HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-04377
, ,
.,. (YJ
",: tl':
1 c:-":
1'1' , '. , ,
r'. ~ ,
".
("1
, :iJ\
, "
I,'
C. I , J
, , ~ ~.
L , , ,. ,
" (I,: 1
i '.' U
'.
','
, .
.'
yOU .1' ......, ItI1UIIIU. 10 "'"' ..
."'''111 IIU'O,,,. 1'1) 'M~ "'CIo011O
WI'MI"'.'flI'" 'tet DIU '"0ll SlUiCe
M'lIlO' 0" '." JUDl\/IIlNf Ill'" II
'fI~1I1D "U'"'' fOij,
..
DOUClLAS, DOUGLAS & DOUa~All
"1'''OilllNIYII.U LAW
, "
" W "")1I1"'U(1
"f). .<11 ,,,.
DCI
{, 1 1998
WI DO "nUll curln 1M,U 'M'
""NIMI'" 'lth "flOCO'".efCOltV
" 'HI O""IIUL 'IUD. 'N 'lUll
.C110N,
If "___.___.__.__._
(") ,,) " "
" W 1'1
.,,',; 1.-
.
11:,:1 , ,
1 ,
...j
( ;,? 11
;'-.1
,',) ~J -1
... , ll, -",
, ,
WILLIAM 1', DOUGl,AS, ESQUIRE
A;ry, 1.0, . 37'126
DOUGLAS, DOUGLAS Ie DOUGLAS
27 WEST HIGH STREET
1'.0, BOX 26\
CARLISLE, I'A, 171113
717.243.17~1l
George N. Rhyne, Individually and as
the Administrator of the Estate of
Gloria Rhyne
In The Court of Common Pleas of
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania
Plaintiffs
v
No, 95-4377 CIVIL TERM
Debra D. Taylor, M.D., tia Masland
Associates; Philip A Neiderer, M.D.,
tia Masland Associates; Gregory
Lewis, M.D.
Defendants
Jury Trial Demanded
NOTICE
YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT, IF YOU WISH TO DEFEND AGAINST
THE CLAIMS SET FORTH IN THE FOLLOWING PAGES, YOU MUST TAKE
ACTION WITHIN TWENTY DAYS AfTER THIS COMPLAINT AND NOTICE
ARE SERVED, BY ENTERING A WRITIEN APPEARANCE PERSON ALL Y OR
BY ATTORNEY AND FILING IN WRITING WITH THE COURT YOUR
DEFENSES OR OBJECTIONS TO THE CLAIMS SET FORTH AGAINST YOU.
YOU ARE WARNED THAT IF YOU FAIL TO DO SO, THE CASE MAY
PROCEED WITHOUT YOU AND A JUDGMFNT MA ~ BE ENTERED AGAINST
YOU BY THE COURT WITHOUT FURTHER NOTICE FOR ANY MONEY
CLAIMED IN THE COMPLAINT OR FOR ANY OTHER CLAIM OR RELIEF
REQUESTED BY THE PLAINTIFF, YOU MAY LOSE MONEY OR PROPERTY
OR OTHER RIGHTS IMPORT ANT TO YOU,
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU
DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR
TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE
YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP,
Court Administrator
Fourth Floor
Curnb....land County Court House
1 Courthouse Square
Carllsll' P A 17013
717-24lJ..6200
BY
Allor y for Plaintiffs
COMPLAINT
1, The plaintiff, George N. Rhyne, Individually and as Administrator of the
Estate of Gloria Rhyne, Is an adult individual residing at 251 South
Hanover Street, Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania,
2. The defendant, Debra D, Taylor, M,D" is an adult Individual trading as
Masland Associates and/ or Masland Associates, Inc" located at Medical
Arts Building, Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania,
3. The defendant, Philip A, Neiderer, M,D" Is an adult individual trading as
Masland Associates and/or Masland Associates, Inc" located at Medical
Arts Building, Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania,
4. The defendant, Gre~ory Lewis, M,D" Is an adult individual trading as
Carlisle Digestive Disease Associates, located at 60 Brookwood Avenue,
Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania,
5, At all times relevant hereto the plaintiff was a patient of Debra Taylor and
Philip Neiderer t/a Masland Associates, Inc, and the defendant Gregory
Lewis,
6. Gloria Rhyne died as the result of Cardiopulmonary arrest due to the
consequences of Appendiceal carcinoma,
7. The plaintiff died on July 14,1994, at approximately 7:10 a,m,
8, On August 18, 1995, the husband of the plaintiff, George Rhyne, was
appointed administrator of the Estate of Gloria Rhyne, deceased, by Mary
C. Lewis, Register of Wills, in and for Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
9, Gloria Rhyne was survived by her husband George N, Rhyne, and her
children, George N, Rhyne, Jr" Jeffrey Marshall Rhyne and John Gregory
Rhyne,
Count1 .Plalntlff v Debra Taylor and Philip Neiderer lIa Masland Associates
Wrongful Death pursuant to 42 Pa,C,S,A. S 8301
10, The allegations in paragraphs 1 through 9 are incorporated herein and
reference is made thereto as If fully set forth at length,
11. The defendant may have been negligent in the following respects;
13,
As a direct and proximate result of the Mgligence of the defendant, in
failing to properly diagnose, treat and advise the plaintiff, the plaintiff
died as a result of complications associated with Appendiceal cancer,
As a direct and proximate result of the negligence of the defendant, the
plaintiff has had to undergo extensive medical treatment and expense,
As a result of the aforesaid, the plaintiff had endured pain and suffering,
embarrassment and humiliation, aggravation and inconvenience,
disfigurement, permanent disability and a loss of life's pleasures,
As a result of the aforesaid, the plaintiff economic horizons were
terminated,
14,
15.
16,
17.
As a direct and proximate result of the defendants' negligence, the
surviving spouse of the decedent was dependent on her, at the time of her
death, As a result of her death he has been deprived of such support and
livelihood and has suffered damage thereby,
By reason of the death of Gloria Rhyne, George Rhyne, her surviving
spouse, has been deprived of his wife's society, services and comfort.
As a direct and proximate result of the decedent's untimely death, her
estate incurred burial expenses as a result of defendants' negligent acts
and/or omissions.
18,
19,
WHEREFORE, it is prayed thaI judKlnellt be ellff!red in fllvor of the plaintiff and against
the defendants in an amount ill excess of tMt requiring compulsory refnral to IIrbitration
plus costs of suit,
20,
Count 2 . PlaIntiffs v Debra Taylor and Philip Neiderer t/a Masland
Associates
Survival Action pursuant to Pa,C.S.A, 88301
The allegations in paragraphs I through 19 are incorporated herein and
reference is made thereto as if fully set forth at length,
The decedent Gloria Rhyne's, economic horizons were destroyed as the
result of the failure to timely diagnose and treat her condition,
The decedent Gloria Rhyne's had endured pain and suffering,
embarrassment and humiliation, aggravation and inconvenience,
21.
22.
disfigurement, permanent disability and a loss of life's pleasures as the
result of the failure to timely diagnose and treat her condition,
WHEREFORE, it is ImIYt'd Ihllt jud,~"'ml be elllm'd ill favllr of fhe plaintiff tmd tlgllinst
the defendanfs in IIIIIIIIIOIWI ill excess of fhlll reqltirill.~ comlJUlsory referml tll tlTbilmfilln
pIllS costs llf Sll it
23,
24,
Count 3 .Plalntlff v Gregory lewis, M.D.
Wrongful Death pursuant to 42 Pa,C.S,A. S 8301
The allegations in paragraphs I through 22 are incorporated herein and
reference is made thereto as if fully set forth at length,
The defendant may have been negligent in the following respects;
a.
failure to exercise the requisite degree of care and skill
ordinarily exercised in similar cases by other physicians;
failure to conform to the requisite degree of care and skill
ordinarily possessed by other physicians;
failure to conform to the requisite standards of care under
the circumstances;
b.
c.
d,
failure to properly diagnose and treat the untoward
conditions which resulted in the untimely demise of the
plaintiff;
failure to properly examine and treat plaintiff for cancer
during the Inillal months of her apparent symptoms;
failure to perform necessary medical testing;
failure to properly refer patient to the necessary medical
specialists who would have made the diagnosis of plaintiffs
condition;
e.
f,
g.
h.
failure to properly and adequately supervise defendant's
agents, servants, or employees during the examination and
treatment of the plaintiff;
failure to exercise reasonable care in the diagnosis and
treatment of plaintiff's condition for which prompt diagnosis
and treatment were critical for effective medical treatment;
i.
25,
26,
27,
28,
29.
30.
31.
32,
I,
failure to instruct the patient to return to the office after a
diagnosis of acites of unexplained origin was made;
failure to employ indicated diagnostic and/or therapeutic
measures and/or surgical measures;
k.
1.
falhre to refer the plaintiff to a specialist for additional
examination and treatment.
During the aforesaid medical examination and treatment by the def~ndant
Lewis, the plaintiff was rendered medical care by the defendant, his/her
agents, servants, and employees, who did impliedly agree to exercise the
degree of specialized care and skill in their diagnosis and treatment of the
plaintiff as is expected of a person and facility in their professional
standing.
As a direct and proximate result of the negligence of the defendant, in
failing to properly diagnose, treat and advise the plaintiff, the plaintiff
died as a result of complications associated with Appendiceal cancer,
As a direct and proximate result of the negligence of the defendant, the
plaintiff has had to undergo extensive medical treatment and expense,
As a result of the aforesaid, the plaintiff had endured pain and suffering,
embarrassment and humiliation, aggravation and inconvenience,
disfigurement, permanent disability and a loss of life's pleasures,
As a result of the aforesaid, the plaintiff's economic horizons were
terminated,
As a direct and proximate result of the defendants' negligence, the
surviving spouse of the decedent was dependent on her, at the time of her
death. As a result of her death he has been deprived of such support and
livelihood and has suffered damage thereby.
By reason of the death of Gloria Rhyne, George Rhyne, her surviving
spouse, has been deprived of his wife's society, services and comfort.
As a direct and proximate result of the decedent's untimely death, her
estate incurred burial expenses as a result of defendant's negligent acts
and/or omissions,
WHEREFORE, it is pmyed thllt judgment be entered in favor of the plllintiff and against
the defendants in till amount in excess of that requirin.~ compulsory relerral to arbitration
plus costs of suit,
Counl4 . Plaintiffs v Gregory Lewis, M.D.
Survival Action pursuant to Pa,C.S.A. 8 8301
33. The allegations in paragraphs 1 through 32 are incorporated herein and
reference Is made thereto as if fully set forth at length.
34. The decedent Gloria RhY:le's, economic horizons were destroyed as the
result of the failure to timely diagnose and treat her condition,
35, The decedent Gloria Rhyne's had endured pain and suffering,
embarrassment and humiliation, aggravation and inconvenience,
disfigurement, permanent disability and a loss of life's pleasures as the
result of the failure to timely diagnose and treat her condition,
WHEREFORE, it is prayed that judgment be entered in fllvor of the plaintiff and against
the defendants in an amoullt in excess of that requiring compulsory referral to arbitration
plus costs of suit,
I
\ } ~ 1 ~ e\ ','~" 4----
. ~u. . ..''j
Affidavit
This verification is made pursuant to Pa.R.c.p 1024(c) by counsel for the
plaintiffs.
To the best of the signer's knowledge, information and belief, the foregoing Is
true and correct.
(!
'-
William p, Doug as
Attorney for plaintiffs
October 13, 1995
"
DOllGLAS, DOl/IlI.AS 11< !JOl/IlI.AS
11 W. IlIeiH ST.
1'00 161
CARUSU: I'A 11013
TltU'.I'1I0NE 111-243.1190
v
WILLIAM p, IX1UGLAS, E.'IQ,
SUpNIIIU Cuunl,L>,' 37926
GEORGE F, IXlUGLAS, Ill, ESQ,
Supreme Cllunl.L>.' 61886
.=
-
-
=
GEORGE N, RHYNE. Individually
and as Administrator of the
Estate of GLORIA RHYNE.
IN THE COURT OF COM\1ON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA
PLAINTIFF
1995.1./.3'1'7 CIVIL TERM
va
DEBRA D. TAYLOR, M.D., tin
MASLAND ASSOCIATES; PHILIP A.
NEIDERER. M.D.. tla MASLAND
ASSOCIATES; GREGORY LEWIS, M.l).,
and DAVID R. ROYAL, M.D.,
DEFENDANT'
CIVIL ACTION LAW
To: Lawrence E, Welker, Prothonotary
~1l<:IPE
Please issue a writ of summons in a civil. action agaInst the within
defendants:
Debra D. Taylor, M.D.. tla Masland Associates, Medical Arts Building,
Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pa.
Philip A. Neiderer, M.D., tla Masland Associates, Medical Arts
Building, Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pa.
Gregory Lewis, M.D.. Carlisle Digest[ve Disease Associates
60 Brookwood Ave., Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pa.
David R. Royal, M.D., Carlisle Hospital Department of Radiology,
246 Parker Street, Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pa.
Date:
August [5, 1995
by
Atto
Atty.
DOUGLAS & DOUGLAS
" ,-!',';Ll
;,Ji'l~
t ',-,-J'
''',!,.':;
I".,
.' 't
"lii)1
,j^'
:.hl~.
, "
, "
~.~
.,
..~\"
, ('J ~'
. "
\. r',-,
'I"
"
1/1
...
. ~,
::J:
-
:5\
~ )"
-0,.1'
.1 ~~
(') -:"I~ ,
r> ~" c: _~ -
'TjX'\y\ VI t
1* hlrci'l1 .
~ it or!.'l r
~.;.;~_: "
~ )..J ~ ':' Co.)
tJ -0: ... ,." C;
'r5 ~ In '"r'l;):;t::.:, ~
....,0....
~', \.II 0 V1 .I.,'~.,~n iI
~ J ,. ~" ,I'"
,. ...
0() ~ () C '.
- ".~ 11" Ii
..~
VI, ""8..
<[ t
j
~
1-
~ 9..:.&iJ
. I ~
~'~d'~~~ ~~~~ ~a! .
, ,
\D
I ~~~f l C'l . i h' ~fJl !
II '",
WI-' ,... < r 8. QlO w
I (() N .. ~ 1-''''' , of Z -.J
,.... '" ~ '" am., ~ :i -.J
~ ~ .. ~
~;g '8-~<Q I~ ~ .,~ C'l
"',
,... rn i-' I~' ~~~g- ~
~ ~i~ ,..'~
,8 :<l R ...,. QI .
I " S' . ...''0 J: irT,... ~
~, . Ii QI . ~a
EI ~rT:po
ffi . : o <
I ~.. ~ rT ",,...
, ~ . ~..." i~ r
J: p. QI
? i.l ~ ~ ~
~,~ 8.
.
SHERrFF'S RETURN - REGULAR
CASE NOI 1995-04377 P
COnnONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA'
COUNTY OF CU"BERLAND
RHYNE GEROGE N ET AL
VS,
TAYLOR DEBRA D MD ET AL
PHILIP BAUGH"AN
CUnBERLAND County, Pennsylvania,
, Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of
who being Quly sworn according
to la., says, that he served the within WRIT OF sun nONS
upon TAYLOR DEBRA D "D TIA "ASLAND ASSOCIATES
defendant, at 1250:00 HOURS, on the ;ull day of AUClust
1995 at CIO nASLAND ASSOCIATES nEDICAL ARTS BUILDING
CARLISLE. PA 17013 ,CUnBERLAND
County, Pennsylvania, by handing to "ARY STETS, RECEPTIONIST AND
ADULT IN CHARGE
a true and attested copy of the WRIT OF SU"nONS
and at the same time directing ~ attention to the contents thereof.
the
---'
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing
Servic..
Aftidnvi t
Surcharge
18,00
5.50
.00
2.00
$25.50
J q.
~ .pr'l.'''-
So answers: " '.
"'t - ..
;;~ ~~.-::;;~,'.,.,:.~"~
I " - ....' ,-..:..
R, Thomas Kline, ~her if:!
..:~
WILLIA" p, DOUGLAS
08/23/ ~:95j Lt1 V\ f j}
~ Deput~f
Sworn and subscribed to before me
this 30 ~ day of Q.,]'" ~
19 q.,' A.D.
<-- ') .,~...... G, "L.i~,~ UIp..' ,
'1'7 f'ro~honotl!lry
SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR
CASE NO, 1995-04377 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
RHYNE GEROGE N ET AL
VS.
TAYLOR DEBRA D MD ET AL
PHILIP BAUGHMAN . Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of
CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania. who being duly sworn according
to law. says. that he served the within WRIT OF SUMMONS
upon NEIDERER PHILIP A MD TIA MASLAND ASSOCIATES the
defendant. at 1250:00 HOURS, on the 21st day of Auaust
19~ at _~~ASSOC~ MEDICAL ARTS BUILDING
CARLISLE. PA 17013 . CUMBERLAND
County. Pennsylvania. by handing to MARY STETS. RECEPTIONIST AND
ADULT IN CHARGE
. true and attested copy of the WRIT OF SUMMONS
and at the same time directing ~ attention to the contents thereof.
She,'if:!'s Costs:
Docketing
Service
Affidavit
Surcharge
6.00
.00
.00
2.00
So an~;:;r:y/ ~
~~<:~
if:--Tiio",as K..l1ne, - er1
"6. 00 WILLIAM P.
08/23/1995
by
pj;;De",~.
Sworn and subscribed to before me
this ~,,~ day of r.' J<"'..r
19 <;{ A.D.
<'_J. It.~ (;, '.l<-ll....... ~.
r, t'rotnonotary)
SHERIFF'S RETURN . REGULAR
CASE NO, 1995-04377 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA,
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
RHYNE GEROO!;; N ET AL
VS.
TAYLOR DEBRA P MD ET Al.
FH I LI P BAUGHMAN
CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania,
to law, says, that he served the
upon . LEWIS GREGORY MD
defendant, at 1300,00
1995 at 60 BROOKWOOD
CARLISLE. PA 17013
, Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of
who being duly sworn according
within WRIT OF SUMMONS
the
HOURS, on the ~ day of Auaust
AVENUE
County, Pennsylvania,
!1ANAGER
a true and attested copy of the WRIT OF SUMMONS
, CUMBERI.AND
by handing t.o ELLEN SEACHRIST, OFFICE
and at the same time directing ~ attention to the contents thereof.
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing
Service
Aff_davit
Surcharge
6.00
,00
,00
2,00
So answers: _/ ~~
_","/'i .t"':'
.1:'~'" ..;0,r~" ""';c1~'? -- ..,
R. Thomas K11ne, Sheriff
$8.00 WILLIAM p,
08/23/199:5
by
DOUGLAS
eLtpD~ut~f-
Sworn and subscribed to before me
thi.. oj, tt- day of ~____
19 "S A.D. ~
--~~oko~~~r}' ~-C;.
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
County of Cumberland
o \
t,
.2 '"'
i ~~,;(,'
81::.lIl'> I
-J/- (
UI ~.!! ~
IX: ~ J~ Ill-,)~
::E.,~)J "-
0" ~ ...
j~ r: \...: '
a:_~ ~..
LL. ~Q"'-'-
..,. CI
>- .;l~! (
o.~lX~'.
O ~ -~ :J;:\ \'
o ~,- r ,'~
'" . f )
w ~ ~l" )
;:) .f:. :(!c.:
a:~~J
I- 1-- " ,...
H ;-=; ,':
George N. Rhyne, Individually
and as Adninistrator of the
Estate of Gloria Rhyne
VS
Debra D. Taylor. M.D.. tla Masland
Associates, Medical Arts Bldg., carlisle, PA
Philip A. Neiderer, M.D,. tla Masland Associates,
Medical Arts Bldg., Carlisle. PA
Gregory Lewis. M.D., Carlisle Digestive
Disease Associates, 60 Brookwood Ave.,
Carlisle, PA
David R. Royal, M. D.. Carlisle
Hospital Dept. of Radiology,
246 Parker St.. Carlisle, PA
Court ol Commoll Pie..
No, ___9;;.-:4;.lJ_(,.CJ.x,U.1.ll.J;!ll_n..__u___ ~-.--
In __..C;;!Y.i),-~s:.t;,.!9!l.-:'-~~-.- ----..-----.--.--
To .~t?;_!l_J?.:.rEl_Y!9F.,..I::I!Q,_<.!:iJL~!iJffi_~soc.: Philip A. Neiderer, M. 0.. tift Masland
Assoc.: Gre.;pry Lewis, M.D.: and David R. Royal. M.D.
You are hereby notified that
._.. ~{9!l. Jj,. Ni_YI)~j. .!w.iXj,g!l!!!!Y _.'!ll9. Af! _ljQJlJll!I[l~.r::C! ~9F_ .el!. .t.t:!~ _ ~."!. t;,.~ !:!l. _<:!! _ 9.l;,<.?!,~!!,- ~ne.
the Plain rill has commonced an action in __9j.xH.-~<;:.t,A9':l._-.-~~.---n-.-------.--..-...--....--
against you which you are required to delend or a delauh judgment may be entered against you,
(SEAL)
LaWll'ence E. Welker
....---.._.-.....--p~th~~U;;y-...--.......--..-
[)ate __.!'.I.!.'Jl}lSI,Ll~~h----.--..---- 192.~_
'I ,,', \
~' '."' I I. ~';.' ~~", (~ "
By _.~""",-.J__L_ I.."'-'"'.\.......'-~"t-.--...
Depllty ,
! -J~d'N~l b~i~ ~a! ,
I ~~~i~ .c
lJl
I (') : i Q'~ @'Ill ,
..,~ ... III ...' ....
< r a......? ..,
I It) N " ~ Of,Z -J
.... '" g: "Cl am>-l ~"i -J
, -J ..... " l
>, ~31l '!J. If w ., ~ (')
II ...'
~ cnli f"' Gi tb' if g tn. ~,
Po ~ '~ ~'~ . .....
o ~...
I t;; Ill.... " :<l ...' ~
I a' . ~''O;t ~~~
I ....
El i ~i~?
I
I e!." ~... ~~ r
I 'i ~~f~
,
I ~
I
.';!" ~...
f~a
.
..,., ti
1 "
,.c;
....
, ".1
ill.....
'\
.~-..
Commonwealth
County of
of Pennsylvania
Cumberland
n \'
oi "'1Y
I%: ~~, 1-
8! .~ ( ~
wI:,)
a:~'e ',~
';] (.J "
~l"'!;;" '.
~~~1~,
\,L 1- <.J 'G -
> ~,.(
g; ~ ~~ ..
~ II!~ "
~ !--..
~...,~ -
c <:
-. -
George
and as
Estate
N. Rhyne, Individually
Administrator of the
of Gloria Rhyne
VS
Debra D. Taylor, M.D., t/a Masland
Associf.ltes, Medical Arts Bldg., Carlisle, PA
Philip A. Neiderer. M.D., tla Masland Associates,
Medical Arts Bldg., Carlisle, PA
Gregory Lewis, M.D., Carlisle Digestive
Disease Associates, 60 Brookwood Ave.,
Carlisle, PA
David R. Royal, M.D., Carlisle
Hospital Dept. of Radiology,
246 Parker St.. Carlisle, PA
Court of Common Pie>>
No. _..9.:>::4;lJ_'LCj..Y..U_T.!'l_J;J1!nn.m_.__ ~___
In _._G~YJ_l_t\S;J;j9!l__ :_~!!____ __n ..___ ...00__
To _P.E1.t?,~.Jh.:r~!9.F_'n~'P-'_L_tJ.'!.~Sl.~li}ffi_~soc.; Philip A. Neiderer, M. D., tis Masland
Assoc.; Gregory Lewis, M.D.; and David R. Royal, M.D.
You are her.by notified that
,_.. ~~9!!..rj, _ Rh'yI)!?J. _!D9.l.1!!9!l.i!.HY_ .<!l)C;!..!!~ _.~.i.l)j,f;l.t_r:'J~9L qLt}}~ _ ~_!!. ~~t~_ _~t fll:.l:!!'J.!!.J3!,1yne.
the Plaintiff has commeneed an action in n~j.yAL~s:_t:.!9r'__-..~!!________._...___n______n.____.
against you which you are r.quired 10 defend or a default judgment may be entered agai~.l you,
(SEAL)
Lawrence E. Welker
... - --.- - - -..... - -. p~ih~~~i,;';". -... - _...u - -oo..
Dale n .!'-l!9':!~!d?~!L_._______._. 19.?.~_
By --1..~.........-~-)~-t,J.\I.~\..J...P~.~Hi..----.oo
Deputy ,. \
(~~
'-
(:,,;J
'-':u::a
,".::::1
<.~
lfiiU..
, .
I ~W~N~i 3"~~ ~~!
I ~ ~S . ..... ' ,
I c:llll \D
~~~f~' ,0. : f'" U1
fllll ,
, ....
..,.... " !~ r ~[~p ..,
, I C'1) N .. 012 ::J
I .....~ 0':c"O lllo-j ","",.
>' ~ ......,. ~ If;
:g; 'B- ~ ~ ~~- G1 'i (')
II ~ ~i~ ~ ~' ..'
liJ, ~
19 S'q.
I III ~
I I, S' :0 S' -tj' :c i"H
I ". , ~~
$f Ii ~IF'?
I I ~.. i" ~~ r
! ! ~~f~
I
I I p~ f "<
~,~[
- "
; !ii
I':
(,. ~
-I
'"
....
'.
, . '.,
~
~
~f: ~."
.. .
,"f.';:
t..._
',n
N
,'V)
, ,
,~
,
......
,,-,
w
Vl
:i-
~ I:i
~~ w ~
II
l- S
on CO
.. I- CO i
~ 11 z CO
~ ~ .. .,;
:l II
Q ~
~ ! " .; II
Ii ~
~ 0 .. i
~ z ~
to on %
~ 0
...
Q
~
-. 0..
,
,. .
.
.
. '
THOMAS, THOMAS a HAFER
l'fl ,.", J. 1:_,. "fill"
/fJIf1T1mATlIIII /14: '''22
11I__"""
,. 0. I.. III
__'A 11111
/1/" 11,.,111
A_, '" o.f,ndMrll T,yl,,, N,'.", IfId l,wl,
GEORGE N, RHYNE, Individually
and as Administrator of the
Estate of Gloria Rhyne,
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff
No. 95-4377 Civil Term
v,
DEBRA 0, TAYLOR, M,O, tla Masland
Associates; PHILIP A, NEIOERER, M.D.,
tla Masland Associates; GREGORY
LEWIS, M,D. and OAVID R, ROYAL, M,O" :
Defendants JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRAECIPE FOR ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
TO: Lawrence Welker, Prothonotary
Please enter the appearance of the undersigned as attorneys for Debra Taylor,
M,D" Philip Neiderer, M,D., and Gregory Lewis, M.D, in the above-referenced matter,
DATED: ~() SlfX 9~
THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER
-........., .I
. ..' ,/ /
BU/~'//
l_____~Pet~r ~~;r
305 h Front Street
P. O. Box 999
Harrisburg, PA 17108
I.D, No. 16622
Allorneys for Defendants Taylor"Nelderer and
Lewis
'.
CERTIFICA TE OF SERVICE
I, Peter J, Curry, EsquIre, do hereby certify thet / served the withIn
PRAECIPE FOR ENTRY OF APPEARANCE by deposIting e copy of the sllme In the
United Stetes Mail, postage prepaid, at Harrisburg, Pennsylvenie, eddressed to:
WillIam P. Douglas, Esquire
DOUGLAS, DOUGLAS & DOUGLAS
27 West High Street
P. O. Box 261
Carlisle, PA 17013
.' ' THOMAS; -TilrtM,A~~'HAFER
, .,.r:-~
, ~/
i By/~ ....-
'--__. "",,-"-Peter.1. urry /
305 rth FronlStreet
p, ex Box 999
Harrisburg, PA 17108
/,0. No, 16622
Attorneys for Defendants Tay/or, Ne/darer,
and Lewis
DATED:~StfI r;r
'I
,
C'
;. ._'--....~...........~.":,.. ;..~.
THOMAS, THOMAS" HAFER
'" "", J. Cm" I."",.
/I1I1IT/NtATI/1II /10.: '1111
III".,.". ~
',1.116_
-..".'A /1/H
11/1/ nUU1
A_, '" 0."111""" T.,II,. NIl.,., ",tlllwl,
GEORGE N. RHYNE. Individually
and as Administrator of the
Estate of Gloria Rhyne,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff
No, 95-4377 Civil Term
v.
DEBRA D. TAYLOR, M,D, tla Masland
Associates; PHILIP A, NEIDERER, M,D"
tla Masland Associates; GREGORY
LEWIS, M,D, and DAVID R. ROYAL, M,D" :
Defendants JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRAECIPE
TO: Lawrence Welker, Prothonotary
Please enter a Rule upon the Plaintiff in the above-captioned matter to file a
Complaint within twenty (20) days or non pros seq reg,
DATED:01cJ~95 '
THOMAS,)HOMAS & H~FER
, ' )/')//
~P' //
, By ~ ~~_._.
'_ eter J. ry./
305 N Ii Front reet
p, ,Box 999
Harrisburg, PA 17108
I,D, No, 16622
Attorneys for Defendants Taylor, Neiderer and
Lewis
~
'c;l..
-.II ,
~~
l}
.
tll' i
,"
,
,
( , ,
",
I. I ~
. '-
.,'
r
t
~
;... & E ~
""~E",E
il~:~
Ii ~ g
r;.. .. II ~
~ l ~ ci el
\.. 1 Q 0 Go ii
=== ~ ~
. ~.. .
i ~
~
'.
M~\\( l 0 1996
.~
'.
"
'11N{ 1 i ICtJUbl'
.,
....
:1
"
,
to:.
f,':
~
r
I
\
,
I
!
r
I
I
"
I
"
,.
".,.,'
'00"""""",1
,
,. ./,'
::.:U..,_', :.,:.1