HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-04451
court Administrator
cumberland county courthouse
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717)-240-6120
1M Tal COURT or CONHOM PLBA8
or CUKBIRLAHD COUHTY, PIHH8YLVAMIA
VS.
/, J 7 ')
: NO. r;.rJ' 1 /1 ~. I ({?(;t ( \ teL'I'^-.
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
:
I
I
Brice Abbott,
PLAINTIFF
Normand C. Malo and Eleanor
S. Malo, husband and wife,
DEFENDANTS
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
NOTICE
YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. IF YOU WISH TO DEFEND AGAINST
THE CLAIMS SET FORTH IN THE FOLLOWING PAGES, YOU MUST TAKE ACTION
WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS AFTER THIS COMPLAINT AND NOTICE ARE
SERVED, BY ENTERING A WRITTEN APPEARANCE PERSONALLY OR BY
ATTORNEY AND FILING IN WRITING WITH THE COURT YOUR DEFENSES OR
OBJECTIONS TO THE CLAIMS SET FORTH AGAINST YOU. YOU ARE WARNED
THAT IF YOU FAIL TO DO SO, THE CASE MAY PROCEED I~ITHOUT YOU AND A
JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU BY THE COURT WITHOUT FURTHER
NOTICE FOR ANY MONEY CLAIMED IN THE COMPLAINT OR ANY OTHER CLAIM
FOR RELIEF REQUESTED BY THE PLAINTIFF. YOU MAY LOSE MONEY OR
PROPERTY OR OTHER RIGHTS IMPORTANT TO YOU.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU
DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE
OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO fIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PEAS
OF ADAMS COUNTY - PENNSYLVANIA
Brice Abbott,
plaintiff
No.
vs.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Normand C, Malo and Eleanor
S. Malo, husband and wife,
Defendants
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
COMPLAINT
Now comes the Plaintiff, Brice Abbot, by and through his
attorney, H. Anthony Adams, and sets forth the following:
1.
plaintiff is Brice Abbott, an adult individual, who resides at
139 Airport Road, Shippensburg, Cumberland county, Pennsylvania.
2.
Defendants are Normand C. Malo and Eleanor S. Malo, adult
individuals, husband and wife, who reside at 280 Lost Hollow Road,
Dillsburg, York county, Pennsylvania.
3.
On or about June 1, 1994, Defendants and plaintiff entered
into a contract for the construction of a home in the amount of
Eighty Thousand One Hundred Thirty Two ($80,132.00) Dollars.
4.
The contraot was altered by agreement of the Plaintiff and
Defendants to include additional construction in the amount of
Seven Thousand six Hundred Ten ($7,610.00) Dollars.
5.
The Defendants owe to plaintiff the sum of Eighty Seven
Thousand Seven Hundred Forty Two ($87,742.00) Dollars for parts and
labor.
6.
The Defendants have made payment to plaintiff in the amount of
7.
The amount owed to plaintiff is Twenty Four Thousand Ten
($24,010,00) Dollars, which the Defendants have refused to pay even
though demand for payment has been made.
Wherefore, plaintiff prays your Honorable Court enter judgment
in hie favor and against Defendants in the amount of
RespectfullY submitted,
~. .-.....r.
Attorney for plaintiff
128 E. King street
Shippensburg,PA 17257
(717) -532-3270
I verifY that the statements made in this petition are true
and correct. I understand that false statements herein are made
subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. c.s. section 4904 relating to
unsworn falsification to authorities.
/;' /1 !t~.~
/ /y
l!( !,',IA_ f!1. t;/ , '<1-'(-
Br ce Abbott
Datel 7(- (/, r;~-
I
I NO. 95-4451 CIVIL TERM
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
I
I
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY - PENNSYLVANIA
Brice Abbott,
plaintiff
VS.
Normand C, Malo , Eleanor S.
Malo, hu.band and wife,
Defendante
PRAECIPE
Plea.e Re-I..ue the complaint fUed in the above captioned
matter,
Respeotfully submitted,
~iiqu1~~
Attorney for Plaintiff
128 E, King Street
Shippen.burg,PA 17257
(717)-532-3270
<::I
-
to-
~
~
.
=
-"t
en
....
0")
,.
II: ~.
.-t' .
, .
1\1 (, .',
~r'
u. ~_,,,
"
~. I '
:
~.l '
..
'11\:Id 1 1
Ii 1-' rt q.,!:
it'l! ,;
1!..I/.l.1
c A~;l: till: I ',"i'.' ,1,1,1', I'
COHH(,tIWFAI.TII (If' l'UIW,YI'/,\tjjA:
ClJ\lrlT'i III-' ! IInl-l-:hl.^,If'
!\[ljli;'JJ,Jhl' r
"I'
..."
t1l1V' .l!DRI1.MIJ' ..':..I-:T .61",
__R!-_.__Itlr:lfnq~;, J;.l, i 11~.
~3hr"rlfi, yhf) IH!lIlU duly nWOln ncC'ordirH.I
to law, u\)y;.~, l.lid!. lit! Illdthl d d.llIllPIl\ uL'i.truh ;~Hld lf1quity for the villaIn
fli.,lnlI:Jd i.k' l\~IHi'Hd, t., wit
.tJtMJ. E'-<l:MlPH .u;i,
but ....OD unulJ11:} tr:1 l(H:n(l:
lI(.J I
In II I U !!iH lnn<:l-..
Ih? t ht.'rt:.'!Ul'l'
d..:'~lt1 \ i ::f:'fJ t h.~' ;,h~'r 1 f f Id
.. '(1.11'1\
CUtlllt.y, f'unrn-lj'l,vanld.
'-um',"" till' "l'hlll ,':,lIULLAUlJ..,
lln
"f.\V.(:~I!J~~~_L . f:~q!1 1. ~;~~~'-)
"hIP 'dtif '-,-' wau 111 It'C(>l(1t l}l
t.tH! .,l.Id(:).l.d Ifd.\.I111 JIUI'!
'(I Iii)';
\ 1;1.1111, )'. Pf.lllrIBi' 1 '.' iJ 111 tI.
Slll?llJf'u Cl,t:tn:
:~o ;JfI~!WI:J.-"': " .>>~
./' } ,,' - "~""
1,,( ,'k;, ./f/ ;><
,-' /">'i-r/-""'~<<"" .,.......J .,-r--r
r,. 1"11"'1.-1 HI i IH'."'~;hl~'I:"-I--rI"-
Pl'ICl:V( llltl
II ~J t !. f !, I 1.1 fll. ;'
~;Urt'lld Iljl:'
(" (~~.,
. \10
:.',0\'
':.8. ('(0 II i\fl nll!!I't' ldll\!'J'~
11.uU_1\ ';',1'/')'
6W" aU
::-,W(1) n <upf ~: ut, _ ' ( ! 1,1 -! ." !- i I",
ti 1\ , ~ 'i"f!::'! I:: "l 74vu...t....--
",', 9{ l.,1
(~v-r9'1 ,,?1~,.~/~, :" ~ '
.
~dlL!i 11,'1-".; 1<l:I'Uhll
IJtl r I q: 1,(itltlTY
C^~;E Ilfl; lqc",-l1'I'I~'l I'
cmlMOIlWI:ALTll OF l'EIlW'YU'AIIIA;
COUIlTY 'JI-' 'lIIIliEI\l,AIlI'
(lJJ~lfllJ fJR ICE
<--'- -,'.--., --"_..---_._.-..".~-
V'::..;.
t'! flt,R ,.IIQR!1t-,1!1! ...t;:_,~:'L", I~
..n...._I)J~'m'!-'L !Unt'!.,., , ,....-,..--., .
lo lnW', t:.1t-\Yl-;, that Ill? math? a diligput IH!a.rc~h
ShE"!'l!!, who
being duly (;1101"0 nc"ordln\J
and 11l'lUll Y 101 lhe' ~ll.hill
nam('d dpfpl"jarol, 10 ~H..M!\l,I,! m1!l!1MW, C
but waa unablo l.) lo~~t~
dli>putizt'd thl'! :JhO'rlfJ of
to neI ve t h.' ~ it h j II l:OJ1f'l.i\lJI'I
____.___."_ ^~ ..._'u._._______'.....
On . lJ"v\,'",IJ"J.
6 t_h, _ l~,~',lt::
thl? at.t;]f:hl..~d Jt~turn 'IUfl1
Stl~rlf1'u ~V3t.I~:
PCIC"kl?' t nq
Out \11 Ctlllflt. '/
SUI.ch;jl'q~.;.~
YOHK CUIJllTY
1Il,(,(.1
~:I. '-''il')
,:,1%'1
:'1\."',,'1
_ HJIIl..
1ft ll10 IJal11Wlr:I~.
Iii-:> lhelt.?1ol"t'
YOBK
..m Cu\H\ty, f'l.;"Hlli)'lvanla.
-_..~ .--._--~_.~ ~....,..,----'- --~ --~ ._.._..-..~, -...--
thu.1 offiL'L' wun 1n f1.ICI.,q.'t. or
'jl]!,!\.
({I\HI f y, "('flnUr 1 VHrl 1 a.
~.!I_I ;jIjUWI'l t; :
:/
~. . (-/-/.'/,. .../ ~' . ' -.
...' _.......;"~/,,. .r.".... .(:~..."~"
R,'rlturria!' Ii Ii ",.';' . ShT:;i'rrr
':"';7, ;.1,\ 1/, Mnllllll'( I\'-'AII"
1IllH:,; l'I\j',
SVOffl :Jlld ;;\lbUC'-1 tP:fl t_;, bl.'lLl '.' 1l'"
t It I ",\~ ~ - LJ,' ,'! ':11{>~II'C~""""
1'.1 'if ^.I<,
(\, () .~ OJ
-~,I'1,I'IIII.I';11 '" , '/J'lf
. ,..,.,\,',..'
. ........., .."
...., ...\oO"O.........'..~.....,.....'..~..'...i...J...'..,.,...... ...~......... ......,c ....,.......__.~_._
In The Court or C.::mmon ple=s or C:Jr.'::::.:It'l::nd C:.:lU:-:~'YI Pannsylvc:nfo
Brice ^bbott
vs.
Eleanor S. Malo
:'fo. QI;_.441;1 clvi 1 '1'nrnt
.~
----, ..--
~OW, October 11.
,-:-,
C<J .
:'9_ 1, SEZP.!::'F O? Cmt3:::::i'..!..A.'lD CO~~, ?A.,'c!o
, .
1995
, ,
bc:!ly c!cjnI= l!:: Sh::::i 01
York
Co)tml1 10 =.110 :!:is Writ,
.1.1. C!=PIlC= l::!:It _..1. at :.:. ~ :.:d :Uk of :!:e ?'.I_::i.
f~r-'c:~'
~L~at~==~4C~.P~
Amc1avit of Semca
~ow,
October 19
.;
. .
19 Y5
2145
o'dea
p ~L IC"o-ft
:1:1 ';Vidda _ CCn{llaint
E1Mr1Or s. Halo
'''paa
:n
,
York County Court House, 28 East l-larket street, York, York county, Pennsylvania
byl:2:ilqtD
Eleanor S. Malo, personally
&
true and attested
C':lJlT of :!:a ~ri~." I C'lYfIll ai nl:
aDd IIIIde lc:awu :0
her
..
~ :::ne:::s :':c~i.
So LIl.SW=,
.4::..4: t,'h1'~lt.P
5hc::5 of York CaWlIT. PI.
Swcm :Uld rul:sc:-:be:I be:'cn:
COSTS
SEA~1C:Z
It! ~"'GE
1I0'AI\IALS.~:,~publlC ,u r A....-rr
Waml W,l\h::::.v~'ann.vl.lnla\ 999
illl MIICIl 2~,
Mil r fln""I,'IOf''' .
J
s
"'---
I_-_j
.- . .....~.~...._...-_......._--
. ....-.......;..-.
.1...." ,.......;.01... .._.... ..........".'......"..'-l.'H...... . ..... ........ ................... .......--.----.
I" ",'.; .. '.'.-" ....
In The Court or C=mmon ?Ie::s Qr C:Jl",':::'.:IE'1:md c:.:.JU';".~'YI Pannsyl'lcni=
Brice I\bbott
'IS.
Normand C. Malo
95-4451 civil Term
,~
----t ..-
:-fo.
:-low,
October 11. 1995
~9_ 1. SEZl'.!:?'::' OF CmGEr.!.A..'ID COt.~'l'~A.., c!a
....
York ' "
hc::by d..-;:u= tb Sh::l5 of
(Awn., II) =14 -::u W:!:,
:!:!I L-pu=== bei:1r ~ u == ~ ::d :J.sk of :.!:c :"..:-=.
r-~~
Shen:! oi c;:::::!subcd C~Wlrr. p:s"
.
AScavit of Sern=
:-low,
October 19
,Q95
I .-
2145
. 'p
o'~a
~L IC'I-ri
..
. ..
:hI ~c!:!D
eonplaint
'.If'01l
Nornend c. Malo
u
.
York county court House, 28 East Market street, York, York courity, Pe/lIl8ylvania
,
by=dbtla
Normarn C. Malo, personally
c=pr ol :he or.t..!tl r~lAtnt:
..
true and attested
,.
Uld ::wi: bawu :0
him
:!:.e .:::n=:I :!:::::i.
So answ~
J;:-..,L --I.,cbmL.i
Shc!:i 01 York c..wscr, P:&.
Swcm :md IlIbscr:b:d be:cn:
yof
COSTS
SnVICZ
~aUAGE
S 24.00
19_
4.00
MO'IARIAL IIAL ""IC ,u : wA Yir
W, lllllM, ~.,..w.nl'
"" ~iCIIDfIl"'" MIlCh 21. 1899
.
S 28.00
-
,-'-'
I. T.. COURT or COKKO. .LaAI
or cmcaDLUD COUll'l'Y, .....YLVAIIIA
Brice Abbott,
PLAINTIFF
VS.
I
I NO. 95-4451
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I
I
I JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
I
Noraand C. Malo and Eleanor
S, Malo, husband and wire,
DEFENDANTS
NOTICE
YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. IF YOU WISH TO DEFEND AGAINST
THE CLAIMS SET FORTH IN THE FOLLOWING PAGES, YOU MUST TAKE ACTION
WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS AFTER THIS COMPLAINT AND NOTICE ARE
SERVED, BY ENTERING A WRITTEN APPEARANCE PERSONALLY OR BY
ATTORNEY AND FILING IN WRITING WITH THE COURT YOUR DEFENSES OR
OBJECTIONS TO THE CLAIMS SET FORTH AGAINST YOU. YOU ARE WARNED
THAT IF YOU FAIL TO DO SO, THE CASE MAY PROCEED WITHOUT YOU AND A
JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU BY THE COURT WITHOUT FURTHER
NOTICE FOR ANY MONEY CLAIMED IN THE COMPLAINT OR ANY OTHER CLAIM
POR RELIEF REQUESTED BY THE PLAINTIFF. YOU MAY LOSE MONEY OR
PROPERTY OR OTHER RIGHTS IMPORTANT TO YOU.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE, IF YOU
DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE
OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Court Administrator
Cumberland County Courthouse
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717)-240-6120
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY - PENNSYLVANIA
Brice Abbott,
Plaintiff
vs.
I NO, 95-4451
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
I
I
Norman4 C. Malo an4 Eleanor
S. Malo, husban4 an4 wife,
Defen4ants
FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
Now comes the plaintiff, Brice Abbott, by an4 through hie
attorney, H, Anthony A4ams, and sets forth the followingl
1,
Plaintiff ie Brice Abbott, an adult in4ivi4ual, who resi4es at
139 Airport Roa4, Shippensburq, CUmberlan4 county, Pennsylvania.
2,
Defen4ants are Norman4 C, Malo an4 Eleanor S. Malo, a4ult
in4ivi4uals, husban4 an4 wife, who resi4e at 280 Lost Hollow Road,
Dillsburg, York county, Pennsylvania.
3.
On or about June 1, 1994, Defen4ants an4 Plaintiff entere4
into a contract for the construction of a home in the amount of
Bighty Thousand One Hun4re4 Thirty Two ($80,132.00) Dollars.
4.
The contract was altere4 by agreement of the Plaintiff and
Defen4ant to include ad4itional construction in the amount of Seven
Thousan4 six Hundred Ten ($7,610.00) Dollars.
5.
The Defendants owe to Plaintiff the sum of Eiqhty Seven
Thousan4 Seven Hundred Forty Two ($87,742.00) Dollars for parts an4
labor.
6.
The Defendants have made payment to plaintiff in the amount of
sixty Three Thousand Seven Hundred Thirty Two ($63,732.00) Dollars.
7.
The amount owed to plaintitt ia Twenty Four Thousand Ten
($24,010,00) DOllare, whioh the Detendants have rotused to pay even
thou9h demand tor payment has been lIlade.
Wheretore, plaintitt prays your Honorable Court enter judgment
in his t~vor and against Detendants in the amount ot Twenty Four
Thousand Ten ($24,010.00) Dollars.
Respeottully submitted,
~~a;;', Esquire
Attorney tor
128 E, King street
Shippensburg,PA 17257
(717)-532-3270
Date I I) '! 1. 95"
I verify that the statements made in this Petition are true
and correct. I understand that false statements herein are made
subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. section 4904 relating to
unsworn falsification to authorities.
g;(l~ I (f t't/~W
Bf ce A bot
SERVICE
INVOICE
~
AbboTT's CAbiNET S~op
Wood Work
CUllomo,', O,do' No,
iloilo
Phono
I Oo~ 0' O'dO~ -
,..-/1- ~
Add/oll
h
J. feed ;,d /JQ fA .4c1c1~d. #3.$t;ld.(10
1, Oell" ~ '7 At E"cl"f I!r)(/je lied
f-1 ("',dr'IlI Jo/so.(lO
:J, Pal/fuN wedl fi'I4,"'/I/1~ F,'o.., i'r,(1,
I{PM1 h ,SIaI/CldC.".:?O"'/C'
';, Freid '''Me/' Ac:lc/ee/ h /"/c;I",t t1-I!
'u '~;J . t ,I" II t'
,:/.,. 100Al I
/{c:1, (J(J MAIERlAlS t(~, ()(l
100A;t..
LAB6ff ~ 5 'l~. cJ~
Dolo Complolod
lAX
TOlAl 11
AMOUNI{S O(.!(MIJ
~gnanJlO ~'-~~
I horoby acknowl ago tho soH,lactory complotion ollho abovo doscribod wall<
139 Airport Road, Shippombwg, PA 17257, 717/532'B676
COWI'HAGT
" ,j.,. fl." o..',,}' ..t'.r
"''''''','''''''' ",' ','~~"I"C'),':
',,~ ' '" ' ''11.'
No.:..1.O,l .... ......., "_.C,'
> ,.;.- "
, '0 r, / 3 1/9 " ':. ' , ..,' .
O't"' ~ .. "'''el k
, P ~.. '.'",.., -,.... ..,~.~::rp....
. . . . ~,", .
'.'t" . :L.' . "t'". . ;'"'J ,:.',
. , 1, I~. '. . ~ !. . ~'l;l', f -,
Shoot No,. ......,;., _......'.;."""'".,,
1o~;I~.:.\.....
.'.
ABBOTT',; ',-:OUD \';UIi,:lIi'j
CUSTOM LO~ HuMES
139 Ail'POl'l Hond
Shippensbul-", 1'.., II,n.;7
lubmln.d TOl
Normanhlalo
2 Golf Coul'se Hood
Dillsburg
Pa, 17019
('f 17) "3?-B',lC,f
Work To 10 Porrorm.d At.
Nomo
Stroot
City
Stoto
Phono
SIroot l~ol '-,I LOIJl Hollow
City D 111 :d.llll' g
DOlO 01 PlonG II C, I :l 1/911
ArctJllUl.:l
Road
StotoPO,
17019
I ~v c: a g t' C C tu furnISh thu ltlDtor'lUls nnd ,.urtol'l1\ tho lubor nucCfHiDl'Y tor tho c:amlllollon at
::i\l'r:flJ AL,',;
Birmingham Lor, Hal''':! (fini~licd)
Full Bl1sc,menl (unt'lnl:Jhedl
I'lulllblnl>. clCc'LI'll)1I1
Cabinet:1
Kitchell an<l U"c hill !'\~Ii
Carpet and Flo"I'lll1~
Light F'ixlul'c:::
Ductwol'k fOI' ileaL plllflp
Fil'eploce will} t'lu j II
Water well Bnd Septl~
Gt'ude BPouud 1I')l'II'" :llld
Log!! (Killl ',ll'lecl) 9,380,00
id"d;," / "')"it'lIt '.,,61'\0,00
lIU1.1;!d') '}'Jol',d?11'1"nwld11 1,6(10,00
:.:~hf wifl\.L."";~{ 1/, )\juuJ J,3od.OO
1:]o(J, 11~,hl,,/1'iXlll['(~S 1,500,00
PI ulllb! ng (c';,.>!>!!I') r 1 xtur'u:I 9fJ'~', or)
York H.r'./(j;I:': rlll'nnf~p ~),SUO.OO
?X10 TrillS": ,"':<1; (,iJC'U,00
1J"lll-Kuli]{H' 1";] 1('l/,I'II"I- 1 un,O"
1.~l,1.~J~ ';hO....lfJl./lufi :.:irti":/I,';.lllil";"J I , -.
I-'IIHH'/:"lll:;:: 1:11111;::1":1 ~,)(),OU
Total Labor' ,t<?2,'1'(9,I)() (10lllo11r;,1 cor'e lJlt'dl inside UI'S, 2,000;'00
Septic Sy~telll 6,1.\00,00 C:il'pet. ';,0('0,0')
ilell' 2,1100,00 Llnol<J'lI'l 800,00
Fireplace(Stnl 3,r;OO,OO Dl'flll1s,Sr)!'fel,I'ndul 60lJ,OO
( , U. E. '50 G~11 \'.";\ t f!l' Tonl< Y'). 00
Tot.n]'r.lntfoH'tHI~J 1:'!,~',I,.')I) Vjt-'.'h..11l nfl!l't'!',,_Jr.Jfl'I'r:::\!'v ('~tblr:"l. ~:1;_1'/.1').0('t
All malu"ol is gUDl'ontuud to lJe us \ipocllmd. und the uboyo work. to lJe podol'med 1ft ec~orlJunce ""IHI tile tJntWlOgu uod
ISpuciflcotlo'ns 6u'bmitted 10f' abav\! work am! completed In U liubstal\tlul wOl'krnunllku I11tHHlur fOI' the 6um of
.
Dollars 1$;;0, 132,00 I.
b~\tif:l~it-:n t.
~'Y:J l (.'11.
:;:r;''':d .
with poymsnts to bo mouo os 'ollows:
An.,. Ilt."t.oo or d"ll\lon lrum ltA;~U IlJUCII,r..utlllflt lM';OI,'BIl IIltr,
COltl, 'WIll t. ,..cutw onl.,. vpcn .....nUun oraar. GlllJ ",ill WCOnl' "1
,.tr', chlrg, OWllr .f'llI .Ww. trll "lImltD All 'ortulnontl !.;ulltmUi'\t
vpan .trl~et, 'CCldtnU or atllys beyCIIC our tortrol O"n,1' tu tlrr,
I,,. torlUllJIJ llulJ utf",ur 11Il(.:It!ilitr, Itlil\,ll OI\l:lI ,,~q tlol.... "'Jr" "'.(j~.
"1I1n', COl1llM11llil.OI'l 1l'1d fJ..lllt l,"l.,ht, 11l'...lllfl~1I on Ilw,lI ...tJl. I:J LI'
tl~.n Qllt b.,.
Ro,puctlully uub""tlu~
PUI / ~. '.'
, /,.
'. ' '/-,-
" /, ?.f.1'
~. .;,7'
,JIlt CH"I,
rllUV lie WlttuJrO'^1I by uS II not uccepted
~.\u
within ~ :
" ACCEPTANCE or: CO'I'l'HACT
Tho obo,o prICOS, Gpoclllcotlon. onu conUltlon. 010 Got,.fOClOI'y onu 01'0 hor.~y O"".plu~
Payment Will btt ITlltdtl au outlinod ulloys
You aru uuthol'lled tCl du th~ wor~ Uti spuclllcd
Slynuturu
> l.("""~ c.:.. III ,tee)
,,::,1.'....('.,. ,_ )YIL"CC(,
DolO
(: / / / '; i./
6IU1IUt,;f'l.!
,rll)'l='l1r._, '101""
""",,, "
0 ~~
M
I N
~ L,
a. ,-I;
O~
II') .f'~(l
I ffim
(..)
~ ".1
C
~ In Ci
0'
IN 'l'IIE COUR'l' OF coHMON PLEAB
OF CUHDERLANO COUN'l'Y, PENNBYI,vANIA
Orice IIbbott,
I'LII III '1'11'1'
110, ')5-M,51
CIVIl. IIC'I'1011 - LIIW
VS.
1I0rmand C. Molo 011<1 1;;1001101'
S. Malo, huabollll nnll wHo,
DEFEIIOlIll'I'S
JUIlY '!'IUAL IJEMANUEO
1I0'l'leB
YOU IIAVE U1lEll SUllO III COUIt'l'. 1 I' YOU WISII '1'0 OE~'END AGIIINS'l'
'l'lm CIJIIIMS Sr.'I' FOIt'!'II :IH '1'1Ir. FOI,I,OIUllG 1'IIGI~S, yOU MUS'I' '!'IIKE IIC'l'ION
WI'I'IIIl1 'l'I'mll'I'Y (20) I>IIYS IIF'I'r.R 'l'II1B COMPI,AIll'l' AliI> NO'I'ICE liRE
SERVED, OY llIl'J'lmlllG A Iml'I"I'EN IIPI'ElIIll\lWE l'EltSONIILLY OR BY
A'l"I'ORtlEY AIm l'lLlIlG 1/1 ~l/ll'!'ItlG IH'I'II 'l'IIE COUIt'I' YOUH DEFENSES OR
OBJ EC'l'lOttH 'I'D 'I'm; CIJIIU1S SE'I' FOH'l'1I AGAIIlS'l' YOU. YoU AHE 1~IIJtNED
'l'IIA'I' IF YOU FAll, '!'O lJO SO, '1'11I-: ClIllE MAY 1'IWCEED Wl'!'1I0U'I' YOU III1D II
JUDGMEll'!' MIIY OE 1':tI'I'Eltl\U AGIIIII!!'I' YOU OY 'l'IIE COUR'!' Wl'I'1I0U'I' FUR'I'IIEH
NO'l'ICE Fait AllY HOllllY CbAIMlm 1ll '1'11I-: COMPLlIlll'!' Olt II11Y O'I'IIER CLAIM
FOR RELIEI' R~;QUES'!'lm IlY 'l'IIE l'LI\Itl'I'II-'~'. yOU MAY LOSE MONEY OR
PROPEH'!'Y OH O'I'IIEIt IUGII'I'S IMPOIt'I'AN'I' '1'0 YOU.
YOU SIIOULIl 'l'II1(E 'l'IIIS PAPlm '1'0 YOU It LAI'IYER ,.,1' ollCE. IF YOU
DO NO'I' IIAVE A IJI\\~Ylm Olt CMlIlO'I' At'FOltD ONE, GO '1'0 Olt 'l'El,El'1I0tlE 'l'IIE
OFFICE SE'I' ~'01t'1'1I UEWI~ '1'0 nllll OU'I' ImEHll YOU CAN Gll'l' LEGAL IIELI'.
Court IIdministrato1'
CUIIIIJorlnnd county courthouse
Carlislo, I'll 17013
(717)-240-6120
.
-
IN '1'111'; COlJlt'l' OF GOI'IHON I'LI\A~ OF
CUHIlI\ItLANIl CUUNTY, I'ENN~YLVANIA
8RICg AIIIIO'I"!, I
NO. 95-M151
1'1 II Illl lff
VB.
C L V II. AC'l'lON - LAW
NOIt~lANIl G, ~IAI.O III1lI
gLgANOI\ S. HALO,
1l1.'1CIllIllIIlII
,JU\lY TRIAL UI\~lANUgU
ANS\~E\l TO FIIWT ANENUEIl CONI'LAINT
AND NU\~, cume the Defelldants by ulIlI thruugh their
attonley. \lub A, Krug, E[I(IUll'c, unu file lhe following
Answer to thc 1'1ulnliff's \llrst Amel1lleu Complaint:
1. A<lmlL tell.
2. A<lmit te<l.
3. A<lmitted.
II. lll.'nled. It iu spcciflcll11y ucnied thllt lhe
conlL'lIct Imu IIllercd by IIgrecmellt of Lhe 1'111intlff an<l
Dc fl!ndllllL II tu I.nc1ude CUllS true Liun in the IImount of sevon
thuuslln<l IIlx hlll1l1red ten ($7,610.00) uullul's IIn<l proof
thereuf lu demllllllcd lit tl'lal, Ily WilY of further l'esponse,
it l.s IIvel'l'Cll thlll the purlieu <liu rench nn ugreelllent fur
IIOllle mlllJ ll.ulllII CUIlIJU'IIl:L10I1, Thill uuultLunll1 constl'uction
WitS lhl! fllllllhllla of lhl! 1IC'I:Ollll 111ll.hl'uoIII for Olll! lhoulIlIllll
($1,000.00) dulllll'lI, Olll! Iwll elUllllll!11 from <ll'ywnll to
punl!lil1l! (or fUUl' hUllllrl!11 ($/100,00) <lu11 nrll, IIn<l a breakfnst
. .
bar auued for /I\1other fOUL' hUl\llrml ($/100.00) dollllrG, fUI' II
total :I ,.I Iii t IU\1a1 Clt\lOIl!lC!l of 0110 t.hOU!llllld e l.ght hunureU
($1,800.00) dulll1r!l,
5. lIelllcl\. It. III IIpl.c1flclll1y Ilulllcll t.hllt tho
llefellllalll.ll lJI~ed Lo Lhe 1'I1I1IItl ff thl! IIlIlIl of elghty-GOVO\1
thuUflllllll !lCVCIl hUlldrod furLy-HIll (SIlI,7/12.00) dollars fUI'
purts ullll 111bor lI\1d IlLrlct pruof tlwl'oof lB llellUllldell ilL
trial. By I~IIY of furt.her renpulllle, It in IIven'ed thllt the
i\1tlti:l1 ClIlltl'lIct. uf ell.\hLy thuU!llIIlll O\1ll hUl\llrcu thirty-twu
($00,132.00) dlllll1l'lI pluu tho IIgr()ed-upo\1 chUllgen IIf Olle
thousu\1ll eight hU\1llreu ($1,/100.00) dollnrs totul the SUIlI of
eighty-olle thuun/lllll \1illl! hUllllrml thlrty-tlw ($81,932.00)
dollllrfl.
6. 1ll!lllell, It is specifil:lIlly denied thnt the
llefo\1un\1tB hllve 1lI11llo \lIlY\llClll Lu I'llIlntHf 1\1 the U\IIOU\1t uf
siltty-three thuununll Beven hU\1dred thlrty-tlw ($63,732.00)
llol1llrs. By WilY uf furthor reG\lo\1se, it is IIverred thut che
Defe\1Ulllltu Iwvc 1II11llo I'IIYIlIl'IIl.11 tu tho I'lllllltl([ 111 tho IIIl1UU\1t
uf Biltty-flVc LhulIUlIIll1 uilt hlllllll'ell ($(15,600,00) uulluru III\U
credit is rC'IlIcSLClI therefol'.
7, ^dllll Ltcd (,11 \llll't allll dCIlIClI (111 I' t , It lu adlllltLcu
chllt Lho I'llIlnLiff ha!l \IIi1llc llelll:\Ild fOl' I'IIYIlIO\1t for the
lI11egClI IIIIIIIIIIIL lllll! UII thl! C1lI1I:rllcl. Fur rl!IIUOIIII stlltlHl 1,1\
New (-lilt LCI' 1I1l.! CoullLcrcl:llm, It III nl'eclflClllly IIvurrclI thlll.
t.hore III 1I1I IHIIIIII<'l! lhll! III' 1II1111ll'II lluc to Lltc 1'1111\1111'1' frllm
...
the lJefcllllllntll IInd utrict pruuf thercof ill dCllwndcd ot
tdlll, If I'!devllnt, fly I~IIY uf furthcl' rcspunsc, IInd nl'gulllg
in the nlternntlve, it is averred thut hud the Plnintiff's
work becn done ill 1I goud 1111<1 IWrklll1lnl ikc monner, the totul
bnlunce due to Lhe 1'1<lIl1l.lrl' Iwuhl he siKtecn thous;llld three
hundred Lhlrl.y-lIW (~;16,JJ2.0U) (l"lllll'II, 1Ill\~evcr, it ill
fUl'ther livened that the 110rk pcrfurmed by Plnintifr Willi nut
done in 11 guud and Iwrkmanllke m11lllHll' lI\1Il, consequently,
there IIrc nu 1I10nies due to the Plulnt iff.
Iml\REFOlm, lIefendunts (Il'l1Y this lIunorllble Court to
dlslIllllll till! Cumpllllnt uf the Plllintiff l~lLh Plalntl[[
bearing the CoStll of 8uit,
N I~I~ NNI"1'E R
O. lJefclIdunts' rellponllCII to purngruphs 1 tlll'ough 7 Ilre
illcorporlltcd hcrein by refCrlH\CC hereto.
9. Thruughuut the cuurll<J of constructlun. IJcfendllnts
udvllnced a\Hl/ur paid fur certain ItclIlll I~hich werc to be puld
for by the Plaintiff. Thuse itellls ure uo followsl
u. $150.00 for Ilpot survey;
b. $575.00 for kitchen countertop;
c. $J,7/1J,78 for II1l1teriuls I~hlch Ploilltlff
purchllllcd 011 IJcfcllllunl. s I Ilccount at Heoricks Lumbe 1',
If it ill ruund Lhllt lJefe\1llllnts u\~c I'luintlff IInything on the
contrucl., tho Inllullnt uI~l'd Lo Lho PluilltiCf should be reduced
by I.hl! ntHlve flUIIIIl.
.
.
10, 'I'hu 1'I1I111tlff, Lh\'UlIllhllllt Clll1Ht\'lIcLIIlIl,
unillltcl'lIl1y allll withouL Ilppl'llVIII u\' 1I!;\'CCIIIl..!II1. by Lhu
UCfclldnlltB, lIIadc l'h/lIl!;UII III Lhu CllIIIII\'lIcI.IIJlI Ill' Lhu hllllllU
fl'OIll thc Bpcd.(1e plallll of II", hllllHPI lIal<l .:hlllllll'lI IIhllll Ill!
\l\ul'l) fully lWI. IUI'LII III Illd: I.' Ildll 11 I. II , CIIIII1II'\'.:11I11II ht'l'ulll,
II. All a \'eBult u( I'lallltif( 1II111dllfl hlllll 111111111.1'\'111
Chlllltll'lJ III IIII' CUI1!1I.\'l1ctllll1 III' 1.1ll' hlllllll!, Lhc vlIluu III Ihl!
houllu hllll hCl'l1 rClluccd 1II1l1 t11l'l'U CXllllll II 1IIIIIIIIIIlIIIII lll'
vallie 1111 a dll'ccL \'esult u( lhe IICtlulltl hy thc 1'1111111.1(1'.
11.. Thc Iwdt pl!l'(onIlUlI uy Lhe 1'1 II Inti rr /ll1I1/u\' hl'l
ngclILs 111111 clllployces IWll pOlll' 1II1l1 lIul ill II 111111I1 111111
worluuunlilte 1II1I\lIICl' l'cBu1til1l1 ill nUlllc\,uuu IIl1tlllllhllLlIlILllII
!1l'oulclOtl ill COllllLl'Uctioll und tho nt\'ucL\I\'1I1 IIILlll\l'Ily Ill' I.hu
hounc hUll bcel1 CUlllpl'olllised Illllch 1.0 lhe (1Ilunclui Ilull'lnll1lll.
of thc Ill' (UIlUlIllt II.
}3, All II IHl'oct l'ollulL uf 1'1llillLlff'u (11101' 111111
ulllwl'kllllllllllte IW1'k pCl'fllnlll!ll lit lhc Ilefcllllanl.ll' hllllllC 1111
furlhol' CI1I1I11I'\,nLetl III Ilcl'('IIlIIlIlLII' CoUlltl!\'C 111111I 111'1'11111,
UC(CI1t1UIlLII IJIII ue (o\,cell tll UXPI!11l1 II 1I111J11tilllL 1111 1IIIlllllllt III'
lIIulley tu cllr\'ccL III1Ld oIl'fl'cl II ,
WIIEHEFOHE, IlI'fl!IIlIIIIILlI 111'11I111111 11IoIgllIl!lIt IIl\alllllt l'lulllll 1'1'
/llld I'll\' oIll1\1\llIlIill III' 1'1/1111111'1"11 C,III1I' 1 111111 111I h 1'1)11111 III hll
bol'llo by the I'lullltll'r.
COUN'l]mCL^ IN:
14. \JefenJ/lnLII' rellpunlleu Lu purugruphll 1 through 7
IIL'e incurpurated herein by L'cference hcreto.
15, \Jurlnl,\ the COUl'fH! of cunstruction, \Je[enJantll puiu
[or L1w upuL survey of one hundred fifLy ($150.00) Jullarll
/lnJ [or the kitchen cuunLcrLop of five hundL'cd scventy-five
($575,00) JolLaru for a total uf seven hunureJ twenty-five
($725.00) dollaru uf I~hich Lhe I'l/linti[[ promLseJ to
reimuurue Lhe llefl'nJantH,
16, \Juring Lhe courHe of construcLLun, Plaintiff
charged certain milterlaLs on \Jcfendn\lts' IIccount ut RellrickB
Lumuel' '{arJ, TheBe muterl/llll I~ere tu ue paiJ uy the
Plaintiff and there presenLly remainll unpaiu the lIum of
thL'ee thuUlland seven hundred furty-three anu 78/100
($3,7,.3.78) dullurll anu a claim is muue therefor.
17. \Juring the cuurllC of constructiun, the Plaintiff
unilaterally l1Iaue chnngell in the cunlltruction frum the pl/1nll
without the knowLl'ILgl! l\Illl/or approvaL uf \Jefendantll. Theile
moulflcatlonu Include but are noL necl!flflarily limLLl!lL to the
follU\~ing:
/I, \~all in thc IdLchen IWfI extendeu 8 feet
furl her than ludlcated tu lIupport the In/ldequato roof;
h, ^ 6-lnch by C.-inch column IWII placl!u in Lhe
midJio of the lHninll rool1l/kitchon are/li
c. 'I'hu Iltepll 1I0 not lIIeet the> bullllinll code
t'cquil'C'lIIentll;
d. 'I'hcL"l~ ill no clILhcdcl'itl ceil1ng in kitchen:
c. Ilool' In <llninll \'tWill openll fl'olll oppoll1te Ilide
II !HI In oppouiLe <l11'l'cUOII than IIIl Ilhuwn on plan;
f. H Inlw ill f 1t'1l1: flool' ba tht'oom arc onl y
GO-11lch u1nkll unu not the 72-inch liS stated in plaus;
8. 'I'oiletll 1I1'e noL propel'ly centel'ed purlluaut
to plUIIIl.
18. All n l'esult of the 1II01lifications there shall
rellult II <lilllilluLlon in VlIlue of Uefenuunts' pl'opel.ty,
19. HOl'k pet'fol'lIIed by the I'luint1ff IInd/ol' his Ilgent/
employees IUIIl dOlle 1n U pOOl' ami ullworklllanlike mannel'
l'ellulLllI!.\ 111 IlUbutlllltlll1 1Illdltlonul unlllugell La Lhe
Uefellullntu UII Ilhull be enulllel'nLeu herein,
20. 'I'he I'laillLl rf Iluppllell cel'l:uln lIIutet'iuls thut were
1I0t in IWl'plllll l~lLh the IIIl1tcrl,als 1111 Ilpeclfled on the plun
und cllntrllcl: l:lwn~by l'ellllll.llIll In Ilubstnntiul flnunc1ul
IlulIlullell Lu Llw llefel\llanLu I UII 1~111 be 1Il0re fully Bet forLh
hel'ein,
21. All II l'ellult of Lhe 1'11I1nUrr'll pOOl' und
ulllwrkllllllli Jlw IIcL l.ulIll 111 fall1llll Lu ulIpply pl"UpCl' lIIutel'i,lIlll,
thu \)cfellllulILu have 1l1lffl'l'l.'1I Lhe foil u\dn!.\ 1I1111111Bell u!H1
pt'lIblulIIll \~lLh Lhe hUllue l'olHlLnlcl.e<l by LIIl! Pla1llLiff:
n, 1ll!i1I11/l Iwre UIlI y u lr-lh.yeu liB uppUBeu tu
bolllllldlll-ddlJllllWl'chy l'cllUILinl.l ill excessive
Ilhl'lnltul~e illIll bug-lnfcuLiltioll:
b, The bil/lCIIICIlI. Imll /lhul'l.ml by 2 CUUI~lleB
o[ hlOl:lq
c, IHlIlluwu lJuppll eu I~erl! of chell per unu
puorer qUlllity IInd I~el'l! to Ill! 1111 IHlturul, but
il1steml 1~l!l'1J prllllCll. ^ulliUonally, unly 11 Id\lllol~8
l~el'C SUPI'J 1\H1 llllll.euu o[ Lho l'Olluireu 11.:
d, ^ cheuper hut \wter henter WUIl supplied:
(!, ^n clectric funlllce WIIS installed, nut U
gUll [urnllce:
[, The [lreplllco Icnks;
1.1, Thl! hllthtub 111 the [irut floor buthroulII
lelllwd thcrcby dlllllllglllg tho llrop cclllnl.l In the
bllllclllent;
h, Thl!l.c Iwrc cUlltinuous \~utl!r problellls in
the huselllent IIIllI cl'lIcks In the [oundution;
1. Lugll werc nut pruperly treuted lind,
conlll!IIUuntly, IWl'C lIot wlter l'epelll!llt;
J, 2-111ch by u-lnch ru[tcL'/l Iwre uued to
III1Pl'orl. III(! nJUf Illlltl'lIll of the rCllul.red 2-inch
hy IU-III<'II 1J'llllllell rl'Hulllnl1 in II IlUhlltllllt.llllly
I~ulllwr nlllJ' IInd tHInning o[ Ihe roof.
,/
~_.,
22, Ill.!fl'llllaIlL/I hllve hl.!ell llllvlHClI Lhllt I.l 1~11l COllt Lhe
UUIII o[ LldI'LY-lll!Vl'll LIIIHIIIIIIIII thrl.!e hllllured tell ($37,310.00)
doll II 1'/1 Lo lIIalw all the 1I(!el\l'11 IIml reqlllred repairs III1.j
lIIoulflclILlollll to eOl'rl'cL thl.! Ilo[L'cl./I clIuuml by 1'11lInti[['u
poor IWl'lUlIlIlIllhlp 111111 llcfl",tlve 01' IlIIprol'er IIIlIterll11u, 1II1l11l
cll1ll11 ill 1II111le Lherefor,
23. ^1 I the prohlelllll elllllllel'aLClI IIbove lire IIIl II uirect
l'esult uf 1'1aillLlCf'u poor HorlWHl1\lIhil' 1I11t1/01' the supplying
of uefecLlve Ol' IlIlIPl'l'opl'lllLe IIllll ill[erlol' IIInterillla by the
I'lallltlff.
Imlilml'OnE, Ilefendlllll.n dl!11I1II1,1 jllul.\lIIellt IIgllinH t the
I'lallltlff, 1Il11CIi ^UUU'I''I', III the 1I1110Ullt of forty-one thousllnu
sevell 1111lltlred /levellty-elght 1II111 78/100 ($41,778,78) dollnrs
plUll Intel'l.'lIt IInd couts of Hull.
Ilelll'C'ct[1I11 Y uubllllLLed,
Cj2+ A
lmln~nuo;-m~ I Ilir
^tLlIrlley [01' 1'II1III.If[/I
53 1':II/1t CIIIIIII litl'eeL
\lovur, I'^ 17315
(717) 292-5615
MLUl'lIuy I,\l, 1125123
,',
.. .......;r......
V I~ It 1 II 1 C ^_'1' ION
We hel'euy verify tlHlt the fnctn nlld 1n[onnatiulI set
forth 111 the roreuol.lIl~ ^"IlHer to Ne\~ Nutter & Counterclaim
lire true and correct to the beut of our kllowledge,
inforlllat LOI\ ulllI bel Lef. We ul1derutund thut /lny falue
st/lte\llentu contained herein ure subject to the penalties of
16 1'0. C.~, SectLun II lJ 011 , relnL1ng to unsworn fnlsification
to lluthorlLl ell.
)~~ c, /t"v~
tWRRAND---c:-Ml\LO
.-E.. Ona',Xhflt ,~'~ l~
b'ttANU S . 0
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY - PENNSYLVANIA
Brioe Abbott,
plaintiff
NO. 95-4451
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
vs.
Normand c. Malo and Eleanor
s. Halo, husband and wife,
Defendants
ANSWER TO NEW MATTER AND COUNTERCLAIM
Now oomes the plaintiff, Brice Abbott, by and through his
attorney, H. Anthony Adams, and sets forth the following answers:
NEW MATTER
8.
9.
a, A .pot survey was not the responsibility of Abbott and not
part of the oontract.
b. Defendants did not like the countertop installed by the
plaintiff and without agreement or contraot, Plaintiff had another
top made and inatalled.
c. Defendants purchased through plaintiff a wood (tongue and
groove board) to replaoe plaster boards and paint.
10.
Denied, any and all changes made to the house were approved by
the Defendants.
11.
D~nied that unilateral ohanges were made. All ohanges were
approved by the Defendants and it is believed that the house value
exoeeds the amount paid.
12.
Denied, the work was performed in a good and workmanlike
manner and the Defendants are benefitting financially by not paying
plaintiff.
ANSWER TO COUNTERCLAIM
15.
13.
D.nied, after reasonable investigation the Plaintiff is
without .ufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to
the truth of the matter averred.
14,
Paragraph. 1 through 13 of the complaint and Answer are Denied
or Ad.itted a. set forth specifically in the Answers to the li.ted
paragraph,
D.nied, the Plaintiff did not agree to reimburse the
D.f.ndant. for the.e item..
16.
D.nied, aft.r r.asonable inve.tigation
without .Ufficient knowledge or information to
the truth of the matter averred,
the Plaintiff i.
form a boli.f a. to
17.
D.nied, Def.ndant. agreed to any and all ohange. that w.r.
.ad. to the plan.,
a, Denied, no wall in the kitoh.n was .xt.nded, Th. length
of the wall. w.re nece.sary for placement of oabin.t. and
appliance..
b, Admitted, becau.. the Defendant. deleted a supporting wall
and the column was used for support all with the knowledge and
agr....nt of Defendants.
a, Section C is a oonclusion of law to whioh no re.pon.ive
pl.ading i. required.
d. There was never any request by Defendants for a oathedral
oeUing,
e. The French Door does open in a different manner than
normal, however, Defendant Norman Malo expressly accepted the door
when it was delivered by McCune Lumber Company.
f. A 72 inch vanity was ordered by Defendant, however, it was
returned because the plan and bathroom size diotated a 60 inoh
vanity.
g, Denied, after reasonable investigation the plaintiff is
without suffioient knowledge or information to form a belief as to
the truth of the matter averred.
18.
Dsnied, it is believed that the home of the Defendants has
inoreased in value beyond the amount paid.
19.
Denied, after reasonable investigation
without suffioient knowledge or information to
the truth of the matter averred.
the plaintiff ie
form a belief as to
20.
Denied, after reasonable investigation the plaintiff is
without suffioient knowledge or information to form a belief as to
the truth of the matter averred.
21.
Denied,
a. Defendants requested that he receive air dried treated
logs.
b, Denied, the basement is above or equivalent to the
standard height.
0, Admitted that windows were primed, however, they were more
expensive than all wood and Defendant agreed with the ohange, A
door was plaoad in the looation of windows and the front windows
ware singla instead of doubled, all of whioh was done at the
raquest of Defendant.
d, Denied, Defendant, Norman Malo, purchased the hot water
haater.
a. Defendants requested an eleotrio furnace instead of a gas
furnaoe,
f. Denied, after reasonable investigation the plaintiff is
without suffioient knowledge or information to form a belief as to
the truth of the matter averred.
g. Denied, after reasonable investigation the plaintiff is
without suffioient knowledge or information to form a belief as to
the truth of the matter averred.
h. Denied, after reasonable investigation the Plaintiff is
without suffioient knowledge or information to form a belief as to
the truth of the matter averred.
i, Denied, after reasonable investigation the Plaintiff is
without .Ufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to
the truth of the matter averred.
j, Denied, after reasonable investigation the Plaintiff is
without .Ufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to
the truth of the matter averred.
k, Denied, after reasonable investigation the Plaintiff is
without .ufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to
the truth of the matter averred.
22.
Denied, after reasonable investigation
without sufficient knowledge or information to
the truth of the matter averred.
the Plaintiff is
form a belief as to
23.
Denied, after reasonable investigation the Plaintiff is
without sufficient knowledge or information to form a belief as to
the truth of the matter averred.
Respectfully submitted,
~
\ ,
H, 'An ony' A am., Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
128 E. King street
Shippensburg, PA 17257
(717) -532-3270
.F".r......
I verify that the statements made in this Petition are true
and correct. I understand that false statements herein are made
subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. section 4904 relating to
unsworn falsification to authorities.
Datel~
~'~
,JA~
ce Abbo t
Date I 2/1/96
j)(luA ~\~
Dawn M. Shoop
Legal Aeeietant for
H. Anthony Ada.e
128 E. King Street
Shippeneburg, PA 17257
(717)-532-3270
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that I am thie day eerving a copy of the
foregoing document upon the pereone in the manner indicated
bilow, by depoeiting a copy of the eame in the United Statee
Mall, Shippeneburg, Penneylvania, wlth firet claee poetage
prepeid ae followel
Rob A, Krug, Eequire
53 Eaet Canal Street
P,O, Box 155
Dover, PA 17315
PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL
(Must be Iypowrltton ami aubmltted III dupllceto)
TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
(Check one)
Please IIsllho following coso:
X) lor JURY Irla\ atlho IIoxtlorm 01 civil courl,
lor \rIal wllhout 0 lury,
,
....,..,........,.,....,.......,............................................,..............,..,....,...........,...........,.......................,......,.................
CAPTION OF CASE
(en lire capllon musl be slated In lull)
Brice Abbott.
(chock ono)
Assumpsll
Trespass
Trospass (Molor Vehlclo)
(olher)
(Plalnllll)
vs.
Normand C. Malo &
Eleanor S. Malo, his wife.
The Irlalllsl will be called on n"""",hP,. 10. 1997
and
Trials commence on 2-2-98
(Delendanl)
Pretrials will be held on 1-7 -98
(Brlels are duo 5 days belore pretrials,)
(The parlY IIsllng Ihls case lor Irlal shall provide
lorlhwllh a copy 01 the praecipe 10 all counsel,
pursuanllo local Rule 214,1,)
vs,
No, ..Mt5L.-- Civil ,__Actinn
1995.
Indlcale Ihe attorney who will try case lor Iho porlY who Illes Ihla praecipe: .. -.- ...---...- -
II. Anthony Adwns-.-LaQuire ..,128...E...Kiog,.5traet....5hiPpensburg." fA_ .11257__..., - - - ....
Indlcole 1110\ counsel lor olhor parllos II known: .. ,........ ,..'
....+..0>_. .. .-." -.. ...... .-... -..
Ro~....EsQUire..,il.E....c.lllUl.Ji.tr!lllt"I'.,Q..j\.Ql'. 155 ,llQYllr,.!'A.- J I3JL'___'.....
----------.---..-- -------- .--_.~.---
----..-.--..----- - - .....---..-............
S1,".d. .L~-=&U"
Prllll Narno:. II., ,Anthony .A~' ---'
"
This caso Is roady lor trial.
Dolo: _.lQ:.2~91_ . ., -. . ..
Allofnoy lor:
Plaintiff
-- - ------..----"
.,...
[,-
'.
i~'
I.U~ '
!.'!i
V:'i,
yl
f.-]',
-I
(t:'!
.'
()
(J~
,
I..
(..'
<.:.:
'-,
'"
....'
II:
~~~
..
11,
):.,
'..
,"
1
',.,.]
U.L
'~:.j
U
12,
BRICE ABBOTT
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
V
,
,
NORMAND C, MALO & ELEANOR S, : NO. 95-4451 CIVIL TERM
MALO, HIS WIFE
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, January 7,1998, counsel having failed to call the above case
for trial, the case Is stricken from the February 2, 1998 trial list. Counsel may rellst the
case for trial when ready,
By the Court,
H. Anthony Adams, Esq.
For the Plaintiff
\'\('\'\'-<~ CY'p,,' ':>
\ - I J ....\3'
Robert A, Kurg, Esq,
For the Defendant
Court Administrator
:br
~ IJ') E
c
;:: N ~j.-r
~Cl
8.1~ -, ~J;;'
~- ~ ~J:
Q, '+."';
".1;:'
(, ,'" :;~f9
OJ, -
-- {'i:.t;il
'''f'o4 -. diE
{:..: w" ''J
-,
lL ~~
t.o ...1
U ell u
PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL
(MUBt be typewlllten and eubmllled In duplicate)
TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
(Check one)
PleaBe IIslthe following case:
( X ) 101 JURY Illal at the next lelm 01 civil coull,
) 10111lal wllhout a JUlY.
,
.............................................................................................................................................................................
CAPTION OF CASE
(entlle caption must be staled In lull)
(check one)
( X I Assumpsit
Brice Abbott,
Trespass
Tlespass (Motol Vehicle)
(olhel)
(Plalntlll)
vs,
Normand C. Malo & Eleanor S. Malo,
his wife,
The Illalllst wltl be called on _il-?l-QR
and
Tllals commence on --'id.lb9R
(Delendant)
Pretllals will be held on ,_--4,,29:,98
(Bllefs ale due 5 days belole pletrlals.)
(The palty listing Ihls case 101 Illal shall plovlde
10lthwllh a copy 01 Ihe p,aeclpe to all counsel,
pUIBuantlo local Rule 214,1,)
VB,
No.4!!1.L..-- Clvll_Act1oIL._ ,-,,- 19 9~
Indicate the altorney who wllllry case lOllhe parly who Illes this praecipe:
II. Anthony AdnmJ!J,_Es_ql,lireLl~_E,J<J.n...&_S~!-',ge..!L~h.ipp!ln_sl?lIl:B' PA ~7257
Indicate tllal counsel lor othel paltles II known: -- -,-_. .
Rob ~ KrllgJ~I!'(!L?1!~!-9u~n12!.~lJ,tl f~,-I}~x,I,~5_, 1l0ver,P^ 17315
-_.._---_...-_--p_.-.--,.._----~.- - -
- , - - -" - - ~ ' re-
Signed: ~~CS'J'-.l~
Print Nome: II. Anthony Adwns,. Esquire,
This case Is leady fOllrlal.
Dalo: _ 2~25.9B .. '..
Altornev for:
pLnintiff
. .-.1 "-
(': ,r~ ;, ,
I ,,',':
" l~
I .'
[,
I ;'
, r....
C; , :
I'
~ 1: I ,
I
, Lt..
" u1 )
, ) (i" l )
. 'i" ., ~ .
10,
BRICE ABBOTT
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSVLVANIA
v
,
,
NORMAND C, MALO & ELEANOR S, : NO. 95-4451 CIVIL TERM
MALO, HIS WIFE
OAD~A OF COl"lRT
AND NOW, April 28, 1998, counsel having failed to call the above case for
trial, the case Is stricken from the May 18, 1998 trial list. Counsel may rellst the case
for trial when ready,
By the Court,
H, Anthony Adams, Esq,
For the Plaintiff
Rob A, Krug, Esq,
For the Defendant
"'(l<...\.t,-\ C.c'I()\\t.. <:>
r)-I:} _C\ ")s'
Court Administrator
:bb
.... <.0 '-
Ir; c' r~_~
"' . )
,.- .. r
~J~" ..:1
)".' woO , J "
(' .
~~'r ,:...... ..,
- '\, ,
-) . - r."
l! '1-1 , .t..
['\1. . '\\1
1. i . : le1-.
I "I'
- .'
" ,:1 '"J
Q CJ' (.)