HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-04801
."
'\ .--..~.j;.1;
'..
. .".
,
,
STEPHEN G, AND WALTER G,
CUNNINGHAM
Plaintiffs
v,
SCHNEIDER NATIONAL
and
CHARLES HOLMES
Defendants
NOT ICE
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTV, PENNSVLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO, 7!) 1 3d (II ("le '~)llll'-
YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend
against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must
take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and
Notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or
by attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defenses or
objections to the claims set forth against you, You are warned
that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a
judgment may be entered againet you by the court without further
notice for any money olaimed in the complaint or for any other
claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff, YOU may lose money
or property or other rights important to you,
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWVER AT ONCE, IF YOU
DO NOT HAVE A LAWVER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE
OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP,
court Administrator
4th Floor, cumberland County courthouse
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 240-6200
STEPHEN G. and WALTER G,
CUNNINGHAM
548 N. Allison Street
Greencastle, PA 17225-1214
Plaintiffs
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
v,
NO.
SCHNEIDER NATIONAL
One Schneider Drive
Carliale, PA 17013
and
CHARLES HOLMES
P.O. Box 21
Pentress, WV 26544
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
COMPLaINT
1. Plaintiffs, stephen G. and Walter G. Cunningham, are adult
individuals who reside at 548 N. Allison street, Greencastle,
Franklin County, rennsylvania 17225.
2. Defendant, schneider National, is a business entity with
its principal place of business in Green Bay, Wisconsin, and its
local businees address at One Schneider Drive, Carlisle, Cumberland
County, PA 17013.
3. Defendant, Charles Holmes, is an adult individual who
resides at P.O. Box 21, Pentress, WV 26544,
4. This action concerns an automobile collision that
occurred on September 13, 1993, at approximately 2:00 p,m., in
Franklin county, Pennsylvania.
5, At the above-referenced time, Defendant Charles Holmes
was operating a 1992 International Trailer which it is believed to
be owned by Defendant Schneider National.
1
,
6. At the above-referenced date and time, Defendant Holmee
oOllided with a .1.990 Pickup Truck Owned by Plaintiff Stephen G.
CUnningham and driven by Plaintiff Walter G. Cunningham. Thie
acUon ooourred on Route 11 South of Chambereburg, Franklin County,
Pennsylvania.
7. Plaintiff Walter G, Cunningham was travelling southbound
on US 11.
8. Dafendant Holmes Wda Eastbound and stopped at a stop sign
on Loop Road at the intersection of US 11 waiting to turn left.
g. Defendant HOlmee proceeded into the intersection attempting
to mike I left turn direotly in the path of Plaintiff Cunningham's
vehiCle thereby COlliding with Plaintiffs vehiCle.
10. Seid collision oaused damage to Plaintiff's vehicle in an
amount of One Thousand Seven Hundred Six DOllars and Thirty Two
Centa ($1,706.32) in property damage to said vehicle. (A true alld
correct repair invoice is attached hereto as Exhibit A).
COI1N'1' I
STEPHIM o. ~IHOHAH V. CHARLES HOLHES
11 . Paragraphs 1 through 10 are incorporated herein by
reference.
12. The negligence, carelessness, and recklessness of
Defendant Charles Holmes consisted of the fOllOWing:
2
(a) failure to yield right of way ee required by 75 Pe C.S.A,
Sec. 3323(b);
(b) failure to yield right of way to approaching vehicles on
U.S. Route 11 as required by 75 pa C.S,A, Sec. 3324;
(c) failure to be attentive to the traffic conditions thsre
and then existing;
(d) failure to drive in sefe and reasonable manner;
(e) being inattentive;
WHEREFORE, Pleintiffs Stephen G. and Walter G. Cunningham
demand judgment in their favor and against Defendant Charles Holmes
int he amount of One Thoueand Seven Hundred Six Dollars and Thirty
Two cents ($1,706.32), plus interest and costs of suit,
COUNT II
STEPHEN CUNNINGHAM V. SCHNEIDER NATIONAL
13. Paragraphs 1 through 12 are incorporated herein by
reference.
14. Defendant Schneider National is liable to Plaintiff for
damages as alleged herein which were directly and effectively
caused by their negligent, careless and reckless conduct which
consisted of the following:
(a) negligently entrusting their 1992 International Trailer
to Defendant Charles Holmss;
3
(b) allowing Defendant Holmes to operate said vehiole with
knowledge, oonstruotive or aotual that Defendant Charles Holmes
would operate said vehiole in a oareless or reokless manner.
15. An agenoy relationship wae oreated when the Defendant
Sohneider National as prinoipal, provided their vehiole to
Defendant Charles Holmes,
16. Defendant
Sohneider National,
prinoipal,
is
as
vicariously liable for the property damage suffered by plaintiff
oaueed by Defendant Charles Holmes.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff stephen Cunningham demands judgment
against Defsndant Schneider National in an amount of One Thousand
Seven Hundred Six Dollars and Thirty Two Cents ($1,706.32), plUS
interest and costs of suit.
Respectfully submitted,
TOS & ZONARICH; ~
.~~~~
J h R, Zonaric quire
~D 19632
~O state street
N rrisburg, PA 17101
717/233-1000
Attorney for Plaintiffs
DATE:
~F)
4
~'AU: ~~.'Z:l~J ~'~;I~O i ,.,
hUute 10: ~eJre~03~lCllme:':1
COIlltteij
Prehle 10: HAil :e
IIAllOII~IOE lI"URAlltt CO~fAIIY
1\\ S, elH, SlltET SUllt lC~ CH~~EIe8UR', fA IllOI
<1l11 lt3- 3tSe
Oele91 Allel.IO ~,: ICHY CtfRAHCESCU
liFl of lm: Cellllle.
Pellcv NUlbtr: 8SKlfELS
OlMtlbl,: 100,00
1.luncI: eTEPIO clHUlIlWI
Addr",: ~B N M.LIBOt BI CIWIERSBIJI' PA mOl
Hall Pho.l: (717) m-3'l31
ftlttl1ll1 8Ir.lce: 91~IS~
Ollcri~tl": IS90 CHtUROLEI C StR 2~ PICKUP
VIH: I'CGC2IK6LEI33SSe
HlllI.e: 10e,SlO
UCI.II: YS86e6S1 PA
otIllRLT: A
Sllrch C,de: fRAH
LUll t.trv Lebor Utili.. Pert TVPII Ooll.r Lebar
1111 tbiIW hiL Coarltiel\ ~lIcrlctl'O rift Nu.t;.r 6!W1- lln1.L
I MlTO BOOY llVERlWA. rR1 BUllrER ASSY 1.2
. ~T90 BOOY REf'l1',{/RtflACt fit IUI'ItR fACt eAR Ht~ ItUO' lIltl
.
3 soot30 IOOY R[lOl[IREPLI(( rR1 BUllfER IIfRCT eTRlP ISS71111 GH PART IS,2S IHCL
I ~Ol~ BOOY ,[HOU(IREPLACt L fRT tuHPER BRAct llSIOm ~H PART 1:,80 l!Y.l
5 ~OIITO 100Y RtHO'JEllEPLflCE GRILLt 1\6IS110 GH PART m,OO 0,8
t 501&40 800Y Rt~~IItPlACt GRILLt EHeLEH IS~30e3t GH PARI 11,65 IHCl
7 SOl110 100Y REPAIR ."ILLE FILLER PANEL 0,5'
B tI03liO BOOY REl'Il'J[lREPlACE HOllO PNlEl II 16-6H02 173 ,00 O,B
S AUTO RmN aEflH1Sll IfllOO OUTSIDE 3.:
10 MlTO R[fIN REfINISH HOOO UtfJERS10E l,t
11 tlOBSO BIIOY REHllVEllEPLACE L stRIPE TAPE fElltlER Ol.OER fROlI OEAlER IUS 0.2
t: 510Bl0 BIlOY REllOVtlREPLACt L slmE TAPE DOOR OROER r.O" DEALER 1',=' ' ,
13 511100 BOOY !EHO\IEIREPLACE 1 fEHOER PAIlEL 15616621 ~H PARt 103,33 L:
I~ AUTO REflN REflHISlI L fENOER OUTSIDE C 2.~
IS AUTO REFIN aEflNIBN L WIlER EO'E , lM1IDE 1.0
18 GI5MO IfCH ALIGN fROOT SUSrEHSllJl 'H Ll
11 900Soo lOllY .REIllWIHSTM.L .RBI IILOO9 0,1'
IB 521130 BOOY REHOV{IRtPLACE ~IEHIELO WASHER RESERVOIR 11073\31 'H PART 2~,tO 1,~
19 G1BllO 100Y RE"il'JE/IEPLACE L OIR CAD COWL VENI UCREtH 156\531S roH PART loGl ',,3
10 533250 BOOY REPAIR .L fR1 DOOR SHELl. 1.3'
11 AU10 REfIH RErtHISH L fR1 DOOR OUTSlot: C 2.3
II AUtO RtflH ADO'L LABOR CPR TWO TCtIE l.I
13 S3liQl7 r.llD'L C09T HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL 3.00.
:\ AutO ADO'L COSl PAIHI !lA1ERIALS 151,30'
. Jildg....t I tel
II Quality R!plmll.t hrtl
( l.eludeO I. t.a late e.lc
ElUIlI\lT ^
fcllMtE mALL HU!ltER: Gilll/93 Il:03:3& mmomeOSl3'30l
'1lchell o.te ~erll..: ~EP.l3JI (r.Plrloht (Cl I~OO, nltthelllroter..tlao.1
All RloMI Rem'ld
P.g. l:f
'(lBTONE AUT~'OII~E
;;CO RCOSl:VEll A:Jt:
IORK
fA 1710\.0000
.eOOl \l4'\:Jl1 \117) 1l43.em
'l: le.B2'S02 113,00
.~t/l: ,'. ::..'~~ :~;'q' ;,"!,
!stllUI! 10: ~,j7fr.O;t:8C~I:S~',~1
:11 lit'"
":I::t. i:: .. ~'I :~
~
lHJfl tGXl Ilffij
I. labGr Subtatlll
ea~y
Refl.llh
"echa.lcll
l!ill.I ...!W....1ll.ll1
1,1 :1,00 IlO,~
::.1 .. ~ .co J~9 ,eo
I. ~ :: ,co 47.CO
l.tor 5.01etll ;es,20
L.bar h.. U~l ~!,11
l.bar ",nary loti" 10,9 (:0,11
II. ParI IIplam"t '.I..ry
IUltll Peril
~.lu ra, . ~ .~~,
r,ul ..pl.cm.t rifts .lou.l:
~.aunt
109.83
\7,33
031.2Z
Ill, Ad,ltlonal C;III
r moll Co all
Salla I.. ~ E,eCI
latll Addltla'lI Cem:
~:r.u;..r,t
:CQ,Jl
~.tl
1E9.92
:. !~ul Latl1r;
11, lolal R.plm...t ram:
Ill, I;tal Addlll;r.al COllI:
t:Z'.\.31
5J1.~Z
IB9,91
\roll ratal:
I,m,.!
CUltoAr Allowa.cl:
0,00
~ij\tom Rupmlblllt,:
100,00.
,,,t lelll:
11~Z7 .~t
!HIS IE All ESmA![ OI~Y AliD IlOr All AutHORI1AllOfl ro WAll,
AOOlllOfl!L pmEHI Ylll BE HAOE OlllY YlTH Al'PROIIAl PRIOR 10 mAtI,
I
11101' CIIOICE: WIU
'Ill AOVIIE
(::fIPIlIIY EummO
I
A COfY Cf !lil! S:TI~ArE ~~9 l[lt UlTH CwhER OR OUI'ER'S HfREEEhlAIl':E.
:l~ .\~
GARReE AGREE"Elll: ~E AGREE 10 mAlR AlIO GUARAJjIEE UOhHANSIIIP fOI THE
PIICE WllICAIEO,
liME:
.....................................................................-..................................
I
lOCI! SS:, ............ ........ ...,.... ........ .........................
... HOlICE l, CIIIlEI: mSENI M5 fSlIMIE 10 IARm iEFCIE /[fAIRS
AIlE Et:IU/j, In
I
AOMIER'S m:IMUIF...~) \.~h..').'..::.....'!!!'.:.......
E51IMTE REC!Lll/JIlm: 09122"" 17:CO:Ot \SmSmlOCmml
~Ite~ell OaU Vernor.: stP.91,N ,;:,f\,',1 (\llil0, !It't,elllr,lmltl~r.a1
;oil il,MI 'ellfVIl
fa;. ;:t
"OVERAGE CR LLAIMAN1
,Il ~i':- E
1o"I)(N1
~. ~ \' 1 i'll
l.lt!,j~SlMl'll
_ .!:,S
..,....~
,~
'''N~-'
"
t';~:{)N~illAbl ;~ ll~!
'FlNSE
.\1t.l~,,1
(lll.;lIlllE
U...llURSEt.\ENl
~'J
',.I)~" T
"
58- 427830
~,\"I)ANI
.,__e_ ."
. - . - .-... . . .
,1.'1)11""
.
. . . .
"oWN!
. 0
. ._~.~. ' .! Ul,tPAhl
,lAmNI
r,\\\llM
.:.....",tll
'IAl
Nt~NO t.IAI\IlE
105S
_, lnc~101 --
~:" : "\-,",0' ""'''''..~=::::: :]""",=-~::co::::c::::,,""""L=:~---"'O-
\ ( ? I'";. .., \ I~ L:.'c':;--,~-~ ::...___-_.:.~::..~.::.:~- ,;../ __--0-,"--'-'-"'d'}.'\-
. .
-AI'oE
- .'~- .=.:.~.-- .-~
, .
...;..::_.-..~ r
'AANOf.lMlllil
_:;S
"l:A1lON
,.n"SltllO
,\,fVPAl':)Al
'''\lJtJ~llR
'MUtuA
",,,"I
At
! lAiMA.tl1
',NAt
'"
...P....
t'YPf. nNnI
_,:L.-c1 UISS 0--'" l11\I"'IN!
(
" {\l1Ilf
~0GA1~1V[IN ~SIA11
: tolAlI v<<n
,RGEMIlf _rJ p~RnAl lOSS -.p WEUS lOSI
5 \ nFlN5f
.Sf _. j ~I1ORNty ----' rOO[
'I;[
REHAB
.--l \tlOOC~lOR
1,llSC
__e--'. :,\,lA
~ f~Rll~t ___
"l51
IIAlS
,10-1_ .IHI
f~ :-.---
AGENl
tfJMflR -. . .---.----.--
2'
._.-+-~c..-+-_.-.'-.~-
l~ISSN
IN__-
fOR
,;LAIM
'~r[ "f
nnll/IN!
MI,t.til
! .~"
I l' hl
0-
,NlENSIIlD
, AppAAlSAl -
, REHAB
-1 ::lOR -"
_.__----4 o~tA
,IIURllliA1KIN
~i,~Nt ,',
,ntll
,tAIL
, 10l~li M'fI.'
t----l p~RnAl lOSS ---1 WEE'S lOSl
, OPENSE
_JOO!
_~ OI~RI'l~8l(
lOSS
. __. CAuSE .,_ ._e---'
-
~ IICRNLY
11)'l0-"!J
: O'lll~l
,,~\ -----
,,)t~l ~r.I(]\lNl ' ---0
N11HlllD ~t,OJNl --'
'~El ..MOONt --..--. &
.
. . t
I . t
. . .
!ill
.Aj lVl~
1
~~ '
-
7 'i. ~ 7
~
'<-~
,0'" "l-d.':':>
"'; l~ ,--"t:" ...
(: ,wH- j~l'." 'l.,
-
-,
:..:.~TC.. 14...
;:,~I'/ .:.f.....c. ,,~J'" ;;'-r'-'" ~ .::.....",/:').,.
.. L,. '(.
,~....' . .~--_.,...
"ll f:.(')
Vl~, ~. ,....~ ',,",, ,.:.:) ,,,...1 (.~...
AOOVE CI1fll( COVERS ITlMS INDICAtED
\~,
01
o -4
CJR
'--1
l__ .1
._--------,----
Hill 1'~1l1I/lL'
I'f<VMENl I IV.VMENI \
,__~_~_--_r---.-~------1 r,1II ",{.,I V...,.'It.
1 ~ll,!iil--'-~.(lt..t
":'l,-~."
.
'\ ~, . ...:-:- -
.
l.~'-'-" ~
- -,
__--...---.--------- ---1
I fULL p~llllAL'
I 1'f<~MENl p~VMENI. ,..."., I" W'htwld
,-----'-- -~----~ '''''...'''...'''''...-
rot r,,~rnlll~
_IOOVO
,---.-.-
, "
-.............J1---- --
__; lu,l '1#."II!" flOm
, tll\ll t:'I.:.I'I."'1
__. t.1f ~lIV~,I''' ,~,,,.fetJ 10
---~~--- ..'
-
----_,__--1--..-.
i
"-1 rut I" ''''IJIM1.111lI'Uf H.'ilI P11'(~,II,.
\ 1..10." ^ _ ~___, --~- llo'tl
-.....-.---
_. tNw.l_____
to. ~_ _____.- .____-~ 1.!Il....~)Il..ill,I..)...ll4...I,t..."I--,I\
!.ll....t\-..lI l.l~" ~
i In. ''''f',Il",I' "~,,t..,.
ll"'!jltll-lllt"l.~.q,~
---.- ...
. _..--~-
__~..___.t._.._-- "
,,'1
1,-"
.. t"'IMJ,I.t1' \>lif. only 1
--
VERIFICATION
Subjeot to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S, 54904 relating
to unsworn falsifioation to authorities, I, John R. Zonarioh,
Esquire, deolare that I am an attorney for the Plaintiffs stephen
G, and Walter G, Cunningham: that I am authorized to make this
Verification on their behalf: that the facts set forth in the
foregoing Complaint based upon information supplied to me by my
client, which I believe to be true and correct, and time is of the
essence.
Dated: 9- h - 1.r-
!l
d
11'-."-,,,-." '~.'.C--"'.'.. ~.--
STEPHEN G, and WALTER G,
CUNNINGHAM
548 N. Allison street
Greenc8stle, PA 17225-1214
Plaintiffs
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA
NO, 95 - 4801
v,
SCHNEIDER NATIONAL
One Schneider Drive
Carlisle, PA 17013
and
CHARLES HOLMES
P,O. BOK 21
Pentress, WV 26544
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
PRAECIPE TO SETTLE AND DISCONTINUE
Please mark the above-captioned matter, settled , satisfied
and discontinued as to all Defendants, with prejudice.
Respeotfully submitted,
ATOS & ZONARICH
. Zonar!
19632
2 state street
arrisburg, PA 17101
717/233-1000
Attorney for Plaintiffe
DATE: /01/9/95
1