HomeMy WebLinkAbout02-4528THIS IS AN ARBITRATION CASE
MORRIS &ADELMAN, P.C. ~NOTR~UIR~
BY: JAMES W. ADELMAN, ESQUIRE ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF
IDENTIFICATION #02604
P.O. BOX 30477 Atlantic States Insurance Cos.
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103-8477
'(215) 568-5621
Atlantic States Insurance Cos.
'1195 River Road
Marietta PA 17547
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
CIVIL DIVISION
vs. :
Rillo's Inc. :
50 Pine St :
Carlisle PA 17013 : NO. (~a -/~
COMPLAINT
CIVIL ACTION
NOTICE
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action
within twenty (20) days after this complaint and notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney
and filing in writing with the court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail
to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the court without further notice for
any money claimed in the complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the plaintiff. You may lose money or property
or other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT
AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE TH E OFFICE BET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL
HELR
Name
Address
City
CUMBEI~I.ARD COUN'J:Y BAR ASSOCIATION
2 LIB]~I~ AVENUE
CAELISLE, PA 17013
Tel. No. (717) 249-3166
1. Plaintiff is Atlantic States Insurance Cos., an insurance
company duly authorized to issue insurance policies in the Commonwealth
of Pennsylvania.
2. Defendant is Rillo's Inc.
3. Plaintiff, at the request of Defendant, or Defendant's
authorized agent, issued a Worker's Compensation and Employer's
Liability policy naming Defendant as the insured. A true and correct
copy of the policy is attached hereto, incorporated herein and marked
Exhibit "A".
rules, rates and
-Compensation Bureau
premium is subject
4. The total annual estimated earned premium for the insurance
year set out in the policy was $7,671.00. In accordance with the
classifications of the Pennsylvania Worker's
(PWCB) and the premium endorsement, the estimated
to increase or decrease in accordance with the
actual payroll figures established by the insured but not available at
time of policy issuance.
5. Plaintiff was pezmitted to audit the true and correct books
and records of the Defendant.
v.e~la~CATION
Daniel J. Wagner, CPA
Vice President & Treasurer
and that the facts set forth in the foregoing COMPLA~NT
, states that he is
of Atlantic States Insurance ComDanv
are true and correct to the best of
his k-nowledqe, information and belief, and that this
statement is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S.A. 4904
relating to u~sworn falsification to authorities.
Dated:
August 29, 2002
Daniel J. Wggner,C~
'ACORD~ COMMERCIAL INSURANCE APPLICATION
-- APPLICANT INFORMATION SECTION
PRODUCER [ ~HcO,~o, ~,1: ( 7 Z 7) 241~ 599 ~ NAIC COOS:
FAX (717)241-6366 Donegal Mutual /nsurance
.Hopcraft, Hockley & 0'Donne]] Ins Agency
~, PA 17325
AGENCY CUSTOMER iD
0000606S
STATUS O~ SUBMISSION
APPLICANT INFORMATION
DATE
02/15/2000
INDICATE SECllONB AI'i'ACHED I J EQUIPMENT FLOATER
PROPERTY ~ INSTALLATION~IUJLDERS RISK
GLASS AND SIGN ELECTRONIC DATA PROC
ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE/ COMMERCIAL
VALUABLE PAPERS GENERAL LIABILITY
CRIME/MISCELLANEOUS CRIME BUSINESS AUTO
TRANSPORTATION/
MOTOR TRUCK CARGO TRUCKERS/MOTOR CARRIER
POLICY INFORMATION
ENTER THIS INFORMATION WHEN C OMM(~N DATES AND TERMS APPLY TO SEVERAL LINES. OR FOR MONOLINE POLICIES.
JiOIKEDTS'L
Zl, /, Zl, l, / AGENDYS,LL
INDIVIDUAL ~ CORPORATION ~ SUBCH~PTER'~"CGRPORAT,ON
PARTNERSHIP ) ) JOINT VENllJRE t I LIMITED CORPOP~TION
PH NE
iGARAGE AND DEN.ERS
VEHICLE SCHEDULE
BOILER & MACHINERY
WORKERS COMPENSATION
._~ UMBRELLA
PREMISES INFORMATION
SO Pine Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
~ m l N°T FOR PROFITORGANIZATION BUBI~sI~'ARTE D
IACCOUNTING RECORDS CONTACT I (~,%. ~'):
LOC# BLD# 50 PINE ST~TREBT' CITY, COUNTY. STATE, ZIP+4
00001 00001
/ / PA 17013
PA 17013
NATURE OPBUSINESSIDESCRIPTION OF OPERATIONS
RESTAURANT
URANT
GENERAL INFORMATION
EXPLAIN ALL "YES" RESPONSES
1. ISTHEAPPL[CANTASUSSI IARYOFAN THER ENTiTY OR DOES
THE APPLICANT HAVE ANY ~USS OIARIE ~)J
2 IS A FORMAL SAFETY PROGRAM IN OPERATION?
3 ANY EXPOSURE TO FLAMMABLES, EXPLOSIVES, CHEMICALS?
4 ANY CAI'ASTROPHE EXPOSURE?
5. ANY OTHER INSURANCE WITH THIS COMPANY OR BEING SUBMITFED?
S. DA~RYI~NgLTICH~ O~ ~ i Co O~ 5~yR~REs ~D ~N%~AE~D~ 5gANaCLE~L ~ ~ 8R NON-R~[NEWeD
REMARKS
YES NO I EXPLAIN ALL 'YES' RESPONSES
x MOLES~2T,ON A.LEGA~b%, D,~M~NAT,ON O~ NEQU~NT
7 ANYPA TLOSSESOR IMSR TINGTOSEX ALASU OR
~ ~X)an--'" bY ~Y e~pli~nt for .o.~ ins~ Failure to ~se
lyES NO
ANY PERSON WHO KNOWINGLY AND WITH INTENT TO DEFRAUD ANY INSURANCE COMPANY OR ANOTHER
PERSON FILES AN APPLICATION FOR INSURANCE OR STATEMENT OF CLAIM CONTAINING ANY MATERIALLY
FALSE INFORMATION, OR CONCEALS FOR THE PURPOSE OF MISLEADING, INFORMATION CONCERNING
~,N,~Y ,F_A~C..T_ M_A.T_E_R_IA_L_ _T.H.E_R_ETO, COMMITS A FRAUDULENT INSURANCE ACT WHICH IS A CRIME AND
u~a:~./~/tii: H~(JN TO CRIMINAL AND [NY: SUBSTANTIAL] CIV L PENA~
(8197~ ' PLEASE OOMPLETEREVERSESIDE -' Jk~'~'~'D~Cj~ R p ORA T,O N 19 9 3
FAX (717)241-6366
~opcraft, Hockley & O'Donnell Ins Agency
P. O, Box 116
1 Valley Street, Suite 101
Settysburg, PA 17325
CODE:
AGENCYC
00006065
SUBCODE:
COMPANY UNDERWRITER
Donegal Mutual Insurance
APPLICANT
NAME
MAILING
ADDRESS 50 Pine Street
~JP¢o~.~ Carlisle, PA 17013
Cumberland
YRS IN BUS SIC ~l INDIVIDUAL [__.,X I-C O~P 0 RA~OIO; [ ~ OTHER:
PARTNERSHIP I I SUBCHAPTER "S" CORP
FEDERAL EMPLOYER ID NUMBER NCCl iD NUMBER TOTHER RATING BUREAU D NUMBER --
QUOTE I ISSUE POLICY i BILLING PLAN ~, PAYMENTPLAN
BOUNO(GivsdaleanU/oraltachcopy) 02/11/2000 AGENCYBILL --ANNUAL OTHER: i ! AT~XPIRATION MONTHLY
ASSIGNED RISK(Attach ACORD 133) DIRECTEILL I i SEMI-ANNUAL ~ ~----1[ SEMI*ANNUAL OTHER:
QUARTERLY i % DOWN: ! J QUARTERLY
STREET, CITY, COUNTY, STATE, ZIP CODE
00002 $0 PTNE ST.
CARLISLE, PA 17013
PROPOSED EFF DATE (MM/DD/YY)
PART 1
CJMPENEAT1ON (States) PART 2 - EMPLOYER'S LIABILITY
PA $ 100,000 EACH ACCIDENT
$ S00,000 DISEASE-POLICY LIMIT
$ 100,000 DISEASE-EACH EMPLOYEE
DiVl b-E-N5 PL'Ei~/SA~i=~'~A6 OF ...... l ADDITIONAL COMPANY INFORMATION
MEDICAL
INDEMNITY
COM-
STATE i LOC i C 'bASS CODE i PANY CATEGORIES, DUTIES, CLASSIFICATiONS
I I USE
.... -]-- .... --~----- RESTAURANT
Z~'Z~ CX:)O
#OF
IPLOYEES!
~ ~2.4900
ESTIMATED
ANNUAL PREMIUM
[. FACTOR FACTORED PREMIUM
INCREASED LIMITS $
EXPERIENCE MODIFICATION ; · · 9 S ~
MINIMUM PREMIUM $ 38~ i 00' 6E~omr P~'U~ $ ' 6,801 · 00 TO'rAL EST ANNUAL PREMIUM ~ ;3 ....~,~-1~-.~0
PARTNERS, OFF)CERS. RELA33VES TO BE INCLUDED OR EXCLUDED, (Remuneration o be included must be par1 of rating in onna on sec on
.~ 2~ONS_~ ~ .S~HIp % DUTIES INCIEXC CLASS CODE REMUNERATION
................. ~- ....
CLAIMS AMOUNT PAID RESERVE
EXPLAIN ALL 'YES' RESPONSES
1. DOES APPLICANT OWN, OPERATE OR LEASE AIRC R^ F~'/WATER C RAFT?
, DO/HAVE PAST, PRESENT OR DISCONTINUED OPERATIONS JNVOLVE(D)
STOKING, TREATING, DISCHARGING, APPLYING, DISPOSING. OR TRANSPORTING
OF HAZARDOUS MATER AL? (e g. andfl s, wastes, fuel ~anks, etc)
3. ANY WORK PERFORMED UNDERGROUND OR AEOVE 15 FEET?
4 ANY W~RK PERFORMED ON BARGES, VESSELS, DOCKS, BRIDGE OVER WATER?
5. IS APPLICANT ENGAGED IN ANY OTHER TYPE OF EiUSINESS?
6. ARE SUB-CONTRACTORS USED?
7. ANY WORK SUBLET W~TNOUT CERTIFICATES OF INS.?
8 IS A FORMAL SAFETY PROGRAM IN OPERATION?
EXPLAIN ALL "YES" RESPONSES
X 15. ARE ATHLETIC TEAMS SPONSORED?
16. ARE PHYSICALS REQUIRED AFTER OFFERS OF EMPLOYMENT ARE MADE?
CONTACTINFORMA~ON
10. ANY EMP~ ")YEES UNDER 16 OR OVER 60 YEARS OF AGE'~ j X I SPEC31ON NAME
12. IS THERE ANY VOLUNTEER OR DONATED LABOR? ...... J [ ~ RECORD NAME
APPUCANT*S SIGNATURE
PRODUCER'S SIGNATURE
STATEMENT OF ACCOUNT
October 22, 2001
Rillo's, inc.
50 Pine Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Policy No.: WCA 0025920-00
02/11/00.to 02/11/01
Deposit Premium
Audit, 03/01
Audit Revision, 06/01
Total Due:
Payments
7,671.00
3,479.00
8~.00
[ 12,045.00]
(1,911.50)
(1,151.90)
(1,151.90)
(1,151.90)
(1,151.90)
(1,151.9~)
04/14/00
05/12/00
06/08/00
08/16/00
10/18/00
12/11/00
Total Paid
GRAND TOTAL DUE ATLANTIC STATES
[ (7,671.00~
L 4,374.00j
HOME OFFICE COPY
06/27
-DB
* A UD I T INFORMATION PAGE*
0025920 00
RILLO'S INC
50 PINE ST
CARLISLk PA
EFFECTIVE
02/11/00
12:01 AM
o2/ii/oi
ATLANTIC STATES INS. CO.
000431300
17013
HOPCRAFT HOCKLEY & O'DONNELL
INSURANCE AGENCY
P 0 BOX 116
CARLISLE PA 017013
TELEPHONE 717/241-5995
04
NO. BASIS PREMIUM
~/ii/00 TO 07/23/00
~STAURANT
[PERIENCE MOD.
;HEDULE MOD. CREDIT
'/23/00 TO 02/ii/0i
:STAURANT
[PERIENCE MOD.
;HEDULE MOD. CREDIT
{PLOYER ASSESSMENT
975
9898
9887
975
9898
9887
$198,901.
$402,148.
0938
EXPERIENCE RATING MODIFICATION FACTOR. (9898)
PREMIUM DISCOUNT (0063)
LOSS CONSTANT (0032)
EXPENSE CONSTANT (0900)
OTHER.
2.76
.951
25%
2.92
.961
25%
.0375
$ 5,490.00
- 269.00
-1,305.00
11,743.00
- 458.00
-2,821.00
304.00
- 804.00
140.00
EARNED PREMIUM I $i2,020.00
~ LESS DEPOSIT PREMIUM I $ 7,646.00
TOTAL BALANCE DUE: COMPANY $ 4,374.00
ADDITIONAL PREMIUMS DUE COMPANY ARE PAYABLE UPON RECEIPT OF THIS PREMIUM
[USTMENT ENDORSEMENT.
RETURN PREMIUMS DUE INSURED ARE PAYABLE PROVIDED THE ESTIMATED DEPOSIT
]MI UMS ARE PAID IN FULL. JLB
DONEGAL COMPANIES
FEDERAL ID. ~-.~-~ ~v~
AUDIT SUMMARY
BATCH NUMBER INFACS CODE INVOICE NUMBER INS Code
Policy Number
Policy Name
Company Name
/ %~....~.~ Contact's Name
Street Address
c~
AJH state
Policy Date
Reporting Date
Auditor
Completion Date
WCA 0025920 00L3
WORKERS COMP ATLANTIC
Rillos Inc
Joe Rillo
50 Pine St
Carlisle
PA
17013
02111/2000 To 02/1112001
02/11/2000 To 07/23/2000
Joe Gilmartin
0211512001
L 02/11100 ~ 07123100 T~T
L# STATE LOCATION CODE CLASS AL ADJUSTED PREVIOUS DELTA
~~1101 TOTAL BASIS
1 PA Carlisle ~estaurant 198,901 60%049.00 487,368.00 400,000 21.84'
SPLIT 1 TOTAL SPLIT 2 TOTAL
AUDIT TOTAL ADJUSTED TOTAL TOTAL BASIS TOTAL DELTA
[ 1'8"°1'0°11 I oo,o
Description of Operations
THIS IS A ITALIAN STYLE RESTAURANT SERVING ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGES AND FINE DINING~ BOTH OFFICERS ARE INVOLVED IN THE BUSINESS. THE
MOTHER TAKES CARE OF CLEANING THE LINENS PRrMARILY ANOTHER SON IS IN MANAGEMENT BUT IS NOT AN OFFICER IN THE CORPORATION.
Home OJ~f ice, 11 PajillDrive, Marietta, Penn~. lvania 17457 (71 7) 426-1904)
DONEGAL COMPANIES
FEDERAL ID. ~.,.,
SUMMARY DETAIL
BATCH NUMBER INFACS CODE INVOICE NUMBER INS Code
4-0vov~9 ]HI .~00~,0038~ II 4848 I ~ I
Po,ioyNumberWCA 0025920 00
Policy Name WORKERS COMP ATLANTIC
Company Name Rillos Inc
Street Address 50 Pine St
city Carlisle
State PA
Zip '17013
Policy Date 02/11/2000 To 02/11/2001
Reporting Date 02111/2000 To 07~23~2000
Auditor Joe Gilmartin
Completion Date 02/1 $/2001
Phone 243-6141
N# L# Code Title Name/Group Total Adjusted Description Function
~ I 975 Restaurant Staff 584,655.00 584,655,00 COOKS, SERVERS, SARTENDE Employee
2 1 975 Restaurant Staff 0,00 (128,487.00) EXCESS TIPS Employee
3 1 975 President Joseph Rffio 2,200.00 6,900.00 RESTAURANT MANAGEMENT Officer
4 1 975 President Joseph Rillo 3,000.00 8,700,00 RESTAURANT MANAGEMENT Of~cer
5 I 975 Secretary Magdstene Rillo 4,721.00 6,900.00 MANAGEMENT CLEANING OF L Officer
6 1 975 Secretary Magdalene Rillo 6,473.00 8,700.0(~ MANAGEMENT CLEANING OF LI Officer
Source of Data Verification Was There
IINSURED ...,._a [YTD PAYROLL ] I
I .J [PAYROLL SPLITS J I
Legal Entity Subcontractor Amount Gross Overtime
Ic°r"°rat'°' J l $ol I
a c s
Homer)J.! ~ce, 11 P,4JILL DR[FE,,t4.4ltlETTA..OENNSYLV.4~ViA 17547 (717) 426-1904
Period Totals
0?J11/2000 To 07/23/2000 251,408
07/23/2000 To 02/11/2001 349,605
To
To
To
To
TOTAL 601,013
DONEGAL COMPANIES
Class Description
Summary
BATCH NUMBER INFACS CODE INVOICE NUMBER INS Code
[ 4-0~;0~;19 ]1EI200~0038511 !648 II 4 I
NAME # TITLE NAME/GROUP
I Restaurant Staff
.olicyNum~,WCA 0025920 00
Policy NameWORKERS COMP ATLA
Company NameRiJlos Jrtc
Street AddressS0 Pine St
CityCarlisle
State PA
zip17013
Policy Date02/1112000 To 02/11/2001
Reporting Date02/11/2000 To 07~23~2000
Auditor Joe GiJmartin
Completion Date02/1512001
DESCRIPTION OF DUTIES
COOKS, SERVERS, BARTENDERS, KITCHEN
HELP, MANAGERS
2 Restaurant Staff EXCESS TIPS
3 President Joseph Rillo RESTAURANT MANAGEMENT
4 President Joseph Rillo RESTAURANT MANAGEMENT
5 Secretary Magdalene Rillo MANAGEMENT CLEANING OF LINENS
6 Secretary Magdalene Rillo MANAGEMENT CLEANING OF LINENS
Sunday, February 18,2001
Home (3f f tc~ 11 PA JILL DRII~'E. MARIETTA, PENNSYL VANL4 17547 (71 7) 426-1904
WCA 0025920 00
02/11/2000
E200100385
Rillos Inc
01/18/2001
Quality Assurance
The function of tiffs audit is to assure that your policy has been properly undenYntten from the information
we collect through our survey process. Tliere are many occasions in wbich pre~rdtlms may be adjusted to
reflect what Donegal Companies may feel is appropriate.
If you disagree with thc results of our survey because you may feel it is ioaccurate, you should make your
position known to hffacs and tlie underwriters at Donegal Companies '
It is our intention to treat you in the most courteous and respectful manner possible. If you feel that you have
not received this level of service, it is important that you contact us so that we may address your displeasure.
We value your input and hope that you understand this process helps provide the best possible service and
coverage for you and your business as well as our other valued policyholders.
Verification
To the best of nay knowledge, this survey was conducted witli my understanding and that the information to
construct this survey was supplied by me or my representatives, either orally or by documents which pertain
to fi'ds survey. I believe my statements and docmnenls offered to the surveyor to be accurate and current and
all representations to be truthful.
Date
Home Off tee, EasternReglon 11 PA,IILL DRII/E, Aq,4R/ETT,4, PEiVNSI'L I'~4NI,4 17547 (717) 426-1904
The Widener Building -6th Floor
One South Peon Square · Philadelphia. PA 19107-3577
(215)568-2371 · FAX (215)564-4328 · www.~crb.com
ATLANTIC STATES INSURANCE CO
Pennsylvania Compensation Rating Bureau
1195 RIVER RD
PO BOX 302
MARIETTA PA 17547
RILLO'S INC
06/07/01
RE: FILE NLq~ER M 208706
POL NUM WCAO02592000
POL PER 02/11/00 - o2/11/0i
ENDOR. EFF. DATE - 07/23/00
POL. ANNIV. DATE - 07/23/00
THE ABOVE ENDORSEMENT ~AM BEEN DISAPPROVED AS NOTED BELOW. KINDLY
MAKE THE NECESSARY CORRECTIONS.
DOES NOT ACCORD WITH DATA CARD 000001
EXPERIENCE MODIFICATION INCORRECT .951 SHOULD BE .961 ~/
ANNIVERSARY RATING ACCOUNT -
FROM 07/23/00 TO 02/11/01CA/~RIER RATING VALUES IN EFFECT 07/23/00 APPLY.
IF AN ERROR IS CITED BELOW, ENDORSE IM/~EDIATELY. HOWEVER, YOU MUST
ENDORSE THE SECOND PERIOD WI~ THE CARRIER RATING VALUES AND MOD
(LF APPLICAJILE) BECOME AVAILABLE.
*INCORRECT RATE 2.63 FOR CLA~S 975 SHOULD BE 2.92
CODE 0938 EMPLOYER ASSESSNENT OMITTED. IMMEDIATE AD4USTHENT REQUIRED.
JUL 0 6 ZOO1
VERY TRULY YOURS,
POLICY REPORTING
EXTENSION 490
093 034
A COPY OF THIS LETTER MUST BE ATTACIIED TO YOUR RESPONSE.
SHERIFF'S RETURN -
CASE NO: 2002-04528 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
ATLANTIC STATES INSURANCE COS
VS
RILLO'S INC
REGULAR
DAWN KELL Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according to
says, the within COMPLAINT & NOTICE was served upon
RILLO'S INC the
DEPENDANT at 1429:00 HOURS,
at 50 PINE STREET
CARLISLE, PA 17013
JAMES ALLEN, MANAGER
on the 25th day of September, 2002
by handing to
a true and attested copy of COMPLAINT & NOTICE
together with
and at the same time directing His attention to the contents thereof.
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing 18.00
Service 3.45
Affidavit .00
Surcharge 10.00
.00
31.45
Sworn and Subscribed to before
me this ~ ~-- day of
~a~. o16~ A.D.
P~h~6tary ~
So Answers:
R. Thomas Kline
09126/2002
Deputy Sheriff
MORRIS & ADELMAN, P.C.
BY: JAMES W. ADELMAN, ESQUIRE
IDENTIFICATION ~02604
P.O. BOX 30477
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
(215) 568-5621
Atlantic States Insurance Cos.
1195 River Road
Marietta PA 17547
vs.
Rillo's Inc.
50 Pine St
Carlisle PA 17013
ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF
Atlantic States Insurance Cos.
19103-8477
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
CIVIL DIVISION
NO. 2002-04528
ORDER TO SETTLE, DISCONTINUE & END
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
Mark the above-entitled case settled, discontinued and ended
upon payment of your costs only.
So Ordered As Ab~
t~rneys For Plai/ntiff
F: \CLS INC\WORD\JWA1022 - 4