HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-06348
gt'.Oo~~"
.>....:'-.....'.:
,.y,:i:,- ..,
f....
~.,'..t!)...,. ~
,i':~"",~.~~~'
""".".',,....
9j~:_"'--, ..
~V .~
i:i~i>~"
l'~'~ · ~
.~.~.,~'
,".'. .. .0'
:""'-- -;
1;-:
o
"<
ALEXANDER PERRY, a Minor.
by JAIME FELTON, his Parent and
Legal Guardian. and JAIME FELTON.
Individually,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintitl's
v,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
95- CIVIL TERM
CHARLES GLADFELTER and
CROWN DISTRIBUTING COMPANY,
Defendants
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
COM PI AINT
I, Plaintiff Alexander Perry is a minor individual residing at 154 Nonh Pitt Street.
Carlisle, Cumberland County. Pennsylvania 17013 (hereinafter referred to as "Minor Plaintitf.).
~ Plaintiff Jaime Felton is an adult individual residing at 154 Nonh Pitt Street, Carlisle.
Cumberland County. Pennsylvania 17013. She is the parent and legal guardian of Minor Plaintiff
Alexander Perry.
3, Defendant Charles Gladfelter is an adult individual residing at 10 Peach Orchard
Road. Newville. Cumberland County. Pennsylvania 17241 (hereinaller referred to as "Defendant
Gladfelter").
4. DelCmdant Crown Distributing Company is a Pennsylvania business with a place of
business at 121 North Pitt Street. Carlisle. Cumberland County. Pennsylvania \7013 (hereinaller
referred to a5 "Defendant Crown").
5, At all times relevant hereto, Defendant Crown was engaged in operating a beverage
distributorship at 12\ Nonh Pill Street. Carlisle, I'ennsylvania 17013,
[), At all times relevant to the within action. Defendant Gladlelter was acting within the
scope of his employment wilh Delendant Crown
7 On or about August :!1. 1995 at about lOa pm. minor Plaintitl. was lawfully at
Delendant Crown's heverage distributorship tbr lhe porpose of purchasing a can of soda Irom the
soda machine located on Ihe premises of Delendant Crown
H At the same lime and place. Defendant Oladlclter falsely, publicly and maliciously
accused lhe nllnor I'laintill' of dama~in!! lhe soda machine
9, At such time. Defendant Gladfeller forcibly and violently seized. held and detained
minor Plaintiff against his will and consent and falsely and maliciously detained and imprisoned the
minor Plaintiff.
10. Minor Plaintiff has been subjected to great humiliation. pain and sulfering by reason
of the assault. false and malicious imprisonment. detention and seizure,
II, By reason of the Delendants' actions. minor Plaintill' suffered damage to his
reputation and was caused to suller great pain and mental anguish.
COUNT 1- FALSE IMPRISONMENT
AlpYRnder Peny a r\'finnr and Jaime Felton his Parent and Natural Guardian and
Jaime Felton Individually v Charles Gladfelter
12, Paragraphs I through II ofPlaintitfs' Complaint are incorporated herein by reference
as though set forth in full.
13. Defendant Charles Gladfelter. without probable cause. seized. detained and falsely
imprisoned the minor Plaintiff on or about August 21. 1995,
WHEREFORE. Plaintill's demand judgment against Defendant Charles Gladfelter in an
amount in excess ofS50.000.00 and lor punitive damages in an amount to be detennined by the trier
offact. plus costs.
COUNT 11- FALSE IMPRISONMENT
Alexander Pen:}'. a Minor and Jaime Felton his Parent and Natural Guardian and
Jaime Felton Individually v Crown Distrihutinll Company
14. Paragraphs I through 13 ofPlaintitl's' Complaint are incorporated herein by reference
as through set forth in full,
15. Defendant Crown. by and through its agents and/or employees. without probable
cause. falsely seized. detained and imprisoned the Imnor Plaintiff at its beverage distributorship on
or about August 21. 1995
WHEREFORE. Plaintitls demand judgmelll against Delendant Crown Distributing Company
in an amount in excess of $50.000 Oil and lor punitive damages in an amount to be determined by
the trier of lact. plus COSlS
COUNT III - ASSAIJLTIBATTERY
AIl!xander P~nv. a Minor. and Jaime Felton his Parent and Natural Guardian and
Jaime Felton Individually v Charles Gladfelter
16, Paragraphs I through IS of Plaint ills' Complaint are incorporated herein by relerence
as though setlorth in lull.
17. On or about AUllUst 21. 1995. Defendant Charles Gladfelter, without probable cause.
violently grabbed Minor Plaintiff by the neck and forced him into a room and detained Minor
Plaintilfby pUlling a chain across the door,
WHEREFORE. Plaintiffs demand judgment against Delendant Charles Gladfelter in an
amount in excess of$50.000,00 and for punitive damages in an amount to be detennined by the trier
of fact, plus costs,
COIJNT IV - ASSAln.TIRATTERY
Alp-VAnder Pen:y a Minor. and Jaime Felton hig Parent and Natural Guardian and
Jl\ime Felton Individually v Crown Distrihutinw Company
18. Paragraphs 1 through 17 ofPlaintilfs' Complaint are incorporated herein by reference
as though set forth in full,
19. Defendant Crown. by and through its agents andlor employees. without probable
cause. violently grabbed Minor Plaintilf by the neck and forced him into a room and detained Minor
Plaintiff by putting a chain across the door.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs demand judgment against Delendant Crown Distributing Company
in an amount in excess of $50,000,00 and lor punitive damages in an amount to be determined by
the trier of fact. plus costs,
MARTSON. DEARDORFF. WILLIAMS & OTTO
Date: November 6, 1995
By
George B, I. ler. Jr" Esquire
Ten East High Street
Carlisle. P A 170 I 3-309]
(717) 243-3341
Attorneys for Plaintllfs
\'ERIFICA TION
The foregoing Complaint is based upon inlbnnation which has been gathered by my counsel In
the preparation of the lawsuit, The language of the document is that of counsel and not my own.
I have read the document and to the extent that it is based upon intbnnation which I have given to
my counsel. it is true WId correClto the best of my knowledge. inlbnnation and belief. To the extent
that the content of the document is that of counsel. I have relied upon counsel in making this
verification,
This statement and verilication are made subject to the penalties of 18 I'a, C.S, Section 4904
relating to unsworn lalsification to authorities. which provides that if I make knowingly lltlse
avennents. I may be subject to criminal penalties,
~~'___~~J-
J . e Felton~ividually and as
Parent and Legal Guardian of
Alexander Perry
. ,
ALEXANDER PERRY, II Minor,
by JAIME FELTON. his I'arentllnd
Legal Guardian, and JAIME FELTON,
Individually,
IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY,PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintift's
v,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
95. (.<..??-;'( CIVIL TERM
CHARLES GLADFELTER and
CROWN DISTRIBUTING COMPANY.
Defendants
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
COMPLAINT
I. Plaintiff Alexander I'erry is II minor individual residing at \54 North Pill Street,
Carlisle. Cumberland County. Pennsylvania 17013 (hereinafter referred to liS "Minor Plaintiff').
2. Plaintiff Jaime Felton is an adult individual residing at 154 North Pill Street. Carlisle.
Cumberland County. Pennsylvania 17013. She is the parent and legal guardian of Minor Plaintiff
Alexander Perry.
3. Defendant Charles Gladfelter is an adult individual residing at 10 Peach Orchard
Road. Newville. Cumberland County. Pennsylvania 17241 (hereinafter referred to as "Defendant
Gladfelter"),
4. Defendant Crown Distributing COll1pany is a I'ennsylvania business with a place of
business at 12\ North Pill Strect, Carlisle, Cumbcrland County, Pcnnsylvania 17013 (hcreinafter
referred to as "Defendant Crown"),
5, At a1ltimcs relevant hcrcto. Detcndanl Crown was cngaged in operating a bcvcrage
distributorship at 121 North Pill Strcet. Carlisle. Pcnnsylvania 17013.
6. At all times relcvanttothc within action, Dcfcndalll Gladfcltcr WIlS acting within the
scope of his cmploymcnt with Dcfcndant Crown,
7, On or IIbout August 21, 11)1)5 lit IIbOUI 1:00 pm,. minor PllIintifl' WIlS IlIwfully lit
Defcndant Crown's beverllgc distributurship tiJr thc purpose of purchasing a can of Sl1dll fhllllthc
sodllmachinc loclltcd onlhc prcmises of Delcllllunt Crown
8, At the same lime ilnd pluce. Delcndunt GllIdfcltcr falscly, publicly and maliciously
IIccuscd the minor 1'laintil1'of dllmuging the sodul11l1chine
9, At such time, Defendant Gladfelter lorcibly and violently seized, held and detained
minor Plaintiff against his will and consent and falsely and maliciously detained and imprisoned the
minor Plaintiff.
10. Minor Plaintif1'has been subjected to great humiliation, pain and suffering by reason
of the assault. false and malicious imprisonment, detention and seizure.
II. By reason of the Defendants' actions, minor Plaintiff suffered damage to his
reputation and was caused to suffer great pain and mental anguish.
COUNT 1- FALSE IMPRISONMENT
Alexander Peny. a Minor and Jaime Felton his Parent and Natural Guardian and
Jaime Felton Individually v Charles Gladfelter
12, Paragraphs I through II o I' Plaintiffs' Complaint are incorporated herein by reference
as though set forth in full.
13, Defendant Charles Gladfelter, without probable cause. seized, detained and falsely
imprisoned the minor Plaintiff on or about August 21. 1995,
WHEREFORE. Plaintiffs demand judgment against Defendant Charles Gladfelter in an
8I110unt in excess 01'$50.000,00 and for punitive damages in an amount to be detennined by the trier
offaet, plus costs.
COUNT 11- FALSE IMPRISONMENT
Alexander Pen:)'. 8 Minol:. Bnd Jaime Felton his Parent and Natural Guardian and
Jaime Felton Individually v. Crown Dislribulinll Company
14. Paragraphs I through 13 of Plaintiffs' Complaint are incorporated herein by reference
as through set forth in full,
15, Defendant Crown, by and through its agents and/or employees, without probable
cause, falsely seized. detained and imprisoned the minor Plaintiff at its beverage distributorship on
or about August 21. 1995.
WHEREFORE. Plaintitlil demand judgmclllllgainst Defendant Crown Distributing Company
in an amount in excess of $50.000,00 IInd lor punitive damages in an amount to be determined by
the trier offact. plus costs,
. .
COUNT 11I- ASSAULT/BATTERY
Alexander Perl:)'. a Minor and Jaime Felton his Parent and Natural Guardian. and
Jaime Fellon. Individually v Charles Gladfeller
16. Paragraphs I through IS l1fPlaintilt's' Complaint arc incorporated herein by reference
as though set forth In full.
17, On or about August 21, 1995, Defendant Charles Gladfelter. without probable cause,
violently grabbed Minor 1)laintlff by the neck and forced him into a room and detained Minor
Plaintiff by pulling a chain across the door.
WHEREFORE. 1)laintilfs demand judgment against Defendant Charles Gladfelter in an
8IIIount in excess ofS50,000,00 and for punitive damages in an amount to be determined by the trier
of fact, plus costs.
COUNT IV - ASSAULT/BATTERY
Alexander Pen:y. a Minor. and Jaime Fellan. his Parent And Natural Guardian and
Jaime Felton. Individually v Crown Distributini Company
18, Paragraphs I through 17 ofPlaintilfs' Complaint are Incorporated herein by reference
as though set forth In full.
19, Defendant Crown. by and through its agents and/or employees, without probable
cause. violently grabbed Minor Plaintllfby the neck and forced him into a loom and detained Minor
Plaintilfby pUlling a chain across the door.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs demand judgment against Defendant Crown Distributing Company
in an amount in excess of $50,000,00 and for punitive damages In an amount to be determined by
the trier of fact, plus costs.
By
G or
Ten t High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013-3093
(717) 243-3341
Allorneys for Plaintill's
Date: NovenDer 6. 1995
, .
...
ALEXANDER PERRY, A MINOR. BY
JAMIE FELTON, HIS PARENT AND
LEGAL GUARDIAN, AND JAMIE
FELTON. INDIVIDUALLY.
Plaintiff.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA
NO: 96-6348
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
v.
CHARLES GLADFELTER AND
CROWN DISTRIBUTING COMPANY.
Defendant.
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRAECIPE FOR ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY:
Please enter the appearance of Jeffrey B, Rettig, Esquire on behalf
of Defendants, Charles Gladfelter and Crown Distributing Company In the above.
referenced matter.
THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER
Date: /)-/1/ 'i)-
L :.-/ /2.
J REY B. RETTIG. EJIQ IRE
TORNEY I.D. #196~./
306 NORTH FRONT STREET
P.O. BOX 999
HARRISBURG, PA 17108-0999
(7171266-7639
ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANTS
;:,-:'i:~(;;.~i;~:,-~.:~
-
- .,,_.,''''
,''4,;.......'i;.k'"'t..'~.
'i.-""
ALlXAHDIR PIRRY, A MINOR BY
JAID 'ILTON, HIS PARINT AND
LIGAL GUARDIAN AND JAINI
PILTON INDIVIDUALLY,
Plaintifh
IN THI COURT 0' CONNON PLIAS
CUMBIRLAND COUNTY, PINNA.
I.I'IY
NO. 95-1HHt
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
CHARLIS GLAD'ILTIR AND CROWN
DISTRIBUTING COMPANY,
Darandants
JURY TRIAL DIMANDID
RULE 1312-1. The Petition for Appointment of Arbitrators shall be
substantially in the following form I
PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS
TO THE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT I
Jeffrev B. Rettiq. Esquire
Manufacturing Company in the
respectfully represents thatl
1. The above-captioned action (or actions) is (are) at
issue.
2. The claim of the plaintiff in the action is $
The counterclaim of the defendant in the action is
, counsel for the defendant Crown
above action (or actions),
The following attorneys are interested in the case(s)
are otherwise disqualified to sit as arbitrators I
Faller. Esquire. Ten East HiGh Street. Carlisle. PA
as counselor
GeorQe B.
WHEREFORE, your petitioner prays your Honorable Court to appoint
three (3) arbitrators to whcm the case shall be submitted.
Rc!'pf'lctfully Bubmitted,
THOMAS,
DATE liP I' u I q L
Street
17106-0999
-.
.....,
OF Tl~TARY
"
96 AIIG -8 AM 10' II
CUM_~UNTY
I..:
"
~
r::
l5
.:r '>.
.", ~;:
~ '3~
C- ":l~
M ,.:.:'lm
~ :.ili,
.., ~
~ ~
9~
.~ ~
E'0~ ~
~ ~ "'I
C\~ J '-:~<~
\Q
THOMAS, rHONAS" HAFER
'" "''''"8,R'IIIg,I..
MlIII'.fUlIDl No.: '11'1
.....ff....n.1
PO","
.......", I1IOUII'
mnnum
Allor..,. lor 0,1".'011
ALEXANDER PERRY, II Minor by
JAIME FELTON, hi. PlIrent end
Lellll Guerdlen. lInd JAIME
FELTON.lndlvldulUy,
PllIlntlffB
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA
NO: 96.6348
v.
CHARLES GLADFELTER lInd CROWN
DISTRIBUTING COMPANY,
DefendlntB
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
NonCE TO PLEAD
TO: P1llntlff. Ind their ooun.el,
YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED TO FILE A WRITTEN RESPONSE TO THE
ENCLOSED NEW MATTER WITHIN TWENTY 1201 DAYS OF SERVICE HEREOF OR A
JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU.
THOMAS, THOMAS. HAFER
DA11:: /2/2 ~/ tj r
)./ .: )),') 1{"
Jef y 8, Rettig, EBq
I, ,'19616
P,O. BOll 999
306 North Front Street
Herrllburg, PA 17108.0999
17171266.7639
Attorney. for Crown DI.trlbutlng Complny
7. Denied. To the contrary, on Information and ballef, the minor Plaintiff
wal hitting the loda machine located on Defendant's premises.
8. Denied al stated. On Informetlon and belief, It Is admitted that Mr.
Gladfeltar asked the minor Plaintiff to stop hitting the machine which he rafused to do.
9. Danled. On Information and belief, It as averrad thet Mr. Gladfaltar
brought the minor Plaintiff Into the Crown Distributing Compeny building advising him
of hll Intention to call the police, which he did. It Is denied thet Mr. Gladfetler
"Imprlloned" the Plaintiff.
10. Denied. It is denied that the minor Plaintiff has been subjected to great
humiliation, pain and suffering or that he was assaulted or falsely and maliciously
Imprisoned. It Is admitted that he was detained.
11. Denlad. It Is denied that tha minor Plaintiff suffered damage as alleged.
COUNT I - FALSE IMPRISONMENT
Plaintiff v. Oluf"'er
12-13. These allegations are not addressed to Answering Defendent end
thus no r"ply Is required.
COUNT II - FALSE IMPRISONMENT
Plaintiff v. Crown D1ltributlng Company
14. The Answers to Paragraphs 1 through 13 above are Incorporated herein
by reference thereto.
16. Denied. It Is denied that Answering Defendant's agents or employees
falsely seized, detained or Imprisoned the minor Plaintiff.
2
WHEREFORE, An.w.rlng D.fendant requa.t. that Count II of Plaintiff'.
Complaint b. dl.ml...d without co.t to It.
COUNT 11I- ASSAULT/BATTERY
Plaintiff v. Gladfelt.r
16.17. Th..e allegations are not addressed to Answering Dafendant and
thu. no reply Is r.qulred.
COUNT IV - ASSAULT/BATTERY
P.rry v. Crown D1.tributlng Comp...y
1B. Th. An.wers to Paragraphs 1 through 17 above ara Incorporat.d h.r.ln
by r.f.r.nc. th.r.to.
19. D.nl.d. It I. d.nl.d that An.werlng Def.ndant, through It. agent and lor
.mploy..., vlol.ntly grabb.d minor Plaintiff. It Is furth.r d.nl.d that h. WII dataln.d
by putting a chain acro.. the door.
WHEREFORE, An.w.rlng D.f.ndant r.quests that Count IV of Plaintiff'.
Complaint b. dl.ml.sed without cost to It,
NEW MATTER
20. Ba.ed on Information and ballef. on the date and tlma alleged, An.werlng
Defendent'. employee, Charles Gladfelter, ob.erved the minor Plaintiff and hi. cou.ln
hitting a .oda machlna located on Answering Dafendant's preml.es,
21. Upon Informetlon and bellaf, Mr. Gladfelter alked Plaintiff and hi. cou.ln
to ceall hitting the machine which they refu.ed to do.
3
~ \.D '>-
<'"I 1,-
;:: .. ~:;i......
!~ c., ~):--~
:t: I.... ,
.'
Fe u.. C);.:j
II m ~.h-,;
t':
c. hI ,". 1 ~:~
fC\!; (oJ ".'I[i)
I:': ~d lito..
W :5
b In
IT. U
CERIJl'!CAIEJ)IUiERYlCE
I hereby certify that a copy ofthe foregoing Praecipc was scrved this dalc by depositing swue
illlhe Post Office at Carlisle, PA. first class mail. postugc prcpaid. addresscd as follows:
JefTrcy B. Rettig. Esquirc
THOMAS, TIIOMAS & HAFER
305 North Front Street
P.O. Box 999
Hanisburg. PA ] 7108
By
AMS & OTTO
Attomeys for Plaintiffs
Dated: March 3.1997