HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-04363
I,
,I
'.
, i
ii
, I
,J
, :,:'If/
!-i,I.
,j.;'.......r
~.~it.
~ \ l!li;
!',t(j
,,,J
\'If I
t_!;
'lIe'i
I, 'f'
1",1:;:
.'
Fr"
,.If!,
'II j
11/:,1 :'
','li,l!t
'I ,,'1/
,{' .
.j'.I!
I' ,
, I
Ii "I ,
,,) 1'1
, 'I'"'
( ~'l
'~,: ..,"Ii'
. ",~;,
, If;!
\!'".+
.. :~,
I" \ 'Ii,
'"
j," I,'
, (I
dil
d 1,
l'-~fl
)\
,."
"
-I
, ,
,
",
',I
, )
./
I'
'.
~.
cj
"
I",
t,
\' "':-I';il~~'
".--'
,/.1"
(."j")
( "hi,)!,
"1,,1,'"
"
" ,
,~
....9
r<)
-=:r
"
, .'
"
,
LO
cr
"',;','
(/
,'I"
, "
~-..~
..f".j
..':-'
....
\ J
':~
"q"j,-';
DOUGL.AS. DOUGL.AS & DOUGL.AS
ATrORNEVI5 AT LAW
OJ"! W I-lI(Hi \innEr
,"", (), ao)o; ~ef
WII.t.IAM II' OOUOL...I H
01.011I01 ~. eOUal.AS, OJ
CAR~IS~E, PENNSYLVANIA
1701.1-02151
01011I01 ,. COlJQl.Al, ..11'.
I.I.~I..'
...~.o ACMITTIP TO
"""CflCI IN 'LO"'''.
17171 ,,4.1.1 ".0
'A.K (717114.1....1
October 7,1996
The Honorable Harold E. Sheely
President Judge
Cumberland County Courthouse
One Courthouse Square
Carlisle, Pa. 17013
Re: No. 95 . 4363 Civil Term
Bailey v, Jenkins
Dear Judge Sheely:
I will not be presenting any testimony as to our claim for uninsured
motorist payments in this case in the amount of $950,00.
I am agreeable to reducing our claim by $950,00. The award of
arbitrators was in the amount of $6,254.36, which will now be reduced to
$5,304.36,
Respectfully,
!jJJ,JS'\}"- /-
IN\
--'
GFD,II1:jml
CC: David C. Jenkins
402 Anglesey Terrace East
West Chester, Pa. 19380
'C(..'I'IIO AS .... ~T\ll" fIIt1AL AO'llOCA11 BV THI NATIONAl. '0"''''0 01' ""IAI. "'OVOCACV
) ~- 1--( Ai f) It- (?~O
lid 1./ S,.eec t ~
p.f 1.( If1 J'-- .
/
(M ~9 S(t.{~--,
1\.. Jl'-
'Lf L{ 1/r ~b -(~ :'
L (V ,eJ cJ -fJ.,(.,.j ':
f~ 'f / 3 6'
JC~
_A A~j' r rw~ rG 3 .0 !?wr:J
-; 1'+-. Il.NC, ~ n (Jf- ) 6 -
D~-2 rt.J,~ .
St~ -FO-"-./~~
qra(~
~~!3c1 T--...N -h/G
LA v0-J. t ~ vvvI'( (, /f'f?
J~ L C{)/~ C{11----eC.C~
/~<!-( ( L-IIJ ~
,I I~ --PC~ "k{UAA ~
cPt-~ ~ .s d ~ u
/ r L-v.-rt<v F J ~ - -u ~ l.v..r jA//1.-~
I r - ~-C-YpV...-r-- 7 i'7 .0 y
1er. s ~/
CfJd5J ~
--
--
L(L{
V7 '>5. CJ 7
2~C(...l
LI-:zItr I. J/7- -
\
......, .
I f{_) - P/fcl - H
~ A~TG~ ~
RTI( ~r
"t.J It~ '\ L * ~ u-/-r( /-) ~
~c"'~ c~ ~ r:-.. f~tl/~
He ! I---vr 13~ t:L/~ )
F( ~ to.. ;t.-I Ny
lie J!.Jpf(/ .
0-c-0
suM rf! If
"nu ~ CA.~1l (/tt6(.5:r~
/.PtkJ /-..- \ 1,4(0,
~ l'p~ t=- .A.(M~ -kv/q
~(.A@tt/0~ -
I~ vu;~ ~(/C~MJ"(),_-:-
-'
(tvy(' M--
A/vv\ '- v---- or- A../---'
<i I./--J c\.' 4 y -- . _ - fA fA; lA. "
I Ie ~ Iv .. if ( v. ~ "'-f ,-- /~l.JJ f'I " ,
I '....__
""" --.
kl<
'.
JOHN M. BAILEY,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
v.
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
DA VID C. JENKINS,
Defendant
NO. 95 - 4363 CIVIL TERM
V.
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, :
SR.,
Additional Defendant :
PLAINTIFF'S PRE.TRIAL MEMORANDUM
1. A statement of the basic facts as to liability:
On February 4, 1995, at approximately 6:55 P.M., the plaintiff, John A.
Bailey, was operating a 1994 Hyundai Elantra in a southbound direction on
Interstate 81 in Middlesex Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
Mr. Bailey and his wife, Linda, noticed that a one-vehicle accident had
recently occurred on the said southbound Interstate 81, and the victim was in
need of assistance. In addihon, the victim's vehicle was blocking the left-
hand lane of travel. The accident victim is now the additional defendant in
the instant case, Samuel A. Gardner, Sr.
As Mr. and Mrs. Bailey provided assistance to Mr. Gardner, and placed
flares along the roadway, several vehicles passed by the accident scene. Then
the defendant, David C. Jenkins, approached the accident scene traveling in
excess of the posted speed limit, and in the left-hand lane of travel. The
defendant lost control of his 1989 Hyundai Sonata and collided with the rear
end of the Bailey Hyundai Elantra.
The suit was brought in Cumberland County as the accident took place
in Middlesex Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
A companion case was filed at 96-2433 Civil Term, in which David C.
Jenkins filed suit against John M. Bailey and Samuel A. Gardner, Sr. That
case was decided by the Bmud of Arbitrators in favor of the defendants. That
suit has not been appealed, and, therefore, the defendant is estopped from
asserting any contributory nl'gligence on the part of John M. Bailey and
Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., due to res judic.lta. A copy of that decision is attached
hereto, marked Exhibit U AU.
7. :;l:~t1ement:
Despite a request from the plaintiff, the defendant, David C. Jenkins,
has not made an offer.
Respectfully submitted,
DOUGLAS, DOUGLAS & DOUGLAS
Dated: September 26,1996
ByJJ;~rp.- {'. ~ ~
George F. Douglas, III, Esquire
Atty. I,D. #61886
27 West High Street
P.O. Box 261
Carlisle, Pa. 17013
717-243-1790
Attorney for Plaintiff
JUN ? (I '~)96
DAVID C. JENKINS,
PlalnUrt
VI.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO: 96.2433
JOHN M. BAILEY,
Defendant
VI.
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR.,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
.QAllf
We do solemnly swear (or affirm) that we will Support. obey and defend the Constitution of the
United States and the Constitution of this Commonwealth and that we will discharge the duties of Our
office with fidelity.
AWARD
We. the undersigned arbitrawrs, having been dulV appointed and sworn (or affirmed). make the
following award:
IN",,. ",/""'''1''1'", ""'''~ J" 'I'II.JI,""', tI"Y.",,1I
II' '~I",..,"'v """I
,
-1\i~+...,.~ hI ft--\..b_-~ ~1.~-('ttL(:(HLt-:>.
-------
II
Arbitrator, dissents. 1/11"'" nUII,-" '/"II/" ,dd,',
Date uf Hearing: --..!l:jL?JU-r _____..
Dale 01 Award: --WJ/L-----
(
..-'
)
-
S. W,II,ton i.a.'\l;....r:......EsCJw'e
-t~....", .. 'r-
--_d~~~d!~~,__..
Ph.,I,~~~~"II.. E~""E--
GOLDBIRG, KATZMAN. SHIPMAN, P.C.
Thomaa I. ~renner, Esquire - IDI32085
Draw P. Gannon, Eaquire - 10174680
Attorneya for Additional Defendant
3201 Market Street
Strawberry Square
P.O. Box .1268
Harriaburg, PA 17108-1268
(717) 234-4161
COf>Y
JOHN M. BAILEY,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
VB.
DAVID C. JENKINS,
Defendant
NO. 95-4363
VB.
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR.,
Additional Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
*************************************************************......
DAVID C. JENKINS,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
vs.
JOHN M. BAILEY,
Defendant
NO. 96-2433
and
SAMUBL A. GARDNER, SR.,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
STIPULATION OF COUNSBL TO CONBOLIDATB
t.JL~VB-=_~mOJlJ<!LJtAU'.IlRB FQB. ARBITRATION
,
John M. Bailey, by and through his counsel George F. Douglas,
.
III, Esquire, Samuel A. Gardner, Jr., by and through his counsel
Drew P. Gannon, Esquire, and David C. Jenkins, pro se, hereby agree
and stipulate as follows:
L I. t;, l.d 'i:f'
.... ---~_.-.-_.__.
-~....
7. The parties hereby agree and stipulate, pending approval
by the Board of Arbitrators, that both actions may be resolved at
the arbitration hearing scheduled for June 17, 1996.
Respectfully submittad,
GOLDBERG, KATZMAN & SHIPMAN, P.C.
/. ;//
fJ I"
By: ,/~ "I,' ,.....J4...,1..4'9\
Dr w P. Gannon, Esqu ro
Attorney I.D. #74680
320E Market street
P.O. Box 1268
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1268
(717) 234-4161
Attorneys for Defendant Gardner
,... 'i1
By: ~
George F. Douglas, III, Esqu re
DOUGLAS, DOUGLAS , DOUGLAS
27 West High Street
P.O. Box 261
Carlisle, PA 17013
Attorney for John M. Bailey
B~ (~ .\\
Dav d C. Jenk ns, ro Se
50 East High Stree
Carlisla, fA 17013
~--
Date: '_/">--1'
.
GOLDIIRO, KATIMAN , SHIPMAN, P.C.
Thomaa I. Brenner, Zaquire - 10#32085
Drew P. Gannon, Eaquire - 10#74680
Attorney. for Additional Defendant
3201 Hark.t Street
Strawberry Square
P.O. Box 1268
Harriaburg, PA 17108-1268
(717) 234-4161
JOHN M. BAILEY,
Plaintiff
COf'Y
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
VB.
DAVID C. JmNKINS,
Defendant
NO. 95-4363
va.
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR.,
Additional Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
..................................................................*
DAVID C. JENKINS,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
vs.
JOHN M. BAILEY,
Defendant
NO. 96-2433
and
SAMUIL A. GARDNER, SR.,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
STIPULATION or COUNSIL TO CONSOLIDATI
7B1 ABOV~-CAPTIONED MATTERS rOR A~BITRATION
,
John M. Bailey, by and through his counsel George F. Douglas,
.
III, Esquire, Samuel A. Gardner, Jr., by and through his counsel
Dr..... P. Gannon, Esquire, and David C. Jenkins, pro s., h.reby agr..
and stipulate as tollo....s:
1. John M. Bailey tiled a Complaint in Cumberland County
against David C. Jenkins on or about August 18, 1995, in a matter
docketed at 95-4363.
2. David C. Jenkins then filed a Complaint against
Additional Defendant Samuel Gardner on or about November 6, 1995.
3. The matter dockoted at No. 95-4363 was listed tor
arbitration, and on April 1, 1996 James D. Flower, Esquire,
Chairman of the Board ot Arbitrators, scheduled the arbitration tor
Monday, June 17, 1996 at 1:30 p.m.
4. On or about April 30, 1996, David C. Jenkins instituted
a separate action in Cumberland County docketed at No. 96-2433,
saeking to recover damages sustained to his vehicle in the accident
which gave rise to the initial Complaint in this matter docketed at
No. 95-4363.
5. In that subsequent Compl.aint, Mr. Jenkins named John
, Bailey and Samuel Gardner as Defendants.
6. Because the substance ot the two action. i. the same, the
partie. hereby agre~ and stipulate to consolidate both action. for
arbitration.
-'
.-.....
7. The partie. hereby agree and stipulete, pending approval
by the Board of Arbitrators, that both actions may be resolved at
the arbitration hearing scheduled for June 17, 1996.
Respectfully submitted,
GOLDBERG, KATZMAN' SHIPMAN, P.C.
I
'f ;);
By: , /~ ...'~/ t;....s.,,149\
Dr w P. Gannon, Esqu re
Attorney I.D. #74680
320E Market Street
P.O. Box 1268
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1268
(717) 234-4U1
Attorneys tor Defendant Gardner
,...,
. By: l--.
George F. Douglas, III, Esqu re
DOCOLA', DOCGLA' , DOCOLA'
27 West High Street
P.O. Box 261
Carlisle, PA 17013
Attorney tor John M. Bailey
.l,~~"",\ \
By: \/~. . ....-
av C. Jenkins, ro Se
50 East High stree
carlisle, fA 17013
Oat.: ':"/3-,/'
. '
I ~}\:
. , .
I' "
, ~I
t " If
\V I
II
,
._--~--_..._-.....----_. .
,...'-.... ' . (
....___ . . " -. 'r
\
.f
., r
' I
; "
!
L
I
r ,
Ir I
' I
, I ,
/ .I
I
!t1f
l
. I ~ . .. ~ "I ',: .
~
~iN
~ -<t-. ',~ '/~ '.~,tf't .'t~ -;
( I
". L
~,~'
'~.
;~..,.
."
T.
i)
,
I
,
. "
, I
".
01,
'~.'
I
JOHN M. BAILEY,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT or COMMON PLIAS or
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V.
DAVID C. JINKINS,
Defendant
V.
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR., CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Addt'l. Defendant NO. 95-4363 CIVIL TERM
IN RE: PRETRIAL CONFERENC~
At a pretrial conference held Friday, October 4, 1996,
before Honorable Harold E. Sheely, President Judge, present for
the Plaintiff, John M. Bailey, was George F. Douglas, III,
Esquire. The Defendant, David C. Jenkins, appeared on hia own
behalf, and he is not represented by counsel. The additional
Defendant, Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., was represented by Karen S.
reuchtenberger, Esquire.
A trial date has already been set for this case for
Monday, October 14, 1996, at 1:30 p.m. By agreement of David
Jenkins, the claim against Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., has been
withdrawn, and he is not required to appear for trial either
personally or by counsel.
The claim of the Plaintiff against David Jenkins is
solsly for the property damage to hj,s car, which they allege
amounted to $4,491.36. The Plaintiff alao claims a loss ot
$350.00 deductible coverage and a loss ot $950.00 in uninsured
.otorists coverage.
I am not really sure how the uninsured motorist
cov.rag. b.come. a claim in this lawsuit, and I would request
further clarification on that issue trom counsel for the
Plaintiff. In addition, Plaintiff also claims car rental cost.
in the amount of $563.00.
The Detendant would not agree to stipulate to any
matter.; therefore, the Plaintiff will be required to present
te.timony at trial to sustain the claim for the property damage.
to his vehicle as well as testimony concerning the car rental
costs.
The witnesses on behalf of the Plaintiff are set forth
in the pretrial memorandum; however, with the release of Samuel
A. Gardner, Sr., as an additional Defendant, it was not certain
at this time whether Plaintiff would be calling him aa a witness
in the trial.
In a previous case before the Board of Arbitrators in
wbich David Jenkins was the Plaintiff and John Bailey and Samuel
A. Gardner, Sr., were the Defendants, the arbitrators found no
liability on the part of the Defendants in that case, so,
therefore, there is no claim or counterclaim or other matter
inVOlving David Jenkins as the Plaintiff in this case.
Defendant Jenkins has indicated that he int.nds to
call a Penn.ylvania Stat. Police Trooper, Christopher E. Smith,
a. a witn.... He also listed a lady by the name of Emily Ladino
a. a witn....
, , I
,I
~..)
-, I
t ~ , I
,I
".. I
.,
,
~" "
I
, I "
,
.. I
:,,1 1
, .. ,
,,'
..
JIdt:~
~
Cell ..Dlal
LICENSEE
For worldwide reservations
conlact your travel consultant
or call
HOD-FOR-CARS'.
(1-8~.~6~.11~Fl'
9 I I IA 91UYffi
31040 ,I
CAllLlSI.5
1702 HARRISBURG PIKE
CARLISLE, PA 17013
(71 n 243-1l105
PLAINTIFF'S
I ~HIBIT
10'14,<1(., F"I-I
NLAl P.PERCEH1AGE DeDA Il y
~D IJNDER ~I;[ BRIVEII---
"
Illnderd
Rul.1
Aarllm.n,
Sr.l.m.nl
Ariiin.~' 1
V.hltlt No
Si~""iViiiIC:II lUll"
n::.: 02/1J~95
l-~ JChchX I
---! I I I
ur- I . I I
..' I. ,. ~.l I
AlnllnaCIt)
nllll " MIIIIQt
..
__.__ Owning C~__.._"___o--.. ._ RICIIY C?!1.._..__.
TIme I Mll4lgt Gal
..
POW IAfllJrn'" ---...- ~--~_.-_...
9'"
-1
---
=. ~J ~.
,1:) t
I I
I I I
'-'~-
~).t... :
_ I I L
dl@ :
Tlla""
i.- Depollt
(
'(I)'''''
flllUtnlflylf
Numlllr
_1lIo
N,""
MIIC.
Nnl. ,*'d or ....'d
I~'''''--'
1'1)",,""""",
MlIi.---
Ilon"
CI~
I
I I I I I I t
_~!~~'
~~==r::~~~=
Compen, Name
..J...
A_
~l.iV
~
~Lktn."':.--
IIlIIN IlARI\!,1ly ,
[ARUIL[
r-
91"
AddMlonIlll1iOrmlii(j;."----.-------
il,r'Jlllnq lharql applies If or " r.'.ur".d .,lh
.ddIlionIIlII.... (Aenttr'. Inll&lll II nonl) - I PtIont
....... '''L.~'Il'II"L JRl"lr CIIV ---..---....
_______ '. AJD/It ,j)A'LLLV
~". lIun.. No I
f;~tn-'~P' --- --]O"-of lJktit-~-..-.-Tw~IJ~~t
5'+ 3c .:~3.l. O'+cc c~ 18
J'otq~ O"i.."'9~
II" U nu
;rSCI[ COU~CIL ~,
.
'MU
f
o Me
. VISA
.
oc
,
. os
I
.
.
,
I
I iJ
I
1\/1'111111 1001 Ii'lQ,1M')l)O
,
00<0 lID
. nlllll\r rUlul~~'jll~lrV~I""llrt'"(Jr It1i11
..
I
1
-..
forlhll Illinlmu
tlllllllllUllbl
mln,
Vt/'llcltlnl.lll
.........
==-'"
100% OF LOSS
z",
.._ Domooo A--"""
~-........, .
$0
Zlo
.... M
-...,
:iiMI"1
"-
0..
......
,.-li""
s
.IIow flllt NUM
.1 eorr.,,*,.
8768748 8
v~-~6-&'fJe&----
Numbtt
----~L 1241
.n..--PeN'f-.
_No
""lI
City
..
'.,
...
03/02195 10 I 0
OiiidlIiMI5ii-u.---
me
Uood
~'/9!i 161:':
23 Days 18 t1
.-2
"'5
-"
0.,0
...
...!l-
HII
IIuI) T oteI
"'5
TItIo....
-
..........
"'5
""5 .'
-
XXX
1t75,
s...,,- 2.0.
AI"'" 6.0001
ke... ,.."..2.00 D
io
01
un 3.00
$3.00
..
v.......
.......
CIOII
Codoctod
IIoIDuI
TIIltAy
Che';' .u:'~
RENTAL OFFICI
.
:1: ':1 ::.:
1;,11'
P rrlt L ,,' il.: ~ti ::~ ;;
. "
. .
.hm FARM MUTUAl. iHtil,.ktl''f
:t, LlllEmN ~OAD NE~ ,:IIMOERL,NO, fo,l :~';;'J
-:',':7:' nt'KG:
'J.
~ '.1
" .
f,j MI'l ,;umroNs nE'iAROrNl, fH" emMiHF. FLEASE ':ONfAI:r filE
rilOI':"TE~ ,:LIIIM3 HANDLER .... ............. ......._........._
0..." Ammd s~: ,JANIE.. ':OONS JI1'I1TJJ
.'
~ :-: .
PLAlNTIPII'a
IXHlalT
..:3
1001
'...~ .
.. ~ ~ ...
I
TIP' 01 Lou: ,ollt.lon (Sp,ci
D.~e 01 L...: ~2/0\,JC
Oedl,ctibl.: "iJ.~O
[""r.d: JOHN M I WOIl 6AlLi:!
Addrm: Ij1 AMI 0, ';ARLl3LE Pk IT'llS.Sea,
Ho.. Fhon.: (71T) JIJ-5S3~
':i-' .
~ '. .
,...,; ..
a:J ':
- :
:; -:
~ ~~ :~
.~
Hltch.ll Ser"I".: JIaTZI
Oe,eriptlon: IS94 H1UNOAl ELANTRA 10 SEOAN
VIN: KMHJfl1M6RU59199T
Llcen..: NAp.16T PA
Mil.as,: 11,115
OWALT: A
--.
,~ .
II'~,:
Scarch I;ode: /)AUP
Lln. Entry Labor Line It.. Part Typ./ 00 II " Lauor
ilia !llI!m. Iw- Omatlon Oeecription wt Nuober WYnL llni1.
1 9UOSOO FRAME'AOO'L LABOR OPR'UNIBD01iFiAtIE INCLUDES SET.UP SU9LET Z06,00'
, 900500 ffiECH 'AOO'L LA90R OPR.REAR SUSPENSION ALIGNMENT SUBLET 35.00'
.
1 900500 MEeH 'AOO'L LABOR OPR'SET FRONT SUSPENSION TOE.IN SUBLET 0.6'
4 900500 900Y 'AOO'L LA91ltl OPR.RUST COAT ..QUAL REPL PART 15.00' 0,5'
5 90\930 BODY REMOVE/REPLACE WNEEL QUAL RECYCkEO PART 35.00- 0.3
S AUTO mIN REFrNlSH WHEEL 0.5
. LINE MARKUP 125,00 9.75
,
a RIGHT ~AR
9 S00500 9001 -REMOVE/REPLACE .\IAL'lE STEM --QUAL REPL PART 1.50'
10 S00500 BODY 'AOO'L LA90R OPR'SP rN BALHNeE Rr,HT REAR ,HEEL mSrINS 0.4'
11 800146 BODY REIIiIU(,'R!I'lACE WH!:EL COUER 52860-,9110 37.12 0.1
U R r'ill! HE"R
IJ 100500 BOOl 'REIIiIUE/REPL..E 'WHT REAR nRE "QUAL REPL PART 56.00'
II 9ETTERMENT - P R I'iHT REAR nRE llO, ,JO 5.S.
15 815\SO BOOl REIIOVEiREPLAI,E R FRT DOOR REAR VrE~ MIRROR 07606-:S1<H 119.JS Il.3
IS ,lUTO REFIN RmNISH R FRT OOOR ~liROR C 11.+
I: 31;1180 BOOY AU,iN ., lE,!R DOOR ~IIELL l,U.
13 a2')891) BOO/ mArR .ReOF PANEL 5,1)'
lJ .lUro REFrN .~CFW:SII ROOF P~N[L ': 1.9
:'i l::3,1) BODY REIIOI". iEPI.,KE ~ 'lUHRiER GUTER PANEL mo. .:allliJ :S6,:8 is,I) ~
~l ,uTO ACFrNmr:nSIl R ~UARfER PANEL OUTS:OE " L.7
.
,.. ,UTO REnH REFiNISH R PANEL EOI;, ').9
..
ZJ AUTO RmH REFrNr~H R LOCK PrLLHR ': 0.5
2'~ 822160 900Y REPA!R 'L ~URRrER OUiF.R PANEL I.N
,< AUTI] REF!N mrN!SN L CUARiER PANEL OUTS rOE c L.7
...
:6 8,1480 BODY REMOUERF.PL.''-F. R QI:AP rER F~JEL OCCR mllHilOOI) 1:.93 INCL
.' AUTO REF!~ ~EFINrSH R FIIEL OOCR C ;J,3
.'
'19 5::5111 BOOY REIIINE,iF.PL,leE ~UAR iF.~ PUEL OOOR lELEHSE ':HBL., mso.2S001) ]7..2 0,9
~
..:::; .
~, .'
.~ :2
;j .~
':;':I;J ~
"'17= ;;..
;;~ -
i:,../l ~
ilOi ~
~Q ""
t~:t f
::'\];
~.~~
::" ~
r..) .
.~~"'i ;:
',:.. ..
~:] ~
'= ':'I: ~
;~ ~ !7
~
11,.it
-.
- - -
,
.,':.. .
~~ j -
.. ,-
..
., .
-,.,.-.:
2-
"
E3TlMA f! R(':ALL !lUMBER: n,07i15 ll::~::).I 19-7110-:::0 l
MI"ch~!I OJ"J ')"'10.: f,BJ'.11 I:JP''',gM i,;; IS~O, ~1'ch,!I [",,,,,,,on.1
~H ~qh~'l ~l!!1l!r',1111
PIg. I 0' J
.' -
.:s,
~ 'i.
'-:I .
~;; ,~
:S~l! ~
~ ~-:
)I .~
1 ;
\'< .'\
~. -.
'~.'.., ;1. ~E:~':;F. ~fi:.I,'J i'~:~~ ',if" 1:'.ll'" I .~!. :jt ":
;1: ::1 ~OO ( ~tFH:~ .~ 'Jt;t~~ rfj :llhE~ ,tHHF'..
;fFr~1 q~Jr:IDj;~FFjl'~' ~ 'Jt;I~~rf~ INNER ~lillL
,: :':~"': ~'a' .)E~C':E ~tFI.~I:E ~ ilIJ~HE~ 'iE~n ~~ tL~~
~;:~I.:: ~I:lj'l ~t~a'.E,'~E~L,,;.i ~ ~~llrF., ~Er,dllt,
;.. .l.::C':'; ~GO'f ~EM!IE..PlPI,~(E Ii ~1:HRrE~ ~tjl~
:~ ~::r:~I) BI.C ~ ~t~V:t ~H~~(F. I.IJI,'itll,E Lie rHllt:,
:~ ,01;:) <E,IN IErrNI:N LI),I;,1I,E LtO l~umCE
;i WQ REFlN REFINISh LU';I;H.E LtO UNOEiSlcE
;5 UhE N,"~UP l:~ ,II~
13 e:'~oll ecoy 'L!,,/I 'R L'JSI;~';E L!O HINr.E
~.) e:'!6lij a.IQ'( ~L[~ti ilL ~1;til;~1~E lee HIW;E
+~ ~Z3c~li ecoy ~~:~l,!f.'REFl~fE L'j'iC~~E LrC wttlTI'ER:.qF
I; ,r,~lEe 800'( RENOVr.REPLAr:E NEAR 800'( PANEL
,1 Auro REFIN REFINISN REHR 500Y PANEL
.. AUTO RmN iEFlIIlSJi ADO FOR INSIDE
,~ eOO11J 800! REPAIR .REAR BODY FLOOP FAN
'0 HUTO PEFIN PEFINlSJi ~EAR CO"PART"ENT FLOOR
.i 800378 BOO! RENOVE/REPLACE R REAR BODY TRIN PANEL
18 80018Z BOOY RE~UE/PEPLACE R REAR BODY CONPARTNENT TRI"
-9 800191 BOO! RE~VE/REPLACE R CONSINATION LANP ASSEN2LV
50 826330 800! RE~E/REPLACE ,EAR 8UlfER COUER
51 AUTO 'EFIN REFINISH REllR r:O'iER
~: 8zmo 800Y REIl()VEIIEPLACE REAR 8Ullf'CR COVER I1lCG
~J 826m 900! RE~lVE/'EPL~CE R REA' BU"PER IIOUNTlNG 6RACKET
" 8:61\1) 800! REIIOVE/REPLACE REAR 9UI1fCR FILLER TO dUNPER
55 AUTO REFlN REFINISN REAR L~R FILLER PANEL
56 AUTO IEFIN ilOO'L LA80R OPR CLEAI CCAT
57 936001 AOO'L C08T TOl/lNG
59 AUTO ~O'L I,OST PAI~T ~ATERrALS
. Ju.Jg..nt rt..
~ L!bor Nota AppU..
C Incll)~otl '" Cl." Co.t Calc
" ,~ n~ ! , 'I l" . " ': 'f. ~
'..jUI
r I-')r L I ~ ;u, , ~': tI
" ~, ::1: <: :,1. e
",'1
..'j-
~ ..:..
j~~ L'j. ~t~:,ill; :. ~,} U~:~ ~
Jri8::IJ~ = 1 Jt,l) 1.tM
~=~'n-')'~l'~ tl..tu
ytjtL Rf.';-~I'.Lto ~~i 1~5 ,tll)' 1/.5"
C [,J
LL
31.15
Ii .Sl~
Q,~'~
8,'1Z1"=SI)!i: of 0,55 il.l
m,:o';I!lI)11 I,U5 ,,5 U
C 1.6
0.8
ljl:,O.~
1.0
8S7Eil-Z901)1)-AQ 18.31 lNCL
85i10-Z8COO-AQ 2Q.8Z 0,3
91\ON85~1) \5,5/ lNCL
8S6Ill-Z8051) 355.42 0.\
C ~.'t
96671-:8001) 13.'19 lNeL
866,:-Z80eO 33.75 1.2 tt
8665S-Z8000 68.11 0,1i ~
C 0,8
2,5'
65.00'
250,00,
~ j '~;
- -
,....:: -4
.,.... :-..
~,~ ~
~; ~.,
:.. .~
..:~ 'I
-.., >
'~ ~; ::
. j ~
"J ...
_ ':.: 0
'.~ ~ ~
-:: ':J
;: >
.,~ - :3
;::
-
(t,.-,:,
I'," ,
l;.:. I
:.....
!wm
4UALrTV RECYCLED DECK ltO CALL rO" AT HORTH I SOUTH AUTO PARTS
t-80Q-6SHHl
QUALITY RECVCLEO UHEEL CALL KE~lN AT AU"ILLERS WEST 918-.000
I, L.bor SubtOtl1,
8'd'l
i,/,,,,,
:ofech"nl~"l
!inil.l .h.l.2
J7.B :6.\)0
ZLS ~6.'11)
,),6 :6.1)1)
l,bar Subeot.l
llUor 11, l 6,1)01
,.IDor "...or:1 [1'111 53,3
Tc~!l!
88:",)
::9. )11
:5.~1)
L~:~ .111
3:..'t
~ I ti5.j. 3't
rr. Plrt !Opl'Cd.."e S"...r:,
r..aIlL4 P"rts
Parts tl~;\:,l'lItn':
:j,lh5 ra:, t 13,.)1),;
TiJ~al ~sF1JI:III1",''= jl~r~.' ~Iount:
Alltll..lnt
l,731.63
'..: .t~l;
LljtL~1
L,581: ,,)5
'.
. .
" ,: ~
mr~~" !(;"'lIliJN8Ei:)/, 0,,'95 l.::~:J~ JS-itW-;::Ol
~1:c~.ll O.t. 'J~r\1Jn: r'8.95-, ';'P!"I~ht <,;' 1590, Nltc~.l1 l,t.rno!lOMl
.11 il~llts R."r'lftll
,~ -:1
:'~ ;
;" ::.
"', ~ ;
..... -.,
Rt;.. "1
.;. -1.;:e
~ ~ .,
~..~ :.
,
,;.;:
1* : ,/ 1
'"
: ;.
- ,
"
'j
~
.
D.t" 0.'1,'9~ 02"3 P.N. !
,.11 10, 3B-711H2201 .::~;
Supplmnt, 002 IPI o.mm 021,2 P.N. ..
Proflll 10. 30 32 15 .
STATE FARN NUTUAL INSURANCE
115 LINEKILN ROAD NEW CUNBERLAND, PA 17070
17171 77H06l
FOR ANY QUESTIONS RESARDING THIS ESTINATE PLEAGE CONTACT THE
INDICATED ClAINS HANDlER ..__.......__..._._______.____.____
Ol.ag. AII.II.d B11 DANIEL COONS 3001733
Suppl,..nlld BYI DAN COONS3QO\733
T,p. 0' l0111 Colllllon (Sp.cl
0,1. of LOll. 02/04/'5
D.ducllbl.l 250.00
[nlur.d, JOHN N l llNDA BAILEY
Addr'III 1.3 ANY OR CARLISLE PA 17013-BBB.
HOI. Phon.l 17171 m-am
Nilch.11 Smlc" 'lB721
O.scrlpllon, 1"4 HYUNOAI ElANTRA 40 SEDAN
Y/Nl KNHJF22N6RU5BI'B7
llctnSlI NAP-267 PA
OWAlTl A
S.arch COdll OAUP
lln. Enlr, labor Un. II..
llu !IlI.IW. !xaL Ourallon Oncr lolion
I 900500 FRANEIADD'l lAIOR OPRIURltOOY(FRAftE INCLUDES SET-UP
2 '00500 NECH IADO'l lRIOlI OPRIREAR SU5l'ENBIOR A1I6NIllNT
3 '00500 NECH IADO'l lRIOR OfRISET FRONT SUSPENSION TOE-IN
4 900500 100Y IAQO'llAIOR OPRIRUBT COAT
5 lomo 10DY RlNOVE(REPlACE IlHEEl
6 AUTO REFIN REFINISH IlHt:El
1 lINE IlARKIJP 125.00
8 RIIlIT RlAll
, 900500 IDDY IRENOYE I REPLACE IYAL Yf STEN
10 '00500 IOOY IAOO'L lAIOR OPR'SPIN IAlANCE RIBHT REAR WHEEL
11 800 146 BODY REIIO'IE IREPlACE WHUl COYER
\2 RI8HT REAR
13 900500 BODY 'RlNOYE/REPlACE .RlIllT REAIl TIRE
1. tETTERNENT . P RI8HT REAR TIRE 110.00
15 800h7 100Y RlNOVE/REPlACE REAR CTR CONSOLE ASSY
16 '00500 FRANEIADO'llA80R OPRIPUlL REAR FLOOR PAN
17 B15490 80DY RENOYE/REPlACE R FRT DOOR REAIl VIEW NIRROR
lB AUTO REFIN REFINISH R FRT OOOR NIRROR
I' BI1I480 10DY AllSN .R REAR DOOR SHILL
20 820980 BODY REPAIR IROOF PAIllL
21 AUTO REFlN REFINISH ROOF PANEL
22 822060 80DY RENOVE/REPlACE lACK WINDOW NOUlDIN8
23 '00500 BODY IADO'l LABOR OPR'SOlINO DEPOENINI PADS
24 8223.0 BODY RENOY[/REPlACE R QUARTER OUTER PANEL
26 AUTO RlFIN REFINISH R QUARTER PRIllL OUT9lDE
26 AUTO REFlN REFINISH R PAIllL EDU
21 RUTO REFIN REFINISH R LOCK PILLAR
Plrl T1'.1
Pari NUlbtr
SUllET
SUBLET
SUllET
..QUAl REPl PAIlT
QUAL RECYCLED PART
I.QUAl REPL PART
msmB
52960-28\\0
"QUAL REPL PART
84670-2BI2Q-RQ
SU8lET
81606-28701
87130-28000
IlQUAl REPl PAIlT
1\604-28100
ISTINATE "CALL NURIER. 02/01"6 14.2,.3~ 31-7110.e2201
Rilch.1I Oa" ~,rsionl APR.96_R Copjfighl IC) 1990, Allc".11 Inltrnllional
All Righls R...rv.d
"klll,'1 \3,115
Dollar llbor
8IwL IIniL
206.001
36.00'
0.61
15.00' 0.51
35.00' 0.3
0.5
8.15
1. 50.
O.~.
37.12 0.1
5b.00'
6.'~
10UO' 0.3
60.00'
119096 0,3
C o.~
1.01
5.0'
C 2.'
22.62. I
25.001 0.5.
290.18 15.0 I
C 1.7
0.5
C 0.5
,.,. I If 3
. .
.. ,.
;.:,',
..,
'1" ..
'.
~\ ."
,.~ ,
..: :.
~.: '
- =
=.::
::i
:t:-
..,..
,,~
~~.
*f
~.~
>:1
--
<':;
1"f"'"
. "
r
~F
'i ..,i
o~:
~~~
::; ~.,
';rj~
A >~.
'-'
~ l~-;
if;
~'!.:.:
~~~
3q-
--'-11
~4~
~~i
_?i ...
;:....Jo
-~.
,~ 1 '!:l
~. ;
~~~
o~~
~~~
- - ,
a:3~
E;
.2 ;:
~;
. .
. -
~ -
rT~
,.
--
:<-
>'~
r"., :;
...~
~~
.....
"'I:
~,-..
,.-
:::=
,..
~.
...-
,,;:.
,.~
i!~
~!
II
t
I
. 0.111 o~mm 02142 P.". I~~J r
! " 101 38-1110-22201
Suppl..,nl. 002 IPI 04/1~/95 02142 P.M, .
Profll. 101 30 32 15 '~;:.: y.
p~) ;,~ I
18 8223'0 100 V REPAIR 'L QUARTER OUTER PANEL 1.5" "1Tjr.ill
~,!l ::
29 AUTO REFlH REFINISH L QUARTER PANEL OUTSIDE C 1.1 -,,.., (') I
'"':: -I :
30 822110 100 V RENOYE/REPLACE R QUARTER FUEL DOOR mlO-21000 12.93 INCL ~'('1 'tJo
31 AUTO REFlH REF INI SH R FUEL OOOR C 0.3 1 :::;: ;.::
.~ r; ';,0-
32 822620 10DV RENOYE/REPLACE QUARTER FUEL DOOR RELEASE CAlLE 11590-21000 31,B2 O.B .. c:
- D ~ I
-,-" ...
33 1226\0 BODV RE"OYE/REPLACE STRIPE TAPE FUEL LAIEL DECAL 3103B-21000 1.0' ,.0 a'
34 800333 10DV AEPAIR .R QUARTER INNER PANEL -S 6.0' ~5:c I
JjlJ N I
3' REFIN REFINISH/REPAIR R QUARTER INNER PANEL -5 1.0' m,.. .
m'1'J.... '
'0::0 -I
36 INCLUDES PULL :::1_ 0 i
mo Z
31 122110 IODY RENOYE /REPLACE R QUARTER VENT 6RILLE m 10-?6000 2.20 INCL , ~ 1J -t I
-..> 0 I
38 822800 60DY RENOYE/REPLACE R QUARTER RETAINER 98890-21000 1.86 ~~ :c
>"m
39 122620 10DV RENOVE/REPLACE R QUARTER BOll 12493-041\3 0.40 ~;!l "
123430 10DV REHOVE/REPLACE LU86ASE LID PANEL QUAL RECYCLED PART 200.00' 0.5' <"" l>
40 < -'
I..,.> ,:0 '
\1 AUTO REFtN REFINISH LUS6A6E LID OUTSIDE C 1.6 r-
42 AUTO REFIN REFINISH LU68A6E LID UNDER61DE 1.1
43 LINE ftARkUP 12'.00 50.00
4\ 823800 10DV ALIGN 'R LU68A8E LID HIN6E 0.'" Hp
4' 923810 BODV ALl611 'L LU68A8E LID HIN6E Mil 1'"
44 923850 10DV RENOVE/REPlACE LU68A6E LID WlATHERSTRIP 11321-28030 40.95 M ~~~~ I
47 100348 BODY REIlOVE/REPLACE REAR IDOY PANEL 69100-28100 149.35 UI
48 AUTO REFIN REFINISH REAR 100Y PANEL C :;''"
1.6 '.~
z. z
49 AUTO REFtN REFINISH ADD FOR 1N61DE O.B .Jj
~. :lit'
'0 800313 IDDY REPAIR 'REAII laDY FLOOR PAN 2.0" ih~ I
51 AUTO REF!N REFINISH REAR CORPARTRENT FLOOR 1.0 ~.~~ I
52 100318 lODV RENDYE/REPLACE R REAR IODY TRIN PANEL 85760-28000-AO 18.31 INCL
53 800382 laDY REHOYE/REPLACE R REAR BODY COftPARTNEHT TRIN 85140-28000-AO 20.B2 0.3 ~~~i I
'4 100391 IODY REHOYE(REPLACE R CORIINATION LA"' ASSENBLY 92402-28"0 4'.'2 INCL ~"!~
'5 824330 laDY REHOVE/REPlACE REAlI IlIIlPER COYER 16401-21050 3".42 0.4 . .,
,. AUTO REFIN REFINISH REAR COYER C 2.4 .. <1} z
i~;:;t
57 124310 100Y REROVE/REPLACE REAR IIJIlPER COYER 1IlD6 14611-26000 11.39 INCL ~~' z
c, ~....
" 824390 laDY RENOYE/REPLACE R REAR 8URfER ROUNTIN8 8RACKET 86m-26000 33. " 0.2 I ~~~o
" 924440 IOOV REHOYE/REPLACE REAR IUNPER FILLER TO BUNPER 14m-28000 68.11 0.6 I o.~;
~~"
40 AUTO REFtN RiFINISH RERR LNR FILLER PANEL C 0.9 -::' >
41 931084 laDY REROYi/RiPLACE 'IATTERY ..QUAL REPL PART '4.43' 0,2' i5;~ I
42 IfTTERNENT - P 8ATTERY 110.00 '.71
43 900'00 100Y .RENOYE/REPLACE .RT TAIL LANP NT IRACKET NEW 29.32' bi I
" '-UTa REFIN AID'L LAlOR CPR CLiAR COAT 2," ~~.
., 934001 AID'L COST TONIN8 163.00' ~2 ~ !
U AUTO AID'L COST PAINT NmRrALS .,0.00' :
. Il,dglllnl Ill.
I Llbor Noll Applin lEU'
I' . .
C InCludld in Clllr Co.l C.le l ~~i
WW >
-- ....
;:-:r: I
UolllTY ~ECVCLiD DECK LID CALL TON AT RORTH l SOUTH AUTO PARTS >:Q ~ i
-100-492-1413 ::j :;;
UHllry RECYCLED WHEEL CALL KiYI. AT AUNILLERS Wi9T 938-4000 ~",'~ I
l"'"Ic ....1
"'T1m :. I
>;: Z'
::... ~ r
;O:,'S
::=~ ~ I
~g 'J!i
3:- _
'JJ~ ......
m'" :>
~~ S
~! z,
"INATI RICALL NUNIIR. 0'/07/" 14124134 31-7110-22201 z.. d I
II'ft,11 0.1. YI"ilft' An. "_A COPy',gftl ICI 1990, N,lc~Ill 1~I.rn.lion.1 P.g, I" 3 .;r
,. m
.; "
All Righi. R,."v,d <; :.'
-:~ ~ :E
,
I, llbor Sublotlll
lody
R.fin~lh
HlCh.n!'11
Ylllli. -lili.
41.1 30.00
21.~ 30.00
".il 30.00
llbor Sublohl
llbor Tn i b.OOX
llbor SU..lry Tol.ll b3.9
Tohls
I,m.oo
m.oo
11.00
1,917.00
1I~.02
2,032.02
o.t.. 041141Y~ 0214, P.H.
,.1. 10, 31-7110-22,01
Suppl.un!. 002 IPI 04/14195
ProtH. 10. 30 32 I~
II. P.rt R.pl.,...n! SUI..ry
habl. P.rts
P.rll Adjult..nt
Sllu Tn i b.I)OX
Tot.1 R.pll'I..nt Plrts A.ounll
I. Tohl l.bor I
II. Tot.1 R.pllcl..nt P.rtll
Ill. Tot.1 Addition.l Coshl
Gron Tolill
2bl.71- N.I Tolil,
l.11 Pr.vioul N.I Tol.ll
N.I Suppl...nl A.ounl:
Poinl of I.p.,tl $ RI6HT REAR CORNER
lody SIIop' UNk
InlplCtion 51111 FIELD 2-A
IN COMPlTANCE WITH SECTION 1827 OF ACT b OF 19901
ANY PERSON WHO kNOWIN6lY ANO WITH INTENT TO INJURE OR OEFRAUo ANY
INSURER FILES AN APPLICATION OR ClAIH CONTAININ6 ANY FAl6E, INCOHPLETE
OR HISlEADIH6 INFORHATION SHALL, UPON CONVICTION, BE SUIJECT TO
IIlPRISllNIIENT FOR UP TO SEVEN YEARS AND PAYH€NT OF A FINE OF UP TO
m,ooo.
lit CAUTION tI.
FAILIIl8 TO PRESENT THIS ESTIHATE TO THE REPAIRIN6 6ARASE IEFORE REI
HAY RESULT IN ADDITIONAL EXPENSE TO YOU. ANY SUPPLEHENT TO THIS
ESTINATE NUST BE AUTHORIZED IY A STATE FARM ADJUSTER.
NOTICEI REPAIRS TO THIS VEHICLE HAY REQUIRE SPECIFIC WElDIN6
EQUIPHENT AS RECOHHENDEo IY THE HANUFACTURER.
IITIHATI RECall HURlER I 01(07/95 14,24,34 31-1110-11201
Rllch.1I DlI. Y.rtionl APR-'~.A Copyrlthl ICI 1990, Hilch.1I 1~I.r~.l\on.1
All RIghlt R.t,rv.4
Ill. Addilionll COlli
Tmbl. COltl
5.1.1 T.. i b.OOI
Nonliubl. COlh
Tolll Addlllon.l COils I
A.ounl
2~0.00
I~.OO
Ib3.00
m.oo
CUlto..r Allo.lnc.,
0.00
CUIIo..r R'lponlibil~IYI
A.ou~I
2,104.$0
~S.1~
129.60
2,293.05
2,032.02
2,293.0~
421.00
4,m.07
..
rJ}'. .
-~ .
. .
'~'A '/
~]r
",:12
-<,., ,..
I" ~.:
11m l>
~2 .::
1:....~
':"'';';
;J ,:~ ::
~2c
~;\~
:Xlm~
"'jj:
:JLc
"'oz
~:::J....
z>C
:;:H
~:ll"
:co>
<-
m>J:'
I'"
',491.36
4,391.9S") HI~
,.99.38 l- ~
C,' a~.~
~;~~
~)o )_
~2d
~H~
~rio(
neg
C;~i:;;
~Il :
413 .lJ.... ;A~~
J 0'.
99.}8.
787.03>
886.4\$
,.t. 3 If 3
LB
>
,,--
-<,- =
>':n1f,
<:
~lit
~"l~
'''If;~
.,,""..
>zz
~:il~
nil! ~
~d
i! ill'):
I!l
dl
- I
~
".,1 , "j II!
I:,: :1 '1111
'1"l'IlItlll' ""1 lIt
II II "t,' III: ,11 I,
. '
",'"
, .
.
.
,T,HI, 1',':,11 rllI""l 11I'.III;~'''.1
II" I ll-I'r Il.il I'll/Hi' ,,:. '1IIt'_I". 1111ll. PII : ,',
t't \ I "'j,;'
",' II. ,,",,11,)11', ~L"ijn~',I; fi'l, '.;.1:11111, f1,I,ij)ll'lltl~U I,I~.
',1I'i',riltO '.111111; lIijltloll.~...-"
~'J~.'.I. 110'."''''1 b," u,lIlH ruotl:; .,),)1:,1)
"IPII 1'.",,"t.,1 h'.oI ~ijlllIlIlN,!II')l ';, \
1:.'1'. 01. I... I
~4l' IJI \.1.1 ~ .,'
O.:Jln't..b 1.:1
lll''',1lf~,11
u,J,hlt'~~.1
HIJ_ "hulI\::
I, iJ 111.- i\J1I I ';jJ~' I
1..~,rN, 'jl,
I,.' Ill'
J"HN 11 .; IlltUIl "llI.l,
I...: HI11 uR (HiLI ,lE l'li l;u1.I'8ij~..
I Ili I L4~~QY ,'of
tIIl,hell \.rvl~.' '/191/1
U".ri~tl.1I1 m'l H,UHUill n_IHRIl..o SEOIlN
VIN' ~MHJF!lI1.M819a;
ll,en.,1 Hllp.loI PIl
OEM/ALT' H
S.~rch Cod,' OHUP
, '
'/
llll". t.ol/, lob" llA.ltl!lll
~ ~ hIlL UUt:ir..!ti'llI O~cr'Dt)On
I 1005uu fNNME'HDU l L.BuR OPR'UHIBOD1/fRIlME (HCLUOE, ,ET-UP
L I1Muu IIECH 'HOO L LilBuR OPR.REIlH SUSPlHSIOH HlIhHIIENl
.. YUU~;)U tlELK 'ROO'llABOR on-SET FROHT ,USPENSluH TOE'IN
ol 1uv,uo BOUl '.00 LL_aOR UP~'WUST COHT
, Qu..1,lj BOOf REtlOuE,REPLA(f mEl
o HUTO REIl" REf INISH WHEEl
LIHE tlHR~U~ .l~,uu
I R 1&"1 RERR
1'/0(.')') 8M 'WIUUEiRHlHI.E 'VolLUE mM
1'1 ?I)O~UU 800'( -AOO l lHBOR U1H.,PIN a_I.AHH NII;HI REIIR ~Hm
II uUlli~o BOD'( REtlOVEfREPlHtE WHEEl CUUER
,; Rl~Hr REIIR
lJ 'UO~')U BUO'j 'HEMOVEfRiPlHCE 'RI'HT REAR riRE
I. BETmllWT .. P NlhHT HERR T1hf.:I'UII
I' d,;'j,.; Buu; iEtIO''[/Nl/lll(E RENR m (UNSULE H'ii;
'. 1')O~;'N fRllilk-M,O I liEOR liPRoPOll RE~H flOl,R ;,11
l.' dl'olYI) BOD'I NEIIOI,E REPl~([ R FRr DuOR RENR 'IIlW MIRRllR
13 Iluro HUIN ,lflHliH R fRf OUOM tllRROH
I, ~I~old'i 8UOi 1l11.1l ,~ iEH~ OllilA IHElL
.'J J:'Ji3U BOO, RlI." -ROllf l,tHH
: 1 Hllro HEf IH kH INli. ROOf PHNEl
G1HoO bm RENu'/, m'illE 8illA WINDUW IlulllOli",
1UU5uu b.ul '_.0 l LHBuR OIR';OUNO OENOEHIIt. /_0';
:. dli'.u 1U0'/ MEM~Vi/Rm~(E R QIIHRTER UllTER PANEl
. mo mlN REflllli. R QUHRTER PHHEL UIlf\IUE
,~ ,luro m IN REHIU,H R PIlNEl EO.E
HIHII m IN m 1~liH R Lm PlllHR
P4r t IVpel
~,sr~ Nu.r
SUBlET
SUblET
SUBlET
"QUAL Rm P.RT
QUill REC1CLED PRRT
,'QUill REPl ~IlRr
[(I:,IIH&
~i1.I)-1H..U
..QIJ.L REPL PliNT
~"..";':31 !>I'HI)
;II~~(;
il,~ l)ll'l . =~,.Ili
~: L.'I}"~iJI_lhJ
"ijUIIL REPL PIINT
,'1 ~".' :3100
[t'll.; e'ltllldce h..J') bl:fR rlf~cdl';f1loJ'l!\J It',tl~.) .'JI"~itll.IUI)ll!lf'.
..
..
ilttlll MHall HUlIliRI v,iOi.1' 1.::.',1. ;~'/ll')'::;.'
""wI! O"t. V.lli.II' ilPM ,.., H C"~vri'll\t 1(1111'1. Ni,eh.11 lotundti""dl
.11 RI'lilt> R.,.,...,I
l..j I' I
',Ill
IN .1.1 '1.1, IIII
MII..g,' 1},175
Ou I 14r lab.,
H...llt lIllll_
lito.DI)'
J~,')u'
D.o'
15,00' u,5'
J5,110' D.'
U.S
8,75
1.51)-
li,4'
JI,11 I),l
501,00'
~,9ol
11)..,~u' I).)
oO.U'I'
1l9, ?, 1).1
C I), ~
1.0'
~i 1\ .
C ;,,"
Z:..l. I
IUu' .). ,.
,?0,18 l~,n .
C 1.1
11,5
( tJ.~
,.,!It 1.1 1
~.
~
",r
..r
>If
<.
VI"
.-. 'I:
~f; ,
"'l:
n~
)>'.
:nO .
l:"
,.,r
...",
:>or.
iCS:
~~
~~ :
, ~J:
z> .
..."
,."
~: .
-c .
;$i< :,
lo'
r
Hr
~~'"
~!":
~I!~ :
z ~ ~
;;l ..
~-r
~~:
~i~:
~"-
)Or-o;"
i~' -:
z o.
~i~'
Il . c
~' <; ~
.." Z =
~ -.
Il i~
,,:lI~~
" ..
o'll~~ :
... ."i
it. ~::
"_~ ".
IlIo, ,.
!~;
~ri ;
~l~
[E.
>
CD"" :
..r _
~~" ~
- .
.. ;:
...,.., :.
en l: -
'TIm '>
>z 2:
:n... .
K(I1 ~
~~ ~
is t
~L
~H
\l!..c
;!e
~< ~
...-
r-
.
......
J'
,
,
, 'I llll " II l~~"1
, Il,l " 1,'1 "I
q~I' ," ", ,1'11 11', H II llll " " ,.
, rJ'.- .,
, q " I.. " " ~,- "
;i'!1i;'
I ". 'I'~ 'J:
-. ~ ;Z
,,~
I, I, -I,.,,".'
... ~': ".
I'" ~ ,I : ' I.. I /111,1 .,.., "
;I"'" ...
I " ~ :::::-.~
!:./l ~
Ij: '.....;',,'.; " ~ I, ,:;. ~::J
~.. ..,
ql!..l ',L'I"" I lIt, ..>0 ::':
...-: :;:
.~ O,U' ~iif.
-'j I,U' ",IT>"
":lli:'
"'-
r-o :::
l:~ itl" ~:)IJI)IJ ~,'~ III(l . ~:o~
'I~:I'/I}'llflll'} 1.3. ZJlo '...
_" r
>",'"
I;.'} "j~I.,1 '),~Q ...,,-
-O~
U'I"l Wm,l' PMkJ 11\, ',U' 0.'" <<-
",>r
( U ...
1.1
JU5
aml-1WO
b11'1")-:atU'J
OJ.,
0,\"
0,4
4,\ ,
1.0
O,Q
/.Uti
loO
IUI INCl
20.82 U
41.52 INCl
m,42 0.4
C 2,4
18.J~ INCl
n,71 0,2'
68,11 0,6'
C 0,3
\4,4" 0.1'
5.77
29,32'
" '
.
.
40,n
149, j\
L
81/o')'18OUU .liQ
B\7.,O-Z8uOU-ilQ
n.oz.zmo
36bl)l- Z8U\U
360i l-28000
W4Z-Z300U
3oo\HBOuO
"UUSl ml PliRl
MU
lJ.
I6UO.
1\0,00'
r~i. t~II..\t h., ~ftll "'c~I,III.lfO .,t~ j ..Olrl'd pr.tilt,
11111111 "iLMlL "lII'I8IMI u"O;,lS 1'1';~I!~ )8'.'Il'I.l;;UI
"lh.1I a.l. u,,,,.ft' ,,'a.~, C.~"r."hIICI 1"'"). M,>.ch..11 l"te,~.II.~,,1
Itlt ~11'H'l Wp,;,rllltll
,)
"l,.'~' "I'H,' .[ ijUII~I[k OUIIW ,,,lllL
"..) III III ~'(I :111'.11 '. ~\JHlj'l:.~ ~'Il'llL 'HI'.dvl
, ~;)I) ~:U~ll ~tnllH "lIl.1~1. Ii "'\JHh'll~ ~fJll lJtllJh
""I nb iii HE'IIlI',11 II Ilkl Otlilli
,1.<1 t,U(11 kU'.lJI,ll nU'llhl UIJHkiLI( H,lkl UIIIJ~ WLL(It'il t.ltl<LI
,.....'1 C,)~I ktIIU',[I'EILIt',( ',Iklft IME rllEll,etl ~I":,II.
""I." bUUI kE~"lk .R UUHRIEN lI~hEk Pllm
'HIli W Illlill m,IR R QIJHNfER INHER ,"m
IMLlUUlS PULL
R QUHlirER uEhr .RilLi
It UUHHllH kEI"ltlEI
a QUHWTEH auu
lU'GA~E llO 'liHEL
lUGGMbE llO ourSIDE
LUGIi",E LID UHUEkllDE
LINE MHR~UP \,5.I)U
woo.) BOD! MUGH 'R LUGlim LID HINGE
umlll BOD I SWN 'l mGNIiE LID KIHliE
u;mo BOOI kEMOVElmlH([ LU"ilGE LID ~!ilIlIER~INlI'
uuu}.d BUIiI REMOuE/RHlM(E mR BUill 'IINEL
"UTU REfill aEflmH RENR BIiDI PliMEl
"U fO m 1M m IIU SK liDO fOR IHSIOE
,.llvi:5 ijOul RlPMIW 'RIMR buUl flOOR 1HM
HUIO H[fIH REflHISH RENR COMfMRTMEHT FLOOR
8')u3i8 BOOl REMOVEiREPlHEE R REBR BOOI TRIM PHIIEL
~OOJa; BOOI REMOuE/REPlHCE R REHR BOOl COIIPSRIM!NT TR 1M
&ou;91 BVUI REMOuE/REPlIILE R CDHiIMKTIOK lAMP NSSEN8lY
3;,;:") BOD! UMOuEiREPlIICE REAR BUMPER COVER
uUfO II[fIK NEflHhH mR COVER
8;0),'1) aWl REMOVE/REPlHCE Rm BUMPER COVER MlOb
~lbJ1Q aODY REMUUEIRErlN(( R RlAIl St:l'lER :10ij~1IH1i BR~CW
ai.b44>l 8001 UMOUE/REPtIlCE RE~R BUIlPER FIlLER TO BUMm
,tUIO REf I~ A(f lMIS" RENI lWR FilLER PAIUl
tJlud~ BuOI REMOVEI RUlAcE 'BilTTER't
BETTEkMEMI . P aHTIERt 110,uO
9iju~uO BUOI "ENOUE,REllR(E 'Rr f~ll lliMP NT BRIlC'ET
ilUTO REFl" HOOl l~aOR OPR ClEliR CO"I
1)G,,!1 NIiO 1 (U,( fOWIMIi
'turo IluU 1 (U~l r"IMT M,HiRi"l>
. Jlilhlt1leut {tl!!1
i' L.ttlM H'ltf ItOp I If :!I
l lod..,).,] ![. 1.1.,,, (Odt (die
;....., , U',O, Nl,ili"lE. Hf'Lol[
1.","'1 ~UUI HEMO'/E'ntl'lH';(
".;,,:.1 MY WIOVE/WWE
,;:;",,~ UUO\' MEMOUL Rmolt
"UIO HEr 1M REFINISH
MUI.) kEflM RiflKhM
'v
.,
10
I
'ij
"
~ij
"
"
""
.1
v;
05
.~
oj;
'I"
'l.U~
..,1, .l"'.,I.,, OtL' LlU I:HL, IUI1 III MORTH '. SUUTH IlUT<l W;',
1,,1i I):... ~ 'l'
ldl, fl[(mE~ iHEll (KLL HEIlltI Hf HUllIlLlR'i ww 9'H')ul)
"'JIP 1 ,f )
H~s
~ ~;.
o ~ ~~
~~.~
;\ ~~~
~ ~ ~e
~ ~t.
~....~ -=
J}"t,"i:
>>0 ~.;;
;!~...~
:; ~g-
~r -
<~~.
! nt-.
z ~-
~ t~
~~ "
;~~~
Z:-' 1>_
~ i3 -_
1\ ,2 ~ ~
~ ill~c
~",! ,
o ~~.
'" '"IS
- >.
~ ~~-
a 5~~
e'~
~~=
:/.,
_3~
ri,
>
".-
...'-
>~
~~
;;1~
..,,,,
]Oz
iiil
<"l,1l
;:~
i,1l
I!
~I
~>
'"
,
,. ...
'.
, .
..
.
.
. .
.
l,b"r "1111'.",. 11J.t.I.1~ _Jl.:1.!;'t _..l'JLJli
"v,p' -It 4 ,\1}, 1,1,1 l. :l.~ '''I
Ii ':' I' I 'II ~ II ~ I I, <II} , .)" 'I'I~, . f;l,
lb', 1',"11-.,11 '1,.) ,\",'.111 JIJ,IJI)
l.'IVIJt ';Ubl,IIt.JI I, Yl:, 1111
L.~'" r.. ~ o,Uij.. III,.':
l..tbUf )I'."fi'" rill,.,/, o>..~ LtJ.",l.l~i
Ill, 1,11'1I~111l1",1 LI,~t~
14loJult l.,:.t:.
')~lt., rtJ-" 1),1/'1..
HiJnl.1~4bl,! (.bb
I"t.i H~,I'lti.II.1 1:0>1>1
___JtiU.!JDt
,~Il, ':11)
l J . lll~
10.$,1")
.iIL')I)
_~:,.tl,.:1 II' II ,I, l t .1, H ,1
'Ill! :1 'III' ,:."
'1111,1~":1I1.1 "111 tl'l 'j~ IL'I~ 11'1~ ~ 11.
hilI "~ 1111 ;11 '\1 I
[I PilI. kr::'I,I'J.,t:I\It"d, )l11II1II.lr'l ._...JJf\!L!W.!
I Jllld~ Yilt. t,IIU,t,"
11,,, t. ~IJ I'I ,trut!h I -f..1 '.'1
,'.; ,.; f,j. ~ t), III!'; I:.. \,
r'I!..}IIIt;'vl~~t.IllI':'II~ PMt.~ HlIlJllntl :.l".'.,':
I. lut. I l4b.."
11. luloll ~t~14,",,,,,,,t P4' t,I
III. luldl ".1oI1 ""'"ul ,:.,,10'
/"';1.');
2.1i),01
~18,'I'i
bl'bl 101.11
..ll)',?
llJ"tiJ.' H Ilulll~uu:el
~,u~
~uslolll!r ~t;pu",ibilll"l
ioLiI. Htt 101011
le>l ~rto'O'IS Ilcl r.I.I'
Ntt S'J~~it~.t AlollAl'
4.m,98
}..~U5
. i81,Vl,/
'ui"l .f llpocl' 5 RI~KI RUI [OlKER
Kudv ,hup I UH~
I'''poctiu" "ltl FIELD 2-H
IN CUMPllANCE WllH SWIUN lau Of hef . Of 1 i'/ll ,
HHI PERSOH WHO KHaWINGll HMU Win (HIEHT 10 IHJUIlE O~ DEfNHUO AH'!
INIURER filES AH APPllemUN OR ClAI" CaNlItININ' AM'I FALSE. IN[UMPlETE
01 "ISllHOIN' INFOl"mON SHlill, UPUN CONVICTION, BE SUBJEO !Il
II1l'R1SDIftNI roR UP TO SEVEH YEARS AND PHYMENI OF A F [HE OF UP TO
115.~~O,
... [AUTlON ...
FRlllN' TO PRESEHT THIS ESTIMATE 10 IHE IEFHIRING GARHGE BEFURE REPHll
rul'( mUll IH ADOIIIONAl mEHSE 10 YOU, RN'! SUPPlEMENI 10 IHIS
ESIlMATE nuSl BE AUTHORIZEO Bi A SUTE FAIIl ROJUm~,
HOIlCE' UPRns I~ IHIS VEHICLE "HY REQIJlRE \HClm WElDING
EQUIPIIENI H5 mall1lHOED 8'{ IHE MANUFHcrURER,
rhl~ t~"..Ie h., bl.II ,~-..lcul"..I.ith.j ,..,!ifl,.l p,.)t,ll,
III1ATl Rt~Hll HlIIIlill O"ill,9~
Ivllell 0.1. v.".... APIl i\.1l
1.,,41;. lU-'IIO-,i,ul
,.,..dght 1(1 19YO. ""ohell Inl.,...Ii411.'
HII Ri~~'j ..~r.~~
h'l'
\ or \
[!'
.,
"'~
<~
l>>~;
'n .
...~
",.
...".
m;:
'II,..
,.-
i~
n=
,..,..
,.co
-c:
1:-
",111
m."
~ll
me
"'x
m,.
z~
....
~~
<<
m,.
,..
i!;
'!.
a~"
h~
~~~
;~~
~~~
!l>l:;,.
e~;
"O~*
i~~
~~- ~
,. .
.
ji~
11. Q
,~~
a~~
..~-
~:~
"0'
Ii
. -
- ,
(I
,.
:D,-
..-
,'.r.
r-
,,- ,
;~
~'"
ma:'
'"",,,
>Z'
ijo:;
~~
il
~!
II
i,.
,..
Davld C. Jenkln.
402 Anale.ey Terrace Ea.t
We.t Cheeter, P~ 19380
'. -...
. ( ; . .J
, .
. -
.......---
..
~_.
The Ron. Harold E. Sheely
Cumberland County Courthouse
Carllsle. PA 17013
','1r~\.~ ~~"'1.,"" 1",l!I",I!I"""Il"Il,IIII,1
1."11"11..,11,,.11,,.1,1.,
-~,,' -,.,.".. -"""'~.'"~_'M''''_.'''''
" ",., ,.., .;I..-...~.........."'..t.\,I.,.,.l-,."""'".""!~;,:.y,t.lI\l~.."'..'.fM't't-- .~_._--.
~
..IIi'
.
, "
"
\,
,
.
~
. ,
.
I
I
I
i
\
"
,
"
,
,........
.
,-""-
:~-..!"-~ ...:-....-...-...,.. ,.~,.:.. -"::"_~'t:...,
"
...
, . 4-,{,
, I,)LJ'"
"
~"...., ~1IIlUI a ..1...., ..C.
Ia~en .. reuohtenbe~ge~, ..qul~e
ID. IllItI
Atto~ney. fo~ Addltlona1 Defendant
320. Ma~ket .t~eet
.t~awbe~~I .qua~e
'.0. lOll 26.
Ha~~1.bu~9, 'A 17108-1268
(717) 234-4161
Attorney for Additional Defendant, Gardner
JOB II. DIL.Y,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
.
.
I
v..
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
NO. 95-4363
DAVID C. JBKlI..,
Defendant
v..
IAII1J.L A. GUDIID, la.,
Additional Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
.
.
...-TRIAL ..DORAlmUII
I. .a~... ~o LIABILITY
On February 4, 1995, Additional Defendant, Samuel A. Gardner,
sr., wa. drivinq on Inter.tate Route 81 in a .outherly direction.
He wa. travellinq in the riqht lane of travel when he lost control
of hi. vehicle when he encountered icy patche. on the roadway. Hi.
vehicle .truck the bridqe wall on the .a.t.rn berm of the roadway
faeinq ...t .nd cam. to re.t .traddlinq the left l.n. of trav.l.
Oth.r vehicle. p....d Mr. Gardner'. v.hicle without incident and
Pl.intiff, John M. BaUey, .topp.d hi. vehicle in front of Mr.
G.rdner'. v.hicl. on the l.ft b.rm of the roadway to provide
...i.t.ne. to Mr. G.rdner. John Bail.y'. wif., Lind. ..iley, beqan
~
a..i.tinq Mr. Gardner with his injuries. At the .ame time, John
Bailey placed three flare. on the qround approximately 25' apart
behind Mr. aardner'. vehicle to alert approachinq motori.ts of the
accident. Mr. Bailey had additional flare. in hi. hand at the time
that Defendant, David C. Jenkin., approached the accident .cene in
hi. motor vehicle. Mr. Bailey waved the flares in the direction of.
Mr. Jenkin.' vehicle to alert him of the accident .cene.
upon .eeinq the flare., Mr. Jenkin. applied his brakes and
beqan to .kid in the roadway, hittinq the bridqe, then veerinq left
into Mr. Bailey'. vehicle. Mr. Jenkins was travelling approximately
60 mph at the time of the accident.
A witness travellinq behind Mr. Jenkin. was travellinq at 60
mph, the same speed Mr. Jenkins was travellinq. When .he noticed
Hr. Bailey with the flare., she saw Mr. Jenkins hit his brake.,
.kid into the bridqe and then to the left. She went into the riqht
hand lane of travel without difficulty, cro..ed the bridqe and
.topped to as.i.t Mr.. Bailey and Mr. Gardner.
The fact. of this accident .how that Mr. Jenkin. was 100'
liable for the accident involvinq Mr. Bailey'. vehicle.
II. .A~. ~ ~o DaxAG..
Hr. Gardner ha. not made any claim for damaqe.. However, the
fact. a. .tated above evidence that Mr. Jenkin. i. liable for all
da.aqe. incurred by Mr. Bailey.
..
III. >>.I.OI>>L. I..U.. 0>> LIaBILITY AHD Daw.o..
Mr. Gardner has no issues regarding the amount ot damaq..
incurred by Mr. Bailey.
The principle issues ot liability involve whether Mr. J.nkin.
violated the As.ured Clear Di.tanc. Rule by not driving his vehicle
at a speed in which he could stop without causing injury or damage.
to others. Mr. Jenkins raises the Doctrine ot Sudden Emergency a.
a ba.is tor hi. position that he should not be liable tor these
damages. Mr. Jenkin. also raise. the issue ot contributory
negligence by Mr. Bailey stating that he moved unexpectedly into
the right hand lane ot trattic in tront ot Defendant Jenkins'
moving vehicle. Mr. Jenkins also avers that Mr. Gardner is jointly
and severally liable with Detendant Jenkin. or liable over to
Detendant Jenkins for any damages custained by Plaintitt Bailey.
Mr. Jenkins avers that Mr. Gardner was negligent in that he tailed
to set up tlares in front ot his vehicle and tailed to use flasher.
to notify oncoming motorists there was a disabled vehicle in a lane
of travel.
IV. 8VKKAaY 0>> L.OAL I..U.. .ROARDIKG ADMI881BILITY 0>> T..TIKOKY.
am..
At this time, Additional Detendant, Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., i.
not aware of any legal i.sues regarding admissibility ot te.tiaony,
exhibits, or any other matter.
3
a..'%.!aA~. O. ...VIO.
I hereby certity that I am thia day .ervinq a QOPy ot the
toreqoinq elocWDent upon the person and in the aanner indicateel
below, which .ervice .atisties the requirements ot the pennsylvania
cocle, by depoaitinq a copy ot the same in the United St.atas mail,
at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, with tirst-clas. postage, prepaiel, as
tollows:
GeQrge r. Douglas, III, Esquire
DOVGU8, DOVGU8 I DOUGLA'
27 West High street
P.O. Box 261
Carlisle, PA 17013
Daviel C. Jenkins
50 last Hiqh Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
GOLDBERG, KATZMAN' SHIPMAN, P.C.
Datelf-!\l"..;' I"'.,
'1
BYI\'-/ .~':)~~_..
Raren S. reuchtenberger, E.q.
3201 Market Street
P.O. Box 1268
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1268
(717) 234-4161
Attorney. tor Aelelitional Detanelant
,
,
5
LAW ol'PICI'N
GOLDBERG. KATZMAN & SmJ>MAN. P,C;,
RONA~D M, ICATl~AN
HARRY' GOLDllHQ
, Ltt &HIllMAN
PAUL J I15P051TO
NEIl. HlNOlRSHOT
J. JAY COQPER
THOMAS I: IRlNNt:R
JOHN A STA'LER
APRIL I. ~TRANa.KUTAY
auY H BRQOK15
JE,,.Efl&ON J SHIPMAN
MAREN IS FEUCHTENliERGtR,
JERRY J RU1550
ARNOLD B KOGAN
MICHAf.L J CRocrN11
[VAN J ICI.IN[ III
DREW ~ GANNON
5 T[VEN E GRUBa
111,10 MAttKIt'I' H'rHKItT
rnHAWItENHY P-llJl'AHIt
I' 0. nux IUtln
IIAHHIHllUHO. Plf:NNHYI'vANJA 11Inf,.IIJl)U
'fln.KPlloNIt (111!1J1I.....1l1l
'AX (111) 1J11.,.f.tfjOn
ARTHUR I. QOI.DI[RO
0' COUNSEl.
HEAlSH[ Y O"ICE
1)13 WEST CHOCOl.lIIT[ AvENUE
P 0 80X "'&1$
HEA$HlY, PA I 'QU
11111 533.404Q
September 25, 1996
CARLISLE O"ICE
e3 WUT POM'R[T STRUT
CARI.IILE, PI>. 11013
111'1'0415.0&81
YOFl!K O"ICE
I WEST M,t,RKlT !STRUT
I'ORK, PA 11401
11111 8043.1812
Lawrence E. Welker, Prothonotary
cuaberlaD4 COUDty Courthou.e
One Courthou.e Square
Carlisle, PA 17103
.e. JeDkiD. v. .ailey aD4 OarD4er
.0. "-2.33 civil Tera
ICORRUPOND TO
HARRI15IUAO O"le[1
Dear Mr. Welker:
Enclosed for filing please find the Pre-Trial Memorandum of
Additional Defendant, Samuel A. Gardner, Sr.
Very truly
)
~
yours,
-I
1..("'" -)).. ..,.-....-
Karen s. Feuchtenberger
KSr:nd
Ene.
ce: Thomas E. Cheflins, Court Admini~trator
The Honorable Harold E. Sheely
George r. Douglas, III, Esquire
David C. Jenkin.
,'if!) ? /j 100B f1-
OOLDUIlO, ICATIIIAII I I.UIIIUI, . . C .
Ka~en .. reuchtenbe~Qe~, laqu1~e
10 I 58995
Atto~neya fo~ Add1t10nal Dafendant
3201 Ha~ket St~eet
St~awbe~~y Squa~e
P.O. 80X 1268
Ha~~1abu~Q, PA 17108-1268
(717) 234-4161
Attorney for Additional Defendant, Gardner
JOIDI N. BAILBY,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT or COMMON PLIWl
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
.
VI.
DAVID C. JBNlINS,
Defendant
NO. 95-4363
VB.
.AMOBL A. QUO.", .a.,
Additional Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
ItR.-fttAL ..DORMIDUII
I. .aCT8 A8 TO LIABILITY
On F.bruary 4, 1995, Additional D.fendant, Samu.l A. G.rdn.r,
Sr., wa. driving on Interstat. Rout. 81 in a .outh.rly dir.otion.
H. wa. trav.lling in the right lane of travel when he lo.t oontrol
of hi. vehicle wh.n he encount.red icy patch.s on the roadw.y. Hi.
vehicle .truck the bridge wall on the .ast.rn b.rm of th~ roadway
tacing eaat and oam. to r.st .traddling the l.ft Ian. of trav.l.
Oth.r v.hicl.. p....d Mr. Gardn.r'. vehicle without incid.nt and
Plaintiff, John M. Bail.y, stopp.d hie vehicle in front of Mr.
Gardn.r'. vehicle on the l.ft berm of the roadway to provide
a..i.tanc. to Mr. Gardner. John Bail.y'. wife, Linda Bail.y, began
assisting Mr. Gardner with his injuries. At the same time, John
Bailey placed three flares on the ground approximately 25' apart
behind Mr. Gardner's vehicle to alert approaching motori.ts of the
accident. Mr. Bailey had additional flares in his hand at the time
that Defendant, David C. Jenkins, approached the accident scene in
his motor vehicle. Mr. Bailey waved the flare. in the direction of
Mr. Jenkins' vehicle to alert him of the accident scene.
Upon seeing the flares, Mr. Jenkins appli,ed his brakes and
began to skid in the roadway, hitting the bridge, then veering left
into Mr. Bailey's vehicle. Mr. Jenkin. was travelling approximately
60 mph at the time of the accident.
A witnes. travelling behind Mr. Jenkin. was travelling at 60
mph, the same speed Mr. Jenkins was travelling. When she noticed
Mr. Bailey with the flares, she saw Mr. Jenkins hit his brakes,
skid into the bridge and then to the left. She went into the right
hand lane of travel without difficulty, crossed the bridge and
stopped to assist Mrs. Bailey and Mr. Gardner.
The facta ot this accident show that Mr. Jenkins was 100'
liable for the accident involving Mr. Bailey'S vehicle.
II. .ACT. A. TO DAJlAO..
Mr. Gardner has not made any claim tor damages. However, the
facts a. stated above evidence that Mr. Jenkins is liable for all
damages incurred by Mr. BailtiY.
III. PRINOIPLB ISSUBS O. LIABILITY AND DANAOBS
Mr. Gardner has no iSBues regarding the amount of damaqe.
inourred by Mr. Bailey.
The prinoiple issue. of liability involve whether Mr. Jenkin.
violated the Assured Clear Distance Rule by not driving hi. vehicle
at a .peed in which he could stop without causing injury or damaqes
to other.. Mr. Jenkin. raise. the Dootrine of Sudden Emergency a.
a basis for hi. position that he should not b. liable for these
damage.. Mr. Jenkin. also raise. the issue of contributory
neqligence by Mr. Bailey stating that he moved unexpectedly into
the right hand lane of traffic in front of Defendant Jenkin.'
movinq vehicle. Mr. Jenkins also avers that Mr. Gardner i. jointly
and severally liable with Defendant Jenkin. or liable over to
Defendant Jenkins for any damage. .u.tained by Plaintiff Bailey.
Mr. Jenkins avers that Mr. Gardner was negligent in that he failed
to set up flares in front of hi. vehicle and failed to u.e flasher.
to notify onooming motori.t. there was a disabled vehicle in a lane
of travel.
IV. .DIOIUY O. L.GAL :l8.D.. ..GUDlIfG ADMISSIBILITY O. ....'1':lKOIIY..
~
At this time, Additional Defendant, Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., i.
not aware of any 18gal issue. regarding aclmisBibi 11 ty of te.t1aony,
eXhibits, or any other matter.
3
v. .1'1'......
Samuel A. Gardner, Sr.
John M. Bailey
Linda Bailey
bUy Ladino
David C. Jenkin., as on cro.. examination
VI. .lOIIBIT8
At the pre.ent time, Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., doe. not intend
to introduce any exhibits.
VII . 8.TTLDBH'l' If.CJOTIATIOIf8
Samuel A. Gardner, Sr. has not initiated any settlement
negotiation. and is unaware of any settlement negotiations at the
pre.ent time.
Respectfully .ubmitted,
GOLDBERG, KATZMAN' SHIPMAN, P.C.
Date: c'h.r) \q,
BY:~. ~--
- Xaren S. reuchtenberger, Esq.
ID/: 58995
320 Market Street
P.O. Box 1268
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1268
(717) 234-4161
Attorney for Additional
Defendant, Samuel A. Gardner,Sr.
4
CIRTr.rCAT. O. 8IRVrC.
I hereby certHy that I am this day serving a copy of the
foregoing docUIDent upon the person and in the manner indicated
below, which service satisfies the requirements of the Pennsylvania
code, by depositing a copy of the same in the United states mail,
at HarriSburg, Pennsylvania, with first-class postage, prepaid, as
follows:
George F. Douglas, III, Esquire
DOUGLAS, DOUGLA8 , DOUGLA8
27 West High street
P.O. Box 261
CarliSle, PA 17013
David C. Jenkins
50 East High street
Carlisle, PA 17013
GOLDBERG, KATZMAN , SIlIPMAN, P. c.
1
V c_-,~
Byr-1.7 .-.)
Karen S. Feuchtenberger, Esq.
320E Market Street
P.O. Box 1268
HarriSburg, PA 17108-1268
(717) 234-4161
Datel '-r\u4' ~"'7h
Attorneys for Additional Defendant
5
,
.
,
.
GOUUIlO, DTIICIUI I ..lfKAII, '.a.
Karan .. 'auchtanbargar, I.qulra
ID I 58995
Attornaya for Addltlonal Dafandant
3201 Markat Stra.t
Strawbarry Squar.
P.O. Box 1268
Harrlaburg, PA 17108-1268
(711) 234-4161
Attorney for Additional Defendant, Gardner
JOD II. BAILlY,
Plaintitt
.
.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
.
.
vs.
DAVID C. JIHKINS,
Defendant
NO. 95-4363
.
.
vs.
.
.
.
.
8MOIL A. GAaDIrD, sa.,
Additional Defendant
:
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
.
.
PRI-TRIAL MBKORAHDOK
I. .ACTS AS TO LIABILITY
On February 4, 1995, Additional Defendant, Samuel A. Gardner,
sr., was driving on Interstate Route 81 in a southerly direction.
He was travelling in the right lane of travel when he lost control
of his vehicle when he encountered icy patches on the roadway. Hi.
vehicle struck the bridge wall on the eastern berm of the roadway
facing east and came to rest straddling the left lane of travel.
Other vehicles passed Mr. Gardner's vehicle without incident and
Plaintiff, John M. Bailey, stopped his vehicle in front of Mr.
Gardner's vehicle on the left berm of the roadway to provide
assistance to Mr. Gardner. John Bailey'S wife, Linda Bailey, began
,
assisting Mr. Gardner with his injuries. At the same time, John
Bailey placed three tlares on the ground approximately 25' apart
behind Mr. Gardner's vehicle to alert approaching motorists ot the
accident. Mr. Bailey had additional flares in his hand at the time
that Detendant, David C. Jenkins, approached the accident scene in
his motor vehicle. Mr. Bailey waved the tlares in the direction ot
Mr. Jenkins' vehicle to alert him of the accident scene.
Upon seeing the tlares, Mr. Jenkins applied his brakes and
began to skid in the roadway, hitting the bridqe, then veering lett
into Mr. Bailey's vehicle. Mr. Jenkins was travelling approximately
60 mph at the time ot the accident.
A witness travelling behind Mr. Jenkins was travelling at 60
mph, the same speed Mr. Jenkins was travelling. When she noticed
Mr. Bailey with the flares, she saw Mr. Jenkins hit his brakes,
skid into the br.idge and then to the left. She went into the right
hand lane of travel without difficulty, crossed the bridge and
stopped to assist Mrs. Bailey and Mr. Gardner.
The facts of this accident show that Mr. Jenkins was 100'
liable tor the accident involving Mr. Bailey's vehicle.
II. .ACT8 A8 TO DAMAOl8
Mr. Gardner has not made any claim tor damages. However, the
tacts as stated above evidence that Mr. Jenkins is liable for all
damage. incurred by Mr. Bailey.
,
III. >>RINCI>>LB 1880B8 O. LIABILITY AND DAMAOB8
Mr. Gardner has no issues regarding the amount ot damages
incurred by Mr. Bailey.
The principle issues ot liability involve whether Mr. Jenkins
violated the Assured Clear Distance Rule by not driving his vehicle
at a speed in which he could stop without causing injury or damages
to other.. Mr. Jenkin. raises the Doctrine ot Sudden Eoergency as
a basis tor his position that he should not be liable tor these
damage.. Mr. Jenkins also raises the issue ot contributory
negligence by Mr. Bailey stating that he moved unexpectedly into
the right hand lane of traffic in tront ot Detendant Jenkins'
moving vehicle. Mr. Jenkins alBO avers that Mr. Gardner is jointly
and .everally liable with Detendant Jenkins or liable over to
Detendant Jenkins tor any damages sustained by Plaintitt Bailey.
Mr. Jenkins avers that Mr. Gardner was negligent in that he tailed
to set up tlares in tront ot his vehicle and tailed to use tlashers
to notify oncoming motorists there was a dieabled vehicle in a lane
ot travel.
IV. 8UKNARY O. LBOAL 188UB8 RBOAaDINO ADMI88IBILITY O. TB8TINOMY.
~
At this time, Additional Detendant, Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., ie
not aware ot any legal iasues regarding admissibility ot testiaony,
exhibits, or any other matter.
3
V. WI'1'1I118118
Samuel A. Gardner, Sr.
John M. Bailey
Linda Bailey
Emily Ladino
David C. Jenkins, as on cross examination
VI. IIDIBI'l8
At the present time, Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., doe. not intend
to introduce any eXhibits.
VII. 811'1''1'LIIKIIHT NIGOfYA'1'IOIII
Samuel A. Gardner, Sr. has not initiated any .ettlement
neqotiation. and is unaware of any settlement neqotiations at the
pre.ent time.
Respectfully submitted,
GOLDBERG, XATZMAN , SHIPMAN, P.C.
By:
'~ c:) Q--
Karen S. Feuchtenberqer, Esq.
10#: 58995
320 Market Street
P.O. 80x 1268
Harrisburq, PA 17108-1268
(717) 234-4161
Attorney for Additional
Defendant, Samuel A. Gardner,Sr.
Date: C1h.r) \q~
4
"
JOHN M. BAILEY I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V. I
I
DAVID C. JENKINS I NO. 95-4363 CIVIL TERM
I
V. I
I
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR. I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
ORDER or COURT
AND NOW, this 9th day of SEPTEMBER, 1996, a pretrial
conference in the above-captioned matter is SCHEDULED for Friday,
October 4, 1996r at 1130 p.m., in Chambers of the undersigned
judge, Cumberland County Courthouae, Carlisle, Pennsylvania.
Pretrial memorandum ahall be submitted by counsel in accordance
with C.C.R.P. 212-4, at least five (5) days prior to the pretrial
conference.
TRIAL in the matter is SCHEDULED for Monday, October 14,
1996, at 1130 p.m., in Courtroom' 1, Cumberland County
Courthouse, Carlisle, Pennsylvania.
By the Courtr
David C. Jenkins, Pro Se
George F. Douglas, III, Esquire
For the Plaintiff
Karen Feuchtenberger, Esquire
uld
\ ':.' I' " '.~) 1\,.... ':" ~:J,.;
"
S 'I : I !,' "I' /- -- .',~
" t. ,.I'J "" .~,
),lL__,,-.. ,..',:. " ,
~:JI:!~U':.L id
'. .r.'
JOHN M. BAILEY 1 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V. 1
1
DAVID C. JENKINS 1 NO. 95-4363 CIVIL TERM
1
V. 1
1
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR. I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
ORDER 0.. COURT
AND NOW, thia 9th day of SEPTEMBER, 1996, a pretrial
conference in the above-captioned matter ia SCHEDULED for Friday,
Octobe~ 4, 1996, at 1130 p.m., in Chambera of the underaigned
judge, Cumberland County Courthouae, Carliale, penneylvania.
Pretrial memorandum ahall be submitted by counsel in accordance
with C.C.R.P. 212-4, at least five (5) days prior to the pretrial
conference.
TRIAL in the matter is SCHEDULED for Monday, October 14,
1996, at 1130 p.m., in Courtroom' 1, Cumberland County
Courthou8e, Carlisle, Penn8ylvania.
By the Court,
L IC~.A. CIV\ ~ .
~Old E. Sh8ely,
David C. Jenkins, Pro Se
George F. Douglas, III, Esquire
For the Plaintiff
Karen Feuchtenberger, Esquire
Idd
.
PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL
(Must be typewritten and submitted In duplicate)
TO THE PROTHONOl'ARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
,"
Please list the following case:
('j , , '
".
"
(Check one)
for JURY trial allhe next term 0' civil court. ; .
",\
J
, 1
',,1
lei .(")
(X for trial without a Jury, ",.\
............................................................................................................................................4..~..........................'\"1'
,I .(1 .,:,
.... .'
, .(\ ':.3:..
\r,)
CAPTION OF CASE
(entire caption must be stated In full)
(check one)
Assumpsit
JOHN M. BAILEY,
Trespass
( X) Trespass (Motor Vehlclll)
(Plaintiff)
(other)
vs,
DAVID C. JENKINS,
The trial list will be called on
o~c
(Defendant)
15, 1996
lilt
VB.
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR.,
(Additional (Defendant)
vs.
Pretrials will be held on ~to
(Briefs are due 5 days before pre
(The party listing this case for trial sh
forthwith a cop\, of the praecipe to all
pursuant to local Rule 214,1.)
No,22.=!t.32.L. Civil _TIUlIl-___-----1<l8:_
Indicate the attorney who will try case for the party who flies this praecipe:
C..ariA F. Dona1alllr tTt t F.~q.
Indicate trial counsel tor other parties If known: David C. .Io"k I n.., prn ~., ~n I<ut High
St., Carlisle, Pa. 17013; Drew P. Gannon, Esq., Goldberg, Katzman & Shipman, P.C.,
320E Market Street, Strawberry Square,
P.O. Box 1268, Harrisburg, Pa. 17108-1268.
~' DOU~UGLAS ~
Signed: C (lA..
I
Pr!nt Name: George F. Doulllaa, III
This case Is ready tor IrlaL
Date:._ AUllust 30, 1996
Plaintiff
Attorney for:
-
.'
HI
.
;>...
..... ~....
,~J'~ .,_
LU,,,,
~.J'~" .t
~,,-," ~
:~~ ' :' '1;' ~
"lC
u.....
tn
."
N
,
,0./
C"oo.J
, ....
....
......,
'"
"
!,
".>
i: \'~:
1\'
'~.i;
itJ>
'~l~
1";'
J_'
I,:
"
,
.,.. .....
.... ....
DAVIDC, JENKINS
PRO SE DEFENDANT
SO Eaat High Street
Carlisle. PA 17013
Telephone: 717.2S8.9263
JOHN M, BAILEY
Plaintift'
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA,
VS,
DAVIDC, JENKINS
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION LAW
NO, 9S-4363 CIVIL TERM
NOTICE TO PLEAD
TO: JOHN M, BAILEY, Plaintiff
You are notified to file a writtell response to the enclosed Defendant's Answer to Plaintift's
Complaint and New Matter within twenty (20) days from the service hereof or a judgment may be
entered against you,
~G~
David C, Jenkins
'",I:
\f
, ,
"
',"
NEW MATTER - SUDDEN EMERQE1~I!.:.Y.
13, Defendant was operating his vehicle in the right hand lane of Interstate 81, headed in a
southerly direction,
14, Defendant was maintaining a proper a3sured clear distance ahead,
IS, Samuel A, Gardner, Sr, was the operator ofa vehicle which was in a single car accident
immediately prior to the contact between the vehicle owned by the plaintiff and the vehicle owned
by the defendant
16, The vehicle of Samuel A. Gardner, Sr, was situated in the left hand lane of Interstate 81,
17, The vehicle owned by the plaintiff was parked behind the vehicle of Samuel A. Gardner.
Sr,
18, As defendant approached the vehicles owned by the plaintiff and by Samuel A. Gardner,
Sr" Samuel A. Gardner, Sr, moved unexpectedly and without warning into the right hand lane of
traffic,
19, The movements of Samuel A. Gardner, Sr, placed him in front of the defendant's moving
vehicle,
20, As a result of the actions of Samuel A. Gardner, Sr, the defendant was faced with a
sudden emergency and was forced to make a split-second decision to apply the brakes of his
vehicle in order to avoid hitting Samuel A. Gardner, Sr,
21, As a reault of the defendant being forced to make a split-second decision to apply the
brakes of his vehicle in order to avoid hitting Samuel A, Gardner, Sr, the vehicle owned by the
defendant came in contact with the vehicle owned by the plaintiff,
22, Because the contact between the vehicle owned by the defendant and the vehicle owned
by the plaintiff was a result of this sudden emergency, the defendant is relieved of any liability in
cOMection with plaintiffs claim
WHEREFORE, the defendant respectfully requests that this Honorable Court grant judgment
in favor of the defendant. David C, Jenkins, and against the plaintiff, John M Bailey
BY ~C.l~jJ<ft;.-/
David Jenkins
Pro se Defendant
JOHN M. BAILEY
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT Of' COMMON PLEAS
Of' CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNA.
VS.
DAVIDC, JENKINS
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION LAW
NO. 95-4363 CIVIL TERM
AFFIDAVIT
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA )
) SS
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND )
Before me, the undersigned authority, a Notary Public in and for said County and
Commonwealth, personally appeared David C. Jenkins. who being duly sworn according to law,
deposes and says that the averments of fact contained in the foregoing pleading are true and
correct to the best of affiant's knowledge. information and belief.
~in~' ~~
SWORN TO and,Aubscribed
~re_ ~~ this -1L day of
~~~~
Notary blic
~,...
AkoM."'. ~,....
CalIIIe lIotouall, c............ CounIr
..,Cam""_n~,..No.......7.1'"
.-" ~~.... ..-';--'..,.. . . "'.
~_.-:::.c-:""T~.
,I ""j
David (' Jenkins
SO East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
September 8, 1995
George F. Douglas, 111, Esquire
Douglas, Douglas & Douglas
27 West Higll Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
.'
re: John M. Bailey vs David C. Jenkins, 9S-4363
Dear Sir:
I will be living in Carlisle at the above address until June of next year. I would request
that you send further correspondence. pleadings or any other matters pertaining to this suit to me
at the above address and not to my West Chester address in order to help resolve this case as
quickly as possible.
Sincert1ly,
~~~.~
e<:: file
'\) \..V,CL:L\( () LU~~
rr-lcU',:x.. -.\\I.,i...6., ---:','
..\I"c,.. . \, '(Il. \ " _ _ J
\...l:';~
-\ \G '
,h'IJ'\[,
Y L,
"- (~) r..'......
.
PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR ARGUMENT
(ttJat be typewritten and subnitted in "'lpl i""te)
TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY:
Please list the within IllBtter for the next ArglIIBIt CCUrt.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CAPTION OF CASE
(entire caption l1'L1Ilt be stated in full)
JOHN H. BAILEY
(Plaintiff)
VII.
DAVID C. JENKINS
and
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR.
(llefendant)
No. 95-4363 Civil Tam
19
95
1. State IIlIltter to be argued (i.e., plaintiff's IlK)tion for IWW trial. defendent'.
dmurTer to ~laint, etc.):
Defendant'a Motion for Judgment on the Pleadinga
2. Identify counsel wOO will lirgue case:
(al for plaintiff:
Addre8a :
G.orga F. DouglaB, III, Esquir.
27 W'Bt High St.
CarlisI., PA 17013
(b) for defendant:
Addres8 :
David C. Jenkina, Pro se Defendant
50 East High. St.
Carlial., PA 17013
3. I will notify all parties in writing within no deyII thet thU <<:eM _
been listed for argIJIBlt.
4. A19Jn8nt COUrt llete:
lleted:
December 7, 1995
.~\
" \
r.:. - '. \ ;\ ~ , ~ ~
~ - -"-r' JfImc
( j (~~jj l. . (
Pro Be D.f.ndant
:,1,
e '0 ~
U1
-." ~
~O ~~
~Lq ,.,.,
n
:;;"E;;: - 8
u}.~. UI
r~(J -0 i~
:.-
~;n ~
"~'Q (.,)
;J"~ ..
~ U'I
C)
..
j,
.,.
.'
,
I'
.1,.,
0'
I,
I
f
~
-
..
,0 -
., ':~
r '0',1
.-:-r.::
r.-.._
'I
~.,' . I .
':. 'I
,~
I,"'i
L'
0'>
-
c:l;~
"
!, '
"
,I
.
.,
,
"'I,
, "
,'/JCT 11'1 e6'
.
.
,
~
.
.
5, On September 27, 1995, the defendantliled the Defendant's Amended Answer to Plaintiffs
Complaint and New Matters, denying the material allegations of the plaintiffs claim, reasserting as
a new matter the affirmative defense of the sudden emergency doctrine, and adding as a new
mailer in the alternative. the affirmative defense of contributory negligence. The defendant's
pleading was endorsed with an appropriate Notice to Plead. A copy of the Defendant's Amended
Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and New Matters and the Notice to Plead are attached as Exhibit
"En,
6. On September 27, 1995. the defendant served the Defendant's Amended Answer to
Plaintiffs Complaint and New Matters on counsel for the plaintiff by hand delivery in accordance
with Rule 440 of the PeMsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. A copy of the Certificate of Service
is allached as Exhibit "F".
7. The plaintiff was required to plead to the defendant's New Matters within twenty days after
service, The twentieth day after counsel for the plaintiff was served with the Defendant's
Amended Answer to Plaintiffs Complaint and New Mailers occurred on October 17, 1995
8. The defendant has not been served with any pleading to the defendant's New Matters as of
the date of this filing. and the docket entries do not reflect that any pleading to the defendant's
New Mailers has been filed. The defendant has not been contacted by the plaintiff in any manner
to notify the defendant that his reply to the defendant's New Mailers would be delayed.
9. The time for the plaintiff to plead has expired and the pleadings in this matter are closed,
10. This case has not been listed either for trial or for arbitration
II. By failing to plead to the defendant's new mailers, the plaintiff must be deemed to have
admitted defendant's allegations in the new matters, the material aspects of which are as follows:
a. Immediately prior to the contact between the vehicle owned by the plaintiff and the
vehicle owned by the defendant, one Samuel A Gardner, Sr. created a sudden emergency by
moving in front the defendant's moving vehicle unexpectedly and without warning. As a resuh of
being confronted with this sudden emergency. the defendant was forced to make a split-second
decision in order to avoid hitting Samuel A Gardner, Sr Because the contact between the
vehicle owned by the defendant and the vehicle owned by the plaintiff wu a result of this sudden
emergency. the defendant is relieved of any liability in connection with the plaintiffs claim,
b In the alternative, the plaintiff was contributorily negligent in stopping his vehicle in a
lane of traffic on an interstate highway, in failing to set up flares in a manner that would give
sufficient warning to oncoming motorists that a vehicle was stopped in a lane of traffic and in
failing to use flashers or other sufficient means to notify oncoming motorists that his vehicle wu
stopped in a lane of traffic
JOHN M BAILEY
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA
VS.
DAVID C. JENKINS
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION LAW
NO. 95.4363 CIVIL TERM
AFFIDA VIT
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA 1
~ SS
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND J
Before me, the undersigned authority, a Notary Public in and for said County and
Commonwealth, personally appeared David C. Jenkjrn. who being duly sworn according to law,
deposes and says that the averments of fact contained in the foregoing motion are true and correct
to the best ofaffiant's knowledge, information and belief
...' '~ /1
. -'. (' V'
~"--..!,. ~ \. f_. "Jf,\/\/l--,.,./
David C Jenkins -
SWORN TO and subscribed
before me this t9.~ day of
~.1995.
~!'vI ,g,
Notary Public
b;' ll40tarlcll Seal ,....
Ako M ,..., """'" co
Car\l.loloro~''t ..~~~~~.. ;~..
1m romrftlssll')r'l lJI....
............---
,
12, Bued upon these admitted facts, the defendant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.
Under application of the "sudden emergency doctrine" the defendant is relieved of any liability in
connection with the plaintiffs claim since any damages claimed by the plaintiff are the proximate
and direct result of the defendant's confrontation with a sudden emergency. PotenbUflJ v. Vuner,
284 Pa. Super. 19, 424 A.2d 1370 (1981). Alternatively, the causal negligence of the plaintiff
bars recovery pursuant to the Comparative Negligence Act (42 Pa C. S. ~7102).
WHEREFORE, the defendant, David C. Jenkins, requests that the defendant's New Matters
be deemed admitted, and that judgment be entered on the pleadings in favor of the defendant,
David C. Jenkins, and against the plaintiff, John M. Bailey, on his Complaint.
BY ~ G, (l. t.~
David C. Jenkins ~
Pro se Defendant
.,
, ,
,
. i ,t;
COMPLAINT
1. The plaintiff, John M, Dailey. is an individual residing at 143 Amy
Drive, Cllrlisle, Cumberland County, I'a, 17013,
2. The defendant, David C. Jenkins, is an individual residing at 402
Angelsey Terrace East, West Chester, Pa, 19380
3. On February 4, 1995, the plaintiff was the owner of a 1994 Hyundai
Elantra,
4, At or about 6:55 P,M, on the aforesaid date, the plaintiff was
operating the said Elantra in a southern direction on S,R, 81 in Middlesex
Township, Cumberland County, Pa" when he came upon an accident victim
parked in the left lane of travel.
5, At the same time and place, the defendant was operating a 1989
Hyundai Sonata in a southern direction on S,R. 81 in Middlesex Township,
Cumberland County, Pa,
6, The plaintiff stopped his vehicle behind the accident victim and
began to assist the said victim when the defendant hit the side of the said
Elantra,
7, The collision was caused by the np.gligence of the defendant in the
following respects:
a. In failing to operate his vehicle in a safe and prudent manner.
b, In failing to keep a proper lookout.
c, In failing to operate his vehicle within the posted speed limit of 55
miles per hour,
8, As a result of the negligence of the defendant, the plaintiff sustained
$563,00 in car rental costs,
9, As a result of the negligence of the defendant, the plaintiff sustained
a loss of $950,00 in uninsured motorists coverage,
to, As a result of the negligence of the defendant, the plaintiff
sustained a loss of his $250 deductible coverage,
I
I:
I
"
"
"
EXHIBIT "B"
, '
, '
, EXHIBIT "en
t, "
, ,.
. "
,
, , "
, '
"
"I '
, "
.' EXHIBIT "D"
, , .
"
. ,
, ,
EXHIBIT "E"
NEW MA ITER - SUDDEN EMERGENCY
13. Defendant was operating his vehicle in the right hand lane of Interstate 81, heacllld in a
southerly direction,
14, Defendant was maintaining a proper assured clear distance ahead.
IS, Samuel A, Gardner, Sr, was the operator ofa vehicle which was in a single car accident
immediately prior to the contact between the vehicle owned by the plaintift' and the vehicle owned
by the defendant.
16. The vehicle of Samuel A. Gardner, Sr. was situated in the left hand lane of Interstate 81.
17. The vehicle owned by the plaintiff was parked behind the vehicle of Samuel A, Gardner,
Sr,
18, As defendant approached the vehicles owned by the plaintiff and by Samuel A, Gardner,
Sr., Samuel A. Gardner, Sr, moved unexpectedly and without warning into the right hand lane of
traffic,
19. The movements of Samuel A. Gardner, Sr. placed him in front of the defendant's moving
vehicle,
20. As a result of the actions of Samuel A Gardner, Sr., the defendant was faced with a
sudden emergency and was forced to make a split-second decision to apply the brakes ofhi~
vehicle in order to avoid hitting Samuel A. Gardner. Sr.
21. As a result of the defendant being forced to make a split-second decision to apply the
brakes of his vehicle in order to avoid hitting Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., the vehicle owned by the
defendant came in contact witb the vehicle owned by the plaintiff
22. Because the contact between the vehicle owned by the defendant and the vehicle owned
by the plaintiff was a result of this sudden emergency, the defendant is relieved ofany liability in
cOMection with plaintift's claim.
NEW MATTER. CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE
23. Paragraphs 1 through 22 of the defendant's answer are hereby incorporated
24. Both Samuel A. Gardner, Sr. and the plaintiff, John M. Bailey, set up flares in front the of
the vehicle owned by Samuel A Gardner, Sr. immediately prior to the contact between the vehicle
owned by the plaintiff and the vehicle owned by the defendant.
. ---- - .--- _. --..
2S, These flares were set up at a distance not greater than fifty feel ahelld of the disabled
vehicle owned by Samuel A. Gardner, Sr.
26, Plaintiff did not have the flashers of his vehicle operating before or at the time of the
contact between the vehicle owned by the plaintiff and the vehicle owned by the defendant,
27, Samuel A Gardner did not have the flashers of his vehicle operating before or at the time
of the contact between the vehicle owned by the plaintiff and the vehicle owned by the detendant.
28. Alternatively, the defendant avers that any damages sustained by the plaintiff were tM
result of his own contributory negligence and also the negligence of Samuel A. Gardner, Sr, and
that the plaintift's claim is therefore barred by the Comparative Negligence Act (42 Pa. C. S,
~7102), In the alternative, any recovery by the plaintiff must be reduced by the extent of the
plaintift's contributory negligence and also by the ponion of causal negligence attributed to
Samuel A, Gardner, Sr..
29. The defendant avers that plaintiff was negligent in the following manner:
a, In failing to set up tlares in front of the disabled vehicle of Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., in a
manner that would give sufficient warning time to oncoming motorists that a disabled vehicle wu
ahead.
b. In stopping his vehicle in a lane of traffic
c, In failing to use flashers or other sufficient means to notify oncoming traffic that his
vehicle was stopped in a lane of traffic.
30. The defendant avers that Samuel A. Gardner, Sr. was negligent in the following manner:
a. In failing to set up flares in front of the disabled vehicle of Samuel A. Gardner, Sr" in a
manner that would give sufficient warning time to oncoming motorists that a disabled vehicle wu
ahead.
b In failing to use flashers or other sufficient means to notify oncoming traffic that his
vehicle was disabled in a lane of traffic.
c. In moving unexpectedly and without warning into the right hand lane oftraftic in front of
the defendant's moving vehicle
31. Alternatively, the defendant avers that any damages sustained by the plaintiff were the
result of his own contributory negligence and that the plaintift's claim is therefore barred by the
Comparative Negligence Act (42 Pa C S ~7102). In the alternative, any recovery by the
plaintiff must be reduced by the extent of the plaintift's contributory negligence.
. ..... . ...
,.
(",(\~(,... 1'L.r::A~:
32, Alternatively, the defendant avers that any damages sustained by the plaintiff'were the
result of the negligence of Samuel A. Gardner, Sr, and that Samuel A, Gardner, Sr, is sol Illy liable
over to the plaintiff'in accordance with the Comparative Negligence Act (42 Pa, C, S, ~7102), In
the alternative, any recovery by the plaintiff against the defendant, David C, Jenkins, must be
reduced by the proportion of causal negligence attributed to Samuel A, Gardner, Sr..
WHEREFORE, the defendant respectfully requests that this Honorable Court grant judgment
in favor of the defendant, David C, Jenkins, and against the plaintiff, John M. Bailey,
BY
David C. Jenkins
Pro se Defendant
JOHN M. BAILEY
Plaintiff
VS.
DAVlDC, JENKINS
Defendant
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNA,
CIVIL ACTION LAW
NO. 95-4363 CIVIL TERM
AFFIDAVIT
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYL V ANlA )
) SS:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND )
Before me, the undersigned authority, a Notary Public in and for said County and
Commonwealth, personally appeared David C. Jenkins. who being duly sworn according to law,
deposes and says that the averments of fact contained in the foregoing pleading are true and
correct to the best of affiant's knowledge, information and belief.
SWORN TO and subscribed
before me this ~ 1 day of
~ 1995. .
~ 1Y\.~q--
Notary Public
......SelIl
AlaI M.............,.....
c.w........ bInIlMitIIlld c."""
..6.... ....Jl........u..._...... 7, 1"'
~tl~
W1
. ,
~
\iJ
~ '2
f4-;,
?
;Q
~ c<i
._ -Ji -
n ~ <J
j3ti S:
~-"- <
~ <3 .:>~ 0:
:r: .~
E-' i' 'f...3t
o ~3 d3 ~
v? L.
0~~gj
...
~ ~
~
....
:(
:E
en
~
....
o
~
~
-
u.
t-
.:h ~
_ c-
l~-
t ~ d:.
~cl4--
d
\9, ~, ;,
. 5 c....
'() ?
d~1
~3iJ
2 Q..
~ r' .~
~ :-"' k.
\f1 -t> '\l I
~
.~
~
A ..
6)
f~
t;R
if:
#
.....
N
"
,''>1
>.
,r ..
.,
.,
'II 41
<r..:r" I
,...f.
.'
L.r>
-
~
-.
.,
.." ..'
.
/'
,~
tt
',"
~
~
t,\
l;) \n
~
.~
"
.,
f
DO'ljl1LI\.5 DOUGL./.''j ,';, [)Ul)Gl.AS
WI 00 HIlIIU" cum1 tiltH 'HI
'M.THIN IS A '"ul ~NDCO""ltrco""
0' 'IHIl Q"llJ,~~L 'ILU IN nw,
~CflON,
n,
'" T """',,., ,"w
..
.
~
...
':AIHI'>i.E, 1'(;tHI ,TI.V,"II,'
,
GEORGE F. DOUGLAS, III, ESQUIRE
ATTORNEY I.D. # 61HH6
DOUGLAS, DOUGLAS & DOUGLAS
27 WeNt High St.
P.O. Box 261
CarliNle, 1'11. 170 I:I
Tl'Iephonl': 717-24:1-17'10
Attornl'Y for Plaintiff
JOHN t...1. BAILEY
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
VS.
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA.
DA VID C. JENKINS
CIVIL ACTION LAW
NO. q5- 4 3{., ~ C.~;L ;::!...I1v.......
NOTICE
You have b~'en sued in Court. If you wish to defend against the class
set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days
after this complaint and notice are servl~d, by entering a written appearance
personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defenses or
objections to th(' claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail
to do SO, the caNe may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered
against you by the Court without further notice for any money claimed in
complaint or for any otht'r claim or rl'lief requested by the plaintiff. You may
lose money Of property or other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF
YOU DO NOT flA VE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR
TELEPHONE THE OHICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU
CAN GET LEGAL IIELP.
Court Administrator
Fourth Floor
Cumberland County Court HOUSl'
I Court House Square
Carlisle, Pa. 17013
717-240-62IX)
DOUGLAS, DOUGLAS & DOUGLAS
CLAIM NO
38-7110-222 POLICY NO 6776-257-38E 001 LOSS DATe
02/04/95
DRMT NO
DATE
AMOUN T '
1 13 532940 J
02/09/95
$"'***3,604,95
PAYEE
i~~NJl BM\tij~ & .t.tNP1\ B1\IUlY & FREYSINOER PONTI1\C INC
C1\Rt.ISrE PA 17013-8884
,;"
")" l." 1'-"1
..).... ... ,.
r-" -----...--i~r-.'!i1I)-~ rf---'-" ---.,
I -'I'!"'ll','" I
400+ '3,604.9\ J
\ 'I. o A';'
......n ~__ _____ .__.__ ________ .._.__
REMARKS
CREAl ED BY
Scott E<ney
eft.
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
PENNSYLVANIA OF' ICE PHC HAr 10NAL BANK 62.1\/311
CONCOROVILLE, PA
Harrl~blJr9 13.114'
38-7110-222 POLICY NO 6776-257-38E 001 CLAIM UNIT 521
02/04/95
BAII,EY, 'JOHN
1 13 532940 J
OATE 02/09/95
.~;;,~, ~o~~",'.," --- l
400';!- '3.604.9\
, ..,,"";
---.-- .-----------.--
".".....
"OIU...II
,
CLAIM NO
LOSS DATE
INSURED
UUU"U.UUU"'~UU.U""'.""U"U""".E)(ACTL'f T~Ree THOUSAND SIX HUNDRED FOUR 1\140 95/100 DOLLARS $:~:~~:':~,:~:'.~:~l~]~-.':\'lJJl
PlIyrlJ Iliff
Or,l.rol'
JOHN M BAILEY , LINDA BAILEY ,
143 AMY DRIVE
CARLISLE PA 17013-8884
FREYSINGER PONTIAC
TIN 38-2314910'72
AUTI! SERNf:
(j1
INC
_'f$1
APPROVEO BY
,.
r"
t ,', t I'~ !. 'i:: 'I:
1;,111
.
r"'IL";!,: ,'I; .,? lJ
SWE fi,~M MUfUI,I. IlIii'.''''',."
11\ lWP-II.N ;or,o NEW ':IIMmlIolID, 1,l 1';07,)
1,'{J'l;' Ti't"lC6:
W AllY ~umlOll5 fE'i1ir.0111'; !IllS E:HIM'Hf HEMi1. ':0111.,:1 r:,1.
[:'OI':,llt~ (l.,lI!, I!lWOltR.... ........... .,....... '....hm.......
D.,.". A"... ,,,I 6,: IIAllItl. tOOIlS 201117.13
Iyp. of l",: (olll.loo (,p,~)
('ilte c,~ late: IlUr)4/5C
fje.JIlctlbl,,: 1',0.00
[,"',r.,I: JOIiIII! I WeA ,AIlEi'
Ihid,,,,: lilllM',Oll (",Li3lt P,; l'r,lIJ-Oi."~
He.. F",.: (i171 141'8S~;
O."riptl,n: lJq~ If!UIIOM EliiNI,O 40 mAil
~ltch.11 I"ul.e: ,~li711
";' ',,, I'
"
II' ..'
, , .~
I,')'
--
,.
,,'.
::..
~~
';::
;:1
,::.=
;0'
J;:
;i~
e:':
~~ ~:
:.r.:J ~
~~:
~ -' I.
,"~ "
, ",'
""".J" '.J' ,j
OEM/AU: H
_...~
Of,. ;,
SColrch f;[)rJl!: u~~p U:JI ~ :
106 .00'
15.0')'
0.6'
15.0')' 0,5-
'3S.r)'J- 0.3
1;'5
d.7S
!.S,)-
0.4.
3'i.l'2 11,1
~
-" -
:; ~ :';
~': ~ :~
-1-::: ..
Q~~ ;
....r;: ::0.
a~ :;
~ ~Jl ,?
'"I;;; :3
SQ ~
i~:-: =
::'1 ~
r, _~ .....
~;:: ~
r,.) ~
c.i:-J ..1
,..~' ,-'
"':0 ....
:.::~ :::
~ :'i c:
:'J.... "
<~ ;;
''':::. ,..
r
Un. En'.,:; l.hor Un. It" F", 1,'p'l 1),11", LaUar
B~.a ~'y~jl!-l IYl!~_ 9E{r.ili~L........ 9.m.tiili9A____..._.~._.....____._.__ eil:rt!!~!~~L.._.___. il!.Y!mL. I1DlL
~l)lj\,1) FRilr.C'AOo'L 1.(,E06 Oi.q.IjIlIEOOY/fRAr.E IHCI.UOES 5tHF
Z ~005,jO 111.(11 -AWl. 1.I,60R CFR-REM SUSPENSIOII AI.IG"MEIIi
J gOllSCO HEW 'AOO'L 1..60R OFR-1EI F"mll SUSPENSWH laHl1
q ~O')500 80D( -AWL lA80, UPR-RUST COitT
5 80'\9')0 80DY REHOI)WEPI.h(E WHEEL
r, AU fO REF lH liEF I1IlSII wIlEEI.
T I.lIiE IIMRUP m.oo
8 SIGIHFEriR
'J ~,]lj51;0 800y 'REI~GliEiREPll\':E ")"I.VE SfEil
I') 90G500 600'1 'ROD 'I. 1.,;60R GfRoSF;1I S(,lMICE RrGHI WR WHEEl.
11 dl)OI~S SOD'! REHOI)t:REi'LHGE illEEI. COVER
11 RI')III REOR
I] 9005CO 6ao'( 'REIIOliE/REPI.HGE 'RIGNi m! lIRE
I' 6EIlmE:,I . P RIGIIT RE,l' IISF. 1.10.':0
15 015,')a 81lUY Rf.MOVEiF.El'l.liGF. .R ERr OO'l! RCM ')IE'I HI'R0!
15 ,'\JiO Rf.F[Ij REflHISl1 H FRr DOOR III1"OR
I'" %H:l') SOol I!I.I';II 'R f.EtiR GOOR \liEU.
1:1 SZ')'J8Ij iiJO'l W,ltR .,';111' ?MiEL
I') AUln ,lEFIII..[Erll[.SII 'lleF I'",IC(
~u e~2}1i) EOOY Rf.,~al.I,.,\tJL,KE ~ rJUliRfER GllTF.R PMlfL
11 H\JIO mIll mlrl[SlI R ~UA~IEH F~/lEL tJUT5IDE
/1 A\JIO REFill .IEFr.~lill i PAIIEI. tG,;!
23 A\JTn REFIll REFINISH i LOf.K PIl.lAR
1'1 amF.t1 8001 REPAIR 'l ~UARrE! OUIF.! PANEL
,5 Il\JTiJ REFIll RErlNISH L QUARIF.! PIINEl r]IJfSlOE
:s ~1Z\80 600Y RE~OUE/ml!I;E R QIIAR IER FliEl. DOOR
17 AUil) REFIKREFIIIIEH ~ FUEl. r,OCR
18 82261'1 600Y RE"OUE, Rf.PI.,!(~: QU~R IfR FUF.1. DOOR RELE"iE ':"6l,:
,U6lE!
SU6I.EI
SI1DLf.i
..QUill. RF.Pl P,iRI
QIIAI. RWCI.EO FliRI
"CUi,1. Rtfl. 1Mi
mSTIII,;
S,'JI;O-,:)4'IO
"QUA( REPI. rAn r
OiSr]6-:.j\tl1
ilSO'l',~IIi')
SjS :O<~Ol'O
mSIl-4~OOII
mIHAIE REGAll. .~IIMBF.!: 1)1/0'1/15 14:N:.lR 3e-iLlH,',01
MitcholI OO~J IJ,,,ion: "~..J'j.l\ I:O?yl'i~,t Ie) Ij~IJ, Mitcholl Int"',1!!unal
IH l ~~JIIr.1 RII!lllr'iCl!
:6.1)0'
5..34
111.35 1),3
C I),~
LO'
S,I).
G 2.:1
;S6.:~ i5.0 ~
(~ t,?
0.5
': 0.5
1.5'~
C1.7
11.:13 lHet
C 0.3
IT.a1 'l.D
~_.-
I'j' ,
j. .)
.:..':.,.
'..
~,:: :~
,,1.t .'
r."~ ""'i
."
C> ~ .,
. ..,
::; c: :.
~.~, "
l!; ',., ..
l~ ...
Ii: ~ ~
.... '."
i!. ;;
~rtI ~
~'~ ~
h~
i~ ~
f: -
f'.lg0 I 01 J
, ~ l' , . .',"1: :
I,',f'
I,JoIdhl
I. f ': r ; ; ,~ . i L'. .',', 'i I I
'~,
L"__.
~ ;
;.)
~:'.:~'.tl ~'I;I rE~'~i.'f:Ii~J~ltII :~IF.lf~ 'tif~ (',H IA,f. ~;'f,I"
~I;'i~ lJ FoOCrr ~[itl!R .~ IJlltln[~ [WU:~ ~,'.IlFl.
.fflN [[Fliiltll/nlf,." f QIJI'm, llilH'11 fl,llf:
~,:':';.."; ~I;C'~ ~Er!;'.'E.'~FFlj\':E ,i.; ~J;)lF.f[~ 'Inl:' iFtL, r:
~~~C('!J Wi\' ~f:110IJE/~EH,ld: II 1~~'IF,H,; ~El,'dhf~
Ir:'.i'~li S(,Q'r ~EM,jl,V~[FI(\!;E "(~f:,tRr~F ~rJl.r
iJ~'~6:') f',li; ~u~r;':E..HfL,I(f LU~!;tl~:E LIe Fllr,[l
1'1::1:) ;fFiII .fUIIWI lIJI;';,ll;E llO 1!lJrSW,
!oIJlG WIN HftllWI 1.11';';"" LID UlllifF,rcf
llllE Nm'.ip ::':UQ
-R lUljl;~';E I.W Hnjf:[
'l. l.tJI;'_;~I;~: L[[) ft!ljli~
l.iJli(:t1~f. ut: urIHI~f~~r~!lj
fW: ECO'lP.1111ol.
m,SOO'IPHhfl,
(,C'O FCR IIISIOf.
'[f!oR FOl1'l flll0F f,,/I
~'J':):".:J'IIJII ' 'l.
.,I'J
J.I!'
.1; , ,','
'j":l;! 'J' ~C,J::I; :, ~!l r ~l( l =
'J Ii Ii ~ i i) . :: I . I.' (J J ,I;l~
~:i'n';'lt'i'l i), 'iJ '
~1:1.1, i.f:';,'IW ;:filii l:ti,lllj- IJ,S"
c t..l
I,l
31.25
ij,E-U
G.,"
~'rnl~Z5ri!l: ' '!\i,~~ 1J..f
i €~l ~I;!j', :1]1 ~l;' 1,1.;5 <.5 =
<: 1.0
0.11
'~,li,n
'.
.;;
;,
'<
!~
;: ,
:1 .,
'. F' :.
:; "
_. , "
,"
;,
1:1
1';
8':3~('() EI!D'r' I;U!:~I
~~';~l:l e'~O't ~L[I~tI
~2.JtSi) €(Or' ~EI~C(.IF.,.~fFll\(f.
~(;t; ltl~ S'i:T: FE,~orJE.-'F[~llil:E
MT:l ml!lmrmll
(111m mill ;[flrmll
"'011"1 !';!il mrd'
, ,~
~. . .
;~ ';: '4
,:
~. '; ':J
:,1 ~~ :'i
I'::
~ :
.,:,
.,
'IS
.t'o' ,Vlm:15%1 W!IjV'Iff.fl,l([ R ,EAR ~I)L"I lRI~ flilH
., EiJC;e~ oW ,t,~iJVEiRffI..KE R u.lfi EiJD1I;OW,Rr.'f.Mf lRIM
.., r,')(IJ~1 ,'JOY "MII'iE/WI.';':, ,CO!BOilH!IJIj UI~P ,'5([NELI
5') 6163111 acoI ,f.NO'if.iRlFU,CE R["R eu~FF.r< Cll':[R
,.r ,ilJftJ 'fFW'fFlllf,1I fU,R(lIm
S~ 1:::S.l70 S!:O"f F.[J~ljr;'t/~Erlhl~E ~E~" eUMFfR v11.'ER ,~l~",
Sj e2~!~() el;Of RE~IYJE/FF.fIJj(t R RE:',F. EU~HR Hlji.'HflliG EF.rl('~F.r
5'1 .1':1: i~') EI'or "~O'i[ir.lFl("l Ff.,iR ,UMfCR FILl [; ro Rl1m,
'is ,JIITO REfUI m01f511 Rfl1R LWR FILI.E, FlilltL
,I, ,111TO ,EF1~ ,'Dli'L L'l,CR CPR f.IH~ (iJl11
57 J~F,lil!1 IICO'L (fiST feW,
\6 All II) ,',OO'l ,;n:lT PHlIIT HMERl,il.:)
. hJ'J~r;llnt rte~
, l,bor Ilot, 11fpll,s
t; l~dl:I~c:'1 tn l:I~"" (.",1; r..~lr:
~fi 'I'gtj~ ~:6rl,jt)~r,Q
eslll)"l,;r)I)O"A,]
~!IOh'ti5E:)
Ef.f:llI-:M,J
16,11 IIIC[
~1j,8'Z 0, 'l
'.S.", rtiCl.
JEE.12 1),1
I' 2 . ~
I:")') 111I:1.
3J.'1S Ii.: =
66.11 Il.Il =
( ').6
2.S-
(i;'-'"I
U~
:.
<
%~:71~:'t:(;1:1)
€f,~'I:-Zer)0u
Ij~(;S5~ ~~I)t;l)
;. ,: .-
~,~ tj
",:'; ::-
?:i I~j ;
~. C
\1~ J:
1~li ~
:: " ~
'i:j ~
.~ ~~ ~
':: .~ In
~. ,:~ "J
~j 3
c'
65,~')'
1Sll,r)llll
'!lJjL:U
;il,;Uf'l W;Mf.O ow uo I;ALI. TON rlf IIOprH l SIJIJTH ,11Jru Fim
:'cliIJ. 65~ ..'t'f t ~l
;1:11W'( RW':LfO ~lim ':A1.L I(fUllll1f "UHlI.WS ',[:J[ ~";,l-il)II')
r, lJb'~I' Sllht,:t,)b
a,lrf;
!lo.Lb _._f~l.t!t
J7 ,0 '~!; ,(rl!
._...I[:J.JJ_'.
~~~ ,::1)
CSJ,r)Q
15 .~I)
I, ~;s l ,I!j
J,.H
1,t.SIJ,}t
fr, P,1l't Repl.iC.!:r,el'1t f1jlMr.lrr
Tr'iIIJt,! i'.Jrr.~
, P.Jr j~.1 l~d ;\), ~ .It! 1\ t
'~,1f.:J r,n1 d"jl)~
Td.il ~;t~t.l':tll:hlljt ,.1~~t.' 1~I:',OIJI\~:
_...B3~!U~
l,m.6J
t'1.I~!)
" '
. .
tltH~~;~lj ZLS in,lm
~'H;It,ll1k.ll 1),6:6.1)1)
L:lbr,r Sllhb;tJI
lJ~oJr Ln:~ ~ ,Ijd~
Llbor .~IJ",IJr:J roJ~,lIJ Sn.:l
ll;,g ,l~
l,911ll.,j5
"
, ,:~ :;
,
, ,
.~. :; ,
":: '
~ ';
~. .-,
-
J8~i'( lll',Z':ZOt
COP!"':I"! W 1~110, ~,t'n~ll Int~ro,lt'on,'1
I1Il ~1'lht, 1~""'i,iI
'"
;~ ~i
-" "
:'~ 11 :-
~; :z ~~
- :.: .~
,.-,. ..
~.~~ '., :~
:~ ~ :~
;. .; ,.~
-4;' .,
<2 l) "
~~ ; :i
; ilHAfE KE,;AI.L IIU~OEI: ,JZ:07i~S l~ :;~~: H
~it'r,.11 O.,t.. U",ion: Fi9J5_~
PJaa
I~ n f .')
.-
, . j ~ ' , ,j' .,,'
, :,1, "~
, '!'I'
,
, " ,; ~. " ,,;: 'f, ..~ ::
[;L Ai.ld~.I':(I'JI '"a\t
TII,lL.l,) ';,}.\I:,\
~Ill.n i ,I A J .~, '. '.' .
III;r,qJ .J~ I J '"at.l
;:,~:'sl ld!,fitl,:r"l; (':.'l~):
I, ,,1:.111..,1:,,:
It. [,)t,Sl ~1r.;1,:1:l:',~,'" ~Ir~~:
! j!, r':~Jt l'I+~ln... Llll1,d (;',:\;
: ,\ir"l.~,.
: ,,:,81; ,,)~
j:d,lhl
. ~-'
.i!!Htl.:n!:
,:~,;, j('
H:,(<,
,. ,
;,:;,,]Ij
, .
;:1;.';11
',r~u ',:t.li:
11.161),;;'1
r~ ,.:
'.'
(::;:
Cua!l.:lltr Al L:..qr,,:ll; ILIII;
I'.l~nt ." rOF."t: 5 WIH ~(,'~ ,:iJ.IIf:.
~~'dy ,ShIlF: Ijh~
(',:~t~II.lP' F-'~~I:')"'~lhll~ti: Z';f..J4'
rn.Wlfdl,;n ~Itll: I FI!~lO ~~tl
tfut Tel-Ill:
;,t'IC" .oj~
.' ~ ~
~: ~~ ...,
:-;:r ;.
ttI f:C~FUt~lll~f: l,Jrnl ~rl;rrvrl lP.,:; 'if lil:r Ii (F l'!r,li:
liN'(fmC~ YHO ',/IOI/'\';l' i.,'1l ilTII Ihl(~T II) [,',Ju,E r.. ,mAIJO Mil
!II~um fiLE. ,;H tlFfl:l"i,;!'JII CI':l.H1M CGhf,HHIII,; I\H'( flUE, IIi':ml.H(
r.. IHilE",INo WfG.M,IT 1,:,1 SHlil.l., "liN (CH'J Ie null, EE SuE ,iE(] I a
Ir.FHI5ilN~EII] FIIR UF Ia (E'.EII,ER,\5 HlIO P,liNEII] OF ,1 rillE OF UP it)
115 ,')I)'j,
:] "
;~~~ ~~
.{1;;: ..'
:! ~~ .
-t :" :'
~ -'J ..
",f '::
:.;,~ :,
.;
;,
... ~fttJrr~H u.
rMUl1G 10 FmENT II!!G ESflNME TO filE FEF,IIW,; ,nFA';E Bf.iGF,E W,'1l'
IMY FEiIIl,] 1tI MorrWIAL E,IFElIf.E Ta 'I';;l. ,;11'1 SIJFFLfNf.lI] 10 rill"
ESrr~,HE ~USI BE "miJiliEO BY ,I ,WE F,i,~ AOJu.rE~,
him:r.: millRS ],) fill" 'Jf!illlF. IIIi( W;UIFE mmrc mow!,
EIlU!fNElli ,is rcEe'jME,OEJ e', Tlif. N"llJf".;r',fi."
(0
>
Cj,.' .....
-<r~ ;:;
> 'J1 ~~
v; ~ ~~
~:;:? ..~
;;,~ ~
.,,;;; >
);0.... Z
::J'"
~,~ vi ::-
,. c
~)'~ =
"'0 -
~.. S1
~':i ~
-"~
i:'\ 'J ..
.:, 0
~j 2.:
i: ~ -~
,.,: " Co
~~ ~ f1
. ::.>
=b "\J
~ ~ ~
t'71'j:: ,-:J
r-~
12.:J
.1
~
':; .. -
:> ~~ :~;
~".:; ,~
:;"1 ::
-~:., C
~.~ ;:
>- ...
:;!/~ ~
3,~~ ~
;-~ '...
~~.~ :;
'-:' ,:;
;. ;L~
f~Z, ~
~:J~ ~
.. ."
- )0
.;\ ': '.1
-
.-
mlnAIE .WLL IIU~BER: 1);,0',', 'J5
Kit,M.l1 O"t, 'im",: m,JS.11
l+::',:1'.l~"1110-2'lm
CopyriaMl ," IGOil, Mlt,I,~ll Int~r""ti"""l
All il~ht' R'""'I~t1
PIIU'
101 J
,;..' It
>,
,'-" .'" .'Ili
e.. .....-.,:"..... -4\",........~ .
. .,,~l' :
;"~ ~\ : '.
'...
'"'t
......,.
1/
/
--.~
~......~
,'/
"
"
". ,
{i.,
..,
.
, "
. It
.. ~':l
~ ,
. ..,1
-j
,
I,
Oil., 0411419~ 01143 P,K.
..tw tDI 38'7110-11201
Suppl.untl 002 IPI 04/14/95
P"fll, 101 3032 15
STATE fARK KUTUAL INSURANCE
II ~ WEk ILN ROAD NEW cumRLAIID, PA 17070
17171 77H061
fOR ANY OUESTlOIIS REGARDING TillS ESTIMTE FLEASE CONTnCT IHE
INDICATED CLAIKS HANDLER ____._._...______,...._.__.._.____.
Dmge Ammd 8YI DANIEL COOlIS 3001733
Supple.ented 8YI DAN COONS3001733
Typl 0' LOSlI ColIl,lon ISped
D,t, of LO"I OII041!~
D,ductlbltl 111),00
In,uredl JOHN K I LINDA 8AILEY
Addrml 1\3 AK" OR CARLISLE PA 171)1J-asB4
Wn'~ ?hnn~: r?11\ '4q.~q14
nltttlQll ~drYl'~t ~1~/,l
Descriptlonl 1!9\ HYUNDAI ELANTRA 40 SEDAN
VINI Y-!HJfIIK6RU5819B7
Llcln'.l NAP-267 PA
OEKI All: A
Search Cod,: DAI)P
Line Entry Libor Line It..
It.. NUlber ill.L Q2.!,.tion D.,criDtion
I 90(51)0 fRANE 'ADD' L LABOR OPR 'UN I BODY If RAKE INCLUDES SET -UP
2 900500 KECH 'ADD'L LA80R OPR.REAR SUSPENSION ALI_NKENI
3 !00501) KEeH .ADD'L LA80R OPR'SET fRONT SUSFEliSION TOE-IN
4 900500 BODY 'ADD'L LABOR OPR'RUST COAT
5 BOmO 80DY REHOVElREPLACE WHEEL
6 AUTO REm REfiNISH WHEEL
7 LINE MRY-UP m ,00
8 RIGHT REAR
9 !00500 60DY .REIIOYE/REPLACE IVALVE STEK
10 900500 80DY 'ADD'L LA80R OPR'SPIN 8ALANCE RIGHT REAR WHEEL
II 800146 BODY RENOVE/REPLACE WHEfL COVER
1/ RIGHT REAR
13 !00501) BODY .REKOVEIREPLACE .RIGHT REAR I IRE
14 BETTERKENT . P RIGHT REAR TIRE 110,00
15 800167 800" RE,~OVE/REPI,ACE REAR CTR CONSOLE ASSY
16 900500 fRAIIE'ADD'L LABOR OPRIPULL REAR fLOOR PAN
17 815490 eODf REMO'IE/REfVCE R fRI DOOP. REAR VIEW KIRROR
IS AUTO REF IN REfl~I\H R fRr ODOR KIRROR
19 BI8430 80DY ALIGN .R RERR DOOR 3HElL
EO 8/0980 BODY REPAIR IROOF PANEl.
2l AUTO REFIN REFINISH ROOF PRNEL
I~ 8,/060 BODY RE~OVE/REPLACE BACk ~INOOW KOULDING
23 !00500 80DY 'RDD'L LABOR OPR'SOUNO OERDENING PADS
24 822340 eDDY REKOVE/REFLACE R QUARIER OIlTER PANEL
25 AUTO REFIN REfiNISH R QUARTER PANEL OUTSIDE
16 Aura REFIN REFINISH R PANEL EOGE
17 AUTO REFIN REFINISH R LOCk PILLRR
PJrt Typ..1
_ P,r t NUlbrr
SUBLET
SUBLET
SU8LET
"QUAL REPL PART
QURL RECYCLED PART
"QUAL REPL PART
ElISTlNG
51960-28440
"gURL REPL PART
84b70-/8120-AQ
SU8LET
87b0b-2370 1
87130-28000
"QUAL REPl PART
mO~-2BlOO
ESTIKAT! RECRLL NUMBER I 02107195 14:24:34 38-7110-22201
Kilch.lI D~h Vmion: RPR_95_R Copyright ICI 1990, K,tch,11 Inlfrn~lion,1
All Rllhl' R.,ero.d
Kllugfl 13, m
Doll., Labor
Rlount Unl t
206.001
35.00t
0.61
15,001 0.51
35.001 0.3
0,5
8.75
1,501
0.41
37.12 0.1
56.001
5,94
10UOt 0,3
60,001
119.95 0.3
C 0.4
1.01
5.01
C 2.9
22,621 I
25.00t 0.51
296,18 15,0 I
C 1.7
0.5
C 0.5
'~q. I II )
J.
1'::1"
,-
,t. 'I.
,~ r;
......
>:5
"tn'
'n .~
~,.
.",..
~ ~~
...l..
,"~ '=
,...."..
'l:'C
;",;(;
~.. 1:
~".
M,,;
iJ :7;
mo
~1 J;
',OP
';'":
l>'
..j:;;
;;(.:
I~ ;;
r-
"(I'"
~J r'
;: . L
~' ,., .
.j~~
C ~:
~, n,;-
r-\ :i"
;.\,...;,
;,.<-:..
~ ;q .
':: ~ '~:
i~~
> - -
~;': !
2ii':
-, ~. ~:
<<:{:
~~l
,.:L
" ..
';}~:;'
~ r::
"S'
o~.
~ G~:
.9d ::
;:;,:
3,'
, "
( .."
{ :
~ :
0"
, ~'
)>
",-
......
>'-
(~s
.......
>r>
........
"'1:
"''''
>;:
i;:
~Ri
!I
ml
II
"
[i~J r
02:42 P,K. ~ I
l~ ~_:_ ,>t .
"',l'If:;/
"
'" tj v;
:' '0.,
':::,1:') I
r..... ...
";:, -r;.
~ ~-~ ,;,! '
,~,~';, ['
. C
--lJ -j
I III -r
': '? 0 I
_..~ 'U
"'jj ~ I
Do. "r
Ill. .
t)TJ :_
'n ~q 0
;~() Z
"1 JJ -~ I
~ --p 0
.'1'" .0
:. ~, m
-,:1;1 'U I
.:: '.J J.
I-i~i ,:jj I
'"
(
O~l" 04114/l5 02,/,2 p"~.
i . 101 39,'1110.mOI
Suppl.unt, 0~2 IPI 04114/l5
Profli. 10, 30 Je 15
2B 822m BODY REPAIR IL QUARIER OUTER P~NEL
29 AUTO REFIN REFINISH L QUARTER PANEL OUTSIDE
30 B224BI) !ODY REM'IE/FEPLACE R QUARTER FUEL DOGR
31 AUTO REF IN REF IN"H R FUEL ODOR
32 B22b2') BODY RE~O,E/REFLACE QUARTER FUEL DOUR RELEA,E CABLE
33 B22b40 BODY REMOVE/REPLACE STRIFE JAPE FUEL LAPEL Of.CAL
34 B003l3 BOOY REPAIR IR QUARTER INNER PANEL
35 REFIN REFINISH/REPAIR R QUARTER INNER PANEL
lb INCLUDES PULL
J7 8m"N BOD( RmVE/REPLACE R QUARTER VENT GRILLE
3B 822800 BODY mOVE/REPLACE R QUARTER RETAINER
39 822820 iOO'( mOVE/REPLACE R OUAR lER BOLT
,0 823610 BODY REMO,E/FEFLACE LUGGAGE LID PANEL
41 AUTO REFIN WIIIISH LUGGAGE LID OUTSIDE
,2 AUTO REFIN REFINISH LUGGAGE LID UNDERSIDE
1.1 II HF M~~IIF I?j J,,)
'" t:':J,,')IJ c.uur I1lIJ~ th LUb~ltut LIU 11lhbt
45 823810 BOOf ALIGN IL LUGGAGE LID HINGE
,b B23B51) BODY REKOVEIREPLACE LUGGAGE LID WEATHERSTRIF
47 80(1368 BOOI ,EMOVE IRm ACE REAR BODY PANFL
4B AUTO REFlN REFINISH REAR BODY PANEL
4! AUTO REFIN REF INIS/J ADO FOR INSIDE
5.) G00373 BOOI REPAIR IREAR BODY FLOOR PAN
51 AUTO ,EFIN REFlHISij REAR COKPARTmT FLOOR
52 Gll0378 800'( REMO,E/REPLACE R REAR BODY TRIM PANEL
53 800382 BODI RE~O,E/REPLACE R REAR BOO'( COKPMlmr TW
54 BOl)391 BODY REMOVE/REPLAcE R COMBINATION LAMP ASSEKBLY
~5 826330 BODY RE~O,E/REPLACE REAR BUMPER CO'lER
~6 AUla REFIN REFINISH REAR COVER
57 826370 SOOY "HOVE/REPLACE REAR aUMPER COVER MLDG
58 8?b390 SODY REMOVE/REPLAC, R REAR BUKPfR HaUNTING BRAC~EI
59 826440 aool REMOVE/~EPLACE RoAR BUMPER FILLER TO BUKPER
6') AUTO REFIN REFINISH REAR LWR FILLER PANEL
61 931084 BODI RE~OVE/REPLACE ISATTERI
62 SfTTfRHENI - P 8ATTERY 11'),'10
b3 90051)1) BOOY IREMOVE/REPLACE IRT TAIL LAMP KT 8RACKET
b4 AUTO REFIN AOO'L LABOR OPR CLEAR COAT
,\5 936001 AOO'L cas r lOWING
bb AUTO AOO'L COST PAINT ~ATERIALS
I Judg...n t [tao
I L~bo' Not. Appli.,
C Includ.d '" CI.., COdI C~lc
b9110,281j.l0
1,5'1
C 1.1
12,93 INCL
C r,,3 I
31.82 0,8
1.05
8mO-28000
3101HI000
-S
'S
6.01
1.01
91510-28000
98810--21000
12493-04143
QUAL RECVCLEO PART
2.20
1.86
0.40
200.01)1
C
INCL I
0.51
I.G
1.1
5'\'0"
B57bO-28000-AQ
8mO-28000-AQ
9240, -28550
80601-28050
I), ~..
0,511
0,4
4.5 1
I.b
1),8
2.0'1
1.0
18.31 INCL
20,82 0.3
45.52 INCl
355.42 0,4
C 2,4
18.39 INCL
33.75 0.21
be.11 0.6 I
C 0.8
54.431 0.21
5.77
29.321
87321-28030
69100-28100
,0.95
149.35
C
86671-28000
86642-28000
86655-2801)1)
"QUAL REPL PAR T
NEW
2.51
163,001
250.00'
uill.
;L1TY REC'/Cm OEC~ LID C~LL TO" AT NORTH & SOUTH AUTO PARTS
JI)0-692-7413
;LITY RECYCLED WHEEL CALL ~EVIN AT AUMILLERS WiSl 938-4000
rlMAIE RECALL NUMBIR, 02/07/95 14,24,34 36-1110-22201
:ch,lI D." Ver,'on, APR,95_A Copyright IC) 1990, Mitch,11 Inltrn.lIon~1
All Ri9hh R,',,'v'd
P.g' 2 01 3
,:j.'; j ~
::: " ~l -0(
,....,E
"11' '!"~
;: .-? -~ ~
; ','1 ',' \/1
,., i ~
, .~ ~..;!
" ':J L -
: ': ~ 0
'.: 2. '1;1t
'~'iB~
. ~ 1...,z
~ ~~ 2 f1
:; "()'o(
~c3-~~
.r. ,_ 0
~3~~
:U~!
'J~ ~ ~
~;:: l~ ~
~ -,~,
'r~: I"~
..,~ .'
W~r
d,.11 ~
~ ::1 0
':; " ~ f
-.;l.<
rE' I
. ~~: ,
~ I '
~ I
::i': :t I
>~ Ci I
:;~ u; "
>- z
"':":10
rn;: .....
","];10 I
>.;:: Z '
"-;
.".., >-
~.. C I
()Jl -;1
,..m ;r
>00
~s 21
"'JlN I
m,.
1n:l1::J I
~H 0 I
InOZ
"'ll....
3~. ~
. "'
-t. "l:I;
- ,.
~< -
~>>
I, Labor Subtotal.
Body
R,flnl.h
Nochan I c a I
!!!I.!.h ..!ill __.!.9l!l1
.1.8 30.00 I,m.oo
11.5 30.'lO 045,00
0.6 30.00 18.00
L.bor Subtotal 1,~17.00
L.bor 1., i 6.001 115.02
L.bor SUII.ry 10t.l. 63.~ 2,032,02
Ill. Addllional C..t.
laubl. CO!t,
5.1.. lal i 6,001
Nont.,.bl, Co.t.
10t.1 AdditIonal COlt"
"j.t4.!ll
25,),1)0
Il,OO
16MO
.28.00
Oat., 0.1111~5 0.,.2 P,N,
.at. :p; 38-7110-22201
Suppl".nt, 002 IPI O./I./~S
Proftl. 101 3032 15
.
IJJr
<r
J~ ~
(11 t
~-l "t
f'r-
-'/1"
1"1'1"
l'lri
::';/'
ll-
~: v
o'r.
,- iT
~C
....C
~~
'ti-c
;n~
r,;:C
m'"
~~
",
-.:::
<c
f:1~
r-
cu.to..r Allo..nc.,
0,00
C,"tour R~!pon!lbi I dy:
II. P.rt R.plac...n! SU"",
la,abl. Pa,t<
Pari. Adju.t..n"
Sal.. la, l 6.00X
Tot.1 R.plac,.,nt Part. Alount,
AlDunt
2,101.50
58,75
12I,eO
2,213,05
Point of I.pach 5 RIGHT REAR CORNER
80dy ShOpl UNK
I.
II.
Ill.
lotal Labor,
Total R.pl.c...nt Part.,
Tot.1 Additlon.1 COlh,
2,032.02
2,293,05
.IB.OO
Gra.. 10t.I,
.,153.07
161. 71-
N.l 10t.I,
.,491.36
\.l:;J:l . II: 11...10.1 III:~ 1\II,H,
".,J Ii, "V
( ~9.38)
,
'10"'
?,pi
~ ';; ~
,.~.
o .
~ - ~
,~ ~ ~
''il,
~ ~ ~
llo.._
~i ~
is fa e
." '
~F~
'" ~,
~ OI:!
~e~
n~j
In,p.ction Sit., FIELD 2-A
N.t Suppl..,nl A,ount,
IN CONPL/ANCE WITH SECTION 1827 OF ACT 6 OF 19~0:
ANY FERSON WHO KNOWINGLY ANa WITH INTENT 10 INJURE OR OEFRAUD ANY
INSURER FILES AN AFPLlCAlION OR CL,\IN CONI,\INING ANY FALSE, INCONFLETE
OR MISLEAOING INFORNATION SHALL, UFON CONI/ICTION, 8E SU8JECI TO
INPRISONNENT FOR liP TO SEI/EN YEARS ANa PAYNENT OF A FINE OF UP TO
IIS,OOO.
1~I";;'Cl'\", ,
II. CAUTION tI.
F~ILlNG TO PRESENT THIS ESTIMATE TO THE REPnlRING GnRAGE maRE REI
MAY RESULT IN ADDITIONAL EXPENSE TO 'IOU. ANY SUFPLEMENt TO THIS
ESTINATE KUST 8E AUTHORIZED 8Y A STATE FARN AOJUSIER.
NOTICE, REPAIRS TO THIS VEHICLE MAY REOUIRE SPECIFIC WELOING
EQUIPKENT AS REcomNOEO B'( TIlE MANUFACTURER.
} o. *
99.30"
'78'7.0:;.
886'41*
~
[!TlNAII RECALL MUNBERI OV011?5 1.,2.,3439-7110-22201
Hilch,ll Dola V...ionl APR.?5_A Copyright ICI 1?~0, Nitch.1I Inllrn.llon.1
All Right. R,.,r,.d
"9' 3., I '
. I
,.,"
, .
/'11.'. 1I1'II'Il I: 'rl " H
IlII :i.'lllj.,"':.:,!
j.jV~f Idlt'IJI,t lJ111 11'1 I}.I II ';1, ! I t 1 ' II II,
hili II.., 1111 HI \,' I',
.
.
.
,TiIT[ r ,i~'1l tltl I J',l 111)1I~hll( l
11" I liilf 11I1 ~I)"I, ,,:'4 '1I1!tf,/!l,,'III. 1"" I:"'"
I 'I I . ,j "II U ~
"J~ "II, 1I'll',n~lI:, ~l,_~~~III,; 1111, I,',II::"I!. f1,l.;E ('JltI,IU 1,1f.
IIIOI',.llV ~lllllb 1I~lllolf~. ..,.. "__...._
O""~',I' 1I,;">",..,l ~vl IJJllllElI.OUII~ ~')'lli,l)
')IIIHllt:lill'"b;",1 B'.II ~HIl CUIHl).'vl) I :~. j
r:.' ~lt: 'J t I. 0 , ~ I I, iJ III .' i illl I 'i~ll,. I
lJ.1l': 1,1 Lv):.' '.I~dJ'~, "I'!
Ol:'~tjd.t,I,:1 ~'.i,.',jjll
1,,,,,,...,jI JIIIIII II " 1I11uII f.IIIU, "
11,),10<>:,' 14;' "In I,H (IInlliL[ PH liVIHiji",
H'J/~ FII'JIIl:: IiI/I ':"Y'8'lN
! ~ ':' !. ' I I "" I I,
,
I, .1
U~>""~I"'" n~'1 II,UNUIII HllllIn,1 ,W iH'hli
VIII' "'II.Jf i ill.RU\:119ii
ll,.",e' IIltP'l6i
P,l
UlIVOLT' II
i',)I'" (oVe' ~IiIJP
,
'.'
I, lll~~ E'l L, v l Jl'ijr l i III: [tf.'rn
i_L!.:.!s li!m!h-L h~ ~'.LLt~UL- ~"I;riutiufL__________~
i'!v,'!O f~HII!. ',ill~ l LuB'iR Of'R ,UllIROOilf RltME IHU.IIDE, ',if.[ ,UP
N';,,)O 111CH '1I00L I.:'R~H U".iEIIH ,USPEIISrOtl IILII'dll'llIH
y'M,!.) 11HH '~DDllRBUR OPR'iET fROIH SUSPEIISIOH I~E'III
'1-)0,,),) RDU'I 'HOD l lllBDR OPi'HUil (UHI
, ~v~~l' BODI REMUUEiiEPLO(E WHEEL
H')[lj REf IH REf III1SH WHm
LlIIE nhR~IW ;,25,'J.)
RIGIII RERR
9'!v~,,),j ~U"1 .,UOJ')liRlPlllI.[ "M'iE STEIl
1'1 "'M'J'! BU~( 'IIO~'I LuBOR ,lf~';PlIi B,il.lIHCf mill if,,~ WllHl
,I :lv'H,', 800'( Rl1l0IJE,RlPlh'.E WIIEEL (o'm
,; Rl1illl HuR
L,JVII,'lv 8UO'( .k[llIltJE,RI,PlHlE 'RIGIIT RERR 1m
,I BUIlhllliil ,P HI~1I1 HAR TlkE '.1'),,'"
"I ~,;,j,:',; HIWi HUIU',:l:HILlii;l if.HR elR (llHS'iLE :i';.'"
',j 7I,lu\'I'i fRlill",,!!D l li,P'I)R 'H'R'PlIlL ~EllH !lul,R 1..11
81 i.'!>) 8UO'( n~IIiJ~[' ~EPLHCE R FR r 011 OR RW 'IIEW NIRR,)R
,:1 IlU10 HEflliil.fI,jI,1I Rf~TM~111~hO~
: 1 ~IO,j~,j 81101 111,11,11 .~ REt,R OOIlR SHEll
Jl~/aD BOU" RlP~il 'iUUf PlIlIEl
HI)[O RtF lit W IItI'iH RUUf P:IIIEl
Q,llO,\D aWl HE!'UJII"kUL:IC[ BHlK WIiiOIJW IUJlJlDI"ti
Y'iO,'jV BWI ',IDO L LhBUR OPR";UUItD OE,lDEHIIII; PHvl
dll140 81101 REIlUUE/RE'l~(E R QUARTER UUTER PhliEL
HUfO kE/IH REflllllH R QURRTER PltliEL UUTSIDE
. OUTD RE/IH REfl~IIH R 'HHlL EOGE
~IJTO kEFlH in IHI';H R LQ(K PlllhR
,.rt lyp.1
. fJl,t IIIJ.b~,
IIJ8lH
IU8lH
IUBlH
..Ol/hl mL PIIRT
OUAL RECYCLED PRRl
"QllhL REPL PHRI
[mTII~r,
5U'JII~la441)
..g'lIll. REFL PIIRI
i,j,;O- ~:1I1"1111
j'JBW
3,~ lil),) . !~I~.J I
H,'I!".;a'lI),j
"ijUltL REPL PhRf
1I~")4'l810,j
Ihi; l:',.CllAoJtl! htJ':i ~t.'e'A 'I:'"CI.k,Jl..tll",j With ,I .'llli'fjl4.J pj'll)fil~,
d
l~'
IINli HiC~ll HUMBER' D/il);,1~ 1,;:1,1134
"ell D.tij Ue'1Io,,' IIPR '!j I)
i/j-lIl')'W.1
Copvrl~~t ICI 19YD. NiL,"~11 Inltrndlioll.1
~ II R i 'lht; Rl."~l!r Vti',J
'11'''9.' \),m
00 II., L~bQ'
liwllL M\.
l'yo. VI)"
JI,'j~.
0,6'
II,QO. ~,I'
J\ ,1;0' 0, J
G.5
3,15
1.1')'
0,4'
31,12 Ij,l
\.,~O.
\,1,'
IO,UO' ,),)
00,01),
119.'1\ I),)
C 0,",
I,Q.
~.l\t
C t.9
ll,6/' I
ll.O~' 0",
m,IB \UI
C 1.1
'l.5
C ,1,5
P",lt I ot }
"
'"
"
:JJ~
m.
UlJ;
m,.
~'I;
,."
...=
<~
m,.
'"
.D;::~
~t;r<
"2'
o. .
1<1~
~ ~ ~
:l Q ~
;~ ~ ~
~ ~;;
~1~
'\!
o~~
"" .
~r '::
., c: -~
(l~ 8 P
~. z >
,;~n t
.... \":
~ 'i
70...;:
"15 2
0"-
~~~
'~ "
~ .
o <
~ "
v;6~
0,,;';
<'50'_
fA
U
F
~M
?i'f
; ~~
, '
,.
OJ'"
...'"
,.Ul
c.n~
~"
"",
"'m
m;c:
"'m
"Z
:D-<
;c:Ul'
('):1),
r;8
-c
;c:-
~~..
m"
:ll:l1
f;lO
m:D
~~
>.;:3
-0
<< '
m,. ,
'"
..
\
.......
" ""'.1 :1 "
I: II' 11,11
..vi
",I II " IliI,tI"
.
, .
.
I I,' ' jlll "1',11".
'dj~'11 :. ~I~:'I' t I ,.., I 11'1
,""dlt.,. ill! II ': I'
~.~ ,
.
.
iJ ,"j ". ~ .J'}'J"
I,'" j
I, I.'
1;,1, 1,11,1,
L IJ,,'
I: ~.: ~" S
I'j"
\
:", ':-,u ['1'111 .U'HI. -I ullll~IlH UUIlH 1'1I1,ll
"'''I ~diol Hllill;11 l U,jnf,llH ,'lltllll)III',(,'
" ,~" t,VI', Hhlll\o('nl.l,'ll H UVHHII~ lUll 0'1111'
.1',,) tlU lil .It 1111',11 II tlltl UIJI)H
,:",." 00('" W:','.'l,l,ltlll U'IHHIH t~H I'II,)H hllfll',llllfll
J..."" 1'001 HUII)';l !.bLII',[ ',I~lf'l lIill lllll lhtH Oft,l'l
oV', ',\.\ bO" k[~H" .R UOi,HIIH IIINEn ~lIllll
mill HU 111!'ii/mIIIH H OII"HIlR INIIIR PIII!il
IllllllUl'i rUll
H UUt/kltH Vihl \klLli
H IJlIllkll" lIE [HIIH"
k OOllklEIl HULr
ll1bG,iIrE LIL' hlllll
IIIGI,,,,;1 LID OUISIOl
LUGGHl,l LID UllOEk\lOI
I Illf 11,1~~ II? L'~ 'I"
J:,'O',,) ~vOI 1111 Oil 'k llloo"vi II, "1111.1
J!;liI'l BUOI HlIoll -l lIJI;G"CI LID lIlIliiE
U;;)',') BOOY kElltl'l[:klPlIICE lUGCIIG!, LID Wllillll~,f~lf'
ggulou UU~I IEMUvE/REfLACE ~IA~ BU~I PIIlIll
"UfU fiEf III hlf 1111\11 HH~ BOOY PI/Ill
,,'Jill m III REf 1i11>11 AGO fOil !tfSluE
11"'.1';:' UOuY Hi'III; 'HEHA Ol)ul fluO~ f,lll
1,lll'J Hf'lH REf 1/11\11 REAl EOIIPliRltlllll fLI)II/
8')I':.'~ \)001 REIItJ'!E/kEf'lIl(E R REAR euoI TRill "il,EI.
BO~jJ; BOOl REMOVE/REPLHCE R REAR BUO! cm~ARrMEHT IIII~
a'lv;?1 OliOI HIWVliREfll;(E II COMBINllTlOIt lliHP tt';mIBU
!;,IJO BOO I AEMUulilEPLACE REAR BUMPER (OVER
"Uil) mill kHlIlIIII IEHR COVIR
UI.lly BOOI AEnOUI/liPlHCE REAR BUMPER COUER nlGG
U!6iIO BOOI REl1Uvl:nHtHCE ~ HEAri CUMHIt :~Oulllliil; BRmu
a/.H'J 8UOI kEMOVEoREPLhCf. ~EHR BI111PEI E illER 10 BUllrER
1I11l0 REf lrl REf IIHSII IEHR lWR E lLI.EII P(,"El
IJlul+ Ouul REMUVE/RifLAlE -BAIIEIY
BEIIEkMEll1 - P BIIITERI 110,vU
'~vlvO BUOI -RlNUvi,AEPlHCE 'IT filL lAMP MT BHIIC~EI
AUTU IEfl1l 1100 l lReOR UtR CLEAR COAl
';';"'.11 HOD l (Ihl fUWlIl,;
"UTU HUv l ll)>I t'\illlT 11HTERllIl\
. J11,j'_ll'llt:llt Itt1f
~ " I.Jl\l)f Il,)tt! HOp 11e~
l. [r!l~ 111,j,!.J III L Il!M (,)Jt (.j Ie
~..;;, adO. ~lrOOI)[ ~rtIHl(
,,,,IV'J ~OUi "frIO'il/,Ul,,':1
,',,":',i BOOt WIi)VE,Rtrll,(1
J:,.'I) HOuY REMUVE.REPIIILI
HI1111 RlFIN ~Efl~I\1t
IIUI'J Will REfI~I'111
'.~:'
,;, R(CII,liu OW, lI0 (All tllll H tlURrll .; ';UUrll A'Il'! 1"1"
, . iJ '.I .I. ",~ -11 )
: U REmlE~ wllm ClIll mill Hf AUlllllER'i ww '.I~-'II)I)')
Ill',', 'j",. .~I'UIJ
.'ll,l.' ~ ' ~: l ,j IJ ,)
'S
'j
1,0'
I.U'
'I;~ il'. :;]rIIJII
'i~o:>'J'll0"'J
W"1~41.\J
Udlll REflClIQ PHIr
:,1<) IIICl I
1,8.
,)",0
1 i;, IJIJ. O. ~,.
CU
1.1
\U~
sml-IS'))')
, o'/I'i')'I~lv')
',1,',"11
',u..
u
u.
I..
V,8
/,U-;
1.0
18.11 IHCl
/Q,BI ~,l
45,52 IHCl
)55,41 0,4
C 2,4
19, H IHCl
IJ,l5 0,2 I
.3,11 0.6 I
CU
54,4)' 0,2'
U1
21.32'
,10.95
141, i5
C
G5lol)-,SOI)I)"liQ
95I,\I).za,jdHU
, 910101'18150
8~o'1I-19d5')
96011,290')1)
9600\/. 29Ud')
86m-m'I')
nUIJAl REPL PAR'!
IIEW
/,5'
IOUO.
IIO,UO'
r~il .~ll.dle ~d; been 't',.I,,,I,,t.,J .it~. oo,Jirl.d pro/lie,
iI~li HllMIL HUrmU' oj/,UI/VI 1,pl'II)~ JS-1I1v-lllUl
1o~11 O.t. V.';lo.' ArR 95" C.V'"i'I~IICI 1""1. tI'tr.~.III.ttln.tiu...1
Itll, ~ l'_lht i ~P.;~'Ull'tf
'.'.1. / or
[B
1>
rnr- -j
,< r- :t
~~ ij;
'/l- -
--1~ (/.
~r- Z
-4'11 C
r'I1:: _.
"/11 :.-
>z ;.:
::J_j :=>
~'/l r
lJ '.
i],..,-::
~o 9
;'.~ ...
::JJP'
~m 1>
m" _
~B is
mo Z
~JJ ~
'zl>o 0
..." J:
>" ...
=~ ;:
<< --
0'1". ,1:
,-
.; -=.- .
,~, ~ ~
c'" 't] _
? ,., '"
-. ~ = -
o~;,~
:ll~~~
'~d:" :E
7.~"
< .c
n ,<
~ :~ rl ;
~~~~
g~d~
"' ~ ~;;
~F t'l ~
.~..
'.. :;:
,., n,..
~~~~
Q8~::
.' -
~~~;;:
. ~ " ,=
'" 'i-
O. 2 ~
-"'tnC1"'
~", r.:
"'C' ~ '-0
o <-
e-.,s
~(!J?:;::
~ =:~:=
0_:,;
..!I"
~9:
-,.'-
~i2f::
.;;1=
,] ~
,.'3.
lIE)
..
"'... -
-<r =
>Ul ;::
(/)~(..
;:;3 .
-<m
rn;: -
"'m
.z 4:
JI.,
;l;'"
~~ ...
>0,'"
i:S ~
JIll"
",'"
::l~ c
"'0
"':0
m"
Z'O
-'."
"i13'
-,
- )
<< -
rn,. ,'J:
r
.
"
.
, .
.
I. l J~'II JIILII.'II, ,1.,
l;.."",
h',ttlll,.,h
fI~...h'HlI',,11
l'l~pr 'i'UI~I'J1 V
~..i
e....
. .
....~:Hlt~l tq, II ',II,' lPlj" '1,
" I Vi 'II, 'II" ::Oil
, '~
""lvplt"l~hr.1 IIIH li'l 'N 1t.'J~t IJtlJ H.M.
PloIldl:" Itl! \11 II I',
....,
.
.
.
l.IHZ ,l)~
2, 1;\,.1
'lla,l)'i
..
lOr-
..r-
..~
"'''
;:;S
...".
ms:
"""
""
~i;;
pi"
~~
]J~.
m"
~~
mo
m:r
~~
~:E
<0
m<
..
r-
(I, VJI t H"'I,I'I,,':'lIl:llt, ')'tl/I~LJr'/ ._._n_~'
1,1\,.'(II~ ~"II'~ I,lIli.''',
P"r L Id PI JU"l'I,\ ",',I "ll
').)\1':\ It!,,j 0,"1';; 1..-1 I:
r')!dJl /It:VI'I''I.'Ill~lIl ~Mt) Illl1lJIHllI ~.l'?...o'
'll\.l.lJ, _Hili .__!:J!Jb
,.l.1f hi, VI} I.:~'~ ,I}II
Z l . ~; ,\ Ii , I) I, \J .1 r, . t, I}
.)," }IJ ,I,UI la,IIU
l'JblJr Jubt.)t'JI I,? 1/ ,tit}
ldu,,, rd' ~ .,YU;; II~,'J;
1.1,1. 61,) I.UI/,o:
~1J.Jit lIiltal (IHtoj
\'t...,I,11;' tlJ:.h
'it! It:., 1,p.1 I), ')ll~
It'Jlll.Pdbj,~ (ij~t:,
l.t.1 ~~~ILi.".1 Co,\,'
,..,._Itl,^I'W,\
L ';-1/ , 1~IIJ
li,').1
10,),1)1)
iilJ.ljl'
I IvL.lI L,b",'
11, r tJ l,f I H ell 1...," L'1~I:tl t P Jt ~ ~ I
III. I"LJI ,l,I,I.t,~""I'>J~,bl
III
I, 11-; t I' n " ~ , II I I, ~ II ,II, " ,,' I
U, lJ::'~ lut..11
~.l"l.o'l
11,1'111
111",hltll'" HI~~I""I.' i h 11 'II III
;' ,I ll.. tjl~ ~ rill ,Ill,
Lt';..~ tll~'/I'I'1) Ilt:t hHdl1
H~t ~'Jp~dttlleot Illl11lmt I
II, HI ~'~
) 1 t;jV.., 1 ~
/8I,Ui,/
gi~
~ e
" -
o "
:4" ~
<:Ie:;
~~~
,.,!a:
~ ~ ~
~ '1::.
>1'Jo
a ~ j;
-:~;i:
. - .
<~' ~
m -
~I~
. .
!I ~
~ ~
~, ~
'im~
,.~.
o .
M -
~ ~
il ~
~a'
II
, ~:!
,illt v, Irnpdct' "R!f.HI REAR CORllf,R
Bu,j. II,,?, UKK
III'p"ctio" lit". fiElD 2"1
1
I
I
I
i
, ,
III r.UI,PUFilICE WITH SWliJlI IUU OF her. III 1'/,/.)1
~lIt I'ER';OIl WHO K'lOWIIIC,l't .1110 Willi III1EHI 10 INJURE OH Om,1UU MI!
IIlIlJRER filES ,lit ,lPPUtHIlOII OR (L1I1M COIIIIIIIIIII& 1111'1 filllE. IIICOMPlElE
OR tIlSLEHOI/U; IIlfOR/1AflOI! SllHll. UPOH COIW!CflOII. HE SUellCI II)
INPRISOiltlElI1 fOR OP 10 SEVEII mRI 11110 P,I'(l1ENI Of ~ f IIIE Of UP 10
$15,iJOO,
...I (tiUl[ult UI
flllllNG 10 PRESEllr IHII ESlln~rE 10 rHE REflllRIIIG GRkllilE BEfORE REPAIR
IIII'( RESUlT III AOOlrlONAl DPEHI( 10 '(00, All'! SOPPlEMEIIT 10 THII
ESrlllHIE HUll BE AUIIIORIiEO B{ 11 SrAIE FORM 1I0JU'ilER,
IIOrICE. REPIIIRS 10 THII IEHIELE N~Y 'E~I)IRE SPECifiC WELUING
E~'JIPIIEllr H5 RECOHllUlOEO Bt m 1'lflliUfHC rU,ER,
I~I~ r~II..lr hdi u.,It ,~-c~IC'J1ll..1 wllh J< ..,Jir'i.,J' p,.hl..
"IAIl RlCAll HUM1lU' OlI01,9~ 1~'14li"
"h.1I D"i. V.";Ult' APR ,~~ ,H
J8.71lo-lllOl
eo,U,ighl lei 199'1. H;lc~.11 Inl.'It.llon.1
All Riyht, R.,.,.~d
,_,..-_.._..."l.
'~
,."
h. )
MontgolMl)' Ward
Car ReDial
LICENSEE
3~ )
CAM,\"
1702 HARRISBURG PIKE
CARLISLE, PA 17013
(717) 243-1505
/
Slandard
Renlll
Ag,umlnl
Slllemlnl
A:iii,nll'.---- - - 1-------
.1J.I\IC~___3_O"~Q..'J..
~'~n.l'VthlCl.llctnU
,o~023~...\IA.,
~I~~f("-:~ /1 J /9 5
~I,~:r!~,~~~~1~j~..
Mill I I
Plll. _ -).. I _ .il' J '
:.:.l.r.. __ 1._ .c.~_J-.~
~ L ~7d) :
ShQw Thl1 Numb';
All Co"..pond,nct
~fltnliJI
V.hlel,
for wo/rdwide reservations
contact your travel conSUllJllt
ore.1I
HOO.FOR.CARS'.
( 1'800.367-2277l.
-~&lfH)HI.{..!)fHYER""
D." .OJt;;"W ,q"J.~&-:Hrt.t&
,
,.. ~.l': J,L
", ,
A.nlln.1CII! ~nl"IlCit" R,"5..!.!~_'''i..C,'t\, "::.l 1- '" lI!:r, I
nm.6M;"I,&g.--. ---,~n;;"~:i;'''' ...... au' - :.~ i ,') ~~2; ;...
TuTppp--~.- -- .---- p-ow '-il;i~-F" ~- --. - Mik . jDl;"~._ ---{-- ; - : -fim,---OY06-1-9-5-- 16: 2 S
'.':")' : ,') (J)' Un' 23 Days 18 H:r.',
...... "L
LfiiOt~;rt--'--- -Mi;C------.-~--- .A.~I~-AK~l!.OiRIGi -- ~Q.-~- ---:. -r-; -- '~TI~-;----t=--T-
~_L....._.l ...._ ,.._'" ..'__,.....,....., L.... ---,- -_...-aOo. --1-::-
('\ r-I,1 II'" 'rc,,1 '''' 'I.! ~..... c! I ~,'.~, . I 11., ,~.i" ,'1 7~. n
fr.quo;;U~er ______._..___1 'l~tIU - l. Ellnll' - r~ Ih..,IiJ,r-:Wtr ml~lnlll~t\ 1 -. - - Wii- -~hw ---~
NUlT1btl 1-. rl~,ajmu"bt @
Wii~i~'I I t I . I .---.---r-,- ----~ Rtl1'1l --~ Hr.
I I . . I I . . I .
~~;nN _ .x-n]' .2_--L_'rr~l -----L....-rl --!. - I - -. - vtllldlll'lUI. O.y' __.!1!-.
c.o:,,:_~___, _~....._L~~'JT~:':~ RII'eo:....... :;::::.~ge R".""'"~ .----
~~N~.~'~~-:~~:~.~~~:,' "..,1 ~l~~' ;I~'::~:;>~.~~ :~:~~:?~..~~,~,~ :~~ ::.~_
,I pow ICl;eplod: I mI," ctltI9H
:::~-"--;OIlU ;~~~~~==J:~~;;~~;~:,~~~., $0 Surchlogt
A"b.,f -err, $1'lhl lip ~O,:.~n.o
~Al>'("ll~U1~_.._-,~...---_.,,--ri\..I'.'J).u..... $8,95,:
Orhll1 Lk,nlf No. $111111 "r~
....f,.~1~+.7.r.1O oi""h"-"--'rw"Qh" -rH"G'h;"~f"A"--- G'
...Ll.1..!~:l.a,Lc~' -.o.Y..1S,L6-1l-,.....:.., ",,___,..l ',.:.......
L6e1jeiJnltcl PtlOI\I
..__.._..,.._.._........................,...--..u,....... "
,t(jdlllonllllnrorl1'lallon
f'FlAI P'PERCEHIRGE O'OAILY
IJ!)oIJHf1ER.~&flf'iER-,.
.c~ *-.~._.._ 0.1; and "flm~ o:+~2 / ~_5
10:0~
1.75 0
~75 0
, ~..
"
, ~
"
luabl,
RafUlI~Q StMct
x~x
~?5 0
Relli,linlJ Sel"llc4C/l .
,1...l,li~ PetGaJlcwI
Surc:tlarQ' 2. ofitlJ'
^' p , 6,'lOCI
A~C~;S T;wF..2.~O l)
Nun,~ulbl'
A,'ulling Stl\'ltt
Mlac,Ctllrg.. "1\
& Adju'lmtnta "~
5
o
R~fIJ~t'lnq r.hMq~ a~pllt?s if c:lr Ii "'l~UI'ill?d toIdh It-"l'i f'JI? GJ
A,1cJllI~enW(R.II!.r'.lntlllll'lln;;n.dT.--. ----r:"o;'--- + --- r-::- ~~9~
...aus ,'Ie '~~'ILOlk',l Dr: Ci c~ry-~-- -51111.------ -Zlp'- - 1),,(
_ L ~~",..BAZ;H..V...._.
O,hlfsllC"n&o Nr) I
:II
'....--.........r........'..'........
lixpolu Oateol'Uhlh
--.- ----,.- -'--.. ..- .
IIMEX
Personal P3SMnqctr
.- '~.Jlaii7P;Q~~_._- Prlllecllon (PPP)
pjii'14CCiiiYfo.-l p"p-----
[W;'IUtll--..-[il8i~lhi--+' -~C:;i~------ '11'ltooorl 011
E~u
_ -. .---- -.----_._--- -.-.----
un 3.QQ
~ ,
$3.00
I
o
Me
51f3c
::5"' I
- :;).1.
Pllf~nQ,IEJfK1'
Co~eraQl (PEel
"Tc"ACCiPfii) I"IC---'
. !.I ~ OICUH(O
. VISA
.
DC
p,--
. os
I _
d 0\1l~
CO
. ltlnrty'-
I C'5H ''") ) 00
: ::;;;.~"" :~~~;.,,:~.~ pow, ,~.~,~~, '~Iij,~;;;,..,,,
.t I' mw! lor IILlt, MW own pe;$tin".lJlO tnlUfll'lC' Il' bllllllt, ort.flll1tlrOUllh my (flUII
c . m,., covlr II 01 PI'f>>i11l lint. I Il.. '''Mul II 11Il! undlrltlntJ my
J~ . II Ice . AI 10 mlli /l)vldl4 to Wou by m. .n
_~ nllll r ~
.J 1G",,,ru ~"I 'IIIJ .;;;;;i,..'" '~Ilf"; ~;;J"..., 1M. t l'l,cllll l.u"'III\1I ,~\1
.. .~ f''''~ (4,. .O\I~".', " ..., Inr I""V-' 11",1" I"" '0'"''''
_=:,;::..-:-===-.-----;~;.:l:::~=.===
0'+22 2218
I n~ 0611
JOHIlIAIlC;-1Z/9S
:'3'''[ COUUelL
.0 ,~
563 0
..... Voucllff
~1Ild1'C1l, Amount ____.n '.
....., c...
"-' C4l1ecl..J
0.. [- ...0..
A.!:"" ,Thl1flY
Ail\indf..'d~
~'..
Dilly
11I1.
""
"",PI
TlJOIIOO Iflf)l lr)lIIM:)()O
rl'llilt~ 1111"',11.(01/ ';y"I",lI_ I,..:
RWC ~H~RGE~CY PgYSICIANS
117 0 TH ANOV R ST
CARL S E P 17 13-2442
38-232259396
03/02/95
$.......33,21
,\lues
ACCT I 8637019/01 22 1 NICHOLE DAILEV
DOS. 02-04-95
eal/luG-f"
MEDICAL PAYMENT
600.1 'lJ,2!
. TED BY
MLchalLo Hoffman
i-
fUlL
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
PENNSYLVANIA Ofl!CE PNr. NATIONAL BANK 62-15/511
COHCOAOVILlE, PA
Harrisburg 13.114'
1 13 534699 J
DAI! 03/02/95
u_.,_, CO'VE'AGC'-- "
MED ICAl PAYMENr
600,2 'lJ,ll
" NO
DAlE
<EO
38-7110-222 POLICY NO 6776-257-38E 001 CLAIM UNIT 521
02/04/95
BAILEY, JOHN
. .... ................ ............u... ..... ................. .....EXAC rL Y TH I q TV. THREE AND 21/100 COLLARS $.... ,* ,11:,..... 33. 21,
lt1lt!
~'II~~ ....L'-'h.;L4i~J: ',:ii.:i';J.~.i/\L'1';
117 NORTH HANOVER ST
CARLISLE PA 17013-2442
I1N 38-232259396
AUIH SERNE
'jC1...
~~
I\PPROVEO BY
m'.,_,_,...._,..._ j
.. .,' . . p.,' '.' -.
NO 38-7110-222
POllC' NO 6776-257-38E 001
lOSS DATE 02/04/95 DRAFT Ho 1 13 534700 J
DATE 03/02/95
AMoo" $ . . . . . . . 3 3 , 2 1
RWC EMERGENCY PHYSICIANS
117 NORTH HANOVER ST
CARLISLE PA 17013-2442
,
38-232259396
Sg~T ~2~8~~~~5/01 22 1 DOUGLAS BAILEY
_.____"_._..u___.,__.____.__.._.. --------, I
l MEDICAL PAYME~~VERAGE J: I'
I 6DO'~ '33,21
In_'u_____....__ '___'_h_ '
'0 BY Michelle Hoffman
8" STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
'.. PENNSYLVANIA OFI'ICE PNC NATIONAL BANK 61'151311
# CONCOROVlllE, PA
"C\ Harrl5bur'] 13-114
_0 38-7110-222 POLICY '0 6776-257-38E 001 ClAI" UNIT 521
Ale 02/04/95
o BAILEY, JOHN
1 13 534700 J
DATE 03/02/95
j' -_..- .--- ------.-.CO.VERAc-t-.------ -- - .--.~
MEOICAL PAYMENT I
60D'~ ']].~, I
,
I
, I
"..,-------------,---'
,.......................................".""uuu......" ""IiXACfL Y TH I IITY- THRle A~O 21/1QO OQLLAAS $.~,.At'~','.tT":i"'jj."!~'~y,.'..,~,'I'
, ,~,,'~,,\,~.~,t*,<Oj
I..
f RWC EMERGENCY PHYSICIANS
117 NORTH HANOVER ST
CARLISLE PA 17013-2442
"N 38-232259396
~rE
~
~
APP.OVED BY
AUTH
1M NO
"
,',RKS
,liED BY
.......
.
'....I~
1M NO
:i DArE
IJRF,O
38-7110-222 POL 1<;' NO 6776-257 - J8 E 001
1,05S DATE
ORAIl NO 1 13 946083 J
DATE OJ/20/95
,AMOUNT $............. 7,44
, 'tovE;AO~ ,- -_..-,
If MEDICAL PAYMENT
600.2 $7.44
1
I
1_
1 13 946083 J
DATE 03/20/95
""r-' . C-O\iER"AGE
MEDICAL PAYMENI
600.2 Sf J,4
. ....."'......... '" ..."'. u.. ......... '" ............u.......... ........ ..II.....exAcrL y SEVf;'N AND Mt/l00 DIJLLARS $:~. .."'-.,~:'~-:;.-*i..:4~'1
{,} the:
'<'r IJf
~aBL~~&~2~~S~~~~kR ST
CA~LISLE PA 17013-0)10
38-232141105
~g~T #o~~a~~~~ /
SARli SA I LE~
MicholltJ Hoffman
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
PENNSYLV~NIA OFFICE PNe NATIONAL BANk 62,151111
CONCOROVILlE, PA
Harrllsburg 13.114
38-7110-222 POLICY NO 6776-2~j7-38f; 001 CLAIM UNIT 521
02/04/95
BAr;,E'i, JOliN
C~RLISLE HOSPIT~L
BOX 310-246 PARKER ST
CARLISLE PA 17013-0310
TIN 38-232141105
AUIN SERNE
~e
" '.' _' .,_ ,,,'.,. .,_....... ,.. .._. _'h'",,,,,_,, _....."., .. "' . .
. . ,~,",'...'..v ..._...., .". .... ... ..... ~......~ .., ... u....... ,... ..........
f''P
APPROVED BY
:M NO 38-7110-222 POLICY NO 6776-257-J8E 001
1055 DATI
"'.
. ..........",,,....',.,- .......
..
........"..-...... ".... ......., '.
02/04/95
DRAFT NO
DATE
AMOUNT
1 13 945057 J
03/07/95
$...........400,00
I THRIFT~ CAR RENTAL
~~~~ Pt~~~Y~~u~~A~f~g
CARLISI,E PA 17013
'.RKS
'TED BY
" ,~,.
.
'''.I~
:."l NO
; OAr!
,IRED
38-2J1990003
Scot~, E~ney
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
PENNSYLVANIA OrPICE PNe NATIONAL BANK 62'15/311
CONCOROVllLE, PA,
Horrisbur~ 'J.l1~
38-7110-222 POLICY 140 6776-257-38E 001 CLAIM UNIT 521
02/04/95
BAILEY, ,10HN
C':E'~;XRE IMB~~~~~/'N'
" \01,1 $400,00
1-
1 13 945057 J
DATE 03/07/95
I RENTAL REI~9~~~~~~~~E
101'1
1_.. ,
I
I
I
um,____J
S400,OO
...............................................................E~ACTLY 'OUR IiUNOREO AND 00/100 COLLARS
$ il, t ..ili;'~'.o ~;'O:ii
. .. " f .... ,.. ,'. '-"""10 ~. .", ",,'. .'. ,..~,. .. ,1
{O th_
'fa/,
THRIFTY CAR RENTAL
DBAI BUCKLEY LEASING
1702 HARRISBURG PIKE
CARLISLE PA 17013
TIN 38-231990003
AUTH S ERN E
;1.
"l'
APPROVID BY
CLAI" NO
PAlE I
IIN
REMARKS
CRIA lED BY
u... "..
A
''''\lU.'\
CLAI" NO
LOSS DAlE
INSURED
f~SYSlN2~B ~ONTlA~
NEW ~uAilEIlLA~D PA
38-231491072
lNe
17070-1103
1 13 948405 J
04/17/95
$......886,41
COLL;SIO~ (l.;.~~ERACi- '------'-j
400'~ '886.41
1 13 948405 J
DAlE 04/17/95
"""";;'f.~"":~.']
......................................................E>lACTL Y E tGHT HUNDRED E lCHrY'SI X AND 41/100 OOLLARS $:.'..;,,,"'~'~~.~.ij)l.t~~.'~!
PllY {() fh~
Vrdu of'
CLAI" NO
PAYEE
IIN
REMARKS
CRIATED SI
'A"
"U\I U... II
CLAIM NO
LOSS DATE
INSUReD
SUPPLEMENT fOR JOHN BAIt.E:Y' S HYUNOAl
Scott Erney
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
PENNSYLVANIA OFFICE PNC NATIONAL BANK 6~'1\/31'
CONCDRDVILLE, PA
N.rrl.burg 13'114
38-71io-222 POLICY NO 6776-257-38E 001 CLAIM UNIT 521
02/04/95
BAILEY, JOHN
FREYSINGER PONTIAC INC
100 E 15TH ST
NEW CUMBERLAND PA 17070-1103
IIN 38-231491072
AurH~E
~
APPROVED BY
. '- '~'..:. .:~::'.;':~~":.~,;':'....;:\".~::. :Z::;' 7":- ::';::::.:-'.
38-7110-222
LOIS OAlE
02/04/95
ORAl T NO
DATE
AMOUN T
1 13 947565 J
04/06/95
$......199,00
SOUTH MIDDLETON TWP AMBULANCE
POB 218
BOILING SPRINGS PA 17007
TIN
Aurif
38-232328647
S ERILE
L/C
. - ~:- --:.-: ~":~'.: ':'-;".~':;- ..;:' '~:':',.,';" ~;.:'~':'-~'~':-::'~:'~": ::":~':=:-;:":,:;,:;,,..:-_':: ~::-:-..: :.,.:-:.::-.:..:.,~.,:.. ::..
POLICY NO 6776-257-38E 001
SQUTH MIDDLETON TWP AMBULANCE
POB 218
BOILING SPRINGS PA 17007
38-232328647
~~~6l~EP~To~g8a~~^L1DOUGLAS BAI~EY
Michelle Hoffman
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
PENNSYLVANIA OFFiCe PNC NAI/ONAL 8ANK 6~'1\/l11
COHCOAO~ILLe, PA
Harrlsbur~ 13-114
38-7110-222 POLICY NO 6776-257-38E 001 CLAIM UNlr 521
02/04/95.
BAU,EY, 'JOHN
- M;D ICA~' ~'A;ME~~VmGr- - --]
600";!- 1199,00
\ Y'~I"S-
-------
1 13 947565 J
DAlE 04/06/95
10 MEDIC~~-;~Y~E~~ViRAGE-~
600,# 1199.00
l .. _ ___, \ 4,.)\''1)-
................u.........................................UCTLy ONE HUNOA!O NINElY-NtNI AND 00/100 DOLLARS $:';~<,!:
Pa, to 'hI
0,1111' of"
'. ~ 'J(.I
f jtt~.
'q:P
APPROVID II
APR-I3"7-90 F'R 1
:STIMA TE
OF
REPAIRS
11 :".~ F" '''''SI~,c.:;ER~IHJU'(
I
.717
1.'-";)")';2
FREYSINGER PONTIAC, Inc.
MAZDA . ttYUNOAI . MIT5UI3ISIll
JDY SHOP, 100 E, 15th STREET' NEW CUMBERLAND, fA 1/0/0 - (717} 77034G ~::"7) 774,7992
,~O CARS. 1537 BRIDGE S Tf1EET ' NEW CUMBERLAND, I'A 170.,0 - (117) 774,"055 c.7r" .'-
W CARS, 6251 CAflLlSLE PIKE ' MEC~IANICSBURG, I'A 17055... (717) 766,8422 0,10 -,L 1.J/-?
mojtJJn:dU~.W~~n .. Addr0511L.lJ.,..AuYnAL..__.,. CII~.r.4,$.!e..,--.. Phono__..__,.
". .Ji;.tu~, V.ar :l!t__ 5."..1 N/{@..IiZL1!:2:&~dJ:l.f.;!/.ft:f..L__ Body S'~I. __ "/#t:..- Modol ~7Y~(
teage _,_~____ Llconse No __..~.___.____ Paint No. _._..__.._________ lrlm No. ___ lnuuranco Co. -.'---'
iE ~-~.=-=-=-...:..-;=--=''''''-~.=-:- -....""'-'...J:L:::::::::.:::..=.:::.::.::.:~~;<:=:.:~=..:::~=-"'.., ~~kAeoFl ---=----===--
;.IF1 PL,^CE EsmAA1E OF REPAIR COSTS PAINT TIME HR~. PARfS
-==;r;~-=="-O'=-==O"-=7=''''O~'""=-~-~~~-'-'-=<= ==,0--= c._ ~,='-,
.~ ~.IlilI...Je._~?Y:.n_1f3~.//Jt2...:,_~,- ~~/
--'
X- ,~;Lik~../l!bMi;;'~a;;;~Icl..:~~~~:=~~~=~_~~,'~ -== -- ....-..- -,
v .-j f'l.,.. /, /., #., 1",,/"4~
\ I "1" ','.' "" ,", .' ,,,'-,.
L W.J1kr L6l4-ft2.!e...:.__.!.)" ~!:._o..:!.~/..0~..:J_<J...______.
ZUBLET
x
~
'<C
- -,-- ..------.-,..,..--'----;;--J;'--,......,---....,' ..'--
- y - gdo/-_-..-_JP~ -~-..=-
- -- --;--~~LU;;&&ts.I..:~Z;;4!:r;~'..=~(;U!'dl --~
L. - ~t4--LUpL---,-.._..._--,--~..---t-....
-=~-= :~;-~=~~;:m~~~-;;i~-
.... ,(A-d _..__Iif.tdJl'l!er~ - -
-::----::=-.-*1--' 7'
~~ :~f3j~~ ----- ......-------
~H'.t:-//e_A!f;LJ;?5 '
x:
~
-------_.__._---~-_._-_._.------------ -
_~7~/!'n-t~~5-' _, ~... -~~:~-~.:...=~-. ~~
==---",--=,--,,=,-=
=
rOT AL
,.
.~ -,.
I'. lbOI/O Is an t"lmale, oascd cn OlJr in3plfctlon. d."d Con nof e'O'IQr Mdlflonal
MIS or 141)o( wniCI\ mi)'f b, r,qulr,d iller If\~ work n.. b.en opeMl!d lJp. Oeca.
onauy. :&fter worle I'lu 11.a.I''I'.d, worn, brok,n or damllgeoj p.rI~ .VQI di'lcoveted
I'Ilch Ita nof .vh1.nr on II'SI 'nSl)edlon.
BODY
LASOA _,___ H~S. [41_____ t ~_.
PAINT
'-"BOR _,_ HRS, '" .___ ._
IJO'~T10NS ON PARTS AND L~BOR ARE CURRENT AND SlJaJECr TO PARrs.LESS
H~NGe,
.. 101
I
,
.
I
pA.INr MATIiFIlAL_
STlM~'1! M~DE 8V _
w'horiutlon ftef A.p."." You J'" tl.rollbv 'UI/'ldriU1J 10 fTl.a~. lh. "b::;-~~~-;;;~
.\ 11'1.. elt d,.crIOtd l'I.rt,n.
'SUBLET
orHER CHARGES _~_.__
ION~O __________ OAfE ___.._.~____ H"'l. W...~Te RiM. ____________ t
rH'flNn rOTal
I
.
rAX _______.__ 'It I
,
FREYSINGER MAZDA - HYUNDAI
I1II!IZDII
6115 CARLISLE PIKE
MECHANICSBURG, PA 17055
(7171897.8899. (800) 828'()678 · FAX: (717) 697.2145
<l8>
HYUnDAI
ALL CLAIM~ AND ~ITU~NID 00001 MUIT II! ACCOMPANIID BY THIS BILL.
NO IXCHANOI O~ ~IFUND ON ILICT~ICAL O~ SPECIAL 0~01~ PA~TS,
NO ~IFUNDS AFTl~ 10 DAYS. A ~1.STOCKINO CHA~OI WILL Bl MAOI ON ~nU~NEO OOOOS,
. '
DlICUlMlM 01 WAlUlAHTIlI
Anv w.".ntt.. on th. produot .o'd h."by "' 'ho.. mad. by the nwnu'aoturer. Th. ,ell" h.reby .lepr...ly dl.clelm. .n w.".ndu, .lth.,
~. ;'~" ~~ .""';,,'1,:1, 'r-f'I,dl"'l1 ..,...,' !r"'.~H..-f ",,,,,..,.,y ." m..'...,..l"n'....IH''1 ..., ,........... 'r", /II r-~,tl,."I..., ""'7'''1'1"', ..~,~ ,,",Ill ....II.., ....I.~..r .....,-"'" f't",
I) Ij L i i" , ; .: ". ...", ....',:,.... ,'" i . ." t J ,I... . ' ,1 ~. I .: "I ,.' . -'. ,," ~. '. i: . ~ r...';." ,
0... Tt IN !tAIO
4 MAR 95
~ ACCOUNT NO, e 5
~ IMPORT BODY SHOP
T
o
SHIP VIA
Bll NO
"a8440
:1960-28441
7606,-28300
7606-28300-0
1!l04-28330
9510-28000
1590-28000
1038-31000
7510"28000
6140-21000 (li
2493...04143 @..
1321~2'O:SO '
fl60"21100
5760-28000-AQ
2402-28550
64101-28050
8472-a8000
6655-:18000
6642-28000
!l1!I."21l00
..
f.4VOICE
NUMNA
.
It
I
P
T
o
PAR
"
./0'
CU8TOICU CO.
,
18465
PAGE 1 OF 1
, '
. , ..., . , I . ." ~.
'c \ FREYSINGER PONTIAC,'INC,'..I ' ~
wBODYSHOpl", ""r
, 100 E. 15TH STREET
, ,NEW CUMBERLAND, PA 1707(' ."
. :1 . ,
','
.
,
,
;:"';;::~aQ~Y!:$B,Q,ec";N',;
, . BODY SHOP ,..,--. - ,
100 nSTH 81
NEW CUMBERLAND" -, .. '
,.;,':' ,':;" ,
...; ,:;.\:.,;',' ~ ",
.. .."..-. .-. ,.....1." .':'\;;-;'"~:;'''
'GODY SHO'P':';~;.liit
. '~1""j..
~, " ,~,.,~~"...
.. ., ~ .-. .'. -_. .-. ..-...~~.'...
FREYSINGER PONTIAC.INC.~_..
. - , Ii BODY SHOP''''''''''' , "
'100 E;'15TH STREET'V""~""
" --BODY~sHijr~~"
~ . : ~ ,
..._.. ...
FREYSINGER MAZDA - HYUNDAI
(!8/)
HVUnCRI
na2DII
6115 CARLISLE PIKE
MECHANICSBURG, PA 17055
(717)697.8899 · (800)828-0578 · FAX: (717) 697-2145
ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUS T DE ACCOMPANIED DY THIS DILL.
NO EXCHANGE OR REFUND ml ELECTnICAL OR SPECIAL ORDER PARTS,
/10 REFUNDS AFTER 10 DAYS, A RE'STOCKING CHARGE WILL DE MADE ON RETURN[l) GOODS,
DISCLAIMERS OF WARRANTIES
\ 'IV w"",n"" on ,h. pro<luot .01<1 h...by or. Iholl mod. by '"' m.nuI.oluIO', Tho .011., heroby ",pI...'Y <li.ol.lmo oil w.".n,'''' .llh.,
',:, ' , ,,,,""','" " ,,," "",:, , ",' ,'",,' 'i """"'.""'""10' ","." In' 0 pn,,'cul" pu'po... .nJ 'h. ..lIor nol'h.. ...um.. no.
tll/tho,l,elll eny other PIJUOIlIU OIlIlUIlI" Iii' Ii UII, ""0."",,, .' .. ,',I, ".'1 ,> '" ,., '1",,11" ,p" I"
-.---..-..--.. ..
1 e ENlEf'EO YOUR onOER NO.
APR 95 N C 6902C
OA n: SHIPPlO INVOICE OA TE INVOICE
5 l\PR 95 05 APR 95 NUMBEIl
18712
ACCOUNT NO, 85
IMPOR'r BODY SHOP
5
"
,
p
PAG!:: 1 OF 1
5
o
L
U
T
o
T
o
,
FREYSINGER PONTIAC, INC,
BODY SHOP
100 E, 15TH STREET
NEW CUMBERLAND, PA 1707(
~QyQ*~1?~~ ~~
100E,15THST ~
NEW CUMBERLAND, PA H07(
I ~.
I
CODY SHOP
TOTA~
FREYSINGER PONTIAC, INC.
BODY SHOP
100 E. 15TH STREET
BO OY'SH'O'p'07(
ONTIAC PARTS OPEN 7!\M-5PM MON-FRI
AT.7AM-NOON "95"PONTIACS ARE HERE
'AZOA-HVUNDAI PARTS OPEN 7: JO-5PM
ON-FRI .. NO SAT,HOURS
'OME SEE OUR NEW CARS OR "95"
CUSTOM.iIl'S SlQN~'U"'
X
PART
CUSTOMER COP'
nnnv SHOP
FREYSINGER MAZDA - HYUNDAI
<f€i)
HYUnCRI
ITIiIZDB
6115 CARLISLE PIKE
MECHANICSElURG, PA 17055
(717) 697.8899" (800)828.0578" FAX: (717) 697-2145
ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED OOODS MUST BE ACCOMPANIED BY TIllS BILL,
NO F.XCfIANOE OR REFUND ON ELECTRICAL OR SPECIAL ORDER PARTS,
/lO REFUNDS AFTEA to DAYS, A AE.STOCKINO CHARGE WILL DE MADE ON AETURNm GOODS,
DISCLAjMERS OF WARRAN TIES
Any W"Hontt"" on Ihll product ,old hlHoby IHI thou I1l1td, by Ihe Oln"U'ncturar, Th" iloilo, herohy f)llprolllJly dr'1;:lnimll 011 ViOtrooli... ,lth.,
: 'I-"'~ I \ 'r [1,/'1" f, I", l, I,...! '1,..,' 1"..11,_., "'M"ll"'/ "I ......Hd,M""t.lnl'l ~r '11,,,..,,, Irr " nll,II"'''!''f r"tpn~". nno1 thlt ..,,It,,, "nit"'" ,,"..lIn'''4 nl'l'
.' .1 " , ,', ,.,,',,1:.,1 <:, ,.",," ."I,p" ",1, t., 1",'/","1
~~~~~;~n~ ~J~~nt~~ ;;_B -.=k~~ reA5;~~~ 5 ]"~~'C~~~~'_~,~~~~~-_~~;~~n__~_-
~ ACCOUNT NO, 85
~ HlPOfn BODY SHOP
5
II
I
p
PAGE 1 OF 1
r
o
r
o
SHIP VIA
-~. Oil.. NO.
PART NO,
099S-00010
rtRMS
IN'l'EHNAL
O~ C IPTI LIST
S BATTERY A 54.43
F,Q,B. f'Oll'lf
).f~""U '" "'T"'~C'ro~ nl\,
,
I
w....'"
1M"
1
q 0 :\(:,'\\V~ \
f;\5 <<o~~j ~
~&~~\~\c~
G~
FREYSINGER PONTIAC, INC.
BODY SHOP
100 E, 15TH STHEET
NEW CUMBERLAND, PA 1707(
~QyQl$oH,Q.ec .
BODY SHOP
100 E, 15TH STREET
NEW CUMflF.Rl..o.ND, PA H07(
CODY SH
ONTIAC PARTS OPEN 7AM-5PM MON-FRI
AT,7AM-NOON "95"PONTIACS ARE HERE
ZDA-HYUNDAI PARTS OPEN 7: 30-5PM
ON-FRI U NO SAT.HOURS
~'BUUrsnur
PARTS
SUBLET
F E (,iHT
SALES TA!L-
TOTAL
FREYSINGER PONTIAC. lNG,
BODY SHOP
100 E. 15TH STREET
SOOY'S'R6f"
CUSTOMER COP
~,....:..., 1,"111",,",
'~',;\":,*'
.,,"
.
r.' .' ..,':
I' "
'I! \'i ,':'
~\' ..~,' ,
~rt
Il;
'"
II,
-,.(,
'~
,
'~ \f"I:".'J.l
.1.":3a
.:;~~,.
", ;.....
,-
"
"
i..... " '~"';'-"1.
" t.t_,
,I'}" ~.. ."1.,,. ;,""
..
!
, ,
.___:.0:..-'-, ,..'-~, "
...... I ~'" I './/..../~
,.
.,
,
"
II
E:
....
...'
N'
~'''''
~)-
f/>+ .~
IU....,..,' .,
,:?-Z f~ ,"
I,.. I~." r.",
II.. t,-l
1',)1 ~. J
.\ ~.
.. .'"
~', .'
,~j ,L.
, . l"~J
/.a:'\.
h..Z::1
.'"
L.n
-
JJ1
YOU ... H"'." "''l\lllll'' fa 'IL' II
w,,,ruII ltF'\,,"""l f'l n.~ IN-=LI)'1ll1
WI HoW' ,,,,.N'. laal DAU IIl0/lt IUlt\llr.ft
......0' alt . Jun,;~UH MA" ..
I U.I"'F:OU~ .A..L" ,'I
__ ."QINU
, ,
.
.
,
DOUGLAS, DOUGLAS & DOVGLAS
"I DO HIIIIII' CUll" 1NA' "..
WITH'N It" nUl ANG COU'Cfeo.;
0' TMe OIlIlIIN,u ,....D I" 1HI5
ACrlO".
Anr:.ANIl'''lJ,....t I....w
.""'''''-,..1'''"''
100) n,"J'"
~
GEORGE r:, DOUGLAS, III, ESQUII{E
ATlURNEY J.D. # 61HH6
DOUGLAS, DOUGLAS & DOUGLAS
27 West High SI.
1'.0. Box 261
Carlisle, I'a. 171113
Telephone: 717-243-17<)0
Allorney for Plaintiff
JOHN M. BAILEY
IN THE COURT Or: COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA,
VS.
DA VID C. JENKINS
CIVIL ACTION LAW
NO. q s- ~ /4. '3 " '3 &:..1.. ~~
REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS
Plaintiff, by his attomeys, DOUGLAS, DOUGLAS & DOUGLAS, files
the following Request for Admissions on Defendant, pursuant to
Pennsylvania Rule of Civil Procedure 4014, and requests the Defendant to
admit the following. Failure to respond within 30 days will constitute an
admission of the following:
1. That the attached repair bill is an itemization of charges for labor and
materials used in repairing the plaintiff's vehicle, and is a direct and
proximate result of damages sustained in the collision of February 4, 1995.
2. That all the aforesaid costs are fair, reasonable and necessary, and are
reflective of those customarily charged.
Respectfully submitted,
DOUGLAS, DOUGLAS, & DOUGLAS
BY ~ (, ~~'~
George F. Douglas, III, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
Dated: AUG 0 7 1995
,,'
; "';i:
I ,{
,.{
"i
F.r' f~'F'/ ~oll" L,~or
,_u___ ~U'l1'Jm._____ ~L !J.niL
~UBLEf lv6,vO'
SUBI.ET ' 36,00'
, SUBLEf
"QUAL REFI, F,.Rf
QI/AL RECYCLED F,"f
t ~.t i '" I" ' ;:: ,I~
1:,1"
Ft, II' I . I' i i~: ~ I; , :: : ~
.
SWE f,'tRN MUIUA!, 111'0'"'111.
ll'j LmH [I,ll ROI,O III.Y <:IWUffLMtO, F,. I-(ii')
1,'1'1 i;' '{j'l" 'leh:
m "IIY 'M'5f1011G fE'iMOI/l'; TIII\ E::T1~ilIE Fl.fMjE ':OHI,I':1 TltE
II,DI':tilW (l,liMG III\I,OL" ....,..,.._....,'......,_ .........._."
0,,,,,, ",m",1 &~; OI1l/IEI. <:Oims J')'117]J
f,p. ar La,,; (,III,lon (SF.ci
O,lt. "I La,,: Ul/'1+i3G
Oedllctlhllt: ZI;ILOO
[,"'tred; JUlIIl It I L WOA 6A IL((
Mdr",: 1.1 AN', 011 ':",LlSLE FA l'IOI3"6",4
1100' 1h,,,o; (ill) Z;J-gj1i
Hitchell S"'llr.,: 31~m
O..,,(ptlon: 1394 IfrUlIOA! ELtill!", \0 SfOAII
.:~l: ,-;:;:.:'~J:~:...'::;~,i'i;
~, ,t,l; ,i J'~ I llllr' ..01 j',t
OF.N/ALT: A
SCMch !;ode: DAuP
Uno Ent.ry L"o,,, L"a Ha.
E~ I!Y~J,-",r IYK Ql1tt.l!;19.IL...,__, Oe\crl~tloO
I 901)5,0 fIAME'AOO'L LABOR OPR-UllrBOOY/fRAME [NCLUOES SEHP
~ S00500 HECH 'AOO't. Lt.SOR moRE,1R SUSFEIISIOII AlIr,IIMEHT
') ~O')500 NECII 'AOO'L LABOR OFP.SEr fPONT SUSPEIISION fOE"ltI
, 900500 BCD'; 'AOO' L LABOR OFRoRUST COAT
S 80\330 BOOY REHOIJE/REPWE iHEEL
G AUf 0 RlFIII 11Ef[II[SII illEfl
7 lINE HAR~UP 125,(0
I) RIGHT ,cAR
'J 91)0500 BODY '.IEMOI.'EiREPL,;,;[ o~I,lUE Sfm
I'J 300500 BlIDY -AOO'L LAM (fR'SFIII S"L,Ht:E "tillT ;EAR wHEEL
II 8001~6 aOOY REHOVE,'~EPlA(E YHEEl COVER
12 Rr';IIT REoR
,!l 900500 BOOt ,R(HOVE/REPLACE 'RlGIIT PfAR mE
1\ SErTf:RI!E:IT .. r RIGIIT PEAR mE 110,110
[, OlS4JO SCOY REHOVE,',IF.PLACE R fRf DOOR ,lC"llJ1E~ NIRRIJR
IS ,lUTO Rfflll REf[lIr,11 R fRi' OOOR I!IiROR
Ii 51,H81) SfJD( ,iU'ill 'p mp OIIOR SllElL
18 a2,)')I)I) BOO'( REFHfR .Rcnf PAllfL
loJ "Ufo 'fFW miiHSlI ;t1[]f FAtlCl
:,] 9:",,1 BCOY "EHlj';E..RtFL,li'f "~UI1RTE! ,lUTER F:;NfL
21 ,UfO RCfltl RErWISl1 '~IIARrER FANEL OUTSIDE
22 AUTO Rtflll Rff[IIISH R PAIIEI. EO,iE
23 AUTO REf[, REF Illt\H R LOCR PILLA!
N 8Z29S0 SOD I REPAIR 'L QUI,RrE! I1UrF.! PAtIEL
15 AUT,] m!ll RErrlllSH L QUARfER PA~fL OIJ1SroE
26 122\60 BODY movE,Rm,":E R QIJARfER PIIEL OOOA
a AUf 0 REfI, RF.fWISH !I FUEL floeR
28 BZ:620 BOOt' REHOI!E, REPL,lCE QUAFf" FUEL DOOR RElEii,SE 1:,ifiLt[
"QUAL REPL F,lRf
mSWl1i
52j60-2:]4,0
"QUAL ~EPL FARf
il76C6<8,'H'
7t ~0'~'.Zd.l\jIJ
68610<aooo
m811-;eOOI)
EafINAfE RECALL ,IINBER: '12.0'1/35 1\::\:,)\ 18-;WHZ:Ol
!'htchnll O\l~J IJur1inn: Vr,8 'l~j .l COp\fl'j~hr. {C) l'3~ll), ~l~r:hl1l1 rr.~l1r.,..,r.l(lnJl
flU ~lJh~'J ~1t:II!r'.(q
, ,
.i .'.'
"'.
I"'~
':
'.. (~:
..
- '; I
: ..
!
",
~~ ~
~~ -'~ .
''',' ..
,~.:; .
~~ ~
~~ l.: i
>'
C"
H'I'JU~: 11.1(~
>'" ,
[IIi),
:-;.......' I
?::
"
';0;1
is.Ol}-
15,1)0'
0,6'
0,5'
0,3
O,S
... .~
:";-t
:: i.~_
111:0 -.
-;" r~":' ;;.
:. 2 :.~
- -
~~ ::
,:-)~ ::l
2~ ~ I
~~, ';:
1'1 .~ ...
:2;-; C
p,"'S ;!
~? :, ;~'
~ ~~ .~
-, -
,~~ :~
,-
C"
us
1.5:).
(),~"
97,12 1),1
:S,IjO.
U,
1l'J,J6 '),1
C I)"
~ ,11'
S.l)'
,~ ~ ,~l
:96,16 15,\1"
I; 1.7
lLS
I; 0.5
~ ,5'~
G lo7
1:,;1.1 fIIel,
( ').3
37.a2 ,J.tI
,~_.-
" '
i' ,~
...
, -
,
;..~. -
V' ::
S.~
..,,-; .
;.~
~ -.
'co:.:
j.::; "
3 ~ ~~
-, ,
',,".:.
.., ~.
-~
~ ~'J
~]
."J '.J ;.
",~
l'lljlt lo' 1
.'J
!l)
,::,_:~.tl t(~1 ;t~I~I,f. nY:.tlIJ ::l~l~f .'I.n f ~!U IA.I. (;+ ,II!
iC'i11J fiOO, ml1!P 'f QIJ,Wlf.. [IlIIEF '"NF'.
WIN Ff.fI~II,'I,FfE~I, f QI"',I[' IIINE, fI'hr,
J~':~';,: ~IJD'r ':EI'~;I,'E,'~tHt\(E ~ qUllnH, Ilelf ;F [Ut'
~:~~(i!i ~1;1i\' hfI101~Ei~tF(ljLE ~ IJ~IlF.rr~ HlI1UIP:
<1:';',':,; E[m FENIJ':E:FI.F["i';E ,Q,;"m [[it[
t!~:t';IJ F.r:D: F[~.f/,'f. ~[Fl.llF 1.~~lilillt LIC' Ftltll:
"Ull mlN mlHISH l')','i,',';E UO 1IIJlIIOE
;,[JIO FEflH FIE!ilI,H L[I,(~CE LIO UllOEFSlcE
UhE M.l,U' ~;:\ ,00
., lUC"~';E 1.10 HI.~r,E
'I. l~';';I,'llW HIH'iE
Lij,;,:,I,E LIO uFiif.,[,S'm
mR EOO'( P,llIEl
,E~F SOO'( "hE!
",0 fOR WSIOE
'FEAR eOC'l flOO, ""
:t
[,
:s
!6
'J?
J~
~~~;tit]!) €eoy l'l.f(.tl
E;':Clll BOOr ,U':II
mB,,) BCOI FE[IO~f./r.rFli',CE
,'i')i6e Bon'l FEMOVE/fEI'l,":E
~'Jl') F[fllIFEFIHISII
.. ~U10 mlll FEflIHSH
6rJQ'.1'<:l SOl,( FE'AlR
lJ
"I
,[
\:
.,3
,\
,,'
..,.., '."."
"'", ...." ','"
.'...". . ,,,',; ,.,-,., i.,ll ; ,"'.,\
Boom 8'.101 RE~OVEiF[flH([ R FEAR EllOl !RIM FilIlEl
18 SCO,iez 600'( REMOVE/REPlACE R REAR 6001 ';ONfAR!MEHl TRIM
,.9 8')0391 6001 ,EMO'iE/FEFI.,\(E R CONSIH~1[Olll~NP ,<SSEMEU
51; 8261'.10 iDOl RENO'JElREFlHCE RE~R 6UMfER com
51 HliTO FErlH FEflHlSH W,R com
EemQ EWI REMO'iEiREPlA':r. FEAR eOMFCR ':O'jER Mle,;
SJ 8'26J'JO 61]Q( RENO'JE/mUII:E R FEi,R SUHPER MOIJHfllIG ERH(m
\,\ 8:';H') 600'( RENO'JEiREFl,1CE REAR EI'MFCR flllIR 10 80,"ER
55 MilO ,Efl!I mlHISII RE,.R lllft mlER 'HhEl
AlllO PErlH ~OO'l l,\iOR OP8 CI.EAR COM
9'J6001 ,\OO'l cosr 10WIHG
HiHa ,IOO'l ';081 rAliIl Mlr.Rl,.l]
- JuJ~e'cnt Item
~ l,bar 110\' ~Fpli"
,~ Ir'LdIJ~ed In Cl~M ClJJt Cdr.
11
"
,.
S6
57
58
;WL'<J,
;UAUl'i F.Ei;((lEO OW UO ';All 10M HT II0R1H ,\ BOU1H AUra F,lRrS
; -el:0-69~-'i''t(:l
;~AUl'i RWmO ~HCElI;~lL KEUliI Al HUMlll.ERS 'IESl 31HOI)O
iJllill ..1.U1 -lili!),
37,a :G.liiJ ~a~ .ao
:l.S 26.01) SS3,')1j
1),6 :6 ,1)1) ~ 5,;'0
L,Jbor 111btotal II S~7 . ~I}
ld!.;\Jr h:4. 1 6,l)l)~ ]~,+'I
LlutJr 3U"HtlJr~J rot1L~ 59,3 l ItiSI) ,3,+
l. l,o,),' Subt,;,,)I,
S'ld,
R~f: ;'\i~I'
~i!clt~ni~.) l
:., t ~,). I : ~ : '! :'" :: ~II ~
(;Alni
h'lfl ; ~ I(F, . t, ,~. i J
,..-,....
, I~)
l_~_"
:'1 "~l; . ,: J I}'I') l ,(\~
" 1,li-
,,' , ,',-
,
r:~l(j' ')j:J(jlj :, ~Ij r~l[l U
J~~~j!J";~ l' ;llfi l,tl~
~:'d'l"'l"l'+'l ,).,.)
Q[[(,l H:';:':tEli ~,.\n i I:~,lill' Ii. 5/1
( I"
"
1.1
3l.Z5
"
~;: ~
~~ r. ~
~~ ,~i .~
8'1121 ~2el:;I)
6:H';')';I)W,
(l.~'"
O,Sf~
,I.,.
dU
~ 1.6
O,S
-f1..\;.U
.... .
.t. ',~ .:
~. ;.:.,
~. ':: "J
.~:: ~
,"
',u.85
I.U5
,.11
SI',Sr)..,sr,')i)-AQ
85710"28,)I)I)-AQ
3!\OZ-26WI
EEEOI-ZS(,51)
IUllllel
2'l.BZ 0,3
~5,52 IH(l
355 .~Z O.~
I; 2,~
18,'J'l IIICI.
33.'15 0,2 U
68.11 11.6 U
C 0,8
2,5.
_.:~ -,
~-i - .::
;"l: :.:
~.~ ~
.,......, ~
~z 2
:;~ >
~._ c
p~ i!
;..c 0
~:~ :D
__" F:l
,." )>
.~:~ a
:':, z
..,'J -l
~ ~~ ~
-.-: "
;: ~J ~
:;1~ ,::I
,-
[~
SEm-:al)'!')
,ef.€..Zw2el)Q'~
6E655-"')I)')
65.01)'
2\'1.01).
rro P31't, Re?laCI!~ent ~1i\Mnilr'r
rJ>"bl~ P",\,
PJrt~ I;~;l;,bnt!.,r.
:i,~tp,-, r,J:~ t 5, .j()~
fetid ~lIFl.!l:tJr.\lJ,~t P3rt~ Illl',Cljnt:
;:m~A1E ~ECHl.llilj~6Ei: ,12:01/35 1~::~:1~ JHlliH:;OI
1,e,r..ll O.t" V",i.~: rEU5.A Gnp!,rlr)ht ie) 1r)~10, M,t,hell r~terMI'on,,1
,ll ilr)lit,Rmr"~11
_..~~'llinS
1,7.13.03
't!j.G!)
11:€.H
1 I ,gIN .Ij~
_M_'
\
... ~, :
,:.: ..
> :;
"
PlUG 1 nf 1
,j ;;~
~~11 ~
- ~,
;.;,'~ ::
,,1 -.
.. ~ ...
--;:, :J
.> ~1 IT!
~" .,
",: 0 ~.
ri, ':l
,-
I. II '.
'.'
;,
.........
.'
, . L
..
. ~. ,
.."
"
.,
'~
'V'II
~
,
.!
/
<,
O.t'l 0\/1\/95 02143 P.N. G..~,,'
..t. 101 38-7110-22201 .
$uppl...nll 002 IPI 0\/14/95 021\2 P,N.
Prof II. 101 3032 15
STATE FARN NUTUAL INSURANCE
115 LINEKILN ROAD NEW CUNBERLANO, PA 17070
17171 77\-90bl
FOR ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING THIS ESTINATE PLF.ASE CONTACT THE
INDICATED CLAINS HANDLER _.._________.__________,__.___.____
D...g. Assoss.d BYI DANIEL COONS 3001733
Suppl...nted BYI DAN COONS3001733
Typ. of LosS! Coil islon (Spec I
0.1. of Lossl 02/0\/95
D.ductibl., 250,00
Insur.d, JOHN N & LINDA BAILEY
AddresS! 1\3 ANY DR CARLISLE PA 1'1013-B88\
~~'D PM~"~: t717J ,~q-pq'4
Nitch.11 Servlct, 918721
Oneriptionl 1m HYUNOAI ELANTRA \0 SEDAN
VINI KNHJF22NbRU581987 Licensel NAP-2b7 PA
Nillig'l 13,775
OEN/ALTI A Se.rch Cod., DAUP
LInt Entry L.bor Lin. It" P.,l Typ./ Doll.' L.bo,
It.. Nu.ber I:t.u... ODtr.HDn DnerlDlion mtJ!Y.btr A.ounl !!niL
1 900100 FRANEIAOD'L LA80R DPRIUNIBODY/FRANE INCLUDES SET-UP SUBLET 206,001
2 900100 NECH IADO'L LABOR OPRIREAR SUSPENSION ALIGNNENT SUBLET 35.00'
3 900100 NECH IADD'L LABOR OPRISET FRONT SUSPENSION TOE-IN SUBLET O.bl
\ 900100 BODY 'ADD'L LABOR OPR.RUST COAT IIQUAL REPL PART 15.00' O.l'
5 80\930 BODY RENOVE/REPLACE WHEEL QUAL RECYCLED PART 35.00' 0.3
6 AUTO REFIN REFINISH WHEEL 0.5
7 LINE NARK UP X25.00 8,75
8 RIGHT REAR
9 900100 BODY .RENOVE/REPLACE .VALVE STEN .IQUAL REPL PART 1. 50'
10 900500 BODY IAOD'L LA80R OPRISPIN BALANCE RIGHT REAR WHEEL EllSTIN6 0.\1
11 8001\6 BODY RENOVE/REPLACE WHm COVER 52960-28\\0 37.12 0.1
12 RIGHT REAR
IJ 900100 BODY IRENOVE/REPLACE IRIGHT REAR TIRE .IQUAL REPL PARr 56.00'
1\ BETTERNENT - P RIGHT REAR TIRE XIO.OO 5,94
15 800267 BODY RENOVE/REPLACE REAR CTR CONSOLE ASSY 84670-2BI20-AQ 104050' 0.3
16 900100 FRANE'ADD'L LABOR OPR'PULL REAR FLOOR PAN SUBLET 60,00'
17 815490 BODY RENOVE/REPLACE R FRT DOOR REAR VIEW NIRROR 87606-28701 119.95 0,3
18 AUIO REFIN REFINISH R FRI ODOR NIRROR C 0.4
19 81B4BO BODY ALIGN IR REAR DOOR SHELL 1,0'
20 820980 BODY R.PAIR IROOF PANEL 5.0'
21 AUIO REFIN REFINISH ROOF PANEL C 2.9
22 822060 BODY RENOVE/REPLACE ~ACK WINDOW NOULOING 87130-28000 22.62' ,
23 900500 80DY 'ADD'L LABOR OPR'SOUNO DEADENING PADS ..QUAL REPL PART 25.00' 0.5'
24 822340 80DY RENOVE/REPLACE R QUARTER OUTER PANEL 71504-28100 296,18 15.0 ,
25 AUlD REFIN REFINISH R QUARTER PANEL OUISIDE C 1,7
26 AUTO RlFIN REFINISH R PANEL EDGE 0,'
27 AUTO REFIN REFINISH R LOCK PILLAR C 0.5
(STI~AT[ RICALL NUNIIRl 02/07/95 1412413~ 38-7110-22201
"ilch.1l hI. Vmion, APR.95.A Copyrighl IC) 1m, Nllch.1l Inlt,n.llon.1
All RIghls Rt~.rvtd
P'9' I of 3
~;;
,.c
:;<:
~i.
J:/'T'
"'"
",.
"_'
me:
~~ 1:
~"
~"';
l>"
_J:
:;c
--o;!
"'"
r
"ist'"
~~r :
c,.... ~ I
"GO:
cO!':
VI ~"I,;
~;;.'.':
~~::
~ ~;.
~ ~ ,:
~1 ~, '"
}>..>
~ f. ~ I
>c: I
~ <::: ,
~8.::
~:f:
~~:
~ ~ ~1
: 1" I
';.~:: .
em'
~r
"'"'1
;1- <-: ~ ,
;g ~ ~
t
~ ;
, '
~ .~
[i
,,!
"'- t
-<~ j.
>c j
'J'-
...-'
l>r'
...-
"'0:'
"''''
>-
::;l~
3;:(,.'
(')"
,..m
!:~
3:-
,,"
m'"
~~
m~
~~ '
~I
"'/::
.
O.lor o~mm 021\2 P,N. [ ~1 ,
{ ,. 10. 38-7110022201 _~~ I
Supplmnl: 002 IPI O\/I\/~l 021\2 P.M. " I
Profll. 10: 30 32 Il ,~,: :J.I
t..r/li/l I
"
Ir.-UV;
1.5.. t~;~ :.!
C 1.1 .'1-,01
,..,: "'I
12.~3 INCL n", l>
C 0.3 It';":
37.82 0.8 ::'~,~ I
1.0l 6,0' \~~I
.olll::o r
LQt lti.U :J
nB 0
;~O Z
Il,lJ -i I
,,. 0
"., tJ :D I
;."Um
-1JJ 'U I
~O ~
";Pl
"
28 822m BODY REPAIR IL QUARIER DUIER PANEL
29 AUlD REFIN REFINISH L QUARTER PANEL OUTSIDE
30 822\80 80DY REMOVE/PEPLACE R QUARTER FUEL DOOR
31 AUTO REFIN REFINISH R FUEL DOO~
32 822620 BODY REMOVE/REPLACE QUARTER FUEL DOOR RELEASE CABLE
3J 8226\0 BODY REMOVE/REPLACE STRIPE TAPE FUEL LA8EL DECAL
3\ 800333 BODY REPAIR 'R QUARTER INNER PANEL
35 REFIN RCFlNISH/REPAIR R QUARTER INNER PANEL
36 INCLUDES PULL
37 822770 BODY REMOVE/REPLACE R QUARTER VENT G~llLE
38 822800 BODY ~EMOVE/REPLACE R QUARTER RETAINER
39 822920 8001 RENOVE/REPLACE R QUARTER BOLT
40 823630 100Y RENOVE/REPLACE LUGGAGE LID PANEL
41 AUTO REFIN REFINISH LUGGAGE LID OUTSIDE
42 AUTO REFIN REFINISH LUGGAGE LID UNDERSIDE
43 t m MRWP 1?~,0')
4\ G23800 80DY ALIGN .R LUG8AGE L!ij HINGE
45 823810 BODY ALl6N 'L LUGGAGE LID HINGE
46 823850 8DDY REMOVE/REPLACE LUGGAGE LID WEATHERSTRIP
\7 800368 BODY REMOVE/REPLACE REAR BODY PANEL
48 AUTO REFIN REFINISH REAR BODY PANEL
49 AUTO REFlN REFINISH ADD FOR INSIDE
ll) 81)0313 BODY REPAIR 'REAR BODY FLOOR PAN
II AUTO REFIN REFINISH REAR commENT FI,OOR
l2 800378 BODY REMOVE/REPLACE R REAR BOOY TRIM PANEL
l~ 800382 BODl REMOVE/REPLACE R REAR BODl COMPARTMENT TRIM
5\ 8003~1 BCDY REHOVE/REPLACE R COMBINATION LAM? ASSEM8LY
l5 826330 BODY REMOVE/REPLACE REAR BUMPER COVER
56 AUTO REFIN REFINISH REAR COVER
57 B26370 BODY REMOVE/REPLACE REAR BUMPER COVER MLDG
58 8263~0 BODY REMOVE/REPLACE R REAR BUMPER MOUNTING BRACKET
59 826440 BODY REMOVE/REPLACE REAR BUMPER FILLER TO BUMPER
60 AUTO REFlH REFINISH REAR LWR FILLER PANEL
61 ~3108\ BODY REMOVE/REPLACE 'BATTERY
62 BETTERMENT - P BATTERY 110.00
63 ~00500 BODY 'REMOVE/REPLACE 'RT TAIL LANP NT BRACKET
6\ AUTO REFIN ADD'L LABOR OPR CLEAR COAT
65 ~36001 AOD'L COST TOWING
66 AUTO AOD'L COST PAINT MAT,RIALS
. Judq...nt II..
I L.bor Not. Appll..
C IncIud.~ in CIur Co.t Calc
6!llD-2B000
815!0028000
31038-21000
-S
-6
97510028000
!8m-mOO
12493-04143
QUAL RECYCLED FART
87321-2B030
69100-28100
85760-28000-AQ
85740-28000-AQ
~2402-28ll0
B660 H80l0
8667H8000
86642-28000
866lH800Q
..QUAL REPL PART
NEW
lli!!
.LITY RECYCLED DECK LID C.LL TOM AT NORTH & SOUTH AUTO PARIS
31)0-m-7\13
~LITY RECYCLED WHEEL CALL KEYIN AT AUMILLERS WEST 938-~000
IIMAIE RECALL NUMIERr 02/07/95 14:24.34 38-7110-22201
!ch,ll Oa" Ytrmnr APR.95_A Copynqhl ICI 1190, Mitch,ll Inllrna"onal
All RighI< RI''ltrvtd
2.20
1.86
0.40
200,00'
C
INCL I
O.l'
1.8
1.1
~n,M
M'I
0.5'1
4Q,9l 0.4
149.3l 4.5 I
C 1.6
O.B
2.0'1
1.0
18.31 INCL
2o.a2 0.3
~5.52 INCL
355.42 0.4
C 2.4
18.3~ INCL
33,75 0.21
68.\1 0.6 I
C O.B
l4.,.3' 0,2'
5,77
2~,32'
2.5'
\63.00'
25Q,OO'
P.9' 2 of 1
.? ~ ~ r.
t:,.. ~-.o(
;, B 'n'~
;!~2~ I
~r~:;
.r;.' ~ .z:
~'~)lo 0
,';2g
I; ~ ~ ~
t 'ij to
;:~: ~ r~
:,.. n ~
~aa~
~. ~ ~;';
"2,~ 1
lo-:;<.1:.
., ,~ ." .~
~~~.~~
(:''1."10
"1,/"..':_
-;'3':< t
.~'~ ~ c:
",-.ll
. .,~,
; r~'ill
-:.i ~-fi
j ~ ~ '
.~~g I
,::,,.,..
.: l ~ I
rEJ I
~,
....~ 4
:;:.. f I
J'~ (/)
r.~ ~ Cii
~.3 z I
-,,, 0
m~ ....
..,"'..,
~~ Z '
~'.l ~
~i1l ~ I
>00
-c:; ,
!;- 2:1,
1J~~ :
m" ;j I
:ho'
""0 Z
~1l 'Ol
3~"~
.. m
... 1)
- ..
<...:: -
'" > 1l
I. Llbor Subtolll,
Body
R.flnllh
Ntehlnlcll
Una II --BJ11
41.9 30.00
<I.S 30.'10
0.6 30.00
Llbor Subtot~1
Labor II' i 6.001
Llbor Su..ary lotll~ 63,9
III. Additional COltl
I..abl. Co,lI
Sal'l la. i 6.001
Nonta'lbl. COltl
lotal Addlttonal COlt11
CUlto.lr Allo.anclt
0,00
101111
1,254,00
m.oo
18,0'1
1,917.00
115 .02
2,032 .02
A.ount
2~0.00
I~.OO
163.00
428.00
CUlto..r RllponllbilltYI
Oat" 04114/95 02142 P.N,
,alt lOt 39-7110-22201
Suppl.mll 002 IPI 04114/9~
Prolll. 101 30 32 I~
II. Part R.plac...nt Su..ary
hubl. Pull
Partl Ad)Ult..nt
Stili I.. i 6.'101
lotal Rlpllcl..nt Partl A.ounll
I. 10111 Labon
II. Total R.placl..nl Parlll
III. Total Addlllonal COI1II
Gran lottll
261,71- N.l lotall
Lln P"YIOUI Nil [otall
N.t Suppll..nt A.ountl
Polnl of l.plCll ~ RISHI REAR CORNER
Body Shopl UNK
Inlplctlon Sltll FIELD 2-A
IN CONPLIANCE WIIH SECTION 1927 OF ACT 6 OF 19901
ANY PERSON WHO KNOWINGLY AND WIIH INTENT 10 INJURE OR DEFRAUO ANY
INSURER FILES AN APPLICAIION OR CLAIN CONIAINING ANY FALSE, INCONPLEIE
OR NISLEAOING INFORMAIIDN SHALL, UPON CONVICIlOII, BE SUBJECT TO
INPRISONNENT FOR UP 10 SEVEN VEARS AND PAVNENT OF A FINE OF UP 10
''',000.
lit CAUTION lit
FAILING 10 PRESENI IHIS ESIIMAIE 10 IHE REPAIRING GARAGE 9EFORE REI
NAY RESULI IN ADDIIIONAL EIPENSE 10 YOU, ANV SUPPLENENT 10 THIS
ESIINAIE NUSI BE AUIHORIZEO BY A SlATE FARN ADJUSIER,
NOTICEI REPAIRS TO THIS VEHICLE NAY REQUIRE SPECIFIC WELDING
eQUIPNENT AS RECONNENDED 9Y THE NANUFACIURER,
15TINATI RICALL NUNBIRI 02/0119~ 14124134 39'1110-22201
Nilch.1I Da" V."ion: APR.95.A Copyrlghl IC) 1"0, Nilch.1I Inl.,n.lIml
All Rilhll R.I.,y.d
A.ount
2,104.~0
~9.7~
129.90
2,293.05
2,032.02
2,293,O~
429.00
4,m.07
4,491.36
4,m.Y9,.)
",39
(
II' 3 '~tJ...,
I O' *
99'311>
'1B'I'O.P
BB601.'''
'ag. 3 0' 3
l>
wr- -t
.<r- l'
~'./'I (j
('~~ .:;
j;;9 ....
-lll'lC
r"._ ..,
,.
11m ;to
~~ ".
j,... :
!::t'l i.~
(1"1') ..:
r- ,"T'l -
~o r
~Sr
-~ ~
;lJm ..
rn"'Q _
:gB C5
/nO Z
Ul;IJ ~
z:r>>C
'.1"'1') =
"'Urn
-t'll ~
:::0 J;.
-", -
ml>> ,r
....
j~i ~
"' .
'ir;. ;Ii
~~.i<
o __
VI" .... ';t
~~m
~~~~
o(~JoC
"")>)1'-
~ ..~ ~
~~~.
.t ,,, .~,~
!j ~ ,,,
~J>:t;;
. r .
.<(" ~ l>
<. '
~dVc
:;.:';...
0,....'.: :~
11Q.... ;=
.:, ," ~
1)~ z."'-
~-,
".
I;
lB
..
",- -
-<,- =
Joo'l'Icr.
cnC OM
...'U'"
,.;;1 z
"'m C
m1: --i
"'m> I
~-... -
- ,
;IJ...
;:(J1~
olJ -.
....m :t
,..0 0 ,~
-c '"
!:ii~
;lJm"
"'jj ~ I
jj_ 0
mo Z
~ ll"'I"
~I" ~ '
.. ""/'
... " ,
- ]>
'" -
~~ :%)
....
,
. I
..,'"
. -
'Iojl,,; 1,1' II ,/1 I I 1'1 tI ~ I
I~' ~,'III), ':' :'11
J'I~L,II'k'llll 1'111 11'1 IN It ;1,
'1>11111:' 1111 II,' \; I'.
-
.
.
'.TIIll I'li'll 11I11,llll 11t',llkAllll
II" 111!H11I1 NIJIII, ,0:'1 'III!CII'LJIII~. ~II I:"':
1'1 I I "HI) l
"J~ ,ill, 1II/llrl~lI', kl,.HHP""; rill, hlll/lllf, fl.lH,! l'JlII,iU 1iIf,
IIIVI',rill~ '[Hllb Ilrilllol.lR ......., ..'.....,. "
V,,",j"" A"."."., ~" VIIIIIH r.UUIl\ 1'),H:,11
)"P" 1...,,<11 1..1 ~,.., VHII (~IIH~ 'v,\1' :',
r ~l~'t: \J t I u ~ ' I
lJav.' ul Lv)"__ ~
Oc:Jlj.:l HII,:I
I'I")'''I:'I}I
11./11, t'')~.'
H'J. fhvlla::
I,IJ III JIUII I 'iVt;'I, I
IJ~' '/oj, i~t
~ ':~ I.' . I)"
JIIIIH II .; l1l1V11 llll!.!',
I~I Hltl VR (HillilE FA I;vl)'~~d~
liU, ,..'1-a'IN
Ue)."Hti,,,' m'l H',UHUHI HHlmA olD SEUAH
Olll' ~ItHJF Iin.Ru~m3/'
tli', .1." ~! ':'.' ,i _,'.' n~:..L
,
1Ir..n~~1 HAP,I67 PA
OUVAlI' A
,wch CoO.' OHUP
fl,;
l.lll~ Errl,v l,.l"ur lint! Utili
ili.!I ~ ~ OU'!f.Jti')n ~l'~CriDli{Jn
MSvv FRAIIE-AuO l lHBvR OPR-UIIIROO'fIFRAnE IHClUOES SET-UP
'IMOO IllCH -HOD l lHB~R OPR'RE~R SUSPEIIS1011 AllbllMEHT
100,,)0 nEtH -~OO'l lABOR OIR-SET fROIH SUSPEHSIOH TOE'IH
'. NV,OO BOOI -HOO l LHBOR OPR-RUST COAT
'i Ov~I)I) BOOI REMOVE/REPlACE WHHl
,) AUIO REFIHAEfllllSH WHHl
lilt! "AR~Ur ;.IU,)
RIGHI REAR
9')u,')') BUOY 'HEIIU'JE/RHltll,E -OHlV! STEM
1'1 10V50u BUOY -AOO'L lHBOR IIFR-SPIH BHI,~H(E Rim Rfuk WHEEL
\1 JOOI~o BOOl R,nuOE/R,PlA,E WHEEL CuVER
i? RI.Kr REIIR
1;IV'J~I)u EVO'I .""mVEiRfPLACE -R1GKI REAR rIRE
II BHI'~IIElll . P RI~Hr RE~R mE <I'UII
!, 0,;,;,,; BOO, REtIU':EmPlHCf HHR (fR COHS,lLE H'i,;
!.i 1'}0"10 fRHII~.M,O L lRP-OR tiPR'PUU REoR FlOI,R 1HII
!,: OIS.1rl BOO'( RfIIOUE. REPLACE R FRI OuOR REAR my MIRROR
i a Auro REF IH klF 1111,11 R FRT DunN "IAkOR
:, ~Iam BOOI ALI"II -R REAR On,)R SHEll
) J/u110 BOOI RfPiiR 'ROIIF PHIIEl
,\ HlllO HEFIHHHllIl'iK ROOFPHHEl
n,ZlO6D BOO'( REN~VHEPLIILf BHLR WIHOOW 110IllOI".
" 100500 BOO( '1100 l lABOR OPR-\OUIIO OEAOEHlIIO PHOS
,/ OIl1~U 800'/ REnOOE/REPlACE R QUHRTER OIlTER PAllEt
, Horo REFIH REFI~I\H R QUARTER PAIIEl OOTSIOE
.. 11UIO AU IN REHlmK R PAHfl EOOE
/ AUI~ mlH AHIHISH R lOCK PILLAR
r..t Iype/
. Ho, t Itu.O..
SUBLEJ
SUBl ET
SUBlET
"QUAL Rm PARI
QUAL RE'IClEO PARI
..QUAL REPl PART
mST/H&
511.'H8..0
..QIIAl RHl PliRI
3~.':O./3IN'Arl
jllBW
a;t)lt,). :IJI~I) I
a:I.;'1-/3~\I,)
..ijUAl REP\ PARr
m')4-ZBI0Ij
flli; t.)tllldtL- h,j':) b"'1'1\ rLl"clt":tll...'rd ..i~h oJ .tJIJin~l. p'l.fll~.
~
"'.
111lt11 Ritm MUllllA' OliOi/l~ 1~;i~IJ. j~'1l10-l2lrll
,"~11 0.1. V."lon' ~PR ~5 ,R C,~v, i'l~t ICI 1110. Mitch_II Inl".."o".1
~II AI'llItl R.,.,..,j
I1l1ugf' n.m
Ovll., lob..
H.QUllt 1Iuil.
100,0')'
}5,1)~'
rl.6'
I~,OO' 0,5-
J5.00' O.J
O,~
B,l~
1.50-
O,~'
Jl,ll o).l
S.,oo-
~, 9,1
10~,SO- 'l.l
;O,O~-
(IUS
C
Il.)
O,~
1.0-
~, l.~'
CU
lZ..Z'
1~,Orl' O,S-
21UB IU I
C 1.7
I), S
C U
PO'," l.f J
~
'111'11 II,
..
Ill....
-<....
,.",
",c
..."
,.~
'~",
"'1;
"'no
:>>2
,,~
il:Vl
<,,>l:
,..",
,.C
-c
" '.
,,"
m'"
:g~
mO
VlJ:
m,.
~"
,."
..."
-0
<<
m,.
,..
iii~
~~
'i "
~ >>
oz.
)qC'l ,.=
<z::o:;
';i~
..c~.
):...~
110"
.Z~
Z t.1-,
oS~
.~ .
-rc
~c>>
m;1lp
ZJh
~ i!
~~~ ,
::I 5.~
. .
~2~
cili~
~E~'
o < I
~ .,
,J;n~'
"~A
l:S 0'_:
It
~m'
~M~
~J!~
[8
I
..
~::: :;
)Io~ ~
~"tJ ::
,." ..
,- .
"'m ~,
mil: .
"'m :-
~~ :;:
~(I) ~
()]J .:.;
_m -
, 0 .,
~c -:.
~- a
]I"'"
",m ;.
..." ~:
::0::0"-
me z
~:ll_
z. C
...... r
.." ....
-t:O 'T:'
<0 =-
m<~'
. .
,..
,
...1.
,
,',.. 1.1 : I ,. I ill' 11,11
I" JI.I -.1 j,,, ...vl
"JjJl';' """.11 ",11 i1'. ,/'. II I, 1111, H f1
h J( II.. rll~ 'It .' I'
.
, .
I,'"
I, I.
. '1,1' .J }'J'I 1 ~ , " l 1,,1.1.
I 'J \ .
'11 :,,',). .:j',\P/ ': ' ~,: (J.~
ql":'~ ~: I 'i II r) ,IJr,
'S .,V'
.j 1.0'
1;~lIJ.~:N'JI' :. ltj IH(l .
'IB~?'I'IIQli'J I. 8.
1i....HNI~) I). 40
VI/Hl ~EU(LEO P~kl li~, ~U' O,~I
( I.~
J.l
JU~
8ill 1-280iO
b91Ii<!-Zalu'j
U, ~I.
O,~"
0,4
4,~ .
I..
O,S
/.V.,
1.0
IS, H INCl
10.S2 O,}
45,52 IHCL
m,42 0.4
C 2,4
IS,H INCl
lJ,75 0.1'
6S,l1 U'
C 0,8
~4,4}' 0.2'
5.17
19.31'
" -
.
.
40.95
149,15
C
S~1.')-181)OO 'liO
S57H-laO~NO
91401'Ism
86bl)l-ISu~0
86.71- 2SuOO
86641- 2800')
86.55 .ISOIIO
"OIJ~l HErl P~RI
HEW
/.S.
Ii' ,00'
150.00'
fn.. *.11.... nd' bno r."cdl,"I.u,J .itn . .o,Ji.tll~ pru/i1.,
IIHIi Ni'MU NIl/18iNI lIl.uidS 1'I"4'!4 )8./lIu-/l:VI
h~1I 0.'. U.."ion' 01R l' ~ Cuv,,,i,,h' lei IH,J. M,tr,n..1I lottrn.llun.II
It II R IlJI" i KP.~t'"""
,
~,,~u ~Ubl ,ErH" '1 ..hkIER VUIIN rHhll
,,:1" ,dill WIIII;II I. O'J~rlllk I'HHH '}IIi',I(1
" ""I BUI'i ~HI"t<('~I,I,"l k UUHklU< IVIl O,"!1i
".,J '.U III .111111',11 k IVll OOOR
" ,,),'J bul'" W\li'!l,li'lHd iOHwllk tOH ~1I'Jk HlEH',l [HHl
4..... IUO' kllW~l hErlHIE ~Iklri l~fE fUEL lHel1 Ot(ril
~..j. bUUI hl'HII oR ~u~RIER IHHEk PIIUEI
hlflll kIIIHIIH,RlPHIR R UUHRIER IHHlk PIIUll
IRClUOES rUll
R ~UHkfiR Ulhf ~RlllE
R QOAkllk kEIHIIIll
R iU~R fEll BOll
lU~~A~E 1I0 PH/lEl
lUGGH'E LIO OufSIOE
IUGGHGE LIO OUuEkSIUE
tlHI "~R~ HP \;', 'Ii'
WOu') 800Y HlI~ll IR lUGGAGE lI0 HIU~E
UIJHlu BOOI ~lIGH 'l lU'G~~E LIO HIU'E
OllllQ BuOI klMOUEIREPlHlE luGGRGE LIO wE~IUER5Iklr
uuuJol) BOtil RUIOVEtRHLHCE HAR BOtil PMUEl
AUIO REflH REflUlSH REAR BuOI PRUEl
H~ru' kEflH kEflUllH HGO fOR IHSIOE
:1'I'))iJ OOul RHHrK 'REHR Buul flOOR PHil
HUIO HlIH RHIUIIH kEkR COMPAWIEHI fLOOR
B'jvl:a BOOI REMO'JE/kHlHtE R RE~R BUOI IRIII PAuH
UO')la, BUOY REMOVEiREPlACE R RERR 8001 COtlPIJRIMEHI IRIM
80um BOOt RIMOVltRHlHCE R COMBIHIHIOH LAMP H5S111BlY
a;oij~ BOOI ~EMOVEiREPl~EE RE~R BUMPER COVER
"UIO REFIll RHIIIISH REHR EOVER
U,~l/'J 800'( REMOVEtREPl~(E RE~R BUMPER (OUER MlOI;
HIbJ,O 800Y REI10VEiRErlHCE R RE~H 8~r.l'ER ~OjtH lit' BRAChEl
S,.4.~ BOOI REMOVE/REPL,EE RE~R SOMPER fillER 10 BUMPER
,,010 REf lH REf IIHSH REHR lWR F IllER p~UH
9J1Ud. Buul iEMOVE,RlPWE 'BAITER'(
BEllEkMElH . P BHlTER! \lQ,uO
9'iu~uu BOOY .REMO'JE,RHlRC[ 'RI I~IL LHI'P MI BR,Ii:hEr
HUID REflU HOOl lR80R UPR (LERR EOHI
;!ou'!1 HUO l (UiT rO~IH'
"UTO ROO l COlI ~~INf M~IERIHLS
"..:. 'I "liD, RHIOuL iHlHLt
"".IvU ~OOI kEnuVf,'HlI'lHlE
.,,;ti:',1 ijuOI WliIVE/RmHLE
J::,,,'~ OOul iEtlOUE,ilPLHLE
HUfO ~EfIH REFIIIIIH
HUI') kEf III kEFIIWiH
. JIJ,I'Jf.'''I~llt He'l
. ' L..v, ""\0 ~op I,e;
L hit; hJ.Jlt,1 II. L II!M CQJt edlc
::.~~'
,f, iEO'.liu OW, llil lilll rOl1 HI llORrH . SOOfll HUr,) ?Hii\
" 'O'JI.M, II j
: f, RECYllEil ~IIHL (Hll IE'IlIl ilf ROlllllUS ~.sr 9!~.~1)0')
"'~ l.f J
~
,.
rar- .oj
...... :t
>~ ift
'r.'ijt;.
'...
:_,' z
~m C
IT! ~ ~.
"'T'l :.
:.>z ~
~ln >
'. ...
r")JJ ~
r-r"'l :t
~g C
;:.. ."
_" F.
_m ,.
'.ti"C :.'
:c:E C
"'0 Z
"''' ~
:;):10 0
~::l "
",,'"
:jo ~
<< ~
fT'I)ao J:
...
"'~ .
~:a ~
~~ ~
oi;s
~~!;; ,
~i~'
z zl
. jO
~;' ~
. .
'.1 i"i i
,. ,.o!
ii'j!:.I~
.,~'i....
~r 'i:
H~~
Q8.~
dQ-
,~~:
z~."
m Z ~
~ -"
..iI..
~.. c
..!~;;
o ,
_ "0
,-"(')~r;
~~~c
U~
~\l;;
~
,.
OJ'" -
..0('- =
.~ ~
"':!Ii:'
~~ ::
-<me
mil: -
.,,~ >
,.. z
l >
c
~ill ~
c~ ::
Ii!
,..Ii
~Ji
~RlnliM
~ /
CA/ll~\o'
1702 MRRISBURG PIKE
CARLISLE, P~ 17013
(71n 243-1505
/
Sllndl,d
Rlntll
Ag,umlnt
Sllllmlnl
,.... ThI. Num"', On
AM C_......
S 8768748 8
8768H8
IICI.
Nl,jmbtr
e:~~I:'~O 1
_,__~4-1-
AJmn.l. ".hlClt llunu
N'Ln,,MMOU.1-
~~:ro-2/ 1 j/9 5
~l,~t~~c~l:Il_
MI I I I I
0,,, i )a"':11.4.. :
.:: L .'j,G> :
,k, -;JU~
llC1n."-----PGt- f.-JM-
Plt" No
o;;;;;;g---ASiH"~ A--
Clly
VihiCitWiIl be r.tIlJ:li~ 0 1
~Ward
CCD .eDlaI
LICENSEE
CAR
16128
For wo.ldwldlt re5~rvallol1s
conlolct you, travel consullafll
01 call
HOO,fOR,CARS'.
(1'800.367-22~rl NLAl NlRCEH,lAGE D'DAILl ...,1.). r! ,L. ' 03/02/95 10: 010
..--~m '1lIHYE~......~!h\*-Il!H'lffl.......---'"'' v,-" iLjo1,lj.!._+-,.. oil.""l1m'iOOI
OIJI I I . I
R."ll"ll CIIL OwnUlII CIII Rte,hlM CIN .. . -T' a:n I
Time' M,i..~,,-'--' -. -~m'l MII"~ .-- -~ - G"~ :1.__ --.-- =.:i ()(~;2:-:"-
fA'lPPP-- ---.---- POW A AIi;nF;; .--.- MI\C --- -~ --- ~ '"~ J~' :j~&:'-- ]~rg~~ft+nt-
L.uOtPOIII MIK ~------ ~RK dOt R"d ~-~:: Per ~ ~
! _---1 __, ,_______ .', Milt ~
'/'11-1-1 '~Irlol "I'IoI~' " l,.Il"~ 'r I"l,,, ~,/'l. '''r ('"I
______L_~. _~_____L___ "',II)..lId Ir. IoU .. l;,j v v
'11\111101 FJlIu Mtlts 90nus FOf Ih" tll ilppIy m~A. Wk, '
Number 1111111 mUll III en
WM, f,l. -.--r . I R<<\lal H,.
Humbtf : : __l. : Diy' @
lion I) R>:'d ;jj;f- -<:Omm.------.,- "':~~t~:e
Mutlt'Source Sourc& R,flfTaI ----;J.TAQ.n11 0 ~~N. coot, Phy&lcal O'lNgI RUpoMlbinty Sub Tolll
-1~ L If POW dlcllll.d:
m_-..~l-Q.l--- ' 100% OF LOSS
City Sl,t, lip
'I"nd
1'<'13/95
~75 00
~ptI;YNI/TI'
,
Addt".
nmepl13
mllNcl\lrgte
1075 00
PhylCal Olm'Q<I, R'$9OIl.lbillty
I' pow lCCeplld' :
$0
~.-
thon,'
Stal.
x X X X-X
Io?5 00
~~m
111 ~M" 1\lU!.l[
DrNtrlue.nseR,,:"
JOliN "~R I ~,~ ,
mum
$8.95 :
Ihlli"
,t'018Irth
,,"
. "
"
02/20 '9
LoealCOnlaCl
Phon.
R.fl.I.II SfnolC.
PlII'MI_ PtI'GtIlon
RuflJ8tlnq (~arqe ~pplli" If or Ii i"1~Urlled tilth ltl~'i ('Jo:' ~ 0
AdliIIOI'lIl A,nte, (Aeneer" inlllal,11 non.) tpiiOn.-
....... IIG .... "llIl1:L Uni':[" c,~ ' .-k.'---li,' ,., ~iBlh ,.,
L ,'AJ 1:\-' . j) A 1:.LE.J.j-__~ P,rsonal pasaenger
Ortlllf1licenlWlNo r___r_._.=t~llt'/Pr=-_ ~~~~!~:Pl~:p
011, 01 Blr1h W,"~hl HI1llMt Color
Eyu
-- --.- -- --- -
AddItional Jnlormalloo
Sub To~1
Tu Of I:.aL
Su/charge 2. OIMP
""'" 6.I)OOX
....ce.n T.1.xJFI8;?,OI) D
No,," UlbI'
A.tulllno SlMeI
Mlac,Cllargel
A AdJullrTllnl, AO
e.plfn
i\MEX
T
, "e
I '/lBA
.
DC
.
. OB
I
d 'M""
C8
I TM""
V CASH
OIlier
$3.00
UD 3.QO
,
5~3~ 2531 O~c2 ~c18
II;~S O./~4'IZl9'
JOHN IA'Llr '
:'$C~[ CounCI~ ~~
Pt~nal&tftcIS
ClWtrayttPEq
Plc'""ACWilO PIC
.'111 'hlMn atCuNED
-...
00
~rX))
00<0 l/O
"".~
~IIldIlCIII
""
"-"
Vauc'*
...."''''
Cu'
C<;I<<'"
.. Not Duo
T_
0..
~.'Ii
I'Idr.'otll'lf
~
;J
~E
DAlE 03/02/95
AMoo.. $.......33,21
\lW9 ljHf;flGEtlC'l' p(jvsrcIANS
~AflL'i~LtHpAAN?~~~J~J4ol2
38-232259396
ARKS Sg~'f '0~~a4~g~/01 22 I NICHOLE BI\ILEV
COVERAC[
MEDICAL PAYMENT
000'2 Ill,2!
.\TEO BY
Michelle Hoffman
."
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
P[NNSYLVANIA OF, ICE PN~ NATIONAL BANK ~2'15/31!
CONCOROVILLE. PA
Hlrrfsburg 13-114
1 13 534699 J
DATE 03/02/95
COVEAiGE' _. --
MEDICAL PAYMENT
600'2 133,21
'U"I~
:M NO
OATf
REO
38-7110-222 POLICY NO 6776-257-38E 001 CLAIM UNIT 521
02/04/95
BAILEY, JOHN
.....lI....u...uu............uuu......................u..EXACTL Y TH I R ry. THREE AND 21/100 DOLLARS $...". ...... 33.21
',) Inl!
, v).
HW": !:;~I!:;RO!:;N<':Y PHYSICIANS
117 NORTH HANOVER ST
CARLISLE PA 17013-2442
\~
APPROVED BY
TIN 38-232259396
AUTN SERNE
14.-
. .'
,-.-.. -" ..--..----c-.c-----......,.j
DRAFT NO 1 1~ '5'J~700 J ' r
om 03/02/95
AMOUNT $....***33,21 I
.._-"-..~. .~._--..'.....-,.. ....-
NO 38-7110-222 POLICY NO 6776-257-38E 001
LOSS DATE 02/04/95
:S
RWC EMERGENC'l' PH'l'SICIANS
117 NOflTH HANOVER ST
CAflLISLE PA 17013-2442
38-232259396
Sg~T ~2~8~~~~5/01 22 / DOUGLAS BAILEV
533. ZI
..__...~--- CQ'JEAfc!---
MEDICAL PAYMEN!
600.2
-,_... "''''-1
I
-._______nJ
,0 IV Michelle HoHman
I
I
lu_~u_.
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
PfNNSYL VAN I A OF/' I CE PNC NA T 10NAL BANK 62, 15/3 11
CONCOROVILLf, PA
Harrisburg 13-114
1 13 534700 J
OAT! 03/02/95
......-. -COVEA'AGC-
MeDICAL PAYM[NT
600,2 '33.Z1
~O 38-7110-222 POLICY NO 6776-257-38E 001 CLArM UNIT 521
ATE 02/04/95
o BAIt.EY, JOHN
,
,
I
..... ~-...___,..____...J
u...""........".....................................".......u "....iXACTL 'f TH I ~TV' TIHUI AND 21/100 OOLlARS $.' .'.::.~..:~:~;~I~:,;l::~
:htl
1:
RWC EMERGENCY PHYSICIANS
117 NORTH HANOVER ST
CARLISLE PA 17013-2442
~'
~
APPIOV[O IY
fiN 38-232259396
1ji:E
AUTH
ilAYU
TIN
LiJ')') OAfli
~ASLlg&E4~gMMuNln AMB
CARLYSCE PA 17013-0496
38-232298422
NeE
'I~ms ~8~T '0~~O~~~540 I SARA BAILEV
C'fATlO BY Mlchelle Hottman
'-'11 'u.
A
1."".'\
CLAI~ NO
lOSS DAlE
INSU'EO
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
PENNSYlVANIA 01~1CF. PNC NAlIONAL BANK 62'15/311
CONCOAOVILLE, PA
H.rrlaburg 13'114
38-7110-222 POLICY NO 6776-257-38E 001 CLAIM UNIl 521
02/04/95
BAILEY, JOHN
DAlE
AMOUNI
1 1) 534703 J
03/02/95
$......230.00
COVERAGE
MIOICAL PAYMENI
600'2 1210,00
1 13 534703 J
DAlE 03/02/95
r '~;O;CAL-;~~~~~:EAm 1230.00'-1
,
........................................................................EXACTL Y T\./O HUNDRED TH IRTV AND 00/100 DOLLARS $ *""... ...~ 3:0.00
PIlY 10 Ih~
l)rJuol
CARLISLE COMMUNITY AMBULANCE
POBOX 496
CARLISLE PA 17013-0496
TIN 38-232298422
AUlH S ERN E
CLAIM NO
". ". "'-~"""""""r"'~.' .'...,'''''.r'..rl..,.,..~,..,..". ~~.. ~. .....--._ , _", 4.,~......:.-.~:"
LOSS DATE
02/04/95
PAYEE
!'IN
~EMAIIKS
:'EATEO BY
'6"
....~..lIf
LA'''' NO
OSS OA TI
NSU.EO
38-7110-222
peUCY NO 6776-257-38E 001
J.:.j)
APPROVEO BY
,:,-..,..,.~,.~ ..~.~_~__.,,_ ~., ~r
...
-
RW9 EMERGENCY PI:!'iSICIANS
elRL~~~tHp~AN?~~~3~J442
38-232259396
~g~T '03~a~~~lI01 22 I SARA BAILEY
Mlchelle Hottman
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
PINNSYlVANIA 011 'CI PNC NAIIONAL BANK 62'15/311
COHCORDVILLE, PA
HarrIsburg 13.114
38-71-10-222 POLlCY NO 6776-257-38E 001 ~LAIM UNIT 521
02/04/95
BAIL,E'l, JOHN
DRAIT NO
OATI
AMOUNT
1 13 534702 J
03/02/95
$.......33,21
~-,...-..-,-, COVERACE"
MEDICAL PAYMliNr
600'2 133.21
l
!
I
j
. _.____.__ ____._._..J
1 13 534702 J
DATE 03/02/95
'~'-"'-~~-~-'---c6VfiiAGE
I MIOIc.L PAYMENT
600.2
Sll.21
l
I
,
I
.................................................................exACrLY THIRT,-rHREE A~D 21/100 DOLLARS
'.,y to ,It"
I,d_, or
$'ir.:i:lti'~
...;-;.-,..,."l,.J~!~~~
RWC EMERGENCY PHYSICIANS
117 NORTH HANOVER ST
CARLISLE PA 17013-2442
"" 38-232259396
AUTH S ERN E
Cfi
'$
A"ROVID It
I" NO
EE
ARKS
A lEa BY
..
UIUI\
I" NO
,S OATE
UAEO
38-7110-222 pOLICY NO 6776-2 'j 7 - JOE 001
02/04/95
1 13 946083 J
03/20/95
$********7,44
lOSS OAlE
ORM r NO
OAIE
AMOUNT
~S8LH&~2~gg~UQ~R sr
CA~LISLE PA 170i3-0310
38-232141105
i ' MEa I ;""~~;i~~~fAAGr---'----'
17.44
ACCT I 8636987 /
DOS I 02-04-95
SARA BAILEY
I
I
I
I,
Michelle lIoffman
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
PENNSYLV~NIA OFFICE PNC NATIONAL BANK 62.15/311
CONCOROVlllE. PA
Hlrrfllburo 13-114
1 13 946083 J
OAfE 03/20/95
I ~'" ",~-,~,"~1"'" - -~-- -I
tOO'2 17.44
l__ _ ____,_ -- '-'
38-7110-222 POLICY NO 6776-257-38E 001 CLAIM UNIl 521
02/04/95
B."I:'E'i, JOHN
.. ..." ..... ........................ ... ...............**..*...... III ....uEXACTL '( seVEN AND 44/100 DOLLARS $:.'~..:;.'~:'~~:~:,::t<,;~l:t)
,'10 Ih~
(aol
1M NO
:E
,IRKS
A lEa BY
1M NO
S OAIE
JREO
CARLISLE HOSPITAL
BOX 310-246 PARKER ST
CARLISLE PA 17013-0310
fIN 38-232141105
AUIH SERNE
oj/
,;.p
APPROVE 0 BY
-. -:" . . .....:: .. :.-::_.....~-:,:.~;,:::;... :::.:.:..:.::::"
,--......-.-......-.... .,... ., .., .
....~....._., ,~..._.~___ h. _. _",_,_"", .0...__'
~. . - . . . '.
".. ..".,,~'._-_...__.~.~.._'.. ._...... . .........,....,
. :...~_.~....~,'.. ...-- _.
38-7110-222 POLICY NO 6776-257-38E 001
THRIFTY ~R RENTAL
DB~' BUC EY LEASING
17 2 HARR SBURG P KE
CA LISLE PA 1701
38-2:)1990003
02/04/95
1 13 945057 J
03/07/95
$******400,00
LOSS OA IE
ORAFT NO
OAf!
AMOUNT
(E)--'---coviRAGE-----]
RENTAL REIMBURSEMENI
'-- -,' 501-1 1400.00
------- . .---.
Scott Erney
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
PENNSYLVANIA O'F1CE PNC NAIIONAL BANK 62-15/311
CONCOROVILLE, PA
Harrisburg 13-11~
1 13 945057 J
OATE 03/07/95
1-;;~;~~-R~~MB~~f~~~W
501.1 1400.00
L____
38-7110-222
02/04/95
BAILE'i, JOHN
POLICY NO 6776-257-38E 001
I
I
J
$"'il(i~lltI'K'Al
",'I:"'l~ll''':,,,,:ii;;:U.M'IM.f,~!!I
CLAIM UNIT 521
,..............................................................I~ACrLY 'OUM HUNDRED AND 00/100 DOLLARS
to ,1t~
,,. o/'
THRIfTY CAR RENTAL
DBAI BUCKLEY LEASING
1702 HARRISBURG PIKE
CARLISLE PA 17013
fIN 38-231990003
AUTN SERNE
f[
Ir-'"
APPROVED BY
ClAIM N~
PAUl
IIN
..MAUl
CNUIIO I'
'A"
I.......
CLAIM NO
Lon DUI
I NI""O
18-7110-~;1;1 I'''''''.'' Ii rI6-~ ','I-JOf: 001
LOSS DUE
02/04/95
ORAF T NO
OATE
AMOUN T
1 13 948405
04/17/95
$......886.41
~~Ay~~~n~J~~'I.~:I:
IN.:
Ilnlll-llllJ
,-'---'- COVERAGE :J
COLLISION (LOMV~
400"j 1886.41
______ .u____~___ <__< __._______
1 13 948405 J
DATE 04/17/95
~";;,,, ,~:.~..r-- 1
400'.1 S886.41
-.----.
.........................u...........................OACTLY EIGHT HUNDRED EICHn'SIX AND 411100 DOLLARS $'.:_:wrftfr~'."'lf(:~4J
....,.._..".,..:)>.\~'..lt,!l'olo'u.,....,..J!,;.,..:_.._.
38-23149111n
5UPPLEHF.NT rOil .JOIIN IIAI U:Y'1i IIYUNUAI
ScoU F.l'n"y
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
P1NNIILVANIA IlI"CI PNC NAIIDNAL BANK 62.15/311
CONCOCDVILll, PA
N.rrl.bul'~ II,' 14
38-71l0-222 P"110 Nil (i776-257-38E 001 CLAIM UNIT 521
02/04/95
8^ I l,f:V, ,TOliN
P"'y ,., ,h~
o,d".if FREYSINGtlR PONTIAO INC
100 f; 15TII ST
NEW CUMBF.Rl.^ND I'^ 17070-1103
CLAIM NO
PAlII
IIN
AIMun
CIUTlD II
CLAIM NO
LOSS DATI
INSUIID
TIN 38-231491072
AurN ~E
. . . ,.,-; :'.,.,~. ':';",~'.';.~':'~' ~:"::..:'~';..~:~.:..':'.":'"~.-..::~ :-...~";:-::;..:. ;'::':.~:.. . .:::.. ;
38-7110-222 POLICY NO 6776-257-38E 001
~
APPROVED BY
'. '~:- .--=-;::'::-:::-:'"r.~:.:;T.'::;':'T.::.7:;:':;~" ..:' .
LOSS DATE
02/04/95
a~YT" ~IDDLETON TWP AHBVLANCE
~oYL!A3 SPRINOS PA 1'/001
38-232328647
t~ij6I~mP~Tcij~8d~gA!.IDOUGLAS
BAILEY
DRAIT NO 1 13 947565 J
DATE 04/06/95
AMOUNT $......199,00
I MEDIC~~~~-E~~'iERAGe----]
I 600~ '199,00
I Y'~I"S-
l___,__ _______
1 13 947565 J
DATE 04/06/95
I ---"UcovfRACIf- '--'-,
I MEDICAL PAYMENT I
600'~ S199.00
~,__uu___, \ 4,..I'~)- J
$ ", "m,' ~""'~' nt'..', ..,', ",'-fj9j
........ '4 .'"'' "
.,.."}t,",,,, ~ll..t, ~
f
Michelle lIottman
STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
P1NN'YlVANIA O/lICI PNC NATIONAL BANK 62"15/l11
COIICOCO'/llll. PA
H."htMJrg 11.114
38-71l0-222
02/04/95,
BAILEV,JOIIN
POLICY NO 6776-257-38E 001
CLAIM UNlr 521
.......................................................e~ACTLY ONI HUNDRED NINETV'NINE ANO 00/100 DOLLARS
''''''''''''
O,df, dl
10UTH MIDDLETON TWP AMBULANCE
POB 218
BOILING SPRINGS fA 17007
TIN 38-232328647
AurN S ERnE
L)tc
.tR
APPROVID II
APR-1l7-9:l FRI
;STIMA TE
OF
REPAIRS
11 :"'5 F' 'YS IHGER-DODY
I
717.-747992
p.el
FREYSINGER PONTIAC, Inc.
MAZDA . HYUNDAI . MITSUBlSHI
JDV SHOP, 100 E, 151~ STREET' NEW CUMBERLAND. PA 17070 - (717) 774,7346 FAX (717) 774,7992
;EO CARS - 1537 BRIDGE STREET' NEW CuMBERLAND, PA 17070 - (717) 774-7055 d.--, '7 05-'-
W CARS, 6251 CARLISLE PIKE' MECHANICSBURG, PA 17055 - (717) 766'842~ Oal. ~ -- l.i'...::,
me.#l.~k/JttII~/ _ AddresaLfL 4,/ R, _ cll~l"l;s Ie .- Phone
lice 1I/thl'h,' V..r 1111 Serlel NoI{/l/t/T/:1?~6/1t8//~6'1' Bod~ Slyle y,,;?, MoJOI.a,..>>-S(
leag. License No, _ Palnl No, Trim No, _ Insurance Co, -
lABOR .
'1E AE eST'IM.AlE OF REPAIR COSTS PAINT TIME PARTS SUBl~r
AlA PlACE HRS,
C;~" A:?/- --7T 7&0 C/.:#- ~p,. -J/lJ/) , ,-t.; ~/ r
~ -
r' (. ...'
)( ~T---c;,l t~? )1t,ml"h'"y &t9chr VI .a X
.. I 1i.2... b. --
./ -:J7",._ 1"1,, ".. 1-1...,/,4/ ;JI
-- --\- h., ~i;/>" ;;4;; 'j; "'7-'0 &-,-Z ~'d 8 / 10 'A q ,
y ,/ .~~~ -It-
/
111 /L ,,; IPlb / sq ~< ..
y ><=
/
[if,jd L L- W,'- /~,.... (, 1 .../ ik""",_ 1'.#./-'1';.., )/ - --
V ,j .3 ..0 ~
L -'.E." ,# p//p /' / / .:? ~
- ' '
IJ . ~ -/l#~ ht,... ~~ ~ ~ti:J..:;: 'ItJt) .A' A.. '39 [(a.
--
I'A ~ . bd ... ~,.-.. ~ ~--
-,
~A.
-
'" A / j - ./ ~ 1;2,.00'
.
.. .I..
1 ..... -, -"" &/-
~/N;f/e-~J'~ , D .- ....
,.,
/ -
-
- -
07/' .. -
.. , Ct!?/.)15 -
P~rJ
- -
, ,
TOTAL
'"
".
..t
ht abo~o I, In tSllmat.. alud on Qur inJp.ctlon. ar'ld 00" no! cover addillonll
arts or lal)c)r ...."ieh may be requl...d alter t"'d' work n... b"1\ ooentd up. Oeca.
lonaUy, atter work 1'1.. 'lart,d, worn, brok.n or damaged pella ~r. di1co...ltred
l"lch .r, nOf ,..,Id."t on fl,,, In!lMcllon.
jlGNI!O
_ OATE
BODY
lABOR "AS, f!l , __ ,-,-
PAIN"
l.'BO<l HRS, I/o S S
PAATS,LE55 - "\ S
PAINT MATERIAL S
SUBlET 1-
OTHER CH....RGES S
HAZ. WA!Tf! j:lIM, S
TAx _"I S ....-.
lUOTATION5 ON PA<lTS ANO LASOR ARE CURA~NT ANO SUeJECT TO
;HANGE,
'STIMATE "AOe !IV
'OI,IlIJrIIlUon 'Gr R,pll,.. You art ".rny IUlnorlu4 10 ma~. 11'1. .t)Oolt ,Otclnlld rep.'"
') 11\. car dtu'lo.d ~,,,,'I'I.
"
FREYSINGER MAZDA - HYUNDAI
(!8)
HYUnD'U
rnBZDII
6115 CARLISLE PIKE
MECHANICSBURG. PA 17055
(7171897.8899 · (8001 828'()&78 · FAX: (7171697.2145
ALL CLAIMI AND RITURNID GOODI MUST II ACCOMPANIID IV THII IILL.
NO IXCHANGI OR RI'UND ON ILICTRICAL OR SPECIAL ORDIR PARTS,
NO RI'UNDS AmR 10 DAVS. A RI.STOCKING CHARGI WILL II MADI ON RITURNID GOODS.
. '. .
DlIa.AlMlM 01' WAMANtlU
A.V wI"I.dll o. tho p,oduot loId III,lbV 1'1 thou modi bV thl mo""',,"""', Thl .0111' hl,lbV ..proulv dl.ololml 011 wI"..d.l. 11th..
"':-rr.,.. ,,~ rmr1f,-i, 'nMoi1rf'"1 ~"..' fr'l"rlr-..f w,."/t,..,,, "I' m..,,,~,.,.,t.."lllt'l M "...".. 'nr 1\1 r""",,"I,., ;,ltrr""", "..A .",... ""II", r"..h.,.., "'..""..... ,,"',
IUthoriu. tny other ,."on to ...um. for It .nv liability In oonn.odon with the .... 0' .,Id p,oduotl.
INVOICE
NU_A 65
~ ACCOUNT NO. 85
5 IMPORT BODY SHOP
T
o
S
H
I
P
T
o
PAGE 1 OF 1
SHIP VI'"
',0,1, POINT
.:1 FREYS,'NG'ER PONtlAc,IINe,\) ;.'
,.., " " "'BODY'SHOP"", ,'" r '
" 100E.15THSTREET '.
, ,NEW CUMBERLANO. PA HOl( ,
. .:.' .
~~,;~::;r8s 'Of ,"D' ,:\'y"'~ ~(~: "tl'; QP A'l J
. ('.'~.'~' " ~ ;:J. . ~ t
, FREYSIN ER 0 I ,INO,
,,' , BODY SHOP ,',--.-
100 E.:15THSl
NEW CUMBERLAND" .
.t"
,7...,',,~';.,
..,.... .
:~~\:.... .' ' . .
,~ 'h~
...",.. "0.:'"
, \...i.!I', "..,
CODY SHO'P:~'..laJ;.
D ,.. ,~..~~",
. " :..-. ...--. '~"""'.,..,.,~..'-.
fREYSINGER PONTIAC. IN~__
, .. ';; BODY SHOP"";" ;
, 100 E,1sTH STREET'7~'~
. -.BODY~SH~~~7
.~ :
CU.TO.... co.
FREYSINGER MAZDA - HYUNDAI
<:/€i)
HYUnOAI
rna;ma
6116 CARLISLE PIKE
MECHANICSBURG. PA 17056
(717) 697.8899 · (800)828-0578 · FAX: (717) 697-2146
ALL CLAIMS AND RETURNED GOODS MUST B! ACCOMPANI!O BY THIS BILL.
NO EXCHANG! DR REFUND ON EleCTRICAL DR SPECIAL ORDER PARTS,
NO REFUNDS AFTER 10 DAYS. A R!,STOCKING CHARG! WILL BE MAD! ON RHURN~D GOODS,
DISCLAjM!RS OF WARRANTlU
Anv wemmtlu on II,. product lold hereby .r. tho.. mad, by the manufeclunr. The "II., h."by t)cprlllIly dllctalm. ell werrenll.., .lth.,
':'.p" 11 r 11I-{'1I,. f, 1'1.1, 1(,,) rn",' III'ill...l ''1M~,.,,..t'/ r'I' .....,.,,,hl'ln'"'"'ltlt'./ ror 'IInlt"" '''r It "'l,llrlllrH I'''''I'H'''". III"rl 111" ""U"r "'lith", "....,1m". nnr
.ulho,lzu IIny olher pallon 10 luume 'or It .ny Uebl1l1y in connecUon with the ule at 'Did products.
O^ TE ENTERED YOUR ORDER NO.
6 APR 95 N C 6902B
OA TE StllPPEO INVOICE O^ TE INVOICE
6 APR 95 06 APR 95 NUM8EI1
18742
T
o
S
H
I
p
T
o
PAGE 1 OF 1
~ ACCOUNT NO, 85
t, IMPORT BOD'i SHOP
~H1P VIA
TERMS
',O.e:, POINT
U'C''''U''.'T'''CQ''D~ D1\
,
~,
o
8
FREYSINGER PONTIAC, INC.
BODY SHOP
100 E, 15TH STREET
NEW CUMBERLAND, PA 1707(
~Qy9l$otlQ.ec
BODY SHOP
100 E. 15TH STREET
NEW ClIMBERLAND, PA 1707(
ONTIAC PARTS OPEN 7AM-5PM MON-FRI
AT.7AM-NOON "95"FONTIACS ARE HERE
ZDA-H'iUNDAI PARTS OPEN 7: JO-5PM
ON-FRI.. NO SAT, HOURS
OME SEE OUR NEW C 0
CODY SH(W
T TAl
FREYSINGER PONTIAC. INC.
80DY SHOP
100 E. 15TH STREET
BODY'SHOP707<
PARTS
F I
A A
CUSTOMER COP
,
'.' ... ..... .R'
~",n.!!.. L n.::~'"n . : ~ ',;\1 n, n.' :~: n.:'n~v 1 -.': 1-: "'...'... '" ,..
['(1'(1 J "~('IIITH f1MI".,yP:R STfH':[':T
,'I\I"\.1 :11.1';, f'l':rltl^. J '/10) I,J
( .,. 1'/) ::i\1.1~11 !I;I
BOO~ SUOP
[,^,I'I~ 'Y!' Hll/')lc;\i 1~2-'ill'3-1.,1~I,5
\'1""
11','11111'
pl,lIlrL~:
~,~ f: PM'
.n 0 ~'eJ O/~fQ'1 .-
\V 0' ':\~ ~. ,
\ O:JV'o ~
"b~'
~'
\ 'f'~'
III '."T ('I'tlT
,':"'11"!1'!' 111
I,
'\'"
'1 'I'.,
".'I!VI.'
111"'1-;':;' :
,'''11111'' ,~ I.II-II!/\ II I',^II.",'{
,.\ I I\~H 1'1:11/1'; ,:^",r.l;:I.I':.I'.I\ 1'11.11 l
("'!',T 1'. 'i'I: 1:.1.1.'1' I'i ,',1\. '.IN BF: t ',"11':
lK~t'
V't" .
'/ P. .
"\",,,;:,:: II III'" ,:';'1 "',/\
;: 101/1 '\ I, II 1,1'111,11".,:, :1'11;1'11',:1' ',IH'i
,,, ,II 1I,....r 10,11 I",': 1 '''!'
'''llt'II'HI;' :
, I 1.11 'I'; :
',ll'F.' 1'.F,r' , ',",-p.;r-
''''I J'FH'I' '''III\''';~:
";~ ,'.. I:, . (" 11i'1
.,-;:'1 q .liH.~
-
II)'I"/\r, '-'I'I."P'.~f.::: ^~: (..V m~:-r;..l'3.'.l '~'~I.~, ~-: 11,:1 ,1~1/'
I,"T 1'1'11'" ""M"W~: APE N:r:I'M"IArtl'i',; ,0\'1' ::' n .1,1l~ PER [lI\Y.
c h !.c.I6:~..;JtJ.'-r'~/6G~)3
.
"
",;~:."
','
...,',
" ,
- . .' ',..
.,~
l' "t'
",
,
'1
"
....
,I, ,
, " ,"'
, ..~~
,
,-
..'"
..-.....
"- ....'~, ........-.
,'" ,I...
r: ',-.h'"
, i_.
4. ,'-'r-',
,I ...... .. ~.~ ...'..
. ~ ' .,
I
t,,, , '
~-:''',''/../'~ ,,/.//...,~' .....
,
",
- --
--
..- -
I,
"
"
,
"
:;l'::
c;a
.,
"'.n
e .-f,
-.o~;~:'~
"',,,1"1_
11',.."..".,."
:.r,:.lJII;1
~_r: '~.~b
,.:Q.....~
};"1'.J.-
~O'(')
... C",. J I"
~:iJ1
-t'l~
.....
.....
w
...
...
~
.
$
In The Court ci c.:mmO:1 ple:.:s or C:.Jr,~:':-:"it'l:nd C:;l.:':i~'Y, Panr:sylve:r:i:::
David C. Jenkins
'is.
Samuel A. Gardner, Sr.'
~o.
95-4363 civil Term
'~
---t ...-
:iow,
October 23 , 1995
:9_ I. SEZ:~~ 0: C~G:::::.1...A.'ID COt-~TYt ?A.." co
h=-,.:,y c!..-;;u= t!:: Sl='S 0;
Franklin
c,u:rr to :::"'-=-..1t.C -..;.. '.V:::,
:!:!s =-t'uc:cu :~ -.,..:- ~t == ~ =d :-=..u vi :.::c ;)t,:_~.
:?~~f.k.;:~.<<: ?~
I '
Sl1&.~ ot Co:::i:lUW:G C~W1t7, ~:I.
ASc1a.vit or SemI::!
~ow.
October 26
:Sl 95
2:43
o\:!ca ,P
~t. s::-..ri
. ...
== ','ti=
Writ to join addtl def,
".lpoa
Samuel A, 'Gardner. Sr,
~t
617 Westover Rd" Shippensburg, Pa, 17257
~::u:ci.i:q:o
Mr, Gardner
-
a.
True (, Attested
c:py oi :::= o::~..~ (
Writ to join
..
md ::w!:: i:::cwu :0
Him
== .:::u:::s :.~:.-=i.
So ;u:.,w=.
Deputy
.
h.
3_1':1 :me! sui:lc:-:ftd l:e!cmI
== :!::s _ QY 0;
COSTS
snvlCi: 18.2lL- S
.0
..-
~D!.!AGZ 6.16
.~:m^;Tr 4.00
-Z!a..l6
J 21.84 ,refund
r_.~
SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT
157 LINCOLN WAY EAST, CHA"'BER~6URG, PENNSYLVANIA 17201 (717) 261.3877
SHERIFF SERVICE [INSTflUCIIONSFOn S,EIlVICF OF PflOCE;S~I~~.e I~~~-;;~;;;
PROCESS RECEIPT, and AFFIDAVIT OF RETURN IOGlbly 00 nol duln<:h any C"I"U'
--- . ..-.-........._-~,...--..._-.._---_.,-_..-
:J cOlUl! MJMm H
"PlAINTIFF/S/' .
David C. Je"kinB
3'Dif'ENDANT ISI ' '
Samuel A, Gardner, Sr.
SERVE - {" h HAMI tH IN(lIVlIllIAI ! t)f\,lf'Mj', \ Illil"'liAII(,tl! I'
. " Samuel A, Gardner, Sr,
--6 AnmU.HH tSltl'l.tt)l IlHI Ap,ltlllh'lll NIl Clly n'ltOl !...p ~ll.lt" ilfltl/lP CndH)
_AT__ ",'..' 617 Westover Rd" Shippensburg, Pll, 17257
7,INDlCATEUNUSUAl SHIVICf lICOMMON,)! I'A IIDfPlJll/f 111)fIItH
_..__ _....._u.__.
Now'~__~"_.N_ .....19 ,I, SHEnlf.-- OF FflANKlIr-J COUN-rV, PA, do 11t!mhy dnpultlO tho Slwrllf of
___hO__..____ C()llllly 10 l'XI!CultlltlIS Writ and mnkn wturn Ihl!l'llOf i1c(;orclmg
to low. This deputation boing made allhl! rl!qul!sl ilnd f1!jk qt IIw plillllllff
95-4363
" IYfll (H Willi OHU)MPlAINT
Wri~, to join Addt1. Def,
1'1 '01 H'/II I (llllll ',I,IlII'IIIINl)' 1'111/1'1111', 111Hl II Villi AlIAtHllllJlj ~il)lU
.. IlPlClALiiiSi'iluC'ilONSOROTHER INFORMATION THAT WILL ASSISTIN EXPEOmNG SERVICE:
:,dJLJ!lLl ~ Jl'''~Uh.'LiJ.uhTi~'',=~.''..~~~,-~=~.====
NOTE ONLY APPl.JCABlE ON WRIT OF EXECUTION: N,S. WAIVER OF WATCHMAN-All" dl'pul'y !.henlllpvYHl!llJpOn {)/ ;llliIC:hln\l any properly undt.'r
within wrll RIlIV IetlVL' SfJmfJ wlthoul i\ watd1JlldJl, 111 "IJ~;I<ldy <II WIUlll11"i,'f I', r'HHld 111 pIIS'H'~j"'lnll. ;jlh~r 001ll1'll11j pl~r~lJf1 nllev)' ef illlachmtml. Without
lIabilllY on 1.!!!u>~rJ..QI~~ch dYE~I~,'!!.'h"s,l'!.",II'u,,,!~ ,,',,"""1"'"'''''' ""'~ I,,,,,, """"'"(''' ",,,,m""ll "',lIny,"",:h pr!'p,!r1Y.h"I,IIJe sh.",Il':'s"s.;!L~.!!1U,"ol,_,
~:NA:r:;;:;~:_:bo~:e~::~al::::ty ",..,."" ,I () TH H'HON~ NUMBUr J', D~TE,_"u.._,._,__
12. SEND NOTICE OF SERVICE copy TO NAME AND ADDRESS BELOW: IThl. ar.a mu.t be complet.d if nolice II 10 be mail.d)
SMCE BELOW FolfuSE OF SHERlFF'ONLy:':oo NoTWFiiTEBELOwTHiS LINE
~ ~:'::::~~~~~~;;~~d'~~o~~' :, ~~'t5:~~;~"IY <II Cll'rk "n<l Tllh' ,. Di'~'~~~~'~';luJ~":P_~!~~~~;~~.date
16 I hereby CERnFY nod RET\JRN th,lll [-J(!v~' pl'r:-'l)I1.llly '-il'r..! (t r 1110\\11' h'rJdll'Vldl'llcl' of :wrw-;n ,)') shown In Fh!fl1i1rks' U h,lve ~~)tecuh~d <\1 :5hown
in "Remarks", the wnl or complllint dt~')r:tllll'lj ol1lhl' 111l11'Ju1u.li, CIHllII,IIly (or~)(lr,lll()n, nit; . atthn mfdrl'S5 Hhown .lbovt-! or onlhl! IndiVidual, company,
corporahon, ole. at lhe I.Iddress InBmled bH(nw hy h.tndltll'l it TRUE and ATTESTED COPY thmL'of
---.----.--.-----.....-- -.---- --------.-.__._.--------
17 0 I hereby certily and return a NOT FOUND lJf'Cdll',I' I ,Hllllll.lllit, to Joe,lIt' !Ill' HldlVlduill, comp.lfly. c:orporoltloll, nlc . n,lmf!d at1ove. I See remarks below)
18 Narne' and 1...i8-cii~rMii;iduai..se.,:~;;1 \ If no! ~hown Ibnvl') II n -A 11' 1'''''::,1 '(lIl.lhl'~ I\;I~ .,n~;'h~' 1I'lIon thm!
Samuel A. Gardner, Sr. ~:;l~:::~I,l<ll'tlll... ,11'h'I,.j,\I'I~ ullllOlI jlllUIl ,11
20 Address ofWherc.sorvc.d tcompll!le only II dill! fl'nt Ill.!ll ',Ill)....,l dll(II") ('llfl't'l or FWD AIJUftml'nl No , r.J' nolI, ,~I-St"\I. p ',} '} Time
City, Bora, Twp Stale and Zip Code~
617 Westover Rd,. Ship~ensbur,. Pa, 17257 10-26-95 2:42 pm
23 miMPTSI~~~IM';';!OO~~;Til.IO l Mlle. [OOP Inl [001. [ MI_. [Oopln!.[ Dwl. [MIt..[oeP~~tJ~~I. ~~~ Oop.k\l
24 Advance Costs.. '}I} Sf'f\/lCt' Cl)'lh [,Jh Nnt,HV CPr! [2 i Mllf1llllt' or ~ [2R rot,ll Costs ,}9 CO$T DUI OItMf\N)
__,__ _n 18,00 4,00 6.16 28,16 21.84 refund
30, REMARKS
AM
PM
.ST
!05'
3. AfFIRMfO and &ubflcnbed to htllou' nu) It Wi
341~_:_' fic~~~l. ,. , ,Hl
31~-0'~~~~';h;I'
~lF~~oM"'~~lI"' ffl-~~'~"~" '!' ~i:'::N !i~NATURE'
Of AUTtKJRllf,DI~SlJ'l:I~AUrl@ YO,' '1m, I
.. ''leIA . , }I,. _ I.
11'111"~ .)ll~~,llT'.cefllo.r-J, FI",,~III' "':\Jll"'" J' ,-.(' ~ ,
IICSI),I/1IMJ:1 "I~.. ;'-"~'."..!~~Ion e.Ulf.t "'1,'\/ J .OPlt_ I.IJUI~I(1 ,\U rH1lrll rv
27th
95
," IOAHSWElljf:' ,
,.. _:_.. _'~ . ..~_'~". 0'. ~ ____ ' '_
',' ""I""''''''''I/.~7 't ,/ t '~"7
'.It'll "111',111 .. 1(0 e,rt . Mur_r y_ _....<.
1'\ ''''11.,,1011'' 01 ~\tllm"
SHE III" ot 'RANKLIN CoUNTY
'--[iTi).;iO-----
10-27-9~
... .III Oullt .---.-.
,. . ---~---~-_...-
,. Jllln'lh'III"II;"";II'
._-~--
SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT
I,'
157 LINCOLN WAY EAST, CHM,IBERStlURG, PENNSYLVANIA 17201 (717) 261-3877
SHERIFF SERVICE !IN,SHlUCTlONS FOIl SfflVIC~, OF Pfl<lCESS ~1."".ly~~;;;-;;;;;I-
PROCESS RECEIPT. and AFFIDAVIT OF RETURN I.,qlbly Do nol dulnch nlly cop"'.
. -....----.-...--....-.-.--.
;J Cl)\]'" NIJMHt"II
.-PlAINfIFF/SI
David C. Jenkins
3DEFENOA,if/sl
_..__8&11II,..1 A, a.rdner, Sr.
SE.RVE {'6~) NAMt ()t INI)fVIIHtAI '"l'.'I'Mj, ,,'III" ;liAI', I~J f II
Saauel A. Gardner, Sr.
AO[}fH S~; (~)II"t'II)1 HI n, ^1I.1111Iu'li! NIl Cdy Hurd rwp ~~LIII' utlli liP emll')
~,...,'__ , 617 ,Westover 1I.d., Shipp8n.~Ur&, Pa, 17257
1INDtCAT~ UNUSUAL SrtlVICI II COMMON ()f I 'A ' , I JI 1'1I!11f I I , )J I II" I<
---.- ---- -
Now,__..__~_ 1U.1. SHEHlFr OF rnANKlIN COUNTY, PA, do hmohy thmultll! lhl! Sht~rlft of
~___._._m___'__' COUlll'! !'ll')H'cu!ll this Writ and rnakll rt!lurn lht_)rtlol accordllllJ
10 law. This deputation bcinu n1;)de ill tilt' fl'qlll'hl <Inti W,K III ttll-' pl.lInllll
9S-'36)
" 'Yl't Of WHII OJ! COMPl AIN r
Writ fo join.\ddlJ.. l1.r.
I, , ',I lOll I {IIi t 1I ',I HII'IIUN I" I'IH)I'! HI Y !I I H! II JII I) AI 'AU II lJ ()Il ',I JI n
II. sPEClALlNsTiiiJi:'T1ONSOR OTHER INFORMATION THAT WILL, ASSIST IN E XPEDITlNG 5EIlInCE:
. :.oIILJ!lil_ 0JJ !!}.h~,i.:!!l:-;~'!..;uh!i~ ,..--..
NOn ONLY APPUCABlE ON WRIT OF EXECUTION: N.S. WAIVER OF WATCHMAN-^ny IIppIJI\- ',ht>nlllt'vYl1lfl upon at dlt.lt:hln\) ,my propt'rly under
wilhin wril moy lonvll tinnll' wltholJI a w,Lldull.lll III ,.w,!,)!I, "t '.'IIHillll"'I,'f I.; h,und In jJ<)~i';I',~lnl1 .llh.r f1llllIYIJ1\j pl'r~nJll)1 tpvy" or dlluchmellt Without
lJ!I~dilY on lhep.I,I.~.t.Q!~~.h.!.t.!lP'J.IY,f)r It_ll~ _~,t~'-'JI!l !, I ,III}: pLII(\!I!( 1)""1111"1 ,I' Ii I, ,',L, dl'~;hIJcll(Hl or W!'"IlVdr 01 ,Hl~ ',Udl {ltujll'r11' bel~r_'::.8he!!!~~ ~ltg I}}oreof__
8, SIGNATURE 01 ATTORNEY '" olh<', ORIGINATOR I' f) TEl f PHONE NlJMBf Fl [" DATE
__~..__lIhe~i,ff of Cuaberhnd eounty, I ," --- ---
12. SEND NOncE OF SERVICE COPY TO NAME AND ADDRESS BELOW' I This area must be compteled il nolico is to be mailed)
----'~.-SMCE 'BELOY/" F-o-n' USE-OF' SHERiFF. O'Ni..v ~"DO HOt-.WRITE'ifELOvi'THls'i.INE-.,n. -------
~~~~:ck=:~~~~~~~~,~~~~o~:;' l ~=t~:,i;~,iy~;'C"~k,,,~i;ii;;--r'ti~~~~:;~I-~L\F',P'i~:;~~;;;~ dill.
16 I hereby CERTlFY and RETlJRN Ih,lt I 1-1 il~11' pl'fSlllldlly ',I'rwd i:] h,l'l' , I"!jill '''vldt>rlcP 01 'wrvICt~;J~ ~ihl)wn In'FlI!I"'ldlhs [J h.we l'JlI!cuh.'d ag shown
in "Remarks".lhe wtll or complainl (h'~,CJltH'd <:lIlitH' 1Il,I"/1I1'I,jl ':I)llll',IJ'y ,;urI-lUldlton, l'tC ,;It Ihl' ;lljtlrt'~iS ~ihuwtl ,lbl)Vtl lJr llJ\ Iht' Individual, company,
cotpOfoUon. etc. at the addres!:; ltHit'ttHt.! bt!luw hy hd1ldllnq;1 TRUE and ATTESTED COPY lhmt'ol
17,01 hereby certify and return a NOT FOUND \]1'(.1'1',1.' I illllllll.llJlf' I,) "-'C.1t,> 1111' l'ldIVUhml, company, CorporiltllJl1. f!lc. noH1ltl!! ahovl', lSf.'f~ rl'marks below)
t8 Name-Dnd.trtle 0; tf~IVldl~~i-serwll (It rlut .,hUNIl ,lbllWI I If) A p' li.m'l! 'lIIl..tll"-lfl'~ 't1~;'h"-'~!':;I~~~:\-~'---
S.-ael A. Gardner It Sr. ~:~;~:li,I."l t' Ihl' ,1o,1I''',llInl I 'JMUdl pl,1l ,. 11
20 Address o'-w~rePsm;~d It:omplu!(' only If dlfh'rl'llllh III ',huW!I dllnJ") 1';111'1'1 or FiFO, Ap,lrtOlt'tll No [,) 1- OJl" III .'It'r~l(~ 22Tlme----;;;-
CIty. Bora, Twp Slale and Zip Code) ~T
(05T
617 W..tov.r Id.. Sh1~penlbur" r.. 17257 10-26-95 2T~
:~-:: G"~_J MI;; !De~~nn ~O.I.I M'I.. [O.P Inl I oal.1 M'~. [Oep Inl.[ Dale [M'~'IDe~'''':~ro~; M~~L~
24 AdVflnce Costs 2'1 St>rvIlI' (,Il~t, l)t' Nll!.lIY ('I 11 [,J 1 Mileilljl! or ~ [)H, lo'al Co.ls 129 CO'TOUl 0....'_
18.00 4.00 6.16 ..~'_.JL_l_~l.14 re''''
30, REMARKS
"
1','
SQANsMR
34 day 01
31
_,9_4:~@.~
1 ~l
27th
9S
i,I';''1Pol!<IlI."r
OPll ~;I">,,H ~o.l>>.~.rt C.. ~r.~~I-
!" "1'1"" 1111" o! ~ ;hl'rlll
3 t AFFIRMED and suhscribed to b~)forH InP Ihl~,
,,,,,,,,,,,,~;,:.;;.i),'p,,i. ;",.,:",1'.,1""
SHERiff Of fRANIIl1N COuNTy
-"-'EJ" 0". -- ,
. ..____ __.i~7"'$
:\1\ DUIIl
---- -
~f~~ft~}7ff~~IPI OF IHESHEfU;FS RETURN SIGNAT liE,
Of AU HKlRlll: 0 ISSUING AUH'OHlrV AND TITLF _..,..___----'~.._,_......__~___
lH UUhlllltt:II''Itlt'
FCSD.lIIOO:l
'l ^ i 1!:;(i~jL '(
. '
~
~
i
I
I
~ .,
g ~W~ i [ ~ \Q II
3: VI
I
8~ , ""
(') ~ l;(
IV ~r1'(') > ,
VI 111 . , f. w
CD . ~ (')
I .c.. J ~
~ ~~, [. ~~ ",.
<
tj ..=)
w ~~ . ~ c;:;:u
.....
o . ~I CVi]
t;;r1's f ~ l==::J
~
~ ~~ 'Vi}
J II I r
',1 " 1,1
sr 1"1 Oil, ~I fi 11~O
, ,I.)
J,I,,' , ", _,..:J.iO
<:\"'l"I\^rl>1I r.',u" \ 11011<1
filE COpy
V8,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO: 95.4363
JOHN M, BAILEY,
PI81ntlft
DAVID C. JENKINS,
Defendant
V8,
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR"
Additional Defendant
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
NOTICE OF HEARING OF BOARD OF ARBITRATORS
You are hereby notified that the Board of Arbitrators appointed by the Court In the above.
captioned case will sit for the purpose of their appointment on Tuesday, May 14, 1996 at 1:30
p,m., in the Second Floor Hearing Room of the Old Courthouse, Carlisle, Cumberland County.
Pennsylvania.
March 25, 1996
BOARD OF ARBITRATION
\
\ (1,\.1," ,\" 1f'I,L\,~7/
James 0, Flower, Esquire, Chairman
Willia~ S, Daniels. Esquire
Philip C, Briganti, Esquire
COPIES TO:
Court Administrator
One Courthouse Square
Carlisle, PA 17013
David C, Jenkins
50 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
PRO SE DEFENDANT
Drew P Gannon, Esquire
Thomas E, Brenner, Esquire
GOLDBERG, KATZMAN & SHIPMAN, P,C,
320E Market Street
PO, Box 1268
Harrisburg, PA 17108,1268
ATTORNEY FOR ADDITIONAL DEFENDANT
II/!
George F, Douglas, lit, Esquire
DOUGLAS, DOUGLAS & DOUGLAS
27 W, High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
AnORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF
"
:l
L~_
\1
"
"
"
,
,
r:\wp.l1 \A"'II"'I"n\Shlp",,..'~'
VI,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO: 85.4383
JOHN M. BAILEY,
PlaIntiff
DAVID C. JENKINS,
Defendant
VI.
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR.,
r
Additional Def.nda~t~'" I q I i, '
. ' 111,,1 ,',,1 r,f
~ . I'!':
II" ',i ('1.1 ,I;
Court Administrator I I , , ' . ^IM' ,W.4' ", t ,...
PHONE: 240.6200 ,;.1t1' ~.. 4
~llIiam S. Daniels, Esquire VOrew P. Gannon, Esquire..... F
One W. High Street lh81lU i:,.e.~~. a.,m
Carlisle, PA 17013 GOLDBERG, KATZMAN & SHIPMAN'~' '
ARBITRATOR 320E Market Street ()h. ,I 19
PHONE: 243.3831 P,O. Box 1268 'IV"
J UJ.... - Harrisburg, PA 17108.1268
;' Philip C. Briganti, Esquire ~ ~ ATTORNEYS FOR ADDITIONAL DEFENDANT
8 Irvine Row .w "\' -. 1_, P~ 234.4181
Carlisle, PA 17013 l/~v,1 ,
ARBITRATOR " ,
,
PHONE: 243.94 ~~
~eorge F. Douglas, III, Esquire
DOUGLAS, DOUGLAS & DOUG
27W, High Street ' :' '1t1~
Carlisle, PA 17013 ~~ ^ .. "
ATTORNEY FOR PLAI~. ,rf!! 1
PHONE: 243.1790
. . /6'avld C. Jenkins
-V 50 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
PRO IE DEFENDANT
PHONE: 251.9283
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
/1
~
\,'
, ,/,',
,'",.f'l''-
" ',I
! ' .
,
II ( "~ ,-
'I' I
r
.
)d~y{
V
@)Ji/9
,.' I'
C1\..".sI\AJbI'n'lon\DaIl,y
f\lt t\\~1
VI.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO: 95-4383
JOHN M, BAilEY,
Plaintiff
DAVID C. JENKINS,
Detendant
,
.
VI.
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR"
Additional Detendant
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
AMENDED NOTICE OF HEARING OF BOARD OF ARBITRATORS
You are hereby notified that the Board of Arbitrators appointed by the Court In the above-
captioned case will sit for the purpose of their appointment on Monday, June 17, 1998 at 1:30
p.m., In the Second Floor Hearing Room at the Old Courthouse, Carlllle. Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania, Please note that this was originally scheduled for May 14, 1996,
BOARD OF ARBITRATION
April 1, 1996
1\'\'\(""1'" -=1.rlV. /..t;"y/
, James D. Flower, Esquire, Chairman
William 5. Daniels, Esquire
Philip C. Briganti, Esquire
COPIES TO:
CoUll Admlnlslralor
On. Courthouse SqUIre
Carll81., PII 17013
George F, Douglas, III, Esquire
DOUGLAS. DOUGLAS a DOUGLAS
27 W. High Strul
Carlisi., PII 17013
ATTORNIY I"OR PLAINTIFF
~'vId C. Jenklne
50 EuI High SII'HI
Carllsl',"1I 17013
'RO 91 DEFENDANT
Drew p, Gannon, Esquire
Thomas E. erenner, Esquire
GOLDBERG, KATZMAN & SHIPMAN, P.C,
320E Ma,kel Slreet
P,O, Bale 1268
Harrisburg. PA 17108.1268
ATTORNEY FOR ADDlnONAL DEFENDANT
SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT
,
157 LINCOLN WAY EAST, CHAMBERSBURG, PENNSYLVANIA 17201 (717) 261,3877
SHERIFF SERVICE IIN~HlUC'lllNSFOfl SfflVICF OF PI1UCE~~ PI",,'.ly;~-;;r;;~~
PROCESS RECEIPT, and AFFIDAVIT OF RETURN IU'I,hly Do nol dulneh ""y "op""
, .....-.....-.--
;1 l;t)l)HI NIJMIHIl
'j'LAll'illHlS1
,__,_ _ .J911!,-M, Bailey
" Off LNDANIISI
David C, JenkinH
SERVE {h NAML III INllIVlIlll/'li I /1"-H'Mj" ,'101 ,:1;/111"'111< 11",j II';I! I
. ' .S;1mve l A., GlIrdner. Sr,
6 ADDfUHH ISIrI'I" nl IH 11 ^1'oIflllll'111 Nil Ld'i 1\'11" IWfI :11..11' ;Inti liP LOIIt'1
_~_. 617 WeHtover Rd,. ShlppenHburl\' PlI, 17257
1,INOICArrUNUSLJAl HlnVICl: I.ICt)MMt)Nln 11A! llal'IJII/f Ill)IIII:ll
Now,,_.., ,,19 _ ,I, SHEHlrF lJF FflANKLlN COUNTY, PA, do 11I"oby dopul"o Iho SlllItlII 01
__._. ._ CtHUlly III Il)(l!cult. thm WrIt und maku wllJrn thnmal accordllH)
to low. Thh~ dcpulalion bUlfl{l madt! jll It\l~ fj'qul'SI drld t1~k t.ll Itll' pLlltllllf
95-436]
., IYlll tH Wild (HI (,(lMPI.AINJ
Compllllnt a~ainst Addl,
1)lilll',1,I!II'IIONI/lI'IUJI'IHIY "111111\'111) Ar'AI!UllIlll",lllIJ
':,l!i,.I,il j IJI !1'~h~0rji:Liuilj":f-"
II, SPECW.'INSfRUcnoNS all OTHER INFORMATION THAT WILL ASSIST IN EXPEDITING SERVICE:
NOTE ONLY APPLICABlE ON WRIT OF EXECUTION: N,B. WAIVER OF WATCHMAN-Any (h~~llJI~ ~hl:rdl tllVYl!lq IJpon or 01lad11110 illly proPllrly under
wilhin wrll may Ienvl.' 811,"1~ Without il w.llchrn,1I1 III ,_1)',1. I,j'y ,.1 '1,1,. l'll1",!'r ,:, l<i(,IHI III PI,S';I'SSlon, all.!, nulllYlIllj pl'r!ion 01 It '\I i or illlachmf!nl, without
tIBbililypnJ!!~-'?~W..Q.t_.!;iI,l~-b_~~ypLJIY.Il!.I.~)~_)~,_I~~r If r l<! ,111/ pl.lllltdl h '/, '111 !. _,r dill' I. i',',. d..~,tr IJclUlll n,' .removal 01 any ~;lH;h pr~ll.l_f:t I)'J)l!I_t~~t~_ ~~~'_r~t'-.~ .~~l.'!,__~'-!QLe_Q!__._
:_::::::~:Ta:~:::~~I;'''s:R~:I~;:O~ .",. -r'" IllfPHONf NlIMBEH [" DATE "____u_
\2, SEND NoncE Of SERVICE COPY TO NAME AND AODRESS BELOW, ITh" .re. mu.1 be completed il nollee i.lo be mailed)
___._=8PAcE B(!:.QW !,O,~t\J~C6f ~HIlRIFFQNj,\, "" ~l!Q,~QfWRljE lij;i6WTH~!JNe-:-- .'-"-'--
t3,I acknowlcdye rucC'plolthe Writ , SI~TURE "I A"""/7'''I~SD n"I""' '" CI",. "nd r.llo fl. n"", H..,,,,,,,,d fi'j bIHr"I.on/Henrln\l dill.
_ or cOO1~~~n' aa"1dICU~~,.~"b,,-ve 'J]()J),/(,(.t f.J. c6tr:l...' I 11..14-95 ,I 12-.l",='!~____
16 I hereby CERnFY IIndRETURN thilll r] hi I'.'!' pl'r:ilJI1,tll', ',1'1\/1'1) ['I hdVI' Il'q.1I I'vldt'rlCf! 01 ~1'P"Ct' a~ :lhllWIlIIl 'f{I'ITlOlrh r I h;\vp l'llt~clJled as shown
in "Ftemarka", the wnt or cnmpl.llrlt dl'sCllbt'd Oil tlH' 1I1dl',/ldlJdl "lllllP,1I1y ,:orpor.tllon, t~lc. altho ;jddrt':l~i shown ill)!)'"", or (HI IhtllndlvIl1l)O,t, company
corporahon, ale, at lho address jl1~l'rted hl'lnw try Il.lndlilhl,'j TRUE and ATTESTED COPY Ihllrl'ol
--_._---~~.--- - ---------.,-----.--
17 rJ I hereby c~rUly and mlurrl il NOT FOUND I" '(-"I'I~;" I ,!Ill (111.11,10, III I, 1O"I!I' 1111' Hllll'oluhJdl, COIllI.HIIlY. <;orporillu}fl, t'le , rldITWI! ahuvt~, lSee remarks below)
18 Nomo-l.md lltte 01 iiidi~id~~ii-se.iv;;d {II rlllt ',hown .ltll)VI I II!) A p' "",1' ,I ,.,,! Illil "" .1':I,""I~III;~,-;- -----
11'"IIII1"J " n". ,It" 11" 11'1, 1".u.l1 pl,u '1 (J'
_,_~UEL_j~" GAI!QNER. SR, ,'",," "
20 Address 01 whero SCfllud (r;nmplph' only 1111,I/I'III.t Itl 11\ ',llllII>II .IIIlIVt') l'l!rPf't or fifD, Ap.lflml'lll No l'l n,lli' nt '.;.'rll." [:?2-T~mu. ~
City, Boro, Twp Slate and lI~l Cod,,) .......
!g~f
SAME AS 1/6 ll-17-95 9:45 AM
2:j-MTElIPiil- Di."-PoIllU ID8P iot [ Dale I Mile. [Dep Inl l Dale [ Mile. lOop 101. [ Date [Mile. [Dep In_I '[ Oale piiieoi Oop,lnl,
II-16L 28 V-3 ll-I~ 28 V-I L-J
24-Adi.nceCoBI.- -?" S';'~':'~~""h I"" N"I~','O~'" [?i M~'~':'~~'IWU 120 ro~,~~~~s ~e9 ~Q;:~~;;:D
30 REMARKS~-'- - Pd i,) 't JflJ.A':"H
31 AffiRMED and subscribed 10 befortJ n1l' thl~_
34 tt;-'{U~ --;:9~jll!~c. .,', 10
31 -- -- ,. u.' ...-.-. .,-.. .,,',1'If1f~";'1.,iiPl,;;jV'~'~~"; ;1;";';'
~lJA't~IJ(~yp r.M::\miiHEAIi(SREhiRN 91GNATUAE I
Of AUfttoRllE.QISSU~,~l,lT.IQJWii'(cANf,lI\T'",--J, I
! " ',!I~T('I '-1";"1'1 e",,,,,' - L" 'I'r, 1
'1'1' 'I",';' ,><] r. _:;1("\ .'j,' : ''''1" I t.)' :\}In(~ i\i} l' I( illll 'I
20TH
95
. - -- , '~") si1t!/I' 'G2' ,
"../.- ~A
";-~~;'I;'d-III-,;;':;I 7. tAA-, .. . \.. ., . ~
{"'p ',t\l'"l' RONALD J I ON
. ,... ... .
,1.10,110
11-20-95
Ih""jlldl"n',,"il'llIl1lf
It! Oulu
SHERIFF Of FRANKUN COUNTY
r'l"ln"'h.-iil!':'-:;~~'1
llC50dI190:)
-.....-
Thomaa E, Brenner, Eaquire
GOLD..RO, KATZMAN. SHIPMAN,
320 Market Street
Strawberry Square
',0, BOl< 126B
Harrieburg, 'A 17108-126B
Attorney I,D, #32085
(717) 234-4161
JOHN M. BAILEY,
Plaintiff
..c.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
NO, 95-4363
DAVID C. JENKINS,
Defendant
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR"
Additional Defendant
PRAECIPE TO ENTER APPEARANCE
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
please enter the appearance of Thomas E, Brenner, Esquire, and
Drew Gannon, Esquire, of Goldberg, Katzman & Shipman, P.C., on
behalf of Additional Defendant, Samuel A, Gardner, Sr.
Respectfully submitted,
GOldberg,; Jtatzma("'JShiPman, P.C.
By: h (J'r.d_ ...f;r'l( 'v~----
~as E, Brenner, Esquire
1.0. No, 32085
Drew Gannon, Esquire
1.0, No, 74680
320 Market Street
Strawberry square
P.O. Box 1268
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1268
(717) 234-4161
Attorneys for Additional Defendant,
Samuel A. Gardner, Sr.
Date:
) (- - ,./
I2')"/'
, ' e bl ~
]~1 '=" .'J
r'," ,1-\
rt ~'j ,"">
;.;>~". I ~
(.1~-': Q'
~(j C,
.."
':8 ~
~o::: (...),
-.
z '"
~ ~ ....
--
~ ....
, I
" ,
"
, ,
, 'P
, :'~
o"J,1jJf'1
.rill.
,...
....,.,t'-..
~~'.'"
~"J
1~
:;.;
~
..... oW>
~
~
~
'.
f(]
21. Denied for till' r('"sons statl'd in p.lrilgraph 20,
22. Deni('d. TIll' ddl'ndant's negligent act of traveling .It an excessive
rate of speed beyond the posh'd spl'('d limit IVaN the proximate cause of the
accident and defend.lIlt should be Iwld liable for any damageN that resulted
from his negligent conduct.
ANSWER TO NEW MATTER
CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE
23. Plaintiff's original complaint paragraphs I through 12 are
incorporated herein by referl'nce thereto.
24. Denied. John M. Bailey, plaintiff, setup flares behind the vehicle of
Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., and facing oncoming traffic prior to the collision
between defendant'lI vehicle and the vehicle of the plaintiff.
25. Denied, Thr('e flares were set up 25 feet apart for a total distance of
75 feet by the plaintiff.
26. Denied. Plaintiff did have his flashers operating at the time of
the contact by defendant's vehicle,
27. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering phlintiff is
without knowledr;e or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth
of the averment, and therefore, it is denied. Proof thereof, if relevant, is
demanded at the time of trial on this matter.
28. Denied. Defendant was traveling at an excessive rate of speed in
excess of the posted speed limit which was the proximate C<llIse of the
collision between defendant's vehicl~' and the vehicle of the plaintiff.
29. a. Denied. Flares were setup in a sufficient manner to warn
oncoming traffic of an accident.
b. Denied. Plaintiff and his family stopped as Good Samaritans
to help an elderly man who had suffered severe facial injuries in a prior one
vehicle accident.
c. Denied. For reilsons stilted in paragraph 26.
30. a. Denied. For reasons stated in paragraph 25.
b. Denied. h)r reasons stated in panlgraph 27,
c. Denied. (lor n'asons stated in paragraph 20.
DAVID C. JENKINS
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
~
NO.9. - 4363 CIVIL TERM
JOHN M, BAILEY
V.
VERIHCA TION
"
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA )
$.
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
)
I verify that the statements made In the foregoing document are true and
correct, to the best of my knowledge, Information, and belief. I understand that
false statements herein made are subject to the provisions of 18 Pa. C.S,A. S 4904
relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
/Z-Z3.- tj'r
Date
fyi!/n 7?1 e~
M. Bailey
0(\ q -to b~
cctbldu1 'fo
oriq Aid -tf::~
~ ,_ I a/V),,;t<- V l/l /'
?'~ U lO/J-V!1J
, , ~ ,,) r~
0',
~1;~:' ru... ,-J
ItUg) 'I~ "1~
~:: '~~1.:1
"'"r,-
Ol,"r~ 0 ~~~
f~':;J .."
...:-: -..,' ~,i~
,;.:. C'1 -
:ii:~ - ~ I,
..
.::- ~
~, N
..
,"
"
~
"
if:
~
-::r
,.
:.'it:
['II.. '.,
?I~( "
I,',
.....~
'"
~
. '
.f',J
"
'1,;01';'';"
,I"
'."
("
, '
'.'
,I
,
,
,1,'-
"
.'
,
,
'\:
,Ii,"
"
'I,
.
DAVID C JENKINS
PRO SE DEFENDANT
50 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Telephone: 717.258-9263
JOHN M, BAILEY
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA,
VS
DAVID C. JENKINS
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION LAW
NO 95-4363 CIVIL TERM
~OTICE TO PLEAD
TO: JOHN M, BAILEY. Plaintiff
You are notilied to file a written response to the enclosed Defendant's Answer to Plaintift's
Complaint and New Matter within twenty (20) days from the service hereof or a judgment may be
entered against you,
,
r-/jiW MATTJ;R :.SlJPm~N liMJiROf,r-/CY
13 Defendant was operating his vehicle in the right hand lane of Interstate 81. headed in a
southerly direction
14, Defendant was maintaining a proper assured clear distance ahead
I ~ Samuel A, Gardner, Sr, was the operator of a vehicle whieh was in a single car accident
immediately prior to the contact between the vehicle owned by the plaintiff and the vehicle owned
by the defendant.
16 The vehicle of Samuel A Gardner, Sr, was situated in the left hand lane of Interstate 81
17, The vehicle owned by the plaintil1'was parked behind the vehicle of Samuel A Gardner,
Sr,
18, As defendant approached the vehicles owned by the plaintiff and by Samuel A, Gardner,
Sr, Samuel A Gardner, Sr, moved unexpectedly and without warning into the right hand lane of
traffic,
19, The movements of Samuel A Gardner, Sr placed him in front of the defendant's moving
vehicle
20, As a result of the actions of Samuel A Gardner, Sr, the defendant was faced with a
sudden emergency and was forced to make a spli;.second decision to apply the brakes of his
vehicle in order to avoid hitting Samuel A Gardner, Sr
21, As a result of the defendant being forced to make a split-second decision to apply the
brakes of his vehicle in order to avoid hitting Samuel A Gardner, Sr" the vehicle owned by the
defendant came in contact with the vehicle owned by the plaintiff
22 Because the contact between the vehicle owned by the defendant and the vehicle owned
by the plaintilTwas a result of this sudden emergency, the defendant is relieved of any liability in
cOMcction with plaintiffs claim
mw MATTER. COlITBID.UTORY NJilll"lGliliCI;
23 Paragraphs I through 22 of the defendant's answer are hereby incorporated
24 Both Samuel A Gardner, Sr and the plaintiff, John M Bailey, set up flares in front the of
the vehicle owned by Samuel A Gardner. Sr immediately prior to the contact between the vehil:le
owned by the plaintiff and the vehicle owned by the defendant.
2S These flares were set up at a distance not greater than tifty leet ahead of the disabled
vehicle owned by Samuel A Gardner, Sr
26, PlaintitT did not have the flashers of his vehicle operating before or at the time of the
contact between the vehicle owned by the plaintitT and the vehicle owncu by the defendant.
27, Samuel A Gardner did not have the flashers of his vehicle operating before or at the time
of the contact between the vehicle owned by the plaintitT and the vehicle owned by the defendant,
28, Alternatively, the defendant avers that any damages sustained by the plaintitTwere the
result of his own contributory negligence and also the negligence of Samuel A, Gardner, Sr, and
that the plaintiff's claim is therefore barred by the Comparative Negligence Act (42 Pa C. S,
~7102), In the alternative. any recovery by the plaintitTmust be reduced by the extent of the
plaintiff's contributory negligence and also by the portion of causal negligence attributed to
Samuel A Gardner, Sr"
29, The defendant avers that plaintitTwas negligent in the following manner:
a, In failing to set up !lares in front of the disabled vehicle of Samuel A Gardner, Sr, in a
manner that would give sufficient warning time to oncoming motorists that a disabled vehicle was
ahead,
b In stopping his vehicle in a lane of traffic,
c, In failing to use flashers or other sufficient means to notifY oncoming traffic that his
vehicle was stopped in a lane of traffic,
30, The defendant avers that Samuel A Gardner, Sr, was negligent in the following manner:
a, In failing to set up !lares in front of the disabled vehicle of Samuel A Gardner. Sr, in a
manner that would give sufficient waming time to oncoming motorists that a disabled vehicle was
ahead
b In failing to use !lashers or other sufficient means to notifY oncoming traffic that his
vehicle was disabled in a lane of traffic
c In moving unexpectedly and without warning into the right hand lane of traffic in front of
the defendant's moving vehicle,
31, Alternatively, the defendant avers that any damages sustained by the plaintitT were the
result of his own contributory negligence and that the plaintiff's claim is therefore barred by the
Comparative Negligence Act (42 Pa C S ~7102) In the alternative, any recovery by the
plaintitTmust be reduced by the e~tent of the plaintiff's contributory negligence
JOHN M. BAILEY
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF ClIM8ERI.AND COUNTY, PENNA.
VS
DAVIDC. JENKINS
Defendant
CIVil. ACTION l.AW
NO. 95-4363 CIVIL TERM
AFFIDAVIT
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYL VANIA )
)SS
COUNTY OF ClIMBERLAND )
Before me, the undersigned authority, a Notary Public in and for said County and
Commonwealth, personally appeared David ('. Jmlilla, who being duly sworn according to law,
deposes and says that the averments of fact contained in the foregoing pleading are true and
correct to the best of affiant's knowledge, information and belief
~~d--~~
David C. Jenkins
SWORN TO and subscribed
be ore me this .Q}_l. day of
,1995.
ap~;~ fh. f1--
Notary Public
_rtal5eal
Ak. M. ,.... Mollify ""'"
C......lorollllh. CumMiloM Coun"
My CommlOllon bpi... Me....b.". 1ft.
,",OIDI.S. IRMlr, lIqulrw
1.0. No. 31085
GOLDal!lG, KAT~IAN . SIIJI'IItAN, P.C,
310 M.rbl SlI..,
P.O. ... 115.
H.rriobu/J. PA 17101-1261
AI1ll.....y ell' Additlnnal D.''1ndant
JOHN M. BAILEY,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
.
.
NO. 95-4363
DAVID C. JENKINS,
Defendant
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR.,
Additional Defendant
IIOTICII
YOU "II .IIQUI.IID to plead to the within Amended Answer with
New Matter within twenty (20) days of service hereof or a default
judqment may be entered against you.
Respectf.ully submitted,
Goldberq, Kat..an , 8hipaan, P.C.
\
,
I :
BY.: ""1,". '" '/'-" t,..___'-
Thomas E. Brenner, Esquire
1.D. No. 32085
Drew Gannon, Esquire
1.0. No. 74680
320 Market street
Strawberry Square
P.O. Box 1268
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1268
(717) 234-4161
Attorneys for Additional Defendant,
Samuel A. Gardner, Sr.
noma. s. BnlUWr, lMlul,.
1.0. No. 310"
GOLDBERG, KATlMAN .. S1I1PMAN, P,C.
320 M.rbl Sin"
P.o. 10. 1268
Haniob.... PA 17101-1261
AUOtMV (or Addlbunal OIl.ndam
JOHN M. BAILEY,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 95-4363
v.
DAVID c. JENKINS,
Defendant
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR.,
Additional Defendant
AMBIID.D AIIIWII. WITH II" MATT.R O~
ADPITIOIIAL DII..KDANT. I~U.L A. GIRD.... IR.
AND NOW, comes Additional Defendant, Samuel A. Gardner, sr.,
by his attorneys, Goldberg, Katzman & Shipman, P.C., who states:
1. Admitted.
2. Admitted.
3.
Denied.
This paragraph states a legal conclusion to
which no response is necessary.
4. Denied as stated. The vehlcle of Additional Defendant
slid on an lce covered roadway and came to a stop on the left ber.
10. Denied. Additional Defendant Gardner did not move his
person or his vehicle as alleged by Defendant Jenkins.
11. Denied. Additional Defendant Gardner did not move his
person or his vehicle as alleged by Defendant Jenkins. In further
response, Defendant lost control of his vehicle causing it to
strike the vehicle owned by Plaintiff Bailey.
12. Denied. Additional Defendant did not move his person or
his vehicle as alleged by Defendant Jenkins. In further response,
Defendant lost control of hie vehicle causing it to strike the
vehicle owned by Plaintiff Bailey.
13. Denied.
This paragraph states a legal conclusion to
which no response is necessary.
14. Denied. Additional Defendant Gardner was not negligent,
reckless or careless.
a. Denied. Flare. were placed to warn of the disabled
vehicle.
3
,
,II
b. Denied. As a result of the damage to the vehicle
owned by the Additional Defendant the flashers were not operable.
The Additional Defendant's vehicle was partially in the left berm
and left travel lane.
c. Denied. Additional Defendant Gardner did not move
his person or his vehicle onto the road surface and into the right
hand lane of travel in front of the vehicle operated by Defendant
Jenkins.
15. Denied. This paragraph states a legal conclusion to
which no response is necessary.
16. Denied. This paragraph states a legal conclusion to
which no response is necessary. Moreover, the paragraph is
directed to Plaintiff rather than Additional Defendant and
therefore no response is required.
17. Denied. This paragraph states a legal conclusion to
which no response is necessary.
4
II" MATTIR
18. This accident and the damage to the Bailey vehicle arose
solely from the negligence, recklessness or carelessness of
Defendant, David C. Jenkins, in that he:
a. failed to keep his vehicle under proper and adequate
control;
b. failed to bring his vehicle to a stop before
striking the Bailey vehicle which was parked off the travel portion
of the roadway; and
c. operated his vehicle at a speed that was excessive
under the circumstances then and there existing;
19. The damages to the Plaintiff's vehicle arose solely from
the comparative negligence of Defendant, David C. Jenkins.
20. The vehicle operated by Samuel A. Gardner, sr., had been
disabled from an earlier accident and was stopped partially in the
left berm and the left lane. The Gardner vehicle did not move aa
the vehicle of Defendant Jenkins approached.
5
WHEREFORE, Additional Defendant, Samuel A. Gardner, Sr.,
reque.ts that the Complaint of Defendant, David C. Jenkins, be
dismissed with prejudice.
Date: /- f7'1(
Respectfully submitted,
Gold~er9, Kat..an , Ship.an, P.C.
I
,
'"\
By: . . I.. '< .
Thomas E. Brenner, Esquire
1. D. No. 32085
Drew Gannon, Esquire
I.D. No. 74680
320 Market street
Strawberry Square
P.O. Box 1268
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1268
(717) 234-4161
Attorneys for Additional Defendant,
Samuel A. Gardner, Sr.
1:
6
I
1
!
I
I
,
,
I,
i,
I
i'
~
I
I
"
"~I !!
I
I
I
, . I
,'.'
8
.
-
ie'
....
...
("l')
"I
~~ I,
,...
~.-.
t..~....
UJ~.;o'.
':a-',:t4.
~".~,
a.....~....
I 6;~.t ;J1,
l'.la: ~ 1!
'aJ";'~...
~~J H~'
\1. ~,;a:
::>
'0<<.)
I
I
"
,.
.)
'.1
I.,
'.' I
'4
Id
",.
I,'
.:.D
s
.1
, I
',I,
.'.
i"
,
,
I,
"
I
"
I,
'j ",'
'I.
'.
I
"i,
'.1
"
I I
.,.
).
':
',I
..~. ',.
,,'eI!
. ,
.
-.
,
.
.
DAVlDC. JENKINS
PRO SE DEFENDANT
50 Eut HIp Street
Carlille, P A 17013
Telephone: 717-258-9263
JOHN M. BAILEY,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
VS.
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA.
DAVID C. JENKINS,
Defendant and
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR.,
Additional Defendant
CIVIL ACTION LAW
NO. 95-4363 CIVIL TERM
NOTICE
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the
CoUowina Plies, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and notice are
served, by enterina I written appearance personally or by Illomey and filing in writing with the
court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth Igainst you . You are warned thlt if you
fail to do 10 the case RIlly proceed without you and I judgment may be entered against you by the
court without further notice for any money claimed in the complaint or for any other claim or
relief requeated by the plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to
you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE TIllS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU 00
NOT HA VB A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE nIB
OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Court Administrltor
Fourth Floor
Cumberland County Court House
1 Court House Square
Carlille, PI. 17013
717.240.6200
^ .a..-->
Dlvid C.lenkins
Pro II DeCendant
13. Because the contact between the vehicle owned by the defendant and the vehicle owned
by the plaintiffwu I reault of this sudden emergency, the defendant is relieved of any liability in
cOMection with plaintiffs claim.
14. The defendant further Ivers that at the time of the accident, the additional defendant wu
negligent, reckleu and careless under the circumstances in:
I. Failing to set up flares in front of the disabled vehicle of the additional defendant in I
manner thlt would sive aufficient warning time to oncoming motorists that a dil8bled vehicle wu
ahead.
b. Failing to use tluhers or other sufficient means to notify oncoming motorists that his
vehicle wu disabled in a lane of traffic.
c. Moving unexpectedly and without warning into the right hand lane of traffic in front of
the defendant's moving vehicle.
IS. The defendant Ivers that any damages sustained by the plaintiff were the result of the
neglillence of the additional defendant and that he is solely liable to the plaintiff on the plaintift's
cause of action.
16. The defendant further Ivers thlt at the time of the Iccident, the plaintiff was neglillent,
rcckJeu and careless under the circumstances in:
a. Failing to set up tlares in front of the disabled vehicle of the additional defendant in I
manner that would sive sufficient warning time to oncoming motorists that a disabled vehicle wu
ahead.
b. StoPpinll his vehicle in a lane of traffic.
c. Failing to use tluhers or other sufficient means to notify oncoming motorists that his
vehicle wu stopped in I lane of traffic.
17. Alternatively, the defendant Ivers that if the defendant is found neglillent with rellard to
the plaintiWs cause of action, that the plaintiff wu contributorily negligent and that the additional
defendant is jointly and severally liable with the defendant or liable over to the defendant and that
any damqes lII'tained by the plaintiff and recoverable Igainst the defendant must be reduced by
the proportion of causal neglillence attributed to both the plaintiff and the additional defendant.
WHEREFORE, the defendant, Dlvid C. Jenkins, respectfully requests this Court to enter the
following:
1. Judament in his flvor, tOllether with costs.
, ,
TbQaa. I. I~.nn.~, I.qul~.
~".~.., .......... I ..1...,
320 Ma~~t .t~..t
't~.wbe~~y 'qu.~.
P.O. lox 126a
H.~~i.bu~9, PA 17108-1268
Atto~n.y 1.0. '3208~
(717) 234-4161
JOHN M. BAILEY,
Plaintiff
..e.
v.
IN THE COURT or COMMON PLBAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 95-4363
DAVID C. JENKINS,
Defendant
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR.,
Additional Defendant
.
.
.
.
.
1I0000ICI
yOU "II .lIgUI..D to pleat to the vUhi. ADIVBJ: vU:b .ev llatter
vitbi. tve.ty (30) daYI of eervioe hereof or a default judpeat ..y
be eatered a9ai.lt you.
Reepectfully lubmitted,
Goldber9, Kat.... I Ibip..a, ..C.
~~_lro
I.D. No. 32085
Drew Gannon, llquire
I. D. No. 74680
320 Market Street
Strawberry Square
P.O. Box 1268
Harriaburg, PA 17108-126'
(717) 234-4161
ThGaa. .. I~.nn.~, l.qu1~e
101......." ~IIIIAII , ..JP"",
320 H.~k.t .t~..t
.t~.wba~~y 'qu.~.
'.0. lox 1261
H.~~1.bu~9, 'A 17108-126.
Atto~n.y J.D. 1320a5
(717) 234-4161
JOHN M. BAILEY,
Plaintiff
'IC,
IN THB COURT or COMMON PLIlAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 95-4363
v.
DAVID C. JENKINS,
Defendant
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR.,
Additional Defendant
AIISWD _11'11 II" IlAT-':. O.
&DDITIOKaL DII..KDAWT. .axU.L A. GARD.... ...
AND NOW, com.e Additional Defendant, Samuel A. Gardner, Sr.,
by hi. attorneys, GOldberq, Katzman' Shipman, P.C., who .tate.:
1. Admitted.
2. Admitted.
3.
Denied.
Thi. paraqraph .tat.. a legal conclu.ion to
which no r..pon.e i. n.c....ry.
4. Denied a. atated. The vehicle of Additional Defendant
slid on an ice covered roadway and came to a stop on the left bera
and left travel lane of the highway several minutes prior to the
approach by Defendant Jenkins whose vehicle left the road aurface
and struck the vehicle of Mr. Bailey.
5. Denied in part. The vehicle of Additional Defendant
Gardner was stopped partially in the left berm and the left travel
lane.
6. Admitted.
7. Denied. After reasonable inve.tiqation the anawerinq
defendant is without knowledge or information eufficient to fora a
belief a. to the truth of this paragraph and proof thereof is
de.anded.
8. Denied. After rea.onable investigation the anawaring
defendant i. without knowledge or information sufficient to form a
belief as to the truth of this paragraph and proof thereof i.
demanded. Moreover, thie paragraph states a legal concluaion to
which no re.pon.e i. nece.aary.
~
'.l'
II. D.ni.d, Additional Defendant did not move hi. v.hicle a.
all.9.d by the D.f.ndant Jenkin..
10. D.ni.d. Additional Def.ndant did not move hi. v.hicle a.
all.q.d by tha D.f.ndant J.nkin..
11. Denied. Additional Def.ndant did not move hi. v.hicle a.
all.qed by the Defendant Jenkin.. In furth.r reaponae, Def.ndant
loat control of hi. vehicle causing it to strike the vehicle own.d
by Plaintiff Bailey.
12. D.nied. Additional Defendant did not move hi. vehicle a.
all.q.d by the D.f.ndant Jenkin.. In further r..ponae, Defendant
loat control of hi. vehicle causing it to strike the v.hicle ownad
by Plaintiff Bailey.
13. DeniBd. This paragraph stat.s a l.gal concluaion to
w~ich no r..pon.. i. nece.Bary.
14. D.ni.d. Additional DefBndant Gardn.r wa. not n.qliqent,
reckla.. or car.l....
3
a. Deni.d. Flare. w.re placed to warn of the di.abl.d
v.hicl..
b. Deni.d. A. a r..ult of the damage to the vehicle
owned by the Additional D.fendant the fla.h.r. w.re not operable.
The Additional Def.ndant'. vehicle wa. partially in the left berm
and l.ft trav.l lan..
c.
Denied.
Additional Defendant did not move hi.
v.hicl. onto the road .urfac. and into the right hand lene of
travel in front of the v.hicle op.rat.d by D.fendant J.nkin..
15. Denied. Thie paragraph .tat.. a legal conclu.ion to
which no r..pon.. i. nec...ary.
16. D.ni.d. Thie paragraph .tate. a l.gal conclu.ion to
which no r..pon.. i. neee..ary.
Moreov.r, the paragraph i.
direct.d to Plaintiff rather than Additional Def.ndant and
therefore no reftpon.e i. r.quired.
11. D.nied. Thie paragraph .tate. a l.gal eonclu.ion to
which no r..pon.. i. n.c....ry.
4
.
I "t'
, . '''\'1
,),,1"1
. '.',V
. . '1'''.
I ,\, 1.lt(l'':~
'iU:\'
1:,
.n 1m'!"!"
18. Thi. accident and the damage to the Bailey vehicle aro.e
.olely fro. the ne91igence, recklee.neee or carele..ne.. of
Defendant, David C. Jenkine, in that ha:
a. failed to keep hi. villhicle under proper and adequate
control;
b. failed to brin9 hill vehicle to a .top before
.trikinq the Bailey vehicle which wa. parked off the travel portion
of the roadway; and
c. operated hi. vehicle at a .peed that was exc...ive
under the circum.tance. then and there exi.tin9;
19. The damage. to the Plaintiff'. vehicle aro.. .olely tro.
the comparative ne9ligence of Detendant, David C. Jenkin..
20. The vehicle operat.d by Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., had been
di.abled from an earlier accident and was .topped partially in the.
left bera and the left lane. The Gardner vehicle did not aove ..
the vehicle ot Defendant Jenkin. approached.
5
VIlRlfICATION
I, Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., hereby acknowledge that I am an
Additional Defendant in this aqtion; that I have read the foregoing
Answer with New Matter; and that the facts stated therein are true
and correct to the best of my knowledge, inf.ormation and belief.
I understand that any false statements herein are made subject
to penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. Section 4904, relating to unsworn
falsification to authorities.
.2~l_~.jl ,:.( _tlt""<,",,, ~~oJl, ) l
Samuel A. Gardner, Sr.
I
Dated:
.,
'I
I
I
,j
g ..0 ~
UI
r:? :;:I
..,,6') ,,-,.,
rpt.' ...~ ,.'~
~.ii ':~i~
.(.?c- N
lJ).';'; c;r. ~~i: I
~I!\
~ ,1 -::>
~,
~,.';Q ::: n~
I' ' i...lt) W <:5
,,,C .. --'<
~ r. ~
0
"
I,,, ~
-
-....I
(J.;
V1
,..,
" -n
., ::lit
".. -
" OJ:>
..."
::i ~~i g f i ~ .,
~ ~i!); S; '"
8~ 3: VI
... . I
N ......n n ....
VI <11 . ~ . ~ ~
Cll . :z: .
I Io-I.c..; c.. '"
~ ~~ f. ~~ 'J t ~ Q
'" CIl. <
~~ . '-0 ~ ~
00 11
"''''8' $~ P I
~ 1
~~
I, I II
> r
J
, "
,.
"
,
,
~
f
I
~
..,
.l::
~
M
.....
"'It-
",
cur. ,~1:
~'~:i '
',..'..l ,
I f'
,
..
":1'
.'
,t ,) i1: ~_,
i "~~J'
'...LI
"
,.
,
cii
,
"
"
,
,
"
"
.',
"
"
)'1
,.
,
:'
,',
i,','
.,
, ,
,
,
.
..
.~
oil
".-
a
.
DAVID C JENKINS
PRO SE DEFENDANT
50 Eut High Street
Carlisle. PA 17013
Telephone: 717-258-9263
JOHN M BAILEY
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA
vs.
DAVID C. JENKINS
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION LAW
NO 95-4363 CIVIL TERM
DEFENDANT'S ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S
REOUEST FOR ADMISSIONS
I. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is admilled that some of the documents contained
in the plaintift's Request for Admissions purpon to penain to labor and materials used in repairing
the plaintift's vehicle. Plaintiff has also included receipts for car rental charges, towing and
storage fees, and medical expenses which are not pans and labor used in repairing the plaintiffs
vehicle. It is denied that these car rental charges, towing and storage fees, and medical expenses
pertain to the cost oflabor and materials used in repairi:1g the plaintift's vehicle. Plaintiff has also
included several photographs, many of which are not entirely clear and make it difficult to judge
the cars actual appearance and the time of the photographs. The photographs are also
accompanied by several notes that have become illegible u the apparent result of suecessive
photo~opying. It is denied that these photographs penain to the cost oflabor and materials used
in repairing the plaintift's vehicle. After a reasonable investigation, the defendant is unable to form
an opinion as to whether or not all of the damages billed and itemized are the proximate result of
the accident of February 4, 1995. The reasons why all of the damage~ billed and itemized may not
be a proximate result of the accident ofFebruary 4, 1995 are as follows
a. The estimate for damage~ wu revised twice after the initial repon for damages. the lut of
which wu prepared two months after the initial repon for damages.
b. The vehicle may have sustained damage or had damage exacerbated as I result ofthe
towing of thCl vehicle from the accident scene
c. The vehicle may have sustained damage or had damage exacerbated during the storage of
the vehicle in the outside rear lot of Mullen's GIJIt'Service Station for several days.
d. The vehicle may have sustained damagc or had damage exacerbated as a result ot'the
towing of the vehicle from Mullcn's Gulf Service Stalion to the Freysinger Pontiac Body Shop.
e. The vehicle may have sustained damage or had damage exacerbated during the storage of
the vehicle at the Freysinger Pontiac Body Shop
f The vehicle may have sustained damage or had damage exacerbated as a result of the work
performed on the vehicle by Freysinger Pontiac Body Shop
2. Denied. The costs set forth in the plaintift's Request for Admission are not fair, reasonable
and necessary. and are not reflective of those customarily charged. The reasons that the costs are
not fair, reasonable and necessary, and are not reflective of those customarily charged are as
follows:
a The majority of replacement parts used in repairing the vehicle were not used parts. The
majority of these parts could have been replaced with used parts. An insufficient effort appears to
have been made to mitigate the costs of the damages sustained by the plaintift's vehicle.
b. The damage report was revised twice over the course of two months and calls into
question the accuracy of the reports as to the cost of the damages.
~~2-~~~~
Pro se Defendant
'i
',I"
I
"
'" t'
,I',
.,
':',
'.,
f.
-I
.,
",
'. (II,
-',
\ ,.
, .
,
,
.,"
.,
,
,
"
..,
,
. l,.i"
'/,
'.
, ,
"
d"
,.
I
.,
" l
.1
"
"
"
','/ '
"
tl,.
',,;
,,',
,.
'i'
'1,1'
:"",
,.
, ,
, ,
"
",
I,
'J-"
I.t.
'"~,I
.Sf'U
~ O~ rH '95
,', 1'/l,', \Ii ;'C~ '
Of,." h, I !t'tJ N-,lT ,,~y
,ittJJ"j[ :iLM4!J (;,>. ;Uy
~'l ,'iNS /l', ,\1-'/'.1
','1,
"
"
"
.1.,..
,..I
, ,
'. ,
,
.,
"
"I'
, ,
,
,
,
"
I.
'"
"
,
I,
, ,
.,
.,
..........
,
";
:1,
,
,
II
:,
I.
"
.' ,
;/1
I ,
'. '. ,
, ,
, .1',
,.
'\,'
,'I,
.Ii";:
"I '/"
.1.
"'t
,..
'.
" ,
, .!/
"i,
."
,
,
"
"
,
,.
'I'
,
'.
II'
,
1-"
I
I
,
'I,
'I 1 I,
" .1
"
,
"~'I
,I
',I,
'..
!I!
"
..
!'::I'~1 '
/':1,
,
,.i'.
'" ."H ",
'1'. I,
" ..- r :.l, ~ . ':~;'/ .,', \ \,~I
, ' , /.' ~ 'j' I
"l..
I:,
"'/'/;
\, .,
!/ '
,):,:, ~
"'/
'/,'
'i
"
'!Iii
I,.
,,".1':
,'1', "
, "I
)'.J.'L
I,,'
..i.',"
..
I,'.'
'.
:/'
.!
I)
,'1'[
"
JOHN H. BAILEY, I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
Plaintiff I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V. I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
DAVID C. JENKINS, I
Defendant
V. I NO. 95-4363 CIVIL TERM
I Cf4. :WTJ
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR. , I
Additional Defendant
IN RZ I VACATB ARBITRATOR
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, MAY 15, 1996, the appointment of William
Daniels, Esquire is hereby vacated and Stephen B. LipBon,
Bsquire, is appointed in hi. .tead.
By the Court,
James Flower, Bsquire
Chairman
~ephen B. Lipson Esquire
Philip Briganti, Esquire
Court Administrator
IsId
TRUE COPY FROM RECORD
In Tt:.'.'I'r'"h1'!.!" J"!"'. I !"~'~ !):'t" SlIt my IIIIld
and tr.~ ;>:;~~ '~I~ :.\:.J (;~~;~i1 Jt C"Jf.ti~fI9l Pa.
i'J)}S-jf1it.,&.:lliu~~' . ~
~~ r
Prothonotary
,
SHERIff'S RETURN - OUT Of COUNTY
CASE NO: 1995-04363 P
COMMONWEALTH Of PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY Of CUMBERLAND
8AILEY JOHN II
VS.
JENKINS DAVID C
R. Thomas Kline
to law, says, that h. mad.
named defendant, to wit:
, Sheriff, who being duly sworn according
diligent search and inquiry for the within
JENKINS DAVID C
but was unable to locate
Him
in his bailiwick. He therefor.
County, Pennsylvania.
deputized the sheriff of CHESTER
to .erve the within COMPLAINT
On Auaust
28th, 1995
, this offioe was in receipt of
the attached return from
CHESTER
County, Pennsylvania.
Sheriff's Costs:
Dooketing
Out of County
Surcharge
CHESTER COUNTY
- .)
So aps,;,;}.: // /,
.Q~' ,
- -,/- ,. .-,- '.'
--
/- ,-
-',;..:2; ~1ih.""
.....~~.,
,
GEORGE D GLAS
08/2811995
~
18.00
9.00
2.00
22.60
i5T~
Sworn and subscribed to before me
this ~!!Y day of ~ ~r::._ 1..
.
19 t;{ A.D.
q,.-
~ 1\\' h. i' ..~-r...
ro ana aty ,
..
I T' C . C --! . - I d'"
.... n'" ourt or -mmO~1 "'-". or I . ,.- . -:".1...... I ...,~._.'f
,. l;;;i _. . . r __;;) ........"............ _I' ........,-...."
?Srtr:syl'lcr:i ::
John M. Bailey
David C. .Jenkins
'is.
,-,
~".
q ~ - 4 163 C.i.li.i..l-Isu:m
--.
:~---
:iow. .allgIlCt- If..
lQQC;
:9__ I. S:~?...::!"
,"
. -,
.
. )
h=-..i:!y ci..;:u== r.!:.: Sh="..:i' oi
ChPR I'er
O~ /",.,.. ~":"":l. """ CO''''''''''v :::l ,,: .I
... ",,,,,"'4.,:)__~''''; "",.'1~.,....0 ~'" .
~; "dY. .'..1
C -=- '0 ...._.....1;.:' __.. 9" _.
... ..,. -----,= -- ....,
~ -i:puQ.:.cu :~ -~.:- :It == ~ ::d ~ oi :.::= ?!~~.
r~~-K~~
SlIe...,:f at C:::::i:e:"..1l:d C~u:rr, ?:l.
Affidavit or Sem~
:Sow,
hi
o() ,f-L(r;U.'~1
o".:!ca
. .F ~t. 1::".-e:i
.Q (16
. ....
.'.~ ,<'L'I t!~
Cia:)
::: wiCiD C().-Jf.'"1fl,Y\-i- l~\l{'--'
'~paa CM v; ef (l. - Lh..v j(.' OL::-
1t L.Jo~ ANqi;k,c<, -T~I<: Efl-;;"j- lb,::;'
~ I ,
';y ::u:cii:!.t:.o I~V;oJ. C. ,JcNkl}l..~
C'Hc-';,~,f" (' k'5I~(<, (!-"J, t, ~.
I ,
~.-
I.
-,~<\.~~
C':P!' oi == :)it.:.=U (~ \..)( ( )1 'l", ~ '"';--
:r.nd ::wi: COWll :0
H.t>>l
. ..
~ .:=~;:::.:s :'-:::::-:L
So~","""
~L'! 111.11 ~~',~I
.,k)an P '~"I r. '-r''''~I'' Nulnrl ~uhllC
West (,rw :1 I:: 1ft). ~~! '(I';'," r C L II!r~1y
My Corlln,,' . en t:XPll!:i.'\nf1l: I, '!;rJ7
,7<':'l ('{"/
cilIA.,., ?~
.-'-. ,. (i:?t2.--'
C" l' -' -~
.'-T'~_':,'_( .
SWelr: 1.W':i:>d 0.::=
=: ...;. Q:" 0; ~/J
OM~;// .4,~.,~
(/
COSTS
n:A'V"ICZ
~C!U:.AGE
.~:mA;TI'
.J~:...l,..tL
II,oQ
...? . l. Q
..1,00
fa ,.,~ -
._~
s
s
.- "-6
,-
WHEREFORE, your Petitioner prays your Honorable Court to appoint
three (3) arbitrators to whom the case shall be submitted.
Respectfully submitted,
Goldberg, Katzman & Shipman, P.C.
ByM1J~
Drew P. Gannon, Esquire
Attorney's I.D. 74680
320 Market street
P.O. Box 121;8
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1268
(717) 234-4161
Attorney for Additional Defendant
Date: kfl"~
3
,
,
~~~~
. ~~~
("-. 5\
l.\3
.....
uJ
--.j
L\J
c
, \
.' , .-,
. .1
,
"' I
""j .-1 "1
I ..
-- I....) :SJ
--- I,'")
."J
I --,
: . . 'I)
.. .
.. r::' '")11"1
;.r" T .~
,. 1 :1
-, (.n -.
-.
"- .. ,
~.- --
'''- ...
'"
'I
=
!:.\
.....,
=
,:I
w
:z
"
",
....\"1
;:1;
~
-:'1;*,
~ .~
David C. Jenkins
SO East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
January 2, 1996
Originally sent via fax
Thomas E. Brenner. Esquire
Goldberg. Katzman & Shipman, P.C.
P.O. BOX 1268
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1268
re: John M. Bailey vs. David C, Jenkins and Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., 9S-4363
Dear Mr. Brenner:
I am writing to acknowledge receipt of your Answer and New Matter to the Complaint to
Join Additional Defendant that I filed in Cumberland County on November 6, 1995. 1 notice,
however, that the averments of your Answer do not adequately respond to the averments of that
Complaint. Specifically, nowhere in the Complaint and more particularly, nowhere in
Paragraphs 9, 10 and 14(c) of that Complaint is there any reference to the vehicle of Mr. Gardner
entering the right hand lane of traffic at any time before, during, or after the accident. The
Complaint avers only that the additional defendant, Mr, Gardner (that is to say his person),
moved into the right hand lane of traffic in front of the moving vehicle that 1 was operating at the
time of the accident.
I am giving you an additional twenty (20) days from the date of this letter to file an
amended answer that adequately responds to the factual averments contained in Paragraphs 9, 10
and 14(c) of the Complaint to Join Additional Defendant. 1 would also request that you extend
my time to file a response to your Answer until such time as you have filed this amended answer.
Please write to me to acknowledge receipt of this letter if you agree to file an amended
answer within the next twenty days and also grant me an extension of time to file a response to
that amended answer in place of filing a response to your initial Answer and New Matter. In the
meantime I will be preparing a preliminary objection to your Answer and New Matter for the
reasons stated above. If I do not hear from you, then I will assume that you deem your responses
adequate and I will be filing this preliminary objection during the week of January 8, 1996 in
place of a response to your New Matter.
If you any further questions concerning any perceived ambiguities in any further
documents or letters, please do not hesitate to contact me.
Sincerely,
~t,
David C. Jenkins
cc: file
r:tm-omc~
c,~ TI:: "'f!()'1'0'':OTMY
% .1"1.11/ r:t12:~6
"
"U'!.;..,,,..!,, ('C'II\ITV
'" 1"L"'I__ol",o) " .,1".,
1:[ {.II"u'l'/lf..I"\
' ,"II (,Jj ," I, ..
i,'
.,
I,
., ,
,
.,.
, ,
I
I,
,!I
,
.,
.,.
':
.,
I'
,
,
I,',
I.
, .
1-.
IR ~~
. ....
iE ~.r ,:J:! ..
U"Q~
-~,c.>
, ....:1.0;>>
0 ......- ~;:
-::r ~C"'4I)
f3fdz "
~~ lua "
...... ~ "!' ~..
':::II
,. '...
::Ia ,"
.,
"
".,
.
<I. f!
Defendant'. Amended Answer to Plaintiff's Complaint and New Matters i. attached a Exhibit
"D".
5. On October 19, 1995, the defendant filed the Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the
Pleadillp due to the fiilure of the plaintiff to respond to the Notice to Plead that accompanied the
Defendant'. Amended An.wer to Plaintiff's Complaint and New Matters within the required time.
6. Thi. Preliminary Objection is filed pending the outcome of the Defendant's Motion for
Judsment on the Pleadinp.
7. On October 20, 1995, the plaintiff filed a belated An.wer to the defendant'. New Matters.
A copy of the plaintiff's Answer to the defendant's New Matters is attached u Exhibit "E".
II. VIOLATIONS OF RULES OF COURT
8. Under Rule 1028(1)(2) of the PeMsylvania Rule. of Civil Procedure, a party may
preliminarily object by way ofa motion to strike off a pleading because oflack of conformity to a
rule of' court.
A VIOLATION OF RULE 1024(c)
9. The verification to the plaintiff's Answer to the defendant's New Matters wa not made by
the plaintiff, but rather wu made by the plaintiff's attorney, George F. Douala,lII, Esquire.
10. Rule I024(c) oftlle PeMsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure requires that:
The verification shall be made by one or more of the parties filing the pleading unIeu all the
partiee (1) lack IlUflicient knowledge or information, or (2) are outaide the jurilldiction of the
court and the verificltion of none of them can be obtained within the time allowed Cor fi1ing
the pleading. In such cases, the verification may be made by any person havinj sufficient
knowledge or information and belief shall set forth the source of hil information a to matters
not stated upon his own knowledge and the reason why the verification is not made by 1
party.
II. The verification to the plaintiff's Answer to the defendant'. New Matters wa not taken by
the p1aintitf, doea not state the ruson why the verification i. not or could not be taken by the
plaintiff, and does not set forth the source of the plaintiff's attorney's information a to the matters
contained in the Answer to the defendant's New Matters.
12. The verification to the plaintiff's Answer to the defendant's New Matters i. defective
under Rule 1024(c) oCthe PeMsylvania Rule. of Civil Procedure.
B. VIOLATION OF RULE 1024(b)
13. Paraaraph 17 of the plaintiff's Answer to the defendant's New MIUer. conl\ina Iverments
of fict inconsistent with Parqraph 6 of the plaintiffs original Complaint, which wu incorporlted
by reference into the plaintiff's Answer to the defendant's New MIUers.
14. Rule 1024(b) of the penn.ylvanil Rules of Civil Procedure requires that:
If I pleading conwnslverrnents which are inconsistent in fact, the verificltion shall state that
the tianer hu belen unable after rcuonable investigation to ascertain which of the incollJi.tent
Iverments, apecifyina them, are true but thlt he baa knowledae or information sufficient to
form I belief that one of them is true.
1 S. Paragraph 17 of the plaintiff's Answer to the defendant's New MaUers refers to .vehicles
owned by the plaintiff," wherea8 Paragraph 6 of the plaintiff'. Complaint refer. only to I tinaular
vehicle of the plaintiff.
16. Paraaraph 6 of the plaintiff'. Complaint Ivers: "The plaintiff stopped his vehicle behind
the accident victim. . ."; ParqraphslS-16 of the plaintiff's Answer to NewMltterudmit that the
original accident victim wu Samuel A. Gardner, Sr.
17. Paraaraph 17 of the plaintiff's Answer to the defendant's New Mltters avers: "The
vehicles owned by the plaintiff were parked in front of the vehicle C'f Samuel A. Gardner Sr."
18. The verification to the plaintiff's Answer to the defendant'. New Matters does not ltate
that the siana' baa been unable after reuonable investigation to ucerlain which of the inconsiatent
IVerments are true, does not speeuy the incontistent Iverments, and docs not state that the aiper
hu knowledae or information sufficient to form a belief that one of them is true.
19. The verification to the plaintiff's Answer to the defendant's New Mltters i. defective
under Rule 1024(b) of the Pennaylvania Rules of Civil Procedure.
20. The verification beina defective, the plaintiffs Answer to the defendant's New Malters is
not properly verified u required of I pleadina under both Rule I 024(b) and 1024(c) of the
Pennsylvania Rule. of Civil Procedure, and must be stricken.
III. INCLUSION OF IMPERTINENT MATTER
21. Under Rule 1028(1)(2) of the Pennsylvania Rule. of Civil Procedure, a party may
preliminarily object by wsy ofa motion to strike off a pleadina or portioRl thereofbfK:aute ottlle
inclusion of an impertinent matter.
-'~.' ,
-..
GEORGE F. DOUGLAS, 111, ESQUIRE
ATTORNEY I.D. # 61886
DOUGLAS, DOUGLAS & DOUGLAS
27 West High St.
P.O. Box 261
Carlisle, Pa. 17013
Telephone: 717-243-1790
Attorney for Plaintiff
JOHN M. BAILEY
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA,
VS.
DAVID C. JENKINS
: CIVIL ACTION LAW
qS- 4 ~"3 Q....,...i.;::r~
: NO.
NOTICE
You have been sued in Court. If you wish to defend against the class
set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days
after this complaint and notice are served, by entering a written appearance
personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defenses or
objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail
to do so, the case may proceed without YOll and" judgment may be entered
against YOll by the Court without further notice for any money claimed in
complaint or for any other claim or relief reqllested by the plaintiff. You may
lose money or property or other rights important to YOll.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF
YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFfORD ONE, GO TO OR
TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU
CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
DOUGLAS, DOUGLAS & DOUGLAS
TRUE COPY FROM RECORD ~ F. ~~
In TlItImOnYwhet'lOf. I her. unto SIt my hind GEORGE F. DOUGLAS. \II, ESQUIRE
and.hI _I of saiel COIl II Carlisle. PI. Attorney for PI.lintiff
Thill '5~day' of . ..,~
. . "
.' . L,\" . ~
.d P't!'rOlIlOnollry
Court Administrator
Fourth Floor
Cumberland County COllrt HOllse
I Court House Square
Carlisle, Pa. 17013
717.240-6200
o
r'., ~.,
( '.' '- 'I
.:...
-,
~-:;
,""'-. -
",.., '0
;~.:'.-' '..
"...~' :...--:
""!{":"'oo. ",
:>, ,).b ..
.la,"'J ~ /""'1
. ~) ~
"
.~
.....,
,.'
. J
. 1
'.
~-.
'.'.d
I
11. [n addition. fI/lll result of the neglillerH:e of tIll! defendant. the
plaintiff !!ustained $4,491.36 in dflrnages to the sflid vehicle, as is more fully Silt
forth in the attached Exhibit A.
12" Attached hereto are copies of the bills/ estimlltes in this motter,
which are provided pursuflnt to P.1.Itc.P, 1305 (b) (3).
WHEREFORE, the plaintiff claim!! of the defendant!! a sum of 6,254.36,
an amount requiring compulsory referral to arbitration under the local rules
of court.
DOUGLAS, DOUGLAS & DOUGLAS
BY l.t. P. f\-. ..p^ - '!!r
.,~-_. _..~~._..
George F. Dougla!!, Ill, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
", r
"
"
DAVID C. JENKINS
PRO SE DEFENDANT
50 East High Street
Carlisle, PA \'/013
Telephone 717-258-9263
-
JOHN M. BAlLEY
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA
VS.
DAVID C. JENKINS
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION LAW
NO. 95-4363 CIVil TERM
DEFENDANT'S AN~WER TO PLAINTIFF'S
COMPLAINT AND NEW MATTER
ANSWER
1-6. Admitted. Paragraphs 1-6 of the plaintiff's complaint are admilled.
7. Denied. The allegation contained in this paragraph constitutes a conclusion of law. The
same is, therefore, denied as a mailer oflaw.
a Denied. By way of further answer, the defendant was operating his vehicle in a safe and
prudent manner.
b. Denied By way of further answer. the defendant was keeping a proper lookout.
c. Denied By way of further answer, the defendant was operating his vehicle within the
posted 55 mile per hour speed limit
8-12 Denie:l The allegations contained in these paragraphs constitute conclusions oflaw.
The same are, therefore, denied as a matter of law By way of further answer, the defendant is
without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the losses alleged in
paragraphs 8 through 12 of plaintiffs complaint The same are, therefore, denied
NEW MA TTER..:..S!.1.Jllli'.N.EMERGENCY
13. Defendant was operating his vehicle in the right hand lane oflnterstate 81, headed in a
southerly direction
14. Defendant was maintaining a proper assured clear distance ahead.
15. Samuel A Gardner, Sr. was the operator ofa vehicle which was in a single car accident
immediately prior to the contact between the vehicle owned by the plaintiff and the vehicle owned
by the defendant
16. The vehicle of Samuel A Gardner, Sr was situated in the left hand lane of Interstate 81.
17_ The vehicle owned by the plaintiff was parked behind the vehicle of Samuel A Gardner,
Sr.
18 As defendant approached the vehicles owned by the plaintiff and by Samuel A. Gardner,
Sr, Samuel A Gardner, Sr. moved unexpectedly and without warning into the right hand lane of
traffic.
19. The movements of Samuel A Gardner. Sr. placed him in front of the defendant's moving
vehicle.
20. As a result of the actions of Samuel A Gardner, Sr, the defendant was faced with a
sudden emergency and was forced to make a split-second decision to apply the brakes of his
vehicle in order to avoid hitting Samuel A Gardner, Sr.
21. As a result of the defendant being forced to make a split-second decision to apply the
brakes of his vehicle in order to avoid hitting Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., the vehicle owned by the
defendant came in contact with the vehicle owned by the plaintiff
22. Because the contact between the vehicle owned by the defendant and the vehicle owned
by the plaintiff was a result of this sudden emergency, the defendant is relieved of any liability in
connection with plaintiff's claim
WHEREFORE, the defendant respectfully requests that this Honorable Court grant judgment
in favor of the defendant, David C. Jenkins, and against the plaintiff, John M. Bailey.
~~(\ ~~ ""
BY . { '- J ~ ..-
David Jenkins ~
Pro se Defendant
._.___...._~ ___ _...~.___..._ ,__.. ......_.._. ,_"""M _'.._""__'~_ , 4 .....
JOHN M BAILEY
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CU!\ffiERLAND COUNTY, PENNA.
VS.
DAVID C JENKINS
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION LAW
NO 95-4363 CIVIL TERM
Al"FlDA VIT
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA )
) SS
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND )
Before me, the undersigned authority, a Notary Public in and for said County and
Commonwealth, personally appeared David C...Lcmkim. who being duly swom according to law,
deposes and says that the averments of fact contained in the foregoing pleading are true and
correct to the best of affiant's knowledge, information and belief
'~~\j.
David C Jenkins
SWORN TO and subscribed
~ee:;ps ~ day of
~.;199' ~
I [VI.
Not Public
"010,101 SoIl
Ak. M. ,.... "of 01' .........
C......lorough. C"",borlond C._
Myc-ml....nbpl'..N...mbe". ,...
, .l,
,", -
..~'f'-". p....." .
. "fl.. . ',,' 1'1 ' -' I . .: '~' .. .
!.:..,Ai" "::?"':"""":'.tl' '
, -''''.'~ t
...... .l~."....
. . ~,I.f:~ ::~.. '.
.. ,j,.
'.,. ~J \\..
...'i....
'.,' ..... ~.
-. .
DAVID C JENKINS
PRO SE DEFENDANT
SO East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Telephone: 717-258-9263
JOHN M. BAILEY
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA.
VS.
DAVID C. JENKINS
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION LAW
NO. 95-4363 CIVIL TERM
NOJ1CE TO PLEAD
TO JOHN M. BAILEY, Plaintiff
You are notified to file a written response to the enclosed Defendant's Answer to Plaintift's
Complaint and New Matter within twenty (20) days from the service hereof or a judgment may be
entered against you.
~~~.~~j
David C. Jenkins
Ti1.\;,:,: .::':1 ;.;',C '.'; ;: -::':;..':'.~:,;j
\ .. ..........\" . .,.",..' . .."
,n . Elf li~ I ,~:; :.. '. ." ." . .'. . '"
~l~;~t~~~~~~r'ftb~;~
"7 ~f".i~~~I~'"'\'I'~~'
:!s These l1~res were set up at a distance not greater than fifty feel ahead of the disabled
vehicle owned by Samuel A Gardner, Sr.
26. Plainlift'did not have the flashers of his vehicle operating before or at the time of ' ,he
contact between the vehicle owned by the plaintiff and the vehicle owned by the defendant.
27. Samuel A Gardner did not have the flashers of his vehicle operating before or at the time
of the contact between the vehicle owned by the plaintiff and the vehicle owned by the defendant.
28. Alternatively, the defendant avers that any damages sustained by the plaintift'were the
result of his own contributory negligence and also the negligence of Samuel A Gardner, Sr. and
that the plaintiffs claim is therefore barred by the Comparative Negligence Act (42 Pa. C. S.
~7102). In the alternative, any recovery by the plaintiff must be redueed by the extent of the
plaintiffs contributory negligence and also by the portion of causal negligence attributed to
Samuel A Gardner, Sr..
29. The defendant avers that plaintiff was negligent in the following manner:
a. In failing to set up flares in front of the disabled vehicle of Samuel A Gardner, Sr., in a
manner that would give sufficient warning time to oncoming motorists that a disabled vehicle wu
ahead.
b. In stopping his vehicle in a lane of traffic.
c. In failing to use flashers or other sufficient means to notifY oncoming traffic that his
vehicle was stopped in a lane of traffic.
30. The defendant avers that Samuel A Gardner, Sr. was negligent in the following manner:
II. In failing to set up flares in front of the disabled vehicle of Samuel A Gardner, Sr., in a
manner that would give sufficient warning time to oncoming motorists that a disabled vehicle Wl\S
ahead.
b In failing to use flashers or other sufficient means to notifY oncoming traffic that his
vehicle was disabled in a lane of traffic.
c. In moving unexpectedly and without warning into the right hand lane oftraftic in flont of
the defendant's moving vehicle
31 Alternatively, the defendant avers that any damages s\lstained by the plaintiff were the
result of his own contributory negligence and that the plaintiffs claim is therefore barred by the
Comparative Negligence Act (42 Pa C S ~7102) In the alternative, any recovery by the
plaintiff must be reduced by the elttent of the plaintiffs contributory negligence.
JOHN M. BAILEY
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA.
VS.
DAVIDC. JENKINS
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION l.A W
NO. 95-4363 CIYn. TERM
.m:mAm
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYL V ANlA )
) SS
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND )
Before me, the undersigned authority, a Notary Public in and for said County and
Commonwealth, personally appeared David C Jenkins. who being duly sworn according to law,
deposes and says that the averments off act contained in the foregoing pleading are true and
correct to the best of affiant's knowledge. information and belief
~
David c. Jenkins
SWORN TO and subscribed
before me this ~ 1 day of
~199S.
~ rn.8r-
Notary Public
"-"IrtaI~1
Ak. M. ,.... ".-y Pltllk
Co". 10".. Cumloorlond CounIW
My c:.m""""n ..,.... .....-110, 7. 1'"
21. Denied for the reasons stated in paragraph 20.
22. Denied, The defendant's negligent act of traveling at an excessive
rate of speed beyond the posted speed limit was the proximate cause of the
accident and defendant should be held liable for any damages that resulted
from his negligent conduct.
ANSWER TO NEW MATTER
CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE
23. Plaintiff's original complaint paragrilphs I through 12 are
incorporated herein by reference thereto.
24. Denied. John M. Bailey. plaintiff. set up flares behind the vehicle of
Samuel A. Gardner, Sr., and facing oncoming traffic prior to the collision
between defendant's vehicle and the vehicle of the plaintiff.
25. Denied. Three flares were set up 25 feet apart for a total distance of
75 feet by the plaintiff.
26. Denied. Plaintiff did have his flashers operilting at the time of
the contact by defendant's vehicle.
27. Denied. After reasonable investigation, answering plaintiff is
without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth
of the averment, and therefore, it is denied. Proof thereof, if relevant, is
demanded at the time of trial on this matter.
28. Denied. Defendant IVas traveling at an excessive rate of speed in
excess of the posted speed limit which was the proximate cause of the
collision between defendant's vehicle and the vehicle of the plaintiff.
29. a. Denied. Flares were set up in a sufficient manner to warn
oncoming traffic of an accident.
b. Denied. Plaintiff and his family stopped as Good Samaritans
to help an elderly man who had suffered severe facial injuries in a prior one
vehicle accident.
c. Denied. For reasons stated in paragraph 26.
30. a. Denied. For reasons stated in paragraph 25.
b. Denied. For reasons stated in paragraph 27.
c. Denied. For reasons stated in paragraph 20.
1!1
...
-
cc
=t
~
...
o
t;
a::
-
II.
I
~ .
--
~
LD
.-.
F4~rf)
"<.:..-
Vl '+ 0
~ V1 C'-.
nJ -
") . ..,
!J ,- d
Q:J:',+-
~ -t; <;))~
. OJ_
~3 ~
(. # --c'
o t' .
0rnv
A
~
...,.. .
L,
~
.,-
VJ
C
~
~
<..
J
.
d.
-
q)
;:>
~
'(
V)
, '
,
4'"'"
VJ
('6
l'-
--
..
<la:
L. Q..._
~ e:7
() ~
,-t;, JJ
~ .",
.> ~
0-
f' ~
-~
~V)
,.
, ,
. ,
..
JOHN M. BAILEY, I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
Plaintiff I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V. I
I CIVIL ACTION " LAW
DAVID C. JENKINS, I
Defendant I
V. I NO. 95-4363 CIVIL TERM
I
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR. , I
Additional Defendant
IN RIll VACAU ARBITRATOR
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, MAY 15, 1996, the appointment of William
Daniels, Esquire is hereby vacated and Stephen B. Lipson,
Esquire, i. appointed in his stead.
By the Court,
~~
/\\l\l\I~
~\III
/
James Plower, EBquire
Chairman
Stephen B. LipBon Esquire
Philip Briganti, Esquire
Court Adminietrator
uld
~.~
',.
,",
~~
"
~
,.
R.J
~
.~
'"
'\
.
~.
c.
~;
<.
-,-',
r')(i
:?i
L;,
i".':t
;f:.
-\;1
V)
I.J'
,
;\ ~,.
,"
C)
"1/
:1
',;,":I)
;~
!;jJ
!(;{
.j
:j
-l1
-<.
-,.J
~I.:
~I')
..
t,..,J
".
,
t
~ .
I,
..
,J". ' tr'~1 4 c. ,~,
(1 ,0 (')
(- en 0.'
;T':: '/l .)
"'CI', ,.,., . ..-r1
(i'\l ." .\~
7," I ' 1
~. ~ . 'll;."
<OJ. (J\ 'b
10..., ~il
r-; .."
.- - . }~;\
J.:\....
(-( .." l~~~
..p'/ ..
:::- ~r~
.' :"1
, (,) .",
JOHN M. BAILBY I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V. I
I
DAVID C. JENKIN8 I NO. 95-4363 CIVIL TERM
I
V. I
I
SAMUEL A. GARDNER, SR. I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
ORD.R or COURT
AND NOW, this 9th day of SEPTEMBER, 1996, a pretrial
conference in the above-captioned matter is SCHEDULED for Friday,
October 4, 1996, at 1130 p.m., in Chambers of the undersiqned
judqe, Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle, Pennsylvania.
Pretrial memorandum shall be submitted by counsel in accordance
with C.C.R.P. 212-4, at least five (5) days prior to the pretrial
conference.
TRIAL in the matter is SCHEDULED for Monday, October 14,
1996, at 1130 p.m., in Courtroom' 1, Cumberland County
Courthouse, Carlisle, Pennsylvania.
By the Court,
~c-,,',,\ S .~
a old E. Sheely, P.J.
David C. Jenkins, Pro 8e
Georqe F. Douqlas, III, Esquire
For the Plaintiff
Karen Feuchtenberqer, Esquire
Idd
CArf........ fl'>"L.~.l'<i. 1/lo/q".
.J ~'.
"
v:~~\,1J\l.~{'~ f~ I:'d
: ',''''' ... (", ":':r1~}'
-
0"1:11'.1 01 ,Ll;)%
, ,~b\/.LUI ,...ti ~',~ LI """ :/J
~:)ll::\} \J~il:f
\
.....
'j'
I
"''''...., ~..... I ..1....., P.C.
Karen I. reuohtenbe~ge~, 'equi~e
IDa .U"
Atto~naye fo~ Additionel Defendant
320. Ka~ket It~eet
.trawbe~rI lquare
P.O. lox 261
Harriaburv, PA 17108-1268
(7171 234-4161
Attorney for Additional Defendant, G.rdner
0700 II. IIAIL.V,
Plaintiff
IN THI COURT or COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v..
DAVID C. 07...1."
Defend.nt
NO. 95-4363
v..
lHUIL a. GaIUl.U, I..,
Addition.l Defend.nt
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
VIlA.CIP.
TO THE PROTHONOTARY 1
Pl.... withdraw the .ppearance of Drew P. G.nnon, I.quir. on
beh.lf of Addition.l D.fend.nt, S.mu 1 A. G.rdner, Sr.
Date: ?/'2ht
t
.1lA.CI..
TO THE PROTHONOTARY 1
Pl.... .nter the .ppearance of K.ren S. reuchtenb.rqer,
I.quir. of Goldberq, K.tzman , Shipman, P.C. on beh.lf of
Addition.l D.fend.nt, Samuel A. Gardner, Sr.
D.tel 7.--1':<''--'(
---tl ...:; 0
Karen S. '~enberq~r, I.quir.
~:
!'r
" '
n ..'"J n
, r (H '..
"
"'ll' .f) .~ !
!'q '.f1
I~~' \ '"0 ,lr:-
~ " i ,I:g
0'1 '"
(;'.\ , )-,
'",
t-;::'I :r? ':ll
,.,
" "II
.
" r,- '.> 1
" ,
~ ~,J
<n ,
"
'"
!l1.'J.'!):" 1.1' 11':'/1
111:!.!'-'1 Ah'
('A'-il'. !HI; l'j'.,1 I (t"\ .JI',l.l f'
UIMMI//IWI',^I,TII 1.11- 1'1,:NtlSYLVANIA t
CIjIJ/ITY I,ll- f,LJMI'~:rILAN[I
~~_,l.J ,I-, Y .1.I}~ /LM
'1:3.
},~:.N.I\ U!~i.J,~YJ'['H ,;
,HI.J..l11',RTI".,..fJ!L~"_"",'iB",,,: ,._._...._'...' :'__m"_____,, ~;h"'r t f f ,or De PI) t y :;jh'H 1 f f 10 f
CUMBERL^ND County, Prennl3ylV'lrlI.Il, ",tin bl?to\J duly ,,"'orn a...,cIJrdl.ng
t,<1 1.""" ""'yo,, tho? wlth\.n ~i,lj.!2J'UDIlL.,_____,._____,_.._,_."__.._,,....,_____.__ W,.'ii servp.d
u po n _..1-.h r, I !'{~L):,Jllk'L__.. ._,_ ___ __,...___ .._'________ __ ,_,___ __________,...___,___._ the
det en d ,"'I t, at ._l1..'!.Jy2lQ. HOUR:" IOn t, lie Hl,!J, 'Jd Y 'J1: ~i_~p};.~~m.~_"'I.,____.._._.___,_..._".
I ':I'}!~ at _ .:!.:L,:~.A.IJ!JJ:LJ3.g.A.I~____ ____________.......,__.___________
NI-. W_Y,J l.l.E:.L.J.......P A _JJ .:.: <I l__________ ,..___________________.___,. \~IJ M 8 E R L AND .___'
',ounty. Penrsylvanla, by h"ndlng to JQHtl_j)..l.Il!.tJL__._~.P_VkJ_...ltl. CHARGE
a tru'i' and 'lttl?"'t~'d copy lOt thl? ,_:;!lI.l,j.l:,I~"~;!!,l\_,_..__,_,..___,___"_,..____,____.____.
~nd at the same t~ime dlrE'cting H_l~ attent.lon to t-.he cont.Il}nt.G therlo:?of.
~her~ff's Costs:
(JockE'tinQ
Servicl? -
Affld'lvit
Surcharge
101.00
7.04
,I1I0
2.00
:-;'"/-g2~ ~
l-til~}ril-;i:~--Kl-r 11l:.-,1~r i r [
t-Z'7'.-li!I"1-DOUGLA:3 DOUGL.^c:; Mill nOUl.jl.b
09/l9/lqq~ .
b~' ',~~ ~.., -(Fr;~ /k=-
tr-.-~~~F~
~wc)rn and subs~rlbed t.() before mp
\ h I. Il'..JJ, "". day "f -~..4,:!;:."", 1.,0,_
I '4 _,. _,_9.<.." A. [',
, .,1. 'k4k<.<.Gf.:f }~F{i!,,, I *;
{-"-.1'rl_' _ If:)no .ary
JOHN M. BAILEY,
Plaintiff
V.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
DAVID C. JENKINS,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 95-4363 CIVIL TERM
IN RE: VERDICT
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 14th day of October, 1996, a
non-jury trial was held today on the above-captioned case in
which John M. Bailey was the Plaintiff and David C. Jenkins was
the Defendant. On the question of liability, we find in favor
of the Plaintiff, John M. Bailey, and against the Defendant,
David C. Jenkins. Damages are therefore awarded to the
plaintiff as follows:
For property damage to the vehicle, the Court awards
the sum of $4,491.36; for car rental expenses, the Court awards
the sum of $563.00; for the deductible, the Court awards the sum
of $250.00, making the total damages in favor of the Plaintiff
and against the Defendant in the sum of $5,304.36.
The court, upon consideration of the sudden emergency
doctrine, finds that that was not available to the Defendant
under the facts of this case.
By the Court,
.
,
Ha 0
.u\.
"
~
N
\J'
'-..J
r
t=;'>
r
~
~.
,..
,..,
'-
c:-,
I
.....
">l
,
'.~
"
(") 1.0 0
t" 0'\ 'n
. ~ ;J
"1;'1., ;;:-; \:;Q
Coil t
7", ':~
~. ~,
.L -J
(II,
.'
I:., -:"! i2:i
;~; " -
".,.', ',;1;.
(, r';/'~) 'J
- ',.
'Jl .,.;.
.. ~
- . (,0.)
~
",.
...
"
~ ~ - ,'-'-,
I!}
..... 'A.J ~.,l .'-)
I\... ~ "
[., : ,
~ ~ ~ t ~n
~ GF '/' , "~.1 I."
.J;;:-.. (1,:, .,.~ P]
,. .-
. "'). ,,'
~ .' " J ~-?
~ ~ j::,.1
" ('-' .()
~ ~ " .jrn
;::.) ,'::1
.. ,.
~ ".J .n
-"
.
'r
~
'.-:Q .
,-r., IF
<:...l
f'
fV
,-- ---~
*
~
~
""::.
"
~~~
t~ .
-t'..c.
Vol
'1 0(>
. "\ .(;
VI
~
, '
c
~.
"r:'
r')
~r,-: .
,>i
-~
~:~: I.
):'
,
~.
, ,
f
,
i
,
"
~~~'l
--) -I
'..: I"
_ I II:,"
~': ~ l~~
__ .(-J
-::0 _p'TI
I
.r:- :.;
-;r:<
">-
f~
I
I
!
:'
:
f
~ '
I
I'
1
!
,
, I
i
1/
!
I.
.'
I'
" ".
.
,-, It] ~~
Cll ,
." , ;1",: !
(T": , )
I ~'l
::; /-,' ,--',
.1'1
.... (I") UJ, .,'lrJ
...., .
~1,~ ':,')
~ ":': J ~'. -'I
,--l
~::~ i. )..-
l) .,~
\ ~', )1
"I
I'.
-. .r:- :Q
f,'i r'~)
C.. '""~
-.'
~. '. "
.rl/i I"
~I)I, ~
.)
.' .'
(f,i _,~ '-';
f~i:-.i -!:'J
'j:';;, -..
~. ~ J
~:~ C'-j ~~5 , ,
,.I.1'c~ .I'
$j '~.,t
-, - :'iJ
C:::l '.,