The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About95-04977 .. -, .. . I" . . JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 4977 CIVIL 1995 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED v. J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant eBB.'J'R1AL MEMORANDVM I. fACTS AS TO LIABILITY. On January 26, 1994 at approximately 6:30 p.m., Mrs. Kauffman fell as a result of what she subsequently learned was a wet floor resulting in injuries. The accident happened inside the catalog department ofthe J.C. Penney's store in Carlisle. The floor was linoleum tile and naturally slippery when wet. The Defendant had area carpet mats to eliminate this dangerous and slippery condition and had wet floor signs to warn customers of the slippery condition. however, the Defendant failed to use any of these items on January 26 when Mrs. Kauffman fell, The merchandise manager, Jennifer Ahrens, filled out an accident report contemporaneously with the happening of the accident stating that there were water puddles in the area of the fall. Ahrens testified in deposition that there ._,~ ~ . ' . '. were no area carpet mats where the water was found and the Defendant had failed to put up any wet floor signs. The aecident report is attached aa Exhibit "A". II. FACTS AS 'cr> DAMAGES. When Mrs. Kauffman fell, she hit her head on the counter and fell hard to the floor. She injured her head, shoulder, back, hip and leg. Subsequent MRI study of the back showed that Mrs. Kauffman suffered a bulging/protruding disk. An MRI of her knee indicated a linear tear of the meniscus. Mrs. Kauffman missed over three months of work because of this accident and sustained lost wages in the amount of$3,673.27. Medical bills incurred total $3,087.76. Since this accident, Mrs. Kauffman haa had daily pain in her back and leg and takes extra-strength Tylenol daily. III. It is Plaintiffs position that liability is clear and the Plaintiff has suffered a permanent injury resulting in daily pain for over two years. ~ ',- / . . , IV. j&GAlJSSUES. Plaintiff has filed a Motion to Compel, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "8ft. The Plaintiff has filed a Request for Admissions, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "Cft. Plaintiff requests that the Defendant stipulate to medical bills and lost wages as set forth in the requests for admissions. Plaintiff reserves the right to take additional depositions when Defendant fully answers discovery. V. 1. Janet Kauffman; 2. Daniel P. Hely, M.D., treating orthopedic surgeon; 3. Jennifer Ahrens, employee of the Defendant; 4. Don Kraus, employee of the Defendant; 5, Joanne Largent, employee of the Defendant; .3. ", , f I I ! I I i 6. 7. Sarah Frye, employee of the Defendant; -friend of the Plaintiff on issue of damages; and 8. Witnesses listed by Defendant. VI. POTENTIAL EXHuu:m. 1, Accident report filled out by Jennifer Ahrens; 2, Photographs of accident scene; 3. Diagram of accident scene; 4. Medical records; 15. Deposition transcripts; 6. Medical bill summary; 7. Medical treatment summary; 8. Wage loss summary. VII. Plaintiffs initial demand in this case was $49,000 and the Defendant's initial offer was $13,000. After negotiating for a lengthy period of time, the Defendant offered $20,000 in settlement. The Plaintiff has substantially reduced her demand to $30,000. - .. - . , . . Tho Plaintiff is propared to accept $30,000 in full and final settlement of this caso, Respectfully submitted, METTE, EVANS & WOODSIDE BY: c;.::- -"(]=- ANDREW H. DOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Court I. D. No. 39692 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 Telephone: (717) 232-5000 Attorneys for Plaintiff DATED: June 13, 1996 ." ".".;....~.,.,.,.~,. ,..' ...".., G} , <( . ....." . 1, ExhIbIt A REPORT OF ACCIDENT (Customers and the Public) ~ 2. NAME OF INJURED PERSON: ~~ ;::1!/.I;.p.p~ , Age ~ Hom.Add..ss ~/p :JI.tvti~ ~UM5 _~ ,jIj~.~.~ Su.iness Addr...~SS 7;M~T: 1J..1VCrz. #,!,W}/ ~./~ r 3. NAME OF INJURED PERSON'S COMPANION. IF ANY:~- !52A NY~<; Addr... ~~. '];;. ~ &e~ T.l. No~9 ~'t:,3 4. CUSTOMERS, GUESTS OR PATRONS PRESENT: '~,-.. ~ -' -:. Addr.J~~ ~~ 'U. Addr... ~<I':;:- PI-;:Ii:Y 3 5. EMPLOYEE WITNESSES: (Compl.l. r.vers. .id. .,1 this r.porll Nom. & D.pt. ~.c Hom. Addr... Nome & Depl. r;;-;- 6. Date 01 Accid.nt 1/,;;(,/9 f 7. Addr.. Name , ~ Name Injured Perlan', Story 0 How "&'ccidenl Occurrt ~ 9, e.actlacotion 01 Accident III cau..d by a d.l.ct on the pr.mi.... or a product. 10, D..criptian 01 Accident advi.. 01 d.l.ct and ..plain cau.e il known: ~~#~~ ~UP~ 11. N~-r Addr... Of.tJ-.anulactur'Pr or Suppli.r 01 Product or Machine involved in Accid.nt AliI- ' 12, Notur. 01 Injury ~ I ~ 13, Where Token? Name..1 Dr. cr Hc.pitcl tA.€t.J~t..e 'fI!;<P. NO 15, II ncl, whc inlcrme~ ycu 01 ACcid.nt~~~ ~ W AfND~~ ~ 1 ~, 16. Addre.. cl Inlormant DcotiDn Imm.diol,ly after Attld.nt~~ 18. hact Tim 20. Dry?, ::j;,J'!1:~' '2.~r Puddl..? ~22, An Foreign Sub.tcnc.. cr Ob.tructicn.? 23, TypHIJl(JI:I;d!!1~":JJJf!:;Hj De.cribe Any. Delects_ Describe lighting cC1Emr-' 'cn. , .. Woo ";.,,, ''''0' W.o,'" ~ J iIII r.......-n<. 27, Who' Typ. Sha..? ~_ 28, Carrying Bundle. cr O,her Obiects' .m_ Did'Crowding Ccn'ribu'e \0 Accident? _ 25, EMPLOY 3d. Nom 36, Ho .oon afl~r accidenl did you in'~'T.1 locolion' 38, Dry? 39. Any Puddle.?,~~ dO. 41, Any def.cl.. _d2, De.cribe defecl. ,/"". . 43. .(5. 46. ,(7. .(9, . . * If Qu.slio , , EMPLOYEE'S REPORT SO. Nom. 51, Home Address 52. Haw soon ofter accide:1t did' you inspect locarion? 5.(. 'Dry? : 55. Any puddles? ~6. . Describe lighling ,57. Any defects? 58. De.cribe defects 53. Locolion clean? 59, Cu.tom.r wear glass..? 60, Type and condition of .ha.- 61. Any bundl..? 62. Where w.re you when accidenl occurred? 63. Did you ..e accid.nt? 64, If sa, deocrib. fully '65. Cu. lamer'. comments and aNilude * If Que.tion ~Ol Applifable. Answer N/A Signalure ' ~. . . ' " , MAINTENANCE REPORT (To be complel~d if injured person slipped or fell I 66, 68. 69, 71. 73, 74, 75, 76. 77. ,80, 81. NameJel.J1\J I~ ~ Are you respon.ible for mainlaining occidenllocation? If '0, deocribe your time sch.dule far cleaning location Time 10.1 dr....d Wh.n, before accident, did you 10,1 in.pectlocation? Describe its c'ondition Whe~ di~ yo'U Arst. in.~p ella' afler accidenl? I ULJ ~;;,,4..,~ Y Describe Its c;ondlhon ~ _ Was localion .claar\? 78. Dry? j4J1 79, Ligh1inO. Defecl. ? Remark. ? -----,-.-- . - :J-I.be: 72, Floor product u,.d ", ""'M'~.A .' ,;1 I ~ ,I : /, ... "OI,...,~ _n,.'. /0" "co',ln (!) . ~...iiIIt_"'.-t.."'.. <'..:.....'--...g.. ...<;,~""-1~,...__'__;0>,. I!lltlIbIt . l. ~ , . JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CML ACTION - LAW NO. 4977 CML 1995 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED v. (j \0 ~ c: C\ :.-. "00' t- .... C!.i(:) c: ..,.. ::: c'; :!I ~...' r- -',-' I ,m (jj.' . _.J :.:16 -;::. '') ~;" ::~ ,::, ~r' '~:a .. ::; .L. ;.~ "~~ :i>' .1 t:" ~:; .. ~ .. ~ -: \~ J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant MOTION TO COMPEL OF PLAINTIFF rURSUANT TO LOCAL RULE 4001-1 AND NOW, comes Plaintiff, JANET KAUFFMAN, by her attorneys, Mette, Evans & Woodside, and files this Motion to Compel pursuant to Local Rule 4001-1 based on the following: 1. The above-captioned case is a slip and fall that occurred in the J.C. Penney store in Carlisle, Pennsylvania on January 26, 1994. 2. On December 5, 1995 the Plaintiff served on the Defendant a Request for Production of Documents, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "A". 3. On March 15, 1996, Plaintiff filed a Motion to Compel because the Defendant failed to respond to Plaintiffs discovery request. A copy of the Motion to Compel is attached as Exhibit "Bn. 4, Pursuant to the Plaintiffs Motion, the Court signed an Order dated March 19, 1996, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "Cn, 5, On April 11, 1996, Plaintiff received Defendant's response to Plaintiffs Request for Production of Documents pursuant to the Court Order. 6. On June 6, 1996, Plaintiff took the deposition of Jennifer Ahrens, the merchandise manager of J.C. Penney store concerning an accident report she authored as a result of the Plaintiffs slip and fall. The deposition revealed that the accident report was inappropriately redacted by the Defendant before it was produced to the Plaintiff deleting crucial infonnation that this employee observed the day of the accident including defects discovered by the Defendant on the day of the accident and information concerning the lighting conditions. 7. During Ms. Ahrens' deposition, counsel for the Defendant stated on the record that items 24, 25, 29, 30, 40, 41 and 42 were redacted from the accident report. 8. The deposition of Ms. Ahrens and statements made by counsel for the Defendant during the deposition also revealed that there are other discoverable portions of the Defendant's claims file that has not been produced including statements taken of witnesses. 9. Plaintiff requests that the Defendant produce the entire investigative/claims file without redaction to the Court so the Court can properly decide the discoverable portions. 10. This is the second Motion to Compel that the Plaintiff was required to file incurring unnecessary expense and expending unnecessary time. 11. This case is listed for trial for the term commencing July 8, 1996. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requests this Court to enter an Order compelling the Defendant to produce the entire investigative/claims file to the Court at a discovery conference to resolve this matter. Respectfully submitted, METrE, EVANS & WOODSIDE BY: ~ '--- ANDREW H. DOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Court I. D. No. 39692 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 Telephone: (717) 232-5000 Attorneys for Plaintiff DATED: June 7, 1996 4.;:c>," EXHIBIT "A" .\ '; . - " - " ., " JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 95 - 4977. JURY TRIAL DEl\<IANDED v. J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant REQVEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS TO: Kathleen B. Gereaghty, Esquire Kelly, McLaughlin & Foster 1700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19102.5092 Pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. 4009, as amended, the Plaintiff, Janet Kauffman, by her attorneys, Mette, Evans & Woodside, requests you to produce copies of the following documents, at her expense, within thirty (30) days of service of this request. JlIl$TRUCTIONS If you object to the production of any document on the grounds that the attorney-client, attorney work product or any other privilege is applicable thereto, you shall, with respect to that document: (a) State its date; (b) Identify its author; (c) Identify each person who prepared or participated in the preparation of the document; (d) Identify each person who received it; (e) Identify each person from whom the document was received; (0 State the present location of the document and aU copies thereof; (g) Identify each person who bas ever had possession, custody or control of it or a copy thereof; and, ~ (h) Provide sufficient information concerning the document and the circumstances thereof to explain the claim of privilege and to permit the adjudication of the property of that claim. , ~ . DOCUMENTSREQUESTEQ 1. All statements, signed statements, transcripts of recorded statements or interviews of any person or witness relating to, referring to or describing any of the events described in the Complaint. 2. All expert opinions, (include experts resume or curriculum vitae) reports, summaries or other writings in your custody or control or your attorney or insurers, which relate to the subject matter of this litigation. 3. All documents, correspondence or other drawings, sketches, diagrams, or writings in your custody or control or your attorney or insurers, which relate to the subject matter of this litigation. 4. All documents prepared by you, or by any insurer, representative, agent, or anyone acting on your behalf, except your attorney(s), during the investigation of the incident in question or any of the events or allegations described in the Complaint. Such documents shall include any documents made or prepared up through the present time, with the exclusion of the mental impressions, conclusions, or the opinions respecting the value or merit of the claim or defense or respecting strategy or tactics. CORRECTION Previous Image Refilmed to Correct Possible Error . . . . 5. All photographs of any item or thing involved in this litigation. 6. All statements as defined within Pa. R.C.P. No. 4003. 7. All statements and/or transcripts of interviews of fact witnesses obtained in this matter. 8. All docwnents identified in your Answers to any set of Interrogatories propounded by any party in this litigation. 9. All docwnents which you intend to rely upon or introduce at trial of this litigation. NOTE: As referred to herein, "document" includes written, printed, typed, recorded, or graphic matter, however produced or reproduced, including correspondence, telegrams, other written communications, data processing storage units, tapes, contracts, agreements, notes, memoranda. analyses, projections, indices, work papers, studies, reports, surveys, diaries, calendars, films, photographs, diagrams, drawings, minutes of meetings, or any other writing (including copies of any of the foregoing, regardless of whether you are now in possession, custody, or control, your former or present counsel, agents, employees, officers, insurers, or any other person acting on your behalO. METTE, EVANS & WOODSIDE BY: ~ ANDREW H. DOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Court I. D. No. 39692 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 Telephone: (717) 232-5000 Attorney for Plaintiff DATED: December 5,1995 . JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CML ACTION - LAW NO. 4977 CML 1995 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED v. J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant ORDER AND NOW, this day of , 1996, upon consideration of the Motion to Compel of Plaintiff; IT IS HEREBY ORDER AND DECREED that Defendant shall fully and completely respond to Plaintiffs Request for Production of Documents within ten (10) days or suffer sanctions pursuant to Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure 4019. BY THE COURT: J. JANET KAUFFMAN, Plain tiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. CML ACTION LAW ...... ''J - S ",0\ ~ -.... -. /" --- .. ". :.:! . NO. 4977 CML 1995 - -". ':.I ":"J :--::.: r_ 0.' '.." ( . -' c..~ ":- ~J JURY TRIAL DEMANDED I -.'~J :.:. -) - ;:1 i.-- .... .<) .' . .:;,-;1 .. . ,":! '" . c.:; -0 -.;: J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant rtI0TION TO COMPEL AND NOW, comes Plaintiff, JANET KAUFFMAN, by her attorneys, Mette, Evans & Woodside, and files this Motion to Compel based on the following: 1. This case involves a slip and fall that occurred on January 26, 1994 resulting in personal injury to the Plaintiff. 2. The Complaint in the above matter was filed in September of 1995. 3. On December 5, 1995, the Plaintiff filed a "Request for Production of Docwnents" on the Defendant. A copy of the document request is attached as Exhibit "An. 4. To date, the Defendant has not responded to the document request. 5. The plaintiff attempted to amicably resolve this matter as evidence by the correspondence attached Exhibit "Bn dated February 13, 1996 requesting that the Defendant respond to the document request. There has been no response to the February 13, 1996 letter. 6. The Defendant is represented by Kathleen B. Gereaghty, Esquire, Kelly, McLaughlin & Foster, 1700 Atlantic Building, 260 South Broad Street, Philadelphia, PA 19102-5092 WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requests that the Court compel the Defendant to fully and completely respond to the request for Production of Documents or suffer sanctions pursuant to Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure 4019. METTE, EVANS & WOODSIDE BY: ~~.,. ANDREW H. DO -lNG, ESQUIRE Supreme Court I. D. No. 39692 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 Telephone: (717) 232.5000 Attorneys for Plaintiff DATED: March 15, 1996 EXHIBIT "c" .. .' I,~:r> _ -1 <' / Ie,.... ......oJ JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW . . : v. : J.C. PENNY CO., INC., Defendant . . NO. 95-4977 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this \~tlday of March, 1996, upon consideration of Plaintiff's Motion to Compel, a Rule is hereby issued upon Defendant to show cause why the relief requested should not be granted. RULE RETURNABLE within 20 days of service. BY THE COURT, J rew H. Dowling, Esq. 3 01 North Front Street .0. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 Attorney for Plaintiff Kathleen B. Gereaghty, Esq. KELLY, McLAUGHLIN & FOSTER 1700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19102-5092 Attorney for Defendant :rc -'"!'~:":':' ,---'''v .. ,...... ..~':'. dlOl.! bl:CORO I ". . "r,.. :\_ . .... . I I '. ... ", . .... ':-" I. -~.~ !~t i', ~.c~..l ';.. ~. ~ ~. . ~ .'.. . .... .. ." '.. ... '.. -.-. ... ..~ 4 \0... . :0. \..="; ~:'" p~ ,,-.; ~o~ da,! Oim~.:.'., ;9}(;. ................~ a... ~ ""~4.- .l............. , \1" ,............. .l>~ . Prothonotary JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff v. J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION . LAW NO. 95 . 4977 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ~ERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving a copy of the foregoing document upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below, which service satisfies the requirements of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, by sending a copy via facsimile and by depositing a copy of same in the United States Mail, at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, with fU'st class postage prepaid, addressed as follows: DATED: June 7, 1996 Anthony V. Mannino, Esq. Kelly, McLaughlin & Foster 1700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19102.5092 METrE, EVANS & WOODSIDE BY: - ~ - --. ANDREW H. DOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Court 1. D. No. 39692 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 Telephone: (717) 232.5000 Attorney for Plaintiffs v. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CML ACTION - LAW JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant NO. 4977 CML 1995 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ~lFF'S REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS SERVED UPON THE DEJ."ENDANT PURSUANT TO PA R.C.P. 4QH AND NOW, comes Plaintiff, JANET KAUFFMAN, by her attorneys, Mette, Evans & Woodside, and serves this Request for Admissions upon the Defendant pursuant to PA R.C.P. 4014. 1. The medical bills attached as Exhibit "A" totaling $3,087.76 were incurred by the Plaintiff and are fair, reasonable, necessary and causely related to the injuries suffered by the Plaintiff as a result of the accident that occurred at the Defendant's store on January 26, 1994. 2. As a result of the injuries Plaintiff sustained arising out of the above. captioned matter, she was off work for half days on January 31, February 3, and February 15; and the Plaintiff was off work for full days from February 16, 1994 through May 9, 1994. Plaintiff sustained lost wages in the amount of $3,673.27 as a result of the accident that occurred on January 26, 1994 at the Defendant's store. Respectfully submitted, METTE, EVANS & WOODSIDE BY: --::::=-= -- ANDREW H. DOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Court I. D. No. 39692 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 Telephone: (717) 232.5000 Attorneys for Plaintiff DATED: June 7, 1996 EXHIBIT "An ,\ '1. .~ "'1 ..~ ,. !i. .~ --- , - M'EDICAJ,. EXPENSES FOR JANET M. KAUFFMAN f.ROVlDER AMOUNT 1. RWC Emergency Physicians $66.00 2. Carlisle Imaging Associates S52.oo 3. Carlisle Hospital S251.35 4. Carlisle Community Ambulance S220.oo 5. Dr. Daniel P. Hely, M.D. S324.oo 6. Cenlral Pa. MRI Center (Magnetic Imaging Center) S1750.oo 7. People's Drug (now CVS Phannacy) $8.16 8. Carlisle Apothecary S3.75 9. Masland Associates, Inc. (Dr. Brazel) ~4l2.50 $3087.76 TOJ'AL: .'\ CO"" - .~-..A t'lEDlCAL EXPENSES FOR JANET M. KAUFFMAr'i RWC Emergency Physicians Date =--- Service 1/26/94 ER visit Carlisle Imaging Associates Date Service 1/26/94 Spine Lumb, Compl W Obliq Carlisle Hospital Date Service 1/26/94 1/26/94 1/2 6/94 1/26/94 Diphtheria-TET Tox Inj Oxycodone/ Acetaminophen Spine Lumbo Sacral - Routine Class I Visit Emergency TOTAL: Carlisle Community Ambulance Date Service 1/26/94 Ambulance service Amount 66.00 Amounl 52.00 Amount 9.50 1.75 200.10 illlQ 251.35 Amount 220.00 ';\f , , .... . ~; :""_i' '.;t- .':'1. ~ ~:'f" -: .~ ,,' .--. - ....... ......~ Dr. Daniel P. Hely, M.D. Date -- Service Amount 312194 3/11194 3130/94 4/4/94 4/11/94 5/6/94 Office consult Oftice visit - establ. patienl Office visit - establ. patient X-ray of knee (3 views) Office visit - establ. patient Office visit - establ. patient 65.00 40.00 40.00 79.00 50.00 ~ TOTAL: 324.00 Central Pa. MRl Center (Magnetic Imaging Center) Date Service Amount 3nt94 4nt94 MRl Lumbar Spine MRI. JT Lower Extremity 875.00 875.00 1750.00 TOTAL: People's Drug (now CVS Pharmacy) Date Service Amount 3/1 5/94 4/11194 Prescription Propoxy-N/APAP 4.49 li1 TOTAL: 8.16 '} ,~ Carlisle Apothecary ;. ~ ~ (f"'M Service Amount Ibuprofen 400 mg 3.75 Date ~ Service Amount 1/31/94 1131/94 1131/94 1/31/94 1/31/94 1/31/94 2/15/94 3/16/94 6nO/94 9n6l94 12/08/94 New Patient OX: Contusions Back EKG CBC & Platelet Urinalysis Clinical Chemistry Tests Routine Venipuncture/Collection Office Visit OX: Contusions Back Office Visit OX: Sciatica . Office Visit OX: Contusion Leg Office Visil OX: Pain in Limb Office Visit OX: Bursilis Trochanteric 100.00 55.00 16.00 13.00 40.00 7.50 37.00 37.00 37.00 33.00 llOO .~r.. .":{ I, ~: '1 :i ~. TOTAL: 412.50 TOTAL EXPENSES: $ 3,087.76 :~r .' ~. ~ :; ,.. ::~ ,- .. ., '. I .~~:. ., '~,l ~ .~ .~. \~'.t: . I ~. }~; ..I., ;.~~; . j.~ (.. \ \ '.. . \ ... '\f: J'~7: 'll"~' .:!o'E .1'-:'/. . .~~ .'~.. >:.1' ,'.; ,':"., , , y :l ., " . 'C .r;, .;. ~ ;~ '.", " I ,..'-. ;=. -- "r" ,,*>I.i~'i4' __" ;(~.v.~...U'....""~"'N.-:J."t-:<;.;!~".,..... ..'~,.. .~:~ "C; "...."".,........,r ..,......., ". ....''J\........... .I>O.\W(!'; ;::!:~~"~Ht~...;l,....,..;{~.~,. ;:>.":.OO';'.~P'd;'.ji/.:~ l.!~t "'\''',l.''i.'''~y''",.:r;.,?;'. -:'RuC ~EMERG"'~ICYf., YSICIANS'" "{'~'!.\'l;' ,. 'A"',' '"'. -:...,-;.."-~>...,~,,..~'_" ~.~ w"~' ~. .- ,'k'" ...~';- "''''___'''~'_A'''' -,' .JO," _.. ..~J. ~.'H..~ ..._J:~.f;.l;t_....I't'~"'-"'l':~,"st - .;.;..'S/'r.iff~1j..:t 0-0;1 ~'''~ ".....;.."'-... ~o/'-.;-~~.~' . ..., '17 ''I"" ANOVER 'ST'"' .'~-'" ,:=,,,'r.~:t.,..:.,,", "r.. i -.,..,"'- .". ~'~'- .~, ,~~... . N. I '.' ....J.;,~ ........ .'. ... ,~,&."..,Q,,, ,.,,,, .~ ......... ..""".1'0'<..:......."-.,..:0:" .;:~.p-,:rJ.;;O.--~~1.7.7. .I~..~.~.:i~~~:.~~~~\~~~i.i;$.2-. ~~*.~~~t;"~.lf:~,.::...i:'5~").,.\.,.:'~;,..~\":~~~~. .tr,"': "~ .u.... X'. '......,:..,.' .n.>r''';'''''''''''''4'i'''~ .':.' .rl,. ." ..:.,;.~'J:j..<._.,-:...._-- too...'" ....._ _.... ~ .' . . . ._^.. .......-i-..". .'~ T:'t' ,'. !S.. .",..:~..~..., p' - ~,- .-.,;'(,,:... . .~FARt:.'ISL:E;"~PA ~l1O~';;;"'.?2I{." < . 'T.~;!i$:..~~1!i-!,:;:<~,:~5'" ~..t:d.~ '~~W~ -",&,:;tl~:"r~"'.r :. - . - - ~;~J":j,!::c-,.:~..~;}.-.:f:i<:e:-':~ )~~il.Y-":t......~~....;:.:~.;;;~.J"'~~ .. -!..'J7 ;. ~."t,f-.~",:~.~.. .;I:.\;y.~1=, .t'.."....~~) .' 1<.:;;.~~.;:::f....,t.<.:i~;S...';:"~,.~/^~:~$ t~~ ~,.... "';:~<;f.~;,o;~..,;..:?..-;:.."'''';;:.;,~\,7.!ir,\": -.-=s I . I: TELEPHONE: 717-249-9432 BilLING OFFICE HOURS 10 a.m. . 4 p.m. TAX ID~ 23-2259396 J 4/05/94 01/26/9 99282 This CASE HISTORY 01 \ \ EMERGENCY DEF'T VISIT DX-922.3 66.00 ccount Is considered seriouslY delin,u nt. " '. ACCOUNT' CURRENT 7313737 ~ (;... .~:' 'f -:-:-";;:'.' ..... -~ .' _ 'il~ifur ~ ----. . ~~ .. .~~ 66.( t DETACH HERE 1 ..................................................................................................................... . , ;.f~lit~~.:....,,~3~"O:'~;f-f.t-~i.~~l~~\~~~....., ;paH ent)"'1'..;'~i;til~~~~~;r,.:l :(:i~NEi'1MWK~Uf'FMAN~;.",\..:?..~i~~;t~ .....~,;A.,. '\:""I,.:~...':.Y';:;I.~';.....~~~,.....~.~~..~';f$..~.....t..,. .....~~':' .... ...... ....,.. . ..00.."':;; .........IF~~.- ~'~~.. .., .. RETURN THIS STUB WITH YOUR PAYMENT 4/05/94\ 66 PAYMENTS RECEIVEO AFiER STATEMENT DATE ARE NOT REFlECTEO .'..: ." ..._.... _.. ,.." .'. _ .~....,.." ," _~",.......,,~ '.._ ....J.."..,.".~'.....'" ..-,' ....,."..., ......;.........:l:'lo;j.......:';....,- ~\'~:.PLEASE t.lAXE CHECKS PAY,l,EllE TO: ';l:""F ;....,t:O',.;:..':.',l'~ ..;;",.;,.,-,;""..'.i;;:;::,~'l'!);;.~.4..~'::;..~."".';. ~,..~~~,;~,:~...t:r,.,~".^'^.~..;'R"."'~.--:o;~..J.r~.<"'~S3.~.;r~':.\~..."':-~'.,"ff:Jc.'t'.'I.;:<~~.;-.t::::~'2"'''~';<'' f; ::.,.7:,,~~'''''''J.'''','S',''<''''''''~'''::'~'''' ,r.' ".. <}:<',;:: .".....; ~.... ";,~:"",, '< ...~t.'~~I"":.~:).."""'" 'r.:::~.c-"~"",,,\;;;1J.'-~-':-.f ,~ "'.: t, . ,__ :.,..."<:1.,' ~'''C?EHE~'GENCY 'PHYSICIANS ,..~..r""~,.v..lt'-"B~.....!;,:,'".os:'~~' .: .,...:.~... :.._,'~""\. :..... .."w.'" , . ...... ..""...".,.,.'n~-""' N'. ~,~." ~j..t);..:r....'. J .......t~~... ..__."T.I..__.-..,.._........~.r.'S.~.. .'"~..?"'...J,l'...~.~~:\.....,:-..!....~....::.....f. ~."J. --, c:. ....~..,., ~,-.'- '1 .' ....3.:- '."" -....117.... ....HANOVER.. T ........ .",..,~ ..,."", ......',.,...,.:. < .'- .~...",,~,~,. ':.J" '? ...::;.;;.......,. ~ '.. I~ '" ! -;- ,...,\.,..,'....o~.....:'>';...l". ..!j....,..,"".::..,...~:.;.:.2.. ..."',...,........',,:.: :D~;i ::.;~;~.~i(~~,fO;~qx ~',i),7 {~~t;.((:;..@ji~~~~~;~'~';;;'i;':.~.JF{.}2.!..~}:f~::;;~~',:f:';:~:~ ..... ' : ..:' ..... CARL'ISLE" 'F'A"170'13 ~c",;, .,.,.... . ' ,'." . ..:., ...... .,. .:, ..'- :.... F'AGI '" . ,... " '1" ..,.,... ,,<. '.~'..' ". '. ...'.. . c" .. '..' fOR OffiCE USE ONl v ,- ~ .-. - .. '\,' .::.l~ l. o 0 ZC..... C:;l v 1ll0"'Z ~>-'i3cn ::: mc(w Q j:~~~ =- !!!~1f;;;u ~ % .....0 ~ ....Z...ztncn ~ cc -cn~ x::;)wic t-.;; o"'~c ~",,..o wa:~ o en <Xl g~ x~ ~~ It) '" ..J ;! o I- 'w ~J;.:~b?1j;!.ti.;:~ ;:.:~J;~~;>i~l~ ..... ... , "'....~ -,~ ~..,.1'}'.. ~ :,'~" ," '''; '''''',' ~"~,,,".,l;., ..~....<,,-.' l. :aM:.....--:'~.:,._...iil...,-:;:.::s...~ -~'':'''''~..J'''t~71~ . . . "''i<~.l' . ~ 1t ':.. ''''~~''n::~.:{~~~~~ r- 0 C" r-... ... ~ r~ ~ > '!1 <: .~ ;.. .~ ~ -= r..,; ..... :; ~ , :- - .. .... .... .... 0 ;;:; "', =" <..i :1: <Ii UJ Orn~ ;;",0 a:...'" w::!w <illS!;: ClCll::l :Z~U)M~ i= -~ 'Ilf ZClUJl2'" :::J~i-cn OCl .. UC~o..<t'" 0:1-.; ..... <- ....... 1IJWW"'" ~~!;i~UJ UJ ....c- t: ~ z - "'a:0 tt<CU')<:1: c.~.....OCL UJ 9 <II UJ Z <II Q c I- UJ e:: > 0 UJ a. ,",'; ::: l- I;; OZ ZUl CO We ::ie:: "'a" wo O<t c:::; ,-w ::lUJ Ula: OUJ Ula: ...<11 =::l ""0 t;iw 1->- _<II ><t C'.. o~ we:: wo ...a. '<:'" :."" ~':a :..-;..f.-rl :;0;: ';'~"J...: , i:: " ., I, <f ~ ., .-' -t~~.~~~.~:<:,{~~::~~;,.,: ~~.;.~:~" ~'.~'r' .: :::.~ ":. ~;'f,~.~ir'-"'~".."'!;'\.;. ,~...\:.~..,~-_.~~-;.~--: ~~~;,;. .Li:j~~t~'r:~;lt~.;t~~J,;""'i"'~":;,~ r~W-' .<~..... -.... "1N'>1l~; .. <<'~"'"'''''''' .\;~ .~~ ti.....~ .,_.~~.tS.~;~~ - c :c .. ~ : ~ c 2 ~ 1'..... C W <:,t:) 0-<1: O-ll.. .... ~ 0- t:) ::l <: " W ...!I- <l:Ul 1-<1: ....::1: ll.. till- 0% :!:W ..... lJ.!1- .J<: (;~ ll.. ..... .JI- ,,% <:..... ULC ll.. .... t, ..... t. o <:'..... O-oG '0 0->=0 OW- , . C:~ OU tIlO ZO ..... . c;; , C Ul W o " <: :!: tJ .J b' <l:M l:. ' ... :;. b' \!; C~ CC ll.. C;;O t:lO :!: .' U ::I: C o 0::: C;;<:' t:lCJ :!: . . u r~ il-1 IW ,% I i , tr4 .,..., I- b' % . WM :c:...c >-.... <:1 ll.. 'wo ::l0 .::. . b' I- C'j ::I: <: I' M I' I'l ..... I'l I' o % I- Z u.; H I- <I: ll... W ::I: . CJ <:'0- ::I:CJ % .... I-CI: WM I-Zb' <:-0 Z-,.p..j I ~ .. ZI H<:U XW I-l.I..tn 1.1... c~u <1:0 tl.~(f; ~ . .- % o .... I- Cl... .... 0::: tJ Ul lJ.! ,::. W ll..Z Z I- W ..... %lJ.!::I: 'ZI->-WtJ>- ,W::lUH%<I: Z:tOZI-<:ll.. Hll..O:::W<l:CC O.Oll..::l1ll XZ~CCI-IIlU OH<l:W::lZZ I-XCC::l:CH, <: <l:UW ct. 1-1-<1: <I:<:::l WlL!V,I-UUIIl I-UIHHHZ I <:OUl""... <: '>=0"" t.;W .....1.I..'X:>::I:Xv, CCZ::l <:<:CC IJJO~J0.-4 : IJj :::C :t:I:t- I-OW~~1-1-1Il :tuzv,.J.J::I: "->-.....<:<:<1:<: HXll.....!WWIll ,::,ocpu:t:;1- , I .::. <I: lJ.! U Z W ct. W 1.1.. W c: ~e :t:t U L' XX <:<: :t:t WlL!, 1-1- t.:ruc ..:J..J 1.1..1.1...... <1:<: 1-1-':' Wl1.i Z Z C,' :t :t .........1' <1:<: : I OOOOI'lMC-l H.....:t:tb'b'O 1l.1l.Ct..!LNUU . I , , ~"':;""'<"~<"~ o-c-c-c-c-c-c- oGoG-o-oMb'" r.; C"'l r., C".J 'I""t r-! 0 't""'!.-f";"'l""'tf'tnf'. 0000000 I . <:'<:'<:,<:,<:,<:,<:, o-c-c-c-c-Ooc- oGoG-o-oM<:'OO :> . c.j C'j C" C'l .... C-l 0 " ..............."b'" ~, 0000000 , I Ob'OO<:,O... b'''.....OCJOb' I- <: >=0 I- .::. I- ~, ll.. I- .::. I- ::I: <: ..... C-.....OOC,1 M I- 0<:'-0-0 X C,' I ... t.:.: I I- Z ::l o X <: Ob'OC<:,C... b'''...CCJCb' ....... 0-.,..; C C ("'4 M 0<:'00 00 r.~ ... >- I- o .-f~...-!~.....t.,..('" I I I c:: ~ 13 C".: r.. u1 ceo 0 b;cr'~",,;""u'M c... >- .,.0; f"'.. M....,..( Jo.-4 X C '-C ", ""'..... .::. 0 -0 Ci COO CCCO......;.....-t 1I1 \l~ t., :,,-; COO r; to:'"': ~ c..: N N :> " z . ~ . . .: ~ . . , if * ; III III o ct. <: :t U J. o I .::. z w * * I . . ~ , ! .~ I , ~11i I-W a: 0: (f)!;; "':It'l o c:C5: :to:......... uiW"'ui. .JiEX..J(;j (f)_O(/). -..J......~-", C.~..J'N !2.!?q~~ (\J a. C,r.:.: ; i , , I ; ", ... ~ , , 1 :; ", " , .. '; :~: ~; .~~ . ;\',. :~. it: ,. \ " \ . " ~ \ \ .1 o ,. Za:O... 4:)~Z =~~:)W ::: 2 al~l) <l lii:~:iZ :... ",1;;:cou:5 .:c -;:.0. :J::: :I:z":Wal .. i-c:,z.J:!: ~ :I::>w!!!<!-;; U...:S.J ;:w~a: UJa:~C( o U '" '" 9;;5 .x ~ ~ ~ M '" UJ U Z < ...J ::> III ::; <0 < Cl ... ~ 9N Z M~ ::>::; ,;;8 ",. ....01 ::; .... O~it~ u... t- -.... ~)(~,... 1Il0lllw :J1ll:JZ ~c!~~ ua..Ua.. .- 0.G~ .~:. ( , ,:1 ...... . -. ui c Vi UJ z '" Q c: w > ~ ,W ~c: ~z ~o ~~ ....--~ :c: ~ ~.::o :J UJ ~;o :0 UJ ~.-:t, " '" ~~;o ~t w .;:'" -~ V) .>< 'O~ 'I- Co. .,'.....;..:.:.i.':::.~.:..::.- o i ~ 15 2 . VI ...J , . i' o o i' ,..; <: "- ~ ::; ;: "" ... .... ., o ,,", , , ;i .... c: o c.. l- Z . wCfJ ::d~ wo - a. We:: wo ~... .i:'. ;I: I '~ . , ~<. .;f ':!i ~J' '. . r' J' ~ !z:-<l W ~!lil I'- ~ ~oll W D.~ ~~~n ~<l::z: (/)0.0 ~ o D. '" ~ :z: 0:: ~ .0:: :1:' \' ~'a! III III \~-~ " t ffi: >= ~a' ":1-' ., . 5' I ~i \ ffim \ ~ ; \~; , c.. I .-. 0'" o III I'- III W'" a! .':::l o \.~Zc[ C Z-l<Ul. <ct:> ~ 1: .ctO :l "'" Z '< "'" ....... z ;:) 0:0:: ~c: <l: ctl1. =' J:III < 0, Q. E: ;:)0 ffi UI J:Z CD a .... Ill'" ::; iii \II ..I ~ z Z oll'" l-' 0 <t 00 o ll; ., Mill o UI <( a: .., ~ 00 00 .ti ,oll C'l or l\I .... 0: ,0 Z ... 1: .... ..I :::l Ul Q'Z ~8 ,:; 3 _ o:W " 00 .' LL.M :' "'" W"'" 00 Z ctp, ..I<t ctr~ Illll' a- C 1: ~ ...> z...l u.;U! ::;J: ~ l1.11. ~..1 u;W """ ~ <(<( we ..J Q. .... lJJ III o:M ....... UlO 1'-. w~ '0::',; W< 011. W :>Ul ..1..1 WOl c:l'" ...I ollO: ~<t mu ~ - ~_... o 0 0 Il'l 10 oll 00 ... Cl g .~ III ..J ~ g ~ UI ~ g ~ UI Iz 0 ~ ::l ~ 5 8 ~ :! U III c( :.ct..?; .~ r --- a- ..... ... ... ..... M o '",.' i ... ~ ~ - I'- .!1J ... Z I'- <t - ~ >- ~ ..I C(~ \:l :I::n !: ..- WI \Wl 0 tt:r~ <tor \l~ tl't', ...[\1 -0 nr; 00 " UI \II '< 5 0 ~ ~ z _. ~ .J...J W c( :'" ... '" '7. !;( g., Iii '.. . .._--~--'-"'" . ..~ i \ \ I '. ~ J'.~" ..... , \ . \ i . 1 I' , I'- o o I'- W... :::l z<t Z WI1. <l: :> 1: ctO "'" Z '" ........ ::l 0:0:: <( ctl1. =' J:III o 1: ~C> J:Z ~ II'''' Ul ...I Z 00.... <( 00 ., Mill o o Il'l . oll. lit ~lo a~o z '" ... i ~ ;; I ". " \ ", ~. W .J III V1 to'] Z III ~~w ll! Vlct:!OO w<4:Z0 a:a..z<< th ...10 ~p ~lri z~.o I g: \ .\ ""! NEW PATIENT (non-referral) 110204 - ABl.ISHED PATIENT CODES 8ll2,4 8ll2lS REFERRING PHYSICIAN CgNSULTS .,,/ ClG244 1102' 5 CN nball>co. _ [n-..,....Lr /Ice. F.u.C&t. Hoop. _ h. 0<.CpD<t INJECTION ~ Iordon"..." hj*_ofrj, 011I.,..... ..........." l-Unn.""" #090.......-;, rnojc< ,..... SURGERY RepU Ioc, "" 10 Ucm IIepU IK. 2~7.5<m IIomc>.-aI """""'--"<' ~""",,",--p T.._~ 1 Ea<. ;angr"", _ tloaornp- (ClS) Tr'QgOt "- __ b:. _ _.,..... 0Il..w- & .....- Cw. urn to work: Cw. III Duty: 0 Regular Duty 0 ." .~,. DANIEL P. HELY, M.D. '1' 1l\.'tt:O("l IlNl1 c.uusLL HNoU. uo,~ PIl12fWlU r'\ OFFICE VISITS FRACTURES/OISLOCA TlONS I:)SOIl F,"""" __ zs.s.co O-........tWvtact~ Z:lIlCO F,""",.lunen.IIug.'- r.105O Di&loc. ~ _.- ,<500 F,""",.lunooal__ 1U30 Fnd:I.6. a.p_4)1at tuntNI 1<5<10 F......... . .01)10_ 1<640 ..........,. _ 14450 F........ ...,..._ '4870 F,ocu._pcDnaI IS500 F,ocu. .....",.. ti505 ffocu."'" .....,odu:Iion _ F,""",.__ IS545 F'"""'....,;,w.. ",..,educl. :z.scoo F,""",....f... CCIIoI 25COS FIac:t&.r.rwf...CoGes~ 25e22 ~'ocu.OCIjlIloil_ 25830 ffadu. cotpOl_ IOllOO F'........-..paI_ HnO F'"""'. pI\IW<< pcolmolIlniddla H725 F........ pI\IW<< Ndu:lion an50 F,"""" pI\IW<<_ HT55 ffadu. paIanr _-..:lIon HToS ffadu. pI\IW<< _ "I*' ft770 1)0_ 01' Ja" ~ ffadu.pot._ I7s.:lO F'"""'._pIaI.... ' 17750 .F'"""'._....._ 177M F,""","tIU.J__ l7eoo ffocu.___ 11\0170 F,ocu.__ 90702 Tetanus Inj. ORTHOPAEDIC SUPPLIES Shc"lornuprrt 29125 Cn.IdWo So.u Ingof Ipl'ru Hon;'"O "'"0 Kneo_ EIoW: fa Map ClolClpl'.... ~\c4o CHARGES OV S AMOUNT PAID $ r-. i.o:.:! ~ ICCA PHYI X.RA YS =0 6P1Nf11V.c7-S2 720<0 ClSPINE ~ (Of loa) 72050 ClSPINE 4V (rc>.Dw) 72070 T/SPINE 'N ~.........) 721CXl IS SPINE ~ fer -I 72110 IS 5l'INE 4V (rc>.Dw1 72170 PE1.VIS 'v nx>:l ClAVICLE 7>000 BHOU.DER (1'OLCi'>t) T.lOllO .......ERUS T.1070 ElBOW 'N . T.lOeO ElBOW ~ (I.........) ; 'T.lOOO ' FORENlM ::;..7;)U:O MUST 'z.I , T.l110 MUST ~ mlo MUST IN (I.........) T.l12O IW/D2V T.l14O FINGER T.l510 II!' 'N T.l52O HP NID PEl v:s 7:l56O fE).IUll 73500 ICNEE IV T.I6C2 IOIEE ~ ~"""'") 73500 LEG T.lIlOO N<l<l.E 'N T.lOIO N<l<l.E 4V (1'OLCi'>t) ~ FOOT'N T.lID) 'FOOT ~ (~i T.ll>5O HEEl. T.lCOO TOE(S) 67200 6caJOSIS (..... 4V) 1-3\:0 ~"'-c:! va'l(~\;) ll.\qo ~V\"" "ro~(if'I ,1.01-0 st>.~ VO,\(\V) (1-<;'1.. X-RAY TOTAl. CHECK 0 CASH 0 6 ~ ~~:J . (~~=- u~ :,:..,,: C~~lJ:. ;. c..:.,.': .,1 HEALTH INSURANCE CLAIM FORI.! I':: ;I..~:,:....'.'~'" , ':" c.:;J~ iE:.l o~..!: '11t.5.~"::il:: ........il= '"t~....;._.l'" 9...~'''''.~ (5:',0' Ie' ': ,55', r: /Ie r-- ,YA :'.' i: 11 P,l.',:s;'So...:..IJ.a.:i LlI.' 0: yy 6 26 46 ..:-, 16 ,,,,;,.[..,:, A~J.TO't$""C TG IM..;~E' $I- ~I So"~"~ C~oC: o--t.~ , ~ - I S';',l,7! I' '.&7:E"'- S';''':I,;! . p""" ~ ~c;, ..\ So"l.jf -.J ""....: ~ 07-4' ~ I ,E..E:,..:...t '1.,:-...::.. At", :'x, I "17 )243 0325 E~.:-:,.,- ''''''''''-, ."'....-1 7 v - I I I SI",:,'" I I S:.-:r. I ...." 5 "", ,lit' N'~' '''' .,.-, ...,::t ~ ,.. I'. '5" :ii" 5 ";:.0;:"'''''' .,..TE: 10 oS"" 5 >CA'" V 0" O=OU' """S, = l' 1U'.CV"O':~~U"'O':"'Yl.:lUS' .sJRc~ 5 CA ~E Cf BI!:\TM SEI 1:1 AIJ,'C ACCIOE'ij"l PUCE IS:a!" ill VV ..-, 'n ,OVU nooc_ "S N......E OF. sc,.co. ~.a."'E ( CTh::~ ...=:'OEO\":' .-j ,"',.:;.J<C I, ;--, 15;.'-~' I ~'. ...101.': .....11:........... F..':"".... Ll..::t 'iV...a' Sea ': 5:"':, Om eN: .....,.,.,'c..".-.-:.:..,.....,.. I" ......-........OC' '5. .. ... __..... '" .J: c.:.:O\oc....,.""..... .. t.: :. IUAO BACIl. 0' FCRW BEFORE COMPl,.(TIh:" SlCHI":; THIS fORM S OR AUTt<l;;ZE:i PE ~S,jN 5 Sl{,t.:. ':'yRi. I.",:..~"\:,:-tt ""'U ~~ ...., fftf'O.:. O' =,.... onI:T.'~;.r, ,...:tsSI") "', CU-"'" I.'SO ftQ.I": P-'y"","It 01 go.t.~tlll ~.,t!,:, ..:~t'l: mr't~:If 10 Il"t poa-:y ...-c ae.:t:l:.ll,~,n: . -.SIGNATURE.DN Fll.E. CATi: 11~ If P,l7:E"" HAS MA:i s",,,,,i. 01: SIU.....RI.L..tsS GI'JE ~1~S"i OATt J.lt.l ..00 Y'Y I '"~ ION."'" C' "E'[,'.,N"HVS:::4:. 1CURR['.f ~ ILLNESS IF"'II,"'Pf:-., OR DC yy ,N:,JR."1I.a..:::.ct~:;CR ;tlO.tG"I,U.,:V,lU;J, rs :::i;c.""'''':;' PHYS;CIAN CAC'l'ti[~ s.:)URCf. :5 OR NATURE Of' ILLNESS OA lH,;URY tRE~TE iTE.""~ 1,2.3 CR.":O ITEl.l cd BY LINE. 3 L-._ 'L-, . 0 0 I..." I T...\'C.c.:::;'U=\H S!Ol.r:U OR Sl,;PP..IU1' 0: 01 IEI:...-u"l"',....'c",....,':I~t'l yy o... Ci'':' loI':=':! I U'j:!lfIE=- I 101 I I I I I 1 DIAGHOSiS CCOE , I I Ii \' I' il l- "CC:!:: ...!.S..:a....,:.'.'l'~ I ,Fa' 1C'~ c:......, IM)IC'I.: 20628 'L..:5l3 7 if\, V(S "" IVI:"~ or ;>>1"~~ ",,,-OR SUP;..IE~ 3'< N""/:. AN: ~:::.~~~ C" ;.c,-In w"'ElO,~ SC:h'l:H wl~( .; ~~:'" :7!~:r;:~A' (; ~ IIP..:E:)::';" Q~." :-""~ I'll"..... 01 ~".:I, t~.~. lii.~. I in. 8- o' ' 29/94 "" tk.'ll c:. N....""::.~ SSi'o E", .:of o...r.i'.- S ...::.:_~.':'''':; ,.: I':. ~ ,"'- . C ~ ~ ~::"., ~ ! :' P~EA~f PF.."1i O~ TYF'i + I G I H I I ! J I I .. '..., I I "ES'''1: .". O' l'I"\oI~ 1Y" c.::e lCr." U<., Cs;:S. po..~ I oJ I ..... I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I :. TotAl C;.v.A:'! IZ'J A.....::..:..":' '''1: I ~ :,,:,-";::. J'..:~ II , .,., 1 ~~2.._. ~ ~"'S"14N S s.:=;>~tE~ S '1~~I"'J ,......~ ...0::",5.3 :.? ;::CE & '!'O:N! I .. ~~~y T&~Tr .. oJoi.3_:;'i; i """'L.t .J... ",-" 'Jl' ,,-. a.a..::.. If'.... 23206251000 :' ~Si.i=l' ~ A:):-=t15 lHe ~...: .:::-.. I C..H- I' ' c: c: I PA Z' ~~~7 I""'r~:" ;,:."01 '=[' CO:i 11 ....S..;~i:5...;::;.CTG;:;~;J/IICC,':::.....N~"'1i~ , INSUfOE:! OArr CI 1\I:Tu ,.It.' t:' "N SE' ..r; . . 'Ii CI (y;,...01(:; 5 ...../! C" SCt<iC~ N"''': : .,..S~,.""'..:! P-j.,h H,l.M! OR PRCG~':'Y ~.......! e is ;":':'1 .&.~:"r.~ ...E"Lr"'iI'.:'=.T ;l:..A'.' n"u [J NC , 1ft '.~..-::'''''= c.=...~-t.t ..,-, ,.-:t .~ ....S"JRE: 5 ~ ",UT":~IlE:) PE~5:>-. S SiO".... ru;;.r. I ,..~,.c...:. poIr',:,:,ft: ~ rN':":.J,' :of",IU III IN t,t"'C..~.,..: """,t<".a" " '''':~. Ie' ....'W<ll"~:AO' S"'NE~ .--SIG~A11lRE J)N .FILE ~! OATES ~"TIE"'~ Us.t.el.! TO~~' lPoi ::~Jl:r!'lT OC:~"'''';'''''I l.I'.~ CO. n "".. C::: yy 'R':N . TO ~S t<lS:=IT"l.lV';';-;'J.i ~:'CS "E~7:j TC C,Jc;:I",t SE..,,;CES .,... O~ yy "HI DO YY FACU 10 1: c",'TSICE \..AE' S ::""~~:s DvES ONO ~ "'E::CAlQ RU;J51.A;SSiCH CeDE . CAIG:~"'~ Rf:', NO I n 'RICA AVTHCR:.Ll':'Cff N",,'trrI6E~ SCIIAAGU 40 ~ . ! .,....: DANIEL P. HEL Y 816 6.ELVEDERE ST. CARLlSLS, PA"H013 ::~': ':'~::: ':,:: 1'2;: . ':':....., c "- E c < " .., I; I; , , \g 1< ::i C. ,0 u. I~ \@ I~ It:: I~ 1< I~ 'I I I , .., J. I I: II I I::: I~ 18 I~ '- 1-' I~ I~ c I~ t:, I~ ~, .;\: i' ,.t.'. ,(11'1 >>Z1J>:IJ I .CZ >m . >':',C:: 0 ;: :II III , P. ":iJ .m ~." , ......c.m .0 . ~'~ en .z tnl~ ,Ill .~~ . ~ Q Ie 'r- Ot): .. ,m 0,,, 1 Eo'I ,,' il , m .. . m '0& :O~ ~.,,~~ :~ "'. ,mr. " . ~ ~. :~.,. -,..;"<i., :'''',: '.:':';' " . . .t..IIIl"r. .::...........:..1. i~ ~ :~~~ .' ~rg~l~ '.~..:J.i'?~:,~ 'nt:II"/ "..~: .". .~~..t~ . '!if.:v.; ,,",(., I l2*';.~~d!"i~ ':>':>ll- ~,';':~ ~~\''C\''\'" ,\<' p.,. ...', :;';'.' '., "000 ~~rR.":",>:.~~i:Ohv1 ... '. . . :- ,,'s.,~:~@."f ;000 .~~~;;-I..I;\~.~Th~:. :.\.....\\..: .,~. '.' . '000 f<:-;:-:::'::~::,~~i7:~:'~: ~:::: :.. .:,y::; ,:- ",:,'. ~:.~ .~~ ~: t :. , '>, ". ,:..-..1Il .0.... \';: 'rlCI '. - m 'CU ':',(Jl ,0 ... c' '.... ..,. .~"c '0 '. ,0.,:.... ,"')0" .-:,.".... c' '::',0": , m., '..'..r- ,':IJ "c" c: :: .........,1>1Il .',00 ,1>'0" :::l 'm, ';: ::::i ,:>', ..,....z.'.'.. :llQo::-.Zm ,;...:-0': ,2 '.z '~ :: f,i-,' , 'm...,o.,z:~'....,......r.........IIl..' r .,II\'!!?:;: :i' :II>'.' z .:E 0 '.:.', "!T1 ,..e .mm ....(j).... Q 'C: iii 'mQ_,", ~ 'o~:o":~ U1mriS 2.1: ..In:g ~ ~'~,~~,5 '~~:~i ~5 3j ~ m 0 (It rn -< mz ~ ~ -4,^ Z ' ,..,' ~ ~C:t;:: -0:> 1> 0( i5 ~ '" C'l ... :>m rnm :<:i:ll C Z z 1> :;::! :0 r Z ....-1.." ~ == ~ ... ..m -<::: 2 ." m <.' ~ m ~ ~ 0 ~> 3~ ,N rn 'Olli , <: 1>,,,..[.) ~ s: "-1.3 '11\ 2'cll- ~ ~ W::J,~ ::>2 0 'oJ Ie.. ,.. .,.. '.m , ' C ~ Cl- ~ Z .::,11] ...~m g: ....-l ...~ ..',. ~ ... . 5? .. Eo'I \ \ \ . ; I, i , ; , I ! " I \ \ . .. '" ... .:0 . (Jl o o "Q ~~ .. :'z .. ..... oml' Zlll o III '0 PJ~ lJI- Ilri ..." UlI C[.) t. '1\)0 00 1> OZ "'0- ',2 . Qom r ITi"Nz ...'U1 ;,T! ' 009 Z::Z:..\". . - ':.. oc ,It,.. ,'/ ':.. tC)'I" .~:.:... :...,un:.:'~ :.. ." *O~;I'~I;..":" .. :O::OC. .. . ...... '::<1 ,>: 'J .' Z''''''' .:0 :' ~::> '''3 ,.00 .. .< '1>1 .'. *Om ',Z. "C" '. '<':.>~..:'.:i'. \ :'.: ..... :..' .....m ' . ' .: j;J V,', 0 .',' ...., .....0 ". o . ',' () o ~.~.~ '.:' .....:;.g .... :.:: . 'I . ..... 'z .' '-I '.... .' . .:2 '; .M..... '.. 0 ..... .;. mm~ -mlllo .~-;-1:ol '::>1>I: .,". ,..CO:>.. :.,-":. ":~ '. .......:.::....;0 '. ..... .... /f ::~~C'. .... ..... . .>..: '?:j~~ :..... ..' ,..,': !"(~~ ......: 4: .:i ~-;-I ..:..... o:?o -. .z WWob . >, "W"O .,! 'C"OO ," o! 'oQ-lJ-ll ":Ii .:o':'J> .'1 . m~11 'co ........ 1'1: iiiiii . 0 ' rr . b I -<-< .., ., ::>:1> . ' I!I .. . :zz. '!!! .. :mm :: ~ .. .. . -i-; .' a~1 " . ........ , '<-lJ tnl , . Z' '...o...oc: . :1 : P_'i\J:!> ~I ~"''''r ".""1 .. i'n)':!> 2 > 000 r :<<m '. .. .' .... ., .: . '.. '. ", '.::. '... ...... ." ?" " .'33 ........... ':22 ''''';'00 . ..' :..~.?=;:iJ..: 9 ,.. .0 c: .. ,> ~ ~~! 1 oi ~ "I: ~t': ~Il ~i '1 .. ei. =1. :nIt -I' Z I . o! "'I~!,j . ; . . .. , :'.'? ....:~........ :..': ...-......., ;......\;(. ":.. . \ OJ.' ...~:. .... .... ....... .::::: .:..:..:; ~";:'" "t.. :.::....:.. .:. ~.~ . . .. 6.3(:i.""...: ..... 4" ~'... ;":: .' . ...... ..' .,'. .... " .' . ',' ;. '. . ... .'. ,., '" .,....;,...:/ :.: .:.... I~"-J...f: . ......... I'JjlJ ' .:0':> '[.)[.) I I I' I. I] .. ' .... .:0 Li, ~ UI' ,,=-. DANIEL P. HELY, M.D. .1' .E\.....OlN ITNE" c.uusLL. K~ ".n (JU')t...."2 ~1 OFFICE VISITS NEW PATlENT (non.relerral) \102()4 \102D5 fRACTURESf01SLOCA nONS \10214 \10215 2:1500 F,__- cIa'Ildt cIoMd J':).5.4O t)iI:'--~ea~ 2:lCCO F,__- bIN'''' N" rwd< 2)650 0.>0<. .,..,.- cIoMd ,odo,dion 2.500 F...:A>' bIN'" thd cIoMd 2.5:)0 ,.--. -~ ""*'" 2'-500 F'-" .......d)it dooI!I 24640 ~- 24450 F.-.....r....- 24070 F,__'''''' p..,.;,ntI 2SSOO F,__"td'otI &haft 2SS05 F'___...r... &haft,~ asseo F,--- ,..r..w... ...... tSS45 F,--- ,..r..w'" ",,-a_ 25/lOO F,__- ...r.. ColIc< 2~ F''''''''-...r.. CoIIc<,.cl"",," 25422 F,"""'- ocapI'<>d cIoMd 2!6)0 F'--' wpaI cbtd . te600 F,--- mNUfPII cbtd 2G720 F.-.- phoWt< P~ tQ2S F.-.' phoWt<,.cludlOn 2G750 F'-" phoWt< croW 2G755 ,.....,.. phoWt< ofstII ,.clu:lion 2G7a5 fro<U" phoWt< croW - lIG770 D"'" .llIPjoO't 21520 f<ad>6' pololla cbtd 275:)0 F.-..ltliI pIoI.... %7150 ' f<ad>6.....&haadOOl'l ERRING PHYSICIAN CQNSULTS pg';!'C W2'S 1 '~ t'IioI~.iIoIaIod ~ .._...rq~F.u.Cot- " 1b9......~~ INJECTION Ijocb\ _"...:to ~I/r'i,...joO't ~,Honn.joO't ItP< """" "'*" joO't SURGERY a.p.;- Ioc, ~ 10 z.&cm a.p.;- 1oC. Z ~ 7 ,5cm --~. _~o<lotP T.....,novtdtWfT'/ k.~..,ld ~-""'~> trW<~- 10:, """"" _ ol-'" rT1ea F'-'- .,.,. ofstII dOOI'l 27_ ,."""'_ ~.,....- doNd 2&470 F,__- ~ dOOI'l - - , . 90702 Tetanus Inj. ORTHOPAEDIC SUPPLIES S"",,_cprR 29125 ~ &l>.J .-.ge< cprrO ~~ l(l.o mmobIb-" [los:I: ,..,...", CIAC cPre . ~\cAO CIl-w'" & ........... .up: IMl0" Dot. to .,..00<: "". :0 Regular Duty 0 CHARGES OV $ AMOUI-lT PAID $ .. c., (.~-'.. '(\~' .~.\ '\ . ICDA ,2.'\ .'~ pHY# X-RAYS '72o:lO &P\NE1IV-C7-SZ 72()40 C/SPlHE W lOt losS> noso UOPlHE 'V I,,,,,",J 12070 T~ W ~",,",J '12100 U 6PII'E W (0< IosSJ . '12110 U &I'INE 4V ~",,",l '12170 pa.V1S IV 7:lOOO Q,AVlCLE ~~~J T,lOeO tfJIoWIUS p070 f]JlOW W 7:lOllO f]JlOW W I'..u>o) pOQO f(lRUAM '12.00 y,l\lSTW "12110 y,l\lST W Y7~10 y,l\lST ~ I'.,.u-.o) '12120 IWlO ZV "12140 fV'GER "12510 W' 2V 73520 W' NID PEl. VIS . "I25SO fO.IUI T,l5eO IOlEE W "I255Z lOlEE W to",,",J ,"125"0 U<l ~ "KlW "12010 I/'OCLE 4V (lo'D'<) 7)Ol2O FOOT W ~ FOOT W~J T,)Wl tlEEL neeo TOE(5) snoo Sc;OUOSlS (mIn 4',') - ~~ \--Ol'.d va'l~~- ,).\<:\0 ~V\<:. '(.f'O,$?\ i~O)..O Sp'''< VCl,\(W) ("\-<;.1- - '. X.JIAY 'TOTAl. CHECK 0 . . CASH 0 'I: , Gr" r\.JIIY CErn r II (~~~. . " .....~'i PITTSBURGH PA 152.2 e "- C r: c. l: F'C. X -.: y ~ ~. . HEALTH INSURANCE CLAIM FORM I;::;:: :;:;:,-:,:.:,... "0 ..:.I~ " c,::.:...;;. FE:';' O't4E~ :. ""S'JR!$Slt ~..I.'~:.:' ,.:~;':'.. ~~A" _Bl~..I..1.."I':'_ 5,.:'le ,..I' ,/0 232 0E:-511lCil ,,'::':':'.0 O~':'I.I;t..;3 C""'I.~; ,:. ,_ tl,::J':' - .5:;-,:"55'1 ~ .\'.. ~... . SiX \' ;S~~~SFN~';,;'"'~~~;;;~" '''''' ,'" .. lNsu~EO S AC~:-:. a..: Sl.'t: 3G5 S"~~HA~T i\vr C;':'-' : S~:":'i \ I'A ,,; .:-A-;l:",.S,:!,;.;"oAa 1....1 ::. yy 06 2E: 46 u \C.l~ .LU' "',-. ;:."1';41-' t.l<c,. '",~',., 'J JANET i'5 P.a.71:.':7 =i_A~lC:.S"I~ i:'':.Si.iC!C ~ s.~-:y S~..u-:C"t.:- ~,.- . I! III;'';'.!';''; s,:~:us AVE 157.1':': I G SI'RINGS : pr, \ '(;E;~;E7'~;' .;~:;~ POt: 5: 'I:",': '...: ~tI-' ; II: ~,,-. J.l.::. 1l"Io:,I' 'ir F\ i/1:iS SOILIIl'; lil= co~: e...."'.r: M~"~ 5'''i. I ':'r..P-:'.i. .t.:...::. :.=!J. :'C~E . ! b) 7) 7~:~ I,,:,;>t. !:~::::I':'_I F',I...T"..,- Pa~.':'.r...- SIUC..... S'.e,.' ::. IS p.:.~d::;7 5 ';:CNOI.GH =i.E:..4a:; ic;, 17G07 I: INStJ~C.~S p,,:".,:''' 1j=:'Jo ,:= =S:'" '..:".';:: H' .. INS-":==.JS :i':'''';: := :.=~rI ...... :: 'f'! 05 ?6 46 !.. e.'A;:-:.C'fIAc...,7' !CUR~E"" CD PR:':I()'':S 'J c.~ S P0...IC.Y 0= Ci":U:' N~~.~a:.::'; -yes r::-.... .!:-..... : :~.t:.:J..:.: s '.~',':.:" 5:-::. ..~',':. ': ,:,...":': ,:,.::.:::..~, P'..:.:E'S:n ...t:''itL.;: 0= S=7,..; S::", YY y.:: YES ,-, I . ':. ;uS..-=:.:::E =.:'. ~.':":i C:. o::~::,: ".':",':: u : :"_::= ,:,::':e'.il' Hr Al TH /lr,lI:lCA tiPrO':".!E 0= ~~..c:" '1:'1.::: ;i"tlC j: yES : IS ,!,.:~:; ,f,:..:-"::= ..;,:....T" !:.".:;= ~ =.:.... : \'C ~Ei:.=.E:-~::iRLOC.lt..l.:H " O:.,':'N ,.:':.1:' 0;; p~':':'":".: ~;.:::. . .yE'i ;x- Nt: If,.. ......::l"'::~-:...,...-;l: ~3 I~SU~EO S c.: ;....~-o=;;::~ Pc:llS:". 5 S ~";.;'':'\..:: I a..:"-:':" p..,_,ot: ol~.'::' :,.,10:, lC ~t lot.:'" ;.,,; :",\.t...;' ,.::....tc. ,,"'<" e,K':.t: ~It ,.. f'EAO BACK OF FOR'" BEFOf'E COMPLETING I. SI(#NINC THIS FOR.... .,~ AUTHORIZED PERSON S S;G:i,l. "!'U;:!,E 1..u:-.:l':.:.1.... .,"oll' ;! a"f r.oo,C':.&l cr oNl tNorr:-.,l);)l\ tlttt\SMy nt ct'r.'i I.t~ fK;:"U: ='r~1 019""M1f"1 :..","11, tl:r.t' :0 m",:I Cf" 1"' part, wflO acct;'.1'u.;r'-"Nftt SIGNATURE ON FILE 050994 SIGNATURE ON FILE t.:orE S:C,Ncu 16. OATES PAlIE'.. U:.:.~_E TCW~;:.';P' :;,:=:;:'.1 .:.t;.C~:I...-,C'. ..n.' t:.. n J..... 0:' .., FF<C'" .,: .. .. .-.-..... -. ..- -.. \1~ IF P;.TiE~.':' I"JoS rI.lt.Q S.&.I.I~ 0;:; SU..Il.A~I\.lNESS G:'J~ FI~S':" O"~E "".l 00 yy \'" :,0 Nc,.',E"~' RHER"",:l'"YSIC''''' n OUTSIOE l"~' S~l"I.:o:~H :uRf'5.NT ~ ILLNESS IF"SI SY""~:'T.. OR 1:' Y1 IN':U''Y I":C:C'''.:, OF. . ?=\E:GN&.:.CY1L"'? "EHi=I~ING P""YSICI.lt.N OA on"EF. S~URCE 11 t4CSPt~.....;Z:':I:'" u,l,~H ~c...;.:-::..: :...=,:':'.~ 5::=",'1':::$ t.l~.~ 0:' "'f ?",' t~ 'f,! F;:'O.! ':'0 :S0C0 NATUl;E 0; IL~?l::SS OCi IN..:\;RY IAELAiC 1.:.'.~S 1.23 OR.: TO ITc'nole 8Y LINE: --, 'T DYES Ix" NO I 22 "'EO:C.&.IO J;U\,;S'.uSS.c:t CODe. OFUGl'_':'t, A!: 'oC I 3L-,- 2' Pl;IOR ...UTMC~ t:. i;C~ N\:\l;-;:':' 232 0c.2~10G0 , , L-. I e. I C I C I \ PO..:, 1 T"t 1";;OCEoucEs SE;:;',.C::i C=' SU;lPL1ES\ 01 o' _",E~:_~:. U"'.'.3 ~::=..-_,:'.e". YY 'c:.f....,. c.~.,.t, C'" .....-.:1 I ......'.,:.. b 16 I S'3L13 1 \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ I G I )of I I . .: I 1..:":1\:" ....1 I , I C;:' F..-J'I c...- . .....: . il.'.':-S ~ ... I ....J ..-. , E OI.l.GI:';lS:5 c.::: PH::::!: =:= v:-:.:. .S:. SCl--:.r:G:.S- ~':-i'S' Of Se~\ICE... .. l:l 1 \ \ .,.. 1.11.\ !::: Oil 51l 2 1 \ \ I ' ! \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ I , ~ SS~ EI:. 1~201S7.{1 ......;X ~~: 0' PH'fSl:I."Ji QQ. SJ;>:I~'E ~ eG Of.G~H; O~ C;;E:':.'.'l'II.LS I "~:." ....l'~'~.' 0," 11'\' ".,'" n' 'V""Fft-~"r' "'Jiit"" 0S(}994 ': 10m c~;:c, (} \l I': ..,I~~N' ;":1\1\ \ 3~ ..,.~::. :c; \l J~ p.,'fSLCIAtl S Sl:PD1.1E"' S aUINU HolM:: .....=:OAE~S z'P' C::: ,Pt-CNE' DANIEL P HELY elf; BELVEDERE CARlJSU, rr, 2'.", "'CCE~i A5SIG"",'~~lj1 If Of ;M oa-t Mt toKo 57(, X YES ii NO 3c N"".~:. .lNC "'COReSS OF F"CII,.Il'f 'WHERE sc.~v"lS WEA~ ~E';CE.RE.:' III 0,:"" IN- "Ot"'" 01 o"!ctl 2~ P...jIE~.T S .....'::OU~.T hC MO STREET 1701 :< 1 G:lI:' N,' ~ 3 9 :, C " (:14':'[ ,....;:OJ! ........ i . I -. .' ~ ~~ {EO IY M.l.lt, COUNC1L C~I."EOIC.l\.. SE~VICE.' It '" J:,~~ orUUT,..n ....".... <,~S ~ C >: "" :; Co c :: C I.. .- ~ = c ~ '- ;:: c t. Iy , ,... G 11 ;. I ;' ,e ;:: '"" ::; - c '- ~~ :c: 'I... Ie: :~ .(.": Ie I~ 1< 1<; . if. ,,. \E i , Pll Iim 'II~ I : <'5-1 ~2'a&28 ! COlpany -- PatID: li~0i Policy t -- 2~2 2.,SI2~3 Plm.:UiiEH, FI ;.. i~!li:!: S~a~!lfn~ ~/0./~4 - 05/0&/~' Suarant :r --- 000e57.-e0'a1 ~p !P ~1,Jr.:Fa -- er~';p ; Other lnio Hol~lr YJJ.:FFlJ~,:I! J~;E7 lC'~~., .~- ------------ 11\1 Patilnt llau -------------- uHcri?H ~:\ C~!!:r: (~ir:2: ------...----------------------- C;~I c.~':~"; Di!:~': e~~; Dia;~: en2 r.':'.~ l'>.:l Kf<l:i'i':1h:I, J~)iEi '.\ , \ ~Ui'r.ORlIAiI ell :ltl: hd: Pcctt : e~~0Si&-0001 Mliliion : Oi Ichar.la: G'J E3"3 ~;:;Tlm MC~E;.Hi:: ~mi~/Sir.HI~II(.'{E ~Jm LE5 l'.':';"i\ Sir.HIN f:!.~Lin P;'BiCA ~Hi~ii }o!.':Liri h~ERiCA hO!\;'Sl:-E{i ~~.~~ I......... .-;.. l:n~r Total Dilabilit1 : Partial Dillbilit11 ihru r.,r'l Totall Frol e5/0&/~% Thru eS/0&/~' ~0.C'a 0.e-a 0.~ 0.00 0.00 Charg!l PerIanal PaYlentl : lnlurance Pa11entll Total Payuntl 0.10 -%~.00 .'U0 .iii: ~:; ::::1: ~ri~_i~: ~e!~:f;4 ~:~: ~~ ~:~!): 1~~:1~~: :2i l~:,"::-l:~B E~f::,;i'H ti:;!lS) ----- ---------.. ~~:~ ~r:v:~:~ ;li:! ~~:!~ ~. v'.) r:.:~' -;0.~v "1\1.~~ Inj~r1i;rt:~i~c7: Esp\:y. ftlli~!~: N 0::' W, ,~ t-' Vi z~ :::::' w "j' () ~:e' I.I')O~ -tr;['..- 0:: ,=, -. tr) , - :a:x~-.= c-\:: A'.... '..t--, ,"",",-- .., . Q.,..::3t:' ..J""'-- 11'\- ~ f' ct--:--- 0:: = t- ~ Z .< LW U U , , ~ \'.." '. ." 'l' <:' 'l' -0 'l' ..... o o e:: :t: < - - c ,. - i - - c < . l" 0 - 0 r- - ,..; <l: ;: "- - Z to? :J<I l'.!J <I - .... ~I- ..... .::: .::: -'! "- :x: ..1 t!l ::t:::t l'.!J :c - .... ....'..., ..... ~'" .J ... <IO 0 -,t't) Q .~ ;..... . c :1 -, '. :. -' :- t5:af ~~.I! ~;~! o . 10 l" (l) I- Z o U o :3 W Z .... "- to? Cl:: - Z I- ... :3 tl) :J . Z W 0 I- ..... ... l- e:: <: :3 - ... eo:: L:: 0 0 l.L. :z .J ..... .J <I W U U :z w <:: tl) e:; <t :J W r...1') .J Z c.. ..... ,....... .- .- 'J. 0 .' j 'l 0 l .' . . ! r I . . :~if .' I . I ; ~~Al ":.. uid . , , <r. I'" C'J I'" <r. ~ 0 I 0 0 CI:: 0 :I: . I ~, .... '" r,. cc "l . W <:l 0 .... 11'; 0 ~ V, ~ :< . , Z -.:: . . 0 , '. - ~ 0;:) : - i . . " W I -.0 - (J =_ v,e .., ;: -v.f"- 0 \ o:\C-~ - 0 i . ~~""" III ",..- \roC I'" c--.:: - CO ~.... .r-- ~ - , c: C. --- 5 . 'r-- . ,.....- <r -J'-:-- 9 CJ ,.. - r-- c::(.......- :I: >- .... I'" . \.J<l:IX<l:i:! a: ~ 0 - f:CJ<l:CJ\.J 0 5: I-I%:....:t: .... ..: r- ;:. )(!XI-IIX<t Z < ... \.JWIXW , , :< :l:1l.:l:J: , W '-' ~? 2: UI -~ C) >W....t-:c: -"- <t Z ZZ Zi- : :,,:}- .... ([....IXUlCfJ CI:: " ....JL.!J%.:J ~ U. .....tlJ:;,., "- III "L!.n-'\t~ to) - ? :1:;:1 e> J: z ... I-tr.' ..... C'I W -I r. Z~ .... ..., <::0 C r- ,M It; <:''f<l'<:'<:' ~~~c-~ ",......, I'-'f'fr~r,. or.(".I....... "'" <"lijll'i"-j"- ,......., ", --- i.,.., . ., . -..... ,. ., .. , .",~ } ....~i P, --.,' t'",,: " . ; . ~.. .. .....,... .- 1 ' . . !.,: .. , . ' PEGPLES DRUG . I 102 C~qLlSlE PLAZA MALL. C~;'L!5LE. PA . , '.'.-J~LEPHOIjE: 252-3245. I :i ~..':.!:. ....:....~..- ". ," ;;REC~~}~'P.~~r~3i J 1~i~ki2~94! 5TR~! 6271 "IX 35:24C 200 1942 U9i ~ .' .... ~:;'..'..~....~~~:'.~':. '0 .: .~.; . .~ . ... -,',.)ti~TDTAL ':;- ','.' ~A9 '.... PA.~.O% TAX .27 . lOi,;L 4.76 , 'CASH 5.00 7' C~~~h-G}:,. "r .24, I 'U'',;: " IHfJiX YOU ,Cc.'iE AGAIN : ,"-" " ~.; . .. .,... .. I , : I!A!'<CH 15. 1994 '. 4: 10 FK; .' , ':" '. '~".o ,- ;:.- '.~ ;o:.n. CVI PBAIlKACT, /I~1? OA%E/TIKE - 01/0./9. IIUM 37009501 01 1617 Pa.a.JUiA,CI:It . a ID%I)CII'r PACE' 1 . 01/01/9. TaRU 01/0./9. CVI PILUKAC'Y 11617 Lla11S1 , 101 CAJU.ISI.& PI.\ZA IW.L nlllJW. ':AX 10 CAJU.lS1.1 PI. 170130000 1M , (717) 243-1351 IWIFlIWl.JMET m.u-. ( ) 191.7551 7013 ~IILZ PX 'MILT ACCCUWr , 002nl CAJU.ISI.I PI. 17013 JWJn'IWI.= IIRnllAr 01/21/ II 01 SEX , , ~CIl 8 ., N'l. lIDC" OIlUC'OElCllIP'r1Cl1l CCC'Cll-INlI 12 00371052101 lJlOPQXY-I/APAP 100-650 ~ O.P. KELT )1 0037101111' DOX)CYCLlKE 100HC CAPsutz K R)IISOI.~r A OAD II OIU9I n. 011591 n QUAIl 20 11 3rTl un un 3nrl-$ .00 .00 3PrU'$ CUIT-$ 3.67 3.H PJUa-$ 3.17 3.H KEKlEll 01 wrAI.I 7.01 .00 .00 7.01 I IlDD1' CD:1'Irr ':11M' 'rIlZI1 Olues MIl (II IT OJrlD'" 8IS (ClIID) PDSOIW.' I . , ,.:~~.~~\~~ 1ft'! SIc::Q.T'U'U , . . I j' " , I ~ R:::: 6!C0934- Y.AUFFM~N,JANET 7043 CARLISLE PI( C~RLI SLE, PA 03/13/1917:;- FH Lor 335 17013 IBUPF::JFEN 4001'16 TABLET Q~v:30 NOC:: 50732-0744-01 D~vs: 10 Oria Dt:03/1S/1994 Dr : HEL Y , D~Nl EL RPh: RGB J hi.1th;: 31S'7S792 U1.C'PRICE ':l ~" .....1.) COPAY= 3.00 ~ . - 245.,.91 I ~~~~,i 249.5691 "IIOWI' rllSCDflOH srmcr- - PATIENT CONSULTATION- R:~t; 6100934 "AUFFMANIJ~NET I BUPF:OFE~ 400:16 (:~!le:~<;~4 TA::LET FH Ni:lNSTEROI DAL ~~IT! - It 'rU.~:1I\- TGRY DRUGS - CRAL WHY ~M I TAKING Ti-!!S Di=:!JG? For ar~hiitic cp~cit;~~s, ~-ln l~zl-"'-"" ~ ~n ... -. '-r- CI . ". C,U....IC\ ...... . . co."':'. . 0\.1 SHi:lULD 1 TAKE tn Toke with fo~c cr antccij to rccuc: st~Mo~h u:::~. Avoid ~lcoh~l or ~5~ir~~. Follcl"" d\:)ctcq_1E. ii,='':':''~':- ti~ns. R~pOit ot~E~ t~~gi vc.u tC\~e/d i :==i.:;;:; ....:.1.: r.e:1i:. ARC TH=R= A'I'I cu'" 'E==="T=7 Ve~y ur:likE\~/,-tut i'i:'p::;'t~' E"-/--- prcki--- ~;ZZ;-l"t . 1:: 'C'C\1 _..11::'.:_=. \.0.... 1__ .. 'r'ln-L'cn r.:--~~l ~~-r--- . u ICIllo"', ,'C"IIo_ ..,II-=- .,::;,~, difficulty brcathlr.c. bloody s~~ols. -. PLEASE KEEP THIS RECEIPT FOR YOUR TAX AND INSURANCE RECORDS THANK YOU ' -,--'-'---~--'-" -- -.---------.....--- _. -....... .. ...-- \ \ \ , , \ J i I i I I I ; "- , -~1 I I . ! 1 . ... . -" --.-. - .... ...,--- --.---..--.....-. ---.... - - - . . -------- --------.. . .I l i~ " l ~ . l' " 249:569l . 245-5898 '. , R:::: 6100934 llII. HELY ; ~v"UF~"J''''' J.......'CT 1'.13/18/94' \ ,....,....., ,11,.,1.. ~ l"'\.~.... 'd, t" T',t:,.. CT ":: TT...IC'= ,.,^ [.^'; 1..,".,"','-.', . u n~~~' ~ .......~ n,. .~ I 8C!\ ill - ill jJIl1 BUPRCFEi"~ 40CMG TAE-LET J ? ,.r: MOT;:; IN 4':;l~~:5 T AEL!OT .!tOt.v: 31) Mfo: LUCHE~~ F;~T Lft:2.(;t) F:~h: ESP (13/1S/1S;'::" 'Fi;:~ 61(;(;g2~ F:F'~.:r-;t:B C2:1G:'7~' K~UFFt'lA~:. J~~~ET ~0722-(J7;'4-(~~ 7043 C~ELISLE Ft'. C~~.L!SLS~ f~. !,~ I:~F'::::~::~i '!~'~~3 V,;~:T F:: ~~,H~~Yft~~I::~ ~~:iC~;~: :,:~ t ~,:~ I" I.... l \, . . \ \., cu.u:.:mml ~ -~ . . , . . . , . ~IATES It-C. ~ BlCG SllTE 109 STREET 17013 fill f : 23-1929'361 , ~ f'A S; jrIl. JPNfT M. ,225 ,-E. PA ~5 I:elized Statement 01/26/94 - 02/28/$ Page: 1 (c) Elt'Clll9 Printed: 02/28/$ 4:13 flI AcetlO: 541:3 SSH : 17013 ~r: Address/Telephonel: , piCl! ea.pany ~1H N1ERICA i ~te(s) Patient Name I i Policy I Group I Otber Info fkllder Effective Oite(s) 232 06251000 ~ P.O. OOX 2610 Pln56..F.Sl. PA 1sz;0-2610 WFlWl. JPNET II. Code lP.scrip tion Qty/Src Charged Open Provider Place Coml KPlJFFlWl. J~ET II. 99215 OlagP: 922.3 OlagS: 466.0 Oiag3: 473.9 LEVEL 5-EST. PATtEN! CINlI.6ICtS. 8ACl< ERCtOUlIS AClJIE SIN..5IT1S 1.00 100.00 100.00 EMIEL OfC I I KPlJffl'A'l. .JF.NET II. 93000IP OiagP: 922.3 0lagS: 466.0 El<G CINlI.6ICt5. 8ACl< EWt.'iITlS AClJIE 1.00 55.00 56.00 !RAIEL OfC KPlJFFrAN. JANET II. !F.025 ca: & PlATELET 1.00 16.00 0.00 EP.AZEL OFC 0lagP: 922.3 rom.slCtS. 8ACl< 0lagS: o1Co5.0 ERa ellilS AClJIE 1tS4 t'AP HE.~L ill F....E.~ICA PAYl'1EIIl Insur -14.00 ~S4 Hf/,"roJ fiEAL ill MfRlCA FD..umIENI Inlur -2.00 \ KPlJFFi"A'l. JI.'IET II. 81000 LRltlAL'tSIS l.€e 13.00 0.00 EMIEL CF~ OiagP: 922.3 CINlI.6ICtS. 8ACl< ~94 OiagS: 466.0 fmOlITlS AClJIE ....? HrAL 1H F.~E.~ICA PAY11ENI Insur -1l.00 ~94 HfA"PDJ HEAL lH F."fRlCA POJJSOOIT Insur -2.00 \ IOOFFrA'l. JA~ET II. 130016 IH6 CliNICAL OlaIlSlRY TESTS 1.00 4U0 UO SlAIEL eFC Olagp: 922.3 CINlI.6lCtS. PIO< .~: OiagS: 466.0 ERCt(HIllS AClJIE flAP htAL 1H P,~lCA PAYI'lENI lnsur -24.00 HfH'PDJ h'EALTH F/1E.~ICA POJJSTI1ENI Inlur -16.00 I ~ KPlJFFrAN. J~ET II. ::6415 ROUTINE VENIFUNCTUP.E/COlLECTIO 1.00 7.~ 0.00 fAAlEL Cf~ I IISSX:IATES He. IfRTS BLex; 9JITE 109 , pl STREET #, PA 17013 . j:~ 23-l.929:lil I , I ' . !. ~-<<'00 IIA 55 i ' fI'#l. JPllET M. I i r , ..."':;).. . ~', - .:~...:.,:~,:~.,. . : ,-.. . . . . . . . , . .' ~ llesl.zed Stat_nt 01/26/94 - 82/Z8/<}; hgt: 2 leI UCDI\l Printed: 12/7!1$ 4:13 FtI AcetlO: 5413 s:N : rOate(s) Patient Kame Open PrCYi~er PUe! Cud f/94 f/94 II II ~ ~ I ~ ~/S4 ~/S4 k k k k I ,~ 'b/$ ~de Ileseription Qty/Sre Charged 01.1gP: OiagS: 922.3 ~.0 l'AP HEA'\CIl.l CX:tIlI.5Iet.S. Bf(l( fflCrOllTlS AOJTE HEALtH N1fRlCA PA'Il1EIIT HEAltH N1fRICA PIl..l.611'lfNT Insur Insur -4.00 -3.50 KPlJffl'lOH. J.lNET II. 99213 LEVEt 3-EST. PATlOO 01.1gp: 922.3 a:rm.GIet.S. BACl( 1.N 37.00 37.00 EAAIEL OfC KPlJffl'lOH. .lPNET M. 99213 LEVEL 3-EST. PATIENT Oiagp: 724.3 SCIATICA 1.00 37.00 37.00 EAAIEL eFC KPlJffiWl. JPllET M. 99213 LEVEL 3-E5T. PATIENT Oiagp: 924.5 a:rm.GICN LEG KPlJffl'lOH. J.lNET II. 99212 LEVEL - . PATlOO U9 33.00 33.00 EAAIEl OfC DiagP: 455.0 ID-INT/ KPlJffl'HI. JPllET II. 45333 ""'QBE?SI~IOOSXlPY 1.N 2..'5.N 0.00 EAAIEl orc Di.1gP: ~..s.0 ).eo;pH:lID-INTEl<Ml ~AP 1i~P,'lfRlCA PAYI".oo Insur -lll.oo ... HUI'PDJ HE.1ltH Po'IfR1CA POl.51l'.oo Insur -U4.oo 1.00 31.00 31.00 EAAIEl OfC KPlJffl'lOH. JPllET II. 99212 LEVEL 2-EST. PATIENT Diagp: n9.5 PAi~l lila or,; 1.00 33.00 33.00 ro;E.~ 1.oa 37.00 37.CLl EGlER Cf': KPlJffl'lOH. JPllET II. 99213 DhgP: 3!2.9 OiagS: 312.30 KPlJffl'lOH. JPllET II.' 99212 LrA. ~ATIOO Diagp: 413.9 :,5i?t&ris" . , 1.00 33.00 3:),00 EnIEll OfC KPlJffl'lOH. JPllET M. 99213 LML 3-m. PATIENT DiagP: 726.5 a.RS1TI5 TllOJWITDlIC KP/Jffl'lOH. JPllEl II. 69211 " RE."CV.Jl--l~E!llr.lN OiagP: ~J~.;::r~ EAA5 .HEA"PDJ ~ N\fJllCA ~JU;TNNl 1.(0 31.N 31,00 EAAIEl OfC I.N 31.00 1.00 EAAlEl ore Insur -31.00 (;.; . .~..' . . . . , . . . io'S9XlATES I~. IllTS IllOO SJITE 109 , III StREET i ~PA 17013 ; Sl71 i i 10 : 23-l929361 , if' Itemized Stittlent 01/26/94 - 02/28/$ i : I1H000 I'A 55 I lWl. .lPNET ~. AcctlO: 5413 S2l : Oue(s) Pitient Name Code Cescripticn J(f(JfnoA'i. .wa ~. 99213 Ougp: 4n BilinC1!s Totals frail 01/26/94 Thru 02/28/$ SWnC1! 0.00 Ch.arges ~.50 "nce 0.00 '" rsonil Pi)'llll'n IS : 0.00 I BilanC1! 0.00 Insurince Pa)'llll'nts: -164.00 t Bilana> : 0.00 Total Pi)'llll'nts -164.00 lI1ana> 0.00 AdJus l1Iltnts -168.58 bt lli1ina>: 0.00 Coll. Pi)'llll'n ts 0.00 Coll. Adjusl1lltnts : U0 ~~';. I.... Qty/Src Charged . . . . Pige: 3 (c) Elctalp Printtd: 02/28/$ 4:13 R1 Open Provider PUC1! Castl 1.00 37.00 37.00 BlAIEL OfC '. 4. Summary of legal issues regarding admissibility of testimony, exhibits, or any other matter, and legal authorities relied on. Pursuant to Plaintiff's discovery request, Defendant produced a redacted copy of the J.C. Penney form entitled Report of Accident. Plaintiff filed a Motion to Compel challenging the validity of Defendant's assertion of privilege under Pa.R.C.P. 4003.3. Defendant contends that its assertion of privilege was proper, and a response to plaintiff's motion will be provided on or before June 19, 1996. 5. Identity of witnesses to be called: Don Kraus, Store Manager, J.C. Penney Co. Carlisle, Pa. Jennifer Ahrens, Merchandise Manager Joanne Largent, Sales Associate Sara Fry, Manager, Shoe Department Janet Kauffman, Plaintiff "Deb" Myers, previously identified by Plaintiff as witness to accident. J.C. Penney Co. reserves the right to supplement this list as discovery responses are provided by Plaintiff. 6. List of exhibits with identification of each: Photographs of the package pickup area, previously produced by Plaintiff, J.C. Penney Co. reserves the right to supplement this list as discovery responses are provided by Plaintiff. " 7. current status of settlement negotiations I \ I " \ . I settlement negotiations are ongoing. KBLLY, McLAUGHLIN Eo: POSTBR By: 0....;;:;:. - u. ill ~ ~ WILLIAM C. F STER, ESQUIRE ANTHONY V. INO III, ESQUIRE Attorneys for Defendant, J.C. Penney company, Inc. Dated: ~ JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 4977 CIVIL 1995 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED v. J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant mmEB -//' , AND NOW, this ~ day of [e,,, '--'~'1996, upon consideration of the Motion to Compel of Plaintiff Pursuant to Local Rule 4001-1; IT~O}f~ lECIIJ'.ED that a.."'.... ","'.""""wil, held on L ,,~\ IQ - fJ. 19~ before the Honorable "C l \. ". - \/.. IIJ: IJ() A_m.; 1/o1..-'-,? I \/' "-'(', 7"'-< .'..." (h'-fo,,'-l~,'\.../\ \ \ ' 1-----:- ,t' \.. I (~J-3l' L ......,-\ (C\ J-" ' \''-~L.....'''\ '- , }I.... IT IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT at the discovery conference the Defendant produce the entire investigative/claims file without deletions or redactions so the Court can determine discoverable portions that should be produced. BY THE COURT: 1/)1.)( J. JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 4977 CIVIL 1995 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED v. J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant ~OTION TO COMPEL OF pLAINTIFF ~ TO LOCAL RULE 4001~ AND NOW, comes Plaintiff, JANET KAUFFMAN, by her attorneys, Mette, Evans & Woodside, and files this Motion to Compel pursuant to Local Rule 4001-1 based on the following: 1. The above-captioned case is a slip and fall that occurred in the J.C. Penney store in Carlisle, Pennsylvania on January 26, 1994. 2. On December 5, 1995 the Plaintiff served on the Defendant a Request for Production of Documents, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "A". 3. On March 15, 1996, Plaintiff filed a Motion to Compel because the Defendant failed to respond to Plaintiffs discovery request. A copy of the Motion to Compel is attached as Exhibit "B". 4. Pursuant to the Plaintiffs Motion, the Court signed an Order dated March 19, 1996. a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "CWo 5. On April 11, 1996, Plaintiff received Defendant's response to Plaintiffs Request for Production of Documents pursuant to the Court Order. 6. On June 6, 1996, Plaintiff took the deposition of Jennifer Ahrens, the merchandise manager of J.C, Penney store concerning an accident report she authored as a result of the Plaintiffs slip and fall. The deposition revealed that the accident report was inappropriately redacted by the Defendant before it was produced to the Plaintiff deleting crucial information that this employee observed the day of the accident including defects discovered by the Defendant on the day of the accident and information concerning the lighting conditions. 7. During Ms. Ahrens' deposition, counsel for the Defendant stated on the record that items 24, 25, 29, 30, 40, 41 and 42 were redacted from the accident report. 8. The deposition of Ms. Ahrens and statements made by counsel for the Defendant during the deposition also revealed that there are other discoverable portions of the Defendant's claims file that has not been produced including statements taken of witnesses. (~ Exhibit A ,\ " JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION. LAW v. J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant NO. 95 - 4977. JURY TRIAL DEMANDED JlEQUE$T FOR PRODUCT JON OF DOCUMEm:S TO: Kathleen B. Gereaghty, Esquire Kelly, McLaughlin & Foster 1700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19102.5092 Pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. 4009, as amended, the Plaintiff, Janet Kauffman, by her attorneys, Mette, Evans & Woodside, requests you to produce copies of the following documents, at her expense, within thirty (30) days of service of this request. IN$TRUCTIQNS If you object to the production of any document on the grounds that the attorney.client, attorney work product or any other privilege is applicable thereto, you shall, with respect to that document: (a) State its date; " DOCUMENTS~EQUESTED 1. All statements, signed statements, transcripts of recorded statements or interviews of any person or witness relating to, referring to or describing any of the events described in the Complaint. 2. All expert opinions, (include experts resume or curriculum vitae) reports, summaries or other writings in your custody or control or your attorney or insurers, which relate to the subject matter of this litigation. 3. All documents, correspondence or other drawings, sketches, diagrams, or writings in your custody or control or your attorney or insurers, which relate to the subject matter of this litigation. 4. All documents prepared by you, or by any insurer, representative, agent, or anyone acting on your behalf, except your attorney(s), during the investigation of the incident in question or any of the events or allegations described in the Complaint. Such docwnents shall include any documents made or prepared up through the present time, with the exclusion of the mental impressions, conclusions, or the opinions respecting the value or merit of the claim or defense or respecting strategy or tactics. 5. All photographs of any item or thing involved in this litigation. 6. All statements as defined within Pa. R.C.P, No, 4003. 7. All statements and/or transcripts of interviews off act witnesses obtained in this matter. 8. All docwnents identified in your Answers to any set of Interrogatories propounded by any party in this litigation. 9. All docwnents which you intend to rely upon or introduce at trial of this litigation. HQIft: As referred to herein, ndocument" includes written, printed, typed, recorded, or graphic matter, however produced or reproduced, including correspondence, telegrams, other written communications, data processing storage units, tapes, contracts, agreements, notes, memoranda, analyses, projections, indices, work papers, studies, reports, surveys, diaries, calendars, films, photographs, diagrams, drawings, minutes of meetings, or any other writing (including copies of any of the foregoing, regardless of whether you are now in possession, custody, or control, your former or present counsel, agents, employees, officers, insurers, or any other person acting on your behalO. METTE, EVANS & WOODSIDE BY: ~~ ~=-~.::--- ANDREW H. DOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Court I. D. No. 39692 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 Telephone: (717) 232-5000 Attorney for Plaintiff DATED: December 5, 1995 , JANET KAUFFMAN, plaintiff v. J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant ,- - IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 95 - 4977 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED Q,ERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 1 hereby certify that 1 am this day serving a copy of the foregoing document upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below, which service satisfies the requirements of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, by depositing a copy of same in the United States Mail, at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, with first class postage prepaid, addressed as follows: Kathleen B. Gereaghty, Esquire Kelly, McLaughlin & Foster 1700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19102-5092 METrE, EVANS & WOODSIDE _..~- -- BY: ANDREW H. DOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Court I. D. No. 39692 3401 North Front Street p, O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110.0950 Telephone: (717) 232.5000 Attorney for Plaintiffs DATED: December 5, 1995 5'0*\\ -,.~<. echIbIt B ,\ '. v. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 4977 CIVIL 1995 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant ORDER AND NOW, this day of , 1996, upon consideration of the Motion to Compel of Plaintiff; IT IS HEREBY ORDER AND DECREED that Defendant shall fully and completely respond to Plaintiffs Request for Production of Documents within ten (10) days or suffer sanctions pursuant to Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure 4019. BY THE COURT: J. JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION. LAW NO, 4977 CIVIL 1995 JURY TRIAL DEl'ilANDED v. '" ,.., -.. ...:\ 'J '1 t , . " . . ) ; ""] ; " (. ;J I -', ':) :i - .' ) - ,.:;;1 ..., '. c.:.; d , J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant ~OTION TO COMPEL AND NOW, comes Plaintiff, JANET KAUFFMAN, by her attorneys, Mette, Evans & Woodside, and files this Motion to Compel based on the following: 1. This case involves a slip and fall that occurred on January 26, 1994 resulting in personal injury to the Plaintiff. 2. The Complaint in the above matter was filed in September of 1995. 3. On December 5, 1995, the Plaintiff filed a "Request for Production of Documentsn on the Defendant. A copy of the document request is attached as Exhibit "An. 4. To date, the Defendant has not responded to the document request. t "_ exhibit C ,\ 'j J" ','i' - <'J I:,.... '.',) JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff . . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW : . . v. J.C. PENNY CO., INC., Defendant NO. 95-4977 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this \~1\.day of March, 1996, upon consideration of plaintiff's Motion to Compel, a Rule is hereby issued upon Defendant to show cause why the relief requested should not be granted. RULE RETURNABLE within 20 days of service. BY THE COURT, rew H. Dowling, Esq. 01 North Front Street .0. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 Attorney for plaintiff Kathleen B. Gereaghty, Esq. KELLY, McLAUGHLIN' FOSTER 1700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad Street philadelphia, PA 19102-5092 Attorney for Defendant :rc -........ ---.... . . : '. ,''( ::~0\1 RECORD . , -. ..t..... ....~ . , "- ,.' '.: ~ -. . p\.>. . " ..l,,::zt. 0'1 0; 7r]<lN' . 19 9.~. .............JJh..r.'1 a.. ~ . ".... -'f"4w,............ ,t;{iiq' Prothonotary '.I" ",' " .,.", ;~::\.',~~~"!:. '-,- , ,,~,.' , ,_ " ' >~" ;,\1 ~ -, , j,"" .:. ,', ;;~:;:;; ';' ," 0 . ;;..': c ~ 'n ~ ~ 1""<tt~ ,.,..~ .~I"- ~;:::,,-'~~ '};~>';I' , ' "~, ~ , ' ".<" ^,,\~~4.~.:j" " ,JJ~: :. ''itF;u~' . , _."0,, JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 16', 4Cf-r7 {}A. (l, (, ,)It. n.--- v. J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant JURY TRIAL DEMANDED NOTICE YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the Court without further notice for any money claimed in the Complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP, LAWYER REFERRAL SERVICE COURT ADMINISTRATOR CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE CARLISLE, PA 17013 TELEPHONE: (717) 240-6200 tiQl'ICA Le han demandado a usted en la corte. Si usted quiere defenderse de estas demandas expuestas en 188 paginas siguientes, usted tiene viente (20) dias de plazo al partir de la fecha de la demand a y la notificacion. Usted debe presentar una apariencia escrita 0 en persona 0 por abogado y archivar en la corte en forma escrita sus defensas 0 sus objecionesa las demandas en contra de su persona. Sea avisado que si usted no se defiende, la corte tomara medidas y puede entrar una orden contra usted sin previo aviso 0 notificacion y por cualquier queja 0 alivio que es pedido en la peticion de demanda. Usted puede perder dinero 0 sus propiedades 0 otros derechos importantes para usted. LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABODAGO IMMEDIATAMENTE. SI NO TIENE ABOGADO 0 SI NO TIENE EL DINERO SUFFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICIO, VAYA EN PERSONA 0 LLAME POR TELEFONO A LAOFICINA CUYA DIRECCION SE ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE SU PUEDE CONSEGUlR ASISTENCIA LEGAL. LAWYER REFERRAL SERVICE COURT ADMINISTRATOR CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE CARLISLE, PA 17013 TELEPHONE: (717) 240-6200 v. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff J.C. PENNEY CO" INC., Defendant NO. CIVIL 1995 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ~QMPLA.lm AND NOW, comes Plaintiff, JANET KAUFFMAN, by her attorneys, Mette, Evans & Woodside, and files this Complaint against the Defendant, J.C. Penney Co., based on the following: 1. Plaintiff, JANET KAUFFMAN, is an adult individual residing at P. O. Box 225, Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania. 2. Defendant, J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., is a Delaware Corporation with registered offices at CT CORPORATION SYSTEM, 1635 Market Street, Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania 19103. 3. The accident hereinafter related occurred on January 26, 1994 in the catalogue department of the J.C, Penney Co. store located at 250 Carlisle Plaza Mall, Carlisle, Pennsylvania. 4. At the aforesaid time and place, the Plaintiff was shopping at the Defendant's establishment and, therefore, was a business invitee of the Defendant to which the highest degree of care is owed by the Defendant to the Plaintiff. 5. At the aforesaid time and place, the Plaintiff fell as a result of what Plaintiff subsequently learned was a wet floor resulting in serious injuries as hereinafter described. 6. The Defendant had a duty to maintain the aforesaid floor area in a safe condition for its customers, 7. The Defendant had a duty to inspect the aforesaid floor area for dangerous and defective conditions, 8. At the aforesaid time and place, the aforesaid floor area existed in a dangerous and defective condition, 9. The negligence, carelessness and/or recklessness of the Defendant consisted, iDW: BliJl, of the following: - 2 . (a) Maintaining the floor area of the catalogue department in a dangerous and defective condition; (b) Failing to inspect the floor area of the catalogue department for dangerous and defective conditions; (c) Failing to remove, clean or eliminate the water on the floor in the catalogue department; (d) Failing to warn customers of the wet floor in the catalogue department; (e) Failing to place carpet in the aforesaid mentioned area to prevent the slippery condition caused by water on a tile floor. 10. As a direct result of the Defendant's negligence, carelessness and/or recklessness, Plaintiff suffered serious and permanent injuries including: (a) Injuries to Plaintiffs head when her head hit the counter as she fell on the wet floor; (b) Injuries to her shoulder and back; (c) Injuries to her hip and leg; .3. ld) Injuries to her nerves and discs of her spinal column causing a bulging and protruding disc; (e) Injury to her knee. 11. As a direct result of the aforesaid negligence, carelessness and/or recklessness, Plaintiff incurred medical bills and will continue to incur medical bills. 12. As a direct result of the aforesaid negligence, carelessness and/or recklessness, Plaintiff sustained lost wages and a loss of earning capacity. WHEREFORE, plaintiff demands judgment in her favor and against the Defendant and the Plaintiff be awarded an amount in excess of $25,000 and that the Plaintiff be awarded costs and other relief as the Court deems just. ME'ITE, EVANS & WOODSIDE BY~---=-"-- . ANDREW H. uOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Court l. D. No. 39692 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110.0950 Telephone: (717) 232.5000 Attorneys for plaintiff DATED: September 18, 1995 .4. ~ I, JANET KAUFFMAN, hereby acknowledge that I am the Plaintiff in this action; that I have read the foregoing Complaint; and that the facts stated therein are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. I understand that any false statements herein are made subject to penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. Section 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. ~/)~ /(~ J T KAUFFMAN DATED: -". ~. '~:. ' . -"",.- - - .... ::-HEtIFF . illT l]t" 1,:'It.:" ;'. ~.~ .~. . ,'., ~; ~-j I=^""F Nfl: i~j':~~I-1.!14'~I'''''/ F C('IMM',\IIWEAUH OF PUINSYl ':Alll/\: COUIITY ':1F CV~18F:RI.AIIl> li~l::~:1."lL ~A!lE_T_ \'5. E..,Et,iJI.E:L J_~__CI~~ )-'~, __~. ._J]I~='~_:.3~.~_t~D.~ ,'r.. " ! !. w ~ . ~. j : r .., to I.::}..... :~-3y',. t h ,it t,>> ", j,j;. '11 :'l' t;<, 1.11,': I; .., I!; 'll: " n;')J'l1(.lrj der(>nr1.1ni t (, 'ri I t Ti" FEt~N_EY " ; I t".l~. ....)S 1,Jn03b 1.::- f 't',_' ., '''''! " ~ ~ . o! 11:" ~ ;j. .,. < ~.' 'i;::'P\lt_l:;~': tt:.,~ '-h~~l'" ,;" F 11::,\ . t(, ~-::i:,r'l.'(' +'71f;' "'J+nl: '-I~f LA; r~;' 'rl O,,~ . ';...' V ~~ I - - , , '. h.;' ~ \ , '.' 't,. : , " 0, , I , ,.. r.\. w 0 , , H 1 r~ H:: ,\: .' ;:: r-:~' r 11 ! +..: I,.':' .'. ;. ~ '. ': Y. (, ,_ J. n~:; ,..,.1 t , f ,'J ';u r ChJ I l~' F"HILA . '~ii~tl:":' . , .. , 0, " . , ,1 r, 0 '" /.- .-' '-~~""-~.;./ ,~ ';, ! ( .-t, '. . ",.1 ~~ '.,: ,; r ... ..' ". . j ~-, ... . ~ I ~ ,,- 'j{ i-, ..,~_L , \ ~{;~,,~. Ii: Th:: Court CT C~mrnO:1 .. '..... -i " r 1S:S or - " .. ? I . . ..p-,.- ..u,.........-oj .., ,_..., . - C'!' ,~........ \..:.J..._.:". ._n.... I",...l.:., ./, :::nr:..y /_..1... Janet Kauffman V5. J.C. Penney Co., Inc.. ::-fe. 95-4977 ~ivil Term --. :~- :-iow, Sept. 20. 1995 :'9_ !. S~.!:~ 03' C~GE?..!.~'m CO~~':'? ?A,.. co :===1 ci.;:u= ::h: .5h.::::i' ai Philadelphia CAu::ty :0 ==:-.:t: -.:. 'tV:::, ... .. . ., . ... -,..- :::s ~::u=:cu ::~ -.....- u == ~ ::C1 ~ Ot :.:: :':3:::.::I. r~~J~~ Si1e..~ Q~ C:-':'er.:u:d C.,u:ry, ?:L. _A ffida.vit or - . '::=e:"'71c.e :-iow, ~9 .. o'dea ',e. l=:-."":"i -- :::: wi.;":" ~11 1; =r ::u::~ :.a . cpr ci = ~.~. .,1 ... :md -~,.- Cawu :0 :.:.: .:::t::s ::::.-::L So :u:sw=. Shc:::5 of Collin." ?:. 5wco :md S::Csc:-:i:ed bCcn: =:: ::::s c!:r.y oi !~- COSTS ,,~ o<,'VICZ ~au..-\GE .-\:: ilJA ""IT s s Z_ '-II SHERIFF'S RETURN - SUMMONS/COMPL.AINT ',. f4v fIt;;;p; ;[ (] fltlllll~ 'fItv (]j (}}/f SERVED AND MADE KNOWN TO COMMON PLEAS NO, It J1 Iy iY/' W"#17 (/lit)f!t, NO, t. ,Ji?j5J'7iRM. 19 IltJot/L ;f1?JJ7~ &-~ ._ tb/j'? o Defendant ~ndant Company by handin, f \rue ond allested copy of the within Summons IComplaint, issued in lhe;?e captioned mailer on fL1! 7f}bEI(. /tJ;1 ,19 f5 ,at )ta, o'clock, M., E,S.TJD.S.T, at It 5S ;JJd/'1i1 .Y- /lP~", in the County of Philadelphia, State of Pennsylvania, to t!r /i;~ - din ire~r._,,_- o (1) the aforesaid defendant, personally; o (2) an adult member of the family of said defendant, with whom said defendant resides, who staled that his/her relationship to said defendant is that of o (3) an adult person in charge of defendant's residence; the said adult person having refused, upon reo quest, to give his/her name and relationship to said deit:..dant; o ~ the manager/clerk of the place of lodging in which said defendant resides; !Zi'(5) agent or person for the time being in charge of defendant's oflice or usual place of business, o (6) the and officer of said defendant Company; , ,.. ..,....,.. l(,....\:' "'..l,;:. ,;~ E~: ,~ "'~( Ifr I, UT 24 __'IJ So Answers, JOHN O. GIUEN, She,i" ~~.I I:"} J'uL-l NoIBriaI SeeI PulIID By: Je<leIIe Ba"', al,.lf.. NolalY county , PI1llade1pllla, Ptl~", 4, ,* I My commlsSK)I1 1....__ MontlflI, Pwrsy\IlI1I- ,-- III 17,1' 'Ph. 12-117) v. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant NO. 95 - 4977 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT'S "NEW MATl'ER- rURSUANT TO PA RULE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE l0311 13.15. Averments in paragraphs 13 through 15 are legal inclusions to which no answer is required. To the extent that an Answer is required, each and every allegation of negligence is hereby specifically denied. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment in her favor and against the Defendant that the Defendant's New Matter be dismissed with prejudice. METTE, EVANS & WOODSIDE BY: ANDREW H. DOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Court l. D. No, 39692 3401 North Front Street P. 0, Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110.0950 Telephone: (7171 232.5000 Attorneys for Plaintiff DATED: December 5, 1995 . JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION. LAW NO. 95 . 4977 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED v. J,C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving a copy of the foregoing document upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below, which service satisfies the requirements of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, by depositing a copy of same in the United States Mail, at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, with first class postage prepaid, addressed as follows: Kathleen B. Gereaghty, Esquire Kelly, McLaughlin & Foster 1700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19102.5092 ME'M'E, EVANS & WOODSIDE BY: . --- - -=--- c--- .......- ANDREW H. DOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Court 1. D. No. 39692 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110.0950 Telephone: (717) 232.5000 Attorney for Plaintiffs DATED: December 5,1995 ~1111Hi) I : ~. ' :..,::, '. :.;::~.~~ ;., ,o.'F " ~ ;> , 'I. ',".!'-' .... I _ .. - ... ~ . r ."- JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW . . . . . . v. J.e. PENNY CO., INC., Defendant . . NO. 95-4977 CIVIL TERM AND NOW, this ORDER OF COURT I,tLday of March, 1996, upon consideration of Plaintiff's Motion to Compel, a Rule is hereby issued upon Defendant to show cause why the relief requested should not be granted. RULE RETURNABLE within 20 days of service. BY THE COURT, Andrew H. Dowling, Esq. 3401 North Front Street P.O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 Attorney for Plaintiff Kathleen B. Gereaghty, Esq. KELLY, McLAUGHLIN' FOSTER 1700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19102-5092 Attorney for Defendant . . r ~ 3/.;J.oft",. ~ C~.. (\'Ml.....~ ,J. f- Ire . . JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 4977 CIVIL 1995 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED v. J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant QBDER AND NOW, this day of , 1996, upon consideration of the Motion to Compel of Plaintiff; IT IS HEREBY ORDER AND DECREED that Defendant shall fully and completely respond to Plaintiffs Request for Production of Documents within ten (10) days or suffer sanctions pursuant to Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure 4019. BY THE COURT: J. 6U!1;e111 ExhIbIt A '. v, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW JANET KAUFFl\lAN, Plaintiff J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant NO. 95 - 4977. JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ,REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIQN OF DOCUMENTS TO: Kathleen B. Gereaghty, Esquire Kelly, McLaughlin & Foster 1700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19102-5092 Pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. 4009, as amended, the Plaintiff, Janet Kauffman, by her attorneys, Mette, Evans & Woodside, requests you to produce copies of the following documents, at her expense, within thirty (30) days of service of this request. INSTRUCTIONS If you object to the production of any document on the grounds that the attorney-client, attorney work product or any other privilege is applicable thereto, you shall, with respect to that document: (a) State its date; (b) Identify its author; (c) Identify each person who prepared or participated in the preparation of the document; (d) Identify each person who received it; (e) Identify each person from whom the document was received; (f) State the present location of the document and all copies thereof; (g) Identify each person who has ever had possession, custody or control of it or a copy thereof; and, (h) Provide sufficient information concerning the document and the circumstances thereof to explain the claim of privilege and to permit the adjudication of the property of that claim. 5. All photographs of any item or thing involved in this litigation. 6. All statements as defined within Pa. R.C.P. No. 4003. 7. All statements and/or transcripts of interviews offact witnesses obtained in this matter. 8. All documents identified in your Answers to any set of Interrogatories propounded by any party in this litigation, 9. All documents which you intend to rely upon or introduce at trial of this litigation. NOTE: As referred to herein, "document" includes written, printed, typed, recorded, or graphic matter, however produced or reproduced, including correspondence, telegrams, other written communications, data processing storage units, tapes, contracts, agreements, notes, memoranda, analyses, projections, indices, work papers, studies, reports, surveys, diaries, calendars, films, photographs, diagrams, drawings, minutes of meetings, or any other writing (including copies of any of the foregoing, regardless of whether you are now in possession, custody, or control, your fornler or present counsel, agents, employees, officers, insurers, or any other person acting on your behalf), METrE, EVANS & WOODSIDE ---- -. -- BY: ~-~ ~--: ' ,--'- ANDREW H. DOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Court 1. D. No. 39692 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110.0950 Telephone: (717) 232-5000 Attorney for Plaintiff DATED: December 5, 1995 v. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff J.C, PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant NO. 95 . 4977 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED !;;ERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving a copy of the foregoing document upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below, which service satisfies the requirements of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, by depositing a copy of same in the United States Mail, at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, with first class postage prepaid, addressed as follows: Kathleen B. Gereaghty, Esquire Kelly, McLaughlin & Foster 1700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19102-5092 METTE, EVANS & WOODSIDE BY: -' ANDREW H. DOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Court I. D. No. 39692 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110.0950 Telephone: (717) 232.5000 Attorney for Plaintiffs DATED: December 5, 1995 .ilH~l I ..",~",c.-,,,,,, ...,.,\",".A,\<,.~,:,(, ....,.'J'~.G '0" "C'UIIl'@ "';;;til;iI,,,,,,,;,;",~"'~~,I'''':'';'--'';\,;'''~'!<'f-''~'~'i''iIi!r~'-<jI'Mf"''li Ji!:~' .' . ElchIbIt B --~ '\ 'j , HQYtu C. MInt. JAMU W t.VAlol~ ,"OIUT MOQU CHA,"wa z'AUY "TO. J a.UUU. UOYD '" ptJ.j1J}l CMIG A STONE JAMU A UUH DANltL L ~UUIVMol nf.Vf.N D SNYDER CHItLSTOPHU C. CO}l}lEa. UYSE.t.llo:.U.S AtroUW H. DOWU}lG MICHAtL D RUD METTE. EVANS" WOOD81DJoJ I\OmT P. HAYl<lU W PAULA J UJCHT GARY J H1lM DAVID A nTnlMON~ GUY p, u.mVf.NTANO MICHAEL D PlPA ItAI\Elol lol coNNW Y a.OIYN J lATZJr.tAlol JAYSON R. WOlfGANG WZAlf.TH M. CALCAGNO uw. Y L HOffMAN ""A TTHt.W A COU-lolZA lATl-IUl'tl 0 YAloltNEK DAwa M CAMPIW. A PROFEliSIOSAL CORI-oKATIO:ol ATTORNEYS AT LAW 3"01 NORTH FRONT STREET P.O. BOX 6960 HARRISBURG. PA 17UO-OO60 T!J.1PHON' (711) 232.'!lOOO ,^x (1m 230.lIU6 UTtl\lD ROIo. T L WOODSIDE I"-S)IIO 2J.10e~'!l February 13, 1996 Kathleen B. Gereaghty, Esquire Kelly, McLaughlin & Foster 1700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19102-5092 RE: JANET KAUFFM.AN v. J.C. PENNEY CO.. INC. CML ACTION LAW NO. 95-49'77 Dear Ms. Gereaghty: On December 5, 1995 1 sent you a Request for Production of Documents. To date, you have not responded to my document request. Very truly yours, ---= - ---- _ c --- ANDREW H. DOWLING AHD:cf cc: Otto Biller Liberty Mutual Group Janet Kauffman 51u~H , ! i i ! I \ I I I I hereby certify that I am this day serving a copy of the foregoing d()C\1Jllent upon tho ,._(.1..... tho .......' Ind'"'''' "low, wbicl> """.. yt""" tho ...ui""'.... or tho Pe_,..... 'm" of Ciw ..-"" by ..,..ilin' · - or ..m." ih. Uni"" S..... Mon, .t H"""",,,' Pe."',,,...., wiih ."t - ,,- pre"id, .dd...... .. followS: JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff v. J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION. LAW NO. 95 - 4977 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ~ERTlflCATE OF RERV1~ Kathleen B. Gereaghty, Esquire Kelly, McLaUghlin & Foster 1'700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad Street philadelphia, PA 19102-5092 ME'I'l'E. EVANS & WOODSIDE BY; ~J~ ANDREW H. DOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Court 1. D. No. 39692 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 Telephone; (717) 232-5000 Attomey for Plaintiffs DATED: March 15. 1996 51"Il\ I " ~. _. "':;/ t <.<" ...,' ,i," ...0.-....- '.\,:.- :,' .. f-{';~' :.,"":' :y ~ 18" rc o roO L.. f'i:n ~~ ,1L.,,.. q -,'\ -": " -~ " .,-"., ..' .1 '.' t , .J ,c,.," , JANET KAUFFMAN, I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF Plaintiff I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA I v. I CIVIL ACTION - LAW . . J.C. PENNEY COMPANY, INC. , I Defendant I NO. 95-4977 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this ~~(lday of April, 1996, upon consideration of Plaintiff's Motion To Compel Production of Documents, and of the Response of Defendant, J.C. Penney Company, Inc., to Plaintiff's Motion To Compel Production of Documents, Plaintiff's motion is DEEMED MOOT. BY THE COURT, Andrew H. Dowling, Esq. 3401 North Front Street P.O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 Attorney for Plaintiff - c.~ '1.- ~J. 'l/J'flfih, .-6 -{'. William C. Foster, Esq. Anthony V. Mannino, III, Esq. 1700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad street Philadelphia, PA 19102 Attorneys for Defendant :rc . . CERTIPICATE OP SERVICE Anthony V. Manninno, III, Esquire, hereby certifies that he caused a copy of the foregoing Response of Defendant J. C. Penney Company, Inc. to Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Production of Document to be served by first-class mail, postage prepaid to the following parties at the addresses listed below: Andrew H. Dowling, Esquire METTE, EVANS & WOODSIDE 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 DATE: ~ /IL.,/q(p I ' BY: CLL.-h..-I j AtJ..-..> . Ql' WILLIAM C I FOSTER, ESQUIRE ' ANTHONY V. MANNINO, III, ESQUIRE Attorneys for Defendant J. C. Penney Company, Inc. 5. Admitted that Plaintiff sent the correspondence dated February 13, 1996, requesting that the Defendant respond to the document request. Denied as stated that there has been no response to Plaintiff's correspondence. It is averred, to the contrary, that Defendant supplied a response to the Request for Production on April 8, 1996. See Exhibit "A". 6. Admitted that Defendant is represented by Kelly, McLaughlin & Foster, 1700 Atlantic Building, 260 South Broad Street, Philadelphia, PA 19102, and that Kathleen B. Gereaghty was an attorney working on the case at that time. WHEREFORE, Defendant J.C. Penney Company, Inc., respectfully requests that the Court enter an Order denying Plaintiff's Motion to Compel because Defendant has responded to Plaintiff's Request for Production of Documents and Plaintiff's Motion to Compel is rendered moot. KELLY, McLAUGHLIN & FOSTER By: (i,~J\_. J If!<L--..I-~'-~ WILLIAM ~. FOSTER Identification No. 03511 ANTHONY V. MANNINO III Identification No. 77165 Attorneys for Defendant, J.C. Penney Company, Inc. 1700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19102 (215) 790-7900 Dated: April 10, 1996. . JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff v. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA J.C. PENNEY COMPANY, INC., Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW No. 95-4977 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ORDER AND NOW, this , day of , 1996, upon consideration of the Motion to Compel of Plaintiff and Defendant's , J. Response thereto, it is hereby ORDERED and DECREED that Plaintiff's Motion is DENIED. BY THE COURT: JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA v. J.C. PENNEY COMPANY, INC., Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW No. 95-4977 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED RESPONSE OP DEPENDANT, J.C. PENNEY COMPANY, INC., TO PLAINTIPP'S MOTION TO COMPEL PRODUCTION OP DOCUMENTS The Response of Defendant, J.C. Penney Company, Inc., to the Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Production of Documents respectfully represents as follows: 1. Denied as stated. It is averred, to the contrary, that Plaintiff's Complaint alleges that plaintiff slipped and fell on or about January 26, 1994 and allegedly sustained injuries. 2. Admitted. 3. Denied as stated. It is averred, to the contrary, that Plaintiff served a copy of the Request for Production of Documents on Defendant on or about December 5, 1996, via first class mail. After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to whether Plaintiff filed a Request for Production. 4. Denied as stated. It is averred, to the contrary, that Defendant supplied a Response to the Request for Production on April 8, 1996. It is further averred that Defendant has agreed to supply Plaintiff with any non-privileged, responsive documents it obtains. A true and correct copy of Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Request for Production is attached hereto as Exhibit "A". ;>:.'.' '~,' i i~~~{,. . J~t1<" 'f....'; ~~o/f ~," ~~: ." i.' to' Oft;' , f""" ~, f.' l' :" , .. ~', ,,;' I' I. I", p: I i' .' \ " f f ,. F' ;,', :{ "", "':~.r!' :t~' {~:.::~~.~~~t~T_~';.~~~r;ti:'~r:?';' " :\.- .. " I .,' ~! Il4c; il ~ .~ ~~I a8!::: 8~ti1 a~L~ 15~5i --.~~.;;- r;:;,:'!: ..._"'....'.,.. ':;",",1 -:~:;/!~~:{~~f;t);J~ '..~"'_. ",:,\~\:..-,;, r,}':, 'S"U' " ,.'~::t:," 8 ... W,&' " I ,,'~'" ,:;';'~ . ",'1-- .'.:;~".::~ -:., " -" ~,; ~ - '. '. "t:,"."Dae "">,..0 .. CSinlli ..,-......0 ,a) ,I' tr:il ,',R~" tfl' ,.~. ,.'".:.. ;'.--. ,tW == . l I · i,." ,,!,,', "'I'" ",'.,)j ::~ ...... ,. , ;. ,': ~ -'''.,'A. :""::--:~::"" "j'''',.';''.' ',;., ,,>-).", y. r "'. .,. _"I".' "...... ..."......4t 1:*...0. OQ...~....,.....", '- PRAECIPE FOR L.ISTING CASE FOR TRIAL (Must be typewritten and submilled In duplicale) TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY Please list the following case: (Check one) x for JURY trial at the next term of civil court. for trial withoul a jury. --........--....-.....-.-...........-.............................-................................................................................................................ CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be stated in full) (check one) Assumpsit JANET KAUFFMAN, (x) Trespass Trespass (Motor Vehicle) (Plaintiff) (other) vs. The trial list will be called on 6/11/96 J. C. PENNEY COMPANY, INC., and Trials commence on 7/8/96 (Defendant) 6/19/96 vs. Pretrials will be held on (Briefs are due 5 days before pretrials.) (The party listing this case for trial shall provide forthwith a copy of the praecipe to all counsel, pursuant to local Rule 214.1.) No. 4977 Civil _ 19n Indicate the attorney who Will try case for the party who files this praecipe: Andrew H. Dowling, Esq., 3401 N. Front St., Harrisbur~_.1..?.!.J.0-0950 _____ Indicate trial counsel for other parties if known: Anthony V. Ma~~:n~~ ~,I! ~~~,~~_:r~_ __ 1700 Atlantic Building. 260 S. Broad St., Philadelphia, PA 19102-5092. ThiS case is ready for trial. -- .~ ---~-.,-=- - Signed: ___:. _ _ _ _, _ ..::~_ Print Name Andre1oL1L _DllJU1~EsQ. Date: Hay 17. 199&....__ _____ Allorney for ,_ Pla.i.ntiff, _ _,_ _____. ,__ , , ,... - ' , v. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION. LAW NO. 4977 CIVIL 1995 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant CERTIFICATE OF SEllYICE I hereby certify that I am this day serving a copy of the foregoing document upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below, which service satisfies the requirements of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, by depositing a copy of same in the United States Mail, at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, with first class postage prepaid, addressed as follows: Anthony V. Mannino, m, Esq. Kelly, McLaughlin &; Foster 1700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19102-5092 Attorneys for Plaintiff METTE, EVANS & WOODSIDE BY: ~ -~ ANDREW H. DOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Court I. D, No. 39692 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110.0950 Telephone: (717) 232-5000 DATED: May 17, 1996 _41 KELLY, McLAUGHLIN & FOSTER BY: WILLIAM C. FOSTER, ESQUIRE BY: KATHLEEN B. GEREAGHTY, ESQUIRE Identification Nos. 03511/63098 1700 Atlantic Building 260 South Broad Street Philadelphia, PA 19102 (215) 790-7900 JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff Attorneys for Defendant, J.C. Penney Co., Inc. v. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA No.lf6-<lCf 77 CIVIL 1995 J.C. PENNEY COMPANY, INC. JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ANSWER OF DEFENDANT, J.C. PENNEY COMPANY, INC., TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT WITH NEW MATTER Defendant, J. C. Penney Co., Inc., (hereinafter referred to as J.C. Penney), hereby Answers Plaintiff's Complaint in accordance with the numbered paragraphs as follows: 1. Denied. After reasonable investigation, J.C. Penney Co., Inc. is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations contained in Paragraph 1 and, therefore, these allegations are denied. 2. Admitted. 3. Denied. After reasonable investigation, J.C. Penney Co., Inc. is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations contained in Paragraph 3 of Plain- tiff's Complaint and, therefore, these allegations are denied. 4. Denied. After reasonable investigation, J.C. Penney Co., Inc. is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the factual allegations contained in Paragraph 4 63167 .1 and, therefore, these allegations are denied. The remaining allega- tions contained in Paragraph 4 are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required. 5. Denied. After reasonable investigation, J.C. Penney Co., Inc. is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations contained in Paragraph 5 and, therefore, these allegations are denied. 6-7. Denied. The allegations contained in Paragraph 6 and 7 are conclusions of law to which no response is required. 8. Denied. It is denied that the subject floor was in a dangerous and/or defective condition. To the contrary, the subject floor was in a safe and proper condition. The remaining allegations contained in paragraph 8 are conclusions of law to which no response is required. 9. Denied. It is denied that J.C. Penney Co., Inc. was negligent, careless and/or reckless as alleged in this paragraph. It is specifically denied that J.C. Penney, Co., Inc. failed to inspect the floor area, failed to remove, clean or eliminate water on the floor, failed to warn customers of wet floor and/or failed to place carpet in the area in question or that it maintained the floor of the Catalog Department in a dangerous and/or defective condition. To the contrary, J.C. Penney Co., Inc. acted at all times in a safe, proper and prudent manner with regard to the floor of the Catalog Department. The remaining allegations contained in Paragraphs 9 (a-e) inclusive are conclusions of law to which no response is required. 63167 .1 ..;. '..~,.. ,- 10. Denied. After reasonable investigation, J.C. Penney Co., Inc. is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the factual allegations contained in Paragraph 10 and, therefore, these allegations are denied. The remaining allega- tions contained in Paragraph 10 are conclusions of law to which no response is required. However, should a response be deemed necessary, it is denied that J.C. Penney Co., Inc. acted in a negligent, careless and/or reckless manner with regard to the Plaintiff and averred, to the contrary, that J.C. Penney, Co., Inc. acted at all times in a safe, proper and prudent manner. 11-12. After reasonable investigation, J.C. Penney Co., Inc. is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations contained in Paragraph 11 and, therefore, these allegations are denied. The remaining allegations contained in Paragraph 11 are conclusions of law to which no response is re- quired. WHEREFORE, Defendant, J.C. Penney Co., Inc., demands judgment in its favor and that Plaintiff's Complaint be dismissed with costs and interests. NEW MATTER PURSUANT TO PA, R.C.P. 1030 Defendant, J.C.Penney Co. Inc.'s New Matter Pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1030 represents as follows: 13. All or part of Plaintiff's claims may be barred by the applicable statute of limitations. 63167 . 1 14. At all times material hereto, Answering Defendant acted reasonably and exercised due care. 15. If the plaintiff sustained injuries or damages as alleged in the Complaint, all of which are specifically denied, then said injuries and/or damages were cause by the actor failure to act of plaintiff or of persons other than Answering Defendant. WHEREFORE, Answering Defendants, respectfully request judgment in their favor and against the plaintiffs together with interest, costs and fees. KELLY, 63167.1 ,,';,;"., -,', ' -'-'~'- .-.--, -__......C".... VERIFICATION Kathleen G. Gereaghty, Esquire, being duly sworn according to law, deposes and says that she is the attorney for the Defendant, J.C. Penney Company, Inc. in this action, that she is authorized to take this Verification, and verifies that the statements made in the foregoing Answer to Complaint are true and correct based upon knowledge obtained as the attorney of record. This Verification is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa, C.S. 54904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. Dated:1( ~, "7 ) 1'19ZJ CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE t I , I r ! I ~ I , I, Kathleen B. Gereaghty, Esquire, hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the Answer of Defendant, J. C. Penney to Plaintiff's Complaint with New Matter was served this 7th day of November, 1995 via United States Mail, First Class, postage pre- paid, upon the following individuals: Andrew H. Dowling, Esquire 3401 North Front Street PO Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0905 e , , I i I I ~ KELLY, McLAUGHLIN & FOSTER / / .,' , <; (. ~ If' : ".' \. "- athleen B. Gereaghty, Attorney for De.fendant. J.C. Penney Company, Inc. /' I ( BY: c v, 31 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW j i JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff J, C, PENNEY COMPANY, INC" Defendant 95-4977 CIVIL TERM IN RE: REQUEST FOR CONTINUANCE ORnER OF COURT AND NOW, this 11th day of June, 1996, at the call of the civil trial list today the Defendant has moved for a continuance of the case, and we discussed the matter in chambers with counsel for the Defendant and counsel for the plaintiff, This is a slip and fall case in the Defendant's department store, The reason for the request today is that the Defendant contends that discovery is outstanding, There's a possibility that this can be completed in a reasonable time before the trial date, Therefore, the Court directs that the i i I f I case be kept on for pretrial conference, and a decision will be made at that time whether a continuance should be granted to another term of court, By the Court, ~ucN\ ~" Haro Andrew H, Dowling, Esquire For the plaintiff _ u'\J.~. .,.~lul I"/Js-/qc.. \J .... ,oJ Anthony V, Mannino, III, Esquire For the Defendant mal _c. ..... ~ r"\ v. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 4977 CIVIL 1995 JURY TRIAL DEMANDED JANET KAUFFMAN, Plaintiff J.C. PENNEY CO., INC., Defendant ( I I I , TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Please mark the docket in the above-captioned action settled, discontinued and ended. METTE, EVANS & WOODSIDE BY: ----- ~ ~ -- ANDREW H. DOWLING, ESQUIRE Supreme Court 1. D. No. 39692 3401 North Front Street P. O. Box 5950 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0950 Telephone: (717) 232-5000 Attorneys for Plaintiffs DATED: July 9, 1996