The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About95-06911 ii',) 1', ,,' , ',I " " I, " illl , , JI" , '" ", i,) "1 'I,' 'I ,iii ",,1' , , " , , , " " , , "',\, , " , ,iI '1"1' .,d' I'" 'I;' '1'1, "; " " , r'.j '!., ", , ill 'I' , , II'"I{ , ' ~/ ' . ",I " , " , " .Ij '<;:-!' {Pr' \-j'-', I./,I)!. I t.~~ .)1 ,II, IF 'I \~1 I '~('r II ~i'" ;'11, h " J ,1.\ ~\\':'" ',1e/!"!!..,'1 [Pi'''",'''1 " , , " '1,1 ,J,' 'i I, " , I.' , ,I i , , , ',' " " " I' " 'I I:" ,I, , ' I 'I " " I" " ,I, , " , ',I :" ,I " I'! " ,ir " I;" " , I',. " 1,1,\ ii' , 'II' , " ".' " " " ., ,Ii \ \ )/ ,,:1',) I:" , , ,j',j 'II " " , 'II it" " 'I' H, ", " 111,1 , , 'I " I, , " ':11.'. Ii"I" \'.\, ih'i:,~;~{,', t!.~ 1" '<;'/,',.-j ~f#-n'.t ~'J;(.I,;',:.~ ~IV "'" j,~r~>';I: It.-,..".,,: ;"",[ ',/'1,',1.-, ,...., \,I\,I ,'1'1' I ",'.Ii 1" " " , " 'I I ii, " " I II. '" !, I,. " " ,," r I' " " ~.. \'1.' :' " , , I' , , .;1 'It I 'J"I ",' .. , M- lI\lI!lIIIll,,~::":" , , " 'I " ", , \ , , :1' , I:,; ii ~, p.,:, ~ ','\' , " " 'I '" 'I' , il , , 'I " , ' " )' ,;' , , . .' . I' ,1.l,1 I, ,~ " . ! . , " " ' " I ,I " " " " " " JERRY A. PHILPOTT "'TtORNlY.IIT.~IIW P.O. lOX 116 ~7 NORTIl IlIGIl nRlIT DUHCANNON. PA 1702000116 "--' . 17111 814.1017 M~r; r: :. \0080'-' ,. ;'1 " , 1.. ItJ " .d.,....~,_".......__...,""- , ~.-.-......,,"""" '" . , , -,lWIA"" or "NlIIIYlVA"'A ';-"(Oliiifoj C__ 'UAI NOTlel O' APPIAL '110M _1M ""lief Dln.ICT JUSTICI JUDGMINT COMMON'llAIN. 95-6911 Civil Tenn ----"---- HOYlCI 0' A'PlAL Nolle. II gi..ri that ""'..,.,..." ..... lllod '" lho "w.o ("'HI of (00""0" Pleo. 0" _01 f,om tn. judgment ,.nder.d by tho Di.,rlcI Ju.tic. on tho ... and In IN e... .......ltJ boIow _"'N9fliJII'-".' ' ' " ,."......--~MI"'nJ . " ljl~ "'~:r=-!!t ,'i'I.11 I) h ,'/)' .. ':J~:r'r'114:;';'. .'-- ~ C) '/ - / - {j / Q, ;;i; J 1~'.,jJfi~J ' II! I (,'1(, 'yN ) , 1<1 /7{i? () ~ l~n'(.U(')f{'~"'11 .1-..----.-----p:irIo~1 I/~~_(I 'I') II" I, ~I ,;, III I I (,,/ '" r\\',-I'S ,)U' \+ ~ I IIIlN,".o' 01 rlNrOninrr~b. '~Nr .___._._~~ i:,.',,11 :)', 'I r} , ' ~/ !<~::(i!i~L ThII block wi. be .q.d ONlY who" 'hi. ,,,,,,,ho,, " 'O'\u".,l ",1deI Po. R P.JP, J '.. /I appe/lllnt was CLAIMANT (see Po. R.CP,JP. No. loon TN, No'ie. 0/ AwooI, when ...,.......d l>y I'. 0..",,, Jult"O, will opomt. o. 0 1001(6) In action belore District Justice, he MUST SUHR5liDfA5 10 "" j...Jun-t /'" ,"'.......'111 'hi. """ FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty (20) days alter filing his NOTICE 01 APPEAL. !;",,,,tIN" l~ '~ill1hJOflt,lIY lit O',#lClly 'IAICI..I TO INTlI lULl TO 'ILl COMPLAINT-AND RULE TO 'ILI-----' (TIIIIJ SUCtIOn ollutm III btlllSlIf! OM Y wII,," i~."",'"1 Wi" lJUCNlJANT (SilO f'rj, RCPJP, No, 1001(7) In OCl/on belora Dls~lct Justice, , NOT USED, oollJc/J '10m Ct..,V 01 ""tIUI lit III~H...II '11 I:H} SflIVl!(J updn llI-fXJlloo), 'IAICI'I. To I'lo""""'lafY !/I/',;/I/'I, I.... I..... upon /,i, hi I / (,', N.."., III '1l1".lf~I,tIH"I'lJ , .... ._.__.,__ ,oppell..(.), to iii. 0 complaint in this oppooI (e"""""" PIou. No..9!b6<Jll c.1vU 'Innn ) wi.hin ,_ty (201 day. after ...v;t'<,' f:~ ,u/,Iet ..,try 0/ judgment 0/ non """ , :1 / /'/Ut ;/.1/ - / ~~ sppeMa11 ()" h;s enomey or If1II"I , oppeIloe(.), / lUll. 10" JI (j") -} 1\ (\/ j J.)~ 1>/1 I ""1'111 III 1.,,/ICWIr/t. Ii I (~ , (1) You "'" nohflod 'hot 0 rut. I. hentby entered upon y"" 10 flle 0 c.......int in thi. appeal within twenty 1201 day. oft.. tho dole 01 ..vie. 01 tN. rulo upon you by 1'...0001 ''''.0 Of by ,..'11ied '" regl.torod moiL (2) H you do nol flIo 0 ,omplaint w,thin thi. timo, 0 JUDGMfNT Of' NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU. 13) The dole 0' ..,vie. of 'his ,..... if ....ic. WQ' by moil I. tho dole 0/ moili'9 o.e,,: ,1lAI_.....,.r ,!ith., 1995. ' k,<:>. , \J \,Y\(,cwinonn (),>'t, SiIJIIO..oIf11-oU>u,.....,OI~ .-.c .)1 W lit COURT fiLE TC) Ell: FII ED WlTli PROTHONOT AHY .. ,'.. '. C') "I :T.j ~ ~ \' _rl. ~ ~ ~ i PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT r" .", p \1'. ... :1' u! I;t v, t ~ ~ i Uj ).-'~r.- . >J '''1.- ~f k Q 1" \() lJ" ".-~..., 1'1 ,-, , <.I, 'l.J l'l -,~/ r ~-; '-'J['/; , ..-1'] ..'1 ., '.I l,~ . -< , ~~.: l-:.l ,~ ::0 r...::(') ~"C, ~ C)- o) Vi I; l.~ .J.;. 0\ 'l).. J: "L ~ -- (ThiS pro,,' ot "or"". MUST Bf f 1/ fO W/fIIIN rtN ( 10) VA YS AFTEF11111IIg IIloJ /10llCO 0' appeill CIl.ck appI,cebl. bO'.B) COMMONWlALTH Of PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY Of _......m~__.._._._.___'_... __..._...._... ; II AFFIDAVIT: I hereby .wenr or affirm tholl $erv.d n Oll:npy of lilt! Nqllcn 01 AppP.ll\, CQl11nlon Plens N(l .. ._~..._.~..__ ,upon the District Jusuce d061gnaled theroln nn (daftl of sarv/(;6) _ _._.___.____.~._.. ltJ___1 [1 by porsonlll S(~lvtl;A 0 by (cert~flcd) (ruglstered) mall. !j(!l1dor'lS receipt atlachad herel.O, and upon I.he IlpfltJllee. tniJnllJ) .:...._._...._._..--.__.......~____________.._~_.,.... -~---_...._._-..._~.._-, on _____.....-..______, If.\___.j] ny pUf50n.:l1 HtJfvice IJ by (corlillur,l) (ru!Jl~tl:')mtJ) mUll, t-ilHl(jer''j fl}(,l~jpt alta(;had heroto [] and turttwr thllll !il.!rverJ Itlt, Ruh' h.l ~ d(! ,1 Cu'npl;lInt .KC1Jrnpill1ying IIW abovo Nl')\ICO 01 ApfJl;Jul u'pon the oppolle~Jlli) to whom 1110 null} was nrldltlS5lJd on _____, l!L~_._____.. [J l1y ptH50r1l1t 51~rVICO 0 hy (OHlillmt) (roglsterod) mull. sonder'6 locolpt atlllcned horeto SWORN (AFFIRMED) AND SUBSCfllBED llEfORE ME THIS,......- ..', ,...DAy OF !G.,..,._ ._..._."T~------._..._-_...._.--s~Q;i;r;;,;ora',lafil --~---_._--~._~..,-.-_._--~..._~_.._~'~ Slgn,tlllfJ ollJI'ru,J/llfIlof/f IthlJm ;t/fllj,HI/ w'u mddtf ---'-- ....-.---~--_.-.- ntl.01 on'ClI'/ My <;ommlll!llon explIulI on ,'9__, .. ' COMMONWEALTIl or PENN6VLVANIA . COUNTY OF: CUMBERLAND __"'~~=j:O:t~'-'':':'':::'':'==-';;-- 'b.VliI NOTICE OF JUDGMENT{TRANSCRIPT 09-1-01 PLAINTIFF: .MI' ""'AOOflfB8 'HUSTON, ROBERT G. 2139 CIRCLE ROAD CARLISLE, PA 17013 L I Uitiiii'- w..... I.. CHARLES A. CLEMENT, JR. ...'... 1106 CARLISI.! ROAD CAMP HILL, PA '........ (717) 761-4940 17011 -1 CHARLES A. CLEMEN'I', JR. 1106 CARLISLE ROAD CAMP HILL, PA 17011 DEFENDANT: fJ<EYS, SCOTT 18 YMCA DRIVE DUNCANNON, PA L Docket No,: CV-0000368-95 Dale Flied: 9/15/95 VB, N,wE .nd AOOAF.BS I 17020 -1 THIS 18 TO NOTIFY YOU THAT: Judgment: r~1 Judgmellt WOS onlored for: (Neme) L~ I Judgmellt WOI orllllfOlJ against: (Name) III the amounl 01 $ ....___ 5.368.75 FOR PLAINTIFF HUSTON. ROBERT G. KEYS. SCOTT on: (Date) 11/06/95 l.1 Oornege. will be a.sessed on: (Dete & Time) 1..'1 Thl. CI.e dl.mlSled wllhout prejudice, [I [] [J PO....llon not granted. [] Levy 18 Itayed lor _ days or 0 generally slayed. [J Objeollon 10 levy has been flied end hearing will be held: HIe: Place: Amount 01 Judgment Judgment Costs Intere.! on Judgment Attorney Fees $5.248.50 $120.25 $.00 $.00 Posse..lon granled. po.aellton granted II money judgment Is not Ball.lled wl'hln Ihlny days, TOTAL $5,368.75 _~ _'H'M_ Time: ANY PARTY HAS THE RIGHT TO APPEAL WITHIN 30 DAYS OF THE DATE OF JUDGMENT BY FILING A NOTICE O~ APPEA~ WITH THE PROTr?N9TARY I CLERK OFT",E C<;URT O~ COMM~~.~~r.!l(,~!~~L.~I~~910N. .I!.." ,'I, Dale ,_J, (j,' ,,', (-.1 :,' ,''-' ~..:..:::J.,ptsl~ICI,Juslice ~ \ ".,. "'. , .... f. \ '., . I cartily 'hallhls Is a 'rue al)d,correct copyof the rrecord 0' tile p,roceedi!1~~llla!~pg tAo judYIlJOnt, _~~.~(~~_ Date ' .(!, I.' ',', \ l '/ \ :__\:'::=-~\~!?-S:bl~trl~;~JUSIICe MV commission expires first Monday 01 JanUBlY, 1996. "...::/j '., ,... ~Ii,AL' '~II C' T' "1 ... ~ """"111' AOPC 315-11I ,I ,t , I " en ~ U') S~ M :c Q.. ~~ ~' ,... N ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ", " " ... ,I' "."l! I ROBERT G. HUSTON IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW 95-6911 CIVIL TERM v. SCOTT KEYS AND NOW, RUL2 TO SHOW CAUSE this <sfff day of IlyHl\<V'----, 1996, upon consideration of the within Motion, a Rule is issued upon Robert P. Huston, plaintiff herein, to show cause why the requested relief should not be granted.;).. ( \') ('(j ') ('(.-.,\,__L.~.... \0" Iv ) l.Q RULE RETURN, ABLE, {~~ _, ~\. day/~____/, /-"c:~~-~ o'Gloelt--=-~'-hr ...oar~OOII\ number _' ,- HEARING, if necessary, to be held the LJ.:!!t day of ~, 199~, at ~ o'clock at ~.m. in courtroom number I . }r:{;~RT:,~ J. ',',~ ~,., III" ' ' ' '1--"" ", ,'" ' .'"',r-'" , !' , " /,,".,,'" ," '" ;~_ ~.. ...;,l1J.:Io;.IIo'J I ~,~_...-- - '0'/""" f\\EO.{)FF\~ or- 1\" \ ,11~\ $'~ 1!")1 r.r.~ tjt)I\M(~a PH \dll I' ' , , C\.J' \'1' "\' " .-,,,\,N j\i,,,,I,..I,.,,,,,.J \,;...,;v III PENNS'($/ N' 1\/\ ': ," i " :'J " ;" Ii , ' " " , "i'I:,'\,> ',' 1\ " II . ;I ~ -j , , "', , ' , " ,!;. " , " , I v. , IN THB COURT or COMMON Pj:.BAS OF CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PENNSnVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW 95-6911 CIVIL TBRM '( :;~ i. rr', . f 'jl' ,'.i I,,",, ,:r;' , " , ~., ' ~\:: . ,." .;.,., .;1 ~'-, -, I ):" ,\i 1l0BIRT G. HUSTON SCOTT KIYS .!' , MOTION rOR REINSTATEMENT OF APPEAL FROM JUDGMENT OF DISTRICT JUSTICE COMBS NOW, the movant, Scott Keys, by hia counsel, Jerry A. philpott, Esquire, and respectfully moves thia honorable cour~ to reinstate the appeal filed ft'om the judgment of District Justice Charles A. Clement, Jr., alleging the following, to wit: 1. The movant is Scott Keys, defendant in the, above- captioned case, an adult, competent individual residing at 18 YMCA Drive, Duncannon, PA 17020. 2. The responding party is Robert G. Huston, plaintiff in the above-captioned case, an adult competent individual residing at 2139 Circle Road, Carlisle, PA 17013. 3. On November 6, 1995, District Justice Charles A. Cl~ment, Jr., granted judgment to Mr. Huston at ICV-0000368-95. I' , , " .. On or about December 5, 1995, Mr. Keys, acting pro S8, filed a notice of appeal which counael for Mr. Huaton has conceded was timely. S. On December 27, 1995, counsel for plaintiff filed a praecipe to strike the appeal for violation of Rule 1005(B) of the Rull. of Appellate proceedings with regard to judgements and other deci.ion. of District Justices in civil matters. ;fi- '(:~Ii t;, . t cil-,\}'l .:,.. '.,"'_lll_-"'" ' ~:_ it f'., 'I I {tl/,'I . 1'J-,-,,~I'lt ' i'l" , r~([ 'J I I ~~ , ~\)i'1 'I ,t',I( ~f!r_' , Li, ' ",1'. ' f;,,/ ~,' ,._l, rN/-' 'iii " ' \rr ,I ~n-,-: ;'I.oj /l' (,' 1;1' " "1'1 ,r,,' ) 'i [:; ~ I'., ;1,-1 '\Vi j I' ,),( .J,; ~\,_" \\1;' r'i ~i \'\, fK ' I~:i ' I~,:, \,1\-1 Ik._ ., Ii: 'Ji I' :1' ,'..< " ,(' I' " l5. Mr. Keys did lerve his notice of appeal upon Hr. Huston' and the Diltrict' Justice as shown by the attached p;roofB of , service. 7. It is apparent from the attached proofs of ..rvice that both the Diltrict Justioe and Mr. Huston did receive copiel of the notice of appeal. 8. Mr. Iteys thought he had complied with submitting proof of .ervice to the prothonotary, but the record apparently contains no Clopy of the proof of service. 9., ,Attached hereto is another proof of service for filing with the court. , 10. Mr. Keys can not account for why his earlier mailed proof of .ervice did not end up in the court file. 11. Injustice would result to Mr. Keys if he were deprived of an, opportunity to present his case for disposition before a judge of thh court. 12. No subatantial harm wou),d befall Mr. Huston if Mr. KeYI 11 permitted to reinatate his appeal. 13. Under the decision of Ouarato v. Facelifters Limited, 305 Pa.Super. 536, 451 A.2d 777 (1982), a faHure to comply with Rule 1005(8) should be disregarded where the defendant has merely failed to fHe proofs of service but there is evidencll that the plaintiff ~ad received actual notice of the appeal within the requested time period. Such proof is demonltrated by the attaohed return receipt Ihowing that Mr. Huston signed for the notice of appeal on December 8, 19115. (, " ! ROBBRT G. HUSTON I IN THB COURT OF COMMON PLBAS OF ,; I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA , v. I I CIVIL ACTION - L~W il." SCOTT KBYS I I 95-6911 CIVIL TBRM PROOF OF SERVICE COMBS NOW, Scott Keys, pro se, and states that he did mail to Robert G. Huston and District Justice Charles A. Clement, Jr., a notice of appeal required by the rules and that he has received proof of service in the form of a return receipt for the receipt of said articles by both the District Justice end Mr. Huston. f:r; 19,': o ,r:: r;L ." n:V! r-.; '~ ~ r.n Co:) .. ..;I :r.: (l~ .,;J '\ " ,,'1 Cl>'!'" ~:r' - ~. ~ lit .~ (. .~ " .;0)..,," (,)11;) ') ~II ,:j :,'" ',,(1, ",' ;,....rJl' "1)("1:3 i.' I Q:; "~ Q I r,:, -I:': ;i: v.> 0" " I " l' , i t ) 'r, " , " ", , I t , " " " I , ','J " , " " ," 'I ," , , , , . . - . " , - .......... , .. ROBBltT G. HUSTON, plaintiff I I I I I I I I IN THE COURT or COMMON PLEAS or CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW 95-6911 CIVIL TERM, v. SCO'1'T KEYS, Defendant AND NOW, .' 1/ ORDER this ll{ r day of JJiX'!!.--, -1996, upon atipulation of the partie., IT IS ORDERED that the appeal in this matter be and hereby il reinstated, and that the plaintiff, Robert G. Huston, shall within twenty days of the receipt of this order file his complaint. arM cOJ'R~_: ~ . Idi!::.~ 1:.- ~ J. cc: Jerry A. Philpott, Esquire" r.....,;.,..c,;,.,.,.~ C'^- John L. Perry, Esquire --W' 'f/:449(" , ,J,f. STIPULATION COME NOW counael for plaintiff and defendant in the above- captioned diltrict justice appeal matt~r and stipulate that the appeal filed 01\ December 5, 1995, by the defendant at the above number can be reinstat~d and that the ff shall have tWlnty .. . "".. . ROBIRT G. HUSTON, Plaintiff t IN THE COURT or COMMON PLIAS or CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA , ' SCOTT lItBYS, Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW 95-6911 CIVIL TERM v. days from receipt of the reinstate ent order 0 file his complaint on appeal. L. Perry, Bs re orney for Pla ntiff ,I, " , , " " " . ."" .. - ROBERT G. HUSTON Plaintiff I I I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW 95-6911 CIVIL TERM VS. . . SCOTT KEYS, Defendant MO'rI~ YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against the claims set ferth in the following pages, you must take action wi thin twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the court your defenses or objections to the claims Bet forth against you. You are wa~ned that if you fail to do so, the case may proceed without you and judgement may be entered against you by the court without further notice for any money claimed in the Complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiffs. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. Court Administrator 4th Floor, Cumberland County Courthouse Carlisle, pennsylvania 17013 (717) 240-6200 John L. Perry, Esquire 8 South Hanover Street suite 207 Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-1477 '. v. . . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW 95-6911 CIVIL TERM ROBERT G. HUSTON, plaintiff I : SCO'l"I' KEYS, Defendant CDIPLAD'l' NOW COMES, plaintiff, ROBERT G. HUS'rON, by and through his Attorney, John L. Perry, Esquire, and states the following: 1. Plaintiff, Robert G. Huston, is an adult individual currently residing at 2139 Circle Road, Carlisle, Pennsylvania, 17013. 2. Defendant, Scott Keys, is an adult individual currently residing at 18 YMCA Drive, Duncannon, Pennsylvania, 17020. 3. At all times relevant hereto plaintiff was employed as a salesman for Yamaha of camp Hill. 4. On or about April 25, 1992, plaintiff sold Defendant a Yamaha FZR600 motorcycle, VIN Number JYA3HHE05NA042075. 5. plaintiff agreed to finance the purchase of this vehicle through a loan to Defendant in the amount of $5,400.00 secured by the motorcycle. 6. The Agreement pertaining to this loan, a copy of which is attached as Plaintiff'S Exhibit "A", reflects financing by "Yamaha of Camp Hill". 7. The Agreement further reflects an annual interest rate of 12\. '. 8. Dafendant was awan that this loan originated with plaintiff and that all monies were due and payable to the plaintiff. 9. A lien in favor of "Yamaha of Camp Hill" was recorded on the faoe of the Title, a copy of which is attached as Plaintiff's Bxhibit "B". 10. pursuant to the terms of the above referenced Agreement, Defendant was to pay to Plaintiff forty-eight monthly payments in the amount of $142.19. 11. Defendant has made eight payments to Plaintiff. 12. Plaintiff has made repeated requests for payment from Defendant. 13. Defendant has refused to make any additional payments to plaintiff . WHEREFORE, plaintiff prays this Honorable Court enter Judgement in favor of plaintiff and agllinst Defendant in the amount of the actual monies owed plus interest at the rate of 12% per year pursuant to the terms of their Agreement as well as reasonable attorney's fees and such other relief as this Honorable Court may deem appropriate. C~K!- !~ ,/) ,'/ (/~' (f' l/ 'Jo n L. Perry torney for plai 8 S. Hanover str sui te 207 Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-1477 " " . , . VIIl.lCA'l'1~ 0'1 PLUDlIIG I verify that the statemonts made in the foregoing Complaint are true and c~rrect. I understand that false statements herein are maele subject to the penalties of lePa. c.s., Section 4904 relating to unsworn falsifications to authorities. Date: ,$7 ...---,,---' ,.,------~ c _ - ....-:-- --.- Robert Huston ~. /f~~ " '. ...,,_.,....~"' ~.~..'_..._, "'" I .~~ I YAMAHA 1f50&1f0J.&1001o ICE w.,,~ 1.11 Hlllr,l" '"~''''Utr.lIfUI I WAOIH W,"'H' I l.l'YwM I IICWIt I 11Il'.'WtU' \ t'tWK Iln~ IH"ll I 5/10'1/"2 000006 0 OI)()t,I ,MOCU UAIt WON ....., 00<)"'" "~IU' ...111I-...,,".....-....... . I j)llll"~ 'I" ,,"lu' Jl~ lIII,n,.,.. .,.,..... 1.1...._II.....Il...'I..~..........,. ..." ,. '-'"...,It!... II.I/riIM 3" It'll 1101 /w..'"'''' "'~ allllll /)tlOMf ,... 1AWll.WllI....f...n, t" ..,"".".......'w.Mlall....'.'ll.I"'ll. ---- 11'1111I....,..11 ,..NtlHU....'II,U 1._1.1""110"'111I'," ..""'11'........'11_ U.'lllll....I.,....~'UH""....U" 1."IfIlllJI._ , ll" Al....~'~II.._ ~II<<II i ~. ,,,,-I~l""'IIU.. "Il.NI"'U"f.f'UU.~WlILI.I ....rO,..."..1I;1l0 '_'''''''*''11' V......IIIIII"W"....'IIiII\idUWoI ..'......IU..I..l . atOM.lulJill'IWAOf \ ..'" " " II. MConcI ~ It ~.tld'. 14Xll' "'llfILIPI rJ U... IIrll "'\, ". ,.,.. IIrrrrr... ....11...11I '""" ...*.,.., WI'*- au "" ~"Il of tooIaklr v.n.. ..... IN ". IJlPI'",II"" lam M1rJ ... f .'Ii. "CONO~HAI~O. :rt ___"........._".....,_,....,~-_-..3' trY AUTHDAIft1R1PNIINWNl " , ...or"-.daIIl1I....."'"l!,.lII~of.....~IwII\..~ 1~IIt'*tQllt.IOl'~I'IlNll~'-.._I..._I- .;- ,;'-' ' ~I.'''"''';W;) '.: ","; "'1 ~'#"~~ '<<WIF'I"~'N.I\I ' . . . .'" ", ,'", " " :-n=:1::::' -::.~~~:' :':.11:''':':. ~ ~-:::.:~ ,. n ...,IIlItw,......~Il.~...lIurwhonl...(,.'llNlhd..._..."I'....... ~. I"f ,,,,W,,""o,I ",,,..'t I U r....,~t.",...""..11lll1......hr.1II._......I...,,.......t4"""... I",k''''''. ""'.htllO u'~"1 ~I'J -~"~.;- ,..,~.tU,"_'I"Ulf"II' 111'j 11A1~ ril'F:Tiiilm-r.nr- ""'. 'UUUT ---- ,;.1'1' ."'.' 11IA'1 ,.. I)AII IMIWIiD LltlfnOl" .... 'r. .',' I," ,', ........,........II......lW',."*~.'.................... . , ..ll~!"...~tnr-,..,....._.""...lptll... ""III' CI'" ,. -, " IUITIIII, MaOH, VlLLAaI , QOLOMB ay, RICRJ-n II. GOLOIG 1.1). 110. taUS 10TH FLOOR 1201 CHESTNUT STREET PHILADELPHIA, PA, 19107 (215)563-8286 ATTOaNIY 'OR PLAINT I" ARBITRATION MATTER AGNES GAMMON 24 Burbeck Circle Mary.ville, PA 17053 Plaintiff, COURT OF COMMON PLF~ CUMBERLAND COUNTY CIVIL ACTION - LAW v. No. 95-7143 HOPE UNITED METHODIST CHURCH 6260 Carlisle ?ike Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 Defendant, CIRTlrlCATI ow SIRVICI I hereby certify that service of a true and correct copy of the within Answer to New Matter was made on the ~ day of ~"'t , 1996, to the f.ollowing individuals, by first class, U.S. Mail, postage prepaid, on the date below: Brooks R, Foland, Esquire Thomas, Thomas & Hafer 305 N, Front St, 6th Floor P,O. Box 999 Harrisburg, PA 17108 I<REI'l'HEN, BARON, VILLARI & GOLOMB BY: ~~ Richard M, Golomb, Esquire Attorney for Plaintiff S,"I .~ Date: /-. , " i . If) Ci:: ~, ...t' -0 ~~b ..'q (:)'\' 'I' , ;-r; .-.., ('.... (:1 .'.- ';t" :~ '"'"' 'J'- ,~J , I 1.-:':.1 ~ in @!' ,1-- F ~~.; cr" :,..., ,'.l[d f. ", ~'l.o: H. I._I") j Q \;.-. (.) 4 I', " 'j! \ , I, , , ,1,1 ',' (I ',I , 'j:l! Dated: 5- OI~ -,,, By: Y ~~/ HILPOTT, IRE B '116, 227 N. St annon, PA .&; 7 Attorney for Defendant , VS. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLBAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 95-6911 ROBBRT G. HUSTON plaintiff SCOTT KEYS, Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW .o'Uca 'J:O 'LaO '1'01 Robert Huston Via: John L. Perry, Esquire 8 South Hanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 ". ..--- //.... You are required to file a written~~sponse to preliminary objections within twenty (JO) days of s or a judgment may be entered against you. '- ROBERT G. HUSTON plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBEf. LAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. CIVIL ACTION - LAW 95-6911 CIVIL TERM SCOTT KEYS Defendant 'RlLIMI.ARY OBJICTIO.. I. PRELIMINARY OBJECTION ON THE GROUND OF LACK OF CAPACITY OF ROBERT HUSTON TO SUE ON BEHALF OF YAMAHA OF CAMP HILL. 1. The named plaintiff ie an individual suing in hill own capacity. 2. The plaintiff's complaint allegedly sets forth a claim based upon a written contract betwGen Yamaha of Camp HiU, in which the named plaintiff is identified aa a "salesman" on the face of the contract. 3. The plaintiff'a complaint fails to allege any authority in the plaintiff to sue on behalf of Yamaha of Camp Hill. WHEREFORE, the defendant requests thia Court to enter judgment in the favor of the defendant and against the plaintiff for the reason that plaintiff laCKS capacity to sue. II. PRELIMINARY OBJECTION FOR NON-JOINDER OF A NECESSARY PARTY 4. As appears on the face of the complaint, including its exhibits, there is a defect of parties plaintiff in that Yamaha of Camp Hill is not joined as Il. plaintiff and said pleading is defective for non-joinder. " " , , " I (': C"') .' ..~ .' ,.. ~:i' '" l!-:t~,) 1 ~' :r c_ -::t I ' " c, I I' r,...... , ; t,:-~ U!' :,.. ,..-;\ " I.", , ..'- , " ''1 ',:,",i <.:: 1..;, ~ ..) " , ," , , " " , " " " " ROBERT G. ~~:I~~lff I I IN THE COUR'r OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBEILAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW 9~-6911 CIVIL TERM vs. I SCOTT KEYS, Defendant IIO'l'l:CIl YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this Amended complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the court your defenses or obiections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that If you fail to do so, the case may proceed without you and judgement may be entered against you by the court without further notice for any money claimed in the Complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiffs. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. Court Administrator 4th Floor, Cumherland County Courthoune Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013 (717) 240-6200 John L. Perry, Esquire 8 South Hanover Street suite 207 CarliSle, PA 17013 (717) 243-1477 : ., , " ,I I i /, " ;" ( " /, ~I .t, ~' " " I I. .:, " "., r il , , , f l\ ~f\ P i' 1," 1 1.1 " , , Ii 11, I. 1,: , ROBERT G. HUSTON Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYINANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW 95-6911 CIVIL TERM v. SCOTT KEYS, Defendant AllllllDBD c:aIPLUII"l' NOW COME, plaintiff, ROBERT G. HUSTON, by and throuqh his Attorney, John L. Perry, Esquire, and state the following: 1. Plaintiff, Robert G. Huston, is an adult individual currently residinq at 2139 Circle Road, carlisle, Pennaylvania, 17013. 2. Defendant, Scott Keys, is an adult individual currently residing at 18 YMCA Drive, ouncannon, Pennsylvania, 17020. 3. Yamaha of Camp Hill is a motorcycle sales and service facility located at 1101 Slate Hill Road, camp Hill, Pennsylvania 1'1011. 4. Yahama of Camp Hi 11 Service, Inc. is owned by Band B Sales and 5. Band B Service, Inc. is a domestic corporation orqanized under the laws of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. 6. At all times relevant hereto Plaintiff was employed as a manaqer for Yamaha of Camp Hill. 7. On or about April 25,1992, Plaintiff, Robert Huston, sold Defendant a Yamaha motorcycle, VIN Number FZR600 JYA3HHE05NA042075. " 8. Plaintiff agreed to finance the purchase of this vehicle through a loan to Defendant in the amount of $5,400.00 secured by the motorcycle. 9. A copy of the Agreement pertaining to this loan is attached as Plaintiff's Exhibit "A". 10. The Agreement further reflects an annual interest rate of twelve percent (12%). 11. A lien in favor of Yamaha of Camp Hill was recorded on the face of the Title, a copy of which ls attached as Plaintiff's Exhibit "B". 12. By Assignment of Interest dated January 1, 1995, Band B Sales and Service, Inc. by it's president craig Bear and secretary Pat Bear, transferred and assigned all of it's right title and interest in the aforementioned loan. A copy of this Assignment of Interest is attached as Plaintiffs Exhibit "C". 13. Pursuant to the terms of the Loan Agreement, Defendant was to pay to Plaintiff forty-eight monthly payments in the amount of $142.19. 14. Defendant has made eight payments to Plaintiff. 15. Plaintiff has made repeated requests for payment from Defendant. 16. Defendant has refused to make any additional payments to Plaintiff. WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs prays this Honorable Court enter Judgement in favor of Plaintiff and against Defendant in the amount of the actual monies owed pursuant to this Agreement plus interest at the rate of 12' per year as well as reasonable attorney's fees and such other relief as this Honorable Court may deem appropriate. j.~ L. Perry orney for Plai Iff S. Hanover street Suite 207 Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-1477 " '" , " i " VIlIUPICA'l'IW or PLUDIm ,I verify that the statements made in the foregoing Amended Complaint are true and oorrect. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18Pa. e.s., Section 4904 relating to unsworn falsifications to authorities. Date: /,/.J/" ------=-.---:' C ~--;-.- - Ro~t Huston - " ", .' " ~,Vt' , I #,"1 I:i": ',' h,. ~~,' , f: ,I,'. ,,"~I :f. " ' " '" ". " 'i' I' . , ...1...... OJ In....' . . . ..,.. IIC ....io., ZIG., tr~f1n9 and do!n, bUlin... II Vuaba " Clap Hill with . plac. of bu~1ne.. at 1.101 81,t. Hi'h ....4, Cup HU1" 'Inn.ylYlnia 110U., IQJ; anll in ovnd4erat1on of the '\IlI, 0' one dOll" (.1.00) an4 other 9004 and valuable ' , , oon.1de"liion the receipt 01 \th1ch i. hen~y IcJcnowl.cSqld, dCl.. her.lll)' trand.: and ...19n illeS u' over to Robert G. HU8ton, hie b.ir. and a..ign. all of itl r19ht, t1tl. Ind int.reet 1n and to a , , 10.n, and the PC'OCI~' thereof ballliS by the ...19ftOI:' h8r.1n ('1I'.~in9 al Yamlha of C'.p HU1) to Scott P. Xeys, on or about \ . Ap:U II, Uta with '\aU authority to ooUeet ..14 lOin ancS the , , ' 'prOC.,d, tbereot and to r.t,dn 1n tull Ill)' pl'oe..d. th.reot. Th1l ...4,"mlni i. eXtOllted al ot'the lit day of a.nuary, 1~~5. a , B YAMAHA %NC. III IY , I '. . , . '. . " , " " , . , , Plaintiff's Exhibit .C. ~ , I II! '.~ . " ~ It,' r; il. ( . .i , . HI r~; ". o , 0" If"J . ,,(') 0' ~: ',' '1.( "~ ;...,. ,,' :'3 ' J~'.1 " ~{l \'-i; 'i~ - '" z,: 'j o ,'" I' " . " . I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF I OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA ROBERT G. HUSTON plaintiff . . I I CIVIL ACTION - LAW VB. SCOTT KEYS, Defendant 95-6911 CIVIL TERM To: Jerry A. Philpott, Esquire Attorney for Defendant P.O. Box 116 227 North High street Duncannon, PA 17020-0116 DatQ of Noticel July 26, 1995 T1IIlnIl'l'AII'l' .orICB YOU ARB I. DUADL'r BBCAUSB YOU BAU rAILBD '1'0 TAD ACTIC* UQODIID or YOU I. 'l'BlS CASS. UIILBSS YOU Jet WI'l'Bl. '1'11 DIoYS .... 'filii Dloa or 'l'BlS IIO'I'ICB, A JUDG....alft' MY DB ......-0 AGAl_ft YOU wd..-r A Pl"a.DtllG AID YOU MY LOSS YOUR PIOPD'ft OR U'A...... UU"AH'AII'l' UGlft8. YOU l!JBQUU) TAD 'IRIS IIO'I'ICB 'l'O A LAllYBR AT <<*CB. IF YOU DO ." BAU A LAIIYBR OR CADO'l' ArJ'fJRD on, GO 'l'O OR ~ 'filii J'OLL(IIlIIG orrICII 'l'O rIIID OUT tIIIBIlB YOU CAlI GIL'l' LBlJN, BBLP: court: Maini.trator J'ourt:b rloor, CO.......land county courtboUB8 carliale, PA 17013 (717) 240-6200 John L. Perry, Esquire Attorney for plaintiff 8 South Hanover street suite 207 carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-1477 " ~,~,,"J"-"": -- ~., ", \ ., 'I " " -, f;: "'.l,: ^.. WO ll'!{;' ~J,'-(." C' /."' " li I" -;., " o I , 0'1 - . I~~~ , , .. r:::,' "- " ; ):5 ,j-" ') :'~ d,C-;1 '/- 'j-(l ,.,a'l Ii"'" ~ ,\ ~ I J ;",u.. ~:j (J ", -'- ',:' '''" ;?r:':' t,,(") C., " " . , ., ,\ " contr.ary, he purchased it from Yamaha of Camp Hill, plaintiff's employer, 8. It is admitted that the purchase was financed, but it is denied that it was financed by pJ aintHf, It was financed by Yamaha of Camp Hill, 9. Admitted that the copy attached as Exhibit A to the Amended Complaint purports to be the agreement pertaining to the loan, but it is different than the copy which was furnished to and signed by defendant, which is attached as Exhibit A to this Answer. 10. Admitted, ll. Admitted, 12. Admitted that Exhibit B to the Amended Complaint purports to be an assignment, Strict proof of the validity of signatures and the authority of the signers to execute same is demanded, 13, Admitted that defendant was to make the forty-eight payments of $142,19, but denied that they were payable to plaintiff, On the contrary, they were payable to Yamaha of Camp Hill. 14, Denied. Defendant has made ten payments to plaintiff acting as the agent for Yamaha of Camp Hill, 15. It is denied the defendant has made repeated requests for payment, The first time that defendant was aware that plaintiff was demanding any money after plaintiff ref.used to honor the warranty that he had given was when he was sued by plaintiff " , HUllton. 16. Defendant admits he has not made any more payments. He denies that he even owes any money 1;0 plaintiff Huston. WHEREFORE, defendant pr~ys that plaintiff's complaint be dismissed. Nn MATTIR 17. Exhibit A to plaintiff's complaint is not the agreement of the parties signed by Mr. Keys, defendant herein. Attached hereto as Exhibit A to this answer is the document that is in the possession of Mr. Keys that he signed which bear$ a different invoice number and different date than the one attached to plaintiff's complaint. Exhibit A to this answer is the agreement between Yamaha of Camp Hill and defendant, 18, The agreement of the parties (either Exhibit A to the Amended Complaint or Exhibit A to this Answer; both are the Same in this regard) incorporated by reference a "Manufacturer's" warranty, hereinafter "the warranty", 19, The warranty on Yamaha that defendant purchased from Yamaha of Camp Hill was for one year/12,000 miles, 20. In about February 1993, or within approximately ten months and 8,000 miles, defendant experienced electrical problems on his Yamaha and requested Yamaha of Camp Hill, through its salesman, plaintiff herein, to honor the warranty. 21. While plaintiff was driving the Yamaha to Yamaha of Camp Hill to get the warranty work done, the wiring harness began to smoke and was essentially consumed by fire, 22, At the time of the fire, plaintiff Huston came to where the Yamaha had burned, in front of Holy Spirit Hospital in Camp Hill, and picked up the Yamaha and took it back to Yamaha of Camp Hill. 23. Plaintiff, as representative of Yamaha of Camp Hill, refused to honor the warranty, claiming that the burning was caused by defendant's letting the battery go deadl 24, plaintiff told defendant that Yamaha of Camp Hill would charge defendant $1,100 to fix the Yamaha bike notwithstanding the warranty. 25, As a result of the fire, the Yamaha was reduced in value to essentially salvage value, Defendant was able to repair it sufficiently himself so that he used it for a short time thereafter, but it eventually had to be "trashed." COUNTBRCLAXM X - BRZACH OP WARRANTY AGAIN8T PLAINTIFF HUSTON 26, Plaintiff Huston alleges in his Amended Complaint that in all ~aterial respects he, not Yamaha of Camp Hill, was the seller of the Yamaha bike to defendant, 27. The contract between defendant and plaintiff Huston includes the warranty, 28. Defendant relied upon the warranty in entering into the purchase of the Yamaha. 29. The Yamah3 faile~ to conform to the warranty in that plaintiff refused to make repairs of defects that occurred within the warranty period, 30, Defendant notified plaintiff Huston of the breach of the war'ranty by seeking to enforce the warranty as set out above. 31, Plaintiff Huston's failure to honor the warranty by repairing the wiring problems reduced the value of the Yamaha to salvage value, WHEREFORE defendant prays for damages from plaintiff Huston in the amount of the purchase price of the Yamaha, $4,999, for plaintiff Huston's failure to honor the warranty, THIRD PA1I.TY CLAIM - BRIlACH OP WA1I.RANTY AGAINST ADDITIONAL DEFENDANT B & B SALES AND SERVICE, INC. 32. D~fendant Keys incorporates by reference all the foregoing paragraphs of this Anower, 33. Defendant B & B Sales and Service, Inc" (hereinfter "B&BU) is a Pennsylvania corporation with its principal office at 791 Flory Mill Road, Lancaster, Pennsylvania 17601, 34. According to plaintiff Huston, B&B owned Yamaha of Camp Y AMArtA of Camp HIU 1101 Slate Hili Road, Camp Hili, PA. 17011 (717) 761.6192 , J I~ U 11.1\1,..1" 'MONI _CM'''' ..s'c:-o T T .",,, / s> KE'iS 'I'. .."'" nUIID o "IIAl "'0 (UI02 Mnt"'GI ~O~OI DluvUIO ON Of ..101.11 111......01011 "I ACCESSORIES AODII" TAX !'OTAl SETTLEMENT BASE PRICE DEALER PREP'DESTINATlON CHARGE YAMAHA EXTENDED SERVICES SUBTOTAL 1/ t1 fl5/rYc ADE AI~L(jWANCE BALANCE DUE SALES TAX TITLE T AGSITRANSFER 1.2 ENCUMBRANCE TEMPORARV TAGS DOCUMENT INOT ARY TOTAL DOWN PAVMENT yrs).CO BALANCE DUE TI..~ - L- g.\"nUJT RCOORe. .- SUBTOTAL ..10 SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS ~ f3.2 l. - INSURANCE INFORMATION WOrt" y ~nnuIACIUrfH s Donlm 50/50 for 30 dAYS r I No Wilrrnnly "As I!;" r I Othor I hll l11.rnt\ .11\rt l:lWU AI:" flr Ihl~ ",Unl ~I\(rt r.nlf111,I~lI ,11" Ilnll.1t IlWUI"",'1 ptlrlnllll"l) tlllhl~ lI'/h.h.1'ill Nn nihil Aur"'lIIurnl nl ""V klllll, ~1l'IHII U1\11I~'8Iil,'1lItlOnr plom .. '1IIIU'" Of 'flluul 01 Ih.I'lIIIr.hllll' '"rnmp'''''' Ihl8 11111""'"11111 lor IIny 'e.1",Nl mllV'ItIlIIIl,n Iltl 01 Pl\JloIlhll t.Uh' 'flpll!\" hr\11"\,((~hl'tlllt "" hfjlJlcI,llfltldllm"'I"ll. 'hit pu.,h.IUI c,r"rl..thll h4tlah... 01 I'VIIIy' and hl!l"hv ,,"r.ltpllllll\l1l..kl. ' nlll ~oPV 01 Ih,!';h<1I01 1';11111 1> (-..----=;::"'~-.:;:,,;;;.~;;:,::,.""-,,~. _.'P::: ~------ -=.:1 I1lKE9 Will BE UELO FOR JO DAVS ONlV.lJNlES!i rAEVIOlJSI.Y AonEEO UPON A I.. of 110.00 to writ. thlt contrlct Ilong with. 01'1' dolllr . d.y t.. trom d,,'. of contllet will b. cha'g.d If a d.polll ,~fu"d II "qullt.d. !-:IllIm [FF':J R~:'I'URN - OUT OF COlJN't'V CA!-:I~: NO I 1 'J~:J -06'311 P ggna~~Wtj'I'tU"IJ~;Rr~~~:-;YLV ANIA I "~I HUHTON IWH~;RT 0 VS. Kl';Yl:l l:lCOTT I' I " R. Thoma. Kline -' Sheriff. vho being duly Bvorn according . diligent search and inquiry for the within a & ij SALKS AND SERVICE INC I,; to law. ..ys, that he made nemed defendant, to vitI but ve. unable to locate deputized the sheriff of to .erve the within NUTICK, Them in his bailivick. I.ANCASTER _ County, ANl:lW~R N~W MATTER KCT He therefore PII'nnsy 1 vania. I.ANCAS'I'I::R County. r.ceipt of P.nnsy 1 vania. I, , . On AuguBt 15th. l~~b the ettached return from .' this office vas in Shoriff'a Costs I Docketing Out of County Suroharge Lanoaater County 11l.00 9.00 2.00 32,05 $&1.05 JERRY PHILPOTT 08/07/1996 ~3o answers." ) R. 1/~om:::~'::~:/sn:~'1}f .-/ ',' Svorn and aubaorib.d to before me thi. ,~.;,J,.~ day of ((t'j,.,J- 19"""- A. D. ~'" ~' ll"deL~ *.!i.' ro onot.t'y -. SHERIFF'S OFFICE . fill NORH! DUKE S TfiEE T, LANCASTER. PENNSYLVANIA 1',"602 '1717) 200,6200 I ',,'- -..... _.-._~_._-----~ IE ~ttr~f!F ",n;VlllUAl,COMI'ANY, C()JlI'OJl^"0N flC T<' Ill' HlIMO , "".." JUt!;! S<lles OOQser.vi~'e 1m;. . 6 ADDRESS (611001 t)I flFll ApmtlllllJll N'l City 1J00l,) 'I'll! !llulo line! liP (olio) .n~._............___n.7\llJ':L9!:Y .Mill fload I L.;I)1Castl)l" I P^ 1760 I 1 INDICATE UNUSUA,L 6f,RVICE COMMON 0' pp, DLPLJII/f 0",,11 Cumberland NclW,.AUg~'::-n'i;.:,1996. 19", ,I, SHERIFF OFlOOllllIISlI)OO COUNTY, PA, dl)ilor"J?Yd"PUIlle~he' r I __n... LanoMteJ:-,,' , "" " " Counly 10 execule Ihls ~dBla4lti r~l~re to law, This deputation beIng made at tho request And risk of tho plnintilt. 7 ""II"~'~itl."I!L.'rII' . - .. i~ iPlc;',ACINSTRijCTIONS OR OTHEr INFORMA'TlON THAT WILL ASSIST IN EXPEOITING SERVICE' ' " ,," ,,' , INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE OF PROCESS on ... ..- .. iIII lOI'lI'IO, III 'I 0"" .. ... Iolm PIt... 1)1IO .. ""'" IIQIbly 00... _h Ill' copioI, ... ---[i'COUIj'fiilJMUEllnn..._._-_..._._~ 95-6911 Civil TeJm Q .1 1 VilE OF WHIT Oil COMPl AINT -~--tIlI i ' ~ /IIrJl ee. Mewer e<:t. .....-_'! New Matter, Countercldim and Thil'd Party Claim N ."-'1>> >- SHERIFF SERVICE PROCESS RECEIPT, Ind AFFIDAVIT OF RETURN t PL ,iii.tiFf/ilI Robert G. Huston 3 OEFENOANT/Slnh.......,. .'GI .n~ N NOTE ONL V APPLICABLE ON WRIT OF EXECUTION: N,D. WAIVER OF WATCHMAN Any IlllpUI')' lihell" IUYVII1U upon 01 Iltlilr.l1inU II(1Y property Urldllf within writ mllY Iq8V$ same Without II WUl(lIl1\llfl. III I;Wil1jdy 01 .....1101110...nr HI 11)11111111\ jJ01;t;I,bbirJ!l. IIMr I1tl!IIYlllij pl!t~O/lllIIIJVV 01 nllachrnonl. Without lIablllly on lhe plllt 01 lIuch dttpuly or Ihe f>llImll It) uny plllln'I" 111llElIIl hlf ;1/1y Itlhli. Ihll,ltlJClIOI1 m Inmolll\l or Iln')' slJr.h pfOPlJ1ty bolorll tilonU'ij 51110 Iholool ";S~:=E ;~::N:; ,j, 0";" OR~~:;~~RLAND CO SHERI FF ~'~7T:~~;t~~~;~MU,>1.'" ['~~~~E_~~=-6~96 ,iSENO-NOTicE-OF'SERVlce COpy TO NibfItND~~X~t\HliLO~?NtWl~reB mUll b. l:ompl.l.rl If nolle.. h,lo b. mailed) . - --- . -,.. _u._.._ .-... JERRY A PHILPOTT, ESQ. 227 N HIGH ST., POBOX 116, DUNCANNON, PA 17020 -------.--SPACEB'ELow Fo,fuSE OF' SHeRiFF ONLY - '0'0 NOT wRltE"BE(oylTHI!rLlNE----.~..-_..-- - .----- -~~ ~; ilcknowlo"dge recfJl-p~;;~~~} ~..- .--- ,- -NAME-,~;-A\jIl1nnllJd lcSD Ul'Plll')'-;Jf C1nrk . -" 1- 1.1 [j;lilJ--Fl-;;c,l;~u.(j'.,..--" ....!.-'r) E.~Ir;II~ln.l~i{il;'lng UlI'U ..,.o~..'."mplaUll~l~rl".,.O ul""? Juqy MORRIS 295 3609 8-s-96 , 9-5-96. 11) 1 hareby CERTifY and RETUAN Ull1' I '1M'll' pm!,;!ilhlll')' ',IIII/I.d ?(lldV'1 11''1.11 I!VldH"" ill ',I'I \lId' .L'; ',IIIlWI' In 'HI.t1J,lIk<,' tlill/II ()XI'(l,lf'd ;I~ !itllJwn In , "Remark5', the wrll 01 COfl\p1111111 dOt;Ulbf!oI Oil !Ill! .ndll/I,lillll o:.,lll!lIII1Y, L:IIIP,\ldllllll I'to: ,II t11" ;1<1011'",:, ',lllJwn ,111<)1/1' or 'JII 11',1) IndiVidual, t;otl1lJ,ll1y_ <:01 porllllOfl, ale, ""he nddre~!) mserted bLllow by 11utldll\!1 ;1 TRUE flnd ATTESTED COPY thetaol .. n____.___ ~___,.-. .__. . _. 17 'hereby cortily und relum a NOr FOUND 1)1!';oilJH, I ;\Ill llIlalll,\ II) 1')(Hr., 11-," Illlllli,dlJdl (IJIllp;tny "'JII.,)WII<;-n pI<; 115 Name ar,lju,ilieollrlIJlvldlJ-oi"l>unlOd (II rllll 'jhllwn .1110vt') 1f:1!'lilll()r1h!llp In 1Jl!!pndillll) _,~&/1! ~ ,,M , J3 E' A ~ - c.'l l-J /II GfI 20 Addles!) 01 whQre IiIJlVQU (CQmphllll ()Illy If Ij,f!IJt()I1! than ~11()Wn nhl)v'!) (SII'lfllllr IlFlI Slele llI\d lip Codul ApmtllH>nl NO c.ty !lm!), r'Np !\llIlll,'oI olh!}v.~ ISlln r"nl;llk~i tmllw.} 111l A PIli'",,, "I ~ull"rA.! "ut> .11"1 dll,<:I,otloll :::;;;llJ :~;I;L~:;:;.oJ" 111 1M d,.hll"llIlIl ~ IJ~"1l1 (I [jato oj SllI'\IIl:n 2;) T,t11u 'i?'a"'" '3<{O ....... PM --- I'DliT 100.00 I Milo. I Oep Int I I'. No""y C'OII 0"0 I MU" I Oep Inl \,27 M!;IlI\!IOiPOlill\!joIN F I /-,. - - , ,'.'2":; I Dolo ,\, Mil.. T Oopln' I' D.'e '. Mi:' [O'~ ':_. \:la Tollll C()~t!\ i 29 COlT DUI OR ~-~ -".. ._~ , . 1.1")'),, (.... 7' 2:':. 2'fATTfMPTS' -l~o.'. [Mil.' Oep Inl I oal. f,' 8 5 J",-# , U .m S(Jr....lcll Cnfihi 'f.C Adva~neQ-COlli9. R87856 ii'AEMAFiKs ,. , 30.50 31 AFFIAME:~:~..'::""b.<l 10 h'''''' m. ",,' /..,)" ~ . /,,,, , r '1' :J.4 dEOY'~" ~~'~~. _" ...~. .~ 13. & 31 . ~ ._~zi.'!k.iJ.!..L.... " ,. '. 1',,,llw'l' . " MY CO MISE:iION',EXP1RES . i8~ACKNOWLEOcfl'-REC~I-PT OF r~k SHE"I-"'S FlETURN aIGNATUFlE'} OF AUTHORIZED Ibl$JIlNO ",,}."HORITY AND TlTlF; ...-.--------'-.------'.-'7"".---. ---' ,.---....... t. so AN,~WIR: ' fi/ f Co (( J' ~...- ;>:-t ,L~--' (' 1 .11'iJ- r:/fLJrr...0.-- \i:iilllhi' ... ..----..---.- ,,8 ,~n'f"i'--- :16 O~!1l ~ {;. ,-C;'/2. .'jJ.~_. STA .\ JIl ~hil" 111"!fl,."<1 Leso. , '.1~" Am.1\l1eU 1mY.! ! l~l~IHN(, AiJ IH(IHll r '\" " ", f / " , \ I , \ , " , . (1. ',,:.~ C,,1 _t I-l oj .;n O:i ~~ ~'r: ,... :1) 11.1 ".~' ...~" r/l .,;,) III ", :$:: "-.'" ,..,.' ~) I () .t~ 1.1)0 iI IL .(..,) . 'I 1::0 In <{1 l.J... C)(. C' , i~c...) ~~-)' "'1 ..... . ,i::C .,'. Cl IJ~' (~i I " 1.l,J'tt '11111 Cr- -.' C...') -J ....j. :1.;...... . J-e, . l..~ .. II') '.f) ~- 'j CJ1 r:n 0 , , " ~.. ."", . . .. ROBERT G. HUSTON Plaintiff I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYVLANIA I I CIVIL ACTION - LAW I I 95-6911 CIVIL TERM VI. SCOTT KEYS and B'B SALES AND SERVICE, INC. Defendants grgy OP II._&DII._ To the Prothonotary: Please enter my appearance on behalf of additional Defendant B'B Sale. and Service, Inc. Respectf lly 'I li; C') ...... ('.1 -," ." ;~ 1~ (\;j Ir.Jj " r:. ::r.: ,.... :,1. ~ ,~ ~. ~ .1;' "I" ....) :~ {f} ~... ,..; ,.-''9 II. !:l.: ,)~ iL' ~ I ..,,,: t5 V, a (.I' ~t .. " , " I ',I , , , , . ~ ROBERT G. ~~:I~~lff vs. I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA I CIVIL ACTION - LAW 95-6911 CIVIL TERM SCOTT KEYS and B'B SALES AND SERVICE, INC. Defendants I Dr.a.TWItT..'s ......... 'l'O lIB IJA...... un .........._-.f'WI.a.TIIa NOW COMES, Plaintiff, Robert G. Huston, by and through his attorney John L. Perry, EBquire and states the fOllowing answer to Defendants New Matter and Counterclaim filed in the above captioned action: 17. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is specifically denied that the document attached to Plaintiff's Amended Complaint a8 Exhibit "A" is not an aqreement of the parties signed by Defendant, Scott Keys. It is admitted that the document attached to Defendants Answer with New Matter as Exhibit "A" appears to be a similar document signed by Defendant. It is denied that Defendants Exhibit "A" is the agreement between Yamaha of Camp Hill and Defendant. To the contrary, it is one of two documents signed by Defendant reflecting the sale of the Yamaha motorcycle and financing by Plaintiff. 18. Admitted. 19. Admitted. 20. Denied. After reasonable investigation Plaintiff has found no documentation of any such claim by Defendant and therefore strict proof is demanded at trial. 21. Denied in part. Assuming that the allegations of this paragraph refer to events occurring while Defendant was operating . the Yamaha motorcycle, Plaintiff ia without sufficient knowledge to form an opinion as to the truth those averments and strict proof is demanded at trial. It is specifically denied that the wiring harne.. wa. "consumed by fire". 22. Denied in part, admitted in part. It is specifically denied that there was any substantial fire involvinq the Yamaha motorcycle. It is admitted that plaintiff did retrieve the Yamaha motorcycle from the vicinity of Holy Spirit Hospital and return it to Yamaha of camp Hill. 23. Denied. It is specifically denied that Plaintiff individually or in his capacity 8S manaqer of Yamaha of Camp Hill, refused to honor the manufacturers warranty. By way of further answer, Plaintiff did submit a claim to the manufacturers and determination as to the validity of the claim WIlS made by the manufacturers representative. 24. Denied. Any quotation reqardinq costs of repair would have originated with the service department at Yamaha of camp Hill not with plaintiff. After reasonable investiqation Plaintiff has found no documentation of any such quotatlon and therefore strict proof of this averment is demanded at trial. 2!l. Denied. It is specifically denied that any electrical problems relating to the Yamaha motorcycle resulted in a reduction of its value to salvage value. By way of further answer, Plaintiff believes and therefore avers that after experiencing the electrical problems previously referred to Defendant did repair the motorcycle and use it and subsequently was involved an accident in which the motorcycle sustained si,gnificant damage which in turn significantly reduced the value of the motoroycle. ...... '10 I. '1I_._.__-M.... TM ..I 26. Denied. Paragraphs number 6 and 7 of Plaintiff's Amended Complaint clearly alleges that Plaintiff, sold Defendant a Yamaha motorcycle. 27. Admitted. 28. Denied. Plaintiff is without sufficient knowledge to form an opinion as to the Defendant's state of mind at the time of the purchase of the Yamaha in question and therefore is unable to form an opinion as to the truth of this averment. Therefore strict proof is demanded at trial. 29. Denied. plaintiff speci ticall y denies that he refused to honor the manufacturers warranty. Plaintiff's answer to paragraph 23 of Defendant's New Matter is incorporated herein by reference. By way of further answer, Plaintiff believes and therefore avers that any malfunction of the Yamaha motorcycle was the result of Defendant's negligent operation an maintenance rather than manufacturer's defects. 30. Denied. Plaintiff specifically denies that he was notified of any "breach of the warranty". By way of further answer, Plaintiff believes and therefore avers that any breach of the warranty occurred by virtue of Defendant's negligence operation and maintenance of the Yamaha motorcycle. 31. Denied. Plaintiff specifically denied that he failed to honor the warranty, either indi viduall y or in his capacity as manager of Yamaha of Camp Hill. Plaintiff's answer to pa.raqraph 23 of Defendant's New Matter is incorporated herein by reforenoe. By way of further answer, assuming arguendo the averments of paraqrltph 24 of Defendant's New Matter, the value of the Yamaha was reduoed no more than $1,100. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays that Defendant's counterclaim 1- Breach of warranty, against Plaintiff Huston, be dismissed. AII,,- 'l"O _TIIn p~ ,...,....nI - -....... OP --..- 23. The averments of this paragraph require no responsive pleading. To the extent that a responslve pleading is required, Plaintiff incorporates by reference all of his answers to the Defendant's New Matter and counterclaim I. 33. Admitted. 34. Admitted. 35. Denied. It is specifically denied that B&B Sales and Service, Inc. is liable on the warranty. Paragraph 18 of Defendants New Matter is incorporated herein by reference. By way of further answer, B&B Sales and Service, Inc. is not now, nor ever has been engaged in the manUfacturing of motorcycles. 36. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is admitted that Defendant attempted to secure repair of his motorcycle by Yamaha of Camp Hill under the terms of the manufacturers warranty. It is specH ically denied that additional Defendant, B&B Sales and Service and Yamaha of Camp Hill in any way breach the terms of the manufacturers warranty. By way of further answer, additional Defendant BiB Sales and Service, Inc. believes and therefore avers that Defendant breached the terms of the manufacturers warranty by negligent operation and maintenance of the Yamaha motorcycle. 37. Denied. Additional Defendant B'B Sales and Service, Inc., specifically denies that it failed to honor the warranty in question. Any decision regarding performing of repairs under the warranty was made by representatives of the manufacturer. By way of further anSWtir additional Defendant B'B Sales and service, inc. incorporates by reference paragraph 24 of Defendant's New Matter. Assuming arguendo the truth of the averments contained in paragraph 24 of Plaintiff's New Matter, the maximum reduGtion in the value of the motorcycle resulting from the manufacturer's failure to repair the wiring problems under the warranty would be $1,100. WHEREFORE, additlona1 Defendant B'B Sales and service, Inc., prays this Honorable Court dismiss Defendant's Third Party Claim - Breach of Wal-ranty, against additional Defendant B'B Sales and service, Inc. Respectfully submitted, ~~ ~ J I~~---- n L. Perry, Esqui~ South Hanover sJreet Suite 207 Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-1477 Attorney for Plaintiff and Attorney for Additional Defendant, B , B Sales & Service, Inc. VIU'lCl.'fl<* 0' PLUDDIGB BY 'lIIDD ..... I, John L. Perry, Esquire, being duly sworn according to law, depo.8s and says that he is the agent of craig Bear, president of 8'8 Sales and Service, Inc. craig Bear can not make the verification to the foregoing Answer to Third party Claim-Breach of Warranty because he is outside of the court's jurisdiction and his verification can not bEl obtained within the time allowed for filing. The facts set forth in the foreg~ing Answers to the Third Party Claim-Breach of warranty are true and correct based upon his personal knowledge, informatin and belief. s/~ J./f;A,~y/ '7h';.' L. Perry / I , I- Sworn and SUbscl'ibed before me, 8 notarY' public, this ;;;:1 day of September,' 1996 . ("- '-... I "', ' C . ~\fYi~\!:J.f .<::-:.;[)\rLCl. "'Kotar-y-p\ibiJ c NOTARIAL SEAL DENISE SNIOr,R, NOTARY PUBLIC CARLISLE BORO, CUMBERLAND COUNTY MY COMMISSION EXPIRES OCT. 28. 1996 Mlmlll, Plnn. lIen,. AIlIOI.tiln II Nllorln J;I ir If) ,~. ..~ - v .. :..~ !P N '.1): :r.: 1..,) :<~, ..~ - .... I':..C~ "I"" ~, 4'., 'J "'i'.! m~~.' Ci 1,)',1 l.lf\l I '" ("I.\.. ,", '" , (:; (- en ,J " " " , ' , , " , " " ,