:r.EN:r^,T.Q DEFEND \ ....g.OI.t No: 09-2-01 PLAINTIFF: ............00.."" roTTO, JOHN & CAROLYN' I 2720 SPRING RD CARLISLE, PA 17013 L -l VS. DEFENDANT: r,; NAME and AOORE.99 E. LEE KOCH, SUPERINTENDENT" ET AU 240 CLEARWATER DR CARL. SUBURBAN WATER AUTH ~LISLE, PA 17013 -l DocketNo,: CV-00002B3-95 Dale Filed: 6/06/95 OJ NamtI: Hon. PAULA P. CORREAL ..".." EAST WING - COURTHOUSE 1 COURTHOUSE SQUARE CARLISLE, PA T.~_.: 17l7) 240-6564 17013-0000 JOHN & CAROLYN OTTO 2720 SPRING RD CARLISLE, PA 17013 HEARING: CIVIL ACTION HEARING Dale: 07/10 95 " Place: \ , , P.O. BOX 155 27 W. BIG 'SPRING AVENUE NEWVILLE PA 17241 Time: :10:00 AM PLAINTIFF: OTTO, JOHN & CAROLYN You are hereby nolified lhalthe defendanl named below has given nollce of his inlenlto plesent a defense at the hearing in the above case. DEFENDANT: JAMES SLYDER, CONTRACTOR 6- /9-C(.c;- Date @. ~__~i , District JusTice " , My commission expires first Monday 01 January, 2000 . SEAL '. '" AOPC 623,~3 -' . . :'';"ii.:.: r.XlE,', ith c~i(.o/'1~ ... .:..:.)(~l-';-.:; ,....;:...: : u'__ ~ .-...,' '~'.,._:: iu.. ,:~ " '. '-..,-,'. :'; .: 1 ,: " U,~,,-<'-E_~. -,-,"! ..c. 1"":, j';"J;_:~' (-:((. ',~ -:~ 1 ,~~ ". ,~ . :i:tf.,'"""! ~I .-.: -...:.. :.:;. "I <:.~ .~. .:,.... .~ 7CLr;C:E: "'1~iJ~~ J"V I \:IJL t/S1"IJD: P,YtD r.r{ OED< i~;',U'.L r-rCi::;ri nJ: o'm.:il O.t'~~~ f ~ i .! " .~ " -....~ '.. oJ...;, t', &: C';:-:,CL",; ~ tJ ',-nJ ,-. ,.i.....t. ;~.:.'::.::: t". z: .' ......::.:' !~'i:.\:, ,-,-t-'.' .:.,-,\JI'.., .'_ '_'~'i'l j ,,' " ~.. ...:.... . .. . -', .....;. ~; ..., . /' ...,'. . .--. - 1-.'" .', ...... ..~ -'. .'.,. ?;;'I ;.~.: .iT r,::-"7.,:;",; :.-. ~~~:i : _ ,,",.~:'; (~:~ r- ,'., 1-- ~ : _ !TL~\""- :-.;:_ --------.-------------.---- -_. :~:..;: ~.C;.I~.'_ .-:.;:r~..:..~~;.;_\ ;- ;"\.i~.:~2'i' - , .. .' .(': .~,,") ~3rr;[ii.-C Er,'_~: 1~ i7;;..--; H .ai'~J 1-)..':." .4. '..r3~ t:{'~.7', \ ,\.',~' . '~. , .-.,.. -' ." ..... .-... ...... I,_t"-L) !4...'J:':";' ~-;.: ~ 'f..r;:~'i ,- .\'-' .. ~'. ,- '--"',. , " :. ..~2.~; ,=,,'T'\~ , .~..- I.... ," .:< _-_0" _ ....~_.. ,_, ~-..-- ..-.-----..- --.- - -~_..._.- -.----.....------ ._':: 1._ ~.". ,:. " '>', -......-;..." - ..':'.''-':- "': -":"- " .: ..:l- .- ..-..-... ...-....-.---..-.-.-.--.....-...--..-----. ...._+- ..... ..,. . ,-, . . '''J_. !~. :: -~..... .-..-,. ---_.~~- ..--...-...-.....-. __ ...._.. _.~ _.h.'. .==--.,;:;...-~~-":;.=:;'~~ . .'. " .'.',1' ; )'.:_1'1 ,"" ''-':' '_'1.. I,." i;;. ~;:;"'~'" ~ I , r f'" r , .... .Q;tTE: (O:);E1' to, .:,.'(~~' C, ..(.((,;'..1:1 ,'-:.'.:" (;::~: I ~ I...' , . I..',' ..:' I I SCl~(E: p{ln~ r,y ii.~jE.. 1'::TrOD: F'1;rO BY ;::-1::0" t'\;'lJ{L, r~l.c:rPT '1'(1: J O. i.J ~:~ C,:{,CL 'il ~ Ci ;-.;:, "::.7L:ft ::.~: r;, jj (~ ".:. ;..,\. ....~, .. . -~ '. . .,; ~ .,' r:''';'(j''3-::i'JT t~~,C;i"~);-' JIG: --_.._-------- -..-------.,.. --...---.----.-.-.-----..---.-- ------- .... ,":1.7": tel i~li.. i.:: r.; .~ ..:-: .;-; r;- n::7" ~'. ~- ,.-,D.:3TAl-JLC r:::>--1: ~; i:'';.r"'j'{I.:Ti,:~ ~"";~'r3,'.Er:~..T' : ...."'....... \ \.' ~ ~ , ''';~l;',;G rl....;'::.:' i~~]' ~ " "j ..~ ,," , ,,:'.-1'''; ;.. :~~." ~~,~~','.:EF: s:t.:. /',.:il'!.. : 7 ':': :.' +j', ',I,.~ .'h',.'.,'Cj7: I '.t:' 'j ;".-r" .~ J . .: ,-."1 ,....'-'.-.. r--"'-.., ,.\_" I "0' '.:j':,;, j~_.:;::~r=T I.D: .''':'. 1';':,(; DlST ilJ: (.;-..'-: F'Pi.LA P.. cn-;r~~ CI~;"7 ~,'r~.o . ;-~'I.-;- ':-: ,~. ,-'- 1 CiJ ("\'.I-ii:U.:,=. ~":~,~~:: (t..ri. J::.l.E = ~, ,:..;::0: It (1.l~-57 Hr.:U-.;j R::::::':::'"Z: ~ (~'c,J.rr r:Fn_I.::::. ~'.-:u.~~.'r~~;':i.. .. - . '.., .,:, ,~_.. . ..:(.;...,' C.~ ,-:;..T .. ...,- . .-'" .'~--. 1""1., ,'11-1 ~',;_.~ , ~ . ...--..) '..(1.(.':1 .... "'-. ~'.' .'.'."- _.. ..-.... .,'.'. , - ...."....:..... '-', :-~~- .. '. :.'t.*!."" ~.I ";" (.,,.. ~ -:. .. ..- 1" ':-' .._..__" _u_.........._.__ ....-.- ----. -,' .....,.-. , .- "~! " ] !, t - -.- -'.-. ~ ,'.; ..;, (.:. , .' ..::". . . :.~. .~~ , .. .' " " :_iTL:'-.~ ~.:,_ , :,:.' ,-' _'o! .-- .-. -.. ...-.. . ...--_... " , , --.,.,. .... ___"__.0. COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF: CUMBERLAND' u.v,~No; 09-2-0~ OJ NaIM. Hon. PAULA P. CORREAL , ..._, EAST WING -, COURTHOUSE ~ COURTHOUSE SQUARE CARLISLE, PA ~~~,O~7)240-6564 ~70~3-0000 JOHN " CAROLYN OTTO 2720 SPRING RD CARLISLE, PA ~70~3 HEARING: CIVIL ACTION HEARING Date: 07/~0/95 NOTICE OF INTENT TO DEFEND PLAINTIFF: ........ AlXlIOS raTTO, JOHN " CAROLYN 2720 SPRING RD CARLISLE, PA ~70~3 L -, -I VS. OEFENOANT: r.; E. LEE KOCH, SUPERINTENDENT" 240 CLEARWATER DR CARL. SUBURBAN WATER AUTH ~ISLE, PA ~70~3 ...... "'" AIlllAES9 ET AIl , -Ii DocketNo.: CV-0000283-95 Date Flied: 6/06/95 Time: ~O I 00 AM Place: P.O. BOX ~55 27 W. BIG SPRING AVENUE NEWVILLE PA ~724~ PLAINTIFF: OTTO, JOHN" CAROLYN You are hereby notified that the defendant named below has given notice of his intent to plesent a defense at the hearing ,in the above case, DEFENDANT: E. LEE KOCH, SUPERINTENDENT, Q~ G&~~ t. - 1..' ;', ' Cf,' Date My commission expiles filst Monday of January, 2000 . Aope G23.93 <..' ".'. '" .... - ..... ;' t>Jsi(i!:l.jusJice>., . "'.0 . ., I :: ..;~.''''..' .-.. ":.. . . . ,'-. ..... - . .- , .t. : i;:: SEAL ',':: ',' ~ ~: . .:: I ..... :. ~ '0 0" '0. r .> . '" . ,\".....1 ':..,..... '0. ." . , . -00 ~, '. '. .., . . . .... ~! I' .... .....,...:........... COMMONWEALTI;t OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNlY OF: c:mmERLAND, ~mle.Elo.EINr.ENl.TO:DEI;ENb,' OJ Name; Hon. PLAINTlFF: NAME.-.d~ IQ'l'TO, JOHN & CAROLYN 2720 SPRING RD CARLISLE, PA 17013 L .., .' , 09-2-01 1Qg. Ottt. No.: PAULA P. CORREAL ....,"" EAST WING - COURTHOUSE 1 COURTHOUSE SQUARE CARLISLE, PA ,.........' (717) 240-6564 17013-0000 "-- . .J OEFENOANT: r;; NAMEand~ E. LEE KOCH, SUPERINTENDENT" 240 CLEARWATER DR CARL. SUBURBAN WATER AtlTH ~ISLE, PA 17013 V5. ET Ail .J: JOHN & CAROLYN OTTO 2720 SPRING RD CARLISLE, PA 17013 Docket No.: (N- 00002 83 - 95 Date Filed: 6/06/95 HEARING: CIVIL ACTION HEARING , Date:;.,0,7/10 95 Time: 10:..90 AM plac~:.._~L .._ ,., _, , , P.O.' BOX '155 27, W:' .BIG"SPRING AVENUE NEWVILLE"-PA 17241 PLAINTIFF: OTTO, JOHN << CAROLYN You are hereby notified that the defendant named below has given notice of his intent to present a defense at the hearing in the above case. DEFEND~NT: JAMES SLYDER, CONTRACTOR 6-/9-Cf.c; Date G?~ @....~i.. -' , , District Justice My commission expires first Monday of January, 2000 . SEAL " Aore 623,93 JOHN OTTO AND CAROLYN OTTO, PLAINTIFFS IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. EARL F, SMITH, II, E. LEE KOCH, JAMES SL YDER and CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY, DEFENDANTS 95-4276 CIVIL TERM IN RE: MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS BEFORE BAYLEY. J. ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this q..... day of February, 1998, IT IS ORDERED: (1) The motion of Earl F. Smith, II, E. Lee Koch and James Slyder for judgment on the pleadings, IS GRANTED. Plaintiffs' claims against these three defendants, IS DISMISSED. (2) The motion of the Carlisle Suburban Authority for judgment on the pleadings, IS DENIED. / Edgar B. Bayley, J. John Otto and Carolyn Otto, Pro se 2720 Spring Road Carlisle, PA 17013 Hubert X, Gilroy, Esquire For Defendants (I~..u.-~,(L ~/IO/'i8', --J .:..n. :saa _ .r*.-;rr~~ ..~\ ~\r;:..}.~..\~).I'" or.\)",..,n ',' '," ,-" ,,<, ,\\', , " \"l'o ..' \j\ Y'\ .... \~ .' ~'Q.~~~' ",-'/'\ ~,.,.;.; J~ .i '. ,.)..\;...' :.:. r\ ,\.~....\::-. ....~;.j~\:. '\J~ ',,;..1'-" JOHN OTTO AND CAROLYN OTTO, PLAINTIFFS IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. EARL F. SMITH, II, E, LEE KOCH, JAMES SL YDER and CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY, DEFENDANTS 95-4276 CIVIL TERM IN RE: MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS BEFORE BAYLEY. J. OPINION AND ORDER OF COURT BAYLEY, J., February 9.1998:- On August 9, 1995, plaintiffs, John Otto and Carolyn Otto, instituted this suit against defendants Earl F. Smilh, II, E. Lee Koch, James Slyder and Carlisle Suburban Authority, Defendants filed preliminary objections to the complaint on August 25, 1995, Plaintiffs, as of course, filed an amended complaint on September 1, 1995.1 In paragraph 6 of their amended complaint, plaintiffs aver: On July 10, 1991, Plaintiffs (Grantors) executed a contract with the CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY (Grantee) for the purpose of laying and connecting new sewer and water lines to the existing mains on Plaintiffs [sic] property. Workmen did not save top soil [sic] and their backhoe and excavated debris damaged Plaintiffs [sic] blacktop driveway and destroyed lawn and plants, See Exhibit lOA." (Emphasis added,) The contract attached as Exhibit A to the complaint is dated June 10, 1991, not 1. Pa, Rule of Civil Procedure 1028(c)(1). 95-4276 CIVIL TERM July 10, It Is titled "DEED OF EASEMENT, RIGHT-OF.WAY AND RIGHT OF ENTRY AGREEMENT," The document sets forth that the Carlisle Suburban Authority had undertaken construction of a building sewer/sewer lateral to connect a property "Immediately to the East of [the Otto's] property across Pennsylvania Route 34," The Ottos granted and conveyed to Carlisle Suburban Authority "[a] permanent easement and a free, uninterrupted and unobstructed right-of-way" on their property to allow for the construction of that "building sewer/sewer lateral line." The agreement further provided: The [Carlisle Suburban Authority], in connection with the exercise of any of the rights and privileges herein granted, shall restore the surface of the said premises of [the Otto's], as nearly as practical to its contour and condition as existed prior to the exercise of said rights and privileges, within ninety days of termination of each occurrence. Plaintiffs aver in paragraph 7 of their amended complaint: Plaintiffs [sic] contract with the CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY has been breached [sic] Plaintiffs [sic] driveway, lawn and plants have not been " . , restored to Its original contour and condition. . . within ninety days . , .' A copy of the contract Is attached as Exhibit 'B.' (Emphasis added.) Plaintiffs sought judgment against defendants in the amount of $1,500 for lawn, plant and driveway damage, and $2,000 consequential damages. Defendants filed a motion for judgment on the pleadings that was briefed and argued on January 28, 1998, The individual defendants seek to be dismissed because they were not parties to the written contract dated June 10, 1991, which plaintiffs have sued upon. All defendants seek a dismissal of the action based on the -2- ...~ 95-4276 CIVIL TERM four year statute of limitations for contract actions set forth in the Judicial Code at 42 Pa,C.S, Section 5525.2 The written contract dated June 10, 1991, that plaintiffs have sued upon was entered into solely with the Carlisle Suburban Authority, Plaintiffs plead that Earl F. Smith, II, Is the chairman of the Carlisle Suburban Authority, E. Lee Koch is the superintendent of the Authority, and James Slyder Is the contractor for the Authority. .3. Plaintiffs cannot recover damages against the individual defendants based on their complaint seeking damages for the alleged breach of their written contract with the Authority, Accordingly, judgment will be entered in favor of the individual defendants. As to the defense of the statute of limitations, plaintiffs averred in their amended complaint that: On or about June 16, 1991, and in recognition of thoir failure to separate topsoil and undersoll, defendants delivered about one cubic yard of fill dirt containing rocks, stones and weeds. . ., (Emphasis added,) Plaintiffs further averred that they instituted a civil action for breach of their contract with the Authority against defendants before a District Justice, and that suit was dismIssed without preJudice on July 10, 1995.' That suit was instituted on June 6, 1995. In an action for breach of contract, the statute of limitations begins to run from 2. Defendants raised the defense of the statute of limitations in new matter. Pa, Rule of Civil Procedure 1 030(a) , 3, Plaintiffs did not file an appeal from the dismissal by the District Justice of their suit under Pa, Rule of Civil Procedure DJ 1002. Rather, they filed a complaint under Pa. Rule of Civil Procedure 1007, 95-4276 CIVIL TERM the time of breach. Romeo & Sons, Inc. v. Yezbak & Sons, Inc., 539 Pa, 390 (1995), Considering the date of the alleged breach as June 18, 1991, the last date work was performed, the applicable dates are: Date of Contract June 10, 1991 Defendants' date of breach June 18, 1991 Suit Instituted before a District Justice June 6, 1995 Suit dismissed by District Justice without prejudice July 10, 1995 Complaint filed In this case August 9, 1995 The four year statute of limitations In 42 Pa.C,S. Section 5525 ended on June 17, 1995, four years from the date the last work was performed on the subject contract which was June 18, 1991. Thus, plaintiffs' suit filed before the District Justice on June 6, 1995, was within the four year statute of limitations. The dismissal of a complaint wilhout prejudice from the entry of a voluntary nonsuit does not toll the statute of limitations, WIlliams Studio Division of Photography by Tallas, Inc. v. Nationwide Mutual Fire Insurance Company, 380 Pa. Super, 1 (1988). The reason for that rule Is to prevent plaintiffs from extending a period of limitations based on plaintiffs' own conduct. See Rosenberg v. Nicholson, 408 Pa, Super. 502 (1991). In contrast, the dismissal of plaintiffs' action without prejudice by the District Justice In the present case did not result from plaintiffs' conduct. Accordingly, we conclude that the following Section of the Judicial Code at 42 Pa.C.S. Section 5535 pertaining to the limitation of time in Instituting an action is applicable to this case: -4- 95-4276 CIVIL TERM Effect of other actions and proceedings (a) Termination of prior matter,- (1) If a civil action or proceeding Is timely commenced and Is terminated, a party, or his successor In Interest, may, notwithstanding any other provision of this subchapter, commence a new action or proceeding upon the aame cause of action within one year after the termination and any other party may interpose any defense or claim which might have been Interposed In the original acllon or proceeding, (2) Paragraph (1) does not apply to: (I) An action to recover damages for Injury to the person or for the death of an individual caused by the wrongful act or neglect or unlawful violence or negligence of another, (i1) An action or proceeding terminated by a voluntary nonsuit, a discontinuance, a dismissal for neglect to prosecute the action or proceeding, or a final judgment upon the merits, (Emphasis added.) Under Section 5535(a), plaintiffs had one year to Institute this action following the dismissal of their suit before the District Justice without prejudice on July 10, 1995. Accordingly, this suit Instituted by complaint on August 9, 1995, is within the saving period of the limitation on time as set forth In Section 5535 of the Judicial Code, For the foregoing reasons, the following order is entered. ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this ~ day of February, 1998, IT IS ORDERED: (1) The motion of Earl F. Smith, II, E, Lee Koch and James Slyder for judgment on the pleadings, IS GRANTED. Plaintiffs' claims against these three defendants, IS DISMISSED. (2) The motion of the Carlisle Suburban Authority for judgment on the pleadings, IS DENIED. -5- 95-4276 CIVIL TERM John Otto and Carolyn Otto, Pro se 2720 Spring Road Carlisle, PA 17013 Hubert X. Gilroy, Esquire For Defendants :saa . ~"""~';.~' / / / -6- JOHN OTTO CAROLYN OTTO IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiffs NO, 4276 CIVIL 1995 v CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY Defendant RULE 1312.1. The Petition for Appointmcnt of Arbitrators shall be substantially in the following fonn: PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS TO TIlE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT: s I, JOHN OTTO ,cI\:lIm:sllWor the plaintiff~in the above actionl(llt<~, respectfully represents that: 1. The above-captioned action ~1<lI~ is t;Inl)cat issue. 2. The claim of the plaintiff In the action is $ 3500.00 The counterclaim of the dcfendant in the action is 0 00 TIle following attorneys are Interested in the case(t)dls counselor arc otherwise disqualified to sit as arbitrators: Hubert X. Cilro , William Duncan ~?~J~ lLJ~ k:( WHEREFORE. your petitioner prays your Honorable Courlto apPoint~e (3) arbitrators to whom the case shall be submitted, esp, ctfU!U&tted, John Otto, Pro se ~ ORDEROFC qr: AND NOW. I, r . 19_. in consideration of the foregoing petition, ~t./~ /; ~AQ.~.4/te.a., (( ,1..- -t- Esq.. /,;....i. J ,e<,~u2. Esq" and ~.~ ({ ,}1A~( a'~ . Esq" arc appointed arbitrators in the above captioned action (or actions) as p ed for. ~ l P,J. ... .:so (:; ~ (,- c r{ In ,..: .. ;).~ '" .'- \r) ~~ ..:z ~.) :;. c'1 - '<-.) ~.~ <-{ ~ ~t; u.. ....,...:, :t',*, ',- ~,.. r- ','I" u: .,~( 1\ "'- (.:2 61 c.::iE cc u.,& ...x r-;] . :c :~ ~ co ;::. CI\ U ~ Cb , , -c:: Q;. \ \i) - * " '-..: L -/{.... A JOHN OTTO and CAROLYN OTTO, :IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiffs . . v : , 'CIVIL ACTION - 95 - 4276 : I . ( EARL F. SMITH, II and E. LEE KOCH and JAMES SLYDER, Defendants . . . . . . SUPPLEMENTAL ANSWER Attached hereto and marked Exhibit "A", "B" and "c" are the exhibits which were referred to in Defendant's original Answer and New Hatter filed in the above case. ubert X. Gilro , Esquire Broujos, Gilroz & Houston, P.C. 4 North Hanov Street Carlisle, PA 7013 717-243-4574 1",.-., .IM(jNWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA JUNTY or: CUMBERLAND . CIVIL COMPLAINT '- ...~- .=-~ PlAINTIFF r ., ..-eo tMI flo. DJ NeIM Hurl NAUI."" Aoonc.. John ~ Cnrol,n Otto H20 Sprll111 K~ Carlisle, PA 1701] 09.2-01 PAULA P. CORREAL ....- EAST WING - COURTIIOUSE 1 COURTIIOUSE SQUARE CAI\LISI.E, I'A ".._.17171240-6564 17013-0000 L .J VS, IlbrGNDANJ r E.Leo Knch. Supt. b Carli>>le Suburban Walur 240 Clearwatur Dr. LCarllsJe, PA 1701) I~ockel No,: CV-28]-95 J L:.~:rllutl: _ 06-06-9) _. _ - NA.... WwI ADDNSS COlIlCllClur: .., James Slydur Auth. 580 CheBtnul ~ HT.llo11y Sprir PA 17U6~ .J ------- FILlNO! SERVING lOTAL AMOllNt t,4.0U '] .50 ,~O DATE PAID .,L_.I __1.. / 06/ 06/ 95 TO THE DEF ;: 'IOA '10 above named plalnlllf(s) asks Judgmenl against you fOI $..!.!'.22. 00 logalher wilh ,usls upon Ihe follOWIng claim (ClvilllneB musllncluda cilallon of tho statute 01 ordlnanca violaled): On or about June 14.1991. Contractor dug plaintiffs yard to lay/connect utilities tu Michael ~ Linda Rotz's bouse at 27]1 Spring Rd. Otto's plants 8nd lawn were destroyed. top noil WRn not saved. and their black- top driveway was damaged. SlIperviaor and Contractor were negURent. Damage weO[ beyolld redsonable ellpectations and requiremenls of the job ~Ile. and e~ceeded verbal Rnd written agreements between OLios and ROtZ9. nnd KDch. Claim 1s for ruplacemunl of ten year old plants. sod. drive- way repaIr and attendant lapor, John & Calolyn Otto ' I, verily IhollhO lacts set 'onh In this complaInt oro true end correcl to Ihe besl of my knowledge. Inlormallon, and belief. This stalemonlls modo subjoctlo UUI penaltlos 01 Section 4904 of the Crimes Code (18 PA. S.C.A. S 4904) relatod to sworn 11IIsificalion 10 authorities. r:llln~."'. ^hornay: Add,...: T oltpho"e; ____ . IF YOU INTEND TO ENTER A DEFENSE TO THIS COMPLAINT. NOTIFY THIS OFFICE IMMEDIATELY AT THE ABOVE TELEPHONF. NUMBER, YOU MUST APPEAR AT THE HEARING AND PRESENT YOUR DEFENSE. UNLESS YOU DO, JUDGMENT WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU BY DEFAULT. If you have a claim againST the plllintill which Is wilhln district lusllce jurisdiction and which you inlond to assen al the healing, you musl fila lion II complaillllorm allhis olhco alleast live (5) days bel ore thll dale sellar tho 110all/19 If you have a cln'''' agalnslthe plalnll<< which is not within dlstricllusllce juristllclion, you may roqueslll,furmallun lrollllhls olllco as to thll procedures you may lollow, If you a,. dlubled and lequlru 8s818lance, ploue conl8cllho Ma 18torlal DI8111cl oNlce .llhl addles. above. EXHIBIT Aope JOM,V4 I A 11/17/05 18:00 FAr717 2'0 U88 COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYlVANIA COUNTY OF: C'tIIDIULAJm ....Ihl..... O. J. 1011-2-01) ... OJ Sm'UlNJIBRGIlR 1ilI002 NOTICE OF JUDOMENTfTRANSCRIPT PI.AlNT1Ff; tUMllM~ rcn-ro. JOIDf " CAJIOLY1Il' 2720 8P&I_0 RD CARLXSLB. PA 17013 L YB. DEfENDANT: HAM;;__AClCQ:. Ii:. LJrII: Jl:0CIl, StJPlU1~&n&n&.JBHT" 240 CLEAR"ATBJl DR CARL . SOBtJUAJil WATBJI. AtrrB ~18LB. PA 17013 1t'l'Ail 0'-2-01 .., QJ..... MIl.. PAULA. P. CORllEAL -. EAST W:OW - COl1JI.TBOUSJo: 1 COUJl.TBOU8B BQU~ CAJlLXBLE, PA f~:~171 240-6564 _J 1.7013-0000 A'1"1'01UIBY DEII' paXVATB HUBERT GXLROY.BSQ .. K :RlUIuv.... ST CARLXSLB. PA 17013 Docket No" CV-00002113 -95 011I0 F1lod: 6/06/95 &" THIS IS TO N011FY YOU THAT: DXSM%SSKD W/O PJl.BJODXCK o Judgmont WDS entllred lor: (Nomo) o Judgment was ontnrnd ogaInst: (Neme) In tho amount DI $ on: (Oato) o Damages wll be asllllllSllCl on: (011Io & Tlmll) 00 11l1s case dllIm16sed wfIhoul prejudice. D Poosssslon grunted, O p~~lon gra1lDd H money lucJgment is not satJsliod wlthln thirty dllyll. o PnsHllllon not granlnd, o I.8vy Is stayed for _ dllyll or 0 generally staynd. o Objection to IDI/Y has been IIlod and hearing will bo hold: Dato: Place: Amount DI Judgmont Judgment Co8ts Inter1llll on JucJgmonr AItomoy F8llS $.00 ,.00 $.00 $.00 $.00 TOTAL 11mo: ANY PARTY HAS THe RIGKT TO APPI!AL WITHIN 30 DAYS OF lliE DATI! O~ JUDGMENT BY I'lUNG A NancE O~ APPEAL WlTl1 THE PRO OTARY I CL2RK OF THe COURT OF COMMON PLl!AS. CML DIVlSlON. 07-10-95 0010 ~~ .0Islrk:tJUSllcD I CDft/fy lhallhls 15 B lru~rrecl copy 01 tho mco ollho procoedlngll contalnlng The jUllglnont. It-17-9.5 DBle .J{ ~ tI3 .)t...L...L~'''<ill . OIstrlctJU8tIClI MV comml88lon -.cpl''''' f.nIt Mondlly III January. 2000, SEAL AOPc 315-114 EXHIBIT I & 11/17/!1:. 15:110 TX/IlX NO.0281 1'.002 . UPPER MIFFLIN TOWNSHIP LOWER MIFFLIN TOWNSHIP UPPER FRANKFORD TOWNSHIP LOWER FRANKFORD TOWNSHIP NEWVILLE BOROUOH NORTH NEWTON TOWNSHIP WEST PENNSBORO TOWNSHIP PENN TOWNSHIP HELEN B, SHULENBEROER DISTRICT JUSTICE OISTRICT 3.2 'l1 W RIG SPfUNG AVENU[ PO (JOlll!!!! N[WVllLE, PA 1'241 OFFICE 776.3167 December 12. 1995 E. Lee Koch, Superintendent, Et A1 240 Clearwater Dr. Carl. Suburban Water Authority Carlisle, PA 17013 RE: Civil Complaint CV-283-95 John & Carolyn Otto vs. E. Lee Koch. Superintendent., et a1 Dear Mr. Koch: The hearing on the above mentioned complaint was held in my office on July 10. 1995. At the close of the hearing I dismissed the complaint due to the statue of limitations, but unfortunately our Adm. Office of PA Courts computer does not have a block for this type of dismisss1. On the docket transcript the block is marked "TillS CASE DISMISSED WITHOlTl' PREJUDICE" for lack of another dismissal block not being available. IN REALITY THE CASE WAS DISMISSED DUE TO THE STATUE OF LIMITATION with the defendant receiving a $.00 judgment. Sincerely, ~~~ ~~&_~~ HELEN B. SHULENBERGER~ District Justice cc: John & Carolyn Otto Hubert X. Gilroy EXHIBIT I c ~: >- c-: '.. ., I. .. '. - luf N ) C\ " .... rl>; , It.. '"oj 6.:_ " 'J" .'- r, 1".:- :,! 113' C" .'1- '. ~!l' .. ,",j LJ~ . , ,.. l~ r. L... II, r- , L. <.:r ".) PYS510 1995-04276 Cumberland County Civil Case OTTO JOHN ET AL (VS) SMITH prothonotary's Office Page Inquiry EARL FIlET AL 2 Reference No..1 Filed........1 Case Type.....: COMPLAINT Time.........: Judgment. . . . . . 1 .00 Execution Date Judge Assignedl BAYLEY EDGAR B Sat/Dis/Gntd.. Jur~ Trial.... Hig er Court 1 Hig er Court 2 06111/97 PETITION TO VACATE ARBITRATOR APPOINTMENT 06/11/97 COURT ORDER - DATED 6/11/97 - IN RE PETITION TO VACATE ARBITRATOR'S APPOINTMENT - APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS IS VACATED - BY HAROLD E SHEELY PJ - COPIES MAILED 6/11/97 6/18/97 BILLED COUNTY FOR ARBITRATION CHAIRMAN PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT BY JOHN OTTO PLFF LAWN AND PLANT DAMAGE TO PLAINTIFFS PERSONAL PROPERTY PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT BY HUBERT X GILROY ESO MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS FILED BY DEFENDANTS .................*.........*................****..............****.............. * Escrow Information * * Fees & Debits Bea Bal Pvmts/Ad1 End Bal * *......*.**.*...*.*.*...*******.*.**....*~...*..,*.*.....***********...***...*** 8/09/1995 15156 0/00/0000 0/00/0000 10/29/97 12/05/97 35.00 35.00 .00 .50 .50 .00 5.00 5.00 .00 5.00 5.00 .00 15.00 15.00 .00 15.00 15.00 .00 ------------------------ ------------ 75.50 75.50 .00 .....................**.........***.................*...........***....**...**.. * End of Case Information * ............****....**....***...****.........***...*..............******.***.... COMPLAINT TAX ON CMPLT SETTLEMENT JCP FEE APPT OF ARBITRA APPT OF ARBITRA ~ BROU.JOS, OIl.ROV IIr HOUSTON. P. C. . ATTO..NIlV. AT LAw .. HOftTH HAHOV." .,.,.KIIT C.....U.L.E. "lCNN.VL.Y"'N'''' '701:11 (7'''1 ........,.4 7...'..0 ,;-:.:..:..~~. 1 JOHN OTTO and CAROLYN OTTO, Plaintiffs :IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA . . v . . . . :CIVIL ACTION - 95 - 4276 EARL F. SMITH, II and E. LEE KOCH and JAMES SLYDER, . . . . . . Defendants : PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS Defendants, by their attorneys Broujos, Gilroy & Houston, P.C., set forth the following in the nature of Preliminary Objections: Plaintiff's complaint fails to state a cause of action against any of the three defendants. 2 All three defendants demurrer to Plaintiff's complaint. WHEREFORE, Defendants request your Honorable Court to dismiss Plaintiff's complaint. Respectfully submitted, Hubert X. Gilro , Esquire Attorney for D fendants Broujos, Gilroy & Houston, P.C. 4 North Hanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-4574 ~ . "tf;: ::c: C- ... .... M ~~ ....,. WI'"": - .': "_~L.~..r r::-.-. ", .~ .... ~ " . :~I 'f';. '" " ,,-, ....... .., :::> ~ ~J: l: " b.c..:. '" ~"!::' $a> .. . -........ ~ JOHN OTTO and CAROLYN OTTO, :IN THE COURT OF COHHON PLEAS OF :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : : : :CIVIL ACTION - 9S - 4276 : Plaintiffs v EARL F. SMITH, I I and E. LEE KOCH and JAHES SLYDER, . . : Defendants . . MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS Defendants, Earl F. Smith, II, E. Lee Koch, James Slyder and Carlisle Suburban Authority, by their attorneys Broujos, Gilroy & Houston, P.C., set forth the following Hotion for Judgment on the Pleadings: 1 Defendants request that Defendant Earl F. Smith, II be dismissed as a Defendant on the basis that the pleadings relating to Defendant Smith do not form any basis for a claim in fact or in law. 2 Defendants request that Defendant E. Lee Koch be dismissed as a Defendant on the basis that the pleadings relating to Defendant Koch do not form any basis for a claim in fact or in law. 3 Defendants request that Defendant James Slyder be dismissed as a Defendant on the basis that the pleadings relating to Defendant Slyder do not form any basis for a claim in fact or in law. 4 The pleadings disclose that Plaintiff's claim, as it relates to a negligence claim, is barred by the Statute of Limitations and Plaintiff's claim should be dismissed. 5 The pleadings disclose that Defendant's claim, as it relates to a breach of contract between Plaintiff and Defendant Carlisle Suburban Authority dated June 14, 1991, is barred by the applicable Statute of Limitations. WHEREFORE, Defendants request that judgment on the pleadings as outlined above be entered into favor of the Defendants. u ert X. Gi roy, Esquire BROUJOS, GILROY & HOUSTON, P.C. 4 North Hanover street Carlisle, PA 17013 717-243-4574 ,- .-:, .. L": j:. {'.~ " ,', l" " ("I F , l- ( J ,.:>.. '. , I'. r- LJ C' ',) , fL.ol,/oJTlrrS '. .;jt'#J ;' C}J;l.Ll{ '7'1l1 tf) (T Co VV j){:/'t-X) O/IA.-7/7 '. r:"I1l L F: SO, ,1'/--4 ...i ( i?, Let KorH <./'fa) ,:-s SLy!) '(; f) &lIll S li5. JV'~t.A2~P{AfTf(,;'>, t IN TIlE COURT OF COtlMON PLiAS OF ClltIBERt..\ND COUNTY, PENNSYLVAIlIA NO. 4.2 7 f:, CIVIL 19qC RULE 1312-1. The Petition for Appointment of Arbitrators shall be substant~ally in the following form: P~TI~!ON FOR APPOIN~IENT OF ARBITRATORS TO THE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT: '-.JC#'AI C""/ K' s , counsel for the plaintifr/~Adane in ^ the above action (or ae;1eBs)~ respectfully represents that: 1. The above-c~ptioned action (~, y~eieRE) is (~,~~ at issue. 2. The claim of the plaintiff in the action is S ItlCO. 00 ~t../> The counterclail:l of the defendant in the actien is - 0- ('D>7p ~ The following attorneys are interested in wise disqualified to sit as arbitrators: FSQV, aC: WHEREFORE, your petitioner prays your Honorable Court to appoint three (3) arbitrators to whom the case shall be sucoitted. ORDER or COURT ReS~tct;ullY submitted, -2it-L(c.t.~ AND NOW, APt(.,' L .;...$ . 19.!t.:Z. in consideration of the foregoing petition, VA hl >'....! goCAIc.. Esq., /Y) ul2ftl-L WA If~, .I " Esq., and D: 'ZAhdA g.()N L ,Esq.. 3re appointed arbitrators in the above-captioned action (or actions) as prayed for. By hf Court, ., ,f(t.... f~ {, /X' / P. J. ! r--"'_(' :',..... C'. . . ..-;! ';7 .. , .' :.': ;:,1] I .' .. .. _ ..s> 1'(\ t/) ti.~ ~i\: ~ci '., ~ ~ '- (;, I " I n" , . \,:' ."" -', (', " ",1 , Q <;) \i) .J - ,"' ~ ,- (11}17 -plUhJ M_(.".t jrl /iJ,"-",11' l :7:0 Spr 1 ng r,oad Carl isle, PA 17013 - 8708 May 16. 1997 Court Administrator Cumber 1 and COLlnty Court House One Court House Square Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013 REF: C I V I L ACT! Otl NO. 95-4:76 OTTOs v SMITH et al Dear Mr. Richard Pierce: It is requested that reference case listed for Argument Court on May 28, 1997, be relisted for said court on August 13 , 1997. Plaintiff is unable to attend Argument Courts listed for May 28 and June 25, 1997, because of prior plans to be out of town. Hubert X. Gilroy, Esquire, Attorney for the defendants has concurred in this proposed change. -incerely, ohn Otto or F'l aintiffs c:c:: Gilroy I-- Proth off PRAECIPE ~'OR 1.l!>TlNG CASE FOR ARGUMENT (Must be typewritten and subnitted in duplicate) TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY: Please list the within matter for the next Arg\ment Court. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be stated in full) JOHN OTTO and CAROLYN OTTO , , ( Plaintiff) , ' , vs. EARl; F. SmTH. 11 and E. LEE KOCH and JAMES SLYDER t.' ( Defendant) No. 4276 Civil 19 9S 1. State matter to be argued (1.e.. plaintiff's mtion for new trial. defendant's demurrer to complaint, etc.): Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings 2. Identify counsel lOtIo will argue case: (a) for plaintiff: Pro-Se Address: (b) for defendant: Address: Hubert X. Gilroy, Esquire 3. I will notify all parties in writing within 1:100 days that this case has been listed for argunent. 4. Argurent Court Date: J:-~J 11-1'''1 Dated: for Ile f cnda R X. Gilroy. ERqulre ," .. 'I' , , 'L "1 .!! "i..,J :-~ i':~'; I', 'I t! -,(.' I',' (.!' d___~_~~:.~_._..:.tL_~~_~.~l_.__.__.l~.:.~.:_L_ .",ii. _ L ,-' /,', " .,3~H::.t~1 i c;;" t: '~ ~ , L' 1 r" ~.' . ; l'.~' 't" 1,,'1 , , ,;..: ~ r. .'_ 'cq:,'.,': , ' ~.~U; :. ~ 1"- L+~~I IL1.~ I ~I'::'~ '1' [:i:- i ;:.::; ,J~1;; , :.., (:\ ('" .;Ii,l, __'c... '_ :""L ";,...; ,,; ,"" , , , ' ..\..i , ~- <.\ '_ 1 ~ ;I." I,:,';i' ,- -: i '-:, ~ ;'Klrr,:!~l <'Ie ("1"', 'il' '~,' c :_,C-d~tl:;:":';~ , .> <" I, ", '-;';l, .','n .L . ~ . '~. r ~ ,',; <Ii. \.1 :;1 ; f "L' _ ',,'-' ~', j , . i . L,i '_' ,; 1'; ','., l;liGtbOlrro?d '. ; """ '''r''r.' ~, .J .Ji.. , , .. -, .~, ." .." SWORN TO ANO SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME THIS 24TH DAY OF MARCH 1997. f1vr.a~.(b '-.. , NOTARY PUBLIC - 1 ~,.,..,. '...~.. - ""'1 :~'\C\IC'h ~:'-l"'-;J ".J """'j , '_ :;....../cl.,.l, I~. 1;"_. . ~ .~....,,- ,.,....,." \.:. " \,1 ..1. " (';' I' f'- C ;- .......... .~.... , \ \ \ ~ '. . . , BROU.JOS, GILROY Be HOUSTON. P. C. ATTOftNlIYa AT LAW " HaATH HANOyaft aTftlEln" CARU8L.K. PENNSYLVANIA 17013 17'''. .......117" .,o.-,e..o . ,SEP 2 3 199B~ JOHN OTTO and CAROLYN OTTO, : IN THE COURT OF COHHON PLEAS OF :CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiffs . . . . v . . EARL F. SMITH, II and E. LEE KOCH and JAHES SLYDER, :CIVIL ACTION - 95 - 4276 : Defendants . . . . . . COrm:r ORDER AND NOW, this ~ day of ~, 1996, upon consideration of the attached Motion, it is ordered and directed as follows: 1 The above captioned case is stricken from the October 2, 1996 Argument Court List. 2 Defendants are directed to file a responsive pleading to Plaintiff's First Amended Complaint within 30 days from the date of this Order. // / , / B\~/J ~ ac:: John Otto Hubert X. Gilroy, Esquire _ ~..~ ....,oA~M. 'l/:.l'f/'ltp. .,s.f. / r! ~'. '-c'-l:"!'~'- . -./ c '-:~, ' " If: l '-.' ',' "1.....,./ , .~.'I;....jl\:r,,'.d JOHN OTTO and CAROLYN OTTO, Plaintiffs tIN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF :CUHBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : . . v : :CIVIL ACTION - 95 - 4276 Defendants . . . . . . . . ~ 'I I t: I EARL F. SMITH, II and E. LEE KOCH and JAHES SLYDER, MO'l'ION TO STRIKE CASE FRa-I ARGUMENT LIST Defendants, by their attorneys Broujos, Gilroy & Houston, P.C., set forth the following: 1 The above action was commenced by a complaint filed on August 9, 1995. 2 Defendants filed preliminary objections to said complaint on August 25, 1995. 4 3 Plaintiff filed a First Amended Complaint on September 1, 1995. No action took place on this case until August 13, 1996 when Plaintiff filed a praecipe listing the case for argument. 5 Under the item "Matter to be Argued" on the praecipe listing the case for argument, Plaintiff indicates as follows: Defendant damaged Plaintiff's driveway and destroyed front lawn and plants. Contractual terms state that "surfaces" and "condition" will be restored within ninety days. This has not been done. 6 Listing of the case for argument is procedurally inappropriate at this time because the only pleading before the court is the Plaintiff's complaint. WHEREFORE, Defendant's request your Honorable Court to strike the case from the Argument Court List and direct Defendants to file an Answer so that the case may proceed in an appropriate procedural fashion. P.C. 7 Copy of the Plaintiff's Praecipe Listing the case for Argument is attached hereto and marked Exhibit "A". 8 The undersigned counsel wrote to the Plaintiff requesting that the matter be stricken from the Argument List on August 22, 1996. A copy of said letter is attached hereto and marked Exhibit "B". The Plaintiff has not contacted the undersigned attorney. 9 Defendants are prepared to file an answer to the complaint and desire that the case be stricken from the Argument Court List. PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT TO THE PROTHONOTI)Fn OF ClJI1['ERLAND COUI~TY: PI ease 1 ist the within matter few the next Argument Court. CAPTION OF CASE: PLAINTIFF: Je~n and Carolyn Otto, ~720 Spring Road, Carl isle, PA 17013-8708; phone: 243 -/525 vs. ~ 0' C N z: ~~ N 'c;~ :r. ')~ .... ).1 ~f.., C') G- - ':J- Ll, -i; o:P' c.' ,J - 110. -' r; c:t .,"; ~j u- \D U 0 C1' DEFENDANT: Earl F. Smith II, Chairman, Carl isle Suburban Authority lCSAI, 240 Clearwater Drive, Carl isle, PA 17013 E. Lee '::och, Superintendent, CSA, 240 Clearwater Drive, Carl isle, PA 17013 James Slyder, Contractor, CSA, 508 Chestnut Street, Nount Holly Springs, PA 17000 Carl isle Suburban Authority, Carl isle, No. 4~76 Civil Action 1996 I. Matter to be argued: Defendant damaged plaintiff's driveway and destroyed front lawn and plants. Contractual terms state that "surfaces" and "condition" will be restored within ninety days. This has not been done. 2. Counsel who will argue case are: a. for plaintiff: John Otto b. for defendant: Hubert X. Gilroy 3. The la~1 office of Broujos, Gilroy t, Houston, P.C., 4 North Hanover Street, Carlisle, PA 17013 has been notified. 4. Argument Court date: .P-0:-7zl~ /996 ~~ John Otto, "Attorney" for Plaintiff (.j August 1996 EXHIBIT I A JOHN H, BIlOUJOS HUBEIlT X, GILIlOY CHIlISTOPHEIl C. HOUSTON BROUJOS, GIL~OY 8 HOUSTON. r, Co ^lTOllN.:n ^T lAW 4 NORTIt ttANOVtR STRtr.T ~IlLISLF., rENNSYLV^NI^ 17013 111-243-4514 NON-TOLL fOR ~RJlISIIURC AREA' lI1-100-legO fAX124J-8221 August 22, 1996 Hr. John Otto 2720 Spring Road Carlisle, PA 17013 .RE: otto V' CSA et a1 FILE Dear Hr. Otto: I have received notice that you have listed the above captioned case for the Argument Court List. I would note that the docket entry shows that you filed a complaint on August 9, 1995. We filed preliminary objections on August 25, 1995. You then filed an amended complaint on September 1, 1995. No action has been taken since that time. We are prepared to file an answer or preliminary objections in response to the compliant you have filed. However, since neither an answer or preliminary objections have been filed, the listing of the case for the argument court is premature and inappropriate. Please advise if you will agree to withdraw the matter from the Argument Court List. bc cc: E. Lee Koch EXHIBIT I-L ?,: ~J ,; ", " " (--: ( ) f;-' (;'- , , C (-:' l..:.; ~ ("- k r: , , " i .' ~', U . ::,' . (:', (i JOHN OTTO & CAROLYN OTTO I I V. I I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA EARL F. SMITH, II, E. LEE KOCH, JAMES SLYDERI AND CARLISLE SUBURBAN I AUTHORITY I I NO. 95-4276 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 13th day of JANUARY, 1997, the cass not being at issue, the appointment of arbitrators was premature, and the Board is therefore vacated. Marlin R. McCaleb, Esquire, the chairman of the panel, shall be paid the sum of $50.00 for his ssrvices. Marlin R. McCaleb, Esquire _ Chairman By (i:~UF ~ BC:'.'d E. Shee'y, P.J. C'1d- ,.,..~Cu(,. ,/,S/97. A'.p . Isld r ~;, ) -I ..1 ., - [! . .' ~1 '- ir.:; t "J l, c",-, . ,..., ! , 2': , :'J , ) r:... rn .. , ','1 , .n - I LAW Of'l'1CEft "_.L ':~In or- ~ fYi. uff8a/e/. FAANKI..KAQEM PLACE. Z'. EAST MAW STREET POBOX DO MKotA.NlC5BlJAO. PENN5VLVANA 17085 .,,, 8'11.7110 PAX Ht.1772 , November 21, 1996 Richard J. Pierce Assistant Court Administrator Court Administrator's Office Cumberland County Court House 1 Courthouse Square Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013-3387 Re: Otto vs. Smith No. 95-4276 Dear Richard: On November 1, 1996, I was appointed Chairman of a panel of Arbitrators in the above matter. Upon reviewing the file, it appeared to me that the case was not at issue. The file contained only a Complaint an Amended Complaint, with Preliminary Objections by Defendants that were subsequently withdrawn. No responsive pleading had been filed by the Defendants and the case did not appear to be at issue. I spoke by telephone with Hubert X. Gilroy, Esquire, the attorney for the Defendants, and he confirmed that he had not yet filed a responsive pleading, although he intended to do so. Thereafter, on or about November 20, 1996, Mr. Gilroy filed on behalf of the Defendants an Answer with New Matter, to which Plaintiffs owe a response. Mr. Gilroy has further indicated that when Plaintiffs file their Response to New Matter, he intends to move for Summary Judgment. In light of these matters, it appears that the Praecipe for the appointment of a panel of Arbitrators in this matter was premature and may be unnecessary in view of the anticipated Motion for Summary Judgment. Accordingly, I have returned the file to the Prothonotary and I am asking that the appointment of Arbitrators in this . Richard J. Pierce November 21, 1996 Page Two matter be vacated. Very truly yours, !~f2 aUJ&d Marlin R. McCaleb MRM/jlr cc: Hubert X. Gilroy, Esquire Mr. and Mrs. John Otto cr-",./+,.,J 0 rr ~ (\ J4-I'\ (.P c.. l..J,J Q C;-o f'1..f't-IN?'1FFS .IS €' 7"tA-, F: oS',fIt I ,,..ru. €-r 'lI1 L- IN TIlE COURT OF CO~IMON PLeAS OF CIJ1IBERUND COUNTY, I'EfmSYLVAllIA NO. tf z-, '" CIVIL 19 'i!: RULE 1312-1. The Petitian for Appointment of Arbitrators shall be substant~ally in the following form: PETITION FOR APPOINT}IENT OF ARBITRATORS TO THE HONORABLE. THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT: r.5 /DHI'o-J 0"''-'0 . ~~~..~~l for the plaintiff/,l~;.I'~"I' in the above action ~~ aasLs~~), respectfully represents that: 1. The above-captioned action (4.. ..u_Ll..,u~) is (a..L) at issue. 2. The claim of the plaintiff in the action is Sjboc,tfllD COVIl'TC.u:r-.J:', The counterclaim of the defendant in the action is Ilf//A . The following attorneys are interested in the caseV51 as counselor are other- wise disqualified to sit as arbitrators: 1-1 c,("t?1l.T x.. 6'L~tJ"f , _f"o 12. ()t= I="E,.J ~~ N/ WHEREFORE, your petitioner prays your Honorable Court to appoint three (3) arbitrators to whom the case shall be submitted. Respectfully submit:ed, ~rro ORDER OF COURT ~ AND NOW, Nt) V Zm6 !If. / ,19 ~, in consideration of ~. foregoi:lg petition, RJltLI/N dk.tAlLJ, I Esq., CbtJdj" t Jh/udS Esq., and mAil'! 1(. Kl-NAll.dY ,Esq., are appointed arbitrators in the / abave-captioned action (or actions) as prayed for. "feZ:"1 A)/' P. J. -,. en !r ,.-;, I, ,':; lJ I ~ 0' ., FI-' ~ t.: -, ; t ,.)~ (tJ J.:-' r,:\ -..:; '...... ,p ') e. t.;') \~ 0 I.J\ ~ -r 0- ':t ffi - Kl -s.. 'l ::t- 8 1:1 ~ ,j ~ 1,,_: <.J ,. lJ) "..; . '"ro. ~ r.:: , ,.1 " t_._:. - C' I\j" , " ) ....:f,H~ ~ TTO C~ R.()C ytU 0 'C (0 ,.~" a.fr,rF'>o (;,4{?L F 5M /71-1 tr er Ai- ~~,;:jc....lP~r.s IlIlh~ Cuurt of Common l'leus of Cumh~rlund County,l'ennsylvunlu Nu. L/ 2- 7 t;:;. Civil. 19 '15: :I", , <;. (26 C$>ucs.-rtZl) 71f.A-t (, VI/roc) /\.I '-., ";>~ D !2.. Oc. rtmE2. (9 9" J -b f:' , C'A/€ ~D. CIs - ~2 7-6. fo.-2... 4C..fS7"-,u G" Uf I'/!J~ l.ufT1\ "])~I'r-W N'... To Prothunotary .:l~ S L..'/''' "1~~ ~ 1996 /Jj~~ - ~ ~ rorPluilllirr ,r " , ...;.;c~ ~___ -..-_....._ _9* .'~, , : 1-:: fT', (::;::c~ . "":~ :f':~J Tenn, 19 _ No, ~ (" r- "J r:,: ,,' ,I r,. ill ,';' \1, vs, .', h:::', ,,;IL.:f, ~.~. \ PRAECIPE Filed 19_ , Ally. , f , ',,:,,~. ~-- ---.--. '-,";. ....~. :7~C) Spring Road Carl isle, PA 17013 - 8708 May 16, 1997 Court Administrator Cumberland County Court House One Court House Square Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013 REF: CIVIL ACTION NO. 95-4276 OTTOs v SMITH et OIl Dear Mr. Richard Pierce: It is requested that reference case listed for Argument Court on May 28, 1997, be relisted for said court on August 13, 1997. Plaintiff is unable to attend Ar;Jument COllrts 1 isted for May 28 and June 25, 1997, because of pl'ior plans to be out of town. Huber\: X. Gilroy, Esquire, Attorney for the defend8nts toOlS concurred in this proposed change, incerely, -- ohn Otto or Fl aintiffs cc: Gilroy I- Proth off '~ ~" ~ ~' JUlltlOTTC Ct"'lf'(,J:__lll flT!(1 r'l ,,,nt 1 {i, ;1: ;'Ill I.:ll~_w'r CJr- '-==:':1rlCitI r'lri-"'(~ [If"" C'llt1J':Cr.\l_t"irlfJ [QI.HllY 1 r.[tltr:,'it.'.'i~jt!I,''; " no. :t:':';'..., cr....Jt l~.:'l'~., U\FL F. S111T1I, J 1, I,. u:r: I'oel-l. JAMeS SI. H'IT, (,llr, CI'lnL I~:;LE ''-;U[;UF:['{\/'; (11 ,IT1-lor r 1 [1~fC'ndaflts __f'.'lL n[rl[lt~ tit HJ r JOl'J, ,j,_ h 1 ,.M, _l""",- (E,\~lJ~~:'T ~(~, 1 r-/f7~.>, 1.lrJcn consifjc.,-'::>tl':Jn t:f t:.!lt': ;.,Lj".\.cl.l,~-,d !1o;t.l\.lII, It !i:i Lo'd i,\,-.,j dir'L'ct.::.::d 7\~~ f'.',11 ,::,~';;'; r " . L . , , "'-..l..;il-l- 1 . ., , ,.,.-!- ; I t- -,j- ; ("'1'\ on """f~4 .-.'-0"""'1 11._1:..1 i' -' ,- -d'~i.-of or-.r",. r'L,,,,':iUs '-";~(tio '~~' I"H"'.'~I"'." " '~.'__'_',... . ~t ~._.....t_..;.,;:=..:;.;~';.~. I'" I ~j T! ,',d 1 r i 01, tit;w,...L lc ~'J("';'J . ,'..... , J',!),. f:: 'r:ir. r:~y __,~,_ (: l~.1/__,_ - e..o-~~<... ,;;,/,6!Qt,. ..& ,~ -'1,.1 "'" .0 HL.:':':j_'j.t y :.' 'j _ 1.;; ,._~ :gyri/- JUlIN OTTO ~ C{)r'Li~_ Y~l '-'1 -~-C) 1-' I ~, III t Iff It! TilE ('our,'[ OF Ci.)~lt'iOrI II. r.t,:: ur C'Q1f<CmJ,IID ':IJI.ItHY, r"ENtl'-;)'l,','r.tJU, flU. ,~':'7~~ Cl','!L. ll7?C'"~ F.(,f;L F. :;M I TlI, ] J, t:. U.T IClell, JI\MES SL ym:r; {,IJP [r.r::L I SUe SUDl:r,!:NI ;\' !"!' ','r' IT" [I,:":.> f..:'ild ,'.'.1 " ", r:T\..'TL l'iCTIOt,j m:OUEST FDr;: C,:TCIISlml ['If' TlIIE TO r'ILL 1 , r'1':llnt1ffs r';~ql~t(':.t "In c..:,t~"ntj(Jn of t.;\'I'lt/ (:~(J) .j~\'I~: time to fl~P. ,~. .-"_,~-<..-,p.-~r;:-::;l"/C: pl:::".ll::r;-J ~-(."I H':~~J f-1,;tt"I". ~ F'1,,;intirf'~ Hef'C (jut ,:.If L,:.".; JU,'Ji"I'J t:hc t\~J('nt'). ('2(J) d,:.y filing per'lud. ~ ..l. r-'l.,"lntir~, J::Jhn nttCJ, ll."~- t.'\'O:'i: :l~ l _c,nd .-::tl'f J"" vJ i t h ...~ t 1 u 1 11. f~ ":,1.:.:.1. nc',' ~'I.',{ f ~T.. r-,:J l)c,d"J .,\(__h.:.";~ ,:,f,d P'-I ~ r, ;-,t..~,,::..l drlP, \.,j,:\tCI- h.::'.l:l, i"': " .j" I "' ,', ,~ ~ ,'" , ,. -.! , (:/i.'2::' t C'-I' ' 1 1 !Jcc ,:;.rt-, '--.r 1 i/':,',!, C-' ~ .- i t-, i, ~\ t- l' 'c' /;/ c&QetL1) c--3------------- '" !(JllJ"i at t._~J ! h d .: .,- I J: ltel ,~ K4>-1Lv~~1Z1 ~ ONu:... Pt.c-, /I 19'iro I SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 1995-04276 P COhMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND OTTO JOHN ET AL VS. SMITH EARL F 11 ET AL MICHAEL BARRICK . Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, that he served the within COMPLAINT upon SLYDER JAMES defendant, at 833:00 HOURS, on the ~ day of Auaust 1995 at 508 CHESTNUT STREET. REAR MT HOLLY SPRINGS. PA 17065 . CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania. by handing to KATHY SLYDER. ADULT SISTER-IN- LAW OF DEF. & ADULT IN CHARGE a true and attested copy of the COMPLAINT and at the same time directing Her attention to the contents thereof. the Sheriff's Costs: Docketing Service Affidavit Surcharge 6.00 .00 .00 2.00 So ans~~ ~ ~omas K1J.ne~rJ.~ $8.1010 ~. ul.> )1.," :l- ~ j;J. ,7.L. JOHN OTTO "// 0B/211~:95 _ ~/(/6-: V'.' /~~enfX Sworn and subscribed to before me this 10'= day of ~,....... 19 qo( A.D. i~,... C' ,.,1.,,((...... II.!../,l, ---r-r I-'rothonotar)l' , , SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 1995-04275 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND OTTO JOHN ET AL VS. SMITH EARL F II ET AL KENNETH E. GOSSERT CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania. to law. says, that he served the , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of who being duly sworn according within COMPLAINT upon KOCH E LEE the defendant, at 1335:00 HOURS, on the 14th day of AUQust 1995 at CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY 240 CLEARWATER DRIVE CARLISLE. PA 17013 . CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania, by handing to DEB RICHARDSON. BILLING CLERK a true and attested copy of the COMPLAINT and at the same time directing ~ attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing Service Affidavit Surcharge So an,::.:.~s:,~// vA 1" .g~....< ~~ H. I homas K.lJ.ne, ::'~;rJ.:t:t 5.00 .00 .00 2.00 $8.00 JOHN OTTO 08/21/1995 by ;1.~# Sworn and subscribed to before me this ;o'i::' day of ~'...J" 19 'h A.D. ~'I" a 'h,te,., ,.J;",l.,. t'ro hono ary' I ' SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NOI 1995-04276 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA 1 COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND OTTO JOHN ET AL VS. SMITH EARL F II ET AL KENNETH E. GOSSERT CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania, to law, says, that he served the , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of who being duly sworn according within COMPLAINT upon SMITH EARL F II the defendant, at 1336100 HOURS, on the 14th day of Auaust 19~ at CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY 240 CLEARWATER DRIVE CARLISLE, PA 17013 . CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania, by handing to DEB RICHARDSON, BILLING CLERK a true and attested copy of the COMPLAINT and at the same time directing Her attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing Service Affidavit Surcharge 18.00 6.72 .00 2.00 So answers: ~ ./" // V..-: . ~~'r_~~ ..F "",' #-,- '-:.!-:....~4.L...._ ,__ .1 ~. .. H. I homas K1J.ne, erJ.11 6Z6.7Z JOHN OTTO 08/21/1995 by K=.r.~ Sworn and subscribed to before me . ..... C' this ,D day of 4.'....}o- 19 q.; A.D. ' ( )" J I tlroG'o~t.a';y . . "-'ld'l rr::"i:Llf-C I "f- L !':;lltU; CO,':F I [If.. ,iliC.llr1Ftll TI) TilE l'-r;OTfllllHH,W;Y OF ClJI1DFFLltlm cr';"IT"!": '--1.,-\,._, ll'_,t lIw i"Jit.lilrl 1I1.'1ttl~r f,)r ll,c' ll(-~ t" f'it-. (]lllllc:rl I Cour't. C.,PT! 011 OF cn~,r:: r't n 1 NT 1 FF : JDhn ,?inti Curol'lrl at. t (), ::0720 Spr" i n'J nOde!, C,:H" 1 i. ,.11_', r:','"1 1 7(l13~"87(1D ; phCllH;;.\: :~41 J 7r52r.:-. IrE, 0 ?f en .- N " I-' .." .~~ w~! ~~.' ...... );:~ '::;;l r ;0 ,. ,., ,,,- ~~-' . r-: ~ ;jro 1'= ;;:: ~:)u.. LL -', 0 ,0 ::J O' U DEFENDANT: Earl F. Smith II, Chairman, CLII-l isll'~ Subur'b''"..H1 Authority (C5(~), ~40 C10arw~tcr' Drlve, C~rl i~;le, PA 17(113 E. Ll!j-~ l-:uch, Super'llit,QfH1r:nl, CS() , :240 Cle~rwater' Drive, Car'l Isle, PA 17013 J~nle5 Slyder, Corltr'~cL'Jr., CSA, 508 Cllestnut Str--(!(~t, t-1ounl Holly Spt"ings, F'A 17000 Cdt"lislt,] SulJu~-b,.),n (tut:hor"ity, Carlisle, No. 4276 Civil Action Jqq6" ,~ 1. Mdttet'" to bE (:H~gut:::'d: DL'fl~!ndt\nl dam,:1Cjed pl Aintiff's drIveway and destr'uyed ft-llr-It l~WII ~rld plant~. Corltraclual ter'lOs state tha.t 1I~,llt"f.~\cQ',:''' ,:'u1d "condition" \.-,i 11 be f"'estored ~'lthin nInety Cl.;.t,/Si. Thi;~ hD.!"; nelt bec'r1 done. ~ COl\nsel ",ho ~"lll dt'qUrc: Gas(.;;> ,).t~+:.~: a , for p I <. I n t iff : John Otto b. for' d8f-end,)nt: Hul.'tort:-'. Cd 11"\.') 3. The li-\\.-I officE' of D'-'UIIJO:-;, (:.;11t-uy .~, 11uu~3-ton, P.C., ~1 1'~Ot..th '.LJl"IDVpr Stt,(,_,q"i:, [,,-it '1 i', 1" t F'(l 17\',1 '-, ha:'i bCt}n not i f le."d. 4. Argllnll?nl COllr'! di\t,,: 2. c?c 1"<.> !1,&/2. r 9'1b ~~~~"'''"c, { 01' r" i\l nl if ( " (1I\~.~I,;L 1',')'")< , .~-' ,,:HEk I FF' ,,; hETIJlitl HEGlJl.iIf.. CASE tlO: 1995-04276 r COMMOtlWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA, COUNTY OF CUMDERLAND OTTO JOHN ET AL vs. ~MITH EARL F II ET AL _1I MOTHY REITZ J Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania, who be1ng duly aworn according to law, says, the with1n AMENDMEtlT TO COMPLAINT upon SMITH EARL F II d.-fendant. at 19~~:0~ HOURS. on !.he _?th day of Octobc'r 19':15 at 1843 SPRING ROA[I CARLISLE, PA 17013 ,CUMBERLAND County. Pennsylvanla, b}' hilnd1ng to '~!.lI.B-LENE SMITH, WIFE OF was served the EARL .F. SMITH. II a true and attested copy of the AMENDMENT TO COMPLAINT togother wlth NOTICE and at the same t1me d1recting Her attc!ntil)n to the contents thereof. Sheriff's Costs: Docketing Service - Affidavit Surcharge 18,00 2.80 .00 2.00 So ?t/?r/~~~ R:--lTiO~1l1 .!:;-r:T.rnL;;--E;}IP rTTr SZ::.lm-JOHN OTTO '7 -;t?"~ 10/05/1'~95 ~ eL. bY___E~~~'~_n_~ Sworn and aubacr1bed to before me th1s JI~ _ dil)" nf @,~.~____ 19--K._ A. r.. .\ i. ..J),_J:".hLo." ~m .~ ~J~O::I'-~0"':aI-" PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT (Must be typewritten and subnitted in duplicate) TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY: Please list the within matter far the next Argunent Court. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be stated in full) "0OHt) O/7() (3./4 ,:.l. 0 L '-) ;../ _~,,) i\ t)ifO / ( Plaintiff) vs. (;-;1'o-lk F .eMit/-{ .LL Au D ~ / L [;;'r;- Ko/J.I. ~IV D cfl'I1l?~ S L....,.. Dr:l!:. , ( Defendant) No. l.{ 27-b Civil A (TiCl^-.! 19 q~ 1. State matter to be argued (i.e. / plaintiff's lIDtion for new trial, defendant's dEl'lLlJ:rer to canplaint. etc.): L -1-'-0 N 4.""!> j?C+AJT" ~1"r,1-'\A br 10 RI'l' /J7( PF"..j- /'Y;;0cJ f'-J,A-C l--' fl.v FC.i2-Ft?, 2. Identify counsel who will argue case: (a) for plaintiff: fkH A-J CC:J"7rG Address: d ")';;) c...:' ':"'/)1'/( IL, h (0) /" /l 1"'>>< I:: A LIS L i:- ,., ~I'-H)u \ 3> (b) for defendant: ;-fu ~C(?r X. 61LK71 <=-5<3'.01 ru-/ l.( Address: ^~/l7"'; r{"I.<..Iot,eil .s~ C71,lL ,5:.(. ~ 3. I will notify all parties in writing within t100 days that this case has been listed for argunent. 4. Argunent Court Date: 10 l)e-c P-:>7/)[':/2. /191 Dated: Pc ,4~~~~l,~" 0" 1; 27:0 SOrlnq Road Carl isle. PA 17013-8706 November 9. 1997 Hubert X. Gilroy. Eso. North Hanc1ve,' Street Carl lsle. PA 17013 Ref: Civ Act 4276. 1995 Ur I tr 11')697 Dear Mr. Gilroy: ~Je have no ob_Jectlon to YOLlr re~uest to chanqe "OL\r case" f rOil. December 1'). 1997. to Januarv 28. 1998. the ne:< t scheduled Arqument Court date. 5 ncere1 v VOLlrS, cc Cm\rt Admln vF'rothonotarv PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT (Must be typewritten and subnitted in duplicate) TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY: Please list the within matter far the next Argunent Court. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be stated in full) John Otto & Carolyn Otto ( Plaintiff) VB. Earl F. Smith II and E. Lee Koch and James Slyder ( Defendant) No. 95 Civil 4276 19 1. State matter to be argued (i.e.. plaintiff's llDtion for new trial. defendant's dmurrer to canplaint. etc.): Motion for Judgment on the pleadings filed by Defendants. 2. Identify counsel who will argue case: (a) for plaintiff: Address: pro se 2720 Spring Road, Carlisle, PA 17013 (b) for defendant: Address: Hubert X. Gilroy. Esq. 4 N.Hanover St., Carlisle, PA 17013 3. I will notify all parties in writing within hilo days that this case has been listed for argurent. 4. Argunent Court Date: January 28, 1998 Dated: Attorney far D Hubert X. Gilroy -~ '.. - , , - , , , ; , . " '-.' 0 r~~: , , , e:: I i ~ , r- , (:...... C' :., BROUIOS, GILROY 8 HOUSTON, I' r: ^1TOI<NI:n ^T IJ\W JOHN H. BROUJOS HUBERT X, GILROY CHRISTOPHER C. HOUSTON 11I.;.t.n....".. NON, H'II. 10k IIAftkIUHltU", AtllA /I/./nfl'lfluu .. NOKUI IIANl.lVtfl ~ltllTl C^l<l.ISLF.. I'I:NNSYLV^NI^ 1101:1 1N('~t.I.I'";};!/ March 24, 1997 The Honorable Harold E. Sheely, P.J. Cumberland County Court House 1 Courthouse Square Carlisle, PA 17013 Re: Otto v smith et al/95 - 4276 Dear Judge Sheely: I represent the Defendants in the above case. We have filed an answer and we have also filed a Motion for Judgement on the Pleadings. It is our intention to list the Motion for Argument Court in May. The Plaintiff, who is representing himself, has filed a Petition for Appointment of Arbitrators. We believe the Appointment of Arbitrators in this matter is premature, and we request that the Appointment be delayed pending resolution of our Motion. Yours Sincerely, A!J--.. Hubert X. Gilroy wkh cc: E. Lee Koch Earl F. Smith, II ?/ldiJ.o not,., "% P/lf1!(., ItLAtI fltf~c,j, ~d /~) 1l--7 u/C.n -fa p I r: /l . JUN I 0 1997bf" JOHN OTTO and CAROLYN OTTO, Plaintiffs IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA , v CIVIL ACTION - 95 - 4276 EARL F. SMITH, II and E. LEE KOCH and JAMES SLYDER, Defendants AND ff COURT ORDER NOW, this ~ day o~~, 1997, upon consideration of the attached Motion, the appointment of arbitrators in the above case is hereby vacated. The Chairman of the Board of Arbitration, Attorn8~ Marlin R. McCaleb, shall receive compensation of 50 ----. Upon resolution of the Defendant's Motion for Judgement on the Pleadings filed in this case and assuming the case is ripe for referral to arbitration at that time, Plaintiffs may again file an appropriate Motion for Appointment of Arbitrators. cc: Hubert X. Gilroy, Esquire Mr. and Mrs. John Otto ~~ ."",~ ~/" (q],. .. /I" .oQ- Er. r- ,. ,- c:: ~ .. ,]~ ~Q .:r :.Jr.) c: . J.,,: tl:": :.., :t J~ ' . ... (I) , , '1-.' UJ~. - ;:65 _.J,. . .~ .q Ci:. , -, . ~J tJ.. F -, to- r- :3 0 0' u . JOHN OTTO and CAROLYN OTTO, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiffs v CIVIL ACTION - 95 - 4276 EARL F. SMITH, II and E. LEE KOCH and JAMES SLYDER, Defendants PETITION TO VACATE ARBITRATOR' 5 APPOIN'l'MErNT Defendants, Earl F. Smith, II, et all, by their attorney, Broujos & Gilroy, P.C., set for the following: 1 Plaintiff's in the above case are represented pro-se. 2 Defendants had filed a Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings which is currently before the court and scheduled for Argument Court in August. 3 Plaintiffs had filed a Request for Appointment of Arbitrators and arbitrators were appointed. 4 The appointment of arbitrators is premature pending the resolution of Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment. WHEREFORE, Defendants request your Honorable Court to vacate the appointment of arbitrators made in Gilroy, Broujos & Gilroy, .C. 4 North Hanover treet Carlisle, PA 17 13 717-243-4574 ,~.:.. r- .,.. .... .., ~ ~ ~ ~ ~, JOHN OTTO & CAROLYN OTTO, Plaintiffs IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. EARL F. SMITH, II, E. LEE KOCH, JAMES SLYDER AND CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY, NO. 95-4276 CIVIL TERM Defendants NOTICE OF HEARING BY BOARD OF ARBITRATORS You are hereby notified that the undersigned Board of Arbitrators, appointed by the Court in the above-captioned case, will sit for the purpose of their appointment in the Second Floor Hearing Room, Old Cumberland County Court House, in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, on Wednesday, July 9, 1997, at 9:00 o'clock A.M., at which time and place you may appear with your respective clients and your witnesses to present such evidence and testimony as you may have in the case. Murrel R. Walters, III, Esquire Elizabeth Stone, Esquire tt~?ita~ By: Marlin R. McCaleb, Chairman Board of Arbitrators May 27, 1997 TO: John Otto and Carolyn Otto, Plaintiffs Hubert X. Gilroy, Esquire (Attorney for Defendants) Thomas E. Cheffins Court Administrator 1"".""1'1<1'. M^I4I1N It M. I ^l I H - JOHN OTTO , CAROLYN OTTO V. I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA I I CIVIL ACTION - LAW I I NO. 4276 CIVIL 1995 EARL F. SMITH, II, E. LEE KOCH, JAMES SLYDER AND CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY IN RBI VACATE ARBITRATOR ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, MAY 23, 1997, the appointment of James Bogar, Esquire, is hereby vacated and Marlin McCaleb, Esquire, is appointed in his stead. By the Court, L_ P.J. Marlin McCaleb, Esquire _/ ,j Chairman t.cjUf "?11";..!.,l 0/:17/97 L,l<t-- Court Administrator Isld ~. ,":'f-:-:'...... ',:7 ....,. ", , , 't:i, ,- /,1; '.. '. " .\\.(.. eo ll~ l{ r ~~~~\I I\{ 1: t''' ~ttc."'-"J!. \ ~V< 'U(}Ki~J:- IJU'-hv ~tJdk ~ Tt;K.A."Sl.<...~. ~ ~ ~,~ . ~ -d.u:' ""-,,ct-<<.- . ~ Cu~ ~ lJ.t..tx~~\<.~\.L"J w w <t<.:~"'(;J. o{ ~l;l." vw~k, \~>t.....w.g), I\r S~u-t<1 t,(.\..( '~-t 1J.<,..-t'l.u-t' ~l.(, a. cu.\<. k~ c......d ~ L<-<.~.,(d lu- 1Ur.w<."'V-<c..t. (lu......... {w I\w..~ ~~. \\u<....t1, :;rc.c- (~~ I' ~ ~ ~ ~ :y. ~ J -1 ?r. Ul .... ~ 1-; ;-~; " :5.r u~f) - l.) ;.) l. . . .- '.j~i.: It') u.. ~? !:1::J C' 0 ':;", e, , , t_'.. . " ~~!- 1"-' il.j '.J ~.,;";.. r: "- IJ- ~ ~:j 0 0' u '- " . . ~ .-........"'.,' .-', , .:: " ..., :1} 1.1l1, t'- 1',t1" ; , I ; I'd-,i'!.; , .' I I .-, 1",' ~ t . --I" ;;! : "_'- :,'j: If,', ,,__, , .1 l--',:r.-, 1':[!. C':,rL r-. :~,!'1!T~i. l'i, C.. I.;:~I- ~ I.H,..!"". )t-"lrlF':.. ':,L f [I[r: r~;I'il~1 C?,t,L j ;:.l.E ::.U!..tjFL';'i!J 'l!YT'-j,Jr-.l ~ I U.?i.~r,'~ ~nr-.':; ;::.. r '.';- L ..ti.. j [f:HI CORRECT I QI-~ OF COURT RECORe,s PLAINTI FFS BRI EF CONCERNING THE DATE THAT C':'RLl SLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY TERI11NATED THEI R SEWER/WATEWR COI-1I-1ECTI 01-1 VIS-A-VIS PLAINTIFFS LAW!'l I. Detendant POI nted out dul" I no ARGU~IEtlT COURT. on Janual"Y 28. 1998. that Plaintitts indIcated "...tinal wOl"k belno done on June 18.1991." as the date that Cal"! isle Subul"ban Authority (CSAJ completed work on the sewer/water connections on Plalntifts lawn. Detendants Brlet tor Motion 1'01" Judoement on the PleadIngs: pg 2. pal"a II. Al"oument. A. (3d line from bottom:' ~, -. Plaintitfs state that "On 01" about June 18. IQ91 ....C1. " ;'." <." j".., no mention <;,1' "tinal work beinC) done.t! 11n1:lf,:;: f:"r,,~:r'I(11'tl.,:;:.r.l~ '.-: ~,:-.lTtDi~'Jn'!'~. St?c,t:Cto;t:.:-:r- l. L.:.;;r~. I :J:./T, S, F'l2tln.~li'~::,"~ ~'~,;.t.f:- t_r---.,.-r thr;-l-,:' 1.~:' ::I!-.\:,t'::I=1t ~t,r.. c..1{~teo ,iu! ~I-;":;C:" .:',. .J.?br-t '~":3'.,~-,_t:.;,,:~ ;r--':'t;1 r ,"1[';"1'''''' l~:'.n rj'. L~3t:'. F1E>,lrlt.~-1t;:' '~1,11._:W"iltH~.ri!. ':L (\-_"~".' ....r-.~~. ~.':-[')t!-;lll!>~:'I- 1':e'fl .,.. 1 Q;:;r:- . HH I, ljjt:- :.,-:t:~,::h,:.l(j t 1 ,.j: r:'~I::.t,,'~H' ~iL.r,:~. ;c.r'.;:, C.t r ~ .:\ ; n 1:...1 t 1 ::: ,:1 C\ t .~~d ':lLi ':11} . -:",~n : r:.:-jre~ '3t";:~ ,j:;,t:,[.',J jU!. ~ ~:: :.\11':: t.~.,o 31'"(":' ,I, 1~''-!'1. rilt:.' Qj-lctD:JI";:.r.III'-'; ~..1'-0 ,:,:- 1I!:':,t:.( CI' suunlltted {,~r fi.lr,.tt'I~I" C131-tilC~ll.~lrl 'Ji l:Jrlr,tl.:,CU-fH;.t"I~ . i:C,t\I' t t't:.c ;..'t".j ~-lnr::; th(~ ,j;;.\f~0S ':)\- tIlt::' .1 tn ,~.. F'1 alntif i:; aoe,! Oqi.:-;€- ;D'- z;n,,' l-nc.r)rl\"li2nGE:? U",!-.::-.' m,3.- r.a-.;E- c3used 1:rlis HOtliJPt;[,LE COUr:T ,~nd th€..:J [!121~2nd.3nf:-s r-eqat"dJ.nq t.he ~dClt-ementloned on Ot., '::~DOL1t .lLlrif? :8. ):14'1 d,:;,tl'~. WHEREFORE~ Flall,tlf;~ rea'Jest ~hat tillS document ai e~~olanation and c~2r'lficatlCG IJe ~lV~rj fLl11 C8GSldEr~tlon lr', t:h~ ;j(..~d Iber"-3.tl'.:Jn3 cJ-t f:~l:'= HONOFf4l:.LE' CGUFT. F\c'~[)E!ct f ;,.1'11'. . ,.:,tt,;.\c:.hment~ l pq. '5ot.: .tf~ ~' :7:::' ;DI~lnq Roaj C .;'......1 1::; 1 ,":.-. i=;.. 17(, 1 J-87(.5 CF Attornev , :;." INFORMAL ESTIMATE Mr. Roger Ort, provided current retail selling prices and other information for their goods and services as follows: a. Juniper, blue rug, three 0 $14.95, two g.llon X 3 = $ 44.85 b. A:alea, orange, one ~4.95 c. RhodOdendron, Nova Zemba, one 54.95 d. Grass, Japanese variegated, one 11.95 g. Mul ch, sia cu ft l!' $2~) per scoop X 2 = 4(1.00 e. Sod, 720 sq ft 'I. 5.5 sq ft = 130 units X $1.89 per unit = 244.70 f. Top soil, 720 sq ft by 2.5" deep = 28 +/- scoops l!' $18.0<:' per scoop = '5(14.00 11. Sub Totals: a. $ 9~5 .4c) b. $ 925 .4(1 goods - 244.71) sod :f. 680.7';' sub total + 476.49 1 abor + 251) . (H) incidentals :f. 141').19 total c. :f. 925.4() gOOds - 504.00 top soil 421.70 sub total + 295 . 19 1 abor ::5(1.01) incidentals $ 966.89 total Final estimated cost for profp.ssional restoration of damage and destruction to my front yard'. caused by the Carlisle Suburban Authority and their contractor James H. 51 yder', EHcavat ing, 5';'8 Chestnut Street, Nt Holl y Springs. to ^ ~J. 27:0 Spring Road Car lis 1 e, F'A 17':013 14 September 1991 The Rot:s, 2~t Spring Road Carl isle, F'A 17013 Dear Folks, Carolyn and I went to Country Market yesterday to check on the status of our request for an estimate to repair our front yard. Mr. Roger Crt, the manager, decl ined to give us a written estimate for technical and insurance reasons. He said that their landscape company in Dillsburg, phone: (1) 432 1)091, cOLIld do the estimate for a fee of about $11)0 to $21)0. Mr. Roger Crt, at our requ~st, did other data that is compiled at the f i gL,reS and The est :mate to restore our front one 2(" x 5" strip of destroyed edging an repair plus either :t.1410.19 or J:966.89. prefer sod, an instant fi~, we interpose no objection to the use of top soil. Final estimate rec:apitul ation: J:1467.19 or '1'11)23.89. We offer our thanks fer the Jester of goodwill with of "topsoil" with its soil, rocks, shale anc weeds. unable to offer any credit for same. the load We are Encl als Sincerely , .FO"" 0"0 -~ "- oj f.J ( 01/ v. : : : : : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 4276 CIVIL 1995 L ~ JOHN OTTO & CAROLYN OTTO Plaintiffs EARL F. SMITH, II, E. LEE KOCH, JAMES SLYDER AND CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY Defendants . . . . . . . . CIVIL ACTION NOTICE TO: Plaintiffs John Otto & Carolyn Otto 2720 Spring Road Carlisle, PA 17013 You are hereby notified that you must file a responsive pleading to the attached New Matter within twenty (20) days from receipt hereof or a default judgment may be entered against you. /r Irff f(f, I , 1996 BROUJOS, GILROY & HOUSTON, P.C. Hubert X. Gilr , Esquire Attorney I.D No. 29943 4 North Hanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 717/243-4574 717/766-1690 FAX 717/243-8227 JOHN OTTO & CAROLYN OTTO Plaintiffs : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : v : NO. 4276 - CIVIL - 1995 . . EARL F. SMITH, II, E. LEE KOCH, JAMES SLYDER, AND CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY Defendants . . . . . . : CIVIL ACTION ANSWER TO CCMPLAINT Defendants, by their attorneys Broujos, Gilroy & Houston, P.C., set forth the following: 1 Admi tted. 2 Admi tted. 3 Admi tted. 4 Admi tted. 5 Admitted. 6 Denied in part and admitted in part. Denied that there was any contract between the Plaintiffs and Carlisle Suburban Authority. Admitted that Plaintiffs and Carlisle Suburban Authority entered into a Deed of Easement, Right-of-way and Right of Entry Agreement dated June 10, 1991, which is referred to as Exhibit A of Plaintiffs' Complaint. Denied also that workmen did not save topsoil and their backhoe and excavated debris damaged Plaintiffs' driveway and destroyed lawn and plants. 7 Denied. Carlisle Suburban Authority did not breach the contract. The said lawn and plants have been restored to original contour. I r. I, 8 Admitted that Defendant Carlisle Suburban Authority delivered topsoil to Plaintiffs' property. Denied that the topsoil contained solely rocks, stones and weeds. It is further denied that the photographs referred to as Exhibit C are accurate representations of the fill that was delivered to Plaintiffs' property. 9 Denied that said photographs are an accurate representation of Plaintiffs' yard. 10 Admitted in part and Denied in part. Admitted that the parties have been unable to reach an agreement. Denied that Plaintiffs are entitled to any funds. 11 Denied. After reasonable investigation, Defendants are without information that will enable them to determine the truth or falsity of this allegation. Proof thereof is demanded. - -. "-'-- 12 Admitted in part and denied in part. Admitted that Plaintiffs' civil complaint filed against the Defendants was dismissed. Denied that it was dismissed without prejudice. Although the District Justice issued a "dismissal without prejudice" Order in that case. There is no provision in the applicable Rules of Civil Procedure relating to District Justices to dismiss a case without prejudice. The effect of the dismissal was a verdict in favor of the Plaintiff. " 13 Defendants admit that Plaintiff has filed an Amended Complaint. 14 Defendants admit that the parties have been unable to settle the case. WHEREFORE, Defendants request your Honorable Court to dismiss Plaintiffs' complaint. NEW MAT~ 15 The allegations set forth in Paragraphs 1 through 14 above are incorporated herein by reference thereto. 16 Plaintiffs filed an action against the above named Defendants before District Justice Helen B. Shulenberger, which action was Docketed with District Justice Shulenberger at CV-283-95. A copy of Plaintiffs' Complaint demonstrating that said action is identical to the claims filed in this action is attached hereto and marked as Exhibit A. 17 A hearing on the action filed by Plaintiffs against Defendants before District Justice Shulenberger was held before District Justice Shulenberger on July 10, 1995. At that hearing, judgment was entered in favor of the Defendants. 18 The dismissal of the action by the District Justice was issued pursuant to a Order on July 10, 1995, copy of said Order being attached hereto and marked as Exhibit B. 19 District Justice Shulenberger dismissed Plaintiffs' action due to the statute of limitations issues (see letter from District Justice Shulenberger attached hereto and marked as Exhibit C). 20 The above captioned action, which is essentially an appeal of District Justice Shulenberger's July 10, 1995 judgment in favor of the Defendants, was initiated by the filing of a Complaint with the Cumberland County Prothonotary on August 9, 1995. 21 The appropriate method to file an appeal of a District Justice's judgment is to file a Notice of Appeal with the Prothonotary pursuant to PaRCP DJ 1002. 22 Plaintiffs did not file a Notice of Appeal as required by PaRCP DJ Rule 1002. 23 Plaintiffs' claim suggests that one or more of the Defendants negligently damaged Plaintiffs' landscaping while performing excavation work at Plaintiffs' property. 24 Plaintiffs' claim as it relates to negligence is barred by the applicable statute of limitations. 25 Plaintiffs suggests a claim that may sound in contract as it relates to the right-of-way agreement entered into between Plaintiffs and Carlisle Suburban Authority on June 14, 1991. 26 Plaintiffs' claim that is pled in a breach of contract nature is barred by the applicable statute of limitations. 27 Defendant Earl F. Smith II did not perform any of the work which is the subject of this litigation. 28 Although Defendant E. Lee Koch did perform some work involving the water and sewer connections, Defendant Koch did not perform any of the work which is the subject of this litigation nor is it alleged that Defendant Koch caused any of the alleged damage to Plaintiff's property. If( rt , 1996 BROUJOS, GILROY & HOUSTON PC 29 Defendant Earl F. Smith II signed the right-of-way agreement on behalf of Carlisle Suburban Authority in his capacity as Chairman of the Authority and not in his individual capacity. WHEREFORE, Defendants request your Honorable Court to dismiss Plaintiffs' Complaint. 4 North Hanover Street Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013 717/243-4574 717/766-1690 FAX 717/243-8227 1 verify that the statements in the foregoing pleading are true and correct. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 PaCS 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. 2o-.a ~_~'L-o: Earl F. Smith II, in his individual capacity l~~ E. Lee Koch, capacity ~~~~ ~s S y er CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY a -'- -t' /"k ~_ ~e Chairma~ ~ BY .... c-I ro'. ~ ,- ~2 , UJ'': '- l..!{ I' ..'i l,-', ('n . 1 (.1' , l.~ ' . , 'J ,'- t , . ~ , ." -' u ." -- .~...... . .-.;- I . '\'" C-"-{I i '1'11- .' ~>'lf'<l. F.. ':;1'1 [ rH. r I. u:C I ,Det!.. J~11'H:,':;; ';',Li flEr (Ii E.. C,,:iF'L 1 ~;LE-: ~;LJ[iUi~'[.,:'tr j ~-lUTfic)r;, r T r [IEf !::ndc,nt:,: C 1',,'11 t'I;~TlrjjJ ! - , L 1 ,:-;,:;r , (") ..n q c CO) =.~ -., -,I -,.:'f ." ,." " (il. ' .;,J :'i frl r' :;~ ....l C" C) .>, , ~:~ r,. -.1 ,1',! ;~; c.' .~, \l~ '.() ':'",:(" (jCTI ..1....:. - .. .., ;''' ~- ~ "j -. ...J -- ii'jHrl i) i' It! \' !:",lr,t:lt r' p': 1:1 1;1 -; it' I,i,,/'!_ i '_,'I' ',:'1.1;-:1 \l;'ii J 1.'-1 ,"if:: '.-<U:1r.rT'I,'''jl ir t::'Uii T y ~~r If I':', ~,_'.'(ir: J "\ ill': . -~ . CORRECTION OF COURT RECORDS PLA[NTIFFS BRIEF CONCER~H1m THE DATE THAT CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY TERMINATED THE[ R SEWER/WATEWR CONNECT I ON VIS-A-VIS PLA[NTIFFS LAWN 1. De-fendant pOinted out durln9 ARGUI'IEI'IT COURT. on January 28. 1998. that Plaintiffs indicated ....-final worK being done on June 18.1991.' as the date tha.t Carlisle Suburban Authorit>' (CSA) completed worK on the sewer/water connections on P I a I n t i -f -f s I awn. De-fendants Brief for Motion for Judgement on the Pleadings; pg 2. pa.ra [I. Argument. A. (3d line from bottom:> 2. Plaintiffs .tate that 'On or about June 18. 1991 ~Irt 'J:;,") :j.,.i l'I'~.'1 -,j....' ;i-"_~I' no mention of Ilfinal work being done.1I P 1 ,;,t, 1 n t 11: {::, ;':~!Ti,::r', ,ji~;on <-, l~ ,~-, I~ '::.OD : ,.;:, l;) t. _;I'::':D t. ''2mbl~r' t. 1':;:'9::;. ftefTl c. F';61ntl~'t:: st,:.t.,~ tl"i,?t thi?f~:-~' ..,_ ~'\. Cdl~.::.,t.()"r"~tDI-,~ c::,t.eCJ jl~!i, 1~~5, of j~bri~, ~ "~~Jj~~~d ~rGlrl ~l~l~tl-ii~ :;,~~n ~.{ CS~. F'lcllntl'f-t~~. {1'11r-..ildlTt.~C\rt t...: L(Jihl:-'-I')l,~;t.::..~~ei:'t~}filLot:'~" 1~ j.:"".>':;':. l +: O:::qij ':;1 ~ rhi-.~ .:~i:_t-_~i:.ht7.~ i 1 "i~' l:+I),::.tl:...:~jt :~r:.!; ,'q t,e ::', r' "1- 1 r', t 1 ,j ; '; i ,'.:.q'Jr', ~ '. i':tli"'Cl(? ~'H~t? d;\t.E~,:1 Jul ~ ~"" 1 :~"~,~l ?irid j.\'VJ c.\t":-"' (l,jtr:,d 'lU'll.,I~;t: .l. 1,"' j,. TtH,. l)hCJ1..{':j:-H~.rJh ,Jt"t:; ,',~ f!l:-" r..<.r" (';v C:.\JUr t r~f:',_~,Clt"CJ (lnd .:U't: ;;;I_\blrrl..t~to?1.1 t''':Jr~ ,:,.\t tl-j,-~r- .-:l;:\r'l"1.,::.,~\t;t'~JI,) U1 '.I'lf:' -J:"jt.:..S' (it tr-l':~; 1_''!"lDt ij~JI~aL'lh~;;- . -', Flalntl-f~::,~ ;,r)c!l~);~1.::;:;J TLJI- ~,n,/ lrICCiri."lenC~::' th(?'" (rl€~-./ h2VE ':;;US~d thiS HijN!"jFt~DL.t~ CDUFT ~~nd triG' Defc'nd::<.nt~ r~~q::H.dlnQ tnt.:.~ 2torelnentlQr~ed on 0'- ~bout JUl1e 18. 19~1 d~t~. WHEREFORE. F'121ntl+fs request tt,~t th15 documerlt of e;'olanatlon c~nd clarl'ilc::;,tlon be ql\/en -full corl:;ldl?t-~tlon if; the dellbet"atlCins ':'If tnls Hl]~'JOf~'i4E\1._C C:OUF.T. G:espec:t i ,";1 i', . ?1ttachment s l OC!. 5 Ole / jde&g/C{~ / ::-':!', ':;or.ln':~ Fotld Carl )~;1~. FA. 17\:'13-57':'6 CF At t c>rne\,. , I tl! , ,. , ., , t,) C " " c' ~-, ' '-.J ) ,.j . . . . , . , 'L. ! . .' ~" ,( ! l' 'I" ,~! 1:' i . r ' I\;L':'~'H T'J '.; ;\Civ.'(~ I ,__ .i'.'t't:'t-; II b C~-~iH> I' ~!._~ H t: il: r rr .:'iT.. t,,'.: int;:, ~ tJ(.:_'ii: ':"I::':;:\.:"-."'i.' ,-(1'."- ..:*.It,n Tel c:cn'1~' " J'l C.I'-,>'-'. h ~\ j:.. ~ .- r,"! " .: ff' ~'j: 111 I . ,~ ;",,: Tl _JirQ- _~((,CC-rC. ( ,---_.., -- i kd..'c'l t. .1 :'j ! I d';', ,- , "I' " '( , I:!" ',! co. " I ~__ ;- ut': ,. ........-:_-~. ,- nc.f.:'nd,\ni-. _ :.J ,'-j ,'j ~. , 'i (:r-, l'l ::;11,I'-i, I.:.1r;- C:', 'i", ~-. i 1 "'i, ," -,.r"'-, '.~' r -~ '.'r'l iI' ': i i I -~ ' '; f" ,,""It:, :~ f~' ,_:' f , :. ," ,~,Ljl- ; i'!;;" " 1-1 [: ~ ':.' 1'"' i r',", ,t, i'-" 7 . '/~ ~~... ~ - ---_.._-,.. ~ _~_-....:: . 1'" . -~--~-~-:--::-;-~-:::- .~_.t" I , : '.' i ::7{f~; .~ '.~ \.' ,',)- ,'lit: ""; . ~HH 11 ." 'ij i " ,:, I,;, :)1. q! ~ '. ". . 'r;' t ~ : ,~,r'~- l . I , ~:,rL r- 'tq'~!'" t "UCil );"1~1F"-' ~~~~'{r'r.-F: r.:rir\L r -::...:: :Ur'UF F'(',r! [\~.;" '.21-ld,,:-,1. ::..l ,'tl :1) Ir',!,lr~(I:W' ~ .'. , , . I\C:1 1)1: ~~~:.L.~.'~~_"_____-I..~'l !'lL~..~..1.:J::' , , , ..'1 '. r ''::'!'jLi ,'~ ,--;"~;. " 1,_1 r' .i"._'.',"- , :'-.":-ll':"'i.:r- " i~dilli"':t..:-cJ ir; p~~.t-+ ,'\.:';,',)1. i" .......,:,.t :"t:;'" '1,., t C' , . '1 ' ., '.:'~ , , , " C' ,,1'1 " ",; ":'11 L.:,t" "'L ~ ;-, ~ ~ ::'l~[Lt cr '~,'~T; p ;.' ~ :~H-~ '!' : !r: f,f' ':! !'t':::'Y " ,'.It ,-I '1-',,' " t'1 [' I.IOT ~:;..~ 10 j-' ....1 !-!-,'. [, I D t'AI1AGE .,j !-., " ..l di:"'': tr o/-:-<j ;; J .J " ", I'- 1"-' , ' '-i' , " 'd .. :.~ l i . 1: .' f. -.1 ;t',', (:'.Ii,!. .;',. t /-;n.-' .:~ il . '''1' ~ ;~' t . or:. -, '.1, ,h~,I';Y.Jr' ,.," td I.. t . . r,' , jlll; . ~ . l,'.'il.,I- i '. .lJ:','" :'j"; '. i~ 1'- ,1l'L,/ ,'. , ',I'., '__.':.l' C" 'Cl "l .:' ',IL oJ .-:.'1, ~. ,-,it!, t;;:- r::: ;.U'l:,] , '. L ~'I L C' . . .~t! ,- F-, ;! I _ -II \ ~ , 1 , , I, " e ~(CE-p t. ',!o' r.:c..J '::(: t 1~'~li.i t,:,C]l <'ph , .'.1 r'1 " J ; j ~ ,,; ;\1. '.U<itc de:i':; ir:: ;", :, .~ ,L: i ,j'; t!" ;-! '.i ~ . . r-, hed; , -,,' .:,p!H 1, ,. ..:i'.-ir.:: ,'-'li<_f I.": ! ! ,', 1 ~ ' ; I . 0~~"-' _lnJ:\: :'_\.1 ~l ": ", _.11...1 1~rr -- . ", -4--, {)C:CII it t ~",jl~) v;:-, 1,1__ .- , -! l.._.', ! 1 ~. ~ t::: [-,.c. t'lf.:.'::':; h.:i..i_: bL'\:.'r', l.1nc:\ljl j'(J .'., "j! 1j",""': .~' (.'\:" t t~d tlii_', L f" 1 ,;.:. ~.! ":',1 r,. 'I.,' ,I', to, ' F'C'.Jt:...ct ;:.Ij 'r - ,;c.~. .~ lill ".j " I 1"" '.1 ' ~. 1 ".;d I ~-. [l ,; ":. .0. , ;- . :,~_ i l i.J i ~ i 1"'( \:.'::.. ':-" ., IlL".. I ";i:r~ !:r;~.;[ r::: nJ:~1I~:.':.'-' ')~-':!<'l'~"" f-,..... .;1 -.'; J i"l .',. lfi .i:.Ii" "~I ~ , : - ~ (: ;. .. , , 1JII['r "r','1r '." , il I' ,.., ::' ~ 1 denie hl;~ L i ,'.~ l!i 1 \ , . CUli';.U!" )1 Def<?ndants request for di srni ssal . tlH) t-1ATTEP ::,' !_:~uld;n': ;-', L r 1\) f_;::J;Tj.n(}!' ~ -) t~;;jJ~')ltt,:;!d In PCtl-I.: .\i,':': L~;_':i-;l'~" . \ i"' ~: I' l,r' ~"I,J;,j U\,".t "j ..:: ':.-11 ' 1 fl9 .'E:, ~~ t., .:-__1 (1 t~.. j ::- Llj _ L } ~- ':. , .,. ~,i_:( :.:I.,l11 cf,hO:"T 'J,' t- _ T~l \:~ ;::: ,') 'c,; (;;: .', "~ f..1 r "::.t~ ~ r'~..x- :' 1 T: \1 "~!T . '1 'C J!..!r' l :,.1. [,;,.,,)\11-1'_';',1. 1:-'., ,_.c;,". !~. , , , ; ~ i..i .. ;.. .' ,.,; ,.., .-? , i 1 '- ~ I , .--' . riOT! CE OF JUDGEt'lEtIT/TPAtl~;CI PT, C'o,:v" t tlo.: C')-0000283-95, is clearly marked "DI91ISSED W'O PREJUDICE" and is further marked a"X Thi~ C~$~ di ;m!~i0d without prejudice.>> 1 .., Der.ied. [lj:tr\.:t ,.lUEtic.:' ':.!--.ul+?nb~r9(.r diirT,i;;;--?d F'1E<.inti-f-f: C':";:,e v1i th0Ut pre'Judle'? C.:<mm'i/"t_ . ftl (, [, i .z t r i.;: t .J IJ ::. tic c. ~ s l.;ottc-r (-f t' pl~r,:.tjc,n elf 1:: ['~,:.:'mt,-:'i 1':;-'7'5 f.:- C','<2'33-'?5 t\';.\.S i-;;~.u.:-d n.-:-:.r'l) (il_'(- m::;-.th: :...f,-.~,( u....-.:' h.:,,:.r-ing c,;", 10 ,Jul/ 1995. ( ,;..) t? t h (. ['0 i ;: ~ r i ': t. _' l.J ::: t i:;;" :: ~';' ~ t ': r :\ ~ .j.;. -f >? rl .j), r, t:: [ ..., I t,: ~ c.) 1.; ~it :r-' :r';~Ct,-' :,; l'1!':- , "; -' ,~ i- ,;..,..- ':.:.! I~' f'.-'. t" \.3 dl !'! - : I , ,. "1'.j,;. _ ... ' .' , '-J !;i 1 ~.. 'I ", -.)', ~, I' "1"" ~. r-; ,~~ ;'~ ~':L t: f'!:-' ~~::., ',.,-.t., ",\ . .--" _.'1 t :. 1-1--" _'I'.,,', .' ;,' ,,'t:- ~'ii ':';Ut~-l',:'l ~. t,' ,.' _ i ',~ . , ,:; .i -.;'} .,;11. ~ , ; Ci; '_',~ ill' ., I l C; i-,i! l' ,--,' r-;" , , .:.L't , - ., \.'- - _11'._' ..,J'.1_,' ';1.:1.; , L:i " 0 " ';1 'J,L:. ,', t;-:\ >,.'(' " ,~- : I J c-t.., ','" -,.,'" I ,~ ,'-' ;: r Jc,l"..' (.mb(- r 1 S"~ 1 n.:';. r 1~. f i " E' r7"I.:.rl t h: ). f t o'? r E;...r 1 F. '::m j t hIt, (, t )1, ;;:,."n::ludcJ t.heir Id':irl, '~Irf r1':llntiff:" /z-t,r-d. (S('C' CG'}0r l~tt€'r,d E\hibit .-...13.--,) ~, '"-'-' D~ni"d. The- ;:t,~tu(- of imit':1~i,:'r,:_ f':'f ':orltr;t..:t'5. i-: undo:r- stood to be four )u.r., ...~ Den;~d. The lIagrec.m.:'ntU j-;; a vj tal Pj,f't C.r thi:: 1 i tig;;tion. EARL F. SI'lITH II by '.'irtue ,:,f hi:. p,:,:j(jor. ,.,f l~.~dH~hjp and "u thor I tl" <>s Ch" I r 1I\2.r. 0 f th" Car 1 is 1 €' Subur ban Au thor j t)', !i.nd t,;..' hi:;, signature) .!t '~ymbol elf hi,=: ~uthc.rit/ ;'ild hi:: appro,'"l of th€' r>EEC' OF Etl':'CtlD1T, RIGItT-OF-lJt\Y Ar~D RIGHT OF ENTRY AGREEHEIIT, .: ~r.r j ~ s r" :pon: i!:' j I , t,' 'I' did perform "Jorl(~ {H.h:l i" t.r}.: 1 n J.i _~'cl' ~~ :d;\.1 .j ~ :"', i. I t c"j t.h:"\t E. ! !~ 1- -. -,"~<.- J;"_< jJ:'" lOCH ~:;upcr -." I" C:W 1 C',,:,,: 1 '\I"L. 1'",!-1,.:r'1.l I,J':t .i '::.,' ii,t: d ~'10t-! 111'vol \/ in] f.h,-,:. v;...._c Ii, i'1dllli 1.1: ~:.:d Ui....'t E. ',\;,,; '.'.,':'/ ':ill\:"- LEE DC H dj d ;j'.I' < f" , , '/ ,01"(1 i'ih: '~.h i~: ".",r ~.! i'~ t,: ):':~!, ! .\,F<': "",,' J ,- ~-, 1. . ~ J " ;~I '.... ;::,r'r-; 1_ .. ~ ,,;'\' " ;' 1 ;!"," (1';(:t' tl J iu1 f I ..:..:'qu il;.~';.l \..- ~'; q;-'; '-.li ,) '..; t '-'-.Ji ;1-; .'\_ t "":>-, , o ! ~; L' f 1 " 'I ~i .;\ , "'!,;t"l:'d .... '.,; 'C';'\ , i,'; ~ J 11..',':: \1 t 1 '. ~i 'J 1: , H, >,",\ ., .... ~. t '.J I,,:ommc-.nt [;".1 i ~~ ,II ~ '. : I , , , , t.tlt..' C,:O:-It..l i S'i 1 t~ Sur">", ,__ ii '''il.' ,')/ ~ , 1 ,.\r;d ..:11 t"J t~,_~ '"jf l~lC 'r, .11 :.,1 c' CZ.\f C.;l.lt-H.q-t. r' ~ ~' L I " \ "'lr::-r:[~Of:,[ , if.! '-, . . ~ .. D~ f ,r,d.<.n,_ dE-rl i >2 I i"'~ I,;" - t r .eqlJe =- . 1 \7'}-' '" ,-~, ~ f j ( ~ " ~.\ , t'h> ,i'_.\ '....; , .....:1(..' f ,:.r di ~ml ..:li.'. _d ;'j"I',. r:t j;'. , ; '{'i~:" i,jL,... C. 11\ 1 .j c-., ( ',vn:. ~H)l ~~' ,jc.:r: (~ ,~~ :~ :; t- t. I;;;": j"!..\m~-! , " :.il t (") tlJ - ~ ~_'~::'2(\ 1- ,~;r ! , ~ -~! I I, ! ~ I ~.' i , 1,':' 1,-' ~.)U! - ~-. -:-a.l I.. , r-':(),'l (~ ~ j i !' i i i ;j . ! (__, r~' ~:: rOOi r-, . -' I -'L-"',r- ''''.1 ...lntif{:~, .:'; r. 1 \:~ 1'~;:\13 ~:.;~~,,;~~ ",.t". . \; '." , )~- I l " . ." 4..; /\.' .; ,'. .' ':'r,i:r.~;j . , , ;, . " Wedne.day. December 2. 1892 --" _.~- ----- Resident: Authority should pay By Kellle Patrick Sentinltl neJlUrter \ :"-illllh \lhltllrlllll 10\\11,1111' h."lI.h.'1I1 ,.. lllllllll1l111~ III ,"'illlll,h ....ilh t ',lIlt..k Subur h.lll ,\lIlh~lIll~ 0\\,'1" IIh ):11,1 111hll I )1111. ~7~1I Sprilll! Ruad. " 1Il1hapl') ,,1111 till' \\ ay Ihl' authmilY l'Ulll1l'Cll!d Illl' 11I1II1l' tlt<< lIIu'!'o lI\.'ighh(}r~. Mlchal'l .1l111I.in. 11.1 I{llll, III Ih..: 'C"l'r lill\.' in JUIIC' 19lJl. SIIIlI\.' of 1hl' digging hiulln he ,hull" ill lit\.' "lid III Ihl' ()lIm~. \\ollu 'l!!l1l'lt illle,,'" of ~';I'I.'lIIl'lIl ~r;lnling pl'nnl'i,inn. lllUk'( I hI.' l't1l1lr;Kl. llal' HuI/C' .m: "hI rl'slnn: ltn\. lli'i- turlX'11 m.llh\u)' Of lli..lurhcd "~i1S" rcslllting fWIII Ih,,' ,\'\\"\.'T linL' WUlIo. on Ihl' ()Un,' I'IOI'l\.'(1)'. Olin Ihillls th.: lhUIl"}!l" IhOlI rl',uhl'd II' hi, shruhs, mulch. \l1l1 unu IUpsuil were eu:cssi\'l'. ThNl'fore, he says. Ihl' Knl/.l's should l1ul he rcspnnsihle. Ill' \\'.m" IlIl' aUlhority In ma"'c rcslilUliulI. MN. RIIII. say' Suhurhml/\ulhnril)' SUI~r iUlcJuleUI "l.ee Koch c~llloline" In u' hdml' lhe line w'as in'I<1l1ed a hull' w(luhlm'l'tllu hc.' ,Iul:! in Illl' nuns' yard mul Wl.' would he rcspol1,ihh: fur rc'l'l.'din~ Ihe arc.l." She '''ys she and her IIU,hallll wuuld haw "glmlly p:lil'" In reslore Ihc y.mJ where il was dug up. lIOWl'ver. shc sOlys Ihe h1lHI. Sl"Ul1ing was nul minclJ S(I IIII1l'h hCl:.llIse il W.I' dug. up hul ltt:citu,c Ihe i.IUlhllril) pill'll dirt Ul1lUp Ill' il. Sheo ,ays Ihe ,Iulhnrily l'mlltll!ll,ily h.l\'c pli.Il'l'lllhl' pill' of dirt clsl'whcll', 'll il ,Itnuld he rcsJ1C.U1,ihll.' fur rc,luraliun Will.... Suhurh.m AUllu1rily SUI'Crin1e1U1L'1l1 tel' KUl:h 'OJ)" "Ihe hllll11l11linc" IS lhe Ollm. mul Ihe KIlI/"S signell .lII :1~!Jecl11cnl s:I)'illg 1111..' Rnl/l" wcre re'IHllIsihll' fur tlal11:l~l." l'II'IlI',I,I' ;11l"1l11 ,'I 111,- lllllll..ll!, "Wl' \\\\111.1 ',\. llc.dl \'1111 Ollll, ....Plll ;l\M" "'l1ullh' dll"'ll I \~,III' 1\1" 111..';11 KII" h ,ulth Ih,ll. 'inll' C )110 11,1' '1lJ!~l"'ll'll Ihi, III,tllt'l 111.1\ ~p h, 1I11t'alillll. Ih,,' .llllllOII 1\ '.. ,,1111111"'\ liil~ il\h "l'll hlln 11111 In 11I.11..". lilllhl'rnllllill~'lIl, Olio "IY' Ill' b,'l!;IllI,:Orfl"P"IUIiIll! \\lIh 11l1' OIl1lllllfll) hy hoth kltl'r and I1hlllll.' .1' StlUIl .ts Ihl..' \\ur1-. '.\;1' "111I11.... IIi.. lasl lOIll'sl'lln. IklU:C \\lIh Ih,,' tllIlhlllil\" wa, IIllh,,' 'pnn~. lie ';1\' Ih' ;llIlh0I'11\ 'I..'nl a 0"'\\ III 11.'11I0\'1..' iot:~, frolll h", t.:i1ilkllll~hl ,Iltl'r 11ll' \\0'''' ".1' l'lIIlIpll'l""!. mill "(,,, ..enl ,llo:hllll Inp,"il. BUI hI..' ..;1\ '> Ihl..' top,uil \\:." pllnt hl'":;''!''''' II l.'tllll;III1,'1I \\1'1.'\1.. anti rOl....' Ihl..' ,i/l'llt't\\ll n,t, Ill" lelll'r d,lll't! tkl 1~, Itlll!. Iluhl..rt X Gilroy ",1' BIIIUjll\. (f11111)' alltlllll",lllll. Ihe C.uli,k Suhmh;Ul/\ulhunly', soIU:IIU1, pm. puwd all :lgn'l'I1I"'lJl helwl'l'lI Ihe mnhorilY, lhe 01111\ .1II111hl' Knl/n. Thl.' "~rl.'eml.'nl ..mil Ihl.' Olh", wnuhl rt:l:I."i\l' a \I~O \:..,h 1'.1)lIIl.'lllltl rl'plan' :In) ...Inllh... Ilr Ir,,',,'" lli.ll ",,'r,,' ,lama!!I.'11 :lIId pcr- form llult.lilil.',IIItIIl' III Ihe Ihi\'C\\;t)' 11IIrtillll nf till' Olin I'lul1l.'rl) II '1;lIl" Ihl' HUllc", woulll pel lor", llll' "Iilwl ~Iadillg .lIId 'l'l'lllllg" olthl' 0110 prnpl.'l1y. ,lIllllhl' ,ullhurity \\tlIlld I'11IVillw: ,II no l'har ).:l' hI ){1I11 fuur ('uhk yurt!... of fliP' ,nil fill ",,,' in III", l'rojl.'l"I. 0111' ..a}!\ Ihl.' Illt'"I.:~ wl1ultll1t11 nl\l'1 Ihe d,lI11;lgt' IIUlll'. '11 Ill' \Hllh.thl..'I:I\\ linn illl.'l- Il"r ....lyil1~ h,,' \~llllhl lIul .ll.'(Cpl Ihi, uITer. Thl' .mlhonly h".. nnllU.ulc " 111.'\\ litTer. 0110 eslil1l;lll" Ihe ,100m.I!:!\.' oU .')I,4h7.1", whkh hl' ';lVS I' I Ill' .III\IIUIII of 11I011\'\' :t 11I1..;tIIOllllhl':;PI.'(' lold him it wlIuhl ..:",j 10 repltll.'c 1111.' 1'101111'" h1p,,'il ulIII olher Ihlll}:' JeHlc\' Lu"dO,c Sl.'llllnl'1 John Olto shows soil provided by North Middleton, The Rotzes live in the house in the background. Olin !toa)' Wl'n: J;lIn.I!;!I.'11 hy Ihl.' aUlhmilY, Olin ~"Y' he is slill Inuldng fur \\':1)" III ~llh'l' lhi~ prnhlcl1l, Ih.. ha~ talkcd 10 ;l IUl:al 141w)'cl whll sllillll0lhill~ l:uuld be llulll' 111 IImk.: Ihc :.mlhl1rily P:l)' 1m Ihe dmna~c. "lhe 100\\')"cr InlLll11c Ihl' aUlhority luultl du IlIl' sallll' Ihillg ;tgilin III sOlncnnt: d,l.", .1I1tllhllhing wl1uld 1111l1pcl1:' Ollu say.... "I thin'" Ihi, is im"Jltll1,ihlt: gowntlllCn1." The Sentinel city desk open ":30 ~.m. ~ 5 p.m. weekdays. Call 24 EKHIi3 Ie ~Ji l ().JflS t")/l () ~I{ ()t'D t>; (1('(/(( r..L':: ~~,' ~ul1 f:>.:I~ A. <-rT II<.'/t / r r- !5!...czr rCil/:'Tlf At, (\()lG"1O^'~'t.I"")HI f' /, . - ~ .' . L- F[frt; - A __A_"~-'~";;:"';'" .."-....--. 1-, L~ - 2720 Spring Road CarliBle,~ 4Ndv.Ma.~O,'ii1991:;;~.,"') Ur refl Ltr 10/22/ 91, CSA/Otto et al Hubert X. Gilroy Attorney at La~' 4 North Hanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 Dear Counselor: Regarding the "dispute" over the wrecking of my yard, neither the Rot~sNor the ottos were provided a copy of their agreement with the Carlisle Suburban Authority. Mr. Lee Koch promised same and witnessed the signing. c pertaining to Although it is not my intention to speak for the Rotzs, I would suspect that they are of similar mind. Sincerely, CCI John Otto Chair, CSA Super, CSA v-The Rotzs ---- -'----...-. ... - '{;{'{'(~I r It: ,/ JOHN H. OROUIOS HUBERT X. CILROY CHRISTOPHER C. HOUSTON BROUJOS. GILROY 8 HOUSTON. P. C. ATTORNEYS AT LAW 4 NORTH HANOVER. !.TRUT CARLISLE, PENNSYLVANIA 17013 711.243,.57. NON. TOLL fOk HAIUUUUkC AJUA: 117.1&8'1890 'AX: ...3.8227 'If.g~~"1x:1~R ji~j991;P\~;~'t) Hr. John Otto 2720 Spring Road Carlisle PA 17013 Dear Hr. Otto: In response to your letter of November 3, 1991, I am enclosinq the following documents: _..~ A. Copy of Deed of Easement between Hr. and Hrs. Otto and the Carlisle Suburban Authority dated June 10, 1991. B. Copy of Deed of Easement between Hr. and Hrs. Rotz and the Carlisle Suburban Authority dated June 10, 1991. C. Copies of minutes from Carlisle Suburban Authority meetings of June 10, 1991 and October 14, 1991. Copies of these documents have also been sent to Hr. and Hrs. Rotz. I will now look forward to hearing from you and Hr. and Hrs. Rotz relative to my October 22, 1991 letter. cr Encls. (4) cc: Hr. and Hrs. Rotz E. Lee Kor:hlcSA E-fJ+f{ ~,7 B V...l.v (lit(ty '1&1/-(,"'/ (etrl'- 1/1 . 1/ ,) .th ,,"trI.,) In the Court or Common Pleas or Cumberland County. Pennsylvania VI. No. i !l. '/ t Civil. 191." .#.w.tf,t.:d" II: t. Lpv k'ttfi,. , f 9 ~ ~ I ~/, , tt/.?'Li'J}~.J;l1 ,-, l.tAt-tl, ( A .. .LIkAL ('It:dt Ao'~j Ift,/.j(;,dJ -' l:,,/-t/I.)Jjc4'U:".Jc..J.. 0 R D.e F\ ;rllVl'-'-~7 X 1'f9li, rYl _rlt' A/I'~~~I/;t) 0) f}!S .llkseb.....;..{~v '} D?,~k,'-'7~ ~P-<-t. r.)~~-d II f ;~: ;'~J~ ~~, -A. /.L~Y1 fAll .<fJi",j"o ~,."l r-<-~~ .":',-J/t ( )}1:, .::t '~f-<>)9,t</ ').. / . f J 7:l {fff.d/:, __...I (ao.:??"" fP tr__, . C;l.) (Je II) I el7Ai.fJ ""'r~";'" _;--litl'JCu..J..:.j, '),.J...tAj....v'{)~f To (It.t.ufj Q.{ .ftt..U{! f({.l.oLL,hl I'rulhollul:Iry c? 7 ;;'{it (N(t'19 qB d~~ .$.0",- .r , ",,;..:-..---- .'-.~.. ... .".;... .- \, No. Term, 19 vs. I'RAECIPE Filed 19 7J tL C; oJ.) vO ~ n ~ tt.. Q) "J:. l5\ (. oQ . . AllY. ~ a... -6. - -t:::l ~ 8=- . "'~"J :;-; :!!'" . , ! c eJ If" .... \~ .J .":' l::'-.i_1 :~:~~:-.'-:~_.. . .< I . JJ .".) \J.;I:.:J , ....#. -~ .....;. .~t''''''' Cl lIe .. G.. r.I.~ N t5 11" ) ,'1""'\''''\ ) } ) ) ) G"I,)lt -;...\... I.. oJ null....i y 1 , t)~(......L...J,.- OA:1i In The Court of C~cmon Pleas of Cumberland County. ?e~nsylvania So. If.n_ . (HIP' 19f;" We do sol~ly s~ear (or aifi~) that ~e ~ill support, obey and derend the Constitution of the United States and the C~nstitution of this Co~on- ~ealth and that ~e ~ill discharge the duties of our ofiice ~ith fidelity. ~ AW"_1lJl ~e, the undersi~ed arbitrators, having been duly appointed and s~o~ (or a:fi~ed). cake the following award: (Note: If d~ges f~r delay are awarded, they shall be separately stated.) Lv..... l= .".l \-~...c,,- ,.., {\~CI\''''~ \~ t.,,- I... '-4". -t'hL Oct1o..d"nY C t~ f'l~,~hl"l", q",(...l ~ l, "- ~'. l... _ /", ~ ,4 <- ,.,4..../-., I~ .tla "~5..h'.' 0\'= 7/"... fh...I..,l ($3~o. .(oJ CHI",., <.. applicable. ) Arbitrator. dissents. (Insert naee ,: SOTICE OF ~y OF ~ow. the day or Ju..uf...s . 19.:?i-. ae~. &.:1.. award ~s eneered upon ehe docket and ~otice thereof given by ~il ?arti~s or th~i= at:~~eys. nate of Bear~~g: G> h/q .f , . G I?lt", ~ , ' Jaee of Award: Arbitraeors' coapensaeion :0 be paid upon appeal: S :;91') . f'X) the abe....e to the is'! a?7L/ K~~ ~ ?ro onota:-t ~.~ rn." P.~? ?l"(, . ' e?u:.:: G,p'l -1-0 C I) . J<..,ckuuL. .9IE(-<..I;]fL+ - f;/UYl _ q.).1. s, , /u. i2.0~~d-p. K..L,~c ':r<.X\. J~m(.~ ~I-I~ (g... . ':X.cL - c/2.)cr/.1'C..'i:.- rn.~~ L~l (') .n (') ~ CD ." :.-. <- -, -"{lro ! c;:: (riO', , .'- Z .~l 1 :"~l. (.... - 1..f1 -<." I~l. ~~ ;:; ,'-', .- #........ ;,' -, t.:..t -, 9J ;.-';.: ::;~ ~ '" ;J) 0 '< JOII".,6;ro .-(1"",,, F\ ',' 7X ~t(7~)(l;Jjfu (( /J( "-'/tt..i-'3 . ~ii;l.J,z(~/N ~j uTr/C;J?r7j- '[)-';:-k-POAw ( CIVU/SLG' r.r THE COURT 0::' CCf.!MC!T PUft.S .......~"",T ., '''' ,"'OTT'I'!"" ='~ls'rr '" 'II,' .....u,~.I.;.,.. ,J \,.'.... _, .._... __Ir-..___ ~ro . ,-/-2 7 C I (r'v; ( I W~ NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM AT..r~ OF ::OP~:m C::' A.l1EITRATORS TO '1':'..::; ?R~ONCTA.'qY: Not;i'~e is given t":Jat-'ln.uCiIO .1A1IJ(!Il?cL'!tY(..JlE, the aWaI'd of tr.e board of arbitrators enterec ~ t:.:!.s .:yrlL /" I f~ , a?~als ~:'or:t case on Jo../t.:E A jury trial is cemar.ded L:1. (0r.eek~ cox ir a Jury t:,ial is demar.ded. CtheI'T..r1se jury t;r:!.al is '.,ai'led.) I hereby certify that J (1) (2) the compensation of' ~l:e e:obi-::'ato!'s r.as '::ee:1 ;:aid, o!' ~~~11ca~~cn ~~ ~89~ ~O~9 -- ~a:" ;e.&. .<J~;;:31.0n to ?I'U(.;t:=~C 1::. .. au;:er ~ ~~e _~ep;_~~ao_e \ ...~- , , v o~el1ant.s'o: .;t';Qpr:eJ .~"... A??911antf ?lCTS: The, dem.end for jury trie..l on a;:peal f!'om compulsory arbitration is gcuerned by ~..1le 1007.J. (b). (b) ~ro affida'lit or ver:!.:'icat:!.on is :'e~:!.rec. , 1: "'I ~ i 1:1 0 . , 0 (-j . oQ v a- 0 ~ct I.' ," ",'. '. (,;. - j-. l'\ ::l- " 111 n ~ 1t~ O~ .>. '-~ JOHN OTTO & CAROLYN OTTO PIJ'.INTIFFS IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERIJ'.ND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. EARL F, SMITH, II, E, LEE KOCH, JAMES SL YDER and CARLISLE AUTHORITY, DEFENDANTS 95-4276 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 17th day of December, 199B, IT IS ORDERED that a bench trial shall be conducted on the within civil case at 8:45 a,m" Thursday, February 25, 1999, in Courtroom Number 2, Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle, Pennsylvania, John Otto, Pro se 2720 Spring Road Carlisle, PA 17013 . ., I /t':f _ Co "<Lv ...,.,........./...., p. Ii' . a ..!. 1'. Hubert Gilroy, Esquire For Defendants :saa r....',...l': r" loG' ;:~ ''''''~Ir'~ t.,\.,", .~.~., 'r"" )\ I;" ...~.,. ' ,. DEe 1 5 1999 j 'f :!II ,-", ,- J ')!: '~i ( ./ Jr"ll;-1 rn r(i ((\r>(!: 1 r J (! I i tl if! If:1 ftPIr-:l IJl C":(1tn1C1i: f"J ~ 1'-; ! J(" Lt i!'1rrr.r,.! III ji"; i ! ,') 111 L i i . - ~. ;' , ... ,- '!~11r !'-, I'!.' /i"\l ~ r ,', j"{in: ~. '-=:!lrT~,. r~. ! "1.li'I:. _i,)ra'c'. .! Il['!o' /~;lr'.:I ::_~;LF "'":jt~':\Il;T:"ll, 10J 111 .'~,! l i i. ii -, : '1 ~. r . ,~ : r. i " : tit JT J }'r~s i I. Ill;; fll ~ -!'," " ", .j"" tl':'I''-,'U_ p;1t.i t .lor, +:t'H l:'C'd If,'-r Uf" r';J~1ilC'!J r'l r f 'j' ,"/!] ; , ;' ; ~ 1 ! (" ti.:':iI :Il\j 'l-"I" -,I :;)11": (H '!",. 'i"'I' ,J fll.1 '(;1"1; ;I:I(J .(11,' 11, r'~ I TH I rF~:: f ,\'iC!1 ), 'd.Jf '1"11\ 'r'; , ; 1 ,jIJ',' ." \; . ,".i. , I " . en ,:+' "". ." " "d':, i . ~ 'I I .J .., " "ri' 'f.' \,,'il, .1..., . ' 'It' t' ~ t : , . II .l rftLt.L-( (itc .. "~I ~ , . " . " ._.1, ',._"'," ~"IF nrf"; " -~-~ r- " ; I ~! - ~. i~ln: ; ~l(1t'J , ~ ' ,r; I I II' f Uf 1_~"~/1 \ '. I, 'J !": T!~-; q "I., (IC) I" i" (I ._1 r ,~ , , ,~ If ;Ij :t",\'1;1:! -! :' "r- r, 't~r:rr~:i ,'tr 1:"1 "Il'!' '":-- : ~: !' . ",,:11.:, I 'l , :- .:3" >- ~ t:; -<... ,-- c.::' ;3~ w~: <.h. :.'= 'J~ G:~.' i.1.. -, '.I.....l '-,--, :5:~ ~, .~ ;-, ~'U, , ~;'.. Wi... :ErA E~' '-, 1-- 1..'_. ::~u_ c:. lI, 0:: :;:l c\ 0' U JOHN OTTO & CAROLYN OTTO PLAINTIFFS IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. EARL F, SMITH, II, E, LEE KOCH, JAMES SL YDER and CARLISLE SUBURBAN AUTHORITY, DEFENDANTS 95-4276 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 12th day of February, 1999, the petition of plaintiffs to delay the trial because of health problems, which is not opposed by defendants, IS GRANTED. The trial scheduled for Thursday, February 25,1999, IS CANCELLED and may be relisted by any party, / By the Cou~,l . 1/ I // ''-~\,l.{,c.</,' Edgar B, Bayley, J; / John Otto, Pro se 2720 Spring Road Carlisle, PA 17013 c.~",,",.~.L :l.1,~/'l<j. ...J.'6', Hubert X, Gilroy, Esquire For Defendants :saa I ! . RLFD-OmCE OF 11'~ r f"~'. '''''IOT'''Y ot ' .. ,Ir.. 1'1: Itvl 99 FED I 6 AI1 8: 20 CUMp!;;;J';,llJ CO'JifIY PENNsYLVANIA ~ I "'; ., /o._w ,.." ",<1' i" 'I" ., ~ ! ;;1 Iii " " l-; ; l .' l' f"!! ;~,'T [', -...'7....'.. .If! ,H, , .'" ."....f ;:;1.1 \.Ii .T~'.tl! ;-;.:1" ... 1 r ",!'"." ,')I , . r ,. .. , i I ~ ; , . , ' " ". !.i! .-11.. -': '~.aw-' -- ...r ~ b:; Lr. ".1: t-:: .. :'-.J~ ~,I~ N (-:"):' 'C. :c ,-)~ FO[' o "'- (1)!:_.: 0- l-_)>j ',." ':- ~~,: "<'> '012 01~.. CO !d~ w "'- ::r: u. C" ::> c' C'\ U