HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-04486
I
\,.... .
vs.
STERLING K. MOLL,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
95.4486 CIVIL
VICKI JO ERDMAN,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
IN RE: NONJURY TRIAL
FINDINGS AND VERDICT
AND NOW. this 2/r day of October. 1999, following trial without a jury, the
court enters the following findings and verdict:
I. This Is an Intersection accident case which occurred when the plaintiff was In an
InterBl.'Ctlon traveling east and Intending to turn northbound. The defendant was traveling
westbound through the Intersection and collided with the vehicle driven by the plaintiff.
2. We are satisfied that the defendant was causally negligent In this case In that she
misapprehended the movement oflhe plaintiffs vehicle and jammed on her brakes, thereby
losing control of her vehicle and depriving her oflhe ability to avoid the accident. Avoiding the
accident Is something which, In the absence of negligence, she could have done.
3. We are also satisfied that the negligence of the plaintiff contributed to the happening
oflhls accident, He pulled into the Intersection in such a manner as to suggest an Imminent turn
In front of the dcfendant.
4. Taking the combined negllgcnce of the parties as 100%, ncgllgcnce Is allocated as
follows:
The Dcfcndant: 50%
Thc I'luintlll': 50%
.......' .
.~ .
S, The damages proven to be allrlbutnble to Ihls accident total $\,428.70.
Accordingly, we entcr the Iblll1wing:
VERI>ICT
AND NOW. this 2.1 f' day ofOclober, 1999. we lind In favor of the plalntlffand
against the defendant In the amount 01'$714,35.
BY TIlE COURT,
. Ad-
Sterling K, Moll
S \ B North Second Street
Wormleysburll. PA \7043
John R. Nlnosky. Esquire
For Defendant Erdman
_ C4f:t.,,.....JtL II) I~' /4".;.
..&., .
:rlm
.-w
rt rn"'::IT1Cr:
C,- ~." : ""'WJl,Y
IJ9 rr.r (iJ 1'1'1 JI!17
Cl,;:.",. ',.1 (J;:Jr~iY
I," .,.,.."-.11"""
'l:,i\j \:J ll\', '';, \
. ~ .....
.
. t'J (}... 11 . _, V. '^t1 U...Q.
~~-_I!r. l.!:.! !!::'::.. _ Inlhe Courln! Common l'leul or
~ . I
.- 9 ...u.L...~ Cumherlund Counl11l'ennl11~unla
. VI, Nil, ~1-5::-4.AB.b-- Civil. 19 9 5"
'f.JA'~ \::j, F'An~1 Q~ (l.-.~f;' - :f.....).
~ .fk~
)~~~~fl!..n..."
~ ~ :::1":...o.J ;,;"u2!e4 -"m. --'!,.d. .c>"~ ,. ~.o
~ _~~~ . /~.J "~ 0 .<l
~ In 00...
To ~ f:, (.UUV'-flJI:'1 ,'._ ._. I'nllllllllll~lry
_(t) ~U...eJL ~ ~
IV _CZ..L_
~,JU~. ")/"yf'
~ r' _ <7' Y l""fllalmlff
1 '(>, <> ~
;}
,
0\
-
~
~
~
-.
.
~
4j(t
pp FlLt!}-OPFlCE
OF r;.';- ''l1i1 1:"\I')T,\qy
0\
-
96nr.T22 MII/:23
CUMG':IIU:,:, LUJNfY
PC;NNSYL\'AN~'
~
llo
...
u
~
<l:
Ill:
llo
]I
It
-I
I,
I
J
,..... ....>"l1;:;;:.;:..'"'.~'W~-"~ (
l">?"'-~"""'''''' '1
_.".',,~~- i)
,
. -
Sf-Lh I,;,.,. k. #"tjJ
In The Court of Ceamon Pl.aa of
)
)
)
)
)
)
\
Cumberland County, Penn.ylvania
~o.~- iftr'B-c" 19
'/,
I~~ Ie " Jo &/,.Jlnt a...
OA';H
We do .ol-=oly .w.ar (or affirm)
the Couatitution of the Cnitad Stataa
~ealth and that w. vill di.charae the
that VI vill .upport, obey and detlnd
and the Constitutioa ot this Co~on-
'U:~~~y.~
(~ C\ l \,
'..
~
-.,
-'.....-- \
, '
~ ,
AWARD
~e, the undlr.ignad arbitrator., havinl bl.n duly appointad and Iworn
(or af!irmed), make the follawinl award I
(Notal If damella for dllay are avarded, thlY shall be
alparatlly Itatld.)
(/11 r~' y~ #L_~
Arbitrator, dissents.
(Inure nama if
applicabl.. )
/~~
// .",', ,/ C~,ir:Uln \_,
{ ('it-i. (,( '.-~_";;'-J / /...... c.<~_.}:J...tI {.z
(,\0.4\ ./
-. (j
Dan of Rlar:!.ngs
7- ;1/- '7 f-
7- ],,1- 9~
:lata of Award I
-.3
~OTIC! OF ~RY OF AWARD
~ow, thl c7/5+day of :)", 1'1
award wa. entered upon the docket and
parti.. or thei~ attorneys.
, 19f1'.( I ae tl'll, f...:t., the above
~ot:!.ce thereof given by ~:!.l to the
Arbitrators' compensation :0 be
paid upon appeal:
S J1D,Cf)
. /;
rill ~ 4j
i?
( .
YC'Jw'
" Prothonotary
)/' /~
k'. \J!/ ar ~ '
Deput:, , /
I ~I ,
5y;
-) ,
.,( 5~./J l/.J
,1~t".,I., ).~ (,,( ,. 1/ . " I'
flJ.'/t.tJlfI /-I, A';(da~s' - .(lrM
IJi '''0," s, ba"it'/~
CIIl\rle~ E- Ibdrl,c.f S;', 711~,..i..n.. j "".i,L ,~L..k..
.
7.,;)/ (~/
"),.:J.;J ,fly
~tJ(t ~9fU( :"4 (bu 1-1 tY,,<~~,- t4..~
~ft/ (tUlJi.:tl fu 'frt 0/ -h ?d~ '1!c(~
nl THE COURT 0:' CCMMOlI PLEAS
:JUMEERlArl!' comlT! I nN!ISYLVMI!A
.,.g A'l.CL'~. K. \11,r-eQ
. J
.
!J- {ll. "J:..~
Y,
V- ~clt: ~ f\J2 ~'MJ-/,'ll
b .1.1 ,J?v. vi-
-V NOTICE OF APPEAL
FROM A'tlAR!) OF BOARD CF ARBITRATORS
No.
95 ~ 448(,
(l~j~~Q o.C'~ e;"':"1 - ~-a.t.J-
TO TEE PROTHONCT~~Y:
Notice is gi'ren that Y:i!.Yl_(7 .~~ \<. \\'tc,Q\? aPP3als !'ro!:l
the award ot' the board of arbitretors~terec! in this case on
<LA..~ I( 1 1998
~-....L+-&
A JUI'7 trial is demanded a. (Ohesk!.. box if' a jury trial is
demar.ded. Cthel".nse jurr trial is ',.,aived.)
I herebY' certit'j that '
(l)
(~)
tl"..e oompensation of the arbitrators has been ;=aid, or
IU ..1.1wclLJ.onJ... lIel!l!\ !I~e--ru. ;'1'IIi11~"'j'-a: ~'wo.8'!J h.'
_ - - -.-7
'..=J I'll. (stri~<8 out the l.."1appl1:lable olause.)
--2 >>/'t..G!v',~ k'. \')1~Q
Ap~ellant or Attorr.e:r for Ap~ellant
.
The. demand for jul"I' trial on acoeal
from oompulsory arbitration is'~~rned
by Rule l007.1 (b). -
(b) No affidavit or veri:'ioation is required.
~1CT!:
~
r.r.
.J ~
'- \'1 >. ri ~
fro .:J to: ll'-
.,' \)0-
1--= ..
1JJr? L" I " \l ~ ()o.
~~j '-Jl
I'," ....;. \)
(~V' , I ==-
J, ~ ('f,"1 ~ i
t-j' , ~
Co':; ~:' ',.,", ~ r:1...
'" 0
. .il....
I .1 0'
IL CO,, ,:l
(; U' U
By:
By:
.
.
v,
: IN nm COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
STERLING K, MOLL
Plaintiff
VICKI JO ERDMAN,
Defendant
: NO. 4416 CIVIL 1995
PRAECIPE
TO TilE PROTIIONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY:
Kindly withdraw the appearance of Harvey Freedenberg, Esquire and Michael R, Kelley,
Elqulre of the law flrm of McNeel, Wallace and Nurlck, and enter the appearance of John R,
Ninolky, EllIuire oflhe law flnn of Goldberg, Katzman and Shipman, I),C, on behalf of the
Defendant in the above captioned action,
GOLDBERG, KATZMAN
" SIIIPMAN, P.C.
M~NEES, WALLACE" NURICK
Jo R, N nosky, Esquire
Attorney J. D, No, 78000
320 Market Street
1',0, BOK 1268
Harrisburg, I' A 17108.1268
Telephone: (717) 234.4161
arvey Freedenberg. Esquire
Attorney J. D, No, 23152
Michael R. Kelley, Esquire
Attorney J. D. No, 58854
100 Pine Street
1'.0, BOK 1166
lIarrlsburg, I'A 17108-1166
Telephone: (717) 232.8000
DATE: 10 1
10637.\
CERT....ICATE OF SERVICE
IIIERERY CERTIFY that I served a true and correct copy of the foregoing document
upon all parties or counsel of record by depositing a copy of same In the United States Mall at
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. with first-class postage prepaid on the Sa day of~,
1998, addressed to the following:
Mr. Sterling K. Moll
S 18 North Second Street
Wormleysburg, PA 17043
GOLDBERG, KATZMAN" SIIIPMAN, P.C.
By: ~K~~
John ,Nin sky, Esquire
Allol11ey 1. D. No, 78000
320 Market Street
P,O, Box 1268
Harrisburg, P A 17108-1268
Telephone: (717) 234-4161
Allorney for Defendant
.,.. (') .
[~ r..
i~ "
..
UI',:,) ,'-J , "
(J"o .,.
1'.( ;,l:
1-,-! . ~.:'l
i1;(
., l 0' " ,
0'. I \ ,
&.:i' '; -
\-. I'H"l
il.' <- 1:1.
,. e:.:.::
., ,-:" :\
U l~'" U
"
. .
PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FORJRIA~
(Musl be Iypowrlllen and submllted In dupllcale)
TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
(Check one)
Please IIs1 the 'ollowlng csso:
) 'or JURY Irlal 01 tho neKllorm of civil courl.
(I ) for Irlsl wllhoul a jury,
.
........................................,..............,...............................................,...............................,.......,............................
CAPTION OF CASE
(enllre capllon musl be slaled In full)
(check one)
Assumpsit
BTULIIIG l. MOLL
Trespass
(I) Trespass (Molor Vehlclel
( )
--(otherl-- ---'-'
(Plalnllll)
VS.
The trlalllsl will be called on ..J!nuan 5..J.UI..
VUSl JO IlI11W1
(Defendanl)
and
Trials cClmmence on r.bruarl I. 1999
Pretrials will be held on -"!I!uarr 13, 1999 -'
(Briefs are due 6 days before prelrlals,)
(The party IIsllng Ihls case lor lrlal shall provide
forlhwlth a copy of the praecipe 10 all counsel,
pursuant 10 local Rule 214,1,)
vs.
No,4486 .. Civil.. - - -... .
_ 19 9~
Indicate the altorney who will try case for the party who files this praecipe:
John R. NtnoBkl'.a-!\!!Jl!!tr.,,-,.. ..-" _.__n
---- -..----- ,----_.._-_...~.-_.
Indicate trial counsel for olher parties If known: _...''1te~!!'!1l Jto! JColl, Pro Be
---- ---- .-----
_..u___~.__._._~....___u...+.._.-_. .-~.
_--------- ______ '.U'___ +.
SlgnOlJ: ~ ~;J~
Prinl Namo: ,Iohn R. MinORity, KR'Iulre
Allornoy lor IlIlfendant
This caso Is ready lor trial.
Dale Nove.ber 18, 1998
Attorney for Defendant
~....
~ ..
~ERTIFICA TE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that I aerved a true and corrcc:t copy of the foregoing document
upon III partiea or counacl ofrccord by depoaltlnsa copy ofaame In the United Statea Mall at
Harrlabura. PeMaylvanl.. with flrat-claaa poatlse prepaid on the / J /II day of ~"MI ~
1998. addreased to the following:
Mr. SterUns K, Moll
518 North Second Strcct
Wormleyaburg. PA 17043
GOLDBERG, leA TZMAN 1& SHIPMAN, P.C.
By: JOhn~~~~1
Attorney I. D. No. 78000
320 Market Street
P,O. Box 1268
Harriaburg. PA 17108-1268
Telephone: (717) 234-4161
" ,
'>- ,-I
I .~ t.;
I'
u/ (....
, ..'i
f'.
1,.1
Ij'l UI
1"7\:
~. - I J "
\.- ',l-
I'
" (') ~. i
() 0:.' lJ
STERLING K. MOLL,
Plaintiff
vs,
VICKI JO ERDMAN,
Defendant
AND NOW,thls
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
95-4486 CIVIL
CIVIL ACTION . LAW
IN RE: NONJURY TRIAL
ORDER
z. 'I' day of November. 1998. nonjury trial In the above captioned
cue II let for Wednesday, March 31. 1999, at 1:30 p,m. In Courtroom Number 4. Cumberland
County Courthoule. Carlisle, PA.
Sterlll1ll K. Moll
518 North Second Street
Wonnleysburg, PA 17043
John R. Nlnosky. Esquire
For Defendant Erdman
:rlm
BY THE COURT.
Ai
{'~ m'~' ",~ 11/".3' /I/!;
- -,r _J.'-'
STIlRlINO K. MOLL,
Plalnllff
IN T111l COURT OF COMMON P1.I1AS OF
CUMBERl.AND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
vs,
95-4486 CIVIL
VICKI JO ERDMAN,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION -l.AW
IN RIl: PI.AINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL
ORDER
AND NOW, Ihls
3.. day of December. 1998, a brief argument on the plaintiffs
1110110n to compel Is set for Wednesday. February 10. 1999. al 10:00 a,l11, In Counrool11 Number 4,
Cumberland County Courthouse. Carlisle, PA,
BY THIl COURT.
J
Sterling K. Moll
518 North Second Street
Wonnleysburg. PA 17043
n I' ".,";'M 1;I./31}98:,
_ \.-0- Ju.~ .w! ,.
John R. Nlnosky. Esquire
For Defendant Erdman
:rllll
CU,.I:' ., ,.;:\
to,..",:...,'" ..n,
,'('.1'1; ,. J!\."" ,,1\
\'\ l'q i~.';.'t'~,
(',,, ;," .' . \",\'1
rjnrrnlJ \ ,', ,',: r,l\
.' ,
~~~.~
<-~~
",
v~~
I)Fr: ? 4 1998
I ~JA ~ef~~~
: ~t'~~~
I ,G1~~
\ '~,448'~ \995
I~~-~
I
I J.
.' .
DEr. 2 4 1998
.-l~ ~,m.,.R.Q
!S1t\~--8~~~
.PA "0-13
~~)PM.k
~~\{.:m.~J I """lk~(lJ(~~~
. ~~ : ?!.~~
\/...c.i1. ~~J I ~~~5
l>~l ~~-~
I
Jn~JO ~f)~
~o_ .'__.oj :/MI ~ .~ +....._...:f:.JU.,-ol
"Jv ~ .Jct'~:...I ~.......~~ ~
Q...Jl~J ~ R3.nP ~ ~ ~.-IU!~1.199~
~ Jdl. 0_ 1~, A~:::m rrfJf2J ;;iJJ\d A....)
~~~~'JO~l)~
"Jo ~fd>~-4 ',M
J}~ ,AM ~. .tct ,A.Q l?) ~
;t.asi . ~ (27)
.J}. . ~~ '
(~~ ,~~t1Y~'''+
<>fi'~~ ;..... ~..,..J~
~1 ~~
Y .' \ot.~,~.o-<'~ 'l"J
1'98) (U . l\.t, I)
JJl~~ ~^~J\ fA
~~~~~~ '
.A..--n .~ ~ ~....ta..o.::f ~
,
"
-1-
f)~~ ~ jJU ~~:
9. t) .~JL._~ ~-P...:u.~:Jd ~~~~
~':~~~''J~~-~- '\.
~~~~
~.M1 ~~.
'0. "'.QJ)._JL..~ C!J.-r~l'~.M ~,"J-flR..
~-~-,~~--~' ~
~ ~ '0d,9'~1~~~~
~,.nAQ~..Q~o-f~ ~
~~ Y.A'~~'~'
11..0,.........:-- o~ _ ~~~~: __~,t.4 .~.
Q..rn ~ ~ ~.iteuL ~
.~~A~~J~
~cA~~i~J
~~ ~~~/
~~;~~(-+)
~~~ ~~
,<V\Jl IUuz ~ ~ c:,
~, "
19.t>~~~e ' , M~
#iA\I:~~~ . ::rJ~<1
~\I."~
~ ,~~~ .;..p~~,iA' A ,,_.--1-
ttf#~~ ~ ~
. J
~" .' ~^-iI4 .
~ 94-1"'?8~J~A.-vvl,b
~t.-lV\ .AA ~ ~ ~ ~,
-'(.-
.. .
~4, ':J~e~ .tA ~.&.~
.-J) ~ .~V\..Il ~ ..M.AJLJ}~ ;tag
~~ . n-V~~
~~~~
p-a.~~~'
~,.fJ~~(9 '.' ~~,
(fj>. o~V. ....j. .i.>o ~ ~ . .; ....~_ ~ ~ _Ofl.
~ ).~~
~~ . ,~ 4-""
~--~~~~.
""ry. f'+~(9~.,u ~.
{i?~~~;&R . ~~
. ,
~ ~ ..v>1 ....(VrI
~~~~,~~
(;il~ .) .~~
~ ~~ .
j(,~ ,
,. \..., ~ .A.V~-j.u.~ ~~
l~ Ia.~) ~ IUlCl,~ ~ ~ .{\. ,
..e\..(kh.~ ~~.-c">,, .~ ~.~
"iUvt~,~,~' . .
~~~~~~
.~A-ll>> .~",~
~~. I a5)41 Die-3d ~~'3J
...3-
~. 0l-.L~4003.,~~1 ~~
~ ~ <lA.~ ..tV\..Q ~ A;
. ~~~~~
~:1~~~ . ~
~.Q.~J . ~ ~ )
~ ~~
-17f ~QQ~ 4- 0"3. r (a):s ,~4- 0'3.1 (a):',
3, ~9011 +/)o~.I(a)~ '7~..Q.u.~ ~~
~ ~~-~~
~,[~ v.~(',)8'l150
D~C3J ~91[~v.~L\q!;(~)5
o4c~J 5 ''1].
4. ~ ~ t.: "..&.,;..,
~ ~AA~
~~ ,rJ~V'
~ 09;)'~1 n4c~J 500 6V. ~
~ tI~8+~~o DtC'3J ~,~] [~.
~,~*~(1'~~)5+
DiC'i.J''393J ·
5. ~)Uv. ~ cf;UvL~~
. .~ .o..(.4-~) ~1J-~. .-
,~~~~A.
~~., .~.
(.~ v.~ L\9%)8 D4C~~5S~l
ilo~:.A':Qo J\-e ~ ~
~~~~
"4--
., .
~~,f) k~
~ . . ',& .~~,~
.oA ce ~~ i-; Q,.Q ~
.0. ..kP~ ~~ ~ ~ ~f -
fd. ') ;i.acA ~ ~
~ .
J\L)~L~~~
:e~. J;)~~ G ..'
J" . I ~
~~~ ' J"~
I;) JO~'-'Y~
.
~
~.,8~' 'M~
ste'f I in'J ' M ~ II, f~cr Se.
5'8~~~
I PA l~o4~
L~I'7)"'G~- ~O~ 1\
- 5'-
~,m~
Ste.'4' I iY\~ ,;\ 0 "
\f~
~I~'~I~M.<
~ ~ .~ ,t..at.6 Tr'\~
} ~ t'J~"J.. ~
~ ~ ~ -e..:df ....JI
~J~. .k;.~'...
~ ~.~;ta.o.~
-c-f IB.PS' C.S. i~904J "'D1L.~..td ~
. . ;t,.~~
SoJa.: .f)~ ~'JJ 19')8
" ,
. 0.
.. ~f ~Pw~Q..
~ "~A.
. ~~ ~
~ ~ 4';fll. ~~
;t>...u... ~ ~ ~. O,~.:J
~~"O~'m..&~'i1~
~. J9
~, ~'-:'
<!R 0. 4." J .o(1.od ,~ .
19981
.
~<R.
~
"31:0 1;;8 Q
j4? (9. ~,,, PA ''7 '08- I~"'o
)./ 4V\M..4.~
~ 1""
;': ..
Ul~"\ t:1
L" :r;
f'l
'."
l'!f '..
'lit" ,")
f.J' (-J
Ii'
If:'' L'
\.
f L.
II, ('.".
L.l Lj'
""
" 1_/
,
',.
r.:
J,,'
...
I ~t~
u
"
-,
.
.
..i:t,. .JL:......~ ~ ,''(Y\ ~
'" 11\ ~~,c.,~,.g..~t
,tJ-~~PA \'704~
~~'lR'1, '9~~
lJEC 2 4 ~
"-I
.
~ <R. '~ E:"1.u.4.'-'
.Jf~~ ~.~./1YUV"
"3~O~*~
@,O. ~ \ U;8
)4~PA \"<H\-'a(p~
GU. ;,..i'h . w.m~Q 'I, y.i..clU ~ ~~
~ ~.-i48Gew-a>I~~5
lJ!-<i^ 'ou. ~
\\. .~ .-Jl-nA'.Q~~'\.Q~ .o(VI\,~
<O/~ :tu~ ('it)~.J ~~~ @~,JJ.Q
~ [)Jlr-~' ~),:.~~,~~n,~~
.(N~~' .,(J).wv4-~""k ,,@~. .
~ ci ~ ,Ml.J\~ I~' . Jv\ ()J\.It
ia ~ ,A.L~>> ,.u,~ ~Jff, ....i-f.l~ )(.
'rn~V,.r;M,fI.Q.I'~ ~~~('I)~ :&l
~ )'U, t'.4.t.~ ,~1\A.c-f'
V,~~~ ~~Vt,
.)f!!!.. .. ~~: lY\ .....u-~
S-J-e..rlil'\~ 'I(, MolIJ r'C'~Sl!.
[.,(\...~Q(k1.lL"".\
tlf ~ . ?~, ,) . 40 it ~
~~1 ~, i
I
...8~)(.'wl~. I ~A\J-'la~ <96'~,.6).Qw
- ~~ :1~~
V, I
\f~~~1 I ~,+4~Gl '.' 199'5
O~ :~~-~
.~~~
f),~ V'y.JL: ~ ~
~~~)(.'~
"g .A-t~, .t
Jo: VAcltc: ~~
W ~'~i~
no~~ ~
~,~, ~ It. <;9
W~f'A I~I08.laG8
~p~'~
W~-uJ-, ,;t..LAR7 ~~~~ ,1~'8
~~..A.VW-JM A-t-fU"1"~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ c;f,u,U'U:fu--Tl
~l-cI.-'\..l k t'~, R,C,P, N". ....onlj,J~ .
. ~<WL 1d -ea. ~~ -401
I. ~~,tQ;l' ~
Pil.F\,(,,':J. 'f'-l!,.+oowJ ~~~~ ~
f6 ;t.b. ,~'11 ~ ,~ An\ AI!ul ~
~~~~~
~~~~~~~
. .
.........c.4.~ po. R.t.1O. '1\c,. 400'.
A.
"'J-Aua.. ~ ~ ,~
.~~~.~~~:Uua
14 CSl~~ ~~u.~O;?~'
(9.~.~~,~~~ :tRu&
~ .' -tl.4 ;t.JU~ ~.~ ('-4'\1l
.,w,;tb I ~ .<1~"l . .
~. ~~-aNI, .
~,~,;t~.~,~~
~.~ . .
,
'II · Oa ..~..: n1.~ II , .' u 'f) -
I. l'~, '~-r~" .~.~,~ i41ctPQ
~'b~<l.~~
~~J'~~'~'~
~~.
l."l)~/~.~ ~~cY1
Q, ~ -tf ~~I~' ~J "'"
~~~-of~~ cY'
~,-~~~4J} ~~
,wut ~J) ~ -t\. ,~- ~ ~".M
~ ~ _..e.a. ~~~~
b 4 ~~ ~I,~~~(k1l
~' ~ ;t.~ ..vl'\ ~
.-tY'~.~~~~~'
Ad A.rl\ o.1l..rl.-~, ~ ~
~~~~,~~
~ I ' . o-fl ~A--61:;,
~ o-n ....QL"" -.4,
. . II ~. " -' ,nO. ._..il.
"3.\~~ ' ~ ,.A~.~
~,~: -~~ ,<(\.
~'~~~~/~
'~J~~~'
. .-IV\.Q~. - --"^~"-'~-t1 .~/oll ~
~~.~,~
~~~,~j
~,.~ 'i4 .~~ ~ JiJ
~A:et'~/~'~~
~~~~'
~', . A.~~~
~. -a~,
~. ~iaA~
~ I ~ hQll...s2Ao~.I'O :tc, ~ ~
J., ~ :ftsz.. ~ ._~ ~of ~
~ ,~4-, jJb. .~~ ..;i:eJ
~, :iB..a~J;O '~I(J) ~~
~ ~ II ~~v~
-M.a-of~/~I'~~~
~j;~~~, of.~
~vW'
...,. "~'....,~..~~:J,iJ.. fJ~
h".~.~' .
,-<.V& ~I~ ~-(Ul~
.~~~,,-..~
,~~~ iW.A '
~ ~_,.C:JJ. f) ~.
8.
\, ~f'~~~~ " .~
.~.~~ ,AlA~
. ,R~'~:t,~.~
~. .1\h~"~J~~
<1~~J-~~~~
~e~.-<'~<f
~.~A).. ~~oJ'~(cA
,~ ..-&AJJ~ o-n :I.fN1
~~).A J
~lli~~~
of ' ~~~~
~lfu~~~~~)
.~'~.~l ~~.~
~~ ,~.~.;uu
~.
'"3' ~ ~ ~~ ,~,W1 """.~
c.
,. ,~~,~,~.~
~~ ..cM4~.~:~Jl
~.' ~.~
.cJl~'~'~~
),
'1. ,~:h ~ ..~ ,~~ ,+~
;to ~ ,~.~ ....e '.bJ)
~. l~..u
~ .
..~~~~
~ ".;t~. -<vn ~~
4, ~ ~ ;t4. ~ ~.. L\u,'" "
~.h.~~~'
~ ~ ~ ...A _.~t;.~
f), \Al J\.Q~
~~.~-"~~~
~~,.;;~~ '
AI. .......,~ .:t. .--""0 ...,J1
~~ .4~~
c;, ,,oJlfl ~ ~
~ . .k~,~~,
.<0 .JU o.A? ~~ ~ ;t~_itUl .
7,
. .;itN& ~
~~.. ..,.n~~k.
II. ~" ~
~;U"o~~~.
~~~
._~-' ,
.9. ~~ . ~Jl~
~ctf~ ~
jc, ~ ~ ~ '...A.J,~
;tiu1 .~ A
~~~~
~.
.
II'~~~~~~~~
.~~~~:ti~ ~~J,
.~~~~~ -dA~
,o-f'~~'
, ,.
10. .A~ ~~^~..w.~Q~eu,~ .~~.:_n
..uo~;dt 'VJCl.A~_~~~~
~~~~ L}~j)-::
/ ~~.......~. "'"" ~ -:"' ..tW ;tH, ~
~)~~~.
~ ~
~~ .~
'i..~~~~~
~I~ .;to
.c..~ .. ,
13. ~&o..~.,(l.-i~l\.."'.c..~~ -fJUJ--\.(".\:fpjJ -~
,~.Q~~ I .)uA~ ~ . 'M..QQ,;t.. ~........
,-oS' 'to .~ A1-l-Jd~~l''''''''''' .'\.-(\jI. ,c<<J\I\...U..II...,
,c,..,-f\..(~.Il ~~. /~t\ ~1.J).....,.~ .
'",", 'l~ ~ .~f!.JL .A-'-~' ~}J..t *"..4. ~~\Q. Jh,,~~ '~
.0.* ~v ~~ 01( ;.teua. ,A~A!.c.~"~I.6la.. ..~~
~ ~..e.4t.~~ ,C~,~,.:,;t:t .
~~u. ,h.R..t'.-AJI, ~--1..;f
.~ .J2~,~ ~~~.~ ,,fV'y~ --,
~~~, I
IIi. ...aM:...~ -fV"".......:f ~,~
.~~~,~~~~O~
..,.".Jl f'" ff:v" (5) ~ ~ ....iJl
~.~.
H" ~ ~V\ ,~"::4 ~ ,;i-'lA
~ '~I~~J
~.~~~1
~~ ~~~,
,o.,,\R itCt..~tl~-c.L'v<l .c,lc'.(1. A.,Ll<.....~.i) ;N<JJ, ,J>41t..
.<tG) #.Jt ,-o,-.l'~.,.~'" -"
. ''1, ~.._'iciJ., ~_ .~~ ..o-(l ~I
WM-~~.J)~ . d. J
I "0 )
~ ~.~ -ffr:; .~
~ ~~"f ~
><<.. ~
.
?
.
.
'9. tJ.JJ~ .~.~ ~ "
.*-eu. ~. !
;tful ~~,~ hi
,;tltu. ~) '~E I
OA01-' rJ ,.JJ. ' . i
'""-"11' .~.A. ' .. '0 'l.. i
',ll'.uLf'....C_~~'..dl---YV'\-(1~tb.l.o1 ,.--t-c,L hP_ '\.
..c.<.h"'f'-~t..,Q . "
~(). t>~ :tAAA ~ ~ ~-hl..,.~
~~.~ ."J.t~ ~c:... ,:.~~~
~ JLt-j)':-'~ ~. ~~-, 0
~~ ~ ~J~
~ ~~~'YI ~ -e.,.:t~ .~.~:bAA
~~~'
. ~I. f).~'~
~~~
..~..t- ~
~'~"Q\ tJ..A
~2, f).~ ~ .11- -rl\.--"~ .:tJ ~ .
fi>~ ~~~,-
.
~'3. e ...t4C~.e.. --'ic....>- <\...,J! ~w--t"II-V\ ..R n& ..v-JL.CL.eP.fI. .~
..ru~,..,.,.,j! ~.(>~, .:UU. .~J .~......
~4~~~k~~
~...~ ~#d.~.~
.; ~ ....;ti-
'~~__ .V
2.4. Ji!~a e.~ '~~J ,..JJ.JJ ~..u, cf;t4Jt
~.~~.el~)~
~~Jl ~&~..@~~.e~~--~f~/~~&J-
.~~/'~w--.a-~~ @.~
t>~ ~. ' '. .
~" ...:.f :ICt~. D.... . ~
~J\Jl ~...u.-WUl .a;,.J} ~;.~..M1..IlM.
,~~ ~ ;~~\J. . .U\A~~
~~~~.~~~
.~.
It!>>. l) ~ ~ .~ ~ _~...:u ci .;ttu,.
. . ' " 1':\/'1'
.~v-I ~.tL.1 u,,", ..tc7',...c"CJl
(9~~~_t'~'~ .~t 0
;t(A~J~'~~ .
.~~ ~"'.
~~. 'l.\.I.l\R '" J.j\t.,-l.....~\'. (9 tf:~"'\ a., ...(1,,1' .l.\L ~rfU' ftJ\.I1J2
-t~~ f<'I\.ll.. ,A:(,\l. ll,\ (;.1\, t,\.t'.'r'"'f' ,,'\ t'.tt.'\~ 06 ,U,II. .
e tt'\t 1,,;\' L') f ~:c-\,\.,"\..c<Yl .Jd).HICl'~ -{"f(Iu ,,~..I.\k:fV'\\\I
(l<'ft ,\..h.~..o')_.....,...."...t\ll,." >.,t,\.., .(ll\ :(t.o .
. t.t \ ~ t~ "I' .l.' ..(ft'I' "It'ul. JJ!'f-1' .,..I.J n ,;t) ,kd ~""-'-'
.C-lL.llo!..- .... H l\ f1~ 'I. ,..-4- \'\ .(\.. -fJt'-~'t: r. p . (.t.-<u.lltt-'\,~'l\
,rt~ A.({I! It.lu.+ .-4' l.l.! \Q 6u~..<\(\.(..' .@;"k'.<<,~1I.
l).A r (\..:i~~.\~ ,\:t, .-c.Ul~V ~(~\l. C\. rr"" 1\ '(.''l'''V..c, ,J:,,-~~
,('J'l .-- (J..~.1I- (.:fC'-11 ,,(\.!
it'1. 1J.<."" J.?.-~~~jI. (;) ~~U 'L Cl.-,'y\',lJ^1' 4Q. --f1L~JJ ~tl
...ll~6 n..ff.tlnAtL",-,"'11. _~~'pJ'\.1l :t~&l. Q.,"\..0;~:tct.-i~f'I
6'\.<' 'd1\.J.l a,.,JI ;t.ll.....\ _C&. - fl'.t.J) ___'I'n,..t..~ n~
.~ "f-~\,'fl J ..'\.. ~"''''ft.Q..(..""..,,,~t\.. 6l.t~ ~ CJ f t. )
n ,.Jl.I "-
'- ~'tt ....., ,
fJo:hR: II.. ~7-9fi
,g.~.,Jk.,~'{\ K. Yv\ ~
~te't'IIt\Cj K:M 0 II, Pv-o Se
5'18 ~ .~~ ...x'~"'u't
'VJ..~~.e~rA l~o",'5
('117) '7G '3- 40~~
V ,..0 '~L-(, o...t.~ D"Y'\
"'J~ .~t'~./J. ,A ~ ~
~A-u;f~~~ ~
~~ ..aJ\...e. .h'LUD.- ..(l..I~ ~
':J~ :-v-e'+C~C-(1 ~ ~~
~c:(l ~ ~ ~"~-CL~~ ~
'8 Pa.. C. 5 . A. ij 4~o4, .J"\.R~~3. It, .~
~e~ Jt, ~~.
--. ----.----""--.---.--------
.0 .o.Aa~ :
III0NALD M MAUMA"
,. loll: IHI"MAH
..,tUL J lI"O~TO
NIIL HINDtAIHOT
J JAY COO..t..
THOMAI I 'RINNtR
JOtft,t "A,,-t..
A....IL L ITR.ANQ.ItUU.Y
QUY H '''OOMI
JUn"'ON J 'Hlp,.."N
JIIUn oJ "UIIO
NICHAlL oJ ("OCINII
THON'" oJ WtltR
""NOLO' KOOAN
(VAN oJ KLINI, III
JOHN DtLOMHZO
IT(Vlti ( OAUlI
DIANA WOOO'IO(
JOHN" NINOIKl
LAW UrrlCIlB
GOLDBERQ, KATZMAN 8.: SUIPMAN. P.C.
mID MA..IT 8TRICET
aTIIAWII...Y IIQUAIIII
11,0, bOX lunn
JlAlllllaOURU. PIlHNBYLVANIA Iflon.urUR
TBLIUJIlOHB: 17'71 UD""4UU
PAX: (1.71 Go",.anon
or COUNln
.A"THUR L. GOLDltRQ
JOIHUA 0 LOCK
HA"'" I OOLOltAO
11111.18111
UTTIIJ/WWW.OI8'.AWCOH
August 24. 1999
H(RIHEY 0"1(1
171'1133.4041
C"RLIILt O"ICE.
l'1711.UI.0817
YO"M O"IC(
17171...3.7111
Mr. Sterling K. Moll
S 18 North Second Street
Wonnleysburg, PA 17043
Re: Moll v. Erdman
Dear Mr. Moll:
Today, I received your objection to my conducting Patrolman Ambrose's deposition in
this mailer. I disagree with your medical dlagnoslsj however, I do not Intend to burden the Court
with this Issue. Therefore, I agree to cancel to deposition.
I do anticipate receiving medlcallnfonnation which indicates that Patrolman Ambrose wl1l
be medically unable to testify at trial. If Patrolman Ambrose's physicians Indicate that he Is unable
to testify at trial, I Intend to offer Into evidence at trial Patrolman Ambrose's testimony at the
criminal trial pursuant to Pa.R.E. 804
Very truly yours.
~K;J~
John R. Nlnosky
cc: lion, Kevin A, Hess
Fr. 01 ;...
~l
.:'1 .. ,
I' ,e. !~: , " ,
I.
1'" :l.":
I,..' H:..
(l i~
!,; I~)
fT,. C'~.
rill! t . 'JJ
.. L
I.
e ,
" r,~
L' t." '-I
~~,~ \( ."Ylc'j.'\'
...,-18 "(\~'~~~~"\"<'.v.V J::.'.h..". t
'k,lr.r1.."~),'\ '(:..1 i..., .~.~' r'i\ I"' 01\-'"
\1 t ..~, l'lJ'
,. L{ <\ l t <\ .' II.. "', ".
'-.
't!~~ a,~4M
~~~~
e~~~
~J PA '~O\3
6\..: ~~~-:\;;~.<4l~~
~~cf~~G~~
.o.u.Jl ~ ij,g44 ;
j~~"""'~~C3~'^~~
~ .e:g=~ V-~~ ~~-Q'~~
~ cB~ ~ )iJL..R1:lJ9~ ~
'J~~-D~~~~. '
tat.. ~) ~ ~ ~ ...<<. r;:;.;Jd
~ ~ ~ ~ .~vd.8(tQ ~
~~,~- .'
~~~~~
#49~~.:vV>I'~ .~~
~ -A-~~II-IJ ~ ~.. n .M" 0- .~
~~of~,~'1\1 ,~
e~ a-,~ .c.,...,aJl4 ~
~~~,t~~~
53 ~~~"'~
. :~rI~~I~'C.~~
~ ~ .' ~;~ ;tD.4.......e.<
~(9~ ~.o~~
-h ~~~~.
:J 4 . -PC)~V1 ~ -fhL
f.)~ .Jk-~~~~;/& ~""
~, ~~~1~~
.' ~~~J~
9~_~ ~~,~iti .1i> tfJ.A
f)~~...f)e' ) ~~
~~~~~~~.-
.0. '. ~~~:~.~
, 13 - ./t.-.l1iL... ..iA....V ~
~ .4 ~ i-~;t ~1-JJ1&
fj~ -fjA.(9~,t ~ ~
.~~~
~~~'
Ste-r I "11~ I<~ 0 II, ~'foSe
7'1 ~ ~ t"t'- 40 ~;:e
~~
~:~CR.~~
'. ~ \1JJo~
~. WI
618 ~
~~~, PAI'1o"3
~c.d'- ~~, ~9~~ .
~~.~~
'3a.O~~
~.,
J'.e.()W-1C I~~
ij~fA PU08-la"8
61a.:~ V'~l
~ ~ 1'~'8,1~1'1
a,..u-'l 'Ot1t, ~
~~ , I~~~
~ ~ .Q.::t1:cJ\ .
;tIA :Jl--::'~~'~:-',;p ~ J~~'
~~~~~~~
~ J 1/1'~9) J 9:003.. ""J .Af.ut ~ ,&,
~ .Q.~~~~~~
~ ~ .u~.o;t, ~ H~
~ .f)~:"~~,
~~. '(~
~ ~ 'fVl, (l...m..~ .' ~
~~~-<<~.~-&'
~~~o;"~~~~'"
~ ~)~ ~.~ (9.....f'o;4l~~Y1 .(A """
,,~, ~ ~ ~ C1. Ji.E .t},L) -<<... ..Jk.Q
, ,-dc\ ~, r....--. ~--rv I
~~.~~~(3)
~~,' -<VYJl.Jl.~ ~ i...w..aA
..
STERLING K. MOLL,
Plaintiff
IN nm COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMIlERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYI.V ANIA
95.4486 CIVIL
VS.
VICKI JO ERDMAN,
Dcfendant
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
IN RE: NONJURY TRIAL
ORDER
AND NOW,thls J.,I'" day of July, 1999, nonjury trial In thc abovc captioned
mailer is sct for Friday, September 17, 1999. at I :30 p,m.ln Courtroom Number 4, Cumberland
County Courthousc, Carllslc, PA.
BY THE COURT,
Sterling K. Moll
518 North Sccond Street
Wormleysburg,l)A 17043
John R. Nlnosky, Esqulrc
For Defcndan\ Erdman
_ e.(-;"~,,,,, {1"~,-l,,L '1/ ~ ",I qq .
u .,!. l' .
:rlm
r.,\p\.t\r;~"';'
C~ ., ,..-. :. .....)~fn.1
,t' " 1" \ '.I'
99 .l~\l n rl\\ n: \ 1
elll'" .,', ",' ,''''~'(
~,\,;...r.u *h' l.,VI'ii
PEI~NS'(LVINil\
STERLING K. MOLL,
Plaintiff
vs.
VICKI JO ERDMAN.
Defendant
AND NOW,this
IN 1'1 m COURT OF COMMON PI.EAS OF
CUMBERLANI>COlJNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
95.4486 CIVIl.
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
IN RE: NONJURY TRIAL
ORDER
'Z'lJ
day of August, 1999, at the request of eounsel for the
defendant, nonJury trial In the above captioned mailer set for September 17, 1999, Is continued to
Thursday, October 7,1999, at 9:00 a.m. in Courtroom Number 4, Cumberland County
Courthouse, Carlisle, PA.
Sterling K. Moll
518 North Second Street
Wonnleysburg, I'A 17043
John R. Nlnosky, Esquire
For Defendant Erdman
:rlm
BY THE COURT,
I
{!4~"" (l''''.s..t. YJJ 't/ 11 .
- _...E.. 1).
STBRLlNG K. MOLL,
Plaintiff
IN TIlB COURT OP COMMON PLBAS OP
CUMBBRLAND COUNTY. PBNNSYLVANIA
95-4486 CIVIL
vs.
VICKI JO BROMAN,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
IN RE: PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL
AND NOW,thls
ORDER
I o. day of Pebruary. 1999, Ihe objections of the defendant to the
Interrogatories of the plaintiff are SUSTAINBD with Ihe exception that the defendant shall make
avanable to the plaintiff:
I. Any and all wrlllen estimates of the damage to the defendant's vehicle;
2. Copies of any statementl made by the defendant to her Insurance company; and
3. An Indication of whether or not there Is Insurance coverage with respect to the underlying
claim In this case. (This laller requirement Is deemed satisfied In light of the representations of cou\IICl
atlhe argument of this case held this date.)
BY THB COURT.
, AJt.
Sterling K. Moll
518 Nonh Second SUeet
Wormleysburg, PA 17043
_ Coif......, .~"A..tIL
A/"I"" .
~.f.
John R. Nlnosky, Esquire
For Defendant Erdman
:rlm
'-"c'_;"'"
...
fIIJD-NFlCE
or T', ': ,,"".'-' 'f'\T\ny
. ' ,,!) f "'.,
~q W' I 0 Pii :11 10
CIJ:, "
I " .
','r'"
.-.;:.11
. ..
.j "
t_
.
STERLING K. MOLL.
Plaintiff
VS.
VICKI JO ERDMAN,
Defendalll
.2 Co'
IN TIIIl COURT 01' COMMON PLIlAS OJ'
CUMIIERLAND coUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
95.4486 CIVIL
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
IN Rn: PLAINTJIlF'S Rr,ounST FOR CONTINUANCE
AND NOW. this
ORDnR
day of March. 1999. on request of the plalllliff. trial herein
Is continued. Either party may rellstthis mailer for trial after sl~ty (611) days. Discovery Is deemed
completed In this mailer.
Sterling K. Moll
518 North Second Street
Wonnleysburg. PA 17043
John R. Nlnosky. Esquire
Por Defendant Erdman
:rlm
DY TilE COURT,
. A;i.
. ~,,-"'~(hl. 3/o:tl.oICI')
_ e....,r"....'. ..\ -(I.
.'
PI.r:D-OFFlCF.
OF 'f1 ," ',' ''''')TAP..Y
CJg "I" ",;
.. J ,! ~
ill: ?: 115
n.:
'.
. ,;;\
, ,
I i'
A~ 1<._m1i~
iriS ~ fA ''70'''3
~
~, (J..Ii.JU4
"'J~tI~ ~ Jj).Jl~
~O'f ~
19t ~ ''10/3
~~~~~ ~~~
J m~ v. V "\
, <J~ ~. ., ) ";)..MJVrY' ,
~, ""- 9S-~91O ~....t, _ n _~n...J.Of'"J.M.a(l
~~.@~---
(L...II..Jl. Ii 4404 ~ . ~~ \A.Ul~
b -"..;- ~ ~ ,.,.... ... ~. "*I~
j~~~':30r'~'i~~~ ~~a..'
~ '3IJ.'r?~_6,,~~t ~ t).J\. ~ J
~~~:<" ~ ..." ........,_;.~~.AA
~ ,Q,.o/'i\ ~.~; ~"::l.:.4 -"" . 1 ~
~~.~~ ~ ~"-' ~
~~.nM......~ ,~Q,:.._~~.~ 4e.~
~~ ~.~i~'" 'UJ..:t<.
. ~~~~(-~~~P..~
~ f-.:;::JJ.~ .~~ ~ .~~.~
~, ".'yJ.Q,~7"T" .J2J...v~ ~
"all e>\. ~J....-;t.,<,.- r . . i)..J\ .~-u.
--- . .-'1.'. ~1.' ~."... '~_.
,A.4 .~ '"' ~
~1\_-...-_':a.Ll. . .
~~4 ~~
~ ~.i) " J'\.ll~~.."D. ~v...4J
~VJJ ~~~~~-!!
S tlo! .-11"'\ if. .t-h II
., I ~ - H'3' -i I) 1: ~
~.::'~G. ~'~~u:w
, ~~ii-Sl~~
.
S PennStatc Gcisin~
., Health Sy~ICI1l
'"
',nn SIll' G,lIlnl"
Ilrallh Group
Fornllr Mrdicinr
M,(',IIPIII
845 FIShburn Ruad
Ilmhrr. PA 1711)).211IS
717 S)I ml Tel
717 S)I JIIIHa,
Re.:
)i~~ I iV\tt VVto It
OJe 711~/~~
O~~:
I J~
~ .t,. ()..ft'- {){\~, .~
rJJ 4, ~~, do&--t
M ~ <;f~ .-4 ~ r(
~ t4 W--I ~~
~~ J~~f~'
~r~ r~~~
,)...ov\. U- ~ .
~
(4r-a It-
~S~{" II. ~,a-
, "
"o~lI
fA';/'
~.)
I!/
t)
."""\
,\
I,
~ ~ )0<. "1Y\..}2R
518~~
~,PAI~o~3
~ ~04,'9~"",
'J~iaW~ ~(.~'... a,w.u.s
~C!I~~'@~
~ef.~
19~~~
~,PA 1'1013
~~ ~ ti. 'm.-Le v, V~ n.. ~
'lV, 95.~8' e.~~'.q 'J~ ~
Jj'~~'U.n ~
l)A4JI~"'.aU :
~ ~~~ ~~~ 4f~23/199~rm~~
~o. ~.~~;tM..Jl/~~~~
~---u---'~~~.\. ~'~~ '
~('II'5_eQ.~~~ ~~~lt-~~ ~ ~
~.opA,~~JIU~,. "
SA. W~ ~, ~~~.~.....7q.~
~,~.~~ll~~~~
.~.o..-...Jl~.~ ..c~._'p~:I'~. ~
~~:~;raJ}A~J\.tj~~~tI~
~41~_D~.
j~ ~~~~~'p~~fi1~~U'~.~
~/~~~fI4.~~J.U.e~~ .~
~~~.~)~~~,4
~~~::~~~.
~~~fIr'.(l..A:..r;,~~ II~ I
...e..:t ~..D.~A~ J\.Q.t<LU.:f 0. ~ ~4'
~~"-;~~, ~.~~
~"~.~~~l,~~
~-r~.:~;f-:,~:'~
, .'
"'J~ ~ a411"~~J '4. ~ ,-,,<<.e~'(.. "JJ..:u.a.(J~
"fe~~~~e~
ft.:t J;J~~ ~ G~ ~ ;tAA
~ J:J~~'''4.'''A~)M.ac9f)~.
~~~~~~t::::
V-~,~I
..8~ k'.m~
Stt!:...lin~"R:' Moll
?l'l- 7(g3 - 40'U.
~~(il.~~
. . ~
PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL
(Muftt be typewritten and submit led In duplicate)
TO THE PROTHONOTARV OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
(Check one)
Please list the lollowlng case:
) lor JURV trial al the next lerm 01 civil courl.
I ) lor lrlal wllhoul alury.
.
............................................................................................................................................................................
CAPTION OF CASE
(entire caption musl be slaled In lull)
(check one)
Assumpsit
STElLING I. HOLL.
Trespass
II) Trespass (Motor Vehicle)
(Plalnllll)
(olher)
vs.
VlClI JO IWMAII
The trlalllsl will be called on ..JUJ1~___.
(Delendanl)
and
Trials commence on 9/13/99
Pretrials will be held on _M,25/99
(Brlels are due 5 days belore prelrlals,)
(The party listing lhls case lor trial shalt provide
lorlhwllh a copy 01 the praecipe 10 all counsel.
pursuant to local Rule 214.1.)
VS,
No. _~L_.. ClvlI___' _..___.__ 1995_
Indicate the atlorney who will try case lor the party who Illes this praecipe: .!oJt.n,!!._l\in.lJlIky, Require
for Jlefendant, Vicki Jo -.!!rdll!!!!...____ _.___,' ...- ,-,,_. .
Indicate trial counsel for other parties II known: ..~te~lt_n,,-'~~!to!!,. pro .!!!! ,~18.tn.t~f!_
----______0. __. _ _. __._._.______0____0_ _-0-
--_.._._--------_.__.._--_.._.~-".,.-----.. -----------~- -_._. --.-.
This case Is ready lor Irlal.
s,onOd:0~fL~
Print Namo: ,John R. Nlnooky, v'squlr\l
Dale: .June R. 1999
Atlarnov lor:
lie f endanl
}"
"',:::'p,:,~'~",:_~ :"",__"... '.'"'1"'c.
,.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
IIIEREBV CERTIFY that I served a true and correct copy of the foregoing document
upon all parties or counsel of record by depositing a copy of same in the United States Mail at
Harrisburg. PeMsylvanla, with I1nt.class postage prepaid on the !? ~ day of ~
1999. addressed to the following:
Honorable Kevin A. Hess
Court of Common Pleas
Cumberland County Courthouse
One Courthouse Square
Carlisle, PA 17013-]]87
Mr. Sterling K. Moll
518 North Second Street
Wonnleysburg. PA 1704]
GOLDBERG, KATZMAN" SIIIPMAN, P,C.
By: ~ it J\'l.1A~
John . Ninosky, Esquire
Attomey I. D. No. 78000
]20 Market Street
P.O. BOK 1268
Harrisburg. PA 17108-1268
Telephone: (717) 2]4-4161
Attomey for Defendant
:~~j~tt:','-';
il: '" ~
:.:l
,..: ..
n N _J~
U~.. :~)t:.;.
f', ",'
- ( C~: ~.l:'l
fl...
(Ii'.' '");:J
fS~P (j. (,:0
.'1' . I .1.,
~~ ~~.)(jj
,.: ~., ~.
..'. -'J ~l]U..
""J
1(. m "3
0 ,,., t.>
"
,-,-^,."..;-,;
IN THB SUPERIOR COUltT OF PENNSYLVANIA
HARRISBURG DISTRICT
CBRTIFICATB OF CONTENTS OF REMANDED RECORD
PA. R.A.P. 2571 AND 2572
THE UNDERSIGNED, Chief Clerk of the Superior Court of
Pennsylvania, the said Court being a Court of Record, does hereby
certify that annexed to the original hereof is a true and correct
copy of the whole and entire record as remanded from said Court,
in the following matter:
Parts I
1 Part
Caption. Docket Numbers:
Sterling K Moll
v
Vicki Jo Erdman
No. 23 Harrisburg, 1996
(Cumberland Co. No. 95-4486 Civill
in compliance with Pennsylvania Rules of Appellate procedure
2571.
The date on which the record has been remanded is ~tP - 6 1996
An additional copy of this certificate is enclosed with
the original hereof, and the Clerk or Prothonotary of the lower
court or the head, chairman, deputy or secretary of the
government unit is hereby directed to acknowledge receipt of the
remanded record by executing such copy at the place indicated and
by forthwith returning the same. . /1-L .
~'~~:'j 4. tJ~~J -
Chief Clerk - Harrisburg District
Superior court of Pennsylvania
RECORD, etc. RFiCEIVED DATE S. p;.l.:..J ~.p, J /99("
\\. :^,,_ '\'., \'YI~l~(l/)\OI'\" I Df!;[
sig~ure and title
.-
II .
J.S20019/96
STERLING K. MOLL,
Appellant
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
PENNSYLVANIA
v.
VICKI JO ERDMAN,
Appellee
No. 23 Harrisburg 1996
Appeal from the Order entered December 7, 1995
in the Court of Common pleas of Cumberland
county, Civil, No. 95-4486 civil
JUDO".""
011 ~4TfON ........ ...., II II IIOW M" OrMrtd and
adJud,1d by 11th ColUf lhaI 1M jud'mt'" 01 IhI ColUf of
COIIIIIIOII PIIM of CUMBERLAND ColllllY bI. and ,hi IamI
h "'~ AFFIRMED IN PARTI REVERSED IN PART.
CASE REMANDED W/DIRECTIVES.
Jurisdiction Relinquished.
. ' If 77IB COU"T:
DwN: August 13, 1996
,.
~
J.S20019/96
STERLING K. MOLL,
Appellant
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF
PENNSYLVANIA
v.
VICKI JO ERDMAN,
Appellee
No. 23 Harrisburg 1996
Appeal from the Order entered December 7, 1995
in the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland
County, Civil, No. 95-4486 Civil
BEFORE:
TAMILIA, KELLY, and HOFFMAN,
JJ.
II' LE DAUG131996
MEMORANDUM:
This appeal is from the order entered on December 7, 1995
by the Common Pleas Court of Cumberland County which dismissed
appellant's, Sterling K. Moll's, complaint for improper service.
We reverse and remand.
The relevant facts and procedural history of this case are as
follows. As a result of a motor vehicle accident that occurred
July 21, 1994, appellant filed a I2I.Q !W. complaint on August 23,
1995, against appellee, Vicki J. Erdman, to recover vehicle
damages. Appellant attempted service through the first class mail
which was not in accordance with the provisions of Pa.R.Civ.P.
4001 and 402.2 Appellee moved to strike the complaint for
1 Rule 400. Person to Make Service
(a) Except as provided in subdivision (b) and (c) and
in Rules 400.1 and 1930.4, original process shall be
served within the commonwealth only by the sheriff.
(b) In addition to service by the sheriff, original
process may be served also by a competent adult who is
not a party in the following actions I equity,
partition, prevent waste, and declaratory judgment when
declaratory relief is the only relief sought.
continued on following page
,.
. .
J.S20019/96 - 2
improper service. The trial court dismissed appellant's action on
December 7/ 1995. Appellant appealed the order under Pa.R.Civ.P.
126. As there had been no opinion issued prior to the appeal, the
Honorable Judge Kevin A. Hess issued an opinion pursuant to Rule
1925. In that opinion, Judge Hess concluded that although the
complaint was not properly served, it should not have been
dismissed but should have been set aside. Trial Court Opinion,
filed January 25/ 1990/ at 2. This timely appeal followed.
Continued from previous page
Note: Service of original process in domestic
relations matters is governed by Rule 1930.4.
(c) When the sheriff is a party to the action, original
process shall be served by the coroner or other officer
authorized by law to perform the duties of coroner.
(d) If service is to be made by the sheriff in a county
other than the county in which the action was commenced,
the sheriff of the county where service may be made
shall be deputized for that purpose by the sheriff of
the county where the action was commenced.
2 Rule 402. Manner of Service. Acceptance of service
(a) Original process may be served
(1) by handing a copy to the defendant; or
(i) at the residence of the
defendant to an adult member of the
family with whom he resides; but if
no adult member of the family is
found, then to an adult person in
charge of such residence; or
(ii) at the residence of the
defendant to the clerk or manager of
the hotel, inn, apartment house,
boarding house or other place of
lodging at which he resides; or
(iii) at any office or usual place
of business of the defendant to his
agent or to the person for the time
Continued on following page
\.
\
J.S20019/96 - 3
Appellant raises the following issue for our review:
WHETHER PLAINTIFF IS ENTITLED TO REMAND TO THE LOWER
COURT INASMUCH AS THE DECISION TO DISMISS IS IMPROPER AS
A MATTER OF LAW.
Appellant's Brief at 3.
In determining whether proper service has been effected, our
scope of review is limited to whether Pa.R.Civ.P. 402 has been
followed. Collins v. Park, 423 Pa.Super, 601, 604, 621 A.2d 996,
997 (1993), allocatur denied, 536 Pa. 618, 637 A.2d 278 (1993).
Although service of process may be found defective within the
mandate of Pa. R. ci v. P. 402. the proper remedy is to set aside
service and allow appellant to attempt to effect proper service of
process. Weaver v. Martin, 440 pa.Super. 185, 193, 655 A.2d 180,
184 (1995) I Collins v. Park, supral Frvcklund v. WaY, 410
pa.Super. 347, 353, 599 A.2d 1332, 1335 (1991), allocatur denied,
531 Pa. 654, 613 A.2d 560 (1992).
Instantly, the trial court originally found appellant's
service was improper and dismissed appellant's act ion. In the
opinion later submitted by the trial court, Judge Hess conceded
" It] hat the impact of our order should have been to set aside
service as opposed to dismissal of the action." Trial Court
Opinion, filed January 25, 1996, at 2. We agree that appellant's
service should have been set aside. Accordingly, appellant's
complaint is reinstated and appellant is directed to effectuate
service in compliance with Pa.R.Civ.P. 400 and 402.
Based upon the foregoing, we reverse the trial court I s order
dismissing appellant's action. However, we affirm the trial
court's determination that sel'vice on appellee was defective,
Continued from previous page
Continued on following page
and we order such service set aside. Further, we remand the case
for further proceedings consistent with this memorandum.
Order affirmed J.n part and reversed in part. Case remanded.
Jurisdiction relinquished.
i,' ·
J.S20019/96 - 4
continued from previoUS page
being in charge thereof.
"
-- ""
CERTI FICATE AND TRANSMITTAl, Ot' Rt:CORD
UNDER
PENNSYLVANIA RUI.E Qt' APPELJ.ATE I'ROCEDURE 1931 (c)
To the Prothonotary of the ^ppellate Court to which the
within matter has been appealed:
RUPERIOR COURT OF PENNSYl.vANIA
'I'IIE UNDEIlSIGNIW, Prothonotary of the Court of Common Pleas
of ~m1lIldArnl County, the said court being /I court of record.
do hereby certify that annexed hereto is a true and correct copy
of the whole and entire record, including an opinion of the court
as required by P^ R.^.P. 1925, the original papers and exhibits.
if any on file, the transcript of the proceedings. if any, and the
docket entries in the following matter:
Case No. 95-4486 Civil Terml No. 23 HDG 1996
STERl.ING K. Mot.L
VB.
VICKI JO ERDMAN
The documents comprising the record have been numbered
from No, 1 to No. 37 , and attached hereto as Exhibit A is a
list of the documents correspondingly numbered and identified with
reasonable definiteness. including with respect to each document.
the number of pages comprising the document.
The date on which the record has been transmitted to the
appellate court is. February 13. 1996 .
(Seal of Court)
(~U..u'ltb!. r. 1V db\.../."4~t.....
Prothonotary f
An additional copy of this certificate is enclosed. please
sign and date copy. thereby acknowledging receipt of this record.
RECORD RECEIVED:
Date:
RECORD FILED IN SUPERIOR COllRT
FEB 1 a 1996 ..Jl-(
f~~~~~~P, & title)
HARRISUUHli
1- fll.et
--.
f",
Cnnunnnweulth nl "enosyll'lInlu
CnunlY of Cumberlund
\ os:
I. Lawrence E. Welker . I'rulhonolury
01 the Coutl 01 Cnmmnn "Ieus in und lnr sull!
County. do hereby certlly Ihut the lmegnlng Is u
lnll. true und cortect copy oflhe whole record nllhe
eu.e therein Muted. wherein
fHerllno K. Moll
I'hlintlll.und
Vicki ,In Errlm.,n
Ilefendunt _. u. Ihe 'ume remains 01 recmd
CaBe No. 23 HOG 1996 belore lhe ,uld Cnurt al No. 95-4486 nl
Civ\ 1 Term. A.n. 19_.
In TESTIMONY WIIEREOF. I hUle hereunln sct my hand and alli.ed Ihe ,ealol .uld Court
Ihl, 13th day nl February A. [).. 19.2.Cl-.
.;Ylttl.l( /LtG f'. '')jf(CiitL
t1 :t'tJio1/,ut..d. ,Iattt.., it"...,t'rnlh""""'\
I. Harold E, Sheely I'resldent Judge nf the Ninth
Judicial 1l1.lrict. cnmpo.ed of the County of Cumberland. do certlly Ihal Lawrence E. We lker.
'prothonotary . hy whom Ihe anne.ed record. certlncate and
atle,lation were made and given. und who. In hilown proper handwrltlnll. thereunto .ub.erlbed bll name
and alfillCd the scal of Ihe Coort of Common I'leas ohald Counly. Wlll. al Ihe lime oho doing. and now I.
Prolhonotary In and for ,aid County 01 Cumberland In
the Commonwealth 01 Pennsylvania. duly commissioned und quullned to all olwho.e act. a. .uch full lalth
and credit arc and ought 10 he given as well In Cuurll 01 judlcuture a. elsewhere. and Ihallhe laid record.
cerllficale and alteslallon are in due fmm of law und U' hy Ihe proP(c~lfice >{.
,L(.t\, ~:-. ,. //
I"t,idl.'nl.lud,\.'
Commonwealth oll'ennsyllunlu
Counly of Cumherland
Iss:
I. J.llWT<>nf"" E. W"lker . I'rothollolury ill Ihe Courl 01 Common Plea. in
und lor Ihe .ald County. do eerlily Ihat Ihe 1I0nmublc IIllrnlrl E Hh,only
hy whom Ihe lmegolng IlIle.tllllon WUI mllde. und whu huslhereunloluhlerlhed hilnume. Will. ullhe lime
01 maklnll thereol. and .1111 Is I'relldeut Judge ollhe Cumt ulCummun I'leul, Orphan'Court and COUtl of
Quatler Se"lons of the I'eace In nnd fur suld Coullly, duly Cummlllloned und l\uullned; to ull who.e Uetl
us such filII faith uud credilull' urllluught tu be Illven. u. well In Court, 01 judlcuture UI elsewhere.
IN TESTIMONY WIlI:lWOF. I hllle hereuntll
lei my hUllllund um.ed Ihe leulol "aid ('umt Ihi,
nth dllY 01 I'ehr~_ A.Il. Ilj~fL..
~. l. JL L . )/:'1:(
/j~: t 1')....(.(/( ti. )1;lI'(t.,.<-, lC,{1' ",,,,h..,,,,'.II'
J J >0 ! J
c f
~
- - c:l
J . -
.
Cl
Iii l:j
I I .
J ~
I 0 I: ~
~ ., ! 1
... ."" r.1
N ... )
u ~ ~ j ~
cl cl .""
;E jE >
v
PAGE Kl.
1 - 7
8
9
10 - 12
13 - 19
20
21 - 28
29
30 - 33
34 - 35
36 - 37
"
~
Amons Ihe Recnrdl and I'roccedlngl enrolled In the court of Common Pleu In and fur the
counly of C\Jnberland
No. 23 1l0G 1996
10 No. 95-4486 Civil
III the Commonweallh IIf I'elln.ylvania
Term. 19 I. contained the following:
COI'V OF
^ppnnrnnce
nOCK"T "N'fRV
STERI.ING K. MOl. I.
VB.
VICKI JO ERDMAN
Aug. 23, 1995, Petition to Recover Vehicle Damages, filed.
Sept. 20. 1995, Important Notice, filed.
Sept. 20, 1995, certificate of Service, filed,
Sept. 26, 1995. Praecipe to Enter Appearance, filed.
Please enter our appearance in the above-captioned lawsuit on behalf of
Defendant Vicki Jo Eranan.
Byt Ilarvey l'reedenberg, Esq.
Sept. 28. 1995, Defendant's prelUninary Objections to Plaintiff's Canplaint,
filed.
Sept. 29, 1995. Praecipe for Listing Case for Argument, filed.
BYI Michael R. Kelley, Esq,
Oct. 27. 1995. Plaintiff's Reply to Defendants Preliminary Obiections to
Plaintiff's complaint, filed.
1lBc. 7, 1995. Order, filed. In ReI Defendant's Preliminary Objections to
the eanplaint
AND l'O'I, this 7th day of December, 1995, it appearing that service of
the canplaint was not made according to Rule, the preliminary objection of
the defendant, in this regard. is SUSTAINED. The within action is DISMISSED
By the Court, Kevin A. Iless, .J.
Jan. 4. 1996. Notice of Appeal, filed.
Notice is hereby given that Sterling K. Moll, Plaintiff above named,
hereby appeals to the superior Court of Pennsylvania fran the order entered
in this matter on the 7th day of Oecel11ber, 1995. This order has been ente
in the docket as evidenced by the attached copy of the docket entry.
BYI Sterling K. Moll, Pro Se
Jan. 17. 1996, Superior Court of Pennsylvania Notice of Appeal ():)(:keting to
No, 23 1l0G 1996, f\letl.
Jan. 25. 1996. Opinion Pursuant to Illlle 1925, filed,
By tho Court, Kevin A. lIess, .J.
.
"
--
8/1 ~/qs
,. .1,. (" )( "^ '
....\1 :.u. "".' (."'l ,n'\ ,Y \
", L. j
(1) ,}", .'
.. ...\(t'~"'~U(lt)'
VS.
\" " ',' ,",
\' .' j 1,_ \I,p'i , t \ '1, : t'" ',\\ ..,\.,\'Tj
. ~~, i
'. ...
"I' .; . 1 ~.' ' " ''''1 I", i '" I ..... 'L- i. ,'" '"I ,"'. \ j
'v'-A-t' tit ?~' ~;,,,/ "'" 01,
.)!, \ .
.; \'/',--'" ",,'\.. ,t .\'
"
.t. ~ '"
,- l " . J It ".' ,
'.. CfS--448~-, ,,' T?~~
) '," . \ ,,'''' \ I)) ,I
\ t - I 1, r,
:(\ o--t:t.<'Jl. ':J (Y' 0 ~-.J:,
~ ~Ui:. _4-<.~.'(\ A-wR"i.-" oCq-w,;t'~Cr../A.U~
t,. ~ ~"f- ~ -c~~ ..u;t ~ ~~
~4-'';!.~., ~\, ~4 ~~<'Yl.c.,..4-~""
14u.~ '~O).~-, .11;ta,;. ~~,~J)~
.aNI. .A-<.~.Q ei .~ Av.-'4-tb....-. -a... e...
. cYl -o.:tti ~oJ., ~.L., M.AJ~
: ) _ c.-u,,-* ~ ~~~ """ . c~Y\..J ~ ;t.(U. c-, .
A.e-t .~ ~:,~~ '~t\ 'ct"- ~ ~c~)a.J 1 ~\,
p.t~Aq-J~ ~vU~~cuJJ.~~Ja~
(\. ~Q~~;"f --.~~~ J.-.".:b)u.JI.a.~"J'~ --e~-
~ ....w...~J ~,,:.- fu.-') ~~a4. ~ -1l- M, ~ .
ee~~~ ~ .t<<Jz. (!~o........'\1 .~J1 ~ .tvo~ - o.:iau-I)~"l
1tY1J\.c.(J-uo p )u>'9- '& () :-? .J () .--:-) .'l . '. - ~
1 U U U(.,.. .j' ~~rtJl.. .X)" ~tU- ,...;t'rr. 1('" U ~"''\.(l-<j._
.~ _"YYWY\.Qc...\.. ..o-A'-F-'\o.-~~b. .O-fI ~'l kA_e.:t4 "-
,A..'....\-.F~''\...t ~ '~L . .~. .~
~ ~"t.c..QcR. :J -<1-V\x. :J --e<-<I .k?l~)l Jcr
~.(.t'l 'J,'-<1.(.I....}fJl, o.t C)_-~e . \t' -w.uOo-
'~ t.J a.u-R a.~t~l Clyt C~
Cl&tfttJ\cQ (9....\Q.J ,.-I.J~ :J cr 19.11 'J ~Q~e.
I
.
~
"J~ o~ ~~ tfufJ-J. 'J"..
~e.J~~~ ~
~ ~.1lf'
~ ..
~~
~~~
~I PA 1)-013
":J~: ('117) ~-1-e -C;; 200
~"M~
~ste.'(' I"'h~ . M~III.@.Ac:1 ..ill-
.
--
.2-~&'.'~ K ..'ntrrQ~J
~~~p~
Vs.
V ~~ ~ E~""<\,ft,
cD 4"~'\clLt\-",,*
~-'1\ "J_~ (::(,1A..lv+ off r..,,-vv\./t'V\.o.--(l
.(?~"-<l~ fJr&' "~,Ji,,..~)~Uv'vt..~
.YP _Q...,-",,~4. C"~- if (V,'\.~(t.
. . (J
't4r. __ .....t.,.... 1995
1
~~ CJ.c~ - ~
, .
.{;;l..ll.-U~ ':J c-
~crVV\ \t ~~~~ 9~'~~~-
~~J ~ l3't! ,~o-ff.~i- JI~~51
~ ~ fi~,~)~i~v~.~.J ~~
~)~~ ~ H~~ c.r;..uvt~~~
.fY.A/~ k ~~-'I. ~~C-CL D,-Q;~~t
.h4 Df~C'--'Y\A'J V--<-c.t/lL ~ f.A.JL, "'V\(vYt,J ci 2. ',OO~
~ f)Ju.v-'1Jo.r-~"~- 30"3) ~~~J
e.u...~~(\;>'\.J} Cc-u.--,~ ..kP~~~ '70 II .
~ ~-.~"* ~_l_~c~ .~
I. 0* M't.~'J:30 P. M'J ~ ~ RIO- ~ ~
~,1)194-, ~ l:) ~'~-fi/~ .-4i"<)~,~."-'Yl ~
~~ o--<'.C-A-~.J-.~.~ .@~l -oJ- ~
,.A..-~~ ('.-t:c~ ?i (f.l'"-l-'^"U~ c '\ .--~t.lU2,d".(\ Pi\"; :J ~.Q
..g.t>t.ca-t, ..A-vt iteua. 6~'t\'d~L~ .o-f ~'W'\--<'''X''\Q./~,...,~,JJ(\.....Q
c:~~,.G'~"\.'d'A"<lr~ . ,,',,- . .
~. :J~D-"'p.."..!J-tt...vt.l Ar(';a"'l.Q~.. ,JJ:.& ,~tJu.K...z.;tALL.
~ ..et.'\.t.",-vt.6~A .-4,"t1.' 'f (~JJ,v .v...I.' (~......(' Cll j..YI.t~ ~'M-4'~\.j~
3
.
~
I ' . .
...v..\.::t.V\A..e.~ _e.,,;4t.1'1-.-Y\.J-V\~ ,J.>>U!~-t.,
#!vJ- ~~.of ;t.eVJ.. .A.tc-f-r-"..Q. ~CL.c&)~,
~'Y\".(l~ -f~-'Y\ ,A:.(l'\)l.,(\)L.;' n. 0<< .;t~ ..Raft ....l?~tl~~~;t)
~t..'\JJ ~tA-. .-t\-Cl'\..O'-4-..\ ./tt.Q.. 1^<"......:t ~(;tp\Jl. A.....d\..L-cY12.
~tJ.'"t~ ~l4..o, ~.,...' 'Y'-<''8('" . . J
0. 'J~ .j;)-2.u.:,.~ ,...u.L,,~1 r"LJ) Yw..t ~
~~ ;te..ll. 't.J ,"r'l\_.o-.I1.4.(;.Qo. ~'.'kQ.. l~o.. H.u.1)
..A--Y'\ ~ ~ 19 ~ ~~'Y\ ~ ~~cW ~ 1,
~..~~ ~\...:t<.",...vv\ 1G,~8~~aQ
19~4. J~ ~~ ~J\);'J'\G.f1u~ ~
~V\.a}l.t~ .:\ -t.~'\4 ~41-...",.ut~~4 ~
~~~:I "
4. 'J.__tt/L.o~~~~Q.. ~YY'\_Q...,.~ . ,
;t.,- ~ )-#~-v\-~ ~) ~ ~~.M-'~
".v-e.e.-i.-C~ ~.\...{.1l'--<V''VC....._ '('A''''')'k~U\, ~..,At.'~ m~
\~-t-U'L-tv<\.C{L ~~~~'~~ ~~~~J-
~~...-'Uv.. !Y ~,.vtL6f...cl ~,&~-w~Q. ~ ;t~'vL
..k? ~v-...;t:.61f...q. ~~'-'!..4AQ 04 ,.w-. .t<<.a. ~''''''-'l...;i.."Y\.Q.J)
~,~c~.~tt~ ~~'t.)-~<Q ~~'\.1)./"1 ~-e~.
{l..tfuL..~t "....,., ;tc..~ ,(L.C~,&I'.,\'\.-t,
5' . '"J --ik. )? -et\.:~~?..d /9 9 5 .eJ ~~ I 50 fi> ~~
.oJ (J . . )
,. ~V\ At,i.t,:.1 _.cf)'L'YY'-_I\..~ ..<.-n.~'l'-("~;'\ -"',h:J .tt.LC~
J-Ci.(t't.{'~'l ""Q ~<H('\ li...u. .U",,"Q.<k .voxl(l.h..\ (~R4oo.co)
J .
. . ,
(/J' ~ ~ lp_2,\..t...,-;:~~ -::-\\.C -W1J\I'JJ .(l .(' ~.",.t tt~'c-V'\?JI
:J _t.\!~ H"u'" ,\...<0',-1I,\! !J ,,;v-~ t (1 ~~~ (c1, ~ 0 0 . 0 0) .d4u. -...e -...1
" '1-11., '6)) . ,1'. 1 <>
.0-() /\.-MlL ...4-\..4>, 1.' -/.(...,\ _(.._4' l\.....{' (u. .
")
J\- .
.
~
'7. -:J ~II. t) ~.r,,,<>Qc' .,,t. A:'\'.<l,j\"~ X.l1,.. -'j)_.('l.....,'-t.(~~
~ ~\.. YLL('('4.~,"',':(,., _ _R.u)\.~) 4.~Ztf ..tl/.,J).-.\y,--"..'\t-~ ;t;
.o..e-,.t.u.' __e "-f~ ~", n::('-AJ'''1 ,~,' " ~ 'H u' 1o.-c.t.\ .--
MVl. ;~..e(L~-,":>{rif~J ~ ({.,~,'\"Q.'--",'l,'VHI '\ cl-,I(,\1 .('",>1)'U~'1
-o..-....JJ ,:to ;t{k rf ~-vL-<l J\.(\.t;,,"Q. (I.... \C..\jr4 , ,.it1.c IUL.<(:~
~~fu,~\.;le'll- _,:;.i).-A)n.~ ,\.t.'p10,6Jo.f>" II).! , ({V\,~.~-"-(~,
"'..'
,
~~~,1\.Q) ;:t(tQ. fi~~"ct.:~, .....-.r:&));Q-voW
}{ . ~Q J }i~1\.d ..A/.t2. J ...Jl-Q.~ f ~ c 'f. (f--u. (' 0,' ).10 ~~
;t.e... rI ~",G.(" (",vA.-i- -if,,, .<),H.a\,Q <>f
~I'\ 'J .A.J.o' "'J _K't'-,t..t..dtH'...Q ~q \1 ..(..V,'~./\.I2.JJ
n~ ($RI400 .00) ..-v-",a.~I.L ~)
~ 'J.we- )1 ~J\J!J) IJ ~"<\M (; ROO, 00)
~ cf ~(L.C.QL AA.-~Q.. )Xeu.. e,C1'~ of ~ ~
.jf.u.~j ~ h~ .~b{lV)'l :J .J'y') J ,.--!&'L'.1. M1..d? ~.
h -1)-_eecV\..~ (i' 10) 000.00) )dj .L-. (\jl:~...~ .t~ .a..Yf\..()'~4 .
~~.." 4.P." ,,( f.~.1 Ill'. I',. " ' i+- I!
, lJ \'-- '<I -u-'........,.-t.lA.:t"\J
, .
~\C(.__'~',t~.l\'L ''.'\,~' 'l)\ _,1.\'
~ (;.f-t,. >( III, cl Ix"'- ....\" II
'J
rjIA"\,\,\,h, ,.',,','..,. It ..
_ ..-. ' "Ii" ,
\.t,l(t :\ "\ \. ~ .J t., "1:\1 I )/~ ,f"{ ...... 't ,:1
Ph. (717) 7~'5. A.oit~
D c",t..,: f3 / R. 'J / B S
,}
f'"
"
fI'
.
v~~
~, ffi;&.:.~. "".,iie, jd}-"<T -""', ~
:*aa. ~ ~,~ i.1"'I i:fuL ~~ ~
fd~ AlNl. ~ ~ ~& ~. ~--e>a
~.o..o' ~ ~
U~-u~'J)1;:;~ .
~~~,~~~
;\;~~ ~1~l'a.C.S.~4904~
~ ~~ ~a..Jb.cM ~ -(U.~~.
cf>~: BIll 1/95
~
6te'C' I il'\~' . II
~
,
.
~
~-.~f~~..
\ ~~ .u.~ ~t \ ~ 0. JA.wz..
/O.A~ ~ ~~~ -1:: ~~ ~h::~4-
h -fJ.e. ~ .N" .~ ~~~ d~J
th~- ~) ~\A.'Ji J ~ )Ji..JJ..
~~ ':'
V-~~~.
'6.100 ~ QUc.-v, f)~
~ 3<:73
~ J.{~I PA 1701/
, ,"" '"" i
.~
ste..../. ~~ ' )It 0"
~~: .8/2'3/91;)
IU
J\_.J
7
tR
-
:Ie
C1-
tD
m
\.'~!::.!
"
"',-.J
m
t"--l
g
,"".:1"
1 ~
'} ~
~.~ "
~~ ~
~~: ()
.(" -, I
I'_,.t I;'::: V ",
I "'\....)
.',<' \ ~. I.": I';'
';;"'.,. 'I .., 'l....
I 41., ....J-
..... \It
. . I Ii {(:(, (.
-.)l/)/t'IIIJr/ .J I I'
). I. Ir.I
(/ . 1- , nli1S II ( .
CI\\flc1Ll1L'J"'. '
,,) II., IItt ll.'/k.
)(1"1 .-. If', ~'()
M
~
\)...
00
~
~
,~
, "
...Q:.(;....~,..................., ,~~.
,...~~~~~;,i~~~
..........l1........ PROTHONOY;~
. "II~{J/'J~
I~ THE COURT ""..tOMMON PLEAS orC... .~ 2~~UNTY. PENNSYLV~"J.A
I; JVIl. DIVISION
,.8;W~ K. 'M.,.eO,
~~iJ4
VI.
.
'f~ ~ &~.A\J
J)~
File No. Mec;; M 19'35
TOI \f ,'",/1: \l..,. P" 1)~
~ ~ ~ ,. -o;f~'ndant
O.te of Notice:
JfI'CI@TAIIT MOTlet:
Pursuant to P..R.C.P. No. 237.1(.)(2)
YOU ARE iN DEFAULT BECAUSE YOU HAVE fAILED TO ENTER A WRITTEN APPEARANCE
PERSOIIAllY OR BY ATTORNEY AND FILE III IIRITING WITH THE COURT YOUR DEFENSES OR
OBJECTIONS TO THE CLAiMS SET FORTH AGAINST YOU. UNLESS YOU ACT WITHIN TEN DAYS
FROM THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE, A JUDGMENT HAY BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU WITHOUT A
HEARING AND YOU HAY LOSE YOUR PROPERTY OR OTHER IMPORTANT RIGHTS. YOU SHOULD
TAKE THIS NOTICE TO A LAWYER AT ONCE. If YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWVER OR eMNOT
AFFORD ONE GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE FOlLOWING OFFICE TO fiNO OUT WHERE YOU CAli GET
LEGAL HELP:
(Judgment by Dufault)
~~~
TELEPHONE NO. ~o
Signature:....g ~ 'J(. W\,QII
signature of Plht.ntiff or Atty.
Addren: S'IA ~..iP~~'
"J ~~""^. .fA l'lO!l
.~h.. ...~ hr J'4'1') $!:' ""
telephone No, 1 ~ I '7 . . +0 ~ ~
Supreme Court 10 No.: --
H'2f-4 (EH. 7/95)
8
~
.
~
r-
::I
... ~.
~t:
t. ~< _!
UJ, .
~~;'.,
...'.1 '
".
-
-
=
N
fh
V1
u
v
'1 .,"0 ~.f
--
""
~ ;tvJ7. , t< 'M ~
6Ie~~~
, fA \10 oft ~
?o, ~9S
@ .
~~ ~of~
,.~451 ~
~) pA '10\3
~-W\.M" e ~d~ ):A.J 0-(1 'O{~:,/t:t5,C. ~
\,~~-v~. ~
~ ~~_1"-!i~IJ_~ I ~
~, _~ "f'~ ......1)\ t;
~I ~~;td:
v-~ ~ ~
~'oo~~ f)~
~O'3
~ tl~1 fA \10 II
f)~-rtL ~ ~ ~CJ4uA~
1J.~.,.@~A~/ ft~ fiJ~J a-.J)
LJ.o.A ~ ~ ;./d ~r\D-'
~
....-8 ~' n\~
"
.'. ,
(I
aA
-
~~
10( l'
'#I~- -,..I
f,) '.r; ~.
~f..;f.
"j. ;',
"I ,.
~ I;.;
;",i
r-
.:r
=
....,
fb
V1
v
v
"
STERLING K. MOLL,
Plaintiff
v.
VICKI JO ERDMAN,
Defendant
~
....
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 4486 CIVIL 1995
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
PRAECIPE TO ENTER APPEARANCE
TO THE PROTHONOTARYl
Please enter our appearance in the above-referenced lawsuit
on behalf of Defendant Vicki Jo Erdman.
Datedl S'f\e.w.\(.r :lS', '''''If'"'
McNEES, WALLACE & NURICK
By
.
Harvey Freedenberg
I.D. No. 23152
Michael R. Kelley
I.D. No. 58854
100 Pine Street
P. O. Box 1166
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1166
(717) 232-8000
Attorneys for Defendant
Vicki Jo Erdman
,...
~
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on this date a true and correct copy
of the foregoing document was served by first-class mail, postage
prepaid, upon the following I
Mr. sterling K. Moll
518 North Second Street
Wormleysburg, PA 17043
Datedl September a,;-, 1995
If
m
-
;p
,~...
':;.....
~I..
. .
U'"
t..?' Y." ~
t.:. ',', '~-' ~ -~
.t., ~. f',
r-.I .."
I...
. ,,"'
"
,',
~
('r)
( lJ
'"
Jl
.
,.
flaNEE8. WALLACE 110 NURICK
tOO PINE BTREET
P. a, .01 It..
HA"",'.UflG, 'A 17101
w
.
q !)I,/q:r
.
.
STERLING K. MOLL,
plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 4486 CIVIL 1995
v.
VICKI JO ERDMAN,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
AND NOW, this
ORDIR
day of
, 1995, upon
consideration of the within Preliminary Objections of Defendant,
the Preliminary objections are sustained. The "Petition" is
stricken due to improper service. If the defective service is
deemed to have been waived, the claim for infliction of emotional
distress is dismissed, and the claims for recovery of attorneys
fees and punitive damages are stricken as improper under
Pennsylvania law.
BY THE COURT I
J.
~
"
STERLING K. MOLL,
Plaintif f
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
NO. 4486 CIVIL 1995
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
VICKI JO ERDMAN,
Defendant
DI'KNDANT'S PRILININARY OBJICTIONS TO PLAINTI"'S COMPLAINT
Defendant Vicki J. Erdman ("Erdman"), by her attorneys,
McNees, Wallace & Nurick, hereby files the following Preliminary
objections to Plaintiff's Complaint I
1. Plaintiff Sterling K. Moll ("Moll") commenced this
action by filing a "Petition to Recover Vehicle Damages" on or
about August 23, 1995.
2. The "Petition" seeks to recover property damages only
as a result of the alleged negligence of Erdman. There are no
allegations that Moll sustained any personal injuries as a result
of the vehicle accident (Petition, Paragraphs 5.6).
3. The "Petition" also seeks damages for "hardship and
mental abuse" as a result of Erdman's alleged providing of
"inconsistent" facts to a vehicle insurance carrier (Petition,
Paragraphs 4, 7).
4. The a,g damnum clause of the "Petition" seeks recovery
of "legal fees" and "less than $10,000.00 in punitive damages."
5, The Complaint was served upon Erdman by first class
mail with no acknowledgement of receipt of service attached.
'"
""
COUNT I
Motion to Strike Comclaint for Imcrocer Service
6. Paragraphs 1 through 5 above arc incorporated herein by
reference as if set forth in full.
7. Under Pa. R. civ. P. 402, service is properly made upon
an individual defendant within the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
only through "handing" a copy of the complaint to the defendant
or another authorized person.
B. Erdman was not properly served with the "Petition" in
this case because service was attempted only through first class
mail.
WHEREFORE, Erdman respectfully requests that Moll's Petition
be stricken for improper service.
COUNT II
Demurrer to The Claim of "Hardship and Mental Abuse"
9. Paragraphs 1 through 5 above are incorporated herein by
reference as if set forth in full,
10. The attempt by Moll, who is acting ~~, to recover
for "hardship and mental abuse" is an unartful attempt to state a
claim for either intentional or negligent infliction of emotional
distress.
11. Under Pennsylvania law, neither claim can be maintained
absent physical injury.
IS
~
~
12, Moll does not allege that he sustained any physical
injuries as a result of the accident.
WHEREFORE, Erdman respectfully requests that Moll's claim
for infliction of emotional distress be dismissed.
COUNT III
Motion to Strike Claim for Leaal Fees
13, Paragraphs 1 through 5 above are incorporated herein by
reference as is set forth in full.
14. In the sg damnum clause of the petition, Moll seeks the
recovery of "legal fees."
15. Under Pennsylvania law, the recovery of attorneys'
fees, under the facts alleged in the complaint, is not permitted
as a matter of law.
WHEREFORE, Erdman respectfully requests that Moll's claim
for the recovery of attorneys' fees be stricken.
COUNT IV
Motion to Strike Punitive Damaaes Claim
Paragraphs 1 through 5 above are incorporated herein by
reference as is set forth in full.
16. The Petition also contains a claim for recovery of
punitive damages.
17. Punitive damages are recoverable under Pennsylvania law
only where the complaint contains facts which show extreme or
outrageous conduct performed in reckless disregard of the rights
and safety of others.
~
(',
18. The "Petition" describes nothing more than a typical
accident scenario in which Moll claims that Erdman was negligent
in causing property damage.
19. The "Petition" contains no facts which give rise to a
claim for punitive damages.
WHEREFORE, Erdman respectfully requests that this Court
strike Moll's claim for punitive damages.
McNEES, WALLACE & NURICK
By
rt1,((. , ~.
M chael R. Kelley
1.0. No. 58854
100 Pine Street
P. O. Box 1166
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1166
(717) 232-8000
Attorneys for Defendant
Vicki Jo Erdman
Dated: Scf\-,....~~ :2') ''''r
~
f"..
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on this date a true and correct copy
of the foregoing document was served by first-class mail, postage
prepaid, upon the followingl
Mr. Sterling K. Moll
518 North Second Street
Wormleysburg, PA 17043
tJ1~ K. ~_.
M c ael R. Kelley
Datedl septemberl', 1995
~
..
:c
0-
....
'"
=
r-.I
fh
Vl
~;~
.., ~;:
I.. I~, '-. q
I:' -.' , -
,~.:; I.:' "t
':r,:"
,
;'
..
,:1'
;",
. "
'1 r
,.
,
l.....;
-,
w
.
McNa:l:li, WALLACe ft NUItILK
.
q 1~p,/qS
100 rltn !l,..r~ I
.
r U p'JI II...
1l~""IUUlJnQ, PA 17101
......
~
1""\
9 /.1q/~S
PRAECIPE FOR LISTING ("ASE FOR '\RlilJ\IENT
I Must be tYlle\Hlllen alld submlllt'd 111 dUIIIit'lIlt'>>
TO litE I'ROTlIONOTARV,OF CUMBERLANU COUNTY:
I'lca,,'II11 lI,c wllhlnmall"1 1'..1 Ihe ncxl:
[]
IK]
1',,'.Trllll AI~lllnenl ('..1II1
^,~umenl ('111111
.."
.,.~
r-)
U:)
,-
,-'1 ~,
.
('AI'TIUN OF ('AS!'.
(ellll,e ,'allll..II mUll hc IIalel! ill full I
,
, .. I .. ~ ~
w
~
~
p;
~
STERLING K. MOLL,
" C' '. '.
. ..
" '-""('J
. '"\
".;;."'
..~
""',-'
(l'lalnllff)
v..
VICKI JO ERDMAN,
(/ltfendanl)
VI.
No. 4486
Civil ActJon_.::_L~W.. 1'1 9_5..
I. State mailer III he ar~ued (I. e.. plalntlffl mollun fur new Irlal,
defendanl', demurrer tu cumplalnt. etc.):
Defendant's Preliminary Objections to Plaintiff's Complaint
2. Idenlll')' coumel whu will arBue case:
(a) furplalnlllT: Mr. Sterling K. Moll, 518 North Second Street,
Wormleysburg PA 17043
(b) for defenJanl: Michael R. Kelley, Esq., McNees, Wallace &
Nurick, 100 Pine Street, P.O. Box 1166, Harrisburg, PA 17108
3. I wlllnulll')' alll'arll.lln wrlllnB wl1hlnlw..l!a)'1 Ihallhl. calC hill been
IIllcl! for arBumenl._
Ilalel!: September 28, 1995
J;I;Ii.r-W R_ J{ "I ~h1 _'__
(AII..lne)' 1'11I DefendanJt'''''';~-;;:-T
Michael R. Kelley, Esquire
1.0. No. 58854
McNEES, WALLACE & NURICK
100 Pine st., P.O. Box 1166
Harrisburg. PA 17108-1166
(717) 232-8000
f""\
IOI)'7/~f
.
...g ;tv\..t..",~,< . "', ".>} (
T , )
. . -et\-,,~'4~ 1
y.
V ,A.c~"'-~ ~.0(1" f.~V n \.t'l ., \
V....'ff" 'Ie>' ,....~ t-
I
I \1 , I \' t (', 'It
I ~~....~1 ....1-\"", ("~((.~~ D't(''''''''r'''1''''''
I ~ '..I!,' ,I.' () 6;
\.:."-l ,,\\fd \",l\"_'~\.l.\ (~..tl "':'" ~
I.), ' .'
,v' ....\' '\'\/" '. .h. ~ '. I" n. tell\' "
I yt,..". +-, B (" (l'l:U"':'\,I 19'3 [)
I
I l"l (.AI' d.(' 1'", \,. ~.......(ll-
I
..ft? k"J~'.~\ ~'{'':C_l) 'L__:Jr>~_
D~~~~~
jN~\r-,A.Q.J.c-Y\;t~ ~7~~ ~of~"~'
1~13.5, ~~~M~11~~
~ ~ ~ P-:f'~~~ ~~~~,
~~\A 44f~JA:
I.~~o
'l.D~.
3,~' --t~~~~--
~:DJ. . . . 'jJ'~~~H"Y~
~.vJ-, ~, p.2eu ~.A \-v'\.A-t.tA'(\/y\-~ €.cv\..M.JVt J
~~,/ . ,~~.~..,~A; ~
~~ . . ~ ~U-4 .~
~. "
4. (J.JL,.,~I. ~~v.1e. ;!(.~ ~~,
~.' jj> ~~ ilV~:te..PA ...@~(~.Q -~ ~
JM,l.C- 'J~(..t...-a-ct...r\~ ~-(.V\ )j ..(.t~\.l'..J..I (~~,400. 00)
21
,..
f"i\
~'\A ~~~ &"t'Y~ ~\<'.Q ~-'l "'J~".
).I~~($~OO'OO)J)~~ f~ ~~f>>4Q
of..v<-({.(.-~ .
6.~J).
.~4~~6f~__~~a.Q~~.,,"-_. .
_~J"f.l2~~A ~"'3.. ·
~~ ~_~~~~~.~ ,_._._1\.%.Q~:::
G, jdl~~ .~~ 'f~~~ I ~~~
S ~~ .t .v ~~~ f . .' I
~S,()J\~~ ~.~
~~ (1A "f -"~ ~ /t.:V' .~'
r"f.~'
.' .
8. ~~I ~~ ,tQVl-~~~
~. I;j~-v,.~ -M.toR-4 ~~~~
.{<M! ~ ~..-t.yt..... ....;., .~4<~~
~~""q'.A ~ .-f'~ ~~...e.
w.<<~ ,kJ')..e<te,,-J,~ ,.n.eA.-~~
-'Y~\" AJ. Ii ~ /!~~,J.- .
~ __~,..-(..(,..u<) ,..A-Q.I"\-(.J-t.cA J ~ ~
~ ~~i?-t' A .A.t..L~tu~...j. /ip~ll. Ccrv'f....C~...;ft
Ol~ k,.;t.~....\ . ....-<UJ'-',......C';\o!. ,..tl?Vl .v ~
()
",.
~
".....,
~ ~~Jl1).. .-8. WI "";J), A....;..f/!, .JI..AJI
V\ ...J\.J2-c..uA.-r~f ....u.,lrt"4~Q.
J7 ZJif~~~
A~ ~4r-~-~Q.~~"."
9. ,Gl~"" ~,..4 Ci~~..j!....~
~ I)&~ 5 .-tW2 Q
~ ~ -^"f^""~"'" 44 ~e ~ ~
~ ~Jl..e' . . .
10. a.JL....y~ ~~ ft~~ .-'4
~ -1""'" AJ2. ~;... .A-~'
II.fJ~'
II(, .0 ......~~ ;:iJ~~, -o,L"te... ~
~ .~ -{fv~~:: .~~-GV\Jl cf ;t.aJl.
~ ~ '6U ~\.-((A-MJl~ ,
w..e.~, ...G>.e......:..,;~. ~~,
~Ac.-S;;X~ ,"" ..o-"~~~ C!~vi' ~~
<) . . '). I .
.W~-.' , ,..1 Co-t'y~.t..",\.~ .\..'YI A_~.t/'fY~'
'3.
23
. .
---
f"\
I
-,~~~,~ ~~ ~ ~~~~ ~I
~1"'~ m..-t."" ~ ~~~,
___ _._'__.. _, f~ ~~
1:1. 9~':' ~\ ;to .e "r'~.;t-":
~ ' 1~.~5~
4~~~~~cu
,4-. a~Q ,
16. e~J).
Ift~.~~~
EJ li~ C-.....J- ~
Ji'k. ~"~\A'
~&iB~~~~
~~~B~~~-
l<tl..e.,.;.-4n'A ~<..-j,.e.;,." ..t. tJ ~~ ~
--r:-~~f'~ I ~~.I\.t'""~ 6 AiV2
~"-f~~<~1 ~~e.
aA ~ ~f ~"t~ --,-~, f<~'
I b. aJL.~Jl.
4-.
J..Lf
~
~
". ~v~.
le,.o.~\...~..-<.~ ..~c..~~~V\ .
.~~ M ~~V~~~~~~ \\A
,,0... c-cA..A,,"--1l ...A.-C".....,,<V~,,- ..-t:'--'~
) n -D .,' I
..x-~. ...-'W~ ........--v ~(~~V\jL .
I . eJ..)2..~~' V ~9-~ ~ a
~ ~ q" .... ~ ~ ~ ."'" -V"^",
~~J~~"'~'. .
.~ ~ ~ .v.~.-n-~~~~~
.M)C'-.d ~"'-'~ ~~vJ .J"V!--~L)
,@ . ~ ~~t-ekk~v'M ' .
~ .' ~ ~ ,B ~~vf.~\6Q'@~~.' I
.~N1: ,..i; . QQQ ~ .A.V-~~ ..@~.cj
.~. ~M'\ ;t(?~~h~
.<1 ~'c . -:J "" ,.~--n ....o~ ~
~~~~~ ~.
. ~ ,d2(.~I~ ~) ,;t.e.lZ., ....~J.! .~J<
, ~~~~~.
~)f~1 .J? ~YV~ ...rua~~~'1
Jdl~;tfuo. W .qv~,-<>-e-e.. c<>-<<~ cJ2/kHJ-.........
5',
25'
'"
t""'I
;;P~~':' .-d?ov~ f"" ~
.~.
v -' (',"
~,,~~
/l . '. II. ~"..JU,'f"6AlR.
5 \8 'Vw'. . ~L~~
~~, PA \'"104'3
(717) 7(p~40'A~
cf)~ ; 10- ~1-~5
G.
~
,...,
V4~~'
\1 ~~ H. \l1~ ~ ~..utl ,Jd--~
~"'" .;I.RJ";t~4o-'~' -~ \
A.--t' ;t.~ tfl;4 oM ;;bt~,-,1. ~ -c-v-Nu~ ..t;
;te.P- ~ ~ ~~ ~~-Q.-.9.~ 1
. .,vf~~~'~~
~ -f'::!W. ~..t.. ~ '':'
~ ~~.J.tJ ~ -;:-~4 -of
'8 fa., C. :,. j .4-~~4 ~~ .Id .A--V"~
f " t(, ,
~ ~. \'\II.J.'\'
cB~:IO-~7~95
. . , .
._~i."'"
""
f"t
.
_~~ "-f ~~CJl
~~ '. I( 'w\~,r~' b
~~~~:::;
~ 1.A~~ J.~ Yy1~J~
~, (~cQ J ~) ';lR,Jl
~ .~:
.~61,~,E:r
""'.c. ~ ,~~ ~ ~~
100 fiJ~ .~.u;f
9 ~, ~\..c.0- 'I w <D
I'" . I PA 1'7 '08-1l~~
tJ~: \D.~~-9S
l'
,..,
p/7/'1S
--
VR.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
95.44R6 CIVIL TERM
STERLING K. MOLL,
Pllllnttrf
VICKI JO ERDMAN,
Defemlllnt
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
IN RE: DEFENDANT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO THE COMPLAINT
BEFORE BAYLEY AND HESS. JJ.
ORDER
AND NOW,thls
day of December, 1995. l\ IIppearlng thllt service of the
complaint was not made according to Rule, the preliminary objection of the defendanl. In this
regard. Is SUSTAINED. The within action is DISMISSED.
BY THE COURT,
K~t~~~f-
Sterling K. Moll. Pro Se ", ,...ld (o~/"1 p' r, 'I J /
SIR North Second Street
Wurmleysburg,PA 17lJ43
Mlehllel R. Kelley. Esquire ,......;4<( '~'I'~ I;) i 0'
Fur the Defendllnt
:rlm
~ Q\
~ ;
1t1 ~
.~ Po
~ r-
n. ,
1..-'
W I.IJ
r": ~,
\!5 ~
'e;
%: .
<,
"
~,
-'\
~~~.
I, I
'd
r.U m
l.,
a
.1"')
f"\
o.n
r:n
-
~..."-
-, r
.',
.7":")
.-.1
0-
"
=
..,'
-'
----
.
.'
~
IILf/f~
f""',
~eff~ ..W>~
~f I~
,...g 'Y1c. 95 - 4- 4- B (; ~ :) .aJWV\
No. ~.3 Hh<}. N qc,
V~~~
:r>~
~~f~
K.m~~:-~~~
~ **-k:':e~~~ ....O~.
. ~~~~~~ ~
~ih. ~of"'~11995,J~~
~ ~~~.tB.R. .~~~
~~~i~~~
~ . K.'w\~
,Ste'4'/i "~ 1(. 0 II) F"'o se.
518~~.~
I PA ''1043
Phohe,' (711) 7G - 40R~
3(l
,
f
j
I
o'
.
f"t
~
- .
STERLlNO K. MOlL,
Plaintiff
.- .
VI.
IN mE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
95.4486 CIVIL TERM
VICKI JO ERDMAN.
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
IN RE: DEFENDANT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO TIlE COMPLAINT
BEFORE BAYLEY AND HESS. JJ.
ORDER
AND NOW, Ihls
l'
day of December, 1995, It appearing that service of the
compialnt wu not made according to Rule, the preliminary objection of the defendant, in this
regard. Is SUSTAINED. The within action is DISMISSED.
BY TIlE COURT,
. AIL
j Sterling K. Moll, Pro Se
518 North Second Street
Wormleysbura. PA 17043
Michael R. Kelley, Esquire
For the Defendant
:rlm
--:-,...,: P,......" _,......"..,... ....'......,
'."t,. ;,'.., . .
In T:Jill.'. j'" .'
anll \Ii~ :MIl (Ij ~;,.:. .,. ., I ...
This 'J~~-;,day ()f.~ lH'(
~. c.. ""-.,4'~L~ 6~~ .
.
Prolhonotary
. .
.
~
f".
o
~ ~f.A>~
~~~(9(~
,:\, ~~.m~/fM-4.R.I~~
~ ~ ~ ~<1f ,199(;;, ~~
~~'~O(~of ~
~.~ ~U~.~'MJ)
~~~J
.(. : 7" ~,~#-.
m~~,~
me~,1.kOed~ ,~
loojJJ~~
f4>. G. ~ II <0"
IT . ,PA 17108 - IIGt;
~G.)J: ~ ~a.W~
Crwvt- .
~~
Judge A..ignedl
Judgment I
HESS KEVIN A
.00
superior Co
Execution Date
sat/Dill/G(ltd. .
Jury Trial.,..
0/00/00
0/00/00
.
PY8510
lU5-04486
Cumbe~nd county prothonotary'lI affice page 1
~ivil Call& Inquiry ~
PETITION Filed....,...,
B/U{U
................................................................................
General Index Attorney Info
~R&""ftT~V~~~GJ~ &~~~~Ag~~~ ~n~EB~NBERG HARVEY
..................................................~~~~~Y.~l~~~~~.~..............
. Date Entriell ·
...............................................................................*
il/t~/li PETITION TO RECOVER VEHICLE DAMAGES
IMPORTANT NOTICE FILED
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
~ ~ PRAiCIPE FOR ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FOR DEFENDANT BY HARVEY
FRE ~ENBERG ESa AND MICHAEL R KELLEY ES~
~l/~I'~/li DH DANT'S PRELIMINARI OBJECTIONS TO P INTIFF'S COMPLAINT
P IPE FOR LISTING C SE FOR ARGUMENT MICHAEL R KELLEY ESQ
P I~IFFIS REPLY TO DEFENDANTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO
12/07/95 gRDI !F&~'E50~~~~~V8 ~O~;PLA~N~EFENDANT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
TO T E COMPLAINT - SUSTAI ED - WITHIN ACTION DISMISSED - BY KEVIN A
HESS J - COPIES MAILED 12 B/95
.............**...*.............................................................
* Ellcrow Informat~on ·
* r... , Debitll Bea Bal Pvmtll/Ad End Bal *
..........*..............................,...... ...........*...................
~UI6~0'ETITION
!~r~IIENT
3iJl
35:g8
g:88
~n
45,50 45.50 .00
.............**.......................*.........*...............*...............
* End of Calle Information ·
....................*...........................................................
------------------------ ------------
,
33
~"'. ,.
(.)~~
I'...;: ~
f):, j
:' .,',)
" .
. .:.-_1
,,'Ii",!
I' I C~..
ti
()
,J
:)-
t/'l~
ri\
n!'l'
. 1"\
~ ~i
. ~ J.
~
r;)
o
o
f()
~
i? \0
.. l[I
0",
l-'~ ..
.....0 -
-
I);'; .....
\t-U ".:
~~ i'~
liL' .. ~l'
G1'
l'L .
t;:1'1 .'
1'- .,'
.. -/
\<. .~
0 (.1\
'-
\-::
,
-....)
--
,.
1;7/'1(,
'" f"',
superi0r Court of Pennsylvania
Office of the prothonotary
434 Main Capitol Building
P.O. Box 9300
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17108
(717) 772-1294
January 11, 1996
Notice of Appeal Docketing
superior Court Docket No. Assigned
00023H8096
Nil. qJ - '1'1 ire. t!~<<t 1'J.,\.+....
PROTHONOTARY
Cumberland COUNTY
Cumberland Cty. Courthouse
Carlisle, Pa 17013
REI Moll, S V Erdman, V
You are hereby advised that the attached docket
information has been entered into the superior court records
in a case in which you appear as an officer of the court.
Please review this information carefully and notify this
office immediately if you believe correction(s) are in order.
Thank you.
David A. Szewczak
prothonotary
p . ,; n
:.., t~ \ "
"j"";\.! . )
t \." ,. .,i:""
." ~. I ,'~
~: ~ ;:.
: " ~I
, .
t. ; lel
-' :~;': ;:U
;
(..., ..~. :,.}; l
:.( I ~~j (jl"i"l
. "c.W
.." l,l
::1 - .~
"
....
.~'f
.
"'""'
,......
01/11/96
1633
SUPERIOR COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
OFFICIAL DOCKET
DOCKET # 00023HBG96
FULL CAPTION
001T STERLING K MOLL
V
002E VICKI JO ERDMAN
COUNSEL TITLE FOR MAIL
Y0474 STERLING K MOLL PRO SE 001T Y
518 NORTH SECOND STREET
WORMLESYBURG, PA 17043 717-763-4022
58854 MICHAEL R KELLY 002E Y
100 PINE STREET
PO BOX 1166
HARRISBURG, PA 17108-1166 717-232-8000
CONSOLIDATED DOCKET NUMBER
BACKGROUND DATA
TRIAL COURT RECORDS
CATEGORY:
COURT NAME:
COUNTY:
JUDICIAL DISTRICT:
CASE TYPE/CHARGE:
TRIAL COURT CHARGES:
JUDGE (S) :
DISPOSITION TYPE:
DISPOSITION DATE:
APPEAL FILE DATE:
DISPOSITION ENTERED:
TRIAL CRT DOCKET NO.:
OFFENSE TRACKING NO. :
STATUS INFORMATION
01/24/96 DOCKETING STATEMENT DUE
02/13/96 LOWER COURT RECORD DUE
CV
CIVIL
CUMBERLAND
09
CIVIL ACTION - COMPLAINT
HESS, K
ORDER ENTERED
12/07/95
01/04/96
95-4486 CIVIL
DOCKET ENTRIES
01/10/96 NOTICE OF APPEAL
01/10/96 DOCKETING STATEMENT EXITED
FOR
001T
001T
TaAPPELLANT EaAPPELLEE
*aCOURT APPOINTED
3,1)
. ."""
.~
,-..' ...
."",'
.J.~,...;_ ,. ,_.:.-.
~
,..,
II.J.o/q,
STERLING K. MOI.L,
l'IIIlnllff
INTI III cOUln 011 COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMJI\!IUANI) COUNTY, I'ENNSYLVANIA
1)~.44Kfl CIVIL TllI\M
VS.
VICKI JO I!Rl>MAN,
Dcfendlllll
CIVIL ACnON. LAW
IN RI!: OI'INION l'UI\SlJANT TO RULE 1925
Thilll II calc 1IIIIInlluIII nf IIl11u\III vehicle IlceldenllhaluCC\lrred In July of 1994.
Plaintiff II IlrIlC4)cdlllll pm Ie. I Ie 1IIIIIalelllhllllelluII wllh a plelldlnll which he called a
"I'ellllun." 1111 elellrly, hllwever, IlIlellded Iu he II enlllpllllnl. Of slllnlfieancc 10 our dlsJ10slllun
wal Ihe faellhallhe "petlllulI" Will lIullerved IlIlIccmdllncc wllh Ihe provlllons of I'II.R.C.P. 402.
11111 rule Jlfllvldcllhal slleh lervlcc (normlllly hy Ihe Sherif!) mllY be accomplished by hand1lllla
C41J1)' nf II C41mJllalnllolhe defendalll, or hy handlnt II CUJ1)' 10lln IIdull member uf Ihe family
wllh whu", Ihe defendllnl rClldcl, ur In Ihe dcfcndllnl's IIl1enlllllhe defendanl'l rellutllr placc uf
hllllnell. In Ihll ellie, lervlce nl' orlllllllll prnccIK was by ordinary mall.
The Rlllel ul' Clvlll'ruecdllre permlllhe eUllrllu dlsrellard "IIny error or defeel or
JlIlIC41dllrC which lIuel lIulllllcellhe SllhS\1I1111111 rlllhlS ul' Ihc parlles." Pa.R.C.P. 126 On Ihe
ulher IIIIIlIl, Ills well cSlllhlllhed Ihlll, liS III lervlce ul' procclI, Ihc rulcs musl be IIdhered 10
I\rlelly IInd "jurlldlellullul' Ihe cnurluver Ihe pcrsullul' Ihe defendanlls dependenl upon proper
service 11I1V11I1l beelllllllde." Shllrp v. Vlllley Fur~c Mclllelll Cenler IInd Hellrllfuspllatlne.. 422
1'11, 124, 127,221 A.2d IK~, IK7 (1%6). Fur Ihls rellSlln, we 8uslllllled Ihe prellminllry ohjeelions
lit' Ihe dcl'ellllllllllll\lllllsllIlshelllhe IIclllln.
ThoUllh ncllher IllIrl)' culled the ellse IlIuur IIttellllun, we lire lire slIllsl1ellllmllhis mlltter
Is t'llnlrnlll'lI hy E!)'I'klurlll v, Wny, 4\11I'II.SlIper. 347, ~I)I) A.2111332 (11)1)1). Fryeklunll eonl1rms
Ihlll we WI'II' clltrccl III suslllllllnlllhe prellmlnllry IIbjeellons bllsed un InvlIlIll service. The cnse
\..\;
3~
. ,.,.
"! '
~
""
goeR on to provide, however, thatlhe Impact of our order Rhould have been to set aside service
liS opposed to dlRmisaal of Ihe IIctlon. Thus, when we once again hllve jurisdiction of this case
and proper service has been effected, this nction mny proceed.
January..(,( 1996
K:t.~.f J..
Sterling Moll, Pro Se
SIR North Seamd Street
Wormleysburg, PA 17043
Michael R. Kelley, Esquire
For the Defendant
;I
, . " I "I'll.-
L'ud'U'.' r"'-'l~lt,L I :l.,~ , .
p. r.
:rlm
,,.,,
"'"""
~.
~,
1"'1 u~"r':'in:
, 1.-'"
"'~.I'
..;1
f'f' ,..,1'} ,
r" J. I I. ~I
"ll 1'1
1.'1 I ,I
.~'1 ! , ' . ," I' 1 ,-'"
\"li, I.", \._-...'....'11
I .. \ \','_'1
. ~:' ~l 1 ,J I I ,r ~ I;; \
~~.<.,.,",. "."
',... .....:.... ....,... ...... ..............':,. .,.... '.;"'... '.";':.'-";" ":".'
~'~~~~~~~b{.JJ'a~.,j:t'!11i'JJC~:i;:"irn,,*;_;~~~~~.-_.~../<,...~'t"'~-~"'-c"".
STERLING K. MOLL,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 4486 CIVIL 1995
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
v.
VICKI JO ERDMAN,
Defendant
pRAECIPE
TO THE PROmONOTAllY:
Kindly file this Praecipe, which hu attached to It a copy of the check which wu luued to the
Plaintiff In this matter.
Respectfully submitted,
GOLDBERG, KATZMAN Ii; SHIPMAN. P.C.
By, .~ tl.flt.~
John , inos y, Esquire
Attorney J. D. No. 78000
320 Market Street
P.O. Box 1268
Harrisburg. P A \71 08-1268
Telephone: (717) 234-4161
DATE: S(J'1 (00
Attorney for Defendant
(
1".11I11I11I,".1..1..11.,1,1,1
STERL I NO A "OLL
518 N SECONO ST
WOR"LEYSBURO PA 170~3
InNw: ERIE INSURANCE EXCHANGE
PolIoyNo.: QOI 0405402
CIIIm No.: 0101701_
Date ofLoee: 07-...,...
CMllk Mo.: IIMO'"
CMllkAmL: '71..
For:. F1NALPAVMENT \
, PROPERTY DAMAGE UABIUlY
,
ErillnIUCII1Ce oIln home, auto, buINM IIId 1fI1nIInnce.
Cd vour local ERIE A4Ienl to INm ...lIavr.r.....1n ytlII'_.
N"O Baa ~a ~II' 1:0" BOO? :l81: Ii ~O ~ SQ8liOOIl"
Sterlina K. Moll
518 North Second Street
Wonnleyabura, PA 17043
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
il.
~-
\
.
"
I HEREBY CERTIFY thlt I Krved I tNe and correct copy of the foregolna
document upon all counlel ofrecord by depolltlng the 81me in the United Stltel Mill, firlt CIIIS,
poltqe prepaid, It Harrisburg, Pennlylvanil, on the I I ( dlY of /:r.. I . 1998,
addrelacd u followl: I
f
L
"-
OOLDBERG, KATZMAN" SHIPMAN, P.C.
/7 / // I J,/,
By Jot ~~~.Jask~:r~~Qilitfu
1.0. N78000
320 Market Street
P,O. Box 1268
Harrisburg, PA 17108.1268
(717) 2]4.4161
Counsel for Plaintiff
~ C:l ".
-:~ ..:J r
I' :~.:; .. '_.-
N I.
,
k:' .. :
(.'.....
(-I' '.
, , ~n , I
r'l ,
j' 1; ~.J 1
r. , I I'
.. d L.
i- ~\. - .
" .-, ..,
C) I~~) U