HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-06913
I
I
,
i
......
~
I'
,-)
I
, !
r' I
I
I
I; "I
I.
I
""
i I
. 'I
1
,
1
I
1..7 ct.......rI 'I
r "1" )'f- '5
.
I ,Ii (., ,0 ~
'i~ (' t:''''--l'~
...
r fJ.-~tI :).
-:t../...t.. \.4.____"'"
Ii """V> +",t .."
~~<"'(L-,:Lt..1\,7f7
10
In
I"
"'1 ,,(
(t....."'.' A
"
o --<l"',' ..l"~'l .:~-:(.j._i,
~-r\.\
~ b .A..,;;t...,..-,v''''',.( f l\,~"'".c",\"'~,. ,I,... t;{h,j.
J ()
,---
'1 '1
/'''''''A
" '
,\...,;' .\!.
"
I
(,..:CIA
1 ~
d6
S I
'l-4'~' ",.~ (, ~..', t1
('", ~CI'" It II-"
,,".vf.....,.,;t'-,.... 1 H_NC'-,'! "'~II ~1-f;...A
'J 1-- tt ,I - Loot i" t), t'." ',' t.
"'.<C~l'\,<.~v""""" vol ~.,. rr
,I:;' c,,-p ~:I )" ,;. ,'\-1'1 ,(,.-t'\.Y\.
,
\ , \,'f", l' "
" (
~~l_/f..-.td.-,t
';) (.~- t'J "a,~
--
1/1'; " ~('
to.~1 /h.~
,^"'f;."""'-."""'"...-t
'Q( -t'v\.o\v\ a,.~..,.(/
,-L-h't. ..:.
f.<\.-.... '
. ,
-7(, ^-.oP'yj, 1'.....
{..<LLY. ,>(~ .......
^- l-'
'\" L:." (~, td,7,...X
i)
Mr, John F, Olstol
423 W, Jl~nll SI
Carli$k,I'A 170i3
~h, 1\,l<.ill.....
1-1:\ \\. P"UII ~l
rlltJi"I~, 1'.\ 171111 'J'..!.'!:.
--Emi J . k l~,~/t-
'.... _...
"
,
,
,
,
;
,
,
I'
"
"
"
~ en' (:;
-
r,~ .. ",;;'
!;) - -r! ot1"
fi lJ'"~
x:: (.J~r.
y,. ,~",
~ I ;....
~ - ~...~~
..... N .-1 ~(~
b'J (.~~ H:\r~)
fS ,",I .'f,!(J.,.
, CJ ~ ,~.
~ In ;:J ~
Q' u
"
\
\
i
I
I
;
I,
.
NOTICE 0' APPEAL
~WIAL'H D. 'INNlnYANIA
COUIf D. COMMON 'LIA.
fllOM
L-
JUDICIAL DllfllCY
DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT
COMMONPLlASN.. 95-6913 Civil Ttmn
-.._..--._--.-~-~......_-
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Nolie. i. given that tho appellant h,IO filed In lho above Court of Common Plea. on app.al ham the judgment r.nd..ed by the Ci.tdd Ju.tlce on the
dafe and In the call mentioned bel"",
1 i' ,j-N O''7/rJT
NAMleJr ~
- IV! R 5, 6,
IUlDfIUOP .APPlllANT
<-t1- S \I"
:t~~'_q 5 rK'~;'_J;J~~~3--"'~ u...1 (/t~N~l~I'" 'PP1il~~i:~1I~~y~,1~1-,,'~;'7;',,'\' -..- ---...
CV 19.1.L c.. 'I J..l.L1.L \"JY-<J,... .f5, t< V--Y\.J1.JL.
LT 19 _ "\,, f, '-_ r", 0-1,/..:(;, C
Thi. block win be oIgrlld ONLY wh.';- Ihl. 71Ok;;;';" i. r~qUlr.ci'~.;d;;;P';'--R,C,p,Jl Na . If apPella,it was' CLAIMANT'lsm' Pa, HC P,J P. No,
looS&
Thi. Nolie. of Appeal, when ...coived by tho Ci.trict Joltiee, will operot. a. 0 1001 (6) in action before District Justice, /JfJ MUS"
SUPERSEDEAS to tho judgment lot po....~on in Ihl. ,a... FILE A COMPLAINT within twonty (20) iJllys allor
filing hiS NOTICE of APPEAL.
1-<., 17 ,,, t: '<..
j!f.N~ 5r
"'i.'iiY"
. 'IMAGT>1rflo1lllm;Ml'Nbr-.---.-.--'
t'>1 '~ ,,-; ::>, 0 It '-I
--..---51;.".....---........--.-.... .... '-'.1'~0fll----
e A 1'1 qj ~
I)'~,,\r'
,;, "I
_----'._____~_d._ .._____.. ..__.__.__..____. .-----...--..
-------&W,iiiUre- o/--P;e);;looofary 'o,-Oepuiy . -.
---.PRAECIPE--TO 'ENTiRiuifTO,iiEcoMilLAIN'YANDRUi.ETOFILE
nhls section o//orm to be usc'Ci ONLY when ilPflCffanl was DEFENDANT (see Pa, RCPJP. No, 1001 (7 I In action be/ore Dlstocl Jusffc",
IF NOT USED, detach /,om copy of nollCo 0/ aPflCill 10 bu served upon aPflCffcc).
'IAICIPI, To Prothonotary
Enlel' rule upon ____.u..___'____'___'___._________ __,____u.___._._.__,__.___.___u ,appell..(.), to lile 0 ,ompIoint In thI._of
Nil/HO of,Iwe1itW{S)
(Corncr<>n Plea. No.
________1 within twenty (201 day. after ...vic. 01 rule or .uff.. entry of judgment ~I non ""'~
SI!}ll/lllJIH 01 Ur,'(1I/III11 Of ,w~ i,"f)"'~ Ill" '-'1'''''
IULII To
.____________,app.II..(.),
Nwnc of iJWOlk)(!( Ii}
( ') YOlJ ore nohlied thaI a rul. i. horeby .nt...d upon you 10 fil. 0 complaint in thi. appeal within twenly (20) day. aftor tho dole of
",vie. of thI, rule upon you by peroonol ..rviee or by c.rtified or r.gi'lerod "",il.
(2)")IOU do not file 0 complaint within thi. time, 0 JUDGMENT Of NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU,
.',
(3) n.I dote 9f .."ie. of thi. rule if .orvie. wo. by moil i. tho dote of maili~
,
Dote:
,19_.
~'o.--",.hOOliioW;-j.-o;p,,~
1l1I"C312.&4
~
"-
N i>: "-
, f'
M ~
N ~ it
-3"'- \ ~ .
( :lO.
x: u:E
a.. (~ ~_.i ~~
In ~(/;
I ;;<>; ~
,.. -'f>
~, 11J.r'i.! ~-'
Lei ".J~ ''')
C:l ~
~ L/",)
<,...
'-8~'
uo IltJldxe UO,,,,WWOO ,(~
1'101110/0 '/lll
OpllUl iUI jrA'IJI(jU WOliN! UIO/lIq II,J/I/O JO Om/lunlS
IU'/IJ' JO .m/.Un,S
-6~' ----,0 AIIO SIH.l
3~ 3~OH8 a381~OS8nS aNII (a3~~I",II) N~OMS
.OlQJ94 pa4:JUllllld!900J S,JapU8S 'HElW
(pOJOI0160J) (pOIl!POO) Aq 0 OO!^'OOlaUOoJod Aq 0 --6~ ' uo PO'OO'PPO 'OM Oln~ Oul
WOuM 01 (O)OOlloddo 041 uodn looddll 10 OOlloN O^oqo OuI6u!Au"duJOo~.IUI0Idwo:). OH, Ololnl:J 04IPO^,o.IIOul JO'llml puo 0
'OlOJ04 p0400nSld!ooo' O,lOpUOO 'HOW (pomI0!60J) (pOIIIPOO) Aq 0 001^JOSIOU09l0d Aq U 6~ '
uo ,--. ---,----- (owau) 'OOlloddo Oul uodn P'lO '010.104 pOuOOIlOld!oOOJ
O,JOpUOO 'HOW (po'oIBl60J) (pO!IIIJOO\ Aq 0 OOl^,OOIBUOOJOO Aq 0 '--6~' ,--,-- (00lAl0'10 %p)
'10 UIOJ041 POIBU6!BOP oOllsnr IOPISla 041 uodn ' -------------oN 'BOld uowwo:) 'IOodd\110 OOlION 04110 Adoo B 0
,
pe^'o' IIU41 WJIIIO JO '"OMS Aqol04 I :.1IAVOI:l:lV
II: --. ~O AiNnOO
VINV^USNNld JO Hi1nMNOIIIIOO
('0'0'1 "/qrollddo ~O"40 '/roddr/O OO/jOU 04/ nUl//1 UJ,LJ'I SA 'In (0/1 NJi NII/lIM 0171' 18 lsnw 80lA'O')0 joold "41)
.1NIY1dWO:l 311:1 0.1 31ml ONY 1Y3ddY :10 3:l1.10N :10 30lMI3S :10 :lOO~d
"
. '....
,..
~
SUSAN K, DAY
DISTRICT JUSTICE
0_11 tOWNIIH"
DIC...ION tOWNII'"' ,
NIDOLIII" tOWNIIII"
IIt,ltom .,IIIIIOIIIO_OH
IOUtH 1I100UtON tOWNIIIU,
DISTRICT 01.3.03
""lilt
.".'1,.
,n MIL.L "AIIf, ,t>, 101 Ilr
MOUN' HOLLY ,,.UNO.,'" "IMI
RESERIIF.1> JUnGM~:NT np.'r~RMINATlllN
Plaintiff: Hrs, B. Kitner, Ht'. John OtBtot
Defendantl A'lua Treatment, Oavld Roth
Complaint NO.: CII-236-95
Oate of lIearlng: November 21, 1995
1 hereby render judgment to the plaIntiff In the amount of $650.00
together with COBts of $96.00, Totul ,judgment $746.00,
COMMENT: Nationwide Insurnnce Compnny wns removed as a defendant.
The above judgment Is as follows: $150.00 for towing and
storage, $350,00 for book value, snd $150.00 for lost wages,
There was no medical eKcuse for the lost work therefore It
Is my opinion It wus not medically necessury,
AU. PARTIJi:S ARE NOTlFIEO TIIAT TilEY IIAVE TIIIRTY (30) !JAYS FROM Till';
ABOVE I>ATE WI'f11 WIII.CII TO APPEAL Till S .JlIOCMENT TO 'rilE On- ICE OF TilE
PRO'rIlONO'rAIlY. C1Il111EHLANIl COllNT'{ COllin In' COMMON PLEAS, COUIlT 1I00IGI,.
CARLISl.E, PA 17013,
\/ ~u{JI:J
Nm K. 07,') (
Ills t rI c t ,lust Ice
SKD/ldk
..,... COURT FILE
NOllel O. A"IAL
.
<<a 1'101_," Of HMWI\W_
C KlAI
ftlOM
_W DIIT.ICT
DIITIICT JUITlCI JUDOMINT
COMMON'UAoN& 95~6913 Civil Term
NOTlCI O. APPIAL
NoIIce It .;- IllGI .... appoIkrlt ha. fllod In the obo.- C""" 01 Common PIeo. "" oppeollrom tho judgment roroderod by the OIItrlct Juotlce on the
... _1ft'" _ .._41.1..... .....
\ (', I~"" (.IT ')T~'"
~QJI"'" '
. ~~~. I, 1'1 I"l:" \{
'+ 1~ \'" PC""" sr
:..._' l"lHIcMlorr"",..,iIt/
II'" I ,qj- I"'. \1 1.11; ,(
NO.
CV Ill'l', (./ ) " (. '1, ~' -2.
LT 19 .t........ r, n-'l..A./'
... ~ ONLY when .... notallon II NqllIred undor ,'" R.cP. . No. If appellanl waS CLAIMANT (see Ps. R.c.P.J.P. No.
.1001&
tWo NotIce 01 Appeal, wNn recolYOd by the OIltrlct Jultic.. will open>le aI 0 tOO 1 (6) In acllon beforfl District Justice, he MUST
lIUP8SI!DIA$lo .... I~ lot poIMIlion In .... ca.. FILE A COMPt.AINT within twenty (20) days alter
.
filing his NOTICE 01 APPEAL. ~,
S/gIaIlN 01 PnlthonOlBfy Of Deputy '"
an
-IM""'DII.r~:NAMIC"a' .
----L ()> 2~ 1 1'1 ~
$T~11
,? A .
..' 'f~'
!" ,I '. 1-\ I,' r; " r I r I.' ,. r
, I') ~I'~ '
,; "" ,)
I~ , T'~
) () ~ "
,.. CCJDI
/' ,,, ,1 . \ " l.. t.::
<.. 1--..
I T
() I I, ',.~ '7
-
.
'1A1CIPI TO INTI I RULI TO PILI COMPLAINT AND RULI TO PILI
. (TNt NCfton oIloml /0 be used ONLY when sppellant WdS DEFENDANT (see Pa. HC.P.J.P. No. 1001(7) 1/1 action before Dl8trlct Justice.
IF NOT USED, defBt;h /rom CqlY 01 notice 01 flD/JOOl to be served upon appellae).
,.AICI'lo To Plothonotary
IInIw Me upon
(Common I'Ieao ~
,", r '
. .
, app....(I), to file a camplalnt In thIt appeal
Name (Jf awo'Ioo(S J
) within twenty (20) day. oller ....vlc. of rule OIlult. entry 01 ludwnoN of '*' pIVIo .
l' f'
~_ \. . '.. .5Y>afute '" __ Of his __ "':-"
IULlo To.::. I' I appoIt"(I).
. ~~. ' ' ,.~. Ntme 01 appeI_sJ
( II ~ ~ that p ..ule I. herwby entered upon you to file a c"",*"nlln thl. appeal within twenty (20) day. oller the date 01
NNlce of ~ upcioI.~ by I*1OIloi ....vlc. 01 by certified 01 rwgl.tered maiL
.1 ."~'
(2)11 ~ nllrfile a ~t within thl. H...., Q JUDGMENT Of NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOu.
(3) The date at ....vIce of thi. rule W ....vIce WQI by mcl'oIl. the dale 01 maiHng.
0.:
__.19__
S/gllIIn 01 A<lIt..._ V Of 0IpAy
lIOPC ..,...
~
'.. ,... "
lr; I "
lO
f.' ., ',~,l ~J:
~f" C') , )
, , ~) ;'I!
~:; :.:
t:... '-'-1' :i
)' , "
" C:) I')
6)' "
. , !. .'
J,,' "
t:. &';:.1 , "/1
:~ ': L; Il~
I. I.t,~ -,
". " ",)
U (..\ ",)
,
~
,~) ~
'\::l-
i"",
.-~ ,,'")
..Q .~ r-
~ '~
r-J ~ ~~\
'-~ <::::.J ~ ~)
., ."
" .
. .
.
;! ~ ~~
e~~~:!~~
~QC,S~I=!E~
i:J :3 =.7: =E'::::
:S~1ii ~c~e
~If: u
"
.
. 95-081
.
JOHN OTSTQT and
BBTIY J. KITNER,
Plaintiffs
IN TIlB COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
va.
DOCKET NO. 95,6913
NATIONWIDB INSURANCB,
AQUA TREATMENT and
DAVID ROTII,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
Defendants
PETITION FUR APPO~TMENT OF ARBITRATORS
TO TIlB HONORABLB, 'nIB JUDGES OF SAID COURT:
Scott A. Freeland. R'IQ,lIlre. counllel for the Defendant in the above action (or actions),
respectfully repl'esents that:
1. The above-.::aptioned action (or actions) i,~ (are) at issue.
2. The claim of the Plaintiff in the action is $3.000.00 AproK.
The counteH:laim of the Defendant in the action is
The following attorneys are interested in the case(s) as counselor are otherwise
disqualified to sit as arbitrators:
WHEREFORE, your petitioner prays your Honorable Court to appoint three (3) arbitrators
to whom the case shall be submitted.
Scott A,I reel , qui
Attorney for Defendants
3907 Hartzdale Drive, Suite 706
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Telephone No. (717) 731-0988
Identification No. 55663
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, ~-h 'f:. ' 19 ~ ,in consideration of the
foregoing Petition, Wl.. J(,S ~. Esquire, w" J},'jIt,rJ
-1J11u..t:. JM , Esquire and /;0.// L. VlJlls. , F..squire
are appointed arbitrators in tht above-captioned action (or actions) as prayed for.
By the Court,
/\/(.~..,"
w~,.
.,
Pol.
,
,
F1tlID-OFFlCl:
n,: J; ;": /-f: ,'n:'I""'/or-'I1Y
::JLj N.1f? ~5 fir 2: 20
CW,13U;L",u '(UN/I'
I !;iVN:)l'I.V/W!A
"
"
"
"
, ,
.
, ,
"
"
~. " 1"'"
I 1,/',
, ~~':J :'s
l!'(
......
r' ,
'.'
'. ~... i
\)
, f'~
b
l':' " 1.1
,. , ".1.
.....
" . " ,
, " " , , ,
;1 i ~~
~~~_:~~~
~ ~!~~s,::!
:\7.lii !I1C~~
~~ ~ ...~
--
.
..
,
95-081
JOHN F, OTSTOT and
BB1TY J. KITNBR,
Plalnliffs
IN 'IlIB COURT OF COMMON PLBAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PBNNSYLV ANIA
vs.
DOCKET NO, 95.6913
NAnONWIDB INSURANCE,
AQUA TRBA TMBNT and
DAVID Rom,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Defendants
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
VERIFICATION
I,
~M<P.~ TA-'{ I...o~ H
_, employee/agent of Aqua Treatment
Services verify that the statements made In the foregoing Answer of Defendants with New
Matter to Plaintiffs' Complaint are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, infonnatlon
and belief. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penaltie~ of
Pa.C.S.A. 04904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
Dated:
~lili ~
qua Treatment Services,
fendant
95-081
II
JOHN F, OTSTOl' and
BB'ITY J, KITNBR,
Plaintiffs
IN 11IB COURT OF COMMON P~
CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PBNNSYLV ANIA
vs.
DOCKET NO. 95-6913
NATlONWIDB INSURANCB,
AQUA TREATMENT and
DAVID R011I.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
Defendants
VBRIFICATION
I, David Roth ,verify that the statements made in the foregoing Answer of
Defendants with New Maller to Plaintiffs' Complaint are true and correct to the best of my
knowledge, Infonnatlon and belief. I understand that false statements herein are made
subject to the penalties of Pa.C.S.A. 04904, relating to unsworn falslt1catlon to authorities.
Dated: 3- c:. -'Ii.
David Roth, Defendanl
;.~ ,C)
!' ..
t 14-:
lor,,; '")
/"
r' ,". '"
" a: );.t.
(.; /7..j
I. /,., ,0
" (\;
fi: I' . ,
. ~"J
i' ~' lr{l
I),. r::.-;' !a..
'n ..~
u :.:1
&;;, V
!! ~ .-
e!~It~.~~
~l:lll~~::Ii!3E~
iJ~~~=RC_
:i7.b ~E~~
!~ I.l ...~
.. ...
)
-' .
. '.
wo"
'k
I , 5- .:/' . '.
I ..,!I 0 I
'ht ;
~n .. ,
--:r ; ':i r..r~
19(j --
~J~ (t~= I )~<
fi r' Cr) I ::1
. ,..:.; ,
fl"'1 I ,,]"t
. , (,) ';}t'Jl
" f.1.J
1<:. ~'- 1_,:(1..
(,J '" ::i
(}l u
m! ~ .~
e!~~~.i?i~
~ClG;s;;!i?iE~
~ ~=~=RC_
~!i !E8~
J
.
-
.
'.
2. It is admitted that Betty J, Kitner and John F. Olslol are Ihe Plaintiffs in the
present action. The Defendants lack knowledge or infonnalion sufficient to fonn an opinion
as to the ownership of the motor vehicle opel1lled by Betty J. Kitner when the accident al
issue occurred. It is believed that said 1'Iaintiffs reside at 423 West Penn Slreel, Carlisle,
Pennsylvania. It is further admitted that Betty J. Kitner was oper,lling a motor vehicle
involved in the motor vehicle accident in question.
3. It is admitted that David L. Roth is a Defendant in the presenl action and was
opel1lting a truck Ihat was involved in Ihe molor vehicle accident at issue.
4. It is admitted that Aqua Treatment Services, Inc. is a Defendant in Ihe above
captioned mailer. It is admitted that Aqua Trealment Services, Inc. was the owner of the
truck operated by David L. Roth when the molor vehicle accidenl occurred.
5. It is admitted Ihal Nalionwide Insul1lnce Company is a named Defendant in the
above caplioned matter. It is specifically denied that said company is properly listed as a
Defendant in this action and it is specifically requested that said Defendant be dismissed as a
Defendant.
6. The remaining avennenls comained in Plaimiffs' Complaim are denied genel1llly
pursuant to PA, R.C.P. Rule 1029.
WHEREFORE, the Defendants respeclfully pray this Honol1lble Court to dismiss
Plaintiffs' Complaint, and to enter judgment against the Plaintiffs and in favor of the
Defendants.
2
-
NEW MATTER
7. Pamgraphs one through six are incorpomted herein by reference, and made a pnrt
hereof as if set forth in full.
8. Plaintiffs' claims are barred in whole or in part by the provisions of the
Pennsylvania Comparative Negligence Act.
9. Plaintiffs' claims are barred in whole or in part by the provisions of the
Pennsylvania No-Fault Motor Vehicle Insurance Act and/or the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle
Financial Responsibility Law.
10. Plaintiffs' Complaint fails to slate a cause of action upon which relief may be
granted.
11. By the actions of Plaintiffs, the Plaintiffs did assume the risk of any and all
injuries and/or damages allegedly suffered.
12. If there is a legal responsibility for the damages set forth in Plaintiffs'
Complaint, the responsibility is that of other individuals and/or entities over whom Defendant
has no control. Plaintiffs' injuries and damages as alleged were not proximately caused in
any manner whatsoever by Defendant.
13. Plaintiffs' claims are barred by the applicable Statute of Limitations.
14. All matters not heretofore directly controverted are hereby specifically denied.
3
9'-081
JOHN F, OTSTOT and
BB1TY J. KITNER,
Plaintiffs
IN 11IE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PBNNSYL VANIA
vs.
DOCKm'NO.95-6913
NAll0NWIDB INSURANCE,
AQUA TREATMENT and
DAVID R<Ym,
CIVIL ACTION . LAW
Defendants
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
VERIFICATION
Scott A. Freeland, Esquire, attorney for Defendant in the within action, certifies that
the statements made in Ihe foregoing Answer of Defendants with New Matter to Plaintiffs'
Complaint are true and correct to the best of his knowledge, infonnation and belief. He
understands that false statements herein are made 5ubjectto the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S,
Section 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
Dated: Febroal)' 7. 1996
r
Scott /11.. reeland, Esq ire
Attorney for Defendant
3907 Hartzdale Drive, Suite 706
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Telephone (717) 731-ll988
Identification No. SS663