The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About95-06489 " I' Ii I' "(', :ii 'II 'i. 'I' , " I' :,1"1' ,,' ['I i I, " I' "J' I,' , '" III I I, , , "Ii , ",I ", , I, I, 1,1 q, I 'II 1IIIj II,'! , II ,IJ 'II , " " , 'I , , " I , l'lt , " :i iI , Ii 'I" 'I I' " ,I ri 1'1 " " " , , III,' , ',ffl " i " " , I'" -"., , , , , II , I" , "',j I; ! , , , , " 1'1 , I' , :11' , ;,,' .'i " " , " " " 111,1 ir Iii'; \ ii , ,I H! !,;i'a' ,i, "'I/il!'1 .r' "i 1'/' il' j :fJ I' " ,I , , , I," 1-\ :;);, :1 ", JtrH'j'l ',I ! 1'1' I r. " ''I' " " I' , ,i ,I , , " III , " 1./ , , , 'I. 'i " , I; , ,I; "j, , , , , , , , " ','r I'll' , , 'l't:' , " " " , t.,!I, rrir,' '1,11: I 'II'" ,',;: :,_01 I' ';i'i, ,', "h' P.:/.,..,p: rf/-)'!I; ;..' , ..' ' ~',\";\I:' I~ )' :1 1 I' 't '\\11 1,1.__'( .\11,', It.'.,';' JI, '1,. , " " " , " 1'1 ,I., " " ," ,,, 'I 1'1] " Ii , " I,'i', , , ':'\ ",I, , , " -",' " " I, ,\ I ',' , " '" " " ,I, "'I'. , -j , , II , ' ,I , " 'I , , , " ", " :i ,\ "'.1 , ' , , , , " "'I I,': i , , , ,'"I I" " " " , , I,I,,-,,':'Ir :,'\,HttiW , tel '\1,\ "'\' , I , , " ".':1 ), I . C.ul/rlf /11Vc.('f !fai" IiII' (1') ) ) ) ) ) ) ) , I .', , Vs-, -~jlAI 6..~~ tiIoIrJ -'&WNlir ~. ".8~{.-:,c; i)v""UJ OArR , I , In The Cou~c of Common Pl", of Cumb.rland Councy, P,nn.ylv.ni1 ~o. 0...., ~Y3F (Jilt.. 19 Cv,.. ,4(,.'h"N W. do .olemnly 'W'I~ (o~ .ffirm) th.t we will .uppO~t, ob.y and dei.nd the CODlcitution of the Unit.d Stice. .nd the Constitutioa oi this Com=on~ wealth and that wa will di.cha~I' the duci.s o;;our office with fid,lity. , tZtt)~_' /kO - I r:nan AWARD We, thl unde~.igned .rbitrato~s, having b..n duly appoint.d and .worn (or affirmed), make th. followinl award: (Notel If damag,. for d.lay ar. awarded, th.y shall b. ..pa~ately .tat.d.) tutl'l hcd I~ t:;;"",.. ~ ~ .i/!.'M'.;,tr ..it.. ~ Ci'I#UuJ .,~- ~7 a-,J CoD's: H" ~ ,L],..J4J' ~~"'J{. ~M o--d ~~ .&'~ r /, 3r;', ~r.:< ~..h( , , 5<" >t. appl1'Cib1.e. ) Arbitrator, dissents. (Insert name if ~~ ~ AI .t'_'d'~ NOTICE OF ENTRY OF AWARD Now, the dd~d day of . Jo.r\ \.A.Cl.J\..A.\ ,19 QS , II: '::>:.:;)5, P .:1.. the above ave~d wa. .ncar.d upon the dock.c and dotic. th.reof gIVea bY-mail 0 the partia. o~ th.i: atcorney.. Arbitrators' comp.nsation to b. paid upon appeal I ,$ d90,00 Dace of H.aringl DICe of Award I /- ,7J~ ~ /- :<'2- Y8 By: Chair:D4n .()( , " j i ,)" YlF. 1.1') ,~ ~ ~ "" r,; .j N ,~ IlJ t~' :l.... - " g,ji' ' ~~ ~ a ~ , rtJ " '," 6' "I C'J III' ... i, { '" "i~ I; N I.'; cr:::> .( v,:P '" '/' zr ." L l,r) J " .'1. J "",; ~._.U. lJ. en '1] " CI 0' () ~ c;.; " " , , " , ' !, , il',l" , " " 'r~ Law Olftm O'BlUfN, 1JAItlC.. SCHERER 17 W,II SlIulh SIr", C"rllll" ',",,,ylll""/II / 1111 J SIMn J, F/lh/lflm O/Cllunul IMII1 t, O'8riln Dw/J A, BllrI, M/rltll,'A, S,It,,,,. (7/7) J49.1Ja7J FA.'( (7/7) m.sm November 26, 1997 VIA FACSIMILE MlI'lin It McCaleb. E"1ulre "1.'7772 219E,MalnSt. Mechanlcaburs, P A 1705S R. Mark Thomu, Eaquire 69'1.9395 54 E. Main Street MeclwUcaburs. PA 170SS Dawn 5, Sunday. E.quire 39 W. Main St. Mec:lwUcsburs. PA 17055 John B, Manck., Esquire 13..7080 Manke. Wlaner, Henhey and Tully 2233 N. Front St. Hamsburs, PA 17110 REt Curti. Mye" v. John Bender and 80nnle Bender No. 9!!.6489 Dear Counsel: Since receiving the notice or the arbitration in the above mailer scheduled for Thursday, Decembet 4. 1997. I have attempted to contact my clienn in the above mailer repeatedly, These attempts had been wholly unsucceasful until yesterday wheat I met with Bonnie Bender. Throughout the course ofth!s litigation. Ms, Bender has been my contact person and I haye met only with her, I was lnfonned yesterday that she haa been separated from John Bender for approximately one year. I have not been able. to today'a date. to reach lohn Bender reglU'ding Ihis maller, CURTIS MYERS, PlalntUf IN THE COURT or COMMON I'LEAS 011 CUMBERLAND COUNTY, I)ENNSYL VANIA NO. 96.6489 CIVIL TERM v. JOHN Bl!NDER and BONNIE BENDER, Defendants ).ljOTICI!; OF HEARING BY BOARD OF ARBI1'RATOR5 You are hereby notified that the undersil!ned Board of Arbitrators, appointed by the Court In the above-captioned case will sit for the purpose of their appointment It the Law Ollices of Marlin McCaleb,located at 219 East Main Street, Mechan\csburg, Pennsylvania 011 Thursday. January 22, 1998 at 9:30 a.m" It which time and place you may appear with your respective clients and your witnesses to present such evidence and testimony as you llIay have in the case. R. Mark Thomas, Esquire Dawn S, Sunday, Esquire ;;~~!W~ Marlin McCaleb Date: ];)"c~ f" PP7 cc: John B. Mancke, Esquire Attorney for Plaintiff David A, Baric, Esquire Attorney for Defendants Richard J. Pierce Court Administrator aJRTIB MYERS, Plaintiff IN 'rilE COUIlT OF CO~IMON PLIiAS OF CUtlBElll.I.ND COUNTY, PEtiNSYlVAlItA NO. 9~~64R9 CIVIL 1995 f I I I I I I I I f I I RULE 1312-1. The Petition for Appointment of Arbitraton ahall ba aub.tantially in che following forml v. JIlIN BE7'1DE1\ 11M BOONIE BOOm, Defendants PET!':'ION FOR APPllINTIIENT OF ARBITRATORS - TO TIlE HONOMBL!!:, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT: John B. Mancke . counup.l for tho plaintif~/defendant in the abov, 1. 2. Bction (or actions), respectfully represents thatl The above~cQPtioned activo (or actions) is (are) ~t iHSUO. The claim of the plaintiff in the action is S 3,742.62 The counterclaim of the defendant in the action is w1liquidate<1 The following attorneys ara interested in tho coae(s) as counselor nre other- win di.qualified to ait aa arbitrators: n.wicl 1\. Baric, Esq., O'Brien, Baric & Scherer, 17 \q. South Street, Carlisle, P1\ 17013 WHEREiORE, your petitioner praya your Honorable Court to appoint thrae (3) arbitrator. to whom the caae .hall b. aubmitted, Respectfully sUbmit:ad, ~~- .Tohn B. Mancke, EBCJ. 7~15-97 AND NOW, !2RlllJL.Q~'l\Ll!:r. , 19~. in considerntion of the I11~Esq., ~ Eaq., and _,' Esq., 3re appointed arbitrators in the foresoins petition, above-captioned action (or actiona) as prayed ~or. , , , ,> /' , " I"., " , " ,) ,il " , ' " ...:;:--. ~ ,~ t"-'- C) , ~ (Y; ~ di ~ ~ ~5 It, . ..,.. ~ ~ ~r: 1\.) ~.Io (t: I )"J ~ c... (''I :;:'.1 ~ ~ .....'It.J J r') " ... N ,.J'in Q "1t pJ ~ I,k- t ll~ ~ ~ L;.l 'I' ~ ~ ~ " 'b,. " . . H ". .. ... ,~... \,. \ CURTIS NYUB, I IN THI COURT or CONNON PLIAS plainUff I CUMBIRLAND COUNTY, PINNSYLVANIA I v. I I NO. 95-6489 CIVIL TERM JOHN BINDIR, I Defendant I ODD O. COO'!' AND NOW, this ~tt. day of W\~ &.t, 1996, after ,I con.ideration of the within stipulation of counsel, it is hereby ordered that Bonnie Bender shall be named as a oo-defendant in this aoUon. It is further ordered that all pleadings in this action where only John Bender's name appear., be amended to inolude Bonnie Bender .. CO-defendant. BY THE COURT, C;;: 'I r 11:1 vq;o,l::F('~ 11'! iiY (I", I" r>, " "J' .1'. 11.1' PII 31 ~n "lll' " " . '''~.. 'I... ,,',' t, ,1:1 i IY 1'111""," 'i""", ' " hi j. .' If~ ,I " " Iii ,. ClURTIS MYIlRS, I IN THB COURT OF COMMON PLIAS plaintiff I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA I v. I I NO. 915-6489 CIVIL TERM JOHN BENDER, I Defendant I .TI'ULkTIOIiI O. COUM81L AND NOW, thiS'~/ day of ~_ ' 1996, oome the parties to the above aoUon, by their respeotive oounsel, and hereby agree to stipulate to add Bonnie Bender as co-defendant in this aotion. It is also hereby agreed by oounsel that all pleadings in tllis oase shall be so amended to include Bonnie Bender Datel ',)- j-){j ) 'I ~ Bonder's name appears. \\\~, L- JOHN ~~CKE' ~SQUIRE Attorney 10 I 07212 2233 North Front street Harrisburg, PA 17110 717/234-7051 counsel for plaintiff curti. Myers ae co-defendant wllerein only John Datel,;J!).")/1t AwC(J/~. DAVID A. BARIC, ESQUIRE O'BRIEN, BARIC' SCHERER 17 West South street carlisle, PA 17013 717/249-6873 counsel for Defendant Jolln Bender and Additional Defendant Bonnie Bender , 'I " ;, '" " " "I " " I,,' ~!-I:l, .' ," ,,' I'" , " " , 'I: " " " ' '" " " '" I', , , , " , , , '1 I',; ,. " . " ,II " , , I " 11 1",1 ,I " " I " " " Ii ," " II ., " " '. 1:,1 jl " I ," 'J \ " '" I' I' I, " 'II', ,',il " '.,>., II!' 1,1'1: , . , ,,' I,' ."" ,~ I '''i I': 1,'1 ll'i' " " , ;,1, '. ';) I,,;!,\;. I~Jl ,rr\ ,I _ J;\..;il' I_J,Ij,_,; 'I,';:';'i}'; I- l'-l'1~' I '/,:! 'f'lq .)' ," i~; ':(;1 I', 'i1.,i,J '_;i,_','~',?l /,1 '1"'1""11 . J)r:'/.\: ,-ii ;', " j,r' " , , 'il"I' , " ,j " 1,1 " , , ,I "F' r-! , " " ,: ',I " } , " " '. , ,I)!, ,;,01 'i,; ,I,j , ,1"1 i,r I ,I'" " , ,,', ," :1,'; ""t'.I, 'I I , ,I' '" 'j , ' , \"; , ';1 Ji" ~ 'I 1 r I " /,"1 II't~ 'u f ! ~, '" 'I' 'i , I,jl I, , I' !..d , , " '," " " " " , , , : , , " " , , , , " ,'dr_: " I , '-l , " , " " , " , ,I " ;1, " " , 'I ,i,I:1 ,'I"; ,,' : ',; " , , , , '" 1'; rJ iI 'I, , " I " /, " " , ','1' " " " , , ,I I, , I , " , , , , I, i ',I ',I' , , H " , , 1'1 , , "'I' " , " " i i " ,I, i' " "I ,,' I , , 1 ,Ji I , ,I ~ I ' , , , ~w 0PftCI, MANCI<Il. W~Nl!R, MM8HPlY. TULL V . III , , ,; ,I" " ',I , I , , , I, i! , , " , , , "" , d I"~ " ,I :1 III, , : " i , , Ii " I, I , , I " , , , , , " , , " t,l' 'I " ',I , ' ,I",I! 1'1 i" " I,i , " , , , ,',I " \, " , , , u " h 'I ' 'I ,I' I ,11\ r!r:I'lli/,;I;1 I" ",'Ik.,'" 1!;l,I')'fTi- il',\.,q'liJ 1'\ ,'J;::it 1\10;11':;"1 M*. ')'i, dl',M ,'il:1 ]1;'1 .1 i.t;f~o, !, I ,j(I,1 !~t/T~' ,'Ii','\ :"':\b(~ :! _j i/l,J'\})V (J"I'/i','!,' ,k)I,! I!,\;'" CURTI$ MVERS, Plaintiff : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS t CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSVLVANIA NO, 95-6489 CIVIL ACTION. LAW v, JOHN BENDER Defendant MI'l11FF'~ ANSWER TO N~ MATTER e, Paragraph e Is denied, It Is denied that Plaintiff received payment of late chargeslrom the defendant as set forth In Ellhlblt "B" 01 the Complaint. 9. Paragraph 9 Is denied as stated. It Is aVllrred on the other hand that the Borough was contacted and made an Inspaotlon and there was no water leak determined. It Is therefore denied that there was a water loak that oaulled the Detendant to Incur elltraordlnary water and sewer bills. 10, When Plalntltf was notified of Defendant's conoem concemlng Inllect Infestation, Te""lnell was contacted Immediately and treated the unit end continued to treat It on a rsgular basis as needed. 11, It Is admitted there was a $350.00 security deposit but It Is averred that the costs and ellpensell and rental due and remaining all outlined In Paragraph 4 of Plalntltf's Complaint far elleeed the amount oftha seourlty daposlt all was ellplalned at the hearing by the Dllltrlct JUlltlOO. 12. Paragraph 12 Is denied. It Is denied that an Itemization weS not provided Illnee an Itemization was given In front of the District Justloe to the Defendant and was provided In the Complaint. 13, Paragraph 13 Is denied. It Is denied that the Plalntltf ever gave any authority to the Defendant to make modification. to the property. 14. Paragraph 14 Is denied. Plalnl'" did nolllpprove Ihe modification Ihat wu mad. by the Defendant. PLAINTIFF'S ANSWER TO COUNTERClAIM COUNT I 15. Complalnl of Insects was mede to Ihe Plalnllff after Ihe Defendanl moved Inlo Ihe premises and Ihere was no problem prior 10 Ihem moving In. Plalnllff hired Termlnel! to check Into and 10 handle Ihe problem. 16, Ills admitted 10 Ihe elCtenllhal Delendanl did nollfy Plalnllff 01 the Inleslallon and Plaintiff hired Terminal!, 17. Termlnel! was hired and perfonned the services they lell necessary. 18. Paragraph 18 Is denied. 19, Paragraph 19 Is denied. II Is denied Ihal the Inleslatlon made Ihe prop.rty uninhabitable, unsanitary or unsale and In lact, Defend anI conllnued 10 live In Ihe premia" during Ihe period of lime Ihallhe renlls claimed. 20. Paragraph 20 Is denied. It Is denied Ihallhe Inleslallon was a breach 01 any Implied warranty. It Is furlher averred Ihallhere was no problem with Ihe premises prior 10 Ihe Delendant living In the premises. 21. Paragraph 21 Is denied as Plalnllff has no knowledge of ths Irulh of Ihe avennente contained In Paragraph 21 and Ihey are Iherefore denied. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requesls Ihe original amounlln Plalnllff's Complaint. 2 QOUNT II 22. ptragraph 22 II denied as Itated. It Is admitted that there was a water leak and that It wu IIIt.d bV Mr, Souderl, who Is paid by Mr. Myers. 23. Delendant told the Plaintiff he had already lilted It the ceiling. 24. parlgraph 24 Is denied as stated, Delendant John Bender lilted the ceiling and told the Plaintiff about It, but there was no ellpeotatlon or dlsousslon 01 compensation. 215. Paragraph 215 Is denied as Plalntlff Is without sufflolent knowledge to asoertaln the truth 01 the averment, however Plelntlff was never made eware of any $600,00 repair bill. WHEREFORE, PlalntJff demands judgment os Indicated In the Complaint. pDUNT III 28. Plaintiff Inoorporates herein by reference Paragraphs 14 through 26. 27. Paragraph 27 Is admitted to the eldent that a hearing was held and ludgment was ent.red In lavor 01 the Plalntllf even though Defendant argued the Issue of the seourlty deposit u well as other Issues and judgment wae entered In favor 01 the Plalntlff. 29. Paragraph 281s denied, An Itemized list of repairs and damages to the property were provided at the Dlstrlot Justice hearing and Is also Inoorporated In the Complaint. 29. Paragraph 29 Is admitted. 30. Paragraph 30 Is denied as It states a legal conclusion. " WHEREFORE, Plain"" dem~deludgment u origh,ellv called lor, Respectfullv submitted, MANCI<E, WAGNER, HERSHEY, & TULLV BV J n Attome I,D. No. 07212 2233 North Front Street Harrisburg PA 17110 (717) 234-70~ 1 Attomev for Plaintiff DATE: 1- q. (Ib 1M'" I' /, I' , , , " , , 4 \)'1 I, " I' , iI' 'I CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE h I, Holly R, COok, a ..orelary In the law ffnn 01 MANCl<E, WAGNER, HERSHEY & TULJ.Y, do hereby certify that lam thll day lervlng a copy 01 theloregolng document to thelollowtng p81'1011 and In the manner Indicated below, which lervlce lallsffel the requlremlnta 01 the Pennlvlvanla Rul.. 01 Civil Procedure, by depOlltlng the Isme In the United Statel Mall, Harrisburg, Pennlytvanla, with flret oIus postage, prepaid, and addresled u IoIlows: David A. Bario, Esq. 17 W. South Street Carill'e, PA 17013 DATE: 01.()9-ge 'LU( Ii a6 L oily R. Cook, Seoretary MANCl<E, WAGNER, HERSHEY & TULJ. Y 2233 N. Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17110 John B. Manoke, Esq. Attorneys lor Plaintiff I, , , , " ' 'i'" '(,{,\i" , " I,,, ."! " t I ; '.,ll';'1 :,:!'i" "~ii, '\' "," I,'"., 'Ii' ,"J :'1 , " , I" " .... ;;1' ," './ :/ 'I,. , , (,'" , " I,,"~ " , : 'I " " , 'jl ';fl,! :'J d ,,' ,II II ',;1,1 'I " ~,\ I , II,. " /'" I, I " ,,' II, j " , , , , JI , , , , " " " , , , ,'1 , , , , " " . . , " , , . " I , , , i" 'I I " , \ " " " , " , " , , " '/1 i, ..'.J " " , " , " Ii 'I !I , ," " I , , , I j' , , , , " , " , II i,il " ,i' ,1;1 ,If; ", , r, '. ,. , },'!'j/:), I.,,!;,.. !.,'.'t,..,,:, \J."'I:'_I ",';"..1)1(,\,11.,-:( -'-'\;;itlll II:';! i'i' 'I:' LiIL,' ','I ". J~' ,:1 "i,';1<1 i,' /""'.1 'I I ", I,"~ , ',I ~~" ~f~ I J~ Ii lUll 1", \, , , '\ 'I " , " ii. 'hi " :' " ,'I \\1' , , " , , , , , , \ " , Ii' '! ,Ii " " , ill , , 'I " " , " " , , , , , , " , " , " , , " " II' , , 'i'l "i "I" . "I , ',.1 1'1" 1': .' 'I;'''' I. I I"",". ,,; L.1, II!! , , !I ""J)'li" fq I " " , " 'I \'Ij ;""1 i'l I i '. " " " '" " if , , ,I, ii,' " " 1 " , i l' I' " 'III " , , . f :1 iI I..,' , , ,j-I /"1 " , , " ~WUfl'IU' MANCI<Il. WAGNllfI, HI!f18HEV. TULL V " " Ii , , , " ',/I " , " 'if , , " , 'il , , , , , " " .." 1.1 " , " , ' " ,! , , , 'Ii , ! " ;11 "I , , , , " , , ,'\ , " , , " I,ll ii" , , 1,1 " ',I ~' ""I ,.,..-.:... " !j , " " " ';1- I " , , ',I , , " , ','1 " \ , " " ';1 " ;~ !.:.!~\ 1,0,;(1; i,"',W. II 'I ';1 Ii ~ 111 '>\l'j' 1",liiiJ 1/111,.,\,. 11", 'iY'O ,'I: III ijl' '1','11'" ,111\1~ Ti,t"'~I~,II'j " "d( ",I, ./ii:,'1\ , :dil, .,I"i-II ,,;.ill:;t.. 1,,\,1,',."11 ..l,II;),'l' /..:;'1'1 .1 ,tL 1,,1"1:';'\,\ Ii}. '~ /r: '"i'i I,I} , _",1. ,. '1',':\1 "I. "l;'rl '" " '1,1 1,.\ , , , " " O'BRIEN, BARIC & SCHERER ~~~,Ii-. David A. Baric, Esquire 1.0. 144853 17 West South street Carlisle, Pe"nsylvania 17013 (717) 249-6873 V. IN 'rHlt COURT OF COMMON PLEAS or CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 95-6489 CIVIL ACTION-LAW CURTIS MYERS, PLAINTI..../ JOHN BENDER, DEFENDANT. "OTICI TO PLIAD TOt curtis Hyers by his attorney John Hanoke, Esquire Hanoke, Wagner, Hershey & Tully 2233 North Front Street HarriSburg, Pennsylvania 17110 You are hereby notified that you have twenty (20) days in which to plead to the enclosed Answer, New Matter and counter-Claim or a Default Judgment may be entered against you. Date I Ii. /27 If S....... ~ , CURTIS MYI!:RS, PLAINTIFF, I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF I' CUMBlllRr..AND COUNTY, PENNSYLVAN IA I I NO. 95-6489 I I CIVIL ACTION-LAW I I V. JOHN BlllNDER, DEFENDANT. ANSWER .EW MATTER AND COU.TEaCLAIM or DIFI.DANT AND NOW, comes Defendant, John Bender, by and through his attorneys, O'BRIEN, BARIC AND SCHERER, and files t.he within Answer, New Matter and Counterclaim as followSI 1. Admitted. , 2. Admitted. 3. Denied as stated. Dy way of further answer, Defendant and his wife, Bonnie L. Bender leased an apartment from the plaintiff known as 15 East Main Street, Newville, PA being the first floor of said property. The lease agreement was made May 11, 1992 and continued for a period of one year subject to modification by notice provided by the Plaintiff. 4. Admitted in part and denied in part. By way of fUI'ther answer, Defendant responds as follows: a. Defendant paid all rent and late charges accruing during the term of the lease up to May, 1995. Defendant admits that payment of $315.00 was not made for the period September to October 3, 1995 and any 16te charges were not paid aft.er May, 1995. Defendant had good and valid reasons for not making said payment as more fully set forth in New Matter and Counterclaim. 2 b. After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth or falsity of this averment and strict proof thereof is demanded. o. After reasonable investigation, Defendant if without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth or falsity of this averment and strict proof thereof is demanded. 5. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth or falsity of this averment and strict proof thereof is demanded. 6. Denied. Defendant had the permission of Plaintiff to make the modifications. , 7. Denied that the amount set forth in Plaintiff's complaint is due and owing or appropriate. WHEREFORE, Defendant requests judgment in his favor and against the plaintiff. "1M MATTER 8. plaintiff received payment of late charges from Defendant as set forth on Exhibit "B" to Plaintiff's complaint. 9. plaintiff was repeatedly notified that e water leak existed at the property in the line from the publio water service to the property yet plaintiff failed and refused to remedy the defect causing Defendant to incur extraordinary water and sewer bills. 10. plaintiff was repeatedly notified that the apartment unit 3 Buffered from inuot intestation yet plaintiff failed to take appropriate meuures to resolve the infestatlon making the unit uninhabitable. 1\. Plaintiff reoeived a Beourity depoBit from the Defendant in the amount of $350.00 oontemporaneouuly with exeoution of the lease agreement appended to Plaintiff's complaint as Exhibit "A". Plaintiff has failed and refulled to return tho Beourity deposit to Defendant. 12. plaintiff has failed to provide Defendant with an itemization of the damages allegedly cauBed to the property. 13. plaintiff informed Defendant at the outset of the tenancy that the Defendant could make an~' modifications to the property that the Defendant wanted to in order to make himself more comfortabl~ in his occupancy. 14. plaintiff was aware of the partition modification made by Defendant and approved the modification. COUITIRCLMH ~UIT I 15. While Defendant was in possellsion of the proper.ty, the property beoame infested with roaches. 16. Defendant notified Plaintiff of the infestation and requeBted that the roaches be eradicated. 17. plaintiff undertook measures to eradicate the roaohes, 4 'I' however, the aotions undertaken were not appropriate or effectiv$ in resolving the infestation. 18. The infestation continued unabated and was severe and pervasive throughout the property. 19. The infestation made the property uninhabitable, unsanitary and unsafe. 20. The continuing infestation was a breach of the implied warranty of habitability extended to the Defendant by the plaintiff. 21. As a consequence of this breach, Defendant lost several items of personalty including, but not limited to, the followingl a video cassette recorder, television, microwave oven, sofa bed, five video tapes, three bags of food and an answering machine. The VBlue of these items of personalty is estimated as $ 995.00. WHEREFORE, Defendent, counter-plaintiff, demands judgment against Plaintiff in the amount of $995.00 plus interest and costs and any other relief deemed just and proper. COUNT II 22. In or about January, 1995, wBter began to come through the ceiling of the kitchen in the property. The water was coming through a ceiling light fixture and caused extensive damage to the ceiling of the kitchen. 23. Defendant requested that the Plaintiff repair the leak and the oeiling in the kitchen. 24. Defendant informed the plaintiff that Defendant would 5 have the ceiling repaired and expected compensation for the repair from the Plaintiff. Plaintiff oo>>sented to this arrangement and the repair was made. 25. Defendant was charged $600.00 for the repair and has received no reimbursement or set-off fr.om Plaintiff for this expense. WHEREFORE, Defendant, Counter-plaintiff, demands judgment against Plaintiff for the cost of the repair plus costs and interest and any ~ther amount deemed just and proper. COUNT I II 26. Defendant, Counter-Plaintiff, incorporates by reference the averments set forth in paragraphs fourteen (14) to twenty-six (26) . 27. Plaintiff has to the date hereof failed and refused to refund to Defendallt the security deposit paid by Defendant to Plaintiff . 28. Plaintiff has failed to provide Defendant with an itemized statement of alleged repairs or damages to the property. 29. The property leased to Defendant was used primarily for family or household purposes. 30. The actions of Plaintiff, severally and cumulatively are violative of the Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law, 72 P.S. Section 201-1 et seq. 6 V. CIVIL ACTION-I.AW I CURTIS MYERS, PLAINTIFF, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBE~LAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 95-6489 JOHN 8ENDER, DEFENDANT. ~I~ICATE OF SE~VICE I hereby certify that on December ~, 1995, I, David A. Baric, Esquire, of O'Brien, Baric & Scherer, did serve a oopy of the An.war, .ew Matter and Counter-Claim, by first class U.S. mail; postage prepaid, to the party listed below, as followsl John Mancke, Esquire Mancke, Wagner, Hershey & Tully 2233 North Front Street "m"b.ro, pm'~;~, tt. ' David A. Baric, Esquire 9 ')- Tr-t y,-H-I :1:- I ',- j'ij II J '-h ;;'1: "; .--J~ _ .lj I -,'" ' -, - _ .' , II _ - i" !, ..__ 1/ ' ' ~,,","""'II '~'J:l'1JrnNil~~~li"'+-1,"~,J''''_~'lf,H',' '-.,.1'11>" , 1" I "L ,,' I ' J,'/'II_'1~lll.""4~1..,,,p"h_., ,tl" 'I., '1I:,;";:II,f/:J1J:::.t, .,___.._~,.wJ....~~..itlt /Itj -- .,'101;' 11' ;, ,I I, I I " I, .1 " ,~ ~ ~:~ I, t-:J , , 19 ",- ()::r. b: ("):~.i I;'! .... ;':;i'1 , I.t. IN " I... IJ! L,' \:H) I,' llJl~ F '-.l '. ~ In "'\ ..,.. n c- " , I I I I I' " , ,'I , , ,', ,;1 'I CURTIS MVERS Plalnllff t IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY t NO. 9&-6489 CIVIL TERM v, JOHN BENDER Delendant ~OTlCE You have be"n sued In court, II you wish to delend against the claims set lorth In the IoIlowing pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days alter this Complaint and notloe are served, by sntsrlng a wrlttsn appearance personally or by attorney and IlIIng In writing with the , Court your delenses or objecllons to tho claims set forth against you, You are warned that If you fall to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered aglllnst you by the Court without further notice for any money claimed In the Complaint or for any other claim or rellel requested by ths Plaintiff. YOIJ may losa money or proparty or other rights Important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWVER AT ONCE, IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWVER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURT ADMINISTRATOR 4TH FLOOR CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE HANOVER AND HIGH STREETS CARLISLE, PA 17013 (717) 240-6200 OURTIS MYERS Plaintiff I IN THE OOURT OF OOMMON PLEAS : OUMBERLAND COUNTY v, , , : NO, 9&-6489 CIVIL TERM JOHN BENDER Delendant COMPLAINT 1, Plaintiff, Curtis L. Myero, Is an adult Individual residing at 9 Mooredale Road, Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, 2, John Bsnder Is an adult Individual residing at 203 Fairfield Street, Apartment 1, Newvllle, Cumberlend County, Psnnsylvanla, 3, Delendant leased premises at 15 East Main Street, Newville, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania Irom the Plaintiff, copy 01 said lease Is attached hereto and made 0 rart hereol as Exhibit "A", 4, Delendant lalled and relused to pay rent and late oharges that were due on said lease and a copy 01 the charges due Is outlined In Exhibit "B", which Is attached hereto and made a part hereol and which Includes: a, $1,300,00 for rent and late charges, with an additional $315.00 for rent due from September to October 3, 1995, b. $1&&,23 for a water and sewer bill, O. Costs of IIxlng up the premises alter they moved out and to restore the ,premises to Its original condition, Isss wear and tear, $947,39. 5. In addition, thers were five plate glass windows that had been removed which have an sstlmated value of $75,00 each, for an additional amount due of $375,00, " 8, In addition, Delendant placed a partition In the front rccm without permh.llon 01 the Plaintiff and Itla eatlmatsd that It will ccat $660.00 to removo said pertltlon In ths front room and to reatore the prsmlsee to Ita original condition lesa wsar and tear, 7. Bald amountla due and demand lor payment has been made but has not been forthcoming. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against ths Defendant In the amount of . $3,742.62 plus Interest and costs and amount requiring compulsory arbitration, Rsspeolfully submitted, MANCKE, WAGNER, HERSHEY, & TUllY I ~ By John noke, Esquire Attomay 1.0, No, 07212 2233 North Front Street Harrisburg PA 17110 (717) 234-7051 Attorney for Plaintiff DATE: 12.0~.g~ - LEASE . Thllaarermenlll mad. Ih. II ~ h day or _ Mil:.' btlwecn Curtl.s L. Mysrll 9 MQordllle Rd.Carl1llle.Pa. and John N. Pl!nder and HOl'ln19 L. Rend.er 19 92 1I LANDLORD _II Tl!NANT. By Ihllllrcemenllh. LANDLORD leases 10 IheTl!NANT Ihe lldUUtapal'lIl1enlal 1 ~ Ells t MI.I1n -- R~~~~t. NAwv11'A,~A l??Ul flRt. floor) 10 b. used ala rClldenceand for no olher purpose for lhelerm or t Y liar bealnnlnl Ihe 11 th day or _.-M1!I- One Thouund Nine Hundred and (19-9.2-) and endlnllhe 11 tn day of _ Msy , on~ Thousand Nine Hundred and (19-.21..) allherelll of Three hundred and f1fty dollarfl per DolIlII per lerm, payable In advance monlhly on Ihe 11 th equal monlhly Inslallmenll of Pollan 10 CurtJ.jLlu_llYJlX1l--- ---- II 9 Moords!!.. Road. CarH sle .l'a 1 ?013 or Iny olher pi Ice which lhe LANDLORD may delllnale. Renlal plymenl for a pari III monlh of occupancy may be proraled. Renlll due wllhoul demlnd. month (s 1'i0.OO) _ dDY of cach m,onlh In (s 350.00) Thc LANDLORD acknowledlCl recclplfrom Ihe TENANT of . Three hundrecL f1fty dollars ($ ~ 50 _ 00) Doll an II a securlly deposlllO be held by Ihe LANDLORD for Ihe rentallerm In accordance wllh Ihe provlllonl of the Pennsylvania Landlord Tenanl Act of 1951 II amended. NO PART OF THE SECURITY DEPOSIT IS TO BE CONSIDERED AS THE LAST RENT PA YMl!NT DUE UNDER THE TERMS OF THIS LEASE. . Renll arc due on the 11 th day or Ihe monlh In ad vince. Renllhlll be considered overdue If nOI received by Ihal day, Ind If the overdue conllnuCl 1 Ihe TENANT alrelllo PlY I Ille , charse of $ 1.00 per day,and every daY late. -' A check Ihllll relumed wllhoul paymenl by Ihe bank will nol be considered paymenl for the renl and all COlli of Ihal check will be Ihe rnponslblllly of the TENANT. If Ihe renlll nOI plld when due. or In case of a breach or evallon or an allempl to break or evade any pari of Ihe alreemenl, the enllre renl for lhe fulllerm of Ihe lease Ihall become due and PlY able. and the LANDLORD mlY lermlnale lhelelle .nd reponCII Ihe premllCl wllhoUI any nOllce whatsoever. If Ihe LANDLORD accepll any of Ihe renl 01 any lime afler II hll become due. after dcfaull hll been made In Ihe paymenl of Ihe renl, or fallllo enforce any of Ihe rlshts of lhe LANDLORD or any of Ihe penalllellncluded, Ihe LANDLORD II nol walvlnllhe rlghllo enforce IhOle rllhll or penalllll al any other lime. AllemplllO col- lecllhe renl by one means docl nOI walvelhe rllhllo colleclll by any olher meanl. F.XJlInIT UN' " . " , . Ir Ihl!, TENANT beeomu Inlolvetll, mnku In 1..lanmenl ror Ihe benenl or credllon, -.0010111. any lei or bankruplcy, rHu I voluntlry pellllon In bankruptcy, or Ir Iludamenlll enlered or In Involunllry pellllon or blnkruplcy II riled lallnlllhe Tl!NMlT, nlllhe renl ror the rulllunl or Ihe IUlllhl1l become due Ind collec. Ilble Immldlltely, TENANT hll no rlahllo IlIlan or lublease lhe premlm. Mlhe Ind or the lerm 1IIIed In Ihl, lem, ellher Ihe LANDl.ORD OR THE TIlNANT mlY terminate Ihlllcue by alvlnalhe olher plrty wrlllen nollce or Illeasl JO - dlYI. Wlthoulluch nOllce Ihlllult Ihlll conllnueunder the lame lerml Ind conditions In rorce allhe end or Ihe term ror I furlher period or I y.n Ind 10 on rrO~l _ May 11. 1992 unllllermlnlled by either parlY slvlns Ihe other '\ 0 daYI wrlllen notice. Jr Ihe LANDLORD slves one monlh's wrlllen notice prior 10 the end of Iny lerm of his Inlentlon 10 ehlnae Ihe lermllnd eondltlonl of Ihe IUle Ind the Tl!NANT remalnlln posmslon or Ihe properly aner Ihe erreellve date or Ihll nOllee, Ihe TENANT will be cOOlldered as a TENANT under Ihe lerml and condlllonl of Ihe nollce. LANDLORD may make adJuslmenls covcrlnl any price Inercasea In Ihe cosl or ulllllles or scrvlcn upon Ilvlna Ihe TENANT onc monlh's notice, . . Jr TENANT vlcllnlhe premlsnluvlna behind an.1 abandonlna any penonal property dter I rellonlble op- porlunlly 10 remove II. I.ANDLORD Is aUlhorlled and empowered 10 lell Ind dllpole or this properly In Iny mlnner whatsoever. LANDLOJlP has no lIablllly or mponslblllty 10 IccounllO Ihe TENANT ror Ihe dllpOll1 or Ihll property. .' H Ihe LANDLORD or Ihe TENANT are members or Ihe Armed Forces of Ihelr mpecllve counlnn on Icllve duly Ind the LANDLORD recelvel permanenl chanle of Italian orden 10 return 10, or Ihe TENANT recelvCl permlnenl chinle of Itlllon ordm 10 deparl from, the Irel where the premllcs Ire located. or tr either plrty II relieved from acllve duly, or If the 'rENANT II lullned lovernmenl qUlrlm, ellher parly mlY termlnlte Ihll IUle upon alvlna II leis I one month'l wrlllen nollee to the olher parly with n copy or Ihe ornclll orden WI"ln- Ilnlluch termination atlached to the nollce. " Jr the TENANT moves with Ihe consenl or hllLANDLORD prior 10 Ihe lermlnatlon dlte 101 forlh In Ihl. larce- ment, or Iny renewal there or, the TENANT mUll slve one monlh'l wrlllen nOllce In Idvlnce, all renl mUll be plld prior to Ihe movlns date. Ind 1 monthllddlllonal renl mUlt be plld allhe lime or alvlna no lice or Ihe early termination. .-.-.-..-..--.-.-- TENANT will return ,II kayalo Ihe LANDLORD upon Ihulld or Ihelerm orth.lwe, A chari' orSI5.oo will be mlde Ir Ihe keYI nre nol returned. TENANT Ihlll 1101 11111111 IllY nlw or Iddlllonll lockl wllhoul LANDLORD'I pcrmllllon. The premlm mlY bl occupied Ind uled II I perlonal mldencl by thl rollowlna penonl only: .Iann N~ q,A.,rlA1" Rrlod l\nt"'n\flt r."R.Anrltu" l.ln.; ? (~h\'rl.I",.aIL UlllllY chlrllllra 10 bl plld Bnd IIrvlm provided.. rollowll Hcallna 10 be plld by T"III,111 r. Hcallnl or wiler 10 be plld by Te na.n t _ Eleclrlclly 10 bl plldby '1'..n"n~. 01110 be plld by Te nlln t Waler and ICwcr 10 be plld by Tena.n t Trllh Flmovlllo bl plld by Tena.nt Llwn clre provided by Tnnan t Snow removll provided by Tp nan t - LANDLORD Ihall hive Ihl rlBhllo ItOp Ihe lervlm or any utilities. lemporarlly, In Ihe evenl or I mllruncllon or 10 rlcllllllle IlIerlllonllnd/or repaln. TENANT Ihlll not Ule Iny melhol! or heallna olher thin Ihal lupplled by Ihe LANDLORD wllhoul LANDLORD'I permllllon. Ir Ihl premlm arl tOlllly deltroyed or damaBed by nre. lhe leale endl on Ihe dlY Ihl TENANT movel oul. Ir Ihe dlmlle II parllaland repairable, Ihe TENANT may choole 10 lIay Ir Ihe dlmllel cln bl repaired within a rellonlbllllme. . LANDLORD rem VII Ihe rllhl 10 enler upon lhe premhel al reuonable Ilmll ror the purpolC or mlklnl nceelllry Inlpecllon, maklnl repairs, or Ihowlnl Ihe premlm 10 prolpecllve purchucn or lenlnll. Ind 10 dllpllY "ror renl" or "ror laic" Illnl. The TENANT renlllhe premilClln Ihelr exllllnl "II II" cl)l\dlllon. The TENANT Ilrmlo keep th. premllCl In I 100d 1IIIe or prelervallon Ind cleanllnell. No Iplrlmenl hallwaYI or l\alrwaYlahlll be ulld ror Iny purpolI olhlr thin enlrlnce Ind exll. Common Ireu will nol bl uled ror Ilorlle. TENANT Ihall nol permll objcclllo be Iwepl. Ihrown,lhaken or hunl rrom wlndowl, doon or bllconl... TENANT Ihlll nol UII plumblnl or cicc- I trlcll equlpmenl ror Iny purpolC olher Ihln Ihole ror which Ihey were conllrucled. Any dlmal" 10 III plumb- Inl equlpmenl caulld by mlluse or nellllence will be repllred Illhe expenle or Ihe TENANT. Ploon will be properly mllnlllned Ind Iny rU11 rurnllhed by Ihe LANDLORD will be cleaned upon deparlure. Wuhcn, drycn Ind dllhwuhen mlY blulld only wllh Ihe LANDLORD'I permllllon. - . Wllldnw Ihlldu, curlnllls nnd curlnlll radl mn)' belnllnUcd only wllh Ihe L^"IDLOIl.D'. pcIrmllllon. On p.nel- ed willi n.1I1 for hlnllnl pic lUres mly only be pl.ced In lhe IrooVII of Ihl plnlUnl. Ho plcturl hookl, nllll, elc. lirlc, Ihln the nlll ror I 10 lb. plclure hook mly b. InlllUcd wllhoul Ihl e"prcu pcrmllllon Dr Ihl LMmLOIl.D. TI!NANT will PlY Ihe COil or Iny or III replln IIr Iny kind whlUotYCr occurrlnlarltr Ihl bellnnlnl or IhlllUlI wher,lhl Indlvldull CUll or nch repllr Illmlh.n S ' No dOli, CIU, pell or, Inlmlll mlY lie kepi on Ihe premlltl wllhoUllhe wrlllen permlnlon or Ihe LAHDLORD. . No boala Ind no molor vehlcln olher Ihln I IIcenlCd prlnle Paunler lulomoblle mlY be plrked on Ihe premllll wllhoullhe permlnlon or Ihe LAl'IDLORD. ' TI!NI\l'IT Ihall nol meke or allow dlllurbln, nol" 10 be made wllhln lhe premlltllhal InnoYlolher lenanlt or nellhbora or Inlerrern with Ihelr d,hlof qulelenjoymenl. l'Io Inllrumenll Ihal crnle or reproduce loundllhal may be hnrd beyond Ihe cOllrlnn or Ihe premlm Ihall be pllyed bel ween Ihe houn or 10 p,nl. and I I.m. TEI'lANT5 Ihall nol dll or allow any acllvllln In!urloul 10 Ihe premlltl, or Ihe olher lenallll, or which ~I\I ' advmcly arrecl Ihe LAl'IDLORD'1 Inlurance on lhe properlY. LAl'IDLORD Ihall nol be liable for properly daml,e or perlonallnjury on hll properly un leiS Ihe damlle or InJury lCIulll directly from Ihe LAHDLORD'I ,roil nelllBenee. THIS AORl!l!Ml!l'IT IS A BINDIHO COHTRACT. '. ...~ . '~ /; fi;ij' ~ 1 --'-~""AA - 1--:1 LAND'4D MIS . MYlIlS~ .. LAHDLORD ~PM fJG~o~h T Al'Il' JOHN If. Il!NDEl ~""'A.~Q ,-/I. f.~ ,,_J.... T HAHT 1I01l1lI! L. IIENDI!P. , TEHAHT .""....--.-..- " I' " ~AI (lie~;4/;R &v./.u. 1.r,P./,'fliYt,( /V6':""')" :l.~S'C#~d.v~~~&tt1~ Sk-",~~-~ .: ~If""''';' f/d ..l:Yfy,r..l"'<' M<l;fl6y ..1(,1.& .wMr~ """.. .. /99..r /-16~9:r :, I - :J./- 'fr 1/ ;;../()~%-:, ;;l-.l3-?.s- / 3 a -/d ~9 ~-, 3 -/t.-1f:>' ~ .. 1-/tJ~?{",: Lf-/'!-'1-S' ~ S,t/,)..r~" ~--;g-f> ll' 4"16 '9>-, /'IottEIVr'" pd ,:17 )-7-S-'1S' I.+/J ~J,)/)."" 7"/0-- 9.~- 7, ),2. ~ ,/,," /:L. " .z "10 -95"" #0 t<l.3tV r 1'4 i3 / trt-IP'-f$'" Nt> /1./tl'lrfJ ;~- b , '. I" .' dtt.r pa; .$=ltI-"r " ;../o,?Y.: 7-/11-'11 , fi"/'-'1 !, 1-/0 ''''1 I' 1(r1"~"Y , I, 1/ ---/Irfy;, 1t:',fJ-1r ;. i,' .. t,-,-9'r ~ -//-91" 7-~3-9r .!S-13 - 9Y 'J-/() -9r 10-/1 - 9'1 1/-/9 -fY' /)..-/s-91' " 33 I 13 .3 eN '!-/M.G / 9 .j.... , 'I fl, ~~ J . Ol:l .3 ?, (10 r,vu '3 ' 0l:I ~7.."'" /,:;.-; C"O ~ ) 9~ ,,(1rO F9 3.3. d'O 3:;'. "'0 17, Pr> /,,7,()"() .;1.1- 00 g?: (JO 3" ,or:.> '93.otlJ do' ,". _...._--. ~f!)'iJ,"t(J) a.,s"t) r "D 3$(7', liP ~-_.. ,..--.-- " I '4 t?i.. .::!rtJ., III!;, .?3 I' , !/tJ,J;. ~JI",r !I S~l'r .<'Nr ii ?n~ d..v- #1.(.' ., I.,.' I~ W~tI:.'l 't ~~"'\f"1. lr:..(/( II e--..:t ,/."'"'-. ,) ,'"1,,,1 :"~fJ' j, ~"./ .].1' :! ~'I>'l. V 'I ;.~ ~/' o..t" / I, ~~ /" -/,,;/ 3 IS. d~ -" ---.-,..--... H 171'.,'),:;,3 (.b((;di~tI,:'J,.j." I4~J,,,,,1' (}.fot "'6'~, 1/-"', h,,',.;:.,/~"")' _.-li..t.!...:":2- . ; ~:'d& ,t,tr,;;'/".( ) tilt;", ,7.7 I '1. I.t l_ EXHIBIT "B" \, I' , .. I J , , I, WRIFIOAl1ON I verily that the atatementa made In the foregoing document are true and correct. I undel1ltand that false statements hsrsln are made subjeot to the penalties 0118 Pa,C,S, 54904, relating 10 unsworn falsification to authorities, t~.2'-,2" ')'7/#' ... Dated: I,;, - L/ .q '3 , , I' , , , , II' (. , '1 , , I .1' d, ~,. , \-'1' ,,',':', .', \1 I. , " " 'I, ,'" , " (i , " , , I ij I , , 1 , " : , , ,. , : , I', I 1;,'1 , " \" , l'lt , " " .i, " 1'1'1] , , ,'f". " I", ;), H 'I I', III.! , I' , i,11 " , , iI', i , " .i, I., I,i , , 'I,' , " I'j' " " .. . ..\ " "II' I, " 'i , , 1;1 " , I, , , I ,I " II , , , " ,.1 'q , , "J, ,'1'1 , 1 , 1,'1: I" , ,\1 " ;'1 i'l " " " , ! I ,. '" , , , II' 1 " " " , .t .,' !I ;" " 1'1'. I' , , 'jql, " '" I'!' I' Ii 1I'"d 1"1 I I., 'I'/J I I.,,! \i' , , , :J"J", : III ~ \ " 1.'.1 ',I L' '1>'" , J1, g', '.:',,"1'11, ", , , 'I " ,>. ' ,I~i'!""; I.- '.,., 'I'.."'...~..';!.. 'I'" " · ;':";'( " . ! 1 i,i," I ", ,:::,,"1'. "'1 . , ;,'il"l,1 :' : ' .'1. ;,,.l,.l,'\{/' ""I"J;)".', l'l,i,.'1) ,',}.i\'\\ I' "1(1 "I. , ' ;1' "I , "",1 ') I 'Ii, I,; 'I I ,\ , , lil, I' , ," ,I " 1 , , ,H , , , ' ~ ' , , , , ... . , , , " I, ;1" I, , , ,,, , " I , : I I' , " 1 " ,"1 I. , I' , , , 'ii\' ,I <,!! " , , !,. 1'1 , , . , I, ~ ,i , lit ,I! 'I ,I, ,I ,., /, '!./ , ' 'III 1','1 , .1 .)",', 'I :" ,I " 'I I , i' " " '.'" , , " " " " , , , , , I , " '1'1, " , ,I 'I I , .,' " 1 " " " I , " , I: " " " I !' " ! I _l ,', I' ~"""!i' 'I' " I 'l'ttANcltI,.w~'''' MI"IHIY" TUL\.V . ' " " " " " " , , , , I " , 'I' " t,. ,\ 'I , , ' >I' 'I " , , ,I I " 1.-;: 'I ",,t. I i 'I, , , " 'i! I ,IP " II " I I " \i , " ,) I Jr' , 1 , , " " , .1 , 1 , , , , , I , I / I " " I, , I' , I , , , I , , " 11" II 'I , ., ,I, , , , , )1 I , 1 " " , I,j' , I " ,) " " " 'il L! 'fii " I' ','l'L, " ,I;, , " ", " ,I 1,1 .'1' " I', II I,Lt"' ;1' ;' " , , " ,'1\ , , 1(, ,HI!, " 'il;, , I,"~ , ", " t'!.; )'; ,lil,I\I,' , " q 'I' , '. I' 'I H 1 fV c. n;:...- COMMON PLEAS NOTIFICATION r;~"INTIFF REQ~~~!x~..~RM MYERS, CURTIS 9 MOOREDALE ROAD CARLISLE, PA 17013 L V8. OEFtNU"NT NAAll allll "uont-OQ 'Ot:NDER, JOHN 203 FAIRFIELD ST. NEWVILLE, PA 17241 L rOCkmNO': CV-0000152-951 DnloFllocJ: 9/25/95 --"-.'- - DlsposllJon Dole: 10/17/95 Pl.... bl .d,I..d Ih,! In ippe.1 h., boon IIIld In Iho .bove ,.pllonld '''0 Kindly o..lhl, lo,m 10 Indl,.lllh. ,,,oil, In Ihl, ..... .nd ,ltum 10 Ihllllulny .ulhollly 11I.I.d .bo'.', RESULT OF APPEAL Common Pie.. Judge eUMMARY APPeAL APPEAL SmlCKEN . appnl h.. b.on dl..llow.d, APPEAL DISCONTINUED. Ipp..1 ho, b..n dl.onllnuod by .ppoll.nl. D19Tf1ICT JUSTICE OECIGION UPHELD. .ourt hi' ,..chld ..mo docl.lon .. ollgll1ul dl.I,I.llu.lI.. d..I.lon, _ dl.III.llulti.. 0/11.11.10 .01lICI ,.mllnlng Iln..l.o.I., APPEAL sUCCESEFUL . .ourt ha. ,..ch.d docl.lon '"o"bl.lo d.l.ndol1l lull ,olund 10 be I....d by dl.I,I.1 ju.llc, oHI.. pll1l.ll8Iund 10 b"llu.d by dl.I,lcllu.lI.. oHlco, REVisED DisTRIBUTION OF FINES AND COSTG II dlllllot lu.II.. oHlcol.lo IlIu, . p.rtl.1 IOlund, pl....lndlcol. .ny now di.I,lbullon In th. Imounlll) of ftn_. and COlt. II . te.ull 01 'he court', doelalon. OOMMONWEAL TH OF PENNSYLVANIA ,~...-"COUNTV OF: CUMBERLAND -~ ,..."" .....-.,====- 09-3-02 OJN...... ItGII r" HILIN B. SHULENBERGER ........ P.O. BOX 155 27 W. BIG SPRING AVENUE NIWVILLE, PA '.......... 17171 776-3187 17241 I,r " HELEN B. SHULENBERGER P.O. BOX 155 27 W, BIG SPRING AVENUE NEWVILLE, PA 17241 , ' " , 1'" 'c, , I~ , FINE COUNTY CRT COST tJTATE CAT COST STATE CST! HEARING COST , I OTHERlpl.... .poollyl ., ...J ., ...J EMS CAT JCP DVC CVC CCD CIVIL APPEAL APPEAL STRICKEN. .pp..1 h.. b..n dl"lIow.d APPEAL DISCONTINUED. .pp..1 h.. bl.n dllConllnuld by Ipp.lI.nl. DISTRICT JUSTICE DECISION UPHELD. court h.. ,e..hod 'ho '0"'. d.cl.lon .. lho dl,I,lclluotlClludgm.nt. DIBTRlCT J~STICE OECIBION DISMIBSED . court ho. ,..ch.d 0 docl.lon lh.' doo' nol conou, wllh Ihl dl.lllc'lullI.. judgm.nt. WRIT 0' CI!RTlORARI WRIT STRICKEN. IPPltl h.. boon dl.ollow.d, WRIT DISCONTINUED. w,1I h.1 bl.n dl.eontlnu.d by opp.lI.nl DISTRICT JUSTICE DECISION SET ASIDE .Ihl .... will bo IOh..,d du.'o l"oglll,"Iy, lo,k ollu,l,dlcllon, 0' Improp.. v.nUI, WRIT DISMISSED. dl.trlct IUltlc. decltlo" wee not found to bo flawed, lacking jUrllIdlcUon , or having impropor venlJO. STATI!MI!NT 0' OIlJI!CTION (Pi.... glv.. g.n".'lumm.,v 0' Ih. ,..alll) OSJECTION DISCONTINUED. obloollon h.. b.on dl,conllnu.d by In. .ppoll,nl OSJECTION DENIED. obllcllon h.. b.on d.nlod bV Ih. Court 01 Common PI'.. OBJECTION UPHELD. appollanl'. obJ.cllo" hat boon upheld bV tho Court of Con\mon Ploal, AOPC 129-05 FORM PRINTED: 11/20/95 8:40138 .. rtMnaUW'M'" or HHHIYlVAHIA - COlM' or CclMMOIl ".t.r-- " NOTlel 0' A"IAL rllOM 11/1'1/,1' DllTlUeT JUIYlel JUDOMINT "u~CI:'I\MON!~'A'~. 9!.-_1.,! ft! ,c.~,--'!..~...._:__. NOYlCI 0' APPIAL NoIQ II g1V11l that the appoIlant hol flltd In ,he above Co,,' of CO/11mo" ptOOI .", oppool f""" ,he jud(j/11Oll' rondontd by ,he Dllhlc' JlII,kl OIl the ... cnlln !he __ n..~ioIwJ b.Iow. IIHIICIAI DlII.,ey _""~ _________u__ -,.--U-"-'-UU-'--"-'-'--"'-'-.---'-'--I1ilM"~T-." - JOHN BENDBR D.J. SHULBNBBROIR 09-3-02 ~ tI' """"'" M_~_~._.._..___._________.._.._~-~.._-...~----.---.---. .--M-.-.mll--~~-------- ,. COOl' 203 P~IR'IBLD STRRET, ~PT. I NBWYILL~ PE~NSYLV~NI~ 17241 ~~;;;: 11l7~~~YE~~.-.-'"'------'-..-..Vl.---- J;1I~~~-7'" ~ ~,': ..-=~:;; - wi. o9ltd ONLY when ,hil no"'HOII II ..qulred under Po. R.cP.JP, No. "appollanl was CLAIMANT (see Pa, RC,P,J,P. No. I~IL " Thk Nota of ,\ppeol, when ..e....d by the OlI"lct jo,J1Hco. will op,",,'o 01 0 100 1 (6) In 00110/1 before Dlsulet Justice, he MUST ISIJlIltISBlI!AS'" the l~ lot pollllllOll In thll COla FILE A COMPLAINT withIn twonly (20) dllyS Biter I filing his NOTICE 01 APPEAL S/r1,alunl ar7fo//IonolIllY"iYl}"",;;y.--.--' .~...----, --.-.-._.__.~----_....-...-+_.._. '.AICI'I TO INTIR RUL-I To.i"i.icOMPLAINT AND RULI TO fill (th115tHlt/on 01 101m to be used ONLY when appel/alll was DEFENDANT Is/)(} Prl, RCPJ.P, No, 1001171 In ac/lO/1 b%lll D1slllcr Justlco, IF NOT USED, dt1/Bch /rom cqlY 01 nal/ca alappeal fa be sorvod upon appel/oo), P1l41CIPII To Prothonololy , , Enlet nM upon (Common PItoI No. CURTIS MVERS ,____,_____________'._____ ,oppoll..{.), '" fllo 0 complaint I loppeaI NNf'lf} 01 a,lJII1J01J( Ii} 9'>- l. vr'L(I,..J r ~_I within lwenly (201 dOYI oflet ""vlco~ule '" 1~I~rf I ofrlonplOL CY~'~"t, , ----~- """"""''''_OfhltOflrJmOyOf_ IULII To CURTIS MVERS Na". 01 _"..../ __, oppolloo(.), (11'1'"", en noHfled thot 0 Me II hnhy enleted """" you to fill 0 complain' In thll oppool within tWtlflly (201 daYI otlet the dote of' ..-vIce of thIl Me upon you by penono!lI,vkl '" by e"tlfled '" I1Igll'ored moll (2) H you da not flle 0 compIoInt within Ihll Hmo, 0 JUOGMEN' OF NON PROS WilL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU. (3) Tho ~ 01 lINk/of thIl Me II I"vleo WOI by moll II the dote of moiling. . _ 0.:. 7t""~ 1'1, 19....tf. -~, '1'~ \ {;, III '(!l....J AA.a:t:" 8/vIOhn''''~ Of 00pJty 10fIC 1111l... COURT FILE ~, I l d ~ - PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT (Thlt p,oo/ a/lmioe MUST DE FILED WI WIN rfN I /II) IJA YS Af rHI II""~ II," 1I,,,,e" 01 "PP""I, Ch",~ dppll08/Jle /lOUI) COIiIIlOHWIALVH 0' PINNIVLVANIA COUNTVO' ~..MBBRLAI'ID ..............._.. _.. ~ II APPlDAVIT: I hereby swear 0' alll,m thai I lo"od IlV 0 ~opy 01 Ihe Nolloo of Appoo!. COlllmoll PIli'" No .!I5.:di.4.lilL.ciYi l UpOIl Iho Olll,lcl JUlllco dooIO""led Ihe,olh on (dere 0/ servloe) ~.Q.VEMBER 1.7. 10--9.5, IJ IIY pOI.uIIOI .01V1co ~ hy (co,lIt1ed) ('oOlllored) mall, se"del'1 ,.oelpl allachlld herelo, alld UpOll Iho apPlltl.O, /nomo} ..., ,CUR'rlfLMXERfL... ,.-.---..' ,on NnVF.MRF.Il,.l..'L---, 10~ I)y per,ollol'""I<;O [lily ("'ltllllo,J) lillUI.hltOd) 111,,11, oo"dol'. ,ocolplouo.hed haralll, o and ,u,'hor Ihollle,yad lI,alluhl hl FlIlln CUlllpllll"lncCOlllP,,"yl"U Ihanhuy" Nulleo of Appoalupon Ihe oppelleo(l) lowhum 'he Rule WOB oddrosood oil ___._____....'. _., .,.__,_._, lU..,.,., [J hy porooll,,1 ,01V1CO [] by (c,,,lIllod) ("'Qlslo,ed) motl, sondo"s rocolpl ollochod ho,o'u ~',. /~ 'SWORN (AFFIR"IED) AND SUBSCRIBED B. HaRE M. E_. ~./7 / 1/1 t. .J~ - .'I/'V'IfC.V (." v . , THIS _~_DAV OF IL/O,()('''~( 19,.]il -------- a~ slg""",".,.",,n, s,;;;;UfI;' "., b./O" .hO";-'(~S#t.;.~,--- -------- rm,,,'oltld/" t,ly ooml/1l..lon e~plr.. on .19_. N<Xonnl 0o?I ~~IJ",ur,t:"In"JPlbllo cN1ii:Ao r,(ll.l, (l!I' ,1'>'11111\..1 r..?UIl~ Mycc.cr~r"..",r..11 t,:,;.Il:~' 0:.1. I, 1 J.}Il l1fll,ju;]\i7":'.;;':::J ,;..1 ,.:.,-' .' , . ..~.. , " ',- .: II" ".t. ! , .:",- "' , I, L'.) ., l;- I. It '''rl'''' " .r, "'} r. .~i "'\' -:::.,:,1 ., ,",' I, 'J',' '. I ' ,~ L':-j Con ,-, I! ,Ii :1 .. ,1\. ".1 I P 10'1'1 1003 au AICIIPT '0" CI"TI'IID MAIL. ~ IN~lIlW1tl tQV11WIl PAOYIOIO 1IO"QIlI'-"MA1IONAl W.,lll ,5', R'I'lI,,'J ~j,Ji.ll.' ~n Sbul.~~l?tf~t.' '1MMJ:2Jq~pL1p 'lJ e., HtJ:'lrHC.:e:n. . P''''I\II I _1,'r C~~.F;;..--._-~------ "', to ._...,.,__.._....... --l-~ 61,.,...-r:,~ .'~-'~~~'" " " C__WI...'" Of "NNIYlV~IA _-IOn --------"cou.loHOMMilN ,lm NOllel 0' A"PIAL 'ROM II/I'I/?{ DlllYRICY JUlflCI JUDOMINY ~OM/llON mAl No. eN. (. 'I J' ~ e',;J I.u~_ HOYlCI 0' APPIAL II/PlC'AI PlI'.'CI Notk. I. gI_ lhol"'" oppoIlont 110. liI.d In II.. obovo Coor! of C"'"IIllI' PI.o.",. '~lfl.lIl ,,"''' Ih. III')U"'.'" IInd.,.d iJy Ih. DI.hle' Jo.II(. "" lho doIIt and In tlw (a.. monIIonod bolow. ~;~~"-;~~~-~F.~-'-" -1~~;~N~~~~~~~l~ll~~~H-~~~;'~~; "lllllHlrllnll'lUlJ/r-"'- .... " ,.11 It".,.. ------'"JJl:i:ll)f- 203 FAIRFIELD STHERT, APT. 1 NEWVILLE PENNSYLVANIA 17241 ~~_."-"-'--]JllHrlu..Ot'j'w-.jl/j" il).)1,.~',it~/' .. -~...._----.- .l8,{,l.1.m...... . ,gU,T "" YEI" - ,.,. ~"'.l.",, .i~3'"-- o::~, ~ !L9~~"~,~i",~:,.."";,. ,oJ. ",~1;:" ,<,f,;,,, .c,. tff,MA~il;;,;;P;;RCPJP""- 10081. TN. Natk. of "'",,"01, whon ",colvtd by lho 0..,11" Jo.,Ie., will opelol. o. 0 1001 (6) IIlllctlon /Je(om Dls/,Ic/ Jus/Ice, he MUST SUPfRSWf...S 10 lho lodgmonl "" ""..e..lon In Ihl. (0'" FILE A COMPLAINT wit/Jill tWt1llty (20) days aller I11lI1g Ills NOTICE o( APPEAL .. -.. .--.--..--.., -.'- S~jiliJtiJfO--;-}/-'P,liih;)lloi/I'Y' ~)I-l)l.,)uly .____.._____._...._._._n._._... n_'_._. .. PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE YO Fiu COMPLAINT AND RU'LI to,iLI IThIs sflCtlon 01 loml/o be usod ONLY WllOlllVlpOlIlIIII WilS DEFENDANT (SOli "ii, /lCI'JP. No, 100/( 7) 1/1 IICIiOllllClolCl Olsl/lc/ Just/co, IF NOr USED, dolllch I,om c""y 01 /Io/lco 01 'l/lIltJlIl/o IJtJ SQlw1lluIJO/' IIIl/Jt,lIoor PRAICIP.. To !'rothonolory Enlor Ni. 01"'" _u.._uc;UIl~IS t:lyl'~S N.tlIlIJllIll/f>lllk!I.(/)/ '1~. de>" /1,': J ..,- (Common Ploo. No. ___~t,.],LL,,,,",,,,,,'J_",I..u._ , , oppellee('I, 10 file 0 (omplaln' I" I. """.01 " ,I wllhln IWI"'Y (201 doy. oller .erv". 3\'ole '" .off.~~~ol 0/{,''1/ ~" ' ---.-----.--.---.----- ~.----Sjr111111;;'.;;.~.k'II;,' (}I hIS /)"0010)1 Of IIIP'f RULI. To _-'=-!:!.RTIE.JiYERL_____u Nwnll 1)1 ""ldlltW( b} ,. u , appelle.('I, ( I) y"" "'" nollflod lho, 0 rule I. hmby e"tered opon yoo 10 me 0 (olllploln' In Ihl. opp.ol within tWlnly (20) doy. oller Ih. dolo 01 IeIvk. of thi. ",10 open you by ".,,,,nol .ervk. '" by (erllfl.d '" ,"gl,'e",d 111011. (2) H you do not fllo 0 (omplolnl within Ihl. Ilnll, 0 JUDGMENT OF NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AG...INST YOU, (3) Tho do1o of ..,vlce of IhI. rol. If .",vle. woo by molll.lhe dole of I11OlIlng" n C;~ -----~~ ' SIf7><<1'; ~'"Y IN Doopory Deft: 1Uw-.t....I'I ,19U, AOPC3111'.84 COURT FILE TO BE FILED WITH PROTHONOTARY . - PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT (ThlS/1I001 01 SllVIce MUST Bf FILED WI T1I/N r/,'N 11111 /lA YS AI' IT/I I"IIIU "'0 II""CII '" "ppoo' GI,ock IIppl,"ob'o bu.o.) COMIIONWIALTH 0' PINNIVLVANIA COUNTY 0' --.----'..-.-..', :11 AFFIDAVIT: II1",olly owoo. 01 1111"11I 1111111 "n/Vod o II copy ul 1110 Nollco 01 App""1. COlllmOIl 1'10.'0 No _.__' ",.,__,...,.,,,..,, ,Upiln 1I1n O'o"'tl Ju.lIco doolOllolo<l 11101011\ on '11illo ol",vII;ol _,____.,,,,.,..,,11),,.__, r.1 by po'o","" 601Vlco rJ Ily Icollllled) (roo,.IOlod) moll. unool'. '~colp' ollBchod horutl), IIneil/pO" ttlO nppulllJu. tn/lnloJ... t____..___._____...'n_~.___..__.__~_..~__,.__.___.~_.___-, Oil _., 10__."LJ I,y p...."1II1.0IYlCO [J by leulllllu<I) (100'61010<1111I1111, ..,lIjol'6 10CUlplllllOthod 1101010 [j ond IUllhUI 111011 ,ulVu,i 11111 lIuh> I.) Fllu.1 C'lIlljIIlIIII1CtOIllP""yIIO Iho ~boVO Nolleo 1)1 AppoDI upon 1110 oppolloe(.) 10 wl10m 1110 Ruin waG IIdll,o'"UfI 011 '_' ..," ,__",..'_, 10,_".,__ [) by pm.ol1l1l.,mlcu lJ by 1<",11110<1) (100"10100) moll, 6lJl1dl.H'S f'aculpt nllnch13d l1orclo SWORN (AFFIRMED) AND SlIDSCflllJED lJEFOIlE ME THIS .__OA Y 01'._ .____.. ___ , \ 0____. -,,---------"------."sijJmjiijliel','lInl --.-----..-- fl'IJIIIIIlJlII otoll,cltJI'/fJ'OIU ~'Il)f" dlllll/J\!II W,lb /Il/I"IJ --.--- rifl.01u"II;/" MV commlll1on ..plnta on ,19_. o~; e:= c;: .. ~E 1 ,.,il~,:,; ~ p'" ,. w,n fIn! , III' lJ I~' , .".', I ......, ,.1., :11'.1 ,...... ..,I,) !I' "1 }~.,'\ .~ ~t N .1"., . r'" ,~, "If ~LI ~f"; - .....1 u5 " r.n fi. u... .. "" Lu " ~ p; j ~l~ ~ "\ ' ... ~ Iu 11\ "\ t: r .. CbMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF: CUMBERLAND .... IloI ... NOTICE OF JUDGMENT/TRANSCRIPT 09-3-02 I'lAINTlFF _. .... "'~,",1lI IMYERS, CURTIS 9 MOOREDALE ROAD cARLISLF., PA 17013 L .., OJ"IlI'lt~ HELEN B. SKULENBERGER - P.O, BOX 155 27 If. BIG SPRING AVENUE NEWVILLE, PA ,....- 17171776-3187 17241 .J VB. JOHN BENDER 15 E. MAIN STRUT NEWVILLE, PA 17241 OF.FENOANl Iii NMll "11" ....11)1*8$ BENDER, JOHN 15 E. MAIN STREET NEWVILLE, PA 17241 L Doc~UI No, cv-ooooi'52="%1 DaleFlIlld: 9/25/95 _J .., THIS IS TO NOTIFY YOU THAT: FOR PLAINTIFF Judgment --- .------ [!] Judgment wasentered for: (Nsme) -MYERS. CURT I S [!] Judgmenl was Bnlered agslnSl: (Name) BENDER I JOHN In the emount of S 1&12..53 on: (Dsle) ),9./1 7 /9 5 o Damages will be asse$sad on: (Date & Time) -- TOTAL $1,770.23 $49,30 $,00 $,00 $1,819,53 o This case dismissed Without prBjudlce, o Possession grsnted, O Possession granted If money judgmenlls not satisfied withIn thlny days, o Posse88lon not grsmed, o Lavy Is stayed lor _ days or 0 generallv Slaved, o Objection to levy has been lIIed and hearing will be hald: Date: Place: Amount 01 Judgmant Judgment Costs Interest on Judgment Attornev Fees Time: ANY PARTY HAS THE RIGHT TO APPEAL WITHIN 30 DAYS OF THE DATE OF JUDGMENT BY !'ILING A NOTICE OF APPEAL WITH THE PROTHONOTARY I CLERK OF THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS. CIVIL DIVISION. --- Dste , District Jusllee I certify Ihatthlsls a true and correct copy 01 tha record ot the proceedings contslnlng Ihe judgment. _Dale , District Justice MV comml88lon e~plres first MondsV of January, 2000, SEAL AOPC 31 S'~I CURTIS MYERS, Plalntll\' IN THE COURT OJI COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO, 95-6489 CIVIL TERM CIVIL ACTION-LAW v, JOHN AND BONNIE BENDER, Defendantl t#i RULE TO SHOW CAIJSE AND NOW,thilZl..: day of~..l'1~.tJtl-r' 1998. upon review of the enclosed petition a Rule To Show Cause why the relief requested should not be granted Is entered upon John Bender, ."el fO(~I'ttf(, This Rule is returnable 1_ days from service hereot~up!l. JAhlllhlllllf, Service to be made by petitioner, BY THE COURT, ?aLL J, 1:1'(" ('i,,:';': cr. '.il;)1\'( '1'1 1/0/" 'I " 1,1 n3 ' I ~ . < , I " CI" ' , "If' ' ...+~I' " I t; ~I .'J II " 1,,1 , \ , , , , , , '" , 7, Attached hereto is a true and l;orrect copy oflUrther correspondence to Mr, Bender and a copy of the Arbitration Award In the instantl\laller, 8, Prior to the expiration of the oppeal period from the entry oflhe Arbitration Award petitioner requests that this courtllront his pethion 10 whhdrawal os counsel for John Bender, WHEREFORE, petitioner requests this Honoroble Court to Ill'Bnt his requesllo wilhdrawalu counsel for John Bender, Respectfully submitted, O'BRIEN, BARIC & SCHERER ~A~. Dale: 1jl.l,lft David A, Baric, Esquire I,D, 1144853 17 Wesl South Street Carlisle, Pennsylvanlo 17013 (717) 249.6873 dab,dlrllenerallbtndtr,ptl LillI! OIJl~" 01' O'BRlEN"BARlC ~ SCHERER /7 "'", SaUII, Sf/v" Carll,l" PI//"'.I'IY'''''r1 /70/ J SI,,,,/t J, FI,/""." Oleo"",,/ , 'if Roh", L, O'BII'" Dl1Vld A. Ba'l. .III.lta,1 ,4, ,~'clll/'rr (1/7) :NP-681J f.t\' (1/1) :m.ms " December 10,1997 John Bender 203 Falrtleld Street, ApI. 1 NewvUle, Pennsylvania 17241 REI Mytn v, Bender Dear Mr, Bender: I have been working with Bonnie Bender In the above landlord tenant maller, As I am certain you are aware. you are a named delendant In this case, Only recently, Bonnie informed me that the two of you have been separated for some time, The arbitration hearing for Ihis case has been scheduled for January 22, 1998, If you want me 10 represent you 8tthis hearing, plea~e call my olliee with thaI message, You can leave the message on our answering machine anytime of day, You have the righllo have your own independent allomey if you so elecl. If I have not received word 1T0m you prior to the hearing, this case will go forward without you being represented and you may have a Judgment entered against you, If you would like to discuss this case in more detail, rlease give me a call Very truly yours, DAB/jc cc: ~nnie Bender \.!!!e "- '- ;;;;;/2t: :CHERBH David A, Baric, Esquire dab.dlrll'lIur./b,nd,r6,lt r Lall' OfJ/a, O'BRIEN, IMRIC" SCHERER 17 IJ'w SII",II SIIU/ Ca/,I/,I., PoI/lIII,I'I"II/IIa PQI J S/"'tll J, ",1"111111 O/Cou/Il,' Rob"., /., 0'8,1", Dav/d A, /Jail' Mlclla,I,.,. S,III/\'/' (717) J4g.687J F.U' 1m) ug-sw Decemb~r II, 1997 John Bender 203 Fairfield Street, API, I Newville, Pennsylvania 17241 RE: Myers Y. John Bendel' and Donnie Bender Dear Mr, Bender: This correspondence shall conflrnl our conversation of to day's date wherein I advised you to retain your own attorney to represent you in this case brought by Curtis Myers, I will provid~ your atIorney with any information he or she needs to prepare for the hearing scheduled for January 22, 1997, As I informed you. this matter will go forward whether you are in attendance or not and whether you have or have not hired your own attorney, I would strongly sug!!estthat it would be to your benefit to have your attorney become Involved in this case no\\', I want you to understand that a judgment could be entered against you and in favor of Curtis Myers even if you do not attend the hearing Very truly yours, O'BRIEN, BARIC AND SCHERER ~;..,V\/. ',;:..7 ,1: o i ~-- 0~,,- David A. Baric, Esquire DABtjc cc: ~. Ie Bender ~.,' d.b.dlrll,"mlbtndtr7 ,II r CURTIS MYERS, Plaintiff IN nlll COURT OF COMMON PLEAS 011 CUMBERLAND COUNTY, IIENNSYLVANIA NO, 95-6489 CIVIL TERM v, JOHN AND BONNIE BENDER, DetendantB CIVIl. ACTION-l.AW CBRIlflCAllLQr--SmWlCE I hereby certifY that on Junuary~~, 1998, I, David A, Baric. Esqull'e, of O'Brien, Baric & Scherer, did Sllrve a copy of the Petition To Withdrawal As Counsel, by first elm lJ.S, mall, postagc prepaid. to the party listed below, as follows: John Mancke, Esquire Mancke, Wagner, Hershey & Tully 2233 N0I1h Front Street Hanisburg, Pennsylvania 17110 ~d:? /. rt David A, Baric, Esquire , i ,I ,I CURTIS MYERS, Plalnllff IN THE COURT OIl COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COlJNTY, PENNSYLVANIA ", NO 95-6489 CIVil. TERM v. JOHN AND BONNIE BENDER, Defendanls CIVIL ACTION-LAW i,1; I nnm;n OF CQUlt'!' AND NOW, Ihls _, tL day of ,__~doU\-L.l-}--' 1998. upon review oflhe allached Mallon To Make Rule Absolule, Ills hereby ordered and decreed IhB\ Rule previously luued relallve 10 Ihls malter Is ab50tt:le, \.t ~ J))."J ~, 3, n ~ to, C ~ a. '~ " Jcr c! f f"., cJ ..c~"...tJf;.,. .T 3'.",., d"t . &,.llIt.t~...t U~,.- , BY THE COURT, .~~~t!, , , , , FlLEO-QFFICE O~ 11 II: It.rrfl IrHlJTliW 9A Fm I 0 Pi'l III I 0 CUMLI.i-iV\CI ~JjIJNTY P~NI~tWl.V/NIA " , ' , , I, , I , ! " ~, CURTIS MYERS, PlalnUff IN THE COUIn' OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBm~LAND COUNTY, \'ENNSYL VANIA v, NO, 95-6489 CIVIL TERM JOHN AND BONNIE BENDER, Defendanu CIVIL ACTlON.I.AW ManON TO MAKE RUU ADSOl.\Jn: And now, comes David A, Baric, Esquire, attorney lor Delimdallt, Bonnie Bender and respectfully represents as tollows: I, On or about January 26, 1998, Petitioner, Dllvid A Baric, Esquire lUed a I'elltlon For Withdrawal As Counsel rehllive 10 hl~ represent III Ion of John Bender III the above-captioned action, Service of the Rule To Show Clluse WIIS lllllde upon John Bender IInd counsel tor the Plaintiff on or about January 29, 1998 2, To date, no answer has been tiled by the Det'endllnl, John Bender or PlslnUtTto the Petitioll For Withdrawal As Counsel WHEREFORE. Petitioner. David A Bllric. Esquire. respectlully requests lhat this Honorable Court make the Rule To Show Cause which was signed on January 26, 1998 by the HOllorable J. Wesley Oler, Jr, relative to this matter absolute, Respectfully submitted. O'BRIEN. BARIC & SCHERER ~({,cL. Date: .!:l. "i I '1 l' David A, Baric. Esquire JD # 44853 17 West South Street Carlisle, I)ellnsylvania 17013 (717) 249.6873 . . 11~l.Ir!l~"t/11llJn ,,..~-- CAII.!I~[ 11NN1YlV^NI,(17l11\ .'AN 2 G 1995tP ''''--..., , '.--" CURTIS MYEl\S, Plalntll1' v, IN THE COURT Of COMMON IILEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, IIENNSYLVANIA NO 9S-6489 CIVIL TERM JOHN AND BONNIE BENDER, Defendants CIVIL ACTlON.LAW ii' 1llJJJ::. TO SIlO~~ AND NOW, thi~ay of ~ 1998, upon review of the enclosed petition a Rule To Show CRuse why the relief requested should not be granted is entered upon John Bender, .'ot....xl l'JG,:v-J,.w " , I This Rule Is returnable --S.- days from service hereof,"fJ6" JShA Re"der, Service to be mRde by petitioner, BY THE COURT, Ir:! {-< )tJ_J1t (~,~~vt. . I Tfll./t: COpy FROM rU:,CORD In h~I,\.'I:)\~ v.htlfll1f, I here ur.trl f\'J! lilY halO ttlt,) ',llll ~~.li III ~(jtil r~IJtln ;\t (;hrl~~" ';, Pt, Tt",/J!;:.'l-t..pav ~;;J~ HI " '), ... s:' ...2 III:t.orlot~ry , , CURTIS MYERS, Plalntltf IN THI! COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COlJNTV, I)ENNSVL VANIA v, NO, 95-6489 CIVIL TEI\M JOHN AND BONNIE BENDER, Defendants CIVIL ACTION-LAW g;BIIfKAJ:E.!)fJ)l;RYl~ I hereby certifY that on Febl1lary __i_I 1998, I, David A Bwic, Esquire. ofOtOrien, Baric & Scherer. did serve a copy ofthe Motioll To Milke Rule Absolute, by lint class U,S, mall, postage prepaid, to the party listed below, liS toliows: John Mancke, Esquire Mancke. Wagner. Hershey & Tully 2233 North Front Streel HlIrrisburg. Pennsylvanlll 17110 John Bender 203 Fait1eld Street, Apt. I Newville. I)ennsylvania 17241 ~)/Jtf.rL, David A, Baric. Esquire ',i I"'i;"'" ,,\1, ,\, ('(,' .__r i1;j \),, I, 'I' "I " '11,_ , : "-I :," , , " I'; 'Ii ,: ."! , j, " , ',':'1 , ,,' , , ," " " '1'\ '/1" \, , , ,: " " " " I' I; " '. ;II' 'il , ,'d, " " , 'iI I, -"\1 " I"~ " :, " , !' , ," ':, " :.. " II/! , :,