HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-06066
NGUYEN T, STO'IT,
I N 11m COURT 01' lnNJN I'I.MS 01'
Plaintiff
v.
CUMIlEIU..ANIl OOWJ'Y, PENNSYLVANIA
NO, 95-6066 CIVIL TERM
ROIlERT L. STO'IT,
llefendant
PI<<>TECI'WN !'ROM ABUSE
AND NOW,
l'II01B:J'l (fi 0111-
M-~-
this '1((\ 'day of January, 1996, uplln consideration lIf the Consent
Agreelent lIf the parties, the following Order Is entered:
I, The defendant, Robert L. Stott, Is enjlllned fr~ physically abuslna
the plaint iff, Nguyen T. Stllll, or fro. placing her In fear of abuse,
2. The defendant Is enjoined fro. having any direct or Indirect contact
with the plaintiff Including, but nllt 11.lted tll, telephone and written
~Icatlons, Any cOMunicallllns regarding the part les' pending dlvlIrce shal I
be thrllugh their attorneys.
3, The defendant is ordered to refrain frOll harasalng and stalking the
plaintiff and fro. harassing her relatlvea,
4. The defendant Is prohibited fro. entering the plaintiff's area lIf
e.ploYlent at Nasland Industries, except If required by hifl e_ployer, or any
lither place where she BaY be employed.
S. The defendant is prohibited fro. re.uvlng, daaaalna, destroying or
selling any property owned by the plaintiff or jointly owned by the parties, The
defendant shall not allow the parties' marital residence tll fall Into
foreclosure.
6, The defendant Is ordered to stay away frrna the plaintiff's current
residence located at an undisclosed location.
7, The defendant Is ordered to stay away from any residence the
plaintiff may In the future establish for herself,
8, court costs and fees are wnlved,
9, This order shill I remain In effect for n period of one (I) year and
can be extended beyond that time I f the Court finds that the defendant has
cOlllllltted an IICt of abuse or has engaged In n (lattern or I'l'IIct Ice that Indicates
risk of harm to the plaint Iff. This Order shall be enforceable In the SIUlll
manner as the Court's prior Temporary Protection order entered In this case.
10. This Order may subject the defendant to: II arrest under 23 Pa.C.S.
66113; II) a private criminal cllmplalnt under 23 Pa.C.S. 66113.1; III) a charge
lIf Indirect criminal cllntempt under 23 Pa.C,S. 66114, punishable by I.prlson~nt
up to six months and a fine of $100,00-$1,000.00; and Iv) civil cllnteapt under
23 Pa,C,S. 66114.1,
11, The appropriate police depart~nts shall be provided with certified
copies of this Order by the plaintiff's attorney and aay enforce this Order by
arrest for Indirect criminal contempt without warrant upon prObable cause that
this Order has been violated, whether III' not the vlolatllln Is coMitted In the
presence of the police officer. In the event that an arrest Is aade under this
sectllln, the defendant shall be taken without unnecessary delay befllre the court
that Issued the order, When that court 15 unavailable, the defendant shall be
taken before the appropriate district justice. (231'.5, 6 6113),
Joan Carey
LEGAL SERVICES, INC,
Attorney for Plaintiff
n he Court,
l.'- 0-;:- ,
larold E. Sheely,
,M" C ,( , I ~'rf 9(,- ,
.\ ,'.
~-L"------
oldent Judge
r\-,t.l<"4'"
Scott D. Moore
SA I OJ S. OUl DO. SImp . MASI..ANIl
Attllrney for Defendant
. .
Defendant
IN nm COURT OF CON<<lN PLEAS OF
Cl)lBERLANJ) COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 95-6066 CIVIL TERM
PROTECTION f'R(I.I ABUSE
I<<lUYEN T, STO'IT ,
Plaintiff
v,
ROBERT L. STO'IT,
1IIJl'1~ fOR aJn'INUANCB
The plaintiff ~ves the ClIurt for an Order rescheduling the hearing In the
above-captioned case on the grounds that:
I. A Tellporary Protect Ion Order was Issued by this ClIurt on October 23.
1995, scheduling a hearing for Nove.ber I, 1995, at 9:30 a...
2, The CUllberland ClIunty Sheriff's DepartllCnt served the defendant with
a certified CllPy of the Te.porary Protection Order and Petition for Protection
Order on October 23, 1995, at 5:45 p,., at his place of e.ploywent.
3. Counsel for the defendant, Scott D. Moore of SAlOIS, GUIDO, SHUFF'
MASLAND, contacted Legal Services, Inc, staff on October 31, 1995, and requested
a continuance In the matter,
4. The plaintiff agreed to the continuance and requl'sts that the hearlna
be rescheduled,
5, The plaint I ff requests that the Tellporary Protect Ion Order re..in In
effect for a period lIf one year or until modified or terlllnated by the court
after not ice or hear I ng.
6. Certified copies of the Order for ClIntlnuance will be delivered to
the appropriate police departments by the attorney for the plaint I ff.
Wl\EREFORE, the plalnll ff requests that the ClIurt grant this Mot Ion and
~
~
:.'it
t"J...;~
!:~&~
&A.: au';':
~~Q~
Q ~~~~
UJ ~~:-J111
...J 11. tc2:'
,_ .....tu:.:
4, :::LtJI.U
,~.:.: 4..
...'"
CU
a=
,...
...
"';:r
-
~
] ILl:;
;"
J 1
d.~_JI "11
ll', ,
.';',1
; f (~ ," ..
). i:1! d~
,II,
'f ii,
fl'~ I,' li
.:\
!
Cf ~~:'
:;
I,'t' pi,;' , .!
r 1't. ~ ' ' ,;
-J
. .
III On or IIbout OClober 12, 1995, the defendllnt, who Is 6' I" till I
IIIllI weighs /lp(lrllxlmlllely no pounds, grahbed the pllllnliff, who is
S'I" \/111 IInd weighs 106 (lOunds, hy the front of her jllckllt with one
hllnd IInd thrllw Iwr to 1I11l floor with such force thllt she sl id IIcross
Ihe floor IIp(lTllxlmlltely (, feel. The defendnnt then threw his shorts
III Ihe (lllIlnt Iff IInd hit her In Ihe helld wi Ih Ihem, followed hehlnd
her ns she left the room, IIml punched her In the jnw cnuslng her to
filii 10 the fltXll'. The folloWing morning Ihe pllllntiff sought
medlcnl trcntmenl lit Ilunhllm Army Ifospltlll lit Cnrl Isle Bllrracks for
swelling nnd soreness to her jllw. The pllllnliff IIlso filed crlmln/ll
chllrges IIgnlnsl Ihe defendllnl wllh Ihe Norlh Middleton Township
Police llepnJ'tmenl. Thll pllllnllff left the mllrllnl residence on
Octoher 13, 1995, IInd hilS heen stllylng lit IIn umllsclosed loclltion 10
IIvold further' /lhuse /lnd for her own prolectlon.
hI On or IIhout Octoher 2, 1995, Ihe defendnnt, who WIIS driving
Ihe Cllr, nbruplly slruck the pllllntlff In Ihe 11m wllh the hllck of
his hnnd. When Ihe pllllnllff 111111 defendnnl gol home, the defendllnt
demllnded thlll she sit down, commence,lto degrllde IInd humllillte her,
IInd threlltened her sllylng he shoul,1 cut her Ihrollt like O,J. Simpson
cut Nicole Brown Simpson's. The plnlnt I rf sustnlnelln hrulse on her
IIrm ns II resull of Ihls Incident.
c) In or IIhoul July of 1'195, Ihe defendnnt clime 10 Ihe
pllllnllff's friend's home when' slw Il'IIS nltelllling II hlhle stUlly
group, IXllnlccl his finger III Iwr In fronl of the group, demnnded
IhBI she gel upnnd go home, IUlll threnlcnell 10 pil'k Iwr up 1111I1 throw
her oul Ihe wlrlllow if she did nlll Il'lIve. When the plnlntlff gol
Inlo Ihe cllr with Ihe defcndAnl, he pundlcll her In the helllt so hurd
that she "SIIW sturs." When Ihe plulnllff IIAked Ihe defendAnl why he
slruck her, hc IhreuIl'ned to Ihrow her olll of Ihe cur.
d) Since APl'rOXlmlllely 1'17,1, Ihe defenclunl hUI< IIhllRed Ihe
plalnliff In wllYs Inchuting, hul not limllell 10, pushing, shoving,
slupplng, 1111I1 punching her Ahoul IIL'I' helllt, fuee, chesl, hllCk, und
IIrms. The defendAnt Ims grllhhed IIlIlI violently shAkt-n the plulnllff,
Ihrown her to the floor, /lnd I'ulsed his fist in her fllce clluslng her
10 fcnr he Is going 10 strlkl' her. In/llldltlon, Ihc defcndont hilS
repeoledly Ihreulenell 10 hil Ihe pllllnt Iff, to cuI Ihe plulntlff's
Ihrolll like 0..1. Simpson I'ul Nicoll, IIl'llwn Simpson's, anll sllylng Ihat
II will only lake one hullet 10 kill hcl'. The defendllnl, who Is u
gun uficlunllllo, hilS IIPPl'llximlllely lOll fln'lIlms lIlut knives.
5. On 01' uhout Oeloher IJ, 1'195, Ihe plulnl Iff IeI'I her I'cnldence AI
2800 Spring RlIUd, Carlisle, Cumhel'llIlut Counly, Pennsylvunlll, In order 10 IIvold
further IIhuse.
6. The pl/tlnllff helieves lIlul Iherefol'e uvel's Ih/ll she Is In Immedlale
und presenl dllnger of "huse from 11m defendant unci 'hul she I s In need of
protection frnm nueh IIhuse,
7. The plulntlff desires thul Ihe .teh'nllunl h" pl'ohlhited from IlIIvlng
IIny director Indlrecl cl1Illucl wilh the pluintiff Indul!ing, hul not Ilmllelllll,
telephone unll written communlcul Ions.
8. The plulnl I fI' dl'sll'es Ihul Ihe .Ieh'ndlllll he enjoined fmm hlll'asslng
IInd Rtlllklng Ihe pl/llntHf, /Inti from hllr/lsslnl! her IT'I/lI il'es.
'I. The (ll/llnl Iff .h'sln's Ih/ll Ih.. tI..f"llIlunl h., ll'slrnlrll'd frnm l'nledng
hor /lrea of emplnyment /II M/lsl/llIIl IlIIlnslri..s.
10, The plainllff desires lhlll the defendant he l'njolned from removing,
dllmaglng, delllrnylng nr Reiling any property owne.1 joint Iy by the parties or
owned by the pl/llntlff.
Il. I!XC1.USIVE POSSESSION
11. The plalnllff desires thlll the Courlllrder the defendant to stay away
from her currenl residence /lnd IIny olher residence she may in the future
eRtnbllsh fur herself.
The plninli ff cllnnot revenl the nllmes of tIll' owners of the bome becnuse the
nllmes wi II dlRclose her wherellhouls which musl be kept conflclenl inl for her
protection, The plnlntiff is not seeking the eviction of the defendnnt from his
residence,
12. The plaint Iff desires the defendllnt to provirle suilllble alternnte
hnuslng for her.
c. A'ITORNm' I'lmS
13, The pllllnt I ff IIsks lItIIl the defl!ndllnt bl! ordered tn pny renslInnble
nltorney fees to \.egnl Services, Inc.
IIllERI'.FORE, pursuant to the provisions of the "Protect ion from Abuse Act"
of October 7, 1976, 2J P.S. g filOI !!1 seq" liS llmended. the plnlnllff I'rIIYs this
Itonnrable ('..onrt ll' gr/lnt the following relief:
A, Grant n Tempnrllry order pursullnl to the "Prolect Ion from Abuse
Act:"
I. Orderln!l the defelulllnl to refrnln from /lbuslng the
pl/llnllff ur plllclng her In fell!' of IIhusel
2. Orcll'rlng the "dell/Inn I to refrllln from hllvlng /lny direct
or ill/llrecl c'onlnl'l with Ihe pllllnllff inclucllnll, hnt not
Ilmlle.llo, lelL'l'l\lllle 111\11 wrillen l'nmnlunic'lIllonsl
3. Ordering Ihe defendnnl In ref..nln fmm hnl'nRRlrlg nnd
slolking Ihe plninllff nml f..nm hnrnsslng her ..elntlvesl
4, Prnhthlllng Ihe Ilefelulnnl fl'nm entering Ihe (lllllnllff's
nrcn nf em[1IIl~'menl lit MlIslnnd Indust rll'sl
5. Pl'nhlhillng Ih" d..fullllllnl fmm rennlVInl!, dllmnglng,
deslrnylng "" sl'llllll! "..ope..ty jlllntly owned hy Ihe (lllrllell nl'
owned hy the p\nllltlff;
/1, Ordering the defemlnnl In stll)' nWII)' frllm Ihe (llnlnt Iff's
current rtJl'lidellce which Is IIn undlsclosell Inclllllln In nvnld
further IIhuse IInll for her nwn "rnteet lonl
7, O...Il'rlng the d...fl'lulllnl In sIllY IIII'll)' f..om nny residence
the (llnlntlff mny in the fulul'l' eslabllsh fn.. herself, nnd
R, O..dering Ihe defendllnl III [1rnvlde sultllhle nllernnte
housing for the (lllllnl!ff.
n. schedule II hellring in IIcco...lllnce wilh the prnvlslnnR Ilf Ihe
"Prnlect inn from Abuse ACI," nnd, lifter Ruch heuring, enler nn o...le.. 10 he in
effect fnr n (le..lod nf nne yunr:
I, Ordl'ring Ihe defendunl 10 "I'fmln from nhuRlng the
plnlntl ff Il" (llncing hl'r In 1'1'11" of uhuse.
2, Ordl'..ing till' defl'ndnnt In ..efrnln fro:n hllvlng nny Iltn'cl
nr Imll..ect mnlllcl wi t h I hI' pili Inti ff I nc IUIII ng, hul not
liml",,1 to, tldl'phone 111111 wrlllen cnmmunil'1I1 ions.
3, Ol'cluring th" c1dullllllnl III ...,f..llin from IIIHIIR"lng uml
Rtnlklng tIll' pllllnl I rr und from IUllusshw. hI''' n'lutlvl's.
4. Pl'llhlhit illg I hI' 1II'fl'IIIIIInl from l'nll'l'lng Ihe "llIlnl iff's
""1'" IIf I'mp I 11)'11I1'111 III Mil,., 111I111 IllIh,"I..II'".
Intn th" cnl' with th" t1ef"ntlllnt, he (Il1l1che,1 h".. III the he",1 Iln hlll'd
thnt Mhe "IlIlW 1lIIlI'S." Whell the (Illlint I 1'1' IIsked lh" dd"llllllnt why he
sl ruck hel', h" lhrelll"ned tn throw hel' nllt nf I he 1'111'.
d) Slllce IIpproxlmlltely 1973, Ih" l\ert'lllllIlIl hilS IIhllsed Ihe
plaintiff In WIlYM including, hilI nol I imit",1 10, pushing, shoving,
slupplng, IlIllI punching her nhoUI hel' heml, fnl'e, ch"sl, hllck. nnd
arms, The ddemlllnl hIlS gruhhed nml vinlenlly Ilhnk"n Ih" plnlnt Iff,
thrown her 10 the floor, nnd rulsed his flsl In h,,1' fnc" causing her
to fen I' he is going to slrike her, In nddil inn, the def"ndant has
repealedly lhrent"ned to hit the plulntlrf, to cut the plnlntlff's
thront like O.J. Simpson cut Nicole Brown Simpson's, Ilnd snylng thllt
it will only tllke one bullet to kill her, The defendant, who Is a L
gun nflclllnndo, has npproxlmntelY 100 flrenrms and knives.
5, On or nbout october 13, 1995, the plnlntlff left her residence at
2800 Spring Road, Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pennsylvllnln. In order tll avoid
further nbuse.
6, The plnlntlff believes nnd Iherefore nvers lhnt she Is In IlIlIIIedlate
and present dnnger of nhuse from the defendllnt nnd thnt she Is In need Ill'
prlltect Ion frllm such IIbuse.
7, The plnlntlff desires thnt the defemJnnt he prnhlblted frllm hnvlng
nny direct or Indlr"et contnet with the plnlnllff Inc1Ulling, but not limited to,
telephone nnd wrl tlen commllnlcnllons.
8. The plninllff Ilesll'es lhal the defendnnl he "njoined from hllrnsslng
nncJ stnl king the 1'1 III nl i'ff, nnd from hnJ'/lss Ing her re Int I ves,
9. The plnlnllff dClllres Ihnl the dcfendnnl he reslrnlned from entering
her nrea of employmenl lit ""lIllnrlll Induslrles.
,
"
J%gJ~/:c:';;;i~:t::'~:,':f:tL~.!",~~~;:"''',II,~_~M"''~-:;' -
"'< .'.,. :. 'AYriiliH.V* !\NbCOuNULLOII AT LAw '
, P.O. .aXUIO. HAAAa"UaG, PlNNIY\.VANIA 17110.mo
^'-"---..."a.6nJ"'...."-'f....~-'-.,..:.-- _.c"_~,_,,~,, '-__0 ,,~-
AND.90A"~QT'09~Vfi?",~: f
\ - - - -~<,-,}: .~:':,c;;:/r:';---:':::.:,~:,. />i~t';'-'
t. . '"
4.,
HEOf./vEO
OFf=iCEOr .
PRO'! I ;"'iOtARY ,
... Z ,oM'.
DAUPI1IN UOl TV
PENNA'
r . t
.....
.
i'! j.lt I'
i,_! ],'Id/
I.!' I_It 1\1"
I r,: I nIl: 1 ' ,j~. t'q V" I I
1,111I1''IIWI AI'III "I 1'FlllbYI VAlllA,
1,11'IIT'" ',I ,!IMI"'''1 AlII'
~J" I I tll'I'ITII ,
1"
~ JI.'Tl h"l" Ii'! I.
WI:,:I.J, J" '~."~'.t:..
.,,_,.,.. '....... ...._.. ~,Ii"rLff "I [IF.'pUl)' Glll','lIf "t
I \.'Nljl~!\1 AtH' I. ',lint l', l'j,'l1lll:oylvdflla, vhtl fH?lJI\J .duly u:vDrfl ~r-c'nl-111t1U
" I.w. ."'i'., U,,' WI'lilll 1'I'I,JTt:CI1!='!LJ:!W,I1.!lL'l1;J];;"
WUf,~ FiEJJ vlld
up' 11
1'" T h'.I!'lcl(I.J~..
(Iii'
d':J'=-'lid;lrlt, ,jt )~)jl~,!~,O tlll!",~', 'If I I lit., ,--..i!!~1 fl.];' ;,1 r}:,'.';~k~ll
1 '~4'/' tit
n~; hfl!n~ Hil'\': Tf-llc:',
, !l!,~I,'1JL!A~l"""l,',
, '. IrHVt.hL.~!Hl,.
, ",,,,,. i', I'. ""q'lVd/ll.J. f'y 10",.,111111 ." hU!'I:.I<] L. .':i.U,iJ.1
d trui"'
iJll,J at t 1;'I"t ._,\1 ("(iPY
"j . 1;" .!!E'H.!.Il'lli, rli.t,;'1!"!ll'WL
" .
. "11\-' toe, WI'to TF!1I",_'!l~JD 1 !Hl1I;';II VI "liHIi,UmIU': lilli,' UcTlI HHL.....
8lld..jt 'hi FilTnF- '111",' dll"PI.t.llllJ lLtt gtt_l;;'lltll;(I tl\ ttH~ 1'llnt,f-HltE tht?..r'lJJ.
<-,h. r 1 t t 'b -1_'Ft_ r:
l'r i_~l:t"t 1 nq
I I'.' 1 r'F
^ t j 1 t1~" J t
1.11 '.'hdl Ijfd
~: f)
"nLW'~~/~
I;, C.", Fill". 1-1""1 if
Hi. \', \~
.~. tH'
.l'W'1
. \'\~
!t:'t',nl'
l,h~ ~.'l\', i.-',~7'j,.il.-~
! )
. /~.. ./1 . ~'/4 //
(,,/-1 l'r:.;// ((t'Y
t~ Jl.l;' '''li'l i ft
. ""_'1 rl 'tlld .:~td.;_. j It"~.,d t, {'l.t"I'_" ,.,
, tlli
.11 tL_,
l., .1.\
I (JU;" "-'
1" ",~/
, ,
fl. ,
Cf1t.L y' ~,~~l'-(.~ U'pl