The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About96-00819 ,I' ;1 _'},' I~ " , I'; " d I' , " " , " .', ,II, " " " " L i~ 'i , , I!i! " LJ I, " " " " , , c $l - .- 3 " I_I II' , "1'1 " 'I' " " ,\ , ',1 '.,jl'.1 ,I I.' I, JI,. " " ~.- j i I, "1 1 'I I, ;' " , , , '. I .'; , ,ii' f.! , I , " 'Ii I " " '~ I,' ,I 'I, "I' ,-I q ,i " '1', " I, " ,1'1 :: I " \ ,"<j ;_~t! f:. ~l -~ "If' III "/ 1'111 " , " I I I', ' " " , "I ,I , ,I _j I 1 I , , " , "I, I' " " " ,'1 " " " " " " to"~ --' -- oJ --5 ~ " I, '1'1 I,' , ., ': , , " I 'f, " , .. , I, '" 'I " , I'i " ',), 'I' 'I "I' I' "j 'I , \' ," ,>I ,01 II, ,j I " " '.f, ,,'i iI, " , " " " , " " " , , I' ! , , " " " ) 1'1'" .'\:'1,11 ,-I' , ,t !~l 'h) " , ,'.I, , i q :/ I I, " , , , " ~- , ., , " " '" , , '-/'-, ., " 'I 'iI " I , ,I " ., " il. it) i~ ,o! , , , , ' 'I ,I 11,'.1 I' I,ll _ ~ I .' ',' " ,1/1 I , I, " I, " .'/ ,j . , 'l>' /' "~I " " , I , I 11., ( I I, ,I " lil , , I, .'j 'oj , , " d \ /1 ij"t il ,I ,I , ' , Ilfl' , , , , I' , " >i,",' I" " , ,,' ip " , ,[ oJ , , ~ J I I , i I I I I I I I' , " 01" ,I 'II ;1, , , , '" '" It', ! -I"l) , , '-'f , " )1'11 I, " .i' I I' " ,I, " 'I), " ,I ", 'I' !i , " I q" I, , ,:'1: " , .j'l " '" ., it ,I" " " '-j I I,.' "I ',J ,I , ,', I,lL '" I , ,', I, .1 ", " I ';, 'Ji , " 1, 'I i,1 ',I', , , 'I " , " , ',1 , ,I ;'1, 'I ;.\j I l"dj ,,1,- i' , '" , " , 'I " , , " " I " I': " '"I , , ,I ,I ,I " I, " , 'I )' 'I " , , " " , PI; I', ql I " I, '1[; " '__I i_,l " " " " " f, ':1./1 " , !I,' " ,,' cr " " .. , "I! '" - :') 'II " ,-.,' 1,; 'j 'I , , , il, 1 fl' ',1_'" " "'i- , " "I " ()<J I" , , ,1.1 i'd' " \' ,oj , , '.,j , ,I " ';-j, , , , 'i q I J, 'I 'I .. . ',!, " J ;1 , , , , 'I , , 0,) I, " -', " n f }il,; " " " " 'I ,] _-'-,1 . ; 'r' ;~l "t1 . ~ ,.' 1'_1~' ':'-;"1 iH '-':'11 ";;~ "i ,( " ,', " I " 'J" , '; " ll, ll,-',' </-l! 'Ii , II ,,',. " , , "_], " 'I' , " ! " ',I'!)I 'I ,'I " " ,','Ii, 'I.,' " ,1'1 . " i_I, '-1'-1'" I" "-I , \)"i' , I, " ,,'J .II , " '11 ! i I" , ,I " , 'I , , ,j ., , i , I z: , . , I' . , , , , I " ~ -' v. I I I I I I I I I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. '7 (, ~ 11 Ccv.-\:.{ 0 t.-l~..,,_ CIVIL ACTION - LAW I I I r. i" I' , I . DENNIS E. MITCHELL, tla MITCHELL RESTORATION, Plaintiff TERANCE WILSON and CAROL WILSON, Defendants NOTICE '1'01 Terance Wilson and Carol Wilson, Defendants 1312 Sadler Drive Carlisle, PA 17013 You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend agBinst the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served, br entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and f ling in writing with the Court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and jUdgment may be entered against you by the Court without further notice for any money Claimed in the Complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. , , YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FOR'l'H BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. Court Administrator 4th Fl., Cumberland County Cour.thouse Carlisle, PA 17013 J.i(c ft LI', , I I I l V q ~. I , I '1 . ' ,'I , : " : . I ,. I , I I' . 6. I.timate. 9477, 9477-A, 9477-0, 9477-E and 9477-F were approved by the detendants and the plaintiff pertormed the necessary work. 7. Exhibit "A" provides " detailed breakdown of the wOl'k pertormed, but generally the repairs involved interior repair to drywall, including painting, wallpapering and other interior preparation including replacement of carpet and a large portion of the work devoted to the replacement of the roof on the structure at 1312 Sadler orive, Carlisle, Pennsylvania as well as repair of the interior ceilings. 8. The oral contract specified that payment would be made upon completion of the various estimates attached hereto as Exhibit "A." Total cost of the estimated jobs were: 9477. . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $6,989.04 9477-A . $15,220.91 9477-0 . . . . . . . . $ 7,569.97 , 9477-E . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 1,936.72 9477-F . . . . . . . . . $ 2,738.32 Grand Total $34,454.96 9. Of this grand total, payments and credits have been made in the amount of $20,936.72 with a balance remaining of $13,518.24. 10. On or prior to August 31, 1994, plaintiff delivered all the materials called for under the contract at defendants' residence as well as completed all the necessary services included -2- in the estimated exhibits attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "A." 11. On or after August 31, 1994, plaintiff presented defendants with a final invoice entitled job no. 9477 and requested payment in the amount of $13,518.24. A true and correct copy of this invoice is attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "B." 12. Plaintiff has repeatedly demanded payment of the amount due, but defendant has wholly neglected and refused to pay the same or any part thereof. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against DefendBnts for the sum of $13,518.24 with interest from August 31, 1994 and costs. COUNT I BREACH OF CONTRACT 13. Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference the allegations set fort.h in paragraphs 1 through 12 as if the same were fully set forth herein or at length. 14. The actions of defendants as aforesaid are willful and constitute a material breach of the agreement entered into between plaintiff and defendants. 15. As a direct and proximate result of the actions of defendants as aforesaid, plaintiff has suffered and continues to suffer serious injury, including but not limited to loss of the -3- monies owed to it by defendants, loss of use of said monies, lost interest on the money and other such damages as may be discovered. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands that This Honorable Court enter judgment in its favor and against Defendants in the amount of $13,518.24, together with costs and interest. COUNT II QUANTUM MERUIT 16. Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference the allegations set forth in paragraphs 1. through 15 as if the same were fully set forth herein or at length. 17. Between April 1994 and August 1994, plaintiff performed certain work and services for defendants, consisting of purchasing materials and providing there installation in a good and workmanlike conditioned upon the property of defendants and of the specific request of defendants to repair weather related damage. 18. The unpaid work, labor and Rervices performed by plaintiff on defendants' house had a reasonable value of $13,518.24. 19. Defendants have refused to pay plaintiff for the unpaid work, labor and services performed by the plaintiff. 20. As a result of defendants refusal to make full payment to plaintiff of the reasonable value of plaintiff'S work, labor, service and materials, plaintiff has suffered serious and. -4- f"'""I ~ . " I I' ii, , I , " 'i I , , I , , d " I'J il I I " , , I , ,-1 I , " " ,.; 'I I , Ii , " , , 'ii , ~! I ,I , I ,I I , " it " , i! " ;1 'I , , I , , I , " , I 'I fl' , , ;, I " 1'1 , , " , , "I, !) '1 " ,I " , '" , , \J " , I , 'I , , 'I " , , il , ,,' I , 'I I, ,-I j' \' I, I' , , , , 'I , , /1"1 , , " I , , , '/, , , " , ", , , , , , I . " " I , "I , , J.di ;J , 'l , , :, , II ," , y , , I , , " ,'I ;j , , , " " 1'.1 , I , II , , , I' , 'I I " , , " I j' I'j , , , q' . " , I, iii I: 'I " !'j rJ 11 , , I , ,'f' I , I, " Lfl. i I ,I " '.1 il ,., '" , 1 " ,. ". MI tchell Relltorll't ion p,o, ROl( 401 Foil R t Re r I I r1, PII. I 7:11 Ii (717) 2~9~799:1 I-ROO~77:1-RIi~6 "'J'Rllr,'J'IIRP. F.R'J'rMA'J'p. Nllme I C:llro' Wllllon nllte Printed t ORIIRI9~ ,rob. t 9477 PlIse -----------------------------"-------~----------------~----------------------- . neRcrlptlon '/11 111M PPII r,ORt -------------------~--------------------~--~--7---------------________________ Arell Nllme Roof 71 '0" l( :\2 '0" l( 0'0" I Remove old roof 22.72 RQ 2~.00 ~liR,OO 2 ARphlllt RhingleR .100 Ill, (:10 yr) 22,72 RQ II~,OO 19:\1 ,20 :I Remove old roof on mllnllforrl 20,20 RQ H,OO 707,00 4 ARphlllt IIIlI nglell :100 Ill, (:10 yr) 20,'20 "Q 90,00 IR1R ,00 ~ nump I>lnll 40 r.v , .00 P.A 72~,OO 7B,OO Ii r.ut rlown rll fterR 1,00 fiRS 7~,OO B,OO Arell'rotlll, $ ~R24,20 --------------------------------~------~------,------~-----------~------------- " 'I " , I " , , Ii , , , , I, " " I I' Ii, il I" 1"'1 I, , , " I I' I' I ;, \ I r !, . " . . M'tch~11 R~RtorAtlon P.O. ROll 401 P.ARt >>~rl In, P,.. 17:116 (717) 2~q-7qq:l I-ROO-77:1-R6~6 F.STTMA'l'F. SUMMARY ---------------------------------------.-------------------------------------- ,Job , : 9477--A F.RtlmAtor :n~nniR nAt~ Printed : OR/1R/9~ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ .. CUSTOMF.R TNFORMATTON .. .. JOR STTF. TNFORMATTON .. CArol WI IRon 1:112 SAdler nriv~ CArliRle, PA (717) 245-0641 RURi ( ) ContAct: CArol 1:112 SAdler nrlve CAr II R Ie, PA Attn: CArol (717) ~45-0641 , , . '" TNSIJRANCF. TNFORMATTON .. OAR Arlj : RonAnn I ClAim' t Po I , : ned $ : , ------------------------------------------------------------------~--~-------- , , . . STRtlC:TIJRF. TOTAI.S . . Rtructure, , , , . . . $ 1267R,77 TAli ( 6,00%) , . , . , $ 17.60 , , OverheAd ( 1 0 ~ 00%) , $ 1262.27 prnf it (10, OOltO). , . , . . $ 1262,27 " , ------------ Structure Rub-TotAl $ 1!'I220.91 fltructure Rub-TotA I, . .' . . , $ 1~220.91 -----""----...- TotAl $ 1!'1220.91 " ------------ Orllnd rotll' " $' 1~220.91 I ............ , , ' , F.nd Or 'Repor't ' .......... "'........., , I, " . Mitchell ReRtor~tlon p,O, ROlC 401 F.nRt Rerlln, p~, 17:l16 ( 717) 2~9-7ljljl I -ROO-7 7 :l-R6~ I) IITRIlr.rllRF. F.IlTIMATF. Nnme t r.~rol WI I lion n~te printed t OR/IR/9~ ,'01) , : 9477--A p~&e I I ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ /I nellcrlptlon 'III tl/M PPtl e:Ollt ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Aren N~me : F.ntr~nce 6'0" lC :1'0" lC R'O" Inlltnll 1/2" drywnll-celllngR-telC- lR.OO IIPe: I . 1 ~ 20.70 tured rendy for pnlnt 2 Remove 1/2" drywn II - celllngR IR.OO II PC': 0, :l4 6,12 :I Remove/replnce 1 I ght 1.00 M/C': 40.00 40.00 4 Pnlnt 2 contn-celllng (senl ,\oPIII nt ) lR,OO IIPr. 0,47 R.46 ~ Remove wllllpllper ~,OO ROLL 1 ~,7 ~ 7R.7~ 1\ Willi prepnrntlon 1.00 HRII 20,00 20.00 7 Knng Wnl Ipnper ~,OO ROLL 22.00 110.00 Are~ Tot,II $ 2R4,O:l ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Aren Nnme : poyer I~'O" lC 10'0" X R'O" , 1,00 M/C': ~O,OO ~O.OO I~O,OO II PC': 0.47 70.~0 1.00 HRS 22.00 22.00 11,00 ROLL I ~,7~ 17:1. 2~ I. 00 HRS 22,00 22.00 11,00 ROLL 22.00 242,00 Are~ Totl\' $ ~79,7~ nrywnll minor replllrR (to Ii SF) minimum chnrge 2 Pnlnt 2 contn-ceiling (Sel\l ,\oPlllnt) :I M~lIk/cover wnllR, floorn, furniture 4 Remove w~llpnper ~ W~ll prepnrntion 1\ Wnllpnper ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Aren Nnme , powder room ~'O" x 4'0" lC R'O" , nrywn II minor repnirn (to f> !lP) I. 00 M/C': H,OO :I!i .00 minimum chllrge 2 Pnint 2 contn-cei ling (Se~1 ,\op~int) 20,00 !I PC': 0,47 9.40 :I Remove wnllpnper ~.OO ROT.l. 1 ~ .7~ 7fl. 7~ 4 Wnll prepnrntion 1.00 HR!I 22,00 22.00 IITIlIlCTIIIlF. F.IITIMATF. NAme I r.Arol WIIRon OAte Printed r OR/lR/9~ .,..,. .Iob It t 'I477uA PAge r 2 It OeRcrlptlon 111M -----------------------------~------------------------------------------------ l':o l'lt -----.~---------------------------r--------~-.------------____~________________ Uti ~ WA II pApe r ~. 00 IlOLI. AreA TotAl $ PPII 22,00 H~,l~ 110,00 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AreA Nllme : Llvlngroom 17'0" 1C 1 ~ '0" 1C R'O" OrywlIll minor replllrR (to fi SF) 1. 00 "Ill': 1:10.00 1:10.00 minimum chllrge 2 Pllint 2 cOlltR-cel I I ng (Selll R-PII Int) 2B,OO IIFl': 0,47 11'1. R~ .1 Pllint 2 COlltR-WIIIIR (Selll R- plllnt) ~12,OO IIFW O,4~ 2:10,40 4 MIIRk/cover wIIIIR, f loon'!, furniture 2,00 HilS 22.00 44,00 ~ l':leAn cllrpet with detergent-medium 2B,OO 111'1'. 0,22 ~fi, 10 AreA TotAl $ ~RO,.'~ ----------------------------------------------------------------------------~- I Arell NAme , Oining !'oom 15'0" 1C 1 ~'O" 1C R'O" . OrywlIll minor repAirR ( to fi SF) 1.00 MIl': R~,OO R~,OO minimum chllrge 2 Pllint 2 COli t R -WA I I R (Selll R- PII i nt)' 4RO,OO SFW 0,45 21fi,OO :I Plllnt 2 cOAtR-celllng (Selll R-Plllnt) 22~,OO SFl': 0.47 10~,7~ 4 MIIRk/cover Will IR, floorR, furniture 2.00 HilS 22,00 44,00 AreA Totlll $ 450,75 Arell Nllme : Kitchen 1~'0" 1C '1'0" 1C R'O" ------------------------------------------_.~---------------------------------- OrYWlI1 I minor repllirR (to fi Ill') minimum chllrge 2 Plllnt 2 cOlltR-ceiling (Selll R-Pllint) , MIIRk/cover wIIIIR, floorR, furniture 4 Remove wllllpllper ~ Willi prepllrlltion fi Will I pllpe r 7 Hllng Will IpAper horder R Pllint 2 cOlltR-WIIIIR (Selll R- pllint) 1.00 M/C: lB,OO 2,00 7,00 2,00 7.00 :19,00 120.00 SFr. HRS ROLL HilS ROLL M/C: SFW 1:10,00 0,47 22,00 1~,7~ 22,00 22,00 2,00 0.4~ 1:10,00 6.1, 4~ 44,00 110.B 44,00 154,00 7R,OO 54,00 II'rRII~'I'I1RF. P.1I'1'IMA'I'~: Nftme ~ f:ftrol WII"o" Oftte Prfnterl ~ OR/1RI9~ ,Int> /I I 'l4?7--A Pftge t .1 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ' I , Oe"criptfon ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ '111 111M PPII f:Ollt Areft 'rotftl $ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 677,70 Areft Nftme ~ Wftter t>eftter room 'I '0" lC ~'O" lC R'O" Orywft II minor repftir" (to fi liP) 1,00 M/e: fiO,OO fiO.oo minimum chftrge 2 Pftlnt 2 COfttll-Wftllll (Selll fi Plllnt) 224,00 SPW O,4~ 100,RO .1 Plllnt 2 cOlltll-cei 1 ing (Sell/ fiPIt I nt) 4~,00 SP~ 0,47 21, 1 ~ 4 MlIllk/cover Will Ill, fI oorll, furni ture 2.00 fiRS 22,00 44,00 Areft 'rot II I $ 225 ,'I~ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Arell Nllme : KI tchen hll II fi'O" lC .1' 0" lC R'O" nrYWft 1 I mi nor repllfrll (to 6 liP) 1.00 M/e: .1.0,00 .10,00 minimum chllrge 2 Plllnt 2 COli t Il-Wft 1111 (Selll fi PII f nt ) 120,00 SPW 0, 4.~ ~4,OO .1 Pllint 2 cOlltR-cef ling (Selll fiPII i n t) IR,OO SPe: 0,47 R,4fi 4 filing Will Ipllper horrler . 1,00 M/f: .10,00 .10,00 Arell 'rot II I .~ 122.4fi ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Arell Nllme : nllrllge 24'0" lC 24'0" lC 9'0" 1 Remove 112" clrYWII' , - ce I I f ngR ~76. 00 Spe: o ..14 I'I~,R4 2 Remove InllUlllt Ion hllttR from cei I ng 576.00 IIPf: 0.20 11 ~,20 .1 Remove InRUl/1t Ion hllttR from Will IR 21fi.00 SPW 0,1'1 41,04 4 f:rllft fllcecl ffherglllRR R-.10 inllultn 792.00 SP O.RII fi96,96 ~ InR t 11'1 1/2" clrYWIlII-celllngR_telC_ .~7fi, 00 IIPf: l. l.~ , fifi2,40 turecl rellcly for Plllnt fi rnRtll II 1/2" clrywlIll-WIIIIR-telCturecl 21fi,00 SPW .,. 1 ~ 24R.40 rellcly for Plllnt Areft 'rot II I $ 19~9,R4 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ~, I: , I I' 'I I I' .; ,I I I I, , , Il'l'R\JC'I'\JRP. I';1l'l'IMA'I'F. N~me I c.~rol WI IRon n~te Printed I ORIIRI9~ .tob /; I 94?7--A Pllge 4 \JIM pp\J ---------------------------------------------------------~-------------------- CORt /; neRcriptlon UII ---------------------------------------------.---------------------~---------- Arell Nllme : Fllmi Iy room ~2'0" x 1 ~'O" X R'O" nrywlIll minor replllrR (to 6 RF) 1,00 M/r'. 1.10.00 I~O,OO minimum ehllrge 2 Pllint 2 eOlltR-eel ling (Relll .\oPII I nt) 4RO,OO RFr'. 0,47 2B,fiO ~ Plllnt 2 COllt R-WIIII R (Rell I ,. llll i n t ) 2~6,OO RFW O,4~ 11 ~,20 4 MIIRk/eover wlIlIR, floors, furniture 2.00 HRR 22,00 44,00 ~ Remove Willi pllper D,OO ROLl , 1 ~,7~ 204,B 6 Will I prepllrlltlon ~,OO HRR 22,00 fifj,OO 7 Wllllpllper 22,00 ROI.l. 22,00 4R4,OO R Hllng Willi pllpe r ho rde r 1,00 M/r'. I~R,OO I~R,OO Aren 'rollll ,~ 1427.~~ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Arell Nllme : 2nd floor left fr Ilr 1~'O" x 1~'0" X R'O" 1 Remove dry cllrpet IInd plld 2 InRt1l1 I new cllrpetlng in rooms 2~,00 2~ . .1~ RYF RYP 2..B 29.00 79.1,,12 Arell 'I'otlll $ ~R,B 7:l4.~7 --------------------------------------~--------------------------------------- Arell Nllme I Office 14'0" x 10'0" x R'O" 1 Remove dry cllrpet IInd plld 2 TnRt1l1 I new cllrpeting in roomR 1~.~fi lR,fifi RYF RYF 2.B 29,00 ~77, 71 Arell Tot II I $ ~fi.~7 ~41 ,14 -----------------------------------------------------------------------------.. Arell Nllme : l.efr rellr hedroom 1~'0" x 1~'O"x 11'0" 1 Remove 1 /2" drywlIll - wIIIIR 120,00 IIFW o,n 2 Remove inRullltlon hRttR from Willi s 120.00 IIFW 0.19 ~ Crllft flleed flherglllsR R-l'l InRultn 120,00 IIF O,/lR 4 T nR t III I 1/2" drywlIl I-Will IR-texturerl 120,00 Rf'W 1. ,~ relldy for pllln! ~ Hllng Will Ipllper-mlnlmum chnrge 1,00 M/r'. '90,00 ~R.40 22.RO Rl,60 I;\R.OO 90,00 Il'rRIlr.'l'IIRP. P.1l'l'JMA'rF. NRme I CRrol Wi IRon nRte Prlnterl I OR/IR/9~ .Job /I I 9477--A Pllge I ~ ----------------------*------------------------------------------------------- , neRcrlptlon */11 I1/M ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ PPII r.ORt 6 PRint 2 c;oRtR-w/lIIR (lleRI lit p/llnt) 7 PRint 2 CO/ltR-cellfng (lleRI IItP/llnt) R MRRk/cover w/lII/l, floorR, furniture 9 Remove dry cRrpet /lnrl p/lrl 10 TnRt/l1l r.ew CRrpet Ing In roomR 4RO.00 IlFW 0.4~ 216.00 22~.00 IlFr. 0,47 10~.B 2,00 HRIl 22.00 44,00 2~. 00 IlYF 2,B ~R,B 2~,.1.1 IlYF 29,00 7:l4,~7 Arell 'rotRI $ 1~29,R7 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Are/l N/lme : H/lllwRY 16'0" x 7'0" x R'O" 1 Remove rlry cllrpet /lnrl Pllrl 2 JnRtR II new cllrpet In hili I WilY 12.44 12,44 IlYF IlYF Arell 'rot II I $ 2..1~ 29.00 :lR9.99 29,2.1 :160.76 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Arell NRme I IltlllrR fR'O" x :1'0" x 9'0" 1 Remove rlry c/lrpet /lnrl Pllrl 2 JnRt1l1 I new cllrpet/RtlllrR w/full WrRp 6.00 29.00 IlYF T,F :2.:15 ~.42 14,10 1 ~7 ,,1 R Arell 'rOtR I $ I --------------..------------------------------------,.-------------------------- I7I.2R Arell NRme . MRRter tJRthroom 10'0" lC 9 '0" x R'O" , 1 Remove I i no I eum from wooll floor 90.00 IlFF 0,72 64.RO y" '[ 2 Remove /lnll reRe t 0111 tJRRetJollrll JR,OO T,F l. 00 :lR,OO .1 Prep floor for I fnoleum-I fght 90,00 IlFF O. :17 3.1,30 4 RlltR commorle 1,00 F.A .1R.00 .1R,OO ~ Linoleum 13, .lJ IlYF 22.00 29.1,26 6 Remove InRulRtlon tJII t t 1'1 f rom Will I :<I 72,00 IlFW 0,19 13,6R 7 Remove 1/2" rlrYW/l11 - WR 11:<1 72,00 IlFW 0,32 2.1. 04 R r:r/l f t f/leerl fltJ"rglllRR R-19 InRultn RO,OO Ill" 0.6R ~4,40 9 T nR t III , 1/2" rlrYW/l1 I-Will I:<I-texturerl 72.00 IlFW 1. 2R 92,16 relllly for p/lint 10 Remove Willi p/lp"" ~,O() ROLT, 1~.H 7R,H 11 Willi prepRr/lt ion 2,00 HRIl 22.00 44,00 . . Mitchell ReRtorlltlon P.O. Jlox 401 P;IIRt Rerlln, PII, 17.'11fi (717) 2~9M799.'1 1 -1100-77 .'I-llfi~fi F.II'1' I MATF. II\JMMARV ------------------------------------------------------------------.------------ .loh 1/ 19477--0 F.RtimRtor tOennlR Ollte printert t Oll/llllq~ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ .. C:llSTOMF.R I NFORMA'I'ION .. .. .lOR lII'I'F. INFORMA'I'ION .. C:Rrol wilson 1.'112 lIRrller Orlve C:Rrllsle, PA (717) 245-0fi41 Rus: ( ) C'ontRct: C:Arol 1.'112 SlIdler Orive C:RrIIR Ie, PA Attnt C:Rrol (717) 24~-Ofi41 , .. INlIlJRANr.F. INFORMA'I'ION .. OAR Adj IRonRnnl c:1 Rim 1/ : Pol 1/ r Oed $ : ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ . . STRUC:TlJRF. '1'0'1' A I. 1'1 . ill Structure. . , . . , , $ fi2.'1fi,Il 'I'RX ( 6.00%) . " , $ 1~.4R , , . , OverheRd (10.00%) , , . . $ .'I7~,69 Profit (10,00%) . . , . , , . $ .'I7~,69 ------------ \ \ i I \ \ I I I I , I ,t I ;1 ;..i structure suh-'I'otRI $ 6999.97 . . r.ON'I'F.NTS 'I'O'l'AI.S .. C:ontentR , . . . . overheRd (10,00%). Profit (10.00%), , . . . '. $ . . . $ ,I . $' 47~.pO 47.~O 47.~0 , , , , ------------ C:ontentR Ruh-Tot~1 $ ~70. 0.0, " , lItructure Rub-Totlll. . . . . . $ 6999.97' .C:ontentR Rub-'I'otl\l . . . . . . $ ~70.00 ------------ 'I'otlll $.. '7~69.97, '\ i ~TIlII(:TIIIlF. F.RT' MATH Nllme t (:11 ro' WI I Ron ,10b . I 9477~..n nllte Printed t OR/1R/9~ Pille 2 ~----~~--------------------~~--~--~---~--~------~---~~-----~---~-~---~-------- · OeRcr I pt Ion II/II II/M PPII (:OR t --------------------------~--------------------------~-----------..------------ Arell rotlll $ -------------------------------------------------------------------..---------- 1671,90 Arell Nllme t P.ntrllnce 6'0" ~ 3'0" ~ R'O" rllpe IInrl te~ture celllngR lR.OO SF(: Arell rotlll $ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 0.6~ ",70 11.70 Arell Nllme t Foyer I~'O" ~ 10'0" ~ R'O" rllpe IInrl te~ture eel I IngR I~O.OO SF(: Are/l rotll' $ ---------------------------------~-------------------------------------------- 0.6~ 97,~0 97, .~o Arell N/lme t Powrter room ~'O" ~ 4'0" x R'O" rllpe IInrl te~ture cell Ingll 20,00 SF(: Arell 'rot II I .11 -------------------------------------------------------------------..---------- O. 6~ 1,1.00 1.1. 00 Arell Nllme I r.lvlng room 17'0" l( 1~'0" x R'O" rllpe IInrl te~ture celllngll B~,OO SF(: Arell rotlll $ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ , 0.6~ Ifi~.7~ Ifi~,H Arell Nllme t nlning room I~IO"~' 1~'0" x R'O" rllpe IInrl te~ture ceillngll 1 ' 22,~. 00 SFr. Arell rotlll $ , , --------------------------------------------------------------~--------------- 0.6~ 14fi.2~ 14fi,B I , ~nNTp.NTR p.RTrMATp. Nllme Ollte I r:llrol WIIRon Printed r OR/rR/9~ ,lob , t 1/477--0 Pille 4 --"----------------------------------------------------------~---------~------ , OeRcrlptlon 'III "1M PPII f:ORt ----------------------_______.t_________~_~__________________._________________ Arell Nllme MIRc, 1 2 Flnlll clelln up ContentR movtna 1.00 1.00 HRR HRR 22!!.OO 2~O,OO ,22!!.OO 2~0.OO -------------------------~--------,-----------------------.-------------------- Are" Totll' $ 4H.OO , I , ' " I. I, I', I! , " , I, , ,ji , " " 11'1 , , ",I \l I' " ,II " ", ';, " , , I " " 'I ,t I "I' r-)I \ ,I I, " , , 'I " I r' ,1'1 " , ill 'i','1 .11 ..,1 " iil,\ , " I , , - " . t" , .' MIlchell ReRtor/tlfon 1'.0, flox 401 PoIIRt flerlfn, 1'". I7.HI) (717) 2~9-799j I-ROO-77j-RI)~1i RR'I'IMA'I'R RI1MMARY ,loll /I :9477--1' ---------------------------------------------------------------~-------------- RRtfm/tlor ~nen~fR nllle Prlntert r ORIIR/9~ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ .. ~I1RTOMRR INFORMArlON .. .. JOR RITR INFORMATION .. ~lIrol Wi IRnn Ijl2 RAdler nrfve ~ArlfRle, PA (717) 24.~-01)41 RUR I ( ) ~ontAct: ~Aro' Ij'2 RArtler nrfve r./trl fRle, PA Attn! ~Arol (717) 24~-Oti41 OAR · .' INRI1RAN~P. INFORMATION .. ----------------------~-----------------------------------------------~------- , AdJ ~ Ronllnn I r.IAfm /I ~ Pol /I f nert $ ~ . '. RTRI1~TI'RPo TOrAJ.S . . , Rtructure, . . , . . . , . $ 22RI.94 OverheArt (10.00%) . .1 , . . $ 22R,I9 'Profit (10, 00%) . . , , , '$ 22R .19 --..-----...--- Rtructure RUll-TotAI $ 2 7:lR . :'12 Rtructure RUIl-Tot/tl. . . . , . $, $ 27:lR,j2 ,,, To till ------......---- 27.~R. :'12 'I Orll,nrt ,Totlll ------------ ,', 27,~R,:J2 ............ .......... F.nrt Of Repor t "1,: .,......,.. 1'1' ,,' " - "'.).' . . , , , " I' 'ii I, ! Ii " I , , , ,\1 I I' , I! , !it 'I , ,I , , I' , " >I " , I , I '1 ij., , I ;1 1,1 " I Ii' I , I I , , I' " , 'I I, , 'I " H ,) 'I , i' , , I ".' , r , , , , , , , , , ',I , 101 I' " , H " 'I ;-') " I , , I, " jl , " -(j ,ft if I, ,', , , ,-\ , , " ,1/'1 I I, " J,' I". " ,') I I '11I " f :,1 t I, I " " , :-) " I " " I , "'I \ , 'I , " 'I iLl , , , 'I 'I )';;i-! , il I'! I , , .. ,I 'I I' " , I , I , II, " " , " " , I' Ii , , -;' " \f} d , j.r I, I .Ii " " ,i' , , " 'j! ,I I' -II " I, , " " '-l q " I , , , , , " ,I , I' " f' ,:1' " " I i" "! I I , ,I " -f, , , ',I (! Ii " ", I I " " , " , I " , , " " '-I \i , , , " <.f', " H;~lr,' , r.ltllllt . !I ',;! " :! I_..j " ", , , " '!, " Ill! "'1 " '<-j ,I " '" " " 'I." , ,it " , , 'I I I I, I, '. i . 7. ' f MI tche', Rei'ltnrllt Ion P,O. ROlt 401 . P.lli'1t Rp,rlfn, PII. 17:111l /7'7) H9-799.1 I-ROO-77.1";RMIII r ~vorc:F. Job, 19477 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ F.Rtlmlltor InennfR n/lte Prlnterl 1 OR/17/9~ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ .. C:l/RTOMF.R rNFORMATrON .. .. JOR RrTp. rNFORMATrON .. C:II ro' WI) Ron 1:112 Rllrller Orive C:II r ) I R ) e. VA (717) 2H-0/i41 RUR: ( ) C:ontllct: Cllrol 1.112, SlIril er Or t ve 1':11 r I t R Ie, PA Attnl I':lIrol (717) 24.~-0/i4) .. rNRI1RANC:F: HIPORMA'l'rON .. , OAR , , , ----------~----------------------------------------------~-----~---~---------- " , , Arij tRonllnnl I':llIfm II I Pol II t Oeri $ : . . RTRl/C:Tl/RF: TOTALS .. RtrUcture, , . , , , Overhelld (10.00%), Profit (10.00%), , , ," , . . $, . $ . '$ , ~R24:20 ~R2.42' ~R2.42 . , Structure Rub-Totlll "'"--------..-- $ 1l9R9,04 Rtructure Rub-Totlll, . . , . , $' /i9R9,04 '" I I . 'rot II I, '-----...------ $ 119R9,04 C:rerHt R. " . . .',' . . . . '. . ~ I" 209:111.72 C'fr/lnri Totlll 'i"--;----_____ $ -1.1947,/iR ....-:..rz..... '. : I NVOIr.F. , ------"--~---~.--_._--------------------~~------.~--,--~----~----------~--~---- .Iob It r9477--A F.RtlmRlor rOennlR nRte Prlntell ORII7/9~ ------------------------------_._--~--------------~~-------.------------------ . . r.lJSTOMF.R INFORMATION . . . . ,lOR SITF. INFORMATION . . r.Rrol Wi IRon 1~12 SRrller nrlve r.Rrllllle, PA (717) 24~-Oti41 RUllI ( ) r.ontRctl r.Rrol 1~12 RRIller nrlve r.I\rIIRle, PA Attnr r.Rrol (717) 24~-0641 . . INSI1RANr.F. INFORMATION . . OAR " Arlj IRonRnnl r.JRlm It I Pol It ,I nerl $ , ---------~--------------~-----------------------------~----------------------- . . SI1PPI,F.MP.NTAJ.S . . Pollt fmllle .Job It 'I477--A, $ 1~220,91 Pollt ImRte .Iob It '1477--0, $ 7~ti9.97 Pollt fmllle .Iob It 'l477--F.. $ 19.~6.72 Pollt I mille .Iob It 9477--F, $ 27~R,.~2 ===1:===1:1:1:1_1:1 ORANh TO:rAJ.S $ lHIR.24 . .......... F.nll of R e po r t .......... /J',I , , " , I, I , , \' " lo.J ,I, , J' ,'I ,',I t' I' . " " I, ., ' " I " i'. , "1 .,1 , ' " . DENNIS E. MITCHELL, tla MITCHELL RESTORATION, Plaintiff I I I I I I I I I IN THB COURT OF CONHON PLlAs or CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA . v. NO. TERANCE WILSON and CAROL WILSON, Defendant.s CIVIL ACTION - LAW HOTIClA TOI Terance Wilson and Carol Wilson, Defendants 1312 Sedler Drive Carlisle, PA 17013 Le han dernandBdo a usted en la corte. Si Usted quiere detendersa de estas demandas expuestas en las paginas sigUientes, Usted tiene viente (20) dias de plazo al partir de la fache de Ie demanda y la notificacion. Ustecl debe presentar una aparienoia escrita 0 en persona 0 por abogaclo y archivar en la corte en forma escrita sus defensas 0 sus Objeciones alas demanclas en contra cle su persona. sea avisado que si usted no se defiende, la corte tomara medidas y puede entrar una orden contra usted sin previo eviso 0 notificacion y por Cualquier queja 0 alivio que es pedido en la peticion de demanda. Usted puede perder dinero 0 SUS proPiedades 0 otros derechos importantes para USted. LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN A~ODAGO IMMEOIATAMENTE. SI NO TrENE ABOGAOO 0 SI NO TIENE EL 01NERO SUFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERvrcro, VAYA EN PERSONA 0 LLAME POR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA 01REccrON SE ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR OONOE SE PUEOE CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEGAL. Court Administrator 4th Fl., Cumberland County Courthouse Carlisle, PA 17013 J_ _j -2- . 6. Estimates 9477, 9477-A, 9477-0, 9477-E and 9477-F were approved by the defendants and the plaintiff performed the neoessary work. 7. Exhibit "A" provides a detailed breakdown of the work performed, but generally the repairs involved interior repair to drywall, inoluding painting, wallpapering and other interior preparation inoluding replacement of carpet and a large portion of the work devoted to the replacement of the roof on the structure at 1312 Sadler Drive, Carlisle, Pennsylvania as well as repair of the interior ceilings. 8. The oral contract specified that payment would be made upon completion of the various estimates attached hereto as Exhibit "A." Tot.al cost of the estimated jobs weret 9477. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. . . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . $6,989.04 9. Of this grand total, payments and credits have been made in the amount of $20,936.72 with a balance remaining of $13,518.24. 10. On or prior to August 31., 1994, plaintiff delivered all the materials called for under the contract at defendants' residence as well as completed all the necessary services included -2- . . in the estimated exhibits attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "A." 11. On or after August 31, 1994, plaintiff presented defendants with a final invoice entitled jOb no. 9477 and requested payment in the amount of $13,518.24. A true and correct copy of this invoice is attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "B." 12. Plaintiff has repeatedly demanded payment of the amount due, but defendant has wholly neglected and refused to pay the same or any part thereof. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against Defendants for the sum of $13,518.24 with interest from August 31, 1994 and costs. COUNT I BREACH OF CONTRACT 13. PlBintiff incorporhtes herein by reference the allegations set forth in paragraphs 1 through 12 as if the same were fully set forth herein or at length. 14. The actions of defendants as aforesaid are willful and oonstitute a material breach of the agreement entered into between plaintiff and defendants. 15. As a direct and proximate result of the aotions of defendants as aforesaid, plaintiff has suffered and continues to suffer serious injury, including but not limited to lOBS of the -3- . monies owed to it by defendants, 10s8 of use of said monies, lost interest on the money and other suoh damages as may be disoovered. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands that This Honorable Court enter judgment in its favor and against Defendants in the amount of $13/518.24/ together. with costs and interest. COUNT II QUANTUM MERUIT 16. Plaintiff incorporates herein by referenoe the allegations set forth in paragraphs 1 through 15 as if the same were fully set forth herein or at length. 17. Between April 1994 and August 1994, plaintiff performed oertain work and services for defendants, consisting of purohasing materials and providing there installation in a good and workmanlike conditioned upon the property of defendants and of the specific request of defendants' to repair weather related damage. 18. The unpaid work, labor and services performed by plaintiff on defendants' house had a reasonable value of $13/518.24. 19. Defendants have refused to pay plaintiff for the unpaid work, labor and services performed by the plaintiff. 20. As a result of defendants refusal to make full payment to plaintiff of the reasonable value of plaintiff / s work, labor / service and materials, plaintiff has suffered serious and -4- - .......- . . . I \1 ., " " ,I.IIIIIIU' " " "'_I.o;~.. I; .. I' ", ' .1, :I I ':"~"'" "\"1 ~ ;"1. Ii I I, ,;:J:'~'-'::;~;'~'-:1;~;;_~"--')~f!~!~~f'~~. i. .. . " . Mitchell ReRtorlltlon P.O, ROle 401 "'/111 t Re r II n, p,.. 17 .'II () (717) 2~9-799.'1 I-ROO-77.'1-R()~() JlIlT I MATF. Sl/MMARY Job' t9477 ----------------_______________M_____________________________________________._ nllte PrInted I OR/IR/9~ F.Rtlmlltor rnennfll ---------------~--_._--------------------------------------------------------- .. <1l/RTOMJlR INFORMATION .. Cllro I WI I Ron 1.'112 SlIdler nrive CllrliRle, PA (717) 24~-Oli41 RURr ( ) Contllctr <1l1rol GAR *. ,lOR R ITJI I NFORMAT ION . * 1.'112 Illldler nrive <111 r I till e, PA Attnl <1l1rol (717) 24S-0li41 .. INRl/RAN<1J1 INFORMATION * * Arlj IRonllnnf <1ll1lm II I Pol II I , ned $ I , , ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ * * RTRl/<1Tl/RF. TOTAI.S * * Rtructure. . . , , '. , . $ ~R24, 20 OVllrhelld (10.00%) , " , , $ ~R2. 42 Proftt (10.00%) , , , . . . $ ~R2.42 ------------ Structure Sull-Totlll ,1\ li9R9.04 Rtruclture Rub-Totlll. . . .. . . $ 119R9.04 Totlll ------------ $ 119R.9.04 $ 209.'11i. 72 " " ""----------- $ -I.'1947.6R, Da.all.lu.eD... , : , .......... <1r.CIIrl It II. , . . '. , , . . . . . . Orllnd Totlll .......... P,~d 0', Report ., . ,. '. .., '~ Mitchell ReRtorAtlon P.O, lime 401. P.IlRt Rerllll, (717) ~1I9-799:1 PA. 17.111i I-ROO-77:1-1I1i1l1i " R'I'RIIC:'I'IIRR RR'I'IMA'I'F. NAme I C:/lrol WIIRon n/lte Printed I 011/111/911 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ , neRcrlptlon ,rob, I 9477 Pille ----------------------------------------------------------------------------~- fill II/M PPII C:ORt Are/l Nllme Roof 71 '0" x :12'0" x,O'O" , Remove old roof 22.72 RQ 211.00 II Ii II ,00 2 ARphlllt RhingleR :100 lb. (:'10 )Or) 22.72 RQ 1111,00 19:1 1,20 :I Remove old roof on mllnRforrl 20,20 SQ :111.00 707.00 4 ARphlllt RhlngleR :100 II>, (:10 )Or) 20.20 SQ 90,00 111111,00 ~ nUmp binR 40 C:V 1.00 F.A 725.00 7211,00 I) c:ut down TllfterR 1.00 HRR 711,00 711 , 00 AreA 'I'otll I $ 111124.20 , ------------------------------------------------------------~----------------- II , , , " I,t , , I" 1 , , , , , II, q 1 I I , , I" 'I " " " , " , , , , , ,:1 , 'j ,', , " I "I I J, " \', I" - - , , 'I .' 1';/. "~" Mitchell Relltorlltlnn , P,O. Rox 401 P.lll1t Rerlln, PII. 17316 (717) 2~9-7993 I-ROO-773-R6~6 I 1\ , ' P.R1'TMA'I'P' RUMMARY Job' :9477--A -----------------------------------------------.------------------------------ Ollte Printed r OR/lR/9~ P.lltlmlltor rOennill --------------------------------------------.--------------------------------- .. ~lJRTOMP.R TNFORMA1'TON .. ~I\rol WilRon 1312 Rllrller Orive ~l\rl;Rle, PA (717) 245-0641 RUllI ( ) ~ontllct: CArol OAIl .. JOR RT1'P. TNFORMA1'TON .. 1312 Rlloler Orive ~llrllRle, PA Attn: ~lIrol (717) 245-0641 .. TNRURANr.P. TNFORMA1'TON .. Adj :RoMnn; ~lllim # Pol # : Oed $ : ------------------------------------------~----------------------------------- . . R1'RUr.1'IIRF. 1'OTAI.R . . Rtructure, , , , . '., , $ 1267R.77 I'll X ( 6,00%) . $ 17,60 Overhelld (10,00%). $ 1262.27 Profit (10,00%). . . , $ 1262.27 ,..----------- Rtructure Ruh-1'otlll $ 1~220.91 I. " RtTucture Rub-Totlll . . , , . . $ 1~220.91 ------------ ! 1'ot/l1 $ , 1~220.91 -----------/"" Or/lnd 1'ot/ll $ 1~220.91 .1lI11.........' , .......... Rnd Of Report ........h '" ;' Mitchel I ReRlorllt Ion P,O. Rox 401 P.IIRt Rerlln, PII. 1 7~IIi ' (717) 2!l9-799~ 1-f100-77~-RIi51i Il'J'Rlle:'J'l1RF. RIlTIMA'I'P. Nllme t e:llrol Wllllon nllte Printed t OR/lR/95 .101> , f 9477--A Pille f 1 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ , nucrlptlon '/11 lIlM C:Ollt ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ PPII Arell Nllme I Rntrllnce 1i'0" x ~'O" x R'O" lnll till I 1/2" drywllll-cell InIR-tex- IR .00 fiFe: '.15 20.70 tured relldy for Plllnt 2 Remove '/2" drywlIll - eel I InlR IR.OO liFe: 0, :l4 6. 12 ~ Remove/replllce light 1.00 M/e: 40,00 40.00 4 Pllint 2 cOlltR-eeillng (Ilelll &Pllint) IR.OO liFe: 0,47 R.46 5 Remove wllllpllper oS.OO ROLl, 15.7!i 7R.7!l Ii Willi prepllrllt ion 1.00 lfRIl 20,00 20.00 7 lfllng WIII'pllper oS.OO ROLl, 22.00 110.00 Arell Totlll " 2R4.0.1 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Arell Nllme : Foyer 15'0" x 10'0" x R'O" I' 2 .1 4 5 Ii nrYWIIII minor repllirR (to Ii IlF) minimum chllrge Pllint 2 cOlltR-cetllng (Ilelll &Pllint) MIIRk/cover Will IR, floorR, furniture Remove wlII'pllper Will I prepllrlltion Wllllpllper 70.50 22.00 173.25 22.00 242.00 1.00 150.00 1.00 I 1.00 1.00 ".00 M/e: !i0.00 !i0,00 liFe: lfRIl ROLl, lfRIl ROLl. 0,47 22,00 15,7!l 22,00 22.00 Arell Tollll $ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 579,7!l Arell Hllme . Powder room 5'0" x 4 '0" x R'O" , nrywlIll minor repllirR (to /; IlF) 1. 00 M/e: H.OO :l.'i .00 minimum ehllrge 2 Pllint 2 cOlltR-cei ling (Relll &Plllnt) 20.00 RFe: 0.47 9.40 ~ Remove Wllllpllper 5.00 ROT,l, 1S.7!l 7R.75 4 Willi prepllrllt ion 1. 00 lfRR 22.00 22.00 '. ..~ R1'RIle:1'I/RF. FoR1' T MArF. Nllme I CArol Wi IRon nllte Prlntert I OR/lR/9~ Job It I 9477--" PAse t 2 ------------------------------------------.----------------------------------- , neRcription 1111 HIM PPI/ r.ORt -----------------------------------..--------------------------.--------------- ~ WAllpAper ~ ,00 ROI,T, 22.00 2~~.1 ~ 110.00 AreA rotA 1 $ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Arell NAme I I.iviogroom 17'0" lC 1~'0" x R' 0" nrywllll minor repAirR (to 6 Ill') 1.00 M/r. 130.00 DO.OO minimum chArge 2 PAint 2 COA t R-ce II i ng (SeAl '\'Pn I n t ) 2 ~ ~ .00 RFe: 0,47 119. R~ :I pnint 2 cOAtR-wAIIR (Ilenl ,\, pn i n t ) ~ 12,00 IlFW O,4~ 2:10.40 4 MARk/cover wnllR, floorR, furniture 2,00 HRS 22,00 44.00 ~ CleAn cnrpet with detergent-medium 2 ~ ~ ,00 IlFF 0.22 ~6. 10 Arell 'I'ot AI $ ~RO.3~ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Aren NAme : l1ining room 1 ~'O" lC 1 ~'O" x R'O" nrywllll minor repnirR (to 6 SF) 1.00 M/e: R~,OO R~.OO minimum chArge pA I nt )f 2 PA i nt 2 contR-wAII R (Ilenl ,\, 4RO.00 IlFW 0.4~ 216.00 :I Pllint 2 cOlltR-ceillng (Selll '\'PAi nt) 2 2~, 00 IlFe: 0.47 10~. 7~ 4 Mllllk/cover wnl III, floorR, furni ture 2.00 HRS 22.00 44.00 Arell 'I'otn I $ 4~0.7~ ----------------------------------------.------------------------------------- Aren NAme : Kitchen 1~'0" x 9'0" lC R'O" nrywlI 11 minor repAirll (to 6 1lF) 1. 00 M/e: 130.00 1:10.00 minimum chllrge 2 Pllint 2 cOlltll-ceillng (Sen I ....Pnlnt) 135,00 Ilfe: 0.47 6:l.4~ :I Mllllk/cover Will III, floorll, furni ture 2.00 HRS 22.00 44.00 4 Remove wnllpnper 7,00 ROI.I, 1~.7~ 110. 2~ ~ Willi prepltrlltion 2,00 HRIl 2 .00 44,00 6 Wn II pnper 7.00 ROI.I, 22.00 1~4. 00 7 HRng WII II pllper norrter 39.00 M/r. 2.00 7R.00 R Pllint 2 cOAtll-wnllR (Ilen I ,\, pnint) 120.00 IlFW 0.4~ ~4.00 "- (," ' R'rRUC:'rIlRP. P.R'rIMA'rF. N~me I r.~rol WlIRon n~te Printed I OIl/\1I/9~ ,Job If t 9477--A PIIg!! t :l -------------------~---------------------------------------------------------- . neRCrlptlon '/11 111M PPII C:Ol'lt ---------------------------------------------------------------------.--------- Are~ 'rotA I $ 677,70 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Are~ N~me . W~ter hellter room 9'0" x 5'0" x 11'0" , nrywlIll minor repllirl'l (to 6 RP) 1.00 M/f: 60,00 60,00 minimum chllrl:le 2 Pllint 2 COlltR-WIIIIR ( Sell I " plI i nt ) 224.00 SPW 0.45 100,/10 :I Pllint 2 cOlltR-cei 1 ing (Relll "Pllint) 4!i ,00 RPf: 0,47 2\ .15 4 MAl'lk/cover Will 11'1, floorR, furni ture 2.00 HRS 22.00 44.00 Arp.1I 'rot II I $ 225.9!i ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Arell NAme : Kitchen hill I 6'0" x :1'0" X /1'0" nrywlIll minor rcpAirR (to II SF) 1.00 M/f: :lO,OO :l0.00 minimum chllrge 2 PAint 2 COlltR-WIIIIR ( Selll " pllint) 120,00 RPW 0.45 !j4,OO :I Pllint 2 cOAtR-cei ling (ReAl "Pllint) 111.00 RPf: 0,47 /1,46 4 Hllng wllllpllper border .' 1.00 M/f: :lO,OO .10,00 Arell 'rotAI $ 122,4fi ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AreA NAme: Ollrllge 24'0" x 24'0" x 9'0" 1 Remove 1/2" drywlIll - ceillngR 2 Remove inRullltlon hllttR from eel lng :I Remove inRullltion bllttR from Will 11'1 4 f:rAft fllced fiherglllRR R-:lO inRultn 5 InRt1l11 1/2" drywllll-cei I ingR-tex- tured relldy for pllint 6 InRtAl1 1/2" drywllll-wIIIIR-textured relldy for plllnt ~76.00 RPf: 576,00 RPf: 216,00 RPW 792,00 RP 576,00 RPf: 216,00 RPW 0.:14 0,20 0,19 0,1111 1,15 195./14 11 S. 20 41.04 696.96 662,40 1,1 S 2411.40 Arell 'rot II I $ 1959.114 ----------------------------------------------------~------------------------- .. ~ , ~. . /lrRl/r,rl/Rp. p.RrrMArp, Nllme : r.I\rO I WlIl\on Ollte Printed : OR/lR/9~ ,Job /I : 9477--A PIIge : 4 -~---------------------------------------------------------------------------- /I OeRcrlption 11/1/ 111M PPII l':ORt ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Arell Nllme : FRmi Iy room :12'0" lC I~'O" lC 11'0" OrywlIlI minor repR i rR (to fi IlF) 1.00 MIl': 1:10.00 1:10.00 mi nimum chRrge 2 PIl i nt 2 cllRtR-cei ling (Relll &Plllnt) 4110.00 RFl': 0.47 2H.fiO :I Pllint 2 CORtR-WIlI IR (lleRI & Plllnt) 2~fi. 00 RFW 0.4~ 11~.20 4 MRRk/cover wRIIR, floorR, furniture 2,00 HRIl 22.00 44.00 ~ Remllve WRI IpRper 1.1.00 ROI.1. 1 ~. 7~ 204.B fi Willi prepRrRt ion :1.00 HRIl 22,00 fifi.OO 7 WRII pllper 22.00 ROI.1. 22,00 4R4,OO II HRng Will IpRper horder 1,00 M/l': t5R,00 1511.00 Arell rotlll $ 1427,55 ---------------------------------------------------------------~-------------- AreR Nllme : 2nd floor left fr br 1~'O" lC 1~'0" lC 11'0" 1 Remove dry cRrpet Rnd pRd 2 lnRtRl1 new cRrpeting In roomR 25.00 25. :1:1 IlYF IlYF 2.:\5 29,00 ~II.B 7:l4.~7 AreR rotRI $ 79:1.:12 -----------------------,~--------______~L______________________________________ Arell NRme : Office 14'0" lC 10'0" lC R'O" 1 Remove dry CArpet Rnd pRd 2 lnRtRII new cRrpeting In roomR l~.~fi IR.fifi IlYF IlYF 2.:\5 29.00 577.71 :lfi.57 ~41 .14 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AreR 'rotRI $ Arell NRme , I.efr rell r hedroom 1 ~'O" lC I ~ '0" lC R'O" . 1 Remove 1/2" drywlIll - WRII R 120.00 IlFW O. :l2 :IlL 40 2 Remove InRulRtion hRt tR from Willi R 120.00 IlFW 0,19 22.RO l c'rll f t fRced fiherglRRR R-19 InRultn 120,00 SF O.fiR II I . till 4 lnRtlll1 1/2" drYWII11-WRIIR-telCtured 120.00 SFW 1. 15 1:111.0(> reRdy for pRint ~ Hllng Will IpRper-minimum chllrge 1,00 MIl': 90.00 90.00 . <'\>. . ' , II'I'RIlf:"IIRf; FoRT I MATE Hllme r nllrol WII'llon Ollte Printed I OR/lR/9S .Job 1# I 9477--A Pllge r S ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ . Oellcrlptlon It 11/ 111M PPII nOllt -------------------------------------------~------------------------.---------- 6 Pili nt 2 COli tIl-WIII III (Selll " plllnt) 4RO,OO SFW 0.4S 216.00 7 Pili nt 2 cOlltll-cell fng (Rell I ""Plllnt) 2 2 S ,00 IIFf: 0.47 10S,7S R Mllllk/cover will Ill, floorll, furnl ture 2,00 HRR 22.00 44.00 9 Remove dry cllrpet IInd plld H.OO RVP 2,B SR.7S 10 Inlltll II new cllrpeting In roomll H,~.1 RVP 29.00 7:14.~7 Aren Totll I ~ 1~29.R7 -------------------------------------------------------------~---------------- Arell Hllme : HilI I WilY 16'0" x 7'0" x R'O" , Remove dry CII rpe t IInd plld 2 Inlltllll new cllrpet In hllllwlIY '2.44 12,44 SVP RVF 2. :IS 29.00 :lR9.99 29.2:1 :160.76 -------------------------------------------------------------------~---------- Arell Totll I $ Arell Hllme : IItlllrll lR'O" x ~'O" x 9'0" 1 Remove dry cllrpet IInd plld 6,00 SVF 2.:lS 14.10 2 Inll t II II new cllrpet/lltlllrll w/full 29,00 J,P S.42 1 S7, 1 R wrllp .;. Arell Tot A I $ 171.2R ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Arell NAme : Mnllter bnthronm 10'0" x 9'0" X R'O" 1 Remove I i no I eum from wood floor 90,00 SFF 0.72 64.RO 2 Remove IInd reRet old hllRel10Ard .1R,OO l.P 1.00 :lR.OO :I Prep floor for linoleum-light 90.00 SFF 0.:17 :I~,:lO 4 RftR commode 1.00 RA :lR.OO :111,00 S I.lnoleum 1.1 . ~.1 SVP 22.00 29:1.26 6 Remove InRullltfon 1111 t t R from wn II R 72,00 SFW 0.19 1:I.6R 7 Remove 1/2" rlrY'YII II - wlIIIR 72.00 SFW 0,:12 2:1,04 R rorll f t fnced fil1erglnRR R-19 inllultn RO ,00 RF 0.6/1 ~4.40 9 InR t f1' I 1/2" drywnl I-will IR-textured 72.00 SFW 1. 2R 92.16 relldy for pllfnt 10 Remove wnllpllper S.OO ROl.1. IS.H 7R,H 11 WRII prepllrllt ion 2,00 HRR 22.00 44.00 .. " ~, " . Mltchel1 RQ~tnrRtlnn P.O, lIox 401 RRRt lIerlln, PR, '7~1~ (717) 2~9-799~ '-ROO-77~-R~~~ p.IlTrMATR IlIlMMARV Job, :9477--0 RRtlmRtor tOennlR ---------------------------.-------------------------------------------------- OBte Printed I ~R/lR/95 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ .. I':IIIlTOMF.R rNFoRMA'J'YON .. .. .roll IHTF. rNFoRMATroN .. CIlro' WilRnn 1312 RRdler Orlve CIlrIlRle, PA (717) 245-0641 RUR I ( ) 1':0ntRct: I':Rrol 1312 RRdler Orlve I':nrllRle, PA Attnt l':Rrol (717) 24:1-0641 .,. rNlllIRANI':F. rNFORMATrON .. OAR ArlJ Ill0nRnn i 1':1 Il 1m # I Pol # I Oed $ I , , ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ . . /lTRlJr.TlJRF. TOTAL/l . . /ltructure, , , , , , , $ 6236.11 TRX ( 6.00%) , , , . 'i' $ 12.4R OverheRrl (10.00%), . , $ 315.69 Profit (10,00%) . . . , $ ~15.69 ----...------- Rtructure Sub-Toh I $ 6999.97 . . l':ONTF.NTS TOTALS . . 1':0ntentR , , . . . , $ 475.00 OverheRrl (10.00!ll) , . , . , $ 47.50 Profit (10,OO!ll) , " 47.50 ------------ 1':0ntentR Sub-TotRI $ ~70. 0.0 Structure Ilub-Toh J . . . . . . $ 6999.97 1':0ntentR Rub-"otR J " . . " . $ ~70.00 -....--------- Tohl $ , . H6,9,,97 ... ~ .. Mitchel I ReRtorRtlnn P.O. Rnx 401 RARt Rerlln, PRo 17.1'111 (717) 2~9-799~ I-ROO-77~-RII~1I RTRI1C:'l'I1RP. P.R'l'TMA'l'1l NAme I C:/lrol Wi IRon O/lte Printeel I OR/IR/9~ Job , I 9477--0 I Pllse I 1 , OeRcriptlon 1I1M -------------------------------------------------------------~---------------- C:ORt -----------------------------------------~------------------------------------ '111 PPlI Are/l N/lme I UR II hRthroom 9'0" x R'O" x R'O" 1 Remove I fnoleum from wood floor 72,00 sFF 0.2~ IR.OO 2 Prep floor for linoleum mfnimum I. 00 SFF 7~.00 75 .00 .1 r.tnoleum R,OO SYF 211.00 20R.00 4 Replllr RUhfloor I. 00 ffRS 17~.00 175.00 ~ R & R tot let with new WIIX ring 1,00 IlA 42,~lO 42,00 Ii InRt1l1l new hllRehollrrl - unpR I ntrl ~4.00 I,F 2.20 74.RO 7 P/lfnt hllsehollrrls-dffferent Plllnt ~4,OO I,F O.R~ 2R,90 thlln wIIIIR AreR 'l'ntRI $ 1121.70 Arell Nllme : MRRter hllthroom 10'0" x I ------________________________________________________________________________ ; 9'0" x R'O" 1.00 ffRS I. 00 SF I. 00 IlA 4R.00 I,F 4R.00 r.F Section IInel replRce RUb-flnor 2 Remove IInrl replAce WAI I RtUelR Anrl hot tom plAte ~ R & R toilet with new WAX ring 4 InstAll new hARehoArrl - unpAintd ~ PAint hARehollrelR-different pAint thAn WAils AreA T'ltAI $ 17~.00 22~.00 42.00 2.20. O,R~ 175.00 22~.00 42.00 10~.1I0 40.RO ----------------..------------------------------------------------------------- ~RR.40 AreA NAme: MAster herlroom 23'0" x 14'~" xR'O" Remove elry CArpet /lnrl PAeI from herlroom WAlk in CIORct Rnel hili I 2 InstAll new cArpeting in roomR ~~.~3 SYF ~ ~ ..1.1 SYF 2.~~ 12~.~~ 29.00 1 ~411. ~7 " ,.. R'l'RIIr.TIIRF. F.R'l'IMA'l'F. H"me I 'C:" ro I Wllllon O"te Printed I OR/IR/9~ .roh , I 9477--0 P"le I 2 , Oellcrlptlon 111M ------------------------~------------------~---------------------------------- C:Ollt ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 'Ill Arell Tot III $ PPII ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 1671.90 Arell Hllme I Rntrllnce 6'0" x ~'O" x R'O" 'l'/Ipe IInd texture celllngll IR.OO RPC: AreA TotAl $ 0.6S 11.70 11.70 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AreA NAme I Poyer 1~'0" x 10'0" x R'O" 'l'lIpe And texture eel Ifngll '~O.OO RPC: AreA 'l'otlll .$ 0.6S 97.~0 97.S0 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Arell NAme I Powder room ~'O" x 4'0" x R'O" Tllpe And texture eel Ilngl! .' 20.00 RPC: AreA Totlll $ O./iS I~.OO , ------------------------------------------------.------------------------------ 1:l.00 Are" Nllme : I.lvlng room 17'0" x IS'O" x R'O" TApe And texture eel Ilngll 2~~.00 RPr. AreA Tohl $ .0./iS I/iS.H i~. " l/iS.7S ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Are" Nllme : nlnlng room 1S'0" X I~'O" x R'O" T"pe And texture celllngll 22S.00 RPC: AreA Tohl $ O.6S 14/i.H I " I, ,. 'I '1\, :' I. I , 146. H ---~----------------,._------------~------------------------------------------- "'" . . Nllme I C:llrol'Wf'1I0rl n"te Printed f OR/IR/9S lI'l'ill1r:TIIRP. P.IITJMA'l'P. .-... ! .Joh , I 9477--0 .P"le I ~ 'III ----------------------------------------------~------------------------------- , Oucrlpt 'on 111M ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ (')0 lit Are" Nllme ~ Kitchen JS'O" x 9'0" X'R'O" 'l'''pe IInd texture eel IlngR I:I~.OO IIP(') AreA 'l'ot/l I $ PPII o.ti~ R7.H R7.H --------------------..--------------------------------------------------------- Arell Nllme ~ Wllter hellter room 9'0" x ~'O" x R'O" 'l'lIpe And texture cef "ngR 4~.00 RFc: Arell 'l'ot/l I $ O.ti~ 29.2~ 29.2~ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AreA Nllme I Kftchen HilI I 6'0" x ~'O". R'O" 'l'lIpe IInd texture celllngR lR.OO RFC) Arell 'l'otlll $ O.ti~ 11.70 11.70 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ , AreA NAme I Pllmily room .. 32'0" x 1~'0" . R'O" 'l'ape IInd texture celllngR 4RO.00 II PC: AreA 'l'otllJ $ O.tiS .112.00 312.00 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AreA NAme I Mille. C:Ollt of wAllPllper (Ree "ttllched) l. 00 1'0'1' Ruh-'l'otlll $ 2479.21 2479.21 2479.21 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --- - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -'-- -- --- ~ I. I . .. Mitchell Relltorlltlon P.o. Rox 401 F./lllt lhlrlln, PA. 17:l1ti " (7J 7) 2~9-799.~ '-ROO-77 ~-R/I~/I p.RTrMA'l'p. Ill/MMARV Joh, 19477--F. P.lltlmlltor fnennlR ---------.._----------------------------------"------------------------------- n"te Printed I OR/IRI9S ----------------------------------------------------------------------------~- .. C:lJRl'OMF.R INFORMATION .. .. .rOR RI'l'F. INPORMA'l'ION .. r.llrol WIIRon 1~12 Rlldler nrive r.llrltllle, PA (717) 24~-Oti41 RUllI ( ) r.ontRc t I C:A ro I l~12 RAdler Orlve r.llrllllle, PA Attnf C:Arol (717) 24~-Oti41 .. INlllJRANC:P. INPORMATION .. OAR Adj f RonAnn I r.llllm It f Pol It I Oed .$ I 1 ---------------------~._-----------------------------------------------~------ .. RTRIIC:'l'IIRF. TOTAI.R .. RtructuTII. . . . . . . . . . . $ 19:1ti.7~' . ---.-------- Rtructure R~h-'l'OtAl $ 19~ti;72 , 1 , Iltructurll Ilub-'l'oh I. . . . . . $ '9~ti.n -----...------ 'l'ohl $ 19:1ti.72 ---....------- Clr/lnd 'l'ohl $ 19:1ti.72 ...1:1........ , .......... P.nd O~ Report' , .......... , '. " I , , ... II,' , , -.-..'- - II '~ ,~_, ',,"" 'f ;, : Mjtc~e" Relltorntlon P.O. Rox 401 , Fl"/lt Rerfln, Pn. 17."ti (717) 2~9-799~ '-ROO-77~-R~~6 RR'l'IMATF. RIIMMARV -------------------------------------------------------------------------~---- Joh "9477--P Rlltlmlltor IOennl/l ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ,.,. C':UR'l'OMF.R INPORMA'l'ION ,.,. Onte Printed I OR/IR/9S ,.,. .rOR RTTF. INPORMA'l'rON ,.,. C':nrol Wi IlIon 1~12 Rlldler Orfve <':nrllllle, PA (717) 24~-Oti41 RUII: ( ) C:ont"ct: C':Ilrol 1~12 Rlldler Orlve C':lIrlfllle, PA Attn I C':lIro r (717) 24~-Oti41 OAR ,.,. rNIlPRANC':F. rNPORMA'l'ION ,.,. Adj :Ronllnnl C':IRlm 1/ : Pol 1/ : Oed $ I , " ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ,.,. R'l'RIIC':'l'IIRF. 'l'O'l'AI,R ,.,. Rtructure. . . . . OverheAd (10.00~). Prof I t (' 0 . 00"'). . .$ $ $ ~2RI..94 22ft.19 22R.19 .f . . Rtructure Ruh-'l'otlll ------------ $ 27.'R.~2 Rtructure RUh-'l'ot"r. . .' ., . . . 27.'R.~2 ..uu.... ' ... \ \ I ~ i! ~, I I I ii" / \ . , I ' . , i , J: , , r"';!j }. .', " Mitchell Relltorntlon P.O. Rox 401 RARt Rerl fn, PII. '7~16 (717} 2~9-7q9~ l-ROO-77~-Rti~ti ll'l'IHlr:'l'lJRF. F.1l'l'IMATF. N"me I C':n ro I WI I lion Ollte Printed I OR/lR/9~ Job , I 9477--P Pille 1 ---"------------------------------------------"------------------------------- It OeRcr I pt I em 1111 111M PPlI C1nRt ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AreA Nllme F.xterlor 1 TeAr out old dormer/! ~eA 10. ~O HRIl 2~.OO 2ti2.S0 2 Rehuf ld rlormer/! ~ ench 4R.00 HRR 2~.00 1200.00 ~ 'nRtA II RhfngleR on new dormerll l.ti6 IlQ 144.00 2~9.04 4 PIIIRhing .040" thick 9ti.00 RP 2.40 2~0.40 ~ WrAp new dormer/! wfth IIlumfnum 14.00 HRR 2~.00 HO.OO Sub-Tot II I $ 22Rl.94 ------------~-.-----------------------------------"---------------------------- p , , ,:1 ,I i , , " ,I, , " , " , " " +1 " ", ,I " ',' 1'" " " 1;1 , , 1'1 I " " .1, . , " I , , , , ,II' 'I 1:1', " .1 , 'I , 1 " , " .. , , " ,., . . , , {,. ' "l' 1- f , , Mitchell Rli/!torlltlon P.O. Rox 401 , F.AIII Rerl In, PA. lnlti (717) 2~9-799~ I-ROO-77~-Rti~ti INVOIc:F. -----------~--------~--------------------------------~---------------------~-- Joh , 19477 RRtlmlltor IOennl/! O"te Printed I OR117/9~ -------->>--------------------------------------------------------------------- .. C':l/R'l'OMF.R INPORMA'l'ION .. · · ,lOR RI'l'F. INPORMATION .. C':Arol WI I lion 1~12 RAdler Orfve C':A r I f R Ie, PA (717) 24~-Oti41 RUR: ( ) C':ontllctl CArol 1~12 SAdler Orlve C':R r 11111 e, PA Attn: ~Ilrol (717) 24~-Oti41 .. INIlIIRANC:F. TNPORMA'l'ION .. OAR Adj I RonRnn I c: I A 1m It I Pol It t Oed $ : ' , --------------------------------~--------------------------------------------- . . R'l'RIIC:'l'IIRF: 'l'01:Al.S . . Rtructure. . . . . . . . . . $ ~1l2.4. 20 OverheAd (10.00%) . . $ ~R2.42 .' . . . Profit (10.00%) . . . . . $ ~R2.42 ------------ Structure SUh-'l'OtAI $ ti9R9.04 Rtructure Ruh-'l'OtAI. . . , , $ ti9R9 . 04 ----.-------- $ ti9R9.04 'l'otA,f, '()redl'tll. . . . , , , , . . . . $ 209~ti.72 Orllnd 'l'o'hl ------------ $ -1~947.tiR ....~..a.'..II, . . '" ,i. .,. ; INVOIC':F. ---------~---------------_._-----~-------------------------------------~------ .Iob , 19477--A F./!tfmAtor rOenn'" Ollte Printed I ORI17/9S -------------------------~--------------------------~------------------------- · . C':URTOMF.R INPORMA'l'ION. . . . JOR RT'l'F. INPORMATTON . . ~"rol WIlllon 1~12 Rlldler Orlve C"rlf"le, PA (717) 24S-0ti41 RUllI ( ) C':ont/lct I C':lIrol 1~12 Rlldler Orlve C':llrIIRle,.PA Attn~ r.AroJ (717) 24~-0/\41 .. TNRIJRAI'lr.F. INPORMATION . . OAR Acl.j ~RonAnnf C': I II f m /I Pol /I I Oed $ ~ -----------------------------------------------..---------------"-----~-------- . . RUPPI.F.MF.N'l'AI.R . . F./!tlmllte .Ioh /I 9477--A. $ 1 S220. 91 F./!tlmAte .Joh /I 9477--0. $ 7Sti9.97 'RlltlmAte .Ioh /I 9477--'R . . $ 19.1ti.72 'RlltimAte .Ioh /I 9477.,-P. $ 273R.~2 11====1;1=====11: ORANO 'l'OTAJ.R $ I~SIR.24 ~ .......... Rn,d Of Report , .......... " , , ., ,'I II "~'I "~I I; :i ;" " F'l I" " :1' " , , 'Ii /. , ,'I 1'" " , , " , ., " J If , " 'I /, " " . . o",u~o, TI/r 3"E~'" C'ttJ/. , ! !11,~ry rE./5 8 O~ AH '96 , 1,1 , 'I:' [ I" l r: l/\ \ '.. .r~ PENNSYLVANIA 1,- " , , if ., , , , " , ,) , , Ii , , , ,I , , , " I , II h , , , ; , , , , , , , , , , , , , . , i! '1'1' d , ,I It , , " , :' , I, ,-I , i-I 'Ii , , , , Iii , , , , , , i 1 II ,'j n , 'I Il , 1-', , "'1 11 I;,' Ii , ., , \, I, '" L, Ii j,\ 1)1 '.' I i , , ,. I Iii , ., M!1 , , , @;€i \i ,c-!.'J , r.!,:, , l!~!-:;:) \..H (?!J , , :.. I , , , , 1"111 -\ 'J I, il " " 'I , " " , ., ') , , '., 'I .' , " , , I " 'I " H ., 1",1 1\ Hi I, , I ., ., , " , "I 'J )-, , j',.j 1\ ., ;1 ., , , , ,,! , I , I!," -\ , I, 'I i' ". , , );1 -1,\ , " \ , , , , \ " , " " ., , 'i " " , , , , " , , , I I " DENNIS E. MITCHELL, t/a MITCHELL RESTORATION, Plaintiff v. I I I I I I I I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY / PENNSYLVANIA NO. 1996-00819 TERANCE WILSON and CAROL WILSON, Defendants CIVIL ACTION - LAW AMENDED COMPLAINT 1. Plaintiff is Dennis E. Mitchell an adult individual t/a Mitchell Restoration, with his residence and principlll place of business at P. O. Box 6564/ Harr.isburg, Pennsylvania 17112-0564. 2. Defendants are Terance Wilson and Carol Wilson who are adult individuals residing at 1312 sadler Drive, Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013. 3. During the winter of late 1993 through early 1994/ defendants exper ienced a var iety of weather related damages to their residence located at 1312 Sadler Drive, Car lisle, Pennsylvania 17013. 4. On or about April 1994 plaintiff and defendants entered into an oral contract to perform certain work and to furnish certain materials by the plaintiff to repair the weather related damages incurred by the defendants. 5. The oral contract was supported by written e.timat.. which are attached hereto as Exhibit "A." labeled as job no. 9477, 9477-A, 9477-0/ 9477-E and 9477-F~ The est imat.. ar. 6. Estimates 9477, 9477-A, 9477-0, 9477-E and 9477-F were approved by the defendants and the plaintiff performed the necessary work. 7. Exhibit "A" provides a detailed breakdown of the work performed, but generally the repairs involved interior repair to drywall, including painting, wallpapering and other interior preparation including replacement of carpet and a large portion of the work devoted to the replacement of the roof on the structure at 1312 Sadler Drive, carlisle, Pennsylvania as well as repair of the interior ceilings. 8. The oral contract specified that payment would be made upon completion of the various estimates attached hereto as Exhibit "A." Total cost of the estimated jobs were: 9477....................,................... .$6,989.04 9477-A . . $15,220.91 9477-0 . . . . . . . . . $ 7,569.97 9477-E . . '. $ 1,936.72 9477-F . . . . . . . . . . $ 2,738.32 Grand Total $34,454.96 9. Of this grand total, payments and credits have been made in the amount of $20,936.72 with a balance remaining of $13,518.24. 10. On or prior to August 31, 1994, plaintiff delivered all the materials called for under the contract at defendants' residence as well as completed all the necessary services included -2~ in the e.Umated exhibit. attaohed hereto IInd marked aa Exhibit "A." 11. On or after August 31, 1994, plaintiff presented defendants with II final invoice entitled job no. 9477 and requested payment in the amount of $13,51B.24. A true and correct copy of this invoice is attached hereto and marked as Exhibit "B." 12. Plaintiff has repeatedly demanded payment of the amount due, but defendant has wholly neglected and rofused to pay the same or any part thereof. COUNT I BREACH OF CONTRACT 13. Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference the allegations set forth in paragraphs 1 through 12 as if the same were fully set forth herein or at length. 14. The actions of defendants as aforesaid are willful a~d oonstitute a material breach of the agreement entered into between plaintiff and defendants. 15. As a direct and proximate result of the actions of defendants as aforesaid, plaintiff has suffered and continues to suffer serious injury, including but not limited to loss of the monies owed to it by defendants, loss of use of said monies, lost interest on the money and other such damages as may be discovered. -3- -"". \ WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands that This Honorable court enter judgment in its favor and against Defendants in the amount of $13,518.24, together with costs and interest. COUNT II QUANTUM MERUIT 16. Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference the allegations set forth in paragraphs 1 through 15 as if the same were fully set forth herein or at length. 17. Between April 1994 and August 1994, plaintiff performed certain work and services for defendants, consisting of purchasing materials and providing there installation in a good and workmanlike conditioned upon the property of defendants and of the specific request of defendants to repair weather related damage. 18. The unpaid work, labor and services performed by plaintiff on defendants' house had a reasonable value of $13,518.24. 19. Defendants have refused to pay plaintiff for the unpaid work, labor and services performed by the plaintiff. 20. As a result of defendants refusal to make full payment to plaintiff of the reasonable value of plaintiff's work, labor, service and materials, plaintiff has suffered serious and continuing injury, including but not limited to 106S of material.,' time and effort expended on defendants' residence. -4... , , " " 21. Aa a result of defendants' refusal to make full payment to plaintiff of the reasonable value of plaintiff/s work, labor, materials and services, defendants have been unjustly enriched at the expense of plaintiff. 22. The amount in controversy in this matter is subject to compulsory arbitration under Cumberland County RUle 1301-1. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands This Honorable Court enter judgment in its favor and against Defendants in the amount of $13/518.24 together with costs and interest. Respectfully submitted, Date I "~rch r .' 1996 METZGER, WICKERSHAM, KNAUSS & ERB /~~~~ vlr steven P. Miner,-es~uire Attorney 1.0. No. 38901 Mellon Bank Building 111 Market Street P. O. Box 93 Harrisburg, PA 17108-0093 (717) 238-8187 Attorneys for Plaintiff , , <I'q Ii 1 , ' " 1 'I , ,I " I.' I 'I., , , I.F I, , " ! ' 'I \ , , , ! 1 -15- " , ' j I, " , , I, ' , , Exhibit" , , ..' . I' " ,\ ,I ," '!/' '-", " , , ,I .:; ;1/ , " , , 11\ " L' , , I,) , , I' " " , lit " , , ., " , " , ;j ,'II, ., , d , I, ., 'I' ,I"~ '..' ii, ,;1.,1,:, , , ';'1, I' 'I i.' '1_ I ~- ,.", \ . / I ,Ii- , !; . ;" ., , , '" 1./1' , ,;'II"t\ ,. ,I, , " "'JI." '1 't' ,., , I, , " " .,.j , ',il 1-/ I " I " -I 'J I' 1" I, 'I '-';, , 1;-\ )'1 'I .', 'I' '1' ." ',j Ii 1_1\ " iii I' , i , '" .,:'1" I " " , , . , '1;1 . ., " , ,;J Iii , ' , . , " :1 ,;11 ., " I I , I I ;1/' .' , , , , '" , " ". .', , I , " 'I , , ., , , " ,. , " , I , " , , , , ],1' \, 1, , ." " 'i,t i, rl', 'Ii , ' " I , ,I ;/, ,,; II' ~'I t , ,,! I' 'i 1-.1 ';f",1 ;! ., " .',i I' " ' , , " 'I ' ", , ., , " " d, 'll",1 I' ! "1 ,I , , . " '., ,~ ~i,:. Mitchell Relltorlltlon P.O. Rox 401 RAil tiler II n, P". 17:l1 ti (717) 2~9-799~ I-ROO-77 ~-Rl\~ti F:1l'l'INA'l'F. RlJNMARY Job, 19477--A --------------..-------------------------------------------------------------- O"te Printed I OR/1R/9~ Rlltlm~tor 10ennlll ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ .. C':IIIlTOMF.R TNl'ORMA'l'ION .. C':"rol WI I lion 1~12 R"dler Orive C':lIrllllle, PA (717) 24~-Oti41 RUII I ( ) Cont"ct I ~lIrol OAR .. JOR RITF. rNl'ORMATTON .. 1~12 S"dler Orlve C':"rllllle, PA Attnl l':/lrol (717) 24~-Oti41 .. INIWRANr.F. TNPORMA'l'TON .. Adj I ROO/lnn I C':IAlm , I Pol It I Oed $ I ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ . . RTRlJl':'l'lJRF. 'l'OTAl.S . . Iltructure. . . . . '" . $ 12ti7R.77 Tn ( ti.OO'l) . . . . . . . .$ 17.tiO OverheAd ( 10 . 00'l) . . . . . $ 12ti2.27 Prof It (10.00'l). . . . $ 12ti2.27 ------------ Structure Iluh-'l'o till $ 1~220.91 ....,.." ';,' , . Mitchell R"lItor"tlon P.O. Rox 401 P.lll1t 'Rerltn, PA. lnlti (717) 2~9-7993 I-ROO-77~-lIti~ti Il'l'R!lC':'l'lJRF. F./I'l'IMA'l'P. N"me I C':lIrol WI 1 lion Oftte Printed I OR/IR/9s Job , I 9477--1. Pille I 1 ---------_.~------------------------------------------------------------------- . Oellcrtptlon 'Ill !11M PPtI C':Ollt ----------------------~------------------------------------------------------- AreA N"me I P.ntrAnce ti'O" x ~'O" x 11'0" InlltRII 1/2" drywllll-celllngll-tex_ 111.00 SPC: 1.1 S 20.70 tured relldy for pAint 2 Remove 1/2" drywA II - celllngll lR.OO RPC: 0.:l4 ti. 1 2 ~ Remove/replRce light 1.00 M/C: 40.00 40.00 4 PAint 2 cORtll-ceilfng (lIeRI &PRlnt) IR.OO SPC: 0.47 R.4ti ~ Remove wIIllpAper S.OO ROl.l. IS.7S 711.7S ti WillI prepII rR t Ion 1.00 HRS 20.00 20.00 7 Hl\ng Willi pApe r S.OO ROI.I. 22.00 110.00 AreA 'l'otl\l $ 2R4.0~ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AreA NRme I Poyer '~'O" x 10'0" x R'O" " OrywRl1 minor repllfrll (to ti SP) minimum chllrge 2 Plllnt 2 cOAtll-cel ling (SeAl &PAlnt) ~ Mllllk/cover WA111I, floo1'll, furniture 4 Remove wllllpllper ~ W"ll prepllrlltlon ti W" II pllper 1.00 1~0.00 1.00 11.0e> 1.00 11.00 M/C: 50.00 0.47 22.00 Is.7S 22.00 22.00 S79.7S SO.OO 70.S0 22.00 173.2S 22.00 242.00 SPC: HRS ROI.I. HRII ROI.I. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AreR 'l'otAI $ A1"ell NRme . Powder room ~'O" x '4 '0" x R'O" . nrywR II minor repRirR (to ti RP) 1.00 M/C: H.OO 3S.00 minimum chArge 2 Plllnt 2 cORtR-cei ling (SeAl &PRlnt) 20.00 SPC: 0.4.7 9.40 ~ Remove wAllpRper S.OO ROT.I. IS.15 711.7!J 4 WR II prepllrAt ion 1.00 HRR 22.00 22.00. '"' t'.' IITRIlr.'l'IIRF. F.R'l'IMA'l'F. Nllme I C:llrol WI1~on Ollte Printed I OR/lR/9~ Joh , I 9477--A Pille I 2 ------------------------------------------------------.----------------------- , Oellcr I pt I on '111 111M PPII C:o"t ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ ~ W"llp"per S .00 ROT.T. 22.00 110.00 Arell Tot A I $ 25~.1 ~ -----------~------------------------------------------------------------------ Arell Nllme I 1.lvlngroom 17'0" x 1~'O" x R'O" OrywA II minor replllrll (to ti SP) 1.00 M/e': 130.00 1:t0.00 minimum chllrge 2 P"lnt 2 cOlltR-cell fng (Selll &:PAlnt) 2SS.00 II PC: 0.47 119.RS ~ Plllnt 2 COAtR-WIlIIR (ileAl &: plllnt) ~12.00 IlPW 0.4~ 2:t0.40 4 MIIRk/cover wAllR, floorll, furniture 2.00 HRS 22.00 44.00 ~ C:lelln cllrpet with detergent-medium H~.OO IlPP 0.22 Sti.l0 AreA 'l'otAI $ SRO.:t~ -----------.-------------------------------------------------------------------- AreA Nllme I Olning room 15'0" x 1 ~'O" X R'O" nrywllll minor replllrR (to ti SF) 1.00 M/C: R~.OO RS.OO minimum chArge pA t n t )~ 2 Plllnt 2 COAtR-WAIII'l (Ilelll &: 4RO.00 RPW 0.4~ 21ti.00 3 PAint 2 COli t R-ce II i ng (ileAl &:PAint) 22S.00 IlPC: 0.47 105.75 4 MAlik/cover wIIIIR, floorA, furniture 2.00 HRS 22.00 44.00 AreA 'l'otAI $ 4S0.H --------------------------------------------------------------~._-------------- Arell NAme I Kitchen 1~'O" x 9'0" X R'O" OrywA I I minor repllfrR (to ti SP) 1.00 M/C: 1~0.00 1:t0.00 minimum chllrge 2 Plllnt 2 cOlltl'l-cei ling (ileAl &:PAlnt) 1~5.00 IlPf: 0.47 ti:t.4S 3 MARk/cover WIIIIR, floorR, furniture 2.00 HRS 22.00 44.00 4 Remove will IpAper 7.00 ROI.I. IS.75 110.25 ~ WAIl prepll rA t ion 2.00 HRS 22.00 44.00 ti WillI pllper 7.00 ROI.I. 22.00 154.00 7 HAng will IpAper horrler ~9.00 M/C: 2.00 7R.00 R Plllnt 2 COAtR-WIII IR (ileAl &: PA I n t ) 120.00 RPW 0.4~ S4.00 " ,;',. ::, R'l'RtJr.'l'tJRF. 1>.R'l'IMA'I'F. Nllme I C:Arol Wllllon Ollte Printed I OR/IR/9~ Job , I 9477--A PAle I 3 ----"----------------------------------------------------".-------~-------~--- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ t OeRcrlptlon flU ulM PPtl C:Ollt Arell 'l'otlll $ 677.70 -------------------,._----------~---------------------------------------------- ArcII Nllme . Wllter hellter room '1'0" x ~'O" X R'O'" . OrywIIl1 minor repAlrR (to Ii RF) 1.00 M/C 60.00 60.00. minimum ChATI;le 2 p"lnt 2 cOAtll-WAlllI (SeAl III plllnt) 224.00 SPW 0.4~ 100.RO :l Plllnt 2 cOlltll"cell ing (SeAl IIIPlllnt) 4~.00 SPC: 0.47 21.1 ~ 4 MARk/cover WAl III, floorR, furnl ture 2.00 HRS 22.00 44.00 AreA TotAl $ 22~.9~ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Arell Nllme : KI tchen hA II 6'0" x ~'O" X R'O" nrYWllll minor repAirR (to Ii SF) 1.00 M/C: ~O.OO 30.00 minimum chllrge 2 Plllnt 2 cOAtll-WAIIR (ScAI III pllint) 120.00 SPW 0.4S H.OO :l PAint 2 cOAtR-celllng (ScAI &Pllint) IR.OO SPC: 0.47 R.46 4 Hllng wAllpAper horder " 1.00 M/C 30.00 30.00 AreA TotAl $ 122.46 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Are" NAme . OArAge 24'0" x 24'0" x 9'0" . 1 Remove 1/2" orywA 1 , .. ceil ingll ~76.00 SPC: 0.~4 19~.R4 2 Remove InllulAtion hAttR from ce i 1 ng ~71i.00 flPC: 0.20 11~.~0 ~ Remove inllullltion hnttll frnm wnl IR 211i.00 flPW 0.19 41.04 4 CrAft fAced flherglARII R-~O inRultn 792.00 SP O.RR ti9ti.96 ~ InRtAl1 1/2" orywAll-ceillngR-tex- ~76.00 SPC: 1. 1 ~ 662.40 tureo reAdy for pAint 6 TnRtftl1 1/2" drywAl1-WAIIR-texturcd 216.00 SPW 1. 1 ~ 24R.40 reAdy for pAint /\reA Totft 1 $ 19~9.R4 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ I' ~ ",. . " R'l'RIlc:rlJRF. F.IITIMA'l'F. 'Nllme I r.llrol WI irIon Ollte Printed I OR/lR/9~ , joh , t 9477--A P"ge I 4 It Oellcrlptlon ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ C':Ollt 'III 111M PPlI ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Arell Nllme : PAmlly room ~2'0" x l~'O" x R'O" 1 OrYWAl1 minor replllrll (to 1\ liP) minimum chArge 2 Plllnt 2 cOAtll-celllng (ileAl &Plllnt) ~ Plllnt 2 COAtll-WAIIA (ReAl & pAint) 4 MAlik/cover WAIIR, floorR, furniture ~ Remove wAllpllpcr ti WAll prepArAtion 7 WAllpAper R HAng wIIllpAper horder 1.00 4RO.00 2~ti.00 2.00 I~.OO 3.00 22.00 1.00 Aren TotAl $ M/r. RFC: RFW HRII ROLl. HRII ROI.1. M/r. 130.00 0.47 0.4~ 22.00 1 ~. 7 ~ 22.0Cl 22.00 l~R.ClO 1427.55 I~O.OO 22S.6Cl II ~. 20 44.00 204.7~ titi.OO 4R4.00 I~R.OO ______________________________________H_______________------------------------ AreA NAme: 2nd floor left fr hr 1~'O" x I~'O" x R'O" I Remove dry CArpet And pAd 2 TnRt1l11 new cArpeting In roomR 25.00 2~.3~ RYP IIYP 2.~~ 29.00 ~R.7~ 7~4.S7 AreA 'l'otAl $ 79~.~2 _______..______________________________~l_____________------------------------- AreA NAme: Office 14'0" x 10'0" x R'O" 1 Remove dry CArpet And pAd 2 Tn1ltA11 new cArpeting in roomR IS. ~ti IR.6ti IlYP IlYP Are" 'l'otlll $ 2.35 29.00 ~77 . 71 :tti.S7 S41 .14 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AreA Nllme : I.efr rellr hedroom 1~'0" x 1~'0" X R'O" 1 Remove 1/2" drywIIII - will III 120.00 RPW 0.32 :tR.40 2 Remove inRullltlon hllttll from will III 12Cl.00 IlFW 0.19 22.110 3 C':rAft fllccd fiherglllRR R-19 InAultn 120.00 RP O.till Ill. tiO 4 T nil t 1111 1/2" drywIII I-WAI III-textured 120.00 RPW 1.1 S l:tR.OO relldy for pnint ~ HAng wAllpAper-minimum chArge 1.00 M/C: 90.00 90.00 . ~I' . ' . /lTRlJC:TlJRF. R/I'r I MA'l'F. ""me l' C:"rol WI I'll on Ollto Printed I OR/IR/9~ .Joh II I 9477--A P"ge I S ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ , Oellcrlptlon '/11 111M PPII C:Ollt ______________________________________________________________M_______________ ti P"lnt 2 CO/l t II-will III (ileAl " pAint) 4RO.00 /lPW 0.4~ 216.00 7 P"lnt 2 cOlltll-celllng (lie,,' "PAint) 22~.00 /lFr. 0.47 10S.7S R Mllllk/cover WA 1111, floorfl, furniture 2.00 HRR 22.00 44.00 9 Remove dry CArpet And pAd 2~.00 /lVP 2.~~ SR.7~ 10 Tnllt" 11 new CArpet I nil In roomll 2~.~~ RVP 29.00 7H.~7 AreA TCltlll .$ I S29.R7 ----------------------------------------------------------~------------------- Are" N"me : HllllwAY 16'0" x 7'0" x R'O" , Remove dry CArpet And pAd 2 Tn1ltA11 new CArpet In hAllwlIY 12.44 12.44 RVP RVI' 2.~S 29.00 ~R9.99 29.2~ ~60.76 A~eA TotAl $ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Arell NAme: StAirll IR'O" x ~'O" x 9'0" 1 2 Remove dry CArpet And pAd InlltA" new Cllr(let/lltAlrll wlfull wr"p 6.00 29.00 /lVF T,F 2.~~ ~.42 14.10 I ~7.1 R . AreA 'l'OtA 1 $ 171.2R ---------,"-------------------------------------------------------------------- Are" NAme I MAllter hAthroom 10'0" x 9'0" X R'O" 1 Remove I I no I eum from wood floor 90.00 IIPP 0.72 64.RO 2 Remove nnd rellet old hAllehoArd ~R.OO T.P 1.00 3R.00 ~ Prep floor for linoleum-light 90.00 RI'P 0.~7 3~.30 4 R&R commode 1.00 P.A ~R .00 3R.00 ~ T.lnoleum 1 ~. ~~ RVP 22.00 29~.26 6 Remove tnllu III t 1011 hllttll from will III 72.00 Rf'W 0.19 1~.tiR 7 Remove 1/2" drywIIII - WA 1111 72.00 Rl'W 0.32 2~.04 R C:r"ft fneed ftherglnRII R-19 I nllu I tn RO.OO SF O.6R S4.40 9 TnlltA II 1/2" drywnll-wlIl III-textured 72.00 Sl'W 1.2R 92.16 re"dy for plllnt 10 Remove wn II pO(ler ~.OO ROI.I. I ~. 7S 7R.7S 11 WII.I prepnrnt Ion 2.00 HRII 22.00 44.00 .. , t-f" . ~ I . . . R'rRIJC:'l'IIR F. RR1'I MA'l'R . Nllme I C:llrol WI I 1'1 on ' ' Ollte Printed I OR/lR/9~ Job , I 9477--,. PIl8e I Ii ._~-----------------------~----------~--~------------------------------------- , Oe"crlptlon 'III 111M PPl/ C:Ollt .-------------------------------------____________.J___________________________ 1 2 Will I pllpe r l:l PIIlnt 2 cOlltll-celllng (SeAl &PAlnt) ~. 00 ROI.I. 90.00 RPl': 22.00 0.47 110.00 42.30 I f .------------------------------------------------____________________~________ AreA'l'otlll $ 92S.ti9 Are" Nllme I MRllter hedroom 2~'O" x 14'0" x R'O" 1 Remove InlmlAtion hllttR from wAIIII 112.00 RFW 0.19 21.2R 2 Remove 1/2" drywR I I - will III 112.00 RFW 0.32 H.R4 ~ C:r"ft fllcecl flherglAIIR P-19 fnRultn 112.00 /lP O.tiR 76.16 4 InRt1l11 1/2" drywnll-wIIIIR-textured 112.00 RFW 1.2R 143.36 reRdy for pAint ~ PAint 2 cORtR-wnll R ( Senl " pA I nt) ~92.00 /lFW 0.4S 266.40 6 PRint 2 cORtR-celllng (SeAl &Pllfnt) ~22.00 RPC: 0.47 1 ~1 .34 7 HAng WBllpAper horder 1. 00 MIl': 14R.00 14R.00 AreA 'l'otAI $ R42.3R .----------------------------------------------------------------------------- Arell NAme: Misc. 1 nIRlnfect-injectIRprAy-llght 2 Oump I>lnR 40 C:Y , 1~00.00 1. 00 /lFP P.A 0.09 7~0.00 RR~.OO OS.OO 7~0.00 i .--------------~~-------------~---------------~-------________________________ Suh-'l'ot A I $. " , , " I,;' , , , , , , ... ,'.. Mltohell RelltorAtlon P.O. !lox 401 F.Allt !lerlln, PA. 17~lti (717) 2~9-799) I-ROO-77~-Rti~~ ll'l'R!JC:'l'lJRF. F.RTTMA'l'R N"me f ~lIrol WI Jllon O"te Printed I OR/IR/9~ Joh t I 9477--0 Pille I 1 II Oellorlptlon PPtI --------------------------------------------------------.---------._---------- ~ClL'lt II/!J !JIM ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AreA Nllme : HA II hllthroom 9'0" x R'O" X R'O" 1 Remove linoleum from wood floor 72.00 RF\" 0.2S lR.OO 2 Prep floor for linoleum minimum 1.00 /lFP 7~ .00 7S.00 ~ I.lnoleum R.OO /IV" 26.00 20R.00 4 Replllr Ruhfloor 1.00 HRS 17~.00 17S.00 ~ R /I< R toi 1 et with new WIIX ring 1.00 RA 42.00 42.00 6 Tnll t 1111 new hllllehoArd - unplllntd ~4.00 I.P 2.20 74.1'10 7 Plllnt ollllehoArdR-rlifferent plllnt ~4.00 T.P O.RS 2R.90 thlln wIIIIR AreA 'l'ot/\I $ 621.70 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AreA NAme: MARter hAthroom 10'0" x 9'0" x R'O" ; Seotion IInd repll1ce lIuh-floor 2 Remove IInd replAce WillI Rtudll IInd ho t t om p I Ate ~ R & R toilet with new WIIX ring 4 InRt1l11 new hAllehuArd - unpAlntd ~ Pllint ollRehollrdR-rllfferent pAint thllnWlIllR 1.00 HRR lH.OO 22~. 00 42.00 2.20 O.RS 1.00 SP 1.00 F.A 4R .00 I.P 4R.001' T.P Arell 'l'OtIlJ $ ~RR . 40 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ AreA Nllme : MARter hedroom 2~'0" x 14'0" x R'O" Remove dry CArpet IInd pAd from oedroom wlllk In clollet And hA 11 2 InRt1l11 new cArpeting In roomR ~~.~3 IlVP 2. 3 !'I ~~.~~ SVP ~9.00 .., . " -----'- 17S.00 22S.00 42.00 10S.60 40.RO 12S.3~ lS4ti.S7 " ~.". "" ~.. . .' .. ,~ .. J .' ..~ ' Mitchell ReRtorAtlon P.o. ROle 401 ~Allt Rerlln, PII. l7.llti 2~9-7993 I-ROO-77~-Rti~ti (717 ) " R'l'RIIC':'l'lJRF. P.R'l'IMATF. Nllme I C:" ro I WI I Ron O"te Printer! I ORIIR/9~ .----------------------------------------------------------------------------- .----------------------------------------------------------------------------- , Oellcrlptfon Job , t 9477--, Pille I IIlI 111M PPII C:ORt Arell N"me F,'(terfor 1 'l'ellr out old dormerll :lell 10.SO HRR 2~.00 262. SO 2 Rehulld rltlrmerR .1 cllch 4R.00 HRR 2~.00 1200.00 :1 Inlltllll RhlnglcR on new dl)rmerll I. titi RQ 144.00 239.04 4 Plllllhlng .040" thick 9ti.00 SP 2.40 230.40 ~ WrAp new dormerR with Aluminum 14.00 HRR 2~.00 3S0.00 Ruh-'l'ohl $ 22111.94 .----------------------------------------------------------------------------- " " , , H " , , I'. , , , " " I" ,. ii, , , " " , 'I , " " " . , , , , , " " , , . . , , " " " , " , , " , , 'I Ij " , " ,I. . !,j ;} " " -I i I , , , I, " II J' 'd ;);, I , , , ! j ! ;) d , , , JI ' , ' 1"1 i,l. 1'1 " " " I I " I, ; , " "'1 tl, " , " I' Ii ,\, , " , , " " , " , i' ) 'J " ,i , I;{ , , II "I ,. , 'iI " , 'I, , . ) , 'I, , II (: d " " i'; , 1,/ I , , " ,')1 .1 i I"' , , " " " " " '-I 1" },' , , ", " " ',' IIdl " ,!) " " " " ':( ,', i"l, , , ," " " , , " " of' rl' " , ' '" , il " I" " ., ., ,-I' , " '\, , ";,' ,'I" I 'I ~'1\;j"i.!"\~11r'..;:q'I.Wl\f' -', ! I ;\ " , I " i:' " '!l r.b'.,t '.. 'J/ '_I'it Ii "11'1', ' 'I'; .(1 -' 1.1- ' ',1',,1 " , i. , " " ,'F . " "I if , " I, I I " , " , , , " " , " , , " ,; '" " 'I,(i I " " I,\l j''l " ", " , , " " I , " " ;,' I' " " I' J, " I , Ii' I " ", 1"1 Ii , ' " , . , , ", " , " I" I " I., ., I ,I I '" ! ,J" I. ; ~ ' , , 1-" 'I, I,!_ " 'I I -,II " 'J ,'l ,I " J , \' I, '!I ii .' " " ,,' .1 j' I q ,II , ,j " " ~ I ' ' !. , ,,' , , , \)1'1 " " " ,'I. '01,\ d , " ; I~ "I 'I I - I ' , j ;:1,1 I' I i'I'_ oj l'j';_1 _I JI ';\ , , I,' '" " /i" ,'I ; ,j ,1J, '" ':1 ;' " . I, , , , I I " " , ,,' ':1 " , I ,I " 'I }I' II ,1-, ,I " 11,' q , I , J ; ~ ! ! , , , i I I 'I I' "1 " , , " I " , , " I' , , " I,' "I ,) ill I,'il' "',> ;h I , )1 " ,,, II !d, , " " , " " " ., Ll' " I!, q, I 'I ~ ) i, , , /,) , , , " jJ , , , , , , ,I I! _/ , ;1. , , , -111 ] ~ , , " " ,I I I' ,I tl,' I ", , 'iI I " ,I I , iI ,'I I. '1/ ': I i 1,'1 ., 1./ 1,1 1,'1 , 'II 'J", , I, , 1,'1 'j " " I i', " ,jl , , " " " ., " '" \ " f;, , ", , " ,I, " , '1 I, , I d 'Ill p, :11>1,11 ,\ ., ;;'-,'i"i ., ,Iii r- ,I:J-,' , I " h' "1 'I ,;"'., ", ,/ ',',,';1 " \ ., , I' ,', " 'I " ,', ,., .1 ~:~!l: r-;,~~..I'7'7. i:~'f':': .J ,~.\.... "1"'1,-".., -'1,'ill:1 " ',I ;i~I-':l " I " -" 01 "".'\, "~, l' . t ". . . "j' I" , ,-...1_,,,""'""1' ''I,,., .,. , ; " INVOIOP; ! ---------4-----~------_______________4________________________________________ Joh '19477--A F.llttmlltor rOennl1l Ollto Prlnlod I OR/17/9~ ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ .. C:l/IlTOMRR rNPORMA'l'TON .. .... .ron II r'l'F. rNPOIlItIA1'TON '* '* 1~12 Illld'or Orlve C:llrllllle, PA Attnl C:Arol (717) 2H-0641 Ollrol WI 'lion 1~12 Illldler Orlve Ollrlfftle, PA (717) 24S-0641 RUllI ( ) C:ont"ctr C"rol OAR '* '* rNIll/IlANOI': INFOIlMA'l'ION .. Artj I Ronllnn I ~IAfm /I I Pol /I I Oed $ r ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ . '* /ll/PPI.RMRN'l'AI.S Rl'Itlmllte F.lltlmllte Rl'It fmllte Rllt fmAte , , . . .loll /I .Ioll /I .loll /I .loll # 9477--A. $ 1 S 2 20.91 9477--0. .$ 7Sti9.97 9477--P.. .~ 19~1S. 72 9477-_F. .$ 27~R..12 i:====...=~a= GRANO 'l'O'l'AI.S $ lH1R.24 f P.nrl Of Repor t .......... " , .......... '1"" " " ." :, , , , , , . ,'.1 " , I" " ,., I , " I. 'I iI , , " " ., , " , " . ... . ' ~ " VI!lRIPICATION I, Dennis E. Mitchell, t/a Mitchell Restorat.ion, hereby oert.ify that I have read the foreqoinq complaint. and believe it. t.o be t.rue and correct to the best of my knowledqe, information, and beliof. I understand that false statements herein are made subjeot. to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. 54904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. Date ,I e;zlr/tb " " '. , , , , " , , " 'Ii "I' \, , I I ;.) , " i' , , , , , , , , '" ,I 1,1 , , , , , I " , , I , , , , l, ,I , , '1,1 I, " , " , , , I . ! .'1 , ," 1'1 n , , , I," " 'I, , , , I I, ' , I, " ,I I I" ')i " ';1 , , , , , \1 I " ' , , " \;'1 . ";'-'~",J CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, steven P. Miner, Esquire, do hereby certify that on the date ..t torth below, I did serve a true and correct copy of the toregoing document upon the following person(s) at the fOllowing addressees) indicated below by sending same in the United States mail, first-class, postage prepaid: Hubert x. Gilroy, Esquire Broujos, Gilroy & Houston, P.C. 4 North Hanover street Carlisle, PA 17013 METZGER, WICKERSHAM, KNAUSS & ERB Date I March (jJ .t~: 199~ , , , , " " ill , , ,," I, , , " , 'I, " Ii ,lid' ,I 11'1 , , " , , " I Ii ';,; " ,;i"11 ,It I I ! ;,1 " ," ' ;1' I 1)1 ;',f , I , , ii"~ 'I, \ I , 5 Oenied that an oral oontraot Was SUpported by written estimates. Said estimates as referred to in Exhibit A of Plaintiff's Amended Complaint Were initially submitted to the insurance oarrier for the Defendants, PW Group/PrOVidence Washington Group and York Insuranoe Company (PW). 6 Oenied. Not all estimates were approved by Defendants. The majority of these estimates were submitted to PW pursuant to a relationship Plaintiff had with agents of PW. It- is further denied that Plaintiff performed all of the work outlined in the mentioned estimates. 7 Admitted that Exhibit A lists detailed work. Denied that said Work was performed. On the contrary, much of the work outlined on the various estimates wae not performed or, in the alternative, was performed in an unworkmanlike and negligent manner. e Denied. There wae no oral contract between Plaintiff and Defendants agreed to make payment upon l: J " Defendants whereby oompletion of the Work. Admitted that the estimate documents a8 listed on Exhibit A speak for themselves with regard to the quoted prioes. i; " 'i' ,~ II' I I, ;: 9 Denied. Detendant made payment to Plaintitf in cash ot $19,000.00. These payments were made by Defendants pureuant to approval of e8timates Plaintiff submitted to PW. By way of further answer, Defendant believes Plaintiff may have suggested that Defend~nt was entitled to a credit of $1,936.72 for the Defendants doing their own painting work. Defendant addresees those credits below in response to Plaintiff's Complaint. Denied that there is a balance owing of $13,518.24. 10 Denied. On the contrary, Plaintiff has not performed all work or delivered all materials specified under the various estimates outlined in Exhibit A of Plaintiff's Amended Complaint. By way of furthel' anewer it is denied that Plaintiff performed all work on or before August 31, 1994. On the contrary, Plaintiff did not begin work until September 27, 1994 and Plaintiff did not ceuse working at Defendant's property until approximately March, 1995. 11 Admitted that invoice was submitted after August 31, 1994. By way of further answer, Defendante allege that the final invoice was not presented to them until approximately April, 1995. 12 Admitted that Defendants have refused to pay any claim of the Plaintiff. COUNT t 13 No re.ponsive pleading is necessary. 14 Denied. Plaintiff did not perform work that Plaintiff represented to PW that it would perform on behalf of Defendants. By way of further answer, Plaintiff performed work in an unworkmanlike and negligent manner. 15 Denied that Defendants owe any money whatsoever to the Plaintiff. WHEREFORE, Defendants request that Count I of Plaintiff's Complaint be dismissed. COUNT .n 16 No responsive pleading is neceseary. 17 Admitted that Plaintiff performed certain work on property owned by the Defendante. Denied that said work was performed within a good and workmanlike manner. By way of further answer, Plaintiff did not perform any work in between April 1994 and August 1994. Plaintiff did not begin work until September 1994. 18 Denied. Plaintiff has already received payment of over $19,000 in . 24 Th. work allegedly performed by Plaintiff on Defendants' home a. let forth on the estimates labeled Exhibit A of Plaintiff's Amended Complaint was, on numerous occasions, in fact not performed by the !Jlaintiff. 25 The work allegedly performed by the Plaintiff on Defendants home as set forth in Exhibit A of Plaintiff' 13 Amended Complaint was, on numerous occasions, performed in a negligent and unworkmanlike manner. 26 With reepect to Job No. 9477-A, Defendants allege that various i terns were not completed, were done in a poor and incomplete manner, or were quoted in eaid J.nvoice based upon an improper calculation. A listing of those items are set forth on the attached Exhibit A which suggest that Defendants should be allowed a credit/set off of $5,628.96. 27 With respect to Job No. 9477-D, Defendants allege that various items were not completed, were done in a poor and incomplete manner, or were quoted in said invoice based upon an improper calcUlation. A listing of those items are set forth on the attached Exhibit B which suggest that Defendants should be allowed a cr.edit/set off of $2,088.00. ,-.I~ 28 ,With re.peat to Job No. 9477, DefendantB allege that variouB itemB were not completed, were done in a poor and incomplete manner, or were quoted in Baid invoice baBed upon an improper calculation. A li.ting of thoBe itemB are Bet forth on the attached Exhibit C which BuggeBt that DefendantB should be allowed a credit/set off of $8,162.36. 29 Beaause of Plaintiff I s incomplete work, Defendants were required to alean drywall dust out of their draperies at a charge of $128.26. 30 Plaintiff appropriated carpeting owned by Defendants from DefendantB' property with the understanding that said carpeting was to be returned in a bound condition. Plaintiff never returned said carpeting pursuant to the agreement between the parties and, thereby, Defendants Buffered 10sB of $3,538. 31 Because of improper work performed on DefendantB' property by Plaintiff, Defendants will be required to have the textured ceilingB of the property redone BO that the Beams will not show, with the cost of this work and the damage sUBtained by the DefendantB being approximately $2,000.00. 32 Plaintiff underBtood that the weather damage to Defendant.' home wu covered by insurance provided by PW, and Plalntiff further understood that PW required that ~ny work for damage caused by weather to Defendants' home must be first approved by PW before the work is performed. 33 Plaintiff either willingly or negligently proceeded with performing work on the roof of Defendants' dwelling which additional work was required because of weather damage and which work was not previously disclosed by Plaintiff to Defendante or to PW and for which Plaintiff did not atop work and allow PW an opportunity to inspect the additional roof damage. 34 As a result of Plaintiff's failure to allow PW to inspect the additional roof damage, PW has denied a supplemental claim submitted by Defendants to the Defendants' damage of $2,738.32. 35 In preparing estimates for weather damage to the Defendants' home and submitting said estimates to PW, Plaintiff negligently failed to include additional work that was clearly required for hall bathroom flooring of $621.70, Master bedroom flooring of $588.40, Master bedroom carpet of $1,671.90, tape and texture of ceiling of $874.90, wallpaper of $2,479.21, and contractor's overhead and profit of $846.38, for a total of $7,569.97. 40 A. .et forth above, Defendants have suffered damage of $2,000.00 for necessary work to have the textured ceilings redone so that the 8eams will not show. 41 As set forth above, Defendants have incurred damag~ of $2,738.32 as a result of Defendants inability to obtain reimbursement from its insurance company for work on Defendants' roof because of Plaintiff's negligence in failing to obtain approval from PW before performing said work. 42 As a result of Plaintiff's negligence in failing to adequately estimate work required to Defendants' home because of the weather damage, Defendants suffered damage by their inability to not submit a claim to PW for the hall bathroom flooring, maeter bathroom flooring, master bedroom carpet, tape and texture of ceilings, wallpapering, and contractor's overhead and profit for a total of $7,569.97. 43 As B result of Plaintiff's negligence in failing to install a proper new roof on Defendant's home, Defendant's home and their belongings suffered damage in December, 1995 as a result of water leaki~g from the roof that Plaintiff had allegedly repaired. The roof area in question was improperly repaired and will be required EXHIBIT A Amounts to be deducted: .1 - Job. :9477--A ,.rea Item Item Area Item Area Item Area Item \ \ , I ! i 'I . I I i I ! Total charges $15,220,91 (Not done) (Not done) (Not done) (Not done) (Not done) (Not (Not (Not done) done) done) Name: Entrance 3 Remove/replace light 4 Painting Name: Foyer 2 Painting 3 Mask/cover Name: powder room 2 Paint Name: Living room 2 Paint ceiling 3 Paint walls Maskicover Area Name: Dining room Item 2 Paint ceiling 3 Mask/cover 8 Paint walls Area Name: Kitchen Item 2 Paint ceiling 3 Mask/cover 8 Paint walls Area Name: Water heater room Item 2 Paint walls 3 Paint ceiling 4 Mi;lsk/cover Area Name: Kitchen hall Item 2 Paint walls 3 Paint ceiling Area Name: Garage Item 1 Remove drywall (Square footage not done) 448 sqft @ .34 = 2 Remove insulation (Sqnare footage not done) 448 sqft @ .20 = 3 Remove insulation (square footage not done) 120 sqft @ .19 = 4 Fiberglass insul. (square footage not done) 568 sqft @ .B8 = 5 Instl drywall 448 sqft @ 1.15 - 6 Instl drywall 120 sqft @ 1.15 = 7 Cost of finishing seams to ready to paint (poorly done & incomplete) (Not (Not (Not done) done) done) (Not (Not (Not done) done) done) (Not (Not (Not done) done) done) (Not done) (Not done) (Square footage not done) (Square footage not done) Area Name: Family room Item 2 Paint ceiling (Not done) 3 Paint walls (Not done) 4 Mask/cover (Not done) Area Name: 2nd floor left ft' br Item 1 Remove dry carpet and pad (Pad left) EXHIBIT I ^ - $40.00 8.46 70.50 22.00 9.40 - 119.85 - 230.40 44.00 63.45 44.00 54.00 63.45 44.00 54.00 - 100.80 8.46 44.00 54.00 8.46 - 152.32 89.60 22.80 - 499.84 - 515.20 - 138.00 - 200.00 - 225.60 - 115.20 44.00 29.38 Page 2 Area Name: Office Item 1 Remove dry carpet and pad (Pad left) Area Name: Left rear bedroom Item 1 Remove drywall (Sq footage not done) 56 sqft @ .32 " 2 Remove insul. (Sq footage not done) 56 sqft @ .19 = 3 Fibergls insul (Sq footage not done) 56 sqft @ .68 = 4 Instl drywall (Sq footage not done) 56 sqft @ 1. 15 " 6 Paint walls (Not done) 7 Paint ceiling (Not done) 8 Mask/cover (Not done) Area Name: Master bathroom Item 13 Paint ceilings (Not done) 14 Cost of replacing defective wallpaper Adjustment to Overhead Adjustment to Prof i t Total to be deducted from this section II , I , , " , L! , , , , , I d'l I", " . .r; , i' " " , " ,., , , , ", " " , , \' , I'" , /, , , " , 1\,' " _i"t , " " '1-,' 'I" , , >, I! " I , , jl,' :1,11 " i,1 , , 'I - 18.28 17.92 10.64 38.08 64.40 - 216.00 - 105.75 44.00 42.30 -1267.92 - 344.25 - 344.25 -5628.96 i)' , -, i,1 " ,,' I " I I' " " 'I, ,\ " Ij , I '-j I, Ij' I " , 'i I' I', " , '1'111 Page 3 EXHIBIT B *2 - 30b /I : 9477--0 Total Charges $7,569.97 Area Name: Hall bathroom Item 6 Install new baseboard 7 Paint baseboard B Install 1/4 round 22 linft @ 1.10 = Area Name: Master bathroom Item 1 Section and replace sub-floor (Done poorly) - 3 R & R toilet (Double bill - Item 4 on 9477A)- 4 Install new baseboards (Lin footage not done) 32 linft @ 2.20 = 5 Paint baseboard (Not done) 6 Install 1/4 round 16 11nft @ 1.10 = Area Name: Entrance Item 1 Tape & Texture Ceilings (Disputed item) Area Name: Foyer Item 1 Tape & Texture Ceilings (Disputed item) Area Name I Powder room Item 1 Tape & Texture Ceilings (Disputed item) Area Name: Living room Item 1 Tape & Texture Ceilings (Disputed item) Area Name I Dining room Item 1 Tape & Texture Ceilings (Disputed item) Area Name: Kitchen Item 1 Tape & Texture Ceilings (Disputed item) Area Name: Water heater room Item 1 Tape & Texture Ceilings (Disputed item) Area Name: Kitchen Hall Item 1 Tape & Texture Ceilings (Disputed item) Area Name: Family room Item 1 Tape & Texture Ceilings (Disputed item) Note: Because his workmen were not skilled enough to properly repair the ceiling drywall seams. texturing was offered as a solution. Our understanding was that there would be no additional charge. The result was better than the first attempt but still not very satisfactory. Area Name: Misc. Item 1 Final clean up (We cleaned!) 2 Contents moving (We moved!) Adjustment to overhead Adjustment to profit Total deductions from this section (Not done) (Not done) Finally. all of this was denied by ins due to D.M. not calling in adjustor before completing. EXHIBIT I 8 74.80 28.90 24.20 175.00 42.00 70.40 40.80 17.60 11.70 97.50 13.00 165.75 146.25 87.75 29.25 11.70 312.00 225.00 250.00 174.00 174.00 - 2088.00 1 verify that the Itatements in the foregoing pleading are true and correct. 1 understand that false statements herein are made lubject to the penalties of 18 PaCS 4904 relating to unlworn fallification to authorities. ----r:-,L ~ev0<~ ~) ~D1}.v--, 'l'liJRRANCE WILSON , ' " , , " " " I' " , " , .. I , 'i , ;',, , ,/ !, 1 " 'j' , , 1 I'; , ;t " , , 1 >I :i Ii '1 ,1 " " " " I, , " , 'I , ! " " I,') 1 , , \", " , ' , , I' li , , , , " 'Ii 1" 1 , .' 1 'I -I'. " " -Ill " ,Ii !'Ii " " , I verify that the .tatement. in the foregoing pleading are true and QorreQt. I undentand that falle statements herein are made lubjeQt fallUiQation to the penalUe. of to authoriU... 18 PaeS 4904 relating to un.worn /) . cJi: . L-~l, {(:ro~t Lld-tflJ CAROL I SON . . , I' '1' " , " " , ' ..' ., " I , , , , "I " , , , " I , , ., , " , , .1 1 , " L , , 1,1 , , " I, I , , , , ;;11, Ii " , ., I h h'i ., .', , ., , 1'1 , , " r;t , , ''1'1 , I' , .'1 , '" I ", , , " .' " ,'I , , 1')'\ , ': " I , , ,I " " .. , " , , " i,j ;'1 " , , ., , .. " , , , ., , , , , " " ., " , " " ~ " 'I' "', ,....1) DENNIS B. MITCHELL, tla MITCHELL RESTORATION, Plaintiff v. I I I I I I I I I IN THE COURT. OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 1996-00819 CIVIL ACTION - LAW TERANCE WILSON and CAROL WILSON, . Defendants REPLY TO NEW MATTER AND COUNTERCL~~~~~ :~H:~ ~F DENNIS E. MITCHELL. tla MITCHELL RES 0 I TIFF REPLY TO NEW MATTER Plaintiff, Dennis E. Mitchell, t/a Mitchell Restoration, by hi. Attorneys, Metzger, WiCkersham, Knauss & Erb, sets forth the followin." response to the Defendants" Answer to Plaintiff's Amended Complaintl 24. Denied. To the contrary, plaintiff did perform work on estimate labeled Exhibit "A" in a workmanlike fashion. proof of any failure to perform is demanded at trial. strict 25. Denied. To the contrary, the work performed by the plaintiff on defendants' house in Exhibit "A" was performed in a workmanlike manner. Any proof of negligent and unworkmanlike performance is demanded at trial. 26. Denied. It is first denied that plaintiff performed any work in Job 9477-A in a poor or incomplete manner. To the contrary, the items speoified in Exhibit "A" were indeed performed and plaintiff has ottered to make any touch-up or additional repairs a8 needed. It is specifically denied that the defendant.' are due any credit for defective wallpaper, since the plaintiff installed the wallpaper and did not produce the wallpaper itselt. Any claim for defect should be made agRinst the wallpaper manutacturer. It is turther pleaded that a cr.edit setoff suggested by the defendants' should more properly be made by the insurance company since the defendants' have made no payment to the plaintiff to date. 27. Denied. It is specifically denied that the plaintiff performed items of work specified in Job 9477-0 in a poor and incomplete manner. To the contrary, it is suggested that all items were performed in a workmanlike manner and in fact the plaintiff has offered to make any touch-up as necessary. It is further denied that any credit or setoff would be due the defendants', sinco all payments to date have been made by the insurance company and the invoices are currently outstanding. 28. Denied. It is further denied that plaintiff performed items of work in Job 9477 in a poor and incomplete manner. To the contrary, Rll of these items were performed appropriately by the plaintiff. Further, it is specifically denied that any item for roof repair should be permitted as a creditor setoff to the defendants', since they have not paid for the original roof repair to which they seek a credit. Further, it is denied that the plaintiff provided a new roof to the defendants' which apparently is the basis for their setoff in Exhibit "C." 29. Denied. strict proof of same is demanded at trial. -2- ~O. Denied. It is specifioallY denied that plaintiff appropriated carpeting owned by the defendants. To the contrary, defendants' did ask plaintiff to return carpeting in bound condition. However, this property was the property of the insurance company after new carpeting was laid in the defendant's house. It was therefore not the property of the defendant'c and in fact was not salvageable and could not be bound. Therefore any valuation for the carpeting is specifically denied as an item of damage. 31. Denied. strict proof of same is demanded at trial. 32. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is admitted that the plaintiff did perform services for the defendants under an insurance policy issues by PW Group/Providence Washington Group and New York Insurance company (PW). However it is specl.fically denied that PW required any work for damage caused by weather to defendants' home be first approved by PW. These charges were in fact initiated by the defendants themselves and were not part of the underlying insurance claim. These services were specifically requested by the defendants and are the subject matter of Plaintiff'S Amended complaint. 33. Denied. It is first specifically denied that plaintiff either willingly or negligently proceeded with the work on the roof of defendant's dwelling required because of weather damage before disclosing same to the defendants. To the contrary, the defendant specifically requested that this work be performed. It is further -3- denied that the plaintiff d~,d not stop work and allow PW an opportunity to inspect the additional root damaga. Plaintitt did not have the opportunity to seek. inspection because of the ".c.ssity to complete the job before additional weather damage occurred. This again was done with the full knowledge and approval ot the detendants. 34. The averment a of paragraph 34 are specifically denied and strict proof is demanded at trial. 35. The averments of paragraph 35 are specifically denied and strict proof of same is demanded at trial. 36. The averments of paragraph 36 are specifically denied and strict proof of same is demanded at trial. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requests your Honorable Court to dismiss Defendants' New Matter and judgment in favor of the Plaintiff in the amount of $13,518.24 together with costs and interest. REPLY TO COUNTERCLAIM 37. No responsive pleadings is required. 38. The averments of paragraph 38 are specifically denied and strict proof of same is demanded at trial. 39. The averments of paragraph 39 are specifically denied and strict proot of same is demanded at trial. To the contrary, the carpeting became the property of PW after new carpeting was laid in -4- defendants' house. Plaintiff attempted to bind oarpetinq but the carpetinq was not salvaqeable. 40. The averments of paraqraph 40 are specificallY denied and striot proof of same is demanded at trial. 41. The averments of paragraph 41 are specifically denied and strict proof of same is demanded at trial. 42. The averments of paragraph 42 are specif ically denied and strict proof of same is demanded at trial. 43. The averments of paragraph 43 are specifically denied and strict proof of same is demanded at trial. To the contrary, plaintiff performed repairs in a workmanlike manner. Further the plaintiff denies that any weather damagE<s from the severe winter of 1995-1996 can be attributable to his partial roof repairs made in 1994. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requests judgment against defendants in the amount of $13,518.24 along with costs of this action. plaintiff further requests that defendant's counterclaim be dismissed. METZGER, ~~KERSHAM, KNAUSS & ('5(. "--- steven P. M ner, Esqu re Attorney I.D. No. 38901 3211 North Front street P. O. Box 5300 Harrisburg, PA 17110-0300 (717) 238-8187 Attorneys for Plaintiff ERB Date I Mav W . 1996 , -5- VERIFICATIOIt I, Denn!. E. Mitohell, tla Mitohell Restoration, hereby certify that I have read the foreqoinq Reply to New Matter and Counterclaim and believe it to be true and oorreot to the best of my knowledqe, information, and belief. I understand that false atatements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. c,S. 54904 relatinq to unsworn falsification to authorities. ~)~ ~.'" nis ~ 0 e t/a MitChell Restoration Date I , ('" I /~I/? (; , , I il " ,,' , , , , , ' , , , I ',"" 'I' , , !'I I " , ;.'j "j , 1., " , I', I.) ., I"., " ' , I ,i ., ,I, 'I, .t.. I , " " " j.1 ,', ,,' ""1 ., I',! i,' I , ., Ii >J I , H , .'11 I, " , , , , , "