HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-04287
.
c1.
<.t;
.
f
(
d
-;
~
~
-
u
f
L..
~
J
r I
~ I
:r
Law Offices
JAMES D. FAMIGLlO, ESQUIRE, P,C.
Sproul Road at Williamsburg Drive
Broomall, PA 19008
(6101359-9220
By: James D. Famlgllo, Esquire
Attorney 1.0. No,: 51101
CARLA CLARK
128 E, 22nd Street
Chester, PA 19013
v,
,
Attorney for Plaintiff
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
TRIAL DIVISION
TERM.
NO, tJ..4 - /Id~' .') (~~~J"
CIVIL ACTION
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
2520 Lisburn Road
Camp Hili, PA 17001
and
STATE CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTION AT MUNCY
P.O, Box 180
Muncy, PA 17756
NOTICE TO PLEAD
You have been sued In Court. If you
wish to defend against the claims set
forth In the following pages. you must
take action within twenty (20) days
after this Complaint and Notice are
served. by entering a written
appoarance. personally or by attorney,
and iIIlng In writing with the Court
your defenses or objections to the
claims set forth against you. You are
warned that, if you fall to do so, the
case may proceed without you and a
judgment may be entered against you
by the Court without further notice,
for any money claimed In the
Complaint or for any other claim or
relief requested by the plalntiff(s).
You may lose money or property or
other rights important to you.
AVISO
Le han demandado a usted en la
corte. Si usted qulere defenderse do
eslas de estas demandas expuestas en
las paglnas sigulentes, usted dene
veinte (201 dlas de plaza al partir de la
fecha de la demanda y la notlflcacion,
Hace fahe asentar una comparencia
escrita 0 en persona 0 con un
abogado y entregar a la corte en
forma escrlta sus defenses 0 sus
objeclones alas demand as en contra
de su persona. See avisado que si
usted no se deflenda, la corte tomara
medidas y puede contlnuar la
domanda en contra suya sin prevlo
avlso 0 notlficaclon. Ademes, la corte
puede decldir a favor del demandante
y requlere que usted compta con
todes les provisions de esta demanda.
~. "
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO
YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE, IF YOU
DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR
CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR
TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH
BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU
CAN GET LEGAL HELP,
PHILADELPHIA BAR ASSOCIATION
LAWYER REFERRAL AND
INFORMATION SERVICE
One Reading Center
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19107
Telephone: 610-238-1701
Usted puede perder dlnero 0 sus
propledades u otros derechos
Importantes para usted,
LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN
ABOGADO IMMEDIATAMENTE, SI NO
TIENE ABOGADO 0 SI NO TIENE EL
DINERO SUFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL
SERVICO, VAYA EN PERSONA 0
LLAME POR TELEFONO A LA
OFICINA CUYA DIRECCION SE
ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARA
A VERIGUAR DON DE SE PUEDE
CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEGAL.
ASOCIACION DE L1CENCIADOS DE
FILADELFIA
SERVICIO DE REFERENCIA E
INFORMACION LEGAL
One Reding Center
Flladelfla, Pennsylvania 19107
Telefona: 610-238-1701
.
Law Offices
JAMES 0, FAMIGLIO, ESQUIRE, P.C,
Sproul Road at Williamsburg Drive
Broomall, PA 19008
(610) 359-9220
By: James 0, Famlgllo, Esquire
Attorney 1.0, No.: 51101
Attorney for Defendant
CARLA CLARK
128 E, 22nd Street
Chester, PA 19013
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
TRIAL DIVISION
v.
TERM,
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA NO,
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS CIVIL ACTION
2520 L1sburn Road
Camp Hili. PA 17001
and
STATE CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTION AT MUNCY
P.O. Box 180
Muncy. PA 17756
COMPLAINT
1. Plaintiff Carla Clark is an adult individual and citizen and resident of
the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania residing at 128 East 22nd Street. Chester,
Delaware County. Pennsylvania 19013,
2. The defendant, Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Department of
Corrections is a duly authorized Commonwealth party with Its principal office
and/or offices for service of process located at 2520 L1sburn Road, Camp Hili,
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17001.
3, The defendant, State Correctional Institution at Muncy is located at
RD 3, Route 405. Muncy Lycoming County, Pennsylvania 17756-0180 with an
address for service of P.O. Box 180, Muncy Lycoming County, Pennsylvania
17756-0180,
4, On or about August 16. 1993, at approximately 1 :30 p,m" plaintiff
Carla Clark was lawfully upon the premises commonly known as the State
Correctional Institution at Muncy, (hereinafter referred to as "Muncy Prison"), At
the aforesaid location, she was lawfully In the shower area, wnen she was caused
to slip and fall as a result of an obstruction, defect. or other Irregularity causing the
plaintiff to sustain serious and permanent personal Injuries hereinafter more fully
set forth.
5. At all time hereto and for a long time prior thereto, said "shower area"
was owned by and/or within the possession and/or control of the defendant
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania Department of Corrections who was then and
there responsible for the care and maintenance thereof,
6, In the alternative, at the times aforesaid and for a long time prior
thereto, said shower area was owned by and/or was In the possession and/or
within the control of the defendant Muncy Prison who was then and there
responsible for the care and maintenance thereof.
7. The negligence and carelessness of the defendants consisted Inter-alia
of the following:
a. failure to maintain the shower area In a safe manner for those
lawfully In that area, Specifically:
I. failure to properly maintain the drainage system in the
shower area resulting In a backed-up drainage system which caused flooding;
II, failure to properly clean and maintain the shower area
and. In particular. failure to remove baby 011. skin products and other materials from
2
the floor In the shower area;
iii. failure to place safety grips on tha shower floor;
lv, fallura to maintain and/or replace worn out and/or
damagad safety grips on the shower floor;
b, failure to repair the aforesaid obstructions, defects or other
dangerous conditions and irregularities;
c. failure to warn the plaintiff of the aforesaid dangerous
conditions of which the defendant knew or could and should have known in time to
remedy same;
d. In permitting the obstructions, defects or other dangerous
conditions to be and remain in the shower area when the defendant knew or in the
exercise of reasonable care should have known of the danger Involved;
e, In failing to remove, cover, blockade, or otherwise remove the
obstructions, defects or other dangerous conditions of which the defendant knew
or In the exercise of reasonable care should have known;
f, In permitting persons. and the plaintiff, Carla Clark, in particular.
to traverse the shower area when the defendant knew or in the exercise of
reasonable care should have known that It was dangerous to do so and Involved an
unreasonable risk of harm to persons so doing;
g, in falling to inspect the shower area to discover the
obstructions, defects or other dangerous conditions or in inspecting so carelessly
as not to have discovered these conditions;
h, In maintaining the shower area in an Improper manner or In
employing personnel who were not sufficiently qualified to maintain the shower
3
area In a proper manner;
I, In Inspecting the shower area In an Improper manner or In
employing personnel who were not sufficiently qualified to Inspect the shower area
In a proper manner;
j, In failing to hire, employ or retain personnel sufficiently qualified
to supervise maintenance of the shower area;
k, In failing to exercise that degree of care and regard for the
rights and safety of the plaintiff. Carla Clark, as was required under the
circumstances; and
I, In being otherwise careless, reckless and negligent as may be
ascertained by discovery,
8. As the direct and proximate result of the negligence of the defendants
as aforesaid, plaintiff Carla Clark. sustained the following Injuries, all of which are
or may be permanent in nature: severe injuries In and about her body, serious
Impairment of bodily functions and/or permanent serious disfigurement. she
suffered bruises, contusions and a tearing and stretching to various muscles.
ligaments. tendons, vascular, nerve and other soft tissues in and about the area of
his head, face, neck, shoulders. back. arms. legs, ankles and feet; she sustained
multiple herniated disks; she suffered a cerebral concussion with post concussion
syndrome; she suffered injury to various bony structures of her body. especially in
the area of her head. neck, shoulders, back, arms, legs. ankles and feet and the
herniation of multiple vertebral discs; and If, at the time of the accident. the
plaintiff, Carla Clark, was suffering from any pre-existing condition or aliment, such
were asymptomatic; and, as a result of the trauma, such condition or aliment was
4
activated, aggravated, exacerbated and mada symptomatic she suffered a sevare
shock to her nerves and nervous system; all of which did and may and probably
will In the future. continue to, cause her great physical pain and mental anguish;
and these Injuries may and probably will be permanent In effect.
9. Said plaintiff has In the past and probably will In the future suffer
great pain. suffarlng, Inconvenience, embarrassment, mental anguish. and loss of
the enjoyment of life: all of which probably are of a serious and permanent nature
with permanent disabilities and loss of function,
10. Said plaintiff has expended and will be required to expend large sums
of money for medical and surgical attention, hospitalization, medical supplies,
surgical appliances, medicines. and attendant services in an effort to have herself
treated for the aforesaid Injuries.
11. Said plaintiff's earning capacity has been reduced and permanently
Impaired:
12, Plaintiff has been In the past and may and probably will In the future
be hindered from engaging In her usual and daily duties, occupations, pleasures
and activities.
WHEREFORE, plaintiffs claim compensatory and punitive damages from the
defendants Individually and Jointly in an amount not In excess of Fifty Thousand
Dollars ($50,000.001 plus attorney's fees and costs.
Law Offices
JAMES D. FAMI I, ESQUIRE, P,C.
By:
, ~MIGLlO, ESQUIRE
for Plaintiff
5
- .. ""---- .
~ v.
t.LtJo..
CARLA CLARK
(LJa.JL
VERIFICATION
I, Carla Clark, verify that I am the plaintiff In the within
matter and thet the statements made In the foregoing Complaint,
are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, Information end
belief,
I understand that false statements herein are made subject to
the penalties of 18 Pa, C.S.A. ~4904 relating to unsworn
falsification to authorities,
Dated:
r-'
r
~
~
ril~
o-Cll1<
11<
.
Z><
OE-<
~E5 15
00 H
UU E-<
U
~C ~
OZ
~ o-Cl
fa~ .~
::IrilOH
8~zU
::I
rilU
:z:
E-<~
o
Z
'k
~
~
l.l
~.
-l ~ 'K~
~. '.'\'S~\
...:) .
"
....; ...<
i::1 \"
" ....
-, ,
f'-J ,
y) "'-J
-. '-.J
:::,..,;
~\..
l
I,.,
;.:
II:
~
o-Cl
U
~
iil
~
U
E-<
11<
ril
C
Ul
~Z
11<0
H
~E-<
OU 'tl
. ril l::
:> :Z:II: ill
E-<II:
o-ClO
~U
ril
~~
ZO
o
~
o
U
.'
.'-J
.*
\.n
'0
-"'"
"\ ..~,
~~
r,
'"
)
"
I,
><
o-ClU
~Z
Z::I
0:;:
H
E-<E-<
U~
ril
II:Z
11:0
OH
UE-<
::I
rilE-<
E-<H
~E-<
E-<Ul
UlZ
H
~
o i5~
::l 2!l....
8 ]i'e
~ .. ~~ 6
<ti=~ :::
IJ. ",.- c: , In
. i! 3: c: '" ..
O~;;~~o
(1):::"0-: -
~ -.: 8-
~ II:E
< :;~
- e",
c..
<1l
E-<
Z
H
~
o-Cl
11<
:;:
o
U
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CARLA CLARK,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Plaintiff
V.
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
and STATE CORRECTIONAL
INSTITUTION AT MUNCY
NO. 95 -4287
JURY TRIAL DE~mNDED
NOTICE TO PLEAD
TO ALL PARTIES:
YOU ARE HEREBY REQUIRED to respond to the within New Matter
within twenty (20) days of the date of service hereof or a default
judgment may be entered against you.
Respectfully submitted,
THOMAS W. CORBETT, JR.
ATTORNEY GENERAL
\;~ '
tark
ttorney General
y I.D. No. 51786
Office of Attorney General
Torts Litigation Section
15th Fl.. Strawberry Sq.
Harrisburg, PA 17120
(717) 783-1683
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CARLA CLARK,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Plaintiff
V.
NO. 95-4287
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
and STATE CORRECTIONAL
INSTITUTION AT MUNCY
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ANSWER AND NEW MATTER TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT
AND NOW comes Defendant. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania,
Department of Corrections and State Correctional Institution at
Muncy, by and through the Office of Attorney General, and files the
following Answer and New Matter to Plaintiff's Complaint:
1. Admitted in part. It is admitted that Plaintiff Carla
Clark is an adult. After reasonable investigation, the Commonwealth
Defendant is without sufficient knowledge or information to form a
belief as to the truth of the remaining averments.
2. Admitted.
3. Admitted.
4. Denied. It is specifically denied that the Commonwealth
Defendant was negligent in any manner with respect to Plaintiff's
alleged cause of action. It is specifically denied an obstruction,
defect or irregularity existed or caused plaintiff's alleged
injuries.
After reasonable investigation, the Commonwealth
Defendant is without sufficient knowledge or information to form a
belief as to the truth of the remaining averments.
5. Admitted only that the alleged injury situs is a state-
designated area, ancA that the Commonwealth party has those legal
duties as prescribed by applicable state law and regulation. To the
extent the remaining averments require an answer, they are
specifically denied.
6, Admitted only that the alleged injury situs is a state-
designated area. and that the Commonwealth party has those legal
duties as prescribed by applicable state law and regulation. To the
extent the remaining averments require an answer, they are
specifically denied.
7, Denied. It is specifically denied that the Commonwealth
Defendant was negligent and careless in any manner with respect to
Plaintiff's alleged cause of action. By way of further answer, it
is specifically denied that the Commonwealth Defendant was
negligent and careless in the following respects:
a. Failure to maintain the shower area in a safe manner for
those lawfully in that area;
i. failure to properly maintain the drainage system in
the shower area resulting in a backed-up drainage system which
caused flooding;
ii. failure to properly clean and maintain the shower
area and. in particular. failure to remove baby oil. skin products
and other materials from the floor in the shower area;
iii. failure to place safety grips on the ohower floor;
iv. failure to maintain and/or replace worn out and/or
damaged safety grips on the shower floor;
b. Failure to repair the aforesaid obstructions, defects or
other dangerous conditions and irregularities;
c. Failure to warn the plaintiff of the aforesaid dangerous
conditions of which the defendant knew or could and should have
known in time to remedy same;
d. In permitting the obstructions and defects to be and
remain in the shower area when the defendant knew or in the
exercise of reasonable care should have known of the danger
involved;
e. In failing to remove. cover. blockade, or otherwise
remove the obstructions and defects of which the defendant knew or
in the exercise of reasonable care should have known;
f, In permitting persons. and the plaintiff. Carla Clark, in
particular, to traverse the shower area when the defendant knew or
in the exercise of reasonable care should have known that it was
dangerous to do so and involved an unreasonable risk of harm to
persons doing so.
g. In failing to inspect the shower area to discover the
obstructions and defects or in inspecting so carelessly as not to
have discovered these conditions;
h. In maintaining the shower area in an improper manner or
in employing personnel who were not sufficiently qualified to
maintain the shower area in a proper manner;
It is specifically denied that a dangerous condition existed.
Per Stipulation of Counsel filed with this Court subparagraphs
7(i), (j), (k) and (1) have been stricken and deleted.
8. Denied. It is specifically denied that the Commonwealth
Defendant was negligent in any manner with respect to Plaintiff's
(
alleged cause of action or that as a direct and proximate result of
such alleged negligence Carla Clark suffered injuries, After
reasonable investigation, the Commonwealth Defendant is without
sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to the
truth of the remaining averments.
9. Denied. After reasonable investigation, the Commonwealth
Defendant is without sufficient knowledge or information to form a
belief as to the truth of these averments.
10. Denied. After reasonable investigation, the Commonwealth
Defendant is without sufficient knowledge or information to form a
belief as to the truth of these averments.
11. Denied. After reasonable investigation, the Commonwealth
Defendant is without sufficient knowledge or information to form a
belief as to the truth of these averments.
12. Denied. After reasonable investigation, the Commonwealth
Defendant is without sufficient knowledge or information to form a
belief as to the truth of these averments.
WHEREFORE, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Department of
Corrections and State Correctional Institution at Muncy,
respectfully requests that judgment be entered in its favor and
against all other parties.
NEW MATTER
13. The present action is controlled by the provisions of 1
Pa. C.S. ~2310 and Act No. 1980-142, set forth in 42 Pa. C.S.
~~8501, et seq., which Acts are incorporated herein and pled by
reference. The Commonwealth Defendant asserts all the defenses
contained therein.
14. The Commonwealth party is immune from suit pursuant to
I Pa. C.S. ~2310, and this action is not within any of the
exceptions to immunity as set forth in 42 Pa. C. S. ~8522, and
therefore this action is barred.
15. There is no cause of action based upon a failure to
inspect or improper inspection in that sovereign immunity has not
been waived for such claims.
16. The causal negligence of the Plaintiff is greater than
any negligence on the part of the Commonwealth Defendant, and
therefore Plaintiff's recovery is barred pursuant to 42 Pa. C.S.
~7102; in the alternative, any recovery must be diminished in
accordance with the Pennsylvania Comparative Negligence Act,
17. The Plaintiff was contributorily negligent and/or failed
to mitigate the claimed damages, thereby limiting and/or barring
any recovery.
18. If the accident occurred as alleged, then the condition
complained of did not cause the accident or the injuries complained
of.
19. Plaintiff knowingly and consciously assumed the risk
leading to her injuries and is therefore barred from recovery.
20. The Commonwealth Defendant did not have notice. written
or otherwise, of the allegedly dangerous condition, or in the
alternative, if said notice was received. it was not received in
sufficient time prior to the alleged accident for the Commonwealth
Defendant to have corrected or to have warned the traveling public
of the allegedly dangerous condition.
21. The Commonwealth party is immune from suit pursuant to 1
Pa, C.S. ~2310, and this action is not within any of the exceptions
to immunity as set forth in 42 Pa. C.S. ~8522, and therefore this
action is barred.
22. Should liability be found on the part of the Commonwealth
Defendant. the amounts and types of damages recoverable in the
present action are limited and controlled by 42 Pa, C,S, ~8528.
23. punitive damages are not recoverable against the
Commonwealth Defendant,
24. The Judicial Code at 42 Pa, C.S. ~5522(a), which section
is incorporated herein and pled by reference, provides that the
Commonwealth and the Attorney General must have received written
notice of intent to sue within six (6) months from the date the
cause of action accrues. In the absence of such notice. this
action is barred.
25. Plaintiff's injuries, as alleged, were caused by other
persons or parties which were contributory and/or intervening,
superseding causes of Plaintiff's alleged injuries,
26. The Commonwealth Defendant avers that if negligence is
found to exist on its part, said negligence was not the proximate
cause of Plaintiff's injuries.
27. The Commonwealth party is absolved from liability because
any negligence alleged on its part merely facilitated the
Plaintiff/s injuries.
28. If the accident occurred as alleged, then the condition
complained of did not create a reasonably foreseeable risk of the
accident or the injuries complained of.
29. The Commonwealth Defendant is specifically entitled to
the defenses see forth in 42 Pa. C.S.A. ~8524, which section is
incorporated herein and pled by reference.
30. The Commonwealth Defendant is immune from claims grounded
upon negligent supervision or employment.
WHEREFORE, Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Department of
Corrections and State Correctional
Institution at Muncy,
respectfully requests that judgment be entered in its favor and
against all other parties.
Respectfully submitted.
THOMAS W. CORBETT. JR.
ATTORNEY GENERAL
r;
,
~.
Stark
t Attorney General
torney I.D. No. 51786
Office of Attorney General
Torts Litigation Section
15th Fl., Strawberry Sq.
Harrisburg. PA 17120
(717) 783-1683
VERIFICATION
I, Jay W. Stark, Deputy Attorney General. in my capacity as
counsel for Defendant in the within action, hereby verify that the
foregoing statements are true and correct to the best of my
knowledge, information and belief.
/
Dated: II-({; - 95"
S ark
torney General
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that I am this day serving the foregoing
document(s) upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below:
SERVICE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL
POSTAGE PREPAID
ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS:
James 0, Famiglio, Esquire
Sproul Road at Williamsburg Drive
Broomall, PA 19008
THOMAS W, CORBETT, JR.
Attorney Gener,al '.')
\ ~
Office of Attorney General
Torts Litigation Section
15th Floor. Strawberry Square
Harrisburg, PA 17120
717-783-1683
DATED: // -/.p -95-
--.
IN TIlE COURT OF COIIMON PLiiAS OF
Ct,1IBERUND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CARLA CLARK
NO, 4287
1995
CIVIL
v.
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS and
STATE CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTION
AT MUNCY
RULE 1312-1.
in the following
The Petiti~n for Appointment of Arbitrators shall be subst3nt~ally
forn:
PETI7!ON FOR APPOIlITIIENT OF ARBITRATORS
TO THE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT:
JAMES D. FAMIGLIO, ESQUIRE. counsel for the plaintifO>>lilWHWlK in
the above action (or actions), respectfully represents that:
1. The abolle-captioned action~~Kj;) is ~ at issue.
2. The claim of the plaintiff in the action is $ not in excess of. $20,000
The counterclaic of the defendant in the action is n/a
The following attorneys are ~nterested in the case(s) as counselor i1re other-
wise disqualified to sit as arbitrators:
n/a
WHEREFORE, your ?etit~oner prays your
arbitrators to whom the case shall be
Honorable Court to appoint
suooitted.
Res~'ectfullY
'\
th:'ee (3)
---,-
ORDER OF COURT JAM,E~ D. FAHIGLIO, ESQUIRE
AND NOW.-8 Pil, '/ _ /4 I 19i1, in consideration of the
forego1:lg petition, E"dLNRt2-t:I Cu,'dtJ Esq., ~'f)' &~,"^nEhtAJa/
/i /'l..1/ " .J
Esq., and ~7~J1//t. ( J,1Jt..,:fdFl,Esq., are appointed arbitrators in the
above-captioned action (or actions) as prayed for.
P. J.
FLrl)-0:~:E
r" -. ,., . ~'.' ~-,....,'
I.".' - ',,\i
"1 ,." I' ,. I" I I
, I' I' . ..~ j',,; l' ,.
c..:...,' ; I
h.Ni.:;jl~\"\:\'"
-:;:-
-,..
<:::t
; '. CI ;;q ,) 0-
, " 0- Q
1I( ..
..-. . Il
() . ~
f;~ '. .',
Q -' 0
c' 0
L
L_ ~ ~
" ~- ~ "*
I" ~ rl..
~
.
.
CARLA CLARK,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
No. 95-4287 Civil Term
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS and
STATE CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTE
AT MUNCY,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NOTICE OF HEARING BY BOARD OF ARBITRATORS
You are hereby notified that the Board of Arbitrators
appointed by the Court in the above-captioned case will sit for
the purpose of their appointment in the Second Floor Hearing Room
of the Old Courthouse, at Carlisle. Pennsylvania, on Thursday,
November 20, 1997 at 9:00 a.m.
Keith O. Brenneman, Esquire
Stephanie E. C rtok. Esquire
Dated: / /)(3/17
By:
Edward E. Guido, Esquire
Chairman, Board of Arbitrators
James D. Famiglio, Esquire
Sproul Road at Williamsburg Drive
Broomall, PA 19008
SAID IS, GUIDO,
SHUFF &
MASLAND
26 W, Hlsh Slrecl
C..U,le.PA
Jay Stark. Esquire
Deputy Attorney General
Torts Litigation Section
15th Floor Strawberry Square
Harrisburg, PA 17120
SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR
CASE NO: 1995-04287 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
CLARK CARLA
VS,
PA COMMONWEALTH OF ET AL
LEROY HIPPENSTEEL
, Sh&riff or D&puty Sheriff of
CUMBERLAND County. P&nnsylvania, who b&ing duly sworn according
to law. says, th& within COMPLAINT
upon PENNSYLVANIA COMMONWEALTH OF
d&fendant, at 1015:00 HOURS, on th& ~ day of S&pt&mb&r
was s&rv&d
1995 at DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
CAMP HILL. PA 17001
County, P&nnsylvan1a, by handing to TRACEY MCCULLOUGH
CLERK TYPIST
a tru& and att&sted copy of th& COMPLAINT
and at th& sam& tim& dir&cting tl2L att&ntion to th& contents thereof.
Sh&riff's Costs:
Docketing
Service
Affidavi t
Surcharge
18. 00 So answ&rs:~' . ...,,-:---::
8 ....--..,...,., ~~.. ..." '.~"......:...':.
. 40 'f'"' ' ,~.". :"
,00
2.00 R. Ihomaa Kllne, ~her111
628.40 'JAMES D.FAMIGLIO
.H .>" 09/11/1995
j ~ ?, '1u
by k . ~
~ erlff
Sworn and subscribed ~o before me
this Jlw day of ~.......i____
9 .,
I, " ~
A. D.
'--h"
~ ~'D. _ ..ML
rot onotar"y=f=1
the
SHERIFF'S RETURN - OUT OF COUNTY
CASE NO: 1995-04287 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
CLARK CARLA
VS.
PA COMMONWEALTH OF ET AL
R. Thomas Kline , Sheriff, who being duly sworn according
to law, says, that he made a diligent search and inquiry for the within
named defendant, to wit: ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE
but was unable to locate
Them
in his bailiwick. He therefore
County, Pennsylvania.
deputized the sheriff of DAUPHIN
to serve the within COMPLAINT
On September 11th. 1995 this office was in receipt of
the attached return from DAUPHIN County, Pennsylvania.
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing
Out of County
Surcharge
DAUPHIN COUNTY
So answers:
6.00
9.00
2.00
22.50
639.00 JAMES D. FAMIGLIO
09/11/1995
R. Thomas K11ne, ~ner1~~
Sworn and sUb6cribedlo before me
this JI..t day of _I>l~-1..-
.
19 9'; A, D.
Ch1~
~. )h<l'u~ ~.
rothonotiir
COMMONIH;AI:l'll OF I'liNNA:
COUNTY 01' DAlJl'llIN:
SlllilUFF'S Rli'l'lIHN
NO, 95-4287 Civil Term
I'ACJIi 456
,;
III 95 ,lit 10:30 A~I.
AND NOW: August 17th
WITIIIN __ ~P~~.!',t_~~~_ N.ot!,:~
Attorney General
S~:RVlm TilE
UPON
IIANDING '1'0
Stacy Wict, Clerk III, and person in charge at time of
IIY PERSONALLY
service
A TRUE ATTESTED COPY OF THE ORIGINAl.
AND MAKING KNOWN '1'0 her
Complaint and notice
of business, 16th Fl. strawberry Sq. Harrisburg, Pa.
TilE CONTENTS THEREOF AT their place
Hworn and SUhSC1' thud t..
before me thi518th
(~or august II)
..~~Jw~, f (}tt;A7I'))
I
11'1l0'l'HONO'l'AHY
HIA
i,
i
,
i
i
SO ANSWlmS . .
~J?el~ ?{. ~~M.SD
SHERIFF OF DAUPHIN COUNTY, PCNNA
:an'
d~r.<w::;"-..C~ L-Q'.4-?
DEPUTY SHERIFF
95
SIIEIUFF'S COST.. .:):;.50
f.... "J"'n' ~_ COUrT' CT" C-mm...."" ::t",_... "'To ,-......- .IW:.......-l ~'"."-..'I P-"'r:"'yl',,,,-,-
h. -.. &, ltJt" --~..... "'-,""",..-.;;.. .-,,"- .......,'-~.I~ I ;...... .......1....
Carla Clark
'is,
Attorney General's Office
~o.
9'l-4287.. C;v; 1 .Tprm
---.
:?-
~OWJ
AUQust 14. 1995
:9_ !. S:~..z:~ O? C~GE?..!.A."m COt,"':'{TY, .?~ co
h=-.by d...:=u= C: .sn:::..:i ai
Dauchin
C~u:t'1 :0 =::=.1t: = trY:::,
.... ... ., .
:.:::s ~-=u=:cn .:~..,,,, -....- ~t == :::::u=t :':C1
. ~ .
:':..:k of
:.::
?!:L!:::I.
r~~~
5he..~ :f C;:::er.:u:d c"u:rr. ?:l.
.4..Sda:vit or S~:'"7ic=
~OW, ~9 .. o\:!cc:: "t. 1::-.*:':i
:.:: ~.~:"
'~pal1
~;
by ::u:~ :0
~ cpy at = ::::-.,1
...
:I.lId _!t':. !=wn :0 :.:: .:::t:::s :..-:===t.
So =w=.
~lo"':~ 01
CoWltT. ?~
SWCQ :me! s::i::sc:-J:d bCc:n:
ccsrs
::J:..~v"IC:::
~!:IU:.-\G c:
.-\: :1.1.>.'1. VIT
.s
=: :::s _ c!:1y oi
19_
s
f_ --..
'..'- . ow_'.'.". ~;,.. _. .
..' ,.,
SHERIFF'S RETURN - OUT OF COUNTY
CASE NOI 1995-04287 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA I
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
CLARK CARLA
VS.
PA COMMONWEALTH OF ET AL
R. Thomas Kline
, Sheriff, who
being duly sworn according
and inquiry for the within
INSTITUTION
to law, says, that he made a diligent search
named defendant, to witl STATE CORRECTIONAL
AT MUNCY
but was unable to locate
Them
in his bailiwick. He therefore
County, Pennsylvania.
deputized the sheriff of LYCOMING
to serve the within COMPLAINT
On September 11th, 1995 . this office was in receipt of
the attached return from LYCOMING County, Pennsylvania.
Sheriff's CostSI So answ~rsl
Docketing
Out of County
Surcharge
LYCOMING COUNTY
6,00
9.00
2,00
27,00
~ .... -:/ f' /
~? "-. ..._4-
R. Ihomas Kline, Sheriff
B44,~~ JAMES D. FAMIGLIO
09/11/1995
Sworn and subscribed to before me
this day of
19 A. D,
I'rothonotary
I .r,.. C it C t ......T r",~ .-- ....~.......~ .'.,.........'1 p- '" I ............
n I nel" ou CT .:::mmO=1 r =:-. ~. ..........-,~" .-..... 1..,......."" =:1r:...y '1.....1...
Carla Clark
State Correctional Y~Btitution at Muncy
~o.
95-4287 Cavil Term
---.
:~--
:iow,
August 14, 1995
~9__ !. SEZ:~::' O? C~GE?..!.A..'i!) COt-~TY. ?A... ca
=::-...b)' c...::u= = Sb:.E oi
Lycoming
Cwu:q :0 ::::::-.:.t: :is ',V:::,
... .. . ., d .. ..
:::s =u=::cn =~...,fII' -.....- :1t :.::: ::::u::t:.: :-~ Ot ::::
. ~ .
:n":_::i.
.-?'./'J; , ~/~
f ~-..,,~~~
She."'1.:f ::~ C::::::er'..:u:cl C"U:t7. ?~
.4..Sdavit or S~:'"7ic=
~ow,
AUGUSR 30TH
. A
o'dea ~t. l=-.o::i
95
10115
~9
. --
:.:e wi.:":" COMPLAINT & NOTICE
~paa
S.C.I. MUNCY (DEFENDANT)
~;
S.C.I. MUNCY, RD3 BOX 405, MUNCY. PA 17756
=r::u:~:o
CAPTAIN MUSSER
~
c::py of = =:::-:_-9'
COMPLAINT & NOTICE
md -~..:- !=wn :0
HIM
...
. ,.
:.:e .:=::.::::s :'::::=1.
So =w=.
C.w u ~~ ".J',
CHARLES T. BREWER
Shc:ii of LYCOMING CoWl'T. ?..
SWCQ :m*i::sc:-J:d ccc:n: .
=: ~a Qvat !g!l.Q
.~.
ccsrs
S1:2 V-Ie:::
~!:IU:.-\G c:
.-\:: UJA;"IT
" '
~.
,'~'.
~' ,
, /
I;' ..
I:
... .._.~
I ~... ':-:-",
18.00
6.50
2,50
---. ____I
WILt'l,'\~ J. r;.~;\
PlotlL ":::,11',: ( . r. "! C1urt1
_W~rll; ell,' ;,1,'. j t",tlly, PJ,
My (1.1"" ',',,'j I., I J.:n. I), IY96
',.s ,27.00
'..cJ>
v
LAW OffiCES
SAIDIS, GUIDO, SHUFF III MASLAND
l6W,IIIOH ~T.._ '. ll09MARKETSTRF.ET
CARLlSl.B. PA 17013 CAMP HILL. FA 17011
PIIONH (717) l4l,621l PHONE (717)737.3405
SAlOIS, GUIDO,
SHUFF &
MAS LAND
26 W, Iliah Sir...
CllIlisle,PA
CARLA CLARK,
plaintiff
v,
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS and
STATE CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTE
AT MUNCY,
Defendant
CI!RTIFIBD COPY:
~~
.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
No, 95-4287 Civil Term
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NOTICE OF HEARING BY BOARD OF ARBITRATORS
You are hereby notified that the Board of Arbitrators
appointed by the Court in the above-captioned case will sit for
the purpose of their appointment in the Second Floor Hearing Room
of the Old Courthouse, at Carlisle, Pennsylvania, on August 26,
1997 at 9100 a.m,
Dated: '/5"(77
Keith 0, Brenneman, Esquire
Stephanie ~ ok, Esquire
By:
Edward E, Guido, Esquire
Chairman, Board of Arbitrators
James D. Famiglio, Esquire
Sproul Road at Williamsburg Drive
Broomall, PA 19008
Jay Stark, Esquire
Deputy Attorney General
Torts Litigation Section
15th Floor Strawberry Square
Harrisburg, PA 17120
~
Law Offices
JAMES 0, FAMIGLIO, ESQUIRE, P.C,
Sproul Road at WIlliamsburg Drive
Broomall, PA 19008
(6101 359.9220
By: James 0, Famlgllo. Esquire
Attorney I,D, No,: 51101
Attorney for Defendant
CARLA CLARK,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Plaintiff
v,
No. 95-4287 Civil Term
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA.
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS and
STATE CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTION
AT MUNCY,
Defendants
PLAINTIFF'S ANSWER TO DEFENDANTS' NEW MATTER
TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT
AND NOW comes plaintiff, Carla Clark, by and through her attorney. James
D. Famiglio, Esquire. and files the following Answer to Defendants' New Matter to
Plaintiff's Complaint:
13, Denied The averments in this paragraph constitute conclusions of law
to which no responsive pleading is required.
14, Denied, The averments in this paragraph constitute conclusions of
law to which no responsive pleading is required,
15. Denied, The averments in this paragraph constitute conclusions of law
to which no responsive pleading is required,
16, Denied. The everments In this paragraph constitute conclusions of law
to which no responsive pleading Is required,
17, Denied. It Is specifically denied that plaintiff was contributorily
negligent and/or failed to mitigate the claimed damages, thereby limiting and/or
barring any recovery. The averments In this paragraph constitute conclusions of
law to which no responsive pleading Is required.
18, Denied, It Is specifically denied that the condition complained of did
not cause the accident or the Injuries complained of, To the contrary, the condition
complained of directly caused the accident and/or Injuries complained of,
19, Denied, It Is specifically denied that plaintiff knowingly and consciously
assumed the risk leading to her injuries and is therefore barred from recovery,
After reasonable Investigation, plaintiff is without knowledge or Information
sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and
said averments are therefore denied.
20. Denied, The averments in this paragraph constitute conclusions of
law to which no responsive pleading is required, After reasonable Investigation,
plaintiff is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the
truth of the averments of this paragraph and said averments are therefore denied,
21, Denied. The averments In this paragraph constitute conclusions of
law to which no responsive pleading Is required, After reasonable Investigation.
plaintiff Is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the
truth of the averments of this paragraph and said averments are therefore denied,
22. Denied The averments In this paragraph constitute conclusions of law
to which no responsive pleading is required, After reasonable Investigation,
plaintiff Is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the
truth of the averments of this paragraph and said averments are therefore denied.
23, Denied. The averments in this paragraph constitute conclusions of
law to which no responsive pleading Is required. After reasonable Investigation,
plaintiff Is without knowledge or Information sufficient to form a belief as to the
truth of the averments of this paragraph and said averments are therefore denied.
24. Denied, The averments In this paragraph constitute conclusions of
law to which no responsive pleading is required. After reasonable Investigation,
plaintiff Is without knowledge or Information sufficient to form a belief as to the
truth of the averments of this paragraph and said averments are therefore denied,
25, Denied, The averments In this paragraph constitute conclusions of
law to which no responsive pleading is required, After reasonable investigation,
plaintiff is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the
truth of the averments of this paragraph and said averments are therefore denied,
26. Denied. It is specifically denied that if negligence is found to exist on
the part of the Commonwealth Defendant. said negligence was not the proximate
cause of plaintiff's inJuries, To the contrary, said negligence is the direct cause of
plaintiff's injuries,
27, Denied, Denied, The averments in this paragraph constitute
conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required, After reasonable
Investigation, plaintiff is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a
belief as to the truth of the averments of this paragraph and said averments are
therefore denied,
28. Denied, The averments In this paragraph constitute conclusions of
law to which no responsive pleading Is required, After reasonable Investigation,
plaintiff Is without knowledge or Information sufficient to form a belief as to the
truth of the averments of this paragraph and said averments are therefore denied,
29, Denied. The averments In this paragraph constitute conclusions of
law to which no responsive pleading Is required, After reasonable Investigation,
plaintiff is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the
truth of the averments of this paragraph and said averments are therefore denied.
30, Denied, The averments in this paragraph constitute conclusions of
law to which no responsive pleading is required. After reasonable investigation,
plaintiff is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the
truth of the averments of this paragraph and said averments are therefore denied,
WHEREFORE, defendant, Carla Clark, demands judgment in her favor and
against plaintiffs, without prejudice, together with Interest, costs, attorney's fees
and such other relief as deemed to be just and appropriate under the
circumstances,
Law Offices ,
JAMES D, FAMIGLlO, ESQUIRE, P.C,
By:
, ;'
.-', , I I
./ \ ._,j :,..... _//1
JAMES D'fAMI~l!fO, ESQUIRE
Attorney ,for Plaintiff
~c.
VERIFICATION
I, JAMES D, FAMIGLlO, ESQUIRE, verify that I am the attorney for the
plaintiff, Carla Clark, In the within matter and that the statements made in the
within Answer are true and correct to the best of my knowledge,
I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties
of 18 Pa. C,S,A. 14904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities,
Law Offices
JAMES D, FAMIGLlO, ESQUIRE, P,C,
- \
\-----
, ,
By:
~......4'
JAMES,Q, FAMIGLlO, ESQUIRE
Attorney for Plaintiff
Dated:
I I "'" -,.
, - ~-,.. '-I ':.
,
"
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that I am this day serving the foregoing Answer upon the
persons OInd in the manner Indicated below:
Jay W. Stark, Deputy Attorney General
Office of Attorney General
Torts Litigation Section
15th Floor, Strawberry Square
Harrisburg, PA 17120
TYPE OF SERVICE: First Class Mall. Postage Pre.Paid
Law Offices ' I
JAMES D, FAM!GLlO, ~SQUIRE, P,C.
" , l-
By: ,r--::.-- ~ \,
JAMES D. FAMIGLlO, ESQUIRE
Attorney for Plaintiff
Sproul Rd, at Williamsburg Dr,
Broo'mall, PA 19008
610-359-9220
Dated:
I I -,"
,-~ -'1'
NOTE:
Under 18 Pa,C.S. ~4904 (Unsworn Falsification to Authorities) a
knowingly false Certificate of Service constitutes a misdemeanor of
the second degree,
!:?
le
r-.
-'>'
,'-1
,::"-
~:: :;
~_. -
~':
.~2 -)-':;
->::- .~ .~
--
'"
"..
-""
-'=
'n"::;
-...;.1-.1
. ::' ....
~,
.~.
.r
..
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CARLA CLARK,
Plaintiff
v.
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS and
STATE CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTION
AT MUNCY,
Defendants
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
No, 95-4287 Civil Term
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
Please enter my appearance on behalf of the Defendants,
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Department of Corrections, and State
Correctional Institution at Muncy, in the above-captioned action.
Office of Attorney General
Torts Litigation Section
15th Fl., Strawberry Sq.
Harrisburg, PA 17120
(717) 783-1683
">:......~.
Respectfully submitted,
WALTER W. COHEN
ACTING ATTORNEY GENERAL
~
,
tark
ttorney General
1.D, No. 51786
;'
....
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
! hereby certify that I am this day serving the foregoing
document(s) upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below:
SERVICE BY FIRST CLASS MAIL
POSTAGE PREPAID
ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS:
James D, Famiglio, Esquire
Sproul Road at Williamsburg Drive
Broomall, PA 19008
By:
WALTER W. COHEN
Acting Attorney General
u),2]
ark
torney General
Office of Attorney General
Torts Litigation section
15th Floor, Strawberry Square
Harrisburg, PA 17120
717-783-1683
DATED: ~':1~-q5
~
::r.::
.~
on
....
,- >-
.:: ,--
"'\..;." .1
t.I,.,-.
:::~? :-::
"
- ::-"
c:r>
"'"
,-.
::>
~"'"
'~. (
...,
...
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CARLA CLARK,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Plaintiff
v.
No, 95-4287 Civil Term
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS and
STATE CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTION
AT MUNCY,
Defendants
STIPULATION OF COUNSEL
It is hereby STIPULATED and AGREED by the underoi'.Jn'3d counsel
that subparagraphs 7(i), (j), (k) and (l) are hereby stricken and
deleted from the Complaint. It is further STIPULATED and AGREED
that the words "or other dangerous conditions" found in
,
deleted
subparagraphs 7 (d), (e) and (g) are hereby
from the Complaint,
Dated: q-t~9("
ja
At
Dated I &[- b --if!{
Jay
Dep
A
ark
torney General
for Defendants
v.
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I NO. 95 - 4287 Civil Term
,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNT~, PENNSYLVANIA
CARLA CLARK,
Plaintiff
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS and
STATE CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTION
AT MUNCY,
Defendants
BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR A NONSUIT
The Department of Corrections argueo that it is entitled to
judgment in its favor for any or all of the following reasons:
(l) The Department cannot be held liable for a failure to remove
foreign substances from its real property;
(2) Plaintiff will not present evidence demonstrating the
Commonwealth Defendant had prior notice of a dangerous condition of
its real estate;
(3) plaintiff will not be offering into evidence the testimony of
an expert witness to eatablish that the plaintiff's alleged
injuries and aymptomo were the direct and proximate result of a
defect of Commonwealth real eatate.
Pursuant to 1 Pa,C,S.A. Section 23l0, Defendant PennDOT enjoys
,
sovereign immunity absent a legislative waiver of that immunity,
Liability may be imposed upon a Commonwealth agency only when a
plaintiff brings a cause of action that falls within one of the
nine exceptions to sovereign immunity. 42 Pa. C.S,A, Section
8522 (b) (1) - (9) .
It is well established that these limited
exceptions are to be strictly and narrowly construed, First Nat.
Bank of Pennsylvania v. Comm., Dept. of Transo, , l48 Pa. Cmwlth.
l58, 609 A.2d 9ll (1992), appeal denied 614 A,2d 1144, Bruce v,
Comm.. Deot, of Transp"l38 Pa. Cmwlth, l87, 588 A.2d 974 (l99l),
Davidow v. Anderson, 83 Pa. Cmwlth. 86, 476 A,2d 998 (1984).
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has held that in order for the
real estate exception to apply, the dangerous condition must
derive, originate from or have as its source the Commonwealth
realty. Snvder v. Harmon, 522 Pa, 424, 562 A.2d 307 (1986); see
also Kiley v. City of Philadelohia, 537 Pa. 502, 645 A,2d l84
(1994), An artificial condition or defect of the land itself must
cause the injury. Snyder, 522 Pa. at 434-435, 562 A,2d at 3l2.
The Plaintiff has not offered any evidence that the alleged
slippery condition derived, originated from and had as its source
Commonwealth real estate, Plaintiff will not be presenting any
evidence which proves that a defect of the real estate itself
caused her injuries. Rather, the evidence offered has been only by
the plaintiff herself who says simply that the shower area was wet
.
and slippery.
Numerous cases have held that a plaintiff's injuries do not
fall within an exception to governmental immunity where foreign
substances accumulated upon governmental real estate, Fitchett v.
SEPTA, l52 Pa. Cmwlth, l8, 619 A.2d 805 (1992); Walker v. Phila.
Housina Auth., l58 Pa, Cmwlth. 497, 63l A.2d lll7 (l992); Deluca v.
School Dist, Of Phila, 654 A.2d 29 (l994); Shedrick v, Wm. Penn
School dist, et ~, 654 A,2d l63 (1995); Finn v. City of Phila.,
541 Pa. 596, 664 A.2d 1342 (l995); Metkus v. pennsburv School
Dist., 674 A.2d 355 (1996); Leonard v. Fox Chapel Area School
Dist" 674 A,2d 767 (1996); Wolfe v. Stroudsbura Area School Dist"
688 A,2d 1245 (1997).
These cases clearly stand for the rule that no waiver of
immunity exists where there is no proof of an inherent, defective
design of the real estate itself, Without such evidence, the case
must be dismissed,
Other reasons dictate that a nonsuit should be granted by the
Board. The Supreme Court has ruled that notice of a dangerous
condition is a prerequisite to maintaining a cause of action.
PennDOT v. Patton, 546 Pa. 562, 686 A.2d l302 (1997). Plaintiff
has not presented any evidence which shows that the Commonwealth
had notice of an alleged dangerous condition of its real estate.
The Commonwealth Defendant is also entitled to a nonsuit due
to Plaintiff's failure to offer necessary testimony, The testimony
of expert witnesses is required when special skills and training
are necessary to understand the subject matter or when technical
knowledge beyond that possessed by the average juror is required to
resolve an ultimate issue, Steele v. Shepperd, 4ll Pa. 481, 192
A.2d 397 (l963),
Expert testimony is also necessary when the
subject matter is related to some science, profession, business or
occupation beyond the average layman, United Penn Bank v. Bolus,
363 Pa. Super. 247, 525 A.2d l215 (l987), appeal denied 518 Pa,
627, 541 A,2d 1138 (l987).
The cause of an internal injury such as plaintiff alleges here
tills into this category. The testimony of an expert is
indispensable in proving that her injuries and symptoms were
proximately caused by a fall in the shower area in August 1993.
Tennis v. Fedorwicz, 140 Pa, Cmwlth, 7, 592 A,2d l16 (l991),
plaintiff will not be presenting any expert medical testimony.
She cannot, therefore, possibly recover because she has failed to
prove her case as required,
Consequently, a nonsuit must be granted. There is no genuine
issue as to any material fact. The Department of Corrections is
immune for the condition of which plaintiff complains and is
entitled to judgment as a matter of law,
,~
Respectfully submitted,
0, MICHAEL FISHER
ATTORNEY GENERAL
-- &
Attorney General
No. Sl786
Office of Attorney General
Torts Litigation Section
lSth Fl., Strawberry Sq,
Harrisburg, PA 17120
(717) 783-1683
,-~-
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that I am this day serving the foregoing
document(s) upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below:
SERVICE BY HAND DELIVERY
ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS:
James D, Famiglio, Esquire
Sproul Road at Williamsburg Drive
Broomall, PA 19008
D. MICHAEL FISHER
Attorney General
By:
I
tark
Attorney General
Office of Attorney General
Torts Litigation Section
15th Floor, Strawberry Square
Harrisburg, PA 17120
717-783-1683
DATED: /1-,;) D -17
ARB/TAT/ON PACKAGE
Carla Clark
v.
Commonwealth of Pa, Dept. of
Corrections
and
State correctional Institution at
Muncy
95-4287
James D. Famiglio, Esquire
Sproul Road at Williamsburg Drive
Broomall, PA 19008
610-359-9220
MEDICALS
\'
\
I'
;.:
,
1. Muncy Valley Hospital
2. S.C.!. at Muncy - Records
3. Muncy Valley Hospital - P.T.
4. Penn-Del Medical Associates
5. MRI's
6. Dynamic Physical Therapy
..
\J
....-...~
\:
_ __01
l.
.
. :
..~~l~~~W;;,'!;#c!.,'7,,'~V,;!;""l:;^j,...;'lf_\('r,.o;o,....'~~\,~1~_"_._~,_._~"...".
'"
.....--
,
o
.
,'.' ~ ,-......",.... ,'"...~......""""."'-4U,~,t~..~
(
'\
J!o.-_~~,._...._,.~ "__''+-
- , -___.~:<.'i ....-
.
J~ Muncy valley lIospltal
'willi EMERGENCY ROOM RECORD
':11:~.!'j cop,' .
~~.. MLD llLC NO 'T.A:C1-;;O--
'''rL ,
19256194594711a39
_.1.____
COU,il I ll~ ..v,'l 'flC..HQt,t
646-3171
.J. ItO'>>P.t.LflV
_I:MR _
-
,
"J(~'''''''''f I~ASt'llU( WoOO.IIIW'l"" IIfO HlillhMlJ,vkD,lIltlJl.lk_1
RlL BI"'HPLAC;E
II
SIREU
call
PO OOK 1801 MUNCV,PA 17756
A ..., H' ",.
A 'I'~
DR ADAM'M:'ED~LMAN
.. -
-..
'l-IrZ
,
./IJ'tUArtl/!.
," .
.,
. ...
'.
'1~q.$'
!:Sb~
",,,,, N
.;2"
OR OFFICE
.....-- ...-.......
" ..~"..I ...'
. . " - l'A RDEHS "'__' .
..., i _~I...:-
o cse CI SIREP stREEN
OH OPl.PIT
o SeA Cl UA PAEG
o AMYLASE CJ srRlJU PI"EG
o LEVEL
OUA
CJ UACIS
D OTHER
OCAAO\4CLoIBS
'.' ',X'RA,~Rl!ERS:. ',:'
o CHEST 0 KNEE R L
ORISSRL 0118.fl8 R L
OKUS OANKLt R L
o ABO. senll::'s 0 FOOT "L
r.J~ULL OSHOU\.DER
~C'SPINE 0 C"'~CLE R L
OTSPINE OCLBOW R L
LS SPINE CJ'l\'f\lsr R I
o PELVIS 0 HAND R L
CleAT sr."" \
OTHER
PULSE
Cl OXIMETER
D PCN\ FLOW
07ZJt
I.
I
I
I
I
l
""':.:::-::,;;",;; ~._'-' .
- .
o 'INITIAL VISIT 0 RE
ECK
N J:ke
,-
AlLERGIES
Muncy valley Hospital
ER TRIAGE RECORD
N~E--DAuL Ovjil
ACCOUNT NO,
o
CONOITION ON ARRIVAL' [J STAO I:JOUAROED I I CRITICAL II OOA
n A lATORY r: OUlANCE Il OTHER
ARRIVED n CONSCIOUS n S6!I,CONSClOUS n UNCONSCIOUS
NOTIFIED 0 CORONER 0 POLICE () RElATIVE
,SPiCIFV T. n ER [1 OOCtOR
SKIN w.... 0 lllI' [) CXXll. 0 ..... 0 "'-""',
o C'tAHotlC 0 ID(Mol_ ...
NURSES
SlONA TURE
DATE
,_.
,.,
...
-
I CONSENT, AllOW, AND AUTHORIZE MEC'.CAl OR SURGICAL TREATMENT
INClUDINO, OUT NOT LIMIT EO TO ANY TF.~T, TRANSFUSIO',s, INJECTIONS,
MEDICINES AND ARRANOEMENTS rop ANESTHES'A AS ','.W OE DEEMED
NECESSARY III TIlE JlJOOMENT OF THE PHYSICIANS ANOIOn SURGEONS AT
NO THE MUNCY VALLEY HOSPITAL
SIGNEO
WITNESS ,
-
RELAJIONSHIP
--"" - ----
NURSE'S NOTES
;
I
,
!
1
CURRENT MEDS
-'
;
1
I
,
j
a
I
1
PULSE
:. "': ~
..: .'
", ,. ,.
"". '.
PAST MEDICAL HISTORY
....:- i;~"".' .
, ,
PIlII: RUO
RlO
FIonk
Ep;guItIc
~~JV~::'l"AOrHl" 0 SlHTi" 0 UHf HOWE 0 H4
co;;;;.OOHOHOtSl'OSlTlONASTADLE 0 GUAIUlal 0 CAlTlCAl.
T"'E'OF ~sylON -111 C1I
, DlsPosmoo ~ ~ 0 TllANSfERRtD TO 0 EXPIRED
J ' 0 AOf.IITTED TO AU. FOR on
I.',.. .'.'
--',', ,-.-..- ._, I
~
NURSE'S NOTES
CARDIOVA C. LAR AND TRAUMA FLOWSHEET
o A
CARDIOVASCULAR
Hhylhm laid
Monilot 0 No 0 VI.
o -'111m.
Pacemlker 0 No 0 Vn
Masl 0 No OVe.
IV'I
o R_ _Sol..lIon
o L_ Solution ___
RIIt
AIRWAY
o Natural
o NON!
o O<aI
002
BREATHING
o Sponlanoou.
BREATH SOUNDS
R, L
o E,T. Tube ,
o N,T. Tube ,
o 0Ih0<
UM
OArtiIldaJ
TIME
BP
TEMP
PULSE RESP
"',' ,"
.:~,; /
.. .., ..,
. ,.
..'
llWIIWl COOES
A. A8AA8lON '
lo8UAH
O,lXlHTUSlOH
D. DECUIITIIS
E. ECOf\'II08OS
L. LAlVlATIOH
P . PIJHI:TUAE
R'RA8H
S.IWEUfjQ ,
. 1..... . .......- .
. '.__n. ':'. .-, __ "
'::1: .'" ~.:.
" ~ ,~~..:. ,".
I . ~:. ". ~ . '" .J.. ", .:
'.':" "',"-,"
... ,"
J~'." ~ ~ l~(J')t
..,. - '-, .
. .' ....'.,
"
. ..':~.
....
~
:..~,
; ",
, ,
-~,
~ .
. . . ... ..
2 J 4 5 I
RIghi Si'; ;'1' Len
~
o Brllll" 0 SluggIsh
SPEECH
[joaea, 0 GI.bltod 0 Ablenl
;APPROPRI E FOR AGE 0 ND eYes
LOS F CONSCIOUSNESS
o Vel 0 Unknown
OF CONSCIOUSNESS
OO<ionood
REACTS
Approprllle
Verl>aI
Pain
Cervical COllar 0 No
Ilaclllloatd 0 No
Nee 1.00 p.tr.
EXTREMITY MOVEMENT
RI, Ann Appropriale '0 No
RI. Leg Appro"",1e ~
a:" ,.". ApproprIoIe ' 0 No
U. Leg Approprlale
PARALYSIS
SEAT BELTS
, :
i~' .
.. '/
'.
51,: d.
Re
o No
o Nu
o No
~
~
ld"Y"
o VOl
, .
......... .
u
ONo
;;rill"
o Yea
, )
-
..
I
,
" !
"', I
I
.
, .1
,':,1
..'.
','"'r- . .',
". .'1" .
. ,.',' ~ .
;f'~; :
".,1
, ,
':';1,'.
.'j ,
0" .:
:Ii,:,
. 'I
;. "
;'.
"".j'
. '
.. ,
, ,
I
\:
.. Pallfl\t Hamt:
MUNCY VALLEY HOSPITAL. MUNCY, P.\ . EMERGENCY ROOM
.RCARE INSTRUCTIONS TO THE PAT.T
CI')""/I't- _ENNo qY,)I,~'15
,
{;IAY \. I
NOTE: ThO .alllTWWhon and l'Ultm,nl YOII h.I_U fuctll.od 'n lhe (mcllgoney O~'p.ar1m.nl holly. bolln 'unCII,IIC(J on.:an on1-'IQuf\C)' b.1'.I "Ill}'. and DIll nc.lln:,.r\fJ,,>d 10 bI Q
luDtllM. 10' M.llOtt 10 pl'ovld. corr.plell mod".. (o1IV, Your lotlowup OOCIOl (n.llned bolo"" ,*,11 JlltuuO. COPt' 01 rOUf IIJal'(,J, o1nd Dlllosl roPO',. 1111 ""prl.nllhal you
Ie, twn chm)'ou .g,,".'nd Ihill you t.pQf110 Ill'" ,lll)' fWhlW O' '''"l.lullng prool.ml ellhllllmo, bvt'UIO In Impo..,b1.IO 'cCOgl'llZllllnd IIU31.11 .,lemonla 01 ,.,....,'1 0' dlnvll
In It &Ingle EmelQtnc)' DOPlttmenl "lU, M"oIIl.tIlI,. rOLlOW THf INSTRUCTIONS UELOW Oil 'nd".IUd 10 )'ou.
LACERATIONS (Cull, Abt.Unl. Ol,l,n.. Ele,
o I. K"Pthldl"..,,,,cJean'Mdry
C Z. Unltl, Olhtf'ltoll. dlIKled, chang. dl"""" d'tl, 0' 1mm.t,:t..llvt, 1111
bfcomtl..1.
o 3. EIt....I. ~nd II... "'I nuh II PG'''bIf IIJ Ipt.d hut'ng 3nJ
IttltYtp.ain.
C 4. tr lIJound..... ~I IN .nd ..ou.n. thowl pul or IlId llIliIhl.
I.lutn 10 IhI Emot~)' OttpaItmenl o.&pl. Ih. or.OIlell r.OIf'.OIr'1
wound CAN btcamI 6nfectod
CONTUSIONS (Bruo.-.s. Sprainl and 611il1ftll
[] 1. Um.,.. UII of Infufed 1I1111"'lltuc:lld.
[] Z. EIev.1I the .tI/JCted ....
C 3. Aftf*t a tOf' 41 hout1. 30 minutn IVIt/Y hour .mll.w.....
o ... U.. moil' tw.allor 30 minuII.; 4 lim.. d.,a, allctl' lht 11I1l4! houl'.
a 5. Rewrap....1C twndIOe. .v." fOUl how.. RtmOv. al b<<tlinll.
"-move" ~utld ...,. becoIMl coId.lUiftluI. 01 numb.
[] e. No~hlbe"ing.UMCfUIcht.IOl__d.ar',
C 7. Your .....,. hi.... bttn lIad by 1M Eft Ph)'lClln. FOf rOUt addtd
pl'oltclion. rour I.f,)', ". be ,u.Ad the following day by OUI
n.ddoglll. II an, IbnotmlIilil. 1ft lound It\il havI nol b..n
C&IIId 10 ,"OUI .n",,~. you Of )'OUf doclor will be Wtrd
Imtnodaaltly, 01 c.aA 548.4201 '01 1M t..ul1l. Som. IINIIlrlCll,orOI
can onI)' be lIOn In 7.10 dar.: Iht,.lorl. I' )'OUt m.ury .1 nol
NaMa r.lum 101' D ttchtcL
&PUNTJC;oST CAllE
C 1. The aplin, povilSod it 10 ptOlId Iht lIoa )'OU hlvl ~urld. 111110
ttmIin in pIKe II IN timt unit" you ha.... be", InlltuCltd
cWllltnZl)'.
e 1'. YCMoI"llotemovtlhlsplinlin_dl,..
[] 3. Ktep cui dry .1" bmtl. follow IpeC!fc inllNdionl.
[] 4. Raturn 10 E.A. immIcialtl)' " numbneu, &Ingling, or Ollltly
incIHMdpaJn. ,
5. c.I pl'tyaidan " CUI breaks. IooMna 0111 tauloing &kin IrnllllOn.
HEAlllHJURY
C 1. WalCtl IN PlIItnt CIl,'uI, tOf' &hi 11111 24 houri. Outing nonnal
lIMp hourIlW...n the PlIitnt IV'ry _ houri. II.", oIlhI
following DCCUI. c.aII )'OI,lf' family ph)'lbM Of caIVr.lum 10 1M
Emergency Cepe. irrIInIdWtl)', .....n WIthin &her" monthl.
I.CNngo In be.......
2. EaceuNe dtowIif".. or confusion.
3.1NbiIily 10 ,wNfI pt&iInl, c.onvutlion, Of untonKiou..
4. NudIntH or wtP.nnl 01'''''''''-01.
S. Stvtfl ptfIialtnl hladIc:ht.
e.1'IfIIa1enl~. fwor, Of 111ft neck.
7,~pup;lol....IIIgt.....IftIIll),
I. Drlinlot 01 blood or dt&r WcUItom." or nose.
.. Refrain kom IicohoIic bever'OIl. lICI.llon and,"}' pain
_""'''OIlgOtIhanT,tonol.
I Ml.Jnllln Ighl cr.."..
'.', 'TREATMENTllIfDU.OW'UP
[J ,. Con&acIthe Emttgttq' o.p.ttmInlfor IhII r,lUlU .1548-4201 Nt
, _dl,llortheOll'OII11lU1l101yout1t11:
. B"i Relurn;o ErMrg.~y ~PL InuMOtll,lylf condiUon ,udd~nIY
wotMnI, or CMfloe In .,mplCMM.
o 3. .Relumlfnolmprov.menlln_d.V'..
NAUSEA. VOMITINO. AND DIARRHEA
C I. Nolt\lng by moultl rOf 2.4 Mil" alii' vl)IftIl""O.
2.4 ha..." Ill", 1,)'1 vOITIII.ng f'pilOlJo. m.1r 'Lllllo O'~. ''fl' ..I ~OlU CiqJtd.
on, Of Iwo 100l1po0I1' I' . lImo l.hl1r Iruqu~nllr .evul)' !t.lO m'nulfll). II
vomsling '.curl. .~II OIn AdCSsIiOf\a1lo..., hou.. bvlo'l "po31ing I,quldl.
A"I' III1""no in\311 qlolAnllllOI or i!,fuld IIlXIutnl!1 lor ,.Co halllt.. 1.11011
QuAnl't.... 1.2011"""1. mar be OTwen
All" an 1Iddo11On.U 4.6 hOU'1 wllh "0 "'O""I'flIJ, QllOInll'..,ot clo'.v lIQuid, tan
bit OtVIn AI dialled II und,,' G monthl. OIYO Ptd..')1.. L)t,,,r. Ru~, 01
HoCI1)1' (Iva,lIbllf 111 ani crllJtl.IOlIlI,
R.I'I\IIOI\ 01 lluldl 10 pllIvonl dchrdlilllOll II Iho moll It:" ~ltOlnl lhlf'lg
AD::,o"".lr no lood Ihould be Olvln IOf al 1001$1 414 t\oull. Allot 11&11(11 I"
llll1nod 101 20 hou,.. ""Ill .nd fnllh plodllCU Ind IOn Ic)(1s InIQhl be
oradu'lf tnltodUCed Inlo the dovl. Sl.ilIlt wllh ClAthel,. 10111. 01 '.eo.
II vtllY\lIIl'" POllisll ov," 24 hOU'1 Of' ptolu.. dloll'll..OI OVII' '8 houri. pltilWJ
Itlu,hn".."
ClEAR L10UIDS
PW..c1t:1 G,ngelll.
7.Up JUlt8C
(NO d.ctllod.1 ptodUdl1
::L Vc"l.Jf'r'ER RESPIRATOqy INFECTICNS
U 1 O.1nolu"'''Wp.l04.
C! :. ',1" Iuktw..m wOIl" b.1lhs 100IetrlPCl,atu,,, orOOlIO' 1h3n 103 d"li!QOS loctalfy
A,':,,'t. bundling up wiln dotn..; lhis 1niI)' InCIctlSct I,vtr'.
D 3. t.ll'..JT,..noIIOfI.Ylr. dOlo1g..
D'. lna,," hWe! InLlk'. IIJPOOill)' will...r.lo Plh'Clnl deh)'dtlbon.
[J 5. NOIlI, phrlidln or Emo'ooney D,pl. IIIOmptl'~lu'.I"04 dugr".. 01
0"11".
[J 6. 00 nol UIO.apiM With thildren unde, 17 ,03" ol.g..
ABDOMINAL PAIN
[] 1. ThM, II insunlCionl h'idtnca 10 wlmltU Ihcr ~noSil ot 4(...10 abdolfllnll
condition. lequVang haapiUklation. ThI. ma, Change with 1he (\Ul&OO of
bmt. Fot)'OUl' &allry. l1>>U &hould ob"......1ht lOIIOwing ruIIs: .
FOllOw IhI ordet. O..-n 10)'OU ''Galdlng dI.Il, mtdone. ,Ic.
lnct.alinO 'nd INtlllI.nt pain. 6nct,aslng lOI'nollln abdom"n. dill.nbOn
PIf$lAl.nI "omibng. ''''''f, may algl'lll)' . ~ If'lCI ,equitlll re,of'aw!iOn
belo" IhII bmI. In such an h'nt. ua l1>>Uf PG'sonaI pft)'lidOln OIlho doctClf
laIUng hi. calla. If ,OU It, un.1bl. 10 Ioc.t. lhOm. UII Emelouncy doctOf IOf
lultttlrtinltructiOl'll.
Wal:'l'
Vll";"""
i'f"n
.;,.C
Jllll.O
KOOi.\od
OLooD PRE&&URE
[J 1. DINInG )'OUf .laminatlOn in tho Emlroency Ot~.m. )'out b'ood pralSuro
was found to bo ..vlllId. A linglO b1tod plIISU" dctle'min,ll.:m lholoild not
~ ulld 10 mak.lho WOnoSlI 01 HrPtltenslon. Thll il PI'liC'll..,I, 11\18 olin
,Iovllioo lound in &he lometimel -cn:u~ almo.pher, 011"" Enwtglf'lCy
o.partfl'Htnl. VI, do, hoot.o't'O'. focontmond INI rou hI...t )uyr ptOllure
Itd\tdlll'd b)' )'OUt j)CI5Of\o'\l phtsi> 'an and . Cl<<iSion nw:ll at.GuIIll, tIIOd
lor ltlllmunl.
MEDICATION PRECAUTION
[J 1. ThiS modcbon may nu,. ':,o.'SiI'leu. 00 NOT DRIVE. OPERATI!
MACHINERY, OR DRINK AL.COHOl ON this modIC4l1On:
[] 2. The InlibiolC W1I La". ,...36 hour. belot. you nolict III'WI1. la~
mtdCliOft unld COmplcl~lr oone.
e 3. Tok.I mtdabOn W1lh lood; .
04. Tiki ActlaltWlaphtn lTrlonol.elc.).u in$lfUtlod lor p:lln. OoSOI']tt:_
pllWp.IY01y" houtl.
a 5. Taka lbuprol.n (Ad't'il. NUj:ftm. crl...) '-llnall''''tlod 101 Po\in.I.I.." ....,In lood
Doua-:_p'11a tvlIY __haUlS.
Disc.I( ~hp ..../ p~ ",4-t<!,u...J
OTH~R INSTRUCTIONS: '
Dd%/Io\f~ 1'-/ "'~..,}""("''''W fJVI,cIC/,<.,..,r
/l(OTR."J fO~7 /,0' Gll: e.
~ DA. II! _ ;"..(''':t~ I.JE:'~ IIV..-:'M
~t tc'...c.4"'J //1-1..., r"vc,. ~4"
;'
I hereby euthorlzo and ocknowtedgo roceipl of Iho Instructions Indicated obovo, I undersland thai I havo had .",ergency 'rea',n.nl only,
and tho I may bo roleased boforo all of my medical probloms ere known or Iroated, I will ol/3ngo for fOllow,up care as ,"slruc:od above,
V a~ t121. ~/Lfr.J_
PA11ENTIGUARDIAN SIGNATUR~ OOCTOR.NURSE SIGN"lURE Dfoll
INSTRUCTIONS: RETURN TO:
o YOUR DOCTOR 0 EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT
TIME: DATE:
o The above patilnl hit bton undtf OUt Clt. from
andlll!>>ltlortll.rmlowor1lllchoolon
'0
o L.....lionI:
'"
, ". ..' ..'
- "'........:..\-.............
............... .-~_.
.. ....
.____
..' I"
.' ,
...,.
..... . ...... .~... -'.
"" hi
'-.':'-.- "-:~.. ".-r---
.~
...--~-
~
.
'-..
IIUJIcr VlU.LU IIOSPITAL
RADIOLllQY IlIlPOR'f
CLaIUI:, CIIIU.& IIIR
192-56-1'45
Dr. Adu _~
DA%W or~. 08-16-'3
CIlRV%ClIL 8PIJlII.
The vertebral bodiea are in good alignment in all viewe of the cervical Bpine
demonetrating normAl vertebral body heightB and diec spac~s. The posterior elementa
are intact and in good alignment in all viewB. The neural foramina are patent
bilaterally. The bony archltecture and Boft tissues are unremarkable.
DlPR&sSI~.
Normal cervlcal spine.
r,rnnaaq SPIn.
The vertebral bodies are in good allgnment in all vlews of the lumbar splne
'" demonstrating normal vertebral body helghts and'dlsc spaces. The posterlor elements
I <.'. are intact. and in good alignment in all views, The bony archltecture and soft
' ,'. :.': tissue. are' unrlllllArlcable. ' ,
1":---':' -. :.'
, , .' DlPllU8I~.
;~{;;',~~~:', .,~ ,'.
(,:,,:. .. Normal lWllbar .p1n.e.
"
~'" "[
.", .
,', t.
: " ;:'" RIGB1' DIP. ," '..
~ '~i"I": ~,~,~.(.:::.~ :.:', ,I,. ":.~".:' . . ./ ....::~. :::.,', .
..: ..,.:,..\ '.NO. fractur~,' di.locat1on, or other. abnormal tLndlng ie seen.
}.;,.;....,,'.,~...".'.,.';,',..}:,:,0,:.t,.,z-',.i..',.'.,t.,,'!'.~~,~,.,fl,. .~CII,..., ',',: .-..<~.. >'.; ~.
-1' ~ . ..."";:f.~ ~:;'''''::'':~'';
:,,~:"."'.;: ''''.:' Negatj,ye. . ':"~~' :'~ " ~'.' ::" :'
,:.::;':;'<>-';:~~l1b'~""~'" /~"~,":';,,;';? >1,'
'..,," .. 'DI,:.08-17-'3.',. .,.. ,"','
, . . . ,'.:,~' '.' " ".
' ;'" ',' TI' 08-17-!l:r '. ,
.. ;. '\',' , PI.......' I:: " . , "
. '" ., {.
.,
',' .'
.....
,.-..., .
..~
. .:'.... "',
.. ,
. ~." "
.
ChaD' J'oou, X.D.
".',1.',"
.' ....
"
."" .
',~.~/ ,!:;.~:' ~~ :
,
"
". ./l~
" ..;
,''t'
~~.,.~,.~;..(. ..e.;~~.4!"~:"';':l.'"
," ,..,..... .:"~.~.,,...;-. ..:...\~..o::...~,..,.
.'...... ...-:.
....- '.,.. .. .... , .'
(
N
I'
I
I
':i'il.~'t'i:,~.L""'<"~\'"~''' -,' .. _ ~'~ ~
,~~,d""._,'t'+,,,ti~7'i'I__ .. ,-,.. t'!p,~"~Nfid~, M
.... >..:_..---",._.,-....---.....,'_...,_..._~_._-,.."":~~,.;""'""."",
.
'-'-
~-~~.,..._-~---'....__..
'<J
--,
,
,
o
.
,
~.,.__....-..-...-..
I.
.
.
'T""'_-'t~>.,.,VJ,\_.............._,;........:_._.._"..,
.
.!~.
. '
PERSON
INVOLVED
Male 0 :
MEDICAL INCIDENT/INJURV REPORT
'Ill N me) tMiddle In,tial)
Reponed To Dispensary:
Date: f' / / ~ / Q
Hi' ~tJ PM I
-
Tim.:
o
C] VII
SUPERVISOR:
EMPLOYEE I Department
VISITOR 0 Home Address
tJ,
Job Title
-
----
'..... )
Home Phone
Occupation
OTHER 0
PropertY Involved 0 :
"',
. .
"",_......
-.
Reason lor Presence allhls FacllllY
Equlpmenllnvolved 0 :
\
Oesc/ib.e
,
No
atscrlbe Elletly Whit M'l)gentd Why II H.pp,,,td. Ac1ion T....". II." I"jury, SlIll Pin o' Bocty Inluted. If Properry Of EQuipm.nt Dlm.ved.
OtKt,C. Dlm'Q'_ ,. Oiscription ot ItIness/ln'ury
'1
IContlnue on Reverse)
Was Physician Notified? Ves 0
Was Parson Involved Seen By A f>hvician?
Ves 0 No 12"
Was Person Invol ed Taken To A Hos ita I?
Ves N ~
2, IMlallmpression Illness/Injury
NOel'
Was Family Notified?
Time Where
Veso
Nolld"'"
Dale
/
Date
'd"1
Physician's Name
Time
Where
/}f 1/ If
-,/l.. ,
Indicate On Diagram Localion 01 Injury
/
J
TYPE 'OF INJURV
o
o
o
o
o
o.
~
Follow.Up
Reviewing Authority
OC.84
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
MEDICAL INCIDENT/INJURY REPORT
-
. '
I hereby authorize the performance up~n~
.
~G~.J C'~Gd___
Nun. 01 PaLlln'
of the following procedure
rioumeS5 and probable outcome have 'been
to me by anyone concemlng the results
To be performed under the direction of Dr.
I acknowledge that the nature of such operation or procedure, I
aplalned to me, I also acknowledge that no guarantee baa been
which may be obtained, _ .
I understand that in comenting to the performance of this operation or procedure, I am authorizing as well all
procedures which are ordinarily Incident to the procedure including the administration of such anesthetics as may,
be considered advisable.
I consent to the disposal by medical department authorities of any tissues or parts which may be removed,
I consent to the performance of operations and procedures In addition to or d1Uerent from those contemplated
which the above named doctor or his associates or assistants may consider necessary or advisable In the course
of the operation,
~
,v
Q .
,a.l1A UOJlJt-
a~ent or person authorized to consoot Cor patleot
. ,
Rela~onshlp to Patient oC person slcnlng IC other than Patient
institution
c-
~Q.:tm
I II alc,3
,
f L"1'\.,.
U
Date
BC.77
Inmate Identitilition
D.O,B. 1 {l C;/ ~ (;
SSN I C1 .2- - S-r., - 154 S
Ins!. No, (:)fJJljlf))
Name CJ.aAl..J~
..
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
BUREAU OF CORRECTION
CONSENT TO OPERATION OR
OTHER MEDICAL PROCEDURES
.
OC.7S
Inmate IdentiCication
Hypersensitivity
D.O.B. 1-/f-~ ~
SSN /9~ -05'1- /9~.5'"
Inst. No, C'.! ~/fI~ 7
Name (jf;~ (/(1c1'a.-/
.
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
DISPENSARY CARD
Date
Medication or Treatment
Signature
Lincla Grana
__ ~~/_~j,.t-'J":'V,+-.~. SC)h4
~rer) _
..../ -~ ."
~\
Card. Continued
Date
Medication or Treatment
Siillature
:SYl J ~.
- a 5s..o
I'""
.
-"
10
....
-
. .
DC.78
Inmate Identification
0.0,8. 7 - / 5' -~~
SSN I q ~ -,50 - I '1'f~
!nIt, No.Of!::!.fI.f:J.. 7
NameCltAl/ U'-'~V
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
OEPARTMENT Of CORRECTIONS
DISPENSARY CARD
Hypers.n.I~YI
Date
Medication or Treabnent
Signature
~,
/Y!
i (
-. ~
_:i ~ ,0:,._"",..&,,\ .
. -- \.:.-......."
-'
(Over)
Date
Medication or Treatment
Signature
1
L
-
c-
-~..... ~_..
i5r;~miis Way. D
:
-
--
\
,
. .
ce.7S
Inmate Identification
D,O.B, 1-/' - -t- (,
SSN /'1;{-~"'/1~.5-
Inst. No,CIJ ~rI~ 7
Name flI~,~ aLl'tV
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
DISPENSARY CARD
Hypersensitivity
Date
Signature
Medication or Treatment
.'
~~'
"cI X /i
X ~ &V~
:
(Ovpr)
"-:-.
-.,
Date
Medication or Treatment
SlilIature
,; I" . "
j:j)
l'? .
~,~~'
, J- &.1:
e;-~
-
<::~
~~~.
-.
-
:2........ ~
-
.
;;)
'J-~J
:
-
-
DISPENSARY CARD
Jnmate Identification
D,O,B, 7- (~- - G:-'-
SSN /92. _ sr.:_/7C{.J-
Inst, No, (j5 st<ll.,7
Name Ci!~ ~"----'
DC.?S
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
Hypersensitivity
Date
Medication or Treatment
Signature
-'
(Over)
" --..,
,
\
Card. Continued
Date
Medication or Treatment
Signature
s~
a
-
t!":
,
v..A
"'-
,~
?
"-- ~ eo
~
,.:..., ~;S,
t.a-t. \4v-
)...
DC.78
Inmate Identification
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
D.O.B.
7h/l.{.,
1'1 ;l.St,_/S\l~'
SSN
DI5PE~SARY CARD
Inst. No, 073", I{,) 7
Name UCJJ....~
H,'penensitivity
Date
Medication or Treatment
Signature
~
.~,4~ . CPe. ".t..
v/~,r'I.,......f,
~
,/. '11
")-".( :;flltt:, 1\
i~ .- "I
II..:./-I..J J "
([ t, It' I. i',
,
(/,;u;1..
Uki:..
". ,
'i,..'......,\,.
; j' .' \.....;
.. '" .. \".
" 1 I' l'
.l.I.; -...
"ll.':"tl.1., ~ - ~ { ('
" ',/ -" '11' I
;/.....t '! t'! t '..t -
'.' .
I . \ ji. r.',' t ('
...l I'-" _~\',,,l'-. .
. . " ' " .A' i'
, '. " r., J '~', I r. ..kJ-t'l" ' 'P. ' j I I
\ . L"'. - J
. ..... ',. .......
;'." 1'-". . i--I/;7 '; /I '-, ":. ,i I /,- _;, ":'
\. ;
.1...
. l ..j...
l 1',,-' f ,,-I
\"
.'~'"-'
'-
.
".".J., ..'d &,'" ,t .t...
r
</ ~...f,L..<.:t -
#d"....,,//I
j _~!L
.~
.....
'"'
Dis ensar\' Card. Continued
Date
Medication or Treatment
Signature
~~ ~
r
-
c:.
~
,....c9
," 4F'
.
..L~
~
.-< ~
r ,Vo/"'-<-G
re:o Hartz, MOl
,-
I
~ V7..-..
~ Z ,.r"L-
,
/. )-a:...
,
p.
r,- _
-,
.-.
Dis ensan' Card. Continued
Date
:\[edication or Treatment
Signature
-
cP ts.:(::" D ?C~ L
-
..
"
/ -c
'C
-
c... /" r;
._~ (J,e.4 '"
c; It..., .!-,-..:>
..,6 5C~
.d?R.I...:../ ~_
'J ~-.. :::.;o..,~,/(
OC.7B
Inmate Identification
f...J (~ 'tt-
Hrpersensitivlty
D.O.B. 1-15"- Co C,
....
SSN /fj,;'-5'6' -IVY.J
Inst. No. (.'/3 '-1'1:2'7
Ill' , Ii~ ,
Name ~a'~J Ja~~
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
DISPE~SARY CARD
Date
Medication or Treatment
Signature
t,
......tc/
-
.
......"
-n
.~..,,'6-
,~
~
'S"
t----<>-
(
......
..:..
,
'--
.....
....
Dis ensar\' Card. Continued
Dale
Medication or Treatment
Signature
,
.
/ ,.,
...
.
~
.......
.........
"
S
t4: ' ,
-""'c..4........
~ ~ ,~,r
c:......., .:-P..- ~ L t'.
~ ..A-~:. '7"'.-r-7,~p
~
..,<, ~,
. .
~.......,-...-
DC.78
Inmate IdentiCication
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
oePAR~MENT OF CORRECTIONS
D.O,B. 7 -I.,:) -(, (,
5S:-: 1'1 ~ -.5 Co - 1'1 ~S
Inst. No. (I i3 t/l{;l '7
Name C,e~~, Co-..~
DISPEXSARY CARD
N\i(\.
H)'persenslt!vity
Date
Medication or Treatment
Signature
i It,;;' (/
,
.
c"^"""
~
j;))",' 1 f.
~,~ c:
,
~ . ,!. . iL..--<. .
~a~ e~ '-~.~
\J
'-~
/
,?-S', oS, ~ I'<<~ .:-<-; .;t:
....e.
'$
, ,
/.'
.-
a....u< Co
-
t-..-" ~ t:~
A.-.......... ............,,J.-r' ...............-P
,--<4 ~ , ,~
G~ -- A
,~
~,..... " t"_-=--
~m~m ...
o't.;:.~
'.,/~.... -r- ,( c...--e.-
I
r-
:.,t.P.,
C/ .
,"
.,..
~.;.... ~:. 7-;7.. c:......__
,
,;
.....
, - .
.'
--~.---" v - .-.....
-
,
Dis ensan' Card. Continued
,.
UL-.- UU
!,. ',',
.. II ,t. .,
,
f.
I .,,/
r: '..
......
DC.78
Jnmate Jdentification
?' )(. C
, H:'p~rsensitivity
O.O,B, ')-/j--&(:-
-
SSN 19,/1" -56' ~ /'1qJ
Jnst. No.c.~6 <(t/; 7
Name ell!:.it; (!~ rI(L..-
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
DISPEXSARY CARD
Date
Medication or Treatment
Signature
I
~'~~"I -
(1 ,::>'7< .-?
CI
, /"'I./;'t .. \,1..1," .
~
I.
,/....,. . ~
"/'-".' ...!.../'--C". k............ ..
~_:"L ~.
I, t
I" :,
"
/.....
...-'
,;,.,A
./.r-.. I
(..It v /" -'
-
/1"--- ;.
0" ,
r; ,::..;
,/
. ""',4 _ . '.AI"
c.
j,'i
'. ,
,
'.
.' /. '
.. -
'-
J...., . ...,.,.,,/!
~. ... (' r' -td'tc .........'
,~ ~t.., ~-t..--
.,..t'___
A, ',/ It' / -<~.~....r;:';
I'/-~ "* ~.,.,,~ JV' /,/,../;l!,
--
Dis ensarv Card. Continued
Date
Medication or Treatment
Signature
. ~-9~ S. I
J.
~ /~
~ a..v-
/ 0, ' If--J
\
,4. .
-r~
:} "- I. .,
;
....-1-" -<:VI ~ -Co
-
Co
A,,~ ')< /~
Robert Manenkoft.
\clan ~.ssls\ant
Il ~/#'c...
.~-
II
.4
I'
'1-(,-'7'1
'I.l. 't
,i.v,C:f
~ li/~' ..
...
/~.
1(. 7-9
~
OC.?S
Inmate Identification
D.O.B. 1- /j-. t t
ss?\' /'1;/ - 5 ~ -19~J"
Insl. No, () 1.3 ~4;/7
NameOlMJI., (]~~
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
DISPE:\SARY CARD
1,1.f. /J.
Hl'persenslli\'IIY
Medication or Treatment
Signature
/: tlUl. r / fi
-----
LL
J1,...
/ r~-AJ V
I'-r-I~ 7.j-~ 1Yt) ~.
UJJ
, ,
.
.I X,
n~
..,..,..J. ~
3,
;tt........ 1'3
1, ~/,If-'
Robert Manenkofl, PA.C
ys an Assistant
y-/~
v......
/).. -
'"
// ~ Y-)v
~ ~.t '{-,I. 0
~
/?T
/
/ .'
~v US&/lS wi
'f.-
. t't....,.
.. -
. p. ~C1UllStod Sick Call
~
-~
Date
Dis ensarr Card. Continued
~Jedication or Treatment
Signature
L.... C 1
l'L6 ,y\..(...:J
No Show for
1
~.1-U- (~---
~
o
/f, ~/#-c..
~
P.oI:t:t '}.a:.~~""~, PA-C
Phycl. n
~,
~ ~1.<~-
0, ~
I'r:
o.k./..-.4-
.L.'.
()C; 0 0 -;z . 1/.
0-0-
k,: ..I
,
- ~(.. .-k.
.....
.
. ,
rJ"'^
f... (.. a. .' c.hL.' fJ
/. J~ -:: fIJ....
X'" I
T
:/;r I -I- J. ,
k
,
hJw/"p- G
P.ol;l;:: 1,!ar.snkolf, PA.C
...." .
""" ,,;J- /"7
.,~~
~.., S-.___ p..." /~,./~
~~r'_ ~~<a ~/-r..~~
~~~ 5""-;; ~
. ....:.~..
0."; ..,,'-r... r.-J..J
DC,7B
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
OE~ARTME~;T OF CORRECTIONS
Jnmate Jdentification
DI5PE:-iSARY CARD
I ,; f{/}'
Hrpersensilivil)'
O.O.B. /'-/5" - ~
SSN / f;J, - 5" b - /7 fls
Inst. No, 06 t( Y':';> ;7
Name (If.Ci/~~tL-
Date
Medication or Treatment
Signature
,~ '
-.,;~~
~ I t<.
I ,..,? /-t) ~<--
-
Ci / /' /-(/
.; oS
,..,- ....c..I__~ ,., . 1._
1r\~C.:\ J"I"\,;~ ..""
..,..,.~._._,~_. ~
'\
Dis ensar" Card. Continued
Date
Signature
~Iedlcalion or Treatment
,1'4AI-
~Ii
....,
-
~
,
...
lr<.
Ir' . ", ~
~ ~ .-<'A,.. L)
..
::,,:, ~-:~li., .,t;
?net!
.d~ 6.d.
~
~.
(." .hJ
.",~
S'Io?- 9y S,
,oro o. ~
-~,
,,&.. ,:~
.
11, --r~
~Q I
~ ~I.I!J1X/~
A. /vWW /~ - c...
."-.-'/
"
Robert Man~nkoff, PA.c
.......... ''':O'C'.
---
,.-
----
-----
-
(tJ&
H)'Persensitivlty
Inmate IdentiCication
D.O.B. 7 -/6.- "
SSN If:L - ~~ - /fP'~
Inst. No, 06 r; f",;2. T
Name atlt~ &Jt(.../
OC.78
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
OEP.\RTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
DISPENSARY CARD
Date
Medication or Treatment
Signature
(r .1'1 5,
I~
",...,.
~M
~.
h..,....
c:..
riCo
o.
-I-
000
(!->oo.
fp r.! .~4
~
-r~
'.J
,,\~ /
.., '. ,
;?-.
/
/I'".a,
.
, .
-r.<-.,.~.J
! "';-4 . '~aJJ
- 'J
/#.,-
Robert Manenkoff, PA.c
P cf I., -,.:ootC'f
/f.
/
C- .-
-
('
f,-J.o-'i { S,
Il{ov 1/,
It. /l. 1:-
/ ~: ..U
.t.
.II-U; /Y r
~
Robert Manenkoff. PA.c
sielan Assistant
~,C
J.I
-;tt .$ v
}!-< '.....
. ,
,
-:~_..~-_. ~.
--,
......
Dis ensarv Card. Continued
Date
~Iedication or Treatment
Signature
No Shcw for RBql!e~e-I S:~!: r.,ll
~d-~
~
.
(<'?L
.
,
c.-rrn to{
I
~-C'f".I,
-
~ A-.J~ 7
.
:1.r ..!. T'/LJ /'c. X. I~
:iJ / /<. ~-
10\0- II
$I~
,.
c.-1l. . '-< 'c
~ ~ t-.P
~vl;
-
~or-I
-
jJ .-4:.
.....
.....
-
...
~
-....
- "
-.
....,
De.,s
jJ K,f.,
H)'persensitivity
Inmate Identification
i I, ~-/ ~lJ
/ft;?- st.a - 19'(:;-
Inst. No, O!?> l/'t~ 7
Name tWM ~.
D.O.B,
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
Ce?~RTMeNT OF CORRECTIONS
SSN
DISPE~SARY CARD
Medication or Treatment
Signature
-"
,oC-G-'t
".J- ,
.
-
/l ~~_c:.
Robert Manenkoff, PA-C
, "
?-/~i s" ~ .1/,
.....-
Ivo0 (j,
J!,j.(l.
~4-c.
.
-.......-
,~
O'~ 'f~(J'7
lnst. No,
ad Ihd~
Name
DIAGNOSIS
ALLERGIES
~...;I , '? <:; .,
Monlh Yoar
PHYSICIAN
~IEDICATION
I~'u~f ..
-
~.~c."""
~
DELIVERED . INITIAL REFUSED . INITIAL " CIRCLE
DATES NO SHOW. 0
~. , . 'I"""'. "',, ,,',,",',,"" ".,,,...,,,,... .,.
':<. , ,IMINt ...
. ~~ L 1M ~ ~" /
(,.( !Jill" ' It\\
START STOP
DATE DATE
9'3' t7P"
?'+?
II'
,;J.
Ijo'
"
'Pl:-
I>
qft6 ?J~ ~Y'-
.;tSo~
r:-:.L '^ J
'l1J' W~' f1~~ I~;
';'1 'fit a,l.D ~1
.....\"!. . l"
I'-.Lt ~~l,4ol.,
CI (I' . I t;J.-. ...:2,-0
... L'';h~~. ~
R'.(i .tlo"" ~...t \.;; I )I...~' Y
1 i~t"" ~k"'a./.i+1.. . <(
9~1 1/1 ?5O /rx( f?iD
cL t.i t1J..;.uv .,
I
-m
9/v
9/.).1 iO/1I
'J<nr,e',,;,- \ C,
"a'( ,."
"'" r '"
., ~ 1_. U.!ll!:! ,"-
Kt.i::n.. ' qf',1'l I.'~ rJ. "
71:::>. Yf8~ I " ~
:J.Jt5 ID I .1
loA.. ~;.2.LLl.o!ot1< 'i IN,. ~~\ I'''.J. '
INtrlALS NURSE SIGNATURE
-tAL ,J4,u't~.L/
1'/11#
SHIf'T
~
DC.i3
CO~I~IO:-;WEALTH OF PENNSYLVANJA
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
MEDICATION CHARTING RECORD
I/'
IJ.
~I
\(,
I
, iJ~ . II
$: ~h" Il~ ,,,:"!J
I ~'iVY'~ ~ 'T' I~
I
I
I
I
,
I
I
iE~
, , I I I
I I I
.. "" I ~ k. k I
.. :'.WY. l! 1< r. ,I
I , I ,
. . I ,
I I I I
I I I I I
~ ufll I
\
~~, I
SHIFT INITIALS
NURSE SIGNATURE
Inmate Identification
1'1-',1/'
D.O.B.
SSN
Inst. No. t'.j t./~,9 7
Name et:-.--f', ~
START >TO?
DATE DATE m:DI':,HIOS
C(/')7/01" li'IN kl!
o. TES
H.ur 1 1 1 , s I . I : I. , 10 III" I" I.. lIS I,. 1:1 u I II :0 III :::: U 21 U :. :: 11lI 2t 20 ;
I I I I I
~ -;-,
I
I
K.;~~ cr I
I~ ~ I
15'0 "1' I
t'J::t;;. I
iO/~1 I
,I/~ X {)',,-r:;;:j
/'- '1
-
I
I I
I I
I
"',~Iu;. j;\)J ~t<l. "-'~' 1'P.
I I I
I
I
I ~
(~<:I h ~1"'I(lIv.. .I.(b:I$'&1~
I
I~
I I
I
I I
I
I I
I I
I
I I
I I I I
I I I I I
,-, I I I I
I I I I
I I I I
I I I I I
I I I I I
COmlESTS
:
. .
6 (1 <!t/..-i 7
Inst, So,
,I;.' ;; 1 .Ie
!///i,j' Ii /2..1 et-J
) S.m.
Q"
/MZ
I~'i'"
Yea,
DIAGSOSI:; ALLERGIES PHYSICIAS
DELIVERED . INITIAL REFUSED ,INITIAL 4: CIRCLE
START STOP DATES NO SHOW.O
DATE DATE MEDICATIOS Hou.. I 2 S . 5 , 11' t 10 11 m IS 1111511,11 1 11 II 20 2 I ZI 23 21 :5 2C 21 2S :- ",I.,
~f1'4~" Y r.L I I
7j, "14 'q . J , . . . I . I
j,1(""'1 'f ~ 14- I \ I
~d ^ IcI.... 't U. III . I
1-1, . I J!1 I
'7f::t'J... 1~ f..:~'UU- I
R,i. y:. &a.tp. Cf '1 fit I
1-rJ.' "I ~ I
I
I
l "" -I ..,., " -:I I I
IMI I
t'//;2- S/~~ ~~ S(I ~ I
v F-" . . , I
I
(3/f)1yJ 7 ~ u/u I<E 'H' ~ I
,... 04....:- rJ, I 'L/l I
I I Ij In , I
'?fI,e; 'fie 0"" 1 ?A I . I
t'~ ~ l.: ~ h" I I
rt;u:t~~ ~ I t' I I I
'8/n , -:"C I /1 V T I
r. 4"t.,1 ' '7ft "f I t':S'1j: II r- T I
f/i"t'l t;l!. X IJ.~ 4 I II l.~' I I I I
~ t~ If/~J ':) IS ;0- I I ',1 "I'P n. 1
I I I:t <: I
rkl '(1/1 (" f.~ ,~~S/~ . ,-.;. I
().J J.Al. . 1 ,.I., ~~ I
'11/'1 '!'j.u t:/ q, ,1: I
. . . , , I I
I) e.<.- I I
f/,'),I'MI)I./-..4. CJ ( /A 11 I I
SHIFT ISITIALS NURSE SIGNATURE SHIFT ISITIALS NURSE SIG,~TURE
K.Q JlJU.J.fi..~';..r
.(!J /.',1. .
't!~,
uk!- /../ / ~ /_ ./"" f /J.
A ,.
DC.i3 Inmate IdentificatiDn
O.O,B. ~
COmlONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS SSN ..
:\IEDICATION CHARTING RECORD Inst. No, 06 <I'f.J.7
Name C/..a..<.k., fa.d_a..
. .
START ST~~ I DATES
OAT:: DAI~ ~I:::.fi:.\ nos H... I 2" I'" 1<'" .1.11011I1121",..IUllO,,,IIO It "1211%1 n :. 2S I:. 2'1 u " ""I,
~, '(I'.... I , I , I I I I I I
Ih, qt.. (I.. I I I I 1
i,.., t.~ ... 1 1 I
r I
..pi": ,,, 'f I I ,
t:' " ,'tUi~ I I
,'"
" 1 I
I
I
, ,
I I ,
I I I
1 , I I
, , I I
Ii I I
, I I I I
1 I , I I I I I ,
, , I I I I I I , ,
I I I ,
, I I I ,
I I ,
I I I I
I 1 I I I
I I I I , , 1 I I , I
I I , I , I I I I I
I I I 1 I I I I I I
I I , I I I I
I 1 I I I I I I I
TT T I I I I 1
COmlE:STS
:
~
. .
Date of Birth I Aie I Race i ." Heillht I Weillht Puis., I BP , .1 Date of Report
7/15/66 25 C F 5'5" 122. 72 110/60' '1/1/g2 .
Hearinll 'see a\:C!iCll'eter testing Visual Acuil)' (Distance) see telebinocular testing
Rilrhl' WV 115 SV /15 Rilrh t Uncorrected / Corrected To /
Left WV 115 ,SV /15 Left Uncorrected / Corrected To /
Immunizalions
Type Consecutive Immunization Dates .. Remarks
~e~lo.lo "rood 1;/1 R/O., Or 110.1 'iI, ('^""
mvr loon I
Urinalysis Seroloi)' (Specify Test Used and Result)
Specific Gravil)' 1. 040
Sunr I Microscopic Blood Type and RH Factor IEKG ,
Albumin I
RBC IWBC IHb I Poly ~LymPh I Mono 7 EOS I BAS I Abnormal .
4.71 6.6 14.2 49 ' 43 1 0
Color Hair I Color Eyes ,. I Build I Temperature
Bro.n Hazel CJ Slender Gel Medium CJ Heavy CJ Obese 96.9
PhYSical Examination Abnormal Abnormal Findings - Describe In Detall- Continue on Reverse Side
Norm Enter Item No.
1, Head. Face, Neck, ScalD x
2, N 058 X
3, Sinuses ^
4, Mouth and Throat x
5, Ears x
6. Eyes-Puoils x
7. Oohlhalmoscooic N/A
8, Ocular ~fotlll;y x
9, Lunn and Chest X
10, Hear; X
11. Vascular System X
12. Abdomen and Viscera x
13. Anus and Rectum IV~ . .
14, Endocrine System x
15, G.V System x
16, Uooer Extremities x
17. Lower Extremities x
18. Feet x
19. Soine x
20. Skin x
21. Neurololl'ic x
22, Psychiatric LV'"
23, Pelvic x
Teeth see dental chart
DC.GO Inmate Identification ..
,
D,Q,B. 7/15/66
COM:'IONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
DEPARnlEST OF CORRECTIONS SSN 192-56T1945
.
Inst. No. 084427
REPORT OF PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
Name Clark, Carla
Abnormal Find,"p ~.mibe in Detall- Enter Item No,
Remarks
"Ti::;/er FiloJ"
, ,
1. SIP abortioo 3/3:1/92.
2. H hosp/c:p's otherose except childbirth.
3. On no rreds.
4. NKA.
Health Status
. HOUSING
NO LIMITATION RECOMMENDED
LIMITATION RECOMMENDEi>
AS FOUOWS,:
c;! Healthy 0 Acute Disease
,_ x
o Chronic Disease
o Disability
(Describe an)' work limitations or conditions refieclini Institution pro&,!,ammini.)
PULHEST
111
May Participato in Organized Sport,
Yos .2!.....
NCl_
MEDICAllY ClE.lI,~ FO~ r'::>OD HAtJDlfNG
~o
Ex en Signature
"
5/2/92
Date
. .
. '
This information will b~ trea:.~d confld.nually
Par; A: Family H:.:orv I Pan B: Family History of Disease
Alive X Cause of Death Do you have a Family History of: YES !'C
1, Fa;her Deceased l, Diabetes /
Alive J( 2. Tuberculosis /
2, Mother Deceased . 3. Henrt Disease /
3, Siblings -I-- Alive X 4, High Blood Pressure /
Total :>:0: Deceased , 5, Cancer -f.AJ.h4.r / 1'1-10 IlL<-<- /
6, Disease of the Blood /
(Sickle Cell, Hemophilia, etc.)
Obstetric/Gynecological History.. Women Only .
Part C:
1. Date of last menstrual period: /-9l- A~'D"""" /h....rdl. .~'/ J<-1<h .
2. Date of last PAP smear: ,4tJr / / 1') / e.J?z...
3. :':umber of pregnancies: <; Number of live births: .:;. I A~r -I I Co """
4. Have you had a change In menstrual pattern? Yes No..lL. (Frequency, amount of !low, etc,)
5. Have vou ever had a female disorder which reQuired medical or surgical treatment? Yes No ...k..
6. Have you ever been on birth control pills? YesLNo_
Part 0: Drugs. past or present use Yes No Part E: Give a statement of your present health
I.Steroic!.J ./
2. Tuberculo.ls medic:.tion ./ ;/e~"';f~ " Ok'l
3. Tranquiliun and other sedativu ./'
4. Insulin or tablets for diabetes ./
5. Dlt,ulis or heart medication ./
6. H:gh blood pressure medic::stion /'
7. AnticoaiUl~nts (Blood thinner) ./
S. C13uc:om3 motdic3tlon ~/' .. ,
9, Alcohol "'" ,.ttG't:.J4-!t'lt../.
10. Tobacco ./ j{ 1'1:.. ..c:1'V~'
11. f-bvI you ever uud: C t" ,t. e..;g /'
Bubituntel (Downer.) ./
Amphetamine. (UppeD) /
LSD (Psl'chedeUc Dru~.) /
Heroin ./
~l3riju.n. (POI) /'
12. Prelfncly on Iny oUler medication /
BC-65 Inmate Identification
CO:\fMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA D,O.B, '7.. /)"-{.,(,
BUREAU OF CORRECTION SSN 19 :J-S"Cr-/iQS- :
,
INMATE MEDICAL HISTORY "'/'"
Inst, No, C'P 'I -
Nome Cktrlc. c2ttv-I.:o... .
(Over)
00 not write In thls Ipace . . '
Part F: S~'Sl~m R~ :~~\\' Health Services Only
Have vou ~v~r had cr do you now hive Yes No
1, Period. oC un.on.c:o'JI,.... heacl3ch.. /'
2. B1ul'Tld vlslor. 1/
3. Doubl. vl.lon 1./
4, Ch.1l ..In /'
5. DICClcull\' b.uthln, ./
6. Tubffcul",l. ./
7. Whuzlni or '.Ilhm.tlc al13Cks ./
8. HI.h blood ."ssuro 1./
9. Cou.hin- U' blood ./
10, Stom.ch dl..... (1:Ic..., .le,) 1/ ,
U. Llv.r dl..... or h.pallll. (JlundJc.) 7
12. Gallbladder dl..... or ..II. Ion.. 17
13, V omll blood ./
14, Black (T:uT~'1 bOIVel movem.nts 1/
15. Venerul dise:lsr 1/
16. Frequent and,o, p.lntul urtnaUon 1/
17, !(jdn.~' Ilones or blood In urtn. ./
18, SIVolI.. 3I1d painCUI Joints /
19, Bon., lolnt or olh.. deConnllles ./
20. R.cur:enl b..k ..in ./
21, P...",,!, /'
22. Froouenl Ihou.hts oC ,uicld. 1/
23, EolI'DI\' or ,elzure, ./
24, DeDrl!s.lion or excessi\'e WOrtV /
25, :\er:ous trouble V
26. Allerlic fiJction to serums, 1/
Drul' or m~d;~3tion
,- Do \'Ou h.ve .n': oC these .hvslcal lid" . ,
..,
E\,..I.sses ./
He:ltln. :lid V
Broce, or b.ck SUDDOr! V
Arlincl.llimb. ./
Fal,. leeth ./ .
Part G: Hospitalization History - Health Service Use Only
(~e approlCima;e dates, names of hOJPita}!physlclan, diagnosis, surgery)
~ =;tCdt.-tr:1.1-r.. ~e(f /..J6.'(/#~d.oI t7A.tdec.. &.
r, " ' /;// ~~t.. ~ /I I I
. :
,
/~ - tLdut ~.../eL. ~("~J
<r:- / _!/ i.- /l,./,tf ,5"-/-fll...
Oate ..... ' Signature of Inmate Oate Signature of Reviewer
.
l
Part A: To I:.e ~omple:.>c b>' reterring InstiNtlon,
ReCerred to:
Pr
ReCerred Crom:
mJ . Q/r:u. ~
Appt, Date .3/:l. '1/ If {I
Appt. Time' ,;J.. ~ 00
Drug Sensiti\'it>.: :0;0::: Yes (Speclty):
n c !L-)'..!:.u..)\. t7 tJ Q.., ~ .
Current ~Iedications :t.,d Signuicant Medi~atlon History:
!!fsent Illness: (Include Signi!lc:mt Hx, Pertinent PE" Summary of lab and X.Ray studies, and reason .for refenal)
CUtt1.u.rJ::1n..J D meAt-. Ii: (&-t(]'~3 ,v.~ fJ<- c,; L ' .=-t....L JU.j ,;-c::; .A-.~
. G~ l"1'1 I' ,---- I
r:>...'-"'t<~::I,.#u... L ,,-1J) ...... ~r- ---- J' (_ .1,,, .,;,.._..__'\.
~ . . ,:x::.. r. 1- - 1-,
'.- ''-'-'- ------- - ~1'-'-''''''''' , r-o--- f .. · - - '?-
t'~ j:l "'-.;.;.I:.....~;~ c..'fo:.:._:=. . . .
I , I" f~. ..0'\ ~"'- 'l.~:... $:, 1.. ""__ ~'"i ~,..
i'\ <.~~- '-c-:,., .J ~ ~ o'~ , r ..
\0 ~ c---r f .... I' l:... .~
. A,\' . v-/I"~ ( ......~~. ,.., -.1.., ~... ...., ,< __
t.:..:..~.'::C....c\...l-~"" FI """'i"- fU-..... (,- r '-."... -,~""'_:- ._
'L' f':'~'''' ;...."->.. .
J. "",,-,-,,~ ~-c'-'-"'"">"" ...-,-....::;; ~ 'f ,~,,)
I J, L 1 '0... .." -.lo. " .- - r
. ,....c. ~'t.o 6..t.~...<fs."''f'-t,.~ L.... .. --
/.. ''''''"'r-.. , . II ~. d~ .u:-~,..... ~....,..,;\ I 1i-~cJ.--~"", .
"-- ~ ,,--,:c..........c.:t... .---,- - , -~. ,r -J
,,,,~,.....,~'1~
.'
:~/9 /., 't
'Date
......:. .:......~ ,. J'O.
SlgnaNre of reCerrlng Physician
'ar: B: To be completed by consulting Physician,
:xamlnation flndL,gs and test results.
. ,
. Aa_.
L.'"J ~~
r P-'
IV\. c~l ~~.. ~
(Cont, on reverse sIde)
/"Mit 44\
,
Inmate IdentifIcation
:
BC61
0,0,8, 1- /~ -u. (..
SSN /7;;. s~ -/7VS'
Inst, No, I)-~ '-!l./ oJ 7
Name ~lJl.. CA.~
'.
COM~IONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
BUREAU OF CORRECTION
CONSULTATION RECORD
1.. ,,_ ~
:{:~':(;:~.'e~1.Y('f,"H'lt:~_ '. .1
\~1' ... ''''1'''''~'''''''J':ri~4l'1~,''';
~i
".1
...
,;.1;.;""'/;
C')
....<1.1
"""-"'-'~'I""'>lT"f":'M~'i'1i~~W~'.!)'J/'!;:'..,..w
H _
.
---'.- ,.-'-
.~-.
.
o
'*'.-,-... .~.,--
l
.
.
. .
, ,
'-~,
MUNCY VALLEY HOS
PHYSICAL THER
PROGRESS NO
Clara Clark - 192-56-1945
965370 O/P 12-03-93
Diagnosis. Chronic SI dysfunction.
arief aiatory. The patient reports ahe had no previoue hiatory of low back.pain
until fall in Auquat 1993 while getting out of the ahower at state correctional
Institution of Muncy. She It&tes that day they had her aent to Muncy Valley
Hospital for x-rays which were negative and initially she complained of pain in
her low back and the back of her head which she hit when ahe fell. She atates
her low back pain haa progressed since her fall, and she is now experiencing
parestheaiaa and a dull ache into her left leg periodically throughout the'day.
She also fells her left leg is much weaker. She complains of pain with flexion
and rotation activities. she statea Dr. Hartz has had her on several different
medications with which there has been no significant change, and she has also
had an injection to that area with no aignificant change in symptoms. The
symptoms in her left leg are intermittent and always ramain above the knee. ,
She states she does feel a little bit better while having moist heat on in the
shower, but no significant change.
Hed1catioa: She has been on Parafon Forte and states she has a small allergy to
Oemerol.
social aistory. The patient is an inmate at the State Correctional Institution ~f
Muncy,
. ,
S: Refer to brief history.
0:
The patient ambulates into the physical Therapy Department in no
apparent distress, There is no antalgia noted. The left lower
extremity is mildly externally rotated with ambulat!on.
ID!J1ls BQHL
Flexion
_ limited 50' with pulling in the left low back
reqion and deviation to the right
_ limited 50' with centralized low back pain
which travels to the left anterior thiqh
Left side bendinq - within normal limits and pain free
Right side bendinq - limited 75' with pulling in the left SI and
low back reqion
Manual HUBcle Testina: ~
Quadriceps 4+
Tibialis anterior 4+
Extensor hallucis longus 4+
Peroneus lonqus and brevis 4+
~ Tendon Reflexes. +2 and symmetrical bilateral
and symmetrical bilateral patellar tendons.
Laseaue ~ positive on the left and is not enhanced with cervical
flexion.
Extension
~
5 .-
5.
5
5
Achilles, and +1
~ 1l--1"'/;7
PT 1/32
09/88
FORM NO. 709 . 004
, '.
I \
V
. .
.'
MUNCY VALLEY HOSPITAL
PHYSICAL THERAPY
PROGRESS NOTES
Clara Clark~ 192-56-1945
965370 O/P 12-03-93
Fabre'e ~ Poeitive bilaterally tor pain into the lett low back
region,
iI Comoreeeion AnQ Oietraction. Both'poeitive tor pain in the lett low
back region.
poeture. Lett ASIS, PSIS, and iliac creet appear to be elightly
elevated in etanding, Leg length appeare to be equal in eupine and
long eitting, but ie truly hard to aeeeee eecondary to the patient'e.
anxiety with pain and muecle guarding with motion,
paloationl There iea"eiqnificant amount of tenderneee noted along the
lower thoracic and lumbar paraepinal mueculature along with epaem.
=here ie aleo eignificant tenderneee along the euperior aepect of the
left SI joint. There ie no significant left buttock tenderneee noted.
Treatment Given. The patient received ice timee 20 minutee along with
iontophoreeie ueing 1,0 cc. lidocaine hydrochloride and 1.0 cc.
dexamethaeone phoephate delivered poeitively for 20 and negatively for
40 milliamp per minute. The patient was then instructed in a home
etretching program coneieting of piritormie, eingle knee to cheet, ,
hL~etring etretch, and wall lean. Theee are all to be performed timee
10 repetitione t,i.d,
Al The patient ie a 27-year-old female, who reporte to phyeical therapy
after a fall in Auguet, complaining of low back pain and ehowing all
the eigne of a poeeible SI dye function. I feel ehe will benefit from
modalitiee to decreaee her pain and progress flexibility to an
independent home program as the patient is able to tolerate, The
patient is a good rehabilitation candidate.
Goals: . .
1. Full, pain free trunk range of motion.
2, Negative Fabre's and SI compression/distraction tests.
3. Independent home program.
Treatment Freauencv. 6-8 treatment eessions.
Patient Q2All To become pain free with activity again.
PI Will see patient two times weekly for approx~~ately 3-4 weeks tor
modalitiee and home program. The patient may aleo need eome gentle
mobilizatione to correct the poeeible upelip of the left ilium.
Deb Alexander, PT, ATC
OA IClb
0: 12-03-93
T: 12-04-93
tk c., attA,t1r.tp-:r~
cc: Leo Hartz, K,D,
PT # 32
09/88 FORM NO, 709 . 004
"
PT 1132
09/88
, .
."']UNCY VALLEY HOSPITAL
PHYSICAL THERAPY
PROGRESS NOTES
Clara Clark - 192-56-1945
965370 o/p 02-03-94
Di~gnosi.: Chronic SI joint dysfunction.
0:
The patient was seen on 12-13-93 for initial evaluation and follow-up
treatment on 12-22-93. No further treatment sessions have been
scheduled through the State'correctional Institution of Muncy following
that time: Since there has been no contact from,the institution
regarding continuation/discontinuation of the same, and secondary to
prescription for therapy being greater than 30 days old, the patient is
discharged from our services.
A:
Unable to assess attainment of goals as discharge was
at last treatment session. Please refer to objective
assessment from last progress note of 12-22-93.
not anticipa,ted
findings and
i':
Dismiss from our services for reasons stated above.
if appropriate at a later time.
Please reconsult
Thank you for this referral.
4Ctr j*. - ",r,-
. to,.,) u.~.,
!c~ e L. Dg en, PT
v:.O:db
0: 02-03-94
T: 02-06-94
"
cc: State Correctional Institution of Muncy
..r \ t ...:, ,........
" '.. -",:-1,..' ",",
, . of" "a " .
'" ~.,~ .' ...... ....... "
I~~.' Of
,L.....,' . ~~; \
','
( .'
I'-'
.....
. .
\... ..
'.'-" .'.
'-,,,,I":
". "
-,
i-... !
.."
... 0'" \-0. ,
'.., "~I::;;'
_.1
......:,)
...<:('y
" "';;;""\' .~.
.....~ ..
FORM NO, 709 . 004
- --~,
.
KllHcr VALLft' IIOSPIDL
PB1'SIOL 'rBBllAPr
DISCBlIIlGB 5UIIDRl'
carla Clark - 192-56-1945
965370 O/P 06-22-94
o. The patient was lsst seen in the Physical Therapy Department on
03-29-94. At that t1me, a note was sent with the guards to take back
to the State Correctional Institution of Muncy stating that we would
like to .ee the patient weekly time. four weak.. The patient has not
raturned or been acheduled by the State COrrectional Institution of .
Muncy. - .
P. Discharge patient at this time.
N' ~'T7 ~...u....a /TI,.
Matt Andrews, PT
llA. db
D. 06-22-94
T: 06-23-94
cc. State Correctional Institution of Muncy
'. ..
, .
'rf~
..
.
_ t>
':(~:>'l
~ft.t~~;1~~~"~~~~~~.rr;,,<:~,~\h:.1
..
I.
.
<'
.
\.., .
"~;'%"~!I~.~ff!\,....
o
:; :.;;~~;,_,~',;:" "'" ;>;,:\;~~>\):'~\;> \i,i~( ~;;:.~:~ !,:\,*:;',;_J,~"
'''<l.1"
,..--" "
,
'-<,~ !-,,",l;;':\
,;.-.;,,-;;,_,,':,,J,',,j;:?j,1j,
.
~
-"-...... .".--
l
.
NAME C//tt..LA C-I..;4 <....e- PHONE NUMBER .~ I
ADDRESS c:.....~b.-t-.t../ ~li - SHEET NUMBER !"""':'-'J
DATE I PROBLEMS ,..INDINGS IS - Sub,ecllwt: 0 - OblKlrvel I TESTS ORDERED andIOI PLANNED
INum**, .net hi D.lCflfthonl
~h,"/~ ...J___ N.fI ~~~t' R,rm ~.".a... ~ - I
,
t."./., 0 .,. 7<!/);" , - an-, .,,4- ~ 1 ~ 1ZhY7
4/~/l..j) Nt'{r '-,'~
C....... g- - V77 ~-..... ~ 1::..'1 "" ,/: J"
14-10 :r />>,;1_ - C ./ ,I' '.- .,. , /L. A,
v , .
<;:/~(, J - "Jr'. ~. 'L
..,,~"', ~....... , I
.. .,... .L I
\~.. h.1 ."'l ,p, /L ''-~ I
- - -''''~.~
..
I
,,/ {,.., I
-.}- ,....l- I ,
IJ..- HI/A ..... I ,
,j I
;/ ..../ J?~. f h'J.......~' t!' ,.c::.-_ .-d- ." ,~ J I
'7.-:r- ,J'~ .~....~~ - :;> " r _'
- J ~"...., 11 ,.,/~
'" ~ /~,-(/ '-L.. ~~ ~, " .~~ I
,,2 .'/~ IL/~ ,," . ./ /~;~ A...-
.iZ'I P'.~.,,~~ c: _,..~ . v .4/ " /d. '
'" 01' -t./ ~ C " ~ .-...-~ )
ITI .c.... ,~ J c.J ...........-, ';"'/{J
10 ~ c.--........_____._........... '" 7'10
:"'l ,ere.. " ,A,J- ,c. ~.:....._... ~.I-. .r-J' .,tll';-/~ '2,..1 ,f' J_ ;:., ~_\
I/C,,;....... ,--'::.....j .;;:-
:J. , "'1..:~' j :: '- 5. ~ : ' CJl.._:t....;I""\." u,~, I .:.--- ~~
, ,L' .. " . p' ..(~... ,. .
;:. i I/~ I ",."l. ',/, ....,...."'";,.. .~'.L ;-" -";";'-."1..). I -,
r.... ::';"1, .' 'v.,.'.,. - ..,,'
,,' . '- .;;j! 7' " ' 0: " ,
--....., T''',;.:,.'}.. -r" " :"A _.' I"'.,) ... .. ,'" " -. ,
:.~ ,.1,' ~ '~'/'\ll ,..c ~ ../ ";,..,,-~r 'no. -
'.~' ,.!\: ~.,.., ; , ,
It1 I., ,~.,' " I '...u:L.a ~ ";,, ,..) ......, ,.., f'[- I 1, ..,r.'" . I.....'. - I - ~..,,'"
" "- .~<.
.'.:<:' "'u. OJ {'.fA :, ':'f. - rj , _'/,f!:.,J . ..:., ~ .~
, '" .r- ". "........... '. 'J ..;" ..'
.~,~ ~ ~'I'~ ;.4 ';J ,"'}- -;..,... ',p>- ~,\ ,"./ >~.\ '~~U=>"'J7, "'L." .1.t_J" .J
"'f ,il" ,'.'1.': '..... , . , " -.. .......~:..I .....,.' '.. :"'<. <-J-.r,
.Ir ,.. .'l,U*.. (ll.r;:t"......
'- "=1';....,:,,- " '+1." /.". " -, ~ , ''\'".L''''' I " .'
'~.
I. . . 1 ' -r- '., " ;j.,' I
~- . ....-
I,..:. J:. . r,'1 "/ ,?,'''''.-
:"'I-'?,... I.r .'':...-1 " _ . ,
,-
I............. - ("";p ..."
P.'l~ t ,.... , -. ",-::.,\!\ -- ,,' ., .\ '0/ :(1..' '1 ..', , (. '.", ~ ''':''.;- .
~.....",'. , .:- .
..
- .. .
.
~.(; - '. .. .- . -*,,-:- " ;--, ......, .
"::.... '. ."-.. .. " (.'- ( -
," . ~' ......-71 "' ." .- I~ ~~
- . . .. .-. .' .-' . -:-...... u.:;..;... ....... -
.":-~ /, ".' l ("o~ , .1 .' y;- '....--'3< .u ..-.:.}'..... . , "
. . , .\..
i.o -';.. ~.. ':".:J . , . '- -r .
'. '.' .
PROGRESS NOTES
'0"1I1I04a CO,,"W'LI. .".T..... I""C~ c.....II~...IQN. 'WNOt.
~A.'~E (I J?tr./; (!11-'1(II~ PHONE NUMBEA /C )
ADDRESS SHEET NUMBEA 0)
DATE I PADBLEMS fiNDINGS IS - SLb,.ctIW; 0 - ObjeCtlvtl T_DIRID _II' PLANNID
INumbt>t M\d Bnef DncrlDtionl
-J " /:l . .... -
i/ y ~ {( ~C7c ,.. (/ cs-- ,-<J ""'. .- .
/-r
'I -
VA......... r 'r
.
k':t'/- ~ -' ~- ~,,- ~
/' .
".'-f." I .., u.o "".... G/l-,N'-'
.-( '/ V'I-"
..... ~ /l.o n,- / 'L-
A ...J ~ - /r ...
I .e Fir ",. J
I
:4>"", ../~ - ' t't:' ~'-I 'e: 1'------- ~ "'I::
, - I .' "
I ,,'7.. ,. .- ;
. '/1 ""Io~........... -,/ It/' ...
/!. . . ~ L. -
...- ,.
~..' /,,- - ". #" ,/ r
.--
.--
---
"./ i
I " ../ I
1 Co. /_ Ii J' /, /1 " I
,o''' ... l it I (t; ~-.....- I
I . . ./J , /./......._ ,-.J>--
I C/....-r - :....- / , I
-(1;1' ,. / ~T
I i ~, " _"- I ,
I /,M../ (j.... " ,,~ A" .... /7 ~ ,
/ '" ..:,.-v ~:- ".h .,... /1- -.'
I IV , " ;- 7~~
, - ~ / -/
I
t C/ 1,./ /'/H'V'J'-' ~
-
'if t<.~: ~:J- '- ~'A.o _ t.i_d~ } :: d.:. , Q ;::....- ..-,'" ..
).fJ /'l,.t'! h. .",x ,,1':: JJo I. JI"'\ , . .J-""-",-:'. ~ "/r., ,
'A.
i 01'.f......:.w . {.Ii I /.1 I,....: ~ (I" /&1 . u ----
I ,r,.. t:.A;U p/-f'I-t.., 'ilr .. /.., /.. J IJI-f-'-" I /'Vwry ;. I .
, I ~-lA; , / I" './ . , I //' " I'
I :..,..,.".,.' ....-:;,Z"'..-t-f-....,. l'"' t {/...... '~- .
, /.10:. hl.:.~"'" ,.- .' I;"'~. , I
~'.",",- ^ r. C~._... I
, }:;~ "l_ " .:""'-;.-, I
. .,_.. "'~h'_ I " -
, /-----
, . :.../. .
"' ,.".".
.
" ., ,
H' ._.
I
I
I
I
I
fI' U.I yo- ~
I ,,1(7 4~
I' OAT!
'NT/BSA
CPT C9Dl!
I
1/ 17 (r~
,
>'2- 30r
, I
I
I
,- - ,-
i ,) , 0,/,/.-:, \,
... "v...,- ,I. _'"
~'"- /i: .,.
~ ~ '( f-A r- rr--- :::;.- /V)-~,
-'" ~ ,rI- ~
~;-/~_#.;-' -
,~.Q<.--
~~-
tr1-~ -<0' 7 ~
~ .pUf,~ /e~: ~/ -
~........e..--'--
-.-.
~-}----
~~. _r~~"
__ ~r/~I
....71
1
~.h~
/' ~~ ,
r;::; tf"rvy r /y-/'
~~7 f7'u~
~:q'v ~ ~~ 4/' _, __
..-:::l
,~.~ ~:-._~.
-~. - - ,- h_ ----n-~r-:v--..
/i~)'7 \ /....7vl- ;--
~ ..---
Vtr- I /'1'/'1----
~7 ....vo
~~- ,-
- a-----
;t- ')/~~~
- I
,
-,
I
---.'1
I
/i,~ ,'~ I!-,::F'-'-
, /,--r-'
......---- &"""')o"~
/-.~
- I
i
.n................~..~..Il)..._.... "......._......
1 '.. .....~........___....._~-.._.....,
~...........__.fII_2 _, s...~ .......oAtlMN5TlAflOH..'"
-........--................ .. --"'--~
~it_J._' '''~__cn,,>pe.........talitprocMtandh
,...,.,......ahtlraryu~ I'IIiaIM lI:lor-MhaM'Wf....CI'I.tatftblur.
\J5,(1N "fGNANCY
~.......~.........._......._ACl..........CWI__'
...._..........--........ ft'two.......-,.".....ACCl.ft\........
.-.... _....... s... -.INN>>. ...~......... """'-"
CoNnrexILooo PRIssuu IN
MOirf PAmm_IlAJsI7HE DosE.
AccuPRIL
QUmonlHCltablels lO,20.40mg
"'- _ bAIl WM'O"f rJ Y I"'Cflborog ~ tIftCbed
~~
........'... _c-.
o\larIot......,........01950
PO.l03.IAo909'l..'lO'14,
..10026
~ ,".. W:lrNt.l.onOtn C~
LITHO IN CANADA
Pallenl Name
Dale/Diagnosis
, ."
. ., .,},.
~. ~,( (.. I,"
---
,,.. .
Page (Y
PlANS 8< Il
Ilinh Dale
HISTORY'" PHYSICAL (Subjecllve and Objecllve)
'.
:'
/D "
,
~
.. I I
"
'*
--:z.-
~ . ;-v'
""
.
t..-z.,_
?7:- -
'-'--
"
1
~
.h.-t:.--
2.--z..~.
~
c:::.e.-
".,>
aaritin~
!J.'!9 (fnrntRrlinA)
New. bJ.d.
CIarltln:D
~~~:-,__",wr:t..
lnVl'!
"-"~ ......-.',..~
lJaracnl Name
,,,,\
: . ~7'
_A: ~, .l . 11.',(1_
Dlrlh 0.10
.~
P.gc _ 10
0.lclDlagno5i5
a!;1 {O'<'
HISTORY & PHYSICAL (Subjcclivo .nd Objccllvcl
.... ~~
,- .
, ~
.
,/
,.. I..JI- ,--
.'1":\ "..... I
w
/' "_ /I /: .~(... _,/
'"' I." <.01. .~' ...."
Claritin.
New,/Wi
CIarltln:O
"'l~..~"'."'~"
(ovc~
"
.
Pip
PtJ\NS .. a
, ,
-
.
,t-,
.,........, ,
...." "
"JI:..
;/
'.:',c
,-
v,,/?- C,. S
. .0.
"
~o 3~It1d
Clarltln~
__11__........1"_....\
,n', l]'llnl3.~
Nttw, bJ.d.
ClilrItJn:D
.....1.._.........
08L9~8r019 ~O:(l
(,wcr~
3661/8':/ZO
~ ..~-:~ --- --
......-~.-
dt!~ .)
.,.lcal HIIllI
D,1cID1a II
I
#'
r'
-
..
'.
-
.--
-
;....~
a-<-o(
~""d
Oarltln..
1l'!!l(~t::Irl;nP)
'B,'~ 13'll!13d
:D
....I~.__... till.
OeLq~8rOlq ~O:(I
(ow,)
%&1/8:/:0
~ ",
(~ cb~
'\
.
"\
o
III
',' .'
,
,
-L-
. ..~; ~., . ~ . I J .
,
.,.....
'"
~Q~
.' r
... ........... ~ :.
"
~"",,,"
"
....~ ~Jr.:H'.. ollJ..~ ;11 ..... . ....,). " ......~..a....
. .'OI!,. J~i,~,"oo:r..' oljof~'",. (I'
4-0\.; I ,t 1,' i.'';'-'' ": ,,' -.~. . '~"";",
. ':
" .'
.' ~
.f .
C1ar1tln..
~..II^"""",""",.J,'...^'
,]3.', 13']1 ~ 13.l
~ bJ.d.
CIarItkI~D
......-.......-
08,g~8rO,g ~O:('
'. '
,l
..;
',. '.' :f 'j
'::...J';"
I,"J Ii
." .I',
, '
i ~.
. ,,"
o ,C L.
,
.1....
1_' ;
,
"
, ',,"
:,'
'.i
,I
t.' . ~
"p'.
, I
, ,
I ~ ."" J:',
..i'
-I.'l.
~. " ,
. - ,~ j I : .! .
: :1
~. j ! t
:'t.
"
,',
1'"'
':",
I "'j. ~j
I:.
, "
,
..
.: 'i.
" .."
;':1"
".,
.'
"
r'l:
;,
(: /~ c; u~.r<..;'-
i SECTION II ITa tHI complst!d by physician)
I The information on this form will be used by the CAO to make an assessment of your pa;lent's qualification for (1)
General Assistance. Chronically Needy status. on the basis of physical or mantal incapacity for substantial gainful
employmant (substantial gainful employment is any work which your patient can perform at least 30 houl1 wlltlkly for
payor profit,), or (2\ for exemption from public assistance work requirements becaul8 of a physical or mental condition,
Please complate this sactlon basad on your BYaluatlon of the patient's complalntlln Sactlon I,
PHYSICAUMENTAL CAPACITY: Ch.ck 1 ) tho molt approprl.t. block In th.lln below th.t refl.cu your opinion of thl pllllnt's c.pac,
to work, Pi.... Natl: I narmtl prtQnlncy should no; bl rlgardld U In Incapacl;."
IChock 1""'-1 only ani,)
1,0
2.0
CalMCi;., Unllmllld, Phy.lcll/Mlntal CapaclIV II adlqUl1I to ..Ik Ind mllnttln full'llml gllnful Imploymlnt in . nom
work Invlronmlnt with narmll work schedul..,
CaPKl;., Unlimited wllh AccommodatiON, Hlndlcapped or dl.odvontogod by I .lrlaul chronic IIlnlll or condition, t
not to thl point thlt preelud.. full.lIml gllnful Implaymant If rl.anabll accommadltlonl Ire midi, RI.anlbll lCCa
modatlan. may Includl: Itructurtl modlllcallonl, modlflld work Schldul.., acquisition or modlllcallan of IQulpmlnt
dlVICII, pravillanl for rtodln or intlrorttln, jab ,"structUrlng and athlr .Imll.....ctlan.. or thl nled for drug mllntlnln'"
Chock thl fOllowing blockl.1 which IIlply:
D Phy.lcal Limltltlan. 0 Mlntll Llmltltlonl D Hlllth SUltllnlng Medication Needl'
3, 0 CaplOl;., Llmitld, Hu I chronic or .cutl phy.lcaI or m.ntal condition which rlStricu but do.. not prohibit .mploym.
If work II 30 haun or I... I week,
Chock thl fOllowing blockld which IPply:
D PhYllcal Llmilltlan. D M.n;11 Limll3tloN D Hlllth SUltlinlng Medication Needl
4,~ Tlmporarily IncaplOitllad, Currently InclPlc';lted dUI 10 I Ilmparory condition or .. a rllult of an inlury or an acu
candlllan and thl Incaplci;., tlmporlrlly preclud.. am pia mint
Thl IImparlry InclllaclIV Is axpected 10 I.t until ':li' ",,-
. I AT
1.1 '1IISIamlnt of this condition nladed after thl abavI dlte?' 'Sa'YIS 0 No .
5, 0 IncaplOltlled, Profoundly limiting phy.lcal or mental condition ~onontlY preclud.. any form of Imploym.nt.
COMMENTS: If block 2, 3. 4 or 5 is checked, substantiate your assessment of physical or mental incapacity by providing
information regarding:
t1I DIAGNOSIS (Prlmlry and SlCCndary) AND MEDICATIO~S RELATED TO EACH DIAGNOSIS. u. . .'
Prlmlry: "P~'lG;\j~I\l~( Medications: ('ou("l..ll-
,j '" p~ "a/'6.
Sacondary: L.- 5 .$T1~\1\J Medications:. tJ ~
121 FUNCTIONAL LIMITATIONS: f'! 0
tI
W9 ,"lei ) p-'\..~~ .:5f;u'tvl.;/';::f
~~r1Ar{ Sut:Ci:.CJ v
"'L
13) Hu the patllnt eVlr racelvad 3D con;lnuous dayl of InPltllnt Clre In I faclll;., Ihospltll or psychiatric unill for thl mentally ill
or mentally retarded? ~
o V.. DNa (_U known If VII, pll.1 identify facillIV and dltl.
Fmm
To
DATE
PACIL.ITV
PREPARED BY
MEDICAL. PROVIDER
ADDRESS
:,'.:'; tEANC. .:. ).
-,,~.....,.._.._.. ~...-
i.IN'.'ICOD, P,\"' i~~~"i'~~
(tUG) JCO.ll-:a
?j ~'::ATU-::::::
C/ I ? c, / q 1.../
I OATE '
PA 635 . 3/84
..,--.-
La.., '\,L~L (:.J..L LiC
! SECTION II (To bII camp/tired by physician)
I The :nformation on this form will be used by the CAO to make an assessment of your patient's quallfic3tion'for 11)
General Assistance. Chronically Needy status. on the basis of physical or mental incapacity for substantial ]ainful
~mployment (substantial gainful employment is any work which your patient can parform at least 30 houl1 weekly filr
payor profit.), or (21 for exemption from pUblic auistance work requirements because of a physical or mental condition,
Please complete this section based on your evaluation of the patient's complaintlln Section I,
PHVSICAL/MENTAL CAPACITV: Check I I thl man Ipproprllle black in tho lilt below thl; rlfleeu your opInion of tho pltlOnt', ~apooil
to work, PIIIII Nato: I normal pregnlncy should no; bl reglrded as In Incapoolty,
IChock (., only anl,l
I,D
2.D
Capoolty Unllml18d, Physical/Montll Capoolty is adequlte to sNk and mllntlln lull.tlmo gllnlul employment in I no",.
work envlranmlnt with narmll work schedullS,
Capacity Unlimited with Ilccammadltlans, HlndlcaPllld or dlslldvanttQtd by I senaus chronic i1lnlSs or candlllan, b
no; to thl paint Ihal preCludes lull.tlmo gainlul amplaymen; if relSanablo accammadallons Ire mlde, Reasanlble aceo,
madltlans may include: nruCNrl1 madlflcaaans, madlflod work schodullS, ICQUlsltlan or madlflcaaan of equipmen;
davic:os, proVisions far reeda.. or interpretl/I, jab restructUring and ath., slmillr'3Ctians, or thl nlld far drug maintenanet
Check the fOllowing blacklsl which apply:
D Physical Limitations 0 Mentel Limitations 0 Health Sunalnlng Mldicatian Nttdt<
3. 0 Capoo!ly Umlted' Has a chronic or ocutl physical or mental condition wnlch rlStrieu but daIS not prohibit emolavmer
If work is 30 haun or less a week,
Chock the fallOWing black(sl which apply:
~. D Physical Limltttlans D Mental Limita;lons D Health Sunainlng Mealcation Need..
~, c:::::r Temparanly Incapacitated. Currently incepaciteted due 10 a temparery condition or as I result of an injury or .n aeu
, condition and tho incaplclty temparanly precludes emplay?"n;, l f!!'"
The lamparlry IncaplClty is expected 10 lISt until h I- ~ _ q ~
IDA r
Is I rewessment of this candltlon needed 1ft., the abave date? ~es 0 No
5. 0 Incopacimtd. Profoundly limiting physical or mentll condition which permanently precludes Iny farm of employment.
COMMENTS: If block 2, 3, 40r 5 il checked, substantiate your assessment of physical or mentel incapacity by providing
information regarding:
(t) DIAGNOSIS (Primary and StCIlndaryl ANO MEDICATIONS RELATED TO EACH DIAGNOSIS,
I Pnmary: P.~ Medications:
I Secandlry: L-5 S'l7\.P-I-N Medlcltlans:
I
I '21 FUNCTIONAL LIMITATIONS:
.
~.;;
(18N2. <...
FJ"Y
, ."
:.rto
>- ~~ 1/.c
)
. --
~f;(..~CI <__~vl..""4
-' /-- 1/
. i/
~
~pJ-
131 Has the pltiem aver rtlCtlved 30 continuous dlYs of Inplaem Care in a looillty Ihospital or plychlltrio unlU far the mentllly ill
or mentllly retarded? ~ '
o Ves DNa --r-".nawn If Ves, pie_Identify lacillty and dlte,
Fmm
To
DATE
FACILITY
PREPARED BV
MIDICAL PROVIDER
1541 Chlct.eslllr Avenue
,
,
f~.(610) 465-1176 ,-:
ADDRESS
Z, 17~ /q \"
I DATe I
SIGNATURE AND TITLE
PA 835. J/S4
..
<'
'" -_.... -.--.'
I.
\' ....".........,.
. ,~!~,~,>,y'!:L9&:~
,J".~, ..~," "'.' '0,/ _"'~~.
,"-'~..
,:~,;.~;\l~'~%,!,.i~""$."~I~~""~i't'!<:"",,~1
u
'oJ
.-..----
r ,,-'
.
.
1ft
t
_;.1[.\,
J..
"
1_-
.
CROZER
(R01.1R.nIUTtJt \IEDIC.\L [E'fER
l'PLAND P..' I~ll~
William H. a,"". M.D.
C/IlIltINtI
DEPARTMENT OF RADIOLOGY
DII~no'llc RIdIoIoVY CU.ZIOO
Kl Woona Kim. M.D. JOllpl'1 R. Stock, M.D.
Blrblt. A. McCAn,l1y, M,o. John A, BoneYlll. M,D.
RIChIId N. T..",. M.D. Stefan M. Skallna, M.O
Howllll p, R_belll, M,O, Nool L MItnOm, 0,0,
.lamel W. HUlted. M.D. CArne L. Kr.. e. M,D.
RldlaUon Oncolo9Y ..'.Z'CO
G_ E,IoAcC.""", ,",,0,
51_ A, AmQO, f,A,O,
UncoU1 K. PIO. M.D.
NAME:, R" . '.L '
;L..1,.... ..".,. ...
::3 ~. :'::JQ ..-
... .--..--
......~~I :~
AGE OR DOB:
..I.. '
,
,.'
~ ~ ~e
................. ......
~ "1';:'.J
,~'1
PT, BILLING NO,:
3ll~.:.:.::~~11
LOCATION:
':"/C:
:-,-
'. .
SOCIAL SECURITY NO,:
.'):~~~~ :...:;
DISCHARGE OA TE:
~CI1i'~Ej :..:.:; ~ I';.. .... -:".1
:C::..tl ..,::1S~3.;.,:;::.:.L ;r: ::11::
.:7~ :
"'. ....-....
117:=1:":':'" "'"
. .. ... .It.
! ~ !" :oit'...;.! -.... . ;.~ ~ '!:"", . ... ':' . ::'..
.. .. ;\,:i of J!'~ : ...... ~ ,~'"..
;'::1:1::'-: 1~",.,:' .:ml.ilJ" :!.. .:~:.: ,:~:.i, ~';l:'r..lr ~V.~.
;1) '"at! ,,~l'\ l~~-!Ti~';.n~:; .ilo! "ole Joa.':JS :~'H" _Z "".oJ
;;'llr.:-'6't. ,a,1:crt!l. '11) ;)r'~I' J~Ut2t~$ ."''''1 1"....-\1:30.=
"i'i.:': /' '.' t :....~!'. '.;nt~,-
~~ 'aI''' j~.....:I'''4': .n ~!'C\l"
. ~l' :J,~t..ir' $,'".
4t ~.I"td ,:..3-..l ~'..-!.. :ner"i . = '0 t'r':en';~ j'; 11.iC. "i',r"lil":.l,:n. -"<I '!Urli
~:r1m'~a lri )d~~"~. !;,~ .~5U&l'=2~ 'S5~~US ~~r~c~ur~~ lri ;~r~~~r~~u'!.
....1:'; "':h" ....1-~ : .,'J11
'"t-er' .; 'CO ttJ' .h!nc.t ,).; 11:iC '~"I'''''' ~t":~h -?'\'U"i 'il'l :t!' t
I'!::'" 1t1",'a.l :3!''':,'"\' '1i:\'. :I~ ~~. ..t~'i '1~l..;,"~.. -....~.~.::, :i:-! ';'~:;;.~.
,--------- ----_..__...~
~":' ~:'ld .~-it '~",,!::. ~~~:': J 'I,} ,'.::an,:t ',;.; :'JC '~r~.::.~'~;" ~q&ll\, ~i't'!r!
.:ta:' 11! J .1.~a. t : Jr.-:-:'.-l; ~:. iC. ':IJ .;e. :h~ "l~I;_-'11 ..::.....I~:):i, !.I"'l ;i.ta:n....
--------
; ~
,:;~;;"IE ;/RE=G~. I.;).
,',
~;<: ~,..a Jf
S~ot!m~r :~. L'?O~
\'
,
ORDERING PHVSICIAN:
TEANO :10 OHN
,~41 ~~I:~,3T,~ ~V
:_!NWCCD =-:. ~"(o:
7:;:';NO '1D OAt~
/ivv~
:~.J 1 -::41 C:4~S;ER
,~v
_::Iv.~:: :..;. :0:'00:
....",
.
CENTER OF DELAWARE COUNTY
475 KEDRON AVENUE, FOLSOM, PA 19033
610.237-6674
DIrector
STEFAN M. SKAUNA, M,D.
CLAlUt, CARLA
192-56-1945
DR. TBANO
Oata:9/1/95
Statua: OP
CO!C J50BILB
Name:
S~S. No.:
Referring Phyalclan:
Mal OP THE
LUMBAR SPINE I
HISTORY,
Status post injury 1 year ago, with left leg and low back
pain.
IMPRESSION,
Normal examination.
COMMENTS I
MR examination of the lumbar spine was performed including
sagittal TR600/12, sagittal TR5000/119, axial TR600/9 and axial
TR5000/119 images without contrast.
The lumbar vertebral bodies are anatomically aligned. The
disc spaces appear normal. There is no evidence of focal disc
herniation, central spinal or foraminal stenosis. The conus is
normal in size, shape and position, There are no findings to
suggest focal nerve root encroachment.
There is some mild degenerative change of the facet joints in
the lower lumbar spine.
J~ ~~ BIEHLE, JR.. M.D.
JP"S. I qmc
DT: 9/6/95
.('
Mercy Catholic Medical Center
THEIlE"" c. POWER. 0.0,
CIt.'rrMn
MARK E. SCO~ 0.0.
JAMES R. MESHAM. M.D.
Crozer Cheater Medical Center
WILLIAM H, GREEN. M,O,
CINllfMn
STEFAN M, SI(AlJNA, M,O,
;a WOONO KIM, M.D.
JOHN A BONAVITA M.D.
QAIIR'E L KIIESGE. MO,
JOHN F. HIEHLE. JR., M.D.
Delaware County Memorial Hospital
THOMAS'" DlUBERTO, 0,0,
CIt./rm.n
/rf\rY'\
RANJ,T R, SHAH, M,O,
VONG AlOOK (8EN1 KIM. M.D.
BEN-Z10N FRIEDMAN, AI.O.
.
CENTtR a: OI!L4'o1ARE CaJIllTY
475 KEDRON AVENUE. 'OLSOM. PA 11033
.10.:/37.aa74
DIrector
STEFAN AI, SKAUNA. AI,D.
CLARlt. cJ.lIr....
192-511-1945
DR, Tu.HO
Dlteil./19/96
Statue: OP
COlIC JIOI!IILII:
Nam.:
I.S.No.:
R.f.rrlna Phyllclln:
KIll 0. '!'lIB
CEllVYt"AT. sPIn
1/1919111
RXSTOay!
MVA 1 year ago, rule out HNP.
YKPU!UIYOH f
Unremarkable MRI of the cervical spine.
CI'\MII1N'I'g .
Magnetic resonance imaging of ehe cervical spine was performed
utilizing ehin slice technique in the sagietal and axial planes,
The spinal cord is normal in caliber and singal intensity,
There is no evidence or disc herniation, spinal stenosis or neural
roraminal encroachment, The vertebral bodies exhibit normal
stature and signal ineensity,
I'
'm II\.
JOBlfA. IONAVITA, 11.0.
JAJl.qtnc
OT: 1/23/96
""rey Clthollc Medlcll Cent..
_104 G.1'OWI1l. 0.0.
--
....~ L ""'FT. DO.
JAMtU ",_I/o.
CrDII' Chlm, Mldlcl' Clllt...
"'UWlH tMUN. "b.
-
If'UANtI. """"""..c.
lO""ONIl_..D
,/0......, _V1TA...,O
CAM,. ..1OlE1llf. AID
JOHN' HtrHIZ. A, AJ.D.
1I31'1 13>JI ft 13d
DIl.we,. County ".mo.rlal Ho.lpllll
1HOMA4 A OlJ8tll1'O. 0 0
--
ItAIUIT If. SHAH" W D
rDND 1olOOI( INNI I/IAI, .. 0.
'fN.lID'IFIlf_,"D
SEP 15 '95 13:12 FROM MRI CENTER OF DELCO
PAGE,OOI
'.
MRI PROFESSIONALS, INC.
4'75 I<edron Avenue. Folsom. PA 19033
Office: (610) 7.3'7-6674 Billing Service: (610) 690-4755
PATIENT REGISTRATION INFORMATION
.
.r
Datw of Se~:
FItat Name: ~ ~, Middle lnltla~
t SocIal Security: / 9 c2 -.s-~ -/9 fL,j'
laIt Name:
Sex: +" DOB:
:;~
AlIl8 COde: 0 D Telephone No,:
Sla\us: 0 P Hospital:
Relerrlng PhYS~lan::iLl -:l"t. I ~
physlelan Performing Study: p. i./;" h /t"_
Diagnosis: -I-
proa!dure Code: 7021 $'1 Description 01 servictl: t.p};f.::r i ~ ~:u ~ .0
F~~.f", ~otal; Amounl: DIscount Balanoo: ~ h
Stala: ~ ZIp Code:
t,fr<f-ol9'..J R
/ t:t () /.. 7
Rlglstratlon No,:
phone No,:
Charge:
Paid:
Due:
MEDICAL INSURANCE INFORMATION:
PA Blue Shield: I ) Primary:
Oul 01 Slate: I) Primary:
1.0, No,/Agreernenl No,:
Subscriber:
{ J Secondary:
( 1 Secondary:
Group No.:
ReI. to Patienl
at, Date
Aulhorlzalion No,:
Medicare: I ) Primary:
Subscriber: Rei, to Patlant
1 Seoondary:
Ell, Dale
PA Medical Assistance {'/J
ReclpienlNo,: CJ:::1/.;v.;,~ ...,7148
Card Issue No.: /'YJ
.. TOTRL PRGE.OOl ..
CG
I.
(
~ --- .,.~ --' -....
j",,tl1ft-'-'":..,,,~~,.;,......,...~.,,,., ,''''''~
't,J
o
.
.
',0. ';,' '0'~";"'^-''''''';''''':''''''"<'
.....iJ
.~-
-~
'~".-''''.-'-...-
DYNAMIC
PHYSICAL THERAPY &
REHABILITATION CENTER
201 Eut 1011\ Street. r, O. BoA 362 . .....rcu. Houk, rA 19061.0362
!'hone: (6tO) &59-9\10
Fw (610)859.9121
PHYSICAL THERAPY INITIAL EV ALUA nON
NAME: Carll Clark
DATE OF EVALUATION: 11.7.95
AGE: 29
DIAGNOSIS: Lumboslcryl Sprain/Slrain wilh Rldiculopllhy
REFERRED BY: Dr, Dan Teano
HISTORY: Patient is a 29 year old female with eomplainlS of pain in the lumbar region and
pain radiating down the left leg. She stites pain staned when she fell in 1993, X-rays It that
time were negative for frlctures, She WIS unable to receive treatment as she was pregnant and
had increased pain with the pregnancy, She had an MRl approximately 2 monlh's Igo but docs
not know the results, She is referred now for physicallherapy evaluation and treatment.
PAIN DESCRIPTION' Pain is Icross the lumbar region and down the left IC8. She has
oceanional tingling and numbness in the left Icg, Pain increases with lifting. bending. prolonged
sitting or standing.
RANGE OF MOTION:
TRUNK:
Flexion 0.50
Extension 0.10
Sidcbending Left 0.25
SidebendinB Right 0-25
LO 3!l\1d
oJ3W 130ltll3d
OSL9~Sr019 ~O:El 9661IS:I:U
ST'RENOTH:
TRUNK'
Flexion 3+/5
'Extel\llon 3+/5
Sldebending Left 3+/5
Sidcbcndlng Right 3+/5
SPECIAL TESTS: Straight leg raises positlvc for back pain at 600n thc right and 60 on the
left,
REFLEXES: Intact
SENSA nON: Intact
ASSESSMENT: Patient with lumbosacryl ,prain/strain with radiculopathy with pain, limited
trunk mobility and strength, and painful functional activitics.
GOALS: 1. Decreasc pain in the lumbar region and left leg
2, Increase pain free trunk mobility and strenilh
3, Increase upper and lower body strength
4, Return to full pain free functionaJlctivitles
PLAN: 1. Moist heat
2. Ultrasound
3. High volt galvanic stimulation
4. Trunk mobility and Strengthening exercises
5, Progrcss to upper and lower body strcngthening exercises
6, To be seen 3 times weekly for 4 weeks
SO 39':1d
03W 130l1113d
OSL9!;SrOt9
9b61/S~/ZO
.
Thank you for referring Carla Cluk to Dynamic Physical Therapy and Rehabilitation Center, U
you have any questions, please do not hesitate to calJ me,
1 . lit... .
"-1/V /._ f
Michael 1. Pino, P.T.
MJP/ek
, ;.~.!
.3
DYNAMIC
PHYSICAL THERAPY &
REHABILITATION CENTER
I
Phone: 1(610 1859-9110
Fax: (610 859-9211
2011!.ut 10th Street. p, 0, Boll 362 . Marcus Hook. rA 19(6),(1362
11-8-95
Carla C1uk
SUBJECTIVE, Pltient Ilottemporuy pain followins YClterday's ICJsion but paillw tred.
OBJECTIVE: Treatment: Moist heat with high volt galvanic stimulation to the~umb,ar region
for 10 minutes, Ultrasound to the lumbar region at 1. S walls per centimeter squarp fot ;'
minutes, ThCfllpeutic exercise consistins or sinsJe knee to cbest, double knee to CbCst.. ,Ilw back
rolltions, panial sit ups I
, I
,
ASSESSMENT: Patient 8Cltinstempomy pain relicffrom trcalment. I
PLAN: Will continue present program,
\
^-v.Jl-1"'
Michacll! Plno, P.T,
MJP/ek
.'-':::"
::~;'~".'
DYNAMIC
PHYSICAL THERAPY &
REHABILITATION CENTER
1l.Jll-95
Phone: (61~8S9-9110
Pill: (61 11159-9221
\
I
SUBJECTIVE Patitntslltcs that overall pain hu dec:reucd a1ightly since initiljnB urtmtnt
this week, \
OBJECTIW: Treatment; Moist heat with high volt galvanic stimulation \0 thc\ lum~1Ir resion
for 20 ,minutes, Ultrasound to the lumbar region at 1, S walts per centimeter squarf for ,I
minutes, Therapeutic exercise c:onsisting ohingle knee to chest, double knee to clest. 'ow b&tk
rotatioDI, partial sit ups, , \
ASSESSMENT: Overall patient is improved with initiation oflreatmenl.
Carll CJuk
2011!utlOth Street. P. 0, Box 362 . Marcus Hook, PA 1906Hl362
PLAN: If pain remains decreased will increase exercise program next 5eWon,
\ \
~p..Jfr'
.. "_"06\ I' Pin ' P T
lYlIWlaQ. 0,..
MJP/ek
11.15.95
CarJa Clark
.:-.....
.;~.~:.
DYNAMIC
PHYSICAL THERAPY &
REHABIUTATION CENTER
201 ENtlOd1 Street. p, a Box 362 . Mucus Hook. PA 1\10614362
SUBJECTIVE: Patient reporu the gell good pain rc1icffor the remainder of the y f't"owing
treatmCllt IIId thm pain rClU/1lJ the next day. I
OBJECTIVE: Treatment: Moist heat with high volt galvanic stimulation to the I~mb.,. region
for 20 minutCl, Therapeutic exercise consisting of single knee to chest, double ~ to e,'esl,
low back rotations, and paniJl sit up', \ I
ASSESSMENT: Paticnt continues to get tcmporuy pain relief. I I
PLAN: Will attempt to increue exercise prollf1lm next session.
~!-;Ir
MJP/ek
CA,c[tl
C t. II(.~ Ie.
)
)
}
)
)
)
)
c....
III The Court of Cocmon Pleas of
Cumberland County, ?ennsylvania
v
19
,/
'-/)$'7
~o. </)- ,
C orfl, g fc... .
f
OATH
We do solemnly swear (or affirm) that we will support, obey and defend
the Constitution of the United States snd the Constitution of this Co~on-
wealth and that we will discharge the duties
....~
of our offic~ifidelity.
~1-1
/ Cha1r.nan
1/..(
Y ~ .)1';( ('~///-
, .~.../
-' ~- - - ~- r
_ /;::;;Z?/"'. - ..--;;;? .
J -
(or
...... ...0 .
f': ...;. ~
j-'
1.1.1 (' ~ ._.
(").,,
li'(-
cSt.
r-.~.~. ~:
[i'!'-
~ ~;~
l'_ r.... ~:J
<.) 0' U
We. th~ undersigned arbitrators, having been duly appointed and sworn
affirmedi, lllake tbe following award:
(Note: If damages for delay are awarded, they shall be
separately stated.)
: j '~I
AWARD
P, -v d
(; F 1) t' fe,,, J .\,01
A,'" "
5,.)
FA. Ul',,"
AC,/\i,;,<-,T
PLA ..\1 ~cI~ F"
<;-1 %
Ii"
/.>,1"/ '\
fl.... 1-
f' L,'\. '''; ~if ,:
{, Iv
r V.vfl:.'IH, ,.,.: 7
N..!; L I >-e,vc ("
t.3 -( c. C'-f:'d So
, ~
Ib ~I . ,
applicable. )
. Arbitrator. dissen~~~t ~ame i:
\ /,C:J Chair.nan
,A', r;! rJ7-'/t't"'t't!!t'u____
...;::~~6
NOTICE OF ENTRY O~' AWARD
(~,- ,..,,)
/I/:>C/11
UIH I q 7
Date of Hearing:
.1:..........
F'-
Date of Award:
'tJ.,..
lfow. the :)0' day of ~r\,,'......h,l4:'- ,19.11..... atJ6:'I6, .t!..:t., the above
award was entered upon the docket and notice :hereof given by mail to the
?arties or thei: attorneys.
Arbitrators' compensation to be
paid UpOI1 appeal:
roc
$ .~qo,
;:;j~"...~.--.:I..I,. ".c_~ c!'. L,-'L" (,1..( "-
Prothonotary
"
~,h,J,.\ ((, '1l"'f' \
o Deput:,
3y:
.---....
Y4l~~/'~!. (d~1j,L SS"i/ 120- '1'~' 'ltd.1o
~, ; I . ( 1..-"......- l.,
t./ ..J~t. ' .~....,{.. ,_.:J'~L"', ..>k.-;f I ,n..l__''-.
'j ) f'
J.......<.(,t..._r~(.....~ JAh.J\(..hA..... ',-..J/U...
5
r
!
:::
--
11
<'J
A..:;-
. ..,)
~,