Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout95-07197 . ~ . ~ - ~ -2. ~ J .", I VI 7 \... CV. ,.- >- j &. 1 .'". ";',:> " , ,l,;",: . ',.: . ....~ ..~'r . ': .. - J J r- 0- -- r I ~ " "'." ',;;.. , ~'.f" "';"; ,"<1;. '~"V~; :,~~ ::.."! " " ... " , "',; )f . - .~ . . . .' I .~_.."".~,_....__...,.e)."~._..R~___.."",Q ._ .l. lJfi!ll!~Jl..-- Schmidt and Ronca PC Altom.,. AIId CounHlon At LAw ", . o 109 SUlI ...... .....-.. _,...... 11.01 717111''''00 ._. _.._'" Dte) 0 1995~_ '.'. <"_ I . \ VICKI MUTHLER, Petitioner IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA -vs- No. 9.3- 7/17 (} -l.~\'J-L-j,^- KEMPER NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANIES, CIVIL ACTION - LAW Respondent BllI& NOW THIS ~y of ~cP\y{..a~995, AND based on the foregoing Petition to Compel Arbitration, a Rule is directed to the Respondent, KEMPER NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANIES, to show cause, if any, why it should not designate an arbitrator and why the above captioned matter should not proceed to arbitration. "LG' RULE RETURNABLE DAYS FROM SERVICE. By the Court: I JL..A IS ~, J. ...4.. A\J.D'()rACE Of 1\!F f'i:01HONOTlflY 9'5 OEe 2' 1\\110: 05 CUII.i3i:ll\/l.;,) COUNTY Pi:t'INSi'lWNk\ .' '. VICKI MUTHLER, Petitioner IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA -vs- No. KEMPER NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANIES, Respondent CIVIL ACTION - LAW PBTITION TO COMPBL ARBITRATION AND NOW COMES, the Petitioner, Vicki Muthler, by and through his attorneys, Schmidt and Ronca, P.C., and sets forth as follows: 1. The Petitioner, vicki Muthler, is an adult individual residing at RD #1, Box 358, Lock Haven, PA 17745. 2. The Respondent, Kemper National Insurance Companies, is an insurance company duly licensed to do business in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania with its principal place of business located at Hillside corporate Center, 5001 Louise Drive, Suite 102, Mechanicsburg, PA 17055. 3. On or about December 23, 1990, Petitioner was involved in a motor vehicle accident with a vehicle owned and operated by a John J. Perry, at the intersection of Township Route 365 and Pennsylvania Route 287, piatt Township, Lycoming County, PA. (See attached Exhibit "A.") 4. It is believed and averred that at the time of the aforesaid motor vehicle accident, the said John J. Perry was an operator of an under insured motor vehicle within the meaning of the Financial Responsibility Law. 5. At the time of the aforesaid accident, the Petitioner was a named insured under a policy of automobile insurance issued by the Respondent, Policy No. HB542010. (See attached Exhibit "B.") 6. As a result of the aforesaid accident, the Petitioner suffered severe and permanent injuries primarily in the area of her low back, alonq with damaqes to the associated muscles, nerves and liqaments. 7. As a result of the aforesaid accident, the insurance carrier for John J. Perry, State Farm Insurance Company, offered to pay its policy limits of Twenty-Five Thousand ($25,000) Dollars. 8. On or about Auqust 28, 1995, the Respondent waived its subroqation riqhts. (See attached Exhibit "C.") 9. The Petitioner and Respondent have been unable to resolve the value of the damaqes which the Petitioner suffered in the accident. 10. The Petitioner's policy of automobile insurance contains an endorsement for underinsurance motorist coveraqe containinq an arbitration clause which provides for arbitration pursuant to Pennsylvania Uniform Arbitration Act where there is a dispute as to the amount of damaqes to which Petitioner is entitled. 11. The Petitioner has previously requested that Respondent desiqnate an arbitrator, but the Respondent has failed to do so. (See attached Exhibit "D.") WHEREFORE, the Petitioner prays that the court issue a Rule directed to Re.pondent to show cause it any, why the Respondent should not desiqnate an arbitrator and why this matter should not proceed to arbitration. .."".~ "-"-'~', 'ii;-P~T"."~""'" Resp cttull~submitted' SC lOT AN RONCA, .C. ( By: Charles E. Schmidt, Jr. I.D. No. 19198 209 State Street Harrisburq, PA 17101 (717) 232-6300 Attorney tor the Petitioner f'" ~ ,., .,.\,.:;:r..." I ro;;~. -:1~.:V:; ~..- I:i!;~~";'~-----, '.............';- -..t;...,.'" ", , ~' , ,~, ..... r~"~ ..~.'.... .,.... , . .CMTWI__IN'ITY". .,,;;~ POUCI ACC~ ""'~~' ,"'.'.....,. . ;'. .".....~ JQJ'.I<<O-O .....~;'.. ;,....r...r\ .,.., .' .- . ~-r: .~..:~.. ',,\,' . ~,: .'~..~'..,j,'!-- MIJlIO';:. '~~;KI-I;~J.:~~.I';, E.'!'/i~.S\r...:~,. . .~.....~. . . I~-. ' . ... .,....>::'.ll."..w.tA\,.,.,J..~'1 . ".. "~SfoIO'S'"P." Irt-WA"S....,..Y.... -, '......,r.>"Ii';'Q~1i....~..,r.' \l1u.L ~~. ,. _, ~~ 1 .":... ~'~."'f.:.\!~' ~"f. ...,:"., j-' .':,. A.:rA&lc..' t~/......J . Inc, .,:-' ,....:. J"t'ICO,~"?""'-1"1'~ ~""I;~" ,.q .M"~''''''';' ,. ." ,,,-n.";!) I ~ ... .':'I3"':"~;~1 ',.:~{. ff 11'I'/~'/~fll"{} .. .......<'!:.. 7 ...-. 0 11,_ ,. \'''' 'L"'_"':'~:~J l.4::j"'. 10.-'_01 """,wm':'~~'.:'..;I WAD .wu ",;: ::;=DOI'~.i~~'.h~Q~; "~:= \NTI .... ,~.~.t ,,'L......'...1IliOOI1I ~ '..........m.' '!';' I~".." t1.......~.: ... t)~ 1,_ I_MOOIIWI .1. """'....-uuLI yAli,.l a.DllllOlWUC'. ",.,., DMMOI '}'~': ~I~'~" J-IIVl" \NT I .. '. AJ..-" .. , .. ., \.., ..\1...."1:.*. .,.~. t.~ h,';; ... ~, ,.. '.iX':'lr'.'D.... "~"':)'!ol:;i' ,.... ;." ..1 <'~:;'I':"H&JO ,,, . ""1G....J<. ---._. ' .. ~..I"UTI~. 1'iJlft-r" .,-.,,.i .:1', r,,' ,~... '. -'lC7"O,aL. ... ...:..'p'~ $. -' ,....', .. .. '.~L~.t...'L. ~\("'.t'1 .."... . '1,. ,...1' S~ l'lI..... .t",' ," \.,,,.,.... ,.~. - '. _. . -_, "P".:,,'"1l'G"'. '\..- \ ~,~'" . ...'l".".'.. ." ,,,,-1,_'.\,,'. :~. __ .,. a.1I "" " '\,'.':"'11' '"~....... ...":'~'.. ..,~ ;;' ..' ..... '~. '.... .~. ~ '~"""'h'; &1'1', ..'1\..1&,""'''''''- . fIIOT~ ...~.. ." ..' '. ,. ". '.' ...:",."...,~ 'i;,?l' \.j~ ..-{..........:. .. . I W "I...,~~~.NI!" ., l\..'\..~~"n." .,', .[~~~:I~~'~", .~t~~'~~h'c~o'" ...~.. .. r1I '......' "'~CMI""",I'.,:t':. ....;,..-. ..,~.' .:\:1"".. . ..:.... . I. '" ..... '.. ~ t". "',;I:,.J:~' 'i~' ..,.....--..'."(~....._..: :. .:....~ ......,...,..... "')_ .. '1"".,,~ ......(~~.\:...______~......... ... ......,._... .....,.-..... ":-;'.. .... . .;.-.t!:...~cf...O"'"' \~'.""""""'.~Ih'."""" ._ =.!.__.&-...... ,.vtun~ " ......... ..' -.-..-. ~~~D'7'G:. l"rA ......, ~,~.:..:~'.;, .:'II-:-,~i"" I"F-\. 1";:n"'1.-7h~t'.. U . .i \ ~.~ Z~"'-K.-"&ltSIAl ~:-,;\~.~ ',~~J'r~'''''''<)1 ,,"- . .J2Z":"'o'ff'7:. II ~. .'. ......- ,."\..: '.....'....., '.'..,.'-.. ....,'...'_ ..........-..... . I . ::llI'l~' . '.. ., . .'. ...:,.....".... r:" '.' .,lis. .. .. .-':11'.' .J..... .' j,,:.1 '. f -=0 1fIIl9e."U1oJi." .. "'~'U~JI";'\..I;""".'I")(Nrc.S/J ~,;,: . -'J:f~.' "'1i"~nf . I' ~ -, """:''''1. ..'.. ~"t CMAt.ol 0. ~~".". I"N..i:,-"iti~o.JJ ;j::'..~i!'!":t;/,.. ...'t7U*'O' ~(. I'" ~. -~"-. I ~. . .... ." ..'::......,'1:1'4.. I'~'... ;'I~':~':'.:~~'f".". I-....~ '11'- .~ ~~ ~ t" ...~.,..\~;;.. ':";t;~r.'J,'::;~~',I;~:, ...,ea ;}:. ,...j'It ~1 '. 1"\';: ", I"'" "~L,;;";"r>t I-,~,'c),~, r",T. "'i1./~. S'5'::, ~ ~ L. .1_ ~'~3~ l~~;.~/.'17~~'..~ '.:::~~.~i~=':~ '''=0 ig'36t~~C'lIlI)"'~~c;(,l . --'7 '" :lOb6t I 0, ~J.!~ZJs eo. I~ . .. .... ACCQIIIT'" - 1".l1!'!.- I .l'1S'SI'" .... '. .' 'r "-, : :.a"- ...~ , .. ,~..,lol " :' ;,,~~~;,,\t '. ". 'n;}' . ",:,.,~, , ;.... '. "v'. ,';. ~. ,;1> %01 II) , .~u."', . ....l!""h' ~ '. '.."f""" _ .. . ,,:z~.,. , , " ~ .""" . .. . ..r. ,. ~~ " :~.~j\: : '.' to i ,. ."'.i~~ ." .. .. -.' ~.I". , 1,~ll:.. ,', ~'~"-' . , '.. ~ ",~, 12~},:M:. . .< 1......- ,.~.. t H . .. w ~ __.... r .. ~ ~. N . I,W -: ...~:lJ?.~'t; ...~.~~, 'J .. "::~;1'~: . '-1' PI... ~ . '''~ICICIa---:.:r~.. 1..ftCII . j.:fi . ......... ~:, ~ "~}~~'.~ ,: 1'.,;. """':f'!t ."....,. ~ ~""A I-Z$"~ iJ 'roltof ~ ILeP ::.~;,"-o,. SA-'t. ""=1 I J'. L .. o 0 0 t. 10 !O o 0 0 8 To "I;; " aJ 9 '1 /l~tDtl . Oro 0 Gi5~ oro-~7to h ._.._1 -. -..--i:- t . I, I..'.... -..., CH~ "",'~ . .. '.~;!i'~~ ~31:~?~;.. ,,\ . .. , f . ..,....., ) ~ .' . ; :' . \.. . I ::",' ~'~~..l' .).:&,.):....... ..;... -' ..! I'I~.~ ~"-, "~ It I'" ..,") .... .....";... .'.4i~.'~'.. ,..!'..~.-,.-.., ..... j" .--~~&15~.! .;;" A~.Jf.l ";, -.....~fof ~~ ~/,.,.L in. ,*COOUnal CWIJU't 1NIIf' TO MIIOiIO TO aOCllA IMtOUCIN tit Of Me...... .' ;~:.;C' . (;.:.. ~ :t"J.!Jil. . ... .. A-...;!ok.rc.;r. ~..,,;'...,. 'f. ""t.' '. A . C 0 I . 0 NAMa _ 'r",,,., 'lo:'~:ot~'!-;.''',.~ ti ~~~ PMOtIII '. '~,..' H , , fI\ I' :l, 0 O~"\'" ; ~,.~'t;,~~ 'ii~",':;I.";;ii(,I:~,~(;,.,il..... I .J '" 17 J ,. 0 W'L.l"",.b,Jcl/olt. 5/5 8r>>Aot.: L<lU;.~~ B.','''' ,~:.:. ..";.. Z. I (:. U. J , 0 Oft' 2. .J I r:;. SOt '3 , 0 CIR":J '3 ~ il4 (;0 J , 0 ~.J....'-f .J...i~.;".;..._~'! '.- ,..---..--_-L- -. .:~f';:ir.. .,'~r ...... ,....~~t',:r.). .. ",.' . .,'. .... h.. .~.~'.'I,;}',"""'~~.' ....01 ".iL;"~!:' .. . ...... .',;. ,'~'i-I.r~ il;4 '""0'.(.\,. ;.,j . .' ~. ,. .. ,'. . .. .-.. . ., " ... .;". ',1.,,'. .... ,~. -.- :.~.:~~!. ; ,.- . t ~(':. ,. :.,." .'.. '. " .." r ..,. I . i.~ 0 ...' .5 D \.I~::. ..!. .' r.... ~ Q - i.~ . .-:~\ '. 0 ,. ,oj l' '0 , . , " ,I .. ---- ;'. ........ to. ., ...... .. " ~....'r-r...~..:.,..... "'~"If'IlIr.~ :&1.; .1', '. . , . .~.::' :." ..'~~~f".' '. LIt...... ~ DIU., Il-a.:r-'o',,-~":l. . . ......., "'''"'!'''l'O''' . .... "'. ~'" .(, '~'" ,','..; ~. . POUCa P'<:l ~. ft.ACIM"., .t,"" t1t..", '0"'0. I;~~.:"",.I. .. ... _. t .. ..' ~.. .~:......tt\~..:.:.: ; ",' ...~-: .,-S. ," . r. .,.. _.~. .t , l:),,'~""""" . ...\.:.... ", ." ~ '':_~__ ... Ir,' . . :.~......_..... ..," t ;..~...,...; .0 ...... :\. . . ...,:.... P. ...... ;;,. . . . ~ .~~ ::=-.~ . t . O'Ui. ...... ...;,. ..un_.... "'''''1.11':' ~1.1'__' ',...;\..:'I-":~ " - ... .. ~.',.. ~. ,J...-..:..; ;.-..~.J .:1j....-..... :' :'. ..'f(.;:r.... .'.' .._...... ...~. .r~ '~,'1.'~._.---" ..l.f-\~:~~ --- ...j ,.....;.: .' '" .,.~. .__..t, .:.;",,', ..:.'~" ........ .,.~ ....... ..,. "'f._._hU_: ~i,,,.l'.._ !~........ . ,~, ,-- ., ....... . v,~ ....:~.,O(~,~: !'~. : '.' J . "; '.' t I ;~'C'l'~":-;" ..... ~ ~. ~tE ~1 .' .~.... . ..,.~, :.. I z..(i . .: .....~Ij~..... .: ".' :.v;:., ",' "."r.";' ,,"':'1'... .:: : <I.~ .~. ~, "~':...~. '::.,r.. ':,., ",'"':"" ,'. ..... :, ':.,'(!.""" .~ .,' :li :."~. ':-'J T~ ~',Jrtu6J'J1~,m .lJiJ7"'~"I),JtT.I'''.''A ,.m. 'tN.t. S fla? j, u"J,T"1 flU t'.IJM..;;.i....u:'.1.I' I o'~ ..ur~or: .. ,,,, '.." 7U , ~ ~; .' .'" , -, .; - .., ....J'...,." "'-..-." . t..... ,.. ...... .', '. .... ,:,:,::.;\1.1.., , , .~....:~; t' ....;.... ;f,~~.''';.;. '. ..,',' ..... '. . ~. .' " '. .... ;. , .. ....~ .... ., , , . .'..... :"",....... ...... ..;,.... c . ..,....... ,.1' " :"" , " .....~.......',..I .........','1....... . ;.....!".. ,,~.~.., 'o. 7';/~.'.:~....'. : ~'. '7' .'~'. ~?'~: .- ~\' .' , . ". -";.'~' ;...,.'~...,,.~~ \:t" r. .. ,... .'. .. ". .' ". .: . ~~:'~~~l!(,';,l.y ',~. ';",:" '~.~...,...., fl':', i~;.';:'~ '. .~ r ,'. .- .... .. .1. . ~, f. .;'-:' .;:...':".....f,.t;r .: ~1/..' ....t:. I!~'~'!:.; ~'-;I.' .... "~'I .'. .. , .~<l,~~:.:.~:I.f~. ';:J:"~'~r:".~ ..;:~~,,:,I:,,., .. ' ~~;~.~. -:: ..::?:. . .. .\' ;.'\ ..',,: ..ij~t~b' . -"'t". 1'.' ";'_.:... ' ~..z~:....,.~~....5.....-:.Y.. .lf~i'~ .~'.., :, ":~"..~i'l :,..\:. .', ".I..t".-':";':~Ir~~~~ ..",..<.).'\1"" ..'; '~WJ..rr:'''- ri.:: , ......... ..... . -,. '. ......... ........;;...::f:'1~..~.r.:t..~. ..,-;'" ,,;,):~.~""""':' , ~ . '. "."- 'r n . ~ .'. ....N&.....' ;'..~...... .,.'....:... o. . ^... . 1....~7rtv".....-l~........~:..(..:..tJ..;.~.~. ........ '. \. .. .-" '.- .' .:.'...... ;, -f.." .....:..~,...i.. .: ,'~'. . . '. ~~~~":..t'. ';.; ..~ """I ~ultt ,..!..lE.. c: '....ClOOOl....,._.._OI ;, " no ..~-..._ """. --.. M.MA't MIll . lOA .0(;1' "." ,......... UlOT I .....11 o t'\ Oft. ...--. ~....,.~'(':""~~...R~l ~im'-~.-~;.~'--=....,...~......~,."~. ~~;...:'._':.~ :....., \ ' ~. _, . ?:~.:.~. t rYf:f .~, h' .',;'..s.1(I":" ...~.'.!i':"'.":'"':'t. t ~ ...Jt:.. .......... ., . ",,'. I .-t,.. _:.I....,..._\..~...~. ....-...I"~~... I.....~; ""'..)." ,.. CI1IGot MfIOIIT NO.1" ____ .,: ;.f' "',".. -- . .... , ,. '- , ., " - ,r. ,.........\11I n. """IT .:.-. n. ,"MAJ. 0,.,: 0. ,'. o !) ....,. ";.. , ",,' '.;, , ..' .'.~. . ,... . ...::.,. . :.~;;- '" ,....;.. .' ..;..).'it...... ~1 ....,..... '::::~J~. ~' ", . ,~ .' ......,(. ~.;::~:~ .:. .:~;.; : .:.).. "',1 . ....." t.. , ":,,:,~} '..!. ..-:. 10 IHVfSt......'tOf'It COIM'\I'U .:. .. .' 7~' ~~~"""'/' : . ..... '. ....i~.l "~'~i'_"~> ..' .,},~,""~, ",-:,.,:~. ,.,..... ..~\l.~j~ V....~~~~.... . ," o' t. ',-1'" '( " ~'.t..:..'.'.~ .;' ...t. I .....~:1.4 ,",1".. ... . . L. ",-"'''''';",.. . .... "~.........' -: or" . . 'l ..\ ... 1"1- 'c.'f_rJ~\M~Ol'__ .'. . COMMONWIALTHuo:r.-..YUIlUGA,'. f~":>i~~... ..':'.'....:. .. ..:~', . ~ ClJmIlfOll_1NIJ.'I' . .... ;POUC.&_~ ~'!~" 'y; ,.. '.;".,'.' " ..'....... ..... .if ~r.'1IMDNI .. .-r..~" ,.' ,',~.. If'"""""~~. o{'''' ~1~:);..L;",.,....; . . Of ";\":i;".." JI :~~~. 4ttW rn -0.. M utaG . "'f" ~ ,'/ i:fI..:.1 . '1Ilt'll"\'-- '..I', :.t. ~.....;-... ,~.'I ". . .. . ..f"C~'~ t ''--~':\'' ...... "'IQllII......."( 'Wl1"....-.....I.. . .. ~\li~,', . J. ".i. ....,,''l~,\ f~ ~7' 1.~<";;;:"L;',',,~r$,~' ':11;," .,,~. ' ." . .: I~' '''''.~I&~ ~... '.C:' .i.:.\>:;". .n~~:~~'~~~'~ :':;{.>.!~ .:::r.,~~,,~:jl'"'''' ,,;. .ZJ-'jO. r-~ ,~".:. ;.~_-:"'..;.'~'~ .,.~. 4l, ';":!\J~ '..,_IIIIA. " ,,''IO'ir..'4':-'' ......... ".-'-' (..... :~. 1I....1OMJIII: .,~",,;- :.....~\:.;.:. 'LWllCUDAMAQI - '~ ,~,::.... cwo IIAIIID', .:'.1'.... ,"....... 11'.;- ...' ,.,.Q.f'.t...,~ ._... , ;!-,,'- !""!}''\r.:'~ '-UllHT I~.~~t"'t~;' .' ",. 11.=- YII. 'L=:o"~:.>',','.. ~~~.~u.~~~~... ........':.~~.,:..~' ::::.un ....wf'll' ';'.c-\:. ... 1- .... ..t_:'~ ~::', .~\":; ~ . t:"-t-. ~'. .'." ; ~."~" ":-- .~.._.a_.__ "..-... I "..._.-....".~.'~I -,', ..1_.t:I....... _ .---- ,~..'.. .h.~"'\....":"'".,.,';l.~\....J... '..t'4h)I:':'I"'; . " ..' ,. " "'~"',v,..::Jt' . ......'" ,...1- I "I ~ ~ " I _,I, '......:...~ :. ~f',,' ",,"':-/:;';;~~~~J" . .". -I' :, '.' ,I , , + 'mAD' ....~. ';.j..~,~'f..;~/.:;!I'~,' ,\t'-:a '').::1', . j. '. .-:. .." ," ..... . :t'~~,,,,, '.l~'~~:~:'." t:S~.f. ..l~:~~ ~V.:. .~. ....,., ., J '> . .~ ::J:~.'~ / .,"',', """ r " ;,';' .. n.... . "! 'l~ 'r.-: ::--;:'\'i,;';f\rt ',';;;:" !~.".'" ,~. r H'. ';''' . ... I :-', . . ..... ~ ..... ....__ O-.D" 011tWmO "'" , ~ ;' "':". . :, .;~\' ;'''-.', , r<<nlll .... JJ~ncw '. . n. '. .~.~.; r 1-, \.. . :~ :..1. n. . -l~'" ... 1: .... . I:'W '; ..-;-;....'I.w. :!\ 1'''- ..... ~~; f ...,~.~., .. . ~. .t- .. ~- : .......~..... ~I '''; ;:1t .... ~_.... .. ~ ~'.:'.... ..' .. , " ' ....-;\1. f. :..-~ 'I"_.__~~'r.,......_ ,.~........ i~.. I:..'I.....~ .......__ ~.. ~ __ ""'I"t'~""."'-' '(;-.':~-..l: ...~ ......... .'. .': :1:,..:_.__ ........_... : '.. '.. ('t~"." . '1 .......-. -t.......MIaI. ... . . ,..___..-_ ,..IIrftII'9_. "f . . ,.., "".--:. ." .:.._ ........ -.-.- ....-. ...~:'~.~.'. -.---,---' _ I'"."R,.... 1'-""-"" "J,' 1'--- ..... 1"---- ;l:':"'oLe:"" r.t.. \ I -"L' '-'4'\' ',". .m';: t:' U'l.O'J-tl .::. : ~ - -'''IT'' gb.~ ~ ~~ Je.==:C:"':" .'A.-";'"Oj~' , .- .1'W-(;;;~~~. ~ ~ .... ~ - .. ---- .... I .,_ .. ... ,....... . ., : .... ......... \.;.. ....., . : ~~..~~O ,,~ l~ ,..J ~r.o~.....:. ,,::\~,:.;:..~tz..: "~"::":..'-~ N.~'~:~~' 17~,.;:~.; t 0. I-~.":- " I'.:~.... ,'-... '\ ~^ , 1 I........ I """i-' WII' '~:~i" .....L.., ....- ",:.:'0. ., ~: 3 .... : '.~, :.' ;...~~:--,: 'I'" . " ''':oO' I. .' ,:., ':. .. .:.,' .' .... ..~..~...,....~."':..:.~.~.';.....:..r~ ~ _u.t ":~1.' .~ .. ..-- I...... . -- I'~::-._.~.'~!(Ji L~I-~ ..::;',\' ,,',.. .. "'.. ~I .,."..".... 1"- .- -- , ~" .. ' , 1~.~.:C{.!.:.:~.4. .:\,.... ~...~!J.:.~.f".? ::.. '. .~',!-" .'. .r..........~. '. ...~ ,~.,~ I......... '. ~'. "Ij~..a.. . I" I' f .. UGAU:I "_0 '" " .. '\-'. ";'" .....:.:...... . . t'-' _I"'.' '.'!-\''.It.:,'.''i.l..l . " .'_~,.... ..;......... .,'JI:'!;,.' -.~:-- ' . ..' . ......... ~ .ctt~.1. - '...."t."J'"".. I~ \'".." .,,". .' .. I" .. ..!.t"'i:,..:s.':.~l.ftl'::-~'. ::.L:~ ':;." '~If' ..... . .. ,~.~'K'""..... ~ .,l'''' - . . . ..'~ . .....:~....:~~,..t.:.:fltr.l. 1'... ~.,...', '1I;,t.r:..~. . .' ,....:.f'" .', ' ,.'..:?,~J;.;i';V''':;'':' ....:.:....!~".:...~..~" :0 ~ ... . .,.,,~ .. .;..~.~~,~........, .t;'~. ....~".. ~:".r..:"~/: :',-."!fi'. Q............~-.y, m....tOaGCUAnMUIII.....IIO'nOIL..... ;';.;{.'1. ,;~r,.~. ~. ...:'1.... ...~ ,.., " . ., . ".... ..... '. . ..~....~...I.. . ...;~,""....... . .\'~.. - . . __ .... .~.. .'. . fIMONI . 7l1f:'"~..\I. 1"'- ..r' "1" ., 0.'''' ~\"';..." . i-~ I I '~'i";'"'' . ", I -.' '. I, . .~ ,~.,., ~ , 'I i' 1:..:,.... .......-.... '" , h r" f. I ~ ' "1",.' . A:'~"'~C " . , o .... o . ,. " -, ...i 1 _.~L_ I ! I n .. H ..' .'. ti 'rt "to"'''''', .......'.. '. . ...-..p .,,:\'l'~"':..,.~. t\.("";' ,,,,:.;... : .\''!.:' . . '1.... .. .' '.. .'.:.;.J'\:.....~ ~.;,;. .~. , ;.!: ..... . ....' ~.;.l.~..,..'~ . ",. ~ ..,f... ,.. , ---- ..' .' --.' , ., ht " ...... ~.--:~ l' ...... ." --, . ~ '.. .. ., . ~.:.;;.: '. ..t. J '~.1 ," ',' . L .. " " ~~('-h' ~A~ fv, ...- ',10 .. :. . ',,: 001IIII1I aocu ...,...~~......,. P';', ,..... : .~ ......r ",.', ,: " .'~~~~~.!:':'.'~;\'. II "~lt,{7JY:.,!\.I:.",.. . T. -""'f~""'~' ". . "\ ',,' . '4th~f,~I.'. .'~. ~ .; -r:-.' J ". ~./~';:;...';.. :;' ~~..';t,'". r,.';,;: , ...... +' ;I; 4,;. ~! . !j!f. .....-. .... '. '.I'!.....~,.."..~:,....... "~~.~l!".!i ~~ ,'. ;.,',..., '. ... ".' ;..-:C "..j.~.l . I .', .~~".I"" . ~"",.,....... . .(~~t$~\;.~;,.? . ~ ", ilfe~('''' .', .~ '~'., J;,t,.:~~J.' ",,":: '.' . ."i~;'~~" . ' . i .:~.,; .:....:l:~L' ;'" 'r./.../" ..'..... .~. .<II,..T......\.. .:' '.."9 nl~~ ..~_.~.l. . .. . '-,..~~. ". . .',;.lA;r.~ J;V'. 'f.'~... ,.:;.' . \ ~!jl:: ,,~/""'.";""" ... -...,.....- ~r..-::.tt:"";" . ','::' . lOOt. .J. > o . .... ~., '" i':~ ,"\, "~... (~"'~rl'\,I. ", .~.. ~~ .i~i I" ..~'~:~' . .. ~, M'.f '.' ~t!'''-.-, "\ ",. ~\ I.".' ".~;f'~ . ,");,\. "'.'1.\:;" .~ :1' :.::.~!~ . /:~~~~~ .':~' ......J:.J~..... .....'., . .'~!. . .' . ~ . ..... "'I'!'t"'~' ;.-:' ..i~::. "'~i~1.~ ... ......4.. .....:;........ '" .:" ~~'. ~,'f!~. ~ .."'....' .r.::;:"'( . . '.1:;'. ;,: , \. ~"::'.$; i.'\, .~I" . , V.......r...t 'l"~.~. . . .. f", ~.."",..',.. ,. '~r i~"'l..h' . . . ",i.;~ ..... . . J.!i\..~:-f.1,....~~ I I H':. .. ~t~ J ,'....., . .~.:.; ...,...:: ..~..,;..... . Q'" .... "'t':',~.., ..f!,". J' . '.~' ':.~\l~.. .;:~.,.: ..l;;j ~.~.:!. . . .'.~ . ....;-... ',;... .. '.. .~ r "". .f. .. .: I... ~ ;-~~::" ., . ,. ......:,;.' ,: ,.~;~!1!~.l' ..,~. ,*-=t.\f;;~~.~.. .' \\r:~,~;:',; .'-. .f,.. , . ~~~.,.:-. ~'.." ~/.',:.:.:.::,., .. '.. ."" . ..: ... "."\ ...~ ':.\~.\!"..:.:~.:. ~':')''''''''t(-. .~n~:.1.":'I'''u ,./~. .' ;, ",. ~ :J.....: " . ~i.~i.~.:":ri":',' .. ':'Lo;). ~j"l),L;,:. . 4......Ji". ":"" .... ,". < , " ,"':~~J~:.!.:.,,..)'" .....,.:'&t~ . ...1\",..' ..:,. . ~:~;:;:gt.:.;.....,.':.. .~~:~i.i.....'.....-" " , .... ~~ cr .~ ,. ,. r; .~ ;i; .y; .~~~:i:;~:,,,.,. .. 1.;'. _.,'..' ,.(~ ......:. "",., " . ",':{~h"'"'' ." , ......., ..~;;.";.:.. ~. :=E'~ ... .' .'.!.~,..t,.,.'.;.... 4;". .1. ""'._-1-'. .. ...-..' , .. ,'t.; '..t' ,. ,~ ,. !;" n. :~:~~;'k~' _.. -.;" ..",,,.~.I.... .t.:.... .. :; ...J..... ..' . ~..... , ; ..........,.:.!.' .~'. . ~ ....t:' ,..IaC11QtII......IOM.r.. eMAIIOIDI...;......~.:fa.CI.IIIfIOff IlIPOIrf MUll ,.. :...... - "~'. ,~.I....~.... -J -. ,- , ....coaao. . ~ "'-"'" .-n't PI....... I "ClOII \'_:1_-._r ~~~)_. ..... ., .... ..;.Q:r..... . ). ~~}'.\..t... ~ '~. ~~~.;~~..,ACCII*TDM'II. 11..~J-''''/:; .:. 'I.! l' .. A___" .,;'.0(": , ,;...~ ~1'" 1..1I1' ...rt..,~..., I~{ :':I,~ ~~~. ",'. .(....... . , 1 ruc.ua ~'f-.I1.. ,'l~ a . :," :(X~T .u,:;., .... I ,~,'Z .=..,'1 :~ ~ ~~~. .t~-: :~~~;t'I~ ~~1~~'1;i :~0~~~~ )V~. '^"'~.l,', .:;. I..~ ....~"T,.T. :~r:.;~" ,~~~-* ;~~~ 1'i~~~~t} > ;~' . "'.~,&;~:. ~ '.;"/M: ot:l.~,l;jc-",<.:!""'" .,"" ,. . .<" ~:~!<51. /aif.;i;.~ ~'..,.......::' ..~..' .' ,;,~".":. ~:,,~..'~""I"i~""'.~:..tN~:C~~ "of 't$W)f{I'" ..;.~.~.. 1~:l1'" ..;u7',~""!fJ.'; "t::~;;(l.~ ~!;,p;; 1.;,i'::';~I;;!)fi ~ ::~i~~(~~:~~~' r:)j~ .~..:...;.:,t'.t':. ';$;~,.1~i:\~~'~":' ~~;;.~~',:r~;"'~~?ID'J:;r :..'i'''::(-'::''ti 'X: "'.TAf~,:'c,';il' , :,,~.~~~~ 'fA. ,t-"~ If ~.":'~"":"~;.w~ r.;,:i.'!ii~'J>7d:~,'/li' '>~" ,,"";".l.'.~~~:r.:: Uj'.(of. J(1~l v.', ~I. ..... r "'.1.:"A ."..IJ"'~" .~...'~~..::. 'l..!,.l"',;,~,,, ..'-"-~ ..f..~ .,...........\1-.. .,~...... .'. __ ,..1. .,."il."A'" t,~..\"""I"(' ",,. ';;'I""':'.?I~liIJ,,"\:;'~~r.-ft\~'~',; ',~....~. ./,'''- ~ .~~li ~~~~~8{r~~'~"l,.'~t-"}:"':it. 'f.~~'i: ,:,.:::,.' .,. . 'Y.'t<#-,~..t/i"~IJk" !~i" 4..... ,-;~>.<(,~: ;"..'.'.__ :' .~~~;i.}:'. J, ".1.;'.:0 '1 ):!I'~"'''''''' if~ . ..~ ....~ . .:!~~~~ ':+"0.. :. ,;.'" ....f~ll'.. ~j.: ........ . 0,1\, ~-,,,,~,,, I"'" ...... ',':' '.1-_ . ..-. .\t.' 4. ',1', . ,. ",. .' . :!:,......~~,;~\t~ :"i: :~~I:'f.r...,~~~,)~.~; .', ,'.1W1I · \:'.':'!t"l"i:.~\~1.t=1' ,~:. .!tJ..:...A;~:': .!. :J:j;~ ~ ~:<:~.- '~',;;;~M'\:!:f."'.'" ,~j"""l;';""""t'o!' i..~..~"_" ',. .' 'r ..'Ji.O'fr.' ~':"I" ..oiIJ,: .-r=",\".~~:'" ~ . ..:.~,J..,'..:,.,,, ',,~.'!.'''''..' :.......I..-.",w.....'...~. ,. .. ..(.....~ ...~-;-. ~-",;,,";~~'. '- '. ..' ... fl"'~~ , .. . . .~"':t.. 1M.' ""~" ..''''''' :.e,'C. 'J"- ." . '[3" .. ....... ~. .'!.. .. :,;............... .....- . ~..............' ..;.:..~,,}.~., .: .;.... .'t'.. "tl~ :. ............ :/........ . t...aa\.. ;1":,'''''' 'I'; ......... ,'., " ......-.-.nc. .~,:...;.............. '1......-..-......... rj\ L::.:J . .' ....j,'. .:;~;~ . ,....~~\\.'.' . '.it.'.... . '!!:?J,:. '. )Cf,I::: ",-.. . " "'.j'. D' :~~...1::..:~.~~..:}~i " ....~. . ..\.:....., '~..;, ..'.. 7~! .... l'. ...; '4":12'. ,. :....f,.\". """.1.:' ,', . "."~ ...t.~~l~~\~/.:.~ . :~~...: ":,~:, r:1.~:.f~"~" ... ....1.. . . ...... .' . ..... .. .~. . ~. , .: ..~-::. f:~i:.h;;..:J..;(. .~.R:..'~ .....:.,'!.~/~\.~;,,~... .~. '. . .....,... . ..' .. ... ~ . :. .... . <":.4 . ."1' '.:1....: '.~.-;.' ~',,~;,~ '. ~,,". t~~.\.,')~.;:.~~.....J.:;~'" .' . ." - ...,. '.' .'~" .. r'. 'J '. ........ ..... ':'.." . , . :.;~.:.,t.'';''~r;,'.' .,.;.,~. ..: .'~'~r;' '. : ".~ ":;~.'i.;{~~'~ .:.~"t... 'f,: ..~.: :.:;..,;.:~ ~..;- '.-' . - .... .-' . .........~, '.:.' .(ff~".t;.;..~..:.:.' . ....p... l.: ,.,.:.........tt:-";1,... .' .... . . ..l,'. ..,.....".. "'''\'. J ,... .. ..... '.....:. '. .....'i .~)~:",,:,,~"'~;'.r..'Y' "~;(~. '~':":';"~t'i.1.t,rr~. .'<~"":. :~-., ':,,'i;'" ........,.;-t:.:'...~..!J. ~_~,.I~. .\~.~'. 'f'-~;';'.t'ii".-:'-.~ .. . "1..,,........ . . ....-::::l... , ....:.~.~~.a,;:l.::.:~ ,,:~'''\' il't;\...,.~ ~..";',~,;.;:::.f.", N'.' . ,~..,,7:.-;;'....-.:f...7:~ ,.'4.. .,os'. .~';#l.'1." .. . . ",~:.,,~~.S..~'~~"'. .1.Ij-~:t.~i..;;l~!~~:';,,;;' ~ .'.~ ,~'.. 1. ,/,..1,,,,, .' ~,,,,:". '!;';:p.' ...... ,...;,~"...".',.::\. ....'--...'..,....,. ~~I,..'..,...... ,,~;""1';- '. ........ .' ,.lit" .:J.' ',':f.'~"'" . ':.~~:." " .,.' ;0 ,....',1\.~l;o....l;;~J.!.. ,," .A.I." 'I~'..I..~.-'-.Jt...",., "~"" "'" f-,'~' .r'. r~,"..'i'.. . "i""'.' .'.l:;"'~", ... . .. ...,~, ...~.!.::. '.'~' ..... . .... :',.~'''',''':')"''''~' ."l'~';"~'''f .t:'!":"!,~"". ~'. '.,:J..l:."f.;1r~:~~,Uillip1 ..~:-:l;. ,,~i~~l.'!'.' ..... ..... - .~;,;;.1."'I~~..:;O.....~:. ~""'~r ....t~.' or.,...."', ..",.,,'~r.. ..... ." .' I .:to!"';.~'T!'" "'l' "" ~ ...... : )~~.~ , , ....-A. ',' .'''' ....f1:~ .i""~~ ;"_ ":,,r..:r:~,\',..c..~,., ~.~"".'A' ..~II":'o~..,- .,.. '"'-C ..' ....~ " '~"Ai "\'!l',.' ::~\i .... - . l~". , ....!i'i... .~'I ~ ". '. .': ,',:~:?t~~~ 'i!~ .1.. - '.'1'.;)-1.: ,'., ., ': -,- ..,'.r'_ ...~ ,'. . ....,..:-. ..... '. " 1~' .,...., :},.~UII fl. ,,.,, "I' ~ 10 IHYU'~AJIOH cOW'\uu . . .--" ,/ ' --. ..~t 1. ......." ...._-~ ""-. .. 1-' .---.,.. '"--.' ,') _4".__.... :'" -..,- AMERICAN MOTORISTS INSURANCE COMPANY AMENDED ElECLARATIONS p~1 Auto Policy AGENT/BROKER COpy This Amended Oed'roUons replaces .11 prior decl.r.tions .rrlCllve th. dal' and tlm. ShOWl. lor Ih. ~h.nge, Anach IL LO your policy, Ally premium .dlullmenl will be made separ.lely, BILL TO FOLLOW ...---.. ..,- -. CHANGE ENDORSEHENT = Elfec:tl..d.l. 03/08/91 Elf, tlm.12:01 A.M. Policy lumber HB 542 010 Policy from 10/21/90 period LO 04/21/91 12:01 A,H. stand.rd time Ag.nl/Brokor 32-5850 DAVIS INS AGENCY INC 208 EAST CHURCH STREET LOCK HAVEN PA 11745 PAGE 1 OF 1 NAMED INSURED AND MAILINe ADDRESS VICKI HtrrHLER RDIJ1 BOX 358 LOCK HAVEN PA 11745 Insured's _upaUon SECRETARY The .ULO(S) or Italler(s) dllCribed In this policy are principally g...gl<l .tth. .boII. address unless oth.rwise stated, DESCRIPTION OF AUTO(S) OR TRAlLER(S) Insp, 1 89 DODGE DAYTONA 1B3XG24K2KG157588 Sym, T erriLOry N 053 053 Ow code 8121104 Credits Credits: 1. Two er mer. .utos 3 . ComOKl car 5 . Coed LLudtnl 7 - A<cIdtnt pm:entlon courso 0 . MtIo1hol1 dM' disc.>unl 2 . OrMr It.inlne . . Coed pad.. living 6 . Bumper discount A . P...... ristnlnt discount C . MII-IocIc brako discount COVERACES .!. LIMITS OF LIAl!ILITY - Covorag. I: provided only where" premium or limit of liability Is shown for the cover'lo. AULO 1 AULO AuLO AULO $ 100,000 A. L1.billty . each occident B, Medlc.1 P.yments . each penon C, Uninsured MolOrists Bodily Injury' uch acddent $ 35,000 Property Olmlge . uch accident O. Olmage LO your AULO . Ac1UII Cash Vllu. (ACV) minus dedUC1lble shown " Collision Iou $ 250 2, Other Ihln collblon loss $ . 50 Towing and Llbor Costs per dbablemenL TOTAL PREMIUM EACH AUTO AULO 1 Term premium $ 60.00 $ 9.00 $ 125.00 $ 59.00 $ 70.00 $ 323.00 COY' erlges A B Cl C2 01 02 Towing Endts TOTAL AULO Term premium AULO Term premium AULO Term premium See reverse (or endorsemenu anached III this policy, Premium for thll chlnge $ NEW POLICY TOTAL $ 46.00 323.00 COLLISION COVERAGE PROVIDED BY YOUR POLICY EXTENDS TO RENTAL VEHICLES SUBJECT TO 1iIE CONDITIONS AND LIMITATIONS IN YOUR POLICY SUCH AS COVERED TERRITORY, LENGTH OF TIME OR ANY DEDUCTIBLES. Safe Driver Lilt. Points ar, determined by the rula 01 the saf. dmo" plan or ment rat. pfln in your S~l', In molt sUtes twO 112. point ."tnet crlit. a -"'- I I COMP~NY USE OM y KEMPER PAYMENT PLAN ACCOUNT NUMBER "Wl1lltld 1u.9OI 010M " . . Lou Ply" 1 MELLON BANK PO BOX 6070 2731 CAROLEAN STATE COLLEGE PA 16801 fndo<semenlS made part orchil policy. Number Edlllon nlle PP0151 07-90 AMENDMENT OF POLICY PROVISIONS - PA PP0551 07-90 FIRST PARTY BENEFITS COVERAGE - PA COHBINATION FIRST PARTY BENEFITS MAXIMUM TOTAL $ 177,500 FUNERAL $ 2,500 ACC DEATH $ 25,000 PP0419 07-90 UNDERINSURED MOTORISTS COV. (STACKED) UNINSURED MOTORISTS COV. (STACKED) PERSONAL AUTO POLICY PP0423 PP0001 07-90 12-89 : '. ~ .. . .. E><p1'U 03/95 ..- . " -..... Effec:lM Term AuIO premlum 1 $ 70.00 ", ~. f.:,; i' tJ 6 1994 ""-,..\ . N .... naTlllnil. . . InsURilnce l:lIlIlParues . I ( Lumbermens Mutual CUualty Company. American Motorist. Insurance Company American Manufacturers Mutual Insurance Company · American Protection Insurance Company · Kemper Risk Management Services HllllldeCo'po'IIeCente,5001 Loulle D,lve.5ulte 102. Mechlnlclbu'8. PA 17055.6913 . 717/691.7460 . 800/437.3357 . FAX 717/691.7474 SCHMIDT AND RONCA PC CHARLES E. SCHMIDT, JR 209 STATE STREET HARRISBURG PA 17101 08/28/95 CLAIM I: 210 AM 001927 N 210 DLC INSURED: VICKI MUTHLER DATE OF LOSS: 12/23/90 OTHER: CLAIMANT: VICKI MUTHLER DEAR MR. SCHMIDT: WE ARE WRITING TO YOU AT THIS TIME TO ADVISE THAT WE HAVE WAIVED OUR SUBROGATION RIGHTS REGARDING MR. PERRY. BASED ON OUR EVALUATION OF HER INJURY, IT APPEARS THAT SHE WAS ADEQUATELY COMPENSATED BY HER RECOVERY FROM STATE FARM FIRE AND CASUALTY COMPANY. WE DO NOT VIEW THIS AS A CASE OF "UNDERINSURANCE." PLEASE LET ME KNOW WHAT YOUR CLIENT IS LOOKING FOR. SINCERELY, - tf ('j1.C}\,VO ~- AMERICAN MOTORISTS INSURANCE DEBORAH L. CHRONISTER CLAIM DEPARTMENT 717/691-7460 F941T .,.,;"Ot.,.,...,.""'."'*"....""':"~';f:{:"'~:'<-'.(\..{....-. . :. ,. '. ..::...i;~~;~PD~~~..~; I ' ""' 1.;,\-,;,."", j II " ";"",1, "'';)t:r,'''t'~~~'' t" _~""'I'h"_" .f;.-;.."'...;,.ji<::-..~..:"'O":'~.~". ';~:~r-,!~;r '-l'" ~, ~'d '. .-....:.'... - ,Ie. ,:,t..,~; Y.lo.~ ..~~~.....,., :....t:>:-e::-#j)fl'f'';t'f'.;.."..,.;~, .\ .~ . c . (. . Schmidt and Ronca PC 109 State Street Hanlsburs. PennsylvAllIA 17101 7t7/131.6300 FAX 717/131-6467 Attorneys and Counselors at Law August 30, 1995 Ms. Deborah L. Chronister Claim Department KEMPER NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANIES Hillside corporate Center 5001 Louise Drivo, suite 102 Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 ReI vioki Huthler Claim No. 210 AM 001'27 N 210 PCJ Date of LOSSI 12/23/90 Dear Ms. Chronister: Thank you for releasing your sUbrogation rights in reference to Vicki Muthler. We are looking for another $25,000. If you cannot do ,it, would you please send this matter to counsel so arbitrators can be appointed, and we can move the case along. Thank you. Very truly yours, SCHMID~ ~bNCA, V.(t:.: ' I Charles E. Schmi t, Jr. Attorney at Law cES/mq cc: Ms. Vicki Muthler VDI.ICA.'1'IOII I, CHARLES E. SCHMIDT, JR., verity that I am attorney ot record tor the Petitioner, and that the toreqoinq document contains no facts within the knowledqe of the Petitioner, but rather, is based upon the record or facts solely within the knowledge ot the attorney; and, for that reason, I make this Verification on Petitioner's behalf. I verify that the facts contained in the foreqoinq document are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. I understand that intentional false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.s.~.__S4904 relatinq to u.ovorn t.,uiticati... to .UthOritio..~ ~ s ON~~ PIC' ~~I By: Charles E. Schmidt, Jr. I.D. No. 19198 209 state street Harrisburg, PA 17101 (717) 232-6300 Attorney for Petitioner ;<l "" ~, i; . I . en ~....') .. ?i~ en ~ :c 8z a.. .,<: g~ co 59 ~ <...& ~ "" u CI:{E N") L.J UJ 0 eLl C ::: ~ '"'>) ... In ":J - c;'l u ~ ~~.~\ \...j "t c:t. .~ ~d "'::::- .!1. rr ... '1 4 ~ . "':-;-":"~':;~~'":'f;;a..-.:t...~~-i:!.'!':.f'-,:L-:':C-'-'~':. --< __~ 'w::~~_'~,:<.~1'4~.'!~\<~~.~~rl"~TfR f~~~'.. SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NO: 199~-07197 P COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA: COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND MUTHLER VICKI VS. KEMPER NATIONAL INS COMPANIES KRISTIN D. MERTZ , Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to law, says, the within RULE was served upon KEMPER NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANIES the defendant, at 1227:00 HOURS, on the ~ day of December 19~ at HILLSIDE CORPORATE CENTER 5001 LOUISE DRIVE SUITE 102 MECHANICSBURG, PA 17055 ,CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania, by handing to PENNI SCHADLE, CLERICAL SUPERVISOR a true and attested copy of the RULE together with PETITION TO COMPEL ARBITRATION and at the same time directing Her attention to the contents thereof. , Sheriff's Costs: Docketing Service Affidavit Surcharge 18.00 6.72 .00 2.00 So answers: _. .,;/ ~ ./// ~ (~~~ fl. I C:".u::.ne. ~ er::. $2&. '/2 SCHMIDT AND 12128/1995 by RONCA /~A ,;g,O. K ~~ epu y e :t / Sworn and subscribed to before me this 5r!! day off}.....1 19 11. A. D. n. 0 n.~N'd . ~ t'ro(h~ai:+; , " IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA VICKI MUTHLER. No. 95-7197 PETITIONER, v. KEMPER NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANIES civil Action - Law RESPONDENT. ANSIfBR TO PETITION TO COMPEL ARBITRATION 1. Admitted. 2. Admitted. 3. Admitted. 4. Denied. It is specifically denied that at the time of the aforesaid motor vehicle accident, John J. Perry, was the operator of an underinsured motor vehicle. On the contrary, it is averred that John J. Perry was adequately insured given the Petitioner's injuries and damages. 5. Admitted. 6. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth or veracity of the allegations contained in paragraph 6 of Plaintiff's complaint and same are denied and strict proof thereof demanded. 7. Admitted. 8. Admitted. 9. Admitted. 10. Admitted. 11. Respondent has appointed on its behalf Donald Dorer who has agreed to act as an arbitrator. ... GRIFFITH, STRICKLER, LERMAN, SOLYMOS & CALKINS BYI '6C-edO,~ ROB RT A. LERMAN supreme Court 1.0. No. 07490 BYI~ YY1/~ ANN MARGARET GRAB Supreme Court 1.0. No. 55986 Attorneye for Defendant 110 South Northern way York, PA 17402 Telephone No. (717) 757-7602 muth1er.ans ... VBRIPICATION I, Ann Margaret Grab, Raquire, do hereby verity that I am the attorney ot record tor the pleading party herein, and that the tacta aet torth in the toregoing pleading are true to the beat ot my knowledge, intormation and beliet, upon intormation aupplied. I underatand that talae atatementa made herein are made aubject to the penaltiea ot 18 Pa.C.S.A. 5 4904 relating to unaworn talaification to authoritiea. GRIFFITH, STRICKLER, LERMAN, SOLYMOS & CALKINS Dated:~o( BY: ('~ JrI M- Ann Margaret Grab, Esquire supreme Court 1.0. #55986 110 South Northern way York, Pennsylvania 17402 (717) 757-7602 : ',.:' 'i.'''~:'.~~' " .- t' .~"~'fi~'~W,,::.:.'~f:'>.~~"i:.t;\>j.~~.<~~~tj#:,.'f.;.?,;&.J,jrH\j,-~''',~~~,t '" ";' ,!_~ . "~,..- CBRTIFICATB OF SBRVICB I Hereby certify that I have served a copy of Defendant's Answer to petition to Compel Arbitration on the attorneys of record listed below this 18th day of January, 1996 by U.S. Mail, postage prepaid. Charles B.scmidt, Jr., Esq. 209 State Street Harrisburg, PA 17101 GRIFFITH, STRICKLER, LBRMAN, SOLYMOS & CALKINS BY'UJ uL ROBBRT A. LBRMAN supreme Court 1.0. No. 07490 ~ rn ~t BY, ANN MARGARET GRAB Supreme Court 1.0. No. 55986 Attorneys for Defendant 110 South Northern Way York, PA 17402 Telephone No. (717) 757-7602 . muth1er.ans ....;...,.~2iJ.~;}f:,~i...: '.".,j,.,~~.;..:.:;~~ ~~::~..c.:~ ~ 1__'*-'1__ ~ N is 03 c.; t:- ~Q :::l.... g~ U-~ ..'~ U....-~ '., "- rc");:i ~. S(.j .' ~ cC N cc;g ::t b~ ..: rn ..., ~ 15 \D 0"\ ......~::;.,~\iW ' Schmidt and Ronca PC 1"__ ....,....... r-,ew.... ".., "'-'-- -. 71"111"_ ~. -."-. ~-.'101 A.....,. ... c.....e.n at LA. VICKI MUTHLER, Petitioner IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA No. 95-7197 -vs- KEMPER NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANIES, CIVIL ACTION - LAW Respondent PRAECIPE POR DISCONTlNUANCB TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Please discontinue the above captioned action, mark it settled with prejudice and issue a certificate of Settlement. 'Thank you. By: s Charles E. Schmidt, Jr. Attorney at Law 209 State street Harrisburq, PA 17101 Attorney I.D. #19198 (717) 232-6300 Attorney for the Plaintiff -,.. Dated: ~~\r~S', (~1~ , o :"11 '0 >- .. a: l'V r.o j;J: . .. '~ ~i C"'l '~...1: ~r '- .'}?j ,. ,>- , \.0 ~ '(~ ~~.- N 1; Ei2". ..~ _I ,tit .' ::.J ~lo.. I':" -) L'. ,n :.5 0 C'1 D ~ ----: .-' ~ ~~